California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 7, 2001
Berkeley Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2101-01 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait
Berkeley Unified need not serve a student with a learning disability after Hearing Officer finds the family lives in Richmond.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
Parent's separate September 12, 2001 hearing request was settled, contingent on a finding in this case that the student was a District resident.
Summary
Berkeley Unified School District filed for a due process hearing to establish that a 16-year-old student with a specific learning disability did not live within its boundaries. He had received special education from the District for years. A 2000 mediated settlement required his mother to prove Berkeley residency. She submitted a caregiver's authorization affidavit signed by her brother that listed his Berkeley home. The District enrolled the student on that basis for 2000-2001. It later investigated through staff home visits, a private investigator, and direct observation by its manager of student services. The mother represented her son at the hearing. She said they lived at her brother's Berkeley home and offered a driver's license, a PG&E bill, and a phone bill showing that address.
Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait applied the ordinary residency rules in Government Code section 244, following Union School District v. Smith. He found the mother's testimony evasive and not credible. She admitted the utility and phone bills were for a Richmond apartment, and a District manager saw mother and son leaving that apartment. He concluded the family lived in Richmond. The caregiver exception in Education Code section 48104(d) did not apply because the student had always lived with his mother, and actual facts showed he did not live in the caregiver's home. The Hearing Officer ruled that the District was not required to provide educational services. The District prevailed.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO decided special education residency disputes using ordinary residency rules under Government Code section 244. It also shows that a district could look past a caregiver affidavit under Education Code section 48104(d) when actual facts showed the student did not live in the caregiver's home.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Is Student entitled to educational services from the District pursuant to the residency requirements of the California Education Code?
Student and his mother lived in Richmond, not at the uncle's Berkeley home, and the caregiver affidavit exception did not apply, so the District was not required to serve him.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order that the District is not required to provide educational services to Student because he is not a resident of the District.
Key authorities
Union School Dist. v. Smith; Government Code section 244; Education Code section 48100; Education Code section 48104(d)
People named in the decision
- Joann Biondi, Director of special education, Berkeley Unified School District
- Sharon Pincus, Administrator/designee at IEP meeting; witness, Berkeley Unified School District
- Patricia Dyer, Home instruction coordinator; witness, Berkeley Unified School District
- Lawrence Lee, Executive vice principal, Berkeley High School, Berkeley Unified School District
- Rochelle Butler, Student services officer, Berkeley Unified School District
- Gene Nakamura, Manager of student services, Berkeley Unified School District
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard on October 18, 2001, in Berkeley, California, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.
Petitioner Berkeley Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Lenore Silverman. Also present of behalf of the District was Joann Biondi, director of special education. Respondent STUDENT was represented by his mother, MOTHER.
The record in this hearing was closed on October 18, 2001, after receipt of evidence and argument from the parties.
ISSUE
Is STUDENT entitled to educational services from the District pursuant to the residency requirements of the California Education Code?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, age 16, has been receiving special education services from the District for many years because of his specific learning disability.
As early as 1998, the District suspected that STUDENT did not reside within its boundaries. In the IEPs of May 6, 1998, September 28, 1998, October 16, 1998, and January 20, 1999, STUDENT’s mother’s address was listed as ADDRESS 1 address, Berkeley, California.
During the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT’s mother requested a due process hearing because the District proposed to expel STUDENT because of alleged inappropriate conduct. On May 11, 2000, the parties signed a mediated settlement agreement. One of the provisions of the settlement agreement was: “Petitioner’s parent(s) will submit proof of Petitioner’s residence in Berkeley by August 1, 2000; document will be submitted to District care of Joanne Biondi at 2134 Martin Luther King, Jr. Way, Berkeley, CA 94704-1180.”
On August 1, 2000, Ms. MOTHER sent a letter with a care giver’s authorization affidavit to the District. In her letter, Ms. MOTHER said:
Pursuant to the settlement agreement with Berkeley Unified School District, enclosed is Proof of STUDENT’s residency in Berkeley. I am in the process of relocating in Berkeley. Once this is finalized STUDENT will once again be with me. Please feel free to contact myself (PHONE NUMBER 1) or CAREGIVER [illegible] (PHONE NUMBER 2) if you have any further questions.
The telephone number given by MOTHER had an area code of 510 and a prefix of (PREFIX). The only telephone numbers with the area code and prefix are for telephones located in the city of Richmond.
The caregiver’s authorization affidavit is intended to allow a relative who is proving care to a child, but does not have legal custody of a child, to enroll the child in school and authorize medical treatment. The form was not filled out in the way expected. Normally, where the form states “my name,” the caretaker inserts his/her name. In the form provided relating to STUDENT, the name appearing after “my name” is the name of STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER. In the space titled “my address” is listed “ ADDRESS 2.” The form is not signed by MOTHER, but instead is signed by her brother, BROTHER. BROTHER resides at ADDRESS 2. On the basis of this form, the District enrolled STUDENT and provided educational services during the 2000-2001 school year.
On January 22, 2001, an IEP meeting was held in order to determine whether disciplinary conduct by STUDENT was a manifestation of his disability. A note on the form states: “Parent lives in Richmond-will not give out an address.” Ms. Sharon Pincus, who was the administrator/designee at the IEP meeting, testified that she wrote the note concerning Ms. MOTHERS’ living in Richmond and did so because of Ms. MOTHERS’ phone number, which is a Richmond phone number, and because Ms. MOTHER told her that she was not living in Berkeley.
The parties to the January 22, 2201 IEP meeting agreed that an appropriate interim placement would be home schooling.
Patricia Dyer was the home instruction coordinator for the District. She 6testified that she made an appointment to register STUDENT for home instruction. The registration took place at the home located at ADDRESS 2 in Berkeley. It was agreed that the actual home instruction would take place at the West Berkeley Branch Library, which is about two blocks from the ADDRESS 2 home. Ms. Dyer provided instruction to STUDENT at the branch library during two weeks in the latter part of January. She testified that on a couple of occasions, STUDENT came to the session from the direction of the ADDRESS 2 home, but on several other occasions she observed him getting off the San Pablo bus west of the library and in the opposite direction of the ADDRESS 2 home.
On July 3, 2001, Lawrence Lee, executive vice principal of Berkeley High School, visited the ADDRESS 2 home to confirm that it was STUDENT’s residence. He was told by STUDENT’s uncle that neither STUDENT of his mother, MOTHER, was home. STUDENT’s uncle also stated that MOTHER would be back later in the day.
On July 5, 2001, Mr. Lee wrote a supplemental contact report concerning the July 3 visit. He stated that he spoke with Mr. UNCLE, STUDENT’s uncle, who gave the phone number for the address as (510)PHONE NUMBER 3. This number did not coincide with the emergency contact telephone number in the school records.
On July 20, 2001, the District retained the services of a private investigator to help determine whether STUDENT was residing within the District. In a report dated August 17, 2001, the private investigator reported that he had performed a surveillance of the ADDRESS 2 on August 15, 2001. He reported that he did not observe STUDENT at that address. Later in the day, the investigator performed a surveillance of a home at ADDRESS 3 in Richmond. He did not observe STUDENT or his mother at this address. The evidence does not disclose why the investigator performed the surveillance of this home. MOTHER testified that she has never resided at that address and did not know the people who did. She speculated that the investigator got the address through tracing a telephone number.
In his report, the investigator stated that an additional surveillance of the ADDRESS 3 home was conducted on August 16, 2001. Again he did not observe STUDENT or his mother. Late on the morning of August 16, the investigator made a “pretext call” to the phone number that he believed was the number for the ADDRESS 3 home. The investigator stated:
Late in the morning we made a pretext call to the house and a woman answered the telephoned [sic]. We asked for STUDENT; however, she stated that he was not there. We stated that we found a notebook at a library in Berkeley and were advised by some other kids that it might belong to STUDENT. The woman then identified herself as STUDENT’s mother and stated that he had left to work that morning and wouldn’t be home until after 5:00 p.m. She stated that he works at UC Berkeley on the grounds. She then requested that we bring the notebook to her house; however, we advised her that it was too far to travel as we were in Berkeley. She then requested that we leave the notebook at ADDRESS 4 in Berkeley, California. She went on to tell us that STUDENT studies at the library that is near that residence, and that he could pick it up the next time he was there. We discontinued the phone call at that time and discontinued our surveillance.
MOTHER testified that she remembered receiving this phone call, but that she received it at the (510) PHONE NUMBER 1 telephone number, which was located at ADDRESS 5 in Richmond.
After receiving the investigator’s report, the District contacted MOTHER and told her that they would not be convening an IEP for STUDENT to discuss his placement in the fall because STUDENT did not reside in the District. The District also told MOTHER that the caregiver affidavit that she had given during the 2000-2001 year was not valid for the 2001-2002 school year. The District also offered to forward STUDENT’s educational records to the Richmond School District.
In early September 2001, Ms. Rochelle Butler, a student services officer, visited the ADDRESS 2 home on two different Saturdays. On both occasions, upon finding no one home, she left her card. She did not hear back from anyone in response to those visits.
On September 12, 2001, MOTHER requested a haring to force the District to provide services to STUDENT. On September 26, 2001, the Special Education Hearing Office received a request for a hearing from the District to establish that STUDENT did not reside within the District. The parties reached a settlement in relation to MOTHERs’ hearing request which was contingent upon a finding by the hearing officer in the District’s case that STUDENT was a resident of the District.
On September 26,2001, MOTHER provided the District with copies of documents to prove that she resided at the ADDRESS 2. She provided a PG&E bill addressed to her at ADDRESS 2, Berkeley. There was no account number listed on the bill in the place for the account number. During the hearing, MOTHER testified that the bill was for an apartment located at ADDRESS 5, Richmond. She said she pays the bill for the occupants of the apartment but does not live there.
Another document provided by MOTHER was a Pacific Bell bill addressed to her at ADDRESS 2, Berkeley. The telephone listed on the bill is PHONE NUMBER 1. MOTHER admitted during the hearing that the telephone number was for a telephone located at ADDRESS 5. She said she receives her telephone messages at that number but does not live at that address.
The third document provided by MOTHER was a California driver license with MOTHER’s picture on it and listing the holder of the license as MOTHER at ADDRESS 2, Berkeley. The date the license was issued was August 15, 1998.
On October 9, 2001, Mr. Gene Nakamura, manager of student services of the District visited the ADDRESS 5 address. At approximately 8:31 a.m., he observed STUDENT and his mother come out of an upstairs apartment and get into a blue car parked in the parking lot and leave. On October 10, 2001, Mr. Nakamura again visited the ADDRESS 5 address. At approximately 4:16 p.m., he observed MOTHER in the same blue car that he had observed the previous day.
LEGAL ANALYSIS
California Education Code Section 48100 establishes mandatory education of children by “the governing board of the school district in which the residency of either the parent or legal guardian is located....” California Education Code Section 48104 provides for a number of exceptions to the requirement that a child’s parents or guardians be residents of the District in order to qualify for services from the District.
It must first be determined where STUDENT’s mother resides. If it is concluded that STUDENT’s mother does not reside within the District, it will be necessary to determine whether STUDENT is entitled to receive educational services from the District under one of the exceptions provided by Education Code Section 48104.
In Union School District v. Smith, 15 F3d 1519 (1994) the court concluded that:
We find no basis for holding that the determination of residency under IDEA or the California Education Code should be different from the ordinary determination of residency.
California Government Code Section 244 set out a number of rules to follow in determining residency in California.
In determining the place of residence the following rules shall be observed: (a) It is the place where one remains when not called elsewhere for labor or other special or temporary purpose, and to which he or she returns in seasons of repose. (b) There can only be one residence.
(c) A residence cannot be lost until another is gained.
(d) The residence of the parent with whom an unmarried minor child maintains his or her place of abode is the residence of such unmarried minor child. (e) The residence of an unmarried minor who has a parent living cannot be changed by his or her own act. (f) The residence can be changed only by the union of act and intent. (g) A married person shall have the right to retain his or her legal residence in the State of California notwithstanding the legal residence or domicile of his or her spouse.
In this case, STUDENT’s mother admitted that her son has lived with her throughout the years that he has attended school in Berkeley. Therefore, his residence is the same as his mother’s.
STUDENT’s mother contends that her residence and that of her son is in her brother’s house at ADDRESS 2 in Berkeley. She supports this contention by her testimony and three documents which show her address to be ADDRESS 2. For the reasons set out below, the Hearing Officer concludes that the preponderance of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT and his mother do not reside at the ADDRESS 2 address, but rather, reside at ADDRESS 5 in Richmond.
The driver’s licence provided by MOTHER was renewed on August 15, 1998, and contains the ADDRESS 2 address. However, in IEPS dated before and after August 15, 1998, MOTHERs’ address is listed at ADDRESS 1. MOTHER testified that she was living at the ADDRESS 1 address at the time of those IEP meetings. Therefore, it would appear that even though she resided elsewhere, she used the ADDRESS 2 address when renewing her license. Therefore, the mere inclusion of the ADDRESS 2 address on the license does not provide support that MOTHER actually resided at that address.
The P.G. & E. bill provided by MOTHER was addressed to her at the ADDRESS 2 address. However, MOTHER testified that the bill was for utilities at the apartment as ADDRESS 5. The P.G. & E. bill provides significant support that MOTHER actually lives at the ADDRESS 5 address where the utilities were provided.
The telephone bill provided by MOTHER was addressed to her at the ADDRESS 2 address but was for a telephone located at the ADDRESS 5 apartment. This bill provides further support for the fact that MOTHER resides at the same location that the telephone covered by the bill is located, i.e., the ADDRESS 5, apartment. This conclusion is further supported by the fact that MOTHER listed the ADDRESS 5 telephone number on the emergency notification forms filled out for the District. She also provided that telephone number on the care giver’s authorization affidavit that she provided to the District in August 2000. The telephone number given to school personnel by MOTHERs’ brother as the telephone number for the ADDRESS 2 house was not the phone number provided to the District by MOTHER.
Ms. Sharon Pincus, the administrator designee during the January 22, 2001 IEP meeting, testified that during the meeting MOTHER told her that she was living in Richmond, but refused to give an address. Ms. Pincus’s testimony is supported by the notation on the IEP that “parent lives in Richmond - will not give out an address.”
When STUDENT was placed in home schooling in January 2001, the meeting to arrange for the home schooling was scheduled in advance and took place at the ADDRESS 2 home. However, the actual home instruction took place in a nearby branch library. This would suggest that the ADDRESS 2 home was not the actual home of STUDENT, but was only used for formal prearranged meeting with school personnel.
Ms. Patricia Dyer provided some of the instruction that took place at the branch library. She testified that while she did observe STUDENT approaching the library from the direction of the ADDRESS 2 home on a couple of occasions, she also saw him on several other occasions getting off the San Pablo Avenue bus that came from the Richmond area.
On a number of occasions, school personnel visited the ADDRESS 2 and asked for STUDENT and his mother. On none of these occasions did they find either STUDENT or his mother at home.
On August 15, 2001, a private investigator conducted an observation of the ADDRESS 2 home and did not observe either STUDENT or his mother. On August 16, 2001, the private investigator made a pretext call to the PHONE NUMBER 1 number. He talked to a person who claimed to be STUDENT’s mother. She allegedly told him that STUDENT was not home. MOTHER testified during the hearing that she received the call at the ADDRESS 5 address in Richmond. The fact that she was at the ADDRESS 5 address to receive the telephone call and the fact that she referred to it as home provides further support that she resided at the ADDRESS 5 address.
On October 9, 2001, at 8:31 a.m., Gene Nakamura, the District’s manager of student services, observed both STUDENT and his mother come out of an apartment at the ADDRESS 5 apartment and get into a car arked in the parking lot and leave. On October 10, 2001, Mr. Nakamura observed MOTHER at the ADDRESS 5 address at approximately 4:16 p.m. These observations further support the conclusion that STUDENT and his mother actually resided at the ADDRESS 5 address.
The only evidence supporting the allegation by MOTHER that the ADDRESS 2 home was her residence was her own testimony during the hearing. The Hearing Officer finds that her testimony was not credible. MOTHER was evasive while answering questions about her residence. While she claimed that the ADDRESS 2 address was her residence, she was vague as to where she had slept on the days prior to the hearing. MOTHER only provided testimony at the prompting of the Hearing Officer. Rather than providing evidence to prove she was a resident of the ADDRESS 2 home, she argued that she should prevail because the District had not proved that the ADDRESS 2 address was not her residence. She removed the account number on the P.G. & E bill because she did not want the District to know that the bill was for utilities at the ADDRESS 5 apartment. MOTHER has been consistently evasive, uncooperative ad misleading in relation to where she resides.
It is concluded that MOTHER and STUDENT reside at ADDRESS 6 in Richmond. The evidence supports the finding that under Government Code Section 244(a), this is the place where she returns after temporary absences and that it is the place where she returns at times of repose. There was no credible evidence presented that would support the conclusion that MOTHER has ever resided at the ADDRESS 2 address or that she intends to reside there in the future. The mere fact that she receives some mail at her brother’s house does not create a residence. As stated in Government Code Section 244 (b) a person cannot have more than one residence at a time.
In that it has been conclude that MOTHER and STUDENT do not reside within the boundaries of the District, it is necessary to determine whether STUDENT is subject to an exception of the residency requirement.
There is only one exception to the residency requirement that might apply in STUDENT’s case. California Education Code Section 48104 provides that:
Notwithstanding Section 48200, a pupil shall be deemed to have complied with the residency requirements for school attendance in a school district, provided he or she is any of the following:...
(d) A pupil who lives in the home of a care giving adult that is located within the boundaries of that school district. Execution of an affidavit under penalty of perjury pursuant to Part 1.5 (commencing with Section 6550) of Division 11 of the Family Code by the care giving adult shall be a sufficient basis for a determination that the pupil lives in the Care giver’s home, unless the school district determines from actual facts that the pupil is not living in the Care giver’s home.
Although STUDENT’s mother did not argue at the hearing that her brother was STUDENT’s caregiver, she provided a care giver’s authorization affidavit in August 2000. The affidavit purports to state that STUDENT is under the care of and lives with MOTHERS brother. However, the affidavit itself is contradictory. MOTHER is listed as living at the ADDRESS 2 address. If she in fact lived at that address, it would not be necessary to list her brother as the authorized caregiver. MOTHER also testified during the hearing that STUDENT had lived with her at all times.
Subsection (d) states that a District must accept the caregiver affidavit as true unless it determines from actual facts that the pupil is not living in the caregiver’s home. As has already been concluded, neither MOTHER nor STUDENT live at the ADDRESS 2 address. Therefore STUDENT does not qualify for an exception to the residency requirement under subsection (d) of Education Code 48104.
From the discussion above, it is concluded that the preponderance of the evidence supports the conclusion that STUDENT resides with his mother at ADDRESS 6 in Richmond and is therefore not residing within the boundaries of the District. No exceptions to the residency requirement apply to STUDENT. Therefore, the District is not required to provide educational services to STUDENT.
ORDER
The District is not required to provide educational services to STUDENT because he is not a resident of the District.
PREVAILING PARTY
Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The District prevailed on the only issues heard and decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THE DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).
Dated November 7,2001 _____________________________________ Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
