California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 29, 2005
Student v. San Dieguito Union High School District
SEHO Case No. SN 2119-04 · Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown
San Dieguito Union High must provide 30 tutoring hours and 49 Workability hours; Sylvan reimbursement and most claims denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Noted in the decision
None in document. Pre-hearing: Hearing Officer Marilyn Woollard issued Summary Orders on May 5, 2005, denying the District's motions to dismiss the case or limit issues; an unopposed stay put motion was granted by minute order on September 3, 2004.
Summary
A 20-year-old student filed against San Dieguito Union High School District over four school years, 2001-2002 through 2004-2005. She was eligible for special education under the category then called mental retardation. At Torrey Pines High School she attended a special day class (SDC) for academics, took general education electives, and received speech-language therapy and occupational therapy (OT). After she received a certificate of completion in June 2004, the District offered the Mira Costa College Transition Program. Her parents instead paid for tutoring at Sylvan Learning Center.
Hearing Officer Suzanne B. Brown found the District's functional sight-word reading instruction appropriate. She rejected claims that the student needed phonics, more assistive technology, more OT goals, or a longer school day. The SDC was the least restrictive environment for academics, and the Mira Costa program was appropriate for a 19-year-old. However, the IEPs lacked functional reading goals in three years. The October 2002 IEP also lacked a vocabulary goal, and the 2004 IEP had no writing goal. The District also failed to provide the weekly Workability job hours set in the May 2003 IEP. A missing adjustable chair and some shared speech sessions were minor lapses that did not deny FAPE. Because the reading services themselves were appropriate, and the parent had asked to drop the May 2002 goals, the Hearing Officer limited relief. The District must provide 30 hours of one-to-one reading and writing tutoring and 49 Workability hours by June 30, 2006. Reimbursement for Sylvan was denied.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO separated missing IEP goals from the services a student actually received. Because the reading instruction itself was appropriate, missing goals led to a modest compensatory award instead of reimbursement. It also treated the weekly work hours written into an IEP goal as a service the district had to make available, not only as a target.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue I. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year? (present levels and goals in reading, receptive language, OT; reading instruction methodology; assistive technology; length of school day; adjustable chair; LRE)
The May 2001 IEP lacked a functional sight-word reading goal, denying FAPE in that area; present levels, other goals, functional reading methodology, AT, early bus dismissal, chair, and SDC placement for academics were all appropriate.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year? (same claims plus nonconformity with IEP as to adjustable chair, Workability, and individual speech-language services)
The October 2002 IEP lacked functional reading and vocabulary goals; the missing adjustable chair (a footstool served the purpose) and shared 'individual' speech sessions were minor nonconformities that did not deny FAPE; Workability was not late; SDC was the LRE.
- Student prevailed in partImplementation
Issue III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
The May 2003 IEP goals and program were appropriate and in the LRE, but the District failed to make available the 2–5 weekly Workability job hours called for in IEP Goal #5, starting only in January 2004 at one hour per week; shared speech sessions were a minor nonconformity.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue IV. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year? (Mira Costa College Transition Program offer; goals in reading, receptive language, written language, OT; reduced speech and OT services; LRE)
The May 2004 IEP lacked sufficient functional reading goals and any written language goal; otherwise the Mira Costa transition program, reduced speech and OT services, and the placement were appropriate and in the LRE for a 19-year-old.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue V. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the years at issue, is she entitled to compensatory OT services, compensatory speech and language services, additional Workability hours, and compensatory instruction to address her reading skills?
Awarded 30 hours of one-to-one reading and writing tutoring (reduced for equitable reasons, including the parent's request to drop the May 2002 goals) and 49 compensatory Workability hours; no compensatory OT or speech services.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue VI. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to reimbursement for the cost of reading tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center?
Reimbursement denied because the compensatory awards sufficiently remedied the limited denials of FAPE.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. 30 hours of compensatory reading and writing instruction through one-to-one tutoring, to be completed no later than June 30, 2006; the District may use its own credentialed staff or outside providers but is not required to use outside providers.
- Compensatory education. 49 hours of compensatory Workability time, minus any Workability hours already provided under the District's offer at hearing of 60 additional hours, to be completed no later than June 30, 2006.
Total: 79 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; Sacramento City Unified School Dist. v. Rachel H.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; School Committee of Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education; Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education; Poolaw v. Bishop; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ.; Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Board of Education
People named in the decision
- Mary Ellen Nest, special education coordinator; District representative and witness, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Marilyn Cameron, director of education, private learning center; witness for Student, Sylvan Learning Center, Encinitas
- Dr. Kathleen Edwards, special education advocate; witness for Student
- Joy Bischke, occupational therapist, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Debra Lawler, school psychologist, San Dieguito Union High School District
- John Hooker, assistive technology specialist, San Dieguito Union High School District
- Carol Enquist, speech-language pathologist (assessed student in 2000), Rancho Santa Fe School District
- Mary Jeanette Lindebak, adult transition specialist; Transition Program teacher, Mira Costa College Transition Program
- Judy Davis, job placement assistant (Workability), San Dieguito Union High School District
- Dr. Maryjane Palmer, speech-language pathologist (student's therapist 2000–2004), San Dieguito Union High School District
- Lynn Leahy, high school cooking teacher, Torrey Pines High School
- Ana Zeladon, special day class teacher (9th–10th grade), Torrey Pines High School
- Rachel Page, special day class teacher (11th–12th grade), Torrey Pines High School
- Dr. Lynn Gregory, psychoeducational evaluator (1997), Children's Hospital and Health Center
- Perspectives Therapy, private occupational therapy provider (February 2000 OT report)
- Sylvan Learning Center, private tutoring provider (parent placement), Encinitas
- Matthew Basham, general manager of Workability job site, Stumps Market
- Marilyn Woollard, SEHO Hearing Officer (pre-hearing rulings), Special Education Hearing Office
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened for hearing in Encinitas, California, on May 10-13, 17 and 24, 2005, before Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law.
Petitioner STUDENT (Petitioner or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Thomas Nelson. Present on behalf of STUDENT were her mother, MOTHER and, on several hearing days, her father, FATHER. Respondent San Dieguito Union High School District (District) was represented by attorney Peter Sansom. Present on behalf of the District was special education coordinator Mary Ellen Nest.
Petitioner called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: FATHER, STUDENT’s father; Marilyn Cameron, director of education at Sylvan Learning Center in Encinitas; Dr. Kathleen Edwards, special education advocate; and MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother.
The District called the following witnesses to testify at the hearing: Joy Bischke, occupational therapist; Debra Lawler, school psychologist; John Hooker, assistive technology (AT) specialist; Carol Enquist, speech-language pathologist; Mary Jeanette Lindebak, adult transition specialist; Judy Davis, job placement assistant; Dr. Maryjane Palmer, speech-language pathologist; Lynn Leahy, high school teacher; and Mary Ellen Nest, coordinator of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for submission of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the written briefs on June 14, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
This matter previously convened for hearing on April 12, 2005, before Hearing Officer Marilyn Woollard. On that date, the hearing participants clarified Petitioner’s issues. The District moved to dismiss any of Petitioner’s issues prior to May 12, 2003, on the ground that her prior due process case, SN02-00621, was dismissed by the Hearing Office for lack of activity. The hearing officer set a response deadline for the Student to file an opposition to this motion, and also granted a motion by the District to continue the hearing.
On April 15, 2005, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s written notice of three additional issues that Petitioner had failed to raise previously. In a Memorandum Of Issues And Case Status, dated April 20, 2005, Hearing Officer Woollard recounted Petitioner’s issues identified at the April 12 hearing, and also noted the continuance ruling and the District’s motion to dismiss issues prior to May 12, 2003. Also on April 20, the Hearing Office received from the District its written motions to dismiss the case or, in the alternative, to limit issues. In that written filing, the District argued additional grounds that were not raised at the April 12 hearing, such as the parents’ lack of standing to raise issues after Petitioner turned eighteen years old. Subsequently, Petitioner submitted an opposition to the District’s motions and a request that the three issues filed with the Hearing Office on April 15 be included in the Memorandum of Issues for hearing.
On May 5, 2005, Hearing Officer Woollard issued a ruling entitled Summary Orders Denying Motions To Dismiss Case And To Dismiss Or Limit Issues. In that document, the hearing officer denied the District’s motions to dismiss Student’s issues. The Summary Orders stated that Petitioner would be permitted to raise the three additional issues submitted in writing following the April 12 hearing date, but held that “no further additions to the issues will be permitted.” Regarding the motion to dismiss or limit issues due to lack of standing by the parents after STUDENT turned eighteen, the Summary Order held that “any issue regarding whether STUDENT transferred her educational rights to her mother for the time period between July 5, 2003, when she turned eighteen years old, and October 29, 2004, when conservatorship was granted to MOTHER, is a question of fact for the hearing.” Subsequently, at the hearing and in its written closing brief, the District did not present any further argument or evidence regarding the parents’ alleged lack of standing from July 5, 2003, until October 29, 2004; in light of all circumstances, this Decision will not reconsider dismissal on that basis and will allow consideration of Petitioner’s claims during that time period.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
I. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
IV. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
V. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the years at issue, is she entitled to compensatory occupational therapy services to address her fine and gross motor skills, compensatory speech and language services to address her receptive language skills, additional Workability hours, and compensatory instruction to address her reading skills?
VI. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to reimbursement for the cost of reading tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center?
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT, born BIRTH DATE, is a twenty-year-old student who lives with her family within the boundaries of the District. She has four siblings, three of whom are older and one who is younger. STUDENT has been found eligible for special education under the category of mental retardation. She has not attended a District placement since she completed her senior year at the District’s Torrey Pines High School in June 2004. Since that time, she has been receiving instruction at her parents’ expense at the Sylvan Learning Center in Encinitas, California.
STUDENT was born with multiple congenital anomalies due to an extremely rare condition involving partial deletion of two chromosomes. She has had multiple surgeries to address some physical problems stemming from her condition, including hip dislocation and clubbed feet.
As an infant, STUDENT received early intervention educational services and therapy through the local regional center. She began speech therapy at age two and a half and began preschool at age three. When she turned three years old, the elementary school district in which she resided, Rancho Santa Fe School District (RSFSD), found her eligible for special education. During her early elementary school years, as a resident of RSFSD she attended a regional special day class (SDC) in the Encinitas School District, with an instructional aide and other support provided by RSFSD. STUDENT and the other SDC students were fully included with general education students. STUDENT also received designated instruction and services (DIS) of speech-language therapy and adaptive physical education (APE). Beginning in fourth grade, resource specialist program (RSP) services were added to her educational program for thirty minutes per day.
Beginning in fifth grade, STUDENT switched schools and began attending the Rancho Santa Fe Elementary School within RSFSD. She attended a general education grade class with an instructional aide for much of her school day, and also received RSP services, APE, and speech-language therapy. She continued with a similar program for sixth grade, with an individualized education program (IEP) document indicating that she spent half of her school day integrated with typically developing peers and the other half in special education. (Pet. Exh. p. 199.)
For seventh and eighth grades, STUDENT attended RSFSD’s Rancho Santa Fe Middle School, where her daily schedule involved attending a different class each class period. STUDENT’s middle school schedule included music, computers, art, writing, Spanish, APE, speech-language, life skills, RSP math and RSP language arts. (Id.; Pet. Exh. pgs. 237-239, 298.) She also had an instructional aide for part of the school day. For both seventh and eighth grades, her IEP documents indicated that she was integrated with typically developing peers for 35 percent of her school day and spent the remaining 65 percent in special education. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 225, 268.)
Because RSFSD is an elementary school district that provides instruction through eighth grade, STUDENT became a student of the San Dieguito Union High School District (District) beginning in ninth grade. She attended the District’s Torrey Pines High School (TPHS) for all four years of high school, from September 2000 to June 2004.
During the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT was in ninth grade and attended general education classes such as dance and acting. For academic subjects such as math and English, STUDENT attended an SDC taught by Ana Zeladon. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 307, 321.) STUDENT also received DIS of speech-language therapy, APE, occupational therapy (OT), and extended school year (ESY). (Pet. Exh. p. 307.) Her IEP indicated that she spent 66 percent of her time in special education, with the remaining 34 percent mainstreamed with typically developing peers.
On May 25 and June 4, 2001, the IEP team convened to develop STUDENT’s IEP for the 2001-2002 school year. Later in June 2001, FATHER and MOTHER filed a compliance complaint with the California Department of Education (CDE) against the District. On September 5, 2001, CDE’s compliance investigation determined that the District was out of compliance regarding some obligations, such as convening an IEP meeting within the legally mandated time line, and providing speech therapy in conformity with the IEP. (Dist. Exh. 66.) On September 21, 2001, STUDENT’s IEP team developed and agreed upon an individualized transition plan (ITP). The IEP team convened several other times during the 2001-2002 school year to discuss her progress and aspects of her educational program. (Footnote 2)
For the 2001-2002 school year, when she was in tenth grade, STUDENT took general education classes in dance, cooking, theater and band. (Footnote 3) The May 2001 IEP indicated that altogether she spent 31 percent of her school day in special education, with the remaining 69 percent integrated with general education peers. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 351, 517.) For the special education component of her day, she attended Ms. Zeladon’s SDC for math, English, and functional skills, and also received DIS of speech-language therapy and OT.
On May 14, 2002, the IEP team met to develop the IEP for the 2002-2003 school year, which was STUDENT’s eleventh grade year. The District notified STUDENT’s parents about the IEP meeting, but MOTHER informed District staff that she would not attend. (Pet. Exh. p. 573; testimony of MOTHER, Mary Ellen Nest.) The IEP team convened without either of STUDENT’s parents present. The District offered a program with DIS of OT, speech-language and ESY, general education classes of band, dance, and acting, and special education classes of English, math and vocational skills taught in the SDC. (Dist. Exh. 7.) The IEP also included a proposed ITP, which provided for transition services such as learning a functional skills curriculum and working at a job through the “Workability” program. The District sent a copy of the proposed IEP to STUDENT’s parents for their review, but the PARENTS did not return a signed copy and, therefore, the IEP was not implemented at that time. (Pet. Exh. p. 580.)
For the 2002 ESY, STUDENT attended summer school taught by a new SDC teacher, Rachel Page, who became STUDENT’s SDC teacher for the 2002-2003 school year. On October 17, 2002, the IEP team convened with STUDENT’s mother in attendance. The IEP notes indicated that “parent disagrees with goals & objectives from May 14, 2002, Student was not represented at that meeting.” (Dist. Exh. 6.) The team agreed upon a few changes to the goals and objectives, but otherwise agreed upon an educational program very similar to the one offered at the IEP meeting on May 14, 2002. MOTHER signed her consent to the IEP at the meeting on October 17, 2002. (Dist. Exh. 5, p. 12.)
During eleventh grade, STUDENT’s educational program continued to be a mixture of general education classes, SDC classes and DIS. Also during this school year, STUDENT began working at Stumps Market, a grocery store in Rancho Santa Fe, California, as part of the Workability program operated through State grants. (Dist. Exh. 90; testimony of Judy Davis.)
On May 14, 2003, the IEP team convened again to develop STUDENT’s educational program for twelfth grade, which was the 2003-2004 school year. STUDENT’s parents could not attend, but MOTHER agreed that the IEP team members should convene in her absence and then send the documents to the PARENTS for review and signature. The IEP document identified a program wherein STUDENT spent approximately half of her time in general education and half in special education. The proposed general education classes were band, acting and dance. (Pet. Exh. p. 604.) The special education time consisted of OT, individual and group speech-language therapy, and SDC classes for math, English and vocational skills. (Pet. Exh. p. 601-604.) The IEP also included ESY. The ITP again provided for transition services such as learning a functional skills curriculum and working at a job through the Workability program. MOTHER signed her consent to this IEP on May 16, 2003, and it was subsequently implemented for the 2003 ESY and the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s senior year of high school. Rachel Page remained STUDENT’s SDC teacher for that school year.
On April 12, 2004, STUDENT’s IEP team met to address concerns raised by STUDENT’s mother. Among the topics the participants discussed during the meeting were consistency of aide support and implementation of the Workability program. STUDENT’s mother requested “that a high school option be explored at the next annual review.” (Pet. Exh. p. 651.)
On May 14, 2004, the IEP team convened for STUDENT’s annual review. The District members of the IEP team proposed a placement in the Transition Program at Mira Costa College, a local community college. The proposed program included DIS of OT and speech-language therapy, which STUDENT would receive at the school site, and transportation. The IEP document indicated that STUDENT would spend all of her school day in special education. (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 1.) MOTHER did not agree to the District’s offer.
The IEP team convened again on June 9, 2004. The District again offered the Mira Costa Transition Program, including placement there for the 2004 ESY to facilitate STUDENT’s transition to the program for the following school year. The IEP notes indicated that the Mira Costa program would “focus on community skills, vocational skills, recreational skills and functional academics.” (Pet. Exh. p. 758.) MOTHER did not agree to the District’s offer and instead requested placement at a new District high school, Canyon Crest Academy. District members of the IEP team stated that the school would not have age-appropriate peers for STUDENT because Canyon Crest Academy would be a brand-new high school and ninth-graders would compose the entire student population for the 2004-2005 school year.
At the end of her senior year of high school, STUDENT participated in TPHS graduation activities and received a certificate of completion. Thereafter she did not attend ESY within the District. On June 13, 2004, MOTHER sent a letter to the District stating that she was enrolling STUDENT at the Sylvan Learning Center at a cost of $43 per hour.
On August 23, 2004, the Hearing Office received on behalf of STUDENT a request for due process and motion for stay put. The District did not oppose the stay put motion. On September 3, 2004, the Hearing Office issued a minute order granting the unopposed motion to maintain STUDENT’s placement at TPHS pursuant to her last agreed-upon and implemented IEP dated May 14, 2003. MOTHER and District staff disagreed regarding implementation of the stay put placement, and as a result MOTHER did not send STUDENT back to TPHS. (Dist. Exhs. 39, 40.) STUDENT continued to receive instruction at Sylvan Learning Center and did not return to school within the District during the 2004-2005 school year. After a continuance, the case proceeded to hearing on May 10, 2005.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
I. Did the District deny Petitioner a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in the least restrictive environment (LRE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) Federal and State law mandates that all children with disabilities have available to them a FAPE that includes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000.) FAPE is defined as special education and related services that meet state standards, include an appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and that are provided at public expense and in conformity with an IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other services that may be required to allow a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(17).) California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”
Under the IDEA and the U.S. Supreme Court’s Rowley decision, an appropriate educational program must be designed to address the student’s unique needs, be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and be in conformity with his or her IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200.) The Rowley opinion explained that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education instruction or services, or that those services maximize a student’s potential. The Court stated that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 200.) As long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208.) Moreover, to determine whether a school district has offered a student a FAPE, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of the district’s proposed program. (Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).)
An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. (Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994).) Moreover, the actions of the school system cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight...an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999) (citing Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993).) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ., 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).) However, de minimis benefit or only trivial advancement is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).) Additionally, in a due process hearing the District has the burden of persuasion to prove that it complied with the IDEA. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District, No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994).)
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of the student’s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031.) The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming” or education in the LRE. The law demonstrates “a strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” (Daniel R.R. v. State Board of Education (5th Cir.1989) 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45; see also Sacramento City Unified School Dist., Bd. of Educ. v. Rachel H., (9th Cir. 1994) 14 F.3d 1398, 1404 (9th Cir.1994), cert. denied, 114 S.Ct. 2679 (1994).)
To summarize, the IDEA and the Supreme Court’s decision in Rowley require that an appropriate program must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs, must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with educational benefit, and must conform to the student’s IEP. Additionally, the program must be provided in the LRE. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. at 188; Capistrano Unified Sch. Dist. v. Wartenberg, 59 F.3d 884, 893 (9th Cir.1995).)
A. Designed To Meet Unique Needs And Reasonably Calculated To Provide Educational Benefit
To determine whether the District’s offer for the 2001-2002 school year was appropriate for STUDENT, this Decision must first identify what her needs were at that time. There is no dispute that STUDENT had moderate mental retardation, with deficits in areas including academics, memory, auditory comprehension skills, speech, language and communication. Both STUDENT’s cognitive and academic levels were relatively low. Regarding cognitive functioning, a June 1997 psycho-educational evaluation by Dr. Lynn Gregory of Children’s Hospital and Health Center found that STUDENT received a composite score of 49 on the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scale, Fourth Edition. (Dist. Exh. 35.) Upon reassessment by RSFSD in May 2000, STUDENT scored a 6.3 age equivalent on the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence-Third Edition (TONI-3), compared with her then-chronological age of approximately fourteen years, ten months. (Pet. Exh. p. 309; Dist. Exh. 28, p. 2.) Regarding academic achievement, in testing by RSFSD in May 2000, STUDENT scored at a kindergarten level on the Brigance Comprehensive Inventory of Basic Skills (Brigance). (Dist. Exh. 33.) Also in May 2000, RSFSD speech-language pathologist Carol Enquist found that STUDENT scored at the 3.2 year old level on the CELF-Preschool, which tested expressive and receptive language skills. In the same assessment, STUDENT scored at the 4.2 year old level on the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test-Third Edition (PPVT-III), which tested receptive vocabulary skills. (Dist. Exh. 32; testimony of Ms. Enquist.)
STUDENT had speech and language deficits in areas including receptive language, expressive language, articulation, and intelligibility. In the area related to occupational therapy, STUDENT’s weaknesses included gross and fine motor skills and self-help/adaptive skills. STUDENT was very friendly and outgoing; social skills were an area of relative strength for her, although she had some needs in pragmatic areas such as turn-taking in conversations. She enjoyed socializing, using a computer, and participating in creative activities such as dance, art, and music. STUDENT was very well-behaved and tried to comply with directions, although she would “shut down”and not attempt a task if she felt it was too difficult.
STUDENT also had specific needs in the area of reading. While a March 1999 progress report from STUDENT’s seventh grade teachers identified eleven simple sight words that STUDENT could identify within text and on flash cards, reports from 2001 do not reflect an ability to read those sight words. (See Pet. Exh. p. 264.) In a May 2000 assessment, STUDENT’s scores on the Brigance indicated a kindergarten level for reading lowercase letters and printing letters, and a first-grade level for reading uppercase letters. (Pet. Exh. p. 295.) Those Brigance scores also indicated STUDENT could not recite the alphabet or visually discriminate among four words. (Id.) In an April 2001 progress report, STUDENT’s SDC teacher reported in part that STUDENT could identify survival signs, could write her city and phone number from memory, and was “starting to work on lower case letters.” (Pet. Exh. p. 346.) The “Present Levels Of Performance” section of the May 2001 IEP indicated in part that STUDENT read survival signs and picture symbols, was able to copy written information, and “looks at teen fashion magazines and responds appropriately to pictures.” (Pet. Exh. p. 357.) That IEP document’s baseline for her reading/writing goal stated that she “does not write sentences/reads some.” (Pet. Exh. p. 358.) Thus, there is no dispute that STUDENT had severe difficulties in reading and needed intensive services in this area.
There is also no dispute that STUDENT’s reading needs were intertwined with her vocational needs, her upcoming post-graduation transition out of public school, and her need to learn to function safely in the community. Several witnesses described how STUDENT needed to be able to read functional words in the community, so that she could read signs, schedules, and words related to daily living. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Enquist, Ms. Lawler, FATHER, MOTHER.) A February 2001 progress report and the May 2001 IEP’s present levels of performance both stated that STUDENT could identify many survival signs, but other evidence indicated additional safety areas that STUDENT had not yet learned. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 341, 357.) MOTHER testified that STUDENT needed to learn about safe behavior in the community, and gave as an example that STUDENT has difficulty crossing the street because she walks too slowly to cross before the traffic light changes. These concerns are consistent with the information MOTHER and SDC teacher Ana Zeladon provided in the Vineland questionnaire they each filled out in February 2002. Those Vineland results indicated that STUDENT did not understand that she should not accept rides from strangers and that she probably did not look both ways before crossing the street. (Dist. Exhs. 29, 30.) Consequently, STUDENT needed to learn to read functional words in the community and needed to learn about safe behavior in the community.
In summary, STUDENT had needs in areas including speech and articulation, expressive and receptive language, gross and fine motor skills, self-help/adaptive skills, functional reading, and functional skills in the community. To address STUDENT’s needs for the 2001-2002 school year, the District offered placement in an SDC for instruction in math, English and functional skills, and attendance in general education for the lunch period and dance, cooking, acting and band classes, accompanied by an instructional assistant. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 351, 517.) Furthermore, STUDENT’s IEP offered DIS of one hour per month of occupational therapy, four thirty-minute sessions per week of individual speech-language therapy, and one hour per week of group speech-language therapy. Her program also included transportation, ESY and accommodations such as a journal for communication between the school staff and STUDENT’s parents.
Petitioner argued that several aspects of this program offered by the District for the 2001-2002 school year were not designed to meet her unique needs and were not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Petitioner asserted that the IEP’s present levels of performance in reading were inaccurate and the IEP goals in the areas of reading were insufficient. Petitioner also disputed the IEP goals in the areas of receptive language and OT, and contended that the District’s offered program failed to address her needs in the areas of reading and the length of her school day. Regarding reading, Petitioner contended both that the District’s program methodology did not address her needs and that the District should have used assistive technology to track her reading progress. Accordingly, this Decision will examine the IEP components and program areas in dispute.
(1) IEP Goals and Present Levels of Performance (a) Present Levels of Performance in Reading
Petitioner argued that the present levels of performance in the May 2001 IEP were inaccurate because they did not specify whether she could read any sight words. An IEP shall include a statement of the present levels of the pupil’s educational performance. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56435(a).) The key purpose of inclusion of the student’s present levels of performance is so that the IEP team can develop appropriate goals and objectives and an appropriate educational program. The May 2001 IEP contains detailed information about STUDENT’s levels of performance in many areas, but did not indicate whether she could read any sight words. However, other evidence suggested that, around the time that IEP was drafted, STUDENT could not read sight words. A March 2002 District assessment that found that STUDENT could read the letter/word “a” but could not identify the remaining words on a preprimer-level word list. (Pet. Exh. p. 525.) In her testimony, Dr. Palmer indicated that these results were consistent with her knowledge of STUDENT’s functioning around that time. Other documentary records from that time, such as the May 2000 assessment results, were consistent with those levels. (See, e.g., Dist. Exhs. 32, 33; Pet. Exh. p. 346.)
Petitioner argued that the IEP’s present levels were nevertheless inaccurate because earlier documents indicated that STUDENT could read some sight words. STUDENT’s June 1998 IEP indicated that she could read the following functional sight words: go, stop, hot, on, off, mom, dad, enter, exit, do not enter, push, pull, stop, and emergency. (Pet. Exh. p. 235.) A March 1999 progress report from STUDENT’s seventh grade teachers identified eleven simple sight words, mostly different from those on the June 1998 list that STUDENT could identify within text and on flash cards. (Pet. Exh. p. 264.) Similarly, MOTHER testified that STUDENT could read more words in middle school than when she was in high school. MOTHER also noted this concern about regression when filling out a Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales questionnaire for a District assessment in March 2002. (Dist. Exh. p. 2.)
While this evidence potentially suggests that STUDENT’s ability to read sight words may have regressed from June 1998 to May 2001, the fact that STUDENT was not reading sight words in May 2001 thus establishes that the disputed portion of the IEP’s present levels was accurate. Because the time period prior to the 2001-2002 school year is not at issue here, this Decision will not address whether any regression occurred that constituted a denial of FAPE prior to the time period at issue.
Accordingly, because the available information indicated that STUDENT could not read sight words in May 2001, the absence of such information in the IEP’s present levels did not render those present levels inaccurate. Moreover, Dr. Palmer testified that the May 2001 IEP contained enough information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance for the IEP team to draft goals and design STUDENT’s educational program.
Thus, the May 2001 IEP’s present levels of performance in reading were accurate and contained sufficient information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and an appropriate program for STUDENT.
(b) Reading Goals
Petitioner claimed that the May 2001 IEP’s goals were insufficient because there were areas of need in reading that the goals failed to address. The May 2001 IEP identified a reading/writing goal that STUDENT would “develop the ability to communicate using written language by writing 3 sentences about personal experiences using a picture symbol word processing program 3/4 trials for 3 consecutive trial periods as measured by teacher data sheet & work samples.” (Pet. Exh. p. 358; Dist. Exh. 16, p. 8.) The May 2001 IEP also had an expressive language goal with a short-term objective of learning and using safety, environmental, school, community and concept words, although Petitioner argued that the characterization of this objective as part of an “expressive language” goal indicated that STUDENT would be learning to express these words, not learning to read them. Additionally, the September 27, 2001 ITP listed a goal of using a picture schedule for transitions, such as between her classes. (Dist. Exh. 13.) Dr. Palmer explained that this goal was related to post-transition reading needs, because STUDENT needed to learn how to read schedules such as a daily schedule or a bus schedule. (Dist. Exh. 13.)
Thus, the question is whether the reading/writing goal, the vocabulary objective in the expressive language goal, and the picture schedule goal in the ITP were sufficient to address STUDENT’s reading needs. There is no dispute that STUDENT needed to be able to read functional words in the community so that she could read signs and participate in post-graduation activities such as employment. Yet none of these goals were designed to measure STUDENT’s progress on reading functional words in the community, despite the testimony of District witnesses that STUDENT needed a program for functional sight words. To the extent that the IEP did not have a functional sight word reading goal, the program for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. (c) Receptive Language Goals
Petitioner contended that the District failed to provide receptive language goals in oral comprehension, memory, recalling information, and vocabulary. The May 2001 IEP contained three speech-language goals, one of which was a pragmatics goal to increase receptive and expressive social communication. One of that goal’s objectives addressed oral comprehension by teaching STUDENT to ask questions, such as “what’s that?” Another speech-language goal in expressive vocabulary addressed vocabulary development, by stating that STUDENT would continue to learn and use words related to safety, school, community, concepts and her environment. (Dist. Exh. 16, p. 11.) Dr. Palmer explained that these goals and objectives addressed STUDENT’s receptive language needs related to oral comprehension and vocabulary; while the vocabulary objective was technically part of an expressive language goal, learning the words expressively also improved her receptive vocabulary. As a trained and experienced speech-language pathologist who had assessed STUDENT and worked with her for four years, Dr. Palmer was a knowledgeable, credible witness who gave persuasive testimony on this topic. There was also no evidence contrary to Dr. Palmer’s testimony on this topic. Accordingly, the receptive language goals addressed oral comprehension and vocabulary, and there was no evidence that STUDENT needed additional goals in these areas.
Regarding memory and recalling information, Dr. Palmer testified that many of STUDENT’s goals already addressed memory and recalling information, in that STUDENT needed to learn and remember the particular information or skill she was learning, such as how much the coins are worth when counting money. Moreover, Dr. Palmer explained that additional receptive language goals to address these areas would not necessarily be appropriate for STUDENT because memory is based on cognitive ability. Dr. Palmer explained that although educators can develop strategies to improve memory, like visualization and verbalization, such strategies require abstract thought, which STUDENT generally could not do. Therefore, STUDENT did not require these strategies and, instead, it was more effective to focus on areasrelated to concrete thinking, which STUDENT was more capable of doing.
Hence, the evidence established that STUDENT did not need receptive goals specifically addressing memory or recalling information. The evidence further established that the May 2001 IEP’s oral comprehension and vocabulary goals were designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. Therefore, she did not need additional receptive language goals.
(d) OT Goals: Balance and Community Safety
Petitioner contended that she needed OT goals and services to address needs in balance and community safety. Regarding balance, Petitioner points to a February 2000 OT report by Perspectives Therapy, which noted STUDENT had difficulties balancing on one leg and performing balance activities in APE, and stated that these difficulties may be attributed to her small-sized feet. (Pet. Exh. p. 288.) FATHER testified that STUDENT has always had trouble with balance and tends to fall, such that she had developed a fear of falling. MOTHER gave a similar account, stating that STUDENT tends to get hurt when she falls. MOTHER described how STUDENT once lost her balance and fell during summer school at another District school, La Costa Canyon Academy, and as a result the summer school teacher agreed that STUDENT could use a wheelchair for the rest of the summer. However, MOTHER acknowledged that falling was not generally a problem for STUDENT at TPHS because all of her classes were located near one another. MOTHER testified that over the course of four years at TPHS, STUDENT fell only once, resulting in a skinned knee.
District occupational therapist Joy Bischke testified that she did not include balance among STUDENT’s OT goals because it was not among her OT needs. Ms. Bischke stated that, while STUDENT had some weaknesses with balance and coordination, she could get around the campus without problem and therefore did not need OT goals regarding balance. (Footnote 4) Ms. Bischke described how STUDENT walked much like any other child, except at a slower pace. Ms. Bischke had frequently observed STUDENT walking at school, both during Ms. Bischke’s visits to TPHS and when Ms. Bischke taught STUDENT’s SDC in summer 2001. Ms. Bischke also noted that no school staff or other IEP team members had ever raised concerns about STUDENT’s balance. Ms. Bischke explained that in the Vineland Adaptive Behavior Scales administered in February 2002, both the SDC teacher and MOTHER reported that STUDENT could walk up and down stairs. (Dist. Exhs. 29, 30.) While MOTHER reported in the questionnaire that STUDENT could not hop up and down on one foot, Ms. Bischke explained that STUDENT did not need to hop up and down on one foot to be successful in school, at work or in the community.
While FATHER and MOTHER both gave credible testimony on this topic, the evidence that STUDENT has had trouble with balance did not establish that STUDENT needed OT goals in balance for the 2001-2002 school year. Indeed, Petitioner did not offer any evidence contrary to Ms. Bischke’s testimony. In her closing brief, Petitioner pointed to some previous IEPs that included goals for balance and coordination. (See, e.g., Pet. Exh. pgs. 277, 288, 309, 319.) However, as Ms. Bischke noted during the hearing, those goals all concerned STUDENT’s participation in adaptive physical education (APE), not OT. STUDENT did not receive APE for the 2001-2002 school year because her IEP team agreed that she could participate in physical activity with a general education dance class instead of APE. (Footnote 5)
Ms. Bischke’s unrefuted testimony was persuasive for several reasons, including her knowledge of STUDENT’s OT needs, and her background and expertise as a licensed occupational therapist. As described above, the evidence concerning STUDENT’s balance established that STUDENT did not need OT goals or services to address her balance issues. While STUDENT’s parents were credible in their testimony that STUDENT generally has had trouble with balance, the evidence also established that STUDENT did not need OT goals or services in balance in order to access the school campus and therefore did not need OT goals in balance to benefit educationally from her instructional program.
Next, Petitioner argued that she required OT goals and services to address her needs in community safety. This Decision has already found that STUDENT needed to learn about community safety. However, Ms. Bischke explained that community safety is not an area specifically addressed by OT. (Footnote 6) The District pointed out that the May 2001 IEP contained a speech-language goal to learn and use “safety/environmental/school/community and 1-2 concept words each month,” while the September 2001 ITP listed “community experiences” as among STUDENT’s needed transition services. (Dist. Exhs. 13, 15.) Moreover, Ms. Bischke testified that she had observed STUDENT’s SDC teacher teach community safety topics to the SDC students, both as part of classroom instruction and on community outings. Topics such as how to cross the street, understanding and observing safety signs, and walking to the store were all part of the SDC curriculum. (Footnote 7)
Thus, STUDENT’s IEP and ITP addressed community safety needs outside of OT. While STUDENT needed to learn community safety skills like how to cross the street, Ms. Bischke’s unrefuted testimony established that community safety is typically not part of OT and the District’s offer addressed STUDENT’s need for community safety instruction in other aspects of her program. (Footnote 8)
(e) OT Goals: Functional Fine Motor Skills
Petitioner contended that the May 2001 IEP goals and program for the 2001-2002 school year failed to address her unique needs in functional fine motor skills. There was no dispute that functional fine motor skills were an area of need for STUDENT. The February 2000 OT assessment reported that STUDENT had delays in fine motor skills and “may benefit from participation in fine motor skills to improve her functional abilities in the classroom with handwriting skills.” (Pet. Exh. p. 288.) The May 2001 IEP’s present levels of performance indicated that STUDENT could write, could cut soft foods with a knife, and could perform some self-help activities that involved functional fine motor skills, such as brushing her teeth and hair. (Pet. Exh. p. 357.)
Petitioner argued that the District’s program did not address her unique needs in this area because the May 2001 IEP did not have any goals concerning functional fine motor skills. (Footnote 9) Ms. Bischke, a licensed occupational therapist, explained that there was no need for functional fine motor goals at that time because STUDENT could already do many functional fine motor activities on her own and because her educational program already involved working on these skills in the SDC and in cooking class. Ms. Bischke testified regarding her observations of STUDENT performing functional fine motor activities in classes, such as writing, using a knife and fork, and using a computer mouse in the SDC. Both Ms. Bischke and Lynn Leahy, STUDENT’s cooking teacher, testified regarding how STUDENT worked on functional fine motor activities during cooking class, such as stirring, using kitchen utensils, opening and closing containers, and cleaning up.
Ms. Bischke was a knowledgeable, credible witness who was familiar with STUDENT’s fine motor needs in the 2001-2002 school year. She had observed STUDENT in the SDC and cooking class, provided STUDENT’s OT services from September 2001 to June 2004, and taught STUDENT’s SDC in summer 2001. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary regarding the need for functional fine motor goals. Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT’s functional fine motor needs were being addressed within the District’s program in the 2001-2002 school year, and STUDENT did not require a specific goal in this area.
*********
This Decision has found that the May 2001 IEP lacked sufficient goals in reading, which constituted a failure to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading. Because reading was a key area of need for STUDENT, the absence of sufficient reading goals constituted a denial of FAPE in that area for the 2001-2002 school year. However, the May 2001 IEP’s present levels of performance in reading were accurate and enabled the IEP team to draft an appropriate program for STUDENT. Moreover, the May 2001 IEP goals were appropriate for STUDENT in the areas of receptive language, balance, community safety and functional fine motor skills.
(2) Program Offer
Petitioner contended that the District’s program failed to address her needs regarding her reading instruction, assistive technology in reading, and the length of her school day.
(a) Reading Instruction
During the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT worked on reading in the SDC and also during her speech-language therapy sessions. (Footnote 10) In both SDC English instruction and speech-language therapy, STUDENT worked on her reading in part by using computer software programs, such as Rosetta Stone, Writing With Symbols, Simon Sounds It Out, and Earobics. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer; see, e.g., Dist. Exh. 77; Pet. Exh. pgs. 412, 1431, 1439, 1479.) STUDENT worked on her reading by using News-2-You, a publication that contained simple summaries of news stories accompanied by picture symbols for most of the words, followed by activities such as comprehension questions. (Dist. Exh. 78.) STUDENT’s reading program also included daily reading of personalized lunch menus that featured words paired with picture symbols of food items, cooking class worksheets that similarly featured words paired with symbols, and flash cards similarly featuring words paired with visual prompts to teach functional and community words and signs. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer; see, e.g., Pet. Exh. pgs. 1419-1420, 1425-1426, 1551, 1567.)
Petitioner contended that the District’s reading program was inappropriate because it lacked “constant reinforcement and instruction in reading fundamentals, including in the areas of sight words, phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension, spelling, and memory issues.” Additionally, Petitioner contended the program failed to “address STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation.” However, there is no dispute that STUDENT needed a reading program in anticipation of her post-graduation transition out of public school into supported employment and independent living. In essence, all of STUDENT’s reading needs were related to her post-graduation transition to supported employment and independent living. Hence, Petitioner’s claim that the District failed to address her unique reading needs in this area is not a discrete claim, but rather applies to the entirety of the reading program.
Next, to the extent that Petitioner contended that she needed a program that entailed additional instruction in the areas of sight words, phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension, spelling, and memory issues, the evidence did not support Petitioner’s claim. Initially, it bears repeating that, as long as a school district provides an appropriate education, methodology is left up to the school's discretion. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 208.) Moreover, consistent with the findings of undisputed assessments, District witnesses explained that STUDENT required a functional skills approach, wherein reading instruction would focus on teaching related to reading words she would need in everyday life, such as reading safety words in the community and basic words in the grocery store. (Testimony of Carol Enquist, Dr. Palmer; Dist. Exh. 34, p. 8.)
As both Ms. Enquist and Dr. Palmer explained, earlier attempts to teach STUDENT a decoding approach to reading were unsuccessful, and thus the District staff concluded that STUDENT was not likely to benefit from a phonics and/or decoding-based approach. (Id.) Ms. Enquist described how the RSFSD staff tried a decoding-based reading intervention with STUDENT, but that STUDENT was not able to sound out words and was not able to remember word sounds out of context. Similarly, Dr. Palmer explained that, as demonstrated by STUDENT’s work using the Earobics program, STUDENT generally could not remember sound-symbol relationships, which are essential in decoding. Dr. Palmer further explained that because STUDENT’s primary reading needs concerned reading key functional words in the community, she did not need to focus on spelling.
In contrast, in support of her claim that STUDENT’s reading instruction needed to include additional strategies such as phonics, decoding, sound-symbol relationships, and spelling, Petitioner pointed to the testimony of Marilyn Cameron. Ms. Cameron is the director of the Sylvan Learning Center branch that STUDENT attended in Encinitas beginning in approximately June 2004. Ms. Cameron described how, from approximately June 2004 to May 2005, STUDENT made progress in reading at Sylvan using various sight words and phonics strategies. In contrast, Dr. Palmer described how her May 2004 assessment of STUDENT and observation of a “dvd” of STUDENT’s Sylvan instruction indicated that STUDENT had made very little progress after eleven months of Sylvan instruction. Regardless of whether STUDENT made progress at Sylvan, Ms. Cameron’s testimony about her work with STUDENT did not establish that STUDENT needed a phonics-based reading approach. (Footnote 11)
Petitioner’s other main witness for this claim was her own advocate, Dr. Kathleen Edwards. Dr. Edwards testified in part that STUDENT’s reading instruction needed to encompass not only a sight word approach, but also methodologies including decoding, encoding and phonemic awareness. For several reasons, this testimony was not persuasive. First, because Dr. Edwards has not worked directly with STUDENT and has not conducted an assessment of her, she was not as familiar with STUDENT’s needs as were Dr. Palmer and Ms. Enquist, each of whom conducted assessments of STUDENT and provided speech-language therapy to her for four years. Second, because Dr. Edwards was and is STUDENT’s educational advocate, she was not an impartial or disinterested witness. Third, Dr. Edwards’ opinions were inconsistent with some portions of documents that were both reliable and otherwise undisputed, such as the recommendations of the 1997 assessment by the CDE Diagnostic Center that “a whole-word approach be employed, rather than utilizing phonics based strategies.” (Dist. Exh. 34, p. 8.)
For these reasons, the Hearing Officer gives less weight to the testimony of Dr. Edwards than to more persuasive witnesses, such as Dr. Palmer and Ms. Enquist. Both Dr. Palmer and Ms. Enquist provided informative, knowledgeable, reasoned testimony, based upon their respective assessments of STUDENT and their years of working with her.
Hence, Petitioner’s claim that her reading program should have included additional methodologies such as phonics, decoding, sound-symbol relationships and spelling, was not supported by the evidence. Instead, the District established that a program for functional sight words was an appropriate methodology to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading. Dr. Palmer explained that STUDENT needed visual prompts, and that the visual prompts reinforced what the word looked like and helped STUDENT recognize the word in a real-life setting; for example, by seeing a picture of a grocery item paired with the word for that item, STUDENT would later be able to recognize that word in the grocery store.
Petitioner further argued that the District failed to provide “constant reinforcement and instruction” in reading, pointing to a 1997 CDE Diagnostic Center assessment report that recommended a strategy of “overlearning” and maintenance of a word bank for STUDENT, wherein both new words and words STUDENT had already learned would be frequently repeated in instruction. There was no dispute that STUDENT required significant reinforcement and repetition in her reading instruction. To that extent, Dr. Palmer detailed how she and the SDC staff regularly worked with STUDENT on reading using News-2-You, computer software, sentence scripts, worksheets, flash cards and the lunch menu, with repetition and reinforcement. Documentary evidence such as data logs and daily reports likewise reflect regular use of these reading instruction methods. (Dist. Exh. 77; Pet. Exh. pgs. 412, 1431, 1439, 1479.) Therefore, the District established that its program entailed sufficient regular reinforcement and repetition in reading instruction. Regarding maintenance of a word bank, Dr. Palmer explained that while it could be an appropriate strategy, it was simply one option and not the only appropriate strategy for STUDENT. This Decision has already found that Dr. Palmer was a persuasive witness, and there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary on this point.
This Decision has also determined that a program for functional sight words was an appropriate methodology to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading. Dr. Palmer described a variety of ways in which STUDENT worked on reading, such as using instructional computer programs, using flash cards, reading News-2-You, reading personalized lunch menus, and filling out cooking worksheets. The purpose of these instructional tools was to teach STUDENT to recognize functional words by sight. These tools generally paired words with pictures to reinforce sight words with visual prompts.
Thus, the methodology and level of instruction in the District’s reading program were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
(b) Assistive Technology for Reading
Petitioner contended that the District did not utilize assistive technology in the manner she needed to receive educational benefit. Petitioner argued that the District failed to “provide appropriate assistive technology, including computer software, annual goals, or a systematic approach to measure her present levels of performance and progress in reading.”
Special education law identifies assistive technology (AT) as among the supports and services that may be needed to implement a child’s IEP. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.1; 20 U.S.C. § 1401(2).) While this Decision has already discussed STUDENT’s particular needs in reading, there was no evidence establishing that STUDENT needed any additional assistive technology. In September and October 2000, District assistive technology specialist John Hooker conducted an assistive technology assessment of STUDENT. His assessment recommended particular computer software programs, such as Writing With Symbols and Simon Sounds It Out, to assist STUDENT in meeting her IEP goals and objectives, but did not find that STUDENT needed any particular assistive technology. (Pet. Exh. p. 321-324; see testimony of John Hooker.) The District provided STUDENT with the computer software programs that Mr. Hooker suggested and added additional programs thereafter. Dr. Palmer testified about how STUDENT worked on her goals and objectives using those programs. While there was no dispute that several computer software programs were useful tools in working on STUDENT’s goal areas, there was no evidence that she needed additional assistive technology to address her needs to allow educational benefit.
Dr. Edwards testified that STUDENT needed to have her reading progress tracked by assistive technology, but there was no persuasive evidence that this was among STUDENT’s needs. . Pursuant to a student’s IEP, the District must use appropriate objective criteria, evaluation procedures and schedules for determining, at least on an annual basis, whether the student’s annual goals are being achieved. (See Cal. Educ. § 56345(a)(7).) To measure STUDENT’s progress on her goals and objectives during the 2001-2002 school year, her teachers and service providers kept records, provided progress reports, and reviewed her progress at IEP meetings. (Dist. Exhs. 77, 91, 92; Pet. Exh. pgs. 411-412, 416, 424-425, 1432, 1468; testimony of Dr. Palmer.) STUDENT’s March 2002 assessments also contained information about her progress in some goal areas. Special education staff also prepared reports of what STUDENT worked on each day. (Footnote 12) (Pet. Exh. pgs. 1433, 1450, 1460, 1463, 1471-1473, 1480, 1483-1.) Dr. Palmer testified that the detailed information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance contained in the May 2001 IEP was sufficient for the IEP team to develop a program to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Consequently, the District’s program for STUDENT contained appropriate measures of STUDENT’s progress on her goals. Although this Decision has determined that the May 2001 IEP lacked sufficient reading goals, there was no particular need or requirement for the District to use assistive technology to track STUDENT’s progress.
Hence, the District’s use of assistive technology in STUDENT’s educational program was designed to address her unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
(c) Length of School Day
Petitioner alleged that the District’s program denied her a FAPE because she was dismissed early from school each day. MOTHER testified that STUDENT’s SDC teacher had explained that the SDC students left class early because the special education bus left the campus a few minutes early. On the IEP addendum dated October 30, 2001, the IEP notes state “dismissal time - STUDENT will continue leaving class at 2:15.” (Dist. Exh. 10.) MOTHER signed her consent to this IEP addendum. (Id.) Special education coordinator Mary Ellen Nest confirmed in her testimony that this signed IEP addendum was implemented and STUDENT was dismissed from class shortly after 2:00 p.m. each day to walk to the bus. Ms. Nest testified that this early dismissal was appropriate for STUDENT, noting that STUDENT walked at a slow pace and needed time to get to the bus. STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Ana Zeladon, described this situation to MOTHER in the home/school communication log. In an entry dated March 28, 2002, Ms. Zeladon wrote:
School is dismissed at 2:30. However, my students need to be at the buses at 2:15, to allow time for loading students in wheelchairs, and beat the traffic jam. Otherwise, the buses sit for up to 20 min. waiting to leave parking lot....At 2:00, we pass out papers to go home, cover any important events coming up, and then walk to buses. (Pet. Exh. p. 1047.)
At the hearing and in her closing brief, Petitioner recounted that the early dismissal occurred, but failed to offer any argument as to why the early dismissal constituted a denial of FAPE. While there is no question that STUDENT had significant educational needs and required an intensive program, there was no evidence that she needed a particular length of school day to receive such a program. The District’s proffered reasons for dismissing STUDENT and the other SDC students early were reasonable and practical, and there is no indication that leaving school shortly after 2:00 p.m. left STUDENT with inadequate instructional time. Hence, STUDENT’s early dismissal to catch the school bus each day did not constitute a failure to address her unique needs, did not interfere with her receipt of educational benefit, and did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
*********
Thus, this Decision has determined that the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year was not designed to meet her unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit to the extent that the program failed to include sufficient reading goals. However, the other IEP goals and the District’s program to address STUDENT’s reading needs were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit. Additionally, the length of STUDENT’s school day likewise did not deny her a FAPE. Hence, other than the lack of appropriate reading goals, the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit.
B. Conformity With IEP
For the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner contended that her program did not comport with her IEPs to the extent that the District failed to provide an adjustable chair as set forth in her IEPs. In the August 29, 2001 IEP addendum, the notes stated only that “a chair is in place that accommodates STUDENT,” and none of the other IEPs for that school year included any provision for an adjustable chair. (Pet. Exh. 386; Dist. Exhs. 8-16.)
Consequently, the IEPs did not specifically provide for an adjustable chair for the 2001-2002. In any event, MOTHER testified that school staff told her that the adjustable chair disappeared over the summer before STUDENT’s senior year, and Dr. Palmer testified that STUDENT used an adjustable chair in the SDC until the chair disappeared sometime during the 2002 summer break. Thus, the evidence indicated that STUDENT had an adjustable chair for the 2001-2002 school year, regardless of whether it was a specific component of her IEP. Accordingly, the adjustable chair did not constitute a nonconformity with the IEP for the 2001-2002 school year, and there was no denial of FAPE on this basis.
C. Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)
Federal and State law require that, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities shall be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56364.2.)
In determining whether disabled children should be placed in a regular classroom with supplemental aids and services, the courts have created a four-part test: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom, (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with nondisabled peers, (3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom, and (4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom. (Sacramento City Unified School District v. Rachel H., supra at 1404.)
When it set forth the four-part test in Rachel H., the Ninth Circuit explained that “the question whether to educate a handicapped child in the regular classroom or to place [him or her] in a special education environment is necessarily an individualized, fact specific inquiry. In each case, the apparent tension between the IDEA's clear preference for mainstreaming and its requirements that schools provide individualized programs tailored to the specific needs of each disabled child must be balanced.” (Poolaw v. Bishop, 67 F.3d 830, 836 (9th Cir. 1995) (citing 20 U.S.C. §§ 1401, 1414(a)(5), Oberti v. Board of Educ. of the Borough of Clementon Sch. Dist., 995 F.2d 1204, 1214 (3d Cir.1993) and Daniel R.R., supra, 874 F.2d at 1044-45).)
For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT attended Ms. Zeladon’s SDC for math and English, and functional skills. STUDENT also received DIS of individual speech-language therapy four times per week for thirty minutes per session, group speech-language therapy once a week for sixty minutes per session, and OT for sixty minutes per month. For the mainstreaming component of her day, STUDENT took general education classes in dance, cooking, acting and band, and was also mainstreamed for lunch. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 351, 517.) The May 2001 IEP indicated that she spent approximately 69 percent of her school day integrated with general education peers.
Petitioner contended that this placement was not in the LRE because she should have been placed in general education classes for most of her school day, with pull-out services for RSP and DIS. Petitioner argued that she gained significant benefit from interaction with nondisabled peers, and stated that she had made greater progress during elementary and middle school when she had more mainstreaming. In contrast, the District argued that STUDENT could not have received a satisfactory education if she had been placed in general education full-time with some RSP pull-out, because she required a more intense level of instruction and support. The District noted that STUDENT spent 69 percent of her school day in general education during the 2001-2002 school year, which was a greater proportion of her time in general education than she had spent in middle school. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 225, 268.)
In light of these allegations and the legal requirements, the Hearing Officer considers the four LRE factors as follows:
(1) The academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom
There was significant evidence of academic benefit to STUDENT in the SDC. District witnesses described how the SDC provided STUDENT with the intense instruction, repetition, hands-on practice, and small teacher-to-student ratio she required to address her significant needs. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Nest.) This Decision has already determined that a functional skills reading approach was appropriate for STUDENT, so that she could she could read signs, schedules, and words related to daily living, and otherwise function in the community. Consistent with STUDENT’s reading needs, District witnesses explained that STUDENT needed to learn functional skills in math, such as handling money, and therefore her May 2001 IEP included a money skills goal. (Dist. Exh. 16, p. 8; testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Nest.) Similarly, the evidence established that STUDENT needed to work on daily living skills, and that therefore her September 2001 ITP included a grooming goal. (Dist. Exh. 13, p. 3.)
Ms. Nest and Dr. Palmer both explained that these types of functional skills for reading, math and daily living were taught in the SDC, with the intensive instruction and frequent repetition that STUDENT needed. Ms. Nest explained that, to learn this type of functional curriculum, STUDENT needed to repeat, practice and apply the skills she learned, which she could do in the SDC. Dr. Palmer explained that the best way for STUDENT to learn and remember something was to do it, instead of just hearing it or seeing it.
STUDENT’s parents both testified generally that STUDENT had always done better in general education classes than in special education. While there was no question that STUDENT benefitted socially from interaction with typically developing peers, there was no evidence presented regarding how STUDENT’s academic needs could be met in high school general education academic classes. Instead, the only evidence on this question was testimony from District witnesses, who testified that STUDENT could not make adequate progress on her goals and objectives in TPHS’s general education math and English classes. Ms. Nest described TPHS as an academically competitive high school where the academic coursework in a typical tenth-grade general education math or English class was particularly challenging. (Footnote 13) Ms. Nest and Dr. Palmer both testified that the general education English classes at TPHS involved reading novels and writing essays at levels too advanced to modify for STUDENT. Dr. Palmer explained that the material taught in a general education high school English class would be far too advanced for STUDENT, would not address functional reading, and would not use picture symbols with words that STUDENT needed. Similarly, Ms. Nest described how the general education high school math classes were at such a challenging level that STUDENT could not benefit from that instruction. Thus, Ms. Nest’s testimony indicated that STUDENT would have had to spend most of her time in such classes working one-to-one with an aide, and would have had little participation in what the rest of the class was doing. There was no evidence to the contrary regarding how the work could have been modified for STUDENT or how she could have participated more in class activities. (Footnote 14)
This Decision has already found that STUDENT would “shut down”and not attempt a task if she felt it was too difficult, which raises further questions about how STUDENT could have received academic benefit from participating in general education math and English classes operating at a relatively high level. Moreover, Lynn Leahy, STUDENT’s cooking teacher, testified that although STUDENT enjoyed doing many of the tasks in cooking class, she usually did not understand much of Ms. Leahy’s lectures about cooking topics.
In light of the above information, the evidence established that the academic benefit available to STUDENT in the SDC far exceeded the academic benefit available to her in general education math and English classes. The evidence established that STUDENT could receive academic benefit learning math, English and functional skills in the SDC, but there was little evidence of academic benefit available in general education math and English classes at TPHS.
(2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with nondisabled peers
This Decision has already determined that STUDENT was very social and enjoyed interacting with typically developing peers. There was no dispute that she was capable of modeling peers and that she received non-academic benefits from integration with nondisabled peers, including during her attendance in general education elective classes and the lunch period.
The testimony from Ms. Nest and Dr. Palmer indicated that the academic levels of tenth-grade math and English classes at TPHS were such that most of the coursework could not be modified to a level where STUDENT could participate in the classroom instruction and discussion, and thus she would have spent the majority of the class time working one-on-one with an aide. Hence, it is unclear to what extent she would have received additional non-academic benefit from attending general education math and English classes.
(3) the effect of the disabled student’s presence on the teacher and other children in the classroom
There was no question that STUDENT was a friendly student who was well-liked by her peers and whose presence enriched her classroom. This Decision has already found that STUDENT was well-behaved, and there were no allegations that her presence was in any way disruptive to the teachers or other students in the classroom. Perhaps in part because STUDENTattended general education classes with an aide, there was no indication that her presence demanded additional time or attention from her general education teachers. (See testimony of Ms. Leahy.)
(4) the cost of mainstreaming the disabled student in a regular classroom
Neither party presented evidence or argument on this factor, and therefore it will not be considered as a factor in this Decision.
Thus, although her presence had a positive effect on teachers and other students in general education classes, STUDENT would have received significantly greater academic benefit from the SDC for her instruction in academic areas such as math and English. While STUDENT received non-academic benefits from interacting with typically developing peers in general education, she was already receiving those benefits from her elective classes in band, art, dance and cooking. It is unclear to what extent she would have received much additional non-academic benefit from general education math and English classes in high school, particularly given that the level of coursework would likely have reduced her ability to participate in the classroom instruction and activities. Considering all three of the relevant LRE factors, the Hearing Officer concludes that the special education classroom was STUDENT’s LRE for her academic classes such as math, English and functional skills.
*********
Accordingly, to the extent that the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year failed to include sufficient reading goals, the District’s program was not designed to address her unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. In all other respects, the District’s program for the 2001-2002 school year was substantively appropriate because it was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, was in conformity with her IEP and was in the LRE.
II. Did the District deny Petitioner a FAPE in the LRE for the 2002-2003 school year?
Petitioner raised the same claims concerning the 2002-2003 school year as she had raised concerning the 2001-2002 school year, with the addition of two allegations of nonconformity with the IEP.
A. Designed To Meet Unique Needs And Reasonably Calculated To Provide Educational Benefit
Although STUDENT made some progress during the 2001-2002 school year, she continued to have needs in the same general areas for the 2002-2003 school year. For example, a February 2002 assessment by school psychologist Debra Lawler found that STUDENT’s communication, daily living skills and socialization were all in the low range, and a March 2002 academic assessment described STUDENT’s academic skills at the kindergarten to first-grade level. (Dist. Exhs. 27, 28.) There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to have deficits in areas including academics, memory, auditory comprehension skills, speech, language, communication, motor skills and self-help/adaptive skills. She continued to need speech-language therapy and OT. Although socialization was a relative strength, she continued to have some needs in that area, such as in pragmatics.
STUDENT’s reading needs at or about the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year were also generally similar to her needs during the 2001-2002 year. There was evidence that STUDENT had made some progress in reading by May 2002. It is notable that a March 2002 District assessment found that STUDENT could read the letter/word “a” but could not identify the remaining words on a preprimer-level word list. (Pet. Exh. p. 525.) However, when identifying STUDENT’s present levels of performance, the May 2002 IEP document reported that STUDENT could independently read up to 50 percent of News-To-You articles, could answer comprehension questions with one-hundred percent accuracy using picture/word symbols as cues. The May 2002 draft IEP listed six sight words that STUDENT reportedly could read. (Pet. Exh. p. 564.) The baseline to that IEP’s reading/language arts goal noted that STUDENT “reads a few sight words” and “does need picture symbols.” (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 7.) In any event, there is no question that STUDENT continued to need to learn to read functional sight words, continued to have severe difficulties in reading, and continued to need intensive services in this area.
The District offered a program for the 2002-2003 school year that had the same basic components as STUDENT’s program for the prior school year. For the 2002-2003 school year, the IEP team convened on May 14, 2002, and offered placement in an SDC for instruction in math, English and functional skills, with attendance in general education, accompanied by an instructional assistant. (Dist. Exh. 7.) The general education component consisted of lunch and general education elective classes of band, dance, and acting. The May 2002 offer included DIS of one hour per month of occupational therapy, three thirty-minute sessions per week of individual speech-language therapy, and one hour per week of group speech-language therapy. As Dr. Palmer testified, the individual speech-language therapy included practicing reading social scripts and other types of practice and instruction in reading. The IEP offer also included transportation, ESY, assistive technology, an adjustable chair and footstool, and an ITP. The ITP listed goals in five areas, with components such as a functional skills curriculum consisting of reading with picture symbols, building sight word vocabulary, money management, and participation in an off-campus job or in the community through the Workability program. (Dist. Exh. 5, p.11.) The IEP notes indicate that “start-up of Workability happens during school year, therefore in fall of 2002 placements for STUDENT will be explored and placement, if deemed appropriate, will take place.” (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 10.)
The May 2002 IEP meeting convened without either of STUDENT’s parents present, and her parents did not sign the IEP document after the District sent them a copy. Consequently, STUDENT’s May 2001 IEP remained in effect at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. On October 17, 2002, STUDENT’s IEP team convened with MOTHER in attendance. The IEP notes from that meeting state in part that “parents requested a review and revision of IEP goals and objectives from May 14, 2002.” The team members then agreed upon some changes to the May 2002 draft IEP, such as changes to the goals, provision of adult supervision in all of STUDENT’s elective classes, and provision of speech-language therapy four times per week instead of three. However, the other components of the IEP, SDC placement, DIS, and general education electives, generally remained the same. (Dist. Exhs. 5, 6.) With a few additions, the present levels of performance in the May 2002 IEP were incorporated into the October 2002 IEP. MOTHER signed the IEP document on October 17, 2002, and thereafter that IEP was implemented.
As with prior school years, for the 2002-2003 school year Petitioner disputed the present levels of performance in reading and the IEP goals in the areas of reading, receptive language, and OT. Petitioner also again alleged that the program failed to address her needs in the areas of reading instruction, assistive technology, and the length of her school day. Each claim is examined below.
(1) IEP Goals and Present Levels of Performance (a) Present Levels of Performance in Reading
Regarding the present levels of performance in the October 2002 IEP, Petitioner simply contended that while the IEP listed six sight words she could read, there was no way to determine whether she had known those words previously because the May 2001 IEP’s present levels did not specifically identify any sight words she knew. In any event, the alleged lack of information in the May 2001 IEP does not render the October 2002 IEP’s present levels inaccurate or inappropriate. (Footnote 15) Dr. Palmer testified that the IEP’s present levels of performance contained enough information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and an appropriate program, and there was no evidence to the contrary. Thus, the IEP’s statement of present levels of performance were accurate and contained sufficient information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and an appropriate program for STUDENT.
(b) Reading Goals
Petitioner also argued that the IEP’s reading goals were insufficient. The primary reading goal in the October 2002 IEP was a goal that STUDENT would “practice reading & writing skills by dictating [a] 3-5 sentence paragraph based on a picture prompt with appropriate topic sentence & details on 4/5 trials [and] to be written or typed by STUDENT after dictation with 80% accuracy.” (Pet. Exh. p. 589.) The IEP also contained a goal for reading numbers. (Pet. Exh. p. 585.)
This Decision has found that STUDENT needed to be able to read functional words in the community, so that she could read signs and participate in post-graduation activities such as employment. This Decision has also determined that a program for functional sight words was an appropriate methodology to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading. Given those requirements, the October 2002 IEP did not contain goals sufficient to address STUDENT’s functional reading needs.
Notably, the ITP that was drafted on May 14 and signed by MOTHER on October 17, 2002, identified transition activities for STUDENT including “reading w/ picture symbols,” “build sight word vocabulary,” and “reading & writing.” (Pet. p. 593.) However, unlike IEP goals, these transition activities did not contain objectives or benchmarks to measure progress. Given that measurable goals and objectives are the basis for a special education student’s program, the transition activities contained in the ITP were not sufficient by themselves to constitute appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT, and thus did not overcome the IEP’s lack of sufficient goals in functional reading.
The District points to the reading goals offered in the May 2002 draft IEP but dropped from the October 2002 IEP. The IEP notes of October 17, 2002, state that “parents requested a review and revision of IEP goals and objectives from May 14, 2002 IEP,” and “parent disagrees with goals & objectives from May 14, 2002, student was not represented at that meeting.” (Dist. Exh. 6.) Thus, there is little question that the District staff agreed to remove these goals in light of the parent’s disagreement regarding the goals. Nevertheless, the analysis of whether the District offered a FAPE must consider the October 2002 IEP that was eventually agreed upon and implemented. The District’s earlier offer of goals may be relevant in determining the remedy awarded, as this Decision discusses under Issue V, but does not overcome the finding that the October 2002 IEP failed to include sufficient reading goals.
Hence, to the extent that the October 2002 IEP did not have a functional sight word reading goal, the program for the 2002-2003 school year was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
(c) Receptive Language Goals
Petitioner again contended that the IEP lacked sufficient receptive language goals in memory, recalling information, oral comprehension and vocabulary. Regarding the areas of memory and recalling information, this Decision has already determined that, while many of STUDENT’s goals involved such skills, STUDENT did not need specific goals in those areas. As Dr. Palmer explained, STUDENT could not perform the abstract thought necessary to utilize educational strategies to improve memory, and thus it was more effective to teach to STUDENT’s concrete thinking. Therefore, the absence of goals in memory and recalling information did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
Regarding oral comprehension, the October 2002 IEP contained a “reading/listening” goal which stated in part that STUDENT “will continue to develop functional listening comprehension skills by answering 5 ‘wh’ questions correctly after listening to a short on 4/5 trials.” (Dist. Exh. 5, p. 7.) Dr. Palmer testified that this IEP goals addressed STUDENT’s auditory comprehension needs, and there was no evidence or argument to the contrary. (Footnote 16)
Regarding vocabulary, the October 2002 IEP did not contain any vocabulary goals, although there was no dispute that vocabulary was an area of need for STUDENT. The District pointed to the vocabulary goal contained in the May 2002 IEP, and Petitioner’s closing brief likewise addressed the goals contained in the May 2002 IEP. The May 2002 IEP contained a goal for STUDENT to “build a reading and writing vocabulary by reading aloud 5 printed words from at least 3 environments with 100% accuracy for 5 consecutive trials as measured by teacher records.” (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 7.) As discussed above, when the IEP team reconvened on October 17, 2002, the IEP notes indicated that STUDENT’s parents disagreed with the goals and objectives offered at the May 14, 2002 IEP meeting. (Dist. Exh. 6.) Apparently as a result, the October 2002 IEP did not contain the vocabulary goal offered in the May 2002 IEP. While the District’s earlier offer of goals may be relevant in determining the remedy awarded, as this Decision discusses under Issue V, it does not negate the finding that the October 2002 IEP failed to include a vocabulary goal that STUDENT needed.
Therefore, to the extent that the October 2002 IEP lacked an appropriate vocabulary goal, that IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. However, the remaining areas of receptive language goals were designed to meet her unique needs and were reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
(d) OT Goals: Balance and Community Safety
As discussed above, the testimony of licensed occupational therapist Joy Bischke established that STUDENT did not need OT goals in balance because, despite some weaknesses with balance and coordination, STUDENT could walk around campus without problem. Regarding community safety, this Decision has already found that community safety was not part of what occupational therapists worked on with students in OT. Ms. Bischke explained that, while STUDENT needed to learn about community safety, the District offered to address those needs through other aspects of her program, such as instruction in the SDC and community outings with the SDC teacher. Therefore, STUDENT did not require OT goals in balance and community safety to meet her needs and a receive a FAPE.
(e) OT Goals: Functional Fine Motor Skills
Petitioner contended that the October 2002 IEP and program for the 2002-2003 school year failed to address her unique needs in functional fine motor skills. There was no dispute that functional fine motor skills were an area of need for STUDENT. The May 2002 draft IEP contained an OT goal in the functional fine motor skill of handwriting, although after the parent expressed disagreement with some of the goals and objectives, the IEP team agreed not to include this goal in the October 2002 IEP. (Dist. Exhs. 5, 6.) The October 2002 IEP added a new goal “to improve fine motor coordination for greater task independence” by improving typing/keyboarding skills.” (Dist. Exh. 5, p. 9.)
Thus, the October 2002 IEP that was implemented contained a functional fine motor goal, and there was no evidence that STUDENT needed additional goals in functional fine motor skills. As discussed under Issue I, Ms. Bischke testified that STUDENT did not need additional functional fine motor goals because she could already perform many functional fine motor activities on her own and because her educational program already involved working on these skills in the SDC. Ms. Bischke noted that the present levels of performance in the May 2002 draft IEP, incorporated into the October 2002 IEP, indicated that STUDENT could perform several functional fine motor skills, such as drawing, using a computer, using a calculator, taking money out of her wallet to pay for lunch, brushing her hair and using the restroom independently. (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 3.) Ms. Bischke explained that the SDC instruction also included working on independent living skills, which entailed using functional fine motor skills.
This Decision has already found that Ms. Bischke was a credible and persuasive witness, and there was no evidence contrary to her testimony regarding functional fine motor skills. Thus, the evidence established that STUDENT’s functional fine motor needs were being addressed within her educational program during the 2002-2003 school year, and therefore she did not require additional goals in this area. Accordingly, the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s needs regarding functional fine motor skills for the 2002-2003 school year.
*********
This Decision has found that the October 2002 IEP lacked sufficient goals in reading and vocabulary, which constituted a failure to address STUDENT’s unique needs in those areas. However, the October 2002 IEP’s present levels of performance in reading were accurate and the IEP goals were appropriate for STUDENT in the areas of memory, recalling information, oral comprehension, balance, community safety and functional fine motor skills.
(2) Program Offer
Petitioner again argued that the District’s program was not designed to address her needs or reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit in the area of reading and concerning the length of her school day.
(a) Reading Instruction
As with the prior school year, Petitioner again contended that the District’s reading program was inappropriate because it did not entail the instruction that she needed. Petitioner reiterated her claims that the program did not address her needs because it failed to “address STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation” and lacked “constant reinforcement and instruction in reading fundamentals, including in the areas of sight words, phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension, spelling, and memory issues.” As noted in the discussion of the 2001-2002 school year, because Petitioner’s claim regarding transition needs applies to the entirety of the reading program, this Decision will not analyze this claim separately. Instead, this claim is addressed throughout the entire analysis of the reading component of STUDENT’s educational program.
As she alleged for the 2001-2002 school year, Petitioner again contended that the District failed to use appropriate strategies and methods of instruction. This Decision has already determined that STUDENT’s unique reading needs would be appropriately addressed by a functional sight word program geared towards recognizing words STUDENT would need in everyday life, such as reading safety words in the community and words in the grocery store. (Testimony of Carol Enquist, Dr. Palmer; Dist. Exh. 34, p. 8.) STUDENT’s reading needs remained generally the same in eleventh grade as they had been the prior year, and this Decision’s previous findings regarding methodology pertain equally to the 2002-2003 school year. As determined under Issue I of this Decision, the evidence did not support Petitioner’s claim that her program needed to include components such as phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension or spelling.
Additionally, Petitioner again contended that the District failed to provide “constant reinforcement and instruction” in reading. There was no question that STUDENT required significant reinforcement and repetition in her reading instruction. As Dr. Palmer explained, she and the SDC staff regularly worked with STUDENT on reading using materials including computer software programs, short paragraphs, social scripts, News-2-You, and a set of cards featuring words and picture prompts organized around STUDENT’s work in a grocery store. When reading social scripts, STUDENT and a peer practiced what to say during common situations, such as a telephone call, while also engaging in a reading exercise. Dr. Palmer testified that these approaches addressed STUDENT’s need for functional reading and made the words meaningful to her by putting the reading into a real-life setting. Dr. Palmer described how the SDC staff taught functional words repetitively, both by instruction and by reinforcing the words through activities, such as cooking. The Hearing Officer found this testimony persuasive. Thus, although this Decision found that the October 2002 lacked appropriate reading goals, the evidence established that STUDENT nevertheless received significant reinforcement and repetition in her reading instruction for the 2002-2003 school year.
(b) Assistive Technology in Reading
As with the prior school year, for the 2002-2003 school year Petitioner contended that the District did not utilize assistive technology in the manner she needed to receive educational benefit. Petitioner argued that the District failed to provide appropriate assistive technology, including computer software, annual goals, or a systematic approach to measure her present levels of performance and progress in reading.
This Decision has already determined that there was no evidence establishing that STUDENT needed any additional assistive technology during the 2001-2002 school year, and the same findings likewise apply to the 2002-2003 school year. As discussed under Issue I, there was no particular need or requirement for the District to specifically track STUDENT’s progress using assistive technology or to specifically track STUDENT’s progress on computer software programs. STUDENT’s teachers and service measured her reading progress in the 2002-2003 school year by keeping records, providing progress reports, and reviewing her progress at the annual IEP meeting. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer; Pet. Exh. pgs. 599; Dist. Exhs. 4, 72, 91, 92.) Dr. Palmer testified that the detailed information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance contained in the May 2002 IEP was sufficient for the IEP team to draft goals and a program to address STUDENT’s unique needs. Consequently, the District’s program for STUDENT contained appropriate measures of STUDENT’s progress, and there was no evidence that STUDENT required assistive technology to measure that progress.
Accordingly, STUDENT’s reading program was designed to address her unique needs in reading and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit in reading.
(c) Length of School Day
Petitioner alleged that the District’s program denied her a FAPE because each day she and the other SDC students were dismissed shortly after 2:00 p.m. to walk to the school bus, although most TPHS students remained in class until 2:30 p.m. As discussed under Issue I, the District staff implemented this early dismissal for reasonable, practical purposes, such as that staff needed additional time to get students in wheelchairs onto the bus, and that the bus would become stuck in traffic if it failed to leave the parking lot before 2:30 p.m. This Decision has already found that there was no evidence that STUDENT needed a particular length of school day to receive her educational program and that there was no indication that the early dismissal left STUDENT with inadequate instructional time. Therefore, STUDENT’s early dismissal to catch the school bus each day did not constitute a failure to address her unique needs, did not interfere with her receipt of educational benefit, and did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
***********
Thus, while the the October 2002 IEP lacked sufficient goals in reading and vocabulary, the other aspects of the District’s program for the 2002-2003 school year were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit.
B. Conformity With IEP
For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner contended that the District’s program failed to comport with her IEP in three areas: failing to provide an adjustable chair, failing to implement the Workability program, and failing to provide individual speech and language services.
(1) Adjustable Chair
Preliminarily, the May 2001 IEP and its addendums were the last agreed-upon IEP documents applicable to STUDENT’s program until a new IEP was signed on October 17, 2002. As discussed under Issue I, the May 2001 IEP and addendums did not contain any provision for an adjustable chair.
Following the parent’s consent to the new IEP on October 17, 2002, the IEP lists “adjustable chair & footstool” as supplemental aids to be provided to STUDENT in the 2002-2003 school year. (Dist. Exh. 5, p. 2; Dist. Exh. 7, p. 2.) MOTHER testified that school staff told her that the adjustable chair disappeared over the summer before STUDENT’s senior year, while Dr. Palmer testified the staff could not find the chair after the 2002 summer, despite repeated efforts to locate the chair. Ms. Bischke confirmed that the staff did not replace the adjustable chair. Hence, the evidence established that STUDENT did not have use of the adjustable chair during the 2002-2003 school year. Because the IEP identified an adjustable chair as a supplemental aid for STUDENT, the program failed to conform to her IEP to the extent that she did not have an adjustable chair available.
The District argued that STUDENT nevertheless received appropriate seating to address her needs and therefore the absence of an adjustable chair did not constitute a denial of FAPE. MOTHER testified that STUDENT was so short that her feet did not touch the ground when she sat in a regular chair, and stated that therefore STUDENT needed a chair that could be adjusted to her height. Ms. Bischke testified that STUDENT’s feet did not touch the ground when she sat in a regular chair and that that situation caused STUDENT to have poor posture. However, Ms. Bischke explained that there was no need to replace the adjustable chair because STUDENT was able to use a footstool instead. Ms. Bischke stated that the footstool addressed the problem and that STUDENT demonstrated appropriate posture when the footstool was underneath her feet. Ms. Bischke also stated that the footstool was particularly appropriate because it was lightweight and that therefore staff could easily bring it along when STUDENT went from class to class.
Hence, the lack of an adjustable chair constituted a nonconformity with the IEP for the 2002-2003 school year. However, Ms. Bischke’s testimony established that the footstool addressed STUDENT’s needs in this area and fulfilled the same function as the adjustable chair. While MOTHER testified that the school nurse had said that STUDENT could potentially get a blood clot in her ankle if her feet were dangling off the floor, Ms. Bischke’s testimony established that STUDENT could sit while resting her feet on a footstool. Because this need was addressed by the footstool, the lack of an adjustable chair had no discernable affect on STUDENT’s schoolwork, class participation, attendance, or any other aspect of her education. In light of the nature of the nonconformity and Ms. Bischke’s unrefuted testimony that a footstool fulfilled the same purpose as the adjustable chair, the Hearing Officer concludes the nonconformity was minor and did not interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of a FAPE.
(2) Workability Program
Petitioner contended that the District failed to implement the Workability program offered in the IEP dated May 14, 2002. However, STUDENT’s parents did not attend that IEP meeting and did not sign the IEP at that time. The ITP drafted on May 14, 2002, provided that STUDENT would participate in Workability through a job on campus or in the community. The IEP notes stated that “start-up of Workability happens during school year, therefore in Fall of 2002 placements for STUDENT will be explored and placement, if deemed appropriate, will take place.” (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 10.)
When the IEP team reconvened with MOTHER in attendance on October 17, 2002, MOTHER signed the IEP and ITP on that date. On the first page of the October 2002 IEP, next to the line “Participates in Workability” the “yes” box is checked, followed by the words “in progress.” (Dist. Exh. 5, p. 1.) Thereafter, during the second semester of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT participated in Workability by working one hour per week at Stumps Market.
Petitioner argued that the Workability referral should have been made by September 2002, pursuant to the notes in the May 2002 draft IEP document. This argument fails because the May 2002 draft IEP was not agreed upon until October 17, 2002, and thus could not have been implemented before that date. (Footnote 17) Hence, there was no failure to provide a program in conformity with Workability component of the IEP for the 2002-2003 school year, and therefore no denial of FAPE occurred on this basis.
(3) Speech-Language Services
Petitioner contended that the District failed to consistently provide her individual speech and language services during the 2002-03 school year. Both the October 2002 IEP and the May 2001 IEP, which identified STUDENT’s educational program until a new IEP was signed on October 17, 2002, provided for individual speech-language services of four thirty-minute sessions per week. (Pet. Exhs. pgs. 562, 582.)
First, Petitioner argued that the District failed to provide the number of individual speech-language sessions listed in her IEP. The District submitted numerous pages of Dr. Palmer’s notations from STUDENT’s speech-language sessions from various school years, as well as STUDENT’s speech-language therapy progress reports. (Dist. Exhs. 85, 92; see also Pet. Exh. pgs. 1569-1574, 1579.) Dr. Palmer testified that she provided individual speech-language services to STUDENT four times per week during STUDENT’s eleventh grade year, and detailed the variety of methods she used and topics they worked on, such as oral-motor exercises, various computer software programs, practicing social scripts, reading aloud and using flash cards. In rebuttal testimony on the last day of hearing, MOTHER testified that she had compared Dr. Palmer’s notations to a calendar, and determined that Dr. Palmer had missed several sessions. In her closing brief, Petitioner simply stated that she had received only 118 speech sessions instead of 148, but did not explain this calculation or point to other specifics to support that general assertion.
The preponderance of evidence does not support Petitioner’s claim. From the available evidence, there is no means of determining what dates or time periods Petitioner claims Dr. Palmer missed. MOTHER testified that she reached her conclusions by compiling the calendar chart that she referred to during her testimony, but Petitioner did not attempt to submit this chart as documentary evidence. While MOTHER was generally a credible witness, the bases for her opinion on this topic appeared to be based solely on some notations Dr. Palmer made to keep track of what STUDENT was working on, and it is not clear whether those notations constituted a comprehensive history of STUDENT’s speech-language sessions or whether the pages MOTHER relied upon were the entirety of Dr. Palmer’s notations. In contrast, Dr. Palmer was a very credible witness who had a clear, detailed recollection of the services she had provided. The general nature and frequency of Dr. Palmer’s notations were consistent with her testimony that she provided speech-language sessions to STUDENT four times per week. In light of all evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Petitioner’s allegations about the speech-language services were not persuasive in light of Dr. Palmer’s testimony that she provided STUDENT with four weekly individual speech-language sessions in conformity with the IEP.
Second, Petitioner argued that the individual speech-language services were not in conformity with the IEP because the sessions were delivered to both STUDENT and another student at the same time, instead of to STUDENT alone. Dr. Palmer testified that in the 2002-2003 school year, during approximately two out of STUDENT’s four weekly individual speech-language sessions Dr. Palmer would include another student in the sessions so that STUDENT could interact with a peer when practicing social scripts and articulation pursuant to her IEP goals.
Thus, to the extent that Dr. Palmer provided some speech-language sessions to STUDENT with another student present, those sessions were not “individual” as stated in the IEP. However, the District presented unrefuted evidence that the inclusion of another student in STUDENT’s speech-language sessions was pursuant to an educational purpose and did not have any negative effect on STUDENT’s educational progress. Dr. Palmer testified that it was beneficial for STUDENT to have a peer to interact with when practicing social scripts. In a June 2002 progress report, Dr. Palmer wrote that STUDENT “enjoys doing the social scripts with one of the peer assistants than with me.” (Pet. Exh. p. 579.) Dr. Palmer testified that having STUDENT interact with a peer for social scripts during her individual speech-language sessions did not take away from STUDENT’s learning. Dr. Palmer’s testimony, STUDENT’s speech-language progress reports, and the May 2003 IEP all reflect STUDENT’s progress on social scripts and expressive language. (Dist. Exhs. 4, 90.)
Moreover, because the nonconformity had no negative effect on STUDENT’s education, there was no denial of FAPE and no basis for awarding a remedy to compensate for any denial of FAPE. In light of the nature of the nonconformity, the evidence demonstrated that the noncoformity was minor and did not interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of a FAPE.
C. Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)
For the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT received instruction in math, English, and functional skills in an SDC taught by Rachel Page. STUDENT attended general education for acting, band, and dance classes, and for the lunch period. The DIS component of her program consisted of individual speech-language therapy four times per week for thirty minutes per session, group speech-language therapy once a week for sixty minutes per session, and OT consultation for sixty minutes per month. Her program also included components such as ESY, transportation, and aide support. The October 17, 2002 IEP added speech-language consultation for twenty minutes per month and participation in an off-campus job through the Workability program. (Dist. Exh. 5.)
The parties generally cited the same evidence and raised the same arguments concerning STUDENT’s LRE for the 2002-2003 school year as they provided for the 2001-2002 school year, as discussed above. As with the prior school year, Petitioner alleged that her placement for the 2002-2003 school year was not in the LRE because she should have attended general education classes for most of her school day, with pull-out services for RSP and DIS. Petitioner contended that she gained significant benefit from interaction with nondisabled peers, while the District again maintained that STUDENT could not have received a satisfactory education if she had been placed in general education full-time with some RSP pull-out, because she required a more intensive level of instruction and support.
As noted previously, while there was some evidence of progress, there was no dispute that overall STUDENT continued to have needs in the same areas for the 2002-2003 school year as she had the prior school year. Thus, as this Decision determined regarding the prior school year, the District again established that the SDC offered much greater academic benefit to STUDENT than she could have received in general education high school math and English classes, and Petitioner offered no persuasive evidence to the contrary. In the SDC, STUDENT had the opportunity to receive intensive instruction and reinforce what she had learned using hands-on activities. In contrast, general education math and English classes would have offered far less academic benefit, because the opportunities for multi-modal reinforcement would have been much more limited and the level of academic instruction would have been difficult to modify to STUDENT’s level.
Moreover, because the level of instruction would have been so disparate from STUDENT’s functional skills curriculum, modification of the academic work would have entailed frequent one-to-one instruction, which would have had a negative impact on the non-academic benefits she could have received from integration with nondisabled peers in those classes. While there is no question that STUDENT benefitted from interacting with typically developing peers, any such benefit she received would have been in addition to that from her three general education elective classes and lunch period.
As in the prior school year, STUDENT’s effect on the general education classroom was not a significant factor, because STUDENT had only positive effects on the general education teacher and students. Cost was again not a factor.
Considering all of the relevant LRE factors, the evidence again established that the special education classroom was STUDENT’s LRE for her academic classes such as math, English and functional skills. The SDC offered significantly greater academic benefit for STUDENT’s instruction in academic areas related to her IEP goals and objectives. Considering that STUDENT’s participation in much of the instruction and discussion time in general education academic classes would have been limited by the necessary modification of the coursework to address her level, the incremental benefit of additional mainstreaming time for academic classes was outweighed by the academic benefits available to her in the SDC.
*********
In summary, to the extent that the District’s program for the 2002-2003 school year failed to include sufficient reading and vocabulary goals, the program was not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. In all other respects, the District’s program for the 2002-2003 school year was appropriate because it was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, was in conformity with the IEP and was in the LRE. While the District’s delivery of the program did not comport with the IEP in two minor areas, those nonconformities did not interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of a FAPE.
III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
Petitioner raised the identical issues for the 2003-2004 school year as she had raised concerning the 2002-2003 school year.
A. Designed To Meet Unique Needs And Reasonably Calculated To Provide Educational Benefit
While STUDENT demonstrated some educational gains over the course of the 2002-2003 school year, neither party argued that her needs had particularly changed in any area. The evidence indicated that STUDENT continued to have needs in the same general areas for the 2003-2004 school year. Thus, STUDENT continued to be friendly and enjoy socializing, but also continued to have deficits in areas including academics, memory, auditory comprehension skills, speech, language, communication, motor skills and self-help/adaptive skills. She continued to need speech-language therapy and OT. The present levels of performance in the May 2003 IEP indicated in part that she knew “familiar words by sight such as words in her schedule and community safety words. She can also express an understanding of function/meaning of various words and pictures when probed.” (Pet. Exh. p. 609.) There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to need to learn to read functional sight words, continued to have severe difficulties in reading and continued to need intensive services in reading.
For the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT attended twelfth grade at TPHS. Pursuant to her May 2003 IEP, 49 percent of her program was in special education and the remaining 51 percent of her time was in general education. The special education time was comprised of OT, individual and group speech-language therapy, and three periods in the SDC for math, English and vocational skills instruction. (Pet. Exh. p. 601-604.) Rachel Page remained STUDENT’s SDC teacher for that school year. STUDENT had mainstreaming for lunch and general education classes of dance, acting and band, which she again attended with an aide. The IEP also included components such as ESY and transportation. The ITP again provided for transition services such as learning a functional skills curriculum and continuing to work at an off-campus job through the Workability program. The IEP indicated that STUDENT would increase her time at her Workability job, and the ITP stated that she would “participate in community job 2-5 (times)/week (depending on site need).” (Pet. Exh. p. 630.) There is no dispute that the reading program consisted of the same basic components as STUDENT’s program for the prior school year, with the addition of new reading goals. During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT received reading instruction in both the SDC and in speech-language therapy. Methods of instruction included computer software, flash cards, social scripts, and short paragraphs to read. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer.)
As with the prior school year, for the 2002-2003 school year Petitioner disputed the goals in the areas of reading, receptive language, and OT, and again alleged that the program failed to address her needs in the areas of reading and the length of her school day.
(1) IEP Goals and Present Levels of Performance (a) Present Levels of Performance in Reading
The key purpose of inclusion of the student’s present levels of performance is so that the IEP team can develop appropriate goals and objectives that track progress in the student’s area of need. Petitioner argued that the May 2003 IEP was inadequate because the document’s present levels of performance failed to identify how many sight words STUDENT could read or the complexity of those words. However, there was no evidence to establish that such information needed to be included in the IEP document so that the IEP team members could draft appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT. The only notable evidence on this point was the testimony of Dr. Palmer that the May 2003 IEP contained sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance for the IEP team to draft goals and create an appropriate program. Dr. Palmer also described how it was not feasible to include that level of detail in the IEP’s present levels of performance, and instead the records of what specific words STUDENT was working on were kept in a notebook by the SDC teacher. the goals were appropriate to address her reading needs.
(c) Receptive Language Goals
At the hearing, Petitioner asserted that, for the 2003-2004 school year, the District failed to provide receptive language goals in oral comprehension, memory, recalling information, or vocabulary. However, Petitioner’s closing brief does not reiterate her previous claim that the May 2003 IEP lacked receptive language goals in vocabulary; indeed, the May 2003 IEP contained a vocabulary goal that STUDENT would learn and use at least twenty-five new vocabulary words per semester. (Pet. Exh. p. 625.) Moreover, the IEP also contained a functional reading goal to develop sight word vocabulary. (Pet. Exh. 622.) Thus, there is no question that the District provided receptive language goals in vocabulary.
Regarding oral comprehension, the May 2003 IEP contained a goal to increase receptive and expressive social communication, with short-term objectives that STUDENT would correctly role-play using social scripts. (Pet. Exh. p. 624.) Dr. Palmer explained that this objective addressed STUDENT’s oral comprehension needs because the role-playing involved STUDENT listening and comprehending what the other participant in the role-playing was saying. There was no evidence to the contrary, and the Hearing Officer concurs that this goal addressed STUDENT’s oral comprehension needs.
Finally, regarding the areas of memory and recalling information, there was again no evidence to indicate that STUDENT needed goals in those areas. Dr. Palmer testified that STUDENT could not perform the abstract thought necessary to utilize educational strategies to improve memory, and thus it was more effective to teach to STUDENT’s concrete thinking. As this Decision determined regarding the prior school years, the absence of goals in memory and recalling information did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
(d) OT Goals: Balance and Community Safety
As this Decision determined regarding the prior two school years, the testimony of licensed occupational therapist Joy Bischke established that STUDENT did not need OT goals in balance because, despite some weaknesses with balance and coordination, STUDENT could walk around campus without problem. Regarding community safety, this Decision has already found that community safety was not part of what occupational therapists worked on with students in OT. Ms. Bischke explained that, while STUDENT needed to learn about community safety, the District offered to address those needs with other aspects of her program, such as instruction in the SDC and community outings with the SDC teacher. This Decision has previously determined that Ms. Bischke was a knowledgeable, credible witness, and there was no evidence contrary to her testimony. Therefore, the lack of OT goals and instruction in balance and community safety did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
(e) OT Goals: Functional Fine Motor Skills
For the 2003-2004 school year, Petitioner again alleged that the District failed to provide the goals she needed to address her unique needs in functional fine motor skills. This Decision has already determined that functional fine motor skills were an area of need for STUDENT. Although the May 2003 IEP notes reflect that STUDENT met her previous OT goal to “improve fine motor coordination for greater task independence” by improving typing/keyboarding skills, the IEP team agreed to continue a modified version of the goal which contained an additional objective for STUDENT to further improve her skills by increasing her typing speed.
Moreover, as this Decision found concerning the prior two school years, STUDENT did not need additional functional fine motor goals because she could already perform many functional fine motor activities on her own and because her educational program already involved working on these skills in the SDC. Ms. Bischke explained that the May 2003 IEP’s present levels of performance reflected that STUDENT could perform many functional fine motor skills, such as using the computer, printing neatly, opening containers and packages, dusting, organizing shelves, using a time card, using a calculator, and performing grooming activities. (See Pet. Exh. p. 609.) Ms. Bischke stated that the SDC instruction also included working on independent living skills, which entailed using functional fine motor skills.
Hence, the evidence established STUDENT’s functional fine motor needs were being addressed within her educational program, and therefore she did not require additional goals in this area. Accordingly, the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s needs regarding functional fine motor skills for the 2003-2004 school year.
*********
Thus, this Decision has determined that the May 2003 IEP goals in reading, receptive language, and OT were designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit for the 2003-2004 school year.
(2) Program Offer
As with the prior school years, for the 2003-2004 school year Petitioner alleged that the District’s program failed to address her needs regarding reading and the length of her school day.
(a) Reading Instruction
Petitioner reiterated her claim that the District’s reading program was inappropriate because it did not did not entail the instructional components that she needed to receive educational benefit. Petitioner asserted that the program did not address her needs because it failed to “address STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation” and lacked “constant reinforcement and instruction in reading fundamentals, including in the areas of sight words, phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension, spelling, and memory issues.” Petitioner again also alleged that the District’s program failed to meet her reading needs related to transition, and the Decision again considers this claim within the entire analysis of the reading component of STUDENT’s educational program.
Regarding Petitioner’s claims about the type of reading instruction, this Decision has already determined that STUDENT’s unique reading needs would be appropriately addressed by a functional sight word program geared towards recognizing words STUDENT would need in everyday life, such as reading safety words in the community and words in the grocery store. Given that STUDENT continued to have generally the same reading needs as in the prior school year, this Decision’s previous findings regarding methodology pertain equally to the 2002-2003 school year. As determined under Issues I and II of this Decision, the evidence did not support Petitioner’s claim that her program needed to include components such as phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension or spelling.
Likewise, this Decision has previously determined that STUDENT had significant reinforcement and repetition in her reading instruction. The evidence indicated that STUDENT continued to receive similar instruction during the 2003-2004 school year, including computer software programs, short paragraphs, social scripts, News-2-You, and flash cards. In the SDC, the flash cards for community safety signs included both the word and the safety sign, to reinforce STUDENT’s recognition of each. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer.) The evidence established that these approaches addressed STUDENT’s need for functional reading and made the words meaningful to her by putting the reading into a real-life setting. (Id.) Given the similar methods and amounts of instruction during the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer similarly concludes that the reading instruction was designed to meet her unique needs in the area of reading.
(b) Assistive Technology in Reading
As in the two prior school years, Petitioner again argued that the District did not utilize assistive technology in the manner she needed to receive educational benefit, specifically that the District failed to provide appropriate assistive technology, including computer software, annual goals, or a systematic approach to measure her present levels of performance and progress in reading.
This Decision has already determined that, while several computer software programs were useful tools in working on STUDENT’s goal areas, there was no evidence that she needed additional assistive technology to address her needs to allow educational benefit. There was no evidence that STUDENT’s needs had changed regarding assistive technology, and the Decision’s finding applies equally to the 2003-2004 school year. Similarly, this Decision has already determined that
Similarly, this Decision has already found that STUDENT did not need to have her reading progress tracked by assistive technology, nor did she require that her progress on particular computer programs be tracked. During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT’s teachers and service providers tracked her reading progress via records, progress reports, and review at the annual IEP meeting. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Nest; Dist. Exhs. 2, 4, 85, 92; Pet. Exh. pgs. 635-636.) Dr. Palmer testified that the May 2003 IEP’s present levels of performance and baselines provided the information that the IEP team needed to draft an appropriate program and goals, and there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the District’s program for STUDENT contained appropriate measures of STUDENT’s progress on her goals, and tracking by assistive technology was not required.
(c) Length of School Day
As with the prior two school years, for the 2003-2004 school year Petitioner contended that the District’s program denied her a FAPE because each day she and the other SDC students were dismissed shortly after 2:00 p.m. to walk to her school bus, although most TPHS students remained in class until 2:30 p.m. As discussed above, the District staff implemented this early dismissal for reasonable, practical purposes, such as that staff needed additional time to get students in wheelchairs onto the bus, and the bus would become stuck in traffic if it failed to leave the parking lot before 2:30 p.m. This Decision has already found that there was no evidence that STUDENT needed a particular length of school day to receive her educational program and that there was no indication that the early dismissal left STUDENT with inadequate instructional time. Therefore, STUDENT’s early dismissal to catch the school bus each day did not constitute a failure to address her unique needs, did not interfere with her receipt of educational benefit, and did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
*********
Accordingly, this Decision has determined that the District’s program for the 2003-2004 school year was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit.
B. Conformity With IEP
For the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner contended that the District’s program failed to comport with her IEP in three areas: failing to provide an adjustable chair, failing to implement the Workability program, and failing to provide individual speech and language services.
(1) Adjustable Chair
The May 2003 IEP did not identify an adjustable chair as one of STUDENT’s supplemental aids. (Dist. Exh. 4, p. 5.) Instead, the IEP document provided that “STUDENT uses a chair with shorter legs and a wider seat, as well as a small footstool to increase stability and support when sitting.” Since neither this description nor any other portion of the IEP indicated that STUDENT’s chair was to be adjustable, the absence of an adjustable chair did not constitute a nonconformity with the IEP.
(2) Workability Program
Petitioner asserted that the District failed to provide her with all of her Workability hours as offered in the May 2003 IEP and attached ITP. The IEP’s Goal #5 stated that by May 2004, STUDENT would “work in a community job setting for 2-5 hours a week (depending on need of placement) using a time card system to independently sign in/out, record job duties, and the date with 100% accuracy on 3/5 trials.” (Pet. Exh. p. 619) That goal’s first benchmark/short-term objective stated that STUDENT would work in a community job setting for one to two hours per week, achieving a seventy percent accuracy rate for her use of a time card and her recording of work date and duties. (Id.) The second benchmark increased the hours per week to two to three and increased her accuracy rate to eighty percent, while the final benchmark increased the hours per week to two to four and her accuracy rate to ninety percent. (Id.) The ITP also contained a Workability goal which stated that STUDENT would “participate in community job 2-5x/week (depending on site need).” (Pet. Exh. p. 630.) The IEP notes indicated that STUDENT would increase her Workability hours compared to the 2002-2003 school year. (Pet. Exh. p. 604.)
STUDENT did not participate in the Workability program during the first semester of the 2003-2004 school year. In the parent-school communication log page dated December 4, 2003, SDC teacher Rachel Page wrote to MOTHER that “I am working on getting STUDENT’s workability started.” Ms. Page’s note described some difficulties she was having with arranging a job for STUDENT at Stumps Market because the market’s manager had been on vacation and because Ms. Page was having difficulty finding an instructional aide who was willing to drive STUDENT from TPHS in Encinitas to the market in Rancho Santa Fe. (Footnote 19) (Pet. Exh. p. 1318.) Ms. Page wrote to MOTHER that “if you want STUDENT to work at the movie theater in the Highlands, I can get that started sooner.” The note indicated that Ms. Page had enclosed the Workability documents for parent signature. FATHER’s signatures on the various Workability documents are dated December 8, 9 and 10, 2003. (Dist. Exh. 90.)
On or about January 13, 2004, STUDENT began working at her Workability job at Stumps Market for one hour per week. (Pet. Exh. p. 1331; Dist. Exh. 90.) In an entry in the parent-school communication log in February 2004, MOTHER asked Ms. Page about the plans for STUDENT’s participation in Workability, noting that STUDENT’s IEP called for more Workability hours than STUDENT was performing. (Pet. Exh. p. 1340.) In a lengthy response dated February 11, 2004, Ms. Page explained that she was not scheduling STUDENT for additional Workability hours beyond the one hour per week, both because the manager at Stumps Market indicated that the market did not need STUDENT more than one hour per week and because STUDENT did not have any more time for Workability in her schedule, in light of STUDENT’s attendance at three different elective classes. (Pet. Exh. p. 1362.) In describing these obstacles, Ms. Page wrote that she should not have increased STUDENT’s Workability hours in the May 2003 IEP “because I know I am now out of compliance.” (Id.) Ms. Page suggested that she could try to find STUDENT a different Workability job if MOTHER wanted, writing that “I can work on a new placement if you want & try to make it work w/her schedule & my staffing availability. Let me know what you think.” (Id.)
In a letter dated February 24, 2004, the general manager of Stumps Market, Matthew Basham, indicated that he sought to dispel any misperception that STUDENT might be an inconvenience or a disturbance at the market, and wrote that “we at Stump’s appreciate her help, and the owners would have no problem if STUDENT or the school district would like to increase her work day’s or hour’s.” [sic] (Pet. Exh. p. 642.)
In a log entry dated March 3, 2004, Ms. Page wrote to MOTHER that they might change STUDENT’s Workability location to the movie theater because the theater was “closer & will be easier to get her to. There will be no lapse in her job access & I will let you know before she works next week what is happening.” (Pet. Exh. p. 1366.) This change did not occur. STUDENT continued to work at her Workability job at Stumps Market for one hour per week through June 2004, and also worked several additional Workability hours during summer 2004. (Testimony of Ms. Nest, Judy Davis, Dist. Exh. 90.) Job placement assistant Judy Davis testified that Workability is a state-operated program that is available only during the regular school year. However, Ms. Davis explained that in some instances students may be permitted to work during the summer to make up Workability hours missed during the school year; Ms. Nest testified that this is what occurred for STUDENT.
Thus, from January to June 2004, STUDENT worked only one hour per week in the Workability program, although she made up some missed hours during summer 2004. (Testimony of Ms. Nest, Ms. Davis, MOTHER.) The implementation of Workability for only one hour per week beginning in January 2004, failed to implement the May 2003 IEP’s Goal #5, which provided that STUDENT would work in a job for one to hours per week by October 2003, two to three hours per week by January 2004, two to four hours per week by March 2004, and two to five hours per week by May 2004. Such circumstances were also inconsistent with the May 2003 IEP notes stating that STUDENT’s participation in Workability would increase from the prior year’s rate of one hour per week, and the ITP’s Workability goal of participation at a job in the community for two to five hours per week.
The District argued in its closing brief that the IEP’s provision for two to five hours per week was only a goal, not a required component of the program, and noted that the existence of an IEP goal does not guarantee that the goal will be met. While the District is correct that a student’s progress on a goal is not guaranteed, a nonconformity with an IEP can nevertheless occur if a school district fails to provide the instruction or services necessary to implement a goal. Hypothetically, had STUDENT been unable to perform the additional work hours, then that failure to achieve the goal would not have constituted a failure to conform with the IEP. However, that is not what occurred in this case; instead, the District did not implement the specified work hours that would have potentially allowed STUDENT to achieve the goal.
Notably, Ms. Page’s entries in the parent-school communication log indicate that logistical obstacles, such as STUDENT’s busy schedule, prevented the implementation of the Workability hours called for in Goal #5. (Pet. Exh. p. 1362.) While such obstacles may well have been legitimate, an IEP remains the ongoing placement until the parent and other IEP team members agrees upon changes. There is no evidence directly addressing why District staff did not seek to amend the IEP to reduce the Workability hours in light of the logistical difficulties Ms. Page described.
The District also argued that the delay in implementing the Workability program until January 2004 was caused by MOTHER’s refusal to consent to the movie theater as the job location instead of Stumps Market. The District points to the testimony of Ms. Nest that Ms. Page stated during a telephone conversation that MOTHER would not consent to the movie theater job for STUDENT. In contrast, MOTHER described in her testimony that she first heard Ms. Page mention the option of the movie theater job at a “back to school night” in October 2003. MOTHER acknowledged that she initially thought that she preferred Stumps Market as STUDENT’s work location, but tried to keep an open mind and did not reject the movie theater job. MOTHER’s testimony is supported by entries in the parent-school communication log. When Ms. Page mentioned the movie theater job in a parent-school communication log entry dated January 24, 2004, MOTHER wrote back that the movie theater option was “fine,” but that she would like to know more about it. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 1335, 1337.) Thus, the evidence indicates that MOTHER did not reject the possible implementation of the Workability job in the movie theater. While Ms. Nest was a credible witness, she did not have much reliable information on this particular topic because her knowledge of MOTHER’s actions was based upon a hearsay conversation with a third party.
In contrast, MOTHER was much more knowledgeable about her own actions regarding agreeing to the proposed job placement. Moreover, MOTHER’s description of her actions was consistent with her writings in the parent-school communication log. For these reasons, the Hearing Officer finds that MOTHER’s testimony was more credible on this point. Hence, the delay in implementing STUDENT’s Workability job until January 2004 was not due to MOTHER’s refusal to consent to allowing STUDENT to work at the movie theater.
Thus, the evidence established that the District’s program failed to provide a program in conformity with the May 2003 IEP goal for STUDENT to work two to five hours per week in a community job by May 2004. While there is no guarantee that STUDENT would have been able to perform the hours necessary to meet that goal, implementation of the IEP would have included making more hours available and beginning the implementation of Workability in fall 2003 instead of January 2004. While the program conformed to the IEP to the extent that STUDENT worked one hour per week from January to June 2004, and made up additional hours over the summer, the Workability aspect nevertheless failed to conform to the IEP to the extent that the remaining hours did not occur during the 2003-2004 school year and were not made up during the 2004 summer.
(3) Speech-Language Services
Petitioner contended that the District failed to consistently provide her individual speech and language services during the 2003-2004 school year. The May 2003 IEP provided for individual speech-language services of four thirty-minute sessions per week. (Pet. Exh. p. 600.) As with the 2002-2003 school year, Petitioner again argued that there were two areas of nonconformity: first, that the District failed to provide the amount of sessions required by her IEP and, second, that the District failed to provide her sessions on a one-to-one, individual basis as specified in the IEP.
The evidence concerning the individual speech-language sessions for the 2003-2004 is essentially the same as the evidence discussed regarding the 2002-2003 school year. Thus, regarding the contention that the District failed to provide the amount of sessions required by the IEP, Dr. Palmer testified that she provided individual speech-language services to STUDENT four times per week during STUDENT’s twelfth grade year, and detailed the variety of methods she used and topics they worked on. In rebuttal testimony on the last day of hearing, MOTHER testified that she had compared Dr. Palmer’s notations to a calendar, and determined that Dr. Palmer had missed several sessions. In her closing brief, Petitioner simply stated that she had received only 68 speech sessions instead of 148, but did not explain this calculation or point to other specifics to support that general assertion.
This Decision has already determined that the preponderance of evidence did not support Petitioner’s claim for the 2002-2003 school year. For the same reasons that were explained in that discussion, the Hearing Officer reaches the same conclusion for the 2003-2004 school year. As discussed above, Dr. Palmer was a very credible witness who had a clear, detailed recollection of the services she had provided. The general nature and frequency of Dr. Palmer’s notations were consistent with her testimony that she provided speech-language sessions to STUDENT four times per week. In contrast, while MOTHER was generally a credible witness, the bases for her opinion on this topic appeared to be based solely on some notations Dr. Palmer made to keep track of what STUDENT was working on, and it is not clear whether those notations constituted a comprehensive history of STUDENT’s speech-language sessions or whether the pages MOTHER relied upon were the entirety of Dr. Palmer’s notations. In light of all evidence, the Hearing Officer finds more persuasive Dr. Palmer’s testimony that she provided STUDENT with four weekly individual speech-language sessions in conformity with the IEP.
Regarding Petitioner’s argument that the individual speech-language services were not in conformity with the IEP because the sessions were not one-to-one, this Decision has already determined that to the extent that Dr. Palmer provided some speech-language sessions to STUDENT with another student present, those sessions were not “individual” as stated in the IEP. As Dr. Palmer explained, during approximately two out of STUDENT’s four weekly individual speech-language sessions another student was included in the sessions so that STUDENT could interact with a peer when practicing social scripts and articulation pursuant to her IEP goals.
However, as discussed above, Dr. Palmer testified that it was beneficial for STUDENT to have a peer to interact with when practicing social scripts. In a June 2002 progress report, Dr. Palmer noted that STUDENT “enjoys doing the social scripts with one of the peer assistants than with me.” (Pet. Exh. p. 579.) Dr. Palmer’s testimony, STUDENT’s speech-language progress reports, and the May 2003 IEP all reflect STUDENT’s progress on social scripts and expressive language. (Dist. Exhs. 4, 90.) Hence, the evidence again leads to the same conclusion that this nonconformity occurred for an educational purpose and did not have any negative effect on STUDENT’s education.
Moreover, as discussed further under Issue V, because the nonconformity had no negative effect on STUDENT’s education, there is no basis for awarding a remedy to compensate her for any denial of FAPE. In light of the nature of the nonconformity, the evidence again demonstrated that the nonconformity was minor and did not interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of a FAPE.
C. Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)
The components of STUDENT’s program for her senior year of high school were generally similar to those in her junior year. Pursuant to the May 2003 IEP, STUDENT again received instruction in math, English, and functional skills in an SDC taught by Rachel Page, and again attended general education for acting, band, and dance classes, and lunch. The DIS component of her program consisted of individual speech-language therapy four times per week for thirty minutes per session, group speech-language therapy once a week for sixty minutes per session, and OT for sixty minutes per month. Her program also included components such as ESY, transportation, aide support, and participation in an off-campus job through the Workability program. (Dist. Exh. 4.)
The parties generally cited the same evidence and raised the same arguments concerning STUDENT’s LRE for the 2003-2004 school year as they provided for the prior two school years, as discussed above. As with the prior school years, Petitioner asserted that her placement for the 2003-2004 school year was not in the LRE because she should have attended general education classes for most of her school day, with pull-out services for RSP and DIS. Petitioner reiterated that she gained significant benefit from interaction with nondisabled peers, while the District again maintained that STUDENT could not have received a satisfactory education if she had been placed in general education full-time with some RSP pull-out, because she required a more intense level of instruction and support.
While there was evidence of progress, there was no dispute that overall STUDENT continued to have needs in the same areas for the 2003-2004 school year as she had the prior school year. Thus, as this Decision determined regarding the prior school year, the District again established that the SDC offered much greater academic benefit to STUDENT than she could have received in general education high school math and English classes, and there was no evidence to the contrary. The SDC offered STUDENT the opportunity to receive intensive instruction and reinforce what she had learned using activities. In contrast, general education math and English classes would have offered far less academic benefit, because the opportunities for multi-modal reinforcement would have been much more limited and the level of academic instruction would have been difficult to modify to STUDENT’s level.
Moreover, because the level of instruction would have been so divergent from STUDENT’s functional skills curriculum, modification of the academic work would have entailed frequent one-to-one instruction, which would have had a negative impact on the non-academic benefits she could have received from integration with the typically developing peers in those classes. While there is no question that STUDENT benefitted from interacting with nondisabled peers, any such benefit she received would have been in addition to that from her three general education elective classes and lunch period.
As in the prior school year, STUDENT’s effect on the general education classroom was not a significant factor, because STUDENT had only positive effects on the general education teacher and students. Cost was again not a factor.
Considering all of the relevant LRE factors, the evidence again established that, the special education classroom was STUDENT’s LRE for her academic classes such as math, English and functional skills. The SDC offered significantly greater academic benefit for STUDENT’s instruction in academic areas related to her IEP goals and objectives. Considering that STUDENT’s participation in much of the instruction and discussion time in general education academic classes would have been limited by the necessary modification of the coursework to address her level, the incremental benefit of additional mainstreaming time for academic classes was outweighed by the academic benefits available to her in the SDC.
*********
To summarize this Decision’s findings regarding the 2003-2004 school year, the District’s program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit for the 2002-2003 school year. The District’s delivery of the program did not comport with the IEP to the extent that the District failed to provide the Workability hours necessary to implement STUDENT’s goal related to working in a job two to five hours per week. The IEP also failed to conform in a minor area concerning delivery of individual speech-language sessions while another student was present, but that nonconformity did not interfere with STUDENT’s receipt of a FAPE. Additionally, the District’s program was offered in the LRE.
IV. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
Preliminarily, it is notable that at the conclusion of the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT participated in TPHS graduation ceremonies and received a certificate of completion. However, STUDENT remained eligible for special education services and the District remained obligated to provide her with a FAPE. For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered STUDENT a placement in the Transition Program at Mira Costa College, a local community college.
For the 2004-2005 school year, Petitioner raised the same claims as she had raised for the prior school years concerning the District’s failure to design a program that addressed her unique needs, failure to offer a program reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, and failure to offer a program in the LRE. For the 2004-2005 school year, Petitioner added a contention that the program was not designed to address her unique needs because it failed to provide written language goals. Because the District’s offer was not accepted or implemented for the 2004-2005 school year, there are essentially no issues regarding failure to provide a program in conformity with the IEP.
A. Designed To Meet Unique Needs And Reasonably Calculated To Provide Educational Benefit
As with the prior school years, STUDENT continued to have the same general areas of need, despite some progress on her goals and objectives. The District’s May 2004 OT assessment noted in part that STUDENT continued to demonstrate difficulty with fine motor skills, but that she was able to perform man Hence, the absence of further detail in the May 2003 IEP document regarding STUDENT’s sight words did not render inaccurate the IEP’s present levels of performance. The May 2003 IEP’s present levels of performance in reading were accurate and contained sufficient information to allow the IEP team to develop appropriate goals and an appropriate program for STUDENT.
(b) Reading Goals
Regarding the reading goals in the May 2003 IEP, Petitioner argued that the goals did not sufficiently address developing her sight word vocabulary. However, the IEP contained a goal that STUDENT would “continue to develop her sight word vocabulary by identifying a list of 10 words from 3 different environments with 100% accuracy on 3/5 trials as measured by data records.” (Pet. Exh. p. 622.) As Dr. Palmer testified, this goal is measurable and was appropriate for STUDENT; there was no evidence to the contrary, and the Hearing Officer therefore finds that this was an appropriate goal to address STUDENT’s need to learn to read functional words in the community and daily living. Petitioner also argued that this goal was unclear because it did not specify what the sight words would be or which three environments the words would come from. There is no evidence to support Petitioner’s argument that the IEP goal must contain such specificity. For example, Dr. Palmer indicated that it would typically not be feasible to list specific sight words in STUDENT’s IEPs, and that instead teachers kept track of sight words in a notebook. The Hearing Officer finds Petitioner’s argument unpersuasive on this point, and concludes that the vocabulary goal was sufficiently clear.
The IEP also contained goals for STUDENT to learn and use at least twenty-five new vocabulary words per semester, to practice reading and writing skills by dictating a three-to-five-sentence paragraph based upon a picture prompt, to follow a visual (picture/word) check-off list for her grooming, and to identify the numbers one to twenty-five when presented in written form and match them to numeric form. (Footnote 18) (Pet. Exh. pgs. 610-633.) Dr. Palmer described how each of these were appropriate reading goals for STUDENT, because they addressed her need to read sight functional reading needs. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Considering all of the May 2003 IEP goals, the Hearing Officer finds that this IEP contained measurable goals to address STUDENT’s need to learn to read functional words in the community and daily living, and accordingly y functional fine motor skills in the classroom, such as cutting, copying numbers and letters, fastening buttons and zippers, and typing accurately at a rate of four words per minute. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 665-670; testimony of Ms. Bischke.) While STUDENT was able to dress herself independently and use the restroom independently, she did not look both ways before crossing the street and had difficulty cutting food with a knife and fork, although she could use those utensils correctly for spreading. (Id.) The present levels of performance in the May 2004 IEP indicated in part that STUDENT had made some gains in functional academics, such as identifying numbers 1-20, telling time to the half hour and quarter hour, identifying up to ten sight words common to particular environments such as school, and identifying community safety signs. (Dist. Exh. 2, p.3; see also testimony of Dr. Palmer.) There is no dispute that STUDENT continued to have deficits in the same areas, including academics, memory, auditory comprehension skills, speech, language, communication, motor skills and self-help/adaptive skills, nor that she continued to need to learn to read functional sight words, continued to have severe difficulties in reading, continued to need intensive services in reading, and continued to need speech-language therapy and OT.
For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered a placement in the Transition Program at Mira Costa College (Mira Costa), a local community college. The proposed program included DIS of OT and speech-language therapy, which STUDENT would receive at the school site, and transportation. The IEP document indicated that STUDENT would spend all of her school day in special education. (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 1.) The offer also included placement at the transition program for the 2004 ESY to facilitate STUDENT’s transition to the program for the following school year. The IEP notes indicated that the Mira Costa Transition Program would “focused on community skills, vocational skills, recreational skills and functional academics.” (Pet. Exh. p. 758.) The Mira Costa Transition Program teacher, Mary Jeanette Lindebak, described how the program primarily addressed the areas of communication, social/emotional skills, vocational skills, self-care/independent living, gross motor skills/mobility, and functional academics . (See Dist. Exhs. 87, 88.) The transition program class consisted of twelve students, ages eighteen to twenty-two, all of whom were severely disabled. Ms. Lindebak taught the class with the assistance of four aides.
Petitioner argued that the May 2004 IEP’s present levels of performance were insufficient and the IEP goals were inappropriate in the areas of reading, receptive language, written language, and OT. Petitioner again alleged that the program failed to address her needs in the areas of reading and length of school day.
(1) IEP Goals and Present Levels of Performance (a) Present Levels of Performance in Reading
Petitioner argued that the May 2004 IEP’s present levels of performance were inadequate because they failed to specify which ten sight words STUDENT could read. Petitioner pointed to MOTHER’s testimony that she had repeatedly asked for a list of STUDENT’s sight words, but that the District did not provide this list until July 22, 2004. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 763-764.) Similar to this Decision’s findings on present levels of performance in the May 2003 IEP, there was again no evidence to establish that such information needed to be included in the IEP document for the IEP team members could draft appropriate goals and objectives for STUDENT. Instead, Dr. Palmer explained that it was not feasible to include that level of detail in the IEP’s present levels of performance, and instead the records of what specific words STUDENT was working on were kept in a notebook by the SDC teacher. Dr. Palmer also testified that the May 2004 IEP contained sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s present levels of performance for the IEP team to draft goals and create an appropriate program.
Hence, the absence of further detail in the May 2004 IEP document regarding STUDENT’s sight words did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
(b) Reading Goals
Petitioner contended that the May 2004 IEP’s reading goals were inadequate. The May 2004 IEP contained a vocational goal to “use picture symbol and/or sight word materials to complete certain responsibilities in her community setting.” (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 6.) Dr. Palmer explained that this goal worked on STUDENT’s vocational skills for reading and was appropriate to address STUDENT’s reading needs related to vocational skills. The IEP also contained a vocabulary goal that STUDENT would learn and use thirty new vocabulary words per semester, but the goal did not entail STUDENT learning or practicing reading any words. (Pet. Exh. p. 684.) Additionally, the ITP had a functional skills goal with activities such as making a shopping list and locating items in a store. (Pet. Exh. p. 686.)
As discussed in several sections above, the evidence established that STUDENT needed to be able to read functional words in the community so that she could read signs and participate in post-graduation activities such as employment. Yet none of the reading goals measured STUDENT’s progress on reading functional words in the community, despite the testimony of District witnesses that STUDENT needed a program for functional sight words. The District also points to the evidence concerning how the Mira Costa program addresses reading, including the testimony of the Mira Costa teacher, Mary Jeanette Lindebak. As discussed below, Ms. Lindebak and the materials describing the Mira Costa program established that the program offered STUDENT the functional reading instruction and practice that she needed. However, the evidence that the reading services would have been appropriate is not germane to the analysis of whether the reading goals are sufficient. The absence of sufficient reading goals indicates that the program was not designed to address her unique needs or reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit in this area.
(c) Receptive Language Goals
Petitioner again argued that the IEP lacked receptive language goals in oral comprehension, memory, recalling information, or vocabulary. This Decision has already determined that STUDENT did not need goals targeted to memory or recalling information. Regarding vocabulary, the May 2004 IEP contained a vocabulary goal for STUDENT to learn and use at least thirty new vocabulary words per semester. Dr. Palmer testified that this goal would have addressed STUDENT’s need to develop her vocabulary, and there was no evidence to the contrary. Regarding oral comprehension, the May 2004 IEP contained a speech-language goal of correctly using social scripts in structured settings without prompting. Dr. Palmer explained that the speech-language pathologist for the Mira Costa program had described how they would role-play a social script in class, then use it in an actual setting such as a store. Dr. Palmer gave persuasive testimony that this goal would address STUDENT’s oral comprehension needs, and there was no evidence to the contrary. Thus, because the IEP contained appropriate receptive language goals in vocabulary and oral comprehension, and did not need to contain goals in memory or recalling information, the receptive language goals did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
(d) Written Language Goals
Petitioner alleged that the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year denied her a FAPE because the May 2004 IEP did not contain any written language goals. The May 2004 IEP did not contain any writing goals, although the ITP attached to that IEP contained a functional skills goal that included activities such as making a shopping list. (Dist. Exh. 4.) The District acknowledged that the May 2004 IEP lacked written language goals, but argued that STUDENT did not need a written language goal to address her needs or to receive educational benefit.
The May 2003 IEP contained a reading/writing goal that STUDENT would dictate a three to five sentence paragraph based on a picture prompt or when given a choice among two to three topics, to be written or typed by STUDENT after dictation. (Dist. Exh. 4.) A November 2003 progress report indicated that STUDENT had made partial progress on the goal and performed the task with 60 percent accuracy in two out of five trials. (Dist. Exh. 72, p. 2.) The May 2004 IEP found that STUDENT had made substantial progress on this goal, but still needed prompting for sentence structure. (Dist. Exh. 72, p. 11; see also testimony of Dr. Palmer.)
Ms. Lindebak testified that, while the May 2004 IEP did not contain a writing goal, STUDENT’s writing needs would still be addressed by the ITP goal and by the Mira Costa Transition Program. Ms. Lindebak indicated that she would be able to measure STUDENT’s progress in writing through work samples and inform STUDENT’s parents about this progress through progress reports. Ms. Lindebak described how the program included functional writing instruction three to four times per week. Ms. Lindebak’s testimony and the course description of the program identified functional writing activities such as filling out job applications and writing resumes. (Dist. Exh. 87.)
While Ms. Lindebak was a credible witness, her testimony on this point did not persuasively rebut Petitioner’s claim that she required a writing goal for the 2004-2005 school year. Given that writing was one of STUDENT’s areas of need, and that the District has the burden of proof on this issue, the Hearing Officer finds that the lack of a writing goal constituted a failure to design a program to address STUDENT’s unique needs.
(e) OT Goals: Balance and Community Safety
As this Decision determined regarding the prior school years, the testimony of licensed occupational therapist Joy Bischke established that STUDENT did not need OT goals in balance because, despite some weaknesses with balance and coordination, STUDENT could walk around a school campus without problem. Regarding community safety, this Decision has already found that community safety was not part of what occupational therapists worked on with students in OT. While STUDENT needed to learn about community safety, other aspects of the Mira Costa program addressed that area. Mira Costa teacher Mary Jeanette Lindebak described how the Mira Costa students go on outings several times per week, during which they learn and practice how to function safely in the community. Both Ms. Lindebak’s testimony and the course description for the Mira Costa program reported that the program addresses community safety needs, such as street safety. (Dist. Exh. 87.) Thus, the OT goals did not need to include instruction in balance and community safety, and the lack of those goals did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
(f) OT Goals: Functional Fine Motor Skills
Petitioner again contended that the District failed to provide the goals she needed to address her unique needs in functional fine motor skills. This Decision has already determined that functional fine motor skills were an area of need for STUDENT. In the May 2004 OT assessment, Ms. Bischke found in part that while STUDENT still had delays in fine motor skills, nevertheless she was able to perform many functional fine motor skills in the classroom, such as cutting, copying numbers and letters, dressing herself, fastening buttons and zippers, using the restroom independently, and typing accurately at a rate of four words per minute. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 666, 670; testimony of Ms. Bischke.) Ms. Bischke’s assessment report noted that STUDENT had difficulty cutting food with a knife and fork, although she could use those utensils correctly for spreading. (Pet. Exh. p. 666.) The May 2004 IEP’s present levels of performance similarly reported how STUDENT could perform many functional fine motor skill tasks by herself. (Pet. Exh. p. 731.) As a result of the OT assessment, the May 2004 IEP included a goal to cut with a knife and fork appropriately. (Pet. Exh. p. 741.)
Ms. Bischke testified that for the 2004-2005 school year, STUDENT did not need additional functional fine motor goals because she could already perform many functional fine motor activities on her own, as described in the May 2004 OT assessment report. Ms. Bischke explained that, like STUDENT’s SDC at TPHS, the Mira Costa program incorporated functional fine motor activities within the program, such as using computers, handling money, and writing lists and schedules. These activities are consistent with the written course description of the SDC. (Dist. Exh. 87.)
Hence, the evidence established that STUDENT did not require additional goals in functional fine motor skills. Accordingly, the District’s offer was designed to address STUDENT’s needs regarding functional fine motor skills for the 2004-2005 school year.
*********
Thus, this Decision has determined that the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year was not designed to address her unique needs to the extent that the May 2004 IEP lacked sufficient goals in reading and writing. The remainder of the disputed IEP goals, in receptive language and OT, addressed STUDENT’s unique needs and did not constitute a denial of FAPE.
(2) Program Offer
As with the prior school years, for the 2004-2005 school year Petitioner alleged that the District’s program failed to address her needs regarding reading and the length of her school day. Petitioner also contended that the offer denied her a FAPE because it reduced the amount of speech-language and OT services for the 2004-2005 school year, compared to prior years.
(a) Reading Instruction
Petitioner reiterated her claim that the District’s reading program was inappropriate because it did not did not entail the strategies and instruction that she needed to receive educational benefit. Petitioner asserted that the program did not address her needs because it failed to “address STUDENT’s unique reading needs in the area of transition services, particularly in preparation for supported employment and independent living after graduation” and lacked “constant reinforcement and instruction in reading fundamentals, including in the areas of sight words, phonics, sound-symbol relations, comprehension, spelling, and memory issues.” Petitioner again also alleged that the District’s program failed to meet her reading needs related to transition, and the Decision again considers this claim within the entire analysis of the reading component of STUDENT’s educational program.
This Decision has already determined that STUDENT’s unique reading needs would have been appropriately addressed by a functional sight word program geared towards recognizing words STUDENT would need in everyday life, such as reading safety words in the community and words in the grocery store. The course description of the Mira Costa Transition Program indicates that the program’s functional reading and writing curriculum includes “job applications, resumes, rules and regulations, danger zones, safeguards, paycheck words and vocabulary, bus routes, street signs, restaurant signs and words, budgeting words and vocabulary.” (Dist. Exh. 87.) Ms. Lindebak testified that the program’s reading curriculum consisted of instruction and practice in functional reading, such as job-related words, safety words, words on a paycheck, orwords on a menu. Ms. Lindebak testified that the program’s functional reading instruction would be appropriate to address STUDENT’s unique needs in reading. Considering also the prior findings regarding STUDENT’s reading needs, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Lindebak’s testimony persuasive on this topic.
Likewise, the evidence indicated that the District’s program offered significant reinforcement and repetition in her reading instruction. Ms. Lindebak described how she and the program’s instructional aides will often first teach the words in the classroom, with methods such as role-playing exercises or flash cards, then will take the students on outings for generalization and practical application of the words in real-world settings. Ms. Lindebak noted other methodology used as part of the reading instruction, including reading the modified newspaper “News-To-You” and reading social scripts during group speech-language instruction. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Lindebak’s testimony persuasive, and there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary.
Thus, the functional reading program in the Mira Costa Transition Program was appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit.
(b) Assistive Technology in Reading
As in the prior school years, Petitioner again argued that the District did not utilize assistive technology in the manner she needed to receive educational benefit, specifically that the District failed to provide appropriate assistive technology, including computer software, annual goals, or a systematic approach to measure her present levels of performance and progress in reading.
This Decision has already determined that, while computer software programs were useful tools in working on STUDENT’s goal areas, there was no evidence that she needed additional assistive technology to address her needs to allow educational benefit. Similarly, this Decision has already found that STUDENT did not need to have her reading progress tracked by assistive technology, nor did she require that her progress on particular computer programs be tracked. Dr. Palmer testified that the May 2004 IEP’s present levels of performance and baselines provided the information that the IEP team needed to draft an appropriate program and goals, and there was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. Accordingly, the District’s offer included appropriate measures of STUDENT’s progress on her goals, and tracking by assistive technology was not required.
(c) Length of School Day
Petitioner’s statement of issues identified claims that the District “denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide her a full school day for the 2001-2002 through 2004-2005 school years.” As this Decision discussed for the previous school years, the basis for this claim when STUDENT was at TPHS was that she was dismissed from class shortly after 2:00 p.m., instead of at 2:30 p.m., which was the official end of the school day. However, both at the hearing and in Petitioner’s closing brief, there was no allegation or evidence that STUDENT would have received early dismissal during the 2004-2005 school year. For the 2004-2005 school year, the District offered placement at the Mira Costa Transition Program; there was no allegation or indication that STUDENT would be dismissed early from this program. (Footnote 20) The IEP stated that STUDENT’s school day would be six hours per day, and Ms. Lindebak likewise testified that instructional day for the transition program is 9:00 a.m. to 3:00 p.m., five days per week. (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 1.) Hence, it appears that either this claim was identified in error or Petitioner abandoned the claim. In any event, there was no denial of FAPE due to failure to provide a full school day for the 2004-2005 school year.
(d) Amount of Speech-Language Services
Petitioner argued that the District’s offer denied her a FAPE because it offered her less speech-language services than she had received in her previous IEPs. The May 2004 IEP offered STUDENT two individual speech-language sessions per week, for thirty minutes per session. The transition program included group speech-language therapy once a week for all of the students in the class. (Testimony of Ms. Lindebak.)
Dr. Palmer explained that there were two reasons why she recommended that STUDENT’s speech-language services be reduced to sixty minutes per week. First, she believed that STUDENT needed to apply what she had learned over the years by interacting more with other students and individuals in the community. Dr. Palmer explained that she wanted to fade the direct speech-language instruction somewhat so that STUDENT could start implementing in the community what she had learned during her years of individual speech-language instruction. Second, Dr. Palmer explained that STUDENT would be working on speech throughout the day in the Mira Costa Transition Program because the program was highly language-based, with language instruction and reinforcement incorporated into the program. Dr. Palmer indicated that she had observed the Mira Costa Transition Program and was familiar with the program.
This Decision has already found that Dr. Palmer was a persuasive and credible witness. Moreover, there was no evidence to the contrary regarding the amount of individual speech-language services that STUDENT needed. Therefore, the reduction in speech-language services to sixty minutes per week for the 2004-2005 school year did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
(e) Amount of OT Services
Petitioner alleged that the District denied her a FAPE because it offered her fewer minutes of OT services than she had received in previous school years. The May 2004 IEP offered direct OT services for thirty minutes per month and OT consultation services for fifteen minutes per month. Petitioner presented no evidence regarding how much OT service STUDENT needed, but argued that the amount offered was insufficient because the IEP had only one OT goal and STUDENT had previously received sixty minutes of OT services per month.
Ms. Bischke testified that this amount of OT services was appropriate in light of STUDENT’s attendance at the Mira Costa Transition Program. Ms. Bischke explained that she usually does not provide direct OT services to students in the transition program, because it is more effective to provide OT consultation so that the staff members working with the students can implement the OT instruction and modifications throughout the entire school day. Ms. Bischke further stated that the teacher in that program was already very knowledgeable about OT areas and already worked on OT within the class, such as instruction related to gross motor skills, fine motor skills, and independent living. Consistent with that testimony, the course description for the transition program identifies gross motor development and independent living as specific areas covered in the curriculum. (Dist. Exh. 87.) The course description does not identify fine motor skills by name, but lists areas of instruction that would certainly incorporate fine motor skills, such as writing, self-care skills, and counting money. (Id.)
As noted previously, Ms. Bischke was a persuasive and credible witness. Moreover, there was no evidence to the contrary regarding the amount of OT services that STUDENT needed. Therefore, the reduction in OT services to forty-five minutes per week for the 2004-2005 school year did not deny STUDENT a FAPE.
*********
Accordingly, while this Decision determined that the IEP goals were inappropriate to the extent that they failed to include sufficient reading and writing goals, this Decision has further determined that the program offered for the 2004-2005 school year was otherwise designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to allow her to receive educational benefit.
B. Conformity With IEP
Given that the District’s offer for the 2004-2005 school year was not agreed upon and therefore not implemented, any nonconformity with the IEP appears unlikely. Petitioner’s statement of issues identified a claim that the District “denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to provide an adjustable chair as required by her IEPs for the 2001-2002 through 2004-2005 school years.” The May 2004 IEP identified a “modified chair and footstool to increase stability while sitting” as a supplemental aid for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 2, p. 2.) The IEP did not contain any provision for an adjustable chair. In any event, as with the issue concerning the length of Petitioner’s school day for the 2004-2005 school year, there were no allegations or evidence, either at hearing or in Petitioner’s closing brief, indicating that this issue was applicable for this school year. Moreover, there was no allegation or evidence that STUDENT would not have received a modified chair had she attended the Mira Costa Transition Program. (Footnote 21) Thus, there was no evidence of nonconformity with the IEP.
C. Least Restrictive Environment (LRE)
Petitioner alleged that the offer for the 2004-2005 school year was not in the LRE because the offer was for STUDENT to spend 100 percent of her time in special education. Petitioner instead argued that STUDENT should have been placed in a general education setting on a high school campus, with some pull-out for RSP and DIS. In contrast, the District argued that the program would have provided STUDENT with frequent and extensive interaction with nondisabled peers, and that STUDENT needed to learn functional and independent living skills by practicing and applying those skills in real-world settings, which is an essential component of the transition program. Moreover, the District argued that remaining on a high school campus would have denied STUDENT the opportunity to interact with nondisabled students in her peer group because, since STUDENT was nineteen years old during the 2004-2005 school year, the students on a high school campus would have been too young to be STUDENT’s peers.
As this Decision found for previous school years, only two of the four Rachel H. factors are at issue in considering STUDENT’s LRE: (1) the academic benefits available to the disabled student in a regular classroom, supplemented with appropriate aids and services, as compared with the academic benefits of a special education classroom, and (2) the non-academic benefits of interaction with nondisabled peers. As discussed previously, STUDENT’s effect on the teacher and other students in the general education classroom was essentially not a factor, because STUDENT had only positive impacts on the other individuals in the classroom. Additionally, cost was not a factor. Notably, it bears repeating that the law has a preference for mainstreaming and, to the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities shall be educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment should occur only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code § 56364.2.)
Initially, this Decision has already determined regarding previous school years that a special education placement for academic instruction offered significantly greater educational benefit than a full-time general education placement, and that benefit was not offset by the nonacademic benefits of interacting with nondisabled peers for academic instruction. As discussed above, STUDENT’s participation in much of the instruction and discussion time in general education academic classes would have been limited by the necessary modification of the coursework to address her level. Thus, the incremental benefit of additional mainstreaming time for academic classes was outweighed by the academic benefits of academic instruction in an SDC setting. Given that STUDENT continued to have generally the same needs for the 2004-2005 school year, this analysis remains applicable. Hence, the academic benefits of the Mira Costa Transition Program outweigh whatever greater nonacademic benefit STUDENT might have received in a full-time general education high school setting with special education instruction of pull-out RSP and DIS.
The more difficult question is whether the placement offered at the Mira Costa Transition Program would have addressed STUDENT’s unique needs in the LRE when compared with the type of high school placement she previously received, i.e., attendance at a general education high school with mainstreaming for lunch and three general education elective classes per day, and academic instruction in an SDC-type setting for the remaining fifty percent of her school day. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will consider how the two relevant LRE factors compared in both potential placements for the 2004-2005 school year.
First, regarding the academic benefits, evidence about the Mira Costa Transition Program indicated that the program would be an excellent fit for STUDENT’s academic and functional needs. For example, this Decision has already determined that STUDENT needs to learn functional academics and skills, such as reading signs, schedules, words related to daily living, and other functional words in the community. The evidence detailing the transition program indicated the program emphasized instruction and practice in functional reading. Indeed, STUDENT’s areas of unique need closely follow the curriculum areas and skills identified in the transition program’s general course description for all students: functional academics, communication, social/emotional, vocational, self-care/independent living, and motor skills/mobility. (Footnote 22) (Dist. Exh. 87.) Moreover, this Decision has already found persuasive the testimony of District witnesses who explained that STUDENT learns best by performing an activity that applies what she has learned, instead of just hearing or seeing the thing she is trying to learn. (See testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Nest.) The Mira Costa Transition Program would thus have been particularly well-suited to address STUDENT’s needs, because the program emphasized learning by doing, in particular by learning and applying skills in community settings. (See testimony of Ms. Lindebak.)
In comparison, the academic benefits of an SDC placement with some mainstreaming were also substantial, as this Decision has described in detail for previous school years. STUDENT made educational gains in many areas during her high school years; those gains included more intelligible speech, more complex expressive language, increased recognition of signs, symbols, and sight words, improved self-help/adaptive skills, and improvements in social behavior. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Bischke; Dist. Exh. 2, p. 3; Pet. Exh. pgs. 665-670.) However, there was little evidence that continuing attendance at a high school offered greater academic benefit than the Mira Costa Transition Program. Dr. Palmer and Ms. Nest persuasively testified that a continued high school placement would have offered less academic benefit, both because STUDENT had already received the academic benefits that a high school program had to offer and because, with only a few years of special education eligibility remaining, STUDENT needed to work more intensively on learning functional skills in real-world settings, in anticipation of post-graduation activities such as employment and independent living. In light of these factors, and considering the myriad academic benefits available to STUDENT in the Mira Costa Transition Program, the Hearing Officer finds that the transition program offered greater academic benefit than a high school program with a combination of SDC instruction and mainstreaming would have.
Second, this Decision must compare the non-academic benefits of interaction with nondisabled peers at the proposed special education placement with the non-academic benefits of such interaction in a high school placement. This Decision has already determined that STUDENT benefitted from interaction with typically developing peers, and there is no question that she could have participated in general education elective classes and other activities with nondisabled peers during the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. Lindebak testified that the transition program offered many opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers because the program was on a general education community college campus. Ms. Lindebak described how STUDENT would have had opportunities to interact with typically developing peers during lunch and other social activities on the campus, at the library, in a general education college class, and on community outings to the nearby YMCA and other destinations.
STUDENT’s parents both reported that they had tried to locate an appropriate college class for STUDENT to take at the Mira Costa campus where the transition program was located, but that none were available. FATHER testified that the Mira Costa course catalog listed only one daytime class, music appreciation, that might be appropriate for STUDENT. FATHER stated that the course catalog did not offer any cooking, acting or art classes that might be appropriate. FATHER noted that the catalog listed an all-day ceramics class, but STUDENT could not safely use a ceramic oven, nor did she have the stamina to attend a class for that long. Both FATHER and MOTHER testified that STUDENT had tried taking a general education dance class at Mira Costa, but the pace of the class was too fast for STUDENT and the class met at night, when STUDENT was tired. FATHER testified that evening classes were not appropriate for STUDENT because she ordinarily gets tired and goes to bed at 7:00 p.m. Dr. and MOTHER indicated that there were other classes that might be appropriate for STUDENT, but those were located on a different Mira Costa campus.
While the testimony of the PARENTS was credible, Ms. Lindebak was more familiar with the courses available at Mira Costa because she teaches there and has assisted in locating appropriate general education classes for the students in her program. Ms. Lindebak testified that her students have taken general education classes such as painting, keyboarding, aerobics, and computer literacy; however, there was no specific evidence as to whether STUDENT could have participated in any of those classes.
MOTHER also testified that she believed a high school setting would offer greater social benefits to STUDENT because it offered more opportunities for mainstreaming and because high school students could provide more equal-level, peer relationships to STUDENT. MOTHER also pointed out that a high school setting offered a more cohesive social group where STUDENT could have developed friendships, whereas the student population at Mira Costa was more fractured, with students who do not spend the majority of their day on campus.
In contrast, the District argued that, since STUDENT was nineteen years old during the 2004-2005 school year, high school no longer offered an appropriate peer group for STUDENT because the other students were too young to be her peers. (Testimony of Dr. Palmer, Ms. Nest, Ms. Lindebak.) Dr. Palmer testified that the adult students at the community college would have been more appropriate peer models for STUDENT, instead of the less-mature high school students. Consequently, the evidence was mixed regarding the nonacademic benefits of interaction with typically developing peers in each setting. While the Mira Costa Transition Program offered less opportunity for interaction with nondisabled peers than a general education high school placement would have offered, the community college students would have been a more age-appropriate peer group. Moreover, the students with disabilities in the Mira Costa Transition Program would have been age-appropriate peers for STUDENT, whereas her classmates in a high school SDC generally would not have been. However, the Mira Costa placement would have been better for STUDENT if it had included more opportunities for interaction with typically developing peers, or if there was absolute certainty that at least one appropriate general education elective class existed for STUDENT to take each semester.
Next, in conjunction with that evidence regarding nonacademic benefits of interaction with nondisabled peers, the Hearing Officer must weigh the evidence of academic benefits available in each setting. As discussed above, the evidence established that the academic benefits of the Mira Costa Transition Program were greater than the academic benefits STUDENT could have received in a high school SDC with DIS and mainstreaming for lunch and electives. When combined with the evidence regarding the nonacademic benefits available in each setting, the weight of evidence establishes that the Mira Costa Transition Program offered greater benefits overall for STUDENT’s education. While the transition program would not have offered as much interaction with typically developing peers, it would have offered greater academic benefit and interaction with an age-appropriate peer group. In light of the findings discussed herein, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of the Mira Costa Transition program was in STUDENT’s LRE to address her unique needs and allow her to receive educational benefit for the 2004-2005 school year.
*********
In summary, to the extent that the District’s program for the 2004-2005 school year failed to include sufficient reading and writing goals, the program was not designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs and was not reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit. In all other respects, the District’s program for the 2004-2005 school year was appropriate because it was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, was reasonably calculated to confer educational benefit, was in conformity with her IEP and was in the LRE.
V. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to compensatory occupational therapy services to address her fine and gross motor skills, compensatory speech and language services to address her receptive language skills, additional Workability hours, and compensatory instruction to address her reading skills?
Compensatory education is an equitable remedy which may be available when the school district has denied the student a FAPE. (Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489, 1497 (9th Cir. 1994).) In fashioning appropriate equitable relief the conduct of both parties should be reviewed, along with the nature of relief requested, to determine whether an award of compensatory education is appropriate. (Id.) Courts have explained that the purpose of compensatory relief is to replace lost educational services and ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA. (Student W. at 1497; Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991); Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (8th Cir. 1996).) There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. (Student W. at 1497.)
The Hearing Officer determined in this Decision that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, to the extent that the May 2001 IEP failed to include sufficient reading goals. Similarly, the Hearing Officer held that the October 2002 IEP lacked sufficient reading and vocabulary goals, and the IEP for the 2004-2005 school years failed to include sufficient reading or written language goals. Additionally, the Hearing Officer found that the District had denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year to the limited extent that the amount of Workability hours that were made available to STUDENT fell short of the hours called for in her IEP, which constituted a nonconformity with the IEP.
In considering a remedy for the absence of those goals, it is very important to note that, as this Decision has already determined, the District’s programs otherwise delivered appropriate services to STUDENT in reading, writing, and vocabulary. Moreover, considering her cognitive level, STUDENT made progress in those areas over the course of her attendance at TPHS. (See testimony of Dr. Palmer; Dist. Exhs. 2, 72, 92.) For example, Dr. Palmer described how, by twelfth grade, STUDENT was more efficient at remembering words, recognized more sight words, and could answer more “wh” questions.
Additionally, regarding the goals in the 2002-2003 school year, the Hearing Officer considers that the District initially offered appropriate reading and vocabulary goals at the IEP team meeting on May 14, 2002. (See Dist. Exh. 7.) Dr. Palmer testified that these goals in the May 2002 IEP would have addressed STUDENT’s needs in vocabulary and functional reading, and there was no evidence to the contrary. The IEP notes of October 17, 2002, state that “parents requested a review and revision of IEP goals and objectives from May 14, 2002 IEP,” and “parent disagrees with goals & objectives from May 14, 2002, student was not represented at that meeting.” (Dist. Exh. 6.) In light of the inclusion of these goals in May 2002 IEP, and the notations that the parents disagreed with the May 2002 IEP goals, the obvious conclusion is that the IEP team agreed to remove the goals upon the parents’ request. Under such circumstances, equitable considerations warrant reduction of the remedy awarded to compensate Petitioner for the District’s failure to include the appropriate reading and vocabulary goals in the October 2002 IEP.
Considering all of the above, the Hearing Officer awards Petitioner a total of thirty hours of compensatory education services of one-to-one tutoring in reading and writing, to be delivered by the District during the 2005-2006 school year. However, the District may provide the services through one of its credentialed employees, and is not required to utilize a nonpublic agency, nonpublic school or other outside provider to deliver the services.
Next, regarding the District’s failure to make Workability hours available in conformity with the May 2003 IEP during the 2003-2004 school year, the Hearing Officer will award additional Workability hours as compensatory services. The IEP’s Goal #5 stated that by May 2004, STUDENT would “work in a community job setting for 2-5 hours a week (depending on need of placement) using a time card system to independently sign in/out, record job duties, and the date with 100% accuracy on 3/5 trials.” (Pet. Exh. p. 619) That goal’s first benchmark/short-term objective stated that by October 2003, STUDENT would work in a community job setting for one to two hours per week, achieving a seventy percent accuracy rate for her use of a time card and her recording of work date and duties. (Id.) The second benchmark, to be met by January 2004, increased the hours per week to two to three and increased her accuracy rate to eighty percent, while the final benchmark increased the hours per week to two to four and her accuracy rate to ninety percent by March 2004. (Id.) The ITP also contained a Workability goal which stated that STUDENT would “participate in community job 2-5x/week (depending on site need).” (Pet. Exh. p. 630.)
Assuming that STUDENT made substantial progress on the IEP’s Goal #5, STUDENT would have worked one hour of Workability per week from mid-September through October 2003, two hours per week from November 2003 through January 2004, three hours per week from February 2004 through March 2004, and four hours per week from April 2004 to May 14, 2004. (Dist. Exh. 4, p. 11.) This would have been a total of approximately seventy-seven hours for the 2003-2004 school year. This calculation assumes that STUDENT would not have participated in Workability during school vacations or during the first two weeks of the school year, given the evidence that Workability placement required some “start-up” time to arrange the job placement, transportation, work permits, and similar details. (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 10; Dist. Exh. 90, pgs. 1-4; Pet. Exh. p. 1318.)
However, the District made available only one hour of Workability per week from January to June 2004, and additional compensatory hours during summer 2004. This amount totaled approximately twenty-eight hours. (Dist. Exh. 90; Pet. Exh. p. 1686-1687.)
To compensate for this shortfall, the Hearing Officer awards an additional forty-nine hours of Workability, to be delivered during the 2005-2006 school year. Notably, separate from any settlement offer, at the hearing the District already offered to provide an additional sixty hours of Workability. (Dist. Exh. 95.) That offer of services may be utilized to provide the compensatory Workability hours ordered herein. If STUDENT’s parents have accepted that offer and the District has begun providing those Workability hours, the District may deduct the hours already delivered from the forty-nine hours of compensatory Workability hours.
There were no other findings of denials of FAPE, and thus no basis for further compensatory awards.
VI. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to reimbursement for the cost of reading tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center?
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services were appropriate under the IDEA and replaced services that the school district failed to provide. (School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Education (1985) 471 U.S. 359, 369-370; Student W. v. Puyallup School District (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(10)(C)(1997).) However, parents are not required to have procured an exact proper placement under IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. (Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education (5th Cir. 1986) 79 F.2d 1153, 1161.) In addition, equitable considerations may be considered in granting relief, and courts have broad discretion in granting relief. (Burlington, supra; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, supra.)
In the present case, the Hearing Officer has already awarded compensatory services to remedy the limited denials of FAPE. The Hearing Officer finds that the awards of compensatory services sufficiently compensate STUDENT for the denials of FAPE, and further finds that reimbursement is not warranted.
ORDER
1. The District must provide STUDENT with thirty hours of compensatory reading and writing instruction via one-to-one tutoring. The IEP team shall plan that STUDENT’s receipt of those thirty compensatory hours be completed no later than June 30, 2006.
2. The District must provide STUDENT with forty-nine hours of compensatory Workability time awarded herein, less any Workability hours already provided pursuant to the District’s offer at hearing of sixty additional Workability hours. The IEP team shall plan that STUDENT’s receipt of the compensatory Workability hours be completed no later than June 30, 2006.
3. For these awards of compensatory education, the District may provide the services using it own staff or may contract with outside providers, but is not required to utilize outside providers.
4. All of Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement:
I. Did the District deny STUDENT a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 2001-2002 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that failed to offer appropriate reading goals.
II. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that failed to offer appropriate reading and vocabulary goals.
III. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that it failed to provide sufficient Workability hours in conformity with the IEP.
IV. Did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year?
The District prevailed on this issue, except to the limited extent that failed to offer appropriate reading goals or a written language goal.
V. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the years at issue, is she entitled to compensatory occupational therapy services to address her fine and gross motor skills, compensatory speech and language services to address her receptive language skills, additional Workability hours, and compensatory instruction to address her reading skills?
Petitioner prevailed to the limited extent that she is entitled to thirty hours of compensatory instruction in reading and writing. Petitioner also prevailed to the limited extent that she is entitled to additional Workability hours to compensate for the hours she missed; however, the Decision ordered fewer hours than the District had already offered at the hearing. The District prevailed on the remainder of this issue.
VI. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE, is she entitled to reimbursement for the cost of reading tutoring services at the Sylvan Learning Center?
The District prevailed on this issue.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).)
Dated: July 29, 2005 ____________________________________ Suzanne B. Brown, Hearing officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1 During the hearing, Petitioner withdrew as an issue her allegation that the District failed to provide educational records in a timely manner pursuant to requirements of the California Education Code.
2 On March 21, 2002, the Hearing Office received from STUDENT’s mother a due process request. That request stated in part that STUDENT’s band teacher failed to provide STUDENT with taped music as required by her IEP, and that the math and English assignments given to STUDENT in the SDC were not appropriate for her academic level. (Pet. Exh. p. 519-520.) The Hearing Office later dismissed that due process request for lack of activity. (Dist. Exh. 80.) There was no evidence of any settlement agreement between the parties regarding any of the issues raised in that due process request.
3 STUDENT participated in band at the District’s Earl Warren Middle School.
4 Ms. Bischke noted that, even if a student had needs related to ambulation on campus, those issues would typically be addressed by a physical therapist, not an occupational therapist.
5 Petitioner’s issues for hearing did not include any claims regarding APE.]
6 Ms. Bischke explained that occupational therapy covered areas such as gross and fine motor skills, bilateral coordination, motor planning and praxis, sensory processing, grooming and self-help skills.
7 STUDENT reportedly did not attend the SDC’s community outings because her parents did not consent to her participation, and therefore she was not able to practice community safety skills during those outings. (See testimony of MOTHER, Ms. Bischke, Dr. Palmer.) MOTHER testified that she had expressed a preference that STUDENT use school time to attend school, since STUDENT already participated in community outings with her family.
8 Petitioner did not raise any issues regarding community safety instruction outside of OT.
9 In her closing brief, Petitioner points out that the May 2001 IEP had no OT goals whatsoever, even though that IEP included OT services as part of her DIS for the 2001-2002 school year. However, the absence of OT goals for this school year was not an issue for this hearing, and therefore this Decision does not address that issue.
10 Ana Zeladon was STUDENT’s SDC teacher for ninth and tenth grades, and Rachel Page was STUDENT’s SDC teacher for eleventh and twelfth grades. Neither one of the SDC teachers is a current employee of the District, and neither testified at the due process hearing. Therefore, the bulk of testimony regarding STUDENT’s receipt of reading instruction during high school came from Dr. Maryjane Palmer, who was STUDENT’s speech-language therapist throughout high school, from September 2000 to June 2004.
11 Regarding the evidence of STUDENT’s Sylvan attendance in 2004 and 2005, the “snapshot rule” requires that the Hearing Officer analyze the May 2001 IEP in the context of the information reasonably available to the IEP team at the time the IEP was drafted. (See Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d at 1149.) However, the Hearing Officer considers the evidence of STUDENT’s Sylvan experience in light of Petitioner’s position that such evidence demonstrated that Sylvan’s instructional methods would have been appropriate for her in earlier school years.
12 The daily reports were separate from the daily communication journal that STUDENT’s instructional assistant and SDC teacher wrote in to inform the PARENTS about what STUDENT was doing in school.
13 Ms. Nest confirmed that she was describing typical tenth-grade general education academic classes, not honors-level or Advanced Placement classes.
14 While IEPs from RSFSD indicate that STUDENT’s SDCs were fully integrated with general education classes in the lower elementary grades, there was no evidence as to how this would have been implemented at the high school level, where the discrepancies between STUDENT’s academic level and those of the general education students were far greater. Notably, the IEPs indicate that the proportion of STUDENT’s day spent in special education increased as she advanced to the upper grades within RSFSD. (Pet. Exh. p. 77, 199, 225.)
15 This Decision has already determined that the present levels of performance in the May 2001 IEP were accurate and contained sufficient information to allow the IEP team to develop STUDENT’s goals and educational program.
16 At hearing, Petitioner contended that the District failed to provide receptive language goals in oral comprehension. However, Petitioner’s closing brief appears to no longer dispute this point, acknowledging that “clearly, this [May 2002] IEP included a receptive language goal that addressed STUDENT’s unique need to answer comprehension questions.” (Pet. Closing Brief, p. 20.) In reaching this conclusion, Petitioner pointed to a May 2002 IEP goal that STUDENT would answer “wh” questions correctly after listening to a story and would produce sentences based upon story retell. (Pet. Exh. p. 566.)
17 Petitioner does not raise any arguments regarding the time period between the parent’s consent to the IEP on October 17, 2002, and STUDENT’s participation in a Workability job beginning in or about January 2003. In any event, the May 2002 IEP notes already reflected that STUDENT’s participation in a Workability job would not begin immediately upon the referral to the Workability program because staff required some time to “explore placements” and locate an appropriate one for STUDENT. (Dist. Exh. 7, p. 10.)
18 The ITP also identified learning “familiar environment” sight words and identifying numbers as transition activities that were part of STUDENT’s functional skills curriculum. (Pet. Exh. p. 630.)
19 In February 2004, Ms. Page wrote in the parent-school communication log that no instructional aides were willing to drive STUDENT to Rancho Santa Fe, so the District had arranged for a bus to transport STUDENT and her aide to the market and back to school again. (Pet. Exh. pgs. 1363, 1365.)
20 Unlike at most high schools, California community colleges do not have a specific time when the school day ends for all students; thus, the circumstances leading to the early dismissal at TPHS would almost certainly not exist at Mira Costa.
21 MOTHER testified that the chairs with attached desks in the Mira Costa Transition Program would not physically accommodate STUDENT, and expressed concern that providing STUDENT with a modified chair would make her seem different than the other students in the class. However, Petitioner did not raise any issue alleging that use of a modified chair in the transition program would constitute a denial of FAPE, and therefore this Decision does not address that as an issue.
22 The course description notes that each student’s participation in the listed areas and activities depends on his or her unique needs as addressed in the student’s IEP.
