California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 21, 1997

Student v. Williams Unified School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 198-97 · Hearing Officer Keltie Jones

Williams Unified and Colusa County Office of Education prevail; ninth grader found not eligible for special education as SED or SLD.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. Before the hearing, the Hearing Officer granted the Respondents' motion to exclude evidence on eligibility before October 28, 1996, and the Petitioner withdrew three issues and modified others.

Summary

The parents of a 15-year-old ninth grader filed against Williams Unified School District and the Colusa County Office of Education. They claimed she qualified for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) and as having a specific learning disability (SLD). They sought a residential placement, reimbursement, and compensatory education. The student had never been found eligible. In an October 1996 settlement, the parents agreed she was not eligible, so the Hearing Officer considered only whether she had become eligible after October 28, 1996. She had serious behavior problems at home and school and had been out of school since March 1997 while expulsion proceedings were pending. Still, she earned an A- in honors English and a B+ in algebra. The Hearing Officer gave little weight to the parents' private psychologist, Dr. Richard Komm. His report had factual errors and relied on limited sources. The Hearing Officer found that the student met no SED criterion, that her outbursts were tied to unusual circumstances, and that her behavior fit oppositional defiant disorder. Even if she had met a criterion, her condition did not hurt her school performance. Her test scores and grades showed no severe gap between ability and achievement, so she did not qualify under SLD. Because she was not eligible, her FAPE, compensatory education, and reimbursement claims failed. The District also proved its assessments were appropriate. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO separated oppositional or conduct problems from serious emotional disturbance. It also required proof that an emotional condition hurts school performance. Strong grades defeated both the SED and the learning disability claims. The Hearing Officer weighed the private evaluation by checking the accuracy of its facts and how many sources it used.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue Threshold. Whether STUDENT is eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed or as having a specific learning disability since October 28, 1996.

    Student met no SED criterion, her condition did not adversely affect educational performance, and scores and grades showed no severe discrepancy for SLD.

  2. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1. Did the District and the County fail to properly assess and fail to provide STUDENT a FAPE in that they failed to properly place her during the 1996-97 school year, after October 28, 1996?

    Because the student is not eligible, the District had no obligation to provide a FAPE under special education law.

  3. District prevailedDiscipline

    Issue 2. Did the District and the County fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE within her county of residence during 1997 when they used the expulsion proceedings to keep STUDENT out of school?

    No FAPE obligation existed for an ineligible student; the Hearing Officer declined to address exclusion and alternative-program questions outside special education.

  4. District prevailedEligibility

    Issue 3. Was the District and the County's finding STUDENT ineligible for special education a willful act on the part of the District and the County?

    Because the student is not eligible, whether the ineligibility finding was willful is not relevant.

  5. Issue 4. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments performed after October 28, 1996?

    Parents showed no disagreement with District assessments, and the District proved its assessments were appropriate, so no reimbursement is owed.

  6. Issue 5. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for services that should have been provided by the District and the County after October 28, 1996?

    No reimbursement because the student is not eligible for special education.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. Is STUDENT entitled to special education services prospectively for the summer of 1997?

    Not eligible, so no special education services for summer 1997.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 7. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the violations by the District and the County of her right to a FAPE after October 28, 1996?

    No FAPE obligation existed for an ineligible student, so no compensatory education.

  9. Issue 8. Is STUDENT entitled to special education placement and services for the 1997-98 school year?

    Not eligible, so no special education placement or services for 1997-98.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • All of Petitioner's requests for relief are denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Ed. Code § 56026; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9); Ed. Code § 56337; 5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A); Ed. Code § 56329(b); Ed. Code § 56320; Ed. Code § 56324(a); Ed. Code § 56507(d)

People named in the decision

  • Frank Cranley, superintendent of schools, Williams Unified School District
  • Debra Owens, SELPA director and director of special education, Colusa County Office of Education
  • Debra Wiegel, private family counselor, Private provider
  • Richard Komm, clinical and educational psychologist; independent assessor and expert witness for Student, Private
  • Kari Applegate (Christensen), school psychologist (June 1996 assessment), District/County
  • Frank Yoldi, licensed clinical social worker, student's counselor, Private
  • Donald Stembridge, licensed clinical psychologist (1995 evaluation), Private
  • Raylene Lyss, assessor who administered Woodcock-Johnson tests (June 1996), District/County
  • Mary Stone (formerly Jansen), opportunity class teacher, Colusa County Office of Education
  • William Cornelius, school counselor, Williams Unified School District
  • William Merz, professor of psychometrics, California State University, Sacramento; expert witness for Respondents, California State University, Sacramento
  • Linda Wallace, school psychologist (November 1995 assessment), District
  • Vickie Moody, director of alternative education, Colusa County Office of Education
  • Mrs. Hopkins, high school principal, Williams Jr/Sr High School
  • Spencer Van Deusen, private counselor, Private
  • David Velez, pediatrician, Private
  • Brian Goldman, physician, Private

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on June 10, July 7, 8, 9, 10, and 11, 1997, in Colusa, California, before Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law.

The Petitioner/Cross-Respondent (Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma of Ruderman, Varma & Clancy. Attorney Geralyn Clancy was present on Petitioner’s behalf on June 10 and July 11, 1997. Also present on Petitioner’s behalf were her parents, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondents/Cross-Petitioners Williams Unified School District (District) and the Colusa County Office of Education (County) (collectively Respondents) were represented at the hearing by attorney David Girard of Girard and Vinson. Frank Cranley, superintendent of schools, was present on the District’s behalf on June 10, 1997, and July 7, 1997. Debra Owens, SELPA director and director of special education for the County, was present at the hearing on behalf of the County.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Frank Cranley, MOTHER, Debra Wiegel, FATHER, Richard Komm, Kari Applegate, Frank Yoldi, and Donald Stembridge. The Respondents called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Raylene Lyss, Mary Stone, William Cornelius, Debra Owens, and William Merz.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of closing briefs. Upon receipt of the closing briefs, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On June 10, 1997, Respondents presented a motion to exclude evidence and to dismiss issues relating to Petitioner’s eligibility for special education prior to October 28, 1996. No evidence was taken on that date, and the hearing was continued to allow the Petitioner to prepare a written response to the motion. The motion was granted, and at the commencement of the hearing on July 7, 1997, before the Hearing Officer indicated which issues would be dismissed, the Petitioner withdrew three issues and modified others. At that time, the Hearing Officer excluded documents that related solely to the Petitioner’s eligibility for special education prior to October 28, 1996.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

The Petitioner presented the following issues for hearing:(Footnote 1)

1. Did the District and the County fail to properly assess and fail to provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in that they failed to properly place her during the 1996-97 school year, after October 28, 1996?

2. Did the District and the County fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE within her county of residence during 1997 when they used the expulsion proceedings to keep STUDENT out of school?

3. Was the District and the County’s finding STUDENT ineligible for special education a willful act on the part of the District and the County?

4. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments performed after October 28, 1996?

5. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for services that should have been provided by the District and the County after October 28, 1996?

6. Is STUDENT entitled to special education services prospectively for the summer of 1997?

7. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the violations by the District and the County of her right to a FAPE after October 28, 1996?

8. Is STUDENT entitled to special education placement and services for the 1997-98 school year?

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner contends that she is eligible for special education services because she is seriously emotionally disturbed (SED) and because she has a specific learning disability (SLD). The Petitioner further contends that the appropriate placement for her is a residential placement for SED students.

The Respondents contend that the Petitioner is not SED, but that she has a conduct disorder or an oppositional defiant disorder (ODD). Respondents further contend that STUDENT does not have an SLD.

BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old girl who was in ninth grade during the 1996-97 school year. STUDENT has never been eligible for special education services, although the District evaluated her twice for eligibility. STUDENT lives at home with her parents and her eight-year-old brother.

Until the seventh grade, STUDENT performed well in school and had few behavior problems. (Testimony of MOTHER.) At that time, STUDENT entered the Williams Jr/Sr High School. During the seventh grade, STUDENT began having discipline problems in school, including defiance of school staff, dress code violations, and leaving class without permission. In addition, STUDENT’s grades were very low (mostly D’s). (Pet. Exh. 187.) On May 1, 1995, STUDENT was transferred to the opportunity class because she had low grades, had received eleven discipline referrals, and had been suspended a total of six and one-half days. ( Pet. Exh. 186.)

The opportunity class is operated by the County and is located at the Williams Jr/Sr High School campus. The purpose of the class is to give students in grades seven through nine who are at risk for failure or expulsion an opportunity to succeed at school. The class is taught by Ms. Mary Stone (formerly Ms. Jansen). Students in the class work on the subjects they were taking before they were transferred to the opportunity class, and Ms. Stone coordinates with the other teachers as necessary. An opportunity class placement is intended to be a short-term placement, and students are transferred out of the class once their behavior and/or performance improves. (Testimony of Ms. Stone; Dist. Exh. 16, 17, 18.)

At the same time that STUDENT’s behavior in school was deteriorating, so was her behavior at home. STUDENT was defiant to her parents, threw temper tantrums when she could not have her own way, and threatened to cut her family’s throats while they slept. (Testimony of MOTHER.) In November 1994, MOTHER took STUDENT to see a counselor, Ms. Debra Wiegel, to help get STUDENT’s behavior under control. The first few sessions with Ms. Wiegel included both STUDENT and her mother. Ms. Wiegel determined that STUDENT had a great deal of anger toward her father, and she suggested that FATHER join the sessions as well. STUDENT was adamant that she would not participate in sessions with her father present, but he joined the counseling sessions anyway. When her father joined the sessions, STUDENT refused to participate, but also refused to leave the room. According to Ms. Wiegel, STUDENT seemed to want to hear what was being said about her. Ms. Wiegel testified that she saw STUDENT with her mother about four times, and that STUDENT was present for two family sessions. During one of the family sessions, STUDENT stayed in Ms. Wiegel’s play therapy room and wrote a note that she left for Ms. Wiegel to find. The note said “Debra must die” and referred to Ms. Wiegel as a “bitch” and a “whore.” (Pet. Exh. 262.) After the two family sessions, STUDENT refused to come into the counseling sessions. It appears that this refusal was a result of STUDENT’s believing that Ms. Wiegel was blaming her for problems in her parents’ marriage. (Testimony of Ms. Wiegel, MOTHER.)

After STUDENT refused to continue to attend the counseling sessions, Mr. and MOTHER continued to see Ms. Wiegel about once or twice a week, through the present time. These sessions focused almost entirely on how the PARENTS should handle STUDENT’s behavior. Ms. Wiegel did not have any direct contact with STUDENT, but she did see STUDENT occasionally when she came with her parents and stayed in the car. During one session, STUDENT stayed outside and threw walnuts at Ms. Wiegel’s office window. (Testimony of Ms. Wiegel.)

STUDENT’s behavior worsened in May 1995, resulting in a serious outburst on May 31, 1995. On that day, STUDENT became angry about something and began destroying her room. After this destructive behavior, accompanied by verbal abuse of her parents, continued for an extended period of time, FATHER spanked her with a belt. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) At that point, STUDENT went to the kitchen and grabbed a butcher knife. FATHER went to his bedroom to get his handgun, which he asserts was not loaded at the time. MOTHER took the knife away from STUDENT and convinced FATHER to put the gun back. (Testimony of FATHER, MOTHER.) By this time, STUDENT was babbling incoherently, and at some point during the evening, she took a push pin from her wall and repeatedly pressed it into her wrist. This action did not draw a lot of blood. (Testimony of MOTHER.) After STUDENT was under control, the PARENTS decided that they should contact the police. The next morning, they contacted both Ms. Wiegel and the police. At Ms. Wiegel’s suggestion, the PARENTS took STUDENT to Sun Ridge Hospital and had her admitted there for a psychological evaluation. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER.)

STUDENT was in Sun Ridge from June 1 through June 12, 1995. This hospitalization did not result in a final diagnosis because STUDENT refused to do any psychological testing. When her parents convinced her to take the tests, the doctor refused to perform them because he thought STUDENT had been coerced into participating. A drug screening came back negative, but it was performed after STUDENT had been in the hospital for four days and was not necessarily accurate. The report from Sun Ridge does indicate that STUDENT admitted smoking marijuana. (Testimony of MOTHER; Dist. Exh. 25.)

Various documents indicate that STUDENT tried to commit suicide by taking a drug overdose in June 1995, but there was no testimony that such an incident occurred. The source of information about the overdose was STUDENT, herself. (Dist. Exh. 26; Pet. Exh. 55-56.)

In August 1995, STUDENT’s pediatrician, Dr. David Velez, referred her to Dr. Don Stembridge, a licensed clinical psychologist, for a psychological evaluation. Dr. Stembridge performed his evaluation on August 21, 1995. The evaluation consisted of interviews with STUDENT and her parents, a mental status examination, and various psycho-educational tests including the Weschler Intelligence Scales for Children (WISC-III), the Wide Range Achievement Tests (WRAT-3), and the Millon Adolescent Personality Inventory (MAPI). STUDENT told Dr. Stembridge that she had used marijuana and LSD in the past year. (Pet. Exh. 28.) The ability tests given reveal that STUDENT has above-average intellectual ability. (Pet. Exh. 32.) The Personality Inventory for Children profile completed by STUDENT’s parents suggested conduct disorder or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). (Pet. Exh. 30.) STUDENT’s WISC-III results revealed weaknesses in the areas of short-term auditory memory and numerical reasoning. (Pet. Exh. 33.) Her scores on the WRAT-3 indicate that her performance is below her ability. Dr. Stembridge stated that the discrepancy between her ability and performance scores could be attributed to either “underachievement” or “difficulty with attention and concentration.” (Pet. Exh. 35.) Dr. Stembridge stated that the MAPI results were of “questionable validity” because STUDENT did not respond to the inventory in a “fully reliable manner.” Dr. Stembridge diagnosed STUDENT as having ODD and ADHD. He recommended medication evaluation for ADHD, and individual and family counseling. (Pet. Exh. 41-42.)

On August 27, 1995, STUDENT ran away to Oregon with a 17-year-old boy she had known for four days. STUDENT admitted to her mother that she used drugs with the boy and had her first sexual experience with him. The police in Oregon picked her up, and her parents drove to Oregon to get her. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER; Pet. Exh. 82.)

STUDENT was in the opportunity class for all of eighth grade. STUDENT’s behavior problems continued both at home and at school. STUDENT’s relationship with her family continued to be conflicted. In September 1995, STUDENT kicked her father in the head while he was driving home from a very volatile session with counselor Spencer Van Deusen. (This was the first and last time STUDENT saw Mr. Van Deusen.) At that time, STUDENT was involved with the probation department because charges were pending for the knife incident that occurred in May 1995. When STUDENT attacked her father, her parents took her to the probation department, and she was placed in juvenile hall. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER.) While at juvenile hall, Dr. Stembridge met with her and recommended that she be placed in a residential hospital for evaluation. (Testimony of Dr. Stembridge; Pet. Exh. 43-45.)

STUDENT was admitted to West Hills hospital in Nevada on October 13, 1995, and released on October 21, 1995. The staff at West Hills diagnosed STUDENT as having major depression, single episode, ODD, and polydrug abuse. STUDENT reported to the West Hills staff that she uses marijuana, LSD, and crank. The West Hills discharge summary indicated that there was not enough evidence of ADHD to continue that diagnosis, and recommended that STUDENT take Prozac and receive psychotherapy. (Dist. Exh. 26.) Although STUDENT has been prescribed various medications, including Prozac, Tegretol, and Clonidine, she has never taken any of them for more than a short period of time. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

In late November 1995, STUDENT allowed some male friends to enter the family’s home and steal guns and jewelry. The boys were not charged with burglary in exchange for testimony against STUDENT. A trial was held in juvenile court, and STUDENT was not found to be guilty of a crime. (Testimony of FATHER.)

In November 1995, the District assessed STUDENT for special education eligibility at her parents’ request. School psychologist Linda Wallace prepared a report of the evaluations, which concluded that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Ms. Wallace indicated that STUDENT appeared to have a greater learning potential than demonstrated by the standardized tests because she performed very well at the Carden School, an academic program in juvenile hall. Ms. Wallace concluded that STUDENT’s difficulties were due to environmental factors rather than learning disabilities. (Pet. Exh. 55-56.)

In February 1996, an intruder broke into the FAMILY’S home, and he was shot by FATHER. As a result of damage caused by the intruder, the FAMILY had to live in a hotel for about one month. During that time, STUDENT’s behavior with her family was very bad, and she was also suspended from school for about ten days during that month. (Testimony of MOTHER.) In March 1996, an altercation occurred because Mr. and MOTHER wanted STUDENT to get in the car so they could go see Ms. Wiegel. STUDENT refused and shoved her mother against the car. At that point, FATHER slapped STUDENT. STUDENT reported the incident to a counselor, who filed a child abuse report. Child protective services investigated the incident, but no charges were brought. (Testimony of MOTHER, FATHER, Ms. Wiegel.) Mr. Frank Yoldi, a licensed clinical social worker, became involved in STUDENT’s case through Child Protective Services. STUDENT began seeing Mr. Yoldi for counseling in June 1996, and continued to see him approximately every two weeks through March 1997. (Testimony of Mr. Yoldi.)

In school during the 1995-96 school year, STUDENT received numerous referrals for defiance, profanity, and disruptive behavior. By early June, STUDENT had been suspended for more than 31 days. As a result of having more than 30 days of suspension, STUDENT was recommended for expulsion on June 4, 1996. At this point, STUDENT was in the middle of another evaluation for special education eligibility; she was tested on June 3, June 5, and June 20. School psychologist Kari (Christensen) Applegate prepared a report of the evaluations that concluded that STUDENT was not SED and did not qualify for special education. (Pet. Exh. 71.) STUDENT was very uncooperative in the testing and refused to do any psychological tests, stating that she was not “mental” and would not do any “mental” tests. STUDENT participated in the testing only because she was told they were to determine if she could accelerate her education. STUDENT became very angry when she learned that it was a special education assessment. At that point, STUDENT left the test site, and Ms. Applegate had to talk her into returning. (Testimony of Ms. Applegate.)

In spite of her behavior problems, STUDENT performed well academically in eighth grade. She earned grades of B’s and C’s, and was referred to the honors English class for ninth grade. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Stone, Ms. Owens; Pet. Exh. 132.) STUDENT has repeatedly stated her desire to accelerate her education and obtain her high school diploma as soon as possible. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Applegate, Ms. Stone; Pet. Exh. 132.) Her mother and Ms. Stone testified that STUDENT has the ability to complete her work at an accelerated pace, and she often worked ahead on her courses in the opportunity class. In fact, Ms. Stone stated that she recommended that STUDENT be placed in regular classes for ninth grade because she was capable of doing the work and because Ms. Stone did not think it was in STUDENT’s best interests to accelerate her high school education by working ahead in her classes.

STUDENT began ninth grade in the regular high school classes, but had some problems. MOTHER stated that STUDENT was assaulted in the hall by some boys and had other difficulties dealing with the regular class environment. In addition, STUDENT apparently preferred the opportunity class and expressed an intent to behave so badly that she would be sent back to opportunity class. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Stone.) On September 20, 1996, STUDENT was returned to the opportunity class for a five-day “trial run.” (Testimony of Ms. Stone; Dist. Exh. 20; Pet. Exh. 154.) On September 25 and 26, 1996, STUDENT verbally threatened the County’s director of alternative education, Ms. Vickie Moody, after Ms. Moody took away an art project of STUDENT’s because it had “gang writing.” STUDENT asserted that the project was merely calligraphy. Although STUDENT has stated that she belongs to a gang, MOTHER does not believe that she does. STUDENT also threatened Mrs. Hopkins, the principal of the High School, because she refused to give STUDENT information about one of STUDENT’s friends. (Testimony of Ms. Stone; Dist. Exh. 20, 21, 22.) STUDENT was suspended from school, and the District sought a restraining order to keep her from returning to school.

On October 4, 1996, the District and the PARENTS settled the restraining order action, as well as pending special education due process proceedings. As part of the settlement, the District agreed to place STUDENT in the opportunity class for the mornings with independent study for the afternoons, and the parents agreed that STUDENT was not eligible for special education.(Footnote 2) (Dist. Exh. 24.)

STUDENT returned to opportunity class in October 1996. In January 1997, STUDENT was raped by two males at an acquaintance’s house. (Testimony of MOTHER.) MOTHER did not report this incident to the District at STUDENT’s request. After the rape, STUDENT received some counseling from a victims’ program. On February 26, 1997, MOTHER filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office on behalf of STUDENT.

Between October 1996 and March 1997, STUDENT received five disciplinary referrals, each of which resulted in a one-day suspension. Each of the referrals involved defiance and profanity. The last referral, on March 18, 1997, was for making racially derogatory remarks about classmates, resulting in disruption of the class. (Testimony of Ms. Stone; Pet. Exh. 142-152.) After the incident of March 18, 1997, the District commenced expulsion proceedings. The expulsion hearing was postponed, however, at STUDENT’s attorney’s request. (Pet. Exh.16-17.) Since March 18, 1997, STUDENT has not attended school. MOTHER made several attempts to enrol STUDENT in a community school or independent study program through Yuba County, at the suggestion of District staff. However, MOTHER has not been able to find a teacher who will work with STUDENT at their home, and the family is unable to transport STUDENT to Marysville for the community school meetings.(Footnote 3) (Testimony of MOTHER.)

Again, in spite of her behavior problems, STUDENT performed well academically while she was in school during ninth grade. STUDENT’s courses included honors English, in which she received a grade of A- for the first semester. (Testimony of Ms. Stone; Pet. Exh. 258.) STUDENT’s grades at the end of the first semester also included a B+ in algebra, B’s in freshman requirements and art, B-’s in earth science and food/nutrition, and C+ in physical education. (Pet. Exh. 258.)

At the end of March 1997, STUDENT refused to continue any counseling, including her sessions with Mr. Yoldi. (Testimony of MOTHER, Mr. Yoldi.) On May 16, 1997, STUDENT was assessed by Dr. Richard Komm, a clinical and educational psychologist. Based on his interviews with STUDENT and her mother, his review of documents, conversations with Dr. Stembridge and Ms. Wiegel, and STUDENT’s test results, Dr. Komm concluded that STUDENT is SED and that she has an SLD. Dr. Komm diagnosed STUDENT as having Bipolar II Disorder, ODD, and a Disorder of Written Expression. (Pet. Exh. 95-96.) Dr. Komm recommended that STUDENT be placed in a residential treatment center.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The threshold issue presented for hearing is whether STUDENT is eligible for special education services under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). Under the IDEA and California special education law, only individuals with certain disabilities, including serious emotional disturbance and specific learning disabilities, are eligible for special education services. Moreover, the individual’s disability must require instruction, services, or both which cannot be provided with modification of the regular school program. Ed. Code § 56026(a), (b). The Petitioner asserts that she is eligible for special education services because she is SED and because she has an SLD.(Footnote 4) As the parties have agreed that STUDENT was not eligible for special education on October 28, 1996, the Hearing Officer will examine only whether she has become eligible since that date.

Is STUDENT Seriously Emotionally Disturbed?

The criteria for finding a serious emotional disturbance are as follows:

(i) Because of a serious emotional disturbance, a pupil exhibits one or more of the following characteristics over a long period of time and to a marked degree, which adversely affect educational performance: (1) An inability to learn which cannot be explained by intellectual, sensory, or health factors. (2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers. (3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations. (4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

5 C.C.R. § 3030(i). The federal definition of SED indicates that the term includes schizophrenia, but does not apply to children who are socially maladjusted, unless it is determined that they have a serious emotional disturbance. 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(b)(9)(Footnote 5).

Several witnesses testified about whether STUDENT met these criteria. (Dr. Komm, Ms. Applegate, Ms. Owens, Dr. William Merz.) All of the witnesses agreed that STUDENT does not meet the criteria listed in subsection (1), but there is some dispute over whether STUDENT meets the other criteria. Essentially, Dr. Komm testified that STUDENT meets all of the other criteria, as well as the limiting factors set forth in the regulations (occurring over a long period of time, to a marked degree, and adversely affecting educational performance), while Ms. Applegate, Ms. Owens, and Dr. Merz testified that she meets neither the criteria nor the limiting factors. Before reviewing the evidence that relates to STUDENT’s SED eligibility, it is necessary to discuss the basis of the witnesses’ knowledge of STUDENT and the weight their testimony will be accorded.

Dr. Komm both testified and prepared a report of his evaluation of STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 81-99.) The Hearing Officer finds, based on an analysis of the testimony and the documentary evidence, that Dr. Komm’s testimony and report contained inaccuracies and inconsistencies. Dr. Komm’s report made many inaccurate statements, many of which he relied upon for his final conclusions. For example, Dr. Komm wrote that STUDENT attended counseling with Mr. Yoldi on a “sporadic” basis and referred to Ms. Wiegel as the therapist who had had the most contact with STUDENT. (Pet. Exh. 83, 94.) In fact, the reverse was true. Dr. Komm appeared to give great weight to what Ms. Wiegel told him about STUDENT’s behavior, almost all of which she heard secondhand from STUDENT’s parents, and he did not contact Mr. Yoldi at all. Dr. Komm referred to STUDENT’s “several” suicide attempts, and relied on the “fact” of those attempts in drawing his conclusions about her mental state. (Pet. Exh. 85.) In reality, only two attempts were ever reported, one where STUDENT poked herself with a push pin and one drug overdose that STUDENT reported to the West Hills staff. There was absolutely no testimony at the hearing about the drug overdose, or about any other suicide attempt. Dr. Komm also testified that he thought the sharp object STUDENT used to cut her wrists was a knife, when the testimony from MOTHER at the hearing established that it was a push pin. Dr. Komm wrote that Dr. Brian Goldman diagnosed STUDENT “within the past year” as having Bipolar Disorder and borderline anti-social and narcissistic personality traits. (Pet. Exh. 94.) The “diagnosis” from Dr. Goldman consists of notes made on a prescription pad. (Pet. Exh. 74.) Although the note is dated August 30, 1996, it specifically states that Dr. Goldman saw STUDENT in September 1995, almost two years ago, and lists the predominant features of her condition, not a definitive diagnosis. Another inaccuracy in Dr. Komm’s report involves his description of a letter requesting stay put as being from the Special Education Hearing Office, when in fact that letter was from the Developmental Disabilities Area Board III. (Pet. Exh. 87.)

There were also internal inconsistencies within Dr. Komm’s report. He wrote that STUDENT was “only vaguely interested [in] ‘maximizing’ her results” and noted that STUDENT was resistant to and refused to complete testing. (Pet. Exh. 88-89.) Yet Dr. Komm relied on the low scores STUDENT received on tests to find that she had a learning disability. At one point, Dr. Komm wrote about a decline in STUDENT’s written language scores, citing Woodcock-Johnson tests done in November 1995 and June 1996. However, because there was no written language score indicated for the November 1995 testing, it is difficult to see how Dr. Komm could find a decline in that score. (Pet. Exh. 93, 51.) Dr. Komm also stated that STUDENT refused to take most of the projective testing, and yet he used the few results he had and his brief observation of her to diagnose her as having Bipolar II disorder. Dr. Komm briefly noted that STUDENT admitted using marijuana, methamphetamines, and alcohol, but did not discuss how that drug use could be affecting her behavior and performance. (Pet. Exh. 83.)

Dr. Komm repeatedly described his extensive experience with teenagers and the thousands of assessments he has conducted, indicating that his expertise gave him insight into STUDENT’s problems. (Testimony of Dr. Komm; Pet. Exh. 93-94.) However, for this evaluation, all of the information Dr. Komm received about STUDENT came from STUDENT, her mother, and documents her mother chose to give him. Dr. Komm did not speak with any school personnel, nor did he talk to the one therapist who had seen STUDENT the most, Mr. Yoldi. (Testimony of Dr. Komm.) In light of the flaws in his report and his limited sources of information, the Hearing Officer will not place a great deal of weight on Dr. Komm’s opinion of STUDENT’s eligibility for special education.

Dr. William Merz is a professor of psychometrics at California State University, Sacramento. He reviewed STUDENT’s school and hospital records and Dr. Komm’s assessment and testified at the hearing about his impressions of those documents and his opinion of STUDENT. Dr. Merz never met STUDENT.

Ms. Kari Applegate has been a school psychologist since 1995. Ms. Applegate assessed STUDENT in June 1996. She observed STUDENT in class and on campus and conducted tests on two different occasions. In her testimony, Ms. Applegate demonstrated a commitment to serving students with disabilities and a solid understanding of special education eligibility requirements. Ms. Applegate has not seen STUDENT since she left school in March 1997.

Ms. Owens has had little personal contact with STUDENT, but, as the director for special education for the County, she supervised the individuals who evaluated STUDENT for the District. Ms. Owens also demonstrated a broad understanding of special education eligibility criteria.

The Hearing Officer will now proceed to examine whether STUDENT meets the criteria described in subsections (2) through (5) of the definition of SED.

(2) An inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers and teachers.

Dr. Komm testified that there were indications that STUDENT had an inability to build and maintain satisfactory relationships, but that this factor was less obviously clear than others. Ms. Applegate pointed out that STUDENT has a boyfriend and has friends at school. She defined satisfactory relationships as being those with reciprocal interaction. Ms. Owens testified that she has heard from others that STUDENT has satisfactory relationships with both peers and adults. Dr. Merz testified that he did not see any evidence that STUDENT was unable to form relationships.

In addition to the opinions stated regarding whether STUDENT qualifies as SED under this subsection, there was significant testimony from others regarding STUDENT’s relationships. MOTHER testified that STUDENT has had a boyfriend for some time, that she currently has one close friend, that she has many acquaintances that she talks with on the telephone, and that she believed that STUDENT got along well with Ms. Stone. MOTHER stated that STUDENT and her friend had a falling-out a while ago, but that the relationship has been renewed during the past few months. STUDENT and her friend visit at each other’s homes, talk on the phone, and occasionally have sleepovers. Ms. Stone testified that STUDENT got along well with her classmates. Mr. Yoldi testified that at times STUDENT could be the most cooperative client. Most of the adults who evaluated her described STUDENT as bright or interesting, in spite of her oppositional behavior. Mr. Bill Cornelius, STUDENT’s school counselor, described what appeared to be a normal counselor-student relationship with STUDENT.

Based on the evidence of STUDENT’s ability to build and maintain relationships with her peers, and her ability to get along well with adults when she wants to, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not SED due to an inability to build or maintain satisfactory relationships with peers and teachers.

(3) Inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances exhibited in several situations.

Dr. Komm testified that STUDENT’s fears, anxiety, and reactions both in and out of school amount to inappropriate behavior and feelings under normal circumstances. Dr. Merz testified that STUDENT’s anger and reactions appear to be purposeful attempts to get her own way, and that STUDENT seems to be able to turn those reactions on and off. Both Ms. Applegate and Ms. Owens testified that, although STUDENT’s behavior is extreme and beyond the normal expectations for teenage behavior, it does not rise to the level of inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances that is found in an SED student. Ms. Applegate testified that STUDENT’s anger seemed to be specifically related to situations where STUDENT believed that she had been lied to or betrayed. For example, STUDENT’s reaction to learning that the testing from Ms. Applegate was for special education was extreme, but it was a response to being lied to by her mother. Ms. Applegate and Ms. Owens pointed out that STUDENT became similarly agitated whenever she suspected that she was being given “mental” testing. Ms. Owens further stated that STUDENT’s most extreme behavior occurred under abnormal circumstances, such as being hit by her father, participating in a volatile counseling session, and being the victim of a rape. Ms. Applegate also stated that STUDENT appears to react strongly when STUDENT believes that she is being treated unjustly or betrayed, as she did with the “gang writing” incident and the special education testing. This is not a situation where STUDENT was becoming violent or abusive without any type of provocation, even if her reactions were more extreme than the norm.

The Hearing Officer agrees that STUDENT’s extreme outbursts and acting out appear to be linked to abnormal circumstances. STUDENT pulled a knife on her father after he hit her with a belt, and her reported “suicide attempt” with the push pin was part of the same incident. STUDENT kicked her father after a very volatile session with a counselor. STUDENT ran away from home shortly after Dr. Stembridge gave her “mental tests” she did not want to take. STUDENT’s outbursts at school and threats to administrators in September 1996 were triggered by an administrator confiscating her art project and accusing her of gang writing when STUDENT claimed it was only calligraphy. The Hearing Officer also notes that the only behavior documented since October 28, 1997, consists of verbal defiance, profanity, and verbally disrupting class. There was no testimony regarding any specific extreme, inappropriate actions by STUDENT after that date. In fact, most of the testimony and documents focus on incidents that occurred in 1995, at which time, according to STUDENT’s statements to various medical professionals, she was using a variety of illegal drugs.

The only professional who concluded definitively that STUDENT was SED is Dr. Komm. It is interesting that the one therapist who saw STUDENT over the longest period of time, Mr. Yoldi, would neither rule out nor rule in an SED diagnosis. Mr. Yoldi testified that to make a determination about whether STUDENT is SED, he would have to work with STUDENT over a longer period of time and work closely with her family and school professionals. Mr. Yoldi was a very credible witness who expressed a genuine concern for STUDENT’s welfare. The Hearing Officer believes that Mr. Yoldi has the most comprehensive understanding of STUDENT’s problems and the Hearing Officer is impressed by the fact that Mr. Yoldi believes that he cannot come to the conclusion that STUDENT is SED without additional information.

Although there was significant evidence that STUDENT was using drugs, there was no evidence presented regarding whether STUDENT’s inappropriate behavior could be attributed to drug use. MOTHER testified that she believed STUDENT was “high” on something during the knife incident in May 1995. STUDENT, herself, reported use of multiple drugs to various professionals. However, Mr. Yoldi testified that STUDENT had told him she had stopped using drugs. In light of the facts that the circumstances under which STUDENT exhibited inappropriate behavior were often abnormal, that STUDENT’s reported drug use could have affected her behavior, and that there are very few reports of inappropriate behavior since October 28,1997, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence presented does not establish that STUDENT is currently SED because of inappropriate behavior under normal circumstances and in several situations.

(4) A general pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression.

Dr. Komm expressed the opinion that STUDENT is depressed, and has been for some time. He based his opinion, in part, on the facts that West Hills staff diagnosed her as having Major Depression - Single Episode, Dr. Goldman “diagnosed” her with Bipolar Disorder - Manic Variety, and Ms. Wiegel, “who has had the greatest contact with her over a period of time,” saw her as mood disordered. (Pet. Exh. 94.) All of these professionals last saw STUDENT during 1995. Dr. Komm also relied on his brief observation of STUDENT during his testing of her, STUDENT’s self-reported sleep problems, MOTHER’s report of STUDENT’s weight loss, and the results of the Bender Visual-Motor Gestalt test. Dr. Komm asserted that STUDENT’s anger is a symptom of her depression, and emphasized her “several” suicide attempts. Based on all of this information, including two-year-old diagnoses and questionable suicide attempts, Dr. Komm diagnosed STUDENT as having primarily Bipolar II Disorder, and secondarily ODD. (Pet. Exh. 95-96.) Dr. Komm does not discuss what effect STUDENT’s reported drug abuse would have on her mood, or on his diagnosis.

Mr. Yoldi, the professional who treated STUDENT most recently, testified that STUDENT was angry at times, and, at other times, seemed depressed. Mr. Yoldi stated that he did not form a diagnostic opinion of STUDENT until after five or six fifty-minute sessions. At that time, he believed that STUDENT had ODD, and he continued to consider a diagnosis of depression. He did not equate anger with depression. He testified that anger is a legitimate human emotion, while depression is a lowered mood. Mr. Yoldi also testified that STUDENT expressed suicidal ideations in the form of hopelessness, but that her suicidal thoughts were not certain. He stated that at one session, when STUDENT’s boyfriend was talking about ending the relationship, she said “I have nothing else to live for.” Mr. Yoldi testified that after working with STUDENT for about eight months, he was not able to come to a conclusive diagnosis of her problems.

Dr. Merz testified that it is unusual to diagnose a young person with Bipolar Disorder. Moreover, he pointed out that of all of the disorders attributed to STUDENT over the years, STUDENT most exhibits the features of ODD. Ms. Applegate and Ms. Owens concurred that STUDENT has ODD, which is a behavior disorder, not a depressive disorder. Ms. Wiegel also testified that she believed that STUDENT has ODD, but that she also believed STUDENT has an undiagnosed mental disorder(Footnote 6).

STUDENT’s only confirmed suicide attempt involved poking her wrists with a push pin, which is not likely to lead to death. Moreover, many of the symptoms that would support a diagnosis of depression, such as weight loss, sleep problems, and mood swings, could be caused by STUDENT’s reported drug abuse. The Hearing Officer notes that MOTHER testified that after STUDENT was excluded from school in March 1997, STUDENT became depressed. STUDENT sometimes sleeps more than 14 hours at night and has lost about 20 or 30 pounds. However, if this behavior qualified as a pervasive depression, it has not been ongoing for a long period of time and, more critically, there is no evidence that it is affecting her educational performance. In fact, MOTHER implied that it is STUDENT’s lack of participation in school that is causing this depressed behavior, and did not state that her depressed behavior is interfering with her ability to learn. STUDENT has been unable to participate in an educational program since March 1997 because of logistical problems that prevent her from enrolling in the programs made available to her, not because of her emotional state. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not establish that STUDENT had a pervasive mood of unhappiness or depression. The Hearing Officer also finds that the diagnosis of major depression, single episodic, by West Hills in 1995 does not currently qualify STUDENT as SED.

(5) A tendency to develop physical symptoms or fears associated with personal or school problems.

Dr. Komm also asserted that STUDENT is SED because she develops physical symptoms associated with school problems. There was very little evidence presented at the hearing regarding this issue, other than passing references to STUDENT’s having headaches and stomach aches. Moreover, there was no specific testimony or documents that established that STUDENT had physical symptoms associated with school after October 28, 1996. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not qualify as SED under this category. *** Based on her failure to meet the criteria as described above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not qualify for special education as an SED student. Even if STUDENT were found to meet one of the SED criteria, she fails to meet a very important limiting factor: that her condition adversely affects her educational performance. STUDENT is described by virtually everyone who knows her as a bright girl. Ms. Stone testified that STUDENT works ahead in her courses, and both Ms. Stone and MOTHER testified that STUDENT could easily achieve her goal of earning her high school diploma early if she set her mind to it. In the midst of all her behavioral problems, STUDENT earned an A- in honors English, a B+ in Algebra, and no grade was lower than C+. STUDENT was unable to complete her units for ninth grade not because of her behavioral problems, but because of logistical problems in enrolling her in various independent study programs.(Footnote 7) Therefore, even if STUDENT met the criteria, she would still not be eligible for special education services as an SED student.

The Hearing Officer understands that the PARENTS are very concerned about their daughter’s conduct, which is beyond normal adolescent behavior. It may be that STUDENT needs a structured residential environment and intensive counseling to address her significant level of anger and possible drug abuse. However, the Hearing Officer also recognizes that the special education system is not responsible for providing all students’ mental health needs. If a student’s emotional condition is not interfering with her ability to benefit from her education, she is not eligible for special education services. After carefully considering all the evidence in light of the state and federal definitions of SED, the Hearing Officer must conclude that STUDENT is not SED pursuant to special education criteria.

Does STUDENT have a specific learning disability?

California Education Code section 56337 states that the following three requirements must be met for a student to be classified as having an SLD:

(a) A severe discrepancy exists between the intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the following academic areas: (1) Oral expression; (2) Listening comprehension; (3) Written expression; (4) Basic reading skills; (5) Reading comprehension; (6) Mathematics calculation; (8) Mathematics reasoning. (b) The discrepancy is due to a disorder in one or more of the basic psychological processes and is not the result of environmental, cultural, or economic disadvantages. (c) The discrepancy cannot be corrected through other regular or categorical services offered within the regular instructional program.

The California Code of Regulations sets forth the standards to be used when comparing standardized test scores to determine that a student has a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement:

When standardized test scores are considered to be valid for a specific pupil, a severe discrepancy is demonstrated by: first, converting into common standard scores, using a mean of 100 and a standard deviation of 15, the achievement test score and the ability test score to be compared; second, computing the difference between these common standard scores; and third, comparing this computed difference to the standard criterion which is the product of 1.5 multiplied by the standard deviation of the distribution of computed differences of students taking these achievement and ability tests. A computed difference which equals or exceeds this standard criterion, adjusted by one standard error of measurement, the adjustment not to exceed 4 common standard score points, indicates a severe discrepancy when such a discrepancy is corroborated by other assessment data which may include other tests, scales, instruments, observations and work samples, as appropriate.

5 C.C.R. § 3030(j)(4)(A).

Thus, a severe discrepancy is established when the difference between the standard scores on academic achievement and ability tests meets or exceeds 22.5 points, as adjusted by one standard error of measurement. This number is determined by first multiplying the standard deviation of 15 points by 1.5, which equals 22.5 points. Adjustment is then made by adding or subtracting one standard error of measurement, not to exceed four points. The final step in establishing a severe discrepancy is to determine whether the discrepancy is supported by other assessment data.

In his report, the only standardized test scores Dr. Komm presented were STUDENT’s WISC-III scores, which are intellectual ability scores. Dr. Komm’s tests established that STUDENT’s current full-scale IQ is 101. Dr. Komm did not report any academic achievement test scores because STUDENT refused to cooperate with that testing, resulting in very low scores. Therefore, Dr. Komm did not compare ability scores with achievement scores to make a finding that STUDENT has an SLD. Rather, Dr. Komm proceeded to discuss STUDENT’s past scores haphazardly, pointing out scores that he believed had declined over the years. At one point, Dr. Komm asserts that STUDENT’s Woodcock-Johnson Broad Written Language score declined when the full battery for the written language score was given only once. (Testimony of Ms. Applegate; Pet. Exh. 93.) Dr. Komm discounts the possibility that STUDENT’s lack of cooperation and interest in testing, as documented in his own report, could be contributing to the lower scores. Based upon this perceived decline in scores, as well as STUDENT’s refusal to do the calculation portion of the WISC-III, Dr. Komm concluded that STUDENT has visual motor/spatial processing difficulties and a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in written language. (Pet. Exh. 97.)

In the absence of current achievement scores, the Hearing Officer will compare Dr. Komm’s ability scores with STUDENT’s most recent achievement test results: the Woodcock-Johnson Psychoeducational Battery - Revised tests given by Raylene Lyss on June 20, 1996. (Pet. Exh. 65.) Even that testing was not complete, however, because STUDENT refused to perform the calculation subtest. STUDENT’s Broad Reading score was 93, her Math - Applied Problems score was 105, her Broad Written Language score was 79, and her Broad Knowledge score was 95. The only score that comes close to the severe discrepancy standard is the written language score, which was 22 points lower than her full-scale IQ. The written language score came from a score of 89 on writing samples and 77 on dictation (24 points lower than her full-scale IQ). A difference of more than 22.5 points is not conclusive of an SLD, however. That discrepancy must also be corroborated by other assessment data, including work samples. It is interesting that STUDENT’s score on the writing samples portion is significantly higher than the dictation test, belying the fact that a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement exists in the area of written language. It is difficult to believe that a student who earns an A- in honors English has learning disability in written language. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have an SLD in the area of written language.

Dr. Komm also asserted that STUDENT has visual motor/spatial processing difficulties that affect her math calculation abilities. This conclusion is based on STUDENT’s repeated refusal to complete math calculation tests. Dr. Komm repeatedly asserted that STUDENT’s refusal to perform certain tests was an attempt to hide an inability to perform math calculations in her head. Dr. Merz also testified that STUDENT’s test scores over the years reveal a student who learns better with her eyes and hands than with her ears. However, Dr. Merz did not conclude that STUDENT had an SLD. Rather, he asserted that STUDENT could be given paper and pencil, or even a calculator, to accommodate any difficulties she may have processing math problems in her head. STUDENT’s scores on the applied problems portion of the Woodcock-Johnson tests, as well as her grades in algebra, reveal that she can perform adequately in math when she can work the problems with a pencil and paper. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have an SLD that affects mathematical calculation skills that cannot be remedied through services offered within the regular instructional program. The Hearing Officer also notes that the testimony established that one of STUDENT’s favorite activities was doing jigsaw puzzles, and that she is very good at that activity. (Testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Stone.) Doing a jigsaw puzzle involves both visual motor and spatial processing skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT does not have a visual motor/spatial processing SLD.

The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not eligible for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability.

With the threshold issue of eligibility for special education services resolved, the Hearing Officer now turns to the issues presented for hearing.

1. Did the District and the County fail to properly assess and fail to provide STUDENT a FAPE in that they failed to properly place her during the 1996-97 school year, after October 28, 1996?

Under state and federal law, all students who are eligible for special education services are entitled to an appropriate placement and a FAPE. STUDENT is not eligible for special education services; therefore, the District had no obligation to provide a FAPE under special education law.

2. Did the District and the County fail to provide STUDENT with a FAPE within her county of residence during 1997 when they used the expulsion proceedings to keep STUDENT out of school?

Under state and federal law, all students who are eligible for special education services are entitled to an appropriate placement and a FAPE. STUDENT is not eligible for special education services; therefore, the District had no obligation to provide a FAPE under special education law.

3. Was the District and the County’s finding STUDENT ineligible for special education a willful act on the part of the District and the County?

STUDENT is not eligible for special education. Therefore, it is not relevant whether the Respondents acted willfully in finding her not to be eligible.

4. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for the independent assessments performed after October 28, 1996?

California Education Code § 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation.

For the District’s assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code § 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a).

Petitioner put on no evidence as to why the PARENTS should be reimbursed for the assessments they obtained. There was no testimony that the PARENTS disagreed with the District’s assessments. In fact, by agreeing in October 1996 that STUDENT was not eligible for special education, the PARENTS agreed with the conclusions of the District’s assessments. There was also no evidence that the PARENTS asked the District to assess STUDENT after October 1996.

Notwithstanding the fact that the Petitioner did not establish that the parents disagreed with the District’s assessments, the District established that their assessments were appropriate. STUDENT was assessed in all areas of suspected disability, using tests administered in a nondiscriminatory manner. The tests used were given by trained personnel, and the psychological tests were given by credentialed school psychologists. The District did not use a single criterion for making its finding that STUDENT was not eligible for special education. Ms. Applegate testified that her evaluation of STUDENT was the most extensive evaluation she has performed and that it involved gathering and reviewing more information than she has had on any other student.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for assessments obtained after October 28, 1996.

5. Are the parents of STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for services that should have been provided by the District and the County after October 28, 1996?

Parents of students with disabilities are entitled to reimbursement for expenses incurred when a local educational agency does not provide a FAPE. STUDENT is not eligible for special education; therefore, her parents are not entitled to reimbursement for costs incurred for services obtained for STUDENT or the family.

6. Is STUDENT entitled to special education services prospectively for the summer of 1997?

STUDENT is not eligible for special education, and therefore is not eligible for special education services for the summer of 1997.

7. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the violations by the District and the County of her right to a FAPE after October 28, 1996?

Under state and federal law, all students who are eligible for special education services are entitled to an appropriate placement and a FAPE. STUDENT is not eligible for special education services; therefore, the District had no obligation to provide a FAPE under special education law, and STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education as a result of an alleged failure to provide FAPE.

8. Is STUDENT entitled to special education placement and services for the 1997-98 school year?

STUDENT is not eligible for special education, and therefore is not eligible for special education services for the 1997-98 school year.

ORDER

All of Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: the Respondents prevailed on all issues presented for hearing.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).

Date: August 21, 1997 Keltie Jones, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1.The Petitioner’s issues as originally presented can be found at Petitioner’s Exhibit 1-10. Petitioner withdrew issues numbered 1, 5, and 7, and modified numbers 2, 4, 6, 8, and 10. The issues listed in this decision are as modified and are renumbered to avoid confusion. 2.Mr. Cranley, the District’s superintendent, testified that the agreement included an oral understanding that if STUDENT was suspended for a total of five days, her expulsion, which was suspended by the Board of Trustees, would be reinstated. However, MOTHER testified that no such agreement existed. 3.The District has an agreement with Yuba County to provide community school services to students who are expelled from the District schools. 4.It should be noted that STUDENT, herself, does not make these contentions; rather, her parents are seeking special education eligibility and services for STUDENT without her knowledge and against her wishes. MOTHER testified that STUDENT did not know that this hearing was for special education. MOTHER told STUDENT that the hearing was to determine whether she could return to school. MOTHER also stated that STUDENT has said that she will run away if her parents try to put her in special education classes. Special education law permits a parent to seek special education services on a child’s behalf without the child’s consent. Education Code § 56501. 5.The federal regulations were authorized by the federal statutes that were recently amended. Amendments to the IDEA, P.L. 105-17. Although the Amendments refer to “serious emotional disturbance” as simply “emotional disturbance,” there is no indication that the qualifying criteria would be changed. P.L. 105-17, Sec. 602(3)(A). 6.As described in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), ODD is defined as follows:

A. A pattern of negativistic, hostile, and defiant behavior lasting at least 6 months, during which four (or more) of the following are present: (1) often loses temper (2) often argues with adults (3) often actively defies or refuses to comply with adults’ requests or rules (4) often deliberately annoys people (5) often blames others for his or her mistakes or misbehavior (6) is often touchy or easily annoyed by others (7) is often angry and resentful (8) is often spiteful or vindictive.

B. The disturbance in behavior causes clinically significant impairment in social, academic, or occupational functioning.

C. The behaviors do not occur exclusively during the course of a Psychotic or Mood Disorder.

D. Criteria are not met for Conduct Disorder, and, if the individual is age 18 years or older, criteria are not met for Antisocial Personality Disorder.

DSM IV, p. 93-94. The evidence presented at the hearing established that STUDENT exhibits all eight behaviors described above. Generally, ODD does not satisfy the SED criteria. 7. As STUDENT is not eligible for special education, the Hearing Officer will not examine whether the District failed in its duty to provide an alternative educational program to STUDENT while she was being excluded from the District’s schools. Nor will the Hearing Officer determine whether it was appropriate for the District to continue to exclude STUDENT from school on an indefinite suspension without holding an expulsion hearing. Such issues are not appropriate for this forum if the student involved is not eligible for special education services.