California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 6, 2001
Student v. Sequoia Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2047-01 · Hearing Officer Joseph T. Macaluso
Sequoia Union High School District may exclude a student who lives in Fremont; a feeder district's work-based residency does not carry over.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
A 17-year-old eleventh grader eligible for special education with a specific learning disability filed for due process after Sequoia Union High School District refused to readmit him to Menlo-Atherton High School for 2001-2002. He lived with his legal guardians in Fremont. He had attended Menlo Park City School District, a kindergarten-through-eighth-grade feeder district, because his guardian worked nearby. Education Code section 48204(f)(7) counted that employment as meeting the residency rules. He then attended Menlo-Atherton for two years while the District repeatedly asked for proof that he lived in the District. He raised other FAPE claims at first but chose to pursue only residency at the hearing.
The Hearing Officer ruled for the District on both issues. First, section 48204(f)(7) lets an elementary pupil who qualified through a parent's or guardian's job stay through 12th grade only within that same "school district." The Hearing Officer relied on the statute's singular wording, the Education Code's separate district types, case law treating high school and elementary districts as separate legal entities, and 1992 legislative history. That history put feeder-district language only in the interdistrict transfer statute, section 46601.5. Second, the District did not waive its residency objection. The guardian admitted the student never entered under section 48204(f)(7). He attended under what amounted to an at-will transfer with no written agreement between the two school boards, which the District could end after any school year. All requested relief was denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO read the employment-based residency rule in Education Code section 48204(f)(7) in 2001. The protection let a student continue through 12th grade only in the same district. It did not bind a separate high school district fed by the elementary district. Informal transfers without written board agreements could also end after each school year.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Is Petitioner entitled to attend Menlo-Atherton High School in the Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to a prior interdistrict attendance agreement with the Menlo Park City School District?
Education Code § 48204(f)(7) lets a student who qualified through a parent's or guardian's employment stay through 12th grade only in the same single school district, so a separate high school district is not bound by a feeder elementary district's employment-based residency.
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 2. Did the District waive objection to Petitioner's claimed residency within the Sequoia Union High School District because Petitioner attended Menlo-Atherton High School for two years?
No waiver. The student never entered under § 48204(f)(7). He attended under what amounted to an at-will interdistrict transfer with no written board agreement, and the District could end it at the close of a school year.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Petitioner's requested relief denied; Petitioner not entitled to attend Menlo-Atherton High School under the prior Menlo Park City School District interdistrict attendance arrangement.
Key authorities
Education Code § 48204(f)(7); Education Code § 46601.5(c); Education Code § 46600(a); Education Code § 48200; Welfare and Institutions Code § 17.1; McKee v. Edgar; Gould v. Santa Ana High School District; Moyer v. Workmen's Comp. Appeals Bd.; California Mfrs. Assn. v. Public Utilities Com.; Friends of Mammoth v. Board of Supervisors; People v. Davis; Briggs v. Eden Council for Hope & Opportunity
People named in the decision
- Dr. Alice Campbell, administrative vice principal, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Laurie Costigan, special education resource teacher, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Susan Berghaus, District director of information and communications, Sequoia Union High School District
- Peggy Kleikamp, special education resource teacher, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Eric Hartwig, principal, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Jeff Klenow, special day class teacher, Menlo-Atherton High School
- Joyce Willett, District director of special education, Sequoia Union High School District
- Dr. Whitcomb, District staff member at residency meeting, Sequoia Union High School District
- Joe Wade, police officer (witness for Student), Redwood City Police Department
- Makhoba Morojele, advocate for Student
- John D. Nibbelin, attorney for District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Redwood City, California, on October 11, 12, 18 and 19, 2001. Appearing on behalf of Petitioner (STUDENT) were advocate Makhoba Morojele and MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN. Appearing on behalf of Respondent Sequoia Union High School District (District) were attorney John D. Nibbelin and district director of special education Joyce Willett.
The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Dr. Alice Campbell, administrative vice principal at Menlo-Atherton High School (Menlo-Atherton); Laurie Costigan, special education resource teacher at Menlo-Atherton; Susan Berghaus, District director of information and communications; Peggy Kleikamp, special education resource teacher at Menlo- Atherton; Eric Hartwig, principal at Menlo-Atherton; Jeff Klenow, special day class teacher at Menlo-Atherton; Joyce Willett, District director of special education; MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN of STUDENT; and Joe Wade, Redwood City police officer. With the exception of MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN, Mr. Klenow, and Officer Wade, the District called the same witnesses as Petitioner.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following receipt of closing briefs on October 24, 2001, the case was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Is Petitioner entitled to attend Menlo-Atherton High School in the Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to a prior interdistrict attendance agreement with the Menlo Park City School District?
2. Did the District waive objection to Petitioner’s claimed residency within the Sequoia Union School District because Petitioner attended Menlo-Atherton High School for two years?(Footnote 1)
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old eleventh grade student who is eligible for special education and related services due to a specific learning disability. MR. and MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN have had custody of STUDENT since he was fifteen months old. On January 31, 1991, the San Mateo Superior Court appointed MR. and MS. LEGAL GUARDIANS of STUDENT. STUDENT has resided with MR. and MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN within the jurisdictional boundaries of Fremont Unified School District (Fremont) since 1991. However, STUDENT attended elementary and junior high school in Menlo Park City School District (Menlo Park) from 1989 to June 1999 because MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN worked in Redwood City.(Footnote 2) From 1989 to 1992, STUDENT attended kindergarten and first grade at Bellhaven.(Footnote 3) From 1992 to 1997, he attended Oakknoll Elementary School (Oakknoll) from the second to the sixth grade. From 1997 to 1999, STUDENT attended Hillview Junior High School (Hillview) from the seventh to the eighth grade.
MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that in May 1999 Sequoia Union High School District (Sequoia) sent her papers to facilitate STUDENT’s transfer from Hillview, which is in Menlo Park, to Menlo-Atherton High School (Menlo-Atherton), which is in Sequoia. Menlo-Atherton is one of four high schools within Sequoia’s boundaries.(Footnote 4) Both Petitioner’s and the District’s witnesses testified that Menlo Park is one of five feeder elementary school districts for Sequoia.(Footntoe 5) MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that prior to the start of the 1999-2000 school year at Menlo-Atherton, she went to Fremont and filled out the interdistrict transfer papers so that STUDENT could attend Menlo-Atherton.(Footnote 6) MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN also testified that she never used California Education Code § 48204(f)(7) as a basis upon which to enroll STUDENT at Menlo-Atherton. District witnesses Susan Berghaus and Eric Hartwig testified that no students have attended Menlo-Atherton pursuant to Education Code § 48204(f)(7) transfer because of the impacted conditions at the high school.
In May 1999, a transitional individualized education program (IEP) meeting took place at Hillview. Both MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and Mr. Jeff Klenow, a special day class teacher at Menlo-Atherton, attended the transitional IEP meeting. They testified that residency was neither discussed at the meeting nor raised as an issue. In the transitional IEP plan, MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN listed her residence in Fremont.
On August 19, 1999, approximately two weeks before classes began at Menlo-Atherton on September 1, 1999, MS. PARENT, who is STUDENT’s mother, signed a declaration attesting to STUDENT’s residence. MS. PARENT certified that she understood Sequoia’s policy which required that a student attend the school in whose attendance area his parents or guardian resides. Furthermore, she certified that she resided in East Palo Alto, which lies within the Menlo-Atherton attendance area. MS. PARENT verified that she understood that STUDENT would be required to transfer to the school in whose attendance area he resides if it were determined that STUDENT did not reside in the Menlo-Atherton attendance area. On the same day, MS. PARENT filled out an emergency health card but failed to indicate that MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN, who resided in Fremont, was his legal guardian. Again, she noted that STUDENT resided in East Palo Alto. On August 30, 1999, MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN also filled out an emergency health card and listed STUDENT’s residence in East Palo Alto. MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that while STUDENT resided in Fremont at this time, he stayed overnight with his mother a few nights per week so that they could “bond.”
In September 1999, STUDENT began to attend Menlo-Atherton. The District witnesses testified that throughout the 1999-2000 school year, they requested that STUDENT confirm that he was a resident of the District. However, they never received the requested information. MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that the District did not express any concern to her during the 1999-2000 school year that STUDENT’s residency was an issue.
In August 2000, the District held a meeting with MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and STUDENT. Ms. Peggy Kleikamp and Dr. Whitcomb appeared on behalf of the District. Ms. Kleikamp testified that both she and Dr. Whitcomb advised MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN that the uncertainty surrounding STUDENT’s residence had not been resolved the prior school year and that it needed to be resolved as soon as possible. MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that she never hid the fact that STUDENT resided with her in Fremont. Between August 2000 and June 2001, five additional meetings were held with MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and STUDENT. At each meeting, the residency issue was discussed. At IEP meetings in November 1999 and in February 2001, MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN indicated in the IEP plans that her residence was in Palo Alto. However, her address was either supplemented or later replaced with MS. PARENT’S post office box number in Palo Alto. MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that this post office box number was used by her only to receive mail in Palo Alto during the day because she lived in Fremont. STUDENT’s personal information on the school computer also listed the post office box number in East Palo Alto as his residence.
Because of the ongoing controversy over STUDENT’s residence, the District requested that STUDENT produce a bill with his address. STUDENT provided a P.G. & E. bill with MS. PARENT’S address in East Palo Alto. Ms. Berghaus testified that if the address in Palo Alto was in fact STUDENT’s residence, then he should attend Carlmont High School and not Menlo-Atherton. MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN again denied that STUDENT resided with his mother and affirmed that he lived the majority of the time with her in Fremont. Despite the ongoing residency issue, STUDENT finished the 2000-2001 school year at Menlo-Atherton. In June 2001, Dr. Campbell testified that she had a meeting with STUDENT and MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and advised them that they had to clear up the residency issue prior to the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Campbell pointed out that she advised both MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and STUDENT that if the issue remained unresolved, STUDENT could not attend school at Menlo-Atherton any longer. STUDENT attended summer school and successfully completed his course work.
On September 4, 2001, STUDENT appeared for the first day of school at Menlo-Atherton. District personnel advised STUDENT that because he was not a resident of the school, he had to return to his neighborhood school in Fremont. Eric Hartwig testified that STUDENT was not given prior written notice of the District’s decision not to readmit him for the 2001-2002 school year because he had failed to establish residency within the district as requested. On September 6, 2001, Ms. Morojele wrote Mr. Hartwig and other District officials a letter and requested that STUDENT be allowed to attend Menlo-Atherton. Ms. Morojele did not mention Education Code § 48204(f)(7) in her letter as a basis for STUDENT’s residence in the district. On September 11, 2001, STUDENT returned to Menlo-Atherton. He was arrested by Officer Joe Wade and requested to leave campus. On September 14, 2001, Mr. Hartwig sent MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN and Ms. Morojele a letter and explained that if STUDENT could establish residency within the District, he could return to Menlo-Atherton. On September 18, 2001, Petitioner filed his request for a due process hearing.
PARTIES CONTENTIONS
Petitioner contends that he established residency in the Menlo Park City School District because his legal guardian, MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN worked in Menlo Park. Because of the prior established interdistrict attendance in Menlo Park, Petitioner alleges he need not reapply for residency in the Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to Education Code § 48204(f)(7). Finally, Petitioner alleges that because he attended Menlo-Atherton High School for two years, the District waived any objection to the issue regarding his residency within the district.
Respondent does not dispute that Petitioner established residency in Menlo Park pursuant to the Education Code § 48204(f)(7). However, Respondent contends that Education Code § 48204(f)(7) is not applicable in this case because it establishes residency for an elementary school pupil in a single district which has grades k-12. Respondent argues that because Menlo Park City School District only encompasses grades k-8 and Sequoia High School District encompasses grades 9-12, it is a separate and distinct legal entity which is not bound to accept section 48204(f)(7) interdistrict attendance agreements. Finally, Respondent contends that it did not waive objection to the issue regarding Petitioner’s residency within the district because Petitioner’s attendance within the district was, at best, an interdistrict transfer which must be renewed on a yearly basis.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Is Petitioner entitled to attend Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to a prior interdistrict attendance agreement with Menlo Park City School District?
The general rules governing residence of a minor are found in California Education Code § 48200 and Welfare and Institutions Code § 17.1(a) and (b). California Education Code § 48200 provides:
Each person between the ages of 6 and 18 years not exempted under the provisions of this chapter or Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 48400) is subject to compulsory full-time education. Each person subject to compulsory full-time education and each person subject to compulsory continuation education not exempted under the provisions Chapter 3 (commencing with Section 48400) shall attend the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes and for the full time designated as the length of the school day by the governing board of the school district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located and each parent, guardian, or other person having control or charge of the pupil shall send the pupil to the public full-time day school or continuation school or classes and for the full time designated as the length of the school day by the governing board of the school district in which the residence of either the parent or legal guardian is located.
Unless otherwise provided for in this code, a pupil shall not be enrolled for less than than the minimum school day by law.
Welfare and Institutions Code § 17.1(a) and (b) provide:
Unless otherwise provided under the provisions of this code, to the extent not in conflict with federal law, the residence of a minor person shall be determined by the following rules:
(a) The residence of the parent with whom a child maintains his or her place of abode or the residence of any individual who has been appointed legal guardian or the individual who has been given the care or custody by a court of competent jurisdiction, determines the residence of the child.
(b) Wherever in this section it is provided that the residence of a child is determined by by the residence of the person who has custody, “custody” means the legal right to custody of the child unless that right is held jointly by two or more persons, in which case “custody” means the physical custody of the child by one of the persons sharing the right to custody.
An exception to the general rules governing residence of a minor is found in California Education Code § 48204(f)(7). It provides:
Notwithstanding Section 48200, a pupil shall be deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district, provided he or she is any of the following:
(f) An elementary school pupil, one or both of whose parents, or whose legal guardian, is employed within the boundaries of that school district.
(7) Once a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance pursuant to this subdivision and is enrolled in a school in a school district whose boundaries include the location where one parent or both parents of a pupil is employed, or where the pupil’s legal guardian is employed, the pupil shall not have to reapply in the next school year to attend a school within that school district and the district governing board allow the pupil to attend school through the 12th grade in that district if the parent or guardian so chooses, subject to paragraphs (1) to (6) inclusive.
Each party contends that the statute is clear and needs no interpretation. Petitioner argues that a literal reading of the phrase “school district” in Education Code § 48204(f)(7) encompasses an elementary school district, grades k-8, which feeds into a high school district, grades 9-12.
The District disputes Petitioner’s interpretation of the phrase “school district.” The District contends that the phrase “school district,” as used in the statute, applies to a single unified k-12 district. It argues that if Petitioner attended a unified school district with grades k-12, there would be no issue regarding the applicability of a previously agreed-to interdistrict attendance agreement and Petitioner’s ability to establish residency thereunder. However, the District alleges that the phrase “school district” does not encompass an elementary school district which feeds into a high school district because they are two separate and distinct legal entities. Thus, the District concludes that it is not bound to recognize and accept an inter-district attendance agreement from an elementary school district.
In resolving the issue, the Hearing Officer applies several fundamental principals of statutory construction. The primary rule is that in interpreting a statute, one must ascertain the intent of the Legislature so as to effectuate the purpose of the law. (Moyer v. Workmen’s Comp. Appeals Bd., 10 Cal.3d 222, 230 (1973)). To ascertain that intent, one turns first to the language used (Tracy v. Municipal Court, 22 Cal.3d 760, 764 (1978)), and then if necessary to “the legislative history of the statute and the wider historical circumstances of its enactment.” (Sand v. Superior Court, 34 Cal.3d 567, 570 (1983).) “A statute’s words must be construed in context, and statutes must be harmonized, both internally and with each other, to the extent possible.” (California Mfrs. Assn. v. Public Utilities Com., 24 Cal.3d 836, 844 (1979).) Statutes are to be interpreted “so as to make them workable and reasonable.” (City of Santa Clara v. Von Raesfeld, 3 Cal.3d 239, 248 (1970).) Therefore, interpretative constructions that “defy common sense, or lead to mischief or absurdity, are to be avoided” (California Mfgrs. Assn. v. Public Utilities Com., supra, at 844). Thus, a “statute should not be read literally if to do so would bring about a result inconsistent with the intent of the Legislature.” (People v. Davis, 29 Cal.3d 814, 828 (1981).) In other words, “once a particular legislative intent is ascertained, it must be given effect even though it is not consistent with the strict letter of the statute.” (Friends of Mammoth v. Board of Supervisors, 8 Cal.3d 247, 259 (1972).)
A. Statute’s Plain Language
To ascertain the intent of the Legislature, the Hearing Officer turns first to the language used in California Education Code § 48204(f)(7). In 1999, when Petitioner entered Menlo-Atherton High School from Hillview Junior High School, Code section 48204(f)(7) used the phrase “elementary school pupil.” During the 2000-2001 school year, Code section 48204(f)(7) remained unchanged. While the Legislature could have left the scope of this subsection broad by using the phrase “school pupil,” it specifically chose to narrow its applicability by using the phrase “elementary school pupil.” The Hearing Officer finds the Legislature’s choice of words specifically telling because they focus this subsection on “elementary school” pupils. Second, the legislature used the phrase “school district” at the beginning of subsection (7) and continued to use the phrase in its singular form to the end of the section. Had the Legislature intended the reach of subsection (f)(7) to extend to more than one “school district,” it only needed to change the word “district” from its singular into its plural form. However, the legislature chose not to do so. The Legislature’s failure to extend the reach of this subsection to multiple districts is particularly telling because the California Education Code is very specific in its designation and clarification of the various types of districts within this state. California Education Code §§ 50-53 and §§ 80-87. These various district designations have existed for at least the last ten years, which is when the current edition of section 48204(f)(7), as outlined below, came into effect. Finally, California case law has also noted the critical legal distinctions that are made between the various types of school districts. In McKee v. Edgar, 137 Cal. App. 462, 465-466, 30 P.2d 999 (1934), the court stated:
“The existence and organization of common schools is so different from the existence and organization of high schools in their origin and history and in the resulting legislation, that for various reasons of convenience or necessity, the state law contemplates the existence of high school districts as entities separate and distinct from elementary or common school districts. The charter provisions to which we have referred must be read in the light of the Constitution and general laws. So considered, they recognize the separate existence of the two districts, but, treating them as a part of the municipal life, place them under the control of a board of education authorized to care for the administration of the schools in both of the districts...This convenient agency of public schools in cities is contemplated by the law of the state, but there has never been any evidence of legislative intention that this identity of control of the districts should modify or change their status as separate legal entities. They are as completely separate and distinct ‘as though the two were in separate cities and governed by separate boards.’ (Gould v. Santa Ana High School District, 131 Cal. App. 345, 348, 21 P.2d 623, 624 1943).)”
In light of the Legislature’s singular use of the phrase “school district,” the California Education Code’s specific classification of the different types of school districts within the state and the case law highlighting the legal and historical significance of these district classifications, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Legislature did not intend to extend the scope of section 48204(f)(7) beyond elementary school children and one “school district.”
B. Legislative History
To ascertain the intent of the Legislature in section 48204(f)(7), the Hearing Officer may also consider legislative history where it supports his interpretation of the plain meaning of the statute. (Briggs. v. Eden Counsel for Hope & Opportunity, 19 Cal.4th 1106, 1119-1121, 81 Cal. Rptr. 2d 471, 969 P.2d 564 (1999).) Thus, the Hearing Officer turns to the legislative history of section 48204(f)(7). In 1990, the Legislature amended section 42804 of the Education Code. (1990 Cal. ALS. 10; 1990 Cal. AB 149; Stats 1990 ch. 10.) Until June 30, 1990, Education Code § 48204 only required the governing boards of any two school districts when deciding whether to enter an interdistrict attendance agreement to consider the child care needs of the pupil. The law was silent regarding both the duration of the interdistrict attendance agreement and its applicability to one or more districts. After the 1990 regular session of the Legislature, section 48204 was amended to include, among other sections, subsection (f)(7), which read: “Once a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance pursuant to this subdivision and is enrolled in a school in a school district whose boundaries include the location where one parent or both parents of a pupil is employed, or where a pupil’s legal guardian is employed, the pupil shall not have to reapply in the next school year to attend a school within that school district.” (Stats 1990 ch. 10, p. 1, p. 4.) While subsection (f)(7) made reference to “an elementary school pupil” (Stats 1990 ch. 10, p. 3), it made no reference to anything more specific than a “district,” nor did it mention that the statute was applicable to grade k-12.
In 1992, the Legislature considered a proposed joint amendment to section 48204 and California Education Code § 46601.5, the latter of which encompasses interdistrict transfers. (1992 Cal. ALS. 120; 1992 Cal. AB 287; Stats 1992 ch. 120.) Assembly Bill 287 proposed two changes to the aforementioned statutes:
This bill would require the governing board of any unified school district that has entered, and the governing board of any high school district whose feeder elementary school has entered, into an agreement for the inter-district attendance of a pupil based on that pupil’s child care needs to allow that pupil to continue to attend school through the 12th grade in that district if the parent or guardian so chooses, subject to specified provisions of existing law, authorizing school districts to, among other things, prohibit transfers. This requirement would constitute a state-mandated local program.
This bill would impose a state-mandated local program by requiring that, once a pupil is deemed to have complied with the residency requirements and is enrolled in a school in a school district whose boundaries include the location where that pupil’s parent or guardian is employed, that pupil be allowed to continued to attend school through the 12th grade in that district if the parent or guardian so chooses, subject to specified provisions of existing law. (1991 Cal. AB 287 at p. 1 and p. 2.)
While the aforementioned proposals were ultimately adopted in 1991 and became effective in 1992, the former language regarding feeder schools and high school districts was codified only in section 46601.5 regarding interdistrict transfers. The latter language regarding residency and attendance in a school district from k-12 was codified only in section 48204.(Footnote 7) From 1992 to the present, it is particularly noteworthy that the language in these two specific sections of these two statues has remained unchanged and neither statute has incorporated the language of the other. The Hearing Officer can only presume that if the Legislature meant a different interpretation of section 48204(f)(7), that some corrective measure would have been adopted in the course of the many enactments on the subject from 1992 to the present. The interpretation of section 48204(f)(7) contended by Petitioner, then, is neither within the plain language of the statute nor supported by the legislative history of that section and that of section 46601.5(c). Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner cannot be deemed to have complied with the residence requirements for school attendance in the Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to prior interdistrict attendance in the Menlo Park City School District.
ISSUE 2: Did the District waive objection to Petitioner’s claimed residency within the Sequoia Union High School District because Petitioner attended Menlo- Atherton High School for two years?
Petitioner contends that because he attended Menlo-Atherton High School for two years, the District waived objection to his residency within the district. However, MS. LEGAL GUARDIAN testified that STUDENT never entered the District pursuant to the Allen Bill, i.e., California Education Code § 48204(f)(7). Furthermore, she testified that before STUDENT entered the District, she filled out the requisite interdistrict transfer papers from Fremont Unified School District and it was on this legal basis that he entered Menlo-Atherton. As discussed above, there was no legal basis for Petitioner to establish residency pursuant to section 48204(f)(7) when he entered the district for the 1999-2000 school year. Furthermore, the admission by Petitioner’s legal guardian that residency was never the legal basis upon which Petitioner entered the district further supports this conclusion. Thus, Petitioner cannot now allege waiver of residency when it was never in issue in the first place.
At best, Petitioner attended Menlo-Atherton on what was akin to an at-will interdistrict transfer without the required written agreement between the Fremont Unified School District board and the Sequoia Union High School District board. California Education Code § 46600(a). Since Petitioner presented no proof of any agreement between the two boards for Petitioner to attend Menlo-Atherton, any right Petitioner may have had to attend Menlo-Atherton was extinguished at the end of each school year and subject to the District permitting Petitioner to attend Menlo-Atherton for the new school year without any written agreement between the two school boards. After the District requested Petitioner to produce proof of residency for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years without any result, the District had every right to terminate the at-will interdistrict transfer at the end of the 2000-2001 school year. Therefore, Petitioner, without a written agreement, was required to return to his home district in Fremont for the 2001-2002 school year.
ORDER
1. Petitioner is not entitled to attended Menlo-Atherton High School in the Sequoia Union High School District pursuant to a prior interdistrict attendance agreement with the Menlo Park City School District. Thus, Petitioner’s requested relief is denied.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:
The Respondent prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decisions. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: November 6, 2001 _____________________________________ Joseph T. Macaluso, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. Issue number two was not specifically identified as an issue by Petitioner. However, Petitioner raised the issue during the hearing and both parties had a full and fair opportunity to address it. Therefore, the Hearing Officer includes issue number two for decision in this decision. Petitioner initially identified a number of issues regarding alleged past denials of a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) to Petitioner. However, Petitioner chose to forego pursuing these FAPE issues at this time and to only pursue the residency issue in this hearing.
2. STUDENT’S interdistrict attendance in the Menlo Park City School District was pursuant to California Education Code § 48204(f)(7).
3. STUDENT attended Bellhaven during the 1991-1992 school year because he repeated the first grade.
4. The four high schools within Sequoia’s boundaries are Menlo-Atherton, Carlmont, Woodside, and Sequoia.
5. The five feeder elementary school districts are Ravenswood, Las Lomitas, Redwood City, Portola Valley and Menlo Park.
6. Petitioner did not produce the interdistrict transfer papers at the hearing and District witness Susan Berghaus testified that she had never seen these papers.
7. The former language was codified in section 46601.5(c) and the latter language was codified in section 48204(f)(7).
