California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 3, 2005

Student v. College Elementary School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1895-03 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski

College Elementary and Santa Barbara County agencies need not repay $5,000 for UCLA assessment; all other claims withdrawn.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 15-year-old tenth grader eligible for special education under emotional disturbance filed for due process against College Elementary School District, the Santa Barbara County Office of Education, and the Santa Barbara County SELPA. Her claims covered 2000-2001 through 2004-2005. They included child find, failure to assess in all suspected areas such as auditory processing and attention, the appropriateness of her county therapeutic special day class at McKenzie Junior High, IEP implementation, and transition services. She sought compensatory education and reimbursement for private therapy, tutoring, and assessments. The county mental health agency was dismissed by agreement on the first hearing day.

On the last day of a ten-day hearing, the student withdrew her request for compensatory education. She also withdrew every reimbursement claim except one: about $5,000 for a July 2003 evaluation at UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital that included a speech-language assessment by Ilene Umen. Because no remedy was left tied to the FAPE claims, the Hearing Officer found them moot. He denied the remaining claim. Under Education Code section 56329(b), a parent gets an independent assessment at public expense only after disagreeing with a district assessment. The districts had not done a speech-language assessment before July 2003, and the parent had never asked for one. The UCLA testing happened during an urgent medical admission, not because of a dispute over a district assessment. All claims were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled a request to be repaid for a private assessment. Under Education Code section 56329(b), public funding depended on the parent first disagreeing with a district assessment. Testing done during a hospital stay, before any district assessment in that area, did not qualify. The case also shows how dropping remedies can make the underlying FAPE claims moot.

Issues and holdings

  1. Not reachedChild find

    Issue 1a. Did Respondents deny a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY by failing to satisfy their obligations under child find?

    Moot after Student withdrew the compensatory education and reimbursement remedies tied to this claim.

  2. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 1b. Did Respondents deny a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year and ESY by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  3. Not reachedChild find

    Issue 2a. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by failing to satisfy their obligations under child find?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  4. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 2b. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  5. Issue 2c. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  6. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue 2d. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by failing to comport with her IEP?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  7. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 3a. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  8. Issue 3b. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  9. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue 3c. Did Respondents deny a FAPE in the LRE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to comport with her IEPs?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  10. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 4a. Did Respondents deny a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  11. Issue 4b. Did Respondents deny a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit (until residential placement at Casa Pacifica in August 2003)?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  12. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue 4c. Did Respondents deny a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to comport with her IEPs?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  13. Not reachedAssessment

    Issue 5a. Did Respondents fail to offer or provide a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year up to April 23, 2005 by failing to assess in all areas of suspected disability [OHI]?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  14. Not reachedTransition

    Issue 5b. Did Respondents fail to offer or provide a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year by failing to provide driver's education as part of her transition plan?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  15. Issue 5c. Did Respondents fail to offer or provide a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year by failing to provide adequate transportation services?

    Moot after Student withdrew the remedies tied to this claim.

  16. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. If Respondents denied a FAPE for any of the above periods, is Student entitled to compensatory education services?

    Parent withdrew the request for compensatory education on the last day of hearing.

  17. Issue 7a. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for psychiatric counseling services provided by Dr. Ferguson in the amount of $3,000?

    Claim withdrawn on the last day of hearing.

  18. Issue 7b. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for neurologist services provided by Dr. Corazza in the amount of two or three hundred dollars?

    Claim withdrawn on the last day of hearing.

  19. Issue 7c. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for counseling services provided by family therapist Laurie Wright from 2000 through May 2003 in the amount of $3,000?

    Claim withdrawn on the last day of hearing.

  20. Issue 7d. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring services provided by Mary Jane West-Delgado from 2000 into 2003 in the amount of $1,100 to $1,200?

    Claim withdrawn on the last day of hearing.

  21. Issue 8a. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen's speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000?

    No reimbursement: the UCLA testing was not obtained because of disagreement with any district assessment, as Education Code section 56329(b) requires; it arose from an emergency medical admission.

  22. Issue 8b. Are parents entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Binder's sleep studies in the approximate amount of $200?

    Claim withdrawn on the last day of hearing.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Richard Solomon, co-counsel for Student
  • Anne M. Zachry, advocate acting as paralegal for Student's counsel, KPS4Parents
  • Nyanza Cook, paralegal for Student's counsel, Zimmer & Marcus
  • Brian Sciacca, attorney assisting Respondents' counsel, Filarsky and Watt LLP
  • Florene Bednersh, Ph.D., assistant superintendent of special education, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
  • Marcia McClish, SELPA director, Santa Barbara County SELPA
  • Jerry Swanitz, representative (first hearing day only), Santa Ynez Valley Union High School District
  • Maureen Leonard, program manager, Lompoc office, Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services
  • Joseph Lockhart, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist; AB 3632 assessor, Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services
  • Ilene Umen, speech and language therapist; private assessor, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital
  • Ellita Pearce, program specialist, Casa Pacifica
  • Mary Jane West-Delgado, private tutor
  • Yvonne B. Ferguson, M.D., private psychiatrist
  • Ron Russell, Ph.D., school psychologist; Diagnostic Center assessor, Diagnostic Center of Southern California
  • Nancy Quiggle, clinical psychologist, Casa Pacifica
  • Gary Katz, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; witness for Student
  • Pauline Bishop, in-school counselor, Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services
  • Lyn Gutierrez, school psychologist (2001 psychoeducational assessment)
  • Cindy Neal, school psychologist (2002 multidisciplinary assessment), Santa Ynez Elementary School
  • Cathy DeLaurentis, school psychologist, Center for Therapeutic Education
  • Dee Anne Barker, independent speech and language consultant
  • Bill Johnson, coordinator of special education, Santa Barbara County Office of Education
  • Diane Kirkpatrick, speech and language therapist; district assessor
  • Cathleen Park, instructional aide, McKenzie CTE program
  • Thomas Goodman, administrator at February 2001 IEP meeting
  • Saundra Johnson, resource teacher (academic assessment)
  • Dr. Corazza, private neurologist
  • Laurie (Lori) Wright, private family therapist
  • Dr. Binder, private sleep studies provider
  • Casa Pacifica, residential nonpublic school
  • UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital, private hospital assessment provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Santa Barbara, California on December 3, 7-10 and 13-17, 2004. (Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Andrea Marcus of Zimmer & Marcus. Attorney Richard Solomon, co-counsel for Petitioner, was present on most hearing days. Also present on some hearing days was advocate Anne M. Zachry of KPS4Parents, and Nyanza Cook, acting as paralegals for Zimmer & Marcus. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf throughout the hearing was her mother, PARENT. Respondents College Elementary School District (District), Santa Barbara County Office of Education (SBCOE), and Santa Barbara County SELPA (SELPA) were represented at the hearing by attorney Sharon Watt of Filarsky and Watt LLP. Attorney Brian Sciacca assisted Ms.Watt on some hearing days. Also present on behalf of the SBCOE and the SELPA were, respectively, assistant superintendent of special education Florene Bednersh, Ph.D., of SBCOE and Marcia McClish, director of SELPA. Jerry Swanitz appeared on behalf of Santa Ynez Valley Union High School District on the first hearing day only. Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services (Mental Health) was represented by attorney Jerry Czuleger of the Santa Barbara County Counsel’s office. Also appearing on behalf of Mental Health was Maureen Leonard, program manager at Mental Health’s Lompoc office and Joseph Lockhart, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist with Mental Health.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify on her behalf: Ilene Umen, speech and language therapist at UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital; PARENT, STUDENT’s mother; Ellita Pearce, program specialist at Casa Pacifica (a residential nonpublic school); Joseph Lockhart, Ph.D., licensed clinical psychologist with Mental Health; Mary Jane West-Delgado, private tutor; Yvonne B. Ferguson, M.D., psychiatrist; Ron Russell, Ph.D., school psychologist with the Diagnostic Center of Southern California; Nancy Quiggle, clinical psychologist with Casa Pacifica; Gary Katz, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; and Pauline Bishop, an in-school counselor with Mental Health.

Respondents called the following witnesses to testify: Lyn Gutierrez, school psychologist; Cindy Neal, school psychologist; Cathy DeLaurentis, school psychologist; Dee Anne Barker, speech and language therapist; Bill Johnson, coordinator of special education for SBCOE; Diane Kirkpatrick, speech and language therapist; Cathleen Park, instructional aide; and Dr. Florene Bednersh, assistant superintendent of special education for SBCOE.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of written closing arguments, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

1. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY) by:

a. failing to satisfy their obligations under child find?

b. failing to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

2. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment (LRE) during the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by:

a. failing to satisfy their obligations under child find?

b. failing to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

c. failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

d. failing to comport with her IEP?

3. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE during the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by:

a. failing to assess STUDENTin all areas of suspected disability?

b. failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

c. failing to comport with her IEPs?

4. Did Respondents deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by:

a. failing to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?

b. failing to provide a program and placement that addressed her unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit (until residential placement at Casa Pacifica in August 2003)?

c. failing to comport with her IEPs?

5. Did Respondents fail to offer or provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year up to April 23, 2005, (annual review date) by:

a. failing to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability [OHI]?

b. failing to provide driver’s education as part of her transition plan?

c. failing to provide adequate transportation services?

6. If Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE for any or all of the above-mentioned periods, is STUDENTentitled to compensatory education services?

7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for services privately obtained as follows?

a. psychiatric counseling services provided by Dr. Ferguson in the amount of $3,000? b. neurologist services provided by Dr. Corazza in the amount of two or three hundred dollars?

c. counseling services provided by Laurie Wright, the treating family therapist, from 2000 through May 2003 in the amount of $3,000?

d. tutoring services provided by Mary Jane West-Delgado from 2000 into 2003 in the amount of $1,100 to $1,200?

8. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained assessments as follows?

a. for out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000? (Footnote 3)

b. for Dr. Binder’s sleep studies in the approximate amount of $200?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that Respondents denied her a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year (ESY) by failing to satisfy child-find obligations and by failing to assess her in all areas of suspected disability for auditory processing (speech and language), severe emotional disturbance (ED) and obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD), and for attention deficit disorder (ADHD) under the other health impaired (OHI) category. Petitioner further contends that Respondents failed to meet the 50-day timeline for assessment from the date parent requested an assessment to the date of the IEP meeting held in February 2001. Petitioner further contends that required personnel were not in attendance at the February 2001 IEP meeting; specifically, neither an administrator nor a regular education teacher was present.

Petitioner contends that Respondents denied her a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year and ESY by failing to satisfy their obligations under child find and by failing to assess her in all areas of suspected disability. Petitioner asserts that Respondents assessed her in March 2002 for ED only and did not assess her in auditory processing (speech and language), OCD, ADHD (under OHI), and for a sleep disorder. Petitioner asserts that her placement at the McKenzie School Center for Therapeutic Education (CTE) (during the spring 2002) was not appropriate for her and that Respondents failed to comport with her IEPs. Petitioner also asserts that Respondents failed to provide her with a behavior support plan and a transition plan. Petitioner also asserts that Respondents failed to provide regular and special education personnel “adequately prepared” to provide her with instruction and services.

Petitioner contends that Respondents denied her a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and ESY by failing to assess her in all areas of suspected disability for auditory processing (speech and language), OCD, ADHD (under OHI), and for a sleep disorder. Petitioner further asserts that the McKenzie CTE placement was not appropriate for her. Petitioner also asserts that Respondents failed to provide a program that addressed her unique needs (by failing to provide a behavior support plan and a transition plan that included rehabilitation counseling services) and that Respondents failed to comport with her IEPs. Petitioner asserts that home school reports were not consistently sent home, that she slept in class and refused to participate in physical education, and that mainstreaming was not being provided. Petitioner asserts that Respondents lost her November 12, 2002 IEP which resulted in a loss of educational benefit because “if an IEP is non-existent it cannot be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit” and that she was without an IEP for five months, until March 2003, when it was finally rewritten correctly and signed by her parent. Petitioner further asserts that by March 2003, her needs and problems had escalated. Petitioner also asserts that progress towards goals and objectives was not measured and that Respondents failed to provide regular and special education personnel adequately prepared to provide her with instruction and services.

Petitioner contends that Respondents denied her a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and ESY by failing to assess her in all areas of suspected disability for auditory processing (speech and language), OCD, ADHD (under OHI), and for a sleep disorder. Petitioner contends that Respondents’ speech and language assessment failed to meet the standard of assessment for auditory processing. Petitioner asserts that Respondents failed to provide a program (prior to her placement at Casa Pacifica in August 2003) that addressed her unique needs (by failing to provide a behavior support plan, by failing to provide a transition plan that included rehabilitation counseling services, and by failing to provide speech and language services). Petitioner also asserts that her placement at the McKenzie CTE prior to Casa Pacifica was not appropriate for her, that Respondents failed to comport with her IEPs, and that Respondents failed to provide regular and special education personnel adequately prepared to provide instruction and services to her (prior to her placement at Casa Pacifica in August 2003).

Petitioner contends that Respondents failed to offer her a FAPE during the 2004-2005 school year (up to her annual review date of April 23, 2005) by not providing adequate transportation services and by not providing her with a transition plan that included driver’s education.

During clarification of issues, Petitioner sought reimbursement for services privately obtained as follows: psychiatric counseling services provided by Dr. Ferguson in the amount of $3,000; services provided by neurologist Dr. Corazza in the amount of “two or three hundred dollars”; family therapy services provided by Laurie Wright in the amount of $3,000; and tutoring services provided by Mary Jane West-Delgado in the amount of “$1,100 to $1,200.” Petitioner also sought reimbursement for privately obtained assessments as follows: a UCLA assessment that included an assessment by speech language pathologist Ilene Umen for a total amount of $5,000; and for Dr. Binder’s sleep studies in the approximate amount of $200.

During clarification of issues, Petitioner also sought compensatory education services as follows: tutoring services two to three times per week; the services of a 1:1 aide to assist STUDENT for transitioning into mainstream classes; driver’s education as part of a transition plan; a Fast Forward program or a PACE program to address the loss of speech and language services; and that the IEP team be directed to convene to conduct a functional behavioral analysis (FBA) by a certified behavioralist. (Footnote 4)

Respondents contend that they tested STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for all relevant times and that STUDENT was appropriately assessed and found not eligible for special education and related services in February 2001. Respondents assert that STUDENT was appropriately assessed and found eligible in the spring of 2002 under the emotional disturbance (ED) category. Respondents also assert that child find is not applicable because Petitioner was assessed during the 2000-2001 school year and found not eligible for special education. Respondents further assert that STUDENT was provided and/or offered a FAPE during all of the relevant times, that STUDENT was provided an appropriate behavior support plan and transition plan, and that Respondents comported with STUDENT’s IEPs. Respondents generally disputed the appropriateness of awarding Petitioner any or all of the remedies sought.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

After Petitioner’s issues were clarified and Petitioner had withdrawn issues, contentions, and remedies directly involving respondent Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services, Mental Health moved to be dismissed as a party to the proceeding because all of the remaining issues, contentions, and remedies as clarified involved the other respondents only. (Footnote 5) Petitioner did not oppose Mental Health’s dismissal. After discussion about whether any issues remained (and particularly whether procedural timelines had been satisfied), it was determined that Petitioner did not have any issues, contentions or remedies for hearing that remained against Mental Health. With that understanding, Respondents did not oppose the dismissal of Mental Health as a party. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer granted Mental Health’s motion to be dismissed, and Santa Barbara Alcohol, Drug and Mental Health Services was dismissed as a party to the proceeding on December 3, 2004.

In the late afternoon of the very last day of hearing, Petitioner withdrew her reimbursement claims, except for reimbursement of out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA assessment that also included Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessment. (Test. of PARENT.) (Footnote 6) After going off record and consulting with her attorney, PARENT also withdrew Petitioner’s request for compensatory education. Then, in response to the question, “is there any other form of relief that is being sought?” PARENT again consulted with her attorney off the record and returned to answer “no.” Consistent with the position taken by Petitioner on the last day of hearing, that part of Petitioner’s brief that addressed remedies included argument only for reimbursement of the UCLA assessment. It included no argument regarding compensatory education or for reimbursement of out-of-pocket costs for any other assessments or services.

Because all reimbursement claims were withdrawn (other than reimbursement of the UCLA assessment as identified above) and because the claim for compensatory education was also withdrawn, the FAPE claims associated with all remedies withdrawn by Petitioner on the last day of hearing were rendered moot. Thus, it is unnecessary to decide any of the denial of FAPE issues set forth above that relate to the remedies initially sought by Petitioner.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the only remaining issue is whether Petitioner’s parents are entitled to reimbursement of out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, at age fifteen years and eleven months, qualifies for special education and related services as a student with an emotional disturbance. In August 2003, STUDENT was placed at Casa Pacifica, a residential treatment facility in Camarillo, California, and has been a resident there to date. STUDENT is at present in the tenth grade.

In January 1996, STUDENT was originally found eligible for special education and related services as a first-grade student with a specific learning disability (SLD). (Pet. Exh. 4 and Test. of PARENT.) (Footnote 7) STUDENT received Resource Specialist Services (RSP) support at Santa Ynez Elementary School (Santa Ynez) within the College Elementary School District. After showing academic progress, STUDENT was exited from special education in January 1998 (while in the third grade at Santa Ynez) because the IEP team determined, with the agreement of her parent (PARENT), that she no longer required special education services to benefit from her education. (Pet. Exh. 5 and Test. of PARENT.) (Footnote 8) During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT was diagnosed with obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) “in addition to [attention deficit hyperactivity disorder] ADHD” and STUDENT continued to attend Santa Ynez as a fifth-grade student. (Test. of PARENT.)

During the 2000-2001 school year, while in the sixth grade at Santa Ynez, “everything fell apart pretty much from the beginning” for STUDENT, according to PARENT, who noted STUDENT’s problems with attendance and sleeping and that she had a “hard time getting going” in the morning. STUDENT was impulsive and would blurt out answers to questions in class, and her self-esteem was in decline. By letter dated November 27, 2000, PARENT requested that a 504 plan be developed for STUDENT. (Test. of PARENT and Pet. Exh. 43.)

On January 4, 2001, PARENT, accompanied by an attorney, met with the Santa Ynez superintendent and requested that STUDENT be assessed for special education eligibility by letter to the superintendent. (Pet. Exh. 45 and Test. of PARENT.) On January 12, 2001, PARENT signed an assessment plan that addressed the areas of academic achievement, social emotional/adaptive behavior, and intellectual development. School psychologist Lyn Gutierrez and a resource specialist teacher and a school nurse conducted a psychoeducational assessment in January and February 2001 and issued a report in March. (Resp. Exh. 39.) STUDENT was found to be performing within the average range or above her ability level and was found not to demonstrate a significant discrepancy between ability and academic performance and was able to make academic progress without special education support. The IEP team met on February 28, 2001, to discuss Ms. Gutierrez’s findings and determined that Petitioner did not meet eligibility criteria for special education. Instead, the IEP team recommended 504 accommodations. Mr. Thomas Goodman attended the IEP meeting and possessed an administrative services credential that allowed him to sign the IEP as a school administrator. PARENT signed the IEP on March 8, and agreed with the eligibility determination at the time. (Resp. Exhs. 42, 39, and 23 and Test. of Ms. Gutierrez, PARENT, and Dr. Bednersh.)

According to PARENT, STUDENT eventually failed all of her classes in the 6th grade. (Test. of PARENT and Pet. Exh. 20.) STUDENT’s grades are noted on an “At Risk Student Referral Sheet” (dated June 11, 2001) which notes 81 unexcused tardies and 30 absences, and the grade “D/F” for reading, language arts/writing, spelling, and mathematics. (Pet. Exh. 20.)

For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT returned to Santa Ynez for the seventh grade. A 504 plan meeting was held on September 27, 2001, and a 504 Student Accommodation Plan was developed to help STUDENT with her ADD and OCD diagnoses. (Resp. Exh. 22.) Classroom reports indicate that STUDENT was making progress in the fall 2001. However, STUDENT stopped attending school at the end of October or the beginning of November and did not attend school regularly until February 2, 2002, (except for a “day or two” for an hour). (Pet. Exh. 6. and Test. of PARENT.) PARENT described STUDENT’s behavior in the fall of 2001 as “extremely bad” and that STUDENT was “very depressed.” PARENT stated that STUDENT wrote “disturbing” notes at school that were reported to her by STUDENT’s teachers. (Test. of PARENT.) At a parent-teachers meeting held in November 2001, three of STUDENT’s teachers reported to her that STUDENT would not follow rules, that they had picked up notes from her that contained disturbing content, that she had engaged in “bizarre” behavior, and that they saw “big” changes in her. (Test. of PARENT.)

Santa Ynez school psychologist Cindy Neal testified that she first became aware of STUDENT in October or November 2001 when a teacher showed her a letter STUDENT had written for a class assignment that the teacher was concerned about. Ms. Neal reviewed the letter and did a risk assessment to see if STUDENT was suicidal. Ms. Neal concluded that she was not concerned about STUDENT at that point and did not consider reassessing STUDENT because she was performing “all right” in school, her 504 plan was in place, her affect was good, and her thought process was normal. Ms. Neal told PARENT that it was important that she share information concerning the letter with her therapist, and PARENT told Ms. Neal about some of STUDENT’s mental health issues and her being under the care of psychiatrists or psychologists and that they were seeing counselors. PARENT recalled that Ms. Neal talked with her about whether STUDENT was suicidal. (Test. of Ms. Neal and PARENT.) Meanwhile, PARENT obtained a referral from STUDENT’s pediatrician for a child psychiatrist, and STUDENT began seeing Dr. Yvonne Ferguson in November 2001. STUDENT saw Dr. Ferguson until March 2003. (Test. of PARENT and Dr. Ferguson.)

In January 2002, at school, STUDENT had distributed a very explicit email that involved another female student (who was a friend of hers) that resulted in difficulties with her peers. Ms. Neal’s attempt to conduct a “conflict resolution” was unsuccessful because STUDENT would not come to school. (Test. of Ms. Neal.)

Just after her thirteenth birthday, in February 2002, STUDENT, at the recommendation of Dr. Ferguson, was voluntarily admitted to a local psychiatric hospital’s adolescent unit and placed on suicide and “AWOL” precautions. STUDENT was discharged one week later with DSM-IV diagnoses of major depression, ADHD, and OCD. (Pet. Exh. 41 and Test. of PARENT and Dr. Ferguson.) The hospital chart indicates that STUDENT had reported fighting with her parents, had had difficulty sleeping, and was under the medications Dexedrine, Paxil, and Wellbutrin. PARENT testified that STUDENT had attempted to have a birthday party and had passed out invitations to her friends on her own, but only one person came and STUDENT stayed in her room for days afterwards. (Test. of PARENT.) Ms. Neal testified that during the hospitalization, she telephoned PARENT and expressed concern about what was happening to STUDENT who had “decompensated pretty rapidly,” and she discussed doing an assessment.

Following STUDENT’s discharge from the hospital, Ms. Neal prepared a referral for assessment in the presence of PARENT, and PARENT signed the assessment plan on that date (February 25, 2002). The plan included the areas of Academic Achievement, Social Emotional/Adaptive Behavior (including the BASC), Psychomotor Development, Intellectual Development, and Health/Developmental History. Ms. Neal testified that they talked about language and speech but decided it was not necessary. Ms. Neal told PARENT that if she felt a speech and language assessment was needed during testing, she would involve the speech therapist. Ms. Neal also did not feel that a functional analysis assessment (FAA) was needed because STUDENT“wasn’t a danger to others at school, and there hadn’t been significant behavior at school to warrant a Hughes Bill assessment” (i.e., danger to herself or others). (Resp. Exhs. 36 and 37 and Test. of Ms. Neal and PARENT.)

As part of the assessment, Ms. Neal requested information from STUDENT’s therapist (Lori Wright), from Dr. Corazza (her neurologist), from Dr. Ferguson (her psychiatrist), and from the hospital, but only received documents back from the hospital. (Test. of Ms. Neal.)

Ms. Neal conducted a multi-disciplinary assessment of STUDENT on March 21 and 22, 2002. (Test. of Ms. Neal and Resp. Exh. 35.) Resource teacher Saundra Johnson assisted Ms. Neal in preparing the report. Ms. Johnson conducted the Wechsler Individualized Achievement Test (WIAT) and prepared the academic part of the report. Ms. Neal administered the Wechsler’s Intelligence Scales (WISC) and the developmental test of visual motor integration (VMI), and she observed STUDENT’s behaviors during those periods of time. Ms. Neal noted that STUDENT’s affect was much slower than she had previously noted and that STUDENT was very anxious at times and engaged in “OCD behaviors.” During testing, STUDENT obsessed on lotions and used the phone constantly. Ms. Neal noted that STUDENT exhibited attention and focus problems and could not rule out whether the difficulties were a part of depression or a part of attention problems. The assessment took two days (two hours each day) PARENT and STUDENT completed the BASC, and Ms. Neal reported WISC test scores previously obtained in February 2001 and January 1996.

Ms. Neal prepared the background section for the report, relying on information provided by PARENT and the psychiatric hospital report that included information relating to OCD, ADD, and depression, and STUDENT’s medication and that included her conversations with STUDENT. Ms. Neal stated that she found no need to re-evaluate whether STUDENT had these diagnoses and could not because she is not a medical doctor. On April 15, 2002, Ms. Neal issued multi-disciplinary assessment report and concluded that STUDENT appeared to meet eligibility criteria for special education services under the following criteria for emotional disturbance: STUDENT exhibited unusual reactions under normal circumstances and a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. (Test. of Ms. Neal.)

On April 23, 2002, the IEP team met to review the assessment. (Resp. Exh. 21.) At this time, STUDENT was under a bipolar disorder diagnosis made by Dr. Ferguson. (Test. of Dr. Ferguson.) Ms. Neal shared the results of her assessment. Cathy DeLaurentis, the school psychologist for the Center for Therapeutic Education (CTE), also attended the meeting because the IEP team was considering CTE placement. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance. Ms. Neal agreed with the determination and testified that her assessment supported that determination.

The IEP team recommended placement at the Center for Therapeutic Education (CTE) Special Day Class at McKenzie Junior High School. PARENT wanted the CTE placement for STUDENT and agreed with the CTE placement for STUDENT. Under the IEP’s additional comments, teacher reports of “chronic” attendance problems as a “primary concern” and that assignments were not completed “despite use of accommodations including use of tutor, preferential seating, use of planner...” and that “approx. 20% of work is completed.” STUDENT’s recent hospitalization, her bipolar disorder diagnosis, and a medication regimen that included Depakote, Tenex and Paxil, was also noted on the IEP.

The county’s coordinator of special education, Mr. Bill Johnson, attended the April 23, 2002 IEP meeting and described the CTE program. The program serves students with an emotional disturbance and has a mental health component staffed by the Multi-Agency System of Care (MISC) The program has academic core areas to prepare a student for high school “and beyond” within a special education classroom comprising “6 to 12" students that included two instructional assistants and a support staff member such as a behavior specialist, and that the CTE class was designed to give students “a lot of” individual attention. (Test. of Mr. Johnson.)

The IEP also provided DIS counseling services three times per week in 30 minute sessions and also referred STUDENT to Santa Barbara County Alcohol Drug and Mental Health Services for an AB 3632 assessment. Ms. Neal testified that the referral was sent to Mental Health immediately, together with the IEP, the psychoeducational assessment report and medical records for review by Mental Health to determine eligibility for Mental Health services.

After the April 23, 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT would not return to school. At STUDENT’s parent’s request, school psychologist Cindy Neal and her husband visited STUDENT’s home to help get her on the school bus and back to school. Ms. Neal recounted that she went to the home four times to get STUDENT on the school bus, but in response, STUDENT engaged in physical altercations that led on one day to the positioning of a police officer outside the house. Mr. Johnson also attempted to get STUDENT on the school bus. STUDENT eventually returned to school and completed the CTE program for the spring semester. (Test. of PARENT, Ms. Neal, and Mr. Johnson.)

Meanwhile, the AB 3632 referral was received by Mental Health and on June 27, 2002, Mental Health received PARENT’ signed consent to the referral. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart.) Because STUDENT was receiving both psychotropic medications and mental health from private providers, Mental Health decided to wait until the fall (and the start of the school year) to begin the school assessment to determine mental health needs at school. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart.)

During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT attended the McKenzie CTE program as an eighth-grade student. In September 2002, Dr. Lockhart of Mental Health conducted its formal intake assessment pursuant to the AB 3632 referral. Observations of STUDENT were made while she attended the McKenzie CTE classroom. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart and Ms. Bishop.)

At parental request, an IEP meeting was held on September 12, 2002, to review STUDENT’s progress in the CTE program. (Resp. Exhs. 19 and 20 and Test. of PARENT.) PARENT was concerned that she had not received a progress report in June. The IEP included an Accommodations Matrix for California State Assessments, and the IEP team agreed to provide “home/school daily report[s] to reinforce appropriate behavior and work habits” and for “verbal encouragement on task reminders [and] individual help from aide as needed.” While in the CTE class, STUDENT was frequently the object of teasing and sometimes slept in class. (Test. of Ms. Park and Ms. Bishop.)

An IEP meeting was held on November 15, 2002, to discuss the results of the Mental Health assessment. STUDENT was found eligible for AB3632 services and had already been receiving Mental Health services, including in-school therapy that had begun on October 8. The Mental Health service plan was made a part of the November 15, 2002 IEP, and the IEP team continued to recommend placement in the McKenzie CTE program. (Resp. Exh. 17 and Test. of Dr. Lockhart.)

However, the November 15, 2002 IEP was lost by Mr. Johnson and was rewritten and given to PARENT on January 23, 2003. (Footnote 9) The IEP was not returned signed by PARENT until March 20, 2003. (Test. of Mr. Johnson.) During the five-month period, STUDENT’s services, including placement at McKenzie CTE, continued to be implemented in accordance with the last agreed upon and implemented IEP dated April 23, 2002, and Mental Health services were not interrupted. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart, Mr. Johnson, Ms. Park, Ms. Bishop, and PARENT.)

On April 1, 2003, STUDENT’s annual review IEP meeting was held. (Resp. Exh. 14.) Present levels of performance and goals and objectives were revised, and the IEP team recommended continued placement in the McKenzie CTE program. (Test. of Mr. Johnson and Ms. Park.) PARENT signed an Addendum to the Behavior Support plan but did not consent to the IEP. At parent request, an IEP meeting was held on May 12, 2003. (Resp. Exh. 12.) PARENT made additional requests as documented in the IEP notes, and the IEP included an “Addendum at Parent Request.” The IEP team continued to recommend placement at the McKenzie CTE program with mental health and DIS counseling support.

At parent request, an IEP meeting was held on June 3, 2003. (Resp. Exh. 11.) PARENT requested residential placement. The IEP team recommended a referral for assessment by the State Diagnostic Center (eventually completed in February 2004), and recommended continued placement at the CTE program. Mental Health needed time to re-assess STUDENT to determine whether she needed residential placement. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart.)

On June 19, 2003, CTE school psychologist Cathy DeLaurentis issued an Academic Assessment report of STUDENT. According to the report, STUDENT was re-tested (after an earlier evaluation expressed within a report dated March 28, 2003) because of STUDENT’s“high level of distraction” during the prior assessment in order to get a more accurate depiction of her academic skills, but STUDENT was not tested for intellectual ability. (Resp. Exh. 30 and Test. of Ms. DeLaurentis.)

On June 23, 2003, Dr. Lockhart made a home visit to evaluate STUDENT. Dr. Lockhart discussed issues with PARENT regarding STUDENT’s placement. Mental Health recommended that STUDENT be residentially placed because her condition seemed to be deteriorating – STUDENT was “more violent and less responsive to either family or other interventions.” The Mental Health Assistance Team (MATT) had been brought to evaluate her for a possible “5150" (involuntary psychiatric hospitalization) on a few occasions and was “very concerned” about her mental health. The MATT team concluded that while STUDENT“did not quite meet” the 5150 criteria to “take away her liberty in a sense against her will,” she certainly met the criteria to be hospitalized psychiatrically. Dr. Lockhart “very strongly” recommended to PARENT STUDENT’s voluntary hospitalization and expected that if that didn’t happen, MATT would “end up” pursuing a 5150 hospitalization. Mental Health and PARENT agreed that UCLA would be better for STUDENT and would provide more comprehensive services for her than Vista del Mar. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart.)

On or about June 30, 2003, STUDENT was admitted to the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital (UCLA), her second inpatient psychiatric hospitalization. (Footnote 10) STUDENT stayed at UCLA for two weeks. According to the chart, STUDENT’s symptoms prior to admission were consistent with her previous diagnosis of bipolar disorder, NOS. STUDENT’s symptoms included two weeks of “increased impulsivity and aggressiveness, [a] decreased need for sleep, and increased conflict with parents and teachers.” (Pet. Exh. 39.) During the hospitalization, Ilene Umen, M.A., conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Umen determined that STUDENT had significant weaknesses in auditory short-term memory and auditory processing, and she recommended speech and language therapy to work on problem-solving skills, complex syntax production, and auditory short-term memory. Ms. Umen recommended the use of programs such as Fast Forward or PACE to assist with these difficulties. (Pet. Exh. 39 and Test. of Ms. Umen.)

On July 15, 2003, the IEP team met to discuss residential placement. The IEP team recommended a nonpublic school residential placement in accordance with AB 3632 because STUDENT’s symptoms necessitated a more restrictive placement. An attendance goal was added to the IEP, and PARENT requested a speech and language assessment to address auditory processing concerns. An assessment plan was signed by PARENT on July 15. (Resp. Exhs. 9 and 29 and Test. of PARENT.) On July 17, 2003, Dr. Lockhart referred STUDENT to Casa Pacifica’s residential treatment program and STUDENT was “accepted and entered Angel’s Cottage [at Casa Pacifica] on August 14, 2003.” (Pet. Exh. 35.)

On July 30, 2003, speech and language therapist Diane Kirkpatrick conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT in her home. On July 31, Ms. Kirkpatrick issued a written assessment report, concluding that receptive and expressive vocabulary tests showed adequate comprehension and use of single word vocabulary. However, on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF), STUDENT “tested out” three years below her chronological age, indicating difficulties in seeing relationships among words and meanings and with understanding relationships among words and meanings. Noting that STUDENT was on medication that could affect her alertness and accuracy when communicating, Ms. Kirkpatrick recommended speech and language support and made specific recommendations for word classes, word associations, recalling sentences, semantic relationships, and listening to paragraphs. Ms. Kirkpatrick did not recommend direct speech and language therapy services. Ms. Kirkpatrick discussed her assessment at an IEP meeting held in December 2003. (Resp. Exh. 28 and Test. of Ms. Kirkpatrick.)

On August 14, 2003, STUDENT began her residential placement at Casa Pacifica, a nonpublic school (NPS) in Camarillo. (Pet. Exh. 35.) STUDENT resided at Casa Pacifica and attended class there as a ninth-grade student during the 2003-2004 school year and ESY and made significant progress. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Pearce.)

On December 9, 2003, the IEP team met to discuss Ms. Kirkpatrick’s speech and language assessment. Ms. Kirkpatrick did not recommend direct speech and language therapy services. The IEP’s additional comments include the notation that an independent speech and language consultant would observe STUDENT at Casa Pacifica. The IEP was not signed by PARENT. (Resp. Exh. 5 and Test. of Ms. Kirkpatrick and PARENT.)

On January 26, 2004, the IEP team met again at parent request to consider whether STUDENT needed direct speech and language therapy services at Casa Pacifica. The IEP team agreed to obtain an independent consultation from a speech and language therapist who would observe STUDENT at Casa Pacifica and consider the reports of Ms. Umen and Ms. Kirkpatrick. (Resp. Exh. 3 and Test. of Dr. Bednersh.)

The independent assessor, Ms. Dee Anne Barker, conducted two observations and concluded that the STUDENT’s program at Casa Pacifica sufficiently addressed her needs in the area of speech and language, including auditory processing, and that she did not need direct speech and language therapy services. (Resp. Exhs. 26 and 27 and Test. of Ms. Barker.)

During the week of February 23, 2004, a comprehensive assessment was conducted by the State Diagnostic Center of Southern California. A written assessment report was prepared to address the following four questions: 1) What is STUDENT’s true cognitive potential? 2) What are STUDENT’s needs with regard to auditory processing/speech language functioning? 3) What would be the components of an appropriate educational program for STUDENT? 4) Does STUDENT require assistive technology and/or any other related services? The assessors found that although STUDENT functioned within the average range cognitively, she had difficulties with memory and reduced processing and response speed that impacted cognitive performance. The assessment noted that similar processing impairments have been found among individuals suffering from depression, a “prominent” feature of STUDENT’s condition. The assessors found that STUDENT’s difficulties with auditory processing, “evident on tests from all disciplines, not solely on auditory tasks,” are components of a “broader array of processing delays that is a component feature of STUDENT’s neuropsychiatric condition and not a separate disorder.” (Resp. Exh. 25 and Test. of Dr. Russell.)

The Diagnostic Center assessors found that STUDENT’s academic improvements from June 2003 to February 2004 “likely reflected” the positive results of the environmental, behavioral, and emotional interventions she had received at Casa Pacifica. The assessors concluded that STUDENT did not demonstrate any specific areas of need for assistive technology outside of what would be expected for any other ninth grader. (Resp. Exh. 25 and Test. of Ron Russell, Ph.D.)

STUDENT has made and continues to make progress at Casa Pacifica and no longer has a diagnosis of bipolar disorder. STUDENT attends Camarillo High School two periods per day. (Test. of Ms. Pearce and Ms. Quiggle.) Casa Pacifica transcripts indicate that STUDENT is currently “right on track” for high school graduation and that she is doing a “great job” and is receiving “mostly A’s and B’s.” (Test. of Dr. Bednersh.)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

As discussed above, on the last day of hearing, Petitioner withdrew all requests for relief except for her request for reimbursement for the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment. Thus, the Hearing Officer only addresses the sole remaining issue submitted for decision:

Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000?

California Education Code section 56329(b) provides that “[a] parent or guardian has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, as defined by regulations of the board, if the parent or guardian disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency, in accordance with Section 300.502of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations...”

STUDENT was first assessed for speech and language during her hospitalization at the UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital in July 2003. Ms. Ilene Umen, a speech and language pathologist, conducted the assessment over several days (July 7, July 8, July 14, and July 15) and concluded in a report transcribed on August 19, 2003, that STUDENT exhibited weaknesses in auditory short-term memory and in complex syntax production. Ms. Umen recommended speech and language therapy to work on problem solving skills, complex syntax production, and improving auditory short-term memory. Ms. Umen recommended programs such as FastForward or PACE to address auditory short-term memory and auditory processing difficulties. (Pet. Exh. 39 and Test. of Ms. Umen.)

At the time of STUDENT’s release from UCLA, an IEP team meeting was held on July 15, 2003, and PARENT requested a speech and language assessment of STUDENTto evaluate “auditory processing concerns.” The IEP team agreed to conduct an assessment, and an assessment plan was signed by PARENT at the meeting. (Test. of PARENT and Resp. Exhs. 9 and 29.)

On July 30, 2003, speech and language pathologist Diane Kirkpatrick conducted the assessment at STUDENT’s home and prepared an assessment report dated July 31, 2003. (Resp. Exh. 28.) As noted above, Ms. Kirkpatrick found that on the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals (CELF) test, which tests receptive and expressive use of language, STUDENT tested at three years below her chronological age (at the 23rd percentile). Also as noted above, Ms. Kirkpatrick did not recommend direct or pull-out speech and language services at the IEP team meeting she attended on December 9, 2003, when her assessment, and Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessment conducted at UCLA in July 2003, were discussed for the first time by an IEP team. Also, as noted above, IEP team members agreed to have an independent speech and language consultant observe STUDENT one time in class at Casa Pacifica to review her instruction and functioning levels and to make recommendations for classroom modifications or changes in approach for the teacher as needed. PARENT did not sign the IEP. (Footnote 11) (Resp. Exh. 5, Test. of Ms. Kirkpatrick and PARENT.)

Petitioner provided no credible evidence to show that she obtained the speech and language assessment at UCLA because she disagreed with any particular assessment previously conducted by Respondents. It is undisputed that as of July 2003, Respondents had not conducted a speech and language assessment of STUDENT. Moreover, there is no evidence that Petitioner ever requested an assessment in speech and language at any time during the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school years prior to Petitioner’s July 2003 UCLA hospitalization and assessment. None of the IEPs for IEP meetings held during the 2001-2002 or 2002-2003 school years prior to the July 2003 UCLA hospitalization indicate a disagreement with an assessment conducted by Respondents, let alone a request for reassessment by Respondents. Moreover, PARENT did not express disagreement with the assessment plan prepared by school psychologist Cindy Neal on February 25, 2002, and instead signed the assessment plan on that date. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Neal.)

School psychologist Cindy Neal testified that when she met with PARENT on February 25, 2002, and discussed an assessment plan to determine STUDENT’s eligibility for special education and related service after STUDENT’s February 2002 hospitalization, PARENT did not raise concerns over STUDENT’s speech and language. Instead, after the assessments were explained to her, PARENT signed the assessment plan on February 25. (Test. of Ms. Neal.) Ms. Neal also told PARENT that she would expand the assessment to include a speech and language assessment if any speech and language concerns came up during her assessment. Ms. Neal testified that no “red flags” came up during the assessment that indicated auditory processing difficulties. (Footnote 12) (Test. of Ms. Neal and Resp. Exhs. 36 and 37.)

Dr. Bednersh testified that with every notice of an IEP team meeting and every assessment plan, a copy of a notice of rights and procedural safeguards that included a notice of the parent’s right to request an assessment would have been provided to Petitioner’s parents. Moreover, Dr. Bednersh stated that STUDENT’s parent was provided with a copy of a notice of rights at every IEP team meeting that she attended. (Resp. Exh. 78.) Dr. Bednersh further testified that all parents of students enrolled in general education within Santa Barbara county also receive a rights statement at the beginning of each school year within a “back to school” notice, which references both 504 and special education rights. (Footnote 13) PARENT acknowledged receiving such notices. Thus, PARENT was aware of her right to request an assessment but did not do so.

In summary, Petitioner provided no credible evidence that she ever notified Respondents of her disagreement with a particular assessment conducted by Respondents prior to Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessments, or that Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessment was conducted because of Petitioner’s disagreement with an assessment conducted by Respondents. Instead, the credible evidence establishes that Ms. Umen’s July 2003 speech and language assessment conducted at UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital was not in response to a particular assessment conducted by Respondents. (Footnote 14) Moreover, the results of Ms. Umen’s assessment were not shared with the IEP team until the IEP team meeting was held on December 9, 2003, well after Ms. Kirkpatrick had conducted a speech and language assessment at the end of July 2003. Thus, Petitioner provides no persuasive evidence or legal authority to support reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs of Ms. Umen’s assessment. (Footnote 15) The Hearing Officer finds that the UCLA assessment was not conducted as a result of a disagreement over an assessment conducted by Respondents. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b) and tit. 34, C.F.R. § 300.502(b). The weight of the credible evidence establishes that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs relating to Ms. Umen’s assessment at public expense. (Footnote 16)

Furthermore, Petitioner provided no testimony that described the nature of the other tests conducted at UCLA during her hospitalization in July 2003 to establish any basis for reimbursement of the costs incurred for the other tests, or that showed that such tests were conducted because of Petitioner’s disagreement with any particular assessment previously conducted by Respondents. Moreover, the credible evidence establishes that STUDENT’s July 2003 hospitalization at UCLA was a medical response to an emergency psychiatric condition and not as a result of disagreement with a prior assessment conducted by Respondents. (Test. of Dr. Lockhart and PARENT.) See Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Thus, the weight of the credible evidence establishes that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with the other tests conducted during her hospitalization at UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital..

For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs associated with Petitioner’s July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

In accordance with California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each part has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement:

Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for out-of-pocket costs associated with the July 2003 UCLA Neuropsychiatric Hospital assessment that also included Ms. Ilene Umen’s speech and language assessment, all in the amount of $5,000?

Respondents prevailed on the only issue heard and decided. The remaining issues were heard but rendered moot when Petitioner withdrew all other requests for relief connected with those remaining issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision.

Dated: February 3, 2005 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The parties discussed settlement on December 1 and 2, 2004, when the case convened initially, and during the morning of December 3. Just before noon and throughout the afternoon of December 3, the Hearing Officer clarified issues and contentions with the parties after the parties could not reach a settlement agreement.

2. As noted above, Petitioner’s issues and contentions were clarified during detailed discussions by the Hearing Officer. The issues are reformatted to facilitate discussion and analysis.

3. Co-counsel for Petitioner first noted that $5,000 represented parents’ out-of-pocket expense for the UCLA hospitalization and that Petitioner “would be looking specifically at the cost for the assessment.” Petitioner did not offer or provide written documentation at hearing that reflected the cost of Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessment alone.

4. With the concurrence of Petitioner at the end of clarification of issues, the Hearing Officer struck Petitioner’s request for reimbursement for costs of advocates, reimbursement for attorney fees, and for “any and all additional costs to STUDENT’s parents in assessment and advocacy on her behalf, in pursuit of FAPE.” The Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to award the costs of advocates, for attorney fees, or for advocacy costs, including costs relating to the procurement of witness testimony.

5. Mental Health had been added as a respondent to the proceeding at the request of counsel for the respondent school agencies.

6. Dr. Binder, Dr. Corazza, and Ms. Wright did not testify at hearing. Moreover, PARENT did not provide testimony and/or written documentation to support a claim for her out-of-pocket costs for the providers’ services as initially asserted during the clarification of issues.

7. In California, a student can be eligible for special education services under SLD only if the student requires the services, whether or not there is a discrepancy between ability and achievement. (Test. of Dr. Katz.)

8. California does not require standardized testing to exit a special education student from special education. (Test. of Dr. Katz.)

9. Mr. Johnson stated that the IEP was reconstructed to the best of his ability, but PARENT was not happy that Dr. Lockhart’s signature was not on the IEP, and so a typewritten page was added to the rewritten IEP (eventually signed by PARENT on March 20, 2003) that identified the November 15 IEP meeting attendees based upon information provided by PARENT. (Test. of Mr. Johnson and PARENT.)

10. The UCLA chart variously gives an admission date of either June 30 or July 1, 2003.

11. As noted previously, PARENT eventually signed the IEP at the January 26, 2004 IEP meeting. Thereafter, Ms. Barker conducted two classroom observations at Casa Pacifica and concluded that STUDENT did not need direct or pull-out speech and language therapy services to benefit from her education. (Test. of Ms. Barker and Resp. Exhs. 3, 26, and 27.)

12. The assessment plan included an assessment for Psychomotor Development with the following handwritten entry: Test of Visual Processing & Auditory Processing. As discussed previously, the IEP team met on April 23, 2002, to discuss Ms. Neal’s assessment and concluded that STUDENT met special education eligibility criteria as a student with an emotional disturbance. The IEP notes that STUDENT’s“emotional difficulties impact her ability to focus and access the core curriculum.” (Resp. Exh. 21.)

13. STUDENT’s older brother is a student in general education within the county. (Test. of PARENT.)

14. On June 16, 2003, PARENT completed an application for an assessment to be conducted by the California Department of Education’s Diagnostic Center, Southern California. PARENT noted in the application that she was most concerned about STUDENT’s“impulsive and out of control behavior” and her acting out “violently” after getting “frustrated or agitated easily.” PARENT also expressed concerns about STUDENT’s“lack of ability to concentrate” or to sustain school work “or any other activity for over 15 minutes at a time.” The application did not indicate concerns over speech and language and did not express disagreement with an assessment previously conducted by Respondents. On August 28, 2003, the Diagnostic Center’s Admission and Review Committee (ARC) denied the application “at this time” because STUDENT’s“primary difficulties are in the mental health,” based on the IEP team decision to place STUDENTat Casa Pacifica. (Resp. Exhs. 32 and 47.) In December 2003, Respondents submitted a second application for a comprehensive assessment by the Diagnostic Center, and as noted previously, the Diagnostic Center completed its assessment during the week of February 23, 2004. (Resp. Exh. 25 and Test. of Dr. Russell.)

16. California Education Code section 56329(c) provides in pertinent part that the “public education agency may initiate a due process hearing...to show that its assessment is appropriate. If the final decision resulting from the due process hearing is that the assessment is appropriate, the parent or guardian still has the right for an independent educational assessment, but not at public expense.” Because the Hearing Officer has found that the UCLA assessment that also includes Ms. Umen’s speech and language assessment was not conducted because of disagreement with an assessment conducted by Respondents, it is unnecessary to reach section 56329(c).