California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 18, 2005

Student v. Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District (consolidated)

SEHO Case No. SN 2070-02, SN02-02070R, SN04-02813A · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified must reimburse parents for missed DIR services and half of 2003-04 home program costs; most claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 6 of 20 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The original decision in SN02-02070 (February 5, 2003) was vacated on appeal by the federal court (CV 03-8614 DSF) on September 8, 2004 and remanded for rehearing as SN02-02070R. The remand was consolidated with the Student's case SN04-02813. Issues for 2004-2005 were bifurcated into SN04-02813B, to be heard separately. A prior decision, SN02-00931 (July 12, 2002), had found the FEAS assessment appropriate.

Summary

This consolidated case combined a district filing, reheard after a federal court vacated the original 2003 decision, with the parents' later cross-filing. The student, a 10-year-old with autism, attended general education first and second grade in Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified with an aide, speech and occupational therapy, and home DIR (Developmental, Individual and Relationship) services. In fall 2002 his parents moved him to the Calvert School home program.

The Hearing Officer found that the District properly assessed auditory and visual processing and social-emotional development. A late motor planning assessment caused no harm. A teacher's absence from some IEP meetings and accommodations missing from the written IEP were procedural violations that did not deny FAPE. The District did deny FAPE by not addressing articulation from August to October 2001 and oral-seeking behaviors during 2001-02. It ended home DIR services before the July 30, 2002 end date in the agreed IEP. It also failed to provide those services as stay put from its September 11, 2002 filing until its November 20 offer. Leaving DIR out of the 2002-03 offer did not deny FAPE, and the aide was adequately trained. Because the parents never made clear they had rejected public school, the District had to offer FAPE for 2003-04. Reimbursement was cut 50 percent for the parents' lack of notice. The District must reimburse a speech assessment, speech therapy, DIR consultation and tutoring, and half the 2003-04 home program costs.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO handled a district's duty to hold an annual IEP for a child whose parents moved him to a home program without clearly rejecting public school. It also shows that a district's own due process filing triggered stay put, and how equitable reductions were applied to reimbursement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1A. Did the District assess the Student appropriately in visual and auditory processing for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years?

    The school psychologist's June 2001 psychoeducational assessment properly assessed visual and auditory processing. An audiologist was not required, and the assessment cannot be judged in hindsight against a 2004 audiology report.

  2. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1B. Did the District assess the Student appropriately in social/emotional development, or did it improperly use the FEAS as the sole criterion?

    A prior SEHO decision had already found the FEAS adequate, and the psychoeducational and CCR assessments also supported the social goals. The FEAS was not the sole criterion.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1C. Did the District fail to timely conduct a motor planning assessment it agreed to in August 2002?

    The District did not offer an assessment plan until February 2003, seven months late. The delay caused no disadvantage to the Student's education, and the parents did not respond to the plan.

  4. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 2A(1). Were appropriate personnel, including the Student's regular education teacher, present at the Student's 2001-2002 IEP meetings?

    The first grade teacher's absence from five interim IEP meetings was a procedural violation. It caused no loss of educational opportunity and did not seriously infringe on parent participation. The absence of OT and speech providers from some meetings was not a violation.

  5. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue 2A(2). Did the District appropriately identify in the IEP the accommodations made to address the Student's auditory processing deficits?

    The District did not put most of the recommended accommodations in writing. The Student still received them, and the parents knew about them, so FAPE was not denied.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2B(2)(a). Did the District use appropriate methods to measure the Student's progress on his goals and objectives?

    The IEPs contained adequate present levels of performance, and measuring progress by observation was adequate for these goals.

  7. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2B(2)(b). Was the Student's program designed to meet his behavioral needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

    The Student's behavior did not impede learning. His minor misbehavior was handled through classroom discipline, DIR strategies, OT, and speech services, so no behavior plan was required.

  8. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2B(2)(c). Was the Student's program designed to meet his oral sensory needs and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

    The District failed to address the Student's articulation needs from August 17 to October 26, 2001, and failed to address his oral seeking behaviors during the 2001-2002 school year.

  9. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2B(3)(a). Were the Student's DIR services timely provided?

    The District missed the December 3 target date, but it worked diligently to start a new program for several families. Full implementation by February 28, 2002 was timely.

  10. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 2B(3)(b). Were the Student's DIR services appropriately implemented, given the SELPA specialist's training?

    The SELPA autism specialist was adequately trained to supervise DIR services even though she was not DIR-certified and did not receive all the contracted PCDA training, and the services were appropriately delivered.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3A. Did the District's failure to offer DIR services for the 2002-2003 school year constitute a denial of FAPE?

    No particular methodology is required. The Student made social progress through classroom and speech-language methods and did not need DIR services to keep progressing.

  12. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue 3B(1). Was the District required to keep implementing the last agreed-upon IEP (home DIR services through July 30, 2002) after the parents rejected the 2002-2003 offer?

    The District denied FAPE by ending the home DIR services in the November 26, 2001 IEP on June 14 instead of the IEP's July 30, 2002 end date.

  13. Student prevailed in partStay put

    Issue 3B(2). Was the District required to provide home DIR services at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year until the dispute was resolved?

    The District could implement the undisputed parts of the May 30, 2002 IEP when the school year started. Once it filed for due process on September 11, 2002, stay put required home DIR services, which it did not provide until its November 20 offer.

  14. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 3C. Did the District fail to appropriately identify accommodations for the Student's pragmatic language deficits in the May 30, 2002 IEP?

    The IEP addressed pragmatic deficits through two hours of weekly speech-language therapy, a social skills group, and four speech goals. The Student identified no needed accommodation.

  15. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3D. Did the District fail to provide the Student with an adequately trained instructional aide for the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year?

    The aide's autism training plus on-the-job training from the teacher and the SELPA specialist made her adequately prepared. No evidence linked school supports to the Student's absences.

  16. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3E. Did the District appropriately address the Student's oral seeking behaviors during the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year?

    Several staff members gave the BOMP exercises at school and at home appropriately, and the parents declined OT services in the home setting.

  17. District prevailedStay put

    Issue 3F. Did the District fulfill its stay put obligations to the Student?

    The November 20, 2002 stay put offer matched the DIR services as actually implemented under the last agreed-upon IEP and did not need to include PCDA.

  18. Issue 4. Was the District required to offer the Student a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

    The parents had not made clear that they were not interested in a public placement, so the District had to hold an annual IEP meeting in May 2003 and offer FAPE. It failed to do so.

  19. Issue 5A. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for specified independent assessments?

    Reimbursement was denied for the audiology and social-emotional assessments because the District's assessments were appropriate. The $225 August 2002 speech-language assessment was reimbursed because of the oral sensory and articulation violations.

  20. Issue 5B. Are the parents entitled to reimbursement for privately obtained educational expenses for the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years?

    Reimbursement was ordered for 2001 speech therapy and for DIR services during the violation periods. The 2003-2004 Calvert program, tutoring, speech, and DIR costs were reimbursed at reasonable rates, reduced 50 percent for lack of notice and mixed messages. Other claims were denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. $225 for the August 2002 Academic Networks speech and language assessment, within 15 calendar days of receipt of the decision.
  • Reimbursement. $200 for Truesdail Speech Center speech-language services in October and November 2001, within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $1,080 for Playworks DIR training and consultation, September 11 to November 20, 2002, within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. Home tutor DIR services at $10 per hour, 2 hours per day, 5 days per week ($100 per week per tutor), for the same number of tutors at a time as under the November 26, 2001 IEP, for June 15 to July 30, 2002 and September 11 to November 20, 2002, within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $250 (50% of $500) for Truesdail Speech Center services during 2003-2004, within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $620.07 (50% of $1,240.14) for the Calvert School home instruction program for 2003-2004, within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $125 per week for home tutor instruction in the Calvert program, August 15, 2003 to June 15, 2004 (50% of $250 per week), within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $25 per week for administrative coordination services, August 15, 2003 to June 15, 2004 (50% of $50 per week), within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. $180 per month for Playworks DIR supervision and coaching, August 15, 2003 to June 15, 2004 (50% of $360 per month), within 15 calendar days.
  • Reimbursement. Home DIR tutor services at $5 per hour, 2 hours per day, 5 days per week, for the same number of tutors per session as under the November 26, 2001 IEP, August 15, 2003 to June 15, 2004, within 15 calendar days.

Total: $2,375.07 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Burlington; Florence County v. Carter; Adams v. State of Oregon; Ms. S. v. Vashon Island; Doe v. Maher; Gregory K. v. Longview; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley; Amanda J. v. Clark County; Stacy G. v. Pasadena ISD; Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education; OSEP Memorandum, 34 IDELR 263

People named in the decision

  • Gail Lindberg, SELPA special education program manager; District representative, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD / East Valley SELPA
  • Patty Metheny, director of student services, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • James Simonds, Ph.D., school psychologist, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • Suzanne Matich, first grade general education teacher, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • Greg Cinque, second grade general education teacher, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • Nancy Hilbrands, speech-language pathologist, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • Gayle Wray, occupational therapist, East Valley SELPA
  • Misti Fairchild, occupational therapist, East Valley SELPA
  • Laurie Wellner, former SELPA autism program specialist; DIR supervisor; FEAS assessor, East Valley SELPA
  • Anita Ruesterholtz, SELPA administrator, East Valley SELPA
  • Sandra Isaak, speech-language therapist; 2001 speech-language assessor; witness for Student, East Valley SELPA
  • Susan Millar, 1:1 instructional aide; witness for Student, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD
  • Diane Cullinane, M.D., director of DIR training and consultation provider; witness for Student, Pasadena Child Development Associates (PCDA)
  • Carol Atkins, audiologist; independent auditory processing assessor; witness for Student
  • Esther Hess, Ph.D., child psychologist; independent assessor; witness for Student
  • Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D., independent psychoeducational assessor
  • Kelli Wilms, private DIR consultant and trainer (nonpublic agency), Playworks
  • Gwen Palafox, private behavioral intervention provider, Working With Autism
  • Lou Padilla, regional center staff member who observed the classroom, Inland Regional Center
  • Ms. Mason, privately paid coordinator of the home program
  • Reanna, privately paid home DIR tutor
  • Sacia, privately paid home DIR tutor
  • Carol, privately paid home DIR tutor
  • Pasadena Child Development Associates, DIR training and consultation provider under SELPA contract
  • Playworks, nonpublic agency providing DIR services
  • Working With Autism, nonpublic agency providing DTT and behavioral services
  • Children's Center of Riverside, social/emotional assessor (2001)
  • Truesdail Speech Center, private speech-language provider
  • Academic Networks, private speech-language assessor (August 2002)
  • Calvert School, private home instruction program

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in Yucaipa, California, on March 1, 2, 3, 4, 8, and 9, 2005. (Footnote 2)

Petitioner and Cross-Respondent Yucaipa-Calimesa Joint Unified School District (District) was represented by special education program manager Gail Lindberg. Also present on the District’s behalf was Patty Metheny, director of student services. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Kathleen Loyer. Also present on Petitioner=s behalf were his parents, MOTHER and FATHER.

The District called the following witnesses: Ms. Metheny; James Simonds, Ph.D., school psychologist; Suzanne Matich, STUDENT’s first grade teacher; Greg Cinque, STUDENT’s second grade teacher; Nancy Hilbrands, speech pathologist; Gayle Wray, occupational therapist; Laurie Wellner, former special education program specialist for the East Valley Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); and Anita Ruesterholtz, administrator of the SELPA.

The Student called the following witnesses: Diane Cullinane, M.D., director of Pasadena Child Development Associates (PCDA); Susan Millar, instructional aide for the District; Sandra Isaak, speech pathologist; Carol Atkins, audiologist; Esther Hess, Ph.D., child psychologist; and MOTHER.

The Hearing Officer called Gail Lindberg and re-called Ms. Metheny as witnesses.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of the final closing brief on April 20, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision. (Footnote 3)

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Issue No. 1: Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately in all areas of suspected disability?

Issue No. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

Issue No. 3: Did the District offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

Issue No. 4: Was the District required to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

Issue No. 5: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for specified independent assessments and/or for STUDENT’s privately obtained educational expenses for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Student contends that his 2001-2002 educational program was inappropriate in several respects. First, he asserts that the District failed to assess him adequately in the areas of auditory and visual processing and social/emotional development. Second, he asserts that his program was procedurally inadequate because the District failed to have his teacher and his designated service providers present at all of his IEP meetings for the year, and failed to appropriately identify accommodations and modifications to his IEP.

Substantively, the Student asserts that the District failed to measure his progress appropriately on his goals and objectives, and failed to appropriately address his behavioral and oral sensory needs. In addition, the Student alleges that the District failed to appropriately implement social/emotional development services it had agreed to provide to him at home and at school using the “Developmental, Individual and Relationship” (DIR) intervention model.

During the 2002-2003 school year, the Student alleges that the District’s failure to assess him appropriately in the areas of auditory and visual processing and social/emotional development continued to affect his program. In addition, he asserts that the District failed to timely conduct a motor planning assessment that it offered him in August 2002. The Student further asserts that the District erred procedurally by failing to implement his last agreed-upon IEP or to have a new IEP in place for him at the beginning of the school year, and by failing to identify accommodations to address his pragmatic speech deficits.

Substantively, the Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer him DIR services for the 2002-2003 school year, failing to provide him with an adequately trained instructional aide, and failing to honor its “stay put” obligations to him after the initiation of due process proceedings.

Finally, the Student asserts that after his parents withdrew him from the District and enrolled him in a home school program, the District failed to meet its obligation to offer him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.

As a remedy for the District’s alleged denials of FAPE, the Student seeks reimbursement for specified private assessments and for the Student’s educational expenses for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years.

In response, the District asserts that it complied with all procedural requirements and provided the Student with a FAPE for all specified time periods. Further, the District contends that it was not required to offer STUDENT a special education placement and program for the 2003-2004 school year.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a ten-year-old boy who was diagnosed with autism at age two. As a toddler, STUDENT received a forty-hour per week discrete trial therapy (DTT) program in New York. (S. Exhs. 55-61.) Since his family moved to the District in or around 1999, STUDENT has received special education and related services from the East Valley SELPA and the District.

STUDENT’s preschool and kindergarten programs (1999-2001)

During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT attended a language-based preschool special day class (SDC) three days a week and received a thirty-hour per week in-home DTT program supervised by Working With Autism (WWA), a nonpublic agency. In the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT attended a general education kindergarten class at Yucaipa Elementary School, a public school in the District. He was provided with a one-to-one instructional assistant (IA) during class hours, direct and consultation services from an occupational therapist (OT), and speech and language (S/L) consultation services. He also continued to receive a thirty-hour per week in-home DTT program through WWA. (D. Exh. 13.)

On June 6, 2001, near the end of his kindergarten year, STUDENT’s IEP team met to review his kindergarten year and plan his first grade program. STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher reported that he had responded well to her cues to pay attention, followed directions with the rest of the class, had good self esteem, and did not imitate the inappropriate behavior of others. She noted that his math skills were at first grade level, and his reading skills at second grade or beginning third grade level. In terms of social development, STUDENT’s teacher reported that he had shown “great progress,” and had made friends that he would seek out for playtimes. However, he had trouble maintaining eye contact during conversation, and sometimes used idiosyncratic language (repetitive phrases unrelated to the conversation). In fine motor development, his handwriting was legible and had improved, but he still had difficulty writing. (S. Exh. 44-46.)

The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a regular education first grade class at Wildwood Elementary School, another District public school, with a one-to-one classroom IA (provided by STUDENT’s parents and reimbursed by the District); OT services; and an in-home DTT program. The team further agreed that prior to the development of goals and objectives, STUDENT would receive a psychoeducational assessment; an assessment by the Children’s Center of Riverside (CCR); and assessments in visual perception/processing, auditory perception/processing, and speech and language. (S. Exh. 42-47.) (Footnote 4)

At this meeting, MOTHER asked that the DIR intervention model (which focuses on social interaction and interpersonal relationships) be considered as a replacement for STUDENT’s current DTT home program, and the District agreed to consider providing DIR services. (Id.)

District psychoeducational assessment (June 18, 2001)

In June 2001, STUDENT received a psychoeducational assessment from James Simonds, Ph.D., school psychologist for the District. According to Dr. Simond’s report and testimony, STUDENT tested in the low average range in overall intelligence quotient (IQ) and in comprehension of instructions. His neurological abilities appeared intact, although test results indicated that his visual processing abilities were markedly stronger than his auditory processing skills.

STUDENT’s achievement score was markedly higher than his IQ, indicating a high ability to adapt and acquire new skills. His social skills were lower than those of typically developing peers, but he was an affectionate child who related well to the assessor. Dr. Simonds found that STUDENT was sufficiently adept in emotional perception that he should be able to form relationships with others. (D. Exh. 21.)

CCR assessment (June 21 and 28, 2001)

The Children’s Center of Riverside (CCR) assessed STUDENT for social and emotional development through direct assessment, playground observation, and parent interview. In its assessment report, CCR noted that STUDENT had a number of social strengths, in that he was aware of others around him and responded to them regularly. STUDENT demonstrated the ability to identify the feelings of others and offer comfort when he consoled an assessor who pretended to cry after losing a game. He enjoyed playing catch with his brother and the assessor, and was excited when his brother won a race.

STUDENT’s social limitations were evident, however, when he wandered off from interactions that did not directly involve him, made poor eye contact, and appeared not to know how to engage a classmate in kicking a soccer ball. The CCR report concluded that STUDENT would benefit from a program designed to meet his social needs and enrich his interpersonal relationships, initially by increasing his ability to make eye contact and to initiate basic interactions (greetings, requests, or protests). The report suggested that adults talk to STUDENT at his eye level, encourage him to initiate interactions both in class and on the playground, join him in his play, and seek out a “peer buddy” to support STUDENT in social situations. (D. Exh. 20.)

Beginning of STUDENT’s first grade year; DIR program discussions (August-September 2001)

At an IEP meeting on August 17, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team discussed his recently completed assessments and developed eight goals to be implemented by school staff, the home tutors in his DTT program, and his OT provider. Six of the goals sought to improve STUDENT’s social interaction skills by encouraging him to make eye contact, initiate peer interactions, engage in up to six “cycles” (two-way exchanges) in a conversation, answer questions with a complete sentence, and modulate the loudness and pitch of his voice. Two OT-related goals focused on making the “l,” “m,” and “th” sounds consistently, and tolerating foods of various textures without refusal or complaint. MOTHER consented to the IEP. (S. Exhs. 67-69.)

STUDENT began first grade on August 20, 2001. (D. Exh. 11.) At an August 27 IEP meeting, the IEP team continued to discuss STUDENT’s psychoeducational and CCR assessments, and noted that CCR’s observations and recommendations were consistent with other findings regarding STUDENT’s social deficits. District and SELPA representatives at the meeting agreed to investigate options for providing DIR services to STUDENT and for several other students whose parents had indicated an interest in the DIR model. (S. Exhs. 62-65; testimony of Ms. Ruesterholtz and Ms. Lindberg.)

At a follow-up IEP meeting on September 12, a written summary of the SELPA’s proposed DIR services was distributed to IEP team members. The summary indicated that Pasadena Child Development Associates (PCDA) would train staff, parents, and home tutors, who would then directly administer DIR services to the special education students whose parents requested the DIR model. The summary stated that supervision would be provided by SELPA program specialist Ms. Wellner “in collaboration with” PCDA. (S. Exh. 79.) STUDENT’s IEP team approved the plan for STUDENT and agreed to set a start date as soon as possible. (S. Exh. 70.)

Shortly after this meeting, PCDA director Dr. Cullinane reviewed the SELPA summary of the proposed DIR services and contacted the SELPA to clarify that PCDA would be providing only training and consultation services, not supervision. When MOTHER learned of this clarification, she wrote to the SELPA on September 22 expressing her extreme displeasure. MOTHER indicated that she felt “misled and deceived” by the SELPA, and that if she had known PCDA would not be supervising the DIR services, she would not have approved them for STUDENT. She added that Ms. Wellner did not have adequate training to supervise STUDENT’s DIR services, and that she wanted Playworks, another local NPA, to supervise them instead. (S. Exh. 75; testimony of Dr. Cullinane and MOTHER.)

In the meantime, STUDENT appeared to be thriving in first grade. At the September 12 IEP meeting, his teacher reported that STUDENT already had mastered much of the curriculum and was “tutoring other students in the class.” (S. Exh. 70.)

STUDENT’s S/L assessment (September 2001)

Shortly after the September 12 IEP meeting, SELPA S/L therapist Sandra Isaak assessed STUDENT for speech, language, articulation, and oral sensitivity. In her report, Ms. Isaak noted that STUDENT’s ability to process verbal information decreased as the amount of information to be processed increased. STUDENT also showed significant deficits in pragmatic communication, particularly in his use of idiosyncratic language. After observing STUDENT in the classroom, Ms. Isaak noted, “these pragmatic difficulties do not appear to have affected his relationships with peers, but do make it difficult for STUDENT to communicate.”

Ms. Isaak also reported that STUDENT had a “severe oral motor sensory disorder.” He showed hypersensitivity to contact on his inner cheeks, gums, palate, and lips, with almost no sensitivity to the front half of his tongue. Further, he had trouble manipulating oral muscles and tongue movements. As a result of these sensory and motor control issues, STUDENT had difficulty with articulation, particularly in connected speech. When he attempted to speak rapidly and at length, his speech would become virtually unintelligible. Finally, Ms. Isaak noted that STUDENT’s speaking voice was abnormally loud and his vocal quality harsh, indicating possible sensory-motor deficits in his diaphragm and vocal cords. (S. Exhs. 71-74.)

At an IEP meeting on October 26, STUDENT’s IEP team reviewed his S/L assessment and agreed that he should receive thirty minutes of individual and thirty minutes of group S/L services per week. In addition, the team determined that Misti Fairchild, the SELPA therapist currently providing STUDENT’s OT services, would begin a program of sensory and oral motor exercises with STUDENT at school. MOTHER consented to the IEP. (S. Exh. 76.)

Follow-up on DIR issues (October-November 2001)

At the October 26 IEP meeting, the team agreed that the “target date” for the beginning of DIR services would be December 3, 2001. MOTHER agreed to the proposed DIR services for STUDENT despite the fact that PCDA would not be supervising them. In the meantime, it was agreed that SELPA program specialist Ms. Wellner would administer the Functional Emotional Assessment Scale (FEAS) to STUDENT in order to determine his readiness level for DIR services. (S. Exh. 76-77; testimony of MOTHER.)

Ms. Wellner administered the FEAS to STUDENT on November 15, 2001. Using the six milestones of emotional development identified by DIR program founder Stanley Greenspan, M.D., Ms. Wellner determined that STUDENT was most consistent in demonstrating skills in the first two milestones (self-regulation and interest in his surroundings, and forming relationships). With respect to the next two milestones (engaging in conversations and behavioral organization), Ms. Wellner determined that STUDENT was able to engage in ten or more cycles of conversation, but had difficulties talking about his feelings, protesting, and clearly asking for help. Further, he often missed social cues given by his peers, and was unable to regulate his social behavior. Finally, STUDENT showed few skills in the last two milestones of emotional development (use of language to express emotions or abstract ideas, coping skills, and cognitive insight).

Ms. Wellner concluded that STUDENT would benefit greatly from the use of DIR strategies to help his social/emotional development. Such strategies would include increasing STUDENT’s opportunities for social engagement, following his lead in play, expanding play themes to elicit expression of his ideas, helping STUDENT identify emotional themes in his play, seizing opportunities for incidental learning as they arose, and giving STUDENT problems to solve in play situations to help him experience varied emotional themes. Ms. Wellner proposed five goals for STUDENT that would require him to express wants and needs through words and gestures, talk about his feelings, answer “why” questions, and engage in at least five cycles of communication on emotional themes. (S. Exhs. 83-90.)

At an IEP meeting on November 26, 2001, the IEP team reviewed Ms. Wellner’s report and adopted her suggested DIR goals. The team agreed that STUDENT’s DTT program would be “faded out” gradually, that DIR training for parents and staff would occur in early December, and that, once the DIR model was implemented, STUDENT would receive home DIR services for two hours a day through July 30, 2002. MOTHER agreed to the IEP. (S. Exh. 91.)

Delays in implementing DIR services (December 2001-February 2002)

Although December 3 had been identified as the target date to begin STUDENT’s DIR services, the initial PCDA training sessions for staff and interested parents did not occur until December 13, 14, and 18, 2001. (D. Exh. 26, pp. 150-153.) Due to scheduling problems caused in part by the seventy-mile distance between PCDA and the District, PCDA trainers attended fewer meetings and provided less training and consultation to Ms. Wellner than had been anticipated in the SELPA-PCDA contract. In addition, Ms. Wellner’s efforts to create a schedule for STUDENT’s instructional aides to provide DIR intervention at school (during lunch, recess, and after class) was hampered by the fact that the FAMILIES’ privately retained instructional aides were college students with class schedules that conflicted with Ms. Wellner’s proposed schedule. (S. Exhs. 91-96; testimony of Ms. Wellner and Dr. Cullinane.)

As a result, STUDENT’s DIR services were not fully implemented when the IEP team met again on February 14, 2002. The IEP notes indicate that previous efforts to schedule DIR meetings with STUDENT’s home tutors had been unsuccessful, and that a meeting would be scheduled on February 28 to decide the “final parameters of the program.” In the meantime, the IEP team agreed to continue an “informal type DIR program.” MOTHER consented to the IEP. (S. Exh. 97.)

Continued difficulties with DIR implementation (March-May, 2002)

According to Ms. Wellner’s testimony, she implemented STUDENT’s school DIR services through weekly on-site training of school staff and STUDENT’s tutors in DIR strategies, and through observation of his progress. In addition, Ms. Wellner scheduled meetings with STUDENT’s home tutors twice a month to review the implementation of his home DIR services. (D. Exhs. 23, 28.)

Ms. Wellner testified that the school-based portion of DIR services proceeded without incident, but the home-based portion was tense and difficult. MOTHER was unhappy that Ms. Wellner was supervising the services. The home tutors (who were employed directly by the FAMILIES) refused to comply with Ms. Wellner’s directives. In addition, Ms. Wellner was refused admittance to the FAMILY home more than once, either because she was a few minutes late for a meeting or because it was “not a good day.” (Testimony of Ms. Wellner and Ms. Ruesterholtz.)

MOTHER testified that Ms. Wellner was insufficiently trained to supervise DIR services, and gave advice to STUDENT’s tutors that was inconsistent with that of other professionals. As a result, the tutors “didn’t know what to do” to implement DIR strategies at school or at home. At IEP meetings on April 26 and May 7, MOTHER expressed these concerns to the IEP team and again asked that PCDA and Ms. Wellner be replaced by Kelly Wilms of Playworks as STUDENT’s DIR provider. She reported that STUDENT was engaging in tantrums and noncompliant behavior more often at home, and needed a more intensive plan to address his behaviors “within a DIR model.” She also expressed dissatisfaction with STUDENT’s DIR goals. (S. Exhs. 99-103.)

By the time the May 7 IEP meeting took place, it was clear to the SELPA that its contract with PCDA for provision of DIR consultation and training was not working as intended. Nevertheless, SELPA administrator Ms. Ruesterholtz believed Ms. Wellner was “absolutely qualified” to continue supervising DIR services due to her extensive training and qualifications in many autism intervention strategies. At the May 7 meeting, the District offered to continue DIR services with Ms. Wellner in charge. In addition, in response to MOTHER’s concerns about STUDENT’s goals, the District offered to revise the goals to reflect discrete subskills. MOTHER declined to sign the IEP until she had an opportunity to review it further. The May 7 IEP never was signed by MOTHER. (Testimony of Ms. Ruesterholtz; S. Exhs. 102-103.)

STUDENT’s annual IEP (May 30, 2002)

On May 30, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team met to conduct his annual review. STUDENT’s first grade teacher, Ms. Matich, reported that STUDENT was one of the top students in her class in academics. His math skills were high, he knew addition and subtraction, and he also understood the concepts of time and money. STUDENT would ask questions if unsure of an assignment, and would ask for items he needed. No problems were noted regarding his vision or hearing abilities. STUDENT participated in regular physical education, liked sports, books, and “typical little boy games,” and his handwriting was improving. (D. Exh. 4.)

Ms. Matich also reported that STUDENT got along well with his classmates, had made several new friends, and that the other students “really like him.” Although “happy to interact with others,” however, he rarely initiated the interaction. STUDENT had met his social interaction goal of maintaining six cycles of conversation, but had not attained his goal of initiating peer interactions six times per day. It was determined that the peer interaction goal would be continued, with STUDENT’s second grade teacher and S/L therapist being responsible for its implementation. During the meeting, Greg Cinque, who had been chosen to be STUDENT’s second grade teacher after District administrators determined that he would be a good personality match for STUDENT, dropped in to introduce himself to the FAMILIES. (D. Exh. 4; testimony of Mr. Cinque.)

District speech therapist Nancy Hilbrands reported on an S/L assessment conducted on May 23 for STUDENT’s annual review. According to her report and testimony, STUDENT demonstrated average receptive and expressive language capabilities, but had a mild articulation delay, did not readily initiate interactions with others, and did not maintain good eye contact. With respect to pragmatic speech, STUDENT was unable to stay on topic for an appropriate number of utterances, explain problems adequately, or maintain appropriate personal space, loudness and pitch during conversation. (D. Exh. 16.)

Ms. Hilbrands developed four goals for STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year, which included maintenance of eye contact during a five minute conversation; articulating the “th” sound; answering story questions and relating them to personal experiences; and maintaining appropriate loudness and pitch in conversation. In addition, a recently-developed OT goal to help STUDENT decrease “oral seeking” behaviors such as chewing on his shirt was continued for the 2002-2003 school year. (D. Exhs. 4, 16; testimony of Ms. Hilbrands.)

STUDENT’s IEP team discussed his instructional aide (IA) services, and determined that an IA would be provided for four hours per day in second grade until STUDENT had adjusted to the new setting. At that time, the team would determine if STUDENT still needed an IA.

The team then discussed the future of STUDENT’s home DIR services. The District recommended that the home services be discontinued because STUDENT was making enough social progress at school to make home DIR services unnecessary to his successful education. Ms. Wellner agreed with the District’s recommendation, observing that STUDENT’s social goals would be adequately addressed at school by his S/L therapist and his IA. MOTHER disagreed with the recommendation, expressing concern with STUDENT’s continued lack of social skills. To address her concerns, the District offered to increase one-to-one IA services from four hours to a full school day for the 2002-2003 school year.

MOTHER declined to sign the IEP, indicating that she wanted FATHER to review it first. The FAMILYs never consented to the May 30 IEP. The District continued to provide home DIR services to STUDENT through the last day of school (June 14, 2002). (D. Exh. 4; testimony of Ms. Wellner and MOTHER.)

Beginning of STUDENT’s second grade year (August 2002)

STUDENT’s second grade school year began on August 19, 2002. He was placed in Mr. Cinque’s regular education classroom for a full school day (with the assistance of an IA for four hours of the day), and received two hours of S/L services (individual and small group) and fifteen minutes of OT consult per week. (D. Exh. 3.) MOTHER came to school with STUDENT every day the first week, taking notes and intervening to help STUDENT to an extent that Mr. Cinque found counterproductive. Mr. Cinque felt that it was difficult to establish initial rapport with STUDENT, and to assist STUDENT in establishing himself among his peers, with his mother constantly in attendance. Further, STUDENT’s IA, Susan Millar, was uncertain as to how and when to assist STUDENT since his mother was helping him. (Testimony of Mr. Cinque and Ms. Millar.)

At an IEP meeting on August 21, MOTHER reported that most of his instruction was being given verbally, and that she believed he would do better with visual supports. Further, she reported that STUDENT was having limited interactions with his peers. MOTHER stated that she was not in agreement with the District’s offered program, and was not interested in having the IA hours increased to a full school day as a replacement for STUDENT’s previous home DIR services. She was unhappy that the District had changed its policy of allowing her to hire STUDENT’s IA, and noted that the District IA, Ms. Millar, had not yet received any autism or DIR-related training. Since mastery of DIR takes a great deal of time, she did not feel Ms. Millar could be adequately trained to address STUDENT’s needs. (S. Exh. 118-119; testimony of MOTHER.)

On August 23, the IEP team met again to discuss MOTHER’s concerns about STUDENT’s program. MOTHER expressed her disagreement with a recent Hearing Office decision that the FEAS administered by Ms. Wellner in November 2001 was appropriate. (Footnote 5) She felt STUDENT’s DIR goals should be modified and administered in a one-to-one setting, as STUDENT was able to engage in more cycles of communication with her at home than at school. In response, the District offered to conduct another social/emotional assessment of STUDENT. MOTHER also stated that STUDENT was frightened and intimidated at school and was much happier at home. She was concerned that he was not following simple directions at school, and his IA was being overly helpful. MOTHER repeated her request for a behavior plan for STUDENT. The District declined to provide such a plan because it believed STUDENT generally was well behaved, and that his minor misbehaviors were appropriately addressed by his teacher. (S. Exhs. 120-124; testimony of Ms. Metheny.)

Follow-up IEP meeting; District files for due process hearing (September 2002)

Another IEP meeting was held on September 6, 2002, to discuss STUDENT’s progress in second grade. STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Cinque, reported that STUDENT was doing very well both academically and socially. When STUDENT became distracted, Mr. Cinque was able to use nonverbal prompts and verbal redirection to help him reorient to his tasks. Mr. Cinque reported that STUDENT had made a good friend of one of the girls in the class, and in general was making friends and interacting well.

Mr. Cinque also reported that STUDENT’s classroom IA, Ms. Millar, was working well with STUDENT, and that both he and Ms. Millar had been participating in SELPA training regarding autism and application of DIR principles of intervention. (D. Exhs. 1, 26.) MOTHER expressed skepticism that Ms. Millar could be trained to an adequate level of proficiency, and stated that she wanted the IA’s involvement with STUDENT “faded.” Further, MOTHER wanted a daily log kept on STUDENT’s activities at school.

The District noted that STUDENT was being pulled out of school daily at 2 p.m., and as a result was missing an hour of school every day. (Footnote 6) MOTHER indicated that STUDENT was being taken from class to receive home DIR services provided by the FAMILIES, and that STUDENT’s home tutors were only available at that hour. Finally, the FAMILIES agreed that STUDENT would continue to receive two hours of S/L therapy per week. (D. Exh. 1; testimony of MOTHER.)

On September 11, 2002, the District filed with the Hearing Office a request for due process hearing, seeking an order finding that it had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.

STUDENT’s removal from District and enrollment in home program (September-October 2002)

STUDENT remained in Mr. Cinque’s second grade class through October 8, 2002. (D. Exh. 344.) Beginning October 9, STUDENT began to miss school due to a reoccurrence of chronic asthma. As early as September, however, MOTHER had been investigating home school programs for STUDENT because she felt he was becoming noncompliant and aggressive at home and in school, and his former self-stimulatory behaviors (such as hand flapping and “zoning out”) were reappearing. MOTHER believed the District IA, Ms. Millar, was not trained to recognize or redirect these behaviors. By September 30, MOTHER had contracted with the Calvert School to provide a home schooling program for STUDENT. (Footnote 7) (Testimony of MOTHER.)

STUDENT’s private psychoeducational assessment (October 28, 2002)

In October of 2002, the FAMILIES obtained an independent assessment of STUDENT by Sandra Kaler, R.N., Ph.D. During the assessment, Dr. Kaler noted that STUDENT engaged in self-stimulatory behavior such as spinning in circles and rocking, was easily distracted, and demonstrated “motor restlessness” and an inability to calm his body movements.

Dr. Kaler determined that STUDENT was able to function academically at grade level but had “significant difficulty” in areas typical for children with autism. She noted that STUDENT had excellent visual attention skills, but had difficulty understanding what he read, making inferences, and drawing conclusions. Further, STUDENT had significant difficulties with auditory processing. Of greater concern, STUDENT’s social development was significantly delayed relative to his academic and cognitive functioning. He responded well to adults, and he had a group of friends among his peers, but tended not to initiate peer interactions and had difficulty responding to emotional content in conversations.

Dr. Kaler concluded that STUDENT appeared to be appropriately placed at the second grade level, but needed help understanding what he read and learning to make inferences and draw conclusions. She recommended that STUDENT receive the services of an aide “specifically trained in how to engage [him] in sustained, meaningful social interaction,” and added that he would benefit from participation in a small social skills group. (S. Exhs. 179-186.)

Final IEP meeting (November 20, 2002)

On November 1, after STUDENT’s school absences had exceeded ten days, the District scheduled an IEP meeting to determine if it needed to address a change of placement to a home setting. At the IEP meeting on November 20, MOTHER stated that STUDENT continued to suffer from asthma and a viral infection and was being home schooled. She indicated that she would follow up with the doctor to determine how long STUDENT would need to remain at home. The District observed that since STUDENT had been absent from school, he was not receiving his S/L services and OT consultation, and offered to provide these services as well as home-hospital services and homework from STUDENT’s class. MOTHER responded that STUDENT was receiving all the services he currently needed, and declined additional services from the District.

According to the IEP notes, the District, which had filed for a due process hearing in September 2002, “restated its stay put offer” at the November 20 IEP meeting. The offer consisted of placement in a second grade general education class; one-to-one IA services for four hours of the school day; forty-five minutes of OT services per week; one hour of S/L services per week; and two hours per day of home DIR services supervised by the SELPA. MOTHER indicated that she would think about the offer and get back to the District. However, the District received no response from the FAMILIES about its stay put offer or about when STUDENT would return to school. (S. Exhs. 209-210; testimony of Ms. Metheny.)

STUDENT’s home school program (November 2002-June 2004)

STUDENT did not return to Mr. Cinque’s class for the rest of his second grade year. At a School Attendance Review Board (SARB) meeting in January 2003, it was determined that STUDENT was enrolled outside of the District in the Calvert School home instruction program. (D. Exh. 343.) STUDENT completed both second and third grade in the Calvert program, and received a school certificate indicating successful completion of the third grade on June 22, 2004. (Testimony of MOTHER; see D. Exhs. 1113-1152.)

In February 2003, the Hearing Office issued its decision in SN02-02070. The decision found that the District had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, except to the extent that an OT assessment in the area of motor planning might determine the need for additional OT services or goals. (Decision, SN02-02070 [February 5, 2003].)

STUDENT’s return to the District (April-August 2004)

After the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, the District convened no further IEP meetings for STUDENT for the rest of that school year or for the 2003-2004 school year. In April 2004, the FAMILYs contacted the District expressing an interest in returning STUDENT to a District placement for the 2004-2005 school year. Beginning in May 2004, the District convened IEP meetings to plan STUDENT’s fourth grade program for the next school year. STUDENT began fourth grade in a regular education District class in August 2004. (D. Exh. 40; testimony of Ms. Metheny.)

On September 8, 2004, the Hearing Office’s decision in Case No. SN02-02070 was vacated on appeal and remanded for rehearing. On November 23, 2004, the Student filed for a due process hearing, and the two matters were later consolidated for this hearing. (Footnote 8)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District assess STUDENT appropriately in all areas of suspected disability?

Federal and State law require a local education agency (LEA) to conduct an initial evaluation of a child with a suspected disability to determine whether the child qualifies for special education services, and if so, to determine the child’s educational needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a), (b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. These statutes require, among other things, that evaluations under the IDEA be conducted by knowledgeable personnel using a variety of validated assessment tools and strategies, and that they assess the child in all areas of suspected disability. Id. They also require LEA evaluators to review existing evaluation data on the child, including information provided by the child’s parents, teachers and service providers. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

The Student asserts that he was inappropriately assessed by the District in the areas of visual and auditory processing, social/emotional development, and motor planning. These allegations are addressed in turn below.

A. Visual and auditory processing (2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years)

The Student contends that the visual and auditory processing assessments were inappropriate because the visual and auditory processing assessments agreed to in the June 2001 IEP never were performed. (Footnote 9) He also asserts that an auditory processing assessment should have been conducted by a certified audiologist, and that such an assessment conducted by audiologist Carol Atkins in October 2004 identified severe auditory processing deficits that should have been identified and addressed by the District in 2001. The District responds that STUDENT was appropriately assessed in the area of auditory and visual processing in Dr. Simonds’ June 2001 psychoeducational assessment.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position persuasive. The psychoeducational assessment conducted by school psychologist Dr. Simonds in June 2001 addressed STUDENT’s visual and auditory processing skills by testing his abilities to analyze pictorial information, engage in visual planning, aurally process word sounds and sequences, understand verbal instructions, and remember visual and aural information. (Footnote 10) Although Dr. Simonds is not a certified audiologist, the law does not require assessments to be performed by individuals with specified degrees or areas of expertise; rather, it requires that assessments be performed by trained and knowledgeable personnel. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

Dr. Simonds is a fully credentialed school psychologist with advanced degrees in educational psychology and over twenty-five years’ experience in his field. He testified persuasively regarding his background and experience, and explained his assessment tests in great detail. Further, the STUDENT provided no evidence that Dr. Simonds was insufficiently trained or knowledgeable to assess STUDENT in the areas of visual and auditory processing. The Hearing Officer is satisfied that Dr. Simonds was qualified to administer the visual and auditory processing tests he gave to STUDENT in June 2001.

Dr. Simonds determined that STUDENT’s visual processing abilities were strong overall and were markedly superior to his auditory processing skills, which were weakest in the area of remembering lengthy and complex verbal information. Dr. Simonds presented his assessment report to STUDENT’s IEP team on August 17, 2001, and the IEP team decided to implement several of his recommendations to address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits in the classroom, such as seating STUDENT in the front of the class, making sure he understood verbal instructions, and using visual aids to supplement verbal instructions. (D. Exhs. 11, 21; testimony of Ms. Matich.)

Although the Student asserts that Ms. Atkins’ October 2004 assessment provided a more accurate picture of his auditory processing abilities, the District’s assessment cannot be judged exclusively in hindsight. Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 99th Cir. 1999). Rather, the appropriateness of the District’s June 2001 assessment must be determined in light of the information available to it at the time the assessment was conducted. Id. In this case, the Student provided no contemporaneous evidence contradicting Dr. Simonds’ findings with regard to STUDENT’s visual and auditory processing skills. In fact, his findings were consistent with MOTHER’s opinion, expressed at the June 2001 IEP meeting, that STUDENT had strong visual skills but had difficulties with auditory processing. (S. Exh. 46.) Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Atkins’ October 2004 assessment, though more detailed than that conducted by Dr. Simonds in June 2001, reached similar conclusions and made similar recommendations to those in Dr. Simonds’ assessment. (S. Exhs. 1109-1114; testimony of Ms. Atkins.)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT for visual and auditory processing deficits for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years.

B. Social/emotional development (2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years)

The Student asserts that Ms. Wellner’s administration of the FEAS to STUDENT in November 2001 was flawed because Ms. Wellner obtained only minimal parental input in conducting the assessment. Further, the Student alleges that the District’s failure to use any social/emotional assessment standard other than the FEAS violated federal law prohibiting a school district from using “any single procedure as the sole criterion for determining . . . an appropriate education program for the child.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(B). The District responds that its administration of the FEAS was appropriate, and that it appropriately developed the social/emotional component of the Student’s program.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the District’s position. First, the adequacy of Ms. Wellner’s administration of the FEAS test already has been established through earlier due process proceedings, and may not be revisited in this Decision. (Footnote 11) Second, the assertion that the FEAS test was the sole criterion used by the District to determine the social/emotional content of STUDENT’s education program is contrary to the evidence. Both the District psychoeducational assessment and the CCR assessment conducted in June 2001 specifically addressed STUDENT’s social deficits, and both assessment reports were used as a basis for developing the social goals and objectives in his 2001-2002 educational program. (Footnote 12) (D. Exhs. 20, 21; S. Exhs. 62-69.) The Student has not disputed the adequacy of either of these assessments.

In contrast to the psychoeducational and CCR assessments relied upon by the District to develop the social aspect of STUDENT’s educational program, the FEAS is an assessment tool designed by DIR founder Dr. Greenspan to determine a student’s developmental level in accordance with DIR principles. (S. Exhs. 83-90, 405-423.) The August and October 2001 IEPs makes clear that the FEAS was intended to lay the groundwork for STUDENT’s DIR services, and that it was conducted after STUDENT’s social goals and objectives in the classroom already were in place. (S. Exhs. 62-69, 77.)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s administration of the FEAS did not violate statutory prohibitions against using a single procedure as the sole criterion for the development of the social/emotional content of STUDENT’s educational program for the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years.

C. Motor planning (2002-2003 school year)

The Student contends that the District failed to timely conduct a motor planning assessment for STUDENT after agreeing to do so in August 2002. The District does not disagree with this contention, but notes that it belatedly offered the Student an assessment plan to which his parents did not respond.

At the August 23, 2002 IEP meeting, MOTHER asked that a motor planning goal be developed for STUDENT because she had noticed he was unable to sing and do another activity at the same time. MOTHER was concerned that this deficit might impair STUDENT’s ability to listen and take notes in the classroom. The District agreed that an OT assessment would be conducted to determine the need for therapy or goals in this area. (S. Exh. 120.) However, the District provided no evidence that an assessment plan ever was provided to the FAMILIES.

The record of the next IEP meeting on September 6, 2002, contains no reference to the offered OT assessment. (S. Exhs. 125-129.) Beginning October 9, STUDENT was absent from school due to problems with asthma. At the November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, MOTHER indicated that STUDENT would remain absent for medical reasons for an undetermined period of time. She declined the District’s offer of OT services at home, but noted that the promised OT assessment had not yet occurred. SELPA OT provider Ms. Wray offered to perform the assessment at the OT center, and MOTHER tentatively agreed to bring STUDENT to the OT center on November 27. However, STUDENT was ill on that date, and the OT assessment was not performed on November 27 or at any time thereafter. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

On February 5, 2003, the Hearing Office decision in SN02-02070 ordered the District to complete an OT assessment regarding STUDENT’s motor planning abilities and to convene an IEP meeting to determine whether additional goals or services were needed. On February 7, the District sent a motor planning assessment plan to the FAMILIES requesting their consent for the assessment to go forward. (D. Exh. 40, p. 340.) There was no evidence that the FAMILIES ever responded to the District’s request.

In April 2004, the District resumed IEP meetings for STUDENT after his parents expressed an interest in returning him to the District for the 2004-2005 school year. In June 2004, a comprehensive OT assessment of STUDENT was conducted by SELPA OT providers Ms. Wray and Ms. Fairchild. The assessment found that STUDENT was “below average or mildly deficient” in his motor planning abilities, but concluded that overall, STUDENT did not need OT intervention to access his education at this time. (D. Exh. 41.) (Footnote 13)

Although the District failed to develop a motor planning assessment plan until February 2003, seven months after it originally offered to conduct the assessment, there was no evidence that the District’s failure to timely conduct the assessment contributed to the FAMILIES decision to remove STUDENT from school. Further, the Student has alleged no continuing injury or disadvantage resulting from this failure that interfered with his ability to benefit from his education. See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A) (IEPs must address disabilities that affect a child’s “involvement and progress in the general curriculum”); 34 C.F.R. § 300.24(a) (related services such as OT must be provided “as required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education”[emphasis added]). (Footnote 14)

In addition, Ms. Wray testified persuasively that STUDENT’s OT needs were appropriately addressed in the 2002-2003 school year. During that period, STUDENT received fifteen minutes of OT consultation per week to address his sensory input needs. (Footnote 15) Ms. Wray and Ms. Fairchild instructed STUDENT’s classroom IA in various strategies to improve STUDENT’s body awareness and control, such as “heavy work” (moving boxes, “animal walking” on all fours) and use of playground equipment to increase his balance and coordination. Ms. Wray testified that STUDENT made “wonderful progress” in his overall motor abilities.

Finally, when the District did offer a motor planning assessment plan, the FAMILIES did not respond to the offer. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to timely assess STUDENT with respect to motor planning, but also finds that this failure resulted in no evident disadvantage that interfered with STUDENT’s ability to progress in the general curriculum.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately assessed STUDENT in the areas of visual and auditory processing and social/emotional development. With respect to motor planning, the District failed to timely assess STUDENT in accordance with its agreement, but the Student has alleged no disadvantage that interfered with his ability to benefit from his education.

Issue No. 2: Did the District provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE, but ones that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the disabled student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201. While this requires an LEA to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). (Footnote 16)

In summary, a determination of whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE requires the Hearing Officer to examine (1) whether the District met the IDEA’s procedural requirements, and (2) whether the substantive program offered to STUDENT was individually designed to meet his needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP.

A. Procedural issues

The Student asserts that his 2001-2002 educational program was procedurally flawed because his teacher and other appropriate personnel were not present at all of his IEP meetings, and because the District failed to identify the accommodations made to address his auditory processing deficits. These allegations are addressed in turn below.

(1) Were appropriate personnel present at STUDENT’s IEP meetings?

The Student asserts that the District failed to have his teacher, S/L, and OT service providers present at all of his IEP meetings during the 2001-2002 school year. (Footnote 17)

One of the procedural safeguards afforded by the IDEA is the right to have appropriate people attending IEP meetings to make decisions about a disabled Petitioner’s education. Federal law provides that an IEP team must include, among others:

(i) the parents of a child with a disability;

(ii) at least one regular education teacher of such child (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment); (iii) at least one special education teacher, or where appropriate, at least one special education provider of such child; (iv) a representative of the local educational agency [with specified knowledge and qualifications]; (v) an individual who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results [who may also qualify as a team member in another category]; (vi) at the discretion of the parent or the agency, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child, including related service personnel as appropriate; and (vii) whenever appropriate, the child with a disability.

20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B) (emphasis added); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a). In addition, the law provides that the child’s regular education teacher “shall, to the extent appropriate,” participate in the development of the child’s IEP and in a periodic review of the IEP that shall occur “no less than annually.” 20 U.S.C. §§ 1414(d)(3)(C), 1414(d)(4)(B).

The IEP documents from STUDENT’s first grade year indicate that his teacher, Ms. Matich, was present at the IEP meeting on June 6, 2001, when STUDENT’s first grade program was developed, and at his year-end review on May 30, 2002, when his goals and objectives were reviewed in conjunction with the development of his second grade program. (D. Exhs. 4, 12.) Ms. Matich testified that she believed that she also attended STUDENT’s August 17, 2001 IEP meeting, but did not sign the IEP because she was excused by administrators after three hours but before the meeting was concluded. Finally, the notes to STUDENT’s September 12, 2001 IEP indicate that Ms. Matich was present, although she did not sign the document. (Footnote 18)

The documents relating to the other five IEP meetings held between October 2001 and May 2002 show no evidence of Ms. Matich’s participation. As the law makes no provision for the convening of IEP meetings in the absence of any of the statutorily required team members, Ms. Matich’s absence from those meetings constituted a procedural failing by the District. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that this failing did not result in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT, nor did it seriously infringe upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. See W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, supra, 960 F.2d 1479.

The five IEP meetings held between October 26, 2001 and May 7, 2002, appear to have been held primarily to discuss STUDENT’s DIR services (provided at home and during recess at school), the continued services of his “shadow aide” (hired by the FAMILES, and not under Ms. Matich’s supervision), and OT and S/L services provided outside the classroom. The meeting notes reveal no discussions of the generalization of skills or the integration of services within STUDENT’s regular education program, or of any concerns about Ms. Matich’s delivery of that program. Further, Ms. Matich testified that the FAMILIES never voiced any concerns to her about STUDENT’s progress in her class, and there was no evidence that the FAMILIES requested her presence at these interim IEP meetings. Finally, the IEP notes and Ms. Matich’s testimony confirm that she was present and actively participated in the development of STUDENT’s program at his annual IEP meetings. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Matich’s absence from the IEP meetings between October 26, 2001, and May 7, 2002, constituted a procedural violation of the IDEA, but did not result in a denial of FAPE.

The Student also asserts that the District erred by failing to have his S/L and OT providers present at several of his IEP meetings, and by having only administrators present at some meetings. The Hearing Officer finds no error.

Federal law requires the District to have service providers present at IEP meetings “as appropriate” and “at the discretion of the parent or agency.” 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B). The IEP documents for the 2001-2002 school year indicate that the S/L therapist, Ms. Hilbrands, was present at the October 26, 2001 IEP meeting, when STUDENT’s S/L assessment was discussed and his S/L services determined, and again at the May 30, 2002 meeting to report on his progress and develop his S/L goals for the next year. (D. Exhs. 4, 9.)

The notes to the April 26, 2002 IEP indicate that an OT provider was present to discuss STUDENT’s OT assessment and plan his oral exercise program, and OT provider Ms. Wray was present at the May 30, 2002 IEP to discuss his classroom accommodations and to plan for the coming year. (D. Exhs. 4, 6.) (Footnote 19) The other IEP meetings held in the 2001-2002 school year focused almost exclusively on the provision of STUDENT’s DIR services, and were attended by the District administrators and SELPA personnel responsible for those services.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately exercised its discretion to ensure the attendance of personnel relevant to the issues being discussed at STUDENT’s IEP meetings, and that the absence of STUDENT’s OT and S/L providers from some of those meetings did not constitute a procedural flaw.

(2) Did the District appropriately identify the accommodations made to address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits?

The Student asserts that his August 17, 2001 IEP failed to identify what accommodations and supports would be provided to compensate for his auditory processing deficits.

State law provides that an IEP shall include, among other things, “a statement of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided” for the student to advance toward his or her annual goals, progress in the general curriculum, and participate with other students in educational activities. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3). In Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the purpose of a formal, written offer of an LEA’s proposed educational program was to create a clear record of, among other things, “what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.”

STUDENT’s first grade program was developed at IEP meetings held on June 6 and August 17, 2001. At the June 6 meeting, the IEP notes indicate that, as “program modifications and support,” his general education teacher would receive training about autism, and STUDENT would be provided with a “shadow aide” in the classroom. (D. Exh. 21.)

At the August 17 IEP meeting, Dr. Simonds presented his psychoeducational assessment report and suggested accommodations to help compensate for STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits in the classroom. Specifically, Dr. Simonds recommended that STUDENT be seated up front and engaged in frequent eye contact; that he be given verbal instructions in small doses, assisted by visual cues; that he be encouraged to seek help when necessary; that he be given repeated opportunities to answer questions correctly; and that he get extra help learning key concepts by relating the material to previously learned information; and that he be praised and encouraged regularly. (Testimony of Dr. Simonds.)

The IEP team discussed the assessment report, and formulated goals relating to eye contact and answering questions that incorporated two of Dr. Simonds’ recommended accommodations. The team also noted that STUDENT might have difficulty with oral instructions, and decided that visual prompts such as posting a written schedule or writing instructions on the blackboard would be useful accommodations for him. Further, the team noted that due to STUDENT’s strong reading skills, his reading materials might need to be “modified to a higher level.” However, these discussions were not set forth as express modifications to STUDENT’s program. (D. Exh. 11.)

STUDENT started school on August 20, 2001. At the hearing, his first grade teacher, Ms. Matich, testified that in order to help STUDENT learn, she seated him in the front of the class, prompted him to make frequent eye contact with her, called on him regularly to answer questions, and often had him read instructions to the rest of the class – a strategy that involved him and made him a “leader” while also ensuring that he understood the directions he was relating to others. Ms. Matich also labeled items in the classroom for STUDENT’s benefit. (Testimony of Ms. Matich.)

As provided for in the June 6 IEP, STUDENT also was supported in the classroom by a rotating group of “shadow aides” to help him stay on task, prompt him to interact with his peers, and observe and record his behavior. Daily notes kept by the aides confirm that in addition to giving oral instructions, Ms. Matich wrote instructions on the blackboard for STUDENT to read; called on him regularly to make sure he was understanding the lessons; used prompts to help him correct errors in his work; and gave him praise and other positive reinforcements. In a note to MOTHER dated September 25, 2001, an aide observed, “STUDENT definitely has enough support from Ms. Matich.” (S. Exhs. 922-1039.)

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated its procedural obligations to set forth in writing in STUDENT’s IEP the accommodations and supports it would provide to address STUDENT’s auditory processing deficits during the 2001-2002 school year. Although two of Dr. Simonds’ recommended accommodations were expressly incorporated in STUDENT’s IEP as goals (eye contact and answering questions), many other program modifications recommended by Dr. Simonds and provided by Ms. Matich (seating STUDENT in the front of the class, using visual cues, making sure he understood directions, praising him frequently) were not set forth in STUDENT’s IEP as required by law.

Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s procedural violation neither resulted in a loss of educational opportunity to STUDENT nor seriously infringed upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process. STUDENT received the full benefit of the accommodations described above despite the District’s failure to identify all of them in his IEP. Further, the FAMILIES were aware that Ms. Matich was providing additional auditory processing accommodations through the daily notes prepared by STUDENT’s shadow aides, who reported directly to the FAMILIES.

In Union, the Ninth Circuit explained that the purpose of a formal written IEP is to help parents decide whether to accept an LEA’s program offer, to assist them in bringing complaints about the program, and to avoid later factual disputes about the program. Here, the FAMILIES accepted the District’s 2001-2002 program offer despite the fact that only two auditory processing accommodations were set forth in the August 17 IEP. They were made aware of Ms. Matich’s additional accommodations through their aides’ reports, and they raised no complaints about the adequacy of those accommodations. Finally, no factual dispute about the provision of these accommodations was raised at the hearing. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to set forth in writing all of the accommodations made to address STUDENT’s auditory processing needs, while constituting a procedural flaw, did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.

B. Substantive issues

A review of the District’s 2001-2002 program for substantive appropriateness first requires a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs, as indicated by the nature and scope of his impairment and his then-current levels of functioning. The District’s program then will be reviewed to determine if it was designed to meet his unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and comported with his IEP.

(1) STUDENT’s unique needs

STUDENT was diagnosed with autism at age two, and there appears to be no dispute that he shows significant symptoms of autism spectrum disorder, particularly in the areas of social/emotional development and pragmatic communication skills. From an early age, STUDENT has shown developmental delays in his ability to make sustained eye contact; initiate and maintain social interactions, particularly with peers; recognize social norms and boundaries; and understand and express emotional concepts.

The 2001 assessments of STUDENT’s social skills indicated that he was responsive to adults and had made some friends in kindergarten, but had difficulty maintaining eye contact and was uninterested and unskilled in initiating social contacts with most peers. In pragmatic speech, STUDENT could not maintain extended conversations, often stood too close to others, spoke in a loud and high-pitched voice, and at times used idiosyncratic, repetitive phrases unrelated to the conversation.

STUDENT also had difficulty articulating some consonant sounds, and could not tolerate some food textures. In a 1999 OT assessment, he showed “mild to moderate” motor planning delays when he had to stop and consider how to get into a car, approach a swing, or catch a ball. STUDENT also showed a need for continual vestibular and proprioceptive sensory input, which he achieved through running and sliding, and oral sensory input, which he achieved through chewing on his shirt and mouthing other objects. (D. Exhs. 12, 21, 22; testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Matich.) (Footnote 20)

STUDENT’s 2001 psychoeducational assessment indicated that his cognitive abilities were markedly superior to his social skills. He tested in the low average range in overall IQ, but above average in academic achievement. He was a strong visual learner, but his auditory processing skills were deficient, and he was easily distracted from tasks. Physically, STUDENT had average gross motor skills, but exhibited deficits in motor planning, fine motor skills, and sensory integration. Finally, STUDENT periodically engaged in repetitive and self-stimulatory behavior such as idiosyncratic speech, hand flapping, and “zoning out” (unfocused staring).

Academically, STUDENT had average skills in math and above average skills in reading recognition, comprehension, and spelling. His weakest academic abilities were in working memory and in auditory processing of complex information.

In summary, STUDENT’s greatest deficits at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year were in social/emotional development and pragmatic communication, with additional deficits in auditory processing, sensory integration, and motor planning. The parties generally agree that his unique needs included social skill development, speech therapy to address his articulation and pragmatic speech deficits, classroom accommodations to address his auditory processing and sensory integration needs, and a reduction in his oral seeking behaviors. (Footnote 21)

The parties disagree, however, as to whether those needs were met. The areas of their disagreement are discussed below. (2) Was the District’s 2001-2002 program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and was it reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

STUDENT began first grade on August 20, 2001. His educational program consisted of placement in a regular education first grade class five days per week; one-to-one assistance in the classroom by a “shadow aide” (hired by STUDENT’s parents and reimbursed by the District) for three and one-half hours of the five-hour school day; thirty to forty-five minutes of OT services per week; and a supervised in-home program of DTT services. (D. Exh. 12.) In late October, after STUDENT’s S/L assessment was completed, he began to receive thirty minutes of individual and thirty minutes of group S/L services per week.

The Student asserts that the District failed to use appropriate methods to measure his progress on his goals and objectives, and failed to adequately address his behavioral and oral sensory needs. Each of these allegations is addressed in turn below.

(a) Did the District use appropriate methods to measure STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives?

Federal law requires an IEP to be set forth in writing and to include, in relevant part, (1) a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance, including how the child’s disability affects his or her involvement or progress in the general curriculum;

(2) a statement of measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the child’s disability-related educational needs; and (3) a statement of how the child’s progress toward the annual goals will be measured.

See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d).

The Student alleges that the District failed to include “baseline” information in his IEP and failed to indicate how his goals would be measured. (Footnote 22) The District responds that its methods for measuring STUDENT’s progress were appropriate. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the District’s position.

First, the Hearing Officer notes that the law requires “a statement of the child’s present levels of educational performance,” not specific baseline information measuring current abilities in relation to future goals. See id. STUDENT’s June 6, 2001 IEP document reflects the initial planning stages of his 2001-2002 program, and includes a report from STUDENT’s kindergarten teacher on his current math and reading skills, classroom behavior, ability to follow directions, fine motor skills, and social development. (D. Exh. 12.) Based on these present levels of STUDENT’s educational performance, his IEP team determined that a regular education first grade class would be an appropriate placement for him. (Id.)

At the August 27, 2001 IEP meeting, the team received additional information from Dr. Simonds’ psychoeducational assessment, which analyzed STUDENT’s IQ, academic achievement, communication skills, memory skills, and reasoning ability, and explained how his deficits – most notably in the area of auditory processing – might affect his educational progress. The team also reviewed the CCR report on STUDENT’s social skills and deficits, which noted how his poor skills in initiating peer interactions were affecting him on the school playground. (D. Exhs. 11, 20, 21.) Based upon these assessments of STUDENT’s abilities and present levels of performance, which revealed grade-level academic strengths but notable weaknesses in pragmatic communication and social development, the team developed six social/communication goals for STUDENT’s first grade year. (D. Exh. 11.) (Footnote 23) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEPs included appropriate statements of his present levels of educational performance.

Second, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s IEP set forth measurable goals and an appropriate system of measurement. STUDENT’s social goals required him to (1) engage in up to six cycles of conversation at a time; (2) initiate peer interactions six times per day; (3) make eye contact during conversations eighty-five percent of the time; (4) answer questions in complete sentences with progressively fewer prompts; and (5-6) modulate his voice to match his environment with progressively fewer prompts. The August 27 IEP indicates that the goals would be implemented by “regular education staff” and would be measured by observation.

STUDENT’s first grade teacher, Ms. Matich, personally implemented the first four goals by engaging STUDENT in extended conversations, making him “leader for the day,” which required him to give instructions to other students, encouraging him to make eye contact either through a verbal prompt or by touching his shoulder, and prompting STUDENT to answer in complete sentences. Ms. Matich collected data on STUDENT’s performance to measure his progress on his goals. (Testimony of Ms. Matich.)

After the District began to provide S/L services to STUDENT in late October, his social goals also were addressed by District S/L therapist Ms. Hilbrands, who held small group sessions in which students initiated and responded to conversations with each other. Ms. Hilbrands also addressed STUDENT’s voice modulation goals in individual therapy sessions, and collected data on his progress. Both Ms. Hilbrands and Ms. Matich reported on STUDENT’s progress on his goals at his annual IEP on May 30, 2002. STUDENT met all of his social goals except the ones relating to initiating peer interactions and maintaining eye contact. These goals were carried over to the 2002-2003 school year. (D. Exh. 4; testimony of Ms. Hilbrands.)

Although STUDENT’s 2001-2002 IEP reveals only that his goals would be measured by “observation,” the Hearing Officer finds that observation was adequate to measure these goals. Neither federal nor State law express a preference for any particular system of measurement, and STUDENT’s goals involved speech and actions that were easily observed and tracked through data collection. See 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(viii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345. Ms. Matich and Ms. Hilbrands persuasively testified that they personally implemented the goals, observed and recorded his progress, and reported on his progress at STUDENT’s annual IEP. Further, STUDENT accomplished four of these six goals during his first grade year.

Based on the above, the Hearing Office finds that STUDENT’s 2001-2002 IEP appropriately set forth his present levels of educational performance and included an appropriate system of measurement for those goals.

(b) Was STUDENT’s program designed to meet his behavioral needs, and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

In addressing a disabled student’s behavioral needs, the student’s IEP team must consider the inclusion of positive behavioral interventions and supports if the student’s behavior “impedes his or her learning or that of others.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.346. If those behavioral supports prove ineffective or if the student otherwise exhibits a “serious behavior problem,” State law requires the student’s IEP team to conduct a functional analysis assessment (FAA) as a basis for developing a behavioral intervention plan (BIP) for that student. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, §§ 3001(f), 3001(aa), 3052.

The Student does not allege that he has a serious behavior problem warranting an FAA or a BIP. Rather, he alleges that the District failed to consider behavioral interventions and supports warranted by his self-stimulatory and noncompliant behaviors in the spring of 2002. MOTHER testified that during this period, STUDENT was engaging in self-stimulatory behaviors such as idiosyncratic language and hand-flapping. Further, he was becoming increasingly noncompliant and was engaging in tantrums at home and at school. At an April 26, 2002 IEP meeting, MOTHER informed the IEP team of her concerns regarding these behaviors and asked that a behavioral plan be developed to address them, but the District failed to do so.

In response, the District asserts that its educational program appropriately addressed STUDENT’s behavioral needs, and that STUDENT did not exhibit behavioral problems that would warrant a behavioral plan.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position to be persuasive. Ms. Matich, STUDENT’s first grade teacher, testified that she had “no problems” with STUDENT in her class. He paid attention, did his classwork and homework, made friends, and generally behaved well. When he became distracted, she redirected him through eye contact and other prompts. When he misbehaved, she talked to him or disciplined him as she did her other students. On STUDENT’s first grade report card, Ms. Matich graded his performance as “satisfactory” in all areas of behavior and compliance. (D. Exh. 489.)

A review of daily behavior logs kept by STUDENT’s classroom aides in the spring of 2002 supports Ms. Matich’s testimony that STUDENT generally was a well-behaved student whose episodes of noncompliance were appropriately addressed by his aides, playground staff, or his teacher. The logs indicate that from time to time, STUDENT engaged in brief tantrums when the recess bell rang before he had finished playing or when he had to share play equipment with another child. On those occasions, STUDENT calmed down after being talked to by his aide or playground staff. (S. Exhs. 922-1086.) (Footnote 24)

In addition, STUDENT’s DIR goals were directed in part to improving his ability to express needs and emotions in a manner that would help him avoid noncompliant or aggressive behavior. Ms. Wellner testified that in the spring of 2002, she began to teach STUDENT’s aides and playground staff DIR-based strategies to increase STUDENT’s compliance with directives such as lining up for activities, sharing playground equipment, and returning to class from recess. Ms. Wellner testified that these strategies were successful, and that she did not believe STUDENT needed a behavior plan.

STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors were addressed primarily by his OT and S/L service providers. The most pervasive of these behaviors, shirt-chewing and other oral seeking activities, were addressed by his OT through oral sensory exercises administered at lunch and recess breaks. (Footnote 25) During class, these behaviors were addressed by an OT accommodation noted in his IEP – the provision of a “chewy” or oral fidget to redirect STUDENT from mouthing or chewing on inappropriate items. (D. Exh. 4.) Ms. Matich testified that she successfully redirected STUDENT to his chewy when he engaged in oral seeking behaviors in class.

STUDENT’s idiosyncratic language was addressed by his S/L therapist, Ms. Hilbrands, who worked with him individually and in small social-skills groups. In the classroom, STUDENT engaged in other self-stimulatory behavior from time to time (visual fixations, putting hands in pants), but responded to prompt redirection by his teacher or his aides. (S. Exhs. 1081-1086; testimony of Ms. Matich.)

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s program was designed to meet his behavioral needs, and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit. First, STUDENT’s assessments did not identify any marked tendencies to noncompliance or aggression that warranted behavior supports or a behavior plan in his 2001-2002 program. Second, there was no evidence to suggest that his behavior during the school year impeded his learning or that of others. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.346.

On the contrary, STUDENT’s teacher testified that his behavior was within normal limits for first graders, and his episodes of misbehavior were addressed as part of her normal classroom discipline for all students. To the extent STUDENT’s social deficits may have contributed to his frustrations in interacting with his peers, STUDENT’s DIR goals were directed at improving his ability to communicate and to express his feelings, and Ms. Wellner testified that STUDENT made progress in those areas.

Finally, STUDENT’s most significant self-stimulatory behaviors were addressed by his OT and S/L services, and by the provision of an OT device to redirect him from oral seeking behaviors in class. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s 2001-2002 program appropriately addressed his behavioral needs.

(c) Was STUDENT’s program designed to meet his oral sensory needs, and reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit?

The Student asserts that the District failed to appropriately addresss his oral sensory deficits, which resulted in persistent articulation problems and inappropriate oral seeking behaviors.

Under the IDEA and State law, a disabled student is entitled to both specially designed instruction and “related services” to help the student benefit from his education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(7); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2). In designing an IEP with instruction and services to address the student’s unique needs, the local education agency (LEA) first conducts assessments of those needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414. State law provides that an IEP required as a result of an assessment shall be developed within 50 days of the parents’ written consent for assessment, unless the parent agrees in writing to an extension. Cal. Educ. Code § 56043(d).

The evidence does not indicate when the FAMILYs gave written consent for STUDENT’s 2001 assessments. However, the June 6, 2001 IEP meeting notes state that an OT assessment already had been performed, and that several other assessments, including an S/L assessment, would be conducted prior to the development of STUDENT’s annual goals. The FAMILIES signed a waiver extending the triennial assessment to July 30, 2001. Two of the planned assessments were performed over the next several weeks, and their results were reported to the IEP team on August 17, 2001, prior to the beginning of the school year. At that time, the IEP team developed annual goals, including an OT goal addressing STUDENT’s consonant articulation problems and his oral defensiveness to certain food textures. (D. Exhs. 11, 12.)

STUDENT’s S/L assessment, however, was not completed until mid-September, and the assessment report was not delivered to his IEP team until October 26, 2001. (Footnote 26) The assessment indicated that STUDENT had pragmatic speech deficits and a “severe oral motor sensory disorder” affecting his articulation. On October 26, the team agreed that STUDENT should receive sixty minutes of S/L services per week, as well as a program of sensory and oral motor exercises through SELPA OT provider Misti Fairchild, who already provided STUDENT with OT services for thirty to forty-five minutes per week. (D. Exhs. 9, 12.)

The District provided no evidence as to what sensory and oral motor exercises were added to STUDENT’s OT program as a result of the October 26 IEP meeting. In an OT assessment conducted on November 9, 2001, Ms. Fairchild indicated that STUDENT no longer showed consistent oral seeking behaviors such as chewing on his shirt, and recommended discontinuing direct OT services in favor of OT consultation. The FAMILIES disagreed with that assessment, and no reduction in OT services occurred at that time. (S. Exhs. 81-82; 97-98.)

Behavior logs kept by STUDENT’s aides between March and June of 2002 indicate that despite his OT services, STUDENT continued to engage in shirt-chewing and other oral stimulatory behavior at school, but was effectively redirected when told to stop or when given gum or a chewy as a substitute. (S. Exhs. 1081-1086.) At an April 26 IEP meeting, the team agreed to implement the Beckman Oral Motor Protocol (BOMP), a series of oral stimulatory exercises to be administered several times a day over a twelve-week period. In addition, Ms. Fairchild developed a goal to help STUDENT decrease his oral seeking behaviors. (S. Exh. 99.) Ms. Fairchild and Gayle Wray, another SELPA OT provider, trained STUDENT’s home tutors and school staff to administer the BOMP exercises. (Testimony of Ms. Wray.)

At the May 30 IEP meeting, the team agreed to continue the goal to extinguish oral seeking behaviors for the 2002-2003 school year. MOTHER did not sign this IEP, and filed an addendum protesting the fact that the BOMP program would not be completed by the time school ended on June 14, 2002. (S. Exhs. 108-116, 123.)

Based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the District violated its statutory obligation to timely develop an IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s oral sensory needs. Although the FAMILIES signed a waiver of assessment deadlines through July 30, 2001, and the further delay in the S/L assessment was due in part to summer vacation not counted under the statutory timeline, STUDENT did not receive S/L services addressing his articulation needs or OT services addressing his oral seeking behaviors until October 26, over fifty calendar days after the beginning of school on August 20, 2001. (Footnote 27)

Ms. Hilbrands testified persuasively that after S/L services began in October, she implemented STUDENT’s articulation goal and that he made progress on the goal, and the Student has provided no evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to appropriately address STUDENT’s articulation needs from August 17, 2001 (the date his goals were developed for the 2001-2002 school year) through October 26, 2001.

With respect to STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors, however, the District provided no evidence as to the nature or extent of sensory oral exercises provided to STUDENT by Ms. Fairchild between the October 26, 2001 decision to begin such exercises and the April 26, 2002 decision to implement the BOMP program. This lack of evidence, considered in light of Ms. Fairchild’s November 9 determination that STUDENT no longer engaged in consistent oral seeking behaviors (a finding contradicted by Ms. Matich and by STUDENT’s shadow aides), implies that an adequate program to address such behaviors was not occurring during that period. Further, the District did not indicate whether or how the BOMP protocol, begun the last week of April 2002, was carried out after the school year ended on June 14, only six weeks into the twelve-week program.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2001-2002 school year, the District failed to design a program to meet STUDENT’s oral sensory needs that was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District developed appropriate methods to measure STUDENT’s progress on his goals and objectives and appropriately addressed his behavioral needs. With respect to his oral sensory needs, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to appropriately address his articulation deficits from August 17-October 26, 2001, and failed to appropriately address his oral seeking behaviors during the 2001-2002 school year.

(3) Did the District’s 2001-2002 program comport with STUDENT’s IEP?

The Student alleges that his 2001-2002 program failed to comport with his IEP because the District failed to adequately implement a social/emotional component of the program based on the “Developmental, Individual and Relationship” (DIR) intervention model. (Footnote 28) Specifically, the Student alleges that the SELPA’s contract with PCDA to provide DIR training and consulting services was not fully carried out; that as a result, the DIR program was not timely provided; and that SELPA program specialist Ms. Wellner was inadequately trained to supervise his DIR services without PCDA’s support.

The District concedes that the SELPA-PCDA contract was not fully executed, and that SELPA program specialist Ms. Wellner did not receive all of the DIR training and consultation anticipated by the contract. However, it argues that DIR services were timely provided, that Ms. Wellner was fully qualified to supervise the DIR element of STUDENT’s program, and that she supervised his DIR services appropriately.

(a) Were STUDENT’s DIR services timely provided?

Federal and State regulations require IEPs to be implemented “as soon as possible” after a determination is made to provide special education and related services to an eligible child. 34 C.F.R. § 300.342(b)(ii); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3040(a).

At an IEP meeting on October 26, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team set a “target date” of December 3, 2001, for full implementation of DIR services. (D. Exh. 9.) Ms. Wellner’s FEAS assessment of STUDENT, conducted to determine his social/emotional development level for DIR purposes, was completed on November 15, and her DIR goals were accepted by the IEP team on November 26. (D. Exh. 8.)

By all accounts, however, DIR services were not “fully implemented” by the target date. Ms. Wellner began weekly classroom observations of STUDENT on December 4, and met with STUDENT’s parents and home tutors on December 10 to discuss her observations and to plan the transition from DTT to DIR services. In mid-December, PCDA conducted a three-day training workshop for the FAMILIES and other District parents interested in DIR services. (D. Exhs. 8, 26, 28; testimony of Ms. Wellner.)

According to Ms. Wellner, the full implementation of STUDENT’s DIR services was further delayed by difficulties she experienced in hiring aides for STUDENT’s school DIR services and in scheduling meetings with his home tutors. (Footnote 29) In a January 30, 2002 letter to the FAMILIES, Ms. Wellner provided a final schedule for the aides and stated that full DIR services would be implemented on February 4, 2002. In a second letter dated February 4, Ms. Wellner noted that the FAMILIES had disagreed with the proposed schedule, and as a result the full implementation of the program would have to be resolved at an IEP meeting the next week. (S. Exhs. 92-94.)

At the February 14 IEP meeting, Ms. Wellner and the FAMILIES discussed the scheduling problems for home and school DIR sessions, and agreed that the next home DIR meeting would be held on February 28. STUDENT would continue to be provided with an “informal type DIR program” until the meeting, at which time the “final parameters” of the services would be decided. This was the last IEP consented to by the FAMILIES. (D. Exh. 7; testimony of Ms. Wellner and MOTHER.)

Beginning on February 28, Ms. Wellner conducted weekly classroom visits and DIR consultations with STUDENT’s aides at school, and twice-monthly DIR training and supervision meetings with STUDENT’s home tutors. At the next IEP meeting on April 26, MOTHER expressed dissatisfaction with PCDA’s failure to attend home DIR meetings in accordance with its contract. (Footnote 30) She asked that Kelli Wilms of Playworks, a local NPA, be retained to replace both PCDA and Ms. Wellner, because she felt Ms. Wellner was inadequately trained in DIR to supervise the provision of DIR services. According to SELPA administrator Ms. Ruesterholtz, this request was denied because the SELPA believed Ms. Wilms lacked sufficient training and experience to supervise DIR services in the context of a school curriculum, whereas Ms. Wellner was qualified to supervise such services even in the absence of PCDA support. (D. Exhs. 4, 5, 6, 28; testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Wellner, and Ms. Ruesterholtz.)

The FAMILIES did not sign the April 26 IEP or any subsequent IEPs, and the DIR services supervised by Ms. Wellner continued to be provided to STUDENT at home and at school until the end of the school year. (Id.)

Based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s DIR services were timely provided by the District. Although the December 3 target date for implementation was not met, the evidence indicates that the District diligently prepared to deliver the services between October 26, 2001, when the target date was set, and February 28, 2002, when implementation occurred. The passage of four months between those dates is readily explained by the efforts required to organize this new program element and implement it for the several families who wanted to participate: Between October and February, the District and SELPA completed preliminary observations and FEAS assessments, provided the three-day parent training workshop through PCDA, hired aides, and developed and attempted to reach agreement on work and meeting schedules among the many DIR participants.

Further, the delay in implementation of DIR services did not significantly impact STUDENT’s social development, because he already was receiving social supports in the school setting. Ms. Matich worked on STUDENT’s social interaction goals in the classroom, and STUDENT made progress in engaging in cycles of communication and interacting with peers. Beginning October 2001, STUDENT received sixty minutes of S/L services per week that included small-group social skills training. According to Ms. Matich, STUDENT made friends and was socially successful in first grade.

(b) Were STUDENT’s DIR services appropriately implemented?

State law requires LEAs to provide resource specialists to deliver instruction and services to special education students who are assigned to regular classroom teachers for most of the school day. A resource specialist program must be directed by a credentialed special education teacher or clinical services specialist with at least three years of special education teaching experience. Cal. Educ. Code § 56362(a)-(b).

The District’s DIR services were delivered to eligible students by Ms. Wellner, the SELPA’s autism program specialist. The Student asserts that, due to the eventual failure of the SELPA-PCDA contract, Ms. Wellner did not receive enough DIR training to allow her to adequately train and supervise his home and school aides in implementing the services. In support of this argument, the Student introduced the testimony of PCDA director Dr. Cullinane, who testified that Ms. Wellner did not receive most of the training or consulting services anticipated by the contract. (Footnote 31)

Dr. Cullinane recalled seeing Ms. Wellner at only one five-hour DIR training session provided by PCDA, and testified to her understanding that several consulting sessions were missed due to scheduling conflicts experienced either by Ms. Wellner or by PCDA staff. She observed that proper supervision of DIR services required the supervisor to receive extensive training and mentorship, and that one could not be trained adequately simply by attending workshops and conferences. Dr. Cullinane noted that she was still in the process of receiving her own DIR certification from Dr. Greenspan, and that certification normally requires more than a year of intense training and mentorship.

In response, the District asserts that Ms. Wellner was more than qualified to supervise STUDENT’s DIR services even if no PCDA training had been provided. According to SELPA administrator Ms. Ruesterholtz, Ms. Wellner is considered a leader in autism training and education, and co-developed the autism program currently used by ten local SELPAs. When the SELPA decided to develop a DIR-specific program element after several families expressed an interest in the DIR method, PCDA was brought in to help develop the services, train parents and staff in DIR concepts and strategies, and verify that the services were “on track,” but Ms. Ruesterholtz never doubted that Ms. Wellner could supervise the SELPA’s DIR services without PCDA support.

Ms. Ruesterholtz felt that PCDA provided “excellent training,” but its follow-up consultation was “hit and miss.” When it became clear that the contract no longer was working in the spring of 2002, the SELPA did not seek to retain another DIR consultant because Ms. Wellner was qualified to supervise DIR services and was doing so successfully. Ms. Ruesterholtz noted that Ms. Wellner supervised DIR services for at least four other families without complaints.

In her testimony, Ms. Wellner explained her qualifications to administer autism programs. She has held a teaching credential since 1992 and a handicapped specialist credential since 1996, and spent four years teaching a special education class comprised mostly of children with autism. Ms. Wellner also holds master’s degrees in special education and educational administration, has taught courses on children with special needs at Riverside Community College, and has received extensive training in various autism treatment methodologies, including applied behavioral analysis/discrete trial training (ABA/DTT); the TEACCH program; DIR; Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS); social stories; and behavior intervention case management.

With respect to specific DIR training, Ms. Wellner testified that prior to 2001, she attended training sessions in the “Floortime” model, Dr. Greenspan’s initial program that he later expanded into the DIR model. She attended a three-day DIR training in November 2001 and a four-day DIR conference in April 2002, both presented by DIR founder Dr. Greenspan, as well as DIR training sessions provided by PCDA pursuant to its contract with the SELPA. Ms. Wellner acknowledged that she has not pursued a certification in DIR training, but testified that as a result of her training and experience, she felt competent to train and supervise others in the use of the DIR model. In 2002, Ms. Wellner gave DIR training sessions to District personnel on the use of the DIR model in the school setting and in relation to behavior intervention strategies. (Testimony of Ms. Wellner; D. Exh. 26.)

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wellner was adequately trained to supervise STUDENT’s DIR services. First, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Ms. Wellner was competent to administer such services despite her lack of DIR certification or failure to receive all of the PCDA training contracted for by the District: Dr. Cullinane acknowledged that most DIR providers in California are not certified, and her testimony indicated that certification is not required to adequately supervise DIR services. (Footnote 32) Ms. Wellner testified persuasively that she received substantial DIR training from several sources including PCDA, and was sufficiently well-versed in DIR fundamentals that she presented her own DIR trainings to District and SELPA personnel.

Second, Ms. Wellner’s extensive training and experience in numerous autism treatment methodologies is persuasive evidence that she is able to understand and effectively treat autism from a broad-based perspective, despite her lack of specialization in any one treatment discipline. SELPA administrator Ms. Ruesterholtz testified that she considered the variety of Ms. Wellner’s training and experience to be a significant advantage, since studies have shown that successful autism treatment usually requires an evolving series of approaches as a child grows and changes.

Finally, the evidence as to how STUDENT’s DIR services were delivered persuades the Hearing Officer that the services were appropriately implemented under Ms. Wellner’s supervision. Ms. Wellner testified that to prepare to deliver DIR services to STUDENT, she administered Dr. Greenspan’s FEAS test of STUDENT’s social/emotional development. Based on the assessment results, she developed five DIR goals that were accepted by STUDENT’s IEP team in November 2001. (Footnote 33) Ms. Wellner made weekly school visits to train STUDENT’s shadow aides in DIR principles, and provided the aides with forms to record STUDENT’s progress on his goals. She also conducted twice-monthly home DIR meetings, and had the home tutors complete similar forms. (Testimony of Ms. Wellner and MOTHER.) (Footnote 34)

In her FEAS assessment, Ms. Wellner had observed that one of STUDENT’s social deficits that might be addressed through DIR strategies was his difficulty in protesting against unwanted treatment. The notes kept by the shadow aides and home tutors indicate that STUDENT made progress in this area by telling a classmate not to pick on him, and by protesting when another classmate “cheated” during a game. STUDENT also made progress on his other DIR goals, including answering “why” questions, and talking about his feelings (being happy, amused, scared by a story, disappointed when he lost a game, “having a bad day”). (S. Exhs. 1035-1038; 1048-1080; 1087-1094.)

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wellner was adequately trained to supervise and implement STUDENT’s DIR services, and that his services were appropriately delivered in the 2001-2002 school year.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for its failure to appropriately address STUDENT’s articulation and oral sensory needs as described above, the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year.

Issue No. 3: Did the District offer and provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?

A. Did the District’s failure to offer DIR services for the 2002-2003 school year constitute a denial of FAPE?

At STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting on May 30, 2002, the team reviewed his progress in first grade and discussed his program for the 2002-2003 year. After receiving reports that STUDENT was strong academically and had achieved most of his social goals, the team discussed STUDENT’s home DIR services, but failed to agree as to whether they still were necessary. Ultimately, the District made the following offer for the 2002-2003 school year: Placement in a general education second grade class; one-to-one assistance from an IA for the full school day; two hours per week of S/L services (individual and small group); and fifteen minutes per week of OT consultation to continue to deal with STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors. (D. Exh. 4.) (Footnote 35) The FAMILIES disagreed with the offer and did not sign the IEP.

The Student asserts that the District’s failure to offer him DIR services constituted a denial of FAPE. (Footnote 36) The District responds that STUDENT was making enough social progress at school to make DIR services unnecessary to his successful education.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s evidence persuasive. Although federal and State laws require LEAs to address the social deficits of disabled students as a part of their educational development, there is no requirement that an LEA use a particular treatment methodology to do so. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(10(A)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The District and SELPA agreed to provide services using the DIR model when the FAMILIES and other parents expressed an interest in DIR methodology, but the District’s willingness to try a new approach does not negate the appropriateness of other autism treatment methodologies in treating the social/emotional deficits of children with autism.

In this case, STUDENT achieved most of his social interaction goals for the year through methodologies distinct from the DIR model. Ms. Matich, who had attended an autism overview and training session prior to STUDENT’s enrollment in her first grade class, worked on several of STUDENT’s goals in the classroom, including engaging in six cycles of communication and answering in complete sentences. STUDENT achieved those goals, and made progress on his eye contact and voice modulation goals in class. S/L therapist Ms. Hilbrands worked with STUDENT individually on articulation, voice modulation and eye contact, and testified that STUDENT made progress on these goals. She noted that STUDENT was learning to self-correct when he spoke too loudly, and to maintain appropriate “social distance” when speaking with others.

In addition, STUDENT’s S/L therapy included participation in a small social skills group – one of the treatment methods recommended by Dr. Kaler in her October 2002 assessment report. In her small group sessions, Ms. Hilbrands staged conversations between her students, and testified that STUDENT made progress initiating interactions with his peers. Ms. Hilbrands consulted frequently with Ms. Matich about STUDENT’s progress, and invited STUDENT’s shadow aide to his S/L sessions to suggest strategies for working on STUDENT’s pragmatic speech deficits during the school day. (Testimony of Ms. Matich and Ms. Hilbrands.)

All of these communication and social skill-building efforts occurred in the classroom and in S/L therapy, as opposed to in STUDENT’s DIR program. The District’s offer for the 2002-2003 school year would have continued these approaches by providing for two hours of S/L therapy per week (beginning three weeks before classes started); upgrading STUDENT’s pragmatic speech goals to build on his previous accomplishments; selecting Mr. Cinque as STUDENT’s second grade teacher because he seemed a good “personality fit” who would build rapport with STUDENT; and providing one-to-one IA services for the full school day. As STUDENT demonstrated significant progress in communication and pragmatic speech skills as a result of these methodologies in his first grade year, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need DIR services to continue making progress in his social/emotional development in second grade.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to offer DIR services to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year did not constitute a denial of FAPE.

B. Was the District required to implement STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP until it resolved its disagreement with STUDENT’s parents over its 2002-2003 program offer?

The Student asserts that after he declined the District’s 2002-2003 program offer, the District was required to implement his previously agreed-upon IEP until the end of the 2001-2002 school year, and to continue to implement that IEP in the next school year, until the disagreement over the 2002-2003 program offer was resolved. (Footnote 37) The District disagrees with this assertion.

Federal regulations require an LEA to develop and implement an IEP for each disabled student it serves, and to have the IEP in effect at the beginning of the school year. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.341, 300.342. A student’s IEP is to be developed in an IEP meeting with the active participation of the student’s parents. 34 C.F.R. § 300.340(a); Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072, 1077 (9th Cir. 2003); Amanda J. v. Clark County School District, 267 F.3d. 877, 892 (9th Cir. 2001).

The courts have acknowledged, however, that consensus on development of a program is not always achievable at an IEP meeting. When disputes are unresolved, an LEA still has the duty “to formulate the plan to the best of its ability in accordance with information developed at [prior] meetings, but must afford the parents a due process hearing in regard to that plan.” Ms. S. v. Vashon Island School District, 337 F.3d 1115, 1132 (9th Cir. 2003), quoting Doe by Gonzales v. Maher, 793 F.2d 1470, 1490 (9th Cir. 1986). Further, State law provides that an LEA seeking to implement portions of an IEP to which a parent does not consent must initiate due process proceedings to resolve the disagreement. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b).

In this case, the District presented its 2002-2003 program offer at the May 30, 2002 IEP meeting, and the parties reached informal agreement on several elements of the offer. They disagreed, however, on whether STUDENT continued to require DIR services for his social/emotional development. MOTHER did not sign the IEP at the meeting, indicating that she wanted her husband to review it. Ultimately, the FAMILIES did not consent to the offer, and there was no evidence that the parties held any further discussions about their disagreement over the next several weeks.

On July 23, 2002, MOTHER wrote to SELPA program manager Ms. Lindberg expressing her belief that, due to the parties’ failure to reach agreement, the District was required to continue to provide STUDENT with the DIR services agreed to and implemented in his 2001-2002 educational program. She asserted that “services have not continued as per our IEP,” particularly with respect to the “lack of supervision of our DIR program.” Ms. Lindberg did not recall if she responded to MOTHER’s letter. (S. Exh. 117; testimony of Ms. Lindberg.)

At an IEP meeting on August 23, 2002, three days after the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, MOTHER stated that she had not been told that STUDENT’s DIR services would not continue as they had during the previous school year if she declined to sign his IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. She indicated that she would file for a due process hearing as soon as she received the results of additional assessments she had sought regarding STUDENT’s social/emotional deficits. (D. Exh. 2; testimony of MOTHER.)

On September 11, 2002, the District filed its request for due process hearing. The District continued to provide STUDENT with the program offered in its May 30, 2002 IEP and addenda, which did not include home DIR services, until October 8, 2002, STUDENT’s last day of attendance in second grade. (Footnote 38)

The Student contends that when the parties failed to agree on the District’s May 30, 2002 program offer, the District was required to continue providing him with the home DIR services delivered under his 2001-2002 educational program until the disagreement was resolved through settlement or through a due process hearing. The District responds that the Student’s argument seeks a “stay put” placement, but that stay put is not properly invoked until one of the parties files for a due process hearing. To analyze this issue, the Hearing Officer first separates the Student’s contention relating to the end of the 2001-2002 school year from that relating to the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year.

(1) DIR services at the end of the 2001-2002 school year

STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP provided for home DIR services two hours per day, five days per week, through July 30, 2002. (D. Exh. 8.) At the May 30, 2002 IEP meeting, the District proposed terminating those services, but the FAMILIES disagreed. According to the IEP notes, the District agreed to continue home DIR services “through the end of the school year (June 14, 2002),” but MOTHER “[was] not in agreement to not having DIR services through the summer.” The FAMILIES declined to sign the IEP, and the District stopped providing home DIR services to STUDENT as of June 14, the last day of school. (D. Exh. 4; testimony of MOTHER.)

The IDEA defines a FAPE as special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided “in conformity with” the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). By terminating home DIR services prior to the July 30 termination date provided for in STUDENT’s IEP, the District failed to provide services to STUDENT in conformity with his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him with home DIR services as specified in his November 26, 2001 IEP from June 15 through July 30, 2002.

(2) DIR services at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year

When STUDENT began second grade on August 19, 2002, the District had not yet resolved its dispute with the FAMILIES over his proposed educational program for the 2002-2003 school year. Nevertheless, the District implemented its proposed program for STUDENT despite the FAMILIES’ objections to its lack of a home DIR services component.

Under the IDEA, the District was required to have an IEP in effect for STUDENT at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); 34 C.F.R. § 300.342. To meet this requirement after the FAMILIES refused to consent to its May 30, 2002 program offer, the District had various options available to it, including (1) promptly filing a request for a due process hearing to obtain a decision that its offer constituted a FAPE, or (2) resolving its differences with the FAMILIES and obtaining their consent to its offer, or to a compromise offer, prior to the start of the new school year, or (3) implementing the portion of the May 30 IEP to which there was no disagreement.

The District followed the third option when it implemented STUDENT’s May 30, 2002 IEP without DIR services at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, and the FAMILIES permitted the implementation while continuing to dispute the absence of DIR services. However, after the District filed for a due process hearing on September 11, 2002, the principles of “stay put” applied, requiring the District to maintain STUDENT in his last agreed-upon placement pending resolution of the due process dispute. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). As STUDENT’s last agreed-upon IEP provided home DIR services, the District was required to provide STUDENT with those services from September 11 until the resolution of the dispute.

* * *

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was required to implement STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP from June 15, 2002 through July 30, 2002, but failed to deliver the home DIR services provided for in that IEP. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met its requirement to have an IEP in place for STUDENT at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, but failed to maintain STUDENT in his last agreed-upon placement after filing a request for a due process hearing. As a result, the District failed to provide STUDENT with DIR services to which he was entitled in his last agreed-upon placement from September 11, 2002, the day it filed its due process request, through November 20, 2002, the date of the District’s offer to provide home DIR services as a part of STUDENT’s stay-put placement. (Footnote 39)

C. Did the District fail to appropriately identify accommodations to STUDENT’s program in his May 30, 2002 IEP?

The Student asserts that his May 30, 2002 IEP included the observation that his pragmatic language deficits interfered with his ability to communicate with peers and teachers, but failed to identify any accommodations to address this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that this allegation assumes that specific accommodations would have been necessary in addition to the other components of STUDENT’s IEP.

STUDENT’s May 30 IEP identified pragmatic speech deficits in the areas of staying on a conversational topic, maintaining appropriate social distance and voice control, and explaining topics adequately, and expressly provided that those deficits were to be addressed by his S/L therapist, Ms. Hilbrands. The IEP offered STUDENT two hours per week of S/L therapy, which included weekly participation in a small group social skills class conducted by Ms. Hilbrands. (D. Exh. 4.) Further, the IEP included four S/L goals to be implemented by Ms. Hilbrands that would address STUDENT’s pragmatic speech deficits through improving his eye contact, articulation, voice modulation, and ability to relate story questions to personal experiences.

Ms. Hilbrands persuasively testified that STUDENT’s goals addressed his pragmatic speech deficits, and that he made progress on his goals. The Student has provided no contrary evidence, and has not indicated what accommodations should have been made to address these deficits.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s May 30, 2002 IEP appropriately identified the services the District would provide to address STUDENT’s pragmatic speech deficits in the 2002-2003 school year. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the S/L services provided for STUDENT appropriately addressed his pragmatic speech needs.

D. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with an adequately trained IA for the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year?

The Student contends that the District failed to provide him with an adequately trained IA to provide him with one-to-one assistance in his second grade class. (Footnote 40)As a result of this failure, the Student argues that he developed anxiety that manifested itself in asthma problems requiring him to be absent from school for several weeks in the fall, after which his parents enrolled him in a home education program. The District denies these contentions.

State law requires regular and special education personnel to be “adequately prepared” to provide instruction and services to students. Cal. Educ. Code § 56001(o). However, neither federal nor State special education regulations set forth specific training or credentialing requirements for classroom aides. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.23; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(y).

MOTHER testified that she believed the District IA, Ms. Millar, was unqualified because she did not understand how to recognize and redirect STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors such as hand-flapping and “zoning out” (unfocused staring). MOTHER attended class with STUDENT the first week of school, and observed STUDENT’s class on several occasions in September, keeping logs as to STUDENT’s noncompliant behaviors (such as failing to respond to a request from his teacher) or maladaptive behaviors (such as picking his nose or putting his hands in his pants), and recording the instances she felt Ms. Millar was overly responsive or not responsive enough. (S. Exhs. 307-310.)

MOTHER also testified that she felt Ms. Millar did not understand how to use DIR principles (such as acknowledging STUDENT’s point of view and “negotiating for a transition” when STUDENT was reluctant to return to class after recess). She noted that Dr. Kaler’s psychoeducational assessment in October 2002 indicated that STUDENT needed an aide “specifically trained in how to engage him in sustained, meaningful social interaction.” (S. Exhs. 179-186.)

Ms. Millar testified that the District hired her as an IA in the spring of 2002, and she became STUDENT’s one-to-one IA for the 2002-2003 school year. After being assigned to work with STUDENT, Ms. Millar and Mr. Cinque, STUDENT’s second grade teacher, attended an all-day autism overview and training session in San Bernardino and another autism overview presented by the SELPA. (D. Exh. 26.) Most of Ms. Millar’s training, however, was “on the job” training by Mr. Cinque, who instructed her, for example, that STUDENT should be given time to respond to a directive before she intervened to help him so he could learn to be independent. Ms. Millar also received training from Ms. Wellner, who visited once a week to train her in how to use DIR principles to react to STUDENT and to deal with his issues.

Ms. Millar testified that she kept STUDENT “on task” in the classroom, but that he didn’t need help interacting with other children on the playground. He had established friendships with some of his classmates in the previous year, and made new friends in second grade. STUDENT would talk with his friends about his Gameboy, “Yu-Gi-Oh” cards, and other favorite games. Mr. Cinque provided Ms. Millar with a clipboard with STUDENT’s goals attached, and she observed STUDENT and kept notes on his progress on his goals.

Mr. Cinque testified that STUDENT did well both academically and socially in his class, and that Ms. Millar worked well with him. Mr. Cinque addressed STUDENT’s pragmatic social goals in class by calling on him regularly, encouraging eye contact, and encouraging him to ask his peers questions. To facilitate peer interactions, Mr. Cinque would “buddy STUDENT up” with another student for classroom projects. To keep STUDENT from being distracted and “zoning out,” Mr. Cinque would attempt to keep him busy and involved in activities.

The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Millar was adequately prepared to provide one-to-one assistance to STUDENT at school. Ms. Millar testified persuasively that when she was assigned to STUDENT as an aide, she was provided with initial training in the characteristics of children with autism, and received continual on-the-job training from Mr. Cinque and Ms. Wellner as to when and how to be of assistance to STUDENT in class and on the playground.

Further, Mr. Cinque testified persuasively as to his own qualifications as a teacher with fifteen years’ experience, and to his ability to train Ms. Millar to help keep STUDENT focused, on task, and involved in the social activities of the classroom. Although MOTHER was critical of Ms. Millar, she had no criticism of Mr. Cinque. (Footnote 41) As much of Ms. Millar’s training to be STUDENT’s one-to-one aide necessarily involved on-the-job training to establish rapport between student and aide, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Ms. Millar’s preliminary instruction about autism and her on-the-job training by Mr. Cinque adequately qualified her for this task.

The Hearing Officer further finds that the evidence does not support the Student’s allegation that “lack of support in the educational environment” led to his asthma problems and eventual withdrawal from the District. There was no evidence or testimony as to the reason for STUDENT’s asthmatic symptoms in the fall of 2002. Further, STUDENT’s teacher, IA, and all of the other District and SELPA personnel who worked with STUDENT during his weeks in second grade testified that he was generally a well-adjusted, well-behaved, happy child who was succeeding both academically and socially in his school environment.

Based on the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with an adequately trained IA during the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year.

E. Did the District appropriately address STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors during the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year?

The Student contends that the District’s failure to appropriately address his oral seeking behaviors in the 2001-2002 school year continued into the 2002-2003 school year. He acknowledges that an exercise program developed in accordance with the Beckman Oral Motor Protocol (BOMP) was administered by the District during the 2002-2003 school year, and does not challenge the appropriateness of the BOMP to address oral seeking behaviors. Nevertheless, the Student alleges that there was “utter confusion” as to whether these services would be delivered by the OT or the S/L therapist. As a result, the Student asserts that “services waned, his [goals and objectives] were incomplete, and his skill level regressed.”

In response, the District asserts that it administered the BOMP appropriately. SELPA OT provider Ms. Wray testified that the protocol requires the administration of several mouth exercises to the student at least six times a day. Accordingly, Ms. Wray and her fellow OT Ms. Fairchild delivered the BOMP to STUDENT by training his school aides and his home tutors to administer the exercises at school and at home. During second grade, the OTs initially instructed STUDENT’s IA, Ms. Millar, to administer the BOMP exercises, although this function eventually was taken over by the school nurse. (Testimony of Ms. Wray and Ms. Millar.) In addition, the OTs provided STUDENT with a “chewy” or rubber pencil topper to chew on during class, and STUDENT’s teachers and aides would redirect him to the chewy when he engaged in inappropriate oral seeking behaviors. (Testimony of Ms. Matich and Mr. Cinque.) STUDENT left school for medical reasons on October 8, 2002, and at a November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, the FAMILIES declined the District’s offer of OT services in the home setting. STUDENT did not return to school for the rest of the 2002-2003 school year.

The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position persuasive. The administration of the BOMP exercises by a variety of aides does not indicate confusion, but reflects the fact that the exercises needed to be administered at school and at home, and STUDENT had several aides in attendance over the course of a day. Further, although the program was to be administered over a twelve-week period for maximum effectiveness, STUDENT began to miss school after the first six weeks and never returned, and the FAMILIES refused the District’s offer of OT services in the home setting. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately addressed STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors during the first six weeks of the 2002-2003 school year.

F. Did the District fulfill its stay put obligations to STUDENT?

The Student asserts that the District failed to provide him with an appropriate “stay put” placement after it instituted due process proceedings. The District responds that it made an appropriate offer of stay put, but that the Student denied its offer.

Under federal and State law, once due process proceedings are initiated, a special education student must remain in his or her present educational placement until the proceedings are completed, unless the LEA and the parent agree otherwise. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d). This provision commonly is referred to as “stay put.” The purpose of the stay put provision is to maintain the status quo of the student’s educational program, thus assuring some stability in the student’s education, pending resolution of the due process hearing. Stacy G. v. Pasadena Independent School District, 695 F.2d 904 (5th Cir. 1983); Zvi D. v. Gordon Ambach, 694 F.2d 904 (2d Cir. 1982). A student’s “present educational placement” generally is the placement called for by the student’s last agreed-upon IEP implemented before the dispute arose. Thomas v. Cincinnati Board of Education, 918 F.2d 618 (6th Cir. 1990). Stay put automatically goes into effect as soon as a due process hearing is requested.

In this matter, the District requested a due process hearing on September 11, 2002, automatically invoking its obligation to keep STUDENT in the placement called for by his last agreed-upon and implemented IEP. At a November 20, 2002 IEP meeting, after STUDENT had missed several weeks of school due to illness, the District made a formal stay put offer to STUDENT based upon the services he had received under the last agreed-upon and implemented IEP of November 26, 2001. The District’s stay put offer consisted of placement in a second grade general education class; one-to-one IA services for four hours of the school day; forty-five minutes of OT services per week; sixty minutes of S/L services per week; and a two-hour home DIR program supervised by the SELPA. (S. Exh. 209; testimony of Ms. Metheny.) (Footnote 42)

According to the November 20 IEP notes, MOTHER stated that she would think about the offer and get back to the District, but she did not respond to the offer. At the SARB hearing in January 2003, the FAMILIES indicated that STUDENT was enrolled in the Calvert home schooling program and would not be returning to the District for the rest of the year. (S. Exhs. 209-210; D. Exh. 40, p. 343; testimony of Ms. Metheny.)

The Student argues that the District’s November 20 stay put offer was inappropriate because it failed to provide for a DIR program involving PCDA, as had been offered and discussed in IEP meetings from September through November of 2001. The District responds that its stay put offer was appropriate because it provided for DIR services supervised by the SELPA, which the FAMILIES consented to in the November 26, 2001 IEP, and which STUDENT had been receiving without PCDA involvement throughout the spring of 2002. The Hearing Officer finds the District’s position to be persuasive.

The purpose of the stay put provision is to provide stability and continuity in a student’s education pending the resolution of a due process dispute. Stacy G. v. Pasadena ISD, supra, 695 F.2d 904. Although the November 26 IEP lists “SELPA/NPA [nonpublic agency]” as the provider of DIR services, it is undisputed that the DIR services STUDENT had been receiving under that IEP included little or no input from PCDA as the NPA. In fact, PCDA’s lack of participation was the FAMILIES’ chief complaint about STUDENT’s program, and is a central issue in the current due process dispute. The Student has alleged that the District failed to implement the DIR component of his program as agreed in his IEP; accordingly, he has acknowledged that his IEP, as implemented, lacked the very services he now seeks as a stay put placement.

As the District’s stay put offer reflected STUDENT’s DIR services as they were implemented under his last agreed-upon IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer complied with its obligations under stay put.

* * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with an offer of FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year, but failed to meet its obligation to continue to implement STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP after the FAMILIES disagreed with the District’s proposed early termination of home DIR services under that IEP. In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District extended an appropriate stay put offer to STUDENT on November 20, 2002, but failed to implement the home DIR services required as a part of his stay put placement when it initially filed its request for a due process hearing on September 11, 2002. As a result, the District denied STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it failed to provide him with home DIR services from June 15 through July 30, 2002 (as provided in his last agreed-upon IEP), and from September 11through November 20, 2002 (the date of the District’s stay put offer).

Finally, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately addressed STUDENT’s pragmatic speech deficits, provided STUDENT with an adequately trained IA, and appropriately addressed his oral seeking behaviors for the 2002-2003 school year.

Issue No. 4: Was the District required to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?

The Student contends that despite his withdrawal from District jurisdiction and services and his enrollment in private school in the fall of 2002, the District was required to hold his annual IEP meeting in May of 2003 to offer him an appropriate program and placement for the 2003-2004 school year, but that it failed to do so. The District responds that the Student’s enrollment in a private school program in 2002 relieved the District of any obligation to offer him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year.

Federal regulations provide that, if a determination has been made that a child has a disability and needs special education and related services, “an IEP must be developed for the child” in accordance with those regulations. 34 C.F.R. § 300.535. However, the Office of Special Education Programs of the U.S. Department of Education (OSEP), the agency charged with monitoring and enforcing the IDEA, has provided the following guidance regarding an LEA’s obligation to offer FAPE to a child attending private school as a matter of the parents’ preference:

If a determination is made that the child needs special education and related services, the general rule in 34 CFR Sec. 300.535(b) is that an IEP must be developed for the child in accordance with 34 CFR Sec. 300.340-300.350, with one important exception. If the parents make clear their intention to enroll their child at a private school and that they are not interested in a public program or placement for their child, the public agency need not develop an IEP for the child.

OSEP Memorandum to Chief State School Officers, 34 IDELR 263 (May 4, 2000). Further, the IDEA provides that an LEA is not required to pay the cost of private school for a disabled child if the LEA “made a free appropriate public education available to the child and the parents elected to place the child in such private school or facility.” 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(a).

However, if parents place their child in private school because they believe the LEA has denied their child a FAPE, federal law provides that the LEA may be liable for the costs of the private placement if it denied the child a FAPE, and if the parents provided an appropriate placement. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(b); see School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 370-371, 105 S. Ct. 1996. Similarly, State law provides that if the parent of a child in an LEA special education placement enrolls the child in a private placement without the LEA’s consent, the LEA may be required to reimburse the parent for that placement upon a finding that the LEA failed to make a FAPE available to the child “in a timely manner prior to that enrollment” in private school, if the private placement is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56175.

Finally, State law provides that when parents are entitled to reimbursement for an appropriate private placement, that reimbursement may be reduced or denied when, among other circumstances, the parents fail to inform the LEA that they would seek private placement, or fail to provide ten days’ written notice to the LEA prior to the removal of the child from public school. Cal. Educ. Code § 56176.

Accordingly, the District’s obligation to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year depends on whether the FAMILIES initially placed him in private school because they were not interested in a public placement or program, or whether they did so as a result of a FAPE dispute. If STUDENT’s private school placement was the result of a FAPE dispute, the District’s liability for the cost of that placement will depend on whether the District timely offered him a FAPE prior to that placement, and may depend, in part, on whether the District was given appropriate notice of his parents’ intent to place him in private school. A determination of these issues will require a review of the circumstances surrounding STUDENT’s initial withdrawal from the District and placement in private school during the 2002-2003 school year, as well as his re-enrollment in private school for the 2003-2004 school year.

After the FAMILIES declined to consent to the District’s 2002-2003 program offer in May 2002, the parties clearly were engaged in a FAPE dispute over the contents of that offer. Nevertheless, when school began on August 20, the FAMILIES sent STUDENT to Mr. Cinque’s class in the District despite the continuing disagreement. When the District filed a request for due process hearing to resolve the dispute on September 11, 2002, STUDENT remained in school, and continued to attend class until October 9, 2002, when he was reported absent due to problems with asthma. When he had not returned after several weeks, the District convened an IEP meeting on November 20 to determine if a change in placement was underway. MOTHER informed the IEP team that STUDENT continued to be absent due to illness, and that she would obtain a doctor’s note to determine how long he would be out of school. MOTHER refused the District’s offer of a home hospital program or home delivery of OT and S/L services, stating that STUDENT was being schooled at home and was receiving all the services he needed.

At the hearing, MOTHER testified that she began to investigate home school programs for STUDENT in the summer and fall of 2002 because she felt he was “regressing” in terms of his self-stimulatory and noncompliant behavior, and that his District program was not addressing these concerns. The notes to STUDENT’s IEPs in August and September 2002 reflect MOTHER’s many concerns about the adequacy of STUDENT’s program. However, the FAMILIES never informed the District that they were withdrawing STUDENT from school because of these concerns, and did not confirm that STUDENT had been enrolled in a private school program until the SARB hearing in January 2003.

On February 5, 2003, the Hearing Office issued its decision that, except for providing a motor planning assessment, the District had offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. On February 7, the District wrote to the FAMILIES seeking their consent to a motor planning assessment plan, but the FAMILIES did not respond. On May 5, 2003, the FAMILIES filed a complaint in federal court seeking review of the Hearing Office decision. (Decision, CV 03-8614 DSF [September 8, 2004].) In June 2003, STUDENT completed second grade in the Calvert program, and his parents re-enrolled him in the program for the 2003-2004 school year.

There is no evidence that the parties communicated about STUDENT’s educational placement for the 2003-2004 school year between February 2003, when the Hearing Office decision was issued, and August 2003, when school began, and the timeline of events recited above does little to clarify the FAMILIES’ intentions during that period. On the one hand, the FAMILIES’ failure to respond to the District’s February 2003 request for consent to its motor planning assessment plan might have indicated lack of interest in a District placement for the 2003-2004 school year. On the other hand, their timely appeal of the Hearing Office decision in May 2003 gave the District notice that the dispute over its offer for the previous school year was not yet resolved. At the hearing, District representative Ms. Metheny testified that she did not believe the District was required to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year since the FAMILIES had withdrawn him from the District and enrolled him in private school.

Based on the available evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that at the time STUDENT’s annual IEP was due in May 2003, the FAMILIES had not made clear whether STUDENT had been enrolled in private school as the result of their FAPE dispute with the District or because they were not interested in a public school placement. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the FAMILIES had not made their intentions clear as to whether they were interested in a District placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. As the federal regulations and OSEP guidelines provide that the LEA “must” develop an IEP for a child unless the parents “make clear” that they are not interested in a public placement, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was required to hold STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting in order to offer him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, and that it failed to meet that obligation. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.535; 34 IDELR 263.

The matter of reimbursement will be addressed below.

Issue No. 5: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for specified private assessments and/or for STUDENT’s privately obtained educational expenses for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years?

A. Assessments

The STUDENT contends that the District’s assessments in the area of auditory processing and social/emotional development were inadequate, and that he should be awarded reimbursement for independent assessments conducted in those areas by Carol Atkins (auditory processing) and by Dr. Kaler and Dr. Hess (social/emotional development).

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the LEA. The LEA must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56329(b), 56506(c).

The Hearing Officer has determined that the District appropriately assessed STUDENT in the areas of auditory processing and social/emotional development. Accordingly, the District is not required to pay for the independent assessments conducted by Ms. Atkins, Dr. Kaler, or Dr. Hess. Although the Student did not expressly allege that the District failed to assess STUDENT adequately with respect to his oral sensory needs, the notes to a February 14, 2002 IEP indicated that the FAMILIES disagreed with the SELPA OT assessment of November 9, 2001, which concluded that STUDENT no longer engaged in oral seeking behaviors. (S. Exhs. 97-98.) Further, Ms. Matich’s testimony and the shadow aides’ logs regarding the persistence of STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors casts doubt upon the appropriateness of that assessment. Due to the FAMILIES’ continuing disagreement with the District’s efforts to address STUDENT’s articulation and oral sensory needs, they obtained their own speech and language assessment in August of 2002. As the Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE to the extent that it failed to appropriately address STUDENT’s articulation and oral sensory needs during this period, the Hearing Officer finds that the FAMILIES are entitled to reimbursement for the August 2002 speech and language assessment provided by Academic Networks in the amount of $225. (S. Exh. 425.)

B. Educational expenses

Parents are entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services procured for their child when an LEA has failed to provide an appropriate placement, and when the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at 370. The placement or services need not conform exactly to IDEA requirements, but must address the child’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993).

The Student seeks reimbursement for the following services his parents procured for him as a replacement for District services in the 2001-2002, 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years:

(1) Speech and language services provided by Truesdail Speech Center from October 2001-April 2004;

(2) Home DIR services provided by home tutors from June 15, 2002-August 2004;

(3) DIR consultation and training provided by Kelli Wilms of Playworks from August 2002- August 2004;

(4) Educational services provided by Calvert School for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years, including Calvert School instruction services provided by home tutors; and (5) Behavioral intervention services provided by Gwen Palafox of Working With Autism from September 2002-January 2003.

(S. Exhs. 1159-1168 [revised]; testimony of MOTHER.) (Footnote 43) (1) 2001-2002 school year

The Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year to the extent that it failed to adequately address STUDENT’s articulation needs from August 17, 2001 through October 26, 2001, and failed to adequately address his oral sensory needs for the 2001-2002 school year. In October and November of 2001, the FAMILIES sought to remedy these failings by procuring S/L therapy for STUDENT from the Truesdail Speech Center. (Footnote 44) MOTHER testified that these services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit, and no contrary evidence was provided by the District. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to repay the FAMILIES for the S/L services procured from Truesdail Speech Center in October and November 2001 in the amount of $200. (S. Exhs. 481-482.)

(2) 2002-2003 school year

The Hearing Officer has found that the District failed to provide STUDENT with a FAPE at the end of the 2001-2002 school year and at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to the extent that it failed to provide STUDENT with two hours of home DIR services per school day from June 15 through July 30, 2002, and from September 11 through November 20, 2002. The Student has provided evidence of DIR consultation and training provided by Playworks and of DIR services provided by home tutors during that period. (S. Exhs. 293-297.) MOTHER testified that these services addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided him with educational benefit, and provided evidence that Playworks is a certified NPA providing intervention and consultation to families of young children with autism spectrum disorders. (S. Exhs. 1169-1175.)

Although Ms. Ruesterholtz testified that in her opinion, Playworks was not qualified to provide DIR training and consultation services within the context of a District curriculum, the District provided no evidence that Playworks was unqualified to provide such services in a home setting. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by MOTHER’s testimony that Playworks’ training and consultation provided STUDENT with educational benefit, and finds that the FAMILIES are entitled to reimbursement for a reasonable amount of training and consultation services obtained from Playworks during this period.

The Student provided no evidence of paid invoices reflecting DIR training or consultation between June 15 and July 30, 2002, but did provide such evidence for the period between September 11 and November 20, 2002. During that period, the FAMILIES received services from Playworks at a rate of $90 per hour for a total amount of $1,080. (S. Exh. 895). As the training and consultation provided by the District’s DIR program consisted of twice-monthly supervision and training meetings for approximately two hours per meeting, reimbursement for Playworks’ comparable services at a rate of $90 per hour, two hours per meeting, two meetings per month ($360 per month) for the period between September 11 and November 20, 2002 would amount to exactly $1,080. (Footnote 45) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to reimburse the FAMILIES in the amount of $1,080 for Playworks’ services during this period.

The testimony was unclear as to whether the daily home DIR program agreed to in the November 26, 2001 IEP was provided by one or more home tutors at a time. Further, the invoices submitted for STUDENT’s home tutors showed charges of varied amounts per tutor and per month, with no evidence provided as to an hourly rate for services. Nevertheless, an analysis of the home tutors’ time sheets indicates that they were paid $10 per hour for their services. (See, e.g., S. Exhs. 489, 534, 567, 626, 628). (Footnote 46)

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to reimburse the FAMILIES for the cost of a home DIR program provided by the same number of tutors at a time as occurred pursuant to the November 26, 2001 IEP through June 14, 2002. The reimbursement per tutor shall be at a rate of $10 per hour, two hours per day, five days per week ($100 per week), for the periods of June 15 through July 30, 2002, and September 11 through November 20, 2002.

In all other respects, the Hearing Officer has found that the District provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year. Accordingly, the Student’s other claims for reimbursement for that school year are denied.

(3) 2003-2004 school year

The Hearing Officer has found that the District was required to hold STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting in May 2003 and to offer him a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, but failed to do so. In light of this finding, there exists a basis upon which to award reimbursement for expenses related to the FAMILIES’ re-enrollment of STUDENT in the Calvert home school program for the 2003-2004 school year, and their provision of a home DIR program to STUDENT during that year.

(i) Appropriateness of relief

When an LEA fails to provide a child with a FAPE, the child’s parents may be entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra, 471 U.S. at 369. Equitable considerations are relevant to fashioning appropriate relief under these circumstances, and reimbursement may be reduced or denied upon a finding of unreasonableness with respect to actions taken by the parents. Id.; 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(d)(3). Reimbursement also may be reduced or denied if, at the most recent IEP meeting prior to the removal of the child from public school, the parents failed to inform the LEA that they were rejecting its proposed placement, or if they failed to give the LEA written notice of their intent to withdraw their child from public school at least ten business days before doing so. 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(d)(1), (2); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176.

The District argues that the FAMILIES failed to give timely notice of their intention to withdraw STUDENT from public school in the fall of 2002, and the evidence supports this contention. The FAMILIES enrolled STUDENT in the Calvert program while he was still attending public school in September 2002, withdrew him from school for health reasons in October, continued to inform the District that STUDENT was absent for health reasons at the November 2002 IEP meeting, and did not tell the District of STUDENT’s private school placement until the SARB hearing in January 2003.

The issue of timely notice of STUDENT’s withdrawal from public school arguably was moot when STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting was due in May 2003. By that time, the District clearly was aware that STUDENT had been enrolled in private school; however, the reason for that enrollment had not yet been made clear to the District.

The Hearing Officer finds that some reduction of reimbursement is warranted as an equitable consideration under the circumstances. The purpose of federal and State notice requirements is to give an LEA the opportunity to resolve disputes regarding its current or proposed placement so as to avoid incurring financial obligations for a private school placement. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176. Here, District witnesses testified that no offer of FAPE was made for the 2003-2004 school year because they did not think the FAMILIES were interested in an offer. Although this belief did not excuse the District from its obligation to make the offer, the Hearing Officer finds that the belief had some basis in fact in light of the FAMILIES’ mixed messages regarding their reasons for withdrawing STUDENT from public school in 2002 and their failure to respond to the District’s request for consent to a motor planning assessment in February 2003.

The Hearing Officer also finds that, in failing to give the District timely notice of their intent to re-enroll STUDENT in private school for the 2003-2004 school year, or any notice that they might have been interested in an offer of FAPE for that year prior to filing their cross-complaint against the District in November 2004, the FAMILIES’ actions contributed to the District’s failure to offer a FAPE before liability for a private placement was incurred. See 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(d)(3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56176.

Finally, once the May 2003 deadline for STUDENT’s annual IEP had passed without an IEP meeting being noticed or held, it should have been clear to the FAMILIES that the District did not believe an offer of FAPE was expected or desired. The evidence is abundant that the FAMILIES were well informed of their procedural rights and actively pursued those rights whenever they thought the District acted inappropriately. Nevertheless, the FAMILIES did nothing to correct this misunderstanding at any time from May through August of 2003, when an IEP meeting could have led to an offer prior to expenses being incurred for the 2003-2004 school year. Instead, the FAMILIES incurred private expenses for the entire school year without ever informing the District that they would entertain a placement offer from the District.

In light of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that equitable considerations warrant a reduction of the reimbursement that the District otherwise would owe the FAMILIES as a result of its failure to make an offer of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer finds the FAMILIES’ conduct warrants a reduction of any reimbursement by fifty percent.

(ii) Appropriateness of private program and placement

When the LEA has failed to offer a FAPE, the parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of a private placement and services procured for their child if the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, supra, 471 U.S. at 370-371. To be eligible for reimbursement, the placement or services chosen by the parent need not conform exactly to the content of the student’s IEP. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Rather, the private placement and services must address the student’s educational needs and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit. Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 114 S. Ct. 361 (1993). Reimbursement may be awarded even if the private school does not meet State certification requirements. Id. at 14.

The Hearing Officer finds that, in light of the District’s failure to offer a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, the FAMILIES are entitled to reimbursement for private placement and services procured for STUDENT during that school year if the placement and services are found to be appropriate. In this case, the FAMILIES seek reimbursement for S/L services provided by Truesdail Speech Center; the Calvert School home instruction program, including instruction provided by home tutors; DIR consultation and training provided by Kelli Wilms of Playworks; and DIR services provided by home tutors.

Truesdail Speech Center

The FAMILIES have provided evidence of payment in the amount of $500 to the Truesdail Speech Center for speech and language services during the 2003-2004 school year (from September 2003 through April 2004). (S. Exh. 482.) The Hearing Officer already has found that services from Truesdail Speech Center are appropriate for reimbursement under the IDEA. Accordingly, and in light of the fifty percent reduction in reimbursement imposed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to repay the FAMILIES $250 for these services.

Calvert School home instruction program

The FAMILIES have provided evidence of payment to the Calvert School in the amount of $1,240.14 for its home instruction program for the 2003-2004 school year. (S. Exh. 484.) According to Calvert personnel, the school is a member of the National Association of Independent Schools, and its home instruction program is approved by the Maryland State Department of Education and accredited by the Commission on International and Trans-Regional Accreditation (CITA). Calvert School is not approved or accredited in California, but MOTHER testified that she compared State standards for second grade to Calvert’s program standards and believes the Calvert program meets State standards. This contention was not disputed by the District. In addition, the FAMILIES provided copies of the comment sheets in which Calvert instructors graded and commented on STUDENT’s tests and assignments. The comment sheets indicate that STUDENT received grades of “excellent” or “good” on most of his tests and assignments, and satisfactorily completed his third grade year in the program. (Testimony of MOTHER; see also S. Exhs. 173-77, 1113-1152.)

The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of MOTHER, a college professor with a combined doctoral degree in anatomy and physics, persuasive as to the academic appropriateness of the Calvert program. Although the District argues that the Calvert program failed to address STUDENT’s IEP goals or his need for socialization, the Hearing Officer notes that most of STUDENT’s IEP goals related to pragmatic speech and articulation issues, which were addressed by the S/L services procured from the Truesdail Speech Center. Further, the FAMILIES also addressed STUDENT’s socialization needs through the DIR services it procured through Playworks.

Based on the above evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that the Calvert School home instruction program addressed STUDENT’s educational needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Accordingly, and in light of the fifty percent reduction in reimbursement imposed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to repay the FAMILIES $620.07 for the cost of the Calvert program for the 2003-2004 school year.

Calvert instruction services provided by home tutors

The FAMILIES submitted evidence of payment to several home tutors for STUDENT’s instruction in the Calvert program for “a four to six hour school day” for the 2003-2004 school year. (Testimony of MOTHER; see S. Exhs. 1159-1168 (revised).) In addition, the FAMILIES submitted evidence of payments to their housekeeper, Ms. Mason, for administrative duties in coordinating STUDENT’s instruction program, DIR program, tutors, and play dates. However, the evidence of services did not account for overlaps in tutor hours, and MOTHER acknowledged that some of Ms. Mason’s hours were devoted to general housekeeping services and babysitting as opposed to STUDENT’s educational program during the school day. (Footnote 47)

The Hearing Officer already has found that the FAMILIES reimbursed their tutors at a rate of $10 per hour, and that in light of similar contracts between the FAMILIES and the District for previous school years, the rate of payment is reasonable and appropriate. Although no evidence was provided as to the beginning and end dates of the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer looks to the evidence of STUDENT’s previous school years for guidance and determines that, for purposes of reimbursement, the 2003-2004 school year extends from mid-August 2003 through mid-June 2004. (Footnote 48)

Based on MOTHER’s estimate that STUDENT spent four to six hours per day receiving instruction in the Calvert program, the Hearing Officer finds that a reasonable rate of reimbursement for home instruction services would be $250 per week (one home tutor at a rate of $10 per hour, five hours per day, five days per week). In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that a reasonable rate of reimbursement for Ms. Mason’s administrative services for coordinating and administering STUDENT’s various programs would be $50 per week (at a rate of $10 per hour, five hours per week). Accordingly, and in light of the fifty percent reduction in reimbursement imposed above, the District is required to reimburse the FAMILIES $125 per week for home instruction services and $25 per week for administrative services for the period between August 15, 2003 and June 15, 2004.

DIR therapy (Playworks and home tutors)

The FAMILIES provided evidence of paid invoices for DIR “coaching” and supervised therapy sessions provided by Playworks between August 2003 and June 2004, at a rate of $90 per hour, two or two and one half hours per week. (S. Exhs. 900-906.) The FAMILIES also provided evidence of payment to three home tutors (Reanna, Sacia, and Carol) for DIR services provided during that period, although the evidence does not specify the hours devoted to DIR services. (S. Exhs. 1159-1168.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the FAMILIES’ procurement of a DIR program was designed to meet STUDENT’s socialization needs in a home program otherwise devoid of opportunities for socialization, and already has found that Playworks’ consultation and training of STUDENT’s home tutors provided educational benefit to STUDENT. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District is required to reimburse the FAMILIES for a reasonable amount of DIR services provided between August 15, 2003, and June 15, 2004.

However, the Hearing Officer finds that the DIR services procured by the FAMILIES during the 2003-2004 school year exceeded those that would have been provided by an appropriate District program, and that the reimbursement sought is therefore excessive. Specifically, the DIR program provided to STUDENT by the District for the 2001-2002 school year consisted of twice-monthly DIR training and supervision meetings for two hours per meeting, and home DIR services provided by the tutors for two hours per day, five days per week. The Hearing Officer already has found that the District’s 2001-2002 program provided STUDENT a FAPE.

The Hearing Officer finds that reasonable reimbursement for the cost of Playworks’ DIR supervision and coaching sessions would be $360 per month (at a rate of $90 per hour, two hours per session, two times per month). Further, reasonable reimbursement for home DIR services would be at a rate of $10 per hour, two hours per day, five days per week, for the same number of home tutors per DIR session as were employed under STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP.

Accordingly, and in light of the fifty percent reduction in reimbursement imposed above, the District is required to reimburse the FAMILIES for Playworks’ services at a rate of $180 per month, and for home DIR services at a rate of $5 per hour, two hours per day, five days per week, for the same number of home tutors per session as were employed under STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP, for the period between August 15, 2003, and June 15, 2004.

All of the Student’s other requests for relief are denied.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of its receipt of this Decision, the District is ordered to reimburse the FAMILIES for the following costs relating to assessments and educational services procured for STUDENT during the 2001-2002 and 2002-2003 school years: $225 for the August 2002 Academic Networks assessment; $200 for Truesdail Speech Center services; $1,080 for Playworks DIR training and consultation services; and home tutor services as described above from June 15 through July 30, 2002 and September 11 through November 20, 2002.

2. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of its receipt of this Decision, the District is ordered to reimburse the FAMILIES for the cost of the following services procured for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year: $250 for Truesdail Speech Center services; $620.07 for the Calvert School program; $125 per week for home tutor instruction in the Calvert program for the period between August 15, 2003 and June 15, 2004; $25 per week for administrative services for the same period; $180 per month for Playworks’ services for the same period; and home DIR services for the same period at a rate of $5 per hour, two hours per day, five days per week, for the same number of home tutors per session as were employed under STUDENT’s November 26, 2001 IEP.

3. All of the Student’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

The Student prevailed on his allegations that the District failed to adequately address his articulation needs from August 17, 2001 through October 26, 2001, and failed to adequately address his oral sensory needs for the 2001-2002 school year. The Student also prevailed on his allegation that the District failed to provide him with two hours of home DIR services per school day from June 15 through July 30, 2002, and from September 11 through November 20, 2002.

In addition, the Student prevailed on his allegation that the District failed to meet its obligations to hold his annual IEP meeting in May 2003 and to make him an offer of FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year. As a result, the Student prevailed on his request for reimbursement for private educational services procured by his parents for the 2003-2004 school year, as specified in the above Order. However, as an equitable consideration in light of the failure of the Student’s parents to give the District notice of their intended placement of the Student for that school year, the Student’s reimbursement award was reduced by fifty percent.

The District prevailed on all other issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: May 18, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

This consolidated matter is comprised of a remanded case and a bifurcated portion of a second case involving the same parties. On September 8, 2004, the Hearing Office’s decision in the case filed by the District, SN02-02070, was vacated on appeal and remanded for rehearing on the ground that the Student had been denied due process regarding his right to be represented by counsel. The remanded matter was assigned Case No. SN02-02070R.

On November 23, 2004, the Student filed for a due process hearing, raising counterclaims to the District’s contentions in the earlier case and adding allegations relating to other school years. This case was assigned Case No. SN04-02813 and ultimately was consolidated with SN02-02070R. Prior to the hearing, the parties agreed to bifurcate all issues relating to the 2004-2005 school year.

Accordingly, this Decision in Case No. SN02-02070R/SN04-02813A addresses all of the parties’ issues relating to the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years. The Student’s allegations regarding the 2004-2005 school year have been assigned Case No. SN04-02813B, and will be heard separately.

2 The hearing originally convened on December 7, 2004, but was continued prior to the taking of testimony due to Ms. Loyer’s illness.

3 Closing briefs originally were due April 11, 2005, but the Hearing Office granted the District’s unopposed motion for an extension to April 18 due to Ms. Lindberg’s illness. The District did not file its closing brief until April 20, and the Student lodged a protest requesting that the late brief not be considered. The District filed a response enclosing a copy of a date-stamped envelope indicating that the District did not receive the Student’s brief until after the District’s brief had been filed. As there is no evidence that any due process rights were infringed by the District’s short delay in filing its brief, the Hearing Officer denies the Student’s motion.

4 The SELPA referred STUDENT to CCR for a social/emotional assessment and for recommendations as to appropriate services. (S. Exh. 55.)

5 On May 1, 2002, after the FAMILIES had expressed disagreement with the results of the FEAS assessment, the District filed for a due process hearing seeking an order that the assessment had been administered appropriately. After a hearing on June 18, 2002, the Hearing Office issued a decision indicating that Ms. Wellner’s FEAS assessment of STUDENT had been administered appropriately and by competent personnel. (Decision, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD v. Student, SN02-00931 [July 12, 2002]).

6 In a September 27, 2002 letter to the FAMILIESs, the District superintendent expressed concern that by being taken out of class early every day, STUDENT was missing the “Big Buddies” program, in which fourth grade students paired with second graders for various activities. (D. Exh. 40, p. 354.)

7 Calvert School is a home education program in which curricula and assignments are mailed to the student, returned upon completion, and graded by a Calvert instructor. (Testimony of MOTHER; see also S. Exhs. 173-77.)

8 As the Student’s allegations regarding the 2004-2005 school year have been bifurcated, this Decision does not address any issues relating to STUDENT’s return to the District for his fourth grade year.

9 The Student also asserts that the “language processing test” administered by District speech pathologist Ms. Hilbrands in May 2002 was untimely, given the initial assessment decision in June 2001, and was inadequate because it was not administered by an audiologist and failed to identify the severity of his auditory processing deficits. However, Ms. Hilbrands’ report indicates that her assessment was administered as a part of STUDENT’s 2002 annual review, and was intended to focus primarily on STUDENT’s pragmatic speech deficits. Accordingly, her assessment is not at issue with respect to the Student’s claims of error regarding his visual and auditory processing assessments in 2001. (D. Exh. 16.)

10 Dr. Simonds administered the Developmental Neuropsychological Assessment (NEPSY); the Peabody Individual Achievement Test-Revised (PIAT-R); the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children, Third Edition (WISC-III); and the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML).

11 On May 1, 2002, after the FAMILIES expressed disagreement with the FEAS assessment, the District filed a request for a due process hearing seeking an order that the assessment had been administered appropriately. After a hearing on June 18, 2002, the Hearing Office issued a decision indicating that Ms. Wellner’s FEAS assessment of STUDENT had been administered appropriately and by competent personnel. (Decision, Yucaipa-Calimesa JUSD v. Student, SN02-00931 [July 12, 2002]).

12 The social goals STUDENT had not met by the end of first grade were continued in his 2002-2003 educational program. (D. Exh. 4.)

13 This Decision makes no finding as to the adequacy of the June 2004 OT assessment, but takes note of the fact that the Student offered no evidence at the hearing to contradict the assessment’s conclusions.

14 The Student has provided no evidence of motor planning services procured for STUDENT since August of 2002, and has sought neither compensatory education nor reimbursement for services relating to motor planning.

15 Ms. Metheny testified that at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT received thirty minutes of weekly OT services in addition to his fifteen minutes of OT consultation to implement the Beckman Oral Motor Protocol (BOMP) regarding his oral sensory needs. Although STUDENT’s IEPs do not reflect this adjustment, the District’s offer of stay put in November 2002 acknowledged that based on the parties’ most recent agreement, STUDENT should receive forty-five minutes of OT services. (S. Exh. 209.)

16 Federal and State law also require that LEAs educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular educational environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301. As the Student has raised no LRE-related allegation in this hearing, this Decision does not include an analysis of his District placements in light of LRE requirements.

17 Although the Student’s issue statement generally alleges that his teacher and other “knowledgeable personnel” were absent from unspecified IEP meetings during the three school years at issue, there was little testimony on this point and it was not addressed in argument. Accordingly, this portion of the Decision is based on an analysis of the testimony and the documentary evidence in light of the Student’s issue statement.

18 The September 12, 2001 IEP notes state “Classroom teacher reported that STUDENTis doing well in class and it may be possible to start decreasing the amount of aide time in the classroom.” (D. Exh. 10.)

19 To help him cope with his various sensory deficits, STUDENT was provided with classroom accommodations such as a “chewy” or “oral fidget” to keep him from chewing on his shirt, and a weighted vest and seat wedge to keep him from fidgeting in his seat. (D. Exh. 4; testimony of Ms. Wray.)

20 The 1999 OT assessment also indicated that STUDENT was highly resistant to tactile contact with unfamiliar items and textures, and had difficulty holding a pencil and writing legibly. According to the testimony of SELPA OT provider Ms. Wray, STUDENT received OT services for tactile resistance in his kindergarten year, and the issue was largely resolved by the time he entered first grade. The notes to STUDENT’s June 2001 IEP indicate that his pencil grip improved and his writing became more legible in kindergarten. (D. Exh. 12.)

21 There is no evidence that the motor planning delays noted in the 1999 OT assessment translated into motor planning deficits that interfered with STUDENT’s education in the 2001-2002 school year. No concerns about motor planning appear in the documentary evidence until the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, when MOTHER raised a concern about STUDENT’s inability to sing while engaging in another activity. (D. Exh. 2.)

22 In his closing brief, the Student also alleges that the District “failed to develop appropriate, measurable goals” for his education program. As this allegation was not raised in the Student’s issue statement or during further clarification of issues at the hearing, it is not addressed in this Decision.

23 STUDENT’s IEP team also developed two OT goals for the 2001-2002 school year, which are discussed in Section B(2)(c) below.

24 On some occasions STUDENT’s aides reported that when the recess bell rang, he would return to class without incident and would announce to his aide, “I won’t have a tantrum today!” (Id.)

25 The appropriateness of the District’s efforts to address STUDENT’s oral seeking behaviors is discussed in Section B(2)(c) below.

26 According to Ms. Isaak’s report, her assessment was conducted on July 31 and on September 12, 13, and 14, 2001. No evidence was presented as to the reason for the six-week delay between the July and September assessment sessions, or the additional six-week delay between the completion of the assessment and the report to the IEP team.

27 Although STUDENT’s articulation goal was developed on August 17, there was no evidence or testimony that this goal was implemented by Ms. Matich or by other school staff until October 30, when Ms. Hilbrands began to address articulation in STUDENT’s S/L therapy sessions. (Testimony of Ms. Matich and Ms. Hilbrands.)

28 The DIR model, originally known as the “Floortime” model, was developed by Stanley Greenspan, M.D. as a way to enhance the social/emotional development and relationship-building skills of children with communicative disabilities. The model requires the therapist to address the child at his or her developmental level, follow the child’s lead in communication and imaginative play, and increase the cycles of communication between the therapist and the child to greater levels of depth and complexity. (Testimony of Ms. Wellner.)

29 Ms. Wellner testified that in the school setting, DIR social/conversational strategies could be implemented only at recess or lunch, resulting in an awkward and minimal work schedule that made it difficult to hire and retain school aides.

30 According to Dr. Cullinane, PCDA had agreed to provide consultation at ten home DIR meetings, but only attended two such meetings due to scheduling difficulties.

31 Dr. Cullinane testified that PCDA contracted to provide seventy-two hours of DIR training and forty-five hours of consultation services to Ms. Wellner. (See S. Exhs. 1107-08.)

32 When PCDA contracted to provide DIR training to the SELPA, none of the PCDA trainers, including Dr. Cullinane, were DIR certified, and the amount of training PCDA contracted to provide to Ms. Wellner would have been insufficient to result in Ms. Wellner’s certification. (Testimony of Dr. Cullinane; S. Exhs. 1107-1112.)

33 STUDENT’s DIR goals included verbal expression of wants and needs; use of words and gestures together to meet needs; talking about various feelings (joy, fear, disappointment, jealousy); using those feelings as themes in his play; and answering “why” questions. (D. Exh. 18.)

34 MOTHER did not believe Ms. Wellner’s data form was adequate to measure STUDENT’s progress on his DIR goals, and developed her own form for the home tutors. (Testimony of MOTHER; S. Exh. 1096).

35 Although the 2002-2003 school year would not begin until August 20, the District’s offer included S/L services and OT consult services beginning July 30, 2002, and extending until July 30, 2003.

36 It is unclear if the District’s 2002-2003 offer intended to discontinue DIR services in their entirety, or to discontinue home DIR services but continue DIR services at school. Subsequent IEPs and witness testimony indicate that Ms. Wellner’s school-based DIR services to STUDENT continued in second grade. However, the May 30, 2002 IEP offer makes no reference to DIR services of any kind, and MOTHER testified that at the time the offer was extended, she understood that no DIR services were being offered for the 2002-2003 school year. Accordingly, this portion of the Decision assumes that the May 30, 2002 program offer included no DIR services.

37 STUDENT’s last agreed-upon and implemented IEP was his annual IEP of June 6, 2001, as modified by several addenda between August 2001 and February 2002. This section of the Decision addresses the FAMILIES’ complaints about the discontinuance of DIR services agreed to in the November 26, 2001 IEP addendum.

38 All aspects of the May 30, 2002 offer were implemented except the extension of IA service from four hours a day to a full school day, as the FAMILIES expressly declined that offer. At the August 21, 2002 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s S/L services were increased from one to two hours per week. In addition, Ms. Wellner supervised STUDENT’s IA in the provision of DIR services at school during the 2002-2003 school year, despite the fact that the May 30, 2002 program offer did not include such services. (D. Exhs. 2, 3, 5; testimony of Ms. Wellner and Ms. Millar.)

39 The District’s stay put offer is discussed in Section F of Issue No. 3.

40 MOTHER testified to her dissatisfaction with the District’s decision to hire STUDENT’s IA for the 2002-2003 school year instead of allowing the FAMILIES to hire their own aide and to be reimbursed by the District, as had been permitted the previous year. In response, SELPA program manager Ms. Lindberg testified that the District discontinued its previous policy due to problems with supervision, scheduling, and maintenance of liability insurance. She stated that the District informed the FAMILIES of this policy change in the spring of 2002, but allowed the FAMILIES’ own aides to remain in place until the end of the 2001-2002 school year.

41 Lou Padilla, an Inland Regional Center staff member who observed STUDENT’s second grade class at the FAMILIES’ request, also praised Mr. Cinque’s abilities as a teacher. (D. Exh. 1.)

42 The District’s offer failed to reflect the fact that STUDENT’s S/L services had been increased from one to two hours per week in the August 21, 2002 IEP addendum. As the Student did not raise this discrepancy as an issue at the hearing, however, it is not addressed in this Decision.

43 During the Student’s presentation of evidence related to reimbursement, it became apparent that Student Exhibits 1159-1168 contained numerous inadvertent duplications of expenses. By agreement of the parties, the Student submitted a revised version of those exhibits with his closing brief. The parties further agreed that if reimbursement were ordered, they would review the invoices supporting the requests for reimbursement to confirm that duplications had been eliminated and any other errors corrected.

44 The FAMILIES provided evidence of additional S/L services procured for STUDENT from Truesdail Speech Center from September through December of 2002, February through April of 2003, and February through April of 2004. However, the only services obtained during the 2001-2002 school year were those in October and November 2001. (S. Exh. 482.)

45 Ms. Wellner testified that the twice-monthly home DIR supervision meetings usually lasted about two hours.

46 Contracts between the District and the FAMILIES for the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years indicate that during those years, the District also reimbursed the FAMILIES at a $10 hourly rate for home tutor services. (S. Exhs. 286-292.)

47 At the hearing, the Student offered to stipulate to reimbursement for Ms. Mason in the amount of eighty percent of the FAMILIES’ payments for her services, but the District declined to accept the stipulation.

48 The use of District school year dates as a frame of reference for reimbursement is not intended to incorporate the elements of an actual school year, such as vacations or other breaks from school services. Rather, the mid-August through mid-June framework requires reimbursement for specified, proved weekly expenses for the entire period between August 15, 2003 and June 15, 2004.