California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 2, 2002
Student v. Plumas Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2058-02 · Hearing Officer Lawrence E. Mendel
Plumas Unified denied FAPE for five years by missing dyslexia; must repay $12,744 Lindamood-Bell tuition and fund summer services.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents of a 15-year-old ninth grader with a specific learning disability filed against Plumas Unified School District. The Hearing Officer found that the student's core need was a phonological processing disorder (dyslexia). The District never properly assessed it, despite early team notes, a private speech-language report, and its own testing. Claims from before November 1997 were time-barred.
The Hearing Officer found that the District denied a FAPE in every school year from 1997-1998 through 2001-2002. The IEPs never named the core need. Their goals were missing, too broad, or had no usable baselines. No goals covered organization, off-task behavior, or attendance, and the 1999-2000 IEPs had no present levels or goals at all. Services were too limited, delivered inconsistently, and at first left to the student's choice. The 2001-2002 program was not individualized or taught by trained staff. ESY was not needed in 1999 or 2002.
The parents won reimbursement for the June 2000 Lindamood-Bell assessment, $12,744 in Lindamood-Bell tuition, $495 for exit testing and a progress report, and the mother's weekly visit mileage. Apartment rent, Sylvan tutoring, 1999 summer tutoring, and 2000-2001 home tutoring were denied. As compensatory education, the District must fund four to six weeks of summer Lindamood-Bell instruction in Sacramento, with living and travel costs. It must also hold an April 2003 data review. Requests for staff training and outside consultation were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated a district's repeated failure to assess a suspected phonological processing disorder as the root of a FAPE denial lasting several years. It also shows a Hearing Officer weighing parent reimbursement claims one by one, declining to reduce reimbursement for imperfect notice, and ordering intensive summer compensatory instruction instead of after-school services.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
Despite years of signs pointing to a phonological processing disorder, the District never assessed it properly. The 1999-2000 triennial and September 2001 assessments were procedurally and substantively defective: the dyslexia report was late, recommended testing was never done, and some reports were never written.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year, including the 1998 extended school year?
The November 1997 IEP missed the phonological processing need and had no goals for off-task behavior or attendance. Services were too limited and the student was allowed to choose them. He made no meaningful progress, and the District showed no evidence that the 1998 ESY reading program was provided.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
FAPE was denied: the January 1999 IEP had only one goal, dropped goals the student had not met, and cut RSP to 30 minutes a day. However, the student did not need ESY in summer 1999.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year?
The December 1999 and June 2000 IEPs had no present levels of performance and no goals, and they did not fully identify the student's needs. They were so deficient that they denied a FAPE for the year.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
The August and September 2000 IEPs offered 90 minutes a day of RSP. However, they had overbroad goals with inaccurate baselines, no goals for math, organization or off-task behavior, and no multi-sensory instructional strategy for the phonological processing disorder. The offer was not a FAPE.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
FAPE was denied: the September 2001 IEP did not name the core need, two goals were too broad to measure, and the transition plan listed needs with no services or goals. The small-group program was not individualized and was not delivered by staff trained in the methods. The student did not need ESY in summer 2002.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7a. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring from the Sylvan Learning Center during the 1997-1998 school year?
Reimbursement was denied because there was not enough evidence that Sylvan addressed the phonological processing need or gave educational benefit.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7b. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for tutoring from Marci Johnson provided during the summer of 1999?
Reimbursement was denied because there was no evidence of what services were provided in summer 1999 or of any benefit.
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 7c. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Lindamood-Bell assessment obtained in June 2000?
The District's January 2000 dyslexia screening was not tailored to the student's specific needs, so the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell assessment.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7d. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for 13 weeks of an intensive Lindamood-Bell program and post-program reports, including necessary living expenses, during the 2000-2001 school year?
Lindamood-Bell met the student's needs and he made progress. The Hearing Officer awarded $12,744 tuition, the $495 exit testing and report, and the mother's weekly mileage, and declined to reduce the award for imperfect notice. Apartment rent was denied because the father would have lived in Sacramento anyway.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7e. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for private tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year?
Reimbursement was denied because there was no evidence of the curriculum, the tutors' qualifications, any link to the student's needs, or any benefit.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 8. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District's denial of a FAPE from November 1997 to the present?
The Hearing Officer awarded four to six weeks of intensive summer instruction at Lindamood-Bell Sacramento with living and travel costs, plus an April 2003 data review. Requests for staff training and for a consulting contract with Dr. Gardner were denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- IEE at public expense. Reimburse the cost of the June 2000 Lindamood-Bell initial evaluation. Petitioner submits proof within 25 calendar days of the decision; the District pays within 30 calendar days of receiving proof.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the cost of the December 2000 Lindamood-Bell exit testing and progress report ($495 per the findings), on the same proof and payment schedule.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse $12,744 for Lindamood-Bell tuition in 2000, within 30 calendar days of the decision.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse 5,200 miles (13 weeks x 400-mile round trip) for the mother's visits during the Lindamood-Bell program, at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
- Compensatory education. Within 15 calendar days, the District must contract with Lindamood-Bell Learning Center in Sacramento for four to six weeks of intensive services (about 80-120 hours) as recommended in its progress report. Lindamood-Bell instructors decide the number of weeks. Services must be provided before the 2002-2003 school year begins.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse reasonable living and transportation costs of the compensatory program, including room or apartment rent, mileage to take the student to and from Sacramento, and the mother's weekend visits. Parents submit proof within 25 calendar days after the program ends; the District pays within 30 days of receiving proof, at the employee mileage rate.
- Order to assess. In April 2003, the District must conduct a data review and, if necessary, develop an assessment plan to measure progress on the phonological processing disorder. If progress is not sufficient, the IEP team must consider ESY at the end of tenth grade.
Total: 80 hours of compensatory services; $13,239 ordered
Key authorities
Rowley; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Hoeft v. Tucson Unified School District; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri
People named in the decision
- James Pindell, director of special education, Plumas Unified School District
- Cathleen Roberts, school psychologist, Plumas Unified School District
- Paula Gardner, expert witness for Student; associate professor, California State University, Sacramento
- Carol Spicer, resource specialist (RSP) teacher, Plumas Unified School District
- Marci Johnson, teacher, parent advocate and private tutor
- Donna Pilgrim, speech-language pathologist, Plumas Unified School District
- Terri Mehl, clinical director, private provider, Lindamood-Bell Learning Center
- Jennifer Hollibaugh, private speech-language pathologist and learning-disability specialist
- Sylvia Szeker, resource teacher (long-term substitute), Plumas Unified School District
- Kevin Jolly, former school principal, Chester Elementary
- Shawn Mahaffey, algebra teacher, Chester Junior-Senior High School
- Becky Compton, sixth grade and ninth grade English teacher, Plumas Unified School District
- Greg McIntire, sixth grade teacher, Plumas Unified School District
- Scott Cory, school principal, Plumas Unified School District
- Mr. Huitt, school psychologist (1996 assessment), Plumas Unified School District
- Ms. Howe, RSP mentor teacher / assessor, Plumas Unified School District
- Kristine Wilson, private speech-language pathologist
- Ms. Hinrichs, fifth grade general education teacher, Chester Elementary
- Ms. Deane, RSP teacher, Chester Junior-Senior High School
- Mr. Davies, instructional aide, Chester Junior-Senior High School
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Center (Sacramento), private provider / assessor
- Sylvan Learning Center (Redding), private tutoring provider
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Chester, California, on March 21, 22, April 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, and May 13, 14, 15, and 16, 2002.
STUDENT was represented at the hearing by attorney Geralyn Clancy. Also present on STUDENT’s behalf was MOTHER, his mother. Plumas Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Raymond Dunne. Also present on the District’s behalf was James Pindell, District director of special education.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Cathleen Roberts, school psychologist; Paula Gardner, associate professor at California State University, Sacramento; Carol Spicer, resource teacher; Marci Johnson, teacher and parent advocate; Donna Pilgrim, speech/language pathologist; James Pindell, director of special education; Terri Mehl, Lindamood-Bell clinical director; Jennifer Hollibaugh, speech/language pathologist; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; and Sylvia Szeker, resource teacher.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Kevin Jolly, former school principal; Shawn Mahaffey, teacher; Becky Compton, teacher; Greg McIntire, teacher; and Scott Cory, school principal. The District also recalled Carol Spicer, Donna Pilgrim and James Pindell.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the briefs on May 29, 2002, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
Petitioner has raised factual issues extending back to 1995. This case was filed in November 2000. The Hearing Officer finds that any claim for relief based upon the District’s actions which occurred outside the three-year limitation (prior to November, 1997) is barred by Education Code Section 56505(j). However, the Hearing Officer can look at relevant evidence from the time period before November 1997 as background information to assist him in resolving claims that did arise within the three-year time limitation.
During the hearing, it came to light that there was a prior mediation-only case between these same parties, MO98-00028. This mediation-only case was filed by the District to determine whether the District was obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the Sylvan assessment obtained in 1998. There was dispute as to whether the resolution of the prior mediation barred the Petitioner from seeking reimbursement for the Sylvan assessment and for the Sylvan services in this case. The Hearing Officer notes that the cost of the Sylvan assessment was not an issue raised on the first day of hearing. In addition, the cost of that assessment was resolved by mutual agreement between the parties as memorialized by the June 1, 1998 IEP addendum. On the basis of these facts, the Hearing Officer finds that the cost of the Sylvan assessment was not a proper issue for this hearing. The cost of the Sylvan services was never raised as an issue in the prior mediation and is therefore a proper issue for this hearing.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1997-1998 school year, including the 1998 extended school year?
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year?
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for all expenses, including mileage, that they incurred in providing the following services:
(a) Tutoring from the Sylvan Learning Center during the 1997-1998 school year? (b) Tutoring from Marci Johnson provided during the summer of 1999? (c) The cost of the Lindamood-Bell assessment obtained in June 2000? (d) Thirteen weeks of an intensive Lindamood-Bell program and post-program reports, including necessary living expenses, during the 2000-2001 school year? (e) Private tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year?
8. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of a FAPE from November 1997 to the present?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old ninth-grader attending Chester Junior-Senior High School within the Plumas Unified School District. STUDENT was referred for assessment by a student study team in September 1996, when he was in the fourth grade at Chester Elementary. STUDENT was observed having trouble staying on task, decoding words, and retaining information. He also had sensitive hearing. STUDENT was assessed in the areas of health and development, cognitive functioning, and academic achievement. Dr. Huitt, the school psychologist, administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - Third Edition (WISC-III), the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), and the Children’s Auditory Verbal Learning Test-2 (CAVLT-2). Carol Spicer, the RSP teacher, and Ms. Howe, Ms. Spicer’s mentor, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R). The evaluation report concluded that STUDENT had a full scale IQ of 90, which placed his intellectual functioning in the low average range. STUDENT’s scores on broad reading and broad math were both below average. His broad written language was in the second percentile, well below average. STUDENT also had difficulty holding on to new information that was presented with only minimal transition instructions. In his report, Mr. Huitt noted that STUDENT’s attendance had been fair to poor. From the testing, it was concluded that there was a significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s achievement and his ability in the area of written language as a result of processing disorders in the areas of cognitive functioning and attention (Footnote 2).
An IEP team meeting was held on November 20, 1996. The team concluded that STUDENT qualified for special education as a child with a specific learning disability in the area of written expression. STUDENT was identified as having disorders in the areas of attention and cognitive abilities. It was agreed that STUDENT would receive five hours a week in the resource specialist program (RSP). Goals and objectives were developed in the areas of spelling, written expression, organization strategies, reading comprehension and content organization. During the fourth grade, STUDENT’s RSP support services were provided by both pull-out (in the RSP room) and push-in (support from an instructional aide or the RSP teacher in the general education class room). Ms. Spicer, STUDENT’s RSP teacher that year, stated that the type of support provided depended on what STUDENT felt he needed.
In June 1997, STUDENT was assessed by Kristine Wilson, a speech-language pathologist. Ms. Wilson found that STUDENT had a great deal of difficulty manipulating sounds and changing their order. His score on the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC) placed him at the second grade level. STUDENT demonstrated a strong sight word vocabulary, but when reading aloud he only corrected his errors 14% of the time. His errors affected the meaning and his understanding of the passages. STUDENT’s spelling was at the second grade level. Ms. Wilson recommended that STUDENT work on tasks designed to increase his phonemic awareness.
STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting for the fifth grade was held on November 5, 1997. On informal testing to determine STUDENT’s present levels of performance, STUDENT read 62 words correctly at the fifth grade level (significantly below average). When given a story starter, STUDENT was able to write eight related simple sentences with 75% accuracy. STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with “r” controlled vowels and blends, and added “r” to words. He also had difficulty spelling vowel combinations and words with more than three syllables (Footnote 3). STUDENT continued to have difficulty staying on task. The IEP team developed goals in the areas of written expression, spelling, reading comprehension, and organizational skills. At the hearing, there was some confusion as to the amount of RSP support STUDENT was to receive. The first page of the IEP states that STUDENT would receive three hours (180 minutes) a week of RSP support. The IEP also states that STUDENT would receive 45 minutes a day of RSP support for written expression and reading comprehension (225 minutes a week). The “recommended modifications” section of the IEP states that STUDENT’s time with the RSP teacher would be increased to 40 minutes a day for work on written expression and study skills strategies (200 minutes a week).
During the fifth grade both Ms. Spicer, the RSP teacher, and Mr. Jolly, the school principal, recalled that STUDENT wanted to minimize the time he was pulled out of class for RSP services. Ms. Spicer tried to coordinate with Ms. Hinrichs, STUDENT’s general education teacher, to ensure that STUDENT was receiving sufficient support in the general education class. STUDENT received push-in support from either Ms. Spicer or an instructional aide. As in the fourth grade, the level and type of services STUDENT received tended to vary from week to week. Ms. Spicer was not sure whether STUDENT always received three hours a week of either pull-out or push-in support. One of STUDENT’s most significant problems in the fifth grade was his organizational skills. He had trouble staying on task, keeping track of his assignments, and turning in his homework (Footnote 4).
MOTHER was concerned that STUDENT’s academic skills were not improving, so she took him to the Sylvan Learning Center in Redding for testing in February 1998. Sylvan administered the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT). STUDENT tested poor in reading rate and poor on the passage and comprehension score. MOTHER began taking STUDENT to Sylvan for tutoring every Saturday for approximately 6 months. Each session was two to four hours in length. Ms. Spicer did additional informal testing in March 1998. Using curriculum-based measures, she found that STUDENT was able to read 62 words correctly at the fifth grade level, which was still significantly below average. On the Brigance, STUDENT’s scores were poor for oral reading and passage comprehension at the fifth grade level. STUDENT also had significant problems working with phonemes. After this assessment, MOTHER met with Ms. Spicer and Mr. Jolly to discuss STUDENT. At this meeting, it was agreed to conduct a new formal assessment and to develop a behavior contract for STUDENT to try to address his problems with organization and staying on task.
Ms. Spicer administered the WJ-R on April 1, 1998. STUDENT demonstrated broad reading in the 31st percentile (a grade equivalent of 4.3), broad math in the 54th percentile (a grade equivalent of 5.8), and broad written language in the 37th percentile (a grade equivalent of 4.8). Ms. Spicer noted that STUDENT had problems sustaining his concentration and needed to take frequent breaks. STUDENT also had problems in spelling, particularly with vowel combinations and blends. An IEP team meeting was held on June 1, 1998. Although at this meeting the team did review the goals and objectives, the primary purpose of the meeting was to resolve a dispute between MOTHER and the District relating to who should pay for the Sylvan testing. It was agreed that STUDENT would attend summer school with an individualized reading program to be organized by Ms. Spicer. Ms. Spicer purchased a computer program for STUDENT that focused on developing phonological awareness to teach reading and spelling. MOTHER recalls that STUDENT did attend summer school that year, but she did not know what, if any, reading program he received. STUDENT was absent 18 days during the 1997-1998 school year (Footnote 5).
At the beginning of the sixth grade, Ms. Spicer met with STUDENT’s general education teachers to discuss STUDENT’s program and appropriate modifications and teaching strategies. Ms. Spicer is not sure if STUDENT was receiving any RSP support (either push-in or pull-out) during the first part of that year. She stated that pull-out RSP was “so inconsistent with his wanting to be in the classroom...” but stated that RSP was available to STUDENT.
STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting for the sixth grade was held on January 27, 1999 (Footnote 6). On the present levels of performance, it was noted that STUDENT read 80 words correctly. There was no indication what the grade level of the reading assignment was. The present levels also stated that STUDENT spelled 400 words correctly out of 500. Again, the grade level of the list was not noted. Modifications to the general education program were listed as allowing extra time for tests, multi-sensory presentation of assignments and instruction, and use of visual presentation of material. The only goal developed was in the area of written expression. STUDENT was to receive two and one-half hours a week of one-on-one RSP support in the area of writing. Ms. Spicer testified that, in the RSP classroom, STUDENT would work with her or with the instructional aide one-on-one or in small groups. Ms. Spicer also testified to using the phonological awareness computer program she had purchased the previous year to assist STUDENT when he was in the RSP classroom. Ms. Compton, one of STUDENT’s sixth grade teachers, testified that she worked with STUDENT using the Formula Phonics program. This was a basic phonics program that the whole school was using that year. Ms. Compton recalled that STUDENT had significant problems because he was easily distracted and was not staying on task. Ms. Compton also recalled that attendance was a problem that year. Mr. McIntire, STUDENT’s other teacher in the sixth grade, recalled that STUDENT had significant organizational problems, especially at the beginning of the year. MOTHER visited STUDENT’s class often in an effort to help keep up on what STUDENT was doing. Mr. McIntire also felt that attendance was a problem. STUDENT’s teachers testified that his weaknesses were in the areas of spelling, reading, writing, and staying on task.
STUDENT attended the seventh grade at Chester Junior-Senior High School. STUDENT’s triennial review was at the beginning of that year. In November 1999, in preparation for the triennial IEP team meeting, STUDENT was assessed in the areas of health and development, academic achievement, and cognitive functioning. STUDENT was given the WISC-III, the WJ-R, and the Test of Auditory-Perceptual Skills (TAPS). STUDENT’s verbal IQ was 89, his performance IQ was 100, and his full scale IQ was 93. STUDENT’s scores on the TAPS were all within the average range. On the WJ-R STUDENT scored in the 20th percentile in broad reading (a grade equivalent of 4.8) (Footnote 7), the 23rd percentile in broad math (a grade equivalent of 5.8), and in the 2nd percentile in broad written language (a grade equivalent of 3.2). Although there was still a significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s achievement and his ability in the area of written language, Cathleen Roberts, the school psychologist, did not find evidence of a processing disorder that could explain the discrepancy. However, Ms. Roberts did not administer any tests specifically designed to assess STUDENT’s phonological processing. Ms. Roberts did note the number of absences in the previous two years, and concluded that this could have significantly affected STUDENT’s academic achievement.
The IEP team meeting occurred on December 14, 1999. Ms. Roberts shared the results of the assessments with the team. MOTHER informed the team that STUDENT’s father was dyslexic and asked that STUDENT be assessed for dyslexia. The team agreed and the prior assessment plan was revised with a screening for dyslexia added. MOTHER signed the revised plan at the IEP meeting. The IEP team adjourned the meeting without developing any present levels of performance or goals and objectives. The IEP did indicate that STUDENT was receiving 225 minutes of RSP services each week. It appears that the RSP teacher did meet with STUDENT’s general education teacher to develop a checklist of modifications for the general education classes. One of the listed modifications was that STUDENT was to be allowed to go to the RSP class as needed for additional support. Ms. Roberts testified that STUDENT was not receiving any special education services at the time she performed her assessment in November 1999. However, a chronology of services prepared by Ms. Deane, the RSP teacher, in August 2000 indicates that STUDENT was receiving one period of RSP at the start of the seventh grade, which was increased to two periods of RSP at the start of the second semester. In addition, the record contains progress reports for the 1999-2000 school year that also indicate that STUDENT was receiving two periods of RSP support by the end of that year (Footnote 8).
On January 11, 2000, Ms. Roberts administered the Boder Test of Reading-Spelling Patterns and the Ekwal/Shanker Reading Inventory. However, Ms. Roberts did not write her report on this testing until May 24, 2000. Ms. Roberts did not have any specific recollection of why the report was not written until more than four months after the testing was completed, but recalled that there may have been some issue about STUDENT’s attending a private school. Ms. Roberts’ testing showed that STUDENT’s ability to syllabicate words was weak. When reading, he would omit suffixes and make whole word substitutions. He was unable to read all phonetic words at grade level, and he was unable to use decoding skills to figure out non-phonetic words. On the spelling test, he had letter reversals and letter omissions. STUDENT’s independent reading level was at the fifth grade. His rate was very slow with many errors. Typical errors were small word omissions, suffix omissions, and whole word substitutions. Ms. Roberts concluded that STUDENT demonstrated reading and spelling patterns characteristic of dyslexia. She recommended further informal assessments in the areas of decoding, reading speed, oral reading, spelling, syntax in written language, reliance on context for word recognition, listening comprehension, and reading comprehension. This additional testing was not done.
During the seventh grade, MOTHER worked with STUDENT a great deal to help him keep up with class work. MOTHER testified that STUDENT became increasingly frustrated and uncooperative during the year. MOTHER also stated that she became increasingly frustrated because STUDENT’s academic performance did not seem to be improving.
An IEP team meeting was held on June 2, 2000, to go over the results of the dyslexia screening. Ms. Roberts’ results were reviewed by the team. The team concluded that STUDENT was dyslexic and continued his eligibility for special education as a student with a specific learning disability. MOTHER indicated that she was considering the Lindamood-Bell program for STUDENT. The IEP document indicates that STUDENT was receiving 225 minutes of RSP services each week. However, the IEP does not set forth any present levels of performance or goals and objectives. It does not appear that any specific program was discussed at the meeting.
On June 19, 2000, MOTHER took STUDENT to the Lindamood-Bell center in Sacramento for testing. Lindamood-Bell administered the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-IIIA (PPVT), the Test of Problem Solving-Adolescent (TOPS), the Detroit Test of Learning Aptitude, the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, the Slossan Oral Reading Rest-Revised, the Wide Range Achievement Test - Revised-3 (WRAT-3), the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT), the Gray Oral Reading Test -Revised III (GORT-III), the Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test (LAC), the Symbol Imagery Test, the Test of Written Language-3 (TOWL-3), the Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing (CTOPP), and informal tests of writing. STUDENT scored below grade level on almost all tests, with his most significant problems on the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test (grade equivalent of 3.7 on work attack), the WRAT-3 (a grade equivalent of 4 on all parts), the GORT-3 (a grade equivalent of 3.5 on rate, 4.5 on accuracy, and 4.1 on passage), and the TOWL-3, on which he received a composite score in the 10th percentile (a grade equivalent for the TOWL-3 was not provided on the Lindamood-Bell testing summary). On July 7, 2000, MOTHER forwarded the test results to the District and requested that the District set up a curriculum to provide the Lindamood-Bell program to STUDENT and convene an IEP team meeting before the start of school.
An IEP team meeting was scheduled for August 28, 2000. In preparation for this meeting, Ms. Deane, the RSP teacher, prepared a chronology of STUDENT’s services from the District. The IEP identified STUDENT’s areas of weakness as reading, spelling, writing and math. The IEP stated that his processing problems made it difficult for him to understand and complete assignments. It was noted that STUDENT did well with modifications. Goals were developed in the areas of broad written expression, and reading. The program called for 450 minutes of RSP support, pull-out as necessary. The only processing disorder mentioned is “slow processing” affecting his math comprehension and his ability to complete assignments. MOTHER did not agree to the IEP and presented her plans for STUDENT to attend Lindamood-Bell.
Shortly after the IEP meeting, MOTHER enrolled STUDENT at the Lindamood-Bell center in Sacramento. MOTHER also informed the District that she had enrolled STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell. The District convened another IEP on September 11, 2000. Neither of the PARENTS attended this IEP. The purpose of the meeting was to confirm that the IEP team did not agree with the PARENTS’ decision to place STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell and to reconfirm that the District believed that its offer of services contained in the August 28, 2000 IEP was an offer of a free and appropriate education. The PARENTS filed this case in November 2000.
STUDENT attended the Lindamood-Bell program from September 5, 2000, to November 22, 2000. While attending Lindamood-Bell, STUDENT lived with his father in an apartment in Sacramento. From the preliminary testing done in June, Lindamood-Bell determined that STUDENT had some phonemic awareness, but had problems with letter combinations and symbol imagery. At Lindamood-Bell, STUDENT received four hours a day of an intensive, one-on-one program in the morning. In the afternoon, STUDENT received three hours of general education curriculum. At first, STUDENT’s morning program was “Seeing Stars,” a program designed to stimulate phonemic awareness at the visual level. During the fourth week, STUDENT began working with the “Visualizing-Verbalizing” program along with the “Seeing Stars.” STUDENT started working on the “Cloud 9 Math” program at about the ninth week. At the conclusion of STUDENT’s 13-week program, Lindamood-Bell did exit testing and issued a progress report. Lindamood-Bell concluded that STUDENT had made progress in word attack, word recognition, paragraph decoding, spelling, oral language comprehension, written expression and reading comprehension. It also concluded that STUDENT’s math skills had improved but were still significantly below grade level. However, Lindamood-Bell believed that STUDENT’s skills were not yet independent (he continued to need prompting to self-correct his errors) and therefore recommended an additional four to six weeks of intensive treatment. It was also recommended that STUDENT continue to work on reading and spelling daily with an adult who could monitor for accuracy and encourage STUDENT to self-correct using his new skills.
After STUDENT completed the Lindamood-Bell program, he returned to Chester, but did not re-enroll in public school. MOTHER home-schooled STUDENT, with the assistance of tutors, for the remainder of the school year. STUDENT was tutored for one to two hours a week in history, one hour in English, and one hour in science. During the same time, STUDENT’s sister was enrolled in the local charter school. MOTHER and the tutors used STUDENT’s sister’s text books (STUDENT’s sister and one other student participated in the tutoring sessions with STUDENT). On average, STUDENT received fours hours of home schooling each day. MOTHER found she had to change materials frequently to hold STUDENT’s interest and keep him on task. MOTHER testified that she did not contact the District immediately after STUDENT completed the Lindamood-Bell program because she was waiting for the Lindamood-Bell progress report and recommendations. MOTHER did not receive this report until May 2001.
In August 2001, the District developed an assessment plan for STUDENT. The plan called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of health and development, language, adaptive behavior/self help skills, academic achievement, and cognitive functioning. MOTHER signed the assessment plan on September 10, 2001. That same month, STUDENT started the ninth grade at Chester Junior-Senior High School. On September 13, 2001, Donna Pilgrim, the District speech/language pathologist, administered the Phonological Awareness Test (PAT) to determine STUDENT’s sound/symbol knowledge and his decoding skills. Results indicated that STUDENT was knowledgeable in sounds and sound changes at the phoneme and word level when information was presented auditorily or with auditory stimulation combined with manipulatives. However, STUDENT had trouble with decoding active graphemes, particularly in vowel digraphs and blends, short and long vowels, and some writing rules. Ms. Pilgrim testified that her testing indicated that STUDENT needed remediation of his skill deficits caused by to his phonological processing using simultaneous multi-sensory instruction. Ms. Deane administered the WJ-R on September 14, 2001. STUDENT scored at a grade equivalent of 8.8 in broad reading, 5.4 in broad math, and 3.7 in broad written language. No other assessments were performed.
An IEP team meeting was held on September 17, 2001, to formulate STUDENT’s program and services for the school year. It was noted that STUDENT was showing new maturity and self-confidence, as well as greater interest in his class work. The team concluded that STUDENT needed a reduced reading level algebra text and specific remediation in basic language arts skills. Goals and objectives were developed in broad written language (spelling), broad written language (California standards), broad math (basic skills), and broad math (California standards). Specific modifications and supports were described for science, geography, driver’s education, math and English. STUDENT was to receive 88 minutes of RSP services every day (440 minutes a week). Extended school year was also recommended to address remedial skills in math and language arts. Other than the vague statement “Mother reports family history of dyslexia,” this IEP did not identify STUDENT as having a phonological processing disorder. The only specific skill deficits identified were a “reading deficit” and a “deficit in basic skills.” At the beginning of the ninth grade, STUDENT was receiving only one period of RSP services (Footnote 9). The RSP class STUDENT was enrolled in was the study skills class, where students primarily receive supplemental support in their core courses. After the IEP team meeting, MOTHER’s attorney contacted Dr. Paula Gardner about reviewing STUDENT’s program and consulting with the District. Dr. Gardner reviewed some of STUDENT’s educational records, met with Ms. Deane, Ms. Pilgrim, Ms. Compton (STUDENT’s ninth grade English teacher), Mr. and MOTHER, and STUDENT. She also reviewed the September 17, 2001 IEP, the most recent assessment results, and STUDENT’s prior IEPs. Dr. Gardner concluded that the one period of study skills RSP support was not sufficient and recommended adding a period of intensive remedial RSP support. Dr. Gardner also recommended that STUDENT receive one and one-half hours of after-school tutoring, three times a week, in the areas of reading, written language, and mathematical computation. Dr. Gardner concluded that STUDENT had benefitted from the Lindamood-Bell program and recommended that the District incorporate the Lindamood-Bell instruction techniques into STUDENT’s RSP program. Dr. Gardner also concluded that the present levels of performance contained in the September 17, 2001 IEP were not specific or detailed enough to provide the IEP team with a starting point from which to develop goals and objectives. She also concluded that the goals and objectives were neither observable nor measurable, and did not provide STUDENT’s teachers with enough information to know what specialized instruction STUDENT required. Dr. Gardner also recommended that the District establish a specific support plan for STUDENT that would include a list of the specific supports and modifications to be provided in each class and regular meetings between the RSP teacher and the general education teachers to review STUDENT’s progress and recommend changes to his program as needed. Dr. Gardner made other specific recommendations that included allowing STUDENT to use a computer for writing assignments and the use of a daily planner to help STUDENT stay organized and keep up with his assignments.
In November 2001, STUDENT’s schedule was changed and an additional period of RSP replaced Spanish. During this additional RSP class, STUDENT received remediation in language arts in a small-group setting (STUDENT worked in a group with three other students). The language arts remediation program used, among other strategies, the Lindamood-Bell Seeing Stars flash cards and word lists and the Visualizing-Verbalizing program. STUDENT also worked on essay writing, writing mechanics, reading comprehension, vocabulary, and other basic language arts skills. STUDENT’s language arts program was directly supervised by Mr. Davies, an instructional aide, with oversight from the RSP teacher. During the study skills RSP class, STUDENT received assistance with basic math skills from Mr. Davies using the “Plato Math” computer program. At the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, Ms. Deane was the RSP teacher. Unfortunately, Ms. Deane began having health problems that increasingly interfered with her work. Ms. Deane missed three days in October, six days in November, one day in December, four days in January, sixteen days in February, all but two days of March, and all of the remainder of the year. In Ms. Deane’s absence, the District employed Ms. Szeker as a long-term substitute (Footnote 10). Ms. Szeker followed Ms. Deane’s lesson plans, which she found to be complete and well-organized, in administering STUDENT’s program. Ms. Szeker testified that each of the STUDENT’s general education teachers has a list of modifications and supports to utilize with STUDENT. Ms. Szeker stated that written expression and organizational skills are still the main problem areas for STUDENT.
Ms. Compton has been STUDENT’s English teacher during the 2001-2002 school year (Ms. Compton also had STUDENT in her class in the sixth grade). Ms. Compton testified that STUDENT has shown growth in his maturity and responsibility in the past year. STUDENT has become more of a self-starter and has taken more responsibility in getting in missing assignments. However, STUDENT still does not like to write. He still has trouble writing with any length or complexity, and continues to omit words and word endings. Both Ms. Szeker and Ms. Compton noted that STUDENT’s work is inconsistent. Both stated that STUDENT is able to display much better writing skills at times, usually when a subject of higher interest is involved. Ms. Szeker, Ms. Compton and Mr. Mahaffey (STUDENT’s algebra teacher) testified that STUDENT’s absences continue to be a problem. In the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT missed some additional time because he was on the golf team.
On April 16, 2002, MOTHER took STUDENT to Jennifer Hollibaugh, a speech/language pathologist and learning-disability specialist, for further assessment. Ms. Hollibaugh testified that she only had STUDENT for one three-hour session, so she focused her assessment on STUDENT’s reading and spelling abilities. Ms. Hollibaugh administered the CTOPP, the Decoding Skills Test (DST) the Test of Word Reading Efficiency (TOWRE), The Test of Written Expression (TOWE), and the Ayres-Buckingham Spelling Test. The results indicated that STUDENT was functioning significantly below grade level in all areas tested. Ms. Hollibaugh concluded that STUDENT had a specific learning disability in the areas of reading, decoding, sound-symbol association, spelling and written language skills. She recommended intensive remediation consisting of one 45-minute session daily of one-on-one tutoring utilizing methodologies such as the Orton-Gillingham or Slingerland programs for decoding skills and the Wilson Reading Program for reading comprehension.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability? The law requires the school district to assess students in all areas of suspected disability including, when appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, interests, and social emotional status. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. The purpose of assessment is not only to determine an "eligibility" category, but to determine the unique needs of the student. The 1997 amendments to the IDEA clarify that the assessment tools and strategies used must provide relevant information that will directly aid in the determination of the educational needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(D). However, this is not a new requirement. The California Education Code has consistently required that assessments be geared to providing information relevant for the development of appropriate, individual programming for the student. See, e.g., Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320 (e) and 56321 (a). Therefore, an assessment must not only identify a qualifying disability (here, a Learning Disability), but must also assist the team in identifying the student's unique educational needs.
Petitioner contends that the District failed to assess STUDENT in relation to his dyslexia (phonological processing), and that due to this failure the District incorrectly identified STUDENT as having processing disorders in the areas of cognitive functioning and attention. As set forth earlier, dyslexia is characterized by difficulties in single word decoding, usually reflecting insufficient phonological processing abilities. Dyslexia is manifested by difficulty with different forms of language, including problems reading and significant problems with writing and spelling. To properly determine whether a student has dyslexia, the student’s phonological processing must be specifically assessed.
The District was in possession of a substantial amount of evidence that pointed to STUDENT having a phonological processing disorder. A student study team (SST) meeting was held on September 12, 1996, which resulted in STUDENT’s referral for assessment. In the notes from this meeting, there are several notations that indicate possible dyslexia: the note “sensitive ears”; the note “dad-dyslexia?”; and a reference to difficulty decoding. An assessment plan was drawn up that called for assessments only in the areas of academic achievement and intellectual functioning. (Student Exhibit Page 147) Ms. Spicer and her mentor, Ms. Howe, administered the WJ-R to STUDENT. A review of the passage comprehension section of the protocols for this test reveals the notation “dyslexic? - probably.” (Student Exhibit Page 292) Ms. Spicer testified that this was Ms. Howe’s notation. Mr. Huitt, the school psychologist, drafted the psychoeducational evaluation that incorporates the results of Ms. Spicer’s testing. Despite the SST team notes, and the notation in the WJ-R protocols, there is no mention in Mr. Huitt’s report of the possibility of dyslexia or a phonological processing disorder. (Student Exhibit Pages 131-138) According to Ms. Spicer, Mr. Huitt’s report does note numerous factors that are consistent with a phonological processing disorder, for example, “sensitive hearing,” the presence of an auditory processing disorder, STUDENT’s poor written language skills, problems with decoding and reading comprehension, and below average letter-word identification.
In June 1997, STUDENT was assessed by Kristine Wilson, a private speech/language pathologist. (Student Exhibit Pages 30-31) Her report noted that STUDENT had a great deal of difficulty manipulating sounds and changing their order and recommended that STUDENT work on tasks designed to increase his phonological awareness. In November 1997, in preparation for STUDENT’s annual IEP, Ms. Spicer did additional informal testing in the areas of reading and writing. (Student Exhibit Page 39) Despite the existing evidence of a phonological processing disorder, she did no testing that would have assessed STUDENT’s phonological processing.
In summary, the SST report, the indications in the protocols of the September 1996 WJ-R, the numerous assessment findings that were consistent with a phonological processing disorder, and the results of the evaluation of Kristine Wilson establish that the District was, or should have been, aware that an impairment in the area of phonological processing was the probable cause of the significant discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and his achievement and should have conducted further assessments to inquire into this suspected area of need. Therefore, as of November 1997 (the earliest time relevant to this Decision), the Hearing Officer finds that the District had not assessed STUDENT’s educational needs in all areas of suspected disability. Specifically, the District should have assessed STUDENT’s phonological processing.
In February 1998, during STUDENT’s fifth grade year, MOTHER had STUDENT tested at the Sylvan Learning Center because she was concerned with his lack of progress. Additional informal testing was done by Ms. Spicer in March 1998. STUDENT demonstrated significant problems working with phonemes, and his overall performance on the measures taken indicated his reading performance was significantly below average. After this testing, MOTHER met with Ms. Spicer and Mr. Jolly to discuss STUDENT’s performance. It was agreed that additional formal testing would be conducted. On April 1, 1998, Mrs. Spicer again administered the WJ-R. The assessment rendered grade equivalencies and no indication of the causes of the delayed performance. There was no follow-up assessment on STUDENT’s difficulty with phonemes, as indicated by Ms. Spicer’s informal testing. Though attendance, staying on task and organizational skills were of concern, no attempt was made to assess these areas of concern. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District continued in its failure to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and educational needs.
At the beginning of STUDENT’s seventh grade year (1999/2000), STUDENT's triennial assessment was due. By this time, the IDEA 97 amendments and the applicable regulations were in effect. These amendments, and the governing regulations, require that districts conduct, prior to any reassessment, a data review to decide if further assessment is necessary to determine continuing eligibility, the student's present levels of performance, and the educational needs of the student. (34 CFR § 300.533) There is no evidence that such a data review was conducted.
In November 1999, an assessment was conducted in the areas of health, development, academic achievement and cognitive functioning. As in 1996, STUDENT was administered the WISC-III and the WJ-R. STUDENT was also given the TAPS to assess his auditory processing. Again, no testing was done specific to a phonological processing disorder. The results of the WJ-R showed that STUDENT was below grade level in broad reading, broad math, and significantly below grade level in broad written language. However, Ms. Roberts, the school psychologist, did not find evidence of an auditory processing disorder, and concluded that STUDENT’s problems in academic achievement might have been attributable to his attendance problems. On the basis of this testing, Ms. Roberts recommended that the IEP team consider placing STUDENT on a “watch and consult” status for the first part of the school year. At the IEP team meeting, MOTHER again raised the issue of the dyslexia of STUDENT’s father. Ms. Roberts concluded that it was appropriate to assess STUDENT for a possible phonological processing disorder. The amended assessment plan was signed by MOTHER on December 14, 1999. On January 11, 2000, Ms. Roberts, as noted above, did some further testing (the Border Test of Reading-Spelling Patterns and the Ekwal/Shanker Reading Inventory.) Based upon the results of these tests, she concluded that STUDENT demonstrated reading and spelling patterns characteristic of dyslexia. She recommended further "informal" assessments, none of which were ever performed. Ms. Robert's report was inexplicably not completed until May 2000, well beyond the required time line for assessments (once the District has developed an assessment plan and obtained the parents’ consent, the District must conduct the assessments, prepare a written report or reports of the results of the assessment, and convene an IEP team meeting within 50 days [Cal. Educ. Code § 56321, 56327, 56344]), making it of little value for planning for the 1999-2000 school year. In addition, even though the record reveals continuing concerns about STUDENT’s ability to stay on task, his attendance and organizational skills, these areas of need were not addressed in any assessment. The Hearing Office concludes that the 1999-2000 triennial assessment was procedurally and substantively defective.
In May 2001, Lindamood-Bell issued an extensive progress report showing pre- and post-treatment test results, detailing STUDENT’s progress in each area tested, and giving recommendations for ongoing treatment and support. In August 2001, the District developed a new assessment plan, which MOTHER signed on September 10, 2001. This plan called for STUDENT to be assessed in the areas of health and development, language, adaptive behavior/self help skills, academic achievement, and cognitive functioning. (District Exhibit Page 113)
On September 13, 2001, Ms. Pilgrim, the District speech/language pathologist, administered the Phonological Awareness Test (PAT). Ms. Deane administered the WJ-R on September 14, 2001. No other testing was performed. There was no evidence presented as to why the additional testing was never performed. Only Ms. Pilgrim prepared a written report setting forth the results of her testing.
The District did not conduct all of the assessments agreed to and did not prepare written reports for all of the assessments that were completed, as required by law (Cal. Ed. Code § 56321, 56327, 56344.) These failures by the District deprived STUDENT’s parents, and the IEP team, of information needed to develop an appropriate IEP. The Hearing Office concludes that the District’s assessments in September 2001 were also procedurally and substantively defective.
The District had numerous opportunities to fully assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability to determine all of his educational needs. Failing to do so had a serious affect on the District's ability to develop an appropriate program for STUDENT from November 1997 through the 2001-2002 school year, as will be more fully discussed below.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year, including the 1998 extended school year?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities have the right to a FAPE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) FAPE consists of special education and related services that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to the parents, that is provided to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. ) “Related services” means transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services as may be required to assist the child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(a).)
The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether the proposed program was substantively appropriate and whether appropriate procedural steps were followed. (Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).
The standard for determining whether the District substantively offered STUDENT a FAPE involves the following three factors: whether the program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs; whether the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit; and whether the program conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).)
In Rowley, the Supreme Court decided the appropriate level of instruction and services that must be provided to students with disabilities in order to satisfy the IDEA. The Court held that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student's potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.)
In relation to the 1997-1998 school year, Petitioner’s primary contentions are that the District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs due to its failure to properly assess, failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to provide services adequate to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
The November 5, 1997 IEP
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
It has already been determined that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT in the area of phonological processing as of November 1997. Without a proper assessment in this area, it was virtually impossible for the District to accurately identify STUDENT’s unique needs. In this case, the November 15, 1997 IEP identifies STUDENT as having needs in the areas of reading, spelling, writing, impulsivity, and organizational skills. However, the IEP does not describe the kinds of errors STUDENT was making in the areas of reading, spelling, and writing, or in any way indicate that STUDENT’s difficulty in these areas were the result on impaired phonological processing.
Later testing revealed that STUDENT’s core need was, and is, in the area of phonological processing. STUDENT’s impairment in this area was the underlying cause of his demonstrated difficulties in reading, spelling and writing. STUDENT’s impaired phonological processing resulted in problems syllabicating words, omissions of suffixes, omissions of small words, and whole word substitutions. He was unable to use decoding skills to figure out nonphonetic words and his reading rate was very slow. When writing, he demonstrated a pattern of letter-order errors, letter omissions, and whole word substitutions. When reading, STUDENT relied excessively on context for word recognition. (See Cathleen Roberts’ report dated May 24, 2000, District Exhibit Pages 54-55) Impaired phonological processing, typified by the errors listed above, was STUDENT’s primary area of need that should have been identified in this IEP. STUDENT also had needs in the areas of off-task behavior and organizational skills (which were identified in the IEP). Another area of need not mentioned in the November 1997 IEP was attendance. Mr. Huitt’s 1996 evaluation noted that STUDENT’s attendance was fair to poor. Ms. Spicer testified that STUDENT’s attendance problems during the fourth grade impacted his progress. If, as testimony indicates, attendance was an ongoing problem with STUDENT that affected his progress, the IEP team should have listed it as an area of need and developed goals and objectives to address this need.
STUDENT’s Goals and Objectives
An IEP must contain, among other things, the following:
(1) The present levels of the pupil's educational performance. (2) The annual goals, including short-term instructional objectives. (3) The specific special educational instruction and related services required by the pupil. (4) The extent to which the pupil will be able to participate in regular educational programs.(5) The projected date for initiation and the anticipated duration of the programs and services included in the individualized education program. (6) Appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining, on at least an annual basis, whether the short-term instructional objectives are being achieved. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345)
California regulations require that the IEP be written so as to "show a direct relationship between the present levels of performance, the goals and objectives, and the specific educational services to be provided." Title 5, Cal. Code Reg. § 3040. In other words, a completed IEP must not be just a series of separate, unrelated statements, instead it must demonstrate a logical relationship between needs (present levels of performance), goals and objectives, and services to be provided. Although it is certainly not necessary to repeat all of the information from assessments and other sources in the IEP document, the purpose of the above regulation is to ensure that the user of the document can understand from its contents the needs of the student in relation to the type of instruction the student must receive to address those needs.
In this case, the November 1997 IEP identifies the following present levels of performance in relation to STUDENT’s academic skills:
Reading - 62 WRC 5th gr. 5/5 comprehension Spelling - 350/500 80% Writing - 75% simple sentences
Goals were written in the areas of written expression, spelling, reading comprehension and organizational skills. The goal for written expression states, “STUDENT will demonstrate ability to write complex and compound sentences with correct spelling, punctuation, syntax with 80% accuracy.” Nowhere in the IEP was there any mention of a phonological processing disorder as the cause of STUDENT’s writing deficiencies. The spelling goal simply states, “STUDENT will correctly spell 400/500 words from functional word list.” Again there was no indication as to why STUDENT was having trouble with spelling or what kinds of errors he was making. Similarly, the goal in reading comprehension did not identify the cause of STUDENT’s difficulties in that area. The special education services were merely listed as RSP pull out for 3 hours a week.
As indicated above, the District had erroneously, through an incomplete assessment, identified the source of STUDENT’s problem as attention and cognitive abilities. Thus, even assuming that the IEP, read together with the District’s assessment, met the requirements of section 3040 of the California regulations, an educator presumably would have read the document to require instructional strategies that would have addressed STUDENT’s cognitive delays and attention difficulties, rather than his phonological processing disorder. Because the assessment failed to identify STUDENT's educational need in phonological processing, the IEP could not possibly target that need and the intent of section 3040 could not possibly have been met.
The IEP also identified impulsivity (which appears to refer to STUDENT’s documented problems with off-task behavior) and organizational skills as areas of need. Although there was a goal to address STUDENT’s organizational skills, there was no goal to address STUDENT’s problems with off-task behavior (Footnote 11). Nor does the IEP identify the "special education to be provided" to address STUDENT’s needs other than the statement that the RSP teacher would provide support for written expression and study skill support.
The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s IEP was both procedurally and substantively inadequate and not designed to address his unique needs.
The Program Provided by the District
The District argues that, despite any deficiencies in the written IEP document, the services provided did address STUDENT’s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. However, the evidence shows that the program offered and provided was not adequate to address STUDENT’s needs in the area of phonological processing. Ms. Spicer testified, in some detail, that to remediate skill deficits caused by a phonological processing disorder, it is necessary to use multi-sensory, multi-modal teaching techniques. Furthermore, instruction must be intensive, daily and systematic. Ms. Spicer stated that, ideally, STUDENT should have received two and one-half hours of this kind of instruction each day. At a minimum, STUDENT needed 90 minutes a day to remediate his particular skill deficits. The November 1997 IEP provided for, at best, only 45 minutes a day of RSP services (Footnote 12). In fact, STUDENT received less than 45 minutes a day of RSP, and little of it was provided in a systematic manner. Ms. Spicer testified that during the 1997-1998 school year, the services that were provided to STUDENT were either push-in or pull-out. On some days, STUDENT received neither push-in nor pull-out services. Ms. Spicer explained that STUDENT did not like to be pulled out of the general education class, and so he was allowed to choose the kinds of services he received. She said that if STUDENT felt he needed more support, he could go to the RSP room for pull-out services.
Federal regulations state that although the Act does not require that any agency, teacher, or other person be held accountable if the student does not achieve the growth projected in the IEP, the special education must be provided in accordance with the IEP. Not only was the level of services inadequate to meet STUDENT’s needs in the area of phonological processing, it was a violation of law to permit STUDENT to determine the nature and intensity of his special education services. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that implementation of the IEP was both substantively and procedurally deficient.
STUDENT’s Progress
The District also argues that, despite all of the above, STUDENT did make progress. Although STUDENT did obtain passing grades (though some of those grades were modified as part of his IEP) and did advance from grade to grade, the evidence establishes that STUDENT did not make meaningful progress in relation to his primary area of need: his phonological processing disorder. First, it should be noted that, because the District did not identify STUDENT as having an impairment in the area of phonological processing until May 2000, there is no specific testing of his phonological abilities to compare. However, the results of the other academic testing offers some useful information. STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder, although affecting his oral reading and reading comprehension, was most clearly manifested in his written language. On testing in 1996, STUDENT’s score on the WJ-R in broad written language was at a grade equivalent of 1.6. STUDENT was then entering the fourth grade, so STUDENT’s writing skills were roughly 2.4 grade levels behind those of his peers. On testing in 1999, STUDENT’s score on the WJ-R in broad written language was at a grade equivalent of 3.2. STUDENT was then entering the seventh grade. By November 1999, STUDENT’s writing skills were 3.8 grade levels behind his peers. STUDENT was losing ground. Furthermore, a review of the protocols indicates that in 1999 STUDENT was still making the same basic kinds of errors that he had been making in 1996 (e.g.: omissions of suffixes, letter-order errors, and whole word substitutions) (Footnote 13). This evidence establishes that STUDENT was not making meaningful progress in relation to his primary area of need.
The June 1, 1998 IEP Addendum.
This addendum added ESY services to STUDENT’s program. The IEP stated that STUDENT would attend a regular District summer school program with an individualized reading program to be organized by the RSP teacher. Unfortunately, the District was unable to present any substantial evidence to establish that STUDENT actually received the program called for in this IEP.
Conclusion
As a result of its continued failure to properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, the November 5, 1997 IEP failed to identify STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder as the cause of his deficits in reading, spelling and writing. The IEP team also failed to draft goals and objectives that were adequate to address STUDENT’s needs in these areas. In addition, there was no goal to address STUDENT’s off-task behavior and no goal to address the attendance issue.
On the basis of Ms. Spicer’s testimony, the level of services provided to STUDENT during the 1997-1998 school year were not adequate to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. Furthermore, STUDENT was allowed to vary the level and kinds of services he received at his own discretion, contrary to the specifications of the IEP.
As a result of the above failings, STUDENT did not make meaningful progress in relation to his primary educational need. STUDENT’s impairment in the area of phonological processing was the underlying cause for his problems in spelling, writing and reading comprehension. Without proper services to address his phonological processing, STUDENT would not, and did not, make meaningful progress in relation to his skill deficits. Finally, ESY services were recommended in the June 1, 1998 IEP addendum, but the District failed to submit any evidence that the recommended services were provided.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year, including the 1998 extended school year.
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
Petitioner’s contentions regarding the 1998-1999 school year are the same as for the 1997-1998 school year: The District failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs due to its failure to properly assess, failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to provide services adequate to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
STUDENT’s unique needs continued to be the same as in the prior year: impaired phonological processing resulting in problems syllabicating words, omissions of suffixes and whole words when writing, whole word substitutions when reading, impaired decoding skills, slow reading rate and impaired reading comprehension. STUDENT also had needs in the areas of off-task behavior, organizational skills, and attendance. Despite additional testing (an assessment by the Sylvan Learning Center and informal testing by Ms. Spicer), the District’s failure to properly assess these areas continued.
For the first four months of the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT continued to receive a combination of push-in, pull-out, and consultation services, largely at his discretion. STUDENT’s annual IEP team meeting for the 1998-1999 school year was held on January 27, 1999. (District Exhibit Page 30-33) The IEP identified reading, spelling and writing as areas of need. It is also noted that STUDENT continued to need organizational skill support and help with follow through on assignments. As in the previous year, the IEP does not identify a phonological processing disorder as the underlying cause of STUDENT’s difficulties in reading, spelling and writing. There is no mention that comprehension continued to be a problem despite the fact that STUDENT scored below average when tested by Ms. Spicer in 1998 (60% accuracy on a fifth grade passage). (District Exhibit Page 29) Again, there was testimony that attendance continued to be a problem during the fifth grade (STUDENT missed 18 days that year), and yet attendance problems were not mentioned in the IEP. STUDENT’s Goals and Objectives
The January 1999 IEP contained only one goal, in the area of written language. There was no goal addressing STUDENT’s other identified educational needs, and no goal designed to address his impaired phonological processing. The previous goals in the areas of spelling, reading comprehension, and organizational skills were all dropped, despite the lack of evidence that STUDENT had achieved any of the goals in those areas. In fact, the evidence indicates that STUDENT continued to have problems in all of those areas. According to Ms. Spicer’s testing, STUDENT was only spelling at the third grade level in March 1998 and he continued to have deficiencies in the area of reading comprehension. STUDENT’s sixth grade teachers both testified that STUDENT continued to have problems with his organizational skills throughout the 1998-1999 school year. Ms. Compton, one of STUDENT’s teachers that year, also testified that STUDENT had significant problems remaining on task. As in the previous year, there was no goal relating to STUDENT’s attendance problems.
The Program the District Provided
Because STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder had gone unaddressed in the previous year, STUDENT continued to need 90 minutes a day of intensive, systematic, multi-sensory, multi-modal instruction. STUDENT did receive some remediation in the area of phonological processing. In his general education class, STUDENT received instruction using the Formula Phonics program (this was a school-wide program that year). STUDENT also received instruction from Ms. Spicer using a computer program designed to teach phonological awareness. However, as in the previous year, the level of services offered was not adequate. In fact, the level of RSP support was reduced to only 30 minutes a day.
ESY services were not offered in this IEP. ESY is required when the evidence indicates that serious regression occurs over the summer. Hoeft v. Tucson Unified Sch. Dist., 967 F.3d 1298, 1301 (9th Cir. 1992). There was mention at the SST meeting in 1996 that STUDENT had difficulty retaining information over the summer. However, neither Ms. Spicer nor any of STUDENT’s teachers indicated that this was an ongoing problem in the 1998-1999 school year. Based upon the evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require ESY services to prevent regression during the summer of 1999.
STUDENT’s Progress
As in the previous year, there is no evidence that STUDENT made any meaningful progress in relation to his primary area of need: his skill deficits that resulted from his phonological processing disorder. As set forth earlier in this decision, the WJ-R testing showed that STUDENT made only minimal progress on his writing skills between 1996 and 1999. In addition, STUDENT continued to have organizational problems, problems with off-task behavior, and problems with attendance that were not addressed in any way by his program.
Conclusion
The District’s failure to assess STUDENT’s educational needs in relation to his phonological processing disorder continued. Because of this failure, the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In addition, the District failed to draft goals to address most of the areas of need that were identified in the IEP (reading, spelling and organizational skills.) Furthermore, the previous year’s goals to address reading comprehension, spelling and organizational skills were discontinued, despite the fact that there was no evidence that STUDENT had achieved any of the goals in those areas. Finally, the level or services provided was inadequate to properly address STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder. Once again, the programming was inconsistently delivered and not in accordance with the specifications of the IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year.
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year?
The 1999-2000 school year was STUDENT’s first year at Chester Junior-Senior High School. At the start of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s program was still governed by the January 1999 IEP. However, there is conflicting evidence in relation to what services were actually being provided. Although Ms. Roberts stated that STUDENT was not receiving any special education services at the start of the year, Ms. Deane’s chronology indicated that STUDENT was receiving one period of RSP class during the first part of the year.
The December 14, 1999 IEP
The December 1999 IEP was STUDENT’s triennial IEP. As indicated above, the assessment performed by the District was inadequate to identify STUDENT’s educational needs. At the IEP team meeting, MOTHER again raised the issue of STUDENT’s father’s dyslexia. Ms. Roberts concluded that it was appropriate to assess STUDENT for a possible phonological processing disorder. This was the only conclusion reached by the IEP team. No present levels of performance were set out, no areas of need identified, and no goals and objectives developed.
The June 2, 2000 IEP
The June 2000 IEP (held over five months after Ms. Roberts completed her additional testing), like the December 1999 IEP, contains no present levels of performance and no goals and objectives. The IEP does state that STUDENT had “some dyslexia” and lists numerous needs in relation to STUDENT’s impaired phonological processing. It states that STUDENT needed to learn to break words down into syllables, to generalize sounds to new words, to develop strategies to decode nonphonetic words, and to learn sequencing strategies. No needs were noted in relation to organizational skills, off-task behavior, and attendance. It was noted that STUDENT’s reading and listening comprehension were strong.
Conclusion
In past years, the District had attempted to identify STUDENT’s educational needs and draft goals and objectives, although with marked deficiencies. However, for the 1999-2000 school year, both IEPs drafted contained a statement of services and little else. STUDENT’s unique educational needs were not fully identified, and there were no present levels of performance and no goals and objectives. All of these are required components to any IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A).) For the entire 1999-2000 school year, the District failed to develop an IEP that met the requirements of the law. The IEPs would not have provided any guidance to an educator as to what STUDENT’s needs were or what goals they were supposed to be working toward. Furthermore, there were no criteria to measure progress and no mention of the instructional strategies that were essential to addressing STUDENT’s unique educational needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s IEPs for the 1999-2000 school year were so deficient in the required elements that they constituted a denial of a FAPE for that school year ( See Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982).)
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
In relation to the 2000-2001 school year, Petitioner’s primary contentions are that the District failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives and to offer services adequate to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
It must be noted that by this year all of the IDEA '97 amendments were in effect. Pursuant to the regulations, “Special education” includes “specially-designed instruction,” which means “adapting, as appropriate to the needs of an eligible child...the content, methodology, or delivery of instruction...(i) To address the unique needs of the child that result from the child's disability..." 34 CFR § 300.26 (a) (3). The discussion of this regulation (Fed Reg/Vol 64, No. 48, March 12, 1999, p. 12552) indicates that while an IEP need not be overly prescriptive in terms of methods of delivering instruction,
[i]t is clear that in developing an IEP there are circumstances in which a particular teaching methodology that will be used is an integral part of what is “individualized” about a student's education, and will need to be discussed at the IEP meeting and incorporated into the student's IEP. For example, for a child with a learning disability who has not learned to read using traditional instructional methods, an appropriate education may require some other instructional strategy.
The August 28, 2000 IEP
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
Because of the District’s failure to properly address STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder, STUDENT’s needs remained the same as in previous years: impaired phonological processing resulting in problems syllabicating words, omissions of suffixes and whole words when writing, whole word substitutions when reading, impaired decoding skills, slow reading rate and impaired reading comprehension. STUDENT also had needs in the areas of off-task behavior, organizational skills, and attendance.
In June 2000, MOTHER took STUDENT to the Lindamood-Bell Learning Center in Sacramento for an assessment. Lindamood-Bell administered a wide range of assessments to STUDENT, including the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test, Revised, the Slossan Oral Reading Test, Revised, the WRAT-3, the GORT-3, the LAC, the Symbol Imagery Test, the TOWL-3, and the CTOPP. MOTHER then presented these test results to the District and requested an IEP meeting. The IEP meeting was held on August 28, 2000. The District did no additional testing in preparation for this meeting.
The IEP states that MOTHER wanted STUDENT’s program to emphasize reading, writing, spelling and math with the use of phonics and manipulatives. The IEP goes on to detail STUDENT’s areas of weakness as follows:
Reading, spelling, writing and math. Slow processing, reading deficit, makes it difficult for STUDENT to understand and complete assignments however, he has good coping skills and with modifications does well. Writing and spelling make it difficult to complete assignments. Slow processing affects comprehension. (District Exhibit Page 79)
The above statement of weaknesses identifies STUDENT’s underlying processing disorder as “slow processing.” There is no mention of the results of the phonological processing screening the District had performed in January 2000, or the results of the Lindamood-Bell assessment, both of which supported the conclusion that STUDENT’s fundamental impairment was a phonological processing disorder. However, there is reference in the IEP to an attached chronology. This appears to refer to the chronology prepared by Ms. Deane on August 27, 2000. (District Exhibit Pages 69-72) MOTHER recalls receiving a copy of the chronology, but is not certain when she received it. As noted earlier in this Decision, Ms. Deane passed away on May 1, 2002. If the chronology was attached to the IEP, it added considerable detail to the identification of STUDENT’s educational needs. The chronology reviews the results of Ms. Roberts’ screening in January 2000 and Ms. Roberts’ conclusions and recommendations. The chronology also reviews the results of the Lindamood-Bell testing. The report details STUDENT’s problems with organizational skills, staying on task, and attendance.
Read together, the IEP and the chronology successfully identified all of STUDENT’s unique needs. The only new area of need was in basic math skills (Footnote 14). Unfortunately, the IEP did not carry forward all of STUDENT’s areas of educational need into the goals and objectives. The IEP lists the following as areas of need to be addressed by the goals and objectives:
STUDENT needs a comprehensive program of broad written language and reading. This should include phonetics, spelling rules, vocabulary expansion and writing skills as regards sentence structure, paragraph structure and essay formats. He needs a comprehensive reading program which will include strategies for comprehension and word recognition. STUDENT is also somewhat low in math skills which need to be reinforced. (District Exhibit Page 82).
Although this statement sets forth some of STUDENT’s areas of need, it still fails to identify STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder as the underlying cause of his deficits in reading, written language, and math. Nowhere does the IEP recognize that in order for STUDENT to overcome his learning deficits, specific instructional strategies (i.e., the use of multi-sensory, multi-modal instruction) must be used.
STUDENT’s goals and objectives
The statement of areas of need set forth above translated into just two goals, one in broad written language and one in reading. The written language goal called for STUDENT to pass a comprehensive spelling test to include spelling rules and the use of basic spelling strategies at a grade equivalent of 4.5. It also called for STUDENT to write a five-part essay with a thesis, introduction, body and supporting detail with 90% accuracy at a grade equivalent of 4.5. The baseline is listed as a grade equivalent of 3.2 on the WJ-R. First and foremost, this goal fails to identify STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder as the underlying cause of STUDENT’s difficulty in written language. Second, the baseline is inaccurate. The baseline is taken from a WJ-R administered at the beginning of the previous school year.
The reading goal required STUDENT to complete a program of phonics review and reading strategies addressing deficit areas and completing the Wingate Reading Program to level 6.0. The baseline for this goal is “WJ-R 4.8.” This goal refers to “addressing deficit areas,” but does not identify phonological processing as the primary cause of STUDENT’s deficits. As in the previous goal, the baseline provided is inaccurate.
The two goals as drafted, while broadly addressing some of STUDENT’s areas of need, continue to ignore STUDENT’s primary need of appropriate services to address his phonological processing disorder. From reading the goals and objectives, an educator would be unaware of STUDENT’s core educational need, and have little guidance as to what particular “deficit areas” were to be addressed. Furthermore, there is no way to judge progress because there are no usable baselines provided. In addition, the IEP does not contain goals to address all of STUDENT’s areas of need. While the IEP identifies math skills, organizational skills, and off-task behavior as problem areas, no goals were drafted in these areas.
The September, 11, 2000 IEP.
The August 28 IEP meeting ended without any resolution. The PARENTS made it clear that they were considering placing STUDENT with a private provider (Lindamood-Bell), but wanted to consider the District’s offer. Shortly after the August IEP meeting, the PARENTS contacted the District and informed them that they were placing STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell in Sacramento. The District then convened a second IEP meeting on September 11. The PARENTS were not able to attend this IEP. The purpose of the IEP meeting, according to the notes, was to confirm that the IEP team believed that placement at Chester Junior-Senior High School with 90 minutes a day of resource services, implementing the goals and objectives drafted at the August 28, 2000 IEP meeting, was an appropriate offer of services. The team confirmed also that it disagreed with the PARENTS’ decision to place STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell.
Conclusion
From the August and September 2000 IEPs, it is unclear what instruction, if any, was directed at STUDENT's phonological processing disorder. In fact, STUDENT’s primary impairment, his phonological processing disorder continued to be largely unaddressed. The two goals that were drafted were both overly broad, identifying only broad areas of need without identifying STUDENT’s specific educational needs. In addition, the only instructional strategies identified were a program of phonics review and use of the Wingate Reading Program. This fell far short of the intensive multi-sensory, multi-modal instruction recommended by Ms. Spicer. Although this IEP called for a dramatic increase in the level of services (90 minutes a day of RSP support), without appropriate goals and objectives, and without the identification of the appropriate instructional strategies, the program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer contained in the August 28, 2000 and September 11, 2000 IEPs was not an offer of a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year.
6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
Petitioner contends that the District again failed to assess STUDENT’s educational needs in all areas of suspected disability, failed to identify STUDENT’s unique needs, failed to draft appropriate goals and objectives, and failed to provide a program designed to meet STUDENT’s educational needs.
STUDENT’s Unique Needs
Although, as set forth under Issue 1, the District’s assessment was seriously deficient, STUDENT had received a comprehensive independent assessment from Lindamood-Bell. Based upon the exit testing done by Lindamood-Bell, STUDENT continued to have needs in the areas of phonemic awareness/decoding skills, spelling, word recognition, passage decoding, and math computation skills (Footnote 15). The WJ-R indicated that STUDENT was still well below grade level in written language, specifically writing fluency, and punctuation and capitalization. STUDENT also continued to have problems with off-task behavior, poor organization skills, and poor attendance.
The IEP failed to identify all of these needs. It does note that STUDENT was significantly below grade level in broad math (WJ-R grade equivalent of 5.4), math calculation (WJ-R grade equivalent of 5.0), and applied problems (WJ-R grade equivalent of 6.3). Also noted are problems in written language with grammatical and mechanical errors and problems in organization. The IEP states also that STUDENT had a “reading deficit.” However, in answer to the question “How disability affects involvement and progress in general curriculum...” is the statement “Deficit in basic skills will require specific remediation.” Once again, the IEP failed to identify STUDENT’s primary area of need, his phonological processing disorder, or any instructional strategies necessary to meet that need.
STUDENT’s Goals and Objectives
The IEP team drafted goals and objectives in the areas of spelling, language arts, basic math skills, and math standards. The spelling goal calls for STUDENT to master 500 new words from the Dolch and Lindamood-Bell list. The goal also contains the statement “WJ-R 3.7 spelling list including basic spelling rules and phonological rules indicated from baseline.” The meaning of this sentence is unclear, especially since no baseline is indicated. In fact, there is no way for an educator looking at this goal to know what words STUDENT currently knew, much less what strategies to use to implement the goal. There is no indication that STUDENT’s difficulties in spelling were the result of his phonological processing disorder.
The language arts goal requires STUDENT to master 100% of the California Language Arts standards at 70% accuracy and at least a grade equivalent of 4.7 as measured by the WJ-R and class performance. First, this goal is internally inconsistent. Ms. Szeker, STUDENT’s current resource teacher, testified that if STUDENT were only functioning at a grade equivalent of 4.7 as measured by the WJ-R, there is no way he would be able to master the ninth grade language arts standards to 70% accuracy. Second, this goal is so broad as to be unmanageable. There are approximately 53 separate standards contained in the ninth grade California Language Arts Standards. (Student Exhibit Page 502) These standards range from knowledge of Norse mythology to a student’s ability to deliver a polished, formal presentation. A single goal covering such a broad area of knowledge is neither observable nor measurable. In addition, this goal, like the spelling goal, ignores the fact that STUDENT’s problems in language arts are all the result of his phonological processing disorder and offers no guidance as to what strategies should be used to implement the goal.
The math skills goal requires STUDENT to complete the Basic Math skills in areas of addition, subtraction, fractions, decimals, comparison, multiplication and fundamental math as indicated by Plato assessments. Testimony established that “Plato” is a computer math program used in the resource room. Although this goal appears to be a reasonably well-defined goal, there is no starting point. The baseline lists a WJ-R grade equivalent. This tells an educator nothing about where STUDENT was then functioning on the Plato assessments. While this goal may be realistic and obtainable, it is not measurable because there is no meaningful starting point from which to measure progress.
The final goal requires STUDENT to master 100% of the math standards with 70% accuracy as measured by classroom performance and tests and to raise his grade equivalent to 6.4 or better as measured by the WJ-R. The baseline is given as a grade equivalent of 5.4 on the WJ-R. The deficiencies listed in relation to the language arts goal are equally applicable to this goal.
The transition plan contained in the IEP lists STUDENT’s problems with attendance, time management, and task completion as areas in which STUDENT needed assistance (Footnote 16). Unfortunately, there are no services listed in the transition plan to address these needs, and no goals and objectives drafted in these areas. Based upon STUDENT’s history, the testimony of STUDENT’s teachers, and the IEP itself, attendance, time management and task completion were areas of need for STUDENT that needed to be addressed, either by services provided as part of the transition plan or specific goals and objectives.
This IEP did not contain goals to address all of STUDENT’s educational needs, and the goals it did contain did not specifically address STUDENT’s primary need: his phonological processing disorder. Other than the math calculation goal, there were no specific instructional strategies identified to implement the goals.
STUDENT’s Program
At the hearing, there was no real disagreement regarding what STUDENT’s needs were during the 2001-2002 school year. Those needs are set forth above. The central dispute at the hearing revolved around the type and the intensity of the program required. Lindamood-Bell recommended an additional six weeks of intensive treatment at a Lindamood-Bell center. Dr. Gardner, after reviewing the testing and the District program, and meeting with STUDENT, MOTHER and District staff, concluded that STUDENT needed one and one-half hours of intensive remediation, three days a week. This was in addition to the RSP support for his core curriculum classes. Dr. Gardner suggested utilizing Lindamood-Bell techniques for this remediation because she believed STUDENT had been successful in the Lindamood-Bell program. She emphasized the need to have properly trained personnel implementing the program.
Ms. Spicer, STUDENT’s former RSP teacher, testified extensively about teaching methodologies to remediate skill deficits resulting from a phonological processing disorder in general, and STUDENT’s deficits in particular. She stated that phonological processing is a fundamental part of a student learning to read and write. Testing has shown that it is much easier to teach these concepts to a student early on, such as in the first and second grades. The older a student gets, the more time it takes to teach these skills. Ms. Spicer stated that studies have shown that these skills are best taught using multi-modal, multi-sensory instruction in a systematic, repetitive manner. Ms. Spicer stated that there were a number of programs that fit this model, including the Slingerland, Orton-Gillingham and Lindamood-Bell programs. Ms. Spicer also stated that each program has its own strengths and weaknesses and the best program is one the combines various methodologies to address a student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds this testimony very persuasive.
The Hearing Office concludes that to properly address STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder, STUDENT needed a program that consisted of one and one-half hours, every-other day, of one-on-one multi-modal, multi-sensory instruction provided in a systematic, repetitive manner. This program should have utilized either the Slingerland, Orton-Gillingham, or Lindamood-Bell methodologies, or a combination of these programs. The program should have been administered by a person familiar with and trained in the methodologies used. Were Ms. Deane available, the evidence supports the conclusion that she would have been qualified to provide these services.
The IEP called for STUDENT to receive 90 minutes a day of RSP services (two RSP periods in the block schedule). STUDENT started the year enrolled in only one RSP class. In November, STUDENT dropped Spanish and enrolled in a second RSP class. During one of the RSP classes, STUDENT focused on his core curriculum, in particular, working with Mr. Davies, the instructional aide, on the Plato math program. In the other RSP class, STUDENT worked on language arts in a small group of four students. In the language arts class, STUDENT worked with the Lindamood-Bell Seeing Stars, and Visualizing and Verbalizing programs. STUDENT also worked with the Wingate Reading Program, the McGraw Hill Phonics program, and a variety of other programs. (District Exhibit Pages 359-360) Skills worked on included spelling, vocabulary, basic writing skills, and basic reading skills. (District Exhibit Pages 187-188) Although Ms. Szeker worked with STUDENT, most of the language arts program was under the direct supervision of Mr. Davies. The Hearing Officer finds that this program included instruction in phonics, decoding, spelling rules, reading skills, word recognition, writing skills, and basic math skills. However, the services provided, particularly the language arts program, were not specifically designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, and were not administered by a educator with proper training in the methodologies (Footnote 17).
ESY services were not offered in this IEP. Again, there was no evidence that STUDENT had trouble with regression over the summer months. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require ESY services to prevent regression during the summer.
Conclusion
As set forth earlier, the District had again failed to assess STUDENT’s educational needs in all areas of suspected disability. This failure continued to make it virtually impossible for the District to develop an appropriate IEP. The September 17, 2001 IEP failed to identify STUDENT’s primary educational need; appropriate services to address his phonological processing disorder. Only two of the goals (spelling and math skills) were functional. The other two goals were so over-broad as to have been useless. In addition, while the IEP identified attendance, time management and task completion as areas of need, it failed to formulate any goals in these areas or provide any services to address these needs.
In summary, the IEP failed to identify STUDENT’s core educational need, services to address his phonological processing disorder, did not contain appropriate goals and objectives, did not contain goals and objectives in all areas of educational need, and did not identify critical instructional strategies. The program provided was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique educational needs and was not provided in an appropriate fashion by a properly trained instructor. The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.
7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for all expenses, including mileage and tuition, that they incurred in providing the following services:
(a) Tutoring from the Sylvan learning center during the 1997-1998 school year?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) Because of the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year, STUDENT’s parents have satisfied the first part of the test set forth above.
To determine whether the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the unilateral placement of STUDENT at Sylvan, it must also be determined whether the placement was proper under the IDEA. In Florence County School District, Four v. Carter (1993) 114 S.Ct. 361, the Court held that parents may receive reimbursement for their unilateral placement even if the placement does not meet certain requirements of the IDEA. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the child’s IEP, and need not provide a placement that meets state education standards. Moreover, the parents’ unilateral placement is not required to be in the least restrictive environment. However, while the parents’ placement need not be an exact proper placement under the IDEA, the placement still must have met the child’s needs and provided educational benefit. (Florence v. Carter, supra; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 790 F.2d 1153, 1161.)
In this case, the PARENTS did not enroll STUDENT at Sylvan as an alternative to the District program, but in addition to the District program. MOTHER stated that she took STUDENT to Sylvan because she did not feel he was progressing in the District program and she was looking for extra help. MOTHER testified that Sylvan primarily worked on STUDENT’s reading, with some work on spelling and math. While the Sylvan tutoring was aimed at improving STUDENT’s reading and spelling, which were both broad areas of need, there is no evidence that the program was designed to address STUDENT’s primary need, his phonological processing disorder. Therefore, the Sylvan program was not addressing STUDENT’s core educational need. In addition, there is no significant evidence that STUDENT received educational benefit (Footnote 18). The Hearing Officer finds that reimbursement of the Sylvan tutoring is not appropriate because there was insufficient evidence that the program addressed STUDENT’s unique needs or that STUDENT received educational benefit.
(b) Tutoring from Marci Johnson obtained during the summer of 1999?
Marci Johnson testified that she first tutored STUDENT during the summer after the second grade (summer 1995). After she became involved as an advocate for the PARENTS, she did some additional tutoring. Ms. Johnson testified that she tried to help STUDENT with little tricks to improve his reading comprehension, but did not provide any formal tutoring. The Hearing Officer finds reimbursement for the Marci Johnson’s tutoring during the summer of 1999 is not appropriate because there is no evidence in the record to establish what services Ms. Johnson provided during the summer of 1999, or that STUDENT received any benefit from those services. (c) The cost of the Lindamood-Bell assessment obtained in June 2000?
California Education Code Section 56329(b) provides that a parent may obtain an independent educational evaluation from a qualified specialist at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment conducted by the educational agency. If the educational agency establishes at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate, it is not required to pay for the independent evaluation. For the District's assessment to be appropriate, it must meet the requirements of California Education Code Section 56320, which include that tests be administered in a nondiscriminatory manner by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions, validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, and tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Section 56320(f) requires that the student be assessed in all areas of suspected disability. No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Psychological assessments must be conducted by credentialed school psychologists. Educ. Code § 56324(a).
In this case, the District’s assessment in question is Ms. Robert’s testing for dyslexia conducted in January 2000. There is no claim that the testing was done in a discriminatory fashion or that Ms. Roberts was not qualified to administer the test. Petitioner’s claim is that the instrument used was not tailored to assess the specific areas of educational need. Ms. Roberts administered the Boder Test of Reading-Spelling Patterns. Ms. Roberts testified that the Boder was only a screening test and that a full assessment for dyslexia would have gone deeper. In fact, Ms. Roberts’ report recommended further testing in numerous areas to better identify STUDENT’s specific deficits. Ms. Roberts stated that she did not know why this additional testing was never done. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Roberts’ January 2000 assessment was not appropriate because it was not designed to assess STUDENT’s specific areas of educational need.
The original Lindamood-Bell evaluation that MOTHER obtained involved a broad range of both standardized testing and informal testing. The tests were all conducted by a trained Lindamood-Bell consultant. The testing, in total, was designed to evaluate STUDENT’s language deficits. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s parents are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the Lindamood-Bell assessment performed in June 2000.
(d) 13 weeks of an intensive Lindamood-Bell program and post-program reports, including necessary living expenses during the 2000-2001 school year?
It has already been determined that the District failed offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. The question is whether the Lindamood-Bell treatment met STUDENT’s unique needs and provided educational benefit. There was substantial testimony that the kind of treatment STUDENT needed to remediate his dyslexia was multi-modal, multi-sensory instruction provided in a systematic, repetitive manner. The Lindamood-Bell therapy was given as an example of this type of program. In fact, the District utilized the Lindamood-Bell therapies in the program it provided STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year. Furthermore, the evidence establishes that STUDENT made progress during the 2000-2001 school year in the Lindamood-Bell program. Lindamood-Bell’s exit testing showed substantial gains in almost all areas (Footnote 19). In addition, when STUDENT began the 2001-2002 school year at Chester, by all reports he was a much more focused and confident student. STUDENT was noted to use Lindamood-Bell techniques for self-correction. The Hearing Officer finds that the 13 weeks of intensive Lindamood-Bell treatment was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and that STUDENT made educational progress. Therefore, the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the Lindamood-Bell program in the amount of $12,744.
Lindamood-Bell charged the PARENTS a separate fee for the exit testing and the progress report ($495). As set forth above, there is some question about the accuracy of the exit testing because it was given just six months after the original testing. Under the circumstances, it was reasonable for the PARENTS to want to obtain some form of documentation that detailed the services provided, the progress made, and Lindamood-Bell’s recommendations for future services. Although the Hearing Officer has some concern that Lindamood-Bell’s method of exit testing is, to some degree, motivated by marketing, under the circumstances of this case the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for this charge in addition to the tuition.
The PARENTS are also seeking reimbursement for the cost of renting an apartment for STUDENT in Sacramento, utilities for that apartment, and the cost of transportation for his mother to visit him every weekend (Footnote 20). There was testimony that FATHER took a job in Sacramento so that he could live with STUDENT while STUDENT was in school. It was not uncommon for FATHER to take jobs at locations all over the state. Although it was reasonable that STUDENT needed a place to live while attending the Lindamood-Bell program, there is no evidence that the PARENTS actually incurred any extra cost. FATHER had a contract in Sacramento during the same time STUDENT was in Lindamood-Bell. Had STUDENT not been in Lindamood-Bell, FATHER would have had to make living arrangements for himself in Sacramento anyway. In fact, FATHER lived with STUDENT in the apartment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the apartment in Sacramento. However, it was reasonable that MOTHER travel to Sacramento every weekend to visit STUDENT. MOTHER testified that she visited STUDENT every week for the entire 13-week program. The Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are entitled to reimbursement for the cost of transportation for the 400 mile round-trip for each week.
The District argues that the above reimbursement should be reduced or denied because the PARENTS did not properly notify the District of their intent to remove STUDENT from public school and place him at Lindamood-Bell. California Education Code Section 56176 provides, in part:
The cost of the reimbursement described in Section 56175 may be reduced or denied in the event of any of the following: (a) At the most recent individualized education program meeting that a parent attended prior to removal of the child from the public school, the parent did not inform the individualized education program team that they were rejecting the placement proposed by the district..., including stating his or her concerns and the intent to enroll the child in a private school at public expense. (b) The parent did not give written notice to the district, special education local plan area, or county office of the information described in subdivision (a) at least 10 business days ... prior to the removal of the child from the public school.... (d) Upon a judicial finding of unreasonableness with respect to actions taken by a parent.
This statute ensures that a parent give adequate notice to the District of their concerns about the District program and of their intent to enroll the child in a private school at public expense. In this case, MOTHER first notified the District that she was considering pursuing a Lindamood-Bell program at the June 2, 2000 IEP. On July 7, 2000, MOTHER wrote the District and informed it that she and her husband wanted STUDENT to be provided with the Lindamood-Bell program and requested an IEP to implement this program. At the August 28, 2000 IEP meeting, MOTHER presented the team with the parents’ plans to place STUDENT with Lindamood-Bell. However, the PARENTS did not specifically reject the District’s offer at that meeting. During the next few days, the PARENTS did notify the District that they were rejecting its offer and placing STUDENT at Lindamood-Bell. The District then convened another IEP team meeting on September 11, 2000, to confirm that the team disagreed with the PARENTS’ decision. Although it does not appear that the PARENTS complied with the precise requirements of Section 56176 (they did not reject the District’s offer at the August 28, 2000 IEP meeting), it does appear that they kept the District informed of their plans and gave the District ample opportunity to offer an appropriate alternative. Furthermore, Section 56176 leaves the reduction of reimbursement to the discretion of the hearing officer. Because of the number of years that the District had denied STUDENT a FAPE, and because the PARENTS informed the District that they were considering the Lindamood-Bell program long before the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not appropriate to reduce the amount of reimbursement in this case.
(e) Private tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year?
During the last half of the 2000-2001 school year, MOTHER home-schooled STUDENT. To supplement her home schooling, she arranged for STUDENT to receive weekly tutoring for three to fours hours each week in history, English and science. There was no evidence as to the actual curriculum followed or the credentials of the tutors. There was no evidence that the tutors were familiar with STUDENT’s unique needs or that STUDENT made progress because of the tutoring. There was no evidence that STUDENT could not have returned to Chester High after completing Lindamood-Bell. Although the District had not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, there was no evidence that the tutoring he received in the last half of that school year was in any way designed to meet his unique needs or that it provided him with any educational benefit. The Hearing Officer finds that the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the private tutoring STUDENT received during the 2000-2001 school year.
8) Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of a FAPE from November 1997 to the present?
Petitioner seeks additional intensive services from Lindamood-Bell, an order requiring the District to train its staff in Lindamood-Bell techniques, and an order requiring the District to employ Dr. Gardner to provide additional training and consultation to District staff.
When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is "appropriate" in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Court decisions subsequent to Burlington also have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to students who have been denied a FAPE. (See, e.g. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865; Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F.2d 749.) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy. There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.
In this case, the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for five years. The District continually failed to develop IEPs or provide services designed to address STUDENT’s fundamental educational need of remediation of his skill deficits that resulted from his phonological processing disorder. In addition, the District failed to develop goals and objectives or provide services to address STUDENT’s problems with organizational skills, off-task behavior, and attendance. As a result of these failures, the PARENTS removed STUDENT from the District and placed him with Lindamood-Bell, where he received 13 weeks of intensive instruction. When STUDENT returned to the District for the 2001-2002 school year, he was a more confident, more focused student, and he demonstrated significant improvement in all areas of functioning related to his phonological processing disorder. Despite these intensive services, STUDENT still has significant needs in relation to his phonological processing disorder. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education to ensure that he is appropriately educated.
Determining what compensatory education is appropriate requires the consideration of various factors. First, it is important to note, as Ms. Spicer testified, that as STUDENT gets older it is increasingly difficult to properly remediate skill deficits that result from his phonological processing disorder. Furthermore, STUDENT is now entering the tenth grade and the time remaining to properly address his disability is rapidly running out. STUDENT’s desires and expectations must also be considered. STUDENT has stated that he would like to go on to college (Footnote 21). If STUDENT is to achieve this goal, he needs to receive additional intensive remediation in relation to his phonological processing disorder. However, it is not practical to try to give STUDENT the needed intensive services during after-school hours. STUDENT is, by all accounts, a normal, social teenage boy. He enjoyed being part of the school golf team, and will probably want to continue that next year. He enjoys a variety of outdoor activities and enjoys spending time with his friends. Although STUDENT told Dr. Gardner that he was willing to do whatever was needed, it is not reasonable to expect that STUDENT would willingly participate in a program that requires him to spend a significant amount of after-school hours getting extra instruction. Furthermore, because STUDENT is still functioning below grade level in a number of areas, he will continue to need additional RSP support in many of his general education classes. To add time for intensive services to address his phonological processing disorder on top of his general education classes and the RSP support for those classes would result in an unacceptable reduction of the time STUDENT is able to spend in general education. The only remaining alternative is intensive instruction during the summer.
Lindamood-Bell recommended an additional four to six weeks of intensive instruction at a Lindamood-Bell center. This represents from 80 to 120 hours of instruction. Dr. Gardner recommended that STUDENT receive one and one-half hours of intensive instruction three days a week. If this level were continued for an entire school year, it would amount to approximately 160 hours of instruction. Jennifer Hollibaugh recommended that STUDENT receive 45 minutes a day, five days a week, of intensive instruction. This amounts to approximately 130 hours of instruction (Footnote 22). Of these recommendations, the Lindamood-Bell staff had the most substantial basis for their opinion. They had worked with STUDENT for 13 weeks and were familiar with both his level of functioning and his style of learning. The Hearing Officer finds that Lindamood-Bell’s recommendation of 80 to 120 hours of intensive multi-modal, multi-sensory instruction is an appropriate part of a compensatory education award in this case. Lindamood-Bell recommended that the instruction be at a Lindamood-Bell center.
On the basis of the testimony of Ms. Spicer and Ms. Hollibaugh, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate instruction could be achieved using any one of several programs - Orton-Gillingham, Slingerland or Lindamood-Bell. However, there was no evidence presented that there are intensive programs in the Orton-Gillingham or Slingerland programs available in the local area. Furthermore, there was substantial evidence that STUDENT made significant progress in the Lindamood-Bell program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the 80 to 120 hours of intensive instruction shall be provided by the Lindamood-Bell center in Sacramento. This instruction should, if possible, be provided during the 2002 summer. Because STUDENT will have live in Sacramento during this instruction, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for reasonable living and transportation expenses, including room or apartment rent for the duration of the four- to six-week program, and for mileage to transport STUDENT to and from Sacramento and for MOTHER to visit STUDENT on weekends.
Petitioner also requests that the District contract with Lindamood-Bell to provide the staff with training to enable them to provide the necessary ongoing support services to STUDENT and that the District hire Dr. Gardner to provide consultation and in-service training to District staff. The Hearing Officer finds that an accredited RSP teacher already has the necessary training to provide the ongoing support services STUDENT will need during the remainder of his high school years. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not necessary for the District to contract with Dr. Gardner for in-service training and consultation services. The District has the necessary staff to develop and implement an appropriate program for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year.
Conclusion
Because of the District’s failure to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the last five years, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education. As compensatory education, STUDENT is entitled to four to six weeks of intensive instruction through the Lindamood-Bell Learning Center in Sacramento (as recommended by the Lindamood-Bell progress report, District Exhibit Page 124-134). This instruction should, if possible, be provided during the 2002 summer. Because STUDENT will have live in Sacramento during this instruction, the District shall reimburse the PARENTS for reasonable living and transportation expenses, including room or apartment rent for the duration of the four- to six-week program, for mileage to transport STUDENT to and from Sacramento, and for MOTHER to visit STUDENT on weekends.
It should be noted that this is an award of compensatory education. These services are intended to be above those required for a FAPE. In addition to these services, the District has a duty to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year and every subsequent year as long as STUDENT remains eligible for special education and related services. As the 2002-2003 year is STUDENT’s triennial year, the District will have to conduct the appropriate assessments in all areas necessary to establish STUDENT’s educational needs. Because of the intensive instruction that STUDENT will receive during the 2002 summer, the triennial assessments should not be done until after the Lindamood-Bell program has been completed.
Based upon the testimony, the Hearing Officer also finds that remediating STUDENT’s skill deficits at this point in time will be a difficult task. There is no guarantee that the compensatory instruction at Lindamood-Bell will be able to compensate for the years (1997-1998 through 2001-2002) during which STUDENT received an inappropriate program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer further orders that, in April of 2003, the District shall conduct a data review, and if necessary, develop an assessment plan to determine STUDENT's progress in relation to his phonological processing disorder. If the IEP team concludes that sufficient progress has not been made, it shall consider the need for ESY at the conclusion of STUDENT's tenth grade year.
ORDER
a. Within twenty-five calendar days of the date of this decision, Petitioner shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the June 2000 initial evaluation by Lindamood-Bell and the cost of the December 2000 exit testing and the subsequent progress report from Lindamood-Bell. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for these costs.
b. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner $12,744 as the cost of STUDENT’s tuition at the Lindamood-Bell center in 2000.
c. Within thirty calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for the cost of transportation for MOTHER to visit STUDENT in Sacramento during the Lindamood-Bell program. Total mileage for these visits is 5,200 miles (13 weeks times 400 miles per round-trip). Reimbursement for transportation shall be at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
d. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall contract with the Lindamood-Bell Learning Center in Sacramento for the provision of four to six weeks of intensive services as recommend in the Lindamood-Bell Progress Report. Whether STUDENT will receive four, five, or six weeks of instruction is left to the discretion of the Lindamood-Bell instructors. These services shall be provided prior to the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year.
e. Within 25 calendar days of the conclusion of the Lindamood-Bell program, the PARENTS shall submit to the District proof of reasonable living and transportation expenses, including room or apartment rent for the duration of the four- to six-week program, and mileage to transport STUDENT to and from Sacramento and for MOTHER to visit STUDENT on weekends. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of this proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for these costs. Reimbursement for transportation shall be at the rate the District reimburses its employees.
f. In April of 2003, the District shall conduct a data review, and if necessary, develop an assessment plan to determine STUDENT’s progress in relation to his phonological processing disorder. If the IEP team concludes that sufficient progress has not been made, it shall consider the need for ESY at the conclusion of STUDENT's tenth grade year.
g. All of Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
1. Did the District fail to properly assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
2. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1997-1998 school year, including the 1998 extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
3. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1998-1999 school year, including the 1999 extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
4. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year, including the 2000 extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
5. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, including the 2001 extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
6. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, including the 2002 extended school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
7. Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for all expenses, including mileage and, that they incurred in providing the following services services:
(a) Tutoring from the Sylvan learning center during the 1997-1998 school year?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(b) Tutoring from Marci Johnson provided during the summer of 1999?
Respondent prevailed on this issue.
(c) The cost of the Lindamood-Bell assessment obtained in June 2000?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(d) 13 weeks of an intensive Lindamood-Bell program and post-program reports, including necessary living expenses during the 2000-2001 school year?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue.
(e) Private tutoring during the 2000-2001 school year?
District prevailed on this issue.
8. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education as a result of the District’s denial of a FAPE from November 1997 to the present?
Petitioner prevailed on this issue only to the extent set forth in paragraphs “d,”“e” and “f” of the order.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: July 2, 2002 ____________________________________ Lawrence E. Mendel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. For purposes of clarification and organization, the Hearing Officer has revised the Petitioner’s statement of the issues.
2. Testimony and later testing would establish that STUDENT’s difficulties in the area of written expression were actually the result of STUDENT’s dyslexia. Dyslexia is a specific language-based disorder of constitutional origin characterized by difficulties in single word decoding, usually reflecting insufficient phonological processing abilities. Dyslexia is manifested by variable difficulty with different forms of language, often including, in addition to problems reading, a conspicuous problem with acquiring proficiency in writing and spelling. (The Definition of Dyslexia as adopted by the Research Committee of IDA, May 11, 1994 and by the National Institutes of Health, 1994) Hereafter, the Hearing Officer will refer to STUDENT’s underlying processing disorder as a phonological processing disorder, as this is more descriptive of STUDENT’s particular impairment.
3. All of these errors are typical of impaired phonological processing.
4. Testimony from Mr. Jolly and MOTHER established that Ms. Hinricks had problems keeping track of what homework had actually been turned in. Some of STUDENT’s problems with missing homework were likely due to Ms. Hinricks’s organizational problems.
5. MOTHER testified that some of these absences were for family vacations. However, many of the absences were due to STUDENT feeling overwhelmed and asking to stay home so he could try to catch up on his school work. This same combination of factors continued to impact STUDENT’s attendance throughout the time period at issue in this matter.
6. None of the witnesses could recall why the annual IEP was not held until January 1999.
7. Ms. Roberts’ report shows broad reading in the 19th percentile, but the Compuscore shows STUDENT scored in the 20th percentile.
8. This issue could not be resolved at the hearing because Ms. Deane unfortunately passed away on May 1, 2002.
9. Chester High School is on a block schedule. Each student has eight 88-minute periods. Students attend periods 1-4 every other day, and periods 5-8 every other day. Therefore, one period of RSP equals 88 minutes every other day.
10. Ms. Szeker is a retired RSP teacher who is working as a long-term substitute for the District during the 2001-2002 school year.
11. Mr. Jolly, in consultation with the PARENTS, developed a behavior contract for STUDENT in March 1998. This contract addressed STUDENT’s off-task behavior and his organizational problems. The contract was silent in regards to attendance. The behavior contract was not incorporated into, or mentioned in, either of the 1998 IEPs.
12. The IEP is somewhat confusing on this point. Different parts of the IEP specify 36 minutes, 40 minutes, and 45 minutes a day of RSP.
13. STUDENT also took the WJ-R in 1998. The results of this testing indicated a broad written language score at the 4.2 grade equivalent, substantially higher than the 1999 testing or the 2001 testing. However, other scores on the 1998 testing are unusually high as well, such as the writing sample score with a grade equivalent of 8.2 as compared to 3.3 in 1999 and 5.4 in 2001. Not all of the protocols for the 1998 testing were available for review at the hearing. Because the results of many parts of the 1998 WJ-R appear unrealistically high compared to later District testing, as well as testimony, informal assessments and private testing, the results of that test are given little weight.
14. There was testimony that STUDENT’s difficulties with basic math skills was also the result of his phonological processing disorder.
15. It was noted at the hearing that Lindamood-Bell used the same test instruments with STUDENT several times within a 6-month period. This is not considered “best practices” and can lead to inflated scores due to the “practice effect.” In this case, the exit testing done by Lindamood-Bell achieved results comparable to the results of the testing done by the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Lindamood-Bell exit testing did give an accurate picture of STUDENT’s levels of functioning.
16. When a student reaches age 14 and thereafter, his or her IEP must contain a statement of transition services that the student will need to promote the students movement from school to post-school activities. Cal. Ed. Code §56345.1
17. It was a one-size-fits-all program used for all four students in the group. STUDENT was the most advanced of these students and often felt bored and unchallenged by the program.
18. The only evidence relating to benefit is MOTHER’s testimony that she believed STUDENT made progress because his test scores improved.
19. There was substantial testimony that Lindamood-Bell’s practice of giving the same test instruments more than once in a 12-month period was not “best practices,” and was contrary to the publisher’s instructions. However, the results of the Lindamood-Bell exit testing was in substantial agreement with the District testing done at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, the Lindamood-Bell exit testing was reasonably accurate for the purpose of showing educational benefit.
20. There was substantial testimony that Lindamood-Bell’s practice of giving the same test instruments more than once in a 12-month period was not “best practices,” and was contrary to the publisher’s instructions. However, the results of the Lindamood-Bell exit testing was in substantial agreement with the District testing done at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, the Lindamood-Bell exit testing was reasonably accurate for the purpose of showing educational benefit.
21. STUDENT also told examiners that he didn’t feel he was bright enough to go to college. This does not appear to be true. STUDENT is of average intelligence. All of his examiners believe he has the intellectual ability to successfully remediate the skill deficits that have resulted from his phonological processing disorder. If STUDENT’s phonological processing disorder is appropriately addressed, there does not appear to be any reason STUDENT would not be able to go to college if he so desires.
22. However, the results of her testing show STUDENT’s level of functioning to be so far below that indicated by the results of all other testing that it calls the validity of her results into question. Ms. Hollibaugh’s test results are also not consistent with the testimony of STUDENT’s ninth grade English teacher. STUDENT’s teacher stated that while STUDENT was not a natural reader, he was able to satisfactorily read a grade-level novel. The Hearing Officer finds that the results of Ms. Hollibaugh’s testing were, for some reason, unrealistically depressed. Therefore, the results of this testing are given little weight. Ms. Hollibaugh’s recommendations, to the extent that they are based on the results of her testing, are also given little weight.
