California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 22, 2005

Student v. Horizon Instructional Systems

SEHO Case No. SN 2119-03 · Hearing Officer Tracy L. Tibbals

Horizon Instructional Systems offered FAPE by replacing home-based Davis dyslexia instruction with site-based Wilson Reading System services.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

Parents' October 2003 due process request was pending, with stay put in effect; other issues settled before hearing, leaving only the January 31, 2005 IEP offer.

Summary

The parents of a 14-year-old eighth grader filed for due process against Horizon Instructional Systems. Horizon is a home-school charter school that acts as its own local educational agency. The student qualified for special education under specific learning disability, with dyslexia and auditory and visual processing deficits. For five years she had received reading, writing, and speech-language help at home from contractor Jeannine Bird, who used the Davis Dyslexia Association method. Her January 31, 2005 IEP offered 6 hours and 50 minutes a week of resource and speech-language services at Horizon's Elk Grove site, with transportation. Horizon staff would teach reading with the Wilson Reading System. The IEP also set a goal for math fluency. The parents wanted to keep the Davis method and home services, and they asked for algebra goals instead.

The Hearing Officer found that the offer provided a FAPE. Expert Dr. Catherine Christo and supervising resource specialist Linda Frank testified that Wilson is multisensory and teaches phonics. The student's records showed she had enough phonics skill to make the switch. The district chooses the teaching method as long as the program is appropriate. Horizon's staff were qualified even without the publisher's advanced certification. The math fluency goal met a real need. Algebra is part of the regular curriculum and did not require a goal. Moving services from the home to small groups with peers was less restrictive, not more. The Hearing Officer would not interpret the parents' home-school contract. All relief was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley when parents and a district disagreed about a reading method. The district could replace a method that was working for the student with a different appropriate one. For a home-schooled student, the Hearing Officer treated services in small groups outside the home as the less restrictive setting.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Did Horizon fail to offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in her January 31, 2005 individualized education program (IEP)? (Disputes: replacing the Davis Dyslexia Association method and contract provider with the Wilson Reading System taught by Horizon staff; a math fluency goal instead of algebra goals; and moving services from the home to Horizon's Elk Grove site in small groups.)

    The offer met the student's unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Choice of the Wilson methodology was within Horizon's discretion, its staff were qualified, the math fluency goal addressed a need, and site-based small-group services were less restrictive than home instruction.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Petitioner's requests for relief were denied.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.

People named in the decision

  • Lawrence Gimbel, director of special education, Horizon Instructional Systems
  • Linda Frank, supervising resource specialist; Wilson program supervisor, Horizon Instructional Systems
  • Dorothy Sanders, resource specialist (RSP) teacher, math and proposed Wilson instructor, Horizon Instructional Systems
  • Thomas Connolly, general education teacher / education specialist (ES), Horizon Instructional Systems
  • Jeannine Bird, language, speech, and hearing specialist (contract provider using the Davis method), Total Education Services (TES)
  • Catherine Christo, Ph.D., expert witness for Horizon; education professor and licensed educational psychologist, California State University, Sacramento
  • Total Education Services (TES), nonpublic agency / outside vendor for speech and language services
  • Valley Oaks School, private assessor that performed the IEE, Turlock, California
  • Davis Dyslexia Association, private reading program provider and training center, Burlingame, California

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, on February 15, 16, 17, and 22, 2005, in Lincoln, California.

Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bob Varma. Also present on her behalf were her mother and father, MOTHER and FATHER. Respondent Horizon Instructional Systems (Horizon) was represented at the hearing by attorney Trevor Skarda. Also present on Horizon’s behalf was Lawrence Gimbel, director of special education.

Petitioner called as witnesses her mother and Jeannine Bird, language, speech, and hearing specialist. Horizon called as witnesses Linda Frank, supervising resource specialist; Dorothy Sanders, resource teacher; Catherine Christo, Ph.D, education professor; and Lawrence Gimbel.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. The parties argued their respective positions in written briefs. After receipt of the briefs, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Did Horizon fail to offer Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in her January 31, 2005 individualized education program (IEP)?

CONTENTION OF THE PARTIES

Petitioner alleges that Horizon, in the January 31, 2005 IEP, offered inappropriate changes to her educational program. Horizon proposes to provide Petitioner’s services at one of its facilities as opposed to her home where she currently attends a full-time, home-based program. Petitioner has attended a home-based program since enrolling in school. Horizon is also offering the Wilson Reading System rather than the Davis Dyslexia Association reading program that Petitioner has used for the past five years. Petitioner further contends that a specific goal for math fluency in the January 25, 2005 IEP is not necessary because she is ready for algebra goals. Petitioner is seeking to keep her services as outlined in her last agreed upon IEP with its previously designated frequency, duration, and type of reading program utilizing the Davis Dyslexia Association method in her home placement.

Horizon responds that the January 31, 2005 IEP offered Petitioner a FAPE in all respects and will provide services in the least restrictive environment (LRE). Horizon argues that the Wilson Reading System is appropriate to meet her unique needs and is necessary to meet the requirements set forth in the 2004 amendments to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) requiring that methodologies be scientifically based. The amendments go into effect in July 2005. Horizon contends that the Davis Dyslexia reading program does not meet these requirements.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT is a fourteen-year-old, eighth-grade student who resides with her parents in Elk Grove, California. She has been continuously home-schooled since kindergarten, with her mother as her primary teacher. Although MOTHER has met the qualifications to be a registered nurse, she has not served as teacher, except to her own children, and does not have a teaching credential. STUDENT’s home program is provided through Horizon, a public charter school. Horizon is chartered by the West Placer Unified School District and provides home schooling and site-based instruction to approximately 3,500 students in grades kindergarten through twelve in six Northern California counties. Horizon provides home schooling parents with various supports and guidance through credentialed teachers, or “education specialists (ES),” who meet with parents on a regular basis and are available as needed to assist with the implementation of the general education program. Under its charter and applicable law, Horizon acts as its own local education agency (LEA) with the obligation to provide special education services to eligible students. STUDENT has qualified for special education since January 2000, under the category of specific learning disability (SLD). She has been diagnosed with dyslexia and auditory and visual processing disorders.

PARENTS have home-schooled all three of their children. They requested that STUDENT repeat her home-school kindergarten program because she did not master basic letters and sounds. Her mother explained STUDENT’s retention in kindergarten stemmed from the fact that “things were not coming together.” Until STUDENT was in the third grade, during the 1999-2000 school year, MOTHER tried various approaches to teaching her how to read, using commercially available programs based on phonics. None of these were successful.

STUDENT received a general education program until the middle of the third grade when Horizon arranged for a special education assessment in December 1999. STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting was held on January 13, 2000. The IEP team determined that her deficits in auditory processing and visual processing were the underlying basis for her eligibility under the category of specific learning disability. The January 2000 IEP states that STUDENT’s assessments showed discrepancies between her cognitive ability and achievement in basic reading, written expression, math calculation, reading comprehension, oral expression, and listening comprehension. Horizon then offered STUDENT speech and language (Footnote 1) and resource specialist (RSP) services for math in addition to her general education home-school program.

At her parents’ request in March 2000, Horizon paid for STUDENT and her mother to attend a multiday training program at the Davis Dyslexia Association Center in Burlingame, California. The Davis Dyslexia program is a methodology chosen by MOTHER and designed for students who have had difficulty learning to read because of dyslexia. The Davis system employs a multisensory approach and features “symbol mastery” using clay model pictures created by the students to trigger recognition of letters and words. After the Davis training, STUDENT’s speech and language program employed this methodology. Through an outside vendor, Total Education Services (TES), Horizon retained Ms. Jeannine Bird to provide STUDENT speech and language services. Ms. Bird learned the fundamentals of the Davis Dyslexia Association system from a one-day workshop, consultation with representatives of the Davis program, and MOTHER. Ms. Bird came into the FAMILY home and incorporated the system into her teaching. After one year with the Davis program, Ms. Bird reported that STUDENT had progressed from a virtual non-reader to a fluent reader with skills in word attack and recall of letter/sound combinations. According to the assessments conducted in March 2001, STUDENT was functioning at the second-grade level in reading.

The March 13, 2001 IEP team noted that STUDENT had made “extremely good progress” in reading using the Davis system. Additionally, the IEP team increased the duration of RSP math services from sixty minutes per week to ninety minutes and offered to incorporate the Davis methodology into the RSP math program. PARENTS accepted this IEP offer. Within days after the March 2001 IEP meeting, Horizon conducted an academic assessment in mathematics to establish baseline data before STUDENT started her new program. On that assessment, STUDENT scored overall in the very low to low average range on the Woodcock-Johnson, Revised, and below the fourth grade level in all areas of the Brigance Diagnostic Inventory of Basic Skills except in writing numbers as dictated and solving money problems.

By the March 13, 2002 IEP meeting when STUDENT was in the fifth grade, she had advanced to the fourth-grade-reading level. She showed progress in her auditory comprehension and writing skills. Horizon continued to offer RSP math and speech and language services through TES’s Ms. Bird, who continued to employ the Davis method with STUDENT. STUDENT’s parents consented to this IEP.

At STUDENT’s triennial IEP meeting on February 5, 2003, Horizon again offered RSP math and speech and language with Ms. Bird using the Davis methodology. STUDENT, who was now in the sixth grade, was reading orally at the fifth-grade level with comprehension approximately between the third and fourth-grade levels. Although MOTHER declined consent to standardized assessments at that time, Ms. Bird reported to the IEP team that STUDENT was making progress in reading and written and oral expression. Ms. Bird recommended continuing the speech and language services, because she concluded that STUDENT still demonstrated a receptive/expressive language delay. PARENTS accepted this IEP offer.

In late September 2003, Horizon notified the PARENTS that the school now had a speech and language therapist on staff who would be the provider to STUDENT instead of continuing to contract with TES for Ms. Bird’s services. On October 7, 2003, Mr. and MOTHER filed a due process request with the Hearing Office expressing concern over the proposed change in personnel, particularly to individuals not trained in the Davis Dyslexia Association system. The due process request contended that the Davis methodology had been successful, and the PARENTS objected to any change without discussion or an IEP meeting. Horizon has maintained the services through Ms. Bird pending the hearing on a “stay put” basis. (Footnote 2)

The IEP team met for a noticed meeting on February 4, 2004, without parental participation, and offered special education services consistent with the last agreed-upon IEP as a stay put. At this meeting, Horizon general education teacher Mr. Thomas Connolly, who was STUDENT’s assigned ES, reported that her reading, writing, and math skills were at the fifth/sixth grade level. STUDENT was in the seventh grade at that time. Both Mr. Connolly and Horizon RSP teacher Dorothy Sanders indicated that STUDENT was “doing well.” STUDENT’s parents did not consent to this IEP.

Horizon conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT in September 2004, when she was fourteen years and three months of age. The results found that STUDENT was in the borderline average to above average range in all academic areas. The assessor at that time also found that STUDENT did not appear to be eligible for special education any longer, because no processing disorder or severe discrepancy was identified to support a finding of a specific learning disability under the applicable legal standards. The results of Horizon’s assessments were presented at the November 8, 2004 IEP meeting. Mr. and MOTHER objected to Horizon’s assessments and requested an independent education evaluation (IEE). Horizon agreed to pay for an IEE. Special education director Lawrence Gimbel testified that the unusual results in the District’s September 2004 psychoeducational assessment included some achievement scores higher than ability scores. Additionally, Horizon received the advice of California State University, Sacramento, education professor Dr. Catherine Christo, who suggested further assessments were warranted to clear up the uncertainty concerning STUDENT’s eligibility status.

On November 29, 2004, her parents arranged for a private assessment at Valley Oaks School in Turlock, California as the IEE. The Valley Oaks assessment indicated that it was performed to “pinpoint modality and integration issues in the area of learning.” This assessment found STUDENT had both visual and auditory processing difficulties and included specific program recommendations for STUDENT as a student with dyslexia.

The IEP team met again on January 10 and January 31, 2005, to consider the IEE results. Horizon reversed its November 2004 position and agreed that STUDENT was still eligible for special education services in light of the IEE, under the category of specific learning disability, Horizon offered to provide RSP math and reading, writing, speech and language services, and proposed goals and objectives. The speech and language arts component of the offer, however, was to be provided by Horizon staff, who were then implementing the newly adopted Wilson Reading System. In addition to her home-based general education program, Horizon offered more time for the RSP services than the previous offer, and located the services, not in the FAMILY home where they had been provided since STUDENT qualified for special education, but at Horizon’s Elk Grove site with transportation to and from the family residence. Although Mr. and MOTHER participated in these IEP sessions, they did not consent to the offer.

After the parties settled all other issues between them except the offer in the January 31, 2005 IEP, the Hearing in this case proceeded on February 15, 2005.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Did Horizon fail to offer Petitioner a free, appropriate public education (FAPE) in her January 31, 2005 individualized education program (IEP)?

Petitioner contends that Horizon did not offer her a FAPE in the January 25, 2005 IEP. She alleges that the offered changes in methodology and provider for her reading program, her math fluency goal, and group instruction are inappropriate for her. Horizon responds that it did offer a program that will provide STUDENT a FAPE.

There is no dispute that Horizon is responsible for providing special education services. As a public charter school, Horizon must provide for its pupils qualifying for special education “in the same manner as individuals with exceptional needs are served in other public schools.” Cal. Educ. Code § 56145. Horizon’s charter contains written assurances that it will participate as an LEA for purposes of the IDEA, pursuant to California Education Code section 47641(a). (Footnote 3) Therefore, Horizon is required to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to meet her unique needs under the provisions of the IDEA and State law. See 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. A FAPE includes special education and related services that are provided at public expense, under public supervision and direction, and without cost to the parents that meet the standards of the State educational agency, including appropriate education provided in conformity with the student’s IEP as described in 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, provided at no cost to parents that meets the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031. “Related services” include transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a student to benefit from special education as defined in the IDEA at 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22). State law provides for similar services as part of designated instruction and services (DIS) under California Education Code section 56363(a) and Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3001(z).

The United States Supreme Court in the leading decision of Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 198-208 (1982), set the standard by which Horizon’s instruction and services are measured. The Rowley decision, at 198-201, however, held that the IDEA does not require an LEA to provide to the student the best education available or to provide instruction that maximized her abilities. Rather, a special education student is entitled to have access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet her unique needs and to provide educational benefit as a “basic floor of opportunity.”

Special education law also requires that the student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), placing the student to the maximum extent appropriate with typically developing peers. 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550.

In Rowley and the federal and State statutes, discussed above, require the following analysis for substantive FAPE issues: 1. Is Horizon’s program designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs? 2. Is the program reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit? 3. Does the program as implemented conform to her IEP? 4. Additionally, does the program provide a FAPE in the least restrictive environment?

To determine if Horizon offered Petitioner a FAPE, the Hearing Officer will first identify STUDENT’s unique needs.

Student’s unique needs

There is no dispute because of dyslexia, STUDENT needs a multisensory approach to learning to address her visual and auditory processing deficits that affect her skills in reading, writing, spelling, and mathematics. As a result of her deficits, abstract words and concepts challenge her. She requires a structured program that presents information in small increments and aids her in connecting printed words with their respective sounds. STUDENT’s program needs to emphasize spelling, reading, and writing fluency and to link these areas to an understanding of written language. In mathematics, she needs an approach that will increase her speed and fluency in basic math facts to facilitate learning abstract, mathematical concepts. Horizon’s offer

Next, the Hearing Officer will determine if Horizon’s offer meets STUDENT’s needs. Horizon has offered STUDENT RSP services for mathematics, reading and writing, and speech and language services for a total of six hours and fifty minutes per week. The services consist of ninety minutes three times per week for reading, thirty minutes once a week for writing, sixty minutes once a week for mathematics, and fifty minutes once a week for speech and language designated as “individual.” All of the special education services are to be provided at Horizon’s site in Elk Grove. The offer includes transportation from STUDENT’s home, also in Elk Grove, to the Horizon site. Horizon proposes to use the recently adopted Wilson Reading System as the curriculum for reading and writing instruction.

Petitioner contends that the January 31, 2005 offer does not meet her needs. She alleges that the Davis Dyslexia Association method is required for her to continue to make progress in reading and writing. She also claims that rather than the offered goal for math fluency, she should have goals formulated in algebra.

Reading, writing, and speech and language

Horizon has offered Petitioner services for reading, writing, and speech and language at its Elk Grove facility for five hours and fifty minutes per week. Petitioner is not disputing the amount of services. (Footnote 4) She does dispute, however, the appropriateness of Horizon’s offer to replace vendor TES’s Ms. Bird, who has been instructing with the Davis Dyslexia Association system, with its own staff and Ms. Sanders implementing the Wilson Reading System. Petitioner’s parents further contend that they have the right to choose the curriculum under the terms of their contract with Horizon, which states that the PARENTS can select ninety-five percent of their home-schooled child’s “curriculum materials” with the balance selected by the assigned ES (Petitioner Exhibit E, pages 389-390). The contract, however, does not address special education. The evidence establishes that Horizon is a public charter school with IDEA and State law obligations to students with special needs. Whether Horizon offered Petitioner a FAPE is an issue within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office and a proper subject for a due process hearing under California Education Code section 56501(a). Construing the contract between the parties in this case is not. (Footnote 5) Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will not address the contract issue further.

At the start of the 2004-2005 school year, Horizon adopted the Wilson Reading System for students with reading difficulties. This adoption followed a selection process that began in the fall of 2003. Horizon then appointed a three-member committee to chose a remedial reading program. The Wilson program was one of ten recommended to Horizon by the California State Department of Education (CDE). The selection committee included supervising resource specialist Linda Frank, an RSP teacher, and a speech and language pathologist. According to Ms. Frank, the committee developed four criteria to find a program that was most suitable for use by Horizon with its predominately home-schooled student population: (1) the program does not need to be taught on each of the five days in the school week, (2) the program should have workbooks for independent use at home by the students between instructional sessions, (3) there must be adequate training available to the Horizon staff to implement the program, and (4) the program needs to be research-based. The committee also was seeking a program accepted by the CDE that was not totally scripted, as are some widely used programs, but that had suitable training available for credentialed teachers to aid in implementation.

Ms. Frank indicated that her committee picked three out of the ten recommended by the CDE, including Wilson, for further consideration. She stated that the Wilson program met the four criteria and was one of the few available “intervention programs” written specifically for adolescents or adults with dyslexia. It features a ten-part approach to develop skills in reading fluency, spelling, and comprehension. All students entering the program do not start at the same level. Each pupil is placed where appropriate in the program. Each level is “taught to mastery” before the pupil advances to the next step. Ms. Frank stated that the Wilson system is tied to the California State standards and is designed as a remedial program to be implemented in small groups or on a one-to-one basis for up to two years. She stated that some students leave the program before the end of two years and a few may remain for up to three years.

The techniques include tactile and kinesthetic drills such as “tapping” by which the student taps her finger for each sound in a word for reading and spelling. The system also employs a notebook that the student assembles for reference with lists of sounds, syllables, spelling rules, sight words, and vocabulary. To reinforce the vocabulary, students may draw pictures to enhance recall of word meanings. Ms. Frank said that the Wilson authors are trained in the widely recognized Orton-Gillingham reading method, which is known for its multisensory approach to reading. She also stated that the Wilson system’s effectiveness in reaching its target population is documented in the professional literature.

Ms. Frank described a pilot project during the summer of 2004, when Horizon got its “first look” at the Wilson program with its own students. This program was implemented with five pupils, three times a week in ninety minute sessions, for six weeks. Two of the students were in general education. The other three qualified for special education under the category of SLD. Two of the special education students Ms. Frank stated were dyslexic. All made progress as measured by standardized tests. Horizon then adopted the Wilson system as its intervention program for its reading-challenged students starting with the current school year. Wilson trainers gave instruction over a three-day period to the Horizon staff who were to implement the system. Ms. Frank is now the Wilson program supervisor at Horizon. She regularly observes the Horizon providers and students in the Wilson program and has conducted three in-service presentations during the school year. Ms. Frank reported that during her observations all of the Horizon students in the two Wilson groups were “totally engaged” during the sessions and that there was no “down time.” She stated that all of the students in the program this school year have made progress. The groups are comprised of both regular and special education students, as was the pilot group the previous summer.

The Horizon implementer who would provide Wilson reading instruction to STUDENT under the terms of the January 2005 offer is Ms. Dorothy Sanders. Ms. Sanders has been STUDENT’s RSP math teacher. Ms. Sanders has been a teacher since 1989, she holds a master’s degree in special education, and has had an extensive career working with students with learning disabilities including dyslexia. Ms. Sanders testified that she received training in the Wilson methodology and is successfully implementing the program at the present time. Both Ms. Frank and special education director Mr. Gimbel testified to their high regard for Ms. Sanders’ competence, based on her job performance at Horizon and their observations.

Ms. Frank, who has been an SDC teacher, an RSP teacher, and a dyslexia specialist for her school while teaching in Texas, stated that STUDENT would not have a problem in the transition from the Davis method to the Wilson system. Although Ms. Frank has not met or assessed STUDENT, Ms. Frank interpreted STUDENT’s low-average score on the word attack section of the Woodcock-Johnson in September 2004 (Horizon Exhibit 51) to indicate that STUDENT is capable of recognizing sound-syllable relationships sufficient to progress in reading with the Wilson system. Ms. Frank further concluded that STUDENT’s score on this subtest shows that she has acquired some phonics skills.

California State University, Sacramento professor Dr. Catherine Christo testified both to the effectiveness of the Wilson Reading Program and, from a record review, how this program would meet STUDENT’s needs. Dr. Christo’s doctorate is in education, psychological studies, and her dissertation was “The Contributions of Orthographic Representations, Phonological Processing, and Rapid Naming to Reading and Spelling.” She teaches classes in such subjects as human development and learning, assessment of special needs, and psychology in the schools. Dr. Christo also holds a California pupil personnel services credential in school psychology, is nationally certified as a school psychologist, and is a California-licensed educational psychologist. In her capacity as an educational psychologist, she conducts IEEs to determine the effectiveness of reading programs, usually on behalf of students. She has given presentations on scientific and research-based interventions for challenged readers.

Dr. Christo testified to her knowledge of dyslexia. She is a member of the International Dyslexia Association, which Dr. Christo testified is “a respected organization,” founded by Dr. Samuel Orton, who was one of the originators of the Orton-Gillingham method of teaching reading. Dr. Christo characterized dyslexia as a “phonologically based disorder” as opposed to what she said was an earlier clinical view of the disability that dyslexia was visually based or “word blindness.” She opined that dyslexic students need phonics in their reading programs. She listed five “essential components” for a reading program as promulgated by the National Reading Panel, which she said apply to a wide range of readers: (1) phonological awareness and phonological processing to develop the hearing of sounds and the ability to manipulate these sounds in language, (2) phonics taught through systematic instruction in the “sound-symbol” code, (3) reading fluency or rapid, automatic decoding of written language, (4) vocabulary development, and (5) strategies for developing comprehension. Dr. Christo found that the Wilson method includes all five components. She said that the Davis method does not address all of these components, most notably phonics, and is “much more visual.” She also stated that the Wilson system was “scientifically based” referring to the new criteria set forth in the amendments to the IDEA. (Footnote 6) The Davis method, in contrast, does not meet these criteria, according to Dr. Christo. She said that she could find no published peer review of the Davis techniques nor its acceptance by any expert, although she did review an article about the Davis method that did not include an independent test of the methodology.

MOTHER and Ms. Bird both expressed concern that a change in methodology would cause STUDENT to regress. MOTHER described how she tried several well known reading programs with STUDENT before STUDENT was qualified for special education. None of these other programs advanced STUDENT beyond the non-reader stage. According to MOTHER, before she located the Davis Dyslexia Association program, all of the programs relied upon phonics. She stated that no other program has succeeded with STUDENT because dyslexia does not allow her to see the letters or letter combinations necessary to read with a phonics approach. Petitioner argues that both Ms. Frank and Ms. Sanders are not qualified to “Level I certification” to teach the Wilson program to special education students with learning disabilities based on the publisher’s recommendations (Petitioner Exhibit E, pages 473). Petitioner also contends that the Wilson program will not meet her needs as it is “scripted,” not individualized, and she would be required to adapt to a “predetermined group of students.”

Ms. Frank, however, with her own experience with dyslexic students, convincingly pointed to STUDENT’s test scores that demonstrated phonemic awareness, at least on a basic level. Ms. Frank concluded that STUDENT can make the change to the Wilson system. It is also instructive to note the Ms. Bird’s own assessments of STUDENT’s progress, as early as the first year she started in the Davis program, suggested that STUDENT was developing an ability to deal with phonics. In Ms. Bird’s March 2001 assessment (Petitioner Exhibit B, page 107), she stated that STUDENT often used “good word attack skills on unknown words as she remembers letter/sound combinations after first spelling the word aloud.” In her March 2002 assessment (Petitioner Exhibit B, pages 114-116), Ms. Bird observed of STUDENT that “her fluency rate has increased, as her word recognition and the ability to use work attack skills with new words and words that she is able to self correct. STUDENT has mastered 212 of the 229 trigger words for her ‘dictionary.’ Trigger words are those for which there is no mental image, much like a sight word list.”

MOTHER further described STUDENT’s approach to new words is to go to the pronunciation guide in Webster’s Dictionary, which shows that STUDENT has at least some grasp of sound-letter relationships. MOTHER also related that STUDENT, who previously could only enjoy books on tape, can now read contemporary literature for youth, including the popular Harry Potter books, and has acquired a vocabulary that includes words her college-attending sister did not know. Although both MOTHER and Ms. Bird wish to retain the Davis program because it has been successful, Ms. Bird testified that she does not exclusively use Davis materials, but also uses worksheets from other sources in her instruction of STUDENT in reading and writing. In light of the above evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT has acquired a basic, functional awareness of phonics sufficient to allow her to make the transition to the Wilson method.

Regarding the qualifications of Ms. Frank and Ms. Sanders to implement the Wilson program to students with learning disabilities, the Wilson publisher does recommend that teachers go through a two-day “overview workshop” and a one-day “training lab.” The next level of training is sixty hours of on-line course work and five “implementation meetings” directed by a Wilson trainer, followed by a sixty-hour supervised practicum with Wilson teacher observations (Petitioner Exhibit E, pages 473). Ms. Frank stated that Horizon’s implementers did have the three days of training through Wilson instructors, but did not think it necessary to expend the funds for the following levels offered by Wilson. There is no legal requirement that an LEA follow all of a publisher’s recommendations before teachers are considered qualified. The record reflects that both Ms. Frank and Ms. Sanders have years of experience teaching reading to children with learning disabilities, including dyslexia, using a variety of methodologies. Horizon’s experience with the Wilson program to date, with progress reported for every student using this curriculum, shows that Horizon’s staff can implement the program successfully. Ms. Bird, the speech, language, and hearing specialist who has implemented the Davis methodology to Petitioner with good results, only attended a one-day Davis workshop and does not have the experience teaching reading to dyslexic students that Ms. Frank and Ms. Sanders have. Also, Petitioner is seeking to retain Ms. Sanders as STUDENT’s math teacher, but Ms. Sanders testified that she did not receive any formal training in the Davis method that she has used. Ms. Sanders, however, has taught reading to special needs pupils as an SDC and RSP teacher. Her experience includes middle school students diagnosed with dyslexia. She earned a master’s degree in special education and holds a California special education credential. The Hearing Officer finds that Horizon’s staff are qualified to implement the Wilson program.

Because of her disability, MOTHER stated that STUDENT requires the focus only available as the sole student receiving the services. There is no evidence, however, to support the necessity for a one-to-one configuration to meet her needs. Moreover, contrary to Petitioner’s concerns, the Wilson program was chosen because it was not “scripted” and permits trained teachers to individualize and offer one-to-one instruction if necessary.

Ms. Frank described how the Wilson program addresses STUDENT’s needs for an individualized, multisensory approach, divided into small increments, to overcome her processing difficulties that otherwise impede her ability to correlate sounds with written letters, combinations of letters, and words. A student entering the Wilson program is placed at the appropriate level after a brief, non-normed assessment. The Wilson ten-step approach systematically covers sounds and their alphabetic representations, “encoding” or spelling, and reading fluency. Color-coded keys are used to distinguish vowels, consonants, and combinations or “welded sounds.” The “tapping” technique is used to reinforce the formation of words for spelling and writing. A student notebook and magnetic board are used to keep track of what has been learned and to provide a reference that is personalized by the student who can use different modalities or even art as a means to retain the lessons learned. The record indicates that art is one of STUDENT’s interests and area of accomplishment. From the persuasive testimony of Dr. Christo and Ms. Frank, along with corroboration of Ms. Bird’s progress reports and MOTHER’s testimony, the Hearing Officer concludes that the Wilson Reading System is appropriate for STUDENT’s remedial reading, writing, spelling, and language needs. Moreover, a change in methodology is within the purview of the LEA, so long that the LEA is providing an appropriate education. Rowley, supra, at 208-209. In this case, the Hearing Officer finds the Wilson Reading System an appropriate educational program for STUDENT because it meets her unique needs.

RSP mathematics goal

An IEP must include goals related to meeting the pupil’s needs and to enable her to be involved in and progress in the general education curriculum. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(ii); Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(a). Horizon RSP teacher Dorothy Sanders has been providing mathematics instruction to STUDENT. The PARENTS have disputed the need for the proposed goal for math fluency. This functional academic goal, the only one offered in mathematics, projects that by January 2006, “When given 80 basic math facts in addition, subtraction, and multiplication, STUDENT will accurately complete 74 problems in 3 minutes on 2 of 3 trials.” MOTHER testified that she believes this goal is “worthless,” because the IEP offers accommodations for additional time on standardized tests. MOTHER stated that there was no need for this goal to prepare STUDENT ultimately for the high school exit examination because she will have additional time to complete the test. STUDENT’s parents plan on sending her to a comprehensive public high school to complete her K-12 education. MOTHER indicated that she would rather see goals for algebra to build on the progress STUDENT has made to date.

Ms. Sanders would continue to provide mathematics instruction under the current offer. Ms. Sanders testified that STUDENT needs to increase her speed in basic mathematical calculations. Ms. Sanders also indicated that STUDENT needs these basic math skills to assist her in mastering more advanced areas such as algebra. MOTHER, however, acknowledged that although STUDENT knows her basic math facts and “can do them quite well,” she “still needs more time” to do computations. As to algebra, Ms. Sanders testified that STUDENT was ready for this level of instruction and had already handled successfully some of the fundamentals in this mathematical skill. Ms. Sanders has worked with STUDENT for a number of years as her RSP mathematics teacher. The record indicates that STUDENT has progressed well and has a positive relationship with Ms. Sanders. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Sanders persuasively supports the finding that this mathematics fluency goal addresses STUDENT’s needs.

As to algebra, Ms. Sanders testified that STUDENT is ready for this level of instruction and has already mastered some of the algebra fundamentals. There is no defined special education need developed in the evidence that a goal in algebra would address, although Ms. Sanders did describe how she works with STUDENT on other basic mathematical concepts such as “numerator” and “denominator” and uses the Davis clay model method to assist in conveying the meanings to STUDENT. Moreover, an introduction to algebra is part of the California curriculum for eighth graders. A special education student is still required to follow the State curriculum. As algebra is a appropriate component of STUDENT’s curriculum and no special need has been shown in the record that an algebra goal would address, the Hearing Officer finds that no goal is necessary.

The Hearing Officer finds that the January 31, 2005 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs.

Reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit

The Horizon offer in the January 25, 2005 IEP, that included the Wilson Reading Program and the goal of math fluency targets areas where STUDENT has shown progress to date. She, however, has remained a year or more behind, as measured against her peers or her grade level. The Wilson program is specifically designed to improve the competence of a student with deficits in reading, writing and spelling within two years or less. The testimony of Ms. Frank and Dr. Christo indicated that STUDENT will be able to shift to a new program and continue to make progress. Although MOTHER believes that a phonics-based approach will not work, Dr. Christo has convincingly described how the Wilson system is designed to work with dyslexic students and that STUDENT has already acquired some skill with phonics. Ms. Frank and Ms. Sanders have attested to the success that other Horizon students, including at those with dyslexia, have enjoyed using the Wilson program. Dr. Christo specifically concluded that STUDENT would benefit from the Wilson program.

In math, the record indicates that STUDENT has progressed well and has a positive relationship with Ms. Sanders who has provided the RSP math instruction and prospectively would implement the Wilson program to STUDENT. Ms. Sanders described how STUDENT has progressed in her basic math facts through her teaching. (Footnote 7)

The Hearing Officer finds that the January 31, 2005 offer to Petitioner is reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT an educational benefit.

Conforms to the IEP

The record shows that Horizon is ready to implement STUDENT’s program as offered in the January 31, 2005 IEP. As STUDENT’s parents declined the offer, however, this element will not be discussed.

Least restrictive environment

STUDENT’s parents did not agree to the January 31, 2005 offer, in part, because it offered the special education services at Horizon’s Elk Grove site rather than in the FAMILY home where she has received all of her instruction since beginning school. Petitioner argues that the January 2005 offer is more restrictive than her prior IEPs, because the number of hours of special education services is greater and there is no offer of a general education program. Horizon contends that providing STUDENT the services at its Elk Grove facility will be in the least restrictive environment, because it will include STUDENT with peers in an academic setting for the first time.

The element of the least restrictive environment (LRE) as mandated by 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(B), requires “to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled.” State law directs special education programs to ensure that “Individuals with exceptional needs are offered special assistance programs that promote maximum interaction with the general school population in a manner which is appropriate to the needs of both.” Cal. Educ. Code §56001(g). An LRE analysis in most cases, where there is no home schooling involved, considers how much time a special needs student spends during the school week with typically developing peers in the regular education program or “mainsteaming.” The public policy of mainstreaming special education students directs the LEA, to the greatest extent appropriate, to place them in a general education setting. There is no exception in the law for home-schooled students for whom parents have opted to have the entire general education program to be in a class of one.

The LRE analysis typically involves balancing four factors: (1) the educational benefits of placement full-time in a regular class; (2) the non-academic benefits of such placement; (3) the effect the student has on the teacher and children in the regular class; and (4) the costs of mainstreaming the student. Sacramento Unified School District v. Rachel H., 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir. 1994).

STUDENT’s January 231 2005 IEP, contrary to Petitioner’s contention, offers a program that is seventy-five percent in general education with the balance designated for “Time spent in special education setting.” (Horizon Exhibit 52). In this case, however, the student’s academic general education at home is in the most restrictive environment by parental choice. The evidence suggests, however, that STUDENT is well-adjusted in the company of those at or near her own age in several different settings. MOTHER stated that she was sensitive to the criticism of some that home-schooled children are “compromised” socially. For that reason, she has encouraged STUDENT’s activities in several ways. MOTHER testified to a myriad of activities in which STUDENT successfully interacts with typically developing peers, including athletics at which she excels, art classes, and community work. MOTHER portrayed STUDENT as an outgoing, social young woman who also participated in girl scouts, activities with her friends and neighbors in her age group, and entrepreneurial endeavors.

The question raised in this proceeding, however, deals directly with Horizon’s offer of special education services prospectively, at least in part, in a small-group setting outside of the home. Although STUDENT has been in groups for many of her other activities, her academic work has heretofore been exclusively one-to-one. MOTHER has stated that she wants STUDENT to go to a comprehensive, public high school. Horizon’s Wilson groupings have included both special education and general education students. The record provides a list of the various activities STUDENT already enjoys in groups outside of her home, including classes in physical education and art, that foreshadows a successful transition to a comprehensive high school campus.

Applying the Rachel H. standards cited above, only factors (2) and (3) seem relevant in the case of this home-schooled student. The evidence suggests that STUDENT would receive non-academic benefits from the offered groups and would relate well to the general education students and, as the motivated, out-going, and well-mannered young woman described in the evidence, would have no adverse effect on a teacher or other students.

Although Petitioner contends that the increase in hours of RSP services over previous offers is more restrictive, the Hearing Officer has determined that Horizon’s offer, including the additional time allocated to special education, meets her unique needs. For STUDENT, leaving the house for any portion of her academic program would be a less restrictive environment. Additionally, despite the increase in special education services for STUDENT, there is no corresponding decrease in general education services because the home program is not subject to the traditional time limit to the school day imposed by the afternoon school bell.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds Horizon’s offer is the least restrictive environment because STUDENT will not have a reduction in general education services and will receive the additional benefit of receiving some of her services with both typically developing and special education peers rather than one-to-one.

ORDER

Petitioner’s requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON THE ISSUES HEARD

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute:

Horizon prevailed on the issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

DATED: April 22, 2005 _______________________ Tracy L. Tibbals, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Horizon also provided under RSP “speech and language,” reading, spelling, and writing. Reference to “speech and language” in this Decision will also refer to reading, spelling and writing.

2. The “stay put” requirements of 20 U.S.C. § 1415(j) and California Education Code section 56505(d) require Horizon to keep STUDENT in her last agreed upon and implemented IEP placement after the filing of the due process request until resolution of the proceedings or agreement otherwise between the parties. To date, no agreement otherwise has been reached.

3. Section XX of Horizon’s charter states, in part: “...the Charter School will participate as a Local Education Agency (LEA) in a special education local plan (SELPA) approved by the Sate Board of Education (SBA)...Horizon Instructional Systems shall have exclusive responsibility for and otherwise fully comply with the...IDEA.” (Petitioner Exhibit E, page 405).

4. In her closing written argument, Petitioner raises for the first time that the amount of time for RSP services in Horizon’s offer is an “illogical” fifty-one percent increase over her prior services. On the record, during the hearing, Petitioner expressly waived any issue with respect to the amount of services offered, the Hearing Officer will not reach this issue.

5. California Education Code section 56501(a) sets forth the Hearing Officer’s limited jurisdiction. “The parent or guardian and the public school agency involved may initiate the due process hearing procedures prescribed by this chapter under any of the following circumstances: (1) There is a proposal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child. (2) There is a refusal to initiate or change the identification, assessment, or educational placement of the child or the provision of a free, appropriate public education to the child. (3) The parent or guardian refuses to consent to an assessment of the child. (4) There is a disagreement between a parent or guardian and a district, special education local plan area, or county office regarding the availability of a program appropriate to the child, including the question of financial responsibility...”

6. The 2004 amendments to the IDEA for the first time direct that special education programs include “the use of scientifically based instructional practices, to the maximum extent possible.” 20 U.S.C. § 1400(c)(5)(E). and require IEPs to state special education services that are “based on peer-reviewed research to the extent practicable” (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(i)(IV). The Hearing Officer will not make findings on this issue, as the amendments are not in effect until July 1, 2005.

7. The record indicates that the Davis methodology was also used as part of STUDENT’s math program since March 2001. Petitioner argues that the Wilson program is deficient, because it lacks a specific mathematics component. The evidence indicates, however, that the Wilson Reading System will have a carryover benefit in all subjects, because it assists a student in understanding written material. There is no methodology specified for mathematics in the January 2005 offer. Therefore, nothing in the record indicates that Ms. Sanders would be limited in what approaches she could use to assist STUDENT to master mathematical concepts.