California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 18, 2004
Student v. Dublin Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2037-04, SN-2037-04 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin
Dublin Unified's June 2004 IEP and its switch of behavioral providers offered FAPE; parents' reimbursement claim for their chosen agency denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a prior due process case (SN04-00494) filed March 3, 2004 and settled April 5, 2004.
Summary
The parents of a four-and-a-half-year-old boy eligible for special education under autistic-like behaviors filed for due process against Dublin Unified School District. He attended Quarry Lane Preschool, a general education preschool, with a shadow aide. The parents accepted most of the June 11, 2004 IEP. They objected to replacing their chosen behavioral agency, Synergistic Interventions (SI), with PLAY, a provider under contract with the District. They sought reimbursement for SI's services during the 2004 extended school year (ESY) and the 2004-2005 school year. Earlier claims through June 11, 2004 settled at the start of the hearing. The Hearing Officer declined to enforce that settlement or to decide who prevailed on the settled claims.
The Hearing Officer found that the IEP's offer of "up to twenty hours" of transition time was vague, a procedural violation under Union School District v. Smith. But the mother testified she understood the offer to mean twenty hours, so the student lost no educational opportunity and parent participation was not harmed. On the merits, the IEP correctly identified the student's needs. It offered appropriate occupational therapy, adaptive physical education, a one-to-one aide, 15 hours per week of in-home behavioral services, and a three-week transition plan. PLAY was qualified, and the Hearing Officer found SI's director not credible. PLAY later ran short of staff. The District's September 2004 letter naming Quality Behavioral Outcomes (QBO) as the new provider was a valid written change to the offer. Reimbursement was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's choice of behavioral provider. Parents did not have a right to keep a particular agency if the district's provider was qualified. A vague hours term caused no harm because the parent understood the offer. A district could change part of its offer by a specific letter. SEHO also would not enforce settlements or decide prevailing party on settled claims.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1. Did the IEP of June 11, 2004, offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?
The June 11, 2004 IEP offered a FAPE in the LRE for ESY 2004 and the 2004-2005 school year.
- Not reachedThreshold and jurisdiction
Issue 1A(1). Should the Hearing Officer determine prevailing party status for the 2003-2004 school year settlement?
The Hearing Office cannot enforce a settlement agreement (that goes to the California Department of Education complaint process) and declined to decide prevailing party on issues settled off the record before June 11, 2004.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 1A(2). Did the District fail to comply with the requirements of Union School District v. Smith, where the June 11, 2004 offer provided 'up to twenty hours' to transition STUDENT to a new behavioral service provider?
The 'up to twenty hours' language was vague and a procedural violation, but the mother understood it meant twenty hours, so there was no lost educational opportunity and no interference with parent participation.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B. Substantive appropriateness: were STUDENT's unique needs identified, and was the June 11, 2004 offer designed to meet them and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, including the change of behavioral provider from SI to PLAY and the transition plan?
The District had enough information to identify the student's needs, and its OT, APE, aide, 15-hour in-home behavioral program by PLAY, and three-week transition plan were appropriate; the testimony of SI's director was found not credible.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 2. Did the District's modification of its offer on September 17, 2004, deny STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 school year?
The District's letter substituting QBO for PLAY was a specific written modification of the offer that met Union v. Smith, was not made to gain a litigation advantage, and QBO was qualified to deliver the IEP services.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 3. If the IEP failed to offer a FAPE for ESY 2004 and/or the 2004-2005 school year, should the District reimburse STUDENT's parents for the cost of SI's services during ESY 2004 and/or from the start of the 2004-2005 school year to the date of the Decision?
Because the District offered a FAPE, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- The Petitioner's claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified; Fermin v. San Mateo-Foster City School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Blaine Cowick, Ph.D., director of special education, Dublin Unified School District
- Christie Van Slyke (also spelled Christy VanSlyke), special education program specialist and speech and language pathologist, Dublin Unified School District
- Carole King, Ph.D., school psychologist, Dublin Unified School District
- Sherrianne Tennefrancia, occupational therapist, Dublin Unified School District
- Lillian B. Llaneta, occupational therapist, Dublin Unified School District
- Carol Anderson, adaptive physical education specialist, Dublin Unified School District
- Sue Jacobsen, district case manager, Dublin Unified School District
- Victoria Wells, M.A., director and lead behaviorist, nonpublic agency; witness for Student, Synergistic Interventions (SI)
- Kimberly Stokes, C.M.T., co-director, nonpublic agency; witness for Student, Synergistic Interventions (SI)
- Patricia Marin, preschool teacher, Quarry Lane Preschool
- Cheryl Markowitz, director, behavioral services provider, Psychology, Learning and You (PLAY)
- Anne Marie Djetson, co-director of PLAY; occupational therapy provider, Psychology, Learning and You (PLAY)
- Donald Wachelka, director and chief operating officer, behavioral services provider, Quality Behavioral Outcomes (QBO)
- Deborah A. Sedberry, M.D., behavioral and developmental pediatrician (evaluator), private
- Kim Y. Foster, Ph.D., evaluator, Regional Center of the East Bay
- Sally Goodwin, assistant director of preschool, Acorn Learning Center
- Stephanie Blackmun, preschool teacher, Acorn Learning Center
- Adrienne Canales, Early Start special education teacher, Alameda County Office of Education
- Denise Huerta, early intervention assistant, Alameda County Office of Education
- Hitomi Westfall, private occupational therapist, private
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Dublin, California, on September 27-30, and October 1, 5 and 6, 2004.
Petitioner (Student or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Eileen Matteucci. Also present on behalf of STUDENT was his mother and his father, who was present during a portion of the hearing. Dublin Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bridget A. Flanagan of the law firm Miller Brown & Dannis. Also present on the District’s behalf was Blaine Cowick, Ph.D., director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: MOTHER ; Christie Van Slyke, District special education program specialist and speech and language pathologist; Victoria Wells, M.A., director of Synergistic Interventions (SI); and Kimberly Stokes, C.M.T., co-director of SI.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dr. Cowick; Ms. Van Slyke; Carole King, Ph.D., District school psychologist; Sherrianne Tennefrancia and Lillian B. Llaneta, District occupational therapists; Patricia Marin, teacher at Quarry Lane Preschool; Cheryl Markowitz, director of “Psychology, Learning and You” (PLAY); Anne Marie Djetson, co-director of PLAY; and Donald Wachelka, director and chief operating officer of “Quality Behavioral Outcomes” (QBO).
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record remained open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. The Hearing Officer received the last of the written closing arguments on November 2, 2004. The record was then closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the IEP of June 11, 2004, offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?
2. Did the District’s modification of its offer on September 17, 2004, deny STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 school year?
3. If the IEP of June 11, 2004, failed to offer a FAPE to STUDENT for ESY 2004 and/or as modified September 17, 2004, for the 2004-2005 school year to date, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the cost of obtaining the services of SI during ESY 2004 and/or from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the date of this Decision?
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
Petitioner contended that the District did not offer him a FAPE, either for the 2004 ESY or the 2004-2005 school year, because it did not have adequate knowledge of STUDENT’s unique behavioral needs and did not, therefore, offer a program designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Petitioner also contended that his behavioral services provider, SI, was the only provider of behavioral services that had sufficient knowledge of his needs and could therefore provide appropriate services to him. Alternatively, STUDENT contended, if a new provider were to be brought in to provide those services, the District’s offer did not provide either adequate transitional time to a new provider or a suitable alternative provider for either of the periods in issue. The Student contended that the District should reimburse his parents for the cost of SI’s services from June 11, 2004, until the date of the Decision in this matter and that the District should compensate SI directly from the date of the Decision to the end of the 2004-2005 school year.
The District contended that it offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for ESY 2004 and for the 2004-2005 school year. It contended further that the IEP of June 11, 2004, appropriately determined STUDENT’s unique needs and offered a program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit for the 2004 ESY by offering a placement at Quarry Lane Preschool (Quarry Lane) with a “shadow” behavioral aide, occupational therapy (OT) and adaptive physical education (APE) services at school, a fifteen-hour-per-week in-home behavioral intervention program, and an adequate transition program to facilitate a change to a behavioral service provider which was under contract with the District. The District also contended that its offer of the identical behavioral program and services, but by another provider, for the 2004-2005 school year offered STUDENT a FAPE for that year.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a four-and-a-half-year-old boy who resides within the boundaries of the District. He is currently enrolled in Quarry Lane, a preschool that is a certified nonpublic school (NPS). He is eligible for special educations and related services as a student with autistic-like behaviors. 5 C.C.R. § 3030(g).
STUDENT’s motor milestones occurred within expected time frames. He sat up at six months, and walked at sixteen months of age. He spoke his first word at eight months and by the age of two he was using two-word sentences. An audiological assessment performed May 28, 2002, showed normal bilateral hearing sensitivity. However, at two and a half his pediatrician suggested an evaluation of STUDENT’s communication skills. The evaluation determined that STUDENT had moderate receptive and expressive language deficits. The speech pathologist recommended speech and language therapy administered in thirty-minute sessions twice weekly for one year. STUDENT’s parents provided him with the speech and language therapy recommended.
In September 2002, STUDENT entered preschool at Acorn Learning Center (Acorn). In the fall of 2002-2003, assistant director Sally Goodwin observed that STUDENT was having a “difficult” adjustment and was crying much of the time he was in preschool. STUDENT’s parents asked Regional Center of the East Bay (Regional Center) to evaluate STUDENT to determine whether he was eligible for special education services. The Autism Clinic at Regional Center conducted the evaluation because of information related by parents and teachers pertaining to STUDENT’s autistic-like behaviors. He was reported to be easily frustrated, particularly when asked to transition from one activity to another, and, when frustrated, was hitting the other children and exhibiting self-stimulating behaviors such as spinning and flapping. The parents also reported that, when frustrated, STUDENT was striking at them at home, as well. The Clinic recommended strategies to deal with these behaviors. These included services provided by Regional Center beginning October 16, 2002, pursuant to an individual family service plan (IFSP). The Alameda County Office of Education, through its Early Infant Preschool (Early Start), provided STUDENT special education services two days per week. He also attended Acorn two mornings per week.
In preparation for his transition into District schools, and because now STUDENT was having difficulty with toilet training, his parents retained Deborah A. Sedberry, M.D., a behavioral and developmental pediatrician, for further evaluation. As Dr. Sedberry observed in her report, and as Student’s mother testified at the hearing, STUDENT’s self-stimulating behavior continued when he entered preschool. By this time, he also had developed a number of compulsive, ritualistic behaviors related to toilet training. He insisted on turning on the light in the hallway at home and in the bathroom and on personally putting the toilet seat down. He also insisted on personally flushing the toilet. When these rituals were interrupted, STUDENT exhibited tantrum behavior, often violent. Dr. Sedberry observed that his compulsivity and ritualistic behavior relating to toiletry and lighting carried over to the school setting. Student’s mother testified, in addition, that STUDENT found it difficult to interact socially with his peers both at school and outside the school setting. She stated that he often attempted to withdraw from “circle time” at preschool. Dr. Sedberry found sensory integration issues and observed that STUDENT was responsive to deep pressure and being wrapped in a blanket “like a taco.” Dr. Sedberrys’ diagnosis was “pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified” (PDD NOS) or autistic spectrum disorder. She suggested certain strategies focusing on STUDENT’s visual strengths, continued speech therapy, a sensory diet and calming sensory activity, occupational therapy (OT), and medication such as those containing seratonin sensory reuptake inhibitors. She also indicated that he would benefit from an aide at school.
His first IEP meeting in the District was convened May 1, 2003. In attendance at the IEP meeting were STUDENT’s parents, occupational therapist Sherrianne Tennefrancia, Christy VanSlyke, district case manager Sue Jacobsen, and STUDENT’s current Early Start teachers Adrienne Canales, a special education teacher, and Denise Huerta, an early intervention assistant. They also represented the Alameda County Office of Education Early Infant and Family Support Program at the IEP meeting. Ms. Canales and Ms. Huerta delivered their April 2003 developmental summary to the IEP team and participated in the discussion of STUDENT’s unique needs. The IEP team also reviewed the District’s speech and language screening of April 7, 2003, the April 14, 2003 occupational therapy screening by Sherrianne Tennefrancia, the speech-language discharge summary of the Speech Pathology Group dated April 16, 2003, and the psychoeducational evaluation prepared April 17, 2003, by Carole King, District school psychologist. A progress report dated May 30, 2003, from Sally Goodwin, assistant director of Acorn, was also delivered to the IEP team on May 1, 2003.
The IEP team determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services because of his autistic-like behaviors and offered a special day class (SDC) placement in a communicatively handicapped class, four mornings per week, with occupational therapy services, at Croce Elementary School (Croce) within the District. STUDENT’s parents signed the IEP on May 1, 2003, and on May 6, 2003, signed an addendum to the IEP indicating agreement with the program offered. STUDENT entered Croce on May 12, 2003, the following week.
By letter dated May 21, 2003, STUDENT’s parents gave notice to the District that they were withdrawing him from Croce and re-enrolling him at Acorn beginning May 27, 2003; however, this time with a full-time “shadow aide” because, they stated, such an aide was necessary for him to “succeed in a typical preschool.” (Footnote 1) STUDENT’s parents also asked that an IEP be convened.
An IEP meeting was convened on June 6, 2003. The IEP team determined that a change of placement was appropriate. The District agreed to pay STUDENT’s tuition at Acorn and the cost of his one-to-one shadow aide two days per week. A further meeting was to be scheduled to discuss the parents’ proposal for a behavioral intervention evaluation and behavioral intervention services to be provided by an agency identified as Synergistic Interventions (SI). That meeting took place on July 7, 2003. The principals from SI, who were present at the meeting, did not provide statistical information to the IEP team respecting SI’s program or its analysis of STUDENT’s behavior and progress in the SI program. SI did provide a brief “evaluation” of STUDENT consisting of two and a half pages, and containing no testing data or behavioral statistics.
At the July 7, 2003 IEP meeting, the District offered to continue STUDENT’s placement at Acorn two days a week, with a one-to-one aide, two weekly forty-five- minute speech and language therapy sessions delivered in both small-group and individual settings with a sixty-minute consult once monthly, occupational therapy once weekly for forty-five minutes with a sixty-minute consult once monthly, and “behavior-functional analysis @ home & school.” Revisions to, or adoption of, goals and objectives were deferred to the next IEP meeting, to be scheduled when a date acceptable to STUDENT’s parents, the participants from SI, STUDENT’s counsel and the District participants was determined.
In the interim, between the IEP meeting of July 7, 2003, and the next available date, Regional Center utilized STUDENT’s continued eligibility for services to provide an evaluation by Kim Y. Foster, Ph.D. The purpose of the evaluation was to clarify STUDENT’s diagnosis and establish the nature and extent of his disability. Dated July 22, 2003, Dr. Foster’s analysis and testing confirmed STUDENT’s diagnosis as PDD NOS. However, she also included the following comment in her report:
“... [H]is cognitive abilities ... appear to be at least at the average level. These skills somewhat ameliorate the potential for impairment due to his autistic-type behaviors and symptoms. In addition, he clearly has very supportive and capable parents who have worked with him a great deal in regard to his special needs and helped him attain an adequate level of functioning. STUDENT appears to be adequately served in this current educational placement now that he has a shadow aide. If he does not continue to show improvement in his social interaction and reduction of ritualistic behaviors over the next two years, then his parents should have STUDENT re-evaluated to determine his level of adaptive functioning and re-consider his diagnosis.”
By the end of the summer of 2003, there had been no resolution respecting the District’s offer of July 7, 2003. STUDENT continued attending Acorn and continued receiving behavioral services, which included the shadow aide and in-home behavioral analysis and instruction from SI.
Ms. VanSlyke testified that while continuing to find a mutually agreeable date for an IEP meeting, the District sought to learn more about STUDENT’s present levels of performance and it sent an assessment plan to his parents on August 12, 2003, proposing a functional analysis assessment (a behavioral assessment). The parents did not give their consent to the assessment plan.
The next mutually agreed upon date for an IEP meeting was February 12, 2004. In preparation for the meeting, Ms. VanSlyke and Ms. Tennefrancia obtained permission from STUDENT’s parents to observe STUDENT at Acorn. Ms. Tennefrancia presented her observations at the IEP meeting. Her testimony at the due process hearing, consistent with her written OT report of February 12, 2004, and the IEP of the same date, established that STUDENT had made great progress over the six-month period since the IEP team had met. He had met most of his OT goals and objectives and thus was no longer in need of school-based OT services. Stephanie Blackmun, STUDENT’s preschool teacher at Acorn, also reported his progress as positive, stating, “ He was performing above average in all academic subjects, and had improved social skills, particularly in class exercises requiring participation such as ‘circle time.’” There was opposition to the discontinuation of OT services, principally by the SI team members who were present. Ms. VanSlyke testified that after further discussion, the IEP team agreed that Ms. Tennefrancia should consult an additional OT provider familiar with STUDENT to determine if the difference of opinion could be reconciled and whether STUDENT would benefit from additional OT services. Until the results of Ms. Tennefrancia’s consultation, the IEP team determined that STUDENT would be provided OT consultation in the preschool environment once monthly for sixty minutes.
The principals of SI -- Victoria Wells, M.A. and Kimberly Stokes, C.M.T. -- advised the IEP team that they had been providing not only the shadow aide at Acorn for STUDENT, but also a ten-hour-per-week in-home behavioral analysis program since June 2002. They acknowledged STUDENT’s progress, but did not provide to the IEP team any applied behavioral analysis data, customarily given to verify the effect of the behavioral services on his progress. SI recommended the continuation of the aide during the school day and recommended that the in-home behavioral analysis program be increased to twenty hours per week. The rationale for the proposal was that they wanted to take advantage of the increased speed of STUDENT’s learning curve. SI did not provide a statistically based progress report or an intake evaluation as requested by the District.
The District recommended continued placement at Acorn, increased to three mornings per week with the shadow aide, and continued behavioral services. The District stated that it wished to transition to another behavioral service provider and requested that the new provider make a recommendation as to the intensity of the in-home services. The transition was to include observation by the new provider and an exchange of information between SI and the new provider. Cheryl Markowitz, the director of PLAY, was present at the meeting as a potential successor provider. The IEP meeting was continued to February 26, 2004, for the purposes of giving the District an opportunity to observe SI providing STUDENT’s in-home behavioral services, affording additional time for the District to more fully develop a transition plan, and permitting the District more time to determine whether additional behavioral providers were available. The District also requested a second opportunity to observe STUDENT’s interaction with his shadow aide at school.
The District cancelled the February 26, 2004 IEP meeting when the observations requested were denied by STUDENT’s parents. STUDENT’s parents then filed a request for a due process hearing on his behalf on March 3, 2004 (SN04-00494). The parties settled SN04-00494 on April 5, 2004, resolving all issues through April 30, 2004. Ms. Markowitz was allowed to observe STUDENT and his mother interacting in the home for approximately one and one-half hours during the latter half of April 2004. But, SI providers were not present and no observation of the SI in-home program was made.
Ms. Tennefrancia testified that, at the April 29, 2004 IEP meeting, Ms. Blackmun, STUDENT’s teacher at Acorn, again reported on STUDENT’s substantial behavioral progress, his improvement in speech and language skills, and his age-appropriate academic achievement. Ms. Tennefrancia presented proposed OT goals and objectives. Carol Anderson presented the adaptive physical education (APE) assessment and recommended that STUDENT be offered two thirty-minute APE sessions per week. STUDENT’s mother requested that his in-home behavioral intervention program be increased to fifteen hours per week. District members of the IEP team believed they were unable to evaluate her request without input from SI, the behavioral service provider. SI members did not attend the April 29, 2004 IEP meeting. The IEP reflects that the meeting was therefore recessed for the purpose of obtaining information from SI “so that goals/obj can be written & additional programmatic needs addressed.”
Ms. VanSlyke testified that she attempted to follow through by leaving messages at the SI offices seeking to obtain a complete report on STUDENT’s progress, data showing his baseline and present levels of performance, suggested goals and objectives, and information about the home program SI was administering. SI, according to Ms. VanSlyke, did not acknowledge the messages. The following week, Ms. VanSlyke received a letter from STUDENT’s parents, dated May 2, 2004, stating that the District was to contact SI only via a telephone conference call that included STUDENT’s parents and his attorney. During the next five weeks, Ms. VanSlyke testified that she proposed six specific dates for a telephone conference call. No response to the proposed dates was provided. On June 10, 2004, an observation at Acorn was permitted. No observation of SI administering the in-home program was permitted.
The IEP meeting reconvened on June 11, 2004. As will be discussed later in this Decision, the meeting was well attended and all parties participated in the process. The District’s offer, embodied in the June 11, 2004 IEP, consisted of placement at Quarry Lane five mornings per week with shadow aide support, a 15-hour-per-week in-home behavioral support program provided by PLAY, a three-week transition program during which both PLAY and SI would be engaged, an initial post-transition program, OT and APE services. The program offer was to be effective immediately and included the specified services and placement in Quarry Lane’s current 2004 ESY program. By letter dated June 29, 2004, STUDENT’s parents agreed to accept the program offered except for the removal of SI as his provider of behavioral services, and transition to PLAY.
STUDENT enrolled in the 2004 ESY session at Quarry Lane. He received OT and APE services provided by the District, but SI continued to provide the classroom aide and the in-home behavioral program.
On July 29, 2004, the District offered to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for his “educational costs” from May 1, 2004, through June 11, 2004, at such time as the costs were verified. Dr. Cowick testified that the offer of June 29, 2004, was intended to be consistent with the terms of the earlier settlement, which selected April 30, 2004, as the concluding date for reimbursement. However, he stated, because the IEP meeting of April 30, 2004, was rescheduled and the IEP meeting beginning April 29, 2004, did not conclude until June 11, 2004, the latter date was selected after some discussion at the outset of this hearing. During the afternoon of the first day of this Hearing, the parties advised the Hearing Officer that all issues had been settled between them through June 11, 2004. (Footnote 2)
The Hearing Office received the present request for a due process proceeding on August 15, 2004. By letter dated September 15, 2004, the District reaffirmed its offer contained in the June 11, 2004 IEP with one exception for the 2004-2005 school year. The exception was a substitution QBO as the behavioral services provider. The District also offered to convene an IEP meeting to provide STUDENT’s parents and SI personnel an opportunity to evaluate QBO. Dr. Cowick testified at the hearing that what prompted the change was his receiving notification that PLAY no longer had personnel sufficient to service the proposed contract. He also testified that the District’s offer to convene a meeting was declined. The due process hearing convened on September 28, 2004.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the IEP of June 11, 2004, offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
To determine whether the District substantively provided the student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized educational program must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). Federal and State law also requires that districts educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment, with removal from the regular education environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.
To summarize, under the IDEA and the United States Supreme Court decision in Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the District’s proposed program must have been designed to meet the student’s unique and individual needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide the pupil with some educational benefit, and have comported with the IEP. The offer must also have been provided in the least restrictive environment.
The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G v Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra, at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. 458 U.S. at 205. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Accordingly, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to consider both whether procedural requirements have been followed and whether the proposed program was substantively appropriate. Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 206?208.
A. Procedural Appropriateness.
(1) Should the Hearing Officer determine prevailing party status for the 2003-2004 school year settlement?
At the time the request for due process hearing was received by the Hearing Office, the Petitioner raised additional issues involving the educational program offered and/or provided to him during the preceding school year, 2003-2004. Those issues included an alleged denial of FAPE and a request for reimbursement and compensatory education. At the outset of this hearing, the Hearing Officer provided the parties with an opportunity to discuss settlement off the record and outside the presence of the Hearing Officer. Before evidence was taken in the matter, the parties stated on the record that they had resolved all of the issues through June 11, 2004.
Toward the end of the hearing on October 6, 2004, the Petitioner raised a contention, now clearly articulated in his written closing argument, that in fact those issues were not settled until September 29, 2004, the day after the hearing began. Dr. Cowick’s letter to STUDENT’s parents of that date confirmed the dollar amount of the reimbursement, allegedly for the first time.
The Petitioner asks the Hearing Officer to make an additional order and a further finding: (1) an order compelling the District to perform the settlement, and (2) a finding by the Hearing Officer that STUDENT was the prevailing party as to the issues settled.
The Hearing Office is not authorized to enter an order enforcing a settlement agreement. Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District, 223 F.3d 1026 (9th Cir. 2000). Such matters are generally under the jurisdiction of the California Department of Education. 5 C.C.R. § 4650(a)(v). The statutory remedy is the filing of a complaint with the Complaints, Management and Mediation Unit of the California Department of Education. See, Cal. Educ. Code § 56500.2; 5 C.C.R.§§ 4600-4671. Additionally, whether the resolution of the matter was effective when agreed to in principle subject to verification of the amounts, or when the parties agreed on the exact amounts to be reimbursed, all of the issues relating to time periods preceding June 11, 2004, were resolved off the record and out of the presence of the Hearing Officer. It is inappropriate for the Hearing Officer to make a finding determining matters settled outside the presence of the Hearing Officer and off the record. Education Code section 56507(d) expressly provides: “The hearing decision shall indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided...” (Emphasis supplied). There is sufficient information available to the parties for a court of competent jurisdiction to determine whether issues resolved in the settlement were the product primarily of the efforts of one party or the other.
The Hearing Officer declines, therefore, to consider any issues relating to any period prior to the stipulated effective date of the settlement, June 11, 2004, and to consider prevailing party status except for issues set forth above.
(2) Did the District fail to comply with the requirements set forth in Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir., 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994).
STUDENT alleged that the provision in the District’s June 11, 2004 offer of “up to twenty hours” to transition STUDENT to a new behavioral service provider was vague and thus constituted a violation of the specificity requirements of Union School District v. Smith, supra. Union is cited in support of the proposition that the District’s offer must be specific and written. A provision in an IEP that provides services for a variable period of time is generally held to constitute a procedural error. The IEP of June 11, 2004, was prepared at the meeting itself and is handwritten. The phrase “up to twenty hours” is vague, apparently leaving to someone the discretion of determining precisely how many hours would be provided in the transition program. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that a procedural violation exists.
Having determined that a procedural violation occurred, the Hearing Officer must determine whether that violation caused any prejudice to STUDENT or his parents. See in this regard, Fermin v. San Mateo-foster City School District, 33 I.D.E.L.R. 30 (U.S.Dist.Ct., N.D. Cal., 2000). The Hearing Officer finds significant that STUDENT offered no evidence to support a claim that the error, if any, would cause him a loss of educational opportunity or that it interfered with his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process. In fact, the evidence showed that STUDENT’s parents did participate in the IEP of June 11, 2004, and that they were represented at the meeting by counsel. Significantly, STUDENT’s mother testified at the hearing that she was not misled at all and that she understood from the discussion at the June 11, 2004 IEP meeting that the offer was intended to provide a transition program of a total of twenty hours. District witnesses confirmed this testimony.
The Hearing Officer concludes on the basis of Student’s mother’s testimony, that this imprecise phrase in the IEP did not cause STUDENT to lose educational opportunity and did not interfere with his parents’ right to participate in the IEP process
B. Substantive Appropriateness.
STUDENT had been diagnosed as having pervasive developmental disorder, not otherwise specified. It manifested in gross motor and sensory-motor integration and behavioral issues. The District determined STUDENT’s special education eligibility as due to autistic-like behaviors. STUDENT contended that the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, was not designed to meet his unique needs or calculated to provide him educational benefit.
He contended in his statement of issues, at the hearing itself, and in closing argument, that the District did not determine correctly his unique needs because it did not have sufficient information about him to do so. However, he did not introduce evidence in support of his claim, but instead relied on the holding in Clyde K. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No.3, 35 F.3d 1396 (9th Cir., 1994) and its progeny that the District is required to prove that its offer was an offer of FAPE.
The District contended that on the basis of the information that it had, the offer of June 11, 2004, if implemented, would have provided STUDENT a FAPE for ESY 2004 and the 2004-2005 school year.
(1) What Are STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
Federal and State law describe the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child’s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law, “the services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a free appropriate public education must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” 34, C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3)(ii).
Therefore, the Hearing Officer now turns to a determination of whether the District members of the IEP team appropriately identified STUDENT’s unique needs at the IEP meeting of June 11, 2004. (Footnote 3)
(a) Occupational Therapy (OT) Needs:
Sherrianne Tennefrancia established her continuity with STUDENT’s special education program when she testified at the hearing that she conducted STUDENT’s initial District OT screening at Acorn when he was three years old. Her evaluation at that time, which included both classroom observation and record review, concluded that STUDENT had sensory-motor deficits and needed OT services, on a pull-out basis initially, for forty-five minutes per week with a monthly sixty-minute consult. The IEP team adopted her recommendations at STUDENT’s May I, 2003 IEP meeting. Ms. Tennefrancia assigned Anne Marie Djetson as the OT provider and acted as supervisor. (Footnote 4)
In preparation for STUDENT’s next IEP meeting, February 12, 2004, Ms. Tennefrancia testified that she again observed STUDENT at Acorn. She stated that he showed great improvement. At the time, he and Ms. Djetson were working on OT goals and objectives that exceeded those described in the May 2003 IEP. Ms. Tennefrancia reported to the February 12, 2004 IEP meeting that STUDENT’s motor skill development was within age appropriate range and at a par with his peers. She also stated that she did not observe any perseverative, ritualistic, or self-stimulatory behaviors, and concluded that he no longer needed school-based OT. As stated earlier, Kimberly Stokes of SI, one of STUDENT’s behavioral service providers, did not agree with the recommendation. Because Ms. Stokes had more frequent and lengthy contact with STUDENT, the IEP team considered her input. Although Ms. Stokes stated that she did not believe that STUDENT was ready for termination of OT services, she did confirm, however, that Ms. Tennefrancia’s observations were accurate at the time they were made. Out of caution, the IEP team determined that STUDENT continued to need OT consults to monitor his progress. The written IEP reflects that the team also asked Ms. Tennefrancia to consult with other providers and report back at the next IEP meeting with respect to whether it would be appropriate, considering STUDENT’s needs, to develop OT strategies as needed to fit within a more integrated sensory-motor program.
Prior to the June 11, 2004, IEP meeting, Ms. Tennefrancia consulted with Hitomi Westfall, STUDENT’s private OT provider. They concluded that STUDENT still needed once-weekly regular school-based OT services and a once-monthly consultation for the purpose of ensuring his continued developmental progress as well as providing a vehicle for collaborative work among the occupational therapists and other staff providing STUDENT’s special educational services. Ms. Tennefrancia reported these conclusions to the IEP team at the June 11, 2004, IEP meeting. She testified that the team accepted her recommendation and incorporated them into STUDENT’s IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Tennefrancia’s testimony persuasive because of her openness, evidenced by disclosing her willingness to challenge her initial recommendations and modify them after consulting another OT professional. Further, her educational background and extensive prior experience, coupled with her prior service to STUDENT, qualify her to make a well-informed recommendation. The IEP team followed her recommendation and determined that STUDENT had made progress, but required monitoring and an OT program integrated with his other service. Petitioner provided no evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the IEP had sufficient information to determine STUDENT’s OT program and that the June 11, 2004 IEP appropriately reflects STUDENT’s need as to OT services.
(b) Adaptive Physical Education (APE) Needs.
Carol Anderson, District APE specialist, evaluated STUDENT’s need for APE services. Her assessment of April 26, 2004, utilizing the LAUSD Preschool Developmental Scale and the Brigance Motor Skills Inventory, identified continuing developmental deficits in STUDENT’s gross motor skills. Ms. Anderson determined that he needed APE services to correct these deficits, and recommended that the services be delivered on the school campus at a frequency of one time per week for thirty minutes. The IEP team accepted the report and recommendation, determining that STUDENT had APE needs as stated.
STUDENT did not present evidence at the hearing disputing the determination of his need for APE, or the place of delivery or frequency of the APE services. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had sufficient information to determine an APE program for STUDENT and that it appropriately determined his APE needs.
(c) Need for One-to-One Behavioral Aide Support in Classroom.
Deborah M. Sedberry, M.D., the pediatric behavioral and developmental specialist consulted by the District, first identified STUDENT’s need for one-to-one behavioral aide support in the classroom. Dr. Sedberry and other assessors, including District school psychologist Carole King, Ph.D., agreed that a classroom aide would be of significant support in assisting STUDENT with his behavioral needs, particularly considering his difficulty transitioning from topic to topic or from one activity to another, his difficulty with social interaction, and his perseverative behaviors. That need was incorporated into all of STUDENT’s IEPs. The reports of Drs. Sedberry and King were provided to the IEP team on April 29, 2004, and June 11, 2004. Student’s mother, Ms. Wells from SI, Ms. Tennefrancia, and Ms. Markowitz, provided additional input at the IEP meeting on June 11, 2004. The District IEP team members determined at that meeting that one-to-one behavioral support in the classroom was a lessening but continuing need. The District’s offer, in the IEP of that date contained a provision for a one-to-one behavioral aide in the classroom.
STUDENT has not disputed the determination that he had a continuing need for one-to-one behavioral aide support in the classroom. In support of his contention that the District had insufficient information to make a determination, STUDENT suggested that the District had no information of its own. Considering Dr. King’s testimony relating to her assessment and record review, and Ms. VanSlyke’s and Ms. Markowitz’s testimony about the discussion at the meeting, the Hearing Officer finds that contention unsupported. In addition, the testimony established that the District appropriately considered assessment and other information provided by the Student as required by California Education Code sections 56329 (c) and 56381.
Because STUDENT did not dispute the need for continuing aide support in the classroom and given the overwhelming evidence supporting STUDENT’s need for aide support, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District appropriately determined STUDENT’s unique need in that regard.
(d) Need for Behavioral Intervention Services.
The evidence at the hearing established that STUDENT had difficulty focusing, lapsed into preservative behaviors from time to time, avoided social contact with peers, and had difficulty with transitions across topics, activities, places and persons. STUDENT’s parents and SI advocated for the continuation of both in-class and in-home behavioral services. No one from the District disagreed, although the testimony of Ms. VanSlyke, Ms. Marin and Ms. Tennefrancia established that the District appeared more willing to acknowledge STUDENT’s progress than did the witnesses appearing on his behalf.
Carole King, PhD., District school psychologist, testified that on the basis of her review of the Sedberry assessment, the Gillian Autistic Rating Scale administered by Children’s Hospital, her administration of the Southern California Ordinal Scales test and her recent interview of STUDENT, she concluded that STUDENT continued to have behavioral deficits and exhibit autistic-like behaviors, although to a lesser degree currently. She concluded that he continued to have unique needs for behavioral intervention services, although she emphasized in her testimony that, in her opinion, while he did not require a formal functional analysis assessment (FAA), those services should be provided in conformity with an informal behavioral intervention plan (BIP) provided by a qualified behaviorist. Such a plan would describe the services needed, together with a system for tracking services delivered and behaviors observed both at school and in-home.
STUDENT did not dispute the determination that he continued to have needs in this area, and did not challenge the need for a written BIP that included a system for tracking services delivered and behaviors observed.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that IEP of June 11, 2004, appropriately reflects Petitioner’s need for behavioral intervention services.
(e) Need for Transitional Services.
The District members of the June 11, 2004 IEP team also determined to change STUDENT’s present behavioral services provider, SI. The testimony established that SI had been providing direct behavioral services at school, by providing one of its behaviorists as the shadow aide, while it also provided direct behavioral services in the in-home program by providing one of its behaviorists in that program. The District team members proposed to transition the classroom behavioral services to a District-employed school aide to be trained by PLAY. It was also determined that the in-home behavioral program would be transitioned over to PLAY, which would staff that portion of the behavioral program with by one of its behaviorists.
The IEP team considered the evaluations of Dr. Sedberry and Dr. King and determined that, consistent with STUDENT’s difficulties with transitions in general, STUDENT had a unique need for assistance with the transition. The IEP team determined further that STUDENT’s need required the provision of transition services that it described in a transition plan in the IEP. Dr. King, Ms. Markowitz and Ms. VanSlyke all testified at the hearing that upon a change of behavioral service providers, STUDENT would have a need for transition services.
Petitioner contended that no transition plan was needed because he disagreed with the proposed change of service providers. However, he did not dispute that one of STUDENT’s needs was for support during transitions. Thus, if a transition were ordered, Petitioner agreed that transitional services would be necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District correctly determined that one of STUDENT’s unique needs was for transitional services.
(f) Summary.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that STUDENT’s unique needs were identified correctly at the June 11, 2004 IEP meeting and included continued pull-out OT and APE services, a one-to-one classroom aide for behavioral support, in-home behavioral services, and transitional services.
(2) Was the District’s Offer of June 11, 2004, Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Unique Needs?
Next it must be determined if the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer views the appropriateness of the District’s offer in light of the evidence that the IEP team had at the time the offer was made. Adams v. Oregon (9th Cir.1999) 195 F.3d 1141. As stated earlier, the District’s offer must be designed to meet the student’s needs. Moreover, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left to the school district’s discretion. Board of Education of the Hedrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, supra at 207-208; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist., supra at 1314.
The June 11, 2004 IEP contained the District’s offer. The offer provided placement in a general education preschool class at Quarry Lane. The change of schools was made pursuant to STUDENT’s request. Ms. VanSlyke testified, and Student’s mother agreed, that Quarry Lane provided more focus on academic achievement than did Acorn. According to Patricia Marin, STUDENT’s teacher at Quarry Lane, the academic program is more accelerated than at other typical general education schools. Ms. Marin testified that STUDENT’s language skills were above average and that his academic skills were “quite advanced.” The District’s offer proposed no academic support. STUDENT did not dispute this.
Ms. Tennefrancia reported on STUDENT’s OT present levels of performance. Based on his progress since the adoption of the OT goals and objectives in May 2003, she proposed three OT goals with five interim objectives or benchmarks. The OT program was designed to be part of an integrated program with his other providers. The June 11, 2004 offer contained her recommendation and, accordingly, included an offer of one thirty-minute OT session per week, with a monthly consultation of sixty minutes, plus adoption of the proposed goals and objectives. STUDENT did not argue that the OT program offered was incorrectly designed, considering his OT needs.
The offer also contained three revised APE goals and twelve objectives proposed by the District APE specialist. The proposal included the delivery of APE services on the school campus at a frequency of one time per week for thirty minutes. The June 11, 2004 IEP contained the District’s offer of APE services in this regard. STUDENT did not dispute the APE program provided in the IEP.
The area of contention was behavioral services. STUDENT contended that the District did not have sufficient information to design an appropriate behavioral plan. He argued in addition that the District’s proposal for implementation of the plan with a change of providers was inappropriate. Finally, he stated that even if the plan and implementation were acceptable, the transition plan was inappropriate.
Turning now to the first contention, STUDENT argued that his NPA behavioral services provider, SI, was the only provider that had sufficient knowledge of his needs to design an appropriate behavioral plan. However, STUDENT did not produce evidence that SI had exclusive and unique knowledge about designing behavioral plans. The District school psychologist, Dr. King, demonstrated by her testimony that she had knowledge of STUDENT’s needs and that she had extensive experience designing students’ behavioral plans over her thirty-three-year career as a certified school psychologist. Dr. King testified that the design of a behavioral plan proceeds by determining the functions of the behaviors, determining their antecedents, frequency and duration; then determining appropriate replacement behaviors, and positive reinforcement tools; and, by scripting, repetitively using positive reinforcements to imbed the replacement behaviors in the student. Dr. King testified that she attended the June 11, 2004 IEP meeting and that the behavioral goals and objectives were written collaboratively on the basis of the information about STUDENT’s needs discussed previously. (Footnote 5) She stated further that SI’s use of massage therapy, as a reinforcement device, is another tool but not a major change in scripting theory.
Victoria Wells, SI’s lead behaviorist, testified similarly that the design of the BIP that SI was implementing for STUDENT was based on applied behavioral analysis principals, which she described as determining the function of the target behavior; determining an appropriate replacement behavior; and ascertaining what method of positive reinforcement the student responds to, for the purpose of engaging in scripting.
The District members of the IEP team, absent the SI providers who left the June 11, 2004, meeting early, designed a behavioral program for STUDENT that address each of the areas of his behavioral needs, as STUDENT, himself, acknowledged in his written closing argument:
[T]he June 11, IEP appears to have all of the elements of an appropriate behavior program. The proposed social skill goals included one goal in each of then different areas of play. The proposed behavior goals consist of one goal for 4 different types of behavior: tantrums, stereotypical behavior, refusal and perseverative behavior.
The Hearing Officer finds inconsistent STUDENT’s argument that the District did not have sufficient knowledge to design an appropriate program, while admitting that the IEP contained appropriate behavioral goals and objectives in each of the areas of STUDENT’s difficulty. The Hearing Officer observes, also, that STUDENT neither followed through with a statement explaining how the offer was deficient in this area nor proposed any alternative or different behavioral goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer therefore finds STUDENT’s contention unsupported by the evidence and concludes that the District members of the IEP team had adequate knowledge to design an appropriate behavioral plan for STUDENT. (Footnote 6)
STUDENT’s second contention was that the District’s proposal to implement the behavioral plan with a new provider, specifically PLAY, was inappropriate. Cheryl Markowitz, director of PLAY, was present at the June 11, 2004, IEP meeting and participated in the development of the District’s behavioral plan. She received her B.A. degree from Rutgers University, her M.A. from Kane University, and has been working in the field of behavioral services since 1991. Ms. Markowitz testified that she had extensive experience working with children with autistic spectrum disorder. She began working in the field in 1971, was trained in Lovaas methodology by Dr. Lovaas, was trained in the PECS program, integrated play-group methodology, social stories, scripting, discretional training, peer modeling, positive reinforcement, and other methods of treatment. STUDENT did not challenge Ms. Markowitz’s credentials or the credentials of other behaviorists providing services for PLAY. PLAY has approximately 100 students in its care. Its clients are located primarily in the San Francisco East Bay area, where the District is located. The model developed by PLAY is to train district personnel as shadow aides and to provide direct behavioral service to the Student in-home. The services provided follow an applied behavioral analysis model. Ms. Markowitz stated that she and the behaviorists at PLAY utilize the methods from among the numerous options based upon the practical consideration of what works for the particular student. Ms. Markowitz demonstrated during her testimony that she and her staff had extensive knowledge and experience in providing services to children with autistic-like behaviors.
The Hearing Officer concludes, on the basis of the absence of evidence presented by Petitioner to demonstrate that PLAY was not qualified or unable to provide behavioral services to STUDENT as well as on the basis of the testimony discussed above demonstrating that PLAY is a qualified provider of behavioral services and utilizes methodologies as appropriate to the student, that the District’s offer to implement the behavioral plan with PLAY as the provider was appropriate.
Petitioner’s third contention challenged the transition plan itself, as inadequate. To address STUDENT’s need for assistance with transitions, the District proposed a transition plan. (Footnote 7) It consisted of a three-week period during which both SI and PLAY personnel would provide behavioral intervention services cooperatively and jointly. SI was to phase out gradually during the three-week period as PLAY gradually took over as sole provider. During this period, Ms. VanSlyke testified, SI was to share with PLAY the techniques that had proven successful with STUDENT and they were to jointly train the new classroom aide. PLAY was also required by the IEP team to perform a complete record review and prepare a written behavioral assessment and BIP so that STUDENT’s needs in this area could be quantified and his progress measured more accurately.
Ms. Markowitz, a qualified behaviorist, testified that in her experience children with autistic spectrum disorders are typically sensitive to changes and that the transition process was delicate. She stated, in addition, that PLAY was familiar with the process of transitioning behavioral service providers. She stated further that in her opinion the transition proposed for STUDENT would meet his needs and prove successful. Also testifying was Dr. Donald Wachelka, director and chief operating officer of QBO, behavioral service provider. He related that his agency has transitioned in as well as transitioned out of cases involving children with disorders on the autistic spectrum. He stated that there is no “magic” to a transition, suggesting that the practical way of determining exactly how the transition would occur takes place during the initial assessment process by the new provider. He testified additionally that twenty hours (the time provided over the three-week program offered to STUDENT) “seemed like a healthy set of hours for this process.”
The only support to Petitioner’s third contention came from the testimony of Victoria Wells. The Hearing Officer observed that Ms. Wells was resistant to questioning and appeared hostile to cross-examination. She also had a direct and substantial financial interest in the resolution of the due process proceeding. She admitted she was suspicious of the District’s examination in view of a reported conflict over another matter in a neighboring school district. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that Ms. Wells was not a credible witness. On the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Markowitz’s and Dr. Wachelka’s knowledgeable and informative testimony provided a credible response to the Petitioner’s contention.
The Hearing Officer, relying on the credible testimony of Dr. King, Ms. Markowitz and Dr. Wachelka, finds that the behavioral services including the transition plan offered by the District to STUDENT were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs. (Footnote 8)
On the basis of the testimony and documentary evidence presented at the hearing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, was designed to meet each of STUDENT’s unique needs.
(3) Was the Offer Described in the IEP of June 11, 2004, Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit to STUDENT?
The Hearing Officer must next determine if the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that the District designed a program to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of OT, APE, behavioral support in the classroom, in-home behavior and transition.
Each of the witnesses, including those called by STUDENT, stated that they had knowledge that he benefited greatly in each of his areas of need by virtue of the program provided to him by the Regional Center beginning in the 2002-2003 school year and by the District since the 2003-2004 school year. According to these witnesses, STUDENT has made progress in each of the areas of his unique needs and he requires additional assistance to meet his goals in these areas. All of the witnesses testified that the services provided by the June 11, 2004 IEP would result in STUDENT’s continued progress toward his goals.
Therefore, on the basis of the undisputed evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s proposed offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT.
(4) Did the Proposed Program Conform to STUDENT’s IEP?
There is no dispute that the District was willing to provide the program specified in STUDENT’s IEP.
(5) Conclusion.
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for ESY 2004 and for the 2004-2005 school year, memorialized in the IEP of June 11, 2004, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, conformed to his IEP, and thus offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004 ESY and 2004-2005 school year. It also provided him with education in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 9)
2. Did the District’s modification of its offer on September 17, 2004, deny STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 school year?
A. Procedural Appropriateness.
STUDENT argues that the District’s offer of an educational program in the June 11, 2004 IEP was final. He contends that the offer can only be modified through a subsequent IEP meeting. Therefore, he argues, the District’s attempt to modify it by letter, delivered to him by the District on the eve of the hearing, is ineffective and constitutes a violation of the requirements of Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). The District acknowledged that it could not modify an IEP by letter, but contended that it could make adjustments to its offer as long as they were specific and in writing, as was the modification of September 17, 2004.
There is only one change to the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, affecting STUDENT’s educational program for the 2004-2005 school year, namely, the change to QBO as STUDENT’s behavioral service provider. There was no ambiguity generated by the District’s letter. It simply informed of a change of provider and offered to schedule an IEP meeting, as Dr. Cowick testified was necessary because PLAY notified the District that it no longer had sufficient personnel to service the proposed contract.
While the IDEA and Union, supra, require local educational agencies to make a formal written offer of placement, the law does not require that the offer be contained in only one document. In determining whether an offer meeting the standards set in Union, supra, had been made, the Hearing Office has consistently considered offers contained in more than one document (See, for illustrative purposes, the reasoning in, Student v. San Jose Unified School District, et al., SN99-01033).
The purpose of the September 17, 2004 letter was to offer to modify one factor of the educational program presented in the June 11, 2004 IEP. That is, where the IEP offered a program that included transition of behavioral services from SI to PLAY, the letter proposes a different behavioral service provider, namely QBO – a provider not previously discussed with STUDENT’s parents. The letter contains a specific statement of the District’s intention to modify its offer. The District also invited the Student, in the same letter, to an IEP meeting to discuss the change. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s letter seeking to amend its offer and calling an IEP meeting does not violate the procedural requirements of special education law.
Although not really a procedural protection set forth in the IDEA, the Hearing Officer addresses Petitioner’s allegation that the modification was made on the eve of the due process hearing in order to gain an advantage at the hearing. As the evidence established, it had been made eleven days earlier. The evidence showed that this matter involves an educational program offered to the Student at an IEP meeting in June 2004, with disagreement, discussions and an exchange of correspondence over the summer months. The District’s letter falls naturally into that time period. Additionally, the Hearing Officer observes that the District’s letter is contemporaneous with the information it received about the originally proposed provider’s unavailability, as is discussed hereafter.
The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the Dr. Cowick’s letter of September 17, 2004, was a modification to the District’s offer contained in the June 11, 2004 IEP that conforms to the requirements of Union, supra, and that it was not made to gain an advantage in the due process litigation.
B. Substantive Appropriateness.
As stated above, the change to the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, affecting STUDENT’s educational program for the 2004-2005 school year, was a change to QBO as STUDENT’s behavioral service provider required as a result of the unavailability of the aide previously secured. Thus, the substantive inquiry as to whether the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the current school year is limited to the ability of the proposed provider to provide qualified personnel to deliver the services described in STUDENT’s June 11, 2004 IEP. Dr. Cowick is well-qualified to make a selection of a behavioral service provider. Dr. Cowick graduated with a B.A. and an M.A. in psychology. His master’s thesis was about special psychological services in social skills development. He received his Ph.D. from the University of California at Berkeley, where his dissertation was on functional analysis assessments and behavioral program development. Dr. Cowick became a certified school psychologist in 1984, has worked in special education programs continuously since, has also taught graduate level college courses in behavioral intervention, data collection and record keeping at California State University, San Francisco and the University of Montana.
Dr. Cowick testified that he selected QBO because he was aware that QBO was providing acceptable services to children with autistic spectrum disorders in this District as well as neighboring Districts. He had experience working with Dr. Wachelka previously, had checked QBO out thoroughly, conversed with Dr. Wachelka by telephone and concluded that QBO was qualified to provide services to STUDENT pursuant to the June 11, 2004 IEP.
Dr. Wachelka is the CEO and executive director of QBO, an agency that provides behavioral and educational services to more than 100 students in California schools. He received his B.A. from Florida State University and his M.A. from the University of Pennsylvania, both in the field of Applied Behavioral Analysis. Dr. Wachelka provides training to staff and supervision of services both in the classroom and in the home. Since the mid-1990s, he has provided behavioral services, instruction and college-level teaching both in Florida and California.
Dr. Wachelka testified that QBO provides behavioral and educational services to school districts and to individual clients. The staff consists of behavior analysts who are board certified and have a minimum educational requirement of a master’s degree, and behavior specialists and behaviors technician, who have a minimum educational requirement of a bachelor’s degree. Under his ultimate supervision, the staff provides assessments, intervention and analysis of providers, programs and services and direct service, as needed. Dr. Wachelka stated during his testimony that QBO was available to provide services to STUDENT and would do so within the parameters and direction of his IEP. He indicated that in STUDENT’s case, the QBO assessment would focus on determining what the functions of STUDENT’s inappropriate behaviors are, what stimulus he responds to, including physical contact, and how he responds to positive reinforcement of substitute behaviors. He stated that this process would take place during the transition period. He testified that QBO’s procedure is to develop a treatment plan with measurable criteria and develop a data collection and analysis process to determine the student’s responsiveness and performance on the treatment plan.
Dr. Wachelka’s description of the objectives and administration of a behavioral service plan was similar to that of Ms. Markowitz, also a qualified behaviorist. The Hearing Officer, relying on Dr. Cowick’s opinion, the testimony of the behavioral service providers, and the lack of a serious challenge by STUDENT to QBO’s qualifications, finds that the change in the District’s offer to QBO as a provider of behavioral services to STUDENT offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year.
3. If the IEP of June 11, 2004, failed to offer a FAPE to STUDENT for ESY 2004 and/or as modified September 17, 2004, for the 2004-2005 school year to date, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the cost of obtaining the services of SI during ESY 2004 and/or from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the date of this Decision?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under IDEA and are reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir 1994). The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer of June 11, 2004, was an offer to provide a FAPE to STUDENT for the 2004 ESY and the 2004-2005 school year and that the District’s letter dated September 17, 2004, was appropriate to modify the District’s offer. In view of those findings, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are not entitled to reimbursement for tuition paid to the nonpublic school.
ORDER
The Petitioner’s claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute
1. Did the IEP of June 11, 2004, offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2004 extended school year and the 2004-2005 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District’s modification of its offer on September 17, 2004, deny STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2004-2005 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue.
3. If the IEP of June 11, 2004, failed to offer a FAPE to STUDENT for ESY 2004 and/or as modified September 17, 2004, for the 2004-2005 school year to date, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to STUDENT’s parents for the cost of obtaining the services of SI during ESY 2004 and/or from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year to the date of this Decision?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 18, 2004 ___________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
A “shadow aide” is an aide who is introduced to the students as a classroom aide but who is always close to his/ her assigned student, or “shadows” the student in the classroom.
2 Dr. Cowick confirmed the amount of the reimbursement in a letter dated September 29, 2004. There is some disagreement as to whether the District complied with the terms of the settlement agreement, a matter not within the purview of the Hearing Office as is discussed in the Hearing Officer’s analysis of the procedural appropriateness of STUDENT’s IEP.
3 Neither Student nor the District discussed the criteria for providing an ESY program to Student in 2004. Thus, as the issue was not raised, it will not be discussed in this Decision.
4 Ms. Tennefrancia testified that she had been an occupational therapist for approximately eleven years and was evaluating cases and providing supervisory and direct services to OT clients of the District, Regional Center and two NPSs at the present time.
5 SI left the June 11, 2004 IEP meeting without making any recommendations, citing “other conflicting obligations.” The IEP team nevertheless considered their earlier recommendation.
6 SI’s Victoria Stokes testified that because of instructions from Student’s parents, SI refused to allow observations of its delivery of behavioral services to Student, refused to provide the District with statistical data reflecting Student’s behaviors, and provided the District only a scant two and a half page report that was conclusory but not factually informative. The Hearing Officer observes that Student’s contention relating to the District’s alleged lack of information appears to have resulted from the lack of information provided to the District by Student’s parents.
7 This term is not to be confused with the same term used as a term of art, described in California Education Code sections 56341.5(d), 56345 and 5 C.C.R. § 3024.
8 There was considerable evidence introduced by the District relating to the certification of SI as an NPA and the qualifications of its personnel. The Hearing Officer finds that evidence informative but not material, because the proper inquiry is whether the District’s offer was designed to meet the student’s unique needs. Similarly, informative but not material to this Decision in light of the finding that the District offered an appropriate behavioral service program designed to meet Student’s unique needs, was the evidence offered to justify the dismissal of SI because it was uncooperative and failed to provide required data.
9 As discussed above, the student also must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 34 C.F.R. § 300.550 et seq; Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. LRE requires that children with disabilities be educated with children without disabilities to the maximum extent possible. There was no disagreement over the placement at Quarry Lane, a general education preschool, as the LRE. Further, the testimony of Patricia Marin established that Quarry Lane was a preschool providing only general education classes. Therefore, LRE is not discussed in this Decision.
