California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 21, 2002

Student v. Anaheim City School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1887-02, SN-1887-02 · Hearing Officer Michael F. Geary

Anaheim City School District must fund speech IEE, add teacher consultation, and offer ESY; most other claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 15 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Footnote 1 states that the decision was amended: wording was added to Issue 2(b), Issue 8 was reframed, "agreed" was changed to "did not agree" on page 8, a discussion of Dr. Dores' October 2002 observations was added, the District's contention on Issue 7C was stated, and the prevailing-party finding on Issue 8 was conformed to the Order. The footnote says these changes do not affect the ultimate findings. The decision also notes the District's earlier related filings, SEHO Case Nos. SN02-01686 and SN02-01719, which the District withdrew.

Summary

The parent of a six-year-old high-functioning autistic boy filed for due process against Anaheim City School District. She claimed the District breached an April 2002 settlement agreement and denied a FAPE in 2001-2002 and 2002-2003. The Hearing Officer held that the settlement's waiver of 2001-2002 compensatory claims barred claims based on events before April 11, 2002, but not later ones. The District did not materially breach the settlement. The parties had used "discrete trial training" (DTT) to describe the individualized instruction the student was actually getting. The failure to use ACES as the provider, and any missed clinic sessions, caused no loss. The District properly made up 11 missed speech sessions by lengthening later sessions. The student made reasonable progress toward his goals. The District's speech-language reassessment was not appropriate. Its report gave little new data and did not explain the recommended cut in services, so the parent was reimbursed for Abby Rozenberg's independent assessment. The OT reassessment was appropriate, so Nancy Press's assessment was not reimbursed. Holding the June 18, 2002 IEP meeting without the mother, who had called that morning wanting to take part, seriously infringed her participation and denied FAPE. No remedy was ordered for that violation. The parent's refusal to attend the September 2002 meeting was not a violation by the District. The September offer denied FAPE because it lacked a weekly speech consultation with the teacher and ESY during month-long intersession breaks. The IEP team must set ESY and make-up services.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled four questions. A settlement waiver did not cover the district's later failures. A reassessment report had to explain the new data and any recommended cut in services. A district had to make real efforts to include a parent who wanted to attend. Federal ESY rules could require services during intersession breaks of a year-round calendar.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue 1. Are the Petitioner's 2001-2002 school year claims barred by the April 2002 settlement agreement?

    The settlement's waiver of 2001-2002 compensatory education claims bars claims based on acts before April 11, 2002, but not claims based on later acts or omissions.

  2. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2a. Did the District materially breach the April 2002 settlement agreement by failing to provide traditional discrete trial training services through ACES?

    The parties used 'DTT' to mean the individualized instruction actually provided, and the District's failure to use ACES as the provider was not a material breach.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2b. Did the District materially breach the April 2002 settlement agreement by failing to provide one and one-half hours per month of clinic sessions through ACES?

    Any failure to provide the clinic sessions was immaterial and de minimis because the parties achieved home-school consistency through informal collaboration.

  4. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 3. Did the District appropriately make up five and one-half hours of missed speech and language services by pulling STUDENT out of his extended-day social skills program and extending his SL sessions?

    Lengthening the remaining SL sessions fully made up the 11 missed sessions, did not substantially change the program, and caused no lost educational benefit.

  5. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Does STUDENT's failure to meet all of his goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year entitle him to relief?

    For the period after April 11, 2002, the District's efforts were appropriate and the student made reasonable progress toward his goals; failure to meet every goal did not show a denial of FAPE.

  6. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year, what is the award?

    No compensatory education was awarded for 2001-2002 because there was no material breach and no other educational loss.

  7. Issue 6a. Is STUDENT's mother entitled to reimbursement for the independent SL assessment?

    The District's speech-language reassessment and report did not meet statutory requirements: it gave limited new data and no written recommendation or reasoning for reducing services, so the parent is reimbursed for the independent assessment.

  8. Issue 6b. Is STUDENT's mother entitled to reimbursement for the independent OT assessment?

    The District's OT reassessment met statutory requirements and included present levels, needs, and a reasoned recommendation; disagreement with the recommendation does not make it inappropriate.

  9. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 7a. Did the District fail to offer a FAPE for 2002-2003 by holding the June 18, 2002 IEP meeting without the parent's participation?

    The District refused to consider postponing, did not respond to the mother's same-day call, and did not include her by phone as it did an ACES provider; this seriously infringed parent participation and denied FAPE, but no remedy was due.

  10. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 7b. Was the September 23, 2002 IEP meeting improperly held without the parent?

    The parent had adequate notice of a date her attorney had said was available and chose not to attend to further litigation interests; there was no violation, and the September 2002 IEP is the operative offer.

  11. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 7c. Were Dr. Dores' October 2002 school observations without parental consent an improper assessment or impermissible discovery?

    The issue is moot because the Hearing Officer did not consider testimony about the observations.

  12. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7d. Did the September 2002 IEP include appropriate SL goals and services?

    The SL goals were appropriate and eliminating individual therapy was appropriate, but the two 30-minute small-group sessions per week had to be supplemented by a 30-minute weekly consultation between the SL specialist and the teacher.

  13. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7e. Did the September 2002 IEP include appropriate OT goals and services?

    The four OT goals and 30 minutes per week of classroom OT consultation were appropriate; a sensory diet and clinic-based sensory integration therapy were not shown to be necessary.

  14. Student prevailedIEP content

    Issue 7f. Did the September 2002 IEP fail to offer needed ESY services?

    Under the federal ESY regulation, there was sufficient risk of regression during month-long intersession breaks to require some services, with the details to be set by the IEP team.

  15. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 8. If there was a denial of FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, is the Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education or other relief?

    No award for the procedural denial or the missing SL consultation because no loss was shown; the IEP team must add compensatory services for the missed first intersession ESY.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. District to reimburse the mother for the cost of the independent speech-language assessment by Abby Rozenberg within 15 calendar days of receiving appropriate documentation (amount not stated).
  • Order to provide or change services. In addition to the SL services in the September 2002 IEP, District shall immediately provide, for the remainder of the current school year, a 30-minute weekly consultation between the SL specialist and the regular teacher.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days, the IEP team shall convene to determine appropriate ESY services and include them in the IEP.
  • Compensatory education. The IEP team shall add services to the student's program to make up for the ESY services he did not receive during the first trimester break; the amount is left to the IEP team.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Casey v. Proctor; City of Manhattan Beach v. Superior Court; Bleecher v. Conte; Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District (SEHO SN99-01048); Student v. Shasta Union High School District (SEHO SN01-00026); Cal. Civil Code § 1542; Cal. Civil Code § 1668; Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 34 C.F.R. § 300.309

People named in the decision

  • Sherry Blakely, Director of special education, Anaheim City School District
  • Nancy Press, Private occupational therapist (independent OT evaluator), Private
  • Carol Owens, District occupational therapist, Anaheim City School District
  • Sylvia Mende, Psychologist; clinical director of ACES, A Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES)
  • Abby Rozenberg, Private speech-language pathologist (independent assessor), Private
  • Dean Paul, District speech and language specialist, Anaheim City School District
  • Kathy Okunami, District speech and language specialist, Anaheim City School District
  • Paul Dores, Private clinical psychologist; independent assessor under the settlement agreement, Private
  • Diane Crecelius, Former ACES therapist responsible for the home program, A Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES)
  • Kristin Farmer, ACES representative at the September 2002 IEP meeting, A Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES)
  • Tammy Root, Home-based behavioral program provider the parent requested
  • Paul Roberts, Student's attorney at the June 2001 IEP meeting, Roberts & Adams
  • A Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES), Nonpublic agency providing the home program and clinic sessions
  • Juarez Elementary School, District school attended for kindergarten, Anaheim City School District
  • Guinn, District school offered for first grade placement, Anaheim City School District

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office or SEHO), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, at the offices of the Anaheim City School District in Anaheim, California, on October 8, 9, 15, 16, 17, and 18, 2002.

REPRESENTATION

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Paul H. Kamoroff of the law firm Roberts & Adams. Petitioner’s mother, Ms. PARENT, was also present.

Respondent Anaheim City School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Lauri A. LaFoe of the law firm Lozano Smith. Sherry Blakely, the director of special education for the District, was also present during most of the hearing.(Footnote 2)

THE RECORD

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Ms. PARENT; Nancy Press, a private occupational therapist; Carol Owens, a District occupational therapist; Sylvia Mende, a psychologist; Abby Rozenberg, a private speech and language pathologist; Dean Paul, a District speech and language specialist; Sherry Blakely; and Kathy Okunami, a District speech and language specialist.

The District put on its testimony by questioning the witnesses called by the Petitioner, by re-calling Ms. Blakely, and by calling Paul Dores, a private psychologist.

The evidence was presented. Closing arguments were heard. The record was closed on October 25, 2002.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Stipulation Regarding 2001-2002 School Year Issues

The District made a motion to dismiss the 2001-2002 school year issues on the grounds that the parties had already settled all such issues in the settlement agreement that was in evidence and that enforcement of the settlement agreement was not a matter that was within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office to decide. The District withdrew the motion before the Hearing Officer issued his ruling. It was agreed that the Hearing Officer would address the issues described below.

Partial Settlement

At the commencement of day three of the hearing, the parties advised the Hearing Officer that they had settled Petitioner’s claim that the District had failed to offer an appropriate afternoon social skills program for the 2002-2003 school year. In essence, the Petitioner accepted the offer of a social skills program that was contained in the September 2002 IEP.

ISSUES (Footnote 3)

1. Are the Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims barred by the April 2002 settlement agreement?

2. If the Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims are not barred, did the District materially breach the April 2002 settlement agreement by (a) failing to provide traditional discrete trial training services through ACES; and (b) failing to provide one and one-half hours per month of clinic sessions through ACES?(Footnote 4) 3. Did the District appropriately make up five and one-half hours of missed speech and language services by pulling STUDENT out of his extended-day social skills program for approximately twenty minutes four times weekly and extending STUDENT’s speech and language (SL) session accordingly?

4. Does STUDENT’s failure to meet all of his goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year entitle him to relief?

5. If STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year, what is the award?

6. Is STUDENT’s mother entitled to reimbursement for the independent SL and occupational therapy (OT) assessments?

7. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year?

8. If STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2002-2003 school year, what is the award?

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a six-year-old (DOB [date redacted]) high-functioning autistic boy who lives with his mother, PARENT, and his autistic twin brother, BROTHER, within the geographical boundaries of the District.

STUDENT attended Juarez Elementary School (Juarez) within the District during his kindergarten year, 2001-2002. His June 12, 2001 IEP was developed with the participation of his mother, Ms. PARENT, and his attorney, Paul Roberts. At the time of the June 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s present levels of performance revealed weaknesses in the areas of fine motor, social and behavioral skills, receptive and expressive communication, upper extremity strength and auditory processing. According to the IEP documents, STUDENT had not met all of his social goals during the prior year. Several were continued.

STUDENT’s IEP for the 2001-2002 school year included: (1) SL services twice weekly for thirty minutes in an individual session and twice weekly for thirty minutes in a group session, (2) OT twice weekly for forty-five minutes in clinic, and (3) OT consultation once monthly for thirty minutes in the classroom. STUDENT also was to participate in a three-hour extended-day program in the afternoons at Juarez. The program would consist primarily of social/play opportunities in various contexts but would also include sixty minutes of discrete trial training (DTT). The District also proposed that the OT clinic and the extended-day program continue during the last two weeks of the intersession break in July and August 2001 but that the OT clinic only continue during the shorter breaks in October-November 2001 and February-March 2002. Ms. PARENT wanted a home-based behavioral program for STUDENT provided by Tammy Root during the entire intersession break. Seventeen goals were developed for the 2001-2002 school year. There were two designated as fine motor goals, two designated as social goals, one goal focusing on upper extremity strength, two focusing on behavioral issues, one auditory processing goal, and nine SL goals that addressed STUDENT’s needs in the areas of syntax and pragmatics. Ms. PARENT agreed to implementation of the IEP with the goals and objectives as written.

Disputes regarding STUDENT’s program ultimately resulted in the filing by the District of a due process matter seeking a determination that it had offered a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. In early April 2002, the parties entered into a settlement agreement to resolve the disputes. The agreement provided that Paul Dores, a licensed psychologist, would be hired to conduct an independent educational assessment of STUDENT at the District’s expense. The results of Dr. Dores’ assessment were to be presented at an IEP meeting. The agreement also purported to settle the parties’ disputes regarding STUDENT’s extended-day social skills program and home program, as well as STUDENT’s claims to compensatory education for the 2001-2002 and prior school years.

Paul Dores, a clinical psychologist with extensive experience dealing with the needs, educational and otherwise, of autistic individuals, began his independent assessment in mid-April. From approximately April 17 to May 17, 2002, he reviewed some of STUDENT’s records, observed him twice in his home and twice in his school environment, and interviewed his mother and the people involved in his care and education. He did not administer any tests.

Dr. Dores believed that STUDENT’s regular education placement was appropriate, but he believed that in his first grade placement the following year STUDENT would benefit from additional support and structure to help him to improve in four primary areas: attention, independence, behavior, and social skills/peer interaction. He was of the opinion that STUDENT did not need DTT, and he explained that neither the home-based nor the school-based program was providing DTT in any event. He characterized those services as being more akin to individualized instruction than to traditional DTT.(Footnote 5) In his opinion, the services that were being provided were clearly of benefit to STUDENT.(Footnote 6) However, he also noted that such individualized instruction was generally recommended only when appropriate instruction could not be effectively delivered to the child in the regular school environment or when such school-based services needed to be supplemented. He did not believe that was true in STUDENT’s case. According to Dr. Dores, if the goal of the service was to increase the benefit to STUDENT from the “inclusion” experience, the focus should be on school-based social skills training and behavior management. He believed that continued individualized instruction in any environment, home or school, could be counterproductive.

STUDENT was supposed to be receiving SL services from District SL specialist Dean Paul. Eleven sessions were missed in April and May 2002 due to Ms. Paul’s absence. No substitute therapist was offered. On May 28, 2002, the District wrote to Ms. PARENT to inform her that the missed sessions would be made up by tacking fifteen minutes to twenty of the remaining sessions and thirty minutes to one of the remaining sessions. Ms. PARENT objected to this arrangement, preferring that the time be made up in some other way. The District made up the missed time by tacking time on to the remaining sessions. In doing so, STUDENT lost an equivalent amount of time from some aspect of his extended-day social skills program.

Diane Crecelius, formerly an employee of A Comprehensive Educational Services (ACES), was one of those responsible for developing and implementing STUDENT’s home program. In her report of June 10, 2002, Ms. Crecelius noted that there continued to be a number of weaknesses that were impacting STUDENT’s progress in the areas of pragmatic language and social skills. These included his rigid and controlling behavior within activities and his difficulties reading social and contextual cues, sensing information from his environment, predicting outcomes, reading the gestures, tone or mood of others, self-regulating, and problem solving.

On June 11, 2002, Dean Paul, who had been working with STUDENT for two and one-half years, conducted her reassessment of him. According to her report, STUDENT’s above-average test scores showed growth when compared to results from the same test administered a year prior. Ms. Paul found that STUDENT was weak in his ability to correctly use irregular verbs, comparatives and superlatives and that he continued to show below-average ability in his social and functional use of language in play.

On June 12, 2002, STUDENT underwent an OT reassessment by District therapist Carol Owens in the areas of sensory processing and adaptive behavior. She found that STUDENT achieved seventy-five percent of his OT goals for the 2001-2002 school year in the areas of fine motor strength and control, handwriting, social initiation, and auditory hypersensitivity. Ms. Owens noted that, although there was an increase in strength overall, STUDENT continued to exhibit deficiencies in upper extremity strength and muscle tone.

The assessment survey data provided by STUDENT’s aide and Ms. PARENT suggested that STUDENT had some level of continuing needs in the following areas: auditory processing, vestibular processing, oral sensory processing, independent functioning, self direction, responsibility, socialization, and conformity. Ms. Owens concluded that STUDENT had received the maximum benefit from clinic-based OT. She recommended that he be discharged and that his OT program consist solely of classroom consultation in the areas of handwriting, strengthening and sensory regulation as it relates to classroom performance.

STUDENT’s next IEP meeting was begun on June 12, 2002. This was a triennial review. It was attended by all appropriate District personnel, a representative of the Regional Center, Diane Crecelius (ACES), Ms. PARENT, and lawyers representing both parties.

At the meeting on June 12, 2002, Dr. Dores presented his report and findings and emphasized that STUDENT would need to develop improved attention, independence, behavior control, and social skills if he was to be successful in later grades as the curriculum became more demanding. He also questioned the role of the home program in view of the unanimous opinion of the IEP team that STUDENT needed to work on social skills, attention to teacher’s instruction, and progress in the general curriculum. Diane Crecelius, Dean Paul, Carol Owens and the District psychologist presented the results of their respective observations and assessments. The team identified the following potential areas of need: hand strength, self-regulation, social skills, behavior, pragmatic language, syntax, head/ear hypersensitivity, reading contextual cues, problem solving, flexibility and self-help in relation to appropriate clothing. The meeting was continued by agreement of the parties to June 18, 2002, at 2:30 p.m. In the interim, draft goals and objectives were developed by the District and Diane Crecelius, who shared them with Ms. PARENT before the continued IEP meeting.

On Friday, June 14, 2002, at 5:36 p.m., the Petitioner’s attorney faxed a letter to the District’s attorney stating that the June 18 date for the continued IEP meeting was “no longer convenient for Ms. PARENT or [her attorney’s] office” and requesting that it be rescheduled. No proposed new date was provided. The District’s attorney responded by letter dated June 17, 2002, explaining that the June 18 date had been agreed-upon and the meeting would go forward due to the limited time available for a rescheduled meeting before the end of the school term on or about June 27, 2002. There was another exchange of letters between counsel. The last correspondence from the District was dated June 18, 2002, and was faxed at 9:48 that morning with a copy to Ms. Blakely. That letter encouraged Ms. PARENT and her attorney to attend by telephone, if possible, and offered to arrange for the telephone conference.

According to Ms. PARENT, she had already called Ms. Blakely directly between 8:00 and 8:30 a.m. on June 18, 2002, because she had been advised that the District planned to go forward with the IEP meeting and she wanted to participate. Ms. Blakely was unavailable, so Ms. PARENT asked her secretary to have Ms. Blakely call her back. According to Ms. Blakely, she was out of her office all day and did not get the message that Ms. PARENT had called until 5:30 p.m., after the meeting had been concluded.

The continued IEP meeting convened at 3:00 p.m. on June 18, 2002, in the absence of STUDENT’s mother. The team confirmed the earlier communication between counsel and that Ms. PARENT and her attorney had been invited to attend by telephone, but there was no effort to contact Ms. PARENT or her attorney in the course of the meeting to include them in the deliberations. However, there was an effort to include Diane Crecelius in the meeting by telephone pursuant to her request left on Ms. Blakely’s voice mail.(Footnote 7)

Ms. Crecelius’s voice mail message to Ms. Blakely contained some detail regarding suggested modifications to the IEP that were purportedly based upon her thoughts and input from STUDENT’s mother. The team heard the message, then relocated to Ms. Blakely’s office to allow Ms. Crecelius to participate in the deliberation by conference call.

The IEP meeting that concluded on June 18, 2002, resulted in an offer to STUDENT of “full inclusion” in the general education first grade classroom with special day class support, SL for thirty minutes twice weekly, OT consultation in the classroom for thirty minutes once a week, and a morning social skills class from 7:45 a.m. to 8:30 a.m. The IEP contained seventeen goals that addressed STUDENT’s needs in the areas of SL (syntax and pragmatics), OT (upper extremity/hand strength, self-regulation and sensory defensiveness), problem solving, independent living skills (safety/reasoning and following instructions), attention, social and social/emotional. It included no extended school year (ESY) services.

On June 21, 2002, STUDENT filed a compliance complaint with CDE asserting that the District had denied his parent the opportunity to fully participate in the IEP process. On July 10, 2002, STUDENT’s attorney sent letters to the District stating his client’s disagreement with the District’s SL and OT assessments and requesting independent assessments in both areas at the District’s expense. There was no evidence of a District response to the request. But on July 24, 2002, the District filed for due process, seeking determinations that it had offered a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year, that its June 2002 SL and OT assessments were appropriate, that the District was not required to pay for STUDENT’s independent assessments, and that STUDENT was not entitled to an award of compensatory education for SL services missed during the 2001-2002 school year. That filing became SEHO Case No. SN02-01719.(Footnote 9)

Abby Rozenberg, the Petitioner’s independent speech and language pathologist, conducted her assessment of STUDENT over three hours on July 29 and 31, 2002, at STUDENT’s home. The assessment revealed what Ms. Rozenberg characterized as low-average expressive language skills, moderate-to-severe deficiencies in receptive language, and a significant weakness in auditory processing. She also found that STUDENT tended to be echolalic and to use scripted speech in social and instructional contexts.

On August 1, 2002, Nancy Press conducted an independent OT educational evaluation on STUDENT at the request of his mother. She did not administer tests but relied upon observation and clinical evaluation. Ms. Press found that STUDENT had some difficulties with tactile hypersensitivity around the head and deficits in the areas of vestibular function (head acceleration and position and gravity), proprioception (spatial orientation and rate and timing of movement), and auditory hypersensitivity for loud, unexpected noises. She recommended one hundred twenty minutes per week of clinic-based OT for a sensory integration program, a sensory diet, and adaptive physical education. A hearing was commenced in the District’s case on August 15, 2002. The same parties and law firms were involved. The District withdrew the FAPE issue following unsuccessful settlement discussions, and offered to hold another IEP meeting to allow Ms. PARENT to participate more fully in the process. The hearing was continued to the following day, when STUDENT’s attorney advised the then presiding hearing officer that STUDENT had filed his own case. He requested that the matters be consolidated and continued. The motion to continue was granted.

The hearing on STUDENT’s filing was initially set to commence on September 5, 2002. On August 21, 2002, the District withdrew its hearing request in Case No. SN02-01719. On August 19, 2002, District’s counsel sent a letter to STUDENT’s attorney proposing to convene an IEP meeting before the end of the month and the next scheduled hearing date. The Petitioner’s attorney did not agree on a date for that meeting in August. The parties agreed to set the meeting for September 23, 2002, at 9:30 a.m.

STUDENT’s case convened for hearing on September 5 and 6, 2002. However, no testimony was taken. The matter was continued to October 8, 2002.

An IEP meeting was convened on September 23, 2002. District representatives and a representative from ACES (Kristin Farmer) were present. Sylvia Mende, the clinical director of ACES, participated by telephone. No one attended for STUDENT. Ms. PARENT testified that she refused to participate on the advice of counsel. The team participants reviewed and considered the independent assessment reports of Ms. Rozenberg and Ms. Press. Modifications were made to the goals that had been recommended at the last IEP meeting. Several had different current and target achievement levels. Some had minor changes in the language of the goal or one or more of the objectives. A social/emotional goal was eliminated and another social goal was added. Generally, the goals addressed the same needs as those in the June 2002 IEP.

The District’s September 2002 offer to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year is as follows: (1) placement in the general education first grade class at Guinn with a shadow aide; (2) SL services at the school for thirty minutes twice weekly in a small-group setting; (3) OT consultation only for thirty minutes weekly in the classroom; and (4) an afternoon social skills program at Guinn with transition from the home-based program. No other home-based or school-based program or service was offered. The District did not offer ESY services.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Are the Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims barred by the April 2002 settlement agreement?

The District contends that the Petitioner waived all claims to compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year, including those that may have arisen from acts or omissions occurring after execution of the settlement agreement. It points to the Petitioner’s acknowledgment that placement and services “described above” constitute a FAPE and argues that this language demonstrates the parties’ intention to settle all FAPE issues through the date of the IEP meeting that was to take place after the assessment by Dr. Dores. The Petitioner asserts that the settlement agreement does not bar his claims because they were not yet ripe or known at the time the agreement was executed and the agreement contained no release of unknown claims and was nothing more than a general release as defined in California Civil Code § 1542.(Footnote 9)

The claims that STUDENT seeks to assert here are not claims which he did not “know or suspect to exist in his favor at the time of executing the release.” They were claims that did not exist when the release was executed. A careful reading of the statute and a review of the cases interpreting and applying it confirm that Civil Code § 1542 was intended to protect victims from the effect of an unintentional waiver of a claim which existed but of which they were unaware when signing the release. (See: Casey v Proctor (1963) 59 Cal 2d 97, 28 Cal Rptr 307, 378 P2d 579). The statute does not apply to the facts presented here.

The settlement agreement contains a waiver by Petitioner of “any and all claims for compensatory education for the . . . 2001-2002 school year.” The Hearing Officer must determine what the parties meant by that language. In doing so, he will attempt to “ascertain and carry out the intention of the parties.” City of Manhattan Beach v. Superior Court, 914 P.2d 160, 164 (1996), cert. denied, 117 S.Ct. 511 (1996).

An interpretation of the waiver to include claims for acts or omissions that had not yet occurred would suggest that the District intended to exculpate itself from its future failures to provide a FAPE to STUDENT. That would be tantamount to an agreement to exempt the District from responsibility for violations of law. Such an agreement would be illegal. California Civil Code § 1668. The Hearing Officer is reluctant to conclude that the District intended that the waiver language would bar the instant claim of Petitioner, since that intent would, in effect, make the District’s promises to deliver the services illusory and destroy the mutuality of the obligation and with that, the agreement. Bleecher v. Conte (1981) 29 C.3d 345, 350, 352, 213. Furthermore, if the Hearing Officer accepted the District’s interpretation, a settling party would be able to breach a settlement agreement with impunity as long as there was similar waiver language in the agreement. This would have the effect of discouraging settlements.

The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s waiver of all claims to compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year bars all of the Petitioner’s claims that he sustained some educational loss as the result of acts or omissions by the District that occurred before the settlement agreement was executed on Petitioner’s behalf on April 11, 2002. It does not bar claims that rest on acts or omissions occurring after that date.

Issue No. 2: To the extent that Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims are not barred by the April 2002 settlement agreement, did the District materially breach the agreement?

Petitioner contends that the District materially breached the settlement agreement by failing to provide traditional DTT services through ACES. He also alleges that the District materially breached the settlement agreement by failing to provide one and one-half hours per month of clinic sessions by ACES.(Footnote 10)

(a) Did the District materially breach the settlement agreement by failing to provide traditional discrete trial training services by ACES?

There are two parts to this claim. The Petitioner alleges that the District failed to provide five hours of traditional DTT. He claims that the service that was provided was not DTT. The Petitioner also asserts that the service that was provided was not provided by ACES as required by the agreement. He contends that both failures were material breaches of the settlement agreement. The District essentially admits that traditional DTT services were not provided and that ACES did not provide the school program. However, it asserts that neither of these was a material breach warranting relief. The District further claims that it substantially performed its obligations by providing the service that STUDENT actually needed to benefit from his educational program and that was consistent with the home-based program provided by ACES.

Traditional DTT

The Hearing Officer must determine what the parties meant by the description “discrete trial training (DTT).” In this case, the settlement agreement itself does not further define the term or provide any specific information regarding the kind of therapy contemplated by the parties. However, other evidence showed that the parties used the term “DTT” to describe the kind of service that Dr. Dores observed at home and at school, services that he described as a kind of individualized tutorial instruction. For example, the parties use the term “DTT” in the settlement agreement to describe the services that were being provided to STUDENT at home and at school months before the settlement agreement was executed. The evidence indicates that these services were of the same general type observed by Dr. Dores. The same term was used by the parties to describe similar services as early as 2001.

Diane Crecelius, who worked closely with the Petitioner and was his preferred provider, knew that the settlement agreement called for DTT. Ms. Blakely sent a copy of the settlement agreement to ACES, and Ms. Crecelius was in charge of STUDENT’s home program. According to Ms. Paul, Ms. Crecelius also knew what was being done at school. It is clear that Ms. Crecelius was aware that the services were not traditional DTT. In her report of June 10, 2002, Ms. Crecelius never uses the term DTT to describe any part of STUDENT’s current or recommended program.

Ms. PARENT testified that she considered “DTT” to be an important part of STUDENT’s program when the settlement agreement was negotiated. Although she did not state that she was referring to a service different than those that had been provided to STUDENT for months before the negotiations. If it was her intent to indicate that traditional DTT was an important part of STUDENT’s program at the time of the negotiations, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded. Although the Hearing Officer was persuaded that STUDENT’s mother believed that services of the type then being provided by ACES were an important part of STUDENT’s program, those were not traditional DTT. Furthermore, STUDENT’s mother was always aware that the services being provided were not traditional DTT, but never expressed any concern about it until after Dr. Dores mentioned the distinction in his report.

The Hearing Officer finds that the program that was provided to STUDENT at home and at school was the kind of program contemplated by the parties at the time of the settlement agreement. The Hearing Officer specifically finds that the parties did not use the term “discrete trial training (DTT)” in the settlement agreement to describe a traditional DTT methodology, but used it to describe the kind of individualized tutorial instruction that had been consistently referred to as “DTT” by the parties and the service providers before and after the settlement agreement was executed. STUDENT received the services his mother and attorney bargained for in the settlement agreement. The services provided by the District were consistent with the intent of the parties and in compliance with the settlement agreement. The delivery of those services was not a breach of the agreement and no remedy is due.

Provided by ACES

The agreement stated that the “DTT” services would be provided by ACES. There is no question that the parties intended that ACES would be the provider of the service. The District admits the breach. The question is whether it was a material breach.

The parties agreed that one of the primary reasons for insisting that ACES deliver the “DTT” services was to ensure consistency between the home-based and school-based programs. The Petitioner was also concerned about the qualifications of the provider. He argued that the provision of DTT required training that Dean Paul did not have.

By all accounts consistency between the home and school programs was achieved through collaboration between District and ACES staff. There was no evidence to support the Petitioner’s claim that the District’s staff was not qualified to deliver the service that was actually provided. According to Dr. Dores, who observed both programs, the services that were being delivered in the two environments were consistent and appropriate, and STUDENT was doing well in both. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Nor was there any evidence to show that STUDENT sustained any loss as a result of the District’s failure to provide the services through ACES. Finally, Petitioner did not argue for any remedy to compensate for this failure The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide the “DTT” services through ACES was not a material breach. No remedy is due.

(b) Did the District materially breach the settlement agreement by failing to provide one and one-half hours per month of clinic sessions through ACES?

The settlement agreement states that the District will provide one and one-half hours per month of clinic sessions by ACES at home and/or at school. The Petitioner claims that this was not done. The District claims that it was done.

The parties agreed that the primary purpose of the clinic sessions was to ensure consistency of STUDENT’s program across all environments. Ms. PARENT testified that the use of ACES for this purpose was a significant term of the settlement. Diane Crecelius, the ACES therapist until July 2002, was not available to testify. The current ACES clinical director, Dr. Sylvia Mende, testified to her records about the clinic sessions. She stated that Ms. Crecelius attended a clinic session that was provided at the school by school staff in May 2002. This session was provided by District personnel. The records also showed that there were other visits to the school by Ms. Crecelius, including three meetings between Ms. Crecelius and Ms. Paul, but nothing to indicate that ACES provided clinic sessions at the school before September 26, 2002, when Dr. Mende provided one.

According to a January 3, 2002 letter from Petitioner’s attorney to the District’s attorneys, Ms. PARENT specifically requested that the clinic meetings take place in her home. Dr. Mende testified that ACES did provide clinic sessions at home. These sessions were provided during the evening when school staff usually could not attend. The choice of timing of those sessions would clearly not have been the District’s. Dr. Mende did not say how many hours of clinic sessions were provided at all locations after the April 2002 settlement agreement. Nor did the District offer evidence of the amount of time billed to it by ACES for provision of these clinics.

It was clear from the evidence that the parties were able to achieve their intended result, consistency between the home and school programs, through less formal collaboration than the clinic sessions. Considering that what is at stake here is, at most, four and one-half hours of clinic sessions, the need for which has been obviated by the parties’ agreement to phase out STUDENT’s DTT and entire home program, the claimed loss, if any, is de minimus. If there was a breach, it has become inconsequential. The Hearing Officer finds that if the District breached the settlement agreement by failing to provide the clinic sessions as alleged, that breach was immaterial.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any material breach of the settlement agreement. Therefore, no remedy is due.

Issue No. 3 Did the District appropriately make up five and one-half hours of missed speech and language services by pulling STUDENT out of his extended-day social skills program for approximately twenty minutes four times weekly and extending STUDENT’s SL session accordingly?

The District agreed to provide SL services in STUDENT’s June 2001 IEP. That obligation remained until the end of the school term on or about June 27, 2002, or as extended by the stay put doctrine. The District admits that it failed to provide eleven SL sessions to STUDENT over a period of approximately five weeks in April and May 2002 while Ms. Paul was on vacation. However, the District made up all of the missed SL time by the end of the 2001-2002 school year.

The Petitioner alleges that the way that the District made up the missed sessions was inappropriate and resulted in a compensable loss of educational opportunity. He asserts that the plan to make up the missed sessions constituted a change in his program that required an IEP meeting and the participation and consent of Ms. PARENT, neither of which occurred. He also contends that the altered program for delivery of the missed SL services did not comport with his IEP because the SL session was twenty minutes longer and the social skills program was twenty minutes shorter on each day adjusted. The District contends that its plan to make up missed DIS did not result in a substantial change in STUDENT’s program and that it was not required to obtain the parent’s consent before implementing the plan.

According to the testimony of Ms. PARENT and Ms. Blakely, the District informed STUDENT’s mother that it would make up the missed sessions by adding time to the SL sessions that remained for the school year.(Footnote 11) Ms. PARENT objected. She was concerned about STUDENT’s attention and ability to benefit from the additional time and about his missing some other part of the social skills class. Ms. PARENT discussed her concerns with Ms. Blakely, who decided not to use an alternative therapist when she had difficulty finding one and because she ultimately concluded that it was not in STUDENT’s best interests to use a therapist with whom he was unfamiliar.

Missed DIS is not an uncommon event. If a service is missed, the district should exercise reasonable diligence to make it up. That is what occurred in this case. The District’s effort to make up the missed SL service did not substantially change STUDENT’s program. Ms. Paul, who administered the extended SL sessions, testified that STUDENT was able to attend throughout and benefited appropriately. There was no contradictory evidence. There was also no evidence that STUDENT lost any significant educational benefit as a result of being pulled out of his social skills program.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately and fully compensated STUDENT for the missed SL sessions. Therefore, no remedy is due. Issue No 4: Does STUDENT’s failure to meet all of his SL and OT goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year entitle him to relief?

Petitioner alleges that he failed to meet most of his goals for the 2001-2002 school year. He claims that this is evidence that his program was not appropriate. The District argues that the law does not require that the goals be met. The Hearing Officer has already held that this claim is barred to the extent that it depends upon alleged acts or omissions by the District that occurred before execution of the settlement agreement on April 11, 2002. The Hearing Officer must limit his examination accordingly.

The District is not strictly accountable for STUDENT’s failure to achieve his goals and objectives. 34 C.F.R. § 300.350. In essence, STUDENT’s program should have been designed to help him to “advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals” and be involved and progress in the general curriculum and participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with other disabled and typically developing peers. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).

The Petitioner cited a prior SEHO decision, Student v. Colton Joint Unified School District Case No. SN99-01048, in support of his argument that the lack of demonstrable progress toward goals and objectives is indicative of the failure of the District’s program to provide an educational benefit to STUDENT. In Colton, the hearing officer observed that a student’s failure to make any reasonable progress toward annual goals can be persuasive evidence that an IEP does not provide appropriate educational benefit. The Hearing Officer does not find that to be the case here.

Although STUDENT did not meet all of his goals, the witnesses generally agreed that he made progress toward most of them. The amount of progress was disputed. Ms. Paul testified that STUDENT made substantial progress toward all of his SL goals. Ms. Rozenberg disagreed, stating that STUDENT had not met even the first short-term objective for at least three of his nine SL goals. Ms. Owens testified that STUDENT achieved seventy-five percent on all of his OT goals. Ms. Press disagreed, stating at one point that STUDENT had not achieved any of the short-term objectives for two of the OT goals. However, she later testified that STUDENT had made some progress on all goals except that there had been no improvement in his ability to snap fasteners together. The Hearing Officer gave greater weight to the testimony of the District’s witnesses who based their opinions of STUDENT’s progress on months and years of personal knowledge of the skills that STUDENT demonstrates in familiar situations. The Hearing Officer also took into consideration the fact that the Petitioner knowingly waived his claim to compensatory education for all but a part of the last trimester. He finds that the District’s effort after April 11, 2002 to help STUDENT to achieve his annual goals was appropriate and that STUDENT made reasonable progress toward those goals during that time. There is no remedy due on this claim.

Issue No. 5: If STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year, what is the award?

The Hearing Officer has determined that there was no material breach of the settlement agreement by the District and no other educational loss that would warrant an award of compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT is not entitled to an award of compensatory compensation for alleged loss sustained during that year.

Issue No. 6: Is STUDENT’s mother entitled to reimbursement for the independent SL and OT assessments obtained by her?

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with assessment done by the school district. The school district must either pay for the independent assessment or seek a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The Hearing Office has generally held that a district’s assessment is appropriate if it complies with the statutory and regulatory requirements. Student v. Shasta Union High School District (SEHO 2001) SN01-00026, 34 IDELR 139. The Hearing Officer looks at the District’s reassessments of STUDENT in the areas of SL and OT to determine whether they met the statutory requirements.

Speech and Language Assessment

The Petitioner alleges that the District failed to appropriately reassess STUDENT for SL needs. He asserts that the reassessment was not sufficiently broad in scope and that the testing instruments were not appropriate. The District defends its reassessment.

A reassessment is not to be judged by the same standard as an initial assessment. The latter is an effort to determine all areas of need so those can be appropriately addressed in the student’s IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Reassessments do not require that the student be assessed in all areas related to his suspected disability. Rather, the clear intent of the reassessment statute is to ensure that the IEP team has the information it needs to determine, among other things, the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs and whether additions or modifications to the student’s program are required to provide a FAPE. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b).(Footnote 12) A reassessment may be narrowly focused to obtain specific information. The question is whether the reassessment produced the required additional data, if any.

Ms. Rozenberg was critical of the District’s SL reassessment. She testified that the tests used by Ms. Paul are preliminary screening tests only and that she would not administer those tests to an autistic child. In her opinion, the tests used are not sensitive to specific SL deficits. Ms. Rozenberg stated that the instruments used by the District did not adequately reassess for any area of need except for a minor aspect of pragmatic speech. She was also generally critical of Ms. Paul’s report because she believed it did not contain adequate identifying, historical and diagnostic data, a measure of functional communication, behavioral observations, prognosis, or recommendations.

District SL specialist Dean Paul defended her reassessment of STUDENT. Although the District’s counsel systematically walked Ms. Paul through all of the statutory elements of an appropriate assessment, there was no evidence to show what additional data, if any, was required, how the reassessment sought to obtain that required data, or that the required additional data was obtained. Ms. Paul administered the same basic tests that she had administered the year before and determined that STUDENT’s skills had improved and that he was performing at least within the average range. The test results may have provided some data concerning STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas tested, but it was not clear how this data alone sufficed to help the IEP team to conduct an appropriate triennial review of STUDENT’s program and determine that a reduction of SL services was warranted.

Taking into consideration Ms. Paul’s admitted failure to document STUDENT’s progress toward his SL goals either in periodic progress reports or in her report of her reassessment, and the limited additional data contained in her reassessment report, the Hearing Officer was not persuaded that the SL reassessment met the statutory requirements.

The Hearing Officer recognizes that it was the intent of Ms. Paul to present her report and findings to the IEP team. This did not excuse her from the statutory requirement that an adequate written report be provided. In the case of a reassessment, the report should at least contain reference to the additional data sought by the reassessment.(Footnote 13) The Hearing Officer is persuaded by his reading of the pertinent statutes that the person responsible for conducting the reassessment should specifically describe in a written report the additional data that the IEP team members, including the parent, require to understand the student’s present levels of performance and educational needs, as well as the assessor’s recommendations regarding whether additions or modifications to the student’s program are required to provide a FAPE.(Footnote 14)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Paul’s report was lacking. Aside from reporting test scores and indicating that STUDENT was observed to demonstrate continuing below average ability in his social and functional use of language, it contains little of the information required by law. The information is not adequate to allow an IEP team member to fully participate in the deliberations regarding STUDENT’s SL services. Ms. Paul testified that she recommended the reduction in SL services. Her written report should have contained that recommendation and at least some explanation of her rationale.

The Hearing Officer finds that the SL assessment by Ms. Paul was not appropriate. Therefore, Petitioner’s mother is entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by Abby Rozenberg.

Occupational Therapy Assessment

The Petitioner also contends that the OT reassessment was inappropriate. Although his arguments focused on whether STUDENT was assessed in all areas related to his suspected disability and whether Ms. Owens’ recommendations were consistent with her findings, the OT reassessment must be judged by the same standard used to determine the appropriateness of the SL reassessment. The District defends its assessment as appropriate.

The Petitioner’s independent occupational therapist, Nancy Press, had few significant criticisms of the District’s reassessment. She generally agreed with Ms. Owens’ use of the standardized assessments and with the results of those assessments. She described the District’s OT report as thorough but vague and lacking in detail regarding gross motor and visual deficits. She was also critical of the absence of specific testing for STUDENT’s proprioceptive and kinesthetic needs. However, Ms. Press’s main disagreement was with Ms. Owens’ recommendations. Ms. Owens recommended that STUDENT be discharged from direct services and that he receive only OT consultation in his classroom once weekly for thirty minutes. Ms. Press believes that STUDENT requires direct OT services in a clinic for sixty minutes twice weekly.

There was no credible challenge to the District’s compliance with the statutory requirements for an OT reassessment.(Footnote 15) Ms. Owens’ report contains the information concerning present levels of performance and current educational needs that the IEP team would need to consider in determining whether modifications or additions to STUDENT’s IEP would be required to provide a FAPE. It also contains her recommendation and rationale.

The Petitioner disagrees with Ms. Owens’ recommendation and rationale. He argues that it is inappropriate to recommend a reduction in services, the elimination of direct, individual OT, when so many areas of need remain evident. That kind of difference of opinion does not render an assessment “inappropriate,” as that term is used in Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). The Hearing Officer finds that the OT assessment conducted by the District complied with the statutory requirements and was appropriate. The Petitioner’s parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent assessment by Nancy Press.

Issue No. 7: Did the District fail to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year?

Under both State special education law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed education, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. §1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).

The United States Supreme Court has held that a "free appropriate public education" consists of educational instruction specially designed to meet the unique needs of the disabled child, supported by such services as are necessary to permit the child "to benefit" from the instruction. Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et .al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 188-189. It is not necessary for the child’s program to maximize the educational opportunities or put them on a par with the opportunities provided to typically developing students. What is required is that the disabled student be provided with access to a FAPE that is “sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child.” Id. at 200-201. Pursuant to Rowley, a proposed program must meet three requirements in order to constitute an appropriate educational program. It must (1) have been designed to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit; and (3) comported with the student’s IEP.(Footnote 16)

Rowley also recognized that the IDEA reflects the desire of Congress to ensure that there are procedural protections afforded the student and parents that will allow for effective participation in the IEP process. The Court notes that parents can be the most ardent advocates for their children, and that their full participation can be the best way to ensure that all appropriate services are being offered to the handicapped child. The analysis must be two-pronged. First, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA, which are designed to allow and encourage the full participation of the parents. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. A procedural flaw must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process to result in the denial of a FAPE. Second, the Hearing Officer must look at the IEP and placement offer which were a result of those procedures to determine whether they meet the substantive requirement for a FAPE, including the requirement that they meet the unique needs of the child. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; See also: W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484. The District has the burden of proof on both prongs of the analysis. Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, (9th Cir. 1994) 35 F.3d 1396, 1398.

Did the District Comply with the Procedural Requirements of the IDEA?

One of the underpinnings of the IDEA was the intent of Congress to strengthen the role of parents by providing them with a meaningful opportunity to participate in the education of their children. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(B). One or both parents are to be included on an IEP team. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56341(b)(1) and 56342.5. The IEP team is required to address, among other matters, information about the student provided to or by the parents. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56341.1(d)(3) and 56881(b). The parent has the right to present information to the team in person or through a representative regarding recommendations and program planning. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.1(e).

The law provides that the district “shall take steps to ensure that one or both parents . . . are present at each [IEP] meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). The statute requires that the district use other methods to ensure parent participation, including telephone conference calls, when the parent is unable to attend personally. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f).

The law does allow for IEP meetings without the participation of a parent, but the language of the statute makes clear that this is an exception to the rule and should not occur unless the local educational agency “is unable to convince the parent that he or she should attend;” and even then the LEA must carefully document its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed-upon date and time. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).

June 18, 2002 IEP Meeting

Ms. Blakely was aware of the parent’s request for a postponement, but she did nothing to arrange for one. She testified that the term was coming to an end the following week and it was necessary that the IEP be completed before the beginning of the next term in early August. The Hearing Officer is unaware of a requirement that a district must develop and offer an IEP to the student by the end of the preceding school year. Even if this timing is desirable as a practical matter, that practical necessity does not outweigh the importance of parental participation. The District refused to even consider the request for a postponement. This alone was unreasonable under the circumstances.

It is of particular concern to the Hearing Officer that Ms. PARENT called Ms. Blakely on the day of the meeting hours before the meeting was to take place. STUDENT’s mother testified that she was “desperate” to participate, even against the advice of STUDENT’s attorney. She left a message with Ms. Blakely’s secretary requesting a return call, but Ms. Blakely did not get the message until approximately 5:30 p.m. that day, long after the meeting had concluded. It is clear from the testimony that Ms. Blakely did not alert her secretary to the possibility of an urgent message from Ms. PARENT. Greater effort should have been taken to ensure that the parent’s communication with the District and participation at the meeting would be facilitated. Ms. Blakely managed to retrieve a voicemail message regarding the IEP meeting from Ms. Crecelius and conduct a telephone conference involving Ms. Crecelius and other team members. There was no reasonable explanation offered by the District regarding why the same effort was not used to facilitate the communication with and the participation of Ms. PARENT.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to take reasonable steps to allow STUDENT’s mother to fully participate in the development of the June 2002 IEP. This was a violation of the rights guaranteed to STUDENT and his mother by the IDEA. It resulted in a serious infringement on Ms. PARENT’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process and a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT. However, as discussed below, no remedy is due because STUDENT continued to receive services pursuant to the agreement of the parties.

September 23, 2002 IEP Meeting

The circumstances surrounding the next IEP meeting on September 23, 2002 are far different. The Petitioner spent no time for the presentation of evidence or argument on the issue of whether this IEP meeting was improperly conducted in the absence of the STUDENT’s parent. However, the issue needs to be addressed in order to determine whether further consideration is to be given to the District’s offer of placement contained in the September 2002 IEP.

At a due process hearing on August 15, 2002, and again by letter dated August 19, 2002, the District asked the Petitioner to participate in a meeting before the end of that month. Letters from STUDENT’s attorney indicate that there were no dates available until September 9, 23, or 27, 2002. At that time the due process hearing was set for September 5, 2002, with little likelihood that it would be concluded by September 9, 2002. The meeting was eventually scheduled for September 23, 2002.

STUDENT’s mother testified that she refused to participate in the meeting on the advice of counsel. There was no direct evidence to establish the reasons why that advice was given. However letters exchanged between the parties and statements made by counsel lead the Hearing Officer to believe that the refusal to participate at this meeting was due to a concern, reasonable or not, that the District would offer an appropriate program to STUDENT and thereby limit the potential for recovery of attorneys’ fees in this case.(Footnote 17) Although little evidence was presented on the District’s efforts to ensure the participation of Ms. PARENT at the meeting, the Hearing Officer was convinced that no amount of effort would accomplished that feat.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner had adequate notice of the IEP meeting that was set for September 23, 2002. STUDENT’s attorney had stated that this date was available. The first trimester of the 2002-2003 school year was almost two months along. The District reasonably insisted that the IEP meeting take place absent some good cause for a postponement. There was no good cause. The Petitioner’s mother and attorney could have attended the meeting. They made a calculated decision to not participate to further their litigation interests. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP meeting held on September 23, 2002 was not convened in violation of the right of STUDENT’s parent to fully participate in the IEP process. The IEP under consideration for the 2002-2003 school year will be the one dated September 23, 2002.

October 2002 Observations by Dr. Dores

The Petitioner learned in the course of the hearing that Dr. Dores observed STUDENT in his school environment on two occasions in October 2002. There was no parental consent to these observations. The Petitioner alleged that these observations constituted assessments without parental consent and were therefore a procedural violation. He alternatively argued that the observations constituted impermissible discovery, the fruit of which should not be considered by the Hearing Officer. The Hearing Officer did not consider Dr. Dores’ testimony regarding these observations in reaching any of his findings or conclusions. Therefore, the issue is moot.

Did the District Comply with the Substantive Requirements of the IDEA?

According to Rowley, the IEP must also be substantively appropriate. The Petitioner challenges the District’s compliance with these requirements, asserting that the IEP fails to include appropriate SL and OT goals and services. He also alleges that the IEP fails to offer ESY services that he needs to benefit from his education.

Speech and Language Goals and Services

Before examining the goals, the Hearing Officer must make a finding regarding the nature of STUDENT’s needs. The parties agree that STUDENT needs to improve his pragmatic language skills, especially those that will help him to be successful in his general education setting. Ms. Rozenberg believes that STUDENT also has needs in the area of expressive language, as evidenced by test results and STUDENT’s tendency to be echolalic and to rely heavily on scripted speech. She was of the opinion that STUDENT’s greatest needs were in the areas of receptive language and auditory processing. Ms Okunami and Ms. Paul testified that their extensive experience with STUDENT leads them to believe that STUDENT has far greater language skills than those described by Ms. Rozenberg. At the time of the September 2002 IEP meeting, Ms. Okunami stated that STUDENT’s expressive and receptive vocabulary was well within the average range and his language skills were developing appropriately and at grade level. He was able to follow simple, one-step directions, respond to “Wh_?” questions and use proper grammatical forms. He had difficulty with complex directions, comprehension of narrative and contextual information, and predicting situational outcomes. At the hearing, she testified that STUDENT needed to improve his abilities to listen and to initiate and sustain a conversation.(Footnote 18)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Rozenberg is well-qualified but that her test data do not accurately portray STUDENT’s present levels of functioning. The Hearing Officer gave greater weight to the testimony of Ms. Paul and Ms. Okunami, both of whom have extensive experience observing and working with STUDENT and, therefore, a more current and practical appreciation for his functional use of language. On the basis of the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has the greatest needs in the area of pragmatic language, particularly in connection with his inclusive educational environment. He needs to improve his receptive language and auditory comprehension and reasoning skills. STUDENT also needs to improve his social language skills.

The appropriateness of the goals and objectives will depend on the determination of whether or not the IEP contained measurable goals with short-term objectives that addressed STUDENT’s disability-related educational needs and were reasonably calculated to enable him to be involved and progress in the general curriculum. Calif Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2).

Ms. Rozenberg testified that the goals and objectives were not appropriate, primarily because there were not enough goals to address all areas of need. She would add fifteen additional goals to the September 2002 IEP to address the basic elements of STUDENT’s language deficits. Ms. Okunami believes that the current goals adequately address STUDENT’s needs.

Due, in part, to the reasons cited above, the Hearing Officer gave greater weight to the testimony of Ms. Okunami. There are ten goals in the September 2002 IEP that directly or indirectly address the SL skills that STUDENT seeks to improve. The primary focus of these goals is appropriately the improvement of STUDENT’s pragmatic language skills. But there are also goals that address syntax, receptive and expressive language skills, and verbal/auditor reasoning. It would not be reasonable to expect those responsible for implementing goals and documenting progress to have a goal to address every detail of a student’s language deficits. STUDENT’s SL goals are appropriate.

To address these goals, the District proposes to provide two thirty-minute small group sessions per week only. It also proposes to eliminate STUDENT’s weekly clinic OT and substitute one thirty-minute class consultation per week. STUDENT argues that his lack of progress toward his goals and his continuing significant SL and OT needs do not justify a reduction of services. The District contends that STUDENT’s goals are appropriately addressed by the offered services.

The services offered as part of a student’s overall program must be designed to help the student advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals and be involved and progress in the general curriculum and participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities with other disabled and typically developing peers. Calif Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3).

Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT should receive, ideally, three weekly sixty-minute sessions of individual SL therapy from a certified and licensed therapist. In her opinion, STUDENT is in the perfect place to be “flooded” with services. As if reluctantly conceding a point, she noted that if the best program was not possible, an appropriate program would require at least the level of services that Petitioner seeks to retain: twice-weekly small-group sessions for thirty minutes and twice-weekly individual sessions for thirty minutes. Ms. Okunami was just as confident that STUDENT did not need individual therapy. She testified that his needs would be adequately served by the twice-weekly small-group sessions for thirty minutes if supplemented by a thirty-minute class consultation weekly. Ms. Okunami explained that class consultations are customarily done by her regardless of whether or not they are included in the IEP.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s SL goals will be formally implemented by both the SL specialist and his regular teacher, but in practice, the development of STUDENT’s language skills will also be encouraged by his mother, the person or persons working with him in his extended-day social skills class, and his peers. As recommended by Dr. Dores, STUDENT’s program will be focused on the learning and use of skills in all environments, particularly those school environments where successful communication will facilitate STUDENT’s successful participation in the general education curriculum and in extracurricular and nonacademic activities. The Hearing Officer finds that the elimination of STUDENT’s individual SL therapy is appropriate. However, he also finds that the SL services offered by the District in the September 2002 IEP must be supplemented by a thirty-minute weekly class consultation between the SL specialist and the teacher, as recommended by Ms. Okunami.

Occupational Therapy Goals and Services

According to the District’s reassessment, STUDENT has continuing upper extremity and hand weakness and tends to use an improper pencil grasp when not otherwise prompted. Transitions to nonpreferred activities continue to be difficult. Unexpected loud noises occasionally cause STUDENT to become defensive. He will seek out movement, such as by rocking himself, but dislikes other movement, such as having his head inverted. STUDENT is also orally sensitive to temperature and texture and will at times chew on non-food items. He is independent at dressing except for snaps, buttons and zippers, but he has little awareness of the kind or condition of the clothes he wears. STUDENT’s attention will tend to wander, particularly if his aide is not by his side. Finally, he has difficulty sitting still and needs periodic breaks to engage in activities to help him to expend his energy.

Ms. Press had few disagreements with the District’s conclusions regarding STUDENT’s needs. The one significant difference was that Ms. Press believed that STUDENT had a vestibular deficit that should be addressed by incorporating a sensory diet into his program. She believed that STUDENT might benefit from a strict program that involves, among other things, the use of adaptive equipment and a “brushing” schedule every ninety minutes. The Hearing Officer was not persuaded that STUDENT needs a sensory diet. Dr. Dores cautioned against incorporating that or any other sensory intervention into STUDENT’s program without a systematic study. Ms. Press did no such study.

The Hearing Officer identifies four OT goals in the September 2002 IEP. Those deal with sensory defensiveness around the head/ears, hand strength for self-care such as buttoning and snapping clothing fasteners, the ability to self-regulate with reference to time, and the ability to be aware of his own energy level or state of readiness for learning and to identify and engage in appropriate activities to self-adjust as necessary. These goals were consistent with the recommendation of ACES, as set forth in its May 24, 2002 report, with the exception of a gross motor goal to improve playground skills.(Footnote 19) Ms. Owens testified that this is not an educational area of need, and the Hearing Officer agrees. There was nothing in the evidence to suggest that STUDENT’s gross motor skills were significantly deficient or that they would not continue to progress normally, particularly with improvements to STUDENT’s social skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the OT goals are appropriate.

The District proposes to address STUDENT’s goals by providing thirty minutes weekly of OT consultation in the classroom in lieu of the twice-weekly OT sessions at a clinic that he has been receiving pursuant to stay put. Ms. Press recommends that STUDENT receive twice-weekly clinic-based OT sessions of sixty minutes each for a sensory integration program after school. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the OT clinic recommended by Ms. Press is necessary in order for STUDENT to benefit from his educational program. Because STUDENT has so few OT goals and a shadow aide to assist him, the Hearing Officer finds that the OT services offered by the District in the September 2002 IEP are appropriate.

ESY Services

The Petitioner contended that the September 2002 IEP was not appropriate because it did not include the ESY services that he needed to receive a FAPE. The District asserted that STUDENT did not require ESY services to receive a FAPE.

A school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY services when the student requires them during times other than the regular academic year in order to receive a FAPE as determined by the IEP team. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2) (1999). Although it is true that State law appears to place certain limitations on when and in what amounts ESY services can be offered federal law offers greater protections to the student. (Compare: Cal. Code of Regs. Title 5 § 3043 and Code of Fed. Regs. Title 34, § 300.309.) Federal law makes it clear that “the right of an individual disabled child to ESY services is based on that child’s entitlement to FAPE.” The federal regulation does not place limitations on the duration of ESY services or when the services can be offered. The Comments to the regulations state, in part:

For most public agencies, the normal school year is 180 school days. Typically, ESY services would be provided during the summer months. However, there is nothing in the definition of ESY services in § 300.309(b) that would limit the ability of a public agency to provide ESY services to a student with a disability during times other than the summer, when school is not in session, if the IEP team determines that the child requires ESY services during these time periods in order to receive FAPE.

(64 Fed. Reg. pp. 12575-12577.)

Several of the Petitioner’s witnesses testified that STUDENT was likely to regress if he did not receive services during the intersession breaks that were approximately one month long. Ms. Press stated that she would expect STUDENT to regress if he did not receive continuing services in the area of sensory integration. She recommended a home program of two forty-five- to sixty-minute sessions per week for two weeks of the four-week break. She had no opinion regarding STUDENT’s capacity for recoupment. Sylvia Mende believes that there will definitely be regression in STUDENT’s skills if he does not receive services for thirty days. She testified that regression generally occurs with breaks of longer than two to three weeks. She had no opinion regarding STUDENT’s recoupment capacity. Ms Rozenberg stated that one month was too long for STUDENT to go without services.

Ms Okunami testified that in her opinion, STUDENT does not need services during intersession breaks. Dr. Dores testified that he had no opinion about STUDENT’s need for continued SL and OT services during the intersession breaks, but noted that he did not think that STUDENT would lose fundamental skills. In his opinion, STUDENT has the ability to recoup skills, but Dr. Dores still recommended that STUDENT at least be “engaged,” perhaps by working on a school-supplied program at home, during his breaks from school.

The Hearing Officer was not persuaded by the District’s evidence that STUDENT does not need ESY services during month-long intersession breaks. Furthermore, although there was only limited testimony regarding STUDENT’s capacity for recoupment, the Hearing Officer was persuaded by the opinions of the Petitioner’s witnesses and Dr. Dores that there is a sufficient risk that STUDENT will regress during the intersession breaks, particularly in view of the termination of his home-based program, to require that some services be provided by the District during those breaks in the 2002-2003 school year. The nature, frequency and duration of those services will have to be determined by the IEP team.

In summary, the Hearing Officer found that the District’s offer contained in the September 2002 IEP failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in two respects: it failed to include a thirty-minute weekly SL consultation with STUDENT’s teacher and it failed to include ESY services.

Issue No. 8: If STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2002-2003 school year, what is the award?

According to the Puyallup case, above, the Hearing Officer is authorized to fashion an award of compensatory education to provide a student with the services to which he or she is entitled under the IDEA. In his closing argument, the Petitioner requested no award of compensatory education for the 2002-2003 school year. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer will examine each denial of a FAPE to determine whether an award is appropriate.

Procedural Denial

Petitioner failed to offer any evidence of a compensable loss during this time. No award is justified under these facts for the procedural denial.

Substantive Denials

Petitioner could conceivably claim a loss resulting from the failure of the District to provide the thirty-minute SL consultations that the Hearing Officer found to be a necessary part of his program for the 2002-2003 school year. However, Ms. Okunami testified that it has been her practice to provide adequate consultation with the teacher for STUDENT and all of her clients. The Petitioner failed to offer any evidence or argument to show that STUDENT has sustained any compensable loss as a result of this denial of FAPE. Therefore, no compensatory education award is warranted for this denial.

The Petitioner had not begun his first intersession break by the time the hearing in this matter concluded. That break is now more than half over. The Hearing Officer has no way to determine an appropriate award to compensate for this loss. The IEP team will determine the loss as ordered below and incorporate compensation into STUDENT’s program.

ORDER

1. The District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s mother for the cost of the speech and language assessment conducted by Ms. Abby Rozenberg within fifteen calendar days of receipt of appropriate documentation of the expense.

2. In addition to the speech and language services offered by the District in the September 2002 IEP, the District shall forthwith, and for the remainder of the current school year, provide a thirty-minute weekly consultation between the Petitioner’s speech and language specialist and regular teacher.

3. Within twenty calendar days, the IEP team shall convene to determine and include in the Petitioner’s IEP appropriate ESY services and shall incorporate into the Petitioner’s program additional services to compensate him for not having received those services during the first trimester break.

4. All of the other claims of the Petitioner are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Are the Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims barred by the April 2002 settlement agreement?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

2. If the Petitioner’s 2001-2002 school year claims are not barred, did the District materially breach the April 2002 settlement agreement?

The District prevailed on this issue.

3. Did the District appropriately make up five and one-half hours of missed speech and language services by pulling STUDENT out of his extended-day social skills program for approximately twenty minutes four times weekly and extending STUDENT’s SL session accordingly?

The District prevailed on this issue.

4. Does STUDENT’s failure to meet all of his goals and objectives for the 2001-2002 school year entitle him to relief?

The District prevailed on this issue.

5. If Petitioner is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the 2001-2002 school year, what is the award?

The District prevailed on this issue.

6. Is Petitioner’s mother entitled to reimbursement for the independent SL and OT assessments?

The Parties prevailed equally on this issue.

7. Did the District fail to offer and provide STUDENT a free, appropriate public education during the 2002-2003 school year?

The Petitioner prevailed, but only to the extent that he obtained ESY services.

8. If there was a denial of FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year, is the Petitioner entitled to an award of compensatory education or other relief?

The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: November 21, 2002 Michael F. Geary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The Decision has been amended as follows: the words “through ACES” has been added to the end of Issue No. 2(b) on page 2; Issue No. 8 has been reframed; “agreed” has been changed to “did not agree” on page 8, first full paragraph; the discussion of Dr. Dores’ October 2002 observations has been added on page 21; the District’s contention as to Issue No. 7 C has been stated on page 24; and the prevailing party status on Issue No. 8, page 28 has been conformed to the Order at page 27, paragraph 3. None of these changes affect the ultimate findings and conclusions. 2 The hearing proceeded at times in the absence of Ms. Blakely with her consent.

3. The issues were identified in the course of a lengthy and detailed discussion of issues that occurred over several days. They have been organized by the Hearing Officer for the purposes of adjudication. 4. The meaning of the term Aclinic sessions@ is discussed below. 5. The Hearing Officer uses the term Atraditional DTT services@ to describe the therapeutic technique, often associated with Dr. Lovaas, that consists of repeated trials of a specific stimulus to elicit the desired response, which is rewarded. 6. Dr. Dores was more concerned that the nature of and reasons for the service had not been made clear.

7. It was not clear when the message was left by Ms. Crecelius. The IEP states that it was left prior to the beginning of the meeting. 8. It appears from the files that SEHO Case Nos. SN02-01686 and SN02-01719 were essentially the same filing by the District. 9. California Civil Code ' 1542 states:AA general release does not extend to claims which the creditor does not know or suspect to exist in his favor at the time of executing the release, which if known by him must have materially affected his settlement with the debtor.@

10. The parties used the term Aclinic session@ to describe a meeting of the various persons involved in STUDENT’s extended-day social skills and home programs to allow collaboration, and to ensure consistency and effectiveness.

11. Whether Dean Paul added fifteen minutes to each session, as originally contemplated, or twenty minutes as testified to by her, is unimportant. 12. The Hearing Officer is aware that Calif. Educ. Code ' 56381 provides that the reassessment is to be based upon the procedures set forth in ' 56320 et seq. but is not persuaded this reference indicates a different intent than stated above. 13. The Hearing Officer does not suggest that a reassessment report must contain all of the information set forth in Cal. Educ. Code ' 56327. 14. This is not intended to be an exclusive list of information to be reported, but in addition to whatever else the law might require, considering the purpose of the reassessment. 15. The law states that the reassessment to obtain the additional data should begin with a review of existing data. Calif. Educ. Code ' 56381((b)(1). The Petitioner did not challenge this step in the process, but it appeared in any event that Ms. Owens did appropriately determine to reassess STUDENT to obtain additional data on his present levels of functioning and needs in the areas of sensory processing and adaptive behavior.. 16. These conditions must also be met in the least restrictive envir1onment and, at least since the 1997 amendments to the Act, the proposed placement must provide the child with reasonable access to the regular curriculum. Neither of these elements were issues in STUDENT’s case. 17. The Hearing Officer questions the wisdom of a parent’s decision to refuse to participate in an IEP meeting for his or her child solely to gain some advantage on the issue of attorneys’ fees. An attorney’s advice to do so is more questionable still. 18. Ms. Okunami also testified at hearing that STUDENT needed to improved his ability to respond to AWh_ . . .?@ questions. The Hearing Officer notes the possible conflict between this testimony and the information supplied by the witness at the September IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds this apparent conflict to be insignificant. The inclusion of a goal for this skill demonstrates that Ms. Okunami believed that STUDENT had not mastered it. 19. Ms. Press also recommended goals to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs.