California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 20, 2004

Student v. San Ramon Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 1977-02 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

San Ramon Valley Unified offered a FAPE in all five years; parents' private school reimbursement and compensatory education claims denied.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of a 10-year-old girl filed for due process against San Ramon Valley Unified School District. Their daughter was eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment. She was in general education at Neil Armstrong Elementary School and received speech therapy after school. Before third grade, her parents moved her to The Quarry Lane School, a noncertified private school. The parents represented her at hearing after their attorney withdrew.

They claimed the District denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE) every year from kindergarten through fourth grade. They said it failed to assess and address social-emotional needs from an incident outside school, failed to provide counseling and a "safe" campus, and broke several procedural rules. They sought private school tuition and compensatory speech therapy.

Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin found three procedural violations: a kindergarten assessment plan that was eight days late, a first-grade annual IEP held five months late, and a general education teacher missing from the June 2002 IEP meeting. None of them caused the student to lose educational opportunity or kept the parents from taking part. Teachers and the principal described a happy, high-achieving student with no signs of social-emotional problems, so no assessment or counseling was required. The speech services met her needs, and the 2003 offer adopted the independent assessor's recommended increase. The District prevailed on every issue, and all relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied the W.G. v. Target Range harmless-error test to late assessment plans, late annual IEPs, and a missing general education teacher. It also shows that parents' concerns about trauma outside school did not trigger a duty to assess when school staff saw no effect on the student's education.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1a. Did the District deny a FAPE for 1999-2000 (kindergarten)? Procedural: the assessment plan was not prepared within 15 days of the parents' October 12, 1999 request for a speech and language assessment.

    The assessment plan was eight days late under Education Code section 56321(a), but the IEP meeting was held early, within the 50-day limit, and the student lost no educational opportunity.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Did the District deny a FAPE for 1999-2000? Substantive: failure to identify speech and language needs earlier, failure to assess social-emotional functioning, and failure to provide counseling and a safe placement.

    The District reasonably read the preschool screening. No school evidence suggested social-emotional needs, so no assessment was required. The IEP met the student's speech needs, and Neil Armstrong was an appropriate placement.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 2a. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2000-2001 (first grade)? Procedural: failure to hold the annual IEP meeting by December 2000 (it was held May 24, 2001).

    The District admitted the late annual IEP. Services continued, the parents were kept informed, and no evidence showed the IEP would have changed, so the student lost no educational opportunity.

  4. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2b. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2000-2001? Substantive: failure to reassess, failure to provide counseling, a safe environment, hands-on tongue exercises, and quarterly speech therapist consultations.

    No reassessment was needed. No counseling request was proven and no counseling need was shown. The speech therapist provided myofunctional therapy and at least quarterly consultations and reports, as the IEP required.

  5. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 3a. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2001-2002 (second grade)? Procedural: failure to hold the IEP review meeting scheduled for November 15, 2001.

    The parents were in constant contact with the District and received progress information, so the missed review meeting caused no lost educational opportunity and did not exclude them from the IEP process.

  6. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 3b. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2001-2002? Substantive: failure to assess in all areas of suspected disability (social-emotional; refusal to re-administer the COGAT), failure to provide counseling and a safe placement.

    The October 2001 speech and language assessment was comprehensive. The District had sound reasons not to re-give the COGAT, a test used to screen for the gifted program. No social-emotional need appeared, and the program provided educational benefit.

  7. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 4a. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2002-2003 (third grade)? Procedural: the general education teacher was absent from the June 12, 2002 IEP meeting.

    The teacher's absence violated Education Code section 56341(b). Her letter was read at the meeting, the team knew the student well, and no different outcome was shown, so the violation was harmless.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4b. Did the District deny a FAPE for 2002-2003? Substantive: failure to offer appropriate services and a safe placement, untimely mediated psychoeducational assessment, and failure to fund the private school.

    The offer of general education at Neil Armstrong with 60 minutes a week of speech therapy and a new therapist met the student's needs. The assessment delay under the mediation agreement was not shown to be the District's fault.

  9. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 (fourth grade)?

    The August 18, 2003 IEP adopted the increased speech therapy the independent assessor recommended, in general education at Neil Armstrong. It was designed to meet the student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide benefit.

  10. Issue 6. If the District denied a FAPE in any year, should it be ordered to provide compensatory education or reimburse the parents for the noncertified nonpublic school placement in 2002-2003 and 2003-2004?

    Because the District offered a FAPE every year, the parents get no tuition reimbursement and the student gets no compensatory speech therapy for 2003-2004.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Adams v. Oregon; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Foley v. Special School District of St. Louis County; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696

People named in the decision

  • Joanne Ellgas, principal, Neil Armstrong Elementary School
  • Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special education, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Elizabeth Block, coordinator of special programs / special education program manager, San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Nicole Pitts, speech pathologist (agreed-upon new speech therapist), San Ramon Valley Unified School District
  • Sherri Rose, kindergarten and first-grade teacher, Neil Armstrong Elementary School
  • Sue (Susan M.) Robinson, second-grade general education teacher, Neil Armstrong Elementary School
  • Barbara Berry, independent speech pathologist who provided therapy; witness for Student, Independent provider agreed upon by the parties
  • Phyllis Comb, private speech pathologist (current therapist); witness for Student
  • Karen Brown, speech pathologist who provided therapy January to April 2000
  • Donna Brown, speech pathologist who conducted the 1999 speech-language assessment
  • Devon LaHar, speech pathologist who conducted the October 2001 speech and language assessment
  • Cynthia Petersen, Ph.D., independent psychoeducational assessor under the mediation agreement
  • Mary Jane (Jane) McCoy, educational assessor under the mediation agreement
  • Jackie Cheong, originally agreed-upon assessor (unavailable)
  • Patricia O'Neal, myofunctional expert consulted by the speech therapist
  • Eileen Mattucci, former attorney for Student (withdrew)
  • The Quarry Lane School, noncertified private school where parents placed the student, Danville, California
  • Huntington Learning Center, learning center whose director (a family friend) testified for Student

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on June 17, 18, and 24, 2004, in Danville, California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner’s parents, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, attended the hearing and represented Petitioner STUDENT (“Petitioner” or “STUDENT”). (Footnote 1) STUDENT was not personally present at the hearing. Attorney Elizabeth Estes represented Respondent San Ramon Valley Unified School District (“District”). Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special education, also appeared for the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: FAMILY FRIEND 1, a family friend; FAMILY FRIEND 2, a family friend; speech pathologists Phyllis Comb and Barbara Berry; and FAMILY FRIEND 3, a family friend and director of the Huntington Learning Center.

The District called the following witnesses: Karen Heilbronner, assistant director of special education; Elizabeth Block, coordinator of special programs; Nicole Pitts, speech pathologist; Joanne Ellgas, principal of Neil Armstrong Elementary School; Sherri Rose, kindergarten and first-grade teacher; and Sue Robinson, second-grade teacher.

Oral testimony and documentary evidence was offered and received. The record remained open pending receipt of written closing arguments. Upon receipt by the Hearing Officer on July 23, 2004, of the last of the written closing arguments, the record was closed.

ISSUES

1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for academic year 1999-2000 (kindergarten)?

2. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 (first grade)?

3. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 (second grade)?

4. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 (third grade)?

5. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 (fourth grade)?

6. If the District failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for any of academic years 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004, should the District be ordered to provide STUDENT with compensatory education or, alternatively, provide reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the cost of her placement in a noncertified, nonpublic school during academic years 2002-2003 and 2003-2004?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES (Footnote 2)

Petitioner’s Contentions.

For each of the years in issue, STUDENT’s parents contended on STUDENT’s behalf that the District did not offer a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and that was calculated to provide her educational benefit. The following further contentions were made:

Academic year 1999-2000 - Kindergarten. STUDENT’s parents allege that during kindergarten the District failed to provide a timely assessment plan, failed to assess and identify STUDENT’s speech and language deficits in a timely manner, failed to assess STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning, and failed to provide a program of special education and related services that met her unique need for a safe environment and counseling.

Academic year 2000-2001 – First grade. STUDENT’s parents contended that when STUDENT was in the first grade the District committed a procedural error by failing to hold her annual individualized education program (IEP) meeting in December 2000. Additionally, the parents contended that the District failed to provide counseling, a placement that provided STUDENT a safe environment, and consultation with the speech therapist during this academic year.

Academic year 2001-2002 – Second grade. STUDENT’s parents contended that during second grade the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, failed to hold an IEP review meeting in November 2001, failed to provide a program of special education and related services designed to address her unique needs, failed to provide a placement which met her need for a safe environment, failed to provide her with counseling, and failed to pay for STUDENT’s attorneys fees.

Academic year 2002-2003 – Third grade. STUDENT’s parents contended that the District failed to offer and provide her with special education and related services during academic year 2002-2003 and that a psychoeducational evaluation agreed to in mediation was not conducted timely during the third grade. Further, they contended that no new assessments were conducted, that the District did not pay tuition for STUDENT’s enrollment in a noncertified nonpublic school, and that the District failed to pay STUDENT’s attorneys fees. (Footnote 3)

Academic year 2003-2004 – Fourth grade. STUDENT’s parents contended that no IEP was conducted during this academic year and that the District failed to offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for this academic year. Additionally, they contend that the District should have provided compensatory education and/or reimbursement for private school tuition.

District’s Contentions.

The District contended that it identified and addressed STUDENT’s unique needs in each of her kindergarten, first-grade, and second-grade years, that it designed a program to meet those needs and confer educational benefit, and that it provided such a program to STUDENT pursuant to her IEP for each year. The District contended further that, because it offered STUDENT a FAPE in third and fourth grades and, despite the offer, her parents unilaterally placed STUDENT in a noncertified nonpublic school, the District had no obligation to provide her special education services. Finally, the District denied that it owes STUDENT’s parents any reimbursement and STUDENT any compensatory education.

BACKGROUND FACTS

At the time of the due process hearing, Petitioner STUDENT was a ten-year-old student enrolled by her parents in the fourth grade at The Quarry Lane School (Quarry Lane) in Danville, California, a noncertified, nonpublic school (NPS).

STUDENT is the youngest daughter of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT. The documentary evidence that relates to her early childhood development indicates that STUDENT was the product of a normal pregnancy. However, as a young child under the age of three, she is reported to have experienced frequent and prolonged ear infections, two episodes of pneumonia, calcium deposits on her adrenal glands, and cysts on her lungs. The medical reports stop short of postulating a direct connection between STUDENT’s early childhood illnesses and her speech and language difficulties, but suggest that possibility. It is also noted that both of her siblings are impacted by speech and language disabilities and receive special education assistance in the public school system. Other than in the area of speech and language, notably the development of tongue strength and placement causing articulation difficulties, STUDENT is reported to have achieved the usual childhood milestones well within normal time periods. As noted, her speech skills did not develop commensurate with her age group.

STUDENT entered a private preschool when she was five years old and transferred into Neil Armstrong Elementary School in December 1998. When STUDENT entered Neil Armstrong, her mother requested that the District assess STUDENT for articulation errors. The request was very specific. It requested that STUDENT be evaluated for slurred /s/ and consonant blends. On December 15, 1998, the District administered to STUDENT the “Preschool Speech and Language-Screening Test,” a standardized screening administered to preschool students who exhibit speech difficulties. Some errors were noted by the examiner, but it was determined that STUDENT did not qualify for speech therapy. The examiner stated that STUDENT’s difficulties were not significantly worse than those appearing generally in her age group. The examiner postulated that STUDENT’s deficits were likely developmental and would, therefore, resolve over time.

According to the testimony at the hearing, STUDENT’s preschool experience was unremarkable. STUDENT’s parents contend, however, that due to an event following preschool, she entered kindergarten as a post-traumatic stress victim. There is indication in the evidence that in July 1999, the summer between preschool and kindergarten, STUDENT and another female child, who was two or three years older, engaged in sexual experimentation at STUDENT’s home on one occasion. STUDENT’s mother reported that the older girl performed oral sex upon STUDENT. Her mother stated that she discovered the children engaged in this activity and promptly put a stop to it. STUDENT entered kindergarten shortly after the alleged incident in September 1999.

The testimony established that in late September or early October 1999, as the academic year was getting underway, STUDENT’s parents expressed their concern to Joanne Ellgas, the principal at Neil Armstrong. In a brief meeting they communicated their apprehension over the possibility that STUDENT would have a difficult school adjustment due to the incident, which they characterized as a sexual assault. (Footnote 4) One concern expressed by STUDENT’s parents was keeping the girls from having contact with each other at school. The older girl also attended school at Neil Armstrong.

STUDENT’s parents also expressed their concern over STUDENT’s language delays during a meeting with Ms. Ellgas at or about the same time. (Footnote 5) At a meeting on October 12, 1999, they requested a speech and language assessment.

The speech and language assessment requested by STUDENT’s parents was completed and on December 13, 1999, an IEP meeting was convened. STUDENT was then five and one-half years old. The assessor ascertained that STUDENT’s articulation and lateralization errors were not the result of developmental delays, although it was acknowledged that many children develop slowly and do not articulate the sibilant sounds until the age of seven. She found that STUDENT had pronounced muscle weakness and the inability to position her tongue correctly to articulate certain /s/ sounds. The assessor’s recommendation was for speech therapy twice weekly.

The IEP team found STUDENT eligible for special education services as a pupil who has impairments in speech and language. It also adopted the assessor’s recommendations regarding frequency and duration of services. Speech therapy was provided to STUDENT in an individual setting two to three times per week for a total of sixty minutes weekly pursuant to her IEP.

There was no discussion in the IEP meeting relating to social-emotional issues, counseling, or concern for special precautions relating to STUDENT’s sense of safety at school. No one, including STUDENT’s parents, raised these issues at her IEP meeting. Less than one month later, in January 2000, the older girl involved in the incident transferred out of Neil Armstrong.

Pursuant to her IEP, STUDENT was placed in a general education class with pullout services for speech. (Footnote 6) Beginning in January 2000, Mrs. PARENT took STUDENT to her speech therapy appointments twice weekly as provided in the December 13, 1999 IEP. Her speech therapy was scheduled for after-school hours. Thus, STUDENT was not required to miss any general education time on account of her speech services. From January to April 2000, STUDENT’s speech pathology services were provided by speech pathologist Karen Brown. Thereafter, and through 2001, Barbara Berry, a speech pathologist who testified at the due process hearing, provided them.

STUDENT was placed in Ms. Rose’s first-grade class during academic year 2000-2001. (Footnote 7) According to Ms. Rose, STUDENT continued to perform exceptionally well academically and make friends. In mid-first grade, January 2001, Ms. Berry provided a written progress report. She testified that STUDENT had consistently made progress in the production of “fricative sounds,” and she had increased tongue strength throughout the period Ms. Berry had been providing speech therapy. Although STUDENT’s IEP was only intended to be in effect until after the winter holiday in December, Ms. Ellgas testified that the speech therapy services continued until her next IEP meeting. STUDENT’s next IEP meeting took place May 24, 2001. During the five-month period from December 2000 to May 2001, STUDENT had no current IEP in place, but she continued to receive the speech and language services provided for in her December 19, 1999 IEP.

The May 24, 2001 IEP followed the recommendations of Ms. Berry’s written progress report of March 19, 2001. The IEP called for continuing the speech therapy being provided by Ms. Berry weekly. The therapy sessions were to continue to take place outside of school hours (forty-five minutes of direct therapy and fifteen minutes of indirect consultation to teachers and parents so that they could follow through).

Academically during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT performed on the “high average side” according to Ms. Robinson. The Gates-McGinite (COGAT) testing in the fall of the second grade, which was used to test children for eligibility for the gifted and accelerated program, showed STUDENT scoring in the above average range in all areas. There was some concern voiced by STUDENT’s parents about STUDENT’s scores on parts of the COGAT testing. However, as Ms. Heilbronner and Ms. Ellgas testified, the COGAT testing result was positive overall. With respect to some low scores on subparts, the District looked at this test protocol to determine GATE eligibility and not to identify special education issues. STUDENT’s report cards for the year reflected that she consistently earned “standard grades with some superiors,” according to Ms. Robinson.

The next IEP meeting took place June 12, 2002. Barbara Berry gave an update on STUDENT’s progress. She expressed concern that STUDENT was not working on the /s/ sound and seemed to have reached a plateau in that function. On her other speech goals, she was reported as making progress. Thus the recommendation was made to divide the therapy into smaller units and change therapists in an effort to remotivate her. The parents expressed concern that some of the scores on the COGAT testing could point to a specific learning disability (SLD). They believed the test should be repeated and the possibility of SLD be ruled out or otherwise determined. The District members of the IEP team decided not to repeat the COGAT for reasons discussed later in this Decision. They also made a determination to continue STUDENT’s placement at Neil Armstrong with DIS speech therapy as previously provided. The District’s offer for the next school year was contained in the June 12, 2002 IEP.

STUDENT’s parents made the decision to take STUDENT out of the District’s elementary schools and they enrolled her in the third grade at Quarry Lane, a noncertified private school (NPS), for the academic year 2002-2003. Quarry Lane provides a general education environment. It has no special education classes. STUDENT’s parents requested that the District provide speech and language services to STUDENT during third grade, but the District denied the request. The parents filed for a due process hearing on August 30, 2002.

On September 14, 2002, the parties requested mediation offered by the Special Education Hearing Office. The result was an interim mediation agreement calling for an IEP meeting to be held no later than November 4, 2002, continuation of speech services one time per week in forty-five-minute sessions until the next IEP meeting, and completion of a psychoeducational assessment. There was disagreement over the choice of assessors and length of the interim speech therapy sessions. The result was a second interim agreement. It provided an additional fifteen minutes per speech therapy session, and named Jackie Cheong and Jane McCoy to perform the assessments referenced in the request for due process hearing. The parties then discovered that Ms. Cheong was unavailable. Consequently, they negotiated further on the choice of an alternative assessor. It was not until January 2003 that the parties agreed on one, namely, Cynthia Petersen, Ph.D. Ms. McCoy completed her educational assessment on December 4, 2002. Dr. Petersen completed her psychoeducational assessment on February 27, 2003. Dr. Petersen met with STUDENT’s parents on March 13, 2003.

During this interim period between filing for the due process hearing and the completion of the assessments, the District had been paying for STUDENT’s continuing speech and language therapy. On June 3, 2003, the District notified the parents that it would not fund private speech sessions after close of the school year on June 12, 2003. The District’s rationale was founded on the fact that since STUDENT’s parents had voluntarily withdrawn STUDENT from the District, no special education services were due.

STUDENT’s parents then indicated they wished the District to schedule another IEP meeting. One was scheduled for August 13, 2003. The parents rejected the date. Finally, the IEP meeting was held on August 18, 2003. The District made an offer of placement and services at Neil Armstrong. The District rejected the parents’ request to assume the obligation for STUDENT’s tuition at Quarry Lane. The District also explored a possible placement option for academic year 2003-2004 at an alternative elementary school within the District, Montevideo Elementary School. This placement was rejected because, as STUDENT’s parents stated, Montevideo students often graduated to the junior high school that the young girl involved in the incident would likely attend. Consequently, STUDENT attended Quarry Lane at her parents’ expense for academic year 2003-2004.

The due process hearing commenced on June 17, 2004.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for academic year 1999-2000 (kindergarten)?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District substantively provided the student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also requires that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal form the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, comported with her IEP, and have been provided in the least restrictive environment.

The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. 458 U.S. at 205.

Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program were substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206?208.

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).

In the present case, Petitioner argued that certain procedural violations by the District relating to the timeliness of the assessment plan and the IEP meeting constituted a denial of FAPE. She contended that the District failed to provide an assessment plan within the required statutory time and failed thereafter to complete the assessment within the statutory time. California Education Code section 56321(a) provides that the District shall prepare an assessment plan within 15 days of the parent’s request for referral. California Education Code section 56244 requires that an IEP meeting be convened within fifty days of the District’s receipt of parental consent to the assessment plan.

The evidence showed that STUDENT’s parents requested a speech and language assessment on October 12, 1999. The District prepared its plan on November 4, 1999, approximately eight days late. STUDENT’s mother gave her written consent to the assessment plan on November 4, 1999. An IEP meeting was convened December 13, 1999, within the fifty-day time limit.

The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the District violated Section 56321(a) by preparing the assessment plan eight days late. Having determined that a violation occurred, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the violation resulted in any prejudice to STUDENT or her parents. In the present matter, the delay was minimal, a matter of eight additional days from the request to the presentation of the assessment plan. Moreover, the statutory deadline to complete the assessment and hold the IEP meeting is fifty days. In this case, the IEP meeting was held on December 13, 1999, only thirty-nine days from the date consent was received and eleven days before the statutory deadline. Therefore, the District essentially cured the initial defect by holding the actual IEP meeting earlier than required. In addition, the school records and reports show that STUDENT’s scholastic performance was more than adequate during this period. Further, STUDENT was only five and one-half years old at that time. STUDENT’s parents presented a speech therapist as a witness who testified that a delay in providing therapy could result in an impairment that takes longer to resolve or in a greater deficit requiring more therapy in the future. However, no evidence was presented to show that an eight-day delay in the development of an assessment plan would result in a loss of educational opportunity at this particular time in the student’s school career. Thus the Hearing Officer finds that this procedural error did not result in the denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Once procedural matters are determined, the analysis turns to an examination of whether the student was offered and/or provided special education and related services that were substantively appropriate. The IDEA, State law, and Rowley, supra, provide several factors to be examined in a substantive analysis of whether a school district offered a FAPE. First, the offer must have been designed to meet the unique needs of the student. Second, the program offered must have been reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Third, it must have conformed to the student’s IEP. Additionally, the educational program must have been provided in the least restrictive environment. Finally, although not in issue in the present matter, the student’s IEP also must have provided for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with her unique needs and present levels of performance and must have provided for the student to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disabilities.

Section 56320(f) of the California Education Code provides that a student shall be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. STUDENT contended that the District failed to identify her special education needs until well after her entry into kindergarten in September 1999. In particular, she contended that the District should have assessed her speech and language needs at the beginning of kindergarten because of the results of a preschool speech and language screening. Additionally, she contended that the District failed to identify her social-emotional needs during this academic year. She argued that these failures resulted in a denial of FAPE for academic year 1999-2000.

Assessing for Speech and Language Disorder.

As discussed earlier, STUDENT’s difficulties with articulation had been the subject of screening in preschool and it had been determined that she did have an articulation difficulty. However, it was determined by the District’s speech pathologist who conducted the screening to be developmental in nature. In STUDENT’s kindergarten year, when this area of her speech did not improve, STUDENT’s parents requested that the District provide further assessment in speech and language.

Phyllis Comb, STUDENT’s current speech pathologist, testified that earlier intervention would have accelerated the correction of STUDENT’s speech disorder, which was described as a myofunctional disorder primarily due to hypertonic tongue and weak musculature. However, Ms. Comb acknowledged that the District’s interpretation of the preschool screening had been reasonable. Barbara Berry, a speech pathologist who provided STUDENT’s therapy from kindergarten to third grade, also opined that speech pathologists would have been within their standard of expertise to interpret the preschool screening results as indicative of a typical developmental delay.

The Hearing Officer finds that from September through December of 1999, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to identify speech and language as an area of disability. The speech pathologists who testified agreed that the District’s interpretation of the pre-school screening had been reasonable. Therefore, STUDENT was not denied a FAPE from September to December on account of the District’s failure to identify her speech and language needs earlier in the school year. As noted earlier, the District conducted an assessment after receiving the parents’ request for assessment and identified STUDENT as eligible for speech and language interventions by December 1999, more or less within statutory guidelines.

Assessing for Social-emotional Functioning.

STUDENT’s parents contended that the District failed to appropriately assess STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning and determine that STUDENT had social-emotional issues that impaired her ability to benefit from attending school at Neil Armstrong.

As referenced earlier, the documentary evidence showed that STUDENT’s mother reported to several agencies that she discovered STUDENT and another student engaged in sexual activity during the summer of 1999. The incident took place off school grounds, in STUDENT’s home. The contention made at the due process hearing was that as a result of the incident, STUDENT was a victim of a sexual assault and/or was a post-traumatic stress victim. Her parents reported that they discussed this area of concern with the principal of Neil Armstrong, requested counseling for STUDENT, and requested protections for STUDENT against the alleged perpetrator. They contended that the District, in response to their requests, did nothing.

Assuming that the contentions of STUDENT’s parents relating to the facts of the incident itself are true, the Hearing Officer is left with a serious question as to whether STUDENT’s psychological reaction to the experience had any detrimental effect on her education. No direct evidence was presented to show that STUDENT’s education was hindered, impeded, or blocked by any social-emotional needs resulting from the incident.

Further, there was no indirect evidence offered to establish STUDENT’s alleged social-emotional “trauma” such as might be reflected by her actions and/or her attendance at school. The evidence showed that STUDENT was infrequently absent, was not often tardy, never complained to any teacher, aide, or other school employee about feeling unsafe, never acted uncomfortable in the school setting, and showed no signs of school avoidance. The Hearing Officer does not find that the District was required to assess STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning. No evidence was presented that established the District’s obligation to assess social-emotional functioning. No witness testified that STUDENT exhibited any signs of trauma in the school environment. The principal at Neil Armstrong, Ms. Ellgas, testified that at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year STUDENT openly gossiped about her sexual experience with some of the other children at school. Because of the sensitive nature of the subject matter, Ms. Ellgas felt it would be better not to be talking about what is generally considered a private subject and she made this suggestion directly to STUDENT. STUDENT’s response, Ms. Ellgas testified, was a matter-of-fact “o.k.” Mrs. Ellgas testified that during their conversation, STUDENT described the experience in an unemotional and off-hand manner as “yucky.”

STUDENT’s behavior at school, as attested to by several of her teachers and one of the aides at school, corroborated Ms. Ellgas’s testimony describing STUDENT’s reaction to the incident as inconsequential. Sherri Rose, STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher, described STUDENT as a happy child who was willing to please, liked to work, and wanted to get along with everyone. She observed that STUDENT sometimes tended toward perfectionism and therefore provided her with more time on assignments. While Ms. Rose acknowledged that she was aware that STUDENT had an IEP for speech, she indicated that she did not have any difficulty understanding STUDENT’s oral communications.

Ms. Rose testified additionally that while STUDENT did require speech therapy, “STUDENT did not strike me as needing special education for emotional issues.” Similarly, Ms. Rose testified that STUDENT did well academically, did not appear to need counseling, and sometimes exhibited a strong personality but had friends in class and was not a “loner.” Ms. Rose testified that STUDENT’s interests appeared to be similar to many female students her age. The subject she chose for her spring writing project was “How I Love Cats.” Ms. Rose wrote in the comment section of STUDENT’s report card, “It has been a pleasure having STUDENT in my class and I look forward to having her in 1st grade.”

STUDENT did well at school. There was no evidence that her education was impacted by the experience, whatever its scope. Moreover, she was described by all of the school personnel who testified as “a happy little girl.” There was no evidence that supports a conclusion that the District should have conducted an assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional needs. Ms. Ellgas’s decision to unobtrusively observe STUDENT before taking other action was the appropriate course. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the information available to the District was insufficient to trigger a formal assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional issues.

Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

To determine if the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, it is first necessary for the Hearing Officer to determine what STUDENT’s unique needs were during the 1999-2000 school year.

The District held STUDENT’s IEP meeting on December 13, 1999. The speech-language assessment conducted shortly before the meeting identified articulation errors; the speech pathologist, Donna Brown, determined that considering the lack of improvement over the past year of growth, these errors were not attributable to normal developmental delays. At the IEP meeting, the team considered the recommendations of the speech and language assessment. Ms. Brown, who was present at the IEP meeting, reported that STUDENT did not produce /s/, /sh/, and /z/ sounds correctly. STUDENT was determined to be eligible for special education services because of her impairment in communication. The IEP team determined that STUDENT needed speech therapy in both individual as well as small-group settings, for a total of sixty minutes per week. It was determined that STUDENT needed oral-motor exercises to develop tongue strength and mobility, vocal development exercises, and articulation exercises. STUDENT’s parents agreed. Her mother signed the IEP and participated in STUDENT’s speech therapy program by providing transportation to the sessions. There was no dispute at the due process hearing over the determination of STUDENT’s speech and language needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team accurately determined STUDENT’s unique speech and language needs on December 13, 1999.

Once a student’s unique needs are determined, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district’s proposed program. See Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district’s program addressed the student’s unique needs and was calculated to provide some educational benefit, then that district offered a FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8), 1412 (a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

Turning now to the kindergarten IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer addressed STUDENT’s need for speech therapy. The IEP provided speech therapy to address both oral-motor development and strengthening and practice articulating sounds that were difficult for STUDENT according to her treating speech pathologist and the assessor. Goals and objectives were adopted which targeted the production and articulation of the sounds with which STUDENT had difficulty.

During the hearing, STUDENT’s parents alleged that STUDENT was denied a FAPE because the IEP failed to address STUDENT’s social-emotional needs. However, the Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT did not have any social-emotional needs in the school setting requiring special education services. The Hearing Officer notes that at the time of the IEP meeting, STUDENT’s parents did not raise the subject of her asserted need for counseling or other services to address post-traumatic stress disorder or an anxiety disorder that was interfering with her education. (Footnote 8) Moreover, as stated above, at that time the District had no indication from any source that STUDENT had needs in the social-emotional area that were affecting her ability to benefit from her education. Thus no needs in that area were established and none were determined. The appropriateness of the District’s determination of needs must be viewed in light of the information that the IEP team knew or had reason to know at the time an offer was made. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999).

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had needs in the area of speech and language. The goals and objectives and speech therapy program contained in the IEP adequately addressed those needs. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had no social-emotional needs in the school environment that should have been addressed by the District.

Placement and Services

For the academic year 1999-2000, the District offered placement at Neil Armstrong Elementary School in a general education classroom with speech and language services provided after school. STUDENT’s parents contended that placement at Neil Armstrong was inappropriate because of STUDENT’s social-emotional needs. Specifically, the parents asserted that because of her social-emotional needs, Neil Armstrong was not an appropriate placement for her because the other girl involved in the incident attended Neil Armstrong until January 2000. Additionally, the parents contended that another girl who allegedly bullied STUDENT also attended Neil Armstrong. The Hearing Officer has determined that no needs existed within this area. Therefore, the placement was not inappropriate on this basis. Additionally, STUDENT’s IEP could be and was implemented at Neil Armstrong. In view of STUDENT’s demeanor at school, her consistent academic progress, and her progress in resolving her speech issues, it is apparent that the school environment of Neil Armstrong was appropriate. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that Neil Armstrong was an appropriate placement.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

The IEP team developed STUDENT’s speech and language program on the basis of the information it had before it. The therapy provided was designed to increase STUDENT’s ability to produce certain sounds. Ms. Berry testified that she provided continuing reports to and consulted with STUDENT’s family during the period she provided speech therapy to STUDENT. Additionally, STUDENT made progress according to the speech and language progress reports and the verbal reports of the speech pathologist to her parents. This was corroborated by STUDENT’s report cards. The report cards establish that she did well in school and progressed to the next grade level. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that STUDENT’s IEP addressed her speech and language needs with a program that was reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Comport with the IEP.

Ms. Berry testified that the services and placement provided by the District during academic year 1999-2000 were those called for in STUDENT’s IEP, namely sixty minutes per week of DIS speech therapy by a qualified speech pathologist. No evidence to the contrary was provided. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the program implemented comported with STUDENT’s IEP.

Placement in Least Restrictive Environment.

STUDENT was offered and provided placement in a general education class at Neil Armstrong, a District elementary school. She attended school in the general education classroom throughout the school day. Her special education DIS services were provided outside of school hours. She therefore was placed in the least restrictive environment (LRE) as federal law and the Education Code require. (Footnote 9)

Conclusion.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided a FAPE to STUDENT for academic year 1999-2000.

2. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001 (first grade)?

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

Section 56343 of the California Education Code and federal law provide that an IEP team shall meet at least annually to review the pupil’s progress, the individualized education program, whether the goals and objectives are being achieved, the appropriateness of the pupil’s placement and whether to make any revisions. See also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(4)(A). STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting should have been convened by December 13, 2000, but it was not. It was actually held on May 24, 2001. At the hearing the District admitted that a procedural error had occurred.

However, Ms. Ellgas testified that STUDENT’s speech therapy continued without interruption until the next IEP meeting took place. Further, she stated that the speech therapist made reports of progress to STUDENT’s parents throughout the period. During the period that the speech therapy was continuing and before the May 24, 2001 IEP meeting, the speech therapist refined the speech therapy program within the parameters of the existing IEP. Ms. Berry testified that she had identified STUDENT’s need for myofunctional exercises, maintaining lingual-motor contact during lingual extension and retraction, and air-stream management exercises. Ms. Berry also testified that she had discussions with STUDENT’s mother during which the mother was brought up to date with the therapy being provided and with STUDENT’s progress. STUDENT’s speech therapist and her classroom teacher testified that STUDENT continued to make progress in her speech and language goals and objectives and performed well academically at school.

Additionally, STUDENT’s parents had continuing contact with Ms. Ellgas and other District personnel during which there was continuing expression of concern by the parents about what the parents contended were STUDENT’s social-emotional needs. Consequently, Ms. Ellgas testified that she continued to observe STUDENT closely.

Finally, STUDENT was eligible for special education services as a speech and language impaired student only and had no needs except for those in the speech and language area. She was placed in a general education class throughout the school day and was provided speech services after school hours. Her speech issues were articulation and production of certain sounds due to weak musculature. There was no contention by the parents that had the December 2000 IEP been held, they would have suggested any change to STUDENT’s speech and language services. Also, there was no evidence that had the annual review been conducted in December 2000 that any significant changes would have been made to the IEP or that the program provided to STUDENT from December 2000 to May 2001 would have been substantially different. While the parents’ opportunity to participate in an IEP meeting was delayed, the Hearing Officer finds that the matters requiring review were, in fact, the subject of ongoing review and discussion with the parents. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that there was no denial of educational opportunity to STUDENT resulting from that error.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

STUDENT’s parents contended that the District should have updated the speech and language assessment. A reassessment is mandated once every three years, or more often if conditions warrant or there is a request for a reassessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(a). (Footnote 10) Upon her entry into the first grade, the IEP establishing STUDENT’s need for speech therapy was in place and was being followed. Despite her impairment, the testimony established that her speech was intelligible to her teachers and fellow students. Further, at that time she was fully engaged in her speech therapy program. No evidence was presented to show that any speech areas other than articulation and speech production were delayed.

The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT’s prior speech and language assessment, conducted in 1999, was appropriate. Further, no evidence was presented to establish a need to update her speech and language assessment. Moreover, her parents did not request a speech and language reassessment at this time. The Hearing Officer concludes therefore that additional speech and language evaluations were not necessary for this academic year.

STUDENT’s parents contended that her environment was unsafe due to the presence of the alleged offending girls on campus. Consequently, they asserted that the District should have identified and assessed her social-emotional functioning. The evidence presented at the due process hearing did not support that contention. STUDENT’s first-grade teacher, Ms. Rose, observed no changes from kindergarten in STUDENT’s emotional reactions to people or situations at school. Ms. Rose testified that STUDENT did not appear anxious or depressed and that her attendance patterns did not change when she entered first grade. Ms. Ellgas, the principal, testified that she kept an eye on STUDENT as a precaution and that she continued to present as a happy little girl. STUDENT’s speech therapist, Barbara Berry, testified that STUDENT did not strike her as a youngster who needed counseling. Accordingly, school personnel did not consider this an area of suspected disability triggering the need for an assessment. The Hearing Officer concurs.

Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

STUDENT’s need for speech therapy for a total of sixty minutes per week was well established. No one disputed that need.

With regard to the contention by the parents that STUDENT needed a “safe” environment, it should be noted that the Hearing Officer has found that during STUDENT’s kindergarten year she did not manifest any social-emotional issues in the school environment and therefore there were no social-emotional issues the District was required to address. Additionally, there was no evidence presented tending to establish that during the 2000-2001 school year STUDENT had a need for a “safe environment” beyond that of the typical student. The alleged perpetrator had transferred out of Neil Armstrong in early 2000. However, even when the alleged perpetrator was on campus, STUDENT did not exhibit any social-emotional needs on campus resulting from the incident.

Further, none of the school personnel saw STUDENT having a difficult time with the child now characterized by STUDENT’s parents as a bully. STUDENT’s teachers, who saw the two students interact on a daily basis, testified that both girls were strong willed and sometimes “clashed.” But they continued to state that STUDENT appeared to be the one in control, did not appear fearful, and considered the other child her friend. A parent, who volunteered as an aide in the classroom from time to time, testified that she observed STUDENT interacting with the other child and noticed nothing unusual about the interactions. Thus the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT had no apparent unique need for a placement in an environment other than Neil Armstrong.

Finally, STUDENT’s parents contended that during this school year they asked the school principal for a referral to a counselor for STUDENT to meet STUDENT’s need for counseling. (Footnote 11) Ms. Ellgas testified that she did not recall any request for such a referral. She expressed surprise when asked why she did not make a referral to the school counselor. She testified that it was her usual and customary practice to make referrals to the school counselor whenever they were requested, whether she agreed that the referral was necessary or not. From Ms. Ellgas’s testimony on this subject, it was apparent to the Hearing Officer that over her thirty-four years of experience in education, Ms. Ellgas developed a professional belief that counseling is a positive experience and, therefore, the gate to the counselor’s office was never closed. “I always make those referrals” when requested, she stated.

Ms. Ellgas was clear and focused during her testimony and showed excellent recollection of the facts to which she testified. When asked why she had not made a referral when requested, Ms. Ellgas was genuinely surprised at the question (“I always....”). Further, her custom and practice over thirty-four years offers circumstantial evidence that she would have made a referral if requested and infers that she was not so requested. Further, no evidence was presented that a request for counseling was made by STUDENT’s parents. The parents declined to testify and no documentary evidence supported that contention. Finally, no unique need for counseling has been determined by the Hearing Officer in this matter. The Hearing Officer accepts Ms. Ellgas’s statements in this regard and finds that the District was not requested to provide counseling and, therefore, did not fail to provide it when requested to do so.

Placement and Services.

The sole subject of STUDENT’s IEP was her speech therapy program. It was acknowledged by all of the participants in the due process hearing that STUDENT had difficulties articulating and producing certain /s/ sounds and combinations. Fortunately for STUDENT, her speech was intelligible, but it was understood that it would not improve without increasing her tongue muscle strength and mobility. The evidence showed that the impairment STUDENT suffered was one that would impact her education as she advanced in grade because it impacted oral communication. With the foregoing in mind, the IEP team designed a plan that included sixty minutes per week of speech therapy provided by a qualified speech pathologist. The therapy was to focus on speech production and speech and language conversational goals that were to be developed through oral myofunctional exercises, maintaining lingual-motor contact during lingual extension and retraction, and air-stream management exercises. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the program was designed to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of oral communication.

For the 2000-2001 academic year, the District offered and provided STUDENT a placement at Neil Armstrong Elementary School in a general education class with speech and language services provided after school hours. There was no contention that implementing STUDENT’s IEP at Neil Armstrong was impossible or impracticable. STUDENT’s parents contended that this was an inappropriate placement because STUDENT’s social-emotional needs could not be met at Neil Armstrong. However, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT had no unique social-emotional needs in the school setting. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the placement offered by the District for academic year 2000-2001 was appropriate.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District identified STUDENT’s unique needs and offered a program designed to meet those needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

The speech therapy program provided to STUDENT was directed to resolve her difficulties producing certain sounds and articulating those sounds in combinations with others. It contemplated placement, strengthening, air-stream management exercises, and both classroom and home practice. STUDENT made progress in this program. The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the program set forth in STUDENT’s IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to her.

Comported with the IEP.

STUDENT made two allegations regarding the District’s failure to provide a program during the 2000-2001 school year that comported with her IEP. First, STUDENT alleged that the speech therapist failed to provide “hands-on” tongue exercises during speech therapy. Second, STUDENT contended that the District failed to provide “quarterly consultations” with the speech therapist.

Barbara Berry explained during her testimony that the “hands-on” tongue muscle strengthening exercises are technically known as myofunctional therapy. At the hearing she also testified that she did deliver services in that manner, thus meeting STUDENT’s established need in that area. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented STUDENT’s IEP regarding “hands-on” tongue muscle strengthening exercises.

STUDENT’s parents found that written progress reports for the period from June 1999 through November 2000 were missing from the District’s evidence package. They contended that those reports were also missing from their records. Thus, they alleged, the quarterly consultations must not have taken place as intended by STUDENT’s IEP. Barbara Berry, the speech pathologist providing the therapy during this period, testified at the hearing that she provided reports and consultations to the parents and to the District during the subject period. She admitted that she could not now find them in the file, but she was certain that they had been prepared. In addition, Ms. Berry pointed out that STUDENT’s mother brought STUDENT to the therapy sessions and that there were frequent and ongoing informal consultations between them. Moreover, the written progress report of January 2001 makes reference to ongoing consultations and the family’s progress with prescribed “home practice.” Finally, as mentioned above, the therapist and teacher reported that, in fact, progress was made. In this regard, it should be noted that Ms. Berry was not a District employee. She was the independent speech pathologist agreed upon by the parties. As such, her testimony did not reflect any bias in favor of the District. The Hearing Officer finds that the speech therapist consulted with STUDENT’s parents and the District at least quarterly and that written reports confirming the consultations were prepared and provided to them.

In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District implemented a program for academic year 2000-2001 that comported with STUDENT’s IEP.

Conclusion.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided a FAPE to STUDENT for academic year 2000-2001. (Footnote 12)

3. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002 (second grade)?

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

STUDENT’s educational program for academic year 2001-2002 was set forth in her May 24, 2001 IEP. The May 24, 2001 IEP indicated that an IEP review meeting would be held on November 15, 2001. The IEP team did not, however, meet on November 15, 2001. STUDENT’s parents contended that the District’s failure to hold the November 2001 “review” was a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of FAPE.

As stated previously, the IEP team must review a student’s IEP periodically, but not less than annually. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(4); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343(d), 56380(a). The question under consideration is whether the absence of the November IEP meeting resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringed on the parents’ right to participate in the IEP process. The evidence presented at the hearing established that during the period between May 24, 2001, and November 13, 2001, STUDENT’s parents communicated with the District a total of nine times. In addition they received informal speech and language updates and one formal update discussing STUDENT’s progress on her goals and objectives. Between November 13, 2001 and June 12, 2002, STUDENT’s parents communicated with the District another fourteen times. Further, the parents received from the District copies of STUDENT’s COGAT testing, the Stanford 9 test results, classroom assessments, a written speech and language update, and a formal speech and language assessment. In addition, they received STUDENT’s report cards showing only five absences for the year and all above-average and excellent grades. The Hearing Officer concludes from this evidence that STUDENT’s parents were an ongoing and integral part of her educational program and process. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not suffer loss of educational opportunity and her parents were not excluded from the IEP process by reason of the failure to hold a review meeting in November, 2001.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness

Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

STUDENT’s parents contended that the District failed to assess all areas of STUDENT’s disability for academic year 2001-2002 because it did not assess her social-emotional needs resulting from the alleged incident that occurred when STUDENT was five years old. STUDENT’s parents did not contend that the District failed to conduct an appropriate speech and language assessment. However, STUDENT’s parents also contended that the district should have re-administered the COGAT testing, the standardized testing used to determine eligibility for the gifted and talented program (GATE).

Karen Heilbronner testified that a comprehensive speech and language assessment was performed by speech pathologist Devon LaHar in October 2001. Ms. Heilbronner referred to the written assessment report in the documentary evidence and pointed out that the assessor administered standardized tests commonly utilized by professionals in her field to assess speech and language impairments. The written assessment report reflected that the CELF-3 was designed to identify children in grades ranging from kindergarten to the twelfth grade who lack the basic foundations of form and content that characterize mature language use, word meaning, word and sentence structure, and recall and retrieval. The test has six subtests. Ms. LaHar also administered the WORD-R test that evaluates the student’s auditory processing abilities, including her skill at understanding and using vocabulary. STUDENT’s parents did not contend that the speech and language assessment was inappropriate.

STUDENT’s parents did take issue with the District’s unwillingness to readminister a standardized test known as the COGAT. (Footnote 13) The testimony established that the District had several reasons to deny the parents’ request to readminister the same test. First, Ms. Robinson, Ms. Heilbronner and Elizabeth Block, who was the special education program manager at the time STUDENT was in second grade, related during their testimony that the COGAT is a test that has a demonstrated learning element within it. Thus, it is recommended by the test designers that it be given no more than once annually and it had just been administered to STUDENT in the fall of 2001. Secondly, according to their testimony, it is appropriate to examine errant subtest scores with a different test instrument rather than using the one producing the “sport” in the first instance. Finally, they stated, the COGAT is a tool the District uses for identifying students for the GATE program for gifted children. Therefore, it was not appropriate to focus on it as a special education assessment tool. The Hearing Officer relies on the persuasive testimony of the experts in this regard and finds to be without merit the contention of the parents that the District should have re-administered the COGAT test. (Footnote 14)

No social-emotional functioning assessment was conducted. STUDENT’s parents again contended that an assessment in this area was required. As stated previously, however, STUDENT did not exhibit any negative social-emotional symptoms in the educational setting and she made progress both in academic functioning as well as in resolving her speech and language impairment. During this academic year, STUDENT’s second-grade teacher was Sue Robinson. Ms. Robinson testified that she was aware that STUDENT had an IEP in effect for academic year 2001-2002. She characterized it as “an IEP for speech.” She testified that STUDENT was a “great student ... eager.... who performed well and progressed.” Ms. Robinson also described STUDENT as “well-motivated, not withdrawn ... she participated.” “She was a child I didn’t have concerns about academically...[she] was a happy camper most of the time,” Ms. Robinson testified at the hearing.

Ms. Robinson also testified that STUDENT “paired up” with another strong-willed girl in her class – a child later described as a “bully” by STUDENT’s parents. However, Ms. Robinson did not recall any unusual or out of the ordinary incidents taking place in the classroom between these two children which she described as “friends.”

Ms. Robinson observed that STUDENT appeared to be happy in school. She liked drama and had “staked out” the part of Wendy in the school play. “We actually did another play.” Ms. Robinson added, continuing, “but she did well.” Ms. Robinson’s concluding comments were, “STUDENT is a pleasure to have in class. She was happy to be learning, participating in class. I liked her as a person.” Petitioner did not present any persuasive evidence to the contrary.

The Hearing Officer concludes that during second grade, STUDENT provided the District with no indication that a social-emotional assessment was required.

Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language have been examined previously in this Decision. Those needs did not change significantly in academic year 2001-2002. She still needed hands-on, myofunctional speech therapy to increase the muscle strength and mobility of her tongue. She continued to need one-on-one speech therapy to resolve articulation and production issues. Her speech therapist also determined she had a need for continued practice and, in that regard, developed a home program with her parents and a school carryover program that was developed with her general education teacher. The program set forth in STUDENT’s IEP, including its goals and objectives, was designed to address those needs.

As stated above, there was no indication of the necessity to assess STUDENT’s social-emotional functioning in the school environment and the IEP team did not determine that she had any social-emotional needs that related to her education. Further, no evidence was admitted at the due process hearing that supported the existence of such a need. Without evidence that STUDENT had social-emotional needs relating to her education, the Hearing Officer also finds that no counseling need was established. (Footnote 15)

Placement and Services.

For the 2001-2002 school year, the District offered placement at Neil Armstrong in a general education class with speech and language services provided after school hours. The only objection made by STUDENT’s parents to the placement at Neil Armstrong was the contention that its graduating students are placed into a junior high school attended by the alleged perpetrator. (Footnote 16)

The Hearing Officer finds that the concern with future placement was speculative, that the anticipated attendance at the future school by the alleged perpetrator was speculative, and that STUDENT’s anticipated posttraumatic stress syndrome reaction also was speculative. The IEP process implements a special education student’s educational program. The IEP process is examined and re-evaluated annually. Thus, the parents’ objection is, at best, premature. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement at Neil Armstrong with speech and language services provided after school hours was appropriate.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

STUDENT’s IEP was designed with input from her speech therapist and the speech pathologist who provided her comprehensive assessment. The program set forth in her IEP was similar to the ones that had proven successful in the past. Additionally, STUDENT continued to progress at school in the academic curriculum as evidenced by her standardized test results and her report card. She also progressed communicatively and socially as evidenced by her teacher comments and the testimony of her teachers and classroom aide. The results of her comprehensive speech and language assessment reflected her progress and growth toward resolving the areas of her speech and language impairment. The program provided by her IEP proved to be successful. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s IEP was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Conclusion.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided a FAPE to STUDENT for academic year 2001-2002. (Footnote 17)

4. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003 (third grade)?

(a) Procedural Appropriateness.

STUDENT’s educational program and the District’s offer for third grade was developed at the June 12, 2002 IEP meeting. Those attending were STUDENT’s mother, her friend FAMILY FRIEND 3, Ms. Ellgas, pathologist Barbara Berry, and Elizabeth Block, special education program manager for the District. Ms. Robinson, STUDENT’s general education teacher could not attend. She sent a letter in lieu of her appearance describing STUDENT’s progress. STUDENT’s parents contended that the absence of STUDENT’s general education teacher constituted a procedural violation, the result of which was denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.

California Education Code section 56341(f) states that parents of disabled children have the right to present information to the IEP team in person or through a representative and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning. Among the people who must be included in the IEP team are the student’s parents and/or representative, one regular education teacher, one special education teacher or special education provider, a representative of the district, and an individual who conducted an assessment of the pupil or who is knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the pupil and is familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. §USC 1414(d)(1)(B); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b). Additionally, the pupil may be included in the IEP team when appropriate and, at the discretion of the parents or district, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil may be included in the team. (Id.)

The language of California Education Code section 56341(b) is specific, specifying in terms relevant to the present matter, “at least one general education teacher of the pupil” if the student is or will be participating in at least one class in the general education environment. Thus, on its face, the absence of a general education teacher was a procedural violation of California Education Code section 56341(b).

Having identified the violation, the Hearing Officer thus turns to the question of whether this violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or serious infringement of the parents’ right to participate in the IEP meeting. Both State and federal laws emphasize the importance of including a regular education teacher in each meeting to develop, review, or revise the IEP. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.

STUDENT’s general education teacher, Ms. Robinson, testified at the due process hearing that she had not been provided sufficient notice of the date of the meeting and she had a conflict. However, she testified that she had conversations with STUDENT’s parents during the year and that she recalled specifically talking about STUDENT’s progress. She also recalled being informed by STUDENT’s parents that STUDENT was experiencing conflict and stress as a result of contact with the bullying child. Ms. Robinson was careful to observe STUDENT’s interactions with that child and indicated that nothing out of the ordinary took place. She testified, “________ and STUDENT together didn’t seem to raise any hackles.” Ms. Robinson also testified that STUDENT was not withdrawn, was not quiet, and was not afraid or depressed and that she participated in class as did typical students.

Knowing that she would not be able to participate in person at the IEP, Ms. Robinson sent a letter to be read at the meeting. It stated:

According to my personal observation and academic testing, STUDENT ... is a high average student. In reading, she is able to decode and comprehend grade level text and scored above grade level on the Gates-McGinitie. In Writing, she consistently performs above grade level in content and mechanics. She has a solid mastery of the conventions of language and how to express herself in the written form as well as verbally. She contributes clear and focused communication to class discussions and follows directions easily. In Math, STUDENT has mastered all of the standards and benchmarks, noting a complete mastery of regrouping in subtraction that is difficult for most second grade students. She is a pleasure to have in class. /s/ Susan M. Robinson Second Grade Teacher

STUDENT’s IEP meeting and the program offer that came out of it was not fatally flawed by the absence of her teacher at the IEP meeting. STUDENT’s parents took the opportunity to participate in her school program on a continual basis. The school principal, Ms. Ellgas, had ongoing communications with STUDENT’s parents and according to her testimony kept an eye on STUDENT. Ms. Berry saw STUDENT weekly for speech therapy. Ms. Block, the program manager, also had a continuing relationship with STUDENT’s family. The people at the meeting were fully familiar with STUDENT’s progress and performance and they were capable of developing a program offer designed to meet her needs. Ms. Robinson participated in the meeting by transmitting the letter set forth above describing STUDENT’s progress. Finally, no allegation was made and no evidence was introduced to establish that if Ms. Robinson had attended the IEP meeting, a different outcome would have resulted.

Additionally, nothing that took place at any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings affected the presentation of the general education curriculum to STUDENT. Ms. Robinson had been STUDENT’s second-grade general education teacher the previous year and was already familiar with STUDENT’s general education abilities and levels of performance as well as her speech and language impairment. STUDENT’s educational program in second grade consisted of a full day of general education classes and activities and after-school speech therapy once weekly. The District’s offer for third grade was the same. For all intents and purposes, excepting for the speech and language impairment, STUDENT was a general education student who participated in the general education setting in the same way as did other general education students. On these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that the absence of the general education teacher at the IEP meeting did not prejudice the student or her parents, cause STUDENT to lose educational opportunity, or cause serious infringement on the parents’ right to meaningful participation in the IEP process.

(b) Substantive Appropriateness.

Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

The triennial speech and language assessment had been conducted in October 2001. It was updated and provided to the IEP team at the June 12, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Berry prepared a written update, describing STUDENT’s present levels of performance in speech and language therapy, for use at the IEP meeting of June 12, 2002. As with prior years, STUDENT was not exhibiting any social-emotional symptoms and was participating socially in the classroom. No additional evaluations were needed for the meeting.

Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

It was determined by the speech pathologist during the October 2001 assessment that STUDENT was performing at or near grade level in several of the speech and language categories that previously had proven difficult for her. The assessor stated that “STUDENT’s ability to understand and use language skills (including vocabulary, syntax, auditory-processing, fluency, voice, and pragmatics) fall within appropriate instructional range for her age.” The IEP team accepted this encouraging report. However, with Ms. Berry’s additional input, the team determined that STUDENT continued to need speech therapy to resolve her inability to produce certain sounds. She continued to have needs in the area of tongue strength and the production of /s/ and /z/ sounds in connected speech.

Ms. Berry further recommended that the IEP team provide more frequent and shorter sessions and a change of speech therapists in an effort to motivate STUDENT to work more diligently on those sounds. The team determined that it would offer sixty minutes of total speech therapy time per week, as it did previously. However it did agree that a change of therapists could be a helpful motivator. STUDENT’s parents did not dispute the value of the speech therapy program. When they voluntarily withdrew STUDENT from public school, they requested that the District continue her speech and language program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District continued to accurately identify STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of speech and language.

Placement and Services.

No request was made during the June 12, 2002 IEP meeting by STUDENT’s parents for the District to provide a social-emotional assessment, counseling, or special education services in addition to the speech and language services provided in STUDENT’s IEP. Similarly, no objection to STUDENT’s placement in a general education setting with after-hours speech and language services was made at the meeting.

However, STUDENT’s parents contended at the due process hearing that STUDENT needed a change of schools because of her need for a safe environment which protected her from possible contact with the alleged perpetrator, and because of her fear of coming to school because of the “bully.”

The District contended that STUDENT showed no evidence of social-emotional needs or the need for an environment any safer than any other student and the District was prepared to implement her IEP at Neil Armstrong.

The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT had no social-emotional needs that the District was required to address. Further, he finds that the above-described program would have met STUDENT’s speech and language needs for the 2002-2003 school year. As she had no other needs, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Produce Educational Benefit.

The evidence showed that the District’s offer, as in the prior years, was designed to provide STUDENT remedial support in the area of her speech and language impairment. A substantially similar program had proved successful with STUDENT during the immediate past as was demonstrated by the improvement in STUDENT’s communication skills and her continuing grasp of the curriculum and progress in the general education setting. By offering a program substantially similar to one that had been successful previously, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered a program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Comport with IEP.

Ms. Heilbronner testified that had the parents approved the June 12, 2002 IEP and had STUDENT remained in the District, she would have been placed pursuant to her IEP and would have been provided the program set forth in the IEP. Nicole Pitts was identified and agreed upon by the parties as the new speech therapist. When the District agreed in September 2002 as part of an interim agreement to provide speech therapy to STUDENT while she attended Quarry Lane, a noncertified private school, Ms. Pitts provided therapy for STUDENT. When she appeared to plateau, Ms. Pitts added additional expertise to the mix, consulting with Patricia O’Neal, a myofunctional expert. That testimony is undisputed. (Footnote 18)

The evidence established that the District was ready and willing to implement the program proposed and provided STUDENT with speech services in conformity with the interim mediation agreement while she attended Quarry Lane. Thus, the District continued to provide STUDENT speech therapy comporting with her IEP.

Conclusion.

For the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003.

5. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004 (fourth grade)?

STUDENT had been a privately placed student since September 2002; however, her parents contended that her placement was not voluntary. They claimed it was a necessity since the District failed to make STUDENT an offer of a FAPE during academic year 2002-2003.

The District contended that after her withdrawal from public school, there was no longer an obligation on behalf of the District to provide services to her. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that the District is correct that pursuant to the 1997 amendments to the IDEA, children with disabilities who have been voluntarily placed by their parents in a private school or facility have no individual entitlement to receive services from a public educational agency. Foley v. Special Sch. Dist. of St. Louis County, 153 F.3d 863, 865 (8th Cir. 1998); 34 C.F.R. § 300.454(a). However, where, as here, the question of whether the school district has offered the child a FAPE is at issue, the extent of the public educational agency’s obligations to the child may not be determined solely on the basis of the child’s private school status. In this case, the parent requested an IEP meeting to discuss the availability of an appropriate program from the District. The District then held an IEP meeting on August 18, 2003, at which it developed and offered STUDENT an IEP for the 2003-2004 academic year. The Hearing Officer must therefore examine the issue of whether the District offered a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.

Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

On September 14, 2002, the parties entered into an interim mediation agreement providing, inter alia, for a psychoeducational assessment, educational testing and updated speech and language report . The psychoeducational assessment of Cynthia Peterson was completed in March 2003 and was reviewed by the parties at a meeting on June 18, 2003, in advance of academic year 2003-2004. The evaluation identified certain language processing weaknesses and Dr. Peterson concluded that STUDENT had “mild” language based learning disability and therefore qualified for speech therapy. Mary Jane McCoy conducted STUDENT’s educational testing. Ms. McCoy found STUDENT able to benefit from the general education curriculum based upon the results. STUDENT’s broad reading score was in the 85th percentile, her broad math in the 88th percentile, and her broad written language was in the 96th percentile. Ms. Pitts provided an update on STUDENT’s present levels of performance in her speech and language program. The Hearing Officer observes that the Petersen assessment and the updated speech and educational testing confirmed the District’s prior assessments.

Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

The IEP team met on August 18, 2003. It determined that STUDENT remained eligible for services because of a speech and language impairment that impacted communication. Further, it was determined that STUDENT’s needs included continuing speech therapy two times per week for thirty minutes for articulation, one time a week for a total of forty-five minutes for language difficulties, and one time per month for sixty minutes for consultations with teachers. Dr. Petersen recommended the increase in time due to “complex language” issues. (Footnote 19)

Dr. Peterson did not recommend psychotherapy or counseling. Her evaluation assumed the truth of the statements made to her by STUDENT’s parents purporting to describe the incident and bullying. Significantly, Dr. Petersen mentioned no statements by STUDENT that tended to verify the allegations of her parents. Dr. Petersen’s conclusion was that STUDENT had made her own adjustment to the traumas and needed no more help. Dr. Peterson did not find that STUDENT had social-emotional issues that interfered with her education and, therefore, did not find that she had unique needs in that area. (Footnote 20) Placement and Services.

The District offered STUDENT a placement at Neil Armstrong Elementary School in a general education class with speech and language services provided pursuant to her IEP after school hours. The speech services offered were in the increased amounts recommended by Dr. Petersen. Based on the foregoing and the lack of persuasive evidence otherwise, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a program designed to address her unique needs.

Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

The offer made on August 18, 2003, was that of the speech and language program and general education program that STUDENT had received since kindergarten, now somewhat refined and improved with an increased amount of speech therapy time designated. STUDENT consistently progressed in speech and language skills and did well academically throughout this entire period. However, she appeared to plateau in some areas of her speech production and, according to Phyllis Comb, her current speech therapist, she now needed additional therapy in order to move forward toward resolution of this impairment. Barbara Berry also testified that the increased time would be appropriate at this time. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offered by the District was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

Comports with the IEP.

Ms. Heilbronner testified that had STUDENT chosen to return to the District for her elementary education, the District would have placed her in the general education population at Neil Armstrong and provided the speech and language program offered in the IEP.

Conclusion.

For the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for academic year 2003-2004.

6. Compensatory Education/Reimbursement

If the District failed to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for any of academic years 1999-2000, 2000-2001, 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004, should the District be ordered to provide STUDENT with compensatory education or, alternatively, provide reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the cost of her placement in a noncertified, nonpublic school during academic years 2002-2003 and 2003-2004?

Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994). The Hearing Officer has found that the District offered and provided a FAPE to STUDENT for academic years 1999-2000, 2000-2001, and 2001-2002, and offered STUDENT a FAPE in 2002-2003 and 2003-2004. In view of those findings, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for tuition paid to the nonpublic school.

STUDENT’s parents additionally contended that STUDENT is entitled to an award of compensatory education for the speech therapy not provided by the District in school year 2003-2004. The authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes the finder of fact to grant “such relief as it determines appropriate.” Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991). The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services. Moubry v. Independent Sch. Dist. No. 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D.Md. 1996). The Hearing Officer has found that the District made a FAPE available to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year and that her parents instead elected to place her in a private school. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not have an obligation to provide speech therapy during academic year 2003-2004 and that STUDENT is not entitled to any compensatory education.

ORDER

Petitioner’s claims for relief are hereby denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with that requirement:

The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this matter have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is taken, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Dated: August 20, 2004

__________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Attorney Eileen Mattucci, who was Petitioner’s attorney of record, gave notice that she had withdrawn. On the first day of hearing, she made a special appearance for Petitioner, to assist in negotiating resolution of this matter. When that proved unsuccessful, attorney Mattucci withdrew without objection

2 STUDENT’S parents contended that the Hearing Officer should make findings relating to alleged failures or negligence of the District during academic year 1998-1999. They acknowledged during the hearing that any claim for this academic year was barred by the statute of limitations. The Hearing Officer accepts the concession by STUDENT’S parents and therefore declines to make findings relating to any such claims. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(j).

3 The attorneys’ fees contentions are noted. However, that issue is beyond the scope of the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. The Hearing Officer may award fees only with agreement of the parties, a condition not present here. See 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56507(b). Therefore, the issue of attorney’s fees will not be addressed further in this Decision.

4 For purposes of ease of reference as well as neutrality, the sexual activity or experimentation, or alleged molest and sexual assault as STUDENT’S parents contend, is referred to in this Decision as “the incident.”

5 STUDENT’S parents had several meetings with Ms. Ellgas as the school year began. Because their three children were receiving special education and related services, contact with the school was frequent and the contacts often related to issues involving more than one of the children.

6 STUDENT has been in a general education class since preschool. Her related services began in kindergarten. She is currently in a general education class in a noncertified private school. A more restrictive placement has never been found necessary.

7 The program adopted at Neil Armstrong at that time provided for one teacher to teach a class for two years before moving them on to another teacher. The next teacher would also have the class for two years, and so on. Using this device, the students were expected to gain a sense of continuity and stability.

8 The parents contended that they met with Ms. Ellgas and expressed their concern over STUDENT’S experience, but no specific request for counseling was made at that time.

9 “Least Restrictive Environment” is not a disputed issue in this matter and it will not be discussed further in this Decision.

10 STUDENT’S parents designated her speech program as an issue in contention as to each of her school years. The evidence presented, however, was directed primarily to the social-emotional issues alleged and did not establish any significant differences of opinion as to speech except as may be briefly noted in the text of the Decision

11 Cynthia Petersen, Ph.D., who prepared a psychoeducational evaluation in 2003, indicated that STUDENT had no need for counseling and did not recommend it.

12 There was no issue in dispute relating to whether the placement at Neil Armstrong was in the least restrictive environment.

13 (The evidence showed that STUDENT’S COGAT scores were somewhat inconsistent. All of her scores were in the average to above average range. However, the score on one subtest was lower than the rest.)

14 There was no direct evidence that STUDENT’S parents requested counseling.

15 That is, children who attend Neil Armstrong usually matriculate after sixth grade to the same junior high school as the children who attend the alleged perpetrator’s present elementary school.

16 There is no issue in dispute relating to whether the program provided to STUDENT comported with the IEP or whether the placement at Neil Armstrong was in the least restrictive environment.

17 There is no issue in dispute relating to whether the program provided to STUDENT comported with the IEP or whether the placement at Neil Armstrong was in the least restrictive environment.

18 During the hearing STUDENT’S parents contended that the District violated the terms of the interim mediation agreement. The evidence did not support that contention. Pursuant to the agreement, an additional fifteen minutes of speech therapy was provided and a psychoeducational assessment was to be completed. There was a delay in choosing the assessor. The evidence did not establish the District as the cause of the delay. It was not until January 2003 that the parties agreed on one, namely, Cynthia Petersen, Ph.D. Dr. Petersen completed the assessment as the parties intended.

19 Dr. Petersen was not a speech pathologist. However, the District members of the IEP team accepted her recommendation for increased speech therapy at this time.

20 Dr. Petersen did recommend continuation in the non-public school, ostensibly because STUDENT felt safer there with surveillance cameras posted about. However, it was never established that STUDENT felt unsafe at Neil Armstrong. No one, not even her parents, ever suggested that surveillance cameras were one of STUDENT’S unique needs. Further, STUDENT did not express fear or anxiety to any witness who did testify at the hearing. Unfortunately Dr. Petersen did not testify. She was reportedly near-term in her pregnancy and did not wish to appear either in person or by telephone. The IEP team did not adopt her placement recommendation.