California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 13, 2003
Student v. Capistrano Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1887-03 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz
Capistrano Unified's middle school autism class upheld, but district must add clinic OT, an after-school aide, and a transition plan.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Follows an earlier SEHO decision between the same parties (Case No. SN03-00657, July 7, 2003), which awarded compensatory speech and OT services. This decision does not disturb those compensatory OT services.
Summary
Capistrano Unified School District filed for due process to defend its spring 2003 triennial assessments. The parents of a 12-year-old boy with autism filed their own case challenging his summer 2003 extended school year (ESY) program and his 2003-2004 middle school placement. The Hearing Officer found the district's speech-language, occupational therapy (OT), and psychoeducational assessments appropriate, so the parents were not reimbursed for private evaluations.
For ESY, the district denied FAPE in two ways. It dropped the after-school Boys and Girls Club program with a trained aide that the student had received the prior summer. It also gave him no plan for the move to middle school. The other ESY claims failed. The orders from a prior decision could not have been carried out before ESY ended. The general education teacher's absence from two meetings was not a violation. The parents took a full part in the meetings.
For 2003-2004, the Hearing Officer upheld the structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School as appropriate and the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer rejected the parents' preferred class and a full-time one-to-one aide. However, the IEP team must meet within 15 days to create a home-to-school transition plan and reformat the behavior support plan. It must also provide an updated speech strategy, move one weekly OT session to a clinic, and add up to two hours daily at the Boys and Girls Club with a trained aide.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO could uphold a district's proposed placement while still ordering changes to the IEP. Here those changes were clinic-based OT, a community after-school program with a trained aide, and a transition plan. It also shows that services a student received before could be required again when the district gave no evidence that the need had ended.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Were the District's speech and language, occupational therapy, and psycho-educational assessments conducted in May and June of 2003 appropriate?
The triennial assessments were appropriate; apraxia was not a suspected area of need, the language sample was adequate, the OT test adequately covered sensory processing, and the law does not dictate which psychoeducational tests to use.
- District prevailedImplementation
Issue 2A. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to implement the orders in Case No. SN03-00657 into the ESY program?
The IEP team met on time on July 22, 2003, after ESY had ended, so earlier implementation was not reasonably expected and the claim was moot.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 2B. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to include an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club and a District-funded one-to-one aide?
The student still needed to generalize social skills in the community with a trained aide, as in the prior ESY, and the District offered no evidence the need had ended; the ESY offer was inappropriate.
- Student prevailedTransition
Issue 2C. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to provide an adequate transition plan?
After the parents rejected the ESY offer, the District still had to meet the student's undisputed need for a plan to move to middle school, including a reasonable separation from his longtime aide.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2D. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to include a general education teacher at all three IEP meetings?
The general education teacher attended the first meeting and reported on the student's lack of progress, and mainstream academics were not planned, so her absence from later meetings was not a procedural violation.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2E. Did the District deny FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to permit adequate parental participation in the June and July IEP meetings?
The parents took an active part in three meetings and visited other sites, so there was no procedural violation.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year, in the least restrictive environment?
The structured autism SDC at Niguel Hills Middle School was generally a FAPE in the LRE and a one-to-one aide was not required, but the offer had to add an updated speech strategy, a reformatted behavior plan, clinic-based OT, and an after-school program with a trained aide. The District also committed a procedural violation by not holding an IEP meeting the parents requested, which the IEP meeting ordered in this decision cures.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 4. If the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of private assessments they obtained?
Because the District's assessments were appropriate, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement for their private evaluations.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 ESY or for the 2003-2004 school year, is the District required to provide STUDENT with compensatory educational services and other remedies?
The student was entitled to a compensatory transition plan. Adding the after-school program to the 2003-2004 IEP also made up for the ESY loss. The request to include his former aide in the transition was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to meet within 15 calendar days of the decision, and afterward as needed, to carry out the ordered amendments.
- Compensatory education. IEP team to develop an appropriate transition plan from home to middle school, with details left to the team. The team must consider a dedicated one-to-one aide for all or part of the transition period and account for the student's increased need for support.
- Order to provide or change services. Incorporate a reformatted positive behavior support plan in the IEP that identifies individual target behaviors so staff can monitor them and record progress. The behaviorist is to collaborate with the teacher and aides.
- Order to provide or change services. Give the parents an updated speech and language therapy strategy, developed by Ms. Brady and the newly assigned speech-language pathologist, that accounts for the recent auditory processing assessment results.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP so that at least one of the individual 50-minute weekly OT sessions takes place in a clinic-based setting for the rest of the 2003-2004 school year. If the District cannot provide this, it must contract with a certified nonpublic agency.
- Order to provide or change services. Amend the IEP to include the Boys and Girls Club after-school program for up to two hours each school day for 2003-2004, with a District-provided IBI-trained aide. The IEP team sets the aide's level of support and decides whether transportation and a transportation aide are needed.
- Order that district's offer may be implemented. District to provide the full program in the structured autism class at Niguel Hills Middle School as stated in the IEPs, with the ordered amendments.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup; Burlington; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; W.G. v. Target Range; Amanda J. v. Clark County; Ash v. Lake Oswego; Sacramento City Unified v. Rachel Holland; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified
People named in the decision
- Robert Roice, educational advocate for District, Capistrano Unified School District
- Robert White, SELPA director, Special Education Local Plan Administration supporting the District
- Diane Lappi, executive director of compliance for special education, Capistrano Unified School District
- Amy Schuchman, attorney for Student, Roberts, Adams, and Jewell
- Paul Roberts, attorney (observer), Roberts, Adams, and Jewell
- Michael Jewell, attorney (observer), Roberts, Adams, and Jewell
- Laurie Cohen, private occupational therapist, expert witness for Student
- Barbara Moore, private speech and language pathologist, Director of Speech Pathology Associates, witness for Student, Speech Pathology Associates
- Randi Vazzano, 1:1 independence facilitator, Capistrano Unified School District
- Dr. Chris Davidson, private psychologist, expert witness for Student
- Cynthia Johnson, fifth-grade special day class teacher, Ole Hanson Elementary School
- Brett Ellison, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Roz Bellante, behavior program specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Carol Perkin, school nurse, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kelly McKinnon, autism consultant, Capistrano Unified School District
- Brenda Rioux, occupational therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Kelly Newton, upper-grade special day class teacher (2002-2003 ESY teacher), Capistrano Unified School District
- Jennifer Greenfield, Intensive Behavior Intervention specialist and supervisor of IBI programs, Capistrano Unified School District
- Claudia Ginzberg-Brown, occupational therapy supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
- Linda Bedoya, structured autism special day class teacher, Niguel Hills Middle School
- Roberta Brady, speech and language pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
- Linda Guthrie, independence facilitator, Capistrano Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on September 30, October 1-3, and 7, 2003.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented by educational advocate Robert Roice. Also present on behalf of the District on several days was Robert White, director of the Special Education Local Plan Administration (SELPA) that provides support for the District. Also present on behalf of the District for the remainder of the hearing days was Diane Lappi, executive director of compliance for special education. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Amy Schuchman of the law office of Roberts, Adams, and Jewell. Attorneys Paul Roberts and Michael Jewell were present on several hearing days as observers. Also present on behalf of Student on the morning of the first day of hearing was his father, FATHER. Student’s mother, MOTHER, was present on behalf of Student from the afternoon of the first day of hearing until its conclusion.
The following witnesses were called on behalf of Student: MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Laurie Cohen, private occupational therapist; Barbara Moore, private speech and language pathologist; Randi Vazzano, District one-to-one independence facilitator; and Dr. Chris Davidson, private psychologist. The District called the following witnesses: Cynthia Johnson, STUDENT’s fifth-grade special day class teacher; Brett Ellison, District school psychologist; Roz Bellante, District behavior program specialist; Carol Perkin, District school nurse; Kelly McKinnon, District autism consultant; Brenda Rioux, District occupational therapist; Kelly Newton, District upper-grade special day class teacher; Jennifer Greenfield, Intensive Behavior Intervention (IBI) specialist and supervisor of District’s IBI programs; Claudia Ginzberg-Brown, District occupational therapy supervisor; Linda Bedoya, District teacher of structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills middle school; Roberta Brady, District speech and language pathologist; and Linda Guthrie, District independence facilitator.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the limited purpose of accepting further testimony from occupational therapist Laurie Cohen by telephone and to hear oral closing arguments. After closing arguments were presented on October 9, 2003, the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTER (Footnote 1)
Student’s motion to assign the burden of production.
Counsel for Student asserted that the District should bear the burden of production in this consolidated matter because the District filed its case first and because it intended to change the status quo. The District contended that Student should proceed first because it was more efficient to hear the specific challenges to the District’s offer to avoid the District’s having to present testimony regarding all procedural and substantive matters that constitute a FAPE. In this consolidated matter, the District asked for a finding that its assessments were appropriate. Student’s counsel raised the more complex procedural and substantive issues regarding the provision of FAPE for the previous extended school year as well as for the upcoming school year. The Hearing Officer found that Student was in a better position to present his specific challenges to the District’s placement through the presentation of documents and testimony. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer assigned the burden of going forward to Student and Student proceeded with his case first. The District had the burden of proving that it complied with the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA), including that it provided an appropriate educational placement for STUDENT. See, generally, Board of Education of the County of Kanawha v. Michael M., 95 F. Supp. 2d 600, 608 (S.D. W. Va. 2000); Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).
ISSUES (Footnote 2)
Issue No. 1: Were the District’s speech and language, occupational therapy, and psycho-educational assessments conducted in May and June of 2003 appropriate?
Issue No. 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 extended school year (ESY) by:
A. failing to implement the orders in In the matter of STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN03-00657, into the ESY program;
B. failing to include an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club and a District-funded one-to-one aide;
C. failing to provide an adequate transition plan;
D. failing to include a general education teacher at all three IEP meetings; and
E. failing to permit adequate parental participation in the June and July IEP meetings?
Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year, in the least restrictive environment? (Footnote 3)
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments they obtained?
Issue No. 5: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 ESY or for the 2003-2004 school year, is the District required to provide STUDENT with compensatory educational services and other remedies?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Student’s contentions are as follows: The District’s speech and language, occupational therapy and psycho-educational assessments failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability; the District administered some inappropriate test instruments, and in some cases, inappropriately administered the tests. Student’s parents request reimbursement for private assessments they obtained. The ESY placement failed to implement the orders set forth in the Hearing Office’s recent decision in this matter: In the matter of STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN03-00657 (July 2003 Decision); failed to meet STUDENT’s needs for a one-to-one aide in an after-school program; and failed to provide an adequate transition plan. The District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year in the least restrictive environment and STUDENT’s parents request a different middle school special day class placement. Student is entitled to compensatory educational services to be provided by nonpublic agencies in the areas of speech and language and occupational therapy, as well an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded one-to-one aide. The District also committed several procedural violations that denied STUDENT a FAPE.
The District’s contentions are as follows: Student was appropriately assessed in all areas of suspected disability. The speech and language, occupational therapy, and psycho-educational assessments comported with all federal and State special education law standards. The concerns of Student regarding the ESY, namely the failure to implement the Hearing Office’s recent decision dated July 7, 2003, are misplaced. The structured autism special day class offered for the ESY was intended to prepare STUDENT to transition to the similar class in middle school recommended for the 2003-2004 regular school year. The District’s program offer for the 2003-2004 regular school year constitutes a FAPE, in the least restrictive environment. Student is not entitled to any remedies.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT and the District were parties to a recent due process hearing before the Hearing Office. (July 2003 Decision.) Detailed background facts documenting STUDENT’s early school years from April 2000 through May 2003 can be found in that recent decision. The background facts set out here focus on those facts and circumstances that are relevant to the issues presented for this hearing.
STUDENT is a twelve-year eight-month old student who has been eligible for special education and related services as a child diagnosed with severe autism since the age of three. He is also hyperactive and impulsive. Starting at age ten, STUDENT also began to suffer seizures for which he is under the care of a pediatric neurologist and prescribed medication. STUDENT lives within the boundaries of the District with his parents and younger brother. STUDENT attended the fifth grade in a noncategorial special day class (SDC) at Ole Hanson Elementary School. He repeated the fifth grade in the same SDC at Ole Hanson for the 2002-2003 school year. At the start of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT was slated to transition to a sixth grade class in middle school. (Footnote 4) The District offered to place STUDENT in a structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School. STUDENT’s parents disagreed with that placement. Before school began, the parties agreed that STUDENT could attend a special day class at Shorecliffs Middle School as a stay-put placement pending the outcome of this due process hearing. On the evening after his second school day, STUDENT suffered a seizure at home. Convinced that the seizures were caused by the new setting, new teacher, and the absence of the same one-to-one independence facilitator who had assisted STUDENT for the past five and one-half years, STUDENT’s parents withdrew him from school. STUDENT has remained at home.
STUDENT’s annual review was scheduled for February 2003. In advance of the IEP meeting, the District provided his parents with a triennial assessment plan on November 27, 2002. When STUDENT’s parents did not consent, the District presented the plan twice more and ultimately received a signed authorization on April 24, 2003. (District Exhs. 11, 12, 13, 14, 17, 18, 19.) During May and June 2003, STUDENT was assessed in the areas of academics, social/adaptive behavior, psycho-motor development, communication development, intellectual/cognitive development, occupational therapy, behavior, and health. Hearing and vision screenings were also performed. (Student Exhs. 19, 24, 37, 41, 43, 44.) (Footnote 5)
On June 11, 2003, the IEP team met for the first of a two-part meeting in order to review the assessment results. (Student Exh. 10.) School psychologist Brett Ellison presented the results of a psycho-educational assessment that he conducted at the end of May and beginning of June 2003. (Student Exh. 37.) STUDENT was rated by his parents as severely autistic (Childhood Autism Rating Scale) as well as hyperactive and impulsive (Conners’ Teacher and Parent Rating Scale-Revised). Mr. Ellison reported that STUDENT scored only a full scale IQ score of 56 on the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children-Third Edition, but warned that because the standardized instructions had been altered to accommodate STUDENT, the results should be viewed with caution. On previous and relatively recent cognitive assessments, STUDENT consistently performed in the low average to average range. (See, Student Exh.16.) Based upon an analysis of the subtests, Mr. Ellison described STUDENT as a child with significant verbal deficits and borderline visual skills. Mr. Ellison reported that performance on verbal tasks was STUDENT’s greatest area of weakness. STUDENT had difficulty answering “wh” questions, responding to general information questions, defining simple words, describing how two words are alike, and solving simple mathematics word problems. On achievement tests, STUDENT performed in the average range in spelling and in the borderline range in word reading and decoding skills. STUDENT’s reading comprehension, numerical operations, math reasoning and written expression skills fell below average.
STUDENT’s fifth-grade SDC teacher, Cynthia Johnson, reported that STUDENT’s academic skills are in the low average range. Consistent with Mr. Ellison’s test results, Ms. Johnson reported that STUDENT received low average scores in basic reading skills (word attack, reading comprehension) and low scores in written language (inability to develop syntactically correct sentences, capitalization). He scored very low in mathematics calculation (addition and subtraction, use of money) and applied problems. STUDENT demonstrated improvement in multiplication, decoding skills and spelling. (Student Exh. 41.)
District behavior intervention specialist Roz Bellante observed STUDENT on multiple occasions and presented the result of her behavior assessment. (District Exh. 22.) STUDENT exhibited noncompliance, inattention, impulsivity, difficulty maintaining his distance from others, loud verbal outbursts, and failure to complete tasks. Ms. Bellante noted that STUDENT relied heavily on his one-to-one independence facilitator and that her redirection met with limited success. Ms. Bellante made recommendations about how to modify STUDENT’s classroom behaviors. Ms. Bellante told the IEP team that she and the occupational therapist would collaborate to develop a sensory program.
District speech and language pathologist Roberta Brady reported that STUDENT continued to demonstrate severe receptive and expressive language delays with significant deficits in semantics, syntax, morphology and pragmatics with a mild disorder in phonology. (Student Exh. 19.) District occupational therapist Brenda Rioux reported that STUDENT had significant fine-motor problems, difficulty following one-step verbal directions, poor seating posture, difficulty walking heel-to-toe on a taped line and a sensory modulation problem. She told the IEP team she would develop a sensory diet for the classroom and IBI staff. (Student Exh. 24.) The adaptive physical education (APE) teacher reported that STUDENT exhibited some gross motor delays. She told the team that she incorporated social interactions into her APE sessions. The regular education teacher reported that she had modified the work for STUDENT but wondered whether he benefitted from being in her class. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, requested more time to review the assessments.
One week later, on June 17, 2003, the IEP team reconvened for the second part of the IEP meeting to discuss goals, objectives and the recommended placement for the upcoming 2002-2003 extended school year (ESY) and 2003-2004 school year. (Student Exh. 11.) The IEP program and placement recommendations for the 2003-2004 school year included a class placement in a newly developed structured autism special day class at the Niguel Hills Middle School in the District. Members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT attend the structured autism special day class at Hankey Elementary School for the 2002-2003 ESY as a way to transition to the similar middle school placement. The class at Hankey included two students who were enrolled in the Niguel Hills class. For the ESY, STUDENT was offered the same level of designated instructional services in speech and language, occupational therapy and APE as offered for the upcoming 2003-2004 school year. The District also offered to provide the assistance of the same one-to-one independence facilitator who had worked with STUDENT for the past five years.
The IEP for the 2003-2004 regular school year included a behavior support plan, designated instructional services and consultation services by the District’s autism specialist and the behaviorist. Goals and objectives were presented in the areas of reading, written language, mathematics, self-regulation, regular physical education, social skills, and speech and language. Class placement was discussed and members of the IEP team recommended a newly developed structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School taught by a highly trained and experienced teacher that included one period of social life skills each day. Emphasis was on behavior management, communication, social skills and language development. At the time this matter was heard, there were two other boys enrolled in the class and it was hoped the class would reach its cap of eight students. According to the District witnesses, the structured program itself is meant to prepare STUDENT to transition back to possible full inclusion. Intensive individual attention is meant to increase STUDENT’s ability to more fully participate in the regular education program and the community. MOTHER asked to visit the class placement. Because the class was to begin for the first time at the start of the regular school year, members of the IEP team suggested that she visit the elementary school structured autism classroom.
In addition to the class placement, the IEP team offered designated instructional services in the areas of speech and language (two thirty-minute individual sessions each week), adaptive physical education (two forty-five minute groups sessions each week) and occupational therapy (one forty-five minute consultation session each month at the classroom site). Consultation services were to be provided by a behavior specialist for forty-five minutes, twice each month and by an autism specialist for thirty-minutes, twice each month. Modifications included providing extended time on assignments, the use of a calculator, assistance with note taking and use of a sensory diet. A visual schedule and visual pictures and symbols would be used as assistive devices.
Rejecting the IEP team’s offer for the 2002-2003 ESY placement that began on June 23, 2003, STUDENT’s mother brought STUDENT to the Lobos Elementary School special day class program on or about the first day of instruction. The District acquiesced and placed STUDENT in the special day class and provided STUDENT with the assistance of the same independence facilitator who had worked with him for the past five years.
On July 22, 2003, another IEP team meeting was held to consider the orders set forth in the July 2003 Decision. (Student Exh. 12.) The order primarily required the team to amend the IEP to provide for compensatory educational services in speech and language and occupational therapy services. The team amended the IEP and included the awarded compensatory educational services as part of its modified IEP offer for the 2003-2004 school year. Increases were made to both speech and language and occupational therapy services. (Footnote 6) Speech and language services were increased to three fifty-minute individual sessions each week and one twenty-five minute group session each week. Occupational therapy services were increased to two fifty-minute sessions each week, with one in the classroom, one pull-out session, and thirty minutes of consultation services one time each month. Goals and objectives for staff and for the occupational therapist were added for sensory modulation (identification of activities to help STUDENT self-calm) and motor planning and work behaviors (help with transitions and organization of classroom materials). Pursuant to another order in the July decision and parental request, an assessment plan was presented to STUDENT’s parents to test STUDENT in the areas of auditory processing and assistive technology. STUDENT’s parents consented to the new plan that same day. (District Exh. 28.)
According to the IEP meeting notes, STUDENT’s parents agreed with the provision of speech and language services but disagreed with the level of services. They also expressed concerns that new speech and language strategies had yet to be identified. STUDENT’s parents asked that the District fund a trained aide to accompany STUDENT to the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club for two hours daily. District staff informed STUDENT’s parents that the IEP team would consider the after-school program request and respond by August 15, 2003. STUDENT’s parents did not consent to the offered placement and expressed a preference for a special day class at Vista Del Mar Middle School. District staff explained that the SDC at Vista Del Mar was designated for severely handicapped students. Student’s counsel orally requested another IEP meeting to discuss alternative placements for the upcoming school year.
On August 29, 2003, the District submitted its request for a due process hearing asserting that its May and June 2003 assessments were appropriate and requesting that STUDENT’s parents not be reimbursed for independent educational evaluations they had obtained. About the same time, the parties agreed that for the start of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT would attend a special day class at Shorecliffs Middle School with a one-to-one independence facilitator pending the outcome of this due process hearing. On September 3, 2003, the Hearing Office received a request for due process hearing from Student’s counsel challenging the validity of the District’s assessments and contending that neither the ESY placement for the 2002-2003 school year nor the District’s proposed program and placement for the 2003-2004 regular school year offered STUDENT a FAPE. On September 18, 2003, the cases were consolidated and the issues were joined for hearing.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Were the District’s speech and language, occupational therapy, and psycho-educational assessments conducted in May and June of 2003 appropriate?
Both State and federal special education law provide that a reassessment of a child with a disability shall be conducted at least every three years as part of the District’s continuing obligation to make a free appropriate public education available to the student. Cal. Education Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(2)(A); 34 C.F.R §. 300.536(b). Reassessments shall be conducted in conformity with the procedures specified in Cal. Education Code sections 56320 and 56321(b). The purpose of reassessment is not only to determine whether the student remains eligible for special education and related services but to also determine the educational needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D); Cal. Education Code §§ 56320(e) and 56321(a). In addition, a student must be assessed in all newly suspected areas of disability and need. See, 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2); (b)(3)(C); Cal. Education Code § 56320(f). In determining the areas to reassess, the IEP team may review existing available data and determine what, if any, additional information or testing is needed. 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a)(1) and (2). (Footnote 7)
The assessments at issue were conducted as part of STUDENT’s triennial review. According to the request for reassessment, the IEP team wanted to identify STUDENT’s current educational placement needs. On the assessment planning form, STUDENT’s regular education teacher, who had STUDENT in her language arts class for thirty minutes each day during the 2002-2003 school year, wrote that STUDENT exhibited a loud vocal quality, a lack of focus, and disrupted her class. STUDENT’s SDC teacher indicated that while he was making progress toward his IEP goals and objectives, STUDENT needed many prompts, reteachings, and support for all academic areas. (District Exh. 13.)
Student’s counsel challenged the appropriateness of the speech and language, occupational therapy and the psycho-educational assessments. These current assessments were completed before the July 2003 Decision issued.
Speech and language assessment. Student’s counsel maintained that the assessment failed to assess STUDENT in the area of apraxia and that it obtained an inadequate language sample. Ms. Brady testified that she was aware of Student’s concern regarding apraxia as a potential area of deficit. Although she had never observed signs of apraxia during her two years of providing speech and language therapy to STUDENT or suspected this deficit from her review of previous assessments, Ms. Brady performed an oral peripheral examination to determine whether STUDENT had needs in this area. Ms. Brady observed grossly normal structures and had never seen him drool. Ms. Brady testified persuasively that these results were inconsistent with a child experiencing apraxia. In the July 2003 Decision, based upon a review of records available before the current assessment was completed, the hearing officer found that there was no evidence to suggest that STUDENT had unique needs in this area. As the hearing officer noted there, STUDENT had been assessed many times in the area of speech and language for the previous six years. Only one report concluded that STUDENT had verbal apraxia. Director of Speech Pathology Associates Barbara Moore, who had never assessed STUDENT and only met with him for forty-five minutes the day before the current hearing, testified that the diagnosis of apraxia was corroborated by her observation during the recent visit because STUDENT bit his lip. On the basis of the information available, including the six years of previous speech and language assessments, the first-hand observations by Ms. Brady, who worked with STUDENT for two years, and her current assessment results, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Brady’s conclusion more convincing that apraxia was not a suspected area of need. The Hearing Officer also finds that no further assessment in this area was required.
Ms. Moore also asserted that Ms. Brady’s assessment failed to obtain an appropriate language sample because Ms. Brady recorded only thirty-five rather than fifty utterances. Ms. Brady testified convincingly that she obtained an adequate language sample by asking STUDENT to talk about a CD-Rom he enjoyed. Ms. Brady testified that she considered the statements made by STUDENT during the oral expression subtest of Oral and Written Language Scales in conjunction with the language sample and obtained an accurate mean rate of utterance. Ms. Brady also relied on her own experience working with STUDENT. Notably, the parties did not dispute that STUDENT had expressive language deficits. With no expert testimony to explain why the words obtained did not provide sufficient data to plan for STUDENT’s undisputed expressive speech and language needs, the Hearing Officer finds that this challenge is unsupported.
Occupational therapy assessment. In May and June 2003, Ms. Rioux conducted STUDENT’s first OT assessment for the District. (Student Exh. 24.) Student’s counsel maintained that the District’s OT assessment failed to adequately assess STUDENT in the area of sensory processing, that one test was administered too close in time to a similar battery conducted by the adaptive physical education teacher, and that the teacher’s rating scale minimized STUDENT’s OT-related needs, necessitating further interview. Private occupational therapist Laurie Cohen, who performed two OT evaluations at the request of STUDENT’s parents’, was critical of Ms. Rioux’s report.
The parties do not disagree that sensory processing is an area of need for STUDENT. In order to assess in this area, Ms. Cohen testified that Ms. Rioux should have administered an extensive battery of tests. Ms. Rioux testified convincingly that she administered the DeGangi-Berk Test of Sensory Integration and appropriately assessed STUDENT’s sensory, motor and perceptual skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the test administered provided the IEP team with sufficient information regarding this area of need. Ms. Cohen further testified that Ms. Rioux’s assessment of STUDENT’s gross motor functions was invalid because subtests that measured STUDENT’s gross motor skills had recently been administered by the adaptive physical education assessor using a test instrument that measured similar skills. (Student Exh. 43.) According to Ms. Cohen, STUDENT learned from the first test and therefore his OT scores were artificially elevated. Ms. Rioux testified that she did not perform gross motor subtests because gross motor functioning was more within the realm of adaptive physical education. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer observes that some of the tasks STUDENT was asked to perform by Ms. Rioux and the APE assessor were similar. While Ms. Cohen and Ms. Rioux expressed divergent opinions on whether the test instructions permitted more than one assessment of gross motor skills close together in time, neither presented the instructions and the Hearing Officer is unable to determine whether the tests were administered improperly. (Footnote 7) In any event, Ms. Cohen, Ms. Rioux, and the adaptive physical education teacher consistently concluded that STUDENT had difficulties with balance and coordination and exhibited gross motor deficits.
Ms. Cohen also expressed her view that Ms. Rioux relied on a teacher rating scale ratherthan direct teacher interview. Although the Hearing Officer finds that there is no legal requirement for an interview to accompany a written rating scale, Ms. Rioux testified she interviewed STUDENT’s teacher and aide, and included the results of these interviews in her report. (Student Exh. 24.) Finally, Ms. Cohen pointed to a numerical miscalculation on one subtest. Ms. Rioux conceded that she inadvertently transposed a score but that the overall results were not affected by the mistake. The Hearing Officer finds that the complaints regarding the validity of the District’s OT assessment were misplaced. In any event, as the Hearing Officer will discuss below, the crux of the dispute regarding STUDENT’s OT-related needs had less to do with the assessment results, or whether STUDENT should receive OT-services than it did with the setting where the services should be provided.
Psycho-educational assessment. Student’s counsel asserted that the psycho-educational battery was inadequate because different test instruments were better determinants of STUDENT’s needs. The law requires that assessment tools and strategies must be sufficiently comprehensive to identify the student’s special education and service-related needs that are suspected and may not have been previously identified. The law does not designate which of the numerous tests should be used. See, 34 C.F.R. § 300.533(a),(c). In addition, the complaint that the psycho-educational assessment did not accurately measure STUDENT’s oral language is not well-taken. STUDENT’s language needs were appropriately assessed by the speech and language pathologist. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s psycho-educational assessment provided sufficient information for the IEP team to determine STUDENT’s cognitive functioning ability and academic needs.
Auditory Processing Assessment. In the July 2003 Decision, the hearing officer determined that STUDENT should undergo a comprehensive auditory processing disorder assessment to determine the specific nature of STUDENT’s educational needs in the area of auditory processing and, if appropriate, to include compensatory services in STUDENT’s IEP. To the extent Student’s counsel was correct that STUDENT should have been assessed to determine whether he had auditory processing difficulties, the Hearing Officer observes that an audiologist has recently assessed STUDENT to determine whether he has unique needs in this area. (Student Exh. 47.) Because the purpose of the reassessments is to update the IEP team, the Hearing Officer finds this complaint is without merit. Nevertheless, it appears that the IEP itself does not yet reflect the information contained within the assessment.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive the challenges to the appropriateness of the assessments the District conducted for STUDENT in preparation for the 2003-2004 school year. The testimony of Ms. Brady, Ms. Rioux, and school psychologist Brett Ellison established that the District’s assessment of STUDENT complied with all federal and State special education law requirements governing reassessments.
Issue No. 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 extended school year (ESY)?
Extended school year services (ESY) are educational services that extend instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District, 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or when the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. Students entitled to receive ESY services are defined as:
Such individuals [who] ... have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition. Id.
The District offered to place STUDENT in a structured autism special day class at Hankey Elementary School to prepare him to transition to the similar autism class placement it proposed in the middle school for the 2003-2004 school year. The two students enrolled in the structured autism middle school class also attended the class at Hankey. The offer of placement included the same level of designated instructional services offered for the regular 2003-2004 school year. The placement offer also included the assistance of Randi Vazzano, the same one-to-one independence facilitator who had worked closely with STUDENT for the previous five years. (Student Exh. 11, pg. 5.) STUDENT’s parents rejected this offer and presented STUDENT at a noncategorical special day class at Lobos Elementary School. The District acceded to the demands of STUDENT’s parents and placed STUDENT at Lobos, providing STUDENT with the same designated instructional services as in its offer for the regular school year, as well as the assistance of Ms. Vazzano.
A. failing to implement the orders in In the matter of STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN03-00657, into the ESY program.
Student’s counsel maintained that the 2002-2003 ESY program denied STUDENT a FAPE because the program did not incorporate the orders set out in the July 2003 Decision. The District argued that the ESY session ended on July 18, 2003, and that therefore the IEP team did not have the opportunity to meet before the ESY ended. The IEP team was ordered to convene within 15 days from the date of the decision, and this Hearing Officer finds that the IEP team met timely on July 22, 2003. By then, the ESY had ended. The Hearing Officer finds that it was not reasonable to expect that the IEP team would implement the July 2003 Decision any sooner and the Student’s complaints in this regard are moot. (Footnote 8)
B. failing to include an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club and a District-funded one-to-one aide.
Student’s counsel asserted that the ESY placement denied STUDENT a FAPE because it failed to include an after-school program with a District-funded intensive behavior intervention (IBI) trained aide to assist him. The Hearing Officer finds convincing the undisputed testimony of STUDENT’s mother that when STUDENT attended the Boys and Girls Club program, he derived academic and nonacademic benefits. According to Student’s counsel, STUDENT continued to need to practice social skills in the community setting during the 2002-2003 ESY. The District did not effectively respond to this contention and presented no testimony or argument that described the Hankey program or how the placement met STUDENT’s need in this area or how STUDENT would not have regressed. However, the Hearing Officer observes that an after-school program was part of STUDENT’s placement as recently as the previous summer. (See, Student Exhs. 63, 65; April and June 2002.) The District did not present any evidence that the risk of regression over this particular extended school year was any less than the year before. Instead, as set out in Issue No. 3 to follow, the recent assessments established that STUDENT’s need to prepare for independent living by generalizing social skills in a community setting persisted. At the time the IEP team proposed STUDENT’s ESY program, these assessment results were available. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required the after-school program as part of the ESY placement in order not to regress.
The evidence established that when STUDENT attended the Boys and Girls Club, he was accompanied by his mother. As MOTHER testified, however, she was not trained to provide the necessary academic and behavioral support STUDENT required. Accordingly, Student’s counsel asserted that the District should have funded a trained aide to accompany STUDENT to the program. The Hearing Officer observes that the 2001-2002 ESY placement included an after-school program with a trained IBI aide. Accordingly, lacking evidence that STUDENT’s need for trained assistance in the after-school program had abated, the Hearing Officer finds that the District should have provided STUDENT with a trained aide during the ESY. To the extent the District failed to include an after-school program with a trained one-to-one aide, the District’s offer for the 2002-2003 ESY was inappropriate. The consequences of this failure shall be addressed below in Issue No. 5.
C. failing to provide an adequate transition plan.
As discussed above, the District intended that STUDENT would attend a structured autism class at Hankey Elementary School where he would be assisted by his familiar one-to-one aide, Ms. Vazzano, as a way to prepare him to transition to the similar middle school program. However, when STUDENT’s parents refused the placement offer, the District acquiesced and placed STUDENT in a mixed special day class for the ESY. The parties do not disagree that STUDENT needed a transition to middle school. In fact, the Hearing Officer observes that the District has provided transition plans to STUDENT in the past. (See for example, Student’s Exh. 62.) Although STUDENT’s parents rejected the ESY placement, the District maintained its obligation to meet STUDENT’s undisputed transition needs. The District did not contend that the mixed special day class placement provided a suitable transition. The Hearing Officer finds that the District should have developed a transition plan designed to help STUDENT move from the fifth grade to the different environment of the middle school. In addition, the Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT has been home since the second day of the 2003-2004 regular school year, intensifying his need for transition support. The Hearing Officer shall order the IEP team to develop an appropriate transition plan. The Hearing Officer shall leave the particulars of the plan to the discretion of the IEP team. The team may consider including a dedicated one-to-one aide for all or part of the transition period and be cognizant of STUDENT’s increased need for support as he transitions from home to school.
Student also asserted that because the District’s offer of placement for the 2003-2004 regular school year did not include Ms. Vazzano, STUDENT’s one-to-one aide for the past five years, the transition plan during the ESY was deficient. According to Student, STUDENT should have been given the chance to say good-bye to Ms. Vazzano. The Hearing Officer finds that the District acted reasonably when it provided Ms. Vazzano’s assistance during the ESY despite the fact STUDENT’s parents unilaterally presented him to a different placement than had been offered. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the failure to allow a reasonable time for Ms. Vazzano and STUDENT to separate and to provide any farewell visit(s) was antithetical to STUDENT’s undisputed social skills deficits. The consequences of the failure to develop a transition plan shall be addressed below in Issue No. 5.
Substantively, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded aide and failed to provide an adequate transition plan, and as a result denied STUDENT a FAPE for the ESY. Student’s counsel also asserted that the District committed procedural violations.
The Court in Rowley recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), which are designed to ensure effective parental participation in the IEP process and careful consideration of a student’s educational needs. Not every procedural flaw constitutes a denial of a FAPE. Procedural flaws must result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s participation in the IEP process to constitute a denial of a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S., at 206-207; see also W.G. v. B.D. of Target Sch. Dist. No 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992); Amanda J. v. Clark County School District, 267 F.3d 877 (9th Cir. 2001).
D. failing to include a general education teacher at all three IEP meetings.
Student’s counsel asserts that the STUDENT was denied a FAPE because the regular education teacher failed to attend all three IEP meetings in June and July 2003. Cal. Education Code section 56341(b) requires that the regular education teacher of the pupil shall be part of the IEP team, if the pupil is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment. See also, 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2). However, depending on the circumstances, the regular education teacher need not attend all the IEP meetings or participate in all decisions of the IEP team. See, 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, pp. 12477-12478 (App. A, Q. 24); see also 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, p. 12583 (Comments to 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a)(2). Here, for the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT had participated in one academic class in the general education curriculum. STUDENT’s regular education teacher attended the first of a two-part IEP meeting which reviewed the triennial assessment results, but did not attend the next IEP meeting, which discussed the proposed placement at Niguel Hills Middle School. (Student Exhs. 10, 11 and 12.) The regular education teacher also did not attend the July 2003 IEP meeting that discussed implementation of the July 2003 Decision.
The Hearing Officer finds that the regular education teacher had only limited knowledge of STUDENT, and it was not anticipated that STUDENT would participate in academic mainstream classes in the proposed placement. At the IEP meeting that the regular education teacher did attend, STUDENT’s mother and the regular education teacher discussed STUDENT’s poor progress in her class. (Student Exh. 18.) The teacher also provided her June 2003 written progress report. While the report card indicated that STUDENT demonstrated some creativity in various language arts activities, it also stated the regular education teacher’s belief that STUDENT did not show growth from being included in the regular classroom, that STUDENT distracted himself and others, and that STUDENT was unaware of the actual classroom activities. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents and other members of the IEP team were fairly apprised of the regular education teacher’s opinion that STUDENT was not making progress in the general curriculum. Accordingly, the absence of the regular education teacher at the two remaining IEP meetings did not seriously infringe on STUDENT’s parents’ ability to make an informed decision about the proposed placement and was not a procedural violation.
E. failing to permit adequate parental participation in the June and July IEP meetings.
The IEP meeting notes demonstrate that STUDENT’s parents were active participants in the IEP process. Three meetings were held and convened to discuss the triennial assessment, the proposed placement, and actions the IEP team took in response to the July 7, 2003 decision. STUDENT’s parents were given every opportunity to ask questions, and the meeting notes reflect their comments as well as responses from District staff members of the IEP team. During the course of the summer, STUDENT’s parents were provided with the opportunity to visit other middle school sites accompanied by Dr. Davidson and the chance to discuss and question those programs with District school staff. The Hearing Officer finds that the parents were afforded a large measure of participation during the IEP process. There was no procedural violation.
* * * * * The Hearing Officer finds that the District comported with procedural safeguards, but denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY by failing to include the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded IBI-trained aide and by failing to provide an adequate transition plan.
Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year, in the least restrictive environment?
Under both the State law and the IDEA all students with disabilities have the right to a FAPE that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the students at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the students’ individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including language and speech remediation, adaptive physical education, counseling and guidance. Cal. Education Code § 56363(b)(1)(5)(9); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). Special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability. Polk v. Central Susquehana Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173 (3rd Cir. 1988); Cal. Education Code § 56345(3).
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities. (Id., at 198-200.) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some benefit.” Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir.1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
A stated purpose of the IDEA is “to ensure that all children with disabilities have available to them a free appropriate public education that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d). Additionally, education is the ability to be successful outside the classroom and incorporates much more than merely traditional academics. Ash v. Lake Oswego School District, 980 F.2d 585, 587 (9th Cir. 1992).
To determine whether the District’s proposed IEP offers STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed placement. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed placement is designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs, is reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District offered a FAPE, even if his parents prefer another placement and even if his parents’ preferred placement would result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. Therefore, under the IDEA and Rowley, the placement the District proposed for the 2003-2004 school year must meet the following requirements to constitute a FAPE for STUDENT: be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit and prepare STUDENT for employment and independent living. (Footnote 9)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A): 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Education Code § 56031.
Student’s counsel advanced several arguments, both substantive and procedural in nature, in support of the contention that the District’s offer of placement for the 2003-2004 school year was not a FAPE for STUDENT, in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT’s parents preferred a different special day class. The Hearing Officer will first address the substantive appropriateness of the District’s program offer.
SUBSTANTIVE APPROPRIATENESS
To determine whether the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer turns first to a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs.
STUDENT’S UNIQUE NEEDS
The parties generally agree that STUDENT’s unique needs fall into the areas of socialization; academics; behavioral management; transition; independence; OT, and speech, language and communication.
Socialization. Based upon the recent assessments and progress reports for June 2003 and the 2002-2003 ESY, the Hearing Officer finds that there is little dispute that the development of social skills remains a critical area of need for STUDENT. There is some disagreement whether STUDENT initiates social interaction. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT initiates a greeting. However, according to Ms. Vazzano, STUDENT frequently has to be prompted to do so. In addition, according to Ms. Brady, STUDENT uses a prepared “script” as a greeting rather than his own words. Most of the District witnesses consistently testified that beyond a greeting, STUDENT does not engage in any further conversation. Ms. Bellante, who conducted the District’s behavioral assessment, testified convincingly that STUDENT’s participation with his classmates was more aptly described as parallel rather than direct engagement. STUDENT’s teacher for the 2002-2003 ESY, Kelly Newton, described STUDENT as a student who remained isolated, failed to make eye contact with any of the other students, and was “in his own world.” In addition, Ms. Cohen, Ms. Rioux, and STUDENT’s teachers testified persuasively that STUDENT approached others too closely and that he failed to recognize social cues. There was some dispute whether STUDENT modeled his behaviors after his classmates or peers. STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT mimicked his brother’s behaviors at home. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the uniform testimony of Ms. Johnson, Ms. Bellante and Ms. Newton persuasively established that, in the school environment, STUDENT shows little awareness of his peers.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has significant deficits in the areas of social skills development, including engaging others, recognizing another’s personal space, making social judgments and awareness of others. To meet these deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs a program that emphasizes social skills, pragmatic language, and decreasing reliance on prompts. This area of need takes on heightened importance as STUDENT enters the middle school environment and approaches his teen years and prepares for independent living. Consequently, STUDENT also requires the opportunity to generalize social skills in the community.
Academics. STUDENT showed scattered progress on some of the academic goals and objectives developed for the 2002-2003 school year. On STUDENT’s June 2003 progress report, however, his teacher commented that to meet his goals, STUDENT needed frequent reteachings, redirects, and other modifications for success to occur. (Student Exh. 111.) The testimony of Ms. Vazzano and STUDENT’s mother established that frequently the assignment modifications and reteaching were provided by his aide rather than the classroom teacher. Importantly, STUDENT’s fifth grade special day class teacher, Ms. Johnson testified that STUDENT was significantly behind academically. Despite the drastic measure of having STUDENT repeat the fifth grade, the recent academic achievement testing revealed that STUDENT continued to exhibit significant academic deficits in the areas of reading comprehension, written language and mathematics computations and applied word problems. He demonstrated relative strengths in spelling and reading decoding and increased knowledge in multiplication. At age twelve years three months, STUDENT’s achievement test scores ranged from four years nine months on applied mathematics problems to nine years six months on spelling. Many of his scores were equivalent to children ages seven and eight. (Student Exh. 41.) Based upon her recent assessments and work with STUDENT for the past two years, Ms. Johnson added that STUDENT did not internalize what he had learned and exhibited no critical thinking. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to have academic deficits in the areas of reading skills and comprehension, written language, and mathematical computation. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs intensive teacher instruction and reteaching, and redirection to stay on task.
Behavioral Management. As part of its triennial evaluation, the District conducted a behavioral assessment by behavior intervention specialist Roz Bellante. There was general agreement among the parties that STUDENT’s behaviors were neither self-injurious nor dangerous to others. There was no disagreement that STUDENT exhibited unique behavioral deficits that included: inability to inhibit (out of seat, talking out, vocalizations or noises during instruction time, talking to peers during instruction time, too close in proximity to peers or staff), inability to initiate (not following staff direction to begin a task, movement toward preferred activity rather than toward the assigned task), difficulty with transition and self-monitoring (unsure what to do without prompts from staff, difficulties sustaining attention even with prompting, unaware of impact of behavior on class environment), inappropriate touching of staff, too close in proximity to staff) and difficulty in language and communication (talking too loudly, talking at inappropriate times, perseverative speech, echolalia, and video-talk.) (Student Exh. 22.) The parties agree, and the Hearing Officer finds, that STUDENT needs a behavioral support plan as part of his IEP to address his behavioral problems.
Need to develop independence. There was a wealth of testimony and documentary evidence in support of the fact that STUDENT is heavily reliant upon repeated prompts from his independence facilitator throughout his school day for assistance with most class assignments. The behavior specialist observed that STUDENT pays less attention to teacher instruction than to his aide. Consistent with this observation was the testimony of Ms. Newton, STUDENT’s teacher during the 2002-2003 ESY. According to Ms. Newton, STUDENT’s aide modified class assignments and, unlike the other SDC students, STUDENT could not follow class directions. Ms. Johnson made similar observations. Both Ms. Vazzano and STUDENT’s mother testified that STUDENT depended heavily on Ms. Vazzano. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT requires an educational setting in which he will receive intensive teacher instruction with decreasing reliance on an aide and fading of prompts.
OT-related needs. The recent assessments conducted by both Ms. Rioux on behalf of the District and Ms. Cohen, at STUDENT’s parents’ request, substantiate that STUDENT continues to have significant OT-related needs. Ms. Cohen reassessed STUDENT’s skills in September 2003. (Student Exh. 50.) Consistent with Ms. Rioux’s findings as well as Ms. Cohen’s previous assessment in February and March 2003 (Student Exh. 15), she found that STUDENT’s coordination and balance remains poor. Like Ms. Rioux, Ms. Cohen concluded that STUDENT has motor planning deficits. Although both assessors described STUDENT’s tactile aversion, Ms. Cohen reported that STUDENT pushes, touches and smells people who come in close proximity to him. Ms. Cohen’s observation was consistent with teacher and behaviorist reports that STUDENT is unable to maintain an appropriate distance from others. Ms. Cohen explained that STUDENT has sensory integration deficits, although Ms. Rioux described STUDENT’s need for “sensory modulation.” The Hearing Officer finds from the convincing testimony of Ms. Vazzano and his mother that STUDENT positively responds to sensory input and feedback, and concludes that this is a distinction without a difference. Both assessors agree that STUDENT has poor seating posture, a factor that contributes to his inability to maintain eye contact and directly impacts his ability to gaze at his peers and follow instructions. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that to meet STUDENT’s OT-related deficits, STUDENT needs intensive OT services that addresses focusing on task, motor planning, balance and coordination, sensory-integration, and the ability to navigate safely in school and in the community.
Speech, language and communication. There was no dispute that Ms. Brady’s recent assessment, conducted in May 2003, substantiated STUDENT’s significant speech and language delays. For receptive language skills as measured by the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Revised, STUDENT scored at the six-year one-month level. STUDENT continues to exhibit deficits in expressive language, receiving a score of eight-years, two months on the Expressive One Word Picture Vocabulary Test. On another test that measured expressive and receptive language skills, STUDENT received scores equivalent to a three-year, three-month age level. STUDENT also continues to demonstrate a rapid rate of speech and measures of his syntax and morphology placed him three years below age expectations. When he speaks spontaneously, STUDENT’s mean rate of utterance was 3.5 words per sentence. He deletes verbs “He eating,” “How you feel,” and inconsistently uses incorrect irregular verbs and past tenses. His speech continues to be perseverative and echolalia is also present. STUDENT tends to speak too loudly, an observation shared by witnesses from both sides. Ms. Brady concluded that STUDENT demonstrates pragmatic language deficits and cannot effectively socially interact with peers. He has difficulty organizing his speech and expressing his thoughts. STUDENT’s fifth grade teacher described STUDENT’s tendency to quote language from a video that was frequently off-topic, rather than speak spontaneously in his own words. As found above in Issue No. 1, the Hearing Officer concluded that, contrary to Ms. Moore’s continued assertion, STUDENT did not have unique needs in the area of apraxia. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to need intensive speech and language therapy, both individually and in a small group and assistance with pragmatic language and communication.
* * * * * In sum, to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, STUDENT needs a program that emphasizes social skills in the classroom and in the community, intensive teacher instruction and close academic support and monitoring, a behavior support plan, decreasing reliance on an aide and gradual fading of prompts, and intensive OT and speech and language therapies. The Hearing Officer will next evaluate, within the context of the parties’ contentions, whether the District’s program offer is designed to meet these needs.
PROGRAM OFFER
As noted, the parties to this matter recently participated in another due process hearing. When that matter was decided, the hearing officer in that case did not have the results of STUDENT’s triennial assessment. Based on the information available to the hearing officer at the time, the hearing officer found that placement in a noncategorical special day class, with designated instructional services and with certain amendments to his IEP, was, up until May 22, 2003, an appropriate placement. However, as discussed more fully below, new information became available. Recent comprehensive reassessment results and teacher progress reports werepresented to the IEP team. Despite having been provided with a full-time classroom aide, various behavior support plans, designated instructional services, and after-school programs, and despite the significant fact that he had repeated fifth grade, STUDENT continued to exhibit substantial academic, speech and language, behavioral and social skills delays and in all matters was overly dependent upon his one-to-one aide. Having found that STUDENT made so little progress and relying on the current assessment of STUDENT’s needs, the District proposed a different special day class, a structured autism special day class, as part of its program offer for the 2003-2004 school year.
The District’s offer of placement and services was described in the June 17 and July 22, 2003 IEPs. The offer provided for a structured autism special day class at the Miguel Hills Middle School for students in the sixth through eighth grades. The assigned teacher, Linda Bedoya, is a highly trained and experienced teacher of children diagnosed with autism. (Footnote 10) Both a behavior specialist and an autism specialist would provide consultation twice a month for thirty and forty-five minutes respectively. Twice weekly, STUDENT would attend forty-five-minute group adaptive physical education classes. For speech and language therapy services, STUDENT would receive three individual fifty-minute sessions and one twenty-five-minute group session weekly from the speech and language pathologist. STUDENT would also receive two weekly OT sessions, one in the classroom and one pull-out session each week. The occupational therapist would consult with the staff for thirty minutes one time each month.
1. Is the program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
a. structured autism class.
As set out above, the program offer includes placement in a structured autism special day class. The student-staff ratio is very low and allows for individual teacher instruction. Jennifer Greenfield, the District’s autism specialist who oversees the program, testified that applied behavior analysis methods, positive reinforcement, shaping and discrete trial training are methods that are used throughout the day. As described by the classroom teacher, Ms. Bedoya, the daily schedule is aligned with the regular education middle school schedule, which provides for different class periods for each subject class. The day begins with some time on the school yard with the teacher and classroom aide, which allows the students to interact with nondisabled peers. Four periods each day are devoted to a core academic curriculum modified to the student’s IEP and one period each day is scheduled for social skills development. Fifth period is devoted to study skills, tests, mathematics and language arts. For the sixth period, the students attend the regular education physical education class. Testimony established that middle school typical peers, trained by the autism specialist, carry the designation “Shark mentors.” These students would assist in the classroom, accompany STUDENT to lunch, recess, and physical education. The class would join a mixed special day class for science instruction. Included would also be a community behavioral intervention program to take the students on structured outings to learn to manage money, make use of public transportation, and develop other community orientation skills.
The crux of the dispute in this matter was whether this special day class is appropriate. Student’s counsel maintained that the structured autism class is not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because the academic program emphasizes functional life skills, there are insufficient peer role models, the class is not adequately language-based, the behavior support plan is inadequate, and STUDENT continues to require a dedicated one-to-one aide. Private psychologist, Dr. Chris Davidson testified in support of these assertions.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s concern that the class placement is not academically appropriate for STUDENT is unsupported. (Footnote 11) The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s argument is based upon Dr. Davidson’s erroneous assumption that the class emphasizes functional life skills rather than academics. The evidence established that four of the six class periods are devoted to a core academic curriculum. According to the persuasive testimony of Mr. Ellison as well as Ms. Johnson who taught STUDENT for two years, STUDENT’s academic goals and objectives are appropriate for his levels of performance and consistent with his recent assessment scores. Ms. Bedoya, a highly trained teacher of students diagnosed with autism, reviewed STUDENT’s IEP and testified convincingly that she can carry out STUDENT’s IEP academic goals and objectives in her class. To the extent STUDENT’s IEP and the class curriculum includes academic skills beneficial in life, such as counting money, the Hearing Officer finds that these additional elements are designed to meet STUDENT’s cognitive deficits as measured on the recent assessments as well as his need to prepare for independent living.
With regard to whether the two students presently enrolled in STUDENT’s class will provide sufficient role models, the Hearing Officer finds convincing Ms. Bedoya’s testimony that the two students use verbal language to express their needs and are at cognitive levels similar to STUDENT’s. Ms. Bedoya testified that STUDENT’s individual areas of academic need were similar to those of the other students already enrolled in her class, and like STUDENT, they demonstrated academic deficits, but also areas of strength. Furthermore, Dr. Davidson did not effectively explain why the provision of structured daily social skills classes, individual interaction with trained nondisabled peer mentors in a variety of school settings, structured community outings, exposure to children with other disabilities in a daily science class, a weekly group speech and language therapy session and twice weekly in adaptive physical education, and physical education in the regular education program, would not provide STUDENT with sufficient role models during his school day.
Dr. Davidson also testified on behalf of Student that the autism special day class was inappropriate for STUDENT because it relied solely on a picture-exchange communication system (PECs) to communicate. According to Dr. Davidson, STUDENT should be in a program where language is emphasized. However, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Davidson’s opinion was unfounded. Ms. Bedoya testified persuasively that she communicates with the students using a variety of techniques including visual cues and other visual supports, pragmatic language, and written instruction. In addition, the students use individual written schedules.
With regard to addressing STUDENT’s behavioral needs, the parties generally agree that STUDENT requires a positive behavior support plan. As found above, it was undisputed that STUDENT did not demonstrate behaviors that were either a danger to himself or others, and the provisions commonly referred to as the Hughes bill do not apply. Accordingly, because STUDENT’s behaviors were not “serious” as that term is understood, Student’s counsel is wrong that the proscriptions set out in C.C.R., tit. 5, section 3001(f) had to be followed. (Footnote 12)
There was further disagreement concerning the format of the plan. To be effective, the Hearing Officer finds that the plan should be in a format that can be readily implemented by staff. See, 34 C.F.R. § 300.382(f). Here, the District’s behaviorist observed STUDENT and prepared a report that properly listed each target behavior. (Student Exh. 11.) In contrast, the behavior support plan attached to the IEP clustered the behaviors altogether under the broader category of “self-regulation.” (Student Exh. 45.) As a result, on the behavior plan that was incorporated into the IEP, the individual behaviors that were identified from the original data were not specified. The staff charged with implementing the plan should not have to parse several documents to discover which particular behaviors to monitor and replace. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer shall order the behaviorist to retrieve the individual behaviors that were contained within her report and reformat the behavior support plan in order to include these individual behaviors. The behaviorist shall collaborate with STUDENT’s teacher and classroom aides to ensure their understanding of the plan. The IEP team shall then meet to incorporate a completed and approved plan within STUDENT’s IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds, based upon the persuasive testimony of Ms. Bellante, that the target behaviors identified in the original data can be met with the close teacher supervision and redirection the structured autism class provides. In addition to years of experience teaching children diagnosed with autism, Ms. Bedoya was a certified behavior intervention case manager for another school district. The Hearing Officer finds that both she and Ms. Bellante have the training and experience to implement STUDENT’s behavior plan and provide the consistent monitoring, data collection, and teaching of replacement behaviors that STUDENT needs.
Student’s counsel also asserted that STUDENT continues to require the assistance of a one-to-one trained aide. The District maintained that the structured autism class provides the appropriate close supervision STUDENT needs by a trained teacher and trained assigned classroom aides. Based upon the testimony of witnesses from both sides, the Hearing Officer finds that for STUDENT to progress academically, he needs to receive the greater part of his instruction and assignment modifications from his teacher rather than his aide. Ms. Johnson persuasively testified that in order to meet his academic goals and objectives, STUDENT needs the intensive individual teacher support that she was unable to provide in a mixed special day class. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds convincing the testimony of the District witnesses that STUDENT’s reliance on the assistance of an aide needs to be significantly reduced if he is to prepare for independent living.
Further, the Hearing Officer declines to draw the conclusion urged by Student’s counsel that STUDENT needs a dedicated aide to protect him in the event he has seizures. Student’s counsel presented no expert medical testimony in support. (Footnote 13) Even assuming that STUDENT needed intensive supervision for his safety, Student did not explain why the very low student-staff ratio in the structured autism special day class would not adequately protect STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that this claim is unsupported.
Thus, the Hearing Officer is not convinced by Dr. Davidson’s opinion that the structured autism special day class is inappropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Davidson’s testimony was based upon inaccurate suppositions regarding the particular aspects of the program’s fundamentals discussed above. Further, Dr. Davidson’s opinion that a placement would be appropriate for STUDENT only if it employed applied behavioral analysis (ABA) techniques lent further support to the District’s position. The testimony of Ms. Bedoya, Ms. McKinnon and Ms. Greenfield established that the proposed class placement employs ABA principles. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Bedoya and Ms. Johnson that the structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School is designed to meet STUDENT’s need for intensive teacher instruction, redirection and refocusing to task in his areas of academic deficit. The Hearing Officer will next address Student’s contentions regarding the remaining components of the District’s program offer, including the appropriateness of the offer of designated instructional services and the absence of an after-school program.
b. designated instructional services.
The parties agree that STUDENT needs designated instructional services in speech and language, APE and OT. There was no dispute regarding the provision of APE services. The parties agree with the offered speech and language therapy services, except to the limited extent that a promised change in strategy designed to stimulate progress was not delivered. Although testifying that the strategies were devised, Ms. Brady acknowledged that the new plan was not provided to STUDENT’s parents. Moreover, she conceded that recently identified auditory discrimination deficits would affect the therapist’s approaches. The District shall provide an updated speech and language therapy strategy to STUDENT’s parents forthwith.
Turning to the provision of OT services, the parties generally agree with the level of services contained in the offer. (Footnote 14) The IEP, modified after the July 2003 Decision, provided for two fifty-minute individual OT sessions each week, one in the structured classroom described above and one pull-out session, and thirty minutes of consultation once each month. (Footnote 15)
The parties disagree where STUDENT should receive the OT services. Ms. Rioux testified that STUDENT should receive OT services in the classroom because that is the “natural environment” where he needs to demonstrate success. Ms. Cohen, on the other hand, testified that STUDENT needs to receive his OT services in a clinic-based setting. According to Ms. Cohen, a clinic setting offers a wider variety of tactile stimuli to help STUDENT learn appropriate ways to receive sensory feedback to avoid inappropriate touching and invading the space of his peers. A clinic setting also provides a greater variety of equipment, such as ramps and overhead swings, and unlike the static environment of a school playground, the equipment can be moved in different configurations to assist STUDENT to meet his motor planning deficits. In addition, because of the undisputed history of STUDENT’s poor regard for his own safety, STUDENT can be more closely monitored in the clinic setting than on the playground.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Rioux’s opinion as to where STUDENT should receive OT services rests on the premise that STUDENT needs to exhibit success in the classroom and school campus environment. The Hearing Officer finds that this opinion is too circumscribed and ignores the IDEA’s emphasis on preparing STUDENT to navigate independently in the community. Thus, for example, during the recent assessment she observed that STUDENT had poor seating posture and balance, poor coordination and difficulty walking heel-to-toe on a taped line or balance beam, difficulty understanding where his body was in space so that he turned around without regard for obstacles in his path. Nevertheless, Ms. Rioux concluded that STUDENT had adequate balance for the educational setting. But as STUDENT is growing older, such a limited view ignores STUDENT’s need to transport himself from one place to another in the community. In addition, Ms. Rioux’s opinion ignores STUDENT’s undisputed disregard for his own safety and his history of falling off large equipment in the playground. Ms. Rioux did not explain how she could offer the sufficient protection on the school playground as would be provided in a clinic setting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer accords Ms. Cohen’s opinion in this regard more weight. (Footnote 16)
Thus, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that to satisfy STUDENT’s OT-related needs as well as the IDEA’s goal to prepare STUDENT for independent living, STUDENT needs to receive at least one of his individual OT sessions in a clinic-based setting. The IEP shall be amended to provide for at least one of the individual fifty-minute sessions to take place in a clinic setting. Although Ms. Rioux testified that the District has two schools with OT clinics, the District presented no testimony as to whether or not it was able to provide clinic-based OT services. If the District does not have the facilities to provide this service to STUDENT, it shall contract with a certified nonpublic agency to implement this order.
c. after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded trained one-to-one aide.
Student’s counsel asserted that STUDENT’s program should include an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club and a District-funded IBI-trained one-to-one aide to accompany STUDENT to the program. The only testimony provided by the District in opposition to the after-school program was from Ms. McKinnon, who testified that generally a student might not be able to apply the skills learned in the structured autism class to a club. Ms. McKinnon conceded, however, that she could not comment on STUDENT’s needs specifically in this regard because she had very limited familiarity with STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. McKinnon’s speculation was insufficient to overcome the convincing and uncontradicted testimony of STUDENT’s mother that STUDENT derived academic and other nonacademic benefits from attending the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club. The Hearing Officer further finds that the District’s position fails to consider the IDEA’s emphasis on preparation for independent living and, as discussed below, is inconsistent with the virtually uniform testimony of all its own witnesses that time is of the essence for STUDENT. Educational benefit as dictated by STUDENT’s unique needs includes expanding his social and emotional growth to settings other than the school environment. Moreover, the District presented no testimony or other evidence as to what circumstances had changed that explained why the District eliminated from its placement offer an after-school program that it had provided in the past.
The Hearing Officer further finds that because STUDENT will be starting a new middle school, with new classmates, STUDENT will derive the additional benefit of attending a setting with which he is familiar. In sum, incorporating the after-school program for the remainder of the regular 2003-2004 school year into STUDENT’s IEP is designed to meet STUDENT’s need to generalize the social skills learned in the structured class to the community and to foster independence.
Just as STUDENT needs individual and intensive attention by trained staff in the classroom, the Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT needs someone to accompany him to the after-school program. A District-funded IBI aide can provide the close monitoring STUDENT requires, assist in implementing STUDENT’s behavior plan, and help him to apply the skills learned in his social skills classes to a larger community environment. Accordingly, the District shall identify, arrange and provide for an IBI-trained aide to accompany STUDENT for two hours each school day to the after-school program. The IEP team will determine the level of support that the aide provides to STUDENT. The IEP team will also determine whether transportation and a transportation aide is necessary, and will provide such assistance if appropriate.
As found in Issue No. 2, STUDENT is entitled to a remedy for the District’s failures to provide a District-funded aide in the after-school program during the 2002-2003 ESY. Amending the IEP to include the after-school program for the 2003-2004 regular school year will serve the dual purpose of providing STUDENT with a FAPE for the current school year as well as compensating him for this previous educational loss.
* * * * * Based upon the information regarding STUDENT’s needs that became available as a result of the recent assessments, the Hearing Officer finds that generally the structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. As found above, the class will provide STUDENT with the intensive teacher instruction, redirection, focusing to task and gradual reduction of prompts, that he needs. However, given the evidence in this case, the Hearing Officer further finds that to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the District shall amend its offer to include an updated speech and language strategy, a reformatted behavior support plan, clinic-based OT, and the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded IBI-trained aide.
2. Is the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer found above that, with certain modifications, the program is substantially designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. These same factors support a finding that the program is reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Ms. McKinnon, Ms. Greenfield, Ms. Bedoya and Ms. Johnson, that the intensive and routinized setting of the structured autism class offers promise that STUDENT’s goals and objectives will be met. Ms. McKinnon and Ms. Greenfield are experienced professionals with knowledge about the program’s fundamentals, Ms. Bedoya is acquainted with each of STUDENT’s IEP goals and objectives, and Ms. Johnson, as STUDENT’s teacher for two years, is intimately familiar with STUDENT’s needs and present levels of performance. The Hearing Officer finds that, as discussed above, Dr. Davidson’s contrary opinion was based upon supposition and inaccurate assumptions about the program’s fundamentals and therefore was not credible. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that with the amendments to the IEP discussed above, the placement is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
3. Will the program prepare STUDENT for independent living?
Turning to whether the program prepares STUDENT for independent living, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that time is of the essence. Witnesses from both sides expressed concerns regarding the importance of this period for STUDENT. STUDENT’s SDC teacher of two years testified that it was time to wean STUDENT away from his over-dependence on his one-to-one aide and significant prompting. Ms. Bellante, the behavior specialist, agreed that it was time to take a more proactive approach and to assist STUDENT to become less prompt dependent. The Hearing Officer finds convincing the testimony of the District witnesses that STUDENT requires more individual and structured teacher attention if prompts are to be gradually reduced. Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT needs the structure, routine, and teacher attention and monitoring that the proposed placement will provide in order to acquire the ability to learn without prompts or dependence upon a one-to-one aide.
Both Ms. Cohen and Ms. Bellante explained that while STUDENT’s inappropriate touching of others may have been endured by his elementary school peers, it was highly unlikely that his middle school classmates would demonstrate corresponding tolerance. The modification to the placement to provide for clinic-based OT services will assist STUDENT to develop more appropriate ways to receive sensory feedback and help him to navigate safely and successfully in the community.
With regard to STUDENT’s social needs, STUDENT rarely initiates contact with others and has not yet learned to respond appropriately to social cues. As found above, the intensive daily social skills development training by his highly experienced teacher will help to meet these needs. The addition of the after-school program will expand STUDENT’s social and emotional growth to the community. Developing social judgment through these means will help prepare STUDENT to live in the community.
Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the program, with the ordered modifications, is consistent with the IDEA’s emphasis on preparing STUDENT for independent living.
4. Is the program the least restrictive alternative?
The Hearing Officer has found above that with the ordered modifications, the District’s program constitutes a FAPE for STUDENT. The final contention of Student’s counsel is that the program is not in the least restrictive environment. STUDENT’s parents prefer a special day class at another middle school in the District and assert that their placement is also a FAPE in the LRE. Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Education Code § 56031; C.C.R., tit.5, § 3001(ab). The least restrictive doctrine mandates that even when regular education is not a significant component of a student’s placement, the student remains entitled to the least restrictive environment that will provide the student with a FAPE. See, 64 Fed. Reg. No. 48, p.12638 (comment to 34 C.F.R. § 300.551.) (Footnote 17) In general, the LRE requirement is designed to prevent a school from placing a student, who does not require such a placement, in a setting that isolates the student from regular education or students with other types of disabilities, or imposes physical restraints. See for example, Cal. Education Code §§ 56520(3)(b)(1); 56001.
STUDENT’s mother testified that she prefers a special day class at Vista Del Mar Middle School, along with the assistance of Ms. Vazzano. Student presented scant testimony about the placement but, according to District witnesses, the Vista Del Mar special day class is for severely handicapped special needs children. The class has ten to fifteen students and includes children of varying disabilities. Ms. Greenfield testified that all the students have global delays and that their cognitive levels range from age equivalents of 24-36 months old to 4-6 years of age. The academic instruction emphasizes functional skills and is at the prekindergarten level. Ms. Greenfield testified that a “teen living” component assists the students with activities of daily living.
On the basis of the evidence presented by Student, the Hearing Officer is unable to find that the Vista Del Mar special day class is substantively appropriate for STUDENT. In fact, Dr. Davidson’s testimony weakened rather than advanced Student’s argument, when she concluded that the Vista Del Mar program was missing an applied behavior analysis approach that, in her opinion, STUDENT needed in order to benefit from his education. In addition, although Student’s argument was that he needed core academics, the District witnesses testified persuasively that the Vista Del Mar class emphasized functional life skills. Moreover, the evidence established that the children in the class were far below STUDENT’s level, not at or above his abilities as Dr. Davidson supposed. Dr. Davidson’s surmise to the contrary, based only upon her cursory look at some posted student work, was unsupported. Although the Vista Del Mar program included community outings, there was no evidence that the program included the level of social skills structure that STUDENT needs, as the Hearing Officer has found above. As also found above, STUDENT has unique needs for intensive individualized academic instruction by a trained teacher to help him focus and to allow prompts to be gradually reduced. There was no evidence that the Vista Del Mar class had a sufficiently low student-staff ratio to meet this need. STUDENT’s parents’ request to include a dedicated one-to-one aide did not consider his need to reduce dependence on this type of assistance and prepare him for independent living.
As discussed above, the District has offered a program that includes access to regular education students for physical education, lunch and recess. Typically developing peers (trained Shark mentors) will provide individual assistance to STUDENT in his classroom, as well as when he participates in the regular education curriculum. STUDENT will be exposed to children with other disabilities when he attends adaptive physical education twice weekly, a group speech and language therapy session once a week, and every day when his class meets with a mixed SDC for science instruction. With the addition of the after-school program, STUDENT will be exposed to typically developing peers for up to two hours every day after school.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement provides the maximum activity and contact with regular education students and students with other disabilities which is consistent with STUDENT’s needs. Consequently, the District’s offer of placement, with the additional modifications ordered above, is the least restrictive environment where STUDENT can receive a FAPE at this time in his education.
PROCEDURAL VIOLATION
Student’s counsel contends that the District failed to reconvene a fourth IEP meeting to discuss other placement options at STUDENT’s parents’ request. At the July 22, 2003, IEP meeting STUDENT’s counsel orally requested another IEP meeting to further discuss alternative placements. Cal. Education Code section 56343(c) provides that an IEP meeting shall be held at a parent’s request to review or revise the IEP. (Footnote 18) It is undisputed that there have been no further IEP meetings to discuss placement. The failure to convene another IEP meetingwas a procedural violation. The Hearing Officer turns to whether the procedural violation amounted to a denial of a FAPE. Documents presented by both parties included correspondence between Student’s and the District’s representatives from late July through early September 2003 discussing placement, placement alternatives and parental visits to other middle schools. See, for example, Student Exhs. 84, 85, 86, 87, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94. No further mention was made by either side regarding another IEP meeting and the documents demonstrate that STUDENT’s parents were informed of the placement situation. Technically, however, the District should have convened another IEP meeting to discuss placement, based upon the parents’ request. The remedy for the District’s failure is to convene another IEP meeting. Inasmuch as the Hearing Officer is ordering another IEP meeting so that the District shall amend its placement offer to include the modifications discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that no additional remedy for this deficiency is required.
Summary.
In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer to place STUDENT in the structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School generally constitutes an offer of FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year. However, given the evidence in this case, the District shall amend its offer to include an updated speech and language strategy, a reformatted behavior support plan, OT services in a clinic-based setting, and the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded aide. With these changes, the District’s offer constitutes a FAPE for STUDENT in the LRE.
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments they obtained?
A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the educational agency, and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its assessment was appropriate. 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Education Code § 56329(b). The Hearing Officer found above that the District’s assessments were appropriate. Accordingly, STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the IEEs they obtained.
Issue No. 5: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 ESY or for the 2003-2004 school year, is the District required to provide STUDENT with compensatory educational services and other remedies?
Based upon the principle enunciated in School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985), that a child with a disability is entitled to “appropriate” relief when a school district fails to provide a FAPE, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, for example, Student W. v. Puyallup, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The purpose of compensatory education is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Id. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497. In addition, courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy which helps a student to overcome lost educational opportunity. Burlington; Puyallup.
The Hearing Officer found above that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2002-2003 ESY because it failed to include the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club with a District-funded IBI-trained aide, and failed to provide an appropriate transition plan to the middle school.
After-school program. The Hearing Officer has found above that the District’s failure to include an after-school program during the 2002-2003 ESY denied STUDENT a FAPE. STUDENT lost educational opportunity in that he was not provided with a program that met his needs to generalize his social skills to the community and to prepare him for independent living. The Hearing Officer also found above that to meet STUDENT’s present needs the District should add the after-school program to the IEP for the 2003-2004 regular school year. Inasmuch as the after-school program is being added to the IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that no additional remedy for the deficiency during the ESY is required.
Transition Plan. As found above, to meet STUDENT’s needs the District was obligated to provide STUDENT with a transition plan to the middle school and the failure to do so denied STUDENT a FAPE. Accordingly, the IEP team shall develop an appropriate transition plan to provide the appropriate support for STUDENT as he moves to the dramatically different environment of the middle school. As also found above, STUDENT should have been given the opportunity to separate from Ms. Vazzano. Student requests that Ms. Vazzano be included in the compensatory transition plan to make up for this deficiency. The Hearing Officer finds that while it may be reasonable to have someone familiar help STUDENT transition, the evidence established that Ms. Vazzano has been reassigned to another student and is no longer available. The Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT has not seen Ms. Vazzano since the end of the ESY. Student’s counsel presented no evidence to indicate that STUDENT has since asked for Ms. Vazzano or that he has suffered harm or lost educational opportunity by her absence. (Footnote 19) Accordingly, because a significant period of time has elapsed, the Hearing Officer finds that including Ms. Vazzano in the transition plan might serve to hinder rather than help STUDENT and is not in his best interests. The particulars of the transition plan shall be left to the discretion of the IEP team. The IEP team shall consider including a dedicated one-to-one aide for all or part of the transition period. In addition, because STUDENT has been home since the start of this school year, the transition plan should take account of his increased need for support to transition from home to school.
ORDER
1. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this decision and thereafter as necessary, the IEP team shall meet and do the following:
(A) develop an appropriate transition plan to ease STUDENT’s transition from home to middle school. The particulars of the plan shall be left to the discretion of the IEP team. The IEP team shall consider including a dedicated one-to-one aide for all or part of the transition period and the plan shall take account of STUDENT’s increased need for support as he transitions from home to school;
(B) incorporate a reformatted positive behavior support plan within STUDENT’s IEP that effectively identifies individual behaviors in a manner that enables the District staff to maintain adequate monitoring of target behaviors and records of STUDENT’s progress;
(C) provide MOTHER AND FATHER a copy of an updated speech and language therapy strategy. The strategy shall be developed as the result of a collaboration between Ms. Brady and STUDENT’s newly assigned speech and language pathologist, and shall take account of STUDENT’s needs as identified by the recent auditory processing assessment test results;
(D) amend STUDENT’s IEP to provide that at least one of the individual fifty-minute OT sessions shall take place in a clinic-based setting for the remainder of the 2003-2004 regular school year. If the District is unable to provide the clinic-based OT services, it shall contract with a certified nonpublic agency to provide that service; and (E) amend STUDENT’s IEP to include a placement at the after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club for up to two hours each school day for the 2003-2004 regular school year. The District shall identify, arrange and provide for an IBI-trained aide to accompany STUDENT to the after-school program. The level of support of the after-school aide provided to STUDENT shall be determined by the IEP team. The IEP team shall also determine whether STUDENT requires transportation to the after-school program and whether he needs an aide to accompany him and shall provide that additional assistance, if appropriate.
2. The District shall provide STUDENT with the full program in the structured autism class at Niguel Hills Middle School as it is contained in the IEPs with the program amendments and modifications ordered above.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
Issue No. 1: Were the District’s speech and language, occupational therapy, and psycho-educational assessments conducted in May and June of 2003 appropriate? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2002-2003 extended school year (ESY) by:
A. failing to implement the orders in In the matter of STUDENT v. Capistrano Unified School District, Case No. SN03-00657, into the ESY program;
B. failing to include an after-school program at the Boys and Girls Club and a District-funded one-to-one aide;
C. failing to provide a transition plan;
D. failing to include a general education teacher at all three IEP meetings; and
E. failing to permit adequate parental participation in the June and July IEP meetings? The District prevailed on subparts (A), (D) and (E). Student prevailed on subparts (B) and (C).
Issue No. 3: Has the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 regular school year, in the least restrictive environment? The District prevailed to the extent that the District’s offer of the structured autism special day class at Niguel Hills Middle School constitutes an offer of FAPE, in the least restrictive environment. The Student prevailed to the extent that the District’s offer of FAPE was modified by this Decision to include an updated speech and language strategy, a reformatted behavior support plan, clinic-based OT services, and an after-school program with a District-funded aide.
Issue No. 5: If the District failed to adequately assess STUDENT, is the District required to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of private assessments they obtained? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 6: If the District failed to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 ESY or for the 2003-2004 regular school year, is the District required to provide STUDENT with compensatory educational services and other remedies? Student prevailed to the extent that he is entitled to a compensatory education transition plan and to the extent that the District’s offer of FAPE was modified by this Decision.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Education Code section 56505(i).
DATED: November 13, 2003 ________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Mr. Roice withdrew the District’s motion to dismiss several of Student’s issues after the issues were clarified at the start of the hearing.
2. The issues have been reframed to reflect the discussion with the parties and for the purpose of analysis
3. The focus of dispute between the parties was what constitutes an appropriate prospective program for STUDENT as he enters middle school for the 2003-2004 school year.
4. The District initially placed STUDENT in the seventh grade. Upon the insistence of STUDENT’s parents, the District agreed to place STUDENT in the sixth grade for the 2003-2004 school year.
5. The District’s assessments were conducted shortly after the conclusion of testimony in the previous due process hearing. The previous decision was based upon a review of several aspects of the District’s placement provided to STUDENT from April 2000 to May 22, 2003. The results of these current assessments were not known to the hearing officer in the previous case. (See, July 2003, Decision, pp. 6, 19, fn. 20.)
6. In the July 2003 Decision, the hearing officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer occupational therapy services for the period from April 3, 2000, through May 2003, and failing to offer an appropriate level of speech and language services from February 2002 through May 2003.
7. At the start of the hearing, the Hearing Officer asked if the parties could stipulate that the assessments met any of the following legal standards: Assessments must be conducted by individuals who are both “knowledgeable of the student’s disability” and “competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.” Cal. Education Code §§ 56320(g), 56322; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(B)(ii). Tests and assessment materials must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; must be selected and administered so as not be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication unless this is clearly not feasible. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Education Code § 56320(a), (b). No single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Education Code § 56320(e). A psychological assessment must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. Cal. Education Code § 56324. Although the parties could not agree, Student put on no evidence or argument on these matters and they were not adjudicated.
8. The Hearing Officer observes that the Hearing Office lacks jurisdiction to enforce its own orders. See, Jonathan Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District, 223 F.3d 1026 (9th Cir. 2000).
9. Because STUDENT has never attended the Niguel Hills Middle School program, there is no issue regarding comportment with the IEP.
10. Ms. Bedoya has a bachelor’s degree in education and a master’s degree in special education specializing in educating children diagnosed with autism and behavior management techniques. She taught a structured autism special day class for five years at the elementary school level. Ms. Bedoya developed a similar program in the Torrance Unified School District. In Los Angeles City Schools, Ms. Bedoya was a certified behavior intervention case manager. She has attended many seminars in different teaching strategies developed for children with autism, including Natural Language Paradigm, and IBI with discrete trial training.
11. MOTHER also observed the structured autism class, but there was no evidence that she observed the class under typical circumstances. Although she expressed concern that one of the boys was reading a Dr. Seuss book that she considered below STUDENT’s reading level, there was no testimony as to whether the student was reading the book as part of a reading lesson or for recreational purposes.
12. Under federal law, the IEP team may develop strategies including positive behavioral intervention strategies and supports to address behaviors that impede a student’s learning. 24 U.S.C. § 1414 (d)(3)(B)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2)(i). These behavior support plans are left up to the District to devise.
13. Student’s counsel submitted a note from STUDENT’s pediatric neurologist. (Student Exh. 83.) However, absent testimony from the doctor, the letter was uncorroborated hearsay. Thus, for example, there was no way to know whether the doctor was aware of the close supervision STUDENT would receive in the offered program.
14. Despite their differences regarding how particular assessment instruments were to be administered, both Ms. Rioux on behalf of the District, and Ms. Cohen, on STUDENT’s behalf, made generally consistent observations of STUDENT’s OT-related deficits.
15. The July 2003 Decision included the following order: “The matters of apportionment of therapy time between STUDENT’s respective OT-related deficits, apportionment between clinic-based OT and school-site OT, and details regarding OT consultation are placed in the discretion of the IEP team, thereby enabling the team to incorporate future assessment data into STUDENT’s program.” As already discussed, the results of the recent assessments were not available to the previous hearing officer. The issue in the present matter is, based upon the current assessment data, whether STUDENT should receive some of his OT-related services in a clinic setting. The matter of the compensatory OT-related services previously awarded is not addressed or disturbed by this decision.
16. While the District’s advocate urged the Hearing Officer to find Ms. Cohen not credible because of some purported contract disputes with another school district, the Hearing Officer found Ms. Cohen’s observations of STUDENT, identification of his needs, and conclusions regarding the appropriate setting to receive OT services credible. Mr. Roice did not effectively establish that Ms. Cohen had an animus to school districts in general or toward the Capistrano Unified School District in particular to establish that she was biased or testified untruthfully. Indeed, Ms. Cohen stated that she has testified on behalf of districts on at least four occasions. As the Hearing Officer found above, Ms. Cohen’s assessments were consistent with those of Ms. Rioux, although Ms. Cohen and Ms. Rioux disagreed where the services should be delivered.
17. The leading case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874 (1992); adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994), provides the definitive definition of LRE in the Ninth Circuit. Holland does not specifically address the facts in this case where the dispute does not involve placement in regular education. Nevertheless, Holland provides useful guidance.
18. Cal. Education Code section 56343.5 requires the request to be in writing. If the request is made orally, the District shall inform the parent of the requirement that the request be in writing and the procedure for filing a written request. Id. There is nothing in the record to demonstrate that the District informed STUDENT’s parents about the requirement that the request for another IEP meeting be in writing.
19. As found above, the Hearing Officer is unable to draw the conclusion urged by Student’s counsel that STUDENT suffered a seizure at home after the second day of the 2003-2004 regular school year because of the absence of Ms. Vazzano. See Issue No. 3 (1)(a) and fn. 13.
