California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 26, 2004

Huntington Beach City Elementary School District v. Student

SEHO Case No. SN 2080-03 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

Huntington Beach City Elementary's assessments and IEP offer upheld, but District must add a transition plan; Prentice tuition denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 1 of 3 issues (1 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision notes that the prior dispute (SN02-00881) was settled, with the District paying for Prentice in 2002-2003. No remand, vacatur, or correction is noted.

Summary

Huntington Beach City Elementary School District filed for a hearing to defend its May 2003 triennial assessments and its May 29, 2003 IEP offer. The 12-year-old student had received speech-language and resource services at Hawes Elementary. Under a settlement, he then attended the Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school, at District expense for 2002-2003. In May 2003 his eligibility was changed to specific learning disability. The District offered a summer special day class with speech therapy at Hawes. For 2003-2004 it offered half general education and half resource specialist program classes at Sowers Middle School. The parents re-enrolled him at Prentice. They sought tuition and the cost of private assessments by Dr. Christine Davidson and optometrist Dr. Beth Ballinger.

The Hearing Officer found the District's assessments appropriate. They covered dyslexia symptoms, visual and auditory processing, attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), and language, and no separate occupational therapy assessment was needed. He gave little weight to the optometrist's opinion that visual processing was the student's main disability. The District therefore did not have to pay for the private assessments. The offer met the student's needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, with one exception. The IEP lacked the written plan the Education Code required for moving a student from a nonpublic school into regular classes. That gap did not cause the Prentice enrollment, so tuition was denied. The District must hold an IEP meeting within 15 days to add a transition plan.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO applied former Education Code section 56345(b)(4). That section required a written plan when a student moved from a nonpublic school into regular public classes. The Hearing Officer found that leaving this plan out was a violation. He still denied tuition reimbursement because the missing plan was not the reason for the private placement.

Issues and holdings

  1. Issue 1. Were the District's educational evaluations of Student appropriate within the meaning of Education Code sections 56320 et seq. and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b), or was the District obligated to pay for the independent educational assessments by Chris Davidson, Ed.D., and Beth Ballinger, O.D.?

    The District's 2003 assessments covered all areas of suspected disability (dyslexia symptoms, visual and auditory processing, ADHD, language), no separate OT assessment was needed, and the assessments met legal criteria, so reimbursement for the private assessments was denied.

  2. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 2. Did the District's offer of placement at Hawes Elementary School for ESY 2003 and at Sowers Middle School for academic year 2003-2004 constitute an offer of FAPE to Student?

    The ESY and 2003-2004 offers met the student's unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, but the IEP lacked the written plan required by Education Code section 56345(b)(4) for moving the student from a nonpublic school into regular classes.

  3. Issue 3. If the District's offer for academic year 2003-2004 did not constitute a FAPE, should the District be ordered to reimburse Student for the cost of his placement at Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school?

    Reimbursement was denied because the missing transition plan was not why the parent enrolled the student at Prentice; she chose Prentice because she believed he was making more progress there.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. The IEP team must meet within fifteen calendar days of the decision to amend the May 29, 2003 IEP to add a written plan for moving the student from Prentice to Sowers Middle School, and to incorporate the revised goals and objectives the District proposed by letter dated October 2, 2003.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District must implement the May 29, 2003 IEP as amended.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23; School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Lenn v. Portland School Committee; Hailey W. v. Puyallup School District; Morton Sch. Dist. v. Washington State E.A.; Etowah County Bd. of Educ.

People named in the decision

  • John M. Conniff, director of special education, Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Jim Hemsley, executive director, West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE)
  • Cindy Costello, RSP teacher and proposed case manager, Sowers Middle School
  • Ellen Fitzsimmons, school psychologist (district assessor), Huntington Beach City Elementary School District
  • Tina Hennig, fourth grade teacher, Hawes Elementary School
  • Laura Irving, speech and language pathologist, Sowers Middle School
  • Patrick Kunody, general education math teacher, Sowers Middle School
  • Gigi Leiby, speech and language pathologist (district assessor), Hawes Elementary School
  • Kim Roncone, RSP teacher, Hawes Elementary School
  • Teresa Olavarri Rosales, M.D., pediatric ophthalmologist, expert witness for District
  • Jack H. Schnell, Ed.D., educational psychologist, expert witness for District
  • Jane Vogel, special education consultant and vision specialist, expert witness for District
  • Christine Davidson, Ed.D., educational psychologist, independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Beth Ballinger, O.D., consulting optometrist, independent assessor and expert witness for Student
  • Karen Lerner, principal, Prentice School
  • Jane (Jan) Court, teacher, Prentice School
  • Prentice School, certified nonpublic school
  • Tranh T. Le, M.D., private pediatric neurologist
  • Teddi Softley, Ph.D., private neuropsychological assessor, Long Beach Memorial Medical Center
  • Sylvan Learning Center, private summer tutoring provider
  • Miller Children's Hospital, private evaluator (earlier evaluation)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on November 20, 21 and 25, and December 9 and 10, 2003, in Huntington Beach, California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.

Petitioner Huntington Beach City Elementary School District (the District) was represented by Caroline A. Zuk, attorney at law. John M. Conniff, director of special education, and Jim Hemsley, executive director of West Orange County Consortium for Special Education (WOCCSE), also appeared for the District. Respondent Student was represented by Michael Jewell, attorney at law, of Roberts Adams and Jewell. Student ’s mother, also appeared on his behalf.

The District called the following witnesses: John M. Conniff; Cindy Costello, resource specialist program (RSP) teacher at Sowers Middle School (Sowers); Ellen Fitzsimmons, school psychologist; Tina Hennig, fourth grade teacher at Hawes Elementary School (Hawes); Laura Irving, speech and language pathologist at Sowers; Patrick Kunody, general education math teacher at Sowers; Gigi Leiby, M.A., speech and language pathologist at Hawes; Kim Roncone, RSP teacher at Hawes; Teresa Olavarri Rosales, M.D., ophthalmologist; Jack H. Schnell, Ed.D., educational psychologist; and, Jane Vogel, special education consultant and vision specialist. The following witnesses were called on behalf of the Student: Student’s mother; Christine Davidson, Ed.D., educational psychologist; Karen Lerner, principal at the Prentice School (Prentice); Jane Court, Prentice teacher; and Beth Ballinger, O.D., consulting optometrist. Oral testimony and documentary evidence were offered and received. (Footnote 1) The record remained open pending the receipt of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the written closing arguments by the Hearing Officer, the last of which was received on December 31, 2003, by the Hearing Officer, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

1. Were the District’s educational evaluations of Student appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b) or was the District obligated to pay for the independent educational assessments by Chris Davidson, Ed.D., and Beth Ballinger, O.D. provided by the Student?

2. Did the District’s offer of placement at Hawes Elementary School for the extended school year (ESY) 2003 and at Sowers Middle School for academic year 2003-2004 constitute an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student ?

3. If the District’s offer for academic year 2003-2004 did not constitute a FAPE, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to Student for the cost of his placement in Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school? (Footnote 3)

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

A. Petitioner’s Contentions.

The District contends that it conducted appropriate assessments in the areas of language and communication, cognition, auditory and visual processing and academics in May 2003 and that it identified all areas of the Student’s disabilities. The District also contends that it determined the Student’s unique needs in all areas. Finally, the District contends that it offered the Student a FAPE for the extended school year 2003 (ESY) and for academic year 2003-2004.

B. Respondent’s Contentions.

The Student contends that the District failed to identify and assess all areas of his disability, in particular dyslexia, visual processing, auditory processing, occupational therapy and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). He also contends that the District failed to determine and provide for his unique needs in the area of vision. In addition, he contended that the May 29, 2003, individualized education program (IEP) was deficient in that it failed to provide a transition plan, failed to identify accommodations and modifications required to address his unique needs and did not offer an appropriate placement for academic year 2003-2004. (Footnote 4)The Student requests reimbursement for tuition paid to the Prentice School during the academic year to date, for an order placing him at Prentice for the remainder of the academic year, for an order requiring that vision services be provided “as recommended by Petitioner’s experts” and for reimbursement for independent assessments.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a twelve-year-old student who resides with his parents and an older brother within the boundaries of the District. For the current academic year, he was enrolled by his parents and currently attends Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school where he is a sixth grade student.

His eligibility for special education and related services was established first during academic year 1997-1998, his kindergarten year at Hawes Elementary School, a District school. At that time, he was found eligible for special education services due to language disorder, specifically difficulty with morphology and syntax. During first grade, academic year 1998-1999, Student ’s academic performance fell behind. He was evaluated and on the basis of his assessment results, his eligibility for services was established under the primary category speech and language impaired (SLI). He continued to receive designated instruction services (DIS) in the area of speech and language and he was provided assistance with academics in the resource specialist program (RSP) forty-nine percent of the day. The other fifty-one percent of the school-day he was instructed in the general education setting.

Student ’s mother consulted a pediatric neurologist, Tranh T. Le, M.D., during Student ’s third grade year. A recent diagnosis of ADHD by Student ’s pediatrician was confirmed. Dr. Le observed that there was a significant family history of similar disabilities. He had treated Student ’s brother for ADHD some years earlier. Dr. Le also had treated Student ’s older brother for Tourette’s syndrome and learning disorders. Dr. Le found that Student ’s ability to focus was not improving on his present medication, so the doctor changed it from Ritalin to Adderall. Consistent with the District’s evaluations, Dr. Le also observed that Student appeared to have a “language delay,” although he indicated that it was unclear whether this was due to the ADHD condition or an underlying learning disorder. Dr. Le recommended a further evaluation. Consequently Student’s Mother commissioned a neuropsychological assessment by Teddi Softley, Ph.D., of Long Beach Memorial Medical Center. Dr. Softley’s testing, conducted in July 2001 at the conclusion of Student ’s third grade year, resulted in a formal diagnosis of ADHD, reading disorder, written expression language disorder and asthma. Student’s Mother followed up on Dr. Softley’s recommendations by providing Student with a summer program at the Sylvan Learning Center in 2001. She also provided the Softley evaluation to the District which incorporated the diagnoses contained therein. Student continued to receive special education services in the RSP program and DIS services at Hawes through the academic year 2001-2002, his fourth grade year.

The IEP team met on January 24, 2002. At the meeting, which was attended by Student’s Mother, the team adopted goals and objectives in the areas of written language, reading, mathematics, and semantics. The assessments conducted for the 2000-2001 academic year had been updated in part by Kim Roncone, Student ’s RSP specialist. The Woodcock-Johnson III results showed Student performing at the 2.5 grade level in written language skills and 2.2 grade level in reading skills. In mathematics, his best subject, his results were in the 4.0 range, only somewhat behind his grade level. The WORD-R test confirmed that he was still experiencing difficulty with semantics. The testing indicated that Student had low-average cognitive abilities. However, that alone was not sufficient to explain his significantly below-grade academic performance. Despite the intensive RSP program and related services provided by the District, services that were formulated during annual IEP meetings with the participation of Student ’s parents, at the end of academic year 2001-2002 Student ’s academic performance continued to be below grade level. His mother was not satisfied with his progress and consequently disagreed with the District’s offer for academic year 2002-2003 made at the May 23, 2002 IEP meeting.

During the spring semester of calendar year 2002, she made further inquiry and on the basis of her evaluation of the information provided, she concluded that a certified non-public school specializing in dyslexia would better serve Student ’s needs. Student’s Mother requested a due process proceeding. The disagreement, which became due process matter SN02-00881, was resolved by an agreement that provided for Student to attend the Prentice School during academic year 2002-2003 at District expense. In addition, it provided sixty minutes per week of additional speech and language services from September to June 2003.

The settlement agreement also provided the District with the right to further assess Student in the areas of cognition, academic achievement and communication and set an IEP meeting to follow the assessments for the purpose of developing an educational program for academic year 2003-2004. (Footnote 5)These assessments, conducted pursuant to a formal assessment plan of March 27, 2003, are the assessments in issue in this matter.

Student’s Mother attended the IEP meeting that took place May 29, 2003. Personnel from the Prentice School attended via telephone conference call. At that meeting, the triennial assessment results were evaluated, and the Prentice School reports and oral statements of progress and the information presented by Student’s Mother were considered. Kim Roncone, District RSP provider, expressed her disappointment in Student ’s progress at Prentice. She presented his January 2002 assessment results and compared them to the results obtained in May 2003, demonstrating virtually no progress in most areas and some regression in others. The District found that Student continued to be eligible for special education services. His eligibility was changed to specific learning disability (SLD) on the basis of the disparity of his scores on standardized intelligence tests to his academic performance and he was offered an ESY placement at Hawes for summer 2003 during which he would receive one hour per day of speech and language services (four days a week) and four hours per day in a special day class (SDC) four days, and five hours on the fifth day. In addition, for academic year 2003-2004, the District offered Student a placement at Sowers Middle School with three periods in the general education class and three periods in the RSP program together with DIS speech and language services one time per week for forty-five minutes and various accommodations and modifications. Student ’s parents declined the District’s offer and requested another year of placement at Prentice at District expense. The District repeated its offer by letter on July 25, 2003.

On September 15, 2003, Student’s Mother notified the District that its offer was rejected and indicated her intention to enroll Student at Prentice. Student was enrolled at Prentice by his parents for the 2003-2004 academic year and is currently attending Prentice. (Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Were the District’s educational evaluations of Student appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b) or was the District obligated to pay for the independent educational assessments by Chris Davidson, Ed.D. and Beth Ballinger, O.D. provided by the Student?

Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §§ 1400 et seq. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000 et seq. The purpose of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and California’s conforming statutes is to provide disabled students with access to public education. Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982). A free appropriate public education consists of special education and related services that are available to the child, at no charge to the parent or guardian, which meet the State educational standards and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. §1401(8). (Footnote 7)

A school district must first identify the student’s unique educational needs in all areas of the student’s suspected disability. Assessments of a student’s impairments must be conducted by individuals who are both knowledgeable of the student’s disability and competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by a district. (Footnote 8) If a request for such an independent assessment is made, a district must either agree to pay for it, or it must establish at a due process hearing that the school district’s assessment was “appropriate.”

In order for the District to prevail at a due process hearing on the issue of the appropriateness of its assessments, it must show that its assessments evaluated all areas of suspected disability and met the criteria for appropriate assessments.

An appropriate assessment is defined by California Education Code sections 56320 and following. The Education Code provides that assessments must be conducted by individuals who are both “knowledgeable of the student’s disability” and “competent to perform the assessment, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area.” (See specifically Cal. Educ. Code §§56320(g), 56322; see 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(3)(B)(ii)). Tests and assessment materials must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used; must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally or sexually discriminatory; must be provided and administered in the student’s primary language or other mode of communication unless this is clearly not feasible; and must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of such tests. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a), (b)). No single procedure may be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2), (3); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e)). And, where a psychological assessment is part of the assessment program, it must be performed by a credentialed school psychologist. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56324).

The agreement settling the matter for the prior academic year, the settlement in case number SN02-00881, included provisions giving the District the right to assess Student prior to the May 2003 IEP meeting. These assessments constituted the triennial assessment required by California Education Code section 56380 et seq. (Footnote 9) However, Student contends that the assessments were not appropriate and did not inquire correctly into all areas of his suspected disability. He contends that the District failed to assess dyslexia, visual processing, auditory processing, occupational therapy (OT) and ADHD. The Hearing Officer turns to those contentions as well as to an examination of whether the assessments were appropriate.

Dyslexia is a term which describes symptoms of a reading disorder, according to the testimony of Jack Schnell, Ed.D. (Footnote 10) While still a valid term, appearing in the education code, Dr. Schnell testified that the modern practice is to assess for the symptoms of dyslexia in a comprehensive psychoeducational assessment using such tools as the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (C-TONI ), the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), and Test of Visual Perceptual Skills Revised (TVPS-R), the Stanford-Binet, Doss, and parts of the Woodcock-Johnson-III. In other words, modern practice is not to simply identify the reading disorder, but to inquire further into its causes. The District did so. Dr. Schnell testified that he conducted a comprehensive record review in connection with this matter and found that Student had been tested by Ellen Fitzsimmons, the school psychologist, Gigi Leiby, the speech pathologist, and others. He concluded that the testing administered incorporated measures which would identify symptoms of dyslexia and provide information by which these symptoms could be addressed in the Student’s IEP. He opined that his review of the records did not indicate that dyslexia was the primary disorder affecting this Student, although decoding and reading difficulty were areas of Student ’s symptoms. There was no evidence offered by the Student to indicate otherwise. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Schnell’s testimony to be credible and concludes that the District’s testing was appropriate to identify dyslexia.

The District also conducted assessments directed to visual and auditory processing, despite assertions by the Student to the contrary. Ellen Fitzsimmons, M.A., is a credentialed school psychologist, who conducted Student ’s 2003 psychoeducational evaluation. (Footnote 11) Her assessment included a records review which included assessments obtained by Student ’s parents, as well as the administration of six standardized tests. She chose the Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (C-TONI), the Developmental Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI), the Wide Range Assessment of Memory and Learning (WRAML), the Conners’ Rating Scale – Teacher’s Edition (Conners), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills Revised (TAPS-R) and Test of Visual Perceptual Skills Revised (TVPS-R). The testing was administered in English, which Ms. Fitzsimmons had determined to be Student ’s primary language. She testified that each of the standardized tests that she used were those recognized as current and appropriate by members of her profession. She testified that these tests and the subtests within them were designed to identify difficulties with visual and auditory processing. In addition, she stated that the tests had each been validated for the purposes for which they were used. Further, the tests had not been found to be discriminatory on the basis of race, culture or gender. She was familiar with each of these tests and had been trained to administer them. No evidence was offered to the contrary. The Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s testing was appropriate to identify visual and auditory processing issues.

The Student’s contentions included a statement by Chris Davidson that the District failed to appropriately assess in the area of OT. Generally OT addresses fine motor skills such as handwriting, scissors-skills, self-help skills such as dressing and brushing hair. It may also address oral-motor issues that affect speech issues such as articulation. The District did not undertake an OT assessment for the 2003-2004 academic year. While there were some OT issues, such as handwriting, identified in 2001, Ellen Fitzsimmons observed Student ’s handwriting in 2003 as part of her assessment of his written expression skills. She noted significant improvement that was attributed to a combination of maturation and his participation in the District’s RSP program. The Student did not introduce any evidence to support his contention that an OT assessment was required, instead his argument relied on the old evaluation conducted by Miller Children’s Hospital at the conclusion of Student ’s third grade. Ms. Fitzsimmons testified that if there were fine motor skills issues when Student was younger, they appeared to have resolved. The Hearing Officer notes that there were goals and objectives relating to written expression included in Student ’s IEPs in 2001-2002 as well as earlier years and there was testimony that Student ’s handwriting improved while he was at Prentice during academic year 2002-2003. The Hearing Officer concludes on the basis of the evidence presented that a separate OT assessment for academic year 2003-2004 was not required.

Ms. Fitzsimmons was among the IEP team members whose evaluation resulted in including ADHD as a continuing area of disability in Student ’s triennial evaluation. She chose the Conners to determine whether Student continued to have symptoms of ADHD. The test was completed by Student ’s fifth grade teacher at Prentice. The results confirmed continuing attentional deficits. (Footnotes 12) Student ’s school records contained prior diagnoses of ADHD. They also contained references by current and past teachers to Student ’s behaviors, also indicators of ADHD. Curiously, the Student does not deny that he continues to be hampered by ADHD; he appears only to complain that the District did not obtain a repetitive, formal medical diagnosis for the triennial assessment. The Hearing Officer does not find that complaint persuasive. There is ample evidence in the school records to substantiate a diagnosis of ADHD. The Hearing Officer concludes that ADHD was appropriately identified and assessed by the District.

In May 2003 Gigi Leiby conducted an assessment of Student ’s language and communication skills. (Footnote 13)She conducted a prior assessment in November 2000 which provided her with some measure of familiarity and continuity with the student. Ms. Leiby administered five standardized tests to Student and also took a language sample. The testing was administered in English that she determined to be Student ’s primary language. She testified that each of the standardized tests that she used were those recognized as current and appropriate by members of her profession. She stated that the tests had each been validated for the purposes for which they were used. Further, the tests had not been found to be discriminatory on the basis of race, culture or gender. And, she was familiar with these tests and had been trained to administer them. There was no disagreement expressed by Student’s counsel. (Footnote 14)

The District seeks a finding that its assessments in this matter are appropriate. In order to prevail, the District must demonstrate by the evidence that the assessments were conducted by individuals who were knowledgeable in the areas of the student’s disability and who were competent to perform the assessments conducted. Ms. Fitzsimmons, Ms. Leiby and Ms. Roncone qualify as such individuals. In addition, the assessments must be conducted in the student’s primary language, must be valid tests selected and administered so as not to be sexually, racially or culturally discriminatory. The testimony supports these findings as well. Further, no single test instrument may be used to design a program for the student and a credentialed school psychologist must be employed to administer a psychological assessment. In this matter, no single test instrument was used as is discussed above. Finally, Ms. Fitzsimmons is a credentialed school psychologist as required. The District presented persuasive and undisputed evidence to show that all legal criteria were met. Each of the factors set forth in the Education Code have been discussed in the context of reviewing the assessments in response to Petitioner’s contentions. The materials and procedures used by the District were culturally neutral. The testing was done in Student ’s primary language. Validated tests were given by trained personnel according to the protocols. And the tests were designed to accurately reflect the student’s levels of performance and identify his impaired skills. Moreover, the District’s evaluations correctly identified the areas and extent of Student ’s disabilities. The Hearing Officer finds that the District established that it evaluated Student in all areas of his suspected disabilities and that the District’s assessments were conducted in accordance with the requirements of California Education Code section 56320 and 34 C.F.R. section 300.532.

The Student has asked that the cost of Dr. Davidson’s and Dr. Ballinger’s assessments be reimbursed. In determining whether the cost of those assessments should be reimbursed, the issue for the Hearing Officer to determine is whether the District’s assessments were legally “appropriate.” In this case, the Hearing Officer has found above that the District’s assessments were appropriate.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the criteria for reimbursement of private assessment costs to the Student were not met and his claim for reimbursement of the cost of the assessments of Dr. Davidson and Dr. Ballinger is denied.

2. Did the District’s offer of placement at Hawes Elementary School for the extended school year (ESY) 2003 and at Sowers Middle School for academic year 2003-2004, constitute an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student ?

A FAPE consists of special education and related services, that are available to the child at no charge to the parent or guardian, which meet the State educational standards and conform to the child’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction which meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. Under the IDEA, the student’s unique needs to be met are those that result from the student’s disability. The special education program is also designed to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and as the Supreme Court stated in Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, it must be reasonably calculated to provide the pupil with educational benefit. The Act does not require that the benefits conferred permit the student to reach the highest attainablelevel. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm. 998 F.2d 1083 (1st. Cir. 1993). What is required is entry to a “basic floor of opportunity” through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, at 201. That education is to be provided in the least restrictive environment and prepare the student for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. §1412; 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.

In summary, State law and Rowley provide four factors to be examined in an analysis of whether a school district substantially offered a FAPE. First, the offer must be designed to meet unique needs of the student. Second, the program offered must be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. And third, it must conform to the student’s IEP. Additionally, the educational program must be provided in the least restrictive environment. The third and fourth factors are not discussed in this Decision because they are not at issue.

Federal and State law describe the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child’s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law, “the services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a free appropriate public education must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” Title 34, C.F.R. § 300.300(a)(3)(ii).

Once those unique needs are determined, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Student Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs and is designed to provide some educational benefit, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Student Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401(8), 1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.

The Supreme Court also recognized the importance of adherence to procedural requirements in Rowley, supra at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and to ensure that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. But procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., supra at 1484. (Footnote 15)

(a) Determining Student ’s Unique Needs.

The Student made a general contention that the District failed to determine and provide for his unique needs. The District introduced evidence demonstrating specific methods it used to determine Student ’s unique needs in each of the areas of his difficulty.

(i) Speech and Language.

The District introduced evidence showing how it historically developed an educational program based on its identification of Student ’s unique needs in speech and language. Initially, in academic year 1998-1999, the District found Student eligible for special education services in the District’s RSP program. His specific areas of speech and language difficulty were found to be in the areas of morphology, syntax, semantics and pragmatic speech. He was provided speech and language services and an RSP program during his first through fourth grade years. Gigi Leiby, who conducted the current speech and language evaluation for the May 29, 2003 IEP meeting, had a significant continuum of prior experience with Student, having conducted his earlier assessments and having provided Student with RSP services during those first four elementary school years. She reported to the IEP team that by May 2003, Student ’s test results demonstrated that he made appropriately developmental progress in the areas of morphology and syntax. This progress was reflected by his scores on the Structured Photographic Expressive Language–II (SPELT-II) and the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals-III (CELF-III) subtests. Using the statutory standard set forth in the California Regulations at 5 C.C.R. section 3030 (c)(4)(B), she concluded that Student no longer qualified as language disordered in morphology and syntax. Additionally, she reported that the subtests demonstrated a weakness in auditory memory, but not one that met the criteria for classification as a language disorder. Ms. Leiby also found improvement in Student ’s pragmatic language skills. Student ’s improvement in these areas was described as “extremely encouraging” by Ms. Leiby.

In the area of semantics, Ms. Leiby testified that an analysis of the results of the SPELT-II and CELF-III plus the WORD-R, Receptive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (ROWPVT) and Expressive One-Word Picture Vocabulary Test (EOPVT), demonstrated that as of the May 29, 2003 IEP he continued to have significant difficulty with semantics and continued to qualify for special education services in that area. Overall, her conclusion was to recommend that the IEP team continue to qualify Student as an individual with exceptional needs in the areas of expressive and receptive language, although noting progress had been made. She recommended continued speech and language therapy in a small-group setting.

(ii) Intellectual and Cognitive Function/ADHD.

During the IEP meeting of May 29, 2003, it was proposed that Student ’s eligibility classification be changed to include SLD because his academic performance was now significantly below his intellectual ability. This was due to a combination of his auditory processing problems enhanced by his attentional difficulties. In the areas of intellectual and cognitive function, Ms. Fitzsimmons testified that Student obtained a standard score of 96 on the tests of nonverbal intelligence. A score of 96 constitutes an average range score. However, she testified that there was indication, by his score on the WRAML, of below average intellectual functioning. She testified that his score on the WRAML indicated below average functioning of short-term verbal memory as it related to recall of numbers and in story telling and sentence recall. She then observed that the results of the TAPS testing provided a better performance score at this level. These somewhat mixed conclusions, she explained, were due to Student ’s ADHD, which can overlap with or entirely mask his auditory processing issues. The results on the Conners scales, which contained input from Student ’s teachers, further confirmed Student ’s ADHD diagnosis. Thus, Ms. Fitzsimmons found evidence of both auditory processing and ADHD issues during her assessment. Ms. Fitzsimmons testified that when these two conditions overlap, it is difficult to ascertain which the predominant issue is. However, whether the cause of his difficulties was ADHD or auditory processing, Ms. Fitzsimmons recommended to the IEP team that Student be provided classroom strategies such as preferential seating, multi-sensory instruction, repetition, step-by-step small-group instruction, graphic organizers, and presentation of information in discrete “chunks” to help him follow auditory direction in the classroom. (Footnote 16)

(iii) Visual Processing.

The only area of Student ’s unique needs specifically in dispute was visual processing. The Student contended that Student needed vision therapy to remediate a visual processing disorder. The District contended that while Student had one area of visual processing weakness, he did not have a visual processing disorder and that vision therapy was not a remedy for a processing disorder in any event. (Footnote 17)

The C-TONI, WRAML, VMI and TVPS-R were utilized by Ms. Fitzsimmons to evaluate Student ’s visual processing. Ms. Fitzsimmons testified that Student ’s C-TONI results were in the average range in the pictorial and geometric subtests and the geometric and pictorial nonverbal IQ segments. She also testified that the WRAML visual scale scores were 84 and 87, the average to low-average range, and similar results were recorded in the TVPS-R, with one exception. That exception was a significant low score in visual sequential memory, a skill that relates to the ability to spell. Portions of the C-TONI, WRAML, VMI and TVPS-R were utilized by Ms. Fitzsimmons to evaluate Student ’s visual processing. Ms. Fitzsimmons testified that Student ’s C-TONI results were in the average range in the pictorial and geometric subtests and the geometric and pictorial nonverbal IQ segments. But she also testified that the WRAML visual scale scores were 84 and 87, more in the low-average range, and similar low-average results were recorded in the TVPS-R. However, the WRAML also revealed a significant low score in visual sequential memory, a skill that relates to the ability to spell.

The Student presented two witnesses who disagreed in part with Ms. Fitzsimmons and who provided the opinion that Student has a visual processing disorder. Christine Davidson, an educational psychologist, testified that Student ’s score on the WISC-III coding subtest and the Woodcock-Johnson-III subtests indicated a visual processing problem. (Footnote 18) However, on cross-examination, she admitted that the WISC-III subtest scaled score relating to visual processing had been stated incorrectly on her report (which resulted in raising it from “4” as stated to “7” as corrected). (Footnote 19) She nevertheless maintained her opinion that the results she obtained on the Woodcock-Johnson indicated visual processing weakness and she recommended that this be explored further. (Footnote 20)

Because Dr. Davidson suggested that Student ’s visual processing be further evaluated, Student’s Mother testified that she consulted Beth Ballinger, O.D., who is an optometrist who frequently consults with school districts. (Footnote 21)Dr. Ballinger administered two standardized tests in use in her field, the Visual Integration Processing Test (VIPT) and the Visual Motor Integration Test (VMIT). She testified further that in her opinion Student ’s VIPT and VMIT results, combined with his WRAML and TVPS-R results, demonstrated that he may have had deficits in ocular-motor tracking and vision development. Dr. Ballinger’s conclusion was that Student ’s primary educational disability was visual processing and that he needed vision therapy. (Footnote 22)

District witnesses disagreed with Dr. Ballinger’s conclusion. Although they conceded that there was at least one area of visual processing weakness, visual sequential memory, they disagreed that visual processing was a significant area of Student ’s disability. Dr. Schnell pointed out in rebuttal testimony that Dr. Ballinger was only qualified to testify from an optometric standpoint and that, therefore, her analysis should be limited to her ocular findings. That is, the optometrist measures the physical function of the eye, its clarity, strength, and musculature, which, he testified, is a function different from that of visual processing. He stressed that “the optometrist is not qualified by training and experience to make determinations about brain functioning, that is, processing issues.” Teresa Rosales, M.D., a pediatric ophthalmologist in private practice, who is also on the faculty at the University of California at Los Angeles, further clarified the issue. She testified that vision therapy by an optometrist deals with acuity, alignment, binocularity, and convergence. It does not deal with visual processing. (Footnote 23) In other words, these witnesses were of the opinion that Dr. Ballinger may have had the qualifications to make observations about Student ’s eye function, but she was not qualified to testify as to her conclusions about processing issues, functions and processes that take place in the brain.

Dr. Ballinger did make some observations about Student ’s eye function. She testified that on the basis of her tests he had a tracking problem, particularly with his left eye. Jane Vogel disagreed with Dr. Ballinger. Jane Vogel, M.A., is a consultant in the field of vision and visual processing. She holds six school credentials, and a bachelor’s and a master’s degree in special education. She was appointed by the California Senate Rules Committee to the California Board of Optometry for a period of six years. Her duties on the Board were to participate in the determination of licensure procedures, adjudications affecting the practice of optometry, and the development of statutes and regulations affecting the practice of optometry. She has been consulting for school districts and been in private practice for more than 30 years. Her professional experience encompasses both fields -- special education and optometry. Ms. Vogel observed that Student did not have a profile of a child with a visual processing disorder. She agreed with Dr. Rosales and Dr. Schnell that visual processing is about the inability of an individual’s brain to process visual information. She testified that it is the consensus of professionals that visual processing disorders relate to a breakdown of the language information centers in the brain. She also observed that Student did not appear to have a significant optometric problem. Student ’s classroom behaviors indicated to her that he utilizes vision as his main information intake system. (Footnote 24) Thus, in her opinion even if he had minor difficulty with physically tracking and alignment, his classroom behavior demonstrates that he relies on vision to intake information. This indicates, she testified, that neither vision nor visual processing is a significant area of his disability.

Based on the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds questionable Dr. Ballinger’s opinion to the effect that Student exhibited a significant visual processing disorder. In addition to the fact that her opinion exceeds the area of Dr. Ballinger’s expertise, the reliability of the assessment itself is doubtful. It was conducted over a four-hour period during which Student exhibited fatigue and distractibility, symptoms of his ADHD. It was also conducted immediately prior to the due process hearing and for the purpose of the hearing, possibly showing the assessor’s bias. Moreover, it appeared to the Hearing Officer that Dr. Ballinger’s testimony focused more on her contention that optometry should be accorded equal status with the science of ophthalmology than on her evaluation of Student. Thus, the Hearing Officer has accorded little weight to her conclusion.

The IEP team was provided with information that clearly identified Student ’s attentional issues, low average intellectual functioning, his speech and language deficits and his processing issues. The 2003 assessments showed that Student ’s academic performance in reading and written language fell significantly below grade average in all measured areas. He appeared to be functioning at the average range in math.

Kim Roncone, Student ’s RSP teacher from second to fifth grade, testified that because of Student ’s processing disorders in attention, memory and language he needed preferential seating in the classroom to help him focus on class instruction. She indicated that he would benefit from having tests read orally due to his difficulty with written language. She also recommended small group instruction to meet his needs in the areas of attention and expressive language and graphic organizers to assist him to focus and to process information. Ms. Roncone also testified that he needed small group, multi-sensory, step-by-step instruction and repetition to facilitate attention and retention of auditory and visual information. (Footnote 25) Mr. Conniff, director of special education, and Ms. Fitzsimmons, school psychologist, agreed with Ms. Roncone. Significantly, the principal at Prentice, Karen Lerner, testified that the success of Prentice, in her view, was the use of the Slingerland Method, a teaching method utilizing small group, multi-sensory instruction. Jan Court, Student ’s sixth grade teacher at Prentice, testified that she used the small group, multi-sensory instructional techniques, the “chunking of information,” and repetition. In short, the parties concur as to what were Student ’s unique needs in the classroom.

(iv) Classroom Accommodations and Teaching Techniques.

The IEP team was provided with information that clearly identified Student ’s attentional issues, low average intellectual functioning, his speech and language deficits and his processing issues. The 2003 assessments showed that Student ’s academic performance in reading and written language fell significantly below grade average in all measured areas. He appeared to be functioning at the average range in math. As a result of the assessments and other information presented to it, the IEP team determined that Student ’s unique needs included classroom accommodations and related techniques.

Kim Roncone, Student ’s RSP teacher from second to fifth grade, testified that because of Student ’s processing disorders in attention, memory and language he needed preferential seating in the classroom to help him focus on class instruction. She indicated that he would benefit from having tests read orally due to his difficulty with written language. She also recommended small group instruction to meet his needs in the areas of attention and expressive language and graphic organizers to assist him to focus and to process information. Ms. Roncone also testified that he needed small group, multi-sensory, step-by-step instruction and repetition to facilitate attention and retention of auditory and visual information. (Footnote 26) Mr. Conniff, director of special education, and Ms. Fitzsimmons, school psychologist, agreed with Ms. Roncone. Significantly, the principal at Prentice, Karen Lerner, testified that the success of Prentice, in her view, was the use of the Slingerland Method, a teaching method utilizing small group, multi-sensory instruction. Jan Court, Student ’s sixth grade teacher at Prentice, testified that she used the small group, multi-sensory instructional techniques, the “chunking of information,” and repetition. In short, the parties concur as to what were Student ’s unique needs in the classroom.

(v) Summary.

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District identified correctly the areas of Student ’s needs and that at the time of the May 29, 2003 IEP, Student was exhibiting attentional or ADHD problems which combined with low average or below average intellectual functioning, expressive and receptive language disorders in the areas of semantics and pragmatics, and auditory processing deficits. The District found that Student ’s unique needs included preferential classroom seating accommodation, oral reading of tests, multi-sensory small teaching techniques, small-group instruction, repetition, the use of graphic organizers and weekly speech therapy. The Hearing Officer will now turn to the issue of whether the proposed placement was designed to meet those unique needs.

(b) Was the District’s Proposed Placement Designed to Meet Student ’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit?

Student was offered both a summer 2003 program as well as a program for academic year 2003-2004. Mr. Conniff testified that the District’s offer was of programs which included classroom seating accommodation, repetition, oral reading of tests, multi-sensory small group instruction, repetition, the use of graphic organizers and weekly speech therapy. The speech therapy during 2003 ESY was increased to four times weekly, forty-five minute sessions and his classroom instruction was to be in an SDC during the summer session when he was expected by the District to return from Prentice. The ESY session was determined to be appropriate to address his need for an intensive program due to the lack of expected progress at Prentice during academic year 2002-2003. The May 29, 2003 IEP provided Student with an offer for ESY 2003 of one hour per day of speech and language therapy, four days a week and four hours per day of special day class (SDC) five days per week at Hawes Elementary. ESY is mandated if the student’s handicap is likely to continue for a prolonged period and the interruption in service of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression. 5 C.C.R § 3043. Regression is deemed significant if the student has limited recoupment capacity. Morton Sch. Dist. V. Washington State E.A., (2001) 35 IDELR 103; Etowah County Bd. Of Educ. (2001) 34 IDELR 302.

The District offered Student the ESY at the conclusion of academic year 2002-2003. His record at that time indicated limited growth at Prentice, and the District believed that there was a likelihood of regression if services were discontinued during the summer. Based upon his regression in certain areas of academics, it was feared that he may have limited recoupment capacity. The Hearing Officer finds that the offer of ESY was appropriate. The offer was declined by Student ’s parents. Student’s Mother testified that she believed that at that time “he needed a rest.”

The District’s offer for academic year 2003-2004 was forty-nine percent RSP and 51 percent general education class at Sowers Middle School. In addition one 45-minute session per week of speech and language therapy was offered.

Patrick Kunody, who would have been Student ’s general education teacher at Sowers during academic year 2003-2004, testified that he was prepared to provide preferential seating, extra time for tests, oral instructions, graphic organizers, a smaller group environment, and prompts in the general education class setting. Mr. Kunody, an experienced teacher of ten years, also planned to assign a “buddy” to Student to provide additional assistance in the class. He was to be in the general education class three periods a day, social studies, mathematics and science. Mr. Kunody recommended reconvening the IEP meeting 45 days after Student ’s entry into Sowers in order to evaluate his progress and determine whether any additional steps should be taken. Cindy Costello, the RSP teacher at Sowers, was to be Student ’s case manager and RSP provider. She has special training and expertise in the treatment and remediation of dyslexia and is experienced as a credentialed special education provider to SLD students and speech and language impaired students as well. She testified that she intended to provide Student with a multi-modal reading and literacy program, such as the “Language!” program, a research-based program used successfully by the District. She stated that she would be having Student in class for three periods per day, two of language arts and one of RSP support. Both teachers had studied Student ’s IEP and related school records and each was prepared to implement the program offered. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the testimony of Mr. Kunody and Ms. Costello.

The IEP contained eight goals and fourteen objectives, each of which was directed to an appropriate area of Student ’s needs. (Footnote 27) Annual goals are “statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child’s special education program. Short-term instructional objectives are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The standard for the formulation of goals and objectives in the student’s IEP is governed by California Education Code § 56345(a)(2) and 34 C.F.R. § 300.346(a)(2). They require that the child’s IEP include annual goals and objectives which are measurable. Student ’s IEP satisfied these requirements.

The IEP, however, did not contain a written transition plan. At the time of the IEP, Student was attending school at Prentice. Prentice was a private school serving only pupils with learning disabilities. There were no general education classes or general education students at Prentice. In effect, it was the private equivalent of an SDC in a public school system. Section 56345(b)(4) of the California Education Code provides that when appropriate the IEP shall contain “[P]rovision for the transition into the regular class program if the pupil is to be transferred from a special class or nonpublic, nonsectarian school into a regular class in a public school for any part of the schoolday ....” The Education Code therefore mandates a transition plan in these circumstances. None was provided. In this matter the testimony established the need for such a plan. Student had expressed to his mother and to others, such as Dr. Davidson, how much he liked Prentice. He felt comfortable there. Since the student population at Prentice was a homogenous group of students whose primary learning disability was reading disorder, it is apparent that Student was faced with two transitions: first, it was proposed that he move from what was effectively a private, specialized SDC to a public, generalized, elementary school SDC for summer 2003; and secondly, he was then to move a fifty-one percent public general education middle school at the beginning of academic year 2003-2004. In addition to those significant transitions, Student was being asked to return initially to a school (Hawes) for ESY where he had been called names and been made to feel “stupid.” Under these circumstances, the Hearing Officer finds that the lack of a transition plan dealing with these issues is significant.

In summary, as stated previously the District identified Student ’s unique needs and concluded that he needed a program which provided him with speech and language therapy and specialized instruction in the RSP program that would address his need for multi-sensory learning, repetition, and teaching methods and accommodations to address his attentional issues. Through the IEP process, he was offered a program that was individually designed to provide him with skills that the IEP team believed he needed to progress in school. The program was formulated after considering all relevant assessment material as well as after considering Student ’s progress made with the program provided during his elementary school experience at Hawes and his sixth grade year at Prentice. At the IEP meeting the team considered all of the assessment material as well as telephonic reports from Prentice and reports from Student ’s teachers at Hawes. In addition, the District presented its proposed program with input from the teachers Student would be having at Sowers. The Hearing Officer concludes that the proposed program offered by the District constituted a program designed to meet Student ’s unique needs, except that the program offered failed to include a transition plan as required by law.

The Hearing Officer also concludes that the program was calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit. Student demonstrated growth in all years he was in the public school program. He demonstrated some growth in the Prentice program that was similar to the public school program except that it was in a more restrictive environment. The program offered by the May 29, 2003 IEP was similar to the successful programs provided previously. For 2003-2004 it contained further refinement based upon the District’s assessments and Student ’s progress, and it was clearly calculated to provide him educational benefit. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered a FAPE to Student for ESY 2003 and academic year 2003-2004 except to the limited extent that it failed to provide a written transition plan by which to move him from Prentice to the public school setting.

3. If the District’s offer for academic year 2003-2004 did not constitute a FAPE, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to Student for the cost of his placement in Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school?

The parents of a disabled child may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for expenses they incur for private education or services which they obtain in order to meet their child’s special education needs. Such reimbursement is an appropriate remedy where the school district has failed to provide their child with a FAPE and the private educational services are found to be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the child. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 358 (1985); Haileigh W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir., 194) 31 F.2d 1489; See also Florence County School District Four et al v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).However, reimbursement may be reduced or denied if the parents did not advise the District of their concerns or if the actions taken by the parents were unreasonable. Cal. Educ. Code § 56176.

In this matter, the Hearing Officer has found that the District offered Student a FAPE for the periods at issue, except for the District’s failure to provide a transition plan so that Student could smoothly re-enter the District school system. There was no complaint made by Student ’s parents before the hearing of any concern about the absence of a transition plan.

Student did make a contention at the hearing that the lack of a transition plan was an error by the District, but did not indicate that it was the cause of his enrollment at Prentice. Student’s Mother testified that the reasons Student was placed by her for the second year at Prentice were that, in her view, he was making more progress at Prentice than he had in the District schools. She also mentioned during her testimony that he had an unhappy experience at Hawes and did not wish to return. In that regard, it should be noted that the District’s placement offer for ESY 2003 was in an SDC at Hawes, not in the general education setting where he may have been made to feel unwelcome previously. Thus, the underlying reason for Student ’s enrollment at Prentice did not relate to the lack of a transition plan and it cannot be said fairly that tuition expenses were incurred because of the lack of a transition plan. Thus, while the Hearing Officer has found that a transitional plan is required and will order the IEP team to convene to develop such a plan, that finding in this case does not warrant an order of reimbursement.

ORDER

1. The IEP team shall convene within fifteen calendar days of the date of this Decision for the purpose of amending the May 29, 2003 IEP to provide a written plan to transition Student from Prentice to Sowers Middle School in conformity with his IEP of May 29, 2003. The IEP shall incorporate, in addition, the revised goals and objectives proposed by the District by letter dated October 2, 2003.

2. The District shall implement the May 29, 2003 IEP as amended.

3. All other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE.

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with that requirement:

1. Were the District’s educational evaluations of Student appropriate within the meaning of California Education Code sections 56320 et seq and 34 C.F.R. section 300.502(b) or was the District obligated to pay for the independent educational assessments by Chris Davidson, Ed.D. and Beth Ballinger, O.D. provided by the Student?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District’s offer of placement at Hawes Elementary School for the extended school year (ESY) 2003 and at Sowers Middle School for academic year 2003-2004, constitute an offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) to Student?

The District prevailed on this issue except to the limited extent that it did not provide a written transition plan to move the Student from a nonpublic school to a public school in which the Student will be attending general education classes, and to that extent the Student prevailed.

3. If the District’s offer for academic year 2003-2004 did not constitute a FAPE, should the District be ordered to provide reimbursement to Student for the cost of his placement in Prentice School, a certified nonpublic school?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this matter have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is taken, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

__________________________________ Dated: January 26, 2004 ___________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. One document, tendered as Respondent’s Exhibit 29, was offered during the hearing. However page 2 of that exhibit was missing from the exhibit. The missing page was supplied on December 31, 2003 by Student’s counsel and is now included in the exhibit file.

2. The wording and sequence of the issues stated differs somewhat from the statement of the issues filed by the District. The issues are restated here for purposes of focus and clarity and to facilitate analysis in this Decision. No changes in substance have been made.

3. The District stipulated at the outset of the hearing on November 21, 2003, that the Hearing Officer may determine reimbursement issues in this matter if it were logically appropriate to do so, even though this was a District-filed matter and not a case filed by the Student. 4. The Student did not make any contention challenging the appropriateness of the District’s ESY 2003 proposal.

5. The settlement agreement also provided that in the event of disagreement, the stay put placement would not be at the Prentice School.

6. On October 2, 2003, the District amended its offer by rewriting the goals and objectives covered in the May 29, 2003 IEP and setting an IEP meeting to review those rewritten goals and objectives. On the same date, October 2, 2003, the Hearing Office received a request for a due process hearing filed on behalf of the District. The Student contended that the request for the hearing invalidated the rewritten goals and objectives. The evidence did not support that contention and the Hearing Officer declines to so find.

7. Each special education student’s program is memorialized in a document referred to as an IEP. Cal. Educ. Code section 56345 describes the required content of an IEP. Section 56345(a)(2)(A-B) provides that an IEP shall contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum“ and “meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability.”

8. The results of an independent educational assessment shall be considered by the school district and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56329(c); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b).

9. A school district is required to conduct a reassessment of the pupil at least once every three years. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. The IEP team is directed to review existing assessment data, including assessments and information provided by the parents of the pupil, teacher observations, and related provider observations and conduct additional assessments as appear appropriate to determine whether the student continues to have exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56381(b)(1) & (2), (c) & (d).

10. Dr. Schnell holds a doctorate in education from the University of San Francisco with a major in educational and counseling psychology. His experience includes service as an educational psychologist, consultant and counselor in the school setting for over 30 years. He is licensed and credentialed as a school psychologist as well as a marriage and family counselor. Dr. Schnell is a Diplomate of the American College of Forensic Examiners and is one of only ten members of the Board of Diplomates of the American Board of Professional Psychology. Dr. Schnell testified that he was personally and professionally familiar with the disorder identified as dyslexia.

11. Ms. Fitzsimmons obtained a B.A., with honors, in psychology and sociology, and an M.A., in psychology, from California State College, Long Beach. She obtained her pupil personnel credential as a school psychologist and obtained a credential in school counseling in 1997. She is experienced in counseling, crisis intervention and conducting assessments and evaluations

12. ADHD had been formally diagnosed as early as first grade. The Conners was one measure by which to obtain confirmation that the issue was a continuing one.

13. Ms. Leiby is a speech and language pathologist, who holds B.A. and M.A. degrees from California State University, Long Beach. She holds an education credential in communicative disorders, a certificate of clinical competence and a license from the American Speech and Language Association (ASHA) and is in her twenty-sixth year of service as a resource specialist provider to the resource specialist program (RSP).

14. The result of the testing, assessment and evaluation will be discussed further below.

15. Finally, although not at issue in the present case, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d), 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).

16. Student ’s contention that no accommodations were recommended as part of the District’s offer was erroneous. Classroom accommodations were specifically included in the May 29, 2003 IEP at page 2.

17. The area of weakness, visual sequential memory, is only one of the aspects of visual processing. Standing alone, it is not of such significance as to result in a diagnosis of visual processing disorder. Further, the District witnesses testified that this area is more closely related to attentional and auditory processing, both of which were to be dealt with in the proposed program for academic year 2003-2004.

18. Dr. Davidson holds an Ed.D. in educational management from Laverne College. She received her B.A. in elementary and special education from Rutgers University in 1977 and her M.A. in counseling from California State University, Long Beach, in 1983. She is a credentialed school psychologist. She has extensive experience as a classroom teacher, school counselor, and school psychologist. From 1992 to 1996 she was director of special education at Tustin Unified School District. She had been in private practice since 2000.

19. Dr. Davidson also offered the opinion that Student ’s capacity for intellectual functioning was average. Ms. Davidson’s conclusions appear to rely heavily on her intelligence tests, particularly the WISC-III. It was the consensus of the other experts that the results of her testing were invalid, since Student had taken the same test more than once, in actuality four times, a factor which experts accept as invalidating because it is known to significantly raise the test scores.

20. The testimony established that the difference between the District’s and Dr. Davidson’s intellectual function and cognitive ability evaluations appeared to be minor, the difference between low and low average. Both agreed that Student had visual processing difficulties, the District to a lesser degree than Dr. Davidson.

21. Dr. Ballinger is an optometrist whose specialty is vision consultation and vision therapy. She has been Board certified since 1979 and is a Fellow of the College of Optometric and Vision Development. In addition to her extensive therapy practice, she teaches at California State University, Fullerton, and has consulted with many school districts and SELPAs in Southern California.

22. Dr. Ballinger’s written report and the Student’s notice that she was to be called as a witness were presented to the Hearing Officer and to the District during the second day of the hearing even though the information had been obtained three days earlier by the Student. The Hearing Officer allowed the late introduction of the evidence and amendment of the witness statement, and granted a continuance to the District to allow it to have adequate notice and an opportunity to respond, although the continuance delayed the final conclusion of the hearing and extended the hearing itself by two full hearing days.

23. Dr. Rosales further testified that studies have been conducted by the American Academy of Ophthalmologists, of which she is a member, which establish that vision therapy does not improve learning disabilities. She acknowledged, however, that the optometric community strongly disagrees. The Hearing Office declines to make a finding on that issue in view of his finding that Dr. Ballinger’s optometric evaluation should be given little credibility.

24. Student , she observed, did not demonstrate ocular motor control issues in the classroom by, for example, tilting his head to one side, covering one eye, putting his head down on the desk, using a finger or instrument to follow words in a written text, skipping words in a text, complaining about blurriness, or having difficulty copying from a chalk-board. Student ’s teachers concurred with Ms. Vogel’s observations.

25. Ms. Roncone holds a B.A. and M.A. degree in special education and special education credential designated “mild to moderate.” She is in her sixth year of teaching and has been Student ’s RSP teacher during his attendance at Hawes.

26. Ms. Roncone holds a B.A. and M.A. degree in special education and special education credential designated “mild to moderate.” She is in her sixth year of teaching and has been Student ’s RSP teacher during his attendance at Hawes.

27. On October 2, 2003, the District proposed revised goals and objectives which clarified those proposed in the IEP. Student asserts that this proposal was in the nature of posturing. However, there is no indication in the record that the District was doing anything more than clarifying language based on its review of the IEP.