California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · August 3, 2001
Student v. Tamalpais Union High School District et al. (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2087-00 · Hearing Officer Judy F. Hirano
Tamalpais Union High and Marin County Mental Health must reimburse two Texas residential placements and an independent evaluation, and fund tutoring.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parents and Tamalpais Union High School District both filed for due process, and the cases were consolidated. The County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health (CMH) was also a party. The student, 16, was eligible for special education under emotional disturbance. He had long-standing social, emotional, and attention difficulties. He attended Tamalpais High School with resource specialist program (RSP) support. In fall 2000, the District and CMH offered a therapeutic special day class at Redwood High School or Braun day treatment. The parents wanted residential care. In February 2001 they placed him at Oaks Treatment Center and then at Hill Country Place, both in Texas.
Hearing Officer Judy Hirano ruled for the student on every issue. The District and CMH never assessed attention, an area of suspected disability, so the parents were reimbursed for Dr. Vincent Nunno's independent evaluation. The 1999 and 2000 IEPs lacked present levels of emotional functioning, short-term objectives, clear service amounts, and mental health services. The fall 2000 offer listed several alternative programs, including RSP support that school staff agreed was no longer enough. Braun also offered a shortened instructional day with no extended school year. Based on testimony from his long-time psychiatrist and Dr. Nunno, the Hearing Officer found he needed a residential placement. The District and CMH must reimburse both Texas placements. The District must also reimburse private therapy from May 23 to October 2, 2000, and fund compensatory tutoring through fall 2001.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO applied Union School District v. Smith when a district offered several alternative programs and one was inadequate. It also shows that an AB 3632 mental health assessment had to meet Education Code assessment rules. And it shows that residential placement was judged by educational need rather than a danger-to-self-or-others standard.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedIndependent educational evaluation (IEE)
Issue 1. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation by Vincent Nunno, Ph.D.?
The District and CMH assessments were inappropriate because they did not assess attention/ADD, an area of suspected disability. The CMH residential assessor was not a qualified mental health professional and had no signed assessment plan, and the CMH report was not provided two days before the IEP meeting. The parents are reimbursed for Dr. Nunno's evaluation.
- Student prevailedIEP content
Issue 2. Did the District provide the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
The June 1999 IEP did not state the type, start date, duration, or amount of RSP services. Parents did not take part in writing the May 2000 goals. Both IEPs lacked present levels of emotional functioning and short-term objectives. The May 2000 IEP offered no mental health services, and the program was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit. FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 3. Did the District and CMH provide the Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
The District implemented the unconsented May 2000 IEP. The October 2000 offer of three alternative programs, including an RSP program staff agreed was inadequate, was not a clear and definite offer. Braun day treatment did not meet his needs and offered a shortened instructional day with no ESY. He needed a residential placement, so FAPE was denied.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4a. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement, including the cost of transportation, at Oaks Treatment Center, a residential treatment facility (during relevant periods between February 2, 2001 and the present)?
Oaks met his need for a constantly supervised, structured setting, and he made progress. Parents are reimbursed for academic instruction, nonmedical treatment and services, room and board, and transportation.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 4b. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement, including the cost of transportation, at Hill Country Place, a residential school (during relevant periods between February 2, 2001 and the present)?
Hill Country Place met his need for constant supervision, and he showed some progress. Lack of California certification did not bar reimbursement. Parents are reimbursed for tuition and fees, nonmedical services, and room and board through the decision date, plus transportation.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 5. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private counseling services from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to February 2, 2001?
Parents waived reimbursement for periods when they declined offered CMH referral or services. The District must reimburse Dr. Shatkin's therapy only from May 23, 2000 to October 2, 2000, when no mental health services were offered.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If the Student was denied a FAPE during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
He is entitled to compensatory education for the denial of FAPE from the start of 1999-2000 to May 23, 2000 and from October 2, 2000 to February 2, 2001. The remedy is one-on-one tutoring, with the amount set by the IEP team, rather than the residential placement the Student requested as compensatory education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days the Student submits proof of the cost of Dr. Vincent Nunno's psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation. The District and CMH reimburse within 25 calendar days of receiving proof, jointly and severally.
- Reimbursement. Reimbursement of tuition and fees, nonmedical treatment and services, room and board, and transportation for Oaks Treatment Center and Hill Country Place (order says 'Hill County Place'), for the relevant periods between February 2, 2001 and the decision date. Proof is due within 20 calendar days, and payment within 25 calendar days of proof. The District and CMH are jointly and severally responsible.
- Reimbursement. The District alone reimburses the cost of Dr. Eugene Shatkin's individual counseling from May 23, 2000 to October 2, 2000. Proof is due within 20 calendar days, and payment within 25 calendar days of proof.
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the District must convene an IEP meeting to develop a compensatory education plan.
- Compensatory education. Tutoring from the date of the IEP meeting through the end of the District's fall 2001 semester. The IEP team sets the amount, frequency, and tutor credentials, considering the denial of FAPE for over a year. The District pays 3/4 of the cost alone, and the District and CMH are jointly and severally responsible for the remaining 1/4.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees; Union School Dist. v. Smith; School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Educ.; Ojai Unified School Dist. v. Jackson; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ.; Burger v. Murray County School Dist.
People named in the decision
- Sandra Piotter, District director of instructional services, Tamalpais Union High School District
- Stephen Parsons, M.F.T., Supervisor, CMH youth and family services, County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health
- Karen Mates, Program manager, Marin County Office of Education
- Barbara Buchanan, Ph.D., CMH clinical psychologist; AB 3632 assessor, County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health
- Amira Mostafa, M.A., School psychologist; conducted August 2000 psycho-educational assessment, Marin County Office of Education
- Debora Waring, M.S., CMH residential placement case manager; AB 3632 assessor, County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health
- Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., Private psychologist; independent evaluator and expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Eugene Shatkin, M.D., Student's treating psychiatrist; expert witness for Student, Private practice
- Virginia Reiss, Ph.D., Educational psychologist; witness for Student
- James LeFan, Ph.D., Psychologist and therapist; witness for Student, Oaks Treatment Center
- Michael LeBlanc, M.S.W., Director; witness for Student, Hill Country Place
- Brian O'Connor, Resource specialist, grade 10 RSP teacher, Marin County Office of Education / Tamalpais High School
- Pamela McMullan, Former resource specialist, grade 9 RSP teacher, Tamalpais High School
- S. Margaret Lee, Ph.D., Private clinical psychologist (1992 assessment)
- Frank Benson, School psychologist (1994 and 1996 assessments)
- Anna Minton, School psychologist (May 1999 triennial assessment), Marin County Office of Education
- Ms. Searles, Resource specialist (May 1999 educational assessment)
- Meri Murphy, Ph.D., CMH clinician consulted in assessment, County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health
- Dr. Karnik, Adolescent psychiatrist, Oaks Treatment Center
- Dr. Simson, Psychiatrist, Hill Country Place
- Oaks Treatment Center, Private residential treatment facility (Texas)
- Hill Country Place, Private residential school (Austin, Texas)
- Braun day treatment, MCOE/CMH day treatment program offered by District
- Redwood High School CMH special day class, Therapeutic special day class offered by District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Judy Hirano, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in San Rafael, California, on March 6, 7, 15, 16, May 1, 2, 15, 16, 22, 23, and 24, 2001. STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented by attorney Jane Reid. Also present on STUDENT’S behalf was his mother, MOTHER. His father, FATHER, was present on most of the days. Tamalpais Union High School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Jan Tomsky. Also present on the District’s behalf was Sandra Piotter, District director of instructional services. Respondent County of Marin Division of Community Mental Health (CMH) was represented by attorney Alexis McBride. Also present on CMH’s behalf was Stephen Parsons, M.F.T., supervisor, CMH youth and family services.
The Student called the following witnesses: Karen Mates, program manager, Marin County Office of Education (MCOE); Barbara Buchanan, Ph.D., CMH clinical psychologist; Amira Mostafa, M.A., MCOE school psychologist; Debora Waring, M.S., CMH residential placement case manager; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., psychologist; Eugene Shatkin, M.D., psychiatrist; Virginia Reiss, Ph.D., educational psychologist; James LeFan, Ph.D., psychologist; and Michael LeBlanc, M.S.W., director, Hill Country Place.
The District and CMH called the following witnesses: Barbara Buchanan, Ph.D., CMH clinical psychologist; Debora Waring, M.S., CMH residential placement case manager; and Stephen Parsons, M.F.T., supervisor, CMH youth and family services. In addition, the District called these witnesses: Karen Mates, MCOE program manager; Amira Mostafa, M.A., MCOE school psychologist; MOTHER, STUDENT’S mother; Brian O’Connor, MCOE resource specialist, Tamalpais High School (Tamalpais HS); Pamela McMullan, former resource specialist, Tamalpais HS; and Sandra Piotter, District director of instructional services.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was kept open for the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On January 29, 2001, the Hearing Office issued a minute order that denied the Student’s motion to dismiss or change the order of going forward at the hearing. On the first day of hearing, the Student renewed his prior motion. According to him, both his and the District’s cases, which had been consolidated, raised essentially the same issues related to the provision of a free appropriate public education (FAPE) over overlapping time periods. Thus, the Student renewed his motion to dismiss as unnecessary the District’s case, which had been filed after his; alternatively, he renewed his request to place the burden of going forward on the District.
The Hearing Officer stated that the law bestowed upon the District the right and also the obligation to file for due process when the parent refused to consent to a program which the District determined offered a FAPE. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b). Further, the Hearing Officer noted that generally, the party seeking to change the status quo is the party that bears the burden of going forward. Burger v. Murray County School Dist., 612 F.Supp. 434, 437 (N.D. Ga. 1984). In this case, both parties sought to change the status quo: the District proposed a change to a special day class, and the parents, to a residential placement, from the current resource specialist placement. The Hearing Officer stated that when both parties seek to change the status quo, generally, the burden of going forward is placed on the party that requested a hearing first. The attorney for the Student stated that she would proceed first but that it was inequitable that the Student was required to proceed without a clear understanding of how the District’s and the Students’s issues may differ substantively. The Hearing Officer stated that the District’s statement of issues and proposed resolution provided the Student with the District’s perspective on its issues for hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6).
ISSUES(Footnote 1)
1. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation by Vincent Nunno, Ph.D.? 2. Did the District provide the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
3. Did the District and CMH provide the Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
4. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement, including the cost of transportation, at the following places (during relevant periods between February 2, 2001 and the present): a. Oaks Treatment Center, a residential treatment facility?
b. Hill Country Place, a residential school?
5. Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private counseling services from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to February 2, 2001?
6. If the Student was denied a FAPE during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) is a 16-year-old boy who was initially found eligible for special education as having a speech and language impairment, then a specific learning disability, and in May 1999, an emotional disturbance (ED).(Footnote 2) He has been diagnosed with an anxiety disorder; attention deficit disorder (ADD); pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), not otherwise specified (NOS), with prominent Asperger’s symptoms; mood disorder, NOS; and dysthymic disorder. From approximately age 4-1/2, STUDENT received counseling and, for a period of time, took Imipramine. In February 2001, his parents unilaterally placed him at Oaks Treatment Center, a private residential treatment facility in Texas. Approximately 6 weeks later, he was placed by his parents at Hill Country Place, a private residential school in Texas, and he currently is attending this school.
EARLY YEARS THROUGH MIDDLE SCHOOL
STUDENT was adopted at birth, and his biological mother reportedly suffers from bipolar disorder. At age 2, he became fearful and strong-willed and displayed a severe temper. At age 4-1/2, he started private therapy with a child therapist. His behavior was out of control; he was often angry and was hurting and frightening other children without remorse. An assessment when he was age 5 indicated some difficulty with fine motor tasks, and he received consultative services. In kindergarten he had no real friends. In grade 1, he was referred for a speech and language assessment, but he was assessed privately.
In January 1992, when STUDENT was age 6-1/2, clinical psychologist S. Margaret Lee, Ph.D., conducted a private psychological assessment. Tests revealed average intellectual functioning and some weakness in visual-motor integration. Personality testing revealed disordered thinking processes and very poor reality testing. When his impulses were not contained, his behavior was characterized by sexualized content and aggression. He had not developed a cohesive sense of identity, was frightened of emotions stemming from personal interactions, and maintained a distance from others. During the testing, he was distracted and impulsive and exhibited deviant behavior and communication. Dr. Lee concluded that he suffered from serious emotional difficulties. She recommended a regular education classroom and continued therapy twice weekly. However, she noted that, at some point, he likely would need a highly structured specialized classroom with a low student-teacher ratio. In spring 1992, STUDENT began private therapy with psychiatrist Eugene Shatkin, M.D., and continued therapy with him for almost 9 years.
In November 1993, when STUDENT was in grade 3, he was found eligible for special education because of a speech and language impairment and received speech and language services. He was also referred for special education because of difficulties with writing, staying on task, and getting along with peers, and exhibiting unusual behavior (e.g., making odd noises and facial gestures). He was in a school socialization group focused on developing friendships.
In January 1994, school psychologist Frank Benson conducted a psychological assessment. STUDENT had difficulty staying focused. Test results disclosed visual-motor integration problems related to learning difficulties, particularly with written language. Social-emotional testing revealed poor reality testing, social-emotional immaturity, and disorganized thought processes. He lacked a sense of self and had difficulty relating interpersonally and dealing with emotions. Mr. Benson concluded that STUDENT’S significant social-emotional problems required close monitoring and that he was eligible for a CMH assessment.
That same month, STUDENT’S special education eligibility category was changed to a specific learning disability (SLD) based upon poor auditory and visual memory skills. The IEP recommended a regular education class with resource specialist program (RSP) and speech and language services. From April 1994 to June 1998, STUDENT was prescribed Imipramine to address his attention difficulty and periodic depressive moods. In grades 4 and 5, he continued to receive RSP and speech and language services. In grade 5, he also received private tutoring focused on organizational skills.
In May 1996, when STUDENT was in grade 5, Mr. Benson conducted a triennial psychological assessment. STUDENT needed constant homework assistance and had only a few transitory friendships. In class, he required refocusing and displayed silliness, a bathroom humor, and an interest in violence. He often did not turn in class work and tended to be outside of the group socially. The resource specialist stated that he had difficulty sitting still, staying focused, and finishing assignments, and that he made inappropriate comments that included violent, aggressive content. Social-emotional testing disclosed a preoccupation with fantasies involving aggression and violence. He continued to reveal poor reality testing, confused thought processes, and poor judgment. His interpersonal relations were impaired. According to Mr. Benson, the danger was that he would be aggressive and controlling in relation to others rather than expose his vulnerability. However, he was not currently displaying physical aggression at school, which had been an issue in the past. Mr. Benson concluded that STUDENT exhibited a moderate range of social and emotional problems.
Also in May 1996, it was determined that STUDENT no longer required speech and language services but that he continued to have a learning disability, with poor visual-motor skills. In June 1996, RSP services were recommended for middle school. Instead, in fall 1996 STUDENT attended grade 6 at a private school, at his parents’ expense. In May 1997, he scored at or above the average range in all skills tested, except for spelling.
Because of socialization and academic concerns, STUDENT returned to the public middle school. In grade 7, he had two RSP classes, in language arts and math, and also received RSP support for his regular education classes. In May 1998, his social and emotional development was of greater concern than academics. He was awkward socially and antagonistic with peers and appeared not to have many friends at school. On some days he was withdrawn and unfocused in class.
In grade 8, STUDENT attended an RSP class daily. In May 1999, when he was in grade 8, his academic skills were found to be commensurate with his ability. However, he continued to exhibit a weakness in visual-motor integration and had difficulty completing class work and homework. A May 1999 triennial assessment was conducted by school psychologist Anna Minton. She noted that STUDENT’S therapist Dr. Shatkin had diagnosed an anxiety disorder and ADD. During her testing, STUDENT was frequently in motion, and his sense of humor was either immature or displayed a violent, sexual, or morbid content. Her assessment indicated average cognitive ability and visual-motor skills. The social-emotional testing revealed disturbed thinking, poor reality testing, poor self-esteem, and possible depression. His social skills were described as problematic, and STUDENT, his parents, and teachers all agreed that he tended not to get along with other students. Ms. Minton concluded that STUDENT appeared to meet the ED eligibility criteria. Significant emotional concerns had been evident for a long period of time and to a marked degree. He had manifested an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relationships with peers. His teachers’ reports suggested that educational performance was adversely affected by emotional factors (i.e., he had difficulty with task completion, other students did not like to work with him, and he did not work well in groups). She stated that an option was a CMH referral for assessment for mental health services.
A June 3, 1999 IEP states that STUDENT met the ED eligibility criteria. The recommended program for May to June 1999 was RSP two to three times weekly in the resource room. The IEP states that a CMH referral was offered but that STUDENT currently was working with a private therapist. The IEP sets forth accommodations or modifications for all subjects.
HIGH SCHOOL YEARS
During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT attended grade 9 at Tamalpais HS. He had one RSP class focusing on study skills. He often went to the resource room during his math class to work on math assignments. In the first semester of grade 9, STUDENT obtained an A- for creative learning (RSP); C’s for geography/cultures and math; and D’s for English, physical education (P.E.), computer literacy, and art exploration. He obtained second semester grades of A for computer application and graphics; B for social issues, English, and RSP; C for math and photography; and D for P.E.
A May 23, 2000 IEP, unsigned by the parents, recommended 240 minutes weekly of direct RSP services. The IEP sets forth a goal and objectives related to improving classroom responsibilities and time management. The IEP contains accommodations, a statement of needed transition services, and a behavior intervention plan. The parents submitted a dissent, stating that STUDENT required a therapeutic residential school.
In August 2000, when STUDENT was to enter grade 10, the parent requested a CMH referral. In response, school psychologist Amira Mostafa conducted a psycho-educational assessment and prepared a September 1, 2000 report. During the testing, STUDENT made a couple of inappropriate sexual or personal comments. Although he reported having many friends, it appeared that he engaged primarily in solitary activities. He specifically stated that he had problems with large classes, group work, and conversations and interactions with classmates. Ms. Mostafa consulted with Dr. Shatkin, who was still providing weekly therapy to STUDENT. Dr. Shatkin revealed his diagnosis of a multiple complex developmental disorder, including symptoms of ADD without hyperactivity, anxiety disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, obsessive compulsive disorder, and some symptoms of schizophrenia and Asperger’s disorder.
The Kovacs Children’s Depression Inventory, administered by Ms. Mostafa, revealed significant anxiety and unhappiness with school and social situations. Statements that STUDENT agreed with were “I have trouble sleeping every night,” “I feel tired many days,” and “I think about killing myself but I would not do it.” His responses on the Achenbach Behavior Rating Scale were in the clinically significant range for Delinquent Behavior and in the borderline range for Attention Problems and Thought Problems. Statements he endorsed included “I act without stopping to think,” “I hear sounds or voices that other people think aren’t there” (“warning about what I am going to do”), and “I don’t feel guilty after doing something I shouldn’t.” As for the mother’s responses, of particular concern were high ratings for Delinquent Behavior, Social Problems, Attention Problems, and Thought Problems.
The Rorschach results indicated that STUDENT was most comfortable in a structured, predictable environment. He had difficulty accurately perceiving events and others’ actions and anticipating the consequences of his actions. His thinking process and ability to draw reasonable conclusions were impaired. His poor perception, difficulty separating fantasy from reality, and faulty judgment were likely to result in difficulty functioning adequately over an extended period of time. His responses indicated considerable emotional stress, rendering him vulnerable to anxiety and depression. He appeared to be preoccupied with his own needs but had a negative internal self-perception. Ms. Mostafa stated that it was important to be alert to the development of possible psychotic thinking.
She concluded that STUDENT continued to meet the ED eligibility criteria. In several situations, he exhibited an inability to build or maintain satisfactory interpersonal relations and displayed inappropriate types of behavior or feelings under normal circumstances. Moreover, his ED condition negatively impacted his educational functioning. She further concluded that RSP support no longer appeared adequate to meet his educational needs. She recommended a small structured special education program with a therapeutic component to provide additional support. She strongly recommended an AB 3632 referral to CMH. On August 24, 2000, Ms. Mostafa referred to CMH the parents’ request for an AB 3632 assessment, along with a copy of her assessment report. In the transmittal letter, she indicated that the District was considering changing STUDENT’S program from RSP to the therapeutic special day class (SDC) at Redwood High School (Redwood) or Braun day treatment.
A September 12, 2000 report from STUDENT’S psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin states that STUDENT initially displayed anxiety, suspiciousness, and difficulty in maintaining attention. Dr. Shatkin stated that STUDENT had been hurt by many persons who teased him because of his immaturity and his misperceptions. He blames others for his problems and harbors fantasies of retaliating against his tormentors. However, Dr. Shatkin stated that he had no evidence that STUDENT had ever acted on his fantasies, and, in fact, STUDENT avoided physical confrontations. Dr. Shatkin had prescribed Imipramine for several years but discontinued the medication because of its apparent negligible impact on the target symptoms.
Dr. Shatkin diagnosed STUDENT with anxiety disorder, NOS, and ADD without hyperactivity. In addition, he stated that STUDENT’S primary issues (mild to severe thought disorder, reality functioning difficulties, and problematic misperceptions in life) fell within a syndrome known as multiple complex developmental disorder. However, because this diagnosis was not in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual (DSM-IV), STUDENT’S condition might be considered a form of pervasive developmental disorder (PDD), NOS. Dr. Shatkin recommended more intense therapy in the form of consistent monitoring, mentoring, and supervision, preferably in a residential setting where STUDENT’S acceptance by peers could be controlled.
An October 2, 2000 IEP, unsigned by the parent, mentions Ms. Mostafa’s September 2000 psycho-educational assessment and an oral report of an October 2000 AB 3632 assessment by Barbara Buchanan, Ph.D., of CMH. An October 2 IEP addendum page indicates that the District and CMH offered STUDENT the CMH SDC at Redwood or day treatment, with individual, family, group, medication monitoring, and wraparound services.(Footnote 3) The addendum states that the parent had rejected the Redwood SDC and requested a residential placement. The addendum states that CMH had determined that STUDENT was not eligible for residential placement at that time because he had not yet tried the least restrictive environment but that CMH would conduct a further assessment to examine a residential placement pursuant to the parent’s request.
A November 3, 2000 report by Debora Waring, M.S., of CMH, states that the AB 3632 mental health assessment was undertaken at the IEP team’s request. According to the report, STUDENT stated that he had much difficulty concentrating in the regular classroom and that he needed help with organization and staying on task. The report states that Ms. Waring informed the parent of the continuum of services offered by CMH, starting with outpatient therapy and culminating in a residential placement for persons “severely at risk and possibly dangerous to self or others.” The report notes that the parents had declined prior CMH referrals in 1996 and 1999 and recommends a CMH special day treatment class with integrated mental health services that might include individual, family, and group therapy and psychiatric referral if necessary.
A November 6, 2000 AB 3632 mental health assessment report was prepared by CMH clinical psychologist Dr. Buchanan.(Footnote 4) Her notes reveal a diagnosis of mood disorder, NOS, but the diagnosis is not included in her report. She testified that she spent about an hour with STUDENT. Her report states that she saw no obvious signs of a thought disorder but that STUDENT acknowledged hearing voices (auditory hallucinations) occasionally and disclosed a lifelong problem going to sleep because of acute anxiety (e.g., fear of nightmares and of people entering through his window). Dr. Buchanan stated that he is not suicidal but has thought about death since a friend killed himself in May. According to her, STUDENT said that to achieve more success in school, he wanted to attend a boarding school that provides one-on-one assistance, is not too strict, and will permit him to use a computer.
Dr. Buchanan concluded that to meet his academic, behavioral, and social-emotional needs, STUDENT needs mental health services that are more comprehensive than the outpatient therapy he had received from Dr. Shatkin. She stated that he needs a smaller, more structured setting providing integrated academic and therapeutic services. She noted that Ms. Waring’s assessment indicated that he did not meet the CMH criteria for residential care at this time, and she recommended mental health services through the Redwood SDC or Braun day treatment program. Dr. Buchanan stated that these settings would offer individual, group, and family therapy; case management; and medication monitoring in the least restrictive environment. She also set forth two goals and objectives of treatment to (1) help STUDENT develop the necessary social skills to cultivate and sustain friendships and (2) intervene on-the-spot when he displayed a distortion of reality and assist him to shape his perceptions and experiences based upon reality. These interventions were to help reduce his anxiety and form a more positive sense of self.
A November 6, 2000 IEP Addendum recommends the CMH SDC at Redwood or Braun day treatment starting November 6, 2000, with CMH services 5 days a week in the classroom and off-site clinic. According to the addendum, Dr. Buchanan reviewed her report and Ms. Waring’s report, both of which had concluded that STUDENT did not meet the CMH criteria for residential placement. The parents had indicated that they disagreed with the District’s denial of their request for a residential placement and that only residential treatment would help STUDENT.
A Tamalpais HS discipline report shows that STUDENT received warnings in April, May, and November 2000 for receiving unblocked inappropriate information through e-mail, for horseplay before the teacher entered the gym, and for not dressing for P.E., respectively. On November 7, a truancy conference was held, and STUDENT signed a student truancy contract.
A November 12, 2000 report by private psychologist Vincent Nunno, Ph.D., sets forth the results of a psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation. Cognitive testing showed average intellectual functioning. Memory and neuropsychological test results disclosed problems with visual, verbal, and overall general memory; a significant deficit in accessing information; and the inability to develop a useful problem-solving strategy. According to Dr. Nunno, the findings indicated that underlying STUDENT’S problematic functioning is a significant neuropsychological and developmental component. He stated that the WIAT results revealed mild to severe problems in academic functioning, with the greatest dysfunctional area in writing.
Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT’S social and emotional functioning was an area of grave concern. STUDENT reported that he had difficulty sleeping and was getting a maximum of 3 to 5 hours of sleep each night. He reported that since age 10 he has been hearing voices when feeling stressed. Dr. Nunno stated that it was difficult to view the voices as those typical of schizophrenia but that given STUDENT’S history and the current assessment results, he could be experiencing warning symptoms of schizophrenia. With his biological background, his symptoms could be warning signs of the onset of juvenile bipolar disorder. Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT is at high risk for more serious symptoms because his symptoms appear to be rooted in the frontal areas of the brain, where the neurobiological dysfunction in serious mental disorders is located.
The social and emotional testing conducted by Dr. Nunno disclosed that STUDENT does not have much of an identity, feels socially anxious, and uses humor to conceal his anxiety and to express his sexual and aggressive issues. His stories and associations contained predominantly aggressive themes as well as acting out and sexual themes. He tells stories with unrealistic aspects or makes socially inappropriate comments and appears not to understand the impact on other people’s attitude toward him. According to Dr. Nunno, severely socially isolated persons may create a fantasy world full of wishful thoughts and unrealistic aspirations, suggestive of a tenuous hold on reality. He noted that this characteristic may suggest the existence or emergence of a more psychotic disorder. The Rorschach results showed poor reality testing, significant measures of thought disorder, high egocentricity, and strong depressive features. Social isolation measures were at the cusp of significance. Aggressive and sexual contexts were again present. On the Millon Adolescent Clinical Inventory, STUDENT’S profile was characterized by impulsive hostility, oppositional behavior, and an angry mistrust of others, with depressive feelings. He reported strong feelings of peer rejection and harbors resentment that may be unleashed in impulsive acts. Although he may initially present an affable facade, he is very troubled and appears to be sliding downhill quickly and may be manifesting symptoms of a more serious affective disorder.
Dr. Nunno diagnosed PDD, NOS, with prominent Asperger’s symptoms (social failure and sexual preoccupation); dysthymic disorder, chronic and severe; ADD; cognitive disorder, NOS, immediate and short-term memory dysfunction; disorder of written expression; and also an avoidant, passive-aggressive personality with narcissistic features. Dr. Nunno recommended residential treatment to address STUDENT’S pervasive emotional and social problems and potential further loss of adaptive functioning. Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT needed a full-time placement, with constant supervision, that offered academic challenges; therapeutic tolerance; individual, group, and milieu treatment; and social skills training in a setting that resembled more a residential school than a “treatment program.” Dr. Nunno stated that constant supervision was necessary because, although STUDENT’S preoccupation with aggression and sexual material had not yet manifested in overt acts, he may be less able to control himself as he matures, particularly if his psychiatric condition deteriorates. Dr. Nunno stated that STUDENT likely would not be able to complete high school unless placed in a supervised school and treatment environment, with one-to-one small group instruction. Moreover, STUDENT required individual counseling and medication, as appropriate.
On November 27, 2000, the Hearing Office received from the Student a due process hearing request. Issues raised were whether the District and CMH had failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE and had failed adequately to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Other issues involved reimbursement for costs incurred in obtaining private assessments and in providing him with an appropriate educational placement and compensatory education for the denial of a FAPE. A December 6, 2000 IEP Addendum was signed by the parent, who consented to services to be provided through the first week of January 2001. The parents indicated that they would unilaterally place STUDENT at a boarding school soon after January 1. A comments page states that “[a]t this point voices are preventing STUDENT from fulfilling his academic potential.” Another page indicates that the District continued to offer Braun or the Redwood SDC but would support a temporary plan to help STUDENT until he moved to his new placement. The temporary plan provided, in part, for him to be able to go to the resource room when feeling stressed or out of control, and, if he needed to “process,” to see a counselor or the school psychologist. Further, the school psychologist was to check in with him at least twice weekly.
A December 8, 2000 letter from Tamalpais HS notified the parents that STUDENT had been deemed an habitual truant. According to school policy, a student may receive a reduced grade in any class with 4 or more unexcused absences and would lose one credit in any class with 5 or more unexcused absences. The letter indicated that STUDENT had 4 unexcused absences in one class and 5 such absences in another class.
On January 17, 2001, the District filed a request for a due process hearing on the issue of whether its October 2, 2000 and November 6, 2000 IEPs offered STUDENT a FAPE. The District’s unopposed motion to consolidate its case and the Student’s case was granted.
In grade 10, STUDENT received these first-semester grades for these courses: B+ - creative learning (RSP); C - photography; D - English, world history, and P.E.; and F - algebra and science. Comments were that the credit was reduced for truancy (algebra), he had missing assignments and homework (science), and he had low or missing test scores (science and world history). His mother testified that he took the final exams before he left for Texas. His academic grade point average (GPA) was 1.21; and his total GPA, 1.19.(Footnote 5)
STUDENT’S psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin wrote a January 29, 2001 updated report. He stated that in the past few months, STUDENT had mentioned “hearing voices” when he was falling asleep. Moreover, his school work had deteriorated. Dr. Shatkin stated that Dr. Nunno’s November 2000 neuropsychological assessment findings and diagnoses, coupled with STUDENT’S admission of “hearing voices,” caused him to recommend further assessment in a psychiatric residential setting as soon as possible. According to Dr. Shatkin, STUDENT required a thorough inpatient evaluation and consideration of medication trials if appropriate.
On February 2, 2001, the parents unilaterally placed STUDENT in a residential treatment center, Oaks Treatment Center (Oaks), in Texas and later notified the District that they sought reimbursement and prospective placement by the District. On March 20, 2001, STUDENT was discharged to Hill Country Place Boarding School, a private residential school in Texas. According to a discharge summary from Oaks, STUDENT was admitted because of increasing difficulty with academic progress, work completion, organization, appropriate behavior, and attention, and inadequate social/emotional functioning and adjustment. The summary reviewed Dr. Nunno’s assessment findings and states that a psychological evaluation had been ordered. Treatment involved a 24-hour supervised therapeutic group living setting with clear behavioral limits. In addition, STUDENT received an individual educational program; individual, group, and family therapy; and individual and group rehabilitative stabilization and crisis intervention services. During his stay, he had telephone contact with his family.
The discharge summary states that initially STUDENT displayed predominantly impulsive behaviors, was somewhat oppositional and defiant with regard to rules and expectations, and was overly sensitive in interactions with staff and peers. During the course of treatment, he exhibited more control over his impulsivity, was much more cooperative in following rules and expectations, and was less sensitive to feedback from peers and staff. Upon his discharge, his diagnoses were PDD, NOS; depressive disorder, NOS; and ADHD, NOS by history. His Axis IV (psychosocial and environmental) problems were identified as conflict with family (primary support group), oppositional with authority figures, and difficulty completing school work. The summary states that he had shown moderate improvement and recommends individual, family, and group therapy. His discharge goals were to continue to develop better impulse control, complete school work, and develop improved social skills with adults and peers.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
ISSUE 1: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation by Vincent Nunno, Ph.D.?
A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational assessment of the student from a qualified specialist, at public expense, if the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the District, unless the District shows at a due process hearing that its assessment is appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b).
The appropriateness of the District’s assessment is governed by the pertinent California special education statutes, which set forth the following requirements. CMH’s assessment must meet the same requirements imposed on the District. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60020(g). Testing and assessment materials and procedures must be selected and administered so as not to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(a). Tests and other assessment materials must be provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication; must be administered by trained personnel in conformance with test instructions; and must be validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b). The pupil must be assessed in all areas of suspected disability including, where appropriate, health and development; vision, including low vision; hearing; motor abilities; language function; general ability; academic performance; self-help; orientation and mobility skills; career and vocational abilities and interests; and social and emotional status. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). The assessment shall be conducted by persons knowledgeable of the suspected disability. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Assessment materials must assess specific areas of educational need and not merely provide a single general intelligence quotient. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(c). Further, no single procedure shall be used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for a special education child. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(e). Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. The assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.
The Student asserts that the District and CMH failed to assess STUDENT appropriately by not assessing all areas of suspected disability from August 1999 through the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 6) He requests reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Nunno’s November 12, 2000 psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation. The Student’s parents would be entitled to reimbursement if they disagreed with the District’s and CMH’s assessments and the assessments conducted by the District and CMH were not appropriate.
The only assessments conducted by the District and CMH during the pertinent time period were in August 2000 and fall 2000, respectively. At the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting, following school psychologist Ms. Mostafa’s September 1, 2000 written psycho-educational evaluation report and CMH clinical psychologist Dr. Buchanan’s oral report, the IEP team, except for the parent, adopted the two assessors’ recommendations of a therapeutic SDC or day treatment placement. The parent disagreed, requesting a residential placement. CMH agreed to assess further to examine a residential placement. At a November 6, 2000 IEP meeting, following CMH’s additional assessment, the District and CMH again offered the same placements. Again the parents expressed their disagreement, stating their belief that STUDENT required a residential placement. Thus, following Ms. Mostafa’s and the two CMH assessments, the parents expressed their disagreement. The question thus is whether the District’s and CMH’s assessments were appropriate.
The District argues that Ms. Mostafa’s assessment did not need to meet the statutory requirements, including California Education Code Section 56320, because these requirements apply only to the initial assessment for special education eligibility. The District asserts that her assessment was required by California Government Code Section 7576 prior to a CMH referral.
The impetus for Ms. Mostafa’s assessment was the mother’s request for a CMH referral pursuant to AB 3632.(Footnote 7) However, when a CMH referral is made pursuant to subsection 7576(b), the prior assessment “by school personnel [must be] in accordance with Article 2 (commencing with Section 56320).” Cal. Gov’t Code § 7576(b)(1).(Footnote 8) Therefore, the assessment which is the basis for the CMH referral must have been conducted pursuant to the statutes which govern initial assessments, including Section 56320. Ms. Mostafa’s assessment report states that because a psychological evaluation had recently been completed by Ms. Minton (in May 1999), her assessment focused primarily on updating current levels of functioning in the social-emotional area. However, in the referral report requesting an AB 3632 mental health assessment, she states that her evaluation was completed to facilitate the CMH referral. Therefore, pursuant to Section 7576, Ms. Mostafa’s assessment needed to meet the statutory requirements commencing with Section 56320.(Footnote 9)
The District’s August 9, 2000 assessment plan that the parent signed provided for an assessment of social-emotional status and behavior by the school psychologist. To assess STUDENT’S social-emotional functioning, Ms. Mostafa administered the Children’s Depression Inventory, the LePage-Benson Sentence Completion Test-Secondary Version, and the Rorschach Inkblot Test. Behavior was assessed with the Achenbach Behavior Rating Scales, completed by STUDENT and his mother.
The September 2000(Footnote 10) CMH assessment plan signed by the parent provides for an assessment that might consist of classroom observation; interviews with the child, parents, and school personnel; and a review of school records. Dr. Buchanan conducted interviews with STUDENT and his mother on September 27, 2000, and gave an oral report of her assessment at the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting. Her written AB 3632 assessment report, dated November 6, 2000, indicates that the assessment consisted of interviews with STUDENT and his mother; review of the referral information packet sent by the District; Dr. Shatkin’s September 12, 2000 letter; Ms. Waring’s November 3, 2000 assessment report; and collateral conversations with Dr. Shatkin, Ms. Waring, and Meri Murphy, Ph.D., of CMH. Ms. Mostafa testified that the packet sent to CMH contained her two-page referral report and copies of the report of her August 2000 assessment, the May 2000 IEP, and the parents’ written dissent.
Subsequently, Ms. Waring conducted another AB 3632 assessment pursuant to the recommendation of the IEP team at the October 2 IEP meeting. However, no evidence was submitted of another CMH assessment plan signed by the parent, as required by law. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, §§ 60100(b)(3); 60045(b).(Footnote 11) Ms. Waring’s report indicates that her assessment consisted of interviews with STUDENT and his mother; review of prior school psychological assessments in January 1994, May 1996, May 1999, and August 2000, and Dr. Lee’s January 1992 psychological assessment; review of Dr. Shatkin’s September 2000 letter and the parents’ written response to the May 2000 IEP; and a collateral conversation with Dr. Buchanan. Because an assessment plan for her assessment is not in the record, it cannot be determined whether her assessment was in conformance with the plan. To that extent, there is insufficient evidence of the appropriateness of her assessment.
Ms. Waring did not administer, and Dr. Buchanan did not report the results of, any test instruments as part of their assessments.(Footnote 12) However, the tests and other assessment instruments that Ms. Mostafa administered are commonly used in an educational setting and were validated for the purpose for which they were used. Further, no evidence exists that the assessment materials and procedures were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory or that the tests were not administered in conformance with test instructions by Ms. Mostafa, a school psychologist with the requisite training. STUDENT was tested in his primary language. Moreover, the psychological tests, including individually administered tests of emotional functioning, were administered by Ms. Mostafa, a credentialed school psychologist. Thus, the requirements of Sections 56320(a) and (b) and 56324 were met. The District’s and CMH’s evaluations assessed STUDENT for social-emotional functioning and behavior, and no single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for him. The requirements of subsections 56320(c) and (e) were satisfied.
Ms. Mostafa and Dr. Buchanan were competent to perform the assessments, and the requirement of Section 56322 was met with regard to them. However, although no evidence was presented that Ms. Waring has not been determined by the county office to be competent to perform the assessment, it appears that she does not meet the requirement to be a mental health professional qualified to conduct a mental health assessment. The definition of a “qualified mental health professional” who may conduct a mental health assessment (as defined in Title 2, California Code of Regulations, Section 60020(g)) includes licensed practitioners such as a psychiatrist; psychologist; clinical social worker; marriage, family, and child counselor; or one who has received a waiver under Welfare and Institutions Code Section 5751.2.(Footnote 13) Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60020(j). Ms. Waring testified that she has a master’s degree in counseling and is working on a doctorate in clinical psychology but that she holds no credentials or licenses. She did not testify that she has a Section 5751.2 waiver. Thus, it appears that she lacks the requisite qualification to conduct a mental health assessment.(Footnote 14)
Moreover, the Student argues that the District and CMH failed to assess all areas of suspected disability by not assessing for a neurological impairment, ADD, and specific learning disability. The Student asserts that when Ms. Mostafa conducted her assessment, she spoke to STUDENT’S psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin, who had diagnosed multiple complex developmental disorder (MCDD), which has neurological components, and she also had the mother’s response to the May 23, 2000 IEP. Ms. Mostafa’s report notes that in a telephone conversation with Dr. Shatkin, she learned of his diagnosis of “Multiple Complex Disability [sic] Disorder,” an umbrella disorder which is not a DSM-IV diagnosis. In a September 2000 letter, Dr. Shatkin mentioned MCDD but stated that because it was not in the DSM-IV, STUDENT’S condition might be considered to be a form of PDD, NOS, a DSM-IV diagnosis. In his letter, he does not specifically mention a neurological condition or recommend a neuropsychological evaluation. As the District notes, he testified that he did not refer STUDENT for a neurological evaluation because he did not think that it was warranted. The mother’s response to the May 2000 IEP also does not mention a neurological impairment or request a neuropsychological assessment. Thus, the neuropsychological area was not an area of suspected disability when the District and CMH conducted their assessments.
The Student also argues that a learning disability, another area of suspected disability, was not assessed because of an erroneous reliance upon 1999 assessment results. He claims that Dr. Nunno’s assessment revealed a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in written expression, and he has processing deficits related to attention and memory. A May 1999 educational assessment conducted by resource specialist Ms. Searles found that STUDENT’S academic skills were commensurate with his ability and that he no longer met the SLD eligibility criteria. Moreover, in her May 1999 assessment, Ms. Minton found STUDENT’S visual-motor integration, as measured by the Bender Gestalt Test, to be adequate. The Student has provided no evidence that following the 1999 testing and prior to Dr. Nunno’s November 2000 assessment, he displayed deficits in academic achievement that would have required the District to conduct an assessment. Thus, a learning disability was not an area of suspected disability.
Finally, the Student argues that ADD was an area of suspected disability that was not assessed. The record indicates that as early as grade 3, STUDENT had difficulty attending and staying focused in class. Mr. Benson’s January 1994 and May 1996 assessment reports indicate that STUDENT had difficulty sitting still and staying focused and engaged. In her May 1999 triennial assessment report when STUDENT was in grade 8, Ms. Minton noted that his psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin had diagnosed ADD. She stated that during the assessment, STUDENT was frequently in motion and that the assessment results indicated difficulty with attention and concentration. Dr. Shatkin’s September 2000 letter mentions that early on, STUDENT displayed difficulty maintaining attention, and that from 1994 to 1998, he prescribed Imipramine in part to address this problem. When Ms. Mostafa assessed STUDENT, both his and his mother’s Achenbach responses indicated elevated scores for Attention Problems. He endorsed the statements that he had trouble concentrating or paying attention and also sitting still. In completing the CMH Clinical Assessment form on September 27, 2000, under “Psychiatric Symptoms,” Dr. Buchanan wrote, among other things, “poor attention in school.” Mr. O’Connor, STUDENT’S tenth grade RSP teacher, testified that his focus in class was a roller coaster, and on some days it was better than others. The evidence indicates that by the time STUDENT enrolled in the District in August 1999, attention was an area of suspected disability. The District’s August 2000 assessment did not assess or recommend an assessment for ADD. CMH’s two fall 2000 assessments also did not assess or recommend assessing for ADD. Because the District and CMH did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, their assessments were not appropriate.
Dr. Buchanan’s assessment report, which is dated November 6, 2000, the same date as the IEP meeting, also did not comply with State law, which requires that a copy of the mental health service assessment report be made available to the parent at least two days before the IEP meeting. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, §60045(f). Her oral report at the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting similarly did not comply with the law.
The District’s and CMH’s assessments were found to be inappropriate. Dr. Nunno assessed STUDENT for cognitive ability, memory and neuropsychological functioning, academic achievement, and social-emotional functioning. The evidence established that Dr. Nunno is a licensed clinical psychologist in California with the requisite education and training. Thus, he is a qualified specialist to conduct an independent educational assessment.(Footnote 16) Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Therefore, the Student is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Nunno’s fall 2000 psycho-educational and neuropsychological assessment.
ISSUE 2: Did the District provide the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07. The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. a. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
The Student argues that when he transferred from middle to high school, the District violated State law by failing either to have a District representative attend his June 3, 1999 IEP meeting at the middle school or to hold a subsequent IEP meeting within 30 days of his enrollment in the District for grade 9. Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(a), (b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3024(b). The mother testified that at the June 3 IEP meeting, no one present was identified as representing the high school district, and she was not told that shortly after STUDENT enrolled at Tamalpais HS, another IEP meeting would be held to discuss his ninth grade program.
The District asserts that school psychologist Ms. Minton, who attended the June 3 IEP meeting, was an MCOE employee assigned to both the elementary school district and the high school district at the time of the IEP meeting. Ms. Piotter, District director of instructional services, testified that during the 1998-1999 school year, Ms. Minton was employed by MCOE, and that the District contracted with Ms. Minton through MCOE to provide psychological services at San Andreas.(Footnote 17) The June 3 IEP provides for RSP services from May 1999 to June 1999, but does not specifically address the 1999-2000 school year. However, if an authorized high school district representative participated with the elementary school district at the IEP meeting, the IEP should have specified the appropriate high school placement. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3024(b). There is also no other IEP for the beginning of that school year. Nevertheless, without evidence to the contrary, it appears that the District implemented the June 3 IEP for the 1999-2000 school year. In any event, these matters need not be resolved in light of significant deficiencies in the June 3 IEP, discussed below.
The Student contends that the June 3 IEP fails to set forth the duration or type of proffered RSP services. The June 3 IEP merely provides for RSP services in the resource specialist room two to three times weekly. The June 3 IEP does not specify whether the RSP services were to be periodic pull-out or consultative services or an RSP class and also does not set forth the projected starting date, duration, or amount of RSP services weekly. Under federal and State law, the IEP must include a statement of the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided and, among other things, the projected starting date and duration of services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii), (vi); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3), (6). The amount of services must be stated in the IEP to ensure that the level of the District’s commitment of resources is clear to the parents, other IEP team members, and those involved in implementing the IEP. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 35 (1999). Because the above information is missing from the June 3 IEP, these requirements were not met. The District notes that the parents signed the June 3 IEP. However, given the lack of specificity regarding the projected starting date, duration, type, and amount of RSP services, the parents were not in a position to make an informed decision about the District’s offer. Thus, they were precluded from participating meaningfully in the IEP process.
Toward the end of the 1999-2000 school year, another IEP was developed on May 23, 2000. The Student asserts that the goals and objectives for the May 23 IEP were not developed at the IEP meeting because time ran out, and the mother testified that she did not see the page containing the goals and objectives until she received the evidence packet for the due process hearing. The District does not refute this testimony but merely claims that the mother was permitted to participate in the development of the May 23 IEP based upon the testimony of resource specialist Ms. McMullan that she sat next to the mother at the IEP meeting and went over the IEP with her. No District witness testified specifically that the goals and objectives were discussed at the May 23 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds the mother’s undisputed testimony to be credible. To the extent that the parents were not included in formulating appropriate goals and objectives, they were denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process.
It is concluded that the procedural violations discussed above caused prejudice to STUDENT and to that extent resulted in the denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 18)
b. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate educational program for the 1999-2000 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs, the first step is to identify his needs. The IEPs and reports of assessments and teachers up through the 1999-2000 school year establish the following. It is noted that he has exhibited essentially the same problems since the first psychological assessment when he was age 6. STUDENT has been diagnosed with an anxiety disorder and ADD. He has a weakness in short-term memory. Social-emotional testing reveals signs of disturbed thinking and poor reality testing. He does not have a cohesive sense of identity and struggles to manage his disorganized and confusing internal world. He is egocentric but has a negative self-perception and a distorted sense of self. He has difficulty perceiving and processing information from the environment and interprets the environment in an idiosyncratic way. He displays poor judgment. He lacks the ability to organize his resources to cope with daily problems and needs to develop effective problem-solving strategies. Moreover, psychological assessments, including individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning, must be administered by a credentialed school psychologist. The assessors must be trained and prepared to assess cultural and ethnic factors appropriate to the pupil being assessed. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56320(b)(3), 56324. Assessments must be conducted by persons competent to perform the assessments, as determined by the school district, county office, or special education local plan area. Cal. Educ. Code § 56322.
The Student asserts that the District and CMH failed to assess STUDENT appropriately by not assessing all areas of suspected disability from August 1999 through the 2000-2001 school year.(Footnote 6) He requests reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Nunno’s November 12, 2000 psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation. The Student’s parents would be entitled to reimbursement if they disagreed with the District’s and CMH’s assessments and the assessments conducted by the District and CMH were not appropriate.
The only assessments conducted by the District and CMH during the pertinent time period were in August 2000 and fall 2000, respectively. At the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting, following school psychologist Ms. Mostafa’s September 1, 2000 written psycho-educational evaluation report and CMH clinical psychologist Dr. Buchanan’s oral report, the IEP team, except for the parent, adopted the two assessors’ recommendations of a therapeutic SDC or day treatment placement. The parent disagreed, requesting a residential placement. CMH agreed to assess further to examine a residential placement. At a November 6, 2000 IEP meeting, following CMH’s additional assessment, the District and CMH again offered the same placements. Again the parents expressed their disagreement, stating their belief that STUDENT required a residential placement. Thus, following Ms. Mostafa’s and the two CMH assessments, the parents expressed their disagreement. The question thus is whether the District’s and CMH’s assessments were appropriate.
The District argues that Ms. Mostafa’s assessment did not need to meet the statutory requirements, including California Education Code Section 56320, because these requirements apply only to the initial assessment for special education eligibility. The District asserts that her assessment was required by California Government Code Section 7576 prior to a CMH referral.
The impetus for Ms. Mostafa’s assessment was the mother’s request for a CMH referral pursuant to AB 3632.(Footnote 7) However, when a CMH referral is made pursuant to subsection 7576(b), the prior assessment “by school personnel [must be] in accordance with Article 2 (commencing with Section 56320).” Cal. Gov’t Code § 7576(b)(1).(Footnote 8) Therefore, the assessment which is the basis for the CMH referral must have been conducted pursuant to the statutes which govern initial assessments, including Section 56320. Ms. Mostafa’s assessment report states that because a psychological evaluation had recently been completed by Ms. Minton (in May 1999), her assessment focused primarily on updating current levels of functioning in the social-emotional area. However, in the referral report requesting an AB 3632 mental health assessment, she states that her evaluation was completed to facilitate the CMH referral. Therefore, pursuant to Section 7576, Ms. Mostafa’s assessment needed to meet the statutory requirements commencing with Section 56320.(Footnote 9)
The District’s August 9, 2000 assessment plan that the parent signed provided for an assessment of social-emotional status and behavior by the school psychologist. To assess STUDENT’S social-emotional functioning, Ms. Mostafa administered the Children’s Depression Inventory, the LePage-Benson Sentence Completion Test-Secondary Version, and the Rorschach Inkblot Test. Behavior was assessed with the Achenbach Behavior Rating Scales, completed by STUDENT and his mother.
The September 2000(Footnote 10) CMH assessment plan signed by the parent provides for an assessment that might consist of classroom observation; interviews with the child, parents, and school personnel; and a review of school records. Dr. Buchanan conducted interviews with STUDENT and his mother on September 27, 2000, and gave an oral report of her assessment at the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting. Her written AB 3632 assessment report, dated November 6, 2000, indicates that the assessment consisted of interviews with STUDENT and his mother; review of the referral information packet sent by the District; Dr. Shatkin’s September 12, 2000 letter; Ms. Waring’s November 3, 2000 assessment report; and collateral conversations with Dr. Shatkin, Ms. Waring, and Meri Murphy, Ph.D., of CMH. Ms. Mostafa testified that the packet sent to CMH contained her two-page referral report and copies of the report of her August 2000 assessment, the May 2000 IEP, and the parents’ written dissent.
Subsequently, Ms. Waring conducted another AB 3632 assessment pursuant to the recommendation of the IEP team at the October 2 IEP meeting. However, no evidence was submitted of another CMH assessment plan signed by the parent, as required by law. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, §§ 60100(b)(3); 60045(b).(Footnote 11) Ms. Waring’s report indicates that her assessment consisted of interviews with STUDENT and his mother; review of prior school psychological assessments in January 1994, May 1996, May 1999, and August 2000, and Dr. Lee’s January 1992 psychological assessment; review of Dr. Shatkin’s September 2000 letter and the parents’ written response to the May 2000 IEP; and a collateral conversation with Dr. Buchanan. Because an assessment plan for her assessment is not in the record, it cannot be determined whether her assessment was in conformance with the plan. To that extent, there is insufficient evidence of the appropriateness of her assessment.
Ms. Waring did not administer, and Dr. Buchanan did not report the results of, any test instruments as part of their assessments.(Footnote 12) However, the tests and other assessment instruments that Ms. Mostafa administered are commonly used in an educational setting and were validated for the purpose for which they were used. Further, no evidence exists that the assessment materials and procedures were racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory or that the tests were not administered in conformance with test instructions by Ms. Mostafa, a school psychologist with the requisite training. STUDENT was tested in his primary language. Moreover, the psychological tests, including individually administered tests of emotional functioning, were administered by Ms. Mostafa, a credentialed school psychologist. Thus, the requirements of Sections 56320(a) and (b) and 56324 were met. The District’s and CMH’s evaluations assessed STUDENT for social-emotional functioning and behavior, and no single procedure was used as the sole criterion for determining an appropriate educational program for him. The requirements of subsections 56320(c) and (e) were satisfied.
Ms. Mostafa and Dr. Buchanan were competent to perform the assessments, and the requirement of Section 56322 was met with regard to them. However, although no evidence was presented that Ms. Waring has not been determined by the county office to be competent to perform the assessment, it appears that she does not meet the requirement to be a mental health professional qualified to conduct a mental health assessment. The definition of a “qualified mental health professional” who may conduct a mental health assessment (as defined in Title 2, California Code of Regulations, Section 60020(g)) includes licensed practitioners such as a psychiatrist; psychologist; clinical social worker; marriage, family, and child counselor; or one who has received a waiver under Welfare and Institutions Code Section 5751.2.(Footnote 13) Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60020(j). Ms. Waring testified that she has a master’s degree in counseling and is working on a doctorate in clinical psychology but that she holds no credentials or licenses. She did not testify that she has a Section 5751.2 waiver. Thus, it appears that she lacks the requisite qualification to conduct a mental health assessment.(Footnote 14)
Moreover, the Student argues that the District and CMH failed to assess all areas of suspected disability by not assessing for a neurological impairment, ADD, and specific learning disability. The Student asserts that when Ms. Mostafa conducted her assessment, she spoke to STUDENT’S psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin, who had diagnosed multiple complex developmental disorder (MCDD), which has neurological components, and she also had the mother’s response to the May 23, 2000 IEP. Ms. Mostafa’s report notes that in a telephone conversation with Dr. Shatkin, she learned of his diagnosis of “Multiple Complex Disability [sic] Disorder,” an umbrella disorder which is not a DSM-IV diagnosis. In a September 2000 letter, Dr. Shatkin mentioned MCDD but stated that because it was not in the DSM-IV, STUDENT’S condition might be considered to be a form of PDD, NOS, a DSM-IV diagnosis. In his letter, he does not specifically mention a neurological condition or recommend a neuropsychological evaluation. As the District notes, he testified that he did not refer STUDENT for a neurological evaluation because he did not think that it was warranted. The mother’s response to the May 2000 IEP also does not mention a neurological impairment or request a neuropsychological assessment. Thus, the neuropsychological area was not an area of suspected disability when the District and CMH conducted their assessments.
The Student also argues that a learning disability, another area of suspected disability, was not assessed because of an erroneous reliance upon 1999 assessment results. He claims that Dr. Nunno’s assessment revealed a significant discrepancy between ability and achievement in written expression, and he has processing deficits related to attention and memory. A May 1999 educational assessment conducted by resource specialist Ms. Searles found that STUDENT’S academic skills were commensurate with his ability and that he no longer met the SLD eligibility criteria. Moreover, in her May 1999 assessment, Ms. Minton found STUDENT’S visual-motor integration, as measured by the Bender Gestalt Test, to be adequate. The Student has provided no evidence that following the 1999 testing and prior to Dr. Nunno’s November 2000 assessment, he displayed deficits in academic achievement that would have required the District to conduct an assessment. Thus, a learning disability was not an area of suspected disability.
Finally, the Student argues that ADD was an area of suspected disability that was not assessed. The record indicates that as early as grade 3, STUDENT had difficulty attending and staying focused in class. Mr. Benson’s January 1994 and May 1996 assessment reports indicate that STUDENT had difficulty sitting still and staying focused and engaged. In her May 1999 triennial assessment report when STUDENT was in grade 8, Ms. Minton noted that his psychiatrist Dr. Shatkin had diagnosed ADD. She stated that during the assessment, STUDENT was frequently in motion and that the assessment results indicated difficulty with attention and concentration. Dr. Shatkin’s September 2000 letter mentions that early on, STUDENT displayed difficulty maintaining attention, and that from 1994 to 1998, he prescribed Imipramine in part to address this problem. When Ms. Mostafa assessed STUDENT, both his and his mother’s Achenbach responses indicated elevated scores for Attention Problems. He endorsed the statements that he had trouble concentrating or paying attention and also sitting still. In completing the CMH Clinical Assessment form on September 27, 2000, under “Psychiatric Symptoms,” Dr. Buchanan wrote, among other things, “poor attention in school.” Mr. O’Connor, STUDENT’S tenth grade RSP teacher, testified that his focus in class was a roller coaster, and on some days it was better than others. The evidence indicates that by the time STUDENT enrolled in the District in August 1999, attention was an area of suspected disability. The District’s August 2000 assessment did not assess or recommend an assessment for ADD. CMH’s two fall 2000 assessments also did not assess or recommend assessing for ADD. Because the District and CMH did not assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, their assessments were not appropriate.
Dr. Buchanan’s assessment report, which is dated November 6, 2000, the same date as the IEP meeting, also did not comply with State law, which requires that a copy of the mental health service assessment report be made available to the parent at least two days before the IEP meeting. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, §60045(f). Her oral report at the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting similarly did not comply with the law.
The District’s and CMH’s assessments were found to be inappropriate. Dr. Nunno assessed STUDENT for cognitive ability, memory and neuropsychological functioning, academic achievement, and social-emotional functioning. The evidence established that Dr. Nunno is a licensed clinical psychologist in California with the requisite education and training. Thus, he is a qualified specialist to conduct an independent educational assessment.(Footnote 16) Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b). Therefore, the Student is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of Dr. Nunno’s fall 2000 psycho-educational and neuropsychological assessment.
ISSUE 2: Did the District provide the Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 1999-2000 school year?
Under the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), as amended in 1997, and state law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. §1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A free appropriate public education is special education and related services, at no cost to the parents, that are designed to meet the student’s unique needs and are provided in conformity with the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8)(D), (25). Related services are transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services that are required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); see Cal. Educ. Code § 56303(a) (“designated instruction and services” shall be available when necessary for a student to benefit from his or her special education program).
In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA. The Court concluded that the IDEA provides such a student with a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of “access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit.” Id. at 200-01. The Court stated that the specialized educational services furnished need not maximize each child’s potential. Id. at 198-99.
In addition, the IDEA requires that the states and local educational agencies guarantee to children with disabilities and their parents certain procedural safeguards with regard to the provision of a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(a). Central among the safeguards is the process of formulating the IEP, including parental participation in the process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). The procedural rights afforded parents also include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the right to a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b).
In Rowley, the Supreme Court noted the importance of these procedural safeguards. The Court stated: “It seems to us no exaggeration to say that Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, see, e.g., §§ 1415(a)-(d), as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” 458 U.S. at 205-06. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity or seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process do constitute the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
Thus, the inquiry in determining whether a FAPE has been provided is twofold: (1) has the District complied with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) has the District offered an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07. The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. a. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards
The Student argues that when he transferred from middle to high school, the District violated State law by failing either to have a District representative attend his June 3, 1999 IEP meeting at the middle school or to hold a subsequent IEP meeting within 30 days of his enrollment in the District for grade 9. Cal. Educ. Code § 56325(a), (b); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3024(b). The mother testified that at the June 3 IEP meeting, no one present was identified as representing the high school district, and she was not told that shortly after STUDENT enrolled at Tamalpais HS, another IEP meeting would be held to discuss his ninth grade program.
The District asserts that school psychologist Ms. Minton, who attended the June 3 IEP meeting, was an MCOE employee assigned to both the elementary school district and the high school district at the time of the IEP meeting. Ms. Piotter, District director of instructional services, testified that during the 1998-1999 school year, Ms. Minton was employed by MCOE, and that the District contracted with Ms. Minton through MCOE to provide psychological services at San Andreas.(Footnote 17) The June 3 IEP provides for RSP services from May 1999 to June 1999, but does not specifically address the 1999-2000 school year. However, if an authorized high school district representative participated with the elementary school district at the IEP meeting, the IEP should have specified the appropriate high school placement. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3024(b). There is also no other IEP for the beginning of that school year. Nevertheless, without evidence to the contrary, it appears that the District implemented the June 3 IEP for the 1999-2000 school year. In any event, these matters need not be resolved in light of significant deficiencies in the June 3 IEP, discussed below.
The Student contends that the June 3 IEP fails to set forth the duration or type of proffered RSP services. The June 3 IEP merely provides for RSP services in the resource specialist room two to three times weekly. The June 3 IEP does not specify whether the RSP services were to be periodic pull-out or consultative services or an RSP class and also does not set forth the projected starting date, duration, or amount of RSP services weekly. Under federal and State law, the IEP must include a statement of the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services to be provided and, among other things, the projected starting date and duration of services. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii), (vi); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(3), (6). The amount of services must be stated in the IEP to ensure that the level of the District’s commitment of resources is clear to the parents, other IEP team members, and those involved in implementing the IEP. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 35 (1999). Because the above information is missing from the June 3 IEP, these requirements were not met. The District notes that the parents signed the June 3 IEP. However, given the lack of specificity regarding the projected starting date, duration, type, and amount of RSP services, the parents were not in a position to make an informed decision about the District’s offer. Thus, they were precluded from participating meaningfully in the IEP process.
Toward the end of the 1999-2000 school year, another IEP was developed on May 23, 2000. The Student asserts that the goals and objectives for the May 23 IEP were not developed at the IEP meeting because time ran out, and the mother testified that she did not see the page containing the goals and objectives until she received the evidence packet for the due process hearing. The District does not refute this testimony but merely claims that the mother was permitted to participate in the development of the May 23 IEP based upon the testimony of resource specialist Ms. McMullan that she sat next to the mother at the IEP meeting and went over the IEP with her. No District witness testified specifically that the goals and objectives were discussed at the May 23 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer finds the mother’s undisputed testimony to be credible. To the extent that the parents were not included in formulating appropriate goals and objectives, they were denied the opportunity to participate in the IEP process.
It is concluded that the procedural violations discussed above caused prejudice to STUDENT and to that extent resulted in the denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 18)
b. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
To determine whether the District offered STUDENT an appropriate educational program for the 1999-2000 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and (3) conformed with his IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
(1) Designed to Meet STUDENT’S Unique Needs
To determine whether the District’s proposed program for the 1999-2000 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique and individual needs, the first step is to identify his needs. The IEPs and reports of assessments and teachers up through the 1999-2000 school year establish the following. It is noted that he has exhibited essentially the same problems since the first psychological assessment when he was age 6. STUDENT has been diagnosed with an anxiety disorder and ADD. He has a weakness in short-term memory. Social-emotional testing reveals signs of disturbed thinking and poor reality testing. He does not have a cohesive sense of identity and struggles to manage his disorganized and confusing internal world. He is egocentric but has a negative self-perception and a distorted sense of self. He has difficulty perceiving and processing information from the environment and interprets the environment in an idiosyncratic way. He displays poor judgment. He lacks the ability to organize his resources to cope with daily problems and needs to develop effective problem-solving strategies. STUDENT has additional emotional and social problems. He admits to thinking about killing himself, although he would not do it. He is uncomfortable with emotions and prefers to avoid emotional situations; however, if emotions come through, he is unconcerned about modulating emotional displays. He is afraid of the emotions associated with interpersonal relations and maintains a distance from others. He is socially and emotionally immature, has poor interpersonal skills, and does not get along with other students. He is somewhat antagonistic with peers and makes sharp, caustic remarks. A danger is that he may be aggressive and controlling in relating to others rather than expose his vulnerability. For several years, he was prescribed Imipramine to treat his attention problem and depressive moods. He has had difficulty sleeping since a young age.
STUDENT’S behavior and capacity for self-control vary. He can be cooperative, compliant, and engaged and then sarcastic, arrogant, or withdrawn. He has difficulty maintaining attention, staying focused, and sitting still. He is distractible and impulsive and has difficulty maintaining goal-directed behavior. He has difficulty completing class work and homework. He also has difficulty working with other students in a group in class. When he is unable to contain his impulses, his behavior assumes a sexual or aggressive character. In conversation, he makes odd tangential or unrelated, inappropriate comments which include violent, aggressive, or morbid content. He will say things that are obviously not true.
Because of the above deficits, he needs structure and very clear expectations. He continues to need individual therapy, which he has received since approximately age 4-1/2. He needs to be refocused and requires checking for understanding. He needs to have instructions repeated or rephrased when he does not understand. These are STUDENT’S unique needs.
It is necessary to examine the IEP to determine whether the proposed program was designed to address STUDENT’S unique needs. The IEP is a written statement of the goals and objectives developed to meet the student’s unique needs and the special education and related services and supplementary aids and services that will be provided to assist the student to advance toward attaining these goals. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii), (iii).
(a) June 3, 1999 IEP
On the basis of the May 1999 triennial assessment report, the June 3, 1999 IEP team changed STUDENT’S eligibility category to ED. The Student agues that the June 3 IEP is deficient in failing to set forth STUDENT’S present levels of educational performance related to his emotional functioning, to contain goals and objectives that address all of his needs, and to set forth short-term objectives or benchmarks to assist him to meet his annual goals. These contentions will be addressed in turn.
The Student argues, in essence, that the June 3, 1999 IEP fails to meet the minimum Rowley standards because it does not set forth his present levels of emotional functioning. The IEP must set forth the student’s present levels of educational performance, including how the disability affects his involvement and progress in the regular education curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1)(i); see 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 36 (1996). The IEP team reviewed Ms. Minton’s psychological assessment report which found that STUDENT met the ED eligibility criteria. Although the IEP team changed his eligibility category to ED, as reflected in the IEP, the IEP does not contain his present levels of performance related to emotional functioning. The District’s failure in this respect violates this requirement. Moreover, other components of the IEP (such as the goals and objectives and specific special education and related services) must address the deficiencies identified by the statement of present levels of educational performance. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 36 (1996). Thus, this omission affects other parts of the IEP as well.
The June 3, 1999 IEP sets forth goals and objectives to address STUDENT’S needs related to peer relations and work completion. The peer relation objectives are designed to help him to develop social skills by learning to initiate appropriate conversational topics, demonstrate appropriate social responses, make at least one friend with whom he will initiate social contact, and show tolerance for individual differences. The work completion objectives address keeping track of assignments by recording them in a notebook, turning in long-term assignments promptly, and completing and turning in daily assignments promptly. These goals and objectives are designed to meet STUDENT’S needs in these areas as identified by the assessments and teachers’ reports.
The Student argues, however, that the goals and objectives fail to address STUDENT’S additional educational needs, such as his impulsivity, disruptiveness, tangential thought processes, inability to remain organized and focused and to work independently and in a group, and difficulty with interpersonal relations. The goals and related objectives in the June 3 IEP address peer relations, a component of group work, and work completion, which encompasses organization and independent work. However, no goals and objectives address his other needs such as his lack of focus and impulsive and disruptive behavior. Because these were ongoing identified concerns, the goals and objectives failed to address all of his needs.
The Student further argues that the goals and objectives are deficient in failing to set forth short-term objectives to assist him to meet his annual goals. The objectives lack anticipated completion target dates; thus, it appears that the projected completion dates are one year from the date the services were to begin. However, the IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii). The omission violated the statutory requirement.
The Student argues that the proposed program and related services in the June 3 IEP were not designed to meet his unique needs in that the RSP program and the accommodations were insufficient to assist him timely to complete his class and homework assignments on his own and, as discussed above, the program and related services did not address all of his needs, such as his impulsivity and disruptive behavior.
The June 3 IEP provides the following program, services, and accommodations. The IEP provides for special education for 15 percent of the time for specific skill training. The rest of the proposed program was regular education for all academic areas (language arts, social studies, math and science), physical education (P.E.), and electives. The IEP recommends RSP services in the resource specialist room two to three times weekly.(Footnote 19) A handwritten notation states that resource was recommended to provide support and to work on task completion and organization. Pamela McMullan, STUDENT’S RSP teacher at Tamalpais HS during the 1999-2000 school year, testified that he received 240 minutes of RSP services (specifically, one period of her creative learning RSP class). She testified that his RSP class was composed of 8 or 9 students from grades 9 to 12. Except for STUDENT, all of the other students had a learning disability. Besides the teacher, there was a full-time instructional aide who worked with students academically. According to Ms. McMullan, the class focused on study skills. During the first quarter, Ms. McMullan spent part of the class providing group instruction on study skills. The remainder of the class period was spent providing assistance with specific projects and homework assignments that the students needed to do. In subsequent quarters, the students worked on a library project, read a book together, and wrote an autobiography in a journal format. For 10 minutes each period, the students discussed current events. In addition, during Ms. McMullan’s preparation period, a separate period, students could be sent from their regular education classes to the resource room to make up work or to obtain additional instruction. She testified that STUDENT’S math teacher sent him to her room to do make-up work.
STUDENT’S RSP program was designed to assist STUDENT to attain his goals and objectives related to the timely completion of class work and homework assignments. It included an RSP class focused on acquiring study and other learning skills, such as doing library research, and also RSP services as necessary for his regular education classes. However, the testimony of the mother, discussed further below, indicates that STUDENT required tremendous parental assistance to complete his assignments in his other classes, and, thus, that the RSP services, while perhaps designed primarily to assist STUDENT to complete his assignments for the RSP class, were not designed to assist him to complete his assignments promptly and on his own in all of his regular education classes. To that extent, the program was not designed to meet his unique needs.
The RSP class was designed to help STUDENT to meet his goal and objectives related to developing appropriate peer relationships, through the small class setting, where inappropriate comments and social responses could be addressed as they occurred. However, as noted above, the goals and objectives failed to address all of his needs, such as his impulsivity and disruptive behavior. As discussed below, when STUDENT fell behind in his math assignments, Ms. McMullan learned from the math teacher of a behavioral problem involving another student in the math class. STUDENT also received a disciplinary warning for horseplay in P.E. Ms. McMullan testified that she did not seek information from STUDENT’S regular education teachers about any problems he had in their classes. Her testimony about STUDENT thus appears to be limited to her small RSP class.(Footnote 20)
Ms. McMullan testified that at the start of the school year, she circulated to STUDENT’S regular education teachers the accommodations page of his IEP. The June 3 IEP sets forth accommodations or modifications for all subjects, specifically, a home-school communication system related to homework, shortened assignments and homework if needed, and extra time on assignments if necessary. These accommodations and modifications were designed to assist STUDENT to complete his class work and homework. However, the mother testified that she did not know if all of the accommodations were implemented. According to her testimony, a “progress report” system was ineffectual in notifying the parents of assignments that STUDENT needed to do, and, as discussed below, the accommodations were, in fact, ineffective in assisting STUDENT to complete his class and homework assignments on his own.
(b) May 23, 2000 IEP
The annual IEP review was held on May 23, 2000, and a different IEP developed. This IEP, unsigned by the parents, contains the District’s offer for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. The Student alleges that this IEP is defective in failing to set forth his present levels of performance in the emotional area and to contain short-term objectives or benchmarks and goals and objectives and to offer a program and related services that address all of his unique needs. These contentions will be addressed in turn.
First, the Student correctly argues, in effect, that the May 23 IEP does not contain his present levels of functioning related to the emotional area, including how his disability affects his involvement and progress in the regular education curriculum. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(1)(i). This omission violates the statutory requirement. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i).
The May 23 IEP sets forth the goal to improve classroom responsibilities and time management, with the following objectives. The objective to attend each class daily and promptly addresses STUDENT’S attendance problem. The objective to keep track of homework assignments seeks to improve his organizational ability. The objective to complete and turn in homework promptly addresses his problem completing his homework. The objective to ask for assistance if needed seeks to provide him with help in class. The objective to refrain from disruptive behavior addresses his need to control his behavior. However, the Student accurately points out that the goals and objectives do not contain benchmarks or short-term objectives to assist STUDENT in reaching the annual goal and do not set forth measures to ascertain his achievement of the goals and objectives. Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a)(2); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a)(2). The statutory requirement was not met. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii).
The May 23 IEP proposes the following program and services. The IEP recommends 240 minutes weekly of direct RSP services in the “classroom.” Because the box for the classroom, not the resource room, is checked, it appears that these services were to be provided in the regular education classroom, not the resource room.
The Student argues that the goals and objectives fail to address all of his unique needs, such as his emotional problems and difficulty with interpersonal relations. He further argues that the May 23 IEP does not offer mental health services (no CMH referral or even counseling related services) to address his emotional needs.(Footnote 21) In the May 1999 triennial assessment report, Ms. Minton stated that a CMH referral was an option, and the June 1999 IEP offered a CMH referral, which the parents declined in favor of a current private therapist. As the Student notes, the District cannot fail to offer an appropriate program or services merely because it believes that the parents will reject it. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d at 1526. Because of the failure to develop goals and objectives and to offer mental health services to address STUDENT’S overriding emotional and social issues, the proposed program did not meet all of STUDENT’S unique needs.
The May 23 IEP contains accommodations, specifically, clearly defined limits, reminders of rules, supervision on computer, check for understanding/immediate feedback, use of a calculator on exams, and extended time on tests, quizzes, and exams.(Footnote 22) The accommodations related to clear limits, reminders of expectations, and computer supervision address STUDENT’S behavior problems.(Footnote 23) The accommodations regarding checking for understanding and obtaining immediate feedback address his distractibility and short-term memory deficit. The accommodations regarding using a calculator and having additional time for exams deal with his learning problems and difficulty staying on task. The IEP contains a statement of needed transition services for students age 14 and older.(Footnote 24) This statement addresses his instructional, vocational, and post-school personal living needs. The IEP also contains a behavior intervention plan. The behavior plan states that it was designed to address learning appropriate social protocol and boundaries.(Footnote 25)
In summary, the June 3, 1999 IEP did not provide STUDENT’S present levels of performance and, based upon the present levels of performance, goals and short-term objectives which addressed all of his needs. Further, based upon the mother’s testimony, the proffered program of essentially one RSP class, plus accommodations, did not meet his need for assistance with assignment completion in all of his regular education classes. Consequently, the June 3 IEP failed to address his unique needs. Moreover, the May 23, 2000 IEP similarly failed to address his unique needs by not providing his present levels of performance related to emotional functioning and by not providing goals and short-term objectives and specific special education and related services to address his emotional and social problems. It is concluded that the June 3, 1999 and May 23, 2000 IEPs failed to provide STUDENT with a program and related services that met his unique needs during the 1999-2000 school year.
(2) Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
As discussed above, the applicable IEPs contained significant deficiencies and, thus, to that extent were not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to STUDENT. Moreover, as discussed below, the IEPs, as implemented, similarly were not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Determining whether a program is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit requires a review of various measures, including, among other things, standardized test scores, teacher and staff observations, ratings on course work and tests, grade advancement, and progress on annual goals and short-term objectives.
First, a comparison of STUDENT’S scores on the WIAT in May 1999 and in September and October 2000 reveals that his scores fell on all subtests.(Footnote 26) His standard scores in May 1999 and in fall 2000, respectively, are as follows: Basic Reading, 106, 89; Mathematics Reasoning, 107, 97; Spelling, 100, 81; Reading Comprehension, 113, 100; Numerical Operations, 108, 86; Listening Comprehension, 121, 100; Written Expression, 99, 82.(Footnote 27) STUDENT was age 15 years, 4 months, at the time of the fall 2000 WIAT administration. His lowest age-equivalent scores were for written expression (9 years, 6 months); spelling (11 years, 0 months); basic reading (11 years, 9 months); and numerical operations (12 years, 3 months).
STUDENT received four D’s in the first semester but only one D in the second semester. He received the following first-semester grades: A- for creative learning (RSP); C’s for geography/cultures and math; and D’s for English, P.E., computer literacy, and art exploration. He obtained the following second-semester grades: A for computer application/graphics; B’s for social issues, English, and RSP; C’s for math and photography; and D for P.E. Except for disciplinary warnings related to horseplay during class and not dressing for P.E., no other evidence was presented as to his problems in P.E. which resulted in D’s for both semesters.
Ms. McMullan testified that STUDENT was engaged and focused on his work in her small class, with individual attention provided as necessary. She noted that he needed to learn to say “please” when he needed help and also to wait his turn. With redirection, he was able to do so. With regard to his IEP goal to develop appropriate peer relationships, she gave the following testimony related to the objectives (set forth in parentheses): (1) (Initiate appropriate conversational topics) - The class culture was respectful; in class he was attentive and said nothing inappropriate or bizarre; (2) (Show appropriate social responses) - She did not see any lashing out or put downs; (3) (Make at least one friend) - She thought that he had at least one friend, another student with whom he came to her classroom during lunch; (4) (Show tolerance for individual differences) - She did not recall any intolerant comments.
However, Ms. McMullan testified that she drafted the behavior intervention plan set forth in the May 23, 2000 IEP. According to her, she drafted the plan essentially as a cautionary measure because STUDENT had exhibited behavioral problems in middle school. Nevertheless, she testified that one of the inappropriate behaviors addressed by the plan, inappropriate interaction with classmates, was based upon information that she received from the math teacher that the reason STUDENT was sent to the resource room to work on math assignments was because of another student in the math class who was distracting him. She further testified that she herself never observed STUDENT having any inappropriate interactions with classmates and that she never sought information from his regular education teachers as to whether he had problems with positive peer relations or with appropriate conversational topics. She did, however, acknowledge that STUDENT had a problem with fabrication (for example, he falsely told her that he had erased telephone messages that Ms. McMullan had left for his parent), another inappropriate behavior addressed in the behavior plan that she drafted.
As for the goal to complete class work and homework assignments promptly, Ms. McMullan testified as follows regarding the objectives (set forth in parentheses): (1) (Keep track of assignments) - He maintained a weekly to do list in her room; also, she or the aide would ask him what he needed to do on a given day; (2) (Turn in long-term projects promptly) - He worked on them because they involved working on the computer (which he liked to do); (3) (Turn in daily assignments promptly) - He worked on daily math assignments in the resource room. It is noted that regarding the last two objectives, Ms. McMullan’s testimony did not indicate that STUDENT turned in long-term and daily assignments promptly, as called for by the objectives.
The Student contends that not until well into the semester did the parents become aware that STUDENT was not turning in class assignments and was in danger of failing his courses. Thus, he argues, he did not meet the goal of turning in work on time. The teachers’ comments on his first-semester report card indicate that he had late or missing assignments and homework, low or missing test scores, and inconsistent effort in his English class. In his art class, he also had late or missing assignments and homework, and displayed poor use of class time. The mother testified that when the parents received the progress report before the Christmas break indicating that STUDENT was in danger of failing his classes, the parents again, as they had in the past, embarked upon a massive effort to assist him with his assignments.(Footnote 28) The mother found out from STUDENT’S teachers what assignments he needed to do. She testified that during the Christmas break and the spring semester, the parents spent much time, including weekends, helping STUDENT to complete his assignments and making him revise his work.
Ms. McMullan testified that toward the end of the school year, she became aware that STUDENT was not completing his assignments in math and photography. She testified that if he did not get caught up with his math assignments, he was not going to pass the class. However, she and his math teacher devised a system for ensuring that when STUDENT left his math class to obtain assistance in the resource room, he actually went there instead of to the computer lab. He was thus able to complete his math assignments and received a C in the course. As for his photography class, Ms. McMullan testified that he fell behind in his assignments, but he apparently completed them, possibly with his mother’s help. His mother testified that she took action to ensure that he completed his photography class assignments. Thus, with assignment completion support, he was also able to obtain a C in this class. However, to the extent that his goal and objectives were to turn in class assignments on time, they were not met in relation to his math and photography classes.
The Student further argues that the goals and objectives in the May 23, 2000 IEP are virtually identical to the goals and objectives in the June 3, 1999 IEP, indicating that he received little educational benefit from his program. The similarity in the objectives in the 1999 and 2000 IEPs to keep track of assignments and to complete and turn in assignments promptly indicates that these were areas of need that were not ameliorated. This comparative result, coupled with Ms. McMullan’s testimony related to the ongoing problem with math and photography class assignments, supports the conclusion that STUDENT’S progress in these areas was limited.(Foonote 29)
During approximately May 2000, according to Ms. McMullan, several problems came to light regarding STUDENT’S emotional needs and behavior. As mentioned above, it became known that when his math teacher gave him passes to go to the resource room to work on his math assignments, he instead went to the computer lab. Ms. McMullan also caught him downloading pornography into his personal file on the computer in the resource room. Further, as part of the last quarter autobiography project, he wrote an essay about the inflicted death of a lizard which was “cruel,” according to Ms. McMullan, and raised a red flag. That he exhibited increased emotional and behavioral issues in school toward the end of the 1999-2000 school year indicates that the program and services were inadequate to support his progress in all areas, including nonacademic areas.
During the first semester, STUDENT received D’s in four of his classes, including English. In the second semester, his grades improved, although he required teacher intervention in his math class and extensive parent assistance in his photography and other classes to complete the assignments. Moreover, he did advance to grade 10. However, his standardized academic achievement scores showed a drop in all areas. Further, the evidence is that he did not meet his goal and objectives related to prompt work completion in all of his classes. In addition, at the end of the school year, there was an escalation in disturbing emotional and behavioral problems. Grades are not the sole measure of educational progress, particularly for a student whose eligibility category is ED. Also important is his progress in the social and emotional areas. Therefore, considering the totality of factors, it is concluded that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit on STUDENT.
(3) Conformity with IEP
Because it has been determined that the District failed to provide a program that met STUDENT’S unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, it is unnecessary to address whether the District would have provided a program in conformity with the IEP.
Based upon the foregoing, it is concluded that because the District failed to offer a program that met STUDENT’S unique needs and that was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, the District failed to provide him a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year.
ISSUE 3: Did the District and CMH provide the Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year?
As discussed above under Issue 2, the Supreme Court in Rowley set forth certain requirements for the provision of a FAPE. Thus, to determine whether the District and CMH(Footnote 30) offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, it is necessary to engage in a two-part inquiry: (1) did the District and CMH comply with the procedures set forth in the IDEA? and (2) did they offer an appropriate educational program? Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-07. The Student contends that he was denied a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds.
f. Compliance with Procedural Safeguards (a) May 23, 2000 IEP
Because the May 23, 2000 IEP was the District’s offer at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, the discussion of the procedural violation related to the May 23 IEP, set forth above under Issue 2, applies equally here. The Student also argues that during the 2000-2001 school year, the May 23 IEP was implemented without his parents’ consent. The parents did not consent to the May 23 IEP, and, in fact, wrote a six-page dissent. School psychologist Ms. Mostafa acknowledged that she received a copy of the parents’ dissent in August 2000. However, Mr. O’Connor, STUDENT’S RSP teacher, testified that in fall 2000 he worked with STUDENT on the May 23 IEP, including the accommodations. If a parent does not consent in writing to an IEP, the student shall not be required to participate in the program and services offered in the IEP. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(a). Implementing an IEP to which the parents had not consented seriously infringed upon their opportunity for meaningful participation in the IEP process. Moreover, based upon the mother’s testimony, the Student asserts that because the May 23 IEP was implemented, the accommodations in the June 3, 1999 IEP (to which the parents had consented), particularly a home-school communication system related to homework, were not carried out. Because homework completion was highly problematic for STUDENT, the failure to implement the last (June 3) IEP to which the parents had consented, which provided for a home-school communication system regarding homework, resulted in the loss of an educational opportunity. All of the above resulted in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484.
(b) October 2, 2000 IEP
After the parent requested a CMH referral, a psychological assessment by the school psychologist and a CMH mental health assessment were completed, and an IEP, unsigned by the parent, was developed on October 2, 2000. The Student argues that the District failed to make an offer of a program and services which met the requirements of Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir.), cert. denied, 512 U.S. 965 (1994). The IDEA requires that the educational agency give written prior notice to the parents when it proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of a child with a disability. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3), (c). In Union School Dist. v. Smith, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals stated that this requirement of a formal, written offer “should be enforced rigorously.” The court noted that a formal offer serves several purposes: it would alert the parents of the need to consider seriously the appropriateness of the placement, it would permit the parents to decide whether to oppose the offer or accept it with supplemental services, and in a due process hearing, the District would be better prepared to introduce relevant evidence of the appropriateness of its proffered placement. Id.
The page of the October 2 IEP setting forth the recommended program and services states that from May 2000 to May 2001, direct and consultative RSP services in the amount of 240 minutes weekly were recommended for both the regular education classroom and the resource room. However, this page also recommends CMH services in day treatment or a CMH SDC and further CMH assessment. However, no starting or ending dates are set forth. When mental health services are necessary for a special education student, the IEP must set forth the initiation, duration and frequency of the services. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60050(a)(4). The lack of information in this regard violates this requirement. The October 2 IEP addendum clarifies that the District offered the CMH SDC at Redwood and that CMH recommended day treatment or an SDC, with individual, family, group, medication monitoring, and wraparound services. This IEP thus proposes three different programs: RSP services, day treatment, or a CMH SDC.
The District may argue that the parents were well aware of the day treatment and SDC placements offered and thus were not confused by the additional offer of RSP services in the October 2 IEP. However, in rejecting day treatment and the SDC, the parents chose to have STUDENT continue in an RSP program. MCOE program manager Ms. Mates testified extensively about the RSP services (direct and consultative) offered in the October 2 IEP. She further testified that continued RSP services were offered in the October 2 IEP pending further assessment by CMH related to the parents’ request for a residential placement.
The October 2 IEP thus violates the Union School Dist. v. Smith requirement of a firm, definite offer. Without a proposed starting date, the provision of CMH services was not a firm offer. By offering three different programs, the IEP also violates the requirement of a definite offer. If the District and CMH were offering three different programs, the offer would meet the Union School District requirement only if all three programs were appropriate. However, by August 2000, school psychologist Ms. Mostafa in her psycho-educational assessment report acknowledged that RSP services no longer appeared to be adequate to meet STUDENT’S educational needs. CMH clinical psychologist Dr. Buchanan also testified that at the time of the October 2 IEP meeting, STUDENT’S current RSP placement was inadequate. Moreover, the evidence is that the RSP program, which STUDENT did in fact receive, was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. During fall 2000, he had an attendance problem and was found to be an habitual truant; according to his RSP teacher, Mr. O’Connor, STUDENT was disruptive in class; and he received three D and two F fall-semester grades. Because the District and CMH made offers of several different programs, including RSP services, and the RSP services did not provide an appropriate program for STUDENT, the result is a violation of the Union School District requirement of a firm, definite offer. If the District and CMH made offers of more than one placement, one of which was inappropriate, the parent cannot be expected to select the program that is appropriate. The result is the denial of a FAPE.
g. Substantive Appropriateness of Proposed Educational Program
During the 2000-2001 school year, three IEPs are at issue: the May 23, 2000; October 2, 2000; and November 6, 2000 IEPs.(Footnote 31) As discussed above under Issue 2, to determine whether the District and CMH offered STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, it is necessary to address whether the proposed program (1) was designed to meet his unique needs, (2) was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, (3) was in conformity with his IEP, and (4) was designed to provide all of the above in the least restrictive environment. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89.
To determine whether the proffered program for the 2000-2001 school year was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, the first step is to identify his needs. In addition to the needs set forth above, he has the following needs identified by the assessments, IEPs, school reports, and teacher observations since the 1999-2000 school year. He has been diagnosed with a multiple complex developmental disorder as well as PDD, NOS, with prominent Asperger’s symptoms; dysthymic disorder; mood disorder, NOS; and cognitive disorder, NOS (short-term memory dysfunction). He also exhibits symptoms of oppositional defiant disorder and schizophrenia. He occasionally hears voices (auditory hallucinations) when he is feeling stressed. Although he is not suicidal, he has thought about death since a friend killed himself in spring 2000. He has displayed an increased sleeping problem.
Social-emotional testing revealed that he suffers from considerable emotional stress. He continues to show poor reality testing, significant indicators of a thought disorder, and high egocentricity. He has difficulty accurately perceiving events and others’ actions and exhibits faulty judgment. Despite appearing to have an overvalued self-worth, he does not have much of an identity and has a negative self-perception. Test results revealed an impulsive hostility, oppositional behavior, and an angry mistrust of others. He blames others for his problems and harbors fantasies of retaliating against his tormentors (persons who have teased him because of his immaturity and misperceptions). He is socially anxious and isolated and uses humor to conceal his anxiety and express his sexual and aggressive issues. He tells stories or says things with unrealistic or untrue aspects. He makes inappropriate comments, sometimes with a sexual content. He needs to develop better impulse control. In class, he frequently talks and is disruptive. He displays problems in academic functioning, particularly in writing. He has problems with organization. He continues to have difficulty staying on task and completing his class work and homework. He has a school attendance problem.
Based upon his deficits, STUDENT needs a structured, predictable environment. He needs a small, structured setting providing integrated academic and therapeutic services. He needs help when he feels stressed or out of control in class. He needs on-the-spot intervention when he exhibits a distortion of reality to shape his perceptions based upon reality. He requires mental health services beyond the weekly outpatient therapy that he has been receiving from Dr. Shatkin. He requires individual, group, and family therapy and medication monitoring services. He needs to learn skills and strategies to form appropriate interpersonal relations. He needs help to organize, retrieve, and produce adequate school work. These were STUDENT’S identified needs during the 2000-2001 school year.
In addition, according to the Student’s witnesses, in particular, Dr. Shatkin and Dr. Nunno, STUDENT requires a residential placement in a controlled community of peers, with constant supervision, which provides academic instruction; therapeutic tolerance; individual, group, and milieu treatment; and social skills training. The District and CMH disagree and instead assert that all he requires is day treatment or a therapeutic SDC. The question of whether STUDENT requires a residential placement is discussed below.
Once STUDENT’S needs are identified, the next step is to determine whether the program and services proposed in STUDENT’S IEP were designed to address his unique needs, were reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, and conformed with the IEP.
(a) May 23, 2000 IEP
The May 23, 2000 IEP, discussed above under Issue 2, continued to embody the District’s offer during the initial months of the 2000-2001 school year. The discussion above related to the lack of present levels of emotional functioning and the deficiencies in the goals and objectives and the program and services offered in the May 23 IEP pertains here as well. The conclusion above, that the May 23 IEP failed to offer a program and related services that met all of his unique needs, applies equally here. Moreover, the May 23 IEP provided for RSP services. However, when District school psychologist Ms. Mostafa conducted a psychological assessment in August 2000, she concluded that RSP services no longer appeared to be adequate to meet STUDENT’S educational needs. As discussed above in relation to the Union School District v. Smith violation under “Compliance with Procedural Safeguards,” an RSP program was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit. In addition, the Student contends that Mr. O’Connor, his RSP teacher from August 2000 to January 2001, was unqualified in that he lacked an RSP certificate. A resource specialist must have a special education credential or a clinical services credential with a special class authorization, must have three or more years of both regular and special education teaching experience, and must have demonstrated the competencies for a resource specialist, as established by the Commission on Teacher Credentialing (CTC). Cal. Educ. Code § 56362(b). The CTC has established a procedure for application for a resource specialist certificate and for verification of the competencies required for such a certificate. Cal. Educ. Code § 56362.5. Mr. O’Connor testified that he has a preliminary single-subject teaching credential in social science and a provisional special education credential to teach mild to moderately disabled students in an SDC. However, he testified that he did not possess an RSP certificate and would not work on such a certificate until he had completed work on the special education credential. Thus, because he did not have a resource specialist certificate, he lacked the requisite qualification to teach an RSP class.
Based upon all of the above, it is concluded that the May 23, 2000 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, and, in light of the deficiencies in the IEP, the factor of conformity with the IEP is inapplicable. Because the May 23 IEP did not meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, the proposed program was not the LRE that would have provided him a FAPE.
(b) October 2, 2000 IEP
As noted above, on October 2, 2000, another IEP was developed. In certain sections, the October 2 IEP specifically refers to the May 23, 2000 IEP. The October 2 IEP contains no goals and objectives but instead states that the goals and objectives proposed in the May 23 IEP are to continue. Thus, the prior discussion about the deficiencies in the May 23 IEP goals and objectives applies here. Moreover, the October 2 IEP recommends CMH services. When a mental health service is necessary for a student to benefit from special education, the IEP must contain a description of the present levels of social and emotional performance and also goals and objectives of the mental health services with objective criteria and evaluative procedures to measure whether the goals and objectives are being achieved. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60050(a)(1), (2). The lack of present levels of performance and goals and objectives related to mental health services in the October 2 IEP violates this requirement.(Footnote 32)
In addition, the October 2 IEP offered RSP services in addition to the CMH SDC and day treatment. As discussed above, in fall 2000 RSP services no longer met STUDENT’S unique needs or provided educational benefit, and because one of three proffered alternative programs was inappropriate, the result was the denial of a FAPE. Consequently, the proposed program, including RSP services, was not the LRE that would have provided STUDENT a FAPE.
(c) November 6, 2000 IEP
On November 6, 2000, another IEP meeting was held following a CMH assessment by Ms. Waring related to a residential placement. It is noted that the November 6 IEP Addendum (to the May 23, 2000 IEP), like the October 2 IEP, does not set forth STUDENT’S present levels of social and emotional performance. Cal. Code Reg. tit. 2, § 60050(a)(1). Because the goals and objectives and educational program and related services must address the deficiencies identified by this information, this is a serious omission. See 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 36 (1996).
The November 6 IEP Addendum contains a goal to increase STUDENT’S mental health and related academic functioning, with objectives to (1) learn to request supportive assistance from the SDC teacher in organizing, retrieving, and producing adequate/passing school work consistent with his ability and grade level and (2) participate in individual and group therapy (as available) to gain skills and strategies necessary to form appropriate peer relationships. The first objective addresses STUDENT’S problem with organization and work completion. The second is designed to assist him to deal with his emotional and social-relation difficulties. The Student correctly asserts that there are no measurable objectives or short-term benchmarks. This omission violates the statutory requirement. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii).
The November 6 IEP proposes a placement at the CMH SDC at Redwood or Braun day treatment (Braun). Both placements are jointly run by MCOE and CMH. As discussed above, if the District and CMH offered more than one placement, both placements must be appropriate to meet the requirement of a firm, definite offer under Union School District v. Smith.
The District asserts that either Braun or the Redwood SDC would provide STUDENT with a smaller, more structured environment in which to stay organized and focused and with instruction suited to his individual learning style. Moreover, according to the District, the therapy would address his mental health needs, and the program would provide therapeutic and behavioral support to improve his social functioning.
A. Braun Day Treatment
To determine whether Braun offered a FAPE, it is necessary to consider whether the Braun placement was designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs, was reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit, and conformed with the IEP.
No one from Braun testified. However, the testimony of Dr. Buchanan and Mr. Parsons of CMH establishes the following. Braun has a total of 25 high school students and provides two SDCs (one for grades 9 to 10, and one for grades 11 to 12) of 9 to 12 students each. Besides the special education teacher, there are two instructional aides, and a therapist provides therapy and crisis intervention. The CMH services are similar to those at Redwood--approximately one hour each of individual and family therapy weekly; group therapy (boys, girls, and mixed group); and case management oversight. A psychiatrist is on-site approximately twice weekly for medication monitoring. According to Dr. Buchanan, several students received wraparound services through another agency, California Youth Services Commission (CYSC), with whom CMH collaborated. She also testified that there is a behavior program, with levels 1 to 4, and students receive points for academic and social achievements and for following through on work assignments.
The provision of individual and group therapy was designed to assist STUDENT to meet his IEP objective of learning the necessary skills to develop appropriate peer relations. The relatively small student-to-teacher/teacher aide ratio was designed to help him to attain his objective of producing adequate school work. In addition, the behavior program was calculated to assist him to meet the objective to refrain from disruptive behavior.
The Student asserts that the student population and learning environment at Braun are inappropriate for him. The mother testified that when she and the father visited Braun with Dr. Buchanan in November 2000, she saw students asleep at their desks in both of the classrooms at about 9:30 a.m. In one class, the students were watching the Discovery channel on TV as the science class for the day. She saw students wandering the hall (according to Dr. Buchanan, the students can leave class if feeling stressed), and she noted that they did not make eye contact or acknowledge visitors. Dr. Shatkin testified that he is familiar with the Braun treatment program because he worked with Braun related to two severely disturbed teens (one suffering from schizophrenia, who had a psychotic break at age 15, and another placed by a different county) about seven years ago. Dr. Shatkin met with the youths and provided therapy. He testified that many students were in drug programs and had grave problems, and he indicated that he did not believe that a place with such gravely disturbed students would be appropriate for STUDENT. Dr. Nunno also testified that a day treatment program was inappropriate for STUDENT because he should not be placed in a setting with overtly psychotic, anti-social, or drug-abusing youth. No District or CMH witness testified to the contrary. Thus, it appears that the student population did not meet STUDENT’S need for peers with whom he could develop appropriate social relations.
The Student also argues that the program at Braun is inappropriate in that the academic school day (approximately 16 hours weekly) is shorter than that of nondisabled students (approximately 22-26 hours weekly). The mother testified that a weekly class schedule that she obtained during her visit to Braun indicates that the students receive approximately 16 hours and 15 minutes of classroom instruction weekly. (Student’s Exhibit 21.) According to her, the rest of the school day (which goes from 8:15 to 3:30 p.m.) is spent on other activities such as groups, therapy, and lunch. She further testified that she called and spoke to the Braun director, who essentially confirmed the amount (approximately 16 hours) of weekly instruction. She also testified that when she visited Braun, the director told her that only 46% of the school day was spent in class; much of the rest of the day was spent in therapy groups.
District director of instructional services Ms. Piotter testified that at both Braun and Redwood, a student can earn the necessary credits to graduate within a four-year high school program. She further testified that she believed that the length of the school year for the three comprehensive high schools in the District is 180 student days. Mr. Parsons of CMH testified that the Braun academic year is 210 days, including the extended school year (ESY). Thus, for STUDENT to be able to graduate from Braun within a four-year program, he would need to attend the ESY session.
The Student argues, in essence, that the Braun program failed to meet his need for a sufficient amount of instructional time to work on his IEP goals and objectives and thus denied him a FAPE. He contends that for him to obtain the same amount of yearly instructional time as his nondisabled peers (and to be able to graduate within a four-year high school program), the ESY must be included, and he was not offered ESY services at Braun. In the May 23, 2000 IEP, the ESY section has not been completed. In the October 2, 2000 IEP, which specifically refers to the May 23 IEP in various sections, the ESY section has an indistinguishable mark in the box recommending such services. However, the numbers written on the line for the number of weeks have been crossed out, and the entire section has two diagonal lines through it, apparently indicating that this section should be disregarded. Other boxes marked in this IEP have a clearly written check mark or “x.” Upon closer scrutiny, the mark in the recommendation box may be a check mark that was crossed out. (A similar indistinguishable mark is in a box to indicate location.) In any event, since the type of setting or service, number of weeks, and frequency are not set forth, and the entire section has lines drawn through it, it appears that the October 2 IEP does not recommend ESY. Similarly, the November 6, 2000 and December 6, 2000 IEP Addendums do not recommend ESY and, in fact, do not even contain the preprinted page with the ESY section. Thus, during the 2000-2001 school year, the District and CMH did not offer STUDENT ESY services. Consequently, he was not offered the same amount of yearly instructional time as his nondisabled peers.
The California Code of Regulations provides that a student may attend a special day class for less than the regular school day of his chronological peers only when the IEP team determines that he cannot function for the length of time of a regular school day and his IEP so specifies. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3053(b)(2)(B). A reduction in the instructional schedule or in service hours does not violate the IDEA if the reduction is contemplated by the IEP and linked to valid educational goals and the child’s unique needs. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1150 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Doe v. Maher, 795 F.2d 1470, 1491 (9th Cir. 1986)).
Here, there is no indication that the IEP team determined that STUDENT was unable to function for the length of time of a regular school day, and none of the IEPs and Addendums for the 2000-2001 school year so specifies. Moreover, there is no indication that the IEPs contemplated a reduction in instructional time and that the reduction was linked to STUDENT’S unique needs and valid educational goals. Because the Braun program offered to STUDENT did not provide him with an educational program for the same amount of time as his chronological peers, to that extent the program was inappropriate.
The Student further asserts that he would need to be bused to Braun, which is not his neighborhood school, and to a comprehensive high school campus to take any regular education classes while enrolled at Braun. He notes that Mr. Parsons of CMH testified that the students refer to the bus used to transport students to and from Braun as the “tard” (for “retard”) bus. The Student contends that he would thus be socially stigmatized before his community of peers.
Dr. Shatkin testified that he thought that STUDENT felt stigmatized by being in special education and that STUDENT would suffer a stigma if he remained in the community and attended the SDC or day treatment. He had previously noted that STUDENT felt hurt that others teased him because of his oddity. With regard to the Redwood SDC, clinical psychologist Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT is extremely sensitive to being humiliated because he has not been very successful in life. If he felt that he was being singled out and identified as a special education student (by attending a special class), Dr. Nunno predicted that in a very short period of time, he would stop attending school.(Footnote 33) He would not tolerate being singled out in this way. This testimony applies equally to Braun. Dr. Buchanan of CMH testified that STUDENT was not interested in Braun, and that it would not work if the student was not willing to be engaged in Braun. An educational placement that would not work if STUDENT lacks the interest and willingness to participate in the program and that he therefore may likely stop attending does not appear reasonably calculated to bestow educational benefit.
Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Braun placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer on him educational benefit. There is no evidence that the District would not have provided a program that conformed with the IEP. However, because the Braun placement was not designed to meet STUDENT’S unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, it failed to provide a FAPE. Consequently, from October 2, 2000, the date Braun was first proposed, the District and CMH failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. Moreover, an independent basis for finding the denial of a FAPE is that, as discussed below, STUDENT required a residential placement.
B. Redwood High School CMH SDC
It is not necessary to determine whether the Redwood CMH SDC would have provided a FAPE because the Hearing Officer found, as discussed above, that Braun did not provide a FAPE. As noted above, if one of two alternative placements offered was not appropriate, the parent cannot be expected to select the appropriate placement. In addition, the Hearing Officer has determined below that STUDENT required a residential placement to obtain a FAPE. Therefore, the result is the denial of a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.
C. Residential Placement
The Hearing Officer determined above that the District and CMH denied the Student a FAPE on both procedural and substantive grounds. Because the Student has requested reimbursement for a residential placement, it is necessary to determine whether provision of a FAPE required a residential placement.
The Student argues that both of the proffered day placements are inappropriate because a residential placement is the only educational setting that will meet his needs.(Footnote 34) The District contends that a residential placement, which separates STUDENT from his home and community, is not the least restrictive environment (LRE) that he requires. Dr. Buchanan of CMH testified that if a person can benefit from services in the community, he should be served there and be separated from his family only as a last resort. In STUDENT’S case, she stated that he had not yet tried day treatment, which she thought was the LRE for him.
Special education law requires that a child be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031; Cal. Gov’t Code § 7576(a). To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities should be educated with nondisabled children. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A). In determining the LRE, consideration is to be given to ‟any potential harmful effect on the child or on the quality of services that he or she needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.552(d). “[R]esidential placement is appropriate for a disabled child if necessary for [him] to receive benefit from [his] education.”(Footnote 35) Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996).
If placement in a public or private residential program is necessary to provide special education and related services to a child with a disability, the program, including non-medical care and room and board, must be at no cost to the parents of the child.
34 C.F.R. § 300.302. To determine whether a residential placement is necessary, the IEP team shall consider whether:
A. The child’s needs can reasonably be met through any combination of nonresidential services, preventing the need for out-of-home care. B. Residential care is necessary for the child to benefit from educational services. C. Residential services are available which address the needs identified in the assessment and which will ameliorate the conditions leading to the seriously emotionally disturbed designation.
Cal. Gov’t Code § 7572.5(b).
Dr. Shatkin testified that about two years ago, when STUDENT’S attendance at a small private school did not work out, Dr. Shatkin wanted to let the parents know how disturbed STUDENT was. He talked to them about options and told them that if STUDENT had the opportunity to attend a residential school where he received intensive treatment and found acceptance, he could get better. At the time, the parents were not ready for this step. Dr. Shatkin testified that in fall 2000 during STUDENT’S second year at Tamalpais HS, he was overwhelmed and was experiencing escalating stress. He told Dr. Shatkin that he did not want to go to school, was not doing the school work, and wanted to be out of the school.(Footnote 36) Dr. Shatkin testified that STUDENT was suffering from a lack of friends and acceptance (because he was “weird,” odd, and out-of-step with his peers and felt that he was the butt of jokes). According to Dr. Shatkin, STUDENT has a problem with social reciprocity in that he misses out on cues and nuances.
Dr. Shatkin testified that STUDENT requires a full-time residential placement where certain aspects of the program would be controlled and he could find acceptance among peers who, like him, had problems and are taught to be more accepting and where there would be constant supervision to enhance his ability to behave appropriately and “not shoot off his mouth.” In such a place, he would have to deal with the staff all hours of the day and night, meet a prescribed program, and be on the campus; would be able to deal with problems that arose; would learn to live with his peers; and would avoid oppositional problems that can develop in a family. According to Dr. Shatkin, with his impulses and misperceptions, STUDENT has great needs and cannot now take care of himself.
Dr. Shatkin testified that STUDENT has difficulty with connectedness and bonding, with his parents, his grandfather who lived with the family, Dr. Shatkin, and friends. He lacks empathy (the ability to put oneself in someone else’s shoes) and has a hardhearted attitude which bothered Dr. Shatkin.(Footnote 37) Dr. Shatkin testified that when his impulsivity overrode his judgment, STUDENT acted out to get immediate needs met, and has difficulty realizing the possible consequences of his actions.(Footnote 38) He further testified that he hoped that STUDENT’S impulsivity would not lead to violence but that there was no assurance regarding the potential for violence or sexual acting out.(Footnote 39) He testified that the stresses in STUDENT’S life at school and home (demands to do chores and school work, be in Boy Scouts, relate to people properly) were ordinary stresses but that STUDENT had much greater difficulty dealing with them because of his level of functioning.
According to Dr. Shatkin, both Ms. Mostafa and Dr. Buchanan spoke to him about STUDENT’S hearing voices, particularly in school. STUDENT told him that he heard voices in school sometimes. Dr. Shatkin testified that he did not think that STUDENT was experiencing psychotic hallucinations but rather that if he heard voices, they were coming from anxiety or the fear of falling asleep.(Footnote 40) He further testified that if these were truly psychotic hallucinations, further evaluation, observation, and medication would be more appropriate in a residential setting, where the medication could be monitored.
Dr. Shatkin testified that STUDENT had no attachment to, or bonding with, the community in which he lived. He wanted to be out of his present school and to go to a residential school where he could get help. Dr. Shatkin testified that he expected him to be in the residential program for approximately 2 years (generally, the minimum amount of time for a residential program to accept a student). Dr. Nunno testified that STUDENT requires residential treatment to be able to control and direct his behavior so that he has a reasonable opportunity to be able to complete his education, without becoming more seriously disturbed than he already is.
Moreover, Dr. Shatkin testified that there was no time to first try the County programs because STUDENT needed full time residential care right now, and valuable time would be lost.(Footnote 41) In addition, he would still need to deal with home after school. Dr. Shatkin acknowledged that he did not have specific information about the wraparound services offered in the home, but he testified that he had seen persons coming into the home for one to two hours and had seen tutoring services in the home, and these would not do the job for STUDENT. He testified that a day program would not teach STUDENT how to deal with the community, school, and friends, and it might, in fact, do him in if he was at home at night and could “do his own thing.” Dr. Nunno testified that any therapeutic gains from the day treatment program would be undone when STUDENT is permitted, during the rest of the day, to act in unproductive and dysfunctional ways. Dr. Shatkin also testified that CMH services, including evaluation, treatment, and medication services, would not provide STUDENT what he needs.
Dr. Shatkin is a child psychiatrist who is a licensed physician in California and is licensed by the American Board of Psychiatry and Neurology in child psychiatry and also by the American Board of Pediatrics. He has been a clinical professor in the departments of psychiatry and pediatrics at the University of California at San Francisco School of Medicine and is now semi-retired. Since 1969 he has had a private practice in child, adolescent, and adult psychiatry. He has provided psychiatric consultation at Cowell Children’s Center and St. Vincent’s School for Boys, both of which are residential programs. At Langley Porter, he evaluated children on an out-patient basis to determine their need for residential care. At Redwood House, he performed a psychiatric diagnostic evaluation during the six weeks that children stayed there. According to him, the children generally would go to Sunnyhill and select other residential programs in the state. Dr. Shatkin testified that he provided weekly or twice weekly therapy to STUDENT for approximately 9 years and has also worked with the parents regularly during this time and up to the present. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Shatkin is a child psychiatrist with extensive experience working with children with emotional problems, including children requiring residential treatment, and, as STUDENT’S treating psychiatrist for 9 years, his opinion is entitled to great weight. The Hearing Officer also found Dr. Shatkin to be a forthright and credible witness. Dr. Nunno is a licensed psychologist who has training in neuropsychological assessment and was the neuropsychologist for Kaiser Hospital system in Oakland for 18 years. He has provided consultation to residential programs for adolescents and also to residential and day treatment programs for adults. In his clinical practice he has assessed hundreds of children related to special education eligibility and services and also has extensive experience assessing children in the autistic to schizoid spectrum. The Hearing Officer found that he was a credible witness, and, based upon his extensive experience assessing children with disabilities, finds that his opinion is entitled to substantial weight.
The testimony of Dr. Shatkin and Dr. Nunno establishes that STUDENT’S unique needs cannot reasonably be met through any combination of nonresidential mental health services, including those offered by the District and CMH; that he requires residential care to benefit from his education; and that residential services are available to address his needs and to attempt to ameliorate the problems which have caused him to fall into the category of ED children. Cal. Gov’t Code § 7572.5(b). The Hearing Officer concludes that a residential placement is necessary for STUDENT to obtain a FAPE.
In a case involving a 17-year-old student who had serious social and emotional problems (similar to STUDENT) which impaired her ability to learn, the Second Circuit Court of Appeals held that a residential treatment facility was necessary for the student to make educational progress. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Educ., 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (1997).(Footnote 42) Her clinical social worker recommended a full-time residential treatment program to “provide structured and consistent limits and expectations while providing for the development of age appropriate social skills.” Because of the student’s multi-faceted academic, social, and personal problems, the social worker believed that progress could not be achieved through outpatient means. 103 F.3d at 1117.
In the present case, as the testimony of Dr. Shatkin and Dr. Nunno establishes, since at least the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT has required a full-time residential treatment program with structured and consistent limits and expectations to assist him to learn to control and direct his behavior so that he can have an opportunity to complete his education and to learn to develop appropriate interpersonal relations. Moreover, because he requires a residential program to obtain educational benefit, a residential placement is the LRE that will provide him a FAPE. ISSUE 4: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his placement, including the cost of transportation, at the following places from February 2, 2001 to the present: C. Oaks Treatment Center, a residential treatment facility?
D. Hill Country Place, a residential school?
A hearing officer may require the District and CMH to reimburse the parent for the cost of a private school placement if the hearing officer finds that they failed to provide the child a FAPE in a timely manner prior to enrollment at the private school, and the private placement is appropriate. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(ii); 34 C.F.R. § 300.403(c); School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 370 (1985). To be appropriate, the private placement must be designed to meet the child’s unique needs and to provide him with educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 188-89. The Burlington rule does not limit reimbursement only to a private placement selected by the parent that is the “exact proper placement” under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Indep. School Dist. v. State Board of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986).
A November 18, 2000 letter from the Student’s attorney to the District and CMH stated that because the District was unwilling to provide residential treatment for STUDENT, the parents planned to place him unilaterally in an appropriate residential placement and seek reimbursement for this placement. See 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(iii)(I); Cal. Educ. Code 56176(b). A February 6, 2001 letter notified the District that the parents had unilaterally placed him in residential treatment and sought reimbursement and prospective placement from the District.
On February 2, 2001, STUDENT’S parents placed him at Oaks Treatment Center (Oaks), a residential treatment facility in Texas. He was discharged on March 20, 2001 and was placed at Hill County Place (HCP), a residential school in Austin, Texas. The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. The question is whether the unilateral placement at Oaks and HCP was appropriate under the IDEA.
(1) Oaks Treatment Center
James LeFan, Ph.D., a licensed psychologist in Texas, works at Oaks as a psychologist and therapist. He testified that STUDENT was placed in the Canyon Unit composed of 18-20 male and female adolescents aged 12 to 17. The youths in this unit are having difficulties at school and home following rules and getting along with authority figures and are in need of structure in their daily lives. They may have diagnoses such as depression, conduct disorder, oppositional defiant disorder, or bipolar disorder but no criminal history. The unit residents are placed in a behavior shaping program (based upon different colored card levels) with strict rules (for example, they must ask permission to go to the bathroom and must keep the dorm clean) to teach them to follow directions. A resident is observed and monitored at different frequency intervals by staff, who give or take away points that can be earned for privileges like playing a Nintendo game for a certain period of time. At Phase 2, Level 2, the resident is monitored once hourly. To move from Phase 1, Level 1, a resident must submit to the treatment team a petition, signed by four staff members and the school teacher, indicating why he thinks that he deserves advancement. Generally, at the Phase 2 level, a resident is discharged to a less restrictive setting. There is 24-hour nursing care provided by three shifts of nurses. A sponsor, a staff member on morning and evening shifts, was available to STUDENT from 7:00 a.m. to 11:00 p.m. for guidance and advice. The mental health associates, who conduct group therapy, maintain the structure within the unit, provide guidance, and do data collection. The therapists are licensed professional counselors. Dr. Karnik, a licensed adolescent psychiatrist, saw STUDENTonce a week to discuss any difficulties or issues. The teacher for the Canyon Unit, a special education instructor credentialed in Texas, had an instructional assistant. STUDENT also participated weekly in ROPES recreational activities, which foster team-building and the development of empathy through cooperative group activities.
Each day is very structured with groups, class instruction, and recreational activities. A dorm job (such as vacuuming the social room or cleaning the bathroom) is assigned to each resident weekly. Even lunch is structured. Only residents who have worked up to a certain behavioral card level may eat in the cafeteria; the rest eat in the unit. To go to and return from the cafeteria, the residents must line up and may not talk. The class teacher escorts the residents to the school located on the property. Class is from 12:30 to 3:30 p.m. When the residents return to the unit, they go back to their rooms. Leisure time is also supervised by the staff. During shift changes, the staff spend 30 minutes sharing information. In the evening, the parents or residents may call one another. Bed time is 8:00 p.m. until a resident has earned the privilege based on the point card system to stay up later, eventually until 9:30 or 10:00 p.m. At night, the residents are not allowed to leave their rooms without asking for permission. If a resident wants to use the bathroom, the staff must unlock the door and escort him.
When STUDENT was first admitted, Dr. Karnik conducted a mental status exam. He relied upon reports from Dr. Nunno and Dr. Shatkin and information obtained from the parents and past history. STUDENT was also evaluated by a neuropsychologist. Dr. Karnik diagnosed a developmental disorder. A discharge summary on which Dr. LeFan and Dr. Karnik collaborated sets forth information related to the justification for admission, initial assessment results, services provided during treatment, summary of response to treatment, admitting and discharge diagnoses, and post-discharge plan and goals.(Footnote 43) Dr. LeFan testified that once weekly he provided one hour each of individual therapy and also family therapy by telephone conference call with STUDENT’S parents. STUDENT also had two hours of group therapy weekly.
Dr. LeFan testified that initially, STUDENT had a lot of impulse problems and difficulty adhering to the structure and learning the rules (he would walk out of the room; would blurt out sometimes comical or sarcastic remarks in a group session; or would ask “why” about staff directives). He had difficulty fitting in: he would make insulting or sarcastic comments and his interactions were inappropriate.(Footnote 44) He also had difficulty carrying on a conversation and staying focused instead of going off on a tangent. His ROPES instructor said that initially STUDENT made inappropriate comments and it took a few weeks for him to be able to work productively with the others in a joint venture. His teacher also reported that STUDENT needed a great deal of individual help with assignments and directions; otherwise, he would start acting out.
According to Dr. LeFan, STUDENT’S behavior problems were addressed through the behavioral point card system and peer modeling. He needed to acquire at least 48 out of 60 points per day to earn the privilege to stay up later, play a Nintendo game, or participate in leisure activities. In addition, his peers, who had similar issues, followed the rules and served as peer role models and helped him to follow directions and be less impulsive. Dr. LeFan also stated that STUDENT was determined to move up the card level to show himself, his parents, and his peers (with whom he wanted to be friends) that he could do so. According to Dr. LeFan, he showed a great deal of progress in this respect. Dr. LeFan testified that after a couple of weeks at Oaks, STUDENT began to follow the rules and in group therapy was able to give new residents very good peer feedback. He also eventually could bring up his own issues in group therapy and was changed from one month before. Moreover, at first, he was very self-centered, but after a few weeks, his roommate stated that he could talk to STUDENT about things, and they got along very well. His ROPES instructor also noted that after a while, STUDENT was much more engaged in the cooperative activities. When STUDENT was discharged, he was at Phase 2, Level 2, and was cooperating and interacting well with peers and staff.
The testimony of Dr. LeFan, which the Hearing Officer finds credible and persuasive, established that Oaks met STUDENT’S need for a constantly supervised, structured environment with clear expectations. Moreover, during his approximately six-week stay, STUDENT showed progress in controlling his impulses and relating to the staff and peers. Although he previously had problems doing group work at school, he became more engaged in working with others in a group activity and, in the controlled setting of group therapy, learned to share and accept feedback and participate in the dynamics of the group. Thus, in the short time that he was there, he acquired some skills and group experience to assist him in an academic setting. He thus demonstrated educational progress in this placement. Therefore, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his academic instruction, nonmedical treatment and services, room and board, and transportation to Oaks. Ojai Unified School Dist. v. Jackson, 4 F.3d 1467 (9th Cir. 1993), cert. denied, 513 U.S. 825 (1994).
(2) Hill Country Place
Following his discharge from Oaks on March 20, 2001, STUDENT was placed by his parents at HCP. Michael LeBlanc has been the director of HCP for two years.(Footnote 45) Prior to his current position, he was a therapist at HCP from 1997 to 1999 and provided primarily group therapy and was involved in treatment and discharge plans. As HCP director, he oversees the school, treatment program, and referrals to the school as well as the hiring and training of staff. He also provides group therapy to the students three hours weekly.
HCP is an unlocked co-educational facility which had 14 students (aged 14 to 17) at the time of Mr. LeBlanc’s testimony. The students have average to high-level intellectual functioning and emotional and behavioral problems. They are not overtly psychotic or physically aggressive or assaultive and do not have a predominant substance abuse problem. The HCP program provides supervision, academics, and therapy. With the credits obtained at HCP, a student can transfer to another type of high school or graduate with a diploma and enroll in college.
The residential building is a two-story structure with the boys downstairs and girls upstairs. The staff-to-student ratio is 1 to 5. During 8-hour shifts 24 hours a day, either two or three full time staff are there. Each student is assigned a full time staff as a mentor, representative and advocate with whom the student interacts. This staff member also calls the parents weekly to give a status report.
HCP has 5 phases, with phase 1 being the introductory level. For the first 30 days, the student can have no telephone calls or visits and cannot leave the campus except for doctor’s appointments. He must be within a staff member’s view even when outside. In this phase, the student learns the routine, establishes relations, and develops trust with peers and staff. He must meet daily expectations such as being attentive in group sessions, waking on time, and participating in class. After 30 days, the student can call home about twice a week. He also can petition to move to phase 2. In the petition, the student must address how he is doing socially and academically, including completing daily chores and earning the trust of peers and staff. The student must share his self-assessment with the staff and peers and add their feedback to the petition. As the student progresses through the phases, he is permitted a later bed time. The allowance he receives for daily chores like sweeping and mopping also increases.
In phase 2, the student must show a greater level of participation and initiation related to homework and daily chores. In this phase, he is eligible for a trip to the library or a field trip. Every Friday evening there is an outing (for example, going to dinner and a movie or to the shopping mall), always with staff. The staff-to-student ratio on these outings is 1 to 8. On community outings, the student is expected to act appropriately. After a minimum of two months, a student may petition for phase 3. In phase 3, the student must show more independence in the above activities. He should require fewer reminders and less redirection. For example, during the homework period, he should do the necessary work on his own. The student should show increased maturity and act his age. In addition to the activities in phase 2, the student may stay with his family overnight if they come to visit. There is an additional outing on Saturday evening. The student is expected to show more leadership in the house and more initiative in academics and daily living (with less prompting and redirecting). After an average of about three months, a student may petition for the next phase.
In phase 4, there is a certain level of confidence and trust in the student, and he can request to go to a movie or the mall without supervision once a week. He can also obtain home passes to visit with his family twice a month. The discharge criteria are that the student has managed unsupervised time, has shown success in his daily life at the house and in academics, and is ready to move on. It takes a minimum of 9 months to go up to and through phase 4. In phase 5, the student usually has more involvement in the community. He may call a friend and is permitted two independent outings a week. He can also stay up as late as he wants.
The male and female students eat separately. Before the first group session starts at 8:45 a.m., the students should have made their beds and done their chores. From 9:30 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., they receive academic instruction. At 3:00 p.m., the students check in with the evening staff for 15-20 minutes. During down time, they may stay in their rooms or, with permission, a friend’s room. They get exercise for 1 to 1-1/2 hours. After dinner they do their evening chores, do homework for about an hour, and then have a group session for an hour. There is a computer at the house, and a math tutor downstairs. On the weekends, the students do weekend chores and have a late morning group session. They may have off-campus structured outings and down time at the house.
There is a full time special education-certified teacher and a teacher’s assistant. The teacher’s assistant is also a master’s level art therapist. In the classroom, the students use a textbook and workbook to work on lessons which are mailed to outside graders at the University of Texas, who return the work with grades or an “R” for “re-do.” A student must obtain passing grades on 10 lessons before he can take the final exam in a subject. The work is self-paced, and the teacher will sit down with a student and provide assistance as needed. A student can obtain additional time or assistance or modification of the curriculum if necessary. STUDENT’Smain problem in class is talking and requiring redirection. He has done poorly on his work, obtaining 30's to 40's (out of a possible 100) on his work, which are failing grades. The quality of his written assignments is also poor. According to Mr. LeBlanc, he needs to learn to take the time to understand the instructions and complete the work according to the instructions.
Psychiatrist Dr. Simson is at HCP once a week, sees each student at least once a month, and is on call 24 hours a day. Mr. LeBlanc leads group sessions two evenings a week. He counsels one or two students before the other students; then the students pair off and listen to one another to develop a peer level of support. Some groups are led by students with staff present. One group is specifically for adopted children. There are two parent weekends each year from Friday to Sunday.
STUDENT had petitioned to move to phase 2 the preceding week and the week of Mr. LeBlanc’s testimony, but his petition was denied both times. When a student petitions to move to the next phase, he must obtain feedback from other students. According to Mr. LeBlanc, in the morning group, none of the students supported STUDENT’S petition because he did not do what he was told to do. The specific reasons his petitions were denied are as follows. In academics, he needs to stay focused on his work and homework and take the time to understand instructions and improve his performance on his work. In social relations, he needs to work on problems related to telling exaggerated stories about things he has done which others find not believable, making sexually inappropriate comments which require redirection, and being defiant and asking “why” when asked to clean the table, for example.
According to Mr. LeBlanc, when STUDENT started, he was withdrawn and anti-social but now talks with the other youths. He still has problems with embellishing stories, making sexually inappropriate comments to the other students, and arguing and being defiant related to rules. He also acts out, with a frequency that is not appropriate for his age, video fantasy characters as a way to interact rather than engage in conversation. He lacks confidence being with his own age group. He gets feedback and redirection from the staff during the day and when he petitions to move to the next phase, he gets feedback in meetings. When redirected, he needs to learn to do what he is told without asking questions.
Mr. LeBlanc testified that the average stay at HCP is 1 to 1-1/2 years, and STUDENT will probably remain there for 1-1/2 years. He stated that he believed that HCP is the right placement for STUDENT to assist him to work on his problem with authority and following rules, to learn to concentrate in school (instead of talking and being distracted), and being comfortable with others his age without the need to engage in role-playing. Mr. LeBlanc testified that at this time, a residential program was appropriate for STUDENT because after school hours is when the inappropriate social behavior has been exhibited in the past (being withdrawn, playing video games, and accessing pornography). According to him, in a residential program, in contrast to day treatment, STUDENT was getting more supervision and redirection after school hours. The mother testified that at a May 2001 HCP parent weekend, STUDENT was blossoming socially and asked his parents to take him and his friends to the mall (the first time this had happened). Moreover, she met with his teacher, and although he was still struggling with academics, the reasons were not the previous ones that he was unmotivated, denied that he had homework, or did “slapdash” work. According to the mother, he was eager to work through the self-paced lessons but still needed to learn how to be a student, that is, to slow down and read the materials.
The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Mr. LeBlanc and the mother to be forthright and credible. According to Mr. LeBlanc, at this time, STUDENT requires a full time residential program that provides supervision and redirection to address his needs related to following rules and meeting expectations, staying focused and engaged, and interacting appropriately. Further, he now at least interacts with peers and appears to have friends and also appears to be engaged in his academic work, although he still exhibits multi-faceted deficiencies requiring continued residential placement. Because HCP has met his need for constant supervision and he has shown some progress, HCP is an appropriate placement for him. A student’s progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his disability. See Rowley, 458 U.S. at 202. Therefore, the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the costs of his tuition and fees, nonmedical treatment and services, and room and board up to the date of this decision, and for his transportation to HCP.(Footnote 46) Ojai Unified Sch. Dist. v. Jackson, 4 F.3d at 1467.
ISSUE 5: Is the Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private counseling services from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year to February 2, 2001?
When a school district denied a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to appropriate relief in light of the purpose of the IDEA. School Comm. of Burlington v. Department of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services that they obtained for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate program and services, and the services obtained by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.
The Student requests reimbursement for the cost of counseling services provided by Dr. Shatkin during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years. Neither the District nor CMH has addressed this issue in its closing brief.(Footnote 47) As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the costs related to his unilateral residential placement from February 2, 2001 to the present. However, he is also entitled to appropriate relief for the denial of a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year and during the beginning part of the 2000-2001 school year before he left for a residential placement in Texas.
The District and CMH may argue that because STUDENT’S parents declined the CMH referral in June 1999 and the offer of CMH mental health services made on October 2, 2000, they should not be reimbursed for private counseling services available free through CMH. The Student cites no authority for a parent to decline AB 3632 mental health services from a community mental health service in favor of a private therapist. The regulations provide that mental health services, including psychotherapy, “shall be provided directly or by contract at the discretion of the community mental health service.” Cal. Code Reg. tit. 2, § 60020(i). Thus, by declining the CMH referral proposed in the June 1999 IEP and the CMH mental health services offered in the October 2, 2000 IEP, the parents, in effect, waived the right to such services at the expense of the District or CMH, including reimbursement for privately acquired services. Consequently, they are not entitled to reimbursement for private counseling by Dr. Shatkin during the 1999-2000 school year until the May 23, 2000 IEP was developed.
The May 23 IEP did not offer a CMH AB 3632 referral or mental health services. As discussed above, the failure to offer a CMH referral or mental health services constituted the denial of a FAPE. Thus, from May 23, 2000, until the District and CMH offered such services in the October 2, 2000 IEP, the Student is entitled to reimbursement if the private therapy provided to STUDENT by Dr. Shatkin was appropriate. Dr. Shatkin provided individual private therapy to address STUDENT’S anxiety, depressive moods, and misperceptions and inappropriateness stemming from his mental and emotional disability. Dr. Nunno testified that the therapy provided by Dr. Shatkin helped to keep STUDENT relatively stable through the years, though at this point, STUDENT needs more than out-patient therapy. Moreover, because of the nature of STUDENT’S emotional disability, the Hearing Officer finds that he required consistent treatment that continued beyond the bounds of the regular school year. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief here is reimbursement for the cost of individual private counseling services provided to STUDENT by Dr. Shatkin from May 23, 2000 to October 2, 2000. The District has sole responsibility for the entire cost.
ISSUE 6: If the Student was denied a FAPE during the 1999-2000 and 2000-2001 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
Because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year and the District and CMH failed to provide him a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, he is entitled to appropriate relief. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i); Burlington, 471 U.S. at 369. Compensatory education is a form of equitable relief that may be awarded to help overcome lost educational opportunity. See, e.g., Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to “ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Id. at 1497. Equitable considerations are relevant in fashioning relief. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; Student W., 31 F.3d at 1496.
The Student requests compensatory education in the form of placement in a highly structured, intensively therapeutic residential facility. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for the cost of individual private therapy from Dr. Shatkin from May 23, 2000 to October 2, 2000, and for the costs related to his unilateral residential placement from February 2, 2001 to the present. However, he is also entitled to appropriate relief for the denial of a FAPE from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year up to May 23, 2000, and from October 2, 2000 until he was admitted to Oaks on February 2, 2001. Because of the denial of a FAPE during the identified periods, STUDENT exhibited serious social and behavioral problems in school, experienced difficulty completing class work, demonstrated a drop in academic achievement, and began to have an attendance problem. The Hearing Officer finds that he is entitled to compensatory education for lost educational services.
To address the denial of a FAPE from the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year up to May 23, 2000, and from October 2, 2000 to February 2, 2001, the Hearing Officer finds that one-on-one tutoring services either during his instructional time or after school hours at his residential placement is appropriate relief as compensatory education. Dr. Nunno specifically noted that STUDENT would benefit from one-to-one small group instruction. Because he has difficulty processing information, staying focused, applying study skills effectively, and organizing work, a tutor can assist him to determine and understand the academic tasks he is required to do, keep track of these tasks, formulate an effective plan to carry out these tasks, and then complete them in a timely manner. The tutor can also provide assistance in specific academic areas of need. Tutoring services shall be provided from the date of the IEP meeting called for in Item 5 of the Hearing Officer’s Order through the end of the District’s fall 2001 semester. The amount and frequency shall be determined by the IEP team, considering STUDENT’S schedule and tolerance for additional services. In determining the amount of tutoring, the IEP team shall consider that STUDENT was denied a FAPE for over one year, and remediation may take time given his multi-faceted deficits. The IEP team shall also determine the appropriate credentials for the tutor.
ORDER
6. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, the Student shall submit to the District and Community Mental Health (CMH) proof of the cost of the psycho-educational and neuropsychological evaluation by Vincent Nunno, Ph.D. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District and CMH shall reimburse the Student for the cost of the evaluation. The District and CMH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the reimbursement.
7. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, the Student shall submit to the District and CMH, for the following places, proof of the costs (during the pertinent periods between February 2, 2001 and the date of this decision) of the tuition and fees, nonmedical treatment and services, room and board, and transportation to these places: a. Oaks Treatment Center; and b. Hill County Place.
Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District and CMH shall reimburse the Student. The District and CMH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the reimbursement.
8. Within twenty calendar days of the date of this decision, the Student shall submit to the District proof of the cost of the individual counseling services provided to STUDENT by Eugene Shatkin, M.D., from May 23, 2000 to October 2, 2000. Within twenty-five calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the Student for the cost of the private counseling services.
5. Within fifteen calendar days of the date of this decision, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to develop an appropriate compensatory education plan for the Student. The Student shall be entitled to compensatory education in the form of tutoring services for a period commencing with the date of the IEP meeting and continuing until the end of the District’s fall 2001 semester. The IEP team shall determine the appropriate amount and frequency of tutoring, taking into account the denial of a FAPE for over one year and the length of time remediation will take, and considering the Student’s schedule and tolerance for additional services. The IEP team shall also determine appropriate credentials for the tutor. The District shall be solely responsible for 3/4 of the cost of the tutoring services during the above period. The District and CMH shall be jointly and severally responsible for the remaining 1/4 of the cost of the tutoring services during the above period.
6. All of the Student’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: The Student prevailed on all issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).
Dated: August 3, 2001 ____________________________________ Judy F. Hirano, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. Some of the issues have been consolidated, and the issues have been clarified and their order changed to facilitate the analysis. As an example, issues that were consolidated related to whether the District and CMH had “adequately and sufficiently assessed” the Student and whether he was entitled to reimbursement for the cost of the independent educational assessment conducted by Dr. Vincent Nunno.
2. The 1997 IDEA amendment changed the term “serious emotional disturbance” to “emotional disturbance.” See 20 U.S.C. § 1401(3)(A)(i); 34 C.F.R. § 300.7(c)(4). However, the California regulation still uses the term “serious emotional disturbance.” Calif. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3030(i).
3.The IEP page setting forth the recommended program is somewhat confusing: it shows direct RSP services for 240 minutes weekly from May 2000 to May 2001 and also CMH services, with notations of day treatment/CMH SDC and further assessment.
4. Two versions of Dr. Buchanan’s report are in the Student’s Exhibits. According to her testimony, the initial version at pages 12 to 13 was rewritten and supplanted by the final version at pages 14 to 16 because the original version did not contain goals and objectives and recommended treatment.
5. A grade transcript dated February 27, 2001 shows that STUDENT had completed 102.5 credits out of 112.5 credits attempted. His cumulative total GPA for grades 9 and 10 was 1.82; his cumulative academic GPA for grades 9 and 10 was 1.92; and his academic GPA for grade 10 was 1.17. The reason for the discrepancy from the report card in his grade 10 academic GPA is not known.
6.On the first day of hearing, the attorney for the Student clarified that the time period for the allegation of a failure to assess appropriately is from August 1999 through the 2000-2001 school year.
7. Assembly Bill (AB) 3632/882, codified at California Government Code §§ 7570-7588 as Chapter 26.5, provided for inter-agency responsibility for furnishing certain related services to children with disabilities. Legislation enacted in 1996 (AB 2726) amended or added provisions of this chapter. The commonly used term “AB 3632" will be used to refer to mental health services under this chapter.
8.The District asserts that the CMH referral was made pursuant to subsection 7576(b). However, even a referral made pursuant to subsection 7576(d) must be based on assessments “performed pursuant to Section 56320.” Cal. Educ. Code §7576(d).
9. California Education Code Section 56324(a) provides that any psychological assessment shall be made in accordance with Section 56320
10.The mother testified that she signed September 5, 2000 and September 15, 2000 assessment plans and returned both to Dr. Buchanan. The record contains two September 2000 CMH assessment plans, one clearly dated September 15, 2000 and the other with an unclear date. Both were stamped that they were received on September 19, 2000.
11. If the community mental health service or local education agency determines that an additional mental health assessment is necessary, the two agencies shall proceed in accordance with Sections 60040 and 60045. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60100(b)(3). When a mental health assessment is determined to be necessary, a mental health assessment plan shall be developed and provided, with a consent form, to the parent within 15 days. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60045(b). A mental health assessment plan must meet the requirements of California Education Code Section 56321. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60020(h). No assessment shall be conducted without the parent’s prior written consent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56321(c). Although the mother signed two assessment plans, both were dated September 2000, before the October 2, 2000 IEP team recommendation for a further CMH assessment.
12. On October 6 and 7, 2000, Dr. Buchanan had STUDENT and his mother complete the Achenbach Youth Self-Report (YSR) form and Child Behavior Checklist (CBCL), respectively, and she had STUDENT’s mother complete the Family Empowerment Scale. (Student’s Exhibit 2 at 24-27). However, her assessment report does not mention these rating scales. She testified that because STUDENT gave the maximum rating to the item “Hear sounds” in the category of Thought Problems on the self-report form, she questioned him about hearing voices before the next IEP meeting. Her impression, based upon the inquiry, was that on occasion, he truly heard auditory voices, and that this had been occurring for a number of years.
13. The definition of “qualified” is that “a person has met federal and state certification, licensing, registration, or other comparable requirements which apply to the area in which he or she is providing special education or related services . . . and adheres to the standards of professional practice established in federal and state law or regulation, including . . . the California Business and Professions Code.” Cal. Code Regs. tit. 2, § 60010(r).
14.Ms. Waring testified that probably the reason why she was selected to do the assessment for residential placement is that she has a “strong bias against resident placement” which has nothing to do with the law but is based upon her professional view regarding the mental health of children. She later stated that her bias is for families to stay together. It is noted that STUDENTwas entitled to an assessor who would conduct an objective assessment of his needs without a predisposed bias.
15. Ms. Mostafa administered the Achenbach to assess STUDENT’s behavior pursuant to the August 2000 assessment plan. The assessment plan does not mention attention or ADD as an area to be assessed, and her assessment report neither identifies this as an area of need nor indicates how this deficit might affect his classroom performance or be addressed in the classroom.
16. It does not appear that any regulations define a qualified specialist. However, Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, Section 3001(y) defines “qualified” in the same way that Title 2, Section 60010(r) does, as set forth above.
17. The record is not clear as to what relationship, if any, San Andreas had to Tamalpais HS.
18. The Student has alleged other procedural violations. However, in light of the determination above and below that he was denied a FAPE both procedurally and substantively during the 1999-2000 school year, these additional matters need not be addressed.
19. The IEP also provides for CMH services as an option available to the parents, with the notation that STUDENTwas then working with a private therapist.
20. Ms. McMullan’s testimony reveals that a statement in the May 23 IEP which appears to be the statement of the IEP team is, in fact, a reflection of her own personal experience only. The statement is that a behavioral impediment to learning had “not been observed” since STUDENTbegan attending Tamalpais HS. This statement apparently refers to Ms. McMullan only, since her testimony was that the math teacher reported a behavioral problem which necessitated sending STUDENTout of the class to the resource room. However, the Hearing Officer notes that statements in the IEP purporting to reflect the observations or conclusions of the IEP team should not reflect the literal experience of only Ms. McMullan, the person writing out the IEP, and thus give an inaccurate picture of the student, particularly when her testimony was that at the time of the IEP meeting, she already knew about STUDENT’S behavioral problem in his math class. This discrepancy raises a question about her accuracy or candor.
21. The mother testified that at the time of the May 23, 2000 IEP meeting, a Tamalpais HS administrator and counselor expressed great concern about STUDENT’Semotional functioning and requested permission to contact his psychiatrist, Dr. Shatkin. According to the mother, during the spring, a student that STUDENT knew hanged himself, and STUDENT took it very hard and obtained grief counseling. His conversations and essays appeared to be fixated on death and violence (including a detailed essay he wrote about shooting lizards with a BB gun, which his RSP teacher Ms. McMullan found to raise a red flag). The Tamalpais HS administrator asked the mother if it was likely that STUDENT might “snap.” The mother testified that she did not think that he would be violent against others. She also testified that she did not think that he was suicidal, but she kept a close eye on him because he is a follower and open to suggestions. She further testified, however, that the District did not offer any counseling services or a CMH referral at the IEP meeting.
22. The IEP also states that STUDENT would not be able to attain the District’s regular proficiency standards without accommodations (flexible setting, extended time, and use of a calculator).
23.The IEP states that STUDENT would be denied Internet access because he had downloaded inappropriate material to his personal file.
24. Relying upon Yankton School Dist. v. Schramm, 900 F.Supp 1182 (D.S.D. 1995), the Student argues that the transition plan is inadequate. Schramm is inapposite in that it dealt with a 17-year-old student entitled to an appropriate statement of needed transition services required for each student beginning at age 16. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(b)(2). Because STUDENT was age 15 on May 23, 2000, he was entitled to a statement of transition service needs focusing on courses of study. 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(b)(1). This statement must address the student’s need for instruction that will assist him to prepare for transition. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 11 (1999). The reference to the Sophomore Career Search unit, completion of career assessments, and exploration of post-secondary training options appears to be adequate in this regard.
25. The Student’s argument that the behavior intervention plan improperly was not based upon a functional assessment analysis (FAA) lacks merit. There is no indication that the IEP team had determined that STUDENTdisplayed severe behavior problems (i.e., self-injurious, assaultive, causing serious property damage, or other pervasive and maladaptive severe behavior problems) that significantly interfered with implementation of his IEP and, thus, that an FAA-based behavior intervention plan was warranted. Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5 § 3001(f), (aa).
26.No academic achievement scores for May 2000 are in the record. The August 2000 psycho-educational assessment addressed social-emotional functioning and behavior, not academic achievement.
27. No Oral Expression subtest score was given for May 1999. The May 1999 test results show only percentile, not age-equivalent, scores.
28. The mother testified that during middle school, the parents expended much time assisting STUDENT with his homework. According to her, because he was easily distracted, he would take four to five hours to do homework that should have taken two to three hours. She testified that when his eighth grade teachers said that the parents were overprotective and should let STUDENT fail if necessary, she “pulled back,” but he could not do the work. She testified that the parents continued to help him with his homework because they did not want him to have to repeat eighth grade.
29.The Student also argues that a comparison of the goals and objectives in the June 3, 1999 IEP with the goals in his May 27, 1997 IEP reveals that he made little progress in these areas. However, this argument goes to the appropriateness of the educational programs in the 1997-1998 and 1998-1999 school years, which are not at issue in this hearing.
30. CMH first became a member of STUDENT’S IEP team at the October 2, 2000 IEP meeting, following CMH’s initial assessment by Dr. Buchanan. Thus, its responsibility for providing STUDENT a FAPE commenced on October 2, 2000. For purposes of practicality, in the discussion of issues related to the 2000-2001 school year, both parties are collectively referred to as the “District,” unless CMH specifically has raised an argument or made an assertion that is unique to itself. In certain instances, only the District itself is in fact referred to, and this should be apparent from the context.
31.The December 6, 2000 IEP Addendum, signed by the parent, which provided for a temporary plan through the first week in January 2001 to deal with emotional problems that might arise during the course of the school day, is not in dispute.
32. The Student correctly argues that the October 2 IEP does not provide an appropriate program and related services because transportation services were not offered, although he would require transportation to get to Redwood or Braun since neither is his neighborhood school. 34 C.F.R. 300.24(b)(15). To that extent, the program was not appropriate.
33. It is noted that in fall 2000 STUDENT already had an attendance problem and was declared an habitual truant by Tamalpais HS, with the possibility of a School Attendance Review Board referral.
34. The District contends that STUDENT does not require a residential placement because he has never presented a discipline problem at school or acted out aggressively or violently at home or at school, is not a substance abuser, and has never come in contact with the juvenile justice system. Dr. Buchanan of CMH testified that STUDENT did not require a residential placement because he was not a danger to himself or others. She also testified that a person who is hearing voices needs to be hospitalized only if he is totally unable to concentrate, is delusional, displays behavior that is profoundly affected by the voices, and particularly if he is a danger to self and others. The only other condition that she acknowledged would warrant a residential placement is when a child’s family situation is chaotic, and then Child Protective Services would be involved. She added, however, that STUDENT was in a caring, supportive home. The danger-to-self-and-others standard which Dr. Buchanan testified was the primary basis for placing a child in residential placement is essentially the statutory basis for placing a person involuntarily in a psychiatric facility for 72 hours of treatment and evaluation. Cal. Welf. & Inst. Code § 5150. However, neither the District nor CMH has provided authority that this standard or any of the other asserted factors (disciplinary record, substance abuse, or contact with the juvenile justice system) is a requirement for a residential placement under the IDEA.
35. Each special education local plan area is required to ensure that a full continuum of program options (including regular education; resource specialist program; designated instruction and services; special classes and centers; nonpublic, nonsectarian schools; State special schools; instruction in settings other than classrooms; and instruction in the home, hospital, and other institutions) is available to meet the needs of students with disabilities. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56360, 56361.
36. Dr. Shatkin testified that from an early age, STUDENT could not bring home and turn in homework and could not keep up in school. Dr. Shatkin saw throughout the 9 years of therapy sessions that STUDENT had misperceptions of what was expected, could not remember and retain what teachers and his parents expected, and could not follow through. According to Dr. Shatkin, the expectations were not too high, but based upon his level of functioning, STUDENT was unable to handle them.
37. More than once, STUDENT told Dr. Shatkin that his adoptive parents were not his parents but had adopted him and just took care of him. He would talk about getting money when his grandfather died and about getting money from or fooling his parents. When, in an impulsive act, he crashed his father’s expensive remote-controlled glider although he knew he had no right to use it, he felt no guilt.
38. Besides the glider incident, as an adolescent STUDENT also shot water into an expensive Coca Cola vending machine, causing damage.
39. According to Dr. Shatkin, STUDENT engaged in much talk about sex and body parts. Moreover, he blamed others and had fantasies, but he would “blow hard” and then come down to a more normal level. Dr. Shatkin testified that when provoked during their sessions, STUDENT had called him a creep or said he was not cool but was never violent verbally or physically.
40. Dr. Shatkin testified that he attributed STUDENT’s difficulty falling asleep (staying awake for four hours before falling asleep) to fear and anxiety.
41. A child need not spend time in an educational program which is likely to be inadequate and to hinder his progress merely because it is a less restrictive environment. Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1501 (9th Cir. 1996).
42. Like STUDENT, the student had been enrolled in special education from a young age. She had average intelligence and suffered from an inability to interact with others; distractibility; “terrifying feelings of anger, fear, and sadness”; a disinhibition of impulses; loss of contact with reality; confused thought processes; and oppositional defiant behavior. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Educ., 103 F.3d at 1114, 1117.
43. The District objected to admission of the discharge summary on grounds of hearsay (Dr. Karnik, who signed the summary along with Dr. LeFan, was not testifying), relevance (the summary related to information after the District’s offer of placement), and the lack of opportunity for District and CMH witnesses to testify about this document. The attorney for the Student stated that the document had been served at least 5 business days before the reconvened hearing and that the formal rules of evidence do not apply in a due process hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(7); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b). The Hearing Officer ruled that the document would be admitted. The Hearing Officer stated that although hearsay by itself generally may not support a finding, it may be used to supplement other evidence. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(b). Moreover, the document was relevant to the issue of reimbursement for the unilateral placement. Finally, the District and CMH would have the opportunity to present their cases and have experts testify.
44. Dr. LeFan testified that PDD is accompanied by a structural abnormality like a frontal lobe impairment and is characterized by impaired social interaction and communication skills. Also, an individual with PDD has difficulty controlling impulses and processing and accessing information. He cannot tolerate ambiguity but does well when things are spelled out. Dr. LeFan said that this was true of STUDENT.
45. Mr. LeBlanc has a master’s degree in social work and is a licensed social worker. From 1989 to 1991, he was a therapist at Oaks. From 1991 to 1997, he had a part-time private practice providing individual therapy to adults and periodic group therapy to adolescents and children. Prior to that, he was a therapist with the Devereaux Foundation, which is similar to Oaks. At one time he was a full time child care administrator at a residential treatment center.
46. It is undisputed that neither Oaks nor HCP is certified by the State of California; however, the lack of certification is not a bar to reimbursement for a unilateral placement by the parents if the placement is otherwise appropriate. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993).
47. This issue was raised by the Student’s supplemental issue statement received by the Hearing Office on March 2, 2001. It was reviewed by the Hearing Officer along with the Student’s other issues on the first day of hearing, and neither the District nor CMH raised an objection. Therefore, any objections are deemed to have been waived.
