California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 25, 1996

Student v. Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 198-96, SN 216-96 · Hearing Officer Kathleen S. Chovan

Dry Creek Joint Elementary must keep first grader in full-day general education with new behavior plan and inclusion support.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 2 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District filed for hearing to move a seven-year-old from a full-inclusion general education first grade class at Quail Glen Elementary into a special day class for students with severe disabilities. Her grandparents, who are her legal guardians, filed their own case to keep her in general education. The two cases were consolidated. She was eligible for special education because of developmental delays in academic, motor, and language skills. She had made progress in fully included preschool and kindergarten classes, but her behavior problems grew in first grade.

Using the four-factor Holland/Rachel H. test, the Hearing Officer held that the District had not met its burden. She rejected expert testimony that children who function far below their classmates cannot benefit from inclusion, and she found that the curriculum could be adapted. The student gained social benefits from nondisabled peers, although aides did not help her play with other children at recess. The District's behavior plan, written by Rodger Stein of Applied Behavior Consultants, relied on rewards that did not work for her, lacked clear reinforcement steps, and was poorly documented. Staff came to rely on removing her from class 60–70% of the time. The District did not argue cost. The Hearing Officer ordered a full-day general education placement for second grade with a 1:1 aide and Dr. Frank Marone's positive behavior plan, under his supervision. She also ordered a full inclusion coordinator for 300 minutes a week, then 150 minutes, and an IEP meeting within 15 days.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied the Holland/Rachel H. least restrictive environment test to a student with significant delays. A district seeking a more restrictive placement had to show that appropriate supports, including a properly designed and documented positive behavior plan, had been tried. Comparing the student with her classmates' achievement was not enough.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Is a full-day placement in a regular education classroom the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT?

    Applying the four Holland/Rachel H. factors, the Hearing Officer held that the District did not show the student could not be educated satisfactorily in general education. The student had benefited from earlier inclusion and received social benefits, and the District's behavior plan and supports were inadequate. Cost was not argued.

  2. Issue 2. If a full-day placement in a regular education classroom is not appropriate for STUDENT, is a special day class the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

    This issue was not addressed because the Hearing Officer found the general education placement appropriate.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Placement ordered. Full-day placement in a regular education second grade classroom for the 1996-97 school year.
  • Order to provide or change services. One full-day 1:1 instructional aide. The IEP team must consider Dr. Frank Marone's recommended aide qualifications, but the aide may be a District employee if selected based on the student's needs, especially in language and behavior.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must implement Dr. Frank Marone's April 1, 1996 positive behavioral intervention plan (except for the aide-employer provision). Dr. Marone or his designee is to train staff and supervise the behavior program, and the District must consider using peers to model and support appropriate behavior.
  • Staff training. Dr. Marone, or a person he designates, must train staff as described in his April 1, 1996 plan.
  • Order to provide or change services. Full inclusion coordinator with demonstrated experience: at least 300 minutes per week through the end of November 1996, then 150 minutes per week for the rest of second grade unless the IEP team keeps a higher level. The coordinator and staff must consider the curriculum adaptations listed in footnote 17.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The District must convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the order to revise the IEP to match the order.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874 (E.D. Cal. 1992); Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir. 1994); Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830 (9th Cir. 1995); D.F. v. Western School Corporation, 921 F. Supp. 559 (S.D. Ind. 1996); Mavis v. Sobol, 839 F. Supp. 968 (N.D.N.Y. 1994); Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (5th Cir. 1989); Education Code section 56520 (Hughes Bill); 5 CCR sections 3001, 3052

People named in the decision

  • Clark Redfield, assistant superintendent for Educational Services, Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Agnes Gallant, special education (RSP) teacher, Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Gordon Medd, principal, Quail Glen Elementary School
  • Mary Snyder-Lee, kindergarten teacher, Quail Glen Elementary School
  • Susan Morris, first grade general education teacher, Quail Glen Elementary School
  • Rodger Stein, behavior specialist; director of educational services; author of District behavior plan, Applied Behavior Consultants (ABC)
  • Sherron L. Scripa, education specialist; classroom observer for District, District witness
  • Dr. Diane Ashton, educational consultant, District witness
  • Jenny Grounds, program specialist, Placer County Office of Education
  • Marc LaFleur, school psychologist (triennial assessment), Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Laura Smith, special day class teacher, Brown School
  • Dr. Bryna Siegel, expert witness for District; associate professor of psychiatry, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute, UCSF
  • Angela Mizera, speech-language pathologist, Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Marianna Davis, instructional aide, Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Peggy Farmer, instructional aide, Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District
  • Joanne Day, principal, Parkside Elementary School, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Dr. Alice Davis Parker, director of student services, San Mateo-Foster City School District
  • Julie Ferguson, assistant day-care coordinator, Adventure Club
  • Mary Jane Klope, educational consultant/advocate for family, Student witness
  • Tom Neary, full inclusion consultant; expert witness for Student, RISE
  • Patricia Selby, full inclusion teacher/inclusion specialist, San Mateo County Office of Education
  • Dr. Paula Gardner, assistant professor; witness for Student, California State University, Sacramento
  • Linda Brooks, full inclusion specialist; expert witness for Student, Davis Unified School District
  • Dr. Frank Marone, director of services; behavior expert for Student; ordered to supervise behavior plan, Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA)
  • Larry Douglass, behavior specialist; witness for Student
  • Jackie McHaney, attorney for District, Thurbon and Youngblood

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Kathleen Chovan, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, in Antelope, California, on April 16-19, 1996, April 23-26, 1996, and May 9 and 13, 1996. Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District (District or Petitioner (footnote 1)) was represented by Jeanette R. Youngblood, attorney.)(footnote 2) Also present on behalf of the District was Clark Redfield, assistant superintendent for Educational Services; and Agnes Gallant, special education teacher. Respondent STUDENT was represented by attorneys Dale Mentink and Sarah Clarke. Also present on behalf of STUDENT were GRANDFATHER and GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT's grandparents and legal guardians.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open to allow the parties to submit written closing briefs. Closing briefs were received on June 7, 1996. Thereafter, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

The following witnesses were called to testify by the District: Clark Redfield; Gordon Medd, principal, Quail Glen Elementary School; Agnes Gallant; Mary Snyder-Lee, kindergarten teacher, Quail Glen; Rodger Stein, director of educational services, Applied Behavior Consultants; Sherron L. Scripa, education specialist; Dr. Diane Ashton, educational consultant; Jenny Grounds, program specialist, Placer County Office of Education (PCOE); Marc LaFleur, District psychologist; Laura Smith, special day class teacher, Brown School; Dr. Bryna Siegel, associate professor of psychiatry, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute, University of California, San Francisco; Angela Mizera, District speech and language pathologist; Marianna Davis, District instructional aide; Susan Morris, first grade teacher, Quail Glen; Peggy Farmer, District instructional aide; Joanne Day, principal, Parkside Elementary School, San Mateo-Foster City School District; Dr. Alice Davis Parker, director of student services, San Mateo-Foster City School District; and Julie Ferguson, assistant day-care coordinator, Adventure Club.

The following witnesses were called to testify by the Respondent: Mary Jane Klope, educational consultant; Tom Neary, full inclusion consultant, RISE; Patricia Selby, full inclusion teacher, San Mateo County Office of Education; Dr. Paula Gardner, assistant professor, California State University, Sacramento; Linda Brooks, full inclusion specialist, Davis Unified School District; Dr. Frank Marone, director of services, Behavior Education Training Associates; Larry Douglass, behavior specialist; and GRANDMOTHER, STUDENT's grandmother.

ISSUES

1. Is a full-day placement in a regular education classroom the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT?

2. If a full-day placement in a regular education classroom is not appropriate for STUDENT, is a special day class the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

FACTS

STUDENT is seven years old, and is eligible for special education services because of developmental delays in academic, motor, and language areas. She lives with her grandparents, GRANDMOTHER and GRANDFATHER, her legal guardians, in Roseville, California. STUDENT began the 1995-96 school year as a fully included student in a regular education first grade classroom at Quail Glen Elementary School within the District. However, STUDENT stopped attending school in April 1996, as a result of the dispute which is the subject of this consolidated hearing.

STUDENT first became eligible for special education services in May 1992, when she was three years old. At that time, STUDENT lived within the San Mateo-Foster City School District (San Mateo District). The San Mateo District assessed STUDENT, based on a referral by the GRANDPARENTS, and found her eligible for special education services because of below average general intellectual functioning. The San Mateo District recommended placement for STUDENT in one of three special day classes (SDC), along with related services in the form of speech and language services, adapted physical education (APE), and occupational therapy (OT). (Dist. Exh. A, pp. 67-71)

The GRANDPARENTS agreed with the related services, but did not agree to the proposed SDC placements. On June 22, 1992, the GRANDPARENTS filed for a hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office against the San Mateo District on the issue of placement. (Dist. Exh. A, p. 186) As part of the settlement of that hearing, the parties agreed that STUDENT would be placed in the San Mateo County Headstart Program, a regular pre-school program, in the fall of 1992. As part of her related services, STUDENT was provided integration specialist services for 100 minutes per week. (Dist. Exh. A, p.77)

In November 1992, an IEP meeting was held to review STUDENT's progress, and improvement was noted in all areas. STUDENT's Headstart teacher reported that STUDENT's attention span was improving, and that she interacted with her classmates, she was learning the classroom routine, and that she was well behaved. The teacher's list of concerns included STUDENT's parallel play and her difficulty with waiting in line and taking turns. She also noted that STUDENT needed to increase her active participation in large group activities. (Dist. Exh. A, p. 80)

STUDENT's inclusion specialist stated, "GRANDFATHER and GRANDMOTHER report that STUDENT loves to come to school, and her behavior there reflects that." She noted that STUDENT was beginning to observe and imitate her peers during play and circle time, and that attempts at interactive play were emerging. (Dist. Exh. A, pp. 80-81) During the November IEP, the team decided to assign a 1:1 instructional assistant to STUDENT for one hour per day to assist STUDENT with her toileting needs and her participation in group activities. (Dist. Exh. A, p. 77)

When the IEP team reviewed STUDENT's progress in March of 1993, it concluded that STUDENT had demonstrated gains in all areas. At that time, STUDENT's integration specialist reported:

STUDENT continues to enjoy school. She is easily directed to group circle and the different program areas of the classroom. She follows simple one step directions and responds well to verbal cues and praise. She continues to engage adults for assistance and interaction, and plays on a parallel level with her peers. Some interaction with peers initiating is slowly emerging. She has attempted interactions with a few peers by imitating. Several peers are protective of her.

STUDENT has demonstrated understanding of turn-taking and sharing given verbal cues from staff...STUDENT is always willing to try an activity. She is easy to work with, easily redirected and continues to show growth at her own developmental levels.

(Dist. Exh. A pp. 100-101)

During this IEP, STUDENT's Headstart teacher indicated that STUDENT's lists of strengths included a good attitude toward school, an increasing vocabulary, an ability to stay in circle longer, and an increase in interactive play with other children. She stated, however, that STUDENT needed to work on increasing her interaction with children, and noted that STUDENT was beginning to have small tantrums, including kicking and biting. (Dist. Exh. A pp. 104-105)

When the IEP team met again in December of 1993 to review STUDENT's Headstart placement, they reported that STUDENT had made some very nice gains in her daily functioning in the preschool program. Her Headstart teacher reported that STUDENT was very happy, would join circle time for fifteen minutes, and that she was talking a lot, asking for friends, and trying to have a conversation. (Dist. Exh. A pp. 112, 114).

At this time, STUDENT continued to receive the services of an inclusion teacher, Patricia Selby, for 100 minutes per week. Ms. Selby also reported that STUDENT would sit and participate during open circle, usually for the entire time. She stated that STUDENT interacted with other children, most often by watching and imitating them. Ms. Selby noted that STUDENT still had difficulties with attention to task, standing in line, waiting her turn, and participating in large group activities. She noted, however, that STUDENT appeared comfortable with the daily routine, and that she was interested in school and enjoyed it. Ms. Selby concluded that STUDENT had shown growth in all areas. (Dist Exh. A pp. 125-127).

At the end of STUDENT's 1993-94 preschool year, the IEP team noted that STUDENT had continued to make progress, and recommended placement in a regular education kindergarten program for the 1994-95 school year. The IEP team increased STUDENT's inclusion specialist services to 300 minutes per week, in order to facilitate her transition into kindergarten, and they provided her with the assistance of a 1:1 aide throughout her day. (Dist. Exh. A p. 137)

In August 1994, STUDENT began her kindergarten year in a regular education class at Parkside Elementary, her neighborhood school. STUDENT attended Parkside from August through September 21, 1994, when she moved with her grandparents to Roseville, California. In early November 1994, Patricia Selby, STUDENT's full inclusion teacher, wrote a summary of STUDENT's progress on her IEP goals and her transition from preschool to the kindergarten class at Parkside Elementary. Ms. Selby reported that STUDENT was able to sit in circle time in the small and large group for up to 30 minutes in her kindergarten class. She stated that STUDENT "very much watches and follows the example of her peers, and this was very helpful to her in this transition period." She noted that STUDENT was well liked by her classmates and that she appeared to be forming friendships with several students before she moved away. (Dist. Exh. B-3)

Ms. Selby noted that STUDENT often wanted to work on puzzles, which is a preferred activity for her. In order to encourage STUDENT to try other activities, Ms. Selby described a strategy in which the staff would give STUDENT a choice of two activities that they wanted her to try. When STUDENT would ask instead to do a puzzle, the staff would tell STUDENT that she could work on a puzzle after ten minutes of working on the other activities. Ms. Selby reported that by the end of the first week, STUDENT was choosing to stay with the initial activity for 20-30 minutes before going to a preferred activity. (Id.)

With regard to her IEP goals, Ms. Selby noted that STUDENT continued to need adult support and supervision throughout the day. She indicated, however, that STUDENT's need for support was diminishing, and that the aide was working with other children in STUDENT's class. She noted progress in all areas, including an improvement in STUDENT's conflict resolution skills, although she required prompting from staff. Ms. Selby noted that attention to task remained a difficult area for STUDENT, and that she was easily distracted. She stated that STUDENT worked best with a minimal amount of materials at one time. (Id.)

Once STUDENT moved to Roseville, she was enrolled in a regular education kindergarten class at Quail Glen Elementary School within the Dry Creek Joint Elementary School District. She began attending Quail Glen on October 21, 1994 in the Resource Specialist Program (RSP), and she received 30 minutes per day of RSP services, which were provided within the regular kindergarten class. She also had the services of a 1:1 aide, as well as speech and language therapy, OT and APE. (Dist. Exh. B-2).

At the end of January 1995, STUDENT's teacher, Mary Snyder-Lee, described STUDENT as a "very loving and friendly student" who was increasingly communicating her wants and needs to adults. She stated that STUDENT was following secondary directions, took pleasure in work she completed herself, and was interacting with children during recess. Ms. Snyder-Lee noted concern, however, that STUDENT was displaying inappropriate behavior in the classroom such as kicking, hitting, touching, making loud noises, and intruding into the personal boundaries of other students. She stated that the staff would continue to help STUDENT focus on appropriate classroom behavior. (Resp. Exh. 9)

During the spring of 1995, the District performed a triennial assessment of STUDENT, then age six. The District psychologist, Marc LaFleur, conducted testing of STUDENT and observed her in her kindergarten setting. In his report, Mr. LaFleur noted that STUDENT had a difficult time maintaining attention, although her attending skills had improved significantly. He reported that language was also an area of relative weakness for STUDENT, but that her skills appeared to be rapidly emerging. Mr. LaFleur noted that STUDENT enjoyed the companionship of her peers and would enter into activities. He also noted, however, that her attention span during activities was short, and she tended to engage in parallel play with her peers. (Dist. Exh. B-7)

Based on his assessment, Mr. LaFleur stated that STUDENT was displaying delays in all areas of development, with motor development and language continuing to be areas of relative weakness. He concluded, however, that STUDENT appeared to be growing in her full inclusion setting, and that her placement appeared appropriate. Based on her difficulties with behavior, Mr. LaFleur suggested that the IEP team consider consulting a "behavior intervention specialist" to assist in developing a behavior plan for STUDENT. (Id.)

In April 1995, an IEP team meeting was held to discuss the results of STUDENT's triennial assessment, to review her placement in Ms. Snyder-Lee's class, and to discuss STUDENT's placement for the upcoming year. During this IEP meeting, Ms. Snyder-Lee reported that STUDENT had made "tremendous growth" in the areas of following directions, trying all of the activity stations, and allowing staff to provide her with physical prompting. STUDENT's attention span had also improved during both individual work time and whole group time, although she still needed to work on her whole group skills. Overall, Ms. Snyder-Lee concluded that STUDENT had shown great improvement in class, and she stated that STUDENT's behavior no longer interfered with her learning. (Dist. Exh. B-6)

The IEP team noted that STUDENT's strengths included her emerging language, her improving attention span, and her enjoyment of her peers. The IEP team discussed the development of a behavioral plan, but did not reach a conclusion on this issue during the meeting. The team recommended that STUDENT remain in a regular education setting with RSP services for the upcoming year. (Id.) On April 24, 1995, Ms. Snyder-Lee awarded STUDENT with a certificate for "most improved" student at Quail Glen during April of 1995. (Resp. Exh. 14)

STUDENT started first grade on July 10, 1995 in Susan Morris' classroom.(footnote 3) STUDENT was assigned two aides, with one aide working with STUDENT for the morning session and the other aide working with STUDENT in the afternoon. On August 10, 1995, the parties held a team meeting(footnote 4) to discuss STUDENT's transition into first grade. The GRANDPARENTS and district staff discussed methods for increasing communication between the school and STUDENT's home, and discussed appropriate warning signs and procedures to use in relation to STUDENT's severe headaches. At that team meeting, STUDENT's behavior was apparently not a major topic of concern. (Dist. Exh. B-12).

By the middle of August, however, Ms. Morris had concluded that her classroom was not the appropriate placement for STUDENT. In a statement written around the fourth week of August (footnote 5), Ms. Morris stated as follows:

Since our last Team Meeting, behaviors have gotten progressively worse. STUDENT wants nothing to do with most of the activities that we offer her. When given choices she refused them by either saying or yelling "No, no, no!" When told that she will do an activity or sit in the time out chair, she runs from the adult. The adults try to verbally persuade STUDENT to come back to her seat and she ignores them and continues to distance herself. When STUDENT does go to the time out chair, she puts her hand over her head and hits her hand while yelling out or making very loud crying noises.

STUDENT's attention span is approximately two minutes long in most classroom situations. Given this figure, we have to provide STUDENT with 150 activities to keep her on task. I feel that this is unfair to ask of a regular education classroom teacher who is responsible for educating 29 other children who also have needs.

Since the beginning of the year, we have modified the curriculum so much to try to meet STUDENT's IEP goals that we are spending endless hours on STUDENT alone. I, as a classroom teacher of 30 students, need to divide my time up equally to every child. The math works out to 10 minutes per day per child. This is not happening, and I can no longer go along with it. I want what's best for all children including STUDENT, and I feel that this is not the appropriate placement.

(Resp. Exh. 18)

Because of STUDENT's behavior problems at school, the District asked several people to observe STUDENT in her classroom, including behavior specialist Rodger Stein, from Applied Behavior Consultants (ABC). Mr. Stein observed STUDENT on August 21 and 23, 1995, and drafted a "behavior assessment/intervention program" for STUDENT on August 25, 1995. Mr. Stein met with the GRANDPARENTS individually regarding the plan, and also discussed the plan at a team meeting on August 29, 1995.

During the August 29, 1995 team meeting, District staff noted concerns regarding STUDENT's progress in the classroom and the effect of STUDENT's behavior on the classroom itself. Staff expressed their belief that most of STUDENT's progress on her goals occurred when she received her related services (RSP, OT, speech therapy and APE) outside of the classroom. Rodger Stein indicated that STUDENT lacked basic classroom readiness skills, and estimated that STUDENT's behavior diverted the attention of the other students in the classroom approximately 40% of the time. (Dist. Exh. B-13)

The parties agreed that STUDENT's behavior was a priority for the team, although GRANDMOTHER expressed concern that STUDENT's behavior may be a result of inadequate adaptations of her curriculum. The parties agreed that Mr. Stein would draft a behavioral plan and that the parties would hold an IEP team meeting in September to discuss this plan. Finally, the parties noted that District staff needed a program to address STUDENT's behavior prior to the approval and implementation of STUDENT's behavioral plan. A "three strikes" system was suggested, in which STUDENT would be removed from class and given a ten minute time out for the first two times in which she disrupted the class during the day. If STUDENT needed to be removed a third time during the day, she would be taken to the office and sent home. The parties agreed that this three strike approach would be used in the interim period prior to a formal behavioral plan. (Id.)

On September 7, 1995, the parties held an IEP team meeting to discuss STUDENT's difficulties in school. Ms. Morris, STUDENT's regular education teacher, reiterated her concerns as to whether her classroom was the appropriate placement for STUDENT, and Ms. Gallant, STUDENT's RSP teacher, stated that STUDENT's behavior was interfering with her learning. Mary Jane Klope, an educational consultant for the GRANDPARENTS, indicated that she believed STUDENT could be successful in the placement, but acknowledged that it may not be "pleasant" because of her tendency to avoid tasks which are difficult. Ms. Klope indicated that STUDENT had previously avoided tasks quietly but now was beginning to manifest her avoidance with more problematic behavior. Ms. Klope expressed her belief that STUDENT's primary purpose for attending first grade was to learn how to follow the routine of the first grade classroom, which would facilitate her full inclusion as she got older. Ms. Klope acknowledged that STUDENT needed behavior management, and noted that STUDENT's primary motivator was adult attention. (Dist. Exh. B-15)

During the September 7 IEP team meeting, the parties also discussed Rodger Stein's draft behavioral plan. Mr. Stein acknowledged that the purpose of STUDENT's behavior was escape or avoidance of demanding tasks, but expressed concern over addressing STUDENT's behavior in the regular classroom because of the degree to which she was disrupting the class. The parties agreed on goals and objectives for STUDENT, including goals for improving school behavior, and agreed to implement a behavioral plan. However, the District also proposed alternative placements for STUDENT at this meeting, including moving STUDENT into a severely handicapped SDC for part or all of her school day. The GRANDPARENTS did not agree with these proposals, stating that STUDENT had been successful in previous full inclusion placements. The parties agreed to reconvene to address the specifics of the behavioral plan and to further discuss the issues regarding placement. (Id.)

On September 13, 1995, the parties continued the September 7 IEP team meeting. GRANDMOTHER expressed concern that the behavioral plan seemed complicated and did not reinforce STUDENT's positive actions. She also voiced concern over the plan's use of food as a reward for positive behavior. Mr. Stein emphasized that food rewards would be phased out or "faded" as STUDENT was able to demonstrate more independence. However, Mary Jane Klope, the GRANDPARENTS' advocate, asserted that tangible reinforcers, such as food, were not effective with STUDENT, and she suggested an alternative behavioral plan. Ms. Klope argued that praise should be used to motivate STUDENT to improve her behavior, rather than tangible rewards or food reinforcers. Mr. Stein agreed to modify the behavioral plan based on the suggestions of the GRANDPARENTS and Ms. Klope, including the elimination of tokens or food as rewards for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. B-21)

With regard to placement, the parties agreed that STUDENT's placement would be reduced temporarily to a half day in the afternoon within Ms. Morris' regular education classroom. This temporary placement, to last through the end of the second semester in January, would allow STUDENT to learn appropriate school behavior, and allow staff to be trained and the behavioral plan to be put in place. The parties agreed to review the placement in a IEP team meeting in January, 1996. The District noted that if the team did not feel the placement was appropriate at that time, the District might initiate the fair hearing process. (Id.)

After the September 13, 1995 IEP team meeting, STUDENT started her afternoon placement in Ms. Morris' class, with her related services provided in the morning, prior to class. Both STUDENT's aides were retained to work with STUDENT, with one aide providing services to STUDENT while the other aide took notes on STUDENT's behavior.

On December 18, 1995, the parties had a team meeting to discuss STUDENT's progress at school, with regard to her behavior. Ms. Morris indicated that STUDENT was standing in line with fewer verbal prompts, was patiently waiting her turn in the computer lab, was asking for a break when she needed it, and was gaining independence by asking staff to "wait" when she wanted to do a task by herself. Ms. Morris noted, however, that STUDENT had trouble transitioning to other activities after recess, and was still kicking, pushing, and hitting. Ms. Morris indicated that STUDENT's hitting may be a result of her inability to communicate, and that they were teaching STUDENT to ask for breaks and to apologize. They were also rehearsing appropriate methods for STUDENT to ask for something she wanted. GRANDFATHER suggested that once STUDENT's communication improved, her behavior would also improve. (Dist. Exh. B-25, Resp. 30)

Rodger Stein provided an update on STUDENT's behavior at this meeting. Mr. Stein noted that STUDENT was still creating disruption in the classroom, but that he was seeing less "explosions." He noted that the duration of STUDENT's disruptions was decreasing because the aides were asking STUDENT if she wanted a break before her behavior escalated. Mr. Stein also reported on his observations during a visit to STUDENT's home, and he noted that STUDENT used more language at home. Mr. Stein suggested that STUDENT may be bored at school. (Dist. Exh. B-25)

On January 8, 1996, the parties held an IEP team meeting to review STUDENT's afternoon placement and her progress on behavioral goals. Ms. Morris noted that STUDENT had limited social conversations with peers, such as asking students to "come" on the playground. Ms. Morris suggested that STUDENT's interactions with peers were limited because the classroom activities were too advanced for STUDENT. She stated that STUDENT had appropriate interactions with adults, was asking "please," and was responding well to breaks. She also noted, however, that initially positive interactions could become aggressive with other children. In addition, STUDENT continued to engage in disruptive behavior, such as making loud noises and/or hitting herself or the table, pinching children in library, and calling other students to play during structured work time. Ms. Morris noted that STUDENT was able to label behavior as inappropriate, such as hitting, and would acknowledge that such behavior was wrong when asked. (Dist. Exh. B-27).

During this IEP team meeting, Rodger Stein presented the results of a behavioral plan review which he had conducted on December 8, 1995. (Dist. Exh. B-29) Mr. Stein noted that the intensity and duration of STUDENT's disruptive behaviors had decreased because the staff directed her out of the classroom before her behaviors could escalate. He stated, however, that the frequency of disruptive behaviors had not diminished. Mr. Stein estimated that STUDENT was outside of the classroom approximately 60 -70% of the time in order to calm down. Mr. Stein suggested that STUDENT needed an environment with fewer children and distractions, and one which could more easily tolerate STUDENT's disruptive behavior. (Id.)

Noting that STUDENT's behaviors still inhibited her learning in the classroom, District staff once again recommended that STUDENT be moved to the severely handicapped SDC. The GRANDPARENTS disagreed with this proposal, asserting instead that the afternoon placement was not good for STUDENT because she woke up early and lost the best part of her learning day, which was during the morning. The GRANDPARENTS also stated a belief that the curriculum had to be modified in order to "attract" STUDENT, and suggested that the teacher receive training on curriculum adaptation from Tom Neary, a full inclusion consultant used by the District. Rather than placing STUDENT in an SDC, the GRANDPARENTS requested that STUDENT's placement be changed to the morning session of Ms.

Morris' class. The parties reached an agreement that the GRANDPARENTS would visit the Brown School SDC proposed by the District, and that STUDENT's placement would be changed to the morning session of Ms. Morris' class, to be reviewed at the end of January. (Dist. Exh. B-27)

When the parties held an IEP team meeting at the end of January, the District staff stated that they had not observed a significant difference in STUDENT's academic or behavioral progress as a result of her change to the morning placement. Staff indicated that STUDENT continued to kick, pinch, and hit other students, that she went to "time out" one to three times each day, and that she was less productive in academics during the morning hours than she had been in the afternoon. The District suggested that STUDENT's placement was frustrating to her and was inhibiting her growth. The District scheduled an IEP meeting in mid-February to once again discuss STUDENT's placement. (Dist. Exh. B-31).

On February 5, 1996, the District issued a proposal to change STUDENT's placement to the severely handicapped SDC at Brown Elementary School. The District discussed this proposal with the GRANDPARENTS at an IEP team meeting on February 15, 1996, indicating that STUDENT was not making progress on her IEP goals, and that her behavior was interfering with her ability to be part of the regular education classroom. The District also presented the opinions of several specialists who had observed STUDENT in the classroom and had concluded that STUDENT's regular education placement was not appropriate for her. The GRANDPARENTS did not agree to change STUDENT's placement to the SDC at Brown Elementary School, but contended that she needed to be remain in the regular education classroom. (Dist. Exh. B-34)

On March 1, 1996, the District filed for a due process hearing on the issue of STUDENT's placement (SN 198-96). On March 7, 1996, the GRANDPARENTS filed for a hearing on the placement issue (SN 216-96), and the cases were consolidated as of March 28, 1996. By April 1996, the GRANDPARENTS removed STUDENT from her regular education placement, although she continued to receive her related services.

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES (FOOTNOTE 6)

District's contentions (a) The District contended that STUDENT received little or no academic benefit from her regular education placement, because of the severity of her disabilities. In support of this contention, the District argued that no empirical research has demonstrated that a child functioning four to five years below the developmental level of his or her classmates can obtain any meaningful benefit from inclusion in a regular education setting. The District also argued that the severity of STUDENT's disabilities required that the regular education curriculum be modified beyond recognition, which resulted in her being unable to participate in the regular education classroom. The District contended that any progress STUDENT made was attributable to the related services she received, and it contended she received no academic benefit from her presence in the regular education classroom. The District contended that the academic benefits of a special day class placement for STUDENT far outweigh the academic benefits of placement in the regular classroom.

(b) The District also contended that STUDENT did not derive any non-academic benefits from placement in a regular classroom, because she had not demonstrated the ability to learn by modeling the language or behavior of her peers. The District contended that STUDENT would be able to model the language and behavior of peers in a special day class environment, because these peers are more closely aligned with STUDENT's developmental level. It also argued that STUDENT cannot sustain interaction with non-disabled peers because of her limited language and communication skills, and that she is more likely to have successful peer interactions with children at her developmental level.

(c) Finally, the District contended that STUDENT's placement in the regular education classroom had a detrimental effect on the teacher and on her regular education classmates. The District argued that STUDENT disrupted the class with her behavior, and that STUDENT unreasonably occupied the teacher's time. The District contended that the teacher and staff were forced to remove STUDENT from the classroom for a majority of the day in order to prevent her behavior from disrupting the class. As a result, the District contended that it could not provide STUDENT with an appropriate placement in the regular education classroom. The District stated that STUDENT's unique needs require that she be educated primarily in a special day class setting in order to provide her with individualized instruction at her developmental level, with appropriate opportunities for mainstreaming. The District did not contend, under part (d) of the Board v. Holland test, that the cost of STUDENT's regular education imposed an undue burden on the District.

Respondent's contentions (a) Respondent contended that the District had the burden to prove that she should be removed from her regular education placement. Respondent contended that the District did not prove that she cannot receive educational benefits in a regular education classroom. She argued that the District cannot categorically determine whether she is capable of receiving education benefit based on the degree of her deficits but must evaluate her ability to benefit on an individualized basis. Respondent argued that the degree to which the regular education curriculum must be modified to meet her needs is not relevant in determining whether she can receive educational benefit. She also argued that the regular education curriculum can be appropriately modified in a way which allows her to participate in the activities of the regular classroom.

Respondent contended that the evidence does not support the District's statement that she only received benefit from her related services. She argued that she received academic benefit in her preschool and kindergarten full inclusion placements. She contended that any failure on her part to receive educational benefit during first grade was a result of the District's inadequate curriculum modification and insufficient behavioral intervention plan and services.

(b) Respondent contended that she received non-academic benefits from her regular education placements. She argued that she demonstrated an ability to imitate her peers and that she had meaningful interactions with them. She argued that, to the extent her delays made interaction with other students difficult, the District should have facilitated these interactions and taught her the skills necessary to communicate appropriately with her peers. She contended that the best place to develop these skills is in the regular education classroom with non-disabled peers.

(c) Respondent contended that the adequacy of the District's supplemental aids and services must be considered when evaluating whether her behavior weighs against her placement in the regular classroom. She noted that the District failed to provide any supplemental aids and services to address her behavior when she first entered the first grade. She contended that the behavioral intervention plan finally developed by the District was inadequate for many reasons. Respondent contended that she did not place unreasonable demands on her first grade teacher, and that any difficulties experienced by her teacher were a result of the District's failure to provide appropriate supplemental services.

(d) Respondent argued that the cost of providing appropriate supplemental aids and services is not prohibitively expensive. Rather, Respondent contended that the placement she is requesting will reduce the District's expenditures somewhat, because she requests that one of her two aides be eliminated. She contended that some of the resources made available by eliminating an aide could be used to train the remaining aide in the implementation of an appropriate behavioral plan, and to retain the services of a full inclusion specialist for curriculum adaptation on a regular basis.

Respondent contended that the appropriate placement for her is a regular second grade placement for the 1996-97 school year with appropriate supplemental aids and services, which include a positive behavioral intervention plan, an appropriately adapted curriculum, and appropriate inclusion services.

DISCUSSION

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. Section 1400(c); Education Code Section 56000. Both federal and state law require that, as part of a free appropriate public education, disabled students must be educated with non-disabled students to the "maximum extent appropriate." The federal provision in the IDEA provides:

. . . to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, [should be]

educated with children who are not disabled, and . . .

special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment [shall] occur only when the nature or severity of the handicap is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

20 U.S.C. Section 1412(5)(B).

The requirement that disabled children be educated with non-disabled children to the "maximum extent appropriate" is incorporated into federal regulation under the term "Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)." 34 C.F.R. Section 300.550 et.seq.

California's Education Code states that special education is an integral part of the total public education system and requires that education be provided in a manner that "promotes maximum interaction between children or youth with disabilities and children or youth who are not disabled, in a manner that is appropriate to the needs of both." Education Code Section 56031. State law also contains a parallel provision to the "Least Restrictive Environment" mandate found in federal regulation.

Education Code section 56364. Courts often refer to the concept of educating handicapped children alongside non-handicapped children in a regular educational environment as "mainstreaming." Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 834 (9th Cir. 1995).(FOOTNOTE 7)

The IDEA's LRE provision reflects Congress' preference for educating disabled students in regular classrooms with their nondisabled peers. Sacramento City Unified School District v.

Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1403 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994) (hereafter referred to as "Rachel H.") Because of this statutory presumption in favor of mainstreaming, the District bears the burden of showing that its proposed placement provides mainstreaming "to the maximum extent appropriate" for STUDENT. Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874, 880 and n.7 (E.D. Cal. 1992) (hereafter referred to as "Board v. Holland"), aff'd sub. nom. Rachel H., supra.

1. Is a full-day placement in a regular education classroom the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

The court in Board v. Holland adopted a four-factor test to determine whether a placement provides mainstreaming to the "maximum extent appropriate." This four-factor test, which was subsequently adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Rachel H., requires that the following be considered:

a) the educational benefits of full-time placement in a regular classroom, with any supplemental aids and services that might be appropriate;

b) the non-academic benefits to the disabled child of interacting with nondisabled students;

c) any negative effects of the child's presence in the regular classroom on the teacher and the other students;

d) the cost of mainstreaming.

Rachel H., supra at 1404, Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, 35 F.3d 1396, 1401 (9th Cir. 1994); Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 836 (9th Cir. 1995). Each of these factors is examined below.

(a) Educational benefits available in the regular classroom

The District contended that STUDENT received no academic benefit from her regular education placement, and it attributed this failure to the fact that STUDENT's developmental level was four to five years behind that of the regular education students. The District asserted that the empirical research on mainstreaming contains no studies indicating that a child can benefit from inclusion into a regular classroom when such a large disparity exists between the developmental level of the disabled child and the developmental levels of her non-disabled peers.

The District's primary proponent of this argument is Dr. Bryna Siegel, associate professor of psychiatry, Langley Porter Psychiatric Institute, University of California, San Francisco. Dr. Siegel observed STUDENT in her regular education placement and concluded that STUDENT was too severely developmentally delayed to benefit from inclusion in the regular education setting. She testified that, based on her research, no empirical data exists demonstrating that students functioning four to five years behind (or over 50% below) their chronologically-aged peers can benefit from inclusion.

The District urged the Hearing Officer to accord great weight to Dr. Siegel's testimony, based on her credentials and her reliance on empirical research to support her conclusions. While the Hearing Officer acknowledges Dr. Siegel's extensive credentials, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by her opinion on this point. Although Dr. Siegel emphasized that no empirical research shows any benefit to including a child like STUDENT, she also did not offer any empirical research demonstrating that a child at STUDENT's developmental level will not obtain educational benefit from inclusion. In short, the evidence in this case contained no empirical data conclusively demonstrating one way or the other whether a child at STUDENT's developmental level will benefit from inclusion. Therefore, empirical research is not helpful in deciding the issues of this case.

In addition, Dr. Siegel's generalizations regarding the inherent limitations of children at STUDENT's developmental level run contrary to the requirement that each child be considered on an individualized basis. Both federal and state law contain the presumption that children are entitled to, and benefit from, education in the regular education setting. This presumption is not conditioned on the child demonstrating a threshold level of functioning (e.g., at least 50% of the functioning of the child's peers), as asserted by Dr. Siegel. Rather, this presumption must, in fact, be overcome by a specific showing, on an individual basis, that a child will not obtain academic and non-academic benefit from a regular education setting. As the court noted in Board v.

Holland:

the decision as to whether any particular child should be educated in a regular classroom setting, all of the time, part of the time, or none of the time, is necessarily an inquiry into the needs and abilities of one child, and does not extend to a group or category of handicapped children...

786 F. Supp. at 878.

It is significant to note that the school district in Board v. Holland made an argument similar to the one advanced by Petitioner in this case. In Board v. Holland, the school district claimed that Rachel, the student in that case, was too severely handicapped to benefit from a full time placement in the regular class. The District Court case indicates that, at the time of the trial, Rachel was a nine year old who was functioning at about the academic level of a four year old child. (786 F. Supp. at 875.) The District Court disregarded the school district's "a priori"

approach in favor of examining Rachel's underlying circumstances. The Court concluded that Rachel's regular education placement was appropriate, although she was functioning more than 50% below her chronologically-aged peers. The Ninth Circuit affirmed Rachel's right to be educated in the regular education setting, in spite of her delays.(FOONOTE 8)

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Siegel's opinions regarding STUDENT's placement are not supported by empirical research, since no empirical data was presented to support either side. The Hearing Officer also concludes that Dr. Siegel's approach of making generalized determinations regarding placement is contrary to the approach mandated by federal and state law, as strikingly illustrated by the Board v. Holland case.

The District also contended that STUDENT could not receive educational benefit from a regular education placement because her needs required that the regular education curriculum be modified beyond recognition. It argued that if the curriculum of the regular education classroom must be extensively modified to meet the disabled child's needs, the child effectively is no longer participating in a regular education placement, because the child's curriculum bears little or no resemblance to that of the rest of the class.

The court in Board v. Holland dismissed this argument as well, indicating that the extent of curriculum modification has no significance in and of itself. The court noted that the IDEA contemplates that the academic curriculum will be modified to accommodate the individual needs of the disabled child. It concluded that curriculum modification becomes significant only if it bears upon the other identified factors, such as when modification of the curriculum deprives the child of non-academic benefits, including the benefit of feeling like part of the regular classroom. 786 F. Supp. at 880.

The District argued that STUDENT could not meaningfully participate as part of the class, because her skills were significantly below those of her classmates. Dr. Siegel testified that the regular education curriculum could not be adapted to be developmentally appropriate for STUDENT, due to the severity of her disabilities. This evidence was persuasively refuted by the testimony of several of Respondent's witnesses.

Tom Neary is a full inclusion specialist who testified regarding STUDENT's placement, including the feasibility of adapting STUDENT's curriculum. Formerly, Mr. Neary was a special day class teacher for severely disabled children, and he has specialized in the full inclusion of severely disabled students for over six years. Mr. Neary provides in-service training to school districts on full inclusion, including a five-day full inclusion training course. Mr. Neary was hired by the District to provide consulting services in relation to STUDENT's full inclusion program during both kindergarten and first grade, and several of the District's staff attended Mr. Neary's five-day full inclusion course.

Mr. Neary testified that he observed STUDENT in her placements and was familiar with her unique needs as well as her IEP goals and objectives. He testified that, based on his experience, students who exhibit delays to the same extent as STUDENT (i.e. 50% below that of their chronological peers) are successfully being placed in the regular education classroom. Mr. Neary persuasively testified that all of STUDENT's goals and objectives could be addressed by modifying the regular education curriculum within the setting of the regular education classroom.

As an example, Mr. Neary noted that STUDENT had several goals and objectives related to skills which would enable her to function within the regular education class, referred to as "readiness" skills. These goals included improving her ability to complete tasks, respond to questions, and follow directions. The District argued that STUDENT's inability to perform these tasks contributed to her failure in the regular education program.

The District contended that STUDENT needed to learn these skills in a special day class before she would be ready to function appropriately in a regular classroom. In response to that claim, Mr. Neary testified that severely disabled students like STUDENT usually do not become "ready" to function in a regular education class by learning skills in a special day class, because they have difficulty generalizing a skill they learn in one environment to a different environment. Mr. Neary testified that STUDENT would only truly learn to function in a regular education setting by actively being taught those skills within a regular education environment.

For example, Mr. Neary stated that STUDENT could learn to make transitions between activities during the day by using a picture schedule of class activities. This type of schedule would help STUDENT visualize and anticipate activities as they arise, thereby reducing her potential frustration in making the transition. Mr. Neary also suggested that peers be enlisted to help STUDENT with transitions.

Linda Brooks also testified on behalf of Respondent regarding ways in which the regular education curriculum could be adapted for STUDENT. Ms. Brooks has been a special education teacher for thirteen years, and has a credential to teach severely handicapped students. Seven years ago, Ms. Brooks started the full inclusion program within the Davis Unified School District. At the time of the hearing, she was a full inclusion teacher for thirteen of the twenty-five fully included students in the Davis Unified School District, with grade levels ranging from kindergarten through seventh grade. Ms. Brooks observed STUDENT for two days in March 1996, at the request of the GRANDPARENTS, and wrote a report regarding her observations and opinions on STUDENT's program.

(Resp. Exh. 41)

Ms. Brooks testified that the regular education curriculum could be adapted to incorporate STUDENT's goals and objectives, even if that curriculum included more complex projects. For example, one of the activities in STUDENT's first grade classroom was "writer's workshop", which involved students picking a theme and writing a "book." The District's staff argued that STUDENT could not even begin to meaningfully participate in writer's workshop, and so they worked on her IEP goals separately during this period.

Ms. Brooks, on the other hand, testified that book writing is an activity that can incorporate all of a child's goals, including working on fine motor skills, language development, and sequencing tasks. For example, Ms. Brooks testified that the staff could pick one of STUDENT's favorite topics, such as dogs, and could have STUDENT develop a book with a series of pictures and sentences describing the dog. STUDENT could work on fine motor skills by cutting out pictures of the dog, and could paste them in sequence to tell a story. She could also develop her writing skills by filling in dots which make a word, using hand over hand guidance if necessary. Since language development is an important skill for STUDENT, Ms. Brooks testified that STUDENT could be asked to describe the activity taking place in the pictures. In this example, Ms. Brooks noted that STUDENT is still performing the activity that the rest of the class is doing - a book writing activity - but she is also working on her skills at a developmentally appropriate level.

The Hearing Officer gives considerable weight to the testimony of Mr. Neary and Ms. Brooks because they have ongoing experience in adapting curriculum for students with disabilities equal to or greater than STUDENT's, and they testified that they have done so successfully.(FOOTNOTE 9) While Dr. Siegel contended that such adaptation was not possible, she also acknowledged that she does not perform ongoing curriculum adaptation for students on a routine basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Siegel's testimony is outweighed by the testimony of Mr. Neary and Ms.

Brooks on the issue as to whether the regular education curriculum can be appropriately adapted to meet STUDENT's needs.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not demonstrated that the degree of curriculum modification required for STUDENT precludes her from receiving educational benefit within the regular education classroom.(FOOTNOTE 10)

Finally, the District argued that STUDENT made minimal progress on her IEP goals and objectives, and that this progress was attributable only to the related services she received on a 1:1 basis outside of the regular education classroom. Based on this assertion, they contended that STUDENT needs a special day class environment, because it provides more structure with less distractions and a smaller class size.

In evaluating the extent to which STUDENT made educational benefit within her regular education placement, it is important to note that the standard set out by the District Court in Board v. Holland does not require that STUDENT keep up with her non-disabled peers. Rather, the District Court concluded that a student can be considered to have received educational benefit if she can make progress on her IEP goals and objectives.(FOOTNOTE 11)

In addition, the District Court in Board v. Holland noted the following:

[I]f the child's disabilities are so severe that he or she will receive little or no academic benefit from placement in a regular education class, then mainstreaming may not be appropriate . . . However, the Act's requirement of integration, based on recognition of the non-academic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in a regular classroom . . . The Act's presumption in favor of mainstreaming requires that a handicapped child be educated in a regular classroom if the child can receive a satisfactory education there, even if it is not the best academic setting for the child. Further, in considering the relative educational benefits available in integrated and non-integrated settings, the school district must demonstrate that it has considered whether supplemental aids and services would permit satisfactory education in the regular classroom . . . Only if the child cannot receive a satisfactory education in the regular education class, even if the appropriate support services are offered, should the child be placed in a special education class.

Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 878-879.

In this case, the evidence showed that, to some degree, the District expected STUDENT to perform on par with her non-disabled peers. Her failure to do so prompted the District's staff to conclude that STUDENT was not receiving educational benefit. This conclusion is demonstrated in a report written by Sherron Scripa, an educational specialist who conducted a classroom observation for the District. In her report, Ms. Scripa states:

Every child deserves the opportunity to be in a supportive learning environment with peers with whom she can successfully compete at some level. STUDENT has no peers in her classroom. Her classmates are outdistancing her ability levels at greater speed as each month passes.

(Dist. Exh. B-36)

As noted above, the standard is not whether STUDENT can be competitive in a regular education setting, but whether she can make progress on her goals and objectives, with the assistance of supplemental aids and services. Tom Neary testified that teachers could not expect STUDENT to make the same academic achievement as the her non-disabled peers. He acknowledged, however, that regular education teachers often have difficulty accepting the fact that a disabled child's educational benefit must be measured by evaluating progress on the child's goals and objectives, rather than by comparing his or her performance with the rest of the class.

As described in the factual section above, the evidence showed that STUDENT consistently made progress on her goals and objectives in her pre-school and kindergarten full inclusion placements. Such progress included growth in "classroom readiness skills" such as following directions, trying a variety of activities within the classroom, and remaining on task. When STUDENT's IEP team reviewed her kindergarten full inclusion placement in the spring of 1995, Ms. Snyder-Lee, STUDENT's classroom teacher, concluded that STUDENT had made tremendous growth in her classroom readiness skills. Marc LaFleur, the District's psychologist, testified that by April 1995, STUDENT had made good progress in many areas, including language, motor skills, and her ability to attend to task. He testified that he had recommended that STUDENT remain in a full inclusion placement for her first grade year, based on her growth during kindergarten.

During first grade, STUDENT's progress on her academic goals was more limited. However, the evidence showed that early in STUDENT's first grade year, the IEP team determined that STUDENT's behavior was interfering with her learning. As a result, by September 1995, the team decided to focus on STUDENT's behavioral goals, rather than on her academic goals, in order to facilitate her ability to function within the classroom. In addition, the evidence showed that STUDENT was removed from the classroom 60-70% of the time in order to prevent her from disrupting the classroom. Thus, any determination regarding STUDENT's ability to make academic progress in a regular education setting based upon her experience in first grade must take into consideration STUDENT's behavioral issues during that year.

The parties agreed that STUDENT required a behavioral plan as a supplemental service, in order for STUDENT to benefit from her education. As discussed in section (c) below, the District did not demonstrate that the behavioral plan it provided to STUDENT was appropriate. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not demonstrated that STUDENT could not receive educational benefit in a regular education classroom if she had the support of an appropriate behavioral intervention plan.

In summary, STUDENT has a history of receiving educational benefit in regular education settings, as demonstrated by her progress during her pre-school and kindergarten years. During first grade, the parties agreed that STUDENT's behavior was interfering with her learning. However, the District failed to provide STUDENT with an appropriate behavioral plan, which effectively denied her the opportunity to learn within the classroom. Based on this evidence, and the presumption under both federal and state law in favor of mainstreaming, the Hearing Officer concludes that this factor weighs in favor of maintaining STUDENT's placement in the regular education classroom.(FOOTNOTE 12)

(b) Non-academic benefits of interacting with nondisabled students

A second factor considered by the court in Board v. Holland to determine whether a placement provides mainstreaming to the "maximum extent appropriate" is the non-academic benefits that a handicapped child may receive from exposure to non-handicapped peers. The court considered this factor to be significant, because it concluded that non-academic benefits reflect the fundamental purpose of the IDEA's mainstreaming requirement. In particular, the court found that the language and behavior models available from non-handicapped children may be essential or helpful to the handicapped child's development. Board v. Holland, 786 F.Supp. at 879.

The parties agreed that STUDENT has significant needs in the areas of language development and behavior. They disagreed, however, on the appropriate place for STUDENT to develop her skills in these areas.

The District contended that STUDENT has not demonstrated the ability to learn by modeling the language or behavior of her peers. While it acknowledged that STUDENT may imitate her peers, the District contended that STUDENT does not learn from this imitation activity, but instead must receive direct instruction in order to obtain any lasting benefit. The District also argued that STUDENT's limited language prevents her from sustaining interactions with her peers, even though she initiates contact with them.

In support of its arguments, the District noted the testimony of Ms. Snyder-Lee, STUDENT's kindergarten teacher at Quail Glen. Ms. Snyder-Lee testified that STUDENT had a friend in kindergarten who was particularly patient with STUDENT, so Ms. Snyder-Lee would use this student on occasion to explain activities to STUDENT rather than having the teacher or the aide provide instruction. Ms. Snyder-Lee testified that STUDENT would imitate the student or follow her directions, but would not remember how to do the activity at a later time in another situation.

The Hearing Officer does not find that this testimony supports the District's contentions. The Hearing Officer acknowledges that STUDENT's delays may prevent her from retaining information, and that a peer will not be as skilled as a aide or teacher in the methods of direct instruction required by STUDENT. However, focussing on the degree of academic benefit retained after this type of interaction misses the underlying premise of the non-academic factor.

Based on Ms. Snyder-Lee's description, STUDENT was able to work appropriately with her non-disabled peer and respond to the peer's instructions regarding the activity at hand. While STUDENT may not remember the specifics of the activity at a later time, she was obviously learning how to behave and communicate when working in a regular classroom with a non-disabled student. It is precisely these types of interactions which, in fact, support a conclusion that STUDENT received non-academic benefit in her regular education placements.

In addition, Ms. Snyder-Lee testified that STUDENT made social progress during her kindergarten year. Ms. Snyder-Lee acknowledged that STUDENT had difficulty sustaining interactions, but she also noted that STUDENT had started to use words to approach children, rather than just grabbing children on the playground. Ms. Snyder-Lee testified that STUDENT had made tremendous growth by April of her kindergarten year, as compared with the level of skills STUDENT possessed when she first entered Ms. Snyder-Lee's classroom.

In first grade, the evidence showed that STUDENT greatly enjoyed her interaction with other students, and that she was motivated by these interactions. For example, in a report dated August 28, 1995, Ms. Morris, STUDENT's first grade teacher, noted: "STUDENT loves being with children. She refers to students in her class and children at the Adventure Club(FOOTNOTE 13) as 'my kids.'" (Resp. Exh. 19) In fact, the evidence showed that, to some extent, STUDENT's non-compliant behavior resulted from her desire to interact with peers. For example, one of the problem behaviors identified by Ms. Morris during STUDENT's January 8, 1996 IEP team meeting was STUDENT's tendency to call other students to play during structured work time. (Dist. Exh. B-27)

In spite of her behavioral difficulties, the evidence showed that STUDENT did interact appropriately with her peers, in both structured and unstructured settings. For example, District staff reported that STUDENT had successfully participated in a classroom presentation on "heritage" during November of her first grade year:

STUDENT was included in the heritage presentation by standing up with her classmates and chiming in with her peers at the end of the story. She also read her ancestor paper by repeating after me. She received the loudest applause during the presentation.

(Resp. Exh. 29)

The daily journal recorded by STUDENT's aides also showed that STUDENT was developing her communication and interactive skills during the course of the regular school day, particularly during recess. For example, on March 7, 1996 of STUDENT's first grade year, District staff recorded the following interaction:

Recess: S. [STUDENT] walked out, saw 2 girls clapping hands together, S. went up to them "I help, play?" S.

clapped her hands together w/ girls, S. took girls hands, walked toward ball area, S. let go, girls went toward slide area, S. went to get ball. S. "Bye girls." S. got ball, play catch with girl (30 sec.). Went to monkey bars, kicking ball, saw girl, S. "Oh no, tie shoe" (Girls shoes were not tied). Girl played with STUDENT. S. went to hop scotch with girl. S. "1,2,3, turn around" (girl & STUDENT turned around). Bell rang, STUDENT froze, started to walk away, was reminded "STUDENT, what do we do?" S. "Kids line up." Girl took STUDENT's hand, walked to line.

(Dist. Exh. C, pp 526-527)

The District attempted to discount the significance of such interactions by arguing that STUDENT was too developmentally delayed to sustain her interactions with peers for more than a short period of time. However, the evidence also showed that the District made little effort to facilitate such interactions, in spite of STUDENT's obvious motivation in that regard.

Dr. Frank Marone is the director of services for Behavior Education Training Associates (BETA), which specializes in including children with behavioral difficulties into regular education settings and into the community at large. At the GRANDPARENTs' request, Dr. Marone observed STUDENT for a day in her regular education classroom and he also observed her briefly at Adventure Club, STUDENT's after-school program.

Dr. Marone testified that, during recess, he observed STUDENT attempting to engage children on the playground. He noted, however, that STUDENT did not have the skills to sustain an interaction, even if the children responded. He testified that the aides did not facilitate this interaction, thereby missing the opportunity to teach socialization skills to STUDENT. Both of STUDENT's aides acknowledged that they did not facilitate STUDENT's interaction with other students on the playground. They testified, however, that they left STUDENT alone during recess to provide her with a break from the constant monitoring which occurred in the classroom.

While the Hearing Officer acknowledges that STUDENT needed a break from the aides' intensive monitoring, the District staff's decision to leave her alone during recess deprived her of important opportunities to develop her communication and interactive skills. In essence, the District spent an inordinate amount of time and resources preventing STUDENT from interacting inappropriately during class, and then did nothing to teach her appropriate interaction skills during the one part of the day in which interaction was clearly appropriate.

Overall, the District's conclusions with regard to STUDENT's ability to obtain non-academic benefits mirrored its conclusions regarding STUDENT's capacity for educational benefit, as described under section (a) above. The District determined that STUDENT was too developmentally delayed to benefit from the language and social interactions of her regular education peers, and thus did little to facilitate these interactions.

For the reasons described in detail in section (a) above, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District's contention that STUDENT cannot obtain benefit from regular education classroom, including non-academic benefits, because of the severity of her disabilities. (FOOTNOTE 14) Tom Neary testified that appropriate language models were critical for STUDENT, and he concluded that it was important for STUDENT to be around other children with age-appropriate language skills. Mr. Neary stated that a regular education classroom would have the most appropriate language models for STUDENT, and he testified that STUDENT could be successfully included in a regular education classroom.

The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received non-academic benefit during her regular education placements, including her first grade placement. The Hearing Officer also concludes that STUDENT could have received greater benefits in this area with appropriate support and intervention, and that the District did not sufficiently support STUDENT by facilitating her interactions or teaching socialization skills to her. Therefore, this factor weighs in favor of continued placement in the regular education setting.

(c) Negative effects of the child's presence in the regular education class on the teacher and other students

A third factor to be considered under Board v. Holland is whether STUDENT's placement in a regular education class has a negative effect on the teacher and the other students in the class. Although the District argued that STUDENT did not receive educational or non-academic benefits from her mainstreaming experience, it is clear from the evidence that STUDENT's effect on the classroom and the District staff represented the primary motivation for the District's proposal to remove STUDENT from the regular education environment. Mr. Medd, the principal at Quail Glen, testified that the primary difficulty with STUDENT's placement was STUDENT's behavior. Mr. Medd testified that once STUDENT's behavior was controlled, he would consider STUDENT to be an excellent candidate for full inclusion at Quail Glen.

In this case, the Hearing Officer considers the two elements of this factor separately: i) STUDENT's disruption to the classroom and ii) the burden on the regular education teacher's time as a result of STUDENT's placement.

i. Disruption to the classroom

In this case, the parties agreed that STUDENT presented behavioral challenges as a fully included student in Ms. Morris' first grade class, although they disagreed on the extent and severity of STUDENT's disruptive behavior. The parties also agreed that STUDENT required a behavioral intervention plan as specified under state law.

The heart of the disagreement in this case is whether the District's behavioral intervention strategy, including the behavioral intervention plan developed by Rodger Stein, was adequate, thereby satisfying the district's obligation under federal and state law to provide supplemental aids and services to ensure that STUDENT was mainstreamed to the "maximum extent appropriate."

Under Chapter 5.5 of the California Education Code, otherwise known as the "Hughes Bill," behavioral interventions must be used in a manner that ensures a pupil's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment. California Education Code section 56520(b)(1). "Behavior intervention" means the systematic implementation of procedures that result in lasting positive changes in the individual's behavior...[and] are designed to . . . ensure the individual's right to placement in the least restrictive educational environment as outlined in the individual's IEP. Title 5, California Code of Regulations (CCR) Section 3001(d).

State regulations contain detailed requirements for behavioral interventions plans, and these plans become part of a student's IEP. Title 5, CCR sections 3001(f), 3052. These requirements include conducting a functional analysis assessment; developing an objective and measurable description of the targeted maladaptive behavior(s) and replacement positive behaviors; a detailed description of the behavioral interventions to be used and the circumstances for their use; and specific schedules for recording the frequency of the use of the interventions and the frequency of the targeted and replacement behaviors. Title 5, CCR sections 3001(f)(1),(2),(4), and (5).

Positive behavioral intervention may require that the school district identify the purpose or function of a child's inappropriate behavior, and then positively reinforce the child's acceptable behaviors in a way that meets the underlying purpose of the child's inappropriate behavior. Title 5, CCR section 3052(d)(4). For example, if a district concludes that a child acts inappropriately in order to receive attention, then a positive behavioral plan would direct staff to give attention to the child when he or she was acted appropriately, rather than during inappropriate behavior.

Districts must evaluate the effectiveness of the behavioral intervention plan by documenting the implementation of the program as specified in the behavioral intervention plan (E.g., documenting the written instructional programs and data, and descriptions of environmental changes.). Title 5, CCR section 3052(f)(3).

Although the behavioral plan developed by Rodger Stein contained most of the components required in a plan, the collective or net effect of the plan ran contrary to the requirement that the focus of the plan be on positive programming. The evidence showed that this effect was the result of a faulty plan design, a lack of specificity in the plan, and a failure to systematically implement the plan and document its implementation.

Mr. Stein's functional analysis was divided into two categories: 1) STUDENT's behavioral deficits in the areas of communication, appropriate choice making and classroom readiness skills; and 2) STUDENT's behavioral excesses in the form of non-compliance and tantrumming. Mr. Stein testified that conducting a functional analysis helps determine why a child is doing a particular maladaptive behavior by determining the function of the behavior.

For both of STUDENT's behavioral excesses (non-compliance and tantrumming), Mr. Stein concluded that the function of these behaviors was primarily to escape or avoid demand situations and to communicate her dislikes or desires when she was unable to communicate by more functional means. Mr. Stein also concluded that STUDENT's tantrumming served as a means of gaining attention from others.

In addressing these behavioral deficits and excesses, Mr.

Stein's intervention and program plan outlined procedures for increasing readiness skills and functional alternative behaviors (behavioral deficits) and procedures for decreasing non-compliance and tantrums (behavioral excesses). An integral component of these procedures was the inclusion of two essential strategies: the use of a "token economy system" or reward system for appropriate behavior; and the removal of STUDENT from the classroom for either a voluntary break ("calming period") or disciplinary break ("time out") when she disrupted or threatened to disrupt the classroom.

The first major problem with STUDENT's behavior plan was Mr.

Stein's heavy reliance on the "token economy" system, particularly food rewards. Mr. Stein testified that he generally uses food reinforcers at a high frequency when a behavioral plan is first implemented, because he can generally change behavior quickly with food. He then gradually replaces food with other tangible reinforcers or "tokens" such as giving the child a star for appropriate behavior.

Mr. Stein testified that he initially thought that he could use food and other tangible reinforcers with STUDENT, and he wrote this element into his initial plan. When Mr. Stein met with the GRANDPARENTS prior to the IEP team meeting on September 7, 1995, the GRANDPARENTS indicated that they did not want to use food or other tangible reinforcers for STUDENT, because such reinforcers would not motivate her. Mr. Stein testified that he left food and other tangible reinforcers in the behavioral plan presented at the September 7 IEP team meeting because he felt he could persuade the GRANDPARENTS to use these types of reinforcers. Mr. Stein testified that he continued to believe, prior to the IEP team meeting, that the plan was going to be implemented using tangible reinforcers, including food.

During the September 7, 1995 IEP team meeting, both the GRANDPARENTS and Mary Jane Klope, the GRANDPARENTS' advocate, indicated that tangible reinforcers, including food, would not be motivating to STUDENT. Mr. Stein stated that he agreed to remove the use of food and other tangible reinforcers, although he doubted whether the plan would be effective without these reinforcers.

Respondent argued that Stein's reliance on a token reward system indicated that the plan was not designed to meet her needs. The evidence showed that Mr. Stein himself had determined that tokens were not effective for STUDENT when he conducted his initial assessment in August of 1995. When STUDENT first entered Ms.

Morris' classroom, she did not have an individualized behavioral plan, but was subject to the class' discipline program. Under this discipline program, children started the day with a certain number of tokens in the shape of bears. If a child misbehaved, the child would gradually lose their "bears," and would eventually be sent to the principal's office. In the case summary section of STUDENT's behavioral plan, dated August 25, 1995, Mr. Stein reported that this program did not work for STUDENT. In particular, his report stated: "STUDENT does not appear to benefit [from the school's discipline plan] as she does not indicate an interest in maintaining her 'Bears' or in earning rewards." (Dist. Exh. B-17) On cross-examination, Mr. Stein acknowledged that the token system he suggested in his behavioral plan was essentially the same type of system as the "bear" system, which he had found to be ineffective for STUDENT when she first entered Ms. Morris' classroom.

As noted above, Mr. Stein testified that he generally uses food in the beginning of a behavioral program, and then substitutes other tangible items for food as a means of reinforcement. The evidence showed that Mr. Stein's plan was anchored on the food/token system, in spite of the fact that the GRANDPARENTS objected to it and there was reason to question whether it would be effective for STUDENT. The evidence also showed that when Mr. Stein finally agreed to remove the use of food and other tokens as reinforcement, he had doubts that the remaining plan would work. Nevertheless, he did not change the structure of the plan, and did not even change the document itself, which still referenced the use of tokens and food reinforcers. In response to the parent's request to not use food as a reinforcer, Mr. Stein merely noted in the IEP "can eliminate food reinforcer if family wants." (Dist. Exh. B-21)

The Hearing Officer finds that Stein's heavy reliance on a token economy, including food reinforcers, in spite of evidence it might not work, and his subsequent removal of the food/token system without rethinking the plan, jeopardized the potential effectiveness of the plan even before it became implemented. This approach also did not meet the fundamental requirement of the IDEA that a behavioral plan reflect the individualized student's unique needs.

Once tokens and food rewards were removed from the plan, the parties agreed that social praise would be the primary positive reinforcer for STUDENT in response to appropriate behavior.

However, a second difficulty with Mr. Stein's plan is that the procedure for positively reinforcing STUDENT was not clearly specified.

For example, under the procedures for increasing readiness skills, one part (section 1d) indicates that STUDENT will earn a tangible or food reward for every 5 to 10 minute interval in which she demonstrated at least two readiness skills identified within the plan (i.e., following rules, standing in line). Later in this same section, however, (section 1h), the plan states "if STUDENT initiates any participation that closely approximates the activity/task, socially reinforce and give him [sic] a tangible or food items of his [sic] choice." It is not clear from this procedure whether staff are to reinforce STUDENT immediately when she demonstrates a readiness skill, or whether they are only to reinforce her every 5 to 10 minutes if she demonstrates two of these skills, or both.

Respondent argued that the confusion in these procedures made it difficult for staff to positively reinforce her in a consistent and systematic manner. Respondent also argued that, with the procedures outlined above, she may not understand why she is being reinforced and how long she had to sustain the desired activity before she would be rewarded. Frank Marone testified that, during his observation, staff generally did not appear to know what to do to help STUDENT.

Respondent also argued that a reinforcement schedule of 5 to 10 minutes would not be sufficient for her. For example, Respondent noted that the District wanted to encourage her to stay on task, but it had estimated that STUDENT remained on task for less than two minutes. Therefore, if the District only reinforced STUDENT at 5 to 10 minute intervals, STUDENT might waiver between on and off-task behavior several times before she received any reinforcement for staying on task. The Hearing Officer agrees that this reinforcement schedule does not correlate to STUDENT's needs in this regard.

In practice, several of Respondent's witnesses stated that they did not see STUDENT positively reinforced during their observation of her classroom. In response to this testimony, Mr. Stein testified that the aides did positively reinforce STUDENT, and did so at a greater frequency when the plan was first implemented. Mr. Stein stated that the frequency of praise was reduced or "faded" as STUDENT made progress. The problem with Mr. Stein's contention, however, is that it is inconsistent with the District's position that STUDENT did not make progress with her behavior. Therefore, it is hard to imagine how STUDENT progressed to the point where she did not need positive reinforcement, while she was also increasingly being removed from class for misbehavior. Likewise, Peggy Farmer, one of STUDENT's aides, testified that they positively reinforced STUDENT about every 15-20 seconds initially, but then faded the frequent positive reinforcement so that she would not become dependent upon it. As a result, however, the evidence showed that the District became dependent upon removing STUDENT from the classroom as the primary means of controlling her behavior.

The District presented their own witnesses who contended that they observed the aides positively reinforcing STUDENT. The difficulty in sorting out what actually happened in this regard highlights another problem with STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan, which is the lack of quantitative data regarding the interventions used with STUDENT.

As noted above, once STUDENT switched to a half-day schedule, one of STUDENT's aides would take observation notes while the other provided direct services to STUDENT. This recordkeeping resulted in hundreds of pages of notes. However, Mr. Stein testified that, although he read the notes, he did not consider these notes "hard data" for purposes of determining whether the behavioral plan was being implemented or whether it was effective. The only quantitative data in support of Mr. Stein's conclusions was "probe" data he took once a month. Mr. Stein testified the actual data from those probe sessions was collected on scratch paper and thrown away once he incorporated the information into a report.

In evaluating Mr. Stein's reports, the evidence showed that Mr. Stein had one report dated January 8, 1996, which documented STUDENT's progress regarding her behavior as of December 8, 1995. Under each short range goal, Mr. Stein designated "Not met", "partially met" or "met," and then gave a brief narrative description (some, one to two lines in length) of what STUDENT was doing. These narratives provide almost no description of the staff's interventions, except to say that STUDENT acted in response to a prompt. Mr. Stein's statements regarding staff are generally conclusory, i.e., "The classroom staff has consistently demonstrated a willingness to follow through," or "During observations, the Instructional Assistants implemented the procedures outlined in the program appropriately and consistently." (Dist. B-29) Since, as noted above, the procedures for positive reinforcement were ambiguous, it is not clear from the report what staff would have been doing on a consistent basis.

Following Stein's report of January 8, he wrote another report dated February 1, 1996. (Dist. B-41) In the section updating STUDENT's goals, however, the data in this section is the same observation data from the prior report (December 8, 1995). The only change to this section was a notation at the top that "The following goals remain unchanged and unmet overall, with the exception of Disruptive Behavior (tantrum)." The behavioral goal regarding tantrums had also been met in the early report.

Therefore, in terms of actual data documenting the implementation of STUDENT's behavioral plan, as required by law, the evidence contains approximately 2-3 pages of narrative which primarily describes STUDENT's actions. Frank Marone testified that the lack of information regarding the interventions used can lead to misleading information regarding the severity of STUDENT's behavior.

For example, Dr. Marone noted that if an instructor repeatedly asked STUDENT a question without really giving her an opportunity to respond, this may result in a conclusion that STUDENT has been repeatedly non-compliant, when in reality only one request was made over and over in rapid succession. Based on his observations, Dr. Marone testified that STUDENT's compliance rate with instructions was about 75%, if one looked at repetitive instructions as one instruction.

While the District's documentation did not indicate the range of interventions used, it is clear from the evidence that the District became more and more dependent upon removing STUDENT from the classroom as the primary method for controlling her behavior. In his January 8, 1996 update, Mr. Stein estimated that STUDENT was outside of the classroom to calm down approximately 60% to 70% of the time. Although the plan itself only specifies that STUDENT be removed to control tantrumming behavior, District staff testified that when they thought STUDENT's non-compliance might turn into tantrumming, they prompted her to ask for a break or calming period. Several of Respondent's witnesses indicated that, during their observations, it was often unclear why STUDENT was being removed from the classroom.

In response to this testimony, District staff testified that they proactively prevented STUDENT from having a tantrum by removing her before a tantrum could occur. However, Stein's report found that the function of STUDENT's behavior excesses was to escape and avoid demanding situations, to communicate dislikes and to gain attention. Since the District's response to STUDENT's behavior was to remove her from the classroom, this only served to reinforce the very behavior the plan was intended to remediate.

Mr. Stein acknowledged in the summary of his August 1995 plan that the implementation of his plan might accidentally reinforce STUDENT's inappropriate behavior. He testified, however, that this result was unavoidable because edible or tangible reinforcers were not used, and because disruptive behavior could not be ignored in a regular education classroom. Based on the potential that his plan might reinforce STUDENT's problematic behavior, Mr. Stein suggested in the August 1995 plan that the IEP team consider moving STUDENT to a special day class (SDC). Mr. Stein testified that he made this recommendation because it is easier to ignore off-task behavior in an SDC. He testified many of the children assigned to SDCs have problematic behavior, and STUDENT's non-compliant behavior would not disrupt the class because the teacher and the class were used to it. Therefore, Mr. Stein suggested that STUDENT's inappropriate behavior would not be reinforced in a special day class, because she would not have to be removed from class when she exhibited non-compliant behavior.

Respondent argued that the Mr. Stein's suggestion that her placement be changed to an SDC before an appropriate behavioral plan was finalized and implemented indicated that the District had no real intention of making her placement in first grade a success. Frank Marone and Tom Neary both testified that the plan, as implemented, became reactive and negative in its approach to controlling STUDENT's behavior.

As an example, Dr. Marone testified that he observed STUDENT during lunch in her classroom. He stated that STUDENT sat at her desk for five minutes eating her lunch without disturbing the children around her and without attempting to leave her seat.

During these five minutes, she received no adult attention. When STUDENT then asked to be excused from lunch, the staff directed her to continue eating. STUDENT complied with this request, and received no response from staff. When STUDENT finished eating, she independently left her seat, threw away her trash, and returned to her seat. Again, staff did not interact with STUDENT or reinforce her during this period.

When STUDENT returned to her seat, she sat quietly for one or two minutes, but was given nothing to do. At that point, STUDENT reached over to pick up her neighbor's thermos, which immediately prompted two adults to intervene by speaking to her, removing the thermos, reprimanding her and finally providing STUDENT with a choice of her preferred activities. In his report, Dr. Marone noted that in this example, STUDENT was given no attention for appropriate behavior, but was given both attention and a choice of preferred activities when she misbehaved. (Resp. Exh. 42)

Dr. Marone testified that, rather than giving STUDENT attention for noncompliant behavior, a positive intervention program requires that the staff focus on STUDENT's strengths and appropriate behavior. Dr. Marone recommended a technique called "descriptive acknowledgement," in which staff provide STUDENT with detailed, descriptive positive feedback for ongoing acceptable behavior on a frequent basis. Dr. Marone recommended a frequency of every 30 to 60 seconds throughout the day in the beginning of the program, using techniques designed to avoid disruption to the rest of the classroom. He also recommended that if STUDENT misbehaves, the staff not react to the negative behavior, but return to praising STUDENT when she acts appropriately. The third technique Dr. Marone recommended was the use of "guided practice," in which staff physically guide STUDENT's hand until she gets a feel for an activity.

Dr. Marone testified that he did not see a positive reinforcement program used for STUDENT in the regular classroom, although he saw these techniques used successfully by the adaptive physical education teacher. In his report, Dr. Marone described the approach used by the APE teacher, and noted that STUDENT responded positively to this approach:

STUDENT demonstrated her responsiveness to even slight descriptive performance feedback and her motivation to engage in and complete activities during her adaptive physical education time. During this period, the adaptive physical education teacher showed STUDENT how to do things, by doing them herself, and assisted her as necessary. The teacher rarely repeated instructions, and encouraged STUDENT by praising her during and after each activity. Under these conditions, STUDENT did everything asked of her, even things she originally protested and/or "spontaneous" things thought up by the teacher.

Significantly, STUDENT several times spontaneously initiated approaching her instructional assistants and other adults after an activity and congratulating herself to them (e.g., "Did you see me?"; "I did it.") This was the single time during observation that this writer observed STUDENT smile. It would be difficult for her to more clearly tell us what she requires in an effective support program, and what she now mostly lacks. (Emphasis added)

(Resp. Exh. 42)

The District's failure to use this type of positive reinforcement within the regular classroom was particularly significant for STUDENT, because the evidence showed that interaction with people was one of the most important means of positive reinforcement for STUDENT. Dr. Marone's report states: "There can be little doubt that STUDENT is primarily motivated by interaction with those around her, both peers and adults." (Resp. Exh. 42) Witnesses for both parties testified that STUDENT loved getting attention and being with other children. As noted in section (b) above, the evidence showed that much of STUDENT's non-compliant behavior involved her attempts to interact with other children at inappropriate times.

Respondent argued that her behavioral plan should have provided opportunities to interact with other children as a means of motivating her to behave appropriately. Respondent's witnesses testified that the District could have provided STUDENT with opportunities to interact with other children as a reward for a staying on task during individual work time. They also stated that the District could have provided STUDENT with a picture schedule of her day to assure her that opportunities for socialization were available. In fact, the evidence showed that STUDENT's behavior often improved when she was allowed to work with other children, and that she enjoyed this interaction.

Although Dr. Siegel testified that Dr. Marone's behavioral plan was not realistic, the evidence did not indicate that Dr. Siegel had on-going experience with the implementation of behavioral plans for severely disabled students in regular education settings. On the other hand, Dr. Marone's specialty involves including children with behavioral problems in regular education programs, and he provides these services on a regular basis. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Marone's opinion carries more weight on this issue.

Based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that parties agreed that STUDENT needed a behavioral plan as a supplemental service in order to benefit from her education. The law requires that such behavioral plans focus on positive behavioral intervention. In this case, the preponderance of the evidence establishes that the plan developed by the District was not designed to incorporate effective positive reinforcement for STUDENT in the form of positive interaction with adults and peers. Although social reinforcement was suggested in STUDENT's plan, the evidence showed that the plan lacked specificity regarding the procedure for positively reinforcing STUDENT. Finally, the evidence showed that the District failed to effectively implement a positive behavioral intervention plan, and failed to document any positive interventions that it attempted on a regular basis. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not demonstrate that STUDENT's disruptive behavior cannot be effectively managed with a positive behavioral intervention plan so as to allow her to be fully included in a regular education classroom at this stage of her development. (FOOTNOTE 15)

ii. Undue burden on the teacher's time

The District contended that STUDENT's presence in the classroom placed an undue burden on the classroom teacher, Ms. Morris, and prevented her from doing activities with STUDENT's class which she had done with previous classes. Under Board v. Holland, the District must consider all reasonable means to minimize the demands on the teacher from the presence of the disabled student in the classroom. Although the District did attempt to provide support for STUDENT and her teacher, the evidence showed that the District's support was largely inappropriate and ineffective.

First, the District contended that it used several experts, including Tom Neary, to support District staff in modifying STUDENT's program. As noted above, Mr. Neary testified that he only spent about twenty minutes with Ms. Gallant specifically discussing STUDENT's program. Mr. Neary acknowledged that he did not succeed in what he wanted to accomplish at Quail Glen, because he did not spend enough time with the District in relation to STUDENT's program. Mr. Neary testified that he did not know whether the District's staff had developed the skills necessary to make STUDENT's full inclusion program work.

In addition, the evidence showed that the aides assigned to STUDENT did not positively support her, and that the presence of two aides might have been counterproductive to STUDENT's full inclusion program. Dr. Marone concluded that although STUDENT had two aides, she effectively had no support, because the aides only responded to STUDENT's inappropriate behavior without reinforcing her positive behavior.

The evidence showed that the role of one of the aides at all times was to document STUDENT's behavior, rather than provide her with direct services. While the Hearing Officer acknowledges that some documentation was necessary, the utility of the District's documentation was greatly limited because it ultimately could not be used to determine if the behavioral plan was appropriate.

Therefore, the usefulness of the second aide for such activity was highly questionable.

Linda Brooks, the full inclusion teacher from Davis, testified that STUDENT's program appeared to be very fragmented, and she concluded that the constant attention and demands of the two aides upon STUDENT may have contributed most to the failure of STUDENT's program. In her report, Ms. Brooks stated:

STUDENT's least successful times were at her desk, when I felt, she was the most isolated and the two aides were in her space the most. I can not think of one student in any program who could take this kind of monitoring without rebelling in some way. It is, in my opinion a total waste of resources, totally inappropriate and is possibly contributing most to the failure of the program.

Couple the constant attention and demands of the two aides with the never ending choices, many of which were unrelated to what everyone else was doing, and it is no wonder that STUDENT is having a difficult time.

(Resp. Exh. 41)

Finally, the evidence showed that the primary burden on the teacher from STUDENT's presence in the classroom resulted from STUDENT's disruptive behavior. The Hearing Officer determined above that the District did not demonstrate that it provided an appropriate behavioral intervention plan for STUDENT.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not established that STUDENT's behavior prevents her from being successfully included in the regular classroom, because the District has not demonstrated that its supplemental aids and services, including its behavioral intervention plan, provided appropriate support to either STUDENT or her teacher. Therefore, this factor does not weigh against STUDENT's placement in the regular education classroom.

(d) Cost

The court in Board v. Holland stated that a school district may consider cost as a factor in making placement decisions. It indicated, however, that cost would only weigh against placement of a student in a regular education classroom if the cost of including the disabled child significantly affected the other children in the district. Board v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. at 880.

The District did not argue that STUDENT's placement in the regular education classroom represented an excessive cost.

Respondent contended that the District wasted resources by providing her with two aides which were not helpful to her. She argued that her placement would be more appropriate and less costly if the District eliminated one of her two aides. She contended that the District could use some of the savings resulting from the elimination of one aide to provide her with appropriate support in the areas of behavioral intervention and curriculum adaptation.

The Hearing Officer notes that neither party submitted evidence regarding cost estimates of the proposed placements. However, since the District did not contend that the cost of STUDENT's placement was excessive, and it did not rebut Respondent's arguments that the placement proposed by Respondent would reduce the District's costs, the Hearing Officer concludes that the cost is not a factor which weighs against a regular education placement for STUDENT.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT received educational benefit from her regular education placements prior to first grade, and that she received non-academic benefits during all of her regular education placements, including her placement in first grade. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT's educational progress was limited in first grade by the District's failure to provide her with the supplemental aids and services necessary to enable her to benefit from a regular education placement. In particular, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District's behavioral plan was inadequate, and that the District did not demonstrate that STUDENT's behavior prevents her from successfully participating in a regular education setting, if an appropriate behavioral plan is implemented. Since the District did not argue that a regular education placement for STUDENT presents an excessive cost, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District has not met its burden of demonstrating that STUDENT's existing regular education placement is inappropriate for her. Therefore, at this time, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT should remain in a regular education placement.(FOOTNOTE 16)

Respondent requested that she be placed in a regular education second grade class for the 1996-97 school year, with appropriate supplemental aids and services. Respondent requested that these services include the supervision of her program by a full inclusion coordinator, the implementation of a positive behavioral intervention plan, and the establishment of certain parameters for the adaptation of her curriculum.

Respondent requests that a full inclusion coordinator supervise her regular education placement, and that the coordinator provide technical assistance to the core staff (regular education teacher and instructional aide) on the adaptation of her curriculum. Respondent requests that this full inclusion coordinator have demonstrated experience and success in implementing full inclusion and adapting regular curriculum for children with severe disabilities. With regard to the level of services, Respondent asks that the full inclusion coordinator meet with the core staff on a regular basis to plan her program, which may involve daily meetings in the beginning of the placement and weekly meetings thereafter. Respondent requests that the coordinator be accessible to provide technical assistance to core staff at all times.

Tom Neary testified that, in order to support a full inclusion student such as STUDENT, the District's staff should receive strong technical assistance from a person experienced in successfully facilitating inclusion placements. Mr. Neary stated that this inclusion facilitator must work with District staff for a period of time in order for the staff to develop their skills in inclusion. Mr. Neary noted that the facilitator must be readily accessible to the teachers and aides involved with STUDENT's placement.

As noted above, the Hearing Officer finds Mr. Neary to be a credible witness on this issue because he has on-going experience with the inclusion of severely disabled students. The Hearing Officer also notes that STUDENT was successfully included in her previous placements in San Mateo when she received the support of a full inclusion teacher. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needs the support of an inclusion facilitator or coordinator who has experience with including severely disabled children into the regular education classroom.

When STUDENT left her kindergarten placement in San Mateo, she had been receiving inclusion specialist services at the level of 300 minutes per week. This level of services was intended to help STUDENT transition from pre-school to kindergarten. As noted above, Ms. Patricia Selby, STUDENT's inclusion specialist, concluded that STUDENT had made progress during the time she received these services, although STUDENT moved to Roseville in the fall of that year. Since STUDENT had difficulties during her first grade year, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT needs the assistance of a inclusion coordinator at the level of 300 minutes per week, at least through the end of November of her second grade year, in order to facilitate her transition into second grade. The Hearing Officer concludes that this level of services shall be reduced to 150 minutes per week for the remainder of STUDENT's second grade year, unless the IEP team agrees to maintain STUDENT's inclusion service support at a higher level.

With regard to the positive behavioral intervention plan, Respondent requested that the Hearing Officer order the implementation of a behavioral plan which incorporates the interventions recommended in Dr. Marone's behavioral plan (Resp. Exh. 42). She also requested that her behavioral plan utilize her peers as much as possible to model, encourage, and facilitate appropriate behavior.

The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Marone's plan contains the elements required under federal and state law for behavioral intervention plans, and also contains the specificity and positive tone which was lacking in the District's plan. The Hearing Officer found Dr. Marone to be highly knowledgeable on the requirements of behavioral plans in general, as well as the unique difficulties of including children with behavioral issues into the regular education setting. The Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Marone's behavioral intervention plan is appropriate for STUDENT and should, with one exception, be incorporated into STUDENT's IEP as the behavioral intervention plan supporting her full inclusion placement in second grade.

In his behavioral intervention plan, Dr. Marone recommended that the individual providing one to one assistance for STUDENT be employed by an outside agency providing behavioral services to the District, rather than being employed by the District. Dr. Marone stated that this individual should be recruited, selected, and hired specifically to work with STUDENT.

The Hearing Officer shares Dr. Marone's obvious concern that STUDENT's aide be selected carefully, based on STUDENT's developmental and behavioral needs. However, the Hearing Officer cannot conclude, based on the evidence presented, that a district staff member per se would be incapable of implementing Dr. Marone's behavioral plan, given the training and support envisioned for staff in Dr. Marone's plan. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District need not be limited by Dr. Marone's recommendation that STUDENT's instructional aide be an individual employed by an outside agency rather than employed by the District.

With regard to the supervision of STUDENT's program, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Marone is uniquely qualified to supervise STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan, and no alternative person was identified to provide such services. The Hearing Officer concludes that Dr. Marone should provide overall supervision of STUDENT's behavioral intervention plan unless Dr. Marone recommends an alternative person to provide these services.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by Respondent's request that her behavioral plan incorporate her peers to the extent possible in modelling appropriate behavior. The evidence showed that STUDENT was highly motivated by her peers and that her behavior often improved when she was allowed to share her activities with another student. The Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP team, including the behavioral specialist, should consider ways in which STUDENT's peers can be utilized to model, encourage, and facilitate appropriate behavior for STUDENT.

Finally, Respondent requested in her closing brief that the Hearing Officer order specific curriculum adaptations as part of STUDENT's full inclusion second grade placement. (FOOTNOTE 17) While the evidence supports these suggestions for adaptation, the Hearing Office concludes that the ultimate determination regarding curriculum adaptations for STUDENT should be made by the full inclusion coordinator and District staff, based on STUDENT's needs at the time such adaptations are made. The Hearing Officer concludes that the full inclusion coordinator and District staff should consider, but not be limited to, the curriculum adaptations recommended by Respondent in her closing brief.

2. If a full-day placement in a regular education classroom is not appropriate for STUDENT, is a special day class the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer concluded above that the District has not demonstrated that STUDENT's regular education placement is inappropriate at this time. Therefore, Hearing Officer need not address this issue.

ORDER

1. STUDENT's placement for the 1996-97 school year shall be in a regular education second grade classroom for the entire day.

2. STUDENT's supplemental aids and services for her second grade regular education placement shall include the following:

a. STUDENT shall have the assistance of one instructional aide to support her in her regular education placement for the entire day on a 1:1 basis.

In selecting STUDENT's instructional aide, the IEP team shall consider the recommendations of Dr. Frank Marone in his April 1, 1996 positive behavioral intervention plan (Resp. Exh. 42) with regard to the qualifications of this aide. However, notwithstanding Dr. Marone's recommendation in this regard, this instructional aide may be an employee of the District, so long as the aide is selected based on STUDENT's unique needs, particularly her needs in the areas of language and behavior.

b. Except for the modification as noted in (a) above, the District shall implement the positive behavioral intervention plan drafted by Dr. Frank Marone dated April 1, 1996 (Resp. Exh. 42) to support STUDENT in her regular education second grade placement. The District shall use Dr. Marone, or a person designated by Dr. Marone, to provide the training of staff and supervision of STUDENT's behavioral program as described in Dr. Marone's April 1, 1996 plan. The District shall also consider the use of peers, when possible, to model, encourage, and facilitate appropriate behavior for STUDENT.

c. The District shall provide STUDENT with a full inclusion coordinator to supervise STUDENT's regular education second grade placement for at least 300 minutes per week through the end of November 1996. Thereafter, the District shall provide STUDENT with the services of a full inclusion coordinator for 150 minutes per week through the remainder of STUDENT's second grade year, unless the IEP team determines that STUDENT's inclusion support shall be maintained at a higher level. This inclusion coordinator shall have demonstrated experience and success in implementing full inclusion and adapting regular education curriculum for children with severe disabilities. In adapting STUDENT's regular education curriculum, the full inclusion coordinator and District staff shall consider the recommendations for curriculum adaptation of outlined in footnote 17 above.

3. No later than 15 days from the date of this Order, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to revise STUDENT's IEP in accordance with this Order.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

1. Is a full-day placement in a regular education classroom the least restrictive appropriate placement for STUDENT?

Respondent STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

2. If a full-day placement in a regular education classroom is not appropriate for STUDENT, is a special day class the least restrictive environment for STUDENT?

The Hearing Officer did not address this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: July 25, 1996 ___________________________________ Kathleen S. Chovan, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The District requested the initial hearing in this matter (SN 198-96) for the purpose of changing STUDENT's existing placement from a regular education class to a special day class. Subsequently, STUDENT's grandparents, GRANDMOTHER and GRANDFATHER, filed for hearing (SN 216-96) for the purpose of maintaining STUDENT's existing placement. Based on agreement of the parties, the cases were consolidated as of March 28, 1996. As discussed further below, the District has the burden of providing that STUDENT should be removed from her regular education placement. Since the District made the initial request for hearing and because it bears the burden of persuasion, the Hearing Officer refers to the District as "Petitioner" and to STUDENT as "Respondent" in these cases. 2. Jackie McHaney from Ms. Youngblood's law firm, Thurbon and Youngblood, attended the hearing for several days on behalf of Petitioner 3. Quail Glen runs on a year-round track schedule. 4. During STUDENT's first grade year, the parties held informal "team meetings" which did not necessarily involve all of the parties required to attend the more formal IEP team meetings. Generally, the team meetings involved the classroom staff, some or all of STUDENT's related service providers, and the GRANDPARENTS. In this decision, the term "team meeting" refers to the informal meetings between staff and the GRANDPARENTS, while "IEP team meetings" refer to the meetings with the entire IEP team. 5. The date on the copy of the document in evidence was not clear, but Ms. Morris testified that this statement was written on approximately August 20, 1995. 6. The parties' contentions are grouped to conform to the four-part test in the Board of Education of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Holland, 786 F. Supp. 874 (E.D. Cal. 1992), as described below. All of the contentions offered by the parties fell within this four-part test. 7. The term "full inclusion" means that a disabled child is mainstreamed for 100% of his or her day. The term "integration" is also used interchangeably with the term "mainstreaming." 8. In comparing this case to Board v. Holland, the Hearing Officer in no way implies that the holding in that case regarding Rachel compels a finding that all developmentally delayed children, regardless of their functioning, must be mainstreamed. As noted above, the determination regarding the extent to which mainstreaming is appropriate must be made on an individualized basis. 9. The District urged that Mr. Neary's testimony regarding curriculum adaptations for STUDENT be given little weight, since he had provided consultation to the District on STUDENT's placement during her first grade year, and had not suggested alternative adaptations for STUDENT's curriculum at that time. Mr. Neary acknowledged that he provided information to three of the District's staff, including Ms. Gallant, when they attended his five-day full inclusion course. However, he testified that he only spent about 20 minutes with Ms. Gallant at Quail Glen, specifically discussing STUDENT's curriculum. Mr. Neary admitted that he was not able to accomplish what he had wanted at Quail Glen, and that, in fact, he did not accomplish much with regard to STUDENT. The District did not specifically rebut Mr. Neary's statement regarding the amount of time he spent addressing STUDENT's curriculum during first grade. Therefore, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District's argument that Mr. Neary's testimony be discounted. 10. The District cites the case of D.F. v. Western School Corporation, 921 F. Supp. 559 (S.D. Indiana 1996) for the proposition that mainstreaming under the IDEA does not compel modification of the regular education curriculum "beyond recognition" in order to fit a student's needs. As noted above, however, the District Court in Board v. Holland stated that the extent of curriculum modification, in and of itself, is not significant. 786 F. Supp. at 880. Since D.F. v. Western was not decided in the Ninth Circuit, it is not binding precedent in this case. In addition, the facts of D.F. v. Western are distinguishable from the facts in this case. In D.F. v. Western, the court concluded that the student's curriculum had to be adapted beyond recognition, and that the student gained no non-academic benefits from placement in the regular education classroom. In this case, Respondent's witnesses convincingly testified that STUDENT's curriculum could be adapted to a level appropriate for STUDENT but still be relevant to class activities. Finally, as discussed below, the evidence showed that STUDENT did receive non-academic benefits in her regular education placements. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer does not find D.F. v. Western to be persuasive in this case. 11. See Mavis v. Sobol, 839 F. Supp. 968, 989 (N.D.N.Y. 1994), in which the federal district court stated: [i]n assessing whether [student] can make satisfactory progress in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, such progress must be measured in terms of her abilities as a disabled child. When measuring her educational achievement, [student] should not be compared to a nondisabled child; and, in fact to do so would be in direct contravention of the Act... See also Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F. 2d 1036, 1047 (5th Cir. 1989): Given the tolerance embodied in the EHA [the predecessor to the IDEA], we cannot predicate access to regular education on a child's ability to perform on par with nonhandicapped children. We recognize that some handicapped children may not be able to master as much of the regular education curriculum as their nonhandicapped classmates. This does not mean, however, that those handicapped children are not receiving any benefit from regular education. Nor does it mean that they are not receiving all of the benefit that their handicapping condition will permit. If the child's individual needs make mainstreaming appropriate, we cannot deny the child access to regular education simply because his educational achievement lags behind that of his classmates. 12. The District argued that a special day class would be a better instructional environment for STUDENT. As noted above, the court in Board v. Holland concluded that: the Act's requirement of integration, based on a recognition of the non-academic value of such integration, is not overcome by a showing that a special education placement may be academically superior to placement in the regular classroom. 786 F. Supp. at 878-879. Therefore, the fact that STUDENT may make additional academic progress in a more restrictive setting does not compel a conclusion that her placement should be changed, if she is able to make progress on her IEP goals in the regular education setting. As noted above, the District has not demonstrated that STUDENT cannot make progress on her IEP goals in the regular classroom if an appropriate behavioral plan is implemented for her. 13. Adventure Club was an after-school program on the Quail Glen campus that was jointly run by the District and the City of Roseville. 14. Again, the Hearing Officer notes that in Board v. Holland, Rachel was also functioning four-to-five years behind her peers in the regular education classroom. The court in Board v. Holland concluded that Rachel obtained non-academic benefits in the regular education setting, in spite of the extent of her delay. As noted above, the court found that such non-academic benefits represent the fundamental purpose behind the IDEA's mainstreaming requirement. 15. The District cited Clyde K. in support of its contention that STUDENT's disruptive behavior indicates that the mainstream environment is not appropriate for her. The Hearing Officer finds Clyde K. distinguishable from the present case. In Clyde K., the court found that the student received no academic benefit and minimal non-academic benefits from his placement. As noted above, STUDENT received non-academic benefit from her regular education placement, and was limited in her opportunity to receive educational benefit by the District's inadequate supplemental aids and support. The court in Clyde K. noted that a school district must provide supplemental services and make reasonable adjustments for the student in the regular education environment in order to accommodate the student's disability. 35 F.3d at 1401, n. 7. In addition, the behavior of the student in Clyde K., who was a 15-year old male, involved violent attacks on two students, an assault on a staff member, profanity and vulgar comments to other students and teachers, and sexually-explicit remarks to female students. In contrast, STUDENT's actions, though disruptive, cannot be considered in the same classification of aggressive and violent behavior as those described in Clyde K. Several of Respondent's expert witnesses indicated that they did not observe behavior that they would consider aggressive. Dr. Marone testified that he did not observe behavior such as screaming, kicking, and crying, although he acknowledged that such behavior may have occurred in the past. He also testified that techniques were available for handling any disruptive behavior which might occur. For example, Dr. Marone suggested that staff physically interpose themselves between STUDENT and the target of her behavior, and then praise her when she returns to appropriate behavior. He also suggested that staff could increase the distance between STUDENT and other students when she attempted to make inappropriate physical contact with them. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer concludes that the holding in Clyde K. is not persuasive in this case. 16. The Hearing Officer notes that a child's placement must be reviewed annually, and therefore, the determination as to whether full inclusion is appropriate for STUDENT must be reconsidered during her annual IEP review following second grade. However, based on the evidence regarding STUDENT's needs at this time, the Hearing Officer concludes that a regular education placement is appropriate for her during second grade. 17. In Respondent's closing brief, she requests that her curriculum be adapted in the following ways: (a) curriculum not requiring adaptation (music, science) should be left alone; (b) all curriculum whether adapted or not, should incorporate efforts to address STUDENT's identified deficits and skills in need of instruction, i.e., her IEP goals and objectives; (c) all curriculum modifications must remain connected to the activities of the students around her and must arise out of those activities and subjects; (d) all curriculum modifications must allow for STUDENT to experience success at her level as well as allow her to complete tasks; (e) all curriculum modifications should include involvement of peers in activities with STUDENT such as in a cooperative group structure as described by Dr. Gardner and Mr. Neary and as the evidence demonstrates worked well for STUDENT; (f) activities should, as much as possible, validate STUDENT's need for movement and capitalize on it by giving her specific classroom jobs; (g) STUDENT's IEP goals and objectives and services should focus heavily on remediating language and communication problems so that both academic and behavioral deficits are addressed.