California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 7, 2004

Student v. Duarte Union High School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1935-03 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary

Duarte Union High School District's San Gabriel placement offer was not a FAPE, but the parent's request for Duarte High School was denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A 15-year-old student's mother filed for due process against Duarte Union High School District and Los Angeles County Mental Health. The student was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance and specific learning disability. She attended a special day class for students with emotional disabilities at Mission PAU, a center-based Los Angeles County Office of Education program with close adult supervision and behavior management aides. In September 2003, the mother asked that her daughter return to her home school, Duarte High School. The District instead offered a less restrictive special day class for students with emotional disabilities at San Gabriel High School. The mother rejected that offer. She argued that her daughter's problems had been ordinary teenage rebellion that had now passed.

The Hearing Officer found that the student still had significant emotional and behavioral needs, and that her outbursts and defiance had increased since September 2003. Her Mission PAU teacher, Stephanie Spinks, and school psychologist, Sunita Batra, testified that San Gabriel had no behavior management aides and less supervision, so it could no longer give her enough support. Relying on their testimony, the Hearing Officer held that the San Gabriel offer was not designed to meet her unique needs and was not a FAPE. The Hearing Officer also held that Duarte High School was not an appropriate placement. It had no special day class for students with emotional disabilities, no behavior aides, and no school psychologist. No placement was ordered, and the Hearing Officer made no finding about Mission PAU.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO handled a split result. The parent won her challenge to the district's offer but lost on the placement she wanted. The Hearing Officer relied on the district's own staff, who testified that the student's behavior had regressed after the offer. She found that neither the offered program nor the parent's preferred school met the student's emotional needs.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Was the District's offer of placement at San Gabriel High School an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 school year?

    The San Gabriel ED special day class lacked the close supervision, behavior management aides and pervasive emotional support the student needed, so it was not designed to meet her unique needs and was not a FAPE.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Should Duarte High School be the appropriate placement for Petitioner?

    Duarte High School had no ED special day class, no behavior management aides, no school psychologist and no pervasive adult support, so it could not currently meet the student's social and emotional needs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's request that San Gabriel High School be found an inappropriate placement was granted (declaratory finding only). Request that Duarte High School be found appropriate was denied. No placement was ordered, and the Hearing Officer made no finding on Mission PAU.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Govt. Code § 7576; Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Peter C. Gallup, program specialist and school psychologist, Duarte Unified School District
  • Karen E. Gilyard, attorney for District, Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo
  • Paul McIver, district chief, representative for LACMH, Los Angeles County Mental Health
  • Deborah Smith, program head, Los Angeles County Mental Health
  • Stephanie Spinks, special day class teacher, Mission PAU (LACOE)
  • Sunita Batra, school psychologist, Los Angeles County Office of Education, Mission PAU
  • Susan McEachern, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessor), Duarte district
  • Eugene C. Baumann, AB 3632 mental health assessor, Los Angeles County Mental Health
  • Monrovia Pacific Clinic, contracted mental health service provider, LACMH contract provider
  • Pacific Clinics, private counseling provider
  • Frostig Center, private school requested by parent in 2002
  • Las Encinas Hospital, acute care mental health facility

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Anaheim, California, on December 2 and 3, 2003. Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by her mother, Ms. MOTHER. Respondent Duarte Union High School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Karen E. Gilyard of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Also present on the District’s behalf was Peter C. Gallup, District program specialist. Respondent Los Angeles County Mental Health (LACMH) was represented at hearing by Paul McIver, district chief. Also present on LACMH’s behalf for the first day of hearing only was Deborah Smith, program head.

The Petitioner and her mother testified on her behalf.

The District called the following witnesses: Stephanie Spinks, special day class teacher at Mission Principal’s Administrative Unit (PAU); Sunita Batra, school psychologist for the Los Angeles County Office of Education (LACOE); and Peter C. Gallup, program specialist and school psychologist for the Duarte Unified School District. LACMH did not call any witnesses of its own; however, Mr. McIver conducted examinations of the witnesses called by the Petitioner and the District.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Petitioner and LACMH presented oral closing arguments. The Special Education Hearing Office received the written closing argument of the District on December 9, 2003. The Hearing Office received Petitioner’s reply brief on December 15, 2003, and at that time the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING1 (Footnote 1)

1. Was the District’s offer of placement at San Gabriel High School an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 school year?2 (Footnote 2)

2. Should Duarte High School be the appropriate placement for Petitioner?

CONTENTIONS

Petitioner contends that the placement offered by the District at San Gabriel High School is not appropriate. Petitioner contends that her mother agreed to the current restrictive placement at Mission PAU (principal’s administrative unit) to thwart adolescent rebellion, that she no longer needs a restrictive placement because her period of adolescent rebellion has passed, and that, therefore, the restrictive placement at San Gabriel is also inappropriate. Petitioner contends that she can successfully return to her home school at Duarte High School. The District and LACMH contend that Petitioner still has significant emotional and behavioral problems that impede her learning and that such problems would be appropriately addressed in a more restrictive environment that includes pervasive emotional and behavioral support. The District contends that its offer of the placement at San Gabriel High School is an offer of FAPE. LACMH contends that it has properly assessed Petitioner and has offered all appropriate AB 3632 mental health services. Both Respondents contend that Duarte High School is not an appropriate placement for Petitioner.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who resides within the boundaries of the Duarte Unified School District. She was originally identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of specific learning disabilities (SLD) during the 1995-1996 school year while attending second grade. No evidence was presented regarding STUDENT’s educational programs from second grade through seventh grade. STUDENT is currently attending Mission PAU, which is a program run by LACOE that serves special education students with emotional disabilities. STUDENT is placed in special day classes (SDC) for emotionally disturbed (ED) students. Her placement includes related services of counseling and behavior management. STUDENT is currently eligible for special education as ED and SLD.3 (Footnote 3)

STUDENT attended Northview Intermediary School during the 2001-2002 school year for eighth grade. She spent fifty-six percent of her day in special day classes (SDC) to address English/language arts, math, science and social science. STUDENT received reading instruction in a Resource Specialist Program (RSP) class. She was placed in the general education population for assemblies, field and study trips, lunch, recess, breaks, and physical education.

During her annual review at an IEP team meeting held February 13, 2002, the IEP team instituted a behavior plan for STUDENT. The behaviors of concern were listed as “[I]nability to keep hands and feet to oneself, verbally abusing classmates, cursing, defiance towards adults, emotional outbursts.” Many different and often minor things triggered STUDENT’s emotional outbursts. The outbursts would escalate rapidly into uncontrolled behavior such as cursing and screaming at peers or teachers. STUDENT could not control her behavior and would have to be removed from the classroom as highly disruptive. STUDENT would remain highly agitated and was not able to de-escalate her behavior so as to return to class or return to task. The behavior plan called for STUDENT to comply with existing class rules and to follow disciplinary directions from adults. The plan contemplated that STUDENT may need a break from a general education environment and allowed her to request to go to the counseling office. The teacher could also require STUDENT to go to the counseling office. While in a special education class, STUDENT would be permitted to take a break in a quiet isolated place in the classroom should she need to do so. The teacher could also require STUDENT to take a break. The behavior plan also set forth progressive disciplinary steps in the event that STUDENT became disruptive, defiant, threatening or physically aggressive. The final step in the behavior plan would be recommendation for expulsion.

Testimony at hearing established that STUDENT frequently became involved in disputes with other students, teachers, and staff that would escalate into emotional outbursts. When upset STUDENT requested permission to go to the counseling office but would instead frequently wander around campus and fail to return to class. Testimony also established that STUDENT was disruptive in class, was defiant, and on several occasions became threatening and physically aggressive. Testimony established that a minor conflict would escalate into uncontrolled behavior. For instance, on one occasion STUDENT objected to a student looking at her. STUDENT became angry and her behavior escalated. She began screaming and cursing at the student and then at the adult who intervened. STUDENT was also reported to request bathroom breaks after having just returned from a break. If the bathroom break was denied, STUDENT would become upset and she would often scream, yell and curse at the adult who denied her the bathroom break. STUDENT was unable to stop the confrontation without intervention from another adult. STUDENT’s outbursts were described as loud, profane, aggressive and physically threatening in that she would flail her arms about and shout into the other person’s face.

The IEP of February 13, 2002, noted that STUDENT was to transition to Duarte High School for the 2002-2003 school year for ninth grade. STUDENT’s mother did not want her to enter Duarte High School but wanted STUDENT transferred to the Frostig Center (Frostig) to strengthen her academic skills. MOTHER also wanted STUDENT to have the benefit of Frostig’s more restrictive environment. The District members of the team noted that Frostig did not accept students with behavioral problems. The District members also determined that STUDENT did not require a more restrictive environment because they believed the existing behavior plan was sufficient. The IEP noted that STUDENT’s behavior impeded her learning. STUDENT’s mother agreed to all aspects of the IEP.

Because of her behavior at home, MOTHER arranged for STUDENT to participate in counseling at Pacific Clinics. The intake interview took place on February 22, 2002. STUDENT’s problems were listed as verbal and physical aggression, running away, difficulty with anger management, difficulty academically and defiance to authority figures. STUDENT attended therapy sessions fairly regularly until June 10, 2002.

STUDENT’s mother requested an IEP team meeting to discuss placement, which was held May 3, 2002. MOTHER again asked that STUDENT be placed at Frostig instead of Duarte High School. The District representatives did not agree to place STUDENT in Frostig because they felt that STUDENT was making progress in her current program and the more restrictive program of Frostig was not necessary.

STUDENT was hospitalized at Las Encinas Hospital three times between May 2002 and October 2002. At the end of the last hospitalization in October 2002, STUDENT was released to a foster home.4 (Footnote 4) Las Encinas initially diagnosed STUDENT as having a major depressive disorder but released her with a discharge diagnosis of bipolar disorder.

On September 5, 2002, MOTHER requested that the District reassess STUDENT. MOTHER indicated her concern with STUDENT’s math difficulties. MOTHER was also concerned with STUDENT’s talking out, truancy, depression, and mood swings. Susan McEachern, school psychologist, conducted the psychoeducational assessment. The assessment team’s report dated October 22, 2002, noted that STUDENT remained eligible for special education as SLD. She continued to need consultation with the school psychologist. The IEP team met on October 23, 2002, to discuss the assessments and STUDENT’s placement. The IEP team noted that STUDENT’s primary handicapping condition now appeared to be emotional. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred to LACOE’s Mission PAU for an ED placement. The IEP team also recommended referral to LACMH for an AB 3632 assessment. MOTHER signed the IEP in agreement. MOTHER signed consent forms for the AB 3632 assessment. STUDENT’s goals, objectives and placement at Duarte High School were to continue pending her application for transfer to Mission PAU and pending the AB 3632 assessment.

By letter dated December 11, 2002, Ms. McEachern memorialized her telephone conversation with Sunita Batra, school psychologist for Mission PAU, regarding the IEP team’s recommendation that STUDENT be placed in a more restrictive environment. Ms. McEachern noted her concern for STUDENT’s safety because STUDENT was unable to distinguish safe situations from unsafe situations. Ms. McEachern wrote that STUDENT was found wandering around campus and, on one occasion, was wandering up a freeway onramp. Ms. McEachern also discussed STUDENT’s prior hospitalizations for symptoms of bipolar disorder, and relayed reports from teachers of STUDENT’s aggressive behavior. On other occasions, STUDENT was found deep asleep in class. Ms. McEachern stated that STUDENT visited her office daily, had appeared at the office disoriented, and had stated to her SDC teacher that “the demons” control her actions.

An initial IEP team meeting was held at Mission PAU on December 18, 2002. The team found that STUDENT was eligible for special education as ED and SLD. The team noted that STUDENT “had not been benefiting” from attending Duarte High School and needed the more restrictive environment and emotional supports to be found at Mission PAU. STUDENT was placed in an SDC (small group, flexible setting) five days per week, was provided DIS counseling one day per week and was provided transportation. Behavior goals and objectives were drafted to address defiance, disruption and task-avoidance. The IEP outlined several modifications to assist STUDENT with academic instruction and test taking. MOTHER signed her agreement to the IEP. STUDENT began attending Mission PAU on January 6, 2003.

At hearing, the Mission PAU campus was described as a center-based campus in which restrictive and pervasive adult support for behavior problems was provided. Students were not allowed to wander the campus unaccompanied by an adult. Students were escorted to the counseling offices and restrooms and were closely supervised during breaks, recess and lunch. Students were to seek out adult support and intervention should any conflict arise, whether with a peer or another adult. The counseling office employed “Behavior Management Aides” who worked with students to de-escalate emotional outbursts and return students to task. The aides would also work with students to resolve conflicts. Students were expected to walk away from conflict and use the coping skills taught in both small-group and individual therapy. A major component of every student’s behavior program was the daily point sheet. Students carried a point sheet with them and were evaluated throughout the day with regards to behavior. Students were expected to take the point sheets home daily, review the day’s behavior with a parent, obtain a parent’s signature, and return the sheets the next day. Students could “buy” privileges, such as microwave use, free time or other such privileges with their points.

Eugene C. Baumann, MSW, PHD, AB 3632 Assessor, completed the AB 3632 assessment on January 6, 2003. Mr. Baumann found STUDENT eligible for mental health services and recommended that she receive individual and/or group and family therapy once per week. He also recommended medication support. An IEP team meeting was held on January 22, 2003, to discuss the AB 3632 assessment. STUDENT’s educational program was modified slightly to consist of the following: SDC placement at Mission PAU, counseling on campus once per week for thirty minutes, and outpatient therapy at least once per week for sixty minutes with medication support. MOTHER noted her agreement and signed the IEP. On January 22, 2003, LACMH offered services through one of its contracted service providers, Monrovia Pacific Clinic. MOTHER declined the AB 3632 services and continued to seek therapy for STUDENT through her own resources, also from the Monrovia Pacific Clinic. Monrovia Pacific Clinic’s case management notes on February 10, 2003, document several calls from MOTHER requesting an emergency residential placement because STUDENT was in crisis. The caseworker described the residential placement process to MOTHER and she declined to take further steps.

From May 28, 2003 to July 17, 2003, STUDENT attended mental health therapy infrequently through Monrovia Pacific Clinic.5 (Footnote 5) Testimony at hearing revealed that STUDENT’s behavior was improving while attending Mission PAU. Her SDC teacher, Stephanie Spinks, and school psychologist Ms. Batra both testified that STUDENT’s emotional outbursts had diminished in frequency, intensity, and duration. STUDENT was learning to de-escalate her feelings and return to task. STUDENT had improved significantly in seeking adult help with conflicts and emotional upsets. As a result, STUDENT was spending more time in class.

On September 5, 2003, an IEP team meeting was held at the request of STUDENT’s mother. MOTHER wanted the team to transfer STUDENT back to Duarte High School. MOTHER testified that she believed STUDENT’s adolescent rebellion had passed. While the District members acknowledged STUDENT’s improvement, they recommended STUDENT stay in a more restrictive environment. The District members recommended that STUDENT be placed in an ED/SDC administered by LACOE at San Gabriel High School, a less restrictive placement than Mission PAU. The District members of the team agreed to reconsider MOTHER’s request to return STUDENT to Duarte if STUDENT continued to show improvement in her coping and adaptive behavioral skills while at San Gabriel. Another IEP team meeting was held on September 9, 2003, at MOTHER’s request to again discuss placement. MOTHER again requested that STUDENT be transferred back to Duarte High School. The District members continued to recommend the placement at San Gabriel High School.

MOTHER declined placement at San Gabriel and on September 10, 2003, requested a due process hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Was the District’s offer of placement at San Gabriel High School an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2003-2004 school year?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs and prepares them for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meets the standards of the State educational agency, includes appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and is provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services,” includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. Such services include mental health services if necessary to assist a child to benefit from special education. The State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service…shall be responsible for the provision of mental health services…. when required in the pupil’s individualized education program. (Govt. Code § 7576 (a).)

Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). Removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Educ. Code § 56031.)

To constitute an offer of FAPE, the IDEA requires that the District’s placement, which includes related services and in this case, mental health services, must (1) be designed to address STUDENT’ s unique education needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide her some educational benefit, and (3) comport with her IEP. The offer must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE).

To determine whether the offer made on September 5, 2003, and again on September 9, 2003, was an offer of a FAPE designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine STUDENT’s unique needs.

STUDENT’s Unique Needs

The parties agree that STUDENT has a learning disability that has adversely affected her educational progress in all academic subjects. The parties agree that STUDENT has unique needs that require extra help in all subjects, through RSP and SDC classes. STUDENT needs modifications in testing methods and needs simplified instruction in both teaching and testing. Because there is no dispute, the Hearing Officer will not address STUDENT’s SLD needs further. The parties disagree as to STUDENT’s emotional needs. MOTHER contends that STUDENT does not have emotional needs that impede her learning and thus does not need the emotional support of Mission PAU or San Gabriel. MOTHER contends that STUDENT’s period of adolescent rebellion has passed. MOTHER testified that STUDENT is manipulative but does not have an emotional disability. The testimony established otherwise. MOTHER acknowledged that STUDENT still has a hard time accepting “no” and will seek the opinion of another authority figure to avoid limits on her behavior. STUDENT testified that she sometime finds it hard to accept criticism and hard to take “no” for an answer, but not all of the time. STUDENT also testified that she does not like Mission PAU. She feels that she does not need a behavioral plan. STUDENT and her mother testified that Mission PAU uses a daily point system to track positive and negative behavior. This system is an essential part of STUDENT’s behavior management program. STUDENT, her mother, and Ms. Spinks testified that STUDENT does not return the point sheets daily. STUDENT testified at hearing that she just doesn’t do it. She could not provide an explanation. STUDENT’s behavior plan at Mission PAU requires that she greet staff appropriately in the morning. STUDENT testified that she doesn’t think this is necessary, that she needs to get energized first before she can do this.

The District witnesses testified that when STUDENT started at Mission PAU, she had poor adaptive skills that caused her to have intense and protracted emotional outbursts. STUDENT developed and often created conflicts with other students, teachers and staff. STUDENT was defiant to staff and her conflicts with staff escalated into emotional outbursts. STUDENT had great difficulty in de-escalating her feelings and returning to task. The District witnesses testified that after STUDENT began attending Mission PAU, she improved her adaptive skills and the frequency and intensity of her emotional outbursts diminished. The length of time it took STUDENT to de-escalate her feelings and return to task had decreased. STUDENT significantly improved her ability to seek adult help in resolving conflict.

However, the District witnesses also testified that STUDENT has experienced an increase in emotional outbursts and defiance since September 2003. STUDENT and MOTHER explained this increase in their testimony that a male student had made racial slurs and it was these racial slurs that triggered STUDENT’s recent emotional outbursts. STUDENT and MOTHER testified that staff cannot expect STUDENT to control her reactions in the face of such comments. Ms. Spinks and Ms. Batra testified that Mission PAU expects students to walk away from situations of conflict. The proper behavior would have been to seek out an adult and report the racial slurs. While District witnesses acknowledged the conflict with the male student, the District witnesses also testified as to STUDENT’s continued conflicts with other students, teachers and staff during this time period. Ms. Spinks testified that STUDENT also had some aggressive confrontations with a female student who STUDENT feels betrayed her. The activity log kept by Ms. Spinks from September 10, 2003, through November 21, 2003, indicates that STUDENT still had a difficult time accepting no, following staff instructions, and obtaining proper permission. STUDENT frequently failed to return her point sheets. STUDENT was often disrespectful to teachers and staff. STUDENT continues to have conflicts with other students and adults, which result in emotional outbursts that disrupt the class and take STUDENT off task for significant periods of time. These outbursts continue to impede STUDENT’s learning.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded from the evidence above that STUDENT needs significant emotional and behavioral support. STUDENT has deficits in adaptive behavior and coping skills that result in her difficulties in accepting no, accepting criticism, accepting instruction and directions, regulating her feelings, de-escalating her feelings, interacting appropriately with people and reacting appropriately to circumstances and situations. STUDENT has unique needs that require a restrictive environment, ongoing counseling, and a behavior management plan.

Did the offer of placement at San Gabriel address STUDENT’s unique needs?

Ms. Batra testified at hearing that the SDC at San Gabriel would contain no more than twelve students, with one teacher and one paraeducator in the class. The SDC class is for ED students. The staff is specially trained to teach ED students and implement behavior intervention plans. A school psychologist is available to provide DIS counseling. STUDENT would be mainstreamed into one to three classes per day. Mental health therapy through LACMH would continue to be available. However, San Gabriel does not have behavior management aides and does not supervise students as closely as does Mission PAU. San Gabriel does not have the same level of adult trained support to help students address conflict and return to task. The District’s witnesses Stephanie Spinks and Sunita Batra testified that at the time of the IEP team meetings on September 5 and 9, 2003, they believed that the San Gabriel placement would meet STUDENT’s unique needs. However, by the time of hearing, because of a regression in her behavior, these witnesses no longer felt that San Gabriel could provide the level of emotional support currently needed by STUDENT.6 (Footnote 6) Ms. Batra convincingly testified that STUDENT’s emotional outbursts go beyond “normal adolescent rebellion” in intensity, frequency, and duration. Ms. Batra testified that STUDENT needs supervision and pervasive adult support. STUDENT continues to need close supervision, the support of behavior management aides, availability of immediate conflict resolution and counseling and a support system that is trained to return STUDENT to task as soon as possible. Ms. Batra and Ms. Spinks credibly testified that San Gabriel does not have the intensive level of behavioral support that STUDENT needs. Ms. Batra and Ms. Spinks recommended that STUDENT stay at Mission PAU.7 (Footnote 7) The Hearing Officer is persuaded and finds that STUDENT requires significant emotional and behavioral support for an emotional condition that goes beyond “normal adolescent rebellion.” Ms. Spinks has been STUDENT’s SDC teacher since STUDENT entered Mission PAU. Ms. Batra is the school psychologist that provides DIS services at Mission PAU. In that these two witnesses have worked closely with STUDENT in regards to her emotional needs, the Hearing Officer gives their testimony great weight. Based on the testimony of Ms. Spinks and Ms. Batra, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s adaptive skills are deficient, which condition leads to significant emotional outbursts. Also based on the testimony of Ms. Spinks and Ms. Batra, the Hearing Officer finds that the San Gabriel placement does not have the pervasive emotional support services that STUDENT needs to be successful in school, and therefore is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Was the District’s offer of placement reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit? Did the District’s offer of placement comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

Because of the above finding, it is not necessary to determine this issue.

2. Should Duarte High School be the appropriate placement for Petitioner?

Peter C. Gallup testified that Duarte High School is a comprehensive campus that has four teachers who teach special day classes for students with SLD. The campus does not have an SDC for students with ED. Class size is thirteen to eighteen students generally, with no maximum number. Mr. Gallup testified that there are no behavioral management aides as there are at Mission PAU. He testified that Duarte does not have a school psychologist. Duarte does not have pervasive adult support for students with emotional disabilities.

MOTHER testified at hearing that STUDENT was successful while attending Duarte just nine months previous. However, MOTHER also testified that STUDENT left class frequently at Duarte, wandered around the campus, and spent significant time in the counseling office, in the school secretary’s office and in the nurse’s office. STUDENT manipulated her behavior plan to avoid attending class. While STUDENT testified that she would not display this behavior if returned to Duarte, STUDENT’s defiance of Mission PAU rules demonstrates that she still does not follow school rules, and continues to be defiant to authority figures. MOTHER contends that STUDENT has gone through a normal period of adolescent rebellion that could not have been called an emotional disturbance if she had not placed her daughter in Las Encinas Hospital. The evidence establishes otherwise. Prior to the hospitalization in May 2002, the Duarte IEP team had already developed a behavior plan. By February 2002 STUDENT’s behavior was already adversely affecting her education. Ms. Batra testified credibly that STUDENT’s emotional outbursts are much more intense than those expected with normal adolescence. Testimony established that STUDENT remains defiant and is still resistive to following school rules and adult direction. Testimony also established that STUDENT’s behavior has regressed. She is not able to regulate her emotions, control her behavior, or return to task without support and guidance.

Based on the testimony of Mr. Gallup, Ms. Batra and Ms. Spinks, the Hearing Officer finds that Duarte High School cannot currently meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs.

Is placement at Duarte High School reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT some educational benefit? Does placement at Duarte High School comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

Because of the above finding, it is not necessary to determine these issues.

CONCLUSION

STUDENT has significant emotional and behavioral needs that require intense adult supervision and support. The placement at San Gabriel does not include that level of emotional support and thus does not meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the placement offer is not an offer of FAPE. Furthermore, Duarte High School is not an appropriate placement at this time because the campus does not have behavioral services and supports that can address STUDENT’s current unique emotional needs.

ORDER

1. The Petitioner’s request that San Gabriel High School be found to be an inappropriate placement for STUDENT is granted. 2. Petitioner’s request that Duarte High School be found to be an appropriate placement for STUDENT is denied.8 (Footnote 8)

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Petitioner prevailed as to the offer of placement at San Gabriel. Respondent prevailed as to whether Duarte High School is an appropriate placement.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: January 7, 2004

_____________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Officer

1 The issues have been restated to reflect the results of the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. The issues have been reorganized for ease of analysis. There were no substantive changes.

2 The parties referred to the placement as “interim” or “transitional.” However, as those terms are terms of art with specific statutory definitions, which are inapplicable to this matter, the hearing officer will not use such terms.

3 In her written request for a due process hearing, Mrs .MOTHER requested that the hearing officer change STUDENT’s eligibility status from ED as primary to SLD as primary and ED as secondary. However, at hearing the parties discussed only the issues identified herein and did not present evidence regarding a change of a primary disability status. Therefore, the hearing officer will not address the issue.

4 Las Encinas Hospital is an acute care facility for children and adults with emotional problems. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was released into foster care because she would not agree to pick STUDENT up from the hospital when STUDENT was released on October 4, 2002. MOTHER testified that she informed the hospital that STUDENT was not ready to be released. Las Encinas took steps to release STUDENT into foster care. STUDENT was placed back in her home after a court hearing October 28, 2002.

5 At hearing, LACMH asserted it paid for these services under AB 3632. MOTHER continued to assert that she paid for the services. There were no contentions that LACMH failed to properly assess STUDENT or failed to provide services. The identity of the payer does not affect this decision.

6 Evidence was presented that in September, three different incident reports were issued regarding confrontations between STUDENT and other students. The log kept by Ms. Spinks from September 10, 2003 through November 20, 2003 indicated numerous behavioral outbursts, incidents of defiance and confrontations between STUDENT and other students, and between STUDENT, and teachers and staff. Due process hearings had been scheduled for October 2 and October 28 and eventually for December 2, 2003. The log entries also describe STUDENT’s anxiety over this due process proceeding and in regards to her transfer. Ms. Batra testified that these proceedings are contributory to STUDENT’s regression.

7 Significantly, although the District contends in its closing written argument that San Gabriel remains an appropriate placement for STUDENT, the District witnesses—Spinks and Batra—testified that they would no longer recommend San Gabriel because of the regression in STUDENT’s behavior.

8 Petitioner did not request a finding that Mission PAU was the appropriate placement, nor was evidence presented regarding the appropriateness of placement at Mission PAU. Therefore, the hearing officer will not make such a determination.