California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · September 20, 2001

Student v. Long Beach Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2128-00 · Hearing Officer Marilyn A. Woollard

Long Beach Unified must reimburse a preschooler's home ABA program, private speech therapy, and preschool after denying her a FAPE.

Student prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A preschool girl with autism, diagnosed at age four, filed for due process against Long Beach Unified School District over the 2000-2001 school year. Her mother asked for an assessment on the last day of the 1999-2000 school year. The District did not assess until late September 2000 and did not make a formal, specific offer until November 20, 2000. That offer was a mild-to-moderate preschool special day class at Lowell Elementary with a 10-hour ABA (applied behavioral analysis) aide, 20 hours of home ABA, and one individual and three group 30-minute speech sessions a week. Meanwhile, the parents ran a private home program through Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), paid for speech therapy with Gloria Critelli, and later enrolled her in Kindercare.

The Hearing Officer found the offer did not meet the student's needs. In fall 2000, she needed at least 30 hours a week of one-to-one ABA at home before starting school. The offered class had no peers who could model language at her level, and the formal offer had no gradual transition plan. She also needed two hours of individual and one hour of group speech therapy a week. The Hearing Officer found the offer came 47 days after the IEP deadline. That delay was a procedural violation that denied a FAPE at a critical time for early intervention. The District must reimburse the full costs of BECA, the private speech therapy, and Kindercare from October 4, 2000 through the end of the school year.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO weighed a young child's need for intensive early intervention under the Rowley standard. The Hearing Officer gave more weight to experts who had evaluated the child directly. She checked whether the offered class had peers who could model language. She also treated a late IEP offer as a denial of FAPE because it delayed time-sensitive services.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailedPlacement and LRE

    Issue 1a. Did the District offer Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by offering her an appropriate placement?

    The offered placement in a mild-to-moderate preschool special day class with a 10-hour ABA aide did not meet Student's needs. In October 2000 she needed an all-home ABA program, the class lacked suitable language models, and the formal offer had no gradual transition.

  2. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1b. Did the District offer Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by offering her an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program in a sufficient amount?

    Student needed at least 30 hours a week of one-to-one ABA/discrete trial training delivered entirely at home. The District's 30 hours split between home (20) and school (10) was not designed to meet her needs.

  3. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1c. Did the District offer Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year by offering her a sufficient amount of individual and group speech and language therapy?

    Student needed two hours of individual and one hour of group speech therapy a week from a therapist with autism experience. One 30-minute individual session and three 30-minute group sessions were not enough.

  4. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1 (procedural). Whether the District failed to develop an IEP within thirty calendar days of the start of the school year, as required by Education Code sections 56344 and 56023, for a pupil referred for assessment within twenty days of the end of the prior school year

    The IEP was due by October 4, 2000. The District's first formal, specific offer came on November 20, 2000, which was 47 days late. The Hearing Officer held the delay cost Student educational opportunity at a critical time and denied her a FAPE. Other procedural claims were not addressed.

  5. Issue 2a. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her ABA program through BECA?

    The BECA home program met Student's needs and produced clear progress, especially in her ability to attend. The parents get full reimbursement, including supervision, from October 4, 2000 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.

  6. Issue 2b. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of her private typical preschool from January 2001 to the end of the 2000-2001 school year?

    Kindercare addressed Student's needs in social interaction and communication, and she benefited from it. Its costs must be reimbursed.

  7. Issue 2c. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of private speech and language services provided to her by speech pathologist Gloria Critelli?

    The District did not dispute that Ms. Critelli's therapy met Student's needs and gave her benefit. Student made large receptive language gains, and the full costs must be reimbursed.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the parents for the full costs of Student's BECA program from October 4, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 school year. This includes direct and indirect supervision, training, observation, meetings, and evaluations of the program at home and in consultation with the preschool. No dollar amount is stated.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the full costs of Student's speech and language sessions with Gloria Critelli from October 4, 2000 to the end of the 2000-2001 school year. No dollar amount is stated.
  • Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, the District must reimburse the full costs of Student's Kindercare preschool, which she attended from January 2001, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year. No dollar amount is stated.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; W.G. v. Target Range School District; Burlington; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Education Code sections 56344 and 56023; Education Code section 56441

People named in the decision

  • Susan Melly, SELPA administrator, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Sandra Blazer, director of general and special education services options, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Elizabeth Whitson, home program case supervisor / educational consultant (associate behavior analyst), Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), nonpublic agency
  • Dr. Melanie Lennington, clinical psychologist, expert witness for Student, Private practice
  • Gloria Critelli, private speech-language pathologist, Private practice
  • Andria Davidson, para-educator coordinator, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Carolyn Larson, compliance clerk, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Kimberly Kiku Tan, speech and language specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Mary Ann Feo, preschool special day class teacher, Lowell Elementary School, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Suzanne Boyles, school psychologist, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Carol Dygean, school psychologist and former program specialist, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Dr. Betty Jo Freeman, UCLA professor and psychologist, expert witness for District, UCLA Neuropsychiatric Institute; consultant to District
  • Jorge Sacchetto, psychologist intern, assessment team, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Nancy Tanaka, school nurse, assessment team, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Terrilee Peirce, speech therapist assigned to Lowell Elementary, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Dr. Lisa M. Doi, psychologist who confirmed autism diagnosis, Evaluation initiated by Harbor Regional Center
  • Ms. Savarese, report author, Scottish Rite Clinic
  • Dr. Loren Franke, director, mentor to Ms. Critelli, Scottish Rite Clinic
  • Clare Bothwell, autism resource contact, Newly Diagnosed Autism Support Group
  • Emily, preschool teacher, Kindercare
  • Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), nonpublic agency, home ABA provider
  • Kindercare, private typical preschool
  • Isabel Patterson Child Development Center, prior preschool, California State University, Long Beach
  • Harbor Regional Center, regional center

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Long Beach, California, on February 15 and 16, April 10, 11, 12, June 28, and July 12, 2001.

Petitioner Student (hereafter, Petitioner or Student) was represented at the hearing by attorney Bruce Bothwell from the law firm of Russell, Mirkovich, & Morrow. Also present on Student’s behalf was her mother, Student’s Mother, and her mother’s fiancee, Mr. S.(Footnote 2) Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (hereafter, Respondent or District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Karen E. Gilyard from the law firm of Atkinson, Andelson, Loya, Ruud & Romo. SELPA administrator Susan Melly was also present on the District’s behalf on all hearing days except April 11, 2001, when Sandra Blazer, director of general and special education services options, was present on its behalf.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: her parents, Student’s Mother and Mr. S; Student’s home program case supervisor from Behavioral Education for Children with Autism (BECA), Elizabeth Whitson; clinical psychologist Dr. Melanie Lennington; and speech pathologist Gloria Critelli. She also called the following District employees: Susan Melly; para-educator coordinator Andria Davidson; compliance clerk Carolyn Larson; speech therapist Kimberly Kiku Tan; special day class teacher Mary Ann Feo; school psychologist Suzanne Boyles; and school psychologist and former program specialist Carol Dygean.

Respondent called the following witnesses: U.C.L.A. professor and psychologist Dr. Betty Jo Freeman and Susan Melly.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. At the conclusion of the hearing, the record remained open to allow the parties to submit written closing arguments. Thereafter, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for a decision. ISSUES(Footnote 3)

1. Did the District offer Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2000-2001 school year, by:

a. offering her an appropriate placement?

b. offering her an applied behavioral analysis (ABA) program in a sufficient amount?

c. offering her a sufficient amount of individual and group speech and language therapy?

2. If the District did not offer Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year, is she entitled to reimbursement for:

a. The cost of her ABA program through BECA?

b. The cost of her private typical preschool from January 2001 to the end of the 2000-2001 school year?

c. the cost of private speech and language services provided to her by speech pathologist Gloria Critelli?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

Student contends that the District’s offer of a twenty-hour applied behavioral analysis (ABA) home program and immediate placement in a mild-to-moderate special day class (SDC) for ten hours a week with an ABA in-school aide did not provide her with a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year. Student argues that she required an ABA program of “up to forty hours per week” supervised by Behavioral Education for Children with Autism [BECA], a certified nonpublic agency (NPA), in order to obtain educational benefit. Student asserts that in October 2000, she was not ready to attend any school but required an intensive one-to-one ABA home program. In Student’s view, once she was ready to attend school, she required placement in a typical preschool with typically developing peers rather than in a special day class. Throughout the 2000-2001 school year, Student has received an ABA home program supervised by BECA and she requests that the District be ordered to reimburse her parents for the costs of this program, as well as for the private typical preschool, Kindercare, that she began attending on a limited basis in January 2001. Student also contends that District’s offer of one thirty-minute individual and three thirty-minute group speech and language sessions per week did not provide her with a FAPE. She contends that she required two hours of individual speech therapy and one hour of group speech therapy from a nonpublic provider experienced in working with children with autism. Throughout the 2000-2001 school year, Student received individual speech services from private speech pathologist Gloria Critelli. She requests reimbursement for these services.

The District contends that it offered Student an appropriate educational program that was reasonably calculated to enable her to obtain educational benefit. In the District’s view, in October 2000 Student required a placement in a small, structured special education class that would provide her with an opportunity to use her social skills in the natural environment. In its view, Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate preschool SDC class at Lowell Elementary School with an ABA in-class aide for ten hours a week was such a placement. The District asserts that this placement, coupled with its offer of a twenty-hour ABA home program, offered Student a total of thirty hours of ABA services and was sufficient to provide her with a FAPE. The District also argues that the amount of speech services it offered to Student was appropriate and that small-group therapy was the appropriate primary context in which to address her unique speech and language needs. In its view, reimbursement for the costs of Student’s private program and services is not appropriate.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

Student was first diagnosed with autism when she was four years and two months of age. Prior to her diagnosis, Student attended the Isabel Patterson Child Development Center (CDC) at California State University, Long Beach, where her mother worked as a librarian. During her attendance at CDC, Student was observed to be fearful of other children. She would scream or say “make them [other children] go away.” Student’s Mother frequently observed Student alone at the CDC. She did not develop any friends. At a parent-teacher conference in May 2000, CDC personnel expressed their concerns to Student’s Mother about Student’s fears, her use of echolalia (repeating what was said to her), the status of her language development, her difficulties engaging in conversation, and her limited interaction and interest in her peers. CDC staff recommended that Student receive a speech and language evaluation and a developmental assessment. At this meeting, Student’s Mother was given the name of Clare Bothwell as a person who would be helpful in arranging for a developmental assessment.(Footnote 4)

Student’s Mother researched Ms. Bothwell on the internet and found the word “autism” associated with her name. Ms. Bothwell provided Student’s Mother with a wide array of resources for Student that included the Harbor Regional Center, the District, the U.C.L.A. Neuropsychiatric Institute associated with Dr. Freeman, and Dr. Lovaas at U.C.L.A. When asked to recommend a psychologist for a developmental assessment, Ms. Bothwell gave her Dr. Lennington’s name.

Student’s Mother contacted as many of these resources as she could. She called the Harbor Regional Center and Dr. Lennington the same day. Dr. Lennington gave her an appointment.(Footnote 5)

Student’s Mother also contacted private speech and language pathologist Gloria Critelli for an evaluation. On June 3 and 6, 2000, Student was assessed by Ms. Critelli over two one-hour sessions. Following her assessment, Ms. Critelli diagnosed Student as having a Mixed Receptive/Expressive Language Disorder under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual-Fourth Edition (DSM-IV), pending corroborative data from psychological or developmental and medical assessments.(Footnote 6) Ms. Critelli recommended that Student receive individual and group speech/language therapy four to five times weekly for thirty- to sixty-minute sessions. Shortly thereafter, Student began individual speech and language sessions approximately three times a week for thirty minutes a session with Ms. Critelli using the Links to Language program.(Footnote 7)

In early June 2000, Dr. Lennington assessed Student for twelve hours over four days. From her evaluation, Dr. Lennington concluded that Student met the criteria for autistic disorder and verbally informed Student’s Mother of this diagnosis. Dr. Lennington recommended that Student immediately begin an intensive one-to-one ABA program and suggested several appropriate ABA providers to Student’s Mother, including BECA. Dr. Lennington also recommended that she pursue the IEP process for Student through the District. Dr. Lennington later prepared a written report of her developmental assessment of Student, which was faxed to Petitioner’s attorney on November 13, 2000.(Footnote 8)

On June 16, 2000, the day Dr. Lennington informed her of Student’s diagnosis, Student’s Mother wrote to the District requesting an assessment and an IEP for Student. Because Student’s Mother’s research on ABA emphasized the importance of early intervention, she advised the District that time was of the essence. Student’s grandparents hand-delivered the letter to the District. Carol Larson received the request and prepared an assessment, which Student’s Mother signed and returned to the District that day.

June 16, 2000, was the last day of the 1999-2000 school year for the District. Although in the past, the District had conducted preschool assessments during the summer months, Ms. Dygean testified that the policy had changed and new assessments were no longer being conducted in the summer.

Shortly thereafter, Student’s Mother began contacting numerous ABA programs to review their services. On July 7, 2000, BECA’s educational consultant, Ms. Whitson, conducted an in-home behavioral assessment of Student to provide educational recommendations. Ms. Whitson testified that BECA provides intensive ABA discrete trial training (DTT) to autistic children following the research and philosophy of Dr. Lovaas of the U.C.L.A. Young Autism Project. Ms. Whitson characterized that research as demonstrating that autistic children who received an average of forty hours intensive ABA/DTT home intervention achieved and maintained significant gains in their functioning and intelligence quotient (IQ), and were able to achieve placement in typical educational settings. Following her assessment, Ms. Whitson recommended that Student begin an intensive one-to-one home treatment. The total time in the program would be forty hours per week and would include an appropriate school placement. Ms. Whitson noted that the “primary objective for placing [Student] in school would be to allow her to make social contact with other children. Considering Student’s fear of children it is recommended that any school placement have a small class size and that she attend with an aide trained and working in her home program.” If an appropriate placement could be found, Ms. Whitson recommended that she attend “for approximately one to two hours a day, during times that maximize her ability to socialize with other children and generalize the skills she has learned at home.” The focus of the educational program should be “primarily on the areas of social skills, generative expressive language, communication needs and desires and increasing flexibility. Additional goals should include academic skills, receptive language, self-help, play skills, and motor skills.”

On July 13, 2000, Student’s diagnosis of autistic disorder was confirmed by Dr. Lisa M. Doi, Ph.D., in a psychological evaluation initiated by the Harbor Regional Center. Dr. Doi concluded that, consistent with this diagnosis, Student exhibited delays or abnormal functioning in social interaction, in language as used in social communication, and in symbolic or imaginative play.

On July 25, 2000, Student’s Mother wrote to the District to request a specific date for Student’s assessment. She also asked to view the District’s services and programs for autistic children. Ms. Lawson left a voice mail message advising the parents that there would be no assessment until the fall.

On September 5, 2000, school began for the District’s 2000-2001 school year.

On September 8, 2000, Student’s BECA program began with a three-day workshop that continued through September 9, and 10, 2000. During that workshop, Ms. Whitson trained the aides hired by the family, as well as Student’s parents, her grandparents and Student’s Father, on appropriate one-to-one ABA behavioral interventions for Student using discrete trial training.

Following this workshop, Ms. Whitson recommended that Student’s home program begin at a level of approximately twenty hours a week, with an increase to twenty-five hours once Student adjusted to the structure of the therapy sessions. Ms. Whitson’s supervision of Student’s program would consist of monthly six-hour consultation visits to directly supervise and train Student’s aides and to develop her program, and at least four hours of indirect supervision for telephone consultation, curriculum development and report writing.

On September 11, 2000, Student’s Mother wrote to District SELPA administrator Susan Melly to express her concern about Student’s assessment. Student’s Mother advised the District that Student had begun a therapy program with BECA and that she expected to be reimbursed for the program by the District.

On September 19, 2000, Ms. Melly replied that an assessment of Student was scheduled for September 25, 2000, and that an IEP would be held within the statutory timelines.

On September 25, 2000, the District assessed Student to determine her eligibility for special education and the types of educational interventions appropriate for her. The assessment was conducted over a total period of approximately two hours. The District’s transdisciplinary assessment team was composed of school psychologist Suzanne Boyles, program specialist/school psychologist Carol Dygean, psychologist intern Jorge Sacchetto, speech and language specialist Kimberly Tan, and school nurse Nancy Tanaka.(Footnote 9) The team reviewed reports prepared on Student by Dr. Doi (7/00), Ms. Critelli (6/00), Ms.Whitson/BECA 7/00 and 9/00, and Ms. Savarese of the Scottish Rite Clinic (8/00). In addition, the team interviewed the parents, observed Student at the District Preschool Assessment Center, and administered to Student the Mullen Scale of Early Learning (Mullen) and the Developmental Profile II Alpern-Boll-Shearer (DP-II). Ms. Boyles testified that the District did not dispute Dr. Doi’s diagnosis. As a result, no tests to diagnose the likelihood that Student was autistic were administered.

The assessment team recommended that Student be made eligible for special education as a student with autism. The team noted that Student had not been observed in her home environment or with other children and that information had not been obtained from either Isabel Patterson CDC or from Dr. Lennington. The team recommended that the IEP team review this information when it became available. The team recommended (1) that Student be placed in a small classroom setting that is highly structured, consistent, behaviorally oriented and rich in social development; (2) that consideration be given to involving Student in structured activities with typically developing same-age peers; (3) that Student be provided with group speech and language services to address her social language skills and her expressive language skills (answering questions without pictures; expanding expressive utterances and receptive language, and understanding WH questions); and (4) that ABA be considered as a related service for Student.(Footnote 10) On October 2, 2000, the IEP team met for the first time and determined that Student was eligible for special education as a student with autism. Student’s present levels of performance were reviewed as well as many goals and objectives. Ms. Dygean testified that, although the District had never observed Student in her home program, she had consulted with Ms. Whitson by telephone prior to this IEP meeting and had considered her input in drafting Student’s goals. Because teachers were not available to continue the IEP meeting, the team agreed to reconvene the meeting.

On October 4, 2000, the IEP meeting reconvened. The team discussed Ms. Tan’s recommendation that Student receive speech and language services in a group setting three times a week for thirty minutes each session. After Petitioner’s parents expressed their belief that Student needed individual speech therapy, the District amended its offer to include one thirty-minute individual session per week for a total of four weekly sessions.

The parents requested that the District fund Student’s existing ABA home program with BECA for “up to 40 hours” a week of services. In response, the District offered to fund Student’s home program for a maximum of twenty hours a week for a period of three months. Continued funding would be readdressed at an IEP meeting in January 2001. The District offered to fund Student’s ABA home program through an unnamed certified nonpublic agency (NPA) that would “provide supervision, consultation and program set-up.” Because the District did not have a master contract with BECA at the time, it agreed “to explore” setting up such a contract “to the fullest and if not possible, then a certified nonpublic agency, other than BECA would be explored.” Petitioner’s attorney advised the District that they would accept the twenty hours and seek the additional twenty hours through due process.

After discussing the continuum of placements, the team indicated on the IEP that the District offered Student placement in one of two options: either (1) a special day class with a teacher with a moderate-to-severe credential or (2) a full-inclusion placement at either a CDC or Head Start with support by an itinerant teacher with either an early childhood special education or a moderate-to-severe credential. The District indicated its belief that either of these options may be appropriate.(Footnote 11) The parents agreed to view placements and requested that Ms. Whitson and Dr. Lennington view the placements with them. Student’s placement was deferred pending visitation.

At the conclusion of the October 4, 2000 IEP, Student’s Mother consented only to Student’s eligibility for special education.

Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate SDC class was first mentioned to the parents after the October 4, 2000 IEP meeting. Ms. Dygean testified that although she was aware of Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate class at the time of this IEP meeting, she did not think of it during the meeting. The parents testified that the only SDC placements discussed at this meeting were in moderate-to- severe classes and that there was no discussion of placing Student in a mild-to-moderate SDC class. Witnesses agreed that students in moderate-to-severe classes tend to be more profoundly disabled in cognitive and language skills than those in mild-to-moderate classes.

Following the October 4, 2000 IEP meeting, Ms. Dygean accompanied the parents on their visit to five SDC placements. On October 12, 2000, the parents visited classes at Garfield and Lowell Elementary Schools. On October 18, 2000, the parents visited two classes at Tinchure Elementary and one class at Gant Elementary. Each of the teachers in the classes they observed possessed a moderate-to-severe teaching credential that authorized teaching children with autism. With the exception of Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate class at Lowell, each of the classes visited was a moderate-to-severe SDC.(Footnote 12)

After the visits on October 18, 2000, Ms. Dygean discussed the District’s program for Student with the parents. She wrote on an “IEP Supplement” page form that the District was offering placement in the mild-to-moderate SDC currently at Lowell. She also wrote that the “District agrees that Student will gradually enter the program. Initially, she will attend school 3-4 mornings for 1-2 hours daily....The District will fund a one-to-one ABA-trained aide for up to 10 hours in her school environment. The aide will assist with generalization of home program, structured socialization with typical peers and compliance with classroom routines and one-to-one learning...[as] a component of her intensive early intervention....”

Ms. Dygean testified that after all the placements had been observed, the parents were “eager” to enroll Student in Ms. Feo’s class at Lowell. Student’s Mother and Mr. S testified that they were not eager but believed that Ms. Feo’s class was the best of the classes shown to them. The parents had many concerns about the class because they did not see very many of these children speaking and those who spoke were not as verbal as Student. They told Ms. Dygean that they wanted to have Ms. Whitson observe Ms. Feo’s class because she was in charge of Student’s therapy.

In late October 2000, the parents revisited Ms. Feo’s class at Lowell accompanied by Ms. Whitson, Ms. Dygean and Student. At the end of this observation, Ms. Whitson asked Ms. Dygean if Ms. Feo would be available to speak with her. According to Ms. Dygean, Ms. Feo indicated she would be happy to talk with Student’s Mother, but not with Ms. Whitson. From Ms. Feo’s refusal to talk with Ms. Whitson, the parents believed that Ms. Feo would not work cooperatively or collaborate with Student’s home program. Ms. Feo testified that she told Ms. Dygean she was willing to talk with Ms. Whitson as long as Student’s Mother and Ms. Dygean were present.

On November 9, 2000, Ms. Dygean prepared a notice of an IEP meeting scheduled for November 20, 2000. The purpose of this meeting was to discuss results of Student’s occupational therapy (OT) assessment, and parental agreement to the goals and objectives, placement and related supports and services of the initial IEP.

On November 9, 2000, Ms. Melly wrote to Student’s Mother and advised her that Student’s IEP had been developed on October 2 and 4 and “finalized on October 18, 2000 after site visits.” After reiterating what she believed to be the District’s offer, Ms. Melly wrote that “it has come to the attention of this office that you have not signed Student’s October 4, 2000 IEP. Please make an appointment with Carol Dygean to sign Student’s IEP on or before November 17, 2000.” Ms. Melly indicated that “if no response is received from you by the above date, the District may find it necessary to pursue an alternative resolution procedure to resolve this matter....”

On November 16, 2000, Mr. Bothwell responded to Ms. Melly’s letter, expressing concern at the threat/demand that Student’s Mother sign Student’s IEP on or before the scheduled IEP meeting of November 20, 2000. He indicated that the parents had planned on having Ms. Whitson attend the IEP “in order to continue the discussion concerning appropriate placement and services for Student, and to answer any questions the District may have concerning Ms. Whitson’s views regarding Student’s unique needs.” Because Ms. Melly was demanding that the IEP be signed before November 17, Mr. Bothwell indicated that Ms. Whitson would not attend the IEP.

On November 16, 2000, Ms. Melly replied to Mr. Bothwell and clarified that her letter to Student’s Mother was not a threat or a demand to sign Student’s IEP prior to November 17, 2000, but “to merely request that Student’s Mother make an appointment to sign the IEP prior to November 17th.” She indicated that the scheduled IEP meeting of November 20, 2000, would be an appropriate time to discuss placement and to sign Student’s IEP and that Ms. Whitson’s input would be valuable.

On November 20, 2000, the IEP team met for the third time. Ms. Whitson was not present. Both Ms. Melly and Ms. Dygean testified that the District’s first formal offer of placement for Student occurred at this IEP meeting. The District’s offer was as follows: at school, Student would be placed in Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate SDC class at Lowell Elementary School with a one-to-one ABA aide for ten hours per week. At home, Student would receive twenty hours a week of one-to-one ABA “with set-up, NPA supervision.” The total combined home/school ABA program offered was for thirty hours each week. Student would receive one thirty-minute individual session and three thirty-minute group sessions (120 minutes) pull-out speech and language services. In addition, Student would receive two hours per month of “psychological services” divided between her home and SDC class, and would be provided with mainstreaming opportunities with general education students in a variety of contexts.

At the conclusion of the November 20, 2000 IEP meeting, Student’s Mother indicated her disagreement with the goals and objectives and with the District’s offer of placement and services, except as they related to OT.

On November 21, 2000, the District’s School Board approved a master contract with BECA, effective retroactively to July 1, 2000. The agreement was signed by BECA on January 31, 2001. At no time were the parents advised that the master contract had been placed on the Board’s agenda or that it had been approved.

On December 1, 2000, the Hearing Office received Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing in this matter.

Throughout the 2000-2001 school year, Student continued in her BECA home program. In consultation reports, Ms. Whitson recommended that the intensity of the program gradually increase in five-hour increments as Student adjusted to the routine. Following consultations on November 29 and December 11, 2000, she recommended an increase to thirty-five and forty hours a week. Following two consultations in January 2001, Ms. Whitson indicated that Student had begun attending a private preschool on January 16, 2001. Student attended class with approximately seven typical peers for one hour a day, three days a week. Two of Student’s home program aides took turns accompanying Student to preschool. Ms. Whitson recommended that Student’s combined home and school program should total forty hours per week, with Student’s home program decreasing as her tolerance for school hours increased.

Despite BECA’s recommendations for increased intervention hours, Mr. S testified that Student’s home program was for less than the time recommended because the parents had difficulty obtaining the funding required for the full program. When Student’s Mother testified in April 2001, she indicated that Student was receiving between thirty-five and forty hours of intervention, including time in her typical preschool.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. DID THE DISTRICT OFFER Student FAPE DURING THE 2000-2001 SCHOOL YEAR?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C.§ 1400; Education Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no cost to the parents, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8) (1997).

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (25) (1997). The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). Education Code

§ 56363 (a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, the Hearing Officer must focus on the adequacy of the District’s offered and proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F. 2d 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.C. 3034 (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirement of the IDEA. The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit, but that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student’s abilities. Id. At 198 - 200. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instructional and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Id. at 201.

The Supreme Court in Rowley also recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA. Id. at 205. Thus, the analysis of whether a student has been provided a FAPE is twofold. The hearing officer must determine whether the procedural safeguards of the IDEA have been satisfied and whether the FAPE provided was substantively appropriate. Rowley, 458 U.S at 206-207. To constitute a FAPE as required by the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s offer must meet the following substantive requirements: (1) have been designed to meet Student’s unique needs; (2) have been reasonably calculated to provide Student with some educational benefit; and (3) have comported with her IEP.A. Substantive Appropriateness

1. Was the District’s Offer Designed to Meet Student’s Unique Needs?

a. What are Student’s unique needs?

To determine whether the program offered to Student was designed to meet her unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine what Student’s unique needs were in the fall of 2000.

The evidence persuasively established that Student is a high-functioning autistic child. Dr. Lennington testified that Student’s verbal intelligence quotient (IQ), as revealed in her scores on the Wechsler Preschool and Primary Scales of Intelligence, Revised (WPPSI-R), was a 59, in the mild to severe deficit range. Her performance IQ was 82, in the below-average range, and her full scale IQ was 68, in the mild deficit range. In Dr. Lennington’s opinion, the 23-point discrepancy between Student’s verbal and her performance IQ was of considerable statistical and clinical significance. It suggested that Student has a high potential for learning. Dr. Lennington testified that 82 is the lowest she would expect Student’s IQ to be. Furthermore, once Student’s language skills are established, Dr. Lennington would expect Student’s cognitive level to be at least average and likely above average or superior. According to Dr. Lennington, Student is high-functioning autistic child on the basis of her verbal skills and her ability to do subtests on the Woodcock-Johnson Test of Cognitive Ability that involved novel and fluid problem solving.

Other witnesses concurred.(Footnote 13)

It was also undisputed that Student has a strength in academics. From school psychologist Ms. Boyles’ assessment of Student’s pre-academic and cognitive ability, the transdisciplinary team determined that, cognitively, Student appeared to be functioning within the average range, higher than the borderline intellectual functioning indicated in previous tests by Dr. Doi. On the Mullen, Student demonstrated significant strengths in the area of academics. In addition, although the team noted that this may be an overestimate, Student was functioning at the 66-month range in academics according the (DP-II), a parent report instrument.

Unique Need for Intensive Early Intervention

The Legislature had determined that early education for three to five year old children with exceptional needs may “significantly reduce the potential impact of any disabling conditions,” may produce substantial gains in cognitive, language and speech, psychosocial and self-help skills development, and may “reduce the need for special class placement in special education programs once the children reach schoolage....” Education Code Section 56441 (a), (b) and (f).

The need for intensive early intervention services is of particular urgency for children with autism. As previously discussed, Student was 50 months old (4 years 2 months) when she was diagnosed with autistic disorder. “[A] consensus has emerged among researchers, practitioners, and educators that appropriate intervention/education [for children with autistic spectrum disorders] begins early, usually by thirty months.” Best Practices for Designing and Delivering Effective Programs for Individuals with Autistic Spectrum Disorders, Recommendations of the Collaborative Work Group on Autistic Spectrum Disorders, Sponsored by the Calif. Depts. of Education and Developmental Services, 1997 (hereafter, Best Practices).

The evidence persuasively established that timely early intervention was critical for Student developmentally. Student’s need for intensive services was underscored by several witnesses. As acknowledged by Dr. Freeman, the three-month period between Student’s diagnosis and the District’s assessment was critical for her because children develop so rapidly. As a result, in her opinion, Student’s parents acted appropriately in starting her program with BECA when they did. Ms. Critelli testified that, because Student was starting intervention later than other autistic children, it was a critical time for her to get caught up. Dr. Lennington also emphasized that Student’s program should be designed to develop skills as rapidly as possible because she had not yet acquired many basic skills typical of a much younger child.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student had a unique need for intensive early intervention services during the 2000-2001 school year.

Unique Need for ABA Intervention

Discrete trial training is a specific type of ABA procedure in which a child is taught in small units of instruction using a ‘cue’ or clear instruction, a ‘prompt’ to assist the child in providing a ‘response’ to the cue and an immediate ‘consequence’ or positive reinforcement for a correct response. A brief ‘inter-trial interval’ precedes the next learning trial. “Discrete Trial Training in the Treatment of Autism,” Tristan Smith, Ph.D. According to Dr. Smith, DTT is the best studied approach for beginning instruction in important kinds of discrimination tasks, including imitation which is critical to learning from others, receptive and expressive language, conversation, sentence, grammar and syntax. It is the teaching approach with the strongest empirical support for helping autistic children with receptive and expressive language deficits to begin to acquire these skills. Id.

Dr. Lennington testified that autistic children must be specifically taught, by breaking skills into small pieces to ensure that the lowest level component is learned and a foundation established on which to begin building knowledge. This was particularly important for Student because she had frequent gaps in her lower level learning as indicated by correctly responding to higher level tests or questions but missing easier ones. Dr. Lennington concluded that Student required her tasks to be broken down, with information paired visually and verbally with frequent “in the moment” correction and instruction. Dr. Lennington testified that Student’s performance on subtests of the Woodcock Johnson demonstrated that she learns in a sequential fashion. When errors were pointed out to her at the point of error, Student was able to be successful and to build upon that. In her opinion, Student requires intensive one-to-one treatment throughout the day using ABA/DTT. Other witnesses agreed that Student required the direct systematic overlearning provided by ABA/DTT. (Testimony of Ms. Critelli and Ms. Whitson).(Footnote 14)

Dr. Freeman testified that there is no scientific dispute that intensive early intervention and ABA/DTT is “what works” with autistic children. She acknowledged the importance of Dr. Lovaas’ research that demonstrated that autistic children do learn. As a result, in her opinion, the efficacy of discrete trial training for autistic children is well accepted.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student had a unique need for intensive early intervention using applied behavioral analysis and discrete trial training (ABA/DTT).

Unique Needs Relating to Distractibility and Sustaining Attention

Both Dr. Lennington and Ms. Critelli testified that Student was highly distractible. During Ms. Critelli’s assessment sessions, she observed Student to be “most definitely distractible” and frequently off task. Student had difficulty focusing on tasks, frequently looked away, asked unrelated questions, and asked questions in a perseverative way. She was frequently distracted by both objects and noises. Student was not attending commensurate with her chronological age and was unable to attend for more than five minutes. Ms. Critelli provided Student with frequent breaks and desired reinforcers during the assessment. Similarly, Dr. Lennington testified that Student was very distractible during her assessment. Student had a very hard time complying with her requests to sit and do tasks. She exhibited compliance issues, some tantrums, some deflections to avoid responding and she remained off task throughout the four days of the assessment. Because Student had a difficult time focusing, Dr. Lennington gave her many breaks.

Ms. Tan testified that she recalled Student as focused during her speech assessment although she did not always respond to questions. The transdisciplinary team assessment report indicated, however, that Student “had a difficult time sustaining attention” and that Student demonstrated repetitive behavior in the form of questions about people and noises in the room that had already been explained to her. Student was also observed by the team to ignore questions, to repeat statements, and to change topics. Ms. Tan agreed that loud noise levels could be a problem in class if Student is distractible.

Dr. Lennington testified that, in order to learn, Student must be able to attend. Student was not able to do this and appeared to be “tuned out.” As a result, in Dr. Lennington’s opinion, it would be extremely hard for Student to learn new skills. In her opinion, attending is a basic self-help skill that is required if a child is to be an active learner.

The Hearing Officer finds that, as a result of her distractibility, one of Student’s primary unique needs at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year was to learn to attend to task.

Unique Needs in Social Skills and Communication Skills

As a child with an autistic disorder, Student has unique needs in the area of social interaction skills and communication skills. As indicated in the DSM-IV (p. 66), the “essential features of ‘autistic disorder’ are the presence of markedly abnormal or impaired development in social interaction and communication and a markedly restricted repertoire of activity and interests.”

In rendering her diagnosis, Dr. Doi determined that Student exhibited a qualitative impairment in social interaction, manifested by (1) a marked impairment in the use of multiple nonverbal behaviors such as eye-to-eye gaze, facial expression, body postures, and gestures to regulate social interaction (fleeting eye contact), (2) a failure to develop peer relationships appropriate to her developmental level as she preferred to play alone and did not initiate interactions with peers; and (3) a lack of spontaneous seeking to share enjoyment, interests, or achievements with others.

Student also exhibited a qualitative impairment in communication. Although only one of the four listed characteristics in the impaired communication category must be manifested for the diagnosis, Dr. Doi determined that Student exhibited three of the four manifestations: (1) a marked impairment, by an individual with adequate speech, in the ability to initiate or sustain a conversation with others, (2) a stereotyped and repetitive use of language or idiosyncratic language and (3) a lack of varied, spontaneous make-believe play or social imitative play appropriate to developmental level. (Footnote 15)

These needs were also identified in the District’s September 2000 assessment. The team determined that Student was functioning at the twenty-three-month level in her social skills, as indicated on the DP-II, the team’s observation, and the parents’ report. This was a chronological delay of approximately thirty months. From its assessment, the District concluded that Student had difficulty in engaging in conversation and interacting with peers, difficulty in answering “wh” questions and delays in pragmatics or social communication. Ms. Dygean testified that, even though Student had speech, she had delays in conversation and in knowing how to gather information and in knowing how to get her needs met.

Unique Social-Emotional Needs

In addition to Student’s social communication needs, Ms. Dygean testified that Student had unique social-emotional development needs that specifically related to knowing how to approach peers and how to join with and play with peers, and that she had a need arising out of her fear of other students.

Each of Student’s assessors reported that, according to Student’s Mother, Student would scream if children were near her or ask her parents to make the other children go away. She would cling to her mother or to Mr. S. In addition, it was reported that Student had no friends at CDC, that she remained physically far away from other children and that she was frightened by environmental noises and by noisy children. During its assessment, the District did not talk to CDC personnel or observe Student with other children. Student was observed by both Ms. Dygean and Ms. Feo during the parents’ second observation of Ms. Feo’s class in late October 2000. While they did not see this behavior, the Hearing Officer notes that Student was in the class with three familiar adults and in close proximity to either her mother or Mr. S throughout this observation.(Footnote 16)

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student had unique emotional needs manifested by her fear of other children and of noises that affected her ability to approach and interact with her peers.

Unique Need for Gradual Transition into a Class Setting

According to Dr. Doi, Student had a difficulty with transitions as one of the manifestations of her autistic disorder. In addition, Student had a strong fear of other children. Both Dr. Lennington and Ms. Whitson testified that once Student was ready to attend school, she needed to enter it gradually. Dr. Lennington testified that she should begin with as little as one hour. Ms. Whitson testified that Student should begin school from one to two hours a day, three days a week. The transdisciplinary assessment team indicated that a transition plan may be helpful for Student if the IEP team decided to make changes to her home program.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student had a unique need for a gradual transition into a classroom placement.

Unique Need for Appropriate Language Models

There was a fundamental agreement among the expert witnesses that, in the fall of 2000, Student was a verbal child who spoke in sentences with a range of from two to seven words. (Testimony of Ms. Critelli, Dr. Lennington, Ms. Whitson). Testimony indicated that Student spoke spontaneously and used full sentences to respond to questions (Ms. Whitson), and that she was “chatty” but her sentences were not grammatically correct and sometimes difficult to understand (Dr. Lennington). Both speech therapists, Ms. Critelli and Ms. Tan, testified consistently about Student’s average length of sentence: from two to four words, or a mean length of utterance (MLU) of 3.52 word. According to Ms. Tan, Student’s MLU was below the age-appropriate range of 3.7 to 5.7 words.

Dr. Lennington, Ms. Critelli and Ms. Whitson testified that Student needed typical peers as language role models when she entered school. In Dr. Lennington’s opinion, because Student is high functioning, she requires models at or above her skill level. Further, because Student was in the process of developing language, it would be detrimental to her to be exposed to language that is below her skill level. Student would not be able to learn if she is at the top of the group. Ms. Critelli testified that, in her opinion, Student needed to be with typical peers because she was able to learn from normal language models and required good modeling for language. Ms. Whitson concurred. Both Ms. Dygean and Ms. Melly agreed that autistic children can imitate the behavior of peers to whom they are exposed. Ms. Tan testified that Student would do better with typical peers than with nonverbal peers in class for her expressive deficits and for grammatical errors. All witnesses agreed that Student does not require Picture Exchange Communications (PECs) as a means of communication.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student has a unique need for appropriate, typical peer language models.

Unique Speech and Language Needs

In June 2000, Ms. Critelli assessed Student’s receptive and expressive language skills using both formal and informal assessment tools.

Student’s receptive language demonstrated a scatter of strengths and weaknesses. On the Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test, Revised-Form L (PPVT-R, L), Student received an age equivalent (AE) score of 2.7 years (31 months) at a chronological age of 4 years, 2 months (50 months). Ms. Critelli testified that this score indicated Student had a significant delay in receptive vocabulary skills. On the Test for Auditory Comprehension of Language-Revised (TACL-R), which measures understanding of a variety of language structures, Student receive a total score of 41 to 43 months. Student scored within her chronological age range on subtest that measures word classes and relations (nouns, verbs, etc.). Ms. Critelli testified that Student’s AE score of 28 to 31 months on the elaborated sentences subtest, however, revealed that her processing ability decreases as the length and complexity of a sentence increases (e.g., sentences with “and,” “but,” or two sentences joined by a clause). This indicated that Student’s conversation would break down due to lack of comprehension. Ms. Critelli testified that on the receptive portion of the Clinical Evaluation of Language Fundamentals - Preschool (CELF-P), Student exhibited some strengths in her receptive language skills,(Footnote 17) but significant weakness in her comprehension of different linguistic concepts (e.g., coordination, inclusion/exclusion, spatial and temporal relationships, order and quantitative concepts). This weakness would affect Student’s ability to follow directions.

Student’s expressive language was much weaker. On the expressive portion of the CELF-P, Student demonstrated a weakness in formulating labels and in expressive vocabulary skills. She had weaknesses in her conversational or “discourse” skills in terms of her ability to use questions, to provide responses to questions, to continue a conversation by providing relevant comments and by responding to another clearly, and to change a topic of conversation. Student’s general expressive language skills were reduced in length and complexity. She produced sentences ranging from two to six words in length; however, typical utterances were two to four words in length with inaccurate syntactic skills (word order) and morphological skills (word endings). Student was unable to retell a story but could provide short simple sentences about the story’s pictures by labeling common people, objects and actions. Student’s nonverbal communication skills were also weak in relation to her use of eye contact during conversation as well as in her ability to gain attention, her use of body postures, gestures and physical proximity while communicating with others.

Ms. Critelli testified that Student exhibited a significant discrepancy between her expressive and her receptive language skills, as demonstrated on the CELF-P. Student’s scores revealed a “huge difference” between her ability to understand (receptive language score at the twenty-seventh percentile) and her ability to express herself (expressive language score at the first percentile). Student’s total language score on the CELF-P was at the sixth percentile, or an AE of 2.10 (34 months). According to Ms. Critelli, this great discrepancy between Student’s receptive and expressive language skills is an excellent indicator of her cognitive and comprehension skills. From these results, she would predict average intellectual functioning.

Student demonstrated “scatter” in her abilities on the CELF-P; i.e. she was strong in some areas and weak in others. In Ms. Critelli’s opinion, the educational significance of such a pattern is that Student needed specific and definite language therapy that would target higher level language skills and build up from that level. Student was not at a pre-linguistic or nonverbal level. Even though she was behind for her age, she was speaking in complete sentences.

Ms. Tan evaluated Student’s communication skills as part of the District’s transdisciplinary assessment. She did not prepare a separate speech and language evaluation report. She reviewed Ms. Critelli’s June 2000 speech and language evaluation of Student and discussed Student’s present levels of performance with Ms. Critelli via telephone. Ms. Tan also conducted a parent interview, observed Student, administered the expressive and receptive language subtests of the Mullen, and took a language sample. Ms. Tan’s found that Student had lower expressive than receptive language skills and had problems in conversational skills and interactions with peers.

From the above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student had unique needs in the areas of both expressive and receptive language skills. ***

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that, during the 2000-2001 school year, Student had a unique need for intensive early intervention services utilizing ABA/DTT; a need to learn to attend to task arising out of her extreme distractibility and difficulty sustaining attention; a need in the area of social and communication skills; social-emotional needs arising out of her fear of other children that affected her ability to approach and interact with peers; a need for a gradual transition into a class setting; a need for appropriate language models; and a need in the area of developing her expressive and receptive language skills.

b. Was the District’s offer designed to meet Student’s unique needs?

As previously indicated, the District’s November 20, 2000 offer was as follows: at school, Student would be placed in Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate SDC class at Lowell Elementary School with a one-to-one ABA aide for ten hours per week. At home, Student would receive twenty hours a week of one-to-one ABA “with set-up, NPA supervision.” The total combined home/school ABA program offered was for thirty hours each week. Student would receive one thirty-minute individual session and three thirty-minute group sessions (120 minutes) pull-out speech and language services. In addition, Student would receive two hours per month of “psychological services” divided between her home and SDC class, and opportunities for mainstreaming.

1. Placement in Ms. Feo’s Class:

On November 20, 2000, the District first offered Student placement in Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate special day class with a one-to-one ABA aide for ten hours a week. As discussed below, the Hearing Officer concludes that the offer of placement was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

First, the Hearing Officer finds that, in October 2000, Student’s unique needs required that she be placed exclusively in a home ABA/DTT program for intensive early intervention to ameliorate her deficits in the areas of attending, and expressive and receptive language.

There was a conflict in the evidence regarding Student’s readiness for school in October 2000.(Footnote 18) Dr. Lennington testified that Student was not ready for a classroom placement in October 2000. In Dr. Lennington’s opinion, Student was so distractible and her attention problems were so severe that she needed to gain these skills first, before working on her social behavior. As a result, Student would not function well in a group setting. In addition to needing basic attention skills, Student required ABA/DTT in order to acquire basic skills, including expressive and receptive language skills, and to fill in the gaps in her learning. Dr. Lennington testified that it was apparent during her assessment that Student had a difficulty in interpreting social behavior because she did not understand why someone was talking to her or how someone else had a different experience from her own. With poor language skills, Student would not understand social skills. Furthermore, in her opinion, Student’s inattention appeared to be based on her lack of understanding of what was being said to her. As a consequence, Student required immediate help in expressive and receptive language.

In Dr. Lennington’s opinion, Student would benefit and learn many skills quickly from an ABA home program. Dr. Lennington recommended addressing Student’s fears of children in a progressive fashion, after Student had acquired some of these skills. Ms. Whitson also testified that, because of Student’s negative experiences at CDC, Student was not ready for school in October. In her opinion, Student required intensive one-to-one ABA/DTT therapy followed by a gradual transition to a typical preschool.

In contrast, Dr. Freeman testified that Student was ready to attend a small, structured special education class in October 2000. In her opinion, as a result of her problems at CDC, Student’s primary need at that time was to practice her social skills. From her review of the records, Dr. Freeman concluded that the District’s offer of placement in Ms. Feo’s mild-to-moderate special day class with DIS services was appropriate because Student needed a place to start working on her social skills. From her one-hour observation of Ms. Feo’s class in February 2001, Dr. Freeman concluded that Ms. Feo’s class was a structured education program of a type appropriate for Student because it had planned activities and was a developmentally based behavior program that handled behaviors inobtrusively.(Footnote 19) While Dr. Freeman agreed “one hundred percent” that the goal for Student is attendance in a regular (typical) kindergarten class, in her opinion, it was more appropriate to start Student toward this goal in a small, structured class where she could learn to work independently and practice her social skills. Ms. Dygean agreed that this was an appropriate placement.

In determining the relative weight to be according to the conflicting opinions of Dr. Lennington and Dr. Freeman, the Hearing Officer notes that both experts have substantial experience in treating autistic children. The Hearing Officer gives Dr. Lennington’s opinion greater weight for the following reasons. The Hearing Officer concludes that practicing social and communication skills with her peers was not Student’s primary need in October 2000. While it was uncontested that Student has unique needs in this area, the weight of the evidence established that Student required a firm foundation in expressive and receptive language skills in order to develop her communication skills. As indicated by both Dr. Lennington and Ms. Critelli, Student had considerable deficits in her receptive and expressive language skills that resulted in her not understanding what was being said to her. These deficits in turn led to attentional issues. In addition, Student had unique emotional needs arising out of her fear of other children and her unsuccessful experience at CDC. That fear could only be exacerbated by not understanding what was being said to her. In light of these needs, it would be detrimental to place Student in a social setting without providing her with the foundational skills necessary for success. The evidence also established that Student was working on her unique social communication needs in her home program in a safe emotional context with a group of familiar adults (e.g., beginning conversation by making reciprocal statements and multiple statements followed by a question). In addition, the Hearing Officer give Dr. Lennington’s testimony great weight as a result of the length and duration of her interactions with and observations of Student. Whereas Dr. Lennington spent approximately twelve hours over multiple days assessing and observing Student, Dr. Freeman testified that she had never met Student. (Footnote 20) Finally, Dr. Freeman testified that the “structured education program” she believes critical for autistic children does not necessarily have to be part of special education; in fact, due to early intervention, she currently recommends special education classes less and less frequently, especially for preschooler children. The Legislature has recognized that the home is an appropriate environment for the provision of early intervention services to preschool children. Calif. Educ. Code § 56441.2.

Second, even if Student had been ready to attend school in October 2000, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of placement in Ms. Feo’s class was not designed to meet Student’s unique need for appropriate language role models. The evidence persuasively established that, in October 2000, Ms. Feo’s class was composed of children who were not appropriate language models for Student.

Mr. S testified that when the parents visited Ms. Feo’s class the first time, he tried to look for children who were speaking. His overall impression of the language skills of the students in Ms. Feo’s class was that most were nonverbal. While he noticed one or two who were speaking, he did not notice any speaking on par with Student. Many did not speak at all, and he could not understand some who did. Student’s Mother also testified that, although Ms. Feo’s class was the best of the classes they had seen, the students were not as verbal as Student.

Ms. Whitson testified that when she observed Ms. Feo’s class in late October, she saw three students who used vocal language at a level below Student’s and who had limited play skills in comparison to hers. In Ms. Whitson’s opinion, the class was not an appropriate placement for Student because Student would not have been able to learn language or play skills from these pupils. Ms. Critelli testified that, in her opinion, Student needed to be with typical peers because she can learn from normal language models. An appropriate preschool for Student would include an opportunity for interaction with typically developing peers as well as good modeling for language, social behavior and attending skills. In Ms. Critelli’s view, while placement in a class with children with significant deficits might be beneficial for the other children in that class, it would not be appropriate for Student. She defined children with significant delays as those with cognitive deficits, with mental retardation or developmental delay, who function several years below chronological age and who are nonverbal.

Various District witnesses testified about the verbal abilities of the children in Ms. Feo’s class. Dr. Freeman testified that when she observed Ms. Feo’s class for one hour in February 2001, the majority “were verbal.” Ms. Dygean testified that during the 2000-2001 school year, she visited Ms. Feo’s class approximately six to seven times. She testified that, of the eight students, three had “good verbal skills” and the other five had varying levels of language delays but she would not consider them to be nonverbal. The Hearing Officer finds this testimony unpersuasive because neither Dr. Freeman nor Ms. Dygean described what they meant as ‘verbal.’ In addition, Ms. Dygean did not specify at what point during the school year this observation was made. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Feo to be credible and to be the most reliable reporter of the verbal abilities of the students in her class at the relevant time period. Ms. Feo testified that, in October, 2000, her class had approximately six children with a range of disabilities: one student was other health impaired, three were individuals with mental retardation or developmental delay, and two were autistic. Ms. Feo testified that, at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, two of the children were nonverbal and the rest spoke in only one- to two-word utterances. Ms. Feo’s testimony revealed that, between the beginning of the year and the time she testified in April 2001, two students joined the class. While Ms. Feo testified that the language abilities of her pupils improved during the year, the critical time for determining whether the offer was designed to meet Student’s needs was at the beginning of the school year. As previously indicated, Student spoke in sentences that ranged from two- to seven-words during this time period. The most advanced speakers in Ms. Feo’s class in October 2000 were at the bottom of Student’s verbal range. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Feo’s class did not have appropriate language role models for Student at the time the placement was offered (Footnote 21). As a consequence, it was not designed to meet her unique needs in this area.

Third, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement offer failed to address Student’s unique need for a gradual transition into an appropriate school placement.

As previously indicated, because of her fear of other children, one of Student’s unique needs was for a gradual transition into any school placement. The parent’s expressed this concern to Ms. Dygean following the class observations on October 18, 2000. In response, Ms. Dygean wrote on an “IEP Supplement” page that the District agreed Student would gradually enter the program and “attend school 3-4 mornings for 1-2 hours daily....” Ms. Dygean’s representation of a gradual transition was not made during a properly convened IEP meeting with the IEP team present. Thereafter, a transition plan was never included in the District’s formal offer of November 20, 2000, or during any other properly convened IEP meeting. As a result, the offer of November 20, 2000, was an offer of immediate placement into Ms. Feo’s class for ten hours a week and was not designed to meet Student’s unique transition need.

Fourth, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of a ten-hour ABA aide in Ms. Feo’s class did not address Student’s unique needs. The weight of the evidence established that the primary purpose of the ABA class aide for Student was to generalize the skills she learned in her home program. As previously discussed, however, in October 2000, Student required one-to-one ABA/DTT in her home program for the purpose of acquiring skills necessary as a foundation to the further development of her unique needs.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s offer of immediate placement in Ms. Feo’s class was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs. Petitioner raises additional challenges to the appropriateness of Ms. Feo’s class, including whether she possessed the “necessary competencies to teach individuals assigned to her [SDC] class” as required by 5 Cal. Code Regs. 3053(c). Essentially, Petitioner’s argument is that, although Ms. Feo had the necessary moderate-to-severe credential for teaching autistic children, she testified that she had no experience teaching preschool-age autistic children before September 2000. In light of the above conclusion, it is not necessary to address this argument.

2. Amount of ABA/DTT

The parties disagree about the amount of ABA/DTT intervention Student required. The parents requested an ABA/DTT program of “up to forty hours” as recommended by BECA. The District’s offer of November 20, 2000, consisted of a total of thirty hours, with 20 hours in Student’s home program and ten hours in Ms. Feo’s SDC class with an ABA aide.

Both Dr. Lennington and Ms. Whitson testified that they consistently recommend an intensive forty-hour program for autistic students, as a result of Dr. Lovaas’s research in his 1987 study “Behavioral Treatment and Normal Educational and Intellectual Functioning in Young Autistic Children.” That study demonstrated that forty-seven percent of autistic children in the experimental group who received forty hours of intensive one-to-one treatment a week achieved normal intellectual and educational functioning, with normal-range IQ scores and successful first grade performance in the public schools. In 1993, a follow-up study indicated that these children had preserved their gains over the control group and that some of the children who had previously achieved the best outcomes were indistinguishable from typical children. “Long-Term Outcome for Children with Autism Who Received Early Intensive Behavioral Treatment,” John McEachin, Tristram Smith and Ivar Lovaas. Dr. Lennington testified that her recommendation of a forty-hour ABA/DTT intervention for Student was based not only on Dr. Lovaas’ study, but also on her clinical observations over the years that her autistic clients had not derived benefit from fewer hours.

In contrast, both Dr. Freeman and Ms. Dygean testified that the “Best Practices” guidelines do not support the need for a forty-hour-per-week intervention for all autistic children. Dr. Freeman testified that no one program is appropriate for all autistic children. Each program must be highly individualized to meet the needs of a particular child. In Dr. Freeman’s view, the 1987 Lovaas study demonstrated only that forty hours of DTT intervention is more effective than ten hours and there is no current scientific data to support the efficacy of a particular amount of DTT. There is “no magic” in forty hours. Because the amount of intervention must be individualized for the particular autistic child, Dr. Freeman agreed that, in some cases, a child may need as many as sixty hours of DTT a week.

Dr. Freeman testified that proper “intensive early intervention” for an autistic child should involve a minimum of a thirty-hour-per-week program. In her opinion, a program without a minimum of thirty hours a week is inadequate for an autistic child. Within these thirty hours, there is no evidence about how much of each particular type of intervention (i.e., one-to-one ABA/DTT or group) there should be. Essentially, the child should be engaged in a variety of activities, should have a home component, and should quickly move to school. In Dr. Freeman’s opinion, because Student’s problems are in social communication and using her skills in a natural environment, forty hours of one-to-one services would make her more isolated. Dr. Freeman testified that the District’s total offer of thirty hours ABA/DTT across home and school for Student was appropriate.

The parties’ debate regarding whether an autistic child requires thirty or forty hours of one-to-one intervention services a week is theoretical and not relevant to determining the issue at hand. Rather, the Hearing Officer must determine whether the District’s offer was designed to meet Student’s unique needs at a specific point in her life. Student is a high functioning autistic child with considerable potential. Because she was diagnosed late in her development, her unique needs were particularly acute in the fall of 2000. Student was at a critical stage in her development with a narrowing window of opportunity. She had not previously received any intensive one-to-one services. She required a highly individualized program of intensive one-to-one intervention to acquire skills designed to address her unique needs. As previously discussed, the acquisition of these skills was a necessary foundation for addressing Student’s unique social communication needs with her peers, particularly in light of her history of fear of other children. Student needed to gain these skills quickly and then move into an appropriate preschool environment where she could begin working with typically developing peers.

In light of Student’s specific unique needs, the Hearing Officer finds that, during the 2000-2001 school year, Student required a minimum of thirty hours of intensive one-to-one ABA/DTT intervention services to be provided exclusively in her home program. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s combined home and school offer of thirty hours ABA/DTT intervention services was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs. (Footnote 22)

3. Speech and Language

The parties disagree about the amount of individual speech therapy Student required during the 2000-2001 school year.

While the District agreed that Student had delays in expressive and receptive language skills, its speech therapist Ms. Tan disagreed with Ms. Critelli about the severity of these delays. In her opinion, Student did not have severe speech and language deficits because her skills were scattered and some were within normal limits: i.e., Student had a receptive understanding of basic word concepts. Ms. Tan originally recommended that Student receive exclusively group speech therapy “to address social language skills, expressive language (answering questions without pictures, expanding expressive utterances and receptive language (understanding WH questions).” Ms. Tan testified that she disagreed with the IEP team adding one thirty-minute session of individual speech services for Student.(Footnote 23)

Following a discussion at the October 4, 2000 IEP meeting, the District offered Student one thirty-minute individual session of speech and language and three thirty-minute group sessions. Ms. Tan testified that, in her opinion, Student’s conversation skills would best be addressed in a small group of age-appropriate peers. She testified that the group size would be from one to three children with at least one typical peer. The speech therapist would also be a positive speech model. In her opinion, three thirty-minute small-group sessions was the appropriate amount of speech and language services for Student. According to Ms. Tan, Ms. Critelli agreed to the goals that she proposed for Student.(Footnote 24) Ms. Tan also testified that determining who would be in Student’s group and what methods would be used to implement her speech therapy, would depend on the school at which Student was placed and the receiving therapist.(Footnote 25)

Ms. Critelli testified that typically developing children generally learn from incidental exposure; i.e., they “pick things up” naturally. By contrast, an autistic child like Student requires direct, systematic and repetitive overlearning. In Ms. Critelli’s opinion, individual speech and language therapy is necessary to expose Student to the systematic and direct instruction necessary for learning. Ms. Critelli testified that, in her opinion, Student required two to three hours of speech and language therapy a week, with approximately two hours of individual therapy and one hour of group. In June 2000, Ms. Critelli developed a one-year treatment plan for Student, which identified goals for both individual and group therapy. To increase Student’s language processing and production skills, Ms. Critelli used the “Links to Language” method in individual therapy sessions approximately three times a week for thirty minutes each. A review of that program indicates that the focus of Student’s speech and language therapy was on the development of her receptive and expressive language skills. (Footnote 26) While Ms. Critelli recommended that Student continue in that program, she acknowledged that “Links to Language” is not the only methodology that would be effective for Student. In her opinion, a structured, systematic program that uses repetition and direct instruction and incorporates parent training could work on the same skills for Student.

Dr. Freeman testified that the District’s offer of one thirty-minute individual and three thirty-minute group therapy sessions was appropriate for a child of Student’s level, because she needed to use language with other children in a natural environment. Dr. Freeman also testified that, as a general rule, she recommends that autistic children receive three hours of individual and two hours of group speech, but this depends upon the level of the child. She testified that she is now moving toward understanding the importance of the use of language in a natural environment. Considering Dr. Freeman’s recommendation for three hours of individual speech therapy for the typical autistic child, the Hearing Officer gives much less weight to her testimony of that one thirty-minute individual session is an appropriate amount of therapy for Student.(Footnote 27)

The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Critelli’s testimony regarding the amount of individual and group speech services Student required during the 2000-2001 school year to be persuasive and entitled to great weight in light of her extensive experience in treating autistic children, her extensive experience in working directly with Student throughout the past year, and her experience in working with school districts. Ms. Critelli testified that she has specialized in working with autistic children since becoming a licensed speech pathologist in 1988. Of her twenty-seven current private clients, fifteen are autistic children. For the past eight years, Ms. Critelli has split her time between her private practice and consulting with public school districts. As a school consultant, she has participated in the development of IEPs, conducted assessments, set up programs in SDC and other classes, and provided direct therapy to students.(Footnote 28)

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that Student required two hours of individual speech therapy and one hour of group therapy by a speech therapist with autism-specific experience during the 2000-2001 school year. Accordingly, the District’s offer was not designed to meet Student’s unique speech and language needs.

2. Was the District’s Program Reasonably Calculated to Provide Student with Some Educational Benefit?

From the weight of the evidence as discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s program was not reasonably calculated to provide Student with educational benefit. Specifically, given the critical phase in Student’s development in October 2000, the offered placement was not reasonably calculated to provide her with educational benefit because it did not address her unique learning needs for one-to-one ABA intervention or for appropriate language models; the total amount of ABA/DTT services offered was not sufficient; and the speech and language services did not provide her with a sufficient amount of individual speech therapy to address her unique needs.

3. Did the District’s program comport with Student’s IEP?

Because Student’s Mother did not consent to the IEP, Student never participated in the program offered by the District. It is therefore unnecessary to address this element. ***

For all the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District did not offer Student a FAPE during the 2000-2001 school year.

B. Procedural Appropriateness

Parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the IDEA and its implementing federal regulations. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).

Petitioner asserted a procedural violation for the District’s alleged failure to “develop” an IEP within thirty calendar days of the commencement of the school year as required by Education Code §§ 56344 and 56023 for each pupil referred for assessment twenty days or less prior to end of the previous school year. There was no dispute that Student was referred to the District for assessment less than twenty days before the end of the 1999-2000 school year. Under these sections, Student’s IEP should have been developed no later than October 4, 2000. No written agreement to extend the statutory time lines by Student’s Mother was presented. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s formal offer of placement on November 20, 2000, was forty-seven days late and was untimely.(Footnote 29)

Not all procedural violations automatically constitute a denial of FAPE. Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe upon the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of FAPE.” Id. at 1484. In this case, one of Student’s primary unique needs was for intensive early intervention services. The District’s delay in fully developing its offer in a timely manner came at a critical moment in Student’s life. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the untimely offer by the District resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for Student and constituted a denial of a FAPE.(Footnote 30)

ISSUE TWO: Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the cost of BECA’s program during the 2000-2001 school year and for the costs of private speech and language therapy by Ms. Critelli?

When a school district denies a student a FAPE, the student is entitled to relief that is “appropriate” in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S.Ct. 1996 (1985); see also, 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i) (1997). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement or services and the services provided by the parents were appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. In Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13, 113 S.Ct. 361 (1993), the Supreme Court specifically exempted parents from having to meet certain requirements of the IDEA in their unilateral placements. For example, parents are not required to conform their unilateral placement to the content of the student’s IEP or provide a placement that is certified by the state. Id. The Court has recognized that the parents’ placement does not have to meet a standard as high as a school district’s must meet; however, the parents’ placement must still meet other requirements of the IDEA, such as providing a placement that addresses the student’s needs and provides the student educational benefit. Id.

In light of the conclusion that the District did not offer Student a FAPE for the 2000-2001 school year, the Hearing Officer must determine whether Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement. Petitioner requests reimbursement for the cost of Student’s program with BECA, including costs for supervision, training, observation, meetings and evaluations of the program, as well as for Ms. Critelli’s services and for the costs of Student’s preschool, Kindercare.

The evidence established that BECA is a certified nonpublic agency that currently is providing services to the District pursuant to a fully executed master contract. The District did not dispute that BECA’s program addressed Student’s needs and provided her with educational benefit. Dr. Freeman acknowledged that BECA had “done a good job” with Student, that Student was making good progress; that it made sense for BECA not to start Student at the recommended level of forty hours a week but to work up gradually; and that the fact that Student was not ready for a typical preschool in October 2000 but was in January 2001 suggested that BECA appropriately paced her program.

The evidence persuasively established that Student’s home program addressed her unique needs and provided her with educational benefit. As indicated by Dr. Lennington and Ms. Critelli, Student’s most dramatic improvement was in the area of attending. Dr. Lennington testified that, on reevaluation in April 2001, she observed a dramatic change in Student’s ability to attend. Student was able to sit at the table and comply with requested tasks for a ninety-minute block of time and to return on request after a break. Although Student was still behind developmentally, she was able to engage in tasks that were previously difficult for her. Student demonstrated a ten-month gain in listening comprehension. Ms. Critelli also testified that she observed significant progress in Student’s attention and behavior. Whereas initially Student was able to focus for only five minutes, in April 2001, Student could attend to a structured, nonpreferred task for approximately twenty minutes of a thirty-minute session. It took Student approximately four or five months before she could focus for approximately fifteen minutes. Whereas originally Ms. Critelli had to physically move Student to transition to a new activity due to her distractibility, in April 2001 Student was able to respond to verbal directions to transition.

In addition to the costs of Student’s home aides, the parents incurred costs relating to direct and indirect supervision of the home program by BECA through Ms. Whitson. Ms. Whitson testified that she provided six hours a month in direct supervision of the program therapists and additional four hours of indirect supervision that involved developing Student’s curriculum, generating reports, and telephone consultation. After Student began attending preschool, she also provided direct supervision in the school two hours a month to supervise Student’s aide, and to monitor Student’s tolerance for her time in the program. Witnesses (Dr. Freeman, Ms. Dygean, Dr. Lennington) agreed that supervision was an essential component of Student’s home program. It was also undisputed that it was important for individuals working with autistic children to be trained and experienced in that disorder. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Whitson was appropriately trained and qualified.(Footnote 31)

Considering all the evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the costs of her program with BECA, including costs of supervision, training, observation, meetings and evaluations of the program at home and in consultation with the school, from the date of her eligibility on October 4, 2000 through the end of the 2000-2001 school year.

Petitioner also requests reimbursement for the costs of speech and language services provided to Student by Ms. Critelli. The District did not dispute that Ms. Critelli had addressed Student’s unique needs in her speech therapy or that Student was provided with educational benefit from those services. Ms. Critelli also testified that Student had demonstrated progress. Ms. Critelli testified that Student had responded well to the individual ‘Links to Language’ therapy, had progressed from sentence imitation to higher level skills, and had shown dramatic increases in her receptive language skills as demonstrated on the TACL-R. For example, at a chronological age of fifty months in June 2000, Student scored at the twenty-eight to thirty-one-month level on the elaborated sentences test that measures understanding more complex sentence structures. In April 2001, at a chronological age of sixty months, Student scored at the fifty- to fifty-three-month level on this same test. Student’s total raw score on the TACL-R increased from 36 to 75, and her standard score of 98 in April 2001 was in the average range. In April 2001, Ms. Critelli gave Student the Test of Language Development - Third edition (TOLD-3) that tests expressive language. Ms. Critelli testified that Student demonstrated significant scatter in her expressive language. In her view, the most significant point was that Student had some strong expressive areas that were close to the average range. Considering this evidence, the Hearing Officer concludes that the parents are entitled to reimbursement for the full costs of Student’s speech and language services during the 2000-2001 school year.

Finally, Petitioner requests reimbursement for the costs of Student’s typical preschool, Kindercare. Ms. Whitson and Dr. Freeman agreed that the primary purpose for Student’s attendance at school was to allow social contact with other children. Ms. Whitson testified that Student began attending Kindercare in January 2001 for one hour a day three days a week. She was in a class with seven typical children who ranged in age from three to five years old. Student’s Mother testified that there were actually twelve children in the class, but that it was divided into two groups and Student was in a group with six to seven typical peers.

Ms. Whitson testified that Student’s teacher Emily told Ms. Whitson that she had worked with autistic children in her class before. Ms. Whitson did not know if Emily was a credentialed teacher, but knew that she was supervised by a credentialed teacher who was in the class fifty percent of the time that Ms. Whitson observed it. From Ms. Whitson’s two observations of the class as of February 2001, Student appeared to have made progress. On her first day in school, Student was very reluctant to leave any adult and did not want to be near other children. She wanted to interact only with Ms. Whitson or her aide. Ms. Whitson testified that one of BECA’s targeted goals in the preschool was to decrease Student’s reliance on her aide and to encourage her to be independent. On Ms. Whitson’s second observation several weeks later, Student was able to go approximately fifteen feet from the aide and play independently on a climbing structure. Student was interacting at a beginning level with some peers, responded to brief contact, made some eye contact and hugged one other student. Despite this progress, Ms. Whitson testified that Student still has an aversion or fear of other students that is demonstrated by clenching her hands and staying close to adults. Student functioned well in the academic tasks required of her. Student’s Mother also saw positive improvements in Student’s social skills and in her willingness to interact with other children.

The Hearing Officer finds that the preschool was addressing Student’s needs for social interaction and communication and that Student received benefit from it. Accordingly, the parents are entitled to be reimbursed for the cost of Student’s attendance at Kindercare during the 2000-2001 school year.

ORDER

Within twenty (20) calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner’s parents for costs incurred from October 4, 2000, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, as follows:

a. For the full costs of Student’s program from BECA, including costs for direct and indirect supervision, training, observation, meetings and evaluations of the program at home and in consultation with the preschool school.

b. For the full costs of Student’s speech and language sessions with Ms. Critelli.

c. For the full costs of Student’s Kindercare Preschool.

PREVAILING PARTY

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute:

The Petitioner prevailed on all issues heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. California Education Code § 56505(i).

Dated: September 20, 2001 _____________________________________ Marilyn A. Woollard, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. Please note that the Hearing Office has recently changed its format for numbering cases. The case number now begins with the year the case was filed and is followed by a five-digit reference number.

2. Student’s biological father, Student’s Father, was not present at the hearing. Mr. S has been Student’s father-figure for approximately two years and has been an integral part of the implementation of her home educational program. For ease of reference, the term “parents” as used in this decision refers to Student’s Mother and Mr. S. 3. The issues outlined above differ from those originally submitted by the Petitioner in several respects. First, during the course of the hearing, Petitioner withdrew and amended several issues: On February 15, 2001, Petitioner withdrew occupational therapy as an issue; on February 16, 2001, Petitioner amended her request regarding the amount of individual speech therapy she required from five to two hours, to conform with the recommendation of Ms. Critelli; on April 20, 2001, Petitioner advised the Hearing Office and opposing counsel that she was withdrawing the issue of entitlement to reimbursement for the independent assessment conducted by Dr. Lennington. Second, the Hearing Officer has reorganized the issues for clarity of analysis. Petitioner’s original issue 2 asked whether Student “requires an applied behavioral analysis [ABA] program in order to obtain educational benefit.” As discussed within, the District has never disputed Student’s need for an ABA program; rather, the crux of the dispute between the parties is the appropriate amount of ABA services she requires. Petitioner’s original issue 4 asked whether Student requires speech and language therapy to obtain educational benefit. As discussed within, the District never disputed Student’s need for speech and language therapy; again, the dispute centered on the appropriate amount of individual versus group speech services she requires.

4.Ms. Bothwell is the wife of Petitioner’s attorney and is associated with the Newly Diagnosed Autism Support Group.

5.In July 2000, Student’s Mother also completed an application for Student to be seen at Dr. Freeman’s Autism Evaluation Clinic at UCLA’s Neuropsychiatric Institute. The Clinic acknowledged receipt of Student’s Mother’s application in an undated letter that advised her of a two- to three-month waiting list for appointments.

6.Ms. Critelli testified that she specialized in working with autistic children and suspected that Student was autistic. If Student had been diagnosed with autism before her assessment, autism would have been her primary diagnosis, with expressive and receptive language deficits as a related condition

7.Student later began receiving additional speech and language therapy at the Scottish Rite Clinic. Ms. Critelli testified that for approximately six months, she gave Student an additional session without charge until these free services were available.

8. Dr. Lennington’s report erroneously listed her assessment dates for Student in March 2000. At hearing, she testified that this was incorrect and that the assessment occurred on similar dates in June 2000. Dr. Lennington’s developmental assessment report was never reviewed by the District’s multidisciplinary assessment team or by the IEP team. The parents testified that the report was received sometime in November 2000. Evidence was received regarding attempts by the District to speak to her about Student and to obtain a copy of the report. Ms. Boyle testified that she left a voice mail message for Dr. Lennington during the assessment. Ms. Dygean testified that she left two voice mail messages for Dr. Lennington prior to the October 2, 2000 IEP and never received a return call. Dr. Lennington testified that she had never received a release of information signed by the parents and was therefore unable to discuss Student or the fact that Student was her client. Dr. Lennington testified that she received one voice mail from Ms. Dygean whom she knew only as a private practitioner, not as an employee of the District.

9.Ms. Dygean testified that her role at Student’s assessment was as administrative designee and as a mentor to the team. Ms. Dygean has master’s degrees in counseling and in educational psychology. She holds pupil personnel services credentials in both counseling and in school psychology. She is not a licensed clinical psychologist. Although Ms. Boyles had eight year’s experience as a school psychologist, she had been hired by the District in August 2000. Ms. Tan became a credentialed speech therapist in December 1999. Ms. Dygean spent approximately twenty minutes at the assessment. Ms. Dygean testified that she spent approximately twelve hours in preparation for testimony at the due process hearing, eight of which were in consultation with the attorney for the District.

10. Communication between the parties began to break down during the assessment. For example, the team asked Student’s Mother if they could observe Student in her new home program that same day. Student’s Mother did not know if a therapist was lined up for that day and said she would have to let the District know. On September 28, 2000, Mr. Bothwell advised Ms. Melly that he had been retained on Student’s behalf and understood that the District wished to postpone the IEP meeting to observe Student’s home program with BECA. Mr. Bothwell outlined various conditions for parental consent to the observation, including the parents’ wish to have an observer present to videotape the session observed by the District representative. This observation did not take place and the IEP meeting proceeded as scheduled. In addition, at the assessment, Student’s Mother signed releases of information at the District’s request, but then took the signed releases with her when she left the assessment. Mr. S later returned them to the District.

11. Ms. Dygean testified that, in the District, both the CDC centers and Head Start are part of general education at the preschool level. She testified that full inclusion in either of these programs was an option for Student because her parents met the eligibility criteria.

12. Ms. Dygean testified that the state requires teachers of autistic children to have a moderate-to-severe credential and that the class name does not follow the teacher’s credential.

13.They testified that Student is a high-functioning autistic child because of her language skills (Ms. Critelli) and her nonverbal performance (Ms. Boyles); due to the length of her spontaneous utterances, her level of individual play skills, and that fact that she initiates contact with adults (Ms. Whitson); due to her ability to be communicative beyond echolalia and her average cognitive range (Ms. Dygean); and because she was verbal and able to express her wants and needs (Ms. Tan). Dr. Freeman testified that, based upon her review of Student’s present levels of performance outlined in her October 2000 IEP, Student is a “very high functioning” autistic child with a good prognosis for outcome.

14. Ms. Critelli testified that she has specialized in working with autistic children and has done so since beginning her practice in 1988. She testified that, unlike a typically developing child, an autistic child requires direct systematic overlearning. Even though Student had not been formally diagnosed when Ms. Critelli assessed her, from her experience with autistic children, Ms. Critelli was confident that Student was autistic. Ms. Critelli recommended that discrete trial training services be explored for Student to increase her processing, behavior, attending for a variety of structured and nonstructured, preferred/nonpreferred tasks that gradually increase in length and complexity with then opportunities for generalizing these skills to small group and larger group settings.” According to Ms. Whitson, Student was a good candidate for ABA intervention because she had expressive/receptive language deficits, low eye contact and deficits in play skills.

15. The impaired communication category that was not applicable to Student was manifested in “delay in, or total lack of, the development of spoken language (not accompanied by an attempt to compensate through alternative modes of communication such as gesture or mime).”

16. Ms. Dygean characterized Student as wary, not responsive to Ms. Feo’s greeting, and observing the room peripherally. She did not hear Student scream. Ms. Feo testified that she saw Student and Mr. S on the rug with several other children during this observation and that Student did not seem afraid. She also testified that it was a very chaotic day and she did not recall anything else about Student.

17. In her assessment report, Ms. Critelli indicated that Student showed strengths in her ability to comprehend short simple sentences combined with visual information, in understanding some basic concepts; in comprehending different simple sentence constructions (verb and prepositional phrases, present tense); and in word classes and relations such as common simple vocabulary, short simple sentences, present progressive verb forms and quantitative concepts such as some, together and many.

18. Both Dr. Freeman and Dr. Lennington agreed that, in October 2000, neither a moderate-to-severe special day class nor a full-inclusion class/typical preschool class was appropriate for Student. They also agreed that, in January 2001, Student was ready for a typical preschool environment.

19. The program description for Ms. Feo’s class indicated that it used a “developmental play curriculum focusing on social skills, independence and communication,....” Dr. Freeman’s only criticism of the three-hour class was that it should be longer.

20. Dr. Freeman testified that she spent approximately twelve hours preparing to testify. She met with Respondent’s attorney for approximately eight hours (reviewing the state of the art scientifically regarding programs for autistic children), and spent an additional three to four hours reviewing documents. Dr. Freeman testified as an expert witness pursuant to a one-year “Agreement for Services” with the District that required her to provide consultation services for the office of Special Education “to include services as an expert witness in due process and legal matters specific to cases involving students with autism.”

21. When she testified in April 2001, Ms. Feo indicated that the class had eight pupils. Of these, two pupils who were nonverbal at the beginning of the year spoke with initial consonant sounds or one-word utterances respectively; two pupils who began with one-to two-word utterances were using short sentences; one pupil spoke in two- to three-word utterances; one pupil spoke in complete sentences but was unintelligible; one pupil was echolalic and rarely used spontaneous speech; and one pupil was high functioning and spoke in complete sentences.

22. Mr. S testified that Student did not participate in the entire amount of ABA/DTT intervention recommended because the parents could not fully fund the recommended program. Dr. Freeman testified that Student made good progress on approximately twenty hours a week in her home program based upon her review of BECA’s invoices through February 2001 (Petitioner’s Ex. P). The progress to which Dr. Freeman referred was Student’s mastery of eight DTT programs mentioned in Ms. Whitson’s December 11, 2000 consultation report that she indicated should then be placed in Student’s maintenance book for periodic review. (Petitioner’s Ex. N). The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s progress in these specific programs does not indicate that twenty hours was a sufficient amount of ABA/DTT services. Given Student’s significant deficits in multiple areas, there was no evidence that the mastery of these few programs brought Student’s skills to a level requiring fewer hours. Rather, as part of BECA’s supervision of the home program, Ms. Whitson continually reviewed Student’s progress and expanded her programs by adding new levels to build on existing skills and by addressing completely new skills.

23. Ms. Tan testified that she has a master’s degree in communicative disorders and received her speech and language credential in December of 1999. She was hired by the District in September 2000. Prior to receiving her credential, Ms. Tan worked as a communication aide for the District, primarily with nonverbal children using the Picture Exchange Communication or PECs system. Ms. Tan currently works at the District’s preschool assessment center as a member of the transdisciplinary assessment team. She also has a caseload of student and works with students in an autistic preschool class. Student was one of the first children she assessed at the District. 24. Student’s speech and language goals contained in the IEP of 10/4/00 were as follows: (1) to correctly answer “who,” “what,” and “where” questions without the use of cues; (2) (pragmatics) to improve social communication by maintaining topic for two conversational turns during structured therapy activities when given verbal cues; (3) to follow rules of organized play and initiate social interactions with peers given verbal prompts when needed; and (4) to increase length and complexity of utterances by producing sentences 5-8 words in length containing targeted linguistic structures.

25. Ms. Melly testified that District speech therapist Terrilee Peirce was the speech therapist assigned to Lowell and that she had a life credential that authorized her to provide speech and hearing services. Ms. Melly provided a copy of this credential as well as a list of autism in-services classes contained in Ms. Peirce’s personnel file. Ms. Peirce did not testify.

26. This program focused on (1) developing a core receptive vocabulary of nouns and verbs, (2) extending verbal memory for commands of increased length and complexity; (3) developing receptive understanding of prepositions (in, on, under); (4) developing expressive language skills for imitating key sentence patterns ranging from three word sentences to nine word sentences; (5) developing expressive language skills for answering questions (who, what, where, which is/has +ing); (6) developing expressive language skills for answering questions or describing the nonpresent; (7) developing expressive language skills for oral narrative skills by retelling sequenced verbal material; and (8) increasing receptive and expressive vocabulary skills and concepts for content materials appropriate for a preschool curriculum and functional language units.

27. Lennington also recommended that Student receive three hours of individual speech and language therapy. The Hearing Officer notes that, while neither Dr. Freeman nor Dr. Lennington is a speech pathologist/therapist, each has special knowledge about the speech and language needs of autistic children.

28. Ms. Critelli also that testified Dr. Loren Franke, director of the Scottish Rite Clinic, refers many clients to her private practice and that Dr. Franke has been her mentor for many years. Dr. Freeman testified that, in her opinion, all persons who work with autistic children, including speech therapists, must have autism-specific experience. She testified that she has high regard for Ms. Critelli’s mentor, Dr. Franke.

29. On October 4, 2000, the District offered two very broad options for potential placement to the parents. The placement ultimately offered on November 20,2000, fell within the parameters of one of the options offered on October 4, 2000, in that Ms. Feo was an SDC teacher with a moderate-to-severe credential. This was not a formal, specific offer, however, within the meaning of Union v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526, but essentially left the parents in the position of attempting to determine the best placement for Student.

30. In addition to this issue, Petitioner asserted numerous procedural violations and argued that they constituted a denial of FAPE. Petitioner’s specific procedural claims were first articulated at great length in her closing brief. In its closing brief, Respondent asserted that, because procedural violations had not been explicitly raised in Petitioner’s statement of issues, the only issue before the Hearing Officer was whether Student had been substantively offered a FAPE. The Hearing Officer notes that, in her opening statement, Petitioner broadly raised the issue of the procedural adequacy of the District’s offer. Thereafter, evidence on these issues was elicited by Petitioner without objection from the District, which pursued these topics in its own examination of witnesses. While the evidence suggests there is merit to some of these asserted procedural violations, in light of the conclusions reached above, the Hearing Officer finds it unnecessary to address the balance of Petitioner’s procedural claims.

31. Ms. Whitson testified that she has a master’s degree in clinical psychology and is a board certified associate behavior analyst. From May 1997 to February 2000, she worked at the Lovaas Institute for Early Intervention as a senior aide (training students in modification techniques), as an assessment administrator (administering psycho-educational assessments to children diagnosed with autism to determine cognitive and language ability and adaptive functioning); as a workshop coordinator (for workshops demonstrating use of early intervention techniques) and as a case supervisor (supervising and developing intensive behavioral treatment programs of children diagnosed as autistic and training staff in the use of behavior techniques).