California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 29, 2003

Student v. San Diego County Mental Health et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 1954-02 · Hearing Officer Jessica Katz

San Diego County Mental Health's outpatient counseling offers upheld; father's residential placement and hospital reimbursement claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A father, assisted by a non-attorney advocate, filed for due process against San Diego County Mental Health and Santee Elementary School District for his 10-year-old daughter. She was eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. The District settled and was dismissed during the hearing. The student had several emergency psychiatric holds for behavior at home but showed no behavior problems at school. The father wanted a residential treatment center (RTC) from the start. In May and December 2001, Mental Health instead recommended weekly outpatient counseling under the AB 2726 program.

Hearing Officer Jessica Katz found both Mental Health assessments appropriate. The assessors did not have to review every hospital record or speak directly with treating psychiatrists, and more records would not have changed their recommendations. Outpatient counseling was appropriate and was the least restrictive option because the student was doing well at school. It was offered alongside a District one-on-one aide and county Wraparound family services. Counseling was delivered whenever the student was available, and she had no hospitalizations from October 2001 to April 2002. The father then stopped taking her to counseling. A counselor from Pioneer Counseling who qualified as a mental health professional attended the April 2002 IEP meeting, so no procedural violation occurred. The student did not show a need for extended school year (ESY) services. The 13 days between the October 2002 RTC offer and placement were reasonable. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement for the psychiatric hospital stays on the merits and on equitable grounds.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the AB 2726 rules when a parent asked for residential placement and the student's behavior problems happened at home but not at school. It also shows a parent's failure to take part in offered services counting against reimbursement for psychiatric hospital stays.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did Mental Health properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected mental health needs during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years? (Decided separately for the May 2001 assessment by Mr. Bleiweiss and the December 2001 assessment by Dr. Russ.)

    Both Mental Health assessments met Education Code sections 56320-56329 and the regulations. Assessors could rely on written psychiatric reports and did not need every hospital record before writing the report, and the additional records would not have changed the recommendations.

  2. Issue 2 (2000-2001, from May 2001). Did Mental Health offer STUDENT appropriate services during the 2000-2001 school year (beginning May 2001)?

    Weekly outpatient counseling, together with a District 1:1 aide and Wraparound services, met the student's school-based needs and was reasonably calculated to provide benefit. It was implemented as far as hospitalizations allowed, and an RTC would have been premature and more restrictive than needed.

  3. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2(a). Extended school year for the 2000-2001 school year

    No evidence showed the student needed ESY; Mental Health services were to continue year-round anyway.

  4. Issue 2 (2001-2002). Did Mental Health offer STUDENT appropriate services for the 2001-2002 school year, including whether an RTC should have been offered at the December 2001 IEP meeting and whether counseling was provided as set forth in the IEP?

    Continued outpatient counseling was appropriate because the student behaved well and earned good grades at school. Counseling was delivered weekly from October 2001 to April 12, 2002, when the father stopped bringing her, and no RTC was needed for educational benefit.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2 (April 30, 2002 IEP meeting). Whether a procedural violation occurred at the April 30, 2002 annual IEP meeting because no representative from Mental Health was present

    The student's Pioneer counselor, a qualified mental health professional under the regulations, attended. No violation was found and there was no prejudice because the meeting was discontinued at the parent's request.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2(b). Extended school year for the 2001-2002 school year

    No evidence showed the student needed ESY; Mental Health services were to continue year-round.

  7. Issue 2 (September 2002 - October 21, 2002). Did Mental Health offer STUDENT appropriate services from September 2002 through October 21, 2002, including whether Mental Health was responsible for placement between the October 8, 2002 RTC offer and admission on October 21, 2002?

    No evidence showed inappropriate services. The 13 days between the RTC offer and placement were reasonable given the steps required by 2 C.C.R. section 60110.

  8. Issue 3. Should Petitioner receive reimbursement for multiple psychiatric placements from June 2001 through October 21, 2002?

    Reimbursement was denied because services were appropriate and Gov. Code section 7576(f) excludes psychiatric emergencies. Equitable factors, including the father's non-participation, cancelled services and revoked consent to communicate, would also bar any award.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176; Gregory K. v. Longview School District (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education of Massachusetts (1985) 471 U.S. 359; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489; Gov. Code §§ 7570-7588 (AB 2726); Gov. Code § 7572.5; Gov. Code § 7576(f); Cal. Code Regs., tit. 2, §§ 60100(c), 60110, 60300(c)(6); Education Code §§ 56320-56329

People named in the decision

  • Cynthia Shirley, resource specialist, Santee Elementary School District
  • Roy Freedman, school psychologist, Santee Elementary School District
  • Dianna Danley, school psychologist (conducted June 2002 District assessment), Santee Elementary School District
  • Raydene Wolf, coordinator of special education, Santee Elementary School District
  • Marcia Johnson, District Superintendent, Santee Elementary School District
  • Marcia Ginn, Principal, Pepper Drive Elementary School, Santee Elementary School District
  • Amy Arroyo, instructional assistant, Santee Elementary School District
  • Karen Mays, speech and language evaluator, Santee Elementary School District
  • Francis Edwards, program manager, San Diego County Mental Health
  • Sheldon Bleiweiss, licensed mental health clinician; AB 2726 assessor (May 2001 and October 2002), San Diego County Mental Health
  • Dr. Carol Russ, AB 2726 mental health assessor (December 2001), San Diego County Mental Health
  • Jordanna (Jordy) Wasilesku, marriage and family therapist; counselor through CPS, Private provider
  • Denise Fox, family team coordinator for Wraparound services, Wraparound services (CPS)
  • Dr. Anil Patel, child psychiatrist; treating psychiatrist, Aurora Hospital
  • Dr. McManus, treating psychiatrist, Sharp Mesa Vista Hospital
  • Jane Britton, social services staff, Aurora Hospital
  • Salle Sache, counselor, Pioneer Counseling
  • Theresa Grame, associate clinical social worker; student's counselor who attended the April 30, 2002 IEP meeting, Pioneer Counseling
  • Pioneer Counseling, contracted outpatient mental health counseling agency, Under contract with San Diego County Mental Health
  • Crossroads, successor contracted counseling agency (summer 2002), Under contract with San Diego County Mental Health
  • Aurora Hospital, psychiatric hospital, Private provider
  • Sharp Mesa Vista Hospital, psychiatric hospital, Private provider

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Santee, California, on November 19-22 and December 3-4, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by advocate, Dr. Mark Lopez of SchoolWatch. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was her father, FATHER. Respondent Santee Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney, Pamela Dempsey. Raydene Wolf, the District’s coordinator of special education, was also present on behalf of the District. Respondent San Diego County Mental Health (Mental Health) was represented by attorney, Mara Elliott. Francis Edwards, program manager, was also present on behalf of Mental Health.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Cynthia Shirley, resource specialist; Roy Freedman, school psychologist; Dianna Danley, school psychologist; Raydene Wolf; Marcia Johnson, District Superintendent; Marcia Ginn, Principal of Pepper Drive Elementary School; Francis Edwards, Mental Health program manager; Amy Arroyo, instructional assistant; Sheldon Bleiweiss, licensed mental health clinician; FATHER; Jordanna Wasilesku, marriage and family therapist; Denise Fox, family team coordinator for Wraparound services; and Dr. Anil Patel, child psychiatrist. Mental Health conducted all of its witness examinations following Petitioner’s direct examinations.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon receipt of closing briefs from Mental Health on January 7, 2003 and the matter was submitted for decision.(Footnote 1)

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On November 22, 2002, Petitioner and the District informed the Hearing Officer that the parties had resolved all issues pertaining to the District and asked that the District be dismissed as a party. Therefore, in accordance with the parties’ request, the District was dismissed as a party and the issues were amended accordingly.

On December 4, 2002, the Petitioner agreed to submit a chart of all expenses paid to date. The chart was due to all parties by December 13, 2002. The Hearing Officer also ordered closing briefs to be postmarked by December 30, 2002. No expense chart or closing brief from Petitioner was submitted to Mental Health or the Hearing Office. On January 8, 2003, Mental Health submitted a motion to exclude financial information and closing arguments from consideration because Petitioner failed to submit information within the time frame ordered by the Hearing Officer. The Hearing Officer took the motion under consideration, but because no brief was received, the issue became moot and no closing brief from the Petitioner was considered.

ISSUES

1. Did Mental Health properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected mental health needs during the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?

2. Did Mental Health offer STUDENT appropriate services during the 2000-2001 (beginning May 2001), 2001-2002, and September 2002 through October 21, 2002 school years, including extended school years?

3. Should Petitioner receive reimbursement for multiple psychiatric placements from June 2001 through October 21, 2002?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old girl who is eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. STUDENT had resided with her father, older brother and younger sister until October 2002 when she was placed in a residential treatment center (RTC) in San Diego County.

In September 2000, STUDENT was placed on her first emergency hold at Aurora Hospital as a danger to herself or others when her father called law enforcement because of her behavior in the home. By early February 2001, STUDENT was placed on her third emergency hold (all at the request of her father) so her father requested that the District perform an assessment for special education services. Again in late February 2001, STUDENT was placed on an emergency hold as a danger to herself or others and her father requested an RTC. STUDENT’s teacher was surprised to find out that she had been placed on several emergency holds because she exhibited no behavior problems in the classroom and had only fallen behind in class due to the missed days of school while in the hospital. Further, STUDENT’s name had never come up on the weekly student assessment team (SAT) meetings that the school conducted to discuss students with behavior problems, students with poor academic achievement, or students that the school generally felt were at risk.

In March 2001, the District referred STUDENT to Mental Health for a Mental Health assessment. On April 1, 2001, STUDENT was again admitted to the hospital on an emergency hold for out of control behavior in her home. Upon her discharge and return home on April 13, 2001, her treating psychiatrist, Dr. McManus from Sharp Mesa Vista Hospital, recommended continued outpatient therapy. On April 24, 2001, the District convened the initial individualized education program (IEP) meeting, and STUDENT became eligible for special education as a child with an emotional disturbance.(Footnote 2)

Mr. Bleiweiss conducted an assessment of STUDENT to determine eligibility for services from Mental Health. Mr. Bleiweiss noted that “while there have been no significant behavior problems at school, she recently has not been turning in any homework, and has become withdrawn. STUDENT presents with a traumatic childhood of physical and sexual abuse.” Ibid. Mr. Bleiweiss noted that STUDENT required mental health services as a result of her history of victimization and hospitalizations. However, “to suggest a higher level of mental health intervention would be inappropriate at this time, since her school placement continues to be the least restrictive, most mainstream setting available. Consideration for higher levels of mental health care would be more appropriate after additional academic interventions have been attempted. Therefore, the recommendation from County Mental Health is that STUDENT receive mental health services under the AB 2726 program at the outpatient level of care, consistent with the attached mental health treatment plan.”

On May 8, 2001, a subsequent IEP meeting was held and the IEP team approved the proposed Mental Health treatment plan. (Exh. 21, 81) FATHER was present at both the April 24 and May 8, 2001 IEP meetings and agreed to the recommendations for counseling services from Mental Health for a minimum of one time per week for fifty minutes and a one on one aide in the classroom to help STUDENT stay on task and complete homework that she may have missed due to the frequent hospitalizations, despite his desire to have STUDENT placed in an RTC.

However, services did not immediately begin because STUDENT was subsequently admitted on an emergency hold at Sharp Mesa Vista Hospital from May 27, 2001 to June 7, 2001 for “out of control behavior” in the home. (Exh. 93) Hospital records indicate that STUDENT had become enraged and assaulted her brother after being teased. Dr. McManus referred STUDENT to Child Protective Services (CPS) due to the multiple psychiatric holds. In the referral to CPS, Dr. McManus noted, “the initial finding of CPS was that there was concern or danger regarding the patient’s return home because of what appeared to be a significant lack of structure and support there, and the patient’s often extreme acting out behaviors. Throughout the patient’s many hospitalizations, both at Mesa Vista and Aurora, frequent attempts have been made to get the patient and her family to participate in partial hospitalization program (a summer day-treatment program); this had proved difficult because the family’s inability or unwillingness to provide transportation or participate in that level of care. It appeared, however, that just as there was about to be a Child Protective Services meeting to discuss placement of the patient, probably at the Polinsky Center, father suddenly agreed to the patient attending the Partial Hospitalization. This was felt to be an appropriate treatment for the patient and a potentially successful one.” Ibid. STUDENT’s day treatment program was for six-weeks.

Upon STUDENT’s completion of the program in July 2001, CPS and Mental Health developed a program of intensive treatment. CPS instituted Wraparound services within the home to work with STUDENT and her family. Wraparound services consisted of informal parent-centered weekly meetings, counselors, respite care, emergency relief, and counseling when STUDENT or the family needed emergency help or guidance. Ms. Danley, a school psychologist with much experience with Wraparound services, testified that the purpose behind Wraparound services is to keep the child out of a group home placement by “wrapping” the family with intensive services. She explained that the program is successful because it is “a strength-based program rather than deficit-oriented.” She further explained that the Wraparound assist the entire family not just the child presenting the behavioral problems. Counseling services through Mental Health were also arranged and initial interviews occurred. However, STUDENT was readmitted on an emergency hold in late August 2001. She was in and out of the psychiatric hospital throughout September 2001. Mental Health services and Wraparound services from CPS (for the entire family) were implemented immediately upon STUDENT’s release from the psychiatric hospital in October 2001. Additionally, STUDENT’s Mental Health counselor from Pioneer also participated in the Wraparound team meetings to ensure that the services were complimentary rather than overlapping.

On October 30, 2001, the District requested a new assessment from Mental Health upon request from FATHER. Dr. Carol Russ conducted the assessment. She interviewed STUDENT, her teachers and father. She further reviewed counseling records and records from initial psychiatric placements. Dr. Russ requested reports from STUDENT’s most recent placements. Although the psychiatric reports did not arrive prior to the completion of the written assessment, she did review the doctors’ reports prior to the December 17, 2001 IEP meeting. Dr. Russ recommended that STUDENT continue to receive AB 2726 mental heatlth services at the outpatient level. Dr. Russ also recommended that the father participate in STUDENT’s counseling.

In support of Dr. Russ’ receommendation, she noted, “STUDENT has a history of multiple severe child abuse, and multiple losses of people who mean a great deal to her. Her Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD) is chronic and untreated. Her rageful outbursts with her father and her nanny in the home setting can be understood clinically as re-enactments of the abuse she has suffered, her identity with and conflict with the perpetrators and her attempt at mastery. She is very angry with men and her multiple hospitalizations have increased her feelings of abandonment.” Dr. Russ expressed concern that STUDENT had only had been counseled on five occasions by early November 2001, and that her family had not participated in family counseling through the Wraparound program. Dr. Russ expressed concern that the family had not utilized the services for STUDENT and that it was premature to conclude that outpatient counseling was ineffective because STUDENT was just beginning to show signs of progress.

STUDENT continued to attend counseling on a regular weekly basis through April 12, 2002. However, FATHER did not participate in the counseling despite the many requests from STUDENT’s counselor. Denise Fox, the family team coordinator for Wraparound services, testified that Wraparound services were effective and helpful to both STUDENT and her family because STUDENT was not hospitalized for several months. Mental Health contracted with Pioneer Counseling to provide STUDENT outpatient counseling. Ms. Edwards explained that once the referral was made to Pioneer, Mental Health closed its file on STUDENT, and it became the responsibility of Pioneer to provide all counseling services and attend the IEP meetings. From October 2001 through April 12, 2002, while STUDENT consistently attended counseling, she made good progress, had no incidents that warranted placement in a psychiatric hospital, and she advanced appropriately in her educational program at Pepper Drive Elementary School.

On April 30, 2002, STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was held at the District. STUDENT’s counselor from Pioneer was present at the IEP meeting; however, no employee of Mental Health was at the IEP meeting. FATHER and his advocate, Mr. Lopez, objected to Mental Health’s lack of involvement in the IEP meeting and asked for the IEP meeting to be discontinued until a representative of Mental Health was present. Further, Mr. Lopez requested a third pyschoeducational assessment (exclusive of Mental Health). The IEP meeting was ended and rescheduled for June 19, 2002. FATHER also withdrew his consent for the District and Mental Health to communicate regarding STUDENT’s IEP. Further, FATHER gave his ten-day notice that he would place STUDENT in an RTC and file for due process. However, STUDENT was not placed in an RTC and FATHER did not file for due process until August 28, 2002. Further, STUDENT continued to have outpatient counseling services available to her following the IEP meeting of April 30, 2002, but FATHER failed to transport STUDENT to counseling or respond to Pioneer’s numerous attempts at contact in order to reschedule missed counseling sessions.

On June 19, 2002, the annual IEP meeting was reconvened, but FATHER and his advocate failed to attend because the new District assessment performed by the school psychologist, Dianna Danley had only just been completed on June 18, 2002. FATHER also requested a third assessment by Mental Health but continued to refuse to give complete permission for District employees and Mental Health employees to communicate. Finally, on August 14, 2002, FATHER completed all necessary forms for Mental Health to proceed with the new assessment of STUDENT.

Mr. Bleiweiss was again assigned to conduct the assessment of STUDENT. Mr. Bleiweiss attempted to contact FATHER on several occasions through phone calls and letters to proceed with the assessment. FATHER finally agreed to meet with Mr. Bleiweiss on September 23, 2002 for an intake appointment. Mr. Bleiweiss completed his assessment on October 3, 2002. (Exh. 63) In preparing his assessment, Mr. Bleiweiss reviewed Mental Health’s previous AB 2726 assessment files regarding STUDENT, hospitalization and treatment records, and school records, and interviewed FATHER, STUDENT and Jane Britton of Aurora Hospital social services. (Exh. 63) Ms. Britton informed Mr. Bleiweiss that Aurora had not witnessed any of the behavioral problems that FATHER had described at home and that STUDENT was a model patient while hospitalized and while in the Partial Hospitalization program. (Exh. 70) Aurora staff did not believe that STUDENT received positive support and reinforcement at home because FATHER worked all day and the nanny was very cold to STUDENT. Ms. Britton described the relationship between STUDENT and FATHER as “tense.” She felt that residential placement was needed. Mr. Bleiweiss also exchanged voicemails with Dr. Patel, who agreed that a structured placement was most appropriate. (Exh. 70)

Based on the information that Mr. Bleiweiss obtained, he concluded, “What seems to be needed is an intensely structured program where STUDENT can feel safe, secure, and stable enough to get the help she needs to cope with her overwhelming emotional problems. Therefore, the recommendation from County Mental Health is that STUDENT receive mental health services under AB 2726 program at a residential level of care” (Exh. 63) Further, at hearing, both Mr. Bleiweiss and Ms. Edwards testified that Mental Health changed its recommendation because STUDENT’s mental health was adversely impacting her education; she had not done well during the summer of 2002, had been placed on several emergency holds and in day treatment programs, and had only attended four days of school during the 2002-2003 school year. Additionally, STUDENT’s mental health had declined dramatically because Wraparound services from CPS were discontinued during the summer of 2002 due to funding cuts, and FATHER had not taken STUDENT to any outpatient counseling since April 12, 2002.

FATHER agreed with the recommendation and STUDENT was placed in an RTC in the county on October 21, 2002, when a placement became available.

CONTENTIONS OF PARTIES

Petitioner contends that she was not properly assessed by Mental Health in May 2001 because Mental Health recommended outpatient treatment. Petitioner contends that an RTC should have been recommended at the May 2001 IEP meeting because Petitioner had been placed on an emergency hold at a psychiatric facility five times prior to the assessment. Due to the emergency holds, Petitioner missed several days of school and Petitioner contends that her emotional disturbance inhibited her ability to receive an education during the psychiatric emergency holds.

Petitioner further contends that the assessment in the fall of 2001 was not appropriate because the assessor failed to get all the admission records from the psychiatric institutions that Petitioner had attended, and, had the assessor received all the information, she would have recommended at the December 2001 IEP meeting that STUDENT be placed in an RTC.

Petitioner additionally contends that there was a procedural violation at the April 2002 IEP meeting because no one from Mental Health attended the IEP meeting.

Mental Health contends that STUDENT was properly assessed in all areas of suspected mental health needs at each assessment conducted - May 2001, December 2001, and September 2002. Further, Mental Health contends that it made an appropriate recommendation for outpatient counseling in May 2001 and December 2001 because it was the least restrictive environment (LRE) for STUDENT to receive services.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did Mental Health properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected mental health needs for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years?

Petitioner alleges that Mental Health failed to properly assess STUDENT because it did not gather and review all pertinent documents during the course of its assessment, including hospitalization and police records. Mental Health contends that its assessment was proper because it followed the applicable law concerning mental health assessment.

Assembly Bill (AB) 2726, which is codified at California Government Code §§7570 – 7588, Chapter 26.5, describes interagency responsibilities for providing services, including mental health services, to children with disabilities. Government Code § 7570 describes the joint responsibilities of “ensuring maximum utilization of all state and federal resources available to provide a child with a disability…with a free appropriate public education, the provision of related services…and designated instruction and services…shall be the joint responsibility of the Superintendent of Public Instruction and the Secretary of Health and Welfare.” The State Department of Mental Health, or any community mental health service, “shall be responsible for the provision of mental health services, as defined in regulations by the State Department of Mental Health, developed in consultation with the State Department of Education, when required in the pupil’s individualized education program” Govt. Code § 7576(a).

A review of chapter 26.5 and its implementing regulations reveals a three-stage process for obtaining mental health services: the initial referral for assessment, the actual assessment of a student for mental health services, and the development of the IEP and supplemental IEPs to offer appropriate services. The assessment report is the basic document for determining eligibility for mental health services. If the pupil is determined eligible for mental health services, the assessment report also provides treatment recommendations. The initial assessment report dated May 7, 2001, concluded that STUDENT was eligible for AB 2726 mental health service. Mental Health recommended outpatient-counseling services a minimum of one time a week for fifty minutes, a prescription to be reevaluated after six months of services. FATHER gave written permission for the services at the May 8, 2001 IEP meeting.

In this case, there is no dispute that STUDENT was properly referred to Mental Health for assessment. However, Petitioner disputes the validity of the assessment. Petitioner asserts that Mr. Bleiweiss did not follow all the requirements set forth in the code because Mr. Bleiweiss only looked at reports from the most recent hospitalizations instead of psychiatric reports from all of STUDENT’s hospitalizations. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that the Mr. Bleiweiss failed to contact either Dr. McManus from Sharp Mesa Vista or Dr. Patel from Aurora Hospital, STUDENT’s treating psychiatrists and relied solely on their written reports.

A “mental health assessment” is defined as “services designed to provide formal documented evaluation or analysis of the nature of the pupil’s emotional or behavioral disorder” which is conducted in accordance with the assessment procedures under Education Code §§ 56320 through 56329 and Title 9 Calif. Code Reg. §543(b), 2 Calif. Code Regs. § 60020(g) by qualified mental health professionals employed by or under contract with the community mental health service. Assessment services are “limited to an intake examination, mental health evaluation, physical examination, and laboratory testing necessary for the evaluation and treatment of the patient’s mental health needs.” Title 9 Calif. Code Regs. §543(b).

Education Code §§ 56320 through 56329, sets forth the requirements for conducting an appropriate assessment. Section 56327 requires, in relevant part, that the assessment report include the following: (a) Whether the pupil may need special education and related services; (b) the basis for making the determination; (c) the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in the appropriate setting; (d) the relationship of the behavior to the pupil’s academic and social functioning; (e) the educationally relevant health and development, and medical findings, if any.

May 2001 Assessment

Mr. Bleiweiss conducted the initial Mental Health assessment in accordance with the laws set forth above. The report indicates that STUDENT qualified for special education and related services in the category of emotionally disturbed on April 24, 2001. Areas of concern for STUDENT were withdrawal, failure to turn in assignments, sexual molestation, abandonment, and recent hospitalizations. (Exh. 79). Mr. Bleiweiss considered the following in performing the assessment: a questionnaire completed by FATHER, two reports from Dr. Anil Patel (one of STUDENT’s treating psychiatrists) dated February 12 and 19, 2001; information shared at the IEP meeting on April 24, 2001; District’s pyschoeducational evaluation prepared by Roy Freedman; a speech and language evaluation prepared by Karen Mays; a resource specialist report prepared by Cynthia Shirley; a psychiatric evaluation by Dr. Patel; an intake interview with FATHER where he describes STUDENT’s most recent hospitalizations at Sharp in April 2001, four other hospitalizations and counseling information received from Dr. Patel and Jordy Wasilesku; school observations of STUDENT and a review of inpatient hospitalization records. Although Petitioner contends that Mr. Bleiweiss should have looked at all of STUDENT’s intake records rather than just the most recent records from both Sharp and Aurora, she did not provide any legal authority suggesting that Mr. Bleiweiss’ evaluation was inappropriate. Further, Mr. Bleiweiss testified that had he received the additional information, it would not have changed his recommendation, as he was aware of all recent and relevant information that was summarized in the review of the above referenced information.

STUDENT’s relevant behavior is documented in the assessment. Mr. Bleiweiss observed STUDENT in her classroom setting, interacting with peers, and interacting at recess. He also described how her behavior affected her classroom participation and social functioning. The report further includes relevant health and development and medical findings. It is noted that STUDENT’s developmental milestones were normal, that she had a history of atypical seizure disorder, that she was molested by her stepfather, had participated in private counseling with Ms. Wasilesku, had been hospitalized, and was taking Depakote and Risperdal.

The Hearing Officer finds that the Mental Health assessment performed by Mr. Bleiweiss in May 2001 met the applicable requirements described in, Education Code §§ 56320 through 56329 and the Calif. Code of Regs. §§ 543(b) and 60200 (g). Petitioner’s assertions of alleged deficiencies are unfounded. Mr. Bleiweiss was legally entitled to rely on the written reports of an expert. All relevant information was included in the thorough records secured from various sources and were considered as part of the recommendation; any further information would have been duplicative in nature.

December 2001 Mental Health Assessment

Petitioner contends that she was not properly assessed by Mental Health in December 2001 because the assessor did not have all relevant information necessary to make an informed placement recommendation. Mental Health contends that its assessment was properly conducted in accordance with the requirements set forth under the law and that it made an appropriate recommendation for continued outpatient counseling.

Dr. Carol Russ performed the second Mental Health assessment which she completed for the December 17, 2001 IEP meeting. Dr. Russ concluded that STUDENT qualified for services from Mental Health due to her emotional disturbance, and the areas of concern, once again, were withdrawal, failure to turn in assignments, sexual molestations, abandonment, and recent hospitalization. (Exh. 36) Dr. Russ based her conclusion on interviews of FATHER, the nanny, and STUDENT; observations of STUDENT in the school setting; consultation with STUDENT’s teacher; review of school records; and consultation with STUDENT’s counselor, Salle Sache of Pioneer counseling. Dr. Russ also reviewed all documents that had been utilized by Mr. Bleiweiss’ May 2001 assessment. Although Dr. Russ had timely requested the hospital records from Sharp Mesa Vista and Aurora hospitals, she had not received the records by December 11, 2001, the date of her report. However, Dr. Russ did receive and review all copies of the medical records prior to making her recommendation at the December 17, 2001 IEP meeting. Further, Dr. Russ discussed STUDENT’s recent hospitalizations with her father.

Dr. Russ’s notes indicate that FATHER reported “aggressive behaviors at home, mostly on weekends and right after school which have resulted in additional psychiatric hospitalizations. She has been hospitalized: May (2-3 weeks), June (1 week), July (2-3 weeks), Aug. and September. Triggers: argument w/live-in nanny (NANNY), argument w/bro. where she injured him, refusing time out in her room (by nanny), outbursts at home in which she threatened suicide (jump out window) and homicide (against nanny), and exploding at home after being teased on the bus.” (Exh. 92). According to the assessment requirements set forth in the Education Code §56327, Dr. Russ considered all necessary information and conducted appropriate and required observations of STUDENT. Dr. Russ also included all educationally relevant health and development and medical findings.

Although Petitioner contends that Dr. Russ needed the hospital records prior to the completion of her assessment, she again provided no legal authority necessitating this requirement. Further, no evidence was presented that would indicated that the inclusion of the records would have changed her placement recommendations considering that all information was available at the time of the IEP meeting. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the Mental Health assessment conducted by Dr. Carol Russ met the applicable requirements set forth in the Education Code §§ 56320 through 56329 and the California Code of Regs. §§ 543(b) and 60200 (g).

2. Did Mental Health offer STUDENT appropriate services for the 2000-2001 (beginning May 2001), 2001-2002 and from September 2002 – October 21, 2002 school years?

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code §56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; California Education Code § 56000 et seq.)

The standard for determining whether the Mental Health program offered STUDENT a FAPE involves the following factors: (1) whether the placement and services were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to her; and (3) conformed to her IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; (Board of Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 206-207.)

In Rowley, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200.) In determining whether Mental Health offered appropriate services, the focus is on the adequacy of the Mental Health’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, (9th Cir. 1987) 811 F.2d 1307.) If Mental Health has offered appropriate services, Mental Health is not required to place the student in the program preferred by the parents, even if the preferred program is likely to result in greater educational benefit. (Id.)

Moreover, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Education Code § 56031.)

2000-2001 (beginning May 2001) School Year

Petitioner contends that Mental Health failed to offer her appropriate mental health services after she was found eligible for special education on April 24, 2001. Petitioner asserts that she required an RTC rather than outpatient counseling in order to receive appropriate services. Petitioner seeks reimbursement for psychiatric hospitalizations during the subject period.

Mental Health contends that on May 8, 2001, it offered STUDENT appropriate services and that an RTC would have been too restrictive for an initial placement for STUDENT. Mental Health further contends that Petitioner should not be reimbursed for psychiatric hospitalization because the hospitalizations were not educationally related and insurance covered the expenses.

There is no dispute that STUDENT’s identified unique needs at the time of the initial assessment were a decline in academic performance due to frequent hospitalizations and poor self-esteem. STUDENT had been making A’s and B’s, but since September 2000, had been hospitalized on five separate occasions. Further, according to the Mental Health treatment plan, exhibit 81, she had recently not been turning in any of her homework, and had become more withdrawn in class and had only been completing 75% of her academic assignments. Mental Health also noted that STUDENT had difficulty expressing her feelings appropriately and had a tendency to respond with increased agitation, physical aggression and threats of self-harm when frustrated or upset. However, these behaviors were only occurring in the home, not in the school environment. Further, testimony presented at hearing clearly indicated that STUDENT needed a structured program where she could be provided consistent, appropriate guidance. When school was out on break (school holidays or summer vacation), STUDENT did not have structure or homework to keep her balanced.

Was STUDENT’s placement in outpatient counseling designed to meet her unique needs?

Mental Health offered STUDENT outpatient counseling to meet her unique needs in addition to Wraparound services provided by CPS. The IEP team and FATHER agreed with the recommendation and set forth the following undisputed goals and objectives to meet STUDENT’s social and emotional needs to ensure that she was able to attend school rather than be placed in a psychiatric hospital: to complete all of her academic assignments within the requested time frames and to be able to identify five personal strengths; and to demonstrate positive interactions with peers and adults at least 75% of the time, reducing the frequency of episodic self-harm by 75%, and not needing psychiatric hospitalizations, within six months from the start of treatment. STUDENT’s needs in the classroom were met by the one-on-one aide provided by the District.(Footnote 3)

Mr. Bleiweiss explained in his summary and recommendations in his May 7, 2001 assessment report that “at the last IEP meeting, STUDENT’s teacher commented that because of the many hospitalizations, it has become difficult for STUDENT to keep up with assignments while trying to “catch up” the work she missed. This could help explain her apparent depressed mood and poor impulse control that leads her to act out in anger at home. But to STUDENT’s credit, she has not displayed any of those aggressive, angry feelings at school. Her behavior at school must be the focus of the AB 2726 program.” (Exh. 79) Further, STUDENT’s teacher had been surprised to find out that STUDENT had been placed on emergency hold because she had not exhibited any behaviors in school that would have necessitated an emergency hold. STUDENT had only showed frustration and recent difficulty completing her assignments due to the hospitalizations. Because STUDENT was not exhibiting inappropriate behaviors at school, the Hearing Officer finds that despite STUDENT’s acting out in the home environment, Mental Health’s program of outpatient counseling was designed to meet STUDENT’s mental health needs within the educational setting.

Was outpatient counseling reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

STUDENT’s needs in the school setting were based on remediation from missing school due to frequent psychiatric hospitalizations and to help her overcome the mild depression from getting behind in school. STUDENT was observed in the classroom by Mr. Bleiweiss to be “quiet, lethargic and withdrawn.” However, during “small group activity, she was a more active participant in the activity and in engaging her peers in conversation. Her affect also brightened when they paid attention to her.” (Exh. 79) STUDENT clearly did well in one-on-one situations and responded well. Further, Ms. Wasilesku testified that she had been providing counseling on a weekly basis through CPS from April 1, 1999 through June 30, 2001 when STUDENT became eligible for special education and Mental Health services. She explained that STUDENT had difficulties with her home and social environment, abandonment issues and behavior problems in the home. Ms. Wasilesku explained that she wanted an RTC to be the “last resort.” She explained that STUDENT’s problems occurred when there was less structure during break time because there was no set schedule, no homework and her grandparents would only take her siblings on outings.(Footnote 4) Ms. Wasilesku testified that STUDENT was dealing with issues of rejection and fear and that outpatient counseling enabled her to live at home and not suffer further abandonment from her loved ones.

Further, the IEP team specifically set forth a reassessment process six months after the services began in order to assess the appropriateness of the services and to determine any need for modification. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that based on the information that the IEP team had at the time of the May 8, 2001 IEP meetings and Ms. Wasilesku’s testimony, and the agreement to reassess in six months, a weekly program of outpatient counseling was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Did Mental Health comport with the IEP?

Unfortunately, outpatient counseling did not commence immediately following the IEP meeting because STUDENT was placed on a subsequent emergency psychiatric hold. Dr. McManus recommended a day-treatment program when CPS intervened to discuss possible removal from FATHER’s home. FATHER requested that counseling from Mental Health not begin until STUDENT completed the day-treatment program in mid-July 2001. Outpatient counseling was scheduled to begin in August, but unfortunately, STUDENT was again placed on an emergency hold. STUDENT was in and out of the psychiatric hospital through October 1, 2001. Counseling services through Pioneer counseling, Mental Health’s contracted counseling agency, commenced immediately upon STUDENT’s return to her home. Pioneer also worked with the Wraparound service provider to ensure that STUDENT’s counseling complimented the services that the family received from Wraparound. Wraparound services were provided to the entire family as a support system.

STUDENT’s attendance at counseling was fairly consistent through November 2001 when a subsequent Mental Health assessment was conducted. Although STUDENT only attended two months of counseling, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s counseling program comported with her IEP to the extent possible due to STUDENT’s frequent hospitalizations.

Was STUDENT’s placement in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The final element of a FAPE analysis is whether STUDENT’s placement was in the least restrictive environment (LRE). LRE is a legal mandate of the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) requiring that students with disabilities receive their education in the regular classroom environment with the least possible amount of segregation from the students’ non-disabled peers and community. 34 C.F.R. § 300.550-300.554 provides: “(b) Each agency shall ensure – (1) to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are non-disabled; and (2) that special classes, separate schooling or removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.”

Mental Health and the District recommended that STUDENT remain in the regular classroom with a one-on-one aide provided by the District and outpatient counseling provided by Mental Health rather than be placed in an RTC as requested by FATHER. In determining whether STUDENT needed a residential placement, the IEP team was required to determine if STUDENT’s needs could reasonably have been met through any combination of nonresidential services, preventing the need for out-of-home care and whether residential care is necessary for STUDENT to benefit from educational services. Gov’t. Code §7572.5(b)(1)(2). Further, prior to an IEP team determination that a residential placement is necessary for the pupil to receive special education and mental health services, the expanded IEP team shall consider less restrictive alternatives, such as providing a behavioral specialist and full-time behavioral aide in the classroom, home and community environments, and/or parent training in the home and community environments. C.C.R. § 60100(c).

In this case, STUDENT was found eligible for special education services, and at the same time found that she required mental health services. STUDENT had not received any services through the District or Mental Health prior to April 2001. The IEP team was required to first look at alternatives other than residential placement. The IEP team offered STUDENT a one-on-one aide in the classroom provided by the District and outpatient counseling provided by Mental Health one time a week. STUDENT was doing well in her class work, did not present any behavioral problems in school, and did not need a residential placement in order to benefit from educational services. Further, both Mr. Freedman, the school psychologist, and Mr. Bleiweiss, the Mental Health assessor, testified that an appropriate after-school program would adequately address STUDENT’s needs in relation to her after-school behavior, because she did not present any problems during school hours. Only Dr. Patel testified that he believed STUDENT needed a residential placement, and he based this recommendation solely on her psychiatric needs rather than her educational needs. Further, both Mr. Freedman and Mr. Bleiweiss concluded that STUDENT had issues of abandonment and that placement in an RTC at age eight may trigger deeper problems in terms of loss and abandonment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a residential placement would have been premature for STUDENT and that Mental Health properly recommended continued placement at Pepper Tree Elementary School with outpatient counseling as the least restrictive environment.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Mental Health offered STUDENT appropriate services for the 2000-2001 (beginning May 8, 2001) school year.

(a) Extended School Year

No evidence was presented that STUDENT required an extended school year (ESY). STUDENT was doing well in all academic areas and did not require special education services outside of the regular school year. Further, Ms. Edwards testified that all services offered by Mental Health were to be consistent throughout the calendar year, even though ESY services were not delineated on STUDENT’s IEP document.

2001-2002 School Year

Petitioner contends that she was not provided appropriate services for the 2001-2002 school year because Mental Health failed to provide counseling services as set forth in the May 2001 IEP. Further, Petitioner contends that Mental Health should have offered STUDENT an RTC at the December 2001 IEP meeting. Mental Health contends that it offered STUDENT appropriate services, provided the services listed in the operative IEP, and that the services provided were adequate. Mental Health further contends that STUDENT should not be reimbursed for psychiatric hospitalizations because such hospitalizations were not educationally related and insurance covered the costs.

STUDENT’s unique needs did not vary much from the May 2001 IEP, however, the December 2001 IEP noted that STUDENT has “troubling sexual feelings at school and temper tantrums in the home setting. Her classroom interruptions were rare, she achieved good grades, and otherwise presented no behavioral problems.” (Exh. 37). STUDENT no longer had a problem completing her academic assignments.

Was STUDENT’s placement in outpatient counseling designed to meet her unique needs?

Because STUDENT’s needs had not changed dramatically and because she had only had approximately two months of counseling services from Pioneer Counseling, Mental Health again offered outpatient counseling through Pioneer. The Mental Health goal was to prevent sexual feelings at school from interrupting classroom time and decreasing tantrums at home by 50%. The benchmarks included (1) establishing a working, weekly therapeutic alliance between STUDENT and her family and the Pioneer therapist and developing behavioral intervention plans for temper control deficits; and (2) decreasing temper tantrums by 50% within six months. (Exh. 37) According to exhibit 109, Mental Health faxed the assessment plan to Pioneer Counseling for implementation to begin on December 17, 2001.

Further, STUDENT was receiving Wraparound services from CPS. There were weekly family meetings, counselors available twenty-four hours a day, respite care for any of the children, and family counseling. Further, Pioneer worked with Wraparound and participated in the weekly meetings. With the additional services, the Hearing Officer finds that outpatient counseling was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs because she was exhibiting appropriate behaviors in the school environment and achieving good grades. Further, because STUDENT no longer had difficulty completing her assignments, more intensive day-treatment or after-school programs would not have been necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Was outpatient counseling reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Mental Health’s role was to provide services to help STUDENT cope within the educational setting and to ensure that STUDENT’s emotional disturbance was not interfering with her ability to receive an education. Clearly, STUDENT made progress in the school environment, despite her numerous hospitalizations during the summer of 2001 and at the beginning of the school year. STUDENT no longer had difficulties completing her assignments and she received good grades. Further, with the additional Wraparound services from CPS, outpatient counseling was designed to provide educational benefit.

Did Mental Health comport with the IEP?

STUDENT attended counseling on a regular weekly basis through April 12, 2002. However, FATHER only attended one counseling session despite the therapist’s outreach and that FATHER was home for much of the time on disability recovering from back surgery. STUDENT apparently made much progress in her counseling, as she was not hospitalized once between October 2001 and April 2002. According to counseling notes, STUDENT was able to learn to walk away, take a time-out when necessary, and was ashamed of her misbehavior. (Exh. 109) Despite efforts to reschedule counseling after April 12, 2002, FATHER canceled all further counseling efforts. FATHER testified that he could not provide transportation so he did not take her to counseling.(Footnote 5)

During the summer of 2002, Pioneer Counseling terminated its contract with Mental Health and Crossroads took over the contract to provide counseling services. Numerous phone calls and letters were initiated from both Pioneer and Crossroads in order to insure a smooth transition of services; however, FATHER failed to respond to any of the contacts from either agency and STUDENT never began services with Crossroads. The Hearing Officer finds that services from Mental Health comported with the IEP because STUDENT received weekly counseling October 1, 2001 (immediately upon STUDENT’s release from the psychiatric hospital) through April 12, 2002 when FATHER failed to transport STUDENT or work with either Pioneer or Crossroads counseling.

Was STUDENT’s placement in the Least Restrictive Environment?

The final element in a FAPE analysis is whether the placement was designed to provide the student with an education in the LRE. As discussed above, STUDENT was doing very well in school. She presented no behavioral problems in the classroom environment and was successful in a regular classroom environment. Further, STUDENT had no further psychiatric hospitalizations following the implementation of outpatient counseling through Pioneer. No indication or information was presented that STUDENT required an RTC in order to benefit from her special education services.

Procedural Violations

Petitioner also alleged procedural violations occurred at the April 30, 2002 annual IEP meeting because no representative from Mental Health was present at the meeting. However Petitioner cites no authority for this alleged procedural violation. Govt. Code Section 7572 (d)(1) clearly states that whenever an assessment is conducted by Mental Health, the person who conducted the assessment shall attend the IEP team meeting if requested. However, upon implementation of Mental Health services, Calif. Code. of Regs. Section 60300(c)(6) requires that participation of a qualified mental health professional at the IEP team meetings. A “qualified mental health professional” is defined as “a licensed practitioner of healing arts: a psychiatrist; psychologist; clinical social worker; marriage, family and child counselor; registered nurse; mental health rehabilitation specialist, and others who have been waived under Section 5751.2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code. Such individuals may provide mental health services consistent with their scope of practice. C.C.R. §60020(j).

STUDENT’s counselor from Pioneer was present at the April 30, 2002 annual IEP meeting that convened at the District. Petitioner requested that the meeting end because there was no one present from Mental Health. However, STUDENT’s counselor, Theresa Grame, an associate clinical social worker (ASW) with a masters in social work (MSW), who had worked with STUDENT on a weekly basis for approximately six months and who was in the best position to address STUDENT’s mental health needs, was present. Therefore, no evidence was presented that a procedural violation existed due to the absence of a representative from Mental Health. Further, there was no actual prejudice as the IEP meeting was discontinued to request a third psychoeducational assessment from the District.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Mental Health offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

(b) Extended School Year

As stated previously, no evidence was presented that STUDENT required an extended school year (ESY). STUDENT was doing well in all academic areas and did not require special education services outside of the regular school year. Further, Ms. Edwards testified that all services offered by Mental Health were to be consistent throughout the calendar year, even though ESY services were not delineated on STUDENT’s IEP document.

September 2002 through October 21, 2002

No evidence was presented that Mental Health failed to offer STUDENT appropriate services during the designated time period. STUDENT’s mental health rapidly deteriorated because Mental Health services had been unilaterally discontinued by the father on April 12, 2002 and CPS had terminated Wraparound services in August of 2002 due to funding cuts. Further, FATHER failed to meet with Mr. Bleiweiss until September 23, 2002 for the intake interview. STUDENT was subsequently hospitalized most of August and September 2002 and was only able to attend school for four days at Pepper Tree Elementary School. An IEP meeting was held on October 8, 2002 and both the District and Mental Health offered an RTC. FATHER agreed with the offer, and STUDENT was subsequently placed on October 21, 2002. Petitioner contends that Mental Health was responsible for placement of STUDENT from October 8, 2002 through the date of admission into the RTC on October 21, 2002. However, Petitioner failed to present evidence that would indicate that Mental Health violated any procedures set forth in Calif. Code of Regs. Section 60110. The regulations set forth detailed requirements for case management following a recommendation for placement in an RTC. However, nowhere in the regulations, does it state that the RTC placement must occur on the day the recommendation is made and accepted. To the contrary, Calif. Code of Regs. Section 60110 requires that first a mental health plan must be developed, then a meeting with the parents must take place, then a placement must be identified that is satisfactory to all parties (the parent, the District, Mental Health), payment must then be authorized, followed by a transition plan for the student. Based on the regulations, the Hearing Officer finds that the thirteen days between the placement offer and the actual placement in the RTC was appropriate in light of the numerous requirements that must occur prior to placement.

3. Should Petitioner receive reimbursement for multiple psychiatric placements from June 2001 through October 21, 2002?

The Hearing Officer has found that there is no basis for reimbursing Petitioner for the cost of the multiple psychiatric holds and that Mental Health provided her with appropriate service during the specified time periods. Further, Govt. Code Section 7576 (f) states that Mental Health’s responsibilities “are not designed for use in responding to psychiatric emergencies or other situations requiring immediate response. In these situations, a parent may seek services from other public programs or private providers, as appropriate.”

However, were there any basis to award reimbursement for the psychiatric holds, equitable considerations would preclude an award. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, may be relevant in fashioning appropriate relief. Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Ed. Of Mass., 471 U.S. 359, 374(1985); W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range Scholl Dist., 96 f.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992); Student W. Pullayup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). FATHER failed to appropriately participate in STUDENT’s therapy despite the numerous requests from the psychiatric hospitals and her therapists from Mental Health and through CPS interventions. Further, FATHER did not assist in transportation and unilaterally cancelled STUDENT’s services in April 2002. Further, Petitioner’s advocate, Mr. Lopez, revoked the waiver that FATHER had previously signed that allowed District and Mental Health to communicate. Additionally, all communication between Mental Health and the Wraparound service provider was also revoked by FATHER and Mr. Lopez. Because FATHER failed to take STUDENT to any services beyond April 2002, STUDENT was hospitalized almost the entire time from July 16, 2002 through the date of admission into the RTC on October 21, 2002. Additionally, the inability to communicate caused STUDENT’s Mental Health assessment, initially requested in June 2002 to be delayed until October 2002. Accordingly, STUDENT’s father is not entitled to reimbursement for the psychiatric holds and reimbursement is denied.

ORDER

Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507 (d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute: Mental Health prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Education Code § 56505 (i).

Dated: January 29, 2003

____________________________________ Jessica Katz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Closing briefs were to be postmarked by December 30, 2002; however, no brief was received from the Petitioner. 2. STUDENT’s eligibility was rather tenuous as the school psychologist, Roy Freedman testified that he did not find that STUDENT qualified as a child with an emotional disturbance because, despite her multiple psychiatric placements, STUDENT was progressing appropriately in her school work and was not exhibiting any emotional problems during the school day that would have affected her education. The IEP team determined that because of STUDENT’s multiple psychiatric holds she needed counseling services. 3. Because the parties agreed to dismiss the District from the case, the Hearing Officer will not address whether services offered and provided by the District complied with the provisions of FAPE.

4. Ms. Wasilesku explained that “break-time” meant school holidays, summer vacation etc., rather than after school. 5. To the extent that there may have been an obligation for transportation, it was the District’s responsibility to provide transportation as a related service in accordance with California Code of Regulations § 60200(d)(1) requiring that “the LEA be responsible for transportation of a pupil with a disability to and from mental health services specified in the pupil’s IEP.”