California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 26, 2001
Student v. Fountain Valley School District
SEHO Case No. SN 1966-00 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino
Fountain Valley School District must reimburse $49,807.80 for home autism program and provide compensatory services; IEE claim denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a preschool boy filed against Fountain Valley School District. In fall 1999 the District assessed him only for speech and language, though staff saw echoing, perseveration, high activity and aggression toward peers. His IEP gave two hours of speech therapy a week. Occupational therapy (OT) was added in May 2000. In September 2000 the parents enrolled him in a 23-hour-per-week home discrete trial program run by the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). In November 2000 the District finished a full assessment, found him eligible under autistic-like behaviors and speech or language impairment, and offered about 20 to 22 hours of weekly services.
The Hearing Officer found that the 1999 assessment missed autism-related behaviors and social skills. Oral suggestions of more testing were not a written assessment plan. The 1999-2000 IEPs denied FAPE because they had no behavior or social-skills program and their speech and OT goals were vague or missing. The November 2000 offer was much better. But it came 2½ months into the school year and had no plan for moving the boy out of CARD, so it also denied FAPE. The District must reimburse $49,807.80 for CARD, and the IEP team must design compensatory services for 1999-2000. Claims for compensatory speech and OT services were denied. So was payment for Dr. Mitchel Perlman's independent evaluation.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a narrow first assessment of a preschooler with autism-like signs. Gaps in the first assessment were charged to the district. Those gaps made a later, otherwise strong offer late in the school year. Because the offer had no transition plan, the Hearing Officer ordered reimbursement for the parents' home program.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
The District failed to assess for autism, autistic-like behaviors, atypical behaviors and social skills before the October 1999 placement; vague oral suggestions of more testing were not a written assessment plan. The sensory-motor (OT) assessment in April 2000 was timely, and the speech-language assessment was adequate.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
FAPE was denied. The IEPs had no program for atypical behaviors or social-skill deficits, a speech program delivered with the Links to Language manual could not substitute for one, and the speech and OT present levels and goals were too vague or missing. No LRE violation, because a special day class was mentioned but never offered.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
The October 18, 2000 interim offer continued the denial of FAPE. The much-improved November 17, 2000 offer came 2½ months into the school year because of the District's year-long failure to assess, and it had no plan for moving the student out of the CARD program, making regression likely. It was therefore not designed to meet his unique needs.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 and/or 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement?
The CARD program addressed all areas of need and provided educational benefit, so the parents get $49,807.80 in reimbursement for September 2000 through July 2001. The student also gets compensatory education for the missing 1999-2000 behavior and social-skills program. There was no reimbursement for the private preschool, which was not shown to be appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District's failure to offer or provide speech and language services from October 1999 to April 2000?
No compensatory speech-language services. Despite the IEP's defects, the speech program actually delivered produced major progress in 1999-2000.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District's failure to offer or provide occupational therapy services from October 1999 to May 2000?
The District had no duty to provide OT until May 2000, and the OT it then provided led to good progress, so no compensatory OT was awarded.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 7. Is the District required to pay for the independent educational evaluation obtained for STUDENT from Dr. Pearlman?
The District's October-November 2000 assessment was comprehensive and appropriate, and Dr. Perlman's evaluation came after it, so no public funding was ordered.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of the decision, District to pay $49,807.80 as reimbursement for the CARD program covering September 5, 2000 through the end of July 2001.
- Compensatory education. Compensatory services to make up for the District's failure, for the entire 1999-2000 school year, to provide a program addressing atypical behaviors and social-skill deficits. The IEP team sets the amount and form, considering the student's changing needs and tolerance, the underlying FAPE or private program, and the District's continued speech and OT services during 2000-2001. These services are in addition to FAPE services. No hours were specified.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to meet within 30 calendar days of the decision, and as necessary afterward, to determine the compensatory education services.
Total: $49,807.80 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Target Range Sch. Dist.; Burlington; Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Alamo Heights Indep. Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Cal. Educ. Code 56320; Cal. Educ. Code 56321; Cal. Educ. Code 56345; Cal. Educ. Code 56345.5; Cal. Educ. Code 56441.1(b); Cal. Educ. Code 56329(b); Title 5 C.C.R. 3030(g)
People named in the decision
- Laura Rydell, director of support services, Fountain Valley School District
- Jim Hemsley, director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE)
- Ruth Ketchersid, speech and language specialist, Fountain Valley School District
- Juan Ramon Hernandez, school psychologist, Fountain Valley School District
- Barbara Cracchiolo, occupational therapist (OT assessor and provider), WOCCSE
- Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., independent evaluator; expert witness for Student, Private
- Vincent Redmond, clinic supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., clinical director; private evaluator; witness for Student, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
- Linda Forsythe, program specialist, WOCCSE
- Terrie Somers, school psychologist, Fountain Valley School District
- Annemike Brann, speech and language pathologist, Fountain Valley School District
- Glenda McHale, program specialist; expert witness for District, Greater Anaheim SELPA
- Andrea Walker, staff development program coordinator, Orange County Department of Education
- Ira Lott, M.D., child neurologist (evaluating physician), University of California, Irvine
- Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private provider of home-based discrete trial training program
- Fountain Valley Christian Preschool, private preschool attended by Student
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on March 8, 9, April 12, 13, May 1, 2, 15, 16, 17, June 14, 15, and August 9 and 10, 2001, in Huntington Beach, California.
Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Shelli J. Lewis and Jonathan Barron from the law office of Shelli J. Lewis. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner were his mother, MOTHER, and his father, FATHER. Fountain Valley School District (District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by attorney Caroline Zuk from the law office of Miller, Brown, and Dannis. Also present on behalf of the District were Laura Rydell, director of support services for the District, and Jim Hemsley, director of the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE).
The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Laura Rydell; Ruth Ketchersid, speech and language specialist at the District; Juan Ramon Hernandez, school psychologist for the District; MOTHER; FATHER; Barbara Cracchiolo, occupational therapist for WOCCSE; Mitchel Pearlman, Ph.D.; Vincent Redmond, clinic supervisor at the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); and Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., clinical director for CARD. The District called the following witnesses: Linda Forsythe, program specialist for WOCCSE; Terrie Somers, school psychologist for the District; Annemike Brann, speech and language pathologist for the
District; Glenda McHale, program specialist for the Greater Anaheim SELPA; Andrea Walker, staff development program coordinator for the Orange County Department of Education; and Laura Rydell.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was left open until September 4, 2001, for the submission of written closing arguments. The parties’ closing arguments were received on September 5, 2001.
ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 2)
Issue No. 1: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
Issue No. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
Issue No. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 and/or 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement?
Issue No. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide speech and language services from October 1999 to April 2000?
Issue No. 6: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide occupational therapy services from October 1999 to May 2000?
Issue No. 7: Is the District required to pay for the independent educational evaluation obtained for STUDENT from Dr. Pearlman?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The Petitioner alleges that, for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, he was not properly assessed by the district in all areas of suspected disability, that his disabilities were not properly identified, that proper goals and objectives were not developed, and that appropriate services were not offered. The Petitioner seeks reimbursement for private services obtained through a CARD program. The Petitioner also seeks compensatory education. The District alleges that it has offered the Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the school years at issue.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born [date redacted], has deficits arising from autism or autistic-like behaviors, manifested by hyperactivity, attention or distraction problems, social skill deficits, aggressiveness toward other children, perseveration, self-stimulatory behaviors, and resistance to changes in routines. STUDENT has severe deficits in receptive and expressive speech and language. STUDENT has been receiving speech and language services from the District since October 1999. He has been receiving occupational therapy services from the District since May 2000. STUDENT attended Fountain Valley Christian Preschool (FVCP), a nonpublic school, for the 1999-2000 school year. On September 5, 2000, STUDENT began receiving services through a CARD program, about 23 hours per week. STUDENT also attended FVCP during the 2000-2001 school year, but at a reduced frequency of about two days per month.
STUDENT’s mother first contacted the District on July 19, 1999, to inquire about assessment and services. The District’s search and serve intake form states that STUDENT had been showing delayed speech for the past 18 months. Behavior was active, attention was normal. STUDENT was speaking in one-word utterances, and his speech was not clear. He had just been enrolled in FVCP. (Pet. Ex. 1.)
STUDENT’s mother completed a preschool assessment questionnaire form for the District. The responses stated that STUDENT was attending FVCP, five days per week, from 9:00 a.m. to 2:30 p.m. The mother’s stated concern about the child and reason for the referral was, “He can’t hold a conversation, even a simple conversation, with others. His ability to put sentences together is delayed.” The mother’s responses further stated that STUDENT was hyperactive and would not listen when spoken to. His speech difficulties had been noticed by his parents, by his doctor at the 3-year visit, and by his preschool teacher. STUDENT did not appear to be aware of his speech deficits. He had mastered the alphabet and was counting to 10 at the age of two years. (Pet. Ex. 3.)
STUDENT’s mother met with representatives from the District on September 21, 1999, to develop an assessment plan. Present at the meeting were STUDENT, his mother, and Ms. Ketchersid, the District’s speech and language specialist. Ms. Ketchersid observed STUDENT, interviewed his mother, took notes, and completed a “Comprehensive Analysis of Phonological Processes.” An assessment plan was drafted by Ms. Ketchersid and signed by the mother. The plan stated that STUDENT was exhibiting delay in acquisition of communication skills. The suspected areas of disability checked on the form were “Health” and “Language/Communication Function,” to be assessed by a nurse and speech and language specialist, respectively. (Pet. Ex. 4, 5, 6.)
The assessment was performed by an infant preschool assessment team (IPAT) composed of District employees. STUDENT’s mother was interviewed on September 24, 1999, to obtain more details about STUDENT’s history (Pet. Ex. 7, 10). The mother rated STUDENT’s large- and small-muscle coordination as “good.” Clarity of his speech was described as fair, but functional use of language was described as poor. The mother’s primary concern was STUDENT’s communication skill. He was very active, but his parents and siblings could redirect him. At the interview, the nurse observed that STUDENT did not want anyone to sit on overturned chairs. He lined up block chairs and, after turning them over, he walked and jumped on them. He also climbed on the cupboard (about 4 feet high) and tried to jump. The nurse wrote “High activity level.” According to the mother’s report, STUDENT had no problems with sleep, following directions, temper tantrums, short attention span, or physical violence.
The auditory comprehension portion of the “Preschool Language Scale-3" (PLS-3) was administered by Ms. Ketchersid on September 26, 1999 (Pet Ex. 8). STUDENT’s auditory comprehension score was in the second percentile.
STUDENT’s preschool teacher was interviewed by phone on September 27, 1999 (Pet. Ex. 5). The preschool teacher’s comments, as phrased by the District, include: “Constant problems with attending”; “Needs a great deal of attention”; “When first came, was extremely aggressive with other children”; “Extremely immature”; “Academically: knows numbers to 15, all colors, and alphabet”; “Not processing info. Unable to comprehend”; “He’s following directions better now”; “They ring a bell to change activities”; “He copies what we say”; “Echoes a great deal.” He was also noted to sing repetitive phrases.
The IPAT report was initially completed and signed on or about September 27, 1999. (Pet. Ex. 10.) The report recounts the history as summarized above. The report adds that it was extremely difficult to get STUDENT to focus on any given task for any length of time. The interpretations from the PLS-3 included: “STUDENT demonstrates a severe receptive and expressive speech-language delay characterized by inconsistent responses to auditory verbal information and severely limited expressive output.” STUDENT was noted to have exceptional rote memory. He was able to “name call,” but he could not link meaning with a picture or object. The IPAT report concluded that “STUDENT appears to qualify as an individual with exceptional needs in the psychological areas of receptive/expressive language processing as described in Title V, Section 3030.”(Footnote 3)
The IPAT report states that “the team scheduled further evaluation sessions with STUDENT, and the mother requested that she did not wish to continue with the evaluation at this time. However, she is requesting speech and language services only at this time.”
An addendum to the IPAT report summarizes a classroom observation made on October 1, 1999, by Ms. Ketchersdid and an associate. The addendum also summarizes statements made by the teacher during that visit. According to the addendum, STUDENT had continual difficulties with attending, and he needed constant redirection. However, he had improved greatly and could now follow directions with some prompting. He would make use of other children in order to follow the routine of the classroom. He would repeat statements made by the teacher. He could attend to the task at hand, such as coloring on a ditto picture. He echoed many verbal phrases. When the teacher read a book to the class, he would touch each page of the book. There were “many perseverative behaviors noted” (repetitive behaviors).
An IEP meeting was held on October 5, 1999 (Pet. Ex. 12). The agreed-upon IEP was for speech and language services, 2 sessions per week, 60 minutes per session. Present levels of performance and goals and objectives were attached, all with regard to speech and language. Special day class (SDC) discussed. The parents decided to keep STUDENT in the regular FVCP program.(Footnote 4)
On October 22, 1999, Ms. Ketchersid administered the expressive communication portion of the PLS-3 to STUDENT. Expressive communication was in the fifth percentile. His total language score, after combining the expressive communication score with the previous auditory comprehension scores, was in the second percentile.
On January 10, 2000, STUDENT was examined by Ira Lott, M.D., director of child neurology at the University of California, Irvine. Dr. Lott’s report stated the 3 ½ year old child was seen for “possible autism.” The report stated that STUDENT had been working with a speech and language therapist who had noted a few atypical behaviors including echolalia and over-activity. Dr. Lott stated: “[STUDENT] has a few autistic traits but he lacks many of the salient features of autism. He does have some gaze avoidance up close, prefers parallel rather than interactive play with peers, and has somewhat delayed language development. However, he lacks many of the other traits of autism including transitional difficulties, sensitivity to loud sounds, perseveration and compulsions. The echolalia was consistent with autism but was somewhat nonspecific.”
Dr. Lott concluded that STUDENT should continue in his preschool program with emphasis on speech, language, and socialization. Dr. Lott stated that it would be inappropriate to place STUDENT in a class with severely autistic children and that STUDENT should be mainstreamed whenever possible. Dr. Lott stated that in children with mild or borderline autism such as STUDENT, the autistic symptoms often disappear as the child gets older. (Dist. Ex. 11.)
Pursuant to the parent’s request, the District performed a sensory motor evaluation on STUDENT. The occupational therapy (OT) report dated April 14, 2000, concluded that STUDENT was having some difficulties with sensory processing, specifically with vestibular (sense of movement), proprioceptive (information from muscles and joints), and tactile (sense of touch) input. He had little idea of what to do with toys, and poor ideation of play.
On May 15, 2000, an addendum was added to the October 5, 1999 IEP. The addendum provided for one 45-minute session of OT per week during the regular school year and through October 5, 2000 (Pet. Ex. 16). An IEP addendum dated June 7, 2000, provided for speech and language services during the summer session (Pet. Ex. 17).
STUDENT’s speech and language therapist, Ms. Ketchersid, sent a progress report to Dr. Lott dated June 9, 2000. The report stated that STUDENT had been receiving speech and language services through the District since October 1999. Attendance had been excellent and his family had been extremely supportive. The report stated that “STUDENT presents with a significant receptive and expressive language disorder. He exhibits delay in syntax and morphology, but of greatest concern is his atypical development in areas of pragmatics and semantics. Since October, STUDENT has demonstrated significant progress and is now initiating meaningful requests and comments. His attention and comprehension of auditory stimuli remain inconsistent.” (Pet. Ex. 18.)
On May 24, 2000, STUDENT’s parents had him evaluated by Doreen Granpeesheh, Ph.D., at the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD). Dr. Granpeesheh’s report dated May 24, 2000 (Dist. Ex. 45), appears to be based entirely upon her interview with STUDENT’s parents and her observations of STUDENT during that interview. The report states that STUDENT had been attending a private preschool in a typical class setting for approximately 4 ½ hours per day, 5 times per week. He was receiving about 2 ½ hours of speech and language services per week from Ms. Ketchersid, and OT for about 45 minutes per week. STUDENT’s speech appeared to be limited to his immediate tangible needs, and his eye contact was poor. Self-help skills were fairly age appropriate. He exhibited several maladaptive behaviors. Specifically, he was noncompliant when his parents asked him to do something he did not want to do. He mirrored his environment when others around him were excited, and then would have trouble resuming a normal temperament. Tantrums occurred about once per week; STUDENT would throw himself on the floor or sometimes hit people near him. He would sometimes try to hit or bite his siblings. He also would run away from his parents. There were self-stimulatory behaviors such as repeating words from computer or video games, usually in context. He would line up books in a particular order. He would adhere to strict routines throughout the day, and would become upset when a different person picked him up from school or when his parents would drive a different route. Socially, the report states that STUDENT’s toy play was appropriate. He was very attached to his family members. He was interested in other children, but did not know how to approach them. His social play was parallel, but had improved since he started school. In the assessment room, he was observed attempting to engage his father by saying, “Daddy, let’s play blocks!” He was also observed by Dr. Granpeesheh to avoid eye contact at close range with less familiar individuals. His parents stated he could understand much of what was said to him, and he could follow instructions without visual cues, such as “Let’s go to the park.” However, he had difficulty with abstract concepts, being unable to give an appropriate response to questions like, “Is Kevin your friend?”
Regarding expressive language, Dr. Granpeesheh’s report states that STUDENT could use a number of phrases and labels appropriately. His vocabulary had expanded greatly in the past six months, especially since beginning speech therapy. He used a large amount of expressive language during play and to point out objects of interest, as observed by Dr. Granpeesheh. He would typically speak in full sentences with fairly clear articulation. He was reported by the parents to have a difficult time answering questions about what he had done, but could understand when given a cue such as “Tell Daddy about playing ball today.”
Dr. Granpeesheh concluded that STUDENT was exhibiting a “variety of impairments and behaviors which fall within the diagnosis of Pervasive Developmental Disorder, Not Otherwise Specified (DSM IV - 299.80).” His social interactions were marked by a failure to develop appropriate peer relations and by deficits in the use of social behaviors such as eye contact. His communication skills were delayed in receptive and expressive language. He displayed a variety of self-stimulatory behaviors including repetitive verbalizations, lining up objects, and strict adherence to routines.
Dr. Granpeesheh’s recommendation was 40 hours per week of one-on-one home-based behavioral intervention in the form of discrete trial training (DTT), otherwise referred to by the parties as a “CARD program.” She also recommended a battery of cognitive and language assessments to measure his baseline skills, with annual testing to evaluate his progress and assess the impact of treatment.
By letter dated August 18, 2000, STUDENT’s parents requested the District to convene an IEP meeting as soon as possible. The letter states that the parents intended to place STUDENT in a DTT program and seek reimbursement for the costs. The letter was intended to provide the notice required by Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56176. (Pet. Ex. 19.)
An IEP meeting was held on October 18, 2000 (Dist. Ex. 18). Pending further evaluation, the District offered 45 minutes of OT per week and 90 minutes of individual and 60 minutes of group speech and language services per week. The District presented three goals and objectives for speech and language and five goals and objectives for OT.
Meanwhile, CARD had produced a report dated October 18, 2000, entitled “Initial Review.” (Dist. Ex. 17.) The report consisted of two pages of narrative report entitled “Initial Review” dated October 18, 2000; a “quarterly report” for the period from commencement of STUDENT’s CARD program on September 5, 2000, through September 30, 2000, consisting of drill summaries; 35 pages of goals and objectives; and an additional two pages of recommendations for continuing CARD therapy at a minimum of 30 hours per week, plus 6 hours per month of clinical supervision. The report stated that STUDENT had been receiving 23 hours per week of behavioral and educational programs through CARD, classified as “home behavioral intervention.” The report stated that STUDENT had made significant progress since starting at CARD. Initially, according to the report, he had little functional communication, limited interest in appropriate toy play, a high incidence of noncompliance, a lack of proper impulse control, a lack of some appropriate self-help skills, a high incidence of several kinds of self-stimulatory behaviors, and substantial expressive language delay. Following 3 ½ weeks of intervention, he was communicating more spontaneously by making statements, inquiries, and/or requesting his needs and wants. His self-stimulatory behaviors were decreasing, and he was playing with many of his toys and games more appropriately. He still showed great need for improvement in the areas of independence, impulse control, self-calming skills, auditory processing, social skills, and play skills.
The CARD report was presented at the October 18, 2000 IEP meeting. Placement options mentioned at the meeting were the current speech and language and OT programs, the District’s preschool SDC program, and the parents’ current CARD program. However, the District made it quite clear that it did not intend to pay for a CARD program. The IEP team agreed upon an assessment plan to determine present levels of performance and develop an appropriate placement. Assessment would be in the areas of health, motor ability, language/communication, general intellectual ability, academic performance, and social and emotional adaptive skills. (Pet. Ex. 27.) Comments on the IEP mention that the IPAT had recommended further evaluation sessions in September 1999 that, according to the IPAT report, had been declined by the mother. However, the parents claim that they never refused further evaluation, and that they did not see the 1999 IPAT report until October 2000.
STUDENT’s parents agreed to the implementation of the speech and language and OT services listed on the October 18, 2000 IEP, but they attached a 3-page dissent. In the dissent, the parents disagreed with the District’s assertion that the parents refused assessments of STUDENT. The parents asserted in the dissent that they were offered an “SDC autism class” in October 1999. The dissent also stated that the District was refusing to consider the information provided by CARD, that the District limited the IEP meeting to one hour, and that the District stated it would never consider a CARD program. In the dissent, the parents requested funding of the CARD program, incorporation of the CARD goals and objectives into the IEP, and reimbursement of the CARD services provided to date.
The District conducted further assessments, as summarized in the IPAT report dated November 7, 2000 (Dist. Ex. 27). The report notes that STUDENT was currently receiving speech and language services as designated on the October 18, 2000 IEP. He was also receiving the CARD services, and he was attending FVCP every other Monday. The team observed STUDENT during his at-home CARD sessions, in his FVCP class, and during the evaluation sessions. On the PLS-3, administered on October 17, 2000, STUDENT scored in the 68th percentile for auditory comprehension, 8th percentile for expressive communication, and 30th percentile overall for total language. His PLS-3 percentile scores on September 26, 1999, had been 2nd , 5th, and 2nd, respectively. On the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (K-ABC), his mental processing composite was in the 55th percentile. According to the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R), his developmental age was 48 months (his actual age was almost 53 months). He rated at 34 months in fine motor, 61 months in gross motor, 36 months in eye-hand integration, 64 months in perception, 54 months in imitation, 50 months in cognitive performance, and 50 months in verbal cognitive. On the Young Children’s Achievement Test (Y-CAT), he rated in the 42nd percentile in general information, 75th in reading, and 65th in mathematics, but only 9th in writing and 8th in spoken language. On the Scale of Independent Behavior-Revised (SIB-R), his percentile scores were 2nd in broad independence, 8th in motor skills (limited to very limited in fine motor by age-appropriate in gross motor), 0.2 in social/communication, 1st in personal living, and 6th in community living. In the PEP-R on behavior scales he rated “appropriate to mild” in relating, materials, language, and “appropriate” in sensory. On the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS)-Parent, his autism quotient, which measures the probability of autism, was “below average,” and on the autism behavior checklist he scored 57 (autistic = total score > 77). On the Behavior Assessment System for Children (BASC)-Parent Rating Scales, STUDENT was rated “at risk” in hyperactivity, attention problems, social skills, and adaptive skills composite.
The IPAT report concluded that STUDENT’s cognitive skills were within the average range. His strengths were in the perceptual and gross motor areas. He also had above age-level skills in reading and mathematics. He was age appropriate in imitation and general information skills. STUDENT demonstrated delays in fine motor, sensory-motor, writing, and adaptive areas. He displayed hyperactive and inattentive behaviors. The report states that he was found to exhibit characteristics of a child within the autism spectrum, that he met the Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g) criteria as “autistic,” and that he also met the “Section 3030(c)” criteria as a child with a speech and language impairment. Recommendations were to strengthen his communication, expressive language, and socialization skills, and to provide behavioral support at school.(Footnote 5)
An IEP meeting was held on November 17, 2000 (Dist. Ex. 34). The District had reviewed the CARD recommendations. The District’s offer was speech and language services, 120 minutes per week; social skills group, 120 minutes per week; OT, 45 minutes per week at the WOCCSE clinic; behavioral consultation, 4 hours per month; staff consult regarding autism, 4 hours per month. The District stated that it would agree to fund a private preschool (including FVCP) for 15 hours per week until a placement at Head Start for 15 hours per week was obtained.
The parents agreed to continue the OT goals and objectives from the previous IEP dated October 18, 2000. The parents attached a dissent to the November 17, 2000 IEP. The parents requested 40 hours per week of “Lovaas type therapy;” 10 hours of supervision by CARD (monthly); 3 sessions of speech therapy per week, 60 minutes per session; OT twice per week, 60 minutes each session; and continued funding of private preschool with a shadow aide by a therapist trained and supervised by CARD (as part of the 40-hour-per-week program). The parents also claimed that the “District SDC placement” was not the least restrictive environment for STUDENT, as he imitates peers and needs appropriate peer models.
MOTHER testified that because of her inability to reach an agreement with the District regarding STUDENT’s program, she sought an independent assessment from Mitchel D. Perlman, Ph.D. The report by Dr. Perlman dated February 25, 2001, states that the District offered a deficient program and that STUDENT should remain in the CARD program pending further review by the IEP team, which Dr. Perlman recommended for March 2001. (Pet. Ex. 47.)
Through the commencement of the due process hearing, STUDENT continued to receive speech and language services from the District. He continued in the CARD program, and he continued to attend FVCP twice per month.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320 provides that before any action is taken with regard to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs, assessment of the pupil’s educational needs shall be conducted by qualified persons “in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional status.”
The Petitioner claims that prior to the initial placement, the District failed to assess him in all areas related to his suspected disability in the 1999-2000 school year. Specifically, the Petitioner claims that the District failed to assess him in areas related to autism or autistic-like behaviors, for sensory-motor disabilities, and for speech and language. The District asserts that STUDENT was properly assessed. The District also asserts that further assessments were recommended by the District, and that the parents refused to allow further assessment.
I. Assessment for autism and autistic-like behaviors.
Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030, describes impairments that may qualify a pupil as an individual with exceptional needs, and thereby entitle the pupil to special education and related services if required by the degree of impairment. The impairment of “autistic-like behaviors” is described in Sec. 3030(g), which states:
“(g) A pupil exhibits any combination of the following autistic-like behaviors, to include but not limited to: (1) An inability to use oral language for appropriate communication. (2) A history of extreme withdrawal or relating to people inappropriately and continued impairment in social interaction from infancy through early childhood. (3) An obsession to maintain sameness.
(4) Extreme resistance to controls.
(5) Displays peculiar motoric mannerisms and motility patterns. (6) Self-stimulating, ritualistic behavior.”
The definition of “autism” in Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.7 is similar to the definition of “autistic-like behaviors” in Sec. 3030(g). The Sec. 300.7 definition of autism is “ a developmental disability significantly affecting verbal and nonverbal communication and social interaction, generally evident before age 3, that adversely affects a child’s educational performance. Other characteristics often associated with autism are engagement in repetitive activities and stereotyped movements, resistance to environmental change or change in daily routines, and unusual responses to sensory experiences . . . .”
The September/October 1999 IPAT report states, “STUDENT demonstrates a severe receptive and expressive speech-language delay characterized by inconsistent responses to auditory verbal information and severely limited expressive output.” Therefore, STUDENT, as a preschool child, displayed the primary characteristic of autism and/or autistic like behaviors as those terms are defined in Sec. 300.7 and Sec. 3030(g). Dr. Perlman testified that when a preschool-age child exhibits severe speech and language problems, the probability of autism becomes a concern, and a comprehensive assessment is vital.
The need for additional assessment was further supported by the fact that speech and language deficits were not STUDENT’s only areas of concern. STUDENT was exhibiting what Ms. Ketchersid characterized as “atypical behaviors.” These behaviors are listed in the September/October 1999 IPAT report. STUDENT had been extremely aggressive with other children at FVCP. STUDENT echoed many phrases, sang repetitive phrases, and engaged in perseveration behaviors. He would touch each page of the preschool teacher’s book when she read to the classroom during story time. At the initial observation by the District, he turned over block chairs and would not let other people sit on them. He was hyperactive and would not listen when spoken to. According to the report of Dr. Lott and the testimony of Dr. Granpeesheh and Dr. Perlman, such behaviors are consistent with a diagnosis of autism.
Ms. McHale was called by the District to testify as an expert. Upon questioning by the Hearing Officer, she stated that there were “some concerning markers” in the September/October IPAT report regarding STUDENT’s behaviors, and that, consequently, additional assessments should have been performed. She testified that although all children exhibit some “behaviors,” intervention would have been required for STUDENT’s behaviors if they were preventing STUDENT from accessing his learning or interfering with other children in his class. Ms. McHale testified that information regarding the degree of STUDENT’s behaviors was insufficient. Specifically, a diagnosis had not been made. According to Ms. McHale, information was needed for a diagnosis of STUDENT’s condition, and a more comprehensive investigation was needed regarding STUDENT’s social skills, behavior, and general functioning. She testified that if the parents had refused additional assessments, the District should have discussed the matter with the parents, encouraged them to reconsider, and then presented an assessment plan. The testimony of Ms. McHale and Dr. Perlman confirms what should have been obvious to the IPAT. The observations of STUDENT and the interview with the preschool teacher produced information about STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and lack of social skills that required further assessment, especially when considered in combination with STUDENT’s severe speech and language deficits. No plan for further assessment was submitted to the parents. Instead, the assessment conducted by the IPAT began and ended with some questions about STUDENT’s health history, an interview of STUDENT’s preschool teacher, some observations of STUDENT, and a portion of the PLS-3 for speech and language.
The District asserts that the IPAT orally recommended further evaluations, and that the mother either declined or refused further evaluation. The mother asserts that she never declined recommendations by the District for additional evaluation.
At the hearing, the District was unable to provide reliable detail regarding its alleged recommendations for further assessment. The District’s witnesses could not recall the specific type of evaluations offered. They could not recall the time or place of any specific communications regarding the alleged offers of additional evaluations, or the alleged rejection of those offers. In any event, recommendations, especially vague recommendations, do not constitute an assessment plan. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56321 requires that a proposed assessment plan must be submitted to parents in writing. There was no plan, written or otherwise, for further assessment. Without a plan, there could be no rejection of a plan by the mother.
In summary, a plan for assessment in all areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability was mandatory pursuant to Sec. 56320. The District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the areas of autism, autistic-like behaviors, and/or his atypical behaviors and social skills as described above. The District presented no written assessment plan for those areas. Even if further assessment was recommended orally, the District cannot show that its alleged oral recommendations to the mother constituted an appropriate plan.
II. Assessment for sensory-motor skills.
By request of the mother and Ms. Ketchersid, STUDENT was assessed by an OT for sensory-motor difficulties pursuant to an assessment plan dated April 14, 2000 (Pet. Ex. 13). The Petitioner claims that his sensory-motor skills should have been assessed in September 1999. The District claims it had no notice prior to the end of March 2000 that sensory-motor skills was an area of suspected disability.
On the search and serve intake form dated July 19, 1999, the mother denied that STUDENT had any physical limitations or coordination problems (Pet. Ex. 1). During the health and developmental history interview on September 24, 1999, the mother stated that STUDENT’s large- and small-muscle coordination was “good.” (Pet. Ex. 7.) On the undated preschool assessment questionnaire, there was no indication of motor problems, although the question is not specifically asked on the form (Pet. Ex. 3).Ms. Ketchersid testified that she did not see a significant problem with STUDENT’s motor skills, although that is not her area of expertise. Ms. Ketchersid did not recall when she first realized that STUDENT might have OT needs. The OT evaluator and therapist, Ms. Cracchiolo, testified that she was first contacted by Ms. Ketchersid on March 28, 2000, regarding an OT assessment plan.
According to the OT evaluation, STUDENT’s sensory-motor deficits were manifested by STUDENT tending “to seek out a lot of [sensory] input” and by having a poor ideation of play (Pet. Ex. 14). Apparently, STUDENT’s mother and the IPAT team, consisting of a speech and language specialist, school nurse, school psychologist, and special education teacher, did not notice these manifestations, or at least did not connect them with a sensory-motor problem. The IPAT report did not mention these manifestations.
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320 requires assessment in all areas related to the suspected disability prior to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs. The evidence shows that sensory-motor deficits were not an area related to a suspected disability prior to STUDENT’s initial placement in October 1999. There was no evidence that a proper assessment of STUDENT for autism and autistic-like behaviors in October 1999 would have revealed sensory-motor deficits. When the District and/or the parents suspected that sensory-motor deficits were present in STUDENT and, thereby, related to a suspected area of disability, the District scheduled the appropriate OT assessment.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to assess STUDENT in the area of sensory-motor deficits prior to his initial placement in October 1999. The District’s OT assessment for suspected sensory-motor deficits, performed on April 14, 2000, was timely.
III. Speech and language assessment.
On September 26, 1999, Ms. Ketchersid administered the auditory comprehension portion of the PLS-3 to STUDENT. On October 5, 1999, the parties agreed to the IEP presented by the District for speech and language services. On October 22, 1999, Ms. Ketchersid administered the expressive communication portion of the IEP to STUDENT. The Petitioner claims the parents were not made aware of the October 22, 1999 assessment until November 2000, and that the assessment should have resulted in an IEP meeting to discuss further goals and objectives.
Ms. Ketchersid testified that she believes she reviewed the expressive communication test results with STUDENT’s parents. She testified that she did not use that portion of the PLS-3 to qualify STUDENT for speech and language services because he did not need it.
The present inquiry is whether the District complied with the assessment requirements in Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320 when it assessed STUDENT in speech and language prior to his initial placement.
Sec. 56320 requires assessment in all areas of suspected disability prior to the initial placement of an individual with exceptional needs. Sec. 56320 does not elaborate on the degree of assessment required for each area of suspected disability. It can be inferred, however, that the purpose of the assessment is to gain enough information to develop an appropriate program for all identified areas of disability. In STUDENT’s case, the purpose of the speech and language assessment was to gain enough information to develop an appropriate speech and language program. Prior to the October 5, 1999 IEP, Ms. Ketchersid obtained enough information from parent interviews, observation, and assessment tools, to state in the IPAT that STUDENT demonstrated “a severe receptive and expressive speech-language delay characterized by inconsistent responses to auditory verbal information and severely limited expressive output.” This confirms that Ms. Ketchersid did not need the expressive communication portion of the PLS-3 to conclude that STUDENT had severely limited expressive output. The District included goals and objectives specifically for STUDENT’s expressive language skills in the October 5, 1999 IEP, and Ms. Ketchersid felt she had sufficient data to develop an appropriate plan. For present levels of performance, Ms Ketchersid wrote that STUDENT’s expressive language was characterized by few initiated meaningful communicated utterances as indicated by parent report and observation. The results of the expressive communication portion of the PLS-3 (expressive communication in the 5th percentile) were consistent with her prior findings.(Footnote 6)
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District properly assessed STUDENT in speech and language prior to his initial placement.
IV. Summary.
The District was not required to assess STUDENT in the area of sensory-motor deficits prior to his initial placement in October 1999. The District’s OT assessment for suspected sensory-motor deficits, performed on April 14, 2000, was timely. The District properly assessed STUDENT in speech and language prior to his initial placement.
However, the District failed to assess STUDENT in the areas of autism, autistic-like behaviors, and/or atypical behaviors and social skills. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability prior to his initial placement in October 1999. The effects of the District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT will be addressed in the discussion of FAPE for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years (Issue Nos. 2 and 3).
Issue No. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year?
Under State and federal law, individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1401(8).
The term “special education” means specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parent, to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs, whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services,” at no cost to the parent, that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
The parameters for adequacy of a student’s IEP are set forth in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982). The United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide some educational benefit to the student. Rowley, at 207-208.
To determine whether the District offered the Petitioner a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District's proposed program would have addressed the Petitioner’s unique needs, provided him some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP, then the District offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents' preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.
In summary, there are two overall categories of inquiry. One category of inquiry is substantive appropriateness. Under the IDEA , State law, and Rowley, the program the District has proposed for the 2001-2002 school year must have met the following four substantive requirements to have constituted an appropriate educational program for the Petitioner: (I) designed to meet his unique needs, (II) reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, (III) comport with his IEP, and (IV) provide him an education in the least restrictive environment. The other category of inquiry is procedural appropriateness: Has the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA?
Substantive Appropriateness
I. Did the District offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
A. STUDENT’s unique needs.
Prior to determining whether the District offered a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs.
Atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. For the 1999-2000 school year, the Petitioner asserts that he had unique needs arising from autism and autistic-like behaviors, manifested by atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. Some of STUDENT’s atypical behaviors were listed in the September/October 1999 IPAT report. STUDENT had been extremely aggressive with other children at FVCP. STUDENT echoed many phrases, sang repetitive phrases, and engaged in perseveration behaviors. He was hyperactive and would not listen when spoken to.
The District basically asserts that such behaviors and social skill deficits were not identified by the IPAT or the IEP team as existing to such a degree that intervention was required for the 1999-2000 school year. Therefore, according to the District, STUDENT did not have unique needs arising from those behaviors or his level of social skills. That argument can be promptly discarded. Other information about STUDENT’s behaviors and social skills during the 1999-2000 school year is available. The deficient assessment resulting in a deficient IPAT report did not erase STUDENT’s actual needs.
Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT presented with a “plethora” of behavioral difficulties at age 3. He had limited interest in appropriate play. He would pull toys off the shelf but did not know what to do with them. He had a lack of impulse control. He would knock down chairs, bite people, run out of the room, and not listen. He had a high level of self-stimulatory behaviors and odd ritual behaviors. For example, a person sleeping in STUDENT’s room would have to wear a white T-shirt. Socially, he did not play with people or things. He was very egocentric, showing no reciprocal play. If he was in a room with three people and needed something, he would ask for it but would not direct his request to a particular person. Dr. Perlman agreed there was a scarcity of assessment information about STUDENT in October 1999 for purposes of stating what an appropriate program would have been at that time, but Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT did need a program in October 1999 to address his behaviors and social skill deficits. Dr. Perlman stated it is extremely important to address behavior problems intensively and as early as possible in the classroom for two reasons. First, until the behavior is brought under control the child’s learning is impeded or halted. Second, having a child misbehave in a classroom for an extended period of time is equivalent to training him to misbehave in the classroom.
The father testified about STUDENT’s lack of eye contact, high energy level going from one object to the next without playing with it, and mimicking other children’s behaviors in the wrong context. In tag games at preschool, STUDENT would aggressively chase the other children. In T-ball, STUDENT would run after the ball and tackle other children, if necessary, so he could get the ball. STUDENT would grab things in people’s homes and take things away from people as a method for getting their attention. There were safety concerns when STUDENT would “take off” without worrying about the consequences. STUDENT would not address people by looking at them and speaking directly to a person when he wanted something. When STUDENT asked for something, it was like a “command out into space”; one could not ascertain whom STUDENT was speaking to. The father testified emphatically that he wanted early services for STUDENT so that STUDENT could eventually be in regular classes with normal students, not feel “different” later, and essentially have a normal life. The latter comments of the father show how serious the father considered STUDENT’s social and behavioral deficits to be.
The mother testified that during the 1999-2000 school year, Ms Ketchersid would report to her that STUDENT was aggressive in the speech class. Once he bit another child, but did not break the skin. There was another aggressive boy in the class, and it was necessary to keep them separated.
The District’s witnesses consistently stated that STUDENT was successful in his FVCP class, even without a program to address his behaviors. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT’s experiences at FVCP were nearly as positive as the District’s characterization of those experiences. There was no evidence to show that the behaviors described by the preschool teacher to the IPAT in September 1999, or the behaviors observed by the IPAT in STUDENT’s preschool class on October 1, 2000, subsided to any significant degree during the 1999-2000 school year in the FVCP setting. Ms. Ketchersid testified that she observed improvement in STUDENT’s behaviors during the 1999-2000 school year. However, this does not mean that STUDENT’s behaviors were improved when he was outside of Ms. Ketchersid’s skillful control. Ms. Ketchersid only saw STUDENT for two hours per week. The observations of the parents are a more reliable indicator of STUDENT’s behavioral problems. The parents were with STUDENT not only more frequently, but also in a broader range of environments and situations. The testimony of STUDENT’s parents demonstrated that STUDENT’s continued presence in FVCP was largely a function of that school’s willingness to tolerate his adverse behaviors. The parents authorized the teachers at FVCP to grab STUDENT when necessary to get him under control. The mother testified that, for her, STUDENT’s aggressive behavior had always been an issue.
The evidence shows that STUDENT would need major improvement in atypical behaviors and social skills before he could successfully attend a regular kindergarten class or other grades. One of the specific purposes of early education programs for individuals with exceptional needs is to “reduce the need for special class placement in special education programs once the children reach school age.” Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56441(f). Additionally, with regard to children with exceptional needs, “as the preschool child approaches the age to enter an elementary school environment, the child’s preparation shall be geared toward a readiness for kindergarten and later school success.” Cal. Educ. Code 56441.1(b).
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of atypical behaviors and social skill deficits throughout the 1999-2000 school year. Intervention was required to meet those needs. Furthermore, the District should have made this determination by performing a proper assessment in September/October 1999.(Footnote 7) The consequences of the District’s failure to make a timely determination will be addressed in the discussion of remedies in Issue No. 4.
Sensory-motor. STUDENT had unique needs arising from sensory-motor deficits. The Hearing Officer has previously found that the District’s OT assessment for suspected sensory-motor deficits, performed on April 14, 2000, was timely. The District’s obligation to provide services to address STUDENT’s sensory-motor deficits commenced after the April 14, 2000 OT assessment.
Speech and language. Pursuant to the assessment conducted by the IPAT in September/ October 1999, STUDENT was found to qualify as an individual with exceptional needs in the psychological areas of receptive/expressive language processing as described in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030. STUDENT was identified as having severe receptive and expressive speech and language delay, characterized by inconsistent responses to auditory verbal information and severely limited expressive output. STUDENT needed speech and language services to address his receptive and expressive speech and language delays.
B. The District’s program.
In determining whether the District offered a program for the 1999-2000 school year that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the next step is to compare the program to STUDENT’s identified needs. As established above, STUDENT needed intervention throughout the 1999-2000 school year to address his atypical behaviors, social skill deficits and speech and language delays. Following the April 2000 OT assessment, STUDENT needed OT to address his sensory-motor deficits.
The program pursuant to the October 5, 1999 IEP was speech and language services, 2 sessions per week, 60 minutes per session. The annual goals were to improve receptive language/comprehension by following directions incorporating target concepts and vocabulary, and to improve functional use of expressive language by initiating meaningful requests and/or comments. Special day class was mentioned but was not offered. The parents kept STUDENT at FVCP at their own expense.
Pursuant to the IEP addendum dated May 19, 2000, the District added OT, once per week, for 45 minutes through October 5, 2000, during the regular school year.(Footnote 8) No present levels of performance and no goals and objectives were listed for OT.
Atypical behaviors and social skills. The October 5, 1999 IEP was bereft of services designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. There were no services designed to address his hyperactivity, his attention or distraction problems, his social skill deficits, or his other behaviors such as aggressiveness toward other children. This deficiency in the agreed-upon IEP was one of the consequences of the District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year.
In spite of the deficiencies in the IEPs for the 1999-2000 school year, the District asserts that services to address STUDENT’s attention deficits, social skills, and other atypical behaviors and/or autism or autistic-like disorders were delivered by Ms. Ketchersid through the Links to Language (Links) program. Ms. Ketchersid used the Links program as a major element of STUDENT’s speech and language program. The Links program recognizes that children with a pervasive developmental disorder, such as STUDENT, require specialized instruction to learn the complex processes involved in the manipulation, comprehension, and conceptualization of oral linguistic information through interaction with others. Consequently, the Links program includes, among other components, exercises to develop a child’s ability to consciously attend, recall and recognize actions and events relating to people and objects, analyze tasks involving multiple elements, recall information, and maintain attention to task. As a side benefit, according to the authors of the Links program, social skills are developed because the child becomes accustomed to sustained and successful interactions during therapy. Therefore, the District argues, STUDENT’s behaviors were sufficiently addressed through the Links speech and language program.
Special education law envisions that a pupil’s unique needs will be met through the specific and calculated design of an IEP. The design in an IEP starts with specifically identifying the pupil’s areas of disability and present levels of performance. Goals and objectives are developed. Services are designated to enable the pupil to reach those goals and objectives. The goals and objectives must be measurable, enabling evaluation and appropriate adjustment of the program as it proceeds.(Footnote 9)
With respect to STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and social skills deficits, no program was identified or provided in the IEP. The Hearing Officer recognizes the likelihood and even the common necessity of overlapping services when a pupil has multiple areas of disability or impairment. In particular, speech and language services will often overlap with services for other characteristics of autism. The District has attempted to substitute the manual in the Links to Language Program for the specific and individually structured design that is required in an IEP. The ancillary delivery of a few applicable services through the Links to Language program did not approach the required specificity and substance of an appropriate program designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. Furthermore, the Links program was only delivered to STUDENT by Ms Ketchersid for two hours per week. Even if all of the two hours had been devoted specifically to addressing STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and social skill deficits, STUDENT required more than a two-hour-per-week program to address those behaviors and deficits.
The Hearing Officer finds that for the 1999-2000 school year, the District did not offer a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits.
Speech and language. Ms. Ketchersid testified that the priority speech and language needs for STUDENT in October 1999 were help with the following: attending and comprehending auditory information; memory and focus in pre-verbal and linguistic tasks, enabling him to be ready to learn; expanding the fragments of his language which were sometimes non-meaningful; engaging in meaningful conversation; relating lifetime experiences to his language; and transferring his knowledge and skills into all his communicative settings. Some of the above skills were essentially absent. Ms. Ketchersid testified in detail about other levels of STUDENT’s performance. She testified, for example, about limited or lack of understanding with regard to prepositions, pronouns, quantity concepts, part and whole relationships, categories, and negatives.
For speech and language, the October 5, 1999 IEP describes STUDENT’s present levels of performance as a receptive language delay, indicated by observation, parent report, and a percentile rank of 2 on the auditory comprehension subtest of the PLS-3; and as an expressive language delay, characterized by few initiated meaningful utterances, as indicated by parent report and observation. This was consistent with the IPAT. The annual goals were to have STUDENT demonstrate improved receptive language/comprehension by following directions incorporating target concepts and vocabulary, and to have STUDENT demonstrate improved functional use of expressive language by initiating meaningful requests and or comments. Two periodic objectives for each annual goal were briefly listed for measuring progress.
The detail in Ms. Ketchersid’s memory and personal working notes (Pet. Ex. 161) related to STUDENT’s needs and present levels of performance is far superior to the comparatively scant and vague information on the IEP. The present levels of performance listed in the October 5, 1999 IEP make no mention of the levels of STUDENT’s ability, if any, for memory and focus in pre-verbal and linguistic tasks, relating lifetime experiences to his language, transferring his knowledge and skills into communicative settings, or understanding or use of prepositions, pronouns, quantity concepts, part and whole relationships, categories, and negatives. The goals and objectives are similarly lacking in specificity. When questioned about this discrepancy between her detailed knowledge of STUDENT and the apparently scant details in the IEP, Ms. Ketchersid testified that all of those more-detailed components of STUDENT’s needs and present levels of performance were inclusive and encompassed in the goals and objectives. When asked whether a new speech and language pathologist who might replace Ms. Ketchersid would be able to identify those needs and levels of performance in the briefly-stated goals and objectives on the IEP, Ms. Ketchersid stated she would speak with any new provider about those details.
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 requires a program that is specific with regard to identifying the pupil’s areas of disability, identifying the services that will be provided to address those disabilities, identifying the measurable goals that are intended to be met through those services, and identifying a plan for measuring progress toward those goals.
The Hearing Officer is fully persuaded that when the October 5, 1999 IEP was developed, Ms. Ketchersid knew, with some precision, STUDENT’s speech and language needs, his present levels of performance, and how her use of the Links program would meet those needs. However, Ms. Ketchersid’s knowledge about STUDENT and his program is not the test for the adequacy of his IEP. Detail is necessary in the IEP. Detail allows the determination of, through the course of a program, what the pupil’s achievement has been and what the future expectations are for the program. In addition, detail in the IEP allows the child’s progress to be ascertained and measured by someone other than the person most knowledgeable about the child’s needs and program. In STUDENT’s case, the lack of detail in present levels of performance and goals and objectives, caused the October 5, 1999 IEP to be deficient in its design of a plan to meet STUDENT’s speech and language needs.
Sensory-motor. A program for addressing STUDENT’s sensory-motor needs should have emerged in the IEP addendum in May 2000. However, there mere designation of OT services 45 minutes per week does not constitute a program designed to meet unique needs. The IEP addendum is devoid of a description of STUDENT’s disability, present levels of performance, goals and objectives, or what needs or disability the OT is intended to address. Motor deficits are not even mentioned in the IEP addendum.
C. Summary.
For the 1999-2000 school year, the program offered by the District was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. There was no attempt at designing a program specifically to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. The program offered to STUDENT for his speech and language deficits, due to deficiencies in the statement of present levels of performance and goals and objectives in the IEP, was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in speech and language. The OT program offered in May 2000 IEP addendum was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his sensory-motor deficits. The IEP addendum contained no description of STUDENT’s pertinent disability, present levels of performance, goals and objectives.
II. Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
In determining what meets the Rowley standard of “some educational benefit” in a preschool program, the provisions of Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56441.1(b) provide general guidance in the circumstances of STUDENT’s case. Sec. 56441.1(b) states that “as the preschool child [with special needs] approaches the age to enter an elementary school environment, the child’s preparation shall be geared toward a readiness for kindergarten and later school success.” This is not to be construed as requiring a school district to guarantee readiness for kindergarten or later school success.
Each of STUDENT’s areas of impairment and his related needs affected his readiness for kindergarten and later school success. Cal. Educ. Code 56441.1(b). The absence of a program to address STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and social skill deficits especially jeopardized STUDENT’s readiness for kindergarten and later school success. The deficient description of a speech and language program in the IEP, with respect to present levels of performance and goals and objectives, failed to demonstrate that a speech and language program had been designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. The description of the OT program was nonexistent, except to state OT services of 45 minutes per week. In summary, virtually no aspect of the District’s October 5, 1999 IEP and May 2000 IEP addendum was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program for the 1999-2000 school year was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
III. Did the District’s program comport with STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District’s program comported with STUDENT’s IEP for the 1999-2000 school year.
IV. Did the proposed program provide for an education in the least restrictive environment?
The Petitioner has asserted that the District offered STUDENT a placement in special day class (SDC) for the 1999-2000 school year, and that such a placement would have violated the requirements for placement in the least restrictive environment.
The October 5, 1999 IEP states that an SDC was mentioned in the discussion of placement options. Testimony established that the District informed the parents that an SDC was available, but the District did not offer an SDC in lieu of other services or require placement in an SDC as a condition to receiving other services during the regular school year. There was some discussion between the District and the parents that speech and language services could only be provided during an extended school year if STUDENT was enrolled in an SDC, but ultimately there was an IEP addendum dated June 7, 2000, that continued STUDENT’s speech and language services into the extended school year without involvement in an SDC. Accordingly, there was no violation of the requirements for least restrictive environment for the 1999-2000 school year.
V. Summary.
For the 1999-2000 school year, the District did not offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and did not offer a program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year.
Procedural Appropriateness
Some of the matters alleged by the Petitioner to be procedural violations were actually matters of substantive appropriateness and were discussed above. The Petitioner’s other allegations of procedural violations for the 1999-2000 school year are not pertinent to the results in this Decision and will not be addressed.
Issue No. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Substantive appropriateness
I. Did the District offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs?
A. STUDENT’s unique needs.
Prior to determining whether the District offered a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs as he entered the 2000-2001 school year.
Mr. Redmond’s quarterly CARD report dated September 30, 2000, states that STUDENT had great need for improvement in the areas of independence, impulse control, auditory processing, social skills, play skills, and skills for self-calming.
After the battery of tests performed by the District in October and early November 2000, the IPAT concluded that STUDENT had cognitive skills in the average range and above-age-level skills in reading and mathematics. However, he had delays in fine-motor, sensory motor, writing, and adaptive areas. He had hyperactive and inattentive behaviors. He was found to meet the Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(c) criteria as a child with a speech and language impairment. He was also found to meet the Sec. 3030(g) criteria as “autistic.”(Footnote 10)
Dr. Perlman assessed STUDENT in January 2001. Dr. Perlman testified STUDENT had very poor auditory working memory. Auditory working memory is used in conversation. Deficits in auditory working memory affect the ability to track conversation and also affect reading comprehension; such a student could read the words in a paragraph but not understand the meaning of the paragraph. STUDENT had poor visual-motor integration and poor fine-motor skills. STUDENT had poor language pragmatics. STUDENT had “tremendous difficulty” maintaining attention, and he had hyperactive motor activity.(Footnote 11)
In, summary, at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT needed services to address his speech and language deficits, his sensory-motor and fine-motor deficits, and his autism, as identified by the District. These impairments were manifested by deficits in auditory processing, auditory working memory, and language pragmatics; delays in fine-motor, sensory-motor, self-help skills, and adaptive areas; hyperactive and inattentive behaviors; problems with non-compliant and self-stimulatory behaviors; deficits in impulse control, social skills, play skills, and skills for self-calming.
B. The District’s program offers.
The October 18, 2000 IEP. The purpose of the October 18, 2000 IEP, according to the District, was to conduct an annual review of the October 5, 1999 IEP, discuss the parents’ August 18, 2000 request for DTT services, obtain consent for a comprehensive assessment, and submit an interim plan. The interim plan was quite similar to the program offered at the October 5, 1999 IEP meeting. An additional 30 minutes of speech and language were added. Some goals and objectives were addressed. Meanwhile, from October 5, 1999, through the October 18, 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT had not received a FAPE. The minor changes in STUDENT’s program pursuant to the October 18, 2000 IEP did not halt the continuing denial of a FAPE.
The November 17, 2000 IEP. When the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting convened, the District had completed a rigorous assessment, had reviewed the 35 pages of goals and objectives proposed by CARD, and had incorporated many of the goals and objectives proposed by CARD into a greatly expanded new set of goals and objectives intended to address communication, socialization, and fine-motor skills. The District’s offer was speech and language services, 60 minutes group and 60 minutes individual, per week; social skills group (Cool Stars), 2 sessions per week, 60 minutes per session, at Newland school; OT 45 minutes per week at the WOCCSE clinic; behavioral consultation, 2 times per month, 2 hours per session at Head Start or FVCP; staff consult regarding autism, 2 times per month, 2 hours per session, at Head Start or FVCP. The District stated that it would agree to fund a private preschool (including FVCP for 15 hours (per week) until a placement at Head Start was obtained. The Head Start Preschool would also be for 15 hours per week, and would provide for a program with nondisabled peers.(Footnote 12) An individual behavior plan was presented to address four targeted behaviors. The combined total of the offered services was about 20 to 22 hours per week.
C. Discussion of the November 17, 2000 IEP.
The IEP proposed by the District on November 17, 2000, was clearly a major upgrade when compared to the prior IEPs.
The November 17, 2000 program offer acknowledged STUDENT’s eligibility in the areas of autism and autistic-like behaviors. Goals and objectives specifically designed to meet STUDENT’s behavior and social skill needs were included in the proposed IEP. These goals and objectives involved imitating peers in structured social-skills group activities; following social rules and game-playing rules such as taking turns; accepting defeat; using appropriate verbalizations such as polite phrases, help offers, requests, and commenting/complementing phrases; and communicating appropriately during frustrating situations. In addition, the District offered an individual behavior plan. The individual behavior plan was meaningful for STUDENT’s situation, because it could be applied during the 20-plus hours per week of the program. Statements of present levels of performance and goals and objectives were greatly expanded for speech and language. Present levels of performance and goals and objectives were stated for OT and specifically referenced to STUDENT’s applicable motor deficits. Deficits in adaptive skills were acknowledged and addressed through goals and objectives.
In examining whether or not the District’s November 17, 2000 program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the determinative inquiry is centered on the fact that the program was first offered approximately 2 ½ months into the 2000-2001 school year. The timing of that offer and the consequences of that timing must be analyzed.
The timing of the November 17, 2000 program offer. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56343(c) provides that an IEP team shall meet whenever the parent requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise an IEP. Sec. 56345.5 provides that the meeting, when requested by the parent, shall be held within 30 days, not counting days in July and August, from the receipt of the parents’ request.
STUDENT’s parents notified the District by their letter dated August 18, 2000, that they intended to place STUDENT in a DTT program and seek reimbursement for the costs. The letter also stated the parents’ request for an IEP meeting as soon as possible. Pursuant to Sec. 56345.5, the District was obligated to hold an IEP meeting by October 1, although nothing in the law would have precluded the District from holding an IEP meeting earlier. Ms. Rydell testified that the parents requested an extension of time to accommodate the schedule of the parents’ attorney. The IEP meeting was held on October 18, 2000.
The District’s witnesses consistently characterized the October 18, 2000 meeting as the required “annual review” pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56343(d). Ms. Rydell testified that at the commencement of the IEP meeting, she stated that an hour had been set aside for the annual review and for reviewing the parents’ request for DTT services. Ms. Rydell also prefaced the meeting by stating that she was going to offer a plan for a comprehensive assessment.
The District’s characterization of the October 18, 2000 meeting as an abbreviated annual review shows a somewhat indifferent response to the parents’ August 18, 2000 letter. The District knew throughout the prior school year that STUDENT had autistic traits. There was no apparent reason for the District to wait until October 18, 2000, to submit a comprehensive assessment plan.
From the above-stated facts, one might conclude that the District complied with the time lines for convening an IEP. One might also conclude that the District was diligent in offering a comprehensive assessment, completing the assessment, and reconvening an IEP meeting (the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting) within 30 days of the date the parents consented to the new assessment.(Footnote 13) Such a conclusion would be incorrect.
The District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT in October 1999, combined with the ensuing year-long failure of the District to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disabilities, was the root cause of the District not making a program offer supported by a proper assessment until 2 ½ months into the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, the consequences of the November 17, 2000 program offer having been made 2 ½ months into the school year are chargeable to the District.
The consequences of the late program offer. As the 2000-2001 school year approached, STUDENT’s parents were in a situation that demanded swift action. Their child had a complex disability. The parents knew from their contact with CARD that early intervention for a child with autistic traits could prove to be critical to his future development. The parents wanted STUDENT to be ready, if possible, to start a regular kindergarten program in one year.
In deciding on a course of action, the parents had a choice of relying on the District to properly assess STUDENT and offer an appropriate program, or enrolling STUDENT in the CARD program. The CARD program was presented to the parents as an intensive program, designed to meet his needs arising from his autistic traits, including his behaviors, his speech and language deficits, and his sensory-motor deficits. Dr. Granpeesheh had already performed the initial CARD evaluation in May 2000. The parents could rely upon the CARD program being ready to commence at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. By contrast, if the parents chose to rely upon the District, they would have been relying upon a district that, for the past year, had not provided a FAPE to STUDENT and had not properly assessed him. Whether the District would formally recognize STUDENT as having autistic traits and offer a program designed to meet his behavior needs and social skill deficits was speculative. The District had offered no such program in the past, and the District had done nothing to indicate that it would provide such a program in the future. The parents, quite reasonably under circumstances, chose to start the CARD program.
The CARD program commenced on September 5, 2000. The District did not complete a comprehensive assessment until November 2000. A program offer supported by that assessment was made at the November 17, 2000 IEP meeting, 2 ½ months into the school year.
The question to be addressed is whether the District’s program offer, which otherwise may have met FAPE standards, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs when offered 2 ½ months into the school year.
STUDENT’s parents had acted reasonably when they started STUDENT in the CARD program on September 5, 2001. Therefore, STUDENT had ample justification for being in the CARD program when the District made its program offer on November 17, 2000.
The District’s failure have an appropriate program in place at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year created a new set of unique needs for STUDENT by November 17, 2000. STUDENT had now been established for 2 ½ months in a 23-hour-per-week CARD program. STUDENT was a child with autistic traits. Those traits made him fragile to changes in his environment or routines, as recounted by Dr. Perlman, Dr. Granpeesheh, and STUDENT’s parents. Suddenly removing him from the CARD program and placing him into a different environment would likely have been quite traumatic for STUDENT, and could have caused a serious regression. The likelihood of regression was a concern expressed by Dr. Perlman. Also, while at FVCP, STUDENT had shown a serious increase in his behaviors when FVCP moved him into a new class. The problem of changing environments or routines would have been compounded by following the District’s plan of immediately restarting STUDENT at 15 hours per week at FVCP, then removing him from FVCP and placing him in a Head Start preschool program for 15 hours per week when the Head Start position became available.
The November 17, 2000 program offer contained no transition plan for removing STUDENT from the 23-hour-per-week CARD program, moving STUDENT to increased hours at FVCP, and then removing STUDENT from FVCP and placing him at a Head Start preschool. A transition plan would have been critical for STUDENT because of his autistic traits that included fragility to changes in routines.
In summary, the timing of the District’s November 17, 2000 program offer, 2 ½ months into the school year, had the likely effect of causing a regression in STUDENT. Such a program was, in essence, the opposite of a program designed to confer benefit on STUDENT by meeting his unique needs. Even if the District had offered a transition program, the weeks or months devoted to transition would have slowed or halted STUDENT’s progress at a time vital to his overall development and to his progress in the school year as he was being prepared for entry into a regular kindergarten class.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s November 17, 2000 program offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.
II. Was the District’s program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s program offers for the 2000-2001 school year were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The November 17, 2000 program offer did not sufficiently address STUDENTs unique needs as they existed in November 2000. Implementation of that offer would likely have caused a regression in STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program offer was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.
III. Did the District’s program comport with STUDENT’s IEPs?
There is no dispute that the program provided by the District in speech and language services and OT services for the 2000-2001 school year comported with STUDENT’s IEPs.
IV. Did the District’s proposed program offer STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment?
There is no issue of least restrictive environment arising from the District’s program offer for the 2000-2001 school year.
V. Summary.
For the 2000-2001 school year, the District did not offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
Procedural Appropriateness
There are no remaining issues of procedural appropriateness related to the 2000-2001 program offer by the District.
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 and/or 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement?
The Hearing Officer has found that the District did not provide a FAPE for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years. The Petitioner seeks remedies of reimbursement and compensatory education for the denial of a FAPE
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486.
Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.
There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.
I. The 1999-2000 school year.
For the 1999-2000 school year, the parents funded a regular preschool program at FVCP. For purposes of a reimbursement remedy, the Petitioner did not establish that FVCP was an appropriate placement for STUDENT in the 1999-2000 school year, as required by Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993). Furthermore, pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56446, it is questionable whether the District could have purchased regular preschool services at FVCP. Therefore, the applicable remedy to be discussed for the 1999-2000 school year is compensatory education.
A. Atypical behaviors and social skill deficits.
For the 1999-2000 school year, no program was specifically designed to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. In constructing a remedy, equitable considerations will be applied.
The District’s failure to design and provide a program specifically to meet STUDENT’s needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits was precipitated by the District’s failure to meet its statutory mandate to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. The failure to properly assess was not defensible. Prior to STUDENT’s initial placement in October 1999, the District was fully aware that STUDENT exhibited characteristics of autism. In conjunction with severe delays in receptive and expressive language, those characteristics included hyperactivity, attention or distraction problems, social skill deficits, aggressiveness toward other children, perseveration, self-stimulatory behaviors, and resistance to changes in routines. A comprehensive assessment was required by law. Instead, the District assessed STUDENT only for speech and language, and the District implemented a two-hour-per-week speech and language program.
Accordingly, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education for the District’s failure, during the entire 1999-2000 school year, to provide a program designed to meet his needs arising from his atypical behaviors and social skill deficits. In this particular case, given STUDENT’s changing needs and circumstances, the IEP team is in the best position to determine the specific implementation of compensatory education.
B. Speech and language.
The Hearing Officer has found that present levels of performance and goals and objectives for speech and language were inadequately stated in the October 5, 1999 IEP.
Fortunately for STUDENT, his speech and language program for the 1999-2000 school year was in the capable care of Ms. Ketchersid. In spite of the procedural deficiencies where present levels of performance and goals and objectives were inadequately stated in the IEP, the evidence shows that STUDENT received major benefits from the speech and language program actually delivered by the District. According to Ms. Ketchersid’s testimony, by June 2000 STUDENT was attending and was comprehending much more complex language structures. His memory and focus were expanded in non-verbal and linguistic areas. His mean length of utterance increased from 2-3 words to 5-6 words. He was initiating topics and asking questions related to a topic. He was beginning to understand “WH” questions. He initially did not know what to say to other children. By June 2000 he would approach children and talk or comment appropriately. His attention to auditory information had been fleeting, but in June 2000 he was able to attend an entire hour of group activity. The evidence does show some significant variations in the levels of performance observed or reported by the District, Dr. Perlman, Mr. Redmond, and Dr. Granpeesheh. However, those variations are partially a function of the way STUDENT’s disability causes him to react in different environments. Ms. Ketchersid’s observation of STUDENT over a 9-month period in the consistent environment of her speech and language class provides trustworthy information about STUDENT’s progress in speech and language over a sustained period, as compared to the relative “snapshots” of information seen by the other experts.
The District’s speech and language program in the 1999-2000 school year was a success for STUDENT. Accordingly, there is no award of compensatory education arising from the speech and language component of STUDENT’s program for the 1999-2000 school year.
C. OT services.
With respect to OT services, the May 2000 IEP addendum was deficient. No present levels of performance were stated. No goals and objectives were stated. The addendum listed no reasons for the provision of OT services.
Although the technical requirements of an IEP were not met, in this particular matter an award of compensatory education for OT services would not be appropriate. In reaching this finding, the Hearing Officer has considered that the District’s obligation to provide OT services did not commence until May 15, 2000, when the school year was nearly completed. Additionally, despite the deficiencies in the IEP addendum, the OT services were provided by Ms. Cracchiolo, who also performed the OT assessment. Ms. Cracchiolo testified concerning her findings in the OT assessment and how she provided OT services to address the deficits identified in her assessment. She also testified about STUDENT’s good progress in OT during the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year.
II. The 2000-2001 school year.
The District’s failure to properly assess STUDENT in October 1999, combined with the year-long failure of the District to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disabilities, led to the District not making a program offer supported by a proper assessment until 2 ½ months into the 2000-2001 school year.
The District knew in October 1999 that STUDENT exhibited multiple traits consistent with autism. The District was aware of its statutory obligation to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. The District only assessed STUDENT in the area of speech and language. The District did not present a plan for further assessment until an entire year had elapsed.
Meanwhile, as the 2000-2001 school year approached, the parents knew that early intervention for a child with autistic traits could prove to be critical to his future development. The parents were also anticipating that STUDENT would have only one more year to prepare for a regular kindergarten program. STUDENT needed an appropriate program as soon as possible, and his parents took action by placing him in the CARD program on September 5, 2000. The parent’s action was well-advised under the circumstances.
The Petitioner seeks reimbursement for the CARD program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year. The District asserts that the CARD program suffers from serious programming deficiencies and, therefore, it was not a proper private placement that would support a claim for reimbursement.
When a school District denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 369. Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement of the services they have procured for their children when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, at 370. The Burlington rule is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).
Although courts have recognized that the parent’s placement does not have to meet a standard as high as the school districts must meet, the parent’s placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13 (1993).
In the present case, the parents procured CARD services for STUDENT when the District failed to provide a FAPE. In spite of the lengthy criticism of STUDENT’s CARD program and CARD programs in general, the evidence convincingly shows that the CARD program addressed STUDENT’s needs in all suspected areas of disability, and the program provided STUDENT with educational benefit. This is confirmed by the parents’ testimony, the CARD reports, the CARD drill books and log notes used for STUDENT, and the testimony of Dr. Granpeesheh, Mr. Redmond, and Dr. Perlman.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for his cost of the CARD program for the entire 2000-2001 school year, and extended school year through July 31, 2001.(Footnote 14)
The cost of the CARD program from September 2000 through July 2001 was $49, 807.80, exclusive of evaluations before September 2000 and miscellaneous supplies purchased by the parents. The parents established by documentary evidence presented at the hearing that this amount had actually been paid by the parents to CARD. The District will reimburse the Petitioner by paying $49,807.80.
Issue No. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide speech and language services until April 2000?
The Hearing Officer has previously found that STUDENT is not entitled to an award of compensatory education arising from the speech and language component of STUDENT’s program for the 1999-2000 school year.
Issue No. 6: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide occupational therapy services until May 2000?
The Hearing Officer has previously found that the District did not have an obligation to provide OT services to STUDENT until May 2000.
Issue No. 7: Is the District required to pay for the independent educational evaluation obtained for STUDENT from Dr. Pearlman?
Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56329(b) provides that a parent has a right to obtain, at public expense, an independent educational assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. However, if the district’s assessment, through a due process hearing, is determined to be appropriate, the parent is not entitled to have the independent assessment be at public expense.
The evidence confirms that the District performed a comprehensive and appropriate assessment of STUDENT in October and November 2000. In conformity with Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56320, appropriate testing materials were used, administered by trained and appropriate personnel, in all areas related to STUDENT’s suspected disability. A battery of tests was utilized, as opposed to a single instrument. The independent assessment conducted on behalf of the Petitioner by Dr. Perlman, was commenced in January 2001. Thus, Dr. Pearlman’s independent assessment was performed after the District had appropriately assessed STUDENT. Accordingly, the Petitioner’s request to have the District pay for Dr. Perlman’s assessment is denied.
ORDERS
1. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this decision, the District shall pay to the Petitioner the sum of $49, 807.80 as reimbursement for the CARD program, covering the period of September 5, 2000 through the end of July 2001.
2. Within 30 calendar days from the date of this Decision, and as necessary throughout the course of STUDENT’s compensatory education program, the IEP team shall meet to determine appropriate compensatory education services for STUDENT. In structuring the compensatory education remedy, the IEP team shall comply with the following: a) Compensatory education services shall be designed to compensate STUDENT for the District’s failure, for the entire 1999-2000 school year, to provide a program to specifically address STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and social skill deficits, manifested by hyperactivity, attention or distraction problems, social skill deficits, aggressiveness toward other children, perseveration, self-stimulatory behaviors, and resistance to changes in routines.
b) The IEP team shall consider STUDENT’s changing needs, the structure of his underlying FAPE program or private program, and his ability to tolerate, attend, and benefit from the compensatory education services. Compensatory education services shall be in addition to, not part of, the future services that STUDENT requires for a FAPE.
c) The IEP team shall consider that for the entire 2000-2001 school year while STUDENT was receiving services in the CARD program, the District continued to provide speech and language services and OT services to STUDENT.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
Issue No. 1: Did the District appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 school year and extended school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 4: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 1999-2000 and/or 2000-2001 school years, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education or reimbursement? STUDENT prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 5: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide speech and language services until April 2000? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 6: Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education services for the District’s failure to offer or provide occupational therapy services until May 2000? The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 7: Is the District required to pay for the independent educational evaluation obtained for STUDENT from Dr. Pearlman? The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).
Dated: September 26, 2001 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. The Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. The issues listed here differ in wording from the issues as stated by the Petitioner. Changes were made for purposes of clarification and analysis. 3. The reference is to Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030.
4. The parents repeatedly stated that on multiple occasions the District offered STUDENT an SDC. The evidence showed that the parents were told by the District about SDC’s being available, but the District never made a program offer to STUDENT for an SDC. 5. Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g) utilizes the term “autistic-like behaviors.” 6. The sufficiency of those goals and objectives and the sufficiency of the characterization of STUDENT’s present levels of performance will be considered elsewhere in this Decision. 7. In November 2000, the District found STUDENT eligible under the category of autistic-like behaviors for the 2000-2001 school year. The November 2000 determination by the District is consistent with STUDENT’s atypical behaviors and social skills being related to the eligibility categories of autism and autistic-like behaviors. However, for purposes of the issues in this decision, a finding of eligibility for the 1999-2000 school year under the category of autism or autistic-like behaviors is not necessary. The finding that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of atypical behaviors and social skill deficits is sufficient. 8. The October 5, 1999 IEP was to be reviewed on October 5, 2000. 9. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56345 specifies the requirements of an IEP. Sec. 56343 illustrates the importance of measurable goals and objectives, by requiring an IEP meeting whenever a pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress, and requiring an annual IEP meeting to review a pupil’s progress toward annual goals and to make any necessary revisions. 10. At this juncture of STUDENT’s program, the District recognized that STUDENT met the criteria for “autistic-like behaviors” as defined in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(g). The District refers to that impairment as “autism.” 11. The Hearing Officer recognizes that the onset of the CARD program predated the evaluations by the IPAT and Dr. Perlman by about two months and four months, respectively. STUDENT started his 23-hour-per-week CARD program on September 5, 2000. The report of Mr. Redmond dated September 30, 2000, states that STUDENT had shown very encouraging improvement after the initial weeks of receiving the program. He was communicating more spontaneously, his self-stimulatory behaviors were decreasing, and he was playing with his toys and games more appropriately. Mr. Redmond’s report is consistent with FATHER’s testimony that the improvement in STUDENT was almost immediate after STUDENT began the CARD program. 12. “Cool Stars” refers to a pilot program established in 1999 to teach children appropriate social interaction behaviors. The program includes a direct social-skills instruction group that provides specific activities to teach appropriate social interaction skills utilizing play, language enrichment, and daily living skills. The social skills group utilizes well-known literature stories, follow-up art activities, role playing, social stories, and organized play to reinforce the skills learned. The program also includes an integrated play group which focuses on developing social skills through facilitation of play and peer interaction. The program, according to the literature provided by the District, is designed for children on the autistic disorder spectrum. (Pet. Ex. 39.) Head Start is a special education program for preschoolers. In the District’s proposal for STUDENT, his peers in the Head Start class would have been classified as “under 10 % disabled eligibility.” (Pet. Ex. 40, Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56443.) 13. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56344 requires development of an IEP within 50 days of the date that consent for assessment is given. 14. STUDENT’s needs merit a program through the extended school year. The District has also acknowledged in his IEPs that he should have extended school year services.
