California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · December 1, 2001
Student v. Clovis Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2008-00 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Clovis Unified offered a three-year-old with autism a FAPE for 2000-2001 but must reimburse home program costs for summer 2001.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
On November 29, 2000, the Hearing Office denied stay put in the CVAP program and ordered an analogous District-provided program. On December 12, 2000, the U.S. District Court issued a temporary restraining order requiring the District to fund CVAP. On May 24, 2001, the U.S. District Court denied a preliminary injunction, ending that funding.
Summary
The parents of a three-year-old boy with autism filed for due process against Clovis Unified School District as he moved from regional center services to school district services. He had been receiving an intensive in-home discrete trial training program through the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP). The parents wanted the District to fund 40 hours a week of CVAP services. The District offered its PALS preschool class five hours a day, five hours a week of home discrete trial training, and speech, occupational therapy, and psychological services.
The Hearing Officer found no procedural violation that denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE). Splitting the IEP across two meetings was proper. So was writing up the final goals after a long discussion of them at the meeting. The District did fail to send the final goals with its November 6 cover letter, but this was inadvertent and harmless. On substance, the goals were appropriate and measurable. The highly structured PALS class, taught by Cheri Richardson with school psychologist Dr. Susan Clare and close to one adult per child, could meet the student's needs. Concerns about noise, group learning, and aide training were rejected.
The extended school year (ESY) offer did deny FAPE. It placed him in an unspecified special day class, and the District gave little evidence about that class. The Hearing Officer rejected the request for a 52-week program. The District was ordered to reimburse CVAP costs for the summer 2001 period.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO judged a school-based autism preschool program against a parent-preferred intensive home program under Rowley. A well-supported classroom offer was upheld. The ESY offer failed because it named only an unspecified special day class, and the District gave little evidence that the class could carry out the student's goals.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue I.A.1. Whether the District committed a procedural violation by failing to complete the IEP meeting on the date it was scheduled (October 5, 2000), continuing it to November 1, 2000
No law requires an IEP to be completed in one meeting; the continued meeting was mutually scheduled and parents fully participated.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue I.A.2. Whether the District failed to consider the information provided by the student's parents
Parents and CVAP staff presented information and participated extensively; the District revised assessments and incorporated many CVAP goals.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue I.A.3. Whether the District failed to develop the goals and objectives during an IEP meeting by drafting the final written version after the meeting without the parents
Goals were effectively developed through hours of discussion at the meeting; writing them up afterward, with an offer of another meeting the parents declined, was not a violation.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue I.A.4. Whether the District failed to give the student's parents IEP documents (transition plan, ESY program, PALS description, goals and objectives)
Parents received all documents except the final goals, which apparently were not enclosed with the November 6 cover letter; this inadvertent error did not deny FAPE or seriously infringe participation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.B.1. Whether the District's offered program for 2000-2001 was designed to meet the student's unique needs
Extensive goals plus the highly structured PALS class with near 1:1 adult ratio, related services, and home discrete trial training met the student's needs; claims he was not ready for preschool were unpersuasive.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue I.B.2.a. Whether the District's goals and objectives were inappropriate because based on incorrect present levels of performance and unmeasurable
Present levels were consistent with District assessments and CVAP reports; criticism by the parents' expert of criterion-referenced measurement was unpersuasive.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue I.B.2.b. Whether the student's sensitivity to noise would have precluded benefit in the PALS classroom
Sensory goals, OT, psychological services, work booths, and near 1:1 adult support could address noise sensitivity and distractibility.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue I.B.2.c. Whether the student could not benefit from the PALS classroom because he cannot learn in a group setting
Individual instruction could be adjusted to need, and some structured group instruction would help him generalize skills and build emerging social skills.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue I.B.2.d. Whether the PALS instructional assistants were inappropriately trained to implement the student's program
Aides were trained and supervised in discrete trial training by the teacher and school psychologist; unfamiliarity with CVAP terminology did not show inadequate training.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue II. Did the District offer the student an appropriate 2001 extended school year program?
Placement in an unspecified special day class, with little evidence about its ratio, staff training, or supports, was not shown sufficient to avoid regression; the claim for a 52-week program was rejected.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue III. Are the student's parents entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with his home program provided by the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
Reimbursement awarded for CVAP costs for the 2001 ESY period only, because FAPE was denied only for ESY and CVAP was appropriate.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. District to reimburse costs of the CVAP home program from the start of the District's offered 2001 extended school year through the end of the 2001 ESY (eight weeks), or through the date three weeks before the start of the 2001-2002 school year, whichever period is longer; payment within 15 days of receipt of proof of costs. Dollar amount not stated.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School Dist.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Cleveland Heights-University Heights City School Dist. v. Boss; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; Alamo Heights ISD v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Janet Van Gelder, special education director, Clovis Unified School District
- Dr. Susan Clare, school psychologist; assessor; PALS classroom support, Clovis Unified School District
- Carole Kay Bence, assistant director of special education, Clovis Unified School District
- Linnea Katherine (Katie) Lowe, speech and language specialist and program specialist; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Cheri Richardson (formerly Carberry), special day class (PALS) teacher; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Shirley Feasel, school psychologist; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Laura Lavery, special education teacher; assessor; likely ESY classroom teacher, Clovis Unified School District
- Shangmiaw Sheu, occupational therapist; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Jennifer Fisher, school nurse; assessor, Clovis Unified School District
- Cynthia Cavazos, audiologist (District witness), Clovis Unified School District
- Amalia Gonzalez, instructional assistant, Clovis Unified School District (PALS class)
- Sharon Cook, instructional assistant, Clovis Unified School District (PALS class)
- Rachel Schuler-Fadgen, instructional assistant, Clovis Unified School District (PALS class)
- Jeffrey Simpson, instructional assistant, Clovis Unified School District (PALS class)
- Janie Dansby, instructional assistant, Clovis Unified School District (PALS class)
- Debbie Gonzalez, parent of a student in the PALS class (witness for Student)
- Kathy Medina, parent of a student in the PALS class (witness for Student)
- Mila Amerine-Dickens, clinical supervisor, nonpublic agency home program, Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP)
- Katherine (Kathryn) Gloria, behavior consultation implementer, nonpublic agency, Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP)
- Dr. Melanie Lenington, licensed clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student
- Dr. Paul Lebby, clinical neuropsychologist; diagnosing evaluator, Valley Children's Hospital, Fresno
- Dr. Bryna Siegel, expert witness for District; director of Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic, University of California, San Francisco
- Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh, autism expert under whom the PALS teacher previously worked (mentioned)
- Dr. Ivar Lovaas, autism expert under whom the PALS teacher previously worked (mentioned)
- Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP), private in-home behavior intervention provider
- Central Valley Regional Center, regional center that funded the Early Start CVAP program before age three
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Clovis, California, on January 18, 19, April 10-12, 24, 25, June 25-28, and September 10-12, 24, and 25, 2001.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Ralph Lewis. MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother, was also present on his behalf. Respondent Clovis Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorneys Sandra Woliver and John Hubanks from the Law firm of Miller, Brown, and Dannis. Special education director Janet Van Gelder was also present on the District’s behalf.
The Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Susan Clare, school psychologist; Carole Kay Bence, assistant director of special education; Linnea Katherine Lowe, speech and language specialist and program specialist; Cheri Richardson, special day class teacher; Shirley Feasel, school psychologist; Debbie Gonzalez, parent of student in Mrs. Richardson’s classroom; Amalia Gonzalez, instructional assistant; Sharon Cook, instructional assistant; Rachel Schuler-Fadgen, instructional assistant; Kathy Medina, parent of child in Mrs. Richardson’s class; Mila Amerine-Dickens, clinical supervisor for the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP); Jeffrey Simpson, instructional assistant; Janie Dansby, instructional assistant; Dr. Melanie Lenington, licensed clinical psychologist; Katherine Gloria, behavior consultation implementer; and Dr. Paul Lebby, clinical neuropsychologist.(Footnote 1) MOTHER also testified on her son’s behalf.
The District called as witnesses Cynthia Cavazos, audiologist, and Dr. Bryna Siegel, associate professor of psychiatry and director of Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at the University of California at San Francisco. The District also recalled as witnesses Dr. Susan Clare, Carole Kay Bence, Linnea Katherine Lowe, Cheri Richardson, Shirley Feasel, and Janet Van Gelder.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The closing briefs were received on November 13, 2001. The record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTER
On the first day of hearing, the District objected to Petitioner’s Exhibit 2 on the basis that the exhibit was illegible because it was missing information on the left margin of the pages. At that time, the District requested that Petitioner locate a legible copy of Exhibit 2 to replace the current exhibit. Petitioner agreed to search for a cleaner copy of the exhibit, but stated that he was unable to find one by the end of the hearing. On the last day of hearing, as the admission of the parties’ exhibits was discussed, the District renewed its objection to the admission of Petitioner’s Exhibit 2 in its present condition. At that point, the Hearing Officer allowed Petitioner until October 1, 2001, to provide a legible and complete document to the District and the Hearing Officer. If a better copy was not provided by that time, the exhibit would not be admitted into evidence. As of the date of this decision, no such document was received by the Hearing Office. Accordingly, Petitioner’s Exhibit 2 was excluded from the record.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
I. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year?
II. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate 2001 extended school year program?
III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with his home program provided by the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year?
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT was born on [date redacted]. He is currently four years old and has been diagnosed with autism. As a result of his autism, STUDENT has language, social, behavioral, adaptive, and motor and sensory delays. Through at least the end of the hearing, STUDENT received an in-home behavior intervention program through the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP). STUDENT lives at home with his parents and younger brother.
STUDENT was first diagnosed with autism in July 1999, when he was twenty-one months old. One month prior to STUDENT’s second birthday, MOTHER sought a second opinion regarding STUDENT’s autism diagnosis from Dr. Paul Lebby, a neuropscyhologist at the Valley Children’s Hospital in Fresno. Dr. Lebby assessed STUDENT for approximately four hours and concluded that STUDENT does in fact have autism. During that same month, in October 1999, STUDENT began his in-home behavior intervention program through CVAP. The Central Valley Regional Center funded STUDENT’s CVAP program from that time until he turned three years old.
In August 2000, MOTHER called the District and spoke with Carole Bence, assistant director of special education, to schedule an assessment for STUDENT. As a result, District school psychologist Shirley Feasel visited STUDENT’s home on August 22, 2000, to talk with his parents and to provide them with the District’s assessment plan. According to the assessment plan, the District sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of health and development, motor/perceptual development, cognitive development, academic/pre-academic achievement, communicative development, and personal/social/emotional development. MOTHER signed the assessment plan on August 30 and mailed the assessment plan back to the District. At about that time, the District’s business offices were in the process of moving to another location. As a result, the assessment plan was misplaced at the District and was not located by the District until approximately two weeks after the parents mailed the assessment plan to the District. Ms. Feasel visited the STUDENT home on two other occasions (i.e., September 1 and 22, 2000) to observe STUDENT in his home program and to interview his parents. These two visits lasted a half hour and forty-five minutes, respectively.
The District’s formal assessment, which was initially rescheduled by MOTHER due to a medical emergency, was ultimately conducted on September 25, 2000, at Century Elementary School. The assessment lasted approximately two hours and was conducted by a multidisciplinary team. The assessment team included Shirley Feasel and Dr. Susan Clare, school psychologists; Laura Lavery and Cheri (Carberry) Richardson, special education teachers; Shangmiaw Sheu, occupational therapist; Katie Lowe, speech and language therapist; and Jennifer Fisher, school nurse. The assessment team assessed STUDENT using a “transdisciplinary play-based assessment” approach, by which the team of specialists from different disciplines (e.g., special education teacher, occupational therapist, speech and language therapist, school psychologist, etc.) assessed STUDENT by observing him at play and while interacting with others. Upon entering the assessment room with his mother, STUDENT became agitated. During the initial ten minutes of the assessment, STUDENT cried and screamed. He also exhibited “protest” behaviors such as kicking his legs and flailing his arms. STUDENT eventually calmed down and was able to participate in the remainder of the assessment.
On September 28, 2000, Ms. Lowe and Dr. Clare visited the STUDENT home for about an hour and a half. At the home, Ms. Lowe completed her speech and language assessment and Dr. Clare observed STUDENT in his home program.
On October 5, 2000, STUDENT’s IEP team convened for the first time. The meeting started at approximately 10:00 a.m. and lasted about two hours. Both the District and MOTHER were represented at the IEP meeting by their attorneys. Additionally, MOTHER was accompanied by Mila Amerine-Dickens and Katherine Gloria from CVAP. At the meeting, the District members of the team who assessed STUDENT reviewed their assessment results. By most accounts, the IEP team had not yet discussed the development of STUDENT’s goals and objectives before the meeting concluded. Because District members of the IEP team had scheduling conflicts, the IEP meeting was continued to November 1, 2000, to complete the IEP process. As the meeting ended, Ms. Bence distributed to the team members copies of the District’s draft goals and objectives, proposed transition plan, and proposed extended school year program. (Test. of Carole Bence, Janet Van Gelder, Katherine Gloria, and MOTHER.)
STUDENT’s IEP team met again on November 1, 2000, this time for approximately five to six hours. At the meeting, CVAP presented its proposed goals and objectives to the IEP team. The IEP team discussed the District’s and CVAP’s proposed goals and objectives and his present levels of performance for “several hours.” (Test. of Katherine Gloria.) No final goals and objectives were developed by the completion of the November IEP meeting. According to the conference summary of the meeting as well as the testimony of Ms. Van Gelder, Ms. Bence, and Dr. Clare, there was an understanding that the results of the discussions regarding the goals and objectives would be incorporated into a final version of goals and objectives, which would be provided to MOTHER at a later date. (See also Test. of Kathryn Gloria.)
Also at the November IEP meeting, the District made its final offer of placement and program. For the 2000-2001 school year, the District offered STUDENT a placement in the “Program for the Acquisition of Language and Social Skill Development” classroom for five hours per day for five days per week. The District also offered STUDENT five hours per week of one-to-one discrete trial training in the home environment to be provided by District staff. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT designated instructional services (DIS) in the form of speech and language therapy, psychological services, and occupational therapy. For the 2001 extended school year, the District offered six weeks of instruction in an undesignated SDC class for four hours per day for five days a week, and two weeks of instruction in the home environment, also for four hours per day for five days a week. Additionally, the DIS services offered during the school year would continue during the term of the extended school year.
MOTHER did not consent to the District’s offer. At the end of the IEP meeting, MOTHER submitted a four-page dissent to the IEP, which was handwritten by her attorney. In the dissent, the PARENTS disputed the appropriateness of the District’s proposed goals and objectives and the District’s proposed placement in the PALS classroom. Instead, the PARENTS requested that the District provide STUDENT with a forty-hour-per-week home-based discrete trial training program with twenty hours per month of program supervision through CVAP. MOTHER also requested parent training and supplies for use in his home program.
Subsequent to the IEP meeting, Dr. Clare, Ms. Richardson, Ms. Lowe, and Ms. Van Gelder incorporated the team’s discussion of the goals and objectives into a final version of goals and objectives for STUDENT. The final version of the goals and objectives was sent to MOTHER on November 6, 2000. Attached to the goals and objectives was a cover letter from Ms. Van Gelder, which states the District’s offer to convene another IEP meeting to discuss the final goals and objectives if the PARENTS wanted one. Additionally, Ms. Van Gelder offered STUDENT a District-provided and supervised home-based discrete trial training program that was analogous to his then-current CVAP program pending resolution of the dispute over the District’s offered program and placement.
On November 8, 2001, MOTHER’s attorney requested the current special education due process hearing and a request for stay put in the CVAP program. Three days later, STUDENT turned three years old.
On November 29, 2000, the Hearing Office issued an order denying Petitioner’s request for stay put in the CVAP program. Instead, the order concluded that the District was required to provide STUDENT a program analogous to his CVAP program pursuant to his October 5 IFSP, and that the District could utilize the staff of its choice in implementing the analogous program. On December 12, 2000, Petitioner obtained a temporary restraining order from the U.S. District Court, which required the District to fund the CVAP program pending the preliminary injunction hearing. On May 24, 2001, the U.S. District Court denied Petitioner’s preliminary injunction request and the District was no longer required to fund the CVAP program.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Education Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(a)(8).
The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205 (1982).
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide both whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed placement and program are substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-208.
A. Procedural Appropiateness
The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b) (1997). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Petitioner alleges that the District committed four procedural violations that resulted in the denial FAPE.(Footnote 3) Each of those allegations will be addressed in turn below.
1. Failing to complete the IEP meeting on the date on which it was scheduled
First, Petitioner argues that the District erred when it ended the October 5, 2000 IEP meeting prior to completing the development of his IEP. Although the IEP meeting was continued to November 1 to complete the IEP process, Petitioner contends that the IEP meeting should have proceeded for the rest of the day on October 5 until it was concluded.
California Education Code ' 56341(a) requires that a child=s IEP team conduct meetings during which the child=s IEP will be developed, reviewed, or revised. In convening an IEP meeting, a school district is required to take steps to ensure that one or both of the parents of the individual with exceptional needs are present at each IEP meeting or are afforded the opportunity to participate in the IEP process. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(a). To this end, a school district must schedule IEP meetings at a time and place mutually agreed upon by the parent and the school district. 34 C.F.R. § 300.345(a)(2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(c).
While it is undisputed that the October IEP meeting was adjourned before STUDENT’s IEP was completed, this fact alone does not necessarily result in a procedural violation. Petitioner did not cite, and the Hearing Officer does not know of, any law that requires that an IEP be developed in one meeting only or that the IEP meeting be held for a certain period of time. Additionally, although Petitioner asserts that he was inconvenienced by being required to attend a second meeting in November, the inconvenience did not deny Petitioner the opportunity to participate in the IEP process. By all accounts, the IEP meeting was rescheduled to a time and place that was mutually agreed upon by his parents and the District. Moreover, Petitioner was represented at both meetings by his attorney and two CVAP personnel, and there was no indication that any essential member of the IEP team was unable to attend the November IEP meeting, when the development of the IEP was concluded. Furthermore, the November IEP meeting lasted almost the entire day and, as discussed below, the IEP team members were able to participate in the discussion and development of STUDENT’s educational program. Thus, there is no legal or factual support for Petitioner’s contention.
2. Failing to consider the information provided by STUDENT’s parents(Footnote 4)
Petitioner also argues generally that the District failed to consider the information provided by his parents. As stated above, California Education Code Section 56341.5(a) states that each district convening an IEP meeting for a disabled child shall take steps to ensure that the child’s parents are present at the meeting “or are afforded the opportunity to participate.” Similarly, California Education Code Section 56341(f) states that parents of disabled children have the right to present information to the IEP team in person or through a representative and the right to participate in meetings relating to eligibility for special education and related services, recommendations, and program planning.
Despite Petitioner’s general allegation, Petitioner failed to allege any specific instances when his parents’ information was not considered by the IEP team or to describe how Petitioner was prejudiced by this failure. Additionally, no information was offered to establish that the PARENTS were denied the right to present information to the IEP team or that Petitioner’s parents or representatives were denied the opportunity to participate during the IEP meeting. Rather, the PARENTS were present and were represented by counsel experienced in special education law during both IEP meetings.
It is undisputed that the District revised its assessments after the October IEP meeting to reflect MOTHER’s corrections to factual information contained in the assessments. Additionally, Kathryn Gloria and Mila Amerine-Dickens from CVAP attended the IEP meetings at the invitation of the PARENTS, and they presented information regarding STUDENT’s educational needs and his progress in the CVAP program. They also participated extensively in the team discussions. According to Ms. Gloria and Ms. Amerine-Dickens, there was significant discussion about STUDENT’s present levels of performance, goals and objectives, and educational placement. In fact, Ms. Gloria testified that the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s goals and objectives, including the ones submitted by CVAP, for approximately three to four hours. Furthermore, Ms. Lowe, Dr. Clare, and Ms. Van Gelder testified that many of CVAP’s goals and objectives were later incorporated into the final version of the goals and objectives that were offered to STUDENT. This fact is also apparent from the face of the document containing the final goals and objectives. From the above, there is no indication that the District failed to give weight to the information provided by STUDENT’s parents.
3. Failing to develop the goals and objectives during an IEP meeting,
As mentioned above, STUDENT’s goals and objectives were discussed at length during the November IEP meeting, but the results of the discussions were not incorporated into a final written draft of the goals and objectives until after the IEP meeting by Ms. Lowe, Dr. Clare, and Ms. Van Gelder. Petitioner contends that the District's failure to draft the goals and objectives into a final written document at the IEP meeting, and its failure to invite the parents to attend the meeting where the final version of the goals and objectives was drafted, constitutes a denial of the parents' right to participate in the IEP process. The Hearing Officer disagrees.
Given the complexity of determining goals and objectives for a child such as STUDENT, the sheer number of goals and objectives that were discussed at the meeting, and the amount of time that was spent discussing the goals and objectives at the meeting, it is not unreasonable for the District to spend time outside of the IEP meeting to perform the act of writing up goals and objectives as discussed at the meeting. Doing so would enable the IEP team to maximize its time to discuss other matters relating to STUDENT’s educational program. Additionally, STUDENT’s parents and their representatives were present and able to participate extensively in the discussion on the goals and objectives. For all practical purposes, the goals and objectives were “developed” at the IEP meeting in that the IEP members were able to give input or suggest changes to the District’s and CVAP’s draft goals and objectives and to collect sufficient information to formulate the final goals and objectives. Moreover, after the District drafted and provided the PARENTS with STUDENT’s final goals and objectives, the PARENTS were offered the opportunity to meet with the IEP meeting again to discuss the “final” version of the goals and objectives. The PARENTS declined the District’s offer. Given that the goals were “developed” at the IEP meeting and that the parents declined another IEP meeting to discuss the last draft of the goals and objectives, the District’s failure to produce a written draft of the goals at the IEP meeting did not result in a procedural violation to the IDEA.
4. Failing to give STUDENT’s parents IEP documents during the IEP meetings
Petitioner asserts next that the District failed to provide his parents with a copy of various attachments to the IEP document, including the District’s proposed transition plan, extended school year program, description of the PALS class, and goals and objectives. The District asserts that the transition plan, extended school year program outline, and the District’s first draft of its goals and objectives were given to the PARENTS at the end of the October 5 IEP meeting. Additionally, the District asserts that the description of the PALS class was provided to the PARENTS at the November 1 IEP meeting and the final draft of the goals and objectives were mailed to the PARENTS’ home on November 6, 2000. There is no dispute that each of these documents is a part of STUDENT’s IEP.
California Education Code Section 56341.5(i) states that the district “shall give the parent a copy of the individualized education program.” Although MOTHER originally testified that she did not receive a copy of the District’s proposed transition plan and extended school year program, she later changed her testimony to state that she was given those documents at the October 5 IEP meeting by Ms. Bence.
The Hearing Officer also finds that MOTHER was given a copy of the District’s draft goals and objectives and the IEP attachment describing the PALS classroom. Regarding the draft goals and objectives, Ms. Bence testified that MOTHER was given the document at the end of the October 5 IEP meeting. Ms. Gloria, who was invited to the IEP meeting by Petitioner, also testified that she received the draft goals and objectives at the October IEP meeting. Moreover, everyone but MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s goals and objectives were discussed at length during the November IEP meeting. Specifically, Ms. Gloria, Ms. Bence, and Ms. Van Gelder testified that the team did a side-by-side comparison of the District’s and CVAP’s proposed goals and objectives. Considering that the goals and objectives were discussed for three to four hours by the IEP team, it is implausible that everyone on the team was in possession of the District’s draft goals and objectives but MOTHER. Most convincingly, Petitioner’s four-page dissent to the November IEP references the District’s proposed goals and objectives in detail.
Regarding the PALS description addendum, Ms. Van Gelder and Ms. Bence, who both facilitated the November IEP meeting, testified that MOTHER was provided the same addendum at the meeting. Ms. Bence specifically recalled distributing the addendum at the IEP meeting and writing the date of the meeting on top of her copy, which she attached to STUDENT’s IEP. See Dist. Exh. 12. Additionally, Ms. Van Gelder wrote on the first page of the IEP that the PALS description was attached to the IEP. Ms. Van Gelder testified that she wrote in this notation during the IEP meeting as the team discussed STUDENT’s placement and services recommendations. Furthermore, Ms. Amerine-Dickens testified that the PALS classroom description looked familiar and that she may have seen it before.
Even if Petitioner had not received the PALS description addendum, Petitioner has not established that the denial resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for him or that it seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. The addendum is merely a description of the PALS placement that was recommended by the District members of the team. At that time, MOTHER had already visited and observed the PALS classroom twice. During one of the visits to the classroom, she was accompanied by Ms. Bence, who was available to answer MOTHER’s questions. Additionally, Ms. Bence testified that the team discussed the PALS program components at the November meeting. There is no indication that that PALS description contains information that MOTHER did not already know or had not already seen during her two visits to the PALS classroom. Additionally, the addendum does not add or take away any services that were recommended by the District and that were already contained in the actual body of the IEP that MOTHER received.
Unlike the case with the other documents discussed above, there is no significant evidence that MOTHER was provided the District’s final goals and objectives. Although Ms. Van Gelder testified that the goals and objectives were mailed to MOTHER with her cover letter, she was not the person that purportedly mailed the documents to MOTHER and she has no personal knowledge that the goals and objectives were actually mailed. Rather, Ms. Van Gelder's secretary was the person who would have mailed the documents, but she did not testify at hearing. Thus, there is no persuasive evidence to rebut MOTHER’s testimony that she did not receive the goals and objectives.
However, the District’s failure to provide the draft goals and objectives appears to be inadvertent and did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT or seriously infringe on his parents’ participation in the IEP process. Although MOTHER did not receive the District’s final goals and objectives, she received the cover letter that the goals were to be sent with. In the cover letter, Ms. Van Gelder specifically states that the goals were to be included with the letter and also offers to arrange for another IEP meeting to discuss the goals and objectives if the PARENTS want one. Additionally, at the bottom of the cover letter, Ms. Van Gelder indicated that the goals and objectives would be attached to the letter as “enclosures.” By the very nature of the cover letter, the District was including the PARENTS in the IEP process, and not infringing on their participation by withholding information that indisputably was in existence at the time.
The Hearing Officer notes that the cover letter was mailed to the PARENTS only days after the November IEP meeting and that they received it prior to STUDENT’s turning three years old. Moreover, Petitioner’s parents were clearly put on notice that the District’s proposed goals and objectives should have been included with the cover letter. Thus, the District’s mistake could have been remedied without prejudice to STUDENT if the PARENTS had simply brought the mistake to the District’s attention. From the above, the District’s failure to provide the goals and objectives with the November 6 cover letter did not deny Petitioner a FAPE.
****
In conclusion, the evidence indicates that the District did not commit procedural violations that resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to Petitioner or that seriously infringed on his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Thus, the District did not violate any procedural safeguards that denied Petitioner a FAPE.
B. Substantive Appropriateness As stated above, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education in the form of special education and related services that conform to the student’s individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code § 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d at 130 (2d Cir. 1998). Rather, a child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.(Footnote 5)
1. Designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to have some understanding of what STUDENT’s unique educational needs were at the time the District made its placement offer in November 2000. At that time, STUDENT was almost thirty-six months old. It is undisputed that STUDENT is autistic. Because of his autism, STUDENT has language, social, behavioral, adaptive, and motor and sensory delays.
At the time of the District’s offer, STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language skills were delayed from fifteen to twenty-four months. According to MOTHER, STUDENT was able to exhibit the use of some spontaneous speech. Additionally, STUDENT was able to follow certain one-step instructions (e.g., “come here”), but was not yet able to follow novel instructions or to chain behaviors for two-part directions. (Pet. Exhs. 26 and 36.) Moreover, the reports of Dr. Clare, Ms. Lowe, and CVAP indicate that STUDENT was able to label fifteen to twenty-five nouns and perform verbal imitation. However, Ms. Lowe indicated that he did not have a functional communication system. (See also Pet. Exh. 52.) Rather, STUDENT would tantrum or use non-verbal gestures to get his needs met.
Socially, STUDENT was aware of others around him. He would smile and give eye contact to a person familiar to him. (Pet. Exh. 35.) STUDENT would imitate simple gestures and sounds and display interest in the activities of others. (Id.; See also Pet. Exh. 36.) Additionally, he was learning reciprocal ball play and kicking. (Pet. Exh. 26.) According to Ms. Gloria’s September 2000 report, STUDENT demonstrated strength in acquiring new play skills. Id.
Behaviorally, STUDENT engaged in avoidant, protest, and self-stimulatory behaviors. (Pet. Exh. 26.) According to her September 2000 report, Ms. Gloria indicated that STUDENT would avoid instruction by putting his fingers in his ears (four times per week), would exhibit protesting by screaming or crying (one time per week), or attempting to hit and bite others (seven times per week), and would self-stimulate by sniffing items (fifty times per week). STUDENT also had difficulty sustaining attention for more than approximately two minutes. However, he could engage in learning sessions of fifty minutes in length if given brief breaks every two minutes. Additionally, STUDENT was 94% successful in transitioning from breaks to his home “learning room.”
In the area of adaptive functioning, STUDENT was unable to toilet himself independently. Although he was not self-initiating in the use of the restroom, he was able to hold his bladder until prompted to use the restroom. (Pet. Exh. 26.) STUDENT was also able to feed himself with his hands, sip from a “sippy cup,” work buttons and fastens, and remove his own socks.
Relative to his other skills, STUDENT had strong gross motor skills. Shangmiaw Sheu, the District occupational therapist who assessed him, determined that his gross motor skills were mildly delayed. (Pet. Exh. 32.) STUDENT was reported to be able to run, jump, ascend and descend stairs, climb onto low furniture and play equipment, jump on a trampoline, ride a tricycle, and roll, throw, and catch a ball. (Pet. Exhs. 32 and 48.) STUDENT’s fine motor skills were mildly to moderately delayed. (Pet. Exh. 32.) STUDENT could grasp a crayon with a tripod grasp, put small objects into a container, string one-inch beads, and build block towers using at least three cubes. (Pet. Exh. 48.) Sensorily, MOTHER reported that STUDENT exhibited discomfort in the areas of touch, movement/space, and visual/auditory stimulation. (Pet. Exh. 32; See also Test. of Kathryn Gloria.)
In summary, STUDENT had language, social, behavioral, adaptive, and motor and sensory delays related to his autism. In November 2000, STUDENT did not have a functional communication system, but he showed interest in social interaction. Behaviorally, STUDENT exhibited avoidant, protest, and self-stimulatory behavior. He could maintain sustained attention for approximately two minutes, and could work up to fifty minutes if given short breaks after every two minutes. Adaptively, STUDENT was toileted on a schedule and could eat with little assistance. STUDENT had mildly delayed gross motor skills and mildly to moderately delayed fine motor skills. Moreover, STUDENT had some discomfort to sensory stimulation.
To address STUDENT’s needs, the District proposed fourteen pages of goals and objectives in the areas of preacademic, language, social and behavioral, self-help, and fine and gross motor development. The goals are broken down into thirty-five objectives, which are further broken down into one hundred twenty-four benchmarks.
Additionally, the District proposed for STUDENT a placement in the “Program for the Acquisition of Language and Social Skill Development” classroom for five hours per day for five days per week. In November 2000, there was a maximum of eight students in the PALS classroom on any given day. All of the students in the class were on the autism spectrum. Mrs. Richardson taught the PALS class with the assistance of three to six instructional assistants. Additionally, school psychologist Dr. Clare was in the classroom four hours each day. Other adults that assisted in the classroom were Ms. Bence and the District’s speech and language therapist, occupational therapist, and adapted physical education specialist. According to Dr. Clare, there was generally a one-to-one ratio of students and adults in the classroom. Activities in the classroom included circle time, individual discrete trial training, other instructional activities, snack time, and small-group work.
The District also offered STUDENT five hours per week of one-to-one discrete trial training in the home environment, to be provided by District staff. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT designated instructional services (DIS) in the form of speech and language therapy, psychological services, and occupational therapy.
The evidence established that the District’s offered program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs. The District’s proposed goals and objectives contained in Petitioner’s Exhibit 50 are quite extensive. The District proposed goals and objectives for each of STUDENT’s areas of need as well as for specific deficits that were determined by the District’s assessment team, the CVAP providers, and the reports of MOTHER, as described above. Specifically, the District’s thirty-five objectives targeted STUDENT’s ability to spontaneously communicate requests, to receptively and expressively label and identify colors, peers names, and functions, to receptively and expressively identify nouns, attributes and polar concepts, to understand and use new verbs and spatial concepts, to follow two-step commands, to produce consonant and vowel sounds, to sort items by category, to stack rings and nest cups, to independently complete puzzles, to sustain attention, to match/sort items, to use fine motor skills, to understand numerical concepts, to follow classroom routines, to independently care for toileting needs, to eat with utensils, to drink from a cup, to operate fasteners with greater accuracy, to organize and manage his own materials and belongings, to maintain an appropriate grasp of a writing instrument, to use scissors, to tolerate sensory activities, to generalize gross motor skills, to increase peer interactions, to increase play skills, to appropriately indicate desire for attention, to manage sensitivity to environmental stimuli, and to demonstrate safety skills. Because the goals and objectives addressed STUDENT’s specific deficits, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs.
The District’s offered placement for the 2000-2001 school year in the PALS classroom and various related services would have enabled STUDENT’s goals and objectives to be implemented. The PALS classroom offers a high student-to-teacher ratio that would have enabled STUDENT to receive individualized attention. The class is taught by Mrs. Richardson, a credentialed special education teacher who has extensive training in various methodologies for the instruction of autistic children. Additionally, Dr. Clare, a school psychologist who also has extensive training and experience educating and serving autistic children, assists in the PALS class every day. For each child in the class, Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare determine which skills will be worked on in relation to the child’s IEP and attach this information onto clipboards for the aides to refer to. The clipboards are then used by the aides to implement the student’s program and to collect data regarding the child’s progress. Each week, Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare review the clipboards to “tweak” the child’s educational program according to his or her performance over the past week. As is discussed below, the staff in the PALS classroom are trained to utilize the clipboards to instruct the students individually and in a discrete trial training format at the booths that are set up in the room. Given the strong staff support and the strong oversight of the staff by Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare, it is likely that STUDENT’s goals and objectives could have been implemented in the PALS classroom.
Moreover, the speech and language therapy would have aided STUDENT in the development of his communication skills, and the occupational therapy would have assisted him with his gross and fine motor skills and sensory issues. The psychological services STUDENT was offered would have assisted STUDENT with his behavioral needs and self-stimulation. Dr. Clare, who would have provided the psychological services, was present in the PALS classroom every day and would have been able to continually monitor his progress in the classroom. Each of the other specialists was also on the same campus as the PALS classroom and was available to assist and consult with Mrs. Richardson. Additionally, STUDENT would have been in the classroom with other students with whom he could have worked on his social goals and generalize the skills he learned. Furthermore, the home therapy offered would have enabled STUDENT to generalized his skills to the home environment. Mrs. Richardson has had experience supervising the home programs for other students within the District, as well as past experience working with students’ home programs under the supervision of Dr. Doreen Granpeesheh and Dr. Ivar Lovaas, both recognized experts in autism. Thus, she would have been capable of supervising STUDENT’s home program.
While Dr. Lenington and Kathryn Gloria testified that STUDENT was not ready to attend preschool in November 2000, the reasons for their contention were not persuasive. Ms. Gloria testified that STUDENT was not ready for preschool in November 2000 because he had not been provided peer-play training and he was not toilet-trained. However, Ms. Gloria testified that STUDENT was ready for peer-play training as of September 2000, two months before STUDENT turned three years old. According to Ms. Gloria, STUDENT was not provided peer-play training because CVAP was not funded for the additional training time it would take to implement the peer-play and not because STUDENT was unable to participate in the training. Although STUDENT had not been provided the training by November 2000, the District’s offered placement provided for a transitional period during which STUDENT would have been able to attend the PALS class for an hour a day for “structured/facilitated ‘play visits.’” Thus, the District’s offer provided for some peer-play experiences that would have enabled him to attend the preschool more extensively. Similarly, while STUDENT was not toilet-trained, he was trained to go to the bathroom according to a schedule. Toilet training was included in one of the goals and objectives that would have been implemented at PALS.
Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT was not developmentally ready to attend school. However, she was the only person to testify that STUDENT’s developmental level precluded him from attending school. While Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT lacked certain skills to attend school, each of the skills mentioned was included in STUDENT’s goals and objectives to be worked on in the school environment. As is discussed more thoroughly below, Dr. Lenington’s contentions regarding STUDENT’s needs are based solely on her review of STUDENT’s records and her limited observation of STUDENT in his home environment. The District’s assessors testified that STUDENT would have been appropriately placed in a classroom environment. As mentioned above, Ms. Gloria had specific concerns regarding STUDENT’s readiness for school, none of which were the same as Dr. Lenington’s. As the District assessors and Ms. Gloria had more direct and relevant contact with STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds their testimony more credible and persuasive than that of Dr. Lenington’s.
In summary, the District’s proposed goals and objectives addressed STUDENT’s specific deficits and general areas of need. Additionally, the goals and objectives could have been implemented in the PALS classroom with the significant level of support available. Moreover, the related services offered would have assisted in the implementation of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered program and placement were designed to meet his unique and individual needs.
2. Reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit
Petitioner argues that the District’s proposed program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because the goals and objectives were inappropriate and unmeasurable. Additionally, Petitioner contends that the PALS placement was inappropriate because the classroom was noisy and he would have been too distracted to learn, because it provided for group instruction from which he could not benefit, and because the instructional assistants who would implement his program were inappropriately trained. Each of these allegations will be addressed in turn below.
a. Inappropriate goals and objectives
California Education Code § 56345(a)(2) and 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2) require that IEPs include annual goals and objectives. Annual goals are “statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child’s special education program. There should be a direct relationship between the annual goals and the present levels of educational performance.” Answer to Question 38 of Appendix C to 34 C.F.R. Part 300.
Short-term instructional objectives (i.e., IEP objectives) are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The objectives should be developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals and should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time, such as a school quarter or semester. Id. IEP objectives are necessary in order to provide general benchmarks for measuring the student’s progress toward meeting the annual goals and otherwise gauging the efficacy of the services provided. Id.; see also Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 44 F.3d 391, 399 (6th Cir. 1998) (holding that omission of appropriate objective criteria in IEP was significant violation that “went to the heart of the substance of the plan”). California Education Code section 56345(a)(6) requires that an IEP describe objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether instructional objectives are being met.
Petitioner challenges the appropriateness of the District’s goals and objectives on two grounds. First, Petitioner asserts that the District’s goals and objectives are inappropriate because they are based on incorrect present levels of performance.(Footnote 6) Second, Petitioner asserts that the goals and objectives are unmeasureable.
With regard to Petitioner’s first contention, there was no significant documentary evidence or any witness testimony from STUDENT’s CVAP providers, from the District assessors, or from any member of the IEP team that the present levels of performance were incorrect. As noted above, the District proposed goals in the areas of preacademics, language development, social and behavioral development, functional development, and fine and gross motor development.
Dr. Clare testified that the present levels of performance were derived from information found in assessments and observations. Similarly, Mrs. Richardson testified that the present levels of performance were based on the District’s evaluation as well as other information available to the District. According to the testimony of the District’s assessors, the District’s evaluation comprised information derived from the multidisciplinary play-based assessment at Century School, from interviews of STUDENT’s parents and from parent questionnaires, and from multiple observations of STUDENT in his home environment by at least three people on STUDENT’s assessment team. Moreover, the Hearing Officer notes that the District’s assessment reports also reference information contained in, and consistent with, the September 2000 CVAP report.
During her testimony, Mrs. Richardson specifically correlated her assessment to the goals and objectives and present levels of performance. For example, she correlated the goals and objectives regarding colors, common functions, and seriation to STUDENT’s performance on specific items on the Hawaii Early Learning Profile (HELP). The Hearing Officer notes that many of the present levels of performance are directly reflected in the District’s assessment narratives. Although Dr. Lenington criticized the way that the District scored the HELP, Vineland, and the Rossetti, she did not have significant disagreement with the narratives contained in the assessment reports regarding the skills that STUDENT could and could not perform. In fact, Dr. Lenington’s description of her observation of STUDENT reflected the same findings that were contained in the narratives of the District’s reports. For example, Dr. Lenington testified that STUDENT engaged in avoidance and self-stimulation behaviors. The District’s assessment reports were also revised to reflect corrections made by MOTHER to information contained in the narratives. Once the assessments were corrected, MOTHER did not express any other objection to the information contained in the District’s reports. Thus, the narratives in the District’s assessment likely correctly reflected STUDENT’s needs at that time. Additionally, the present levels are substantially consistent with CVAP’s September 2000 report, as amended by Ms. Gloria, and the testimony of Ms. Gloria regarding STUDENT’s needs as of November 2000.
Moreover, Ms. Van Gelder testified that at the November IEP meeting, the District and CVAP were in general agreement as to STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the areas of language and development. Furthermore, Ms. Van Gelder testified that the District and CVAP did not have “significant differences” regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance in other areas. Ms. Gloria, who testified on behalf of STUDENT, stated that she disagreed with the District’s determination that STUDENT was unable to participate in reciprocal turn-taking games.(Footnote 7) However, Ms. Gloria did not testify about any other disagreement with the District’s draft goals and objectives or present levels of performance. Therefore, the evidence reflects a substantial agreement regarding the present levels of performance between the District and CVAP, the persons who had the most direct information regarding STUDENT’s needs. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s determination of STUDENT’s present levels of performance was appropriate.
Petitioner’s only support for his second contention, that the District’s goals and objectives are unmeasureable, is the testimony of Dr. Lenington. Dr. Lenington criticized the District’s use of criterion-referenced tests such as the HELP to develop and measure STUDENT’s goals and objectives. However, Dr. Lenington testified that she does not administer criterion-referenced tests in her own practice. Additionally, Dr. Lenington acknowledged that nothing in the law precludes the use of criterion-referenced tests for those purposes and that those tests in fact could be used for those purposes, but that she preferred standardized tests.
Dr. Lenington also testified that the goals and objectives were too advanced for STUDENT. However, Dr. Lenington did not formally assess STUDENT and was not present at any of the IEP meetings. Thus, she did not have the benefit of hearing the extensive discussions at the meetings regarding STUDENT’s needs. Rather, the basis for Dr. Lenington testimony regarding the District’s goals and objectives was limited primarily to her review of the student records and her one-hour observation of STUDENT in December 2000. Dr. Lenington’s second observation of STUDENT was made in April, more than five months after the District’s offer, and likely would not have reflected STUDENT’s unique needs in October and November 2000. Additionally, although Dr. Lenington testified regarding the appropriateness of the goals and objectives relating to STUDENT’s speech and language needs, she is not a speech and language therapist and she acknowledged that she cannot state whether Ms. Lowe’s report findings regarding STUDENT’s language needs were incorrect. In light of the above, the Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Lenington’s testimony persuasive.
In conclusion, the evidence established that the District’s proposed goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT. As noted above, the goals and objectives were based on reliable information collected and considered by the District’s trained and experienced assessors, and reflected the comments of STUDENT’s providers from CVAP. The goals and objectives cover all of his general areas of need and also address his specific deficits. Furthermore, there is no evidence that any specific goal and objective was too advanced for STUDENT. Rather, Dr. Clare, Mrs. Richardson, and Ms. Lowe all testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate for STUDENT. From the above, it is found that the goals and objectives proposed by the District were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
b. STUDENT is sensitive to noise
Petitioner contended that his sensitivity to noise would have precluded him from benefitting in the PALS classroom, which he asserts is too noisy. As stated above, MOTHER reported that STUDENT is sensitive to noise. She testified that STUDENT would cover his ears when he heard cars driving by. Kathryn Gloria also testified that STUDENT was distractible and exhibited a sensitivity to noise.
The Hearing Officer finds Petitioner argument unpersuasive. Although STUDENT is reported to have been distractible and sensitive to noise, these deficits could have been addressed in the PALS program to enable STUDENT to benefit from his education. First, the District’s proposed program included goals and objectives to address his sensory needs and attentional difficulties. Second, STUDENT was offered occupational therapy services, which could have addressed his sensory needs. Third, the PALS class is highly structured. By all accounts, the PALS classroom utilizes “boothes” where the children can work individually, apart from the other students. As is described above, the student-to-adult ratio in the PALS classroom is close to or at one-to-one. Thus, STUDENT almost always would have had an adult with him to redirect him and to assist him to attend to task. According to Ms. Gloria and Dr. Lenington, STUDENT responded to redirection by his home therapists, and the strategies such as taking breaks helped to enable STUDENT to attend to task.
Lastly, Mrs. Richardson testified that she would have addressed STUDENT’s sensitivity to noise by training him to desensitize to the sounds while prolonging his ability to attend. (See also Test. of Dr. Bryna Siegel.) Additionally, STUDENT also was offered psychological services, which could have been used to address STUDENT’s behavioral responses to the new environment. The Hearing Officer is particularly persuaded by the fact that the PALS class was taught by Mrs. Richardson, and to a significant degree by Dr. Clare. As discussed above, both Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare have significant experience and training in applied behavioral analysis and in methodologies related to working with children with autism. Thus, STUDENT’s sensory and attentional needs could have been met with these trained professionals in the context of the highly structured PALS class with the additional related services.
c. STUDENT cannot learn in a group setting
Petitioner argues next that he could not have benefitted from being in the PALS classroom because it utilizes group learning and he only learns from individualized instruction. The Hearing Officer also finds this argument unpersuasive. Again, the student-to-adult ratio in the PALS classroom is approximately one-to-one. While the IEP does not indicate how much individualized discrete trial training STUDENT would have received in the classroom, nothing in the law requires that the IEP contain this information. Rather, Mrs. Richardson testified that the level of discrete trial training students in her class receive is determined by their individual needs. Thus, STUDENT could have conceivably received most of his instruction during the day on an individual basis. As is stated above, Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare closely monitor the programs of the students in the PALS class, and they review and amend the programs on a weekly basis according to the students’ progress. Hence, STUDENT’s need for individualized attention likely would have been recognized and addressed by Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare.
The Hearing Officer is not convinced that STUDENT would have been completely unable to benefit from any type of group instruction. By all accounts, STUDENT was able to make eye contact, was aware of others in the room, showed interest in interaction, was able to participate in some reciprocal turn-taking, and was exhibiting some ability to imitate. Additionally, Mrs. Richardson testified that she utilizes “directed instruction” during group instruction time, which is scripted instruction based on the applied behavioral analysis upon which DTT is based. This type of instruction also provides cues for the student to follow and focuses on the consequences related to his or her response. Additionally, Mrs. Richardson testified that the group instruction would have enabled STUDENT to generalize the skills that he learned in the discrete trial training format. Because of STUDENT’s emerging social skills, the structured manner in which the students are taught in a group setting, and STUDENT’s need to generalize his skills, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT would have benefited from some group instruction.
In summary, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s argument that the District’s offered program utilizing some group instruction was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Rather, the instruction in the PALS classroom could be adjusted to increase the level of individual instruction for STUDENT as needed. Additionally, STUDENT would benefit from some group instruction to generalize his skills and to work on his social skills.
d. Instructional assistants are inappropriately trained
Petitioner asserts generally that the instructional assistants in the PALS classroom are inappropriately trained to assist him in the classroom. The only specifics regarding Petitioner’s contention are cursorily contained in his closing brief. In the brief, Petitioner alleges that the instructional assistants are unfamiliar with certain concepts and terminology that CVAP uses with him (i.e., prompting hierarchy, mass trialing, random rotation, fading of tasks, and generalization). (Pet. Closing Brief at pages 18 and 41.)
In this case, five PALS instructional assistants testified at hearing: Rachel Schuler-Fadgen, Sharon Cook, Amalia Gonzalez, Jeffrey Simpson, and Janie Dansby. All of these instructional assistants testified that they were trained by Cheri Richardson and Dr. Clare on discrete trial training, the use of prompts, and facilitating interactions. Additionally, they testified that they receive ongoing, on-the-job training from Ms. Richardson and Dr. Clare in the form of supervision and feedback. Moreover, they testified that they receive additional training during their monthly staff meetings. Even if the instructional assistants are unfamiliar with the terminology used by CVAP, this fact alone does not establish that they are inappropriately trained or are unable to perform their jobs. Rather, they all testified that their duties in the classroom are directly related to the areas of their training and that Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare are available to answer questions that may arise. In light of their testimony, and the absence of any significant evidence of how any alleged lack of training specifically affects their ability to appropriately perform their job functions, the Hearing Officer finds that the instructional assistants were adequately trained to appropriately implement STUDENT’s educational program.
****
In conclusion, the evidence established that the District’s offered program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique and individual needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The District offered STUDENT comprehensive goals and objectives that could be implemented in the PALS classroom and home program with additional related services. The goals and objectives address STUDENT’s specific deficits and are appropriate and measurable. Additionally, the PALS classroom is taught by two well-qualified professionals and is highly structured to enable STUDENT to benefit from his program. Because the District’s offered placement was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and because the District did not commit any significant procedural violations, the District offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 8)
II. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate 2001 extended school year program?
There is no dispute that STUDENT’s needs entitle him to an ESY program during the summer of 2001. However, Petitioner disputes the appropriateness of the District’s offered ESY program for the same reasons as asserted regarding the 2000-2001 school year program. Specifically, Petitioner disputes the appropriateness of the District’s proposed goals and objectives and the classroom placement. Additionally, Petitioner asserts that he requires an educational program that lasts fifty-two weeks per year rather than the program offered by the District that contains an eight-week extended school year program.
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(a)(2). Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner:
Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii). For the 2001 extended school year, the District offered STUDENT a six-week program with the same goals and objectives and related services offered for the 2000-2001 school year. However, rather than the PALS classroom with Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare, the District offered a placement in an unspecified special day class within the District. Additionally, the District offered STUDENT a two-week home-based program to follow the six-week summer school program.
The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s challenges to the District’s goals and objectives are unpersuasive for the same reasons stated above. However, the Hearing Officer does not find that the District’s proposed placement in an unspecified special day class was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. In contrast to the highly structured PALS program supervised by Mrs. Richardson and Dr. Clare that had an approximate one-to-one student-to-adult ratio, the District proposed to place STUDENT in one of the various special day classes within the District.
Although the District witnesses testified that STUDENT’s extended school year placement would likely have been in Ms. Laura Lavery’s classroom with the assistance of one or more of the PALS instructional assistants, not much information was provided about Ms. Lavery’s class or about how STUDENT’s needs could be met there. It is unclear what the student-to-teacher ratio would have been, how many students were in Ms. Lavery’s class and what their needs were, what specific training Ms. Lavery had in instructing a student with STUDENT’s needs, and what kind of additional support Ms. Lavery had in her classroom. As noted above, some key benefits of the PALS classroom were that its structure and support would have enabled STUDENT to receive a high degree of individualized attention as well as support for his distractibility and sensory issues. Additionally, as found above, these characteristics of the PALS classroom would have enabled STUDENT’s goals and objectives to be implemented. It is worth noting again that the District’s proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT are quite extensive, containing approximately one hundred and twenty-four benchmarks. In light of the complexity of STUDENT’s needs and the scant information on Ms. Lavery’s class, it has not been established that the District’s offered placement in Ms. Lavery’s class would have been sufficient to avoid the likelihood of his regression.
Finally, the evidence does not support Petitioner’s contention that he requires a fifty-two-week-per-year program. Although Dr. Lenington testified that she recommends that STUDENT receive such a program, she acknowledged that she makes the same recommendation for all developmentally delayed students and that her recommendation is not specific to STUDENT’s needs. She also acknowledged that the recommendation would be for an “optimal” program, but that nevertheless, it would not be beneficial to have gaps of more than two weeks in the student’s educational program.
In contrast, Dr. Clare testified on behalf of the District that breaks in a student’s program may be beneficial in order to allow him or her to engage in a different repertoire of activities. However, Dr. Clare acknowledged that she has not had the opportunity to observe STUDENT’s regression over smaller periods of time and cannot testify as to whether he needs a fifty-two-week program. Similar to Dr. Lenington, Dr. Clare stated that students will generally not lose skills after a two- to three-week hiatus from school. Dr. Bryna Siegel, director of the Pervasive Developmental Disorders Clinic at the University of California at San Francisco, also testified on this issue. Like Dr. Lenington and Dr. Clare, Dr. Siegel did not have specific information regarding STUDENT’s needs but testified that some autistic children would not be harmed by a two-week break from school and that some students can withstand longer breaks.
The parties do not dispute that STUDENT needs extended school year services due to his limited recoupment capacity and likelihood for regression. However, in light of the lack of specific information about STUDENT’s recoupment capacity and tendency to regress, the evidence does not establish that STUDENT requires a fifty-two-week-per-year program. Rather, the testimony of Dr. Lenington, Dr. Clare, and Dr. Siegel indicates that STUDENT would likely not be harmed by as much as a three-week break from school at a time. From this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT required a program for the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year that did not contain breaks longer than three weeks at a time.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offered placement in an unspecified special day class for the extended school year would not have been sufficient to avoid the likelihood that STUDENT would regress. Accordingly, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 extended school year.(Footnote 9)
III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with his home program provided by the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP)?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). In Florence County Sch. Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court expressly exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the State. Id. at 13-14. Although the Court recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as that required of a school district, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id. In summary, to be entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private services, it must be determined that (1) the student was denied a FAPE, and (2) the student’s private placement or program addresses the student’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him or her with educational benefit.
In this case, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for his private CVAP program during the 2001 extended school year due to the District’s denial of a FAPE for Petitioner during that time. Specifically, the District’s offer was inappropriate because it would have placed STUDENT in an undetermined SDC class rather than a classroom that had identified supports where his goals and objectives could have been implemented so as to avoid the likelihood of his regression. Second, the evidence indicates that the CVAP placement met his needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Ms. Gloria from CVAP testified that STUDENT received an intensive home program in a discrete trial training format. In his program, STUDENT worked on skills relating to his expressive and receptive language, social and play skills, and behavioral needs. Additionally, STUDENT’s home therapists worked with him to improve his self-help skills such as toileting, and preacademic skills such as imitation and following directions.
Because Petitioner was denied a FAPE for the 2001 ESY and the CVAP program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit, Petitioner is entitled to limited reimbursement for costs related to the CVAP program. As was found above, Petitioner requires an educational program that is not interrupted for more than three weeks at a time. Thus, the District is required to reimburse Petitioner for any costs of the CVAP program for the period from the start of the District’s offered 2001 extended school year through the end of the 2001 extended school year (for a total of eight weeks) or through the date that was three weeks prior to the start of the next school year, whichever period is longer.
ORDER
1. The District shall reimburse Petitioner for any costs of the CVAP program for the period from the start of the District’s offered 2001 extended school year through the end of the 2001 extended school year (for a total of eight weeks), or through the date that was three weeks prior to the start of the 2001-2002 school year, whichever period was longer. Reimbursement shall be made within fifteen days from the receipt of proof of such costs.
2. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
I. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year? -The District prevailed on this issue.
II. Did the District offer STUDENT an appropriate 2001 extended school year program? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
III. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for costs associated with his home program provided by the Central Valley Autism Project (CVAP) during the 2000-2001 school year and extended school year? -The Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that reimbursement was rewarded for the 2001 extended school year.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code ' 56505(i).
DATED: December 1, 2001 ____________________________________ Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Cheri Richardson identified herself as Cheri Carberry when she initially testified in this matter on April 10, 2001. Subsequent to testifying on April 10, but prior to being recalled to testify on September 11, 2001, Ms. Carberry got married and changed her last name to Richardson. 2. The issues listed here differ in numbering and content than those noticed by Petitioner at the hearing. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. 3. Aside from the four procedural violations alleged below, Petitioner also contended generally that the District changed the IEP after the IEP meeting. However, very few specifics were offered regarding how the IEP was changed, and there was no significant evidence of any material alteration to the IEP. Additionally, there was no evidence that any change to the IEP resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to Petitioner or seriously infringed on his parents’ participation in the IEP process. 4. Petitioner actually alleged that the District failed to “give weight” to the information provided by his parents. However as is noted below, the law requires that districts “consider” the information, and not “give weight” to the information. Thus, for purposes of proper analysis, the Hearing Officer amended the issues accordingly. 5. The federal definition of FAPE states that the student’s special education and related services must also conform to the student’s IEP. This requirement is designed to determine whether the program offered by the district was implemented correctly. However, this requirement of FAPE is not at issue in this matter because Petitioner was never placed in the District’s offered program. Additionally, federal law requires that disabled students be educated in the least restrictive environment. Because Petitioner did not raise the least restrictive environment as an issue for hearing, this requirement also will not be discussed below. 6. Petitioner also alleged technical violations regarding the scoring of some of the District’s assessments as a basis for challenging the District’s goals and objectives. However, as is determined below, there is no significant evidence that Petitioner’s present levels of performance were substantially incorrect or that the goals and objectives from which they were developed were inappropriate. Thus, because no prejudice resulted from the alleged technical violations in the administration of the District’s assessments, it is not necessary to analyze whether the assessments were appropriate. 7. Although STUDENT may have been able to participate in turn-taking games, the evidence indicates that this skill was only emerging at that time. Thus, a goal and objective to assist STUDENT to develop turn-taking skills was appropriate in his educational program at that time. 8. As noted above, the requirement that the District’s placement must have comported with Petitioner’s IEP does not apply because Petitioner was never placed in the District’s program and the program was never implemented. 9. As it is unclear whether the District’s offered program for the 2001 extended school year would have resulted in a break lasting longer than three weeks, it cannot be determined whether the District denied STUDENT a FAPE on this basis also.
