California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 21, 2000
Student v. Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 1996-99 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Panama-Buena Vista Union School District denied FAPE for 1999-2000 and must reimburse the parent's private after-school program costs.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The student's attorney and Panama-Buena Vista Union School District each filed for due process, and the cases were heard together. The student was a 10-year-old boy eligible for special education based on autistic-like behavior, mental retardation, and a speech and language disorder. He was nonverbal, not toilet-trained, and often ran away from staff. In March 1999, his mother removed him from a Bakersfield City School District autism class over safety concerns. The District offered a Kern County Superintendent of Schools autism class at Buena Vista School, but he never attended.
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a FAPE for the summer 1999 ESY session. It held the June 17, 1999 IEP meeting without the mother, even though she had called to say she could not attend that date. The meeting date had never been mutually agreed. The 1999 IEPs had other problems. The April IEP had no aide or safety changes. The June IEP did not state how much occupational therapy the student would get. The proposed teacher lacked the required credential. Relying on psychologist Jay Fisher, the Hearing Officer found many goals unrealistic for the student and found no evidence that the TEACCH-based program would benefit him. These flaws carried into the September 1999 IEP for 1999-2000. The classroom was not made safe until November 10, 1999. The District must reimburse the mother's actual costs for Valley Achievement Center's after-school program. It must also hold IEP meetings on reassessment and a 2000-2001 program.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated an IEP meeting held without a parent who had asked to reschedule as a denial of FAPE. It also shows that a parent who was never told about the notice requirement could still get reimbursed. A part-day private program could qualify as appropriate if it addressed the child's core needs.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 1a. Did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE during the summer 1999 extended school year (ESY) session?
The District denied a FAPE. It held the June 17, 1999 IEP meeting without the parent and without a mutually agreed date, which seriously infringed on her participation. The April and June 1999 IEPs also had inappropriate goals, no aide or safety changes (April), no stated OT amount (June), an uncredentialed proposed teacher, and an unproven TEACCH program.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 1b. Did the District provide Petitioner a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session?
The District denied a FAPE. The June and September 1999 IEPs kept unrealistic goals, and the TEACCH-based program was not shown to be reasonably calculated to provide benefit. The Buena Vista site was not reasonably safe until November 10, 1999, and the proposed teacher lacked a credential until November 1999.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the summer 1999 ESY session and the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, is he entitled to compensatory education?
The parent's lack of 10-day notice did not bar reimbursement because no evidence showed she was told about the notice requirement. The Valley Achievement Center after-school program was appropriate, so the parent gets her actual costs through the 2000 ESY session.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days, Petitioner submits proof of the parent's actual tuition costs for the Valley Achievement Center after-school program from enrollment in early 2000 through the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session. The District must reimburse within 25 calendar days of receiving proof. Reimbursement is limited to actual costs the parent incurred; the program was reported to be funded by Kern Regional Center.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to consider triennial reassessment needs and, if necessary, present a reassessment plan. If no reassessment is needed, within 15 calendar days of that meeting the District must determine current levels of functioning and convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and an appropriate placement, program and services for 2000-2001.
- Order to assess. If reassessment is necessary, the District must complete it, including current levels of functioning, within 25 calendar days of receiving parent consent. It must then convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and determine placement, program and services for 2000-2001.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Burlington; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ.; Warren G. v. Cumberland Cy. School Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith
People named in the decision
- Janis Spinozzi, District director of special education, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
- David Onsum, Ph.D., District director of special services, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
- Connie Bradley, secretary to director of special services, Panama-Buena Vista Union School District
- Wanda Hall, director of special education, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Jay Fisher, Ph.D., clinical psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Jennie Claus, service coordinator specialist, Kern Regional Center
- Bonny Hulsy, nurse consultant, Kern Regional Center
- Jean Calvillo, service coordinator specialist, Kern Regional Center
- Louis Lopez, director of administrative services; safety witness for Student, New Advances for People with Disabilities
- Gerald Lavarias, afternoon program director, Valley Achievement Center (nonpublic school)
- Robert Pendergrass, instructional aide, Valley Achievement Center (nonpublic school)
- Jolene Billinger, director, Valley Achievement Center (nonpublic school)
- Valley Achievement Center, nonpublic school (after-school program)
- Byron Lewis, adaptive physical education specialist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Adam Bluestone, special education teacher (former SDC teacher), Bakersfield City School District, Cesar Chavez School
- Angela Bluestone, teacher, extended school day/after-school program, Bakersfield City School District, Cesar Chavez School
- Mike Doolittle, safety and loss control; safety witness for District, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Elizabeth Haber, occupational therapist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Elizabeth Zastrow, autism specialist and TEACCH trainer
- Danielle Bresee, program specialist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Stacy Quint, Psy.D., psychologist (behavioral assessment and program recommendations), KCSOS; Porterville Developmental Center at time of hearing
- Sandra (Sandy) McMahan, M.A., speech and language pathologist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Robert Hefner, special education teacher (proposed SDC teacher), Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools, Buena Vista School
- Marcie Gladson, observer at hearing, Office of Clients' Rights Advocacy
- Valerie Geary, assistant to Student's attorney
- Bonnie Diebel, speech and language specialist, Bakersfield City School District
- Johnny Ruth King, school psychologist, Bakersfield City School District
- Anthony Coe, school psychologist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Cathy Newquist, M.S., speech and language specialist, Bakersfield City School District
- Phyllis Hix, O.T.R., occupational therapist, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools
- Nick Bordagary (also spelled Bordagaray), special day class teacher, Bakersfield City School District, Cesar Chavez School
- Mike Thompson, special education director, Bakersfield City School District
- John Watson, Ph.D., author of letter regarding Valley Achievement Center director's program visits
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law, in Bakersfield, California, on April 26, 27, 28, May 16, 25, 26, June 20, 21, 22, and 23, 2000.
Student STUDENT (Petitioner)(Footnote 1) was present for the first half hour of the hearing. He was represented by attorney Donnalee Huffman. Also present on STUDENT'S behalf was his mother, PARENT. Valerie Geary, the attorney's assistant, was present on various days, and Marcie Gladson of the Office of Clients' Rights Advocacy was present on April 26, 2000. Respondent Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (hereinafter District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Stacy Inman. Also present on the District's behalf were Janis Spinozzi, District director of special education, and, on April 26, 2000, David Onsum, Ph.D., District director of special services. Wanda Hall, director of special education, Office of Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS), was present on behalf of KCSOS.(Footnote 2) Petitioner requested an open hearing, and several members of the public observed the hearing on certain days.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify: PARENT, STUDENT'S mother; Jay Fisher, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; Jennie Claus, service coordinator specialist, Kern Regional Center (KRC); Bonny Hulsy, KRC nurse consultant; Jean Calvillo, KRC service coordinator specialist; Louis Lopez, director of administrative services, New Advances for People with Disabilities; Gerald Lavarias, afternoon program director, Valley Achievement Center (VAC); Robert Pendergrass, VAC instructional aide; and Jolene Billinger, director, VAC. Respondent called the following witnesses to testify: PARENT, STUDENT'S mother; Jolene Billinger, director, VAC; Janis Spinozzi, District director of special education; David Onsum, Ph.D., District director of special services; Connie Bradley, Dr. Onsum's secretary; Wanda Hall, KCSOS director of special education; Byron Lewis, KCSOS adaptive physical education specialist; Adam Bluestone, special education teacher, Bakersfield City School District (BCSD); Angela Bluestone, BCSD teacher; Mike Doolittle of KCSOS safety and loss control unit; Elizabeth Haber, KCSOS occupational therapist; Elizabeth Zastrow, autism specialist; Danielle Bresee, KCSOS program specialist; Stacy Quint, Psy.D., psychologist, Porterville Developmental Center; Sandy McMahan, M.A., KCSOS speech and language specialist; and Robert Hefner, KCSOS special education teacher.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On April 26, 2000, Petitioner's attorney requested that the Hearing Officer make an on-site visit to the Buena Vista School to view possible safety issues. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505.1(c). The attorney also requested that Petitioner's proposed witness Louis Lopez be permitted to visit the site. The Hearing Officer agreed to visit the site and to permit both parties' safety witnesses, Mr. Lopez and Mr. Doolittle, to visit the site at the same time. On April 27, 2000, the Hearing Officer visited the Buena Vista site accompanied by the attorneys for both parties, the safety witnesses, the parent, and Wanda Hall, KCSOS special education director. The Hearing Officer had previously directed that no one should speak to her of any substantive matters during the site visit but that the parent could point to areas of concern. The site visit was carried out pursuant to the Hearing Officer's instructions.
On April 28, 2000, the attorney for the District moved to permit telephone testimony by witnesses Dr. Stacy Quint and Liz Zastrow. The only concern of Petitioner's attorney was that Dr. Quint have before her the necessary exhibits related to her testimony by telephone. The attorney for the District agreed to send to both witnesses the exhibits requested by Petitioner's attorney and any other necessary exhibits, and the matter was thereby resolved.(Footnote 3)
Also on April 28, 2000, the parent indicated that she wanted an open hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56501(c)(2); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(f). Petitioner's attorney requested that Jolene Billinger and Theresa Farmer be permitted to observe the hearing. The attorney for the District, Ms. Inman, objected to the observers' presence on the ground that Ms. Billinger, the alleged owner of Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a nonpublic school which STUDENT'S parent had requested as his placement, and Ms. Farmer, the parent of a VAC student, might be called as witnesses on the continued hearing dates. Petitioner's attorney, Ms. Huffman, responded that Ms. Billinger had received a letter from Ms. Inman stating that Ms. Billinger could not be subpoenaed to testify at a due process hearing because she had been permitted to visit Kern County programs for autistic children within the District and had been informed beforehand that she could not use in such a hearing the information gained from her visit. Moreover, Ms. Huffman argued that Ms. Farmer should be permitted to observe as a member of the public. Ms. Inman replied that the March 13, 2000 letter to which Ms. Huffman referred was not from her but from Dr. John Watson, and there was no indication that he was a lawyer or otherwise had any legal background. She stated, moreover, that she intended to call Ms. Billinger as a witness for the District. The Hearing Officer determined that Ms. Billinger's testimony would be relevant to the issues in the case. Since the District intended to call Ms. Billinger as a witness and the parties had agreed to sequester witnesses prior to their testimony, Petitioner's attorney agreed that Ms. Billinger should not be permitted to observe during other witnesses' testimony. In response to Ms. Huffman's inquiry, the Hearing Officer stated that by calling Ms. Billinger as a witness, the District had waived any objection to her testifying at a due process hearing. Ms. Huffman then stated that Petitioner might also call Ms. Billinger as a witness. The Hearing Officer deferred any ruling related to Ms. Farmer because she had not yet arrived. Ms. Farmer did not come to the hearing, and no ruling was made related to her.
ISSUES(Footnote 4)
1. Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the following periods: a. During the summer 1999 extended school year (ESY) session?
b. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session?
2. If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the summer 1999 ESY session of the 1998-1999 school year and during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, is he entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a ten-year-old boy who has been found eligible for special education as having a speech and language disorder, autistic behavior, and mental retardation. He has been diagnosed with autism. He is nonverbal and has no pointing response. He has a significant sensory integration problem, is hyperactive and highly distractible, and exhibits self-stimulatory behavior. He is noncompliant, engages in self-injurious behavior, and displays aggression toward others. He has elopement and safety issues. He is unable to dress himself and is not toilet-trained. He also suffers from recurrent ear infections. He has taken Clonidine to help control his behavior and at the time of the hearing was taking Clonidine, Benadryl and another medication, in addition to antibiotics for yeast infections. He currently resides in the Panama-Buena Vista Union School District (District) and, until removed by his parent, attended school in the Bakersfield City School District (BCSD). His parent placed him in the after school program at Valley Achievement Center (VAC), a nonpublic school, which he currently attends.
In October 1992 when STUDENT was age 2 years, 4 months, he was referred for a special education assessment because of a lack of speech. A December 1992 educational report prepared by the BCSD found that STUDENT qualified for services in the Infant Development Program because of significant delays in language and fine motor skills. He was enrolled in the program at Rafer Johnson School (Rafer Johnson) in the BCSD. According to STUDENT'S mother, he remained an additional year in the Infant Development Program because he did not show much progress.
In a January 1994 assessment, BCSD speech and language specialist Bonnie Diebel found deficits in STUDENT'S receptive and expressive language and concluded that he was eligible for special education as having a speech and language disorder. She recommended consultation by a speech and language specialist with the classroom teacher and parent to assist in developing the prerequisites necessary for speech and language therapy. In a January 1994 psycho-educational assessment when STUDENT was age 3.5, BCSD school psychologist Johnny Ruth King found him eligible for special education based upon a speech and language disorder, autistic-like behavior, and mental retardation. Ms. King recommended a primary focus on developing language and social interaction skills, with other goals to increase his compliance, decrease his distractibility, increase his ability to focus his attention, and increase his awareness of safety issues.
A March 7, 1997 Individualized Education Program (IEP), prepared by BCSD, states that STUDENT'S primary handicap was mental retardation. At the time, he was in a special day class (SDC) for severely handicapped (SH) children at Rafer Johnson in the BCSD. The IEP contains proposed goals and objectives in the areas of self-help, gross motor, fine motor, and communication skills and cognitive development. It also states that STUDENT was using the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) beginning at Level 1. In spring 1997, STUDENT'S family moved into the District, and the IEP mentions a referral to the Kern County Superintendent of Schools (KCSOS) for a multidisciplinary team assessment. In late March 1997, BCSD referred STUDENT to the KCSOS for placement. (According to David Onsum, Ph.D., District director of special services, KCSOS and the District belong to the Kern Consortium SELPA (i.e., special education local plan area), whereas the BCSD is its own separate SELPA.)
A May 16, 1997 report by KCSOS psychologist Anthony Coe sets forth the psychological assessment results when STUDENT was age 6 years, 10 months, and still attending Rafer Johnson within the BCSD. The assessment was based upon classroom observation, parent and teacher interview, review of prior psycho-educational data, and administration of testing instruments. A standardized cognitive test could not be administered because, according to his parent and teacher, STUDENT is nonverbal, has no pointing response, and is unable to make controlled pencil-paper strokes or do form board assemblies.(Footnote 5) On the Adaptive Behavior Inventory Academic Skills assessment, completed by his teacher, STUDENT'S scaled scores and 60 quotient, at the .4 age percentile, fell well below average to significantly below average.
On the Woodcock-Johnson Scales of Independent Behavior-Revised, which measured STUDENT'S adaptive behavior based upon his mother's responses, his full-scale Broad Independence age-level score was 1 year, 5 months, at the <.1 percentile, and significantly below average. STUDENT'S General Maladaptive Index was found to be very serious. The parent identified these areas for primary training objectives with respect to adaptive behavior: develop communication skills; interact with others without aggressiveness; stop wandering away; and recognize dangerous situations to avoid them. Problem behaviors of serious concern to the parent were as follows: banging his head; pulling other persons' hair; throwing objects; yelling and screaming; eating objects or putting them in his mouth; threatening to scratch or pull at others; and having little interaction with others' activities. STUDENT was assessed for autism using the Autism Behavior Checklist-2 and Gilliam Autism Rating Scale, completed by the mother and teacher. The parent also answered questions related to the autism criteria from the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM-IV) Mr. Coe concluded that STUDENT met the special education eligibility criteria for autistic-like behavior. He recommended that goals and objectives include consideration of STUDENT'S needs in the areas of developing communication, reducing aggressiveness, being compliant to verbal requests, and not wandering away.
A May 23, 1997 KCSOS IEP prepared when STUDENT was age 6 years, 11 months, and in kindergarten, states that his qualifying disability was autism. It recommended placement in a KCSOS SDC for autistic children beginning in May 1997, with transportation and an ESY program. The IEP states that the parent would visit the proposed class, the assessment would be completed, and the IEP team would reconvene in July. The assessment was not completed and the IEP team did not reconvene again that year. On July 18, 1997, an inter-SELPA placement(Footnote 6) was approved for STUDENT to continue with the BCSD grade 1 SH autistic SDC during the 1997-1998 school year. In August 1997, STUDENT was enrolled at Cesar Chavez School (Cesar Chavez) in the BCSD.
In April 1998, STUDENT was assessed by BCSD speech and language specialist Cathy Newquist, M.S., when he was age 7 years, 10 months, and in a grade 3 SH autism SDC at Cesar Chavez in the BCSD. The assessment results revealed speech and language skills in the 6- to 9-month range. He was reinforced on a one-to-one schedule using food, hugs, and verbal praise. Ms. Newquist found that STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education as having a speech and language disorder. She recommended no direct individual speech and language services until he had a specified repertoire of gross motor, object-motor, fine motor, and vocal imitations. She recommended weekly 15-minute consultations to classroom staff to review STUDENT'S progress in achieving the prerequisite repertoire of imitative behavior. She recommended at least 5 to 10 minutes per day of individual in-class work toward achieving the imitative behavior provided by a minimum of three different staff members each week. Ms. Newquist further recommended that an expert in speech and language development in autistic children consult at least once a month with the site speech and language specialist to review STUDENT'S progress, address areas of difficulty, and develop new goals.
A May 12, 1998 BCSD IEP was developed when STUDENT was in Adam Bluestone's grade 2 SDC for autistic children at Cesar Chavez in the BCSD. The IEP provides for 15 minutes of speech and language consultation weekly, a nurse's services, regular physical education (P.E.), and an ESY program. His program included PECS, discrete trial training (DTT), the TEACCH(Footnote 7) program, community-based instruction, medication, and reverse mainstreaming for 30 minutes daily. Proposed goals and objectives are set forth in the areas of improving behavior, improving performance in the DTT and TEACCH programs and with PECS, improving community-based instruction skills, and broadening vocational and domestic skills.
A November 23, 1998 IEP, prepared by the District but not signed by any persons in attendance,(Footnote 8) states that the purpose of the IEP meeting was to address inter-SELPA placement. Although STUDENT resided within the District, he was still attending Cesar Chavez in the BCSD, and the IEP proposed to continue that placement at the mother's request. An IEP Addendum states that as part of the triennial assessment initiated in April 1997 but not yet completed, a new assessment plan was presented to the parent for occupational therapy (OT), adaptive physical education (APE), functional analysis, and new speech and language assessments by the Kern Consortium SELPA. The IEP sets forth proposed goals and objectives related to running away, self-injurious behavior, DTT, receptive language skills, matching skills, independence in the classroom, domestic skills, community safety skills, PECS skills, and vocational skills. The next anticipated IEP meeting was to be held within 50 days of receipt of the parent's consent to the proposed assessment plan, i.e., approximately February 1, 1999.
A January 13, 1999 behavioral assessment and intervention plan report was prepared by KCSOS psychologist Stacy Quint, Psy.D., when STUDENT was age 8 and in Mr. Bluestone's class at Cesar Chavez in the BCSD. The parent had requested the assessment and plan for school and home. Dr. Quint observed STUDENTat school and talked with Mr. Bluestone and Angela Bluestone, the teacher of the after school program at Cesar Chavez that STUDENT also attended. The report addressed three problems: eloping (running away from staff and trying to leave the playground area); removing clothing, specifically, his shoes or pants; and engaging in self-stimulatory behavior (tapping objects, clapping, running, and jumping). The proposed intervention plan set forth specific procedures for the staff to follow when any of the targeted behavior occurred. The entire intervention plan would be subject to change as the data collection on the frequency of the behavior indicated.
On January 13, 1999, KCSOS APE specialist Byron Lewis conducted an assessment of STUDENT at Cesar Chavez. Mr. Lewis used the Ulrich Test of Gross Motor Development, which targets seven locomotor and five object-control skills. STUDENT did not willingly participate in displaying the performance criteria. However, he was observed in informal play to demonstrate the skills of running, leaping, and horizontal jumping and also the skills of throwing and kicking a ball. Mr. Lewis concluded that STUDENT exhibited no motor delays and that although normally APE services would not be recommended, continued progression of motor skills and emphasis on peer modeling could enhance his motor development. Therefore, he recommended APE consultation services every other week with the classroom teacher.
After Nick Bordagary replaced Mr. Bluestone as STUDENT'S SDC teacher at Cesar Chavez, STUDENT continued attending an extended school day program at Cesar Chavez taught by Angela Bluestone. He attended this program for part of the spring 1999 semester, up through approximately May 1999.
On February 10, 1999, KCSOS occupational therapist Phyllis Hix, O.T.R., conducted an assessment of STUDENT when he was in Mr. Bordagaray's autism SDC at Cesar Chavez. The referral was based upon a sensory integration concern. The assessment was based upon observation at school, teacher and parent interviews, review of educational records, and administration of test instruments. During the assessment STUDENT exhibited severe difficulties with attention span, distractibility, impulsivity, and activity level. He lacked hand dominance or a mature tripod grip and performed only with constant prompts or hand-on-hand guidance. He had very poor motor planning skills and was dyspraxic. He was unable to dress himself and needed assistance with feeding himself. He had low social, play, peer interaction, and adaptive play skills.
Ms. Hix concluded that STUDENT had significant sensory processing disturbances and that his distractibility was so severe that it significantly interfered with his learning and he was unable to maintain an optimal arousal level for learning except by disruptive physical behavior. She stated that a sensory integration intervention program might help him to attain a more acceptable comfort level in which to learn. She recommended OT services, both consultative and direct as needed, for up to 60 minutes weekly, until June 1, 1999. Classroom adaptations to assist STUDENT included an area set aside for non-disciplinary time out to address his sensory needs with adaptive equipment such as bean bags to sit in and place over him; a heavy bendable mat for him to roll up in, with deep, rhythmic pressure to assist him to obtain an optimal activity level; and various textures for him to stand, walk, and sit on, bare foot if he so chose.
On approximately March 23, 1999, STUDENT'S mother removed him from Cesar Chavez in the BCSD because of elopement reports and a concern for his safety.(Footnote 9)
In an April 15, 1999 report, BCSD speech and language specialist Ms. Newquist sets forth concerns to be addressed at a scheduled April 21, 1999 IEP meeting: an attention problem, ear infections, and poor attendance. Among other things, she recommended reevaluation of STUDENT'S medication schedule, noting that his 11:00 a.m. dosage helped him to be able to attend in order to learn.
An April 21, 1999 IEP was prepared by the District when STUDENT'S school and district of attendance were still identified as Cesar Chavez in the BCSD. The purported purpose of the IEP meeting was to review new assessments and inter-SELPA issues. The parent did not approve of the proposed goals and objectives or the proposed SDC placement at Buena Vista School (Buena Vista) in the District for the next year beginning on May 11, 1999. The IEP provides for 15 minutes of speech and language consultation weekly, APE consultation with the teacher every two weeks, and 60 minutes of OT weekly, both direct and consultative services as needed. The IEP further provides for modified P.E. with the teacher and class, transportation, and an ESY program provided by KCSOS. The April 21 IEP Addendum states that after the ESY program ended, STUDENT would be provided with an interim home and/or class program for four hours a day from August 2 to 20, 1999. The IEP states that STUDENT required PECS for communication and behavioral planning and consultation to address behavioral issues. The Addendum states that the Behavioral Intervention Plan developed by Dr. Quint would be implemented at STUDENT'S school placement. The IEP contains proposed goals and objectives related to carrying and filling his lunch tray, self-regulating his activity and focus level, and using playground equipment and developing recreational and sports-related skills. The IEP Addendum states that the IEP team would be reconvened to rewrite goals and objectives. The Addendum also states that the mother had withdrawn STUDENT from school.(Footnote 10)The IEP team recommended a school site visit to examine safety issues raised by the parent, and a May 3, 1999 site visit was scheduled at Buena Vista. The parent had expressed a need for a male aide and a two-to-one aide ratio initially. The parent requested that STUDENT continue the daily BCSD after school program and that "Nick" continue as a bus aide until safety issues were resolved with the KCSOS program.
In a May 3, 1999 report, KCSOS speech and language pathologist Sandra McMahan, M.A., sets forth the results of an assessment of STUDENT in his home on April 29, 1999, when he was age 8 years, 10 months, and not attending school at the time. Ms. McMahan administered the Rosetti Infant Toddler Language Scale. On the Verbal Language Development Scale, with the mother acting as informant-interviewee, STUDENT obtained a total score of 3, which yielded a 6-month Language Age Equivalency. His verbal language skills fell at approximately the 6-month level. Based upon STUDENT'S performance observed during an informal assessment, Ms. McMahan concluded that his abilities in both the Auditory Comprehension and Expressive Communication areas of the Preschool Language Scale-3 fell below the 1-year level. Ms. McMahan concluded that STUDENT continued to exhibit significant delays in speech and language development, with all assessed areas falling at or below the 12-month level. His behavior and high activity level also interfered with his ability to learn. Ms. McMahan recommended indirect consultative services by the speech and language pathologist. According to her, STUDENT needed to be able to point consistently and to establish a discernible "yes" or "no," both of which are required in PECS. She also recommended that STUDENT'S imitation skills be stimulated in the classroom in a variety of situations with more than one person.
On May 3, 1999, individuals from the BCSD, District, and KCSOS visited the Buena Vista site along with the parent and Jean Calvillo, Kern Regional Center (KRC) service coordinator specialist, to look at safety concerns raised by the parent. Among those present were Mr. Bluestone and KCSOS psychologist Dr. Quint. Following the May 3 site visit, Dr. Quint wrote a May 11, 1999 report which sets forth program recommendations for STUDENT based upon input from the parent and various school personnel present at the site visit. According to the report, the recommendations would be presented to the IEP team for approval. The recommendations focused on acclimating STUDENT to the staff and new school site, including the classroom; making changes to the classroom and school ground to address safety and other issues; and providing an appropriate program and adequate staff for STUDENT. The report states that STUDENT would benefit from a two-to-one staff ratio initially to monitor his behavior and safety issues, and it was recommended that one of his aides be a male for safety.
A June 17, 1999 IEP meeting was held without the parent present.(Footnote 11) The unsigned June 17 IEP states that the meeting was recorded and that the tape and a copy of the IEP would be mailed to the parent. The IEP states that STUDENT was not attending school or an after school program at the time. The IEP sets forth a placement, program, and services similar to those in the April 21, 1999 IEP. However, the weekly OT session was changed to consultation only, and no weekly amount of time was specified. The IEP states that STUDENT required PECS for communication and behavior planning and consultation to deal with behavioral issues. It further states that sensory issues would be addressed throughout the setting with OT consultation regarding sensory modulation. The June 17 IEP Addendum states that STUDENT required a one-to-one aide and classroom modifications, specifically, that the cabinets be secured to the walls or floors and that door alarms be installed. The IEP contains the same goals and objectives in the three areas set forth in the April 21, 1999 IEP. In addition, new goals and objectives address skills in the communication, self-help and adaptive, pre-academic, social, gross and fine motor, and pre-vocational areas. STUDENTnever attended the summer 1999 ESY session or an interim program after the 1999 ESY session.
An IEP meeting was held on September 17, 1999, with the parent present. STUDENT still was not attending school at the time. The parent signed the IEP "with exception" and referred to the September 17 IEP Addendum.(Footnote 12) The proposed placement, program and services are essentially the same as in the June 17 IEP, except for the re-insertion of weekly 60 minutes of direct and consultative OT services. The short-term objectives for the first three proposed goals in the September 17 IEP have anticipated completion dates previously missing in the June 17 IEP. Otherwise, the proposed goals and objectives are essentially the same as in the June 17 IEP. With respect to classroom modifications that were to be performed, specifically, securing the cabinets and installing door alarms, a notation refers to the attached May 11, 1999 program recommendations report by Dr. Quint. The IEP states that STUDENT would begin school after the mother visited the school site and safety issues were addressed. The September 17 IEP Addendum states that in addition to a one-on-one aide, two-on-one aide assistance would be used as necessary. The Addendum also states that after STUDENT had attended the program for three weeks, the goals and objectives would be rewritten and his placement reviewed. His behavior plan would also be revised based upon his behavior in school. The IEP Addendum also states that STUDENT required a male aide, harness, and hook ups in the bus for transportation.
A November 12, 1999 letter to the parent from Dr. Onsum of the District states that the modifications listed in the September 17 IEP had been completed and the classroom placement was ready for STUDENT. Dr. Onsum stated that he anticipated that STUDENT could start school on November 29, 1999, and invited the parent to schedule another visit to the school site before then if she wished. STUDENT never attended Buena Vista school.
On November 29, 1999, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing from attorney Donnalee Huffman on behalf of Petitioner. Safety, transition, and other issues were the asserted basis for the request. On December 3, 1999, the District filed a due process hearing request on the issue of whether it had offered Petitioner a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. The cases were consolidated and heard together.
According to the testimony of Gerald Lavarias, VAC afternoon program director who oversaw STUDENT'S program, on approximately February 28, 2000, STUDENT started attending an after school program at VAC, a nonpublic school. STUDENT never enrolled at a school in the District and was still not attending a regular full-time day program at the time of the hearing.
In April 2000, clinical psychologist Jay Fisher, Ph.D., at Petitioner's request, observed STUDENT in his home twice and conducted an informal assessment. He also viewed a videotape of STUDENT at VAC, which showed STUDENT working with an aide and trying to elope. Dr. Fisher testified that the front door to STUDENT'S home had a metal, not regular, screen, and there was bungee cord across the microwave and refrigerator. Based upon his observations, informal assessment, and materials reviewed, Dr. Fisher concluded that STUDENT suffered from profound mental retardation, with autism. Dr. Fisher informally assessed his compliance and receptive language ability (i.e., the commands he understood) using a fixed ratio reinforcement schedule. (STUDENT'S mother had the strongest reinforcers on hand.) Based upon the behavior sample he observed, Dr. Fisher found that STUDENT displays very poor compliance, low receptive language ability, and no discernible expressive language. STUDENT understood the verbal prompts, "sit down" and "stand up," and "give me five" (with a gestural prompt). However, he could not respond to the command, "Go get your shoe," and did not know what a shoe was. With a gestural prompt, STUDENT picked up something else; he needed to have his head turned in the direction of the shoes, along with a gestural prompt. STUDENT'S expressive language was limited to making sounds and grunts and cooing at a high volume. Dr. Fisher found STUDENT to be hyperactive, moving from room to room quickly, turning the television off and on, and moving about 90 percent of the time. He stated that STUDENT displayed little ability for sustained concentration. Based upon the report of the mother and VAC staff, Dr. Fisher noted that STUDENT had low self-care skills, for example, not being toilet-trained. Dr. Fisher stated that because of his elopement problem, STUDENT is not safe alone and requires one-to-one and perhaps two-to-one aide assistance.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Did the District provide Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the following periods: a. during the summer 1999 extended school year (ESY) session?
b. during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student's unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student's individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) ("designated instruction and services" shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a "basic floor of opportunity" consisting of "access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit." Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child's potential. Id. at 198-99.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: "It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard." 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents' opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07.
a. During the summer 1999 extended school year (ESY) session
Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds.
A. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
Petitioner contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District held the June 17, 2000 IEP meeting without the parent present. Petitioner asserts that the District scheduled IEP meetings without obtaining information about available dates from the parent, and the parent called to notify the District that she was ill or had made other prior arrangements and could not meet on dates set by the District. The District acknowledges that on June 15, 1999, two days before the scheduled June 17 IEP meeting, the parent left a message that she was "canceling the IEP meeting on the 17th."
Under federal and State law, the District must take steps to ensure that at least one parent is present at each IEP meeting or is afforded the opportunity to participate, including giving notice of the meeting early enough to ensure an opportunity to attend and scheduling the meeting at a mutually agreed upon time and place. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a)-(c). If neither parent can attend, the District shall use other methods to ensure parent participation, including individual or conference telephone calls. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(f). A meeting may be conducted without a parent present if the District "is unable to convince the parents that they should attend." 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). In this event, the District must maintain a "record of its attempts to arrange a mutually agreed on time and place." 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(d); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).
In addition, the District must ensure that the parents of a child with a disability are members of any group that makes decisions on the educational placement of their child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(f); Cal. Educ. Code § 56342.5. 34 C.F.R. § 300.501(c)(3), (4) provides:
(3) If neither parent can participate in a meeting in which a decision is to be made relating to the educational placement of their child, the public agency shall use other methods to ensure their participation, including individual or conference telephone calls, or video conferencing; (4) A placement decision may be made by a group without the involvement of the parents, if the public agency is unable to obtain the parents' participation in the decision. In this case, the public agency must have a record of its attempt to ensure their involvement, including information that is consistent with the requirements of § 300.345(d).
Here, it is undisputed that the June 17, 1999 IEP meeting was held without the parent in attendance. Dr. Onsum testified that his secretary, Connie Bradley, contacted STUDENT'S mother about upcoming IEP meetings and that he told Ms. Bradley to call the parent about proposed dates before future IEP meetings. Ms. Bradley testified that initially she more than once had called or attempted to call the parent about available dates for IEP meetings.(Footnote 13) She testified that after trying to call the parent at least three to four times without success, she started sending certified and regular mail notices of IEP meetings to STUDENT'S mother. Therefore, by the time of the April 1999 notice of IEP meeting, she doubted that she called the parent before setting the IEP meeting date. Ms. Bradley testified that on June 4, 1999, she spoke to the parent. She wrote down a notation that the mother would call back if the date and time for the June 17 IEP meeting were "OK" and also the notation "Never called." Ms. Bradley sent the June 4 notice of the IEP meeting by regular and certified mail and received a return receipt dated June 8, 1999. On June 15, 1999, a District staff member took a telephone message from the mother canceling the June 17 IEP meeting.
Dr. Onsum testified that when he received the June 15 telephone message from the mother regarding canceling the June 17 IEP meeting, he called and told her that it was crucial to have the meeting because the District staff were leaving for the summer. He further testified that he offered her the opportunity to participate by a telephone conference call. According to him, the mother said that she did not plan to attend and did not want to participate, although he could not recall the reason. He testified that the mother said that the District could go ahead with the meeting. However, Ms. Bradley testified that she did not recall that STUDENT'S mother ever refused to set a date, or said that she did not want to set a date, for an IEP meeting. KCSOS director of special education Wanda Hall testified that after the IEP meeting, a copy of the June 17 IEP and an audio tape of the meeting were mailed to the parent. Ms. Hall testified that when she spoke to STUDENT'S mother on the telephone after the June 17 IEP meeting, the mother said that she likely would not sign the IEP since she had not attended the meeting. STUDENT'S mother testified that she told Ms. Hall that she would not sign the June 17 IEP because she was not involved in developing it. In rebuttal testimony, STUDENT'S mother testified that beginning in early 1999, she underwent chemotherapy and radiation therapy for cancer and had surgery scheduled shortly before the June 17 IEP meeting. She testified that she did not disclose the fact of her illness or surgery to others outside her family.
Despite Dr. Onsum's testimony that STUDENT'S mother told him that she did not want to participate in the IEP meeting, he could not recall the reason she gave. In the past, she had attended IEP meetings, and, according to her testimony, if she could not make a scheduled meeting on a certain date, she would let the District know. Thus, it does not appear that the District was unable to convince the parent that she should attend, but that she had a conflict with the June 17 date. Moreover, as she testified, the June 17 IEP meeting was not set for a "mutually agreed upon time and place." Although Ms. Bradley's notation was that the mother "[n]ever called" as to whether the June 17 date was fine with her, the mother did in fact call on June 15 to indicate that she did not agree to that date. The District wished to have the meeting on that date because the District staff would be off-duty within a few days.(Footnote 14) However, there is no indication that the meeting could not have been scheduled earlier when the staff would still have been on duty.
As set forth above, special education law emphasizes the important role that parents play in the development of their child's IEP and in the determination of a placement for their child. See, e.g., 20 U.S.C. § 1414(f); 34 C.F.R.§ 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a)-(c). If the District staff is unavailable to attend IEP meetings to develop or revise IEPs during a certain period of time, the District must take all steps to ensure that the meetings are scheduled at mutually agreed upon dates and that they are scheduled early enough to ensure the parent's participation. By failing to schedule the June 17 meeting at an agreed upon date and by holding the IEP meeting without the parent present when there is no clear indication that she would not have attended absent a conflict, the District risked violating the procedural safeguards set forth under the IDEA and denying Petitioner a FAPE.
The Hearing Officer finds that based upon the evidence presented, the District committed a procedural violation which seriously infringed upon the parent's opportunity to participate in the formulation of the IEP and thus denied Petitioner a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
B. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
As discussed above, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the summer 1999 ESY program, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT'S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District's proposed program for the summer 1999 ESY program was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique and individual needs, the first step is to identify his needs. The following needs have been established based primarily upon the testimony of Mr. Bluestone, STUDENT'S teacher at Cesar Chavez for 1-1/2 years, and the current assessments and a safety visit to the Buena Vista School site conducted up through May 1999. It is noteworthy that STUDENT'S basic needs have remained essentially the same since he was first assessed for special education eligibility several years ago. STUDENT has been diagnosed with autism, mental retardation, and a speech and language disorder. He is unable to participate in standardized assessment procedures because he is nonverbal, has no pointing response, is unable to make controlled paper-and-pencil strokes, and is unwilling or unable to participate in displaying the performance criteria. STUDENT exhibits a strong reaction to changes in routine and environment, is unaware of dangerous situations, and responds negatively to commands or requests. He will sit and attend to tasks when reinforced with potato chips, pats, hugs, and verbal praise on a one-to-one schedule. On the Rosetti Infant Toddler Language Scale, administered in April 1999, STUDENT obtained the following age levels: Interaction-Attachment, 9-12 months; Pragmatics, 3-6 months; Gesture, below 9 months; Play, 6-9 months; Language Comprehension, 6-9 months; and Language Expression, 3-6 months. Receptively, STUDENT does not consistently turn his head to locate the source of a sound or consistently respond to "no." Expressively, he uses primary vowel sounds but does not combine sounds to form syllables. He displays significant delays in the acquisition of speech and language skills.
According to the April 1998 speech and language assessment, to be able to benefit from direct individual speech and language services, STUDENT first needs to achieve a repertoire of 20 gross motor imitations, 20 object-motor imitations, 20 fine motor imitations (including pointing to parts of the face), and vocal imitation. He requires DTT to attain nonverbal imitation goals. He requires at least 5 to 10 minutes daily of individual in-class work toward achieving the imitative behavior provided by a minimum of three different staff members each week. He needs to have high and low preferences in foods, activities, and toys identified. He requires 15 minutes of speech and language consultation with classroom staff weekly. He also requires monthly consultation by an expert in speech and language development in autistic children with the site speech and language specialist to monitor his progress and address his problems.
As discussed in the January 1999 behavioral assessment and intervention plan, STUDENT has a problem of eloping. When outside, he requires close monitoring and reinforcement with social praise when he stays in a designated play area or complies with staff commands such as "come here." He also has a problem of removing his shoes or pants and engaging in self-stimulatory behavior. He requires social praise and attention when he engages in appropriate play activities or acts appropriately during work time. He needs to be taught appropriate independent and cooperative play activities and self-help skills such as putting on his shoes and pants. If he engages in self-stimulatory behavior during one-on-one or group activities, he requires hand-over-hand guidance to assist him to perform the designated task. Moreover, based upon the APE assessment, STUDENT'S motor development could be enhanced by continued acquisition of motor skills with an emphasis on peer modeling. He requires APE consultation services with the classroom teacher every other week and modified P.E. with his class. According to the February 1999 OT assessment, STUDENT has a severe problem with right-left discrimination and lacks hand dominance or a mature tripod grip. He does not initiate even the most basic tasks or activities and performs only with constant prompts or hand-on-hand guidance. He has very low motor planning skills and is dyspraxic. He is not toilet-trained, is unable to dress himself, and needs help feeding himself. He has low social, play, peer interaction, and adaptive play skills.
According to several sources, including the OT assessment and April 1999 speech and language report, STUDENT exhibits severe difficulties with attention span, distractibility, impulsivity, and activity level. He is easily distracted by noise. He is very hyperactive and has extremely poor attention until he takes his medication at school. According to the OT assessment, he has significant sensory processing disturbances and his distractibility is so severe that it significantly interferes with his learning and he is unable to maintain an optimal arousal level for learning except by disruptive physical behavior. A sensory integration intervention program may help him attain a more acceptable comfort level in which to learn. He requires weekly 60-minute OT sessions composed of direct and consultation services. He requires an area set aside for nondisciplinary time out to address his sensory needs with adaptive equipment such as bean bags to sit in and to place over him; a heavy bendable mat to roll up in; and varied textures on which to stand, walk, and sit. Either an outdoor or indoor swing should be available to him. He should work on self-help skills such as toileting and dressing. Eating in a quiet room or while facing away from activity may help him not to be distracted.
According to the May 1999 program recommendations report, STUDENT needs at least a one-to-one aide but initially a two-to-one staff ratio to address behavior and safety issues. He needs to become acclimated to the new school setting by starting in an isolated work area. Cabinets require child-proof locks and need to be bolted to the walls or floors, and door alarms must be installed. The outside gate on the school ground needs to be secured with a padlock.(Footnote 15) After he starts at the new school, he will require an updated behavioral assessment and intervention plan.
The next step in determining whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT'S unique needs is to examine the IEP. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student's unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
The April 21, 1999 IEP was signed by STUDENT'S mother, but she did not approve of the goals and objectives or the Buena Vista placement for the year from May 11, 1999, to May 11, 2000, and the 1999 ESY program. The April 21 IEP contains proposed goals and objectives in the areas of self-help, self-regulation, and motor and recreational skills. The self-help objectives address his ability to carry, fill and dispose of his lunch tray and to open his own food containers. The self-regulation objectives address reducing running away and focusing on teacher-directed activities. The motor and recreational skills objectives deal with learning to ride a bicycle with training wheels, to shoot a basketball into the basket, and to run and walk 1/2 mile, and being introduced to other sports like baseball and soccer. At the hearing, psychologist Dr. Fisher was questioned about the goals and objectives in the June 17, 1999, not the April 21, 1999, IEP, but the goals and objectives on pages 9 to 11 of the June 17 IEP are the same as the goals and objectives in the April 21 IEP (and in fact reflect the "4/21/99" date in the upper right).(Footnote 16) Dr. Fisher observed STUDENT in his home on two occasions for a total of approximately 1-1/2 hours and also informally assessed his compliance and receptive language ability.(Footnote 17) He also went to VAC to observe STUDENT, but STUDENT was not feeling well and was on a couch in a room with no light. Dr. Fisher testified that the goals for STUDENT to carry and fill his own lunch tray and to self-regulate his activity and focus level required a higher level of functioning than STUDENT possessed. He further testified that the objective to reduce the running away episodes was appropriate, but the objective to sit and focus on a teacher-directed activity for two minutes, a vague academic objective, required too high a level of functioning for STUDENT to accomplish. As for the APE goal to negotiate playground equipment, Dr. Fisher testified that STUDENT could swing and climb a ladder, but the objectives related to playing with balls, including a basketball, and using a hula hoop required compliance skills which STUDENT lacked and also a high level of coordination, while STUDENT was very low functioning. Dr. Fisher testified that for STUDENT, goals to develop his receptive language and compliance skills should be primary, as well as goals to reduce his self-injurious behavior, eloping, and aggression toward others. The compliance training should focus on toilet-training, self-care, and harm to himself and others. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Fisher was a credible witness as a clinical psychologist with training in, and practical experience with, operant conditioning, similar to DTT, and extensive experience working with individuals with developmental delays. Besides the inappropriateness of some of the goals and objectives set forth in the April 21 IEP, as described by Dr. Fisher, the objectives in the IEP have no anticipated completion target dates.
The April 21 IEP proposes an SDC placement at Buena Vista for the year beginning May 11, 1999, including the summer 1999 ESY session. The uncontroverted testimony of the District's witnesses was that the recommended placement was Mr. Hefner's SDC for autistic children at Buena Vista. However, Mr. Hefner testified that it was not until November 1999 that he obtained an emergency credential to teach moderately to severely handicapped children. He did not testify that he held any other credential prior to that time. California special education law requires that a special day class be taught by a teacher who holds an appropriate special education credential and who possesses the necessary competencies to teach the students assigned to his class. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3053(c). Further, a "noncredentialed person shall not substitute for any special education certificated position." Cal. Educ. Code § 56060. Thus, during summer 1999, Mr. Hefner lacked the requisite credential to teach a class for autistic children.
The IEP also provides for 15 minutes of speech and language consultation weekly, APE consultation with the teacher every two weeks, and 60 minutes of OT weekly, both direct and consultative services as needed. The IEP further provides for modified P.E. with the teacher and class, transportation, and an ESY program, with regular education participation at lunch and recess. The IEP Addendum states that after the ESY program ended, STUDENT would be provided with an interim home or class program for four hours a day from August 2 to 20, 1999. The IEP states that STUDENT required PECS for communication and would require behavioral planning and consultation to address behavioral issues. The IEP Addendum states that the Behavioral Intervention Plan developed by Dr. Quint would be implemented at STUDENT'S school placement.
Besides the deficiencies in the goals and objectives and the proposed teacher's lack of an appropriate teaching credential, discussed above, the April 21 IEP failed to address primary needs that STUDENT had. The Addendum specifically states that the IEP team recommended a site visit to look at safety issues raised by the mother. In addition, the Addendum states that the mother felt that STUDENT needed a male aide and, initially, a two-to-one aide ratio. However, the IEP makes no mention of, or provision for, the related services of even a one-to-one aide. In developing, reviewing, and revising the IEP, the IEP team shall consider, among other things, the concerns of the parents for enhancing the education of their child. 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(1)(i), (b). Moreover, because the IEP team had not yet viewed the school site for safety issues, the IEP also does not mention any modifications necessary to meet STUDENT'S safety needs related to his elopement and climbing issues. Thus the April 21 IEP failed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs.
The June 17, 1999 IEP contains other goals and objectives in addition to those included in the April 21 IEP. The short-term objectives for the three goals contained in the April 21 IEP still have no expected completion dates. The short-term objectives for the additional goals in the June 17 IEP all have anticipated achievement dates of June 2000, one year from the date the services were to begin. Thus, rather than being short-term objectives or benchmarks to assist STUDENT toward achieving the annual goals, the objectives themselves had an annual time line for completion. Cf. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii) (IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives). KCSOS program specialist Danielle Bresee testified that the reason for the one-year completion date for the objectives was that STUDENT was out of school.(Footnote 18) The additional goals and objectives in the June 17 IEP are in the areas of communication, self-help and adaptive, pre-academic, social, gross and fine motor, and pre-vocational skills.
With regard to the communication goals and objectives, Dr. Fisher testified, based upon his informal assessment, that STUDENT cannot achieve complex language skills within one year. According to Dr. Fisher, STUDENT would not be able, within six months, to point to an object from a field of three when given the verbal prompt, "Point to . . ." He further testified that STUDENT could not use PECS to request three objects by presenting pictures of the objects.(Footnote 19) As for the objective to imitate gross and fine motor tasks, Dr. Fisher testified that he had observed STUDENT'S gross but not fine motor skills, and there was no indication that he could "imitate," which presupposes adequate compliance skills. Related to the self-help and adaptive goals and objectives, Dr. Fisher testified that he had not witnessed self-injurious behavior in STUDENT but had seen aggression toward others, and the objectives addressing these types of behavior could be realistic compliance objectives. However, because there were no baseline numbers of incidents, the objectives to reduce these types of behavior to two times a day were not appropriate. He further noted that if STUDENT had been out of school, he could lose skills. Ms. Bresee testified that Adam and Angela Bluestone, with whom Ms. Bresee and Mr. Hefner conferred before developing the additional goals and objectives, thought that the incidents would not be more than two times a day. However, she acknowledged that STUDENT had been out of school for a length of time and would have to adjust to a new environment and instructor. As for the objective to reduce STUDENT'S running away, Dr. Fisher stated that it was good to try to reduce this behavior. With respect to objectives requiring that STUDENT sort clothes, wash his hands, and walk independently, Dr. Fisher stated that these were not realistic given STUDENT'S compliance level. However, the objective that STUDENT put on his pants was possibly realistic. Ms. Bresee testified that the objectives related to sorting clothes and washing hands were based upon the discussion with the Bluestones and the assessment reports, and the objective related to walking independently was compliance-oriented.
Dr. Fisher testified that the pre-academic objectives to match colors and 3D to 3D and 3D to 2D objects were not realistic.(Footnote 20) Ms. Bresee testified that at Cesar Chavez, STUDENT was beginning to match colors, and it was hoped that he could learn to match all primary colors, with the yearly goal to match all 10 colors. She added that new goals and objectives could be written if he mastered the objectives. Dr. Fisher testified that the social skills objective to play an interactive game was not realistic, but the objective that STUDENT respond to the request, "come here," was realistic. Ms. Bresee testified that according to the Bluestones, at Cesar Chavez, an interactive game involved rolling balls or maybe race cars back and forth and learning turn-taking. As for the gross and fine motor area, according to Dr. Fisher, the objective to throw a ball was not realistic (he had previously testified related to the APE objectives that such a skill required compliance and a higher level of functioning than STUDENT possessed). Dr. Fisher testified that the objective to string one-inch beads, aside from requiring fine motor skills, was not realistic given STUDENT'S compliance level and attention span. Ms. Bresee testified that the objective to throw a ball would be done with a shadow prompter standing behind STUDENT and physically prompting him immediately after the instruction, "throw the ball." According to her, the reason for this objective was that it involved much peer interaction and thus promoted socialization as well as gross motor development. She further testified that the bead-stringing objective was appropriate because it required fine eye-hand coordination, sequencing, and attention to detail. Finally, Dr. Fisher found that both pre-vocational objectives to work at his work station for 3 minutes and to sweep a designated area were not realistic because STUDENT was not ready for pre-vocational training. He noted that the objective did not require that STUDENT merely sit, but "work at his work station." Ms. Bresee testified that the pre-vocational objectives were intended to foster independent work skills.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Dr. Fisher to be more persuasive because he interviewed STUDENT'S mother and spent a fairly large amount of time observing STUDENT and informally assessing his receptive language and compliance skills. By contrast, neither Ms. Bresee nor Mr. Hefner performed any type of structured observation of STUDENT prior to developing the goals and objectives in the June 17 IEP and, instead, relied heavily upon a discussion with the Bluestones, although Adam Bluestone had ceased to be STUDENT'S regular day teacher several months earlier. Ms. Bresee testified that she viewed the videotape of STUDENT at VAC prior to testifying at the hearing and acknowledged that if she had known of STUDENT'S behavior problems and regression with Mr. Bordagary, who replaced Mr. Bluestone as STUDENT'S teacher, she might have written different goals based upon the different information. Ms. Bresee also testified that, on instructions from her supervisor Ms. Hall, she did not speak to STUDENT'S mother prior to working on the goals and objectives and was told to rely instead upon the assessors.
The June 17 IEP proposes a placement, program, and related services similar to those set forth in the April 21 IEP. However, as discussed above, Mr. Hefner did not receive his emergency credential to teach moderately to severely handicapped students until November 1999, so in June 1999 he lacked the requisite credential to teach an SDC for autistic children. The IEP Addendum states that STUDENT requires one-on-one aide assistance. However, in the June 17 IEP, the weekly OT session to be provided is consultation only, not a combination of direct and consultative services, and, instead of 60 minutes weekly, no weekly amount of time is provided. However, the amount of services to be provided must be stated in the IEP to ensure that the level of the District's commitment of resources is clear to the parents, other IEP team members, and those involved in implementing the IEP. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 35. In addition, the regular education participation in the June 17 IEP is changed to P.E. in addition to lunch and recess, although the IEP also states that STUDENT would receive modified P.E. with his class and APE consultation services. The information regarding regular education participation appears to present an internal inconsistency within the IEP as to whether STUDENT was to have regular or modified P.E. and would thus be confusing to the parent and the staff responsible for implementing the IEP. The June 17 IEP Addendum states that STUDENT needed classroom modifications, specifically, having the cabinets secured to the walls or floors and door alarms installed. However, no date is set for completing the classroom modifications. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(6) (IEP must include projected date for the beginning of services and modifications). No evidence was presented that these modifications were completed before the start of the summer 1999 ESY program. The KCSOS work orders show that the request to install door alarms and secure the cabinets to the floor or walls was not made until September 20, 1999, and the work was not completed until October 7, 1999.(Footnote 21) Since the IEP team determined that these classroom modifications were required to meet STUDENT'S safety needs in the classroom, until the modifications were completed, the District failed to provide him a program that met his needs.
Based on the foregoing, it is concluded that both the April 21 and June 17, 1999 IEPs failed to provide STUDENT with a program, placement, related services, and modifications which met his needs during summer 1999.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
Petitioner, in essence, argues that there is no evidence that the TEACCH structure Mr. Hefner uses in his SDC would have assisted STUDENT to attain goals and objectives that were designed to meet his unique needs. He thus argues that the District's program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Mr. Bluestone, STUDENT'S former teacher at Cesar Chavez, testified that he took an eclectic approach to teaching his autistic students using TEACCH, DTT, and PECS.(Footnote 22) According to him, TEACCH is structured teaching, not a curriculum, which sets up a physical structure, schedule, and routine for the child. Other District witnesses such as Ms. Hall; Ms. Bresee; the proposed SDC teacher, Mr. Hefner; and TEACCH trainer, Elizabeth Zastrow, also explained the TEACCH program. Ms. Bresee testified that TEACCH uses both a visual and physical structure. According to her, a blended program combining DTT and visual structure is commonly being used in California in particular, although the effectiveness of such a combined approach is still the subject of research. Mr. Hefner testified that TEACCH has four tenets: a clear layout, a schedule, a work system, and good visual structure. Ms. Hall testified that with TEACCH, the child monitors himself so he is independent of prompts. The testimony of the District's witnesses in general was that TEACCH promotes independence in a child.
However, the conclusions of those who assessed STUDENT, including KCSOS psychologist Mr. Coe, Dr. Fisher, and the BCSD and KCSOS speech and language specialists, were that STUDENT'S primary needs are in the areas of developing communication skills, learning compliance with verbal requests, not running or wandering away, developing basic self-care skills, and addressing hyperactivity, distractibility, and attention problems. Mr. Bluestone testified that working on compliance was a major issue for STUDENT, and he had used DDT fairly extensively with STUDENT. Additional areas of significant need for STUDENT are reducing aggressiveness toward others as well as self-injurious behavior. According to the assessors, because of STUDENT'S low functioning level, these basic needs must be addressed before further progress can be pursued. That was the reason that Dr. Fisher found that pre-academic, pre-vocational, and domestic goals and objectives were unrealistic and inappropriate for STUDENT at this time. While attaining independence is a desired goal for all students, disabled or nondisabled, no assessor saw this as a primary need for STUDENT at this time.(Footnote 23)
In fact, there is no evidence that STUDENT showed much progress with the TEACCH structure and tasks. Mr. Bluestone was questioned about current levels of performance in relation to goals and objectives in the November 23, 1998 IEP, which he apparently implemented. He testified that STUDENT required numerous verbal and gestural prompts to manipulate his TEACCH work system to attempt to match objects as called for by the academic objectives. He testified that STUDENT did not master these academic skills. According to Mr. Bluestone, STUDENT also required numerous gestural and verbal prompts to complete a TEACCH structured vocational task (for example, vacuuming) and to complete a TEACCH structured domestic task (for example, bed making). Mr. Bluestone testified that STUDENT did not master the vocational skills. He was not asked specifically about mastery of the domestic skills but testified that domestic objectives like folding laundry were intended to make STUDENT work toward independence, which is not a significant need for STUDENT at this time. In addition, Ms. Calvillo, who went with STUDENT'S mother to observe him at Cesar Chavez in March 1999, testified that during the observation, she noted that STUDENT could not follow the schedule in the TEACCH program as it is supposed to work.
The Hearing Officer concludes that the evidence does not establish that the TEACCH structured program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. Moreover, because a number of the goals and objectives in the April 21 and June 17, 1999 IEPs were inappropriate for STUDENT, as discussed above, to that extent the District's program to implement these goals and objectives was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit upon STUDENT.
(3) Conformity with IEP
In light of the determination above that the April 21 and June 17, 1999 IEPs failed to meet STUDENT'S unique and individual needs and were not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, it is unnecessary to address whether the District would have provided a program in conformity with the IEP.
In conclusion, the District failed to offer STUDENT a program that met his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer on him educational benefit, and, thus, failed to provide him a FAPE during the summer 1999 ESY session.
b. During the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session
As discussed above under Sub-Issue a., the Supreme Court in Rowley set forth certain requirements for an appropriate educational program for a child with a disability. Thus, to determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs; (2) was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit; and (3) was in conformity with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 358 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT'S Unique Needs
STUDENT'S identified unique needs for summer 1999 pertain equally to the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session. In addition, according to the September 17, 1999 IEP, the IEP team determined that STUDENT requires a male aide, harness, and hook ups in the bus for transportation.(Footnote 24) Moreover, in April 2000, independent assessor psychologist Dr. Fisher observed and informally assessed STUDENT in his home. Dr. Fisher's testimony setting forth his observations and conclusions essentially corroborates the findings and conclusions of prior assessors because, as noted above under Sub-Issue a., STUDENT'S basic needs have remained virtually unchanged since the initial special education assessments. According to Dr. Fisher, STUDENT is hyperactive and incapable of sustained concentration. In addition, STUDENT exhibits extremely poor compliance with instructions, low receptive language ability, and no recognizable expressive language. STUDENT possesses low self-care skills, including not being toilet-trained. Dr. Fisher diagnosed profound mental retardation and autism. Because of STUDENT'S elopement problem and related safety issue, Dr. Fisher recommended at least a one-to-one aide and, perhaps, a two-to-one aide ratio.(Footnote 25)
To determine whether the District's proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, was designed to meet STUDENT'S individual needs, it is necessary to examine the June 17, 1999 and September 17, 1999 IEPs. The June 17, 1999 IEP, with its deficiencies, was discussed above under Sub-Issue a. The deficiencies included inappropriate goals and objectives, no specification of the amount of weekly OT, a recommended SDC placement with a teacher who lacked the requisite teaching credential, and an unsafe site. The September 17, 1999 IEP contains essentially the same goals and objectives as the June 17 IEP.(Footnote 26) The only difference is that the objectives for the first three goals have expected completion dates previously missing from the June 17 IEP. The inappropriateness of a number of the goals and objectives in the June 17 IEP was discussed above under Sub-Issue a. As Dr. Fisher testified, many of the goals and objectives in the June 17, 1999 IEP were not realistic or appropriate for STUDENT given his lack of compliance, inability to focus his attention, and low functioning level. That discussion is pertinent to the September 17 IEP as well insofar as the goals and objectives are virtually identical. Thus, as discussed above under Sub-Issue a., many of the goals and objectives in the September 17 IEP failed to address STUDENT'S unique needs.
The proposed placement in a KCSOS SDC at Buena Vista in the September 17 IEP is the same as in the June 17 IEP. As discussed above under Sub-Issue a., until November 1999, when proposed teacher Mr. Hefner obtained his emergency teaching credential, he lacked the requisite credential to teach an SDC for autistic children. The proposed services in the two IEPs are similar, except that the September IEP provides for 60 minutes weekly of both direct and consultative OT services and for not only a one-on-one aide, but also two-on-one aide assistance as necessary.(Footnote 27) Both the June and September IEPs provide for classroom modifications, specifically, securing the cabinets to the floor or walls and installing door alarms. As noted above, the KCSOS work orders reveal that these modifications were not accomplished until October 7, 1999, and other work order modification requests to install locks in drawers, cabinets, and appliances were not completed until November 10, 1999.
Following the April 27, 2000 site visit during the due process hearing, the mother testified about additional safety concerns regarding STUDENT, including the following: getting over the chain link fence surrounding the school ground; getting into a narrow space between a building and a fence; crawling under a gate; getting access to writing utensils, paperclips, and other office supplies on the teacher's desk (because he places things in his mouth); getting on a window ledge and kicking out the screen; and toppling bookcases not attached to the floor. The Hearing Officer notes that these may be legitimate concerns, and the District should address those that pose a risk of harm to STUDENT. The District should also ensure that the school staff, including the teacher and aides, are well informed of the forms that STUDENT'S elopement, climbing, and other risky behavior takes so that they can monitor his behavior closely. The Hearing Officer concludes, however, that at some point the parent should be deemed to have had a sufficient opportunity to notify the District of her concerns for the District to address. Dr. Quint's program recommendations report was specifically intended to address safety concerns, and the District appears to have ameliorated all, if not most, of the safety issues raised in her report. Moreover, the IEP provides for at least a one-to-one aide, and a second aide when necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that as of November 10, 1999, when the final classroom modifications were made and locks were installed in the appliances, cabinets and drawers, the District provided a reasonably safe environment for STUDENT.
Nevertheless, because the Buena Vista site was not made safe for STUDENT until November 10, 1999, the District's proffered placement did not meet his safety needs until that date. Moreover, because many of the goals and objectives in the June 17 and September 17 IEPs were unrealistic and inappropriate, these IEPs failed to meet STUDENT'S unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
The discussion above under Sub-Issue a. relating to the TEACCH program pertains equally here. As discussed above, the evidence did not support the conclusion that the TEACCH program Mr. Hefner uses in his classroom was reasonably calculated to confer on STUDENT educational benefit. Morever, because a number of the goals and objectives in the June 17 and September 17, 1999 IEPs were unrealistic and inappropriate for STUDENT, the proffered program to carry out these goals and objectives was not reasonably designed to provide educational benefit. Therefore, it is concluded that the District's program was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit upon STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session.
(3) Conformity with IEP
Because it has been determined that the District failed to provide a program that met STUDENT'S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, it is unnecessary to address whether the District would have provided a program that conformed with the IEP.
Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that because the District failed to offer a program that met STUDENT'S unique and individual needs and that was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session.
ISSUE 2: If the District failed to provide Petitioner a FAPE during the summer 1999 ESY session of the 1998-1999 school year and during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session, is he entitled to compensatory education?
The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the summer 1999 ESY session and during the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session. In his statement of issues for hearing, Petitioner requests compensatory education for the denial of a FAPE and proposes a placement at VAC. In his closing brief, he suggests reimbursement for the private placement at VAC for the denial of a FAPE. In its closing brief, the District asserts that all of the issues for hearing appear to be a request by Petitioner to have the Hearing Officer find that the District failed to provide him a FAPE during the relevant time periods and, therefore, that he should be placed at VAC, a nonpublic school, at the District's expense. District's Brief at 3. The District goes on to discuss reimbursement for a private placement and argues that reimbursement is not warranted because the District offered STUDENT a FAPE or, alternatively, the private placement at VAC is not appropriate. District's Brief at 3-4.
Because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, he is entitled to appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 374 (1985). Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to "ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA." Id. at 1497. Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.
The District argues that the parent is not entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement of STUDENT at VAC because the parent failed to inform the District of her intent to seek reimbursement. The amount of reimbursement for a private school placement may be reduced or denied if, either at least 10 business days prior to removing the child from the public school, or at the most recent IEP meeting that the parents attended prior to removing their child from the public school, the parents did not inform the District that they were rejecting the District's proposed placement, including stating their concerns and their intent to enroll their child in a private school at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176(a), (b). However, the amount of reimbursement may not be reduced or denied for failure to so notify the District if the parent was not notified of the reimbursement notice requirement. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iv)(IV).(Footnote 28) Here, the District's witnesses testified that the parent was given written information about her rights at the IEP meetings, but no evidence was presented that the information specifically notified the parent of the reimbursement notice requirement.(Footnote 29) Consequently, the parent's failure to give notice of her intent to seek reimbursement should not preclude her from obtaining reimbursement if otherwise appropriate.
A hearing officer may require the District to reimburse the parent for the cost of a private school placement if the hearing officer finds that the District failed to provide the child a FAPE in a timely manner prior to enrollment at the private school, and the private placement is appropriate. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. To be appropriate, the private placement must be designed to meet the child's unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. The Burlington rule does not permit reimbursement only when the private placement selected by the parent is the "exact proper placement" under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Here, in late February 2000, STUDENT'S mother placed him in the after school program at VAC. The testimony of Jolene Billinger, director of VAC, and STUDENT'S KRC case worker was that the after school program was funded by KRC. The parent would be entitled to reimbursement only to the extent of actual costs she incurred in placing STUDENT at VAC.
The question is whether the VAC placement was appropriate under the IDEA. The testimony of STUDENT'S mother was that although she did not see an improvement in his functioning skills while he attended Cesar Chavez, she has seen improvement since he started the VAC after school program. According to her, he now knows that he has a nose, has learned to comply with requests, and she can do at home what he does at school (for example, tell him to "pick up" with a hand prompt). In addition, she testified that his disposition has improved: whereas he formerly fussed and screamed when he got on the bus, he now wants to go.
Ms. Billinger, director of VAC, testified that VAC is a nonprofit center for children with autism which opened in 1997. She testified that she has a 14-year old daughter with autism and has obtained knowledge about autism from a Florida autism specialist. Approximately twelve years ago, she received training in DTT over a two-month period with Dr. Lovaas. According to her, at VAC, DTT is the primary technique used, along with other modalities, such as the visual modality, depending on the child. Ms. Billinger testified that applied behavioral analysis (ABA) is a scientifically-based program which has been proven to work with autistic children. According to her, ABA, or DTT, involves breaking a task into small increments and providing an immediate high reinforcement when the child follows directions.
Robert Pendergrass, STUDENT'S instructional aide in the after school program at VAC, testified that Gerald Lavarias, the afternoon program director, developed STUDENT'S program and gave him instructions regarding what to do with STUDENT. Mr. Pendergrass testified that the training he received at VAC consisted of observations and training by the senior instructional aide in DTT. Mr. Lavarias testified that he has been working at VAC since it opened in January 1997 and that he has worked with approximately 16 children at VAC. He testified that before starting to work there, he received certification from VAC to work with children following 52 hours of training. He further testified that he has received training in intensive behavior modification for over two years. According to him, the afternoon program runs for three hours a day, five days a week.
Mr. Lavarias testified that when STUDENT first started at VAC, he reviewed background information, including copies of IEPs, and conducted an observation of STUDENT, including observing his compliance with his mother's commands. With the senior staff, Mr. Lavarias discussed suitable issues for STUDENT to work on. The three main issues initially identified were communication, motor skills (walking, hand movement, and tilt), and behavior. He videotaped STUDENT'S training and behavior at VAC over several weeks.
Mr. Pendergrass testified that the afternoon program, unlike the full-time day program, is non-academic and focuses on communication, self-help, functional living skills, and socialization. He testified that when STUDENT first started the program, he flipped the table over and would not sit at the desk or in a chair. Therefore, he was permitted to be outside, where he liked the trampoline and swings. Initially, the chairs were arranged outside around the reinforcement area; he received training to comply with the command, "come here"; and the chairs were gradually moved closer to the classroom until they were finally moved into the classroom. According to Mr. Pendergrass, it took two to three weeks to get STUDENT into the classroom. Mr. Pendergrass testified that at the time of the hearing, when STUDENT arrived at VAC, he was first permitted to play outside or in the gym for about 10 minutes, and then he worked on compliance drills. If he was doing well, he would be moved into the classroom.
Mr. Pendergrass testified that STUDENT worked primarily on compliance. He also worked on nonverbal imitation and waiting drills. Mr. Pendergrass testified that STUDENT had not yet begun working on PECS, although that is scheduled for him in the future, because he needs more compliance first. Mr. Pendergrass testified that he has seen improvement in STUDENT'S compliance. At first, he would not sit down at all, would not respond to oral or visual commands, and just ran around. Now, he responds to "come here" and "hands quiet" (i.e., at the desk), and can sit at the desk for three minutes. Mr. Pendergrass testified that STUDENT'S second aide is a female, and he responds fairly well to both. When he has a tantrum, he responds to the female aide, and when given compliance commands, he responds better to the male aide. According to Mr. Pendergrass, STUDENT also worked on basic self-help skills such as washing his hands, removing his pants and diaper in the bathroom, and potty-training. Mr. Pendergrass testified that initially, STUDENT exhibited tantrums during which he would drop to the ground and stiffen, so it would be difficult to pick him up. He would scream, cry, bite, hit, and throw things. According to Mr. Pendergrass, the number of tantrums has since decreased significantly.
Mr. Pendergrass testified that STUDENT tries to climb the chain link fence on one side of the school when he can. If he does, he is told "No, get down" right by his face, and then he is grabbed and pulled off the fence. One of the aides will be pretty close to him. At the time of the hearing, STUDENT had started to respond to verbal commands. Related to STUDENT'S elopement and safety issues, Mr. Lavarias testified that the instructional aide and, unless his mother is there, a shadow (a second helper or prompter) are with STUDENT the entire time that he is attending the afternoon program. When STUDENT is working on drills, the aide and STUDENT sit on opposite sides of the desk. The shadow stands behind STUDENT to keep him from going out the door.
STUDENT'S unique needs were identified under Issue 1 above. The afternoon program at VAC is not a full-time program that would be the equivalent of a regular school day program at a public school. Nevertheless, it has provided STUDENT with training to meet his unique needs in the areas of compliance; communication, including receptive language, skills; behavior; self-help, including toilet-training; elopement; and behavior. Moreover, according to the testimony of his mother and his instructional aide, he has improved in compliance, and his response has been generalized to the home to some extent and also has been generalized so that he responds not only to a male, but also a female, aide. His behavior has also improved. He can sit with his hands on the desk on command and can sit for several minutes. He is also learning basic self-help skills related to hygiene and toileting. A child's progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his disability. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 202. The VAC program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.(Footnote 30)
Because the District failed to provide STUDENT a program to meet his needs, he regressed in terms of his compliance, receptive language, and behavior. The VAC after school program provided him with a program that addressed his needs in these areas and also addressed basic self-help and elopement needs. The program was also reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Thus, while perhaps not the exact equivalent of a regular full day program, the afternoon program provided an appropriate program for STUDENT under the IDEA. Consequently, the parent is entitled to reimbursement for the actual costs she incurred in placing STUDENT in the after school program at VAC from the time he enrolled to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session.
ORDER
1. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to consider Petitioner's triennial reassessment needs and, if necessary, present to the parent a proposed reassessment plan. If reassessment is necessary, within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of the parent's consent to a reassessment plan, the District shall complete the reassessment, including determining current levels of functioning, and convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and determine an appropriate placement, program, and services for Petitioner for the 2000-2001 school year. If further reassessment is unnecessary at this time, within fifteen calendar days of the first IEP meeting to consider reassessment needs, the District shall determine Petitioner's current levels of functioning and convene an IEP meeting to develop goals and objectives and determine an appropriate placement, program, and services for Petitioner for the 2000-2001 school year.
2. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the actual costs the parent incurred for the tuition for the after school program at the Valley Achievement Center from the date he enrolled in early 2000 to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, including the summer 2000 ESY session. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the incurred costs.
3. All of Petitioner's other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: September 21, 2000 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: Because student STUDENT filed his due process hearing request first, for ease of reference, he is referred to as "Petitioner."
Footnote 2: The attorney for the District stated that she also represented KCSOS, but KCSOS is not a named party in this proceeding.
Footnote 3: On June 20, 2000, the District also submitted a written motion for the telephone testimony of Dr. Stacy Quint and Liz Zastrow and orally renewed the motion. Petitioner did not oppose the motion, and Dr. Quint and Ms. Zastrow testified by telephone on June 22, 2000. See Cal. Code Regs. tit 5, § 3082(g).
Footnote 4: The issues have been consolidated and clarified and their order altered to facilitate the analysis.
Footnote 5: The examiner suggested administering the Bayley Scales-2 to obtain a developmental index and baseline data, but the parent withdrew permission to perform further testing beyond the interviews, observation, and checklists completed by the examiner.
Footnote 6: The inter-SELPA placement was between the Kern Consortium SELPA, to which the District and KCSOS belong, and the BCSD SELPA, which is a separate SELPA.
Footnote 7: According to Elizabeth Zastrow, who provides TEACCH training, TEACCH stands for "Treatment and Education of Autistic and Related Communication Handicapped Children."
Footnote 8: The testimony of the District's witnesses established that the persons present at the IEP meeting included STUDENT'S mother; Mike Thompson, BCSD special education director; Dr. Onsum, District director of special services; Wanda Hall, KCSOS special education director; and Mr. Bluestone, STUDENT'S teacher at Cesar Chavez. Dr. Onsum testified that he did not know why no one signed the IEP.
Footnote 9: Jennie Claus, a KRC service coordinator specialist, testified that in March 1999, she went to Cesar Chavez to pick up equipment for a client and parked her van in front of the classroom of Mr. Bordagaray, STUDENT'S teacher at the time. The class had gone into the classroom and the door was left open. According to Ms. Claus, STUDENTcame out of the classroom and got into the van. When she approached him, he got out and sat on the grass for a couple of minutes and then proceeded across the campus. Ms. Claus testified that she notified the staff in Mr. Bordagary's classroom about STUDENT.
Footnote 10: District special education director Janis Spinozzi testified that she had not been aware that STUDENT'S mother had taken him out of Cesar Chavez and that she learned about this at the April 21, 1999 IEP meeting. The April 21 IEP states that STUDENTwas currently not in school and that his last school day was March 26. Angela Bluestone, STUDENT'S extended school day program teacher at Cesar Chavez, testified that she attended the April 21 IEP meeting and at the time had not been aware that STUDENT was transferring from BCSD to Buena Vista. Neither Robert Hefner, the teacher of the proposed autism class for STUDENTat Buena Vista, nor Danielle Bresee, KCSOS program specialist who later wrote IEP goals and objectives for the June 17, 1999 IEP, was present at the April 21, 1999 meeting.
Footnote 11: The parent testified that she called on June 15, 1999, to inform the District that she was not available to attend the meeting. Dr. Onsum testified that the June 17 meeting was held without the parent because that was the last day the meeting could be held since the staff would be leaving for the summer.
Footnote 12: Handwritten at the top of the signature page of the September 17 IEP is the notation, "see IEP dated 6-17-99." It appears that pages 2 through 18 of the June 17 IEP were added to the cover and signature pages of the September 17 IEP, with the notation "Supplemental meeting 9/17/99" written at the top right. Some of the pages are identical to those contained in the June 17 IEP while others contain additional comments or alterations. An additional page 8a, a continuation of the IEP Addendum, is attached. Dr. Quint's two-page May 11, 1999 program recommendations report is attached at the end of the IEP.
Footnote 13: Ms. Bradley testified that she sent to STUDENT'S mother notice of the November 23, 1998 IEP meeting. The evidence established that the mother attended the November 23 meeting. Ms. Bradley further testified that when an IEP meeting was scheduled for February 1999, STUDENT'S mother called before the meeting and said that she was ill and would not be attending the meeting. According to Ms. Bradley, before a scheduled March 1999 IEP meeting, the mother called to say that the IEP meeting would need to be re-scheduled because she had a prior conflicting appointment.
Footnote 14: Dr. Onsum testified that after the June 17 IEP meeting, he left the state the next day for summer vacation.
Footnote 15: Mr. Bluestone, STUDENT'S former Cesar Chavez teacher, testified that STUDENTtried to elope quite often. During his first four to six months at Cesar Chavez, he would run until he reached the chain link fence perimeter of the campus or until a staff member caught up with him. According to Mr. Bluestone, one day an aide reported that STUDENThad run out the front unlocked gate near the bus. Mr. Bluestone testified that as STUDENT'S compliance improved, the elopement subsided, but STUDENTwould still run from certain staff who would give him attention. He further testified that because STUDENTclimbed, the partitions in his classroom were attached to the floor so that he would not knock them down.
Footnote 16: Dr. Fisher testified that he is a licensed psychologist with a Ph.D. in clinical psychology who has been in private practice for over 16-1/2 years. He provides individual psychotherapy and operant conditioning services (similar to DTT) and conducts psychological testing and court evaluations. In his private practice, he has worked with children suffering from pervasive developmental disorders, primarily Asperger's disorder. (According to the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 4th ed. (Am. Psychiatric Ass'n 1994), at page 65, pervasive developmental disorders include autistic disorder.) Dr. Fisher is a specialist who provides therapy and an operant conditioning approach for the home for children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. He has received instruction and training in using operant conditioning techniques with severely mentally retarded individuals and uses DTT daily in his practice. Before becoming a psychologist, for approximately two years he taught trainable mentally retarded adolescents, including three autistic youths.
Footnote 17: Dr. Fisher did not observe and informally assess STUDENTuntil April 2000, but his testimony with respect to the June 17, 1999 IEP is relevant and probative as to whether the IEP was appropriate because STUDENTwas removed from school in March 1999 and was still not in school when the due process hearing commenced in late April 2000. The Hearing Officer notes that because of the nature of STUDENT'S disability, his primary needs have not changed over several years, as indicated by the assessment reports. Moreover, Dr. Fisher has extensive experience working with children with developmental disorders, including autism, and possesses the expertise to evaluate the goals and objectives for such children.
Footnote 18: Ms. Bresee testified that the 1998-1999 school year was the first year that Robert Hefner (STUDENT'S proposed teacher at Buena Vista) had taught, and she worked with him to develop the proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT'S June 17, 1999 IEP. Mr. Hefner testified that before he started working as a special education teacher with KCSOS in August 1998, he had been a long-term substitute teacher. The testimony of Ms. Bresee and Mr. Hefner establish that prior to developing the goals and objectives, they met with Adam Bluestone (STUDENT'S teacher at Cesar Chavez before he was replaced by Nick Bordagary in early 1999) and Angela Bluestone in June 1999 and went over the May 1998 and November 1998 IEPs and STUDENT'S present levels of performance.
Footnote 19: In her May 1999 assessment report, KCSOS speech and language pathologist Sandra McMahan stated that in all assessed areas, STUDENTfell at or below the 12-month level. She noted, however, that for PECS to be effective, it is beneficial that the child be functioning at a minimal 18-month level and that he understand the concept of "exchange" (i.e., give something). She also stated that "pointing" and a discernible "yes" or "no" are necessary for PECS to be successful, but that STUDENTwas not pointing consistently. There is also no indication that he was capable of conveying a discernible "yes" or "no."
Footnote 20: STUDENT'S KRC case worker, Ms. Calvillo, testified that in March 1999, she observed an aide in the SDC at Cesar Chavez trying to get STUDENTto select an object out of a field of two objects upon being shown a picture. According to her, STUDENTwas achieving an approximately 50 percent accuracy, with candy as a reinforcer. She testified that STUDENTwas screaming, clapping, having difficulty staying in his seat, removing his shoes, and being very disruptive.
Footnote 21: The work order request to build a cubicle for STUDENTin the OT room was not completed until October 6, 1999. Other classroom modifications requested by work orders, such as installing locks on drawers, cabinets, the refrigerator, dishwasher, washer, and dryer in the functional living room and child proofing the stove top and oven, were not completed until November 10, 1999.
Footnote 22: Mr. Bluestone testified that he did not think that TEACCH and DTT were mutually exclusive teaching techniques, although others might disagree.
Footnote 23: Ms. Zastrow, a TEACCH trainer for several years, testified that the TEACCH program is based upon the reports of high-functioning autistic individuals who were able to articulate what their disability was and how they operated. According to Ms. Zastrow, because autism is a spectrum disorder, these high-functioning individuals were thus able to articulate for other nonverbal autistic individuals like STUDENTwhat their needs were. However, she did not indicate what evidence there was that the needs of high-functioning and low-functioning autistic persons would be the same. Ms. Zastrow also testified that she consulted with Mr. Hefner, the proposed teacher at Buena Vista for STUDENT. According to her, he was knowledgeable about TEACCH, and she had used him as a TEACCH trainer twice during 1999. She testified that Mr. Hefner has set up a TEACCH structure in his classroom with cubicles for each student to work on tasks with a beginning and an end. She testified that she thought that Mr. Hefner could work with a student with STUDENT'S characteristics, but she conceded that she had never met STUDENT.
Footnote 24: The November 23, 1998 IEP stated that a triennial assessment was initiated in April 1997 but had not yet been completed, and a proposed assessment plan for assessments in other areas was developed. The Hearing Officer notes that it may be time for the IEP team to consider STUDENT'S triennial reassessment needs.
Footnote 25: On cross-examination, Dr. Fisher testified that if exterior classroom doors have alarms but are not locked, two aides would be necessary to avoid injury to STUDENTor others in attempting to stop him from eloping. According to Dr. Fisher, with only one aide, the possibility of excessive force being used to stop STUDENT would expose him to the risk of injury.
Footnote 26: The District appears to argue that because the parent did not object to the goals and objectives in the September 17, 1999 IEP at the IEP meeting, she thereby waived the right to challenge them in a due process hearing. However, the District has the duty to formulate appropriate goals and objectives for a student with a disability regardless of whether the parent objects.
Footnote 27: Ms. Hall testified that two aides may be necessary when required by the curriculum. She first testified that since there are some unassigned aides in the class, one could assist STUDENTwhen necessary. Later, she testified that two aides would be assigned to STUDENT, and when he did not need both, the other aide would assist other students.
Footnote 28: The IDEA specifically requires that the copy of the procedural safeguards which must be given to the parents of a child with a disability upon, among other things, notification of an IEP meeting, must include notice of the requirements for unilateral private placement by the parents at public expense. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(d)(2)(H). Unlike Section 1412(a)(10)(C)(iv)(IV) (its IDEA counterpart), California Education Code Section 56177(d) provides that reimbursement for a parent's unilateral private placement may not be reduced or denied because the parents failed timely to give to the District the requisite notice of the intent to seek reimbursement if the parent did not receive notice of the due process hearing rights under Chapter 5 (commencing with Section 56500). Chapter 5, dealing with procedural safeguards, sets forth due process hearing rights but says nothing about notifying the parents of the requirements for reimbursement for a unilateral private placement. The federal statute requiring that the parents be specifically notified of the reimbursement notice requirement appears to be more protective of parents' rights and governs here. Cf. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994) (state procedures that impose a greater duty to educate children with disabilities, if not inconsistent with federal standards, are enforceable under the IDEA).
Footnote 29: California Education Code Section 56500.1(b) provides that at each IEP meeting, the District responsible for convening the meeting shall inform the parent and student of the federal and state procedural safeguards that were provided in the notice of parent rights pursuant to Section 56321. California Education Code Section 56321(a), which specifically requires that a copy of the notice of parent rights be attached to a proposed assessment plan, states that the notice of parent rights must include a written explanation of the procedural safeguards under the IDEA and the rights and procedures contained in Chapter 5, commencing with Section 56500. Section 56321(a) further states that the notice shall include, among other things, information related to the procedure for requesting a due process hearing, the time line for the process, whether the process is optional, and the type of representative who may be invited to participate. Section 56321 does not specifically mention notice of the requirements if the parent intends to seek reimbursement for a private placement. Because the California Education Code does not specifically mention notice of the requirements for a unilateral private placement at public expense, it cannot be assumed that the copy of rights provided to the parent here at the IEP meetings included notice of the reimbursement notice requirement, absent affirmative proof.
Footnote 30: The District has not argued that the private placement at VAC is inappropriate because it did not provide a program in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer notes that if a private school offers a student an appropriate education, it need not provide the program in the least restrictive environment for the parent to be entitled to tuition reimbursement. Warren G. v. Cumberland Cy. School Dist., 190 F.3d 80, 83-84 (3d Cir. 1999).
