California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 27, 2005
Student v. San Marcos Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2138-04 · Hearing Officer Christian M. Knox
San Marcos Unified must reimburse and fund NewBridge School placement for 2004-05; claims for earlier years mostly denied.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
The parent of a 12-year-old sixth grader eligible for special education for a speech and language impairment requested a due process hearing. San Marcos Unified then filed its own request, and the cases were consolidated. The student had spent three years in a special day class at Carrillo Elementary School. For middle school, the District offered resource specialist program (RSP) classes and general education at San Elijo Middle School. The parent instead placed him at NewBridge School, a nonpublic school in Poway. Under the three-year limit, claims reached back to July 19, 2001.
The Hearing Officer found that no oral motor assessment was needed in any year and upheld most of the District's IEPs through 2003-04. There were two limited violations. In 2002-03 the District did not provide or offer a daily speech-production aide, and the February 2004 IEP left out speech and language goals. No compensatory education was awarded for either violation, because the student kept making progress in speech.
For 2004-05, the Hearing Officer held that the District denied a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The student needed a small, structured setting, and the RSP classes were too large. The offer also lacked vision therapy and occupational therapy (OT) goals, did not say how long vision therapy sessions would last, and left out a computer-based auditory processing program. The District must:
- reimburse NewBridge tuition ($3,500 per quarter) and mileage
- fund NewBridge through the end of 2004-05
- provide compensatory vision therapy and OT consultation
Why it matters
This decision shows how a SEHO Hearing Officer reviewed many years of IEPs one at a time, judging each on what was known when it was written. It also shows that an offer built around a parent's request for the neighborhood school can still deny FAPE when that setting cannot give the student the small, structured class he needs.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 1A. During the 2001 ESY, from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, did the District fail to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability (oral motor assessment)?
No oral motor assessment was needed; the speech therapist knew and met the student's needs, and he was progressing in articulation.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 1B. During the 2001 ESY, from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, did the District fail to offer and provide Student a FAPE?
No FAPE denial because the track-schedule District held no July 2001 ESY session; claims about the February 27, 2001 IEP fell outside the limitations period.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2A. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?
An oral motor assessment was not required; speech production, including oral motor skills, improved.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 2B. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to offer and provide Student with a FAPE (June 20, 2001 and February 13, 2002 IEPs)?
IEPs were procedurally proper and met the student's needs. The Hearing Officer found no fine motor, social-emotional or attention needs, and held that the goals, accommodations, trained speech aide and existing auditory processing methods were adequate.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 3A. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?
An oral motor assessment was not needed because oral motor skills continued to improve.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 3B. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to offer and provide Student with a FAPE?
FAPE was denied only because the District did not provide the daily speech-production aide required by the February 2002 IEP and then did not offer one in the February 2003 IEP. All other contentions failed.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 4A. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?
No oral motor assessment was required; articulation had improved so much that ending articulation services was considered.
- Student prevailed in partIEP content
Issue 4B. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to offer and provide Student with a FAPE?
The February 23, 2004 IEP had no complete speech and language goals, which denied FAPE from that date through year-end. Claims about the aide, auditory processing, accommodations, team members, safeguards, grading and testing all failed.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 5A. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District fail to assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?
No oral motor assessment was needed; even the student's own speech expert saw no deficits warranting one.
- Student prevailedPlacement and LRE
Issue 5B. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District fail to offer Student a FAPE?
The October 25, 2004 offer of RSP and general education at San Elijo denied FAPE. The student needed a small, structured setting, and the offer lacked OT and vision therapy goals, left out a computer-based auditory processing program, and did not state vision therapy duration.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 6. If the District failed to provide Student a FAPE for the 2001 ESY and the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
No compensatory education was awarded. The requested Fast ForWord and academic instruction did not relate to the speech violations, and the student kept progressing in speech.
- Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered
Issue 7A. If the District failed to offer Student a FAPE for 2004-2005, is he entitled to compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy, vision therapy, the Fast ForWord program, and academic instruction?
Compensatory vision therapy and OT consultation were awarded. Fast ForWord was denied because NewBridge already provides it at no extra cost, and academic instruction was denied for lack of evidence.
- Student prevailed in partUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7B. Is Student entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program and NewBridge, a nonpublic school, from August 30, 2004, through the date of the Decision, and reimbursement for transportation costs through the date of the Decision?
NewBridge tuition and mileage were reimbursed because NewBridge was appropriate. Phono-Genix (spring 2004) was denied for lack of connection to the 2004-2005 denial of FAPE.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7C. Is Student entitled to prospective placement at NewBridge for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The District must fund NewBridge through the end of its 2004-2005 regular school year because a mid-spring move without an appropriate IEP and transition would harm the student.
- Student prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 7D. Is Student entitled to round-trip transportation costs to NewBridge in Poway for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The District must reimburse actual round-trip mileage at the District rate through the end of NewBridge's 2004-2005 school year.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Compensatory education. Fifteen hours of vision therapy and four hours of occupational therapy consultation, unless the parties agree otherwise in writing. Services must begin within 30 calendar days of the Decision and be completed by September 1, 2005. (The body of the decision describes the vision therapy as fifteen sessions; the Order says fifteen hours.)
- Reimbursement. Within 20 calendar days of receipt of proof, reimburse the parents for NewBridge enrollment fee and tuition from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through the date of the Decision. The decision notes tuition of $3,500 per quarter.
- Prospective funding of private placement. The District must fund the student's placement at NewBridge from the date of the Decision through the end of NewBridge's 2004-2005 regular school year.
- Reimbursement. Reimburse the parents at the District's mileage rate for actual round-trip mileage on days the student attends NewBridge, from the beginning through the end of NewBridge's 2004-2005 school year. Past costs are due within 20 calendar days of proof; costs for the rest of the year are to be paid at least monthly.
Total: 19 hours of compensatory services
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist.; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Adams v. State of Oregon; M.L. v. Federal Way School Dist.; Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Comm. of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ.; Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter; Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Jackie Bachman, director of special education, San Marcos Unified School District
- Lola Harlan, coordinator of special education, San Marcos Unified School District
- Davina Hsiao, school psychologist (2002 psychoeducational evaluation), San Marcos Unified School District
- Celeste Doughty (also spelled Dougherty), school psychologist (2004 triennial psychoeducational evaluation), San Marcos Unified School District
- Valerie Hutchinson, speech and language pathologist, San Marcos Unified School District
- Theresa Lerager, resource specialist, San Marcos Unified School District
- Colleen Wann, special day class teacher, Carrillo Elementary School, San Marcos Unified School District
- Shannon O'Brien, occupational therapist, San Marcos Unified School District
- Kathleen Wohlgemuth (also referred to as Karen), expert witness for District on auditory processing; program specialist and speech-language pathologist, Anaheim Union High School District
- Suzie Sherwin, resource specialist (RSP) teacher, San Elijo Middle School, San Marcos Unified School District
- Emily Tuten, speech and language pathologist, San Elijo Middle School, San Marcos Unified School District
- Kristen Parker (also spelled Kristine), speech and language pathologist; trained and supervised the speech-production aide, San Marcos Unified School District
- Bobbi Marcel, speech and language therapist (2002-2003), San Marcos Unified School District
- Ted Solino, general education teacher, San Marcos Unified School District
- Fred Wise, principal, Carrillo Elementary School
- Amy Jensen, special day class teacher with general education credential, San Marcos Unified School District
- Debra Tadman, general education teacher at IEP meeting, San Marcos Unified School District
- Lois Campbell, school psychologist (1999 evaluation), San Marcos Unified School District
- Patricia Black-Welch, speech therapist (1998 report), San Marcos Unified School District
- Audrey Weed, assistive technology evaluator (District-requested)
- Dr. Richard M. Skay, vision examiner who did the vision and visual perceptual assessment (District-requested)
- Maria K. Abramson, audiologist; auditory processing evaluation at District request; witness for Student
- Mitchel Perlman, forensic psychologist; private evaluator and expert witness for Student
- Susan Berkowitz, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student
- Janice L. Dalby, occupational therapist; witness for Student, NewBridge School
- Steven Mayo, director, NewBridge School
- Sabrina Macfarlane, math and science teacher, NewBridge School
- Melissa Sisto, phonics and writing teacher, NewBridge School
- Cynthia Haddow, spelling and social studies teacher, NewBridge School
- NewBridge School, nonpublic school (parent's unilateral placement), Poway, California
- Phono-Genix program, private reading program
- Sylvan Learning Center, private assessment provider (2000)
- ABC Children's Center, private school (kindergarten repeat year)
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before Christian M. Knox, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific=s McGeorge School of Law, in San Marcos, California, on January 26 through 28, and February 1, 2, and 8-10, 2005.
Petitioner/Cross-Respondent STUDENT (Student or STUDENT) was represented at the hearing by attorney Patricia E. Cromer. Also present on the Student=s behalf was his mother, MOTHER, and on the first day of the hearing, his grandmother, GRANDMOTHER. Assisting Ms. Cromer at various times during the hearing was law clerk John Ireland. Respondent/Cross-Petitioner, San Marcos Unified School District (District) was represented by attorney Jonathan Read from the law firm of Lozano Smith. Also present on behalf of the District was Jackie Bachman, director of special education.
The Student called the following witnesses: MOTHER, mother; Janice L. Dalby, private occupational therapist; Sabrina Macfarlane, teacher at NewBridge School (NewBridge); Melissa Sisto, teacher at NewBridge; Cynthia Haddow, teacher at NewBridge; Susan Berkowitz, private speech pathologist; Steven Mayo, director of NewBridge; Maria Abramson, audiologist; and Mitchel Perlman, forensic psychologist.
The District called the following witnesses: Jackie Bachman, director of special education; Davina Hsiao, school psychologist; Celeste Doughty, school psychologist; Valerie Hutchinson, speech and language pathologist; Theresa Lerager, resource specialist; Colleen Wann, special day class teacher; Shannon O=Brien, occupational therapist; Kathleen Wohlgemuth, program specialist with the Anaheim Union High School District; Suzie Sherwin, resource specialist; and Lola Harlan, coordinator of special education.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the receipt of written closing arguments on March 14, 2005, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUES (Footnote 1)
1. During the 2001 extended school year (ESY), from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
2. During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
3. During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to: 1. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and 2. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
4. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
5. During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer STUDENT a FAPE?
6. If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 ESY and for the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
7. If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, is he entitled to: A. Compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy, vision therapy, the Fast ForWord program, and academic instruction; B. Reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program and NewBridge, a nonpublic school from August 30, 2004, through the date of this Decision and reimbursement for transportation costs through the date of this Decision; 3. Prospective placement at NewBridge for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year; and
D. Round-trip transportation costs to NewBridge in Poway, California, for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
PROCEDURAL MATTER
California Education Code section 56505(j) provides that a request for due process hearing must be made within three years from the date the parties knew or had reason to know of the facts underlying the basis for the request. In this case, Student filed his request on July 19, 2004. It is undisputed that the period of time at issue in this case commences on July 19, 2001. The Student has raised procedural and substantive violations for each school year from July 19, 2001, through the 2004-2005 school year.
BACKGROUND FACTS
STUDENT is a twelve-year-old boy who has been receiving special education services since kindergarten under the qualifying category of speech and language impaired. STUDENT resides within the boundaries of the District with his mother, stepfather, and a sibling. STUDENT was unilaterally placed by his parents at NewBridge, a certified nonpublic school (NPS), on August 30, 2004. STUDENT is currently in the sixth grade and, at this time, is not receiving any services other than those provided within the regular programming at NewBridge.
STUDENT=s mother first noticed that STUDENT had a communication problem when he was between eighteen months and two years old. In 1996, when STUDENT was three years old, MOTHER contacted his district of residence at that time, Vista Unified School District (Vista), to obtain services. Vista assessed STUDENT and found him eligible for special education services under the qualifying condition of speech and language impaired. STUDENT was provided with speech and language therapy for a short time; however, because the services were offered in the middle of the day, MOTHER discontinued services due to a conflict with her employment.
At the conclusion of the 1996-1997 school year, STUDENT and his family relocated to a residence within the boundaries of the District. STUDENT was assessed by the District in June 1997. The assessment revealed that STUDENT had speech and language needs in the areas of articulation, phonology, language comprehension, and expressive language. The District thereafter identified STUDENT as eligible for special education and related services.
During the 1997-1998 school year, when STUDENT was in kindergarten, he was placed at Alvin Dunn School in a regular education classroom and received speech and language services. During April 1998, a discussion was held concerning retaining STUDENT in kindergarten due to his lack of academic progress. On May 27, 1998, STUDENT=s annual IEP meeting was held. The IEP team agreed to retain STUDENT in kindergarten for the 1998-1999 school year and to continue placement at Alvin Dunn School in a regular education classroom with speech and language services. Instead, STUDENT was unilaterally placed by MOTHER at ABC Children=s Center, a private school, for the 1998-1999 school year to repeat kindergarten. MOTHER did not disagree with the placement and services offered by the District but was hopeful that a private school would provide STUDENT the opportunity to achieve greater academic gains.
In January 1999, the District conducted a thorough assessment of STUDENT. The District determined that STUDENT had significant auditory memory and processing delays. The assessment concluded that STUDENT had needs in the areas of number facility and applied skills, and an inability to reproduce designs from memory, that he inconsistently recited the alphabet with some omissions, and that he had deficits in social/emotional development and reading decoding. STUDENT was described as fearful and anxious. The IEP team convened on February 25, 1999, to discuss the assessment. The IEP team concluded that without special education intervention, STUDENT would not be able to participate and progress in learning and social situations. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT receive resource specialist program (RSP) support four days per week for sixty minutes per session and speech and language therapy. During this school year, STUDENT was also diagnosed by his pediatrician as having attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD) and prescribed Ritalin. STUDENT continued his placement at ABC Children=s Center for the remainder of the school year, at his parents= expense, but received RSP support and speech and language services from the District.
The IEP team reconvened on March 11, 1999, to determine STUDENT=s placement for the 1999-2000 school year. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a regular education classroom and receive RSP support during 22 percent of his school day and thirty minutes per week of speech and language therapy. Goals and objectives were written in the areas of language comprehension, expression, and articulation.
STUDENT was placed for first grade at Carrillo Elementary School for the 1999-2000 school year. (Footnote 2) He received speech and language services from Valerie Hutchinson and RSP support from Theresa Lerager. The IEP team met on November 27, 1999, and increased STUDENT=s RSP services by one-half hour per day and developed goals and objectives in the area of math calculation.
On February 24, 2000, the IEP team met for an annual review. The IEP team increased STUDENT=s time in RSP to 51 percent of his school day. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT continue to receive speech and language services for the 2000-2001 school year. Goals and objectives were developed in the areas of reading, writing, math, articulation, grammar, and syntax. STUDENT continued to receive RSP support from Ms. Lerager and speech and language therapy from Ms. Hutchinson during the 2000-2001 school year. On August 22, 2000, a private assessment was obtained by STUDENT=s parents from the Sylvan Learning Center. The assessment recommended that STUDENT receive assistance through a Lindamood-Bell program.
On February 27, 2001, the IEP team convened for an annual review. The District recommended that STUDENT continue to be placed in a general education classroom with RSP support and speech and language therapy. The IEP indicated that STUDENT was to be in RSP 49 percent of the school day. In addition, the IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading, written language, math, articulation, and grammar. MOTHER agreed with the District=s recommendation. The IEP team reconvened on June 20, 2001, to discuss STUDENT=s progress and to discuss placement for the 2001-2002 school year. The IEP team agreed to increase STUDENT=s RSP support to 78 percent of the day for the remainder of the school year. The IEP team further agreed that STUDENT would be placed in a Alearning handicapped@ (LH) special day class (SDC) for the 2001-2002 school year and continue to receive speech and language therapy. In addition, the IEP team agreed that STUDENT would receive twenty days of extended school year (ESY) programming while he was off track. The IEP team indicated that STUDENT should receive small-group instruction and multisensory strategies for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year and the 2001 ESY.
For the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was placed in the LH SDC of Colleen Wann. In anticipation of STUDENT=s triennial review, the District conducted a speech and language evaluation and a psychoeducational evaluation. The speech and language assessor concluded that STUDENT continued to have articulation errors and low receptive and expressive vocabulary skills, in addition to delayed skills in expressive sentence structure and formation and categories. The psychoeducational report revealed that STUDENT had average cognitive ability. Measures of his social/emotional functioning revealed that he had at-risk behaviors in adaptability and depression, and clinically significant behaviors in anxiety. STUDENT was found to exhibit processing deficits in the areas of auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. The school psychologist, Davina Hsiao, recommended that STUDENT=s teacher continue to provide interventions in the classroom environment, and that his teachers utilize teaching methods that emphasize simultaneous approaches to learning, continue to assist STUDENT in developing appropriate learning behaviors, have STUDENT repeat number and letter combinations to assist in sequential memory, have him repeat and write tongue twisters, et cetera, to facilitate auditory short-term memory, and utilize memory tricks whenever possible. During the middle of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT=s parents provided him with tutoring from an SDC teacher with the Oceanside Unified School District two times per week in one-hour sessions, for reading and math.
On February 13, 2002, the IEP team met for STUDENT=s triennial review. The District recommended that STUDENT continue to be placed in Ms. Wann=s LH SDC and continue to receive speech and language services. MOTHER agreed with the District=s recommendation. According to the IEP, STUDENT was to attend an ESY program for twenty days. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading, written language, math, speech production, and expressive language. The IEP also indicated that on State- or District-wide assessments STUDENT would be tested in all content areas at his instructional level and that accommodations would be provided including extended time and frequent breaks. STUDENT=s mother was provided with a Notice of Procedural Safeguards.
On February 11, 2003, the IEP team met to conduct an annual review. The District recommended that STUDENT continue to be placed in Ms. Wann=s SDC with mainstreaming for physical education and speech and language therapy. MOTHER agreed with the District=s recommendation. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, spelling, math, articulation, and expressive grammar. The IEP team discussed State- and District-wide assessments and indicated that STUDENT should receive modifications including extended time, small-group settings, and frequent breaks. The IEP team also recommended that STUDENT continue to receive twenty days of ESY services. MOTHER received and signed for a Notice of Procedural Safeguards. During the 2002-2003 school year STUDENT continued to receive private tutoring from an outside SDC teacher.
During the 2003-2004 school year, when STUDENT was in the fifth grade, he continued in Ms. Wann=s SDC. On October 7, 2003, the IEP team reconvened to discuss STUDENT=s progress in his placement and his desire to be mainstreamed into general education classes. The notes from the IEP meeting indicate that STUDENT was being Amainstreamed@ into an RSP class for one hour per day, four days per week, for reading and written language. The IEP team indicated that they would pursue additional mainstreaming options for STUDENT. During the 2003-2004 school year, STUDENT=s parents sought assistance for him from a reading specialist with the Phono-Genix program.
In anticipation of STUDENT=s annual IEP meeting, Ms. Hutchinson drafted a goal dated February 4, 2004, because she was unable to attend the IEP meeting. On February 23, 2004, the IEP team reconvened for STUDENT=s annual IEP meeting. The District again recommended placement in an SDC for 70 percent of the school day with speech and language therapy and ESY services. MOTHER agreed to the District=s recommendations. In addition, the IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading comprehension, reading decoding, written language, math, and articulation. The IEP team found that STUDENT should receive accommodations when taking the State- or District-wide assessments, including extended time and administration in a small group. MOTHER received a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards.
MOTHER desired to increase STUDENT=s skills during the 2003-2004 school year so that he could transition to the RSP when he entered middle school. STUDENT continued to receive after-school tutoring at his parents= expense and he started attending Ms. Lerager=s RSP class for math. Because STUDENT=s reading was MOTHER=s primary concern, STUDENT=s reading was again tested by Ms. Lerager in June 2004, using the Gray Oral Reading Test - Fourth Edition (GORT-4). Ms. Lerager determined that STUDENT=s overall reading proficiency was Aseverely deficient.@ STUDENT scored in the 1st percentile in rate and fluency, the 5th percentile in accuracy, and the 16th percentile in comprehension. In August 2004, the Woodcock Johnson was re-administered and he received improved test scores compared to the GORT-4 administered by Ms. Lerager. STUDENT=s reading comprehension and fluency scores were in the 4th percentile and vocabulary in the 3rd percentile. STUDENT=s letter-word identification was in the 9th percentile and his word attack was in the 27th percentile. STUDENT received services from the Phono-Genix program during February, March, and April of 2004, and testing in April 2004 revealed an increase in scores in blending, segmenting, and code knowledge, and a negligible increase in auditory processing.
On June 21, 2004, the IEP team reconvened for the purpose of discussing the testing results and to consider a placement for STUDENT for middle school. The IEP team prepared an addendum to the February 23, 2004 IEP. Shannon O=Brien, an occupational therapist with the District, was invited to the IEP team meeting to discuss whether STUDENT required an OT assessment. It was decided that STUDENT did not demonstrate deficits that would support an occupational therapy (OT) assessment. MOTHER advised the District that she had purchased a home in the San Elijo Middle School attendance area. MOTHER was informed that at that time San Elijo did not have an SDC. The District recommended placement at Woodland Park Middle School in an SDC, with mainstreaming for physical education. The District also indicated that STUDENT could receive math and/or social studies with RSP support instead of the SDC. The IEP team also discussed conducting STUDENT=s assessments for his triennial review earlier than required to receive data to support consideration of alternative placement options. MOTHER did not consent to the proposed IEP.
On July 7, 2004, MOTHER provided the District with a dissent to the June 21, 2004 IEP. In her dissent, MOTHER notified the District that she intended to obtain independent evaluations for STUDENT and that she believed the appropriate placement for STUDENT was in an RSP class or in general education with aide support. MOTHER also notified the District that because it did not offer STUDENT a FAPE, she was seeking placement in a nonpublic school and reimbursement from the District.
On July 19, 2004, the Student filed a request for a due process hearing with the Hearing Office.
On July 28, 2004, MOTHER consented to an early triennial evaluation for STUDENT. The District sought to assess STUDENT in the areas of academic achievement, psychomotor development, language/speech/communication development, cognitive functioning, social/emotional adaptive behavior, assistive technology, central auditory processing, visual processing, and health. STUDENT=s speech and language evaluation was completed in August 2004 and showed that he exhibited strengths in pragmatics, grammar, and syntax structure. STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with the Aunderstanding of language in the areas of auditory comprehension, reasoning, and memory.@
The District attempted to schedule an IEP meeting for August 9, 2004, but MOTHER and her attorney were unavailable. The District wanted to resolve STUDENT=s placement for the 2004-2005 school year prior to the first day of school, August 16, 2004. The date proposed by STUDENT=s attorney for the IEP meeting was August 18, 2004.
On August 4, 2004, the District, through its attorney, wrote a letter to STUDENT=s attorney and advised that it believed the placement at Woodland Park Middle School was best suited to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, but that it was formally offering a placement at San Elijo Middle School in response to MOTHER=s request. The District offered STUDENT four periods per day of RSP services in math, language arts, reading, and organizational skills, including support in science and history, and two periods per day in general education for science and social science, which would include a combination of history, exploratory, and physical education. The District indicated a willingness to convene an IEP meeting prior to the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year. The District further indicated that if STUDENT=s parents would like him placed at San Elijo they should forward their consent to the District.
Sometime during the middle of August 2004, MOTHER decided to place STUDENT at NewBridge for the 2004-2005 school year and notified the District of her intent.
On August 13, 2004, the District again wrote a letter to STUDENT=s attorney, wherein it acknowledged the family=s decision to place STUDENT at NewBridge in Poway, California, and provided clarification of a specific class schedule for STUDENT at San Elijo. The proposed class schedule included homeroom taught by an RSP teacher, RSP language arts, RSP math, band or physical education and history in general education, lunch with homework support two days per week, art two days per week, and social skills activities one day per week.
On August 18, 2004, the IEP team reconvened to discuss placement for the 2004-2005 school year. The IEP team reviewed the offer contained in the District=s August 13, 2004 letter. The District identified a technology class as a possible mainstreaming opportunity for STUDENT. The District continued to offer speech and language therapy and aide support for thirty minutes per week for earth science. The IEP team also continued to offer ESY services for twenty days. The IEP team decided to meet again on September 28, 2004, to review assessments, goals, and any modifications and accommodations which might be necessary. At the conclusion of the meeting STUDENT=s attorney stated that STUDENT would attend NewBridge commencing August 30, 2004.
On August 11 and 25, 2004, an OT evaluation was conducted by Shannon O=Brien, occupational therapist for the District. Ms. O=Brien concluded that STUDENT demonstrated functional development of Aprehension,@ visual motor, and bilateral coordination skills to adequately participate in fine motor activities at school. He also demonstrated average overall visual motor control and average quick dexterity skills. STUDENT was able to produce fairly legible manuscript penmanship at an adequate speed. However, his cursive penmanship showed significantly reduced legibility and speed in both copying and writing tasks. Ms. O=Brien recommended that STUDENT continue to participate in a structured program with multisensory experiences, visual supports, and memory strategies and that the IEP team consider the use of a soft-grip molded mechanical pencil to support use of a consistent grasp and to reduce hand fatigue.
On August 25, 2004, the District filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. Thereafter, the Student=s and the District=s cases were consolidated.
On August 30, 2004, STUDENT began attending NewBridge in Poway, California, approximately twenty minutes from San Marcos. NewBridge has fifty-four students in the school with a maximum of eight students in each classroom. All classrooms are multi-grade and there are currently two middle school groups: sixth and seventh, and seventh and eighth. NewBridge works to transition students back into more traditional educational programs. NewBridge employs a full-time speech and language therapist and a full-time occupational therapist. NewBridge is a language-based educational program and provides services to children with language-based disabilities, such as expressive and receptive language deficits, dyslexia, dyspraxia, and dysgraphia.
On September 13, 2004, Audrey Weed completed an assistive technology functional evaluation for STUDENT at the request of the District. Ms. Weed recommended that STUDENT use software designed to assist students with delays in written language skills, such as Co:Writer, Write:Outloud, and Draft:Builder, a talking spell check and dictionary, and an outlining program. It was also recommended that STUDENT receive systematic instruction in keyboarding skills.
On September 15, 2004, an auditory processing evaluation was completed by Maria K. Abramson, M.S., CCC-A, at the District=s request. Ms. Abramson concluded that STUDENT had normal hearing and middle ear functioning, but he had weaknesses in Abottom top@ auditory processing skills. (Footnote 3) Ms. Abramson also concluded that STUDENT had a deficit in central auditory maturation for processing words that was more than one standard deviation below the mean. Ms. Abramson recommended STUDENT participate in an auditory training program such as the Basic Auditory Training Program or Fast ForWord. She also recommended various accommodations and strategies be implemented by STUDENT=s teachers.
On September 27, 2004, Celeste Dougherty, school psychologist, finalized her report of STUDENT=s psychoeducational evaluation which had been performed on August 11, 16, and 25, 2004. According to his results on the Weschler Intelligence Scale for Children - Fourth Edition (WISC- IV), STUDENT=s scores in processing speed and perceptual reasoning were in the average range, with verbal comprehension in the low average range, and working memory in the extremely low range. STUDENT=s full scale intelligence quotient (IQ) was reported to be borderline. The Comprehensive Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (CTONI) revealed that STUDENT=s nonverbal intelligence was within the low average range. Visual motor testing showed that STUDENT=s ability to integrate perceptual and motor processes was within the average range, but he demonstrated low visual-perceptual-motor integration skills. STUDENT showed significant deficits in the area of short-term memory, scoring in the 1st percentile in number memory, sentence memory, word memory, auditory word discrimination, and auditory quotient. On the Visual Aural Digit Span Test, STUDENT scored below norms in all subtests except in the area of aural-written functioning.
At the September 28, 2004 IEP team meeting, the IEP team reviewed the District=s psychoeducational assessment, speech and language assessment, OT assessment, and assistive technology assessment. STUDENT was identified as having short-term memory and sequential processing skills weaknesses. In the area of speech, STUDENT was identified as continuing to qualify for special education under the category of speech and language impaired and as exhibiting the greatest weakness with inferences. Audrey Weed, the assistive technology evaluator, suggested that STUDENT receive a trial of software and a keyboarding program. No OT services were recommended. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading/vocabulary development, reading comprehension, reading decoding, memory, written language, speech, assistive technology, and math. The District recommended that STUDENT receive accommodations in State- or District-wide assessments including a small-group setting and extended time. The IEP team agreed to reconvene on October 25, 2004, to continue the meeting.
On October 8, 2004, a visual exam and visual perceptual analysis were performed by Dr. Richard M. Skay at the District=s request. Dr. Skay concluded that STUDENT needed improvement in eye focus, speed of accommodation, eye movement, eye fixation, eye tracking, fusional divergence, convergence binocular training, posture, pencil grip, and reading distance, including lateral and directional training to reduce reversals and improve letter/sound recognition. Dr. Skay recommended fifteen sessions of vision therapy.
On October 25, 2004, the IEP team met to finalize STUDENT=s triennial review. Representatives from NewBridge, STUDENT=s private educational placement, were invited and attended the IEP meeting. The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed at San Elijo with RSP support, including three RSP classes per day. In addition, they recommended that STUDENT receive direct speech and language services one time per week for forty-seven minutes, speech and language consultation one time per month for thirty minutes, OT consultation one time per month for thirty minutes, eight sessions of assistive technology, and fifteen sessions of vision therapy. It was also recommended that STUDENT continue to receive twenty days of ESY services.
MOTHER rejected the District=s offer and STUDENT continued to attend NewBridge in Poway, California, at her expense. In November 2004, MOTHER obtained a private speech and language evaluation from Susan Berkowitz and a comprehensive evaluation, including a placement evaluation, from Mitchel Perlman, forensic psychologist. Ms. Berkowitz found that STUDENT had language skills that were in the 1st percentile overall when compared to other students his age. Ms. Berkowitz noted that STUDENT had a significant language learning impairment that was evidenced by deficits in comprehension and use of language. The testing conducted by Ms. Berkowitz also revealed that STUDENT had difficulties with auditory processing that impacted his ability to understand and use language. She also found that STUDENT had difficulties with the structure of language at the grammatical, morphological, and semantic levels. Ms. Berkowitz made several recommendations based on her findings including speech and language services and classroom accommodations. Dr. Perlman agreed with the findings in Ms. Dougherty=s September 27, 2004 report. Dr. Perlman also made several recommendations including a recommendation for a small, well-structured setting, and classroom accommodations and modifications.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Issue No. 1: During the 2001 ESY from July 19, 2001 through July 31, 2001, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
1. Did the District Fail to Assess STUDENT in all Areas of Suspected Disability?
The law requires that a child with a suspected disability be assessed by the school district in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, where appropriate, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language function, general intelligence, communicative status, self-help, and social and emotional status. 34 C.F.R. '' 300.320(a), 300.531; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56320(f). Occupational therapy and physical therapy are also areas that require prior assessment if they are areas of suspected disability. Cal. Gov=t Code ' 7572. The evaluation must be sufficiently comprehensive to identify all of the child=s special education and related services needs. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.532(h). The IEP team must be able to rely on the information from an initial assessment to determine eligibility and to develop an appropriate educational program. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(b).
The Student contends that the District should have conducted an oral motor assessment in July 2001 based upon his speech and language records since his kindergarten year, which indicated that he had difficulty with tongue movement and poor oral motor coordination. The Student relies on notes from 1997 which indicated that he moved his tongue from right to left and he did not move his tongue independently. (Student=s Exhibit page 14A.) These notes appeared to be part of a speech evaluation performed on June 11, 1997. (Student=s Exhibit pages 14-17.) The Student also relies on notes from speech therapy during the 1997-1998 school year. In addition, the Student also relies on his history of articulation errors, reported poor oral coordination, and low scores on articulation tests in support of his contention.
The District contends that it did not need to conduct an oral motor assessment for the IEP team to understand STUDENT=s oral motor needs. The District relies on the testimony of Valerie Hutchinson, STUDENT=s speech and language therapist, in support of its contention. Ms. Hutchinson testified that oral-motor deficits generally impact a student=s articulation abilities. She further testified that she usually conducts oral motor assessments if students exhibit multiple errors at the beginning of an assessment, which indicates that additional information is required. Ms. Hutchinson further testified that an additional oral motor assessment was not necessary to understand STUDENT=s unique needs based upon her review of STUDENT=s prior assessments, her work with STUDENT, and his ability to make progress in the area of articulation.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contention is without merit. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that when STUDENT began receiving services from her during the 2000-2001 school year, an oral motor assessment was not needed. (Footnote 4) Ms. Hutchinson persuasively testified that to reach her conclusion she met with STUDENT, reviewed his relevant IEP and assessments, and spoke with his prior speech and language therapist. A report dated October 29, 1998, from Patricia Black-Welch, speech therapist for the District, indicated that STUDENT was able to produce most sounds correctly in isolated words and phrases, but had difficulty carrying over learned behaviors into less structured connected speech. Thus, STUDENT was able to produce the target sounds. Ms. Hutchinson further testified that she was able to prepare goals and objectives in the areas of speech production and intelligibility and that she was able to meet STUDENT=s needs without an oral motor assessment. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that she implemented oral motor techniques such as oral motor exercises and using a tongue depressor in order to assist STUDENT make progress on the goals and objectives. Ms. Berkowitz=s testimony that she thought an oral motor assessment was warranted was based only on a record review. Ms. Hutchinson, on the other hand, worked with STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year on a weekly basis and was in a better position to determine if STUDENT required an oral motor assessment. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT made progress in articulation and sound production during the time he attended Carrillo. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require an oral motor evaluation during the 2001 ESY.
2. Did the District Fail to Offer and Provide STUDENT a FAPE?
A school district is required to provide a special education student with ESY programming when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year or the IEP team has determined the need for ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 3043; compare with 34 C.F.R. ' 300.309(a)(2). The district is required to provide a minimum of twenty days of ESY services when the IEP team determines that a student requires ESY programming. Cal. Code Regs. tit. 5, ' 3043. Section 3043 of Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations defines such students in the following manner: Such individuals shall have handicaps which are likely to continue indefinitely or for a prolonged period, and interruption of the pupil=s educational programming may cause regression, when coupled with limited recoupment capacity, rendering it impossible or unlikely that the pupil will attain the level of self-sufficiency and independence that would otherwise be expected in view of his or her handicapping condition.
The Student asserts that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001 ESY in July 2001, by failing to set forth in the February 27, 2001 IEP the percentage of time he was to be in an SDC and by failing to state all services he was to receive during the 2001 ESY. The Student also contends that the District denied him a FAPE during the 2001 ESY from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, by failing to (1) develop goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) provide him with a one-to-one aide for speech production; and (3) provide classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near and far point copying of text. The District contends that the February 27, 2001 IEP falls outside the statute of limitations date of July 19, 2001, and that ESY services were not offered until the June 21, 2001 IEP was developed.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. First, the February 27, 2001 IEP specifically states that STUDENT was not offered ESY services. (District=s Exhibit No. 10.) Second, the parties agreed that the statute of limitations date in this matter is July 19, 2001. Therefore, only issues arising after July 19, 2001, may be raised. The Student contends that the District committed procedural violations when it developed the February 27, 2001 IEP, which is outside the statute of limitations and, therefore, cannot be raised by the Student.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE during the 2001 ESY from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001. Lola Harlan, the District=s coordinator of special education, testified that while STUDENT attended Carrillo Elementary School (Carrillo), the District was on a track schedule that resulted in the students being Aoff track@ during the months of July, November, and March. Colleen Wann, STUDENT=s SDC teacher at Carrillo, testified that the 2001-2002 school year commenced during the first week of August 2001. Ms. Wann also testified that ESY services were not offered to STUDENT by the District for July 2001. Ms. Wann=s testimony is corroborated by the June 10, 2001 IEP. (District=s Exhibit pages 126-134.) Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT would have received ESY services in November and March, when ESY programming was provided to students District-wide. In light of the foregoing, it is clear that ESY services were not offered to STUDENT from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, because the District did not provide ESY programming to any of its students during July 2001. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was not denied a FAPE from July 19 through July 31, 2001, because there was no July 2001 ESY session. In light of the above, the Student=s remaining contentions regarding the July 2001 ESY are moot.
**************
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to assess STUDENT in the area of oral motor functioning during July 2001, and that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001.
Issue No. 2: During the 2001-2002 school year did the District fail to: 1. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and 2. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
1. Did the District Fail to Assess STUDENT in All Areas of Suspected Disability?
The Student contends that the District did not perform an oral motor assessment in July 2001; therefore, it should have performed an oral motor assessment during the 2001-2002 school year. The District contends that it did not need to conduct an oral motor assessment for the IEP team to understand STUDENT=s needs.
For the reasons set forth in issue number one, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contention is without merit. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that when STUDENT began receiving services from her during the 2000-2001 school year, an oral motor assessment was not needed because she was able to determine and meet his needs without an assessment. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that she continued to implement oral motor techniques such as oral motor exercises and the use of a tongue depressor to help STUDENT make progress on his goals and objectives. Ms. Hutchinson also credibly testified that STUDENT made progress during the 2000-2001 school year in the area of speech production which includes oral motor skills.
In addition, there is evidence in the record to suggest that STUDENT=s speech and language skills, including oral motor skills, improved during the 2001-2002 school year. Kristen Parker conducted an evaluation in February 2002 which showed that STUDENT=s speech production improved, including his oral motor skills. The IEP team reviewed the results of Ms. Parker=s evaluation and concluded that STUDENT would benefit from continued speech services including a one-to-one aide for speech production. (District=s Exhibit pages 122-125.) The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the area of speech production which encompassed STUDENT=s oral motor skills. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not need to assess STUDENT in the area of oral motor functioning during the 2001-2002 school year.
2. Did the District Fail to Offer and Provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 School Year?
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. ' 1400; Cal. Educ. Code ' 56000. The term Afree appropriate public education@ means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State=s educational standards, and that conform with the student=s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(8).
The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student=s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205.
The procedural rights that extend to parents under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child=s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
ASpecial education@ is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(16). The term Arelated services@ includes transportation and other services that may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(17). California Education Code section 56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided Awhen the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.@
To determine whether the District substantively provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District=s proposed programs. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982), the United States Supreme Court determined that the student=s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee successful results. Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998). The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student=s abilities. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of Asome@ benefit. Walczak, 142 F.3d at 130. Rather, a child=s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child=s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).
Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and that removal of a student from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the student=s disability is such that education in regular education classes cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. ' 1412(a)(5)(A); 34 C.F.R. ' 300.550(b); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56031.
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District=s program must have been designed to meet STUDENT=s unique and individual needs, have been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, comported with his IEP, and have been provided in the least restrictive environment.
During the 2001-2002 school year, two IEPs were in effect and must be analyzed to determine whether STUDENT was offered and provided a FAPE. The June 20, 2001 IEP was the controlling IEP during the period August 6, 2001, through February 13, 2002. The February 13, 2002 IEP was controlling during the period of February 13, 2002, through the end of the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer will consider each of these IEPs separately as they relate to the 2001-2002 school year.
1. June 20, 2001 IEP
The Student has alleged both procedural and substantive violations concerning the June 20, 2001 IEP. a. Procedural Violations
The Student contends that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA and State law when developing the June 20, 2001 IEP in the following respects: (1) by failing to have a general education teacher and administrator present during the IEP meeting; (2) by predetermining his educational placement; and (3) by failing to identify the accommodations and provisions under which he would participate in State testing. The District denies all of the Student=s contentions.
An IEP team is composed of a group of individuals including the parents of the child, a regular education teacher (if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment), a special education teacher, and a representative of the local educational agency. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56341. The regular education teacher plays a central role in the education of a child with disabilities and in determining the child=s involvement and progress in the general education environment. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 24. Thus, the failure of a school district to comply with the requirement of the IDEA, that at least one regular education teacher is present as a part of an IEP team when a child is or might be participating in regular education, may fatally compromise the integrity of the IEP and result in a denial of FAPE. M.L. v. Federal Way School District, 394 F.3d 634 (9th Cir. 2005).
The Student=s contention that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA by not having a general education teacher present during the IEP meeting is without merit. The June 20, 2001 IEP was signed by Ted Solino on the line for the general education teacher. (District=s Exhibit No. 9). Ms. Wann testified that Mr. Solino was STUDENT=s general education teacher at the time of the June 20, 2001 IEP meeting. Further, the notes from the IEP meeting indicate that the classroom teacher discussed STUDENT=s classroom performance. (District=s Exhibit page 130.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District complied with the requirement that it have a general education teacher as a member of the IEP team.
The Student=s contention that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA by not having an administrator present during the June 20, 2001 IEP meeting is also without merit. The IEP team shall include a representative of the local educational agency who is qualified to provide, or supervise the provision of, specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of children with disabilities, is knowledgeable about the general curriculum, and is knowledgeable about the availability of resources of the local educational agency. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B)(iv); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56341(b)(4). The District is not required to have an Aadministrator@ present as part of the IEP team, but someone who meets the requirements of California Education Code section 56341. Regardless, the June 20, 2001 IEP was signed by Fred Wise, the principal of Carrillo. There is conflicting testimony concerning whether Mr. Wise was present during the June 20, 2001 IEP meeting. MOTHER testified that she did not recall Mr. Wise being present at the June 20, 2001 IEP meeting. However, Theresa Lerager, STUDENT=s See also 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A)(v)(I). The June 20, 2001 IEP clearly indicates that STUDENT would be provided with accommodations for State- and District-wide assessments including being tested out of level, being tested in a small group, and being allowed extended time to complete the tests. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural violation in this regard. (Footnote 5)
b. Substantive
The Student contends the District denied him a FAPE by failing to (1) develop goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) provide him with a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; and (3) offer classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near and far point copying of text. The dispute for the 2001-2002 school year also concerns a disagreement on the areas of need in fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention.
STUDENT=s Unique Needs
To determine whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique educational needs for the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain what STUDENT=s unique needs were. The parties are in general agreement as to STUDENT=s deficits and areas of need during the 2001-2002 school year. STUDENT qualified for special education services as speech and language impaired as a result of his phonological deficits, articulation deficits, and expressive vocabulary difficulties. It is undisputed that STUDENT needed speech and language therapy to address his articulation and expressive language deficits.
STUDENT also had significant auditory memory/processing delays and academic delays. Ms. Lerager testified that she tested STUDENT during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT=s second grade year. Ms. Lerager testified that at the conclusion of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT had increased the number of sight words he could read and that he could read number words one through ten. Ms. Lerager also testified that STUDENT could read with 94 percent accuracy at the pre-primer level, and 88 percent accuracy at the primer level. STUDENT also demonstrated that he was able to decode consonant-vowel-consonant words. Ms. Lerager determined that STUDENT could read at approximately a mid-first-grade level, his spelling was at the first-grade level, and math was at the first-grade level. In addition, Ms. Lerager testified that STUDENT could write three- to four-word sentences. In light of these findings, at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT=s third grade year, his academic skills were more than two grade levels delayed.
Ms. Lerager credibly testified that due to the delay in academic skills, STUDENT required more intensive special education services than those provided in an RSP class and he also required a smaller class setting so that he could receive more individualized attention. Ms. Lerager also credibly testified that STUDENT required multisensory instruction to address his auditory processing deficits.
One disputed area of need was fine motor skills. Janice Dalby, an occupational therapist for NewBridge, testified that the results from the Kaufman Assessment Battery for Children (KABC) administered to STUDENT during the 1998-1999 school year indicated that STUDENT could not write his last name. In Ms. Dalby=s opinion, the results of the KABC, together with STUDENT=s kindergarten teacher=s report of poor paper and pencil coordination and fine and gross motor difficulties, should have caused the District to conduct an occupational therapy (OT) assessment. Dr. Perlman agreed with Ms. Dalby=s conclusions. The District contends that STUDENT did not have needs in this area that affected his classroom performance.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. Ms. Lerager testified that she was STUDENT=s teacher, during the 2000-2001 school year and that STUDENT did not demonstrate any behaviors that warranted a referral for an OT assessment. Ms. Lerager also testified that STUDENT=s handwriting was legible, and that he had good letter size and formation of letters when printing. The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of STUDENT=s teacher, Ms. Lerager. Ms. Dalby=s and Dr. Perlman=s opinions are based only upon a review of records from 1998 and 1999, not firsthand knowledge of STUDENT=s functioning in the classroom. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have fine motor deficits when the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed.
Another disputed area of need was related to STUDENT=s social/emotional functioning and attention. The Student contends, based upon Dr. Perlman=s testimony, that the District should have known of his needs in these areas based upon the psychoeducational evaluation completed by Davina Hsiao in February 2002. However, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals has adopted the Asnapshot@ rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot Abe judged exclusively in hindsightYand that an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.@ Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)). Accordingly, the Hearing Officer must examine the information reasonably available to the IEP team at the time the June 2001 IEP was developed.
Ms. Lerager credibly testified that in June 2001, STUDENT had good peer relations, followed rules, and was cooperative with adults. Ms. Lerager also testified that although STUDENT needed adults to assist him in resolving difficulties with peers, this was not unusual for children his age. There is no indication in the evidence that at the time the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed, STUDENT was having difficulties with social/emotional functioning or attention. There is evidence that STUDENT had social/emotional and attentional problems in 1999. The March 11, 1999 IEP indicated that MOTHER reported that STUDENT was fearful, cried a lot, was sad and had poor concentration and unpredictable mood swings. According to MOTHER=s report in 1999, STUDENT was seeing a private psychologist for behavior concerns, including anxiety and tension, and STUDENT had been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and prescribed Ritalin. The February 1999 psychoeducational report prepared by Lois Campbell, school psychologist, indicated that STUDENT had feelings of insecurity, anxiety, and tension. Ms. Campbell concluded that these emotional responses were likely affecting his school performance, but they were not the cause of his learning problems. These concerns were not reported in subsequent IEPs, nor is there evidence that the behaviors observed by MOTHER in 1999 were observed in the classroom when the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed. Ms. Hutchinson testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT was sweet, friendly, and empathetic. According to Ms. Hutchinson, the other children in the speech therapy small group enjoyed STUDENT. Ms. Hutchinson also credibly testified that STUDENT=s social skills were quite good. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that when the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed STUDENT did not have social/emotional or attention needs that required special education services.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of phonation, speech articulation, expressive language, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. STUDENT needed intensive instruction in a small-group setting and he required multisensory instuction. He also needed speech and language services and classroom accommodations.
Designed to Meet Unique Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
To address STUDENT=s unique needs, the June 20, 2001 IEP offered him placement in an LH SDC with mainstreaming for physical education, together with speech and language therapy. The District also offered STUDENT twenty days of ESY programming for 240 minutes per day. Goals and objectives were prepared in the areas of articulation, grammar, reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, and math.
The Student does not dispute the appropriateness of his placement in an LH SDC, the percentage of mainstreaming, or the provision of speech and language therapy. The Student contends that the District failed to develop measurable goals in all areas of his unique needs; offer him a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; and offer necessary classroom accommodations.
Goals and Objectives
The Student contends that goals and objectives should have been written in the areas of sequential memory, social/emotional functioning, fine motor skills, phonemic awareness, and attention. The District contends that goals were written in STUDENT=s areas of need and the goals were written to State standards.
California Education Code section 56345 provides that the IEP shall include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil=s needs resulting from the pupil=s disability and enabling the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See also 34 C.F.R. ' 300.347(a)(2). The purpose of short-term objectives or benchmarks is to provide a mechanism for a child=s teacher and parents to monitor the child=s progress -- or lack thereof -- in special education over the course of the year. See 34 C.F.R., Pt. 300, App. A, Q. 1.
Mitchel Perlman, Ph.D., a forensic psychologist called by the Student, testified that based on his review of the June 20, 2001 IEP and the District=s assessments, he concluded that goals and objectives should have been written in the areas of fine motor, sequencing, phonemic awareness, social/emotional functioning, and attention. As indicated above, the Hearing Officer has determined that STUDENT did not have needs in fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. Therefore, goals and objectives in those areas were not necessary.
As to the remaining areas of need, sequencing and phonemic awareness, the Student contends that the District was required to write goals and objectives that were specifically labeled and designed to address auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. The IEP team must identify how a child=s needs manifest in the classroom, and write goals and objectives to address those needs and correspond with the State standards. Ms. Wann credibly testified that STUDENT=s goals and objectives were written to address each of his needs, and were written to State standards contained in the general curriculum. For example, the goals required STUDENT to decode words, read an additional seventy-five sight words, and answer comprehension questions. Ms. Wann testified that, in addition to addressing STUDENT=s academic deficits, the goals addressed his auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory deficits. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson testified that the speech and language goals addressed STUDENT=s articulation deficits and his phonemic awareness deficits by addressing target sounds. The Hearing Officer found the testimony of Ms. Wann and Ms. Hutchinson credible based on their qualifications in writing and implementing goals and objectives and their extensive experience in providing services to special education students. Thus, they are in a better position to determine the areas of need that were addressed by the specific goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District wrote goals in all of STUDENT=s areas of need, including phonemic awareness, speech articulation, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory.
One-to-One Aide
The Student contends that the District should have offered him a one-to-one aide to assist him with speech production during the school day because minimal improvement had been observed in his speech production during the 2000-2001 school year. The Student=s contention is also based on two subsequent speech and language pathologists= recommendation that he receive daily practice in speech production. The District contends that a recommendation for a one-to-one aide for speech production was not made until February 2002 and that STUDENT made substantial progress on his articulation goals from the February 27, 2001 IEP without a one-to-one aide.
Pursuant to Adams, supra, the Hearing Officer must consider what information was reasonably available to the District at the time the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed. Ms. Hutchinson testified that she provided STUDENT with oral motor exercises to assist him in making the different target sounds and that she sent information home with STUDENT so that his parents would be able to help him with exercises to accomplish his articulation goals. Ms. Hutchinson also worked with STUDENT=s tongue placement by providing him a mirror and tongue depressors to use when practicing speech production. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson provided STUDENT with a home component consisting of daily speech production practice.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. As set forth above, Ms. Hutchinson had training and experience in providing speech production therapy, including oral motor exercises, to students with articulation deficits. According to the IEPs and Ms. Hutchinson, STUDENT made great progress during the time he received speech and language therapy during the 2000-2001 school year. Ms. Hutchinson worked with STUDENT on speech production weekly and provided information to MOTHER so that he could receive reinforcement at home. In light of Ms. Hutchinson=s experience in the area of speech production and the home component of STUDENT=s speech and language therapy, there is no evidence that he required a one-to-one aide for speech production in June 2001. Further, there is no indication that STUDENT was not making satisfactory progress in the area of speech articulation at the time the June 2001 IEP was developed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require a one-to-one aide for speech production when the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed.
Auditory Processing Program
The Student also contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District did not offer him an auditory processing program that addressed his bottom-top auditory processing deficits. Ms. Abramson testified that the only two programs she knew of which addressed this type of auditory processing deficit were Fast ForWord and the Basic Auditory Training Program (BAT), which she authored. The District contends that it addressed STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits through direct services and methodologies, such as Project Read and computer programs such as Earobics.
The Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. Ms. Abramson did not evaluate STUDENT until September 15, 2004. The Hearing Officer notes that Ms. Abramson did not testify concerning STUDENT=s deficits or needs during the 2001-2002 school year. Moreover, the standard under which a denial of FAPE must be analyzed is whether the District provided the child with a FAPE based on the information that it had or should have had at the time the IEP was prepared. Adams, supra. The District determined that STUDENT had auditory processing deficits in 1999. (District=s Exhibit page 236.) However, during the March 11, 1999 IEP meeting, the IEP team reviewed the results of Ms. Campbell=s assessment and agreed with her conclusion that there was not a significant discrepancy between STUDENT=s auditory processing ability and his academic achievement. The IEP team determined that STUDENT=s needs could be met with small group instruction and speech and language services. Ms. Wann testified that during the 2001-2002 school year, she provided STUDENT with instruction through Project Read, multisensory teaching techniques, and Earobics to address STUDENT=s processing deficits. Ms. Wann credibly testified that these techniques were sufficient to meet STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits.
Karen Wohlgemuth was called by the District as an expert witness in auditory processing. Ms. Wohlgemuth is a program specialist with Anaheim Union High School District and a licensed speech and language pathologist. Ms. Wohlgemuth testified that she receives continuing education in all areas of communicative disorders and monitors the newest developments. Ms. Wohlgemuth has been an instructor at California State University in Fullerton at the graduate and undergraduate levels. Ms. Wohlgemuth is a member of the California Speech, Language, and Hearing Association and has been on the advisory committee for District Eight as an educational commissioner for the past two years. In addition, Ms. Wohlgemuth is a member of the International Dyslexia Association. Ms. Wohlgemuth testified that the methodologies employed by the District, including Project Read, multisensory teaching techniques, small-group instruction, and Earobics were effective methods to address the needs of students with auditory processing deficits such as STUDENT=s based upon the research in the field and the acceptable practices to address auditory processing deficits The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Wann and Ms. Wohlgemuth persuasive. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by not offering him Fast ForWord or BAT at the time the June 20, 2001 IEP was developed.
Classroom Accommodations
Among other things, an IEP must contain a statement of the modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for a student to advance appropriately toward attaining the annual goals, be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities, and be educated and participate with other students with disabilities and nondisabled students in activities. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345; 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A).
The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text. In support of his contention, the Student relies on the record review and assessment conducted during the 2004-2005 school year by Jan Dalby, an occupational therapist with NewBridge. The District contends that STUDENT was offered and provided the accommodations set forth in the June 21, 2001 IEP, as well as the accommodations that were provided as part of the SDC program.
The Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. The June 20, 2001 IEP states that STUDENT was to be provided small-group instruction and multisensory strategies. In addition, Ms. Wann testified that as part of her SDC program she provided STUDENT with numerous accommodations, including small-group instruction all day, access to visual material, written schedules, the assistance of either her or an aide, directions repeated to ensure understanding, extra time for assignments, and preferential seating. Ms. Wann testified that the use of visual materials, assistance of an aide, repeated instructions, extra time for assignments, and preferential seating were underlying components of an SDC program and, therefore, not discussed at the IEP meeting. Therefore, the accommodations which are the subject of dispute in this case are a slant board and near- and far-point copying of text.
The Student relies on the testimony of Ms. Dalby in support of his contention. However, Ms. Dalby=s testing was not completed until over two years after the preparation of the June 20, 2001 IEP and, therefore, is not reflective of STUDENT=s need for accommodations during the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Wann persuasive. Ms. Wann worked with STUDENT on a daily basis and was very familiar with his needs and required accommodations. Ms. Wann credibly testified that the accommodations STUDENT received were designed to meet his needs and additional accommodations were not necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate accommodations and that he did not need a slant board or near- and far-point copying of text.
The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the District provided STUDENT an educational program with supports that was designed to meet his unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the educational program offered was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The educational program addressed all of STUDENT=s needs and provided him with individualized instruction in a small-group setting.
Comported with STUDENT=s IEP
There is no dispute that the District provided the placement and services, and implemented the goals and objectives specified in the June 20, 2001 IEP.
Provided in the LRE
There is no dispute that STUDENT was provided placement and services in the LRE.
2. February 13, 2002 IEP
The Student has alleged both procedural and substantive violations concerning the February 13, 2002 IEP.
a. Procedural Violations
The Student contends that the District failed to procedurally comply with the IDEA and State law when developing the February 13, 2002 IEP by failing to have a general education teacher present during the IEP and predetermining his educational placement. (Footnote 6) The District refutes all of the Student=s contentions.
The Student asserts that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to have a general education teacher present at the February 13, 2002 IEP meeting. The District asserts that although a teacher who taught general education classes was not present at the IEP meeting, Ms. Lerager was present and was qualified because she was knowledgeable about the general education curriculum and the general education environment due to her extensive experience participating in general education classes and providing both push-in and pull-out services to students placed in the general education program and facilitating their involvement in the general education environment. As set forth above, an IEP team is comprised of a group of individuals including a regular education teacher if the child is, or may be, participating in the regular education environment. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B), Cal. Educ. Code ' 56341. The general education teacher must participate in the discussions concerning the development, review, and revision of the IEP and assist in determining appropriate positive behavioral interventions and strategies, and supplementary aides and services, program modifications or supports for school personnel that will be provided for the child. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.346(d).
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. In M.L. v. Federal Way School District, 394 F.3d 634 (9th Cir. 2005), the Court held that a district is required to have a general education teacher as a member of an IEP team where the child is or may be participating in the general education program. In this case, STUDENT was placed primarily in an LH SDC and was to participate in general education physical education. Since he was to be participating in a general education class, a general education teacher was required to be a part of the IEP team. The District had two teachers present at the February 13, 2002 IEP meeting who might have fulfilled the requirement for a general education teacher: Ms. Lerager and Amy Jensen. Ms. Lerager testified that she was knowledgeable about the general education curriculum by virtue of her general education teaching credential and her experience providing RSP services in a general education environment. In addition, Ms. Lerager had personal knowledge of STUDENT as his teacher for two years. Amy Jensen was also present at the February 13, 2002 IEP meeting. Ms. Jensen is currently an SDC teacher for the District, but possesses a general education teaching credential. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lerager and Ms. Jensen were knowledgeable about the general education curriculum in the regular classroom and were able to ensure STUDENT=s involvement and progress in the general education environment. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds the District complied with the procedural requirements of the IDEA and State law.
The Student also contends that the District committed a procedural violation by predetermining his placement at the February 13, 2002 IEP. The Student contends that the District drafted the IEP prior to the meeting and failed to consider any other placement options at the IEP team meeting. The District contends that it may develop preparatory placement proposals for discussion at IEP teem meetings and that the District did this to facilitate discussion at the IEP team meeting.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. As with the previous IEP, the notes from the IEP meeting indicate that the team discussed STUDENT=s progress in his placement and discussed placement options for the new IEP team, including the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year and the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year. The IEP indicates that the IEP team considered a variety of educational placements including general education, RSP, and SDC. MOTHER testified that she participated in the IEP process and indicated on the IEP that she Ahad the opportunity to help develop his Individualized Education Program.@ The notes from the IEP meeting also indicate that MOTHER asked questions regarding the amount of speech time STUDENT would receive. After discussing MOTHER=s questions, the IEP team added a one-to-one aide for speech production. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that a full discussion took place before STUDENT=s February 13, 2002 IEP was finalized. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s educational placement was not predetermined. (Footnote 7)
b. Substantive
The dispute for the 2001-2002 school year concerns a disagreement regarding STUDENT=s areas of need. The Student contends that he had needs in fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. The Student further contends the District denied him a FAPE by failing to (1) develop goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) offer him an auditory processing program; (3) include the district psychologist=s recommendations in the February 13, 2002 IEP; (4) provide him with a trained one-to-one aide; and (5) offer classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text.
STUDENT=s Unique Needs
To determine whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique educational needs for the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain what STUDENT=s unique needs were at the time of the February 2002 IEP. The parties are in general agreement as to STUDENT=s deficits and areas of need at that time. STUDENT continued to qualify for special education under the category of speech and language impaired. STUDENT=s speech impairment included phonological deficits, articulation deficits, and expressive vocabulary difficulties. In addition, the parties agreed that STUDENT had significant auditory memory/processing delays and academic delays.
In January 2002, STUDENT was assessed by the District in anticipation of his triennial review. STUDENT=s speech and language evaluation revealed that his speech production was characterized by sound substitutions and distortions at the single-word level and in connected speech. STUDENT was also described as having difficulty with unfamiliar and multisyllabic words. Regarding language skills, STUDENT=s receptive and expressive vocabulary skills were below average and he had difficulty with expressive sentence structure and formulation. STUDENT also demonstrated difficulty with categories. It was recommended that STUDENT continue to receive services in speech articulation and expressive language. (District=s Exhibit No. 31.)
In January 2002, a psychoeducational evaluation was completed by Davina Hsiao, school psychologist. Ms. Hsiao reported that STUDENT=s cognitive ability was in the average range; however, he was making slow academic progress. Ms. Hsiao testified that STUDENT=s phonemic awareness was in the low average range. Ms. Hsiao attributed this to STUDENT=s processing deficits in the areas of auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory, as well as his lack of attention to task and his lack of organization. The report indicated that STUDENT had been diagnosed with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder and was noted by his teachers to have a lack of focus and organization, and an inability to stay on task. Regarding his social/emotional functioning, the report indicated that STUDENT had at-risk behaviors in adaptability and depression, and that his anxiety was in the clinically significant range. (District=s Exhibit No. 32.)
The Student contends that he also had fine motor needs during the 2001-2002 school year based upon his scores on a Visual Motor Integration test administered by Ms. Hsiao in February 2002, on which he scored in the below average range on the fine motor subtest. The Student also contends that he had fine motor needs based on school records from the 1998-1999 school year, as set forth above in the June 2001 needs analysis. The District contends that STUDENT did not have needs in this area that affected his classroom performance.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. Ms. Wann described STUDENT=s fine motor skills at the February 13, 2002 IEP team meeting. According to the IEP, STUDENT=s printing was appropriate and he was beginning to write cursive. Further, Shannon O=Brien, an occupational therapist for the District, testified that she worked in Ms. Wann=s SDC for approximately two years during the time STUDENT was placed in Ms. Wann=s class. (Footnote 8) Ms. O=Brien testified that she was in the classroom one time per week providing OT services to another student in the class. According to Ms. O=Brien, she had an opportunity to observe STUDENT and concluded that he did not have any fine motor deficits during this time. As previously stated, the Student=s contention is based on the opinion of Ms. Dalby, who concluded that STUDENT had fine motor needs for the 2001-2002 school year based upon a records review. The Hearing Officer did not find Ms. Dalby=s testimony persuasive. Ms. Wann and Ms. O=Brien had firsthand knowledge of STUDENT during the 2001-2002 school year and were able to observe his classroom skills. (Footnote 9) In addition, the VMI test results were not consistent with STUDENT=s classroom performance. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have fine motor needs at the time the February 13, 2002 IEP was developed.
The Student contends that the results from his psychoeducational evaluation by Ms. Hsiao revealed that he had at-risk behaviors in adaptability and depression and that his anxiety was in the clinically significant range and, therefore, he had needs in the social/emotional area. The Student also contends that he had needs in the area of attention based upon the findings in Ms. Hsaio=s report. The District does not dispute the findings of the psychoeducational report; however, it contends that STUDENT=s social/emotional and attention scores were not consistent with his classroom behavior.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. There was no persuasive evidence that STUDENT was exhibiting social/emotional behaviors in the classroom that were interfering with his education. Ms. Wann described STUDENT as happy, relaxed, and an active participant in the class during the 2001-2002 school year. Ms. Wann further testified that STUDENT was involved in campus activities, such as safety patrol, peace patrol, student council, the school- wide running program, and dramatic performances. STUDENT also participated in District-wide track meets. (Testimony of Ms. Wann.) The findings in Ms. Hsaio=s report identifying STUDENT as having anxiety, depression, and difficulty with adaptability are concerning. Ms. Hsaio=s findings were consistent with the findings of Ms. Campbell in her 1999 psychoeducational report. However, it does not appear that these deficits were interfering with STUDENT=s ability to participate in his educational program. Despite his emotional concerns, STUDENT was still not only making academic progress, but also participating appropriately in various campus activities. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have social/emotional needs.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT did not have needs in the area of attention. During Ms. Hsiao=s observation of STUDENT which was conducted as part of her psychoeducational evaluation, Ms. Hsiao observed STUDENT to be off track for approximately two minutes, but easily redirected by Ms. Wann. Ms. Hsiao=s report indicates that medication had been successful in addressing STUDENT=s attention deficits. There was no evidence to the contrary. Ms. Wann did not testify that STUDENT had attention difficulties that interfered with his education. In addition, no one testified that goals and objectives in the area of attention were necessary to meet STUDENT=s needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have needs in attention that interfered with his education and required goals and objectives.
In summary, STUDENT had deficits in the areas of phonation, speech articulation, expressive language, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. STUDENT needed placement in a small group setting that provided him with more individualized attention and more intensive academic instruction. He also needed speech and language services and classroom accommodations to address his areas of need.
Designed to Meet Unique Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
To address STUDENT=s unique needs, the District offered and provided him placement in an LH SDC with mainstreaming for physical education, together with speech and language therapy as set forth in the February 13, 2002 IEP. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide in the classroom to work on speech production. The District also provided STUDENT with twenty days of ESY services for 240 minutes per day. Goals and objectives were prepared in the areas of articulation, grammar, reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, expressive language, and math.
The Student does not dispute the appropriateness of placement in an LH SDC, the percentage of mainstreaming, or the provision of speech and language therapy was appropriate. The Student contends that the District should have developed goals in all areas of his unique needs; offered him an auditory processing program; included the school psychologist=s recommendations in the IEP, provided an appropriately trained and supervised one-to-one aide; and offered necessary classroom accommodations.
Goals and Objectives
The Student contends that goals and objectives were not written in all areas of need, specifically sequential memory, social/emotional, fine motor, phonemic awareness, and attention. The District contends that goals were written in the areas of deficit that impacted STUDENT=s education and were written to State standards. As noted earlier, California Education Code section 56345 provides that the IEP shall include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to meeting the pupil=s needs resulting from the pupil=s disability and enabling the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See also 34 C.F.R. ' 300.347(a)(2).
Dr. Perlman testified that upon his review of the February 13, 2002 IEP and the District=s assessments, goals and objectives should have been written in the areas of fine motor skill, sequencing, phonemic awareness, social/emotional functioning, and attention. The Hearing Officer found above that STUDENT did not have educational needs in the areas of fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer determines that STUDENT did not require goals and objectives in these areas.
The Student contends that the District was required to write goals and objectives that were specifically labeled and designed to address auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. Ms. Wann credibly testified that STUDENT=s goals and objectives were written to address each of his needs and were written to State standards. For example, goal number one required STUDENT to decode words, read an additional one hundred sight words, and answer comprehension questions at the mid-second grade level. Ms. Wann testified that this goal addressed STUDENT=s auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory deficits. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that the speech and language goals in the February 13, 2002 IEP addressed phonemic awareness, sound sequencing, expressive language, and articulation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District developed goals to address all of STUDENT=s areas of need, including phonation, speech articulation, expressive language, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory.
Auditory Processing Program
The Student also contends that he was denied a FAPE because the District did not offer him an auditory processing program that addressed his bottom-top auditory processing deficits and that he required the Fast ForWord or BAT program. The District contends that it addressed STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits through direct services and methodologies, such as Project Read and computer programs such as Earobics.
For the reasons set forth in the analysis of the June 20, 2001 IEP, the Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. To meet STUDENT=s needs concerning his auditory processing deficits, Ms. Wann testified that she provided STUDENT with Project Read, multisensory teaching techniques, and Earobics. As set forth in the discussion of the previous IEP, these were effective methods to meet STUDENT=s auditory processing needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by not providing him with the Fast ForWord or BAT program during the 2001-2002 school year.
One-to-One Aide
There is no dispute that the District offered and provided STUDENT a one-to-one aide for speech production from February 13, 2002, during the remainder of the 2001-2002 school year. The Student contends that the one-to-one aide provided to assist him with speech production was not properly trained and was not supervised by a speech and language pathologist. The District asserts that the aide was trained by the speech pathologist and assisted STUDENT daily in the area of speech production.
Title 5 of the California Code of Regulations, section 3051.1 provides that speech and language services may be provided by an aide if the aide is working under the direct supervision of a credentialed language, speech, and hearing specialist and if the use of an aide is specified in the IEP.
The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the Student=s contention. The State regulations require that an aide work under the direct supervision of a speech pathologist. However, the law does not require that an aide be trained according to the Current Polices and New Directions for Speech-Language Pathology Assistants, which was cited by the Student in his Closing Brief.
Lola Harlan, a special education coordinator for the District, credibly testified that STUDENT was provided with a one-to-one aide for speech production and that the aide was trained by Kristen Parker, a licensed speech pathologist. Ms. Wann credibly testified that the aide worked with STUDENT fifteen minutes each day on speech production. (Footnote 10) Ms. Wann testified that service providers, including speech and language therapists, came into her classroom on a regular basis. Ms. Harlan testified that the aide was working under Ms. Parker=s supervision as it related to providing STUDENT help and practice with speech production. In addition, the aide was not providing speech and language therapy for STUDENT. STUDENT continued to receive weekly speech and language therapy from Ms. Parker, with whom he worked on articulation. Thus, the one-to-one aide was providing practice sessions for the maintenance of the services provided by Ms. Parker and to assist STUDENT to use his skills in the classroom setting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the aide met the requirements of the regulation because she was trained and supervised by Ms. Parker. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was provided an appropriately trained one-to-one aide for speech production.
Psychologist=s Recommendations
The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by not including Ms. Hsiao=s recommendations in the February 13, 2002 IEP. The Student contends that the recommendations were not offered for the family=s consideration at the IEP meeting, and resulted in a Union violation. The Student contends that the recommendations included necessary modifications and support that should have been set forth in the February 13, 2002 IEP. The District contends that the Student did not present evidence that the District failed to incorporate recommendations of any IEP team member into the IEP that were necessary to provide him a FAPE.
In her January 2002 report, Ms. Hsiao recommended that STUDENT continue to receive the educational interventions being implemented and that his teachers continue to assist him in developing appropriate learning behaviors. She also recommended that STUDENT=s teachers use teaching methods that emphasized simultaneous approaches to learning and assisted him with auditory sequential memory, have him repeat and write tongue twisters, rhyming poems, or limericks to facilitate auditory short-term memory, and to use memory tricks whenever possible. Ms. Hsiao testified that many of the recommendations she made were a standard special education curriculum and could be implemented by either an RSP teacher or an SDC teacher. Ms. Hsiao also testified that goals and objectives regarding auditory processing and short- term memory would have also been appropriate for addressing her recommendations, such as having STUDENT retell a story of what was previously read to him.
The Hearing Officer relies on the testimony of Ms. Hsiao as to this contention. Ms. Hsiao testified that the recommendations she made were typically part of an SDC program and an SDC teacher=s standard teaching techniques. Ms. Hsiao=s testimony was supported by the testimony of Ms. Wann. Further, by the plain language of the recommendation, it is clear that Ms. Hsiao knew that some of the recommendations were already being implemented in the classroom. For example, she recommended Acontinued educational interventions . . . continue assisting STUDENT . . .@ (District=s Exhibit No. 32.) Further, recommendations were not modifications or accommodations, as alleged by the Student, but teaching techniques and, therefore, were not required to be a part of STUDENT=s IEP. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345.
Classroom Accommodations
Finally, the Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer necessary classroom accommodations, including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text. In support of his contention, the Student relies on the record review and assessment conducted by Ms. Dalby during the 2004-2005 school year. The District contends that STUDENT was provided with appropriate accommodations as set forth in the February 13, 2002 IEP, and additional accommodations were a standard component of the SDC program.
The Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. The February 13, 2002 IEP states that STUDENT was to be provided small-group instruction and multisensory strategies. In addition, Ms. Wann testified that as part of her SDC program she provided STUDENT with numerous accommodations, including small-group instruction all day, access to visual material, written schedules, individualized instruction through either a teacher or aide, directions repeated to ensure understanding, extra time for assignments, and preferential seating. There is no evidence that STUDENT=s needs in terms of classroom accommodations had changed since the June 21, 2001 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Wann persuasive. Ms. Wann worked with STUDENT on a daily basis and was very familiar with STUDENT=s needs and required accommodations. Ms. Wann credibly testified that the accommodations he received were designed to meet his needs and additional accommodations were not necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate accommodations and that he did not need a slant board or near- and far-point copying of text.
The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the District provided STUDENT an educational program with supports that was designed to meet his unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the educational program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The educational program addressed all of STUDENT=s needs and provided him with individualized instruction in a small-group setting. (Footnote 11)
Comported with STUDENT=s IEP
There is no dispute that the District provided STUDENT an educational program which comported with his February 13, 2002 IEP.
Provided in the LRE
There is no dispute that STUDENT was provided placement and services in the LRE.
*********
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001-2002 school year, including the ESY. The District=s placement and services were designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and were reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer notes that the educational program provided comported with STUDENT=s June 20, 2001 and February 13, 2002 IEPs and was provided in the LRE.
Issue No. 3: During the 2002-2003 school year did the District fail to: 3. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and 4. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
A. Did the District fail to Assess STUDENT in All Areas of Suspected Disability?
The Student contends that the District should have but did not perform an oral motor assessment of him during the 2002-2003 school year. The District contends that it did not need to conduct an oral motor assessment for the IEP team to understand STUDENT=s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contention is without merit. The evidence shows that STUDENT=s oral motor skills improved during the 2001-2002 school year, and throughout the 2002-2003 school year. As noted previously, speech and language therapist Kristine Parker=s February 13, 2002 assessment showed STUDENT continued to improve in speech and language skills, including oral motor skills. Ms. Hutchinson testified that the provision of speech and language services was sufficient to meet STUDENT=s needs and that an oral motor disability was not suspected. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the area of speech production which addressed STUDENT=s speech production. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not need to assess STUDENT in the area of oral motor functioning during the 2002-2003 school year.
B. Did the District Fail to Offer and Provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 School Year?
During the 2002-2003 school year there were two IEPs in effect that must be analyzed to determine whether STUDENT was offered and provided a FAPE. The February 13, 2002 IEP was the controlling IEP during the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through February 11, 2003. The February 11, 2003 IEP was controlling during the period February 11, 2003, through the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
1. February 13, 2002 IEP
The Hearing Officer has already determined that the February 13, 2002 IEP was appropriate and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on procedural or substantive grounds and there is no evidence that his needs had changed. The only additional allegation not yet addressed is that the District failed to implement the February 13, 2002 IEP during the first part of the 2002-2003 school year by not providing a one-to-one aide for speech production.
The school district has the burden of proving at the administrative hearing that it complied with the IDEA, including that it provided a program that complied with the student=s IEP. Clyde K. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist. No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994). Here, the District offered no evidence that it provided a one-to-one aide so that STUDENT during the 2002-2003 school year so that he could practice speech production five to ten minutes per school day. The February 13, 2002 IEP states that STUDENT was to receive a one-to-one aide for speech production during the school day. There is no evidence that STUDENT received the assistance of a one-to-one aide from the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year through February 11, 2003. Bobbi Marcel, STUDENT=s speech and language therapist during the 2002-2003 school year, wrote a letter on February 7, 2003. In her letter, Ms. Marcel suggested that STUDENT could use five to ten minutes per day at home or in class working on /s/ and /z/ sounds. (District=s Exhibit page 109.) Therefore, it is reasonable to conclude that STUDENT was not receiving the assistance of a one-to-one aide in the classroom. In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT an educational program which comported with his February 13, 2002 IEP to the extent that it did not provide a one-to-one aide to assist STUDENT with speech production five to ten minutes per day.
2. February 11, 2003 IEP
The Student has alleged both procedural and substantive violations concerning the February 11, 2003 IEP.
a. Procedural violations
The Student contends that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA and State law when developing the February 11, 2003 IEP by (1) failing to have a general education teacher present during the IEP; (2) predetermining his educational placement; and (3) failing to provide his parents with a current copy of the notice of safeguards and procedural rights.
As set forth above, a general education teacher is required to be a member of the IEP team if the child is or might be participating in the general education program. During the 2002-2003 school year, except for mainstreaming into physical education, STUDENT was not participating in the general education program. Ms. Lerager was again present at the February 11, 2003 IEP meeting. As noted previously, she had a general education teaching credential and extensive experience with the general education curriculum and setting. Based on Ms. Lerager=s experience and knowledge of the general education curriculum, her general education teaching credential, and STUDENT=s needs, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lerager was able to provide appropriate input concerning STUDENT=s involvement and progress in the general education environment and her presence met the requirements of the IDEA and State law. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural violation. (Footnote 12)
The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not predetermine STUDENT=s placement and services for the 2002-2003 school year. The notes from the February 11, 2003 IEP meeting indicate that the IEP team reviewed the goals and objectives from the February 13, 2002 IEP and the proposed goals and objectives, and discussed placement in an SDC. MOTHER=s concerns were noted in the IEP. MOTHER testified that she participated in the IEP process and she indicated on the IEP that she Ahad the opportunity to help develop this Individualized Education Program.@ Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s educational placement was not predetermined.
The Student next contends that the District failed to provide his parents with a then-current copy of the notice of safeguards and procedural rights. The District contends that the parents were provided with the notice of procedural safeguards.
California Education Code section 56301 provides that parents must be given a copy of their rights and procedural safeguards upon initial referral for assessment, notice of an IEP meeting or reassessment, filing of a complaint, filing for a prehearing mediation, or filing of a due process hearing. The notice of procedural safeguards must include a full explanation of the procedural safeguards of the IDEA in the parents= native language that includes the right to an independent educational evaluation, prior written notice, parental consent, access to educational records, the opportunity to present complaints, a child=s placement during the pendency of a due process proceeding, procedures for students in alternative educational settings, requirements for the unilateral placement by parents of children in private school, at public expense, and rights related to mediation, due process hearings, state level appeals, civil actions, and attorneys= fees. 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(d)(2); Cal. Educ. Code ' 56500.1.
The February 11, 2003 IEP notes reveal that MOTHER was provided a copy of her rights, and attached to the IEP is a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards signed by MOTHER. A complete copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards provided to MOTHER was not introduced into evidence. The document provided indicates that the parent received three written pages of procedural safeguards. (District=s Exhibit No. 7, page 112.) Thus, the Hearing Officer cannot determine the complete content of the safeguards provided to the parent. However, there is neither evidence nor argument that any alleged change in the procedural safeguards specifically affected the Student=s rights in this case.
The Student identifies several California statutes which may have changed prior to the February 11, 2003 IEP meeting: California Education Code sections 56001(a) (an education is assured through completion of the course of study or until proficiency standards have been met), 56021.1 (definition of consent), 56174 (a district is not required to pay the cost of an education at a private school if the district made a FAPE available), 56174.5 (students in private schools may received a different amount of services than students in public schools), 56176 (reasons for reducing or denying reimbursement for private schools), 56320(h) (the IEP team must comply with the federal law when conducting an assessment or reassessment and may meet without an IEP meeting), 56381 (review of a reassessment may be conducted without a meeting), 56345(b)(4) (transition from special class or nonpublic school to regular education programming), 56347 (district shall ensure that regular education teachers and special education teachers have access to a child=s IEP), and 48900, et seq. (discipline procedures for children with special needs). While it is not possible to determine if the new or amended language was incorporated into the rights received by the parents, the Notice of Procedural Safeguards received by MOTHER indicates that she was advised of the IDEA and was provided notice of her right to prior written notice and her right to participate in STUDENT=s IEP meetings, and notice regarding surrogate parents, parental consent, and the right to a nondiscriminatory assessment. All of these rights met the requirements of the IDEA and State law.
The Hearing Officer finds that even if a technical violation occurred, there was no prejudice because none of the changes in the law affected STUDENT=s educational program or MOTHER=s meaningful participation in the IEP process. The Student has not alleged that he was removed from an educational program prior to completion of the course of study or proficiency standards were met or that MOTHER involuntarily gave her consent to the implementation of the IEP. In addition, STUDENT was not a privately placed student, nor was he being transitioned to a regular education program or facing disciplinary proceedings. Finally, the IEP team did not meet to review any assessment or reassessment outside of an IEP meeting. Therefore, STUDENT did not lose educational opportunity nor was MOTHER=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process seriously infringed upon as a result of any procedural violation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation that denied STUDENT a FAPE with regard to the February 11, 2003 IEP.
b. Substantive
The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE at the February 2003 IEP meeting by failing to (1) develop measurable goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) offer him a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; and (3) identify necessary classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text. The Student also contends that his parents were not provided with progress reports. The District asserts that STUDENT was provided with a FAPE for the remainder of the 2002-2003 school year.
There is no dispute that STUDENT=s needs did not materially change between the June 2001 IEP and the February 2003 IEP. STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the areas of reading fluency, written language, phonemic awareness, immediate memory, and sequential memory. The Student continued to contend that he also had needs in the areas of fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. However, the Hearing Officer previously determined that STUDENT did not have needs in these areas that required special education intervention and Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT=s needs did not materially change by the time of the February 2003 IEP. The dispute for the 2002-2003 school year is whether or not the program met STUDENT=s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and whether the District provided STUDENT with progress reports as provided by his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer will only analyze the contested components of FAPE: whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and whether it comported with the February 11, 2003 IEP.
To address STUDENT=s unique needs at the February 2003 IEP meeting, the District continued to offer him placement in an LH SDC with mainstreaming for physical education, together with speech and language therapy. The District also provided STUDENT with twenty days of ESY programming for 270 minutes per day.
Goals and Objectives
The Student contends that he had needs in the areas of fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. The Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. The February 11, 2003 IEP contained goals and objectives in the areas of reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, spelling, math, articulation, and expressive grammar. The Student=s claim that the District did not develop goals in all areas of his unique needs is based upon the same contentions raised for the 2001-2002 school year. The District asserts that it did develop goals and objectives in all areas of need.
As set forth above, the Student contends that the District was required to propose goals and objectives that were specifically labeled and designed to address auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. Ms. Wann credibly testified that STUDENT=s goals and objectives were written to address all of his needs and were written to State standards. Goal number one required STUDENT to decode words with vowel teams. Goal number two required STUDENT to answer reading comprehension questions at the mid-third grade level. Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT=s goals in the February 11, 2003 IEP addressed his auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory deficits, even though they were not labeled as such by addressing the academic areas affected by the deficits such as reading and math. Ms. Wann also credibly testified that the goals and objectives were written to address STUDENT=s academic skills because the purpose is to assist the child in making academic progress. Therefore, the goals were written to State standards. The goals and objectives for speech and language were written in the areas of articulation and expressive grammar. Further, as found above, STUDENT did not have deficits in fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, or attention that interfered with his education. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop goals in all areas of his needs.
One-to-One Aide for Speech Production
The February 11, 2003 IEP did not provide for a one-to-one aide for speech production in the classroom. The Student contends that he required a one-to-one aide for speech production in the classroom for the 2002-2003 school year. The District responded to the Student=s contention for the 2002-2003 school year by relying on its position for the 2001-2002 school year.
The Hearing Officer finds the Student=s position persuasive. Bobbi Marcel, STUDENT=s speech and language therapist for the 2002-2003 school year, prepared a written report of STUDENT=s progress in speech and language therapy for the February 11, 2003 IEP meeting. Ms. Marcel indicated in her report that STUDENT could benefit from services provided five to ten minutes each day in class and/or at home to focus on using correct /s/ and /z/ sounds when speaking with others. (Student=s Exhibit page 334.) According to Ms. Wann, this was the type of service which was provided by the one-to-one aide during the 2001-2002 school year. Unlike the services provided by Ms. Hutchinson, Ms. Marcel=s speech and language services did not include a home component and no evidence was produced to establish Ms. Marcel=s qualifications in the area of oral motor and speech production. The Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT continued to need the assistance of a speech production aide five to ten minutes per school day during the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2002-2003 school year to the limited extent that it did not offer him a one-to-one aide for speech production practice five to ten minutes per school day.
Auditory Processing Program
As to an auditory processing program, the Student and the District both rely on the arguments set forth in issue number two above. To meet STUDENT=s needs concerning his auditory processing deficits, Ms. Wann testified that she continued to provide STUDENT with Project Read, multisensory teaching techniques, and Earobics. Ms. Wohlgemuth, the District=s expert, testified that these methodologies were effective methods by which to address the needs of students with auditory processing deficits such as STUDENT=s. In addition, Ms. Abramson, an audiologist, did not testify concerning STUDENT=s deficits or needs during the 2002-2003 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by not offering him the Fast ForWord or BAT program during the 2002-2003 school year.
Classroom Accommodations
Finally, the Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer necessary classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text. In support of his contention, the Student relies on the record review and assessment conducted by Ms. Dalby during the 2004-2005 school year. The District contends that STUDENT was provided with appropriate accommodations as set forth in the February 13, 2002 IEP, as well as many that were provided as a standard part of the SDC program.
The Hearing Officer does not find the Student=s position persuasive. The February 11, 2003 IEP states that STUDENT is to be provided small-group instruction and multisensory strategies. In addition, Ms. Wann testified that as part of her SDC program she provided all students, including STUDENT, with numerous accommodations, including small-group instruction all day, access to visual material, written schedules, individualized instruction with either a teacher or aide, directions repeated to ensure understanding, extra time for assignments, and preferential seating. There is no evidence that STUDENT=s needs in terms of classroom accommodations had changed since the June 21, 2001 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Wann persuasive. Ms. Wann worked with STUDENT on a daily basis and was very familiar with STUDENT=s needs and required accommodations. Ms. Wann credibly testified that the accommodations he received were designed to meet his needs and additional accommodations were not necessary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate accommodations and that he did not need a slant board or near- and far-point copying of text.
The Hearing Officer, therefore, finds that the District offered and provided STUDENT an educational program with supports that was designed to meet his unique needs. The Hearing Officer also finds that the educational program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit. The educational program addressed all of STUDENT=s needs and provided him with individualized instruction in a small-group setting. (Footnote 13)
Comports with the IEP
The Student contends that the District failed to provide his parents with progress reports. In support of his contention, the Student relies on the testimony of MOTHER who stated that she only received progress reports at IEP meetings. The District contends that STUDENT was provided with required progress reports.
An IEP must include a statement of how the parents will be regularly informed (through such means as periodic report cards) of the progress toward the annual goals, and the extent to which that progress is sufficient to enable the child to achieve the goals by the end of the year. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.347.
The February 11, 2003 IEP indicates that progress reports for the 2002-2003 school year had been completed in October 2002 and February 2003. The copy of the February 11, 2003 IEP entered into evidence also indicates that a progress report was completed in June 2003. (District=s Exhibit No. 7, page 114.) Significantly, the IEP identified the extent to which progress had been made by the reporting periods, and whether the progress was sufficient to meet the annual goal. Additionally, Ms. Wann testified credibly that she used a modified version of a report card for her SDC students which contained a report of progress on work habits and a comment by her concerning the child, and that it was her practice to attach a copy of the goals and objectives with notations of progress. Ms. Wann testified that the progress reports concerning STUDENT=s progress toward his goals and objectives were sent home to STUDENT=s parents at the same time report cards were provided for nondisabled children. MOTHER testified that she only received goal and objective progress sheets at the IEP meetings. However, MOTHER did not contend or testify that she did not receive STUDENT=s report cards. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Wann prepared the progress reports and attached the goal progress reports thereto. In addition, Ms. Wann testified that she sends home a daily report that must be signed by parents every night. MOTHER did not dispute Ms. Wann=s testimony in this regard. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that progress reports were provided to STUDENT=s parents as required by law.
LRE
There is no dispute that the educational placement was provided in the LRE.
***********
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided STUDENT a FAPE in the LRE for the 2002-2003 school year, except to the limited extent that it failed to provide a one-to-one aide for speech production from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year through February 11, 2003, as set forth in the February 13, 2002 IEP and failed to offer STUDENT a one-to-one aide for speech production from February 11, 2003 through the end of the 2002-2003 school year.
Issue No. 4: During the 2003-2004 school year did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
1. Did the District Fail to Assess STUDENT in All Areas of Suspected Disability?
The Student contends that the District should have but did not perform an oral motor assessment for the 2003-2004 school year. The District contends that it did not need to conduct an oral motor assessment for the IEP team to understand STUDENT=s needs.
The evidence in the record suggests that STUDENT=s oral motor needs decreased during the 2003-2004 school year. In fact, the IEPs show that STUDENT=s speech production improved. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in the area of speech production which addressed more complex speech. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT=s progress was so significant that she considered discontinuing speech services in the area of articulation at the time the February 2004 IEP was held, including oral motor skills. Ms. Hutchinson=s testimony is corroborated by Susan Berkowitz, a speech and language pathologist called by the Students, who testified that she did not believe STUDENT demonstrated any deficits that warranted a specific oral-motor examination, nor did she believe that articulation was a major area of concern when she evaluated him in November 2004. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required assess STUDENT in the area of oral motor functioning during the 2003-2004 school year.
B. Did the District Fail to Offer or Provide STUDENT a FAPE during the 2003-2004 School Year?
During the 2003-2004 school year there were two IEPs and an addendum that were in effect and must be analyzed to determine whether STUDENT was offered and provided a FAPE. The February 11, 2003 IEP was the controlling IEP during the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year through February 23, 2004. On October 7, 2003, the IEP team met and prepared an addendum to the February 11, 2003 IEP. The February 24, 2004 IEP was controlling during the period February 24, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year. The IEP team met again on June 21, 2004, and prepared an addendum to the February 24, 2004 IEP. However, this addendum addressed the 2004-2005 school year and, therefore, will be discussed in issue number five. The Hearing Officer will consider each of the IEPs and addendum separately as they relate to the 2003-2004 school year.
1. February 11, 2003 IEP
The Hearing Officer has already determined that the February 11, 2003 IEP was appropriate and did not deny STUDENT a FAPE on procedural or substantive grounds. The Hearing Officer previously found that STUDENT had needs in the areas of phonation, speech articulation, expressive language, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. The Hearing Officer also found that STUDENT needed a small-group setting where he could receive more individual attention and intensive instruction. He also needed speech and language services, classroom accommodations, and goals and objectives to address his areas of need.
The only area of dispute for the 2003-2004 school year as controlled by the February 11, 2003 IEP, is the necessity of a one-to-one aide for speech production. The Hearing Officer previously found that the District should have offered and provided STUDENT with a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2002-2003 school year. However, the evidence shows that by the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, a one-to-one aide for speech production was no longer required. Ms. Hutchinson testified that as of the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year, she was again assigned to provide speech and language services to STUDENT. Ms. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT=s speech production needs had significantly decreased by the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that STUDENT=s articulation was much improved and that he was intelligible. In addition, neither Ms. Hutchinson nor Ms. Berkowitz testified that STUDENT needed a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2003-2004 school year. In light of Ms. Hutchinson=s professional experience, her experience with STUDENT, and STUDENT=s decrease in articulation errors, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not need a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2003-2004 school year.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered and provided STUDENT an educational program that was designed to meet his educational needs. In addition, the program offered was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit. The program addressed
STUDENT=s needs and was provided in an environment where he received individualized instruction in a small-group setting.
There is no dispute that the District provided STUDENT an educational program that comported with his February 11, 2003 IEP. There is also no dispute that the District provided STUDENT an education in the LRE.
2. October 7, 2003 Addendum a. Procedural violations
The Student contends that the District failed to have a general education teacher present when developing the October 7, 2003 addendum. The Student contends that a general education teacher was not present at the October 3, 2003 IEP meeting because the general education teacher signature line is blank. (Footnote 14) The District contends that Ms. Lerager was present at the IEP meeting and was a credentialed general education teacher and was able to provide the necessary input as to STUDENT=s participation in the general education environment.
For the reasons set forth above, the Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. The October 3, 2003 IEP meeting was convened to discuss mainstreaming options for STUDENT. According to the IEP meeting notes, MOTHER wanted the IEP team to pursue mainstreaming options for STUDENT in science and RSP for math. The IEP team agreed to pursue more mainstreaming options. (District=s Exhibit No. 6, testimony of Ms. Wann.) Ms. Lerager had extensive experience with the general education curriculum and was a credentialed general educational teacher. Ms. Lerager was able to provide the IEP team with information concerning the general education curriculum and mainstreaming opportunities. (Testimony of Ms. Lerager.) The Student also contends that the general education teacher to whom he was later assigned for science was required to have been the general education teacher present during the October 3, 2003 IEP meeting. This contention is without merit. The law does not require that the general education teacher who the child might have in the future attend the IEP meeting. Further, the notes indicate that mainstreaming options were going to be considered by the IEP team. There is no evidence that the team had made a decision as to which class STUDENT would be mainstreamed into prior to the October 3, 2003 IEP meeting, rendering it impossible to have invited that teacher to the IEP meeting. Therefore, Ms. Lerager=s presence at the IEP meeting satisfied the requirement that a general education teacher be present at the October 7, 2003 IEP meeting.
Sometime after the October 7, 2003 IEP meeting, without a further IEP meeting, STUDENT was mainstreamed into a general education science class. However, MOTHER did not feel mainstreaming was appropriate and STUDENT was later returned to the SDC for science. There are no further allegations to be considered based upon the October 7, 2003 addendum.
3. February 23, 2004 IEP
The Student alleges both procedural and substantive violations concerning the February 24, 2004 IEP.
a. Procedural violations
The Student contends that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA and State law when it developed a goal on February 4, 2004, outside of an IEP meeting, and failed to later include that goal in the February 23, 2004 IEP. The Student also contends that the District did not comply procedurally with the IDEA and State law when developing the February 23, 2004 IEP by failing to (1) have a speech and language pathologist present during the IEP meeting; (2) provide his parents with a current copy of the notice of safeguards and procedural rights; (3) identify that he would be receiving modified grades; and (4) provide that State testing would be read to him.
Goal Drafted on February 4, 2004
The Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation by developing a goal outside of the IEP process and by failing to later include that goal in the February 23, 2004 IEP. The District contends that it is permitted to draft goals outside of the IEP meeting to facilitate discussion. The District also contends that there is no evidence that the goal drafted on February 4, 2004, was implemented prior to the February 23, 2004 IEP meeting.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by preparing the February 4, 2004 goal outside of the IEP process. The Code of Federal Regulations allows a district to engage in preparatory activities to develop a proposal to present to parents at a later meeting. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.501(b)(2). There is no evidence that the February goal was implemented without parental consent. In addition, the February 4, 2004 goal was not complete at the time it was attached to the February 23, 2004 IEP. The goal required STUDENT to work on target sounds but the target sounds were not identified. (District=s Exhibit No. 5.) Ms. Hutchinson testified that she gave a copy of her draft goals to MOTHER and Ms. Wann and thought that the goals would be discussed and implemented, as determined appropriate by the IEP team, after the upcoming IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation by preparing a draft goal outside of the IEP team meeting. (Footnote 15)
Failure to have Speech Pathologist Present at Meeting
California Education Code section 56341 provides that the IEP team shall include, among others, a special education teacher or a at least one special education provider. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B). This requirement can be met by participation of either the special education child or a special education provider such as a speech and language pathologist if the related service consists of specially designed instruction and is considered special education under the applicable State standard. If, after the completion of an evaluation, there is a need for a specific service, such as speech therapy, the district should ensure that a qualified provider of that service either attends the IEP meeting or provides a written recommendation concerning the nature, frequency, and amount of services to be provided to the child. 34 C.F.R. Part 300, App. A, Q. 30.
Ms. Wann was present at the IEP meeting as STUDENT=s special education teacher. Ms. Hutchinson testified that she was unable to attend the February 23, 2004 IEP meeting because of a family emergency. Ms. Hutchinson also credibly testified that she prepared the present levels of performance for STUDENT and goals and objectives in the area of speech and language prior to the IEP meeting and provided them for consideration by the IEP team. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson made herself available for later telephonic consultation and indicated that she would be willing to attend a meeting at a different time. Ms. Hutchinson also testified that she spoke with MOTHER on the telephone after the IEP meeting. Ms. Hutchinson also reviewed the IEP and signed it indicating that she agreed with its contents. Therefore, the IEP team was provided with adequate input from the speech therapist upon which to make a decision regarding the provision of speech and language services and MOTHER was able to receive information necessary to actively participate in the IEP process. The Hearing Officer finds that the requirements of California Education Code section 56341 were satisfied and the District did not violate the procedural requirements of the IDEA or State law in this regard.
Notice of Procedural Safeguards
The Student reiterates his argument that the District=s failure to provide his parents with a then-current copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards constituted a procedural violation. The Student alleges changes in the law to certain statutes as set forth above. The District contends that it provided a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards to MOTHER.
The February 23, 2004 IEP notes reveal that MOTHER was provided a copy of her rights, and attached to the IEP is a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards signed by MOTHER. As with the prior school year, even if it a technical violation occurred, there was no prejudice because there is neither evidence nor argument that any of the changes in the law specifically affected STUDENT=s educational program or MOTHER=s participation in the IEP process. The Student has not alleged that he was removed from an educational program prior to completion of the course of study or proficiency standards were met or that MOTHER involuntarily gave her consent to the implementation of the IEP. In addition, STUDENT was not a privately placed student, nor was he being transitioned to a regular education program or facing disciplinary proceedings. Finally, the IEP team did not meet to review any assessment or reassessment outside of an IEP meeting. Therefore, STUDENT did not lose educational opportunity nor were MOTHER=s opportunity to participate in the IEP process seriously infringed upon as a result of the possible procedural violation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation in this regard.
Modified Report Cards
An IEP must contain, among other things, a statement of how the student=s progress towards annual goals will be measured and a statement of how the parents will be regularly informed of the student=s progress. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345; 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A).
The Student contends that his report cards failed to address his progress on District standards in academics and only addressed work habits and that, thus, his grades were modified. The Student further contends that his parents did not consent to the receipt of modified grades and the provision of modified grades was not in writing and, therefore, violated Union. The District contends that there is no express requirement that an IEP describe whether a student will receive modified grades. The District further contends that the Hearing Office does not have jurisdiction to hear a dispute regarding whether an IEP must state that a student will receive modified grades, because the grading process does not affect a student=s identification, assessment, or educational placement or the provision of a FAPE to the child.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation, because the IEP states that the parents would be informed of STUDENT=s progress once per trimester by providing annotated goals/objectives. (District=s Exhibit 5, page 91.) California Education Code section 56345 requires that the District provide progress reports concerning a student=s goals. Ms. Wann credibly testified that she provided reports that addressed STUDENT=s work habits, behavior, and effort and a progress report on goals and objectives. Ms. Wann=s testimony is corroborated by the report card introduced into evidence. (District=s Exhibit 35.) MOTHER did not contradict this evidence. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District met the requirements of California Education Code section 56345 and did not commit a procedural violation in this regard.
State Standardized Testing
The Student contends that the District committed a procedural error by failing to identify in the IEP that the State standardized tests would be read to him. The Student=s contention is based upon his not being able to read at grade level. The District contends that the Student=s claim is not within the jurisdiction of the Hearing Office. The District also contends that having a test read to a student is not a widely accepted practice and that the Student=s contention is not related to the remedies he seeks.
California Education Code section 56345(a)(5) provides that the IEP must identify the individual modifications to be provided to the pupil in the administration of State- or District-wide pupil assessments that are needed in order for the pupil to participate in the assessment. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A)(v)(I). The February 23, 2004 IEP identified that STUDENT would participate in State- and District-wide testing and that he would receive extended time and a small-group setting as accommodations. Ms. Harlan testified that these accommodations were sufficient to meet STUDENT=s needs. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary. In addition, Ms. Harlan credibly testified that if the tests were read to a student, it would alter the data being sought and would skew the results. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to have STUDENT=s State tests read to him and did not commit a procedural violation in this regard.
b. Substantive
There is no dispute that STUDENT=s needs did not significantly change between the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and the 2003-2004 school years. STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of reading fluency, written language, phonemic awareness, immediate memory, and sequential memory. The Student contends that he also had needs in the areas of fine motor, social/emotional functioning, and attention. However, the Hearing Officer previously determined that STUDENT did not have needs in these areas that required special education intervention and no evidence was produced that his needs in these areas increased for the 2003-2004 school year. The Student also contends for this school year that the program was not designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs or was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit. The Hearing Officer will only analyze the contested components of FAPE: whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and whether it comported with his February 23, 2004 IEP. To address STUDENT=s unique needs, the February 23, 2004 IEP offered him placement in an LH SDC with mainstreaming for physical education and speech and language therapy. The District also provided STUDENT with twenty days of ESY programming for 240 minutes per day. Goals and objectives were prepared in the area of reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, math, and articulation.
The Student contends that the District=s offer in the February 23, 2004 IEP was not designed to meet his needs because it failed to include (1) goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; and (3) classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text.
Goals and Objectives
The February 23, 2004 IEP contained goals and objectives in the areas of reading comprehension, reading decoding, written language, and math. The Student=s claim that the District did not develop measurable goals in all areas of his unique needs is based upon the same contentions as those raised for the 2001-2002 school year. The Student contends that goals should have been written in the areas of fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, attention, reading decoding, reading comprehension, written language, spelling, math, articulation, expressive grammar, auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory. The District asserts that it developed goals and objectives in all areas of need.
The Hearing Officer has found that STUDENT did not have educational needs in the areas of fine motor skills, social/emotional functioning, and attention. Therefore, goals were not required in those areas.
With regard to the contention that the District was required to write goals and objectives that were specifically labeled and designed to address auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory, Ms. Wann credibly testified that STUDENT=s goals and objectives were written to address each of his needs and were written to State standards. Goal number one required STUDENT to be able to answer literal and inferential reading comprehension questions orally and in writing. Goal number two required STUDENT to decode words with vowel teams and read two hundred additional sight words. Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT=s goals in the February 23, 2004 IEP addressed his auditory processing, sequential processing, and memory deficits even though they were not labeled as such. Ms. Wann also credibly testified that the goals and objectives were written to address STUDENT=s academic skills because the purpose was to assist the child to make academic progress.
However, the only speech and language goal which can be identified as being a part of the February 23, 2004 IEP is the February 4, 2004 goal. This goal was not complete because the target sounds were not identified in the goal. In addition, there were no goals written in the area of expressive language or grammar. Ms. Hutchinson testified that she gave copies of proposed goals to MOTHER and Ms. Wann for consideration by the IEP team. However, no such goals were attached to the February 23, 2004 IEP and there is no indication in the evidence that the IEP team discussed Ms. Hutchinson=s goal and objectives at the February 23, 2004 IEP meeting. (Footnote 16)
In light of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include goals and objectives to meet STUDENT=s speech and language needs from February 23, 2004 through the end of the school year. It is undisputed that STUDENT continued to have needs in speech and language during the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Hutchinson testified that MOTHER had discussed with her the possibility of terminating STUDENT=s speech and language services; however, Ms. Hutchinson did not agree with MOTHER and was of the opinion that STUDENT should continue receiving speech and language services. In addition, Ms. Hutchinson testified that she delivered speech and language goals and objectives to Ms. Wann for consideration by the IEP team. The February 23, 2004 IEP does not contain any of those goals and objectives. Further, STUDENT continued to be identified as eligible for special education and speech and language therapy under the category of speech and language impaired. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District improperly failed to include speech and language goals and objectives in STUDENT=s February 23, 2004 IEP and to that extent denied him a FAPE from February 23, 2004, to the end of the 2003-2004 school year.
One-to-One Aide for Speech Production
The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by failing to offer a one-to-one aide for speech production in the February 23, 2004 IEP. The District contends that STUDENT did not require a one-to-one aide for speech production for the 2003-2004 school year.
The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require a one-to-one aide for speech production for the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Hutchinson testified that she provided STUDENT with speech and language services throughout the 2003-2004 school year. The progress reports for the February 11, 2003 IEP goals and objectives indicate that STUDENT met all of his articulation goals by February 2004. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that STUDENT had developed a much more sophisticated use of language by February 2004. In addition, STUDENT had developed a higher level of sound production which was part of later speech development. Further, Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that MOTHER and she discussed exiting STUDENT from speech and language therapy in February 2004 due to the progress he had made. Thus, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by to offer a one-to-one aide for speech production because the evidence established that this was not necessary to meet his needs or provide him educational benefit.
Auditory Processing Program
As for an auditory processing program, the Student contends that he should have been offered the Fast ForWord or BAT program during the 2003-2004 school year. The District contends that it was meeting STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits through the use of appropriate methodologies. To meet STUDENT=s needs concerning his auditory processing deficits, Ms. Wann testified that she continued to provide STUDENT with Project Read, multisensory teaching techniques, and Earobics. Ms. Wohlgemuth testified that these methodologies were effective methods to address the needs of students with auditory processing deficits such as STUDENT=s. In addition, Ms. Abramson did not testify concerning STUDENT=s deficits or needs during the 2003-2004 school year. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by not offering him Fast ForWord or BAT during the 2003-2004 school year.
Classroom Accommodations
The February 23, 2004 IEP provides that STUDENT was to receive services from a speech and language specialist and small-group instruction. The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE by not providing the classroom accommodations set forth in issue number two above. Ms. Wann credibly testified that STUDENT was provided extra time to complete tasks, memory strategies, and preferential seating and that no other accommodations were required to meet STUDENT=s needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not require a slant board and near- and far-point copying of text.
The Hearing Officer finds the testimony of Ms. Wann persuasive. Ms. Wann worked with STUDENT on a daily basis and was very familiar with STUDENT=s needs and required accommodations. Ms. Wann credibly testified that the accommodations he received were designed to meet his needs and additional accommodations were not necessary. In addition, Ms. O=Brien had observed STUDENT in the classroom on almost a weekly basis for the past three years and testified that he did not need a slant board or near- and far-point copying of text. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided STUDENT with appropriate accommodations and that he did not need a slant board or near- and far-point copying of text.
*******
To summarize, the District provided STUDENT a FAPE except to the limited extent it failed to include goals and objectives in the area of speech and language in the February 23, 2004 IEP. (Footnote 17) In addition, the educational program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit except to the extent it failed to include goals and objectives in the area of speech and language.
Comported with the IEP
There is no dispute that the District provided STUDENT a program that comported with the February 23, 2004 IEP.
Provided in the LRE
There is also no dispute that STUDENT was educated in the LRE.
**********
In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District provided a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year except to the limited extent it did not offer speech and language goals and objectives from February 23, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year. Except for failing to provide speech and language goals from February 23, 2004, through the end of the 2003-2004 school year, the educational program was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.
Issue No. 5: During the 2004-2005 school year did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer STUDENT a FAPE?
2. Did the District Fail to Assess STUDENT in All Areas of Suspected Disability?
The Student contends that the District did not perform an oral motor assessment during the 2004-2005 school year. The District contends that it did not need to conduct an oral motor assessment for the IEP team to understand STUDENT=s needs.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contention is without merit. There is no evidence in the record to suggest that STUDENT=s oral motor needs increased during the 2004-2005 school year. The evidence shows that STUDENT=s speech production had improved from the previous school year. Ms. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT made progress throughout her therapy with him. According to Ms. Hutchinson, STUDENT=s progression was so significant that she considered discontinuing speech services in the area of articulation at the time the February 2004 IEP was held. Ms. Hutchinson=s testimony is corroborated by Susan Berkowitz, STUDENT=s expert witness, who testified that she did not believe STUDENT demonstrated any deficits that warranted a specific oral-motor examination, nor did she believe that articulation was a major area of concern when she evaluated him in November 2004. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not need to assess STUDENT in the area of oral motor functioning during the 2004-2005 school year.
B. Did the District Fail to Offer STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004-2005 School Year?
On June 21, 2004, the IEP team reconvened for the purpose of discussing the testing results and to consider a middle school placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. This process was not complete until the October 25, 2004 IEP was developed. The IEP team prepared an addendum to the February 23, 2004 IEP. (Footnote 18) During this meeting, MOTHER advised the District that she had purchased a home in the San Elijo Middle School attendance area and wanted STUDENT to attend his neighborhood school. Because San Elijo did not have an SDC the District recommended placement at Woodland Park Middle School in an SDC, with mainstreaming for physical education. The District also indicated that STUDENT could receive math and/or social studies with RSP support instead of the SDC. MOTHER did not consent to the IEP and provided the District with a dissent in which she requested that STUDENT be provided placement in an RSP or in general education with aide support. Ms. Bachman testified that upon receipt of MOTHER=s dissent, she contacted the staff at San Elijo and began investigating placement options.
On July 19, 2004, the Student filed a request for due process hearing with the Hearing Office. On July 28, 2004, MOTHER consented to an early triennial evaluation for STUDENT and STUDENT was assessed in the areas of academic achievement, psychomotor development, speech and language, cognitive functioning, social/emotional, adaptive behavior, assistive technology, central auditory processing, visual processing, and health. STUDENT=s speech and language evaluation was completed in August 2004 and showed that he exhibited strength in pragmatics, grammar, and syntax structure. STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with the Aunderstanding of language in the areas of auditory comprehension, reasoning, and memory.@
The District and MOTHER, through her attorney, exchanged letters throughout the summer of 2004 in an effort to reach an agreement concerning placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. The District=s August 4, and 13, 2004 letters proposed placement at San Elijo in the RSP program with a schedule that included homeroom taught by an RSP teacher, RSP language arts, RSP math, band or physical education and history in general education, lunch with homework support two days per week, art two days per week, and social skills activities one day per week. The District requested an IEP meeting to discuss the proposal in its letters.
On August 18, 2004, the IEP team reconvened to discuss placement for the 2004-2005 school year. The IEP team reviewed the offer contained in the District=s August 13, 2004 letter. The District identified a technology class as a possible mainstreaming opportunity for STUDENT. The District continued to offer speech and language therapy and aide support for thirty minutes per week for earth science. The IEP team decided to meet again on September 28, 2004, to review assessments, goals, and any modifications and accommodations which might be necessary.
On August 30, 2004, STUDENT was unilaterally placed by his parents at NewBridge in Poway, California, approximately twenty minutes from San Marcos.
At the September 28, 2004 IEP team meeting, the IEP team reviewed the District=s psychoeducational assessment, speech and language assessment, OT assessment, and assistive technology assessment. STUDENT was identified as having short-term memory and sequential processing skills weaknesses. In the area of speech, STUDENT was identified as continuing to qualify for special education under the category of speech and language impaired and as exhibiting the greatest weakness with inferences. Audrey Weed, the assistive technology evaluator, suggested that STUDENT receive a trial of software and a keyboarding program. No OT services were recommended. The IEP team developed goals and objectives in reading/vocabulary development, reading comprehension, reading decoding, memory, written language, speech, assistive technology, and math. The District recommended that STUDENT receive accommodations in State- or District-wide assessments including small-group setting and extended time. The IEP team agreed to reconvene on October 25, 2004, to continue the meeting.
On October 25, 2004, the IEP team met to finalize STUDENT=s triennial review. Representatives from NewBridge, STUDENT=s private educational placement, were invited and did attend the IEP meeting. The District members of the IEP team recommended that STUDENT be placed at San Elijo with RSP support, including three RSP classes per day. In addition, they recommended that STUDENT receive direct speech and language services one time per week for forty-seven minutes, speech and language consultation one time per month for thirty minutes, OT consultation one time per month for thirty minutes, eight sessions of assistive technology, and fifteen sessions of vision therapy. It was also recommended that STUDENT continue to receive twenty days of ESY services. MOTHER rejected the District=s offer and STUDENT continued to attend NewBridge in Poway, California, at her expense.
During the 2004-2005 school year there was one IEP relevant to a determination of whether STUDENT was offered a FAPE, the October 25, 2004 IEP. However, there were four IEP meetings held to develop the October 25, 2004 IEP. IEP meetings were held on June 21, 2004, August 18, 2004, September 28, 2004, and October 25, 2004. In addition, the District wrote two letters to the Student during the summer of 2004: one on August 4, 2004, and one on August 18, 2004.
4. June 21, 2004 Meeting
The Student contends that the District failed to comply procedurally with the IDEA and State law when it conducted the June 21, 2004 meeting by (1) failing to have a general education teacher present during the IEP meeting; (2) predetermining his educational placement; (3) failing to provide his parents with a then-current copy of the notice of safeguards and procedural rights; and (4) failing to identify that he would be receiving modified grades.
General Education Teacher
As set forth above, a general education teacher is required to be a member of the IEP team if the child is or might be participating in the general education program. During the June 21, 2004 meeting, the IEP team did not contemplate that STUDENT would be participating in general education, except for mainstreaming into physical education. The District had previously attempted to mainstream STUDENT into a science class; however, MOTHER was not happy with the science teacher and requested that STUDENT no longer be mainstreamed for science. In addition, Ms. Lerager was again present at the IEP meeting and she has a general education credential and extensive experience with the general education curriculum and setting. Based on Ms. Lerager=s experience and knowledge of the general education curriculum and STUDENT=s functioning, the Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lerager was able to meet the requirements of the IDEA and State law. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Lerager was knowledgeable about the general education curriculum in the regular classroom and was able to ensure STUDENT=s involvement and progress in the general education environment. Therefore, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by not having a general education teacher present during the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting
Predetermining STUDENT=s Educational Placement
The Student contends that the District denied him a FAPE because it predetermined his educational placement when it offered placement in an SDC at Woodland Park. The evidence showed that MOTHER actively participated in the IEP process. Ms. Wann testified that prior to the IEP meeting she spoke with MOTHER about STUDENT=s placement for the 2004-2005 school year. Ms. Wann further testified that MOTHER did not want STUDENT to attend San Marcos Middle School, so Ms. Wann began investigating alternative placements to bring to the IEP team. The notes from the June 21, 2004 IEP team meeting indicate that the IEP team considered placement in RSP classes, as well as the SDC. In addition, the notes indicate that it was not the District=s final offer. (District=s Exhibit No. 4.) Ms. Harlan credibly testified that the program at Woodland Park Middle School was described and that MOTHER was provided with phone numbers so she could arrange a visit at the school and talk with teachers. Ms. Harlan=s testimony is corroborated by the meeting notes which provided the names and telephone numbers of the SDC teachers at Woodland Park. Ms. Harlan testified that MOTHER wanted an opportunity to consider the placement so the June 21, 2004 meeting adjourned. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was not predetermined because other options were considered and MOTHER=s input was actively sought. In addition, this was not the final offer of the District because the IEP team continued to meet and the District continued to investigate other placement options for STUDENT.
Procedural Safeguards
The Student reiterates his argument that the District=s failure to provide his parents with a then-current copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards constituted a procedural violation. The Student=s contention is based upon changes to the California Education Code previously identified. The District=s contention is the same as for the previous school year as well. The June 21, 2004 addendum notes reveal that MOTHER was provided a copy of her rights, and a copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards signed by MOTHER is attached to the addendum. It is not possible to determine if the new or amended language was or was not incorporated into the rights received by the parents because a complete copy of the Notice of Procedural Safeguards was not introduced into evidence. However, even if it a technical violation occurred, there was no prejudice because there was neither argument nor evidence that any changes in the law affected STUDENT=s educational program or MOTHER=s participation in the IEP process. The Student has not alleged that he was improperly removed from an educational program or that MOTHER involuntarily gave her consent to the implementation of the IEP. In addition, at the time of the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting STUDENT was not a privately placed student, nor was he being transitioned to a regular education program or facing disciplinary proceedings. Finally, the IEP team did not meet to review any assessment or reassessment outside of an IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation in this regard. (Footnote 19)
Modified Report Cards
An IEP must contain a statement of how the student=s progress towards annual goals will be measured, and a statement of how the parents will be regularly informed of the student=s progress. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56345; 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(A).
The Student contends that his report cards failed to address his progress on District standards in academics and only addressed work habits and thus his grades were modified. The Student further contends that MOTHER did not consent to the receipt of modified grades and the provision of modified grades was not in writing and, therefore, violated the Union requirement. The Hearing Officer analyzed this contention fully in the 2003-2004 school year. The contentions are the same and the law in this area did not change. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that no violation occurred.
2. August 4, 2004 and August 13, 2004 Letters
The Student contends that the District committed procedural violations by making an incomplete written offer in a letter dated August 4, 2004, outside the IEP process. The Student also contends that the August 4, 2004 letter required his parents to determine whether placement in an SDC or an RSP class would provide him with a FAPE. The District contends that it acted reasonably in attempting to address MOTHER=s concerns and requests while ensuring that an offer of placement was available and provided in writing prior to the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year and that the August 4 and 13, 2004 letters constituted an offer of FAPE.
It is well established that one procedural violation that may constitute a denial of FAPE is the failure of a school district to make a formal, written offer of placement in compliance with the IDEA=s procedural requirements as discussed in Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519, 1526 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied, 115 S.Ct. 428 (1994); 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(b)(3). In Union, the district failed to make a formal written offer of a particular placement because it believed the parents would reject the placement. According to the district, the parents had expressed their Aunwillingness@ to consider it as a placement. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals held that the district could not Aescape its obligation under the IDEA to offer formally an appropriate education placement by arguing that a disabled child=s parents expressed unwillingness to consider it as a placement.@ The Court of Appeals stated, AThis formal requirement [of a written offer of placement] has an important purpose that is not merely technical, and we therefore believe that it should be enforced rigorously.@ Regarding the purpose of the requirement of a written offer of placement, the Court stated:
The requirement of a formal, written offer creates a clear record that will do much to eliminate troublesome factual disputes many years later about when placements were offered, what placements were offered, and what additional educational assistance was offered to supplement a placement, if any. Furthermore, a formal, specific offer from a school district will greatly assist parents in Apresent[ing] complaints with respect to any matter relating to the . . . educational placement of the child.@ Id. The Court further explained that, under the facts of Union, a formal written offer would have alerted the parents Ato the need to consider seriously@ whether the particular placement was appropriate under the IDEA, would have allowed the parents to decide whether to oppose the placement or to Aaccept it with the supplement of additional education services,@ and would have helped the district to better prepare to introduce sufficient relevant evidence regarding the appropriateness of the placement at hearing. Id.
The Student contends that the August 4, 2004 letter constitutes a placement offer that was prepared outside of an IEP meeting. The District contends that the letters were prepared in an effort to communicate with MOTHER prior to the beginning of the school year since it was not possible for the IEP meeting to occur before that time. (Footnote 20) Further, the District=s offer of placement at San Elijo Middle School in the August 4, 2004 letter was being offered in response to MOTHER=s request and was, therefore, not prepared without her input or participation.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. The District convened the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting so that the IEP team could discuss placement for the 2004-2005 school year. MOTHER fully participated in that meeting and indicated her desire for STUDENT to be placed in his home school, San Elijo. Ms. Bachman testified that she reviewed the dissent to the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting prepared by MOTHER and that she believed that if the District and the parents worked together, several of the issues could be resolved. Ms. Bachman also testified that she contacted the staff at San Elijo to determine what could be offered to STUDENT at San Elijo that would provide him with an appropriate placement and services. Ms. Bachman stated that it was not her intent to make a placement offer outside of the IEP process. Ms. Bachman stated that she was trying to meet STUDENT=s transitional needs and trying to find a way to connect the parent to more information about San Elijo. Ms. Bachman further testified that it was her intent that the placement option would be discussed at an IEP meeting prior to the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year. The August 4, 2004 letter is clear that the District believed the most appropriate placement for STUDENT was an SDC, but that it could offer him an appropriate placement and services at San Elijo. The evidence shows that the District was diligently trying to identify an appropriate placement for STUDENT prior to the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year that would be agreeable to MOTHER and work with MOTHER. In addition, there were monthly IEP meetings, the first of which was held two days after the beginning of the school year, and the IEP was not finalized until the October 25, 2004 IEP was prepared. (District=s Exhibit No. 1, 2, and 3.) The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate the procedural requirements of the IDEA and State law by preparing the August 4, 2004 letter.
Likewise, the August 13, 2004 letter from the District to STUDENT=s attorney provided information concerning a possible schedule for STUDENT if he chose to attend San Elijo. (District=s Exhibit No. 58.) At the time the August 13, 2004 letter was sent, an IEP meeting was scheduled for August 18, 2004. (District=s Exhibit No. 59.) The August 13, 2004 letter reiterates the District=s desire to provide STUDENT a placement option at San Elijo for the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. Although these letters contained an offer of placement, the offers were not made without parental involvement as in Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2003). In Shapiro, the district made an offer without including the parents in the IEP process. Here the letters were not intended to take the place of an IEP meeting, but were developed as the result of an earlier IEP meeting and to facilitate a later IEP meeting. The testimony of Ms. Bachman establishes that the District was diligently trying to schedule an IEP meeting prior to the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. In addition, the letters were prepared in response to MOTHER=s request at the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting for placement at San Elijo. Accepting the Student=s position would lead to a chilling effect on attempts by districts to discuss and explore compromises with parents. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not violate the procedural requirements of the IDEA and State law in this regard.
3. August 18, 2004 Meeting
The Student contends that the District committed procedural violations when the IEP team met on August 18, 2004 by (1) requiring his parents to determine which placement would provide him with a FAPE; (2) failing to provide a complete offer; and (3) failing to accurately identify the speech and language services he had been and would be receiving. The District contends that it clearly indicated that the Woodland Park SDC placement would provide STUDENT the greatest educational benefit, but that to meet the parents= request it was offering him a FAPE in the San Elijo RSP and that the speech and language services were clearly delineated in the August 18, 2004 addendum.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contention that the August 18, 2004 meeting required his parents to determine which placement would provide him a FAPE in violation of Union is without merit. The District consistently maintained at the IEP meeting that an SDC placement at Woodland Park Middle School would provide STUDENT with the greatest educational benefit, but that it was offering him a FAPE in the RSP at San Elijo. (Testimony of Ms. Bachman, Ms. Wann; District Exhibit No. 3 and 61.) The District did not provide MOTHER with a Asmorgasbord@ of placements. The language of the letters and the notes of the IEP meeting clearly indicate that the District was offering STUDENT placement at San Elijo, not Woodland Park. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation in this regard.
The Hearing Officer also finds the Student=s contention that the August 18, 2004 addendum did not provide a complete offer also without merit. The development of the IEP for the 2004-2005 school year was an evolving deliberation process from June 21, 2004, through October 25, 2004, when the IEP was finalized after the completion of numerous assessments, investigations, and discussions concerning placement options. The June 21, 2004 IEP meeting was the beginning of the IEP teams discussions about placement for the 2004-2005 school year when the District first received parental input as to the appropriate placement for STUDENT for the 2004-2005 school year. The August 18, 2004 addendum was an addendum to the controlling IEP which was dated February 23, 2004. In addition, the IEP team agreed to continue the August 18, 2004 meeting to September 28, 2004, to review assessments, goals and objectives, and modifications and accommodations. (Footnote 21) (District=s Exhibit No. 3, page 73.) It is clear that the team anticipated the receipt of evaluations before completing the IEP process. Therefore, the District did not commit any procedural errors in this regard in creating the August 18, 2004 addendum. (Footnote 22)
The Hearing Officer finds Student=s contention that the August 18, 2004 addendum failed to identify speech and language services is without merit. The August 18, 2004 addendum provides that the District was offering speech and language services forty-five times per year in twenty minutes sessions. The goals and objectives for the 2004-2005 school year were not completed during this IEP meeting. (District Exhibit No. 3, page 73.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit a procedural violation during the August 18, 2004 meeting.
4. September 28, 2004 IEP
The Student further contends that the District committed procedural violations when developing the September 28, 2004 IEP by: (1) requiring his parents to determine which placement would provide him with a FAPE; (2) failing to provide a complete offer; (3) predetermining his placement; (4) failing to invite representatives from his nonpublic school to the IEP meeting; and (5) failing to identify what modifications would be provided in the classroom. The District contends that its position concerning the placement offer was clear and that it did not predetermine STUDENT=s placement. The District contends that although it did not invite a representative from NewBridge to attend the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT was not deprived of educational benefit because he had only been attending NewBridge for three and a half weeks and the staff had limited experience with him during that short time. The District also contends that the Student=s contention concerning the failure to provide modifications is without merit because appropriate modifications and accommodations were attached to the September 28, 2004 IEP.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s first two contentions are without merit for the reasons set forth under the analysis of the August 18, 2004 IEP meeting. The development of the IEP for the 2004-2005 school year was an evolving process from June 21, 2004, through October 25, 2004. The IEP was finalized in October 2004, after the completion of numerous assessments, investigations, and discussions concerning placement options.
The Student contends that the District predetermined his placement when it prepared the September 28, 2004 IEP. The Hearing Officer finds the Student=s position is without merit and contradictory. The Student argues that the District failed to provide just one placement offer and that the placement offer was predetermined. In June 2004, the District=s position was that STUDENT should be placed in an SDC at Woodland Park. MOTHER disagreed with the District=s recommendation and wanted STUDENT placed at San Elijo with special education support for 70 percent of the school day. (Student=s Exhibit pages 412-413.) Ms. Bachman testified that upon receipt of MOTHER=s dissent she made inquiries to determine if MOTHER=s requests could be accommodated. Thereafter, the District began preparing a placement at San Elijo that would meet STUDENT=s needs and comply with the requests of MOTHER. The IEP meeting notes indicate the team considered changing STUDENT=s qualifying condition, but that discussion was continued at the parent=s request until after receipt of the auditory processing and visual therapy assessment reports. The IEP team also discussed goals and objectives and adjustments were made to the comprehension goal. The team did not have an opportunity to discuss placement for the 2004-2005 school year prior to the termination of the IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the placement was not predetermined.
As set forth above, California Education Code section 56341 provides that the IEP team shall consist of the parent(s); a general education teacher, if the child is or might be participating in the regular education environment; a special education teacher or special education service provider; a district representative; the person who conducted or is knowledgeable about an assessment of the child; at the discretion of the parent or the district, anyone who has special knowledge of the child; and, if appropriate, the child. 20 U.S.C. ' 1414(d)(1)(B). The IDEA requires the person most knowledgeable about the child to attend the IEP meeting and that may include a representative from a private school. Shapiro v. Paradise Valley Unified School District, 317 F.3d 1072 (9th Cir. 2003); W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees, 960 F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992). (Footnote 23)
The Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to invite representatives from his nonpublic school to the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting. The District contends that although it did not invite a representative from NewBridge to attend the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting, STUDENT was not deprived of educational benefit because he had only been attending NewBridge for three and a half weeks and the staff had limited experience with him during that short time and that it complied with California Education Code section 56341.
The Hearing Officer finds the District=s position persuasive. The September 28, 2004 IEP indicates that Ms. Wann, Ms. Lerager, and Ms. Hutchinson were present at the IEP meeting, in addition to many other participants. Ms. Wann and Ms. Hutchinson had worked with STUDENT for many years prior to the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting and were most knowledgeable about his educational needs. Additionally, STUDENT has been unilaterally placed at NewBridge by his parents. The District had continued to offer placement at San Elijo with RSP support. Moreover, STUDENT only began attending NewBridge at the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. The September 28, 2004 IEP indicates that Debra Tadman was present as a general education teacher, Ms. Wann was present as STUDENT=s special education teacher, and Ms. Lerager was present as the District=s representative. Also present were District evaluators including Celeste Doughty, school psychologist, Shannon O=Brien, OT, Audrey Weed, assistive technology evaluator, and Valerie Hutchinson, speech pathologist. Ms. Wann, Ms. Lerager, and Ms. Hutchinson had extensive knowledge of STUDENT. They had worked with STUDENT for several years. In addition, the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting was continued to October 25, 2004, and NewBridge was invited to and attended the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that all persons required to be members of the IEP team, including those most knowledgeable about STUDENT=s educational needs were present during the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting.
As to the Student=s final contention that the September 28, 2004 IEP failed to identify the modifications to be provided in the classroom, the Hearing Officer finds this contention is without merit. The September 28, 2004 IEP states that STUDENT was to be provided with modified assignments, instruction in small groups, and aide support while he was in a general education setting. (District=s Exhibit No. 2, page 53.) In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that this was an IEP process that was not concluded until October 25, 2004. The notes from the IEP meeting indicate that the team agreed to continue the IEP meeting to October 25, 2004. In addition, the front page of the September 28, 2004 IEP was not completed, indicating that the IEP had not been finalized. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not commit any procedural violations when conducting the September 28, 2004 IEP meeting.
5. October 25, 2004 IEP a. Procedural violations
The Student contends the District committed procedural violations when developing the October 25, 2004 IEP by (1) conducting the IEP meeting before all educational assessments had been received; (2) failing to have qualified personnel present to discuss and interpret data from the vision therapy and auditory processing assessments; (3) requiring his parents to determine which placement would provide him with a FAPE; and (4) predetermining his educational placement. The District contends that all educational assessments were completed by the time the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting was conducted. The District also contends that it obtained as much information as possible from evaluators who could not be present at the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting and offered to fund a review between the assessors and MOTHER. The District contends that it was clear that an SDC was the most appropriate placement to meet STUDENT=s unique needs, but that the District offered STUDENT a FAPE in the RSP at San Elijo. Finally, the District contends that the placement was not predetermined, but was the result of input from MOTHER.
The Student contends that the District conducted the IEP meeting prior to receiving all educational assessments. The Hearing Officer finds the Student=s position to be without merit. The records indicate that all assessments had been completed prior to the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting. (Footnote 24)
As to the Student=s second contention, the Student argues that the District failed to have anyone knowledgeable about the developmental optometry or the audiology assessments present during the October 28, 2004 IEP meeting. The Student further contends that neither Ms. Bachman, who presented Dr. Richard M. Skay=s vision therapy report, nor Emily Tuten, a District speech pathologist who presented Ms. Abramson=s audiology report, was knowledgeable about the assessment procedures, results, or recommendations contained in those reports. The District contends that although Ms. Bachman, the director of special education, is not an optometrist, she has received vision therapy and had knowledge of the service. The District contends that two speech therapists spoke with Ms. Abramson and attended the IEP meeting to present Ms. Abramson=s report. The District also contends that it offered to pay for a one-hour consultation between MOTHER and the assessors.
California Education Code section 56341 provides that an IEP team must include individuals who conducted an assessment of the pupil or who are knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used to assess the pupil, and are familiar with the assessment results or recommendations. The individual shall be qualified to interpret the instructional implications of the assessment results.
Ms. Bachman credibly testified that she wanted the assessors present at the IEP meeting and invited both Dr. Skay and Ms. Abramson to attend; however, they were not available and could not attend by telephone. Ms. Bachman testified that she spoke to Dr. Skay about his report and reviewed the report for the IEP team on October 25, 2004. In addition, Ms. Bachman testified that she instructed two speech pathologists to interview Ms. Abramson and present the information to the IEP team. The notes from the October 25, 2004 IEP indicate that both Emily Tuten, a District speech pathologist, and Ms. Hutchinson spoke to Ms. Abramson on two occasions and presented Ms. Abramson=s report to the IEP team. The notes also indicate that the reports and recommendations were presented to the IEP team. However, the Hearing Officer finds that there was insufficient evidence produced to show that Ms. Hutchinson or Ms. Tuten were knowledgeable about the assessment procedures used by Ms. Abramson and her assessment results and recommendations, or qualified to interpret the instructional implications of the assessment results. Ms. Hutchinson testified that she had been trained in the use of Fast ForWord, but did not offer testimony as to her training and experience in evaluating auditory processing delays. Further, Ms. Tuten did not testify in this proceeding. The District has the burden of proving that Ms. Hutchinson and Ms. Tuten were qualified to present Ms. Abramson=s evaluation to the IEP team in accordance with California Education Code section 56341. The District did not meet this burden. In addition, the Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. Bachman was not qualified to interpret the instructional implications of Dr. Skay=s assessment results. Ms. Bachman is the director of special education and does not have any training or experience in the delivery of vision therapy services. Ms. Bachman has personally received vision therapy services, but this did not render her knowledgeable of Dr. Skay=s assessment procedures, results, and recommendations or qualified to interpret the instructional implications of the assessment results for the IEP team. Therefore, a procedural violation occurred in this regard. In light of this, the Hearing Officer must determine whether any prejudice occurred as a result of the procedural violation.
On October 26, 2004, the District wrote a letter to STUDENT=s attorney and informed him that it would be willing to pay for Dr. Skay and Ms. Abramson to review their reports with MOTHER and convene a further IEP meeting if MOTHER desired. (District=s Exhibit No. 291.) In addition, the District offered to pay for MOTHER to consult with both Dr. Skay and MOTHER and convene an additional IEP meeting if desired. (Footnote 25) The District ensured that it had the vision and central auditory processing assessments and recommendations explained to it through Ms. Bachman and two speech and language pathologists. The District adopted the vision therapy recommendations and all of the auditory processing recommendations with the exception of the BAT computer program. The Hearing Officer finds that although the assessors were not present at the IEP meeting, the District made substantial efforts to ensure that MOTHER was fully informed concerning the vision therapy and auditory processing evaluations. Any prejudice which may have occurred by the failure of Ms. Abramson and Dr. Skay to attend the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting was overcome by the District=s offer to pay for a consultation between the assessors and MOTHER. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that a procedural violation did not occur that seriously infringed on the parents= opportunity to participate meaningfully in the IEP process.
The Student contends that the October 25, 2004 IEP violated Union because it required his parents to determine which placement was most appropriate for him. For the reasons set forth in the analysis of the August 18, 2004 addendum, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not require STUDENT=s parents to determine which placement was most appropriate for him. The IEP documents, as well as related correspondence, clearly state that the District believed the SDC at Woodland Park would provide STUDENT the greatest educational opportunity but that it was offering him a FAPE in the RSP at San Elijo. Following the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting, the only offer made by the District was placement at San Elijo with RSP support.
The Student contends that the District predetermined his placement at the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not predetermine STUDENT=s educational placement. The notes from the October 25, 2004 IEP meeting indicate that the IEP team reviewed the results of assessments, developed goals and objectives, and discussed placement options and supports. The IEP team also discussed accommodations and strategies, assistive technology, and a transition plan. MOTHER=s concerns were noted in the IEP. MOTHER testified that she participated in the IEP process and indicated on the IEP that she had the opportunity to help develop the IEP. In addition, MOTHER was represented by an attorney at the IEP meeting who also provided input and made requests. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT=s educational placement was not predetermined and no procedural violation occurred in this regard.
b. Substantive
The Student contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year because the proposed IEP did not (1) contain goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) include occupational therapy, vision therapy, a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; (3) offer him an appropriate transition plan; (4) identify the frequency and duration of the vision therapy, auditory processing therapy, and occupational therapy consultation; and (5) provide classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text. The Student also contends that the District=s offer was not the LRE.
STUDENT=s Unique Needs
To determine whether the program was designed to meet STUDENT=s unique educational needs for the 2004-2005 school year, the Hearing Officer must first ascertain what his unique needs were at the time the offer was drafted. The Student contends he had needs in the areas of fine motor skills, language, auditory processing, sequencing, immediate memory, attention, phonemic awareness, rapid naming, cognitive flexibility, working memory, visual scanning, reading, math, writing, reading fluency, social/emotional functioning, and problem solving. The Student=s contentions are based on the District=s reports and the reports of Dr. Skay, Dr. Perlman, Ms. Berkowitz, Ms. Abramson, and Ms. Dalby. The District contends that it accurately assessed and identified STUDENT=s needs and that Dr. Perlman confirmed the findings of its assessment.
Celeste Doughty, the District=s school psychologist, completed an evaluation of STUDENT in August 2004. Ms. Doughty=s evaluation occurred over a three-day period and included an observation at NewBridge. Ms. Doughty concluded that STUDENT had weaknesses in the areas of phonemic awareness, auditory sequencing, visual sequencing, working memory, ability to control finger and hand movements, and auditory processing. Ms. Doughty also concluded that STUDENT was in the borderline clinical range for anxiety/depression and social problems. Ms. Doughty also found that STUDENT scored within the clinical range in the area of internalizing problems. Ms. Doughty noted that during the fifth grade, STUDENT was very social and well liked by his peers. According to Ms. Doughty, STUDENT participated in school plays, peace patrol, safety patrol, a running program, and track meets. STUDENT was described as polite and it was noted that he frequently complimented school staff. MOTHER secured a private educational evaluation from Dr. Perlman in November 2004. Dr. Perlman testified that Ms. Doughty had adequately assessed STUDENT and that he agreed with her findings. Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT had deficits in the areas of working memory, reading fluency, sequential processing, immediate memory, phonemic awareness, reading, written language, and math. (Footnote 26) These deficits are consistent with those identified by Ms. Doughty.
However, the District disagrees with Dr. Perlman=s conclusion that STUDENT had social/emotional and attentional needs based upon his classroom behaviors. In support of its position, the District relies on the testimony of Ms. Wann and Ms. Hutchinson, who both reported that STUDENT was very social, well liked, and got along well with his peers and adults. However, Sabrina MacFarlane, STUDENT=s math teacher at NewBridge, credibly testified that STUDENT participated in a lot of side by side play, made inappropriate comments, and could not interact with his peers when he entered NewBridge. Ms. MacFarlane also testified that STUDENT exhibited anxiety. For example, he cried when frustrated or upset, such as when he did not know what words to use to communicate his thoughts to teachers or peers. It is the District=s position that STUDENT=s frustration at NewBridge was due to the new school setting. The Hearing Officer finds that this position is supported by the evidence presented at the hearing. STUDENT had previously attended Carrillo since the 2000-2001 school year and had been placed in Ms. Wann=s class since the 2001-2002 school year. It is undisputed that STUDENT had to change schools for the 2004-2005 school year because he had completed elementary school. Therefore, in light of the test results obtained by both Ms. Doughty and Dr. Perlman, as well as STUDENT=s behaviors at NewBridge, the Hearing Officer finds that the behaviors exhibited at NewBridge would have been exhibited at any new placement, including San Elijo. The District should have had knowledge of STUDENT=s transition behaviors because his transition to NewBridge occurred in August 2004, and the IEP was not completed until October 25, 2004. In addition, the District acknowledged STUDENT=s transition difficulties when it created the transition plan in the October 25, 2004 IEP. Currently, STUDENT is not exhibiting any behaviors at NewBridge. (Testimony of Ms. MacFarlane.) In light of STUDENT=s results on his social/emotional testing and his behaviors at NewBridge, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had social/emotional needs during the transition to a new school for the 2004-2005 school year.
In the area of attention, STUDENT scored in the average range on District assessments. Dr. Perlman=s results indicated that Anot enough behaviors were reported to occur with regular frequency@ to suggest that STUDENT may have ADHD. Dr. Perlman concluded that STUDENT had quite narrow Aattentional focus.@ Again, Dr. Perlman=s test results were not confirmed by STUDENT=s behavior in the classroom at Carillo. Ms. Wann reported that STUDENT was on task, focused, and responded positively to a structured schedule. Ms. Wann also reported that STUDENT worked on assignments to completion, which at times took thirty minutes. Ms. MacFarlane also testified that STUDENT had difficulties with attention at times, but that he was able to use strategies such as Brain Gym to regain his attention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have deficits in the area of attention that were interfering with his ability to access the curriculum.
STUDENT also was evaluated by Valerie Hutchinson, speech and language pathologist. Ms. Hutchinson found that STUDENT had needs in the areas of articulation, auditory comprehension, reasoning and memory, semantics, and expressive language. Susan Berkowitz, STUDENT=s private speech and language assessor, also found that STUDENT had needs in auditory processing, language comprehension, phonological awareness, auditory memory, comprehension and use of syntax, comprehension and use of vocabulary, verbal formulation skills, and narrative discourse skills. Ms. Berkowitz observed STUDENT for one and a half hours and did not speak to any of his previous teachers or speech and language therapists. The areas of need identified by Ms. Berkowitz were also identified by either Ms. Hutchinson or Ms. Doughty, except for the area of narrative discourse. Ms. Hutchinson testified that STUDENT was able to engage in a narrative discourse with her. Ms. Hutchinson testified that during one session STUDENT was able to describe which cellular phone plan would be the best for Ms. Hutchinson to obtain, as well as the blackout areas and where to purchase the cellular phone. Ms. Hutchinson=s testimony is corroborated by her therapy notes. (Student=s Exhibit page 591.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not have needs in narrative discourse, but that he did have speech and language deficits in the areas of articulation, auditory comprehension, reasoning and memory, semantics, and expressive language. It is undisputed that STUDENT needs speech and language services to address these needs.
STUDENT also received an auditory processing evaluation, paid for by the District, that was conducted by Maria Abramson in September 2004. It is undisputed that STUDENT has auditory processing deficits. Ms. Abramson found that STUDENT has Abottom up@ auditory processing deficits which impact the way the brain processes or interprets the signal it receives; this impacts auditory decoding skills. In addition, Ms. Abramson found that STUDENT=s central auditory processing testing revealed developmental delays. Ms. Abramson testified that as a result of these deficits, STUDENT needs a Abottom up@ auditory training program such as BAT or Fast ForWord. The District disputes that STUDENT needs BAT or Fast ForWord. Ms. Abramson testified that she could not recommend Fast ForWord without the input of a speech and language pathologist and the IEP team because the program takes an hour and forty minutes every day. Ms. Abramson also testified that some auditory processing problems can be addressed by a speech and language pathologist and a special education teacher, although they usually address Atop down@ weaknesses. In addition, Ms. Wohlgemuth testified that auditory processing deficits are more effectively addressed through direct intervention. Ms. Wohlgemuth also testified that she knew Ms. Abramson and would respect her opinion. Although the parties disagreed on the type of service needed, it is undisputed that STUDENT has auditory processing deficits. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has deficits in auditory processing and needs direct intervention.
STUDENT also received an occupational therapy evaluation from Shannon O=Brien in August 2004. Ms. O=Brien found STUDENT did not have OT deficits that interfered with his educational environment and required direct services. Ms. O=Brien assessed STUDENT=s fine motor skills and assessed his sensory processing abilities. Ms. O=Brien concluded that STUDENT demonstrates sensory processing function similar to most people of his age group, except in the area of Aidentifying low registration@ and he was able to demonstrate an appropriate level of alertness for individual assessment activities, was able to follow directions and manage personal material, and exhibited no significant sensory-related behaviors. Ms. O=Brien made recommendations for interventions including participation in a structured educational program with multisensory experiences, use of a soft-grip molded mechanical pencil to support use of a consistent grasp and that would encourage reduced pressure in grasp contributing to hand fatigue, and practice in hand relaxation exercises. (Student=s Exhibit pages 791-795.) The Student did not challenge the validity or appropriateness of Ms. O=Brien=s evaluation. Dr. Skay=s report also concluded that STUDENT had deficits with posture and pencil grip. Concerning the Student=s assertion that he has sensory processing deficits, in addition to the testing performed by Ms. O=Brien, Ms. Wann did not testify that STUDENT had tactile seeking behaviors difficulties in class. Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT was able to sustain attention and complete tasks that took approximately thirty minutes. Based upon the assessment information, the IEP team found that STUDENT had OT needs and required OT services. All relevant assessors agree that STUDENT has difficulty with pencil grip.
Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had OT deficits in posture and pencil grip and required services to overcome these deficits. The Hearing Officer does not find, however, that STUDENT has sensory processing deficits that interfered with his participation in the educational environment. In November 2004, STUDENT was evaluated by Janice Dalby, an occupational therapist at NewBridge. Ms. Dalby concluded that STUDENT had sensory processing deficits related to auditory stimuli, vestibular-proprioceptive stimuli (which contributed to his difficulty in sustaining an upright posture while sitting and regulating his pencil grasp, tactile seeking behaviors, and a need for sameness and predictability. First, the information available to the District at the time it developed its proposal for the 2004-2005 school year, which included Ms. O=Brien=s OT assessment, did not indicate that STUDENT had any sensory processing deficits that were interfering with his ability to be successful in the school setting. Additionally, the sensory processing difficulties described in Ms. Dalby=s report were not seen in the educational setting at Carillo. As noted earlier, Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT was able to sustain attention and complete tasks that took approximately thirty minutes and did not testify that STUDENT had tactile seeking behavior difficulties in class.
It is undisputed that STUDENT has vision deficits and requires vision therapy. STUDENT received a vision therapy assessment by Dr. Skay in October 2004. Dr. Skay found that STUDENT had deficits in eye focus and speed of accommodation, eye movement, eye fixation, and eye tracking, fusional divergence and convergence binocular training, posture, pencil grip, and reading distance; and that he requires laterality and directionality training to reduce reversals and improve letter/sound recognition. Dr. Skay recommended fifteen vision therapy sessions and the use of reading glasses. (District=s Exhibit No. 24.) Dr. Skay=s findings and recommendations are undisputed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT had vision deficits and needs fifteen sessions of vision therapy.
It is also undisputed that STUDENT requires assistive technology. STUDENT received an assistive technology assessment conducted by Audrey Weed in September 2004. Ms. Weed=s report concluded that due to STUDENT=s deficits in the use of vocabulary, spelling, and grammar, he would benefit from a word prediction program such as Co:Writer. Ms. Weed also recommended an outlining program, such as Draft:Building, to assist STUDENT with organization and help him with written language production, and keyboarding instruction due to STUDENT=s low keyboarding skills. Dr. Perlman reviewed Ms. Weed=s report and agreed with her conclusions. Therefore, STUDENT has assistive technology needs that should be addressed using a word prediction program, outlining program, and keyboarding instruction.
The dispute in this case centers mainly on the program components necessary to meet STUDENT=s needs. The parties agree that STUDENT needs a small classroom with special education support in reading, written language, and math. The parties also agree that STUDENT needs modifications and accommodations in the classroom including those designed to address auditory sequential memory, to assist STUDENT with what to listen to before delivering auditory information, to provide visual information to support auditory information, and to ensure STUDENT has adequate opportunities for repetition of information through different experiences to enhance memory. Dr. Perlman contends that a comprehensive campus setting is not appropriate for STUDENT unless the campus can be made small for him. The Hearing Officer finds that the evidence produced at the hearing does not support this contention. According to Ms. Wann and Ms. Hutchinson, STUDENT was able to participate in the Carrillo campus setting, including being involved in school plays, safety patrol, and peace patrol. The Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was able to successfully attend a comprehensive campus and did not experience any difficulties in this regard. However, there is also evidence that STUDENT required a comprehensive transition plan to alleviate his anxiety and frustration in transferring to a new school.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT has speech and language deficits, including deficits in the areas of articulation, auditory comprehension, reasoning and memory, semantics, and expressive language. STUDENT also has deficits in the areas of phonemic awareness, auditory sequencing, visual sequencing, working memory, ability to control finger and hand movements, auditory processing, and social/emotional functioning. To meet these deficits, STUDENT needs a small structured, predictable classroom environment with special education supports in academic areas. STUDENT also needs speech and language services, auditory processing interventions, assistive technology, vision therapy, and OT.
Designed to Meet Unique Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit
To meet his unique needs, the District offered STUDENT placement in the RSP and general education program at San Elijo Middle School, his home school. According to the October 25, 2004 IEP, STUDENT was to participate in RSP for homeroom, math, reading, and written language. STUDENT was to participate in the general education program for art, technology, earth science, and physical education. STUDENT was to receive aide support in the earth science class. STUDENT was also offered speech and language services in forty-seven-minute sessions per week in a therapeutic setting and the classroom, thirty minutes per month of speech consultation, thirty minutes per month of OT consultation, eight sessions of assistive technology, fifteen sessions of vision therapy, and consultation between all service providers and the general education teachers one time per month for thirty minutes. The District also prepared goals and objectives in the areas of reading/vocabulary development, reading comprehension, reading decoding, reading sight words memory, written language, spelling, memory, math, expressive/receptive language, articulation, and keyboarding. STUDENT was also to be provided with pentel markers, soft grip mechanical pencils, Co:Writer, Draft Builder, Write Outloud, Type to Learn, and direct instruction in how to use the computer programs. In addition, the software was to be installed on STUDENT=s home computer. STUDENT was to receive accommodations and strategies including assistance in the sequencing of first, next, last when being given projects and instructions; and teachers were to get his attention by using his name before speaking and state the topic to be discussed, show the finished product when requesting work to be completed, repeat main ideas and key concepts, and provide reinforcement for good listening. STUDENT was to receive preferential seating, short oral instructions and presentations, encouragement of Are-auditorization,@ modified assignments in general education, small-group instruction, and aide support in general education.
The District also developed a transition plan that included a visit to the school to meet the other students and teachers, and a peer buddy. STUDENT was to be shown the cafeteria process and the physical education area including the locker room. STUDENT also was to be introduced to office staff and the school counselor. STUDENT was to be permitted to participate in a social skills group two times per month to allow him to get to know other students.
The Student asserts that the District=s offer was not designed to meet his unique needs because the District failed to (1) develop goals in all areas of his unique needs; (2) offer him with occupational therapy, vision therapy, a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program; (3) offer an appropriate transition plan; (4) identify the frequency and duration of the proposed vision therapy, auditory processing therapy, and occupational therapy consultation offered; and (5) offer necessary classroom accommodations including additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text.
Goals and Objectives
The Student contends that the District failed to develop goals in the areas of speech and language, fine motor, OT, VT, assistive technology, auditory processing, sequential processing, reading memory, working memory, attention, phonemic awareness, social/emotional functioning, and reading fluency. The District contends that after the triennial review was conducted the IEP team revised the goals and objectives and that, as a whole, the goals and objectives were designed to meet STUDENT=s unique needs.
The October 25, 2004 IEP contains goals and objectives in the areas of reading/vocabulary development, reading comprehension, reading decoding, reading sight words- memory, written language, written language, spelling-memory, math, expressive/receptive language, articulation, and keyboarding.
Ms. Berkowitz testified that the expressive/receptive language goal prepared by the District does not address STUDENT=s language needs because the goal is more of a reading goal and not a language goal. According to Ms. Berkowitz, STUDENT=s language needs are in the area of semantics, which requires him to listen and reason. The goal, as written, requires STUDENT to listen to a story and retell/rephrase or explain the story with a clear beginning, middle, and end. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that the goals and objectives written addressed STUDENT=s speech and language needs, not only semantics and expressive language, but phonemic awareness and memory. The goals require STUDENT to use listening skills and to access his vocabulary in order to retell or rephrase the story; according to Ms. Hutchinson, phonemic awareness is required in the reading decoding goal. In addition, the articulation goal identifies STUDENT=s needs regarding /s/ and /z/ sounds. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the speech and language goals address STUDENT=s areas of speech and language needs.
The Hearing Officer also finds that STUDENT=s sequential processing, auditory processing, reading memory, working memory, phonemic awareness, and reading fluency needs were addressed by the goals and objectives. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that STUDENT=s memory needs were addressed by the expressive/receptive language goal. STUDENT=s memory needs were also addressed in the goals written for sight words and spelling. (Testimony of Ms. Wann.) Further, based upon the testimony of Ms. Wann concerning the development of goals to State standards set forth above and a review of the goals contained in the October 25, 2004 IEP, the Hearing Officer finds that the District addressed STUDENT=s needs in sequential processing, auditory processing by developing goals that addressed reading comprehension, reading development, and expressive/receptive language.
As to the Student=s contention that the District failed to develop goals and objectives for assistive technology, the Hearing Officer finds the Student=s position is without merit. The October 25, 2004 IEP contains an assistive technology goal to address STUDENT=s keyboarding skills. The remainder of the assistive technology services were to be provided through instruction on software programs to assist with achieving the goals in academic areas. There was no evidence that specific goals concerning the use of the software programs were needed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE in this regard.
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student=s contentions concerning the failure to develop fine motor goals and vision therapy goals is persuasive. It is undisputed that STUDENT had vision therapy needs and that he required services in this area. However, goals and objectives were not developed for vision therapy. (District=s Exhibit No.1.) Without goals and objectives, it would not have been possible for the IEP team or STUDENT=s parents to determine whether he had made progress in therapy or whether additional therapy was required. Likewise, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was in need of OT for posture and pencil grip. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT had needs in this area and offered consultation services. (District=s Exhibit No. 2.) However, like vision therapy, goals and objectives were not prepared to address STUDENT=s OT needs. Without goals and objectives it would not have been possible to determine what the OT was to accomplish during the consultation services and whether the consultation services were sufficient to address STUDENT=s OT needs. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop OT and vision therapy goals.
The Student also contends that the District failed to develop goals and objectives in the areas of social/emotional functioning and attention. As set forth above, the Hearing Officer found that STUDENT has needs in social/emotional functioning as it relates to a transitions to a new school based upon the results on his assessments and his anxiety and frustration behaviors exhibited in the new classroom at NewBridge. The District developed a transition plan to assist STUDENT with his social/emotional needs. The Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT=s social/emotional needs arise only in the context of a transition to a new school, his needs should have been addressed through a transition plan and that goals and objectives in this area were not required. The District developed a transition plan to meet STUDENT=s social/emotional needs and the adequacy of that transition plan will be discussed below.
Necessity of OT, Vision Therapy, One-to-One Aide for Speech Production, and Auditory Processing Program
The Student contends that the District did not offer him necessary OT, vision therapy, a one-to-one aide for speech production, and an auditory processing program. The District contends that it provided STUDENT with adequate supports and services to meet his unique needs.
The Hearing Officer finds Student=s contention concerning vision therapy to be without merit. The October 25, 2004 IEP clearly offers to provide STUDENT with fifteen sessions of vision therapy. The Hearing Officer also finds Student=s contention concerning OT without merit because the Hearing Officer found that his needs in this area were limited to posture and pencil grip. Ms. O=Brien credibly testified that STUDENT did not require direct OT services to address these deficits based upon her observation and testing of STUDENT. In addition, Ms. Wann testified that STUDENT was able to produce legible written work. Therefore, the thirty minutes of consultation per month would have adequately met STUDENT=s needs in this area.
The Hearing Officer also finds Student=s contention that he needed a one-to-one aide for speech production for the 2004-2005 school year is without merit. STUDENT=s speech and language needs were evaluated by both Ms. Hutchinson and Ms. Berkowitz. Neither of these assessors recommended that STUDENT be provided with a one-to-one aide for speech production.
Finally, concerning an auditory processing program, the Student relies on the testimony of Ms. Abramson to support his position that he required a computerized auditory processing program consisting of either Fast ForWord or BAT. The District relies on the testimony of Ms. Wohlgemuth to support its position that STUDENT did not require a computerized auditory processing program.
The Hearing Officer found above that due to the Abottom up@ auditory processing deficits identified by Ms. Abramson, STUDENT needs a direct intervention program. Ms. Abramson credibly testified that for a Abottom up@ auditory processing delay, STUDENT must receive a program that requires him to label and sequence sounds. Ms. Abramson also testified that this can only be accomplished through the use of a computer program. Although Ms. Wohlgemuth was called by the District to testify as an expert in this area, Ms. Wohlgemuth testified that Ms. Abramson was a qualified audiologist and she would respect Ms. Abramson=s opinion when determining the appropriate auditory processing intervention. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT should have been offered an auditory processing computer program such as BAT or Fast ForWord.
Placement
To meet STUDENT=s unique needs, the District offered him placement at San Elijo with RSP support. STUDENT would have been placed in Suzie Sherwin=s RSP class for homeroom, math, and language arts. STUDENT would have been in general education classes for art, physical education, and band. STUDENT would also have been in a general education class with aide support for earth science.
Ms. Sherwin testified that she has eighteen students in her language arts class and sixteen students in math. Ms. Sherwin has two aides who work with her the entire school day. Emily Tuten, the speech and language therapist at San Elijo, is a member of the IEP team and her office is next door to Ms. Sherwin. In addition, Ms. Tuten is in the classroom three to four times per day, two and a half days per week. Ms. Tuten and Ms. Sherwin collaborate on classroom instruction related to language issues. Ms. Sherwin has three Alpha Smarts and one computer. The computer has the following programs installed: Earobics (to address phonemic awareness), Read Naturally (reading fluency comprehension, reading speed, and vocabulary), and Inspiration and Kidspiration (visual organizers that assist in writing essays). In addition, Ms. Sherwin uses many graphic or visual organizers to assist the students with organization and memory. The students are taught the Cornell note taking method in history and science. (Testimony of Ms. Sherwin.) According to Ms. Sherwin, due to the number of students in the class, the students are able to use the computer once a week for twenty to thirty minutes.
The Student relies on the testimony of Dr. Perlman and Ms. Berkowitz in support of his contention. Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT=s needs far exceed what an RSP can provide. According to Dr. Perlman, the RSP at San Elijo is an incredible program and would be perfect for a regular education child who requires RSP support. Dr. Perlman=s criticism of the RSP class is that it is too large - at the time he observed there were twenty-two students in the class - and would have not provided enough structure and support for STUDENT. Dr. Perlman testified that STUDENT=s needs were too great to have been met in an RSP setting.
The Hearing Officer finds the Student=s position persuasive. Ms. Wann, STUDENT=s last SDC teacher, testified that STUDENT should have been placed in an SDC for the 2004-2005 school year and that he will not be ready for an RSP class until he has attained a fifth grade reading level. It is undisputed that as of the fall of 2004, STUDENT was reading at a late second to early third grade level. In addition, due to STUDENT=s auditory processing deficits he requires a small structured setting. (Testimony of Ms. Abramson and Dr. Perlman.) The placement at San Elijo does not meet this need. Not only does the RSP class consist of between sixteen to twenty-two students, but STUDENT would have been in general education art, band, and physical education with approximately thirty students or more. The District was attempting to provide a placement to meet STUDENT=s needs and the requests of the parents. However, STUDENT=s needs were too great to have been met in a general education setting with RSP support. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by not offering an educational placement designed to meet his unique needs. (Footnote 27)
Transition Plan
The District also offered STUDENT plan to transition him from his current placement at NewBridge to the San Elijo RSP. The transition plan developed by Ms. Sherwin offered by the District included a visit by STUDENT to San Elijo to meet the other students and teachers and the assignment of a peer buddy. STUDENT would have been shown the cafeteria process and the physical education situation including the locker room, would have been introduced to office staff and the school counselor, and would have participated in a social skills group two times per month to allow him to get to know his fellow students. Ms. Sherwin testified that the transition plan developed by the District would have met STUDENT=s needs. There is no evidence to the contrary. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT was offered with an appropriate transition plan.
Frequency and Duration of Services
The Student also contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE because the IEP failed to identify the frequency and duration of the proposed vision therapy, auditory processing therapy, and occupational therapy consultation offered. The face page of the October 25, 2004 IEP clearly identifies that STUDENT was to receive monthly OT consultation for thirty minutes and fifteen sessions of vision therapy. The Hearing Officer finds that the frequency and duration of the OT consultation was clearly stated. However, the IEP did not identify the duration of the vision therapy services. The proposed IEP did not include auditory processing therapy. Therefore, the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to indicate the frequency and duration of the auditory processing therapy; however STUDENT was denied a FAPE to the limited extent that the duration of the vision therapy services was not identified in the October 25, 2004 IEP.
Classroom Accommodations
The Student contends that he needs classroom accommodations and modifications consisting of additional time to complete work, memory strategies, a slant board, preferential seating, and near- and far-point copying of text based on the same reasons set forth for previous school years. The District asserts that it offered STUDENT appropriate accommodations and modifications for the reasons set forth in discussions set forth for previous school years. The October 25, 2004 IEP provides that STUDENT would have received accommodations consisting of sequencing of first, next, last; getting his attention by using his name before speaking; stating the topic to be discussed; showing finished product when requesting work to be completed; repeating main ideas and key concepts; providing reinforcement for good listening; providing him preferential seating; giving short oral instructions and presentations; encouraging Are-auditorization@; modifying assignments in general education classes, providing instruction in small groups; and providing aide support in general education. For the reasons identified in the analysis of previous school years, the Hearing Officer finds that the accommodations and modifications offered by the District were sufficient to meet STUDENT=s educational needs.
Comports with the IEP
The Student contends that the District has failed to provide OT and vision therapy since his placement at NewBridge by his parents and, therefore, the program has failed to comport with his IEP. However, STUDENT=s parents did not consent to the implementation of the October 25, 2004 IEP. The District was willing and able, and remains willing and able, to implement the October 25, 2004 IEP.
Provided in the LRE
The Hearing Officer has found that the District=s offer of placement at San Elijo would not provide him with a FAPE. Therefore, there is no reason for the Hearing Officer to consider whether the RSP at San Elijo was the LRE.
*************
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year by failing to develop goals and objectives in the areas of vision therapy and occupational therapy, by failing to offer an appropriate auditory processing program, and by failing to offer STUDENT an educational placement that would have met his unique needs for a small structured environment. The Hearing Officer also finds that the District did not offer STUDENT an educational program that was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit because the program offered did not meet his needs. STUDENT required a more restrictive environment and smaller class size.
Issue No. 6: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 ESY and for the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such Arelief as it determines is appropriate.@ AThe purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.@ Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F.Supp. 867 (D.Minn. 1996). Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir. 1991).
The Student seeks compensatory education in the form of Fast ForWord and academic instruction for denials of FAPE for the 2001 ESY to the 2003-2004 school year. The Hearing Officer found that the District did not deny STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 ESY or 2001-2002 school year. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education for those time periods.
The Hearing Officer found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2002-2003 school year to only to the limited extent that he was not offered and provided the services of a one-to-one aide for five to ten minutes each school day to work on speech production. The Hearing Officer also found that STUDENT was denied a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year from February 23, 2004, through the end of the school year only to the limited extent that the District failed to provide goals and objectives in the area of speech and language. The Hearing Officer must determine whether the compensatory education sought is the appropriate remedy for these denials of FAPE.
Ms. Hutchinson testified that during the 2003-2004 school year she worked with STUDENT on a weekly basis and addressed irregular past tense, articulation, auditory processing, and grammar. Ms. Hutchinson credibly testified that STUDENT made progress in speech and language during the 2003-2004 school year. He had a much more sophisticated use of language, his sentence structure was more mature, his receptive skills increased, and he was better at retelling stories indicating an improvement in expressive/receptive language and auditory processing. STUDENT=s articulation skills also improved. (Testimony of Ms. Hutchinson.) The IEPs for the 2002-2003 and 2003-2004 school years show that STUDENT made progress in the area of speech and language, including speech production. In addition, STUDENT would have only received the assistance of a one-to-one aide for fifteen minutes out of the school day. The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT did not receive a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2002-2003 school year and did not have speech and language goals and objectives for the 2003-2004 school year, he received speech and language services which addressed his areas of need and he made progress during both of these years. In addition, the Student did not request compensatory education in the area of speech and language, and Ms. Berkowitz did not testify that he needed compensatory education in the area of speech and language. Therefore, the compensatory education sought is not an appropriate remedy for this denial of FAPE.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the Student=s request for Fast ForWord and academics is not an appropriate remedy for the District=s failure to provide a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2002-2003 school year and the failure of the District to provide speech and language goals during the 2003-2004 school year from February 23, 2004, through the end of the school year. The one-to-one aide was to assist STUDENT with speech production and articulation. The requested compensatory education is not related to STUDENT=s articulation needs. In addition, STUDENT is currently receiving Fast ForWord as an embedded part of his program at NewBridge. The invoice produced at the hearing showed that there is not an extra charge for this service. Mr. Mayo testified that it is provided to students if it is determined they would benefit from the program. Mr. Mayo did not testify that STUDENT would require additional sessions in the Fast ForWord program beyond that provided at NewBridge. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT is not entitled to compensatory education in the form of Fast ForWord.
Issue No. 7: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, is he entitled to: a. Compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy, vision therapy, the Fast ForWord program, and academic instruction; b. Reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program and NewBridge, a nonpublic school from August 30, 2004, through the date of the Decision and reimbursement for transportation costs through the date of this Decision; c. Prospective placement at NewBridge for the remainder of the 2004- 2005 regular school year; and d. Round-trip transportation costs to NewBridge in Poway, California, for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
As set forth above, when a school district denies a FAPE to a child, that child is entitled to relief that is Aappropriate@ in light of the purposes of the IDEA. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. ' 1415(i). Thus, parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they have procured for their child when the school district failed to provide an appropriate placement and the placement provided by the parents was appropriate under the IDEA. Burlington, 471 U.S. at 370. The Burlington rule of reimbursement is not so narrow as to permit reimbursement only when the placement or services chosen by the parent are found to be the exact proper placement or services required under the IDEA. Alamo Heights Independent School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 790 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). However, the parents= placement still must meet certain basic requirements of the IDEA, such as the requirement that the placement addresses the child=s needs and provides him educational benefit. Florence County School Dist. Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7, 13-14 (1993). Reimbursement may be awarded even if the private school does not meet state certification requirements. Id. at 14.
The rationale behind Burlington=s holding is that parents who elect shoulder the risk shouldering of a private placement because they believe the IEP offer is inappropriate, and whose judgment is wholly or in part vindicated by the district court, should receive more than an Aempty victory.@ Id. As stated by the Court, if Aappropriate relief@ in the form of reasonable reimbursement is not allowed, Athe child=s right to a free appropriate public education, the parent=s right to participate fully in developing a proper IEP, and all of the procedural safeguards would be less than complete.@ Id. (footnote omitted).
Compensatory Education for Occupational Therapy, Vision Therapy, Fast ForWord, and Academic Instruction
The Hearing Officer has found that the District did not offer STUDENT appropriate OT services and vision therapy services as identified in the October 25, 2004 IEP because of the lack of goals and objectives in these areas. In his Closing Brief, the Student seeks reimbursement for the OT provided during his placement at NewBridge. However, the issue identified for hearing was not reimbursement, but was compensatory education. There is no dispute that STUDENT had OT and vision therapy needs as identified in the October 25, 2004 IEP. These needs have not been addressed and STUDENT continues to have needs in these areas. The District failed to offer STUDENT an appropriate program for the 2004-2005 school year and caused him to lose educational opportunity in the areas of OT and vision therapy. The October 25, 2004 IEP identified that STUDENT was to receive thirty minutes of OT consultation per month and fifteen sessions of vision therapy to meet his needs. Therefore, the District is ordered to provide the fifteen sessions of vision therapy as identified STUDENT=s October 25, 2004 IEP and four hours of OT consultation to remedy the denial of FAPE in these areas. Unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, the District begin to provide these compensatory education services immediately and by no later than thirty calendar days from the date of this Decision and shall provide all compensatory education services by September 1, 2005.
The Hearing Officer also found that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE by failing to offer him an auditory processing program. The Student claims in his Closing Brief that he is entitled to reimbursement for the Fast ForWord Program provided while he was attending NewBridge. However, this was not identified as an issue in these proceedings. In addition, there is no evidence that the Fast ForWord Program was provided to STUDENT at additional expense. As set forth above, Mr. Mayo testified that Fast ForWord is provided as an embedded part of the program at NewBridge if necessary. There was no testimony or evidence that an additional fee was incurred for STUDENT=s participation in Fast ForWord. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not order this as reimbursement. Further, for the same reasons discussed above in issue number six, STUDENT is not entitled to an award of Fast ForWord as compensatory education.
The Student failed to produce evidence as to what compensatory education would be appropriate in terms of academic instruction. Further, in his Closing Brief, the Student did not identify what academic instruction is being sought. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the Student is not entitled to compensatory education for academic instruction. (Footnote 28)
Reimbursement for the Phono-Genix Program and NewBridge from August 30, 2004, Through the Date of the Decision
The Hearing Officer finds that the Student is not entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program. There must be a nexus between the remedy sought and the denial of FAPE. The Phono-Genix program was provided to STUDENT in the Spring of 2004 and is a reading program. The denial of FAPE addressed in this issue is for the 2004-2005 school year. (Student=s Exhibit page 639.) Thus, the Phono-Genix program was procured prior to the District=s denial of FAPE and there is no nexus between the denial of FAPE and the reimbursement sought. Therefore, STUDENT is not entitled to reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program.
In order to determine whether STUDENT is entitled to reimbursement for placement at NewBridge, the Hearing Officer must first determine whether NewBridge met certain basic requirements of the IDEA and calculated to provided STUDENT with educational benefit. It is undisputed that STUDENT has benefitted from his placement at NewBridge.
Steve Mayo, the director of NewBridge, testified that fifty-four students currently attend NewBridge; the maximum capacity for NewBridge is fifty-six. The NewBridge campus consists of three buildings (one main building and two portables) that are connected by a picnic area and a deck. Mr. Mayo testified that all classrooms are multi-grade and currently, there are two middle school groups: sixth through seventh, and seventh through eighth. Each class has a maximum of eight students. Mr. Mayo testified that the goal of NewBridge is to assist children in attaining the skills necessary to transition back into more traditional educational programs. Currently, STUDENT is placed in a slower paced middle school group to make sure he develops strategies that he can use independently. (Testimony of Mayo.) STUDENT=s group is in the portables and he rotates between three of the four classes in those buildings.
According to Mr. Mayo, NewBridge provides a curriculum-based program based on State standards and most of the goals written are aligned to State standards. Mr. Mayo also testified that all teachers have a special education credential, except for one, and are working toward their master=s degree. There is a full-time speech and language therapist and a full-time occupational therapist on staff. NewBridge works primarily with children with language based disabilities. At NewBridge, instructions and presentations are broken down into small segments to address auditory processing deficits. In addition, students are given visual cues with auditory instructions. Mr. Mayo described NewBridge as providing a strategy-based program, which he defined as teaching students how to process and retain information in a number of different ways so that students will be successful in the classroom and can transfer to a new placement.
STUDENT attends homeroom, phonics, reading, science, writing, social studies, math, physical education, tutorial, and homework club. STUDENT also receives Fast ForWord as part of his educational program to address his auditory processing needs. STUDENT is also receiving assistive technology, Brain Gym (to addresses fidgeting in the classroom), OT as part of the curriculum, and embedded speech and language services. According to Mr. Mayo, STUDENT is provided with a number of accommodations including smaller work samples (do odds or evens); longer response times; significant visual cues; overhead sheets projected on a screen; Gestalt instruction (top down); closed procedure activities (provide with structure and he fills in the pieces); carefully controlled presentations (i.e., too many examples are far more detrimental than helpful); frequent check ins with the teacher (asks if doing this right, etc.); frequent checks to make sure he is on track and applying appropriate strategies; strategy sheets, multiplication sheets, and steps of division; repetition; constant review and reinforcement; a word wall that lists key vocabulary, phonemes, and consonant blends in the classroom; a flip chart of all the spelling rules; fidgets (for attention); and a slant board, and pencil grips or mechanical pencils. STUDENT also received modifications such as changes to the curriculum in math and reading. Sabrina MacFarlane, STUDENT=s math and science teacher, Melissa Sisto, STUDENT=s phonics and writing teacher, and Cynthia Haddow, STUDENT=s spelling and social studies teacher, all testified that STUDENT=s goals and objectives could be, and are being, implemented at NewBridge. In addition, according to Mr. Mayo and STUDENT=s teachers at NewBridge, he is doing quite well in his placement.
Dr. Perlman observed STUDENT at NewBridge and testified that it is a wonderful program for STUDENT and meets all of his needs by providing him with an intimate setting, clear expectations, accommodations to help him sustain attention, and assistive technology. Dr. Perlman also testified that STUDENT does not feel singled out or different at NewBridge. There is no evidence to the contrary. In addition, there is no dispute that STUDENT has made progress while at NewBridge. Based upon the foregoing, the Hearing Officer finds that NewBridge is meeting STUDENT=s educational needs.
Thus, because the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year and because NewBridge is meeting basic IDEA requirements and providing him with educational benefit, STUDENT=s parents are entitled to reimbursement for fees incurred to place STUDENT at NewBridge for the 2004-2005 school year from August 30, 2004, through the date of this Decision. Mr. Mayo testified that tuition for NewBridge is $3,500.00 per quarter. Therefore, the District shall reimburse STUDENT=s parents for tuition costs in the amount of $3,500.00 per quarter from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through the date of this Decision, within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof. (Footnote 29)
Prospective Placement
The Student is also seeking prospective placement at NewBridge for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year. The Hearing Officer finds that prospective placement through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year is appropriate. There are less than two months remaining in the regular school year, and at this point it likely would be detrimental to STUDENT=s ability to benefit from his education to change schools so late in the year. As noted previously, STUDENT has social/emotional needs related to his ability to transition to a new educational setting. Therefore, he needs time and a transition plan to meet those needs. Dr. Perlman testified that to be successful, STUDENT needs to take tools that he has learned at NewBridge to the new placement, and additional time is needed to ingrain strategies so that STUDENT will be able to use these strategies in a different educational setting. Dr. Perlman also credibly testified that for a successful transition, additional time would be necessary to allow the staff at NewBridge to confer with the staff at the receiving school to reinforce accommodations. Dr. Perlman also suggested an overlap in placements as well as the assignment of a peer buddy for STUDENT. It does not seem reasonable that a successful transition could be accomplished in less than two months in light of the fact that currently there is no proposed IEP that would provide STUDENT with a FAPE. Therefore, due to the limited time remaining in the school year and the need for a transition plan, the Hearing Officer finds that prospective placement at NewBridge through the end of the 2004-2005 regular school year is necessary and appropriate. Therefore, the District shall fund STUDENT=s placement at NewBridge for the remainder of NewBridge=s 2004-2005 regular school year.
Transportation
Transportation is a related service which must be provided if necessary for a child to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. ' 1401(22). ATransportation@ may include travel to and from school and specialized equipment (such as special or adapted buses, lifts, and ramps), if such equipment is required to provide special transportation for a child with a disability. 34 C.F.R. ' 300.24(b)(15). The appropriate mode of transportation will depend on the student=s unique needs. See 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, Attachment 1, ' 300.24. STUDENT=s parents seek reimbursement for costs incurred to transport him from San Marcos to Poway each school day so that he could attend NewBridge. Because the District has not offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year and the Hearing Officer has found that NewBridge is substantially appropriate, STUDENT needs transportation to and from NewBridge. MOTHER testified that she has provided transportation for STUDENT to NewBridge, which is located approximately twenty miles from the family home. Therefore, the District shall reimburse STUDENT=s parents for their actual round-trip mileage for each day STUDENT has attended NewBridge from August 30, 2004, until the date of this Decision at the District mileage reimbursement rate. The District shall also reimburse STUDENT=s parents for transportation costs from the date of the Decision until the end of NewBridge=s 2004-2005 regular school year at the District mileage rate.
ORDER
1. Unless the parties agree in writing otherwise, the District shall provide STUDENT with fifteen hours of vision therapy and four hours of occupational therapy consult as compensatory education. The District shall begin to provide these compensatory education services immediately and by no later than thirty calendar days from the date of this Decision and shall provide all compensatory education services by September 1, 2005.
2. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse the parents for the enrollment fee and tuition for NewBridge from the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year through the date of this Decision.
3. The District shall fund STUDENT=s placement at NewBridge from the date of this Decision through the end of NewBridge=s 2004-2005 regular school year.
4. Within twenty calendar days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse STUDENT=s parents at the District=s mileage rate for transportation costs incurred from the beginning of NewBridge=s 2004-2005 regular school year until the end of NewBridge=s 2004-2005 school year, for actual round trip mileage for days STUDENT attends NewBridge. With regard to transportation costs incurred during the remainder of the 2004-2005 school year, the District shall reimburse the parents on at least a monthly basis.
5. All of the Student=s remaining requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with the statute:
Issue No. 1: During the 2001 ESY from July 19, 2001, through July 31, 2001, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE)?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 2: During the 2001-2002 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 3: During the 2002-2003 school year, did the District fail to: 5. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and
6. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
The Student prevailed on this issue only to the limited extent that the District failed to offer and provide him a one-to-one aide for speech production during the 2002-2003 school year. The District prevailed on all remaining contentions.
Issue No. 4: During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer and provide STUDENT with a FAPE?
The Student prevailed on this issue only to the limited extent that the District failed to include speech and language goals and objectives from February 23, 2004, through the end of the school year. The District prevailed on all remaining contentions.
Issue No. 5: During the 2004-2005 school year, did the District fail to: A. Assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability and B. Offer STUDENT with a FAPE?
The District prevailed on this issue as it relates to assessing STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. The Student prevailed on all remaining contentions.
Issue No. 6: If the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 ESY and for the 2001-2002, 2002-2003, and 2003-2004 school years, is he entitled to compensatory education?
The District prevailed on this issue.
Issue No. 7: If the District failed to offer STUDENT a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year, is he entitled to: a. Compensatory education in the form of occupational therapy, vision therapy, the Fast ForWord program, and academic instruction; b. Reimbursement for the Phono-Genix program and NewBridge, a nonpublic school from August 30, 2004, through the date of the Decision and reimbursement for transportation costs through the date of this Decision; c. Prospective placement at NewBridge for the remainder of the 2004- 2005 regular school year; and d. Round-trip transportation costs to NewBridge in Poway, California, for the remainder of the 2004-2005 regular school year?
The District prevailed on this issue with respect to the Phono-Genix program, Fast ForWord, and academic instruction. The Student prevailed on all remaining remedies sought.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505(i).
Date: April 27, 2005 _________________________________ Christian M. Knox, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
The District filed a request for due process hearing on August 25, 2004, seeking a decision on whether it offered STUDENT a FAPE for the 2001 extended school year (ESY) and 2001-2002, 2002-2003, 2003-2004, and 2004-2005 school years. These issues had also been identified by the Student in his request for due processing hearing on July 19, 2004. The matters were consolidated for hearing.
2 At all times referred to herein, Carrillo Elementary School was on a track system and was off track for the months of November, March, and July of each school year. 3 A Abottom-top@ auditory processing delay is related to whether the brain is receiving the auditory signal in its integrity from the bottom (ear) up to the top (brain) as it relates to intensity, pitch, and timing. (Testimony of Maria Abramson, audiologist). A Abottom-top@ processing delay can adversely affect receptive language, phonemic awareness, reading, and spelling skills. 4 Ms. Hutchinson has approximately twenty years of experience as a speech and language therapist and has assessed and provided services to over two thousand students. Ms. Hutchinson is fully licensed as a speech and language pathologist and has received specific oral-motor training through the California Speech-Language-Hearing Association and the North Coastal Consortium for Special Education. Ms. Hutchinson=s training includes oral motor training from Dr. Broussard whom, Ms. Hutchinson testified, is considered the Aguru@ of oral motor assessments. 5 In the Student=s Closing Brief, he also asserts that the District committed a procedural violation as defined by Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994). The Student did not allege a Union violation for the 2001-2002 school year prior to the closing brief and, thus, the District did not have an opportunity to respond to the allegation. A party to a due process hearing is required to identify the issues to be decided at least ten days prior to the hearing. Cal. Educ. Code ' 56505. The Student did not previously identify this as an issue. If the Hearing Officer considered the Student=s contention at this date it would violate the District=s right to prior notice of the issues of hearing and an opportunity to respond. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider this contention. 6 The Student initially asserted that the District also failed to have a speech and language therapist present during the February 13, 2002 IEP meeting. However, this issue was withdrawn in the Student=s Closing Brief. 7 In the Student=s Closing Brief, he again asserts that the District committed a procedural violation as defined by Union School District v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994). The Student did not allege a Union violation for the 2001-2002 school year prior to the closing brief and thus, the District has not had an opportunity to respond to the allegation. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider this contention. 8 Ms. O=Brien is a registered and licensed occupational therapist and has worked for the District for approximately six years. Ms. O=Brien has her certification in sensory integration and has received extensive training in the area of occupational therapy. Ms. O=Brien has also been a presenter at several school districts, special education local planning areas, and symposiums. 9 The Student had originally raised contentions relating to the failure to assess in the area of OT and the necessity of compensatory education in the form of OT, but withdrew these contentions during the course of the hearing. 10 Neither Ms. Parker nor the instructional aide were called to testify. 11 Although it is not relevant to a determination of whether STUDENT was provided a FAPE during the 2001-2002 school year, it is important to note that the District and Dr. Perlman agree that STUDENT made Ameaningful@ progress during this school year in his academic development. 12 In the Student=s Closing Brief, he asserts for the first time that the District also did not have a speech pathologist present at the February 11, 2003 IEP meeting. However, not only was this issue not raised prior to the closing brief, but the IEP indicates that speech pathologist Bobbi Marcel provided a written report to the parents and encouraged the parents to telephone her with any questions. MOTHER testified that she did call Ms. Marcel and that all of her questions were answered. Ms. Marcel reviewed the IEP document after the meeting and signed in agreement. (Testimony of Ms. Hutchinson.) 13 Although not determinative of whether STUDENT=s educational program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, the Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT met all of his goals and objectives for the year and made academic progress. 14 In his Closing Brief, the Student also alleges for the first time that a placement change was made without an IEP meeting, and that appropriate accommodations were not provided by the general educational science teacher and as a result he was removed from the general education science classroom without an IEP meeting. The Student also asserts that he should have but was not provided with an aide in the general education classroom. None of these contentions were raised as issues during the issue clarification or subsequent review of the Memorandum of Issues to be Decided. Therefore, they will not be addressed in this Decision. 15 The February 4, 2004 goal will be addressed substantively below. 16 The District did not address the lack of speech and language goals in the February 23, 2004 IEP in its closing brief. 17 Again, although not determinative of whether STUDENT=s educational program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, the Hearing Officer notes that Dr. Perlman and Ms. Wann both testified that STUDENT made two and a half years progress over the past two and a half years. Further, STUDENT=s scores on the Woodcock Johnson administered in June 2004, showed an increase in scores over those obtained in January 2002. 18 The IEP team considered the document prepared at the June 21, 2004 meeting an addendum. The IEP team made a recommendation for placement and retained the goals and objectives from the February 23, 2004 IEP. However, because the IEP team met to consider placement for middle school, the Hearing Officer will refer to this as an IEP, not an addendum. 19 The Hearing Officer also notes that the parent did not consent to the IEP and that STUDENT retained counsel less than thirty days after the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting. 20 The parties could not find a mutually convenient date for an IEP meeting to occur prior to the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year. 21 The IEP team had discussed conducting an early triennial assessment of STUDENT at the June 21, 2004 IEP meeting. After receipt of the July 18, 2004 dissent, the District drafted an evaluation plan for MOTHER=s review. MOTHER consented to the early triennial evaluation on July 28, 2004. 22 The parties did not challenge the timeliness of the assessments. 23 California Education Code section 56383 requires the involvement of a nonpublic school in the review of a child=s IEP after a child has been placed in a nonpublic school by a local education agency. However, in this case, STUDENT was unilaterally placed at NewBridge by his parents. Therefore, this section is not applicable to this analysis. 24 In his Closing Brief, the Student asserts for the first time that the District prematurely held IEP meetings on August 18, and September 28, 2004. This was not the issue identified for hearing during issue clarification or discussions concerning the Memorandum of Issues to be Decided. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not address this contention. 25 There was no evidence produced that MOTHER spoke with either Dr. Skay or Ms. Abramson. 26 Dr. Perlman also testified that STUDENT had deficits in the area of social/emotional functioning, attention, and find motor skills. These area will be discussed later in the Decision. 27 Because the District=s offer for placement for the 2004-2005 school year was the RSP at San Elijo, the Hearing Officer will not address the appropriateness of the SDC at Woodland Park. 28 Further, as will be seen shortly, STUDENT=s parents will be reimbursed for the NewBridge placement, which has been addressing STUDENT=s academic needs for the 2004-2005 school year. 29 STUDENT also attends Homework Club at a cost of $100.00 per month. Mr. Mayo testified that this is an optional program. The Student did not identify reimbursement for Homework Club as an issue to be decided by the Hearing Officer during the Hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer has not determined whether STUDENT needs Homework Club and whether his parents are entitled to reimbursement for this service.
