California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 25, 2001

Student v. Pleasant Valley School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2085-00 · Hearing Officer Paul E. Lacy

Pleasant Valley School District must increase speech and occupational therapy for a preschooler with autism and reimburse private therapy costs.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

Parents of a three-year-old girl with autism filed against Pleasant Valley School District. The case was about the speech-language and occupational therapy (OT) services in her 2000-2001 preschool IEP. Before she started school, she was getting two hours of individual speech therapy and two hours of OT each week through Tri-Counties Regional Center providers. The District offered two 30-minute individual speech sessions, one 30-minute group session, and two 30-minute OT sessions per week. Her parents kept outside speech therapy with Cheryl Fletcher and enrolled her in OT at the Saratoga Clinic.

The Hearing Officer found that the District's offer was a net cut in services. The District's witnesses could not explain why. They also could not say whether school services alone would let her reach her goals. Her progress came from the school and private services together. Classroom notes also showed she did better after clinic OT sessions. Separately, the District had no record of providing OT for the first six weeks and delivered only about half of the required sessions afterward. The Hearing Officer held that this alone was a denial of FAPE.

The District was ordered to:

- provide 3.5 hours of speech therapy per week (three hours one-to-one, half an hour in a small group) and three hours of OT per week;

- provide 18 hours of compensatory OT;

- hold an IEP meeting;

- repay the parents $370 in co-payments;

- reimburse the parents' insurer, if the parents show the insurance claims cost them benefits or money.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This case shows how SEHO handled a district's progress argument when a child also received private services at the same time. The district had to show its own program was enough. The decision also shows SEHO ordering repayment to a parent's private insurer when using the insurance reduced the family's benefits or raised their costs.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Was the District's offer of speech and language services and occupational therapy for the 2000-2001 school year designed to meet Student's unique needs and thus provide her with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

    The District's offer of speech therapy (two 30-minute individual sessions and one 30-minute group session weekly) and occupational therapy (two 30-minute sessions weekly) cut services the child was already receiving, and the District could not show that its program alone met her needs. Her progress came from the District services combined with private services. Separately, the District's failure to deliver much of the IEP occupational therapy, including no record of services for the first six weeks, was itself a denial of FAPE.

  2. Issue 2. If the occupational therapy services offered by the District were not designed to meet Student's unique needs and provide her with FAPE, is the District required to reimburse her insurance company for the occupational therapy services rendered from January 1, 2001, through the date of this decision?

    The private clinic's occupational therapy was appropriate because it addressed the IEP goals. Citing 34 C.F.R. 300.142(f) and Raymond S. v. Ramirez, the Hearing Officer held he has authority to order reimbursement to the parents' insurer. The order requires proof that the insurance payments reduced the parents' benefits or increased their costs.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. Within 10 calendar days, District must provide three hours of one-to-one and one-half hour of small-group speech and language therapy (weekly) for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, including extended school year.
  • Order to provide or change services. Within 10 calendar days, District must provide three hours per week of occupational therapy for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year (including ESY), in addition to services normally part of the special day class; District may provide it directly or fund it at the Saratoga clinic if appropriately State-certified.
  • Compensatory education. Three hours per week of compensatory occupational therapy for six weeks immediately following the 2000-2001 school year (18 hours), for missed services in September and October 2000.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days, convene an IEP meeting to amend the 2000-2001 IEP to conform speech-language and occupational therapy services to the order.
  • Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days, reimburse parents $370.00 (stipulated co-payments/deductibles: $120 for 2000 and $250 for 2001) paid to Saratoga for occupational therapy.
  • Reimbursement. Reimburse parents' insurance company for funds expended or liabilities incurred for occupational therapy from January 1, 2001, to the date of the order, within 30 calendar days after receiving proof that (a) the insurance payments caused a decrease in benefits or increase in costs, (b) reimbursement will restore those losses, and (c) the actual amount spent or owed. Amount not stated.

Total: 18 hours of compensatory services; $370 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Educ. of Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley; School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District; Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S.; Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education; Raymond S. v. Ramirez; 34 C.F.R. 300.142(f)

People named in the decision

  • Catherine Cartwright, Director of special services, Pleasant Valley School District
  • G. Robert Roice, Educational consultant representing District (non-attorney), Pleasant Valley School District
  • Cheryl Fletcher, Private speech-language pathologist, Funded through Tri-Counties Regional Center
  • Deborah Kruchowy, School-based speech-language pathologist, Pleasant Valley School District
  • Jane Johnson, Preschool special day class teacher, Pleasant Valley School District
  • Rita Suley, Occupational therapist, Pleasant Valley School District
  • Jan Goodis, Private occupational therapist, Saratoga Clinic
  • Ms. Bagatell, Expert witness for District (occupational therapist)
  • Leslyn Keith, M.S., OTR, Occupational therapy evaluator, Easter Seals
  • Tri-Counties Regional Center, Regional center (Early Start services)
  • Easter Seals, Infant program / occupational therapy provider
  • Saratoga Clinic, Private occupational therapy clinic

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific. It was heard on March 22, and April 17 and 18, 2001, in Camarillo, California.

STUDENT (or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Joel Aaronson. Also present on her behalf were her parents, PARENTS. Pleasant Valley School District (hereinafter “District” or “Respondent”) was represented by G. Robert Roice, educational consultant. Catherine Cartwright, the District’s director of special services, was also present on behalf of the District.

The Hearing Officer received oral and documentary evidence during the course of the proceedings. The parties submitted written briefs regarding any jurisdictional limitations on the Hearing Officer to order reimbursement in the event STUDENT prevailed. The briefs, post-marked April 27, 2001, were received by the Hearing Officer, and the record was closed on April 30, 2001.

ISSUES(Footnote 1)

1. Was the District’s offer of speech and language services and occupational therapy for the 2000-2001 school year designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus provide her with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE)?

2. If the occupational therapy services offered by the District were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with FAPE, is the District required to reimburse her insurance company for the occupational therapy services rendered from January 1, 2001, through the date of this decision?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a girl born on [date redacted]. She is presently three years and eight months old and is attending the preschool special day class in the Pleasant Valley School District, where she also receives speech and language services and occupational therapy. At age two, she was diagnosed with autism, and as a result of her disability, she meets the state eligibility criteria for special education. At the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT, at age three years and one month, could speak only one and two-word phrases, and most of those were echoes. In addition, she had a limited ability to gesture. She was virtually unable to communicate with others in a meaningful way. STUDENT also had sensory defensiveness and sensory integration deficiencies. She could not tolerate loud talk, laughter, hair brushing, or the feel of clothing on her body. STUDENT also had difficulty focusing her attention on a given task and frequently could not transition successfully between activities. She was also unable to normally filter and process external stimuli. Moreover, her impaired gross and fine motor skills interfered with her ability to successfully sit in a chair, kick a ball, or manipulate instruments such as pencils, crayons, and scissors.

STUDENT was initially interviewed by the Tri-Counties Regional Center for Early Start services on May 8, 2000. An Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP) was also developed that day. The IFSP called for services in the Infant Program to address both STUDENT’s speech and sensory needs. Thereafter, Tri-Counties referred STUDENT to Cheryl Fletcher, a speech pathologist, for a developmental and speech and language evaluation on May 14, 2000.

The developmental evaluation indicated that STUDENT had delays in gross and fine motor functioning, relationships to inanimate objects, language communication, self-help, relationships to persons, and emotion and feeling states. Although STUDENT was approximately 33 months old at the time the tests were administered, results of the developmental evaluation revealed that her performance age ranged between 10 and 24 months. The speech and language evaluation indicated even more profound delays. Her tests scores in this area reflected an age equivalency of 6-12 months old. (Student’s Exhibits 6 and 7.)

On May 8, 2000, Tri-Counties authorized two hours per week of speech therapy services for STUDENT with Cheryl Fletcher. (Student’s Exhibit 9) On May 19, 2001, Tri-Counties authorized an additional 1.5 hours per week of services to STUDENT’s Infant Program, where she received occupational therapy from Easter Seals to address her sensory needs. (Student’s Exhibit 10.)

On May 19, 2000, the District completed its speech and language assessment of STUDENT. The assessment report indicated that STUDENT demonstrated significant delays in receptive and expressive language skills. (District Exhibit 2.) On June 8 and 12, 2000, the District conducted a psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT.(Footnote 2) The examination noted that previous evaluations had reflected a diagnostic impression of autistic disorder, and that “current evaluation results also indicate that STUDENT demonstrates many characteristics of autistic disorder, including continuing impairment of communication, socialization and play skills.” (District’s Exhibit 3.) The assessment also indicated that “delays continue in communication, adaptive, socialization, play and motor skills. Sensory processing difficulties also continue to be present which affect her tolerance of group situations.” (District’s Exhibit 3.) The District’s assessment stated that STUDENT met the criteria for special education. The District also issued an occupational therapy screening report for STUDENT on September 1, 2000. That report indicated that “STUDENT would benefit from the related service of occupational therapy to support her in her education program.” (District’s Exhibit 4.) The District’s occupational therapy screening specifically relied on the occupational therapy tests conducted by Easter Seals on July 10 and 17, 2000, which had evaluated STUDENT for infant developmental needs and occupational therapy services. (District’s Exhibit 3 and 4.)

The Easter Seals evaluation indicated that STUDENT had shown tremendous progress since receiving services at Easter Seals, but that she continued to demonstrate delays in speech and language, gross motor, perception, cognition, and sensory processing skills. The evaluator remarked that STUDENT had improved tolerance in group activity, but noted that it continued to be a challenge for her. According to the evaluation, STUDENT’s vocabulary had improved but remained a major area of concern. Easter Seals recommended that STUDENT continue to receive occupational therapy until September 2000, when she would be transitioned into a school program.

On September 8, 2000, an IEP team meeting was held for STUDENT. The IEP called for STUDENT to be placed in a special preschool day class five days per week for three hours each day. The IEP also called for speech and language services three times each week for 20-30 minutes per session.(Footnote 3) In addition, the IEP called for two 30-minute sessions of occupational therapy to be provided in the classroom and the school’s occupational therapy room. STUDENT’s IEP described her present levels of performance and articulated her strengths and weaknesses consistent with her assessment evaluations. The IEP also set forth goals and objectives for STUDENT and identified specific benchmark dates to evaluate her progress.(Footnote 4) Because STUDENT’s parents did not agree with the District’s offer for related services, they did not sign the IEP document. The District then informed the PARENTS that it would provide the services set out in the IEP and that they could contact their insurance company if they wished to obtain additional services for STUDENT.

On September 13, 2000, Tri-Counties authorized Cheryl Fletcher to extend speech therapy services from September 1, 2000, through October 30, 2000. Also on September 13, Tri-Counties extended its authorization for occupational therapy services through October 30, 2000. On October 6, 2000, another IEP meeting was held to discuss the speech and language and occupational therapy services being provided to STUDENT by the District.(Footnote 5) STUDENT’s parents requested that the District provide STUDENT with more occupational therapy and speech and language services than those offered. The District noted in the IEP document that it believed STUDENT was offered the appropriate services. The District did not provide STUDENT with any additional services other than those called for in the IEP. On October 30, 2000, Tri-Counties authorized Cheryl Fletcher to again extend her speech and language services to STUDENT through June 30, 2001. STUDENT’s parents enrolled her in the Saratoga Clinic occupational therapy program, where she receives services in addition to what the school provides.

POSITIONS OF THE PARTIES

STUDENT contends that the speech and language services offered by the District are insufficient to meet her unique needs and thus provide her with a free and appropriate education as required by State and federal law. Under STUDENT’s IEP for the 2000-2001 school year, she is to receive two one-to-one and one small-group speech and language sessions from the District. Since May 2000, STUDENT has also been receiving speech and language services from Cheryl Fletcher through Tri-County. She contends that it is the combination of the District’s and Cheryl Fletcher’s speech and language program that meets her unique needs and allows her to benefit from her educational program.

STUDENT also claims that the occupational therapy services offered by the District are inadequate to meet her unique needs. STUDENT’s IEP calls for her to receive two thirty-minute sessions of occupational therapy from the District. Since the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT has also received two hours of occupational therapy from the Saratoga Clinic. As with speech and language, she contends that the combination of the services provided by the District and Saratoga Clinic is necessary to meet her unique needs and allow her to benefit from her educational program. Moreover, STUDENT contends that the District failed to provide her with adequate occupational therapy equipment to meet her unique needs. She argues that the District did not provide a sufficient variety of equipment in a large enough therapy room to meet her particular needs.

The District responds that both the speech and language and occupational therapy programs it offered are adequately designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. It maintains that STUDENT is meeting or exceeding her educational goals as set forth in her IEP. The District argues that STUDENT’s educational progress is attributable mostly to the services that it provides, and that her progress is evidence that the District’s programs are designed to meet her unique needs. The District does not dispute that STUDENT’s program must be designed to meet her unique needs, but it points out that under Board of Educ. of Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist., Westchester County v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, it is not required to provide STUDENT with the best available services, but only with those which are sufficient to allow her to benefit from her educational program.(Footnote 6)

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue Number 1: Was the District’s offer of speech and language services and occupational therapy for the 2000-2001 school year designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus provide her with a free and appropriate education (FAPE)?

Applicable Law

Both State and federal law provide that children with disabilities are entitled to a free and appropriate public education (F.A.P.E.) (Cal. Educ. Code §56000 et seq.; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.,) State law does not set a higher standard for educating children with disabilities than that found in federal law. (Cal. Educ. Code §56000.) Federal statute 20 U.S.C. §1401(8) defines a free and appropriate education as follows:

The term "free appropriate public education" means special education and related services that-- (A) have been provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without charge; (B) meet the standards of the State educational agency;

(C) include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education in the State involved; and (D) are provided in conformity with the individualized education program required under section 1414(d) of this title.

(See also Cal. Educ. Code §56000.)

Special education is defined under 20 U.S.C. §1401(25) as follows:

The term "special education" means specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability, including-- (A) instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings; and (B) instruction in physical education.

(See also Cal. Educ. Code §56031.)

Additionally, under both State and federal law, designated instruction and services as specified in the individualized education program shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program(Footnote 7). (Cal. Educ. Code §56363(a); 20 U.S.C. §1401(22).) Speech and language services and occupational therapy are specified “designated instruction services” or “related services” under both State and federal law respectively. (Cal. Educ. Code §56363(b) (1) and (6); 20 U.S.C. §1401(22).)

In this case, the Hearing Officer must decide whether the speech and language services and occupational therapy provided by the District were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. In balancing the evidence presented by the parties, the Hearing Officer is cognizant of the fact that the District bears the ultimate burden of proving at the administrative hearing that the services and programs it offered STUDENT were designed to meet her unique needs and thus complied with the IDEA in providing FAPE. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994.) (Footnote 8)

Evidentiary Analysis

In order to determine whether the designated instructional services (speech and language and occupational therapy) afforded STUDENT by the District were designed to meet her unique needs, it is necessary to review those needs.

There is virtually no dispute that STUDENT suffers from an autistic disorder that is manifested in what can only be described as profound delays in receptive and expressive language, developmental delays in fine and gross motor skills, and significant sensory problems. With the dispute in this case focused on the level of speech and language services and the scope of occupational therapy the District provided to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer will analyze each service separately as follows:

Speech and Language Services

As to speech and language, the various tests given by both the District and speech pathologist Cheryl Fletcher indicated that STUDENT was one to two years behind in language development. (District’s Exhibit 3.) Indeed, Deborah Kruchowy, STUDENT’s present school- based speech pathologist, testified that at the beginning of the present school year (2000-2001) STUDENT was only able to speak one-to two-word utterances, and those were largely echoes. Cheryl Fletcher’s testimony on the subject was consistent with that of Kruchowy’s, and she added that STUDENT’s language skills were that of a nine-month-old child. STUDENT’s September 8, 2000 IEP notes that her communication, socialization and play skills are impaired and those impairments “affect her ability to participate appropriately in group settings and in social interactions.” (District Exhibit 5.)

In determining whether the District’s speech and language program was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must evaluate both the nature and context of those needs. STUDENT is in preschool and between the age of three and four years. She is diagnosed with an autistic disorder that profoundly affects her ability to communicate, socialize, and adjust emotionally. The nature of STUDENT’s individual needs are fundamental language and communication skills. The context in which they arise is the beginning of her educational program. Both the District and the outside speech therapists (Deborah Kruchowy and Cheryl Fletcher) agreed that speech and language are fundamental skills that affect a child’s very ability to be educated. Therefore, STUDENT’s needs require that her speech and language skills progress from that of a toddler to a preschooler capable of communicating, following directions, and interacting with others in a classroom setting.

In response to STUDENT’s unique language needs, the IEP team set forth a number of related annual goals in her IEP. The goals included such basic skills as having STUDENT request an object, use two-and three-word functional phrases, and follow two-step directions. The annual goals were set to be met by September 2001. Each goal also included particular short-term objectives, or benchmarks, to be evaluated in February, April, and June 2001 respectively.

In an effort to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, the District offered STUDENT speech and language services at the September 2000 IEP meeting. As noted above, the District offered STUDENT two sessions of one-to-one therapy for thirty minutes each and one session of small- group (four students) speech therapy one time per week for thirty minutes(Footnote 9). The IEP also indicated that speech and language would be included in the classroom, but it did not specify how or to what extent. At the time the District made its offer, STUDENT had already been receiving two hours each week of speech and language services from Tri-County through Cheryl Fletcher. STUDENT’s parents initially assumed that the District would be responsible for the services already being provided by Cheryl Fletcher. The District, however, believed that the school-based program it was offering would adequately address STUDENT’s language needs.

To support its contention, the District also introduced evidence that STUDENT had met, exceeded, or significantly progressed in virtually all of the bench marks toward her annual communication-based goals. STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Jane Johnson, testified that STUDENT had made tremendous progress in the area of speech and language. Specifically, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Ms. Johnson, testified that since the beginning of the school year, STUDENT had increased the number of words used in her spoken phrases from one and two to three and four. In addition, Ms. Kruchowy, STUDENT’s school-based speech pathologist, testified that STUDENT’s school program of two weekly one-to-one sessions and one weekly small-group session was sufficient for STUDENT. Ms. Kruchowy asserted that she believed the “largest part” of STUDENT’s success was “attributable to the teamwork at school.”

Ms. Kruchowy, however, testified that in initially determining the levels of speech and language services in the September IEP, she did not know whether the outside speech and language services that STUDENT was already receiving were even considered. She didn’t inquire, she testified. Additionally, Ms. Kruchowy did not explain why she concluded that the District’s program and teamwork accounted for the “largest part” of STUDENT’s success.(Footnote 10) On cross-examination, Kruchowy admitted that she did not know whether the school-based speech and language services were enough for STUDENT to reach her goals without the outside services. STUDENT’s special day class teacher, Ms. Johnson, also testified that she could not say whether STUDENT’s school-based speech and language services were enough.

Cheryl Fletcher testified that she had already been providing STUDENT with one-to-one speech and language services for two hours per week since May of 2000. In fact, she stated that she had helped develop the speech and language goals in STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. Fletcher further testified that she received weekly lesson plans from Ms. Johnson, STUDENT’s special day class teacher, and that at least monthly she communicated directly with Ms. Johnson (the special day class teacher) regarding STUDENT’s speech and language services. Ms. Fletcher also explained that her services for STUDENT took into account the information she received from her communications with Ms. Johnson. In her testimony, Ms. Johnson confirmed Ms. Fletcher’s recollection of the nature and frequency of their communications. Ms. Fletcher did testify, however, that she could not say for sure that STUDENT would not eventually meet her speech and language goals without her services, but she was certain that it would take much longer. Critical to the Hearing Officer’s findings on this issue is the fact that the District’s evidence simply did not refute Ms. Fletcher’s testimony on this point. While it is clear that STUDENT has made progress in her educational program throughout the 2000-2001 school year, the evidence indicates that her progress is a result of both programs and not the District’s alone. The Hearing Officer finds that regardless of which program contributed most to STUDENT’s success to date, the District’s program alone was not initially designed to meet her unique needs for the 2000-2001 school year.

For the four months preceding her September 2000 IEP, STUDENT received two hours of one-to-one speech therapy each week. Yet by all accounts, STUDENT at that time (September 2000) was only able to utter one-and two-word phrases and those were limited to echoes. (Testimony of Johnson and Fletcher.) The District’s program of two thirty-minute one-to-one speech sessions and one thirty-minute small-group speech session represents a loss of one hour per week of one-to-one speech and language therapy and an overall net loss of thirty minutes. In light of the fact that STUDENT’s speech and language skills were so significantly impaired at a point in time (preschool) when correcting or improving those skills was critical to her future educational success, the Hearing Officer concludes that it is reasonable to infer that an increase rather than a decrease in speech and language services was called for. In this case, however, the District’s proposal represents a net reduction in those services.

As noted above, STUDENT has met, exceeded, or significantly progressed toward her communication-based goals during the 2000-2001 school year to date. Over the course of that year, STUDENT’s overall speech and language program–the District’s program combined with Ms. Fletcher’s–included a total of three hours per week of one-to-one therapy and thirty minutes of small group each week. Two of the three hours, or two-thirds of STUDENT’s one-to-one time, were provided by Cheryl Fletcher outside of the school’s program. Both Ms. Fletcher and Ms. Kruchowy communicated with STUDENT’s special day class teacher and tailored their services to support STUDENT’s educational program. While Ms. Fletcher’s therapy was directly related to STUDENT’s educational program, it did not duplicate the language services provided by the school. Thus, it is reasonable to conclude that the District’s program alone would not have resulted in STUDENT’s educational success, at least in the time frame agreed on in the IEP. On balance, the evidence offered by the District did not outweigh the evidence presented by STUDENT that her unique needs were met by a combination of the two programs.(Footnote 11) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs require that she receive three hours of one-to-one and one-half hour small group speech and language therapy for the 2000-2001 school year.

Occupational Therapy

STUDENT’s need for occupational therapy services is not in dispute. The District’s occupational therapy screening report concluded that STUDENT would benefit from occupational therapy. The District’s report relied on the July 10, 2000 evaluation undertaken by Leslyn Keith, M.S., OTR of Easter Seals. The Easter Seals report indicated that in the area of sensory processing, STUDENT demonstrated auditory defensiveness. Loud or sudden noises such as laughter upset her. She had difficulty in large groups and responded by covering her eyes or ears, leaving the area or having a tantrum. She sought certain types of tactile input and avoided others. She was upset by hair brushing and did not tolerate having her teeth brushed. Transitions were difficult for her when she was engaged in her favorite activities. Both Rita Suley, the District’s occupational therapist, and Jan Goodis, STUDENT’s occupational therapist at the Saratoga clinic, testified that their observations of STUDENT’s sensory impairments were consistent with the Easter Seals Report.

The Easter Seals report, as well as the testimony of Ms. Suley and Ms. Goodis, also noted that STUDENT displayed low muscle tone overall and difficulty with balance, which affected her gross motor skills. STUDENT resisted descending stairs without someone holding her hand, and she indicated a preference for sliding down stairs on her bottom. She was unable to balance on one leg, and could not swing her leg to kick a ball. STUDENT was fearful of walking backward, avoided activities requiring her to be in a prone position or lift her head or arms against gravity, and she disliked being supported supine in the pool. The District’s psychoeducational report commented that STUDENT exhibited significant delays in fine and gross motor skills. Ms. Suley, Ms. Goodis, and Ms. Bagatell, an expert witness on behalf of the District, all agreed that STUDENT needed to organize her senses so they could function normally. Each of these three occupational therapists agreed that addressing STUDENT’s sensory defensiveness, sensory integration, and motor skills was essential for her to progress in her educational program. Moreover, the witnesses agreed that it was important to provide occupational therapy for a child such as STUDENT as early as possible in their life.

As with the issue of speech and language, the Hearing Officer must analyze the occupational therapy program the District offered in light of STUDENT’s particular sensory and motor function deficits. The nature of the skills at issue here are fundamental to learning. They have to do with grasping objects, sitting still in a classroom, wearing clothing, maintaining balance, and physical self- awareness, to name only a few. Again, at STUDENT’s age, motor and sensory functions are fundamental prerequisites to any educational success.

In response to STUDENT’s impairments, the IEP team set forth six goals to address gross motor skills, sensory defensiveness, visual motion, and fine motor skills. The goals required STUDENT to remain calm in class during singing or laughter; draw a vertical and diagonal line, a cross, a circle; color a portion of a picture with a crayon; and cut a four-inch circle, square, and triangle using regular scissors.

In an effort to assist STUDENT in attaining her goals, the District, at the September 2000 IEP meeting, offered her two sessions of occupational therapy per week for 30 minutes each. The service was to be provided in the classroom and in the school’s occupational therapy room. The District contends that the sessions it offered, and ultimately provided STUDENT, met her unique needs. Rita Suley testified that although she was not present at the September IEP when STUDENT’s goals and service levels were set, she believed that two thirty-minute sessions of occupational therapy were adequate.

In support of its contention, the District pointed to the undisputed fact that STUDENT was on track to meet most of her goals relating to motor function and sensory integration or defensiveness. The problem, however, is that because STUDENT received school-based services contemporaneous with that provided by the Saratoga clinic, her progress does not prove that the District’s program was adequate by itself to meet her unique needs and account for her educational benefits.

While the District presented evidence that school-based occupational therapy is generally preferable and perhaps superior to clinic-based services, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s occupational therapy program at Saratoga was substantially similar in nature to those services provided by the District. Her occupational therapy at both the school and Saratoga focused on her sensory defensiveness and sensory integration, and they both addressed such basic systems as the vestibular, proprioceptive, tactical, auditory, and visual. Both programs also included exercises and activities to help organize STUDENT’s senses and strengthen certain muscles that were essential to gross and fine motor development. Therefore, the Saratoga program cannot be eliminated per se as a source for STUDENT’s success in meeting her IEP goals, and the question remains the same: Was the District’s program designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs?

The Hearing Officer notes that in September 2000, when STUDENT’s IEP was drafted for the 2000-2001 school year, she was already receiving two hours of occupational therapy services from Easter Seals in its infant program. The District did not re-assess STUDENT for occupational therapy services, but instead relied on the Easter Seals assessment of July 2000. (District Exhibit 4.) In the IEP, the District proposed two thirty-minute sessions of occupational therapy per week. The District, however, did not explain why it proposed to reduce STUDENT’s services by half even though it relied on the same Easter Seals assessment utilized by Tri-County in July 2000 when two hours of occupational therapy were authorized. Ms. Suley, the District’s occupational therapist, testified that although she did not participate in the initial goal setting in the September IEP, she believed that the two thirty-minute sessions offered by the District were adequate to meet STUDENT’s individual needs. However, Ms. Suley did not elaborate on the basis for her opinion.

The fact that STUDENT was progressing in her educational program is not in dispute. The evidence, however, indicates that her progress was not substantially a result of the District’s program. Throughout the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT received approximately two hours a week of occupational therapy from Saratoga, while the District’s program offered her only one hour. Moreover, as will be discussed below in more detail, the District did not even provide the level of service that it proposed in the IEP. Together, the District and Saratoga provided an average of approximately 2.7 hours of occupational therapy per week between the beginning of school on September 13, 2000 and March 19, 2001.(Footnote 12) Roughly two of those hours were provided by Saratoga. According to the District’s therapist, Rita Suley, whatever the initial service level set at the IEP, she would recommend that the level be adjusted upward or downwards depending on the students progress or lack thereof. In this case, Suley stated that she would not recommend that the present level of STUDENT’s occupational therapy be adjusted. Therefore, because STUDENT was virtually on target with her goals, the Hearing Officer finds that for the 2000-2001 school year, an occupational therapy program of at least 2.7 hours per week is necessary to meet her unique needs.(Footnote 13)

In addition, the Hearing Officer is also persuaded by Petitioner’s evidence that without the additional two hours of services provided by Saratoga, she would not benefit from her educational program. Ms. Johnson, while referencing a booklet of parent-teacher communications (Student’s Exhibit 37)(Footnote 14), testified that on certain days STUDENT did not do well, had an off day, or did not have an easy day. She also noted in the book the days when STUDENT was doing well or making progress. Petitioner presented evidence indicating a significant correlation between her attendance at Saratoga and her classroom performance. Dates when Ms. Johnson observed that STUDENT was not doing well in class frequently corresponded to times when STUDENT had not been to the Saratoga clinic for a few days or more. The evidence also indicated that on many of the days that STUDENT did well or progressed in class, she had been at Saratoga clinic the day before. A couple of notable examples include October 16 and 17, 2000. Ms. Johnson testified that on October 16 STUDENT had a “quiet, clingy day.”(Footnote 15) On October 17, Ms. Johnson noted that STUDENT had a “good day.” The uncontradicted evidence presented by STUDENT’s mother indicated that she had attended the Saratoga clinic for outside occupational therapy services on October 12, four days prior to the 16th, and again on the afternoon of October 16, the day before her class on the 17th.(Footnote 16) Another example is October 7. Ms. Johnson observed STUDENT to have had a good day. The evidence indicated that she had been to the Saratoga clinic the prior afternoon. Ms. Johnson noted that STUDENT did not have an easy day on January 30, 2001, but did well the next day. Again, the evidence indicated that she had not attended the clinic for five days prior to the 30, and she had therapy at Saratoga the afternoon prior to the 31. The Hearing Officer finds that the correlations between STUDENT’s sessions at Saratoga and her educational progress support the inference that the additional services were necessary to meet her unique needs and provide educational benefit.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program as proposed for the 2000-2001 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or provide her with educational benefit.

The Hearing Officer also finds that even if the occupational therapy program proposed by the District in STUDENT’s 2000-2001 IEP had met STUDENT’s individual needs, the District’s failure to comply with its own proposal would in itself constitute a denial of FAPE. As discussed above, the District failed to provide a substantial portion of the occupational therapy services set forth in STUDENT’s IEP. Ms. Suley admitted that at the beginning of the school year she missed several occupational therapy sessions with STUDENT as a result of her work load in getting the program started. She was not certain how many sessions were missed, but she thought that it may have been as many as 10 to 20. Beginning in November, she started keeping track of her sessions with STUDENT in a written document. (See Petitioner’s Exhibit 25.) She further explained that the check-marks on the record–Petitioner’s Exhibit 25– indicated her sessions with STUDENT. Ms. Suley revealed, however, that she was not always able to update STUDENT’s attendance record at the time the sessions occurred and that at least a portion of the record was reconstructed after the fact. The attendance record, which covers the period of time between November 2000 through March 2001, indicates that Ms. Suley had 20 school-based occupational therapy sessions with STUDENT. This in a period of time when STUDENT’s IEP called for two sessions per week; thus, according to the IEP, STUDENT was required to receive at least 40-42 sessions between November 2000 through March 2001. While Ms. Suley explained that some sessions were missed due to holidays, absence, and shortened school weeks, STUDENT’s IEP does not provide for reduced occupational therapy services under such circumstances. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s occupational therapy services were significantly out of conformance with those called for in STUDENT’s IEP. Because there was no dispute as to the important role occupational therapy played in STUDENT’s educational program, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s failure to provide the service in conformity with the IEP in and of itself would constitute a denial of FAPE. This is particularly true where the District has no record that it provided STUDENT occupational therapy services at all for the first six weeks of school.

Petitioner also argues that the District did not provide adequate occupational therapy equipment to meet her unique needs. Because the District cannot account for providing STUDENT with more than 10 hours of occupational therapy between September 2000 and March 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that it is not possible to determine whether its equipment is adequate to meet her unique needs.

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s occupational therapy program as set forth in STUDENT’s 2000-2001 IEP was not designed to meet her unique needs and provide her with an educational benefit. Moreover, even if the District’s program had met STUDENT’s unique needs, its failure to substantially provide the services called for would itself constitute a denial of FAPE.

Issue No. 2: If the occupational therapy services offered by the District were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with FAPE, is the District required to reimburse her insurance company for the occupational therapy services rendered in the calender year 2001 to the date of this decision?

Special education law provides that when a school district denies a student FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. (School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 , 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. §1415(i) (1997).) Thus, the parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. (Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at p. 370.) As discussed above, however, the rule in Burlington is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parents are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the Act. (Alamo Heights Independent school District v. state Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).)

Regarding STUDENT’s occupational therapy services, the District did not directly assert that the services obtained by Petitioner from Saratoga were inappropriate under Burlington, but in the course of the hearing it did introduce evidence as to why school-based occupational therapy services were superior to and different from clinic-based programs. In this case, however, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s services at Saratoga were designed to carry out her IEP goals. Ms. Goodis testified that the purpose of STUDENT’s occupational therapy at Saratoga was to organize her senses so they could function normally. She also explained that the service focused on sensory integration defensiveness, and included basic systems such as vestibular, proprioceptive, tactical, auditory, and visual. The nature of the services provided by Saratoga clinic included basic exercises and activities on a variety of equipment to organize STUDENT’s senses and strengthen certain muscles that were essential to gross and fine motor development. Ms. Goodis also testified that she had received a copy of the IEP goals and designed her therapy program at Saratoga to further STUDENT’s progress toward her goals.(Footnote 17) In short, Saratoga’s services played a direct role (if not the predominate role) in helping STUDENT achieve her goals. Thus, the Hearing Office finds that the services provided by Saratoga were appropriate for purposes of reimbursement, even if school-based services are generally more advantageous. Moreover, the nature of the occupational services provided STUDENT was such that the physical location of its delivery is not overly significant at this point.

STUDENT contended that if the Hearing Officer found that the District denied her FAPE, she was entitled to reimbursement for speech and language services and occupational therapy services. The District did not dispute STUDENT’s right to reimbursement in the event that the Hearing Officer determined that it had denied her FAPE.

At the hearing, the parties stipulated that in the event the Hearing Officer found for STUDENT on the underlying question of FAPE, the PARENTS were entitled to $370.00 of reimbursement for their direct payments(Footnote 18) toward her occupational therapy. Prior to closing the hearing, however, counsel for STUDENT raised the issue of reimbursement to the PARENTS’ insurance company for services it paid for. Counsel for STUDENT argued that the PARENTS’ insurance company limited the number of occupational therapy visits she could receive in a year. As a result, STUDENT would not have insurance coverage for private occupational therapy services at the conclusion of the present IEP.

After discussion by the parties and the Hearing Officer, the Hearing Officer determined that in the event STUDENT prevailed in the underlying case the question of reimbursing the PARENTS’ insurance company was a question of law: Does the Hearing Officer have jurisdiction to order the District to reimburse the PARENTS’ insurance company for prior services rendered? The Hearing Officer directed counsel for the parties to prepare a brief on this question of law.

On April 30, 2001, the Hearing Office received the parties’ briefs. STUDENT contends that in the event she prevails on the underlying issues, reimbursement includes those monies expended by her parents directly ($370.00) and any funds paid on her behalf by her insurance company. The Code of Federal Regulations, section 300.142(f), states in its pertinent part:

(f) Children with disabilities who are covered by private insurance. (1) With regard to services required to provide FAPE to an eligible child under this part, a public agency may access a parent's private insurance proceeds only if the parent provides informed consent consistent with § 300.500(b)(1). (2) Each time the public agency proposes to access the parent's private insurance proceeds, it must-- (i) Obtain parent consent in accordance with paragraph (f)(1) of this section; and (ii) Inform the parents that their refusal to permit the public agency to access their private insurance does not relieve the public agency of its responsibility to ensure that all required services are provided at no cost to the parents.

The District Court in the Northern District of Iowa noted that:

In December of 1980, the United States Secretary of Education issued a Notice of Interpretation on Use of Parent's Insurance Proceeds in which the agency concluded that: The Secretary interprets the requirements that a free appropriate public education be provided "without charge" or "without cost" to mean that an agency may not compel parents to file an insurance claim when filing the claim would pose a realistic threat that the parents of handicapped children would suffer a financial loss not incurred by similarly situated parents of non-handicapped children. Financial losses include, but are not limited to, the following: (1) A decrease in available lifetime coverage or any other benefit under an insurance policy;

(Emphasis added.) (Raymond S. v. Ramirez (1996) 918 F.Supp.1280, 1293.)

The Court in Raymond also held:

...because of [IDEA]'s emphasis upon a free appropriate public education, this Court concludes that parents of a handicapped child cannot be required to utilize their private medical insurance benefits where the utilization of those benefits would cause them to incur a financial cost. See Interpretation of 34 C.F.R. § 104 and 300 at 45 Fed.Reg. 86,390 (1980). Any other conclusion would be inconsistent with the concept of a free appropriate public education which underlies the [IDEA].

(Raymond S., supra, 918 F.Supp. at p. 1294.)

Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that he has jurisdiction under the law to order the District to reimburse the PARENTS’ insurance company for funds expended on STUDENT’s behalf for educational services. The District correctly points out, however, that whether expenditures by the parents’ insurance company would result in a decrease in service or an increase in costs is a question of fact and, thus, the parents have the burden of proving this issue. The District also accurately notes that no testimony was taken on this issue at the hearing. However, receipt of testimony at the hearing is not necessary to determine the scope of the PARENTS’ remedy. It is common practice in cases where the Special Education Hearing Office has ordered a public agency to reimburse a parent that the order is conditioned upon the parent supplying adequate proof of the debt and the amount owed.

In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that he has authority to order the District to reimburse the PARENTS’ insurance company for funds expended on their behalf, conditioned on their submitting to the District (1) adequate proof as to the amount of money actually expended or owed and (2) adequate proof that as a result of those expenditures or liabilities they suffered a decrease in benefits or an increase in costs. Remedies

In this case, the District did not contend that the speech and language services provided by Cheryl Fletcher were inappropriate. At the same time, Petitioner did not claim any losses or request reimbursement for those services. Thus, no reimbursement is required for speech and language services to date.

Furthermore, because the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s evidence failed to prove that it provided STUDENT with any occupational therapy for at least the first six weeks of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT is entitled to compensatory educational services in addition to the reimbursement set forth above. Specifically, to make up for the missing services in September and October 2000, STUDENT is entitled to an additional 3.0 hours per week of compensatory occupational therapy for a period of six weeks following the 2000-2001 IEP period.

ORDER

1. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District must provide STUDENT with three hours of one-to-one and one-half hour small-group speech and language therapy for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 19)

2. Within 10 calendar days of the date of this decision, the District must provide STUDENT with three hours of occupational therapy per week for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year in addition to those services that are normally part of her special day class.(Footnote 20)

3. The District must provide STUDENT with three hours per week of compensatory occupational therapy for six weeks immediately following the 2000-2001 school year.

4. Within 15 calendar days, the District must convene and IEP meeting to amend STUDENT’s 2000-2001 IEP to conform the speech and language and occupational therapy services consistent with this order.

5. Within 30 calender days of this order, and in accordance with the stipulated agreement entered into by the parties at the hearing, the District must reimburse the PARENTS $370.00 for co-payments directly made by them to Saratoga for occupational therapy services.

6. The District must reimburse the PARENTS’ insurance company for funds expended or liabilities incurred on behalf of STUDENT for occupational therapy services. The order is limited to those services provided between January 1, 2001, and the date of this order. The District must make the reimbursement payment within 30 calender days of receiving the following:

a. Proof that as a result of payments made or liabilities incurred by the insurance company, the PARENTS actually received a decrease in insurance benefits or an increase in costs;

b. Proof that reimbursement by the District to the insurance company will in fact restore those losses (decrease in benefits or increase in costs); and c. Proof of the actual amount of funds spent or liability incurred for services performed during the time period specified in this order.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statue:

1. Was the District’s offer of speech and language services and occupational therapy for the 2000-2001 school year designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and thus provide her with a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) –STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

2. If the occupational therapy services offered by the District were not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and provide her with FAPE, is the District required to reimburse her insurance company for the occupational therapy services rendered from January 1, 2001, through the date of this decision –STUDENT prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties in this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (Cal. Educ. Code §56505(i).

Date: May 25, 2001 ___________________________________ Paul E. Lacy, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Footnote 1: The issues listed here are framed slightly differently from those stated by Petitioner in her statement of issues prior to the hearing. The Hearing Officer changed the wording to better clarify the issues and to more accurately reflect how the issues were framed by Petitioner at hearing during discussion, argument and the presentation of evidence. Footnote 2: Although the examination document indicates that the tests were administered in June 2000, it does not state the date the report was actually drafted or issued. It may be inferred from the content of the report that it was drafted after July 17, 2000, since it refers to the Easter Seals occupational therapy evaluation conducted on that date. Footnote 3: Initially, the IEP did not specify the teacher-to-student ratio, but the amended IEP of October 6, 2000, clarified the speech and language services to be 30 minutes each and include two sessions of one-to-one with the third session in a small-group setting. (District’s Exhibit 5.) Footnote 4: The benchmark dates were modified in the October 6, 2000 supplemental IEP to maintain consistency with routine progress reports. (District Exhibit 6.) Footnote 5: The IEP team also added an additional occupational therapy goal and objective for STUDENT at this meeting. Footnote 6: The Hearing Officer notes that the Court in Rowley explained that it is problematic to determine when handicapped children are receiving sufficient educational benefits to satisfy the requirement of the statute. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at p. 202.) The Court noted “that the educational benefits obtainable by children at one end of the spectrum will differ dramatically from those obtainable by children at the other end, with infinite variations in between.” (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at p. 202.) It also stated that it would not establish any one test for determining the adequacy of educational benefits, and the Court specifically limited its decision to the facts in the case. (Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at p. 202.) Footnote 7: While State law uses the term “designated instruction and services,” the federal statute uses the term “related services.” (Cal. Educ. Code §56363(a); 20 U.S.C. §1401(22).) Footnote 8: Although the Court’s statement in Clyde D. was arguably dicta, subsequent courts within California and the Ninth Circuit have adopted the Court’s statement as legal authority. (See Seattle School District, No. 1 v. B.S. et al, 82 F.3d 1493, 1498 (9th Cir. 1996); Alan Norton v. Orinda Union School District 29 IDELR 1069 (9th Cir. 1999); Robert Everett et al v. Santa Barbra High School District et al, ____ (C.D. Ca 2000).) Footnote 9: The initial September 2000 IEP stated the speech and language services would be delivered for 20-30 minutes each session, but the October IEP specified the services would be provided for 30 minutes each session. Footnote 10: While asserting her unexplained conclusions, the Hearing Officer observed Kruchowy’s demeanor to be defensive and mildly hostile. Kurchowy’s demeanor, combined with a lack of articulated reasoning to support her conclusions, minimized the weight of her testimony in the opinion of the Hearing Officer. Footnote 11: The District argues that even if STUDENT benefitted from services above and beyond that provided by the school, it does not necessarily follow that the additional services are required in order for her to receive FAPE. While the District’s premise is absolutely correct, the Hearing Officer’s findings are not based on this premise; Rather, as discussed above, they are based on the finding that the content of the school’s services alone do not meet STUDENT’s particular needs for the 2000-2001 school year. Footnote 12: According to Petitioner’s records (Petitioner’s Exhibit 37), which Respondent did not contest, STUDENT received approximately 43 hours of occupational therapy from the Saratoga clinic. Over the same period, the District can account for roughly 10 hours of therapy (20 half-hour sessions). While the District may have provided some additional therapy prior to November, there is no record of it. In addition, Ms. Suley had no specific recollection of what sessions were held. Thus, STUDENT received approximately 53 total hours of occupational therapy by the third week of March 2001. Over 20 weeks (September 13, 2000-March 19, 2001), STUDENT essentially received an average of 2.7 hours of occupational therapy each week. Footnote 13: As with speech and language, the District argues that merely because a student benefitted from additional related services does not mean that those services are required to provide FAPE. Again, the Hearing Officer agrees with the District’s premise. But in this case the nature of the service and the evidence presented at hearing, particularly the inferences drawn from Ms. Suley’s testimony, support a finding that STUDENT’s approximately 56 total hours of occupational therapy account for the fact that she is on target with her goals. Footnote 14: Ms. Johnson testified that the booklet of parent-teacher communications contained writings that she and STUDENT’s mother exchanged as a way of updating each other regarding STUDENT’s progress or difficulties. Footnote 15: While the Hearing Officer notes that the entry for October 16 in the parent-teacher communication booklet also mentions that Ms. Johnson observed that STUDENT was happy and completed her assignments, in the context of occupational therapy it is her observations of STUDENT’s behavior that are most notable. Ms. Suley testified for the District that occupational therapy addresses a child’s sensory integration and defensiveness issues, which she linked to a student’s ability to learn. Footnote 16: MOTHER testified that the services at Saratoga were provided in the afternoon after STUDENT’s special day class session. Footnote 17: Goodis added that the goals and objectives Saratoga established for STUDENT were not couched in the same terms as the District’s, but they addressed the same basic sensory and motor functions necessary for her to meet her school IEP goals. Footnote 18: The parties stipulated that if reimbursement was ordered, the District would accept $120.00 as the amount owed the PARENTs for the year 2000 and $250.00 for the year 2001, for a total of $370.00. The parties stipulated that the “figures represent out-of-pocket co-pays or deductibles.” Footnote 19: The 2000-2001 school year as referenced throughout this decision includes the extended school year as provided in the Petitioner’s IEP. Footnote 20: The District may choose to provide these services itself or fund them at the Saratoga clinic (provided that Saratoga is appropriately State-certified), as long as the services and equipment are designed to meet the Petitioner’s unique needs.