California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 24, 2003

Student v. Huntington Beach Union High School District et al.

SEHO Case No. SN 2042-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Huntington Beach districts denied FAPE in reading and writing; IEP team must set compensatory decoding services, not 240 clinic hours.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 4 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None stated.

Summary

The parents of a student with a specific learning disability based on an auditory processing disorder filed for hearing against Huntington Beach City Elementary School District, Huntington Beach Union High School District, and the West Orange County Consortium for Special Education. They challenged her eighth-grade program (2001-2002) and her ninth-grade program through November 19, 2002. They asked for 240 hours of intensive Lindamood-Bell clinic services as compensatory education.

The Hearing Officer found that her needs were listening comprehension, auditory recall, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and basic writing. In eighth grade, the program worked for listening, auditory recall, and writing. However, her decoding scores did not improve during the year, and her IEP had no reading comprehension goals. Both failures denied her a FAPE. The high school's May 2002 transition IEP also had no reading goals and gave her no services to work on her writing goals. That also denied a FAPE. The high school did provide the accommodations, speech-language consultation, and resource monitoring her IEP required.

The Hearing Officer ordered an IEP meeting within 15 days to plan decoding instruction and decide on compensatory decoding services. If the team chose Lindamood-Bell type services, they had to be given in summer, and 54 hours was the appropriate amount. The team also had to write reading comprehension and writing goals. The Hearing Officer ordered no compensatory education for comprehension or writing because she had made strong progress in both. He also denied reimbursement for the parents' private assessments.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows a SEHO Hearing Officer treating missing IEP goals as a denial of FAPE even when the student was progressing. It also shows him relying on decoding test scores over good grades. He sized compensatory education by the student's actual needs and her class time, not by a private provider's recommended hours, and he left the details to the IEP team.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did HBCESD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to offer services designed to meet her unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder?

    The eighth-grade program met needs in listening comprehension, auditory recall and basic writing, but denied FAPE in reading decoding (no measurable progress) and reading comprehension (no IEP goals).

  2. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2A. For the period from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through November 19, 2002, did HBUHSD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer services designed to meet STUDENT's unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder?

    The May 9, 2002 transition IEP was appropriate for listening comprehension and auditory recall, but denied FAPE because it had no reading goals and no services to carry out its writing goals.

  3. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2B. For the same period, did HBUHSD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to properly implement the accommodations, consultative services, and monitoring specified in the May 9, 2002 IEP?

    The accommodations, twice-monthly speech-language consultation with the reading teacher, and RSP monitoring were all provided as the IEP required.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. If one or more of the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during all or a portion of the period from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

    Compensatory decoding services were ordered, to be set by the IEP team (54 hours of summer Lindamood-Bell type services if that method is chosen, not the 240 hours requested); none for comprehension or writing; assessment reimbursement denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, Respondents must convene an IEP meeting and formulate a program for reading decoding. The team may arrange further assessment, must consider that services since November 2001 produced no measurable decoding progress, and should avoid substantial loss of class or homework time. Specialist support within the reading skills class period may be an appropriate balance.
  • Compensatory education. At the same IEP meeting, the team must determine the amount of compensatory reading decoding services owed for the period from the start of 2001-2002 through November 19, 2002. Off-campus intensive services during the school year would be counterproductive. Any Lindamood-Bell type services must be given in the summer, and 54 hours is the appropriate amount; 240 hours would be excessive.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. At the same IEP meeting, the team must determine present levels, develop goals and objectives, and plan services for reading comprehension and for basic writing skills.
  • If the Respondents cannot otherwise agree, responsibility for compensatory decoding services is split pro rata between HBCESD and HBUHSD. The split compares 2001-2002 elementary school days with high school days from September 3 to November 19, 2002.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345

People named in the decision

  • Christopher Russell, education consultant for Student, Retained by family
  • Kathleen Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., private clinical psychologist; expert witness for Student, Private
  • Jackie Earwood, clinical director, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
  • Barbara Phila, private speech-language pathologist, The Reading and Language Center
  • Dianne Romero, resource specialist program teacher, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Shirley Laurie, school psychologist, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • John Conniff, director of special education, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Kathleen Butcher, speech and language specialist, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Sharon Oakland, history and language arts teacher, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Phil Williams, science teacher, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Julie Gray, algebra teacher, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Linda Rutherford, speech and language pathologist, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Thomas Coupe, English teacher, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Jane Burke, reading skills teacher, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Anne Manning, physical science teacher, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Dennis Creighton, resource specialist program teacher, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Jon Borchert, math teacher, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Jim Keating, director of special education, Huntington Beach Union High School District
  • Jim Hemsley, executive director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education
  • Karen Colby, assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction; witness for Respondents, Ocean View School District
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private provider (nonpublic agency), Newport Beach clinic
  • The Reading and Language Center, private provider (nonpublic agency)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on December 3, 4, 5, 6, and 10, 2002, in San Juan Capistrano, California.(Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania Whiteleather. Also present on behalf of the Petitioner was her mother, MOTHER; her father, FATHER; and her education consultant, Christopher Russell. Respondents Huntington Beach Union High School District (HBUHSD), Huntington Beach City Elementary School District (HBCESD), and West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE) were represented by attorney Caroline Zuk from the law office of Filarsky and Watt, LLP. Also present were Jim Hemsley, executive director of WOCCSE, on behalf of all the Respondents; Jim Keating, director of special education for HBUHSD, on behalf of HBUHSD; and John Conniff, director of special education for HBCESD, on behalf of HBCESD(Footnote 2).

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Christopher Russell; Kathleen Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., clinical psychologist; MOTHER; Jackie Earwood, clinical director at Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes; Dianne Romero, resource specialist program teacher; Shirley Laurie, HBCESD school psychologist; FATHER; John Conniff; Linda Rutherford, HBUHSD speech and language pathologist; Thomas Coupe, HBUHSD English teacher; Jane Burke, HBUHSD reading teacher; Kathleen Butcher, HBCESD speech and language specialist; STUDENT; and Barbara Phila, Reading and Learning Center speech and language pathologist.

The Respondents called the following witnesses: Sharon Oakland, HBCESD history and language arts teacher; Phil Williams, HBCESD science teacher; Julie Gray, HBCESD algebra teacher; Jim Hemsley; Anne Manning, HBUHSD physical science teacher; Dennis Creighton, HBUHSD resource specialist program teacher; Karen Colby, assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction at Ocean View School District; Jon Borchert, HBUHSD math teacher; Dianne Romero; and John Conniff.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Closing briefs were received by the Hearing Officer on January 6, 2003, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 3)

Issue 1: Did HBCESD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to offer services designed to meet her unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder?

Issue 2: For the period from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through November 19, 2002, did HBUHSD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE by:

A. Failing to offer services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder and

B. Failing to properly implement the accommodations, consultative services, and monitoring specified in the May 9, 2002 IEP?

Issue 3: If one or more of the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during all or a portion of the period from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, born [date redacted], was initially found eligible for special education services in March 1998 during her fourth-grade school year at HBCESD. Her eligibility category at that time was speech and language impairment. Her first individualized education program (IEP) states that she had “a severe delay in language both receptively and expressively.” On the November 1, 2000 IEP for STUDENT’s seventh-grade school year, her eligibility category was changed to “specific learning disability” arising from an auditory processing disorder. STUDENT continued to receive services at HBCESD through eighth grade. On September 3, 2002, she commenced receiving services in ninth grade at HBUHSD. Throughout the above-stated time periods, STUDENT’s educational program has predominately consisted of general education classes with resource specialist program (RSP) support and speech and language services.

During the 2000-2001 school year, a dispute arose between STUDENT’s parents, HBCESD, and WOCCSE regarding the appropriateness of STUDENT’s special education program. Kate Stuhr Mack, Ph.D., a clinical psychologist, performed a private psychoeducational assessment at the request of STUDENT’s parents. In her March 26, 2001 report, Dr. Mack concluded that STUDENT had a “neurophysiological processing deficit in auditory conceptualization.” She recommended an intensive remediation program including 80-120 hours of individual direct remedial instruction to focus on phonemic awareness, symbol imagery, and concept imagery. At the request of STUDENT’s parents, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (Lindamood-Bell) promptly reviewed the assessment information from WOCCSE and from Dr. Stuhr Mack. Lindamood-Bell recommended that STUDENT receive its “intensive sensory-cognition stimulation” program in the areas of phonemic awareness and symbol imagery to improve reading and spelling. Lindamood-Bell also recommended its intensive sensory-cognitive stimulation program in the area of concept imagery to improve oral and written language comprehension and critical thinking.

STUDENT’s April 2, 2001 IEP states that her parents wanted HBCESD and WOCCSE to provide her with certain Lindamood-Bell programs, including LiPS, Seeing Stars, and Visualizing/Verbalizing, in accordance with the recommendations from Dr. Stuhr Mack. According to the notes in the IEP, the parents’ request was denied on the basis that a free appropriate public education (FAPE) was already being offered. The parties participated in mediation later that day, and they reached a settlement agreement. The April 2, 2001 settlement agreement did not change the educational program listed on the April 2, 2001 IEP. For purposes of the present due process hearing, paragraph 1 was the central provision of the settlement agreement. Paragraph 1 states: “The district agrees to reimburse the parents in an amount not to exceed $8500 for Non-public agency services in the area of reading. Reimbursement will be provided to parents within 60 days of invoices provided to the district for such services. Pursuant to this agreement the parent agrees not to request any additional non-public agency or non-public school services from the date of this agreement through April 2, 2002.”

STUDENT’s parents enrolled her at The Reading and Language Center (RLC) in July 2001, and they paid for the RLC program with the funds from the above-referenced settlement. The September 2001 progress report from RLC states that STUDENT’s “progress in learning to read was discrepant compared to her cognitive ability.” The report states that because of the discrepancy, RLC was teaching decoding and spelling skills to STUDENT using the Lindamood Phonemic Sequencing (LiPS) program. To further address the discrepancy, RLC was teaching auditory and reading comprehension skills and verbal expression skills using the Lindamood Visualizing/Verbalizing program (V/V). STUDENT received instruction at RLC for fifteen hours per week from July 2 through August 27. STUDENT resumed the program for a brief period commencing on September 12, 2001, at four hours per week All instruction time was evenly divided between LiPS and V/V.

Shortly after September 12, 2001, STUDENT’s parents had used the entire $8500.00 from the April 2001 settlement in obtaining RLC services, and those services were discontinued. The September 2001 RLC report contained a comparison of scores from testing performed by RLC on May 12 and September 19, 2001. On the basis of those scores, RLC concluded that STUDENT had made progress in some of the areas addressed by the RLC services, including word attack and spelling.(Footnote 4) The RLC report recommended continued instruction in LiPS and V/V. The report also recommended supplementing the LiPS program with portions of the Seeing Stars program to “develop symbol imagery to increase visual memory skills for retaining letter patterns of increasing length for decoding and spelling.” Encouraged by the RLC report and their own observations of STUDENT’s progress, the parents requested an IEP meeting for consideration of the RLC data and recommendations. The IEP team met on October 3, 2001. The meeting notes state that the parents were requesting an opportunity to review assessment results and proposed goals and objectives prior to the next IEP meeting, and the parents were also requesting a program to address goals using the Lindamood-Bell program.

The next IEP meeting was the annual review on November 30, 2001. STUDENT had entered the eighth grade. The special education program services offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE primarily consisted of one daily period of RSP, one weekly 40-minute session of speech and language, and some general education program accommodations and modifications. Goals and objectives were presented. The meeting notes state that the parents were requesting more Lindamood-Bell program services as specified on the RLC report, and additional goals were requested by the parents. The notes state that HBCESD and WOCCSE agreed to consider the parents’ requests and respond within ten school days. The parents signed their consent for HBCESD and WOCCSE to implement the program as proposed, and the parents wrote a notation characterizing their consent as an “interim agreement.” Throughout the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT continued with her eighth-grade program as delineated in the November 30, 2001 IEP.

An IEP meeting was held on May 9, 2002, to address STUDENT’s transition from eighth grade to high school. HBUHSD and WOCCSE offered a program to commence on September 3 and continue through the date of the annual review on November 30, 2002. The parents signed their consent. The program included six general education classes, an RSP “monitor,” 30-minute speech and language consults twice per month, and general education program accommodations and modifications. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT start work with the “Regular Education Reading Program” and attend tutorials regularly. The IEP meeting notes contain no mention of Lindamood-Bell program services or a request for such services.

STUDENT’s parents obtained additional private assessments in June 2002. A pretesting summary by Lindamood-Bell lists STUDENT’s June 19, 2002 scores on a variety of formal test instruments. In a letter dated September 9, 2002, Lindamood-Bell stated that its testing of STUDENT indicated weakness in concept imagery. The weakness in concept imagery, according to Lindamood-Bell, was contributing to associated weaknesses in oral and written language comprehension and expression, problem solving, and following directions; and it was causing a propensity to process parts of information instead of the whole. Treatment with the V/V program was recommended to address STUDENT’s weaknesses in concept imagery. The letter states that testing also revealed weakness in phonemic awareness/symbol imagery, meaning the ability to auditorily perceive and visually image the identity, number, and sequence of sounds and letters within words. Described as a weakness in “sensory-cognitive processing,” STUDENT’s problems with phonemic awareness/symbol imagery were stated to be contributing to weaknesses in word attack, word recognition, contextual reading fluency, and spelling. The LiPS and Seeing Stars programs were recommended for the weaknesses in phonemic awareness/symbol imagery. Lindamood-Bell recommended that treatment be continued until STUDENT manifested “self-generating, self-correcting cognitive processing.” Intensive “sensory-cognitive training” was recommended, four hours daily, for a minimum of 240 hours with re-evaluation at the end of the treatment period.(Footnote 5) A private assessment obtained by STUDENT’s parents at RLC resulted in a June 2002 report entitled “speech/language evaluation.” The results from several formal speech and language test instruments are listed in the report, including the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test (PPVT--III), Expressive Vocabulary Test (EVT), Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals–3 (CELF--3), and Test of Auditory-Processing Skills--Revised (TAPS–R). As interpreted by RLC, test results showed that STUDENT’s receptive vocabulary and receptive language scores were close to the mean, but her expressive language and expressive vocabulary scores were almost one standard deviation below the mean. On the EVT, scores were in the low-average range. On the CELF--3, her expressive language score was at the 7th percentile, and her standard score on each of the expressive language subtests (formulating sentences, recalling sentences, and sentence assembly) was at least one standard deviation below the mean. The RLC report states that STUDENT had difficulty with the correct use of modals (will, would, should), verb tenses (perfect tenses), and conjunctions. On the tests of auditory processing, she demonstrated strengths in some areas, but she demonstrated weakness in recalling a series of numbers forward, in repeating sentences, and in syntactic language skills. The report concluded by stating that STUDENT’s difficulty with the structure of language was expected to have an impact on her academic achievement in the areas of speaking, writing, and comprehension. RLC recommended language therapy to improve STUDENT’s “syntactic language skills as they relate to verbal and written expression.”

The Petitioner filed her request for the present due process hearing on September 6, 2002. The essence of the contentions listed in the September 6 filing is that although STUDENT had struggled in her academics throughout the 2001-2002 school year and could do homework only with her parents’ help, the Respondents had done nothing to provide her with the required remediation services and had never responded to the parents’ repeated requests for additional Lindamood-Bell programs. The resolution proposed by the parents was that the Respondents be ordered to provide a compensatory program consisting of intensive therapy at Lindamood-Bell’s clinic in Newport Beach for four hours per day, five days per week, until STUDENT’s processing deficits are remediated and she is able to function academically at an independent level.

The final IEP meeting prior to commencement of the due process hearing was held on November 19, 2002, as part of the IEP team’s annual review. The parents provided HBUHSD and WOCCSE with the recent Lindamood-Bell and RLC reports and requested 240 hours of Lindamood-Bell services in a clinic setting at a time to be determined. STUDENT’s parents consented to an assessment plan for assessment in language/communication function by a speech and language specialist and in academic performance by an RSP teacher. As an interim agreement until the next IEP meeting scheduled for January 2003, the parents consented to continuation of goals and objectives from the May 9, 2002 IEP and a new speech and language goal was added.(Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue 1: Did HBCESD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to offer services designed to meet her unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder?

Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education.” 20 U.S.C. §1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code §56000. The term “free appropriate public education” (FAPE) means “special education” and “related services” available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards and conform with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). State law further defines the term “special education” as meaning specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of individuals with exceptional needs whose educational needs cannot be met with modification of the regular instruction program, and “related services” that may be needed to assist these individuals to benefit from specially designed instruction. Cal. Educ. Code §56031.

Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.

To determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code §56031.(Footnote 7)

Generally stated, the Petitioner’s contentions with respect to the 2001-2002 school year are that she has an auditory processing disorder; that the program offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE was neither designed to meet her unique needs arising from that disorder nor reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit; and that HBCESD and WOCCSE should have implemented the recommendations of RLC contained in the September 2001 RLC report. During discussions at the hearing and prior to the receipt of evidence, the Respondents and the Petitioner did not express agreement regarding the nature of the Petitioner’s unique needs, although the Respondents did acknowledge that the Petitioner has an auditory processing disorder. Thus, before examining the Petitioner’s assertions, the Hearing Officer will first identify the Petitioner’s unique needs for the 2001-2002 school year. Thereafter, within the context of the assertions made by the Petitioner, the Hearing Officer will examine whether the program offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE was designed to meet the Petitioner’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.(Footnote 8)

A. STUDENT’s unique needs.

The triennial assessment conducted in the fall of 2000 was considered by STUDENT’s IEP team when the team formulated STUDENT’s program at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. The triennial assessment included testing of STUDENT by HBCESD school psychologist Shirley Laurie in October 2000. Ms. Laurie’s report states that as measured by the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children–III (WISC–III), STUDENT had a verbal IQ of 92, a performance IQ of 112, and a full-scale IQ of 101. Ms. Laurie stated that STUDENT’s Performance IQ score of 112 was probably the best single estimate of her overall ability. STUDENT’s reading composite score was at the 14th percentile and her math composite score was at the 47th percentile on the Kaufman Test of Educational Achievement–Comprehensive (KTEA–C). Her cluster scores in reading, math, and written language were all in the average range on the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Academic Achievement–Revised (WJ–R). STUDENT’s visual recall was in the superior range, but auditory recall was below average on the Learning Efficiency Test–II (LET–II), measuring the ability to process, sequence, and recall letters. After considering the above scores in addition to scores on other subtests of the above-referenced instruments, Ms. Laurie concluded that STUDENT had a “significant difference between achievement in reading decoding and basic writing skills and ability expectancies, as measured by both the KTEA and WJ–R.” Ms. Laurie believed that the significant discrepancy shown in comparing STUDENT’s reading decoding and basic writing skills to the significantly higher ability expectations indicated by her performance IQ, met the criteria for a specific learning disability due to a disorder in auditory processing, as set forth in Title 5, C.C.R. section 3030(j). Having considered the speech and language evaluation performed by Kathleen Butcher as part of the triennial assessment, Ms. Laurie also concluded that STUDENT was performing significantly below her chronological age in receptive and expressive language. Ms. Laurie’s testimony at the hearing was consistent with the content of her report.

Ms. Butcher testified that she had been STUDENT’s speech and language therapist at HBCESD from the sixth grade through the end of the 2001-2002 eighth-grade school year. Her October 2000 speech and language report shows that on the CELF– 3, STUDENT’s receptive language score was at the 34th percentile and her expressive language score was at the 9th percentile. Subtest scores included the 9th percentile on listening to paragraphs and 5th percentile on recalling sentences. Ms. Butcher testified that on the basis of her October 2000 assessment, STUDENT barely qualified for speech and language services. She stated that recalling sentences was difficult for students with auditory recall problems and that the area of concern for STUDENT in speech and language was actually receptive language as opposed to expressive language skills. Accordingly, she believed that STUDENT’s 5th percentile score in recalling sentences was a function of receptive problems, not expressive problems. She testified that during her work with STUDENT over three years, she saw no expressive language problems. Her therapy approach was to have STUDENT listen to paragraphs, answer questions about the paragraphs, and then rephrase the paragraphs.

Other information available to STUDENT’s IEP team at or near the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year included the above-referenced reports by Dr. Stuhr Mack and RLC. Dr. Stuhr Mack concluded that in the area of cognitive processing, STUDENT had a weakness in “the creation of a linguistic gestalt as well as serial organization. STUDENT’s weakness in creating a gestalt also interferes with the connection to and interpretation of incoming language. It affects her ability to understand what she hears and what she reads and reflects a specific language-based learning disorder in the areas of Language Comprehension and Reading.” Consequently, according to Dr. Stuhr Mack’s report, STUDENT’s performance in reading and written expression was substantially below what would be expected, “given her measured non-verbal intelligence scores.” RLC concluded in its September 2001 report that STUDENT’s progress in learning to read was “discrepant compared to her cognitive ability” and that she needed to be taught decoding and spelling skills, auditory and reading comprehension skills, and verbal expression skills.

In their closing brief, the Respondents expressed skepticism regarding the private assessment by Dr. Stuhr Mack and the Lindamood-Bell methods of testing and/or therapy performed at RLC and at Lindamood-Bell. The Hearing Officer, however, finds significant areas of consistency in the reports of Ms. Laurie, Ms. Butcher, Dr. Stuhr Mack, and RLC. The reports are alike in showing that STUDENT has a specific learning disability arising from an auditory processing disorder and that the disorder interferes with her ability to interpret and/or process incoming language, both written and oral. Consequently, as identified in the reports and in testimony, she had receptive language difficulties manifested by deficits in listening comprehension, auditory recall, and reading decoding. The reports also showed that her auditory processing disorder adversely affected her basic writing skills.

Finally, STUDENT scored at the 7.2 grade level in reading comprehension on the Gray Oral Reading Test–3 (GORT– 3), administered by RLC in September 2001. Notwithstanding her GORT–3 score in reading comprehension, the evidence showed that STUDENT’s mother had complained to HBCESD in a January 11, 2001 letter stating that STUDENT appeared to be at least two grade levels behind in reading and that she “still has problems reading and decoding even the simplest of sentences.” Dr. Stuhr Mack’s March 2001 report stated that STUDENT had difficulties with reading comprehension. When tested by HBUHSD in February 2002, STUDENT scored at the 4.6 grade level in reading comprehension, as measured in the “diagnostic reading profile.” Considering all of the above, STUDENT’s GORT–3 score is demonstrated to be inconsistent with the weight of the evidence. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had unique needs in the area of reading comprehension.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT required services designed to meet her unique needs in the areas of listening comprehension, auditory recall, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and basic writing skills, all arising from an auditory processing disorder(Footnote 9).

B. The program offer.

The November 30, 2001 IEP sets forth the program offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE for the 2001-2002 eighth-grade school year. The IEP provided for STUDENT to attend general education classes for five of the six daily periods. The IEP provided for one daily period of RSP and one weekly 40-minute session of speech and language. General education program accommodations and modifications listed on the IEP included taking tests in the RSP room as needed, modifying assignments as needed, and allowing extra time for taking tests. The IEP contained goals and objectives characterized as covering written language, receptive and expressive language, and reading. The meeting notes state that HBCESD and WOCCSE agreed to consider the parents’ requests for more Lindamood-Bell type services and respond within ten school days.

The Hearing Officer will now determine whether the program offered for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

(1) Listening comprehension and auditory recall.

STUDENT’s HBCESD speech and language pathologist, Ms. Butcher, testified that at the November 30, 2001 annual-review IEP meeting, she recommended continuing work on STUDENT’s listening comprehension. The overall annual goal was to have STUDENT progress from her then-current levels pertaining to listening to a paragraph and rephrasing it in her own words with good accuracy, to being able to do the same exercise and rephrase important events from short stories of 3-4 pages. No other goals involving the speech and language therapist were stated in the IEP. Ms. Butcher testified that the goal in the IEP was appropriate for meeting STUDENT’s unique needs insofar as what a speech and language therapist would address.

The Petitioner asserts that the recommendations in the September 2001 RLC report describe the services required to meet all of STUDENT’s needs arising from her auditory processing disorder, including the areas of listening comprehension and auditory recall. The September 2001 RLC report recommends that STUDENT continue instruction in the Visualizing/Verbalizing (V/V) program to develop “concept imagery,” stated to be essential for comprehension of information received through auditory modalities and visual modalities (i.e. reading). The report states that in the V/V program, the student is “directly instructed how to describe the information received when listening to or reading passages of increasing length and complexity. She is then taught how to visualize and talk about the information in a detailed, organized, and sequential manner. Additionally, she is asked about factual, sequence, cause and effect, prediction and inferential questions about information heard or read.”

The Hearing Officer observes that the V/V program, as it is described in the RLC report, bears great similarity to the approach recommended by Ms. Butcher and incorporated into the November 30, 2001 IEP for addresing STUDENT’s needs in listening comprehension. The most apparent difference, aside from the V/V description being wordier, is intensity. RLC had recommended that the V/V program be received for about three hours per week, and the HBCESD members of the IEP team had recommended that Ms. Butcher’s services be received for 40 minutes per week. If all other factors were considered equal, such as available time for regular education classes, one could reasonably infer that the more intensive V/V program recommended by RLC would have been the better program at that time for STUDENT. However, for purposes of FAPE analysis, the focus of inquiry must be on the adequacy of the district’s program and not whether the program preferred by the parents would be a better program. Gregory K., supra. Thus, the determinative question is whether the services recommended by Ms. Butcher and incorporated into the IEP were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of listening comprehension and auditory recall and were reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

Evidence presented to support the appropriateness of the program offer included records of STUDENT’s academic performance and progress. Karen Colby, assistant superintendent of curriculum and instruction at Ocean View School District, testified regarding her interpretation of STUDENT’s scores on the Stanford Achievement Test, Ninth Edition (SAT– 9). Comparison of her sixth-grade scores obtained in March 2000 with her seventh-grade scores obtained in April 2001 showed that STUDENT maintained scores in the average percentile range for total reading, math, spelling, and language. Her grades at the end of her seventh-grade school year were B in language arts, A- in social science, B in science/health, and B- in high math. STUDENT’s overall grades in her classes through November 2, 2001, ranged from A- to B. Testimony showed that at the November 30, 2001 IEP meeting, the HBCESD members of the IEP team reasoned that because STUDENT was performing grade-level work and had performed well in seventh grade and through the first two months of eighth grade, continuing the use of a similar approach for meeting her needs in the eighth grade was appropriate. Furthermore, specifically with regard to STUDENT’s ability to listen to paragraphs and rephrase the information, her score on the “listening to paragraphs” section of the CELF–3 had risen from the 9th percentile in October 2000 to the 63rd percentile in the fall of 2001. Finally, regarding her performance in the 2001-2002 school year, her SAT-9 scores remained in the average percentile range when tested in April 2002 and her grades as of June 2002 were B in science/health, C- in algebra, B in social science/U.S. history, and B- in language arts.(Footnote 10)

On the basis of the above-cited documentary evidence and testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offer by HBCESD and WOCCSE for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of listening comprehension and auditory recall, and was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

(2) Reading decoding and reading comprehension.

Reading decoding. STUDENT’s IEP team adopted results from the September 14, 2001 testing at RLC as STUDENT’s present levels of performance in the area of reading. The present levels of performance summarized on the November 30, 2001 IEP include 6.7 grade level in word attack on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Tests–R (WRMT–R); 4th grade level in reading on the Wide Range Achievement Test– 3 (WRAT– 3); 4.9 grade level in rate, 5.8 grade level in accuracy, 5.3 level in passage, and 7.2 grade level in comprehension on the GORT– 3. On the basis of those present levels of performance, HBCESD submitted an annual goal for STUDENT increasing her word-recognition skills from the 6.7 to 7.7 grade level. Instructional objectives included STUDENT averaging at least 100 correct words read per minute when presented with a previously read selection from a seventh- to eighth-grade-level reader by June 2002, and STUDENT reading three paragraphs aloud from an eighth-grade core-curriculum textbook with a word-recognition accuracy of 80 percent. The IEP listed STUDENT, her regular classroom teachers, her RSP teacher, and her parents as the persons responsible for STUDENT’s meeting the goals and objectives.

The Hearing Officer initially notes that the above-listed present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to reading did not use the term “decoding.” Instead, the goals and objectives were phrased in terms of “word recognition.” Ms. Romero testified that she considered the IEP goals and objectives for word recognition to be of the same nature and require the same supportive services as if the term “decoding” had been used. For purposes of determining whether the IEP goals and objectives and services were intended to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading decoding, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Romero’s statement was supported by the evidence. The annual goal for “word recognition” in the IEP is directly referenced to the 6.7 grade-level for word attack measured on the WRMT–R. John Conniff, HBCESD director for special education, was present at the IEP meeting. He testified that the term “word recognition,” as used in the goals and objectives, referred to a series of sub-skills in the area of decoding. He distinguished the term “word recognition,” as used in the IEP, from the term “sight-word recognition.” He explained that sight-word recognition referred more directly to a function of memory.(Footnote 11) The Hearing Officer is satisfied that the November 30, 2001 IEP goals and objectives for reading refer to reading decoding, as the term is used in the above findings regarding STUDENT’s unique needs, and that Ms. Romero actually worked with STUDENT on reading decoding.(Footnote 12)

Having found that the program offer was intended to address STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading decoding, the next question to be addressed by the Hearing Officer is whether that program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading decoding and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. The Petitioner asserts that the program offer was deficient because it did not follow the recommendations of the September 2001 RLC report for continuing the LiPS program to develop and utilize phonemic awareness to teach decoding and spelling skills and to develop reading fluency, supplemented by the Seeing Stars program to increase visual memory skills for retaining letter patterns of increasing length for decoding and spelling.

HBCESD and WOCCSE, citing several factors, assert that their offer was appropriate for meeting STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading decoding. The first factor cited is that upon completion of a similar program during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT met her annual goal for increasing her word recognition skills from the 5.4 grade level to the 6.4 grade level, and the grades in all of her regular education classes were consistent with academic progress. HBCESD and WOCCSE assert that because STUDENT progressed under a similar program during the prior school year, continuation of the same type of services in the 2001-2002 year was appropriate. Next, according to HBCESD and WOCCSE, STUDENT’s classroom success and her predominately average SAT-9 scores showed that her instructional time would be more appropriately focused on regular education subjects instead of reducing classroom time in favor of an intensive amount of special education services. Moreover, STUDENT would be receiving instruction in her language arts regular education class during the 2001-2002 school year, and the areas of instruction in that class included instruction in listening, speaking, reading, and writing. Finally, HBCESD and WOCCSE refer to STUDENT’s performance during the 2001-2002 school year as proof that the ongoing program was appropriate. Her overall grades at the conclusion of each grading period were generally in the B range. Her SAT-9 score in total reading improved from the 29th percentile in April 2001 to the 50th percentile in April 2002. Ms. Colby testified that the degree of improvement in reading on the SAT-9 was statistically significant and represented strong growth.

Examination of other evidence, however, reveals that on May 12, 2001, RLC measured STUDENT’s word-attack skills at the 2.9 grade-level equivalent using the WRMT-R. After STUDENT received intensive services including about 54 hours of LiPS instruction at RLC in the summer of 2001, RLC reported that STUDENT’s word-attack skills had increased from a grade equivalent of 2.9 to a grade equivalent of 6.7, as measured by RLC using the WRMT–R. At the end of her next year of services in the HBCESD program, STUDENT’s word-attack skills as measured by Lindamood-Bell on June 19, 2002, using the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test–NU was at the grade equivalent of 6.2.(Footnote 13) The June 19, 2002 score is consistent with STUDENT’s grade-equivalent score of 6.3 in the letter/word identification subtest of the WJ–III, administered by HBCESD on November 25, 2002. STUDENT’s performance on the STAR reading test, administered by HBCESD in April 2002, was consistent with the above-stated scores. Her grade-equivalent score on the STAR reading test was 6.2, considered to be in the below-average category.

The Hearing Officer considers the validity of the above-referenced 2.9 grade-equivalent score in word attack to be questionable.(Footnote 14) The subsequent scores, however, are consistent. The scores show that HBCESD’s ongoing program for the 2001-2002 school year had no measurable effect on STUDENT’s reading decoding skills. Word-attack skills were measured at 6.7 grade level near the start of the school year, but only 6.2 at the end of the school year. The assessment information related to word-attack and word-recognition skills is the most specific indicator of whether the 2001-2002 school year program was appropriate for addressing STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading decoding, and that assessment information is not outweighed by facts concerning STUDENT’s performance in other areas, including her overall classroom performance. Furthermore, STUDENT made no measurable progress toward her annual goal for reaching the 7.7 grade level in word-recognition skills. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the ongoing program for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading decoding and, in that respect, was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

Reading comprehension. Ms. Romero testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT came regularly to the RSP classroom to work on reading, and the specific areas worked upon included decoding, fluency, inferences, context rules, and comprehension. However, the evidence shows that reading comprehension was not addressed by the goals and objectives in the November 30, 2001 IEP.

Section 56345 of the California Education Code provides that the IEP shall include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil’s needs resulting from the pupil’s disability and enabling the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. Ms. Romero’s services in the area of reading comprehension, to whatever extent they may have been provided, were rendered without reference to present levels of performance or goals and objectives in an IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of reading comprehension and, in that respect, was not reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

(3) Basic writing skills.

The November 30, 2001 IEP lists STUDENT’s present levels of performance related to basic writing skills. As derived from administration of the WJ–III by HBCESD in October 2001, STUDENT’s grade-equivalent scores were 6.9 in written expression, 7.1 in writing fluency, and 5.9 in reading samples. The WRAT–3 score showing spelling at the 6th grade level, obtained by RLC in September 2001, was also listed as a present level of performance. HBCESD submitted one page of goals and objectives in the area of written language at the November 30, 2001 IEP meeting. In accordance with discussions at the IEP meeting, another page of goals and objectives for written language was drafted by HBCESD and mailed to STUDENT’s parents approximately ten days after the meeting. The annual goals provided for STUDENT to independently demonstrate correct writing conventions to include punctuation, capitalization, and simple sentence structure at eighth-grade standards with ninety percent accuracy; and for STUDENT to write a “clear coherent and focused core curriculum based research report,” with introductions, bodies of supporting evidence, conclusions, and proper use of grammar, punctuation, capitalization, and spelling. Short-term objectives were stated under each annual goal. The IEP listed STUDENT, her regular teachers, her RSP teacher, and her parents as the persons responsible for implementing the goals.

The Petitioner again asserts that the program offer was deficient because it did not adopt the recommendations in the September 14, 2001 RLC report. RLC had recommended the continuation of direct instruction in the LiPS and Seeing Stars programs to improve spelling and the V/V program to improve written expression skills. HBCESD and WOCCSE refer to several sources of evidence in asserting that the offer was appropriate to address STUDENT’s basic writing skills. First, the Respondents refer to STUDENT’s performance during the 2000-2001 school year wherein she received services similar to the program offered for the 2001-2002 school year. Her sixth-grade scores on the SAT–9 were at the 35th percentile in language and 50th percentile in spelling when tested in March 2000. Her seventh-grade scores were at 47th percentile in language and 46th percentile in spelling in April 2001. Thus, the scores indicate that she progressed sufficiently to allow her to maintain the same percentile rank among her national peers when she moved to a higher grade level. The SAT–9 language subtest is composed of five “content clusters” in capitalization, punctuation, usage, sentence structure, and content and organization. In March 2000, STUDENT scored in the below-average range on two of the content clusters, but in April 2001 she scored in the average range on all five of the content clusters. The same pattern was demonstrated in the four content clusters for spelling. Other evidence of STUDENT’s progress during the seventh-grade school year included her grade of B in language arts. As described by Ms. Romero, STUDENT had “almost” met her annual writing goal on the seventh-grade IEP for “completing all written assignments in general education classroom with assistance in RSP and receive a passing grade.” On the basis of STUDENT’s performance and progress during seventh grade, HBCESD and WOCCSE assert that the intensive program of Lindamood-Bell type services requested by STUDENT’s parents was not warranted at any time during the eighth-grade 2001-2002 school year. Instead they assert that offering a program similar to what had been provided during seventh-grade, with updated goals and objectives, was appropriate.

As further evidence of the appropriateness of the eighth-grade program offer in addressing basic writing skills, HBCESD and WOCCSE refer to STUDENT’s performance during eighth grade. STUDENT’s language arts and social science/U.S. history teacher, Sharon Oakland, testified that she has twenty years of experience in teaching, including experience in special education and as a speech and language therapist. She testified STUDENT benefitted from accommodations in the general education classroom, including seating at the front of the class, reinforcement of oral directions with written directions, asking STUDENT if she understood the information, and encouraging STUDENT to seek clarification when necessary. She testified that she graded STUDENT in the same manner as the other students, although some accommodations were made for testing. She testified that she initially shortened some of STUDENT’s tests but eventually stopped that particular accommodation at STUDENT’s request. STUDENT took most tests and quizzes in the regular classroom. The final exam in language arts and the large “chapter tests” in U.S. history were taken in the RSP room. By the end of the school year, STUDENT had earned a B- in language arts and a B in social science/U.S. history.

Regarding the matter of progress during the ongoing program, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s April 2002 SAT–9 score in total language dropped to the 35th percentile compared to the 47th percentile in April 2001. On those same tests, spelling increased from the 46th to the 72nd percentile. The Respondents’ witnesses stressed that all the scores were in the average range and must be considered in conjunction with STUDENT’s actual performance and progress in the classroom. STUDENT’s eighth-grade RSP teacher, Ms. Romero, generally testified that STUDENT had demonstrated good progress in all areas throughout the school year. Ms. Romero’s testimony regarding her observation of STUDENT’s ongoing progress in written language during the 2001-2002 school year was corroborated by STUDENT’s November 2002 scores on the written language portion of the WJ–III. She scored at the grade-equivalent levels of 8.3 in broad written language, 10.1 in writing fluency, 6.6 in spelling, and 8.9 in writing samples. Those levels were significantly higher than her levels of performance from one year earlier.

Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offer for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of basic writing skills and was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit.

C. Summary and conclusions.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of listening comprehension, auditory recall, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and basic writing skills, all arising from an auditory processing disorder. The program offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit in all areas of need except reading decoding and reading comprehension. To that limited extent, STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

Finally, the finding of a denial of FAPE is not affected by the assertion of HBCESD and WOCCSE that funds from the April 2, 2001 settlement agreement may have obviated the need for a more extensive public school program by enabling the Petitioner to purchase nonpublic agency services. The settlement agreement pertaining to matters arising during the prior school year did not operate to absolve HBCESD or WOCCSE of their FAPE responsibilities for the 2001-2002 school year. Also unavailing is the assertion that the settlement agreement barred the Petitioner from asking HBCESD and WOCCSE to provide nonpublic agency services during the 2001-2002 school year. Even if such an agreement would be enforceable, the plain language of the settlement agreement did not purport to preclude the Petitioner from asking HBCESD and WOCCSE to use their own personnel or the personnel of some other public agency to provide services akin to Lindamood-Bell.

Issue 2: For the period from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through November 19, 2002, did HBUHSD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE by:

A. Failing to offer services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder and

B. Failing to properly implement the accommodations, consultative services, and monitoring specified in the May 9, 2002 IEP?

************

A. Failing to offer services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder. (1) STUDENT’s unique needs.

The evidence discussed above showed that STUDENT achieved progress in certain areas during the 2001-2002 school year, but her areas of unique needs remained the same when HBCESD and HBCHSD convened the May 9, 2002 IEP meeting to plan STUDENT’s September 2002 transition into high school. Specifically, she had unique needs in the areas of listening comprehension, auditory recall, reading decoding, reading comprehension, and basic writing skills, all arising from an auditory processing disorder.

(2) The program offer.

The program offer by HBUHSD and WOCCSE for the portion of the 2002-2003 school year at issue in the present case is set forth in the May 9, 2002 transition IEP. The program recommendations on the IEP were listed as applicable from September 3 through November 30, 2002.(Footnote 15) The IEP provided for six periods of general education classes, 30-minute speech and language consults twice per month, and an RSP “monitor.” Accommodations and modifications included STUDENT taking tests and working on assignments in the RSP room, receiving tutoring help with assignments, receiving extended time on tests, and having tests read to her, all as necessary. The team recommended that STUDENT participate in the “Regular Education Reading Program.” The IEP specified that if other modifications were needed in the core curriculum, an IEP meeting would be held within 30 days of notification. Speech and language goals and objectives were to be developed “within two weeks of start of school.”

The Hearing Officer will now examine, within the context of each of STUDENT’s areas of unique needs, whether the program offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

Listening comprehension and auditory recall. The annual goal from the November 30, 2001 IEP involving listening to and rephrasing paragraphs and short stories was attached to the May 9, 2002 IEP. However, that particular goal required direct services from a speech and language therapist. STUDENT’s transition IEP did not provide for direct services from a speech and language therapist in high school. Instead, the transition IEP provided for consultation services. Accordingly, the IEP specified that new speech and language goals and objectives would be developed. Linda Rutherford, a speech and language pathologist at HBUHSD, testified that she prepared the new speech and language goals and objectives. Mr. Hemsley mailed the proposed speech and language goals and objectives to STUDENT’s parents with a cover letter dated October 15, 2002.

The Petitioner again asserts that the program offer was not appropriate because she required the intensive Lindamood-Bell type services to address her needs in all areas. The Respondents assert that the program offer was appropriate.

Ms. Rutherford and Ms. Butcher both attended the May 9, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Rutherford testified that the IEP team discussed STUDENT’s progress on the current speech and language goal involving listening to and rephrasing paragraphs and short stories. As recounted by Ms. Rutherford, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be attending a reading skills class for five hours per week at HBUHSD, addressing both receptive and expressive language. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT’s goals and objectives related to speech and language, meaning listening to paragraphs, ect., could easily be addressed and met in the reading skills class. The IEP team also agreed that addressing STUDENT’s speech and language goals in the reading skills class would be preferable to pulling STUDENT out of a regular education class for direct speech and language services. Ms. Rutherford noted that the reading skills class was relatively small, and STUDENT would receive direct attention from the reading skills teacher. Additionally, the IEP provided that the reading skills teacher would be in consult with the speech and language therapist. Ms. Rutherford testified that the provision on the May 9, 2002 IEP for speech and language consults in the “classroom” meant consults by the speech and language therapist with the reading skills teacher in the reading skills classroom, and not necessarily consults with STUDENT’s other teachers. Ms. Rutherford’s testimony was consistent with testimony by Ms. Butcher. Ms. Butcher testified that she recommended only consultative services at the May 9, 2002 IEP meeting because STUDENT’s scores in listening comprehension had improved dramatically and she was able to appropriately rephrase short stories.

Ms. Rutherford testified that the page of goals and objectives prepared by her at the beginning of the school year and forwarded to the parents on October 15, 2002, references STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder and states that “STUDENT is receiving language/reading skills from the districts LANGUAGE! program on a daily basis. Her current teacher reports that STUDENT is doing good work in the writing, vocabulary, and story comprehension assignments. Based on IEP information from 5/02, continued work is needed on STUDENT’s auditory processing skills, (auditory processing, auditory association, and auditory comprehension) and includes emphasis on inferences, conceptual matching, and drawing conclusions.” The annual goal was for STUDENT to make inferences and draw conclusions from a group of inclusive and exclusive descriptors under conditions involving “20 descriptions with five choices presented verbally and in written form.”

Jane Burke is STUDENT’s reading skills class teacher at HBUHSD. Her testimony showed that she works with STUDENT on the goals and objectives prepared by Ms. Rutherford related to listening comprehension and auditory recall, and much of her teaching in that area is one-on-one. Ms. Burke stated that she was in weekly communication with Ms. Rutherford to discuss the program being provided to STUDENT, and Ms. Rutherford monitored STUDENT’s progress by reviewing STUDENT’s work and consulting with Ms. Burke. Ms. Burke testified that STUDENT was making good progress in the reading skills class. Although STUDENT had not been retested in the specific area of listening to paragraphs on the CELF–3, Ms. Burke testified that she had no concerns about STUDENT’s progress. She stated that STUDENT’s grade in the reading skills class was A-, and that in several areas she had progressed from performing fifth-grade work in September to seventh-grade work more recently.

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the program offer for the portion of the 2002-2003 school year up to November 19, 2002, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs in the area of listening comprehension and auditory recall and was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

Reading decoding and reading comprehension. The evidence showed that HBUHSD tested STUDENT’s reading skills in February and April 2002. The testing indicated that STUDENT was at least two years below grade level in reading. HBUHSD and the IEP team recommended the reading skills class taught by Ms. Burke. STUDENT started receiving reading instruction from Ms. Burke in September 2002. Although STUDENT’s May 9, 2002 IEP recites STUDENT’s preset levels of performance in reading as they were listed on the prior IEP, the May 9, 2002 IEP contains no goals and objectives for reading. Therefore, while the instruction rendered to STUDENT in the reading skills class may in fact have addressed STUDENT’s deficits in reading decoding and reading comprehension, the instruction in those areas was provided without reference to measurable annual goals or short-term objectives. The absence of IEP goals and objectives for reading was a violation of Cal. Educ. Code section 56345 and, to that extent, resulted in the denial of a FAPE. Evidence to be discussed subsequently in this Decision shows that STUDENT demonstrated substantial progress in her reading skills when formally tested in November 2002, and her progress will be considered under the topic of remedies in Issue 3.

Basic writing skills. The May 9, 2002 IEP lists STUDENT’s present levels of performance in written language as previously stated in the November 30, 2001 IEP. It also contains the page of goals and objectives from the November 30, 2001 IEP involving writing conventions and sentence structure. Another goal involving the writing of grammatically correct declarative, interrogative, and declaratory sentences and identifying nouns, verbs, and predicates in sentences was also attached. The source of this latter goal was not indicated at the hearing, but the dates for the short-term objectives show that the goal was probably written prior to April 2002. All of the above-stated goals and objectives list an RSP teacher as being among the group of persons responsible for implementation. However, in contrast to the November 30, 2001 IEP, the May 9, 2002 IEP did not designate a daily period for RSP services. The May 9, 2002 IEP specified only that an RSP teacher would monitor STUDENT and she would have access to the RSP classroom for taking tests and working on assignments.

Aside from whatever basic writing skills STUDENT was developing in her regular education classes at HBUHSD, including her English class, HBUHSD and WOCCSE did not show that an RSP teacher or any other teacher was attempting to implement the May 9, 2002 IEP goals and objectives related to basic writing skills. Dennis Creighton, the RSP teacher assigned to STUDENT at HBUHSD, testified that he monitored STUDENT’s progress by speaking with her teachers and reviewing her work, but there was no indication he worked directly with STUDENT on her basic writing skills or any other skills. STUDENT’s HBUHSD English teacher, Thomas Coupe, testified that STUDENT had transferred out of his class at the end of November. He testified that his class was challenging for all of his students. He testified that STUDENT’s grade was between an D and D+ in his class, and her grade was bolstered by credits received for completion of homework and classroom assignments. He testified that STUDENT struggled with writing, and the grades on her writing assignments were generally D’s. He believed that STUDENT would likely have received at least a C in his class if she had sought assistance from him, but she did not. He testified that he was aware of the accommodations listed on STUDENT’s IEP, but he did not know the nature of her disability and knew nothing about her goals and objectives.

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that in the area of basic writing skills, the Respondents failed to offer a program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit, and to that extent STUDENT was denied a FAPE for the portion of the 2002-2003 school year up to November 19, 2002.

B. Failing to properly implement the accommodations, consultative services, and monitoring specified in a May 9, 2002 IEP.

The Petitioner asserts that HBUHSD and WOCCSE failed to implement accommodations, consultative services, and RSP monitoring specified in the May 9, 2002 IEP, and that consultative speech and language services were required to be provided to all of STUDENT’s teachers and not just the reading skills teacher. Testimony of STUDENT’s HBUHSD teachers and Ms. Rutherford established that the accommodations and modifications specified in the IEP, including taking tests and working on assignments in the RSP room, tutoring help with assignments, extended time on tests, and having tests read to STUDENT, as necessary, were all made available to STUDENT upon her request. Regarding consultative services, the May 9, 2002 IEP required HBUHSD to provide 30-minutes of speech and language consults twice per month. As discussed above, Ms. Rutherford credibly explained that the provision for speech and language consults referred only to the speech and language therapist providing consults to the reading skills classroom teacher. The testimony of Ms. Rutherford and Ms. Burke showed that the requisite amount of speech and language consultation was provided. Finally, with respect to RSP monitoring, the testimony of Mr. Creighton and STUDENT’s HBUHSD teachers showed that Mr. Creighton, as the RSP specialist assigned to STUDENT, had been communicating with STUDENT’s teachers for the purpose of monitoring her progress. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the HBUHSD and WOCCSE complied with the requirements specified in the May 9, 2002 IEP for accommodations, consultation, and monitoring.(Footnote 17)

Issue 3: If one or more of the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during all or a portion of the period from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

A. Contentions of the parties.

The sole remedy sought by the Petitioner for the Respondents’ failure to provide a FAPE is characterized by the Petitioner as compensatory education. Specifically, the Petitioner seeks the 240 hours of intensive Lindamood-Bell services at the Newport Beach clinic as recommended in the September 9, 2002 report from Lindamood-Bell, with follow-up services to be determined after completion of the 240 hours. The Petitioner also requests transportation to and from the Lindamood-Bell services. Also characterized by the Petitioner as compensatory education is her parents’ request for reimbursement of the cost of evaluations performed by Lindamood-Bell and RLC in June 2002.

B. Applicable law.

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of private placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district fails to provide a FAPE, and the placement or services are determined to be appropriate under the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting such relief. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 358. Among the factors to consider is the conduct of the parties. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist. (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1486. Court decisions subsequent to Burlington have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. See Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation for missed services. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496.

C. Discussion.

The Hearing Officer has determined that denial of a FAPE arose in the areas of reading decoding and reading comprehension for the 2001-2002 school year and through November 19, 2002, and in the area of basic writing skills for the portion of the 2002-2003 school year up to November 19, 2002. A remedy for the denial of a FAPE in each area will now be considered.

Reading decoding. STUDENT’s IEP for the 2001-2002 eighth-grade school year included RSP services for reading decoding, but a FAPE was denied when STUDENT failed to make progress in her reading decoding skills and the IEP team took no action to reconsider or modify the program during the course of the school year. Throughout the eighth-grade school year, STUDENT’s decoding skills remained at the sixth-grade level. STUDENT has participated in a reading skills class during her ninth-grade school year through November 19, 2002, but her May 9, 2002 IEP contains no goals and objectives for reading. When tested by WOCCSE on November 25, 2002, STUDENT’s grade-level reading scores on the WJ–III were 8.7 in broad reading, 6.3 in letter/word identification, 10.4 in reading fluency, and 6.7 in passage comprehension. Those scores generally indicate considerable improvement in STUDENT’s reading compared to the levels of performance listed in her November 2001 IEP. However, to the extent that the letter/word identification score is an indicator of her decoding skills, she is still at the sixth-grade level.

The remedy proposed by the Petitioner would be for the Hearing Officer to order an intensive program at Lindamood-Bell’s clinic in Newport Beach, consisting of at least 240 hours of therapy. The evidence does not support that request. First, the 240 hours recommended by Lindamood-Bell was intended to address an array of skills, not just reading decoding. Next, the September 2001 RLC report states that after 54 hours of LiPS instruction at RLC in the summer of 2001, STUDENT’s word-attack skills increased from a grade equivalent of 2.9 to a grade-equivalent of 6.7, as measured by RLC using the WRMT–R. However, as discussed above, the 2.9 score is suspect. STUDENT’s word-identification skills were recorded at the 5.4 grade level and her reading decoding at the 4.6 grade level one year earlier on her November 1, 2000 IEP. Furthermore, the 2.9 score is dramatically lower than all other grade-equivalent scores recorded for STUDENT in reading during the applicable time periods. Although the RLC report indicated some gains in other categories of reading during the summer of 2001, the RLC data do not warrant a remedy whereby STUDENT’s high-school class time and study time would be unduly infringed upon by her participation in an intensive Lindamood-Bell program, especially when her classroom performance is in the average range, she is benefitting from being in class, and her academic progress is highly dependent upon having sufficient time to do her homework. If implemented during the school year, a program as extensive and time-consuming as the compensatory education sought by the Petitioner could likely cause more harm than benefit to her academic progress.

As stated in Puyallup, supra, “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” STUDENT requires a program that appropriately addresses her needs in the area of reading decoding. For the past year, she has not received such a program. The Hearing Officer will order STUDENT’s IEP team to meet for the purpose of formulating a program to address STUDENT’s needs in reading decoding. The IEP team may arrange for further assessment in that area. The IEP team shall consider that the services rendered to STUDENT after November 2001 have not resulted in measurable progress in STUDENT’s reading decoding skills; that the degree of STUDENT’s progress in the area of reading decoding while receiving services at RLC was significantly overstated by the September 2001 RLC report; and that STUDENT should not be required to lose a substantial amount her available classroom time for regular education instruction in content areas, or homework time, when receiving services to address her decoding deficits. Some form of specialist support within her reading skills class period may be an appropriate balance of time usage.

The IEP team shall also determine what additional amount of services in the area of reading decoding is required to compensate STUDENT for having been denied a FAPE and making no progress in that area from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that placing STUDENT in an intensive Lindamood-Bell type program at the Newport Beach clinic or any other off-campus location during the regular school year session would be counterproductive. Such a program might improve her performance in certain areas of reading, but the reduction of available classroom time for regular education instruction in content areas and the reduction of time available for homework would outweigh the other potential gains. If Lindamood-Bell type services are designated by the IEP team as compensatory education for the denial of FAPE in the area of reading decoding, those services shall be rendered during the summer months. Finally, as stated above, 240 hours of Lindamood-Bell type services as a compensatory education for the denial of a FAPE in the area of reading decoding would be excessive, even if rendered in the summer. The 240 hours of services recommended by Lindamood-Bell was in reference to multiple areas, not just reading decoding. In contrast to Lindamood-Bell, RLC had a working familiarity with STUDENT. In the summer of 2001, RLC provided about 120 hours Lindamood-Bell type services address STUDENT’s needs in multiple areas. RLC apportioned 54 hours of the total program to LiPS for the purpose of addressing STUDENT’s reading decoding skills. RLC’s September 2001 report shows that it considered the 54 hours to be an appropriate apportionment of services.(FOOTNOTE 18) The Hearing Officer finds that in the event STUDENT’s IEP team chooses to designate Lindamood-Bell type services for compensatory education in the area of reading decoding, 54 hours of Lindamood-Bell type services would be an appropriate amount.

Reading comprehension. STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year when her IEP contained neither goals and objectives nor designated services to address her needs in reading comprehension. The same situation has arisen for the 2002-2003 school year up to November 19, 2002. The effects of this denial of FAPE can be reasonably quantified by assessment data presented at the hearing. The reading assessment that bore results most consistent with STUDENT’s educational performance during the 2001-2002 school year was the assessment performed by Ms. Burke on behalf of HBUHSD in February and April 2002. On that testing, STUDENT received a grade-equivalent score of 4.6 in reading comprehension. On November 25, 2002, STUDENT scored at the 6.7 grade-equivalent level in passage comprehension, as measured on the WJ–III administered by WOCCSE. The latter score indicates a two-year improvement in reading comprehension over a period of approximately 9 months. The validity of that measured level of improvement is strongly indicated by the evidence. First, Ms. Romero testified that she did address STUDENT’s reading comprehension in the RSP class during the 2001-2002 school year, even though reading comprehension was not listed on the IEP. Additionally, STUDENT began attending the HBUHSD reading skills class on or about September 3, 2002, taught by Ms. Burke. Ms. Burke testified regarding the nature of the reading skills class and STUDENT’s participation in the class. She testified that she is working with STUDENT on word-attack skills (described as breaking words into phonemic units), decoding, comprehension, vocabulary, speed and fluency, and exposure to leisure reading. She testified that STUDENT is progressing well in the class and that in several areas she has progressed almost two grade levels.

In summary, the evidence shows that although STUDENT was denied a FAPE because of the above-described deficiencies in her IEPs, STUDENT has benefitted from the RSP class and the reading skills class to the extent that she improved almost two grade levels during the period at issue in this case. Therefore, a compensatory education for reading comprehension is not warranted. However, reading comprehension remains an area of need for STUDENT. To correct the deficiency in STUDENT’s IEP, HBUHSD and WOCCSE shall be ordered to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of determining STUDENT’s present levels of performance in reading comprehension, developing goals and objectives in reading comprehension, and determining an appropriate plan for meeting the goals and objectives.

Basic writing skills. STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year when her IEP contained goals and objectives but no applicable designated services to address her needs in basic writing skills. The evidence shows that in October 2001, STUDENT’s grade-equivalent levels of performance related to basic writing skills, as derived from administration of the WJ–III, were 6.9 in written expression, 7.1 in writing fluency, and 5.9 in reading samples. She also had a September 2001 WRAT–3 score showing spelling at the 6th grade level. STUDENT’s November 25, 2002 grade-equivalent scores on the written language portion of the WJ–III were 8.3 in broad written language, 10.1 in writing fluency, 6.6 in spelling, and 8.9 in writing samples. The latter scores show that except in spelling, STUDENT’s basic writing skills have improved substantially during the past year. Having considered (a) the degree of STUDENT’s improvement in basic writing skills from September 2001 through present, (b) the level of STUDENT’s basic writing skills as measured on November 25, 2002, and (c) the approximately two-month absence of a provision in STUDENT’s high school IEP for addressing STUDENT’s needs in the area of basic writing skills as calculated from the beginning of the school year to November 19, 2002, the Hearing Officer finds that compensatory education is not warranted in the area of basic writing skills. Instead, HBUHSD and WOCCSE shall be ordered to convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of determining STUDENT’s present levels of performance in basic writing skills, developing goals and objectives in writing skills, and determining an appropriate plan for meeting the goals and objectives.

Other matters. The Hearing Officer has ordered compensatory education arising from the failure of HBCESD, HBUHSD, and WOCCSE to provide an appropriate program to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading decoding. STUDENT now attends HBUHSD. Therefore, having HBCESD participate in the development and funding of compensatory education may pose logistical challenges. Other than applying principles of pro rata calculations to the respective amounts of time that the Petitioner was denied a FAPE by each Respondent, the Hearing Officer does not have sufficient information about the contractual relationships between the three Respondents to make a more specific order regarding apportionment of the responsibility for compensatory education.

Finally, the Petitioner’s request for reimbursement of the cost of the June 2002 Lindamood-Bell and RLC assessments is denied. In the present case, the reimbursement request is not appropriate as compensatory education, nor is it appropriate on other grounds.

ORDERS(FOOTNOTE 19)

1. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the Respondents shall convene an IEP meeting and formulate a program to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of reading decoding as defined in this Decision. The program shall be consistent with the following findings by the Hearing Officer:

(A) The IEP team may arrange for further assessment in the area of reading decoding.

(B) Services rendered to STUDENT after November 2001 have not resulted in measurable progress in STUDENT’s reading decoding skills.

(C) The effectiveness of Lindamood-Bell type services in addressing STUDENT’s needs in reading decoding was significantly overstated in the September 2001 RLC report.

(D) STUDENT should not be required to lose a substantial amount of her available classroom time for regular education instruction in content areas, or homework time, when receiving services to address her decoding deficits. Some form of specialist support within her reading skills class period may be an appropriate balance of time usage.

2. At the same IEP meeting ordered above, the IEP team shall also determine what additional amount of services in the area of reading decoding is required to compensate STUDENT for having been denied a FAPE and making no progress in that area from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002. The compensatory education program shall be consistent with the following findings by the Hearing Officer:

(A) Placing STUDENT in an intensive Lindamood-Bell type program at the Newport Beach clinic or any other off-campus location during the regular school year would be counterproductive. Such a program might improve her performance in certain areas of reading, but the reduction of available classroom time for regular education instruction in content areas and the reduction of time available for homework would outweigh the other potential gains.

(B) If Lindamood-Bell type services are designated by the IEP team as compensatory education for the denial of FAPE in the area of reading decoding, those services shall be rendered during the summer months.

(C) Two hundred and forty hours of Lindamood-Bell type services as compensatory education to address the area of reading decoding would be excessive. The 240 hours of services recommended by Lindamood-Bell was in reference to multiple areas, not just reading decoding. Fifty-four hours of Lindamood-Bell type services for compensatory education would be an appropriate amount.

3. At the same IEP meeting as ordered above, the IEP team shall:

(A) Determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance in reading comprehension, develop goals and objectives in reading comprehension, and determine an appropriate plan for meeting the goals and objectives.

(B) Determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance in basic writing skills, develop goals and objectives in writing skills, and determine an appropriate plan for meeting the goals and objectives.

4. If HBCESD, HBUHSD, and WOCCSE are unable to otherwise agree on how to apportion their responsibility for the provision of compensatory education in the area of reading decoding as ordered above, the parties shall apply a pro rata calculation as between HBCESD and HBUHSD in determining apportionment, comparing the number of elementary-school days in the 2001-2002 school year to the number of high-school days from September 3 to November 19, 2002.

5. The Petitioner’s request for reimbursement of the cost of the June 2002 Lindamood-Bell and RLC assessments is denied.

6. All of the Petitioner’s remaining requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.

Issue 1: Did HBCESD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year by failing to offer services designed to meet her unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder? The Petitioner prevailed partially on this issue to the extent the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE in the areas of reading decoding and reading comprehension. The program offered by HBCESD and WOCCSE was found to be appropriate in the area of listening comprehension, auditory recall, and basic writing skills.

Issue 2: For the period from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through November 19, 2002, did HBUHSD and WOCCSE deny STUDENT a FAPE by:

A. Failing to offer services designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs arising from an auditory processing disorder. The Petitioner prevailed partially on this issue to the extent that the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE in the areas of reading decoding, reading comprehension, and basic writing skills. The program offered by HBUHSD and WOCCSE was found to be appropriate in the areas of listening comprehension and auditory recall.

B. Failing to properly implement the accommodations, consultative services, and monitoring specified in a May 9, 2002 IEP. The Respondents prevailed on this issue.

Issue 3: If one or more of the Respondents denied STUDENT a FAPE during all or a portion of the period from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education? The Petitioner prevailed partially on this issue to the extent that compensatory education was ordered to address the Petitioner’s needs in the area of reading decoding.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).

Dated: January 24, 2003 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. On December 10, 2002, the hearing was concluded by telephone conference call. 2. HBUHSD, HBCESD, and WOCCSE are collectively referred to as the “Respondents” in this Decision. 3. For purposes of clarification and analysis, the issues listed here differ slightly in wording from the issues as stated by the Petitioner. 4. The RLC report states that “word attack” tests “the student’s ability to apply phonemic and structural analysis skills in order to pronounce words with which she is unfamiliar,” also referred to in the report as “decoding skills.” 5. The September 9, 2002 letter from Lindamood-Bell makes no reference to STUDENT’s actual test scores or educational performance and appears, on its face, to be almost entirely a form letter.

6. At the commencement of the due process hearing on December 3, 2002, the Petitioner stated that she was raising no issues for the period between the date of the settlement agreement and the start of the 2001-2002 school year. HBUHSD and WOCCSE asserted that issues pertaining to the 2002-2003 school year were not yet ripe for hearing. They asserted that they had first seen the June 2002 reports from Lindamood-Bell and RLC at the November 19, 2002 IEP meeting, that more time was needed to review the reports and perform the agreed-upon reassessment, and that the parties had agreed to defer the formulation of a new program until the next IEP meeting in January 2003. The Petitioner asserted, correctly, that an agreement regarding temporary placement pending the outcome of a due process hearing should not be construed as a resolution of the issues. In ruling on the matter of ripeness, the Hearing Officer gave strong consideration to the fact that the Petitioner was not seeking a finding on the appropriateness of the program offered at the November 19, 2002 IEP meeting. Instead, the core of the Petitioner’s claim was that a FAPE had been denied from the start of the 2001-2002 school year through the date of the hearing, and the remedy being sought by the Petitioner was in the nature of compensatory education. Having considered all of the above, the Hearing Officer determined that the time period at issue in this case would be the period from the start of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002.

7. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. 960 F.2d at 1484. Finally, although not at issue in the present case, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. §1414(d), 34 C.F.R. §300.347(a). 8. The Petitioner has alleged, as procedural violations, the Respondents’ repeated and continuing failure to consider the RLC recommendations and the parents’ requests to adopt and implement those recommendations. As emphasized by the Petitioner throughout the course of the due process hearing, the RLC recommendations reflect the core of the Petitioner’s position regarding her unique needs and the services required to appropriately address those needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will consider the RLC recommendations in determining whether the Respondents’ programs were substantively appropriate. Further examination of those allegations as procedural violations would not affect the outcome of this Decision. Consequently, the Hearing Officer will not examine those allegations as procedural violations.

9. Although the Petitioner repeatedly made reference at the hearing to the fact that her unique needs would have been met by the program recommendations described in the September 2001 RLC report, the Petitioner did not state with consistency in her issue statements, discussions prior to the presentation of evidence, or closing written briefs, the precise areas of need and or deficits that the Respondents allegedly failed to address in their program offers. Part of that failure was undoubtedly due to the fact that in describing STUDENT’s auditory processing disorder and her associated deficits, the documentary evidence contained, and the witnesses sometimes used, different terms for the same needs and the same terms for different needs. Prior to the presentation of evidence, the Petitioner did identify, generally, areas of need in auditory processing, language processing, speech and language, reading, and writing. STUDENT’s unique needs as identified by the Hearing Officer in this Decision reflect his categorization, within the context of the Petitioner’s overall contentions, of the areas of need that were demonstrated by the evidence. All of those areas of need were addressed both by the Petitioner and the Respondents in their presentations of evidence. 10. Considerable controversy arose at the hearing regarding the significance of STUDENT’s grades, both in elementary school and high school. The Petitioner attempted to show that although her overall grades were good, those grades were good only because they represented a composite grade in each class, derived from test scores, classroom projects, homework, and other activities. The Petitioner asserted that her test scores in every class ranged almost invariably from D to F. However, testimony from STUDENT’s teachers showed that her test scores ranged from F to A. The Hearing Officer was persuaded that although STUDENT’s classroom test scores often were demonstrated to be only a minor consideration in her grades, her overall class grades did reliably indicate academic progress in most instances. 11. When asked to comment on goals and objectives for “decoding” written by Mr. Russell and submitted for consideration at the IEP meeting, Ms. Romero testified that she preferred the decoding/word recognition goals presented by HBCESD because they were written to conform with STUDENT’s levels of performance. Ms. Romero testified that the annual goal for decoding proposed by Mr. Russell was for reaching the ninth-grade level and STUDENT had not yet reached the eighth-grade level. 12. The terms “reading decoding,” “word attack,” and “word recognition” were used frequently in the documentary evidence and testimony. The witnesses offered a variety of definitions for those terms. The testimony of HBHUSD speech and language pathologist Linda Rutherford and other witnesses showed that those terms have overlapping meaning. Collectively, those terms generally refer to a student’s ability to recognize a word through a combination of memory skills, processing of its phonemic components, and understanding the context in which it is used. For purposes of clarity and analysis in this Decision, the Hearing Officer will use the terms “decoding” or “reading decoding” in reference to all of the above-stated skills and terms. “Decoding,” as used in this Decision, is to be distinguished from “sight-word recognition.” An example of sight-word recognition, as described by Ms. Rutherford, would be the ability to know from memory what a word is by seeing it on a flashcard, but without reference to context. 13. The RLC report describes “word attack” as “the student’s ability to apply phonic and structural analysis skills in order to pronounce words with which the student is unfamiliar,” and the report expressly characterizes word attack as a decoding skill. 14. The 2.9 score is in conflict with STUDENT’s word identification skills having been recorded at the 5.4 grade level and her reading decoding score at the 4.6 grade level on her November 1, 2000 IEP, and the score is dramatically lower than the other grade-equivalent scores recorded for STUDENT in reading during applicable time periods. 15. The annual-review IEP meeting was not due to be held until November 30, 2002. 16. The history of this additional goal was not made clear at the hearing, although its precise origins have no bearing on the results in this Decision. 17. In an October 15, 2002 letter to STUDENT’s parents, Mr. Hemsley itemized what he characterized as “clarifications” to the May 9, 2002 IEP. The clarifications included a description of consult and monitoring services that varied somewhat from the corresponding provisions in the IEP. The consideration of those variations would have no effect on the outcome of this Decision. Consequently, they will not be further addressed by the Hearing Officer. 18. The Hearing Officer notes that in her March 2001 report wherein she reviewed formal testing and STUDENT’s academic performance, Dr. Stuhr Mack recommended 80-120 hours of individual instruction in “sensory-cognitive processing” to address multiple areas, including reading decoding. Thus, Dr. Stuhr Mack’s recommendation was similar to the total amount of program hours that RLC delivered to STUDENT in the summer of 2001. 19. The orders in this Decision are made for the purpose of remedying the fact that STUDENT was denied a FAPE in certain areas during portions of the period, and in some respects all of the period, from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year through November 19, 2002. The Hearing Officer has made no findings regarding the appropriateness of the program offered to STUDENT at the November 19, 2002 IEP meeting or thereafter. 20. STUDENT’s annual-review IEP meeting was not due to be held until November 2002.