California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 31, 2001
Student v. Orange Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 1842-00 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Orange Unified denied FAPE for four years; Hearing Officer orders residential placement and compensatory education through age 22.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The student's August 8, 2001 post-hearing motion to dismiss the residential placement issue was denied. The decision notes the District is already a party to a related Orange County Superior Court (juvenile) case.
Summary
A 17-year-old student with a long history of severe aggressive behavior filed for due process against Orange Unified School District. The Orange County Health Care Agency (HCA) was also a party. The District listed the student's eligibility as emotional disturbance. He challenged his programs from 1997 through 2001 and asked to be found eligible under multiple disabilities. He opposed the District's request for residential placement and proposed a 24-hour in-home behavior program instead.
Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino found the District denied a FAPE in all four school years, counting from October 16, 1997, under the three-year limitations period. For years the student received about one to one-and-a-half hours a day of "home teaching." He had no behavioral intervention plan and no meaningful speech-language services, and his IEPs lacked present levels or goals. The District repeatedly agreed to weak programs to satisfy the mother instead of filing for due process. The Hearing Officer found the student met the multiple disabilities definition (emotional disturbance plus speech-language impairment) and also had specific learning disabilities. The experts agreed that the mother would undermine any home-based program, so he ordered residential placement and overrode her lack of consent. HCA must fund its share despite the District's premature October 2000 residential offer. He also ordered a 24-hour positive behavior plan, direct speech therapy, and compensatory education set by the IEP team through age 22.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO treated a parent's consent to deficient IEPs: it did not excuse the district, which had a duty to file for due process. It also illustrates an open-ended compensatory education award that an IEP team defines through age 22. Finally, it shows that a premature residential offer did not shift mental-health funding away from the county agency when the agency suffered no prejudice.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a FAPE to the Petitioner for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
The District denied FAPE in every year from October 16, 1997 (the three-year limitations date) through 2000-2001: it offered only 1 to 1.5 hours a day of home teaching, no behavioral intervention plan, inadequate speech-language services, and IEPs missing present levels and goals, and it held no timely IEP meetings. A checked 'behavior strategies and supports' box was not itself a procedural violation.
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. What eligibility designation most appropriately reflects the Petitioner's educational needs?
Student meets the federal definition of multiple disabilities (emotional disturbance and speech and language) and has specific learning disabilities, while remaining eligible as ED.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 3. Is residential placement necessary for STUDENT to receive a program that is designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?
Residential placement is necessary. Unanimous expert opinion showed the mother would undermine any home-based program, so the student's proposed 24-hour in-home IABA plan was rejected and the mother's lack of consent was overridden.
- Not reachedPlacement and LRE
Issue 4. What is the least restrictive environment in which the Petitioner could benefit from his education for the 2001 extended school year and the 2001 to 2002 school year?
Moot in light of the residential placement finding on Issue 3.
- Not reachedImplementation
Issue 5. Has HCA provided Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on the Petitioner's IEP and treatment plan dated September 14, 2000?
No finding made because the issue did not affect the outcome; the record suggested any missed services were mainly due to the mother's lack of cooperation.
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 6. If residential placement is ordered, should the District bear financial responsibility for such a placement because of its alleged disregard for procedural mandates and HCA's role in residential placement?
The District's October 10, 2000 residential offer violated Government Code sections 7572 and 7572.5, but it was corrected eight days later and caused HCA no prejudice, so HCA remains obligated to fund its share of the residential placement.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services?
Compensatory education is owed for a flagrant denial of FAPE since October 16, 1997. The equities weigh substantially in the student's favor despite the mother's conduct, and the IEP team must set services through the student's 22nd birthday.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, and thereafter as necessary, the expanded IEP team must meet to develop an IEP consistent with the Hearing Officer's FAPE findings (Order 1 A-G).
- Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include: a positive behavioral intervention plan based on a functional analysis assessment (such as Dr. Willis's plan), with ongoing counseling (preferably by a board-certified psychiatrist), cognitive therapy, and a waking and sleeping schedule, strictly implemented 24 hours a day; speech-language direct therapy at least twice per week in 30-45 minute sessions as tolerated; services for specific learning disabilities; ESY and instruction well beyond 3-5 hours per week (goal of 3-5 hours per day or more as tolerated); a vocational program; and a transition program for independent adult living.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, the expanded IEP team must convene to designate the persons responsible for identifying an appropriate residential placement under Title 2, C.C.R. section 60100.
- Placement ordered. Subject to Juvenile Court jurisdiction, within 60 calendar days of the Order 2 IEP meeting, the District must place the student in a residential placement. The placement must be a 24-hour facility with staff trained to implement the behavior plan, have security that keeps a structured environment and prevents the program from being undermined by the mother's presence, and provide the integrated FAPE and compensatory services directly or by contract. The IEP team must hold six-month reviews under Gov. Code 7572.5(c)(2) and, if the placement is out of state, plan for less restrictive alternatives under Gov. Code 7572.55(c).
- Compensatory education. Within 15 calendar days and as needed afterward, the IEP team must determine compensatory education in addition to FAPE services, including but not limited to academics, speech and language, counseling, therapy, and vocational training. The team must consider the student's tolerance, the continuous denial of FAPE since October 16, 1997, and that more than one-to-one replacement may be needed. Services continue through the 22nd birthday, and the student may request more later.
- The Hearing Officer overrode the mother's lack of consent to residential placement under Education Code section 56346(b). The District and/or HCA must seek authority from the Juvenile Court or other Superior Court divisions to place the student. The student's post-hearing motion to dismiss the residential placement issue was denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Cal. Gov. Code 7572.5; Cal. Educ. Code 56346(b); 34 C.F.R. 300.7(c)(7); Title 2, C.C.R. 60600(c)
People named in the decision
- Nancy Shipcott, director of pupil services, Orange Unified School District
- Lynn Gonzales, program coordinator, Orange Unified School District
- Susan Ferencz, coordinator for psychological services, Orange Unified School District
- Manny Robles, Chapter 26.5 coordinator, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Anne Slagle, resource specialist and home teacher, Orange Unified School District
- Susan Berkowitz, speech pathologist; expert witness for Student
- Robert Patterson, psychologist; independent evaluator and witness for Student
- Cheryl A. Pitts, therapist and licensed clinical social worker, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Michael Mullen, clinical psychologist, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Shirley Lanyi, neuropsychologist; neuropsychological evaluation
- Marc Pastore, speech-language pathologist; speech, language, and auditory perceptual assessment
- Thomas Willis, behavior analyst; comprehensive functional assessment, Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA)
- Daniel Kane, home instruction teacher, Therapeutic Educational Center (TEC)
- Janet Eckleman, site director, Therapeutic Educational Center (TEC)
- Carmen Rivera-Tara, staff coordinating behavior instructional assistant, Therapeutic Educational Center (TEC)
- Patricia Cromer, court-appointed attorney and educational surrogate for Student
- Rossier School, nonpublic school
- Therapeutic Educational Center (TEC)/Olive Crest, nonpublic school
- Otto Fischer School, juvenile court school, Orange County Department of Education
- Goodwill Industries, proposed vocational training provider
- Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis (IABA), private behavior agency
- College Park, nonpublic school / day treatment option considered
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on June 19, 20, 21, and 22, 2001, in Orange, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by his attorney, Patricia Cromer. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was his mother, MOTHER, represented by attorney Kathleen M. Loyer. Ms. Cromer and Ms. Loyer were acting as court-appointed attorneys pursuant to a related juvenile court proceeding. Respondent Orange Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Ronald D. Wenkart from Schools Legal Service, Orange County Department of Education. Also present on behalf of the District were Nancy Shipcott, director of pupil services for the District; Lynn Gonzales, program coordinator for the District; and Susan Ferencz, coordinator for psychological services for the District. Respondent Orange County Health Care Agency (HCA) was represented by attorney Jan J. Martin, deputy county counsel for Orange County. Also present on behalf of HCA was Manny Robles, Chapter 26.5 coordinator for HCA.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Anne Slagle, resource specialist at the District for special needs students; Manny Robles; Susan Berkowitz, speech pathologist; and Robert Patterson, Ph.D., psychologist. The District called the following witnesses: Cheryl A. Pitts, therapist and licensed clinical social worker at HCA; Michael Mullen, Ph.D., clinical psychologist at HCA; Mannyl Robles; MOTHER; and Nancy Shipcott.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Documentary evidence included several volumes of exhibits and 107 pages of stipulated facts. The record was left open until July 23, 2001, for the submission of written closing arguments, which were received from each party on that date.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)
(1) Did the District fail to offer and/or provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Petitioner for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
(2) What eligibility designation most appropriately reflects the Petitioner’s educational needs?
(3) Is residential placement necessary for STUDENT to receive a program that is designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?
(4) What is the least restrictive environment in which the Petitioner could benefit from his education for the 2001 extended school year and the 2001 to 2002 school year?
(5) Has HCA provided Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on the Petitioner’s IEP and treatment plan dated September 14, 2000?
(6) If residential placement is ordered, should the District bear financial responsibility for such a placement because of its alleged disregard for procedural mandates and HCA’s role in residential placement?
(7) Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner alleges he was denied a FAPE from the 1997-1998 school year through the 2000-2001 school year because of substantive deficiencies in the District’s program offers and because of procedural violations committed by the District. The District admits some procedural violations, but it does not admit denial of a FAPE to the Petitioner.
The Petitioner seeks a change in his eligibility designation to “multiple disabilities,” as defined in Title 34, C.F.R. 300.7(c)(7). The Petitioner asserts that use of the emotionally disturbed, or “ED,” designation, does not appropriately describe his unique needs. The District asserts that the federal definition of “multiple disabilities” is not applicable to the Petitioner.
The District asserts that STUDENT should be placed in a residential placement. The District claims that a residential placement is necessary because any other type of placement would be doomed to fail through the unreasonable interference of STUDENT’s mother. The Petitioner claims that the least restrictive environment would be a carefully supervised 24-hour-per-day in-home program, with provision for attending classes in a public school.
The Petitioner seeks compensatory education services due to the alleged denial of FAPE. The District claims that any award of compensatory education should be tempered by equitable factors. Those equitable factors, according to the District, arise from the conduct of STUDENT’s mother.
HCA claims that it has fulfilled all of its legal obligations to STUDENT as required by STUDENT’s IEP and treatment plan dated September 14, 2000. HCA also claims that because the District offered a residential placement to STUDENT without first involving HCA in the procedures required by law, any residential placement should be solely the financial responsibility of the District. The District claims that HCA should be ordered to pay for a residential placement because HCA has recommended residential placement and HCA has not been prejudiced by the District’s actions.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], has been in special education programs since the beginning of kindergarten in November 1989. He has been in the District since September 1990. STUDENT has multiple areas of disability. His current eligibility classification by the District is “emotional disturbance” (ED).(Footnote 3) STUDENT is a large young man, about 6 feet 2 inches in height and weighing nearly 500 pounds.
STUDENT has a history of receiving minimal educational services. Beginning with kindergarten in the Anaheim School District, he was placed on a 20-minute school day. When STUDENT moved to the District in 1990, he was placed on home teaching at the commencement of first grade for 1 hour per day, and was later placed in a special day class (SDC) for an unknown number of hours per day. He was identified on his October 2, 1990 IEP as having “delays in language, perceptual, motor skills, academic and behavior functioning.”
The District’s triennial assessment team report dated December 1992 (Pet. Ex. p-31) states that STUDENT had been in a learning handicapped (LH) special day class (SDC) from October 1990. At the age of 8 ½ years, he was 5 feet tall and weighed 169 pounds. Tests to measure his academic achievement in third grade showed performance at first-grade levels or less. He demonstrated mild hearing loss. The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scale-Classroom Addition showed severe deficits, with percentile scores of 1 percent in communication, daily living skills, and socialization. The Woodcock-Johnson Scales of Independent Behavior showed results in the 1 to 5 percentile range. Disruptive or problem behaviors were present, rated in various categories as nil to extremely severe, with the teacher rating consistently showing greater problems than STUDENT’s mother would list. The mother did agree, however, that STUDENT was uncooperative on a daily basis by refusing to do chores, pouting, and refusing to go to school.
Because of his behaviors, STUDENT was placed at Rossier School, a nonpublic school, in November 1993, at the age of 9 years. STUDENT’s eligibility designation was changed in May 1995 to ED. His behavior was considered to be out of control, and he was assigned a full-time classroom assistant.
The District’s triennial assessment team report dated March 1996 (Pet. Ex. p-162) states that STUDENT had a history of severe behavioral difficulty resulting in police intervention on three occasions. At the age of 11 years and 9 months, STUDENT was 5 feet 8 inches tall and weighed over 250 pounds. He failed the hearing screening in his right ear. The assessment report states that continued severe behavior difficulty was “indicated,” and anger, aggression, and extremely low frustration tolerance were “suggested.” He continued to have delays in academic, self-help, pre-vocational, and visual-motor areas.
The Rossier School sixth-grade progress report for STUDENT, issued April 3, 1996, showed present levels of academic performance ranging from K.0 to to 2.0, with scores lower than his 1995 scores in many areas. (Pet. Ex. p-170.) By letter dated May 15, 1996, the Rossier School informed the District that it was terminating STUDENT from the school. The letter states that “we must terminate STUDENT mainly because of the mother’s refusal to work in a cooperative manner with the school system. It is our feeling that STUDENT would be workable and we could make some significant gains in changing his behavior, but we obviously have no control over the mother and she has great impact on him.” The letter also states that STUDENT had been very assaultive to the school staff and had often damaged school property. (Pet. Ex. p-176k.)
A September 24, 1996 letter from the District to the mother states that since STUDENT’s dismissal from Rossier in May 1996, the District had been unable to obtain the mother’s cooperation or consent in finding a suitable placement. The District had recommended placement at McPherson School in a self-contained classroom of approximately two students and at Therapeutic Educational Center (TEC). The letter further states that because the mother would not agree to the proposed placements, STUDENT had been placed in a home-teaching program as a temporary setting while other alternatives were explored. The letter emphasizes that the home setting was only intended as temporary. The letter states that STUDENT’s behavior needs required a small and restrictive setting with a lot of positive reinforcement. The letter expresses the District’s concern about STUDENT’s educational progress and his ability to cope with social and emotional conflicts involving other human beings. The District believed STUDENT’s IEP goals would be better met in a placement other than home teaching. (Dist. Ex. 11.)
STUDENT was in a home teaching program for portions of the 1996-1997 school year with various teachers, who submitted periodic grade reports. (Dist. Ex. 11.) The last report prior to the 1997-1998 school year was for the period February 3, to May 21, 1997.
In September 1997, the District attempted to recruit a teacher for STUDENT’s home-teaching program. According to the District’s record, from September through October 1997 sixteen teachers were asked to teach STUDENT, but they all declined the position. An additional three teachers accepted the position, but then refused the assignment after encountering what they claimed to be an incredibly abusive attitude by the mother. (Pet. Ex. p-176m, Dist. Ex. 21.)
An IEP meeting was held on November 25, 1997, at the mother’s request. (Pet. Ex. p-176p, Dist. Ex. 11.) The IEP lists ED as the primary eligibility designation. The District offered home teaching at Portola, 60 minutes per session, 5 sessions per week.(Footnote 4) The IEP lists no specific designated instruction or services (DIS). There are eight academic goals and objectives listed; one self-help goal regarding STUDENT’s being able to say and write his name, birthday, address, and phone number; a sensory motor goal regarding printing in small-case letters; and two social/emotional goals regarding working with a teacher to orally resolve frustration issues and using words to clearly express his feelings and desires. The IEP references an educational assessment performed in November 1997, but results of that assessment are not stated in the IEP. (Pet. Ex. p-177.)
The next IEP meeting was January 15, 1998. (Pet. Ex. p-181.) The thrust of the District’s recommendation in the IEP document appears to be that the needs of STUDENT would best be met by transition to middle school. However, there was no transition plan stated, other than an increase in home teaching from one hour per day to 1 ½ hours per day, and then a review of the matter in four weeks. The mother appears to have given oral consent to this IEP. Three additional goals and objectives were added regarding returning to on-task behavior after a period of rest, following teacher directions at the first request, and demonstrating cooperative behavior with the teacher/authority figure.
The next IEP meeting was held on February 12, 1998. (Pet. Ex. p-187.) The District recommended placement at STUDENT’s school of residence, with a program consisting of 35 percent in regular education, 4 daily periods in SDC, extended school year, and a regular physical education period daily. The ultimate decision, however, was to continue STUDENT in his present program, meaning his home program. The mother and STUDENT both signed their consent to this IEP.
An agreed-upon IEP addendum dated September 23, 1998, with an effective date of September 24, states that STUDENT would be released from home teaching to start four daily SDC periods, plus regular education electives, at Orange High School. The plan included concealing from Orange High School the details about STUDENT’s past, for the purpose of seeing what would occur if STUDENT started on a “clean slate.” (Pet. Ex. p-206, 207.)
STUDENT started attending Orange High School on or about September 24, 1998. A behavior incident reported on October 7, 1998, states that STUDENT kicked another student. (Pet. Ex. p-207b.) On October 8, 1998, STUDENT was reported to have intimidated the cafeteria manager by “making fists and swearing.” STUDENT was suspended for two days. (Pet. Ex. p-207a.)
At the next IEP meeting on October 19, 1998 (Pet. Ex. 208), STUDENT’s SDC periods were increased from four to five, with a corresponding decrease in the regular education classes. His present levels of performance for this ninth-grade student were listed at grade score 4.2 for word recognition, 4.0 for math, 1.0 for spelling and writing. It was noted that he had made no friends, was below age level socially and emotionally, had slow motor skills, needed direct instruction consistently, and was consistently late to class. Four categories of annual goals and objectives were listed in the IEP, addressing behavior, writing, reading, and math.
STUDENT’s first report card from Orange High School was issued on November 6, 1998. (Pet. Ex. p-212m.) STUDENT received one “F.” His other grades were “B’s” and “C’s” with an “A” in PE. He was noted to have excessive absences, incomplete homework, and disruptive/inconsiderate behavior, but he was also reported to be interested in learning and trying hard.
A behavior incident was reported on December 8, 1998. By the school’s account, there was a fight in the classroom between STUDENT and another male student. STUDENT reportedly lifted his desk and threw it across the room, hitting a female student seated two rows away. The classroom was evacuated.(Footnote 5) (Pet. Ex. p-212n, 212nn.)
At the December 16, 1998 IEP meeting, the team discussed STUDENT’s return from suspension following the desk incident. (Pet. Ex. p-212r.) It also discussed alternative placement and an AB 3632 referral to HCA. A goal and objective were added for improvement of frustration tolerance. The mother signed her consent to a “functional behavior analysis” (Pet. Ex. p-212y; see also Joint Ex. p. 59, which refers to the proposed assessment as an FAA, or “functional analysis assessment.”) STUDENT’s report card on January 29, 1999, included a C, A-, and four B’s, with comments that he was a pleasure to have in class. (Pet. Ex. p-212y-8.)
The next IEP meeting was on February 8, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-212z.) There was discussion regarding STUDENT’s instructional assistant. A triennial assessment plan was signed for the following categories: health and developmental, general ability, academic performance, social and emotional status. On February 23, 1999, HCA wrote to the District stating that “due to circumstances out of our control, we will not be able to complete a mental health assessment on this student. Please let me know if you would like to convene an IEP to discuss this further.” (Pet. Ex. p-212ee.)
Present levels of performance bearing the date of March 1, 1999, showed grade-equivalent performance ranging from first-grade to third-grade levels. STUDENT was considered by his SDC teacher to be learning to relate to his peers, reaching out to them with teasing and joking. He was generally well-behaved with a few incidents of defiance toward his aide or his teacher. He was improving in self-help but needed to be constantly reminded of his class schedule. He had difficulty following directions, staying on task, and focusing. (Pet. Ex. p-212bb.) It is unclear whether this one-page document dated March 1, 1999, and completed by the special day class teacher is intended to constitute the triennial assessment ordered at the February 8, 1999 IEP. The parties have stipulated in Joint Ex. p. 62 that this document was part of the February 8 IEP.
In March 1999, Orange High School sent a letter to STUDENT’s mother congratulating her on STUDENT’s being placed on the honor roll at the end of the first semester.(Footnote 6) (Pet. Ex. p-212ff.) A “Secondary Referral Form” dated March 5, 1999, states that STUDENT had been continually slamming a door and using profanity. (Pet. Ex. p-212hh.)
Reports from Orange High School involving an incident on March 15, 1999, state that STUDENT was out of control in a District office. He was ripping papers and throwing the papers at another person. Various paraphrased quotes attributed to STUDENT in the reports are that he would “hurt him the next time,” that he “was going to bring a gun and shoot him,” that he would “kill the aide and his whole family,” that he was going to “kill him tomorrow,” and that he “wasn’t playing and meant business.” STUDENT also reportedly threw magazines on the floor and threw an open soda can at a secretary. (Pet. Ex. p-212kk, 212ll, 212mm.)
Following the March 15, 1999 incident, STUDENT was arrested and placed in the custody of his mother. He was also suspended from school. He was subsequently incarcerated at juvenile hall. An IEP meeting was held on March 17, 1999, to review reasons for STUDENT’s suspension and to review his goals, objectives, and placement. (Pet. Ex. p- 212mm, 212pp.) A police officer was in attendance. The police department agreed to coordinate an appointment with HCA for the family. It was agreed that an independent evaluation would be performed by Robert Patterson, Psy.D. (Joint Ex. p. 64, 65.)
Dr. Patterson commenced an assessment on March 22, 1999. His report dated April 16, 1999, contains an extensive review of STUDENT’s history. (Pet. Ex. p-213.) Dr. Patterson stated that the behaviors in the classroom leading to STUDENT’s suspension from school and his incarceration were a manifestation of his ED. Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT’s placement was not appropriate. According to Dr. Patterson, STUDENT needed an extremely modified setting. Dr. Patterson recommended that a functional analysis assessment be performed, and that the assessment include development of a series of very specific protocols. He also recommended a functional analysis of STUDENT’s behaviors in whatever new setting STUDENT may be placed. STUDENT needed very practical cognitive therapy and the use of social scripting and social stories to teach him how to relate better to his peers and how to deal with his feelings and emotions. Dr. Patterson stated that relaxation strategy therapies would also be useful for teaching STUDENT to relax and to evaluate his own anger cycle. He needed social skills training and had specific adaptive skill deficits and educational deficits in the area of academics that needed to be remediated using standard multisensory teaching strategies.
Dr. Patterson also concluded that it was important to consider providing behavioral therapy and training for STUDENT’s mother if he was to remain at home. He stated that consideration should be given to locating a classroom where the staff had experience dealing with students having low incident, high intensity behaviors. He stated that the staff of either the ED class at Foothill High School in Tustin or TEC (Therapeutic Educational Center)/Olive Crest in Santa Ana had such experience.
On April 14, 1999, the District wrote to HCA stating that the AB 3632 evaluation requested earlier in the year had “evidently” not been completed because of the mother’s schedule, and that she had indicated she would be available sometime after spring break. The District was requesting that HCA reopen the case in the event the mother called. (Pet. Ex. p-259.)
The next IEP meeting was held on April 22, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-265a.) Dr. Patterson attended, but the mother did not attend. Placement options and support services were discussed, consistent with Dr. Patterson’s recommendations. The plan was to encourage the mother to reopen the case with HCA. The mother consented to the IEP and asked for the necessary documents to reopen the case with HCA.
On May 19, 1999, an IEP meeting was held at Otto Fischer School (Pet. Ex. p-268), the school STUDENT was attending while institutionalized through the juvenile court. This school was part of the Orange County Department of Education (OCDE). No one from the District attended the IEP meeting. The proposed placement was 45 minutes of resource specialist program, once per week. Present levels of performance were listed at second- and third-grade levels. Difficulties were specified in oral expression, listening comprehension, social/emotional adaptation, monetary concepts, time measurement, and balanced-meal concepts. Goals and objectives were written for math, written expression, listening comprehension, and behavior management skills. The mother consented to this IEP. OCDE recommended and received a consent from the mother for an assessment in speech and language. (Pet. Ex. p-279.)
An eligibility statement was prepared by the District during STUDENT’s incarceration at juvenile hall. The statement bears the mother’s signature and consent dated May 19, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-280.) Through the marking of a series of boxes under the category entitled “Specific Learning Disability (SLD) Discrepancy Criteria,” the eligibility statement shows that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and general academic skills in the classroom. He also had a disorder in basic psychological processes involving auditory processing, visual processing, and sensory motor skills. The above-stated discrepancies were found to be the result of developmental delay and ED. Under a separate category entitled “Other Disabilities,” a box is checked to confirm that STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria for ED.(Footnote 7)
An IEP meeting was held by the District on June 8, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-281.) The mother signed her consent to the IEP. The assigned school would be determined upon STUDENT’s release from Otto Fisher School. The program would be six periods of SDC daily with extended school year, transportation, and one period of physical education daily. The mother emphatically stated that she did not want STUDENT affiliated with a group home. The meeting was continued to a later date so that all the regular members of the IEP team could be present.
OCDE issued a speech and language report on June 30, 1999, pursuant to the referral by the Otto Fischer School. (Pet. Ex. p-285.) The assessment team concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education services as a speech and language impaired student.
HCA completed an “AB3632/882-Chapter 26.5 Assessment” while STUDENT was still incarcerated at Orange County Juvenile Hall. The report dated July 1, 1999 (Pet. Ex. p-289), notes that when STUDENT was initially referred for assessment in January 1999, he appeared for the initial session but then the mother stated that her son was not willing to continue with the assessment because he did not want to miss school, and that she would not be available to bring him for the assessment until after April 4, 1999. The report concluded that STUDENT had limitations in his cognitive and social adaptive behaviors, and that previous testing suggested significant developmental delays in the borderline range of functioning. The report further concluded that his symptoms raised questions about a possible neurological or organic disorder that may be causing his severe behavior problems, and that if a neurological evaluation ruled out a neurological problem, “then a thought problem or disorders of severe social impairment may need to be considered.”
Current strengths listed in the HCA assessment included STUDENT’s being very attached to and respectful of his mother, and being cooperative during the evaluation process. He indicated willingness to participate in counseling. Services proposed as beneficial included individual and family therapy to address STUDENT’s anger management issues, defiant behaviors, and depression. The assessment also recommended supportive services through the Orange County Regional Center, neurological testing, and referral to a behavioral neurologist who has worked with children with significant behavioral problems. A service plan was attached. (HCA Ex. 5).
An IEP meeting was conducted by the District on July 29, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-302.) The primary eligibility classification was still listed as ED. The specific learning disabilities listed on the May 19, 1999 eligibility statement are not listed on the July 29 IEP. The instructions on the boilerplate IEP form prohibit the listing of more than one “primary handicapping condition.” The HCA evaluation and recommendations were reviewed. The recommended program was an SDC in a nonpublic school 300 minutes daily, TEC counseling 45 minutes weekly, one period daily of physical education, extended school year as needed, and transportation. Children and Youth Services (CYS), a division of HCA, was offering to provide individual therapy one to two times per week at the school site, and collateral counseling. Busing to CYS was offered and rejected, with the mother expressing that she would rather have STUDENT go straight home than go to counseling with him. It was agreed that the court-appointed surrogate would take STUDENT and the mother to visit TEC. If STUDENT and the mother agreed to a placement at TEC, the District would provide a full-time aide trained in behavioral intervention strategies. Another IEP meeting was to be scheduled after the TEC visit to determine goals and objectives and the length of the school day.
An IEP addendum dated August 5, 1999, shows that the speech and language evaluation was discussed. It appears that the District’s offer regarding speech and language services was the provision of consultation one hour per month to some unspecified person for the purpose of reviewing the modifications and recommendations of the speech and language specialist at OCDE. Carmen Rivera-Tara at TEC and Ms. Shipcott at the District were to work together to obtain the services of a trained behavior instructional assistant. Transportation would be arranged with Laidlaw when school began on September 7, 1999. The District also offered TEC group/individual therapy at 45 minutes each per week, HCA individual counseling at 50-100 minutes weekly, and HCA collateral counseling at 50 minutes weekly. There was no signature on the line for parental consent, but the TEC program did commence one month later. (Pet. Ex. p-305.) STUDENT attended his first day of school at TEC on September 7, 1999. On September 8 and 10 he was absent. On September 20, there was a report of oral threats to his one-on-one aide. On September 22, he was absent. On September 27, there was an incident involving destruction of property, oral threats, and physical violence, including throwing furniture at other students. (Pet. Ex. p-316.) On September 28, STUDENT was placed on independent study. A September 29 letter from the County of Orange to STUDENT’s surrogate stated that STUDENT was being placed under house arrest, and there was some concern about whether a meeting could occur as scheduled on September 30 to discuss the transition to TEC. (Pet. Ex. p-311, Joint Ex. p. 82.) The meeting did occur on September 30, with STUDENT’s parole officer present. From October 1 through 29, STUDENT was “not in attendance.” From November 1 through 18, there were thirteen excused absences. From December 1 through 17, there were an additional thirteen excused absences. (Pet. Ex. p-316.) The record does not indicate the dates that STUDENT was under house arrest and whether the house arrest contributed to his absences from TEC.
On January 3, 2000, OCBHA sent a letter to the District regarding the scheduling of a new IEP meeting to discuss case management issues including school-related issues and the provision of services through HCA. (Pet. Ex. p-314.) There had been an intent to schedule the meeting since October 1999.
On January 4, 2000, Daniel Kane took work packets from TEC to the mother’s home. After the third week of January, the mother informed Mr. Kane that he did not need to return to her home to instruct STUDENT. Mr. Kane reported the mother’s request to Janet Eckleman, the site director at TEC. Ms. Eckleman told Mr. Kane to discontinue home instruction and wait for further instructions. On January 31, STUDENT was dropped from the TEC attendance register.
In March 2000, STUDENT was put back on the attendance register at TEC. Although he was marked in attendance for 22 days in March, STUDENT was not actually in attendance. Instead, TEC was sending work packets to his home. The work packets were periodically retrieved by TEC and reviewed by a teacher. This continued through April 28, 2000, when an IEP meeting was held. (Pet. Ex. p-317 to 322, Joint Ex. p. 83 to 84.)
The main purpose of the April 28, 2000 IEP meeting was to establish a regular, daily, home-teaching schedule. The schedule would start with 3 one-hour sessions and then increase, with the goal being to re-integrate STUDENT into the program at TEC starting one hour daily, 3 times per week, then increasing to 5 times weekly. There were six goals and objectives attached. There was no provision for a behavior plan, an aide, counseling, or DIS services. The mother signed her consent to the program. Commencement of instruction was delayed due to staffing problems at TEC. Instruction started on May 15, 2000. The TEC workers complained that the mother’s home was unsafe due to wasps. TEC ceased the instructional services after only two sessions, pending recommendation of an alternate site. (Joint Ex. p. 86 to 87.)
On July 17, 2000, the court-appointed educational surrogate sent a written request to the District for an IEP meeting. (Pet. Ex. p-326.) On August 2, 2000, counsel for the District sent a letter to counsel for STUDENT stating that the District was interested in resolving the matter quickly and that “District and we believe [HCA] are willing to place STUDENT in a residential placement but mother is opposed. Please call me ASAP to discuss.” (Pet. Ex. p-327.)
An IEP meeting was held on August 4, 2000. (Pet. Ex. p-328.) The recommended program, consented to by the mother, included one-on-one instruction at Goodwill (Industries) for vocational training and daily nutrition instruction for a minimum of 60 minutes daily up to 120 minutes daily, 5 times per week, depending upon STUDENT’s tolerance level. The IEP was not implemented. Goodwill had not been spoken to specifically about STUDENT prior to the offer, and Goodwill subsequently refused to accept STUDENT.
On September 8, 2000, the attorney for the District, Mr. Wenkart, wrote a letter to the juvenile court judge requesting his assistance in getting the mother to sign the August 4, 2000 IEP so that STUDENT could be placed at Goodwill Industries. (Pet Ex. p-336.) It is unknown why this letter was sent, since the mother’s signature appears on the consent portion of that IEP. On October 10, 2000, Mr. Wenkart wrote to Ms. Cromer and again stated the District’s belief that STUDENT should be placed in a residential facility. The letter states: “. . . District hereby offers to place STUDENT in a residential placement (e.g., Day Star) that would be appropriate. We will be glad to work with you, the family, and the juvenile court to provide an appropriate residential placement or day treatment facility such as College Park. The [District] will make a referral to [HCA] for assessment for residential placement.” The letter concludes by requesting the mother’s consent for records releases and assessment, and by stating that home teaching would not be offered as a temporary placement because in the past it had been unsafe for the teacher. (Pet. Ex. p-336.)
On October 18, 2000, Mr. Wenkart wrote another letter to Ms. Cromer “to clarify and modify” the October 10 letter. The October 18 letter states: “Pursuant to Government Code Section 7572.5, the [District] is interested in convening an expanded IEP meeting to include [HCA] for the purpose of discussing residential placement. The [HCA] may wish to assess STUDENT. [Mother’s] consent will be necessary. If [HCA] recommends residential placement, the [District] will support residential placement for STUDENT.” (Pet. Ex. p-337.)
Dr. Patterson submitted a psycho-educational assessment update on October 12, 2000, for the purpose of assisting the IEP team in determining an appropriate placement for STUDENT. (Pet. Ex. p-338.) Dr. Patterson reviewed the history available since his previous report in March 1999. Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT appeared to require a structured educational setting where there would be no intervention from his mother. Dr. Patterson recommended placement in a residential, nonpublic school setting where staff have familiarity in dealing with students with disruptive behaviors who are also seriously emotionally disturbed. He also recommended a program where positive reinforcement was used and where a number of functional replacement behaviors are developed for each student. Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT also needed development of appropriate social skills and the language of social skill interaction, which had not developed. He needed assistance in developing an understanding of his own strengths and weaknesses, which would lead to the development of a more accurate self-concept. He needed a program for acquisition of skills that would allow him to eventually return to his home school district. For STUDENT to return to his home school district, he would also require a transition program, developed very slowly and carefully.
An expanded IEP meeting was held on October 26, 2000. (Pet. Ex. p-348a.) The plan was to abandon the August 4, 2000 IEP, which had failed to place STUDENT at Goodwill Industries, and then reinstate a modified version of the April 28, 2000 IEP. The result was that STUDENT would receive home teaching at Portola 3 times per week. The home teaching would eventually be increased to 5 times per week. The IEP team would later offer nonpublic school placement options, such as College Park, pending a visit and approval by the family. The District requested an AB 2726 assessment referral to HCA, and the mother consented. The mother and STUDENT were understood to be very much against residential placement. The mother agreed that the District could contract with Dr. Tom Willis at IABA for a functional analysis across all environments, including her home.
A neuropsychological evaluation was performed on November 8, 2000, by Shirley Lanyi, Ph.D. (Pet. Ex. p-351.) Dr. Lanyi’s tests and recommendations were extensive. Basically, she recommended that a certification such as multiple handicapped might be useful, since STUDENT at various times had been categorized as being developmentally delayed, having an emotional disturbance, and having specific learning disabilities. Dr. Lanyi concluded that STUDENT required placement in a highly specialized special education setting with a very small student-teacher ratio which would address his learning and social emotional needs. STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors were likely used by him as a defense mechanism against ridicule or the fear of ridicule for his deficits. With a smaller group or one-on-one instruction, he would be less likely to experience such ridicule and less likely to use his inappropriate behaviors. Dr. Lanyi recommended in-depth assessment of STUDENT’s speech and language functioning to rule out central auditory processing disorder (CAPD). STUDENT also needed a vision exam and a sleep deprived EEG with testing for photosensitivity for seizures, as he had displayed a tendency to “space out.” Because of his excessive weight, it was important to schedule frequent breaks for physical activity. Because learning was extremely stressful for STUDENT, he needed assistance in learning strategies that would help him achieve increased internal control and learning opportunities in a multi-sensory format. A functional analysis and behavior intervention plan was needed, as well as monitoring of medications. The report concluded that for STUDENT to benefit from any type of mental health intervention while in the primary care of his mother, it would be important for her to gain a clearer understanding and acceptance, if possible, of her son’s many challenges.
As to placement, Dr. Lanyi concluded that a residential treatment setting could provide STUDENT with very intensive services for a period of time that would be geared toward addressing his social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties while improving his adaptive skills and ability to function more independently. Although STUDENT and his mother were very close, his dependency on her had prevented him from learning how to cope more adaptively with everyday challenges. An intensive treatment program that the mother also participated in could more easily facilitate change for STUDENT and the family system. Vocational planning and training should be included in the school programs. His interest in computers should be further explored. Reviewing himself on videotape with trained mental health personnel, done very carefully, could be very helpful in giving STUDENT a better visual understanding of a behavioral situation. Any change in his program would likely be met with fear, displayed as anger and frustration and withdrawal. Over time he would need to learn how to tolerate increasing amounts of discomfort to become more adaptable. Because of STUDENT’s limited verbal skills, “talk therapy” approaches were not recommended. Dr. Lanyi suggested alternatives, such as cognitive behavioral approaches, eye movement desensitization reprocessing, and nonverbal approaches such as art therapy.
By referral from the District, Marc Pastore, MS, CCC, prepared a speech and language auditory perceptual report on November 14, 2000. (Pet. Ex. p-402.) Testing and evaluation by Mr. Pastore demonstrated a severe delay in STUDENT’s ability to understand words being used by others. He ranked in the zero to first percentile in receptive and expressive language. He had severe delays in the ability to explain inferences, determine causes of problems, understand negative why questions, determine solutions to problems, and comprehend how to address problems as they emerge. STUDENT demonstrated significant difficulties in all areas of language development in addition to having a diagnosed hearing loss. In the testing situation, he was compliant, but very distractible. He did not appear aware of his limitations in expressing himself or in understanding directions from the examiner. Testing results confirmed significant difficulties in processing auditory information. When asked to follow directions, he was often unable to remember, understand, and execute the commands. He demonstrated difficulty with self-expression and understanding the pragmatics of language. His inability to use social language was significantly affecting his ability to relate to others. The report provided recommendations and strategies, including environmental and behavior modification strategies.
An assessment plan was signed by the parent on January 16, 2001, for a “Functional Analysis-IABA” and for assessment of motor abilities, including muscle coordination and/or visual perceptual skills. (Pet. Ex. p-408.)
STUDENT’s present levels of performance in an adapted physical education scale, as rated by the District on February 2, 2001, were in the 10 to 50 percent range. (Pet. Ex. p-409.) The District performed an audiogram on STUDENT on February 14, 2001, and STUDENT passed the hearing screening in both ears. (Pet. Ex. p-410.)
On March 16, 2001, a “Comprehensive Functional Assessment and Recommended Support Plan” was completed by Thomas Willis, Ph.D., from IABA (Institute for Applied Behavior Analysis) on March 16, 2001. (Pet. Ex. p-450.) The referral had been made by Ms. Shipcott. The report is 111 pages. Dr. Willis conducted an exhaustive review of the available records and assessments on STUDENT dating back to kindergarten in 1989. He also interviewed STUDENT, the mother, and various professionals involved with STUDENT. Dr. Willis found that STUDENT was functioning 5 to 10 years below his expected grade level. There was a question as to whether his failure to progress was the result of an underlying cognitive/learning disability, the amount of time he had lost being out of school, or the limited schooling he had received, such as home teaching. At his present rate of instruction, consisting of about 3 hours per week of home teaching in the Portola facility, STUDENT would need nine years of instruction to receive the amount of instruction that an average student might receive in one year. STUDENT had been receiving home teaching from Anne Slagle since November 22, 2000, utilizing a room set aside at Portola Middle School. To make up for his losses, Dr. Willis believed STUDENT needed 24 hours per day, 7 days per week, of behavioral and educational remediation. It was Dr. Willis’s impression that STUDENT did not have the time for something to happen piecemeal. He required full implementation of a multi-element treatment plan by an agency and people who have a “zero-reject policy.” Dr. Willis stated “with great assurance” that restraint, seclusion, time-out, and suspensions had taught STUDENT nothing. Because of the failure of those procedures and STUDENT’s increasing size (about 6' 2" and nearly 500 pounds), the consequences had escalated to police intervention and arrest. There was no question that STUDENT had not had the benefit of a truly positive support plan.
Regarding STUDENT’s mother, Dr. Willis stated his opinion that she did not have a commitment to counseling. Dr. Willis stated that this was not surprising, because the mother did not believe that STUDENT had a problem. STUDENT needed counseling, and it was difficult for Dr. Willis to see that happening when the mother was not in support of counseling and did not believe STUDENT had a problem for which counseling was necessary.
Dr. Willis concluded that STUDENT’s educational and behavioral needs could not be met in his current living arrangement. Instead, STUDENT required a living arrangement that could provide treatment his entire waking day and throughout the night (24-hour treatment). He stated that this could be accomplished in a residential school where all of his services were localized and provided by a single agency. According to Dr. Willis, the key to success of such a support arrangement would be the ability to implement the recommendations in his report. Dr. Willis also stated that STUDENT required consistent treatment and follow-through by a board-certified psychiatrist and ongoing counseling to help him with his emotions and the suspicion and distrust that he has lived with for so many years.
The next IEP meeting was on March 19, 2001. (Pet. Ex. p-412.) Dr. Willis’s report was reviewed. The IEP team discussed the option of residential placement and the option of an “individualized school based program” (ISBP). It was agreed that the District’s staff would further discuss the ISBP outside the IEP meeting and then respond to the Petitioner’s counsel. The District requested the mother’s consent for evaluation for residential placement. HCA agreed to do the evaluation, but the mother refused to consent. The District stated that if HCA did an evaluation and recommended residential placement, the District would support that decision. Meanwhile, the District offered 60 minutes of speech and language, 5 times per week, and 60 minutes “home,” 3 times per week. (Joint Ex. p. 100.) Proposed goals and objectives were provided in academics, speech and language, and vocational skills. STUDENT’s counsel and the mother’s counsel agreed to review those goals and objectives and provide recommendations to the District. A dissent by the Petitioner’s counsel listing 17 items was attached. (Pet. Ex. p-423.) An assessment plan was signed for vision, central auditory processing, and assistive technology. (Pet. Ex. p-424.)
An April 16, 2001 letter from Ms. Cromer to Mr. Wenkart states Ms. Cromer’s understanding that before she and Ms. Loyer reviewed the goals and objectives offered by the District, the District would first make some changes to address the Petitioner’s objections regarding the goals and objectives not being written to the curriculum, not being measurable, not being clear as to their purpose, and not addressing DIS. Ms. Cromer stated that she was still waiting for those revisions from the District. Meanwhile, speech and language services were not being provided. (Pet. Ex. p-426.)
Mr. Wenkart sent a reply to Ms. Cromer dated April 20, 2001. He stated his understanding that basically it was the Petitioner’s turn to make specific suggestions on revising the goals and objectives, and that the Petitioner did not want speech and language services to commence until agreement was reached on the goals and objectives. Mr. Wenkart stated that the District was willing to commence speech and language services, but that first a consent was needed from the mother. He also listed some concerns about the mother’s declining a central auditory processing assessment and being unavailable by phone to arrange a vision therapy and assistive technology assessment.
By his letter dated May 15, 2001, Mr. Wenkart notified Ms. Cromer that on May 2, 2001, he had been advised that HCA would be recommending residential placement for STUDENT. He also stated that the District would support residential placement for STUDENT.
An IEP meeting was held on the morning of June 19, 2001, prior to commencement of the due process hearing that same morning. Goals and objectives were discussed. (Declaration of Mr. Wenkart.) HCA recommended residential placement for STUDENT. (Testimony of Mr. Robles.)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. (1): Did the District fail to offer a free appropriate public education to the Petitioner for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years?
Under State and federal law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Secs. 56000, 56031. The term “free appropriate public education” means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8).
The term “special education” means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services,” at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
The parameters for adequacy of a student’s IEP are set forth in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982). The United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-208.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitiled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
In summary, there are three inquiries. One inquiry is whether a school district has complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Another inquiry is whether, under the IDEA and Rowley, the proposed educational program offered by a school district is designed to meet the student’s unique needs, is reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and comports with the student’s IEP. A third inquiry is whether the proposed program provides for an education in the least restrictive environment.
The 1997-1998 School Year(Footnote 8)
Substantive Appropriateness
STUDENT’s Needs. Before determining whether the programs offered to STUDENT by the District for the 1997-1998 school year satisfied the requirements of FAPE, it is necessary to have an understanding of STUDENT’s unique needs as that school year approached.
STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition as listed by the District had been ED since 1995. At Rossier from 1993 to 1996, he had been very assaultive to school staff and damaging to school property. The 1996 triennial assessment states STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties had escalated to a level where police intervention was required on at least three occasions. STUDENT’s behavioral difficulties had been marked by anger, aggression, and extremely low frustration tolerance. STUDENT needed an effective program to address his behaviors.
In addition to his ED, STUDENT had other disabilities and deficits when he entered the 1997-1998 school year. He had originally been classified by the District as LH (learning handicapped). In 1992 he scored at the first percentile on the Vineland scale in communication, daily living skills, and socialization. STUDENT had consistently performed at several grades below his expected grade level based on age. The District’s triennial assessment in 1996 confirmed continuing delays in academic, self-help, pre-vocational, and visual-motor areas. He had failed a hearing screening in his right ear. Academic performance in his sixth-grade year was at levels ranging from K.0 to 2.0.
As STUDENT started his eighth-grade school year, no present levels of performance were listed on his November 25, 1997 IEP. However, the proposed goals and objectives give some general indication of his levels of performance. Eight academic goals and objectives were listed, including one self-help goal regarding STUDENT being able to say and write his name, birthday, address, and phone number; a sensory motor goal regarding printing in small-case letters; and two social/emotional goals regarding working with a teacher to orally resolve frustration issues and using words to clearly express his feelings and desires.
One of the consequences of STUDENT’s ED had been limited exposure to teaching. Initial programs in kindergarten and first grade were designed for 20 minutes to one hour per day. Following his termination at Rossier, STUDENT had the erratic home-teaching program for the 1996-1997 school year. The history also shows that the conduct of STUDENT’s mother contributed to his termination at Rossier and the District’s difficulties in staffing the home-teaching position.
STUDENT needed a program that would address his assaultive and out-of-control behaviors, his communication deficits, his overall academic deficits, his hearing deficit, his visual motor delays, and his pre-vocational delays. He also needed intervention to either address or circumvent the inability of his mother to work with the school District and his teachers in a cooperative manner. Most importantly, this child needed an intensive program.
The District’s Offers and Programs. In response to STUDENT’s needs for the 1997-1998 school year, at the November 25, 1997 IEP meeting the District offered home teaching at Portola, 60 minutes per session, 5 sessions per week, with a further meeting to develop goals. The IEP lists no specific designated instruction or services (DIS). There were goals and objectives as listed above, to be implemented by the home teacher, the mother, and STUDENT.
At the next IEP meeting on January 15, 1998, home teaching was again recommended by the District, to be reviewed in four weeks. Home teaching would be 1½ hours per day. The mother gave oral consent to this IEP. Three additional goals and objectives were added regarding behavior, again to be implemented by the home teacher, the mother, and STUDENT.
The District’s recommendation at the February 12, 1998 IEP meeting was placement at STUDENT’s school of residence, with a program consisting of 35 percent in regular education, 4 daily periods in SDC, extended school year, and a regular physical education period daily. However, the District consented to the mother’s preference of continuing in his home program.(Footnote 9)
Discussion. Until the February 12, 1998 IEP meeting, the District’s response to STUDENT’s academic deficits was to offer 1 to 1 ½ hours per day of home teaching. This was grossly inadequate for an eighth-grade student who was performing at kindergarten to second-grade levels.
At the February 12, 1998 IEP meeting the District finally attempted to address the insufficiency of school hours by recommending placement at STUDENT’s school of residence, with a program centered on four periods in SDC per day, plus a regular physical education period. However, the District’s offer was still deficient. STUDENT’s difficulties in expressing himself orally suggested speech and language deficits, but no speech and language services were offered and no speech and language assessment was recommended. His reported hearing deficits were not addressed. His visual motor delays and pre-vocational delays were not addressed, except to the extent they may have been touched upon in the goals and objectives regarding STUDENT writing his name and address and printing small case letters.
The most glaring deficiency in the District’s SDC proposal was the lack of an appropriate program to address STUDENT’s behaviors. STUDENT’s longstanding history of aggressive behaviors begged for the design and implementation of a behavioral intervention plan, administered on a consistent basis by trained personnel.(Footnote 10) His more recent behaviors may have been less newsworthy to the District due to his isolation in a home-teaching program since May 1996, but based on his overall history it was clear that any attempt to transition STUDENT into an SDC program would require a comprehensive and strictly implemented behavior plan.
The mother refused to consent to the District’s SDC proposal. Ironically, she insisted on continuing the 1½ hour per day home-teaching program, which had even greater deficiencies than the District’s SDC-based offer. The District relented. By agreeing to the home-teaching program, the District chose to placate the mother rather than confront the fact that STUDENT’s educational program would remain grossly insufficient unless the District resorted to due process procedures.(Footnote 11)
The Hearing Officer finds that the programs offered by the District for the 1997-1998 school year were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and they were not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. There was no plan to address STUDENT’s behaviors. There were no speech and language services. There was no plan to address STUDENT’s visual motor delays and pre-vocational delays. There was no plan to address his academic deficits. The District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 16, 1997, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year.(Footnote 12)
Procedural Appropriateness
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56343 provides that an IEP team shall meet upon the occurrence of certain events that are specified in that statute. Meetings are required at least annually and whenever the pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress.
The District waited until November 25, 1997, to convene an IEP meeting following STUDENT’s termination from Rossier in May 1996. This violated the provisions of Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56343 regarding the requirement that IEP teams meet at least annually, and whenever there is a lack of anticipated progress demonstrated. Dismissal from school is a clear indication there has been or will soon be a lack of anticipated progress, regardless of whether or not the mother’s attitude was the reason for STUDENT’s dismissal from Rossier.
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 lists numerous items that are required to be included in IEPs. Without doing an exhaustive comparison of those requirements to the three IEPs issued during the 1997-1998 school year, it is sufficient to note that all three IEPs failed to show present levels of performance. The February 12, 1998 IEP stated no goals and objectives. These are violations of Sec. 56345.
Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the pupil or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
The delay in conducting an IEP meeting for the 1997-1998 school year did seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. However, the importance of that infringement to this Decision is diminished because of the applicable three-year statute of limitations. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(j). STUDENT’s due process hearing request was filed on October 16, 2000. Therefore, relief applicable to the District’s delay in convening an IEP meeting can only arise from violations occurring after the limitations date of October 16, 1997.
Apart from the delays, the mother’s ability to meaningfully participate in the IEP process was seriously infringed upon because of deficiencies in the three IEPs for the 1997-1998 school year. The District’s view or data on present levels of performance was not stated. Therefore, the mother was denied important information affecting her right to meaningfully participate in developing goals and objectives to meet her son’s needs. Goals and objectives were not stated in the February 12, 1998 IEP. The failure to state goals and objective’s also impaired the mother’s right to meaningful participation in the IEP process. Without stated goals and objectives, the mother could not evaluate the intended nexus, if any, between the District’s program offer and STUDENT’s unique needs.
It has already been determined, in considering the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offers, that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE from October 16, 1997, through the end of the 1997-1998 school year. The Hearing Officer also finds that from October 16, 1997, through the remainder of the 1997-1998 school year, the procedural violations regarding failure to timely convene an IEP meeting, failure to state goals and objectives, and failure to state present levels of performance, when considered collectively in this case, constituted a denial of FAPE to STUDENT.
The 1998-1999 School Year
Substantive Appropriateness
STUDENT’s Needs. As the 1998-1999 school year began, STUDENT still needed a program to address his assaultive and out-of-control behaviors, his oral communication deficits, his overall academic deficits, his hearing deficit, his visual motor delays, and his pre-vocational delays. He needed intervention to either address or circumvent the inability of his mother to work with the school District and his teachers in a constructive and cooperative manner. This was well illustrated by the District’s retreating from its recommendation for an SDC program in February 1998 and, instead, agreeing with the mother for continuation of a home-teaching program.
The District’s Program Offers. Commencing on September 24, 1998, the agreed-upon program pursuant to an IEP addendum was to release STUDENT from home teaching to start four daily SDC periods, plus regular education electives, at Orange High School. This IEP addendum was essentially an implementation of the District’s initial recommendations at the February 12, 1998 IEP, before the District had relented to the continuation of home teaching. There was no behavior support plan with the IEP addendem. The IEP addendum listed no present levels of performance. There were no new goals and objectives. The last goals and objectives had been written for the January 15, 1998 IEP and were designed for a 1 ½ hour per day home teaching program. Part of the placement plan by the District and the mother included concealing from Orange High School the details about STUDENT’s past, for the purpose of seeing what would happen if STUDENT started on a “clean slate.”
Reports of behavioral events, including kicking another student and intimidating the cafeteria manager, commenced within two weeks after the placement. The latter incident resulted in STUDENT’s first suspension at Orange High School. The response of the IEP team at the October 19, 1998 meeting was to increase the SDC periods from 4 to 5 periods per day. There were 4 categories of annual goals and objectives listed in the IEP consisting of behavior skills, writing, reading, and math, to be implemented by the SDC teacher, the regular education teacher, the mother, and STUDENT. The December 8 incident involving a propelled desk and resulting classroom evacuation led to an IEP meeting on December 16. There was discussion regarding behavior, alternative placement, and an “AB 3632" referral to HCA. A goal and objective was added regarding improvement of frustration tolerance. The mother signed her consent to a “functional behavior analysis” of STUDENT. STUDENT’s behavioral history in the Orange High School placement culminated in the March 15, 1999 incident, when STUDENT reportedly was out-of-control in a District office, ripping papers, throwing papers at a person, throwing magazines on the floor, stating he meant business, and stating he was going to get a gun and shoot his aide, kill that person and his whole family, and kill him tomorrow.
STUDENT did show some temporary gains at Orange High School. In October it was reported he had made no friends, was below age level socially and emotionally, had slow motor skills, needed direct instruction consistently, and was consistently late to class. On the report card from Orange High School in November 1998, STUDENT was noted to have excessive absences, incomplete homework, and disruptive/inconsiderate behavior, but he was also reported to be interested in learning and was trying hard to learn. The January 1999 report card showed good grades and comments that STUDENT was a pleasure to have in class. In March 1999, Orange High School sent a letter to STUDENT’s mother congratulating her on STUDENT’s being placed on the honor roll at the end of the first semester. Also in March, he was reported by his SDC teacher as learning to relate to his peers and reaching out to them with teasing and joking.
In spite of STUDENT’s temporary improvement, present levels of performance bearing the date of March 1, 1999, showed grade-equivalent performance ranging from first-grade to third-grade levels. By the middle of March, his behaviors had led to incarceration in juvenile hall, where he remained for several months.
In total, there were seven IEP meetings from September 23, 1998, to May 19, 1999. The first IEP placed STUDENT at Orange High School without a behavioral intervention plan. The subsequent IEPs were in response to his multiple behavioral incidents, culminating in the last IEP being held at Otto Fischer School during STUDENT’s incarceration in Orange County Juvenile Hall.
Discussion. In September 1998 the District placed STUDENT in the untenable position of trying to succeed in high school with no credible behavioral support plan to assist this child. STUDENT needed a functional analysis assessment and a behavioral intervention plan. None was forthcoming. Predictably, STUDENT’s placement at Orange High School without the appropriate behavioral supports culminated in his incarceration at the Orange County Juvenile Hall by March 1999. The December 16 referral to HCA for an AB3632 assessment was a positive step, but because of scheduling delays the assessment was not commenced until STUDENT’s incarceration, and it was not completed until July 1, 1999. In any event, the referral for an HCA assessment should have been made during the prior school year, if not earlier.
The IEP implemented on September 24, 1998, which placed STUDENT at Orange High School, listed no present levels of performance and contained no goals and objectives. The next IEP on October 19, 1998, did contain present levels of performance and goals and objectives, but the parties agree the annual goals were not measurable and there were no social and emotional goals, even though it was identified that STUDENT had no friends and required a behavior intervention plan. (Joint Ex. p. 54.) The IEPs that initiated STUDENT’s ill-fated stay at Orange High School were thus deficient on their face. Furthermore, there still was no provision for speech and language services, no provision for counseling and/or therapy, and nothing was done to address STUDENT’s reported hearing deficit. The March 15 incident at Orange High School led to an agreement for an independent evaluation by Dr. Patterson. Although the evaluation by Dr. Patterson was not completed until April 1999, his report confirms what should have been obvious to the District long before the commencement of the 1998-1999 school year. STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors were a manifestation of his ED handicapping condition. STUDENT needed a functional analysis assessment and a behavioral intervention plan. STUDENT needed an extremely modified educational setting where a behavior plan could be implemented and educational deficits could be addressed. STUDENT needed cognitive therapy to teach him how to better relate to his peers and how to deal with his feelings and emotions. He needed social skills training. He needed behavioral therapy and training for his mother if he was to remain at home. He needed some type of intervention to address the behavior and/or decision making of his mother.
In summary, for the 1998-1999 school year the District did not offer an educational program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and the District did not offer a program that was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year.
Procedural Appropriateness
The main contentions that the Petitioner raises as procedural violations have been addressed above as substantive violations. The Petitioner has made other claims of procedural violations by the District for the 1998-1998 school year, but analysis of those allegations would have no effect on the resolution of the issues presented for hearing.
The 1999-2000 School Year
Substantive Appropriateness
STUDENT’s Unique Needs. STUDENT completed the 1998-1999 school year at the Otto Fischer School while institutionalized through the Orange County Juvenile Court. This resulted in some additional assessments by OCDE and IEPs by OCDE and the District during STUDENT’s stay in the juvenile hall.
An eligibility statement prepared by the District and consented to by the mother on May 19, 1999, lists specific learning disability (SLD) criteria as general academic skills in classroom, auditory and visual processing, sensory motor skills, all as a result of developmental delay and emotional disturbances. STUDENT also met the criteria for ED.
A speech and language report was issued on June 30, 1999, pursuant to a referral by the Otto Fischer School. The assessment team concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education services as a speech and language impaired student. STUDENT had mild to moderate speech production difficulties involving certain sounds. Speech fluency was interrupted by word-finding difficulty, frequent use of fillers and pauses, and whole word and whole phrase repetitions. Overall oral language skills were reduced compared to his ability levels. He displayed mildly reduced skills in listening comprehension. In the area of semantics, receptive and expressive oral vocabulary were significantly reduced for his age. His oral language skills were below average in syntax and grammar. He demonstrated reduced pragmatics or social skills.
The “AB3632/882-Chapter 26.5 Assessment” was completed by HCA while STUDENT was in placement at Orange County Juvenile Hall. The July 1, 1999 report concluded that STUDENT had limitations in his cognitive and social adaptive behaviors, and that previous testing suggested significant developmental delays in the borderline range of functioning. Recommended services included individual and family therapy to address his anger management issues, defiant behaviors, and depression. Also recommended were continuing supportive services through the Orange County Regional Center, neurological testing, and referral to a behavioral neurologist who has worked with children with significant behavioral problems. A service plan was attached (HCA Ex. 5).
The record shows that STUDENT’s unique needs leading into the 1999-2000 school year remained the same as in prior years, with the additional factor of speech and language deficits having been assessed and confirmed in greater detail.
The District’s Offers and Programs. At the IEP meeting conducted by the District on July 29, 1999, the recommended program was placement at TEC, a nonpublic school, with SDC for 300 minutes daily, TEC counseling 45 minutes weekly, one period daily of physical education, extended school year as needed, and transportation. CYS, a division of HCA, offered to provide individual therapy 1-2 times per week at the TEC school site, and collateral counseling to include the mother either at TEC or at CYS. The mother was to visit the school site before making a decision.
An IEP addendum dated August 5, 1999, states the District was offering one hour per month of speech and language services, TEC group and individual therapy at 45 minutes each per week, HCA individual counseling at 50-100 minutes weekly, and HCA collateral counseling at 50 minutes weekly. Carmen Rivera-Tara at TEC and Ms. Shipcott at the District were to work together to obtain the services of a trained behavior instructional assistant. Transportation services would be arranged. It is not clear from the record whether STUDENT was still going to receive 300 minutes weekly of SDC. SDC is not mentioned in the IEP addendum. (Pet. Ex. p-305.)
Parent consent was not signed on the IEP addendum. However, STUDENT did attend his first day of school at TEC on September 7, 1999. Immediately thereafter, STUDENT’s course at TEC degenerated into a series of extended absences, multiple behavioral incidents including throwing furniture at students, meetings with a parole officer, placement under house arrest, and an erratic independent home study program where STUDENT would periodically have his school assignments dropped off and picked up by TEC personnel.
The independent home study program continued into April 2000. The District held an IEP meeting on April 28, 2000. The agreed-upon plan was to establish a regular, daily, home teaching schedule. The schedule would start with 3 one-hour sessions and then increase, with the eventual objective being to re-integrate STUDENT into the program at TEC starting one hour daily, 3 times per week, then increasing to five times weekly. There were six goals and objectives attached. There was no indication of a behavior plan, counseling, or speech and language services. Instructional services ceased after two visits because of wasps at STUDENT’s home.
Discussion. The District’s program offers on July 29 and August 5, 1999, did address some of STUDENT’s needs that had been either completely or periodically ignored in the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years. STUDENT needed a more specialized teaching environment, which was offered at TEC. STUDENT needed an intensive educational program, which was offered at least initially as 300 minutes per day of SDC. STUDENT needed practical cognitive therapy and social skills training, which would presumably be addressed to some extent by TEC and HCA counseling. STUDENT needed counseling for his mother, which was offered as collateral counseling through HCA.
Unfortunately for STUDENT, the District’s offers again had serious flaws. There was no indication of services specifically designed to address STUDENT’s specific learning disabilities. The IEP of July 29, 1999, listed no goals and objectives and stated that goals and objectives would be developed and presented at a later date. No goals and objectives were listed on the August 5, 1999 IEP.
STUDENT still needed a formal behavioral intervention plan, which again was not provided. The offer of a trained behavioral instructional assistant was grossly insufficient to address STUDENT’s severe behavior problems, especially with no present levels of performance or goals and objectives listed in the IEP.
STUDENT needed speech and language services. His speech and language deficits were affecting his academic performance, his social skills, and his ability to express or discuss his frustrations without resorting to aggressive, assaultive, and destructive behaviors. These were longstanding deficits that had been ignored for years. The District’s offer in response to STUDENT’s speech and language deficits, as this Hearing Officer understands the applicable IEPs, was a scant one hour per month of speech and language consult. Susan Berkowitz, a speech pathologist, testified that one hour per month of speech and language consultation would not meet STUDENT’s needs. She testified that STUDENT’s needs required direct-intervention therapy, at least twice per week in 30-45 minute sessions, depending on his tolerance.
STUDENT needed intervention from his IEP team when the plan the District devised for him at TEC fell into disarray within the first weeks of September 1999. No IEP meeting was held until April 2000. By that time, the plan for intensive services at TEC had first disintegrated into no program whatsoever and then rematerialized as a disjointed home-study program.
When the District did convene an IEP meeting on April 28, 2000, the agreed-upon offer was to restart the failed home-teaching through TEC, with the ultimate goal being to reintegrate STUDENT into the previously failed program on the premises at TEC. This cannot be construed as a program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.
For the 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The District failed to offer a program reasonably calculated to provide academic benefit to STUDENT. Furthermore, although implementing the deficient IEPs still would have resulted in failure to provide a FAPE, the District failed make a reasonable effort to implement the IEPs for the school year by ignoring the failures at TEC and not addressing the location problem caused by the wasps.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer a FAPE to STUDENT for the 1999-2000 school year.
Procedural Appropriateness
The Petitioner has asserted procedural violations in the 1999-2000 school year. Most of those allegations have already been addressed above as substantive violations, and resolution of the remainder would not affect the ultimate findings in this Decision.
The 2000-2001 School Year
Substantive Appropriateness
STUDENT’s Unique Needs. STUDENT’s need for intensive services was increasing. Academically, he continued to fall further behind his expected grade level due to the minimal, if not negligible, teaching time he had received for several years. His behavior, in the context of his size and age, increased the probability of an event having disastrous consequences.
There were several assessments during the 2000-2001 school year. On October 12, 2000, Dr. Patterson completed an update of his March 1999 report. Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT needed a structured educational setting where there would be no intervention from his mother. He recommended placement in a residential, nonpublic school setting where the staff was experienced in dealing with ED students who have disruptive behaviors. For his behavioral problems, he needed a positive reinforcement program with functional replacement behaviors. He needed to develop both social skills and the language of social skill interaction. He needed assistance in developing a more accurate self concept. Eventually, he would need a transition program back to his home school district.
Dr. Lanyi performed an extensive neuropsychological evaluation, completed on November 8, 2000. Dr. Lanyi concluded that a functional analysis [assessment] and behavior intervention plan were needed. She recommended a residential treatment setting so that STUDENT could receive very intensive services for a period of time geared toward addressing his social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties while improving his adaptive skills and ability to function more independently. He also needed vocational planning and training. He needed a better understanding of his behavioral situation.
A speech and language auditory perceptual report was completed by Marc Pastore on November 19, 2000. The report concluded that STUDENT ranked in the zero to first percentile in receptive and expressive language. STUDENT did not appear aware of his limitations in expressing himself or in understanding directions from the examiner. On February 14, 2001, STUDENT passed an audiogram for both ears.
Dr. Willis completed a “Comprehensive Functional Assessment and Recommended Support Plan” on March 16, 2001. To make up for his losses in instructional time, Dr. Willis concluded that STUDENT needed 24 hours per day, 7 days per week of behavioral and educational remediation. A multi-element treatment plan needed to be implemented by an agency and people who had a “zero-reject policy.” As did Dr. Patterson, Dr. Willis concluded that STUDENT needed a positive support plan. He observed that restraint, seclusion, time-out, and suspensions had taught STUDENT nothing. STUDENT also needed consistent treatment by a board-certified psychiatrist.
The District’s Offers and Programs. Pursuant to an agreed-upon IEP dated August 4, 2000, the planned program was focused on one-on-one instruction at Goodwill [Industries] for vocational training and daily nutrition a minimum of 60 minutes daily up to 120 minutes daily, five times per week based upon STUDENT’s tolerance level.(Footnote 13)
The plan to place STUDENT at Goodwill Industries was short-lived. Goodwill refused to accept STUDENT into its program. On October 10, 2000, the District notified STUDENT’s counsel that it was offering a residential placement for STUDENT. An expanded IEP meeting was held on October 26, 2000. The IEP team agreed to have an “AB 2726" assessment performed through HCA. It was agreed that Dr. Tom Willis would do a functional analysis assessment across all environments. Meanwhile, having not been accepted by Goodwill Industries, STUDENT needed an interim program. The IEP team decided to restart the April 28, 2000 IEP. The plan was for home teaching commencing at 3 hours per week, with eventual consideration of placement at College Park, a nonpublic school.
Following various assessments as described above, the next IEP meeting was held on March 19, 2001. The offer was 60 minutes of speech and language, 5 times per week; 60 minutes “home,” 3 times per week; no extended school year; no transportation; HCA 50 minutes, 3 times per week. Proposed goals and objectives were provided in academics, speech and language, and vocational. (Pet. Ex. p-424.)
During the next month, a stalemate developed. Counsel for the District and for STUDENT exchanged letters regarding a dispute about whether the District had agreed to revise the goals and objectives before STUDENT’s counsel would make further recommendations to the District regarding goals and objectives. STUDENT’s counsel expressed concern that speech and language services were not being given, and the District’s counsel expressed concern that the mother would not sign consents for speech and language services and further assessments.
Anne Slagle testified that she provided home teaching to STUDENT pursuant to the October 10, 2000 IEP 3 days per week, one hour per day. STUDENT’s attendance rate was about 50 percent. Amidst the procedural activities by the parties, STUDENT’s hours with Ms. Slagle constituted his academic program for the 2000-2001 school year.
Discussion. Although the August 4, 2000 IEP was agreed upon by STUDENT’s present counsel and court-appointed educational surrogate, that IEP contained no goals and objectives. It did not provide for speech and language services. It did not provide for academics, except for what STUDENT might have gleaned from working 60 minutes daily at the proposed Goodwill Industries placement and through the proposal for STUDENT to apparently engage in solo attempts at learning math, reading, and writing on a computer. In the Petitioner’s closing brief, these are the types of deficiencies which the Petitioner’s counsel consistently emphasized as constituting a denial of FAPE during prior school years.
The October 10, 2000 IEP provided for no speech and language services and was designed to resurrect the inadequate home-instruction services of the April 8, 2000 IEP. On the positive side, there was a plan to do the necessary assessments for eventually implementing behavioral supports. Unfortunately, Dr. Willis’s functional analysis assessment was not completed until March 16, 2001.
At the next IEP meeting on March 19, 2001, there was finally a reasonable provision for speech and language services after many years of that need being ignored. However, because the parties could not agree on other components of the plan, the speech and language services were not provided. The offer was for 60 minutes of home instruction, 3 times per week. Again, this was woefully inadequate to meet STUDENT’s academic needs.
The end-result of STUDENT’s 2000-2001 school year was 7 months of home-teaching at about 1 ½ hours per week, with no speech and language services and no behavioral intervention plan. The District failed to offer a program for the 2000-2001 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and failed to offer a program reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
Procedural Appropriateness
The Petitioner has alleged numerous procedural violations arising from the 2000-2001 school year IEP process. Those alleged violations primarily concern the March 19, 2001 IEP. The Petitioner asserts that the IEP, among other things (a) failed to fill in the blank for the assigned school, (b) erroneously listed ED as the primary handicapping condition, (c) did not adequately explain the meaning of 60 mins 3 x wk, (d) failed to identify whether transportation would be provided for his speech and language and HCA services, (e) did not describe the behavior strategies and supports which were claimed to be provided, and (f) failed to address the state “star” assessment.
The matter of STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition will be addressed elsewhere in this decision. The Hearing Officer will address the matter of the IEP not describing behavior strategies and supports, as this was also a contention by the Petitioner for other IEPs written by the District for the Petitioner. Page MIS 6-2 of the District’s preprinted IEP form contains a heading entitled “Special Factors Considered (Goals and Objectives Attached, as Appropriate).” Beneath that heading is a series of items with an optional box to be checked by each item. One of those items reads “Behavior strategies and supports,” and the box for that heading has consistently been checked on the Petitioner’s IEPs. The Petitioner claims the checking of that box confirms that behavior strategies and supports would be implemented, yet a plan for implementing those behavior strategies and supports is not attached to the IEP.
The Hearing Officer has determined that a consistent deficiency in STUDENT’s IEPs has been the failure to design and implement a behavior intervention plan to meet STUDENT’s needs. However, the section of the IEP to which the Petitioner objects is no more than a statement that behavior strategies and supports were considered in developing the IEP. It is not intended as a confirmation that behavioral supports were developed. This does not constitute a procedural violation.
The remaining procedural violations alleged by the Petitioner either have already been addressed as substantive violations, or are not addressed because their resolution would have no bearing on the ultimate findings in this decision.
Issue No. 2: What eligibility designation most appropriately reflects the Petitioner’s educational needs?
The Petitioner’s primary eligibility category listed on his IEPs since 1995 has been ED. The Petitioner claims the District has designed its programs for the ED category at the expense of giving adequate consideration to the Petitioner’s other impairments. The Petitioner asserts that he should be granted eligibility for special education under the category of “multiple disabilities.”
Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7(a) states: “As used in this part, the term child with a disability means a child evaluated . . . as having mental retardation, a hearing impairment, including deafness, a speech and language impairment, a visual impairment, including blindness, serious emotional disturbance (hereafter referred to as emotional disturbance), an orthopedic impairment, autism, traumatic brain injury, and other health impairment, a specific learning disability, deaf-blindness, or multiple disabilities, and who, by reason thereof, needs special education and related services.”
Sec. 300.7(c)(7) defines the term “multiple disabilities” as “concomitant impairments (such as mental retardation-blindness, mental retardation-orthopedic impairment, etc.), the combination of which causes such severe educational needs that they cannot be accommodated in special education programs solely for one of the impairments. The term does not include deaf-blindness.”
There can be no credible dispute that STUDENT meets the criteria for ED under Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(i)(2)(3). Consistent with the language of Sec. 3030(i)(2)(3), as a result of a serious emotional disturbance, STUDENT exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, and he exhibits inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in “several” situations.(Footnote 14) These characteristics have been exhibited to a marked degree over a long period of time, and they adversely affect his educational performance. STUDENT requires special education and related services to address his ED.
In addition to ED, STUDENT has other disabilities “concomitant to” or accompanying his ED. One of those concomitant disabilities is speech and language, as verified by the OCDE speech and language report dated June 30, 1999, and the speech and language auditory perceptual report dated November 14, 2000. (Pet. Ex. p-285, 402.) The combination of these disabilities does cause such severe educational needs that they cannot be accommodated in a special education program solely for one of the impairments. For example, placing STUDENT in a special education program solely for the purpose of addressing his ED would not meet his speech and language needs. A program addressing all of his deficits is necessary. This is consistent with the definition of multiple disabilities in the federal regulations.
In reply to the Petitioner’s request for the multiple disability designation, the District asserts that STUDENT’s educational needs could be accommodated in a placement for his emotional disability, such as a residential placement serving emotionally disturbed students, and therefore the definition of multiple disabilities is not satisfied. The District’s argument is non-responsive to the definition of multiple disabilities in Sec. 300.7(c)(7). The District’s argument would be correct if STUDENT’s educational needs could be met by putting him in such a placement and solely providing services to address his ED. No such plan has been suggested. Instead, a residential placement program for STUDENT would involve placing STUDENT in a residential facility serving emotionally disturbed students and concurrently rendering services in that facility to address his other disabilities. Such a plan is consistent with, not contrary to, the definition of multiple disabilities.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT meets the eligibility criteria of “multiple disabilities” as that term is defined in 34 C.F.R Sec. 300.7(c)(7). Those multiple disabilities include serious emotional disturbance and speech and language. STUDENT also exhibits one or more specific learning disabilities as described in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(j), including but not limited to visual processing, auditory processing, and sensory-motor skills as listed in the agreed-upon eligibility statement dated May 19, 1999. (Pet. Ex. p-280.) The identification and inclusion of other possible disabilities within the category of multiple disabilities is a matter for determination by STUDENT’s IEP team.(Footnote 15)
Issue No. 3: Is residential placement necessary for STUDENT to receive a program that is designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?
The experts who performed assessments of behalf of HCA recommended residential placement for STUDENT. Accordingly, HCA made a recommendation for residential placement at the June 19, 2001 IEP meeting.(Footnote 16) The District has supported HCA’s recommendation for residential placement. The Petitioner opposes residential placement. The Petitioner proposes an alternative plan by which he would receive continuous services at home and at school 24 hours per day, seven days per week.
Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031. A residential placement constitutes one of the most restrictive environments for a pupil. A residential placement may be inappropriate if the pupil’s needs can reasonably be met through any combination of nonresidential services, preventing the need for out-of-home care. Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 7572.5.
To determine whether residential placement is necessary for STUDENT to receive a program designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, it is necessary to: (I) identify STUDENT’s current unique needs, (II) identify the services that are required to address STUDENT’s needs and provide some educational benefit, and (III) consider whether those needs can be reasonably met through any combination of nonresidential services. If a residential placement is required, the Hearing Officer must determine (IV) the parameters of what constitutes an appropriate residential placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.(Footnote 17)
I. What are STUDENT’s current unique needs?
STUDENT has unique needs arising from his ED and behavior problems, his speech and language deficits, and his specific learning disabilities, including visual processing, auditory processing, and sensory motor skills. STUDENT has severe academic deficits; he is performing several years below his grade level. STUDENT also has unique needs arising from the difficulty he will have making a transition into adult life with a measure of independence and productivity.
II. What services are required to address STUDENT’s unique needs?
Until STUDENT’s adverse behaviors arising from his ED are sufficiently modified or eliminated, STUDENT’s ability to access and benefit from services designed to meet his unique needs will be suppressed. This is demonstrated by STUDENT’s history.
Programs that rely upon physical restraint, seclusion, time-out, or suspensions have not modified STUDENT’s behaviors to any significant degree. As Dr. Willis stated in his report, those procedures have taught STUDENT nothing. Dr. Patterson, Dr. Willis, and Dr. Lanyi stated that STUDENT needs a positive behavioral intervention plan. Such a plan includes systematic implementation of procedures designed to result in lasting positive changes in the individual’s behavior by targeting maladaptive behaviors and replacing them with positive behaviors (Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3001(d)(e)(f)(aa)).
In addition to implementation of a positive behavioral intervention plan, STUDENT, according to Dr. Willis, also needs ongoing counseling, which would include consistent treatment by a board-certified psychiatrist. This would help STUDENT with his emotions and the suspicions and distrust he has lived with for so many years. Dr. Lanyi recommended therapy, but because of STUDENT’s limited verbal skills, she questioned the usefulness of “talk therapy.” Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT needs cognitive therapy to teach him how to interact with people. He concurred that “insight therapy” would not be appropriate because STUDENT does not have the necessary language tools. Dr. Patterson stated that STUDENT needs assistance in developing an understanding of his own strengths and weaknesses, leading to the development of a more accurate self-concept. He also needs a waking and sleeping schedule, and he needs adaptive and social skills development.
The above-stated opinions are well-supported by the evidence and are consistent with STUDENT’s history. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that because of the severity of STUDENT’s ED, a program for STUDENT consistent with the FAPE requirements of meeting his unique needs and providing some educational benefit must, at the very least, be centered upon a positive behavioral intervention plan based on a functional analysis assessment, such as the plan outlined by Dr. Willis. The positive behavioral intervention plan must also incorporate ongoing counseling, preferably by a board-certified psychiatrist; cognitive therapy; and a waking and sleeping schedule. The plan must be strictly and consistently implemented 24 hours per day in a highly structured and controlled environment. The goals would be to ameliorate STUDENT’s ED, teach him a more accurate self-concept so that he can understand his strengths and weaknesses, and have him acquire social skills and a knowledge of how to interact with people.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT requires the development of a program that is consistent with his ability to tolerate the intensity of the program. The IEP team should anticipate that STUDENT’s ability to tolerate services will increase as his behavioral intervention plan proceeds. An overall goal must be for STUDENT to receive, depending on his tolerance, speech and language services, including direct intervention therapy at least twice per week in 30-45 minute sessions. Speech and language services are a critical priority because STUDENT needs alternative methods of expression and a better ability to communicate with those who are trying to counsel him and teach him. STUDENT also requires services to meet his needs arising from his specific learning disabilities. STUDENT requires a program to address his academic deficits and his vocational deficits, which means extended school year and teaching substantially beyond the scant 3 to 5 hours per week he has received in the past.(Footnote 18) With the proper services to support him, STUDENT may well be able to receive 3 to 5 hours per day of instruction, or more, instead of 3 to 5 hours per week. STUDENT must have a vocational program reasonably calculated to provide him with skills for gainful employment. STUDENT also needs a transition program designed to enable him to function in society as an adult with the self-help skills necessary for living on his own.
III. Can STUDENT’s needs be reasonably met through any combination of nonresidential services?
With the exception of placement, the basic services required for STUDENT have been identified above. The next question is whether those services can be appropriately delivered in a nonresidential placement. To answer that question, it is necessary to understand the experts’ opinions regarding the influence that STUDENT’s mother would likely have on the effectiveness of his program, and it is necessary to consider alternatives to nonresidential services.
The Influence of STUDENT’s Mother. Dr. Patterson, Dr. Willis, Dr. Mullen, and Dr. Lanyi concur that STUDENT cannot reasonably be expected to benefit from treatment while he remains under the influence of his mother. Their concern is that unless STUDENT is effectively separated from the influence of his mother while he is in a treatment program, her interference will undermine the program.
Dr. Patterson testified at length about how, in his review of the records, it was apparent that STUDENT’s mother, through her objections, complaints, and interference, had undermined every situation where STUDENT was being taught outside of a home-teaching program. Also, STUDENT displayed a pattern of looking to his mother for her idea of the appropriate response to make in a given situation. Without his mother to make the responses for him, STUDENT has a hard time functioning. For these reasons, Dr. Patterson concluded that STUDENT required a structured educational setting where there would be no intervention from his mother. Dr. Lanyi concluded that STUDENT and his mother were very close, and his dependency on her had prevented him from learning how to cope more adaptively with everyday challenges. Furthermore, although STUDENT’s condition required intensive mental health treatment and intervention, STUDENT’s mother did not have an understanding or acceptance of her son’s many deficits and needs. The mother’s failure to understand the magnitude of her son’s deficits and needs was an impediment to the success of any intervention plan that would involve her participation. Dr. Lanyi stated that a residential treatment setting could provide STUDENT with very intensive services for a period of time that would be geared toward addressing his social, emotional, and behavioral difficulties while improving his adaptive skills and ability to function more independently.
Dr. Willis stated his opinion that the mother did not have a commitment to counseling. Dr. Willis stated this was not surprising, because the mother does not believe that STUDENT has a problem. Dr. Willis wrote that STUDENT needs counseling and that it is difficult to see that happening when the mother is not in support of counseling and does not believe STUDENT has a problem for which counseling is necessary. Dr. Willis concluded that STUDENT’s educational and behavioral needs cannot be met in his current living arrangement. Instead, STUDENT requires a living arrangement that can provide treatment his entire waking day and throughout the night (24-hour-per-day treatment).
Dr. Mullen testified that a major issue for STUDENT is ego development and individuation, which is the process by which one forms a separate personality and identity. Dr. Mullen testified that individuation is an early part of personality development where one develops a sense of separate self, meaning the ability to perceive oneself separately and act separately. The beginnings of separation patterns are typically at age 2 or 3 years. STUDENT, at age 17 years, is very infantile with respect to his early personality development. His ego development is in a very primitive state. He is very dependent upon his mother for formation of his opinion and belief system, which mirrors many of his mother’s mood-states and idiosyncratic beliefs and suspicions. The longer this process continues, the more difficult it is to undo. Once a personality is fully developed, it is very difficult to change, and it can take years of therapy. Dr. Mullen believes that separating STUDENT from his mother will give him the best chance of developing a normal personality. Dr. Mullen recommends a residential placement.
Alternatives to Residential Placement. As an alternative to residential placement, the Petitioner proposes a 24-hour-per-day home-care program administered and staffed through the IABA (Institute of Applied Behavior Analysis). The IABA proposal was described in Dr. Patterson’s testimony. Through the IABA, services would be provided 24 hours per day. There would be aide service at the family home. An educational aide would accompany STUDENT at school. STUDENT would also receive a behavioral intervention plan, such as the plan outlined by Dr. Willis. The plan would not be effective if IABA simply managed school employees. The aides would have to be trained. Implementation of the behavioral intervention plan would have to be consistent, with a weekly meeting of the staff for 2 to 3 hours to adjust the protocols as appropriate. Dr. Patterson testified that the IABA plan could work, but success would require appropriate cooperation from STUDENT’s mother. Ms. Pitts, a therapist who is very familiar with STUDENT and his mother, testified that she has serious doubts about the probability of an IABA program succeeding in the mother’s home. The mother would be extremely guarded about other persons trying to interfere with her relationship with her son. She might do things to undermine the program such as questioning the behavioral specialists and challenging their recommendations. This would create stress and confusion for STUDENT because he would not know which instructions to follow.
Discussion and findings. The Hearing Officer has previously found that a program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his ED and other deficits must be centered upon a positive behavioral intervention plan, strictly and consistently implemented 24 hours per day in a highly structured and controlled environment, and supported by counseling, cognitive therapy, and a waking and sleeping schedule.
With respect to nonresidential placement alternatives, the Hearing Officer has considered that STUDENT will reach 18 years of age in about eight months. STUDENT is in vital need of an intensive program, delivered with resolve and effectiveness in a highly structured and controlled setting. STUDENT does not have the time to be subjected to further trials of nonresidential-placement alternatives, including alternatives such as the IABA plan proposed by STUDENT, on the basis of hope that STUDENT’s mother would now become adequately cooperative. The record shows no reason to believe that STUDENT’s mother would be cooperative for the requisite duration of time. The mother’s trait for protectiveness is understandable, but her judgement abilities negate the likelihood of success for a program in which even a portion of the 24-hour-per day services are delivered inside the mother’s home.
The Hearing Officer finds that to prevent the mother from undermining STUDENT’s program, STUDENT requires effective isolation from potential interference by the mother. The Petitioner’s proposed IABA plan, as an alternative to residential placement, is rejected as inadequate. Since the next step above an IABA plan would be some form of a residential placement, it follows that there are no suitable alternatives to residential placement. Therefore, STUDENT’s unique needs cannot reasonably be met through any combination of nonresidential services.
With respect to residential placement, the experts’ opinions and recommendations are considered by the Hearing Officer to be unanimously consistent on the position that a residential placement is required for the successful implementation of 24-hour-per-day services designed to address STUDENT’s ED and his other mental health service needs. The experts’ recommendations are properly responsive to the dismal history of STUDENT’s prior educational programs, and their recommendations appropriately account for the fact that the mother would most likely undermine the program if any of the services were delivered inside her home.(Footnote 19)
The Hearing Officer finds that a residential placement is necessary for STUDENT to receive a program that is designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.
IV. What are the parameters of an appropriate residential placement for STUDENT in the least restrictive environment?
Since a broad range of placements can be characterized as “residential,” specific parameters are required to delineate a residential placement that is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Title 2, C.C.R. Sec.60025 describes various types of facilities that fall within the spectrum of residential placements.(Footnote 20) Residential placements can vary from “certified family homes” to “foster family homes” to “community treatment facilities.” STUDENT requires a 24-hour-per-day facility that has a staff appropriately trained to strictly and consistently implement his positive behavioral intervention plan. The facility must have sufficient security to keep STUDENT in a controlled and structured environment for the purpose of implementing the behavioral intervention plan. The facility must be capable of delivering the appropriate services to STUDENT without the program being undermined by the presence of STUDENT’s mother. The facility must be capable of providing the integrated services described above as being required for STUDENT to receive a FAPE, either by itself or through contracting with other providers.
Residential placement for a pupil who is emotionally disturbed may be made out-of-state only if in-state alternatives have been considered and are found not appropriate to meet the pupil’s needs and only when the requirements of Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 7572.5 and Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56365(e) have been met. Cal. Gov. Code Sec. 7572.55.
Until the District and HCA conduct a search for a facility that conforms with the above- stated requirements, it will be unknown whether STUDENT requires placement in an out-of-state facility. In either event, the Hearing Officer finds that the preliminary requirements of Sec. 7572.5 have been met. Specifically, STUDENT has been determined to be ED, as defined in Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.5. The District and HCA, as part of an expanded IEP team, have recommended residential placement on the basis of relevant assessment information. STUDENT’s needs cannot reasonably be met through any combination of nonresidential services. Residential placement is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from educational services. The remaining requirements of Sec. 7572.5 and Sec. 56365(e) concern matters for future compliance by the expanded IEP team.
The parties are reminded that while STUDENT is in a residential placement, the IEP team will still have continuing responsibilities for providing STUDENT an appropriate program. The parties’ attention is particularly directed to Sec. 7572.5(c)(2), requiring a review by the full IEP team at least every six months regarding the case progress, the continuing need for out-of-home placement, the extent of compliance with the IEP, and progress toward alleviating the need for out-of-home care. The parties’ attention is also directed to Sec. 7572.55(c), requiring that in the event of an out-of-state placement, a plan shall be developed for using less restrictive alternatives as soon as they become available, unless it is in the best educational interest of the child to remain in the out-of-state school. If the child is a ward or dependent of the court, this plan shall be documented in the record. Issue No. 4: What is the least restrictive environment in which the Petitioner could benefit from his education for the 2001 extended school year and the 2001 to 2002 school year?
This issue has been rendered moot by the findings in Issue No. 3.
Issue No. 5: Has HCA provided Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on STUDENT’s IEP and the treatment plan dated September 14, 2000?
In its statement of issues, HCA seeks a finding that HCA has provided Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on STUDENT’s IEP and the treatment plan dated September 14, 2000.(Footnote 21) “Chapter 26.5" refers to Sections 7570 et seq of the California Government Code. Those sections delineate responsibilities of agencies such as HCA to provide assessments and mental health services to children with disabilities upon referral by an IEP team.
The parties do not dispute whether HCA fulfilled its obligations regarding assessments and the provision of mental health services. The parties presented evidence regarding the reasons for some, but not all, of the missed appointments and delayed assessments. Accordingly, to the extent that Chapter 26.5 mental health services designated by STUDENT’s IEPs and his treatment plan were delayed or not actually provided, it appears from the record that such delay or failure was due primarily, and perhaps entirely, to lack of cooperation by the mother. However, this issue is not relevant to the outcome of this case. Therefore, the Hearing Officer makes no finding regarding whether HCA provided all of the Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on STUDENT’s IEP and the treatment plan dated September 14, 2000.
Issue No. 6: If residential placement is ordered, should the District bear financial responsibility for such a placement because of its alleged disregard for procedural mandates and HCA’s role in residential placement?
HCA asserts that because the District offered a residential placement to STUDENT without first following the procedures in Gov. Code Sec. 7572.5 and Title 2, C.C.R. Sec. 60100, the District should bear the responsibility for a residential placement if a residential placement is ordered. The District asserts that because the placement is prospective and because HCA has also recommended residential placement, HCA should fund its portion of the residential placement.
Gov. Code Sec. 7572 provides in part that when a mental health assessment is performed, a related service shall be added to the IEP only if a qualified person conducting the assessment recommended the service in order for the child to benefit from special education. When a mental health assessment has been conducted, then following discussion by the IEP team, the final recommendation of the person who conducted the assessment shall be the recommendation of the IEP team members who are attending on behalf of the local educational agency.
Gov. Code Sec. 7572.5 provides that when a child is found to be ED and any member of the IEP team recommends residential placement based on relevant assessment information, the IEP team shall be expanded to include a representative of the county mental health department. The expanded IEP team shall then determine whether a residential placement is necessary. If the required review calls for residential placement, the resulting IEP shall include, among other requirements, designation of the county mental health department as lead case manager and identification of an appropriate residential facility. Sec. 7576(a) provides that the community mental health service shall be responsible for provision of the mental health services required by the pupil’s IEP. Similar provisions are found in State regulations that implement Chapter 26.5. See Title 2, C.C.R. Secs. 60100 and 60200.
On October 10, 2000, Mr. Wenkart sent a letter to the Petitioner stating: “District hereby offers to place STUDENT in a residential placement. . . .” At that time, there had been no mental health assessment or recommendation as required by Sec. 7572. There had been no expanded IEP team meeting to include HCA, as required by Sec. 7572.5 whenever residential placement is recommended by an IEP team member for a child who is ED.
The District asserts that Mr. Wenkart’s October 10, 2000 letter did not actually contain an offer for residential placement. That assertion is contrary to the clear language of Mr. Wenkart’s letter. Furthermore, Mr. Wenkart’s letter dated October 18, 2000, indicates that the District realized its procedural mistake of offering a residential placement without first complying with the assessment and the expanded IEP team procedures required by Secs. 7572 and 7572.5. In his October 18, 2000 letter, Mr. Wenkart “clarifies” the October 10 letter by stating that the District is interested in convening an expanded IEP team meeting to include HCA for the purpose of discussing residential placement. An expanded IEP team met on October 26, 2000. Further assessments were performed, culminating in the recommendation by HCA for residential placement at the June 19, 2001 IEP meeting. The Petitioner has never consented to a residential placement.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s October 10, 2000 letter constituted an offer for residential placement. This was a procedural violation of Secs. 7572 and 7572.5. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s error was corrected 8 days later by Mr. Wenkart’s October 18, 2000 letter. In the interim, the Petitioner did not accept the residential placement offer. Following expansion of the IEP team to include HCA, and through the date that HCA recommended residential placement, the Petitioner remained opposed to residential placement. Therefore, there has been no prejudice to HCA arising from the District’s premature offer of residential placement, and no potential is found for future prejudice to HCA arising from that premature offer.
HCA relies on Title 2, C.C.R. Sec. 60600(c) as authority for its assertion that the District must now be financially responsible for what would have been HCA’s portion of the residential placement funding. Sec. 60600(c) provides that when a service “has been included in an IEP by an IEP team without the recommendation of the qualified professional in accordance with Sec. 7572 of the Government Code, the LEA [local educational agency] shall be solely responsible for the provision of the service. In such circumstances, the dispute, if any, is between the parent and the LEA and shall be resolved pursuant to Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations.”
HCA’s reliance on Sec. 60600(c) is misplaced. By its plain language, Sec. 60600(c) would only have been applicable to this case if the IEP team had actually produced an IEP providing for residential placement without the recommendation of the person who conducted the mental health assessments described in Cal. Gov. Code Secs. 7572 and 7572.5. If that had occurred, then by operation of Sec. 60600(c) the District could have been solely responsible for providing the residential placement. The assignment of responsibility in Sec. 60600(c) would be appropriate to that hypothetical situation, because otherwise the applicable mental health agency would be obligated to fund a residential placement when the agency had no opportunity to participate in the process prescribed for the agency by Secs. 7572 and 7572.5. The provisions of Sec. 60600(c) are consistent with the principle that unless prejudice resulted to HCA or would somehow result to HCA in the future from the District’s procedural violation, then HCA should not be relieved of responsibility for funding the residential placement.
In the present case, there has been no IEP that includes a residential placement. The District’s premature offer bound or purported to bind HCA to nothing, and there has been no prejudice to HCA. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the actions of the District have not relieved HCA of its legal obligation to fund the Petitioner’s residential placement.
Issue No. 7: Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
In his 66-page closing brief, the Petitioner did not specify what he is seeking in the nature of compensatory educational services, except for what is appropriate based on four years of denial of FAPE, less the period excluded by the statute of limitations.
In its closing brief, the District states: “The petitioners have not demonstrated that STUDENT suffered any significant harm as a result of the services provided by the school district since October 16, 1997.” The District’s disconcerting statement on the matter of compensatory education evades the question of whether STUDENT suffered harm as a result of the services that were not provided by the District from October 16, 1997, through the present. The list of services not provided includes a positive behavioral intervention plan for a student who is over 6 feet tall, weighs nearly 500 pounds, and has a history of assaultive and destructive behaviors achieving almost legendary status within the District; speech and language services for a child who ranks in the zero to first percentile in receptive and expressive language; services to address his specific learning disabilities; and teaching in excess of 3 to 5 hours per week (except for the perfunctory effort at TEC and the ill-fated program at Orange High School).
The Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is required in this case as a remedy for the flagrant denial of a FAPE to the Petitioner from the 1997-1998 school year through the present.
In addition to denying the need for compensatory education, the District also claims that any award for compensatory education should be tempered by equitable factors, including the conduct of the mother.
Neither party has “clean hands” in this matter. None of the programs offered by the District through the 1999-2000 school year would have satisfied FAPE requirements, yet the programs consistently sought by the mother were even more deficient. The mother has embarked on a course of keeping STUDENT in her home whenever possible instead of allowing him to be educated in school. However, this preference by the mother is somewhat understandable. STUDENT has a propensity for serious behavioral events. The likelihood of a ruinous outcome from one of those events has increased concurrently with STUDENT’s size and age. The potential for catastrophe was particularly increased whenever the District, without developing a behavioral intervention plan, sought to place STUDENT in a classroom with other students. Meanwhile, the District has demonstrated a clear pattern of devising and/or agreeing to deficient programs in an effort to placate STUDENT’s mother in lieu of providing a FAPE. The Hearing Officer recognizes that, on several occasions, the mother signed her consent to deficient IEPs. The agreed-upon IEPs provide no defense to the District in this situation. The evidence overwhelmingly establishes that the mother is not capable of making appropriate educational decisions for STUDENT, and the District has had knowledge of the mother’s limitations for many years. The District had the expertise necessary to develop a FAPE for STUDENT. If the mother would not agree to an appropriate program, the District had an obligation pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56346(b) to seek due process intervention. Such intervention was not sought.(Footnote 22)
The Hearing Officer finds that although the conduct of both the Petitioner and the District has contributed to STUDENT’s grim educational history, the equities weigh substantially in favor of the Petitioner. Accordingly, in fashioning a compensatory education remedy, significant consideration will not be given to the conduct of the Petitioner as a contributing factor to his denial of FAPE.
Compensatory education services will be provided in addition to the services that the Hearing Officer has previously described as being required for a FAPE. The extensive 24-hour-per-day program and other services that STUDENT requires for a FAPE have been described above in the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding the necessity of residential placement. The comparison of that program to what STUDENT has received since October 16, 1997, which essentially consisted of a few hours per week of teaching and some therapy through HCA, illustrates the magnitude of the continuing denial of FAPE since October 16, 1997.(Footnote 23) Despite his vital need for such services, over the past four years STUDENT has had no behavioral intervention plan, no speech and language services, no services to address his specific learning disabilities, no vocational training program, and no plan to transition STUDENT into a relatively independent adult life.
The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal in Puyallup, supra, determined that the right to compensatory education does not create an obligation to provide day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for the opportunities missed. In STUDENT’s case, an appropriate amount of compensatory education may require more than the equivalent of a one-to-one replacement for the missed services. Appropriate intervention for STUDENT’s ED has been delayed for the entire four years at issue in this case. The Hearing Officer agrees with the testimony of Dr. Mullen that the longer the ED and other adverse mental health processes have continued the more difficult they are to undo. The Hearing Officer also finds that the adverse effects of delay also apply generally to the District’s delay in providing appropriate services and intervention for STUDENT’s other deficits, such as speech and language, making not only his mental health condition more difficult to undo, but also his other deficits.(Footnote 24)
The evidence shows that STUDENT will most likely qualify for special education and related services as an individual with exceptional needs until shortly after his 22nd birthday.(Footnote 25) However, before STUDENT can tolerate increased amounts of basic FAPE services to address his specific learning disabilities, speech and language deficits, overall academic deficits, and vocational and transition needs, STUDENT’s behaviors must be modified. STUDENT’s limited tolerance and the need for behavior modification will initially delay STUDENT’s ability to receive and benefit from the complete array of services that he requires for a FAPE. Similarly, STUDENT’s ability to tolerate compensatory education services will be delayed. This situation could likely result in STUDENT’s needing time well-beyond his 22nd birthday to receive his compensatory education services. The appropriateness of compensatory education beyond STUDENT’s 22nd birthday will best be determined by the IEP team as STUDENT approaches his 22nd birthday. At that time, the IEP team can give due consideration to STUDENT’s needs, his progress during the intervening four years, and the level of compensatory education provided to STUDENT during those four years commencing with the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will order compensatory education through STUDENT’s 22nd birthday. The order will not preclude STUDENT from requesting an extension of compensatory education beyond his 22nd birthday.
Because the specific compensatory education services appropriate to STUDENT’s needs will be variable over a period of several years, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team is in the best position to fashion and implement the details of a compensatory education program during that time. The type and intensity of compensatory education services shall be determined by the IEP team, consistent with the factors stated in this Decision. The IEP team shall weigh STUDENT’s individual needs and his ability to tolerate more extensive services with his right to compensatory education for the continuous and grievous denial of FAPE since October 16, 1997. The IEP team should consider additional counseling, vocational services and training, and other options.
MOTION TO DISMISS THE ISSUE OF RESIDENTIAL PLACEMENT
On August 8, 2001, nearly two months after the conclusion of testimony, the Petitioner filed a motion to dismiss the District’s issue of residential placement. In support of that motion, the Petitioner claims that after the conclusion of the due process hearing, the District offered a new program which changed its offer of placement to an offer that does not include a residential component. Therefore, according to the Petitioner, the issue presented by the District regarding residential placement should be dismissed. The District claims that it has not withdrawn its recommendation and request for residential placement.
The Background Facts summarized above and the papers submitted in support of the motion and in opposition to the motion show the following: At the March 19, 2001 IEP meeting, it was decided that the goals and objectives proposed by the District at the March 19 meeting would subsequently be reviewed by the Petitioner, and that the Petitioner would then provide the District with recommendations. On the morning of June 19, 2001, the parties participated in an IEP meeting prior to commencement of the due process hearing later on the same morning. The District states the June 19, 2001 IEP was held for the purpose of reaching an agreement on goals and objectives, if possible, prior to the due process hearing. The IEP meeting concluded without a written IEP being completed. Following completion of the due process hearing, the matters discussed at the June 19, 2001 IEP meeting were reduced to writing. On June 28, 2001, Mr. Wenkart sent a copy of the proposed written IEP to the Petitioner for review. Enclosed with that proposed IEP was a cover letter from Mr. Wenkart stating that all goals and objectives reflected revisions per the IEP team discussion, and that the District was proposing that home instruction continue at Portola until receipt of the decision from the Hearing Officer regarding placement.
The Hearing Officer has reviewed the proposed written IEP dated June 19, 2001. The proposed IEP states that the specified instruction and services would continue in a home-school program at Portola. Goals and objectives were attached. Residential placement was not mentioned, but the cover letter explains the District was proposing that instruction continue at Portola until a decision was received from the Hearing Officer regarding placement.
Mr. Wenkart’s June 28, 2001 cover letter is consistent with the District’s assertion that it never withdrew its request or recommendation for a residential placement, and that the purpose of the June 19, 2001 IEP did not include consideration of the residential placement issue. Instead, the purpose was to provide STUDENT with agreed-upon services, if possible, pending resolution of the placement issue to be presented at the due process hearing. The District’s position on this matter is also consistent with the fact that none of the parties claimed at the due process hearing that the residential placement issue was being withdrawn.
The Hearing Officer considers the Petitioner’s motion to be without merit and based on a distortion of the facts. The motion to dismiss is denied.
ORDERS
1. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this Decision and thereafter as necessary, the expanded IEP team shall meet to develop an IEP for STUDENT consistent with the findings of the Hearing Officer regarding the overall requirements of a FAPE program for STUDENT. Those findings are as follows:
(A) STUDENT requires the development of a program that is consistent with his ability to tolerate the intensity of the program. The IEP team should anticipate that STUDENT’s ability to tolerate services will increase as his behavioral intervention plan proceeds.
(B) STUDENT requires a positive behavioral intervention plan based on a functional analysis assessment, such as the plan outlined by Dr. Willis, also incorporating ongoing counseling, preferably by a board-certified psychiatrist; cognitive therapy; and a waking and sleeping schedule. The plan must be strictly and consistently implemented 24 hours per day in a highly structured and controlled environment. The goals would be to ameliorate STUDENT’s ED, teach him a more accurate self-concept so that he can understand his strengths and weaknesses, and have him acquire social skills and a knowledge of how to interact with people.
(C) STUDENT requires, depending on his tolerance, speech and language services, including direct intervention therapy at least twice per week in 30-45 minute sessions. Speech and language services must be considered to be a critical priority because STUDENT needs alternative methods of expression and a better ability to communicate with those who are trying to counsel him and teach him.
(D) STUDENT requires services to meet his needs arising from his specific learning disabilities.
(E) STUDENT requires services to address his academic deficits and his vocational deficits, which means extended school year and teaching substantially beyond the scant 3 to 5 hours per week he has received in the past. An appropriate goal would be 3 to 5 hours of instruction per day, as tolerated, or more.
(F) STUDENT requires a vocational program reasonably calculated to provide him with skills for gainful employment.
(G) STUDENT requires a transition program designed to enable him to function in society as an adult with the self-help skills necessary for living on his own.
2. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this decision, the expanded IEP team shall convene an IEP meeting to designate the persons responsible for identifying an appropriate residential placement in accordance with Title 2, C.C.R. Sec. 60100.
3. An appropriate residential placement for STUDENT must:
(A) Provide for a 24-hour-per-day facility that has a staff appropriately trained to strictly and consistently implement STUDENT’s positive behavioral intervention plan.
(B) Have security designed to keep STUDENT in a controlled and structured environment for the purpose of implementing the behavioral intervention plan. The facility must be capable of delivering the appropriate services to STUDENT without having the program undermined by the presence of STUDENT’s mother.
(C) Provide the integrated services required for STUDENT to receive a FAPE and compensatory education, either by itself or through contracting with other providers. 4. While STUDENT is in a residential placement, the IEP team shall comply with Gov. Code Sec. 7572.5(c)(2), requiring a review by the full IEP team at least every six months regarding the case progress, the continuing need for out-of-home placement, the extent of compliance with the IEP, and progress toward alleviating the need for out-of-home care.
5. In the event of an out-of-state placement, the IEP team shall comply with Gov. Code Sec. 7572.55(c), requiring that in the event of an out-of-state placement, a plan shall be developed for using less restrictive alternatives as soon as they become available, unless it is in the best educational interest of the child to remain in the out-of-state school.
6. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this decision, and as necessary throughout the course of STUDENT’s compensatory education program, the IEP team shall meet to determine appropriate compensatory education services for STUDENT in accordance with his needs. Compensatory education services shall be in addition to, not part of, the services that STUDENT requires for a FAPE. Compensatory education shall include such components to supplement STUDENT’s FAPE program as he can tolerate and benefit from. Services considered by the IEP team for compensatory education shall include, but not be limited to academics, speech and language, counseling, therapy, and vocational training and services.
7. In determining the type, amount, and intensity of compensatory education services, the IEP team shall consider the following factors:
(A) STUDENT’s individual needs, balanced against his ability for tolerating a longer school day;
(B) STUDENT’s continuous denial of FAPE since October 16, 1997, in almost every area that required services to meet his unique needs and provide him with some educational benefit;
(C) the long delay in attempting appropriate intervention for STUDENT that has made his mental health condition and other deficits more difficult to undo, indicating that an appropriate amount of compensatory education may require more than a one-to-one replacement for the missed services.
8. STUDENT’s compensatory education shall continue through his 22nd birthday. The orders in this Decision shall not preclude STUDENT from making a request for additional years of compensatory education and initiating a due process hearing regarding additional years of compensatory education.
9. Subject to Juvenile Court jurisdiction in the Orange County Superior Court, within 60 calendar days from the date of the IEP meeting specified in order number 2, the District shall place STUDENT in a residential placement meeting the criteria specified in order number 3.
10. Pursuant to the California Education Code, including Sec. 56346(b), the Hearing Officer has overridden the mother’s lack of consent for implementation of the residential placement. The District and/or HCA, as necessary, shall seek authority from the Juvenile Court or other appropriate divisions of the Superior Court to place STUDENT, and shall seek other orders, as necessary, to support the placement.(Footnote 10)
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
(1) Did the District fail to offer a free appropriate public education to the Petitioner for the 1997-1998, 1998-1999, 1999-2000, and 2000-2001 school years? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(2) What eligibility designation most appropriately reflects the Petitioner’s educational needs? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(3) Is residential placement necessary for STUDENT to receive a program that is designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit? The District prevailed on this issue.
(4) What is the least restrictive environment in which the Petitioner could benefit from his education for the 2001 extended school year and the 2001 to 2002 school year? This issue was rendered moot by the findings in issue number 3.
(5) Has HCA provided Chapter 26.5 mental health services as designated on the Petitioner’s IEP and treatment plan dated September 14, 2000? No findings were made on this issue.
(6) If residential placement is ordered, should the District bear financial responsibility for such a placement because of its alleged disregard for procedural mandates and HCA’s role in residential placement? The District prevailed on this issue.
(7) Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory educational services? The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56505(i).
Date: October 31, 2001 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1.The Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. The issues listed here differ in wording from the issues as stated by the parties. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis. Issues 1, 2, 4, and 7 were presented by the Petitioner. Issue 3 was presented by the District. Issues 5 and 6 were presented by HCA. 3. The parties and the records most often refer to STUDENT’s eligibility designation as “emotional disturbance” (ED), which is defined in Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7(c)(4). “Serious emotional disturbance” (SED) is defined in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(i). The definitions of ED and SED are considered identical for purposes of this Decision. For consistency, the Hearing Officer will use the term ED. 4. There are several references to “home teaching at Portola” in the IEPs. The actual meaning of the term “home teaching,” as used in STUDENT’s IEPs, is that STUDENT would go to Portola, a District school, and receive his instruction in a room specifically reserved for STUDENT and his assigned teacher. 5. Witnesses interviewed by the District claimed that STUDENT threw his desk at another student and hit him. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT told him the chair, which apparently was attached to his desk, fit so snugly that when STUDENT stood up the chair was stuck to him. When STUDENT shook his body to dislodge the chair, the chair and/or desk were propelled toward the other student. 6. STUDENT’s grades were achieved in his SDC curriculum.
7. The record does not indicate when or how this document was generated by the District for the mother’s signature. 8. Requests for hearing must be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(j). The Petitioner’s due process hearing request was filed on October 16, 2000. Therefore, issues related to the appropriateness of programs offered by the District are limited to the period from October 16, 1997, forward. 9. A cursory reading of the February 12, 1998 IEP could give the impression that the District’s SDC proposal was agreed-upon, as all the elements of the SDC plan are listed under “Program Options,” home-teaching is not listed as a program option, and the mother signed her consent. However, under the heading “Committee Action” there is a box checked for “Cont. in Present Program,” which was home teaching. 10. The term “behavioral intervention plan” is defined in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3001(d)(e)(f)(aa). It is a written document which is developed when the individual exhibits a serious behavior problem that significantly interferes with the implementation of the goals and objectives of the individual’s IEP. The plan is based on results of a functional analysis assessment, and it includes a systematic implementation of procedures designed to result in lasting positive changes in the individuals behavior. The plan must include an objective and measurable description of the targeted maladaptive behaviors and replacement positive behaviors; the individual’s goals and objectives specific to the behavioral intervention plan; a detailed description of the behavioral interventions to be used and the circumstances for their use; specific schedules for recording the frequency of the use of the interventions and the frequency of the targeted behaviors, including specific criteria for discontinuing the use of the intervention for lack of effectiveness or replacing it with an identified and specified alternative; criteria by which the procedure will be faded; interventions which will be used in the home, residential facility, work site or other noneducational settings; and specific dates for review by the IEP team. “Functional analysis assessment” is described in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3052(b). 11. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56346(b) provides that if a parent does not consent to part of a proposed special education program which the district determines is necessary to provide a FAPE to the pupil, then the district shall initiate the due process hearing procedures pursuant to Sec. 56500 et seq. 12. The term “offer,” as used in this finding, refers to the programs that the District presented to the Petitioner for consideration, the agreed-upon programs described in the IEPs, and the services actually provided. 13. This IEP was consented to by STUDENT’s new court-appointed educational surrogate, Ms. Cromer, who is also STUDENT’s attorney in this due process matter. 14. The criteria in Sec. 3030(i)(3) is actually an understatement of STUDENT’s behavior. He has exhibited inappropriate behavior in far more than just “several” situations. 15. STUDENT’s entitlement to certain services, such as services available through HCA, may require that he have a handicapping condition of ED. The finding that STUDENT meets the definition of multiple disabilities should not be construed as a finding that STUDENT is not ED. STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services as a student who is ED, and he is also eligible as a student who has multiple disabilities. 16. This was established by Mr. Robles’ testimony. Mr. Robles also testified that since the IEP team has not agreed to a residential placement, HCA has not conducted a “least restrictive environment search” to identify an appropriate residential placement facility. HCA has expressed concerns about how such a placement could be enforced on STUDENT without consent. 17. A residential placement, if required, would be only one component of an overall FAPE program. Furthermore, the term “residential placement” encompasses a broad range of residential settings or facilities. Therefore, the determination of whether a residential placement is required for STUDENT, and the characteristics of that residential placement, must be addressed in the context of the overall services that would collectively constitute a FAPE. Neither the District nor HCA has identified the educational services they propose for STUDENT in conjunction with a residential placement. The parties have reached no agreement regarding what services STUDENT generally requires. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must determine what services are currently necessary to address STUDENT’s needs and to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. 18. Dr. Patterson testified that STUDENT is not mentally retarded, and that he is capable of learning. STUDENT’s temporarily improved grades at Orange High School and his effort and grades in the home teaching by Ms. Slagle demonstrate that he is capable of learning. 19. One of the concerns about implementing a residential placement is uncertainty over how STUDENT would react to being separated from his mother. Dr. Patterson noted that STUDENT’s course while in juvenile hall for several months was an indicator that separation would not be a serious problem. Dr. Mullen testified that there was no way to predict how STUDENT would react to being separated from his mother, but he thought the potential for good outweighed what he believed would be short-term risks for STUDENT. Ms. Pitts testified that she thought the initial affect of separating STUDENT from his mother would be very traumatic, but over time he would probably adjust. Ms. Pitts noted that when STUDENT was separated from his mother at the juvenile hall, it was difficult for him at first, and he would have tantrums. As time progressed, STUDENT began to participate in the program and seemed to do well over a period of several months. 20. Title 2, C.C.R Sec. 60100(c)(1) characterizes the various facilities listed in Sec. 60025 as residential placements. 21. In its presentation of issues at the hearing, HCA was seeking a determination of whether it provided all required services from September 14, 2000, to present. However, in its closing brief, HCA appears to seek a determination that it provided all required services from January 8, 1999, to present. 22. On at least one occasion, STUDENT’s educational surrogate signed her consent to an inadequate program; however, the Hearing Officer will not presume to know what pressures from the mother, STUDENT, and the District led to her decision-making strategy. 23.As mentioned in Dr. Willis’ report, STUDENT has generally received about 3 hours of instruction per week. At that rate, STUDENT would need nine years of instruction to receive the same amount of instruction that an average student receives in one year. 10. The District is already a party to the Orange County Superior Court case number 001353.
