California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · January 26, 2001

Student v. Chula Vista Elementary School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2125-00 · Hearing Officer Glenn A. Fait

Chula Vista Elementary must follow stipulated preschool services agreement; parent's remaining two claims dismissed with prejudice and neither side prevailed.

Decision by settlement

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

This case was resolved by a decision by settlement under California Code of Regulations, title 5, section 3087. The parties agreed on the terms, and the administrative law judge adopted them after finding they were not contrary to law. The case was not decided after a contested hearing, so the judge made no findings on the disputed issues; any findings come from the parties' own stipulations.

Summary

The parent of a preschool girl filed for due process against Chula Vista Elementary School District and represented herself. The District served her through its preschool autism program. The six issues covered whether her goals were understandable, whether speech-language services and one-to-one instruction should be delivered at Harborside Preschool, autism training for staff and the parent, the aide's qualifications, daily feedback to the parent, and a sensory diet.

On the first hearing day, the Hearing Officer worked with the parties on the record, and they signed a stipulation. The District agreed to provide weekly individual and small-group speech-language sessions and one hour per school day of one-to-one instruction at Harborside through June 14, 2001. It also agreed to give the parent written notes after each one-to-one session, to train the aide and other staff in autism methods and sensory integration, to give the parent two training sessions, and to provide a sensory diet twice a day under the District occupational therapist's supervision. The parties agreed that the January 18, 2001 IEP goals and the Harborside placement were appropriate.

The mother then asked for a continuance to hire a lawyer and to take back the stipulation. The Hearing Officer denied both requests, finding she had signed the stipulation voluntarily. She then withdrew the goals-wording issue and a request for videotaping, both with prejudice. The Hearing Officer ordered compliance with the stipulation and found that neither party prevailed.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO could turn a stipulation signed during the hearing into a binding order. It also shows that a parent who signed voluntarily could not take the agreement back after a continuance was denied. Issues withdrawn with prejudice were dismissed and cannot be raised again in a later hearing.

Issues and holdings

  1. Dismissed / withdrawnIEP content

    Issue 1. Were STUDENT's goals and objectives written so that STUDENT's mother and other lay persons could understand them?

    Mother withdrew the issue with prejudice before evidence was taken, calling it a compliance matter for the Department of Education; dismissed with prejudice.

  2. Dismissed / withdrawnPlacement and LRE

    Issue 2. Should speech and language services and one-to-one instruction be provided to STUDENT at Harborside Preschool where the remainder of her program is provided?

    Resolved by stipulation: District to provide individual and small-group speech-language and one hour daily of one-to-one instruction at Harborside Preschool; Hearing Officer ordered compliance.

  3. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Should the regular preschool teacher, STUDENT's aide, and her mother receive training in the techniques for working with autistic children?

    Resolved by stipulation: aide training, a trained behavior aide for two weeks, autism workshop videotapes for staff, and two 30-minute parent training sessions; Hearing Officer ordered compliance.

  4. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue 4. Does STUDENT's aide have the necessary qualifications to provide services to STUDENT?

    Resolved by stipulation on aide training and on the one-to-one instructor's qualifications and experience; Hearing Officer ordered compliance.

  5. Dismissed / withdrawnIEP procedure

    Issue 5. Should the District provide daily feedback to STUDENT's mother concerning STUDENT's daily activities at school?

    Daily written communication was resolved by stipulation; the related videotaping request was withdrawn with prejudice after the first witness testified.

  6. Dismissed / withdrawnFAPE: services offered

    Issue 6. Should the District provide occupational services in the form of sensory diet every two hours while STUDENT is at school?

    Resolved by stipulation: sensory integration training for staff, and a sensory diet twice per school day supervised by the District occupational therapist; Hearing Officer ordered compliance.

What the decision orders (agreed terms)

  • Order to provide or change services. Parties ordered to comply with the January 25, 2001 stipulation. At Harborside Preschool from January 29 to June 14, 2001, the District will provide one 30-minute individual speech-language session weekly and two 30-minute group sessions weekly (groups of 3 or fewer, including typically developing peers). It will also provide one hour per school day of one-to-one instruction at Harborside starting within 10 calendar days and continuing through June 14, 2001, delivered by an instructor experienced with autism. The District will try to secure an instructor with a moderate-severe credential. Under the stipulation, the District will also send the parent written communication after each one-to-one session.
  • Staff training. Per stipulation: a trained behavior aide will work with the student and train classroom aides from January 29 to February 9, 2001. By February 9, the student's aide will receive 3 hours of autism training covering discrete trial training, Floortime, pivotal response training and applied behavior analysis. Workshop videotapes will be made available to staff. By February 9, 2001, the preschool teacher and aide will be trained in sensory integration.
  • Per stipulation: two 30-minute parent training sessions by February 28, 2001. Preschool staff will implement a sensory diet twice per school day under the supervision of the District occupational therapist.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Education Code section 56507(d); Education Code section 56505

People named in the decision

  • Deborah R.G. Cesario, attorney for District, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Susana Waisman, special education director, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Nancy Vaccaro, program coordinator, Chula Vista Elementary School District
  • Pat Belden, autism workshop presenter (videotapes made available to staff)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This case was heard in Chula Vista, California on January 25 and 26, 2001, by Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.

Petitioner STUDENT was represented by her mother, MOTHER.

Respondent Chula Vista Elementary School District (District) was represented by attorney Deborah R.G. Cesario. Also present on behalf of the District were special education director Susana Waisman and program coordinator Nancy Vaccaro.

Documentary evidence and witness testimony was received and the record was closed on January 26, 2001, and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES

1. Were STUDENT’s goals and objectives written so that STUDENT’s mother and other lay persons could understand them?

2. Should speech and language services and one-to-one instruction be provided to STUDENT at Harborside Preschool where the remainder of her program is provided?

3. Should the regular preschool teacher, STUDENT’s aide, and her mother receive training in the techniques for working with autistic children?

4. Does STUDENT’s aide have the necessary qualifications to provide services to STUDENT?

5. Should the District provide daily feedback to STUDENT’s mother concerning STUDENT’s daily activities at school?

6. Should the District provide occupational services in the form of sensory diet every two hours while STUDENT is at school?

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

Prior to the receipt of evidence in this hearing, the parties attempted to reach a settlement of the issues. After attempting to reach a settlement, the parties informed the Hearing Officer that a settlement could not be reached and that the hearing should go forward. The Hearing Officer inquired about the possibility that the parties could agree to a stipulation on some or all of the issues. The parties indicated a willingness to consider formulating such a stipulation. For the rest of the first day of hearing, the parties worked with the Hearing Officer, on the record, to attempt to formulate such a stipulation. By the end of the day, the parties had drafted and signed a stipulation that settled all of the issues except the issue relating to the wording of the goals and objectives and the need for the District to videotape STUDENT’s daily activities and send the video- tapes home to STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER. It was agreed that those issues would be the only issues heard by the Hearing Officer on the next day.

MOTHER then requested that the hearing be continued so that she could retain the services of an attorney to assist with the remaining issues. The Hearing Officer denied the continuance on the grounds that MOTHER had already had an opportunity to seek counsel and that the matter had already been continued once. After the Hearing Officer denied the continuance, MOTHER stated that she wished to rescind her agreement to the stipulation. The Hearing Officer said he would take her request to rescind the stipulation under consideration and would rule on the request the following day.

On the second day of the hearing, the Hearing Officer denied MOTHER’s request to rescind the stipulation. He concluded that she had entered into the stipulation voluntarily and was not the subject to coercion or duress when she signed the stipulation. He then ordered that the parties forthwith comply with the terms of the stipulation in order to ensure that STUDENT’s special education needs would be addressed without further delay.

The hearing then went forward on the two remaining issues. Prior to taking evidence, MOTHER withdrew, with prejudice, the issue relating to the wording of the goals and objectives, stating that this was actually a compliance issue that should be addressed by the Department of Education. She then called her first witness on the issue of whether the District should be required to provide a videotape of STUDENT’s daily activities. After the first witness’s testimony, she withdrew, with prejudice, the final remaining issue relating to the videotaping.

The hearing concluded with the understanding that the Hearing Officer would prepare a written decision formalizing his order to comply with the stipulation.

STIPULATION

The following stipulation was executed by the parties on January 25, 2001.

1. The District agrees to provide speech and language services to STUDENT at the Harborside Preschool from January 29, 2001, to June 14, 2001, as follows:

a. One session a week of individual speech and language services for 30 minutes per session; and b. two sessions a week of group speech and language services for 30 minutes per session. The group will consist of 3 or less students including STUDENT and typically developing peers.

2. The District agrees to provide one-to-one instruction, one hour per school day to STUDENT at Harborside Preschool as soon as possible but no later than ten calendar days from the date of this document through June 14, 2001. In the interim, the one hour of one-to-one instruction will continue at the PACE program (preschool autism coordinated education) located at Rogers Elementary school pursuant to the December 21, 2000 interim agreement. The services at Harborside will occur in a location selected by the Harborside school staff. The staff will attempt to provide the services in a consistent location.

The one-to-one instructor will implement the goals and objectives written in the January 18, 2001 IEP, or pursuant to an order by the hearing officer. The District will attempt to secure a one-to-one instructor with a moderate-severe teaching credential, to include the possibility of securing a teacher with an emergency credential. The one-to-one instructor will have experience in working with students with autism, including specific strategies and methodologies.

3. The District agrees to provide written communication to MOTHER following each one-to-one speech and language session addressing STUDENT’s daily activities. The District further agrees to provide daily written communication to MOTHER following each one-to-one session described in paragraph 2 above, addressing STUDENT’s daily activities.

4. The parties agree that the regular preschool teacher at Harborside is qualified to work with STUDENT. The District has provided training to the regular preschool teacher at Harborside with regard to working with children with autism and other pervasive development delays, including teaching methodologies and strategies.

5. From January 29 – February 9, 2001, an experienced and trained behavior aide will be assigned to work with STUDENT and train the aides assigned to STUDENT’s classroom. In addition, by February 9th the aide assigned to STUDENT will receive training for three hours in the area of working with children with autism, which will include learning the techniques appropriate for working with STUDENT, such as discrete trial training, Floortime, pivotal response training, and applied behavioral analysis. The District will also make available the four videotapes of Pat Belden’s workshop on autism to the staff who works with STUDENT.

6. The District agrees to provide two, 30-minute parent training sessions to MOTHER by February 28, 2001. The exact date and time is to be mutually agreed upon by the District staff member and MOTHER.

7. The District agrees to train the preschool teacher and aide in the area of sensory integration by February 9, 2001. The sensory diet will be implemented by the preschool staff under the supervision of the District’s occupational therapist two times per school day, once prior to STUDENT receiving her related services and once prior to the time STUDENT attends the preschool program.

8. The parties agree that the goals and objectives and placement (Harborside Preschool) described in the January 18, 2001 IEP are appropriate for STUDENT.

9. The parties agree that the only issues for hearing are:

1. Whether the District’s goals and objective(s) can be understood by the parent and person(s) responsible for implementing the goals and objectives.

2. Videotaping of the one-to-one speech and language sessions and the one-to-one instruction mentioned in paragraph 2 above, for the purpose of providing MOTHER with information concerning STUDENT’s activities in these settings.

However, the District does not waive its right to argue that the hearing officer does not have subject matter jurisdiction to hear these matters.

10. Neither party is considered a prevailing party for agreeing to these stipulations.

ORDER

1. The parties shall comply with the stipulation set out above.

2. The issues concerning the wording of the goals and objectives and videotaping of STUDENT’s daily activities are dismissed with prejudice as due process hearing issues.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: Neither party prevailed on the issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of the receipt of this decision. Education Code section 56505(I).

Dated:

Glenn A. Fait, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office