California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 7, 2002
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1869-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Los Angeles Unified must keep 90 weekly minutes of private-agency speech therapy for an autistic fifth grader; OT reduction upheld.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a fifth grader filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The student, described in her IEPs as nonverbal and severely autistic, attended a special day class at Walgrove. She also received speech and occupational therapy (OT) from Therapy West, a nonpublic agency. At her March 2002 three-year IEP review, the District offered 60 minutes a week of school-based speech plus 60 minutes at Therapy West, down from 90. It also offered 60 minutes a week of school-based OT plus 60 minutes at Therapy West, down from 120. The parents wanted 120 minutes a week of agency speech therapy and wanted agency OT to stay at 120 minutes.
On speech, the Hearing Officer found both therapists credible. However, Therapy West's Cheryl Larsen showed that the student had recently begun making real progress on spoken sounds and words, and that she could focus for long periods at the agency. The school-based services focused mainly on picture exchange and other nonverbal communication. Cutting agency therapy therefore did not meet her needs or provide some educational benefit. The Hearing Officer ordered 90 minutes at the agency and 60 at school each week, but denied the request for 120 agency minutes. On OT, District therapist Stacey Bracken and Therapy West's Sara Huesman both supported the reduction. They planned to move sensory strategies into the classroom, so the OT offer was upheld. The IEP team had to meet within 15 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled conflicting views from a district therapist and a private-agency therapist under Rowley. The Hearing Officer relied on recent evidence of the student's emerging speech to keep agency services. The OT reduction was upheld because both treating therapists agreed with it and no expert testified against it.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue A. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year through March 18, 2003, to the extent that it proposed to reduce STUDENT's NPA-based speech and language services from 90 minutes to 60 minutes per week?
Cutting nonpublic agency speech therapy to 60 minutes was not designed to meet the student's critical oral-motor and vocalization needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit; 90 minutes NPA-based plus 60 minutes school-based required, though the request for 120 NPA minutes was denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue B. Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year through March 18, 2003, to the extent that it proposed to reduce STUDENT's NPA-based OT services from 120 minutes to 60 minutes per week?
The offer of 60 minutes NPA-based and 60 minutes school-based OT, with the classroom teacher sharing responsibility for generalizing sensory strategies, met the student's needs; both the District and NPA therapists supported it.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 days of the Decision, the IEP team shall meet to amend the March 18, 2002 IEP consistent with the Decision.
- Order to provide or change services. Through the annual review date of March 18, 2003, program shall include 90 minutes of NPA-based and 60 minutes of school-based speech and language services per week, in addition to any remaining compensatory sessions under the parties' prior agreement; NPA services shall continue to address verbalization, articulation, and/or oral-motor skills.
- IEP team shall decide whether to adjust the NPA-based speech and language goals and objectives, and shall meet as appropriate to decide whether the student can tolerate and benefit from more intensive speech services, taking care not to overburden her schedule.
Key authorities
Rowley
People named in the decision
- Harry Brown-Hiegel, advocate for Student, Westside Regional Center
- Angela Gordon, District attorney, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Lisa Test, District coordinator for occupational therapy, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sharon Snyder, District speech and language specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Peppi Rein, District speech and language pathologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Stacey Bracken, District occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
- Sara Huesman, occupational therapist, nonpublic agency, Therapy West
- Cheryl Larson (also spelled Larsen), speech and language therapist, nonpublic agency, Therapy West
- Therapy West, nonpublic agency providing speech-language and OT services
- Walgrove, District school (special day class placement), Los Angeles Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on August 8 and 9, 2002, in Los Angeles, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by her advocate, Harry Brown-Hiegel, from the Westside Regional Center. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner were her mother, MOTHER, and her father, FATHER. Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Ricardo R. Silva from the law office of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District at various times throughout the hearing were Angela Gordon, District attorney; Lisa Test, District coordinator for occupational therapy (OT); and Sharon Snyder, District speech and language specialist. The Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Peppi Rein, District speech and language pathologist; Sara Huesman, occupational therapist from Therapy West; FATHER; Cheryl Larson, speech and language therapist from Therapy West. The District called the following witnesses: Stacey Bracken, District occupational therapist, and Peppi Rein. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until the receipt of closing briefs on August 26, 2002.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year through March 18, 2003, to the extent that it proposed:
A. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based speech and language services from 90 minutes to 60 minutes per week, and
B. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based OT services from 120 minutes to 60 minutes per week?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born on [date redacted], has received special education services from the District since 1995. She is described in her written individualized education programs (IEPs) as “non-verbal” and “severely autistic.” Her IEP for the 2001-2002 school year included placement in a special day class (SDC) at Walgrove, a District school. Various services received at Walgrove included 30 minutes of speech and language and 60 minutes of OT per week. In addition to services received at Walgrove, STUDENT’s IEP also provided for 90 minutes of speech and language and 120 minutes of OT weekly at Therapy West, a nonpublic agency (NPA).
The dispute in this case involves the District’s program offer for STUDENT’s fifth-grade, 2002-2003 school year. Specifically, STUDENT objects to the District’s proposal to decrease the weekly amount of NPA-based speech and language and OT services.
Before making a program offer for the 2002-2003 school year, the District assessed STUDENT’s speech and language in February 2002 as part of a triennial assessment. The District’s speech and language therapist, Ms. Rein, recommended an increase of STUDENT’s weekly school-based speech and language services from 30 to 60 minutes, with a corresponding decrease in weekly services at Therapy West from 90 minutes to 60 minutes.
Before making a program offer for the 2002-2003 school year, the District also considered recent OT assessments/progress reports conducted by the District and the NPA. STUDENT’s District occupational therapist, Ms. Bracken, conducted her assessment in March 2002. Her report listed no recommendations; instead, recommendations were deferred to the next IEP meeting. STUDENT’s NPA occupational therapist, Ms. Huesman, wrote an OT progress report in March 2002. In her report, she recommended that STUDENT continue OT at Therapy West one time per week using “sensory strategies” to address weaknesses in STUDENT’s ability to keep her behavior “organized.” Ms. Huesman also recommended continuation of school-based OT to address STUDENT’s fine-motor, visual-motor, and functional life skills.
STUDENT’s IEP team met on March 18, 2002, to conduct STUDENT’s three-year review. After considering the above-summarized reports and recommendations from the speech and language and OT therapists, the District made a program offer extending to March 18, 2003. With respect to weekly speech and language, the District offered 60 minutes of school-based and 60 minutes of NPA-based services. With respect to weekly OT, the District offered 60 minutes of school-based and 60 minutes of NPA-based services.
STUDENT’s parents agreed to the speech and language and OT goals and objectives offered at the March 18, 2002 IEP meeting, but they objected to the District’s proposal insofar as it would reduce weekly NPA-based speech and language services from 90 minutes to 60 minutes and OT services from 120 minutes to 60 minutes. The parents wanted NPA-based speech and language services to increase from the prior level of 90 minutes to a new level of 120 minutes per week, and they wanted NPA-based OT services to remain at 120 minutes per week. On April 30, 2002, STUDENT’s parents filed the present request for a due process hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
The issues presented for hearing are whether the District has failed to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year through March 18, 2003, to the extent that it proposed:
A. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based speech and language services from 90 minutes to 60 minutes per week, and
B. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based OT services from 120 minutes to 60 minutes per week.
Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit.
In the present case, STUDENT asserts that because of the proposed reduction in NPA-based speech and language and OT services, the District’s program offer is not designed to meet her unique needs in the areas of speech and language and OT and is not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit. STUDENT asserts, consequently, that the District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year does not constitute an offer of FAPE. Each of those assertions will now be addressed.
I. Speech and language.
STUDENT’s unique needs: Before determining whether the District’s program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language, those needs must be identified. Ms. Rein’s February 2002 report, prepared in her capacity as STUDENT’s District speech and language pathologist, states that STUDENT’s strengths include following one-step directions and using picture exchange to communicate. Her weaknesses include inconsistent receptive language skills and a heavy reliance on prompts and cues. She was primarily “nonverbal,” meaning she could not communicate orally with words. She could vocalize pleasure or displeasure by laughing, crying, or screaming. According to the mother, she had verbalized several words. Ms. Rein noted that STUDENT can imitate bilabial sounds if given maximum cuing. She has done several oral-motor exercises with STUDENT such as blowing bubbles or whistles, but those activities have not yet facilitated oral verbalizations during therapy sessions. STUDENT has been heard to produce a variety of vowels and consonants. She chiefly communicates through gestures or sign language such as by pointing or by signing “good morning” and similar expressions. Furthermore, STUDENT has a short attention span. According to the report, she can sustain attention for only 2 to 4 minutes on highly motivating activities.
Ms. Larsen is STUDENT’s speech and language specialist at the NPA. Her July 2002 report states that STUDENT met her IEP goals and objectives involving the expression of needs and wants using total communication (i.e. pictures, signs, gestures, verbalization) with prompts. The report discusses STUDENT’s oral-motor articulation, receptive communication, expressive communication, and attention and behavior. The report states that in oral-motor skills, STUDENT has shown “tremendous changes,” especially in the last few months. Ms. Larsen has been using oral-motor exercises for the tongue and in and around the mouth. With practice, STUDENT has progressed to being able to “imitate most isolated sounds, both vowels and consonants, when given a model and tactile cue.” Tactile cues include Ms. Larsen putting her finger on her face/lips to represent the desired sound. The report states that STUDENT has great difficulty isolating her articulators and moving them volitionally, but she has been sincerely trying. The report states that with continued effort and with frequent practice, repetition, and opportunity, STUDENT could gain increased control and precision of articulators to formulate clearer sounding single words in the near future. STUDENT is heavily reliant on visual cues to process and follow through with directions from an adult. Expressively, she is capable of communicating thoughts and needs through signs, a picture exchange communication system (PECS), vocalizations, and gestures. Her vocal repertoire, however, is profoundly limited. For example, she can spontaneously make requests by saying “buh-buh” for bubbles, and when given a model, prompt, and practice, she can produce more single-word oral verbalizations such as “come,” “help,” “STUDENT.” The report states that STUDENT is sometimes able to remain at a table participating in oral-motor activities for 30 minutes without requiring redirection to task. Her ability to attend and focus during therapy sessions is considered to be one of STUDENT’s overall strengths. Simple calming strategies such as facial massage, blowing activities, rhythmic swinging, music, chewy foods, and use of weighted vests and blankets are effective in helping STUDENT with her frustration and focus.
In summary, STUDENT is a fifth-grade student with profoundly limited speech and language skills. Her spontaneous oral language consists of a few utterances such a “buh-buh” for bubbles, but with prompts and tactile cues she can reproduce a few words and a variety of vowel and consonant sounds. She needs a “total communication” strategy so she can not only utilize her relative strengths in picture exchange but also develop her articulation/oral-motor skills and her motivation to use oral language. She needs prompts and tactile cues to assist in developing her oral-motor skills. She needs calming strategies to alleviate her frustration and help her to focus on tasks. Given STUDENT’s profound deficits in speech and language and the importance of speech and language as her most pressing educational need, she requires an intensive speech and language program.
The program offer: In response to STUDENT’s speech and language needs, the District has offered, pursuant to the March 18, 2002 IEP, 60 minutes of school-based and 60-minutes of NPA-based speech and language services per week. The school-based speech and language services would address goals and objectives related to STUDENT’s use of a “multi-modal communication system” utilizing signs, picture exchange, and verbalizations, to initiate requests for motivating items and to use descriptors in those requests. The NPA-based speech and language services would address separately written goals and objectives nearly identical to the goals and objectives written for the school-based services. The proposed goals and objectives are not contested.
Ms. Rein proposed and wrote the program for speech and language in the March 18, 2002 IEP. In her testimony, Ms. Rein described the “total language approach” she had used for the past 11 months in working with STUDENT as her District speech and language specialist. Ms. Rein’s testimony showed that the total language approach was basically the same as the “multi-modal communication system” referenced in the IEP goals. She explained how tactile cue strategies similar to those described in Ms. Larsen’s report were and would continue to be used in conjunction with signs, gestures, and picture exchange to assist and encourage STUDENT in using oral language. Ms. Rein testified that during the 2001-2002 school year program, STUDENT had made substantial progress in gaining limited skills in speech and language. She testified that STUDENT was applying the skills learned during speech and language sessions to the classroom and various school settings. To some extent, she was now able to work and communicate with peers in the classroom and access the classroom curriculum. She used her picture exchange system to initiate communication outside of the classroom, such as when ordering her lunch from fifth-grade peers working in the school cafeteria.
Ms. Rein testified concerning her reasons for proposing the reallocation of speech and language services to 60 minutes per week in the NPA and 60 minutes per week in the school-based setting. First, Ms. Rein stated her belief that 60 minutes in each setting was sufficient for STUDENT to make appropriate progress on her goals and receive educational benefit. Second, according to Ms. Rein, STUDENT needed increased opportunities for generalizing her skills. Ms. Rein had no significant criticism of STUDENT’s NPA-based therapy; however, she wanted STUDENT to have more time working on her speech and language skills in the school setting, thereby allowing STUDENT to increase the generalization of her skills with many different adults and peers, as compared to the limitations of communicating with adults and peers in a therapy room. Accordingly, the therapist would provide the additional 30 minutes of school-based speech and language services in the classroom, if possible, instead of in the therapy room. STUDENT’s behavior patterns on each particular day would dictate the location for therapy.
The Petitioner does not object to the proposal for additional school-based therapy, but she believes the NPA-based therapy should be increased from 90 minutes to 120 minutes per week, instead of being reduced from 90 minutes to 60 minutes per week. Ms. Larsen, STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at the NPA, testified it is her recommendation that STUDENT receive 120 minutes of speech and language therapy each week at Therapy West, delivered in no fewer than two sessions per week, in addition to 30 or 60 minutes of school-based therapy. Ms. Larsen stated her opinion that the proposal for 60 minutes of school-based therapy and 60 minutes of NPA-based therapy would not meet STUDENT’s needs. In support of her opinion, Ms. Larsen testified that about three months before the date of the due process hearing, she had subjected STUDENT to some exercises to see whether STUDENT was receptive to certain speech strategies that emphasize tactile cues to develop articulation skills, and that STUDENT was amenable to those strategies. Thereafter, STUDENT began making substantial progress in her oral verbalization skills. She testified that STUDENT’s NPA-based speech and language services should be increased to focus on oral verbalization.
Ms. Rein’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s receptiveness to services focusing on oral verbalization was substantially different from Ms. Larsen’s testimony. Ms. Rein testified that she used a portion of the time in each 30-minute therapy session attempting to have STUDENT imitate sounds by giving her tactile cues. This is part of the multi-modal communication approach. Ms. Rein testified, however, that she believed STUDENT’s imitation ability was too limited to justify increased focus on vocalization skills. She testified that she viewed her role as that of helping STUDENT become a functional communicator with the use of successful, as compared to unsuccessful, techniques. Thus, although Ms. Rein used the multi-modal communication approach, she did not emphasize vocalization skills. She testified that the appropriate time to direct more therapy toward vocalization skills would be when STUDENT can imitate sounds consistently.
Ms. Rein and Ms. Larsen agree that STUDENT requires an intensive speech and language program to meet her unique needs, but they disagree on the amount of services STUDENT can tolerate. According to the testimony of Ms. Rein, 120 minutes of speech and language therapy per week is an intensive program both for STUDENT and for special needs students in general. In Ms. Rein’s opinion, a greater amount of services would be counterproductive because STUDENT’s ability to attend to one concentrated type of activity would be exceeded. Ms. Rein’s opinion is consistent with the portion of her report characterizing STUDENT as having a short attention span and stating that she could sustain attention for only 2 to 4 minutes on highly motivating activities. However, according to the testimony of Ms. Larsen, STUDENT would tolerate and benefit from 120 minutes of NPA-based services in addition to at least 30 minutes of the proposed school-based services. Ms. Larsen’s opinion is consistent with the portion of her July 2002 report, written about 5 months after Ms. Rein’s report, characterizing STUDENT’s ability to attend and focus during therapy sessions as an area of strength and stating that she was sometimes able to remain at a table participating in oral-motor activities for 30 minutes without requiring redirection to task. Ms. Larsen’s report also notes the effectiveness of using calming strategies to help with frustration and focus during therapy.
The Hearing Officer considers the testimony of both Ms. Rein and Ms. Larsen to be credible. If their reports and testimony are taken as substantially accurate, STUDENT has a notably increased ability to stay on task when receiving speech and language therapy at the NPA, as compared to her ability to stay on task during school-based therapy. Furthermore, she is substantially more receptive to tactile cue strategies at the NPA, designed to address her vocalization deficits. Thus, the NPA-based therapy is designed to meet and should be particularly effective toward meeting STUDENT’s critical needs in the area of oral-motor/vocalization skills. A reduction of her NPA-based therapy would be inconsistent with meeting those critical needs, especially when the proposed school-based services would not be focused on STUDENT’s vocalization skills and have not been effective toward that area of need.
Although continuing the NPA-based therapy for at least 90-minutes per week is consistent with meeting STUDENT’s needs in the area of oral-motor/vocalization skills, the Hearing Officer concurs with Ms. Rein’s opinion that STUDENT needs 60 minutes of school-based speech and language services per week for the purpose of generalizing her skills outside of the therapy room. However, the Hearing Officer is persuaded, contrary to Ms. Rein’s opinion, that STUDENT can productively tolerate more than 120 total minutes of speech and language services per week, so long as the services include both school-based and NPA-based therapy. This latter finding is supported by the observations of Ms. Larsen regarding STUDENT’s attention to task at the NPA and the fact that STUDENT would receive services from different providers in different environments, thereby providing more variety to maintain her interest as opposed to working on one concentrated activity in the same setting.
In summary, speech and language is a critical area of need for STUDENT. She is presently unable to orally communicate with words. The testimony of Ms. Larsen demonstrated that STUDENT has recently shown good potential for making significant progress in her vocalization skills within the near future, if given appropriate supports and services. The evidence has shown that STUDENT can productively tolerate more than 120 minutes of weekly speech and language services, yet the program proposed by the District would reduce the amount of time used to develop STUDENT’s vocalization skills in the NPA-based services. Meanwhile, the focus of school-based services as proposed by the District would be on STUDENT’s use of picture exchange and other non-vocal methods of communication. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that because of the proposal to reduce the NPA-based speech and language services, the District’s program offer in the area of speech and language was not designed to address STUDENT’s critical needs in the area of oral-motor/vocalization skills.
For the same reasons as stated immediately above, the Hearing Officer also finds that the District’s program offer in speech and language was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. Speech and language skills are basic to educational progress. Although picture exchange has proven to be useful for STUDENT, her educational progress has consistently been a severe area of deficit. Given that STUDENT has recently demonstrated a potential for developing some practical expressive oral-language skills, the general FAPE standard of “reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit” is not satisfied by a program designed to have STUDENT make some progress at school using picture exchange, while foregoing an appropriate attempt to develop her expressive oral language. This finding is especially mandated for STUDENT as a fifth grader whose available time for learning such oral-language skills and applying them in school is diminishing.
In accordance with the above, the Hearing Officer finds that an appropriate speech and language program would include at least 150 minutes of services per week, allocated as 90 minutes of NPA-based speech and language services, at a minimum, and 60 minutes of school-based speech and language services. Finally, although the strategies recently being used by Ms. Larsen at the NPA were within the bounds of the “multi-modal communication system” referenced in the March 18, 2002 IEP goals and objectives, some refinement of the goals and objectives may be appropriate. After receiving this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team can decide whether goals and objectives should be adjusted and whether STUDENT would tolerate and benefit from more than 150 minutes of speech and language services per week.
II. Occupational therapy.
STUDENT’s unique needs: In its program offer, the District has proposed a reduction of STUDENT’s NPA-based OT services from the current level of 120 minutes per week to a new level of 60 minutes per week. The proposed 60 minutes of NPA-based OT would be in addition to 60 minutes of school-based OT. Before determining whether the District’s proposed program is designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of OT, those needs must be identified.
Ms. Bracken’s March 2002 OT assessment report, prepared in her capacity as a District occupational therapy specialist, states that she assessed STUDENT through clinical observations, therapist-directed activities, teacher interviews, and classroom observations. STUDENT’s then-operative IEPs listed four OT goals. Goals “1" and “4," as they were identified in the report, were being worked upon at Therapy West and would be covered in a progress report from that NPA. Goals “2" and “3" were being worked upon at Walgrove. Goal 2 involved STUDENT being able to perform a novel 3-step fine-motor task with only one oral cue. Neither the goal nor the short-term objectives were achieved, as STUDENT required visual prompts rather than oral prompts. Goal 3 involved improvement of visual-motor skills measured by STUDENT’s ability to copy a circle, square, rectangle, diamond, and triangle. Except for the diamond, STUDENT achieved the goal. The report describes STUDENT’s overall improvement in fine-motor, visual-motor, perceptual-motor, and bilateral coordination skills necessary or helpful in STUDENT’s access to her classroom program. Those skills included grasping her pencil, stabilizing her paper with her non-dominant left hand during coloring and cutting activities, tracing letters when provided with dotted lines, writing her first name, and coloring within boundaries. In the area of sensory modulation, STUDENT demonstrated “moderate difficulties maintaining appropriate levels of arousal and organization of behavior” to complete desired tasks within the school day. Proprioceptive and vestibular sensory input from the environment appeared to moderately affect STUDENT’s overall attention to task. The report also described deficits in praxis and self-help skills.
Although Ms. Bracken’s report states that STUDENT had shown improvement in her motor skills, she confirmed in her testimony that STUDENT still has needs in the areas of fine motor and sensory integration. Ms. Bracken testified that STUDENT requires vestibular and proprioceptive input to help her attend and stay organized in her behavior, and she especially needs to develop the ability to generalize her organization of behavior skills outside of the classroom.
Therapy West’s March 2002 OT progress report, written by Ms. Huesman, covers the two NPA-based goals being addressed by Therapy West. Goal 1, as described in the report, involved STUDENT’s developing the ability to plan and execute a 3-step obstacle course. The goal was not met. The report states that STUDENT had only been able to plan one step of a 3-step obstacle course independently. Goal 4 involved participation in reciprocal games with peers. The report states that by March 2002, none of the short-term objectives related to goal 4 had been met. The report states that STUDENT had difficulty maintaining sufficient organization of her behavior to complete her tasks in the gym and at a table. With access to activities providing proprioceptive and/or vestibular input, such as a jump-o-roo or swing, she was able to calm herself and demonstrate increased organization of behavior skills. Although she participated with a therapist in reciprocal ball play with minimal verbal cues, she required maximum verbal, visual, and sometimes physical cues to participate with a peer in a reciprocal game. Difficulty communicating her wants and needs was leading to increased frustration. Increased frustration was adversely affecting her organization of behavior, leading to decreased attention, increased arousal, and difficulty being redirected to task.
In her report, Ms. Heusman recommended continuing OT at Therapy West one time per week using “sensory strategies” to address STUDENT’s weaknesses in organization of behavior. A proposed goal was that STUDENT would learn to calm herself by leading a therapist to a piece of equipment or tool that could provide calming input, such as deep pressure, proprioceptive, or vestibular input. Ms. Huesman recommended continuation of school-based OT to address STUDENT’s fine-motor, visual-motor, and functional life skills.
In summary, STUDENT needs services to address her deficits in organization of behavior. She needs to learn sensory strategies for calming herself, and she needs to be able to generalize her learned skills outside of the therapy room. She also needs services to address her deficits in fine-motor, sensory integration, and functional life skills.
The program offer: In response to STUDENT’s OT needs, the District has offered 60 minutes of school-based OT and 60 minutes of NPA-based OT per week. The school-based OT services would address goals and objectives for copying safety words with accurate letter formation and completing novel 4-step fine-motor tasks with one visual cue. The OT therapist and the special education classroom teacher would be responsible for those goals. The NPA-based OT services would address goals and objectives related to increasing STUDENT’s organization of behavior through initiating the use of a sensory calming strategy by leading the therapist to equipment or tools that provide calming input. The NPA-based goals would be reevaluated in 6 months.
The Petitioner does not object to the proposed goals and objectives. Instead, her contention with respect to OT services is that a reduction of weekly NPA-based OT services from the prior level of 120 minutes to the proposed level of 60 minutes would not be designed to meet her needs. In support of her contention, the Petitioner asserts that her learning style requires extensive practice and repetition. She asserts that the combined efforts of the school-based and NPA-based therapists enabled her to make progress in the area of OT during the 2001-2002 school year, and an indispensable component of her therapy was the practicing of specific tasks repeatedly until the particular skills targeted by those tasks or drills were learned. Accordingly, the Petitioner asserts that a reduction in the OT services would be inconsistent with her need for extensive practice and repetition as mandated by her learning style.
The District’s program offer with respect to OT is derived from the recommendations of Ms. Bracken, the District occupational therapist. Ms. Bracken testified that the purpose of NPA-based therapy during the 2001-2002 school year was to address STUDENT’s weaknesses in organization of behavior skills, thereby also addressing her deficits in attention to task and overall functioning in school. However, on the basis of her own observations of STUDENT, having worked with her 30 minutes per week in the classroom and 30 minutes per week in the OT clinic, Ms. Bracken concluded that STUDENT had not received adequate benefit from the sensory integration strategy implemented at the NPA to justify continuation of those services at the level of 120 minutes per week. Most significantly, in Ms. Bracken’s opinion, STUDENT was not able to take the sensory integration strategies being learned at the NPA and transfer or generalize those skills into school and community settings.
To address STUDENT’s ongoing needs related to her ability to organize her behavior and generalize her organization of behavior skills outside of the therapy room, Ms. Bracken proposed a new approach for the 2002-2003 school year. Instead of relying strictly on OT personnel in clinic-based OT settings for teaching and implementing sensory integration strategies, Ms. Bracken proposed making STUDENT’s classroom teacher and the OT therapist jointly responsible for certain OT goals and objectives in the IEP. Ms. Bracken believed that the new approach of involving the classroom teacher would better address STUDENT’s needs regarding her ability to generalize organization of behavior skills into the classroom setting. Meanwhile, STUDENT would still receive one hour per week of NPA-based therapy designed to increase her organization of behavior by initiating the use of sensory strategies to calm herself. Because the educational benefit from two hours of weekly NPA-based OT therapy had been questionable during the 2001-2002 school year, the remaining one hour of NPA-based therapy would be reevaluated for its benefit to STUDENT, if any, in 6 months.
The OT-related goals and objectives in the March 18, 2002 IEP coincide with Ms. Bracken’s recommendations. The OT therapist and the special education classroom teacher would be jointly responsible for goals and objectives involving the copying of safety words with accurate letter formation and completing novel 4-step fine-motor tasks with one visual cue. Ms. Bracken’s testimony showed that although those particular goals do not specifically mention sensory-integration strategies, having the classroom teacher responsible for those goals would require that the OT therapist teach sensory-integration strategies to the classroom teacher, thereby addressing STUDENT’s need for generalization of those strategies into the classroom. Sensory-integration strategies suitable for the classroom could include activities such as having STUDENT sit on a special air cushion for proprioceptive input, having deep pressure applied by the teacher or aide, and wall pushups.
The District’s progam offer in the area of OT is also consistent with the recommendations stated by Ms. Huesman in the NPA report, summarized above. Furthermore, the offer is consistent with Ms. Huesman’s testimony at the hearing. She testified that, on the basis of what she had observed, the sensory strategies and input used in the clinic/gym setting had positively impacted STUDENT within that setting. However, she had spoken with Ms. Bracken about STUDENT’s performance, and Ms. Huesman agreed that expanding the use of sensory strategies into the classroom would better address STUDENT’s need to be able to learn in the classroom environment. Ms. Huesman recommended reduction of NPA-based OT from twice per week to once per week, and she recommended one hour of school-based OT in a private room or in the classroom, in accordance with STUDENT’s particular mood on a given day.
In summary, Ms. Bracken and Ms. Huesman are both knowledgeable about STUDENT through their capacity as her OT therapists. Their opinions regarding an appropriate OT program for STUDENT were substantially similar. Ms. Bracken stated that the OT services at the NPA had not resulted in sufficient benefit to merit continuation of that therapy at two hours per week. The better approach, according to Ms. Bracken, was to enlist the involvement of the classroom teacher in utilizing sensory-integration strategies. Ms. Huesman testified that STUDENT had shown good overall improvement within the setting of the NPA environment, but she did not know whether STUDENT had been able to generalize her skills in the classroom. She agreed with the proposal to reduce the NPA-based services to one session per week and place increased emphasis on performance in the classroom. No expert opinion testimony to the contrary was offered. Neither Ms. Bracken nor Ms. Huesman expressed concern that despite STUDENT’s ongoing deficits in organization of behavior, the new program called for a reduction of the NPA-based services. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer in the area of OT services was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.
III. Conclusions.
The Hearing Officer finds that to the extent the District’s program offer in the area of speech and language was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, the District has not offered her a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.
REMEDIES
The Petitioner’s request for an order that the District provide 120 minutes of NPA-based speech and language services per week is denied. The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT should be able to tolerate and benefit from 90 minutes of NPA-based and 60 minutes of school-based speech and language services per week. Fewer services under the current circumstances would result in the denial of a FAPE. Whether STUDENT could tolerate a more intensive program will be left to the discretion of the IEP team. Also left to the discretion of the IEP team will be the determination of whether goals and objectives specific to the NPA-based speech and language services should be revised to reflect the Hearing Officer’s findings regarding the needs being addressed by the NPA in the area of verbalization, articulation, and/or oral-motor skills.
ORDERS
1. Within 15 days from the date of this Decision, STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet to amend the March 18, 2002 IEP in a manner consistent with the findings in this Decision. More specifically, through the annual review date of March 18, 2003, STUDENT’s program shall include 90 minutes of NPA-based and 60 minutes of school-based speech and language services per week, in addition to whatever compensatory speech and language sessions remain pursuant to a prior agreement of the parties. The NPA-based services shall continue to address STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of verbalization, articulation, and/or oral-motor skills.
2. The IEP team shall determine whether adjustment in the currently-written goals and objectives pertinent to the NPA-based speech and language services is necessary.
3. As STUDENT proceeds through her program, her IEP team shall meet as appropriate to determine whether STUDENT would be able to tolerate and benefit from more intensive speech and language services than the amount stated above. The IEP team shall exercise caution not to overburden STUDENT with a schedule that is excessively demanding.
4. The OT services are found to be appropriate as offered by the District.
5. All of the Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year through March 18, 2003, to the extent that it proposed:
A. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based speech and language services from 90 minutes to 60 minutes per week (the Petitioner prevailed on this issue), and
B. to reduce STUDENT’s NPA-based OT services from 120 minutes to 60 minutes per week (the District prevailed on this issue)?
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: October 7, 2002 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Ms. Rein’s report also noted that STUDENT had received twelve 30-minute sessions of school-based compensatory speech and language services and was due to receive eleven more sessions in addition to her 30 minutes of school based and 90 minutes of NPA-based speech and language services.
2. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.
3. Unless the context indicates otherwise, references in this Decision to the “2002-2003 school year” mean the period through March 18, 2003, the date that STUDENT is scheduled for annual review of her IEP.
4. State and federal law require that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. State and federal law also require that the district’s program conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031; Rowley, supra. Furthermore, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20. U.S.C. Sec. 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. Sec. 300.347(a). None of the above matters were at issue in the present case.
5. This activity was described in the report. On several occasions, Ms. Rein observed STUDENT completing the process of searching through her picture exchange book, finding the desired symbol, such as bathroom, jumprope, popcorn, placing an “I want” card in front of the picture to form a sentence strip, then walking to her communication partner, getting his or her attention, and placing the sentence strip in her communication partner’s hand.
6. In accordance with terminology used in the various assessment reports and the testimony of the speech and language specialists, terms such as “verbal,” “oral-motor,” “ verbalization,” “ oral verbalization,” “vocalization,” and “articulation” are used synonymously in this Decision unless the context indicates otherwise.
7. For example, to encourage STUDENT to produce the “t” sound, Ms. Larsen would make the “t” sound while tapping her index finger above her own upper top lip in the middle. Other tactile cues included touching STUDENT on the alveolar ridge and the tip of her tongue and telling her to make them “touch.”
8. Descriptions could include size, color, shape, quantity, and location.
9. The goals and objectives for the 30-minute sessions of compensatory speech and language services were also essentially the same.
10. The Hearing Officer also observes that, as stated in a footnote above, STUDENT had received twelve 30-minute sessions of school-based compensatory speech and language therapy in addition to the other 120 weekly minutes of speech and language services described in her IEP. Neither party asserted at the hearing that STUDENT had been overburdened by the compensatory sessions.
11. STUDENT’s limited academic skills are apparent from the content of her IEPs.
12. As discussed above, neither Ms. Rein nor the District was proposing a program devoid of an attempt to develop STUDENT’s expressive oral language skills. Ms. Rein described how her “total language” approach included some attempts to encourage articulation. However, having considered Ms. Larsen’s testimony about STUDENT’s potential for developing verbalization skills, the Hearing Officer found the program offer to be inappropriate because more services were needed in the area of expressive oral language.
13. To receive a FAPE, STUDENT will require the NPA-based and school-based services, totaling 150 minutes per week, as described in this Decision. STUDENT’s IEP team is in the best position to decide how and when to incorporate STUDENT’s remaining 30-minute sessions of compensatory speech and language sessions into her schedule.
14. The operative IEPs at that time were dated March 12, 2001 and June 11, 2001. Goal 1 was on the March 12, 2001 IEP, and goal 4 was on the June 11, 2001 IEP. The persons listed as responsible for goals 1 and 4 were OT personnel.
15. Goals 2 and 3 were from the March 12, 2001 IEP. The persons listed on the IEP as responsible for goals 2 and 3 were OT personnel.
16. Ms. Bracken’s report describes sensory modulation as “the process by which one regulates incoming sensory information to perform tasks purposefully, while maintaining an appropriate level of attention needed to complete a task.” Proprioceptive sensory input is described as “input to her muscles and joints that tells where one’s body is in space.” Vestibular sensory input is described as “movement of her head in relation to gravity for balance or equilibrium.”
17. Ms. Bracken’s report describes praxis as the “ability to plan, organize, and execute a novel motor task.”
18. By contrast, clinic-based OT utilized different tools such as suspended equipment, swings, and scooter boards.
