California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 8, 2003

Student v. Conejo Valley Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2079-00 · Hearing Officer Judith E. Ganz

Conejo Valley Unified denied an honors student a FAPE by isolating her in school offices; Hearing Officer orders math tutoring and reimbursement.

Split decision: student prevailed on 4 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. Before the record closed, the Hearing Office denied Petitioner's request to reopen it for additional evidence. In footnote 20, the Hearing Officer declined the District's request for a finding that the relief obtained was "not more favorable" than its settlement offer and deferred that question to the District Court.

Summary

The parents of an eighth grader at Redwood Middle School filed against Conejo Valley Unified School District in November 2000. She was eligible as other health impaired because of chronic asthma and severe allergies. Her March 2000 IEP called for "hand selected" classrooms that would benefit her health. That fall, her honors English and math classes met in modular classrooms. Her allergists linked her worsening symptoms to those rooms, but the principal refused to move the classes. An IEP meeting on November 21, 2000 ended without agreement. The Hearing Officer found the District's ideas at that meeting were informal "options," not the clear written offer that Union School District v. Smith requires. From late November until June, the District had her spend her English and math periods alone in the administrative offices. She got monthly English packets and short, irregular math sessions before school. The Hearing Officer held that this denied her a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. It did not meet her needs, did not follow her IEP, and gave no educational benefit in math. She kept high English grades, so no English remedy was ordered. The District should also have reassessed her. The Hearing Officer did not decide whether the modular rooms were unsafe and found no bad faith. The District must provide 2.5 hours per week of in-home math tutoring through the 2002-2003 school year and extended school year. It must also reimburse the part of Dr. Peerless's bill covering his evaluation and letter.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO treated a health-based classroom dispute as an LRE question. Seating a general education student alone in an office, with no teacher or classmates, violated LRE even though the room was environmentally safe. Discussing informal "options," or the parents rejecting them, did not replace a formal written placement offer.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue I.A. Was placement of Student in two modular classrooms from August 29, 2000 until November 22, 2000 appropriate?

    The Hearing Officer declined to decide whether the modular classrooms harmed the student's health. The student did not challenge the instruction she received or seek a remedy for that period, so neither party prevailed.

  2. Not reachedImplementation

    Issue I.B. Did the District have the obligation to test the classrooms to which Student was assigned in a timely fashion?

    The Hearing Officer did not address this because it had no legal bearing on the remedy sought. Neither party prevailed.

  3. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II. Were the District's suggested classroom options at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting appropriate?

    The District's ideas (a college prep English class, math in a resource room, or home teaching) were only informal options, not a clear written offer. The parents' objections did not excuse the District from making a formal offer or from filing for due process.

  4. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue III. Did the District provide Student a FAPE in the least restrictive environment when it located Student in administrative offices for English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 until the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

    Placing the student alone in the administrative offices did not meet her needs or follow her IEP's 'hand selected classrooms' provision. It was not the least restrictive environment and gave no educational benefit in math. English packets met Rowley's minimum only because of the student's own abilities.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue IV. Is Student entitled to compensatory education for the failure of the District to provide her with a FAPE from November 27, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

    The Hearing Officer awarded compensatory in-home math tutoring because the student lost educational opportunity in math. English tutoring was denied because there was no evidence of lost opportunity in English.

  6. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue V. Was the District obligated to perform a reassessment of Student and are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of medical assessments they obtained at private expense?

    Conditions warranted a reassessment under Education Code section 56381(a). The parents get reimbursement for one independent assessment, limited to Dr. Peerless's evaluation and his September 27, 2000 letter. Medical treatment and Dr. Seltzer's fees are not covered.

  7. District prevailedThreshold and jurisdiction

    Issue VI. Did the District act in bad faith in this case?

    The Hearing Officer called the District's response 'unusually inept' but found the evidence insufficient for a finding of bad faith or deliberate indifference.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 20 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting. Working with the parents and around the student's schedule, the team must set a schedule for 2.5 hours per week of in-home math tutoring.
  • Compensatory education. Immediately after that IEP meeting, the District must provide 2.5 hours per week of in-home math tutoring for the rest of the 2002-2003 regular school year and the extended school year. The decision's findings say the tutoring is to be given by a credentialed teacher at District expense.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 business days after receiving proof of payment, the District must reimburse the parents for Dr. Peerless's independent assessment. Reimbursement is limited to his evaluation of the student and his time preparing and writing the September 27, 2000 letter. It excludes medical treatment and payments to Dr. Seltzer. No dollar amount was stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Burlington; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Cal. Education Code section 56381(a); Cal. Education Code section 56346(b)

People named in the decision

  • Brett Tamburri, night custodian, Redwood Middle School
  • Donna Blackmun, school custodian, Redwood Middle School
  • James Roberts, custodian, Redwood Middle School
  • Dr. James Seltzer, private allergist/immunologist and indoor environmental expert; expert witness for Student, Indoor Hygienic Technologies Corporation; University of California San Diego
  • Dr. Allen G. Peerless, private allergist/immunologist; independent assessor
  • Christina Pantoja, eighth grade Honors English teacher, Redwood Middle School
  • Karon Maloney, eighth grade Honors mathematics teacher, Redwood Middle School
  • Sheryl Holtz, school counselor, Redwood Middle School
  • Thalia Diamantopoulos, parents' advocate
  • Jack Bannon, associate director of special education, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Tim Carpenter, principal, Redwood Middle School
  • Brian Stratouly, mechanical engineer and indoor air quality specialist; District's air quality tester, Aero Environmental Services
  • Bryan McLaren, heating and air conditioning mechanic, Conejo Valley Unified School District
  • Janet Cosaro, coordinator of special education, Redwood Middle School
  • Jean Gordon, vice principal, Redwood Middle School
  • Susan Lipman, health clerk, Redwood Middle School

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Thousand Oaks, California, on October 23, 24, 25, and October 29, and 30, 2002. Additional testimony was taken, with the agreement of the parties, by telephone conference on November 14 and 26, 2002.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Steven Wyner. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were her mother, MOTHER, and father, FATHER. Respondent Conejo Valley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney John Hayashida of the law office of Parker and Covert LLP. Also present on behalf of the District was Jack Bannon, associate director of special education.

The Petitioner called the following witnesses: Brett Tamburri, night custodian at Redwood Middle School; Donna Blackmun, school custodian at Redwood Middle School; James Roberts, custodian at Redwood Middle School; Dr. James Seltzer, STUDENT’s allergist and immunologist; Dr. Allen G. Peerless, STUDENT’s allergist and immunologist; Christina Pantoja, STUDENT’s eighth grade Honors English teacher; Karon Maloney, STUDENT’s eighth grade Honors Mathematics teacher; Sheryl Holtz, STUDENT’s school counselor; Thalia Diamantopoulos, the PARENTS’ advocate; Jack Bannon, associate director of special education for the District; Tim Carpenter, Redwood Middle School principal; Brian Stratouly, mechanical engineer and indoor air quality specialist; Bryan McLaren, heating and air conditioning mechanic for the District; and STUDENT and FATHER and MOTHER.

The District put on its case by questioning the witnesses called by the Petitioner and also calling Janet Cosaro, coordinator of special education at Redwood Middle School; Jean Gordon, vice principal at Redwood Middle School; and Susan Lipman, health clerk at Redwood Middle School.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the submission of written closing arguments and for the limited purpose of considering admission of additional exhibits and brief testimony. Two telephone conferences were held after the hearing was concluded for that purpose. Thereafter, the parties submitted closing briefs on December 2, 2002, and the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the close of the hearing, the record was kept open for the limited purpose of allowing Petitioner to review documents provided by Respondent on the last day of hearing and for the parties to submit closing briefs. One day before the record was closed, Petitioner requested that the record remain open to consider additional testimony and documentary evidence. The District filed an opposition to Petitioner’s motion. The Hearing Office denied Petitioner’s request to take additional evidence. There was no showing by Petitioner that the witness Petitioner sought to question was not available before the conclusion of the hearing. The Hearing Officer notes that Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing was received over two years ago on November 22, 2000 providing ample time to conduct investigation. Even if the Hearing Officer reached the merits of Petitioner’s request, the fact that another student became ill in a portable classroom at the Redwood Middle School does not reflect STUDENT’s needs, which are unique to her. The proposed evidence was of marginal significance and provided an insufficient reason to expand the purpose for which the record was kept open.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING(Footnote 1)

I. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE for her English and mathematics instruction from the start of the 2000-2001 regular school year until November 22, 2000?

A. Was placement of STUDENT in two modular classrooms from August 29, 2000 until November 22, 2000 appropriate?(Footnote 2)

B. Did the District have the obligation to test the classrooms to which STUDENT was assigned in a timely fashion?

II. Were the District’s suggested classroom options at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting appropriate?

III. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment when it located STUDENT in administrative offices for English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 until the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

IV. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the failure of the District to provide her with a FAPE from November 27, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

V. Was the District obligated to perform a reassessment of STUDENT and are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of medical assessments they obtained at private expense?

VI. Did the District act in bad faith in this case?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT maintains that she was denied a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year when she was placed in modular classrooms for her Honors English and Honors mathematics classes that were not environmentally safe for her. STUDENT asserts that if the District did not agree that she became sick because of the conditions in the classrooms, it should have performed its own medical assessment of STUDENT and/or an assessment of the modular classrooms in a timely manner. STUDENT contends that the District continued to deny her a FAPE in the least restrictive environment when in placed her in the school’s administrative offices for English and mathematics from November 27, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year. According to STUDENT, she is entitled to compensatory educational services for the instruction she lost while in the administrative offices. In addition, STUDENT maintains that her parents are entitled to reimbursement for the independent medical assessments they obtained.

The District contends that it provided STUDENT with a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year. The District asserts that the Petitioner failed to establish a cause and effect relationship between STUDENT’s allergic reactions and conditions in the modular classrooms. The District maintains that it did assess the modular classrooms in June 2001 and found that the air quality of the room was not degraded. In addition, the District asserts that it made other reasonable placement suggestions and that STUDENT’s parents did not register an objection to STUDENT’s placement in the school’s administrative offices. According to the District, STUDENT benefitted from her education when she was provided instruction in English and mathematics in the school’s administrative offices. In the alternative, the District asserts that it previously offered to provide the same compensatory educational services that Petitioner seeks as a remedy. Finally, the District maintains that it is not required to pay for any medical assessments obtained by STUDENT’s parents since Petitioner failed to provide proof of the amount spent.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fifteen-year-old student who lives with her parents, MOTHER and FATHER, within the boundaries of the Conejo Valley Unified School District. She is presently identified as eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired due to her diagnosed chronic asthma and severe allergies. STUDENT functions in the above average to superior range in cognitive ability. STUDENT currently attends tenth grade in the Thousand Oaks High School.

STUDENT was diagnosed in 1994 with chronic disabling asthma and environmental allergies. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 1.) STUDENT attended a nonpublic elementary school from the first through the third grades and transferred to Manzanita elementary school within the boundaries of the District in the fourth grade. (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, pp. 236-237.) She missed many days of school.(Footnote 3) In the fifth grade (1997-1998), STUDENT was absent from school for twenty-three days and required home schooling. (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, p. 237.) In 1998, concerned that STUDENT might fall behind in her academic progress due to her illness and absences and worried over the social isolation engendered by her home instruction, STUDENT’s parents requested a special education assessment. Responding to the PARENTS’ request, the District’s assessor interviewed the PARENTS and the school nurse and reviewed STUDENT’s school and medical records. Relying completely on STUDENT’s doctors’ findings and opinions and performing no medical testing of its own, the District’s assessment noted that STUDENT carried several medical diagnoses, including asthma, chronic sinusitis and chronic severe nasal allergy. (Petitioner’s Exh. 8.) At that time, STUDENT was under the care of two pediatricians; an ear, nose and throat specialist; and Dr. Allen G. Peerless, an allergist/immunologist.(Footnote 4) STUDENT’s medication regimen varied depending on the severity of her symptoms, but generally included the use of antibiotics, inhalers, nebulizers, steroids, and saline nasal rinses. (MOTHER testimony.) In times of extreme distress, STUDENT was taken to the emergency room. The PARENTS told the District that STUDENT’s treatment included medications and “strict environmental control of [her] allergies.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, pp. 1 and 10.) STUDENT’s home was tested for molds and dust mites and treatment included the use of HEPA filters and dehumidifiers. (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, pp. 235-241.)

At the initial IEP meeting in June 1998, upon consideration of this assessment, STUDENT was found to be eligible for special education as other health impaired (OHI). The team concluded that STUDENT’s severe chronic asthma and allergies led to limited strength and vitality and alertness, impacted her ability to attend school, and adversely impacted her school performance, and that STUDENT required support from special education. Mr. Jack Bannon, the associate director of special education for the District attended the meeting and testified that the IEP team was told of STUDENT’s allergies to molds and dust mites. The PARENTS requested that STUDENT’s classrooms be tested for these allergens, but the District declined and no testing was performed. Observing that STUDENT missed a great deal of regular school because of her medical condition, the primary goal was to improve STUDENT’s school attendance to fifty percent of the time. (Petitioner’s Exh. 10.)

In the sixth grade, for the year governed by the 1998 IEP, STUDENT transferred within the District to Banyon elementary school, which had a regularly maintained and cleaned filtered air and heating system. (Petitioner’s Exh. 11, p. 250.) There STUDENT’s health and school attendance improved. Exposure to a science project in her classroom which involved molds caused STUDENT to become ill and to resume home schooling. Following this incident, on May

12, 1999, Dr. Peerless informed the District that STUDENT should avoid environmental mold exposures and he recommended abatement procedures that included removal of these contributory conditions and other remedies.(Footnote 5) (Respondent’s Exh. 8.)

At the end of sixth grade at the next IEP meeting held on May 27, 1999, it was noted that although school records reported that STUDENT’s attendance had improved to approximately eighty percent, the register did not include the days STUDENT left school early because of her illness. (Petitioner’s Exh. 11, p. 255.) To adjust for STUDENT’s early departures, it was agreed that for seventh grade STUDENT’s core subjects would be scheduled early in the day and that electives and physical education would be slated later. The IEP goal was for STUDENT to improve her full-day school attendance to eighty percent. (Petitioner’s Exh. 11, p. 254.) The IEP also provided that a “safe room,” that is an environmentally clean room, would be identified where STUDENT could go if she felt ill. The PARENTS would be notified in advance of any science project that involved chemicals, plants or molds. In November 1999, Dr. Peerless recommended that STUDENT avoid the gymnasium and library environments because these areas are “usually replete with mold, a documented group of allergens to STUDENT.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 29.)

STUDENT attended Redwood Middle School for seventh and eighth grades. The IEP team met in March 2000. STUDENT continued to be eligible for special education as OHI. The team determined that STUDENT should be excused from physical education, that she should attend five class periods each day and that she could obtain home teaching upon her parents’ request. The goals included that STUDENT attend school “on a regular basis.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 12, p. 261.) MOTHER testified that the team discussed STUDENT’s health and her placement. The team added to the IEP “classrooms that would benefit her health (hand selected classrooms) will be assigned for STUDENT’s class schedule.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 12, p. 259.) During the seventh grade, all STUDENT’s classes were held in the school’s main building. (Cosaro testimony.) According to FATHER, it was the first time STUDENT did not require home schooling in two years. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, pg. 33A.) STUDENT was treated by an allergist/immunologist and indoor environmental expert, Dr. James Seltzer, starting in 1999.(Footnote 6) According to Dr. Seltzer and STUDENT, STUDENT’s health improved in the spring of 2000.

Over the summer months, STUDENT was weaned off all medications with the exception of rinsing her sinuses with a saline solution, and she gained weight and grew. (FATHER testimony; STUDENT testimony.)

For the eighth grade STUDENT was scheduled to attend an Honors English and an Honors mathematics class, which met in modular classrooms rather than in the main building. According to the testimony and STUDENT’s time tracker, STUDENT began to feel sick from the first day she was in the modular units. (Petitioner’s Exh. 3, p. 163C.) STUDENT reported her increasing symptoms to Drs. Peerless and Seltzer. STUDENT testified that she attended her English and mathematics classes but would go home early as she got progressively worse. STUDENT resumed her heavy medication regimen. These treatments continued into the night hours because STUDENT had difficulty sleeping. (STUDENT testimony; MOTHER testimony.) Both Dr. Seltzer and Dr. Peerless attributed STUDENT’s “dramatic” and complex set of symptoms to her presence in the modular classrooms. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, pp. 32; 34-35.) On September 27, 2000, Dr. Peerless wrote a letter to Tim Carpenter, the school principal, requesting that STUDENT be moved to one of the permanent classrooms. MOTHER testified that she hand-delivered this letter to Mr. Carpenter and asked if STUDENT’s Honor classes could be taught in the main building instead of the modular classrooms, but that this request was declined.

Sometime between September and November 2000, Mr. Bannon became aware of the problem. Mr. Bannon testified that he and Mr. Carpenter spoke about Dr. Peerless’s letter. Neither thought that there was proof that STUDENT was having problems in the modular classrooms. Mr. Carpenter indicated that STUDENT’s teachers did not observe that she was ill and the school’s attendance records did not show unusual absences. (Respondent’s Exh. 31.) In an attempt to resolve the problem, the IEP team met again on November 21, 2000. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 13 and 59.) The PARENTS’ advocate demanded that STUDENT not return to the modular classrooms and reported to the team STUDENT’s doctors’ opinions that STUDENT should be removed from the modular units.(Footnote 7) Mr. Bannon noted that Dr. Seltzer suggested that installation of HEPA filters in the units’ ventilation system might be an alternative and Mr. Bannon asked FATHER to investigate what kind of filtration system was needed. (Bannon testimony.) The testimony and the handwritten summary of the meeting indicated that other classroom “options” were discussed. (Petitioner’s Exh. 13.)

The IEP meeting ended without resolution. On November 22, 2000, Petitioner filed a request for a due process hearing. On November 27, 2000, the PARENTS brought STUDENT to the administrative offices and requested “an alternative safe and healthy setting” for STUDENT to continue her mathematics and English instruction. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 51.) The District located STUDENT in the administrative offices and kept her there until the end of the 2000-2001 school year for her English and mathematics class periods. STUDENT attended her other classes in the main building. STUDENT testified that when she was out of the modular classrooms, her health gradually improved.

During the seven months STUDENT was in the administrative offices for two periods per day, Mrs. Karon Maloney, the Honors mathematics teacher, met with STUDENT in those offices for anywhere from fifteen to forty-five minutes on days when Mrs. Maloney did not have a conflicting appointment or when neither of the two was ill. (STUDENT testimony; Mrs. Maloney testimony.) Mrs. Christina Pantoja, the Honors English teacher, did not meet with STUDENT face-to-face but sent STUDENT month-long packets of assignments. (Pantoja testimony; STUDENT testimony.)

On June 21, 2001, one day after the 2000-2001 school year ended, at the request of Mr. Bannon, Mr. Brian Stratouly of Aero Environmental Services tested the air quality of certain classrooms, including the two modular classrooms.(Footnote 8) After making a visual inspection, collecting air samples and conducting tests, Mr. Stratouly found no elevated fungal growth within the classrooms. Mr. Stratouly concluded that the air quality in the units was not degraded by fungal spores and that the classrooms were safe for occupancy. (Respondent’s Exh. 34.) Mr. Bryan McLaren, the HVAC mechanic testified that the units were well maintained and that the modular classrooms were properly heated and cooled.(Footntoe 9)

Attempts at mediation and settlement failed and the matter proceeded to hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

The parties agreed that STUDENT was eligible for special education under the category of other health impaired (OHI). STUDENT was so identified in 1998 and STUDENT’s diagnosed chronic asthma and severe allergies adversely affected her educational performance. See Title 5 C.C.R. section 3030(f). There was also no dispute that STUDENT was above average in cognitive ability and skills. The parties were also in agreement that the primary goals were for STUDENT to maintain her high academic standards in the regular education program, to improve her full-day regular school attendance and to avoid the isolation of home instruction.

I. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE for her English and mathematics instruction from the start of the 2000-2001 school year until November 22, 2000?

Petitioner identified several issues which arose out of STUDENT’s assignment to two modular classrooms for her Honors English and Honors mathematics classes from the beginning of the school year until the start of the Thanksgiving holiday in November 2000. The Hearing Officer will address two of these concerns together.

A. Was placement of STUDENT in two modular classrooms from August 29, 2000 until November 22, 2000 appropriate?

B. Did the District have the obligation to test the classrooms to which STUDENT was assigned in a timely fashion?(Footnote 10)

The hearing was consumed by considerable testimony regarding STUDENT’s assignment to two modular classrooms from the beginning of the fall 2000 through November 22, 2000 for Honors English and Honors mathematics classes. There was testimony that while STUDENT’s health had improved in the spring and summer of 2000, STUDENT’s allergic reactions and asthmatic symptoms dramatically increased from the first day she was in these modular units. (STUDENT testimony; Petitioner’s Exh. 3, p. 163C.) STUDENT’s doctors’ opined that contaminants in those units caused her distress and precipitated her need to restart her heavy medication regimen. (Petitioner’s Exh 1, p. 32 and 34.) There was some further testimony that even though the District had completely relied previously on STUDENT’s expert doctors’ opinions, and the District received a letter at the end of September from one of STUDENT’s allergists/immunologists linking her symptoms to these classrooms and asking that she be removed from them, Mr. Carpenter and Mr. Bannon did little more than talk to each other.

The District provided no explanation why it disregarded STUDENT’s board-certified and expert doctors’ assessments and opinions on this occasion when it had previously relied on them in determining STUDENT’s eligibility for special education. Nor did it provide a rationale for its dependance on the untrained observations of its staff that STUDENT appeared well. Mr. Carpenter refused MOTHER’s request that STUDENT’s Honors classes be moved to the main building, deciding that such a move would be too “disruptive” and that his teachers would be inconvenienced if they had to move their supplies. (Carpenter testimony; Maloney testimony; Pantoja testimony.) According to MOTHER, Mr. Carpenter added that he “would not move four classes for one sick kid.” As part of his “problem solving,” Mr. Bannon conceded that he might have suggested that STUDENT wear a mask. (Bannon testimony.)

In addition, there was testimony concerning the nature of portable classrooms in general as well as whether these particular modular units contained contaminants or were sufficiently ventilated, cleaned and maintained to provide the environmentally safe classrooms the IEP team had determined STUDENT required to meet her needs. The District finally got around to retaining an air quality expert to perform a limited test of the modular classrooms after the school year ended in June 2001. While the District’s expert concluded that its June 2001 test results meant that the modular units had been safe for occupancy in the fall of 2000 (Stratouly testimony; Respondent’s Exh. 34), STUDENT’s expert, Dr. Seltzer, opined that the District’s tests were neither comprehensive enough or sufficiently close in time to access the risks to STUDENT’s health back in the fall of 2000.

Nevertheless, the fact remains that STUDENT received instruction in English and mathematics from the start of the school year until she was removed from the modular classrooms on November 27, 2000. Notably, Petitioner does not challenge the academic adequacy of that instruction, nor does she seek compensatory educational services for the period that she was in the modular units. Petitioner requests that the Hearing Officer issue findings concerning the effects on STUDENT’s health of modular classrooms in general and these rooms in particular as well as a finding that the classrooms should have been assessed in a timely fashion. However, these matters are not of legal significance in determining whether STUDENT is entitled to the remedy she does seek, namely compensatory educational services for lost educational opportunity after she was removed from these two modular classrooms. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will not address these issues. The Hearing Officer notes that the testimony is of some use because it provides a backdrop from which to analyze the District’s conduct at a November 21, 2000 IEP meeting, and to determine the appropriateness of the placement that ultimately followed.

II. Were the District’s suggested classroom options at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting appropriate?(Footnote 11)

Although there was some disagreement about the nature of the meeting, it appears that the IEP team met on November 21, 2000, both in an attempt to address the concerns of STUDENT’s parents and to provide an annual review of STUDENT’s goals and objectives. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 13 and 59.) The District personnel testified that the meeting was contentious and was not going anywhere. (Gordon testimony.) The PARENTS’ advocate demanded that STUDENT not return to the modular classrooms, relying on Dr. Peerless’s view and quoting Dr. Seltzer’s opinion that STUDENT should “avoid [modular units] at all costs.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 59, pp. 30-31; Respondent’s Exh. 16 [letter dated October 17, 2000].) Both the unofficial transcript of the PARENTS’ tape recording of the meeting and the handwritten summary of the meeting revealed that alternative classroom “option[s]” were mentioned (Petitioner’s Exh. 13, p. 268; Petitioner’s Exh. 59.)(Footnote 12) Mrs. Jean Gordon, vice principal of Redwood Middle School, testified that the District suggested placing STUDENT in an eighth grade College Preparatory (CP) English class with a modified curriculum in the main building.(Footnote 13) According to Mrs. Gordon, the District proposed that STUDENT could attend a resource specialist teacher’s classroom in the main building and receive special mathematics instruction either from the Honors mathematics teacher or the resource specialist teacher in that room. At the meeting the PARENTS were asked whether they wanted to resume home teaching. (Petitioner’s Exh. 59.) Although there was debate over the appropriate classroom for STUDENT to receive her English and mathematics instruction, the team reached no agreement and made no formal offer of a change of STUDENT’s classrooms.

The Hearing Officer finds that the placement dialogue cannot be characterized as anything more than a conversation and that the IEP team never produced a clear, coherent offer of alternative classrooms for STUDENT. The IEP team, on the handwritten addendum, merely referred to its suggestions as “options.” Furthermore, Mr. Bannon conceded that there was no formal offer to change STUDENT’s classrooms because in the District’s view there was insufficient “proof” that STUDENT should be moved out of the modular units.(Footnote 14) The PARENTS had no reason to believe that the proposed “options” or suggested choices amounted to a clear IEP decision that should have been taken seriously. See Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. section 1415(b)(3). The District’s suggestions demonstrated that it had not carefully thought through and selected alternative classrooms that were appropriate for STUDENT nor did it alert the PARENTS that they should seriously consider them.(Footnote 15)

In effect conceding that it made no formal placement offer, the District nevertheless asserted as a defense that the alternatives it proposed were reasonable and that it was the PARENTS who were to blame for STUDENT’s ultimate classroom location for rejecting its proposed alternatives. This argument is unavailing. The District is mistaken that either the contentious nature of the meeting, or the fact the team reached no consenus, or that the meeting ended without resolution absolved it from its responsibility to see to it that the IEP process resulted in a clear written offer of placement alternatives that were appropriate for STUDENT. See Union, 15 F. 3d at 1526 [“We find that a school district cannot escape its obligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate educational placement by arguing that a disabled child’s parents expressed unwillingness to accept that placement.”]; see also Seattle School District, No.1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493 (9th Cir. 1996). If the District actually considered the options identified at the IEP appropriate placement offers or even a partial new offer, in light of the PARENTS declining these choices, it had the right and duty to file promptly for a due process hearing to implement the IEP and insure STUDENT a FAPE. See Cal. Education Code section 56346(b).

Here the District neither made a formal offer to change STUDENT’s classrooms nor sought legal redress to implement the alternatives it had suggested. Ultimately, the District acquiesced and removed STUDENT from the modular classrooms for her English and mathematics instruction and placed her instead in the school’s administrative offices for two periods a day for the remainder of the school year. The Hearing Officer will next determine whether STUDENT’s placement in the administrative offices was appropriate in the least restrictive environment.

III. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment when it located STUDENT in administrative offices for English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 until the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

Under both the State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) The student’s IEP must provide, among other things, for the student to be involved and progress in the general curriculum and to participate in extracurricular and other non-academic activities. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d).) “Special education” is defined as specially designed education, at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Education Code section 56031.)

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s individualized education program must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the students’ abilities.

In summary, under the IDEA and the Rowley decision, the educational program must be designed: (1) to meet the student’s unique needs; (2) to provide the student with some educational benefit and; (3) to conform to the students’ IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley 458 U.S. 176.) Additionally, (4) all of these requirements must be met in a placement that constitutes the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Education Code § 56031.)

After the unsuccessful November 21, 2000 IEP meeting, on November 27, 2000, the PARENTS brought STUDENT to the administrative offices. In a letter addressed to the school, they wrote that because of STUDENT’s physician’s request that she be situated in permanent classrooms, “we are requesting an alternative safe and healthy setting for STUDENT to continue her academic skills at her level with the proper instructor. She will be attending all her other classes as usual.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 51.) MOTHER testified that she hoped the school would know what to do and assumed that there would be ongoing discussions about program options. The PARENTS both testified that they did not ask for STUDENT to be placed in the administrative offices. Mr. Carpenter could not recall how the “transfer” happened. (Carpenter testimony.) Nevertheless, the District never moved STUDENT from the administrative offices and she spent two hours each day in these offices for the remainder of the regular 2000-2001 school year. STUDENT’s Honors English teacher had no face-to-face contact with STUDENT during that time, and STUDENT’s Honors mathematics teacher met with STUDENT on a part-time and irregular basis. STUDENT testified that at first she was placed in a walkway area and sometimes had to sit on the floor. (Petitioner’s Exh. 37.2.) STUDENT testified that this area was noisy; all students who were late or being disciplined were present in this area, telephones rang, and teachers walked by on the way to their lounge. Mrs. Holtz testified that STUDENT was then placed in a room within the administrative offices behind the nurse’s office, but that in December STUDENT was moved to her old counseling office. (Holtz testimony; Petitioner’s Exh. 37.4.)

1. In order to determine whether the English and mathematics placement from November 27, 2000 to the end of the regular 2000-2001 school year was appropriate in the least restrictive environment, it is necessary to first identify STUDENT’s unique needs.

a. What were STUDENT’s unique needs?

To determine STUDENT’s unique needs, it is necessary to identify her physical limitations. STUDENT suffered from diagnosed chronic asthma and severe allergies. STUDENT’s doctors managed STUDENT’s physical limitations at home using a combination of medications and “strict environmental controls” to limit STUDENT’s exposure to molds and dust mites which were known allergens for STUDENT. The District was aware that all STUDENT’s doctors recommended similar environmental restrictions at school, including that STUDENT avoid particular science projects and the gymnasium and library since those areas were usually replete with mold. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, pp. 1; 10; 20; 25; 27; 29; 30; Peerless testimony.)

At the initial IEP meeting in June 1998 and all those that followed, the District concluded that STUDENT’s allergies and medication regimen adversely impacted her ability to attend school with her peers on a regular basis and to complete her class and home work assignments on time. At the time of the initial meeting, STUDENT had been on home teaching for several months (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, p. 239) and the PARENTS worried both that STUDENT would fall behind in her academics and that home schooling isolated STUDENT from her peers. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 47 [June 10, 1999 letter].) The IEP team observed that STUDENT preferred attending school (Petitioner’s Exh. 10, p. 247) and STUDENT’s home teacher stated that it is “unfortunate [that STUDENT] has to miss the social interaction on which most eleven year old girls thrive.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, p. 237.)

In sum, STUDENT’s diagnosed illness and allergies often consigned her to homebound instruction, limited her ability to attend school on a regular basis and caused her to miss intellectual and social interactions with her peers. The Hearing Officer finds to meet these limitations, STUDENT’s unique needs were to improve her full-day attendance at school, to avoid the isolation of home instruction, to interact with her peers and to participate fully in the regular education program. In addition, the Hearing Officer further finds that STUDENT’s unique needs included assignments to classrooms that were environmentally safe for her.

b. Did the administrative offices meet STUDENT’s unique needs?

STUDENT’s unique needs required her to be in a regular classroom that did not exacerbate her allergies and included full participation with her peers in the general education curriculum. While the administrative offices met STUDENT’s need for an environmentally safe room,(Footnote 16) the Hearing Officer finds that locating STUDENT in an administrative office for two hours each day without any classmates, let alone a teacher, utterly failed to meet her unique needs either to be educated with her peers or to be in a regular classroom setting.

2. Did the placement confer some educational benefit?

It is by now well settled that “implicit in the Congressional purpose of providing access to a ‘free appropriate public education’ is the requirement that the education to which access is provided be sufficient to confer some educational benefit upon the handicapped child. ...We therefore conclude that the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the handicapped child. (footnote omitted.)” Rowley, 458 at pp. 200-201. The primary question presented in this case is whether locating STUDENT in the administrative offices for English and mathematics instruction provided access to a program that conferred educational benefit.

a. STUDENT’s English instruction.

STUDENT’s English teacher, Mrs. Christina Pantoja, provided STUDENT with a packet of assignments for one month at a time through either a student or Mrs. Holtz. (Pantoja testimony; STUDENT testimony.)(Footnote 17) STUDENT was told to “learn and study.” (STUDENT testimony.) While Mrs. Pantoja was available to STUDENT by way of notes or communication through the PARENTS and by telephone contact for clarification of her assignments, Mrs. Pantoja had no direct instructional contact with STUDENT from November 27, 2000 until the end of the school year in June 2001. (Pantoja testimony; STUDENT testimony.) Access to a regular education program contemplates at a minimum regular instruction in a classroom by a teacher typically along side other students. STUDENT received no such access. Receipt of instruction while sitting alone in an administrative office provided only with month-long packets of English assignments not even delivered by her teacher was, as Petitioner’s attorney aptly put it, akin to a “correspondence course.” STUDENT was deprived of teacher-to-student and student-to-student interaction that even Mrs. Pantoja acknowledged was a significant part of the English curriculum. Only by virtue of the fact that STUDENT’s English scholarship is superb and that her intellect and tenacity allowed her to essentially become an autodidact and to maintain high grades is the Hearing Officer constrained to find that STUDENT received access to a program which conferred some educational benefit in English sufficient to satisfy the IDEA and Rowley.

b. STUDENT’s mathematics instruction.

As for STUDENT’s mathematics instruction, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not provided with access to a program that was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. The credible testimony demonstrated that the approach was hit or miss and that STUDENT was not provided with a full class hour of mathematics instruction on a regular basis. Mrs. Maloney, STUDENT’s Honors mathematics teacher recalled that Mrs. Holtz, STUDENT’s counselor, asked her to instruct STUDENT during her free period, which was the school’s first period. Mrs. Maloney testified that she was advised that it was not a “good policy” to provide individual instruction during a free period, so she met with STUDENT before school started. Mrs. Maloney testified that she provided instruction every day unless she had a meeting, or a morning study session, or attended a conference, or if she or STUDENT was sick, or if she was on “stair duty.” Mrs. Maloney stated that she met with STUDENT for anywhere from fifteen to forty minutes. STUDENT recalled that they typically did not really get started until 8:45 a.m. and stopped before the first period class began at 9:05 a.m.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that STUDENT continues to struggle in this area of study because she was not provided with an adequate foundation in eighth grade mathematics and did not derive educational benefit from this instruction. According to Mrs. Maloney, she and STUDENT would work out the homework problems together, would discuss the next lesson and try some problems. However, STUDENT testified that Mrs. Maloney permitted her to solve complex mathematics problems “in her own way” rather than the “correct way.” The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s grade in mathematics in the spring 2001 school term fell from an A minus to a B minus, a drop of one grade which the Hearing Officer finds significant for this gifted student. In the ninth grade, STUDENT’s grade dropped to a C. (Respondent’s Exh. 38.)

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the dropping by of a mathematics teacher on an irregular and part-time basis to review homework assignments and to scan parts of lessons in an area of study that STUDENT continues to find difficult did not come close to approximating what Congress intended by access to an instructional program that conferred educational benefit on a student.

3. Did the placement comport with the March 2000 IEP?

The March 2000 IEP reiterated previous goals that focused on improving STUDENT’s full-day school attendance. (Petitioner’s Exh. 12, p. 261.)(Footnote 18) In addition, there was no dispute, that the IEP required that STUDENT fully participate in the regular education program. Finally, the IEP required that STUDENT would attend classes in rooms that were environmentally safe for her. The IEP team determined that “classrooms that would benefit her health (hand selected classrooms) will be assigned for STUDENT’s class schedules.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 12, p. 261.) There was much testimony and dispute over the meaning of this provision. The District witnesses testified that this language simply meant that the order of STUDENT’s class schedule would be designed especially for her instead of generated by the computer. On the other hand, the PARENTS testified that this phrase meant that particular rooms were to be chosen to reflect STUDENT’s unique need for an environmentally safe classroom.

The Hearing Officer does not find convincing that this provision in the IEP was only meant to address scheduling concerns. The Hearing Officer finds that the provision means what it says.(Footnote 19) Mrs. Gordon acknowledged that the word “classroom” in an IEP typically indicates a specific room. (Gordon testimony.) The Hearing Officer finds more persuasive the testimony that the phrase “classrooms that would benefit her health (hand selected classrooms)” meant that when STUDENT’s class schedule was made, classrooms would be especially selected to meet STUDENT’s unique need for environmentally safe rooms. This finding finds further support in the history of this case and the course of development of STUDENT’s IEPs. By the time of the March 2000 IEP meeting, the District was keenly aware of STUDENT’s need for an environmentally safe classroom.

The location of STUDENT in administrative offices did not comport with STUDENT’s IEP. STUDENT was not placed in “hand selected classrooms.” She was not placed in a classroom at all. For STUDENT, remaining at school rather than being instructed at home and participation in regular education classes with her peers was the core of her educational experience and one she was denied for her English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 to the end of the regular 2001 school year.

4. Was the instruction provided in the administrative offices in the least restrictive environment?

Special education law requires that a child be educated in the least restrictive environment. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 20 U.S.C. 1414(c)(5)(1)(A)(iii)(III); Cal. Education Code § 56031). The IDEA mandates that a special education student be educated with nondisabled peers to the maximum extent appropriate and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the “nature or severity of the disability of the child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see Rowley, 458 U.S. at 202 and n.24.)

It barely needs stating that locating STUDENT in administrative offices isolated from her peers for seven months for two hours each day was not placing her in the least restrictive environment. The District presented no evidence to the contrary. The least restrictive environment was placement in classrooms in the main building. STUDENT testified credibly that being in the administrative offices was far worse than being confined to her home for instruction. For all intents and purposes, with the exception of the intermittent visits by her mathematics teacher, STUDENT was left alone with written packets of English assignments and a mathematics textbook to fend for and teach herself. The Hearing Officer finds that the placement of STUDENT in the administrative offices was akin to placing her in a “bubble” and one that wholly failed to meet the legal requirement that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment.

Implicit in the District’s defense that it was not to blame for STUDENT’s ultimate placement in the administrative offices was its assertion that STUDENT’s parents did not register an objection to her placement there. The Hearing Officer has already rejected the District’s similar contention that it should not be found liable because it allegedly made reasonable alternative classroom suggestions at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting that the PARENTS refused. As noted earlier, the District had an obligation to provide STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment no matter what the parents’ position.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for her English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 until the end of the school year in June 2001 to the extent that it failed to provide a placement that met STUDENT’s unique needs, failed to confer educational benefit in mathematics, failed to comport with her IEP, and failed to satisfy the requirements of the least restrictive environment.

IV. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the failure of the District to provide her with a FAPE from November 27, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

STUDENT requests an award of compensatory education in the form of in-home tutoring at the District’s expense in both English and mathematics in the amount of one hour for each hour of instruction she missed from November 27, 2000 through the end of the regular 2000-2001 school year. The District, in a position to know STUDENT’s needs, apparently offered to provide that tutoring. (Respondent’s June 14, 2002 Statement of Issues, Proposed Resolution.)

When a school district denies a special education student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. In addition, equitable considerations may be weighed in granting relief and courts have broad discretion to fashion a remedy which helps a student to overcome lost educational opportunity. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). There is no obligation to provide day-for-day or hour-for hour compensation. “Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA” Puyallup, 31 F.3d at 1497.

In the present case, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE to the extent that it did not provide an appropriate placement in the least restrictive environment for her English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 to the end of the school year. However, it is difficult to ascertain based upon the sketchy evidence presented if STUDENT has suffered residual educational harm in English two years later. Fortunately for the District, STUDENT is a gifted student, who through her own hard work achieved high grades in English throughout the 2000-2001 school year and appears to continue to do so. (Respondent’s Exhs. 32 and 38.) Accordingly, in the absence of evidence of lost educational opportunity in English, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that STUDENT is entitled to English tutoring.

The evidence of lost educational opportunity for mathematics is more substantial. STUDENT testified that at the present time she continues to experience problems in her mathematics classes. Unlike some other subjects, mathematics courses build on one another and, where as here, STUDENT missed a semester of instruction, she is ill equipped for the following years. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds STUDENT’s testimony persuasive that her ongoing difficulties in mathematics stem from the poor foundation in her eighth grade instruction whereby she was permitted to solve problems in her “own way” rather than the “right way.” As stated earlier, the Hearing Officer observes that STUDENT’s mathematics grade dropped from an A minus to a B minus over the course of the eighth grade, and further notes that STUDENT’s grade in the ninth grade was a C. (Respondent’s Exh. 38, 2/2002 transcript.). In addition, taking account of the equities, the District’s suggestion at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting that STUDENT be placed in a resource specialist program for mathematics was hardly a reasonable proposal.

Given that tenth grade mathematics is fairly demanding but also taking account of STUDENT’s intelligence and her high school schedule, the Hearing Officer finds that 2.5 hours per week of in-home tutoring in mathematics by a credentialed teacher at the District’s expense for the remainder of the 2002-2003 regular school year and the extended school year is adequate. The tutoring will be arranged with STUDENT’s parents to fit STUDENT’s schedule and in a fashion that accommodates a FAPE.(Footnote 20)

V. Was the District obligated to perform its own assessment of STUDENT and are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of medical assessments they obtained at private expense?

Petitioner asserts that the District was obligated to conduct a reassessment of STUDENT during the fall of 2000 when it refused to believe that STUDENT was becoming ill in the modular classrooms. STUDENT’s parents seek reimbursement for the costs of independent medical assessments they obtained which linked STUDENT’s illness to her presence in the modular units.

Cal. Education Code section 56381(a) provides that reassessment of a student with a disability “shall be conducted at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the pupil’s parent or teacher requests a reassessment and a new individualized education program to be developed. (Emphasis added.)” Here, the Hearing Officer finds that a reassessment by the District was warranted.

Until the fall of 2000, the District had completely relied on STUDENT’s private doctors’ findings and expert opinions to determine that STUDENT was eligible for special education as OHI and never performed any testing of its own. The District had not disputed that STUDENT’s diagnosed asthma and allergies were so severe as to warrant special education. The March 2000 IEP team agreed, based upon STUDENT’s doctors’ recommendations to impose restrictions on the school environment to which STUDENT was exposed, that STUDENT required placement in classrooms that would benefit her health. The District was aware days before the fall 2000 school term began that the PARENTS had serious concerns about placing STUDENT in the modular units. (Holtz testimony; FATHER and MOTHER testimony.) In the early days of September, STUDENT’s parents repeatedly contacted Mrs. Holtz and Mr. Carpenter and reported that STUDENT was getting sick in those classrooms and asked that her classes be moved to the main building. According to the testimony, the District denied these requests relying on the conclusions of its untrained staff that STUDENT did not look sick to them.(Footnote 21) Without a professional medical evaluation of STUDENT of its own, the District was left with its unsupported conjecture that the modular classrooms did not pose a danger to STUDENT’s health at the crucial time it was making decisions where to place STUDENT.

Absent an assessment by the District, STUDENT’s parents were entitled to obtain one independent assessment. According to the IDEA, the purpose of either the initial assessment or reassessment is to gather all relevant information, including information provided by the parents, that will assist the IEP team to determine whether the student is a child with a disability and, if so, to provide the team with information it will need to develop an appropriate IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(A)(B).) The IDEA emphasizes the need to gather information and data from parents, teachers, classroom observations, and “other qualified professionals.” (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(4)(A); 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c)(1)(A).) See also Cal. Education Code §§ 56329(b); 56505(c); 34 C.F.R. § 3022. Although a parent’s independent assessment is not legally required to play such a role, the Hearing Officer observes in this case that Dr. Peerless’s September 27, 2000 letter played a pivotal part in determining STUDENT’s educational needs. Accordingly, upon receipt of proof of that portion of Dr. Peerless’s bill which can be attributed to his time to evaluate STUDENT and for the time attributed to preparing and writing the September 27th letter, the District shall reimburse Petitioner for that amount. This award is not meant to cover the cost of medical treatment, nor for payments for Dr. Seltzer.

VI. Did the District act in bad faith in this case?

Petitioner requests that the Hearing Officer make findings that the District acted in bad faith or with intentional disregard for or deliberate indifference for STUDENT’s rights. Petitioner has failed to cite any authority for the Hearing Officer to make such findings. The Hearing Officer is aware that federal regulations state that the District shall make a good faith effort to assist the child to achieve the goals and objectives or benchmarks listed in the IEP (34 C.F.R. § 300.350(a)) and that Burlington suggests that remedies may be equitable. The Hearing Officer observes that the District was unusually inept in failing to respond timely or sensibly to the situation presented by STUDENT’s illness. In addition, once having acquiesced to STUDENT being removed from the modular units, the District failed in its duty and responsibility to find an appropriate alternative educational setting and/or insure that STUDENT had a FAPE in the least restrictive environment for her English and mathematics instruction. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that there is insufficient evidence in this case that justifies making the findings that Petitioner requests.

ORDER

(1) Within 20 calendar days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting. In consultation with STUDENT’s parents and mindful of STUDENT’s schedule, the team shall determine a schedule to provide 2.5 hours of in-home tutoring in mathematics per week for the remainder of the regular 2002-2003 school year and the extended school year.

(2) Immediately upon completion of the IEP meeting conducted in Order (1), the District shall provide 2.5 hours of in-home tutoring in mathematics per week for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year and the extended school year.

(3) Within 30 business days after receipt of proof of payment consistent with this Decision, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the cost of the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Peerless limited to his evaluation of STUDENT and the time to prepare and write the September 27, 2000 letter.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Cal. Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:

I. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE for her English and mathematics instruction from the start of the 2000-2001 regular school year until the end of November 2000?

Neither party prevailed on this issue.

II. Were the District’s suggested placement options at the November 21, 2000 IEP meeting appropriate?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

III. Did the District provide STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment when it located STUDENT in administrative offices for English and mathematics instruction from November 27, 2000 until the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

IV. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for the failure of the District to provide her with a FAPE from November 27, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 regular school year?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services in mathematics.

V. Was the District obligated to perform a reassessment of STUDENT and are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the costs of medical assessments they obtained at private expense?

Petitioner prevailed on the issue that the District was obligated to perform a reassessment of STUDENT and prevailed to the extent that STUDENT’s parents will be reimbursed for the cost of one assessment.

VI. Did the District act in bad faith in this case?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Education Code § 56505(i).

DATED: January 8, 2003 _________________________________ Judith E. Ganz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The issues listed here differ both in numbering and wording from those noticed by the Petitioner. Changes were made for the purposes of clarification and appropriate analysis. 2. According to the testimony, STUDENT was assigned to the two modular classrooms until the start of the Thanksgiving 2000 holiday. 3. STUDENT was absent eleven days in the first grade, nine days in the second grade, eleven days in the third grade, and sixteen days in the fourth grade. (Petitioner’s Exh. 8, pp. 236-237.) 4. Dr. Peerless has been treating STUDENT since 1997. He is a board-certified allergist and immunologist. Dr. Peerless diagnosed STUDENT with perennial allergic rhinosinusitis and reactive airway disease (asthma). (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 12.) 5. Dr. Peerless suggested that the District provide clean air ventilation with exhaustion of contaminated air to the outdoors, use of a properly sized and rated dehumidifier, keeping the classroom humidity at less than 35%, routine cleaning of the classroom with fungicidal solution, routine use of the fungistatic agent Impregon, and routine use of a properly sized and rated portable HEPA air filter. The District did not undertake these measures. 6. STUDENT started seeing Dr. Seltzer in 1999. He is a board-certified pediatrician, and has been an allergist/immunologist and an expert in environmental medicine for fourteen years. Since 1992, he has been an assistant clinical professor in allergy and immunology at the University of California San Diego. For three years, he served on the advisory panel of the United Stated Environmental Protection Agency indoor air quality committee. He is an expert on the impact of the indoor environment on health. He has qualified as an expert in court in the areas of medicine and the environment fifteen times.(Petitioner’s Exh.3, pp. 77-92.) Dr. Seltzer also performs environmental evaluations under his separate entity, the Indoor Hygienic Technologies Corporation. (Petitioner’s Exh.3, p. 104.) 7. The advocate referred to Dr. Peerless’s September letter and read a letter dated October 17, 2000 from Dr. Seltzer. (Petitioner’s Exh. 1, p. 34.) FATHER testified that in retrospect he should not have waited to produce the doctor’s letter until the IEP meeting. 8. Mr. Stratouly is a registered mechanical engineer and has been an indoor air quality specialist since 1989. He is a certified safety professional and is on the Board of Safety Commission. Mr. Stratouly possesses a bachelor’s and master’s degree in mechanical engineering from the Worcester Massachusetts Polytechnical Institute. He has testified as an expert approximately ten to twelve times in court. (Stratouly testimony.) 9. Mr. McLaren has been the heating and air conditioning mechanic for the District for four and one-half years. 10. Petitioner also asserts that the District failed to perform an assessment of STUDENT to evaluate whether the modular classrooms made STUDENT sick. Discussion of this issue is deferred until the Hearing Officer addresses whether STUDENT’s parents should be reimbursed for the independent assessment they obtained. See section V. 11. While this issue was not specified at the beginning of the hearing, it was addressed by both parties during the course of the hearing. Petitioner presented testimony and documents in support of its assertion that this IEP meeting did not result in a formal offer of appropriate alternative classrooms for STUDENT. Implicit in the District’s defense that it provided an appropriate education for STUDENT was its assertion that it proposed options at this meeting and that it was the PARENTS who were to blame for rejecting its reasonable suggestions. In addition to this issue being a subject that was addressed by both parties, it is also relevant to determining the appropriate remedy. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will address this issue. 12. The handwritten notes stated: “Review of accommodations of 3/00. Option discussed of placing STUDENT in the [College Preparatory] classes outside the modular buildings. That English teacher would enrich her curriculum. Dad did not wish this option.... [Petitioner’s advocate] declined home instruction for STUDENT speaking for the parents.” (Petitioner’s Exh. 13, p. 268). 13. According to the testimony of the PARENTS, there was some misunderstanding whether the District proposed placing STUDENT in a seventh or eighth grade CP English class. The Hearing Officer is satisfied based upon the written IEP report and the unofficial transcript of the November 2000 IEP meeting, that the District was suggesting that STUDENT attend the eighth grade CP English class. 14. Mr. Bannon testified that he did not “know one way or the other” whether STUDENT’s health was adversely affected by her attendance in the modular classrooms. Mr. Carpenter was concerned about the “far reaching ramifications to me and the school if a doctor can write a letter and we have to move all the classes around.” 15. Petitioner asserts that the proposed CP English class that would have maintained STUDENT in the regular education program was not a change in placement per se and that the District advanced no reason why it failed to make that administrative change. It is unnecessary to reach the merits of this individual contention however, because the Hearing Officer finds that considering the District’s proposals as a whole, the alternatives suggested amounted to a placement change that required a formal offer. While the proposed English class is a closer question, the recommendations that STUDENT resume home teaching or that she attend a mathematics class in a resource specialist room with some ill-defined assistance from her mathematics teacher was a drastic departure from the goals of the March 2000 IEP to increase STUDENT’s full-day school attendance in the regular education program. 16. The District provide portable HEPA filters in the administrative offices, and agreed to turn on the filters earlier in the morning before STUDENT’s arrival. While there was some testimony that the HEPA filters were not turned on in a timely manner or placed on the correct setting (STUDENT testimony; FATHER testimony), there was also no testimony that STUDENT became ill during her time in those offices. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that locating STUDENT in the administrative offices comported with that portion of her IEP that she be placed in an environmentally safe room. 17. Over the course of the school year, Mrs. Pantoja provided the assignment packets more frequently, such as every few weeks (Petitioner’s Exh. 54), and modified the assignments after discussion with STUDENT’s parents. (Pantoja testimony.) 18. In STUDENT’s initial IEP in 1998, the objective was for STUDENT to attend school fifty percent of the time. (Petitioner’s Exh. 10.) In the following IEP as well as the March 2000 IEP, the attendance objective was increased to eighty percent. (Petitioner’s Exhs. 11 and 12.) The IEP team observed that STUDENT frequently had to leave school early when she became ill. The attendance goal included not only that STUDENT attend school on a regular basis, but also that she stay in school for the full day of instruction. 19. The word “class” in this context is defined as “a group of students who are taught together because they have roughly the same level of academic development.” (The American Heritage Dictionary (4th ed. 2000.)) In the IEP, the word “room” is used to modify class and carries a completely different meaning. A “room” is defined as “a space that may be occupied,” or “an area separated by walls or partitions from other similar parts of the structure or building in which it is located...” (Id.) 20. In its written closing brief, the District requests that the Hearing Officer make a finding that the relief obtained is “not more favorable” to the parents than the offer of settlement citing 20 U.S.C. section 1415(i)(3)(D)(III). The cited provision lies within the statute which discusses prohibition of attorney’s fees under certain circumstances. An award of attorney’s fees is a matter that lies within the jurisdiction of the District Court. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1415(i)(3)(A) and (B)). The Hearing Officer declines to make such a finding and defers to the District Court as the statute permits. The Hearing Officer notes that another subdivision provides an exception to the prohibition on the award of attorney’s fees, namely that the District Court may determine whether the prevailing party was “substantially justified in rejecting the settlement offer.” See 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i)(3)(E). On this record, there is no evidence presented on the matter why the District’s offer was refused. 21. The District contended that it relied in part on its attendance register that did not record unusual absences for STUDENT. (Respondent’s Exh. 31.) However, the Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of MOTHER and STUDENT that soon after the fall term began, STUDENT had to leave school early approximately half the time after her English and mathematics classes because she was sick. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s attendance records were inaccurate. Although the school health clerk, Mrs. Susan Lipman, testified that STUDENT “looked very healthy,” she did observe that STUDENT checked out early during the fall term.