California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 22, 2001
Student v. Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1856-99 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified must continue compensatory services until graduation or age 21; independent assessment reimbursement denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
The decision refers to earlier rulings in the same matter. A December 6, 1999 expedited decision found the District used improper procedures to transfer the student to Rancho Del Mar and ordered his return to Palos Verdes Peninsula High School; the parents chose to keep him at Rancho Del Mar. A December 13, 1999 order adopted the parties' agreement on further assessments. On March 30, 2000, the parties settled prospective education issues, and the settlement was written into the April 7, 2000 IEP.
Summary
A 16-year-old tenth grader was suspended and moved to a continuation high school. His parents then filed for due process against Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District. The District filed its own request to finish assessing him, and the two cases were consolidated. Many issues were settled along the way through an earlier expedited decision, an agreed assessment order, and a March 2000 settlement. Under that settlement, the student was found eligible based on a learning disability and a speech and language disability. Three issues remained.
First, the parents asked to be repaid for two assessments by independent psychologist Dr. Claudia McCulloch. The Hearing Officer denied this. At the time of her first assessment, the parents had not disagreed with the District's assessments. Instead, they objected to more testing and to the assessor the District chose. He also found the District's assessments appropriate, including one by Dr. Bruce Gale, who gathered input from teachers.
Second, the District admitted it owed compensatory education. It had failed to identify, assess, and serve the student in seventh through ninth grades. The Hearing Officer limited the claim to the three years before filing and rejected day-for-day compensation. He ordered the District to keep providing daily resource specialist service, 50 minutes of counseling a week, 90 minutes of speech therapy a week, and one hour of tutoring a day until graduation or age 21.
Third, he denied the parents' request to be repaid for the cost of serving subpoenas.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated an independent assessment request based on objections to further testing or to a chosen assessor, rather than disagreement with completed assessments. It also shows a compensatory award that relied on the Ninth Circuit's Puyallup case, rejected day-for-day relief, and tied services to graduation or age 21.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1a. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Claudia McCulloch's independent assessments? (a) Did the parents disagree with the District's assessment?
When the first independent assessment was done in November 1999, the parents had not disagreed with the District's completed assessments. They objected to further testing and to the District's chosen assessor, which does not create a right to an IEE. They did disagree before the December assessment.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1b. Were the District's assessments appropriate?
The District's assessments by Hanson, Gambaro and Dr. Gale were appropriate and covered all areas of suspected disability. Dr. Gale validly used the TAT and Rorschach and drew on teacher input, so no reimbursement was owed for Dr. McCulloch's assessments.
- Student prevailed in partChild find
Issue 2. What compensatory education should the District be required to provide to the student?
The District conceded it failed to identify, assess and serve the student in grades 7–9. The claim was limited to the three years before the November 1, 1996 cutoff, and a day-for-day award was rejected. The District was ordered to continue the agreed services until graduation or age 21.
- District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 3. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for costs relating to the service of subpoenas?
A hearing officer has no authority to award attorney's fees or other legal costs; only a court may do so.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. The District must keep providing these services as compensatory education during the regular school year, and during extended school year if the IEP includes it, until the student graduates from high school or turns 21, whichever comes first: (1) resource specialist service one period each school day; (2) one 50-minute counseling session each week; (3) 90 minutes per week of individual speech and language therapy; (4) one hour of individual tutoring each school day; (5) other services the IEP team deems appropriate.
Key authorities
Burlington School Committee v. Department of Education (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994); Education Code section 56329; Education Code section 56344; Education Code section 56320; Education Code section 56504.5(j); Education Code section 56507
People named in the decision
- Lynn Busia, director of pupil services, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Claudia McCulloch, independent psychologist/assessor retained by parents; witness for Student, Private
- Winifred Sonya Porter Gambaro, speech-language pathologist/assessor, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Carol Hanson, school psychologist, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Chris Glassy, school nurse, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Jack Schnel, school psychologist assigned to further assessment, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Bruce M. Gale, private psychologist retained by District to assess, Private practice
- Carol Atkins, clinical audiologist
- Kelly Johnson, principal, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Cathyrn Boyd, resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- William Howard, principal, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
- Kathleen Sullivan, special education teacher, Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The hearing in this case was conducted in Palos Verdes Estates on November 30, and December 9 and 10, 1999, and March 30, August 22 and 23, November 16 and 17, and December 11, 2000, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner STUDENT was represented by his mother, MOTHER, throughout the hearing, and by attorney Marcy J.K. Tiffany during the final three days of hearing. Also present on behalf of petitioner during portions of the hearing was his father, FATHER.
Respondent Palos Verdes Peninsula Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Andrew V. Arczynski. Also present on behalf of respondent was Lynn Busia, director of pupil services.
At the conclusion of the hearing, the record was left open for the receipt of closing briefs. The briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on January 22, 2001, the record was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to be reimbursed by the District for the cost of independent assessments performed by Claudia McCulloch?
2. What compensatory education should the District be required to provide to STUDENT?(Footnote 1)
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to be reimbursed by the District for costs relating to the service of subpoenas?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a 16-year-old young man who was first identified as being eligible for special education services at age four because of delays in expressive language. In the spring of l989, he was placed by the District in a special day class to address his severe delays in syntax, morphology, and receptive language skills.
In September 1989, STUDENT was enrolled in the Torrance School District, where he remained for kindergarten through third grade. He received resource specialist services until the end of the second grade, when he was removed from special education by his parents. STUDENT transferred back to the District at the beginning of his fourth grade year. He did not receive any special education services during the fourth grade.
At the end of the fourth grade, STUDENT’s parents requested the District to address STUDENT’s articulation problem. No formal assessment was performed by the District, but an IEP was developed and speech and language services were provided during the fifth grade.
STUDENT continued to receive speech and language services in the sixth and seventh grade. The last IEP during this period was completed in May l996, at the end of his sixth grade year. There is no evidence in the record to indicate that special education services were provided after the seventh grade. STUDENT’s grades began to suffer in the seventh grade and continued to be a problem in the eighth grade. There were meetings of STUDENT’s student study team to address these problems, but there is no evidence that the District conducted any assessments or developed further IEPs. There is little information in the record as to STUDENT’s education during the ninth grade other than report cards that indicate he was continuing to have academic problems, including D’s in English and algebra.
On September 21, 1999, shortly after he began his tenth grade year, STUDENT was suspended for three days because he was alleged to have extorted money from another student. On October 20, 1999, STUDENT’s mother wrote to the District requesting that an IEP meeting be convened to arrange for special education services. On October 22, 1999, STUDENT’s parents approved an assessment plan. The plan included assessment in the areas of academic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, language/speech communication, general ability, and health and development. On October 26, 1999, STUDENT was suspended for five days because he was alleged to have been in possession of a small baggie of marijuana. On November 1, 1999, the District transferred STUDENT to Rancho Del Mar, a continuation high school. On the same day, STUDENT’s parents filed a request for an expedited hearing to address his change of placement and other issues concerning STUDENT’s eligibility to receive special education services.
A preliminary IEP team meeting was conducted on November 9, 1999, during which the team reviewed an assessment of speech and language performed by Winifred Sonya Porter Gambaro, a psychological assessment by school psychologist Carol Hanson, and a health assessment by school nurse Chris Glassy.
In her assessment dated November 8, 1999, Ms. Gambaro concluded that STUDENT had significant delays in receptive language components of auditory memory, auditory comprehension, sound discrimination and synthesis. He also had delays in expressive language. He had delays in complex grammar use for both verbal and written language and showed pragmatic weakness with regard to drawing inferences and understanding multiple meanings for sentences. Ms. Gambaro recommended language support, speech therapy, and various modifications and accommodations in his classroom.
Ms. Hanson evaluated STUDENT on October 27 and 28, 1999. In her report Ms. Hanson concluded that STUDENT had a severe discrepancy between his ability and achievement in math calculations and written expression. These discrepancies were due to a disorder in visual processing and sensory motor skills. Ms. Hanson also concluded that STUDENT did not have an attention disorder and that he was not emotionally disturbed.
School nurse Chris Glassy concluded from her health assessment that STUDENT did not suffer from any health problems that would impact on his education.
After a review of the assessments on November 9, the IEP team attempted to determine what to do next. STUDENT’s parents felt that STUDENT’s eligibility for special education had been established based upon STUDENT’s learning disability and a speech and language disorder. They wanted the District to immediately begin providing special education services. The District, while not denying that STUDENT was eligible for special education, wanted to do additional assessments in the area of emotional and behavior prior to developing an IEP. The District’s witnesses testified that they wanted additional assessment in this area because of information provided by STUDENT’s parents concerning his mental and emotional state.
Following the November 9, 1999 IEP meeting, the District, later in the day, attempted to arrange for school psychologist Jack Schnel to further assess STUDENT in the areas of social-emotional and behavior. In a letter dated November 9, 1999, STUDENT’s mother wrote to the District requesting that it retain the services of Dr. Claudia McCulloch to conduct an independent educational assessment. When the District did not agree to fund such an independent assessment, STUDENT’s parents retained the services of Dr. McCulloch, who assessed STUDENT on November 21 and 22, 1999.
In her report, Dr. McCulloch concludes that STUDENT meets the diagnostic criteria as major depressive disorder and may be at risk for suicide. She also concludes that he meets the diagnostic criteria as attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), predominantly inattentive type, oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder. She made a number of recommendations for his treatment including placement in a residential treatment program and vigorous family therapy.
On November 30, 1999, an expedited hearing was conducted to determine whether STUDENT was appropriately removed from his placement at Palos Verdes Peninsula High School. The issue relating to STUDENT’s transfer to Rancho Del Mar was heard and the hearing was continued to December 9 and 10, 1999, at which time STUDENT could present evidence on the other issues raised in his request for hearing. A decision by this Hearing Officer was issued on December 6, 1999, which concluded that the District had not followed appropriate procedures in transferring STUDENT from Palos Verdes Peninsula High School to Rancho Del Mar High School, and ordered the District to return him to his former placement at Palos Verdes Peninsula High School. In spite of this decision, STUDENT’s parents agreed to continue him at Rancho Del Mar.
The District filed a hearing request on November 30, 1999, requesting that it be allowed to complete its assessment of STUDENT. Eventually, the District moved to consolidate its hearing request and the previous hearing request by STUDENT, and further requested that the Hearing Officer hear the issue of assessment prior to addressing the issues raised in STUDENT’s hearing request. The hearing was reconvened on December 9 and 10, 1999, at which time the Hearing Officer granted the request to consolidate the cases and hear first the issue of the right of the District to do further assessments of STUDENT. The District contended that it was not prepared to put on its case at that time and asked for a continuance. The Hearing Officer ruled that the District would not be forced to put on its case concerning assessment at that time, but would not further delay STUDENT’s right to present his case concerning the issues raised in his hearing request. STUDENT’s mother called a number of witnesses including herself, Dr. McCulloch, Carol Hanson, Winifred Sonya Gambaro, Lynn Busia, principal Kelly Johnson, RSP teacher Cathyrn Boyd, principal William Howard, and special education teacher Kathleen Sullivan.
After STUDENT’s mother rested her case, the District made a motion to grant its request for further assessment and continue the hearing until those assessments were completed. The Hearing Officer told the parties that the evidence presented by the witnesses called by STUDENT’s mother convinced him that the District should be permitted to do further assessments of STUDENT in the areas of social-emotional status and attention disorders and further assessments in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer suggested that to save time it might be appropriate for the parties to enter into an agreement concerning further assessments by the District. The parties reached an agreement, and the Hearing Officer issued an order on December 13, 1999, requiring the parties to comply with the agreement. The order also required the parties to conduct an IEP meeting following the assessments, and continued the hearing to January 11 and 12, 2000.(Footnote 2)
Further speech and language assessments were conducted by Ms. Gambaro on December 16, 1999. Ms. Gambaro found that STUDENT had “difficulty when addressing certain auditory processing tasks in the given test setting” and suggested additional testing by an audiologist.
On behalf of the District, Dr. Bruce M. Gale performed psychological assessments of STUDENT on January 7, 13, and 17, 2000. In his report dated January 29, 2000, Dr. Gale concluded that STUDENT’s suffered from a depressive disorder. He also concluded that while there were indications of ADHD/inattentive type, it should be ruled out at this time. Dr. Gale recommended a number of interventions, including family counseling, and recommended that a referral be made to the Department of Mental Health.
On January 23, 2000, clinical audiologist Carol Atkins conduct an audiometric evaluation of STUDENT. She concluded that his hearing was “within the range of normal bilaterally.”
After the hearing on December 9 and 10, 1999, STUDENT’s parents independently requested Dr. McCulloch to do further assessment of STUDENT. She met with STUDENT on December 17, 20, 21 and 23, 1999. In her report dated December 28, 1999, Dr. McCulloch reached the same conclusions that she had in her previous report. She concluded that STUDENT has a major depressive disorder, ADHD/inattentive type, oppositional defiant disorder and conduct disorder. However, in this report Dr. McColluch does not recommend a residential placement.
On February 1 and 14, 2000, the IEP team met to review the assessments and develop an IEP for STUDENT. Goals and Objectives were developed in the areas of math, written expression, organization and study skills, and speech and language. A transition plan was also developed. The team agreed that STUDENT should receive one period per day of resource specialist services and counseling once a week. The District concluded that STUDENT’s primary qualifying disability related to his depression and recommended classifying him as emotionally disturbed. Although much progress was made during these meetings, STUDENT’s parents disagreed with a number of elements of the program including the qualifying disability. They believed that STUDENT’s depression was situational and had not been a long-term problem. They believed that he was eligible for special education because of his learning disability, speech and language deficiencies, and ADHD. The District wanted STUDENT returned to Peninsula High School as the least restrictive environment. STUDENT’s parents wanted him to continue at Del Mar High School until the end of the school year. STUDENT’s parents also requested additional services including more one-to-one tutoring and the Fast ForWord program during the summer. The parties continued to communicate through a series of letters.
The hearing in this matter was reconvened on March 30, 2000, at which time the parties attempted to reach agreement concerning STUDENT’s IEP. The parties reached settlement concerning prospective education for STUDENT and agreed to conduct an IEP meeting on April 7, 2000, to incorporate the terms of the agreement into STUDENT’s IEP. The only issues that remained to be decided in the hearing were whether STUDENT’s parents were entitled to reimbursement from the District for the costs of Dr. McCulloch’s independent assessments and whether STUDENT was entitled to compensatory education. The parties agreed to continue the hearing on those issues and to meet with a mediator to see if they could reach a final resolution could be accomplished.
The IEP team met on April 7, 2000, and incorporated the terms of the settlement agreement into STUDENT’s IEP. The IEP provided for increasing the amount of speech and language to 90 minutes per week, and one-to-one tutoring to between four and five hours per week. Counseling of 50 minutes per week for ten sessions was also added. The District agreed to classify STUDENT as eligible for special education as a student with a learning and speech and language disability. The placement would continue to be at Del Mar High School, and special accommodations would be provided including preferential seating and extra time for tests and completion of assignments. The District agreed to provide the Lindamood-Bell program and the Fast ForWord program during summer school. There were also some modifications of the goals and objectives.
During the first half of 2000, STUDENT remained at Del Mar High School. Although STUDENT’s IEP had not been completed until April, the regular program at Del Mar had many of the accommodations provided to learning disabled students, including small class size, individually tailored assignments, and extended time to complete assignments and tests. During his first full semester at Del Mar, STUDENT received all passing grades including A’s in music appreciation and woodshop, B’s in health and history, C’s in computer typing, physical education, English and math. He earned 45 units toward graduation during this semester. During summer school, STUDENT completed the Fast ForWord Program and earned 10 units toward graduation.
At some time during the summer of 2000, STUDENT was wounded in a drive-by shooting. His parents sent him to live with relatives in Northern California. STUDENT eventually ran away from the relatives’ home and returned to his parents’ home. He briefly returned to Del Mar High School until the court revoked his parole and sentenced him to 90 days at a youth camp, where he is currently serving his sentence.
Although this hearing has lasted over a year, many of the issues originally raised by the parties have been resolved by decision, order, and agreement. The only issues remaining to be decided are those relating to the parent’s request for reimbursement for assessments and the cost of serving subpoenas and what compensatory education should be provided to STUDENT.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
1. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to be reimbursed by District for the cost of independent assessments performed by Claudia McCulloch?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of a child at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessments performed by the public educational agency. However, the educational agency may initiate a due process hearing to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the decision of the hearing officer concludes that the educational agencies assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent educational assessment. Education Code Section 56329(b).
School authorities have fifty days from the time the parent agrees to an assessment plan to perform assessments and develop an individualized education program (IEP). California Education Code Section 56344.
a. Did STUDENT’s parents disagree with the District’s assessment?
In this case, STUDENT’s parents approved the assessment plan on October 20, 1999. Assessments were performed by school psychologist Carol Hanson and speech pathologist Winifred Sonya Porter Gambaro. After these assessments were performed, the IEP team met on November 9, 1999, to review those assessments. The District members of the IEP team agreed that further assessments were necessary in order to develop STUDENT’s IEP. Specifically, they determined that there was a need for additional assessment in the area of social-emotional status. The District members of the IEP team were alarmed by statements made by STUDENT’s parents concerning his mental and emotional state. At the time of this preliminary IEP meeting, only 20 days had elapsed from the date that STUDENT’s parent had approved the assessment plan, leaving the District with 30 more days to complete its assessment and develop an IEP for STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the need for further assessment and wanted the District to begin providing services immediately based on his eligibility as a learning disabled student.
After the IEP meeting on November 9, 1999, STUDENT’s mother wrote to the District requesting immediate services for STUDENT. In the letter she stated, “Ms. Hanson clearly indicated that she has found no indication of emotional disturbance and we have agreed with that assessment. Assessments regarding behavioral and emotional areas have already been conducted.”
The District assigned psychologist Jack Schnel to conduct further assessments of STUDENT. The parents of STUDENT became concerned about the impartiality of Mr. Schnel after they discovered that he had referred to them as “that crazy family.” In a letter from Ms. PARENT to the District on November 10, 1999, she stated, “please provide me with the district’s criteria for independent assessment immediately. Everyday STUDENT is at home, he grows more despondent and I am deeply concerned as his mother.” Also on November 10, Ms. PARENT wrote a letter formally requesting that the District either initiate a hearing to show that the District’s evaluation is appropriate or provide an independent educational evaluation at public expense.
The law provides that parents may request an independent assessment if they disagree with the assessments performed by the District. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56329(b) In this case it appears that STUDENT’s parents did not disagree with the assessments that had already been performed at the time they retained the services of Dr. McCulloch in November 1999.. If fact, Ms. PARENT in her letter of November 9, 1999, specifically stated that she agreed with Ms. Hanson’s assessment. It appears that the reason they requested an independent assessment was not because they disagreed with the District’s assessments done by Ms. Gambaro and Ms. Hanson, but because they did not want the District to do further assessments and did not like Jack Schnel, the assessor that the District had chosen. The law does not provide a right to an independent assessment because a parent disagrees with the District’s choice of assessors. When Dr. McCulloch performed her first assessment on November 21 and 22, 1999, the District had not completed their assessments, and STUDENT’s parents had not indicated that they disagreed with the assessments that had already been completed by the District. Therefore, it is concluded that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. McCulloch on November 21 and 22, 1999.
The District filed a request for hearing on November 30, 1999, seeking an order allowing them to do further assessment of STUDENT. The Hearing Officer indicated that the evidence, including the independent assessment performed by Dr. McCulloch, convinced him that the District was correct in believing that further assessment should be done. The parties agreed to the further assessment and the Hearing Officer ordered them to proceed with those assessments.
STUDENT’s parents did object to the assessments performed by Ms. Hanson during the hearing on November 30, 1999. They especially disagreed with the failure of Ms. Hanson to diagnose STUDENT as suffering from ADHD. Shortly after the hearing on November 30, 1999, STUDENT’s parents again retained the services of Dr. McCulloch to perform further assessments of STUDENT. Dr. McCulloch assessed STUDENT on December 17, 20, 21, and 23, and prepared a report dated December 28, 1999. In the mean time the District retained the services of Dr. Bruce Gale, a private practicing psychologist, who assessed STUDENT. The IEP team utilized the assessments performed by Carol Hanson, Dr. Gale, and Dr. McCulloch in eventually crafting an IEP for STUDENT.
At the time of Dr. McCulloch’s December assessment of STUDENT, the parents had stated their disagreement with Ms. Hanson’s assessment.
b. Were the District’s assessments appropriate?
The District is not required to pay for an independent assessment if it can show in a hearing that its assessments were appropriate. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56329(a). In determining whether the District’s assessments were appropriate the Hearing Officer will look at all of the assessments done by the District, including the reports of Dr. Gale and Ms. Hanson. These reports would have been completed within the mandated 50-day period had STUDENT’s parents not refused to allow the additional assessment thereby, forcing the District to request a hearing in order to compel the additional assessments.
Schools are required to assess student in all areas related to the suspected disability. Cal.Ed. Code Section 56320(f). The assessment instruments may not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, must be administered in the pupil’s primary language, have been validated for the purpose for which they are used, and administered by trained personnel. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56320(a-b). Tests used during an assessment must be tailored to assess specific areas of education need, and they must be selected and administered to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56320(c-d) No single procedure is used as the sole criterion for developing a child’s IEP. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56320(e).
In this case, STUDENT was assessed in all of the areas of his suspected disability including academic achievement, social and emotional development, motor ability, speech and language communication, general ability, and health and development. There is no evidence that the assessment instruments were discriminatory or that they were not administered in STUDENT’s primary language. There is no evidence that the tests were not administered by trained personnel, or that the tests were not validated for the purpose for which they were used.
The attorney for STUDENT argues that by Dr. Gale should not have used the Thematic Apperception Test (TAT) and the Rorschach tests with STUDENT because his severe language processing problems would interfere with the validity of the test results. Dr. Gale testified that STUDENT did have a significant language processing problem and that he included other tests to determine whether that language processing problem would interfere with the TAT and Rorschach test. He concluded that STUDENT’s language processing problems were not so severe that they would affect the validity of the tests. His explanation of his use of these tests was persuasive. The evidence does not support the conclusion that the assessment done by Dr. Gale was inappropriate because he used the TAT and Rorschach tests.(Footnote 3)
STUDENT’s attorney contends that Dr. McCulloch’s assessment is appropriate and that as far as Dr. Gale’s assessment was inconsistent with Dr. McCulloch’s assessment it is inappropriate. Both Dr. Gale and Dr. McCulloch concluded that STUDENT suffered from a significant depressive disorder. The only difference between the conclusions of Dr. Gale and Dr. McCulloch related to the degree of STUDENT’s ADHD. Dr. McCulloch concluded that he suffered from moderate ADHD predominantly inattentive type. This conclusion was supported by the results of a number of assessments instruments that were completed by STUDENT and his parents. Dr. McCulloch did not receive any input from STUDENT’s teachers. STUDENT’s parents stated during the hearing that they had another child who had been diagnosed as having ADHD and they believed STUDENT also had ADHD. It is likely that this perception had an effect on their answers on the various tests. For instance, on the Connor’s Scales, the parents responses indicated that STUDENT was markedly atypical on the Conners’ ADHD index. When STUDENT completed the Conners-Wells’ Adolescent Self Report Scale, his responses indicated only a slightly atypical rating on the ADHD index. Dr. Gale, on the other hand, administered a number of tests to STUDENT’s teachers as well as to STUDENT and his parents. This more comprehensive gathering of information from those who worked closely with STUDENT provided a better, more reliable picture of STUDENT’s functioning. Dr. Gale concluded that “STUDENT clearly shows signs and symptoms that are consistent with ADHD/inattentive type.” Dr. Gale concluded that STUDENT’s depressive disorder might interfere with accurately diagnosing ADHD and recommended “that treatment focus on his social and mood dysfunction and periodically reassess his attentional and language capability....” During the hearing, Dr. Gale testified that if STUDENT suffered from ADHD it was probably a mild form. The broader base of information used by Dr. Gale leads the Hearing Officer to have more confidence in his opinion.
Another reason that the Hearing Officer has serious doubts about the opinions of Dr. McCulloch was her change of opinion concerning STUDENT’s appropriate placement. In her report of November 22, 1999, Dr. McCulloch recommends that the parents consider a residential treatment program for STUDENT. A week later, during the hearing, Dr. McCulloch testified that STUDENT could be returned to his regular high school with proper support. Her change of opinion about his appropriate placement from the most restrictive to the least restrictive in a week’s time undermines the credibility of her opinions.
For the reasons stated above, it is concluded that the District’s assessment of STUDENT was appropriate and, therefore, the District should not be required to reimburse STUDENT’s parent for the cost of Dr. McCulloch’s assessments.
2. What compensatory education should the District be required to provide to STUDENT?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) as amended in 1997, children with disabilities are entitled to receive a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) with special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (A-D) & 1401 (25). A FAPE must be provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. section 1401 (8) (D).
In Burlington School Committee of the Town of Burlington, Massachusetts, et al, v. Department of Education of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, et al., 471 U.S. 359 (1985), the Supreme Court held that a child may be awarded compensatory educational services when a school district has failed to provide a free appropriate education (FAPE) to a child. The Court held that equitable considerations should be used in determining the appropriate award of compensatory education.
A request for a due process hearing must be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56504.5(j).
In this case, STUDENT’s parents contend that STUDENT was denied FAPE from the time he reenrolled in the District when he was entering the fourth grade. During the hearing, they argued that the District should be required to provide six years of higher education to STUDENT to compensate for the six years in which the District failed to provide FAPE. However, in their closing brief, STUDENT’s parents stated that it will be difficult to determine the appropriate compensatory education because STUDENT has not graduated from high school or reached age 21. They suggest that the Hearing Officer determine the amount of compensatory education to which STUDENT is entitled and determine the form of the compensatory education after STUDENT either graduates from high school or reaches age 21.
The hearing was requested by STUDENT’s parents on November 1, 1999. Therefore, normally it would only be appropriate to review events that have occurred within three years of November 1, 1999. This means that it would only be appropriate to address whether the District failed to provide FAPE in the time between November 1, 1996, and the date they filed for hearing. That would cover the period when STUDENT was in the seventh, eighth, ninth and tenth grades.
STUDENT’s attorney argues that the three years only began to run when the parents knew or should have known of the facts providing the basis for the decision. They contend that they were not aware of STUDENT’s learning disabilities or his need for special education. The evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT’s parents knew or should have known the facts underlying this claim. They knew about special education programs because STUDENT had received special education services for a number of years. In fact, it was STUDENT’s parents who withdrew him from special education after the second grade against the advice of school personnel. They knew that STUDENT had a language processing disorder. They knew that he had been receiving speech and language services as recently as the seventh grade. Both of STUDENT’s parents are educated, intelligent people who should have recognized the need to more fully address STUDENT’s needs. Ms. PARENT is currently an attorney, fully familiar with the law relating to special education. For these reasons the Hearing Officer concludes that the three-year limitation of filing a hearing request will apply and will limit the period of time at issue to the time after November 1, 1996.
The District did not contend during the hearing that it had provided FAPE to STUDENT in the period following November 1, 1996. The District appears to recognize STUDENT’s right to compensatory education, but contends that such compensatory educational services are now being made available to STUDENT, and that if he continues in school and avails himself of those services he will be able to graduate from high school, thus fulfilling the District’s obligation to compensate him for past failures to provide FAPE.
While the District concedes that compensatory education is appropriate, it does not specifically admit which facts justify a conclusion that it had denied FAPE to STUDENT. It will be important to determine the nature of the District’s failure to address STUDENT’s needs in order to determine the appropriate compensatory education.
School districts are required to provide for the identification and assessment of a student’s exceptional needs, and for the planning of an instructional program to meet the assessed needs. Cal. Ed. Code Section 56302.
In this case, the District failed to identify and properly assess STUDENT when he began experiencing academic difficulties during his seventh, eighth, and ninth grades. It also failed to develop an IEP or provide special education services during that time. It also appears that the District stopped providing speech and language assistance after the seventh grade. The District knew that STUDENT had a significant language disorder and had received special education in the past. While STUDENT was in the tenth grade, the District did perform appropriate assessments and eventually develop an IEP. It agreed to provide a number of services which it felt would appropriately remediate its past failures to provide FAPE. The services included psychological counseling, educational therapy, and tutoring. It provided specific programs such as FastForWord, and it offerred to provide the StepForWord program to remediate reading deficits, and provided resource specialist and speech and language services to further compensate for the time he spent without a FAPE. The District contended that, with these services, STUDENT made great strides toward graduation while attending the Rancho Del Mar High School.
STUDENT’s parents have argued that they are entitled to one day of compensatory education for each day STUDENT was denied FAPE. They initially requested that the Hearing Officer order the District to pay for six years of higher education in order to compensate STUDENT for its six-year failure to provide FAPE. In her closing brief, STUDENT’s attorney withdrew the request for higher education and stated that the form of compensatory education should be determined after he either graduates from high school or reaches age twenty one. However, they still contend that STUDENT is entitled to one day of compensatory education for each day FAPE was denied. This request is not supported by the law. In Student W. v. Puallup School District 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994) the court stated:
There is no obligation to provide a day-for-day compensation for time missed. Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Student W. was able to graduate from high school, before reaching age 21, without more services than provided for in his annual IEP. The IDEA promises him no more.
In STUDENT’s case, the District offered special services including counseling, tutoring, resource specialist services, and speech and language services. With the provision of those services, STUDENT was able to obtain passing grades and earn 55 credits toward graduation during the spring semester and summer school of the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer concludes that the special services offered to STUDENT during that semester constituted appropriate compensatory education and that the District must continue to provide those services until STUDENT either graduates from high school or reaches age twenty one.
3. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to be reimbursed by the district for costs relating to the service of subpoenas?
There is no authority in either State or federal law for a hearing officer to award attorney’s fees or other legal costs. 34 CFR Section 300.513 and Cal. Ed. Code Section 56507(b). Only a court of competent jurisdiction may make such and award. Therefore, the request of STUDENT’s parents to be reimbursed by the District for the costs of serving subpoenas is denied.
ORDER
The District shall continue to make the following services available to STUDENT as compensatory education while he is attending school during the regular year, and extended school year, if an extended school year is provided for in his IEP, and these services will continue until either he graduates from high school or reaches the age of twenty one, whichever occurs first:
1. Resource specialist service for one period each school day. 2. One fifty-minute session of counseling each week.
3. Ninety minutes per week of individual speech and language therapy. 4. One hour of individual tutoring each school day.
5. Other services deemed appropriate by the IEP team.
In all other respects the petitioner’s claims are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the issues of reimbursement for assessments and the cost of serving subpoenas. Neither party should be considered the prevailing party in relation to the issue of compensatory education.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).
Dated:
Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: At the beginning of the hearing it appeared that there was a dispute as to whether STUDENT was entitled to compensatory education. However, the testimony of Lynn Busia, and the District’s closing brief reflect that the District has conceded that compensatory educational services were appropriate because of a failure by the district to earlier identify and assess STUDENT and provide him with special education services. The only issue in dispute is the nature of the required compensatory services.
Footnote 2: Because of difficulties in scheduling the additional assessments and the IEP meeting, the hearing was continued a number of times and was eventually scheduled to reconvene on March 30, 2000.
Footnote 3: It should also be noted that the TAT and the Rorschach tests are primarily used to evaluate the social emotional status of the child. In this case, both Dr. Gale and Dr. McCulloch agreed on the fact that STUDENT suffered from significant depression. Therefore, there is no evidence that use of the TAT or Rorschach in any way resulted in an inappropriate diagnosis.
