California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 31, 2003
Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2085-02 · Hearing Officer Lina Foltz
Los Angeles Unified must fund tutoring, Lindamood-Bell instruction and new assessments after a stipulated two-year FAPE denial.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Footnote 1: the decision was amended to show an issuance date of January 31, 2003, with no substantive changes.
Summary
A ten-year-old fifth grader with a specific learning disability filed for due process against Los Angeles Unified School District. The District admitted it denied him a FAPE from March 2000 to June 17, 2002, because it never assessed him after a January 2000 referral. It agreed to pay back private school tuition, a 2001 summer program, transportation and a UCLA assessment. The Hearing Officer held that this repayment did not replace compensatory education. The private schools were not designed for his needs, and he made no academic progress there.
The District's June 2002 assessment also fell short. The assessment plan was late, but that caused no harm. However, a behavior rating scale was given improperly, and achievement scores were compared against the wrong grade level. The District also did not assess speech and language, central auditory processing, occupational therapy, assistive technology or social-emotional needs. Without that information, the June 2002 IEP, the summer extended school year offer and the temporary Baldwin Hills special day class did not offer a FAPE. Baldwin Hills remained the last agreed-upon placement.
The District must repay the agreed costs and Huntington Learning Center tutoring. It must fund 195 total tutoring hours, a six-week Lindamood-Bell course and weekly gymnastics. It must also finish the missing assessments and hold an IEP meeting within 50 days. Requests for Delphi Academy placement and some summer program costs were denied.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO handled a district's agreement to repay private school costs. That repayment was kept separate from compensatory education because the private programs were not built around the student's needs. The decision also illustrates that putting off assessments of suspected language and auditory processing problems in favor of a special day class trial undermined the IEP offer.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 1. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for District's stipulated denial of a FAPE from March 1, 2000, until June 17, 2002, in addition to reimbursements that District stipulated it will provide?
The stipulated private school reimbursement did not substitute for a FAPE because the private placements were not tailored to the student's needs and gave no educational benefit, so compensatory education was also owed.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment
Issue 2A. Did District provide STUDENT with a timely assessment plan?
The plan came 28 days after the April 24, 2002 request instead of within 15 days, but the IEP meeting was still held within the time that would have applied, so there was no prejudice.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2B1. Did District administer tests in conformity with instructions and other assessment materials?
The BASC teacher scale was invalid because it was not given according to its instructions, and the WJ-R scores were computed against the wrong grade level, which overstated achievement.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2B2a. Was District required to conduct an assessment for speech and language and central auditory processing disorders?
The student's 2nd-percentile auditory processing score and other red flags required assessments by qualified specialists for a language disorder and a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD); the District's plan to 'wait and see' in a special day class did not meet the IDEA.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2B2b. Was District required to assess STUDENT's need for occupational therapy and assistive technology?
The student's low visual-motor integration (VMI) score and writing deficits called for an OT assessment that included assistive technology.
- Student prevailedAssessment
Issue 2B2c. Did District assess STUDENT's needs related to his social-emotional status?
The District's social-emotional assessment relied on an invalid BASC and reports from untrained observers, and it ignored the UCLA report despite repeated suspensions, so it did not satisfy the IDEA.
- Student prevailed in partAssessment
Issue 2B3. Did District's written report satisfy requirements of the IDEA?
Reporting the teacher's classroom observations was allowed, but the report's many inaccuracies and boilerplate statements meant it failed to meet IDEA requirements.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3. Did District offer STUDENT a FAPE by the IEP dated June 17, 2002, and offer of placement at Angeles Mesa in a special day class (SDC)?
Without adequate assessment, the District could not identify the student's unique needs, so neither the June 17, 2002 IEP nor the summer 2002 ESY offer provided a FAPE; procedural claims and LRE were not reached.
- Student prevailedStay put
Issue 4. What is the result of the agreement between District and STUDENT's family for placement at Baldwin Hills pending completion of the subject due process procedures?
Agreeing to the interim Baldwin Hills SDC did not waive the student's right to challenge it, and that class did not offer a FAPE, but it became the last agreed-upon placement for stay put.
- Student prevailed in partIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained from Huntington Learning Center and Lindamood-Bell Learning Process and/or tutor services STUDENT received beginning in July 2002?
Huntington tutoring from July 1, 2002 and the Lindamood-Bell assessment were reimbursable; the Huntington assessment (done before District testing), YMCA and summer gymnastics were not.
- Student prevailedChild find
Issue 6. If STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education from March 1, 2000, until June 17, 2002, what compensatory education is STUDENT entitled to receive?
Partial interim compensatory education was awarded: 195 total hours of Huntington tutoring, a six-week Lindamood-Bell course, and one hour per week of gymnastics until reassessment and a new placement offer.
- Student prevailed in partPlacement and LRE
Issue 7. If District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE by the IEP of June 17, 2002, what relief is appropriate?
Delphi Academy placement was not ordered because no appropriate program could be identified without assessment; the District must reassess, then make a new offer and a comprehensive compensatory education plan.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse parents for tuition at Marcus Garvey School, Marie Fagan School (spelled 'Fegan' in the order), St. Anselm School, and The Study Institute at West Los Angeles College (Summer 2001), per the District's stipulation. The stipulation reduces St. Anselm tuition proportionally for religious instruction.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse round-trip mileage for transportation twice daily between home and the program on each day the student attended (at the state rate, per the conclusion).
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse the cost of the UCLA assessment and report for testing between October 18 and November 29, 2001.
- Reimbursement. Within 30 calendar days of receiving proof, reimburse intensive tutoring the student received at Huntington Learning Center before the date of the order.
- Compensatory education. Intensive tutoring through Huntington Learning Center for a total of 195 hours, including the hours already reimbursed.
- Compensatory education. An initial six-week course of language remediation through Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes. The findings specify three hours per day, five days per week.
- Compensatory education. Gymnastics tutoring (Los Angeles School of Gymnastics) for one hour per week, pending reassessment, development of an IEP and a new placement offer.
- Order to assess. Further assessments including: speech and language (potential language disorder); central auditory processing disorder and its effect on learning; OT assessment that evaluates need for OT and assistive technology for visual-motor integration deficits; social-emotional assessment of behavioral, social and emotional status and its effect on educational performance; and any other assessments that become appropriate.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 50 calendar days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to consider the new assessment data, offer an appropriate program and placement, and include a plan for comprehensive compensatory education that accounts for the interim services awarded.
- The conclusion declares that the Baldwin Hills Elementary SDC is the last agreed-upon (stay put) placement pending reassessment, an IEP meeting and acceptance of a new offer, unless the parties agree otherwise.
Total: 285 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Burlington; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Ford v. Long Beach Unified Sch. Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Stacy G. v. Pasadena Independent Sch. Dist.
People named in the decision
- Debra Berg, Director and tutor/tester, private tutoring provider (witness for Student), Huntington Learning Center
- Sarah Harvey, Resource specialist; administered WJ-R, Angeles Mesa Elementary School, LAUSD
- Maxine Hawk, Principal, Angeles Mesa Elementary School, LAUSD
- TaJuanna Hudson, Assistant principal, Angeles Mesa Elementary School, LAUSD
- Amber Low, Clinic director; signed assessment report, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
- Josh Right, Test administrator, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
- Barbara Pliha, Speech pathologist, resource and reading specialist; expert witness for Student, Reading & Language Center (nonpublic agency)
- Peter Stern, Fourth-grade general education teacher, Angeles Mesa Elementary School, LAUSD
- Deidre Walker, School psychologist; conducted psychoeducational assessment, LAUSD
- Sharon L. Wenger, Resource specialist and educational therapist; expert witness for Student, LA Education Station
- Cheryl Copeland, Special education teacher, Angeles Mesa Elementary School, LAUSD
- Susan Glickman, Due process specialist, LAUSD
- Victoria McKendall, Due process administrative coordinator and school psychologist; District expert, LAUSD
- Marsha L. Tate, Special day class teacher, Baldwin Hills Elementary School, LAUSD
- Nnamdi Uzor, Program specialist, LAUSD
- Agatha Metichecchia, Due process specialist (District representative at hearing), LAUSD
- Ms. Tillett, Second-grade teacher, Cimarron Elementary School, LAUSD
- K. Goetemann, Second-grade teacher, Arlington Heights Elementary School, LAUSD
- Ms. Sorrell, Principal, St. Anselm School (private)
- Claudia Kernan, Examiner, independent psychological assessment, UCLA Department of Psychology clinic
- Janice Jones, M.A., Supervisor, independent psychological assessment, UCLA Department of Psychology clinic
- Eric N. Miller, Ph.D., Supervising psychologist, UCLA Department of Psychology clinic
- Jill Waterman, Ph.D., Clinic director; follow-up recommendations, UCLA psychology clinic
- Mr. Thompson, Gymnastics coach; letter writer, Los Angeles School of Gymnastics
- Dr. Cokely, Physician who conducted a neurological assessment
- Delphi Academy of Los Angeles, Private school requested by Student (not ordered)
- The Study Institute at West Los Angeles College, Private summer program (2001)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Lina Foltz, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on October 8, 15, 22-25, 29 and 30, 2002, in Los Angeles, California.
Petitioner, STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by his mother, MOTHER, and stepfather, FATHER, on the first day of hearing, October 8, 2002. On October 15, attorneys Michael Jewell and Paul M. Roberts of Roberts & Adams, Attorneys At Law, represented STUDENT. Mr. Jewell represented STUDENT during the remainder of the hearing, except for October 24 when attorney Scott Ayers represented STUDENT on behalf of Roberts & Adams. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, was present each day, except for October 25, when she attended via telephone.
Petitioner called the following witnesses: MOTHER; Ms. Debra Berg, director of the Huntington Learning Center; Sarah Harvey, District resource specialist at Angeles Mesa Elementary School (Angeles Mesa); Maxine Hawk, principal at Angeles Mesa; TaJuanna Hudson, assistant principal at Angeles Mesa; Amber Low, clinic director for Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes; Barbara Pliha, a speech pathologist, credentialed resource and reading specialist and proprietor of the Reading & Language Center in Newport Beach; Peter Stern, STUDENT’s fourth-grade regular education teacher at Angeles Mesa; Deidre Walker, District school psychologist for Angeles Mesa; and Sharon L. Wenger, M.Ed., resource specialist and director of LA Education Station.
Respondent Los Angeles Unified School District (District) was represented by attorneys Tina Hunt and Cynthia Floyd of the Law Offices of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of District was Agatha Metichecchia, due process specialist for District. District called the following witnesses at the hearing, in addition to District employees who were called by Petitioner: Cheryl Copeland, District special education teacher at Angeles Mesa; Susan Glickman, District due process specialist; Victoria McKendall, District due process administrative coordinator and credentialed school psychologist; Marsha L. Tate, District special day class (SDC) teacher at Baldwin Hills Elementary School (Baldwin Hills); and Nnamdi Uzor, District program specialist. Oral and documentary evidence was received. The matter was submitted following oral closing arguments on November 4, 2002.
ISSUES(Footnote 2)
1. Is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education for District’s stipulated denial of a FAPE from March 1, 2000, until June 17, 2002, in addition to reimbursements that District stipulated it will provide?
2. Did District conduct an assessment of STUDENT that satisfied requirements of the IDEA and corresponding California law?
3. Did District offer STUDENT a FAPE by the IEP dated June 17, 2002, and offer of placement at Angeles Mesa in a special day class (SDC)?
4. What is the result of the agreement between District and STUDENT’s family for placement at Baldwin Hills pending completion of the subject due process procedures?
5. Is STUDENT entitled to reimbursement for independent assessments obtained from Huntington Learning Center and Lindamood-Bell Learning Process (Lindamood-Bell) and/or tutor services STUDENT received beginning in July 2002?
6. If STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education from March 1, 2000, until June 17, 2002, what compensatory education is STUDENT entitled to receive?
7. If District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE by the IEP of June 17, 2002, what relief is appropriate?
PRELIMINARY MATTERS
District stipulated that by failing to assess STUDENT for special education eligibility following referral on January 11, 2000, it denied STUDENT a FAPE from March 2, 2000,(Footnote 3) until June 17, 2002, when STUDENT’s IEP team meeting convened and developed an IEP offering placement at Angeles Mesa in an SDC. District stipulated that STUDENT would have been eligible to receive special education and related services, including an extended school year (“ESY”) if District had assessed STUDENT timely after referral in 2000. District further stipulated that it would reimburse STUDENT’s family, subject to proof, for the independent assessment of STUDENT at the University of California at Los Angeles (UCLA) in November 2001; and for his private school placements at Marcus Garvey, Marie Fagan and St. Anselm Schools, reducing a proportional share of tuition for the period STUDENT received religious instruction at St. Anselm; for the Summer 2001 program at the Study Institute at West Los Angeles College; and for round-trip transportation twice daily on each day STUDENT attended private school and his summer program at the Study Institute in Summer 2001.
CONTENTIONS
STUDENT contends that he is entitled to compensatory education, in addition to the stipulated reimbursement for his private placements. STUDENT further contends that District’s initial eligibility assessment of him in June 2002, failed to satisfy requirements of the IDEA (1) to provide a timely assessment plan; (2) to conduct tests in conformity with test instructions; (3) to assess in all areas related to his suspected disability, including speech and language, central auditory processing, occupational therapy, assistive technology, and social-emotional status; and (4) to provide written assessment reports that satisfied IDEA. STUDENT also contends that District continued to deny him a FAPE after his IEP meeting and offer of placement at Angeles Mesa on June 17, 2002. STUDENT contends that District (1) failed to offer services designed to address his unique needs; (2) failed to develop an IEP that contained the substantive elements required by the IDEA and parallel State law; (3) failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate ESY program for the summer of 2002; (4) violated the procedural requirements of the IDEA that seriously infringed upon his parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process and (5) failed to offer a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year.
District contends that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education for the stipulated period that it denied him a FAPE because its agreement to reimburse STUDENT’s family for his private placement essentially substituted as a FAPE. District further contends that it appropriately assessed STUDENT on June 3, 2002,(Footnote 4) and on June 17 offered STUDENT a FAPE through placement in an SDC at Angeles Mesa Elementary School (Angeles Mesa). District also contends that an agreement between District and STUDENT’s mother to place him at Baldwin Hills pending due process review constituted an offer of a FAPE, and bars a challenge to the sufficiency of the Baldwin Hills placement.
FACTUAL BACKGROUND
STUDENT is a ten-year-old fifth-grader in the 2002-2003 school year. On or about June 17, 2002, four days before the end of the regular 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was first identified as eligible for special education services on the basis of a specific learning disability (SLD). He was determined to have a severe discrepancy in reading comprehension and math reasoning that was attributed to disorders in attention, visual processing, auditory processing, and sensory motor skills. (Exhibit R1, p.18). STUDENT attended general education classes exclusively, until the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, when he attended three days in an SDC at Baldwin Hills.
STUDENT attended a private school, Busy Bee, until the second grade, when he began his public school education at Cimarron Elementary School (Cimarron) in the Los Angeles Unified School District (LAUSD) in January 2000. During his first week at Cimarron, STUDENT was referred for a special education assessment. On January 11, 2000, District provided an assessment plan to STUDENT’s mother, which she signed and returned to District on the same day. (Exhibit P-1) The assessment plan specified that STUDENT would be assessed in the areas of social/emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, perceptual development, communications/language functioning, and health. (Id.)
District did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT at Cimarron, however, and his school problems mounted. STUDENT’s teacher at Cimarron, Ms. Tillett, told STUDENT’s mother that he required one-to-one instruction and often visited the restroom during class. (Testimony of MOTHER) On March 2, 2000, Ms. Tillett reported “serious problems,” stating that STUDENT was failing to complete class assignments; failing to return homework; restless inattentive and continually talking in class, fighting, late and found outside of the designated play area. (Exhibit P1(a), p.2) STUDENT’s teacher reported that he “continued getting into trouble in class, the lunch area and playground,” and that he was restless and did not pay attention without constant one-to-one attention. (Id.; Exhibits P1(b); P28/R28) Other students prompted STUDENT to engage in inappropriate behaviors, “asking him to act like a monkey.” (Exhibit P1(a), p.2) On March 22, 2000, STUDENT transferred from Cimarron to his home school at Arlington Heights Elementary School (Arlington).
STUDENT attended a regular education class at Arlington for the remainder of the second grade in the 1999-2000 school year. STUDENT’s teacher at Arlington, Ms. K. Goetemann, reported that STUDENT was easily distracted, would ask to go to the restroom often, and required one-to-one instruction. (Id.) Ms. Goetemann reported that STUDENT was performing at grade level at the end of second grade. (Exhibit P28, p.1/R27, p.4, bearing initials KG) STUDENT and his family relocated to the Angeles Mesa service area in May 2000. (Testimony of MOTHER)
In September 2000, STUDENT attended a private school, Marcus Garvey School (Marcus), beginning the third grade. (Testimony of MOTHER) STUDENT had a good response during the first part of the month at Marcus and was eager to go to class. (Id) However, when STUDENT was transferred to a different class, a few weeks later, he began to cry when being dropped off at school and his school difficulties resumed. (Id)
In November 2000, STUDENT enrolled at the Marie Fagan School, a private school, where he attended a regular education third-grade class until the end of the school year in June 2001. STUDENT’s teacher at the Marie Fagan School reported that STUDENT was easily distracted and frequently visited the restroom. (Testimony of MOTHER) During the summer of 2001, STUDENT enjoyed success at a summer program and a two-week science program at West Los Angeles College, where he presented a science project and enjoyed a positive response.
STUDENT began the 2001-2002 school year in a regular education fourth-grade class at a private school, St. Anselm School (St. Anselm), where he remained for three quarters of the school year. (Testimony of MOTHER) STUDENT earned “Cs” for the first two quarters of the year in reading, for the third quarter in spelling, and for each of the three quarters in music and art. (Exhibit P4(a)) The remainder of STUDENT’s quarterly academic marks were “Ds.” STUDENT’s report card indicates that STUDENT had “low test/quiz scores” in written expression and handwriting. His behavior was identified as “as affecting his grades” in relation to following classroom and playground rules, showing courtesy and responding to correction. STUDENT obtained an “A” in the first quarter in physical education and “Bs” for the second and third quarter. (Id.) STUDENT’s teacher at St. Anselm reported that STUDENT was easily distracted, often asked to visit the restroom, and took the teacher’s time away from the other students. (Id.; Exhibit P18) Ms. Sorrell, school principal at St. Anselm, also was concerned about STUDENT’s distractability. (Testimony of MOTHER) STUDENT’s mother worked as a volunteer at St. Anselm, in order to observe STUDENT in class, and tutored him at home. (Testimony of MOTHER)
In October and November 2001, STUDENT’s mother had him assessed for a learning disability at the UCLA Department of Psychology psychology clinic by examiner Claudia Kernan, under the supervision of Janice Jones, M.A., and supervising psychologist Eric N. Miller Ph.D. (Exhibit, R26/P3)(Footnote 5) The UCLA team concluded that based upon STUDENT’s performance on tests that measure ability, achievement and attention, he was stronger in the ability to process visual information than the ability to process auditory information and that information with social content held his interest. (Exhibit R26, p.11) The UCLA team recommended that STUDENT’s teachers and tutors attempt to increase educational opportunities “through more visual means and hands-on learning.” (Id., p. 13)
The UCLA team diagnosed STUDENT as exhibiting “Attention Deficit Hyperactivity Disorder (ADHD), Combined Type,” based upon the DSM-IV(Footnote 6) criteria, with demonstrated deficits in reading, writing and mathematics. (Id.) His ability to understand and follow directions was assessed at below kindergarten level. STUDENT’s academic performance for reading and mathematics was assessed as two years below grade level and writing skills were in the borderline range between second and third grade level. (Id., p.11) The measure of his cognitive performance, yielding a full scale IQ of 70, was considered invalid because he stopped trying during the testing. (Id., p.7) The team recommended that STUDENT be placed in another learning environment as soon as possible because St. Anselm did not “meet his educational needs and was a possible source of constant public humiliation.” (Id. at p. 13) They suggested either a classroom where his curriculum would be tailored to his current achievement level or holding STUDENT back a grade. (Id.) The UCLA team also noted STUDENT’s “extreme sensitivity to what he perceives to be failure on academic tasks.” (Id.)
STUDENT left St. Anselm on April 19, 2002. On April 22, 2002, STUDENT began attending Angeles Mesa in a regular education class taught by Mr. Peter Stern. Entering a new class just five weeks before the end of the semester, STUDENT immediately began having difficulties at school. On April 23, 2002, STUDENT’s mother requested that an IEP meeting be scheduled for STUDENT because of his past learning difficulties and STUDENT’s assessment results from UCLA. (Exhibit P5) On April 24, STUDENT’s mother submitted a formal written request for a special education assessment of STUDENT. (Exhibit P5(b)) On the same date, STUDENT was placed on probation from suspension until May 3, with the understanding that he would “stop calling students names, using bad language,” and that he would listen and follow “directions given by after school staff.” (Exhibit P5(a))
On April 30, STUDENT’s mother hand-delivered an explanatory letter regarding STUDENT’s school-related difficulties and a copy of his UCLA psychological assessment to the office of Angeles Mesa school principal, Maxine Hawk and assistant-principal, TaJuana Hudson. (Exhibit 5(c)) STUDENT was sitting in the office when his mother arrived and he was sent home with her allegedly because of his prior behaviors.(Footnote 7)
In May 2002, Assistant Principal Hudson notified STUDENT’s mother that District had scheduled a student success team (SST) meeting, “a process of regular education,” on May 3, 2002, to discuss solutions for STUDENT’s reported behaviors at Angeles Mesa. (Exhibit P 5(d), testimony of Ms. Walker) On May 6, 2002, the meeting SST meeting was held.(Footnote 8) STUDENT, his mother and stepfather attended the SST meeting with Angeles staff, including Mr. Stern, Ms. Walker, school psychologist, Vice principal Hudson, and Ms. Harvey, resource specialist. (Testimony of Ms. Walker)
An SST report was prepared to identify strategies for addressing behavioral concerns that the team members had discussed. (Testimony of Ms. Walker & MOTHER; Exhibit 5(l)) The SST report noted that STUDENT had been referred for assessment and that school staff would contact STUDENT’s parents if his behavioral problems persisted. (Id.) The next day, May 7, District issued notice that STUDENT had been suspended and would be suspended from after-school playground activity indefinitely if he did not follow playground rules in the future. (Exhibit 5(e-f))
On May 13, 2002, STUDENT’s teacher, Mr. Stern, completed the Teacher Rating Scales of the BASC questionnaire that Ms. Walker provided in preparation for her assessment of STUDENT. (Exhibit R12, p.4) On May 15, and 23, Principal Hawk issued suspension notices regarding STUDENT’s alleged disobedience and fighting with other students. (Exhibit P5(h & j)) STUDENT’s “wilful defiance and wilful use of force or violence” were cited as reasons for his suspension. (Id.)
On May 22, Angeles staff provided STUDENT’s mother with a special education assessment plan. (Exhibit P5(i)/R15) STUDENT’s mother signed and returned the plan the same day. The assessment plan specified that STUDENT would be assessed in the areas of “social/emotional development,” “cognitive development,” “perceptual development,” “motor development,” and “communication/language.” The assessment plan also identified academic achievement and health, including hearing and/or vision, as areas to be assessed. (Exhibit P5(j)) On May 23, Ms. Hawk issued another suspension notice regarding STUDENT’s conduct on the playground. On May 25, 2002, STUDENT was evaluated at the Huntington Learning Center. (Exhibit P-9) STUDENT was evaluated using the Slosson Visual-Motor Performance Test, Slosson Oral Reading Test, an Informal Reading Inventory, the CAT5 Standardized Achievement Test (third grade level), a writing sample and the Huntington Math Placement exam. (Id., p. 2) STUDENT scored “at least” two and a half grade levels behind in academic testing. (Id., p.3) STUDENT was determined to exhibit “specific needs in the areas of sound recognition, sight word recognition, reading rate/fluency, auditory and visual reading comprehension, technical and comprehension writing, and math.” (Id.)
On May 28, 2002, STUDENT’s SST met a second time. (Exhibit P5(m)) Angeles Mesa staff reported improvement in STUDENT’s effort at school, less anger and more willingness to talk. (Id.) No strategies to address concerns about STUDENT’s academic problems were developed by the SST.
On June 3, 2002, Ms. Walker, District school psychologist, administered District cognitive testing to STUDENT and Ms. Harvey, administered the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Achievement, Revised (WJ-R) to assess his academic achievement. (Exhibit P30, p.63-79; Testimony of Ms. Harvey) Ms. Walker also administered the Learning Efficiency Test II (LET II), the Test of Auditory Perceptual Skills (TAPS), the Test of Visual Perceptual Skills, non-motor (TVPS) and the Beery Test of Visual Motor Integration (VMI). (Exhibit P30, p.17-27) Ms. Walker prepared a psychoeducational assessment report that incorporated STUDENT’s academic achievement scores with results she obtained from test instruments and the Behavioral Assessment Scale for Children (BASC) rating scale responses, obtained in from Mr. Stern, STUDENT’s fourth-grade regular education teacher, and MOTHER, his mother. (Exhibit R-12/P5(s))
STUDENT’s academic achievement results showed his highest score, on the “letter-word identification” subtest, was in the average range based upon finding a grade-equivalent (GE) of 4.1, or the 53% mark. (Exhibit R-12, p. 3) STUDENT’s “passage comprehension” scores were rated at the 16% mark (2.6 GE). His subtest scores for “dictation” and “writing samples” were rated at the 7% mark (2.2 GE), and 39% mark (3.3 GE), respectively. STUDENT’s “math reasoning,” and “applied problems” were scored at the 12% mark (2.3 GE) His “calculation” subtest was scored at the 21% mark (3.3 GE).
Ms. Walker’s administration of the LET II, a test that provides information regarding learning, visual and auditory memory, showed that STUDENT’s visual recall was slightly stronger than his auditory recall. (Exhibit R-12, p.3; Testimony of Ms. Walker) However, STUDENT’s summed standard score on the LET II in the auditory modality was 102, while his summed standard score in the visual modality was 109. (Exhibit R12, p.3)(Footnote 9)
On the TAPS-R, STUDENT’s auditory processing skills were ranked at the age level of five years four months (5-4) in the Auditory Interpretation of Directions; five years nine months (5-9) in Auditory Sentence Memory; and five years one month (5-1) in Auditory Word Memory. (Exhibit R12, p.6) STUDENT’s summed score of auditory processing on the TAPS-R placed him in the second percentile in relation to age peers. (Id.)
STUDENT’s results on the VMI generated a scaled score of 75, which placed STUDENT at the fifth percentile, in relation to his peers, regrading the degree to which his visual perception and finger-hand movements were coordinated. (Exhibit R-12, pp. 5-6) Ms. Walker concluded that STUDENT scored “better than 5 percent of his age peers,”(Footnote 10) noting that delays in visual motor integration may hinder one’s ability to do written assignments and copy from a model.
Ms. Walker administered two of the questionnaires from the Behavioral Assessment Scale for Children (BASC), the teacher rating scale and the parent rating scale, to assess STUDENT in the area of social-emotional status. (Exhibits R12, pp.4-5; P30, pp.31-62) Mr. Stern and STUDENT’s mother completed the questionnaires.
On June 10, Ms. Hawk issued another suspension notice regarding STUDENT’s alleged use of “obscenity/profanity/vulgarity” and “willful use of force/violence.” (Exhibit P5(n)/R11) Also on June 10, District notified STUDENT’s mother that an IEP meeting was scheduled for June 17, 2002. (Exhibit 5(o)) STUDENT’s mother responded to District’s notice of the IEP meeting, requesting that District provide her with a copy of its assessment results before the IEP was completed. (Id.)(Footnote 11) Also on June 10, Huntington Learning Center sent STUDENT’s mother the diagnostic evaluation summary and recommendations generated from its diagnostic evaluation of STUDENT. (Exhibit P6 and R13) STUDENT was found to be “at least 2.5 grade levels behind in academic performance.” (Id., p.3)
On June 17, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened. STUDENT’s parents, Ms. Walker, Ms. Harvey, Mr. Stern and Ms. Hudson attended the IEP meeting and Ms. Hawk participated for approximately half of the meeting. District determined that STUDENT was eligible for special education and prepared his initial IEP. At the meeting, Ms. Harvey read the nurse’s report to the IEP team and typed up modifications to the IEP. STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP verifying her attendance, but told District staff that she wanted to review the IEP before she decided how to proceed. (Exhibit R1-16) The IEP stated that STUDENT would attend the fifth grade in an SDC, for 90% of his day, for the 2002-2003 school year, beginning in September 2002 at his school of residence, Angeles Mesa, and would receive extended school year (ESY) services. (Exhibit R1-14)
On June 18, STUDENT’s mother told Ms. Hawk her concerns regarding STUDENT’s proposed IEP and the concerns were documented in the IEP. (Exhibit R1-16) STUDENT’s mother also discussed ESY services for the summer with Ms. Hawk and requested an opportunity to review the summer school curriculum with the RST, Ms. Harvey. (Id.) Ms. Hawk allegedly told STUDENT’s mother that the summer school class at Angeles Mesa had thirty students and was too full for STUDENT to attend.(Footnote 12) (Testimony of MOTHER) Ms. Hawk referred STUDENT’s mother to Mr. Uzor, to locate potential ESY services for STUDENT that might be available.(Footnote 13) (Testimony of MOTHER) On June 20, 2002, STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP indicating her disagreement with the designated instructional setting and specific instruction and services. (Id.) She requested an informal hearing to resolve disputed IEP issues, but did not request a due process hearing. (Id.)
On June 21, 2002, STUDENT’s mother left a letter, the UCLA report, the Huntington Learning Center assessment and STUDENT’s proposed IEP at Mr. Uzor’s office, conveying her concern regarding STUDENT’s need for ESY services for the summer. (Exhibit P7) On June 22, the last day of the regular education school year, Mr. Uzor contacted STUDENT’s mother and they scheduled a meeting to observe the learning disabled class given at Baldwin Hills. Mr. Uzor did not hear back from STUDENT’s mother until September. (Testimony of Mr. Uzor) However, during the second week of summer school, STUDENT’s mother asked to enroll STUDENT in Ms. Harvey’s SDC during the summer of 2002. Principal Hawk told STUDENT’s mother that he could not enroll in the class without agreement upon an IEP. (Testimony of Ms. Hawk) Ms. Hawk did not advise STUDENT’s mother that she could agree to parts of his IEP while disputing others. (Id.; Testimony of MOTHER)
On July 1, 2002, STUDENT was enrolled at the Huntington Learning Center for remedial tutor services. (Testimony of MOTHER) On August 6, 2002, staff from the UCLA psychologic clinic, including Ms. Kernan and the clinic director, Jill Waterman, Ph.D, provided further recommendations for STUDENT’s educational program, after reviewing District’s assessment results and STUDENT’s proposed IEP of June 17, 2002. (Exhibit P8) The UCLA staff recommended an individualized instructional plan tailored to his current achievement level, an educational environment that included small groups and one-on-one tutoring, and a placement that would minimize the risk of peer stigmatization and foster a sense of accomplishment through positive reinforcement. (Id., p.1-2)
On September 3, 2002, STUDENT’s mother notified Principal Hawk that she found STUDENT’s placement at Angeles Mesa inappropriate and that the placement did not meet STUDENT’s unique needs. (Exhibit P5(v)) On September 4, 2002, STUDENT’s mother discussed with Mr. Uzor her interest in placing STUDENT at a school outside STUDENT’s district. (Testimony of Mr. Uzor) On September 5, 2002, STUDENT’s parents and District due process specialist, Ms. Glickman met to discuss informal resolution of the issues raised by the disagreement over STUDENT’s IEP. (Testimony of Ms. Glickman) The same day, Ms. Glickman told Mr. Uzor that STUDENT could not be placed at a school outside of his home district “G,” and instructed him to offer STUDENT alternative placement within district G pending resolution of the disagreement. (Testimony of Mr. Uzor)
Mr. Uzor notified STUDENT’s mother that placement was not available outside district G and offered two SDC options for a temporary placement alternative to the SDC at Angeles Mesa, pending resolution of the issues raised by STUDENT’s family’s disagreement with the IEP recommendations and placement. (Undisputed testimony of MOTHER and Mr. Uzor) STUDENT’s mother selected an SDC at Baldwin Hills for STUDENT until a resolution of issues raised by STUDENT’s parents. STUDENT began the SDC at Baldwin Hills in September, after the semester had begun. However, after three days, STUDENT’s mother withdrew him from the class because she decided that the class was not responsive to STUDENT’s needs and that STUDENT was exhibiting unacceptable distress over interactions with his teacher, Ms. Tate.
On September 12, 2002, STUDENT’s mother met with Ms. Glickman to attempt an informal resolution of the dispute over STUDENT’s June 17 IEP and placement at Angeles Mesa. Ms. Glickman offered placement for STUDENT at one of three nonpublic schools (NPS) and a speech and language assessment in exchange for settling all educational claims against District. (Exhibit R-2) STUDENT’s parents rejected District’s proposal allegedly because each of the proposed NPS schools focused upon students who exhibited severe emotional disturbance and associated problem behaviors. (Testimony of MOTHER) The parties could not reach an agreement and on September 13, 2002, the Hearing Office received STUDENT’s due process hearing request.
On September 25, 2002, staff of Lindamood-Bell administered academic testing of STUDENT and additional tests of auditory and phonological processing.(Footnote 14) (Exhibits P24&P27) The stated goal of the assessment was to determine STUDENT’s “level of cognitive processing as it related to language function and his potential for further development. . . .” The tests were administered by Mr. Josh Right. The Lindamood-Bell report, which is signed only by Ms. Low, states that STUDENT’s results on the Lindamood-Bell and Symbol Imagery tests confirmed his weakness in phonemic awareness that “interferes with his ability to reliably judge the order, number and identity of sounds and letters within words and underlies his poor performance in tests of decoding and spelling.” (Exhibit P27, p.10) The report further states that STUDENT demonstrated difficulty in processing language, including oral language comprehension, following directions, critical thinking/problem solving, reading recall and reading comprehension. (Id.) The report recommends an initial minimum of 360 hours of “intensive sensory-cognitive training” for four hours per day through the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes. (Id. , p.11)
STUDENT has not attended school in a classroom setting since the end of the regular 2001-2002 school year, except for the three days he attended Baldwin Hills. He has received intensive tutoring from the Huntington Learning Center since July 2002, three days per week, for one and one-half hours per day. (Testimony of MOTHER) His family seeks reimbursement for assessments by the Huntington Learning Center and Lindamood-Bell. STUDENT’s family also seeks the following: (a) a speech and language assessment to determine whether STUDENT has a language disorder; (b) assessment for a central processing disorder by a pediatric audiologist; (c) an occupational therapy (OT) assessment concerning his assistive technology needs; and (d) a behavior assessment to evaluate STUDENT’s social-emotional deficits, particularly evaluating the relationship between STUDENT’s anxiety and frustration over poor academic performance and his inappropriate behaviors and inattention at school; (4) reimbursement for tutoring services at the Huntington Learning center and (4) compensatory education in the form of continuing instruction at the Huntington Learning Center, enrollment at the L.A. School of Gymnastics, remedial language instruction through the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, and placement at the Delphi Academy of Los Angeles, a private NPS.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
California, as a participating state, has subscribed to the mandate of the Individuals with Disabilities in Education Act (IDEA) and has implemented conforming legislation. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56000-56885. Accordingly, California law, establishes that children with disabilities are entitled to a “free and appropriate education” (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c), Cal. Educ. § 56000. State educational standards of participating states that are consistent with the IDEA also are enforceable under the IDEA. See Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1311-1312 (9th Cir. 1987).
A FAPE means special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision, at no charge to the parent or guardian, meet the State educational standards, and conform with the student's individualized education program. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) “Special education” is specifically designed instruction, provided at no cost to the parent or guardian, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1402(25) Related services are provided in California as “designated instruction and services” (“DIS”) when necessary for the student to benefit educationally from his or her instructional programs. Cal. Educ. § 56363. The IDEA also requires special education and related services to be provided in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5); see Cal. Educ. § 56031. Further, to satisfy the mandate of the IDEA, the special education program must provide for the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii), Cal. Ed. § 56345(a)(2)(A) District has the burden of proving that it satisfied the requirements of the IDEA. See Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994)
The inquiry into whether a state educational agency has provided a FAPE is twofold. Bd. of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Ctr. Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, 200, 207-208 (1982) Id. The state educational agency, here District, must satisfy the procedural requirements and the substantive requirements of the IDEA in order to provide a FAPE. (Id.) An educational agency satisfies its obligation to provide a FAPE by providing an eligible student with a “basic floor of opportunity” through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually tailored to provide some educational benefit, in conformity with an IEP that was developed through procedures that satisfy the IDEA. (Id.) The IDEA does not require states to provide an educational program that maximizes a student’s ability or potential in order to provide a FAPE. Id. at 199-200.
ISSUE 1: IS STUDENT ENTITLED TO RECEIVE COMPENSATORY EDUCATION FOR DISTRICT’S STIPULATED DENIAL OF A FAPE FROM MARCH 2, 2000, UNTIL JUNE 17, 2002, IN ADDITION TO REIMBURSEMENT THAT DISTRICT STIPULATED IT WILL PROVIDE?
As stated previously, District stipulated to the fact that it denied STUDENT a FAPE between March 2, 2000, and June 17, 2002, as a result of having failed to assess him and offer a program of special education services until June 17, 2002. District stipulated that he would have been eligible for special education, including ESY, beginning March 2000, if District had timely assessed him.
When a school district denies a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Sch. Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Edu., 471 U.S. 359 (1985) Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that is available under appropriate circumstances. Clyde K. at 1496, citing Burlington.
District argued that its stipulation to reimburse STUDENT’s family for private school tuition, summer programs and transportation essentially substituted as a FAPE during the stipulated period that District denied STUDENT a FAPE, and therefore, compensatory education is not available for that period. District argued alternatively that if STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education, he should receive a maximum of 155 hours of intensive tutoring services as compensatory education for its denial of a FAPE prior to June 17, 2002. There was no agreement on the record that STUDENT’s parents intended to forego a claim for compensatory education based upon District’s stipulation to reimburse them for tuition and transportation costs for the alternative programs they obtained in attempting to find an appropriate educational program for STUDENT. Thus, the first issue is whether STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education for the stipulated period, from March 1, 2000, to June 17, 2002, in addition to the stipulated reimbursement.(Footnote 15)
STUDENT’s deficits in the areas of social-emotional, attention, visual-motor integration, auditory and visual processing had not been assessed before any of his private placements were initiated. Nor had he received any specialized educational services. Therefore, his educational needs related to his deficits were unknown. Moreover, District did not submit any evidence suggesting that STUDENT’s private placements were or possibly could have been tailored to address his individual needs. Thus, District did not satisfy its burden to establish that STUDENT’s private placements satisfied the substantive requirement for a FAPE under Rowley that his placements must be based upon a determination of STUDENT’s unique educational needs. It follows that the programs could not have been expected to provide educational benefit.
In fact, the evidence indicates that STUDENT’s private programs did not provide him the minimal degree of benefit identified by the Rowley Court as necessary to satisfy the IDEA, that is, to progress from grade to grade. STUDENT’s teacher at Arlington reported that STUDENT was performing at grade level at the end of second grade when he left public school to attend the third grade at Marcus Garvey. Pursuant to District’s stipulation, STUDENT already should have been receiving special education services when he began the third grade. Twenty-two months later, in November 2001, STUDENT was ranked within the second-grade level in summed scores for Broad Reading, Broad Math, and Broad Written Language on the WJ-III administered at UCLA.(Footnote 16) (Exhibits R12 and R28, p.4)
The UCLA report, consistent with District’s assessment in June 2002, provided undisputed evidence that STUDENT had not progressed academically since completing the second grade. The UCLA report and the testimony of STUDENT’s mother and Ms. Berg, who has tested and tutored STUDENT since July 2002, convincingly demonstrated further that, since completing second grade, he had developed an emotional response to his failure on academic tasks and public humiliation that impaired his willingness or ability to confront academic challenges. (See e.g. Exhibit R26, p.12) Thus, the evidence did not show that STUDENT’s private placements provided educational benefit.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s private placements were not individually tailored to address his unique educational needs, later identified in areas related to social-emotional status, attention, auditory or visual processing deficits, or visual motor integration deficits, and therefore could not constitute a FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds further that STUDENT’s private placements were not shown to meet the threshold level of access to education required by the Rowley Court, that is, to allow him to progress successfully from grade to grade, and therefore did not provide him with a FAPE.(Footnote 17)
The subject hearing was conducted after District’s stipulation for reimbursement was made. The stipulation was not withdrawn. Therefore, in addition to providing reimbursement for the UCLA assessment, District is obligated to reimburse STUDENT’s family for his private placements, summer programs and transportation as stipulated. The Hearing Officer finds that in addition to reimbursement STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education for the period between March 1, 2000, and June 17, 2002, because STUDENT did not waive a claim for compensatory education and his prior placements did not constitute a FAPE. Appropriate compensatory education is discussed with remedies below.
ISSUE 2: DID DISTRICT CONDUCT AN ASSESSMENT OF STUDENT THAT SATISFIED REQUIREMENTS OF THE IDEA AND CORRESPONDING CALIFORNIA LAW?
STUDENT contends that District violated requirements of the IDEA (A) by failing to timely provide an assessment plan, and (B) by failing to conduct an educational assessment that complies with the requirements set forth in California Education Code § 56320 and the IDEA. STUDENT alleges defective test administration, a failure to assess in all areas related to his suspected disability, inadequate test selection, failure to consider independent assessments and failure to prepare appropriate assessment reports.
District asserts that it conducted appropriate assessment of STUDENT. District provided an assessment plan on May 22, 2002, identifying the areas in which it suspected STUDENT needed assessment (Exhibit R5/P5(i)), and administered academic achievement and psycho-educational tests to STUDENT on June 3, 2002, the results of which were documented in the written report by Ms. Walker, school psychologist. (Exhibit R12)
A. Did District Provide STUDENT With A Timely Assessment Plan?
STUDENT’s first contention regarding the insufficiency of District’s assessment is that District did not provide a timely assessment plan to his parents. District did not dispute the timing of the request for assessment or provision of an assessment plan. Nor did District offer evidence that it provided a timely assessment plan.
When STUDENT’s mother requested assessment of STUDENT on April 24, 2002, District was required to submit an assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents within fifteen days of that referral. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321. Undisputed evidence established that District did not provide an assessment plan to STUDENT’s mother until May 22, 2002, twenty-eight days after District received his mother’s written request for assessment.(Footnote 18) (Compare Exhibit P5(b) and P5(i)) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that District did not provide a timely assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents.
Procedural flaws do not constitute a denial of IDEA rights, however, unless substantial prejudice results. Ford v. Long Beach Unified Sch. Dist., 291 F.3d 1086, 1089 (9th Cir. 2002). The evidence does not reveal prejudice to STUDENT that resulted from District’s violation of assessment plan time limits because District convened an IEP meeting and offered placement for STUDENT within the same fifty-day time limit that would have resulted if District had provided a timely assessment plan. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56344. If District had submitted a timely assessment plan by May 9, 2002, fifteen days after the assessment request, and STUDENT’s mother had returned it the same day, District would have been required to complete STUDENT’s assessment and conduct an IEP meeting within fifty days, by Friday, June 28, 2002. District held an IEP meeting on June 17, 2002. Thus, STUDENT’s IEP meeting was not delayed by District providing an untimely assessment plan.
STUDENT did not argue or identify other potential prejudice and none is apparent from the evidence. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not prejudiced by District’s failure to submit his assessment plan until May 22, 2002.
B. Did District Conduct An Assessment Of STUDENT That Complied With Requirements Of The IDEA And Corresponding State Law?
California Education Code § 56320 requires tests and other assessment materials that District used for assessment to be “validated for the specific purpose for which they are used [and] administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions provided by the producer of the test and other assessment materials . . . .” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b) Assessment tests and other assessment materials must “include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need”; must be selected and administered “to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills, produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’s aptitude, achievement level, or other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’s impaired sensory, manual or speaking skills, unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(d). Assessment must be conducted by persons knowledgeable in the pupils disability and special attention must give to the student’s unique educational needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g).
STUDENT’s next allegation regarding assessment is that District failed to comply with requirements of the IDEA for administration and selection of tests. The evidence STUDENT presented at hearing raised issues concerning The IDEA requirements: (1) that tests be conducted in conformity with test instructions; (2) that District assess in all areas related to a suspected disability using appropriate tests and assessment materials; and (3) that District provide a written report of each evaluation that District conducted. District maintains that its assessment satisfied requirements of the IDEA.
1. Did District Administer Tests In Conformity With Instructions And Other Assessment Materials?
STUDENT specifically alleged that the BASC, which Ms. Walker used to evaluate STUDENT’s social-emotional status, was improperly administered and that District incorrectly entered STUDENT’s grade level for WJ-R to yield inflated computer calculations of his grade equivalent scores.(Footnote 19) District argued generally that its assessment, which was administered by Ms. Walker and Ms. Harvey, satisfied the IDEA. However, Ms. Walker agreed that the teacher rating scale from the BASC was not administered to Mr. Stern in conformity with the test instructions and that Mr. Stern’s responses were invalid for use in the test instrument. Ms. Walker asserted that Mr. Stern’s responses still provided some information, presumably sufficient to constitute an assessment.
The teacher questionnaire from the BASC required a responding teacher to provide information regarding how the child has acted “during the last six months.” (Exhibit P30, p.46) STUDENT had been in Mr. Stern’s class for approximately two and a half weeks when Mr. Stern provided his responses. (Testimony of Mr. Stern) Mr. Stern rated the severity of specific behaviors based upon his brief impressions of STUDENT in a new school following the humiliating experience at St. Anselm that fostered his sense of inadequacy and tendency not to persevere. (See R26, pp. 6 ¶3, 11 ¶1,13-5) Two weeks after providing the BASC responses, Mr. Stern reported at the SST meeting that STUDENT needed to become more acclimated to school and that his behavior was improving. (Exhibit P5(m)) Thus, the behaviors Mr. Stern observed were not consistently as severe as those he first encountered.
The validity of Mr. Stern’s BASC responses also was called into question, based upon content, because his rating of STUDENT’s behaviors generated an “extreme caution” warning from the computer analysis of the responses. (Exhibit P30, p.49) The analysis warned that Mr. Stern’s responses may indicate “the rater’s tendency to be excessively negative in describing the child’s behaviors . . . or [the rater] misunderstood the items.” The test instrument required the responses to be consistent with other information before they can be considered valid. (Id.) However, Ms. Walker did not identify reliable corroborating information supporting Mr. Stern’s extreme responses.(Footnote 20)
Moreover, Mr. Stern’s own reports regarding STUDENT’s behaviors in class were contradictory because he reported that STUDENT was not only distrustful and defiant, but was friendly and helpful with adults. (Exhibit R12, p.2; Testimony of Ms. Walker) In addition, Ms. Walker’s only personal observation of STUDENT, during testing, showed that he was cooperative, compliant and courteous. (Testimony of Ms. Walker, Exhibit 12, p.2) The Hearing Officer finds that the accuracy of Mr. Stern’s responses was not validated in conformity with the BASC test instructions.
The BASC instructions state also that the computer-generated report for either the teacher or parent questionnaire should not be relied upon “as the sole basis for making diagnostic or treatment decisions.”(Footnote 21) Nonetheless, the sole information identified in Ms. Walker’s report as a social-emotional assessment was responses from the two BASC questionnaires, one of which was invalid and the other, the parent questionnaire, which could not be relied upon to identify STUDENT’s educational needs. The Hearing Officer finds the foregoing evidence persuasive to establish that the BASC was not administered in conformity with its instructions and was invalid as an assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional status.
STUDENT also challenges District’s administration of his academic testing, contending the WJ-R did not produce test results that accurately reflect his achievement level because Ms. Harvey entered his then-current grade level incorrectly for the computer calculation of his achievement. STUDENT’s grade level was entered as 4.0, when STUDENT was at the grade level of 4.9. (Exhibit R28, p.2) Therefore, the comparison of STUDENT’s academic performance level was in relation to a student who was more than nine months behind him in grade level. Ms. Walker, Ms. McKendall and Ms. Barbara Pliha all agreed that the computer calculation of STUDENT’s grade-level performance yielded scores that overstated his academic achievement level.
For example, the calculation of STUDENT’s achievement on the letter-word identification subtest, his highest score, yielded a grade-equivalent rating of 4.1, slightly above the mean in relation to the erroneous comparison to grade 4.0 peers. (Exhibit R28, p.2) STUDENT’s calculated grade level then provided the ranking of his academic achievement level in relation to his peers and expected achievement. STUDENT ranked in the average range, slightly above the mean, on that subtest as is shown in his standard score and percentile ranking. (Testimony of Walker) STUDENT’s letter-word identification subtest result was incorporated into his Broad Reading summed score. (Testimony of Ms. Wenger)
In contrast, STUDENT’s age-equivalent on the same test yielded rating of nine years three months ( 9.3), which was eleven months behind his actual age of ten years, two months (10.2) and below the mean in relation to his peers. (Exhibit R28, p.4) All of District’s grade-equivalent-based rankings for STUDENT’s academic achievement yielded higher standard scores and percentile rankings in relation to his peers than did his age-equivalent scores. (Exhibit P10, p.2 ¶ 3; compare Exhibit R28, pp.2&4) District contends that the difference between STUDENT’s grade-equivalent scores and his age-equivalent scores was not significant. (Testimony of Ms. McKendall) The Hearing Officer finds District’s contention unpersuasive on its face.
The difference between being nearly one year behind one’s peers or slightly above the mean in academic achievement can be an important consideration. Regardless of the differences between the two scores, however, the evidence clearly demonstrated that STUDENT’s grade-equivalent-based scores were not accurate in that they overstate STUDENT’s academic achievement level. The IDEA required District to calculate STUDENT’s scores in conformity with test requirements to produce scores that accurately reflect his achievement level. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that District’s calculation of STUDENT’s academic achievement based upon grade-equivalent rankings was not done in conformity with test requirements and the grade level results were inaccurate.
District’s failures to administer the BASC in conformity with the test instructions and to correctly calculate the WJ-R grade level for STUDENT’s academic achievement would not necessarily constitute a denial of IDEA rights. Ford at 1089. However, the failure to gather assessment data using test instruments in conformity with test instructions and other assessment material requirements can undermine the sufficiency of District’s assessment and the resulting IEP, as is discussed further below.
2. Did District Assess STUDENT In All Areas Related To His Suspected Disability?
The IDEA required District to assess STUDENT in all areas related to the suspected disability, “including, where appropriate, . . . hearing, motor abilities, language function, general ability, academic performance, self-help, orientation and mobility skills, . . . and social and emotional status.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). No single procedure can be used as the sole criterion for determining the appropriate program. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e). Tests and other assessment materials must include those tailored to assess specific areas of educational need. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c).
STUDENT contends that District failed to assess him in all areas related to his suspected disability.(Footnote 23) He alleges that District’s assessment was inadequate to identify his unique educational needs and, specifically, that an appropriate assessment would require (a) a speech and language assessment to evaluate indications of a language disorder and an assessment by a pediatric audiologist for a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD);(Footnote 24) (b) an occupational therapy assessment to identify his needs arising from visual motor integration deficits, particularly his need for assistive technology; and (c) a behavioral assessment to evaluate his emotional status and social misconduct related to his social-emotional needs.
District contends generally that it assessed STUDENT in conformity with requirements of the IDEA, identifying his educational needs through Ms. Walker’s psycho-educational assessment and academic testing administered by Ms. Harvey. District did not conduct a speech and language assessment of STUDENT or an assessment for a CAPD. District contends that further assessment was not necessary.
a. Was District Required To Conduct An Assessment For Speech And Language And Central Auditory Processing Disorders?
A student must be assessed as eligible for special education and related services based upon a language or speech disorder when “he or she demonstrates difficulty understanding or using spoken language to such an extent that it adversely affects his or her educational performance.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56333. California law further mandates assessment for a suspected language disorder as follows: “[D]ifficulty in understanding or using spoken language shall be assessed by a language, speech, and hearing specialist who determines that such difficulty results from . . . [i]nappropriate or inadequate acquisition, comprehension or expression of spoken language such that the pupil’s language performance level is found to be significantly below the language performance level of his or her peers.” Id.
District testing of STUDENT’s verbal and written language performance from the WJ-R placed him two or more years below his age peers. (Exhibits P30, pp.72, 75, 76) STUDENT scored at the second percentile on the TAPS-R, District’s measure of STUDENT’s ability to “understand what he hears.” (Testimony of Ms. Walker; Exhibit R12, p.6) Based upon STUDENT’s scores from the TAPS-R, with ninety-eight percent of STUDENT’s age peers expected to perform better, Ms. Walker reported that “significant deficits in auditory processing may hinder one’s ability to read and do written language.” (Id., emphasis added)
Undisputed evidence showed that STUDENT exhibited impaired abilities in reading and in written language that Ms. Walker recognized as symptoms of auditory processing deficits and the corresponding inability to understand what he hears. (Testimony of Mr. Stern; Exhibit R1-18; R26, p.7-9,11) On STUDENT’s IEP, District acknowledged that he exhibited a severe discrepancy in reading comprehension that constituted an SLD. (Exhibit R1-18) Further, Ms. Walker testified that District’s assessment also showed that STUDENT exhibited an SLD in written language, although District did not identify STUDENT’s written language deficits as a basis for eligibility. (Testimony of Ms. Walker; Exhibit R1-18)
District did mark the box on STUDENT’s IEP indicating that his severe discrepancies in reading comprehension and math reasoning were the result of a “disorder” in auditory processing, in addition to disorders in attention, visual processing and sensory motor skills. (Id.) However, at hearing, Ms. McKendall, an experienced school psychologist, testified that none of STUDENT’s test results were sufficient to establish that he actually has a CAPD. (Testimony of Ms. McKendall) Further, no assessment was conducted by an individual qualified to evaluate whether STUDENT has educational needs related to a language disorder, despite undisputed evidence of his impaired understanding of what he hears. Thus, the evidence is persuasive to establish that, although District conducted testing sufficient to identify certain deficits, District did not obtain sufficient assessment data to determine whether STUDENT had educational needs related to a language disorder or CAPD.
District administered the LET II to evaluate STUDENT’s learning recall, visual recall and auditory recall. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) The LET II is intended to provide information regarding an individual’s preference in learning style by evaluating verbal learning ability in comparison to visual learning ability. (See Footnote 8) Ms. Walker concluded that STUDENT exhibited a relative strength in auditory processing, even though the LET II yielded a higher summed standard score in tests of STUDENT’s visual processing than he obtained in auditory processing. (Exhibit R12, p.3) Nonetheless, the evidence did not suggest that the LET II clarified whether STUDENT has a language disorder or CAPD.
Ms. Pliha(Footnote 25) opined that District’s assessment of STUDENT was inadequate, first, because it did not include a speech and language assessment to evaluate indications of a language disorder, and second, because STUDENT’s test results should have prompted further inquiry to determine whether STUDENT has a CAPD. Ms. Pliha cited District’s assessment results, including STUDENT’s scores on the TAPS that ranked him in the second percentile and a writing sample error, which she identified as a language error, rather than a spelling error,(Footnote 26) and his UCLA assessment, which she argued contained many “red flags” indicating a severe language problem. Ms. Pliha testifieded that STUDENT’s score below the first percentile, prekindergarten level, in Oral Language “understanding directions” subtest from the WJ-III, the Peabody receptive vocabulary score and WISC score from the UCLA assessment further indicated significant language difficulties that had not been appropriately assessed by District. (See Exhibit R26) Ms. Pliha opined further that District erred when it described STUDENT as having a relative strength in auditory processing and that instead his assessment test results indicated that he needed further assessment for a CAPD.
Ms. Sharon Wenger(Footnote 27) testified that STUDENT exhibited significant language impairment and auditory processing deficits that necessitated an “in-depth” assessment by a qualified specialist to evaluate for a CAPD. (Exhibit P10, p.3) She too interpreted STUDENT’s test results from District and UCLA, as well as the assessments done at the Huntington Learning Center and Lindamood-Bell, as strong indications of a CAPD that required further assessment. (Id.). Ms. Wenger noted that the symptoms associated with a CAPD are often misinterpreted as attention or behavior problems. (Testimony of Ms. Pliha; see also Exhibit P10, p.3 ¶2) Ms. Wenger and Ms. Pliha agreed that STUDENT’s test performance suggested that his academic deficits are the result of auditory processing deficits and a language disorder rather than attention deficits and that STUDENT does not exhibit a relative strength in auditory processing skills.
Ms. Walker testified that a speech and language assessment was not necessary because STUDENT’s problems with language expression, shown in the TAPS, were the result of his deficits in auditory processing, not articulation, speech or expression. Ms. Walker did not explain why STUDENT’s receptive language skills were not considered in her determination that further speech and language assessment was unnecessary. Ms. Walker agreed, however, that STUDENT did exhibit difficulties in oral expression during testing, including deficits in the ability to recall and repeat sentences. Consistent with Ms. Pliha’s testimony, these difficulties appeared to be related to STUDENT’s inability to understand spoken language. Ms. Walker apparently did not consider the inability to understand oral language to be an area of concern that related to the need for a speech and language evaluation.
Ms. Walker did not obtain further testing to determine whether STUDENT exhibited a language disorder because she observed that he could carry on a conversation. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) Ms. Walker testified that she would not recommend a speech and language assessment for STUDENT unless and until his SDC teacher determined that STUDENT showed signs of a language disorder after STUDENT began his new program. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) Similarly, although District’s own assessment results confirmed STUDENT’s severe auditory processing deficits, Ms. Walker testified that additional assessment for a CAPD would not be warranted until STUDENT tried a smaller class setting to see how he performed. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Pliah and Ms. Wenger, particularly Ms. Pliha’s opinion regarding STUDENT’s test results from District and UCLA, persuasive to establish that STUDENT exhibited deficits in understanding spoken language that necessitated further assessment by qualified individuals both to evaluate for a language disorder and for a CAPD.
Importantly, District’s own expert, Ms. McKendall, testified that neither District testing nor independent assessments were sufficient to determine whether STUDENT has a CAPD. Ms. McKendall opined that STUDENT’s attention deficits are the cause of his low auditory processing scores. Moreover, Ms. McKendall asserted that all of STUDENT’s assessment results were insufficient to identify his educational needs. Ms. McKendall contended that STUDENT’s educational needs must be determined through observation of an SDC teacher because STUDENT does not perform consistently on tests.
The Hearing Officer finds unpersuasive District’s contention that STUDENT’s deficits and resulting needs could not be identified through appropriate assessment prior to offering him an SDC placement. The premise of an assessment that conforms with requirements of the IDEA is that District’s assessment should provide the information to identify STUDENT’s educational needs unless sufficient data are available from other reliable sources. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.320(b)(1); 300.533, see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Language function is an area related to a suspected disability when, as here, facts and circumstances suggest inquiry is necessary to distinguish the student’s educational needs. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). District’s proposal to “wait and see” in the absence of assessment data identifying STUDENT’s educational needs is inconsistent with requirements of the IDEA.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Pliha, Ms. Wenger and Ms. McKendall persuasive to establish that District has insufficient assessment data to determine whether STUDENT has a language disorder or CAPD, even though the boxes are checked on the preprinted form used for his IEP to indicate that he has disorders in auditory processing disorder and attention. Ms. Pliha is a speech and language specialist who exhibited a thorough knowledge of language related deficits and educational interventions. Therefore, as the only expert qualified to assess a language disorder, her testimony was accorded greater weight in determining that further assessment was necessary to evaluate STUDENT’s deficits in language and auditory processing. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that because District did not assess STUDENT sufficiently regarding his receptive language deficits, District has not conducted adequate assessment to determine whether STUDENT’s inattention is a symptom or a cause of his language processing deficits or a CAPD; therefore, District cannot identify his related educational needs.
STUDENT is not required to prove that he has a language disorder or CAPD. As part of its initial assessment, District was specifically required to include tests and assessment materials to evaluate STUDENT’s areas of educational need related to his auditory deficits and language problems that were known from the UCLA assessment and confirmed by District assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). The speech and language assessment and CAPD assessment that were needed must be conducted by qualified specialist, not an SDC teacher. Cal. Educ. Code § 56333. The Hearing Officer finds that District did not assess STUDENT in primary areas related to his suspected disability because it did not obtain assessments by qualified individuals for a language disorder and CAPD.
b. Was District Required to Assess STUDENT’s Need For Occupational Therapy And Assistive Technology?
STUDENT contends that District should have assessed his need for occupational therapy (OT) and assistive technology after his visual motor integration deficits were identified through testing administered by Ms. Walker. District argues that a need for OT and assistive technology needs were not suggested by STUDENT’s assessment results.
OT is included in the list of services available to a special education student. OT is provided to address:
(A) Improving, developing or restoring functions impaired or lost through illness, injury, or deprivation; (B) Improving ability to perform tasks for independent functioning if functions are impaired or lost; and (C) Preventing, through early intervention, initial or further impairment or los of function.
Cal. Educ. Code § 56363. An OT assessment must be conducted by medical professionals. Cal. Gov. Code § 7572(b).
STUDENT’s assessment plan identified motor development as an area related to a suspected disability. The plan calls for an assessment to “evaluate how the student uses large and small muscle abilities, general physical conditioning and motor and hand-eye coordination skills.” (Exhibit R15). Ms. Walker conducted the VMI to determine whether STUDENT exhibited deficits in hand-to-eye coordination that resulted in educational needs. (Exhibit R12, p.5-6) STUDENT performed below ninety-five percent of his age peers. (Id.)
Ms. Walker reported that “delays in [visual motor integration] may hinder one’s ability to copy from a model and do written assignments.” (Exhibit R12, p.6). On his IEP, District identified STUDENT’s sensory motor skills as a cause of the specific learning disability. (Exhibit R1-18) Ms. Walker did not consider an OT assessment because the IEP team decided upon placement in an SDC, anticipating that then District would see whether further assessment was needed. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) However, as noted above, Ms. Walker testified that STUDENT’s deficits in written language were sufficient to constitute an SLD in written language. Mr. Stern also observed that STUDENT had greater difficulty expressing himself in written form. (Testimony of Mr. Stern).
Ms. Pliha concluded that STUDENT should have received further assessment for OT because of the deficits he demonstrated on the VMI. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Pliha’s opinion regarding the results from the VMI as indicative of the need for an OT assessment, particularly in light of STUDENT’s difficulty with written assignments that Ms. Walker found significant enough to provide an independent basis for identifying STUDENT as exhibiting an SLD. Whether STUDENT’s deficits would require OT must be determined by a qualified medical professional.
Ms. Pliha and Ms. Wenger also opined that STUDENT needs assistive technology to address his visual motor integration deficits. Simple devices such as a slant board, pencil grip and electronic spelling tool would assist STUDENT to overcome visual-motor integration deficits manifested in poor performance in writing tasks and visual perceptual deficits that District had identified. (Testimony of Ms. Wenger) Ms. Pliha opined that STUDENT should have instruction in computer keyboard use to compensate for his difficulties in writing caused by his visual-motor integration deficits.
Determining service needs, including the need for assistive technology, is a matter that must be considered and identified by the IEP team in light of adequate assessment data. Here, STUDENT’s need for OT and assistive technology cannot be determined based upon available data identified by either party. However, like his need for OT, STUDENT’s need for assistive technology is suggested by existing data. The Hearing Officer finds the opinions of Ms. Pliha and Ms. Wenger persuasive to establish that STUDENT has potential assistive technology needs related to his visual-motor integration deficits, the nature of which has not been assessed. Therefore, STUDENT’s need for assistive technology should be assessed in conjunction with an OT assessment. c. Did District Assess STUDENT’s Needs Related To His Social-Emotional Status?
STUDENT contends that District did not assess his social-emotional status as an area related to his suspected disability. He contends that his emotional status must be assessed before his related educational needs can be identified. District argued essentially that it assessed STUDENT’s social-emotional status as an area of educational need related to his behavior. District noted that STUDENT’s behaviors were addressed in his IEP by a behavior support plan derived from information obtained, for example, in the SST meeting held before formal assessment by Ms. Walker using the BASC.(Footnote 28) However, District did not identify an assessment of STUDENT’s emotional status.
It is undisputed that STUDENT’s mother came to Angeles Mesa in late-April 2002 to obtain the assessment STUDENT should have had over two years earlier. She requested assessment of STUDENT and provided District with the UCLA report, which identified his attention problems, auditory processing deficits, peer conflicts, repeated academic failures and embarrassment over his performance. STUDENT’s behaviors and emotional state were problems areas identified at UCLA. Similarly, District identified problem behaviors immediately. It issued numerous suspension notices in the month of May and one in June, all of which concerned behaviors on the playground involving conflicts with peers and failure to follow the instructions of the playground staff. (Exhibits P5(e-h,j & n)) When District decided that further assessment was necessary, it had received the UCLA report, reports from playground staff and reports of concerns from Mr. Stern about STUDENT’s poor academic performance and behavior. Ms. Walker subsequently administered the BASC.
The Hearing Officer has found that the results that Ms. Walker obtained from the BASC were invalid because they were not obtained in conformity with the test instructions. Therefore, the assessment that Ms. Walker identified in her report did not constitute an assessment of STUDENT’s educational needs related to his social-emotional status within the meaning of the IDEA. However, STUDENT’s IEP indicates that District based its identification of STUDENT’s social-emotional needs upon “alternative assessment.” (Exhibit R1-5)
The question then arises of whether, consistent with the IDEA, District assessed STUDENT’s social-emotional status using valid data, rather than the results from District’s administration of the BASC. The IDEA required District’s assessment to include tests and other assessment materials “tailored to assess specific areas of educational need.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). District did not conduct any apparent testing that was valid. However, other assessment materials reasonably could include data obtained by District from other sources. To constitute an assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional status the data District relied upon must satisfy requirements of the IDEA and the corresponding California Education Code § 56320.
Reports from Mr. Stern and playground staff could not constitute assessment data because the individuals were not qualified to interpret STUDENT’s behavior in relation to his suspected disability. Although Mr. Stern’s testimony conveyed his genuine concern about STUDENT’s well-being and problem behaviors, he did not have the training or experience to distinguish whether STUDENT’s problem behavior, for example, of not “listening and following directions given by after-school personnel,” was defiance, or rather was related to STUDENT’s ability to process oral instructions at the kindergarten level. (See Exhibit P5(a)) Similarly, no evidence indicates that playground staff were competent to interpret STUDENT’s failure to follow their verbal instructions in light of his severely limited ability to process auditory instructions. District did not identify observations of STUDENT’s behaviors by any staff member qualified to interpret those behaviors. Further, staff observations were insufficient data, because the observations had been made before Ms. Walker administered the BASC to obtain additional assessment data. Ms. Walker did not personally observe STUDENT as assessment. The Hearing Officer finds the reports and information provided by Mr. Stern and playground staff did not constitute assessment that satisfied the IDEA.
As part of an initial evaluation of STUDENT, District also was required to review existing evaluation data, including evaluations and information provided by his parents, current classroom-based assessments and observations of his teacher, and on that basis identify what additional data, if any, was necessary to determine the educational needs of the child. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.320(b)(1); 300.533, see also Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). STUDENT argued that District’s assessment did not consider the data regarding his educational needs related to social-emotional status that was provided by his UCLA assessment report. Ms. Walker testified that she received and reviewed STUDENT’s UCLA assessment report before she conducted her assessment but did not comment upon it in her report. Ms. Walker did not address the UCLA report because she intended to explain her own assessment results. (Testimony of Ms. Walker) Neither the IDEA nor State law required Ms. Walker’s report to include a discussion of her consideration of the UCLA report, although such a discussion may have provided information regarding the basis for her conclusions. (Testimony of Ms. Pliha) However, the IDEA did required Ms. Walker to determine whether additional testing was necessary to address the areas of educational need that were suggested in the UCLA report. 34 C.F.R. §§ 300.320(b)(1); 300.533.
The UCLA report provided information concerning some of the behaviors that Ms. Walker had attempted to assess further using the BASC. (Exhibit R26, p.10-11) Under the caption of “Behavior and Personality,” the UCLA report sets forth the results of the examiner’s separate administration of questionnaires from the BASC, consisting of the parent rating scale and a “self-report,” completed by STUDENT. (Id.) In addition, STUDENT’s mother completed the Youth Outcomes Questionnaire(Footnote 29), identifying parent concerns regarding STUDENT’s behavior and emotional state. (Exhibit 26, p.10) Further, the UCLA examiner observed STUDENT over three days of testing and in class at St. Anselm. (Exhibit R26, p.4-6)
From the UCLA examiner’s observations and testing, the UCLA team concluded that STUDENT was experiencing “significant distress due to his underachievement in school.” (Id. at p. 12) The examiner stated that STUDENT’s self-report and that of his mother on the BASC suggested that STUDENT was engaging in problem school behavior or “acting out” to avoiding academic tasks because of his feelings of inadequacy. (Id.) The report states further that STUDENT displayed symptoms of depression and anxiety. (Id., p. 13) STUDENT’s teacher at St. Anselm also expressed her concerns about “a number of behavior problems” the teacher observed. (Id.) The teacher reported that STUDENT was a “sweet child” but was often inattentive and became easily frustrated when he did not understand the materials. (Exhibit R26, p.11) STUDENT would often yell and use profanity when other students upset him. (Id.) The UCLA report specifically noted that the “teacher’s style of instruction [that] makes public STUDENT’s academic weakness relative to other children in his class” appeared to be “particularly unsuitable for him.” (Exhibit R26, p.12).
District did not acknowledge emotional problems related to STUDENT’s school performance and conducted no apparent assessment of his anxiety, depression or feelings of inadequacy that the UCLA report identified. Nor did District endorse the test results from the UCLA assessment regarding STUDENT’s social-emotional status as adequate data. STUDENT’s IEP did not mention the conclusions from the UCLA report regarding his social-emotional status. Moreover, Ms. Hudson, Angeles Mesa vice-principal, testified that the IEP team specifically did not consider the UCLA report, consistent with her understanding of District policy. (Testimony of Ms. Hudson). The Hearing Officer finds that District did not consider the UCLA assessment in conjunction with District’s assessment of STUDENT’s social emotional status.
Neither Ms. Walker’s assessment report nor STUDENT’s IEP identify sources of information that constituted an assessment of his social-emotional status that satisfied the IDEA. The information concerning STUDENT’s social-emotional status relayed in the IEP consists entirely of results of the invalid BASC and information Ms. Walker obtained from lay observers. (Testimony of Ms. Walker; Exhibits R1-5; R12, pp.2, 4-5, 7) Moreover, District failed to consider the influence of STUDENT’s language deficits and/or auditory processing deficits, which District did not adequately assess, upon the behaviors District relied upon as indications of his social-emotional status. After STUDENT’s mother requested assessment and provided the UCLA report, STUDENT’s repeated suspensions should have triggered a meaningful evaluation of the social-emotional needs evidenced by his behavioral problems, rather than a perfunctory administration of the BASC and adoption of lay reports of misconduct. The Hearing Officer finds that District did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT’s social-emotional status that satisfied the IDEA.(Footnote 30)
Whether STUDENT needs a functionally based approach to identify his needs was not shown by the evidence. Ms. Pliha recommended a functionally based assessment to address the need for a supportive educational environment. The UCLA assessment identified STUDENT’s need for a supportive environment and self-respect without an FBA. However, the UCLA assessment now is more remote in time. The Hearing Officer finds that additional data from tests or other evaluation materials are needed before District can identify STUDENT’s educational needs related to his social-emotional status.
3. Did District’s Written Report Satisfy Requirements Of The IDEA?
Personnel who assessed STUDENT were required to prepare a written report of the results of each assessment. Cal. Educ. Code § 54327. The report must include (a) whether the pupil may need special education and related services, (b) the basis for making the determination, (c) the relevant behavior noted during the observation of the pupil in an appropriate setting, and (d) the relationship of that behavior to the pupil’s academic and social functioning. (Id.)
STUDENT contends that Ms. Walker’s report fails to satisfy requirements of the IDEA because she does not report STUDENT’s relevant behavior based upon her own personal observations in an appropriate setting and because the report does not explain the relationship between STUDENT’s academic performance and the behaviors observed. District argues that Ms. Walker’s report satisfied the IDEA by identifying STUDENT as eligible for special education based upon its identification of an SLD and adequately discussing the results of District testing. Ms. Harvey testified that her findings were accurately reported by Ms. Walker.(Footnote 31)
The IDEA does not require Ms. Walker to personally observe all behaviors she reported in District’s assessment, although the nature of the information gathered by other persons may undermine the sufficiency of an assessment, as was discussed above. However, the observations of behavior that Mr. Stern provided are not required to constitute an assessment before being included as observations in an assessment report.
Ms. Walker’s report of classroom observations identifies, in part, that STUDENT exhibits a very short attention span; needs constant reminders in the classroom; claims not to know the rules on the playground; has difficulty following directions, shifting from one activity to the next, and organizing tasks; and has trouble working independently and completing tasks. (Exhibit R12, p. 2) In the absence of personal observation or test data, Ms. Walker attributes STUDENT’s impulsivity, failing to finish what he starts and not listening to his attention deficits. (Exhibit 12, p.7) Ms. Walker also includes lay interpretations of STUDENT’s classroom behavior as “distrustful and defiant toward adults.” However, the IDEA does not prohibit inclusion of unsubstantiated or even erroneous conclusions in the assessment report.
Ms. Walker clearly notes that the classroom observations were based upon reports from Mr. Stern and that she did not observe STUDENT. (Exhibit 12, p.2) Therefore, the information is not misleading. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Walker’s report is not inconsistent with requirements of the IDEA because the classroom observations she reported were those of STUDENT’s teacher. The report satisfied the IDEA requirement for including a statement of relevant behavior noted during observation in an appropriate setting and the purported relationship of that behavior to STUDENT’s academic and social functioning.(Footnote 32)
STUDENT also asserts, in effect, that Ms. Walker’s assessment report violates requirements of the IDEA because the report is factually inaccurate and contains erroneous conclusions. District disputed whether the report was inaccurate.
The Hearing Officer notes that the assessment report contains numerous statements appearing to be remnant boiler plate statements. For example, the assessment report states that “efforts to intervene in the regular classroom did not result in STUDENT’s ability to perform successfully in the regular education classroom and is the impetus of this evaluation.” (Exhibit R12, p.2) The report incorrectly states the reason for assessment, which in fact was required because of STUDENT’s mother’s request. Further, undisputed evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s behaviors improved after District held the SST meetings(Footnote 33) and no interventions were implemented to address STUDENT’s academic deficits.(Footnote 34) (Exhibit P5(m)) The Hearing Officer finds that
District’s assessment report does not satisfy the requirements of IDEA because the many inaccuracies preclude the report from providing accurate information for use by STUDENT’s IEP team.
***********
The Hearing Officer has found that after over two years of failing to identify STUDENT’s need for special education and related services, District failed to administer assessment tests in conformity with test instructions and failed to assess STUDENT in all areas related to his suspected disability. As a result STUDENT’s IEP was fatally inaccurate because STUDENT’s IEP team used the grade-level reference point to identify his present levels of performance and develop goals and objectives. The invalid BASC results did not provide reliable information regarding STUDENT’s social-emotional status.
Further, District did not consider the UCLA assessment report that STUDENT’s parents obtained and provided to District in the long struggle to understand why STUDENT was not succeeding in school. District remains unable to identify STUDENT’s educational needs because it does not know whether an attention deficit disorder is the cause of STUDENT’s inability to understand oral language and progress academically, as District’s expert believes, or whether, in addition or instead, his impaired performance is related to a language disorder and/or CAPD that is manifesting as inattention and behavior difficulties.
The evidence was compelling that District did not obtain sufficient reliable assessment data to identify STUDENT’s unique educational needs, including those related to the necessary areas of speech and language, auditory processing, OT, assistive technology and social-emotional status. Therefore, District did not conduct an assessment of STUDENT that satisfied the IDEA or California Education Code requirements.
ISSUE 3: DID DISTRICT OFFER STUDENT A FAPE BY THE IEP DATED JUNE 17, 2002, AND OFFER OF PLACEMENT AT ANGELES MESA IN AN SDC?
STUDENT contended that District failed both substantively and procedurally to offer him a FAPE for the ESY of the 2001-2002 school year and for the 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT alleged procedural denials of a FAPE, including failing to convene an IEP team meeting that included individuals knowledgeable in the resources that were available to meet STUDENT’s educational needs and failing to advise his parents that portions of his IEP that were undisputed could be implemented pending resolution of the disputed issues. Resolution of STUDENT’s claims will not alter the result here because District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT in significant areas of concern preclude it from offering a FAPE.
As was discussed above, District did not identify key areas of suspected need and therefore did not identify STUDENT’s unique needs. Until STUDENT’s unique needs are established, District cannot establish that a proposed program meets STUDENT’s unique needs. District has the burden of proof to establish that it has offered a FAPE. Clyde K. at 1398. District has not met its burden. Accordingly, District could not offer STUDENT a FAPE on June 17, 2002. The Hearing Officer finds that District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE on June 17, 2002(Footnote 35).
For the same reasons, District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE for the ESY in Summer 2002 or by an agreement to temporary placement of STUDENT in an SDC at Baldwin Hills, pending resolution of the dispute concerning the sufficiency of District’s offer. A determination of what placement and services would satisfy the IDEA cannot be made until further assessment has been completed consistent with the order herein.
ISSUE 4: WHAT IS THE RESULT OF THE AGREEMENT BETWEEN DISTRICT AND STUDENT’S FAMILY FOR PLACEMENT AT BALDWIN HILLS PENDING DUE PROCESS PROCEDURES?
Undisputed evidence established that STUDENT’s mother agreed with District that STUDENT would be placed in an SDC at Baldwin Hills pending resolution of the issues raised by STUDENT’s request for a due process hearing. (Testimony of MOTHER; Exhibit P22(a)) STUDENT’s mother agreed to the placement, but still had unanswered questions about the content of the Baldwin Hills SDC. (Testimony of MOTHER; Testimony of Mr. Uzor; Exhibit P22; P22(a))
District contends that STUDENT’s mother’s agreement to temporary placement at Baldwin Hills precludes him from disputing whether the placement constituted a FAPE. Neither federal nor State law preclude STUDENT from challenging the sufficiency of the SDC that his mother agreed to at Baldwin Hills or the sufficiency of STUDENT’s IEP to constitute a FAPE.
Again, because District did not identify STUDENT’s unique needs through appropriate assessment, District did not offer STUDENT a FAPE when STUDENT’s parents agreed to his temporary placement at Baldwin Hills. The fact that STUDENT’s mother agreed to try the placement at Baldwin Hills did not constitute a waiver of STUDENT’s right to assert that the placement and program did not offer a FAPE.
STUDENT’s parents’ agreement to placement at Baldwin Hills, however, resulted in Baldwin Hills becoming STUDENT’s last agreed-upon placement pending a resolution of the issues raised by their initial request for due process hearing in September 2002. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(d); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j); Stacy G. v. Pasadena Independent Sch. Dist., 695 F.2d 949 (5th Cir. 1983). If STUDENT elects to return to public school pending reassessment in conformity with the Order contained herein, an IEP meeting and acceptance of a new offer of placement, STUDENT’s placement would be in the SDC at Baldwin Hills, unless an alternative agreement is reached between the parties.
ISSUE 5: IS STUDENT ENTITLED TO REIMBURSEMENT FOR INDEPENDENT ASSESSMENTS OBTAINED FROM THE HUNTINGTON LEARNING CENTER AND LINDAMOOD-BELL AND/OR TUTOR SERVICES STUDENT RECEIVED BEGINNING IN JULY 2002?(Footnote 36)
A parent has the right to obtain, at public expense, an independent assessment of the pupil from qualified specialists, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the public education agency. Cal. Educ. Code §56329(b) The IDEA does not authorize reimbursement to a parent for an independent educational evaluation that is conducted prior to completion of District testing.
STUDENT’s mother obtained an assessment from the Huntington Learning Center on May 25, 2002, three days after she signed the assessment plan from District and before District had conducted assessment. District had not conducted an assessment that STUDENT could disagree with. District had obtained STUDENT’s mother’s consent to the assessment plan only three days earlier. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted by the Huntington Learning Center.
STUDENT was assessed by Lindamood-Bell on September 25, 2002, to determine STUDENT’s “sensory-cognitive processing as related to language function. (Exhibit P27) The evaluation targeted areas in which District’s assessment was inappropriate. STUDENT’s mother had notified District that she disputed the adequacy of its assessment to identify STUDENT’s educational needs for special education. District contended at hearing that the tests administered at Lindamood-Bell were not those generally relied upon by school districts. However, District did not establish by the evidence that the testing was defective in any manner. District had not conducted a speech and language assessment despite STUDENT’s mother’s request for it on June 18, 2002. (Exhibit R1-16) District did not prepare an assessment plan within fifteen-days of the request. District did not notify STUDENT that it refused to conduct the assessment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the educational assessment completed at Lindamood-Bell.(Footnote 37)
STUDENT also seeks reimbursement for services his family obtained for him after June 17, 2002. STUDENT seeks reimbursement for tutor services he obtained from the Huntington Learning Center and fees for summer programs at the YMCA and a Summer gymnastics program at The Los Angeles School of Gymnastics.
When a school district has denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purposes of the IDEA. Sch. Comm. of Burlington v. Dept. of Edu. of Massachusetts, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for appropriate privately obtained services when a district fails to offer a FAPE. Burlington at 370. STUDENT seeks reimbursement for the intensive tutor services he began receiving in July 2002, during the period the Hearing Officer has found that District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE.
Undisputed evidence established that STUDENT made substantial academic and social-emotional gains after he began receiving tutor services at the Huntington Learning Center for three hours per day, three to four days per week. (Testimony of Ms. Berg) The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Berg’s testimony persuasive that at least some of STUDENT’s needs that resulted from a denial of special education for over two years were being met by the intensive academic tutoring and it clearly provided STUDENT with educational benefit, as is discussed further below. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the tutoring was appropriate for STUDENT and his family should receive reimbursement for the cost of the tutor services provided at the Huntington Learning Center since July 1, 2002.
Evidence was not submitted that indicated STUDENT educationally required or benefitted from his participation in the summer YMCA or the Summer gymnastics program. STUDENT attended the two-week YMCA program for five days per week from nine o’clock in the morning until five o’clock in the evening. (Testimony of MOTHER) The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has not demonstrated that the programs were educational programs that served the purposes of the IDEA. Accordingly, no reimbursement is appropriate.
ISSUE 6: IF STUDENT IS ENTITLED TO COMPENSATORY EDUCATION FROM MARCH 1, 2000, UNTIL JUNE 17, 2002, WHAT COMPENSATORY EDUCATION IS STUDENT ENTITLED TO RECEIVE?
STUDENT’s entitlement to compensatory education cannot be fully determined until further assessment of STUDENT’s educational needs is completed consistent with the order contained herein. However, partial interim relief can be awarded based upon credible testimony and the parties’ expert witnesses’ agreement that STUDENT is benefitting significantly from particular tutor services and would substantially benefit from remedial language services. These services are appropriate to address the consequences of his unmet special education needs since March 2000.
Undisputed evidence established that the forty-two hours of intensive tutor services STUDENT received at Huntington Learning Center have assisted STUDENT to gain confidence in his ability to master academic tasks and progress substantially in his academic achievement. (Testimony of Ms. Berg) His progress was demonstrated by his increased ability to attend to academic tasks and to remain focused upon educational tasks in small groups of three to five other students and a staff ratio of two staff to each child. Inappropriate behavior has not been observed. (Id.) STUDENT made six months of academic progress between July 1 and late-September 2002. (Id.) STUDENT has progressed from his prior ability to attend to academic tasks only briefly to being able to work continually for one-hour tutor sessions, three to four times per week. (Id.)
Prior to providing tutoring, Ms. Berg conducted a series of tests to assess STUDENT’s skills in reading, writing, and mathematics skills. (Exhibits P6, P6(a); P6(b)) Ms. Berg derived a computer-based estimate of STUDENT’s skills to determine that STUDENT would require an initial program of approximately one-hundred and ninety-five hours of intensive tutoring working on building confidence and closing the gap between his performance and ability levels. (Testimony of Ms. Berg; Exhibit P6(b)). At the time of hearing, STUDENT was beginning to make significant gains in confidence, attention and academics, after he had completed approximately twenty-one percent of the estimated hours. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Berg’s testimony persuasive to establish that tutor services at Huntington Learning Center have allowed STUDENT to make significant educational gains.(Footnote 38) The Hearing Officer finds further that partial interim compensatory education, in the form of intensive tutor services at Huntington Learning Center, is appropriate for one-hundred and ninety-five total hours, including those hours provided since commencement of the services in July 2002.
Ms. Berg testified that her tutoring would not address STUDENT’s demonstrated deficits in auditory and visual processing. Ms. Pliha testified that an initial six-week Lindamood Bell program would be expected to provide substantial benefit to STUDENT by teaching him tools to compensate for language deficits. Ms. Wenger provided credible testimony that Lindamood-Bell methods applied five days per week for three hours each day would “go a long way” toward addressing the gap in STUDENT’s academic performance related to auditory and visual processing deficits indicated by District’s belated assessment. Ms. Berg, Ms. Pliha, Ms. Wenger and Ms. McKendall agreed that STUDENT would benefit significantly in the area of reading skills from a Lindamood-Bell program. Ms. McKendall maintained that other types of programs could also assist STUDENT in improving his reading skills and suggested a trial period in an SDC first. However, she did not dispute that the Lindamood-Bell program would assist STUDENT to overcome his reading comprehension deficits. Ms. Pliha’s persuasively testified that basic reading skills are necessary for success in all academic areas. The Hearing Officer finds the unanimous opinions of the experts persuasive to establish that an initial Lindamood-Bell program of six weeks, at three hours per day, five days per week, is appropriate partial interim compensatory education for STUDENT pending further assessment and an offer of placement that constitutes a FAPE.
STUDENT also seeks compensatory education in the form of individual instruction from a “gymnastics/movement specialist” for one hour once per week at The Los Angeles School of Gymnastics. A letter of explanation states that STUDENT “is very responsive to sensory integration through the form of gymnastics.” (Exhibit P13). The author, Mr. Thompson, offers that STUDENT’s motor planning and coordination would improve through the program.
The Hearing Officer finds that the letter is insufficient as hearsay to establish whether STUDENT requires such a program to address visual-motor problems identified in the letter. No independent evidence indicates that STUDENT has gross-motor deficits or how such a program might be related to STUDENT’s needs in the area of visual-motor integration. However, the social component of the program is an important consideration because of the behaviors STUDENT has exhibited in social settings involving sports activities and peers at school. Testimonial and documentary evidence demonstrated that at Angeles Mesa STUDENT routinely was involved in conflicts on the playground with peers. The UCLA assessment showed that STUDENT’s self-confidence in his sports ability provides a uniquely constructive setting for positive social interactions. (Exhibit R26, p. 5-6) In addition, undisputed evidence established that STUDENT’s access to typically developing peers during athletic activities has been limited significantly because of STUDENT’s unassessed social behaviors.
STUDENT’s inability to interact appropriately with peers on the playground at Angeles Mesa prompted multiple suspensions and exclusion from playground activities. (Exhibit P5(e);Testimony of Mr. Stern) At Baldwin Hills, STUDENT was required to stay in a confined area away from typically developing peers. (Testimony of Ms. Tate). Consistent with the observations stated in the gymnastics coach’s letter, Ms. Berg testified that STUDENT does not exhibit inappropriate behavior in small groups or when he has one-to-one direction from an adult. The Hearing Officer finds the evidence of STUDENT’s peer conflicts at Angeles Mesa in the context of athletic activities persuasive to establish that STUDENT’s peer interactions have been adversely influenced by District’s failure to assess the relationship between his disability and his behavior with peers.
The Hearing Officer finds the observations of Ms. Berg, the observations of the UCLA examiner and District’s multiple suspension notices persuasive to establish that STUDENT’s behavior toward peers in the context of sports activities is an important area of social-emotional need made worse by District’s neglect in identifying STUDENT’s disability. Although the proposed gymnastics instruction is one-on-one, gymnasts work together in the gym and STUDENT interacts constructively with peers. (Exhibit P13)(Footnote 39) Learning good sportsmanship provides a skill that can assist STUDENT to develop constructive relationships with typically developing peers. Further, District has not conducted any assessment of STUDENT in the setting where his behavior caused multiple disciplinary actions in the few weeks that he attended Angeles Mesa. Participation in a gymnastics program would provide a setting for informative observation of STUDENT’s social-emotional status.
The Hearing Officer finds that the gymnastics class at the Los Angeles School of Gymnastics, and the opportunity for positive social interactions with typically developing peers, is appropriate as compensatory education here. STUDENT’s negative interactions with peers in the context of sports activities has become so severe during the years he was not assessed that multiple suspensions seriously disrupted his access to education. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, as partial interim compensatory education, STUDENT should receive one hour per week of participation in the gymnastics program pending reassessment and an offer of placement that constitutes a FAPE.
ISSUE 7: IF DISTRICT DID NOT OFFER STUDENT A FAPE BY THE IEP OF JUNE 17, 2002, WHAT RELIEF IS APPROPRIATE?
STUDENT seeks placement at the Delphi Academy of Los Angeles for the current school year as an appropriate program rather than an SDC at Angeles Mesa. District asserted that the SDC at Angeles Mesa was appropriate.
As was discussed above, the absence of adequate assessment data to determine STUDENT’s related educational needs in the areas of speech and language, auditory processing, occupational therapy and social-emotional status precludes identifying an appropriate educational program that addresses STUDENT’s unique needs. Placement in the SDC at Angeles Mesa or the SDC at Baldwin Hills potentially could offer STUDENT a FAPE if it is based upon adequate assessment, an IEP that satisfied requirements of the IDEA, including that of LRE. However, the determination of a program that would constitute a FAPE for STUDENT simply cannot be made based upon the current assessment data. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that District must make a new offer of placement after obtaining adequate assessment data to identify STUDENT’s unique educational needs and developing an IEP that is consistent with the IDEA. In conducting additional assessments, District should remain alert to the possibility that assessment specifically ordered by this Decision may reveal other areas of suspected need. If so, District should assess in those areas as well.
CONCLUSION
Considering the evidence presented at hearing, the Hearing Officer finds the following:
STUDENT is entitled to receive compensatory education for the period of March 1, 2000, through June 16, 2002, in addition to the private placement reimbursements that District stipulated to provide.
STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the assessment conducted at UCLA in October and November 2001, reimbursement for private school tuition at the Marcus Garvey School; Marie Fegan School, St. Anselm School, and for The Study Institute at West Los Angeles College and reimbursement for round-trip transportation twice daily at the state rate, pursuant to District’s stipulation. STUDENT is further entitled to reimbursement for tutor services he received at the Huntington Learning Center between July 1, 2002 and the date of this Decision.
District failed to assess STUDENT in significant areas, including speech and language, central auditory processing and social-emotional status, which were related to his identified specific learning disability and suspected disabilities of a language disorder and/or attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Therefore, District did not identify STUDENT’s related unique educational needs. Accordingly, District could not meet its burden to establish by a preponderance of the evidence that it offered STUDENT a FAPE pursuant to the IEP that was developed on June 17, 2002.
Necessary educational services and appropriate placement for STUDENT cannot be identified until District conducts further assessment in the areas of speech and language, central auditory processing, social-emotional status, occupational therapy and assistive technology.
STUDENT’s placement at Baldwin Hills Elementary School in a SDC for learning disabled students was the last agreed upon placement between District and STUDENT’s family. Unless the parties agree otherwise, Baldwin Hills Elementary School would be STUDENT’s public school placement pending reassessment, an IEP meeting and acceptance of a new offer of placement.
Temporary interim compensatory education funded by District is appropriate in the form of (a) intensive tutor services through the Huntington Learning Center for a total of one-hundred and ninety-five hours since commencement of those services in July 2002, (b) an initial six-week course of language remediation through the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process, and (c) participation in gymnastics tutoring for one hour per week pending reassessment and acceptance of a new offer of placement.
ORDER
1. Within 30 calendar days from receipt of proof, District shall reimburse STUDENT’s parents for the following:
a. Tuition for private school placements at The Marcus Garvey School, The Marie Fegan School, St. Anselm School, and The Study Institute in Summer 2001 at West Los Angeles College;
b. Round-trip mileage for transportation twice daily between home to the service location each day Petitioner attended the programs;
c. The cost of the UCLA assessment and report for testing between October 18 and November 29, 2001;
d. For the intensive tutor services STUDENT received at Huntington Learning Center prior to the date of this Order.
2. District shall provide as partial interim compensatory education the following:
a. Intensive tutor services through the Huntington Learning Center for a total of one-hundred and ninety-five hours, including those hours for which reimbursement was provided pursuant to paragraph one above;
b. An initial six-week course of language remediation through the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process; and c. Participation in gymnastics tutoring for one hour per week pending reassessment and development of an IEP and a new offer of placement.
3. District shall conduct further assessments, including, but not limited to, the following:
a. A speech and language assessment regarding a potential language disorder;
b. An assessment to determine whether Petitioner has a central auditory processing disorder, and if so, how it might affect his learning process;
c. An occupational therapy assessment which evaluates his need for OT and assistive technology regarding identified visual-motor integration deficits;
d. A social-emotional assessment that considers STUDENT’s behavioral, social and emotional status and how those factors affect his educational performance; and e. Such other assessments as may become appropriate as a result of the assessment conducted as specifically required herein.
4. Within 50 calendar days from the date of this Decision, District shall convene an IEP meeting to consider additional assessment data and offer STUDENT an appropriate program and placement. District shall include in its offer an appropriate plan for comprehensive compensatory education taking into account the services awarded pursuant to paragraph two above.
5. If the parties fail to agree upon a new program and placement for STUDENT, either party may request a due process hearing.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the following finding is made: Petitioner prevailed upon all issues heard and decided herein.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Ed. § 56505(i)
DATED: January 31, 2003
Lina Foltz, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
FOOTNOTES
1. The Decision was amended to reflect the date of issuance of January 31, 2003. No substantive changes were made. 2. The issues were identified in the course of lengthy discussions on multiple days as the parties reached stipulations regarding District’s denial of a FAPE prior to June 17, 2002 and its agreement to reimburse the family for private school placements, summer programs and transportation prior to that date. The issues have been reorganized by the Hearing Officer for the purposes of adjudication. 3. District’s calculation that STUDENT would have received special education services beginning on March 2, 2000, was based upon the fifty day statutory time period within which District was required to hold an IEP meeting following written consent by STUDENT’s mother that she returned to District on January 11, 2000. However, fifty days would have run on March 1, 2000, because it was a leap year. 4. Behavioral assessment scales information obtained by the school psychologist, Ms. Walker on May 13, 2002, are considered as part of District’s assessment on June 3 because the assessment was completed on that date. 5. STUDENT’s mother testified that the UCLA assessment report contained an inaccurate statement regarding STUDENT’s “Academic History.” She testified that she did not remove STUDENT from Cimarron for the reasons stated and the information in the report was based upon by MOTHER report about another student’s experience at Cimarron. The remainder of the report accurately reflected information she provided to the examiner. 6. The DSM-IV is the Diagnostic and Statistics Manual of Mental Disorders-Fourth Edition, published by the American Psychiatric Association. 7. STUDENT asserts that he was in Principal Hawk’s office because District had discriminated against him based upon his disability by keeping him from participating in a field trip. STUDENT’s discrimination claim is not within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Officer and is not addressed. 8. STUDENT also had a medical assessment on May 6, upon a referral by District. (Exhibit P5(y)) 9. In addition to providing diagnostic information regarding memory capacity and possible impairment, the purpose of the LET II is identified as an assessment tool that “Yields information about a person’s preferred modality for learning and provides insights about the impact of inference on memory storage and retrieval, and the kinds of metacognitive strategies used during learning.” 9 Mental Measures Year Book, pp. 832-833 review by Alice J. Corkill, assistant professor of Counseling and educational psychology, University of Nevada, Las Vegas. Scaled scores provide the basis for identifying the subject’s specific modality strengths and weaknesses. Id. 10. Ninety-five percent of STUDENT’s peers would be expected to score higher than he. 11. STUDENT’s mother also delivered a letter to Ms. Hawk on June 10, requesting information regarding District’s assessment of STUDENT, but District’s assessment already had been completed. (Exhibit 5(k)) 12. The parties dispute whether it was the SDC or the general education class that Ms. Hawk said was full. 13. MOTHER asserted that District did not have a summer school class available for STUDENT at Angeles Mesa. District contended that the regular education class was full and therefore unavailable, but that a special education class was available, which MOTHER rejected as an option. 14. The tests identified in the Lindamood-Bell Report were: the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test III; the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude for Verbal Absurdities, Level-4 Word Opposites, and Level 2 Oral Directions; Test of Problem Solving-R; The Woodcock Reading Mastery Test-Revised Word Attack; The Slosson Oral Reading Test-Revised; The Wide Range Achievement Test-Revised/3 in Spelling and Arithmetic; The Gray Oral Reading Test Recall; The Gray Oral Reading Test-Revised/4 in Rate, Accuracy, Fluency and Comprehension; The Lindamood Auditory Conceptualization Test; Informal tests of Writing Sound/Symbol Associations and Nonsense Spelling; The Symbol Imagery Test; The Comprehensive Test of Phonological Processing various rapid naming tests. (Exhibit 27, p. 1-3) 15. Neither party submitted evidence concerning the substance of the private school programs that STUDENT’s family obtained between March 1, 2000, and April 2002. 16. Broad reading, Broad Math and Broad Written Language represent scores compiled from other subtests from which a derived score is calculated by a computer formula. Therefore, variations in the underlying tests would alter the resulting Broad score. 17. The evidence did not suggest that STUDENT’s family engaged in any behavior to impede District’s ability to identify STUDENT’s special education needs or to provide him with a FAPE. Moreover, District had an independent obligation under the IDEA to locate and identify STUDENT’s need for special education and related services even if he had not been referred for assessment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3); Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56300-56301. Thus, no equitable basis for denying an award of compensatory education to STUDENT was shown. 18. On April 23, 2002, STUDENT’s mother also had requested, in writing, that an IEP meeting be held for STUDENT. (Exhibit P5) 19. The BASC utilizes questionnaires that can be completed by different categories of individuals, including parents and teachers who have observed the child, to determine social-emotional status based upon behaviors. 20. It was not the accuracy of the described behaviors that was suspect in Mr. Stern’s responses. It was the frequency and severity of the rating he reported with qualifiers like “always” and “never.” (Exhibit P30, p.47-48) 21. The computer-generated analysis for the teacher rating scale of the BASC questionnaires includes the caveat that the BASC “is an integrated system designed to facilitate . . . the classification of a variety of emotional and behavioral disorders of children and to aid in the design of treatment plans. The computer-generated report is based upon one component of this system and should not be the sole basis for making important diagnostic or treatment decisions.” (Exhibit P30, p.49) The parent rating scale contains a similar caveat. (Id., p.34) 22. STUDENT had finished all but nineteen days of the fourth grade although the notation is grade 4.9. 23. STUDENT’s assessment plan identified the areas that District and STUDENT’s parents agreed needed to be assessed as: social/emotional development, cognitive development, academic achievement, perceptual development, motor development, communication/language functioning and health. (Exhibit R5/P5(i)) 24. The witnesses used varying terms to describe STUDENT’s potential processing disorder, including auditory processing disorder, central processing disorder and central auditory processing disorder (CAPD). The term CAPD is used here to include each usage, although a central processing disorder additionally may implicate deficits in processing visual information. Auditory processing deficits are not equivalent to a CAPD. 25. Ms. Barbara Pliha holds a master’s degree in communicative disorders and is certified as a resource specialist and speech pathologist. She has reviewed approximately four-hundred psycho-educational assessments. She was employed by California school districts as a resource specialist, for five to six years, and as special day class teacher. She now operates a certified nonpublic agency, the Reading and Language Center in Irvine. Ms. Pliha reviewed documents concerning STUDENT, including District’s assessment, the UCLA assessment and school records, but did not observe STUDENT. (Testimony of Ms. Pliha) 26. STUDENT had written a sentence in which he described a “brawken leg.” 27. Ms. Sharon L. Wenger, holds a bachelor’s degree in psychology, a master’s degree in education, and three teaching credentials: K-12 multi-subject, learning handicapped specialist and resource specialist. She has several years of experience as a resource specialist and as a special education teacher in California school districts and private schools. She is currently in private practice providing educational therapy, including language services using the Lindamood-Bell teaching method. (Testimony of Ms. Wenger; Exhibit P10) 28. District also argued that STUDENT’s behaviors were not so extreme as to warrant a functional analysis assessment (FAA), or Hughes Bill assessment, the requirements of which are set forth in the California Code of Regulations title 5, § 3052. However, STUDENT did not seek an FAA. Therefore the need for an FAA is not discussed. 29. The Youth Outcomes Questionnaire purportedly measures areas of: intrapersonal distress, somatic symptoms, interpersonal relations, social problems and behavior dysfunction, based upon observations by the parent. (Exhibit R26, p.10) 30. The Hearing Officer notes that the behavior support plan also contains inaccurate information regarding each of the first seven categories concerning the identified behaviors and unsupported factual assertions. (Exhibit R1-19) For example, District reports that STUDENT “says he needs to go to the bathroom when he don’t [sic] want to do his work.” (Id.) Although STUDENT reportedly requests to go to the bathroom when he is anxious about an assignment, he has had accidents in class when he was not permitted to go to the restroom. (Testimony of MOTHER). District simply has no competent information from which to conclude that STUDENT does not need to visit the restroom because of his anxiety. The behavior support plan is fatally flawed with inaccuracies. 31. No evidence was presented regarding the absence of a report from Dr. Cokely’s neurological assessment, which purportedly revealed a cyst on STUDENT’s brain. (Testimony of MOTHER) Therefore, its absence is not discussed. 32. The IDEA requirement is implemented pursuant to California Education Code § 56327. 33. The evidence did not establish whether STUDENT’s behavior improved because of the interventions or because he was becoming acclimated to his new school environment. 34. The evidence established that STUDENT’s mother did not want STUDENT to be held back a grade to accomplish instruction at his academic achievement level because STUDENT allegedly is large for his age and may respond to being held back as a humiliation. (Testimony of MOTHER; Exhibit R26, p.13). 35. The Hearing Officer notes that the evidence submitted at hearing raised concerns regarding whether an SDC class is the least restrictive environment for STUDENT. However, a resolution of that issue again is not undertaken here because District’s failure to appropriately assess STUDENT obviates further inquiry into the sufficiency of the procedures or substance of District’s IEP and placement offer. 36. No reimbursement is available to STUDENT’s family for his assessment at the Learning Center because his family did not incur a cost from the assessment. 37. Ms. Wenger testified that she conducted a “quick” assessment of STUDENT but that STUDENT’s family was not charged for that assessment. Therefore, reimbursement for Ms. Wenger’s services is not an issue. 38. If STUDENT maintained proportional improvement to that obtained in forty-two hours, STUDENT could substantially overcome his academic achievement deficits one year after beginning the program at Huntington Learning Center, using an average of three and one-half hours of intensive tutoring per week. 39. The statements in the School of Gymnastics letter are consistent with Ms. Berg’s observations that STUDENT exhibits appropriate behavior and strives when he receives one-to-one direction. The letter states: “STUDENT has become a ‘player,’ meaning he very much enjoys the gym and appears to feel comfortable here. He talks with all the coaches and other gymnast; he is happy and tries his best to succeed.” (Exhibit P13)
