California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 21, 2000
Student v. Ventura Unified School District et al.
SEHO Case No. SN 1943-99, SN 1943-99A · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Ventura Unified may exit gifted student from special education, but he remained SED-eligible during disputed 1999-2000 periods.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Bifurcated decision. This is the eligibility phase (SN 1943-99A). The reserved issues (FAPE, residential placement, reimbursement, and claims against VCBH and VCOE) were to proceed as SN 1943-99B. Earlier orders: a summary order dated August 21, 2000, and an order dated September 8, 2000, denying VCOE's motion to dismiss.
Summary
The mother of a 14-year-old gifted ninth grader filed for due process after Ventura Unified School District's IEP team found her son no longer eligible for special education. He had been eligible as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) since sixth grade. The Hearing Officer split the case. This decision covered only eligibility. Questions about placement, reimbursement, and claims against Ventura County Behavioral Health and the Ventura County Office of Education were left for a second phase.
Because the District wanted to change the student's status, it had the burden of proof. The Hearing Officer found that he stayed eligible from July 28 to December 13, 1999, because no assessment supported an exit before then. He also stayed eligible from May 2 to June 15, 2000. In that period, the IEP team confirmed his eligibility and later put off any change until an independent assessment was done.
On current eligibility, the District prevailed. The Hearing Officer found that the student had long-standing, marked depression and obsessive-compulsive behavior that disrupted his homework. But he had good relationships with teachers and was making friends. His grades were mostly A's and B's, and his achievement scores stayed at the top of the test's range. Repeated breaks in school attendance did not by themselves show an adverse effect on educational performance. The Hearing Officer required a significant impact on his educational standing. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting by December 11, 2000, to exit him from special education.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled the requirement that an emotional disturbance adversely affect educational performance, here for a gifted student with clinical diagnoses. The Hearing Officer required a significant impact on educational standing. She rejected a fixed rule requiring all D's and F's and held that missed school alone did not prove an adverse effect.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1a. Did Student remain eligible for special education as SED from July 28, 1999 through December 13, 1999?
Student stayed SED-eligible for this period because no assessment supported an exit before the District's December 10, 1999 assessment and the December 13, 1999 IEP decision, so the District could not meet its burden.
- Student prevailedEligibility
Issue 1b. Did Student remain eligible for special education as SED from May 2, 2000 through June 15, 2000?
Student stayed eligible through stay put and the transfer eligibility affirmed on May 2, 2000. On June 13, 2000, the IEP team did not act on the new assessment and instead continued eligibility while an independent assessment was done.
- District prevailedEligibility
Issue 2. Is Student currently eligible for special education as SED?
Student met two SED characteristics: long-standing depression and OCD behavior affecting homework. But he could build relationships, and his grades and test scores showed no significant adverse effect on educational performance, so the District met its burden to exit him.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP meeting no later than December 11, 2000, to exit Student from special education consistent with the decision.
- Case SN 1943-99B may proceed on issues arising from Student's SED eligibility during the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Office will calendar it unless the parties report agreed dates by December 13, 2000.
Key authorities
Letter to Ulissi (1992) 18 IDELR 683; Santa Ana Unified School District (1994) 21 IDELR 1189; Baldwin Park Unified School District, SN 931-97; Student v. Hemet Unified School District, SN 550-91; Berkeley Unified School District (1987) EHLR 509:197; Doe v. Board of Education of the State of Connecticut, 753 F. Supp. 65 (D. Conn. 1990); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i)
People named in the decision
- Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services, Ventura Unified School District
- Amy Balchum, supervisor of special education support systems; licensed clinical social worker, Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Jim Foster, director of special education (VCOE representative), Ventura County Office of Education
- Brian Thomas Lee, private therapist
- Michael Appleton, school psychologist (initial SED assessment), Santa Barbara Unified School District
- Kelly Washam, therapist, Helicon Youth Center
- Jeffrey L. Zelinka, band teacher, Ventura Unified School District
- Anne Wilson, regular education teacher (Junipero Serra Elementary), Ventura Unified School District
- Karen Schroeder, regular education teacher, Ventura Unified School District
- Laura Castro, regular education math teacher, Ventura Unified School District
- Julie Myers, resource teacher (study skills), Ventura Unified School District
- Eleanor Marie Fritz, senior clinical psychologist, Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Deborah Allen, former psychiatric social worker in SED class, Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Pam Merrell, probation officer, Ventura County Probation
- Paul Saffron, school psychologist, Ventura Unified School District
- Cindy Goff, clinical psychologist / therapist, Teton Peaks Residential Treatment Center
- Richard Morris Deamer, treating psychiatrist
- Lois A. Weinberg, Ph.D., educational specialist, expert witness for Student, Mental Health Advocacy Services, Inc.
- Lisa Hellwig, school psychologist (psychoeducational assessments), Ventura Unified School District
- Sheri Schoenwald, school psychologist and program specialist, Ventura Unified School District
- Wendi McCoy Butler, GATE teacher, De Anza Middle School, Ventura Unified School District
- Denise Abdun-Nur, SED special day class teacher, De Anza Middle School, Ventura Unified School District
- Jimmy D. Hughes, regular education technology teacher, De Anza Middle School, Ventura Unified School District
- Barbara Kellner, psychiatric social worker (AB 2726 assessment), Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Ray C. Easler, Ph.D., independent educational evaluator; school psychologist, Riverside SELPA
- Howard Kelley Harper, director and clinical psychologist, Teton Peaks Residential Treatment Center
- Gary Richard Pentis, Sheriff Captain, Ojai Police Department
- Dr. Thurston, former psychiatrist
- Dr. Carvalho, treating psychiatrist, Anacapa Hospital
- Dr. Michael Vivian, treating psychiatrist, Vista Del Mar
- Dr. Benbow, treating psychiatrist, San Luis Rey Hospital Residential Treatment Center
- Dr. Leslie Singer, senior psychologist (AB 2726 assessment), Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Dr. Shawn Crombie, psychiatrist, Ventura County Behavioral Health
- Carrie Rodriguez, case manager, Teton Peaks Residential Treatment Center
- Ms. Lynch, computers teacher, De Anza Middle School, Ventura Unified School District
- Ms. Crawford, teacher (administered Woodcock-Johnson), Helicon Youth Center
- Teton Peaks Residential Treatment Center, private residential treatment center (Idaho)
- Helicon Youth Center, residential treatment center (probation placement)
- Phoenix Day Treatment Program, day treatment program (proposed referral)
- Genesis, in-home family therapy service (proposed referral)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
The matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Ventura, California, on August 22 and 23, September 11 through 13, 2000, and September 20, 2000.
Petitioner (hereafter Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf was his mother, MOTHER.(Footnote 1)
Respondent Ventura Unified School District (hereafter, the District) was represented by attorney Donald Austin. Also present on the District’s behalf was Riccardo Nargie, director of pupil services.
On August 22, 2000, Respondent Ventura County Behavioral Health (hereafter, VCBH) was represented by attorney Linda Randlett Kollar. Also present on VCBH’s behalf was Amy Balchum, supervisor of VCBH’s special education support systems.
Respondent Ventura County Office of Education (hereafter, VCOE) was represented by Jim Foster, its director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: therapist Brian Thomas Lee; Santa Barbara Unified School District school psychologist Michael Appleton; Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER; Helicon therapist Kelly Washam; District regular education teachers Jeffrey L. Zelinka, Anne Wilson, Karen Schroeder and Laura Castro; District resource teacher Julie Myers; VCBH clinical psychologist Eleanor Marie Fritz; former VCBH psychiatric social worker Deborah Allen; VCBH licensed clinical social worker Amy Balchum; Petitioner’s stepfather, STEPFATHER; Ventura County probation officer Pam Merrell; District school psychologist Paul Saffron; Teton Peaks clinical psychologist Cindy Goff; psychiatrist Dr. Richard Morris Deamer; and Lois A. Weinberg, Ph.D., educational specialist with Mental Health Advocacy Services, Inc.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: District school psychologist Lisa Hellwig; District school psychologist and program specialist Sheri Schoenwald; gifted and talented education (GATE) teacher Wendi McCoy Butler; special day class (SDC)/SED teacher Denise Abdun-Nur; regular education teacher Jimmy D. Hughes; District director of pupil services Riccardo Nargie; VCBH pychiatric social worker Barbara Kellner; Riverside SELPA coordinating/psychologist and independent educational evaluator Ray C. Easler, Ph.D.; Teton Peaks director and clinical psychologist Howard Kelley Harper; and Ohai Police Department Sheriff Captain Gary Richard Pentis.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record remained open pending the submission of written closing briefs and reply briefs. The matter was then submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The parties identified numerous issues for hearing between Petitioner and Respondent District, beginning with the question of whether STUDENT qualified as an individual with a serious emotional disturbance (SED)(Footnote 2) during the 1999-2000 school year and/or whether he currently qualifies as SED. If STUDENT was or is SED eligible, issues include whether the District provided him with a free appropriate public education (FAPE); whether STUDENT required or currently requires placement in a residential treatment center (RTC); if so, whether the District is responsible for reimbursing STUDENT’s MOTHER or otherwise paying for any part of that placement, including his placement by his mother at Teton Peaks Residential Center in Idaho, or any RTC placements ordered by the juvenile court; and whether the District must reimburse STUDENT’s MOTHER for the costs of private counseling. The parties identified the following as issues for hearing between Petitioner and Respondent VCBH: whether VCBH has any obligation to reimburse Petitioner for placement at Teton Peaks RTC, or for any residential placement made by the Ventura County Probation Department.(Footnote 3) Issues identified as existing between Petitioner and Respondent VCOE were whether VCOE provided STUDENT with a FAPE between June 26, 2000, and July 18, 2000, and what obligation, if any, VCOE owes STUDENT from July 18, 2000, forward.
On the first day of hearing, the District’s “motion to bifurcate and try threshold issues first” was argued.(Footnote 4) The District contended that Petitioner raised many issues which would be moot if his eligibility for special education was not established. Arguing in support of the District’s motion, VCHB contended that failure to bifurcate would require it to participate in a lengthy hearing to determine STUDENT’s eligibility, an issue for which it is not responsible. Although Petitioner initially opposed the motion based on potential prejudice due to delay, at the hearing he withdrew his opposition. The Hearing Officer granted the motion to bifurcate. The eligibility portion of the bifurcated hearing shall be referred to as SN 1943-99A; all reserved issues will be addressed in SN 1943-99B.
The District acknowledged that, since it was seeking to change STUDENT’s status quo as an SED eligible student, it had the burden of proof on the issue of eligibility and should present its case first. Petitioner agreed to allow them to do so. As a result of the bifurcation, all parties agreed that neither VCBH nor VCOE was required to be present at the hearing until the issue of eligibility was concluded. Thereafter, VCBH appeared at the hearing only as necessary to represent its employees and former employees who were testifying. VCOE was present throughout the hearing.
On the first day of the hearing, Mr. Foster argued VCOE’s motion to be dismissed as a party. Petitioner was given time to submit a written response. On September 8, 2000, the Hearing Officer issued an order denying VCOE’s motion to be dismissed.
ISSUES(Footnote 5)
The issues currently before the Hearing Officer in this bifurcated hearing are as follows:
1. Did STUDENT remain eligible for special education as SED during the following time periods within the 1999-2000 academic year:
a. from July 28, 1999 through December 13, 1999?
b. from May 2, 2000 through June 15, 2000?
2. Is STUDENT currently eligible for special education as SED?
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a 14-year-old mentally gifted student in the ninth grade. In the second and third grades, STUDENT was recommended for placement in the gifted and talented education (GATE) program.(Footnote 6) From the third grade to the middle of the seventh grade, STUDENT attended school in the Santa Barbara Unified School District (SBUSD). In the fall of 1997, STUDENT entered sixth grade at SBUSD’s La Cumbre Middle School and attended GATE core classes in English and social studies. In December 1997, STUDENT was removed from GATE classes for not turning in his homework on time as required by his GATE contract.
In April 1998, STUDENT was admitted on three occasions to Vista Del Mar psychiatric facility in Ventura for self-endangerment based upon repeatedly running away from home. In one episode, STUDENT “ran into traffic on the freeway and...was almost killed.” Treating psychiatrist Dr. Deamer diagnosed STUDENT with major depression, single episode, obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD) with multiple tics, and severe, chronic family conflict with mother in particular. STUDENT was continued on anti-depressant medication and was prescribed anti-psychotic medication. He was discharged from Vista Del Mar on May 5, 1998, with a “fair” prognosis.
Determination of Eligibility as SED by Santa Barbara Unified School District (SBUSD)
STUDENT was initially determined to be eligible for special education as SED in May of 1998 while attending SBUSD’s La Cumbre Middle School, based upon the psycho-educational evaluation conducted by school psychologist Michael Appleton. Mr. Appleton was aware that STUDENT had recently been diagnosed with emotional disturbances by Dr. Deamer. He also had received information from STUDENT’s former psychiatrist, Dr. Thurston, that STUDENT’s diagnoses of oppositional defiant disorder, OCD and motor tic disorder “compromise performance and disturb behavior to a degree requiring special education accommodation at school.” In addition, STUDENT’s school counselor reported that he had a very difficult time in conforming to regimented rules, turned in assignments late and was very disorganized. STUDENT left school without permission once on March 26, 1998, and was later found walking along the freeway toward Ventura. Mr. Appleton’s evaluation results confirmed “very high levels of problems in school and home environments.” He noted that STUDENT was “not able to perform well enough to stay in the GATE program for which he is qualified.”(Footnote 7)
On May 15, 1998, the IEP team determined STUDENT to be eligible for special education as SED and placed him in the resource specialist program (RSP) for three periods per day. A Behavior Plan, which provided that STUDENT would be supervised by adults 100% of the day, was attached as an addendum to the IEP. In September 1998, DIS counseling services of two to four times per month were added to STUDENT’s IEP.
Determination of Eligibility as SED by Ventura Unified School District
In March of 1999, STUDENT returned to school in the District.(Footnote 8) At a March 10, 1999 transfer IEP meeting, STUDENT was determined eligible for special education as SED and placed at De Anza Middle School in the regular seventh grade class for all six periods daily. DIS counseling services were to be provided twice a month for thirty minutes a session. Due to STUDENT’s OCD diagnosis, physical education was waived so he could have a period of study hall/resource room. STUDENT’s MOTHER consented to this IEP.(Footnote 9)
STUDENT’s schedule included three GATE classes with teacher Wendi McCoy Butler in science, language arts and U.S. history. Ms. Butler testified that she was STUDENT’s GATE teacher for a total of approximately five and a half months at De Anza. STUDENT performed “quite well” in her seventh grade GATE classes and earned grades of B+ in both science and U.S. history and an A in language arts.
On August 12, 1999, the IEP team met to develop IEP goals and objectives and to discuss accommodations for STUDENT. Two goals were established. First, STUDENT would satisfactorily complete assignments and turn them in on a timely basis. Second, STUDENT would learn to pace himself with assignments, based on teacher’s approximate time goals. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT and his teachers would schedule a regular time to review assignments and develop strategies for completion, and that STUDENT’s class grades for language arts, science and social studies would be “based on class participation and test performance (written and verbal).” Modifications for STUDENT’s math homework were to be determined. STUDENT’s MOTHER signed this addendum to the IEP of June 15, 1999. Although not memorialized on this IEP, the District proposed exiting STUDENT from special education services and providing him with accommodations under a Section 504 plan. STUDENT’s MOTHER did not agree to this exit plan.
STUDENT began his eighth grade year at De Anza on July 28, 1999, and regularly attended school until September 24, 1999. Ms. Butler was STUDENT’s eighth grade GATE teacher in language arts, U.S. history and science classes. STUDENT earned an A+ in language arts and A’s in both U.S. history and science. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that, during this same time, STUDENT had daily ‘rages’ after school which she reported to District school psychologist, Lisa Hellwig.
Beginning in late September 1999, STUDENT experienced a series of psychiatric hospitali-zations which resulted in his leaving De Anza. On multiple occasions, STUDENT was involuntarily placed at Anacapa Hospital, then voluntarily placed in Vista Del Mar. Anacapa treating psychiatrist Dr. Carvalho diagnosed STUDENT with major depression, recurrent, and severe parent/child relational problems. During one admission, Dr. Carvalho indicated that STUDENT “was angry and ran away from home...the Ventura Police found him in the Main Street river bottom and he admitted to both possible suicidal and homicidal ideation....” Vista Del Mar treating psychiatrist Dr. Michael Vivian diagnosed STUDENT with major depression, obsessive compulsive disorder, impulse control disorder and conflicts with mother. While at Vista Del Mar, STUDENT had “one suicide gesture where he was found in his shower with a pillow draped over around the back of his neck. He was feigning to be unconscious.” Dr. Vivian noted that STUDENT’s family was both a source of support for him as well as a liability. STUDENT’s MOTHER and her fiancee had just had a baby and STUDENT had recently resumed contact with his biological father. On discharge from Vista Del Mar, STUDENT was reported to be “looking forward to residential treatment as he was not willing to return home to his mother and stepfather.”
On October 22, 1999, STUDENT was admitted to San Luis Rey Hospital Residential Treatment Center (SLR/RTC) for an estimated stay of two to three months. Treating psychiatrist Dr. Benbow diagnosed STUDENT with major depressive disorder, recurrent, moderate; impulse control disorder; and family relations disturbance. Obsessive-compulsive disorder was to be ruled out. STUDENT advised Dr. Benbow that he had “a specific problem ... relating to family members, having apparently become involved in arguments that lead to property destruction.” During his stay at SLR, STUDENT was moved from the RTC into the more restrictive acute inpatient unit following an incident of self-mutilation (piercing his eyebrow with a staple). STUDENT also made one unsuccessful attempt to go AWOL (absent without leave) from the facility.
On November 2, 1999, the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be referred to VCBH to determine his eligibility for AB 2726 mental health services.(Footnote 10) STUDENT’s MOTHER signed this IEP, and Ms. Hellwig completed the referral that day.
On November 14, 1999, STUDENT was discharged from SLR/RTC. Due to STUDENT’s “tendency to run away... from treatment facilities and home,” the SLR staff and administration recommended that STUDENT be placed in a locked RTC which could “safely contain him and prevent runaways.” According to Dr. Benbow’s discharge report, a locked facility was available in Utah and the insurance company had agreed to fund it, but STUDENT’s MOTHER declined to place STUDENT there. Instead, she chose to have STUDENT treated at a partial hospital program closer to home, and STUDENT was discharged to her care. Based on the recommendation that STUDENT be placed in a locked RTC, however, STUDENT’s MOTHER did not re-enroll him at De Anza.
STUDENT began to attend weekly therapy sessions with therapist Brian Lee. Mr. Lee testified that the primary focus of these sessions was on STUDENT’s problems at home and on his experiences in various placements. There was not a lot of talk about school.
Shortly after his return home, STUDENT became involved with the juvenile court system. On November 19, 1999, STUDENT left home after crawling out his bathroom window. He called home two hours later. When the police met STUDENT, his clothes were wet, and he told them “that he went for a walk and fell in the water at the Ventura river bottom. He said that his mother typically overreacts and calls police.” The next day, STUDENT’s MOTHER brought STUDENT to the Ventura Sheriff’s office to report him as a habitual runaway and beyond parental control. While STUDENT’s MOTHER spoke to a deputy, STUDENT “vanished” and was discovered to have “entered the attic space to the building.” After about thirty minutes, STUDENT came through the ceiling uninjured and surrendered. He was charged with misdemeanors for vandalism based upon damage to the Sheriff’s ceiling and for willfully resisting a peace officer. STUDENT was detained at the juvenile court center.
In early December 1999, two of STUDENT’s mental health providers, therapist Brian Lee and psychiatrist Dr. Vivian, wrote to the District to recommend that STUDENT be placed in a locked residential treatment facility due to his emotional and behavioral instability.
On December 10, 1999, school psychologist Lisa Hellwig, in consultation with school psychologist and program specialist Sheri Shoenwald,(Footnote 11) conducted her first psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT. Ms. Hellwig concluded that STUDENT met was not eligible for special education. Although he met the SED criteria for depression to a marked degree based on hospital reports, “this has not been seen over a long period of time (i.e. at least six months) or to affect educational performance since he has not been in school post-diagnosis.” Based on this assessment, Ms. Hellwig recommended that the District develop a 504 plan for reasonable classroom accommodation to address STUDENT’s study skills and that VCBH determine STUDENT’s eligibility for mental health services as a community client.
On December 13, 1999, VCBH senior psychologist Dr. Leslie Singer conducted a psychological assessment of STUDENT and determined that he was eligible for outpatient mental health services pursuant to the IEP team’s AB 2726 mental health referral. She diagnosed STUDENT with depressive disorder NOS, impulse control disorder NOS, and parent-child conflict. OCD, by history, was to be ruled out. Dr. Singer recommended that STUDENT participate in outpatient individual and family therapy to address issues of family conflict. “An intensive, in-home intervention, such as Genesis, is recommended to reduce the ongoing conflict between STUDENT and his mother.” She noted that STUDENT’s MOTHER was not willing to have a therapist come into her home and did not believe outpatient services to be sufficient for STUDENT at this time. Dr. Singer also recommended social skills development for STUDENT, “as this has been an identified problem area for him.”
District Determination of Ineligibility as SED
On December 13, 1999, an IEP meeting was held. The District’s team members determined that STUDENT no longer met the criteria for SED, because he did “not demonstrate evidence of emotional disturbance at school which significantly impacts on his educational performance.” This recommendation was opposed by MOTHER, who faxed a request for a due process hearing to the Special Education Hearing Office that same day. Dr. Singer advised Ms. Hellwig that, based on the District’s determination that STUDENT was no longer eligible for special education, he did not meet the eligibility criteria for AB 2726 mental health services.
Determination of Eligibility as SED by Conejo Valley Unified School District (CVUSD)
On December 17, 1999, STUDENT admitted to vandalism and was released to his grandfather, GRANDFATHER. On January 18, 2000, STUDENT was declared a § 602 ward(Footnote 12) of the juvenile court, removed from his parents’ custody, and placed in the legal custody of his grandparents.
While living with his grandfather, STUDENT enrolled at Redwood Intermediate School within the CVUSD. At a February 4, 2000 review/transfer IEP meeting, the CVUSD IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education as SED. STUDENT was enrolled in eighth grade at Redwood for three days; however, a comprehensive middle school campus was determined not to be appropriate for him. Witnesses testified that they were told that STUDENT was removed from Redwood as a result of wearing a black trench coat reminiscent of the gunmen at Columbine High School and for advising a female student about “the right way” to commit suicide. From February 9 through February 29, 2000, STUDENT received one hour daily of home teaching from the CVUSD.
Sometime in late February 2000, STUDENT’s grandfather refused to continue to care for him and dropped him off at the office of his therapist, Mr. Lee.
Placement at Teton Peaks Residential Facility
On March 3, 2000, following his return to his mother’s care, STUDENT and his mother became involved in an argument regarding his curfew violations. STUDENT repeatedly punched his mother, then threw a can of chili at her, which struck her in the hand. STUDENT was taken into custody and formally charged with misdemeanor battery. On March 24, 2000, the juvenile court continued STUDENT as a ward and released him to MOTHER’s custody for placement through her private insurance at Teton Peaks Residential Treatment Center in Idaho. According to Dr. Harper, director of Teton Peak’s Behavior Health Center, this is a locked facility.
On March 27, 2000, STUDENT was admitted to a program at Teton Peaks described as being from six to nine months in length, with a focus on individual and family therapy, cognitive restructuring, anger management and social skills. His diagnoses on admission were oppositional defiant disorder, dysthymia, and parent/child conflict.(Footnote 13) On April 10, 2000, Teton Peaks staff developed a treatment plan for STUDENT. This plan did not address STUDENT’s education.
On April 27, 2000, STUDENT returned to Ventura from Teton Peaks.
District Determination of SED Eligibility Pending Further Assessment
On May 2, 2000, a transfer IEP meeting was held for STUDENT by the District. STUDENT’s MOTHER attended the IEP via a telephone conference call and was represented at the IEP by her attorney, Ms. Graham. STUDENT’s MOTHER advised the IEP team that, while at Teton Peaks, STUDENT had assaulted another student and was on the lowest level in behavior at the residence. STUDENT’s MOTHER wanted to inform the District that STUDENT could engage in violent behavior and she requested immediate placement for STUDENT in a residential facility.
Ms. Hellwig testified that, at the beginning of this IEP meeting, there was a presumption by District IEP team members that STUDENT was eligible as SED. However, that view changed following a telephone conference with Teton Peaks’ staff. The team was advised that, while at Teton Peaks, STUDENT was not reported to have engaged in any specific aggressive behavior or inappropriate sexual behavior. He displayed less problematic behavior than the other students in that setting. He was not on an active I.E.P. Although STUDENT was able to leave the campus several times a day, he did not attempt to go AWOL. The IEP team was informed that STUDENT was discharged because he did not display the targeted behavior. His treating physician and therapist recommended that STUDENT continue to receive individual and family therapy as an outpatient. They did not see a need for continued residential treatment. This information was corroborated at the hearing by the testimony of STUDENT’s therapist at Teton Peaks, Ms. Goff, and by Dr. Harper. Ms. Hellwig testified that, based on this information, the IEP team questioned STUDENT’s continuing eligibility.
STUDENT’s MOTHER disputed this information and advised the District that STUDENT’s case manager at Teton Peaks, Carrie Rodriguez, had told her about STUDENT’s violent act against a student. In MOTHER view, the failure to document this incident was a paperwork error by Teton Peaks. STUDENT’s MOTHER also disputed that STUDENT was discharged by Teton Peaks because he no longer need treatment. She believed that he was discharged only because her insurance denied ongoing payment.(Footnote 14) Ms. Goff testified that she provided STUDENT with weekly individual therapy and family counseling with his mother by telephone. In her opinion, STUDENT’s biggest problems at the facility were that he was argumentative and liked to engage in power struggles. STUDENT was discharged because he did not exhibit any clinically significant behavior. She was not aware of any assaultive behavior by STUDENT. Dr. Harper testified that the absence of a written incident report meant either that it did not occur or that it was not viewed by staff as serious. While at Teton Peaks, STUDENT consistently received high scores for meeting his daily behavior goals.
At the conclusion of the IEP meeting of May 2, 2000, STUDENT was determined to be eligible as SED, based upon CVUSD’s eligibility determination. Ms. Hellwig testified that the IEP team would have placed STUDENT in GATE classes at this time, if his mother had requested it. Instead, at MOTHER’s request, STUDENT was placed in De Anza’s SED-SDC for four periods, with two periods of regular education in P.E. and an elective.(Footnote 15) The team recommended a referral to VCBH for assessment for AB 2726 services, an updated assessment by the District, a referral to Phoenix Day Treatment Program, and a review of the placement by June 21, 2000, after completion of assessments. STUDENT’s MOTHER did not sign this IEP.
On May 4, 2000, STUDENT returned to De Anza, where he finished his eighth grade year. STUDENT was in Denise Abdun-Nur’s SED/SDC class for language arts, social studies, algebra and science for approximately five and a half weeks. There were eight other students in the class with one full-time aide. In order to access a higher level of math, STUDENT worked independently on algebra in the computer lab. He attended a technology class with Mr. Hughes. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, at MOTHER’s request, she gave STUDENT GATE material in language arts and social studies, which she copied from the GATE texts. Generally, STUDENT did GATE work or asked her for additional assignments. Because he was generally doing different work than the rest of the SED class, she or her aide would work with him individually. The only time STUDENT worked with the other students was in science, where she presented material with which he was not familiar. She gave him more work in science than the other SED students. STUDENT earned A’s and B’s during this trimester.
Shortly after his return to De Anza, STUDENT became involved in an ongoing conflict with peers outside the SED class that began with a name-calling incident and culminated in an alleged gun threat. STUDENT wore a gothic cross and black nail polish to school. A female student called STUDENT “gay” and he called her a “whore.” The girl’s boyfriend came to her defense. Because STUDENT was afraid he was going to get beaten up, one day he and a friend walked home instead of getting on the bus. The school was aware of MOTHER’s concerns about STUDENT’s runaway attempts and, once it was known that he left campus, he was picked up and driven home by the school psychologist. Shortly after this, rumors began that STUDENT threatened to bring a gun and shoot the girl. The girl told STUDENT that if he brought a gun, she would bring one and shoot him first. The boyfriend told STUDENT he would stab him if he didn’t leave his girlfriend alone. This incident was investigated by the Ventura police and the school administration. Several mediation sessions were conducted and the situation was successfully resolved. The only student punished was the boyfriend, who received a suspension based upon his threat to STUDENT.
On May 18, 2000, STUDENT was hit by a car while riding his bicycle in the community. STUDENT’s MOTHER believed this to be a suicide attempt. STUDENT denied that it was. As a result of his injuries, STUDENT was taken out of his P. E. class. He became a teaching assistant in an art class.
On June 2, 2000, Dr. Vivian wrote a letter which indicated that he had resumed psychiatric medication management for STUDENT and that there was “ongoing severe conflict and low level violence in the home again since STUDENT returned home 4/00. He may require placement out of the home for safety of self and family if he cannot be stabilized by reinstitution of medication.”
On June 6, 2000, social worker Barbara Kellner conducted VCBH’s second AB 2726 assessment on STUDENT. As part of this assessment, VCBH psychiatrist Dr. Shawn Crombie diagnosed STUDENT with an obsessive compulsive disorder, bipolar II disorder, most recent hypomanic, and parent-child conflict. In Ms. Kellner’s interview with STUDENT, he reported “that school was going very well for him. He wants to stay and finish the school year at De Anza; and he hopes to attend the high school in the fall.” STUDENT “reported that he spends a lot of time out of the house to avoid conflict.... He reports that he has friends that he has maintained over time.” For her assessment, Ms. Kellner relied on the written classroom observations of VCBH social worker Debbie Allen, who provided mental health services in the SED class at De Anza. Ms. Allen reported that STUDENT’s behavior is “appropriate most of the time.” Ms. Allen concluded that, if STUDENT were not graduating on to high school, “the teachers and administration would welcome him to continue attending De Anza. The teachers and administration at De Anza believe that he would be best served by attending Gate classes with on-site mental health support in high school.”
Ms. Kellner concluded that STUDENT “meets the qualifying criteria for Chapter 26.5/AB2726 services. STUDENT needs mental health services in order to benefit from his educational plan. At times, acting out behaviors interfere with his ability to focus on and participate in his school program. STUDENT is a very bright and artistically talented youngster who has demonstrated abilities to do well in GATE classes. STUDENT is a very good candidate for therapeutic intervention.” Ms. Kellner recommended family therapy to assist in the reduction of conflict; individual therapy “to assist STUDENT in developing appropriate problem solving skills to reduce acting out behaviors” and psychiatric medication evaluation and monitoring.
On June 9, 2000, Ms. Hellwig, in consultation with Ms. Schoenwald, conducted her second psycho-educational assessment of STUDENT in order to “re-determine his educational needs and appropriate placement following psychiatric problems at home and in the community.” Ms. Hellwig concluded that STUDENT did not continue to meet the eligibility requirements for a student with emotional disturbance. Although “behaviors of much concern remain in the home and community settings,” STUDENT’s “achievement, attention, and concentration appear to be consistently good in school,” both at the time of the assessment and “for his entire attendance at De Anza.” Ms. Hellwig again recommended that a Section 504 plan be developed with reasonable classroom accommodations to address STUDENT’s study skills and that county mental health determine his eligibility for county mental health services.
On June 13, 2000, the IEP team again met. Ms. Hellwig reviewed her recent assessment of STUDENT and her conclusion that he was not SED eligible. After STUDENT’s MOTHER expressed her concern that STUDENT was able to act appropriately for a short time, the District members of the IEP team decided to defer the decision on STUDENT’s eligibility and to extend the assessment period into the fall. The District proposed that an independent assessment be conducted. The team indicated that a review would occur by December 2000 and that stay put remained in effect. STUDENT’s MOTHER disagreed with the decision not to find STUDENT eligible at this time. STUDENT was placed in SED-SDC for three periods each day, and three periods of general education daily. Mental health AB 2726 services were to be provided pursuant to a treatment plan. The District recommended a referral to Genesis, an intensive six week in-home family therapy service.
On June 23, 2000, STUDENT was placed in juvenile court custody for failing to obey his court-ordered curfew. On June 26, 2000, another IEP meeting was conducted at MOTHER’s request. STUDENT’s MOTHER reported that STUDENT was running away three times a week. STUDENT was taken into protective custody by his probation officer after he called to report that he was in danger in his home. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that STUDENT called to report danger after she gave him a minor punishment for misbehavior. According to the IEP summary, STUDENT’s MOTHER reported that STUDENT was suicidal and homicidal and had been assaultive to her, to his baby sister, and to his stepfather. She did not report these incidents to STUDENT’s probation officer because “she does not want him removed by probation. She wants him placed through the school district.” No changes were made to STUDENT’s placement or services. STUDENT’s MOTHER rejected both Genesis services and placement at Phoenix Day Treatment Program. Based upon “the emergency nature” of MOTHER’s concern, the District requested that the independent assessment proceed sooner than originally planned. STUDENT’s MOTHER signed an assessment plan, subject to her agreement on an independent assessor.
On June 29, 2000, STUDENT appeared before the juvenile court on charges of violating probation. The court removed STUDENT from his parents’ care and placed him in the care of the probation officer “for placement in a suitable open placement.” In mid-July 2000, STUDENT was placed at Helicon Youth Center Residential Treatment Center in Riverside, California, by Ventura County Probation.
On July 5, 2000, the Special Education Hearing Office was advised by Petitioner to place the due process hearing back on calendar.(Footnote 16)
In July 2000, the parties agreed that the independent assessment of STUDENT would be conducted by Ray Easler, Ph.D., school psychologist with the Riverside SELPA. In his assessment, Dr. Easler acknowledged that STUDENT has experienced feelings of a depressive nature and has manifested obsessive compulsive behaviors and impulse control difficulties as reflected in his Diagnostic Statistical Manual, Fourth Edition (DMS-IV) diagnoses. In his opinion, however, “when looking at the extent to which the behaviors have adversely affected STUDENT’s educational performance, it appears that the behaviors have had little impact on his ability to learn or function in a public school setting when allowed to attend school....” His opinion that there was no adverse affect on STUDENT’s educational performance “is based upon his general grades of ‘A’s and ‘B’s in GATE, regular and special education classes and above grade level academic standard scores, commensurate with, or above, his cognitive ability standard scores.” Dr. Easler recommended that “consideration be given for the development of a 504 plan to accommodate any needs that STUDENT may have based upon his DSM-IV diagnoses in areas such as homework completion.”
On September 1, 2000, STUDENT was arrested by Ventura County Probation for violating probation.(Footnote 17) He was removed from Helicon and returned to juvenile detention in Ventura. On September 7, 2000, the court ordered that STUDENT “be placed in a similar placement with the same level of restriction” as Helicon.
On September 12, 2000, VCBH senior psychologist Dr. Fritz assessed STUDENT while he was at the juvenile detention center. She testified that STUDENT was an enjoyable young man who is bright, manipulative, a good historian, situationally depressed and presently psychologically stable. He would be challenging to caregivers when he does not get his way. She was not able to confirm a recent diagnosis that STUDENT is bipolar. In her opinion, STUDENT’s MOTHER has been a good advocate for STUDENT. However, due to the “ongoing, insidious, and now chronic problems” with the parent-child dyad, STUDENT would require extensive on-going individual and family therapy to resolve extreme family issues.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “child with a disability” is a child with mental retardation, hearing impairments, speech or language impairments, visual impairments, emotional disturbance, orthopedic impairments, autism, traumatic brain injury, other health impairments, or specific learning disabilities. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A). A student is eligible for special education and services when, as a result of the student’s disability, the student requires instruction, services or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56026(a) and (b). In determining eligibility for special education, a blanket exclusion based on a student’s high I.Q. is prohibited. Students who are intellectually gifted may be found eligible for special education if they otherwise meet the eligibility criteria. Letter to Ulissi (1992) 18 IDELR 683; Santa Ana Unified School District (1994) 21 IDELR 1189. The issue in this case is whether STUDENT was and is eligible for special education as SED.
Serious Emotional Disturbance (SED) Eligibility Criteria
A student meets the eligibility criteria as SED when, due to an emotional disturbance, he or she exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance:
(1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.
(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.
34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(i); Cal. Code Regs. Tit. 5, § 3030(i). California regulations add that any inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances must be “exhibited in several situations.” Cal.Code Regs. Tit. 5 § 3030(i)(3). A student does not meet special education eligibility criteria as SED, if he or she is “socially maladjusted,” unless it is determined that the student has an emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4)(ii).
Burden of Proof
Before determining that a pupil is no longer an individual with exceptional needs, the local educational agency is required to conduct an assessment of the pupil. Educ. Code § 56381(e); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(5). In this case, District has the burden of demonstrating that STUDENT no longer meets the SED eligibility criteria. To meet this burden, the District must demonstrate that there has been a change in circumstances sufficient to justify the conclusion that STUDENT is no longer eligible by (1) establishing that STUDENT does not meet any of the asserted qualifying criteria for a long time and to a marked degree, and (2) establishing that there was no adverse affect on STUDENT’s educational performance as a result of an emotional disturbance as manifested in one of the qualifying criteria.
Contentions of the Parties
Petitioner contends that he was and is currently eligible as SED because he exhibits an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers, exhibits inappropriate types of behaviors or feelings under normal circumstances, and has a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. According to Petitioner, his educational performance has been adversely affected because he has been unable to remain in school for more than a few months at a time due to his mental health issues, and because the District has modified his class work, grades and homework requirements during his attendance at De Anza.
The District does not dispute that STUDENT has clinical mental health diagnoses under the DSM-IV. Rather, it asserts that whatever psychological problems STUDENT has do not affect his educational performance as required by the definition of SED because he consistently has had high scores on standardized tests and good grades. The District further asserts that it is questionable whether STUDENT meets any of the SED qualifying characteristics. In seeking to exit STUDENT from special education, the District relies on the two psycho-educational assessments its school psychologist Lisa Hellwig conducted on STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year, as well as on the independent assessment of STUDENT conducted by Dr. Easler in August 2000. The District argues that STUDENT’s disability can be accommodated by a Section 504 plan with modifications in the regular or GATE classroom.
ANALYSIS
I. ISSUE ONE: Did STUDENT remain eligible for special education as SED during the 1999-2000 academic year?
Because STUDENT’s special education status and placement changed on multiple occasions during the 1999-2000 school year, it is not appropriate to analyze his continued eligibility as SED for the entire 1999-2000 school year. Rather, STUDENT’s eligibility must be analyzed in light of the assessments conducted by the District and the actions taken by the IEP team in response to those assessments at the time they were conducted. Accordingly, to facilitate analysis, the Hearing Officer has divided the eligibility periods as set forth below.
A. Was STUDENT eligible as SED from July 28, 1999 through December 13, 1999?
At the time he began his eighth grade year at De Anza on July 28, 1999, and continuing through September 24, 1999 when he left the District, STUDENT had an active IEP in the District which identified him as SED eligible. Although the District’s IEP team members had suggested to STUDENT’s MOTHER on several occasions that STUDENT be exited from special education and placed on a § 504 accommodation plan, the team made no formal recommendation to do so. Ms. Hellwig completed her first psycho-educational evaluation of STUDENT on December 10, 1999. Based upon that assessment, the District members of the IEP team first determined STUDENT to be ineligible on December 13, 1999. Because there had been no previous assessment indicating that STUDENT no longer qualified, there is no legal basis for redetermining STUDENT’s eligibility for the time period before the December assessment and decision by the IEP team. The District therefore cannot meet its burden of proof for this period. Based upon the agreed-upon eligibility determination of the IEP team, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was eligible as SED from July 28, 1999, through December 13, 1999. B. Was STUDENT eligible as SED from May 2, 2000 through June 15, 2000?
STUDENT remained eligible pursuant to the automatic provisions of stay put when STUDENT’s MOTHER filed her request for a due process hearing on December 13, 1999. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). On February 4, 2000, STUDENT was determined to be SED eligible by a different district, CVUSD. STUDENT attended school in CVUSD from February 9 through February 29, 2000. As previously indicated, STUDENT did not return to De Anza until May 2, 2000. At the time he transferred back into the District, he was SED eligible pursuant to CVUSD’s eligibility determination. This eligibility was affirmed at the District’s IEP meeting of May 2, 2000. STUDENT was again determined to be eligible for AB 2726 mental health services. Pursuant to the direction of the IEP team, Ms. Hellwig reassessed STUDENT and again concluded he was not SED eligible. When the IEP team met on June 13, 2000, however, it did not act on Ms. Hellwig’s assessment and did not make a formal finding that STUDENT was ineligible as SED based on her new assessment. Rather, it agreed to continue STUDENT’s eligibility and to expand the assessment period to allow an independent assessment in the fall. STUDENT was again placed in the SED class. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT remained eligible as SED from May 2, 2000, through June 15, 2000, the end of 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE 2: Is STUDENT currently SED eligible?
As discussed below, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District met its burden of establishing that STUDENT is not currently eligible as SED.
1. Does STUDENT exhibit “an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers,” to a marked degree, which has extended over a long period of time?
STUDENT was initially determined to be eligible as SED in the sixth grade based, in part, upon this factor. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not have friends and that his strongest attachments were to his toys. STUDENT’s therapist, Mr. Lee, testified that STUDENT talked about friendships “in an attachment disorder way.” In Mr. Lee’s opinion, these relationships were not deep connections, although they may have been relative to STUDENT’s experience. In Dr. Weinberg’s opinion, STUDENT met this qualifying criterion based upon information relating to his social problems contained in the records she reviewed. However, Dr. Weinberg also testified that she did not have information from STUDENT’s teachers about his relationships while at De Anza. The Hearing Officer therefore gives Dr. Weinberg’s opinion on this point significantly less weight.
In her December 1999 psycho-educational evaluation, Ms. Hellwig noted that STUDENT was slow to make new friends and wished he were different. Nonetheless, she concluded that STUDENT did not meet this qualifying criterion for SED because he had good rapport with most of his teachers and school staff. Although STUDENT’s social skills needed support, he had a few friends at school with whom he maintained relationships. She also indicated that STUDENT reported building friendships with peers during his hospitalizations. In Ms. Hellwig’s June 2000 re-assessment, STUDENT told her that he was making friends at De Anza and reported “feeling accepted and making friends for the first time in middle school.”
While STUDENT has historically had difficulties in social skills, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s social interactions at school have improved since the sixth grade, both by his own self-report and based on observations of teachers. During both of his assessments, STUDENT told Ms. Hellwig that he had friendships at De Anza. These statements were corroborated by the observations of his teachers and mental health staff (Ms. Lynch, Ms. Butler, Ms. Abdun-Nur, Ms. Allen and Ms. Kellner).
STUDENT’s GATE teacher, Ms. Butler, testified that STUDENT had friends, although his success with friends varied. Because the students in her GATE class were a clique which STUDENT had difficulty entering, he had fewer friends when he entered De Anza in the seventh grade. He started out a loner, then began some friendships. According to Ms. Butler, the GATE students did not like STUDENT because he failed to follow through on class group projects. By the time STUDENT returned to De Anza in the spring of 2000, however, he had a sizable group of about ten friends. This circle of friends, who were described as artistic or gothic students, were not GATE students. In Ms. Butler’s observation, STUDENT was the nucleus of this group, which formed within a week of his return to campus. As STUDENT’s teacher for approximately 5.5 months, Ms. Butler had the most opportunity of any of the witnesses to observe STUDENT’s relationships at school. The Hearing Officer finds her testimony to be persuasive.
Ms. Abdun-Nur also testified that STUDENT had positive relationships with peers in the spring of 2000. She testified that STUDENT had “a following,” particularly among girls. Ms. Abdun-Nur also described STUDENT as being at the center of the artistic group shortly after his return to campus.
STUDENT’s ability to maintain relationships with peers was affected by his school disruptions. As a result of his hospitalizations and court-ordered placements, STUDENT’s attendance at De Anza was divided into two brief blocks of time. Dr. Weinberg testified that simply interacting with peers does not mean that a student is able to form relationships, and that the quality of the relationship must be examined. She also testified that a student who is in a school setting for only one or two months might have difficulty in forming higher quality relationships. Dr. Easler testified that, in reviewing a student’s ability to maintain relationships, longer relationships would be expected the older a student became. Where there are multiple school disruptions, however, the focus should be on the student’s ability to form and develop relationships within the time period he or she is actually present rather than on the length of the relationships over time. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Easler’s analysis persuasive.(Footnote 18) In addition, STUDENT appears to have continued at least some friendships he had begun in the fall of 1999, based upon the quick formation of his circle of friends on his return to De Anza.
The evidence also established that STUDENT had the ability to both build and maintain relationships with teachers. Ms. Butler described her relationship with STUDENT as a teacher-student relationship which was mutually satisfying because they talked about issues which were “bigger than class.” During her time as STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Butler spent about five minutes each day after class with STUDENT and often walked with him to another class or area. Ms. Butler believed that STUDENT sought her opinion on issues. He showed her his poetry journal. Ms. Butler acknowledged that STUDENT cared about her so he tried to do well in her classes.(Footnote 19) In the spring of 2000, when STUDENT was in Ms. Abdun-Nur’s class, Ms. Butler observed STUDENT daily on the quad. STUDENT came to talk with her once every few weeks.
According to Ms. Abdun-Nur, STUDENT had positive relationships with teachers. Due to STUDENT’s high intelligence, Ms. Abdun-Nur took obvious delight in having STUDENT as her student and enjoyed their conversations. Ms. Abdun-Nur believed that she and STUDENT had a satisfactory relationship during the time he was in her class. She testified that having STUDENT in her class was like having a “college peer” with whom she could discuss issues. They spoke primarily about educational issues. For about ten percent of the time, STUDENT would talk to her about his distress outside the classroom. She would generally direct him to Ms. Allen to discuss personal problems.
The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT had the ability to both build and maintain relationships with teachers and that he was building relationships with peers. To qualify under this section, there must be a demonstrated inability to build or maintain relationships with peers and teachers. It has been noted that this is a very high standard. (Baldwin Park Unified School District, SN 931-97) To satisfy it, STUDENT’s difficulties in relationships must be with both peers and teachers. Because he had satisfactory relationships with teachers and was developing relation-ships with peers during the 1999-2000 school year, he does not meet this criterion for SED.
Based upon this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT does not have an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.
2. Does STUDENT exhibit “inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances,” to a marked degree, which have extended over a long period of time?
A. Inappropriate behaviors stemming from STUDENT’s obsessive compulsive disorder (OCD)
STUDENT has received multiple OCD diagnoses, beginning in April 1998 by Dr. Deamer, with the most recent diagnosis from VCBH’s Dr. Crombie in June 2000. Mr. Appleton relied heavily on STUDENT’s OCD diagnosis in initially determining that STUDENT qualified as SED under this category. In support of Petitioner’s contentions, Dr. Weinberg testified that STUDENT’s OCD continues to affect every aspect of his life. According to Dr. Weinberg, STUDENT’s obsession on every detail of his class work and homework has caused him to spend inordinate amounts of time doing his school work. This has resulted in the need for the District to modify STUDENT’s class work, to not give him homework, and to modify his grades so that he is graded only on tests and class work performed. Dr. Weinberg also testified that STUDENT’s OCD causes him anger and behavioral difficulties at school. This was manifested by STUDENT not sharing the floor in class which, in turn, led to social alienation. His anger was manifested at home in the daily “rages” which STUDENT’s MOTHER testified occurred due to stress from inability to complete his work. Based on these factors, Dr. Weinberg formed an opinion that STUDENT met this qualifying characteristic. Dr. Weinberg testified that she had not assessed STUDENT and did not know how often this type of behavior had occurred in STUDENT’s class work since March of 1999. The Hearing Officer gives little weight to Dr. Weinberg’s opinion as it relates to STUDENT’s functioning while at De Anza because she did not have current information from his teachers and staff.
The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s OCD did not cause him to spend an inordinate amount of time doing class work. In her December 10, 1999 psycho-educational assessment, Ms. Hellwig described STUDENT as “able to keep up with assignments although he continues to struggle with pacing himself (i.e., obsessing on details).” Nonetheless, he “passes classroom tests, shows superior cognitive ability scores, performs daily academic tasks at a satisfactory level, attempts activities which appear difficult, and shows consistent achievement across academic areas.” In her June 2000 psycho-educational assessment, Ms. Hellwig noted that, although STUDENT may take longer to complete his work, the quality of his work is considered ‘exceptional.’” Both Ms. Butler and Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, occasionally, STUDENT took more time on assignments than other students. According to Ms. Butler, this occurred more frequently when the assignment was artistic and STUDENT would become over-detailed. In general, however, Ms. Butler did not believe that STUDENT took an inordinate amount of time to do class work. She worked with him on this issue and his performance improved over time. Similarly, Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that STUDENT was generally able to follow through and complete class work. Because he did not like to follow rules, he was sometimes behind in his work but he was caught up on his work by the end of the year.(Footnote 20)
The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s grades were not modified based upon his homework accommodation in GATE classes. In Ms. Butler’s GATE classes, STUDENT was excused from all homework except for significant projects. Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT completed the significant projects in the same amount of time given to other students. She also testified that, at De Anza, practice homework was not included in academic grades and that, in any event, STUDENT completed about seventy-five percent of these practice assignments. Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT’s grades were not modified and that she occasionally graded him harder or expected him to complete a more lengthy paper because she knew his capabilities.
The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s OCD-type behaviors were not inappropriate or disruptive in his classes while he was at De Anza. In the five and a half months Ms. Butler had STUDENT in her GATE classes in 1999, STUDENT was generally “better than average” in behavior. Ms. Butler classified him on the low-end of a ten-point scale of inappropriate behavior during his attendance. Ms. Hellwig noted in her assessment that STUDENT “will occasionally interrupt class conversations to make his point and not notice other students becoming frustrated with him.” Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT was responsive to her social prompts about his monopolizing and interrupting behavior during class discussions and this behavior improved while he was in her class. She observed him to be occasionally frustrated but never angry. Similarly, Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, while STUDENT’s main behavioral issue in her class in May and June 2000 was that he loved to talk and dominate conversations, he learned to respond to her social prompts to “stop sharing.” Ms. Abdun-Nur would not call STUDENT a “serious interrupter.” In the SED/SDC class, STUDENT actually stimulated conversation among students who typically had a more difficult time getting interested in the subjects. According to Ms. Abdun-Nur, STUDENT’s behaviors were not inappropriate and he did not exhibit any substantial misconduct. She observed STUDENT to be occasionally upset but never very angry at school. This observation was corroborated by social worker Ms. Allen.
As to each of the behaviors addressed above, the Hearing Officer concludes that, to the extent they are attributable to STUDENT’s OCD, they were not exhibited “to a marked degree” in his classes.
STUDENT’s OCD behavior has historically affected his ability to complete his homework. For example, according to MOTHER, STUDENT spends seven hours at home to complete a twenty-minute assignment. Although the District has questioned STUDENT’s MOTHER credibility on this point, STUDENT has also acknowledged that he has problems with homework to Lisa Hellwig and to Dr. Easler.(Footnote 21) Not turning in homework was the reason STUDENT was originally removed from GATE classes in La Cumbre and, in part, formed the basis of his initial eligibility as SED. While STUDENT was capable of doing excellent work in his GATE classes, his obsessiveness has caused him severe stress and resulted in his being excused from all but significant homework assignments in Ms. Butler’s class. STUDENT was not required to do any homework in the brief time he was in Ms. Abdun-Nur’s class. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that she was advised not to give any homework to STUDENT unless STUDENT’s MOTHER requested it. The June 13, 2000 IEP indicated that STUDENT “was able to complete his assignments in class, but was not required to do homework in an attempt to not stress him and reduce obsessiveness.” The impact of STUDENT’s OCD behavior on his homework has been acknowledged for a long time and has, historically, manifested itself to a marked degree. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT continues to meet this criterion for SED, based upon his OCD behavior as it impacts upon his ability to do homework.
B. Inappropriate behaviors stemming from STUDENT’s impulse control disorder
STUDENT has been diagnosed with impulse control disorder on multiple occasions, beginning in October 1999 by Dr. Vivian and most recently by Dr. Singer in December 1999. Dr. Singer concluded that STUDENT’s overall profile shows a “high risk of impulsive and self-destructive behavior” as a result of which “STUDENT could be expected to act out in unpredictable circumstances, placing him at greater risk.”
Petitioner argues that STUDENT met this qualifying characteristic because he exhibited inappropriate behaviors of chronic running away and impulsivity. According to Petitioner, these inappropriate behaviors have been manifested at school in (1) his leaving school without permission (AWOLs) in 1998 and, again, in May 2000, when he walked home instead of getting on the bus; (2) in his May 2000 “threat” to kill another student, which STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that STUDENT admitted to her; (3) in his May 2000 bike accident, an impulsive act that caused him serious injury; and (4) in his exclusion from CVUSD comprehensive campus in February 2000 for instructing female students how to commit suicide.
The evidence does not support a finding of inappropriate behavior by STUDENT based on his leaving school without permission. The incident at De Anza on which Petitioner relies occurred in May 2000, during the time of the name-calling incident and before the alleged gun threat. STUDENT reported that he decided to walk home because he believed he might get beaten up. The evidence supports a finding that this action was in response to a conflict with peers, not as a result of an emotional disturbance. In addition, the Hearing Officer notes that over two years elapsed between STUDENT’s AWOL from La Cumbre (March 1998) and this episode. As a result, STUDENT’s behavior of leaving school without permission did not occur to a marked degree.(Footnote 22)
There is insufficient corroborating evidence to support a finding that STUDENT threatened to kill a student in May 2000. The evidence demonstrated that the allegation that STUDENT had made such a threat was taken seriously and resulted in an investigation by both the local police and the school administration. STUDENT admitted the name-calling to the police but not the threat. Unlike the other male student involved in this episode, STUDENT was never disciplined as a result of this incident.
Petitioner argues that his bicycle accident supports a finding of inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances. Dr. Weinberg testified, that, regardless of whether or not STUDENT’s bicycle accident was a suicidal gesture, it was an impulsive act because he did not look for traffic. The Hearing Officer concludes that, even if this act were attributable to his impulse control disorder, this single incident of inappropriate impulsive behavior does not meet the requirement that the behavior be exhibited to a marked degree over a long period of time.
Petitioner asserts that his behavior in February 2000 which led to his exclusion from CVUSD’s comprehensive campus qualifies him under this category. There was no testimony from any one with personal knowledge about the reasons for STUDENT’s exclusion from this campus. No documents from CVUSD were introduced which directly discussed the underlying factual basis for placing STUDENT on home teaching. Rather, all information provided to the Hearing Officer was based on second-hand or third-hand reports. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer can make no factual determination about the reason STUDENT was removed from CVUSD, and this information cannot be the basis of a finding of inappropriate behavior. Even if this information were true, however, this single behavioral incident does not meet the “marked degree” requirement, particularly in light of STUDENT’s subsequent predominantly positive behaviors at De Anza.
Finally, the evidence demonstrated that STUDENT has experienced episodes of running away, suicidal ideation and suicide attempts, hospitalization and interaction with the juvenile court system. In his closing briefs, Petitioner does not argue that these episodes were instances which would qualify as “inappropriate types of behaviors and feelings under normal circumstances.” Nonetheless, Dr. Weinberg testified that STUDENT met this criterion due to his repetitive running away, ending up on the freeway, and hospitalizations. The record persuasively demonstrates that these episodes were caused by STUDENT’s conflict with his parent. The Hearing Officer notes that the series of hospitalizations which led to STUDENT’s leaving De Anza in the fall of 1999 occurred at a time when he was experiencing a newborn sibling, a new father-figure, contact with a biological father he had not seen in nine years, as well as ongoing and escalating conflicts with MOTHER.(Footnote 23) The record is replete with comments from STUDENT to professionals, both inside and outside the District, about his extreme anger and alienation from his family and his desire for independence. These include STUDENT’s recent comment to Dr. Easler that “my mother had a child I didn’t want my mom to have. She has hooked me up with an attorney I didn’t want, to find an agency to put me in a place I don’t need to be...Her purpose is to lock me up, but I prefer to be here rather than at home.” While STUDENT’s MOTHER suggested that STUDENT has difficulty telling the truth, many assessors, including both Dr. Easler and Dr. Fritz, have found STUDENT to be an accurate historian who is willing to describe problems he is experiencing.
3. Does STUDENT exhibit “a general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression,” to a marked degree which has extended over a long period of time?
STUDENT has been clinically diagnosed with depression since April 1998, when Dr. Deamer first diagnosed him with major depression, single episode. Since that time, he has had multiple depression-related diagnoses and has most recently been diagnosed as situationally depressed by Dr. Fritz. STUDENT has taken anti-depressive medication with some regularity since 1998. Based on these diagnoses, Dr. Weinberg testified that STUDENT has met this criterion over a long period of time and to a marked degree.
In her December 1999 psycho-educational assessment, Ms. Hellwig noted that STUDENT’s MOTHER rated STUDENT in the “clinically significant” range on the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC) in numerous areas, including aggression and depression. STUDENT rated himself in the clinically significant range in sensation seeking, locus of control, and relations with parents, but not depression. Ms. Butler did not rate STUDENT as clinically significant in any area on the BASC. She rated STUDENT in the “at risk” (potential problems) range in several areas, including depression and withdrawal. Ms. Hellwig indicated that STUDENT did not appear depressed or report any of the symptoms of depression during the assessment. “He did appear unhappy in that he expressed desire for more control over his life and making decisions in his family.” She concluded that STUDENT met the SED criterion for depression to a marked degree based on hospital reports, but that this depression has not been seen over a long period of time. In her June 2000 assessment, Ms. Hellwig did not find that STUDENT demonstrated a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression because he did not appear to be depressed and did not report any symptoms of depression. STUDENT did, however, “appear frustrated in that he wanted more control over decisions affecting his life, and he expressed a strong desire for independence.” The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Hellwig’s determinations that STUDENT had not met this qualifying criterion for a long time or to a marked degree were erroneous in light of Dr. Deamer’s April 1998 diagnosis and STUDENT’s ongoing depression diagnoses and medication regimen.
STUDENT was not described as manifesting his depression at De Anza. Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT’s general demeanor in her classes at De Anza was “cheerful” with “no feeling of moroseness.” Like all children, STUDENT “had bummed out moments.” Ms. Butler was aware that STUDENT was occasionally upset about teasing or other school issues. On three or four occasions, STUDENT told her he was having a bad day. Ms. Butler testified that they talked about “leaving it at the door” and these incidents did not interfere with STUDENT’s educational performance. Ms. Abdun-Nur described STUDENT’s typical mood in her class as easygoing. He did not appear depressed. She described him as being “like sunshine,” and as a very charismatic individual who “lifts the spirits of everyone around him.” Ms. Abdun-Nur had observed STUDENT to be upset, particularly in the mornings, due to conflicts at home or on the way to school. On these occasions, Ms. Abdun-Nur generally referred STUDENT to social worker Debbie Allen to discuss his emotional issues. Because Ms. Allen did not arrive at class until after the first period, STUDENT would have to wait until after first period to talk with Ms. Allen. According to Ms. Abdun-Nur, STUDENT was able to handle his emotions when upset. He was responsive to her directions to do his work until the social worker arrived.
To satisfy this qualifying criterion, the depressed mood must be “pervasive.” This requirement means that the unhappiness or depressed mood must be exhibited in the major areas of the student’s life, including his or her home, school and community. Dr. Easler initially testified that STUDENT’s diagnosis of major depression disorder alone would not satisfy this criterion because the depression was not manifested at home, at school and in the community. Dr. Easler subsequently testified, however, that STUDENT has had depression for a long time and to a marked degree based upon Dr. Deamer’s April 1998 diagnosis and the fact that STUDENT has been taking medication for depression within the last few months.
It is without question that STUDENT has been affected with depression in both the home and the community. Although neither Ms. Butler nor Ms. Abdun-Nur described STUDENT as “depressed” at school, they each observed him to have episodes of being upset. Both teachers were aware that STUDENT was occasionally teased by peers. Ms. Butler was aware of STUDENT’s social isolation and difficulty with peers when he first arrived at De Anza. While in Ms. Abdun-Nur’s class, STUDENT had occasions when he had to wait for Ms. Allen’s arrival to discuss his feelings. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT met this qualifying characteristic based upon these facts, as well as on Dr. Easler’s testimony that STUDENT had experienced a pervasive mood of depression which existed over a long period of time and to a marked degree.
4. Did any of the qualifying characteristics which STUDENT met “adversely affect” his “educational performance”?
To summarize, the Hearing Officer has concluded that, over a long period of time and to a marked degree, STUDENT met the SED-qualifying characteristics for (1) inappropriate behaviors under normal circumstances, based upon his OCD behavior as it impacts upon his homework; and (2) a pervasive mood of depression, based upon his extensive diagnoses of depression and his medication regimen for depression. The critical inquiry in this case is whether these qualifying characteristics had an “adverse affect” on STUDENT’s “educational performance.” To resolve this question, it is necessary to know what degree of adverse affect is legally required for SED eligibility.
Dr. Easler testified that two tests must be met to demonstrate an adverse affect on educational performance. First, the student must not be receiving credit for his or her course work. This would be shown if the student did not pass from grade to grade. Second, there must be a discrepancy between a student’s ability and his or her achievement. In Dr. Easler’s opinion, adverse affect on educational performance is shown when a student experiences two semesters of all D’s and F’s and has standard scores not commensurate with his or her ability. In his opinion, “educational performance” encompasses a student’s academics, standard scores, ability to interact with peers and adults, and ability to act in structured and unstructured settings in and out of class in a school setting. Dr. Weinberg testified that “educational performance” is broader than mere academics. In her opinion, continuing educational and social disruption and the need for modifications in school suffice to demonstrate “adverse affect.”
Dr. Easler’s opinion that two semesters of all D or F grades are necessary to show adverse affect was based upon “best practice” of school psychologists in the United States. He acknowledged that there was no statutory or regulatory basis for this definition of adverse affect. The Hearing Officer concludes that neither state nor federal law support the notion that the “adverse affect on educational performance” required for SED eligibility must be this extreme.
There is no federal statutory or regulatory interpretation of “adverse affect.” In 1989, the Office of Special Education Programs (OSEP) was asked to provide guidance on what the term “adversely affects educational performance” means in the context of identifying SED students. In its administrative interpretation, OSEP indicated that this term is subject to a variety of interpretations by the states. “In reference to SED children and youth, States typically include within the parameters of educational performance those elements which are of specific educational concern to the school, which are reflected in the school’s curriculum and which generally receive some type of formal rating. While some States do provide additional procedures and guidance related to [this term]...[its] application to a particular child continues to be based largely on the unique facts, and circumstances of the particular case.”
While some states have enacted specific regulations defining “adverse affect on educational performance,” California has not done so. In California, it has been noted that “there is no qualifying language to indicate that any more than some adverse effect is needed to satisfy this criterion....However, there is reason to believe that the adverse effect required by the regulation must have a significant impact on the student’s educational standing.” Student v. Hemet Unified School District and Riverside County Mental Health Department, SN 550-91 [interpreting identical federal language (Villmoare)].
The Hearing Officer concludes that a “significant impact” on a student’s educational standing must be present to demonstrate “adverse affect.” That impact must be determined in light of the unique facts of each case, however, rather than by a rigid rule of all D’s or F’s for two semesters as suggested by Dr. Easler. Nonetheless, a review of STUDENT’s educational performance indicates that it has not been adversely affected by his OCD or his depression.
STUDENT’s Standard Scores
A comparison of STUDENT’s Woodcock-Johnson scores from 1998 and 2000 does not reflect that there has been an adverse affect on his educational performance as a result of emotional disturbance. In 1998, when he was initially qualified as SED, STUDENT tested at a 16.9 grade level in both broad reading (SS=170, 99.9%) and broad written language (SS=198, 99.9 %). He tested at the 11.6 grade level in broad math (SS=148, 99.9%). STUDENT’s scores in July 2000 reveal that he is currently at the 16.9 level in all three areas. There was some variation in STUDENT’s standard scores.(Footnote 24) While STUDENT’s standard score in broad math declined five points, his grade equivalent increased five years from a 11.6 in 1998 to a 16.9 in 2000. STUDENT’s score on broad written expression declined 20 points; however, he remained at the 16.9 grade equivalent level. While STUDENT’s writing score decreased, the fact that STUDENT remained at the 16.9 grade equivalent demonstrates that there was not a significant adverse affect on his writing. In addition, STUDENT’s excellence as a writer was underscored by Ms. Butler’s testimony that he was the best writer she has taught out of approximately 1600 students.
STUDENT’s Grades and Homework Accommodation
STUDENT’s grades at De Anza were predominantly above average. For the third trimester of seventh grade in the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT received grades of B+ in both his GATE science and U.S. history classes, an A in his GATE language arts class, a B in advanced band, an A+ in computers/communication and a C in math. During this trimester, STUDENT received an outstanding citizenship grade in computers. His teacher, Ms. Lynch, commented that STUDENT was doing excellent work, had excellent behavior, and was above grade level ability. STUDENT received all satisfactory citizenship grades in his GATE classes. Ms. Butler commented that he was above grade level ability in language arts. In the one class in which he received a C, his teacher, Ms. Castro, commented that STUDENT was “at grade level ability.” STUDENT received “needs improvement” citizenship grades in both band and math.
For the first trimester of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT received an A+ in GATE language arts, and A grades in both his GATE U.S. history and science classes. Ms. Butler gave STUDENT an outstanding citizenship grade and commented that he was doing excellent work in language arts. STUDENT received an A+ in his algebra class and a “needs improvement” responsibility grade.
STUDENT received two below-average grades during this trimester. STUDENT received a D in advanced band and a “needs improvement” in responsibility. His band teacher, Mr. Zelinka, commented that STUDENT was not completing assignments or projects, which meant that he was not playing his part well. Mr. Zelinka testified that STUDENT was respectful and polite in class, and liked to talk to his neighbors. STUDENT received an F in his study skills class with Ms. Myers, an unsatisfactory citizenship grade and comments that he was not completing assignments and not bringing books to class. Ms. Myers testified that the purpose of her study skills class is to teach resource students about taking notes, doing homework, and basic organizational skills. STUDENT was not a resource student and, in her opinion, did not belong in the class. Her students were on a low level and did work as a group. Because STUDENT was at a much higher level, he did his own work and refused to do the class work. Ms. Myers testified that STUDENT’s behavior in class was not bad; he simply was not responsible in doing what he was asked.
STUDENT’s grades for the third trimester of the 1999-2000 school year at De Anza were above average. All of his responsibility grades were satisfactory. He received A’s in language arts and social studies. He received a B+ in science and B grades in algebra and social studies.(Footnote 25) He did “A-level” work in Mr. Hughes’ technology class and was described by his teacher as “exceptional” in describing the geometry of what makes a good bridge.(Footnote 26)
The argument is made that STUDENT’s homework modification adversely affected his educational performance by artificially inflating his grades. Without that accommodation, his grades would have been lower and would have demonstrated adverse affect. Under the facts of this case, the Hearing Officer rejects this argument. Although it is true that STUDENT was not required to do practice homework in Ms. Butler’s class, she testified that, at De Anza, academic grades were not modified for STUDENT or for any other student based on practice homework. Completion of homework was considered as part of the responsibility grade. As a result, the only grade impacted by this accommodation was the responsibility grade. While it is possible that STUDENT’s responsibility grade was inflated, Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT completed a large percentage of practice homework anyway. Both Ms. Butler and Dr. Easler testified that the fact that STUDENT could earn such high academic grades in his GATE classes without doing the practice homework suggested that he did not need the homework to learn the curriculum. In addition, two District school psychologists, as well as Dr. Easler, testified that any homework issues STUDENT had as a result of his OCD could be accommodated via a §504 plan. Dr. Easler testified that the mere fact that modifications have been instituted so a student can perform in class and attain A and B grades does not mean that the student’s educational performance has been adversely affected. For example, a student study team can suggest modifications and, if these are successful, the student is not assessed for special education.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s grades during the 1999-2000 school year do not demonstrate that he suffered an adverse affect on his educational performance due to any of the qualifying characteristics. Based upon Ms. Myers’ testimony, STUDENT’s F grade in study skills appears to be the result of a conscious decision on his part. Viewed in context, STUDENT’s substandard grades in band and study skills do not demonstrate that he experienced an adverse affect on his educational performance based on either depression or OCD behavior.
Educational Disruption
Dr. Weinberg testified that the amount of time STUDENT was unable to attend school due to his emotional problems affected his educational performance because “being educated is part of educational performance.” She also agreed that (1) a child with a DMS-IV diagnosis was not necessarily SED eligible; (2) that a child with a DMS-IV diagnosis who required hospitalization for the DMS-IV condition would not automatically be SED eligible; and (3) that STUDENT’s DMS-IV diagnoses and hospitalizations alone do not automatically render him SED eligible. In Dr. Weinberg’s opinion, however, the more times a student is hospitalized and the more diagnoses he or she is given, the more likely the student will be able to qualify as SED because this history is very significant.
The extent of educational disruption experienced by STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year is very troubling. It is reasonable to assume that repeated disruption in school attendance due to an emotional disturbance would inherently result in an adverse affect on a student’s educational performance. That assumption has particular appeal where, as in this case, those disruptions resulted in the student attending the District’s school for only a two-month period at the beginning and for under a two-month period at the end of the academic year. Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer concludes that educational disruption alone does not result in an adverse affect on educational performance. The statutory phrase itself demands that the student’s educational performance be examined to see how the emotional disturbance is affecting the student’s ability to function in school.
The Hearing Officer has found one California case which concluded that “it is certain that a pupil cannot receive educational benefit if he cannot attend classes.” Berkeley Unified School District (1987) EHLR 509:197. The Hearing Officer in that case determined that, “notwith-standing the [student’s] demonstrated high academic achievements, his condition adversely affects his educational performance.” In that case, however, the student ran away from home and stopped attending school due to emotional disturbance. As a result, his grades had deteriorated from A’s and B’s to receiving no credits due to nonattendance. At the time of the hearing, the student should have been advancing to the twelfth grade, but had only received a portion of his tenth-grade credits.
In this case, there is no contention that STUDENT lost academic credits due to his educational disruptions. The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT passed from the eighth grade to the ninth grade. In addition, STUDENT attended school in his different placements.(Footnote 27) STUDENT received above average grades in each of these schools except for one C grade in world history while he was at San Dieguito. No grade information was provided regarding Teton Peaks or Helicon. In Doe v. Board of Education of the State of Connecticut , 753 F. Supp. 65 (D.Conn. 1990), a gifted student suffered an emotional deterioration which led to his hospitalization for a period of approximately four months. His parents sought to have him determined eligible for special education as SED and unilaterally placed him in a residential facility. In affirming the hearing officer’s determination that the student was not eligible, the court concluded that the student’s “academic performance (both his grades and his achievement test results) before, during, and after his hospitalization were satisfactory or above.” Id. At 69. In this case, STUDENT’s grades were generally above average before, during and after his various placements. While there is no doubt that the continuity of his curriculum suffered due to his educational disruptions, the evidence presented did not demonstrate that he suffered an adverse affect on his educational performance as a result.
Since attending De Anza, STUDENT attended summer school for approximately one month while residing at Helicon Youth Center. His classes were poetry, P.E. and math. His therapist, Kelly Washam, testified that school was the one area at Helicon where STUDENT excelled and he was actually good the entire time. To her knowledge, STUDENT was given homework daily and completed it, although she did not know if he was given time in class to do it. She was not made aware of any ‘rages’ by STUDENT regarding completing his homework.(Footnote 28) The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s ability to function appropriately at school in Helicon was consistent with his generally positive performance at De Anza during the 1999-2000 school year. This conclusion is supported by the MMPI-A administered to STUDENT by Dr. Easler while STUDENT was at Helicon. While STUDENT had many clinically-elevated scores on this assessment, his scores on the Adolescent School Problems subscale were in the normal range. Dr. Easler noted that this “relatively low score...would suggest that STUDENT does not perceive himself as experiencing school difficulties to a greater degree than the average adolescent his age. This appears to be supported by the school records.”
In summary, based upon the District’s two assessments, the independent assessment of Dr. Easler, and on Dr. Fritz’ testimony that STUDENT is presently psychologically stable, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has met its burden of establishing that STUDENT is not currently eligible for special education as SED.
ORDER
1. The District shall convene an IEP meeting no later than December 11, 2000, to exit STUDENT from special education consistent with the findings of this decision.
2. Case SN 1943-99B may proceed on issues arising out of STUDENT’s SED eligibility during the 1999-2000 school year. Unless the parties advise the Hearing Office by no later than December 13, 2000 of the dates on which they have agreed to put this matter back on calendar, the Hearing Office will calendar SN 1943-99B for the next available hearing dates.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
On the first issue (1999-2000): the Student prevailed.
On the second issue (current eligibility), the District prevailed.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 21, 2000 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: After she filed a request for a due process hearing, Petitioner’s mother changed her name from MOTHER to MOTHER. To avoid confusion, she will be referred to throughout this decision as MOTHER.
Footnote 2: When the federal IDEA was amended in 1997, the term “serious emotional disturbance” was changed to “emotional disturbance,” and the federal regulations embody this change. See: 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). The California special education regulation still uses the term “serious emotional disturbance” (See: Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i)) and that term will be used in this decision.
Footnote 3: Issues identified regarding whether VCBH should be dismissed as a party following STUDENT’s placement at Helicon by Ventura County Probation and whether STUDENT’s MOTHER should be dismissed for lack of standing following the June 29, 2000 juvenile court order removing STUDENT from her legal custody were addressed by the Hearing Officer in the summary order dated August 21, 2000.
Footnote 4: On August 10, 2000, the Hearing Office received the District’s written motion, which was opposed by the Petitioner. VCBH joined in this motion. No response was received from VCOE. On August 21, 2000, the Hearing Officer ruled that this motion would be addressed by the parties at the first day of hearing.
Footnote 5: The parties prepared a joint statement of issues at the outset of the hearing. The Hearing Officer has modified their articulation of the issues to facilitate proper analysis.
Footnote 6: STUDENT attended the District’s Junipero Serra Elementary School for his first and second grade. According to teacher Anne Wilson, he was reading at a high school level when he entered the first grade. STUDENT’s GATE recommendation was based on his Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills (CTBS) scores which were in the 99th percentile in reading and the 88th percentile in math and on his 99+ percentile score on the RAVEN assessment.
Footnote 7: On the Woodcock Johnson Achievement Test given for this assessment, STUDENT scored at the 99.9th percentile in broad reading, broad written language and in broad math. Mr. Appleton testified that achievement was not an area of need for STUDENT. Rather, the focus of his IEP was on his behavior and following the rules.
Footnote 8: In October 1998, STUDENT attended the District’s Cabrillo Middle School, pursuant to an intra-district transfer from De Anza, for eight days. This did not work out to the parent’s satisfaction and STUDENT returned to La Cumbre.
Footnote 9: A second transfer IEP meeting was scheduled on June 15, 1999, which STUDENT’s MOTHER was not able to attend and did not sign. On the IEP prepared for this meeting, STUDENT’s eligibility and placement was unchanged, except that DIS counseling services were to be provided “as needed.” The District members of the IEP team discussed exiting STUDENT from special education with a Section 504 accommodation plan at this meeting.
Footnote 10: Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, which is codified at California Government Code §§ 7570 - 7588, Chapter 26.5, describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or enacted provisions of this chapter.
Footnote 11: Ms. Hellwig has been a school psychologist for four years. Ms. Schoenwald has been a school psychologist for 22 years. They testified that the District has a policy of consultation between psychologists in all cases of determining SED eligibility. Ms. Hellwig spent approximately ten hours observing and talking to STUDENT for this evaluation. She also had extensive contact with MOTHER.
Footnote 12: Pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code § 602, any person who is under the age of 18 years old when he or she violates any criminal law is within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge the person to be a ward of the court.
Footnote 13: Because no records were provided to the District or the Hearing Officer from Teton Peaks, it is unclear if this diagnosis was based on a new assessment or from information or records provided by the parent. Ms. Schoenberg testified that the District attempted to obtain STUDENT’s records from Teton Peaks pursuant to a release of information signed by STUDENT’s MOTHER on May 2, 2000. STUDENT’s MOTHER wrote on the release that no personal communications from STUDENT to his therapist were to be released. Ms. Schoenberg testified that she later spoke to Teton Peak’s records clerk and was informed that STUDENT’s MOTHER told Teton Peaks that no records were to be released.
Footnote 14: Ms. Goff testified that she was advised the insurance refused to continue funding at Teton Peaks because STUDENT’s MOTHER was not participating in family therapy, either in person or by video-conferencing. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified she was in the process of purchasing a video-conference machine when notified of the termination of funding.
Footnote 15: Three goals were provided for STUDENT. In academics, STUDENT was to “complete his assignments and turn them in on a timely basis.” He was also to “learn to pace himself with assignments based on time increments allotted by the teacher.” STUDENT’s social and emotional goal was as follows: “In special education class, STUDENT will appropriately express his emotions using the resources available to him (e.g., mental health therapist, decision room).”
Footnote 16: The hearing was taken off-calendar by Petitioner on December 21, 1999. Thereafter, it was re-calendared on March 21, 2000 and taken off-calendar on March 28, 2000. On July 19, 2000, the parties agreed to continue the Hearing until August 22-23, 2000.
Footnote 17: STUDENT was charged with being AWOL, intimidating another resident and engaging in inappropriate sexual activity with residents. One count of sexually inappropriate behavior was dismissed and STUDENT admitted the remaining counts.
Footnote 18: There is also evidence that STUDENT consciously selected his friends. For example, Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT did not maintain lasting friendships in the GATE class and Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that STUDENT did not have friendships in her SED class. According to Dr. Easler, the fact that STUDENT had no friends in these classes, but did have friends in the “artistic” group outside these classes, demonstrates that STUDENT chooses his friends. It does not demonstrate an inability in this realm.
Footnote 19: For example, Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT had a math teacher who was very rigid. Ms. Butler believed STUDENT performed differently for her than the math teacher because he liked her.
Footnote 20: In her June 9, 2000 letter to Ms. Kellner for STUDENT’s AB 2726 assessment, Ms. Allen indicated that “STUDENT... may take longer than other [SED] students to complete assignments.” This observation was contradicted by Ms. Abdun-Nur. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Abdun-Nur’s testimony more persuasive on this point. Ms. Allen was not responsible for teaching in the SED class. There is no indication from her letter or testimony what subject was being taught when she made this observation. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, except for science which presented new material for STUDENT, he was generally working on GATE level material independent from her other SED students. Without a context, therefore, Ms. Allen’s observation carries little weight on this point.
Footnote 21: The Hearing Officer notes that, in discussing Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, the DMS-IV states that “children generally do not request help, and...[m]ore often the problem is identified by parents, who bring the child in for treatment. Gradual declines in schoolwork secondary to impaired ability to concentrate have been reported. Like adults, children are more prone to engage in rituals at home than in front of peers, teachers, or strangers” p. 420 [emphasis added]. As acknowledged by Dr. Weinberg, it is possible that STUDENT’s power struggles with STUDENT’s MOTHER accounted for the extra time he spent on homework. This possibility is reinforced by MOTHER’s testimony that she went over STUDENT’s report for Ms. Butler line by line. Footnote 22: Mr. and STUDENT’s MOTHER also testified to an earlier incident when STUDENT left the place he was to be picked up by his parents at night after a school band trip. STUDENT was eventually found by STUDENT’s STEPFATHERwalking around the campus. In his closing brief, Petitioner did not rely on this incident; nonetheless, the Hearing Officer concludes that there is insufficient evidence that this behavior was attributable to an emotional disturbance.
Footnote 23: The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s MOTHER was not the “cause” of these events. As testified by Dr. Easler, while STUDENT’s anger focuses on MOTHER, she is not the cause of it. Dr. Fritz testified that STUDENT’s MOTHER has been and is an excellent advocate for STUDENT. That assessment of her is borne out by the record in this case.
Footnote 24: According to Dr. Easler, the Woodcock-Johnson test has a grade equivalent ceiling of 16.9, so educators cannot measure beyond that ceiling. Ms. Crawford, STUDENT’s teacher at Helicon who administer the Woodcock Johnson test, reported to Dr. Easler that STUDENT was sick during the assessment. As a result, it is possible that STUDENT’s current abilities may be higher than indicated on his standard scores.
Footnote 25: The record is unclear about STUDENT’s two grades (an A and a B) in social studies. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, after STUDENT’s accident, he was excused from P.E., and STUDENT’s report card reflects an NG (no grade) for P.E. STUDENT began working as a teaching assistant for an art class, but there is no reference to this class on the report card.
Footnote 26: Mr. Hughes testified that STUDENT did all A level work in his class but, because he missed one module, his total grade for the class was a C. This testimony about STUDENT’s C grade conflicts with the A grade which appears on his June 15, 2000 report card. Because the lower grade was based on time STUDENT was not in class, however, the higher report card grade is consistent with De Anza’s policy of grading students only for their time in class.
Footnote 27: The record indicates that STUDENT attended the following schools during the 1999-2000 school year when he was not at De Anza: San Dieguito Union High School District (October 23 to November 14, 1999), McBride Juvenile Court School (November and December 1999 and March 2000); home teaching at CVUSD’s Redwood Middle School (February 9 to February 29, 2000) ); and Teton Peak’s school (no records) (late March and April 2000). In August 2000, STUDENT attended school at Helicon Youth Center.
Footnote 28: Ms. Washam expressed her opinion that, in the future, STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors would eventually manifest themselves in the school and affect his school performance. There was no evidence, however, that this was presently occurring.
Footnote 1: After she filed a request for a due process hearing, Petitioner’s mother changed her name from MOTHER to MOTHER. To avoid confusion, she will be referred to throughout this decision as MOTHER.
Footnote 2: When the federal IDEA was amended in 1997, the term “serious emotional disturbance” was changed to “emotional disturbance,” and the federal regulations embody this change. See: 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). The California special education regulation still uses the term “serious emotional disturbance” (See: Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(i)) and that term will be used in this decision.
Footnote 3: Issues identified regarding whether VCBH should be dismissed as a party following STUDENT’s placement at Helicon by Ventura County Probation and whether STUDENT’s MOTHER should be dismissed for lack of standing following the June 29, 2000 juvenile court order removing STUDENT from her legal custody were addressed by the Hearing Officer in the summary order dated August 21, 2000.
Footnote 4: On August 10, 2000, the Hearing Office received the District’s written motion, which was opposed by the Petitioner. VCBH joined in this motion. No response was received from VCOE. On August 21, 2000, the Hearing Officer ruled that this motion would be addressed by the parties at the first day of hearing.
Footnote 5: The parties prepared a joint statement of issues at the outset of the hearing. The Hearing Officer has modified their articulation of the issues to facilitate proper analysis.
Footnote 6: STUDENT attended the District’s Junipero Serra Elementary School for his first and second grade. According to teacher Anne Wilson, he was reading at a high school level when he entered the first grade. STUDENT’s GATE recommendation was based on his Comprehensive Test of Basic Skills (CTBS) scores which were in the 99th percentile in reading and the 88th percentile in math and on his 99+ percentile score on the RAVEN assessment.
Footnote 7: On the Woodcock Johnson Achievement Test given for this assessment, STUDENT scored at the 99.9th percentile in broad reading, broad written language and in broad math. Mr. Appleton testified that achievement was not an area of need for STUDENT. Rather, the focus of his IEP was on his behavior and following the rules.
Footnote 8: In October 1998, STUDENT attended the District’s Cabrillo Middle School, pursuant to an intra-district transfer from De Anza, for eight days. This did not work out to the parent’s satisfaction and STUDENT returned to La Cumbre.
Footnote 9: A second transfer IEP meeting was scheduled on June 15, 1999, which STUDENT’s MOTHER was not able to attend and did not sign. On the IEP prepared for this meeting, STUDENT’s eligibility and placement was unchanged, except that DIS counseling services were to be provided “as needed.” The District members of the IEP team discussed exiting STUDENT from special education with a Section 504 accommodation plan at this meeting.
Footnote 10: Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, which is codified at California Government Code §§ 7570 - 7588, Chapter 26.5, describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or enacted provisions of this chapter.
Footnote 11: Ms. Hellwig has been a school psychologist for four years. Ms. Schoenwald has been a school psychologist for 22 years. They testified that the District has a policy of consultation between psychologists in all cases of determining SED eligibility. Ms. Hellwig spent approximately ten hours observing and talking to STUDENT for this evaluation. She also had extensive contact with MOTHER.
Footnote 12: Pursuant to Welfare and Institutions Code § 602, any person who is under the age of 18 years old when he or she violates any criminal law is within the jurisdiction of the juvenile court, which may adjudge the person to be a ward of the court.
Footnote 13: Because no records were provided to the District or the Hearing Officer from Teton Peaks, it is unclear if this diagnosis was based on a new assessment or from information or records provided by the parent. Ms. Schoenberg testified that the District attempted to obtain STUDENT’s records from Teton Peaks pursuant to a release of information signed by STUDENT’s MOTHER on May 2, 2000. STUDENT’s MOTHER wrote on the release that no personal communications from STUDENT to his therapist were to be released. Ms. Schoenberg testified that she later spoke to Teton Peak’s records clerk and was informed that STUDENT’s MOTHER told Teton Peaks that no records were to be released.
Footnote 14: Ms. Goff testified that she was advised the insurance refused to continue funding at Teton Peaks because STUDENT’s MOTHER was not participating in family therapy, either in person or by video-conferencing. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified she was in the process of purchasing a video-conference machine when notified of the termination of funding.
Footnote 15: Three goals were provided for STUDENT. In academics, STUDENT was to “complete his assignments and turn them in on a timely basis.” He was also to “learn to pace himself with assignments based on time increments allotted by the teacher.” STUDENT’s social and emotional goal was as follows: “In special education class, STUDENT will appropriately express his emotions using the resources available to him (e.g., mental health therapist, decision room).”
Footnote 16: The hearing was taken off-calendar by Petitioner on December 21, 1999. Thereafter, it was re-calendared on March 21, 2000 and taken off-calendar on March 28, 2000. On July 19, 2000, the parties agreed to continue the Hearing until August 22-23, 2000.
Footnote 17: STUDENT was charged with being AWOL, intimidating another resident and engaging in inappropriate sexual activity with residents. One count of sexually inappropriate behavior was dismissed and STUDENT admitted the remaining counts.
Footnote 18: There is also evidence that STUDENT consciously selected his friends. For example, Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT did not maintain lasting friendships in the GATE class and Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that STUDENT did not have friendships in her SED class. According to Dr. Easler, the fact that STUDENT had no friends in these classes, but did have friends in the “artistic” group outside these classes, demonstrates that STUDENT chooses his friends. It does not demonstrate an inability in this realm.
Footnote 19: For example, Ms. Butler testified that STUDENT had a math teacher who was very rigid. Ms. Butler believed STUDENT performed differently for her than the math teacher because he liked her.
Footnote 20: In her June 9, 2000 letter to Ms. Kellner for STUDENT’s AB 2726 assessment, Ms. Allen indicated that “STUDENT... may take longer than other [SED] students to complete assignments.” This observation was contradicted by Ms. Abdun-Nur. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Abdun-Nur’s testimony more persuasive on this point. Ms. Allen was not responsible for teaching in the SED class. There is no indication from her letter or testimony what subject was being taught when she made this observation. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, except for science which presented new material for STUDENT, he was generally working on GATE level material independent from her other SED students. Without a context, therefore, Ms. Allen’s observation carries little weight on this point.
Footnote 21: The Hearing Officer notes that, in discussing Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder, the DMS-IV states that “children generally do not request help, and...[m]ore often the problem is identified by parents, who bring the child in for treatment. Gradual declines in schoolwork secondary to impaired ability to concentrate have been reported. Like adults, children are more prone to engage in rituals at home than in front of peers, teachers, or strangers” p. 420 [emphasis added]. As acknowledged by Dr. Weinberg, it is possible that STUDENT’s power struggles with STUDENT’s MOTHER accounted for the extra time he spent on homework. This possibility is reinforced by MOTHER’s testimony that she went over STUDENT’s report for Ms. Butler line by line. Footnote 22: Mr. and STUDENT’s MOTHER also testified to an earlier incident when STUDENT left the place he was to be picked up by his parents at night after a school band trip. STUDENT was eventually found by STUDENT’s STEPFATHERwalking around the campus. In his closing brief, Petitioner did not rely on this incident; nonetheless, the Hearing Officer concludes that there is insufficient evidence that this behavior was attributable to an emotional disturbance.
Footnote 23: The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT’s MOTHER was not the “cause” of these events. As testified by Dr. Easler, while STUDENT’s anger focuses on MOTHER, she is not the cause of it. Dr. Fritz testified that STUDENT’s MOTHER has been and is an excellent advocate for STUDENT. That assessment of her is borne out by the record in this case.
Footnote 24: According to Dr. Easler, the Woodcock-Johnson test has a grade equivalent ceiling of 16.9, so educators cannot measure beyond that ceiling. Ms. Crawford, STUDENT’s teacher at Helicon who administer the Woodcock Johnson test, reported to Dr. Easler that STUDENT was sick during the assessment. As a result, it is possible that STUDENT’s current abilities may be higher than indicated on his standard scores.
Footnote 25: The record is unclear about STUDENT’s two grades (an A and a B) in social studies. Ms. Abdun-Nur testified that, after STUDENT’s accident, he was excused from P.E., and STUDENT’s report card reflects an NG (no grade) for P.E. STUDENT began working as a teaching assistant for an art class, but there is no reference to this class on the report card.
Footnote 26: Mr. Hughes testified that STUDENT did all A level work in his class but, because he missed one module, his total grade for the class was a C. This testimony about STUDENT’s C grade conflicts with the A grade which appears on his June 15, 2000 report card. Because the lower grade was based on time STUDENT was not in class, however, the higher report card grade is consistent with De Anza’s policy of grading students only for their time in class.
Footnote 27: The record indicates that STUDENT attended the following schools during the 1999-2000 school year when he was not at De Anza: San Dieguito Union High School District (October 23 to November 14, 1999), McBride Juvenile Court School (November and December 1999 and March 2000); home teaching at CVUSD’s Redwood Middle School (February 9 to February 29, 2000) ); and Teton Peak’s school (no records) (late March and April 2000). In August 2000, STUDENT attended school at Helicon Youth Center.
Footnote 28: Ms. Washam expressed her opinion that, in the future, STUDENT’s aggressive behaviors would eventually manifest themselves in the school and affect his school performance. There was no evidence, however, that this was presently occurring.
