California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · October 26, 2001
Student v. Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2034-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard
Huntington Beach City Elementary must provide compensatory OT, DTT and speech services to a preschooler with autism; most other claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Within the case, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner's motion to disqualify her and dismiss without prejudice (Order of May 22, 2001) and also denied reconsideration. A separate due process hearing and decision concerned the presence of the District's attorney at the May 11, 2001 IEP meeting. In a parallel compliance complaint about the parent support group, CDE found the District in compliance.
Summary
The self-represented parents of a preschooler with autism filed for due process against Huntington Beach City Elementary School District over the 2000-2001 school year and the extended school year (ESY). They challenged the district's assessments, the special day class (SDC) placement at Hawes Elementary, the amount of speech therapy, a cut to occupational therapy (OT), a delay in discrete trial training (DTT), and their own involvement in the program. The Hearing Officer found the psycho-educational, speech, OT and adaptive physical education assessments timely and appropriate. The district did not have to assess for music therapy, recreation therapy or DTT. The SDC was the least restrictive environment. Later, the SDC plus two days a week at St. Wilfred's preschool with a shadow aide was the least restrictive environment. Forty minutes of weekly speech therapy was enough during the school year because the SDC and DTT also worked on language. However, the district denied FAPE in three limited ways. It dropped the student's weekly 30-minute group OT without parent agreement from January 8 to May 11, 2001. It delayed DTT for one month while hiring an aide. Its ESY speech offer was too small once the student left the SDC and DTT was cut in half. The district must provide 540 minutes of group OT, 32 hours of DTT, and 320 minutes of individual speech therapy within three months. Reimbursement for the parents' independent evaluations was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO measured related services against a student's whole program. Speech therapy that was enough with daily SDC and DTT support was not enough for ESY once those supports were gone. The decision also held that a district may not delay early-intervention services for a young child with autism while it hires staff.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue I. Did the District provide timely and appropriate assessments of Student in psycho-educational, speech and language, OT, APE, music therapy, recreational therapy, play skills, discrete trial training (DTT), and physical therapy (PT)?
Assessment plans and assessments were timely and appropriate; the District did not have to assess for music therapy, recreation therapy, or DTT, and it assessed play skills within the OT and APE evaluations.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue II. If the District did not provide timely and appropriate assessments, must it develop an assessment plan or convene an IEP meeting to consider Petitioner's independent assessments?
Because the assessments were proper, there was no basis to order new assessment plans or an IEP meeting.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue III A. Did the District deny FAPE for 2000-2001 by failing to timely assess Student in all areas of need?
Student was appropriately assessed in all areas of need, so there was no denial of FAPE.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue III B. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to provide a placement in the least restrictive environment?
The SDC was appropriate and the LRE from October to December 2000, and the SDC combined with a regular preschool was the LRE after that.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue III C. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to offer an appropriate type and amount of speech and language services?
Two 20-minute sessions a week, together with language work in the SDC and DTT, met Student's pragmatic language needs and provided educational benefit.
- Student prevailedImplementation
Issue III D. Did the District deny FAPE by unilaterally changing his occupational therapy services?
The parents had consented to the full OT offer, and the District denied FAPE by removing the 30-minute weekly group OT from January 8 to May 11, 2001 without parent agreement.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue III E. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to adequately or timely implement the IEP in reporting progress, providing speech and language services, or DTT services?
Any lapses in progress reporting caused no prejudice and speech services matched the IEP, but delaying DTT one month to hire an aide denied FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue III F. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to make an appropriate offer of extended school year services?
The ESY offer of 40 minutes of weekly speech was too little without the SDC and with DTT halved; Student needed two one-hour individual sessions a week.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue III G. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to allow appropriate parental involvement in his education program?
The parents took an active part in seven IEP meetings, goal drafting, and DTT meetings, so they were not denied involvement.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue III H. Did the District deny FAPE by failing to facilitate or allow the development of a parent support group at Student's SDC preschool class?
FAPE did not require a parent support group specific to the class.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue IV A. If the District denied FAPE, is Student entitled to compensatory education?
Hour-for-hour compensatory OT, DTT, and speech services were ordered for the three violations; all other requests for compensatory education were denied.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue IV B. Must the District reinstate his group OT services pending further assessment?
Reinstatement was not appropriate because Student had left the SDC and his individual OT had been increased; compensatory education was the remedy.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue IV C. Must the District provide speech and language services consistent with the recommendations of his independent assessor?
The independent assessor's level of service was not required during the school year but was required during ESY, which compensatory services addressed.
- District prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue V. Must the District reimburse Petitioner's parents for the cost of independent speech and language and occupational therapy assessments?
Reimbursement for the independent speech, OT, and psychological evaluations was denied because the District's assessments were appropriate.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. Small-group OT for a total of 540 minutes. If both sides agree, nine one-hour individual OT sessions instead.
- Compensatory education. DTT services for a total of 32 hours.
- Compensatory education. Individual speech and language services for a total of 320 minutes.
- All compensatory services must be completed within three months of receipt of the decision, unless the parties agree to a different schedule.
Total: 46.33 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. Missouri; Amanda J. v. Clark County
People named in the decision
- Etta Marie Smith, principal, Hawes Elementary School
- Collette Amedee, district speech-language therapist, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
- Linda Herrick, school psychologist and case carrier, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
- Theresa Colomb, preschool special day class teacher, Hawes Elementary School
- Cheri Carpenter, physical education teacher and adaptive physical education specialist, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
- Leora Ann Shaffer, independent speech-language pathologist (IEE), Speech Pathology Associates
- Dr. Duane Dishno, superintendent, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
- Meryl Schrantz, program specialist and DTT supervisor, WOCCSE
- Barbara Cracchiolo, occupational therapist, WOCCSE
- Charlotte Ann Feichtmann, private pediatric physical therapist who assessed at the District's request, Private
- John Conniff, director of administrative services, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
- Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, psychologist who evaluated Student; witness for Student, Private
- Jim Hemsley, SELPA director, WOCCSE
- Dr. Ira Lott, diagnosing physician, professor of pediatrics and neurology, University of California, Irvine
- Amy Marshall, independent occupational therapist (IEE), Private
- Irene White, program director, WOCCSE
- Dr. Stein, physician who recommended a PT assessment, Private
- Pamela M. Lewis, private speech-language provider, Private
- St. Wilfred's, private typical preschool, Private preschool
- Hearing Officer Gant, Hearing Officer who handled the initial prehearing matters, Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Huntington Beach, California, on February 13, 14, 20, 21, March 29 and 30, May 23, and July 13 and 31, 2001.
Petitioner Student (hereafter, Petitioner or Student) was represented at the hearing by his father, Student’s Father, who is not an attorney. Also present on Student’s behalf was his mother, Student’s Mother. Respondent Huntington Beach City Elementary School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Caroline A. Zuk, from the law firm of Miller, Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District’s behalf was its director of administrative services, John Conniff. Jim Hemsley, director of the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE), was present on all hearing days except the last three dates.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: Etta Marie Smith, principal of Hawes Elementary School, speech therapist Collette Amedee, school psychologist Linda Herrick, Hawes special day class teacher Theresa Colomb, physical education teacher and adaptive physical education specialist Cheri Carpenter, independent speech and language therapist Leora Ann Shaffer, school superintendent Dr. Duane Dishno, WOCCSE program specialist Meryl Schrantz, WOCCSE occupational therapist Barbara Cracchiolo, private physical therapist Charlotte Ann Feichtmann, John Conniff, Student’s Mother, Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, and Student’s Father.
Respondent examined witnesses called by the Petitioner to present its case.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the conclusion of the hearing, the record remained open to allow the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision. ISSUES(Footnote 2)
I. Did the District provide timely and appropriate assessments of Student in the following areas: psycho-educational, speech and language, occupational therapy (OT), adaptive physical education (APE), music therapy, recreational therapy, play skills, discrete trial training (DTT), and physical therapy (PT)?
II. If the District did not provide timely and appropriate assessments of Student in any of the areas listed above, must it develop an assessment plan in any of these areas or convene an individualized educational program (IEP) meeting to consider the results and recommendations contained in Petitioner’s independent assessments and any assessments that may be ordered in connection with this hearing?
III. Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year by:
A. failing to timely assess him in all areas of need;
B. failing to provide a placement in the least restrictive environment; C. failing to offer an appropriate type and amount of speech and language services; D. unilaterally changing his occupational therapy services;
E. failing to adequately or timely implement the IEP in the areas of reporting progress, providing speech and language services, or DTT services;
F. failing to make an appropriate offer of extended school year services; G. failing to allow appropriate parental involvement in his education program; and/or H. failing to facilitate or allow the development of a parent support group at Student’s SDC preschool class with Ms. Colomb at Hawes School?
IV. If the District denied Student a FAPE to the extent described in Issue III,
A. is he entitled to compensatory education?
B. must the District reinstate his group OT services pending further assessment? C. must the District provide him with speech and language services consistent with the recommendations of his independent assessor?
V. Must the District reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of independent speech and language and occupational therapy assessments?(Footnote 3)
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
At the conclusion of the due process hearing, Student had recently turned four years old. Student had been found eligible for special education and related services as an individual with autism in October 2000, and had received such services during the 2000-2001 school and extended school (ESY) year. During the ESY 2001, Student was placed at St. Wilfred’s, a private typical preschool, with a shadow aide, and received his related services/designated instruction and services (DIS services) through the District.
On August 25, 2000, at three years two months of age, Student was diagnosed with autism by Dr. Ira Lott, professor of pediatrics and neurology at the University of California, Irvine. Dr. Lott indicated that “Student meets all of the salient criteria for autism. He has had a delay in language, difficulty with eye contact, relative social disinterest, preservation of sameness, sensitivity to loud sounds, transitional difficulties, echolalia, and a fair degree of hyperactivity.” Dr. Lott indicated that Student appeared to be on the “moderate” end of the autistic spectrum. He recommended that Student enroll in a preschool class for children with autism, with an emphasis on speech, language, and socialization.
That same day, Student’s Father advised the District of Student’s diagnosis. Ms. Smith, principal of Hawes School, completed a referral for assessment form on Student in the suspected area of disability of autism. District school psychologist Linda Herrick was assigned as Student’s case carrier.
September 5, 2000, was the first day of school for the District’s 2000-2001 school year. On September 7, 2000, Ms. Herrick prepared a proposed assessment plan for Student to be assessed in the following areas of suspected disability: health; language/communication function; general ability, including intellectual functioning; academic performance, including pre-readiness skills; and social and emotional status. Motor ability was not a proposed area of assessment. Student’s Father signed the assessment plan that day.
On September 7 and 19, 2000, Ms. Herrick conducted a preschool developmental assessment/psycho-educational evaluation of Student. As a result of her assessment, Ms. Herrick recommended that the IEP team make Student eligible for special education due to his diagnosis of autism, that it set goals and objectives for Student “in the main developmental areas,” and that it consider placing him in a preschool special day class (SDC).
On September 19, 2000, a speech and language evaluation of Student was conducted by District speech therapist Collette Amedee. Ms. Amedee determined that Student demonstrated difficulties with his pragmatics, or use of language. She recommended that Student receive speech and language services once a week to address identified weaknesses and that those weaknesses also be addressed in his classroom communication goals.
October 5, 2000 Initial IEP
At his initial IEP meeting on October 5, 2000, Student was determined to be eligible for special education as a child with autism. The IEP team offered Student placement in the pre-kindergarten special day class (SDC) at Hawes preschool for one year, five days a week from 8:30 to 12:15 daily, excluding DIS services. The IEP team approved seven annual goals for Student in the areas of social communication, social skills, cognitive skills, self-care, fine motor, and speech and language. The IEP team agreed, however, that the classroom teacher version of the Evaluation and Programming System (EPS) would be administered to Student within thirty days after he began his placement and that his goals would be modified as indicated. In addition, Student would participate in recess twenty minutes a day and in assemblies with “typical” students at Hawes. Student would attend regular physical education; however, APE and OT evaluations would be completed within thirty days of placement. Student was determined to be eligible for ESY with speech and language service as indicated on the IEP.
The IEP team increased Ms. Amedee’s recommended level of speech services. Student was offered speech and language therapy twice weekly, for a total of forty minutes. The team agreed that Ms. Amedee would provide the parents with an oral report within thirty days of the start of service regarding the goals and services and any recommendations for change in the program or services.
At the conclusion of the IEP meeting, Student’s Mother initialed her consent to the IEP program, the goals and objectives, and to the program placement and designated instruction services, with one exception noted. Next to the box for permission for program placement and DIS services, Student’s Mother wrote that the “number of days per week to be discussed.” All goals were initialed by the parents. Despite this consent, in hindsight, Petitioner’s parents believed they had not been provided with sufficient information by the District to give their ‘informed consent’ to the IEP. Student’s Father argued that the IEP was, essentially, an adhesion contract.(Footnote 4)
On October 10, 2000, Student began attending Ms. Colomb’s SDC class at Hawes. Prior to his enrollment, Ms. Herrick provided the parents with a document from the Orange County Department of Education entitled the “Systematic Utilization of Comprehensive Strategies for Ensuring Student Success” or “S.U.C.S.E.S.S. Classroom Components.” Ms. Herrick advised the parents that these components were used in Student’s class. Parent support groups were listed as part of the “Support of Families” component. Student’s Mother testified that this was exactly what she was looking for in a classroom.
On October 24, 2000, Student’s Father wrote to District Superintendent Dr. Dishno to file a formal complaint against WOCCSE director Jim Hemsley.(Footnote 5) The underlying basis of this complaint was the parents’ concern that Student’s OT and APE evaluations were not completed in a timely manner.
In late October and early November 2000, Student was assessed by both the APE and OT therapists. District APE specialist Cheri Carpenter found that Student was functioning below age expectancy in his gross motor domain and recommended that he receive APE services. WOCCSE occupational therapist Barbara Cracchiolo also concluded that Student appeared to be having motor difficulties and recommended that OT services be determined by the IEP team.
November 13, 2000 IEP Meeting
On November 13, 2000, the IEP team reviewed Student’s OT and APE assessments. The IEP team recommended that Student receive APE services twice a week for a total of sixty minutes and OT services once a week for a total of forty-five minutes. The team also reviewed fifteen goals proposed by Student’s SDC teacher, Ms. Colomb, after her completion of the EPS, as well as goals proposed by Ms. Carpenter and Ms. Cracchiolo. In addition to the goals approved at Student’s initial IEP meeting, nineteen new goals were presented by the IEP team in the areas of cognition, social communication, social skills, self-care, fine motor, APE and OT. The IEP team also recommended that Student receive four sessions of discrete trial training (DTT) a week for a total of eight hours in the SDC classroom, with services to begin on December 13, 2000. DTT team meetings were offered once a month for an hour.
Petitioner’s parents requested (1) individual speech and language sessions for Student four days a week for thirty minutes each session, (2) related services for Student in art, music and swimming therapy; and (3) that Student be transitioned to a typical preschool. The District denied the request for additional speech services “based on appropriate education being provided.” The District denied the other requests as well, but indicated they would be discussed at the next IEP meeting. The parents were asked to provide more information about programs they were considering. At the conclusion of the IEP meeting, the parents initialed only that they had received the notice of rights. Consent was not provided for the program, goals and objectives, or placement.
On November 14, 2000, Student’s Father wrote to Mr. Conniff to advise him that the parents intended to obtain an independent educational evaluation (IEE) in the area of OT, but that they consented to the OT and APE services offered by the District and asked that they be initiated for Student without delay. Also on November 14, 2000, Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing due to the District’s denial of additional speech therapy services and related services of art/music therapy, and occupational/recreational therapy.
Student’s Mother testified that, after Student was enrolled in Ms. Colomb’s class, she felt there was little parental involvement in the SDC class. Hoping to start a parent support group specific to Student’s SDC class, on November 20, 2000, Student’s Mother asked Hawes principal Marie Smith if she could send eight flyers through the school’s distribution system to the parents of the students in Student’s class. Ms. Smith checked with school superintendent Dr. Dishno about distribution of flyers by the school. Following this consultation, Ms. Smith advised Student’s Mother that distribution of the parents’ flyers through the school’s distribution system was not allowed.(Footnote 6)
December 7, 2000 IEP
On December 7, 2000, the IEP team agreed to place Student in a regular preschool class two days a week for a total of eight hours, with a shadow aide, beginning on January 8, 2001. To accommodate that change, the team agreed to reduce Student’s placement at the Hawes SDC from five to three days a week. The team notes reflect that, while at Hawes, Student would continue to participate in recess, assemblies and music with typical kindergarten children. The parents disagreed that Student had an opportunity to interact with typical peers during these times at Hawes. The team added new or modified goals in the areas of speech and language, social skills, social-communication, and APE to those originally proposed but not authorized during the November 13, 2000 IEP. The team agreed that “staff will provide monthly written updates on Student’s goals and objectives.”
The IEP team clarified the manner in which Student’s DTT services were to be provided. Effective on January 8, 2001, the eight hours a week of DTT services would be split between Student’s home and the SDC classroom. In addition to the previously-offered monthly DTT team meetings, two hours per month of DTT supervision would be provided by WOCCSE personnel. Student’s OT services were expanded to include one session of group OT in class for thirty minutes a week, in addition to the forty-five minutes a week of individual OT. Because Student, like all the children in the SDC class, had already been receiving these group OT services, the parents indicated their disagreement that group OT was a ‘designated instructional service’ (DIS) on the IEP document. The IEP team noted that the District “owed” Student four individual OT sessions as of that date.(Footnote 7) The District denied the parents’ requests that Student attend the Pacific School of Music and the Arts for one day a week with a shadow aide and receive one weekly swimming lesson fifty-two weeks of the year at the Blue Buoy Swim School. At the conclusion of this IEP meeting, the parents did not consent to the program, goals, objective, placement or services. However, on December 8, 2000, Student’s Father initialed his consent to all of Student’s goals.
On December 18, 2000, Student’s Father advised Mr. Conniff of the parents’ intent to obtain an IEE in the area of speech and language. On December 21, 2000, Leora A. Shaffer from Speech Pathology Associates conducted a speech and language evaluation of Student. Ms. Shaffer diagnosed Student with a speech disorder and with a receptive/expressive language disorder. She recommended that Student receive individual speech/language therapy twice weekly for one hour each for a period of at least six months.
On January 2, 2001, Student began attending St. Wilfred’s preschool.
January 19, 2001 IEP
At the IEP meeting of January 19, 2001, the IEP team eliminated Student’s thirty-minute group OT, because Student was attending St. Wilfred’s preschool on Tuesday, when the SDC class at Hawes received its group OT services. The parents objected to the elimination of this service. To replace that service, the District proposed OT consultation with Student’s shadow aide at St. Wilfred’s and the IEP indicated that Student’s shadow aide at St. Wilfred would be provided with thirty minutes of monthly consultation by both the speech and language specialist and the occupational therapist. The parents requested additional time for speech and language. The IEP team made no change in Student’s total time for speech services. In response to Ms. Shaffer’s evaluation, the team agreed that Ms. Amedee would forward additional speech and language goals by January 23, 2001. The parents did not consent to this IEP.
On January 29, 2001, pediatric physical therapist Charlotte Feichtmann conducted a physical therapy (PT) evaluation of Student at the request of the District through WOCCSE. Ms. Feichtmann concluded that PT for strengthening “was not educationally necessary to help Student learn in school or access his environment.” While she agreed that pool therapy may be beneficial for Student, Ms. Feichtmann could not state that it would help him to learn or to access his school environment. She recommended that the family pursue funding for swimming through their medical insurance. Ms. Feichtmann also concluded that occupational therapy in the area of sensory integration (OT/SI) was educationally necessary for Student to learn and recommended that Student receive individual OT services twice a week. During her testimony, Ms. Feichtmann conceded that she would defer to the recommendation of an occupational therapist on this issue.(Footnote 8)
The due process hearing commenced on February 13, 2001. Following the commencement of the hearing, three IEP meetings were held that involved the 2000-2001 school and extended school year.
At the April 6, 2001 IEP team meeting, the team reviewed Student’s PT assessment by Ms. Feichtmann as well as the parents’ independent occupational therapy evaluation by Amy Marshall. Ms. Marshall recommended that Student receive OT services twice a week. Ms. Marshall was not present at the IEP meeting and did not testify at the due process hearing. The IEP team did not recommend a change in the level of Student’s OT services and did not offer PT services. The parents did not consent to this IEP.
At the May 11, 2001 IEP meeting, the IEP team doubled the total amount of Student’s individual OT services to two forty-five minute sessions a week for a weekly total of ninety minutes. This increase in OT services was occasioned by Ms. Cracchiolo’s observation that Student was demonstrating behaviors that could be considered sensory seeking or sensory avoiding (e.g., chewing holes in his shirts, having a difficulty in his balance, putting his head on the floor in an upside down position). Two OT goals were added to the IEP and consented to by Student’s Mother.(Footnote 9) The team agreed that a pragmatic language goal(/s) would be submitted to the parents by May 25, 2001.
The IEP team also outlined Student’s ESY program and agreed that he would attend St. Wilfred’s preschool for three hours each day, with a shadow aide, from June 26 through July 26, 2001. During this same period, Student would receive DIS services of twice weekly speech and language for a total of forty minutes (one individual and one group), twice weekly APE for a total of sixty minutes, twice weekly OT for a total of ninety minutes and DTT services two hours a week at home and two hours per week at school.(Footnote 10) The parents did not consent to this IEP at the meeting, but later advised Mr. Conniff in writing that they consented to the IEP team’s proposed change in Student’s OT individual services and to program placement and/or DIS services in this IEP subject to their amendments.
On June 11, 2001 an IEP Addendum meeting was held. The IEP team agreed that the occupational therapist would work on eight of the goals and objectives originally identified in the December 7, 2000 IEP. The team also agreed that Student would attend the August maintenance program for DTT. The parents consented to the addendum on that date and subsequently initialed their consent to the OT and pragmatic language goals.
Motion to Recuse the Hearing Officer
On May 14, 2001, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s motion to disqualify the Hearing Officer and to dismiss the case without prejudice. Hearing Officer denied this motion in the Order dated May 22, 2001. In essence, the Hearing Officer found that superintendent Dr. Dishno’s letter to the Director of the Hearing Office about the Hearing Officer’s rulings during the pendency of the due process hearing constituted an indirect ex parte communication with the Hearing Officer. The Hearing Officer concluded, however, that her review of this letter would not result in an inability to impartially hear and decide the case and was not a sufficient ground for disqualification. At the reconvened hearing on May 23, 2001, Petitioner made an oral motion for reconsideration of the denial of his motion to disqualify and dismiss. That motion, supported by documents marked as Petitioner’s Exhibits E 1-4, provided no new or different facts, circumstances, or law that did not exist prior to the Hearing Officer’s ruling on the original motion. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer denied Petitioner’s motion for reconsideration.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE 1: Did the District provide timely and appropriate assessments of Student in the following areas: psycho-educational, speech and language, occupational therapy, recreational therapy, music therapy, physical therapy, discrete trial training (DTT), adaptive physical education, and play skills?
Under the IDEA and state law, before providing special education and related services, a local educational agency must conduct a full and individual initial assessment of a student with a suspected disability to determine his eligibility for special education and his educational needs. 20 U.S.C. §1414(a)(1)(A), Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. Parental consent must be obtained before the evaluation is conducted. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(1)(C), Educ. Code § 56321(c). The child must be assessed “in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, including low vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, career and vocational abilities and interests, and social and emotional needs.” Educ. Code § 56320(f), 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C).
A written assessment plan must be provided to the parents within fifteen calendar days of the referral for assessment “not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions or terms or days of school vacation in excess of five schooldays from the date of receipt of the referral, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an extension.” Educ. Code §§ 56321(a), 56043(a), 56023. A ‘referral for assessment’ means a written request for assessment to identify an individual with exceptional needs made by a parent, teacher, or other service provider.” Educ. Code § 56029. An IEP required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed fifty days, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five school days, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees, in writing, to an assessment. Educ. Code § 56344.
The assessments must be conducted by qualified persons in conformity with the requirements of Education Code § 56320 as follows: testing and assessment materials and procedures used for assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory (§ 56320, subdiv. (a)); tests and assessment materials must (1) be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication; (2) be validated for the purpose for which they are used; (3) be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions (§ 56320, subdiv. (b)); include those tests and assessment materials that are tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not merely those designed to provide a single general intelligence quotient (§ 56320, subdiv. (c)); and be selected and administered to best ensure that, when administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills, the test produces results that accurately reflect the student’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the student’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure (§ 56320, subdiv. (d)). In addition, no single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for an individual with exceptional needs. Educ. Code § 56320 (e). The assessment shall be conducted by persons competent to perform them. Educ. Code § 56322. Any psychological assessment of a student must be conducted by a credentialed school psychologist who is trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Educ. Code § 56324 (a). Petitioner does not dispute the timeliness of the initial psycho-educational or speech and language assessments conducted pursuant to his initial assessment plan and the Hearing Officer finds that these assessments were timely.
Appropriateness of the Psycho-Educational Assessment
On September 7 and 19, 2000, Ms. Herrick conducted a preschool developmental assessment/psycho-educational evaluation of Student. For her assessment, Ms. Herrick used the Vineland Adaptive Behaviors Scale parent interview (Vineland), the Bayley Infant Scales (Bayley), the Gilliam Autism Rating Scale (GARS), and the Evaluation and Programming System (EPS) parent questionnaire. Ms. Herrick erroneously identified the EPS in her report as the Early Programming System. In addition to her standardized testing, Ms. Herrick reviewed Student’s records, and observed him both during her evaluation and during the evaluation of speech therapist Ms. Amedee. Student was observed to be an active, verbal child who spontaneously named objects in the room, spoke in full sentences, communicated with his parent, quickly lost interest in testing and had limited eye contact or interest in the District examiners.
Student’s Mother was the respondent for the Vineland interview. From her responses, Ms. Herrick found that Student was at the 2.7 year old age equivalent (AE) in communication, at the 1.6 year old AE in daily living skills, at the 1.3 year old AE in socialization, and at the 2.3 year old AE in motor skills. Student’s adaptive composite score on the Vineland was an age equivalent of 1.11 years. Ms. Herrick indicated that Student’s overall communication measurement was within an age-appropriate parameter. While Student “has developed significant language skills, delays are present in his use of language to communicate with others.” Ms. Herrick characterized Student’s delays in daily living skills and in socialization skills as mild. Ms. Herrick noted that Student’s skills were limited in both gross and fine motor (hopping, walking downstairs with alternating feet, opening and shutting scissors), but also emerging (building three-dimensional structures, climbing on high play equipment and screwing and unscrewing jar lids). Overall, Ms. Herrick characterized Student’s motor skills development as having a “mild level delay.”
Student was unable to complete the standardized portion of the Bayley. However, from her clinical observation of his abilities and the parent’s report on his skill development in relation to the Bayley items, Ms. Herrick estimated that Student had a mental developmental age of approximately 2.6 years. This suggested that Student was “functioning within an ‘average’ age appropriate cognitive range with gaps in skill development at a younger age level and some specific skills at a higher level. Student’s autism quotient of 72 on the GARS suggested a low probability for the diagnosis of autism. However, Ms. Herrick concluded that Student was functioning within the autism spectrum based upon his developmental history and her clinical observation. As previously discussed, as a result of her assessment, Ms. Herrick recommended that the IEP team make Student eligible for special education due to his diagnosis of autism, that it set goals and objectives for Student “in the main developmental areas” and consider placing him in a preschool SDC.
The evidence demonstrated that Ms. Herrick did not use any racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory test, that the tests and assessment materials were administered in Student’s primary language of English, and that they were validated for the purpose for which they are used. No single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining Student’s eligibility or placement. It was also undisputed that Ms. Herrick is an appropriately credentialed school psychologist.
Petitioner asserts that Ms. Herrick incorrectly interpreted the results of some tests, incorrectly indicated that Student had some skills that he did not (ability to use scissors), used the wrong test name for the acronym EPS, and participated with Ms. Amedee in using a composite score from the Vineland inventory to make a recommendation about Student’s speech therapy needs. There is no merit to these contentions. For example, Ms. Herrick testified that she initially recorded the GARS scores incorrectly in her draft test profile. As soon as she realized her error, she advised the parents of the correct scores. The incorrect GARS scores were not used in her assessment report and did not form the basis of any of her recommendations. In fact, Student’s correct GARS scores suggested a low probability of autism. Rather than rely on this single test to determine that Student was not eligible as an autistic child, Ms. Herrick used her clinical observations of Student along with his developmental history to conclude that he was indeed eligible based on autism. Petitioner’s primary concern was that the adaptive composite score Ms. Herrick derived from the Vineland was used by Ms. Amedee as the basis for her recommendation about the level of Student’s speech needs. The Hearing Officer finds that there was no evidence that the Vineland score itself was in error or that it tested other than what it purported to test. In addition, there is no factual basis for the assertion that Ms. Herrick participated in the formulation of Ms. Amedee’s recommendation regarding Student’s speech needs.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the psycho-educational assessment satisfied the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320, 56322 and 56324 and was appropriate.
Appropriateness of District’s Speech and Language Assessment
On September 19, 2000, Student’s speech and language evaluation was conducted by District speech therapist Collette Amedee. For her assessment, Ms. Amedee review Student’s existing school records, considered input from the parents, consulted with Ms. Herrick, and observed Student during both Ms. Herrick’s and her own assessment. She also administered to Student the Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT), the Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOWPVT), the Preschool Language Scale-3 (PLS-3) and gathered a language sample. Ms. Amedee’s direct assessment of Student occurred over a period of approximately ninety minutes. Student’s results on the standardized speech and language tests administered to him by Ms. Amedee were as follows:
Test AE SS %ile
ROWPVT 2.0 100 50
EOWPVT 2.6 109 73
PLS-3
Auditory Comprehension 1.8 85 16 Expressive Communication 2.4 104 61 Total Language Score 2.0 94 34
Ms. Amedee testified that she used information from Ms. Herrick’s psycho-educational assessment to reach her conclusion that, at 3 years and 3 months of age, Student was functioning at the beginning 2-year old level developmentally. Ms. Amedee found that Student’s receptive and expressive language skills, that ranged from 1.8 to 2.6 year levels, “appear to be commensurate with overall abilities.” Ms. Amedee determined that “Student is demonstrating difficulties with his pragmatics, or use of language. He uses question forms to request, immature sentence patterns during spontaneous speech, and limited use of spontaneous language. He is unable to answer simple questions or participate in conversational speech.” Ms. Amedee recommended that Student receive speech/language services once per week to address these weaknesses and that they also be addressed in his classroom communication goals.
The evidence demonstrated that Ms. Amedee is an appropriately credentialed and qualified speech and language specialist with both bachelor’s and master’s degrees in communication disorders. She has assessed and designed speech and language programs for autistic children within the District for six years and maintained her currency in the field by attending workshops on autism. Ms. Amedee testified that she did not use any racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory tests, that she administered the tests and assessment materials to Student in his primary language of English, that the tests she used were validated for the purpose for which they are used, and that she did not rely on a single assessment tool to determine Student’s speech needs.
Petitioner contends that the speech and language assessment was not appropriate because his present level of language performance was derived from a language sample that included echolalic speech. Ms. Amedee testified that she gathered a 50-utterance language sample of Student using a modified Hannah-Gardner language analysis procedure. Twelve of Student’s forty-six listed utterances were echolalic. From her analysis of this sample, Ms. Amedee concluded that Student had a mean length of utterance (MLU) of 4.36 words, and that the predicted chronological age for a child with this MLU is 48 months. Because Student was 39 months of age at this time of Ms. Amedee’s evaluation, the MLU indicated that he was functioning expressively nine months above his chronological age. Independent speech therapist Leora Shaffer testified that it was not appropriate to use echolalic speech in determining a student’s MLU because it would produce an inflated MLU. In her opinion, only spontaneously generated expressive language should be collected for the sample. In doing this during her own evaluation, she found that Student’s spontaneously generated expressive language consisted primarily of two- and three-word utterances with occasional four- and five-word utterances. In contrast, Ms. Amedee testified that echolalic speech could provide the speech therapist with good information about a child’s understanding of syntactic structures that were embedded in the memorized speech. Ms. Amedee conceded, however, that it was possible that a child would not understand the syntactic structures embedded in the echolalic speech.
Ms. Amedee found that, receptively, Student was functioning between 1.8 and 2.0 years of age. This finding was derived from Student’s age equivalent score on the ROWPVT and the PLS-3. Student’s receptive age equivalent score on Ms. Amedee’s evaluation was consistent with the 1.9 year receptive age equivalent score obtained by Ms. Shaffer when she administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-IIIA to Student in December 2000. Expressively, Ms. Amedee found Student to be functioning between 2.4 and 2.6 years. This present level of performance was derived from Student’s age-equivalent score on the EOWPVT and the PLS-3, not from the MLU. On the PLS-3 expressive communication subtest, Ms. Amedee found that Student was able to combine three to four words in spontaneous speech. Ms. Amedee noted that, expressively, Student’s sentence length was up to a 4-year old level; however, she acknowledged in her assessment report that “although Student demonstrates an appropriate MLU, most of his sentences were memorized from videos and computer games. Sentences which were spontaneous or not echolalic were shorter and usually grammatically incorrect....Sentences that were not echolalic were used primarily to request and comment about pictures or toys.” As a result, she concluded that Student’s expressive language skills appeared to be greater than they actually were. From this understanding, Ms. Amedee found that Student’s “sentence length and complexity, including the use of syntactic structures, appears to be at a higher level. However, he does not appear to understand or use some of these structures....He is weak in his ability to formulate sentences spontaneously.”
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the MLU was not used to determine Student’s present levels of performance.
Petitioner also contends that the assessment was not appropriate because Ms. Amedee used Student’s Vineland adaptive composite score of 1.11 years to set a developmental age for him that was then compared to his language performance to determine his speech and therapy needs. Of particular concern was the fact that the Vineland composite reflected Student’s weaknesses in areas of self-help, such as his lack of toileting skills. In his view, this was the type of test misuse that Education Code § 56320 (d) was designed to prevent. In support of Petitioner’s argument, Ms. Shaffer testified that it was inappropriate to use the 1.11 composite score rather than Student’s chronological age level in scoring these tests because the cognitive scores of young children change over time. Ms. Shaffer testified that, from her experience working in the public schools, the failure to use a chronological age creates a risk that the level of services offered would be decreased based upon a perception of a child’s limited ability.
Ms. Amedee testified that she reported Student’s standardized scores on these tests based upon a developmental age of 1.11 years from the Vineland Adaptive Composite because it revealed his developmental level across the board, including his communication, daily living skills, motor skills and pre-readiness skills. Student had a significant delay of over one year on the Vineland with a scatter of abilities up to the 2.6 year developmental age estimated by Ms. Herrick. In Ms. Amedee’s opinion, it was inappropriate and unfair to Student to use his chronological age because cognitive skills develop with speech and his overall skills were much lower. In addition, Ms. Amedee testified that, even if the 1.11 year figure was incorrect, it only affected Student’s standard scores and percentile scores. It did not affect the age equivalents derived which were what she used in determining Student’s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the use of a developmental level rather than a chronological age in a speech and language evaluation does not invalidate an otherwise valid assessment. Such use is recognized as an appropriate method of determining the existence of a language disorder. See, Title 5, Cal. Code Reg. § 3030 (4)(A). While Student’s eligibility for special education based upon the presence of an expressive or receptive language disorder was not at issue in this hearing, this section provides useful guidance in appropriate assessment techniques. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Amedee’s assessment was not rendered inappropriate by her use of Student’s Vineland adaptive composite score. From Ms. Amedee’s undisputed testimony, the Hearing Officer also finds that Student’s age equivalent scores on these tests were not affected by Ms. Amedee’s use of the composite score. Whether the actual level of speech and language services provided to Student was designed to meet his unique needs and to provide him with some educational benefit will be discussed below.
Finally, Petitioner contends that the speech and language assessment was inappropriate because there was no assessment in the area of pragmatic language. There is no merit to this contention. The evidence clearly demonstrated that Student’s pragmatic language was assessed. Both Ms. Amedee and Ms. Shaffer testified that there are no standardized tests of language pragmatics. They also agreed that a determination of need in this area is properly based upon clinical observation, clinical judgment, and the language sample. The language sample provides insight into a child’s pragmatic language abilities. Ms. Amedee testified that, in Student’s case, the language sample revealed that he used an excessive amount of echolalia and frequently used questions for sentences that he intended to be statements. It also provided insight into his conversation skills, including his ability to initiate, change, or maintain conversational topics, his ability to take turns, and his use of eye contact. From her clinical observations and judgment as well as the language sample, Ms. Amedee concluded that Student was using language in an inappropriate manner and was demonstrating difficulties with his pragmatics, or use of language. The Hearing Officer finds that Student was appropriately assessed in the area of pragmatic language.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s speech and language assessment satisfied the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320 and 56322 and was appropriate.
Occupational Therapy (OT) and Adaptive Physical Education (APE) Assessments
Timeliness of OT and APE Evaluations
Petitioner contends that the District’s OT and APE assessments were untimely. In Petitioner’s view, because he had a medical diagnosis of autism when he first contacted the District, his motor abilities were by definition an area related to his suspected disability that should have been assessed immediately.(Footnote 11)
Ms. Herrick testified that Student’s motor ability was not a suspected area of disability when she prepared the initial assessment plan for several reasons. Ms. Herrick had observed Student to be very ambulatory with no indicators of need in this area. She had also reviewed the health and developmental history form for Student that had just been completed by his parents. This form indicated that Student’s large and small muscle motor coordination was fair. Ms. Herrick also reviewed the Dr. Lott’s August 25, 2000, letter diagnosing Student as autistic. In that letter, Dr. Lott reported that, in “watching [Student] move about the room, there was no spasticity, ataxia, or focal neurological signs.”
Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f), mandates that a child be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability “where appropriate.” The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Herrick reasonably relied on the above-described factors to determine that it was not appropriate to assess Student’s motor abilities at the time of the initial assessment. In addition, the Hearing Officer was persuaded by Ms. Herrick’s testimony that, even if she disagrees about the necessity for a particular assessment verbally requested by a parent, her practice is to assist the parent to put his/her request in writing and to then prepare an assessment plan.
In her psycho-educational assessment report, however, Ms. Herrick recommended that Student be further assessed in the areas of occupational therapy and adaptive physical education. Ms. Herrick testified that she prepared this report approximately one week before the October IEP meeting. At the October 5, 2000 initial IEP meeting, the IEP team agreed that OT and APE assessments would be completed within thirty days of his placement in the special day class. Ms. Herrick prepared an assessment plan for these evaluations that Student’s Father signed that same day. The Hearing Officer finds that the assessment plan was timely developed within fifteen days of the psycho-educational assessment.
Student was placed in Ms. Colomb’s special day class at Hawes on October 10, 2000. The APE evaluation was completed on October 30, 2000. The OT evaluation was completed on November 4, 2000. The Hearing Officer finds that the OT and the APE evaluations were completed within the time agreed to by the parties at the October 5, 2000 and reviewed at the November 13, 2001 IEP meeting within the time required by Educ. Code § 56344. From their review, the IEP team recommended that Student receive APE services twice a week for a total of sixty minutes and OT services once a week for a total of 45 minutes.
Appropriateness of OT Assessment
WOCCSE occupational therapist Barbara Cracchiolo assessed Student on October 24, 31, and November 3, 2000. She used the following methods for her assessment: her clinical observations of Student, her review of Student’s records, her interview with Student’s SDC teacher, and her analysis of a sensory behavior inventory that she had Student’s Father complete. The focus of Ms. Cracchiolo’s assessment was on Student’s ‘sensory motor processing’ or his ability to take information in from his senses, understand that information and be able to respond to it with an appropriate and effective motor response. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that, while the main emphasis of the assessment was on sensory motor, it also covered Student’s fine motor skills, his motor planning, his muscle tone, and his play skills.
From her assessment, Ms. Cracchiolo concluded that Student appeared to be having difficulty with his sensory processing. Student “present[ed] himself as a low muscle tone child with poor quality of movement, difficulty with motor planning and difficulty with awareness of where his body is in space.” Student was observed at school to collapse into furniture, bolsters or other classroom equipment rather than lifting up his legs and climbing over or around objects. He was observed to sit slumped in chair, to sit for only short periods of time, to “W-sit” on floor and to frequently lay on the table or floor. Ms. Cracchiolo also determined that Student had poor fine motor skills and difficulty using both hands together.
The evidence demonstrated that Ms. Cracchiolo is an appropriately qualified occupational therapist with a bachelor’s degree in occupational therapy. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that she is a registered occupational therapist with twenty-six years of experience. For eleven of those years, she has assessed and provided occupational services to young autistic children. The majority of the students she currently services are between three and seven years of age. Ms. Cracchiolo has both attended and presented workshops in her field, including in the area of sensory integration. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that she did not use any racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory tests, that she assessed Student in his primary language of English, and that she did not rely on a single assessment tool to determine Student’s occupational therapy needs. It was for this reason that she met with Student over a three-day period. In addition, she observed Student before the assessment while he was in the SDC class sensory motor OT group. By the time of the assessment, Student knew her and she had developed a rapport with him. Ms. Cracchiolo also testified that the sensory behavior inventory she had Student’s Father complete was designed to be completed by anyone who knows the child.(Footnote 12)
Petitioner contends that Ms. Crachiolla’s OT evaluation was not appropriate because she did not use any standardized tests. Petitioner was particularly concerned because Ms. Cracchiola’s assessment failed to provide a standardized measure of his deficit in fine motor skills. On November 14, 2000, Petitioner had advised the District that he considered Ms. Cracchiola’s OT assessment to be inadequate and that he intended to seek an independent OT educational evaluation at public expense. On February 5, 2001, Amy Marshall, OTR, evaluated Student, and administered the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales to Student that indicated an overall poor rating on fine motor ability. Ms. Marshall concluded that Student was exhibiting delays in his perceptual fine motor and sensory processing skills and recommended that Student receive individual OT therapy in sensory-motor stimulation two times a week. Ms. Marshall did not testify at the hearing.
At the hearing, Ms. Cracchiolo testified that it was considered good practice for occupational therapists to rely on the assessment methods she used. In addition to those methods described above, she considered information from standardized testing conducted or attempted by the school psychologist (i.e., information about Student’s functional abilities and motor skills from the Vineland, information regarding Student’s fine motor and motor planning skills from the Bayley and information about Student’s functional skills at home from the EPS form completed by the parents). While she considered these scores, one score from the Vineland would not determine Student’s occupational needs. From Ms. Cracchiolo’s undisputed testimony regarding appropriate OT assessment techniques, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Cracchiolo used appropriately recognized methods to conduct Student’s OT assessment.
Petitioner also contends that the assessment was inappropriate because it failed to provide specific recommendations for OT services, and only recommended that his need for OT service be determined by the IEP team. A written assessment report shall include “whether the pupil may need special education and related services.” Educ. Code § 56327 (a). A review of Ms. Cracchiolo’s report indicates that she did not expressly recommend that Student receive OT services. Instead, she described Student weaknesses in sensory processing, muscle tone and fine motor skills, and recommended that the need for OT services be determined by the IEP team. During the period between the October 5, and the November 13, 2000 IEP meetings, Student’s SDC teacher, Ms. Colomb, was observing Student and conducting the teacher version of the EPS to modify Student’s goals as she had been instructed by the IEP team on October 5, 2000. These new goals were presented to and considered by the IEP team at the November 13, 2000 IEP meeting. Student’s motor abilities from his APE assessment were also to be reviewed at the November 13, 2000 IEP meeting. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that, educationally, OT is used to enhance a student’s activities in class and that OT services must be educationally relevant to what the child is doing in the class. Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that deferring the recommendation for OT services to the IEP team was appropriate.
Although the parents disagreed with the adequacy of the OT assessment, it provided sufficient information regarding Student’s present levels of performance to prepare two OT goals that were presented at the IEP meeting of November 13, 2000. The parents did not consent to any OT goals for Student until May 11, 2001. Nonetheless, Ms. Cracchiolo testified that she was a member of the IEP team deemed responsible for working with Student on his SDC goals. She did that, with emphasis on his OT needs. The Hearing Officer concludes that the occupational therapy assessment complied with the requirements of Education Code §§ 56320, and 56322 and was appropriate.
Appropriateness of District APE Assessment
On October 26 and 27, 2000, District APE specialist Cheri Carpenter assessed Student’s gross motor skills. For her assessment, Ms. Carpenter reviewed Student’s file, completed an informal gross motor skills checklist, completed the teacher assessment portions of the EPS in the gross motor domain for children birth to three years of age and relied on the parent EPS form in the same area. On the EPS teacher assessment, Student achieved 78% of the gross motor skills normally acquired by children between birth and three years of age.
From her testing and observation, Ms. Carpenter found that Student had developed a broad repertoire of gross motor movement abilities and concluded that Student was currently functioning below age expectancy in his gross motor domain. She noted that, in addition to gross motor delays, Student’s poor attention to task was also a factor that inhibited his skill practice and overall development. Ms. Carpenter recommended that Student receive APE services to develop and refine the fundamental movement patterns of childhood, including locomotor skills, object control skills, and stability movements. Ms. Carpenter indicated that Student’s program would also focus on developing physical fitness, motor planning, and recreational skills (tricycles, roller skates, and playground play). The extent of Student’s APE services was to be determined by the IEP team.
The evidence demonstrated that Ms. Carpenter is an appropriately qualified APE specialist. She testified that she has a bachelor’s degree in physical education with an emphasis in APE. In addition to her eleven years of teaching experience, Ms. Carpenter has ten years of experience as a Special Olympics coach and, in that capacity, has coached three- and four-year- old children in track and field meets. She has worked with approximately twenty autistic children each year. Ms. Carpenter testified that she did not use any racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory tests, that she assessed Student in his primary language of English, that the tests she used were validated for the purpose for which they are used, and that she did not rely on a single assessment tool to determine Student’s APE needs.
Petitioner’s contends that Ms. Carpenter’s APE assessment was inappropriate because she used information from the EPS inventory to derive an age-equivalent score that he asserts was contrary to the instructions provided by the producers of the test. The Hearing Officer finds no merit to this contention. The EPS manual with complete instructions was not in evidence.(Footnote 13) Ms. Carpenter testified that EPS test did not provide age equivalents but that she computed an approximate gross motor developmental age equivalent for Student of 2.4 years from the teacher version of the EPS. Student had mastered 43 out of 55 total possible items, or 78 percent, in the gross motor domain. Ms. Carpenter computed a rough age equivalent by multiplying 36 months by 78. Petitioner does not dispute the validity of the raw score or of the percentage Student achieved on this test. The Hearing Officer finds that extrapolating information from a valid test result is not prohibited. Furthermore, there was no evidence to indicate that the age equivalent was used to deny or limit APE services to Student. As previously discussed, this assessment resulted in Student receiving APE services twice each week for a total of one hour.
The Hearing Officer finds that the APE assessment comported with Education Code §§ 56320 and 56322 and that the APE assessment was appropriate.
Music Therapy, Recreation Therapy, and Play Skills Assessment
Petitioner contends that the District had an obligation to develop an assessment plan and to specifically assess him for music therapy, recreation therapy, and play skills. In his view, such assessments are particularly important for the preschool child because both the IDEA and state law distinguish between preschoolers and older children. Respondent contends that Educ. Code § 56320(f) only requires that a child be assessed in “all areas related to the suspected disability” and does not require that a District assess a student before offering a particular method or instructional strategy.
Ms. Colomb testified that Student participated in music on a daily basis as a part of the instructional program in her SDC class and that he attended a music class for thirty minutes once a week with kindergarten students. Petitioner presented no evidence of how music therapy was related to his disability. The Hearing Officer finds that music therapy is not related to a suspected area of disability for Student and that the District was under no obligation to prepare an assessment plan and to conduct an assessment of Student to determine his need for music therapy.
Similarly, the Hearing Officer finds that recreation therapy is not related to a suspected area of disability for Student and that the District was not obliged to prepared an assessment plan and assess Student to determine his need for recreation therapy. In addition, the evidence clearly demonstrated that Student’s recreational skills were addressed by both the APE and OT assessments. Neither Ms. Carpenter nor Ms. Cracchiolo believed that swimming therapy was necessary for Student. Ms. Carpenter testified that, in her opinion, aquatics would be particularly important for children with orthopedic problems who cannot exercise on land by giving them an opportunity to work without pain and with a larger range of motion. Student did not have these problems.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed Student’s play skills as part of both the OT and APE evaluations and that an independent assessment plan and assessment report in this area was not required. As previously indicated, Ms. Cracchiolo assessed Student’s play skills as part of her OT assessment. Her testimony that there was no need to use a formal assessment tool regarding play skills was undisputed. Student’s play skills were also assessed as part of his gross motor domain on the EPS administered by Ms. Carpenter. That assessment included the broad categories of jumping forward, pedaling and steering a tricycle, running and avoiding obstacles, catching, kicking, throwing and rolling a ball, and climbing up and down play equipment. Because “play skills” encompass social interaction, Student was assessed by Ms. Carpenter both on a one-to-one basis and in a small-group setting with age appropriate peers. While Student attempted tasks next to his peers, he showed no real interest in playing with other children. Ms. Carpenter noted that Student did seem aware of the other children and would often watch them playing. Play skill strategies she used in APE involved working with one to two other children to teach them needed skills and then have them play together.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to formally assess Student in the areas of music therapy or recreation therapy and that the District appropriately assessed Student’s play skills within the context of the OT and the APE assessments. (Footnote 14)
Discrete Trial Training
Petitioner asserts that an assessment for DTT services should have been included in his initial assessment plan of September 7, 2000, that DTT services should have been determined in an IEP meeting no later than October 27, 2000 and that DTT services should have commenced October 28, 2000.
On December 1, 2000, Ms. Schrantz prepared an assessment plan in the area of developmental skills to determine Student’s need for discrete trial training. On December 3, 2000, Student’s Mother signed this assessment plan. On December 8, 2000, Ms. Schrantz completed a developmental skills/DTT baseline checklist and observation of Student to determine if he would benefit from discrete trial training. Student began receiving DTT on December 11, 2000.
The strained relationship between the parties caused particular confusion in the area of DTT. Ms. Schrantz testified that the District did not typically conduct assessments for DTT for autistic children before beginning DTT services. The “assessment” she conducted on Student was simply a baseline that was typically done at the commencement of providing services. Because the parents seemed to be closely scrutinizing the District, however, she completed the assessment plan and prepared the assessment report summarizing the DTT baseline.(Footnote 15)
As previously discussed, the assessment required by Educ. Code § 56320(f) does not include the methods or educational strategies such as DTT used to address an individual’s area of suspected disability.(Footnote 16) The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to formally conduct an assessment of Student’s need for DTT before it could offer Student a particular method of instruction such as DTT. Whether DTT services were offered to Student in a timely manner to provide him with FAPE is discussed below.
Physical Therapy (PT) Assessment
The weight of the evidence established that the District had no reason to suspect that Student required a PT assessment prior to the parents’ request for an assessment in this area. All of Student’s service providers agreed that he did not present any signs or symptoms that would indicate a need for assessment by a physical therapist. Thus, a consensus on this point was demonstrated through the testimony of experienced professionals, including school psychologist Ms. Herrick, occupational therapist Ms. Cracchiolo, APE specialist Ms. Carpenter, DTT supervisor Ms. Schrantz, and SDC teacher Ms. Colomb. These witnesses observed that Student did not appear to have any orthopedic problems, did not have contractures, had a range of motion, and could walk and run.
On December 15, 2000, Petitioner provided the District with a written request for a PT assessment, which was based upon a similar recommendation contained in a November 10, 2000, letter from Dr. Stein.(Footnote 17) The District acknowledged receipt of the request on December 15, 2000. It was undisputed that the District’s winter recess for the 2000-2001 school year extended from Monday, December 25, 2000 through Friday, January 5, 2001 and encompassed ten school days. Pursuant to Education Code §§ 56029 and 56043, an assessment plan was required within fifteen days, not counting school vacation over five school days. The Hearing Officer finds that the District had an obligation to develop an assessment plan for Student in the area of PT by January 13, 2001. Because such a plan was forwarded to the parents on January 8, 2001, by WOCCSE Program Director Irene White, the Hearing Officer finds that the District developed the assessment plan in a timely fashion. Thereafter, on January 29, 2001, pediatric physical therapist Charlotte Feichtmann conducted an evaluation of Student and determined that PT for strengthening was “not educationally necessary to help him learn in school or access his environment.” Petitioner does not contest the results of that assessment.
From the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District timely developed an assessment plan within fifteen days of the date of the referral and thereafter timely assessed Student in the area of physical therapy. * * *
In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that the District’s assessment plans in the areas of occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, and physical therapy were timely. The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s psycho-educational, speech and language, occupational therapy, and adaptive physical education assessments were appropriate. The Hearing Officer has found that the District was not required to conduct assessments of Student in the areas of music therapy, recreation therapy, or discrete trial training. The Hearing Officer has found that the District appropriately assessed Student’s play skills as part of its occupational therapy and adaptive physical education assessments.
ISSUE II: If the District Did Not Provide Timely and Appropriate Assessments of Student in Any of the Areas Listed Above, What Remedies are Available to Petitioner?
From the findings reached above, the Hearing Officer concludes that there is no basis to order the District to develop an assessment plan in any of these areas or to convene an IEP to consider the results and recommendations of such assessments.
ISSUE III: Did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2000-2001 school year?
Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).
“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and other supportive services as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education, including recreation and therapeutic recreation services. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of possible related services are psychological services other than for assessment and development of the IEP, health and nursing services, and language and speech development and remediation services. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363 (b) (1987).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student . Id. at 201.
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).
To demonstrate that it offered Student a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s placement offer must have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs, and have been reasonably calculated to provide him with with some educational benefit. In addition, the services provided to Student must have comported with those offered in the IEPs.
Student’s Unique Needs
Prior to addressing the asserted violations of FAPE, the Hearing Officer must determine what Student’s unique needs were during the 2000-2001 school year.
As indicated in the psycho-educational assessment, Student demonstrated the following symptoms associated with his autistic diagnosis: he has difficulty in developing peer relationships at an age-appropriate level, he has a lack of social and emotional reciprocity, he has a marked impairment in the ability to sustain simple conversations and social exchanges, he uses repetitive (echolalic) speech and he has encompassing preoccupations, such as favorite videos.
Ms. Herrick testified that one of Student’s primary unique needs in October 2000 was to become involved in an intensive special education program where he could be observed for the purposes of developing goals and objectives for him. She also determined that Student had needs in the area of social and pragmatic skills. She testified that, although Student’s speech and language skills were good and Student’s Mother reported that he had seven-word sentences, Student did not use his language for social communication. Ms. Herrick also testified that Student had no prior school experience except for a parent participation preschool program.(Footnote 18) As a result, in her opinion, Student had a unique need in the area of readiness for learning. District witnesses testified that Student was very distractible and had difficulties attending to task. This testimony was corroborated by Dr. Lott’s observation of Student’s behavior during his diagnostic examination.
Ms. Colomb testified that from her observation and assessment, she concluded that Student had relative strengths in cognitive ability, and knew his letters, numbers and colors. His main areas of weakness were in self-care, structure, following directions, and in fine motor. Ms. Colomb believed Student to be bright, but he needed to learn to focus on self-care, to follow directions, and to work within the structure of a class activity rather than on his own agenda.
From the assessments previously described and the testimony set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has unique needs in the following areas: attention, school readiness, language pragmatics, social communication, social interaction, self-care, fine motor skills, gross motor skills, sensory processing, and motor planning.
ISSUE III A: Did the District Deny Student a FAPE by Its Delay In Assessing Him In All Areas of Need?
Petitioner contends that, since the District failed to fully assess him, his unique needs have not been determined. As indicated in Issue I, above, the Hearing Officer has determined that Student was appropriately assessed in all areas of need. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny Student a FAPE based on the alleged failure to timely assess him.
ISSUE III B: Did the District Deny Student FAPE by Failing To Place Him In the Least Restrictive Environment?
Special education law requires that, to the maximum extent appropriate, a student with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) with children who are not disabled, and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U. S.C. § 1412 (a) (5) (A); Education Code § 56031.
Petitioner contends that before the October 5, 2000 initial IEP meeting, Ms. Herrick had predetermined that the SDC was the proper placement for Student, and that the IEP team as well as the parents relied on her recommendation. As a result, there was no discussion of the least restrictive environment for Student at the IEP of October 5, 2000. Because of this, Petitioner asserts that the IEP of October 5, 2000 denied him FAPE. The District contends that a student must be educated in the LRE where it is ‘appropriate’ and that, from the information available to District staff as of the October 5, 2000 IEP, Student required an intensive special education placement.
Was the SDC Class an Appropriate Placement for Student?
On October 10, 2000, Student began his placement in Ms. Colomb’s SDC class at Hawes. Ms. Colomb testified that her class was highly structured, and provided daily one-to-one training and instruction to each of her seven students on their goals, as well as an opportunity to learn various activities at independent work stations. Ms. Colomb testified that she used the TEACCH method and that the basis of this program was to provide children with help both in socialization skills and in independent work skills. District witnesses (Ms. Smith, Ms. Herrick, and Ms. Colomb) and Dr. Freeman agreed that TEACCH is an effective instructional method for young autistic children.
Ms. Colomb testified that Student had a very difficult time and was frequently out of control when he began attending her class. For example, during his first two weeks, Student was unhappy and did not want his parents to leave. He would throw himself on the floor. During this time, Student needed an adult with him the majority of the day. Ms. Colomb and her aide took turns staying with Student. Student frequently indicated that he would not or could not do various activities. He did not want anyone to touch him during circle time. He was not interested in interacting with peers.
Ms. Colomb testified that after observing Student and completing the EPS, she drafted fifteen new proposed SDC goals for Student in the areas of cognition, social communication, social skills, self-care, and fine motor. She selected these goals from the EPS, that follows a structured, developmental sequence. These goals were added to Student’s IEP at the November 13, 2000 IEP meeting, but not consented to by the parents. At the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, new or modified goals, including goals proposed or drafted by the parents, were added to those originally proposed but not authorized during the November 13, 2000 IEP. On December 8, 2000, Student’s parents consented to these goals.
Ms. Colomb testified that the SDC class worked on Student’s social and social communication goals from the moment of entry into class and throughout the day by modeling reciprocal greetings, hand shakes and eye contact, pairing children off for play time with an adult or with children from another SDC class, allowing each child an opportunity to be the leader of the day on a rotating basis during circle time, and pairing children for art projects. Socialization was also a focus of one-to-one DTT work. Cognitive goals were addressed throughout the day including during circle time and computer time. In addition to Student’s specific fine motor goals, fine motor skills were used during art projects. Ms. Colomb testified that Student’s fine motor skills required continual work. She worked on his fine motor goals in consultation with the OT specialist, Ms. Cracchiolo. From a review of the SDC goals in the IEPs of October 5 and December 7, 2000 and Ms. Colomb’s testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC class was designed to meet Student’s unique needs.
In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the weight of the evidence established that Student received educational benefit from his attendance in Ms. Colomb’s SDC class. Student’s Mother testified that she noticed progress in some areas for Student, but believed he also experienced regression and detriment. She noticed that Student improved in tricycle riding and in answering questions, and that cognitively, he seemed brighter although she did not attribute this to the SDC class. By contrast, Ms. Colomb testified that she observed a major change in Student’s behavior since he first entered the SDC class and that he continually progressed. He learned attending skills, could sit in a chair and attend in group activities for five minutes, had receptively mastered naming/showing emotions. Ms. Colomb testified that Student was “doing beautifully” in her class and had changed significantly compared to his behavior in the SDC class when he first entered it. For example, when Student first came to the SDC class, he was not interested in interacting with his peers, and he did not want anyone to touch him or interact at circle time. Ms. Colomb noted that Student was now willing to stay in an area and play, he was willing to share, he had become very interested in the activities, loved to sing, share and pay attention. He enjoyed being the leader of the day. On the playground, Student had learned that he must pull other children in the car in order to be pulled. Student’s improvement in the area of attending to task was also observed by Dr. Freeman during her evaluation in late April and early May, 2001. Dr. Freeman testified that Student was alert and seated for the tasks, he cooperated with testing over a one-hour period with breaks, and was able to complete standardized tests. The fact that he was able to do this was a good prognostic sign in her opinion.
No evidence was presented to suggest that Student’s placement in the SDC did not comport with his IEP.
Was the SDC Class the Least Restrictive Placement for Student?
There was a consensus among District witnesses that the SDC class was the least restrictive placement for Student in October 2000. A key factor articulated in support of this opinion was that the SDC was a highly structured program that focused on socialization and learning school readiness skills. An additional factor was Student’s need to attend a class with a teacher experienced in working with autistic children using methods that have proven effective in teaching autistic children. According to Ms. Amedee, because Student could not focus, he was not ready to attend a regular preschool in October 2000, even with the supplemental service of a shadow aide. The Hearing Officer finds that the SDC placement was the least restrictive placement for Student at the commencement of the 2000-2001 school year. As previously discussed, the evidence overwhelmingly established that Student required a highly structured placement at the beginning of the school year to address his unique needs, particularly in the areas of attention and school readiness. Although the parents vehemently disputed that Student was offered a true opportunity to interact with typical peers while in the SDC, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered Student appropriate opportunities to mainstream with typical peers through recess and in the music class at Hawes. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Colomb to be particularly persuasive in this regard.(Footnote 19)
In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately acknowledged Student’s need for greater inclusion with typical peers within a matter of months when, at the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, it offered him placement in a regular education class at St. Wilfred’s two days a week with a shadow aide. This decision was an uncomfortable one for the educational professionals within the District, particularly for Ms. Herrick and Ms. Colomb, who believed that Student still required the structure and continuity of the SDC.(Footnote 20) Nonetheless, because of Student’s progress in the SDC class, as well as in an effort to accommodate the parents’ strong concerns, the District agreed to this placement as a step toward Student’s anticipated full-time inclusion the following school year. The combination of the SDC class and the regular class for the last half of the 2000-2001 school year offered Student both the structure of the SDC staff with its experienced personnel and the expanded opportunity to interact with and learn from typically developing peers. Petitioner’s parents ultimately removed Student from the SDC class toward the end of the school year due to their concern that his behavior was being negatively influenced by the students in the SDC class. As acknowledged by Student’s Mother, however, it is difficult to determine the cause for any change in Student’s behavior. The Hearing Officer has insufficient evidence to determine if or why Student’s behavior changed or to attribute such change to any particular setting or condition.(Footnote 21)
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the SDC was an appropriate placement and the least restrictive placement for Student from October through December 2000 and that, subsequently, the combination of the SDC class and the regular preschool class for the last half of the 2000-2001 school year was the least restrictive placement for Student. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to place him in the least restrictive environment.
ISSUE III C: Did the District Deny Student FAPE by Failing to Offer Him An Appropriate Type and Amount of Speech and Language Services?
Petitioner contends that because the District’s speech and language evaluation was inappropriate, he received no pragmatic language training, or any speech training focused on syntax, semantics, or conversation. The Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s speech and language evaluation was appropriate. Throughout the school year, Petitioner requested more speech services than offered by the District and asserted that the goals developed by the District in this area were simplistic and incomplete.
In support of Petitioner’s position, Ms. Shaffer testified that the amount of speech and language services offered Student by the District was insufficient. Following her assessment, Ms. Shaffer diagnosed Student with a speech disorder, because he used a significant amount of unintelligible utterances while playing independently. She also diagnosed a receptive and expressive language disorder that involved problems in syntax, amount of words used and pragmatic usage. Ms. Shaffer identified three multifaceted areas of focus for Student’s speech therapy in receptive language, expressive language and pragmatic skills, and recommended that he receive two one-hour individual speech and language sessions a week. Petitioner also contends that Dr. Freeman’s psychological evaluation of him supports Ms. Shaffer’s recommendation. From her evaluation, Dr. Freeman recommended that Student’s speech and language services “need to include a minimum of three individual thirty-minute contact sessions per week and two thirty-minute group sessions per week in order to increase his language abilities and understand the pragmatics of social communication."The District contends that it offered Student an appropriate type and amount of services to address his language and social communication development across instructional settings, in his SDC class, in his DTT sessions, and in his direct speech and language therapy services. The District asserts that, when viewed in the context of Student’s program as a whole, its offer of two twenty-minute sessions of speech and language therapy a week constituted an appropriate education. In addition, it argues that Ms. Shaffer inappropriately concluded that Student had a speech disorder and a receptive and expressive language disorder.
It was undisputed that Student required speech and language services in the area of pragmatic language to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b). The Hearing Officer has previously found that Student has unique needs in the areas of pragmatic language and social communication. In determining the appropriate amount of speech and language services Student required, it is necessary to determine whether such services were needed to address either an articulation/speech disorder or an expressive/receptive language disorder. The weight of the evidence established that Student did not have an articulation disorder. All of Student’s service providers, as well as Dr. Freeman, testified that his speech was intelligible. Ms. Amedee testified that Student’s communication was clear and that the only errors demonstrated were developmental. Ms. Shaffer also testified that she was able to understand Student a majority of the time when he spoke in two- to three-word utterances in meaningful contexts. The Hearing Officer finds that Student did not require speech and language services to address articulation needs in order to benefit educationally from his instructional program.
The District contends that Student did not have a receptive and expressive language disorder because Ms. Shaffer testified that she only administered one standardized test (the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test - IIIA) to assess Student’s receptive language and he scored above the seventh percentile, and also testified that she did not administer any standardized tests of his expressive language. Where special education eligibility based on a language or speech disorder is not at issue, the requirements of Cal. Code of Regs., tit. 5, § 3030(c)(4) are not determinative of the need for speech and language services. The issue is whether speech and language services must be provided in order for Student to benefit educationally from his instructional program. Both Ms. Amedee and Ms. Shaffer agreed that Student has a pragmatic language disorder that was manifested in part by an excessive use of echolalic speech. From their assessments and testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has a need in the appropriate use of expressive language in meaningful, non-echolalic speech, particularly in the area of pragmatic language.
The inquiry now is whether the District’s offer was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and to offer him some educational benefit.
At the October 5, 2000 IEP, from Ms. Amedee’s assessment, two annual speech and language goals were written for Student. First, Student was to “improve [his] ability to answer yes/no and various ‘what’ questions about pictures or games.” Ms. Amedee testified that these are skills Student should have had at his age. She selected this particular goal because Student had problems answering any type of question and “what” questions are learned first developmentally. Second, Student was “to improve pragmatic skills by producing two or more simple sentences to tell about a picture.” Ms. Amedee testified that these initial goals focused on Student’s important needs for foundational pragmatic language skills. At the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, a new speech and language goal was written. Student was to increase his use of personal pronouns “me, my, you, your” during cooperative games (teacher-facilitated or with a peer) and to use “he, she, they” to describe pictures. Ms. Amedee testified that Student was initially provided two individual sessions a week; however, after the new goal using personal possessive was added at the December 7, 2000 IEP, one of Student’s session was in a small group with one other child.
In response to Ms. Shaffer’s independent assessment reviewed at the IEP meeting of January 19, 2001, Ms. Amedee agreed to draft additional language goals to address these areas, to be provided to the parents by January 23, 2001. These goals involved the expressive and receptive use of prepositions, understanding concepts and expressively using attributes to describe pictures. Ms. Amedee testified that the prior goals already encompassed what was in the new goals; however, she wrote them because the parents wanted more specific goals, similar to Ms. Shaffer’s. The three goals Ms. Amedee developed were not approved by the parents until April 19, 2001.
The Hearing Officer finds that these goals addressed Student’s pragmatic and expressive language needs. By focusing on Student’s ability to understand and respond to questions and to describe scenes observed, the October goals addressed his foundational receptive and expressive conversational skills. The December goal developed an expressive and receptive understanding of pronouns and focused, in addition, on increasing Student’s use of syntactic structures (pronoun +is/are+verb-ing) in the context of learning play skills and turn-taking with a peer. The April goals continued Student’s development of expressive and receptive language skills. Beginning in December, Student had an opportunity for pragmatic interaction with a peer under the guidance of the speech therapist.
Ms. Amedee testified that in determining the amount of recommended speech services for Student, she looked at the fact that speech and language services were being provided in a variety of settings – i.e., in the SDC and during DTT services– as well as in speech therapy. In her opinion, this accounted for the difference between her recommended amount of direct speech services and Ms. Shaffer’s. In Ms. Amedee’s opinion, the greatest factor was Student’s placement in the SDC because the class provided many language-rich activities. In addition to class activities, Student’s SDC social communication and cognitive goals addressed his receptive and expressive language skills, and his social goal addressed his pragmatic language play skills in the class setting. If Student had not been in the SDC, she would have recommended more time for him to meet his goals. Ms. Amedee testified that she was in Ms. Colomb’s class several times a day and collaborated with Ms. Colomb on implementing Student’s goals. In addition, the aides who provide DTT services, as well as Student’s shadow aide, observed him in speech therapy so they could incorporate what was being worked on in speech therapy into their own program. While Student had reduced time in the SDC following his placement at St. Wilfred’s twice a week in January 2001, in that context he was exposed to typically developing peers and typical language role models.
Both Dr. Freeman and Ms. Shaffer agreed that staff other than a speech therapist could implement some of Student’s communication goals. Dr. Freeman testified that because of the importance of making language use functional, speech services could be provided by a combination of speech therapists, SDC teacher and DTT staff. Ms. Shaffer agreed that a credentialed SDC teacher was qualified to implement some communication-related goals, particularly for generalization of skills taught by the speech therapist. She also testified that social skills are beneficial when taught in a small group with an SDC teacher with training in the area. A review of the SDC goals indicates that they include social communication skills of learning to greet and shake hands with peers during circle time, responding to two-step directions, and expressively and receptively identifying feelings through actions, words and facial expressions. Ms. Colomb’s previously described testimony regarding Student’s participation and benefit from these activities indicates that social-communication and pragmatic skills were successfully taught in the SDC class as well. In addition, Ms. Shrantz testified that DTT services, of eight hours a week beginning in December 2000, included consultation with the speech therapist, work on Student’s IEP goals, and drills on expanding sentence length.
From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of speech services, in conjunction with the language-based activities in the SDC class and in DTT services, was designed to meet Student’s unique needs in the areas of pragmatic language, including expressive use of non-echolalic speech, and social communication. The District was not required to provide an amount of speech and language services consistent with Ms. Shaffer’s recommendation. In finding that an appropriate amount of direct speech services was offered by the District, the Hearing Officer finds that neither Ms. Shaffer nor Dr. Freeman had sufficient information about Student’s complete educational program to determine the extent of his service needs. Ms. Shaffer testified that because she had not seen Student’s educational program, she did not have an opinion regarding whether it was necessary for him to receive two hours of speech therapy to benefit from his educational program. Dr. Freeman testified that she did not have enough information about Student’s school program during the 2000-2001 school year to render an opinion about the appropriateness of the speech services offered and that she did not intend for her recommendation to apply retroactively. Both Ms. Shaffer and Dr. Freeman had limited contact with Student. Accordingly, their opinions regarding the amount of speech services Student required during the 2000-2001 school year are entitled to less weight.
The uncontradicted evidence established that Student received educational benefit from his speech and language sessions. Ms. Amedee testified that, when Student began receiving services, he could not sit and attend, could not answer yes or no questions or any “wh” questions, could not comment about things he saw when asked about them, and had little reciprocal conversation. It was difficult for her to keep Student in one place with an erect posture. When Ms. Amedee testified in February 2001, Student was able to sit for an entire session and pay attention. He had achieved his goal of increasing his ability to answer yes/no and “what” questions. In addition, he was able to answer “who” questions and was beginning to answer “where” questions. Student was also close to achieving his pragmatic goal of producing two or more simple sentences to describe pictures. He was able to use grammatically correct sentences about pictures and things he saw, and was beginning to use adjectives in those sentences. Ms. Amedee also testified that she had observed a significant improvement in Student’s expressive use of spontaneously generated, non-echolalic speech. Initially, Student was able to use only two- to three-word sentences. She had observed Student to use fewer echolalic responses and his spontaneous language was growing in sentence length.
The evidence also established that Student’s expressive and receptive language skills had improved over the 2000-2001 school year. Dr. Freeman’s May 2001 psychological evaluation demonstrated that Student’s expressive and receptive language age equivalent scores had improved. In receptive language, Student scored at the forty-nine-month level, four months above his chronological age. In expressive language, Student scored at the thirty-nine-month level. While this was six months below Student’s chronological age, it was significantly higher than the 2.4 year to 2.6 year expressive age equivalents he achieved on the EOWPVT and PLS-3 administered by Ms. Amedee in September 2000.(Footnote 22)
From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the type and amount of speech and language services offered to Student during the 2000-2001 school year were designed to meet his unique needs, and provided him with educational benefit. There was no contention that the speech services provided did not comport with Student’s IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Oficer concludes that the District did not deny Student a FAPE on this basis. ISSUE III D: Did the District Deny Student a FAPE by Unilaterally Changing His Occupational Therapy?
On November 13, 2000, the IEP team offered Student individual OT services once a week for forty-five minutes. At the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, the IEP team added one thirty-minute session of group OT a week as a designated instructional (DIS) service, to be provided in Student’s SDC class.
This added group OT session was the subject of controversy between the parties. Student had already been receiving group OT with his classmates since his initial placement in the SDC class, as a part of the SDC class instruction. In the parents’ view, the District was attempting to placate their requests for additional OT services by adding something that Student was already receiving. The IEP team notes indicate that the parents disagreed that group OT was a DIS service. From the perspective of the District members of the IEP team, group OT was a DIS service. This was confirmed by the testimony of WOCCSE OT specialist Ms. Cracchiolo. She also testified that the group OT offered by the IEP team was the same as the group OT that had been provided informally in the SDC.
An apparently unintended consequence of Student’s placement at St. Wilfred’s private preschool was that he was not at the SDC on Tuesdays, when group OT occurred. At the next IEP meeting on January 19, 2001, the group OT service was dropped from the list of DIS services on the face of the IEP. Neither Ms. Cracchiolo nor another occupational therapist was present at this IEP meeting. The IEP meeting notes indicate that the parents disagreed with the District’s removal of group OT and wanted the service continued. The District recommended that OT consultation with Student’s shadow aide at St. Wilfred’s be substituted. The parents did not consent to this IEP.
Petitioner contends that the District denied him a FAPE by removing this DIS service without his parents’ consent. As a result of this action, Student’s total OT services were reduced. In Petitioner’s view, this action potentially contributed to a deterioration in his behavior that caused Ms. Cracchiolo to recommend an increase in his individual OT services at the May 11, 2001 IEP meeting to twice a week for a total of ninety minutes.
The District contends that Petitioner never consented on the IEP document to the group OT offered to him as a DIS service at the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, and that the District found Student’s Father’s “voluminous” correspondence regarding what services the parents did or did not consent to very confusing. Mr. Conniff testified that it was difficult to determine when and to what services the parents had provided their consent because it was not provided on the IEP documents but contained in frequent detailed letters. The District also asserts that the group OT was not a DIS service but an instructional method that it was free to change, particularly since the parents did not explicitly consent to it.
In Student’s Father’s November 14, 2000 letter, after advising Mr. Conniff of the parents’ intent to seek an OT IEE, Student’s Father wrote “we have no objection and in fact request that Ms. Cracchiolo, your occupational therapist, initiate the additional 45 minutes/week OT session that she would recommend.” (Emphasis added). On December 16, 2000, after the District formally offered group OT as a DIS service, Student’s Father wrote to the District to summarize the parents’ view of Student’s current status quo IEP. In that letter, Student’s Father stated that the parents “have not agreed that the amount of service delivery is appropriate in the area of occupational therapy.... however we have agreed that as of Student’s November 13, 2000 IEP meeting services in occupational...therapy will be delivered as per the district recommendation.”
The Hearing Officer acknowledges the difficult position in which the District found itself of trying to determine what services the parents had consented to, when they had provided consent, and, consequently, what services District staff could legitimately provide to Student. This difficulty was apparent to the Hearing Officer during the hearing, for example, when Student’s Father questioned District witnesses about whether they had provided services to Student on a timely basis and, at the same time, queried whether the witnesses believed they had parental consent to implement particular goals. Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents provided consent to the implementation of the District’s complete offer of OT services, both within the SDC class and as an individual service, regardless of whether or not the group OT was specifically designated as a DIS service. The correspondence quoted above clearly reflects the parents’ understanding that individual OT services were supplemental to the group services Student was receiving in the SDC class. In addition, any other conclusion is contrary to the parents’ consistently expressed desire for more OT services for Student. Their frustration regarding the provision of OT services was exacerbated by an earlier misunderstanding by the District regarding whether the parents had consented to the implementation of individual OT services. That misunderstanding led to a one-month delay in the delivery of Student’s individual OT services (see Footnote 6, supra). Even assuming that the District was legitimately confused, the Hearing Officer finds that it had the burden of seeking clarification before removing these services without parental agreement.
A contrary conclusion would be inconsistent with the District’s position that its OT program addressed Student’s needs in the broader context of his program as a whole. As previously discussed, the main emphasis of Ms. Cracchiolo’s OT assessment of Student was on his sensory-motor processing, i.e., his ability to take in information with his senses and interpret and respond to it in an efficient, functional manner. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that this can be a difficult problem for autistic children. For the group OT sessions, she provided a theme around which the children in the SDC class would practice sensory-motor skills (i.e., gross and fine motor, tactile, oral motor), balancing skills (jumping), strength coordination (pouring skills) and daily living skills. She would then provide Ms. Colomb with a handout about what the class had done that day. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that the goal of OT services was to assist with a child’s needs in the classroom and that, as a result, there may be occasions where OT services are not necessary. Implicit in her testimony is the notion that her recommendation for Student’s individual OT services rested on the larger picture of services he was receiving in the SDC classroom. These services included group OT. On May 11, 2001, Ms. Cracchiolo increased Student’s individual OT services with the knowledge that he was no longer receiving group OT services in the SDC.
From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied Student a FAPE to the limited extent that it removed his group OT services from January 8, 2001 through May 11, 2001. In reaching this conclusion, the Hearing Officer makes no finding, express or implied, that the removal of the group OT service led to an asserted deterioration in Student’s condition or behavior in the late spring of 2001. No evidence was presented sufficient to support such a conclusion.
ISSUE III E: Did the District Deny Student a FAPE by Failing to Adequately Or Timely Implement the IEP in the Areas of Reporting Progress, Providing Speech and Language Services or DTT Services?
Reporting progress
Petitioner asserts that the District failed to comply with agreements in the IEPs to provide the parents with various reports. First, the October 5, 2000 IEP provided that the speech and language therapist was to provide the parents with an oral report within thirty days of the start of services (October 9, 2000) regarding Student’s goals and service and any recommendations for change in Student’s program or service. Ms. Amedee testified that she provided this report at the IEP meeting of November 13, 2000. Second, because the parents expressed concern about Student’s safety on the playground, the IEP also provided that the classroom aides would monitor Student’s playground behavior for the first two weeks of attendance and his teacher would report to the parents. Ms. Colomb testified that the aide she assigned to watch Student then got sick and was not at school every day. Ms. Colomb wrote some information in the communication book that went to the parents on a daily basis and orally reported to Student’s Father. She did not write about this topic in the communication book on a daily basis. Third, the December 7, 2000 IEP, provided that the “staff will provide monthly written updates on Student’s goals and objectives.” Because the parents did not sign the December 7, 2000 IEP, the District contends it was not required to make these reports. When she testified in late February 2001, Ms. Colomb indicated that she had provided these reports on two occasion. Ms. Amedee testified that she spoke to the parents only at IEP meetings.
Procedural violations do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, unless there is a showing of prejudice; i.e., a loss of educational opportunity to the student or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479. The Hearing Officer concludes that any violations that may have occurred in the provision of the above reports did not result in the type of prejudice that would constitute a denial of FAPE.
Speech and Language Services
As previously discussed, the District provided Student with an appropriate type and amount of speech and language services and the services provided comported with his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not deny Student a FAPE on this basis.
Timeliness of DTT Services
At the initial IEP meeting on October 5, 2000, the parents requested that Student begin DTT services within sixty days and that DTT be provided twice a week for two-hour sessions each. The District agreed to discuss DTT at the next IEP meeting and Student’s Mother consented to the IEP. At the November 13, 2000, IEP meeting, the District offered Student DTT services four times a week for a total of eight hours in the SDC classroom, to begin on December 13, 2000. WOCCSE program specialist and DTT supervisor Ms. Schrantz testified that the District required one month in order to obtain a DTT aide for Student. The parents did not consent to this IEP.
As previously discussed, on December 1, 2000, Ms. Schrantz prepared an assessment plan to determine Student’s need for discrete trial training and Student’s Mother consented to the plan on December 3, 2000. On December 4, 2000, Student’s Father wrote to Ms. Schrantz expressing dissatisfaction at the length of the delay for initiating Student’s DTT services and surprise that Ms. Schrantz told the parents that she did not have written consent to assess Student for DTT services. On December 6, 2000, Mr. Conniff wrote a letter to Student’s parents in response to this complaint and acknowledged that the parents requested that the DTT program proposed for Student in the November 13, 2000 IEP be implemented in a timely manner. Ms. Schrantz also testified that, from this letter, she assumed the parents consented to DTT services. At the December 7, 2000 IEP meeting, however, the IEP team notes indicated that delay in the initiation of services was because the District was “waiting for parental authorization for DTT.” Student began receiving DTT services on December 11, 2000.
The Hearing Officer finds that the failure to offer DTT services at the October 5, 2000 IEP did not deny Student a FAPE. Ms. Schrantz testified that on October 5, 2000, she had not had an opportunity to observe Student. While she may have made a general statement that DTT was a good strategy, she would not have agreed to DTT services at the IEP. Ms. Schrantz testified that between the October and the November IEP meetings, she was in the SDC class six to eight times for one-hour periods and observed Student during this time. From her class observations, she learned that Student would benefit from DTT due to his compliance issues with following directions and attending. He needed prompts to respond to directions, to learn compliance and to lengthen the time he could attend to tasks. Ms. Schrantz testified that, in her opinion, Student was on the higher end of the autistic spectrum. She believed DTT was appropriate for him and that he would greatly benefit from it. During this same period, Ms. Schrantz consulted with Ms. Amedee and Ms. Colomb and they also agreed that DTT would be appropriate for Student.
The District’s November 13, 2000 offer of DTT services, however, delayed implementation of these important early intervention services for one month while it sought out and hired staff to provide the DTT services. This action erroneously placed the burden of delay on Student at a time when he required intensive early intervention services. The Hearing Officer finds that the District had sufficient notice of Petitioner’s desire and need for DTT services, as well as of the parents’ consent to such services in the correspondence outlined above. As early as late September or early October 2000, Ms. Herrick recommended that the IEP team discuss the efficacy of DTT services for Student. Because Student was diagnosed with autism, there was a high probability of the need for DTT services. This need was underscored by the parents’ request at the October 5, 2000 IEP meeting from their reading about the importance of this type of early intervention. The District should have taken whatever preliminary administrative or personnel actions were necessary to ensure timely implementation of DTT services. See Calif. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3040(a). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Student a FAPE to the limited extent that it delayed implementation of DTT services for one month in order to hire an aide.
ISSUE III F : Did the District Deny Student FAPE by Failing to Offer Him an Appropriate ESY Program?
Extended school year (ESY) programming is educational programming that extends instruction beyond the normal school year to prevent serious regression over the summer months. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F. 3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). In California, a school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. Tit.5 § 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. §300.309(a)(2).
Student’s ESY 2001 placement was developed and refined at the IEP meeting of May 11, 2001 and the June 11, 2001 IEP addendum. Essentially, the IEP team agreed that Student would attend St. Wilfred’s preschool for three hours each day, with a shadow aide, from June 26 through July 26, 2001. During this same period, Student would receive DIS services of twice weekly speech and language for a total of forty minutes (one individual and one group), twice weekly APE for a total of sixty minutes, twice weekly OT for a total of ninety minutes and DTT services two hours a week at home and two hours per week at school. The parents agreed to the ESY placement and DIS services, but continued to dispute the adequacy of the amount of speech and language services provided.
For ESY services, the issue is whether the District offered Student enough speech and language services to avoid regression during this time period. The Hearing Officer has previously determined that the amount of speech services offered to Student during the school year was appropriate. That finding was based in large part, however, on Student’s participation in the SDC class in which his social communication and pragmatic language goals were taught by a credentialed SDC teacher, as well as on his receipt of eight hours a week of DTT services. Ms. Shaffer’s recommendation regarding the amount of services Student required during the school year was entitled to less weight because she was unaware of these important components of Student’s educational program. During the ESY, however, the evidence established that Student did not attend the SDC, that he did not receive any direct speech and language services at St. Wilfred’s, and that the total amount of DTT services was reduced by fifty percent. The District introduced no evidence to address how its speech and language offer for the ESY addressed these critical changes.
As previously discussed, Ms. Shaffer testified that Student required two hours of speech and language services to meet his unique needs. Because Student’s participation in the SDC was no longer a factor present during the ESY, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Shaffer’s recommendation about the appropriate amount of services to be persuasive for the ESY. In addition, Dr. Freeman testified that Student’s language was rapidly developing and she also recommended increased speech and language services. Given the nature of Student’s disability and his developmental stage, the Hearing Officer finds it likely that he would experience regression during the ESY without more than forty minutes of direct speech therapy a week. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that Student required individual speech therapy services a minimum of two times a week for one hour each session during the ESY. The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Student a FAPE to the limited extent that it failed to offer him a sufficient amount of speech and language services during the ESY. The remedy for this denial of FAPE is discussed below in Section IV A.
ISSUE III G: Did the District Deny Petitioner a FAPE by Failing to Allow Appropriate Parental Involvement in His Educational Program?
Early education services for preschoolers from the ages of three to five must include opportunities for active parent involvement. Educ. Code § 56441.2. The great weight of the evidence established that Student’s parents had an appropriate opportunity for involvement in his educational program. The record clearly indicates that the parents were involved as active members of the IEP team, participated in seven IEP meetings during the course of the year, became actively involved in drafting proposed goals for Student that were included in the IEP by the IEP team, actively corresponded with District and WOCCSE staff regarding areas of concern to them, and attended some of the monthly DTT meetings at Petitioner’s grandmother’s home. Student’s Mother testified that she felt the parents were excluded by the District from classroom and school gatherings, particularly after the commencement of the due process hearing. On the other hand, Student’s Mother observed in the SDC class, volunteered on at least one occasion, received a flyer from WOCCSE regarding a parent resource group, and thereafter regularly participated as a member of that group. From this evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents were not deprived of an opportunity for appropriate involvement in Student’s educational program and that Petitioner was not denied a FAPE on this basis.
ISSUE III H: Did the District Deny Petitioner a FAPE by Failing to Facilitate or Allow Development of a Parent Support Group at His Preschool?(Footnote 23)
Petitioner contends that a parent support group specific to Student’s SDC classroom could have been a means to offer the parents an opportunity to participate in his educational program.
As indicated in Section III G, above, the parents had an ample opportunity to become involved in Student’s educational program and did so. The tragedy of this case is that, at a time when the parents had just learned of their son’s serious diagnosis and needed emotional support, the parties became embroiled in a series of escalating conflicts. The parents perceived the District as unprofessional, calloused and uncaring. The District perceived the parents as unreasonable, demanding and insulting to their staff. This dynamic of mutual mistrust persisted throughout the year. Due to Student’s young age and need for educational planning and services for the foreseeable future, the Hearing Officer strongly encourages the parties to focus on collaborative decision making, either themselves or through the use of a mutually respected expert in the area of autism. The Hearing Officer does not disagree that a parent support group specific to Student’s SDC may have improved the relations among the parties and lessened the parents’ stress. Nonetheless, the Hearing Officer concludes that there was no requirement for the formation of such a support group in order for Student to receive a FAPE and that the District did not deny him a FAPE on this basis. *** *** ***
In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District denied Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school and extended school year to the limited extent that (1) it eliminated Student’s group OT services from January 8, 2001 to May 11, 2001, (2) it delayed the implementation of Student’s DTT services by one month, and (3) it failed to provide a sufficient amount of speech and language services during the ESY.
ISSUE IV A: If the District denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to compensatory education based on inappropriate delay and interruption in providing any of the above services?
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have also extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3rd Cir. 1990) 916 F. 2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for-hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the Student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir.1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1497.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to compensatory education to address the areas in which the District denied him a FAPE: i.e, by eliminating his group OT services, by delaying the implementation of his DTT services for one month, and by failing to provide a sufficient amount of speech and language services during the ESY. While there is no automatic entitlement to hour-for-hour compensation, in this case, the Hearing Officer finds that this level of compensatory education is appropriate, given Student’s age and disability. The parties’ conduct over the course of the 2000-2001 school year must not obscure the fact that, as a young autistic child, Student requires intensive early intervention services. As indicated by the Legislature, such services may significantly reduce the potential impact of disabling conditions and reduce the need for special education class placement. Educ. Code § 56441. The Hearing Officer finds that Student is entitled to compensatory education as follows:
1. For the elimination of his thirty-minute a week group OT over a period of eighteen weeks from January 8 through May 11, 2001, the District must provide Student with small-group OT services for a total of 540 minutes. However, because Student is no longer in the SDC class, in the alternative, the parties may agree to nine one-hour individual OT sessions.
2. For the one-month delay in implementing Student’s DTT services of eight hours per week, the District must provide Student with thirty-two hours of DTT services.
3. For the loss of eighty minutes a week in speech and language services during the four-week period of the ESY 2001, computed as the difference between the forty minutes a week of speech and language services provided and the two one-hour sessions a week he should have received as discussed in Issue III F, the District must provide Student a total of 320 minutes in individual speech and language services.
The District must provide Student with these compensatory services within three months of receipt of this decision. However, because the Hearing Officer has no information about Student’s current placement or schedule, the parties may mutually agree to a different schedule for the completion of compensatory education services.
All other requests for compensatory education are denied.
ISSUE IV B: If the District denied Student a FAPE, must it reinstate his group OT services pending further assessment?
Because Student is no longer attending the SDC and the amount of his individual OT services was increased pursuant to the IEP of May 11, 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not appropriate to order the reinstatement of those services. As indicated in Issue IV A above, compensatory education is the appropriate remedy for this denial of FAPE.
ISSUE IV C: If the District denied Student a FAPE, must it provide him speech and language services consistent with the recommendations of his independent assessor?
As discussed in Issue III C, the Hearing Officer has found that the District offered Student an appropriate type and amount of speech services during the 2000-2001 school year. Accordingly, the District was not required to provide speech services consistent with the recommendations of Petitioner’s independent assessor, Ms. Shaffer, during the 2000-2001 school year. However, as discussed in Issue III F, because Student was not in the SDC during the ESY, the District was required to provide individual speech services consistent with Ms. Shaffer’s recommendation. The appropriate amount of compensatory speech services during the ESY has been discussed in Issue IV A, above.
ISSUE V: Must the District reimburse Petitioner’s parents for the cost of its independent speech and language and occupational therapy assessments?
The Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis for reimbursing Petitioner for the costs of either the independent occupational therapy assessment by Ms. Marshall or the independent speech and language evaluation by Ms. Shaffer. As previously indicated, the District appropriately assessed Student’s OT and speech and language needs. Accordingly, reimbursement is denied. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
On May 14, 2001, Petitioner filed a motion to add additional proposed remedies that included a request for reimbursement for Dr. Freeman’s May 2001 psychological evaluation. Dr. Freeman testified that she did not intend for her recommendations to apply retroactively. Because the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s psycho-educational assessment of Student was appropriate, reimbursement will not be ordered. Educ. Code § 56329(b).(Footnote 24)
ORDER
1. Respondent shall provide Student with the following compensatory education services:
a. small group OT services for a total of 540 minutes. In the alternative, upon mutual agreement, Respondent shall provide Student with nine one-hour individual OT sessions.
b. DTT services for a total of thirty-two hours.
c. individual speech and language services for a total of 320 minutes.
2. The compensatory education services required by Order No. 1 shall be completed within three months of the date of receipt of this decision, unless the parties mutually agree to a different schedule for completion.
3. In all other respects, Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
Respondent prevailed on Issues I and II Issues III A, B, C, G, and H Issues IV B and V
Petitioner prevailed on Issue III D
Respondent prevailed in part and Petitioner prevailed in part on
Issues III E and F Issues IV A and C
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: October 26, 2001 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number. 2. On January 25, 2001, this matter initially convened before Hearing Officer Gant who issued a memorandum order, dated February 2, 2001, outlining Petitioner’s issues for hearing. On March 28, 2001, Hearing Officer Woollard issued a summary order denying Petitioner’s request to add new issues. In that summary order, the issues outlined in the order of February 2, 2001, were reiterated and expanded to include the parties’ discussion with the Hearing Officer on February 13, 2001. For clarity of analysis, the Hearing Officer has organized the original nine issues as set forth above and has eliminated those issues that Petitioner indicated were moot in his closing brief (i.e., whether the District denied him a FAPE by failing to provide him with physical therapy and by unilaterally changing his extended school year services without parental consent). 3. On May 14, 2001, Petitioner filed a motion to add additional proposed remedies, which was opposed by Respondent. The additional remedies proposed in the area of compensatory education were encompassed within existing issues. In addition, Petitioner requested an order for reimbursement for the witness fees for Ms. Shaffer, Ms. Feichtmann and Dr. Freeman. The Hearing Office does not have the authority to order reimbursement of witness fees. Finally, Petitioner requested to add remedies of reimbursement for the independent psychological evaluation by Dr. Freeman and for costs of speech and language services of Pamela M. Lewis from February 2001 to the end of ESY 2001. These requests are discussed in Section V. 4. As discussed below, after the October 5, 2000 IEP meeting, the parents did not provide consent to Student’s program or placement on any subsequent IEP document at the IEP meeting. After the IEP meeting of May 11, 2001, consent was provided to program, placement and DIS services, but not to the IEP, goals or objectives. Consent to certain aspects of Student’s program was provided to the District in various letters from Student’s Father to Mr. Conniff. Consent to Student’s goals was provided after some IEP meetings by initialing the goals. Petitioner did not include as an issue for hearing that the District implemented any part of his IEP/s without appropriate parental consent. Calif. Educ. Code § 56346. 5. On November 18, 2000, Student’s Father advised Mr. Conniff that he had not named WOCCSE as a party to the due process hearing and requested that the District exclude Mr. Hemsley from Student’s mediation and hearing process. On January 24, 2001, the Hearing Office denied Petitioner’s motion to exclude Mr. Hemsley from the hearing. See Memorandum Order dated February 2, 2001. 6. The flyer read as follows: “IS YOUR CHILD IN THE HAWES SCHOOL SPECIAL DAY CLASS? PARENT SUPPORT GROUP NOW FORMING.” The parents’ names and telephone number were provided. On November 20, 2000, Student’s Father wrote to Dr. Dishno expressing his concern that the refusal to allow the distribution of the flyers was an effort to stifle communication between parents in the SDC class and that this action may have been in retaliation for the parents’ pending personnel complaint against Mr. Hemsley. 7. On December 6, 2000, Mr. Conniff wrote to the parents to advise them that Student had been receiving APE services as specified in the November 13, 2000 IEP twice a week for a total of sixty minutes a week. Mr. Conniff noted, however, that Student had not received his weekly OT services since that date and had missed four sessions. Mr. Conniff indicated that he was responsible for not informing the OT therapist that the parents consented to the services in their letter of November 14, 2000. As a result, the District agreed to provide Student with four make-up OT sessions, beginning the week of December 11, 2000. Ms. Cracchiolo testified that these make-up sessions had been completed. 8. The parents were initially provided a copy of Ms. Feichtmann’s report through Mr. Conniff’s office that had three pages, with the last page showing Ms. Feichtmann’s signature at the top of the sheet. Ms. Feichtmann’s report was a four-page document that contained six lines of text at the top of the fourth page before her signature. In a letter to the parents dated March 12, 2001, Mr. Conniff apologized for mailing them an incomplete copy. At the hearing, Mr. Conniff testified that he had no idea how the signature page of Ms. Feichtmann’s report was altered to delete six lines of text that contained her recommendation for twice weekly OT(SI) which appeared above to her signature. He received the report from WOCCSE and simply forwarded it. 9 The parents requested that the District’s attorney, Ms. Zuk, not be present at the May 11, 2001 IEP meeting because, in their view, her presence violated the statutory requirement that IEP meetings to be nonadversarial. This request led to a separate due process hearing and decision. 10. The parents’ request for a trained shadow aide, reiterated in the IEP addendum of June 11, 2001 and argued in Petitioner’s closing brief, is not an issue properly before the Hearing Officer. 11. Petitioner cites Amanda J. v. Clark County School District, (9th Cir. August 2001) –F.3d –, 2001 WL 902125, for the proposition that deficits in motor control are an inherent part of the autistic diagnosis. This is not one of the diagnostic criteria for autism. The essential features of autism are “the presence of markedly abnormal or impaired development in social interaction and communication and a markedly restricted repertoire of activity and interests. Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), at 66. 12. On the Sensory Behavior Inventory, Student’s Father wrote that “as a parent, I don’t feel qualified to judge age appropriateness.” 13. In his closing brief, Petitioner refers to the instructions of the test producers in the Assessment, Evaluation and Programming System (AEPS), rather than the Evaluation and Programming System (EPS). It was undisputed that all District assessors utilized the EPS. 14. The Hearing Officer also rejects Petitioner’s contention that the District violated 34 C.F.R. §300.503, by not providing him with the basis for its refusal to initiate an evaluation in these areas. On December 22, 2000, in response to Petitioner’s request for a reason for the denial of swimming lessons, art and music therapy, Mr. Conniff advised the parents that the District did not believe such services were required for Student to benefit from his educational program. To the extent that Mr. Conniff’s letter did not provide sufficient information regarding the District’s basis for refusing to conduct these assessments, there was no showing that Petitioner was prejudiced by either a loss of educational opportunity or by a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Bd. Of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F. 2d 1479. 15. The purpose of the baseline was to determine if the child had mastered, was in progress toward mastering, or had not been taught a variety on skills in the areas of attending, nonverbal imitation, matching, following instructions, verbal imitation, play skills, receptive language, expressive language, and expressive and receptive action labels. After taking the baseline, the checklist was to be used on a quarterly basis to monitor a student’s progress in the DTT program. 16. Petitioner’s reliance Government Code § 7572 (d) for the proposition that a related service or DIS service can be added to an IEP only after a formal assessment has been conduct is misplaced. That section is applicable to interagency responsibilities for related services (i.e., Departments of Mental Health, Health Services, and Social Services). 17. In his closing brief, Petitioner asserts that the District had a “child find” obligation to prepare an earlier assessment plan for PT because he mailed Dr. Stein’s letter to Ms. Herrick and provided it to the IEP team on December 7, 2000. Whether the District complied with its ‘child find’ obligations is an issue that was never raised during the hearing. 18. District witnesses testified that Student had not attended school except for the limited participation in the parent participation preschool. Student’s Mother testified that this was incorrect and that she was shocked that the District had not contacted his prior school, which was part of the District’s program according to Dr. Dishno. She testified that from January to August 2000, Student attended a parent participation pre-preschool once a week for three to three and a half hours. Student’s Mother was with him throughout this time. In September 2000, Student began attending a parent-participation preschool twice a week for three and a half hours a day. Student’s Mother was in the class but not next to Student at all times. Forms completed by the parents at the time of Student’s initial assessment indicated that Student had not attended a nursery school. 19. Student’s Mother testified that she believed Ms. Colomb deliberately lied about whether Student was the youngest student in her class and that she lied about many other things as well. 20. Ms. Colomb testified that, in her opinion, placing Student at St. Wilfred’s two days a week was premature. Based on Student’s progress since he first entered the class, Ms. Colomb believed that her class would continue to be appropriate and challenging for him even for the next school year. 21. On March 21, 2001 and April 26, 2000, Student’s Father wrote to Mr. Conniff to express his concern about Student’s placement in the SDC arising from the parents’ observation of an increase in a variety of self-stimulatory behaviors. The parents proposed withdrawing Student completely from the SDC, but continuing to bring him to Hawes and WOCCSE for his DIS services. At the April 6, 2001 IEP meeting, the team agreed to complete a functional analysis of Student’s behavior. This issue was not included as an issue in this hearing. See: Summary Order dated March 28, 2001. 22. Dr. Freeman testified that Student did not reach a “ceiling,” or point where he repeatedly could not answer questions, on either the receptive or expressive tests on the Mullen. As a result, the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scales of Intelligence-Revised (WPPSI-R) was administered. On the verbal subtests of the WPPSI-R, Student achieved a verbal IQ of 88, in the low average range of verbal abilities, a score that she expected to shift upward over time. 23. The parents also filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) alleging that the District had failed to implement Student’s IEP of October 5, 2000 by failing to facilitate or allow the parents to develop a parent support group at the SDC class at Hawes. On January 24, 2001, CDE found the District to be in compliance. On February 8, 2001, the Hearing Office denied the District’s motion to dismiss this issue and ruled that it was permissible to proceed with the issue of whether the District must facilitate or allow the development of such a group in order for Student to receive a FAPE. 24. In his May 14, 2001 request to add additional remedies, Petitioner requested reimbursement for the costs of his speech and language services by Pamela M. Lewis from February 2001 to the end of ESY 2001. Ms. Lewis did not testify at the hearing and no evidence was presented regarding her qualifications or of the type, frequency or amount of any speech services provided to Student. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer does not order reimbursement for services rendered by her during the ESY.
