California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 27, 2004
Student v. Temecula Valley Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2103-03, SN03-01731, SN03-02103 · Hearing Officer Mark D. Brylski
Temecula Valley Unified offered a FAPE in a special day class with an aide; only two reading goals must be revised.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None noted. The decision mentions a prior SEHO decision, from around December 2001, finding that the student required a one-on-one instructional aide.
Summary
Temecula Valley Unified filed for due process to confirm that its June 2003 IEP offer, clarified in a July 25, 2003 letter, gave a 12-year-old sixth grader with multiple disabilities a FAPE for 2003-2004. Since January 2002, the student's parents had placed her in nonpublic schools, and they enrolled her at Sierra Academy. Her attorney cross-filed two days before the hearing, and the cases were consolidated. The district offered a small special day class at James L. Day Middle School with a full-time one-to-one aide, one daily period of Lindamood-Bell reading instruction, and related services. Because of her balance and mobility needs, it also offered use of a staff hallway and early release from class during passing periods.
The Hearing Officer found that the offer met Union v. Smith even though the class and teacher were not in place when it was made. The district offered one specific program and gave the parents the class size and the teacher's qualifications before school started. Sixteen of eighteen goals were appropriate, but two reading goals were not. One targeted three- to four-syllable words with five sounds, and the other could not be measured. Lindamood-Bell's own test data showed little progress, so one period a day was enough. The placement was the least restrictive environment because Sierra Academy offered no contact with nondisabled peers. The aide and hallway accommodations were needed for safety. No physical therapy reassessment was required. The Hearing Officer denied reimbursement and prospective placement but ordered an IEP meeting within 14 days to revise the two goals.
Why it matters
This decision shows how SEHO treated an offer of a class that did not yet exist. A single, specific written offer was enough under Union v. Smith. It also shows the Hearing Officer weighing mainstreaming at a public campus against a nonpublic school with no nondisabled peers. Two flawed goals out of eighteen did not support reimbursement.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue Procedural. Did the District fail to make a clear, written offer of placement for Student for the 2003-2004 school year (Union v. Smith), where the proposed special day class did not yet exist and its teacher had not yet been hired when the offer was made?
The July 25, 2003 letter offered a single, specific program. The parents learned the class size and the teacher's qualifications before school started. No authority requires the class to exist or be open for parent viewing before an offer is made.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 1A. Were Student's goals and objectives set too low for her present levels of performance?
Sixteen of eighteen goals were appropriate. Reading/spelling goal 1 (three- to four-syllable words with five sounds) and reading-in-context goal 2 (vague and not measurable) were not shown to be appropriate.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 1B. Was the District's offer of one period per day of Lindamood-Bell services appropriate for Student, who contended she needed two to three (or three to four) hours per day?
Lindamood-Bell's own pre- and post-test data showed little progress except in word attack. One period per day was appropriate, and more hours would take time away from other needed instruction.
- District prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 1C. Was the District's offer of placement in a small SDC class at James L. Day Middle School, with a full-time one-to-one aide, a separate hallway, and early release from class during passing periods, in Student's least restrictive environment?
The placement offered mainstreaming that the all-disabled nonpublic school did not. The aide and hallway accommodations were needed for a safe transition. Concerns about overstimulation and lost independence were speculative.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1E. Was the District obligated to reassess Student in the area of physical therapy before offering PT services?
Student had a District PT assessment in December 2002 and an independent PT evaluation in February 2003, and no reassessment was requested. Conditions did not warrant a reassessment, and Government Code section 7572 did not apply.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2a. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to reimbursement for educational costs?
The placement offer was a FAPE in the LRE. Given the overall findings, the two flawed goals did not justify reimbursement.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 2b. If the District failed to offer a FAPE, is Student entitled to prospective placement at Sierra Academy?
Prospective placement at Sierra Academy was denied.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. Within fourteen calendar days of the decision, the IEP team must convene to revise goal numbers one and two of the June 5, 2003 IEP. All other claims for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range; Daniel R.R. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Glendale Unified School Dist. v. Almasi; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Alamo Heights v. State Bd. of Educ.; Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm.
People named in the decision
- Deborah Miller, director of special education, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Christa Smith, program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Dana Connolly, special day class teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Ronnie Plotner, adapted physical education specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Jim Sullivan, special day class teacher, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Karen Stoelting, special day class teacher (proposed class), James L. Day Middle School, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Shirley Kunkel, speech-language pathologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Connie Miller, school nurse, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Jeffrey S. Owen, Ph.D., psychologist; conducted triennial psychoeducational assessment; District witness, Private practice, testifying for District
- Troy Knudsvig, program specialist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Michelle Pullman, occupational therapist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Dwayne Lizar, speech-language pathologist and audiologist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Jan Cunningham, physical therapist, Temecula Valley Unified School District
- Patti Pollack, audiologist, Riverside County SELPA
- Caroline (Carolyn) Upham, nonpublic school teacher; Student witness, Banyan Tree Day School
- Katie Hancock, program director; Student witness, Sierra Academy (nonpublic school)
- Sharon Criger, private physical therapist; independent PT evaluator, Private
- Allison Katos, director of Lindamood-Bell center; Student witness, Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes
- Joanne Ellison, educational consultant for Student, Private
- Sierra Academy, nonpublic school (current parent placement), Kids One, Inc.
- Banyan Tree Day School, nonpublic school (2002-2003 placement), Purchased by Kids One, Inc. and renamed Sierra Academy
- The Country School, nonpublic school (prior placement)
- Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes, private reading instruction provider, San Diego / Del Mar centers
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Temecula, California, on October 10, 14-16, and November 18, 19, and 25, 2003. (Footnote 1)
STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Edwin Egelsee of the Law Offices of Kathleen M. Loyer, Inc. Also appearing on behalf of Student were her mother and father, PARENTS. The Temecula Valley Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Peter A. Sansom of Lozano Smith. Also appearing on behalf of the District was, on some days, either Deborah Miller, director of special education, or Christa Smith, program specialist.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Dana Connolly, special day class (SDC) teacher; Ronnie Plotner, adapted physical education (A.P.E.) specialist; Jim Sullivan, SDC teacher; Karen Stoelting, SDC teacher; Shirley Kunkel, speech and language pathologist; Connie Miller, school nurse; Christa Smith, program specialist; Jeffrey S. Owen, Ph.D., psychologist; Troy Knudsvig, program specialist; Michelle Pullman, occupational therapist; Dwayne Lizar, speech pathologist; PARENT, STUDENT’s father; and Jan Cunningham, physical therapist.
STUDENT called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Caroline Upham, teacher at Banyan Tree Day School; (Footnote 2) Katie Hancock, program director of Sierra Academy; Sharon Criger, physical therapist; Allison Katos, director of Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes; Joanne Ellison, educational consultant; and PARENT, STUDENT’s mother.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the parties’ written closing arguments were received, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.
ISSUES
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2003-2004 school year?
2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the above-mentioned period, is STUDENT entitled to:
a. reimbursement for educational costs?
b. prospective placement at the Sierra Academy?
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
The Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing on August 6, 2003. That case is designated Case No. SN03-01731. At the request of Student’s attorney, Edwin Egelsee, a prehearing telephone conference was held on September 12, 2003. During the conference attended by attorneys Egelsee and Sansom, the presiding Hearing Officer clarified the issues for hearing, and the Student identified her contentions as to why the District had not offered a FAPE. The parties agreed that Student could assert a claim for remedies even though Student had not cross-filed. On September 15, 2003, the Hearing Office issued a written prehearing conference order. The order expressed both the District’s issues and proposed resolutions and Student’s contentions and proposed resolutions that resulted from the discussion held with the presiding Hearing Officer during the prehearing telephone conference.
On October 7, 2003, just two days prior to the scheduled commencement of this matter and just three weeks after the pre-hearing conference order was issued, Student’s attorney cross-filed for due process and raised new issues. That case is designated Case No. SN03-02103. On October 8, 2003, the Hearing Office received Student’s motion to consolidate the two cases. (Footnote 3)
At hearing, the District opposed the motion to consolidate in light of the recent issuance of the prehearing conference order and the fact that Student had failed to file an amended statement of issues more than ten days prior to the scheduled first hearing day. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505 (e)(6). The District noted that Student’s counsel had specifically asserted during the prehearing telephone conference that Student did not contend that the District had committed any procedural violations that resulted in a denial of a FAPE for Student. Nor did Student raise as an issue for hearing the contention that the District had failed to reassess STUDENT in PT prior to offering PT services. The District would not agree to a continuance, however, and the matter went forward on October 10, 2003, with opening statements and testimony. The Hearing Officer then continued the matter for good cause to October 15, 2003, and directed Student’s counsel to provide an explanation, by written declaration, as to why he had not raised the issues at the prehearing conference that he now sought to consolidate. The Hearing Officer directed both parties to brief the matter. Following receipt of Student’s declaration and the District’s written opposition to consolidation, and after additional oral argument, the Hearing Officer, on October 15, 2003, granted the motion to consolidate. After further clarification, the Hearing Officer added the following contentions raised by Student: whether the District had made a clear, written program offer to the Student in accordance with Union v. Smith, and whether the District had denied Student a FAPE by failing to reassess her in the area of physical therapy.
Because the two hearing requests involved the same parties, the same time period, and common issues of fact, and because the alleged procedural violations were inextricably linked to whether the District offered Student a FAPE, the Hearing Officer granted consolidation: (1) to further judicial economy by avoiding duplicative proceedings and (2) to avoid inconsistent results.
CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES
The District contends that at the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting and within its letter dated July 25, 2003, it offered STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year Student contends that the District did not make a valid offer of placement and services in accordance with Union principles and that this omission led to a procedural denial of a FAPE. Student asserts that the District could not make an offer consistent with Union requirements because at the time of the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting and at the time of the July 25, 2003 offer letter, a special day class appropriate for STUDENT was not yet in existence and the District had not yet hired a qualified teacher for the classroom.
Student also contends that the District denied her a FAPE on substantive grounds for the following reasons: the goals and objectives formulated by the IEP team were set too low in relation to STUDENT’s present levels of performance; the District’s offer of one period per day of Lindamood-Bell (LMB) services was not appropriate for STUDENT, who needed two to three hours of LMB services; and the offer of placement was not in Student’s least restrictive environment (LRE) because STUDENT does not need a one-to-one aide in her current placement at Sierra Academy. Student also contends that the District’s offer of a full-time one-to-one aide, together with accommodations for the use of a separate hallway and for leaving class five minutes early during passing periods is too restrictive for her. Student also contends that the District denied her a FAPE by not reassessing her in physical therapy before offering her PT services.
Student seeks reimbursement for independent services and placement for STUDENT through the date of the Decision as a result of the District’s denial of a FAPE. Student also seeks prospective placement at Sierra Academy which it contends is an NPS. The District asserts that it offered STUDENT a FAPE and that if the Hearing Officer finds that it denied STUDENT a FAPE, that Sierra Academy is not properly certified for past reimbursement or for prospective placement.
BACKGROUND FACTS
Petitioner STUDENT is a twelve-year-old student who resides with her family within the jurisdictional boundaries of the Temecula Valley Unified School District. STUDENT is in the sixth grade and is eligible for special education and related services under the category of Multiple Disabilities. STUDENT was born with congenital abnormalities resulting in her need to undergo numerous surgeries. (Test. of PARENT and Student Exh. 160). STUDENT has been diagnosed with Vater type syndrome, which is a combination of multiple medical conditions resulting in developmental delays. She also has atresia of the ear canal and microtia, resulting in deafness in her right ear and difficulties with higher frequencies in her left ear. STUDENT also has Duane’s Reaction Syndrome, an eye movement disorder characterized by a limited ability to mover her eye outward toward her ears and up and down. STUDENT has demonstrated delays in overall fine and gross motor development and in speech and language. STUDENT also has renal and bowel difficulties that require her to use a urostomy bag for the drainage of urine and a cecostomy “button” for manual voiding of her neurogenic bowel. STUDENT has orthopedic impairments that affect her mobility and balance. (Test. of PARENT and Dr. Owen and Dist.Exh. 5).
STUDENT attended SDC kindergarten for two years (July 1996 to June 1998) at Paloma Elementary School before transitioning into Vail Elementary School (Vail) with Resource Specialist Program (RSP) support. For the following three years (fall 1998 through December 2001), STUDENT received educational instruction in a general education and RSP placement, together with the following Designated Instructional Services (DIS): adapted physical education (A.P.E.), occupational therapy (OT), speech and language therapy, and visually handicapped itinerant services. (Test. of PARENT and Dist. Exh. 5).
In January 2002, STUDENT was unilaterally removed by her parents from Vail and placed at The Country School, an NPS. STUDENT attended the school until she transferred to the Banyan Tree Day School, another NPS, which she attended during the entire 2002-2003 school year. STUDENT also received privately obtained Lindamood-Bell (LMB) services at the LMB center site in San Diego, California, from May 2003 until the first or second week of August 2003. STUDENT no longer receives LMB services. (Test. of Ms. Katos) STUDENT currently attends Sierra Academy, a school with 34 students, as a sixth-grade student. (Test. of Ms. Katos, Ms. Hancock, Ms. Upham, and PARENT). STUDENT has not attended a District school since she was removed from Vail by her parents in January 2002.
During a triennial evaluation conducted in November and December 2002 and January 2003, STUDENT was assessed in the following areas: visual functioning, psychoeducational, computer technology needs, speech and language, adapted physical education (A.P.E.), occupational therapy, and physical therapy. (Dist. Exhs. 4 through 9 and Student Exhs. 149-150). In December 2002, Jeffrey S. Owen, Ph.D., a licensed clinical psychologist and credentialed school psychologist, conducted a thorough psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT and concluded that STUDENT met the eligibility criteria for Multiple Disabilities. (Test. of Dr. Owen and Dist. Exh. 5).
On May 5, 2003, the IEP team met to develop a program and placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. The team received a report, by telephone, of STUDENT’s current levels of performance from Carolyn Upham, STUDENT’s teacher at Banyan Tree. The team also discussed goals and objectives for STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Upham, Ms. Smith, Ms. Connolly, Mr. Sullivan, and Dr. Owen and Dist. Exh. 1).
The IEP team met again on May 13. PARENT presented health information about STUDENT, District speech and language pathologist Dwayne Lizar reviewed a May 5, 2003 speech and language progress report from Banyan Tree, and Ms. Joanne Ellison, Student’s educational consultant, discussed Lindamood-Bell (LMB) test data in the area of reading. Math data taken from assessment reports presented at the May 5 meeting as well as present levels of performance for written expression were agreed to by the IEP team. Riverside County SELPA audiologist Patti Pollack discussed her May 7, 2003 testing of STUDENT and the student’s trial use of a micro-ear fm system and easy listener fm systems. Occupational therapist Michelle Pullman discussed by telephone her OT recommendations and STUDENT’s present levels for written communication, ocular-motor control, and sensory diet needs. (Student Exhs. 232-245)
On June 5, 2003, the IEP team met again and formulated goals and objectives for STUDENT. The District proposed a program to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year. (Test. of Dr. Owen, Mr. Knudsvig, and PARENT and Dist. Exh. 2). Two District special day class teachers described their respective classrooms, but both teachers concluded that their classrooms were not appropriate for STUDENT. (Test. of Ms. Connolly and Mr. Sullivan). The District informed the IEP team that it would be creating a third, smaller, special day class for the fall that met STUDENT’s needs. (Test. of Mr. Knudsvig) The June 5 IEP outlines the following program for STUDENT: a special day class at the James L. Day Middle School in Temecula; one period of Lindamood-Bell reading instruction per day; adapted physical education (A.P.E.) one period each school day; occupational therapy (OT) two times per week in a direct, one-to-one format with thirty minutes of consultation per month; language and speech (LAS) therapy in thirty-minute sessions two times per week on an individual basis and one time per week in a thirty-minute session in a small-group format; consultation one time per week for thirty minutes by a vision itinerant teacher; and one-to-one assistance of an Instructional Assistant III, full-time.
On June 9, 2003, Student’s attorney sent a fax memorandum to the attorney for the District indicating that Student disagreed with the District’s placement recommendations. (Dist. Exh. 19)
On July 25, 2003, the District’s attorney sent a detailed letter to Student’s attorney that further clarified the District’s offer of placement and services to STUDENT for the upcoming school year. The letter indicated that STUDENT would be placed in a sixth-grade special day class at the James L. Day Middle School and that the class would be taught by a qualified special education teacher in a small group setting. The offer letter further provided that STUDENT would spend 20% of her day in the general education environment and that she would receive the following DIS services: physical therapy (PT) in two, thirty-minute sessions per week; A.P.E. for one period, five days per week; OT two times per week for 30 minutes in a direct, one-to-one format with 30 minutes of consultation per month; sensory brushing and joint compression every 90 minutes by District personnel; speech and language therapy two times per week in thirty-minute sessions on an individual basis, and one time per week in a thirty-minute session in a small-group format; consultation one time per week for thirty minutes by the vision itinerant teacher; a full-time, one-to-one Instructional Assistant III (one-to-one aide) to assist STUDENT during the regular school day; and door-to-door transportation. The District also offered one period of Lindamood-Bell instruction per school day to be provided in a one-to-one format by an appropriately trained, qualified employee. (Test. of Mr. and Mrs.PARENT and Dist. Exh. 22).
On August 5, 2003, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT sent a detailed letter to the District’s attorney in response to the District’s offer letter of July 25, 2003. The PARENTS requested additional information concerning the District’s offer, including a request as to how many students would in STUDENT’s SDC and for information on the credentials and training of the SDC teacher and the LMB instructor. (Dist. Exh. 23 and Test. of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT).
On August 6, 2003, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing. (Footnote 4) On August 14, 2003, the District sent a detailed letter to the PARENTS in response to their letter of August 5. In relevant part, the letter indicated that there were seven students enrolled in the SDC class the District proposed for STUDENT. The District’s letter also described the qualifications and training of the SDC teacher. (Dist. Exh. 24) On August 26, 2003, the District sent a letter to Mr. and Mrs. PARENT that described the qualifications and training of the LMB instructor. (Student Exh. 311).
On September 2, 2003, the PARENTS paid tuition for one year for STUDENT to attend Sierra Academy. STUDENT began school at Sierra Academy on September 2, 2003. (Test. of PARENT and Ms. Hancock)
On September 9, 2003, PARENT and educational consultant Joanne Ellison made observations of the James L. Day Middle School campus and the SDC classroom offered to STUDENT. PARENT and Ms. Ellison also observed a lunch period and the separate hallway to be used by STUDENT for passing periods. Ms. Ellison prepared a two-page written report that sets forth her detailed observations. (Test. of Ms. Ellison and PARENT and Student Ashes. 347-348).
On September 12, 2003, the parties participated in a prehearing telephone conference for Case. No. SN03-01731. The Student’s contentions regarding the inappropriateness of the District’s offer were clarified, and a Prehearing Conference Order was issued on September 15, 2003, containing the issues and contentions for hearing of both parties.
On October 7, 2003, just two days prior to the scheduled hearing in this matter, the Hearing Office received Student’s cross-filing request for due process. The Student’s case was designated Case No. SN03-02103. On October 8, 2003, the Hearing Office received Student’s motion to consolidate the two cases, and the motion to consolidate was granted on October 15.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Under the amended federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, children with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meets the State educational standards, and that conform with the student’s individualized educational program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et al. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that to receive a FAPE, the student’s IEP must be designed to meet the unique needs of the student and reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education must be provided for the student. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).
The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural protections afforded by the IDEA. 458 U.S. at 205. States are required to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each child with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled, and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range, 960 F.2d at 1483; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Additionally, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:
To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (Footnote 5)
The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming,” or education in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE). The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Bd. of Educ., 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must have met the following four substantive requirements in order to have constituted an appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, (2) been reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, (3) comported with her IEP, and (4) been provided in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 6)
Procedural Appropriateness
Did the District fail to make a clear, written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year?
The Hearing Officer first addresses Student’s contention that the District failed to make a formal clear, written offer of placement for STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year.
The failure by a school district to make a formal clear, written offer of placement to a student is a procedural violation that may result in a denial of a FAPE. Union School Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994); cert. den., 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3). The Ninth Circuit in Union stated that “this formal requirement [of a written placement offer] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced vigorously.” The court further observed that a formal, written offer alerts the parents “to the need to consider seriously” whether the particular placement is appropriate under the IDEA, and would allow the parents an opportunity to decide whether to oppose the placement or to accept it with the supplement of additional education services. A clear written offer would also assist a district in preparing to introduce sufficient relevant evidence at hearing regarding the appropriateness of the placement. Id. at 1526.
The District argues that its offer of placement and services to STUDENT for the 2003-2004 school year is clearly expressed within the June 5, 2003 IEP and with sufficient clarity within its July 25, 2003 offer letter to STUDENT’s parents. Student contends that the offer was not clear and that the District could not make a clear, written offer because, both at the time of the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting and at the time the District prepared its July 25, 2003 offer letter, the special day class proposed by the District was not yet in existence and the District had not yet hired a qualified teacher for the class.
It is undisputed that the District offered certain DIS services at the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting and that within a single letter dated July 25, 2003, the District further clarified its program and identified STUDENT’s SDC placement “within a small group setting” at the James Day. It is also undisputed that the District informed STUDENT’s parents by letter dated August 14, 2003, that the proposed placement contained seven students. The letter also described the classroom teacher’s qualifications. It is also undisputed that the District’s proposed SDC class, taught by a qualified teacher, Ms. Stoelting, was in existence at the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s July 25, 2003 offer letter satisfies the legal requirements of Union v. Smith. The Hearing Officer is unaware of any authority, and Student does not cite persuasive authority under federal or State special education law, that requires that a school district, before making a valid offer for a placement needed at a future date, have the proposed classroom in place, the proposed teacher hired, and the proposed teacher in the proposed classroom for inspection by a parent. Nor does Student provide persuasive authority for the proposition that Union or any other provisions of special education law require that a parent be given an opportunity to view the placement before deciding upon the appropriateness of a district’s offer.
The credible evidence establishes that the District created an SDC classroom and hired a qualified teacher, Ms. Stoelting, prior to the start of the school year. The District also informed Student’s parents prior to the start of the school year that the SDC classroom proposed for STUDENT contained seven students, and the District described the teacher’s qualifications. The credible evidence also establishes that the PARENTS enrolled STUDENT in Sierra Academy on September 2, 2003, and therefore knew at that point the precise size of the District’s proposed classroom and the classroom teacher’s qualifications. There could be no confusion over the related services offered or the precise classroom being offered at James Day at the time STUDENT was enrolled at Sierra. Moreover, PARENT and Ms. Joanne Ellison, an educational consultant, were also given an opportunity to view the proposed SDC classroom prior to the start of the school year, but scheduling conflicts led to a viewing of the classroom and campus by Ms Ellison and PARENT on September 9, 2003. (Test. of Mr. Knudsvig, PARENT, and Ms. Ellison).
Although PARENT testified that she read the District’s detailed written offer letter of July 25, 2003, and that she observed the proposed classroom on September 9, 2003, PARENT also stated that she still lacks sufficient information to decide whether the District’s offer was or is appropriate. The statement suggests that even after seeing the classroom in session and even after knowing the qualifications of the classroom teacher, PARENT was still not satisfied and wanted yet more information. Therefore, Student cannot persuasively argue that her inability to see the proposed class in session prior to her enrolling at Sierra Academy constitutes a Union violation.
Moreover, Student’s assertion that the District could not have made an offer as of July 25, 2003, because the class was not yet in existence and the classroom teacher had not yet been hiredis not supported by the citations presented by the Student in her legal brief. The federal court case cited by Student, Glendale Unified School District v. Almasi, 122 F.Supp.2d 1083 (C.D.Cal. 2000), actually supports Temecula’s position, because the court in Glendale interpreted Union to require that the District formally offer a single, specific program. It is undisputed that the Temecula District, unlike the Glendale District, offered a single, specific program. In contrast, the Glendale District had presented a student’s parents with four different placement offer options. The federal court, in upholding the Hearing Officer’s determination that Glendale’s “offer” violated Union, cited with approval the following language from that Decision: “The parent clearly cannot be required to ferret out from multiple inappropriate placements the one placement offered by the District that, in fact, could have offered her daughter an appropriate placement. The law simply does not impose such a duty to the parent.”
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the amount of detailed information provided by the District to Student’s parents was sufficient for her parents to “consider seriously” whether the particular placement was appropriate for STUDENT, and enabled STUDENT’s parents to decide “whether to oppose the placement or to accept it with the supplement of additional services.” For the foregoing reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s formal single written placement offer to the Student’s parents satisfies the legal requirements of Union v. Smith.
Accordingly, the District, in making its program offer to STUDENT, did not commit a procedural violation that resulted in a denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.
Substantive Appropriateness
1. Did the District offer STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year?
Student contends that the District’s placement offer for the 2003-2004 school year was not substantively appropriate for her and was not a FAPE because the goals and objectives were set too low in relation to her present levels of performance and because the offer of one period of Lindamood-Bell services per day was not appropriate. Instead, Student contends that she needs two to three hours of Lindamood-Bell services per day.
Student further contends that the District’s placement offer was not a FAPE because it was not in her LRE. Student argues that the one-to-one aide offered by the District and accommodations providing for STUDENT’s use, during passing periods, of a separate hallway (used by staff but not by other students) and the accommodation that she leave class five minutes early was too restrictive for her. The District contends that STUDENT needs a one-to-one Instructional Assistant III in order to transition her safely from Sierra Academy, a very small school, to a large comprehensive school and campus, James Day. The District also contends that STUDENT needs to use a separate hallway designed for teachers during passing periods, and that she needs to leave class five minutes early. The District contends that these accommodations are necessary for STUDENT to access a comprehensive campus that will give STUDENT opportunities to interact safely with nondisabled peers at lunchtime, recess, during an elective keyboarding class, and during assemblies. The District argues that its offer is STUDENT’s LRE and that STUDENT’s current nonpublic school placement at Sierra Academy allows no opportunity for her to interact with nondisabled peers because the school serves only disabled students.
The Hearing Officer will address each of Student’s contentions separately but will first discuss STUDENT’s unique needs.
Was the District’s offer designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit?
Dr. Owen testified that he administered a comprehensive neuropsychological battery of test instruments: a measure of nonverbal intelligence, auditory perceptual skills, visual perceptual skills, academic achievement, and an assessment of STUDENT’s emotional and behavioral functioning that included her self-esteem and self concept. (Footnote 7) Dr. Owen described STUDENT’s areas of need as follows: for three reading skills, in the areas of reading decoding, reading fluency, and reading comprehension, STUDENT’s test scores are significantly sub-average in all areas, placing her as a sixth grader at a level significantly below the instructional range of a sixth grade classroom. Dr. Owen stated that STUDENT’s reading decoding skills are in the second grade range and are, in relative terms, higher than her comprehension and fluency skills; for math skills, STUDENT’s development of math skills is significantly below average for her chronological age as well as her sixth-grade placement. Dr. Owen stated that STUDENT was functioning in the “lower” second grade range in the following two areas: STUDENT was able to perform addition and subtraction of digits that did not require regrouping or borrowing, and STUDENT did not demonstrate “parallel skills” for understanding money or time.
Dr. Owen stated that STUDENT has “tremendous” needs in the area of writing, in her ability to spell and formulate sentences, and in the semantic and syntax aspects of writing. Dr. Owen found that the physical act of “putting pencil to paper” is “extremely difficult” for her and that in the area of writing skills, STUDENT is functioning at a level significantly lower than would be expected given her age and grade level. In the area of general knowledge, Dr. Owen estimated STUDENT’s ability to be at the third grade range, although her ability to demonstrate general knowledge might not quite be at the third grade level other than through verbal articulation because of the physical factors that would interfere with the demonstration of that knowledge. Student did not challenge Dr. Owen’s description of STUDENT’s areas of need and levels of functioning.
Dr. Owen stated that STUDENT’s “overwhelming strength” is her sociability, her ability to form relationships, [and] to relate to others.” Dr. Owen therefore expressed concern that having a person (aide) next to her all of the time would inhibit her ability to advance socially and emotionally, not only in the short term but also in the long term. Notwithstanding his concerns about an aide “hovering” over STUDENT, Dr. Owen asserted that it is critical that STUDENT be provided with an instructional aide as a transition from Banyan Tree into the public school setting and that an aide is critical given her multiple medical issues, citing STUDENT’s long history of multiple surgeries for a variety of different difficulties affecting most of her senses — in vision, hearing and mobility (orthopedic abilities). Dr. Owen further stated that a one-to-one aide would be able to address a number of different needs that STUDENT has. Because STUDENT becomes distracted easily, Dr. Owen stated that a one-to-one aide would be able to bring her back to task when she gets off task and could provide instruction and direction at critical times in order for STUDENT to be able to focus on what she needs to learn. In Dr. Owen’s opinion, a one-to-one aide was necessary for STUDENT to transition back to a comprehensive campus.
Dr. Owen testified that STUDENT’s needs could not be met within a regular education classroom, even with a full-time one-to-one aide. Student does not contend that her needs require that she receive instruction in a regular education classroom with a one-to-one aide.
The parties do not dispute the nature of STUDENT’s needs, and Student does not contend that her needs have changed since she left the District in December 2001. (Footnote 8) STUDENT has needs in the areas of reading, math, money skills, written expression, occupational therapy (including sensory processing; writing skills such as letter formation, sentence alignment, and writing directionality; and visual tracking), adapted physical education (in dynamic and static balance) and speech and language. Although the parties do not dispute the general nature of STUDENT’s needs, they dispute how those needs should be met. The District contends that STUDENT’s needs can be met within a small, structured SDC classroom at James Day school with a full-time one-to-one aide, with accommodations. Student contends that STUDENT needs a structured, small classroom in a small school environment that does not require the use of a one-to-one aide.
Student’s contends that the District’s proposed goals are set too low and will not properly address her needs. Student also contends that the LMB offer is insufficient to meet her needs, and that the aide and accommodations proposed by the District make the James Day proposed placement a too restrictive placement for her, citing a high level of independence and higher self esteem she experienced at Banyan Tree.
The Hearing Officer now addresses Student’s specific contentions in light of her needs.
A. Were STUDENT’s goals and objectives set too low for her present levels of performance?
At the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting, the parties developed eighteen goals and objectives for STUDENT. (Footnote 9) Although the Student did not put in evidence regarding all of the goals and objectives and Student did not cross-examine occupational therapist Michelle Pullman regarding the OT goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer will address the appropriateness of each goal because of Student’s contention.
It is undisputed that the District obtained STUDENT’s present levels of performance from her Banyan Tree classroom teacher, Carolyn Upham, by telephone with Ms. Upham during the May 5, 2003 IEP meeting. Ms. Upham testified that she taught STUDENT for the entire 2002-2003 school year (from September 2002 to June 2003) and that she issued an academic progress report dated April 25, 2003. (Footnote 10) (Student Exhs. 220- 224). Ms. Upham testified that all of the goals and objectives formulated by the District were set too low for STUDENT in relation to STUDENT’s present levels of performance. Thus, the Hearing Officer addresses and discusses each goal separately.
District Goal Number One - Reading and Spelling -
As of May 2003, STUDENT was able to decode (read) and encode (spell) [single syllable] words with up to five sounds, in 4 out of 5 trials, with 80% and 70% accuracy, respectively. According to the academic progress report by Ms. Upham, STUDENT as of May 2003, was able to decode phonetically predictable words, but had difficulty with complex and multi-syllable words with blends and diagraphs. (Student Exh. 220 and Test. of Ms. Upham).
District goal number one provides that STUDENT, by August 25, 2004, decode and encode phonetically predictable real and nonsense words with three to four syllables and five sounds with 80% accuracy in 4 out of 5 trials. (Dist. Exh. 2) Although Ms. Upham acknowledged in her testimony that decoding three to four syllable words is a more advanced skill than decoding and encoding one syllable words, the District did not establish the appropriateness of goal number one for STUDENT because it was not established that there are more than a very few words that have three or four syllables with five sounds. The District did not establish that the goal meets STUDENT’s needs or that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit.
District Goal Number Two - Reading in Context -
As of May 2003, the Banyan Tree annual goal that STUDENT decode phonetically predictable words with up to two simple syllables was still in progress. District goal number two provides that by August 25, 2004, STUDENT decode an unspecified number of “unfamiliar yet real words” with 80% accuracy in 4 out of 5 trials. However, the District’s benchmarks refer to decoding and encoding one, two, and then three words. The Hearing Officer finds that the annual goal is vague in relation to the proposed benchmarks because the annual goal does not indicate the number of syllables STUDENT is expected to decode and encode after one year. The goal is therefore unmeasurable. (Test. of Ms. Upham). Because the goal is vague and not measurable, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not establish that the goal meets STUDENT’s needs and is therefore not appropriate for her.
District Goal Number Three - Reading Sight Words -
As of May 2003, STUDENT had learned 91 new words, according to the testimony of Ms. Upham. District goal number three provides that STUDENT read “100 new sight/Dolch words over her baseline (taken 8/03).” (Dist. Exh. 2) The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive the testimony of Ms. Upham that the appropriate District goal was that STUDENT learn 150 new sight words. The Hearing Officer weighs the twenty-nine years of experience of speech and language therapist Ms. Kunkel, the over twenty-two years of experience of Dr. Owen, and the seven years of experience of SDC teacher, Ms. Connolly, with the relative inexperience of Ms. Upham (one and one-half years of experience teaching in nonpublic schools). The Hearing Officer finds that the District goal is not set too low because the goal requires STUDENT to learn more words (100) than she learned during the previous year (91) when, according to the testimony of Ms. Upham, STUDENT made “huge” gains. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal for learning 100 new sight/Dolch words over her baseline meets STUDENT’s need to learn new sight words, and the goal is reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit (learning 100 new words).
District Goal Number Four - Math - numeration, calculation, math vocabulary
As of May 2003, STUDENT, according to the academic progress report prepared by Ms. Upham, could compare and judge numbers 25 to 50 and add and subtract two digit with one digit numbers when employing a multisensory strategy. (Student Exh. 222). District goal number four provides that STUDENT demonstrate an understanding of math concepts/vocabulary and perform addition and subtraction problems for numbers up to 100. (Dist. Exh. 2 at page four) According to the testimony of Mr. Sullivan, a special day class teacher with over fourteen years of experience, the goal is not too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels because the goal requires STUDENT to perform double-digit addition that will result in a three digit number, a more advanced skill than that shown by STUDENT’s present levels. Moreover, Dr. Owen, who as part of his pyschoeducational assessment, administered the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test - Second Edition in December 2002, determined that, in the areas of numerical operations, math reasoning and matehmatics composite, STUDENT obtained standard scores placing her in the .1, .2 and less than .1 percentiles, respectively, testified that the goal was not too low for her. The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to an experienced SDC teacher than to the testimony of a teacher with approximately one and one half years of experience in nonpublic schools. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is not set too low and finds that it reasonably exceeds STUDENT’s present level of performance as of May 2003. The Hearing Office also finds that the goal meets STUDENT’s need to improve her computation skills, and the goal is reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit – that STUDENT perform computations resulting in three-digit numbers, a skill greater than working with numbers 25 to 50.
District Goal Number Five - Math - (telling time)
As of May 2003, STUDENT could tell time to the five minute mark. (Student Exh. 223). District goal five provides that STUDENT tell time to the one minute mark. (Dist. Exh. 2) It is undisputed that telling time to the one minute mark is a more advanced skill than telling time to the five minute mark. (Test. of Ms. Upham, Mr. Sullivan and Dr. Owen). The Hearing Officer gives greater weight to the testimony of Mr. Sullivan, an SDC math teacher with over 14 years of experience, and less weight to the testimony of Ms. Upham, with her approximately one and one half years of experience teaching in nonpublic schools. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is not set too low for STUDENT and that it meets her needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit because STUDENT will be able to tell time more precisely, in one-minute increments.
District Goal Number Six - Money skills - (making change)
As of May 2003, STUDENT needed teacher assistance in order to make change. (Student Exh. 223). As of January 2003 and May 2003, STUDENT had not yet met her benchmarks at Banyan Tree in making change for fifty cents (independently) and in making change for one dollar (with one adult prompt). District goal six provides that STUDENT make change for one dollar independently. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is a more advanced skill for STUDENT because the goal provides that STUDENT make change for one dollar independently and meet STUDENT’s need to learn to make correct change. The goal assists STUDENT in gaining independence. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit because STUDENT will be able to achieve a goal not yet reached at Banyan Tree independently.
District Goal Number Seven - Reading - (to improve fluency)
As of May 2003, STUDENT was “averaging 70 words per minute on a second grade reading passage with an average of 2 errors per passage.” (Student Exh. 224). District Goal seven provides that STUDENT“fluently read up to 100 words per minute, at a beginning third grade level, with no more than three errors...” (Dist. Exh. 2). Although Ms. Upham testified that the District goal was set to low in that the District goal allowed for an additional error, Ms. Uham also acknowledged that if STUDENT were to increase her reading rate by 30 words per minute, that she would likely make more errors and that such an increase represented an almost 50% increase in fluency and progress for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer weighs the experience of the three District witnesses who testified that the goal was not set too low, the fact that the District goal would result in a significant (50%) increase in fluency, and the relative inexperience of Ms. Upham, and finds that the goal is not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels. The Hearing Officer also takes into consideration the LMB test results that indicate that, except for gains in word attack skill, STUDENT’s reading scores have declined. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is designed to meet STUDENT’s need to improve her reading fluency. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit, to increase her fluency from 70 to 100 words per minute.
District Goal Number Eight - Writing - (to improve written language skills)
As of May 2003, STUDENT could not write independently and could edit her work only with the use of computer software and adult assistance. STUDENT had difficulty formulating an organized expository paragraph with expanded sentences without teacher assistance. (Student Exh. 224). District goal number eight provides that STUDENT independently write/type a paragraph that contains correct grammar, capitalization, punctuation, a topic sentence, two supporting sentences, and one conclusion sentence. (Dist. Exh. At p. 5). The Hearing Officer weighs the testimony of Ms. Connolly, an SDC teacher with seven years of experience with that of Ms. Upham, who has just one and one-half year’s of experience in nonpublic schools. Moreover, Ms. Upham’s testimony that the goal only requires that STUDENT turn on the computer is contradicted by the plain language of the goal. The credible evidence establishes that the goal is not set too low for STUDENT and is designed to meet STUDENT’s need to improve her writing skills to a point where she is independent in writing. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal provides STUDENT with an educational benefit, to write independently. Moreover, the goal will further STUDENT’s level of independence.
District Goal Numbers Eleven, Twelve and Thirteen (Footnote 11) - OT goals- (to improve sensory processing, written communication, and visual tracking)
Ms. Michelle Pullman conducted an occupational evaluation of STUDENT on January 7, 2003, as part of STUDENT’s triennial evaluation. Ms. Pullman found significant deficits for STUDENT in the areas of sensory processing as well as deficits in tactile, vestibular, and proprioceptive processing. (Test. of Ms. Pullman and Dist. Exh. 9). District goal number eleven provides that STUDENT “improve her sensory processing by maintaining participation in a movement activity involving changing planes/directions & rhythms for 10 min[utes]...” (Dist. Exh. 2 at page 6). Ms. Pullman testified persuasively that the goal was not set too low in light of the deficits found by her during her assessment conducted just five months earlier and in light of the September 2003 OT Banyan Tree progress report that indicates that STUDENT continues to have significant sensory integration deficits. Moreover, Student did not cross-examine Ms. Pullman and did not offer evidence to suggest that the goal was set too low or was inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels, and the goal addresses STUDENT’s need to improve her sensory processing. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal provides STUDENT with an educational benefit -- improvement of her sensory processing.
Ms. Pullman’s January 7 OT assessment report also identified significant deficits in STUDENT’s letter formation, sentence alignment, and writing directionality. (Test. of Ms. Pullman and Dist. Exh. 9). District goal number twelve provides that STUDENT will improve written communication by copying 3 sentences...using proper letter formation, dir ectionality, case alignment, & spacing with 80% accuracy. Ms. Pullman testified persuasively that the goal was not set too low in light of the deficits found by her just five months earlier and in light of the September 2003 OT Banyan Report progress report that indicates that STUDENT continues to have needs in the areas of letter formation, sentence alignment, and writing directionality. Moreover, Student did not cross-examine Ms. Pullman and did not provide any evidence to suggest that the goal was set too low or was inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels, and the goal meets STUDENT’s need to improve letter formation, sentence alignment and writing directionality. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit – improvement of her letter formation, sentence alignment, and writing directionality.
Ms. Pullman’s January 7 OT report also identified significant deficits in STUDENT’s visual tracking. (Test. of Ms. Pullman and Dist. Exh. 9). District goal number thirteen provides that STUDENT will improve ocular motor control by demonstrating visual tracking by maintaining visual contact in all visual planes for 60 seconds. Ms. Pullman testified persuasively that the goal was not set too low in light of the deficits found during her assessment of STUDENT conducted just five months earlier, and in light of the September 2003 OT Banyan Tree progress report that demonstrates that STUDENT continues to have needs in the area of visual tracking. Moreover, Student did not cross-examine Ms. Pullman and did not offer any evidence to suggest that the goal was set too low or was inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels, and the goal meets STUDENT’s need to improve visual tracking. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit -- improvement of visual tracking.
District Goal Number Fourteen - improve self-advocacy skills
District goal number fourteen provides that STUDENT improve her self-advocacy skills by independently initiating adaptations and modifications according to her health and educational needs (i.e., latex allergy, print too small, [and] need to use computer). (Dist. Exh. 2 at page 8). District program specialist Troy Knudsvig testified persuasively that the goal was not set too low. Moreover, Student did not introduce any evidence on this issue and did not provide any evidence to suggest that the goal was inappropriate for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low and meets STUDENT’s need to improve self-advocacy skills. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit -- improvement of self-advocacy skills.
District Goal Numbers Fifteen and Sixteen - A.P.E. goals - (to improve dynamic and static balance)
According to a December 2002 A.P.E. assessment report, STUDENT has significant deficits in dynamic balance. (Dist. Exh. 8) Mr. Ronnie Plotner, an A.P.E. specialist, testified that a February 2003 assessment instrument administered at Banyan Tree confirms that STUDENT has significant deficits in dynamic balance. District goal number fifteen provides that STUDENT walk forward on a 4 inch wide tape line while walking forward using arms reciprocal to legs in a distance of 8 feet without stepping off line in 4/5 trials. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Mr. Plotner’s opinion that District goal number fifteen was not set too low for STUDENT. Student, did not present any evidence on this goal. The Hearing Officer further notes the testimony of Ms. Upham to the effect that STUDENT, within a few weeks following knee surgery in the spring 2003, demonstrated the same level of mobility in moving about at Banyan Tree that she had demonstrated before her knee surgery. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels and that the goal met STUDENT’s need to improve dynamic balance. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit -- improvement of dynamic balance.
According to a December 2002 A.P.E. assessment report, STUDENT has significant deficits in static balance. (Dist. Exh. 8). District goal number sixteen provides that STUDENT stand on her preferred foot for 5 seconds independently [with] hands on hips, no swaying, lifted foot 6 inches off surface, without touching other leg in 4/5 trials. The Hearing Officer finds persuasive the opinion of A.P.E. specialist, Mr. Ronnie Plotner, who testified that District goal number sixteen was not set too low in relation to the December 2002 assessment and the February 2003 assessment administered by Banyan Tree. The Banyan Tree assessment found that STUDENT has significant deficits in static balance. Student did not present any evidence on this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels and that it met STUDENT’s need to improve static balance. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit - improvement of static balance.
District Goal Numbers Seventeen, Eighteen, Nineteen and Twenty - speech and language goals -
As of May 2003, according to a benchmark progress report propared by a Banyan Tree speech and language therapist, the goal set by Banyan Tree had not yet been met and that STUDENT “has difficulty monitoring her own productions and needs frequent verbal cues to produce consonants clearly during speech tasks.” (Dist. Exh. 28) Mr. Dwayne Lizar, a licensed speech and language pathologist and audiologist with the District, stated that the Banyan Tree speech pathologist who wrote the progress report is certified under the American Speech and Hearing Association (ASHA) and therefore assured him that “she at least has a basic level of competence in speech language pathology.” Mr. Lizar determined STUDENT’s speech and language needs as follows, based on the Banyan Tree progress report: speech production, intelligibility, the ability to produce consonant speech sounds in different contexts, and a moderate to severe hyper nasal voice quality.
Mr. Lizar testified that he relied on the Banyan Tree report in drafting District goal number seventeen which provides that STUDENT “demonstrate the ability to relate a personal incident or retell a short story with 80% intelligibility.” (Footnote 12) Mr. Lizar testified persuasively that this goal was not set too low in light of the Banyan Tree progress report and that it addressed STUDENT’s need for increased speech intelligibility. Moreover, a September 30, 2003 speech and language progress report from Banyan Tree, not in evidence and not available to the IEP team, also supported Mr. Lizar’s opinion that STUDENT was at the same progress level as in May 2003. (Test. of Mr. Lizar) The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels and that it meets STUDENT’sneed for increased intelligibility. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal provides STUDENT with an educational benefit – increased intelligibility up from 70% to 80% by increasing her clarity of speech production. Mr. Lizar stated that seven out of ten words understood is not as good as eight out of ten words understood.
As of May 2003, according to a benchmark progress report prepared by a Banyan Tree speech and language therapist, the goal set by Banyan Tree had not yet been met and that STUDENT “has a tendency to state a similarity and difference that is tangentially related to the given words, but is not the main difference/similarity.” Mr. Lizar testified that he relied on the report to draft District goal number eighteen which provides that STUDENT “demonstrate the ability to orally define a weekly list of 10 vocabulary words and formulate sentences for each word with 80% accuracy.” (Dist. Exh. 2 at page 9). Mr. Lizar testified that goal number eighteen relates to STUDENT’s deficits in semantic language usage and the use of basic concepts and vocabulary skill. Mr. Lizar further stated that the goal addresses STUDENT’s need to expand her vocabulary and to have a better understanding and use of different types of language such as antonyms, synonyms, definitions, basic concepts, and stating similarities and differences between words.
Mr. Lizar testified persuasively that the goal is not set too low in light of the May 2003 Banyan Tree progress report and the September 2003 speech and language progress report that he reviewed during his testimony and that the goal addresses STUDENT’s needs. Student did not present any evidence on this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels and meets STUDENT’s need to expand he vocabulary and use of language. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to give STUDENT an educational benefit – to expand her vocabulary and use of language.
As of May 2003, according to a benchmark progress report prepared by a Banyan Tree speech and language therapist, the goal set by Banyan Tree had not yet been met and STUDENT could only adequately relay a personal event in 2 out of 4 trials with the assistance of a graphic organizer and that STUDENT needs “frequent verbal prompts to include sufficient detail and sequence events appropriately in order for the listener to get the gist of her narrative.” Mr. Lizar testified that he relied on the report to draft District goal number nineteen which provides that STUDENT “be able to recall details from a story or personal incident, including beginning, middle [and] end, with appropriate sequencing [and] adequate vocabulary in 4/5 consecutive trials.” (Dist. Exh. 2 at page 9). Mr. Lizar testified persuasively that the goal meets STUDENT’s need to develop her narrative language skills, to recall details in a story in sequence, to describe personal incidents, and to use adequate vocabulary. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal is not set too low for STUDENT in light of the Banyan Tree benchmark progress report and the September 2003 speech and language progress report that he reviewed during his testimony. Student did not present any evidence on this issue. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goal is reasonably calculated to confer an educational benefit for STUDENT by developing her narrative skills.
As of May 2003, according to a benchmark progress report prepared by a Banyan Tree speech and language therapist, the goal set by Banyan Tree had not yet been met and that STUDENT was at the “65-70% accuracy level for topic maintenance, requests for clarification, and making repairs.” Mr. Lizar testified that he relied on the Banyan Tree report in drafting District goal number twenty which provides that STUDENT “demonstrate the ability to participate in a small group discussion, utilizing appropriate turn taking, topic maintenance, requests for clarification [and] if needed, commenting [and] making repairs with 80% accuracy.” (Dist. Exh. 2 at page ten). Mr. Lizar testified that goal twenty refers to pragmatic language usage involving turn-taking, topic maintenance, requests for clarification, and use of repairs. Mr. Lizar testified persuasively that the goal meets STUDENT’s need for a more appropriate and accurate pragmatic usage. Mr. Lizar persuasively testified that the goal is not too low for STUDENT in light of the Banyan Tree benchmark progress report and the September 2003 speech, the Banyan Tree language progress report that he reviewed during his testimony. Mr. Lizar testified that there was no change in STUDENT’s level of functioning between the May and September Banyan Tree progress reports and therefore the goal is still appropriate because it hasn’t been achieved yet. Student did not present any evidence on this issue. The Hearing Officer finds that the goal was not set too low for STUDENT and that it is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with an educational benefit – improvement of pragmatic language usage.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that, except for goal numbers one and two, the District’s proposed goals and objectives were not set too low for STUDENT in relation to her present levels of performance and meet STUDENT’s needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals, except for goal numbers one and two, provide STUDENT with an educational benefit. The Hearing Officer found that the District failed to establish that goal numbers one and two were appropriate goals for STUDENT.
B. Was the District offer of Lindamood-Bell services appropriate for STUDENT?
The District contends that it’s offer of one period of Lindamood-Bell (LMB) services per day is appropriate for STUDENT. At the prehearing telephone conference held in this matter, the attorney for Student asserted that the District’s LMB offer was not appropriate and that STUDENT needed two to three hours of LMB services per day. However, at hearing, Ms. Allison Katos, the director of the LMB program in Del Mar, first stated that STUDENT needed four hours of daily LMB services and then stated that STUDENT needed three to four hours of daily LMB services. Joanne Ellison, educational consultant for the Student, also testified that STUDENT needed three to four hours of daily LMB services.
It is undisputed that the District offered STUDENT one period per day of LMB services. (Test. of Dr. Owen and Dist. Exh. 22) The District argues that STUDENT does not need more than one hour of LMB services per day and that additional hours of LMB services per day would take away from other courses scheduled for her that are designed to meet her other needs. The District also argues that the very data collected by the LMB staff shows that STUDENT, during the period she received LMB services, made little progress in reading except in one area, word attack, and that she has regressed in some areas, including perhaps the most important area, reading comprehension.
Ms. Katos stated that she knew STUDENT as a student at LMB during the spring and summer of 2003, and that she worked with STUDENT “at the very beginning, in early May 2003,” but that other LMB staff members (not called as witnesses to testify at hearing) worked with STUDENT directly. (Footnote 13) STUDENT attended the LMB center in San Diego for “intensive treatment” beginning on April 27, 2003 and continuing until early August 2003, and stopped receiving LMB services in August after completing 188 hours of the 240 hours recommended by LMB. (Test of Ms. Katos) STUDENT received 169 hours of the Seeing Stars program and 19 hours of the Visualizing and Verbalizing program. Ms. Katos recommended that STUDENT return to LMB “for approximately 240 to 300 hours of further sensory-cognitive treatment.” (Test. of Ms. Katos and Student Exh. 322). (Test. of Ms. Katos and Student Exh. 312)
Ms. Katos described the LMB programs: the LIPS program addresses phonemic awareness by developing skills to read on the page through articulatory feedback; the visualizing and verbalizing program addresses comprehension weaknesses, described by LMB as concept imagery conducted by questioning a student’s imaging; and the Seeing Stars program addresses phonemic awareness and symbol imagery weaknesses by questioning a student’s imaging of letters through sounds and symbols. Ms. Katos stated that STUDENT needs to develop her decoding and encoding skills through the LIPS and Seeing Stars programs, which address reading on the page (encoding and decoding). Ms. Katos also stated that STUDENT needs to develop reading comprehension through the visualizing and verbalizing program. Ms. Katos recommended that STUDENT receive LMB programs in the following order: first, Seeing Stars; next, visualizing and verbalizing; and finally, Cloud Nine math, which is an LMB program for the development of math skills. (Test. of Ms. Katos).
STUDENT was given an LMB pretest on March 31, 2003, by LMB staff members, and various test instruments were administered. (Test. of Ms. Katos) After receiving 188 hours of LMB services for four hours per day, five days per week over a period of just over four months (“except for possibly a one week period spent at summer camp”), STUDENT was retested with the same instruments administered to her on the pretest. (Test. Ms. Katos and Student Exhs. 312-323). The parties did not contest the validity of the test results. (Footnote 14)
Ms. Katos acknowledged that STUDENT’s test scores either declined or showed little or no progress on the following tests: the Detroit Tests of Learning Aptitude -- word opposites (antonyms); verbal absurdities, described by Ms. Katos as the high order thinking skills; oral directions (oral comprehension); the Test of Problem Solving-R, described by Ms. Katos as testing high order thinking skills; the Gray Oral Reading Test (GORT) for the third grade; and the GORT Revised/4, in the areas of rate, accuracy, fluency, and comprehension. Ms. Katos testified that STUDENT’s test scores increased from the 8th to the 25th percentile on the word attack section of the Woodcock Reading Mastery Test. Ms. Katos attributed the increase to STUDENT’s work with the Seeing Stars program where she decoded nonsense words through the Seeing Stars program). Ms. Katos recommended that STUDENT receive “further stimulation” through Seeing Stars. Ms. Katos generally testified that STUDENT needed more time in the Seeing Stars program because “we wanted to get her closer to the normal range...in percentiles, that’s 25th to 75th, from the 3rd percentile she is at right now.”
Dr. Owen testified that apart from increasing her skill level in word attack on the Woodcock Reading mastery test, STUDENT’s overall scores for reading as indicated by LMB pretest and retest results (above) have declined and that STUDENT has not shown a significant improvement in her reading ability. Instead, Dr. Owen stated that STUDENT has “gotten worse in reading” over the period that she received LMB services. Dr. Owen’s testimony regarding STUDENT’s overall lack of progress under LMB was unrefuted.
Moreover, Dr. Owen did not agree with the LMB recommendation that STUDENT receive three to four hours of LMB services per day, describing the amount of time as excessive because that amount of LMB services would reduce the amount of time STUDENT would have to meet her other needs, such as science and social studies. Dr. Owen also stated that not attending courses such as science and social studies would detract from STUDENT’s ability to develop a common body of knowledge with her peers, thereby widening the gap between STUDENT and her nondisabled peers. Dr. Owen also asserted that STUDENT needs all of her related services which should not be reduced or terminated in order that STUDENT receive an increase in LMB services.
The Hearing Officer notes Ms. Katos’ acknowledgment that she had not reviewed any of STUDENT’s IEP goals, nor had she reviewed any Banyan Tree or Sierra Academy reports or goals. Ms. Katos stated that she had not reviewed Dr. Owen’s report and that in forming her recommendation for additional LMB services, she does not make any recommendations “based on anything other than our evaluations.” When asked how STUDENT could receive the LMB recommendation of four hours of LMB services per day when STUDENT had additional classes such as social studies, math, language arts and physical education, Ms. Katos replied, “that would be up to the District and the family.” Ms. Katos acknowledged that it “wasn’t within her decision-making” that STUDENT miss out on social studies but later stated that it would be appropriate for her to miss out on social studies and science in order to keep her recommended increase to four hours per day of LMB services.
Joanne Ellison, educational consultant, also testified that STUDENT needed three to four hours of LMB services per day and that she needed that number of hours over the whole school year. Ms. Ellison acknowledged that twenty hours of LMB services per week, eighty hours per month, multiplied by nine months per year equaled 500 hours of LMB services. (Footnote 15) The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Ellison’s testimony was inconsistent with Ms. Katos’ recommendation that STUDENT needed 240 to 300 hours. Ms. Katos stated that STUDENT would be retested “after about 240 hours” to decide if her goals were reached and if LMB services would continue. Ms. Ellison also stated that STUDENT’s course work in science, social studies, math, and language arts could be provided through LMB methodology, but Ms. Katos stated that the order of programs that she projected for STUDENT were as follows: Seeing Stars (“she needs more work on that”), visualizing/verbalizing (“intensively”), “and then, hopefully, we go to On Cloud 9 [math].”
Shirley Kunkel, a District speech and language pathologist with twenty-nine years of experience, stated that STUDENT would not benefit from an additional hour or two of LMB per day in light of STUDENT’s performance on the LMB testing. (Footnote 16) However, Ms. Kunkel acknowledged that she had never observed STUDENT in a classroom and did not attend any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings.
The Hearing Officer does not find persuasive Student’s contention that she needs either two to three hours, or three to four hours, of LMB services per day when the data provided by LMB generally indicate that STUDENT has not made significant progress except in one skill area, word attack. The data instead support the District’s offer of one hour of LMB services because that level of LMB services would help STUDENT with her transition to James Day and enable STUDENT to maintain and develop her word attack gains. (Test. of Dr. Owen) Moreover, school districts are given deference under the IDEA in choosing appropriate methodologies, and the District’s selection of the SRA reading program in the SDC class proposed for STUDENT appears to be an appropriate methodology. (Test. of Ms. Stoelting and Ms. Upham).
The Hearing Officer gives great weight to the opinion of Dr. Owen who has twenty years of experience as a clinical psychologist and whose comprehensive neuropsychological assessment of STUDENT was unrefuted by Student. Dr. Owen’s opinions concerning STUDENT’s needs and the appropriateness of the District’s proposed program were expressed in a detailed and measured manner. Dr. Owen attended two important IEP team meetings held for STUDENT on May 5, 2003 and June 5, 2003, and Dr. Owen observed STUDENT in a variety of settings and made observations at Banyan Tree and at the proposed SDC classroom at James Day. Dr. Owen’s testimony reflected a balanced understanding of STUDENT’s needs and the services required to meet all of her needs.
The Hearing Officer gives less weight to the opinion of Ms. Katos. Ms. Katos did not attend any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings and did not display a detailed understanding of, let alone an interest in, all of STUDENT’s unique needs. Ms. Katos had not reviewed any reports, that she remembered, or any of STUDENT’s IEPs, thereby reducing the foundational value of her testimony. Ms. Katos testified that she had only worked with LMB for one year and that she “barely ever” actually provides LMB services, at one point stating that the amount of time that she gives direct LMB services is basically “zero.” Ms. Katos has not taught in a California public school or in a special education classroom. Ms. Katos was simply unable to provide a reasonable explanation for her opinion, in light of STUDENT’s performance on the LMB tests, that STUDENT needed an additional 240 to 300 hours of LMB services and that STUDENT “needed” the services three or four hours per day, five days per week, notwithstanding the effect on STUDENT’s ability to attend the academic classes proposed by the District.
The Hearing Officer carefully considered the opinion of educational consultant Joanne Ellison regarding STUDENT’s need for LMB services and gives less weight to her testimony than to Dr. Owen’s testimony for the following reasons: Although Ms. Ellison also attended STUDENT’s IEP meetings, Ms. Ellison did not assess STUDENT. Moreover, Ms. Ellison’s opinion that STUDENT needed 500 hours of LMB services lacked credibility and foundational value because the estimate greatly surpassed the recommendation given by Ms. Katos (240 to 300 hours) who was unprepared to state whether STUDENT would continue to benefit from LMB services after receiving the amount of hours recommended. Ms. Ellison did not provide a satisfactory explanation as to how STUDENT would receive instruction in social studies, science, math and language arts within the four hours of recommended daily LMB instruction.
The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District offer of one hour of LMB services per day is appropriate for STUDENT.
C. Was the District’s offer of placement in STUDENT’s least restrictive environment?
As noted above, special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Congress created such a strong preference in favor of educating children with disabilities with their nondisabled peers (mainstreaming) that it rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption. Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036 (1989).
Student does not contend that she belongs in the general education classroom. Since January 2002, STUDENT has been attending nonpublic schools, beginning with The Country Day school, then with Banyan Tree Day School, and at present, Sierra Academy, since her parents removed her unilaterally from Vail Elementary School. It is undisputed that STUDENT has no opportunity for interaction with nondisabled peers at Sierra Academy, because all of the students at Sierra are disabled. (Test. of Ms. Hancock and Ms. Upham). The Hearing Officer has already found that the placement offered by the District at James Day, with the use of a full-time one-to-one aide and with accommodations for passing periods and leaving class five minutes early, is appropriate for STUDENT.
The District contends that the offer of placement for STUDENT in a small, structured SDC classroom at James Day taught by Ms. Stoelting was an appropriate placement for her, and that STUDENT needs a full-time one-to-one aide to transition to James Day from Sierra Academy.
Student contends that the placement offer is not appropriate for her because the campus is too large and too noisy and would be over-stimulating and overwhelming for her. Student also contends that opportunities for interaction with nondisabled peers are unlikely given STUDENT’s preference for a smaller campus environment like Sierra Academy. Student contends that she doesn’t need a one-to-one aide at Sierra Academy and that having one at James Day would tend to isolate her, is too restrictive, and would reduce the level of independence and self-esteem she experiences at Sierra Academy. In summary, Student contends that the need for a one-to-one aide, while necessary for her for safety reasons at James Day, is too restrictive for her, thereby rendering the proposed placement inappropriate.
The Hearing Officer will address each of Student’s contentions regarding the appropriateness of the District’s proposed placement at James Day.
It is undisputed that James Day, with approximately 1,300 students, is situated on a very large comprehensive campus with large athletic fields that affords both disabled and nondisabled students opportunities to engage in a variety of physical education and social activities. (Test. of Mr. Knudsvig) It is also undisputed that Sierra Academy is a very small school with approximately 34 students that is located within an industrial park with no athletic fields and that affords little or no opportunity for outside physical education activities, apart from the use of a basketball hoop placed against the outside wall of the building Sierra Academy shares with adjacent businesses. The basketball “court” is a two-lane driveway that runs parallel to the building and leads to a rear parking area. The driveway is used by businesses and parked cars were observed in the rear parking area. A fire lane sign is posted at the driveway entrance. (Test. of Ms. Upham and Ms. Hancock and HO MDB observations.).
Ms. Ellison testified to observations that she made during her visit to James Day on September 9, 2003: She felt that the campus would be “overwhelming” for STUDENT and that the large number of students and the high activity and very high noise level there would be “overstimulating” for STUDENT. Ms. Ellison saw “a lot of people moving in different directions” and that “all of those things would be overstimulating and confusing” for STUDENT. Ms. Ellison also expressed concerns about STUDENT’s mobility deficits and her ability to navigate such a large campus.
Student’s concerns about the very large campus and large number of students attending James Day, with a high activity level and noisy environment must be placed in context. The District’s proposed SDC class, taught by a qualified teacher, Ms. Stoelting, contains, at most, just eight students. Moreover, a large part of STUDENT’s school day (80%) would be spent either within Ms. Stoelting’s small SDC classroom or while receiving DIS services one-on-one or in small groups. Ms. Stoelting credibly testified that her classroom was not noisy. Ms. Stoelting also stated that her classroom is very open and very easy to maneuver and that the student’s desks are shaped in a U. Moreover, Ms. Ellison’s detailed written account of her observations of the classroom on September 9 do not indicate that the classroom was noisy or that the classroom presented obstacles that raised concerns about STUDENT’s mobility. (Student Exhs. 347-348). Moreover, an fm trainer will be made available to STUDENT while she attends Ms. Stoelting’s SDC class. The trainer will reduce background noise and help STUDENT focus on instruction. (Test. of Mr. Lizar)
Only 20 % of STUDENT’s school day will be spent in mainstreaming opportunities, either at lunch, during physical education, assemblies, or while attending a computer keyboarding class. It is undisputed that at present, STUDENT enjoys no opportunities for interaction with nondisabled peers at the Sierra Academy at any time. (Test. of Ms. Hancock and Ms. Upham). The Hearing Officer finds that the proposed placement at James Day is not too large or too noisy for STUDENT.
Ms. Ellison’s assertion that James Day would be over-stimulating and overwhelming for STUDENT is not persuasive. Ms. Ellison’s acknowledgment that she has never observed STUDENT at James Day or in a large group setting reduces the foundational value of her opinion. It is speculative to predict how STUDENT will respond to James Day without first seeing her on the campus. Moreover, STUDENT enjoys participating in activities that occur in public settings, activities involving fairly large numbers of people and high noise levels. For example, STUDENT regularly participates in soccer games where spectators observe the games. (Test. of PARENT) STUDENT also participates in gymnastics in a “huge” enclosed gymnastics studio with “lots of kids” there. STUDENT has participated in two Special Olympics that included 150 people at the events. (Test. of PARENT) STUDENT also enjoyed attending a hockey game. (Test. of PARENT)
Dr. Owen credibly testified to the benefit STUDENT will receive in having to deal with challenges she will encounter at James Day which will help prepare her for the challenges she will face outside of school. The Hearing Officer finds that the James Day proposed placement would not be overstimulating or overwhelming for STUDENT.
Mainstreaming opportunities
It is undisputed that STUDENT enjoys no mainstreaming opportunities at Sierra Academy and that she will have mainstreaming opportunities at James Day. Ms. Ellison’s testimony that she would not expect STUDENT to interact with nondisabled peers at lunchtime and during keyboarding class thereby making the placement inappropriate for STUDENT is unpersuasive. Ms. Ellison acknowledged that she has never seen STUDENT at James Day, and therefore, Ms. Ellison’s opinion is speculative as to how STUDENT will respond to the presence of nondisabled peers at lunchtime and during keyboarding class. Moreover, it is undisputed that STUDENT is very sociable and loves to interact with peers and therefore it is more – not less likely, that STUDENT will interact with nondisabled as well as disabled peers at James Day when given the opportunity.
One-to-one aide
It is undisputed that STUDENT will need a full-time aide to transition from Sierra Academy to the James Day campus. Ms. Ellison’s testimony that attendance at James Day will result in a loss of independence and reduced self-esteem due to a reliance upon a one-to-one aide is unpersuasive and does not appear to take into account the LRE mandate that STUDENT be educated with nondisabled peers to the maximum extent appropriate. Moreover, it is speculative whether STUDENT will experience lowered self-esteem or a loss of independence at James Day. Ms Ellison has never observed STUDENT at James Day. The Hearing Officer places great weight on the mainstreaming opportunities James Day offers STUDENT. Ms. Upham testified to STUDENT’s high level of independence and a high level of self-esteem she experienced at Banyan Tree. Ms. Hancock testified to STUDENT’s ability to get around Sierra Academy and navigate the two floors there without assistance. And yet Ms. Upham acknowledged that she generally taught STUDENT academic subjects in a one-on-one basis rather than in a group setting, a practice which does not appear to foster independence. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s concerns about experiencing reduced self-esteem and less independence at James Day are, at present, speculative and ignore potential opportunities for interaction with nondisabled peers that may ultimately lead, over time, to a greater degree of independence and a higher self-esteem level for STUDENT. (Test. of Dr. Owen)
The Hearing Officer also notes the abundant, credible testimony that characterizes STUDENT as courageous and very special, a young girl who enjoys social interactions with peers immensely. (Test. of PARENT, Ms. Upham, Dr. Owen, Ms. Hancock). The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s strengths, that she is very social and courageous, will hold her in good stead in accessing the opportunities James Day offers all students who attend the school. (Test. of Mr. Knudsvig).
It is also undisputed that STUDENT needs, at present, a one-to-one aide to deal with a large James Day campus and to assist her in making transitions between periods. (Test. of PARENT, Dr. Upham, Mr. Knudsvig). The Hearing Officer finds that the use of a one-to-one aide is appropriate for STUDENT at James Day. Mainstreaming opportunities at James Day are more likely to give STUDENT a greater opportunity for independence by allowing her a chance to interact on a comprehensive campus with nondisabled peers than continued placement at a very small school with no chance for mainstreaming.
Use of separate hallways and leaving class five minutes early during passing periods
Regarding the District’s proposal that STUDENT use a separate hallway for staff during passing periods, Ms. Ellison acknowledged that it was necessary for STUDENT’s safety because STUDENT “would have trouble navigating through the hallways, when there are a lot of other people there” and “I think she has some balance issues, she could be easily knocked over...” The Hearing Officer finds that the proposed use of a separate hallway and the proposal that STUDENT leave class five minute early during passing periods are appropriate accommodations for STUDENT and address concerns over STUDENT’s mobility deficits. The accommodations will give STUDENT access to James Day. It is undisputed that once STUDENT demonstrates her ability to navigate the campus and passing periods safely at James Day, the IEP team can revisit STUDENT’s need for such accommodations as well as her need for a full-time one-to-one aide.
The weight of the credible evidence establishes that the District’s proposed placement for STUDENT at James Day in a small special day class with a one-to-one aide and the accommodations outlined above is appropriate for her and addresses her unique needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that without the one-to-one aide and without the use of a separate hallway for passing periods and the ability to leave class five minutes early, placement at James Day would not be appropriate for her because STUDENT needs the aide and accommodations to transition safely from Sierra Academy to James Day. (Test. of Dr. Owen) A safe and successful transition will mean that STUDENT will have ample opportunities to interact with nondisabled peers at lunchtime, during physical education, and during keyboarding class, opportunities that do not exist at Sierra Academy.
The rebuttable presumption that favors placement on a comprehensive campus with nondisabled peers has not been overcome by speculative concerns about how STUDENT will feel or how she will respond at James Day. Nor has the rebuttable presumption been overcome by speculative concerns that STUDENT will not interact with her nondisabled peers. STUDENT is, by all accounts, very social, very special, and very courageous. STUDENT has a demonstrated ability to interact with nondisabled persons outside a school environment. (Test. of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT). It is implausible that STUDENT at James Day will no longer enjoy social interactions. (Test. of Mr. and Mrs. PARENT, and Test. of Ms. Upham and Dr. Owen) Moreover, concerns raised at hearing about STUDENT’s mobility and independence at James Day must also be taken into context. Banyan Tree (and Sierra Academy) witnesses extolled the benefits of a small school and STUDENT’s independence and mobility in getting around the small school. However, the school has two floors and has virtually no opportunity for outsidephysical education activities. In contrast, James Day is situated on one floor, making it even more accessible to STUDENT, and James Day has ample space and athletic fields for outdoor physical education activities.
The District’s offer of a one-to-one aide and the accommodations at James Day will help STUDENT get started again on a comprehensive public school campus, after a two-year absence. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement in a small, SDC class with a one-to-one aide and with accommodations at the James L. Day Middle School was in STUDENT’s least restrictive environment.
E. Was the District obligated to reassess STUDENT in the area of physical therapy?
A reevaluation of a special education student must be conducted “if conditions warrant a reevaluation, or if the child’s parent or teacher requests a reevaluation, but at least once every three years.” 34 C.F.R. § 300.536(b). It is undisputed that neither STUDENT’s parents nor teacher requested a physical therapy (PT) reevaluation of her prior to the commencement of the 2003-2004 school year. The District last conducted a physical therapy evaluation of STUDENT on December 12, 2002, during her triennial. (Student Exhs. 149-150). On February 7, 2003, STUDENT’s parents obtained an independent PT evaluation from Sharon Criger and the findings were shared with the IEP team. (Student Exhs. 392-395).
It is also undisputed that Student did not request that the District conduct a PT evaluation until raising the matter within Student’s request for a due process hearing (Case No. SN03-02103) that was filed on October 7, 2003. An assessment plan for a PT assessment was provided to Student’s parents on October 8, 2003, but Student’s parents refused to sign the assessment plan. (Dist. Exh.34 and Test. of PARENT).
The District argues that conditions did not warrant reassessment of STUDENT in the area of physical therapy and that the District was therefore not obligated to reassess STUDENT.
Student contends that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE because the District offered her PT services for two 30-minute sessions per week without a PT assessment. Student cites in her brief Government Code section 7572(a), (d) and (e) for the proposition that before offering related services, a district must first assess a student in the area of the proposed related service. The Hearing Officer notes that section 7572(a), (d), and (e) is not applicable to the facts in this case because section 7572 applies to assessments conducted by California Children’s Services (CCS) and not to districts. See also sections 60300 and 60310, et. seq., of the California Code of Regulations.
The Hearing Officer now addresses the issue whether conditions warranted reassessment of STUDENT in the area of physical therapy. It is undisputed that STUDENT was assessed in PT in December 2002, just six or seven months prior to the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting and prior to the District’s offer letter of July 25, 2003. It is also undisputed that the June 5 IEP team also considered the independent assessment conducted by Sharon Criger on February 7, 2003. The Hearing Officer also notes the testimony of STUDENT’s teacher, Ms. Upham. Ms. Upham stated emphatically that after STUDENT’s knee surgery in the spring 2003 and following the use of a wheelchair (for three weeks) and the use of a walker for a “half week,” STUDENT’s ability to get around Banyan Tree without any assistive devices was the same as it was prior to the surgery. (Test. of Ms. Upham)
Moreover, the Hearing Officer found inconsistent Ms. Criger’s testimony regarding the District’s need to reassess STUDENT in PT before providing PT services, and yet Ms. Criger acknowledged that she herself could continue to provide PT services to STUDENT without first undertaking a PT reassessment. Ms. Criger also stated that if she were ill, a colleague could provide PT services to STUDENT without first conducting a reassessment of STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds credible the testimony of Jan Cunningham, a licensed physical therapist with over ten years of PT experience, who stated that a records review and a telephone call to Ms. Criger was sufficient to determine STUDENT’s current PT needs, and that a formal PT reassessment of STUDENT was not warranted at this time.
The credible evidence establishes that conditions did not warrant a PT reassessment of STUDENT.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer for the 2003-2004 school year, with the limited exception of the inappropriateness of goal numbers one and two, was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to provide her with some educational benefit, and therefore was a FAPE.
2. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the above-mentioned period, is STUDENT entitled to:
a. reimbursement for educational costs?
b. prospective placement at Sierra Academy?
When a school district denies a FAPE, a student is entitled to relief that is appropriate in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i). Parent may therefore be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide an appropriate placement, and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. Under Burlington, reimbursement is allowed even if the placement or services selected by a parent are found not to be the exactly appropriate placement or services required of school districts under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). Nevertheless, a placement chosen by a parent must still meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA. The placement must address the student’s needs and provide her with an educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993). Reimbursement may be awarded even if the private school does not meet the requirements for state certification. Id. at 14.
To qualify for reimbursement, Student’s parents must have addressed STUDENT’s needs and provided her with educational benefit. Student has the burden of proving that the parents’ program was appropriate and that reimbursement is warranted. Equitable considerations, including the conduct of the parties, is relevant in fashioning an appropriate remedy. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 374; see also W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range School Dist., 96 F.2d 1479, 1486 (9th Cir. 1992).
The Hearing Officer finds that based on the abundant record in this matter, the decision by Student’s parents not to enroll STUDENT at James Day was based on Student’s contention that placement in a small SDC class at James Day was not appropriate for STUDENTand was not in her LRE. Although the Hearing Officer has found that placement was appropriate for STUDENT and was a FAPE in the LRE for the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer also found that District’s proposed goal numbers one and two, out of a total of eighteen goals, were not appropriate for STUDENT. In light of the overall findings in this matter and the findings on goal numbers one and two, and the relative importance of all of the findings, the Hearing Officer finds that Student is not entitled to reimbursement for educational costs incurred during the relevant period. The Hearing Officer also finds that Student is not entitled to prospective placement at Sierra Academy.
ORDER
1. Within fourteen calendar days of the date of this Decision, the IEP team is directed to convene to revise goal numbers one and two of the June 5, 2003 IEP.
2. All of Student’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
In accordance with Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District prevailed on each issue heard and decided except for two out of eighteen goals that were found to be not appropriate.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: January 27, 2004 ____________________________________ Mark D. Brylski, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1. No evidence was taken on October 9, 2003, the first day scheduled for hearing. The day was taken up largely with arguments over Student’s motion to consolidate Student’s Case No. SN03-02103. The presiding Hearing Officer also conducted site inspections on December 8, 2003 at the James L. Day Middle School and Sierra Academy in the presence of the attorneys for the parties.
2. Banyan Tree Day School, a nonpublic school (NPS), was purchased by Kids One, Inc. during the spring of 2003 and renamed Sierra Academy. STUDENT attended the Banyan Tree Day School (Banyan Tree) during the 2002-2003 school year and has attended Sierra Academy during the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer refers to each school by name to avoid confusion because Sierra Academy underwent some staffing and other changes after Banyan Tree was purchased by Kids One, Inc.
3. Student’s spare motion contained just a single, short paragraph signed by Mr. Egelsee. The motion did not refer to the prehearing conference order, did not contain any specificity regarding the factual issues of each case, and did not include a supporting declaration.
4. The District raised as issues for hearing whether it had offered STUDENTa FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year and extended school year and if not, whether the District must fund her private placement for the remainder of the 2003-2004 school year. During a discussion with the presiding Hearing Officer at hearing, the parties agreed to drop as an issue for hearing whether the District offered a FAPE for the 2003-2004 ESY because the issue was premature. The issues as framed by the presiding Hearing Officer reflect the prehearing conference order and discussions at hearing with the parties, particularly concerning those issues that were consolidated for hearing. The issues have been reworded to facilitate analysis.
5. The Hearing Officer does not employ the four-factor balancing test, cited in the parties’ briefs, for determining whether the District’s placement offer is in STUDENT’s LRE because Student’s parents do not seek a regular education classroom placement for STUDENT. Sacramento City Unif. School Dist. v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398.
6. The IEP was not implemented because Student did not attend the school placement proposed by the District. Therefore, the Hearing Officer does not address whether the District comported with her IEP. No evidence was offered at hearing to show that the District could not implement STUDENT’s IEP. Moreover, Petitioner’s main contention was that the District’s proposed placement was not in the LRE. The Hearing Officer also addresses whether the offer met STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer some educational benefit.
7. Dr. Owen is a licensed clinical psychologist and a credentialed school psychologist with over twenty years of experience in conducting psychoeducational and neuropsychological assessments. He is in private practice and conducts psychotherapy for a range of individuals typically focusing on children and their families. Dr. Owen estimates that he has conducted two or three thousand assessments. Dr. Owen has a bachelor’s degree in psychology from UCLA, and a master’s degree in clinical psychology from USC, where he studied psychology and education and different disabilities such as abnormal psychology and experimental psychology. Dr. Owen earned a Ph.D. from USC with an emphasis in clinical psychology and a minor in educational psychology. Dr. Owen’s described his Ph.D. dissertation as a “tripartite” analysis of WISC-R, the “most frequently used test of intelligence or cognitive ability.” Dr. Owen is a nationally certified school psychologist and has diplomate status in administrative psychology.
8. By letter dated May 23, 2003, STUDENT’s parents informed the District that “[o]ther than the surgeries which have decreased STUDENT’s current mobility, STUDENT’s medical/health condition and needs have basically not changed since she left the District in December 2001, which was around the same time SEHO found in STUDENT’s favor in the Due Process Hearing over whether STUDENT required a one-on-one Health Aide.” (Dist. Exh. 17) [note: the determination was that STUDENT required the use of a one-on-one Instructional Aide.]
9. Goal numbers nine and ten were deleted and incorporated into other goals at the June 5, 2003 IEP meeting.
10. Ms. Upham testified that she holds a mild to moderate teaching credential in California and that she is certified in Florida as a specific learning disabilities teacher. Ms. Upham holds a bachelor’s of science degree from the University of Central Florida and is working on a master’s of science degree in educational counseling. Ms. Upham stated that she began teaching her first classroom in March 2002 where she was “fully responsible” for drafting IEP goals and maintaining progress on IEP goals. At the time of hearing, Ms. Upham had approximately one and one-half years of teaching experience in nonpublic schools, but has never taught in a public school. (Test. of Ms. Upham).
11. There is no goal number nine or ten, because the skills addressing OT needs for the two goals were incorporated into other goals.
12. Mr. Lizar holds a bachelor’s degree from Phillips University in Oklahoma with a major in speech pathology/audiology and a master’s degree in speech pathology/audiology from the University of Oklahoma Medical Center. Mr. Lizar also completed all course work and examinations required for a Ph.D. at Vanderbilt University as well as completion of a dissertation that compared a group of Down’s syndrome children with non-Down’s syndrome children in language development. Mr. Lizar is a licensed speech pathologist and audiologist in California and in other states. Mr. Lizar is also certified by the American Speech and Hearing Association (ASHA) in speech pathology and audiology. Mr. Lizar has been working in the areas of speech pathology and audiology for 35 years. Mr. Lizar estimated that he has conducted approximately 3,500 assessments in the areas of speech and language pathology and audiology.
13. Ms. Katos stated that she had been at LMB “for about one year,” and that she had received clinical training in LMB as well as consultant and management training. Ms. Katos has a bachelor’s of science degree in early childhood education and a master’s degree in leadership from the University of San Diego. Ms. Katos has a current California multi-subject teaching credential, a current teaching license in Georgia, and teaching experience in elementary schools in Georgia from 1994 to 1995 and from 1998 to 2001.
14. The Hearing Officer notes that the retest results were not available to the IEP team on June 5, 2003. Nevertheless, the test results are useful in evaluating Student’s contention that she needs three to four hours of LMB services per day. See Adams v. Oregon, (9th Cir. 1999) 195 F.3d 1141.
15. Ms. Ellison stated that she holds a bachelor of science, dual degree, in elementary education and special education of the mentally retarded from Boston University and a master of arts degree in special education for the neurologically impaired from Teachers College of Columbia University (New York, New York). Ms. Ellison also has a professional certification in educational therapy (C.E.T.) from the University of California at San Diego. Ms. Ellison has training in Lindamood-Bell and taught brain injured children in New York from 1972-1976 as a special education teacher and unit coordinator. Ms. Ellison has also taught in private elementary schools in California and Massachusetts (1986-1987) and as a part-time teacher for grades K through 7 in San Diego from 1992-1994. Ms. Ellison has acted as a special education advocate and as an educational consultant. (Test. of Ms. Ellison and Student Exh. 123).
16. Ms. Kunkel stated that she had received LMB training from the founders of LMB and that she had received training on all of the LMB reading programs.
