California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 2, 2005

Student v. Capistrano Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2102-04 · Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel

Capistrano Unified must assess gross motor needs and reimburse private occupational therapy; its preschool autism class offer was otherwise upheld.

Split decision: student prevailed on 3 of 17 issues (3 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

The parents of a three-year-old boy with autism filed for a hearing against Capistrano Unified School District. When he turned three and left regional center services, the District offered a structured preschool/kindergarten special day class for children with autism at Hankey Elementary School. The parents wanted the District to fund instead his home program from the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), plus private speech and occupational therapy. They also wanted reimbursement for independent assessments.

Hearing Officer Claudia J. Wrazel found the District's assessments thorough except in one area. Its own parent interview showed gross motor delays, such as poor balance and falling when running, but no one assessed gross motor skills, and the IEP had no goals for those needs. The District won every other issue. The IEP team was properly made up, the written offer was specific enough, and the District considered the parents' input and revised goals at their request. The goals, speech therapy, supervision of the behavioral intervention, summer services and teaching methods were adequate. The boy was ready for a small, structured group class, which was the least restrictive environment. The District was ordered to assess gross motor skills within 15 days and to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days after that. It must also reimburse private occupational therapy from May 9, 2004 until a corrected IEP is in place. Requests for CARD funding, compensatory education and assessment reimbursement were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a missed assessment area. Gross motor delays recorded in the District's own interview data required an assessment, and missing it supported limited reimbursement for therapy. It also shows that a District could recommend a school-based class over a home program the parents preferred, as long as it genuinely considered their input.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District assess STUDENT adequately?

    The psychoeducational, speech-language and OT/sensory assessments were appropriate, but the District failed to assess gross motor skills even though its own Vineland interview showed gross motor deficits.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2A(1). Did the District fail to have appropriate personnel present at the IEP meetings (general education teacher, CARD representative, OT provider at follow-up meetings)?

    No general education teacher was needed because regular class participation was never contemplated; inviting CARD or having the OT at the follow-up meetings was discretionary, so there was no violation.

  3. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2A(2). Did the District fail to make an appropriately specific formal offer of placement?

    The offer of a structured pre-K class at Hankey met Union v. Smith because both sides understood it meant Ms. Acosta's class; reassigning the class to Ms. Lerman after Ms. Acosta resigned was not a procedural failing.

  4. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 2A(3). Did the District make a predetermined, 'boilerplate' offer without considering the PARENTS' input during the IEP process?

    Draft documents were a starting point. The District sought the parents' input, revised goals at their request, and could keep its placement recommendation even though they disagreed.

  5. Student prevailed in partIEP content

    Issue 2B(a). Were the goals and objectives developed by the District inappropriate or insufficiently challenging for STUDENT?

    The goals were appropriate and closely tracked his CARD goals, but they were inadequate to the extent they did not address his gross motor needs.

  6. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2B(b). Did the District fail to adequately address STUDENT's behavioral and sensory needs?

    A behavior intervention plan claim was outside the issues set at the prehearing conference. The behavioral goals, the IBI program and the OT sensory diet adequately addressed his behavioral and sensory needs.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2B(c). Did the District's program offer include insufficient S/L therapy?

    Thirty minutes each of individual and small-group speech therapy per week, with language addressed throughout the school day, was reasonably calculated to provide some educational benefit.

  8. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2B(d). Did the District's program offer insufficient IBI supervision?

    Three hours per month of IBI supervision, joint supervision with CARD during the transition, and eight parent training sessions were adequate.

  9. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2B(e). Is a group education setting unsuited to STUDENT's needs?

    He had readiness skills for group learning, and the structured, low-ratio autism pre-K/K class suited his needs.

  10. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2B(f). Did the fact that Ms. Acosta's class had older children make it an unsuitable placement for STUDENT for the last month of the 2003-2004 school year?

    The presence of five- and six-year-olds did not make the class unsuitable. Group instruction would be adjusted, and there was no evidence of aggression.

  11. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2B(g). Are the teaching methods in the Hankey pre-K/K classes unsuitable for STUDENT?

    The witnesses' observations lacked context, and credible District testimony showed the teaching methods were suitable.

  12. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue 2B(h). Did the District's offer of an ESY program and maintenance services fail to appropriately address the possibility of skill regression over the summer?

    A 20-day ESY plus IBI maintenance, with no break longer than two weeks, adequately addressed the risk of regression.

  13. District prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2C. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

    The school-based autism class, not the more restrictive one-to-one home program, was the least restrictive environment, and the transition plan addressed potential harmful effects.

  14. Issue 3. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement in a CARD home program and other related services for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

    FAPE was denied only on gross motor needs, which the District can fix, so no prospective CARD placement or private services were ordered.

  15. Issue 4. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of all educational expenses incurred since May 9, 2004?

    Reimbursement was ordered only for private OT addressing gross motor deficits (Big Fun Gymnastics and Susan Perrine). Other expenses were denied.

  16. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 5. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE and if the parents' reimbursement claims are denied in whole or in part, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

    Compensatory education was not warranted because reimbursement for the private OT remedied the gross motor denial.

  17. Issue 6. Are STUDENT's parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?

    The Perlman, Bostani and Berkowitz assessments did not concern gross motor needs. The Vinceneux OT assessment was obtained before the District's reports were issued, not because of disagreement with them, so none were reimbursed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 15 calendar days of receiving paid invoices, the District must reimburse the parents for private OT services from Big Fun Gymnastics and Susan Perrine, from May 9, 2004 until the District implements an IEP corrected to address gross motor needs. No dollar amount was set; the father testified that costs from May through November 2004 were about $1,910.
  • Order to assess. The District must assess the student for gross motor deficits within 15 calendar days of the decision and give the parents 5 calendar days' notice of the assessment date. The parents must make the student reasonably available.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the gross motor assessment, the District must convene an IEP meeting to address gross motor needs.
  • Order that district's offer may be implemented. The District must remain ready and able to implement all portions of its 2004-2005 program offer (Petitioner's Exhibit 33), as corrected under the order.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; M.L. v. Federal Way School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District; Amanda J. v. Clark County School District; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District; Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H.; Lester H. v. Gilhool

People named in the decision

  • Sandra Garrison, school psychologist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Joan Sternberg, speech pathologist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Gwyneth Chua, occupational therapist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Jennifer Fant, autism specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Beryl Adams, autism supervisor, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Charlene Lerman, special education teacher, pre-K/K autism class at Hankey Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Jennifer Acosta, former special education teacher, pre-K/K autism class at Hankey Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District (former)
  • Ms. Walsh, teacher, K-2 special day class at Hankey Elementary, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Rayana Sheli, transition specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Kim Gaither, legal specialist, Capistrano Unified School District
  • Paul Dores, Ph.D., autism consultant; expert witness for District, Capistrano Unified School District (consultant)
  • Sara Larsen, case supervisor, Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD)
  • Betty Bostani, Psy.D., independent autism assessor; witness for Student, formerly employed by CARD
  • Susan Berkowitz, private speech-language pathologist; independent assessor, private practice
  • Chris Vinceneux, private occupational therapist; independent assessor, private practice
  • Mitchel Perlman, M.D., independent assessor (cognitive and social/emotional), private practice
  • Susan Perrine, private one-to-one occupational therapy provider, private practice
  • Big Fun Gymnastics, private OT/gymnastics provider, private provider
  • Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD), private home ABA program provider, private agency
  • ACES, nonpublic agency, prior home program, nonpublic agency
  • Intervention Center for Early Childhood (ICEC), early intervention preschool program, private provider
  • Thelma Utterback, RCOC representative, Regional Center of Orange County
  • Patrick Ruppe, RCOC representative, Regional Center of Orange County
  • Evan Springer, RCOC representative, Regional Center of Orange County
  • Robert White, SELPA representative, South Orange County SELPA
  • Terrence B. Ohler, Hearing Officer who held the prehearing conference, Special Education Hearing Office
  • Haide Valadez, paralegal assisting Student's counsel, Student's counsel
  • Stephen Gonzales, paralegal assisting Student's counsel, Student's counsel

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Juan Capistrano, California, on November 3, 5, and 30, and December 7-10, 14, and 15, 2004.

Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Shelli Lewis. Also present on the Petitioner’s behalf were his parents, FATHER and MOTHER. Respondent Capistrano Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Dan Harbottle. Also present on behalf of the District was Kim Gaither, legal specialist. (Footnote 1) The Petitioner called the following District employees as witnesses: Sandra Garrison, school psychologist; Joan Sternberg, speech pathologist; Gwyneth Chua, occupational therapist; Jennifer Fant, autism specialist; Beryl Adams, autism supervisor; and Charlene Lerman, special education teacher. The Petitioner also called as witnesses Jennifer Acosta, former special education teacher for the District; Sara Larsen, case supervisor at the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD); Betty Bostani, Psy.D., an autism assessor formerly employed by CARD; Susan Berkowitz, speech pathologist; Chris Vinceneux, occupational therapist; MOTHER; and FATHER.

The District called as witnesses Jennifer Fant and Paul Dores, Ph.D., autism consultant for the District. The Hearing Officer recalled Charlene Lerman, and the Petitioner recalled Sara Larsen as a rebuttal witness.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of closing briefs on January 19, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Before testimony was taken, the Petitioner brought a motion to allow his representatives to observe a District classroom taught by Ms. Walsh. He asserted that the District’s special education placement offer at issue in this dispute was a preschool special day class (SDC) at Hankey Elementary School (Hankey) that was taught by Jennifer Acosta at the time of the offer, and that now is taught by Ms. Walsh. The District opposed the motion, asserting that the SDC it had offered to the Petitioner was a prekindergarten-to-kindergarten (pre-K/K) SDC for autistic students at Hankey taught at the time by Ms. Acosta and now taught by Ms. Lerman. The District stated that Ms. Walsh’s class was a kindergarten-to-second-grade SDC that had not been offered to the Petitioner. On the basis of the District’s representations, the Petitioner’s motion to observe Ms. Walsh’s class was denied.

In accordance with a prior order that the parties allow mutual observations of their proposed educational placements, the parties then arranged for Dr. Bostani to observe Ms. Lerman’s pre-K/K class prior to Dr. Bostani’s testimony. The Petitioner asserts that when Dr. Bostani observed Ms. Lerman’s class prior to her testimony, the District “unreasonably” asked her to leave before her evaluation was completed, requiring her to make a second visit to finish the observation. As a sanction, the Petitioner seeks reimbursement from the District for Dr. Bostani’s travel time and expenses in making a second trip from her office in Tarzana to San Juan Capistrano.

A presiding hearing officer may impose sanctions for contempt with the prior approval of the General Counsel of the California Department of Education. Cal. Educ. Code § 3088. Contempt is defined in relevant part as noncompliance with a lawful order by the hearing officer, or as unlawful interference with the proceedings before the hearing officer. Cal. Govt. Code § 11445.10. Petitioner has failed to indicate why the District’s action was unreasonable, or how it constituted either a violation of the prior order or unlawful interference with the proceedings. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer declines to impose sanctions.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING

The issues for hearing were clarified at a prehearing conference and set forth in detail in a memorandum dated October 25, 2004. (Footnote 2) They are summarized as follows:

Issue No. 1: Did the District assess STUDENT adequately?

Issue No. 2: From May 9, 2004, through the end of the 2004-2005 school year, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment? (Footnote 3)

Issue No. 3: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to prospective placement in a CARD home program and other related services for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

Issue No. 4: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of all educational expenses incurred since May 9, 2004?

Issue No. 5: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE and if the parents’ reimbursement claims are denied in whole or in part, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

Issue No. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner contends that the District’s 2004-2005 program offer was inappropriate in several respects. First, he asserts that the District failed to assess him adequately. Second, he asserts that the District’s offer was procedurally inadequate because the District (1) failed to have appropriate personnel present at his individualized education program (IEP) meetings; (2) failed to make an appropriately specific offer of placement; and (3) made a predetermined, “boilerplate” offer that failed to consider his parents’ input during the IEP process.

Substantively, the Petitioner asserts that the District failed to develop sufficiently challenging goals and objectives; failed to adequately address his behavioral and sensory needs; and failed to offer sufficient speech and language (S/L) therapy or sufficient supervision of its offered intensive behavioral intervention (IBI) program. Further, he asserts that he is unable to learn in a group setting such as a pre-K/K class; that the class he was offered was particularly unsuitable due to the presence of some older students; and that the teaching methods in the District’s pre-K/K classes are unsuitable for him. The Petitioner also contends that the District’s program failed to adequately address the risk of skill regression over the summer.

Finally, the Petitioner asserts that the District’s offer of a pre-K/K class violated its obligation to provide him with a FAPE in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE).

Due to the District’s alleged failures, the Petitioner contends he is entitled to prospective services from CARD and to other related services, including S/L, occupational therapy (OT), and transportation expenses. The Petitioner further seeks reimbursement for CARD, S/L, and OT services he has received since his third birthday, which at the date of the hearing amounted to approximately $56,000, and which continue to accrue. In the event his reimbursement claims are rejected in whole or in part, the Petitioner seeks an award of compensatory education. Further, the Petitioner seeks reimbursement for independent assessments obtained by his parents.

The District contends that its offer to the Petitioner constituted a FAPE, but that the Petitioner’s parents were only interested in the CARD program. It alleges that it invited the parents’ input and participation at IEP meetings, and modified the proposed goals and objectives in accordance with their requests. The District further contends that its offer of a pre-K/K SDC constitutes the least restrictive environment for the Petitioner, because too much one-to-one instruction might prejudice his future ability to learn in a group setting. It asserts that its structured SDC, with its low staff-to-student ratio, would have addressed the Petitioner’s social/emotional and behavioral needs. The District denies that the Petitioner is entitled to prospective CARD or other services, compensatory education, or reimbursement for educational expenses or independent assessments.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a three-year-old child with autism-spectrum disorder. He was first diagnosed with developmental delays and autism-related symptoms at the age of fourteen months, and was referred to the Regional Center of Orange County (RCOC) for early intervention services in July of 2002. Early assessments indicated normal hearing and vision, mild delays in cognitive and motor development, moderate to severe delays in social/emotional development, and severe delays in receptive and expressive communication. (S. Exh. 2.)

STUDENT also has chronic health problems. He regularly suffers from gastrointestinal irritation and diarrhea, and takes Prevacid for acid reflux. STUDENT’s doctors have described him as showing “failure to thrive” (poor weight gain), and currently he weighs only thirty pounds. STUDENT also has many food allergies, and resists eating many different types of foods. (Testimony of MOTHER.)

STUDENT’s early educational programs (September 2002-September 2003)

When STUDENT was sixteen months old, he was placed by RCOC in a preschool program at the Intervention Center for Early Childhood (ICEC) with a dozen or more other children with global developmental delays. In the ICEC program, the children rotated among five stations addressing different developmental needs. According to MOTHER, STUDENT could not adjust to the transitions, because every time he began to adapt to a station, it would be time to move to the next one. He also was sick “all the time” during this period, missing many program dates and feeling ill during others. STUDENT attended ICEC from September to December of 2002, but spent so much time crying and screaming that his parents ultimately determined that he was unable to learn in a group setting and withdrew him from the program. (S. Exhs. 1, 2, 49; testimony of MOTHER.)

In January of 2003, RCOC approved a home program for STUDENT, and he began to receive ten hours per week of home instruction from ACES, a nonpublic agency. In May, RCOC approved an increase in services from ten to twenty hours per week. The PARENTS initially were pleased with the new program because STUDENT stopped crying and screaming, but ultimately they determined he was making little progress in skill building. According to MOTHER, the ACES tutors were poorly supervised and their instruction methods were inconsistent.

The CARD program (September 2003-present)

In September of 2003, the PARENTS withdrew STUDENT from ACES and enrolled him in the Center for Autism and Related Disorders (CARD) home instruction program for 20 hours per week. The CARD program, which was funded by RCOC, consisted of behavior modification strategies and skill building drills provided by a rotating group of home tutors regularly supervised by a senior tutor or case manager. By March of 2004, STUDENT had matured enough to be able to pay more attention to learning, and RCOC funded an increase in his CARD program hours to 35 hours per week.

The PARENTS have been very pleased with the CARD program, and recently increased STUDENT’s program to 40 hours per week. (Footnote 4) The PARENTS believe STUDENT has made significant progress from September 2003 to the present, and believe CARD has been instrumental in reducing STUDENT’s maladaptive behaviors and increasing his skill levels. (Testimony of FATHER and MOTHER.)

STUDENT’s assessments by the District (March-April 2004)

In February and March of 2004, the PARENTS met with District representatives to plan STUDENT’s transition into a District-supervised educational program upon his third birthday on May 9, 2004. (S. Exh. 7.) In a visit to the PARENTS home, District school psychologist Sandra Garrison and District speech pathologist Joan Sternberg interviewed MOTHER and an RCOC representative about STUDENT, his needs, and any concerns the PARENTS might have about his transition into the District. In discussing STUDENT’s potential placement options, Ms. Garrison told MOTHER that “traditionally, the District looks to a group or school program; that’s probably what you can expect.” During the meeting, which lasted approximately ninety minutes, Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg developed an assessment plan for STUDENT. (S. Exhs. 8-12; testimony of MOTHER and Ms. Garrison.)

After obtaining the PARENTS’ agreement to the plan, the District assessed STUDENT through direct observations and standardized tests administered by Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, and occupational therapist Gwyneth Chua. The tests measured STUDENT’s current levels of performance in areas of cognition, communication, adaptive skills, fine motor skills, sensory processing, behavior, and socialization. In addition, the District assessors and the school nurse reviewed STUDENT’s medical records and his educational records from RCOC, CARD, and other programs. (S. Exhs. 14-23, 25-29.) (Footnote 5)

Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg conducted their assessments of STUDENT on March 22, March 30, and April 12, 2004, at the PARENTS home and in an elementary school room. Each assessment period lasted between one and two hours, and consisted of direct observation and testing of STUDENT as well as interviews with MOTHER. A summary report of the assessment results placed STUDENT in the moderate to severe range of autism, with a composite score of one year four months in overall development (STUDENT was two years eleven months old at the time of the assessments). STUDENT’s scores were highest in fine motor skills (two years four months), and lowest in socialization (zero years, four to eleven months in different areas). (S. Exh. 25.)

In adaptive skills, STUDENT could pull up his pants and remove front-opening shirts. He would tug at his pants when his diapers needed changing, and was beginning to be toilet-trained. He could eat solid foods and drink from a cup or straw, but would overstuff his mouth and often would choke while drinking. He could spear food with a fork but did not yet bring it to his mouth without assistance. STUDENT showed sensitivity to tone of voice, and would smile in response to positive statements. He was beginning to engage in imitative play, and with adult modeling, could kiss and pretend to feed dolls.

With respect to his gross motor abilities, STUDENT could walk and climb on low play equipment. He had poor balance, however, and often would fall when attempting to run. STUDENT could not walk downstairs with alternating feet without assistance, nor could he hop on one foot, jump over low obstacles, or pedal a tricycle. (Footnote 6)

In her direct observations, Ms. Garrison noted that STUDENT was sweet-natured, tried hard to perform the tasks presented, and was easy to work with. “As with most autistic children,” however, he had difficulty paying attention to the task at hand. (Footnote 7) STUDENT engaged in some self-stimulatory behaviors, such as squinting, repetitive jargon, and preoccupation with long objects. The TABS test assessing STUDENT’s temperament and atypical behaviors indicated that STUDENT did not exhibit many “hyperactive or hypersensitive” behaviors, such as being easily upset or frustrated, but did exhibit many symptoms of “detachment,” such as ignoring others and being overstimulated by too much light or noise. (S. Exhs. 19, 25; testimony of Ms. Garrison.)

Ms. Sternberg administered S/L assessments, and determined that STUDENT was below average in expressive and receptive language skills, with an age equivalency of about one year six months. STUDENT could follow simple familiar directions with cues, respond to safety directions such as “stop” or “wait,” use objects appropriately in play, and point to some body parts. He did not understand verbs in context or spatial concepts such as “in” or “out.” STUDENT satisfied his wants primarily by pulling a caregiver toward a desired object. He was beginning to use a few words in a general way (such as “chip” for all types of food), and could produce most age-appropriate consonant sounds. Ms. Sternberg determined that STUDENT did not show any oral motor or articulation problems.

On April 16, 2004, STUDENT was assessed by the District’s occupational therapist, Gwyneth Chua. The assessment was conducted in an OT clinic at a District elementary school and lasted for about an hour. FATHER brought STUDENT to the clinic and remained in the room throughout the assessment.

Ms. Chua assessed STUDENT for fine motor and visual motor skills, but did not conduct any gross motor tests because none was called for by the assessment plan and because she did not notice any gross motor deficits in her observations of STUDENT. (Footnote 8) Ms. Chua observed that STUDENT separated easily from his father, and immediately began to explore the array of toys and equipment in the OT clinic. He initially refused to engage with Ms. Chua, but eventually complied with her requests after multiple instruction, demonstration, and physical prompting. STUDENT exhibited echolalia and self-stimulatory behaviors such as toe-walking, and never engaged in eye contact. He would scream when requested to do a new task, but when Ms. Chua would say “do this and then we’ll take a break,” he would comply. (Footnote 9)

Ms. Chua’s assessment report indicated that STUDENT could finger-feed himself, drink from a sippie cup, help with dressing and undressing himself, and respond appropriately to routine directions given in context with a gesture prompt. He showed interest in adults and would engage in interactive play with them such as peek-a-boo and tickling. STUDENT also had started to use some Picture Exchange Identification System (PECS) icons to communicate wants and needs at home. In terms of maladaptive behaviors, the report indicated that STUDENT would engage in self-stimulatory behavior constantly unless redirected by his parents or tutors, and showed a high degree of resistance to transitions from preferred activities to new or non-preferred tasks.

STUDENT demonstrated below average fine motor skills, with an age equivalency of about fifteen months. He could pick up items with a pincer grasp without difficulty, but still used his fist to grasp and draw with a writing tool. STUDENT showed slightly higher visual motor skills to accomplish eye-hand coordination tasks, with an age equivalency of about twenty-five months. He could stack blocks, insert shapes correctly on a form board, and unscrew a bottle lid. STUDENT could string beads after a demonstration, but could not manipulate scissors correctly. He imitated horizontal and vertical lines by scribbling, and refused to copy block shapes.

Ms. Chua also tested STUDENT for sensory processing deficits that might be interfering with his ability to function. She found that STUDENT showed definite differences from typically developing children in auditory processing, sensory sensitivity, sensation avoiding, and having a low sensory input threshold. Ms. Chua developed a “sensory diet” for STUDENT, consisting of recommended activities he could engage in at home, such as swinging on a swing, rubbing lotion into hands, and playing tug-of-war, that would improve his body awareness and increase his ability to tolerate sensations. She also developed a list of recommended pre-scissor activities, such as using salad tongs and squirting water from a spray bottle, to develop his fine motor skills. (S. Exhs. 27, 30 and 31; testimony of Ms. Chua.)

STUDENT’s private assessments (March-September 2004)

In March of 2004, the PARENTS referred STUDENT to Chris Vinceneux, a private OT consultant, for a comprehensive OT and sensory processing evaluation. (Footnote 10) Mr. Vinceneux reported that STUDENT had poor coordination, balance, posture, and body awareness. Due to poor motor planning skills, STUDENT was unable to imitate simple but unfamiliar body movements, climb on equipment, or catch or throw a ball. STUDENT showed initial interest in play equipment but became confused and gave up on activities he could not understand or imitate. Mr. Vinceneux also noted that STUDENT’s frequent self-stimulatory behavior interfered with his attention to task and his exploration of his environment. He recommended OT services at a rate of two hours per week, with regular staff/parent consultations to make sure STUDENT’s learning environment was organized to minimize confusion and distraction. He also recommended the development of a sensory diet to help STUDENT remain focused and organized. (S. Exh. 46.) (Footnote 11)

In April of 2004, the PARENTS referred STUDENT to Susan Berkowitz, a private S/L therapist, for an evaluation of his current skill levels and needs. Ms. Berkowitz first observed STUDENT working with his CARD therapist, and noted that STUDENT “displayed appropriate session and attending skills” and responded consistently to almost all tasks presented. STUDENT then proceeded to work with Ms. Berkowitz for almost an hour.

Ms. Berkowitz reported that STUDENT demonstrated severely delayed S/L skills, with an age equivalency of one year four months. Based on his prior assessments, however, STUDENT had shown great improvement over the past several months. He showed greater communicative intent and ability to express himself with PECS symbols, increased oral-motor imitation skills, greater understanding of directions, and improved attention to task. Ms. Berkowitz recommended that STUDENT continue to receive S/L therapy “at least 3-4 times weekly,” continue with “all current CARD goals,” and continue with his CARD home program. In a follow-up evaluation conducted in August, Ms. Berkowitz again noted that STUDENT was cooperative and attentive during her assessment despite the fact that he had just returned from an S/L therapy session. She reported that STUDENT’s labeling skills and his ability to imitate words had improved, and that although prior standardized tests could not be repeated due to practice effect, his S/L skills showed enough improvement to place them in an age range of approximately two years (an increase of eight months over his April assessment score). (S. Exhs. 24, 41.)

In July of 2004, the PARENTS referred STUDENT to Mitchel Perlman, M.D., for an assessment of his cognitive and social/emotional needs. Dr. Perlman administered some standardized tests, reviewed those previously administered by the District, viewed tapes of STUDENT in his CARD program, and spoke with his CARD supervisor. He concluded that STUDENT’s language processing deficits made it difficult to assess his cognitive skills and that his social/emotional functioning was low and should be addressed in his goals and objectives. Dr. Perlman recommended that STUDENT continue with the CARD program in light of the progress reported by CARD in STUDENT’s ability to communicate, attend to task, and reduce his maladaptive behaviors. (S. Exh. 40.)

In September of 2004, the PARENTS referred STUDENT to Betty Bostani, Psy.D., for a diagnostic evaluation and assessment. At the time of the assessment, Dr. Bostani was employed by CARD. Her assessment, which was based on parental interviews and a review of STUDENT’s prior assessments and records, indicated that STUDENT was unaware when his actions bothered others, played carelessly and without regard to physical danger, and did not regulate his behavior to suit his social environment. He also had a short attention span and needed adult assistance to stay focused on a task. STUDENT was often overwhelmed and overstimulated in crowded, busy situations, and was disturbed by changes in his environment. Dr. Bostani concluded that STUDENT’s considerable deficits indicated that he should remain in his home-based CARD program. (S. Exh. 47.)

The initial IEP meeting ( April 22, 2004) (Footnote 12)

On April 22, 2004, the District convened an initial IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s assessments and review proposals for his placement and his educational goals and objectives. (Footnote 13) In advance of the meeting, the District had prepared a proposed transition plan from CARD to District services, and had drafted an outline of recommended placement and services to be provided in a structured pre-K/K SDC at Hankey Elementary School, STUDENT’s school of residence. (S. Exh. 33, pp. 1, 6, and 13.)

Also in advance of the meeting, the District assessors had prepared summary assessment reports and had drafted proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT. Copies of the proposed goals and objectives were not delivered to the PARENTS until 9:00 p.m. the night before the 9:00 a.m. meeting, however, and copies of the assessment reports apparently were not provided to the PARENTS until the meeting itself. (Testimony of MOTHER.) (Footnote 14)

At the meeting, the IEP team members first reviewed the District assessment reports page by page, and the PARENTS were invited to correct any errors in the reports. (Footnote 15) The team reviewed and clarified STUDENT’s food allergies, and agreed that in a school setting STUDENT should only be given food sent from his home. Ms. Garrison noted that STUDENT had been cooperative in the assessments and had not seemed upset or uncomfortable in the school settings where they were conducted. The PARENTS stated that STUDENT was cooperative “as long as you don’t ask him to do anything,” and Ms. Garrison responded that initial resistance to new settings and tasks was “pretty typical for all of our kids,” and was viewed as part of the learning process. The team members also discussed STUDENT’s self-stimulatory behaviors and the strategies the PARENTS had developed to deal with them.

Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, and Ms. Chua then explained the standardized tests that they had administered as a part of their assessments, how the tests were scored, and how the test results helped develop a baseline of STUDENT’s current skills that the assessors used as the foundation for their proposed goals and objectives. They solicited further input from the PARENTS to get a better picture of STUDENT’s current performance levels, and the PARENTS observed that some of the tasks STUDENT had failed to perform during the assessments were things he was able to do, with prompts, in the home setting. At the conclusion of each part of the discussion, the District representatives asked the PARENTS if they had any further questions or comments before the IEP team moved to a new topic.

The District assessors then explained their proposed educational goals and objectives for STUDENT and noted that many of the goals would look familiar since they were based not only on the assessment results, but also on the goals that had been developed for STUDENT by CARD. They asked the PARENTS for updates on any CARD goals STUDENT had mastered so that corresponding District goals could be modified accordingly. (Ms. Sternberg added that even in some cases where mastery had occurred, she would suggest retaining the goal as drafted so it could be generalized to the school setting.) The assessors also explained that in addition to one-to-one drills, many of the goals would be addressed in different ways as part of the normal school routine.

MOTHER noted that the goal for attending to task for three minutes was not challenging enough, because STUDENT could sit for ten to fifteen minutes doing tasks he enjoyed. The District agreed to revise the goal to increase the time span to five minutes and to specify that it was to apply only to non-preferred tasks. (Footnote 16) At MOTHER’s suggestion, the District also revised goals involving matching pictures, matching colors, responding to greetings, and fine motor skills in order to make them more challenging for STUDENT. As the team discussed each goal, the District asked the PARENTS if they agreed with the goal as drafted or modified before moving to the next goal. The PARENTS gave verbal assents to some of the goals during the meeting, but stated that they needed more time to review the goals before formally agreeing to them.

A follow-up meeting was scheduled to continue the discussion of proposed goals and proposed placement. In the meantime, it was agreed that the PARENTS would observe Ms. Acosta’s pre-K/K class, where the District proposed to place STUDENT, to get a sense of how the school setting would compare with STUDENT’s CARD home program. (S. Exhs. 33, 48; testimony of FATHER and MOTHER, Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, and Ms. Chua.)

Follow-up meeting to the April 22 IEP (May 4, 2004)

On May 4, the IEP team met again to continue the discussions begun at the April 22 meeting. (Footnote 17) The District gave the PARENTS copies of the April 22 IEP document with handwritten changes reflecting the goal modifications made at the earlier meeting. The PARENTS expressed concerns about the time gaps between the end of the 2004 school year and the ESY program, noting that after a recent week-long vacation during which STUDENT missed three days of CARD therapy, it took him three weeks to recoup his skills. The District acknowledged that children regress during school breaks and explained that it tracked Petitioners’ “regression recoupment” skills during weekends and other breaks over the school year to determine whether or how to extend ESY programs to address their regression. The District noted that, since STUDENT had not yet been in school, it did not know how he would regress over breaks, but that it would gather data once he was in school to determine if his ESY program should be extended.

The PARENTS asked if they could discuss the placement recommendation, but the District responded that it was important to resolve the issue of goals and objectives first because the goals drive the program and determine the placement. The team then resumed its discussion of the proposed goals and objectives, but ultimately, the PARENTS said they were unprepared to agree to them as a whole. MOTHER said she couldn’t tell if the proposed goals were “enough” or if they were “too much.” She needed more time to think about the goals in relation to the times allotted for each benchmark and didn’t know how to determine when STUDENT might be able to accomplish a particular task.

In response, the District pointed out that the proposed goals and objectives merely represented a baseline, and if they turned out to be insufficiently challenging for STUDENT, the team could meet in thirty days to raise the challenge levels accordingly. The District noted that children often experience lulls and growth spurts in their learning process and that the monthly student progress meetings proposed by the IEP were a way to keep up with STUDENT’s progress and to modify his goals as necessary.

The discussion turned to reinforcement strategies to encourage STUDENT to comply with unfamiliar tasks and drills. The District offered to inform STUDENT’s instructors that the PARENTS wanted to avoid use of food as a reinforcement tool as much as possible (although MOTHER acknowledged that, “if you’re doing a new drill, you’re pretty much going to have to haul out the chocolate chips”), and the group discussed the use of secondary reinforcement strategies such as toys and praise. The PARENTS stated that STUDENT would respond positively to hugs and “atta-boys,” and the District noted that this was a useful development for STUDENT’s ability to learn.

The team next discussed the PARENTS’ visit to Ms. Acosta’s classroom. The PARENTS stated that they had observed some one-to-one instruction, but hadn’t been able to observe any transitions from one activity to another in a group setting. Since transitions had posed a major problem for STUDENT in the ICEC program, the PARENTS wanted to see how they were handled in the District classroom. Accordingly, the District arranged for MOTHER to do another observation of Ms. Acosta’s class the next week, and suggested that she visit Charlene Lerman’s class as well, since that class had younger children more representative of the age group Ms. Acosta would have when the 2004-2005 school year commenced in the fall.

Ultimately, MOTHER asked if there were any placement options other than Ms. Acosta’s pre-K/K class. The District responded that Ms. Acosta’s class was its recommendation, and indicated that it would prefer to discuss with the PARENTS anything about the placement that made them uncomfortable rather than “just kind of willy nilly go out and try to find something [different].” The District acknowledged the PARENTS’ concerns about the ages of some of the children in Ms. Acosta’s class, but noted that the class composition would change soon as the older children moved on to first grade and other children STUDENT’s age entered in the fall. The District also noted that some of its other preschool SDCs either were further away than Hankey, the PARENTS’ neighborhood school, or were less appropriate because they were designed for children with disabilities other than autism.

The PARENTS stated that they were “struggling” with the placement recommendation because STUDENT’s experience in the ICEC program had been so bad and he had made so little progress. In contrast, after being in the CARD home program for only four months STUDENT was “not even the same child.” The PARENTS admitted, however, that STUDENT had been ill during much of his time with ICEC and they weren’t sure how that had affected his progress. The District acknowledged the PARENTS’ fears that STUDENT’s bad experience could happen again, but observed that many fears based on past experiences prove unfounded. The IEP team agreed to meet again after the PARENTS had a chance to do a follow-up observation of Ms. Acosta’s class. (S. Exh. 49.)

Second follow-up IEP meeting (May 11, 2004)

On May 11, the IEP team met to complete the program and placement discussions begun on April 22. (Footnote 18) MOTHER said she had visited Ms. Acosta’s classroom again and had decided that she did not feel it was the right placement for STUDENT. First, she noted that there were “way too many distractions” for him. Further, she was concerned about the age of the children in the class, some of whom were five and six in the spring of 2004. MOTHER said that because STUDENT was just turning three and was of small size and weight, she was afraid for his physical safety in a class with older and larger children. She also was concerned that when other children exhibited problem behaviors, they would require so much instructor time and attention that the teacher-student ratio would diminish for STUDENT and the other children. She noted that she had seen a child continually bite his arm and hand without being redirected by an adult, which gave her concerns about classroom supervision.

MOTHER said she felt STUDENT needed a home environment and one-to-one instruction at this stage of his development, particularly because he regularly cycled through maladaptive behaviors that required a caregiver to be “on him” immediately so that the behavior could be extinguished. FATHER added that there was only a short span of years – until age six or seven – in which STUDENT’s development could be significantly molded and that they wanted to make the best use of that time. He said their eventual goal was to move STUDENT into “a mainstream environment” and the best path was to give him one-to-one support at this early stage.

The District asked what maladaptive behaviors the PARENTS were concerned about, and the team discussed STUDENT’s screaming, self-stimulatory behaviors, and noncompliance with directions. The discussion then turned to the proposed goals and objectives. The PARENTS said that they felt the time lines for the goals weren’t aggressive enough for STUDENT, since their goal was to “move him up to his peers” and he was far behind his peers in skill development. The District again noted that the goals as drafted were merely a starting point and that if STUDENT progressed through them faster than anticipated, the team could meet as often as necessary to update the goals. The District pointed out that CARD has a different review and update process, but that the District program, like CARD, was geared to adjust to an individual Petitioner’s progress.

The PARENTS stated that much of the District program included learning in a group setting and that they felt a group setting was not a priority for STUDENT right then. They felt he had made so much progress with CARD that its approach was preferable at that point. The District observed that it had found that increased social interaction actually helps children generalize their skills and progress more quickly than they would in a strictly one-to-one setting. FATHER responded, however, that he was “convinced that [the CARD] program is going to give him as good a chance as he has right now.”

The PARENTS concluded that they would like the District to provide the CARD home program to STUDENT for forty hours per week. The District noted that it also had a home program, but the PARENTS responded that they wanted CARD. After the District summarized its program offer, and attempted to describe how the parent training component of the program might address some of the PARENTS’ concerns, the parties acknowledged that they had failed to reach agreement on a program and placement for STUDENT.

On August 20, 2004, the PARENTS filed their request for a due process hearing.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Issue No. 1: Did the District assess STUDENT adequately?

Federal and State law require an LEA to conduct an initial evaluation of a child with a suspected disability to determine whether the child qualifies for special education services, and if so, to determine the child’s educational needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320. These statutes require, among other things, that evaluations under the IDEA be conducted by knowledgeable personnel using a variety of validated assessment tools and strategies, and that they assess the child in all areas of suspected disability. Id. They also require LEA evaluators to review existing evaluation data on the child, including information provided by the child’s parents, teachers and service providers. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(c); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

The Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess him adequately because its assessors spent too little time with him, failed to observe him in his home program, and failed to solicit the input of his CARD instructors. Further, he asserts that the PLS-4 language test administered by the District was not scored in compliance with prescribed scoring standards. Finally, the Petitioner asserts that the District failed to assess him appropriately in the areas of self-help needs, self-stimulatory behaviors, and communication skills; failed to identify the severity of his noncompliant behavior; and failed to adequately assess his gross motor needs.

The District responds that its assessors were highly qualified and experienced, and appropriately assessed STUDENT through proper administration of standardized tests, parent interviews, and review of STUDENT’s prior assessments, medical records, and performance data. It notes that with the exception of the PLS-4 test, the Petitioner has challenged none of the assessment protocols or their results. Finally, the District points out that its findings as to STUDENT’s deficits were in most respects confirmed by the independent assessments obtained by the PARENTS. (Footnote 19)

The Hearing Officer finds that with respect to the Garrison/Sternberg assessment, the evidence indicates that STUDENT was assessed appropriately by the District. Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg are highly qualified professionals, each with almost twenty years’ experience in their respective fields. They administered a broad array of standardized test instruments to STUDENT in both home and school settings on three separate days, for one to two hours each day. Further, they reviewed his education and medical records and interviewed his mother at length. Ms. Garrison testified that the educational data she reviewed from CARD included STUDENT’s intake assessment, goals and objectives, and progress reports on his home program. The Hearing Officer finds that the Garrison/Sternberg assessment complied with IDEA standards for thoroughness and breadth, and due to its inclusion of an extensive review of CARD documentation, was not rendered inadequate by a failure to observe STUDENT in his home program or to seek additional input from CARD personnel.

Nor does the Petitioner’s assertion that the District improperly scored the PLS-4 language test indicate that he was assessed inadequately. Ms. Sternberg acknowledged that when administering the PLS-4 to preschoolers, she sometimes modifies the standardized basal and ceiling limits establishing a child’s skill range by stopping before all tasks are attempted if she is satisfied that the child either can or cannot perform at that skill level. She adjusted the ceiling level for STUDENT to keep him from being unduly frustrated during the assessment process. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Sternberg’s credentials and experience qualify her to make such decisions. Further, Ms. Berkowitz, who conducted the Petitioner’s private S/L assessment, acknowledged that such a variance probably would have had little or no effect on the test results.

With the minor exception noted above, there is no evidence to indicate that the assessment was out of compliance with any State or federal requirement, and significantly, the Petitioner has not challenged the validity of any specific test result. Further, the independent assessors’ findings as to STUDENT’s deficits and needs do not appear to vary significantly from those noted by the District. Both the District and Dr. Bostani determined that STUDENT’s autism fell in the moderate to severe range, with the District reporting a CARS score of 39.5 and Dr. Bostani a score of 37. The District rated STUDENT as severely deficient (in the one percent range) in interpersonal relationships and play skills when it administered the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales in March of 2004; Dr. Perlman rated him in the same percentile when he administered the Vineland in July 2004.

Although the Petitioner alleges that the District’s assessments failed to address his self-help needs, communication skills, maladaptive behaviors, and compliance issues, he cites no specific incidents of failure, and his allegations are not supported by the evidence. The Garrison/Sternberg assessment specifically addressed STUDENT’s self-help needs (feeding, grooming, dressing, toileting) through administration of the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales (VABS) questionnaire; his communication skills through the PLS-4 and parent interview; his self-stimulatory and other maladaptive behaviors through the Temperament and Atypical Behavior Scale (TABS) questionnaire; and his noncompliant behaviors through parent interview and direct observation. (See S. Exhs. 14-19, 25.)

Further, although STUDENT’s CARD records indicated serious tantrum and noncompliance issues when he enrolled in that program in September 2003, they also indicated (and CARD witnesses testified) that these behaviors had been significantly reduced over the course of the program. On the TABS questionnaire provided by the District as a part of its assessment in March 2004, MOTHER reported that tantrums, mood swings, irritability, severe noncompliance, impulsivity, and aggressive behavior were “not a problem” for STUDENT. (S. Exh. 19.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the Garrison/Sternberg assessment adequately addressed STUDENT’s self-help and communication needs and his maladaptive and noncompliant behaviors.

Ms. Chua’s OT assessment of STUDENT consisted of direct observation, standardized tests, a record review, and a parent interview. Contrary to the Petitioner’s allegations, the assessment directly addressed STUDENT’s sensory processing deficits and how they interfered with his ability to learn. Both Ms. Chua and Mr. Vinceneux, the PARENTS’ private OT assessor, administered the Sensory Profile parent interview, and both concluded that STUDENT had severe processing deficits, particularly in the areas of auditory processing and low threshold for response to stimuli. (Compare S. Exhs. 27 and 46.)

With respect to STUDENT’s gross motor needs, however, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the Petitioner. Ms. Chua testified that she did not assess STUDENT for gross motor deficits because it was not required by the assessment plan. However, the plan indicates only that assessment was required by an occupational therapist; it does not specify whether assessment should occur in the areas of fine motor, gross motor, or both. (S. Exh. 9.) The Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales parent interview conducted by the District on March 22, 2004, indicated that STUDENT had poor balance, would fall when running, could not descend stairs with alternating feet without assistance, and could not hop, jump over low obstacles, climb on high play equipment, or pedal a tricycle. (S. Exh. 16.) In their scoring of the Vineland and in their final report, District assessors Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg noted that STUDENT’s gross motorskills were lower than his fine motor skills. (S. Exhs. 17, 25.) (Footnote 20)

As this information provided the District with knowledge of gross motor deficits but failed to prompt an assessment in that area, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. Further, given the gross motor deficits described above, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has gross motor needs that should be addressed by his goals and objectives.

Issue No. 2: From May 9, 2004, through the end of the 2004-2005 school year, did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment?

Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a student free of charge, that meet the standards of the State educational agency, and that are provided in conformity with the student’s IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(17); Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3001(2).

A claim that there has been a denial of a FAPE can present both procedural and substantive questions. Among the IDEA’s procedural mandates is the requirement that the process for the development of the IEP allow the parents to meaningfully participate in it. Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 206-207, 102 S. Ct. 3034 (1982). Not every procedural flaw is critical, but one that results in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP process may constitute a denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Board Of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483-1484 (9th Cir. 1992).

Substantively, the determination of a FAPE is based on the appropriateness of the educational program offered or provided by the local education agency (LEA) to the disabled student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court stated that the LEA is not required to provide a student with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. Rather, the Court held that an LEA is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to meet the student’s needs, reasonably calculated to provide him or her with some educational benefit, and that comport with the student’s IEP. Id. at 201. While this requires an LEA to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not require the LEA to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).

Federal and State law also require that LEAs educate disabled children in the least restrictive environment (LRE), with removal from the regular educational environment occurring only when the nature and severity of the children’s disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56301.

In summary, a determination of whether the District offered STUDENT a FAPE requires the Hearing Officer to examine (1) whether the District met the IDEA’s procedural requirements, and (2) whether the substantive program offered to STUDENT was individually designed to meet his needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. (Footnote 21) If the District has offered a FAPE, its proposed program must then be reviewed to determine if it would educate STUDENT in the least restrictive environment.

A. Procedural issues

The Petitioner asserts that the District made procedural errors in its 2004-2005 program offer by (1) failing to have appropriate personnel at his IEP meetings; (2) failing to make an appropriately specific offer of placement; and (3) making a predetermined, “boilerplate” offer without considering his parents’ input during the IEP process. Each of these issues is addressed below.

(1) Did the District fail to have appropriate personnel present at the IEP meetings?

The Petitioner alleges the District failed to have a general education teacher or a CARD representative present at the IEP meeting or its two follow-up meetings, or an OT provider at the follow-up meetings. He asserts that these failings constitute procedural violations of the IDEA.

One of the procedural safeguards afforded by the IDEA is the right to have appropriate people attending IEP meetings to make decisions about a disabled Petitioner’s education. Federal law provides that an IEP team must include, among others:

(i) the parents of a child with a disability;

(ii) at least one regular education teacher of such child (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment); (iii) at least one special education teacher, or where appropriate, at least one special education provider of such child; (iv) a representative of the local educational agency [with specified knowledge and qualifications]; (v) an individual who can interpret the instructional implications of evaluation results [who may also qualify as a team member in another category]; (vi) at the discretion of the parent or the agency, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the child, including related service personnel as appropriate; and (vii) whenever appropriate, the child with a disability.

20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(B) (emphasis added); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.344(a).

In M.L. v. Federal Way School District, 341 F.3d 1052 (9th Cir. 2003), the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the plain meaning of this statute requires at least one regular education teacher to be included on an IEP team “if the student may be participating in a regular classroom.” In that case, student M.L. had been in an “integrated” preschool and kindergarten with some disabled and some typically developing peers. In a note to the IEP team, M.L.’s preschool teacher recommended that he “remain in a general education kindergarten.” No general education teacher was present at the IEP meeting, however, and over his parents’ objection, the IEP team ultimately recommended placement in a more restrictive setting. The Ninth Circuit found that since the evidence indicated a distinct possibility that M.L. might have participated in a regular classroom, the absence of a regular education teacher from his IEP meeting was a fatal procedural flaw.

In this case, neither of the parties ever has suggested that STUDENT might have participated in a regular education setting. The District’s recommended placement was a special education pre-K/K class, and the PARENTS are seeking a home program – a more restrictive setting than that recommended by the District. Thus, the requirement that a general education teacher must be present at the IEP meeting “if the child is, or will be, participating in the regular education environment” is not at issue in STUDENT’s case.

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT’s IEP team included all personnel required by the statute, including STUDENT’s parents, special education teacher Ms. Acosta, District personnel familiar with the District’s resources and educational options, and the District assessors who explained their test results to the PARENTS. Further, the IEP team included OT instructor Ms. Chua, who attended the first meeting, explained her assessment results to the PARENTS and reviewed her proposed OT goals and objectives with them. Federal law provides that related service providers such as Ms. Chua attend IEP meetings “at the discretion of the parent or agency,” and the District appropriately provided for her input at the April 22 meeting. There is no indication in the IEP transcripts that the PARENTS sought further information from Ms. Chua that would have necessitated her presence at the two follow-up meetings.

The District acknowledges that it did not exercise its discretion to invite a CARD representative to the IEP meetings, noting that it had received extensive records from CARD, which had been reviewed and taken into account in preparing the District’s proposed placement offer and goals and objectives. Although the Petitioner asserts that a CARD representative should have been present at the meetings, the PARENTS acknowledged that they knew they had the discretion to extend this invitation themselves, but chose not to do so. (Footnote 22)

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that neither the absence of a general education teacher or a CARD representative at the three IEP meetings, nor the absence of an OT instructor at two of those meetings, constituted a procedural violation of the IDEA.

(2) Did the District fail to make an appropriately specific formal offer of placement?

The Petitioner asserts that the District failed to clearly identify the class offered for STUDENT’s placement. He notes that the April 22 IEP refers only to a “structured pre-K” class at Hankey Elementary School, without naming the classroom teacher. (Footnote 23)The Petitioner asserts that the District referred to Ms. Acosta’s class as the recommended placement at the IEP meetings, but later indicated that Ms. Lerman’s class was the offered placement.

The District responds that its written placement offer in the April 22 IEP clearly identified the recommended placement as a “structured pre-K class” for autistic students at Hankey. When the offer was extended in April 2004, there were two such classes at Hankey, taught by Ms. Lerman and Ms. Acosta, and the District informed the PARENTS that it intended to place STUDENT in Ms. Acosta’s class. (S. Exhs. 48-50.) Some time after the PARENTS rejected the District’s offer, Ms. Acosta resigned her position, and the District informed the PARENTS that Ms. Lerman would be teaching the structured pre-K/K class at Hankey for the 2004-2005 school year. (Footnote 24)

Federal law requires an LEA to make a “formal, written offer” of placement under the IDEA. Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S. Ct. 428 (1994). In Union, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that a formal offer was required in order to (1) provide a clear factual record for later review; (2) assist the parents in presenting complaints about the placement; (3) allow the parents to decide whether to accept the placement; and (4) assist the LEA in presenting relevant evidence about the placement offered. A “placement” is defined in California law as “that unique combination of facilities, personnel, location or equipment necessary to provide instructional services” to a special education student. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3042(a).

The Hearing Officer finds that the District made an appropriately specific formal offer of placement to STUDENT. The nature, structure, and location of the class were identified in detail in the April 22 IEP. Although there was no written reference to Ms. Acosta as the teacher of the class, the IEP transcripts and witness testimony make clear that the District and the PARENTS understood that the specific classroom that would be made available to STUDENT on May 9 was Ms. Acosta’s class. For this reason, Ms. Acosta was present at all three IEP meetings, and the District arranged for the PARENTS to make two observations of her class. (Footnote 25) The offer’s compliance with the specificity requirements set forth in Union is evident in that (1) the factual record of the offer of Ms. Acosta’s class is clear, (2) the PARENTS made specific complaints about Ms. Acosta’s class during the IEP process, (3) the PARENTS rejected the District’s offer partly because of specific features of Ms. Acosta’s class (the presence of older children), and (4) the District was able to present relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of that class.

Further, the fact that Ms. Lerman has been assigned as the teacher of the class for the 2004-2005 school year does not constitute a procedural failing by the District. As Ms. Acosta’s resignation illustrates, LEAs do not exercise total control over their personnel rosters and, therefore, are not prohibited from replacing an instructor should the need arise. After Ms. Acosta resigned during the summer and Ms. Lerman became the available pre-K/K teacher for the 2004-2005 regular school year, the District informed the PARENTS. Further, District witnesses testified persuasively that the structure and the teaching methods employed by Ms. Acosta and Ms. Lerman in their pre-K/K classes, both of which are part of the District’s structured autism program for preschool and kindergarten students, were virtually identical.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately identified its placement recommendation for STUDENT.

(3) Did the District make a predetermined offer without considering the PARENTS’ input during the IEP process?

The Petitioner asserts that the District made a predetermined, “boilerplate” offer that disregarded his parents’ input during the IEP process. The District responds that STUDENT’s educational program was developed through District assessments and IEP team discussions of his unique needs. Further, the District asserts that it actively solicited the PARENTS’ input at the IEP meetings and made several program modifications in response to their suggestions.

The development of a disabled student’s educational program must include consideration of the student’s initial or most recent assessments and the parents’ concerns for enhancing the student’s education. 300 C.F.R. § 346(a)(1). Parental participation in the individualized education program (IEP) process is one of the basic procedural requirements of the IDEA. Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072, 1077 (9th Cir. 2003); Amanda J. v. Clark County School District, 267 F.3d. 877, 892 (9th Cir. 2001); see 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(20). The law requires an IEP to be “developed, reviewed, and revised in a meeting in accordance with Secs. 300.341-300.350.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.340(a). The Shapiro court held that the IDEA “imposes upon the school district the duty to conduct a meaningful meeting with the appropriate parties.” Shapiro v. Paradise Valley USD, supra, 317 F.3d at 1078 (emphasis in original).

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer was based on STUDENT’s unique needs as determined by his assessments and by discussions between District personnel and the PARENTS at STUDENT’s IEP meetings. District assessors Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, and Ms. Chua testified persuasively that the development of STUDENT’s IEP offer resulted directly from their assessments of his unique needs. These needs were established in the initial intake interview with the PARENTS, the assessors’ direct observations and tests of his skills, further parental interviews and questionnaires, and a review of STUDENT’s medical and educational records. (See S. Exhs. 7-23; 25-29.) In addition, many of the goals the District initially proposed for STUDENT were based on the personalized goals developed for him by his CARD instructors. (S. Exh. 48.) (Footnote 26)

Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the District appropriately considered the PARENTS’ input in the creation of STUDENT’s program. The IEP transcripts make clear that the District actively solicited the PARENTS’ input regarding the District’s proposed goals and objectives for STUDENT, modified the goals in accordance with their suggestions, and noted that the monthly progress meetings included in the program offer would allow them to continually adapt goals to STUDENT’s functional level.

When the PARENTS asked about other placement options, the District noted that its other preschool classes were designed for children with other needs or were at more distant locations. In the District’s opinion, Ms. Acosta’s pre-K/K class for autistic children at Hankey, STUDENT’s neighborhood school, appeared to be the most suitable placement. The District encouraged the PARENTS to discuss their concerns about Ms. Acosta’s class and pointed out that their discomfort with the presence of some five- and six-year-old children in the class would cease to be an issue shortly (since the regular school year would end in a month and younger children would replace the older ones in the fall). (See S. Exhs. 48-50.) (Footnote 27)

The District recognized the PARENTS’ qualms about placing their small, three-year-old, home-schooled son in a classroom setting for the first time, and attempted to reassure them. District representatives noted how compliant STUDENT had been during his assessments by strangers in unfamiliar settings, and observed that a classroom setting tends to help preschoolers generalize their skills. At several points during the IEP meetings, District representatives responded to various concerns raised by the PARENTS by noting that “that’s not uncommon,” or “that’s an issue for all of our kids.” The District arranged for class observations to help the PARENTS familiarize themselves with Ms. Acosta’s class and its curriculum.

The District acknowledged the PARENTS’ concerns about skill regression over summer breaks and explained how it would deal with regression recoupment. It acknowledged STUDENT’s bad experience as a toddler in the ICEC group program, but noted that this experience was not necessarily a blueprint for the future. The District added that the program’s transition plan would give the IEP team the opportunity to watch for any of the potential problems raised by the PARENTS and to modify STUDENT’s program accordingly. In her testimony, MOTHER noted that District personnel were pleasant to work with and that the IEP meetings were always congenial.

The fact that the PARENTS’ objections to a school-based program did not result in a modification of the placement offer does not mean that the District disregarded their input, but rather that the District believed that a school-based program was the most appropriate placement for STUDENT. As the LEA responsible for STUDENT’s education, the District had a duty to offer the program and placement that, in its professional judgment, constituted a free appropriate public education suited to STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. 20 U.S.C. § 1414; see Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176. District witnesses testified that they generally recommend group instruction for students at STUDENT’s age and functional level to help them develop social skills and generalize other skills, and that STUDENT’s assessments revealed no medical, behavioral, or other deficits that would warrant a departure from that practice. The District was entitled to extend an offer based upon its best professional judgment of what was the most appropriate placement for STUDENT, even if his parents disagreed with that judgment.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer did not consist of predetermined, “boilerplate” elements, and that the District appropriately considered the PARENTS’ input during the IEP process.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that with respect to procedural issues, STUDENT’s IEP meetings were attended by the appropriate personnel; the District made an appropriately specific offer of placement; and the District’s offer was based on STUDENT’s unique needs as determined with appropriate consideration of the PARENTS’ input during the IEP process.

B. Substantive issues

A review of the District’s program for substantive appropriateness first requires a determination of STUDENT’s unique needs, as indicated by the nature and scope of his impairment and his then-current levels of functioning. The District’s program offer then will be reviewed to determine if it was designed to meet his unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit.

(1) STUDENT’s unique needs (a) Nature and scope of impairment

STUDENT was diagnosed as autistic before he was two years old, and there appears to be no dispute that he shows significant symptoms of autistic spectrum disorder. From an early age, STUDENT has shown global developmental delays in cognitive and motor skills, and severe delays in social/emotional development and receptive and expressive communication. He exhibits maladaptive behaviors such as screaming and noncompliance when faced with new tasks, and engages in self-stimulatory behavior “almost constantly” unless his behavior is redirected. He has difficulty paying attention to task and is quite sensitive to noise, crowds and distractions. Physically, STUDENT is small and underweight for his age, with many chronic digestive ailments and food allergies.

(b) Levels of functioning

Both District and private assessments conducted when STUDENT was approaching his third birthday indicated that his functional communication skills were at an age level of approximately one year four months. His emerging skills included the ability to follow simple directions, to use some PECS symbols to indicate wants and needs, to imitate some words and phrases, and to produce most age-appropriate consonant sounds. He was learning to label objects and body parts and could use a few words in a generalized way.

STUDENT’s socialization skills also were severely delayed for his age. He responded well to adults, and displayed strong bonds with his parents, compliance with tutors and assessors, and appreciation of adult praise. However, he generally ignored or appeared unaware of his sister and peers, and preferred to play by himself.

In adaptive skills, STUDENT could assist in dressing and undressing himself, could finger-feed and eat with a fork (with some assistance), and could drink from a cup or straw, although he tended to overstuff his mouth and choke while eating and drinking. He showed readiness for toilet training by tugging on his pants when his diapers needed changing. STUDENT also was beginning to engage in imitative play, and could play with dolls with adult modeling.

In the area of fine motor skills, STUDENT could use a pincer grasp to pick things up and could scribble with a writing tool held in his fist, but had not yet developed a tripod writing grip and could not trace lines. He could string beads, stack blocks, and turn doorknobs, but could not manipulate scissors. In gross motor skills, STUDENT walked and sat up by himself, but had poor balance on play equipment, would fall while running, and could not descend stairs with alternating feet without help.

With respect to his behavior, STUDENT’s compliance with directions and attention to task had shown marked improvement in recent months, and his most severe maladaptive behaviors had receded. In the spring of 2004, his maladaptive behaviors included temporary resistance to transitions and new tasks (indicated by noncompliance and “expressive” screaming), which usually could be overcome with promises of play breaks or other reinforcements. He cycled through self-stimulatory behaviors, particularly when new tasks were introduced, but usually could be redirected through introduction of competing behaviors (for example, having him take a drink of water to stop him from screaming).

(c) Needs

As indicated above, STUDENT’s level of impairment showed global developmental delays, particularly in social/emotional development and communication. The parties generally agree that his unique needs included speech therapy and other communication-based instruction to compensate for his speech delays; intensive academic instruction; careful monitoring of his dietary intake; a sensory diet to address his sensory integration needs; specialized instruction in self-help skills such as feeding, dressing, and toilet training; and occupational therapy to help him achieve those self-help skills. Further, STUDENT needed consistent behavior intervention to reduce his maladaptive behaviors, redirect him away from self-stimulatory behaviors, and increase his attention to tasks.

The parties disagree, however, as to how these needs should be met. Their areas of disagreement are discussed below.

(2) Was the District’s 2004-2005 program offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, and was it reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit?

The Hearing Office must next determine whether the educational program offered by the District was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs described above, and whether it was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The District’s 2004-2005 program offer was summarized in the April 22 IEP document as follows:

A ten-week transition plan from CARD services to District services;

A structured pre-K/K class four hours per day, five days per week, with one-to-one and small group instruction (in accordance with the District’s “BLASST-Off” autism instruction program), beginning on STUDENT’s third birthday through the end of the 2003-2004 regular school year (May 9-June 9, 2004);

Twenty-three proposed goals and objectives to address STUDENT’s preacademic, self-help, communication, fine motor, sensory integration, and behavioral needs;

Intensive Behavior Intervention (IBI) services ten hours per week (five hours at school and five at home);

IBI supervision three hours per month (including a monthly student progress meeting);

Parent training in IBI for eight one-hour sessions;

S/L services one hour per week (thirty minutes each individual and small group session);

OT services thirty minutes per week (individual);

Specially designed adapted physical education;

Continuation of program and services described above at the same level for the 2004 ESY (June 14 - July 9, 2004);

IBI maintenance ten hours per week from July 26-August 6, 2004; and

Resumption of the regular school year program described above for the 2004-2005 regular school year from August 25, 2004 to June 16, 2005.

The transition plan provided for District collaboration in STUDENT’s CARD home program for the two weeks prior to his enrollment in class (April 26-May 7), followed by collaborative supervision by CARD and District personnel for two hours per month from May 10 through July 9 (the end of the 2004 ESY). (S. Exh. 33, p. 13.) (Footnote 28)

The pre-K/K class offered to STUDENT was a part of the District’s “BLASST-Off” program for preschool and kindergarten students with autism. “BLASST-Off” (Building Language, Academics and Social skills through Structured Teaching) is described as “an intensive, highly structured, language-based” program using Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) and Intensive Behavioral Intervention (IBI) throughout the school day. BLASST-Off classes have a 2:1 student/teacher ratio, and also include typically developing peers in a “reverse mainstreaming program” for half of the school day. (See S. Exh. 13.) Dr. Paul Dores, who helped develop the District’s program, trained its teachers, and periodically evaluates its classes, testified that the program’s key structural elements are its low student/teacher ratio, its focus on ABA and IBI philosophy and techniques, and its ongoing personnel training and supervision.

The Petitioner asserts that the District’s program offer was substantively inappropriate because (a) most of the goals and objectives developed by the District were insufficiently challenging; (b) the District failed to adequately address his sensory and behavioral needs; (c) the program offered insufficient S/L therapy; (d) the program offered insufficient supervision of its IBI program; (e) a group educational setting such as a pre-K/K class was unsuited to his unique needs; (f) the older and larger children in Mrs. Acosta’s class made it a particularly unsuitable placement for him; (g) the teaching methods in both of the structured pre-K/K classes at Hankey were unsuitable for him; and (h) the offer of ESY and maintenance services over the summer were insufficient to prevent skill regression. These allegations are addressed in turn below.

(a) Were the goals and objectives developed by the District inappropriate or insufficiently challenging for STUDENT?

The Petitioner asserts that nearly all of the twenty-three goals and objectives set forth in STUDENT’s IEP were inappropriate and that most were insufficiently challenging. (See S. Exh. 33, pp. 14-22.) Although the Petitioner acknowledges that some of the District’s proposed goals were based on his then-current CARD goals, he alleges that they still were insufficiently challenging because CARD had scheduled those goals for mastery long before the District’s projected mastery date.

In response, the District asserts that, although MOTHER testified that she felt the proposed goals generally fell short of STUDENT’s abilities, neither she nor any other witness presented evidence indicating that the goals were below STUDENT’s skill levels in the spring of 2004 or were otherwise inadequate. (Footnote 29)

District assessors Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg and Ms. Chua testified that they drafted the proposed goals based on their assessments of STUDENT, their determination of his current skill levels, and their review of his past performance records, including his CARD progress reports. Further, they noted that many of their goals were based on STUDENT’s current goals as developed by CARD, in order to provide a smooth transition for his skill development as he adapted to a District program. They noted that in some cases they chose not to increase the challenge levels beyond those set in the current CARD goals, because they believed the efforts STUDENT would need to make in order to generalize current skills to a new environment would pose a sufficient initial challenge for him. In any case, as they informed the PARENTS at the IEP meetings, the assessors saw the goals as fluid concepts that would regularly be subject to refinement once STUDENT was in the District program and they could measure his performance in that setting.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District’s goals and objectives were inadequate or insufficiently challenging for STUDENT. A comparison of the District’s twenty-three proposed goals to STUDENT’s twenty-seven CARD goals for 2004 supports the District’s testimony that most of its goals were modeled on and are quite similar to STUDENT’s then-current CARD goals: Of the seventeen substantially similar District goals, five were somewhat less challenging than the comparable CARD goals (e.g., identifying seven body parts instead of ten; mastering spoon feeding instead of spoon and fork feeding); two were more challenging (voiding on the toilet instead of sitting for a specified period; attending to task for ten minutes instead of seven); and the rest were virtually identical (e.g., responding to “hi” and “bye;” sorting items by color for eight colors). Other goals were substantially similar but stated differently (e.g., using forty new words to label objects and labeling fifteen new objects, instead of labeling seventy-five new objects). (Footnote 30) The Hearing Officer notes that the Petitioner expressed nothing but satisfaction with the CARD program and raised no concerns regarding any of his CARD goals for 2004.

Nor is the Hearing Officer persuaded that the later mastery date set for the District’s goals made them insufficiently challenging for STUDENT. According to CARD’s progress report, its goals were scheduled for mastery by November 2004; the District goals as initially drafted were scheduled for mastery by April 2005. (See S. Exhs. 5, 33.) As the District noted at the IEP meetings, some overlap was to be expected in a home-to-school program transition, and mastery of goals was likely to be somewhat delayed by STUDENT’s need to adapt to the new setting and to generalize skills across settings. In any case, after the PARENTS asked for an increase in the goals’ challenge level, many goals were individually modified and the mastery date for all of the District goals was moved up to September 15, 2004. (See S. Exh. 33, pp. 14-22.)

Further, the District provided the PARENTS with ample opportunity to revise any goals they found unsatisfactory. Although the District did not deliver its initial draft of goals to the PARENTS until the night before the April 22 IEP meeting, it readily scheduled a follow-up IEP meeting to give the PARENTS time to review the proposed goals and provide their input. The IEP transcripts make clear that at the second meeting on May 4, the District accepted virtually every change suggested by the PARENTS and modified the goals accordingly, either by increasing their challenge level, moving up the date of expected mastery, or deleting goals STUDENT already had met. Accordingly, the twenty-three goals the Petitioner contends are inappropriate or insufficiently challenging are goals that already have been modified by the District at the PARENTS’ request in order to address these very concerns.

To the extent the District’s proposed goals are less challenging than the CARD goals, the Hearing Officer notes that they were based in part on the District assessors’ own assessments of STUDENT, which in some areas reflected slightly lower skill levels than STUDENT demonstrated in his home program. (Footnote 31) At the IEP meetings, the District assessors indicated that once STUDENT’s performance could be observed and measured in the school setting, his goals could be adjusted accordingly. The District offered to hold an IEP meeting after the first thirty days of the program in order to make these adjustments.

Finally, the Hearing Officer notes that the District goals are consistently more rigorous than the CARD goals in the level of performance expected for mastery. The CARD goals and supporting data indicate that STUDENT’s successful performance of a task on four of five tries during a single drill would be considered mastery of that task. By contrast, the District standards require successful performance on four of five trials conducted on four of five different trial days.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s proposed goals and objectives are not inappropriate or insufficiently challenging for STUDENT. However, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives are inadequate to the limited extent that they fail to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs.

(b) Did the District fail to adequately address STUDENT’s behavioral and sensory needs?

The Petitioner alleges that the District failed to develop a behavior intervention plan or behavioral goals for STUDENT, failed to address his sensory needs, and failed to develop a sensory diet for his IEP. The District asserts that its offered program adequately addressed STUDENT’s behavioral and sensory needs.

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence favors the District on both points. First, the October 25 prehearing conference memorandum specifically states that the Petitioner did not contend that a formal behavioral intervention plan was required, and the Petitioner confirmed at the beginning of the hearing that the memorandum accurately set forth his contentions. The Hearing Officer will not address an issue raised for the first time in argument. See Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(6). With respect to behavioral goals, the Hearing Officer notes that the several of the District’s proposed goals related to redirecting STUDENT from self-stimulatory activities and attending to task, and the autism instruction program as a whole offered daily one-to-one IBI instruction and IBI techniques applied throughout the school day.

With regard to STUDENT’s sensory needs, the Petitioner does not explain how the District’s findings were inadequate. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Chua’s sensory integration profile of STUDENT made findings similar to those made by private OT consultant Mr. Vinceneux. Contrary to the Petitioner’s allegations, Ms. Chua also prepared a sensory diet to help STUDENT with sensory integration. Further, she prepared a list of proposed activities to develop STUDENT’s pre-scissor skills, noting that they were useful to sensory integration since these activities develop a sense of the pressure needed to operate a tool, the ability to control the tool, and awareness of finger position. (S. Exhs. 30, 31.) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District adequately addressed STUDENT’s behavioral and sensory needs.

(c) Did the District’s program offer include insufficient S/L therapy?

The Petitioner contends that the District’s offer of speech and language (S/L) therapy was insufficient. He notes that he currently receives ninety minutes per week of individual therapy, but the District has offered only sixty minutes per week of S/L therapy, of which only thirty minutes would be individual and thirty minutes would be in a small group setting. The District responds that its offer of S/L therapy was based on the opinion of its speech and autism specialists that thirty minutes each of individual and group therapy would be appropriate for STUDENT, particularly as his speech and communication needs would be addressed in his general instruction throughout the school day.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of S/L therapy was appropriate. In addition to individual therapy, STUDENT’s speech needs would be addressed throughout the school day, and five of his IEP goals were directed to improving his receptive and expressive communication skills. Further, the fact that STUDENT currently receives more S/L therapy than that offered by the District does not render the District offer inadequate. Special education programs are not required to provide the best education available or instruction and services that maximize a child’s abilities. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 198-200. Rather, the District is required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” individually designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. Id. at 201. District witnesses testified persuasively that the program offered to STUDENT was designed to meet his unique needs. Taken together with the other facets of the program, including the inclusion of S/L therapy throughout the school day, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of S/L therapy was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.

(d) Did the District’s program offer insufficient IBI supervision?

The Petitioner also contends that the IBI offered by the District did not include adequate supervision. Instead of the three hours per month of supervision offered by the District, the Petitioner asserts he should have received an offer of bi-weekly progress report meetings between the IBI supervisor and instructors for two to three hours each, and a parent training component in which the IBI supervisor trains the parent how to use IBI techniques. The District contends that its offer of three hours per month of IBI supervision was based on what its educational experts felt was appropriate to help STUDENT succeed.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Petitioner’s arguments. As stated above, the fact that STUDENT currently receives more IBI supervision than that contained in the District offer does not render the offer inadequate. Although STUDENT’s CARD supervisor testified that his program required a great deal of initial supervisory input as his tutors discovered his learning style and range of maladaptive behaviors, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded that such extensive supervision would continue to be necessary indefinitely. The District’s transition program provided for collaborative supervision with CARD for the first two months, and offered three hours per month of continuing IBI supervision including student progress meetings that, while scheduled for an hour, were allowed to continue “as long as necessary.” As a part of the transition plan, the District also offered eight one-hour sessions of in-home parent training in IBI skills generalization. For all of these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of IBI supervision was adequate.

(e) Is a group education setting unsuited to STUDENT’s needs?

The Petitioner asserts that, due to his unique learning style, susceptibility to distractions, and maladaptive behaviors, a group setting such as the District’s pre-K/K class would be an unsuitable learning environment for him.

Sara Larsen, STUDENT’s case supervisor at CARD, testified that STUDENT’s severe communication deficits have presented a significant teaching challenge. After trying different approaches to teaching STUDENT, his CARD instructors discovered that he learns best through an unusual “linking” method, in which a previously learned response (such as matching two pictures of noses) would be paired with a new, communicative response (“STUDENT, touch your nose”). Ms. Larsen testified that CARD’s efforts to develop an effective teaching program for STUDENT required extensive additional training for his instructors, and added that, of the thirteen cases she supervises, only one other child has required as many modifications to his educational program as STUDENT has required. Further, Ms. Larsen testified that STUDENT’s constant self-stimulatory behavior rapidly evolves from one maladaptive behavior to the next, requiring constant attention and redirection by his instructor.

MOTHER testified that STUDENT also is easily overwhelmed by noise, distractions, and large groups of people, and thus is not yet able to learn in a group setting such as the pre-K/K class recommended by the District. She cited STUDENT’s difficulties in the ICEC group program, which he attended from September-December 2002 when he was sixteen to twenty months old. During that period, STUDENT cried “all the time” and had difficulty transitioning from one learning station to the next every twenty minutes. She also testified that when not attending to a specific task, STUDENT engages constantly in self-stimulatory behaviors such as squinting, toe-walking, and preoccupation with long objects, and that his instructors need to be “on him” constantly to redirect him to appropriate replacement behaviors.

Chris Vinceneaux, an OT consultant who assessed STUDENT at the PARENTS’ request in April and May of 2004, testified that STUDENT has severe sensory processing deficits that would make it difficult for him to learn in a group setting. According to Mr. Vinceneaux, STUDENT has a malfunctioning central nervous system that significantly contributes to his learning and behavior difficulties. He is easily disorganized by visual stimuli, startled by certain noises, and upset with disruptions to routine. STUDENT also is constantly in motion, regularly engages in self-stimulatory behavior, and is often restless and uncomfortable.

Mr. Vinceneaux also observed STUDENT at Big Fun Gymnastics, where STUDENT had been enrolled by the PARENTS for private OT sessions. At Big Fun, STUDENT received one-to-one therapy in an open gymnasium setting with other children present. The activities included climbing over obstacles, forward rolls, hanging from rings or bars, and climbing ladders. Mr. Vinceneaux noted that STUDENT cried almost constantly during the forty-five-minute session and appeared completely overwhelmed. He added that STUDENT’s Big Fun therapist told him that STUDENT “always cries a lot; he appears terrified of a lot of these activities; the sensory input just seems too much for him.” (S. Exh. 46; testimony of Mr. Vinceneaux.)

The District disputes the Petitioner’s assertion that the nature or severity of his disability requires placement in a home program. On the contrary, the District alleges that STUDENT’s learning style can be appropriately addressed by its “BLASST-Off” structured autism program for preschool and kindergarten students. Dr. Dores, a psychology professor, clinician, and autism expert who helped develop the program and periodically evaluates its delivery in the classroom, testified that the program was developed in accordance with current “best practices” in the treatment of autism, including the maintenance of a low student-teacher ratio, consistent teaching methods, breaking down skills into easily learned parts, and reducing distractions. (Footnote 32) The District notes that such a program is well suited to addressing STUDENT’s need for strong adult supervision of his behavior and patient teaching in a minimally distracting environment.

Dr. Dores testified that he reviewed STUDENT’s assessments and observed him in his home program. He testified that STUDENT appeared very similar to the other students in the District’s pre-K/K classes, and that he observed nothing about STUDENT’s deficits or CARD’s teaching methods that could not be ably addressed by the District’s program.

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the nature of STUDENT’s learning style renders him unable to learn in a group setting. Both CARD and District autism experts testified that different learning styles among autistic children are not uncommon. Although STUDENT’s deficits may have presented significant challenges to CARD, his instructors evidently developed an effective approach to teaching him, and they acknowledged at the hearing that if STUDENT entered a District program, they would participate fully in a transition plan to train District instructors in the methods they found successful.

With respect to STUDENT’s poor experience in the ICEC group program, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT attended ICEC when he was very young – from sixteen to twenty months old. He was physically ill during much of that period, and the PARENTS have acknowledged that they were unsure how much of STUDENT’s difficulties at ICEC were caused by his health problems. Moreover, STUDENT’s recent unhappiness at Big Fun Gymnastics, as described by Mr. Vinceneux, appears less attributable to the presence of other children than to his resistance to activities beyond his current skill level.

Contrary to the assertion that STUDENT is too disorganized, distracted, restless and uncomfortable to learn in a group setting, both District and private assessment reports indicate that at the time the District extended its offer in April of 2004, STUDENT possessed or was developing many of the readiness skills important for group learning. He separated easily from his parents, showed curiosity in the assessment settings, and was sweet-natured and ready to work with assessors who were strangers to him. He also paid attention to task for several minutes at a time, complied with directives, and was easily redirected to task when distracted or when engaging in self-stimulatory behaviors. STUDENT responded to adult modeling and was beginning to engage in imitative play, an important precursor to learning in a group setting. He responded to safety directives such as “no” and “stop,” could assist in dressing and undressing himself, and could eat solid foods and drink from a cup or straw. MOTHER ranked STUDENT low on the TABS hypersensitivity scale, indicating that he was not unduly irritable, easily frustrated, or difficult to comfort. STUDENT also responded to praise and positive feedback, which is an important attribute in lessening reliance on food as a learning reinforcement tool.

STUDENT’s readiness for group learning is further evidenced by his progress in his CARD home program. (Footnote 33) STUDENT’s current learning environment is one of considerable social activity: He lives with his parents and five-year-old sibling, has a nanny, and interacts well with the different CARD instructors who come to his home each day. He is learning successfully in his home program despite the distractions of other people coming and going, the telephone ringing, housework occurring, and cars going by outside. (Testimony of Dr. Dores.) His CARD instructors testified that when he begins to show mastery of a skill, they take him outside of his primary teaching room so that he can generalize the skill across settings and across people. The Hearing Officer notes that a group learning environment would provide STUDENT with increased opportunities for socialization with adults and peers. (Footnote 34)

Further, Dr. Dores testified persuasively that the pre-K-K classroom teacher, Ms. Lerman, is experienced and extremely able in the instruction of autistic children, has great rapport with her students and their parents, and has worked for several years with her three instructional aides to the extent that they show great “synergy” as a team. Ms. Lerman testified that she is accustomed to receiving three-year-old children in her class who, like STUDENT, are entering the school environment for the first time. She is sensitive to parents’ concerns and children’s difficulties in making this transition, and works to make it as smooth as possible.

With respect to the PARENTS’ particular concerns about STUDENT, Ms. Lerman noted that her class was designed to reduce distractions, and contains cubicles for students who need breaks from the stimuli in the classroom. She also testified that her student-teacher ratio was capped at 8:3, allowing for significant adult intervention and redirection from self-stimulatory behaviors. Regarding STUDENT’s social deficits, she noted that the four typically developing peers who come into the class for “reverse mainstreaming” were specifically chosen for their demeanor and willingness to socialize with and provide good role models for her students. Ms. Lerman added that other students in her class are of STUDENT’s small size, and that none of her students is aggressive.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that a group education setting such as Ms. Lerman’s pre-K/K class is suited to STUDENT’s educational needs.

(f) Did the fact that Ms. Acosta’s class had older children make it an unsuitable placement for STUDENT for the last month of the 2003-2004 school year?

The Petitioner alleges that Ms. Acosta’s class was particularly unsuitable for him in May 2004 because at that time, her class had older, larger children who were learning at an advanced level and who might have posed a physical threat to him. The District responds that Ms. Acosta’s class was an appropriate placement for STUDENT in May 2004.

Ms. Acosta testified that when the District extended its offer to STUDENT in the spring of 2004, it intended to place him in her pre-K/K class from May 9 to the end of the regular school year on June 9. At that time, her class had seven special education students, at least three of whom were five or six years old, and two instructional aides, providing for a student/teacher ratio of 7:3. (Footnote 35) MOTHER testified that when she observed Ms. Acosta’s class in April of 2004, “all of the children looked at least five or six,” and the instruction appeared to be structured for children older than STUDENT. For example, MOTHER noted that in their circle time period, the children in Ms. Acosta’s class were discussing the weather and their emotions. She asserted that STUDENT, who could not even say the word “cloud,” was not yet at a level of development where he could gain anything from such discussions.

MOTHER also was concerned that the older, larger children might pose a safety threat to STUDENT, who was just turning three and was of small size and weight. During her observation, MOTHER saw one child try to escape the class, which required the attention of an instructional aide for a significant period, while another child gnawed at his own arm for some time, leaving visible bite marks, before an adult intervened and redirected his behavior. MOTHER was very upset by this incident, and expressed concern that the behavioral needs of other special education children in a classroom setting would make it more difficult for instructors to pay sufficient attention to STUDENT.

District witnesses noted that the level of instruction in special education classes is determined by the students in the class, and that group instruction periods such as circle time would be modified to make sure the needs of STUDENT or of any other new student were accommodated. (Footnote 36) Further, STUDENT’s individual instruction would be determined by the goals and objectives in his IEP.

With respect to behavior control issues, District autism specialist Jennifer Fant testified that Ms. Acosta had informed her that on the day MOTHER observed her class in April 2004, her two regular aides were absent and she was working with substitute aides who did not provide the usual level of controls in the classroom. Ms. Acosta said that under normal circumstances, the student biting his arm would have received immediate adult intervention and redirection. Ms. Acosta also told her that the child who was biting his arm was doing so as a self-stimulatory behavior and ultimately was redirected to a chew toy by an instructional aide. According to Ms. Acosta, the child did not break any skin and did not require medical attention.

The Hearing Officer finds that the presence of older children in Ms. Acosta’s classroom did not make it an unsuitable placement for STUDENT. The class was structured specifically for autistic children between the ages of three and six, who would share many of STUDENT’s educational needs. District witnesses testified persuasively that group instruction is geared to the needs of the students currently in the class, and would have been modified to accommodate STUDENT’s presence. Further, STUDENT’s individual instruction would be governed by his IEP.

In addition, the District’s offered transition plan would have eased STUDENT’s transfer into Ms. Acosta’s class by providing collaborative CARD and District instruction in his home program for the two weeks prior to placement, and collaborative supervision of his IBI program for the last month of school and throughout the ESY. During the transition period, any difficulties STUDENT experienced in Ms. Acosta’s class could be identified by CARD personnel familiar with his needs and addressed by the IEP team.

Finally, the fact that some children were older or larger than STUDENT does not mean that they posed a physical threat to him. Although MOTHER’s discomfort with the incidents she witnessed in Ms. Acosta’s class is understandable, the behaviors described appear to have consisted of noncompliance and self-stimulation rather than aggression towards others. No witness who observed Ms. Acosta’s class described aggressive or threatening behavior by any of her students, and there was no evidence that any incident of student aggression had ever occurred in her classroom. (Footnote 37) Further, the low student-teacher ratio in Ms. Acosta’s class would allow individual behavior issues to be addressed without unduly affecting adult supervision of the other students.

For the reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the presence of older children in Ms. Acosta’s class did not make it an unsuitable placement for STUDENT.

(g) Are the teaching methods in the Hankey pre-K/K classes unsuitable for STUDENT?

The Petitioner asserts that observations of Ms. Acosta’s and Ms. Lerman’s classes revealed teaching and behavior intervention methods unsuited to STUDENT’s needs. MOTHER observed a child being “inundated with candy” as a reinforcement tool, and saw an aide grab an escaping child with too much force. Ms. Larsen and Dr. Bostani testified that they saw maladaptive behaviors being rewarded instead of redirected, and tantrum behavior being rewarded with hugging and comforting instead of alternative behaviors being introduced.

The District disputes these assertions. Ms. Lerman testified that children who are new to her class often are taught using edible reinforcers (if allowed by their IEPs) because they are the most effective, but that her goal is to pair the food with a secondary reinforcer, such as praise or clapping, and to wean the child from food as a reward. She added that her students generally adapt to this change as they build a relationship with their instructor. Ms. Lerman interviews parents to learn what other secondary reinforcers, such as favorite toys, work best for the child, and ultimately works them into the learning process.

With respect to maladaptive behaviors, Ms. Lerman testified that tantrums generally are ignored, except to ensure the child is safe, and harmful behaviors receive consequences such as time-outs. Where the behavior appears to stem from an inability to communicate, she or her aides try to identify the issue and help the child find a way to communicate their wants. Often, however, children are hugged and comforted when they cry “because they are children first, and need to feel that they are in a safe and loving environment.”

The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence does not support the Petitioner’s assertion that the teaching methods in the Hankey pre-K/K classes are unsuitable for him. First, the observations reported by the Petitioner’s witnesses lack context, so that what appeared to be inappropriate comforting or rewarding of maladaptive behaviors might have been appropriate in context or susceptible to a different interpretation. (Footnote 38)

Second, the evidence indicates that District personnel are professional and conscientious in their delivery of their autism instruction program. The IEP transcripts indicate that District staff were painstaking in their program development discussions with the PARENTS, soliciting their ideas for secondary reinforcers for STUDENT, for example, and offering to ensure that food was not used as a reinforcer if the PARENTS preferred such an approach. The Hearing Officer also found Ms. Lerman, in particular, to be an impressive witness. She is a credentialed special education teacher who has spent the last five years teaching autistic children exclusively, with substantial and ongoing training in IBI theory and technique. She testified thoughtfully and articulately about her teaching methods and behavior strategies, and appeared to be highly qualified for her position.

The Hearing Officer also found Dr. Dores’ favorable testimony about the District’s structured autism program to be convincing. Dr. Dores credibly testified that his evaluation of the District’s autism program is thorough and ongoing, and that he contracts with the District and his other LEA clients on the clear understanding that he will give criticism freely when called for. He testified that he often participates in joint assessments for both parents and LEAs, so as not to be unduly identified with one side of a dispute, and that he has recommended private placements for LEA pupils when he has felt it was appropriate.

In Dr. Dores’ opinion, the District’s BLASST-Off program for preschool and kindergarten children provides consistent teaching by well-trained staff in accordance with best practices of autism instructional theory. Dr. Dores has known Ms. Lerman for four years, has observed her class at least six times, and was convincing in his testimony that she and her aides are highly competent instructors. He noted that all of the children who had been in one of Ms. Lerman’s pre-K/K classes had gone on to less restrictive educational environments – some to regular education classes. Dr. Dores also had observed Ms. Acosta’s class when she was with the District and found her to be a competent teacher as well.

For the above reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the teaching methods in the Hankey pre-K/K classes are suitable for STUDENT.

(h) Did the District’s offer of an ESY program and maintenance services fail to appropriately address the possibility of skill regression over the summer?

The Petitioner alleges that the District’s offer of an ESY program and IBI maintenance services were insufficient to prevent skill regression over the rest of the summer. MOTHER and Ms. Larsen testified that a recent one-week family vacation resulted in a regression of STUDENT’s skills that took over three weeks to recoup. (See also S. Exh. 33.)

Federal and State regulations provide for extended school year (ESY) services when a disabled Petitioner’s IEP team determines such services are necessary to provide a FAPE. 34 C.F.R. § 300.309; Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. In California, ESY services must be provided when the interruption of a Petitioner’s educational program may cause regression that is unlikely to be recouped in the next school year. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, § 3043. When an ESY program is provided, it must consist of no fewer than twenty days of instruction. Id.

In this case, the District offered a twenty-day ESY program that would begin one week after the end of regular instruction, and would provide the same instruction and services, including DIS services, that STUDENT received during the school year. In addition, the District offered ten hours per week of IBI maintenance services from July 26 through August 6, with regular school instruction scheduled to resume on August 25, 2004. No interruption in the District’s offered program would last longer than two weeks.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s ESY and IBI maintenance offer adequately addressed the possibility of skill regression. ESY services are required when an instructional break may cause regression unlikely to be recouped in a year, and in STUDENT’s case, a one-week break had resulted in a regression that was recouped within three weeks. Based on this history, a program with two two-week breaks over the summer would appear more than adequate to address the risk of regression. Further, the District informed the PARENTS that they would chart STUDENT’s regression over weekend breaks in the regular school year and would modify his offer appropriately if his regression recoupment proved to be more than anticipated.

* * * *

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for the failure to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs, the District’s offer was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to offer him some educational benefit. The group setting in a pre-K/K class provided a suitable educational environment for STUDENT, and the fact that Ms. Acosta’s class had some older children did not render her class unsuitable for STUDENT in May 2004.

Both the District’s BLASST-Off autism program and its proposed goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The autism program’s focus on communication and its combination of group and individual instruction would address his most severe deficits, which were language and social skills; its low student/teacher ratio and emphasis on IBI techniques would address his attention and behavior issues; and its S/L and OT services would provide additional support to his speech and motor development. The proposed transition plan would address the difficulties inherent in the change from home-based to school-based instruction. Finally, the offered ESY program and IBI maintenance services would ensure that STUDENT’s transition to a school-based program was not unduly disrupted by a lengthy summer break.

C. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

Upon determining that the District has offered STUDENT a FAPE, the Hearing Officer must assess whether the offer was made in the least restrictive environment (LRE). The Petitioner alleges that the District failed to meet its LRE obligations to STUDENT by offering him a school-based program in a group setting instead of one-to-one instruction in a home-based program.

In response, the District asserts that its LRE obligations are central to the development of its special educational programs. District witnesses testified that school-based placements are the norm for its special education students, with general education placements offered where appropriate, and SDCs with mainstreaming opportunities offered to children who need a more structured classroom setting. (Footnote 39) The District asserts that the pre-K/K class offered to STUDENT was the least restrictive environment for his education.

For the reasons stated above regarding the adequacy of the pre-K/K class offered to STUDENT, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with its obligation to offer him an education in the least restrictive environment. The IDEA allows disabled children to be separated from the regular educational environment “only if the nature or severity of the disability is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.” 34 C.F.R. § 550(b)(2). (Footnote 40) The Hearing Officer has found that the nature and severity of STUDENT’s disabilities would not make him unable to learn in a classroom setting, particularly in the structured autism pre-K/K class offered by the District.

In selecting an LRE, consideration must be given to any potential harmful effect on the child or on the quality of services that he or she needs. 34 C.F.R. § 552(d). The Hearing Officer acknowledges that due to STUDENT’s age, his sensitivity to distractions, and the newness of a school setting, he might be expected to have some difficulties in adapting to a pre-K/K class. However, the District’s offer addressed these potential harmful effects by including a ten-week transition plan that provided for collaboration with CARD instructors, parent training, and student progress meetings to help STUDENT succeed. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Issue No. 3: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is he entitled to a prospective placement in the form of services from CARD and other related services for the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year?

When an LEA denies a Petitioner a FAPE, the Petitioner is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA, which may include prospective placement at a nonpublic school at LEA expense. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education, 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985). In this matter, the Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE to the extent that he was not offered designated instructional services to address his gross motor deficits.

As addressed below, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate relief would include reimbursement for private OT services the PARENTS have provided to STUDENT since his third birthday. There is no indication, however, that the District is unable to correct its offer of OT services to address STUDENT’s gross motor deficits if it is ordered to do so. Accordingly, there is no basis for an order of private OT services to address STUDENT’s gross motor deficits.

In all other areas, the Hearing Officer found that the District provided STUDENT with an offer of FAPE. Thus, no prospective placement is warranted.

Issue No. 4: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, are his parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of all educational expenses incurred since May 9, 2004?

Parents are entitled to retroactive reimbursement for services procured for their child when an LEA has failed to provide an appropriate placement, and when the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, supra, 471 U.S. at 370. The placement or services need not conform exactly to IDEA requirements, but must address the child’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993).

Here, the Hearing Officer found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer services related to his gross motor deficits. The PARENTS began providing private OT therapy to address these deficits while STUDENT was receiving services through RCOC, and have continued to do so since rejecting the District’s program offer in May. (Footnote 41) From May to October, they enrolled STUDENT at Big Fun Gymnastics for ninety minutes per week. In November 2004, the PARENTS switched to another one-to-one OT provider, Susan Perrine.

The Hearing Officer finds that the OT services retained by the PARENTS meet the standard for reimbursement under the IDEA. According to Mr. Vinceneux’s assessment report, Big Fun Gymnastics provided STUDENT with one-to-one OT services for gross motor activities that included climbing on play equipment and playing with balls, activities designed to address his deficits and provide him with educational benefit. (Footnote 42) The PARENTS testified that they were satisfied that the one-to-one OT services provided by Ms. Perrine since November 2004 have benefited STUDENT. The District raised no challenge to the qualifications or adequacy of service by either OT provider.

Accordingly, the District is ordered to pay to the PARENTS, upon receipt of paid invoices, the cost of private OT services provided for STUDENT through Big Fun Gymnastics and Susan Perrine from May 9, 2004, through the date the District implements a corrected IEP in accordance with the Order at the end of this Decision.

Issue No. 5: If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE and if the parents’ reimbursement claims are denied in whole or in part, is STUDENT entitled to compensatory education?

Court decisions have extended relief in the form of compensatory education to Petitioners who have been denied a FAPE in order to ensure that a Petitioner is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. Lester H. v. K. Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District, 916 F.2d 865 (3d. Cir. 1990). In view of the fact that the PARENTS have been providing private OT therapy to address STUDENT’s gross motor deficits, and in light of the order that the District reimburse them for those services, compensatory education is not warranted.

Issue No. 6: Are STUDENT’s parents entitled to reimbursement for the cost of independent assessments?

The Petitioner contends that the District’s assessments were inadequate, and that he should be awarded reimbursement for independent assessments conducted in the areas of cognitive and social/emotional needs (Dr. Perlman), general areas of executive function and emotional control (Dr. Bostani), speech and language (Ms. Berkowitz), and occupational therapy (Mr. Vinceneux).

The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the LEA “in all areas relating to the suspected disability.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f). Occupational therapy is an area of service requiring prior assessment. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572. The evaluation must be “sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child’s special education and related services needs.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(b).

A parent has the right to obtain an independent assessment at public expense if the parent disagrees with the assessment done by the LEA. The LEA must pay for the independent assessment unless there is a determination through due process that its assessment was appropriate. Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56329(b) (emphasis added) and 56506(c).

In this matter, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District’s assessments of STUDENT were appropriate in all areas except as they related to his gross motor deficits. Accordingly, the District is not required to pay for the independent assessments conducted by Dr. Perlman, Dr. Bostani, and Ms. Berkowitz, as those assessments were unrelated to gross motor issues.

Mr. Vinceneux’s OT assessment did relate in part to STUDENT’s gross motor deficits. However, the PARENTS sought this assessment in March 2004, before the District assessments had been completed or its reports issued, because of the PARENTS’ concerns regarding STUDENT’s sensory processing difficulties. At the initial IEP meeting on April 22, 2004, the PARENTS mentioned to the District that they were in the process of obtaining private S/L and OT assessments. (S. Exh. 48.)

As the PARENTS did not receive the District assessment reports until the April 22 meeting at which they mentioned their pending private assessments, it is evident that the those assessments were not obtained due to any disagreement with the results of the District assessments. Accordingly, the PARENTS are not entitled to reimbursement for the OT assessment conducted by Mr. Vinceneux.

ORDER

1. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of its receipt of paid invoices, the District is ordered to reimburse the PARENTS for the cost of private OT services provided to STUDENT by Big Fun Gymnastics and by Susan Perrine from May 9, 2004, through the date the District implements an IEP corrected to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs as described below.

2. The District shall assess STUDENT for gross motor deficits no later than fifteen (15) calendar days after the date of this Decision. The District shall inform the PARENTS five (5) calendar days in advance of the date of the assessment. The PARENTS shall make STUDENT reasonably available for the assessment.

3. Within fifteen (15) calendar days of the assessment, the District shall convene an IEP meeting to address STUDENT’s gross motor needs.

4. The District shall remain ready and able to implement all portions of its program offer for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year, as set forth in the offer described in Petitioner’s Exhibit 33, and as further corrected in accordance with this Order.

5. All of the Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code Section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The Petitioner prevailed on its allegation that the District failed to adequately address STUDENT’s gross motor deficits. The District prevailed on all other issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).

Date: February 2, 2005 _________________________________________ Claudia J. Wrazel, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

Also present at various times during the proceedings were Robert White, representing the South Orange County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA); J. Anthony Smith, attorney for the District; Haide Valadez and Stephen Gonzales, paralegals assisting Ms. Lewis; and Patricia Cromer, an attorney assisting Ms. Lewis.

2 The prehearing conference was held before Hearing Officer Terrence B. Ohler on September 15,16 and 22. At the hearing, the Petitioner confirmed that the memorandum accurately set forth the issues, except for an additional allegation of procedural error arising from confusion as to what SDC placement had been offered to the Petitioner.

3 The District’s responsibility for STUDENT’s education began on his third birthday, May 9, 2004. Accordingly, the program and placement offer at issue in this dispute was made for the period covering the last month of the 2003-2004 regular school year (May 9-June 9, 2004), the 2004 extended school year (ESY) (June 14-July 9, 2004), and the 2004-2005 regular school year (August 25, 2004-June 16, 2005).

4 RCOC funding of the CARD program ended on May 9, 2004, STUDENT’s third birthday, and the PARENTS have paid for the program since that date. In addition, the PARENTS have been paying for private OT services for STUDENT for ninety minutes per week since September 2002, and for private S/L therapy for ninety minutes per week since May 2003. (S. Exh. 12; Testimony of MOTHER.)

5 The standardized tests used by the District included the Preschool Language Scale-4th Edition (PLS-4); the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales; the Temperament and Atypical Behavior Scale (TABS); the Psychoeducational Profile Revised (Pep R)(which rates the subject’s skills in comparison to other autistic children); the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS); the Peabody Developmental Motor Scales-2nd Edition (PDMS-2); and an Infant/Toddler Sensory Profile.

6 These gross motor deficiencies were reported by MOTHER in the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales interview conducted on March 22, 2004. (S. Exh. 16.)

7 Ms. Garrison said that of the autistic children she has assessed in the last eighteen years, STUDENT was “probably right in the middle” in terms of the difficulty he experienced in paying attention to task.

8 Ms. Chua also noted that when gross motor tests are called for by an assessment plan, they usually are administered by the District physical therapist.

9 Ms. Chua noted that STUDENT’s screams were not due to distress, but rather appeared to be a way to “express disinterest” in a task. MOTHER confirmed that STUDENT uses two clearly distinct types of screams; one for distress and one merely to express himself.

10 According to Mr. Vinceneux, the PARENTS sought the evaluation because they suspected STUDENT had “a variety of sensory processing difficulties” that were interfering with his education. (S. Exh. 46.)

11 Although Mr. Vinceneux’s assessment was conducted between March and May of 2004, he did not prepare his report until September 2004. The April 22 IEP indicates that the PARENTS informed the District that it was in the process of obtaining independent S/L and OT evaluations and “planned to share those with the team,” but there is no indication that the District was aware of Mr. Vinceneux’s OT assessment results before his report was issued in September.

12 This factual summary is based on the written IEP document, witness testimony, and transcripts of tape recordings the PARENTS made of the April 22, 2004 IEP meeting and two follow-up meetings on May 4 and May 11, 2004 (See S. Exhs. 33, 48-50).

13 The District representatives present at the beginning of the IEP meeting on April 22 were psychologist Sandra Garrison; speech pathologist Joan Sternberg; special education teacher Jennifer Acosta; autism supervisor Beryl Adams; autism specialist Jennifer Fant; and transition specialist Rayana Sheli. District OT provider Gwyneth Chua arrived during the meeting. Also present were FATHER and MOTHER and RCOC representative Thelma Utterback. (See S. Exhs. 33, 48.)

14 The Garrison/Sternberg assessment report is dated April 21, 2004, and the Chua report is dated April 22, 2004. The transcript of the hearing indicates that Ms. Garrison acknowledged that the District’s preparation of the assessment reports and goals and objectives were “kind of an eleventh hour effort.” (See S. Exhs. 25, 27, and 48.)

15 In response to this invitation, MOTHER crossed out statements in the Garrison/Sternberg assessment indicating that STUDENT suffered from dysregulated behaviors. MOTHER stated that she had incorrectly marked the “yes” column for those behaviors on the TABS test. (Testimony of MOTHER; see S. Exhs. 25 and 48.)

16 As the transcriber of the IEP tapes rarely was able to identify individual voices of District personnel, the transcribed statements of unidentified District personnel are referred to here as statements made by “the District.”

17 The May 4 transcript does not indicate who was present at the meeting. However, the April 22 IEP document has notations of “5/4/04” next to the names of Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, Ms. Utterback, Ms. Adams, Ms. Acosta, and FATHER and MOTHER. (S. Exh. 33, p.2.)

18 Present at the May 11 meeting were Ms. Adams, Ms. Garrison, Ms. Sternberg, Ms. Acosta, FATHER and MOTHER, and RCOC representatives Patrick Ruppe and Evan Springer.

19 The District assessment in March and April of 2004 scored STUDENT’s adaptive behavior composite at one year four months, with S/L skills ranging from one year one month to one year six months. Ms. Berkowitz’ S/L assessment, conducted in April 2004, resulted in an S/L composite score of one year four months. (Ms. Berkowitz testified that the potential for “practice effect” in the District S/L test, which occurred shortly after her assessment, might argue against reporting a standardized score on the District test, but would not lessen the value of the District’s substantive findings, which were essentially equivalent to her own.)

20 The Garrison/Sternberg assessment report is dated April 21, 2004, and its findings may have been unknown to Ms. Chua when she conducted her OT assessment on April 16. However, the information contained in the report was in the District’s possession since it was collected by Ms. Garrison and Ms. Sternberg in March 2004, and should have been timely conveyed to Ms. Chua or otherwise acted upon by the District.

21 Generally, a substantive evaluation of a special education program under the IDEA also requires an analysis of whether the services provided comported with the student’s IEP. Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 201. Since this case involves an offer of services rather than their actual provision, a comportment analysis is not required.

22 MOTHER testified that she and FATHER decided not to invite a CARD representative to the IEP meetings because they thought their issuance of such an invitation might be seen as confrontational by the District.

23 District witnesses indicated that they use the terms “pre-K” and “pre-K/K” interchangeably to refer to classes with both preschool-age children (ages 3-4) and kindergarten-age children (ages 5-6). Classes with only preschool-age children are referred to as preschool classes.

24 District witnesses testified that at the time of the IEP meetings, they believed that Ms. Acosta might be planning to resign before the next school year began, but were unable to discuss this possibility at the IEP meetings since no resignation had been received.

25 The District also offered an observation of Ms. Lerman’s class to give the PARENTS a sense of what a younger student group was like, since younger children were expected to enroll in Ms. Acosta’s class in the fall. (S. Exhs. 48-50.)

26 The fact that the proposed transition plan, educational program, and goals and objectives were prepared by the District in advance of the April 22 meeting does not indicate that the offer was “predetermined.” A local education agency (LEA) is permitted to prepare a draft offer in advance of an IEP meeting to provide a convenient starting point for discussion, as long as it makes clear to the parents that the draft is only a recommendation for review and discussion with them. See 34 C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, Question 32. The IEP transcripts clearly indicate that, at several points during the April and May IEP meetings, the District noted that the offer was a “baseline” or starting point and was open to revision both through the PARENTS’ input and through periodic assessments of STUDENT’s progress.

27 District witnesses acknowledged that Ms. Lerman’s pre-K/K class for autistic children had younger students than Ms. Acosta’s class in May 2004, but her class was not offered at that time because it was at its enrollment limit of eight students. The Petitioner alleges the District never explained this to the PARENTS. The IEP transcripts do not reveal any explanation to the PARENTS as to why Ms. Acosta’s class was being offered instead of Ms. Lerman’s class, but the April 22 transcript is incomplete and all three transcripts indicate muffled portions of tape that could not be transcribed. The transcripts do reveal discussions of the fact that Ms. Lerman’s class had younger children than Ms. Acosta’s class.

28 District witnesses testified that if STUDENT had needed additional transition time, they would have extended the plan accordingly.

29 The prehearing conference memorandum of October 25, 2004, sets forth the Petitioner’s views as to how each District goal should be modified to increase its challenge level, but does not indicate why the Petitioner felt the existing goals (as modified with the PARENTS’ input at the April and May 2004 IEP meetings) were insufficiently challenging.

30 Most of the remaining District goals were speech- and OT-related; CARD had no similar goals, presumably because STUDENT receives S/L and OT services from other providers. A final District goal related to attending to task in a small-group setting. (Compare S. Exh. 5, pp. 7-24, with S. Exh. 33, pp. 14-22.)

31 At the hearing, the PARENTS acknowledged that STUDENT’s performance during the District assessments was not always up to his actual capability levels, most likely because he was being asked to perform by a stranger in an unfamiliar setting.

32 According to Dr. Dores, the BLASST-Off principles also included consistent feedback and reinforcement and consistent data collection to measure progress.

33 Dr. Bostani, who was employed by CARD at the time she assessed STUDENT in September of 2004, acknowledged in her testimony that STUDENT’s skill levels showed he could benefit from a school environment, although she did not feel competent to judge whether his behaviors would interfere with his ability to learn.

34 Although the PARENTS have asserted that they do not believe group learning should be a priority for STUDENT right now, they have acknowledged that STUDENT’s lack of social skills is one of his most serious deficits and have sought to address it themselves in the development of STUDENT’s program. The prehearing conference memorandum of October 25, 2004, indicates that the PARENTS wanted to increase the challenge level of the District’s proposed goal for STUDENT regarding interactive play, and wanted to add a goal requiring STUDENT to initiate activities with peers.

35 The student-teacher ratio was increased by the attendance of two typically developing peers in Ms. Acosta’s class, but was lowered again by the fact that some of her special education students participated in “partial mainstreaming” in general education classrooms for part of the school day.

36 MOTHER acknowledged that, when she told the District of her concerns about the level of instruction during circle time in Ms. Acosta’s class, the District offered to allow STUDENT to go to Ms. Lerman’s class for circle time.

37 In fact, Ms. Fant testified that one of the factors that would prompt the offer of a home program by the District would be if the student in question appeared too aggressive for a classroom setting.

38 For example, Ms. Lerman testified that a child’s IEP might approve the use of candy as a reinforcer as part of an initial learning phase, and that while her policy is to ignore most tantrum behavior, she comforts children who are genuinely upset. Testimony regarding the forceful grabbing of the child appeared to indicate that he was about to crash into furniture, indicating that the grabbing might have been an attempt to keep him safe. Finally, it appeared to the Hearing Officer that testimony as to what constituted an apparent “reward” for maladaptive behavior and what constituted an appropriate redirecting of behavior was at times indistinguishable.

39 The District also offers a home instruction program and funds private and medical placements where necessary, but limits those more restrictive placements to situations where medical needs or severe behavioral problems require them.

40 The federal courts have devised factors to consider when determining whether an LEA’s placement offer satisfies LRE requirements. See, e.g., Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 786 F. Supp. 879 (1992); adopted by the Ninth Circuit in Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel Holland, 14 F.3d 1398 (9th Cir. 1994) cert. denied, 114 S. Ct. 2679 (1993). As those factors do not address whether an LEA has improperly offered a less restrictive environment than that required due to the nature and severity of the disability, however, they are not discussed here.

41 FATHER testified that the cost of private OT services from May 2004 through November 2004 has amounted to approximately $1,910.00.

42 Although the PARENTS ultimately switched providers after being advised that STUDENT was not receiving much benefit from the program, the lack of a successful result does not indicate that a program or service was inadequately designed. See Walczak, supra, 142 F.3d at 133.