California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 1, 2003

Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1935-02 · Hearing Officer Terrence B. Ohler

San Ramon Valley Unified prevails as Hearing Officer finds its teacher adequately trained to deliver Lindamood-Bell reading instruction.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The Hearing Officer took official notice of a July 11, 2003 SEHO decision involving the student's sibling (SN02-01934/SN03-01034) as it related to Dr. Mied's training.

Summary

A parent, representing her daughter herself, filed against San Ramon Valley Unified School District. The 11-year-old student received special education for an auditory processing disorder and attended general education classes at Bollinger Canyon Elementary. A July 2001 mediation agreement required 45 minutes a day of one-to-one Lindamood-Bell reading instruction from Dr. Mary Lou Mied or another Lindamood-Bell-trained instructor. The only issue was whether Dr. Mied was properly trained from September 12, 2001, onward. The parent asked for 120 hours of private Lindamood-Bell instruction.

The Hearing Officer split the time into four periods. In September 2001, Dr. Mied had taken only one of the three main Lindamood-Bell workshops and admitted she was not fully trained, so services did not match the agreement. But the district then offered an extra 15 minutes a day at the Lindamood-Bell Danville center through December. That came to about 14.25 extra hours, which offset the roughly 9.75 hours missed. For October through December 2001, the offer of private clinic services met the district's obligation. By January 2002, Dr. Mied had finished workshops in all three programs. No witness identified any missing training, including the Lindamood-Bell clinic director. Mixed test scores and grades did not show that her teaching caused poor progress. Her reaction to the parent's criticism did not make her unqualified. The same finding applied to 2002-2003. The district prevailed, and relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated mediation agreements as the agreed part of an IEP when judging a "trained instructor" requirement. It also shows that extra services already offered could offset a short gap. A parent who challenged a teacher's training had to show what training was missing and that the teaching caused the lack of progress.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1. From September 12, 2001, through the present, was Dr. Mary Lou Mied appropriately trained to implement Student's Lindamood-Bell reading services?

    Dr. Mied was not trained for September 12-30, 2001, but the district's offer of an extra 15 minutes a day of private Lindamood-Bell instruction offset the missed time. Private clinic services met the obligation for October-December 2001. Dr. Mied was appropriately trained from January 2002 through the 2002-2003 school year. Relief was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's request for relief (120 hours of private Lindamood-Bell instruction) was denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Houston Independent School Dist. v. Bobby R.; Lucht v. Molalla River School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Dr. Mary Lou Mied, special education teacher; Lindamood-Bell instructor, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Charlene David, clinical director, Lindamood-Bell Danville Center; witness for Student, Lindamood-Bell
  • Lisa Nowell, director (former director) of Lindamood-Bell Danville Center, Lindamood-Bell
  • Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special programs, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Liz Block, coordinator of special programs, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Ms. Michelotti, fourth grade general education teacher, Bollinger Canyon Elementary School
  • Ms. Donnelly, resource specialist, Bollinger Canyon Elementary School
  • Lindamood-Bell Danville Center, private reading instruction provider, Lindamood-Bell

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Terrence Ohler, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Danville, California, on June 19, 20, 24, and 25.

STUDENT (Petitioner) was represented by her mother, MOTHER. Respondent San Ramon Valley Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by attorney Kimberly Schulist.

The following witnesses were called to testify: Charlene David, clinical director of Lindamood-Bell’s Danville Center, Dr. Mary Lou Mied, special education teacher, MOTHER, Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special programs for the District, and Liz Block, coordinator of special programs for the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of written closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE(Footnote 1)

From September 12, 2001, through the present, was Dr. Mary Lou Mied appropriately trained to implement STUDENT’s Lindamood-Bell reading services?

PROCEDURAL MATTER

After the record was closed, the Hearing Office received a request for judicial notice from the District on July 16, 2003, which requested notice of a Hearing Office decision rendered on July 11, 2003, in the case of Student vs. San Ramon Valley Unified School District, case number SN02-01934/SN03-01034. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s response on July 17, 2003. This Hearing Officer takes notice of that decision as it relates to the training of Dr. Mied.(Footnote 2)

BACKGROUND FACTS

Petitioner is an eleven-year-old student who is receiving special education because of an auditory processing disorder. Her fourth and fifth grade years are at issue, which were the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years. STUDENT attended the District’s Bollinger Canyon Elementary School in general education classrooms. STUDENT was first deemed eligible for services in June of 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 24 and 25.) The comments page from STUDENT’s IEP meeting of June 9, 2000, indicates that STUDENT was functioning in the low average range in the classroom and that the IEP team was therefore making the decision to place STUDENT in special education for assistance. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.) Even though STUDENT received services in both mathematics and language arts, only language arts instruction is at issue here. STUDENT struggled with spelling, reading, and writing skills, and the District augmented STUDENT’s general education classroom with one-to-one assistance. At the September 19, 2000, IEP meeting, District personnel indicated that Lindamood-Bell instruction would be used as part of “STUDENT’s reading and language arts assistance.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 26-2.)(Footnote 3)

Shortly after the parties agreed that Lindamood-Bell instruction would be provided to STUDENT, MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE), which is identified as CDE compliance investigation case number S-0686-00/01. In findings of fact dated April 6, 2001, the CDE found that the District had failed to provide Lindamood-Bell services as provided for in the September 19, 2000, IEP document. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 52.) (Footnote 4) The CDE ordered the IEP team to determine, among other things, how missed Lindamood-Bell services should be made up. After MOTHER filed a due process hearing request in Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) case number SN 1275-01, the parties settled their dispute in mediation. (Footnote 5) The final mediation agreement of July 12, 2001, provided, in part, that the agreement settled all disputes through the end of the 2000-2001 school year. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 56.)

The July 12, 2001, mediation agreement also contains a prospective provision pertaining to the 2001-2002 school year. Paragraph two states, “[d]uring the 2001-2002 school year, the parties agree that the student will receive 1:1 service from Mary Lou Meade (sic.) or another instructor who has been trained by Lindamood-Bell.” The paragraph also provides that STUDENT will receive the services five times per week for 45 minutes per session. Paragraph four of the mediation agreement indicates that an IEP meeting would be held during September 2001 to conform the IEP to the terms of the mediation agreement. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 56.)

Dr. Mied met with MOTHER and STUDENT at MOTHER’s home on or about September 12, 2001. According to MOTHER, Dr. Mied indicated she was not yet fully trained in the Lindamood-Bell program. As a result of this conversation, MOTHER filed another compliance complaint with the CDE, which is compliance investigation case number S-0239-01/02, by a letter dated September 25, 2001. She alleged that the District failed to provide a Lindamood-Bell trained instructor for the 2001-2002 school year as required by the July 12, 2001, mediation agreement. (District’s Exhibit 107-1 through 3.)

Two days after MOTHER’s letter to the CDE, an IEP meeting was convened on September 27, 2001. At this meeting, MOTHER informed the IEP team of her compliance complaint, and she refused to consent to the IEP. The IEP indicates that the District would provide private Lindamood-Bell services at the Danville center for five hours per week from October 1, 2001, through December 21, 2001. In addition, from January 2, 2002, through the end of the school year, the IEP indicates that the District was offering STUDENT one-to-one instruction from a District trained person for forty-five minutes per day, five days per week. (District’s Exhibit 56-4.)

On November 16, 2001, the CDE found that the District was out of compliance with the terms specified in the July 12, 2001, mediation agreement. However, it refused to award any corrective action because MOTHER refused the District’s offer to pay for private Lindamood-Bell instruction until the District had a fully trained teacher. (District’s Exhibit 107-2.) After the CDE’s decision, MOTHER decided to accept the District’s offer stated in the September 27, 2001, IEP, and the District paid for STUDENT to receive private Lindamood-Bell services from December 3, 2001, through January 4, 2002, at the Danville center. Thereafter, Dr. Mied began providing STUDENT with Lindamood-Bell instruction from January 23, 2002.

On January 22, 2002, another IEP team meeting was held, but MOTHER declined to consent to the resulting IEP. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 63.) MOTHER presented her concerns to the IEP team in a five-page document. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 46.) Prior to the next scheduled IEP meeting on February 14, 2002, MOTHER planned to meet with selected District personnel to discuss goals and objectives, but the interim meeting never occurred. The February 14, 2002, IEP meeting convened, but MOTHER did not consent to the IEP because of various concerns. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 64.) For example, MOTHER believed that the goals and objectives presented by Dr. Mied (see Petitioner’s Exhibit 64A) were vague. In addition, MOTHER noted the same concerns she previously presented (see Petitioner’s Exhibit 46) in connection with the January 22, 2002, IEP, which she felt had still not been adequately addressed. (Footnote 6) Nevertheless, Dr. Mied agreed to meet with MOTHER and Ms. Lisa Nowell, the director of the Lindamood-Bell’s Danville center, to discuss how to further develop STUDENT’s goals and objectives.

On February 19, 2002, MOTHER and Dr. Mied met Ms. Nowell at Lindamood-Belle’s Danville center, together with Ms. Liz Block, coordinator of special programs for the District, and Ms. Charlene David, clinical director of Lindamood-Bell’s Danville Center. Although witnesses have varying accounts of what occurred at this meeting, the parties agree that their intent was to further develop STUDENT’s goals around the Lindamood-Bell program. Since the time Dr. Mied had first begun providing Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT, MOTHER indicated that this meeting marks the time when she first believed that Dr. Mied was unqualified to deliver the Lindamood-Bell programs to STUDENT. This meeting will be discussed in greater detail below.

On March 8, 2002, MOTHER met with STUDENT’s fourth grade teacher, Ms. Michelotti, and the resource specialist who was working with STUDENT, Ms. Donnelly. MOTHER informed them that she thought Dr. Mied was not properly trained to deliver Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. Shortly thereafter, Dr. Mied learned of MOTHER’s statement. Dr. Mied felt upset and betrayed. Before that time, Dr. Mied wanted MOTHER’s input and wanted to please MOTHER. Now, Dr. Mied felt that MOTHER had not been “up front” with her, and she wanted a third party present at any time MOTHER came to observe Dr. Mied’s instruction with STUDENT. Dr. Mied testified that she told STUDENT about her mother’s negative comment, although she could not remember exactly what she said to STUDENT. Dr. Mied testified that her feelings about MOTHER did not impact on how she provided services to STUDENT.

In April of 2002, MOTHER filed another compliance complaint with the CDE, which was compliance investigation case number S-0695-01/02. She alleged that Dr. Mied was not adequately trained to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction. On May 2, 2002, the CDE found that Dr. Mied was properly trained because she had received Lindamood-Bell instruction and was properly credentialed. (Footnote 7) (Petitioner’s Exhibit 67.)

After the compliance complaint was filed but before the CDE’s findings were made, Dr. Mied presented her revised goals and objectives by letter memorandum to MOTHER and her husband dated April 15, 2002. (District’s Exhibit 69-1.) These revised goals and objectives were developed after the meeting at Lindamood-Bell on February 19, 2002, and attempted to incorporate both District goals and Lindamood-Bell goals. (District’s Exhibit 69-1, 69-4 through 6.) Ms. Block assisted Dr. Mied in writing the goals and objectives. After receiving the revised goals and objectives, MOTHER sent an e-mail to the District on April 16, 2002, rejecting them. Although MOTHER could not remember whether she provided the District any other written feedback on why the goals were unacceptable, both Dr. Mied and Ms. Block testified they did not receive other communication from MOTHER to explain her concerns. Throughout the time Dr. Mied worked with STUDENT, MOTHER never consented to the District’s goals and objectives for STUDENT. Nevertheless, Dr. Mied provided Lindamood-Bell spelling and reading instruction to STUDENT from January 23, 2002, through June 13, 2002, meeting with her for forty-five minutes per school day.

For the 2002-2003 school year, Dr. Mied did not provide any instruction to STUDENT. Furthermore, STUDENT did not otherwise receive Lindamood-Bell reading instruction. On August 23, 2002, the Hearing Office received MOTHER’s hearing request in this matter. On September 17, 2002, the parties reached an interim agreement in mediation. (District’s Exhibit 77.) The first provision indicates that MOTHER, the mediator, and the “Reading Instructor” will meet to discuss STUDENT’s reading program. The third provision states:

The parties will review STUDENT’s schedule to agree upon a time during the school day that STUDENT will receive individualized reading instruction and written language instruction. STUDENT will receive 45 minutes per day, 5 days per week of individualized reading + written language instruction. District will explore the possibility of increasing this instruction to one hour per day.

Although the parties now dispute whether the provision implicitly referred to Lindamood-Bell instruction for the 2002-2003 school year, the interim agreement is the last agreed upon and implemented statement of terms describing what reading related services the District would provide STUDENT. STUDENT did receive individualized reading instruction from someone other than Dr. Mied, but it was not Lindamood-Bell instruction. On March 13, 2003, MOTHER asked to place the matter back on the Hearing Office’s calendar. Although two IEP meetings were held after this interim agreement, MOTHER did not consent to any of the terms discussed at either of those meetings. (Footnote 8) In an attempt to resolve this matter, the District offered a compromise of fifty hours of private Lindamood-Bell reading instruction in a letter dated June 5, 2003 (see District’s Exhibit 106), but MOTHER rejected the offer.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

From September 12, 2001, through the present, was Dr. Mary Lou Mied appropriately trained to implement STUDENT’s Lindamood-Bell reading services?

From September 12, 2001, to date, Petitioner asserts that Dr. Mied was not appropriately trained or qualified to provide Lindamood-Bell reading instruction to STUDENT. Petitioner requests 120 hours of private Lindamood-Bell reading related instruction as compensatory education. In contrast, the District asserts that Dr. Mied was appropriately trained and qualified at all relevant times. For the 2001-2002 school year, the District contends Dr. Mied was properly trained to provide services from the beginning of the school year. In addition, the District asserts that at STUDENT’s September 27, 2001, IEP meeting, it offered to pay for private Lindamood-Bell instruction through December and to provide a District-trained person through the end of the school year. Therefore, the District argues that it is not responsible for any compensatory education for the time period from October 1, 2001, through January 4, 2002, when private Lindamood-Bell services had been offered by the District.

For the 2002-2003 school year, the District asserts that it did not provide, offer, or agree to any Lindamood-Bell services for STUDENT, at least for any period of time after the September 17, 2002, interim mediation agreement. Accordingly, the District contends that the only issue for resolution -- Dr. Mied’s training and qualifications to implement Lindamood-Bell instruction -- has no relevance during this time period and should not be considered by the Hearing Officer. As to remedy, the District argues that assuming there were periods of time when Dr. Mied was not properly trained, the educational loss to STUDENT was either inconsequential or, at the most, the District’s offer of fifty hours of private Lindamood-Bell reading instruction was sufficient.

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term FAPE means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). Pursuant to the IDEA and the decision of the Supreme Court in the matter Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et.al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176 (hereafter, Rowley), an appropriate educational program must (1) be designed to meet the student's unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, and (3) conform with the IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, 458 U.S., at 188-189.

For purposes of deciding the issue in this case, the parties do not dispute what constitutes STUDENT’s needs or any aspect of STUDENT’s education other than the training of Dr. Mied. For the 2001-2002 school year, the parties’ mediation agreement dated July 12, 2001, indicates that Dr. Mied or another trained instructor will provide Lindamood-Bell instruction every school day for 45 minutes per session. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 56.) For the 2002-2003 school year, the parties agree that the District offered Dr. Mied to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. However, the District contends this offer was withdrawn as of the parties’ interim mediation agreement dated September 17, 2002. (District’s Exhibit 77.) The agreement indicates that STUDENT will receive “individualized reading + written language instruction” in the same amount specified in the prior mediation agreement. Although the interim mediation agreement does not specifically state either that Lindamood-Bell instruction will be provided or that Dr. Mied will provide the instruction, Petitioner contends that the right to the continuation of Lindamood-Bell instruction is implicit in the agreement and that Dr. Mied’s instruction was offered by the District. Accordingly, this Decision will only address the last factor as identified by the Supreme Court in Rowley, whether or not the Lindamood-Bell reading instruction offered by the District conformed to STUDENT’s IEP. In this instance, the agreed portion of STUDENT’s IEP consists of the two mediation agreements just described.

The discussion of Dr. Mied’s training will be divided into four time periods because of different considerations that apply to each. They are September 2001, October through December 2001, January through June 2002, and the 2002-2003 school year.

I. September 2001:

As to her general education and background, Dr. Mied testified that she obtained a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a master’s degree in education with a concentration in special education, and a second master’s degree in educational administration. She also obtained a doctorate in clinical psychology in 2002. (District’s Exhibit 94.) She has taught special education students in various settings for the past twenty-eight years. Since 1980, she has been employed by the District. She possesses a standard teaching credential (kindergarten through ninth grade, valid for life) and a specialist credential in learning and severely handicapped (preschool through adult, valid for life).

With regard to Lindamood-Bell training in particular, Ms. David, clinical director of Lindamood-Bell’s Danville Center, explained that there are three main language arts programs at Lindamood-Bell: “Lindamood Phoneme-Sequencing Programming” (LIPS), “Seeing Stars,” and “Visualizing and Verbalizing” (VV). She indicated that the LIPS program focuses on building phonemic awareness. It is designed to help a student understand and coordinate sounds with symbols. The Seeing Stars program focuses on building a student’s visual memory, which assists in improving spelling and reading fluency. The VV program focuses on building comprehension through picturing information. Ms. David also testified that all three programs are helpful to a student learning to write. Similarly, Dr. Mied summarized that LIPS relates to teaching phonics, Seeing Stars relates to teaching spelling, and VV relates to teaching comprehension.

As of September 12, 2002, Dr. Mied had only attended one series of workshops pertaining to Lindamood-Bell. On August 21-22, 2000, she took the LIPS workshops. These were daylong workshops presented by Lindamood-Bell personnel. MOTHER testified that Dr. Mied had indicated in their meeting on September 12, 2001, that she was not fully trained in Lindamood-Bell. This testimony was not contradicted. In fact, Dr. Mied testified that she believed she needed to complete all three series of workshops prior to giving instruction in Lindamood-Bell. The District apparently indicated during a compliance investigation that Dr. Mied was not sufficiently trained, even though the District is now arguing the opposite. (Footnote 9) Ms. Heilbronner, assistant director of special programs for the District, testified regarding what training she understands is sufficient, but her testimony is ambiguous with respect to whether a teacher trained in one particular program of Lindamood-Bell is qualified to teach that program.(Footnote 10)

From the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mied was not appropriately trained to teach any of the Lindamood-Bell programs as of September 12, 2001. Dr. Mied admitted that she was not appropriately trained, and MOTHER could not be expected to accept services from a teacher who, herself, claimed inadequate training. Furthermore, the District’s conduct evidences its belief that Dr. Mied was not adequately trained when it offered STUDENT private Lindamood-Bell instruction on September 27, 2001, particularly when viewed in light of the District’s statement to the CDE described above. (District’s Exhibit 56-4.) Therefore, from September 12, 2001, through September 30, 2001, the District’s program did not conform with STUDENT’s IEP.

If a district fails to provide a FAPE, then a child is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the Individuals with Disability Education Act (IDEA). School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 374 (hereafter Burlington). Based on the principle set forth in Burlington, federal courts have held that compensatory education is a form of equitable relief which may be granted for the denial of appropriate special education services to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, for example, Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist. (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496-1497. Nevertheless, there is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation for time missed. Id., at 1497.

From September 12, 2001, through September 30, 2001, the District did not offer private Lindamood-Bell instruction. However, the September 27, 2001, IEP (see District’s Exhibit 56-4) offered STUDENT an extra fifteen minutes per day of Lindamood-Bell instruction for the period of time from October 1, 2001, through December 21, 2001, as compared to the prior mediation agreement (see Petitioner Exhibit 56). The IEP offers one hour of one-on-one instruction per day, whereas the mediation agreement only offers forty-five minutes per day. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the extra time offered by the District in the IEP sufficiently offsets the missed instructional time. (Footnote 11)

II. October 2001 through December 2001:

Although Dr. Mied did not complete the Lindamood-Bell workshops for LIPS, Seeing Stars, and VV until December 5, 2001, the analysis of the October-through-December period is different from the previous time period because of the District’s offer of private Lindamood-Bell services. Essentially, the District’s IEP offer of September 27, 2001, provided for the same Lindamood-Bell services that were agreed to in the July 12, 2001, mediation. The offer states,

The district agrees to provide 1-1 instruction 5 hours per week at Lindamood Bell Clinic in Danville from 10/1/01 to 12/21/01. (Paragraph.) During December, a meeting will be held to discuss transition to district trained staff. From 1/2/02 until the end of the school year, student will receive 1-1 instruction from a district trained person 45 minutes per day 5 days per week.

(District’s Exhibit 56-4.) The mediation agreement states, in pertinent part, “the parties agree that the student will receive 1:1 service from Mary Lou Meade (sic.) or another instructor who has been trained by Lindamood-Bell,” and that STUDENT would receive these services “five times per week for 45 minutes per session.” (Petitioner’s Exhibit 56.) Although MOTHER’s testimony varied as to why she did not consent to the September 27, 2001, IEP, she acknowledged on cross-examination that she does not know why she did not consent to it. (Footnote 12) This IEP comports with the parties’ July 12, 2001, mediation agreement as to Lindamood-Bell services. In addition, the parties stipulated that the District paid for STUDENT to receive private Lindamood-Bell instruction from December 3, 2001, through January 4, 2002. Therefore, from October 1, 2001, until Dr. Mied began rendering services in January 2002, the District met its obligation under the mediation agreement to provide an appropriately trained Lindamood-Bell instructor, regardless of whether Dr. Mied was appropriately trained during that time.

III. January 2002 through June 2002:

Dr. Mied testified that she provided Lindamood-Bell spelling and reading instruction to STUDENT from January 23, 2002, through June 13, 2002, meeting forty-five minutes per school day. Prior to beginning instruction, Dr. Mied observed STUDENT receiving Lindamood-Bell instruction at the Danville center on or about December 21, 2001, pursuant to MOTHER’s request. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 79A-81, which is Dr. Mied’s notes of observation.) MOTHER testified that she requested some testing of STUDENT in January. (Footnote 13) An IEP meeting occurred on January 22, 2002, to discuss, among other things, scheduling of the Lindamood-Bell instruction, but MOTHER did not consent to the IEP document. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 63.) Nevertheless, Dr. Mied’s instruction began the following day and was delivered in accordance with the parties’ July 12, 2001, mediation agreement. By the time she began instructing STUDENT, Dr. Mied had completed all three series of Lindamood-Bell workshops prior to instructing STUDENT. In addition to her prior LIPS training, Dr. Mied attended four other, daylong workshops presented by Lindamood-Bell personnel. On November 8-9, 2001, she took the “Seeing Stars” workshops, and on December 4-5, 2001, she took the “Visualizing and Verbalizing” (VV) workshops. (Petitioner’s Exhibits 68 and 69.)

Ms. David was the only witness from Lindamood-Bell to testify. Ms. David testified on direct that she was qualified to assess whether someone is adequately trained to implement Lindamood-Bell instruction. The Hearing Officer asked Ms. David if she knew whether Dr. Mied was or was not appropriately trained before she rendered services to STUDENT. Ms. David responded, “I’m unable to answer that question right now.” This testimony was particularly significant given that Ms. David, as an employee of Lindamood-Bell for over three years, was in the best position of any of the witnesses to know what training Dr. Mied should have had in order to be qualified to render Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. (Footnote 14) Petitioner’s own witness, who presumably had more knowledge of the Lindamood-Bell programs than any of the witnesses, was unable to support Petitioner’s contention that Dr. Mied was inadequately trained. Furthermore, even though MOTHER argued that there were at least four different levels of Lindamood-Bell training, Ms. David contradicted this argument and rejected the notion of different levels of training. While she indicated there are different types of training, she did not believe that Lindamood-Bell characterizes its training by level.

MOTHER stated that she felt the workshops Dr. Mied attended must have been insufficient because STUDENT had not made sufficient progress. As to MOTHER’s ability to comment on the sufficiency of Dr. Mied’s training, MOTHER admitted on cross-examination that she had no training in Lindamood-Bell. By the end of her testimony, MOTHER demonstrated that she, herself, was unclear about what training Dr. Mied was missing. The Hearing Officer asked her what specific qualifications Dr. Mied lacked in order to teach Lindamood-Bell to STUDENT. MOTHER replied, “I don’t think I can answer that honestly.” She again reiterated her lack of training in Lindamood-Bell by stating that she had never attended a Lindamood-Bell workshop. In sum, Petitioner provided no evidence on what specific Lindamood-Bell training Dr. Mied was missing.

Furthermore, Dr. Mied testified that her understanding was that she was properly trained to deliver the Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. Dr. Mied testified that she understood that she was qualified to teach Lindamood-Bell after completing the LIPS, Seeing Stars, and VV workshops she took. She also stated that no one had ever indicated that she needed more training than what she had received in order to teach Lindamood-Bell.

As to Dr. Mied’s testimony as a whole, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Mied demonstrated a solid grasp of the Lindamood-Bell reading programs. Dr. Mied testified for over one day, but no material gaps in her understanding of the LIPS, Seeing Stars, or VV programs were demonstrated. Dr. Mied articulately explained how she delivered Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. The evidence did not show that Dr. Mied improperly delivered instruction to STUDENT.

In terms of Lindamood-Bell workshops or other coursework, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Mied was appropriately trained to render Lindamood-Bell instruction during this period of time. As stated above, no witness was able to identify any workshops or other classroom training that Dr. Mied was missing prior to beginning instruction in January 2002. Ms. David identified the LIPS, Seeing Stars, and VV programs as the “three main programs” when asked on direct-examination to generally explain the Lindamood-Bell programs, and Dr. Mied took two-day workshops in each. Although MOTHER alluded to various levels of training, no evidence was admitted to demonstrate Dr. Mied needed to attain a certain numerical level of training. In addition, the only Lindamood-Bell witness to testify, Ms. David, dismissed the entire notion that there were different numerical levels of Lindamood-Bell training.

Nevertheless, Petitioner’s contentions are not limited to an attack on the specific workshops or other coursework Dr. Mied completed. She also contends that other circumstances bear on the issue of whether Dr. Mied was properly trained to render services. In other words, Petitioner contends that Dr. Mied’s delivery of services to STUDENT demonstrated that she was in some manner inadequately trained or qualified to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. Petitioner’s other contentions fell primarily into three areas: Dr. Mied’s alleged failure to integrate the VV program into her teaching, Dr. Mied’s alleged responsibility for STUDENT’s stagnating or declining test scores, and Dr. Mied’s handling of MOTHER’s criticism after the February 19, 2002, meeting at Lindamood-Bell. Each of these contentions will be addressed in turn.

A. Dr. Mied’s alleged failure to integrate the Visualizing and Verbalizing (VV) program into her teaching:

Petitioner contends that Dr. Mied did not instruct STUDENT properly because she did not integrate the VV program into her teaching of the other two programs, LIPS and Seeing Stars. The District disagrees with this contention. At first, Dr. Mied indicated that she had not used the VV program with STUDENT, but she later testified that she used the VV program toward the end of her time with STUDENT, although she did not identify a date when such instruction began. She began using the VV method of instruction to help improve STUDENT’s writing skills, which did not occur until after she had exclusively used the LIPS and Seeing Stars methods of instruction to improve STUDENT’s spelling and reading skills. She testified that no one from Lindamood-Bell had informed her that it was necessary to integrate VV with the other two programs.

Petitioner relies heavily upon a Lindamood-Bell “Position Paper,” which was revised October 9, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhibit 70.) The document states that “[w]hile Lindamood-Bell programs may be used separately, to achieve a balanced and global approach to literacy development at least three programs need to be integrated….” (Italics in original.) The three programs it lists are LIPS, Seeing Stars, and VV. The document continues, “[t]he integration of our programs requires training in each program and an understanding of how they produce the gestalt of sensory-cognitive processing for complete reading and spelling competency.” Significantly, the document does not state that any of the three programs cannot be taught separately. Instead, it indicates that programs “may be used separately.” (Footnote 15)

Moreover, Petitioner’s contention is belied by Ms. David’s testimony that during the time STUDENT was receiving instruction at Lindamood-Bell, only the LIPS and Seeing Stars programs were utilized, never the VV program. Thus, even the Lindamood-Bell instructors, themselves, do not necessarily integrate all three programs. No persuasive evidence was presented that all three programs must be taught together in order for Lindamood-Bell to be properly delivered. The Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Mied was not rendered unqualified to teach Lindamood-Bell by the fact that she did not necessarily integrate the VV program with the other programs when delivering instruction to STUDENT.

B. Dr. Mied’s alleged responsibility for STUDENT’s stagnating or declining test scores:

Petitioner alleges that STUDENT’s test scores, report cards, and work samples demonstrate that Dr. Mied was unqualified to deliver Lindamood-Bell instruction to STUDENT. The District disagrees with these contentions. At the outset, it is appropriate to recognize that the law does not require the responsible educational agency to guarantee totally successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). In addition, STUDENT’s performance must be judged against herself, not her peers. Houston Independent School Dist. v. Bobby R., 200 F.3d 341, 349 (5th Cir. 2000). For example, STUDENT may have made individual progress for her while still remaining below grade level.

The data presented does not persuasively demonstrate that STUDENT’s performance stagnated or declined during Dr. Mied’s span of instruction. The only witness who explained standardized test results was Ms. David. Her testimony was confined to interpreting tests given by Lindamood-Bell. (District’s Exhibits 75 and 103.) However, the test dates she compared are not closely related in time to when Dr. Mied was providing services to STUDENT. Although there was a test date near the beginning of Dr. Mied’s services, there is no test date corresponding to the end of Dr. Mied’s services. In other words, Exhibit 75 contains results from testing performed on February 5, 2002, which is close to the time Dr. Mied began providing services on January 23, 2002. (Footnote 16) However, Exhibit 103 contains results from testing performed on April 17, 2003, which is a full ten months after Dr. Mied finished providing services to STUDENT on June 13, 2002. It is difficult to know how testing performed ten months after Dr. Mied performed services can be used to demonstrate that Dr. Mied’s instruction was deficient.

The Gates-MacGinitie Reading Tests were briefly mentioned by MOTHER. However, in discussing the Gates-MacGinitie Reading Tests given to STUDENT on May 21, 2002, MOTHER demonstrated that she did not have sufficient knowledge of the tests to interpret the results. (District’s Exhibit 70.) For example, she did not know what the initials “PR” meant. She also could not identify whether the numbers reflected in the percentile column fell within the average range for the test. The data itself does not demonstrate poor relative performance by STUDENT. The exhibits contain Gates-MacGinitie Reading Tests results from September 12, 2001 (District’s Exhibit 53), May 21, 2002 (District’s Exhibit 70), September 10, 2002 (Petitioner’s Exhibit 13.57(Footnote 17) ). While the comprehension component of the test results shows a decline in the grade equivalent score (i.e., 4.0, 3.7, and 3.8, respectively), the vocabulary component shows an increase in the grade equivalent score (i.e., 3.7, 4.1, and 4.5, respectively). In addition, the total score shows an overall increase in the grade equivalent score (i.e., 3.8, 3.9, and 4.1, respectively). Yet, as discussed more fully below, Petitioner still would have needed to establish that Dr. Mied was the cause of STUDENT’s poor performance, even if these results unequivocally demonstrated poor performance by STUDENT, which they do not.

Separate and apart from standardized test scores, Dr. Mied testified that STUDENT made progress during her five months of instruction. STUDENT improved at reading individual words at grade level and completed the fourth grade vocabulary words. She improved at spelling three syllable words. She mastered one, two, and three syllable words on the Visual Spelling Chart, a learning system Dr. Mied explained. STUDENT made progress at phonics generally, and Dr. Mied indicated STUDENT had a good foundation in phonics. Dr. Mied’s progress report dated June 2002 further identifies work STUDENT completed, as well as areas of STUDENT’s strengths and weaknesses. (District Exhibit 90.) No testimony was offered by other witnesses to demonstrate that STUDENT had not completed the specific assignments that Dr. Mied indicated she had. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Mied’s testimony persuasive.

Dr. Mied also offered an explanation for why a student may in fact be making progress even though the student’s grades and general class work may be poor. She testified that a student who is behind grade level may perform poorly because the classroom work is beyond the student’s current ability. The Hearing Officer finds this explanation logical and concludes that STUDENT’s poor grades and particular items of poor classroom work do not necessarily have a direct bearing on whether Dr. Mied gave competent Lindamood-Bell instruction. For example, Dr. Mied may have provided the best Lindamood-Bell instruction possible, but STUDENT may still have fallen short in her classroom work because she had not yet attained grade level proficiency.

As with the standardized test scores, STUDENT’s grades do not necessarily demonstrate STUDENT’s lack of relative performance. In comparing the second and third trimesters of her fourth grade report card, the only change in the reading portion of her report card was in one of five categories, “using various strategies to determine word meaning.” (District’s Exhibit 71.) On a 1 through 4 grading scale with 1 being the worst and 4 being the best, this category declined from a 2- to a 1. However, given that four of five categories remained the same, it is difficult to determine from the raw numbers that STUDENT was not learning. It is equally as plausible that she was continuing to learn at the same rate. For her fifth grade year, STUDENT’s first trimester grades are actually all better in reading than the last semester of her fourth grade year. (District’s Exhibit 108.) Of course, one cannot know whether this is because of actual improvement or because the two teachers simply had different grading standards. Neither STUDENT’s fourth grade teacher or fifth grade teacher testified. There is simply no way to determine from the report cards whether STUDENT’s performance stagnated or decreased.

Even if the record had clearly shown that STUDENT performed poorly during the time Dr. Mied provided instruction, Petitioner still would have needed to demonstrate how Dr. Mied was the cause of that poor performance, which she has not. Petitioner’s assertions presuppose that Dr. Mied is the cause of STUDENT’s poor scores, etc. However, the issue of whom or what is to blame is far from clear. Dr. Mied only provided forty-five minutes of instruction per day from January 23, 2002, through June 13, 2002, which is less than five months. During that time, STUDENT also received related instruction from her fourth grade teacher, Ms. Michelotti, and from a resource specialist, Ms. Donnelly. The Hearing Officer does not mean to imply that either Ms. Michelotti or Ms. Donnelly provided inadequate instruction. The point is that even if there were data showing poor performance during the specific time frame that Dr. Mied provided instruction, no evidence was presented to establish that Dr. Mied, as opposed to other instructors, was the cause of the poor performance. In addition, there may be other reasons for poor performance besides the quality of instruction STUDENT received. For example, MOTHER testified that STUDENT “sometimes” does her homework. STUDENT consistently received low marks in the area of “completes and returns homework” from both her fourth grade and fifth grade teachers. (District’s Exhibits 71-2 and 108-2.) Clearly, the failure to complete homework assignments could have a dramatic impact on both STUDENT’s work assignment and, ultimately, her grades.

In summary, Petitioner has not demonstrated that STUDENT’s decline, if any, was caused by Dr. Mied’s instruction.

C. Dr. Mied’s handling of MOTHER’s criticism after the February 19, 2002, meeting at Lindamood-Bell:

Petitioner testified that Dr. Mied failed to demonstrate proficiency in Lindamood-Bell instruction at a meeting on February 19, 2002, and that Dr. Mied willfully failed to communicate with MOTHER after learning of MOTHER’s criticism. Petitioner implies that Dr. Mied’s handling of the criticism may have adversely affected STUDENT’s academic progress. The District disputes these contentions.

On February 19, 2002, a meeting occurred at Lindamood-Bell’s Danville center that was attended by MOTHER, Dr. Mied, Ms. David, Ms. Nowell, the former director of the Danville center, and Ms. Liz Block, coordinator of special programs for the District. After listening to Dr. Mied’s interaction with Lindamood-Bell personnel, MOTHER believed Dr. Mied was unqualified to deliver the Lindamood-Bell programs to STUDENT. MOTHER felt that Dr. Mied was not able to adequately answer questions or describe the Lindamood-Bell programs at the meeting. MOTHER testified that after Dr. Mied made a statement that she was “sick and tired” of a particular Lindamood-Bell diagram, Ms. Block abruptly ended the meeting by stating, “we’re done.” MOTHER felt that the meeting had been prematurely adjourned by, what she perceived to be, Dr. Mied’s frustrated outburst. In contrast, Ms. Block testified that she did not recall the meeting ending in a negative way but in an “amicable, natural way.” She believed the participants had a cordial and informative discussion and that the meeting ended simply because everything had been covered. Ms. Block testified that she and Lindamood-Bell personnel agreed that any questions could be handled by a telephone call. She testified that she would have remembered if the meeting proceeded negatively because she would be careful, as a District representative, not to have a negative meeting. No testimony was elicited from Dr. Mied or Ms. David regarding either Dr. Mied’s alleged “sick and tired” comment, their characterization of whether the meeting was productive, or their respective impressions of how the meeting ended. The only other person at the meeting, Ms. Nowell, was never called to testify. Ms. Nowell wrote a letter dated the day after the meeting, but it sheds no light on these issues. (District’s Exhibit 96.)

Regardless of what actually transpired at that meeting, MOTHER later informed STUDENT’s fourth grade teacher, Ms. Michelotti, and the resource specialist who was working with STUDENT, Ms. Donnelly, on March 8, 2002, that she did not believe Dr. Mied was properly trained to implement Lindamood-Bell instruction. After Dr. Mied learned of MOTHER’s statement, Dr. Mied testified that she felt upset and betrayed. She wanted a third party present anytime MOTHER was observing Dr. Mied’s instruction with STUDENT. Dr. Mied told STUDENT about her mother’s negative comment, although she could not remember exactly what she said. Dr. Mied testified that her feelings about MOTHER did not impact on how she provided services to STUDENT.

MOTHER testified that after Dr. Mied learned of her criticism, Dr. Mied’s demeanor changed. For example, MOTHER stated that Dr. Mied would walk by her without saying “hello.” MOTHER perceived that Dr. Mied was willfully failing to communicate with MOTHER about STUDENT and otherwise ignoring her. MOTHER stated that at some point she apologized to Dr. Mied for her handling of the situation in that MOTHER felt she should have addressed Dr. Mied directly instead of addressing the matter with others. Despite her apology, MOTHER does not believe her relationship with Dr. Mied ever improved after Dr. Mied learned of the criticism.

Even though Dr. Mied’s own testimony reflects that she was upset with MOTHER after learning of the criticism, the evidence does not reflect that Dr. Mied failed to make necessary communications with MOTHER or that she otherwise failed to properly instruct STUDENT. The evidence reflects that Dr. Mied probably learned of MOTHER’s criticism shortly after March 8, 2003. Yet, after that time, Dr. Mied substantially revised STUDENT’s goals and objectives and provided them to MOTHER. (Compare District’s Exhibits 88 and 69-4 through 6.) MOTHER did not contact Dr. Mied to discuss why the three pages of revised goals and objectives were inadequate. On the basis of what was presented at hearing, her only response was a three-sentence e-mail, which did not specifically identify alleged deficiencies, to another District employee. (District’s Exhibit 97.) Dr. Mied also provided MOTHER with a progress report in June 2002. (Footnote 18) (District’s Exhibit 90.) In response to a question regarding whether Dr. Mied ever failed to respond to a specific request for information, MOTHER stated, “I don’t know that I made any requests.”

Perhaps it would have been preferable for Dr. Mied to resist making any substantive comments to STUDENT about MOTHER’s criticism. Yet, Dr. Mied appears to have maintained a good rapport with STUDENT. MOTHER indicated that STUDENT asked her how MOTHER could not like Dr. Mied when Dr. Mied was so nice to STUDENT. MOTHER also stated that Dr. Mied was “extremely friendly” to STUDENT. When asked how Dr. Mied’s reaction to MOTHER’s criticism had affected STUDENT’s academic progress, MOTHER indicated, “I can’t answer that.” The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence does not show that Dr. Mied was inadequately trained or otherwise unqualified to teach Lindamood-Bell as a result of her handling of MOTHER’s criticism.

IV. The 2002-2003 school year:

Although the parties have differing views on whether Lindamood-Bell reading instruction was even offered after the September 17, 2002, interim mediation agreement, the parties agree that from the beginning of the school year through September 16, 2002, the District offered Dr. Mied to provide Lindamood-Bell instruction. (Testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Heilbronner; District’s closing statement, pp.15-16. (Footnote 19) ) Therefore, at the least, the Hearing Officer must decide whether Dr. Mied was appropriately trained to implement Lindamood-Bell instruction from the beginning of the school year through September 16, 2002. Because there was no evidence to suggest that the requirements for delivering Lindamood-Bell instruction changed at any time during the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer concludes, on the basis of his previous analysis, that Dr. Mied was appropriately trained to implement Lindamood-Bell instruction for the entire 2002-2003 school year.

ORDER

Petitioner’s request for relief is denied.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: August 1, 2003 ____________________________________ Terrence B. Ohler, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. A prehearing conference order was issued on June 18, 2003, which stated the only issue for hearing as: “[f]or the time periods from June 2000 through the present, has the District provided STUDENT with teachers appropriately trained to implement her Lindamood Bell services?” The Hearing Officer has revised the issue to reflect discussion at hearing, including an evidentiary ruling. For the time period at issue, Dr. Mary Lou Mied is the only teacher whose qualifications are at issue. Furthermore, the Hearing Officer ruled that he would not consider any issue pertaining to the 2000-2001 school year because the parties entered into a mediation agreement dated July 12, 2001, resolving that year. Petitioner chose September 12, 2001, as the beginning date for the Hearing Officer’s analysis, which is the date MOTHER and STUDENT met with Dr. Mied at MOTHER’s home. 2 A hearing officer may consider other decisions of the Hearing Office as persuasive authority. 5 Calif. Code of Regulations § 3085. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer can take “judicial” or “official” notice of the prior decision. Even though the Hearing Officer takes notice of the prior decision involving Petitioner’s brother, the Hearing Officer also recognizes that the record in the current matter is entirely separate and that an analysis of the facts presented in this hearing may lead him to a different conclusion. 3. Ms. Charlene David, a clinic director for Lindamood-Bell at the Danville center, explained that Lindamood-Bell is a private business that has programs aimed at improving students’ spelling, reading, and writing skills. A more detailed explanation of some of the Lindamood-Bell programs is provided below. 4. The CDE references a July 19, 2000, IEP, but the reference should have been to September instead of July. 5. Although mediation agreements are generally confidential, the mediation agreements referenced in this Decision were admitted into evidence without objection from either party. 6. MOTHER indicated that another reason she did not wish to sign the February 14, 2002, IEP was that she intended to file a due process hearing request, which appears unrelated to the request filed for the current dispute. 7. The CDE’s findings made after a compliance complaint investigation are not binding on the Hearing Office. See the Hearing Office’s decision in Student v. Auburn Union Elementary School Dist., case number SN 823-00, citing Lucht v. Molalla River School Dist. (D. Ore. 1999) 57 F.Supp.2d 1060, 1065, and Letter to Lieberman, 23 IDELR 351. 8. The IEP meetings occurred on April 21, 2003, and May 28, 2003. (See District’s Exhibits 93 and 105, respectively.) MOTHER did not attend either of these IEP meetings. She claims she did not get timely notice of the first meeting and was unable to attend the second meeting because of a personal scheduling conflict that the District would not accommodate. The Hearing Officer will not address these procedural issues because they were not raised before testimony commenced, let alone at least ten days before the hearing date. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6). Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer does not find that these procedural issues in any way impact the issue stated here for decision. 9. In the investigation document signed November 16, 2001, the CDE states, “During a telephone interview on 11-14-01, the District acknowledged that the agreed upon teacher was not fully Lindamood-Bell trained when school resumed in fall, 2001. To remedy the situation, the District offered to pay for 1:1 instruction at a Lindamood-Bell clinic….” (District’s Exhibit 107-2.) 10. Even if her testimony was clear that a teacher would be qualified to teach the one program in which a teacher had received training, Ms. Heilbronner’s testimony in this area was not entitled to great weight because her knowledge derives from conversations with another District employee, not Lindamood-Bell personnel directly. 11. From October 1, 2001, through December 21, 2001, there were approximately fifty-seven days of instruction. (District’s Exhibit 110-2.) If STUDENT received an extra fifteen minutes of instruction during each of these days, this would total 14.25 hours of additional instruction that was not required by the parties’ July 12, 2001, mediation agreement. By comparison, STUDENT missed approximately 9.75 hours (i.e., 13 days times 0.75 hours) of Lindamood-Bell instructional time from September 12, 2001, through September 28, 2001, because no Lindamood-Bell instruction was provided. 12. At another point in her testimony, MOTHER testified that she did not know she could consent to a part of an IEP, which may help to explain why she did not consent to any portion of numerous IEPs pertaining to STUDENT. 13. This may explain why Dr. Mied’s services did not start until January 23, 2002. In any event, Petitioner has not specifically raised as an issue the gap in Lindamood-Bell instruction from January 5-22, 2002, and she did not address the issue at hearing or in her closing brief. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer does not otherwise address this time gap. 14. Ms. David began working at Lindamood-Bell after receiving her bachelor’s degree. She spent one year as a clinician, another year as a consultant, and another year as an associate clinic director prior to having recently become the clinic director at the Lindamood-Bell Danville center. 15. Although it is unclear whether there are more than three reading related programs at Lindamood-Bell, Ms. David identified only these “three main programs” when asked on direct-examination to generally explain the Lindamood-Bell programs. 16. The Hearing Officer notes that the results from the test date of February 5, 2002, are difficult to compare with other tests because very few tests were performed on that date as compared to prior testing dates and the April 17, 2003, testing date. (See the third column of Exhibit 75 entitled “Re-Test 2/5/2002,” which contains numerous blank spaces.) 17. See the bottom right-hand corner of the page marked “13.57,” which is within Petitioner’s Exhibit 13. 18. MOTHER’s e-mail states, “I received your goals & objective[s] [in] the mail today. None that I requested are mentioned at all. These are not expectable [sic. – acceptable].” 19. See also the District’s letter to the Hearing Office dated June 18, 2003, in support of its motion to dismiss at p. 3 where the District’s counsel states that the “District offered the same District staff person, Dr. Mary Lou Mied[,] to provide Lindamood Bell services to STUDENT during the 2002