California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 10, 2001
Student v. Glendora Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1934-99 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke
Glendora Unified denied FAPE in fall 1999 and must reimburse 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell services, assessment, and mileage.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a student with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Glendora Unified School District. The student was working at the pre-primer reading level in second and third grade. The Hearing Officer found that the district correctly decided in November 1998 that he was not eligible, based on two school psychologists' reading of his test scores. It then properly found him eligible in January 1999. Resource specialist program (RSP) help in second grade gave him some educational benefit. Two errors that year did not deny FAPE: the district did not give the parents the speech screening results, and it left the eligibility category off the IEP. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for a private vision therapy assessment, vision therapy, and a Phono-Graphix reading program. There was no district assessment for the parents to disagree with, and the services were not shown to be needed.
The Hearing Officer found that the district denied FAPE in fall 1999. Both of his teachers saw by September that general education with RSP was not working. Even so, no IEP meeting was held until December, although the mother asked for one on September 17. The IEPs given to the parents also lacked present levels of performance. The district gave no written notice that it refused Lindamood-Bell, and RSP services started late. The January 2000 special day class offer was appropriate. As compensatory education, the district must reimburse 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell instruction, the Lindamood-Bell assessment, and proven mileage.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO used reimbursement for a parent's private program as compensatory education for an earlier denial of FAPE, even though the district's later offer was appropriate. It also shows that waiting months for an IEP meeting after a parent's request and teacher concerns could deny FAPE.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 1. Did the District improperly fail to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP meeting?
Two school psychologists credibly found no severe ability-achievement discrepancy, so the November 1998 finding of ineligibility was correct. The district offered a Section 504 plan and classroom modifications, then found him eligible in January 1999.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
The district did not give parents the speech screening results and left the eligibility category off the IEP, but these errors caused no loss of educational opportunity. RSP instruction met his needs and gave educational benefit, so FAPE was provided.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the vision therapy assessment performed in 1998 by Dr. Stephey's office?
The private vision assessment came before any district assessment, so there was no district assessment for the parents to disagree with. No evidence showed the district required it, so reimbursement was denied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of vision therapy provided in 1998 and 1999 by Dr. Stephey's office and the costs of transportation to and from therapy sessions?
Petitioner did not show he needed vision therapy to benefit from his education. It did not help his reading, so therapy and transportation costs were denied.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Graphix program that was provided by Dr. Stephey?
Petitioner did not show he needed the Phono-Graphix program, and he made no progress with it, so reimbursement was denied.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
FAPE was denied from September 1999 to January 2000. General education with RSP did not meet his needs, no IEP meeting was held within 30 days of the parent's request, the IEPs lacked present levels, no written notice refused Lindamood-Bell, and RSP started late. The January 2000 SDC offer was a FAPE in the LRE.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) assessment and services he received from March through July 2000, and the costs of transportation to and from the LMB clinic?
The LMB program met his needs and produced significant gains. As compensatory education for the fall 1999 denial of FAPE, the district must reimburse 12 weeks of LMB instruction, the LMB assessment, and proven mileage.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of payment, the district must reimburse the parents for the proven costs of 12 weeks of Lindamood-Bell services starting in February 2000, including the LMB assessment. The award is compensatory education for the denial of FAPE in the first half of 1999-2000.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof of miles and days driven, the district must reimburse the parents for transporting the student to and from the LMB clinic during the 12 weeks, at the district's standard employee mileage rate.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Nein v. Greater Clark County School Corp.; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Ted McNevin, director of instructional and student support services, Glendora Unified School District
- Gigi Maurizio, assistant superintendent of personnel services, Glendora Unified School District
- Christopher Russell, educational consultant and advocate for Student
- Virginia Russell, educational consultant, witness for Student
- Sandra Pellow, third-grade general education teacher, Cullen Elementary School
- Linda Haughtelin, resource specialist program teacher and case carrier, Glendora Unified School District (Cullen Elementary School)
- Lenora Mar, special day class teacher, Cullen Elementary School
- Donna Eaves, district resident, witness for Student
- Jule Dombrower, program specialist and school psychologist, Glendora Unified School District
- Laura Whittington, resource specialist program teacher in new district, Pleasant Valley School District
- Lisa Holliday-Aggers, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Glendora Unified School District
- Cheryl Bonner, principal, Cullen Elementary School
- Angelica Benson, regional director of development, Lindamood-Bell; assessor and witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center
- Patricia Martinez, deputy district attorney, witness for District, Los Angeles County District Attorney's Office
- Ms. Okerson, first-grade teacher, Cullen Elementary School
- Ms. Ferguson, second-grade general education teacher, Cullen Elementary School
- Margaret Schlosser, conducted speech and language screening, Glendora Unified School District
- Dr. Douglas W. Stephey, private optometrist (vision therapy, Phono-Graphix reading therapy)
- Dr. Soonsi Kwon, private optometrist, vision assessment and therapy, Office of Dr. Douglas W. Stephey
- Frostig Center, private school, summer reading program
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center (Newport Beach), private clinic, unilateral placement
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Glendora, California, on December 5 and 6, 2000, February 6, 7, and 8, 2001, March 21 and 22, 2001, May 1, 2, and 3, 2001, and June 28 and 29, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT (hereafter, Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania Whiteleather, advocate Christopher Russell, and his mother and father, PARENTS. Respondent Glendora Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or the District) was represented by attorney John Hayashida. Also present on behalf of the District during different portions of the hearing were Ted McNevin, director of instructional and student support services for the District, and Gigi Maurizio, assistant superintendent of personnel services for the District.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: PARENTS, STUDENT’s parents; Christopher Russell, educational consultant; Sandra Pellow, STUDENT’s third-grade teacher at Cullen Elementary School (Cullen); Linda Haughtelin, resource specialist program teacher for the District; Virginia Russell, educational consultant; Lenora Mar, STUDENT’s special day class teacher at Cullen; Donna Eaves, resident of the District; Jule Dombrower, program specialist and psychologist for the District; Laura Whittington, STUDENT’s resource specialist program teacher at Pleasant Valley School District; Lisa Holliday-Aggers, school psychologist for the District; Ted McNevin, director of instructional and student support services for the District; Cheryl Bonner, principal at Cullen; and Angelica Benson (formerly Dirtadian), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center’s regional director of development for the East Coast.
The following witnesses were called by the District: Gigi Maurizio, assistant superintendent of personnel services for the District, and Patricia Martinez, deputy district attorney for the county of Los Angeles.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. Closing arguments were received from both parties and the record closed.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the last day of hearing, Petitioner presented a written brief outlining procedural errors he alleges the District committed. Petitioner contended that he was not required to allege specific procedural violations of the IDEA in his statement of issues, but that if the Hearing Officer so required, he requested that he be allowed to amend his issue statement to include the procedural allegations. The Hearing Officer permitted the District to respond to Petitioner’s motion in writing, and a telephone conference was held with both parties’ counsels on Friday, July 13, 2001, to discuss this issue.
During the July 13, 2001 telephone conference, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion to amend his issues, stating that an amendment was not necessary because the specific procedural allegations noted in Petitioner’s June 29, 2001 brief were either directly related to previously identified substantive issues or became known to Petitioner through witness testimony during the hearing. The Hearing Officer left the record open, however, and gave the District the opportunity to submit additional witness testimony and/or documentary evidence. The District had sufficient notice that the stated procedural matters were at issue, and had a full and fair opportunity to submit argument and evidence on all procedural errors alleged in Petitioner’s written brief. Therefore, the District was not prejudiced by the Hearing Officer’s considering Petitioner’s specific procedural allegations.
After the record was closed, Respondent submitted a written objection to the Hearing Office contending that facts stated in Petitioner’s closing arguments that were not admitted into evidence may not be argued. Petitioner responded to the objection, stating that nothing in Petitioner’s closing argument was untrue or not based on the evidence admitted at hearing. The Hearing Officer notes that the parties' closing briefs are not evidence to be considered by the Hearing Officer. In any case, the record had already been closed for the submission of additional evidence. For these reasons, the only evidence that will be considered is that which was introduced by the parties at the hearing. Those portions of either party’s closing briefs that may contain facts or other evidence not introduced into the record during the hearing will not be considered by the Hearing Officer in rendering a decision in this matter. ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Did the District improperly fail to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP meeting?
2. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the vision therapy assessment performed in 1998 by Dr. Stephey’s office?
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of vision therapy provided in 1998 and 1999 by Dr. Stephey’s office and the costs of transportation to and from therapy sessions?
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Graphix program that was provided by Dr. Stephey?
6. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
7. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) assessment and services he received from March through July 2000, and the costs of transportation to and from the LMB clinic?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly assess and identify him for special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP meeting. Petitioner also alleges that once he was identified as eligible for special education, he was denied a FAPE for the 1998-1999 and 1999-2000 school years in that the services provided by the District were not appropriate and did not meet his unique educational needs. Petitioner also contends that the District required his parents to secure vision therapy and a vision therapy assessment, for which they should be reimbursed.
The District contends that it did not wrongfully deny STUDENT special education services after he was assessed in 1998. It also argues that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE by first providing him an academic program for the 1998-1999 school year that included resource specialist program (RSP) assistance, and then providing placement for the 1999-2000 school year in a special day class (SDC) with a teacher who has experience in teaching children with reading difficulties.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is nine years and eight months old and attends the fourth grade at Las Collinas Elementary School in the Pleasant Valley School District. The dispute in this matter, however, arose when STUDENT attended Cullen Elementary School (Cullen) located in the Glendora Unified School District.
MOTHER testified that she began having concerns about STUDENT’S progress in1996, during STUDENT’s kindergarten year. STUDENT could not identify any letters of the alphabet or numbers. STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher also expressed concern and suggested that STUDENT use the Alphabuild program to help him identify letters. STUDENT’s kindergarten report card noted that STUDENT ”needs more time and/or help” with his pre-reading and language skills. (Pet.’s Exh. C-1.) His teacher also suggested that he be retained in kindergarten and take part in a school program for children who have self-esteem issues. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
MOTHER stated that during his first-grade year, STUDENT continued to try very hard, but was not progressing. At the beginning of STUDENT’S first-grade year, she expressed her concern to STUDENT’S teacher, Ms. Okerson, who told her not to worry because they would work with STUDENT. Ms. Okerson then noticed that when reading, STUDENT had difficulty remembering small words from one page to the next, so she suggested to MOTHER that STUDENT’s eyesight be checked. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
STUDENT’s mother took him to see their family therapist, who recommended that STUDENT see Dr. Douglas W. Stephey, an optometrist, for further consultation. STUDENT was assessed by optometrist Dr. Soonsi Kwon, an associate of Dr. Stephey. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Dr. Kwon’s May 14, 1998 assessment results indicated that STUDENT had a significant problem in the area of eye tracking. Dr. Kwon found that inadequate eye movement control may have caused STUDENT to lose his place when reading, to have difficulty copying from the blackboard, and to skip or omit small words when reading. (Pet.’s Exh. D.) Dr. Kwon also found that STUDENT had visual processing problems, noting that STUDENT had difficulty processing and analyzing incoming data. Dr. Kwon recommended a vision therapy program designed to remediate the eye movement and visual perceptual deficiencies. The recommended program included fifteen to twenty weekly office visits at $55 per visit. STUDENT received visual perceptual therapy from Dr. Kwon for a couple of months in 1998; and in 1999, optometrist Dr. Stephey provided STUDENT with reading therapy using the Phono-Graphix method; however, STUDENT attended irregularly. (Testimony of MOTHER; Pet.’s Exh. K-1.) Ms. Okerson later informed MOTHER that the vision therapy was not working and suggested that MOTHER file a request to have STUDENT assessed by the District. Ms. Okerson advised that his problems did not appear to be the result of his vision and that she suspected that he had a learning disability. Hoping that STUDENT would make some progress, MOTHER continued to send STUDENT to vision therapy even though it was not working. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Mrs. Okerson also reported to MOTHER that she never had a student who worked as hard as STUDENT, yet made no progress. (Testimony of MOTHER.) STUDENT’s first-grade report card reflected both MOTHER’s and his teacher’s concerns regarding his progress, especially regarding his skill level in the language arts area. (Pet.’s Exh. C-2.)
During the summer of 1998, STUDENT attended the Frostig Center, a private school that administers a summer reading program focusing on the basics of language arts. (Testimony of MOTHER; Pet.’s Exh. E.) At the end of the program, the Frostig Center generated a report regarding STUDENT’s progress. The report concluded that STUDENT would benefit from a multisensory reading program in a one-to-one setting or very small group to sustain his attention. The report also noted that STUDENT should continue to practice reading aloud, and that he would benefit from repetition of new skills. (Pet.’s Exh. E.) MOTHER agreed with the recommendations contained in the Frostig Center report and forwarded a copy to Cullen School and to STUDENT’s first-grade teacher. STUDENT’s attendance at the Frostig Center did not help improve his skills. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
For the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT continued at Cullen for the second grade in Ms. Ferguson’s regular education class. (Pet.’s Exh. C-3.) According to MOTHER, while volunteering in STUDENT’S class, she observed that STUDENT was extremely behind academically, and could not read or do any of the math work. Socially, STUDENT started thinking he was “dumb,” and rarely invited any of his friends over to their home to play. Additionally, Ms. Ferguson reported that STUDENT started being very disruptive, aggressive, and hostile in class.
STUDENT was initially assessed by the District in the fall of 1998, during his second-grade year at Cullen. Lisa Holliday-Aggers, the District’s school psychologist who assessed STUDENT, determined that STUDENT was functioning within the average range for ability and showed significant strength within the area of visual sequencing. Academically, however, Ms. Holliday-Aggers concluded that STUDENT’s skills ranged from mid-kindergarten to mid-first-grade level, and he displayed relative weaknesses in the areas of arithmetic calculation, numerical reasoning ability, and reading comprehension. According to Ms. Holliday-Aggers, STUDENT evidenced processing disorders in the areas of association and sensory-motor, which were reflected in his deficit in the areas of remote/long term memory and visual perception. In spite of the evidencing disorders, Ms. Holliday-Aggers found that STUDENT did not demonstrate a significant difference between ability and achievement in any of the academic areas, and therefore, concluded that he did not meet the eligibility requirements for special education. She did, however, make some specific recommendations for STUDENT’S educational program and suggested the assessment results be reviewed with STUDENT’S parents at an IEP team meeting, where eligibility for special education assistance could be determined.
STUDENT’S first IEP team meeting was held on November 16, 1998, at which time the IEP team determined that STUDENT was not eligible for special education because he did not meet the eligibility requirements for a specific learning disability. However, the IEP team agreed to write a Rehabilitation Act section 504 plan (Section 504 plan) for STUDENT, and to conduct a “mini-achievement screening” at the end of STUDENT’s second-grade year if he continued to struggle and not show sufficient progress in the classroom. MOTHER attended the November 16, 1998 IEP team meeting and signed the IEP document, thus agreeing to its provisions. A Section 504 plan meeting was later held, at which time MOTHER rejected 504 services for STUDENT and told the attendees that she believed STUDENT should receive special education services. An IEP team meeting was later held on January 25, 1999, and STUDENT was found eligible for special education services because his teachers and parents had concerns with his classroom performance and because, academically, STUDENT was falling further behind than at the beginning of the semester. (Testimony of Lisa Holliday-Aggers.) Although an eligibility category was not identified on the January 25, 1999 IEP document, the document states that the IEP team, including MOTHER, agreed that STUDENT would continue in Mrs. Ferguson’s class and receive assistance in reading, written language, and math through the resource specialist program (RSP). (Pet.’s Exh. H.) The IEP team also recommended administering a speech and language screening. Goals and objectives in the areas of reading, written language, math, and pre-vocational were written and made a part of the January 25, 1999 IEP. (Id.) After receiving RSP instruction starting mid-year, STUDENT’S attitude began to improve; however, he continued to have great difficulty completing grade-level work and needed a great deal of one-on-one assistance. (Pet.’s Exh. C-4; Testimony of MOTHER.)
STUDENT began the 1999-2000 school year in Ms. Pellow’s regular education third-grade class at Cullen. On September 17, 1999, concerned that STUDENT’s RSP instruction had not yet begun for the 1999-2000 school year, MOTHER wrote the District and requested that an IEP team meeting be held. (Pet.’s Exh. I; testimony of MOTHER.) STUDENT’S RSP services resumed during the third full week of the fall semester. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) An IEP team meeting was held on December 6, 1999, at which time STUDENT’s parents and their advocates requested that STUDENT attend the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center (LMB) to receive a sensory cognitive intensive program, which they believed would address “remediation of [STUDENT’S] auditory processing and weak symbol imagery deficits.” (Pet.’s Exh. P-2.)(Footnote 3) However, the District members of the December 1999 IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed in Lenora Mar’s special day class (SDC) at Cullen. (Testimony of MOTHER and Christopher Russell.) The IEP team agreed to reconvene after MOTHER visited the SDC at Cullen, at which time STUDENT’s placement would be determined and goals and objectives written. The December 1999 IEP also notes that the parents would obtain an assessment from LMB. The parents believed that the District required them to obtain the assessment at their own expense before the District would consider placement at the LMB clinic. (Testimony of MOTHER.) MOTHER visited and observed Ms. Mar’s SDC for approximately two hours one morning in 1999, and concluded that Ms. Mar’s class would not meet STUDENT’s need in symbol imagery and phonemic awareness. (MOTHER; Pet.’s Exh. Q.)
On December 13, 1999, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing.
On December 14, 1999, STUDENT was tested at the LMB clinic. Almost all of STUDENT’s reading and spelling scores were at or below the 5th percentile, which, according to Angelica Benson of LMB, was shocking since she believed STUDENT had the capability and potential to achieve a much higher level. (Testimony of Angelica Benson.) The LMB preliminary testing summary indicated that STUDENT had weaknesses in the areas of phonemic awareness and symbol imagery. (Testimony of Angelica Benson; Pet’s. Exh. T.) According to Ms. Benson, if a student’s imagery is compromised, he/she will have memory difficulties. Ms. Benson described STUDENT as a “global” student, having several different impacted areas, all of which needed remediation. Ms. Benson recommended that STUDENT initially receive 16 to 20 weeks, four to six hours daily, of the Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing- phonemic awareness (LiPS), visual memory (Seeing Stars), and concept imagery (Visualizing & Verbalizing) programs. (Pet.’s Exh. T-3.)
On January 10, 2000, another IEP team meeting was held to consider a possible program change for STUDENT. (Pet.’s Exh. X.) Ms. Benson attended the January 10, 2000 IEP team meeting with STUDENT’s parents and advocates, and she reviewed her recommendations and the theoretical aspects of the LMB program. Ms. Benson also invited the District to call her with any questions it may have about the LMB program or STUDENT; however, she received no follow-up calls from the District. (Testimony of Angelica Benson.)
The January 10, 2000 IEP team, including STUDENT’S parents, agreed to the following trial placement until mediation between the parties had concluded:
1. STUDENT would spend mornings in the special day class;
2. Monday and Wednesday afternoon, STUDENT would remain in the SDC; and 3. Tuesday, Thursday and Friday afternoon, STUDENT would participate in his current third-grade class until dismissal time.
The IEP team decided that if STUDENT experienced any difficulty adapting to the above-noted program, his existing placement in the regular education classroom with RSP support would be reinstated at the request of his parents. The IEP also noted that STUDENT’S goals and objectives from the December 6, 1999 IEP would be continued. (Pet.’s Exh. X-1.)
As of January 18, 2000, STUDENT attended Lenora Mar’s SDC, where Ms. Mar temporarily placed him in a group of students with whom she was using the strategy of McCracken’s spelling through phonics. (Testimony of Lenora Mar.) STUDENT’S group was in the process of learning consonants and short vowel sounds. STUDENT remained in Ms. Mar’s class for 18 instructional days, through mid-February 2000. Ms. Mar testified that she did not see evidence of any measurable progress while STUDENT was in her class.
On February 17, 2000, FATHER forwarded a letter to Ted McNevin at the District, expressing his disappointment with STUDENT’s program, and informing the District that he intended to place STUDENT in the LMB clinic in Newport Beach for sensory cognitive therapy and would seek reimbursement for the LMB program. (Pet.’s Exh. AA.) STUDENT began receiving services at the LMB clinic on February 28, 2000. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Since STUDENT’S attendance at the LMB clinic affected his ability to comply with requirements regarding study time and the completion of assignments, the Cullen Elementary School principal, Cheryl Bonner, suggested that STUDENT enroll in the District’s independent study program. (Testimony of MOTHER.) MOTHER responded to this suggestion in a letter dated February 23, 2000, stating that STUDENT would attend the LMB clinic for three hours daily, and work at home one hour per day with computer-based learning.(Footnote 4) MOTHER also noted in her letter that STUDENT might be able to do the independent study program, but only after he completed the LMB program and learned to read. (Pet.’s Exh. BB.)
In February 2000, STUDENT’S parents removed him from the District and placed him at the LMB clinic. STUDENT received 12 of the 16-20 recommended weeks of instruction (168 hours) in the LMB LiPS and Seeing Stars (symbol imagery ) programs at the LMB clinic. (Pet.’s Exh. DD-1.) The issues were not resolved through mediation and the case proceeded to hearing.
On June 8, 2000, Patricia Martinez, deputy district attorney with the Los Angeles County District Attorney’s (D.A.) office, forwarded a letter to PARENTS regarding STUDENT’s poor school attendance and requested that they appear for a meeting with a representative of the D.A.’s office to discuss California law pertaining to regular school attendance. (Pet.’s Exh. EE.) STUDENT’s parents later were informed by the D.A.’s office that they need not attend the meeting, and the matter was subsequently dropped.
STUDENT never returned to the District, having moved with his family in August 2000 into the Pleasant Valley Unified School District (PVUSD). He began attending Las Collinas Elementary School in September 2000, where he currently is a special education student receiving RSP instruction in reading, math, and written language, and two hours a week of one-on-one instruction from PVUSD personnel in the LMB Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing (LiPS) and Visualizing/Verbalizing (V/V) programs for reading and spelling. (Testimony of Laura Whittington.)
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District improperly fail to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP meeting?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) State education law also requires districts to establish written policies and procedures for a “continuous child-find system” designed to locate, identify, and assess children within their jurisdictional boundaries who are eligible for special education. Those policies and procedures must include written notification to all parents of their rights and the procedures for initiating a referral for assessment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.)
The decision as to whether or not the assessment results demonstrate that the student requires special education must be made by the individualized education program (IEP) team. Moreover, the IEP team is required to take into account all relevant material that is available on the student. No single score or product of scores shall be used as the sole criterion for the IEP team’s decision as to the student’s eligibility for special education. (5 California Code of Regulations § 3030.)
Petitioner contends that the District failed to properly assess and identify him for special education services and, therefore, wrongfully denied him special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP team meeting. The District contends that Ms. Aggers’ psychoeducational evaluation concluded that STUDENT did not meet the state eligibility requirements for specific learning disability because there was no severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and one or more of his academic achievement scores in the area of reading. The District argues that the IEP team, including MOTHER, then concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education services pursuant to California Education Code § 56337.
Although STUDENT was not found eligible for special education at the November 16, 1998 IEP team meeting, the District offered to provide STUDENT with a Section 504 plan, which MOTHER later refused. The November 1998 IEP document also notes that a “mini achievement screening” would be conducted at the end of STUDENT’s second-grade year if he continued to struggle and show little progress within the classroom. Additionally, Ms. Holliday-Aggers’ psychoeducational report made a number of recommendations for modifications to STUDENT’S regular education program, including modifying or shortening assignments in reading and writing; using a multi-sensory reading program within a small-group setting when possible; rewarding STUDENT for starting, continuing, or completing assignments; assigning tracing activities to help him improve sensory motor skills and visual concentration; placing him in PIP to improve feelings about school; having him discuss current events, doing memory exercises and other enrichment activities to help his remote memory; repeating new skills, and having him work with digraphs and blends by adding them to word endings to form words. (Pet.’s Exh. F.)
At an IEP team meeting held of January 25, 1999, the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services because his second-grade teacher reported that his academics had recently fallen even more than at the beginning of the semester and his mother continued to have concerns regarding his lack of progress. STUDENT was identified as having a specific learning disability, although his eligibility category was not noted on the IEP document. The parties dispute the interpretation of STUDENT’s ability and achievement test scores in determining the existence of a severe discrepancy, and consequently, his eligibility, as of November 1998, for special education. Petitioner argues that the difference between his IQ performance scale score and his achievement test scores established a severe discrepancy. Petitioner offered no expert testimony to support his contention. Conversely, Ms. Holliday-Aggers testified credibly that from her professional judgment, education, and training, a severe discrepancy did not exist between the verbal and performance scale scores, and therefore, STUDENT’S IQ full scale score was a better representation of his actual potential. Consequently, STUDENT’S IQ full scale score was used to determine whether a severe discrepancy existed between his ability and achievement scores. Jule Dombrower, a District school psychologist since 1974, and current program specialist, concurred with Ms. Holliday-Aggers’ interpretation of STUDENT’S test scores.
Although Petitioner asserts that in November 1998, his test scores established that he was eligible for special education, much weight is given to the two school psychologists who concurred in their conclusions that STUDENT’S test scores did not establish eligibility. Although the IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services in January 1999, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the IEP team correctly found him ineligible for services at the November 16, 1998 IEP team meeting. The District then appropriately proposed to take remedial action at the November 1998 IEP team meeting when it offered STUDENT a Section 504 plan, modifications to his regular education program, and a “mini achievement screening” at the end of the school year if he continued to struggle. The evidence establishes that the District placed STUDENT in the least restrictive environment with appropriate modifications to his regular education program, and offered additional remedial support through a Section 504 plan, which was refused by STUDENT’S parents.
The Hearing Officer thus concludes that the District did not fail to properly identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services in November 1998. Although STUDENT did not receive special education services in November 1998, after unsuccessful trial modifications to his classroom program and the parents’ refusal to implement a Section 504 plan, the District took the next logical step in January 1999, and offered STUDENT special education services. 2. Was Petitioner denied a free appropriate public education for the 1998-1999 school year after he was found eligible for special education services in January 1999?
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code section 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District’s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Educ. Code § 56031.)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; (3) comported with his IEP; and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment.
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student's educational program. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Supreme Court noted in Rowley that "Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation" at every step "as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP." (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 205-206.) Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (W.G., supra, 960 F.2d at 1484.) Procedural violations which result in a "loss of educational opportunity" or which "seriously infringe the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE." (Id.)
Regarding the 1998-1999 school year, Petitioner contends that the District committed procedural errors that constituted a denial of FAPE. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that although the District recommended a speech and language screening, as noted on his January 25, 1999 IEP, the District failed to provide the parents with an assessment plan and a copy of the screening results and also failed to address those results in an IEP team meeting. Petitioner also alleges that during the January 25, 1999 IEP team meeting, the District failed to identify his category of eligibility.
Regarding the speech and language screening, STUDENT’s January 25, 1999 IEP notes that STUDENT was to receive a speech and language screening; however, the details regarding the time and place are not mentioned. Linda Haughtelin, STUDENT’S “case carrier” and RSP teacher, testified that after Margaret Schlosser conducted the speech and language screening, Ms. Schlosser verbally reported the results back to her. The negative results of the screening indicated that there was no need for a formal assessment and, therefore, an IEP team meeting was not called. An IEP team meeting is typically not called after a speech and language screening that produces negative results. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) A speech and language screening is not an assessment, but rather, a determination of whether there is a need for an assessment. (Testimony of Gigi Maurizio.)
The term “assessment” as used in applicable State special education law has the same meaning as the term “evaluation” in the IDEA. (California Education Code § 56302.5.) Thus, the Hearing Officer looks to the federal regulations applicable to the IDEA for guidance as to what constitutes an “assessment” for purposes of the IDEA. According to 34 Code of Federal Regulations § 300.500(b)(2), “evaluation” means procedures used to determine whether a child has a disability and the nature and extent of the special education and related services that the child needs.
Here, the speech and language screening was not used to determine whether STUDENT had a disability. Rather, it was used as an initial test to determine whether a full assessment was warranted. Moreover, at the January 25, 1999 IEP meeting, MOTHER had knowledge of, and agreed in writing to, the speech and language screening. The Hearing Officer finds that an informal screening process, the results of which do not warrant further formal assessment, does not rise to the level of a formal assessment designed to determine the existence of a disability, and thus does not require an assessment plan, assessment report, and subsequent IEP team meeting. The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’S parents should have been provided with the results of the speech and language screening. The actual one-page written report was first provided to Petitioner and put into evidence during the course of this due process proceeding. (Pet.’s Exhibit SS.) Petitioner did not show that he was prejudiced by the District’s failure to timely provide STUDENT’s parents with a copy of the written results of the speech and language screening. Therefore, the failure to provide the parents with a copy of the screening results did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringe upon his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process.
Petitioner also contends that the District failed to identify on his January 25, 1999 IEP his category of eligibility, thus precluding the IEP team from determining his unique educational needs. (Pet.’s Exh. H.) The District argues that the law does not require the IEP to include the student’s “disability category,” although, in practice, the IEP typically includes it. (Resp.’s closing argument, pg. 45.) The District adds that documents in STUDENT’S file described his difficulties and that school psychologist Lisa Holliday-Aggers discussed these difficulties with the parents during the IEP team meeting.
The Hearing Officer finds that identification of a student’s eligibility category is an essential step in the IEP process and should be noted on the IEP document so that parents and personnel implementing the program have information regarding the student’s disability and needs. However, both of Petitioner’s parents indicated that they were aware of STUDENT’S disability. In fact, MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s first-grade teacher suggested that STUDENT be tested because she believed he might have a learning disability. MOTHER also stated that after researching STUDENT’s assessment test scores, she understood that STUDENT’S scores indicated that he had a learning disability, which is why she requested that STUDENT receive special education services instead of a Section 504 plan. Gigi Maurizio, assistant superintendent of personnel services for the District, stated that MOTHER was eager to have STUDENT identified as learning disabled and made eligible for special education. Ms. Haughtelin, STUDENT’S RSP teacher, testified that she understood that STUDENT had a learning disability and that she helped draft the goals included in the IEP dated January 25, 1999. She also identified numerous strategies used to address STUDENT’S deficits in visual perception and memory and his other specific needs. Additionally, Ms. Maurizio testified that STUDENT was classified as a learning disabled student at the January 25, 1999 IEP team meeting and that the failure to identify STUDENT’S disability category on the IEP form was an error due to their unfamiliarity with the IEP form, having never before used it.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s IEP document should have clearly stated his area of disability. However, the evidence establishes that STUDENT’s disability was discussed during the January 25, 1999 IEP team meeting and that STUDENT’s parents were aware of his disability. There was no indication that the District’s failure to identify STUDENT’S category of eligibility on his IEP document resulted in loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or that it seriously infringed upon his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process.
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no denial of FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year because of procedural violations of the IDEA.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
The standard for evaluating the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offered program involves four factors: whether the placement and services were designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs, whether the placement and services provided him with educational benefit, whether the placement and services conformed to his IEP, and whether the program was provided in the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S. C. § 1400 et seq.; Education Code § 56031; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176.)
Petitioner contends that it became apparent towards the end of the 1998-1999 school year that STUDENT’s placement in the RSP program was not appropriate because it did not allow him to make educational progress. The District argues that the provision of RSP services, which included instruction in reading, math, and written language on a one-to-one and small-group basis, provided STUDENT with a FAPE.
Designed to meet his unique needs
The Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s unique needs as of January 25, 1999. The parties agree that STUDENT had a specific learning disability and that he had processing disorders in the areas of association and sensory-motor.
Information regarding STUDENT’S needs in second grade during the 1998-1999 school year can be gleaned from a review of testing done by District personnel and the Frostig Center. The District’s school psychologist, Lisa Holliday-Aggers, performed a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in September and October 1998. STUDENT achieved performance, verbal, and full scale IQ scores within the average range of cognitive ability on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children III test. However, the same test showed weaknesses in the areas of information, which involves long-term memory, and coding, which involves visual and motor skills. All except one of STUDENT’s WIAT, WRAT-3, and Woodcock Johnson-Revised subtest academic scores indicated that he was in the low average range in basic reading and reading comprehension, word recognition, math reasoning and calculation, spelling, and writing. STUDENT’S first-grade report card and growth and development chart indicated that he was below grade level in all academic areas and a nonreader. Ms. Okerson, STUDENT’s first-grade teacher, noted that she was concerned about STUDENT’S skill level in academic areas, especially language arts, and questioned whether he would be able to work successfully in the second grade. (Pet.’s Exh. C-2 & 4.)
Teacher comments on STUDENT’S second-grade report card for the first quarter stated that STUDENT needed to improve his reading and writing skills, but indicated that the parents’ working with him appeared to be helping. However, STUDENT’S first quarter second-grade achievement marks indicated that he was “not achieving minimal standards” in language arts, was achieving “limited success” in math, and “satisfactory” achievement in social science and health/science. (Pet.’s Exh. C–3.)
Finally, a report from the Frostig Center, where, during the summer of 1998, STUDENT attended a class on the basics of language arts, indicated that STUDENT could identify the sounds and words beginning with the first 8 letters of the alphabet, and was able to sound out 12 words. He had difficulty producing the short /a/ sound, and his attention often wondered in class. (Pet.’s Exh. E.) The report also recommended that STUDENT would benefit from a multisensory reading program in a one-on-one or very small group setting to sustain his attention. Ms. Haughtelin, STUDENT’S RSP teacher, testified that by the middle of second grade, a student should have some decoding, sight word, and basic spelling skills at the first level.(Footnote 5) He/she should also be able to use “inventive spelling” to put thoughts in writing, have some comprehension skills, know the names and sounds of all the alphabet letters, and add and subtract through 10, without regrouping. Ms. Haughtelin reported that during RSP language arts instruction, STUDENT was in a group of five students, two of whom were similar to STUDENT in terms of their knowledge of letter names and sounds. In October 1998, STUDENT scored at the pre-primer level on the Brigance reading test and when he began RSP, he did not know any letter sounds. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.)
In sum, testing and other evidence demonstrate that during the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT’s reading, spelling, and math skills were very low. Additionally, his second-grade teacher commented on his first quarter report card that his work was incomplete or late and that he was disruptive in class. (Pet.’s Exh. C-3.) District witnesses indicated that STUDENT was found eligible for special education because of the continual decline in his academics and because of his struggles in school. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin, Gigi Maurizio, and Lisa Holliday-Aggers.) The evidence establishes that STUDENT needed remedial assistance in the basics of reading, spelling, and math.
The Hearing Officer next considers whether the District’s program pursuant to the IEP dated January 25, 1999, was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs. After the development of the January IEP, STUDENT continued the 1998-1999 school year in Ms. Ferguson’s regular education second-grade class. However, RSP support in reading, written language, and math, four times a week, was added to his educational program. (Pet.’s Exh. H.)
The IEP dated January 25, 1999 includes goals to learn 50 new sight words with 90% accuracy, to write 5 sentences with a capital letter at the beginning and correct ending punctuation using 1 of 5 spelling words with 90% accuracy, to accurately compute 10 double-digit addition problems and 10 double-digit subtraction problems with regrouping with 80% accuracy, and to print his full name, full address, and phone number when asked with 80% accuracy.
During his second-grade year, STUDENT received RSP instruction on a one-on-one basis for math, and he was one of five students for language arts instruction. Ms. Haughtelin testified credibly that she used a variety of reading and writing programs and materials with STUDENT in the RSP class. (Resp.’s Exh. 15.) According to Ms. Haughtelin, during the forty-five minutes a day of RSP instruction, she used at least 4 or 5 of the 17 educational strategies listed in Respondent’s Exhibit 15. The Edmark and Random House programs were the mainstay programs that she used every day. The Edmark reading program directly relates to reading and spelling and was designed to teach sight words. The program is very repetitious and uses various multisensory modalities, including requiring the student to point, read out loud, and touch. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) The Random House Structural Reading program focused on decoding, with an emphasis on phonics. Use of a “language tray” that contains the letters of the alphabet helped STUDENT learn blends such as “fl” and “dr,” and learn to build words. To address STUDENT’S sensory motor needs, Ms. Haughtelin required a limited amount of paper/pencil tasks. She also used Geo-Safari electronic instructional games, which included a variety of pre-reading, phonics, and sight word activities. (Resp.’s Exh. 15, pg. 1; Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) Ms. Haughtelin also used a touch math program and the Insta-Learn language boards. The language boards were plastic trays with individual alphabet letters and jigsaw language strips for building words. The letters have grooves so that a student can feel the shape of the letter. To address STUDENT’S memory problems, Ms. Haughtelin used a lot of repetition of teaching and directions, asking STUDENT to repeat directions back to her, and memory and concentration games. In addition to certain Geo-Safari activities and the Edmark program, Ms. Haughtelin also used individual flash cards, certain activities on the Reader Rabbit computer program, and a word wall activity to respond to STUDENT’s sight word deficit. STUDENT also received reading, phonics, and math worksheets at least two times a week to complete as homework.
Other than MOTHER, none of Petitioner's witnesses observed STUDENT’s placement during the second grade. However, the District's witness who testified that the RSP instruction addressed STUDENT'S needs--Ms. Haughtelin--worked directly with STUDENT in an educational environment. Her testimony establishes that STUDENT received individual and small-group instruction in reading, math, and written language, which had been identified as his areas of need. The testimony of Ms. Haughtelin establishes that she employed strategies that were consistent with the recommendations of assessors and therefore designed to meet STUDENT’S needs. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Haughtelin’s testimony persuasive with respect to the District's providing a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer next determines whether the District’s program provided STUDENT with educational benefit. Petitioner contends that the RSP services did not allow STUDENT to make educational progress. (Pet.’s closing argument, pg. 8.) The District argues that there was evidence that STUDENT received some educational benefit from the RSP because he made progress in his goals and objectives. (Resp.’s closing argument, pg. 15.) As shown above, STUDENT’S program was individualized on the basis of his psychoeducational assessment and his performance. Ms. Haughtelin testified that STUDENT’S IEP provided the appropriate support while having STUDENT participate as much as possible in general education. Ms. Haughtelin, an experienced RSP teacher, was STUDENT’S “case carrier,” and responsible for scheduling his IEP meetings, completing his benchmark reports, and providing actual RSP instruction. Ms. Haughtelin testified that STUDENT’S progress was clear, if a bit slow and tedious. According to Ms. Haughtelin, STUDENT was making appropriate progress for a child with a learning disability. In April and June 1999, STUDENT made “good progress” on one of his objectives and “some progress” on all other objectives. (Pet.’s Exh. J.) By April 1999, STUDENT had learned 20 new sight words and he could build words with the language tray with less difficulty. STUDENT did not know the sounds of letters when he started RSP in February 1999; however, he showed progress in this area by the end of the 1998-1999 school year. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) Ms. Haughtelin also testified that although informal assessments indicated that STUDENT was still reading at the pre-primer level, he missed fewer words when re-tested in October 1999. (Pet.’s Exh. N.) Finally, MOTHER testified that the RSP significantly helped STUDENT both socially and emotionally, to the point that his second- grade teacher commented that he was no longer “acting out” in class. The evidence establishes that the District’s program pursuant to the IEP dated January 25, 1999, provided STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1998-1999 school year.
Conform to the IEP
There was no dispute that STUDENT’S program conformed to the IEP. There is no dispute that services identified in the IEP dated January 25, 1999 were provided to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year.
Least Restrictive Environment
There was no dispute that STUDENT’s program during the 1998-1999 school year was provided in the least restrictive environment.
Conclusion
As determined above, the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’S educational needs, provided him with educational benefit, conformed to his IEP and was provided in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District provided STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 1998-1999 school year.
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the vision therapy assessment performed in 1998 by Dr. Stephey’s office?
Petitioner contends that his parents should be reimbursed for the vision therapy assessment performed by Dr. Stephey’s office since his first-grade teacher suggested that his parents have his “eyes checked.” A parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if: (1) the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show that its evaluation was appropriate at a due process hearing. (34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).) Federal and State special education law provides that before any action can be taken with regard to the placement of a child in special education, an assessment of the student’s educational needs shall be conducted. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.) When a parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public educational agency, the parent has the right to an independent assessment from qualified specialists at public expense, unless it is established in a due process hearing that the public educational agency’s assessment was appropriate. (Education Code § 56329(b).) For the educational agency’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which states, in part, that a school district’s assessment must be administered by qualified personnel and utilize instruments that are not racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory and that must have been validated for the purpose for which they are used. Subsection 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.
In the present case, an assessment plan was signed by MOTHER on August 1, 1998, and received by the District on September 10, 1998. (Resp.’s Exh. 1.) The District’s psychologist conducted an initial psycho-educational study of STUDENT in September and October 1998. The assessment covered all areas of suspected disability, including academic achievement, personal, social, and emotional development, perceptual-motor development, speech and language, learning potential, vocational skills, vision and hearing, and neurological development. The psychologist’s November 16, 1998 report noted that STUDENT passed both vision and hearing screenings within normal limits. Further, there is no dispute that the District’s assessments were administered by qualified personnel, utilized nondiscriminatory instruments, and were validated for the purposes for which they were used.
Petitioner contends that the District instructed him to obtain a vision therapy assessment before any other assessments would be conducted by the District. (Pet.’s Issue Statement.) By her own testimony, however, MOTHER acknowledged that STUDENT’S first-grade teacher, Ms. Okerson, suggested that STUDENT have his “eyes checked.” MOTHER then made an appointment with their family therapist, who, after confirming that STUDENT had 20/15 vision, recommended that STUDENT see Dr. Stephey for further consultation. There is no convincing evidence that the District instructed the parents to obtain a vision therapy assessment for STUDENT.
Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s parents obtained the vision assessment by Dr. Stephey’s office prior to the assessments performed by the District.(Footnote 6) The District mailed the assessment plan to the parents on June 19, 1998, the parents signed it on August 1, 1998, and the District received the signed plan on September 10, 1998. Dr. Stephey’s associate, Dr. Kwon, completed her testing on May 12, 1998, and her report on May 14, 1998, long before STUDENT was referred for assessment by the District.
Dr. Kwon’s assessment was not the result of the parents’ disagreement with the District’s assessment. MOTHER testified that she took STUDENT to Dr. Stephey’s office for “further consultation” at the suggestion of their family therapist. Petitioner’s request does not meet the statutory criteria for reimbursement because there was no District assessment with which the parents disagreed; therefore, the parents did not have the right to an independent assessment at public expense. Having failed to meet the statutory requirements for reimbursement, Petitioner’s request for reimbursement of the independent vision assessment by Dr. Soonsi Kwon of Dr. Stephey’s office is denied.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of vision therapy provided in 1998 and 1999 by Dr. Stephey’s office and the costs of transportation to and from therapy sessions?
Petitioner asserts that Dr. Stephey’s services were obtained at the request of STUDENT’s first- grade teacher, Ms. Okerson. According to MOTHER, Ms. Okerson told her that STUDENT was having many problems in class and she thought that perhaps STUDENT’S eyes did not process what he saw. Ms. Okerson suggested that she first call their family optometrist and have STUDENT’ eyes checked and possibly obtain vision therapy. STUDENT was examined by the family’s optometrist, who concluded that STUDENT’s eyes were fine and that he had 20/15 vision. However, the optometrist nevertheless recommended that STUDENT see Dr. Stephey for further consultation. (Testimony of MOTHER.) The Hearing Officer notes that there was no evidence explaining the family optometrist’s recommendation for further consultation. The May 14, 1998 assessment conducted by Dr. Stephey’s office recommended a vision therapy program designed to remediate STUDENT’S eye movement and visual perceptual deficiencies. However, the assessor also alerted the parents that any improvements in those areas from the vision therapy “should not be expected to directly improve school or reading performance.” (Pet.’s Exh. D-2.) STUDENT started vision therapy with Dr. Stephey’s office in approximately May 1998, and continued until June or July 1998. However, the vision therapy did not help STUDENT with his academic problems. (Testimony of MOTHER.) Although Ms. Okerson told MOTHER that vision therapy was not working, MOTHER continued sending STUDENT to vision therapy in hopes of seeing some improvement. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student's unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student's individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8)(D), (25).) Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from his education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a).) Vision therapy is a related service under Title 5, California Code of Regulations, Section 3051.75. Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services they have procured for their child when a school district failed to provide an appropriate education, and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 370 (1985); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c).) Although the parents’ services do not have to meet a standard as high as a school district must meet, the parents’ services must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a service that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. (Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993).)
The evidence establishes that the vision therapy did not help STUDENT with his classroom problems because he did not progress; STUDENT still had the same problems and his reading did not improve. There was no evidence why the family optometrist referred STUDENT to Dr. Stephey’s office or that he required vision therapy. Additionally, Dr. Stephey’s office alerted STUDENT’S parents not to expect improvement in school. Petitioner did not establish that he required vision therapy during the 1998-1999 school year to meet his unique needs or to benefit from his educational program. Therefore, Petitioner has not established that he is entitled to reimbursement for this related service as a form of replacement services. Consequently, Petitioner is also not entitled to reimbursement for costs of transportation to and from vision therapy.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the Phono–Graphix program that was provided by Dr. Stephey?
Petitioner requests reimbursement for a copy of the Phono-Graphix program that he obtained from optometrist Dr. Douglas W. Stephey during the 1998-1999 school year. A letter dated October 15, 1999, from Dr. Stephey states that his office used the Phono-Graphix program to provide reading therapy to STUDENT, but STUDENT attended irregularly and was last seen by Dr. Stephey on August 31, 1999. (Pet.’s Exh. K.) Petitioner has not established that he required this program to meet his unique needs or to benefit from his educational program. In fact, FATHER testified that from 1998 through 2000, STUDENT made no progress with the Phono-Graphix program. Additionally, no information was provided that Petitioner required and was eligible for similar assistive technology. Therefore, Petitioner has not established that he is entitled to reimbursement for this program.
6. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
A. Procedural Appropriateness
Petitioner contends that the District committed a number of procedural errors during the 1999-2000 school year. Considering the results of the substantive analysis below, it is only necessary to discuss the following procedural errors. Specifically, Petitioner alleged that the District failed to identify his present levels of performance at IEP meetings, failed to provide written documentation of its rejection of his parents’ request for LMB services, and failed to hold an IEP meeting when he demonstrated a lack of anticipated progress.
Present Levels of Performance
The first IEP team meeting during the 1999-2000 school year occurred on December 6, 1999. Petitioner and Respondent stipulated during the hearing that Petitioner was only provided with a two-page IEP document during the December 1999 IEP meeting. Those two pages are admitted as Petitioner’s Exhibit P. Respondent’s Exhibit 8, however, consists of 14 pages, and is labeled in its exhibit packet as the annual IEP dated December 6, 1999. The District’s version of the December 6, 1999 IEP contains pages noting STUDENT’S present levels of performance at that time. However, the two-page IEP document that the parents received at the December 6, 1999 meeting includes only the signature page and a comments page that included the parents’ request that a sensory cognitive intensive program, such as that offered by LMB, be used to remediate STUDENT’S auditory processing and weak symbol imagery deficits. MOTHER and Mr. Russell, the parents’ advocate, both testified that they first saw the District’s Exhibit 8, which contains STUDENT’S present levels of performance as of December 6, 1999, when they received the District’s evidence packet in this matter.
Education Code section 56345 requires that the IEP document state the present levels of the student’s performance, including how the student’s disability affects the student’s involvement and progress in the general curriculum. The December 6, 1999 IEP document that STUDENT’S parents received at the December 1999 IEP team meeting (Exhibit P) did not include STUDENT’S present levels of performance or an indication of how his disability affects his involvement and progress. District witnesses, as well as MOTHER, testified that the initial intent of the December 6, 1999 IEP meeting was to discuss the late start of STUDENT’S RSP services. However, during the meeting, the IEP team discussed the services that STUDENT was receiving and his level of progress. (Testimony of MOTHER and Christopher Russell.) The meeting resulted in the participants agreeing to reconvene to decide placement and to write goals and objectives after STUDENT was tested at LMB and his parents had visited the SDC. (See Pet.’s Exh. P.) In spite of the IEP team’s agreement, the requirements of Education Code Section 56345 were not met in that the necessary information was not recorded on the IEP document provided to the parents.
The Hearing Officer next analyzes the same issue regarding the IEP team meeting held on January 10, 2000. The IEP dated January 10, 2000, consists of two pages, including the signature page and an optional page that outlines STUDENT’s trial placement in the SDC that would be in place until the parties concluded mediation. (Pet.’s Exh. X.) The IEP dated January 10, 2000, fails to state STUDENT’S present levels of performance; however, page one of the document recommends continuation of the goals and objectives from the December 6, 1999 IEP. As discussed above, the December 6, 1999 IEP received by the parents did not list any goals and objectives or STUDENT’S present levels of performance. Therefore, the January 2000 IEP was inadequate because it refers to the December 1999 IEP provided to the parents, which did not include STUDENT’S levels of performance.
Written Rejection of LMB Request
Petitioner alleges that the District failed to provide written documentation of the rejection of the parent’s request for LMB services. During the December 1999 IEP team meeting, the parents’ advocates requested, on STUDENT’s behalf, that STUDENT receive LMB educational services. (Testimony of MOTHER.) According to Petitioner’s and District witnesses, the District verbally informed STUDENT’S parents that before the District could consider LMB, STUDENT first must be assessed by the LMB clinic, at the parents’ expense. STUDENT was assessed by the LMB clinic; however, during the January 10, 2000 IEP team meeting, the parties ultimately agreed to temporarily place STUDENT in the SDC. PARENTS and Christopher Russell all testified that the during the January 10, 2000 IEP team meeting, the District verbally indicated it was not willing to pay for LMB services for STUDENT.
Nowhere on the IEP dated January 10, 2000, is it written that the District rejected the parents’ request for LMB services. The IDEA requires that the District provide parents with prior written notice whenever it refuses to change the educational placement of a child. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3).) Some of things that the prior written notice must include are a description of the action refused by the district, why the district refuses to take action, a basis for the refused action, and any other relevant factors. (20 U.S.C. § 1415(c).) Although the evidence indicates that STUDENT’S parents knew the District was unwilling to place STUDENT at the LMB clinic, the District failed to provide written notice of its rejection to the parents as required under the IDEA.
Failure to Hold IEP Team Meeting
Petitioner contends that the District should have held an IEP team meeting when he demonstrated a lack of progress. STUDENT’S third-grade teacher, Sandra Pellow, testified that at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, she informally spoke with Ms. Haughtelin about a possible change in placement for STUDENT. By the end of September 1999, Ms. Pellow wasn’t seeing any immediate progress in STUDENT’S work and believed the regular education third-grade class with RSP was not the appropriate program for him. Because of this lack of progress, Ms. Pellow and Ms. Haughtelin decided that an IEP meeting should be held to discuss STUDENT’S progress and possible placement change. (Testimony of Sandra Pellow and Linda Haughtelin.) Ms. Pellow also informally talked with MOTHER about her concerns. (Testimony of Sandra Pellow.) Ms. Haughtelin testified, however, that she wanted to give STUDENT some time in the RSP during the 1999-2000 school year because she understood that STUDENT received some special training or tutoring over the summer and that, therefore, she did not want to automatically send him to a more restrictive SDC immediately upon his return to school in the fall 1999. Consequently, an IEP team meeting was not arranged until MOTHER, concerned about the late start of RSP services in the fall 1999, forwarded a letter dated September 17, 1999, to Mr. McNevin at the District asking that an IEP team meeting be scheduled. (Testimony of MOTHER; Pet.’s Exh. I.) Ms. Haughtelin stated that she was “glad” an IEP team meeting was eventually held in December 1999, because she and Ms. Pellow both felt that STUDENT needed more help than what was offered in RSP. Both teachers felt that a full-day special day class would be appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs, especially in science and social studies, where he needed more individual attention. According to Ms. Pellow, STUDENT needed to be in a small-group setting with some one-to-one instruction within a small group, and she believed that an SDC could provide STUDENT with such an environment.
The Hearing Officer finds that an IEP team meeting should have been scheduled, at the latest, within 30 days of receipt of the parent’s September 17, 1999 letter requesting a review of STUDENT’S IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code Sect. 56343.5) In the alternative, when STUDENT’S regular education and RSP teachers had serious concerns about STUDENT’S placement and lack of anticipated progress in the program, an IEP team meeting should have been scheduled. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56343(b).) The Hearing Officer finds it unacceptable for the District to have waited three months to determine if STUDENT would succeed in a program, particularly when both regular and special education teachers realized from the beginning of the school year that the program was not meeting his needs. Ms. Haughtelin testified that IEP team meetings were scheduled, but STUDENT’S parents cancelled them, making it impossible to have an IEP team meeting in a timely manner. The special education time-line waiver that was admitted into evidence states that the District scheduled IEP team meetings for STUDENT on October 18, 1999, and November 1, 1999, both of which were either postponed or cancelled at the parents’ request. (See Resp.’s Exh. 16; Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) STUDENT’s parents, however, did not sign the waiver. Therefore, the evidence is inconclusive as to reason for the delay of the IEP meeting. Nevertheless, as a result of these delays, STUDENT’s next IEP team meeting was not held until December 6, 1999. If STUDENT’S teachers had concerns regarding the appropriateness of STUDENT’s program and his lack of anticipated progress, the District should have scheduled an IEP team meeting and held that meeting within the required statutory time frame, regardless of whether the parents were available to attend. A district can conduct an IEP team meeting without a student’s parent if it is unable to convince the parent that he/she should attend. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).) Moreover, if neither parent is able to attend, a district must use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f).) There is no evidence that the District attempted to use other methods to include parent participation in the IEP team meetings scheduled in October and November 1999.
The delay in holding an IEP team meeting and ultimately revising STUDENT’s educational program resulted in STUDENT’S remaining in an inappropriate placement that did not meet his needs until January 2000, and consequently, in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT for half of the 1999-2000 school year.
In conclusion, as noted above, the Hearing Officer finds that during the 1999-2000 school year, the District committed procedural errors that affected STUDENT's education and his parents’ participation in the IEP process. The legal consequences of those errors will be discussed below.
B. Substantive Appropriateness
The 1999-2000 school year began in September 1999. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) From September 1999 to January 2000, STUDENT continued in the regular education program with RSP support, pursuant to his previously agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated January 25, 1999. Thereafter, pursuant to an IEP dated January 10, 2000, STUDENT was placed in an SDC, where he remained for only 18 instructional days before his parents unilaterally removed him from the District.
Petitioner disputes that the District provided him a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year on several grounds. First, Petitioner alleges that his continued placement at the beginning of the school year in the RSP did not meet his unique educational needs or provide him educational benefit. Petitioner also alleges that at the beginning of the fall 1999 semester, the District’s program failed to comport with his then-current January 25, 1999 IEP, in that the RSP services listed in his IEP were not timely provided. Petitioner also alleges that once he was placed in the special day class, his teacher, Ms. Mar, did not timely provide instruction. Lastly, Petitioner alleges that at the December 1999 and January 2000 IEP team meetings, the District failed to determine what placement constituted the least restrictive environment. Respondent contends that the program and services provided to STUDENT fulfilled the requirements of California law.
STUDENT’s unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year
The Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’S unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year. The parties still agreed that STUDENT had a specific learning disability, but disagreed as to the severity of the disability. Consequently, the parties also disagreed as to the type of services and placement STUDENT needed during the 1999-2000 school year.
At the beginning to 1999-2000 school year, the District assumed that STUDENT’s needs remained the same as those of the previous school year, and continued to provide services to STUDENT in accordance with his January 25, 1999 IEP. However, early into the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’ regular education and RSP teachers became concerned that his continued placement in the same program would not meet his needs since he could not perform grade-level work. Petitioner’s parents also were concerned about his lack of progress, and during the December 6, 1999 IEP team meeting, they requested that STUDENT be placed in an intensive program of 4 to 6 hours of instruction per day, five days per week, for an initial 16 to 20 week period at the LMB clinic. The District believed that STUDENT’S initial placement in the regular education third-grade class with RSP provided STUDENT with an academic program that met his educational needs and that placement at LMB would have been too restrictive.
Information regarding the intensity of STUDENT’S needs during the 1999-2000 school year is obtained from a review of testing done by District personnel and the LMB clinic.
As previously stated, the November 16, 1998 psychoeducational evaluation indicated that STUDENT had processing disorders in the areas of association and sensory-motor. These disorders were reflected in STUDENT’S deficits in the area of long-term memory and visual perception.
Ms. Pellow, STUDENT’S third-grade teacher, testified that when STUDENT entered her class at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year, he was still reading at the pre-primer level (end of kindergarten, beginning of first grade).(Footnote 7) According to Ms. Pellow, STUDENT needed a great deal of individual or small-group instruction to help him progress. He also had great difficulty finishing assignments and had a limited range of reading abilities, requiring constant assistance from Ms. Pellow or her aide. When STUDENT came across a word in context, he could, on a limited basis, sound out the word and recognize it. However, Ms. Pellow testified that she does not believe this is “reading.” Rather, “reading” is reading an entire passage and understanding its context. Ms. Pellow observed that STUDENT knew 15 or 16 very basic words and could sound out words, such as “cat,” to which he had been exposed; however, he had not mastered consonant-vowel-consonant (cvc) words. Although STUDENT could communicate and had good spoken vocabulary, his spelling was very poor. According to Ms. Pellow, STUDENT was considerably below the skill level of other students in the class.
Ms. Haughtelin administered several informal assessment tests at the beginning of 1999-2000 school year and in December 1999. In September 1999, STUDENT was at the pre-primer level for sight words. (Pet.’s Exh. M-2; Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.) As of December 1999, STUDENT scored 50% at the pre-primer level in word recognition on the Green Brigance test, and was not yet able to pass the pre-primer level in oral reading and reading comprehension on the Green Brigance test. Although STUDENT knew approximately 35-40 sight words, he was unable to read on his own and could not read third-grade materials across the curriculum. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) Regarding written language, in December 1999, STUDENT scored 60% at the first-grade level in spelling on the Green Brigance test, and his writing efforts were minimal in RSP since he had great difficulty thinking of something to write. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) As of December 1999, STUDENT scored 100% at the first-grade level and 75% at the second-grade level in math computational skills on the Green Brigance test, and was unable to pass the lowest level in word problems on the Green Brigance. STUDENT was completing modified and shortened assignments in general education third-grade math with highly inconsistent progress. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.)
In testing done at the LMB Newport Beach clinic on December 14, 1999, STUDENT scored in the 63rd percentile on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-III, the 9th percentile in oral directions on the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-2, the 25th percentile in word opposites and the 18th percentile in problem solving-R on the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-4, the 25th percentile on word attack on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-NU, the 3rd percentile on the Slosson Oral Reading Test-R, the 3rd percentile in spelling and 5th percentile in arithmetic on the Wide Range Achievement Test-3, and a score of 57 on the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization (LAC) test. Angelica Benson, current regional director of development for LMB, testified that scores in the 25 to 75 percentile range are considered average, with 25 percent being borderline average. Regarding the LAC test, according to Ms. Benson, although this test is not yet normed, scores are reviewed in comparison with the scores of students in other grade levels. STUDENT’S score of 57 indicated he was at the middle of first-grade level as to his knowledge of nonsense words. According to these standards, STUDENT scored well below average in all but two of the tests administered.
As established above, the District erred in not holding an IEP team meeting to address the concerns of both STUDENT’S teachers and his parents. Testing and other evidence establishes that during the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’S needs were intensive. He had problems in all academic areas, he could not read, and his long- term memory, visual perception, and visual memory negatively affected his ability to complete grade-level work. Both his regular education and RSP teachers testified that STUDENT was increasingly off-task, his tasks were not completed, he was regularly tired, extremely lethargic and unmotivated in class, and would often “blank out” as if he was unable to mentally focus. STUDENT’S behaviors prompted his teachers to write a letter to a medical doctor and to encourage his parents to have STUDENT seen by a doctor to rule out any physical and/or neurological causes for his behaviors. (Pet.’s Exh. R.) These problems first surfaced in STUDENT’s third-grade year. STUDENT’s teachers noticed marked changes in his classroom performance and in his social behavior. STUDENT’S limited abilities made it impossible for him to perform at grade level without constant assistance.
As will be discussed more fully below, STUDENT’S third-grade and RSP teachers both believed that STUDENT needed more assistance than what was offered in the general education and RSP programs. STUDENT’S difficulties with word recognition, oral reading, reading comprehension, spelling, math, and written language warranted an intensive program.
The Hearing Officer next separately considers the appropriateness of the District’s RSP and SDC programs during the 1999-2000 school year.
Third-Grade Regular Education Class with Resource Specialist Program (RSP): September 1999 - January 2000
Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs
Ms. Pellow, STUDENT’S third-grade classroom teacher, testified that she or her aide often assisted STUDENT during reading assignments since STUDENT had great difficulty finishing assignments, especially in science, social studies, and math, where he needed individual attention. Each day the class participated in “centers,” which were language arts-based activities, such as reading the newspaper, working on the computer, and other activities conducted at their tables. STUDENT had difficulty participating in the newspaper activities because he couldn’t read the words. Consequently, Ms. Pellow would use an “easy” book to do “shadow reading” with STUDENT. Shadow reading involved reading with STUDENT in unison, and pausing and letting him sound out words she thought he may not know. STUDENT was placed in a class group with four other children who had lower reading abilities; however, STUDENT’s skills were considerably below the four other group members.
Ms. Pellow also testified that the goals and objectives that were being implemented during STUDENT’S third-grade year were appropriate; however, she believed his needs were not being met in regular education and RSP because STUDENT was not making sufficient progress. Ms. Pellow stated that she was unable to give STUDENT the individual or small-group instruction he needed to progress at an appropriate rate. The number of students in her classroom also affected STUDENT’s ability to progress, and time constraints worked against STUDENT in that she was limited in the amount of time she was able to work directly with him. (Testimony of Sandra Pellow.)
The credible testimony of the teachers who worked directly with STUDENT indicated that he was in the wrong placement and not receiving the services he needed to make sufficient progress. The evidence supports a finding that the program consisting of placement in the regular education third-grade classroom with RSP support four times a week did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer next determines whether the District’s program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT meaningful educational benefit. Ms. Pellow and Ms. Haughtelin both testified that STUDENT was making limited progress from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. By November 1999, STUDENT had met only one of his benchmarks. (Pet.’s Exh. J.) Ms. Pellow also testified that because of STUDENT’s lack of progress, she knew as early as the end of September 1999 that placement in her class may not be appropriate because she was unsure that she could meet his needs. In addition, Ms. Pellow testified that although she was familiar with STUDENT’S IEP, STUDENT’S participation in many of the class activities that involved reading was limited because he could not read, and neither Ms. Pellow nor her aide had sufficient time to give him the individual support he needed. Lastly, although STUDENT knew 35-40 sight words by December 1999, Ms. Haughtelin testified that the fact that STUDENT was still reading at the pre-primer level in February 2000 did not demonstrate sufficient progress.
Although the District is only required to provide STUDENT with a “basic floor of opportunity,” de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczek v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d. Cir. 1998; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 208.) The Hearing Officer concludes that the program outlined in the IEP dated January 25, 1999, which continued to be implemented in September 1999, through January 2000, was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit during the first half of his third-grade year.
Conform to the IEP
Petitioner contends that the District’s program failed to conform to his IEP. STUDENT’S IEP dated January 25, 1999, called for RSP services four times per week in the RSP room. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s third-grade year started out disastrously because STUDENT did not receive RSP services for the first two weeks of the 1999-2000 school year. She testified that for the first two weeks of the school year, STUDENT would segregate himself from the other children by sitting on the playground by himself and would come home from school crying. MOTHER spoke with Ms. Haughtelin about the delay in the start of RSP services, and was told that Ms. Haughtelin’s room was under construction. (Testimony of MOTHER.)
Ms. Haughtelin testified that RSP classes generally don’t take place during the first few weeks of school because she has to review IEPs, devise programs, conduct her own assessments, and coordinate schedules with the regular education teachers. Additionally, starting RSP classes after the first two weeks of the school year allows the RSP students to feel they are a total part of the regular education class and not singled out. Ms. Haughtelin added that she believes STUDENT’S RSP instruction started on the Monday of the third full week of the school year because of construction in her classroom.
The evidence establishes that the District failed to timely provide STUDENT’S RSP services at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year and, therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program did not conform to IEP dated January 25, 1999, for a brief time during the 1999-2000 school year.
Least Restrictive Environment
Although Petitioner alleged that the District failed to determine the least restrictive environment, the December 1999 IEP called for STUDENT to receive some instruction in the regular education classroom. There is no evidence that STUDENT was not educated, to the maximum extent possible, with children who are not disabled.
Conclusion
In summary, as determined above, the District committed both procedural and substantive violations of the IDEA during the 1999-2000 school year. Standing alone, some of the procedural violations by the District might not have amounted to a denial of a FAPE. For example, standing alone, the failure to provide written notice of rejection of the parents’ request for LMB services and the two-week delay of RSP services do not amount to a denial of FAPE. However, considered collectively, the District’s substantive and procedural violations clearly resulted in a denial of FAPE as they resulted in STUDENT not receiving the appropriate special education services from September 1999 until January 2000.
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District’s program from September 1999 to January 2000, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and did not conform to his IEP for the first two weeks of the 1999-2000 school year. In addition, the District committed prejudicial procedural violations of the IDEA, which caused a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT for half of the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the first half of the1999-2000 school year.
Special Day Class (SDC): January 18, 2000 - mid-February 2000
The January 10, 2000 IEP placed STUDENT on a trial basis in Lenora Mar’s SDC, with three afternoons per week in the regular education third-grade class. The January 2000 IEP also states that STUDENT’S goals and objectives from his December 6, 1999 IEP would continue. (Pet.’s Exh. X.)
Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs
STUDENT’S goals and objectives from the IEP dated December 6, 1999, continued when he began the SDC on January 18, 2000. (Resp.’s Exh. 8.) Ms. Mar testified that she informally evaluated STUDENT upon his entry into her class and placed him in a group that she believed was most appropriate for him.(Footnote 8) She determined that STUDENT was weak in the areas of word recognition, oral reading fluency, and sight word skills. After the January 10, 2000 IEP team meeting, Ms. Mar prepared new draft goals and objectives, which she brought to be discussed with the parents during the mediation conference held on February 14, 2000. (Pet.’s Exh. Y.) However, STUDENT’S parents removed him from the District before those goals and objectives were implemented. (Pet.’s Exh. AA; Testimony of Lenora Mar.) Goals from the District’s version of the December 6, 1999 IEP included reading fluently with comprehension when shown a grade 1, 2nd semester reading passage and writing a sentence for each of 5 spelling words with beginning capital letter and correct ending punctuation. Goals from the IEP dated February 14, 2000, included reading fluently, writing in paragraph format, adding and subtracting double-digit numbers with or without regrouping, and independently completing classroom tasks. The significant difference between the December 1999 IEP and the January 2000 IEP was the placement for implementing the goals and objectives.
STUDENT attended the SDC each morning and two afternoons per week. All other time was spent in his regular education classroom. Most of his instruction was received in small groups, unless Ms. Mar had time to work with him individually. During the time that STUDENT attended Ms. Mar’s class, she had 11 third-, fourth-, and fifth-grade students who had learning disabilities, including various processing disorders. She had one full time aide and one other aide who worked directly with another child. (Testimony of Lenora Mar.) Ms. Mar testified credibly that she is trained in early intervention strategies for at-risk, struggling readers, which include having a print-rich environment, doing “modeling,” and using guided reading. Ms. Mar testified that she tries to coordinate her program as much as possible with the general education program.
Ms. Mar stated that strategies used in her program would address areas in which STUDENT demonstrated weakness, such as symbol imagery, phonemic awareness, explicit phonics, sight words, and literacy skills. (See Resp.’s Exh 14.) Ms. Mar also stated that most of the students she has taught in the past have had disabilities based on discrepancies in reading, writing, and math and that her program has worked successfully with students with needs similar to STUDENT’s. According to Ms. Mar, her program could meet STUDENT’S needs and address his goals.
The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Mar persuasively identified how the educational strategies employed in her SDC could successfully meet STUDENT’S unique needs.
Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The parties did not dispute that STUDENT needed to work on reading, writing and math skills. Ms. Mar testified that she observed STUDENT in her class, placed him in a group that best fit his needs and had like-skilled peers, and prepared new draft goals and objectives that could be addressed in her class. Because STUDENT attended the SDC for only 18 instructional days, there was not sufficient time to determine whether he progressed. (Testimony of Lenora Mar.) However, according to Ms. Mar, from her success in utilizing the Edmark and other instructional strategies with similarly situated students, she believed that STUDENT also would have made at least six-month’s progress in a year’s time while in her program. Ms. Mar testified that after STUDENT achieved a foundation at the pre-primer level, he would likely have progressed in his decoding skills, and then increased his sight word bank. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Mar’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s potential success had he remained in her program. Ms. Mar had been teaching for 23 years and her credible testimony about her program and the specific strategies that she successfully uses in her class establishes that the District’s offer of placement in the SDC would have provided STUDENT with educational benefit during the 1999-2000 school year.
Conform to the IEP
Petitioner contends that Ms. Mar failed to provide STUDENT with SDC services in February 2000 because she was conducting additional testing. (Pet.’s closing argument, pg. 32.) However, the evidence does not support this contention. Ms. Mar testified that during class, she observed STUDENT’S work and how he fit in with the group to which he was assigned. She also stated that she administered some informal, nonstandardized tests to STUDENT as a way to monitor his growth. (Testimony of Lenora Mar.) There was no indication that STUDENT missed instruction because of testing. STUDENT started attending the SDC on January 18, 2000, and Ms. Mar testified that when STUDENT entered the class, she temporarily placed him in a group with whom she was utilizing the strategy of McCracken spelling with phonics. The Hearing Officer finds that the District provided the placement, services, and implementation of goals and objectives in the IEP dated January 10, 2000.
Least Restrictive Environment
Petitioner contends that there was no discussion at the January 2000 IEP team meeting as to what constituted the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that, therefore, Respondent failed to comply with State and federal requirements to determine the LRE. According to District witnesses, a good deal of time during the January 2000 IEP team meeting was spent discussing the LMB program with its director, Angelica Benson. Ted McNevin, director of instructional and student support services for the District, testified that the IEP team considered the fact that when compared to general education and RSP support, the SDC was the next level of placement on the continuum of least restrictive environments. The SDC was the least restrictive environment because the regular education and RSP were no longer appropriate for STUDENT’s needs. Therefore, the decision was made to place STUDENT in an SDC.
The evidence establishes that the IEP team considered and chose the LRE when proposing a placement for STUDENT in the SDC.
Conclusion
The Hearing Officer finds that the District made an appropriate offer to place STUDENT in Lenora Mar’s SDC at Cullen, where goals and objectives in reading, writing and math could be implemented on a more intensive basis. Credible testimony from Ms. Mar confirmed that placement in the SDC was reasonably calculated to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, was designed to provide him with educational benefit, conformed to his IEP, and was provided in the least restrictive environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the last half of the 1999-2000 school year.
7. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) assessment and program services he received from March through July 2000, and the costs of transportation to and from the LMB clinic?
Petitioner seeks reimbursement for his attendance at the LMB clinic for a 12-week period beginning February 28, 2000, including the LMB assessment and transportation costs. Given the Hearing Officer’s determination that the District’s offer pursuant to the IEP dated January 10, 2000, provided him a FAPE for the last half of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’S placement at the LMB clinic does not constitute replacement services for services that the District failed to provide. Therefore, Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for replacement of educational services for the period from January 18, 2000, to mid-February 2000. (See Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. 359, 370.) However, Petitioner did prevail in part in that the District denied him a FAPE for the first half of the 1999-2000 school year. Where parents prevail in whole or in part, they “should receive more than an ‘empty victory,’” and “if ‘appropriate relief’ in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed ... the child’s right to a free appropriate public education ... would be less than complete.” (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Equalization (5th Cir. 1986) 79 F.2d 1153, 1161.) With this in mind, the Hearing Officer considers awarding relief in the form of compensatory education.
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.) In determining an appropriate award of compensatory education, the Hearing Officer must examine what services would be necessary to compensate for the District’s failure to provide appropriate services during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year.
STUDENT’S instruction at the LMB clinic was intensive. Angelica Benson testified that although STUDENT did not complete the recommended initial 16 to 20 week program, he did receive one-to-one instruction using the Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing (LiPS) and Seeing Stars programs for three hours a day, five days a week, for a period of 12 weeks. Both programs are used in conjunction with each other, helping the student to learn sight words, identify and remember patterns of letters, and do text reading. (Testimony of Angelica Benson.) Ms. Benson testified that STUDENT’S re-testing summary prepared after receiving LMB services indicated that he had made growth of four years, three months to the high-average range in his word attack skills (sounding out nonsense words). He also had made some improvement in his spelling, his LAC score had gone up from 57 to 76, which is at the mid-third grade level, and his score in oral directions on the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude-2 had risen from the 9th to 25th percentile. The LMB informal testing indicated that STUDENT had made four years’ growth in visual attention span for letters on the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude and that his symbol imagery score had gone up from 12 to 20 out of a total of 50. (Pet.’s Exh. DD.)
Additionally, PARENTS testified in considerable detail as to how STUDENT’S academic performance improved as a result of attending the LMB clinic. STUDENT’S parents observed significant improvement in his reading, writing, and his attitude towards his school work. Since attending the LMB clinic, STUDENT can read third-grade level-books, he has done a couple of book reports, he can now do word problems, he writes poetry and reads it in front of his class, and last semester at his new school, he received all “As” on his report card. (Testimony of PARENTS.) The Hearing Officer finds that the LMB program met STUDENT’s unique needs and provided him with educational benefit, as indicated by the significant improvement in his test scores and parent observations of improvement in his reading, writing, and attitude.
The LMB instruction served as compensation for the District’s failure to provide appropriate services during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year. For approximately four months, STUDENT was unproductive in school, his scores continued to decline, he spent more time off-task and not completing tasks, he was lethargic and “blanking out” at times in class, and by November 1999, he had met only one of his IEP objectives. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin & Sandra Pellow.) Additionally, according to MOTHER, the late start of RSP seriously disturbed STUDENT, causing him to segregate himself from the other students and come home from school crying. In January 2000, the District made an appropriate offer to place STUDENT in a more intensive SDC program, where he could get more individualized and small-group attention similar to that provided to STUDENT at the LMB clinic. However, STUDENT’s parents were left with the decision to either keep STUDENT in the SDC and risk further decline in his skills, or place him in the LMB program, which they believed would better meet his needs. Notwithstanding STUDENT’S parents’ dilemma, the District’s offer of FAPE for the last half of the 1999-2000 school year does not go without notice. District witnesses believed that STUDENT would have made sufficient progress had he remained in the SDC program.
The Hearing Officer finds that the most equitable remedy is to order the District to reimburse STUDENT’S parents for the 12 weeks of instruction at the LMB clinic, including the costs of the LMB assessment, as compensatory education for the District’s failure to address his needs during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year. (Nein v. Greater Clark County School Corp., et al., 95 F.Supp.2d 961, 985 (S.D. Indiana, 2000).) STUDENT’s parents could have requested compensatory education in the form of prospective services since the LMB clinic advised that STUDENT needed 16 to 20 weeks of LMB instruction in order to “stabilize” his areas of difficulty and he only received 12 weeks of the recommended program. (Testimony of Angelica Benson.) Given the PARENTS’ unilateral removal of STUDENT after the District offered a FAPE, the Hearing Officer finds that rather than award compensatory education of 8 additional weeks of LMB services, 12 weeks is the appropriate compensation for the first half of the 1999-2000 school year, including the cost of the LMB assessment. .
Within 30 days of receipt of proof of payment from STUDENT’S parents, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for their educational expenses at the LMB clinic for the 12-week period, beginning in February 2000, including the costs of the LMB assessment.
C. Costs of Transportation to LMB Clinic
STUDENT’s parents also request reimbursement for their cost of transporting STUDENT to the LMB clinic. Transportation is a related service that must be provided if necessary for a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) FATHER testified that STUDENT attended the LMB clinic five days a week, and that he transported STUDENT on the 45-60 minute drive. FATHER also testified that STUDENT participated in a car pool to and from the LMB clinic, which required FATHER to drive STUDENT and another student for 6 of the 12 weeks. Another person drove STUDENT and the other student for the other 6 weeks. There was no testimony, however, regarding the number of miles that STUDENT’S parents actually drove to the LMB clinic. Therefore, STUDENT’s parents shall submit proof of the number of miles and the number of days that they transported STUDENT to and from the LMB clinic. Within 30 days of receipt of such proof, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the proven miles during the 12 weeks at the standard rate that the District reimburses its employees for mileage.
ORDER
1. Within 30 calendar days of the District’s receipt of proof of the PARENT’s payment for LMB services, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for the proven costs of the 12 weeks of LMB services obtained, starting in February 2000, including the cost of the LMB assessment.
2. Within 30 calendar days of the District’s receipt of proof of the PARENT’s costs of transporting STUDENT to and from the LMB clinic during his 12 weeks of instruction in 2000, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for their proven costs of said transportation at the District’s standard rate for mileage reimbursement to District employees.
3. All of Petitioner’s remaining claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.
1. Did the District improperly fail to identify STUDENT as eligible for special education services at the November 16, 1998 IEP meeting?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1998-1999 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the vision therapy assessment performed in 1998 by Dr. Stephey’s office?
The District prevailed on this issue.
4. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the costs of vision therapy provided in 1998 and 1999 by Dr. Stephey and the costs of transportation to and from therapy sessions?
The District prevailed on this issue.
5. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Graphix program that was provided by Dr. Stephey?
The District prevailed on this issue.
6. Was Petitioner denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year?
Petitioner prevailed in part and the District prevailed in part.
7. If Petitioner was denied a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell (LMB) assessment and services he received from March through July 2000, and the costs of transportation to and from the LMB clinic?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: September 10, 2001 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number.
2. On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer clarified the issues for hearing. Petitioner’s September 18, 2000 issue statement includes claims that Respondent violated section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act (Section 504) and section 1983 of title 42 of the United States Code (Section 1983). The Hearing Officer ruled that any claims of alleged acts or omissions stated in Petitioner’s issue statement would be addressed in the context of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Hearing Office has no jurisdiction under its contract with the State of California or under any federal or State statute to hear claims brought under Section 504 or Section 1983.
3. During the hearing, the parties stipulated that the two pages of Petitioner’s Exhibit P were the only documents that STUDENT’s parents received at the December 6, 1999 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer notes, however, that Respondent’s Exhibit 8, listed in its exhibit packet as the December 6, 1999 IEP, consists of thirteen pages, noting STUDENT’s disability and eligibility category, present levels of performance, and goals and objectives. Petitioner contends that he did not receive the additional pages of the December 6, 1999 IEP contained in Respondent’s Exhibit 8 until it was provided to him in Respondent’s exhibit packet for this hearing. (Testimony of MOTHER and Christopher Russell.)
4. MOTHER testified that she worked one-on-one with STUDENT using the Lexia computer software program for individuals with dyslexia, after which FATHER would review words and sounds with STUDENT.
5. Ms. Haughtelin has worked for 13 years as an RSP instructor at Cullen and one year as an SDC teacher at another school. She has a master’s degree in special education and credentials as a “learning handicapped” specialist and resource specialist. (Testimony of Linda Haughtelin.)
6. The record does not reflect the exact date that the District’s vision screening was performed. However, given that the signed assessment plan providing for this screening was received by the District on September 10, 1998, and the results of the screening were later referenced in the psychologist’s November 16, 1998 report, the Hearing Officer can conclude that the vision screening was performed sometime between September 10, 1998, and November 16, 1998.
7. Ms. Pellow testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in Education, a master’s degree in reading and education arts, and a California reading and language arts credential.
8. Ms. Mar has taught in an SDC for the past 23 years. She has a master’s degree in special education and California credentials as a multiple subject and “learning handicapped” specialist.
