California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 24, 2003
Student v. Pasadena Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1845-02 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals
Pasadena Unified's June 2002 preschool autism offer upheld, but its December 2002 offer denied FAPE; District must fund in-home CARD therapy.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The Pasadena Unified School District and the parents of a three-and-a-half-year-old girl with autism each filed for due process, and the cases were consolidated. The girl was moving from regional center services to the District. Since February 2002, her parents had paid the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) for in-home discrete trial training (DTT). That training later reached about 35 hours a week. The District's June 12, 2002 IEP offered a sensorimotor preschool special day class with 10 hours a week of school-based DTT, plus speech-language therapy and occupational therapy. The parents wanted up to 40 hours a week of CARD services at home.
The Hearing Officer found the June offer appropriate. The April 2002 assessment covered all areas of suspected disability, and the IEP team was properly constituted. The goals met the girl's needs, and the choice of method and provider was the District's to make. In November 2002, the District learned she had made major progress. On December 4, with less than a day's notice and no parent present, it offered a blended inclusion class with the same goals. The Hearing Officer held that this offer denied FAPE. The District had not reassessed her, did not know her present levels, and did not address the risk of regression. The notice claims were not decided. The District must reimburse CARD costs from December 4, 2002, and pay CARD directly through the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO judged two offers to the same preschooler separately. The first offer was valid when made. The district later replaced it with a new placement after learning of major progress, without reassessing, updating present levels, or revising goals. That replacement offer denied FAPE. Reimbursement ran only from the date of the deficient offer.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1a. Did the District offer the Student a FAPE for the 2001-2002 extended school year and the 2002-2003 school year through the June 12, 2002 IEP (as clarified June 24, 2002), for the period up to December 4, 2002? The Student challenged the April 2002 assessment, the IEP team's makeup, the goals, the service providers and DTT hours, and the sensorimotor special day class placement.
The April 2002 assessment covered all areas of suspected disability, the team was properly constituted, and the sensorimotor class with 10 hours/week of school-based DTT and therapies was a FAPE in the LRE; methodology and provider choice were within the District's discretion.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1b. Did the District's December 4, 2002 IEP, which replaced the June offer with a blended inclusion class and the same goals, offer the Student a FAPE through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year?
The December 4 offer denied FAPE because the District had not reassessed the Student after learning of major progress, did not know her present levels, kept the June goals unchanged, and did not address the risk of regression; the notice and parent participation claims were not reached.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for services provided by the nonpublic agency CARD through the date of the Decision and to prospective placement with CARD at District expense?
No reimbursement through December 3, 2002, because the June offer was a FAPE; the state-certified CARD program was appropriate, so the District must reimburse CARD costs from December 4, 2002 and fund CARD through the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District shall reimburse the parents the amounts shown on CARD invoices for DTT and related services from December 4, 2002 through the date of the Decision (March 24, 2003). No dollar amount stated.
- Prospective funding of private placement. District shall arrange to receive CARD invoices and pay CARD directly for the current level of services from the date of the Decision through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
Key authorities
Rowley; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter
People named in the decision
- Alyson Beecher, program specialist, Pasadena Unified School District
- Roxana Daly, speech-language pathologist and assessor (credentialed special day class teacher), Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Beth Levy, school psychologist and assessor, Pasadena Unified School District
- Lisa Serby, occupational therapist and assessor, Pasadena Unified School District
- Joan Madden, school nurse and assessor, Pasadena Unified School District
- Mirell O'Brien, administrator designee on IEP team (credentialed special education teacher), Pasadena Unified School District
- Joan Welday, sensorimotor preschool special day class teacher, Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Bernhardt, District psychologist supervising DTT aides, Pasadena Unified School District
- Dr. Edward Ritvo, expert witness for District (psychiatrist, UCLA professor emeritus), University of California, Los Angeles Neuropsychiatric Institute
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, CARD founder and clinic director; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Dr. Sebastien Bosch, CARD research director; IEP attendee and witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Theresa Bartholomew, CARD supervisor; IEP attendee and witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Henry Moore, CARD supervisor; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), nonpublic agency providing in-home DTT
- Frank R. Lanterman Regional Center, regional center that provided early intervention services under an IFSP
- Glenn Fait, Hearing Office Director (observer), California Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This consolidated matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Pasadena, California, on December 12, 13, 17, and 18, 2002, and January 7, 8, 9, 10, 14, and 15, 2003. Hearing Office Director Glenn Fait attended the morning session on December 12 as an observer.
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Shelli J. Lewis. At various times during the course of the hearing, attorneys Don Gonzales and William Whalen from Ms. Lewis’s office additionally appeared for the Student. Also present on the Student’s behalf were her parents, FATHER and MOTHER. The Pasadena Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Alexa J. Jackowski. Also present on behalf of the District was Alyson Beecher, program specialist.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the receipt of written closing briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for the 2001-2002 extended school year and for the 2002-2003 school year including the extended school year?
2. Is the Student entitled to be reimbursed for services provided to her by the nonpublic agency (NPA) Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) through the date of this Decision and also entitled to prospective placement with CARD at District expense?(Footnote 2)
CONTENTIONS
The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 extended school year and for the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year. The District offered STUDENT immediate placement in District classes and services through District providers as of June 2002.
The Student challenges the District’s April 2002 assessment. She also disagrees with the needs determination, goals and objectives, service providers, and placement in the June 12, 2002 IEP.
The Student also contends that the December 4, 2002 IEP that the District offered in place of the June 12, 2002 IEP offer is legally insufficient because of lack of parent participation. She further disagrees with the placement offer in the December 4 IEP as not meeting her unique needs and asserts that the offer does not constitute a FAPE.
The Student further contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for CARD services from the District. The Student also seeks prospective placement and funding with CARD for in-home therapy up to 40 hours per week.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The District made a prehearing motion to shift the burden of going forward to the Student. After reviewing the written submission from the District and hearing the arguments of counsel, the Hearing Officer granted the motion. The District has never provided services to the Student. The Student is in a better position to frame the issues and provide a description of the CARD program that the Student is seeking as a remedy.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a three-and-one-half-year-old with a diagnosis of autism. Her disability significantly affects her verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction skills. Her behaviors consistent with her diagnosis have included the displaying of tantrums, self-stimulating activities, discomfort around other people, and a lack of social skills appropriate to her age.
Shortly after her second birthday, STUDENT began receiving services under an individualized family service plan (IFSP) through the Frank R. Lanterman Regional Center. Through this program she received speech and language therapy and various assessments including occupational therapy/sensory integration, vision, and hearing. The Regional Center also funded preschool attendance. STUDENT attended different preschools under the auspices of the Regional Center, but her parents removed her from each program. They did not believe that STUDENT benefitted from these programs. STUDENT currently attends a Montessori preschool program accompanied by a CARD aide.
Since February 2002, STUDENT has participated in discrete trial training (DTT) provided by CARD at her home. She started with 15 hours per week of this therapy and is now receiving 35.4 hours. STUDENT’S parents and private service providers reported remarkable progress and a dramatic lessening of the negative behaviors in recent months.
STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the District. When STUDENT approached the age of three, the transition process from the Regional Center to services from the District began. The District assessed her in April 2002, and concurred with the autism diagnosis. After the District assessment in April 2002, an individualized education program (IEP) meeting convened on June 12, 2002. STUDENT’S parents were present along with District representatives. At the invitation of the parents, two CARD representatives also attended. They shared their suggested goals and objectives with the team.
The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services “due to quantitative impairments in socialization, communication and repetitive and stereotypic behaviors that are consistent with the autistic spectrum.” (Student and District Exhibit 12) The team also incorporated some of the CARD suggestions into the IEP goals and objectives.
The District’s offer of placement for STUDENT in the June 12 IEP (clarified as to the level of services in a follow-up letter of June 24, 2002) was a sensorimotor preschool special day class of seven special needs children, six of whom had autism spectrum disorders. The offer also included individual and group school-based speech and language services, individual clinic and classroom-based occupational therapy, and school-based DTT for two sixty-minute sessions per school day (10 hours per week). The services were to begin during the 2001-2002 extended school year (ESY) and included door-to-door transportation. (Student and District Exhibits 12 and 13)
STUDENT’S father visited the offered sensorimotor class and another District program that was also considered at the meeting. This was a blended inclusion class in which the majority of the students were nondisabled.
STUDENT’S parents have challenged the propriety of the June 12 IEP meeting. They claim that this IEP meeting was procedurally flawed because of the absence of a general education teacher and a special education teacher on the team.
STUDENT’S parents also did not agree to the placement in the June 2002 IEP. In early July 2002, FATHER wrote a letter expressing his “Disagreement to IEP.” (Student and District Exhibit 14) This letter challenged the proposed placement in the sensorimotor special day class as not the least restrictive environment (LRE) for STUDENT as she would have no interaction with typically developing peers. The letter further disagreed with the goals and objectives in the IEP as not the same as the ones proposed by CARD. FATHER requested that CARD provide the DTT “as the NPA provider,” stating that he did not agree with the offered level of services at ten hours per week and that CARD services are not interchangeable with those of District providers. The letter accepted the District’s proposed level of individual occupational therapy “at the NPA” but wanted individual speech and language therapy rather than the group and in-school services offered by the District.
The Hearing Office received a request from the District for a due process hearing on August 7, 2002, seeking a determination that the offer contained in the June 12, 2002 IEP, as clarified in the June 24, 2002 letter from the District, constituted a FAPE.
The Hearing Office then received a request from the Student for a due process hearing on August 12, 2002, seeking a determination that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 extended school year and the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year. The parties later agreed to consolidate the two cases.
During November 2002, the District learned from FATHER and two of STUDENT’S service providers that STUDENT had made substantial and remarkable progress in language, socialization, and behavior since the June assessment. STUDENT had greatly reduced the number of tantrums and had increased verbal and social skills. The District also then learned that STUDENT had been enrolled in a community preschool class.
On December 4, 2002, a week before the due process hearing was to begin, the District convened an additional IEP meeting. The parents received an answering machine message at their home on December 2 that the District wanted to schedule an IEP team meeting with no time specified. FATHER responded with a telephone message to the District the next day asking that the Student’s counsel be contacted to set up the meeting. The District left a telephone message on Ms. Lewis’s office telephone on December 2 and sent a letter to her by facsimile at 4:50 p.m. on December 3 announcing that an IEP meeting was set for 8:30 a.m. on the morning of December 4. Neither STUDENT’S parents nor her attorney attended this session.
The December 4, 2002 meeting yielded a new IEP that supplanted the June 12 IEP and offer. The new IEP offered placement in the blended inclusion class instead of the sensorimotor class and retained the same goals and objectives contained in the June 12 IEP. The District members of the IEP team based the change in placement on the updated information received in November 2002. They concluded that the more restrictive sensorimotor class was no longer needed in light of the reports of STUDENT’S behavior and communication improvements and preschool attendance since the June 12 IEP meeting.
After the December 4 meeting proceeded without Student representation, District counsel sent a letter to the Student’s counsel, forwarding a copy of the latest IEP, and proposed another IEP meeting with the parents. Additional correspondence went from the District and District counsel to the Student’s parents and the Student’s counsel mentioning the need to set up an IEP meeting.
STUDENT’S parents challenged the propriety of the December 4 IEP meeting because of lack of advanced, written notice. They also disagreed with the placement. They indicated that they might accept the blended inclusion class in September 2003, with a CARD aide. They seek an order of reimbursement for the CARD services already provided to STUDENT. They also seek an order for the District to provide continuing CARD services for DTT at home through the rest of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue Number 1: Did the District offer a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to the Student for the 2001-2002 extended school year and for the 2002-2003 school year including the extended school year?
The District is obligated to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to meet her unique needs under the provisions of the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law. 20 U.S.C. §1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.
This free appropriate education includes special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)
“Special education” is specially designed instruction without cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22);
Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(z). State law provides for similar services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
The standard which the District’s instruction and services must meet is to provide the student some educational benefit. Board of Educ. Of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-200. This United States Supreme Court decision does not require a district to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximizes her abilities. STUDENT is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet her unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”
An appropriate public education does not require the absolute best or a “potential maximizing” program for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F. 3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The standard for the school district is whether the proposed placement is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student, not whether the student may obtain a greater benefit from a placement preferred by the parents. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).
Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) mandates the following:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
Education in the least restrictive environment, or “mainstreaming,” is a “strong preference” in special education law “which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).
Therefore, the standards by which the District’s offer to STUDENT is measured to determine if it constitutes a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment are as follows:
1. Is the offer designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs?
2. Is it reasonable calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?
3. Does is conform to her IEP?
4. Does it provide STUDENT the least restrictive environment?
Before it can be determined if the District has offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education, her needs must be identified.
What are STUDENT’S unique needs?
When STUDENT was approaching thirteen to fourteen months of age, her mother and father observed that she seemed to regress in her development. Her parents were concerned that she had severely limited speech and language skills. She was not paying attention when her parents talked to her, and she would not follow directions. When her mother would attempt to read a book to her, STUDENT looked away and did not seem to understand the process. She would not sleep through the night. She had a low frustration threshold and was prone to tantrums. Her behaviors included rolling on the floor, banging her head, face or hands on a wall, and screaming. She would bite both her finger nails and toe nails. She did not like to be around a lot of people and did not want to be held or touched. STUDENT strongly resisted having her hair brushed or her face washed. She would run away and hide for hours in various locations in and around the house such as a closet or the garage. She played alone, did not relate to her younger sibling, and did not play with toys. STUDENT would not sit still. The family kept the house doors locked for fear she would run into the street.
At about the time of her second birthday before she began receiving services from the Regional Center, she was diagnosed with pervasive development disorder not otherwise specified (PDD NOS) with overall delays. Her vocabulary was limited to four words--“hi,” bye,” cookie,” and “bubble.” STUDENT’S mother testified that she did not use “hi” and “bye” in an appropriate context. She was later specifically diagnosed with autism and “as a child with autistic-like behaviors.”
The parties agree with her diagnosis of autism. They also concur that her general areas of need include language and speech including abstract reasoning skill and auditory processing, socialization, and behavior.
The Student, however, contends that the District assessment did not identify her specific unique needs and did not address her gross motor skills. FATHER requested the goals and objectives prepared by CARD as he maintained that these goals and objectives, and not those adopted by the District, “address all of STUDENT’S areas of need (Student and District Exhibit 14).”
The District must assess the Student in all areas of suspected disability before any action is taken. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.
The evidence shows that as part of the transition from regional center services to District services for STUDENT, she was assessed by District professionals. The Student questions the assessment report’s (Student and District Exhibit 10) deferral of gross motor skills assessment until STUDENT is in a classroom setting. The Student also objects to the lack of any observation of STUDENT’S “educational performance” in the CARD program. She lists some 40 needs identified by CARD that she contends were not identified by the District.
The District’s assessment included observations and testing by District speech and language therapist Roxana Daly, District psychologist Dr. Beth Levy, occupational therapist Lisa Serby, and school nurse Joan Madden. All four testified at the hearing. These evaluators described how they applied their professional experience to observe STUDENT and tested her using standard evaluation tools. They also gathered substantial information from STUDENT’S parents, who were present and met with the assessment team.
The following discussion deals with the issues raised by the Student as listed above.
The District’s Gross Motor Skills Assessment
The testimony of the District occupational therapist Lisa Serby demonstrates that STUDENT’S gross motor skills were adequately addressed. Ms. Serby stated that no obvious gross motor problems were observed during STUDENT’S assessment and that it was standard practice to assess gross motor skills after placement in the classroom, along with an adapted physical education evaluation. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’S gross motor skills were properly considered using recognized procedures.
The District’s Observations of STUDENT in the Assessment
The District assessors also testified that the District assessment was grounded in and corroborated by observations of STUDENT during the assessment in a play-like setting. Psychologist Dr. Levy, occupational therapist Serby, and speech and language therapist Daly based their findings, in part, on observations of STUDENT at play in their presence. These observations were “in an environment appropriate for a child of that age” as required of at least one IEP team member under Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(e). The Hearing Officer finds that at the time of the June 12 IEP offer, the observations of STUDENT at play by the District IEP team members met the statutory requirements to complete her assessment.
The District’s Assessment of STUDENT’S needs
As to the list of 40 needs claimed to have been missed by the District’s assessment set forth in the Student’s brief, each is, in fact, covered in the District’s report. For example, the CARD categories of “Oral Motor Weakness,” “Articulation,” “Deficits Of Auditory Comprehension (Auditory Processing),” “Selective Attention Storage,” “Deficits in Gaining Listener Attention,” “Extremely Discontinuous Receptive Language,” ” Moderately Discontinuous Expressive Language,” “Deficits in auditory memory beyond immediate recall,” and “Difficult for her ‘to get the big picture’” were covered within the District’s section entitled “Language and Communication” on page 4 of Exhibit 10. This District section has subheadings of “Receptive Language,” Expressive Language,” and “Speech” that cover these CARD topics.
Similarly, the sections in the District’s report of “Sensory-Motor” and “Social/Emotional and Play” cover the other needs identified by CARD.
The Student avers that the District assessment found STUDENT “compliant” rather than throwing “Tantrums when she is frustrated.” The CARD records showed STUDENT threw temper tantrums both before and after June 12, 2002. The District assessment portrayed STUDENT’S deportment during the session as the assessors observed it. She apparently did not engage in such extreme behavior in their presence. The District assessment at page 3, however, does include the observation that STUDENT was “compliant when tasks were structured. During unstructured time, she had more difficulty organizing her behavior.” The report at page 6 also incorporates under the category “Social/Emotional and Play” her mother’s description of the wide range of STUDENT’S emotions and of the severe tantrums that required physical restraint.
The District evaluation relying in part on the input of STUDENT’S parents recommended that STUDENT be found eligible for special education services based on “handicapping conditions” in the areas of speech and language, fine motor skills, and “sensory seeking and avoidance behaviors that may have a significant impact on classroom behavior, safety and ability to fully access the preschool curriculum.” The report summary also quoted two prior assessments, including one from CARD dated January 21, 2002, agreeing that STUDENT displayed “qualitative impairments in social interaction, communication and repetitive and stereotypic behaviors that are consistent with a diagnosis of autism.” (Exhibit 10, page 7)
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did assess STUDENT in all of her areas of suspected disability as of April 2002. Her needs were sufficiently identified to formulate a program to meet STUDENT’S needs at that time.
The District Offers
The record includes two offers to STUDENT. The first was contained in the June 12, 2002 IEP. This IEP was to cover the 2001-2002 extended school year and the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year. The offer of placement in this document is for a sensorimotor class of mostly autistic children. Accompanying this placement are offers for school-based DTT through District behavior technicians for 10 hours per week, school-based speech and language therapy provided by a District speech pathologist individually for 60 minutes per week and in small groups for 90 minutes per week, individual occupational therapy provided by a District occupational therapist for 30 minutes per week, and clinic-based occupational therapy provided by a nonpublic agency for 120 minutes per week.
The District replaced the June 12 offer with its second and current offer contained in the December 4, 2002 IEP. This second IEP places STUDENT in a blended inclusion class with the same services as included in the June IEP except for a reduction in clinic-based occupational therapy to one hour per week. The sufficiency of the June 12, 2002 offer will be determined first for the time period up to December 4, 2002. Thereafter, the December 4, 2002 offer will be examined.
THE JUNE 12, 2002 OFFER
Was the District’s June 12 offer designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs?
The Student challenges the June 12 offer on several grounds including a contention that the IEP team membership was not legally sufficient. This procedural matter will be dealt with first.
The Constitution of the June IEP Team
The Student contends that the IEP team was not properly constituted as it lacked a special day class teacher and a general education teacher as mandated by Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(1) and (2). The evidence, however, shows that Mirell O’Brien, who was on the team as the designated administrator, is a credentialed and experienced special education teacher. She has also taught a general education class. Speech and language pathologist Daly is also a fully credentialed and experienced special day class teacher. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the team was properly constituted. Moreover, there is no indication that STUDENT suffered any prejudice from the make up of the team.
Student Objections to the June Placement Offer
STUDENT’S father further objected to the placement contained in the June IEP in writing to the District (Student and District Exhibit 14). In this letter he requested that the CARD goals and objectives be incorporated into the IEP.(Footnote 3) He also contended that the IEP goals and objectives did not address all of STUDENT’S areas of need. He objected to the District-administered DTT both as to the providers and the level of therapy. He requested that CARD be the DTT provider for 40 hours per week rather than the ten hours offered by the District.(Footnote 4)
FATHER also later stated an objection to the physical layout of the sensorimotor classroom as a safety issue. FATHER testified that the sensorimotor classroom was too small, and that the therapy equipment was in such close quarters that it presented a hazard.
FATHER further objected to the lack of contact with nondisabled peers would not provide proper modeling for STUDENT and that she would acquire undesirable behaviors.
FATHER also did not believe that the placement would include contact with nondisabled peers and that it would not place STUDENT in the least restrictive environment. These objections are discussed in the section below dealing with the least restrictive environment issues.
CARD supervisor Theresa Bartholomew accompanied FATHER to view the sensorimotor class and was on the June 12 IEP team. She observed during her testimony at the hearing that the classroom would be too distracting for STUDENT as compared to the CARD in-home therapy.
The following discussion deals with these objections.
The June IEP Goals and Objectives
The District program and the goals and objective that followed in the June 12 offer related to each of STUDENT’S needs as identified in the District assessment. The June 12 IEP includes 13 goals ranging from “STUDENT will demonstrate the ability to initiate and to respond appropriately when others initiate conversational openings. . .” to “STUDENT will ambulate throughout the preschool environment and use sensory equipment safely with minimal verbal cues.” (See District and Student Exhibit 15).
The June 12, 2002 IEP meeting that followed the assessment lasted over three hours. The District evaluators participated with the parents and two CARD representatives, Supervisor Theresa Bartholomew and research director Dr. Sebastien Bosch. The CARD representatives gave a presentation and described the therapy administered to STUDENT and the progress she had made to date.(Footnote 5)
The IEP goals and objectives incorporated substantial portions of the submitted CARD proposed goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer further finds that the goals and objectives adopted in the IEP sufficiently cover STUDENT’S identified needs as of June 2002.
The June Placement Offer and Meeting STUDENT’S needs The sensorimotor class teacher, Joan Welday, is a fully credentialed teacher with substantial experience and education in early childhood education, children diagnosed on the autism spectrum, and special education in general. She described a typical day in her class and outlined the structure and activities of the program in detail. The class operates with three aides. The aides administer the DTT with supervision by District psychologist Dr. Bernhardt, who does reliability checks on the aides’ performance. He also has weekly meetings with the staff to review the progress in each child’s file and adjusts the therapy as needed. The controlled environment addressed the safety issues. The room is in an enclosed and locked area. The classroom is available for speech and language therapy, occupational therapy, and DTT.
The evidence points to a controlled, structured classroom environment with peers and trained adults as the best means to meet STUDENT’S needs in June 2002 to generalize her emerging skills and improve her language and socialization.
The June Placement Offer and Classroom Safety
The IEP team weighed STUDENT’S parents’ concern for her safety in the school setting. Her parents asserted that STUDENT would run off by herself and needed close supervision. Occupational therapist Lisa Serby also testified that she was concerned after her assessment of STUDENT that she needed close supervision as she “had no fear of falling” and needed to learn to be responsive to verbal cues. The District asserted that this information was all taken into account in recommending a placement for STUDENT in a controlled classroom environment to meet these needs.
FATHER’s safety concerns are not borne out by the record. The equipment in the classroom is used only with the trained therapists. The teacher and three trained aides are present to work with the seven students in the class. The evidence, therefore, supports a finding that with the high ratio of adults to children and the controlled, structured classroom, the sensorimotor class is a safe and supervised environment that met STUDENT’S safety needs as of June 12, 2002.
The June Placement Offer and Level of Services
As to the level of services, the evidence offered by the CARD witnesses was that 40 hours per week was necessary for STUDENT to advance.
CARD founder and clinic director Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh also testified. She worked with Dr. Ivar Lovass at the University of California, Los Angeles. She participated in the well-known 1987 study that concluded intervention at an early age with intense DTT of up to 40 hours per week yielded a 27 percent recovery rate among autistic youngsters.
She participated in the initial CARD evaluation of STUDENT and reviewed the CARD records of her progress. Dr. Granpeesheh advocated a 40-hour-per-week DTT program through CARD. She indicated that STUDENT should remain in this in-home program until the fall of 2003. This is notwithstanding the evidence the STUDENT received substantially less than 40 hours a week at least during the first half of 2002 through the June 12 IEP meeting.
The District offered the testimony of Dr. Edward Ritvo, who is a professor emeritus at the Neuropsychiatric Institute (NPI) at the University of California, Los Angeles. He is a medical doctor with a specialization in psychiatry and has worked with autistic youngsters for most of his career. Over 40 years ago, he participated in the first school program for autistic children at the NPI. He also helped found the first medical journal devoted to autism. He has authored over 120 peer review articles and several books dealing with autism. He wrote the definition of autism used in the DSM-IV and has continued to work with autistic children all over the world.
Dr. Ritvo stated that autism is a “remittent condition” that improves in the vast majority of cases without intervention. He nevertheless favors therapy, because if children are left alone they will become “stuck” in their development. He advocates mainstreaming of autistic children as soon as they are able to relate to others. As to the level of DTT, Dr. Ritvo believes that a 40- hour-per-week program is justified only in the extreme cases such as with a child who is completely noncommunicative, self-isolating, very aggressive, or self-injuring. Even in this extreme situation, Dr. Ritvo advocates decreasing the number of hours rapidly as progress is made.
He said too much therapy can make the children “robotic” and cue-dependent or dependent on one adult. Dr. Ritvo testified that the 1987 Lovass study was controversial and had been criticized in the professional literature.
The District witnesses, Dr. Bernhardt, Dr. Levy, and Ms. Welday, also recommended ten hours per week as more appropriate for STUDENT at that time to meet her needs as imbedded in the District program. Dr. Bernhardt commented that the professional literature is conflicting as to the general use and value of 40 hours per week of DTT. These District professionals have training and experience in DTT and other therapies designed for the education of autistic children. Dr. Bernhardt, program specialist Beecher and Ms. Welday testified that the District’s program would be adjusted after STUDENT enrolled in the class to meet her needs as they change over time.
The record does not support that 40 hours a week was a necessary number for STUDENT at the time of the June 2002 IEP. The evidence indicates that even in the CARD program she was receiving far less than 40 hours in June 2002. She started at the level of 15 hours a week in February 2002 without a classroom program with trained teachers, aides, and therapists. The CARD program as described by Dr. Granpeesheh also contemplates reducing the hours of DTT once STUDENT is in a District classroom.
Dr. Ritvo reviewed various exhibits, including the IEPs. Dr. Ritvo visited both classrooms that the District offered and observed the programs. On the basis of his record review, he found the sensorimotor class to be suitable for STUDENT as of June 2002. He strongly advocated placing students in a school setting as soon as possible.
The offer also contemplates that STUDENT will attend class with her peers. This interaction and socialization, according to Dr. Ritvo, is a vital element of the program. He endorses reducing DTT hours to place children in a peer setting as soon as is practicable.
Based on the state of the record, the Hearing Officer finds that 10 hours a week of DTT in the District’s total program was an appropriate level for STUDENTas of June 2002. The District offer envisioned STUDENT entering the classroom with the benefit of the peer interaction and socialization as well as the various therapies. The evidence supports that the peer interaction as of June 2002 in the natural learning environment of the classroom would address STUDENT’S needs in the speech and language, socialization, and behavior areas.
The June Placement Offer Service Providers and Methodology
STUDENT’S CARD supervisors, Henry Moore and Theresa Bartholomew, described their professional training and manner in which CARD provides therapy and documents results. CARD trains and supervises its personnel. The CARD personnel work closely with the parents. The program includes monthly clinics to assess progress and adjust therapies as necessary. CARD research director, Dr. Sebastien Bosch, pointed out differences in “teaching style” between CARD techniques and those implemented by the District that he believed made CARD more effective. Both Dr. Granpeesheh and Dr. Bosch described differences in the therapeutic practices between CARD and the District.
The District regularly monitors and evaluates the progress of each student receiving DTT. Adjustments are made as needed. The District professionals also are trained in other therapies in addition to DTT. The constant monitoring and other techniques in the District repertoire enhance the capability of the District to meet STUDENT’S evolving needs. As to therapeutic methodology, Dr. Ritvo described it as “an art” with no specific formula for all autistic children. Treating autistic children is not a “one size fits all” proposition as Dr. Ritvo observed.
This disagreement on methodology does not require the District to hire CARD for STUDENT to provide DTT. District psychologist Levy indicated that outside providers are not considered if the District has professional providers available in the school setting. The record shows that the District has such professional providers. As long as the District is providing an appropriate education, methodology is properly within the District’s discretion. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 458.
The June Placement Offer Classroom Distraction and Behavior Modeling
Dr. Ritvo said that the classroom is a proper setting for appropriate therapies and that STUDENT would probably adjust to the potentially more distracting environment than the home. Dr. Bernhardt also stated that children learn to filter out the background activity in the classroom. He said this was an essential skill to learn in the classroom for school success. Therefore, even if the sensorimotor class were found to be measurably more distracting, STUDENT needs to learn to function in the classroom if she is to have success in school.
Addressing the issue of STUDENT modeling inappropriate behaviors in a class with other autistic youngsters, Dr. Ritvo said that all children will pick up behaviors they observe. He said, however, that a trained teacher in the classroom would deal with this typical situation.
One of the fundamental issues for autistic children as described by the witnesses including Dr. Granpeesheh, Dr. Bosch, and Dr. Levy, is generalization or the ability to implement the skills or language patterns they learn in therapy in everyday situations. The District assessment as expanded in Dr. Levy’s testimony found STUDENT to have average nonverbal intelligence, a good memory, and good problem solving abilities in April 2002. It was her language and socialization skills that were delayed. Dr. Ritvo advocated stressing a child’s skills to work on the weaknesses. Her analytic skills can be applied to her classroom interaction. Dr. Levy testified that the offered program would allow STUDENT to use her intelligence and memory to improve on her communication and social skills in the classroom.
On the state of this record, the Hearing Officer finds that as of June 12, 2002, the evidence supports the District’s offer of the sensorimotor class and services with District providers as an appropriate means to address STUDENT’S ‘handicapping conditions” of “social interaction, communication and repetitive and stereotypic behaviors” identified in the District’s April 2002 assessment.
Therefore, the June 12, 2002 program as designed by the District to be administered by experienced District professionals did meet STUDENT’S unique needs based on the information available to the District at that time.
Was the District’s June 12 offer reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit?
Experienced District special education teacher Joan Welday and trained classroom aides in that classroom would work with STUDENT. Dr. Bernhardt supervises the aides and meets with the teacher and aides on at least a weekly basis. Both language and speech and occupational therapy services are provided by experienced and trained professionals who have worked with a substantial number of autistic children.
Although STUDENT did not accept the placement and services in the June 12 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that based on this IEP and the evidence of the offered sensorimotor class, providers, and designated services, STUDENT would likely have received some educational benefit at that time.
Did the District’s June 12 offer conform to STUDENT’S IEP?
As this IEP was not implemented, this standard is not applicable.
Does the District’s June 12 offer provide STUDENT the least restrictive environment?
As of June 2002 STUDENT’S parents and District assessors had expressed concern for STUDENT’S safety. She had a history of running away, falling down, and hiding. The doors at home were locked to keep her from straying into the front yard and street. On equipment she showed no fear of falling. She threw frequent tantrums. All of these concerns led to the placement in the controlled and structured environment of the sensorimotor class rather than another preschool program that would be less restrictive.
FATHER expressed concern that STUDENT would be the highest functioning student in the class and that she would not have a chance to interact with typically developing peers. This class, however, is located on a private school campus housing general education students. STUDENT’S June 12 IEP provided for inclusion with these students and provided an environment that was as restrictive as necessary to meet her needs as determined as of that date.
The sensorimotor class was on a private school campus. Nondisabled peers were in other classes and STUDENT would have the opportunity to relate to them as part of the offered program. Because of her communication, behavior, socialization and safety needs, the sensorimotor classroom was selected by the IEP team. As STUDENT had these unique needs of such a severity in June 2002, education in regular classes could not be achieved satisfactorily at that time.
District psychologist Levy observed that the CARD in-home program would surround STUDENT with only adults. The CARD home program is the more restrictive environment for STUDENT. The District program specifically provides peer interaction in school, which is a natural learning environment for a child of STUDENT’S age. Although the home is also a natural learning environment for STUDENT, the record supports the classroom setting as providing a proper balance of peer interaction and services.
Dr. Levy termed the classroom therapies as “a good transition” from the home-based therapy. STUDENT would have the opportunity for interaction with general education students for a minimum of ten percent of her time in school. All of these aspects of the placement were, at that time, designed to meet STUDENT’S needs of close supervision and attention to delayed language and speech development, tantrums, stereotypic behaviors, and socialization skills in the least restrictive environment.
The evidence shows that the June 12, 2002 offer provided the least restrictive environment for STUDENT.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for the period from June 12, 2002, through December 4, 2002, the District offered to STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment.
The next issue for determination is whether the offer contained in the December 4, 2002 IEP constitutes a FAPE for STUDENT.
THE DECEMBER 4, 2002 OFFER
Was the District’s December 4, 2002 offer designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and calculated to provide some educational benefit?
The record suggests that the District was keenly aware on the eve of the due process hearing that STUDENT’S improvement since the June 12, 2002 IEP might render the original offer at that time inappropriate to her changed needs. The evidence also suggest that the District wanted an updated IEP and offer of placement for introduction into evidence at the imminent hearing.
The Student has raised the question of notice and procedural violations in the conduct of this IEP meeting. Although serious issues are present as to whether the District violated procedural requirements, the Hearing Officer need not reach them. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer finds that the December 4 offer was substantially inappropriate and, therefore, denied STUDENT a free appropriate public education.
Although the record does not indicate explicitly, it appears that the limited disclosures to the District of STUDENT’S great strides forward may have come about either inadvertently or fortuitously. FATHER was visiting the blended inclusion class for the second time and made the statements about STUDENT’S progress while engaging in conversation with District program specialist Beecher. The record does not indicate whether FATHER volunteered the general comments about STUDENT in passing or whether Ms. Beecher solicited the update. Nevertheless, Ms. Beecher and District occupational therapist Lisa Serby followed up and obtained some further information from STUDENT’S non-CARD service providers about her progress.
Although a different placement for STUDENT became proper after the November 2002 disclosures, the December 4, 2002 IEP falls short of the mark.
The initial placement of a special needs child requires an assessment of the student’s educational needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. The law provides for reassessment every three years or if conditions warrant it. The oral statements heard by the District underscore the fundamental change in STUDENT’S condition. This fundamental change clearly triggered the need for a reassessment. The substantial differences in STUDENT’S condition mandated a reassessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381.
The law requires that the IEP include a statement of present levels of performance. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a) . The District did not know what STUDENT’S present levels of performance were on December 4, 2002. Moreover, the December 4, 2002 IEP adopts the June 12 goals without any revisions. The District was unable to establish that the goals and objectives suited STUDENT’S unique needs in December 2002. The goals and objectives did not reflect the quantum leaps in the social, behavioral, and language arenas that STUDENT’S father reported and that the District believed had occurred. The District knew that there were changes but knew little else about the nature of that progress or her changed needs.
The June 12 offer, on the other hand, was based on what the District knew through quantitative and qualitative evaluation and collaboration with STUDENT’S parents and CARD representatives. The December 4 offer issued without any observation of STUDENT. The December 4 offer arose not only without input or discussion with the parents, but also without a follow-up inquiry to CARD, STUDENT’S chief service provider since February 2002. The District simply had no data beyond general statements of what Dr. Granpeesheh termed “astounding progress” to base a placement that is required to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. The District did not know what her needs were on December 4 except to suspect that they were quite different from what the District had assessed in April 2002.
The District’s own witnesses testified to the lack of knowledge of STUDENT’S needs as of December 4. District psychologist and December 4 IEP team member Dr. Levy testified that she had “no opinion” of STUDENT’S needs as of December 2002. District occupational therapist Ms. Serby testified that she could not indicate STUDENT’S current needs, not having seen her for eight months.
The District certainly recognized that STUDENThad changed since the last evaluation. Notwithstanding this awareness there was no effort to obtain a new assessment as required by California Education Code section 56381(a).
Moreover, the serious issue of regression also is not addressed in the December 4 IEP. Dr. Granpeesheh and Dr. Bosch testified that without sustaining STUDENT’S DTT at 35 to 40 hours until she goes into a District classroom, she will regress. There is evidence supporting less than 35 to 40 hours as part of a total program for STUDENTas her needs were known in June 2002. There is no controverting evidence in the record, however, specifically challenging the statements of Dr. Granpeesheh and Dr. Bosch on the risk of regression. No District witness has responded to what is a crucial consideration for any youngster diagnosed on the autism spectrum who has shown even the slightest progress. It is even a more compelling consideration for a child who has made substantial progress. Dr. Granpeesheh described STUDENTas a “recovery child” within that minority category of autistic children who may be eventually served in a general education class and become indistinguishable from her non-disabled peers. STUDENT’S dramatic progress is too important not to consider the risk of regression in evaluating her present levels and her current needs.
Although the District did place in the December 4 IEP a summary of STUDENT’S changed circumstances labeled “present level”and acknowledged the need for follow-up IEP team sessions to revise goals and objectives, without an updated assessment and goals and objectives based on such an assessment, the December 4 IEP does not meet the IDEA or State law requirements that an offer of FAPE identify and address unique needs.
Because the District’s December 4 offer did not meet STUDENT’S unique needs at the time, the issues of some educational benefit, conformity to the IEP, or the least restrictive environment need not be reached.
The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence indicates that the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the period from December 4, 2002, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
Issue Number 2: Is the Student entitled to be reimbursed for services provided to her by CARD through the date of this Decision and also entitled to prospective placement with CARD at District expense?
A denial of FAPE by an educational agency entitles the student to “appropriate” relief in light of the purposes of IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v.Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374; 105 S.C. 1996 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415. Burlington provides for retroactive reimbursement as equitable relief for the denial of appropriate special education when parents provide an appropriate replacement education. This equitable principle also provides hearing officers with the authority to award prospective placement or services in a private school or NPA at public expense. State law imposes the additional requirement that the NPA be state-certified. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.2.
In unilateral placements, parents are expressly exempted from some of the requirements of the IDEA, such as conformity to the student’s IEP, if the private program meets the student’s needs and provides an educational benefit. Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 113; 114 S.C. 361 (1993).
STUDENT’S parents chose to engage the services of CARD for STUDENT in February 2002. From the assessments by the District in the spring 2002, until the anecdotal reports received in the fall of last year, STUDENT showed progress during the time she was receiving the CARD therapy. Her parents rejected the June 12, 2002 offer from the District and have continued with CARD therapy to the present date.
The Hearing Officer has determined that based on the data available at that time, the offer of June 12, 2002, constituted a free appropriate public education to STUDENT. Therefore, no compensation is awarded for the period through December 3, 2002.
In contrast, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s December 4, 2002 offer, that supplanted the June 12 offer, did not provide a free appropriate public education to STUDENT. The record indicates that STUDENT has made stunning advancements since the April 2002 District assessments. Although this progress has not been assessed, the evidence of her progress indicates that the CARD therapy clearly meets STUDENT’S current needs and provides her a benefit. There is no dispute in the record that CARD is state-certified. The Hearing Officer finds that the CARD services were appropriate.
Therefore, commencing December 4, 2002, until the date of this Decision, STUDENT’S parents are awarded retroactive reimbursement of the costs of the CARD services under Burlington, supra.
The Hearing Officer has determined that the District from December 4, 2002 through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE and that the parents’ placement at CARD was appropriate. There are currently approximately two and one-half months remaining in the 2002-2003 school year and only four weeks in the extended school year. Insufficient time remains for the District to develop a revised offer to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. Consequently, STUDENT shall remain in the CARD placement for the balance of this school year and extended school year and the District shall pay the costs.
Receipt of the CARD services will allow STUDENT to continue to progress until the District has an opportunity to assess her and craft a program to meet her unique needs.
ORDER
(1) The District offer in the June 12 IEP constituted an offer of FAPE to the Student.
(2) The District offer in the December 4 IEP did not constitute an offer of FAPE to the Student.
(3) The District shall reimburse to the Student’s parents the amounts shown on CARD invoices for DTT and related services for STUDENT for the time period from December 4, 2002 through the date this Decision. Thereafter, the District shall arrange for the receipt of CARD invoices and shall pay CARD directly for the current level of services to STUDENT continuously from the date of this Decision through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
(4) All other requests for relief of the parties’ are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
(1) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The District prevailed on the issue of the June 12, 2002 IEP offer. The Student prevailed on the issue of the December 4, 2002 IEP offer.
(2) The District prevailed in part and the Student prevailed in part. The District prevailed for the 2001-2002 extended school year and for the 2002-2003 school year through December 3, 2002. The Student prevailed for the period from December 4, 2002, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(I).
DATED: March 24, 2003 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The wording of the issues here differs somewhat from the statements of issues filed by the parties before the hearing. Changes in the language and in the order were made for clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No Changes in substance have been made. 2. The Student’s closing brief raises for the first time an issue of compensatory education in the areas of speech and language and occupational therapy. The evidence indicates that STUDENT has been receiving these services through the Regional Center. The District has also offered services but has not provided any. The Hearing Officer will not reach this issue as there was no evidence or argument concerning compensatory education during the hearing. 3. As some of the CARD goals were incorporated, it appears that FATHER was requesting that all of the CARD goals be included. 4. It is not clear from the record what the exact number of hours of DTT STUDENT was receiving from CARD in June 2002. The CARD testimony indicated that she started at 15 hours per week in February 2002 and increased the level to 37.5 hours by the end of 2002. Student Exhibit 15, which are the invoices for CARD services, shows a level of therapy for May 2002 at 4.5 hours, August 2002 at 14.5 hours, September 2002 at 44.5 hours, and October 2002 at 37.5 hours. 5. It was not until November 2002 that the District learned of STUDENT’S spurt of progress during the intervening months.
