California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 23, 2003
Student v. San Francisco Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 192-02 · Hearing Officer Patrick J. Balucan
San Francisco Unified must reimburse private school tuition and therapies after IEPs failed to name a specific placement.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 7-year-old girl eligible for special education under multiple disabilities filed against San Francisco Unified School District. The disputes covered four school years. The District took about six months to send an assessment plan after the June 1999 referral, and its first IEP was not held until March 2000. Each IEP offered only a type of program, first a special day class and later an "inclusion program," without naming a school or class. The parents searched for a placement themselves. Meanwhile, they paid for private preschool, 150 Parker, Laurel School, and private therapies.
Hearing Officer Patrick J. Balucan held that the late assessment and the failure to make a formal, specific written offer under Union School District v. Smith denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) from November 1999 through 2002-2003. The District's enrollment process, which assigned schools each January from parent choices, did not cure the problem. The May 2002 IEP also left out how often, how long and where therapies would be given. The Hearing Officer found the District's play-based cognitive assessment appropriate, so it did not have to pay for the private neuropsychological evaluation. The District was ordered to reimburse, less insurance payments, private OT, speech, psychological, PT and aide services, transportation, play programs, and tuition at 150 Parker and Laurel School. Claims for vision therapy and inclusion consultation were denied. The District also had to hold an IEP meeting within 10 days that names a specific school site.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO applied Union v. Smith. Offering a general program type, such as "SDC" or "inclusion," without a specific school or class was treated as a procedural violation that denied FAPE. That supported reimbursement for private school and therapies. The decision also rejected a centralized enrollment lottery as a substitute for an IEP team's placement offer.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1. Did the District provide Student a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year?
The District's late assessment plan delayed the initial IEP about four months, and the March 2000 IEP offered an unspecified special day class with no specific class or site, violating Union v. Smith; FAPE denied from November 1999 through year end.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District provide Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
The October 2000 and March 2001 IEPs offered an 'inclusion program' without a specific site or class; a later placement-center assignment to Sutro, made outside the IEP team, did not cure the defect. FAPE denied.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3. Did the District provide Student a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
The December 2001 and May 2002 IEPs again named no specific site, and the May 2002 IEP failed to state the frequency, duration and location of speech, OT and PT services. FAPE denied.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4. Did the District provide Student a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002 school year to the present?
The District's lottery-style enrollment process, which assigned special education students to schools each January from parent choices, did not produce a single specific offer and could not meet the requirement to implement IEPs promptly. FAPE denied for 2002-2003.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 5. Did the District assess Student in all areas of suspected disability when she was referred for services in June of 1999?
The play-based cognitive assessment was appropriate. However, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to assess motor needs through qualified OT/PT assessors before the initial IEP. The prevailing-party section still lists the District as the prevailing party.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 6a. Reimbursement for neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Tina Guterman
Denied because the District's cognitive assessment was appropriate and reached similar conclusions.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6b. Reimbursement for occupational therapy assessment and services by OT for Kids
The private OT assessments (Jetter, Clarke) and OT services (Clarke, Wong) are reimbursable because the District assessed late and inadequately, denied FAPE, and the services gave the student educational benefit.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6c. Reimbursement for speech and language assessment and services by Speech, Inc.
Speech, Inc. and oral-motor therapy services met the student's needs and produced progress, so they are reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6d. Reimbursement for psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass
Dr. Pass's psychosocial services and informal evaluations met the student's needs and gave her benefit. The order requires reimbursement, although the prevailing-party section lists the District.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6e. Reimbursement for vision therapy assessment and services by Dr. David Grisham
Denied because no evidence was presented about vision needs or these services.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6f. Reimbursement for physical therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions
Private PT is reimbursable only from the date FAPE was denied (November 1999 in the analysis; December 1999 in the order) forward. Parents did not have to accept the District's offer piecemeal.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6g. Reimbursement for one-to-one instructional assistance by Scott Wilson
The privately funded 1:1 aide met the student's needs and gave her educational benefit, so the cost is reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6h. Reimbursement for transportation services
Transportation is a related service, and parents were justified in arranging replacement services, so mileage is reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6i. Reimbursement for facilitated play program at Speech, Inc.
The play group addressed socialization needs and the student made progress, so it is reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6j. Reimbursement for facilitated play program at California Pacific Medical Center
The OT-centered play therapy met the student's needs and she made progress, so it is reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6k. Reimbursement for services and placement at 150 Parker, including tuition, transportation, and program materials
The 150 Parker transitional kindergarten for 2000-2001 was appropriate and beneficial, so it is reimbursable.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6l. Reimbursement for services and placement at Laurel School, including tuition, transportation, and program materials
Laurel School was appropriate and beneficial for 2001-2002 and 2002-2003. Reimbursement covers the full 2002-2003 year because a mid-year move would harm the student.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6m. Reimbursement for inclusion consultation services at 150 Parker
Denied because no evidence was presented about what these services were.
- Not reachedFAPE: services offered
Issue 7. Is Student entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District's denial of FAPE?
Moot, because reimbursement for Laurel School through the end of 2002-2003 was ordered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 15 days of proof from parents, less insurance reimbursements: OT assessments and services from Teri Jetter, Susan Clarke and Gwendolyn Wong.
- Reimbursement. Speech and language assessment and services by Speech, Inc.
- Reimbursement. Psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass.
- Reimbursement. Physical therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions from December 1999 to the present.
- Reimbursement. One-to-one instructional assistance by Scott Wilson.
- Reimbursement. Actual mileage between home and service providers, at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
- Reimbursement. Facilitated play programs at Speech, Inc. and California Pacific Medical Center.
- Reimbursement. Placement and services at 150 Parker for 2000-2001, including tuition, transportation and program materials.
- Reimbursement. Placement and services at Laurel School for 2001-2002 and 2002-2003, including tuition, transportation and program materials, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to determine placement for the next school year; the IEP must clearly state the specific school site the District deems meets the student's needs.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup; Glendale Unified v. Almasi; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Linda Lee, content specialist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Scott Wilson, private 1:1 aide, Parent-funded
- Page Hersey, private school teacher (first/second grade), Laurel School
- Sharon Rosedale, private school kindergarten teacher, Laurel School
- Gwendolyn Wong, private occupational therapist
- Kathryn Pengilly, private speech-language specialist, Speech, Inc.
- Dr. Tina Guterman, neuropsychologist, expert witness for Student
- Dr. Stephanie Pass, private psychologist
- Janet Green-Babb, private physical therapist, Developmental Progressions
- Kathleen O'Hara Hemlock, private speech-language pathologist (oral motor)
- Deborah McKnight, executive director of special education, San Francisco Unified School District
- Katharine McCauley, coordinator of designated instruction and services, San Francisco Unified School District
- Sophronia Brown Bess, program administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
- Arleen Honda, program administrator, San Francisco Unified School District
- Dorothy Fletcher, speech-language pathologist/assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Jennifer Brown, school psychologist/assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Kay Cook, content specialist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Jennifer Carothers-Liske, physical therapist/assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Marian Morales, placement specialist, Educational Placement Center, San Francisco Unified School District
- Theresa Tong, occupational therapist/assessor, San Francisco Unified School District
- Stacey Akemi Hata, occupational therapist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Dr. Minoo Shah, school psychologist, San Francisco Unified School District
- Dr. Pamela Mills, program administrator, psychological services, San Francisco Unified School District
- Shannon Kong, private speech-language pathologist/assessor
- Teri Jetter, private occupational therapist/assessor, OT for Kids
- Susan Clarke, private occupational therapist, California Pacific Medical Center
- Dr. David Grisham, private vision therapy provider
- Ms. Hurling, preschool director, St. James School
- M. Britton, inclusion consultant, 150 Parker
- Ericka Martinez, legal assistant, for the District
- Jennifer Johnston, law clerk, for the District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Francisco, California, on February 11-14 and 18-20, 2003.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Kathryn Dobel and her mother, MOTHER. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf during some parts of the hearing was FATHER, her father. Respondent San Francisco Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Susan Marks and Katharine McCauley, the District’s coordinator of designated instruction and services (DIS). Also present on behalf of the District during various parts of the hearing were Sophronia Brown Bess and Arleen Honda, program administrators with the District, and Deborah McKnight, the District’s executive director of special education. Present at some parts of the hearing on behalf of the District were Ericka Martinez, legal assistant, and Jennifer Johnston, law clerk.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: Linda Lee, a content specialist with the District; MOTHER; Scott Wilson, STUDENT’s one-on-one aide; FATHER; Page Hersey, STUDENT’s teacher at the Laurel School; Gwendolyn Wong, an occupational therapist; Kathryn Pengilly, a speech and language specialist; Dr. Tina Guterman, a neuropsychologist; Dr. Stephanie Pass, a psychologist; Janet Green-Babb, a physical therapist; and Kathleen O’Hara Hemlock, a speech and language pathologist. The District called the following witnesses to testify: Ms. McKnight; Ms. McCauley; Dorothy Fletcher, a District speech and language specialist; Jennifer Brown, a District psychologist; Ms. Lee; Kay Cook, a District content specialist; Jennifer Carothers-Liske, a District physical therapist; Marian Morales, a placement specialist with the District; Theresa Tong, a District occupational therapist; Stacey Akemi Hata, a District occupational therapist; Dr. Minoo Shah, a District psychologist; and Dr. Pamela Mills, the District’s program administrator over psychological services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the receipt of closing briefs. After receipt of the closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
3. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
4. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002 school year to the present?
5. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability when she was referred for services in June of 1999?
6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses: a. Neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Tina Guterman;
b. Occupational therapy assessment and services by OT for Kids; c. Speech and Language assessment and services by Speech, Inc.; d. Psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass;
e. Vision Therapy assessment and services by Dr. David Grisham; f. Physical Therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions; g. One-to-one instructional assistance by Scott Wilson;
h. Transportation services;
i. Facilitated play program at Speech, Inc.;
j. Facilitated play program at California Pacific Medical Center; k. Services and placement at150 Parker, including tuition, transportation, and program materials; l. Services and placement Laurel school, including tuition, transportation, and program materials; and m. Inclusion consultation services at 150 Parker.
7. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of FAPE?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
At the close of hearing, Ms. Marks requested that Petitioner supply documentation of reimbursements her parents had received from their insurance company for services provided to her. Over no objection from Petitioner, the record was held open for receipt of the additional evidence. On February 26, 2003, the Hearing Officer received Petitioner’s reimbursement summary indicating a compilation of insurance payments received by PARENTS. The document was accompanied by a letter from Ms. Dobel indicating that these figures are related to those documents found in Petitioner’s Ex. 86, which was admitted into evidence at the hearing. On February 27, 2003, the Hearing Officer received a letter from Ms. Marks, indicating no objection to the document. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer admitted those documents submitted by Petitioner in their reimbursement summary, and those pages were added to Petitioner’s Ex. 86.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seven-year old student, identified as eligible for special education with multiple disabilities. STUDENT experienced difficulty breathing during the first week after birth. Early in life, she continued to have difficulty breathing, which caused sleep apnea and loud snoring. At the age of 17 months, STUDENT had a tonsillectormy and an adenoidectomy, and she also had tubes placed in her ears. Her neuropsychologist, Dr. Guterman, has diagnosed her with a central nervous system disorder not otherwise specified. Her psychologist, Dr. Pass, testified that her disability manifests itself as similar to autism because STUDENT displays self-stimulatory behaviors, sensitivity to environmental stimuli, and shows obvious difficulties in relating to her peers.(Footnote 2) STUDENT has never attended school within the District, and currently attends the Laurel School, a private school not certified by the State of California as a non-public school (NPS).
For pre-school, STUDENT attended the St. James School at her parents’ expense. While STUDENT was attending St. James, the director, Ms. Hurling, suggested that STUDENT might require the services of a one-to-one paraprofessional. Ms. Hurling recommended that MOTHER contact the District about receiving those services from the District. According to MOTHER, she contacted the District sometime in May of 1999 in order to obtain special education services for STUDENT.(Footnote 3) On June 22, 1999, as a result of MOTHER’s inquiries, the District generated an Early Childhood Special Education Referral and Intake form, which indicated that MOTHER was seeking services from the District. The intake included the following areas of concern: speech and language, motor skills and behavior.
Because of her concerns with STUDENT’s deficits, MOTHER asked Shannon Kong, a speech and language pathologist, to assess STUDENT. Ms. Kong assessed STUDENT and issued a report on August 10, 1999. Ms. Kong found that STUDENT was mildly delayed in the area of auditory comprehension and also scored in the low average range in the area of expressive communication and expressive vocabulary. STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills and auditory processing skills appeared to be exceptional. However, Ms. Kong warned that the scores were inconclusive and that STUDENT’s language skills in these areas might actually be higher due to STUDENT’s non-compliance on several items. Ms. Kong noted behavioral difficulties, specifically that STUDENT often became agitated. Eight sessions were required to complete STUDENT’s assessment.
In the fall of 1999, STUDENT again attended pre-school at the St. James School. Up until this time, MOTHER had still not heard from the District regarding her request for special education services. STUDENT attended this pre-school at her parents’ expense.
In September of 1999, STUDENT began receiving private physical therapy services from Janet Green-Babb. Ms. Green-Babb testified that when she first met STUDENT, she displayed difficulties with her balance and equilibrium. Ms. Babb further testified that she noted concerns with STUDENT’s lack of postural tone, hyper mobility in her joints, and a compromised walking pattern. She also stated that STUDENT displayed visual and auditory processing difficulties. Because of these concerns, STUDENT began attending weekly, one-hour physical therapy sessions with Ms. Green-Babb.
Shortly after STUDENT began her physical therapy sessions, PARENTS sought the services of Teri Jetter, a therapist with OT for Kids in order to obtain an evaluation of STUDENT’s sensory and motor needs. Ms. Jetter conducted her evaluation in October and November of 1999 and issued a report of her findings. Ms. Jetter identified difficulties in the areas of balance and equilibrium, muscle tone, bilateral integration and coordination, motor planning, manual dexterity, visual and visual-motor abilities, sensory processing of tactile and auditory stimuli. Ms. Jetter recommended occupational therapy on an individual basis, one time per week for one hour sessions, the implementation of a sensory diet and motor based home program, and collaboration with a pediatric optometrist to address vision needs. In February of 2000, STUDENT began OT sessions with Susan Clarke at the California Pacific Medical Center.
Meanwhile, pursuant to the request for assessment, the District provided PARENTS with an assessment plan in December of 1999. The assessment plan called for the following areas to be tested: Cognitive Development/Thinking Strategies, Motor/Perceptual Development, Communication Development, Social/Emotional/Adaptive Behavior, Educational/Academic, and Hearing. MOTHER signed the assessment plan on December 4, 1999, and returned it to the District.
After PARENTS signed and returned the assessment plan, the District scheduled STUDENT’s assessment for February 29, 2000. Jennifer Brown, a District psychologist and Dorothy Fletcher, a speech and language pathologist, conducted the District’s initial assessment of STUDENT. Their report noted that MOTHER referred STUDENT for assessment because of concerns regarding her fine and gross motor skills, behavior and communication. It also noted MOTHER’s concerns regarding STUDENT’s social skills. Ms. Brown and Ms. Fletcher used a play-based approach to assess STUDENT, in which STUDENT was given the opportunity to play independently with numerous toys and books that were placed around the room. The assessors also used items from standardized tests, albeit in a non-standardized manner, to assess STUDENT. Ms. Brown and Ms. Fletcher found that STUDENT displayed average potential in the area of cognitive/pre-readiness skills, but noted weaknesses in her self-help skills, socialization, and fine and gross motor skills. In the area of communication, the report noted that STUDENT displayed good receptive and expressive language skills and intelligibility. However, STUDENT displayed uneven pragmatic skills (defined in the report as how effectively and appropriately language and behaviors are used to communicate with others) during the evaluation.
Shortly after the District’s assessment, and at the urging of Ms. Jetter, PARENTS sought the services of Susan Clarke, another OT. Ms. Jetter referred STUDENT to Ms. Clarke because of STUDENT’s difficulties modulating her responses to sensory input from her tactile, auditory, visual, vestibular and propioceptive systems. Because of the difficulty modulating her responses to these sensory inputs, STUDENT was not able to maintain proper arousal to allow for full participation in any task. At PARENTS’ expense, Ms. Clarke conducted an assessment and prepared a sensory diet for STUDENT. Ms. Clarke prepared a report dated March 23, 2000, in which she recommended the implementation of a sensory diet in order to maintain the proper level of arousal.
On March 28, 2000, MOTHER and the District convened the first meeting to develop an individualized education program (IEP) for STUDENT. At that meeting, the team found that STUDENT qualified for special education with multiple disabilities because she displayed difficulties in more that one area, including speech and language, gross and fine motor, and social areas. At that meeting, the team decided upon placement in a special day class (SDC) with speech and language services consisting of a combination of small group and individual consultation for sixty minutes a week. In addition, the IEP team made referrals for occupational and physical therapy assessments and mental health services. On April 3, 2000, MOTHER signed the IEP, indicating that she agreed with the recommendations and consenting to the implementation of the IEP.
After this IEP meeting, MOTHER observed several of the District’s pre-kindergarten SDC classes. Via letter dated May 31, 2000, MOTHER indicated her preference for the program at Muir Elementary School. However, Marian Morales, the District’s placement specialist, indicated to PARENTS that Muir was not an appropriate placement for STUDENT because it was a pre-kindergarten class, and STUDENT would be 5 at the start of the 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT never enrolled at Muir.
Sometime in late March of 2000, at the recommendation of Ms. Kong (STUDENT’s occupational therapist), STUDENT’s parents arranged for her to receive speech and language services from Kathryn Pengilly, private speech and language specialist with Speech Inc. According to Ms. Pengilly’s testimony, STUDENT presented with uneven performance in several areas. While STUDENT was advanced in some areas and age level in others, she displayed deficits in expressive and receptive language, and articulation. Ms. Pengilly’s initial impression was that group services were not appropriate for STUDENT, and she recommended services on an individual basis twice a week for 60 minutes. On May 8, 2000, at her parents’ expense, STUDENT began receiving these services from Speech, Inc.
At approximately this time, in the Spring of 2000, STUDENT also began receiving private psychological services from Dr. Stephanie Pass. According to Dr. Pass’ testimony, when she first met STUDENT, STUDENT was anxious and unregulated, and had difficulties modulating her arousal. Dr. Pass’ concerns were that her fluctuating arousal states would make it difficult for her to develop social relationships with her peers, as well as affect her ability to pay attention and learn in class. STUDENT also displayed self-stimulating behaviors, including self-talking.(Footnote 4) She tended to disengage and recite Disney videos to herself. Because of these concerns, PARENTS arranged regular developmental play sessions with Dr. Pass in order to develop STUDENT’s ability to regulate herself. MOTHER also attended these sessions in order for her learn to understand STUDENT’s cues.
Pursuant to the referral for additional assessments made at the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting, the District conducted occupational therapy and physical therapy assessments of STUDENT. On June 28, 2000, Jennifer Carothers-Liske conducted the District’s physical therapy assessment and prepared her report. During this assessment, STUDENT displayed deficits in strength, balance, bilateral coordination, motor planning and sensory processing. Ms. Carothers-Liske recommended that District staff consult with STUDENT’s classroom teachers to provide her with activities and strategies that would promote her gross motor development in her educational environment. Ms. Carothers-Liske recommended only consultation because STUDENT was already receiving physical therapy services from her private providers.
Also on June 28, 2000, Theresa Tong conducted the District’s occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT and prepared a report. Ms. Tong’s report indicated that STUDENT had not developed hand dominance specific to tool use, had difficulties crossing the midline, and showed a confused development of writing skills.(Footnote 5) Based on these results, Ms. Tong recommended that STUDENT receive OT services to address her fine motor and visual motor skills.
In September of 2000, based upon the recommendation with Ms. Green-Babb, STUDENT’s parents began providing her with OT services from Gwendolyn Wong. Ms. Wong testified at hearing that when she first saw STUDENT, she noted STUDENT had low muscle tone and endurance. She noticed STUDENT displayed difficulty planning movement, a lack of organization, and difficulty regulating herself. She also noted that STUDENT displayed temper tantrums when she was faced with challenges, but that when she was successful, she was “delightful and funny.” At that time, Ms. Wong co-treated STUDENT during her PT session with Ms. Green Babb. At approximately this time, STUDENT’s parents also began providing her with the one-to-one aide services of Scott Wilson, in order to help with her social interaction. Mr. Wilson worked with STUDENT during her PT and OT sessions with Ms. Green-Babb and Ms. Wong. He also worked with her during a few home visits and eventually, at some pre-school visits at 150 Parker.
For the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended a transitional kindergarten class at 150 Parker, a private school. PARENTS provided the 150 Parker placement at their own expense.
Shortly after she began attending the 150 Parker, MOTHER requested, via letter dated October 6, 2000, an inclusion placement at the Clare Lilienthal School. When she was told that the inclusion placement at Lillienthal was unavailable, MOTHER again wrote to the District on October 26, 2000, and requested the inclusion program at the Sutro School. MOTHER was again told that there was no inclusion placement available at Sutro. She continued to look for placement within the District for STUDENT.
On October 16, 2000, the IEP team met to discuss the results of the OT and PT assessments conducted by the District. At this meeting, the IEP team continued the offer of speech and language services in a small group and consultation for 60 minutes per week, PT consultation 30 minutes per month, and OT service 1-2 times per week for 30 minutes. Pre-school early intervention services (PEI) were added, and STUDENT’s placement was changed from the SDC class to an inclusion program. STUDENT received OT services from the District once a week for 30 minutes. She continued to receive her private OT, PT, speech and language and psychological services.
On January 22, 2001, MOTHER again wrote the District requesting a full inclusion placement for STUDENT. Having been told that there was no inclusion placement for STUDENT at the Sutro School, MOTHER again wrote a letter to the District requesting that STUDENT be placed at the Argonne School.
Meanwhile, PARENTS asked Susan Clarke, STUDENT’s occupational therapist with the California Pacific Medical Center, to conduct another OT assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Clark conducted her OT assessment, at PARENTS’ expense, in January through March of 2001 and prepared a report dated March 4, 2001. In that report, Ms. Clarke noted improvement in modulation related to body position and movement, and some improvement in modulation related to sensory input affecting emotional responses, emotional/social responses, and planning tasks. However, Ms. Clarke also noted areas of concern related to STUDENT’s sensory processing, social skills, gross motor and fine motor, visual/perceptual, and self-care. Ms. Clarke recommended continuing the OT and PT services provided by the District, as well as the private OT and PT services provided by PARENTS.
On March 12, 2001, the IEP team met again to conduct an annual review of STUDENT’s program. The team continued to recommend an inclusion placement in the District, direct OT services and consultation one to two times per week for 30 minutes, direct PT services and consultation one time a week for 30 minutes, and individual and group speech and language services two times per week for 60 minutes total. On March 9, 2001, MOTHER signed this IEP, indicating that she agreed with the recommendations and consenting to its implementation. However, MOTHER disagreed with the omission of a one-to-one paraprofessional to assist STUDENT during her school day. MOTHER indicated on the IEP that she felt that STUDENT needed the one-to-one paraprofessional to assist STUDENT throughout her school day.
In the meantime, having not heard from the District regarding her request for inclusion placement at the Argonne school, MOTHER again wrote a letter dated March 29, 2001 to the District for placement at the Sutro School. Based on MOTHER’s request, the District placed STUDENT in the inclusion program at the Sutro School for the 2001-2002 school year. PARENTS accepted the Sutro school placement. However, PARENTS continued to object to the inclusion placement at Sutro without the services of a one-to-one aide. Because the District would not provide a one-to-one aide specifically for STUDENT, PARENTS did not place STUDENT at Sutro.(Footnote 6)
In July of 2001, PARENTS obtained additional speech and language services for STUDENT from Kate O’Hara-Hemlock. Ms. O’Hara-Hemlock specializes in working with children with oral motor musculature speech disorders. During her initial visit with STUDENT, she noted areas of concern with STUDENT’s oral motor skills related to her cheek and jowl work. She indicated that STUDENT was unable to voluntarily inhale, smell or sniff, and that she had difficulty with eating. Because of these difficulties, Ms. O’Hara-Hemlock began an oral motor therapy program for STUDENT to strengthen the muscles in the oral area and to develop use of her lips and tongue.
Around this time, PARENTS also obtained a neuropsychological evaluation from Dr. Tina Guterman. Dr. Guterman conducted an evaluation in August and September of 2001 and prepared a report outlining her findings. Dr. Guterman diagnosed STUDENT with a severe neurodevelopmental disorder demonstrated through diffuse regulatory and learning deficits. She found that STUDENT’s overall verbal cognitive functioning skills were solidly in the average range, and that her abilities for comprehension and concept formation were in the average to high average range. She also found that STUDENT required a high degree of support and structure for non-verbal problem solving. The report also noted that STUDENT’s neurocognitive disorders negatively impacted her ability to relate to her peers, initiate and sustain appropriate conversation, read non-verbal cues, and modulate her output, which included her emotional responses.
For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT began attending the Laurel School for kindergarten. She was provided this placement at her parents’ expense. At the time she attended the Laurel School, STUDENT was receiving the following services funded privately through her parents: speech therapy with Ms. O’Hara-Hemlock one hour per week; speech therapy with Speech, Inc. for two hours per week; OT from Ms. Wong for two hours per week; PT from Ms. Green-Babb for 1 hour per week; psycho-social therapy from Dr. Pass for one hour per week; vision therapy from Dr. Grisham for one hour per month; and paraprofessional services from Scott Wilson for 20 hours per week. In addition, STUDENT was receiving OT and PT services from the District for a total of 1 to 1 ½ hours per week. STUDENT never received the LAS services called for in her IEP.
On December 10, 2001, another IEP team meeting was held. The purpose of this meeting was to add the services of a one-to-one aide specifically for STUDENT, to update the OT and PT services being offered, and to review the report prepared by Dr. Guterman. The IEP offered both OT and PT services, each for 1 time per week for 30 minutes on an individual and consultative basis. The services of a one-to-one aide were also written into the IEP. However, the IEP was written to include the aide support in the classroom for only four months in the inclusion program; the decision to provide the aide support would then be reassessed in April of 2002. On December 17, 2000, PARENTS wrote a letter to the District in which they stated that while they agreed with the goals and services of the this IEP, they did not agree with the placement and the supports for school personnel contained in the IEP.
Via letter dated January 29, 2002, Petitioner requested this due process hearing.
On May 14, 2002 Petitioner and the District again convened a meeting of the IEP team. At this IEP meeting, STUDENT was again offered an inclusion placement with a one-to-one aid; the need for an aide would then be reassessed in four months. There were no service specifications for STUDENT’s speech and language, OT and PT services. Instead, the IEP indicates that those services would be offered if STUDENT enrolled in an SFUSD site. Via letter dated May 24, 2002, PARENTS indicated their disagreement with the IEP. Around this time, in May of 2002, because STUDENT had reached the age of 7, the District discontinued STUDENT’s OT and PT services through the District.(Footnote 7)
In September of 2002, PARENTS again enrolled STUDENT in the Laurel School, at their own expense, for the 2002-2003 school year. She was placed in Page Hersey’s first and second grade combination class. During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was receiving the following services at her parents’ expense: speech therapy with Kate O’Hara Hemlock and Speech, Inc.; OT with Ms. Wong; PT with Ms. Green-Babb; psychosocial therapy with Dr. Pass; vision therapy with Dr. David Grisham; and one-to-one aide through Scott Wilson. She was no longer receiving OT and PT services from the District. At the time of this Decision, STUDENT was not attending school in the District.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District has denied her a FAPE from the 1999-2000 school year to the present. For the 1999-2000 school year, Petitioner argues that the District committed procedural violations of the IDEA that denied her a FAPE. In particular, Petitioner argues that the District failed to timely conduct an IEP meeting after the initial referral for assessment in June of 1999. Furthermore, when the District finally conducted its assessment, Petitioner argues that it failed to adequately assess her cognitive abilities, and failed to fully assess STUDENT based upon her parents’ areas of concern. Petitioner also contends that, for the 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to offer Petitioner a FAPE. Petitioner argues that the District’s offer of placement for this year failed to offer any services to meet her gross and fine motor needs. Petitioner also contends that the District’s program failed to address her delays in social skills.
For the 2000-2001 school year, Petitioner argues that the District continued to fail to provide the services to adequately address gross and fine motor skills through the next meeting of the IEP team on October 16, 2000. Petitioner also argues that when the District finally made an offer for OT and PT services at that IEP meeting, its offer was insufficient for STUDENT to make progress. Petitioner also argued that the District’s offer of group speech and language was insufficient, and that the District’s offer failed to address her sensory issues and social skills deficits.
Petitioner also contends that the District failed to provide FAPE to STUDENT for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner argues that the OT, PT and speech and language services offered by the District were insufficient, and that the District continued to fail to address Petitioner’s sensory issues and social skills deficits. Petitioner further contends that she should have been provided with a one-to-one paraprofessional assigned to her for the full day while attending the District’s inclusion program.
For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner contends that the District continued to deny Petitioner a FAPE for the reasons stated above.
The District responds they have offered an appropriate program to Petitioner for all the years at issue. For the 1999-2000 school year, the District asserts that while the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting to discuss its initial assessment was late, Petitioner did not suffer any prejudice because STUDENT continued to attend private school for the remainder of the school year. Furthermore, the District argued that it has offered an appropriate program that met Petitioner’s unique needs for each of the school years at issue. Specifically, it asserts that Petitioner did not require the services of a one-to-one paraprofessional specifically assigned to her in order to benefit from her education.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
Pursuant to the IDEA and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepare them for employment and independent living. (20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Edu. Code §5600.) A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents, that meets the unique needs of the child. (20 U.S.C. §1401(25); Cal.Edu.Code § 56031.) “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. §1401(22).) State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).)
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. (Id. at 205.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (Id. at 1484.) Procedural violations may result in a denial of FAPE if they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (Id.)
Therefore, the inquiry in IDEA cases is twofold. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206.) The first question is whether the school district has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA. (Id.) The second is whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures is reasonably calculated to enable the student to receive an educational benefit. (Id. at 207.) The school district has the burden of proving at an administrative hearing that it has complied with the IDEA, including that it provided an appropriate educational placement for the student. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).) For the 1999-2000 school year, Petitioner has alleged that the District failed to provide her with an appropriate program.
1. Compliance with procedural requirements Petitioner alleges that the program offered by the District for the 1999-2000 school year did not meet the requirements of state and federal law. The District responds that its program offer provided STUDENT with a FAPE. However, before addressing the issue of whether the District’s offer constituted a FAPE, the Hearing Officer first determines whether the District’s offer of placement complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA. In this case, the District failed to make an appropriate offer of placement at the initial IEP meeting on March 28, 2000.
a. Timeliness of District’s Assessments
Petitioner contends that the District failed to conduct its assessments in a timely manner. The law requires that a proposed assessment plan be developed within 15 calendar days of the referral for assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code. § 56321(a).) Exceptions to this timeline are permitted if the referral is made during school vacation periods in excess of 5 calendar days, and in such cases, the assessment plan shall be developed within 10 days after the commencement of the subsequent regular school year of the pupil’s regular school term. (Id.) An individualized education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil must be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 calendar days from the date of the receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code §56344.)
The evidence establishes that STUDENT was referred for assessment on June 22, 1999, via a telephone call from MOTHER to the District.(Footnote 8) (District’s Ex. 2) It is undisputed that STUDENT’s assessment plan was not provided to her parents until sometime in December of 1999, and that PARENTS did not sign the assessment plan and provide their consent until December 4, 1999. (District’s Ex. 5.) The District admits that it was tardy in convening the IEP to discuss these assessments. The District argues that, based upon the date PARENTS signed the assessment plan, the assessments and the IEP would have had to have been completed by February of 2000. STUDENT’s initial IEP to discuss these assessments was not held until March 28, 2000, and therefore, the District asserts, it was only one month late in conducting the assessments. However, the timelines governing the referral and assessment process begin at the point the referral is made, not at the time the District provides the parents with an assessment plan. In this case, after the initial referral for assessment on June 22, 1999, the District was required within 15 days to develop an assessment plan. (Cal. Educ. Code §56321(a).) Even assuming, as the District argues, that these timelines did not run in the summer, the latest that an assessment plan should have been provided to the parents would have been 10 days after the commencement of the 1999-2000 school year. (Id.) Assuming that PARENTS would have responded as quickly as they responded to the assessment plan actually provided to them in early December 1999 (which they signed on December 4, 1999), it is reasonable to assume that the District should have conducted their assessment and convened an IEP by approximately the second week of November, 1999. Instead, the District did not provide the assessment until December of 1999, assessments weren’t completed until February of 2000, and the IEP meeting to discuss these assessments was not held until March 28, 2000. Thus, the District’s failure to provide a timely assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents caused approximately a four-month delay in its initial IEP offer.(Footnote 9) Therefore, the timeliness of the assessment and IEP was clearly outside the statutory mandates.
As noted earlier, procedural violations result in a denial of FAPE only when they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483.) In this case, the District’s delay resulted in lost educational opportunity for STUDENT. The District’s failure to conduct these assessments and convene an IEP meeting delayed the point at which PARENTS should have received an offer of a FAPE. Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that, due to the District’s failure to timely assess STUDENT, the District denied her a FAPE for the four-month period between November of 1999 (when an IEP meeting to discuss the assessments should have been held), when an IEP should have been held, and March 28, 2000 (when STUDENT’s initial IEP team meeting was actually held.)
b. Formal Written Offer of Placement
Among the procedural violations that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA's procedural requirements. (Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. §1415(b)(3).) In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated, "this formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe it should be enforced rigorously." (Id.) The Court went on to discuss the reasons for imposing the requirement: (1) to alert the parents of the need to consider seriously whether the proposed placement was appropriate under the IDEA; (2) to help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) so that the district is more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement. (Id.)
In this case, the District failed to make a formal written offer of placement for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year at the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting or at any time thereafter. At that IEP meeting, STUDENT was found eligible for special education with multiple disabilities, classified as non-severe. The District’s offer of placement consisted of an SDC, with 60 minutes per week of small group and consultation speech and language services. However, in this IEP, the District failed to designate a specific class or school site where STUDENT would be attending her SDC class. As will be discussed more fully below, without offering to STUDENT a specific SDC class at a specific site, the District has failed to make a formal written offer of placement that met the requirements of Union.
Ms. Morales, the placement specialist who works in the educational placement center (EPC), testified that, at the time of the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting, the District’s placement procedure required the parents to fill out an enrollment request form, which could include as many as five choices of schools. That form would be submitted to the EPC, those choices would be entered into a computer, and the student would be randomly assigned a school site. The school site choices were based on the placement specification called for in the IEP – in this case, an SDC class. If the student was not assigned a school placement by the computer, then EPC staff would work with the family to try and find a suitable placement for the child.
This placement policy did not ensure that PARENTS were provided with a formal and specific offer of placement. First, the placement offer is driven by parental choice, not by a District offer of what it believes is an appropriate educational placement for the child. Second, the placement policy is not consistent with the requirements of Union. The March 28, 2000 IEP offered an unspecified SDC class within the District. Ms. McKnight, testified that the SDC classes available within the District are varied. There are over 120 schools in the District. Ms. McKnight testified that SDC classes can range from 12-14 students for mildly to moderately handicapped individuals, to classes with a maximum of 10 students for the severely handicapped. Ms. McKnight further testified that these classes are usually staffed with one or two paraprofessional aides. Based on these parameters, STUDENT’s classroom placement could have run the gamut from a class of fewer than 10 students to a class of 14, with peers that are mildly to moderately handicapped or severely disabled. Under the reasoning of Union, it is clear they parents are not required to run around to 120, or even 5, school sites to locate a program that might believe meets their child’s needs. To the contrary, the District must offer a specific placement that the parent can readily identify and decide whether to accept or reject.
Furthermore, the Hearing Officer notes that, by offering STUDENT a placement in an SDC without specifying a specific class or school site, the District implied that all of their available SDC placements were appropriate. However, the District did not present any evidence that every one of the SDC placements in the District was appropriate for STUDENT. California special education law defines “educational placement” as that “unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program.” (5 Cal. Code. of Regs. § 3042(A).) At a minimum, a district must be able to demonstrate at hearing that it considered the above factors in making its decision. The District failed to do so. Further, Courts have held that Union requires that a district formally offer a single, specific program. (See e.g., Glendale Unified School District v. Almasi, (C.D. Cal. 2000) 122 F. Supp. 1093; 33 IDELR 221.) Offering a variety of placements would require a parent to eliminate potentially inappropriate placements and make it more difficult for a parent to decide whether to accept or challenge a school district’s placement.(Footnote 10) (Id.) Thus, by merely designating an SDC class without specifying in which class STUDENT would be placed did not meet the Union and IDEA requirement of a formal written offer of placement.
Procedural violations result in a denial of FAPE only when they result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. (W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483.) Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a specific, written offer of placement in the 1999-2000 school year that satisfied the requirements of the IDEA and Union, and this denied Petitioner a FAPE. Combined with the fact that the District was four months late in even making an offer of placement, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT was denied a FAPE from November of 1999 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year.(Footnote 11)
2. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs
For the 1999-2000 school year, Petitioner contends that the District failed to offer a program that addressed petitioner’s motor issues and psychosocial issues, due to their failure to adequately assess these areas. However, the Hearing Officer has already found that the District denied a FAPE to STUDENT because of its failure to provide to her a formal, written offer of placement pursuant to Union and the IDEA. Therefore, it is unnecessary to determine whether her program substantively constituted a FAPE.
Issue No. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
As noted previously, the inquiry under the IDEA is two-fold: first, whether the school district has complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA; and second, whether the IEP developed through the IDEA’s procedures is reasonably calculated to enable the student to receive an educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207.) The Hearing Officer will first determine whether the District has met the procedural requirement of the IDEA by providing PARENTS with a formal written offer of placement in the 2000-2001 school year pursuant to the IDEA and Union. (See above.)
1. Compliance with procedural requirements
STUDENT’s first IEP meeting for this school year occurred on October 16, 2000. (District’s Ex. 19.) The purpose of this meeting was to discuss OT and PT assessments that had been conducted by the District in June of that year. (Id.) At this meeting, the District’s offer of placement included continuing the offer of speech and language services in a small group and consultation for 60 minutes per week, PT consultation 30 minutes per month, and OT service one to two times per week for 30 minutes. The IEP indicates that pre-school early intervention services (PEI) were added, and STUDENT’s placement was changed from the SDC class to an inclusion program. (Id.) However, the IEP does not indicate which school site or specific class STUDENT would attend. (Id.) On March 12, 2001, the District convened another meeting of the IEP team. The District again offered an inclusion placement, but again, it did not designate a specific school site or classroom.
Ms. McKnight testified that the inclusion program involved a placement in a general education classroom and is available in about 40% of the District’s schools. The student is actually placed in a general educational classroom, and the general education teacher is the teacher of record for the student. However, schools with this inclusion placement program also have an inclusion support teacher assigned to the school, who provides situational modification and supports to the general education teacher, including participating in team teaching, providing in-class support, and assisting with modifications of the grade level curriculum. The inclusion program also includes support from one-to-one paraprofessionals; however, Ms. McKnight testified that that paraprofessionals are not assigned to specific individuals. Ms. McKnight further testified that the inclusion program would include a maximum of 12 students for a school site, but that enrollment at these programs in SFUSD schools usually is much lower. The District’s goal is to place only one special education student in any general education classroom by grade.
Based on the testimony of Ms. McKnight, the Hearing Officer finds that, much like the District’s offer of an SDC placement in the 1999-2000 school year, the offer of an inclusion placement would vary from class to class. Based upon Ms. McKnight’s description of the program, each inclusion placement would be unique, dependant upon the number of general education students in the school and the amount of support that the inclusion teacher and aides could provide to the special education student. By merely stating in the IEP that STUDENT would be placed in an inclusion class, the District’s offers in November and March 2001 for the 2000-2001 school year were riddled with the same procedural flaws as the offer for the 1999-2000 school year and violated the requirements of a specific written offer of placement under Union.
The evidence establishes that the District’s failure to provide a formal written offer of a specific classroom or school site hampered PARENTS’ efforts to locate a school for STUDENT to attend. As noted in the previous section, the District made no specific offer of placement in March of 2000. As a result, at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT had no offer of a public school placement. Shortly after the March 28, 2000 IEP, MOTHER observed 4 different SDC pre-kindergarten classes in order to attempt to find an appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 12) For the 2000-2001 school year, MOTHER requested a pre-kindergarten placement for STUDENT despite the fact that STUDENT would be 5-years-old by the fall of 2000, because she felt that STUDENT was still not ready for kindergarten. MOTHER observed the pre-kindergarten classes at McKinley, John Muir, and D’Avila schools, and the Presidio Child Development Center. (Petitioner’s Ex. 21.) In observing these SDC placements, MOTHER found that the D’Avila SDC was for children with limited language skills, McKinley’s SDC was for the remediation of language skills, and the Presidio, with 34 students, was too large a class for STUDENT’s needs.(Footnote 13) MOTHER then requested the John Muir SDC class as STUDENT’s most appropriate placement, due to its small class size and excellent teacher. Via letter dated July 14, 2002, PARENTS received notice from the District indicating that she had been placed in the pre-kindergarten, non-severe SDC class. (Petitioner’s Ex. 24.) Shortly after the placement, however, Ms. Morales contacted PARENTS and informed them that the pre-kindergarten SDC placement at John Muir was inappropriate because STUDENT was turning five and was too old for the pre-kindergarten class. MOTHER testified that she was not offered another placement, and she was told that there was no school that could serve her on a pre-school level. A written offer of placement from the District, indicating a classroom or a school site, would have eliminated the need for MOTHER to embark on her Goldilocks-like quest to find a placement that was “just right.” A formal written offer of placement would also have alerted MOTHER that the school site she finally decided upon was inappropriate for STUDENT due to her age. As it stood, by the time the following school year had started, STUDENT still did not have a school assignment.
In October of 2000, after the IEP meeting that changed the placement offer to inclusion, MOTHER observed several inclusion classes and requested that STUDENT be allowed to attend the inclusion placement at the Clare Lillienthal School. (Petitioner’s Ex. 27.) PARENTS were told that the Lillienthal school was unavailable, which prompted them to request placement at the Sutro school. (Petitioner’s Ex. 32.) The District again told PARENTS that there were no inclusion placements available at Sutro. In January of 2001, PARENTS wrote another letter to the District and requested the Argonne School. (Petitioner’s Ex. 34.) However, in March of 2001, having received no response, PARENTS again wrote a letter to the District requesting placement at the Sutro school. (District’s Ex. 44.) Finally, in April of 2001, the District honored PARENTS’ request, and placed STUDENT at Sutro. (Petitioner’s Ex. 46.)
The District cannot argue that finally offering a placement at Sutro “cures” the defective offer of placement made at the October 2000 IEP meeting. Union requires that districts make a formal written offer of an appropriate educational placement. (Union, 15 F.3d at 1526.) Merely coming to a conclusion that Sutro was an appropriate placement for STUDENT because there was space available did not meet these requirements. The evidence presented at hearing was that Marian Morales and her staff at the Educational Placement Center made the placement at Sutro, after considerable effort from FATHER to find a placement for their daughter. Ms. Morales testified that she was not part of any of STUDENT’s IEPs, and the placement was not made by an IEP team considering whether the Sutro school placement met STUDENT’s unique needs. Merely finding a placement for STUDENT as a matter of convenience to the District does not cure its responsibility to make a formal written offer of an appropriate educational placement. Because the District failed to offer a specific placement, STUDENT did not receive the special education she required to address her needs for the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
2. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Programs
Because the Hearing Officer has already found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to make a formal written offer of placement for the 2000-2001 school year, it is unnecessary to determine whether the District’s program offered STUDENT a FAPE.
Issue No. 3: Did the District provide STUDENT with FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year?
In the 2001-2002 school year, the District held two IEP meetings for STUDENT. On December 10, 2001, the District held an IEP to offer an inclusion placement and to add a trial period of a one-to-one aide. The inclusion placement did not state a specific class or school site for STUDENT to attend. On May 14, 2002, another IEP team meeting convened. At this IEP meeting, the District again offered an inclusion placement without stating specifically the school site or placement STUDENT was to attend. This IEP also did not state STUDENT’s speech, PT and OT services, instead it indicated that they would be offered when STUDENT enrolled in a District school.(Footnote 14)
As noted previously, the failure of the District to set forth in the IEP a specific school site constitutes a violation of the requirement under the IDEA and Union of a formal written offer of placement. Moreover, the failure of the District to add the specifics of STUDENT’s speech, PT and OT services at the May 14, 2002 IEP meeting is contrary to federal and State law which requires that the IEP specify the frequency, duration and location of such services. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vi); Cal.Edu.Code § 56345(a)(6).) By failing to put the specific offer of these services in the IEP, PARENTS were not given enough information to evaluate the program being offered by the District, and thus were denied the opportunity to participate in the formation of STUDENT’s IEP. Because of the failure of the District to provide a formal written offer of placement, and because the offer of services failed to meet the requirements of applicable law, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
Issue No. 4: Did the District provide STUDENT with a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002 school year to the present?
The May 14, 2002 IEP governed STUDENT’s placement for the 2002-2003 school year. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District failed to make an appropriate offer of placement in that IEP.
In the 2002-2003 school year, the District’s placement policy for special education students changed slightly. Ms. Morales and Ms. McKnight testified that after the IEP meeting is held to designate the student’s program (in this case, a general education inclusion placement), the parents fill out an enrollment application where they can make their selection of up to five schools. In January, special education students are then pre-assigned, ahead of their general education peers, into a school. A computer runs a diversity index and, depending upon space, assigns a school from among the 5 choices that parents give to the District.(Footnote 15) This is the same process for choosing school sites for general education students. While the District’s goal of ensuring the parents choice in the placement of their child is laudable, it does not cure the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with an appropriate offer of placement for the 2002-2003 school year. While the District can continue to offer a range of possible placements, it must then offer a single appropriate placement from the range of options it has offered. (See e.g., Glendale Unified School District v. Talar Almasi, (2000) 122 F.Supp.2d 1093, 33 IDELR 221.) The District’s new policy for placing students with an IEP still does not offer a single, specific school site or classroom. Moreover, the District's placement policy, applied rigidly, makes no sense when addressing placement decisions for students with disabilities. IEPs are effective immediately upon completion, unless other dates are specified in the IEP itself. The specific offer of placement must be made so that as soon as possible after the development of the IEP, the actual placement can be made.(Footnote 16) (34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1)(ii).) With the varying dates of IEP meetings, there is simply no way that an arbitrary date of January for assigning all special education students to specific placements could possibly meet the requirements of law. In this case, STUDENT’s IEP was held in May of 2002. Yet, according to the District’s policy for placing students, STUDENT’s placement assignment would not occur until January of 2003. The District failed to explain how its standard placement policies comport with the requirements of State and federal special education laws. Therefore, the Hearing Officer must conclude that the District’s failure to provide a formal written offer of placement denied PARENTS the opportunity to evaluate and decide whether to accept the offer of placement. The District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue No. 5: Did the District conduct an appropriate assessment of STUDENT when she was referred for services in June of 1999?
Petitioner argues that the District’s assessments conducted in February of 2000 failed to fully explore the nature of STUDENT’s disabilities.(Footnote 17) Petitioner argued that her assessments did not adequately describe her strengths and weaknesses in terms of her cognitive ability, and that an understanding of these strengths and weaknesses was critical in developing an appropriate program for STUDENT. Petitioner also argues that the District failed to formally assess STUDENT’s motor needs. Finally, Petitioner further argues that the assessments conducted by the District did not comply with the mandates set forth in State law.
The District responds that STUDENT’s initial assessment was conducted appropriately and addressed all of her suspected areas of disability. The District further responds that any tardiness in conducting the assessments was minimal and did not cause Petitioner any prejudice because of her parents’ decision to keep her in a private school placement during the 1999-2000 school year. Each of Petitioner’s allegations will be addressed in turn.
1. District’s Failure to Adequately Assess STUDENT’s Cognitive Needs
The law requires a school district to assess students in all areas of suspected disability, including when appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, interests and social emotional status. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.) The purpose of an assessment is not only to determine an “eligibility” category, but to determine the unique needs of the student. The 1997 amendments to the IDEA clarify that the assessment tools and strategies used must provide relevant information that will directly aid in the determination of the educational needs of the child. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D).) However, this is not a new requirement. The California Education Code has consistently required that assessments be geared to providing information relevant for the development of appropriate, individual programming for the students. (See, e.g., Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(e) and 56321(a).) Therefore, an assessment must not only identify a qualifying disability but must also assist the team in identifying the student’s unique educational needs.
Ms. Brown, a District psychologist, and Ms. Fletcher, a District speech and language pathologist, conducted STUDENT’s initial assessment in February of 2000, when STUDENT was 4 years and 10 months old. (Petitioner’s Ex. 14.) In terms of the cognitive profile assembled by the District, Ms. Brown testified that the only standardized test that she used was the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Rating Scale, and she did not do standardized IQ testing per District policy.(Footnote 18) She further testified that she determined STUDENT’s cognition levels by using a play-based developmental assessment, which she normally administered to pre-schoolers. She testified that, in her opinion, this was a good way to assess pre-schoolers because of their difficulty attending to standardized tests. Based on her assessment, Ms. Brown found that STUDENT’s skills were within normal limits, with her verbal skills being more developed than non-verbal. Her auditory processing skills were also within normal limits.
Petitioner’s expert, Dr. Guterman, conducted a neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT in August and September of 2001. To test her overall cognitive functioning, Dr. Guterman administered the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children, third edition (WISC-III). (Petitioner’s Ex. 57.) Based on her assessment, Dr. Guterman found that STUDENT had a wide range of abilities, with very specific strengths and weaknesses that were crucial in understanding her functioning. (Id.) She found that the STUDENT’s overall cognitive functioning fell solidly within the average range, with noted strengths on verbal conceptual reasoning and vocabulary skills. Dr. Guterman found deficits in STUDENT’s non-verbal problem solving. She was critical of the District’s assessments for not adequately identifying STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses, and failing to describe STUDENT’s cognitive functioning in more detail. She was also critical of the District’s assessors for failing to conduct standardized testing to measure Petitioner’s cognitive ability.
However, despite Dr. Guterman’s criticism of Ms. Brown’s assessment, both assessments came to similar results. Both assessments found that STUDENT was average in overall cognitive ability, and both noted strengths in verbal reasoning and weaknesses in non-verbal skills. Dr. Shah and Dr. Mills testified credibly that, while Dr. Guterman’s report was more in-depth, she generally came to the same conclusions found in the District’s report. Ms. Brown testified that at the time she conducted her assessments, STUDENT was too young to be given standardized cognitive tests to determine cognitive abilities, and that normal practice for assessing pre-schoolers was to use the play-based assessment. Dr. Mills further testified credibly that using play-based assessments was the best practice for assessing preschoolers. The fact that Ms. Brown and Dr. Guterman came to the same conclusions regarding STUDENT’s cognitive functioning is persuasive evidence that the District had conducted an assessment that identified STUDENT’s needs in this area. Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessment appropriately evaluated STUDENT in terms of her cognitive functioning.
2. Failure to Assess STUDENT’s Motor Needs
Petitioner contends that STUDENT should have been assessed in the areas of PT and OT in the District’s initial assessment.(Footnote 19) The District responded that it was its practice to allow the assessment team, in this case Ms. Brown and Ms. Fletcher, to make a determination about whether STUDENT required further assessment in these areas. Only then would further assessments be conducted.
When the District initially assessed in February of 2000, Ms. Brown and Ms. Fletcher did assess in the areas of “small muscle” and “big muscle.” (Petitioner’s Ex. 14.) However, the Hearing Officer finds that this limited inquiry was more in the nature of a “screening,” as evidenced by the IEP team’s subsequent recommendation to conduct further assessments in this area. The law requires that districts assess in all areas of suspected disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.) There was no dispute that motor needs was an area of concern regarding STUDENT’s disabilities. (District’s Ex. 2.) Furthermore, the assessment noted, and MOTHER testified at hearing, that she was concerned about motor deficits. (Petitioner’s Ex. 14.) Therefore, motor needs were an area of suspected area of disability that should have been assessed. The law further requires that districts not just test for a disability but to ascertain the child’s educational needs to assist the team in formulating an appropriate IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D).) By failing to conduct a full and complete assessment of STUDENT’s motor needs, the IEP team was unable to fully address her needs. The “screening” performed by Ms. Brown and Ms. Fletcher indicated deficiencies in these areas. They should have recommended further assessment prior to the IEP team meeting.(Footnote 20)
The law further requires that the test be administered by "qualified persons" and "trained personnel" and by "persons knowledgeable of that disability." (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320, emphasis added.) Ms. Brown is a psychologist. Ms. Fletcher is a speech pathologist. While each may have some knowledge about motor needs, neither has the training, qualifications or knowledge to ascertain a child's needs for services such as OT and PT. The District should have conducted a formal occupational therapy and/or physical therapy assessment with qualified, trained and knowledgeable individuals. As noted above, at the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting, the District recommended further testing in the areas of OT and PT. (District’s Ex. 18.) However, in order to provide STUDENT with a program that met all her needs, formal assessments in this area should have been conducted prior to that IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability by failing to conduct OT and PT assessments prior to the IEP team meeting.
Issue No. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses:
a. Neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Tina Guterman;
b. Occupational therapy assessment and services by OT for Kids; c. Speech and Language assessment and services by Speech, Inc.; d. Psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass;
e. Vision Therapy assessment and services by Dr. David Grisham; f. Physical Therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions; g. One-to-one instructional assistance by Scott Wilson;
h. Transportation to services;
i. Facilitated play program at Speech, Inc.;
j. Facilitated play program at California Pacific Medical Center; k. Services and placement at 150 Parker, including tuition, transportation, and program materials; l. Services and placement at the Laurel school, including tuition, transportation, and program materials; and m. Inclusion consultation services at 150 Parker.
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the District was to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(10)(C).) The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. (Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., (6th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.) However, the parents’ placement still must meet certain basic requirement of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement address the child’s needs and provide him educational benefit. (Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter (1993) 510 U.S. 7, 13-14, 114 S.Ct. 361.)
Furthermore, a parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the student. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). However, if an educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessments were appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. (Id.) Each of Petitioner’s requests for reimbursement will be addressed in turn.
a. Neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Tina Guterman
Petitioner alleges that because the District’s assessments failed to adequately determine STUDENT’s cognitive strengths and weaknesses, her parents should be entitled to reimbursement for Dr. Guterman’s assessment. However, as noted previously, the District’s evaluation adequately determined STUDENT’s cognitive abilities. Therefore, the request for reimbursement for Dr. Guterman’s assessment is denied.
b. Occupational therapy assessment and services
Petitioner contends that because of the District’s failure to provide her a FAPE, she is entitled to reimbursement for OT therapy and assessments. Specifically, Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the following OT services: an assessment done by Teri Jetter in October and November of 1999; an assessment by Susan Clarke, completed on March 23, 2000; and therapy services provided by Ms. Clarke and Gwen Wong, beginning in February and September, respectively.
Petitioner argues that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for Teri Jetter’s assessment because the District failed to assess her in a timely manner. As noted above, the District did fail to conduct STUDENT’s assessments in the time periods prescribed by law. While the District may not have been required to assess STUDENT at the time her parents obtained Ms. Jetter’s assessment, the fact remains that the District failed to conduct its assessment and hold an IEP until March of 2000. At that time, the District still did not conduct formal OT assessments of STUDENT. Therefore, because the District failed to conduct appropriate assessments in at timely manner, reimbursement for Ms. Jetter’s assessment is appropriate.
Petitioner also argues that her parents should be reimbursed for an OT assessment conducted by Ms. Clarke in March of 2000 due to the District’s failure to address sensory issues related to STUDENT’s OT needs. Ms. Jetter recommended the services of Ms. Clarke because of STUDENT’s difficulties modulating her responses to sensory input from her tactile, auditory, visual, vestibular and propioceptive systems. At the time her parents obtained this assessment, the District still had not formally conducted its OT assessment of STUDENT. (See above.) Moreover, this assessment was done in order to identify services that were appropriate to address STUDENT’s OT needs. Because the District failed to appropriately assess STUDENT in a timely manner, her parents should be reimbursed for Ms. Clarke’s assessments.
With regard to the OT services provided by PARENTS, the Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement is appropriate. As noted above, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by its failure to provide a formal written offer of placement. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed some level of OT. Ms. Wong testified at hearing that STUDENT has shown progress in her program. And MOTHER testified that STUDENT is better able to regulate her responses to environmental stimuli. Thus, the services provided by her parents did provide her with educational benefit. Therefore, reimbursement for these services is appropriate.
c. Speech and Language Assessment and Services.
Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the following speech and language assessments and services: the assessment and services provided by Speech, Inc and services provided by Kate O’Hara Hemlock, STUDENT’s oral motor and respiratory specialist. As previously noted, the District has consistently failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT during the school years at issue. In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT has speech and language needs. Ms. Pengilly, from Speech, Inc., testified that the services she provided were designed to address her receptive and expressive language deficits. Ms. Hemlock testified that the program she is providing is an oral therapy motor program designed to strengthen her oral muscles, and to develop her skills in using the lips and tongue. These programs are thus designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. Moreover, both Ms. Pengilly and Ms. Hemlock testified that STUDENT is progressing in her therapy, indicating she has received educational benefit from these services. Therefore, reimbursement for these services is appropriate.
d. Psychological Assessment and Services by Dr. Stephanie Pass
Petitioner contends that she is entitled to reimbursement for the psychological assessment and services provided by Dr. Pass. Dr. Pass provided psychosocial therapy to STUDENT to assist her to regulate her arousal and conducted informal evaluations in order to identify services that were appropriate for STUDENT. Neither party disputes that STUDENT has psychosocial needs. Dr. Pass testified that STUDENT was unable to regulate her arousal, sometimes being overexcited, and other times appearing down. STUDENT also had a tendency to lapse into self-stimulatory behaviors, including hand flapping, using her tongue as a pacifier, and reciting videos to herself. These behaviors made it difficult for STUDENT to interact with her peers. She misses social cues when she is too up or down, and gravitates toward self-stimulatory behaviors rather than interaction with her peers. These behaviors also affect her ability to sit and attend in the classroom environment. Dr. Pass used a developmental play session to teach STUDENT and her mother to understand and remedy these behaviors. She also testified that while STUDENT was in her program, she observed a marked decrease in her self-stimulatory behaviors. MOTHER and Mr. Wilson testified that STUDENT was making progress in her social relationships with her peers. Thus, Petitioner has established that these services were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit. Therefore, reimbursement for these services, including the informal evaluation sessions, is appropriate.
e. Vision Therapy Assessment and Services by Dr. David Grisham
Petitioner did not present any evidence regarding the services and assessment provided by Dr. Grisham. Petitioner did not establish whether vision therapy was an area of need that was not addressed by the District, or whether this was an area of suspected disability that the District failed to assess. Therefore, the request for reimbursement for these services is denied.
f. Physical Therapy Assessment and Services by Developmental Progressions
Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the physical therapy, and the informal assessments to determine appropriate PT services, by Janet Green-Babb, STUDENT’s physical therapist, at Developmental Progressions. There is no dispute that STUDENT has physical therapy needs. Ms. Green-Babb had been treating STUDENT since September of 1999. She testified that her program is designed to address balance, equilibrium, and low postural tone. Ms. Green-Babb testified that while STUDENT was in her program, she had made progress with her physical therapy needs. Moreover, although the District offered PT services to STUDENT at the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting, PARENTS were not obligated to take the District’s offer piecemeal. Under Burlington, PARENTS were entitled to seek a private placement. Therefore, reimbursement for these services is appropriate. However, as noted above, the Hearing Officer has found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE from November 1999 onward. Therefore, reimbursement for Ms. Green-Babb’s services are limited to the time from November of 1999, when the District should have convened its initial IEP, to the present.
g. One-to-one Paraprofessional Services by Scott Wilson
Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the one-to-one services provided by Scott Wilson. Mr. Wilson began providing these services in approximately September of 2000. While the District disputes that STUDENT required a one-to-one paraprofessional in her school setting, the evidence establishes that these services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit. Dr. Pass and MOTHER testified that STUDENT required the services of a one-to-one paraprofessional in her various school and therapy environments. Because STUDENT has a tendency to be overwhelmed, Mr. Wilson redirects STUDENT and assures her participation in activities and therapies. Moreover, Ms. Green-Babb, Ms. Wong, Dr. Pass, and Ms. Hersey all testified that Scott would keep STUDENT focused and attentive in her various environments. Therefore, because STUDENT’s one-to-one aide addressed her needs and provided her with some educational benefit, reimbursement for these services is appropriate.
h. Transportation to services
Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for costs of transportation to and from her services and her private school placements. Pursuant to State and federal law, related services include the costs for transportation (20 U.S.C. §1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).) The District, as found above, failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE and her parents were justified, under Burlington, in finding replacement services. Therefore, transportation costs are appropriate costs for reimbursement.
i. Facilitated Play Program at Speech, Inc.
Petitioner request reimbursement for play-group based speech therapy through Speech, Inc., which began in June of 2000. The play-group was introduced to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of socialization. Moreover, the evidence establishes that STUDENT made progress in her playgroups, demonstrating that she did in fact receive educational benefit from the playgroup sessions. (Petitioner’s Ex. 36.) Thus, reimbursement was appropriate for the playgroup therapy provided by the parents.
j. Facilitated Play Program at California Pacific Medical Center
Petitioner is also seeking reimbursement for the play therapy services to address her occupational therapy needs provided by Sue Clarke at the California Pacific Medical Center. As noted earlier, it is undisputed that STUDENT has needs in both Occupational Therapy and social needs. Thus, a play program centered around occupational therapy would be designed to meet her needs. Moreover, MOTHER testified that STUDENT has made progress in these areas, indicating that STUDENT has received some educational benefit from this program. Reimbursement for these services is appropriate.
k. Services and Placement at 150 Parker, Including Tuition, Transportation, and Program Materials
STUDENT attended the150 Parker School for transitional kindergarten during the 2000-2001 school year. Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the placement and services they procured at 150 Parker because of the District’s failure to provide her with FAPE.
As noted above, the District failed to provide a formal written offer of placement, and thus denied STUDENT a FAPE, for the 2000-2001 school year. To qualify for reimbursement, the parents’ placement must at the very least have addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit. 150 Parker was STUDENT’s transitional kindergarten classroom. The evidence established that 150 Parker School provided STUDENT with a classroom placement of approximately 11 children, in a program that combined structured time with free choice time. (Petitioner’s Ex. 95.) Moreover, STUDENT’s March 12, 2001 IEP, which was held while STUDENT was attending 150 Parker indicated that she was making improvement in activities, number concepts and receptive/expressive language. (District’s Ex. 20.) By the time of this IEP, STUDENT could write her name, recognize letters, and she had begun to recognize phonics cues. (Petitioner’s Ex. 95.) She was also participating more fully in circle time activities by asking questions and sharing stories and information. (Id.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s placement at 150 Parker was appropriate, and that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for that placement.
l. Services and Placement at Laurel School, Including Tuition, Transportation, and Program Materials
STUDENT attended the Laurel School for the 2001-2002 school year, when she was in kindergarten. She also attended the Laurel School for the first grade, from the fall of 2002 to the present. Petitioner contends that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for placement at the Laurel School due to the District’s failure to provide FAPE in the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school year.
As noted previously, the District has denied Petitioner a FAPE due to its failure to provide a formal written offer of placement for the 2001-2002 school year. Petitioner’s parents provided STUDENT with a kindergarten placement at the Laurel School. She was placed in Sharon Rosedale’s classroom, which consisted of between 5-6 students at the time STUDENT attended, with a highly structured program and the basic kindergarten curriculum. (Testimony of MOTHER and Scott Wilson.) Mr. Wilson testified that STUDENT was learning to write letters and do basic math skills. The Hearing Officer finds that the program addressed STUDENT’s needs. Moreover, STUDENT progressed during her kindergarten year at the Laurel School. Mr. Wilson testified that he saw STUDENT making social progress at recess time, engaging in play with peers and compromising with play. Her IEPs during this school year, on December 10, 2001 and May 14, 2002, indicate that she was starting to read, and that her math and writing skills were improving. (District’s Ex. 23.) The evidence establishes that the Laurel School placement met STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit for the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for the parents’ placement at the Laurel School is appropriate.
The Hearing Officer has also found that the District denied a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year due to the continuing failure to provide a formal written offer of placement. In the fall of 2002 to the present, STUDENT was attending first grade in Page Hersey’s classroom at the Laurel School. Ms. Hersey testified that her classroom is a first and second grade combination classroom, with seven students total in her classroom. STUDENT’s daily schedule includes art, literacy and writing exercises, and math, science, and social studies instruction. STUDENT’s placement at Laurel was thus designed to meet her needs. Ms. Hersey also testified that STUDENT was making progress at her placement for this school year. She stated that STUDENT’s reading was more expressive, her reading was more fluent, she had begun to show independence at snack and recess, and her writing had improved. Ms. Hersey further testified that STUDENT had shown progress in math science and social studies. The evidences establishes that the Laurel School placement was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit for her first grade year. The Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for the parents’ placement at Laurel School is appropriate.
Petitioner further argues, however, that PARENTS should be reimbursed for the entire placement at Laurel School for the 2002-2003 school year.(Footnote 21) Because this Decision will be issued so close to the end of the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that it would be in the best interest of STUDENT to remain in her placement for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year. The District has yet to make a formal written offer of placement for STUDENT. Because of the District’s failure to provide such a formal written offer of placement, there is no indication in the record of a placement that STUDENT would attend after this Decision is issued. The District must convene an IEP, offer an appropriate placement, and then provide that placement for STUDENT. After all of these steps have taken place, there will be little, if any, time left in the school year to make it worthwhile for STUDENT to switch schools. Moreover, MOTHER, Dr. Pass and Mr. Wilson all testified that because of STUDENT’s disabilities, she has difficulty transitioning to new environments. Thus, it would be detrimental to STUDENT’s education to force a change of placement at this late point in the school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement for the full 2002-2003 school year is appropriate in light of these unique circumstances.
m. Inclusion consultation services to 150 Parker
Petitioner did not present any evidence as to what services were provided as “inclusion consultation services” by M. Britton. Therefore, the request for reimbursement for these services is denied.
Issue No: 7: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of FAPE?
Petitioner contends that the she should be provided with compensatory education in the form of continued placement at Laurel School through the end of the 2002-2003 school year. However, Petitioner also argued that an alternative remedy would be reimbursement to the parents for tuition paid through the remainder of the school year. As noted above, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the Laurel School placement through the end of the 2002-2003 school year. For this reason, the request for compensatory education is moot.
ORDER
1. Within 15 days of receipt of proof from the parents, and minus any amounts reimbursed by the private insurance for these services, the District shall reimburse PARENTS for the following services:
a. Occupational therapy assessment and services from Teri Jetter, Susan Clarke, and Gwedonlyn Wong; b. Speech and Language assessment and services by Speech, Inc.; c. Psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass;
d. Physical Therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions from December of 1999 to the present; e. One-to-one instructional assistance by Scott Wilson;
f. Transportation services for the costs of actual mileage incurred by the parents in transporting between their home and her various service providers, at the rate that the District reimburses its employees; g. Facilitated play program at Speech, Inc.;
h. Facilitated play program at California Pacific Medical Center; i. Placement and services at 150 Parker, including tuition, transportation, and program materials for the 2000-2001 school year; j. Placement and services at the Laurel school, including tuition, transportation, and program materials, for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school year, including placement through the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
2. Within 10 days from the date of this Decision, the District and PARENTS shall convene an IEP meeting to determine STUDENT’s placement for the next school year. This IEP shall state clearly the specific school site that the District deems meets STUDENT’s needs.
3. All other of Petitioner’s request for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §5607(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
1. Did the District provide STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
4. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 2002 school year to the present? Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
5. Did the District assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability when she was referred for services in June of 1999? The District prevailed on this issue.
6. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the following expenses:
a. Neuropsychological assessment by Dr. Tina Guterman. The District prevailed on this issue.
b. Occupational therapy assessment and services by OT for Kids. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
c. Speech and Language assessment and services by Speech, Inc. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
d. Psychological assessment by Dr. Stephanie Pass. The District prevailed on this issue.
e. Vision Therapy assessment and services by Dr. David Grisham. The District prevailed on this issue.
f. Physical Therapy assessment and services by Developmental Progressions. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
g. 1:1 instructional assistance by Scott Wilson. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
h. Transportation services. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
i. Facilitated play program at Speech, Inc. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
j. Facilitated play program at California Pacific Medical Center. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
k. Services and placement at 150 Parker, including tuition, transportation, and program materials. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
l. Services and placement at Laurel school, including tuition, transportation, and program materials. Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
m. Inclusion consultation services to 150 Parker. The District prevailed on this issue.
7. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of FAPE? This issue was moot.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).
Date: May 23, 2003 Patrick J. Balucan, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
1. These issues are a restatement of the issues Petitioner presented for hearing, based upon the discussion of the issues held at the beginning of the hearing. 2. MOTHER and Mr. Wilson, STUDENT’s one-on-one aide, explained that STUDENT has a tendency to recite Disney and Japanese animé cartoons to herself, and that this behavior impedes her ability to relate to peers and to make friends. This behavior was evident early in life and has remained a concern to her parents throughout her schooling.
3. MOTHER testified that she had to contact the District on several occasions before receiving a response to her request. 4. Dr. Pass testified that STUDENT does not meet the diagnostic criteria for autism, but that her behaviors resemble those of autistic children.
5. Using the Battelle Developmental Inventory to measure hand coordination, STUDENT scored at the age equivalent of 36 months. Using the Beery Visual Motor Integration test, STUDENT scored in the 4 years 6 month age equivalency. She was 5 years and 2 months at the time of the testing. 6. The District was not unwilling to provide the aide services. In fact, the inclusion programs at the District school included aides. However, the aides would not be assigned specifically to STUDENT, and PARENTS contended that STUDENT must be provided with a one-to-one paraprofessional if she were to attend a inclusion placement. 7. Pursuant to the IDEA, and governing regulations, school districts are not required to pay for special education and related services for children who have been placed in private schools by their parents if the district made FAPE available to the child and the parent elected to place the child privately. Districts however are required to make a proportionate share of the federal funding available to provide some services to some private school children, based upon priorities for service established by the district, in consultation with representatives of privately placed children. The "proportionate share" is determined by a formula specified in the law and regulations, and districts are not required to spend more than the formula dictates. See 34 CFR § 300.403-457. SFUSD has decided to use the proportionate share of special education funds for children in private school to service children aged 3-6 years old. When PARENTS continued STUDENT's placement in private school after the October 16, 2000 IEP meeting, the District apparently interpreted this as a voluntary placement by the parent and elected to provide STUDENT only PT and OT under the "proportionate share" requirements and the District's established service priorities. The District then apparently determined that when STUDENT reached the age of 7, she was no longer eligible to receive services from the District unless she discontinued her voluntary placement in private school and enrolled in the District. At hearing, however, the District did not argue nor establish facts that indicated that PARENTS "choice" to place STUDENT in private school was voluntary and not the result of a disagreement over the District's offer of FAPE. (See School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer treats this dispute as a FAPE dispute and, if it is determined that District failed to offer or provide STUDENT a FAPE for the years in question, must determine whether STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred.
8. MOTHER testified that she contacted the District in May of 1999. However, there is no evidence in the record that a referral for assessment was made prior to June 22, 1999, and the only documentation that exists in the record indicates that a referral was made on June 22, 1999. (District’s Ex. 2.) Therefore the Hearing Officer finds the District was first aware of the referral for a special education assessment on June 22, 1999. 9. The District argues that the delay of approximately 1 month in conducting the assessments and holding an IEP meeting did not prejudice STUDENT because her parents chose to continue her private school placement. First, as noted in the discussion, the District misunderstood or miscalculated when the timelines for assessments and IEP meeting began. More importantly, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s assertion that STUDENT was not harmed because her parents kept her in private school is specious, if not alarming. What other choice did the parent have when the District had not even completed its assessment within the statutory timeframe? 10. The Hearing Officer is not holding that a District must in all cases offer only one placement. Indeed, in some instances, two or more specific placements may be equally appropriate. The Courts, however, do disapprove of the “shotgun” approach of placement offers, such as here, where the District seemed to assume that any one of its unidentified and varied SDC placements constituted “an offer.” 11. Because the District made no further offer of placement until the IEP meeting in October of 2000, the Hearing Officer will discuss the length of this denial under the 2000-2001 school year FAPE issue.
12. As noted previously, the District argued that the delay in holding an IEP meeting did not prejudice STUDENT because her parents chose to continue her private school placement, and may point to MOTHER’s letter (Petitioner’s Ex. 21) as evidence that she was seeking placement only for the 2000-2001 school year. However, the argument is unpersuasive. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District was approximately four months late in conducting its assessments. And because of its failure at the March 28, 2000 IEP meeting to provide a written offer of placement that met the requirements of Union, MOTHER was forced to observe several classes before deciding on a placement that was suitable for STUDENT, and did not request the John Muir placement until her letter, which was dated May 31, 2000. Furthermore, MOTHER testified that because of STUDENT’s disabilities, she had difficulty with transitioning to new environments. Thus, because any placement decisions would have occurred so close to the end of the school year, it would be reasonable to assume that MOTHER would forego placement for the 1999-2000 school year because of STUDENT’s difficulties with transitions. Regardless, the District presented no evidence that MOTHER sought placement for STUDENT only for the 2000-2001 school year because of a decision to keep her at St. James.
13. The variety that MOTHER found in these programs is further evidence that the District's implicit contention that any SDC class can meet STUDENT's needs is without merit.
14. It is apparent from this demand that the District was attempting to treat PARENTS’ placement of STUDENT in a private school as a voluntary act, rather than as a result of the District’s own failure to offer FAPE. Again, the Hearing Officer notes that there is no evidence that PARENTS were not sincere in their attempts to locate an appropriate public school placement for their daughter.
15. Ms. McKnight testified that the diversity index is a computer analysis that looks at several race-blind factors to assure diversity in the schools, and was implemented pursuant to a consent decree.
16. The comments to the federal regulations state that, with some limited exceptions, IEPs for most children with disabilities must be implemented without undue delay following the IEP meeting. The comments further state that if there is a pattern or practice in a given State of not making services available within a reasonable amount of time (e.g. within a week or two following the IEP meeting), there would be a question of whether the State would be in compliance with the 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(1)(ii). (64 Fed. Reg. 48, 12579 (1999)(Comments to § 300.342).)
17. At hearing, Petitioner also argued that the District’s assessment in February of 2000 should have included an OT and PT assessment.
18. Ms. Brown testified that the District does not use standardized assessments to test cognition because IQ tests weren’t normed for the population of SFUSD students.
19. The Hearing Officer notes that PT and OT are related services/DIS and technically not areas of need. The areas of need that these services often address are fine and gross motor problems. However, the Hearing Officer also notes that it is common for both parents and educators to speak in terms of OT/PT needs.
20. While the District is not prohibited from refusing to conduct “OT/PT” assessments until after a suspected motor deficiency has been further documented, such a practice cannot result in the delay of such assessments until after the IEP meeting is conducted, and such assessments cannot be based solely upon an IEP recommendation for such assessments. District must assess thoroughly in all areas of suspected disability and obtain sufficient information, where possible, prior to an IEP meeting, so as to permit the IEP team to adequately address the students’ needs in the IEP. 21. The Laurel School is not certified by the Sate of California as a non-pubic school (NPS). Therefore, the Hearing Officer cannot order a prospective placement at the Laurel School for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56502.2)
