California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · June 2, 1999

Student v. Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 186-99 · Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote

Tahoe-Truckee Unified need not add swimming to make-up adapted PE or reassign a preferred one-to-one aide.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision references a prior SEHO decision between the same parties dated December 2, 1998 (SN 129-98 and SN 986-98). No remand, vacatur or correction of this decision is noted.

Summary

A 12-year-old sixth grader's father filed for due process against Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District. The student uses a wheelchair. He spends 90% of his day in general education with resource specialist support, and he receives adapted physical education (APE), therapies and a one-to-one aide. At the start of the hearing, the parties settled two issues. The District agreed to hold a full-team IEP meeting and to schedule APE so it would not interfere with academics. It also agreed to provide 20 make-up APE sessions, because the APE position sat empty for about 20 weeks in fall 1998. The District asked the Hearing Officer to exclude the father's documents and witnesses. She refused because the District's own evidence packet showed it had received them on time.

Two issues remained. First, the father argued that the make-up APE sessions had to include swimming. Hearing Officer Mary L. Cote disagreed. No IEP named swimming, the APE goals focused on ball handling and adapting PE and recess activities, and no evidence showed the student needed swimming to benefit. Second, the father wanted a former aide, Mr. Gimperli, reassigned and wanted an aide who had passed the CBEST teacher exam. The Hearing Officer credited resource specialist Nancy Casper, who said the current aide was doing a "fine job." Nothing showed that only Mr. Gimperli could meet the student's needs. Under Rowley, the District did not have to provide the best possible services. All requests were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled requests for a specific activity in make-up services and for a specific aide. The Hearing Officer looked at whether the IEP or the evidence showed a need, not at past practice or parent preference. Aide assignment was reviewed only for whether the assigned aide could meet the student's needs.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Must swimming be included in the adaptive physical education (APE) sessions that the District has agreed to provide to compensate STUDENT for sessions that were not provided during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years as called for by his IEP?

    No IEP named swimming as an APE activity, the APE goals concerned ball handling and adapting PE and recess activities, and no evidence showed the student needed swimming, so the 20 agreed make-up APE sessions need not include swimming.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Does STUDENT require Mr. Gimperli ("Mr. G.") as his one-to-one aide?

    The current aide was appropriately qualified and met the student's needs, no evidence showed that only Mr. G. could serve, and no evidence showed a need for an aide who had passed the CBEST; under Rowley the District need not provide the best services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief were denied. Before the hearing, the parties settled other matters: a full-team IEP meeting on May 17 or 24, 1999; APE scheduled so it does not interfere with academics; and 20 make-up APE sessions. These terms were agreed by the parties and were not ordered by the Hearing Officer.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Education Code 56505(e)(7); Education Code 56565.1(f); Title 5 California Code of Regulations 3042(a); 20 U.S.C. 1401

People named in the decision

  • Kay Atchison, SELPA administrator; District representative at hearing, Placer/Nevada County SELPA
  • Michael Bowdish, District coordinator of special education; witness, Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer (observer), Special Education Hearing Office
  • Mike Jensen, APE specialist, Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Nancy Casper, resource specialist teacher; witness, Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • Patrick Gemma, District superintendent (listed witness), Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District
  • L. McKechnie, listed witness (role not stated)
  • Susan Phebus, assistant principal/vice principal; witness, Sierra Mountain Middle School
  • Mr. Gimperli (Mr. G.), former one-to-one aide requested by parent, Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Truckee California, on May 13, 1999. Petitioner STUDENT was represented at the hearing by his father, FATHER. Respondent Tahoe-Truckee Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by Kay Atchison, administrator, Placer/Nevada County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA). Also present on behalf of the District was Michael Bowdish, District coordinator of special education. Trevor Skarda, Hearing Officer, was present as an observer. Oral and documentary evidence was received, the case was closed, and the matter was submitted for decision. ISSUES (1) Must swimming be included in the adaptive physical education (APE) sessions that the District has agreed to provide to compensate STUDENT for sessions that were not provided during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years as called for by his individualized educational program (IEP)? (2) Does STUDENT require Mr. Gimperli ("Mr. G.") as his one-to-one aide? PROCEDURAL MATTERS ISSUES At the beginning of the hearing, the parties engaged in settlement discussions outside of the presence of the Hearing Officer. The parties settled two of the four issues for hearing. In response to Petitioner's request that the District hold a "full team IEP [individualized educational program]" meeting, the District agreed to convene an IEP meeting on May 17 or 24, 1999, at 8:00 a.m. with a full IEP team present for the entire meeting. To settle the issue related to the provision of APE during Petitioner's class time, the parties agreed that the "regular classroom teacher and the APE teacher in cooperation with the parents will meet to identify times to receive APE services which would not interfere with his [Petitioner's] academic schedule." The parties reached partial agreement as to the District's responsibility to provide Petitioner with additional sessions of APE to make up for APE sessions that were not provided during the first semester of the 1998-1999 school year. The District agreed to provide Petitioner with 20 sessions of APE to supplement his current APE. Remaining at issue is whether swimming must be included as an activity in the 20 make-up APE sessions EVIDENCE The District made a motion to exclude Petitioner's proposed documentary evidence and also to preclude Petitioner from calling witnesses at the hearing. The District asserted that Petitioner had not provide the District with either the evidence or a list of witnesses five business days in advance of the hearing as required by special education law. Petitioner asserted that he provided his evidence and the list of witnesses to the District in a timely manner. California Education Code  56505(e)(7) provides that the parties have the right to receive from the other parties to the hearing, at least five business days prior to the hearing, a copy of all documents and a list of witnesses and their general area of testimony that the parties intend to present at the hearing. It is at the discretion of the Hearing Officer whether to bar evidence and witnesses that have not been timely exchanged between the parties. (Education Code  56565.1(f).) At the hearing, Petitioner proposed to introduce 11 pages of documents. The cover sheet of the documents states "As per your request this is a list of documents for the above hearing." The cover sheet also indicates that copies of the documents were sent to the Hearing Office and to the District. The Hearing Office received the 11 pages of documents by facsimile on March 4, 1999. A copy of the same 11 pages, including the cover sheet, is contained within the evidence packet submitted by the District. A handwritten note on the cover sheet of Petitioner's documents in the District's evidence packet states that Petitioner's documents were received on March 5, 1999. The Hearing Officer concluded that the fact that the District included Petitioner's proposed documentary evidence in its own packet of evidence establishes that the District had, in fact, received a copy of Petitioner's evidence. Because Petitioner complied with the legal time lines for exchanging evidence, the Hearing Officer accepted Petitioner's documentary evidence. Petitioner's list of proposed witnesses for the hearing also was included in the District's evidence packet, thereby establishing that the District had received notice of the witnesses Petitioner proposed to call at the hearing. The letter identifying Petitioner's witnesses is dated March 31, 1999, and states "This is the list of witnesses as requested: Pat Gemma, Mike Bowdish, Mike Jensen, Nancy Casper, and L. McKechnie." Petitioner's list of witnesses did not identify the general area of testimony by each witness; however, at the hearing, Petitioner stated his intent to limit testimony to the issues related to APE and the aide. He also stated that he intended to call Mr. Bowdish, District coordinator of special education, Ms. Casper, resource specialist teacher, and Patrick Gemma, District superintendent. The District stated that it also intended to call Mr. Bowdish and Ms. Casper. Because the District had timely notice of Petitioner's witness and, in fact, intended to call the same witnesses that Petitioner indicated he would be calling, the Hearing Officer concluded there was no basis to preclude Petitioner from calling Mr. Bowdish and Ms. Casper to testify. BACKGROUND FACTS STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student in the sixth grade. STUDENT has been diagnosed with cerebral palsy and spastic quadriplegia. He uses a wheelchair. STUDENT is eligible for special education and related services including adapted physical education (APE), physical therapy (PT), occupational therapy (OT), speech and language therapy, and the services of a one-to-one aide. STUDENT receives 90% of his instruction in the regular education classroom and is provided additional support from the resource specialist program (RSP). A prior due process hearing (SN 129-98 and SN 986-98) involving the same parties resulted in a decision on December 2, 1998. The issues addressed at the prior hearing related to reimbursement for independent assessments procured by STUDENT's parents, the appropriateness of STUDENT's OT and PT services, STUDENT's need for individual aide support during school field trips, small-group instruction, and direct therapy sessions, and STUDENT's need for additional technology services and assistive equipment. FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW ISSUE NO. 1: Must swimming be included in the adaptive physical education (APE) sessions that the District has agreed to provide to compensate STUDENT for sessions that were not provided during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years as called for by his individualized educational program (IEP)? Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C.  1400; California Education Code  56000.) The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student's individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C.  1401(a)(18).) Special education students are entitled to related services, which, in California, is referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS), if the services are necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his/her instructional program. (20 U.S.C.  1401(22); California Education Code  56363(a).) STUDENT has been entitled to APE as a related service during the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years. There is no dispute that the District did not provide STUDENT with APE for a total of approximately 20 weeks. The APE teacher was unavailable because she had taken a personal leave of absence and the District was unable to fill her position during the first semester of the 1998-1999 school year. Mike Jensen, APE specialist, has provided STUDENT with APE since February 1, 1999. The District has agreed to provide STUDENT with 20 make-up sessions during nonacademic sessions. Petitioner contends that the make-up sessions must include swimming activities because STUDENT previously participated in swimming as part of his APE program. The District contends that make-up sessions do not have to include swimming. The District asserts that STUDENT's IEPs do not indicate that APE goals must be met through swimming. The District also asserts that swimming is unnecessary for STUDENT to meet his goals and objectives. The documents presented at the hearing by the District establish that APE goals and objectives agreed to at the May 1997 IEP continued in effect as of the IEP dated January 7, 1998. STUDENT's IEP dated January 7, 1998, called for one to two sessions weekly for up to 45 minutes each session. The APE goals and objectives in effect at that time were related to (1) improving STUDENT's ball handling skills and (2) adapting physical education and recess activities to STUDENT's abilities. There is nothing in the IEP dated January 7, 1998, or subsequent IEPs that specifically identifies swimming as an activity to meet these goals and objectives. (Footnote 1) There was no evidence that STUDENT requires swimming to meet his APE goals and objectives or to benefit from APE or from his instruction in either general or special education program. Susan Phebus, assistant principal at Sierra Mountain Middle School, testified that neither the regular nor the adapted physical education programs at Sierra include swimming. In summary, the evidence presented at the hearing does not establish that STUDENT's make-up APE sessions must include swimming activities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the 20 make-up sessions of APE that the District has agreed to provide to STUDENT do not have to include swimming. ISSUE NO. 2: Does STUDENT require Mr. Gimperli ("Mr. G.") as his one-to-one aide? Personnel issues are generally left to the discretion of the District; however, in this case, the issue related to STUDENT's aide is germane to STUDENT's receiving a free appropriate public education. Moreover, in California, placement is defined as that "unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exception needs, as specified in the individualized education program. . . ." (Title 5 California Code of Regulations  3042(a).) The questions that must be resolved are (1) whether the aide currently assigned to STUDENT is appropriately qualified to allow STUDENT to benefit educationally from his instructional program and, if not, (2) whether the District must assign Mr. Gemperli (Mr. G.) as STUDENT's individual aide. STUDENT is entitled to the assistance of an individual aide as a related service. The Hearing Officer in SN 129-98 and SN 986-99 concluded that STUDENT required "individual aide assistance during school field trips and small-group instruction, but not during direct therapy sessions unless the therapist wants to train the aide." Following the decision, STUDENT has received the services of an individual aide. Petitioner disputes whether the current aide is meeting his needs. Petitioner asserts that the aide does not communicate effectively with the parents and does not possess adequate academic skills to effectively assist him with his school work. Petitioner asserts that he requires a "CBEST [California Basic Educational Skills Test] qualified aide" and that "Mr. G." should be reassigned as his one-to-one aide. (Footnote 2) The District contends that the current aide is a college graduate and has met all District requirements to hold his present position. The District also contends that personnel matters are the responsibility of the District and that the parent cannot dictate who fills a specific position. The District has agreed to assign a different aide to STUDENT in the fall of 1999. In order to determine whether STUDENT's needs are being met by the current aide, it is necessary to have some understanding of the role of the aide. The testimony of Mr. Bowdish, Ms. Casper, and Ms. Phebus, establishes that STUDENT's aide provides the following services: he assists STUDENT with transitions and transfers from his wheel chair; he accompanies STUDENT to class to make certain that materials are available for STUDENT; he works with STUDENT to ensure that he is able to fully participate in the regular education curriculum; and he is a liaison between the teacher and STUDENT. The testimony also establishes that the aide does not provide direct academic instruction to STUDENT. Mr. Bowdish testified that the aide has met District criteria to serve as an aide. That is, he has passed drug and fingerprinting tests, holds at minimum a high school diploma or equivalent, and has passed a District proficiency test. It is Mr. Bowdish's understanding the STUDENT's aide holds a college degree. Ms. Casper expressed her opinion that the aide is doing a "fine job" with STUDENT. She testified that he generally understands the curriculum. Ms. Casper acknowledged that on those few occasions when the aide has had some difficulty with a math lesson, he consulted with her. Ms. Casper testified that she meets regularly with STUDENT's aide to collaborate and to discuss what is going on in STUDENT's classes. Ms. Casper testified that she anticipates that the aide will receive a satisfactory annual evaluation. As to FATHER's concerns about the aides ability to communicate with the family, Ms. Casper testified that a communication book is used as means for communicating with the family. She noted that the teacher as well as other service providers and the parents write in the communication book. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Casper persuasive on the issue of the aide's ability to perform the functions that are necessary to meet STUDENT's needs. Her testimony was supported by Susan Phebus, the school's vice principal. Ms. Casper observes STUDENT in class daily, has worked with STUDENT's aide, and is responsible for supervising him. Thus, she has greater familiarity than FATHER does with the aide's ability to meet STUDENT's needs in the educational environment. As to whether Mr. G. should be STUDENT's aide in the fall of 1999, FATHER asserts that Mr. G. is the most qualified person to work with STUDENT. Mr. G. is familiar with STUDENT's safety and educational needs and has proven his ability to work effectively with STUDENT and his family. There was little testimony about Mr. G. or his qualifications to serve as STUDENT's aide. In any case, there was no compelling evidence that the functions performed by STUDENTs aide, which were described above, can be met only by Mr. G. There also was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT requires an aide who has passed the CBEST. Moreover, the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or services. Rowley at 176. In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT's current aide is appropriate and there is no evidence that only Mr. G. can serve as STUDENT's aide. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District does not have to assign Mr. G. as STUDENT's aide. ORDER All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied. PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE Pursuant to Education Code  56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided. RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code  56505(i). DATED: June 2, 1999 ________________________ Mary L. Cote, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Subsequent IEPs have been disputed and have not been agreed to by the parents. APE was not addressed at a previous due process hearing, which resulted in a decision on December 2, 1998. 2. Persons applying for a teaching credential in California must pass the CBEST. The testing is not required of instructional aides.