California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 2, 2001
Fullerton Joint Union High School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2013-00, SN 3-01 · Hearing Officer Hee C. Kim
Fullerton Joint Union High School District's special day class offer for a student with autism denied FAPE; new IEP ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Student's consolidated case (SN 3-01) was withdrawn on March 14, 2001; the hearing proceeded on the district's case, SN 2013-00.
Summary
Fullerton Joint Union High School District filed for due process. It asked the Hearing Officer to approve its 2000-2001 offer for a 15-year-old ninth grader with autism. He had not attended school since August 1999 and had received services at home and in the community. His mother filed her own case, which was consolidated and later withdrawn. The November 2000 IEP offered a gradual start in two special day class periods at Troy High School. It also offered a one-on-one aide, speech therapy, and occupational therapy. Because of an irregular sleep pattern, the student could not be taught until about 11 a.m.
The Hearing Officer found the offer did not provide a FAPE. The witnesses who knew the student best said social development was his greatest need. They said he needed time with typical peers. Because the offer had no general education time, it did not meet his needs or place him in the least restrictive environment. It also provided too little instruction, with no community-based or after-school services. The district did not show the aide would be properly trained. The district won on aide consistency and computer access. It also won on placement at Troy rather than his assigned school, because Troy was closest and had the needed services. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 20 days and offer general education time, after-school instruction, and a trained aide.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's request to approve its own IEP. The Hearing Officer applied the Rachel H. factors and found that a plan with no general education time denied FAPE. The decision also held that a student's limited availability during school hours did not reduce the district's duty to provide enough instruction.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1-I-A. Is the District's proposed program designed to meet Student's unique educational needs, given that it does not provide for interaction with typical peers?
Social development was the student's greatest need; an offer of only special day class periods with no general education participation did not meet his unique needs.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-I-B. Does the District's proposed program provide sufficient community-based instruction?
Because the student was available for school only a few hours a day, the district had to provide community-based instruction after the school day, at least during the transition; the IEP team sets the frequency.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-I-C. Does the District's proposed program provide an adequate number of instructional assistant hours (Student sought 30 hours per week)?
At most two hours a day of school instruction was insufficient given the student's severe delays and unavailability before about 11 a.m., but the record did not support the 30 hours sought; the IEP team must set the hours.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-II-A. Is the proposed program reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, given whether it provides an adequately trained instructional assistant?
The district did not show the assigned aide had training in autism, applied behavior analysis, or the student's needs, and the IEP did not specify training, so the program was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-II-B. Does the proposed program provide a consistent person to fill the instructional assistant role?
The district identified a specific aide for the transition and nothing showed it intended anything other than consistent aide services.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1-II-C. Is the proposed program deficient because the IEP does not provide access to a computer for instruction?
Computer use might help, but no evidence showed the student required it to benefit, and computers were readily accessible at Troy.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1-IV-A. Does the proposed program provide an education in the least restrictive environment, given that it does not provide for interaction with typical peers?
Applying the Rachel H. factors, nothing justified keeping the student out of general education, so the program with no general education participation violated LRE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1-IV-B. Does the proposed program violate LRE by failing to offer placement in Student's neighborhood school (Fullerton High School)?
Troy was closest to the home, was attended by most neighborhood peers, and offered services Fullerton High lacked, so placement at Troy did not violate LRE.
- Dismissed / withdrawnPlacement and LRE
Issue Withdrawn issue. Whether Student requires placement in a nonpublic school to benefit from special education.
Treated as withdrawn after the student withdrew his request for nonpublic school placement and the district never proposed one.
- Not reachedStay put
Issue Footnote 6. Whether the District failed to provide FAPE during 2000-2001 because of alleged stay-put violations (raised first in closing argument).
Not adjudicated because the stay-put claim was not raised in the request for hearing or during the hearing.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the district must convene an IEP meeting to discuss, develop, and offer an appropriate program that conforms with the decision's findings.
- Order to provide or change services. Program must include, at a minimum: (1) significant opportunities for general education participation, chosen with regard to the student's sensitivity to loud noise, difficulty with large groups, and low academic achievement; (2) specific instruction one-on-one or in a small group in a quiet environment; (3) services beyond the regular school day, at least during the transition period, including community-based instruction and one-on-one instruction in a quiet setting such as the home, with frequency set by considering the instruction the student would receive over a full school day.
- Staff training. The district must provide an instructional assistant trained in autism, applied behavior analysis, techniques for challenging behaviors, and the student's unique needs. The extent of training is to be set in consultation with Dr. Huynen if possible, or Dr. Valdez, and noted in the IEP.
Key authorities
Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Sacramento City Unified Sch. Dist. v. Rachel H.; Oberti v. Board of Educ.; Daniel R.R. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Murray v. Montrose Co. Sch. Dist.; Flour Bluff Independent Sch. Dist. v. Katherine M.; Kevin G. v. Cranston Sch. Committee
People named in the decision
- Ronald Anderson, director of special education and student welfare and support services, Fullerton Joint Union High School District
- Lourene Happoldt, director of student support services, Fullerton Elementary School District
- Kenneth Dixon, behavior consultant, Vista Behavior Consulting
- Rich Hess, special education department chair and teacher, Troy High School
- Janis White, associate executive director, Orange County Regional Center
- Kim Huynen, Ph.D., owner and president of nonpublic agency; licensed clinical psychologist; behavior services supervisor, Vista Behavior Consulting (formerly Behavior Change Associates)
- Russ Sipple, school psychologist, Troy High School
- Abigail McGuire, SELPA program specialist, North Orange County SELPA
- Sandra Kossler, special day class teacher, Troy High School
- Jennifer Lone, speech and language specialist, Troy High School
- Patricia Glancy, standards and training supervisor, Orange County Regional Center
- Steve Valdez, Ph.D., school psychologist; triennial assessor; witness for Student, Fullerton Elementary School District
- Sallie Dashiell, private speech-language pathologist; witness for Student, Private practice
- Kevin, proposed 1:1 instructional assistant, Fullerton Joint Union High School District
- Vista Behavior Consulting, nonpublic agency (behavior services)
- Behavior Change Associates, nonpublic agency (behavior services)
- Buena Park Speech & Language Development Center, nonpublic school (prior placement)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Fullerton, California, on January 25 and 26 and March 13-16, 2001.
Petitioner Fullerton Joint Union High School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Cynthia Yount from the firm of Parker & Covert. Also present on the District’s behalf was Ronald Anderson, the District’s director of special education and student welfare and support services. Respondent STUDENT (STUDENT or Student) was represented by attorney Carol Graham from the Law Offices of Carol Hickman Graham. Also present on the Student’s behalf during most of the hearing was his mother, MOTHER.
The District called the following witnesses to testify: Lourene Happoldt, the director of student support services for the Fullerton Elementary School District (FESD); Kenneth Dixon, a behavior consultant with Vista Behavior Consulting, a certified nonpublic agency; Rich Hess, the special education department chair and a teacher at Troy High School (Troy); Janis White, the associate executive director of the Orange County Regional Center; Kim Huynen, Ph.D., the owner and president of Vista Behavior Consulting; Russ Sipple, a school psychologist based at Troy; Abigail McGuire, a program specialist for the North Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area; Sandra Kossler, a special day class teacher at Troy; Jennifer Lone, a speech and language specialist based at Troy; Patricia Glancy, a standards and training supervisor for the Orange County Regional Center; and Mr. Anderson.
The Student called the following witnesses to testify: Steve Valdez, Ph.D., an FESD school psychologist; Sallie Dashiell, a speech and language specialist in private practice; and MOTHER.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was held open for the submission of written closing arguments. After the parties' written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING
Has the Fullerton Joint Union High School District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
I. Withdrawal of Student’s Case
When the hearing in this matter was convened on January 25, 2001, the instant case was consolidated with STUDENT v. Fullerton Joint Union High School District (SN 3-01). The issues in SN 3-01 and SN 2013-00 were essentially identical. On March 14, 2001, Ms. Graham indicated that the mother wished to withdraw the Student’s request for hearing. Ms. Yount did not, on behalf of the District, voice any objection to the mother’s intention to withdraw SN 3-01. As the issues remained essentially the same despite the withdrawal of SN 3-01, the mother was allowed to withdraw her case and the hearing proceeded on SN 2013-00.
II. Withdrawal of Issue
In a supplemental issue statement dated January 15, 2001, the District also identified as an issue for hearing the question of whether STUDENT requires placement in a nonpublic school (NPS) to benefit from his special education. The District identified placement in an NPS as an issue only in response to one raised by the Student in his case (SN 3-01), which asserted that STUDENT might require placement in a nonpublic school to benefit from his education. Given that the Student withdrew his request for placement in an NPS on January 26, 2001, and the District has never proposed an NPS placement for STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, the NPS issue is considered withdrawn.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who resides in the city of Fullerton. STUDENT was initially identified as a child eligible for special education and related services by the Fullerton Elementary School District (FESD) in 1990 when he was a preschool student. In September 2000, upon STUDENT’s classification as a ninth-grade student, the responsibility for providing educational services to him transferred from FESD to the Fullerton Joint Union High School District. He currently is identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of autism.(Footnote 1)
Prior to the 2000-2001 school year, when the District assumed responsibility for providing STUDENT with educational services, he had been placed by FESD in a variety of different placements, ranging from full inclusion in a regular education classroom in his neighborhood school to in-home programs. During the second half of the 1998-1999 school year, when STUDENT was in the seventh grade, FESD placed him at the Buena Park Speech & Language Development Center (SLDC), a certified nonpublic school, in accordance with a mediation agreement executed by MOTHER and FESD. In or about April 1999, FESD contracted with Behavior Change Associates (BCA), a certified nonpublic agency, to assess STUDENT and provide him with one-on-one instruction through behavior therapists.(Footnote 2) BCA provided STUDENT with one-on-one instruction while he was at SLDC and in the community.
In August 1999, STUDENT’s mother withdrew him from SLDC. Thereafter, he continued to receive services through BCA and then Vista, albeit in his home and in the community, and not in a school setting. STUDENT has not attended any school, public or private, since August 1999.
On July 18, 2000, an IEP meeting was held to effect the transition of educational responsibility from FESD to the District. The District was unable at this meeting to obtain the mother’s permission for its staff to observe STUDENT before the next scheduled IEP meeting. During the meeting, the team reviewed the triennial assessment that had just been completed by FESD that same month. The assessment results were set forth in a written multidisciplinary assessment report authored by school psychologist Steve Valdez, Ph.D. Dr. Valdez assessed STUDENT through alternative assessment procedures, including a historical review of data compiled regarding STUDENT since 1990, interviews with the parent and educational personnel working with STUDENT, and observations of STUDENT in the community with his nanny, behavior therapist, and mother.
Dr. Valdez found that STUDENT continued to evidence autism, as manifested by extreme diminishment of social interest and range of interests, severe retardation of language development, severe cognitive functional retardation, severe delays in self-help and prevocational skills, and moderate delays in motor skill development. According to Dr. Valdez, other symptoms included a need for routine, intolerance to loud noises and close proximity to others, and high anxiety levels. Specifically, using the Southern California Ordinal Scales as a guide, Dr. Valdez found that STUDENT was functioning in the age range of eight to twenty-four months in cognition, twelve to eighteen months in communication, and eighteen to twenty-four months in motor coordination (although his fine motor coordination is more typical of the pre-operational level of a four- to six-year-old).
Using the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales, Dr. Valdez concluded that socialization was STUDENT’s most severe area of disability (with an age equivalent score of one year, six months) and that language development was his next greatest area of need (age equivalent score of one year, seven months). Dr. Valdez found a relative strength in motor development (age equivalent score of three years, two months), with self-help skills being STUDENT’s next most developed area (age equivalent score of two years, six months). Dr. Valdez noted that STUDENT’s case manager at Vista reported that STUDENT had made good progress over the last year. The case manager reported that STUDENT was using words again, which, according to the mother, he had begun to do at age one but then stopped altogether at age two. The case manager also indicated that STUDENT was not often aggressive. The case manager stated that STUDENT needed increased peer exposure in a school setting and a more structured prevocational curriculum. Dr. Valdez concluded in his report that, with the exception of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s “experiment” in a home program had not been successful. Dr. Valdez stated that the assessment results indicated that STUDENT had not recovered all the skills he had demonstrated by age six. Dr. Valdez reported that, for STUDENT to make progress with understanding, his social interest needs had to be made the priority in an integrated manner with his skills-based instruction.
On October 25, 2000, the District held another IEP meeting for STUDENT to discuss placement. In attendance at the meeting were both FESD and District personnel, as well as Dr. Huynen. However, MOTHER was not present, although she had been notified of the meeting. At the meeting, the team recommended that STUDENT be placed in a special day class (SDC) at Troy High School (Troy) five days per week with the related services of occupational therapy (OT) and speech and language therapy. The team recommended that STUDENT participate in the regular education program during breaks, lunches, and assemblies, to the extent that he could tolerate it. The IEP noted that a positive behavior intervention plan would be developed, if necessary, in the new educational setting at Troy. At about the same time in October 2000, Vista ceased providing services to STUDENT. FESD was no longer funding the Vista services because of the transition of responsibility to the District. Additionally, disagreements had arisen between the parent and Vista with regard to how the services should be provided.(Footnote 3)
By letter dated October 27, 2000, the District informed MOTHER that it would soon provide her with a draft IEP and that, in the interim, it was responsible for providing STUDENT with services to implement his current IEP. The District indicated its understanding that the mother had refused any further services from Vista, and stated that it would be sending a District staff person to her house to provide the one-on-one instructional assistant (IA) services beginning November 1, 2000. The District informed MOTHER that a second District staff member would accompany the IA on November 1 to observe STUDENT in his educational program and that a Vista supervisor would also be present to supervise and train the assistant.
The District staff member, IA, and Vista supervisor arrived at STUDENT’s house at 8:00 a.m. on November 1, as stated in the District’s letter. However, MOTHER had not received the letter and was unaware of their intent to visit. Additionally, because of STUDENT’s atypical sleep pattern, STUDENT was still asleep at the time of their arrival.(Footnote 4) MOTHER refused them entrance into her house. By letter dated the same day, she informed the District that she felt “threatened and harassed” by its approach in providing services. She indicated that she would like to have an IEP meeting in January 2001 but would not like to be disturbed by the District’s attorney or staff until that time.
The next day, on November 2, Richard Anderson, the District’s director of special education, wrote a letter to MOTHER in reply. Mr. Anderson communicated to MOTHER the District’s understanding that she was refusing the services outlined in its letter dated October 27, 2000. He indicated that if at any time she wished to accept the services, she need only contact the District and the services would be provided as soon as practicable. He enclosed a copy of the IEP developed on October 25, 2000, and reiterated the District’s prior notification that an IEP meeting was to be held on November 8, 2000, in an attempt to finalize the IEP. Mr. Anderson concluded by stating that the District did not believe that it would be in STUDENT’s best interests to wait until January 2001 to complete the IEP and implement the proposed services.
On November 8, 2000, the IEP team met, with MOTHER in attendance. The IEP developed on that date indicates that the following program was recommended by the District: placement in SDC at Troy five days per week with OT and speech and language services; the services of a one-on-one aide while STUDENT is at Troy; participation in the regular education program during assemblies, as tolerated; and extended school year services. The IEP also indicated that a positive behavior intervention plan would be developed, if necessary, after STUDENT started attending Troy. The IEP also contained a plan to transition STUDENT to the Troy campus. This included having the current speech and language provider, Sallie Dashiell, continue to provide five hours per week of services to STUDENT for the first six weeks of the transition. The transition plan also included steps to introduce STUDENT to Troy personnel and the Troy campus as follows: on November 13, STUDENT would visit the Troy campus accompanied by Ms. Dashiell; on November 14, he would go to Disneyland to meet with Troy staff and his new aide(Footnote 5); on November 15, STUDENT would come to Troy at 1:30 p.m., where his mother would meet him, and remain on the campus for as long as he is comfortable; on November 16, STUDENT would come to Troy at 1:30 p.m., where the SDC teacher would meet him, and remain for as long as he is comfortable; and, on November 17, STUDENT would again come to Troy and remain for as long as he is comfortable. According to the IEP, the goal was for STUDENT to be able to tolerate attending fifth and sixth periods at Troy. The team agreed to meet in two months to review STUDENT’s educational program and progress. At the conclusion of the meeting, MOTHER indicated that she wanted to take the IEP home and review it before signing it.
The next day, on November 9, MOTHER met with school psychologist Russ Sipple, special education chair Rich Hess, and SDC teacher Sandra Kossler. She handed them a letter that she wanted included as part of the IEP. In the letter, she stated that she did not agree with the recommended SDC placement, but would agree to placement in the general education program with appropriate supports. She indicated that she agreed with the proposed interim goals and objectives, as well as the proposed frequency and duration of OT and speech and language services. She also stated that she was in agreement with the provision of a one-on-one instructional assistant during school hours, although the service should be provided a minimum of thirty hours per week in the community and on campus. Finally, MOTHER noted that the IEP team had not discussed community goals and objectives, and indicated that she wanted the existing community goals to be continued until the next meeting in January 2001. MOTHER stated that at the next meeting, she wanted the IEP team to generate new community goals and objectives, as well as discuss literacy goals and computer access.
By letter dated November 13, 2000, the District informed MOTHER of its regret that she did not agree with the IEP developed on November 8, 2000, and its intent to resolve the dispute through a due process hearing. The District stated that it would continue to provide STUDENT with the related services of OT and speech and language services, which MOTHER had indicated agreement with, until such time as a new IEP was agreed upon or deemed appropriate through a due process hearing. The District noted in its letter that the mother previously had declined the one-on-one instructional assistant services previously arranged by the District.
That same day, the District filed a request for a due process hearing. No further IEP meetings have been held.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: Has the Fullerton Joint Union High School District offered STUDENT a free appropriate public education for the 2000-2001 school year?
Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A “free appropriate public education” consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law refers to related services as “designated instruction and services” (DIS) and, like federal law, provides that DIS services shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.
The District contends that the educational program it offered STUDENT for the 2000-2001 school year, as set forth in the IEPs dated October 25 and November 8, 2000, constitutes a FAPE. Because the parent has refused to provide her consent for implementation of the proposed program, the District seeks through this due process proceeding a determination that its proposed program is appropriate for STUDENT. The Student argues that the District’s proposed program is not substantively appropriate for STUDENT.(Footnote 6) Specifically, the Student contends that the District’s proposed program is inappropriate because it does not provide for interaction with typical peers, an adequately trained instructional assistant (IA), a consistent person to fill the role of the IA, an adequate number of IA hours, access to a computer for instruction, sufficient community-based instruction, or placement in STUDENT’s neighborhood school. The parties agreed at hearing that there was no dispute with regard to the appropriateness of the District’s offers for occupational therapy and speech and language therapy for the 2000-2001 school year.
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If the District’s proposed program is designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs, is reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, and comports with his IEP, the District offered a FAPE, even if his parent prefers another program and even if his parent’s preferred program would result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314. The District was also required to offer STUDENT a program which educates him in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Therefore, under the IDEA and Rowley, the program the District proposes for the 2000-2001 school year must meet the following four requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program for STUDENT: be designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs, be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comport with his IEP, and provide him an education in the least restrictive environment.
I. Is the District’s Proposed Program Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Educational Needs?
It is necessary to have some understanding of STUDENT’s educational needs to determine whether the program and placement offered by the District is designed to meet his unique educational needs. STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who was diagnosed with autism at the age of four. Currently, STUDENT continues to evidence autistic characteristics, including extreme diminishment of social interest and range of interests, severe retardation of language development, severe cognitive functional retardation, severe delays in self-help and prevocational skills, and moderate delays in motor skill development. According to Dr. Valdez, other symptoms include a need for routine, intolerance to loud noises and close proximity to others, and high anxiety levels. Socialization is STUDENT’s most severe area of disability, with language development being his next greatest area of need.
The Student contends that the District’s proposed program is not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs because it does not provide for interaction with typical peers, sufficient community-based instruction, or an adequate number of IA hours. Each of these arguments shall be addressed in turn.
A. Interaction with typical peers
First, with respect to the Student’s contention regarding interaction with typical peers, it is noted that STUDENT’s educational program has not included placement on a school campus since August 1999, when he was withdrawn from the Buena Park Speech & Language Development Center. However, there is no dispute that STUDENT’s needs presently require placement on a comprehensive high school campus. The dispute centers around the amount of interaction with nondisabled peers the program should include.
The District proposes that STUDENT’s transition to a comprehensive high school campus consist of two special day classes, starting with a sixth-period SDC English class and then a fifth-period collaborative dance class, as STUDENT’s ability to tolerate being on the high school campus increases. While the sixth-period SDC English class consists of fourteen special education students, the fifth-period collaborative dance class is composed of about thirty regular education students and ten special education students, who are team taught by a regular education teacher and a special education teacher. The District’s proposed IEP dated November 8, 2000, notes that it does not include participation in the general education program but does provide for participation in assemblies “as tolerated.” The District notes that the IEP developed in October and November 2000 was intended as a plan to transition STUDENT to the high school campus and that further opportunities for inclusion would be considered by the IEP team at the review scheduled in January 2001, when the team could take into consideration STUDENT’s progress in tolerating being on campus. The District argues that given the nature of STUDENT’s disability, the fact that he is not available to attend school until noon, and the fact that he has not attended school on a regular education campus since his first-grade year, STUDENT cannot be “satisfactorily” placed in regular education classes at this time, despite the use of supplemental aids and services.
The Student contends that even for purposes of transitioning STUDENT to a high school campus, he should be placed in the regular education program, preferably in elective classes. The Student argues that presently STUDENT’s greatest area of need is social development and that he requires exposure to nondisabled peers to address his socialization deficits. The Student notes that STUDENT currently shows an interest in watching his typical peers and is able to learn appropriate behavior through modeling. According to the testimony of those who have recently assessed or worked with STUDENT, STUDENT does require exposure to nondisabled peers to address his socialization deficits.
Dr. Valdez testified that because of his autism, STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit is social development. According to Dr. Valdez, STUDENT has a lack of social interest that must be developed in order for him to progress in an educational program. When Dr. Valdez assessed STUDENT in June 2000, he found that STUDENT’s socialization skills were roughly equivalent to those of a one-year-and-six-month-old child. Dr. Valdez testified that STUDENT’s withdrawal from a school environment allowed him to withdraw from social engagement, and that the withdrawal from a school environment partly explains STUDENT’s regression and failure to progress substantially over the last several years.(Footnote 7) Dr. Valdez testified that STUDENT needs exposure to other people and gradual encouragement to engage in social interaction in order to lessen his dependence on his mother and to increase his ability to function independently. According to Dr. Valdez, STUDENT needs to be in a normal school setting with students his own age and in a program with some opportunities for interaction with peers who, if not entirely nondisabled, at least function socially within the normal range. Dr. Valdez testified that this type of exposure could take place during any part of the school day, including classes, lunches, or breaks, and could be achieved through a program blending elements of a special education program with inclusion in the general education program. Dr. Valdez noted that STUDENT does need specific instruction in certain areas, including speech and language, functional daily living skills, and self-help skills.
The Hearing Officer found Dr. Valdez’s testimony in this regard to be credible. Dr. Valdez has both a bachelor’s and master’s degree in psychology, the last of which was received in 1977. He also received a Doctorate of Philosophy degree in psychology in 1982 and has been working for school districts, alternately as a school psychologist and special education administrator, for at least that long. Dr. Valdez has worked with STUDENT off and on since he was in preschool and performed the most recent assessment of him in June 2000, all on behalf of FESD, STUDENT’s previous district of residence. In short, Dr. Valdez was well qualified to speak about STUDENT’s educational needs. Moreover, Dr. Valdez’s testimony in this regard was supported by the testimony of those professionals who have worked with STUDENT most recently, including Dr. Huynen and Ms. Dashiell.
Dr. Huynen works primarily with children with autism. She has a bachelor’s degree in psychology, and a master’s and a doctorate degree in clinical psychology. Dr. Huynen is a California-licensed clinical psychologist who has known STUDENT since approximately April 1999, when he began to receive services from Behavior Change Associates. From approximately April 1999 to October 2000, Dr. Huynen observed and assessed STUDENT, as well as provided consultation and supervision services for his case.
Dr. Huynen testified that STUDENT has made significant progress in the last couple of years by decreasing his resistive and self-injurious behaviors, increasing his ability to communicate to his aides, improving his self-help skills, and increasing his ability to tolerate a variety of settings and changes in his schedule. Dr. Huynen testified that by July 2000, she began to recommend that STUDENT be placed in a school setting. She explained that STUDENT needs a consistent and age-appropriate setting where he can generalize and build on his skills and that the appropriate community setting for STUDENT, given his age, is school. She testified that he needs exposure to a consistent set of peers and adults in order to generalize the skills he has learned. She also testified that he needs exposure to typically developing peers who have age-appropriate language and social skills. According to Dr. Huynen, exposure to typical peers would afford STUDENT opportunities to observe appropriate language use and social interactions, as well as opportunities to learn how to interact socially, to practice his interaction skills, and to develop friendships with typical peers using the skills he has learned. However, Dr. Huynen noted that while a small cooking or art class with typical peers would be appropriate for STUDENT, a large class or academic regular education class would not be appropriate during the initial transition period. Dr. Huynen testified that, given STUDENT’s sensitivity to loud noises and recent lack of regular exposure to large numbers of peers in one room, the transition to the school campus should begin with a small-size class because STUDENT would likely have difficulty tolerating a large group of students. She also testified that, academically, STUDENT would have a difficult time learning in a typical math class because he would not be able to meet the academic expectations of the class or be able to develop his language or social interaction skills in such a class. Additionally, Dr. Huynen noted that STUDENT’s program also had to include some time for one-on-one instruction to teach STUDENT new skills.
Ms. Dashiell, a speech and language therapist in private practice who has worked with STUDENT since 1996, testified that STUDENT’s major area of need is in social communication. She testified that STUDENT is very focused on watching the behavior and language of other children, and that allowing him to watch typical peers engage in appropriate social interaction and communication would be very beneficial for him. She also stated that placement with typical peers would decrease problems of generalization and provide for opportunities to teach STUDENT in a naturalistic manner (i.e., he can be taught language and social skills in incidental ways as the situations arise, rather than in an artificial or directive manner).
The District did not present any persuasive evidence to establish that participation in the general education program would not be appropriate for STUDENT at this time. Instead, the District emphasized that the November 2000 IEP set forth a transition plan that was to be reviewed within six weeks of its implementation and that consideration of more inclusion opportunities would be left for the team’s review at a time when it could be determined how successfully STUDENT was able to tolerate being on the school campus. Additionally, the District argues that, given STUDENT’s severely depressed cognitive functioning (which Dr. Valdez described as being in the severely retarded range), low functioning in other areas, need for quiet, structured environments, and lack of recent exposure to a school environment, an SDC setting would better suit his needs. The Hearing Officer disagrees.
The District proved at hearing that an autistic child with deficits as profound as STUDENT’s is usually placed in the SDC program. SDC teacher Sandra Kossler testified that STUDENT is similar in terms of level of functioning to other children in her sixth-period SDCEnglish class. School psychologist Russ Sipple, who never had an opportunity to observe STUDENT, testified that an SDC would be the most appropriate primary setting to begin with for STUDENT because of the smaller class size and structure. However, neither of them testified as to how placement in two SDC periods would address STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit, that of social development. On the other hand, Dr. Valdez, Dr. Huynen, and Ms. Dashiell, the professionals who had worked with STUDENT the longest and had been the most involved with his educational program than any of the other witnesses at hearing, all testified that STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit was social development and that he needed exposure to typical peers to address this.
There was neither argument nor evidence that any of the factors enunciated by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994) indicates that STUDENT should be precluded from placement in a regular education class, even for the initial transition period. In Sacramento City, the Court adopted a four-factor balancing test to determine whether a child should be placed in a regular education classroom with supplemental services. The Court found that the following four criteria should be considered: the educational benefits of placement in a regular education class; the non-academic benefits of such a placement; the effect the disabled child will have on the teacher and children in the regular class; and the costs of mainstreaming the disabled child. Id. at 1404. No evidence was produced to suggest that STUDENT would have a negative impact on the teacher and/or children in a regular education classroom or that the cost of placing him in a regular education classroom would be significantly more expensive than an SDC placement. The testimony of all those who have worked with STUDENT the most recently establishes that, although he has a history of disruptive and sometimes aggressive or self-injurious behaviors, he is not demonstrating these behaviors currently. With the appropriate support and acknowledgment of his needs from those working with him, STUDENT has been able to remain “behavior-free.” Additionally, the Hearing Officer notes that the District had agreed to provide STUDENT with a one-on-one instructional assistant during all times that STUDENT was on the Troy campus, even while he was placed in an SDC. Therefore, there would be no cost-difference should STUDENT be placed in a regular education classroom and require one-on-one aide assistance to function in the regular education classroom.
Further, the evidence was overwhelming that placement in a regular education classroom would address STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit and provide him with substantial benefit. A reviewing body must pay “special attention” to those unique benefits a disabled child may obtain from integration in a regular classroom which cannot be achieved in a segregated environment, such as the development of social and communication skills from interaction with nondisabled peers. Oberti v. Board of Educ. of the Borough of Clementon Sch. Dist., 995 F.2d 1204, 1216 (3rd Cir. 1993). As the Fifth Circuit recognized in Daniel R.R.v. State Bd. of Educ., 874 F.2d 1036, 1049 (5th Cir. 1989), a disabled child may be able to absorb only a minimal amount of the regular education program but may benefit enormously from the language models that his nondisabled peers provide. Therefore, even a determination that a child with disabilities might make greater academic progress in a segregated special education class may not warrant excluding that child from a regular classroom environment. Oberti, 995 F.2d at 1217.
Here, the District acknowledges that because of his irregular sleep cycle, STUDENT is not available for school until later than the start of the normal school day. The District also acknowledges that STUDENT requires a slow, gradual transition into the school environment because of his difficulty in tolerating new environments and new people. However, the District has failed to provide for opportunities for STUDENT to participate in the general education program in the limited time that he has available during the school day, and has not established that any opportunities for participation in the general education program would be made available after STUDENT’s successful transition onto the school campus. While the District’s proposed program does include a collaborative dance class consisting of about thirty general education and ten special education students, Dr. Huynen’s testimony establishes that such a large class would not be appropriate for STUDENT during the initial transition period. STUDENT’s difficulty in tolerating crowds and noisy environments, coupled with the stress he is likely to feel at being introduced to the new school environment, would render the collaborative dance class too overwhelming for him at such a fragile stage. Furthermore, while the IEP team may eventually want to consider placement in an SDC for a few periods to ensure STUDENT some one-on-one time to work on specific goals, the fact that STUDENT will only have a very limited amount of time available for attending school during the transition period necessitates that the limited time available be spent addressing his most serious need, which is increasing his social interest and providing him with appropriate social communication role models.
In determining participation in the general education program, the IEP team should take into consideration Dr. Huynen’s testimony that an appropriate way to introduce STUDENT to the new school setting might be initially to allow him to be in the library, where it is quieter and there are less people. STUDENT could begin to familiarize himself with the new school setting in the library by greeting the librarian and a few other students. According to Dr. Huynen, another appropriate general education setting may be a smaller size cooking or art class, where STUDENT could be seated in the back and engage in some sort of motoric activity. A collaborative class consisting of general education and socially appropriate special education students may also be appropriate, so long as it is not a lecture or academic class. Additionally, in determining which classes to place STUDENT in, the team should take into consideration STUDENT’s sensory deficits as they relate to loud noises and difficulty in tolerating large crowds. Finally, STUDENT will still require some specific instruction on a one-on-one, or possibly small-group, basis which may not necessarily be appropriate in the general education setting.
B. Community-based instruction
Second, with regard to the amount of community-based instruction, there is no dispute that STUDENT requires instruction designed to teach him how to function in the community. The dispute centers on whether the District’s proposed program provides STUDENT with sufficient instruction in the community. The Student contends that in order for STUDENT to progress towards independence, he must be given one-on-one instruction in how to interact with others in environments beyond the school setting. The Student requests that thirty hours of services be provided per week in the school and in the community. The District counters that the special education program at Troy provides for a number of community outings that teach and reinforce skills such as recognizing survival sight words, making purchases at stores, and interacting in community environments including amusement parks, as well as opportunities to teach community goals within the school setting.
Dr. Huynen testified that her company’s work with STUDENT took place in the home and in various community settings, and that instruction in the various community settings resulted in STUDENT’s being better able to tolerate a variety of settings. However, Dr. Huynen testified that, when STUDENT was in his home program, his home was not able to provide all of the necessary community settings and so he had to be taken into the community for his community-based instruction. According to Dr. Huynen, the high school is STUDENT’s community, given his age, and the high school can provide the setting for STUDENT’s community-based instruction. Dr. Huynen testified that the school library can stand in place of the public library, the cafeteria can be used to teach the same skills as could be taught in a restaurant, and the school’s pool can provide for the same community-based instruction as one outside of the campus. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Dr. Huynen’s testimony that the Troy campus is able to provide many of the community settings necessary to teach STUDENT the different skills he will need to function in various community settings. However, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District’s proposed program provides for sufficient community-based instruction.
Ms. Kossler’s testimony established that the special education program at Troy brings students into the community to work on various skills on a regular basis. For example, Ms. Kossler testified that the independent living skills class takes its students to the grocery store one time per week, that her SDC English class goes to the mall or out into other parts of the community to work on identifying survival sight words and the practical application of other lessons taught in the classroom, and that the workshop class takes its students off campus for lunch on a fairly regular basis. Given that the program presently at issue is the one meant to transition STUDENT to the school setting and that it is uncertain the degree to which STUDENT eventually will be available to attend a longer school day, it is difficult to predict which of the community outings described by Ms. Kossler STUDENT eventually will be able to attend. Moreover, there was no evidence provided with regard to which of the classes with community-based instruction described by Ms. Kossler, if any, were being proposed for STUDENT.
In light of the fact that STUDENT requires exposure to typical peers but is currently available for instruction during the school day for only a very limited amount of time, the Hearing Officer finds that the District has an obligation to provide STUDENT with community-based instruction after the conclusion of the regular school day, at least during the initial transition period.(Footnote 8) The amount of time that STUDENT is available for school-based instruction may increase in the future, whether because he becomes better able to tolerate the school environment or because of changes in his sleep cycle. Should the amount of time that STUDENT is available for school-based instruction increase, the District thereafter may be able to address his community goals in the school setting or through some of the special education classes mentioned in Ms. Kossler’s testimony. However, until then, STUDENT’s need for instruction to address his functional skill deficits must be addressed in the community since the limited time he has available for school-based instruction necessarily will need to focus on exposure to typical peers. Because the evidence produced at hearing did not establish specifically the amount of instruction STUDENT requires to address his community goals, the frequency of the community-based instruction is a matter left for the IEP team. In determining the frequency of the community-based instruction, the IEP team shall take into consideration the amount of community instruction that STUDENT would receive were he available for the entire length of a regular school day.
C. Instructional assistant hours
Finally, with regard to the Student’s contention regarding the number of hours for the instructional assistant, the Student argues that he requires thirty hours of service from an IA per week. The Student’s request for thirty hours appears to imply that the Student requires a thirty-hour-per-week educational program, which is to consist of school- and community-based instruction.(Footnote 9) The District argues that its proposed program is appropriate given STUDENT’s need to transition slowly onto the school campus and his present unavailability for instruction before 11:00 a.m.
As it presently stands, the District proposes to provide STUDENT with a maximum of two hours per day of school-based instruction (with the amount of services provided dependent on his ability to tolerate the school campus), at least during the initial transition period, in conjunction with five hours per week of speech and language therapy and two hours per week of occupational therapy. For a child with severe global delays such as STUDENT, this amount of services is simply insufficient, even for a transition period. The District has provided no persuasive justification for offering STUDENT an educational program that provides less than three and a half hours of instruction per day. While STUDENT may be unable to attend school to receive instruction during the District’s established school hours, the District retains a responsibility to provide him with an educational program that meets all of his unique educational needs. In this case, the child’s unique needs happen to require instruction outside of the normal school day because of his irregular sleep pattern and unavailability for instruction until at least approximately 11:00 a.m. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make a sufficient offer of services, given STUDENT’s known and undisputed unavailability for instruction during half of the normal school day and the severity of his deficits.
However, nothing in the record establishes that the required amount of instructional service is thirty hours per week, as asserted by the Student. The Hearing Officer is unable to determine from the present record how many IA hours are required per week. Given STUDENT’s need for one-on-one assistance, the amount of instructional assistance must necessarily correlate with the number of hours contained in an educational program for STUDENT. Accordingly, it must first be determined by the IEP team what services STUDENT requires beyond the normal school day before the amount of IA hours may be determined. In determining what additional services STUDENT requires outside of the normal school day, the IEP team shall consider not only community-based instruction but any other type of instruction STUDENT may need to address his unique educational needs, including one-on-one instruction to teach specific skills in the home setting or another quiet environment.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program is not designed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The proposed program does not address STUDENT’s greatest area of deficit (i.e., social development), because it does not provide for participation in the general education program. Secondly, the proposed program does not address the need for community-based instruction, at least during the transition period. Finally, the proposed program does not address STUDENT’s inability to attend the first half of a regularly scheduled school day because of his irregular sleep pattern and, consequently, his need for instruction beyond the normal school day.
II. Is the District’s Proposed Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Educational Benefit?
The Student contends that the District’s proposed program is not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because it does not provide for an adequately trained IA, a consistent person to fill the role of the IA, and access to a computer for instruction. Each of these arguments shall be addressed in turn.
A. Adequately trained instructional assistant
The Student contends that, in the absence of an adequately trained IA, he cannot be expected to benefit from his placement and may regress behaviorally. The Student argues that he requires the services of an IA trained in autism generally and in applied behavior analysis specifically. The Student also argues that he requires the services of an IA trained to understand his unique educational needs, as well as one who has the ability to recognize the sometimes subtle indications of stress and frustration that STUDENT exhibits and the knowledge of how to handle STUDENT in those situations. The District contends that the instructional assistant selected to work with STUDENT has prior experience working with autistic children and that it was the District’s intention that the IA will be trained by Vista and District staff specifically with respect to STUDENT before he begins to work with STUDENT. The District points out that, towards this end, the IA arrived at STUDENT’s house on November 1, along with a Vista staff member and a SELPA program specialist, to meet STUDENT and be trained by Vista to work with him but was refused entrance by the parent.
The evidence establishes that the District chose the person who was intended to be STUDENT’s IA, known at the hearing as Kevin, because of his calm disposition and prior experience working with children with autism and with challenging behaviors. The evidence also establishes that the IEP team was in agreement that the IA would be provided with some training regarding autism and STUDENT’s unique needs. The evidence established that Vista had agreed to assist the District in transitioning STUDENT to the high school campus and in training District staff, including STUDENT’s IA, at the IEP meeting on November 8, 2000.
The testimony of Dr. Valdez, Dr. Huynen, Kenneth Dixon, and Ms. Dashiell made clear that the relationship between STUDENT and his IA would be one of the most important factors in determining whether STUDENT would benefit from his educational program. The testimony of those who had worked with STUDENT previously established that he needed to be provided an IA who was caring and perceptive, with whom he could build a relationship of trust and acceptance, in order for him to be able to succeed in the high school placement. The Hearing Officer finds that the District took this into consideration in determining who would be assigned STUDENT’s IA. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence established that the District realized the need for a trained IA and took some steps to accomplish this. At the IEP meeting, the team agreed that Vista would provide consultation and training for STUDENT’s transition to the school program. Dr. Huynen testified that at the meeting the team discussed having some overlap time with her staff and the District IA, which would allow the IA to observe Vista personnel demonstrate the appropriate way to work with STUDENT, as well as allow the IA to start to provide direct services to STUDENT under the supervision of Vista personnel. Dr. Huynen stated at hearing that Vista continues to be willing to provide this training and supervision to the District IA on STUDENT’s behalf.
However, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to demonstrate that the IA assigned to STUDENT has sufficient training to provide appropriate services to STUDENT so that he is able to benefit from his educational program. Dr. Huynen testified that the IA should have some course or workshop knowledge in applied behavior analysis and autism generally, as well as training on STUDENT and his specific needs, before he is qualified to work with STUDENT. No information was provided with regard to Kevin’s previous training in autism, except that he has been an IA for the District for two and a half years and has previously worked with some children with autism or autistic-like characteristics. Second, no specific information was provided with regard to how many hours of training the IA was expected to receive before working directly with STUDENT. It is noted that the District’s transition plan had specifically provided for only one visit to allow the IA to get acquainted with STUDENT before STUDENT begins his transition to the high school campus, and that the visit was scheduled at an hour when it is known that STUDENT is generally unavailable for instruction because of his irregular sleep cycle. Third, Dr. Huynen stated that there was no discussion at the IEP meeting regarding the specifics of what Vista was expected to provide to assist in the IA training. It is noted that the IEP also does not provide any information with regard to what training the IA would have before working with STUDENT. Given that an appropriately trained IA is crucial to making the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit and the District failed to establish at hearing that the IA would be appropriately trained to provide services to STUDENT in the school setting, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to show that its proposed program is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. The District shall assign an IA to STUDENT who is trained in autism, applied behavior analysis, techniques to address challenging behaviors, and STUDENT’s unique needs.(Footnote 10) The extent of the training necessary shall be determined by the IEP team in consultation with Dr. Huynen, if possible, or Dr. Valdez and shall be noted in the IEP.
B. Consistent person to fill instructional assistant position
Another element that was established at hearing as important in making the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit was the consistency of the IA. Dr. Huynen, Mr. Dixon, Ms. Dashiell, and Dr. Valdez all testified that STUDENT has difficulty adjusting to new staff and that, during the period of adjustment, STUDENT makes little to no progress except in terms of increasing his ability to tolerate working with that particular staff member and that his behavior often deteriorates. Mr. Dixon, who worked the most closely with STUDENT and his IAs during the period when Vista provided services, testified that it may take STUDENT up to three months to feel comfortable with a new IA and for that IA to become comfortable with him. Dr. Valdez agreed that consistency is extremely important for autistic children like STUDENT. Dr. Valdez testified that having to train another IA every three months would be greatly counterproductive to STUDENT’s ability to progress because he would need to go through that period of readjustment each time and would only benefit after establishing a comfortable relationship with that new person. Dr. Huynen testified that STUDENT requires a change in IA at least every six months in order to ensure generalization of skills and that it would be appropriate to have two to three IAs on a rotating schedule working with STUDENT at any given time. However, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Dr. Valdez’s testimony that introducing new aides should be left until at least a few weeks into STUDENT’s attendance at the school site, when he has had an opportunity to become more comfortable with the new school environment and the other staff members at that site.
According to the information available at hearing, the District members of the IEP team had in mind a person to fill the IA role for STUDENT in November 2000. According to special education department chair Rich Hess, Kevin was to be assigned to work with STUDENT during his initial transition to Troy and Kevin’s time with STUDENT would increase as STUDENT’s time on campus increased. There was no evidence that the District intended to change STUDENT’s IA during his transition to the high school campus. Additionally, although a school district is never able to guarantee consistency in personnel, there was no evidence to suggest that the provision of STUDENT’s IA services was intended to be anything but consistent.
C. Access to a computer
The Student contends that STUDENT requires access to a computer and that because the District did not note in the IEP that computer access would be provided to STUDENT during his educational program, the District’s proposed program is not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that the testimony of Ms. Dashiell and MOTHER established that STUDENT has recently developed an interest in working on the computer and that the computer may be used as a valuable tool in introducing literacy and other basic academic skills. However, while it may be of benefit to STUDENT to include computer access during some portion of the school day, there is no evidence that he requires computer access to address his unique needs or to benefit from his education. Further, there is no indication that the District was required to provide specifically for computer access on STUDENT’s IEP in order to offer him a FAPE. Regardless, the testimony of Ms. Kossler established that computers are very accessible to students on the Troy campus.
III. Does the District’s Proposed Program Conform with STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute regarding whether the District’s proposed program conforms with STUDENT’s IEP.
IV. Does the District’s Proposed Program Provide STUDENT an Education in the Least Restrictive Environment?
The final step is to determine whether the District’s proposed program will provide STUDENT with an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Student contends that the District’s proposed program does not provide STUDENT an education in the LRE because it does not provide for interaction with typical peers or placement in STUDENT’s neighborhood school.
A. Interaction with typical peers
Special education law requires that a child with disabilities be educated in the least restrictive environment. Specifically, the IDEA provides that state and local educational agencies must ensure that:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities ... are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.
20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).
As discussed in Section I, subsection (A) of this Decision, STUDENT’s unique educational needs in the area of social development require that his program include participation in the general education program. Because the District’s proposed program does not provide STUDENT with any opportunities to participate in the general education program and none of the factors cited in Sacramento City indicate that STUDENT should be segregated from his typical peers during the majority of the school day, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program failed to provide STUDENT with an education in the LRE.
B. Placement in neighborhood school
As for the Student’s contention regarding placement in the neighborhood school, the evidence produced at hearing established that STUDENT would be assigned to Fullerton High School (Fullerton), not Troy, in the ordinary course of things were he not a disabled student. STUDENT’s home is located on the boundary line between Fullerton and Troy, with the houses on his side of the street assigned to Fullerton and the houses on the other side of the street assigned to Troy. However, STUDENT’s house is located geographically closer to Troy and, according to the testimony of special education director Ronald Anderson, the majority of the high-school-age students residing in STUDENT’s neighborhood attend Troy under the District’s “open enrollment” policy.(Footnote 11)
The Student contends that the District should have offered STUDENT placement in his home school, Fullerton. The District argues that Troy is a sort of special education magnet school with the resources and personnel necessary to provide STUDENT with an appropriate program, while Fullerton generally serves children with less severe disabilities and would not be able to provide the same level of resources and personnel to meet STUDENT’s needs.
Consistent with the LRE requirement, school districts are required to ensure that a child’s placement “is as close as possible to the child’s home.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.552(b)(3). School districts are also required to ensure that, “[u]nless the IEP of a child with a disability requires some other arrangement, the child is educated in the school that he or she would attend if nondisabled.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.552(c). However, these provisions create at most a preference for education in the school that the child would attend if not disabled (i.e., the neighborhood school). Murray v. Montrose Co. Sch. Dist. RE-1J, 51 F.3d 921, 929 (10th Cir. 1995). As the Court stated in Murray:
A natural and logical reading of these two regulations is that a disabled child should be educated in the school he or she would attend if not disabled (i.e., the neighborhood school) unless the child’s IEP requires placement elsewhere. If the IEP requires placement elsewhere, then in deciding where the appropriate placement is, geographical proximity to home is relevant, and the child should be placed as close to home as possible. [Citations omitted.]
Id. (italics in original).
It should be noted, however, that the proximity preference is merely one of many factors for a district to take into consideration in determining a student’s proper placement and does not amount to a presumption that a disabled student should attend his or her neighborhood school. Flour Bluff Independent Sch. Dist. v. Katherine M., 91 F.3d 689, 693-694 (5th Cir. 1996). Therefore, for example, when a school district has an obligation to provide a disabled child with a school placement that includes a full-time nurse on duty, it is not required to change the district’s placement of nurses when care is readily available at another easily accessible school. Kevin G. v. Cranston Sch. Committee, 130 F.3d 481, 482 (1st Cir. 1997).
Here, Troy is the school located “as close as possible” to STUDENT’s home but is not officially his neighborhood school. However, based on the evidence produced at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that Troy is STUDENT’s de facto neighborhood school in that it is the school located closest to his home and is the site which most of his high-school-age neighbors attend. The apparent purpose of creating a regulatory preference for a child’s neighborhood school is to maintain that sense of community for the child. Under the unique circumstances of this case, placement at Troy would serve that purpose, although it is not STUDENT’s official neighborhood school. Moreover, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT’s IEP calls for placement at Troy. According to the testimony of many of the witnesses, the Troy campus offers STUDENT an abundant array of support services that he would not be able to receive at Fullerton. For example, Ms. Kossler provided testimony regarding the many opportunities for community outings through the Troy special education program. Ms. Kossler also described the many functional skills classes available at Troy such as the independent living skills class, the manners and social skills class, and the communication skills class. Additionally, unlike Fullerton, the Troy campus offers teachers experienced in working with severely handicapped students and staff in general who have more experience integrating severely handicapped students into the general education program. Furthermore, Dr. Valdez testified that because of the community and level of acceptance of and services for children with disabilities on the Troy campus, he would recommend it as the appropriate placement for STUDENT. Conversely, the testimony produced at hearing regarding Fullerton did not establish that it had the appropriate personnel and programs to provide STUDENT with the level of services, including community-based instruction, he requires.
Since the level of services that STUDENT requires is readily available at an easily accessible school, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate the LRE requirement when it offered STUDENT placement at Troy instead of his neighborhood school. However, as discussed earlier, the District did violate the LRE requirement by failing to provide for sufficient opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers.
* * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed program for the 2000-2001 school year fails to offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education. The District’s proposed program failed to address STUDENT’s unique educational needs in that it did not provide for participation in the general education program, services beyond the regularly scheduled school day, or an adequate number of hours of instructional assistance. The proposed program also is not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit because it did not provide for an appropriately trained instructional assistant. Finally, the proposed program failed to offer STUDENT an education in the least restrictive environment because it failed to include opportunities for participation in the general education program. The District is ordered to convene an IEP meeting to develop a new IEP consistent with the findings contained herein.
ORDER
Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of discussing, developing, and offering an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. The program shall conform with the findings made herein and shall have, at a minimum, the following characteristics:
1. Significant opportunities for participation in the general education program – selection of the appropriate opportunities for participation in the general education program shall take into consideration STUDENT’s sensitivity to loud noise, difficulty in tolerating being in the presence of a large group of people, and low academic achievement
2. Opportunities for specific instruction in a one-on-one or small-group setting in a quiet environment
3. Services beyond the regularly scheduled school day, at least during the transition period when STUDENT is not available for the length of the regularly scheduled school day a. Such services shall include community-based instruction, at least during the transition period, and one-on-one instruction in a quiet environment, such as the home setting b. In determining the frequency of such services, the IEP team shall take into consideration the amount of instruction STUDENT would receive if he was available for the length of the entire school day
4. The services of an instructional assistant trained in autism, applied behavior analysis, techniques to address challenging behaviors, and STUDENT’s unique needs – the extent of the training shall be determined in consultation with Dr. Huynen, if possible, or Dr. Valdez and shall be noted in the IEP.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: Respondent STUDENT substantially prevailed on the only issue heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Date: May 2, 2001 Hee C. Kim, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
Footnote 1: According to MOTHER, STUDENT was diagnosed as autistic at the age of four. Footnote 2: In January 2000, BCA sold off the child portion of their business to Kim Huynen, Ph.D. Dr. Huynen formerly worked with BCA and is now the owner and manager of Vista Behavior Consulting (Vista). Since January 2000, Vista has provided the services to STUDENT that he previously received from BCA. Footnote 3: By letter dated September 25, 2000, MOTHER had informed FESD that she believed that the Vista services were of little to no value to STUDENT because he often was very agitated and aggressive during the therapists’ visits. She also indicated in the letter that she was concerned over the inconsistency of the persons sent to provide services, as well as the amount of services provided. She requested that the IEP team consider immediately discontinuing Vista’s services and discuss alternate therapist providers. Footnote 4: According to testimony produced at hearing, STUDENT, like many with autism, has difficulty with his sleep cycles. STUDENT often has difficulty sleeping at night and typically wakes at about 11:00 a.m. Some nights, STUDENT sleeps only three to four hours, causing him to sleep ten to twelve hours several nights later. Occasionally, STUDENT does not sleep at all. Footnote 5: According to MOTHER’s testimony, she often takes STUDENT to Disneyland and currently takes him to Disneyland a minimum of two times per week. MOTHER testified that he is becoming very independent at Disneyland. November 14, 2000, was the day scheduled for Troy’s annual field trip to Disneyland. Footnote 6: In his closing argument, the Student also argues for the first time that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-20001 because of alleged stay-put violations. This argument had not been raised previously in the Student’s request for hearing in SN 3-01 or during the discussion of issues on the first day of hearing, the Student’s opening arguments, or any other time in the course of the hearing process. Because it was understood at all times during the hearing process that the issue for hearing centered on whether the District’s proposed program is appropriate for STUDENT and should be implemented prospectively, and that the hearing did not involve any allegations of procedural violations, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student failed to put in dispute during the hearing process whether the District complied with the stay-put provision. Therefore, this Decision will not adjudicate any issues with regard to what the District’s obligations were under the stay-put provision during the 2000-2001 school year or whether the District met those obligations. Footnote 7: Dr. Valdez qualified this statement, however, by noting that the data indicated that STUDENT had “recovered” some of the lost progress during the period Vista provided him with services. Footnote 8: As established by Dr. Huynen’s testimony, the high school campus has facilities available for instruction in community goals. However, since the school is closed at the conclusion of the regularly scheduled school day, those school facilities will no longer be available for STUDENT and therefore the community goals will need to be addressed within the community. Footnote 9: Thirty hours per week of services is what STUDENT was receiving from Vista pursuant to an FESD IEP and mediation agreement, prior to the transition of educational responsibility from FESD to the District. Footnote 10: The District may choose to provide Kevin with sufficient training in these areas before he begins to work directly with STUDENT or assign another person to serve as STUDENT’s IA. Footnote 11: Mr. Anderson explained that, during an approximately five-week period in January and February, the open enrollment policy allows students in the District to select any District school to attend, with students being denied admission to their school of choice only when a cap has been placed on the number of students a school can admit.
