California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · May 25, 2004

Student v. San Diego Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 209-04 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

San Diego Unified need not provide a one-to-one nurse but denied FAPE with a vague offer; $1,300 reimbursement ordered.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 3 issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A six-year-old first grader, eligible under orthopedic impairment, attended a special day class for medically fragile students at San Diego Unified's Field Elementary School. At school he needs frequent suctioning of oral secretions, seizure care, tube feeding, and nebulizer treatments. After a trial with a one-to-one nurse, the District decided at a November 5, 2003 IEP meeting to end nursing services on January 1, 2004 and rely on classroom staff. His mother represented him and filed for hearing after the nurse was removed without her consent.

The Hearing Officer found the student does not need a full-time one-to-one nurse. California law allows trained school staff supervised by a nurse to perform suctioning. The District's medical consultant, Dr. Howard Taras, testified persuasively that a dedicated, trained special education technician with a full-time nurse on campus would be safe. But the District still denied a FAPE. The IEP did not say what would replace the nurse. It named no dedicated one-to-one technician and included no care plan or transition plan for staff training. The vague offer seriously impaired the mother's participation. The District also ended the service without consent instead of filing for hearing. It was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 10 school days to make a specific offer and adopt care and transition plans. It must keep the one-to-one nurse until the transition is complete and reimburse up to $1,300 for private nursing.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated health services for a medically fragile student. Trained aides supervised by a nurse could replace a one-to-one nurse. But the IEP had to spell out the staffing, the care plan, and a transition plan. A district also could not end a service without parent consent and without first filing for hearing.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I. Does Student require a full-time one-to-one nurse at school to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs and thereby receive a FAPE?

    Student's suctioning, seizure, G-tube and nebulizer needs can be safely met by a trained, dedicated one-to-one special education technician supervised by a full-time school nurse; a one-to-one nurse is not required (Educ. Code § 49423.5).

  2. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II. Did the District offer Student appropriate services to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs before it terminated his one-to-one nursing services on January 1, 2004?

    The November 5, 2003 IEP offered no specific health services to replace the nurse (no dedicated aide, care plan, or transition plan), seriously impairing parent participation, and the District ended services without consent; this denied a FAPE procedurally and substantively.

  3. Issue III. Must the District reimburse Student's mother for the cost of private nursing services she incurred in January 2004?

    Because the District denied a FAPE by ending nursing services without consent or a clear replacement offer, the mother is entitled to reimbursement of up to $1,300 for private nursing in January 2004.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 10 school days of the decision, convene an IEP meeting to (a) offer related school health services including a dedicated one-to-one special education technician and a full-time school nurse on site; (b) amend or prepare and adopt a care plan of specific continuing specialized physical health care services with appropriate implementation guidelines; (c) prepare and adopt a transition plan setting a time to complete training and certify competence of the one-to-one technician and substitute technicians.
  • Order to provide or change services. District shall continue to provide a one-to-one nurse through the end of the transition period identified by the IEP team.
  • Reimbursement. Within 10 school days of receiving an invoice showing payment, reimburse the mother for January 2004 private nursing services, up to $1,300.

Total: $1,300 ordered

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Cedar Rapids Community School Dist. v. Garrett F.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Adams v. Oregon; Clyde K. v. Puyallup; Burlington; Cal. Educ. Code § 49423.5; Cal. Educ. Code § 56346; 5 C.C.R. § 3051.12

People named in the decision

  • Jennifer Hunt, special day class teacher, Field Elementary School, San Diego Unified
  • Ruthann Schroeder, special education technician, Field Elementary School, San Diego Unified
  • Carole Phillips, school nurse, Field Elementary School, San Diego Unified
  • Dr. Howard Taras, District medical consultant (pediatrician), witness for District, San Diego Unified School District; UC San Diego
  • Nancy Duncan, special education itinerant nurse, San Diego Unified School District
  • Lisa Turner, registered nurse and Special Care Center case manager, witness for Student, Special Care Center
  • Todd Lordson, Regional Center case manager, witness for Student, San Diego Regional Center
  • Doreen Casuto, independent case manager and registered nurse, witness for Student
  • Dr. Sung Min Park, treating pulmonary specialist, Pulmonary Clinic, Children's Hospital and Health Center
  • Patsy Hartman, clinical director (letter author; did not testify), Special Care Center
  • Special Care Center / Special Care School, private pediatric day health care provider and licensed preschool/kindergarten; source of one-to-one nurses
  • Maxim Healthcare Services, private nursing agency

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter convened for hearing before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in San Diego, California, on April 22, 23, and 29, 2004. On April 30, 2004, the hearing was convened by telephone to accommodate a witness and for oral closing arguments.

STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented throughout the hearing by his mother, STUDENT’S MOTHER. San Diego Unified School District (Respondent or District) was represented by its attorney, Amy Bozone.

Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify on his behalf: his mother; Lisa Turner, registered nurse (RN) and STUDENT’s Special Care Center case manager; Todd Lordson, STUDENT’s San Diego Regional Center case manager; and Doreen Casuto, STUDENT’s independent case manager and registered nurse, who testified by telephone.

Respondent called the following witnesses from its Field Elementary School (Field) to testify on its behalf: Jennifer Hunt, STUDENT’s current special day class teacher; Ruthann Schroeder, special education technician; and Carole Phillips, school nurse. The District also called its medical consultant, Dr. Howard Taras, as a witness.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. Following oral closing arguments on April 30, 2004, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision.

ISSUES (Footnote 1)

I. Does STUDENT require a full-time one-to-one nurse at school to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs and thereby receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

II. Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate services to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs before it terminated his one-to-one nursing services on January 1, 2004?

III. Must the District reimburse STUDENT’s MOTHER for the cost of the private nursing services she incurred in January 2004?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner contends that he is a medically fragile child who requires constant monitoring and frequent suctioning of his oral secretions by a one-to-one nurse to safely participate in his school program at the District’s Field Elementary School (Field). In Petitioner’s view, the District has provided him with a one-to-one nurse in the past and there has been no change in his physical condition to justify terminating his nursing services. Petitioner contends that the existing staff in his special day class at Field are not nurses and are therefore not qualified to provide for his suctioning care and to monitor his frequent seizures. In addition, Petitioner asserts that because his classroom staff at Field is responsible for the needs of multiple medically fragile students, he will not receive one-to-one monitoring and the prompt suctioning necessary to decrease the risk of seizures. Petitioner asserts that, although the District is currently providing one-to-one nursing services to him pursuant to stay put, his mother incurred approximately $1,300.00 in expenses for a private nurse in early January 2004 and should be reimbursed for these services. Petitioner does not dispute any other component of the educational program offered to him by the District.

The District contends that STUDENT can safely attend its Field Elementary School and receive a free appropriate public education without a full time one-to-one nurse. The District contends that it offered STUDENT a FAPE at the November 5, 2003 IEP team meeting when it decided to terminate his one-to-one nurse effective January 2004 and to replace his nurse service with its special education staff. The District asserts that Field has a full-time school nurse who is frequently in STUDENT’s classroom and who can reach his room within a minute. In addition, the District argues that STUDENT is placed in a very small class with an experienced special education teacher and three special education technicians who are qualified to perform the suctioning he requires under the supervision of the school nurse. The District notes that it initially offered STUDENT a one-to-one nurse at the recommendation of its school doctor, Dr. Taras, on a trial basis to review the stability of his health care needs at school. The District contends that, after reviewing the records of STUDENT’s nurses documenting his physical health care needs at school, Dr. Taras determined that STUDENT’s medical condition was stable and that his undisputed specialized physical health care needs could be safely met at school by trained special education staff under the supervision of the school nurse. As a consequence, the District contends that it should not be ordered to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one nurse as a related service or to reimburse STUDENT’s mother for nursing costs.

FACTUAL BACKGROUND

STUDENT is a six-year-old student who has been eligible for special education and related services since his third birthday in July 2000, based upon his orthopedic impairment. STUDENT is currently attending first grade in the integrated life skills special day class (SDC) taught by Jennifer Hunt at the District’s Field Elementary School (Field). This class has a total of ten medically fragile students and is staffed by five adults. In addition, STUDENT is attended throughout the school day by a one-to-one nurse, pursuant to stay put. STUDENT is a client of the San Diego Regional Center and he receives physical and occupational therapy services from California Children’s Services.

STUDENT suffered a severe hypoxic injury at birth. As a consequence, STUDENT has cerebral palsy with spastic quadriplegia and associated mental retardation. STUDENT has a seizure disorder treated with Dilantin and reactive airway disease (asthma) treated with Albuterol and Pulmo-Cort administered via a nebulizer. STUDENT has gastro-esophageal reflux disease (GERT) and has had several unsuccessful fundoplication surgeries in an attempt to decrease the reflux of his stomach contents up his esophagus. On March 30, 2004, STUDENT had a gastric bypass operation in lieu of another fundoplication. STUDENT is fed and receives medications by a gastronomy tube (G-tube) in his stomach. STUDENT has multiple vision problems, uses a wheelchair, and wears glasses, ankle foot orthosis (AFOs), and a body brace to prevent scoliosis. STUDENT is nonverbal, but will smile, respond to familiar voices, and show pleasure and displeasure with facial expressions and vocalizations. Due to his multiple medical needs, STUDENT is monitored by many specialists, including by his pulmonary specialist, Dr. Sung Min Park.

In October 2001, STUDENT began preschool at the District’s Lindbergh-Schweiter Elementary School (Schweiter) but left due to illness. At some point, STUDENT began to attend Special Care School, a private licensed preschool and kindergarten staffed by teachers, nurses and patient care assistants. This school is part of Special Care Center, a pediatric day heath care provider, whose services STUDENT receives pursuant to Medi-Cal funding.

On December 9, 2002, STUDENT’s triennial IEP team meeting was convened. At the time of this IEP team meeting, STUDENT was attending Special Care School with a plan to begin kindergarten in a special day class (SDC) at Schweitzer. STUDENT’s MOTHER asked the IEP team to provide STUDENT with a one-to-one nurse while he attended Schweitzer, or to fund his placement at Special Care School. The IEP team advised STUDENT’s MOTHER that she must provide the District with a physician’s statement before this request could be considered.

On December 16, 2002, Dr. Park wrote a letter in support of STUDENT’s MOTHER’s request. As described by Dr. Park, the primary concern was STUDENT’s difficulties in controlling his secretions that resulted in a need for frequent suctioning throughout the day. The District’s medical consultant, Dr. Howard Taras, reviewed Dr. Park’s letter and recommended a trial period with a one-to-one nurse for STUDENT while he was at school. Dr. Taras noted that there were “divergent views from health professionals on whether STUDENT requires 1:1 nursing (versus close observation from non-nurses and availability of a nurse within a couple of minutes).” Dr. Taras recommended that STUDENT’s care by the one-to-one nurse during the trial period be carefully documented to assess his clinical stability at school.

On February 27, 2003, the IEP team agreed to hire a private nurse for STUDENT from Special Care Center for a trial period of four to six weeks while he was at school. The team agreed that the trial would include documentation by the school nurse of STUDENT’s “suctioning schedules/emergencies, and G-tube feeding times.” The IEP team further agreed to meet again within four to five weeks to determine whether or not to continue the nursing services. With this recommendation, STUDENT’s MOTHER consented to both the February 27, 2003 addendum and to the December 9, 2002 annual IEP. STUDENT enrolled at Schweitzer in the spring of 2003. In April 2003, the IEP team agreed to extend STUDENT’s nursing services through summer school and to reevaluate the need for nursing services when STUDENT entered first grade. (Footnote 2)

On September 29, 2003, STUDENT began attending first grade at the integrated life skills special day class (SDC) for medically fragile students at Field Elementary School. His IEP team convened for an annual review on November 5, 2003. Dr. Taras, Field’s school nurse, Carole Phillips, and special education itinerant nurse, Nancy Duncan, were among the District representatives at the IEP team meeting. Ms. Phillips presented her Nurse Assessment Report dated November 3, 2003, in which she concluded that there was “no reason that the existing staff at Field School could not meet [STUDENT’s] medical needs…. The nurse and the classroom staff are qualified to provide respiratory assessment and intervention, provide care during seizures, provide G-tube feedings and administer medications….”

All IEP team members, except for STUDENT’s mother, agreed “that STUDENT’s medical needs can be met by the existing staff at the school site.” The team further agreed that the nurse would continue to work with STUDENT at school until January 1, 2004, “with the exception of Wed[nesday]. Parent agreed to try Wed[nesday] w/out nurse at this point.” Finally, the IEP team agreed that “the classroom teacher and school nurse will create a transition plan to ensure all of STUDENT’s medical needs are met. Classroom staff will be trained in suctioning and parent will be invited.” Resp. Ex. A. STUDENT’s MOTHER did not agree with the part of the IEP relating to the termination of STUDENT’s nurse services. At the hearing, STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that she did agreed at the meeting to have STUDENT participate in the proposed trial without a nurse on Wednesdays, but that she ultimately took him to Special Care on those days instead.

On December 4, 2003, STUDENT was seen at the Pulmonary Clinic at Children’s Hospital and Health Center. Dr. Park wrote a prescription as follows: “STUDENT should continue nursing at school due to frequent seizures & poor secretion management. Needs prompt attention to medical needs to ensure his conditions doesn’t worsen & for appropriate infection control.” Resp. Ex. D.

In mid-December 2003, STUDENT’s MOTHER met with Ms. Phillips and STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Jennifer Hunt, to review a document prepared by Ms. Phillips entitled “STUDENT’s Care Plan for School Attendance” (hereafter Care Plan). One of the components of this Care Plan provided that “STUDENT will have a 1:1 staff member assigned to him at all times when he is at school.” Resp. Ex. B 4. The Care Plan was revised to include STUDENT’s MOTHER’s input.

On January 1, 2004, STUDENT’s one-to-one nursing services ceased without parental consent. STUDENT’s MOTHER hired a nurse for STUDENT from Maxim Healthcare Services, a private nursing agency, for approximately one week.

On January 30, 2004, the Hearing Office received STUDENT’s MOTHER’s request for hearing. STUDENT’s MOTHER indicated that STUDENT had not attended school at Field Elementary for a month because his nurse services were stopped by the District. Beginning in February 2004, STUDENT’s MOTHER took STUDENT to school at Special Care.

In February 2004, Dr. Taras prepared two memoranda to the District regarding STUDENT’s health care needs. On February 11, 2004, Dr. Taras advised that he would review the documentation of the one-to-one nurses who had worked with STUDENT to make a recommendation regarding his health care needs at school based upon those records. On February 24, 2004, after his review of Maxim Healthcare nursing agency’s nursing records on STUDENT during school from September 29, 2003, to January 1, 2004, Dr. Taras recommended that the District provide STUDENT with two levels of service at school. Specifically, Dr. Taras wrote that schools throughout the country performed the type of health services STUDENT needed and that “sometimes we arrange for children to have 5-day per week nurses placed at the school site to manage these issues well. For STUDENT, I would recommend both levels of care: classroom-trained staff and a 5-day per week nurse on site. Everything observed during STUDENT’s trial period supports that this level of care is safe.” Resp. Ex. E.

On March 3, 2004, STUDENT was again seen by Dr. Park at the Pulmonary Clinic at Children’s Hospital and Health Center, who recommended that STUDENT continue to receive nursing care at school “at the present level.” Pet. Ex. 2.

On April 22, 2004, the due process hearing commenced. Dr. Park did not testify at the hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE I: Does STUDENT require a full-time one-to-one nurse at school to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs and thereby receive a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?

Under both state law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).

The term “related services,” referred to as designated instruction and services (DIS) in California, means transportation and such developmental, corrective, and “other supportive services… as may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education….” 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22), Cal. Educ. Code § 56363 (b). As defined in federal regulations, related services under the IDEA include “school health services…provided by a qualified school nurse or other qualified person.” 34 Code Fed. Regs. § 300.24(b)(12). Health and nursing services are specifically included as DIS services in California. Cal. Educ. Code § 56363(b)(12). In Cedar Rapids Community School District v. Garrett F., 526 U.S. 66, 119 S. Ct. 992 (1999), the United States Supreme Court determined that a school district may be required to fund continuous nursing services as a related service to enable a ventilator-dependent student to attend school, and that such services are not excluded medical services.

Under California law, health and nursing DIS services required for a student to benefit from their education may include “providing services by qualified personnel” and “managing the individual’s health problems on the school site.” tit. 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3051.12(a). “Specialized physical health care services” are defined as “those health services prescribed by the individual’s licensed physician and surgeon requiring medically related training for the individual who performs the services and which are necessary during the school day to enable the individual to attend school.” tit. 5 Cal. Code Regs. §§ 3001(ad), 3051.12(b) (1)(A). Specialized physical health care services “include catheterization, gavage feeding, suctioning, or other services that require medically related training.” Cal. Educ. Code § 49423.5 (d), tit. 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3051.12(b).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services to maximize a student’s abilities. Id. at 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205.

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE offered was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 206-207. In this case, STUDENT has many educational needs. His only dispute regarding the educational program offered him by the District, however, is whether he continues to require a one-to-one nurse to attend to his specialized physical health care needs during the school day and whether the District denied him a FAPE by terminating his related nurse services. It is well established that the burden of demonstrating compliance with the IDEA rests with the local educational agency. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Accordingly, to demonstrate that it offered STUDENT a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District must establish that its offer of school health services as described in the November 5, 2003 IEP was procedurally appropriate, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs, and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. (Footnote 3)

A. What are STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs? (Footnote 4)

To determine whether STUDENT requires a one-to-one nurse to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs, the Hearing Officer must first identify those needs. In this case, STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs, described below, are essentially undisputed by the parties, who focused their dispute on the manner in which those needs must be met. STUDENT’s undisputed unique needs in this area are as follows:

1. Unique Respiratory Need for Secretion Management by Suctioning Machine: The parties do not dispute that STUDENT has a unique need for frequent monitoring and suctioning of his oral secretions to ensure that his airway is clear and that he is able to breathe. As indicated in his private agency nursing notes and in the District’s Care Plan, STUDENT’s respiratory status must be assessed by listening for wheezing and for noisy, rattling, or gurgling breathing sounds. Registered nurse Lisa Turner, who is STUDENT’s case manager at Special Care Center, testified that STUDENT breathes through his mouth and this makes it easier to observe him and to listen for sounds of respiratory distress. In addition, STUDENT’s respiratory status can be determined by observation for secretions pooling in the back of his throat, and for respiratory distress such as difficulty breathing, agitation, paleness, excessive coughing or choking, cyanosis (blueness) and patency (openness) of airway. Ms. Turner testified that airway protection is her primary concern for STUDENT. She explained that STUDENT can cough up some of his secretions but is not able to clear his throat and may aspirate these fluids into his lungs. STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Jennifer Hunt, testified that STUDENT’s suctioning needs are episodic and that he can go for days without any suctioning at school, but that he has bad days requiring up to eight suctions during the school day. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that on a good weekend day, she may suction STUDENT four times a day. On difficult days, she may suction him five to eight times. Both STUDENT’s MOTHER and Ms. Hunt testified that patting STUDENT on the back with a therapy ball may help him clear his airway.

It was also undisputed that STUDENT needs to be suctioned promptly. Ms. Turner testified that it is because STUDENT’s suctioning must be done immediately that he needs to have someone with him on a one-to-one basis. Ms. Hunt testified that because STUDENT requires continuous monitoring throughout the day by a one-to-one trained person, she recommended that a provision for one-to-one staffing be included in his Care Plan. In addition, STUDENT becomes agitated or panicky when he is not suctioned. SDC special education technician Ruthann Schroeder testified that when STUDENT panics about his breathing, she removes any tight clothing that may hinder his breathing, and massages his arms to calm him down. There was also a consensus among those who have worked with STUDENT that there may be a relationship between the failure to promptly suction him and the onset of a seizure (testimony of STUDENT’s MOTHER, Ms. Hunt, and Ms. Schroeder). In her November 3, 2003 Nurse Assessment Report, Ms. Phillips reported that STUDENT’s “LVN feels that his seizures may be triggered when he feels anxious due to respiratory congestion.” While not sure these events were connected, Dr. Taras agreed that the relationship between STUDENT’s suctioning and his seizures should be documented.

2. Unique Need for Seizure Care and Management: The parties do not dispute that STUDENT has a unique need for seizure care and management that includes calming him during the seizure, documenting of the time and duration of each seizure, and occasionally administering medication. According to Ms. Hunt, on difficult days, STUDENT has two to three seizures at school. During this time, he is rolled to one side so his secretions can drain out. Ms. Hunt testified that STUDENT is frightened during his seizures and that SDC staff members talk to him and work to calm him down. She also testified that STUDENT has orders for an anal suppository, Diastat, that can stop the seizure, and must be administered by a nurse. A review of the records of the two nursing agencies involved in STUDENT’s care from September 29, 2003, through April 19, 2004, indicates that the vast majority of STUDENT’s seizures are of under forty (40) seconds in duration. These records also document that on several days, STUDENT has had multiple seizures ranging from two to three minutes in duration.

3. Unique Need for Feeding, Hydration, and Medication by Gastronomy Tube (G-Tube): Another of STUDENT’s undisputed unique specialized physical health care needs is providing nutrition, water, and medication by G-tube. During his school day, STUDENT typically requires feeding via a G-tube, followed by water. STUDENT also receives some seizure medications (Dilantin) at school via G-tube.

4. Unique Need for Asthma Care by Nebulizer Machine: It is undisputed that STUDENT requires the administration of his asthma medications (Albuteral and PulmoCort) while at school. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that STUDENT receives Albuterol and PulmoCort asthma treatments from two to four times a day via his nebulizer machine and that two of these administrations are at school.

Can STUDENT’s unique needs only be met by a one-to-one nurse?

Petitioner asserts he is medically fragile and requires a nurse to constantly monitor him to ensure that he is suctioned appropriately, to respond to his seizures, and to care for his feeding and medication needs. As a consequence, Petitioner asserts that the termination of his one-to-one nursing services was not designed to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs. The Hearing Officer now examines Student’s principal contention that his unique physical health care needs can only be met by a one-to-one nurse.

There is no legal requirement that the type of specialized physical health care services STUDENT requires can only be met by a nurse. To the contrary, California’s Education Code provides that special education students who have specialized physical health care service needs, such as suctioning, during the regular school day may be assisted by either a credentialed nurse or by “qualified designated school personnel trained in the administration of specialized physical health care provided they perform such services under the supervision of a school nurse, public health nurse, or licensed physician and surgeon.” Cal. Educ. Code § 49423.5 (a). In this case, the weight of the evidence establishes that, with an appropriate offer, STUDENT’s unique needs can be met by qualified school staff, such as the District’s “special education technician,” whose essential job duties include “perform[ing] specialized health care procedures under direction of school nurse.” Resp. Ex. J.

First, the Hearing Officer finds that the actual use of the suctioning machine, as well as the suctioning procedure itself, is not complicated or technical. The evidence established that STUDENT is suctioned using a machine with multiple ports to which catheters of varying degrees of thickness and flexibility can be attached. Suctioning may be done orally or nasally. As explained by nurse Lisa Turner, a hard, curved plastic catheter, similar to a dentist’s saliva vacuum, is used for oral suctioning of the sides of STUDENT’s mouth and the back of his throat. A narrower soft catheter is used to enter his nostril and move down the throat for “naso-pharyngeal” or “deep” suctioning. On the vast majority of occasions at school, STUDENT is suctioned orally. Dr. Taras testified that this type of procedure is performed by school personnel throughout the nation and that many parents have been trained to use suction machines and to suction their children, both orally and nasally. (Footnote 5) STUDENT’s independent case manager, registered nurse Doreen Casuto, also testified that STUDENT’s suctioning needs can be managed by someone who is specially trained.

Second, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has been suctioned, both orally and nasally, while he is at home by individuals who are not nurses. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that she suctions her son when he is not at school, in the evenings and on the weekends. STUDENT’s MOTHER also testified that STUDENT has seizures at home, which she documents for time and duration. According to STUDENT’s MOTHER, she began training to become a certified nurse assistant (CNA), but had to leave school to care for STUDENT. It was in this context that she learned how to suction. STUDENT’s family members also care for his suctioning and other unique needs. STUDENT’s Regional Center case manager, Todd Lordson, testified that STUDENT receives “Family Vendorized Respite Care” from the Regional Center. Under this program, STUDENT’s MOTHER selects a family member or members whom she trains to care for STUDENT’s unique needs when she needs respite. The Regional Center pays STUDENT’s MOTHER, who then pays the family member for respite care. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that her sister is her primary respite provider, but that she has trained all of her family members to suction STUDENT, as well as to monitor his seizures, to provide him with medicine, and to feed him by G-tube. No evidence was presented that STUDENT’s MOTHER’s family members have had any medical training or are nurses.

Third, from the testimony of Dr. Taras, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s specialized physical health care needs can be safely performed at Field Elementary School by a one-to-one special education technician under the supervision of the school nurse, without a one-to-one nurse. The Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Taras’s opinion that this level of care is safe for STUDENT is entitled to great weight. Dr. Taras is a practicing pediatrician, a professor of clinical pediatrics and interim chief of the School Health Division of Community Pediatrics at the University of California, San Diego. He is the chief medical consultant to the District and to five other school districts, and the medical consultant and director of the Special Care Center for Medically Fragile Children in San Diego. Dr. Taras is certified by the American Board of Pediatrics and the Medical Council of Canada and is licensed in California and New York. His extensive publications include numerous articles in the area of school health. See: Resp. Ex. F.

Dr. Taras testified that, as a school doctor, one of his primary functions is to explain to doctors who are unfamiliar with school systems what services schools can safely provide to children with health care needs. His primary concern is the child’s safety. In this case, following Dr. Park’s initial recommendation for one-to-one nurse services in December 2002, Dr. Taras recommended that the District provide STUDENT a trial period with a one-to-one nurse in order to document his stability in the classroom. Following his review of STUDENT’s nursing records, from both Special Care and Maxim in February 2004, Dr. Taras concluded that STUDENT’s condition was stable and did not require one-to-one nursing. Dr. Taras’s conclusion regarding the stability of STUDENT’s condition was also shared by Ms. Casuto and Ms. Phillips. Dr. Taras also testified that he spoke to Dr. Park on April 28, 2004. As indicated in his memorandum to the District on that date, Dr. Taras described to Dr. Park “the plan we had for services: A 1:1 special education health technician would be assigned to STUDENT—and handle all suctioning needs immediately. STUDENT would be assigned to a school with a 5-day a week nurse so that a nurse would be available within seconds to minutes should anyone require her assistance. Dr. Park was very agreeable to this level of treatment. The plan can be sent for his signature at any time.” Resp. Ex. M. No persuasive evidence was provided to the contrary.

Fourth, the Hearing Officer finds that Field’s full-time school nurse, Ms. Phillips, can train and supervise the special education technicians, in accordance with statutory and regulatory requirements. Ms. Phillips testified that, as Field’s full-time school nurse, she is responsible for the administration of medications and would administer medications to STUDENT if he did not have a one-to-one nurse. Ms. Phillips also testified that she is in STUDENT’s classroom numerous times each day assessing and providing medication to students, that she is in the wing of the building where the medically fragile classes are for forty percent of each day, that she uses a walky-talky and school intercom when she is not in her office near her telephone, and that she can reach STUDENT’s classroom within a minute in an emergency. Ms. Phillips’s uncontested testimony established (1) that she has provided the three special education technicians (SETs) with a demonstration and a basic training in suctioning, (2) that she will supervise and ensure the competency of each of them in suctioning techniques before they suction STUDENT without her physical presence, and (3) that she will certify their competency in these techniques thereafter on a monthly basis.

As recognized in the regulations, “supervision” means “review, observation, and/or instruction of a designated school person’s performance and of physical health care services, but does not necessarily require the immediate presence of the supervisor at all times.” tit. 5 Cal. Code Regs. § 3051.12 (b)(1)(D). Such supervision may be immediate (supervisor shall be physically present while a procedure is being administered), direct (supervisor shall be present in the same building as the person being supervised and available for consultation and/or assistance), or indirect (supervisor shall be available to the qualified designated school person either in person or through electronic means to provide necessary instruction, consultation, and referral to appropriate care and services as needed). In this case, Ms. Phillips’s testimony established that she would provide immediate supervision until she initially certified the competency of the SETs in performing the suctioning procedure and that she would provide predominantly direct supervision thereafter. Her testimony also established that the SETs in STUDENT’s SDC class are CPR-certified. (See: tit. 5 Cal.Code Regs. § 3051.12 (b)(1)(C).). (Footnote 6)

From the totality of the evidence presented, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs can be met at this time by a trained and dedicated one-to-one special education technician supervised by a full-time school nurse. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that STUDENT does not require a full-time one-to-one nurse as a related service at school to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs and to receive a free appropriate public education.

Issue II: Did the District offer STUDENT appropriate services to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs before it terminated his one-to-one nursing services on January 1, 2004?

As outlined above, STUDENT has the following undisputed unique specialized physical health care needs for which he requires school health services: a unique respiratory need for secretion management by suctioning machine, including one-to-one monitoring; a unique need for seizure care and management; a unique need for feeding, hydration, and medication by gastronomy tube (G-tube); and a unique need for asthma care by nebulizer machine.

As determined in Issue I, the District is not required to offer STUDENT a one-to-one nurse as a related service in order to meet his unique specialized physical health care needs and provide a FAPE. The evidence also established that the District has many of the components of an appropriate program in place to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. For example, STUDENT is placed at a school that has a full-time school nurse, he is placed in a small SDC classroom with an adult-to-student ratio of 1:2, and this class has three special education technicians who can, with appropriate training, provide health care services to him under the supervision of the school nurse. Nonetheless, the District was required to make a specific offer of related school health services to meet these needs once nursing services were terminated.

At the November 5, 2003 IEP meeting, the District IEP team members concluded that the staff at Field was capable and qualified to meet STUDENT’s health needs; however they did not identify or offer STUDENT any specific continuing specialized physical health care services in the IEP to meet his unique needs without a one-to-one nurse. It is apparent from a review of the IEP team notes that the District made some beginning efforts to flesh out these needs. For example, the IEP notes indicate that “the classroom teacher and school nurse will create a transition plan to ensure all of STUDENT’s medical needs are met. Classroom staff will be trained in suctioning, and parent will be invited.” Thereafter, however, the District failed to convene another IEP team meeting to review the transition plan, the care plan, or to specify the type or frequency of assistance STUDENT would receive to address his unique health care needs. In addition, the District terminated STUDENT’s nursing services on January 1, 2004, without parental consent. Cal. Educ. Code § 56346. (Footnote 7)

As a procedural matter, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to make a specific offer to meet STUDENT’s unique specialized physical heath care needs. It is well established that the “IDEA explicitly requires written prior notice to parents when an educational agency proposes, or refuses, to initiate or change the educational placement of a disabled child.” Union v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). Pursuant to this obligation, a school district must make a formal written offer of placement to the parents of a student with a disability. Id. In addition, the IEP is the blueprint for a student’s educational program and must include a statement of the specific special education and related services to be provided to the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(iii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(3). California regulations expressly provide that “specific continuing specialized physical health care services required in order for the individual to benefit from special education will be included in the individualized education program….” tit. 5 Cal.Code Regs. § 3051.12 (b)(3)(A ).

In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer contained in the November 5, 2003 IEP was not clear and did not provide sufficient detail of how the District planned to meet STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs without a one-to-one nurse. As a consequence of this procedural violation, the parent did not have sufficient information to seriously consider the offer. First, the IEP did not indicate what level of staffing and services STUDENT would be provided in lieu of a one-to-one nurse. The IEP did not specify that STUDENT would be placed on a campus with a full-time nurse and that he would be assigned a one-to-one trained special education technician who would provide his health care services under supervision of the school nurse. As indicated in his February 24, 2004 memorandum, Dr. Taras recommended that STUDENT be provided with two levels of service to ensure his safety: placement at a school with a full-time nurse and trained classroom staff to address his health care needs. The weight of the evidence established that the termination of a one-to-one nurse was appropriate only with this staff configuration. While the IEP makes vague reference to the District IEP team members’ belief in the competence of Field’s staff, the failure to specify the staff configuration under the facts of this case renders the offer to the parent essentially meaningless. In addition, while the District later indicated that “STUDENT will have a 1:1 staff member assigned to him at all times when he is at school” in the “STUDENT’s Care Plan for School Attendance” (Care Plan) prepared a month after the IEP, it was not included in the IEP’s offer of related school health services. (Footnote 8)

Second, the IEP failed to include a detailed care plan for STUDENT to address his continuing health care needs. The Care Plan prepared by Ms. Phillips with input from Ms. Hunt and STUDENT’s MOTHER after the IEP did outline the physical health care services STUDENT requires while at school, including suctioning, medication administration, G-tube feeding and hydration, and monitoring of seizures. (Footnote 9) This Care Plan also incorporated the District’s standard procedures or guidelines for Nasopharyngeal and Oral Suctioning (Guidelines) that were designed for use by the special education technicians both in their training and in following the suctioning procedure. As indicated by Dr. Taras, such care plans must be reviewed and revised at least annually. They must be included in the IEP. While the District may have intended to provide STUDENT what it believed to be appropriate specialized health care services at school pursuant to a “transition plan” (presumably the Care Plan), the offer must be viewed at the time it is made, not in hindsight, fleshed out by speculative or potential future additions. Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141,1149 (9th Cir.1999). Third, rather than filing its own request for a due process hearing on this issue as authorized by Cal. Educ. Code § 56346(b), the District terminated STUDENT’s nurse service in January 2004 without parental consent.

A procedural violation does not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE unless it has resulted in a loss of educational opportunity or a serious infringement on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, 960 F.2d 1479, 1484 (9th Cir. 1992). In determining whether Petitioner suffered prejudice from the procedural violations outlined above, it is useful to consider the three important purposes of a written offer identified by the court in Union. First, the Court determined that “the requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any.” Second, the Court reasoned that “a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in ‘presenting complaints with respect to any matter relating to the …educational placement of the child’…by alerting [them] to the need to consider seriously whether [the offered service] was an appropriate” and whether they should oppose it or accept it with the supplement of additional educational services. Third, the Court noted that, “by making a formal offer, the District would have been more prepared to introduce sufficient relevant evidence to the hearing officer of the appropriateness” of the placement. Id.

The Hearing Officer finds that, in this case, the District’s failure to offer STUDENT any specific physical health care services to replace the one-to-one nursing services at the November 5, 2003 IEP seriously infringed on the parent’s rights to participate in the IEP process. The failure to specifically offer STUDENT the related service of a one-to-one special education technician supervised by a school nurse made it difficult for the parent to know how STUDENT would be cared for at school and to thus seriously consider the District’s offer. The confusion generated by the absence of a specific offer for specialized physical care services is best illustrated in relation to the question of a one-to-one aide for STUDENT at school. The IEP does not mention the assignment of a one-to-one staff member for STUDENT. The Care Plan prepared after the IEP stated that “STUDENT will have a 1:1 staff member assigned to him at all times when he is at school.” At the due process hearing, Field’s staff testified that STUDENT would not be individually assigned a trained aide to work exclusively with him. Rather, Ms. Hunt testified she would assign one of the three special education technicians to watch STUDENT at all times pursuant to a detailed class schedule and that she would feel comfortable with this arrangement as long as there was no change in the configuration of her classroom. Nonetheless, as indicated in the testimony of special education technician Ruthann Schroeder, STUDENT would not receive one-to-one service of an special education technician, but only of a technician responsible for two students. STUDENT’s MOTHER’s questions at the due process hearing conveyed her ongoing confusion and distrust regarding how STUDENT would receive one-to-one staff monitoring when there was a staff-to-student ratio of 1:2 in the classroom. As a result of this serious infringement on STUDENT’s MOTHER’s right to participate in the IEP process, the Hearing Officer concludes that these procedural violations resulted in a denial of FAPE.

As a substantive matter, the Hearing Officer finds that, as a consequence of its failure to offer STUDENT a dedicated one-to-one special education technician in the IEP, the District’s offer failed to meet STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care needs for close monitoring of his respiratory suctioning needs and his seizure activity (See discussion under Issue I, supra). In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique physical health care needs because it failed to include a transition plan outlining how these needs would be met during the period between the offer and the completed training and certification of the special education technician staff. As indicated in the testimony of Ms. Casuto, it is essential that the person working with STUDENT be trained, be able to assess his condition, and be able to act promptly. There is obviously a time period during which Ms. Phillips will have to train and certify the competency of the assigned one-to-one SET, as well as backup or substitute SETs, to perform necessary procedures for STUDENT outside her immediate presence and observation. Before the District can transition STUDENT from his one-to-one nurse to its own staff, the IEP team must prepare and adopt a transition plan. Until that plan is fully implemented, the District must continue to fund STUDENT’s one-to-one nurse services.

* * * *

In summary, while STUDENT’s unique physical health care needs can be met by the District’s staff at Field without a one-to-one nurse, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District cannot currently implement its proposed plan because its offer was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique health care needs or to provide him with educational benefit. Rather, the District must convene an IEP team meeting to do the following: (1) make an appropriate offer of related school health services to STUDENT consistent with this Decision, including a dedicated one-to-one special education technician and a full-time school nurse on site; (2) amend as necessary and adopt the existing Care Plan and appropriate supporting guidelines to address STUDENT’s unique specialized physical health care services as outlined above; (3) prepare and adopt a transition plan identifying a time for completion of training and certifying the competence of the one-to-one special education technician and backup technicians; and (4) provide for one-to-one nursing services pending completion of the transition plan. (Footnote 10)

ISSUE III: Must the District reimburse STUDENT’s mother for the cost of private nursing services she incurred in January 2004?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370.

In this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by terminating his nursing services on January 1, 2004, without parental consent, and without providing a clear offer of specific specialized physical health care services to replace the nursing services at the November 5, 2003 IEP team meeting. It was undisputed that STUDENT’s MOTHER incurred costs of $1,300.00 for private nursing services she secured from Maxim Healthcare Agency for STUDENT in January 2004 after the termination of his one-to-one nursing services. STUDENT’s MOTHER testified that she paid Maxim the full amount in cash and that she would be able to provide the District with an invoice showing this payment.

The Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the full cost of these nursing services. As indicated in Order Three (3) below, the District shall reimburse STUDENT’s MOTHER for these nursing services upon proof of payment.

* * *

In addressing the needs of a medically fragile student like STUDENT, it is imperative that the District carefully identify and clearly address each specialized physical health care need. Such attention to detail is essential for STUDENT’S physical safety at school. While the Hearing Officer observed District staff and consultants to be highly concerned with STUDENTs safety at school, the services necessary to ensure his safety must be clearly articulated in an IEP and its supporting care plan, guidelines, and transition plan. Such clarity should help to ease the parent’s understandable safety concerns and ensure that STUDENT continue in the classroom setting he obviously enjoys.

ORDER

1. Within ten (10) school days of the date of this Decision, the District shall convene an IEP team meeting to do the following:

a. make an appropriate offer of related school health services consistent with this Decision, including a dedicated one-to-one special education technician and a full-time school nurse on site; b. amend and/or prepare and adopt a care plan for STUDENT outlining specific continuing specialized physical health care services required and incorporating appropriate guidelines for implementation of the procedures; and c. prepare and adopt a transition plan identifying a time for completion of training and certifying the competence of the one-to-one special education technician and substitute technicians.

2. The District shall continue to provide STUDENT with the services of a one-to-one nurse through the conclusion of the transition period identified by the IEP team in Order 1.

3. Within ten (10) school days of receipt of an invoice demonstrating payment for nursing services in January 2004, the District shall reimburse Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, for the cost of the nursing services up to $1,300.00.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code ' 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

On the First Issue: Respondent prevailed;

On the Second Issue: Petitioner prevailed;

On the Third Issue: Petitioner prevailed.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. California Education Code ' 56505(i).

Dated: May 25, 2004 ____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The issues have been reworded for clarity of analysis.

2 STUDENT has worked with numerous one-to-one nurses through Maxim Healthcare Agency and Special Care Center.

3 Because the IEP regarding related school health care services has not been implemented, it is unnecessary to address the additional requirement that the services offered comport with the services actually provided to him.

4 While STUDENT has other physical needs, such as toileting, the unique needs outlined here are the focus of the disputed issue of one-to-one nurse services.

5 A review of the nursing notes from both Maxim Healthcare and Special Care from September 29, 2003 through mid-April 2004, indicates that STUDENT was very rarely suctioned nasally. Ms. Hunt and Ms. Phillips also testified that they had never seen STUDENT nasally suctioned by his private nurse at school.

6 Contrary to STUDENT’s MOTHER’s assertion that Ms. Phillips was callously determined to make STUDENT’s life difficult, the Hearing Officer found Ms. Phillips to be willing to reassess her recommendation for STUDENT based upon new information regarding his medical condition. Ms. Phillips testified that she probably would recommend a one-to-one nurse for STUDENT if he had frequent vomiting and was being suctioned three to four times an hour as suggested in an letter from Patsy Hartman, clinical director of Special Care Center. Ms. Hartman did not testify at the hearing. Rather, Lisa Turner testified that Ms. Hartman’s letter summarized Special Care’s nursing notes contained in Petitioner’s Ex. 4. On review, these nursing notes do not document instances of vomiting, and STUDENT’s MOTHER did not testify that STUDENT was experiencing vomiting. As acknowledged by STUDENT’s MOTHER, Ms. Hartman wrote this letter for her several years ago and had reprinted it later for her use. Ms. Hartman’s letter refers to STUDENT’s refundoplication of November 13, 2002, when he may have been experiencing frequent vomiting. As indicated in Petitioner’s Ex.1, on March 30, 2004, STUDENT had a gastric bypass in lieu of his failed refundoplication.

7 STUDENT’s Regional Center case manager, Todd Lordson, attended this IEP team meeting. He testified that he understood another IEP meeting would be held before nursing services were terminated.

8 This finding comports with California’s definition of specific educational placement as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services to an individual with exceptional needs, as specified in the individualized education program, in any one of a combination of public, private, home and hospital, or residential settings.” Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3042(a).

9 Key components of the Care Plan provided: (1) for the use and exchange of a communication book between STUDENT’s mother and school staff each morning that documented the time of his last seizure and his respiratory status during the past eight hours; (2) for the transfer of medical equipment (nebulizer and suction machines, G-tube feeding supplies, and medication (Dilantin, PulmoCort, Albuteral) from the parent to the school staff ; (3) that “STUDENT will be assessed as follows: Respiratory status will be determined by listening for noisy, rattling, or gurgling breathing sounds, observing for secretions pooling in back of throat (pharynx), observing for respiratory distress, difficulty breathing, agitation, paleness, excessive coughing or choking, cyanosis (blueness) and patency of airway. He will be suctioned as needed for above symptoms using the attached guidelines;” (4) that “STUDENT will have a 1:1 staff member assigned to him at all times when he is at school;” and (5) that “seizures will be monitored for time, duration and manifestation and will be recorded on seizure log and communication book.”

10 The Hearing Officer notes that there is a conflict between the evidence presented at the hearing and the District’s guidelines for Nasopharyngeal and Oral Suctioning (Guidelines) that were incorporated into STUDENT’s Care Plan. Ms. Phillips, who is an experienced school nurse, testified that she would not nasally suction a student or would do so only in unusual situations. In this case, it is apparent that STUDENT is only rarely nasally suctioned by his private nurses. Nonetheless, the District’s standard suctioning guidelines, in effect since 1999, state that the health care provider should “always suction the nose first…” (See Resp. Ex.B4 No. 10.) It is imperative that the written procedures in which the SETs are trained are accurate and are tailored to meet STUDENT’s unique needs. It is clear to the Hearing Officer from the evidence presented in this case that the suctioning guidelines on which the District is relying are not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique suctioning needs. These guidelines should be reviewed and revised as necessary and incorporated into STUDENT’s new Care Plan offered at an IEP team meeting pursuant to Order One (1) below.