California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 1, 2000
Morongo Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 1981-99 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara
Morongo Unified wins an order placing a 17-year-old with serious emotional disturbance in a locked residential facility.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None stated.
Summary
Morongo Unified School District filed for due process after a parent rejected its offers of a nonpublic school placement for her 17-year-old son. He was eligible for special education as seriously emotionally disturbed and attended Twentynine Palms High School. No one appeared for the student. The Hearing Officer had denied the parent's request for a continuance and made repeated efforts to reach her. Morongo Basin Mental Health was added as a party. Its report recommending residential care was late and reached the District only after the hearing began. The District then offered a residential placement, which the parent refused. The Hearing Officer let the District amend its issue to ask what placement the student needed.
Fourteen school and mental health witnesses described escalating threats of violence, physical aggression, self-injury, and refusal to stay in class or do any work. Every behavior plan failed. The mental health witnesses said he would not stay in an unlocked facility. Applying Rowley and the Holland least restrictive environment factors, the Hearing Officer found that he got no academic or social benefit at the high school and that a 1:1 aide was not practical. She held that a locked residential facility was his least restrictive environment. She ordered an expanded IEP team meeting within five days to find a locked residential placement with therapy, any needed substance abuse treatment, and small academic classes. She declined to decide how the District and the mental health agency should share costs.
Why it matters
The case shows how SEHO handled a district-filed placement case when the parent did not appear and the mental health agency's report arrived late. The Hearing Officer applied the Holland factors and found a locked residential facility was the least restrictive environment. She would not decide cost-sharing or lead-agency questions between the district and the mental health agency.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1. What placement does STUDENT require to receive an appropriate education for the 1999-2000 school year? (Issue as amended at hearing: what is an appropriate placement based on all the evidence presented.)
The student's severe emotional disturbance, escalating threats and aggression, and refusal to stay in class meant he got no benefit on a high school campus. A locked residential facility was the least restrictive environment that could meet his needs.
- Not reachedResponsible agency
Issue Fn. 2(1). If STUDENT requires residential placement, how shall the cost of that placement be apportioned between the District and Morongo Mental Health?
The Hearing Officer held that cost apportionment was not an appropriate issue for a due process hearing and referred the parties to 2 C.C.R. §60200(c)(d) and Education Code §60110.
- Not reachedResponsible agency
Issue Fn. 2(2). Is Morongo Mental Health or the District the "lead agency" for responding to STUDENT's placement needs?
The Hearing Officer held that the lead-agency question was not an appropriate issue for a due process hearing and referred the parties to the governing regulations.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. An expanded IEP team meeting must be convened within five days of the order to identify an appropriate locked residential placement, in compliance with 2 C.C.R. §60100 and all other statutes on residential placement of a disabled child.
- Placement ordered. The District and Morongo Mental Health must take all appropriate steps to promptly place the student in the identified locked residential facility. The facility must provide a highly structured environment with group and individual therapy, any substance abuse treatment needed, and an academic program with small class sizes designed to meet the State's high school graduation requirements.
Key authorities
Board of Education v. Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H. (Holland), 786 F. Supp. 874 (1992), 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 17 Cal.3d 425 (1976); 5 C.C.R. §7576(a); 2 C.C.R. §60100; Education Code §56031
People named in the decision
- Vincent Freeland, math teacher, Twentynine Palms High School / Morongo Unified School District
- Charlene O'Reilly, special education teacher, Morongo Unified School District
- John Bucko, wood shop teacher, Twentynine Palms High School / Morongo Unified School District
- Kim Caughlin, English teacher, Twentynine Palms High School / Morongo Unified School District
- Margo Recker, educational aide, Morongo Unified School District
- Donna Powell, special education instructional assistant, Morongo Unified School District
- Mary Stevens, SELPA director; District representative at hearing, Morongo SELPA
- Sheila Folkestad, AB 2726 mental health clinic coordinator and therapist, Morongo Basin Mental Health
- Bruce Karp, Ph.D., director of mental health agency, Morongo Basin Mental Health
- Lawrence Thigpen, campus security coordinator, Twentynine Palms High School / Morongo Unified School District
- John Calveri, school psychologist, Morongo Unified School District
- Heidi Lanning, special day class teacher, Morongo Unified School District
- Dr. Jeffrey Morse, assistant principal, Twentynine Palms High School
- Liz Roman, principal, Twentynine Palms High School
- Cedar House, residential facility recommended by Morongo Mental Health and offered by the District; later found not available and not suited to the student's needs
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
Case Number: SN 1981-99 Case Year: 1999 Petitioner: MORONGO UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT Issue: Placement CDS Code: 36-67777 District: Morongo Unified Disability Type: Seriously Emotionally Disturbed
Case Details This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Twentynine Palms, California, on January 11, 12, 31, and February 1, 2000.
Petitioner Morongo Unified School District (hereinafter District or Morongo) was represented by attorney Justin Shinnefield with the law firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. Mary Stevens, director of the Morongo Special Education Local Planning Area (SELPA), was also present on the District's behalf.
No one appeared on behalf of Respondent STUDENT (hereinafter STUDENT). Respondent Morongo Basin Mental Health (hereinafter Morongo Mental Health) was represented by Dr. Bruce Karp and Sheila Folkestad from Morongo Mental Health for portions of two days. Thereafter, Morongo Mental Health expressed its understanding that it would be bound by any orders contained herein, and waived further participation in the proceedings.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: Vincent Freeland, math teacher; Charlene O'Reilly, special education teacher; John Bucko, wood shop teacher; Kim Caughlin, English teacher; Margo Recker, educational aide; Donna Powell, special education instructional assistant; Mary Stevens, SELPA director; Sheila Folkestad, mental health AB 27-26 clinic coordinator and therapist; Bruce Karp, Ph.D., director of Morongo Mental Health; Lawrence Thigpen, campus security coordinator; John Calveri, school psychologist; Heidi Lanning, special day class (SDC) teacher; Dr. Jeffrey Morse, assistant principal; and Liz Roman, principal.
Respondent STUDENT did not present oral or documentary evidence.
Dr. Bruce Karp and Sheila Folkestad provided testimony on behalf of Respondent Morongo Mental Health when called as witnesses by the District. Its mental health report was submitted into evidence by the District. Morongo Mental Health did not submit documentary evidence.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The Hearing Officer received the written closing arguments, the record was closed, and the issue was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On the first day of the hearing, neither Ms. PARENT, mother of STUDENT, nor any other representative, appeared on STUDENT's behalf. The Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) had sent Ms. PARENT written notice of the date, time, and location of the hearing on December 21, 1999. On January 3, 2000, SEHO received a letter from Ms. PARENT in which she stated that she was unable to attend the hearing scheduled for January 11 and 12, 2000. On January 4, 2000, SEHO received the District's opposition to Respondent STUDENT's motion to continue. A copy of Ms. PARENT's correspondence to the District's attorney regarding her unavailability for hearing was received by SEHO on January 5, 2000. A Hearing Officer denied the Respondent's motion on January 5, 2000, finding that good cause for a continuance had not been established. On January 6, 2000, SEHO reached Ms. PARENT by telephone and read her the minute order denying her motion to continue. SEHO explained that the hearing would go forward as scheduled, and Ms. PARENT indicated that she understood this. The minute order denying Ms. PARENT's motion was also mailed to her.
Because Ms. PARENT's preferred method of communication is email, the District emailed her on January 6, 2000, confirming that her motion had been denied and that the hearing would go forward. Ms. PARENT responded by email stating, "Like I said I can NOT be there." On January 11, 2000, at
9:28 a.m., the District emailed Ms. PARENT that the hearing would go forward that day and her presence was expected. On the morning of the hearing, the Hearing Officer requested that SEHO telephone Ms. PARENT to advise her that the hearing was scheduled to proceed at 9:30 a.m. that day. The person who answered the telephone did not identify him or herself, but stated that Ms. PARENT was not at home. The Hearing Officer then instructed SEHO to telephone the Respondent's home again and leave a message that if Ms. PARENT did not appear or contact the District office by 11:00 a.m, the hearing would proceed. Ms. PARENT did not respond by 11:00 a.m, and the Hearing Officer determined that the hearing would go forward, finding that Ms. PARENT had received multiple, clear notices of the date and time of the hearing.
On January 12, 2000, the second day of hearing, the District provided the Hearing Officer with an email message from Ms. PARENT that had been sent to the Hearing Officer via the home email address of the high school's principal. In this message, Ms. PARENT claimed that she was not attending the hearing because a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) prohibited both her and her son's presence on school property. The Hearing Officer issued a minute order finding that the TRO was applicable to STUDENT and did not prohibit Ms. PARENT's attendance at the hearing. Furthermore, the TRO prohibited STUDENT's attendance at District schools. Participation in a due process hearing was not synonymous with school attendance and the hearing was being conducted at the District's main office, not at a school site. Ms. PARENT was given until 11:00 a.m., January 12, 2000, to either appear at the hearing or contact the District offices. This order was emailed to Ms. PARENT by the Hearing Officer. Pursuant to the instructions of the Hearing Officer, SEHO immediately thereafter telephoned the Respondent's residence and spoke with an individual who identified himself as STUDENT. When he said that Ms. PARENT was sleeping, SEHO read him the minute order and obtained his acknowledgment that he was writing it down. That same day, SEHO sent the minute order to Ms. PARENT by overnight mail service. When Ms. PARENT did not appear or respond by 11:00 a.m., the second day of hearing began on January 12, 2000.
A notice that the hearing would reconvene the week beginning January 31, 2000, was sent to Ms. PARENT by SEHO on January 19, 2000. On January 31 and February 1, 2000, Ms. PARENT again did not attend the hearing. On each of these days, attempts were made to contact her by email and telephone. The starting time of the hearing was delayed both mornings to give her an opportunity to arrive or respond to the efforts to reach her. Despite these efforts, Ms. PARENT also did not participate in the third and fourth days of hearing.
Before the hearing reconvened on January 31, 2000, the District added Morongo Mental Health as a party. Morongo Mental Health raised no objection and appeared on January 31, 2000 (Footnote 1) both as a party and in response to the District's subpoena. After providing its evidence, Morongo Mental Health expressed its understanding that it could be bound by orders resulting from the hearing, but determined that it was not necessary for it to remain for the duration of the hearing.
On the last day of the hearing, the District argued that due to circumstances beyond its control, namely that it had received Morongo Mental Health's report recommending residential placement only after the hearing began and then had obtained testimony from the same agency that elaborated and changed those written recommendations, it must be allowed to amend its Statement of Issues according to the evidence presented. It requested that its amended issues be as follows: (1) a determination of an appropriate placement for STUDENT based upon all of the evidence presented at the hearing; (2) an apportionment of financial responsibility in residential care for mental health services verses educational services between the District and Morongo Mental Health; and (3) a finding of whether the District or Morongo Mental Health is the "lead agency" for STUDENT's residential placement. The District maintained that it had been prejudiced by the unavailability of the mental health report, which was delayed well beyond the statutory fifty-day time limit for its completion. The District only learned that the mental health report was complete when it called a therapist from Morongo Mental Health as a witness on the second day of the hearing. Before the hearing reconvened two weeks later, the District obtained the mental health report and immediately held an Individual Education Plan (IEP) meeting, which Ms. PARENT attended. At the IEP meeting, the District offered the residential placement recommended by Morongo Mental Health. When the hearing resumed, the testimony of the mental health experts expanded upon, clarified contents, and changed some of the recommendations contained in the mental health report.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded that at all times the District was attempting to make a placement offer consistent with STUDENT's needs. Unfortunately, it was often denied access to the information necessary to determine his needs. Initially, STUDENT was enrolled without an IEP and his mother would not authorize the District to obtain prior educational records. Ms. PARENT did not sign a record release until after the hearing began. The first educational documents from a prior school were not received by the District until January 31, 2000, the third day of hearing. Additionally, Ms. PARENT did not consent to a referral to a mental health agency until October 5, 1999. Upon Ms. PARENT's rejection of the District's offer of a nonpublic school (NPS) placement, the District filed for a due process hearing as required by California Education Code §56346(a)(2)(b). When the hearing began on January 11, 2000, the District had not yet received a report from Morongo Mental Health as required by Education Code §60045(d). As indicated above, only during the course of the due process hearing did it discover that such a report was available. As soon as it obtained the report, the District convened an IEP meeting and made a formal offer of residential placement consistent with the recommendations of Morongo Mental Health as required by Education Code §60045(a) (2)(f)(2). After extending this offer, it learned through elaborating testimony provided by the mental health therapist at the reconvened hearing that the facility recommended by Morongo Mental Health, and offered by the District, was not available, nor was it the type of facility likely to meet STUDENT's needs. The District was placed in the awkward position of attempting to formulate an appropriate placement offer for a student with a severe emotional disturbance without the benefit of information from the agency charged with determining a student's mental health needs, parental cooperation, or access to prior educational documents. The Hearing Officer concluded that amending the issues would not prejudice the other parties; therefore, the Hearing Officer granted the District's request.
ISSUE
1. What placement does STUDENT require to receive an appropriate education for the 1999-2000 school year? (Footnote 2)
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District agrees that STUDENT is eligible for special education under the criteria of severely emotionally disturbed and that he is therefore entitled to a free and appropriate education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment. However, the District contends that STUDENT's needs are too great to be accommodated on a high school campus. It is the position of the District that STUDENT requires a residential placement with a therapeutic/counseling program. It contends that STUDENT cannot receive educational benefit until his behavioral issues can be appropriately addressed.
Contentions were not presented at the hearing for Respondent STUDENT. However, Ms. PARENT did communicate with the Hearing Officer through an email. In this email, Ms. PARENT states that the District has obtained a Temporary Restraining Order against her son, caused a second, pending proceeding in another court, and filed for a due process hearing. She concluded with her contention that "[t]his whole procedure of the school district is to confuse the state and federal laws and take advantage so to NOT have to provide any services for my son until a µdecision' is made by one of three hearings that they want or until my son quits school."
Respondent Morongo Mental Health did not present any contentions at the hearing. However, it did provide testimony recommending that STUDENT be placed in a residential facility.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-and-a-half-year-old student who is eligible for special education services because of a serious emotional disturbance (SED). STUDENT moved into the Morongo School District and began attending Twentynine Palms High School in April 1999. He enrolled in school without providing the District a prior IEP or any other school records. Based upon his mother's oral representations that he was a special education student, STUDENT was placed in the high school's resource specialist program (RSP).
Following his enrollment, school personnel were confronted by multiple episodes of disciplinary and behavioral difficulties with STUDENT. His mother confirmed that STUDENT had been identified by prior school districts as seriously emotionally disturbed and consented to a multi-disciplinary psychoeducational evaluation by the District. Before the assessment was conducted, Ms. PARENT provided the school psychologist with a neuropsychological report prepared in 1995 by a clinic in another state. The testing for the District's evaluation was conducted on May 10, 1999, and an IEP meeting was convened to discuss the results on June 23, 1999. Other than the 1995 neuropsychological report submitted by Ms. PARENT, the District had been unable to obtain STUDENT's past school records or verification of any high school credits he had previously earned.
At the June 1999 IEP meeting, Ms. PARENT presented a decision from the U.S. District Court, Southern District of Indiana, Indianapolis Division entitled Metropolitan School District of Martinsville v. PARENT, 950 F. Supp. 899 (1997). Ms. PARENT also stated that she had decisions from hearing officers in Indiana pertaining to STUDENT's education and would try to find them for the IEP team's review. She did later provide various pages from the decisions. Ms. PARENT first agreed to sign a release authorizing Morongo to obtain STUDENT's Indiana school records on January 20, 2000. The complete decisions by the hearing officers were included in the partial records received from the Indiana school district by Morongo on January 31, 2000. The present Hearing Officer includes information contained in these decisions as they provide quasi-judicial "Findings of Fact" made after proceedings at which STUDENT was represented by his mother and counsel. These decisions supply reliable historical information regarding STUDENT's disability that is otherwise unavailable in the absence of either complete records from prior schools or parental testimony.
Contained in the decision from the Indiana District Court is a "Statement of Facts" which found that the Indiana School District had offered to place STUDENT in a self-contained classroom for the emotionally handicapped at an IEP meeting on September 24, 1991. Ms. PARENT objected to this placement and repeatedly challenged it before independent hearing officers, the Indiana Department of Education (IDOE), the IDOE's Board of Special Education Appeals, and the U.S. Department of Education's Office for Civil Rights. One of these requests for due process by Ms. PARENT resulted in a decision and orders issued by an Indiana Hearing Officer on July 24, 1995. The Hearing Officer found that the Indiana School District's proposed placement was generally appropriate; however, STUDENT required a behavior management program with more detail and structure to accommodate his violent behavior. On September 10, 1996, Ms. PARENT filed another request for due process alleging that the Indiana School District was not providing the services ordered by the Hearing Officer in his decision. This case was assigned to a different Hearing Officer, who issued an interim order in the case before the hearing began. Ms. PARENT notified the Indiana School District that she would not comply with any interim order issued by the Hearing Officer and removed STUDENT from school. The Indiana School District then sought enforcement of the orders issued by both Hearing Officers, a court order returning STUDENT to school, and the appointment of an educational surrogate parent for STUDENT. The Indiana District Court refused the school district's request for court enforcement of the Hearing Officers' orders regarding STUDENT's placement. The court found that it only had subject matter jurisdiction in an action brought under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) when the party bringing the action was an aggrieved party, which the school district was not.
One of the due process proceedings referenced by the Indiana District Court resulted in a decision in Case Number 592 rendered by a Hearing Officer on March 14, 1992. This decision included the following "Findings of Fact" concerning STUDENT's disabilities: (1) a school psychologist's evaluation conducted on February 1, 1991, when STUDENT was nine years old, revealed that he demonstrated behaviors typical of students identified as emotionally handicapped, and that there was mild evidence of a learning disability, (2) an independent neuropsychological report found an Attention Deficit Disorder with Hyperactivity (ADHD) as well as evidence of both a learning disability and an emotional handicap, (3) STUDENT was verbally and physically aggressive on numerous occasions and he demonstrated self-injurious behavior, (4) his behaviors had escalated in frequency and intensity over the prior year becoming so extreme that on several occasions the police were summoned, (5) he was suspended on several occasions, and (6) following one school incident which caused STUDENT's removal by the police, the Indiana Department of Welfare instituted proceedings that resulted in his hospitalization outside the school district. The Hearing Officer rendered conclusions of law finding that STUDENT's primary disability was an emotional handicap and the school district in which his mother resided was the district responsible for providing a FAPE. On May 15, 1992, the Hearing Officer issued an amended order to his decision to comply with an order issued by a county circuit court that took the ability to make educational decisions away from Ms. PARENT and gave educational authority to the County Department of Welfare or any surrogate parent appointed by the school district.
The Hearing Officer's decision of July 24, 1995 (when STUDENT was thirteen years old), which gave rise to the above cited decision by the Indiana District Court, included the following "Findings of Fact" pertaining to STUDENT: (1) he was hospitalized in December 1991 in an adolescent psychiatric unit, then placed in foster care for the remainder of his fourth grade and all of his fifth grade school year, (2) he was returned to his mother before the beginning of the sixth grade, (3) Ms. PARENT agreed with the school's recommendation that STUDENT required homebound placement, (4) a private psychologist reported that STUDENT's abilities were greater than his achievement, he showed marginal social adjustment, displayed considerable hostility toward authority figures, had ADHD (medicated with Ritalin), severe Oppositional Defiant Disorder and secondary Dysthymia, (5) he returned to middle school in the fall of seventh grade where his disruptive behaviors, name calling, vulgar outbursts, and a determination that he was a threat to himself and others led to a homebound program at an administrative building with a full-time teacher's aide, (6) Ms. PARENT refused a school behavior plan created with the input of STUDENT's private treating psychologist to slowly return him to the middle school campus, (7) a recommendation of either hospitalization or day treatment was rejected by Ms. PARENT, and (8) STUDENT's behaviors included directing vulgar and profane language toward school personnel, throwing things off his desk, leaving his classroom at will and refusing to return, taking pictures of women from the newspaper, cutting their throats and saying he had cut them like Nicole Brown's throat had been cut, and placing a staple in an apple a teacher was eating. The Hearing Officer determined that STUDENT was emotionally handicapped and required placement in a self-contained classroom with a special education teacher trained to work with SED students. He further found that STUDENT required a more detailed behavior plan.
On February 18, 1997, another decision was rendered by an Indiana Hearing Officer regarding STUDENT in case number 921-96. At that time STUDENT was fifteen years old and in the ninth grade for the 1996-97 school year. The "Findings of Fact" established that: (1) STUDENT had a duel disability caused by a learning handicap and an emotional disability, (2) the school had hired a teacher licensed to teach both the learning and emotionally disabled to provide one-on-one instruction to STUDENT, (3) a behavior plan was instituted and, except for four days of suspension for three offenses, the 1995-96 eight grade school year was fairly successful, (4) problems in the ninth grade increased and included cursing, derogatory comments and actions toward teachers, insubordination, disruptive and oppositional behaviors, and leaving his classes without permission, which resulted in multiple suspensions, and (5) the police were called to the school several times to respond to STUDENT's outbursts of yelling, screaming, punching doors, cursing, rude gestures, and verbal threats, which resulted in him being handcuffed and transported to the police station on more than one occasion. The Hearing Officer found that the school had provided a FAPE, but detailed some specific procedures to be followed when responding to STUDENT's inappropriate behaviors.
Following STUDENT's enrollment in Twentynine Palms High School, Mrs. PARENT reported to Morongo's IEP team members that her son had attended school in Indiana through a portion of the 1995-96 school year. They then moved to Tennessee where she home-schooled him for the remainder of that year, as well as for the1996-97 and1997-98 school years. She also reported that she continued his home- schooling during the 1998-99 school year until they moved to Twentynine Palms, California, and STUDENT entered the Morongo School District in April 1999. This information is inconsistent with the decisions of the Indiana Hearing Officers, which indicate that STUDENT remained in Indiana at least through February 1997, the date of the last reported hearing.
As will be discussed in greater detail below, STUDENT's behaviors at Twentynine Palms High School included the same kinds of behaviors enumerated by the Indiana Hearing Officers in their "Findings of Fact." However, his behavior difficulties had increased by the time he enrolled in the Morongo School District, and thereafter continued to escalate. STUDENT's current behaviors are described as including the following: routine use of excessive profanity; physical aggression toward the school staff and other students; defiance and a refusal to respond to any disciplinary attempts; extreme anger and out-of-control behaviors; verbalizing specific threats (that must be taken seriously according to each of the professionals who work with him); self-mutilation with pins, needles and other sharp objects; and wearing inappropriate clothing to which he attaches nails, pins, and Sheetrock screws which present a risk of harm to himself and others. The police have been called to the campus to respond to his outbursts and acts of aggression. His inappropriate behaviors also occur in his home and his community.
Within a month and a half of STUDENT's enrollment, Morongo had concluded its psychoeducational assessment and convened the first IEP meeting. The District initially offered to place STUDENT in a nonpublic school (NPS) equipped to respond to his emotional and resulting academic needs. Ms. PARENT rejected this placement stating that her son had not attended high school within the District long enough to make a determination that he required an NPS placement. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would remain at the high school for the time being, and a Behavior Modification Plan (BMP) was instituted. Ms. PARENT rejected special education and mental health services, unless STUDENT were to ask for them. Because the BIP was unsuccessful, it was modified frequently. Seven ensuing IEP meetings were held to address STUDENT's behaviors and his lack of educational progress. At an IEP meeting in December 1999, the District expressed its position that it could not accommodate STUDENT's emotional/behavioral needs, and again offered to place him in an NPS. Ms. PARENT continued to reject this offer, and the District filed for due process.
The District referred STUDENT to Respondent Morongo Mental Health as soon as Ms. PARENT agreed on October 5, 1999. After the District received the report from Morongo Mental Health (not until after the hearing in this case had begun), the District conducted an IEP meeting before the hearing reconvened. At the meeting, the District offered a residential placement at Cedar House, the recommendation made by Morongo Mental Health. Ms. PARENT attended the IEP meeting and refused the offer of residential placement. The hearing thereafter continued in this matter on the issue of the appropriate placement for STUDENT based upon the documentary and testimonial evidence presented at the hearing.
DISCUSSION
"Special education" is defined as "specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . " 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), "free and appropriate public education" means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.
As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. The term "related services" includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California's term for related services, shall be provided "when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program." Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5) (A); Education Code §56031.
Thus, a district has fulfilled its obligation to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the IDEA, and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services (1) identifies and addresses the student's unique needs through an individually designed program; (2) conforms to the IEP; (3) affords the student some educational benefit; and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.
ISSUE ONE
What placement does STUDENT require to receive an appropriate education for the 1999-2000 school year?
It is undisputed that STUDENT has qualified for special education services for many years as seriously emotionally disturbed and that this disability continues. What must first be determined when analyzing an appropriate placement are his resulting unique needs. Several high school staff members who have worked with STUDENT provided testimony describing his behaviors, the various methods used to respond to those behaviors, their fear of him, the impact his actions have had on other students, and the ways in which his behaviors have escalated. These witnesses included his teachers, instructional aides, administrators, school security, the high school principal and assistant principal.
Multiple witnesses reported that STUDENT has made general threats to damage the school and its occupants as well as specific threats directed at specified individuals. The educational and mental health witnesses were unanimous in testifying that STUDENT's threats must be taken very seriously as it is highly probable that he will attempt to carry them out. These witnesses also testified to the personal trepidation they feel as a result of STUDENT's menacing words and behaviors.
All of the District's witnesses emphasized STUDENT's pertinacious use of vulgar language and gestures. Although the witnesses provided direct quotes from STUDENT to convey his language, the Hearing Officer does not find it necessary to repeat his words. Instead, the Hearing Officer will summarize the examples given by stating that STUDENT was reported to use sexually explicit, excremental, and socially unacceptable words. The District high school staff emphasized that STUDENT typically would not utter a single sentence that did not contain obscene language. It was estimated that 60% of his profanity was directed at specific individuals and 40% was general language usage. Most frequently, STUDENT addressed this language toward the adult staff, although there were certain groups of students to whom he also spoke in this manner. There was consistent testimony among the witnesses that any attempt to discipline STUDENT for his use of inappropriate language would result in his "blowing up" and responding with even more vulgar language and aggressive behaviors. Examples were also given of STUDENT's frequent use of obscene gestures. These included, but were not limited to, such things as using his hand to simulate masturbation (he would also make this gesture using a coke bottle), "mooning" and "giving others the finger." Female students reported that STUDENT made upsetting sexual remarks to them. He also used derogatory names to address the female staff and once placed posters he had made around the campus stating that a certain female teacher performed a particular sex act.
Testimony established that STUDENT wore inappropriate clothing with items attached that created a risk of harm to both himself and others. His hair was styled in a spiked Mohawk that he painted a variety of different colors. He wore torn clothing and would continue to rip his clothes during the school day. He wore a cape and black lipstick. STUDENT attached safety pins to his clothes (at one count there were 52 pins), and he sometimes stuck them into himself. A teacher found him using a needle and thread from a sewing kit kept in a life skill's class to sew a zigzag pattern down his forefinger and up his thumb. He sometimes came to school with a safety pin through his eyebrow. STUDENT wore neck and arm chains and rings on each finger. The rings were linked to each other with chains. He physically restrained other students until they would comply with his demand that they "punch knuckles"with his rings (strike their knuckles against his rings/chains). STUDENT wore leather wrist bands studded with nails and sheetrock screws. He also inserted approximately twenty, three and one-half inch drywall screws through the soles of his work boots. School staff testified that all attempts to curtail STUDENT's dress code violations were unsuccessful. For example, if they managed to get him to remove all of the safety pins, he would take them off, throw them to the ground and refuse to pick them up.
Both the psychologists and the educators testified to STUDENT's defiance of authority. Each witness characterized his behavior as the most severe case of hostility toward authority figures that they had encountered throughout their years of working with children. The testimony established that no one could control STUDENT's actions. He refused to comply with rules or directions, all forms of discipline were ineffective, and he flaunted the fact that no one could effectively respond to his conduct. Multiple behavior interventions were attempted. However, without exception, they each failed. STUDENT refused to remain in his classrooms, stay seated when he was in class, participate in class, or complete homework. The District witnesses testified that, as a consequence, he received no educational benefit from school.
School personnel also testified to multiple episodes of physical violence and aggression. STUDENT's rage would erupt if any attempt were made to discipline him. His face would turn red, he would clench his fists, get an unusual look in his eyes, flail his arms, assume a threatening posture, position himself within an inch of the disciplinarian, use profanity, and often threaten the individual. STUDENT would also slam and kick doors, throw things, and lift chairs over his head and then fling them to the ground when he became upset. When being escorted from a classroom, he once began yelling, cursing and slamming his guitar onto the walkway. He would throw his book bag. He threw and broke the Dreamwriter computer furnished by the school. In his wood shop class, STUDENT kicked and threw things, thereby creating a risk of harm to the teacher and the other students. The police were called after STUDENT struck the campus security coordinator in the eye with an object. He hit the campus security coordinator with small rocks. He purposefully and repeatedly threw a ball at a group of disabled students. He defaced school property with profanity. While being driven home by staff following suspensions (Footnote 3), STUDENT would scream, refuse to wear a seatbelt, open the car door while it was moving, and threaten to jump out. He entered unassigned classrooms yelling, acting out, and using foul language when he was upset. He "crashed" against campus windows while screaming profanities. STUDENT also engaged in self-mutilation. As mentioned above, he sewed his fingers and put safety pins through his eyebrow. He also would staple his fingers, use sharp instruments to dig into his skin, and self-tatoo. The witnesses agreed that STUDENT's self-infliction of harm was not indicative of self-loathing, but rather, done for "shock value" and to show his ability to withstand pain. The educators and mental health witnesses all testified that the violent nature of STUDENT's behaviors was rapidly escalating.
STUDENT frequently made threats of violence. He has told individual school personnel that their "day is coming." He writes about rape, drugs, and incest. He has stated, "I don't like it here [school], no one can make me do anything, I just want to blow everyone here away." He has threatened a particular group of students and their church. Later, the church pastor had to call the police when STUDENT entered church property in a threatening manner during a youth group. While angry with one witness, STUDENT located her office, entered it, and said in a menacing way, "now I know where your office is." The witness believed that this was a threat of harm and she remained anxious about her safety for a substantial period of time following the event. On one occasion, the high school was evacuated because of a bomb threat. An object was found that appeared to be a pipe bomb, but was later determined not to be an explosive. During the evacuation, STUDENT told a staff member about all of the pipes he had at his home. A teacher told of how STUDENT entered her room in a fit of rage yelling about bringing a knife to school so he would be expelled.
Of particular concern to the high school staff, students, parents, community, and mental health professionals were STUDENT's repeated references to the Columbine High School shootings. One witness testified that on the day of the Colorado shootings, STUDENT was in the school office. He started talking in depth about his admiration for the murderers because "they had the courage of their convictions." This witness testified that STUDENT was absolutely serious in his comments. STUDENT later repeated these remarks to another staff member. When that person responded with "but STUDENT, those people killed," STUDENT told him: "exactly, that's my point." Another witness told how STUDENT entered her class (to which he was not assigned) and began talking about how much he admired what the Columbine shooters had done. Other witnesses testified to similar remarks by STUDENT. An explicit threat in this vein was made on an occasion when STUDENT was being escorted off campus for disciplinary reasons. STUDENT was reported by witnesses to have said, "I hate this f²school, I hate the f²teachers. I wish I could blow it up. On Monday, I'm coming to this f² school with a gun and blow everyone's head off." His demeanor was depicted as angry and out of control; his arms were flailing, his face was flushed, and he was yelling and using profanity. This specific threat precipitated the TRO.
STUDENT told several people that he had kicked a dog in the head until it died. This incident was corroborated by school personnel in another district. Ms. PARENT revealed to multiple witnesses that she had placed several telephone calls to the police because STUDENT was destroying their home while enraged. She further disclosed her fears for her personal safety and stated that she had left their home to escape her son. All of the District personnel testified that they are afraid for the safety of the students, other staff members, and themselves. They believe that STUDENT intends to carry out his threats. Each witness discussed the way in which his threats of violence have escalated. He began with general threats, but they became increasingly specific until they contained "who, what, how, and when." The educators testified that they had been taught that a suicide or homicide threat is usually real when it is specific as to time, place, victim, and method. The mental health experts testified that they viewed STUDENT's threats as specific enough to require warnings pursuant to the case of Tarosoff v. The Regents of The University of California, 17 Cal3d 425 (1976), which imposes a duty upon a therapist to notify intended victims of specific threats to their safety made during otherwise privileged counseling sessions.
The District's teachers and administrators testified that as a result of the above-described behaviors, STUDENT requires the most restrictive setting, a highly structured program, and a very small class size. The program must provide consistent monitoring of STUDENT, anger management counseling, therapy, and living and social skills training. Because STUDENT will not comply with any academic requirements, they further testified that his behavioral needs must be addressed before he can gain academic benefit. STUDENT refuses to remain in an assigned classroom on the high school campus. He has made it clear to multiple people that he will not stay in a residential facility. Several people also testified that they heard him threaten his mother that she better not agree to residential placement. Consequently, the District's staff believes that he would elope and that he requires a secure facility where his "environment can be physically imposed upon him" to benefit from his education.
STUDENT was diagnosed with a severe conduct disorder by Morongo Mental Health. However, if he were six months older, his diagnosis would be an antisocial (formerly termed a sociopath) personality. (Footnote 4) It was determined that his disorder was of long duration, pervasive, and that it adversely affected his social and academic performance. Because he freely boasted of drug use, a secondary diagnosis of drug dependency was made. The testimony was that STUDENT "is out of control." He was found by Morongo Mental Health to have deviant behaviors, no empathy, and no remorse. Thus, he possessed the "behavior criteria to meet the population of those who would grow up to kill unless there is some intervention." The therapists further concluded that "STUDENT gives the appearance of danger, and he is dangerous. If STUDENT said he was going to do a Columbine, believe him. He fits in the category of people who would do something like that." On a scale of one to ten, with ten being the most dangerous, the therapist stated that STUDENT is the "highest you could go." The therapists also testified that STUDENT "initiates violence." His violence is not in response to provocation and it is completely volitional behavior.
Morongo Mental Health professionals concluded that STUDENT's mental health needs are too great to be addressed through outpatient therapy. They testified that it is imperative for STUDENT to be in a secure residential facility to provide the "optimal or maximum amount of control in his environment with increased individual attention." His placement should be in a duel diagnosis facility that can address both his addictions and his mental health problems. Both therapists testified that it would be best for STUDENT to be placed in a locked facility where he must participate in group and individual counseling. They also recommended that he receive training in anger management, social skills, and impulse control, as well as therapy to enhance his self-esteem. However, the psychologists had no information regarding the availability of such facilities or their authority to recommend placement therein. They had not investigated such placement because Ms. PARENT maintained that she would not agree to residential care.
The mental health therapist who conducted STUDENT's evaluation testified that, initially, Ms.
PARENT sought information concerning residential care for her son. However, after a confrontation with STUDENT, she was described as fearful and refused further discussion of residential placement. Ms. PARENT reported to the evaluating therapist that STUDENT had threatened to destroy her home if she agreed to out-of-home placement. The psychologists also testified that, generally, they first attempt placement in a less restrictive facility, and then move the person to a more restrictive facility only if the prior placement fails. However, they acknowledged that there are exceptions to this if circumstances so warrant. In this case, STUDENT is extremely dangerous to others, he is not amenable to treatment, he defies authority, he will not remain in an assigned classroom, participate in his education, or voluntarily engage in therapy. When asked their opinion of whether STUDENT would remain in an unlocked residential facility, the therapists testified that STUDENT was a "ten for risk of danger and severity of flight." It was the further opinion of the mental health experts that STUDENT requires residential care to provide him with a consistent environment, which he is not getting at home. The psychologists concur that it is first necessary to deal with STUDENT's behaviors before he can benefit educationally.
The Hearing Officer is aware of California Code of Regulations, Title 5 C.C.R. §7576(a), which provides that "a local education agency shall not be required to place a pupil in a more restrictive environment in order for the pupil to receive the mental health services specified in the pupil's individualized education program if the mental health services can be appropriately provided in a less restrictive setting." The Hearing Officer has also considered the requirements for least restrictive environment as defined in the case of Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp.879 (1992); adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (1994). Holland necessitates an evaluation of the academic and nonacademic benefits to the disabled student from mainstreaming, as well consideration of the cost and the disabled student's effect on the regular education students.
STUDENT does not have positive relationships with classmates and his behavior is not positively influenced by association with nondisabled peers. His social interactions are poor and the other students are frequently frightened and confused by his verbal threats and physical aggression. He intimidates others, will initiate fights with adults and peers, and is physically cruel to others. STUDENT has endangered the physical safety of both disabled and nondisabled students on campus. Contrary to modeling the appropriate behaviors of his nondisabled peers, STUDENT instead manipulates younger students. As a result, he receives little or no nonacademic benefit from social interaction with nondisabled students and has an extremely negative impact on the other students. Providing STUDENT with an individual aide to respond to his behaviors pursuant to C.C.R. Title 2 §60100(c) would not be practical or beneficial. All evidence indicates that STUDENT seeks confrontation with authority figures and will not respond to their directions. It is difficult to imagine how an individual aide could exert any control over STUDENT's behavior. Moreover, legitimate concerns would exist for the safety of any shadow aide assigned to monitor STUDENT. School witnesses testified that as a direct result of his emotional disability, STUDENT received no educational benefit while he attended Twentynine Palms High School. STUDENT usually refused to attend or remain in class. When he did attend, he was loud, vulgar and disruptive. He would not perform his class work or homework. He refused to take tests. Consequently, he was receiving failing grades in most of his classes. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT's needs cannot be met in any type of mainstream environment.
Based upon the above, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT suffers from a severe emotional disturbance that requires residential placement in a secure facility. All of the evidence establishes that STUDENT desperately needs mental health treatment and will not voluntarily remain in an unlocked residential facility. STUDENT is six months away from his eighteenth birthday. Only a brief opportunity exists to provide treatment in a placement where he is required to remain and participate in addressing his inappropriate behaviors. The description of STUDENT's rages, out of control behaviors, physical aggression, and specific threats to inflict great bodily harm to others is particularly alarming. His conduct has created justifiable fear in the school staff, student body, parents and community. The testimony of the mental health experts greatly increases concerns, as it confirms that STUDENT is psychologically capable of fulfilling his threats.
STUDENT requires residential placement to protect himself from his inability to control his own actions and to minimize the danger he presents to others. Additionally, STUDENT has unique needs for group and individual therapy in a highly structured residential environment where rules and consistency can be imposed upon him. He further requires assistance with anger management, impulsivity, acquiring appropriate responses to authority, and social interactions. The residential facility should also be equipped to address any drug dependency problems STUDENT may have. Hearsay references to Attention Deficit Disorder (ADD) were contained in the documentary evidence. Although the evidence was insufficient to establish the existence of this condition, upon admission to a residential facility STUDENT should receive a medical evaluation for ADD as well as any psychiatric disorders that may be present. Although it is clear that STUDENT's emotional needs demand primary attention, he will also require an educational program directed toward acquiring high school credits for graduation. His academics should be provided in classes with a low student-to-teacher ratio so that individual attention is readily available.
Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT can only receive educational benefit in a locked residential facility where he can be mandated to physically participate in his education and therapy. This is the least restrictive environment to meet his needs.
CONCLUSION
STUDENT requires residential care to meet the unique needs created by his severe emotional disability. Such placement is the least restrictive environment that can provide him with the structure he requires to benefit from mental health and educational services. STUDENT further requires placement in a locked facility to prevent elopement and to protect him from harming himself or others. The District and Morongo Mental Health must immediately arrange to place STUDENT in such a locked facility and take all necessary steps to ensure that he is so placed.
The Hearing Officer is aware that Ms. PARENT has refused to consent to her son's placement in a residential facility. Notwithstanding this position, there was also credible testimony that Ms. PARENT loves her son very much and, at times, has expressed an awareness that he needs residential treatment. She has periodically sought information regarding such placement. The Hearing Officer further understands from the evidence presented that Ms. PARENT may be legitimately afraid of STUDENT's reaction if she were to agree to residential care. However, it is highly probable that either STUDENT or someone else will suffer harm. Moreover, STUDENT will be eighteen in six months. At that time, absent court action, he will legally be an adult and Ms. PARENT's last opportunity to provide her son with beneficial treatment will vanish. In the event that Ms. PARENT is frightened of the consequences of placing STUDENT in a residential facility, the IEP team should advise Ms. PARENT of the methods available to safely transport STUDENT to a residential treatment facility.
ORDER
1. STUDENT requires placement in a locked residential facility to accommodate his unique needs for mental health and educational services. An expanded IEP team meeting shall be convened within five days of the date of this order to identify an appropriate locked residential placement in compliance with C.C.R. Title 2 §60100 and all other statutes pertaining to placement of a disabled child in a residential treatment program. The District and Morongo Mental Health shall take all appropriate steps to promptly place STUDENT in the identified locked facility. The locked residential facility shall be equipped to provide a highly structured environment with group and individual therapy, as well as any substance abuse treatment STUDENT may require. Additionally, the facility must provide an academic program with small class sizes that is designed to comply with the State's requirements for high school graduation.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement:
The District prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision pursuant to Education Code §56505(i).
____________________ _________________________________________ Date GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law
Footnotes 1. At the request of the Hearing Officer and the District, Morongo Mental Health also returned to provide additional testimony on February 1, 2000. 2. The District offered the following additional issues: (1) If STUDENT requires residential placement, how shall the cost of that placement be apportioned between the District and Morongo Mental Health, and (2) Is Morongo Mental Health or the District the "lead agency" for responding to STUDENT's placement needs? These are not appropriate issues for a due process hearing. However, the Hearing Officer cites the parties to C.C.R. Title 2 §60200(c)(d) and California Education Code §60110. 3. STUDENT's mother did not have transportation, so the District agreed to transport STUDENT home when he had to leave school. 4. STUDENT is presently seventeen years, six months of age. A diagnosis of anti-social disorder cannot technically be made until the age of eighteen.
