California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 13, 2003

Student v. Pasadena Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1873-02 · Hearing Officer Heather A. Hoyle

Pasadena Unified's special day class offer for a 12-year-old with a severe intellectual disability upheld as FAPE in the LRE.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A mother, representing her 12-year-old son herself, filed for due process against Pasadena Unified School District over his 2002-2003 placement. He is eligible under "mental retardation" (now called intellectual disability) in the severe range. He has a seizure disorder that has not responded to treatment and has caused him to lose skills. In 2001-2002, at his parents' request, he attended a resource specialist program (RSP) at Sierra Madre Middle School, with general education time and a one-to-one aide. The District found this was not working. After an assessment by the state Diagnostic Center of Southern California, the District offered a special day class (SDC) for students with severe disabilities at Wilson Middle School. The offer included speech-language services and daily adapted physical education (APE). The mother wanted a blended inclusion class. She also argued that classroom dust and carpet, too little activity, and diet could increase his seizures, and that the APE goals were inadequate.

The Hearing Officer found that he needs a functional skills curriculum in a small, structured group. The evidence did not show that allergies, inactivity, or diet affected his seizures. A Diagnostic Center pediatrician found no medical support for those links. The APE goals met his needs. Earlier inclusion attempts had failed. The SDC is next to general education classrooms, and its students join peers at lunch and breaks. The District prevailed and may implement the November 20, 2002 IEP.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed a parent's medical concerns about allergies, activity and diet against a Diagnostic Center assessment. Letters from physicians who did not testify, and that did not explain a link between allergies and seizures, did not prove the student needed a special classroom environment. Applying Rowley, the Hearing Officer upheld a functional skills SDC over inclusion.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District's offer to place STUDENT in a special day class on the Wilson Middle School campus offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year? (Including the parent's challenges to the APE goals, the student's claimed seizure-related needs for allergen control, physical activity and diet, and whether the SDC was the least restrictive environment compared to a blended inclusion class.)

    The SDC offer, with a functional skills curriculum, speech-language services, daily APE and facilitated peer contact, met the student's needs, was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and was the LRE. The APE goals were appropriate, and the parent did not prove that allergies, inactivity or diet affected his seizures.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District is entitled to implement the program, placement and services in the November 20, 2002 IEP and must make them available to the student. All of Petitioner's claims for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Seattle School Dist. v. B.S.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Judith Barhydt, Director of special education, Pasadena Unified School District
  • LaVonne Knedel, Project coordinator of special education; District witness, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Joanne Weigel, M.D., Developmental pediatrician, Diagnostic Center assessor; District witness, California Department of Education, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Deborah Holt, Director of the Diagnostic Center; District witness, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Pam Mallon, Program coordinator, behavioral support; developed the offered SDC; District witness, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Wendy Parry, Adapted physical education teacher; District witness, Pasadena Unified School District
  • Crystal Chang, Resource specialist program teacher; District witness, Pasadena Unified School District, Sierra Madre Middle School
  • Rochelle Coombs, SDC teacher of the offered class, Pasadena Unified School District, Wilson Middle School
  • Cressey (first name redacted in source), Education specialist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Brenda Steel, School psychologist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Laura Clark, Speech-language pathologist, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Jose Preciado, Registered nurse, Diagnostic Center assessment team, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Dr. Michael Kaplan, Private allergist/immunologist (letter submitted; did not testify), Private provider
  • Dr. Bruce Enos, Private neurologist (letter submitted; did not testify), Private provider
  • Champion Gymnastics Academy, Private provider of the "Big Fun" gymnastics program (report submitted), Funded by San Gabriel-Pomona Regional Center
  • San Gabriel-Pomona Regional Center, Regional center funding the Big Fun program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Pasadena, California, on January 14, 15, and 16, 2003.

Petitioner (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by his mother, (STUDENT’S mother). FAMILY FRIEND, a family friend, was also present during portions of the hearing on behalf of STUDENT. Pasadena Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Howard Fulfrost from the law firm of Lozano Smith, and Judith Barhydt, director of special education for the District.(Footnote 1) Ms. LaVonne Knedel, project coordinator of special education for the District, also attended portions of the hearing on behalf of the District.

STUDENT’s mother was the sole witness called to testify on behalf of Petitioner. The following witnesses were called to testify on behalf of the Respondent: Dr. Joanne Weigel, developmental pediatrician at the California Department of Education, Diagnostic Center of Southern California (Diagnostic Center); Deborah Holt, director of the Diagnostic Center; LaVonne Knedel; Pam Mallon, program coordinator at the District; Wendy Parry, adapted physical education teacher at the District; and Crystal Chang, resource specialist program teacher at the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of oral closing arguments on January 16, 2003, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing in this matter, January 14, 2003, Mr. Fulfrost made two motions on behalf of the District prior to the taking of evidence.

Motion to bar witness from testifying

The District objected to allowing STUDENT’s mother to testify on behalf of her son STUDENT and made a motion at hearing to bar STUDENT’s mother from testifying. The District’s position generally was that STUDENT’s mother should not be permitted to testify on behalf of her son because she allegedly failed to put the District on notice of her intention to testify.

California Education Code section 56505.1 (f) states that the presiding hearing officer may exclude the testimony of witnesses or presentation of documents not provided five business days prior to the first day of hearing. After hearing from the parties regarding the motion, the Hearing Officer found that while STUDENT’s mother indicated in a letter to Mr. Fulfrost dated January 10, 2003, that she intended to call no witnesses in this case it was clear that STUDENT’s mother planned to present her case and explain to the Hearing Officer her concerns regarding STUDENT’s education. While STUDENT’s mother did not formally indicate her intention to testify five business days prior to the start of the hearing, the District presented no credible basis to support its argument that the District would be prejudiced should STUDENT’s mother be permitted to testify on behalf of her son. STUDENT’s mother was not represented by an attorney at the hearing, and based on her representations to this Hearing Officer, planned to present her case by “telling her story” to the hearing officer.

The Hearing Officer denied the District’s motion to exclude STUDENT’s mother’s testimony and STUDENT’s mother was permitted to testify. The Hearing Officer advised the District that if after STUDENT’s mother’s testimony the District believed it required additional time to rebut or respond to her testimony, the Hearing Officer would consider a brief continuance. The District did not seek a continuance after the conclusion of STUDENT’s mother’s testimony.

Motion to exclude documents

The District also made a motion to bar the introduction into evidence of the documents STUDENT’s mother sought to admit in this matter, as they were not provided to the district five business days prior to the start of this hearing. STUDENT’s mother sought to admit six documents: (1) a record indicating STUDENT’s attendance at Pasadena Unified School District from 1996-2002, (2) a report dated January 13, 2003, from Champion Gymnastics Academy, (3) a letter dated January 7, 2003, from Dr. Michael Kaplan, (4) a letter dated January 7, 2003 from Dr. Bruce Enos, (5) a psycho-educational assessment dated December 17, 1997, and (6) an IEP document dated November 11, 1997. The District was given an opportunity to review the documents off the record. The District then reiterated its objection to the admission of the documents. After hearing from both parties regarding this motion, this Hearing Officer admitted the documents and indicated that the documents would be afforded due weight in addressing the issues in this hearing. Two of the documents offered, the IEP and psycho-educational assessment, were documents created by the District and therefore available to them prior to hearing. The District presented no credible basis for the argument that it would be prejudiced by these documents being admitted into evidence. The other three documents offered by Petitioner included recent reports drafted by health care providers and one service provider, and provided information relevant to the issues in this case. While STUDENT’s mother failed to disclose these documents to the District five business days prior to the hearing, one of the documents was not in existence five days prior, and the other two were created exactly five business days prior to the hearing. In light of the circumstances in this matter, including the nature and number of documents and their relevance to the issues in this hearing, the Hearing Officer exercised her discretion and admitted the documents.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Did the District’s offer to place STUDENT in a special day class on the Wilson Middle school campus offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2002-2003 school year?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that the District’s offered placement for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year in a special day class (SDC) located on the Wilson Middle school campus was not appropriate. Petitioner asserts that the offered SDC placement is located in a remote portion of the Wilson Middle school campus, does not provide enough exposure to typically developing peers, and may expose STUDENT to dust and other allergens that may affect the number of seizures STUDENT suffers. Petitioner also alleges that the SDC class would not provide enough physical activity for STUDENT and the alleged sedentary nature of the class may exacerbate STUDENT’s seizures. Petitioner also contends that the school site may be unable to accommodate STUDENT’s special dietary restrictions. In addition, the Petitioner alleges that the District has not provided appropriate adapted physical education (APE) goals for STUDENT. Petitioner’s position is that the services STUDENT currently receives from the “Big Fun” program offered by Champion Gymnastics Academy is the ideal type of placement for STUDENT. This program is provided by the San Gabriel-Ponoma Regional Center and offers one-to-one interaction with a gymnastics coach. Petitioner’s position at the IEP meeting held to discuss STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year was that STUDENT requires a “blended inclusion” placement providing the maximum exposure to typically developing peers.

The Respondent contends that it offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education in the least restrictive environment for the 2002-2003 school year. Respondent’s position is that STUDENT requires placement in a special day class to address his unique needs. In particular, STUDENT’s needs require that he focus at this point in his education on functional life skills in a small-group setting. Respondent asserts that it tried to accommodate STUDENT’s mother’s request during the 2001-2002 school year when she insisted that STUDENT not be placed in an SDC program by offering a combination of RSP and mainstreaming. However, the District did found that RSP placement was not successful for STUDENT. Respondent’s position is that while STUDENT’s mother has expressed concerns regarding the offered placement including the classroom location, physical activity of the students, possible inability of the placement to accommodate any dietary needs STUDENT may have, and alleged presence of allergens possibly affecting the number of seizures STUDENT may have, the validity of these concerns is not supported by reliable evidence. The Respondent’s contention is that the appropriateness of the offered SDC placement is further supported by the results and recommendations from the Diagnostic Center’s assessment of STUDENT of September 2002. In addition, the District asserts that appropriate goals were developed for STUDENT in the area of APE.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student currently attending school in the Pasadena Unified School District. STUDENT attends between one to one and one half hours per day in a resource specialist program at the Sierra Madre Middle school site, participates in regular education classroom activity accompanied by a one-to-one instructional aide, and receives APE and speech and language services.(Footnote 2) (Respondent’s Exhibit 4) Petitioner is eligible as a student with a disability under the category of mental retardation.

STUDENT was developing typically until he was approximately five years old and he began to suffer from seizures. STUDENT has been diagnosed with Lennox-Gastaut Syndrome, a severe form of epilepsy.(Footnote 3) The seizures continue and have severely affected STUDENT’s development. STUDENT has regressed in areas of academic and social functioning since the onset of the seizures, and has lost skills he was once able to accomplish.

STUDENT has attended school within the District since his enrollment in kindergarten in 1995.(Footnote 4) STUDENT participated in a regular education kindergarten and first grade program at the District. STUDENT then attended District SDC programs operated on the Willard campus as well as at the Sierra Madre school site. During the 2001-2002 school year based on a request from STUDENT’s parents STUDENT’s placement was changed and he attended an RSP classroom at Sierra Madre and participated in regular education classes for a portion of the day.

The District IEP team members concluded that the RSP classroom with participation in regular education classes was not meeting STUDENT’s needs and recommended that he return to an SDC program. Several IEP team meetings were held regarding STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year because STUDENT’s parents did not want STUDENT placed in an SDC program. On May 23, 2002, an IEP team meeting was held and the District members of the IEP team recommended and the District offered STUDENT placement in an SDC classroom. STUDENT’s mother signed STUDENT’s IEP approving all the components of the IEP and agreeing with the IEP team decisions with the exception of the District’s offered placement. The IEP team met again on May 30 and July 30, to discuss the disagreement between STUDENT’s parents and the other IEP team members regarding STUDENT’s placement. The District made a referral to the California Diagnostic Center in April of 2002. The District and the Petitioner’s parents agreed to a temporary placement for STUDENT pending the completion of the Diagnostic Center’s assessment. STUDENT continued to attend the RSP classroom at Sierra Madre Middle school site and received speech and language as well as adapted physical education. On August 7, 2002, STUDENT’s mother filed a request for a due process hearing on behalf of STUDENT to address the disagreement with the District regarding the appropriate placement for STUDENT in the 2002-2003 school year.

The assessment by the Diagnostic Center was conducted during the week of September 30, 2002. The Diagnostic Center conducted a transdisciplinary assessment of STUDENT. As explained by Ms. Holt, the director of the Diagnostic Center, the assessors work together as a team and compile one report. Multidisciplinary teams, by comparison, typically are composed of individual assessors who each complete separate reports that are later reviewed and compiled by one person into a single report. All of the transdisciplinary team members meet and confer throughout the assessment process. Parents are active members of the team. The transdisciplinary team that assessed STUDENT included STUDENT Cressey, education specialist; Brenda Steel, school psychologist; Laura Clark, speech-language pathologist; Joanne Weigel, M.D., developmental pediatrician; and Jose Preciado, registered nurse. The Diagnostic Center team conducted both formal and informal assessments as well as parent and school staff interviews. The team also reviewed STUDENT’s medical, family and educational history.

On November 14, 2002, the Diagnostic Center team, along with District staff, met with STUDENT’s parents to discuss the results of the assessment and review the report the Diagnostic Center team had prepared. An IEP team meeting was held on November 20, 2002, to review and discuss the results of the assessment. The District members of the IEP team then reiterated the earlier offer of an SDC program located on the Wilson Middle school campus. Petitioner’s parents again consented to the IEP with the exception of the offered placement. STUDENT continues to receive RSP services at Sierra Madre Middle School pursuant to his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP as modified by agreement of the parties pending the outcome of this hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2002-2003 school year?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(18).

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 175, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. Thus, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. Seattle School District v. B.S. (9th Cir.1996) 82 F.3d 1493; Union School District v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, cert denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994). The focus when addressing disputes between parties regarding placement for a student is not whether the student may obtain greater benefit in a placement that is preferred by one of the parties. Rather, a placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2nd 1307.

In summary, under the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in Rowley, an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student's unique needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, conform to the student’s IEP, and be provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.

What are STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine whether the placement the District offered STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year would provide him with a FAPE, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. Testimony of all of the Respondent’s witnesses established that STUDENT is a student with a disability of mental retardation and that his disability falls within the severe range of mentally retarded students. Testimony of Dr. Joanne Weigel, pediatrician at the Diagnostic Center, was that STUDENT currently functions consistently at a developmental level of twenty-four months and has some scattered skills that are between the two-to four-year-old skills level. (Footnote 5) However, these higher-level skills are exhibited sporadically and not generalized across environments. (Respondent’s Exhibit 2)

STUDENT continues to suffer from uncontrolled seizures that have been resistant to medical treatment, including a number of medications prescribed and administered to STUDENT over the last six years. According to both Dr. Weigel’s and STUDENT’s mother’s testimony, STUDENT is currently not taking medication to treat his seizures. STUDENT’s mother also testified regarding STUDENT’s diet and indicated that STUDENT had been on a ketogenic diet, but that he is no longer on that diet and that she is gradually reintroducing other food into his diet.(Footnote 6)

Dr. Weigel testified regarding STUDENT’s seizure disorder and how it affects STUDENT’s educational needs. Dr. Weigel’s testimony was that in her professional opinion an individual such as STUDENT, who suffers from uncontrolled seizures, might experience regression and lose skills he had previously mastered. In addition, Dr. Weigel testified that based on her review of STUDENT’s records and her assessment, STUDENT has suffered from brain damage due to the uncontrolled seizures that is likely permanent even if the seizures were to cease. Dr. Weigel further testified that based on the amount of time STUDENT has suffered from seizures, and his current age, even if the seizures were brought under control, it is unlikely that STUDENT would be able to “catch up” or regain those skills he has lost. Dr. Weigel explained that STUDENT has not been developing typically during the last six to seven years and is reaching an age that new development, particularly in the brain, slows. Therefore even if STUDENT’s seizures were to cease, he would probably not be able to move to the next developmental level, although he would likely be able to learn new skills within his current developmental level.

Testimony at hearing by Respondent’s witnesses was that STUDENT requires a functional skills curriculum to address his needs in the areas of language arts, vocational, self help and independence, recreational and leisure, community, English, social skills, math, safety, health, pre-vocational, expressive language, pragmatics, receptive language, gross motor, and reading. STUDENT is currently placed in Crystal Chang’s RSP class an average of one to one and one-half hours per day depending on his schedule and pull out services.(Footnote 7) Ms. Chang testified that STUDENT can follow directions sometimes and that his academic functioning is low. He does not consistently recognize letters or numbers. STUDENT does not initiate contact with regular education peers. However, during facilitated interaction or reverse mainstreaming, occasionally she will see STUDENT “hi-five” another student. Deborah Holt’s testimony, as well as that of Dr. Weigel and Ms. Chang, indicates that STUDENT will likely need supervision and care all of his life.(Footnote 8) Ms. Holt testified that STUDENT might continue to learn new skills and become an active member of his community and school, but that he needs a functional skills curriculum to address his needs and allow him to learn those skills. The testimony of Dr. Weigel, Ms. Chang, and Ms. Holt indicating that STUDENT requires a functional skills curriculum to address his needs was persuasive, and Petitioner did not dispute that STUDENT requires a functional skills curriculum.

Wendy Parry, STUDENT’s APE teacher, testified regarding STUDENT’s needs in the area of APE.(Footnote 9) Ms. Parry testified that she has known STUDENT for approximately seven years and that she has provided APE services to him in the past. Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT currently can cross the midline without turning his body and has exhibited right-hand dominance in some tasks. Ms. Parry’s testimony established that STUDENT has needs in the area of kinesthetic awareness and motor planning including laterality and directionality. While STUDENT’s mother also testified regarding STUDENT’s APE needs, her testimony did not indicate that she disagreed with Ms. Parry’s assessment of STUDENT’s APE needs or that she specifically thought STUDENT had other needs in the area of APE.

All of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT should have opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT requires maximum exposure to typically developing peers. However, Respondent’s witnesses testified that those interactions should be provided in a facilitated manner and that the most appropriate manner would be through reverse mainstreaming or mainstreaming for a portion of STUDENT’s day in an elective course. (Respondent’s Exhibit 2) The persuasive testimony of both Respondent’s witnesses as well as STUDENT’s mother, established that STUDENT requires opportunities to interact with typically developing peers. The parties disagree as to the extent STUDENT requires interaction with regular education students and the appropriate measures to address STUDENT’s need in this area will be discussed more fully below.

In addition to STUDENT’s needs as summarized above, STUDENT’s mother alleges that STUDENT has other needs that relate to his seizures. STUDENT’s mother’s testimony addressed her concerns regarding STUDENT’s seizures and what she believes may cause STUDENT’s seizures to increase in frequency. STUDENT’s mother asserts that a lack of respiratory activity as well as STUDENT’s allergies may increase the number of seizures STUDENT has. STUDENT’s mother also contends that STUDENT has special dietary needs related to controlling his seizures.

In particular, STUDENT’s mother testified regarding what she called an allergy and seizure “cup.” STUDENT’s mother explained that in her opinion STUDENT may not suffer a seizure based solely on exposure to dust mites, or perfume, or the wrong food, or carpeting, but when too many things are placed in STUDENT’s cup and the cup overflows, STUDENT is likely to experience an increase in seizures due to the cup overflowing. STUDENT’s mother provided letters from a Dr. Michael Kaplan and Dr. Bruce Enos regarding STUDENT’s medical conditions. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 3 and 4) However, the letters from STUDENT’s physicians do not persuasively support a medically and scientifically established link between allergies and seizures, and neither physician testified at hearing. Dr. Kaplan, practicing in allergy and immunology, indicates the following in a letter dated January 7, 2003: “He [STUDENT] also has chronic intermittent nasal symptoms and was found to be allergic to house dust mites. There seems to be a correlation between increased nasal blockage and frequency as well as severity of seizures. . . [t]herefore I am requesting that he is allowed to be in a class environment that is not dusty and preferably with a wall to wall carpet.”(Footnote 10) Dr. Enos, who has according to his letter of January 7, 2003, followed STUDENT in a neurology clinic for two to three years, states: “STUDENT’s mother has strong views with regard to certain issues which she feels are impinging on STUDENT’s seizure frequency. These include allergies and medications themselves. She has been experimenting considerably over the last few years and is convinced that certain environmental factors will make her son’s seizures worse. I cannot comment on the validity of any of these assertions.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 4) Dr. Weigel persuasively testified that that after she assessed STUDENT in September 2002, she conducted further research in the medical literature and databases regarding STUDENT’s mother’s assertions that there was a connection between allergies and seizures and was unable to find anything that would support such a connection. Without further explanation through testimony or documentary evidence regarding the alleged connection between allergies and seizures, Petitioner has failed to establish a relationship between STUDENT’s allergies and increased seizures. As Petitioner failed to establish that allergies exacerbate STUDENT’s seizures, the Hearing Officer finds that based on the evidence presented STUDENT does not require a special physical environment or other environmental accommodation to benefit from his education.(Footnote 11)

In addition, STUDENT’s mother asserted during her testimony that STUDENT may experience an increase in seizures as a result of periods of inactivity, and in particular a lack of respiratory activity. The District’s witnesses agreed that in general students require physical activity. Dr. Weigel testified that she knew of no link between a lack of respiratory activity and an increase in seizures, and in fact, testified that strenuous physical activity may be more likely to precipitate a seizure. Petitioner failed to establish that STUDENT requires a particular level of respiratory activity, and the Respondent’s witnesses persuasively established that students in the offered District SDC are active during the school day.

STUDENT’s mother also testified at length regarding STUDENT’s diet. In particular, STUDENT’s mother indicated that STUDENT has been on a ketogenic diet to assist in controlling his seizures. However, testimony at hearing as well as the letter from STUDENT’s neurologist Dr. Enos, was that STUDENT is no longer on this diet. STUDENT’s mother acknowledges that while she is still preparing STUDENT’s food daily, and delivering his meals to school, STUDENT is no longer on the specialized diet. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 4) Therefore, Petitioner has failed to establish that STUDENT has a particular need regarding his diet, as he is no longer following the ketogenic diet and there was no persuasive evidence presented that he required a specific diet to benefit from his education.

The Hearing Officer finds on the basis of the documentary evidence and the testimony at hearing that Petitioner has not established that he has additional needs regarding his seizures with respect to allergies, lack of respiratory activity, or diet. Therefore, in conclusion, STUDENT’s needs as expressed by the witnesses and the documentary evidence require a functional skills curriculum to address the areas of language arts, vocational, self help and independence, recreation and leisure, community, English, social skills, math, safety, health, pre-vocational, expressive language, pragmatics, receptive language, gross motor, and reading. In addition STUDENT should have opportunities to interact with typically developing peers and receive APE. Next, it must be determined whether the goals and objectives, services, and placement offered by the District are designed to meet STUDENT’s needs.

Is the proposed placement designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

The goals and objectives identified on STUDENT’s current IEP address development of the following: language arts, vocational, self help and independence, recreational and leisure, community, English, social skills, math, safety, health, pre-vocational, expressive language, pragmatics, receptive language, gross motor, APE and reading.(Footnote 12) Petitioner did not dispute the appropriateness of the goals or objectives developed for STUDENT with the exception of those in the area of APE.

Ms. Parry testified that the goals identified on STUDENT’s IEP for the 2002-2003 school year address STUDENT’s APE needs. In particular, STUDENT’s IEP identifies a laterality and directionality goal to address his gross motor needs: “STUDENT will participate in a game activity demonstrating three procedures, i.e. hitting ball running to a base etc either verbally or being motored moderately.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 1) Ms. Parry also testified regarding STUDENT’s APE goal to “improve arm strength and coordination.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 15) This goal seeks to address STUDENT’s need to improve his kinesthetic awareness. Ms. Parry testified that STUDENT has weak upper body strength and difficulty in “knowing his arms are attached to his body.” To address this need, STUDENT’s IEP for the 2002-2003 school year provided the following goal and corresponding benchmarks: “STUDENT will life a two pound weight with arms in a variety of patterns with physical cures 3 of 5 tries. [STUDENT] [w]ill lift a two pound with arms in a variety of patterns without physical cues-voice command 3 of 5 tries. [STUDENT] [w]ill stretch the heavy rubber bands across his chest [right and left] arm 3 of 5 tries.”

While STUDENT’s mother testified that she did not agree with the APE goals for STUDENT, STUDENT’s mother could not identify a specific need that was not met by the goals as drafted for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT’s mother expressed concern regarding an annual social recreation and leisure goal stating that “STUDENT will participate in turn taking activities with another student (i.e. table games, shooting hoops) with prompts to demonstrate those turn taking exchanges 3/5 times.” (Respondent’s Exhibit 1) STUDENT’s mother indicated that she did not think the turn-taking activity was appropriate because STUDENT had a similar goal in previous school years regarding basketball. However, other than her disagreement with the use of basketball as an example of a turn-taking activity, STUDENT’s mother did not identify an area of need she thought was not addressed or any other reason the goal was inappropriate. The specific goal STUDENT’s mother asserts is not appropriate is not an APE goal, but rather a social, recreation and leisure goal, as was confirmed by STUDENT’s IEP as well as the testimony of Wendy Parry. Ms. Perry testified that this goal provided an opportunity for reverse mainstreaming, and could be worked on with regular education students. STUDENT’s mother did not indicate that she thought the turn-taking aspect was inappropriate, and in fact, her testimony suggests that social skills training is something she approves of as a goal for STUDENT. On the basis of the evidence and testimony at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds the annual goals in the area of APE regarding STUDENT’s kinesthetic and motor planning are appropriate and address his unique needs. In comparing all these goals to STUDENT’s needs identified above, it is concluded that the goals and objectives are designed to meet his needs.(Footnote 13)

The placement and services offered to STUDENT includes an SDC program for students with severe disabilities at the Wilson Middle School, classroom based speech and language services for thirty minutes two times per week, and APE for forty minutes five times per week. (Respondent’s Exhibit 1) The offered SDC class is taught by Rochelle Coombs and is located in a wing of Wilson Middle School along with regular education classrooms. Ms. Knedel, who has known STUDENT since 1997, testified that the Wilson SDC program offers APE every day, safety is addressed daily, and behavior needs are addressed throughout the curriculum.(Footnote 14) Ms Mallon, Ms. Chang and Ms. Knedel all testified regarding the offered SDC classroom’s functional skills curriculum and in particular Ms. Mallon testified extensively regarding the daily schedule of the SDC.(Footnote 15) The SDC offers a rich language environment to address speech and language needs and social skills are taught in the classroom by learning to be kind to other students, lessons and practice with other students, and turn taking. The SDC program also provides vocational opportunities. For example, students work on tasks for the school’s administration staff, including collating documents for school staff distribution and performing other clerical tasks for the school’s office. Ms. Mallon testified that in addition to eating lunch with regular education students, the SDC students also attend a nutrition break each morning providing additional opportunities for SDC students to interact with typically developing peers.

Ms. Mallon has known STUDENT for over five years and has been involved in his program during that time as well as providing behavioral support. She testified that she agreed with the recommendation of an SDC placement for STUDENT based on her knowledge of his previous success in a similar program as well as his needs at the time of the IEP team meeting. Ms. Mallon testified that she developed the SDC currently taught by Ms. Coombs at Wilson Middle School and is familiar with the teachers and the student population the program typically serves. Ms. Mallon testified that the SDC program offers mulitsensory modalities to help the students access the curriculum using all the students’ senses. For example, a lesson might include both a lecture and a picture of the subject of the lecture, as well as a hands-on project, and the actual object. In addition, the program offers physical cues, and picture schedules. It is highly structured, in contrast to regular education and RSP programs offered in middle school. Both Ms. Mallon and Ms. Chang testified that RSP programs and regular education middle school classes tend to be fluid and students and teachers have a fairly large degree of flexibility in how the class proceeds. Ms. Knedel and Ms. Chang testified that RSP programs and regular education classrooms are not appropriate for students with needs similar to STUDENT’s, as such students benefit from a structured environment with continuity and routine.

Ms. Chang’s testimony was that the curriculum in her RSP class is a modified general education curriculum while the SDC program the District has offered STUDENT utilizes an alternative curriculum, addressing functional skills. Testimony of Ms. Chang as well as Ms. Mallon and Ms. Knedel was that STUDENT requires not only a small group setting, but also a functional skills curriculum such as is offered in the SDC program to address his needs, particularly social skills, safety and life skills.

STUDENT’s mother testified that she observed the District’s offered placement two times during the 2002-2003 school year. One observation was for approximately one half hour, and the other for approximately five minutes. STUDENT’s mother’s testimony regarding these two observations illustrated her concerns regarding the classroom’s carpeting and “air stagnation,” possibly increasing the number of STUDENT’s seizures. STUDENT’s mother also was not impressed by the tasks the students in the class were working on. In addition, STUDENT’s mother expressed concern regarding what she perceived as a lack of physical movement of the students during the period she observed the classroom. Testimony of Ms. Mallon and Ms. Chang indicated that the SDC class the District has offered follows the “bell schedule” of the middle school so that students are moving to and from tasks according to the schedule, as well as attending to different activities within the one-hour segments between bells.

Ms. Knedel accompanied STUDENT’s mother on one of the observations of the offered SDC program. She testified that the observation lasted approximately fifteen minutes and that the children were well behaved and some of the children were working on computers during the time she was in the classroom. Ms. Knedel testified that she did not notice the classroom being dusty and that it was not dirty. Her testimony was that her understanding is that the program includes a significant amount of activity and that in her opinion the classroom did not seem either over or under stimulating for the students. Ms. Knedel also testified that the children appeared to know the routine and seemed comfortable with the tasks they were working on at the time of her observations. Ms. Knedel indicated that there were approximately seven children present during her observation and her impression was that the classroom was highly structured.

STUDENT’s mother’s concerns regarding the SDC classroom placement are in part based on her assertions that STUDENT has needs regarding his seizures that she testified the SDC would not be able to address. As discussed above, after evaluating the testimony provided at hearing as well as the documentary evidence no persuasive evidence was submitted to support a finding that STUDENT requires a special physical environment free of allergens or with a certain level of physical activity to benefit from his education. In any case, the testimony of Ms. Mallon, Ms. Knedel, and Ms. Parry all indicated that the offered SDC program does provide physical activity and based on their knowledge and experience with the particular teacher of the offered program, the students are in fact active throughout the day. Petitioner also failed to establish that STUDENT requires a special diet at this time as STUDENT’s mother’s testimony was that STUDENT is no longer on a ketogenic diet. If STUDENT’s mother continues to keep STUDENT on a special diet and provide STUDENT’s food, the District established through credible testimony that it would accommodate that diet.

The testimony as discussed above establishes that the District has offered placement and services designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. In summary, the placement and services offered will provide a functional skills curriculum to address STUDENT’s language arts, vocational, self help and independence, recreational and leisure, community, English, social skills, math, safety, health, pre-vocational, expressive language, pragmatics, receptive language, gross motor, and reading needs. In addition STUDENT will be provided APE services as well as opportunities to interact with typically developing peers.

Is the proposed placement reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT?

District witnesses Ms. Mellon, Ms. Chang and Ms. Knedel all testified that STUDENT had previously made progress on his goals and objectives while receiving services and participating in an SDC placement in the District similar to what has been offered for the current school year. In addition, the testimony of the both Dr. Weigel as well as Deborah Holt was that the offered placement would allow STUDENT to benefit by providing a functional skills curriculum as well as a small-group setting with other children who have similar needs and level of functioning. Both Ms. Mallon and Ms. Knedel testified that the SDC program is designed to address functional living skills. Ms. Mallon, Ms. Chang and Ms. Knedel testified that the program and services offered in the Wilson SDC program are designed to help make STUDENT a functional member of society.

It is concluded that the District has offered services and placement that will address STUDENT’s needs and allow him to improve his language arts, vocational, self help and independence, recreational and leisure, community, English, social skills, math, safety, health, pre-vocational, expressive language, pragmatics, receptive language, gross motor, and reading and will allow STUDENT to benefit from his education as required by Rowley.

Does the proposed placement conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

The evidence establishes that the District is ready and able to implement the placement offered in the IEP. Therefore the Hearing Officer finds that the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE.

Was the SDC placement offered by the District the least restrictive environment to meet STUDENT’s needs?

Special education law requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment, which means ensuring that his education is provided in a manner that promotes his interaction typically developing peer, and is appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. 20 U.S.C. §§ 1412 (a)(5)(A), 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii)(III), California Education Code § 56031. This requirement that children with disabilities be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as mainstreaming or as an education in the least restrictive environment. Petitioner argues that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by offering placement in an SDC classroom instead of a blended inclusion classroom or other placement providing the maximum exposure to typically developing peers.(Footnote 16) In addition, Petitioner alleges that the physical location of the classroom serves to segregate STUDENT.

Ms. Knedel testified that blended inclusion classrooms typically are composed of approximately twenty to thirty regular education students as well as approximately five to ten special education students. A regular education teacher and a special education teacher in a parallel learning environment teach the blended inclusion class.

Ms. Mallon, Ms. Knedel and, STUDENT’s current teacher Ms. Chang, all testified that a blended inclusion classroom is not appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Knedel testified that STUDENT’s needs are more severe than those students successfully participating in blended inclusion placements. She explained that students placed in a blended inclusion classroom participate in a modified regular education curriculum and are involved in the same activity as the regular education students. She further indicated that STUDENT’s skills are not at the level at which he would benefit from such a program and would not be able to participate meaningfully or benefit from that type of placement. In addition, Ms. Knedel as well as Ms. Chang testified that attempts to include STUDENT in a regular education classroom during the 2001-2002 school year accompanied by a one to one aide were unsuccessful. STUDENT at times refused to enter the classroom or demonstrated other behaviors indicating his discomfort with being in the regular education classroom that led to the aide removing STUDENT from the room. (Respondent’s Exhibit 15)

The SDC program and the functional skills curriculum will provide STUDENT the opportunity to gain the skills STUDENT’s mother testified she wants STUDENT to possess. Additionally, testimony of Ms. Mallon was that the location of the SDC classroom at the end of a row of rooms in one portable wing on the Wilson campus. However, Ms. Mallon further explained that the SDC classroom is next to regular education classrooms and students pass by the SDC classroom and walk through the hall where the classroom is located on their way to other areas of the building.

STUDENT’s mother’s testimony indicated that one of the reasons she disagreed with the District’s offer of placement in an SDC was that she though STUDENT would be more likely to exhibit undesirable behaviors due to his exposure to the other SDC students. Testimony of Ms. Holt, Ms. Chang, Ms. Parry and Dr. Weigel indicated that STUDENT is unlikely to benefit from, or model behavior, either positive or negative behavior, based solely on observation. STUDENT requires direct interaction and instruction to learn new skills and to reinforce those already mastered.

The testimony and other evidence established that STUDENT needs a small-group setting to address his needs using a functional skills curriculum, and that the classroom location is not segregated or isolated from the regular education students on campus. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered placement in the SDC classroom at Wilson Middle School offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

In summary, the SDC placement offered by the District satisfies the requirements under Rowley and the IDEA of offering STUDENT an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, and reasonably calculated to offer STUDENT some educational benefit as well as comporting with STUDENT’s IEP.

ORDER

(1) The District is entitled to implement the program placement and services included in STUDENT’s IEP dated November 20, 2002. (District Exhibit 1)

(2) The District is directed to make the program, placement, and services offered in the IEPs dated November 20, 2002 available to STUDENT. (District Exhibit 1)

(3) All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Respondent Pasadena Unified School District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: February 13, 2003 ______________________________ Heather A. Hoyle, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

FOOTNOTES

1. Attorney Amanda Georgino from the law firm of Lozano Smith attended the first day of the hearing on behalf of the District. 2. Currently STUDENT’s program is a modified version of his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP based on the parties’ agreement to modify what would be STUDENT’s stay put placement during the pendency of these due process hearing procedures. STUDENT’s mother does not allege that this stay put placement is inappropriate or that the District committed procedural errors. Therefore, this Decision will not address any issues regarding procedural appropriateness of STUDENT’s IEPs or STUDENT’s current RSP placement. STUDENT’s schedule provides that STUDENT attend school from 9:00 a.m. to 12:45 p.m. on Mondays and from 10:00 a.m. to 2:00 p.m Tuesday through Friday. 3. At times during the testimony and in the documentary evidence provided, STUDENT’s seizures were described as a complex seizure disorder and severe refractory epilepsy. 4. According to the psycho-educational assessment conducted by the District, dated August 2000, STUDENT attended a regular education kindergarten class operated by the District for the first semester of the 1995-1996 school year, but did not attend the second semester of the kindergarten class. STUDENT’s mother then reenrolled STUDENT in kindergarten for the 1996-1997 school year. 5. Dr. Weigel testified that she has worked with children for the last twenty-five years, and has been employed by the diagnostic center for approximately nineteen years. 6.STUDENT’s mother’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s diet indicated that while he is no longer on the ketogenic diet, he still is receiving special food as she is slowly reintroducing other items into his diet. 7. Ms. Chang testified that she has been employed by the District for twelve years as an RSP teacher and prior to that was a regular education teacher for approximately seventeen years. 8. Ms. Holt testified that she has worked in different capacities for the Diagnostic Center for approximately twenty-five years and has held her current position as director for the last ten years. 9. Ms. Parry testified that she has worked for the District as an adapted physical education teacher for eighteen years 10. Based on the testimony and representations of STUDENT’s mother, her understanding of Dr. Kaplan’s recommendation was that STUDENT be allowed to be in a classroom “preferably without wall to wall carpeting.” However, as Dr. Kaplan did not testify at hearing this apparent discrepancy was not resolved. 11. The Hearing Officer notes that the District indicated in a letter dated January 14, 2003, that an IEP team meeting will be held to discuss the letters from STUDENT’s physicians provided by STUDENT’s mother to determine whether or not any additional changes should be made to STUDENT’s IEP. (Respondent’s Exhibit 74) While the evidence presented during this hearing does not establish that STUDENT requires a specific physical environment to benefit from his education, the Hearing Officer would encourage the District to continue to work together with STUDENT’s parents. As indicated in the Diagnostic Center’s assessment, STUDENT’s parents, the District, and STUDENT’s health care providers must continue to communicate and collaborate to provide an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. (Respondent’s Exhibit 2) 12. There have been numerous IEP team meetings held since May 2002 to discuss STUDENT’s placement. Neither party raised issues regarding the procedural or substantive appropriateness of those IEPs other then STUDENT’s mother’s disagreement with the one APE goal as discussed in this decision Therefore, this decision will not address the appropriateness of the IEPs, other than the APE goal STUDENT’s mother identified as an issue for this hearing. 13. The goals and objectives addressed are those set forth on the November 20, 2002 IEP as well as those developed at STUDENT’s May 30, 2002 IEP. STUDENT’s mother signed both IEPs agreeing to everything except placement. 14. Ms. Knedel testified that she has been employed at the District for twenty-one years and prior to working for the District Ms. Knedel taught at a private school. 15. Ms. Mallon testified that she has been employed by the District for approximately thirty years. She was an SDC teacher for the severely handicapped for twenty-four years and has held her current position for the last five years. Ms. Mallon currently provides support to teachers and expertise in addressing needs of the severely handicapped population and in particular behavioral support. 16. STUDENT’s mother also indicated that she liked the “Big Fun” gymnastics program STUDENT attended and thought it was an ideal placement for STUDENT. However, the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Parry indicated that the program consisted of one-to-one interaction between the coach and STUDENT. Based on Ms. Parry’s observation of the program, STUDENT did not interact with any of the other children that were present in the facility. Despite several attempts by the Hearing Officer to clarify STUDENT’s mother’s position both during discussion of the issues and proposed resolutions for hearing, as well as during her testimony, it is unclear whether or not STUDENT’s mother’s position is that Big Fun is ideal based on her perception of the results of the sessions or the one to one instruction. A one-to-one instructional model would seem at odds with STUDENT’s mother’s repeatedly expressed desire to expose STUDENT to typically developing peers and increase his social skills.