California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · March 17, 2005
Student v. Newport-Mesa Unified School District (consolidated)
SEHO Case No. SN 2186-04, SN04-02186, SN04-02814 · Hearing Officer My T. Huynh
Newport-Mesa Unified must hold an IEP meeting; reimbursement for a Utah residential placement denied despite two FAPE violations.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Newport-Mesa Unified School District filed first, asking the Hearing Officer to confirm that it had properly assessed a ninth grader and offered him a FAPE in 2003-2004. The student then filed against the district and the Orange County Health Care Agency (OCHCA), and the cases were consolidated. The student, now 16, was found eligible in March 2004 as emotionally disturbed because depression affected his attendance and his ability to finish work. In August 2004 his parents placed him at Liahona Academy, a residential program in Utah, at their own expense.
The Hearing Officer found the district had no duty to assess him earlier, because staff did not learn of his depression until a January 2004 student study team meeting. The district sent its mental health referral three working days late, but the delay caused no harm. The March 2004 IEP's present levels and goals were adequate. However, that IEP denied FAPE because it offered no counseling, even though the parents said they preferred their private therapist. The May 2004 IEP added OCHCA therapy and was appropriate. Residential placement was not needed then. The district also denied FAPE by failing to hold an IEP meeting by October 2004, after OCHCA asked for one. Scheduling problems with the family did not excuse this. Residential placement was never shown to be necessary, and Liahona is not state-certified, so reimbursement and future placement there were denied. The district must hold an IEP meeting within 30 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO kept findings of FAPE violations separate from the remedy. Failing to offer counseling and failing to hold an IEP meeting were violations. Still, the parents got no reimbursement for a residential placement that was never shown to be necessary. The decision also held that a district must offer needed services even when parents say they prefer private ones.
Issues and holdings
- District prevailedChild find
Issue 1. From February 2003 until the assessment completed in March 2004, did the District fail in its child find duties by not assessing Student for special education eligibility?
Poor grades and illness-excused absences did not trigger a duty to assess, and the District did not know of the depression diagnosis until the January 23, 2004 student study team meeting.
- District prevailedAssessment
Issue 2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District err by failing to provide Student a preliminary referral to the OCHCA for mental health services at the January 2004 student study team meeting?
No preliminary referral was required because assessment had only just begun and no one requested one; the Hearing Officer gave the opinion of Student's expert little weight.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 3a. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in its March 2004 IEP by failing to include a nurse at the IEP meeting?
The law does not require a nurse, and the school psychologist who supervised the assessment, including the health screening, attended.
- Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure
Issue 3b. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in its March 2004 IEP by failing to provide a mental health referral packet to the OCHCA within five days of the IEP meeting?
The referral packet was sent three working days late, but the delay caused no loss of educational opportunity or parent participation.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3c. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in its March 2004 IEP by failing to include appropriate present levels of performance?
Read as a whole, the IEP contained quantified baselines (for example, 30% attendance and 10% organization) in the annual goals and benchmarks.
- District prevailedIEP content
Issue 3d. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in its March 2004 IEP by failing to tie the IEP goals to the present levels of performance?
The goals and benchmarks for attendance, work completion and organization were directly tied to the present levels.
- Student prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 3e. Did the District deny Student a FAPE in its March 2004 IEP by failing to offer counseling services?
Counseling was an undisputed need; the District had to offer it even though the parents said they preferred their private therapist.
- District prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 4a. Did the District and OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in the May 2004 IEP by failing to include a psychiatrist or Ph.D. psychologist at the IEP meeting?
No law requires such a participant, and no party invited the treating psychiatrist or therapist.
- District prevailedFAPE: services offered
Issue 4b. Did the District and OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in the May 2004 IEP by failing to offer sufficient levels of mental health services?
Two 30-minute individual sessions and one 30-minute collateral session per month were appropriate given Student's reported improvement; the OCHCA clinician was credible.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 4c. Did the District and OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in the May 2004 IEP by failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration?
No one requested residential placement, Student was improving, and the treating psychiatrist testified that residential placement was not needed before July or August 2004.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 5a. During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to conduct an expanded IEP meeting?
After learning of the unilateral placement and receiving OCHCA's request, the District had to hold an IEP meeting by October 2004, even without parent cooperation; failing to do so denied FAPE.
- District prevailedResidential placement for mental health
Issue 5b. During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration?
The District was on summer recess, and the parent did not share key information about Student's decline before placing him, so the District had no duty to refer.
- District prevailedTransition
Issue 5c. During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE by failing to offer a transition plan to return Student from his current residential placement to a District program?
Neither side offered evidence, and the parents never asked to have Student return to the District, so a transition plan was not a current need.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6a. Is Student entitled to reimbursement to Student's parents for Student's privately placed residential placement program?
Reimbursement was denied because residential placement was never shown to be necessary and was not a remedy tied to the two violations found.
- District prevailedUnilateral placement and reimbursement
Issue 6b. Is Student entitled to prospective placement at Student's current residential placement program?
Education Code section 56505.2 bars prospective placement at a noncertified private school, and Liahona is not certified.
- Student prevailedIEP procedure
Issue 6c. Is Student entitled to an IEP meeting to discuss how Student can make up lost units towards graduation?
The District was ordered to convene an IEP meeting to address Student's current needs, including how he may make up high school credits.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District to convene an IEP meeting within 30 days of the decision to discuss Student's current needs and develop a program to meet them; per the decision's analysis, the team is also to discuss how Student may make up high school credits.
- Reimbursement for the Liahona Academy residential placement and prospective placement there were denied; all other requests for relief were denied.
Key authorities
Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Adams v. Oregon; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; School Committee of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. of Educ.; Alamo Heights Ind. School Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ.
People named in the decision
- Patrick Ryan, director of special education, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Manuel Robles, AB 3632 coordinator, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Nancy Ferda, general education English teacher, Estancia High School
- Candy Barela, special education coordinator, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Gail Longfellow, resource specialist program teacher, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Michelle Geracitano, school counselor, Estancia High School
- Sean Boulton, assistant principal, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Meghan Hanna, school counselor (witness called by the Hearing Officer), Tewinkle Middle School
- Charlotte Smith, school psychologist, Newport-Mesa Unified School District
- Clay AhQuin, program director, residential placement, Liahona Academy
- Joseph AhQuin, service provider (proposed telephonic witness), Liahona Academy
- Edgar Collins, service provider (proposed telephonic witness), Liahona Academy
- T. Brent Price, therapist, Liahona Academy
- Christine Davidson, licensed educational psychologist, expert witness for Student, private practice
- Emily Johnson, treating psychiatrist, witness for Student, private practice
- Samuel Dambrucia, private therapist, private practice
- Carlita Hughes-Darby, licensed clinical social worker and case manager, Orange County Health Care Agency
- Victor Cota, service chief, Orange County Health Care Agency
- An Le, psychologist, Orange County Health Care Agency
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter was heard before My T. Huynh, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Costa Mesa, California, on January 18-21 and 25-28, 2005. (Footnote 1)
Petitioner and Cross-Respondent Newport-Mesa Unified School District (District) was represented at the hearing by attorney Vivian Billups. Also present on the District’s behalf was Patrick Ryan, director of special education. Respondent and Cross-Petitioner (Student) was represented by attorney Michael Jewell. Also present on Student’s behalf were his mother and father. Cross-Respondent Orange County Health Care Agency (OCHCA) was represented by attorney Carolyn Frost. Also present on OCHCA’s behalf was Manuel Robles, AB3632 coordinator.
The District called the following witnesses: Nancy Ferda, English teacher; Candy Barela, special education coordinator; Gail Longfellow, resource specialist program teacher; Michelle Geracitano, school counselor; and Sean Boulton, assistant principal.
Student called the following witnesses: mother; Clay AhQuin, Liahona Academy program director; Christine Davidson, educational psychologist; Father; Emily Johnson, psychiatrist; and T. Brent Price, therapist.
OCHCA called the following witnesses: Carlita Hughes-Darby, licensed clinical social worker, and Victor Cota, service chief. In addition, the Hearing Officer called Meghan Hanna, school counselor.
Oral and documentary evidence was received. The record was closed upon the completion of closing arguments on January 28, 2005, and the matter was submitted for decision.
PROCEDURAL MATTERS
On August 31, 2004, the Hearing Office received the District’s request for a due process hearing naming Student as respondent. The District requested a hearing for a determination that it appropriately assessed and offered Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) during the 2003-2004 school year. The District also sought a determination that Student’s parents were not entitled to reimbursement or other remedies for their placement of Student at an out-of-state residential facility. The matter was assigned case number SN04-02186.
On November 23, 2004, the Hearing Office received Student’s request for a due process hearing naming the District and OCHCA as respondents. Student alleged that the District and the OCHCA failed to offer him a FAPE from the 2001-2002 school year to the present. Student also raised claims that the District and the OCHCA failed to conduct appropriate assessments for the same period. Student claimed that these failures warrant a finding that he is entitled to remedies including compensatory education, reimbursement for independent educational evaluations and privately obtained educational services. This matter was assigned case number SN04-02814. Student also requested that his and the District’s matter be consolidated. The District and the OCHCA did not oppose the motion. The Hearing Office granted the request for consolidation and the matters were jointly set for hearing.
On the first day of hearing, the Hearing Officer reviewed with the parties their issues. The District raised issues that it appropriately assessed and offered Student a FAPE during the 2003-2004 school year. Accordingly, the District asserted that Student was not entitled to any requested remedies. Correspondingly, the OCHCA raised issues that it properly assessed Student and offered appropriate mental health services during the same period. It also claimed that Student was not entitled to any requested remedies.
The Hearing Officer also reviewed Student’s issues. Student alleged specific claims that the District failed to identify and assess him from February 2002 through March 2004. In addition, Student contended that the District failed to offer a FAPE substantively and procedurally from March 2004 to the present. Further, Student claimed that the OCHCA failed to appropriately offer services to him. As remedies, Student requested (1) reimbursement for residential placement, (2) prospective placement, and (3) compensatory education. Because of the overlap between the parties’ respective issues, the Hearing Officer merged the issues to consider only those matters that were in dispute by the parties; these issues are reflected below. This consolidation of issues culminated in a list of Student’s issues, which subsumed the District’s and the OCHCA’s respective claims.
Telephonic Testimony
Student moved to allow telephonic testimony of four witnesses: Clay AhQuin, Joseph AhQuin, T. Brent Price and Edgar Collins. Student asserted that these witnesses are service providers for Student at his current placement at Liahona Academy in Utah and would provide relevant information regarding Student’s educational needs and progress at his current placement. Student’s attorney offered declarations from the witnesses that to give in-person testimony at the hearing would cause great hardship to each witness given the distance and time necessary to travel to and attend the hearing.
Both the District and the OCHCA objected to the request for telephonic testimony. They argued that these witnesses were not timely disclosed five business days prior to the hearing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(7). Further, they asserted that telephonic testimony would deny them the opportunity to confront and cross-examine the witnesses and evaluate demeanor that would affect the witnesses’ respective credibility. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(e)(3).
Under California law, the hearing officer may conduct all or part of a hearing by telephone or other electronic means if each participant in the hearing has an opportunity to participate in and to hear the entire proceeding while it is taking place and to observe exhibits. Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3082(g). The Hearing Officer determined that the testimony of the four potential witnesses was relevant to the proceeding because such testimony would offer evidence of the appropriateness of Student’s current placement for purposes of determining potential remedies. The Hearing Officer also found that it would be an undue hardship to compel their personal attendance in California. To allow proper notification and ensure sufficient time for the District and the OCHCA to prepare for these witnesses, the Hearing Officer ordered Student to arrange for the witnesses’ testimonies to occur five business days later. Further, the Hearing Officer required Student to make all exhibits available to the witnesses for review during their questioning. Given these safeguards, the Hearing Officer granted Student’s motion for telephonic testimony of its out-of-state witnesses.
Testimony of Student
The District moved to compel the in-person testimony of Student. The District asserted that Student would provide relevant information regarding his past and current state of mind and educational needs. The District noted that it named Student as a potential witness on its witness list and made a request to Student’s attorney prior to the hearing to make him available for testimony. The OCHCA joined the motion.
Student’s attorney opposed the motion. Student’s attorney asserted that Student has been determined eligible for special education as emotionally disturbed. Currently, Student is attending Liahona Academy in Utah and being treated for his depression. Student’s attorney argued that his current emotional state makes him incompetent to testify. According to Student’s attorney, his fragile psyche would be harmed if he were to be compelled to travel to California and undergo difficult cross-examination during a hearing. Further, Student’s attorney contended that the travel to California would interrupt his educational program and would set Student back in his emotional and academic progress.
The Hearing Officer denied the motion to compel Student’s in-person testimony. Initially, the Hearing Officer considered the parties’ arguments as to whether Student was competent to give testimony. The Hearing Officer did not reach a determination as to Student’s competence because the Hearing Office does not have the legal authority to compel the attendance of an out-of-state person. Although the Hearing Office may issue subpoenas to compel attendance of witnesses, this authority does not extend beyond the geographical boundaries of California. Cal. Code of Reg. tit. 5, § 3082(c)(2). (Footnote 2) Without this authority, the Hearing Officer could not compel Student’s attendance and the motion was denied.
ISSUES (Footnote 3)
1. From February 2003 until the assessment completed in March 2004, did the District fail in its child find duties by not assessing Student for special education eligibility?
2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District err by failing to provide Student a preliminary referral to the OCHCA for mental health services at the January 2004 student study team meeting?
3. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) in its March 2004 Individualized Education Program (IEP) by:
a. Failing to include a nurse at the IEP meeting;
b. Failing to provide a mental health referral packet to the OCHCA within five days of the IEP meeting; c. Failing to include appropriate present levels of performance; d. Failing to tie the IEP goals to the present levels of performance; and e. Failing to offer counseling services.
4. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District and OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in its May 2004 IEP by:
a. Failing to include a psychiatrist or Ph.D. psychologist at the IEP meeting; b. Failing to offer sufficient levels of mental health services; and c. Failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration?
5. During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE by:
a. Failing to conduct an expanded IEP meeting;
b. Failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration; and c. Failing to offer a transition plan to return Student from his current residential placement to a District program?
6. If the District and the OCHCA denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to the following remedies:
a. Reimbursement to Student’s parents for Student’s privately placed residential placement program; b. Prospective placement at Student’s current residential placement program; and c. An IEP meeting to discuss how Student can make up lost units towards graduation?
BACKGROUND FACTS
Student is a sixteen-year-old boy who currently resides in St. George, Utah, and attends the Liahona Academy (Liahona). Student is currently eligible for special education and related services as an emotionally disturbed (ED) student. Liahona is a noncertified, nonpublic school that includes a residential placement facility that services students suffering from a variety of problems, including mental illness, and requiring around-the-clock supervision. (Testimony of Clay AhQuin.) Student’s parents, MOTHER and FATHER, reside within the jurisdictional boundaries of the District. (Footnote 4) Student has been attending Liahona since August 2004, at his parents’ expense.
Student attended Maranatha Christian Academy, a private school, for his elementary years and was considered a good student and received primarily A and B grades. (Testimony of Mother.) He was energetic and participated in several sports leagues. In addition, he had normal sleep habits and no behavioral difficulties.
In the seventh grade, STUDENT began attending Calvary Chapel, another private school. According to Mother, Student began having difficulty with sleeping by the seventh grade. Student also began showing changes in his motivation towards school and extracurricular activities. By his eight-grade year at Calvary Chapel, Student’s attendance began to become a problem and his schoolwork suffered. Student’s Calvary Chapel grade reports indicated that he was missing assignments and working below ability. (Stu. Ex. 17.)
Because Student had many close friends in his neighborhood, his parents considered transferring him to the local public school. Following a discussion with Tewinkle Middle School (Tewinkle) school counselor Meghan Hanna, Student’s parents enrolled him in the District. In February 2003, Student began attending Tewinkle, at the start of the spring semester. During that semester, Student continued to demonstrate attendance problems and failed to turn in assignments. Mother also saw that Student developed difficulty falling asleep. Concerned about his school performance, Mother contacted Ms. Hanna to schedule a meeting with Student’s teachers. At the meeting, Ms. Hanna, Mother, and Student’s teachers discussed Student’s class work and his low grades. Ms. Hanna attributed the adjustment to a new school and transferring during the middle of the school year as reasons for Student’s difficulties.
Student attended ninth grade at Estancia High School (Estancia), a District comprehensive school, during the 2003-2004 school year. From September 16, 2003, through December 17, 2003, Student missed approximately fourteen days of school due to illness. (Dist. Ex. 36.) During the autumn months, Student suffered from bronchitis and ear infections, requiring him to stay home. In addition, Student’s inability to fall asleep increased, causing him to miss school. Because of these problems, Student’s parents provided illness notes to Estancia’s attendance office requesting that his absences be excused.
In October 2003, Mother continued to be concerned about Student’s poor grades and contacted school counselor Michelle Geracitano. In response, Ms. Geracitano contacted Student’s teachers and requested that they utilize a weekly progress report for him. Once a week, Student would be required to take a form to all his classes and have the teachers indicate his progress and attitude. This report would be brought home to his parents for review. Further, Ms. Geracitano scheduled a meeting on October 28, 2003, with Student’s teachers and Mother. At the meeting, the participants discussed Student’s attendance and low grades. On November 7, 2003, Ms. Geracitano contacted Mother to confirm whether Student was bringing home his progress reports and learned that he had not been returning the reports. (Dist. Ex. 7.) Ms. Geracitano recommended that Mother create consequences for Student should he fail to bring home the reports.
In November 2003, Student complained to his parents that “something was going on in his head.” Out of concern, Student’s parents consulted Dr. Samuel Dambrucia, a therapist, to assist Student. Dr. Dambrucia diagnosed Student with depression and provided weekly therapy sessions for Student through early December. Dr. Dambrucia also referred Student to Dr. Emily Johnson, a psychiatrist. In December 2003, Dr. Johnson began prescribing antidepressant medications for Student.
By early December 2003, Student was not attending school regularly. On December 10, 2003, Mother contacted Ms. Geracitano requesting her assistance in collecting assignments from Student’s teachers. Mother also informed Ms. Geracitano that Student was having “psychological difficulties.” (Dist. Ex. 8.) Ms. Geracitano requested that Student’s teachers send assignments to Mother and passed along to his teachers the information that Student was having “psychological difficulties.”
On January 20, 2004, Mother requested additional assistance from Ms. Geracitano to help with Student’s declining grades. Ms. Geracitano scheduled a student study team (SST) meeting with Student’s teachers and Mother for January 23, 2004. At the meeting, an assessment plan for special education was discussed for Student. At the end of the meeting, Mother gave consent to begin assessing Student for special education. (Dist. Ex. 12-14.) Shortly after the SST meeting, the District began assessing Student in cognitive, academic and emotional areas. In addition, a District nurse conducted a health screening and determined that Student’s physical health was normal. The cognitive instruments determined that Student had average intelligence with an intelligence quotient of approximately 98. (Dist. Ex. 17.) His academic ability was also found to be in the average to above average range in reading, writing and mathematics. (Footnote 5) The District administered three different instruments to measure Student’s social and emotional functioning. The instruments indicated that Student had symptoms of depression to the extent that they interfered with his attendance and ability to complete schoolwork. (Dist. Ex. 17.) The assessment report concluded that Student’s depression met the criteria as emotional disturbed (ED) for purposes of special education eligibility.
On March 9, 2004, the District conducted an Individualized Education Program (IEP) team meeting and found Student eligible for special education and related services under the category of ED. (Dist. Ex. 19.) The team determined that Student’s depression adversely affected his ability to attend school, organize and complete assignments. As part of the IEP offer, Student was provided one daily class period of the resource specialist program (RSP) to address these deficits. (Footnote 6) In addition, potential counseling services were discussed for Student. However, Student’s parents informed the team that Student was already seeing a private therapist and they were comfortable with the current arrangement. As a result, the District did not offer any counseling services as part of the March 2004 IEP. In addition, the IEP team also made a referral to the OCHCA for an additional assessment and possible mental health services to address his depression. (Dist. Ex. 22.) The team agreed to meet after completion of the OCHCA’s assessment to amend or otherwise modify the existing March 2004 IEP. On March 19, 2004, the District sent the referral to the OCHCA. (Dist. Ex. 22.) The referral was received by OCHCA on March 30, 2004. (HCA Ex. Q1.)
On April 1, 2004, the OCHCA sent correspondence to Student’s parents seeking their consent and cooperation in its assessment of Student. (HCA Ex. D.) On April 5, 2004, Mother gave consent to the OCHCA’s assessment plan. (HCA Ex. F.) Following some scheduling problems, Mother and Student met with Carlita Hughes-Darby, LCSW and case manager, for Student’s initial intake and assessment on April 13, 2004. (HCA Ex. G, Q3-Q7.) The OCHCA’s assessment report concluded that Student demonstrated depression. The report noted that Student suffered from difficulties falling asleep, decreased energy, lack of motivation, concentration problems, irritability, poor appetite, and loss of interest in activities previously enjoyed. The report recommended mental health services developed in the OCHCA’s client service plan (CSP). The OCHCA offered Student through the CSP, at minimum individual therapy for thirty minutes twice per month. The CSP also included at minimum collateral therapy for thirty minutes once per month. (Footnote 7) (HCA Ex. K.) Following completion of the mental health assessment report, Ms. Hughes-Darby met with Mother to discuss the OCHCA’s proposed CSP for Student on May 11, 2004. (HCA Ex. K8.) Mother agreed with the CSP and gave consent to its proposed services. (HCA Ex. L.)
On May 28, 2004, the IEP team reconvened to add the proposed mental health services to Student’s existing IEP dated March 9, 2004. Mother agreed with the proposed services offered by the OCHCA and consented to the revised IEP for Student. (HCA Ex. M.) At this point, Student had discontinued his private therapy sessions and began receiving his therapy exclusively from the OCHCA.
Pursuant to the amended IEP of May 28, 2004, Ms. Hughes-Darby saw Student three times for individual therapy from June 1, 2004, to June 22, 2004. She also met with Student’s family for collateral therapy sessions on three occasions during this time period. After June 22, 2004, Student’s scheduled therapy sessions with Ms. Hughes-Darby were often cancelled or rescheduled at the request of Student’s parents. In addition, Student failed to attend one scheduled session. On July 13, 2004, Ms. Hughes-Darby contacted Mother regarding the scheduling of therapy sessions. During that conversation, Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that she was “looking into alternative methods” for Student’s mental health services. (HCA Ex. Q33.) On July 27, 2004, Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student’s parents were considering discontinuing the OCHCA’s services and having Student see a private therapist exclusively. On the same day, Ms. Hughes-Darby attempted to contact the District to arrange for another IEP meeting to discuss discontinuation of mental health services pursuant to Mother’s wishes. However, because the District was in summer recess, Ms. Hughes-Darby was unable to reach Charlotte Smith, school psychologist, and inform her of Mother’s request.
In late July 2004, Student’s parents consulted an educational consultant regarding options for Student’s educational placement. They began researching various residential placement facilities and chose Liahona. On August 9, 2004, Student’s parents arranged for Student’s transportation to Liahona in St. George, Utah. On the same date, Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby of Student’s placement. Since that day, Student has been attending Liahona’s residential placement program. Upon the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year, Ms. Hughes-Darby sent a letter to Ms. Smith seeking another IEP meeting to discuss the discontinuation of Student’s mental health services. (HCA Ex. P.) In September 2004, Ms. Smith attempted several times to schedule an IEP meeting with Student’s parents and attorney and offered several dates for a meeting. (Dist. Ex. 40.) However Student’s representatives did not agree with the proposed dates and refused to provide alternative dates for a meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Smith.) No IEP meeting has ever been noticed or taken place for Student since May 2004.
Since August 2004, Student has attended Liahona and has not returned to California. According to program coordinator Clay AhQuin, Liahona is a residential placement facility serving young men ranging from ages twelve to sixteen. It provides a structured environment of academic coursework, counseling, sports, community services and medication monitoring. It is not certified by the State of California as a nonpublic school. According to school officials, Student has made great strides mentally and academically at Liahona. Initially, Student suffered from homesickness and struggled with the structure. Presently, Liahona's staff reports strong academic progress and improvement in his demeanor and depression-related problems. However, school officials believe that he is best served by remaining at Liahona for the near future until he is mentally able to return to his parents and attend a comprehensive high school in the regular education setting exclusively. Accordingly, the present decision seeks to determine whether the District and the OCHCA failed in meeting their duties under State and federal special education law and, if they did fail in this regard, whether Student is entitled to remedies including reimbursement and continued placement at Liahona.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
ISSUE NO. 1: From February 2003 until the assessment completed in March 2004, did the District fail in its child find duties by not assessing Student for special education eligibility?
Under the amended Individuals with Disabilities Act (IDEA) and State law, children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Cal. Code Educ. § 56000. State education law also requires school districts to establish policies and procedures to locate, identify, and evaluate children within their boundaries who are eligible for special education. Cal. Educ. Code § 56300 et seq.; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3). Each school district has an affirmative duty to actively and systematically seek out all individuals with exceptional needs who reside in the district. Cal. Educ. Code § 56300; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(3). All referrals for special education and related services shall initiate the assessment process and must be documented. Cal. Code of Regs. tit. 5, § 3021(a).
Tewinkle Middle School
Student contends that the District failed in its duty to assess him for special education upon his entrance into Tewinkle in February 2003 through the end of the school year. Specifically, Student asserts that the District had knowledge of his poor attendance, sleeping habits, and grades. Further, Student alleges that his lack of motivation in school and interest in outside activities were other signs that the District should have recognized as potential areas of concern requiring a special education assessment. The District contends that Student’s problems, to the extent known to the District, were not to an extent warranting a special education assessment.
Mother testified that after Student’s first progress report, she requested a meeting with the school counselor, Meghan Hanna, to discuss these concerns. At the time, Student was receiving below C grades in all classes. (Stu. Ex. 40.) A meeting was called, which included Student’s teachers, Ms. Hanna, and Mother. Mother recalled that the meeting focused on Student’s class work. The participants agreed that Student’s level of work was acceptable but that his poor attendance affected his ability to turn in assignments and maintain good grades. Mother testified that she told the District personnel that Student was having sleeping problems that affected his attendance. Mother acknowledged that she did not inform the District that Student suffered from any other problems. In addition, she acknowledged that she did not make a request for any special education assessment or services at that time. However, Mother’s recollection of these events was very general. She could not recall when the meeting took place or offer any testimony about the specific discussion.
The District asserts that, in any case, the events of the second semester of Student’s eighth-grade year would not have put the District on notice that a special education assessment was warranted. Although Ms. Hanna also only generally recalled the events of the meeting and could not specify when it took place, Ms. Hanna did recall discussing Student’s problems with both his mother and teachers during the meeting. Ms. Hanna recalled from the meeting that Student’s classroom ability and test scores were within the average range. Ms. Hanna stated that she did not recall any discussion regarding Student’s sleeping problems. She added that Student’s conduct was not a problem. Nor was there any indication that Student was suffering from any psychological or emotional difficulties. Moreover, Ms. Hanna testified that her discussion with Mother and Student’s teachers did not elicit any information indicating a problem that required special education assessment. Ms. Hanna testified that Student’s below average grades, attendance, and sleeping difficulties, would not have been sufficient to trigger a special education assessment. (Footnote 8) In the past, Ms. Hanna has referred students for special education assessment based on her training and experience as a special education student teacher and licensed school counselor. In her opinion, given the information at hand, there was no reason to refer Student for a special education assessment.
In determining whether the District had an obligation to conduct an assessment for Student during his eight-grade year, the Hearing Officer must review the evidence as to the information available to the District at the time. Initially, the Hearing Officer notes that neither Mother nor Ms. Hanna had complete recollections of the meeting. Nonetheless, given the limited information provided by Mother and Student’s teachers, Ms. Hanna did not believe that a special education assessment was required. It is undisputed that Ms. Hanna is a trained and accredited school counselor who has served as a student teacher in a special education setting for two years. This firsthand experience provides Ms. Hanna with the ability to identify students who may require special education. She concluded that Student did not require an assessment. None of Student’s expert witnesses testified as to whether Student required an assessment for special education in his eight-grade year at Tewinkle. Given Ms. Hanna’s persuasive testimony, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to assess Student for special education while he attended Tewinkle.
Estancia High School
Student also alleges that the District should have assessed Student for special education during his ninth-grade year at Estancia before January 23, 2004. He claims that the District was aware of concerns expressed by Mother about Student’s continuing decline in attendance, class work, and grades. In addition, Student asserts that the District also was aware of his depression. Given this information, Student asserts that the District should have conducted an assessment for special education before the January 23, 2004 SST meeting. (Footnote 9) The District contends that it was not required to assess Student before the SST meeting because Student did not exhibit problems to the extent requiring assessment.
In support of Student’s position, he relies on the testimony of Mother. She testified that Student had poor attendance from the start of the ninth-grade year. She attributed the poor attendance to his bouts with bronchitis and ear infections. In addition, Student’s sleep problems significantly worsened. Although Student would go to bed at 11:00 p.m., she testified that he often would not be able to fall asleep for hours. She noted also that Student had a loss of appetite and a loss of weight. Mother stated that these problems affected his attendance and were reflected in his poor grades.
Mother testified that in early October 2003, she contacted Michelle Geracitano, school counselor, to discuss Student’s grades. She acknowledged, however that she did not share information about Student’s sleeping difficulties or weight loss. Initially, Ms. Geracitano suggested that Student circulate a weekly grade and attitude report to his teachers to complete. This report was to then be brought home by Student for his parent’s review. In addition, Ms. Geracitano organized a meeting with Student’s teachers, Mother, and herself to discuss Student’s class performance and grades. After the meeting, Student’s attendance and class performance continued to be problems. He attended school less frequently and had greater difficulty completing assignments, causing him to struggle with academic subjects.
Mother added that after Dr. Dambrucia diagnosed Student with depression in November 2003, she contacted Ms. Geracitano in early December 2003 and informed her that STUDENT had depression. Ms. Geracitano sent an e-mail to Student’s teachers requesting that they contact Mother so that she could obtain Student’s assignments. Moreover, Ms. Geracitano informed the teachers that Student was “having psychological difficulties.” (Dist. Ex. 8.) However, the District did not offer nor did she request an assessment plan at this time. On January 20, 2004, Mother contacted Ms. Geracitano again regarding Student’s performance and requested an SST meeting. On January 23, 2004, the District conducted the meeting. At that time, the District offered an assessment plan for Student, which Mother signed. Mother acknowledged that she never requested a special education assessment prior to the January 23, 2004 meeting. Student contends that the above-described events and the information provided to the District by Mother should have put it on notice prior to January 23, 2004, to assess Student for special education.
In response, the District argues that the available information, at the time, did not warrant an assessment of Student prior to January 23, 2004. Nancy Ferda, Student’s ninth-grade English teacher, testified that throughout the ninth-grade year, Student was an average student that paid attention and completed assigned work in the classroom. (Footnote 10) He also did not exhibit any behavior or conduct problems in her class. Outside of class, she observed him as being energetic and freely socializing with friends and classmates. She testified that she was concerned that Student was missing class often. In conversations with Student, she encouraged him to attend class but he was not forthcoming with the reason for his absences. Ms. Ferda testified that she spoke with Mother on the telephone on two occasions during the fall semester. In addition, they also met once in December 2003, at which time Ms. Ferda gave Mother assignments for Student to complete. Ms. Ferda stated that in these interactions, Mother never once discussed Student’s having any mental illness or depression or that he was receiving counseling. Ms. Ferda testified that she saw no signs of depression or other emotional problems. Instead, she understood that Student’s attendance was due to his inability to get to school in the morning.
School counselor Michelle Geracitano corroborated Ms. Ferda’s testimony. (Footnote 11) Ms. Geracitano testified that she first became acquainted with Student after Mother contacted her on October 13, 2003, to discuss his grades. In response, Ms. Geracitano requested that Student’s teachers complete weekly grade and attitude reports for his parents’ review. On October 23, 2003, Ms. Geracitano spoke with Mother again to check on Student’s status and the effectiveness of the weekly progress reports. She stated that Mother shared with her that Student had some family problems. Specifically, Ms. Geracitano testified that Mother told her of the difficulties as a grandparent raising a teenager. Thereafter, Ms. Geracitano scheduled a meeting with Student’s teachers, Mother, and herself to discuss his academic problems. On October 28, 2003, the meeting participants talked about ways to improve Student’s attendance and his grades. However, Ms. Geracitano testified that there was never any discussion about mental health or other medical issues regarding Student.
On December 10, 2003, Ms. Geracitano received another phone call from Mother regarding Student’s attendance and grades. (Dist. Ex. 8.) Ms. Geracitano testified Mother asked her to share with Student’s teachers that he was having “psychological difficulties.” Ms. Geracitano explained that these “psychological difficulties” were related to the family problems that Mother had earlier discussed with Ms. Geracitano. However, Mother never discussed Student’s diagnosis of depression or his therapy. Ms. Geracitano testified that she did not become aware of any mental illness or therapy until the SST meeting on January 23, 2004.
As discussed above, in determining whether the District had an obligation to assess Student for special education from September 2003 to January 23, 2004, the Hearing Officer must view the evidence as to the information available to the District at the time. First, the Hearing Officer analyzes the undisputed facts in this matter. Here, it is undisputed that Student had poor attendance from September through December 2003. He missed approximately fourteen days during this time period. It is also undisputed that his poor attendance caused him to miss many class assignments, and therefore, he received low grades. With respect to Student’s attendance, the number of absences in such a short time period might have raised concerns about Student requiring further investigation. However, Ms. Geracitano testified that although Student was often absent during the fall term, his parents cited illness for all these absences. Mother corroborated this testimony by stating that Student had four bouts of illness from bronchitis or ear infections during this time and she did not require him to go to school on these days. During this time, Mother stated that Student was also missing some school because of his sleeping difficulties. Nonetheless, Mother acknowledged that she called or wrote notes to the school citing illness as the cause of Student’s absences during this time frame. Ms. Geracitano stated that these illness-related absences would not have put the school on notice that there were any problems warranting a special education assessment. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Geracitano’s explanation credible regarding Student’s attendance. Further, the Hearing Officer determines that, under the circumstances, Student’s illness-related absences would not have required the District to pursue special education assessment.
Next, the Hearing Officer analyzes the disputed fact of whether Mother informed the District of Student’s diagnosis of depression in December 2003. Ms. Geracitano testified persuasively that on December 10, 2003, Mother contacted her to seek assistance with collecting assignments for Student. This request was memorialized in Ms. Geracitano’s note completed contemporaneously with the conversation. (Dist. Ex. 8.) Ms. Geracitano also testified credibly that the “psychological difficulties” referenced in the note were the words that Mother wanted to convey to Student’s teachers. Ms. Geracitano’s explained that Mother was guarded in her words and did not want Student’s teachers to have any additional information regarding Student. She also stated that the “psychological difficulties” were no more than those described in previous discussions regarding the family dynamic between grandparents and grandson. In addition, Ms. Ferda corroborated this testimony that in December 2003, Mother never mentioned Student as having depression or that she was seeking any counseling or other mental health assistance for him. Ms. Ferda also testified that she was very familiar with and sensitive to depression because a close family member suffered from depression for years. She noted that discussion of depression would not have escaped her attention.
The Hearing Officer finds that the testimony of the District’s witnesses more persuasive as to the disputed fact. Ms. Geracitano and Ms. Ferda each testified independently that they did not learn of Student’s depression diagnosis until the January 23, 2004 SST meeting. Moreover, the actions taken by Ms. Geracitano and Ms. Ferda were responsive to Student and Mother. Specifically, Ms. Geracitano quickly called meetings in October 2003 and January 2004 at Mother’s request. Further, Ms. Geracitano also sent e-mails to Student’s teachers conveying Mother’s requests for assistance. Ms. Ferda also met with Mother to discuss Student’s work and provide assignments at her home. Each provided consistent testimony of the information provided by Mother. The Hearing Officer finds that Mother was not entirely forthcoming with information about Student with respect to his problems. Specifically, Mother failed to inform school officials of Student’s sleeping problems as a cause of some of his absences. Instead, she consistently provided notes to the school requesting that Student’s sleep-related absences be excused for illness. Lastly, Mother never requested a special education assessment. The Hearing Officer finds Mother’s actions were reflective of her unwillingness to share sensitive information about Student that would have been helpful in determining his need for an assessment. Given the limited information available to the District, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District was not aware of Student’s depression diagnosis before the January 23, 2004 SST. Accordingly, it was not compelled to assess Student for special education before the SST meeting.
Given the findings above, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s attendance and declining grades would not have placed the District on notice to assess him during the fall 2003. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s claim that the District should have assessed Student prior to the January 23, 2004 SST meeting is not persuasive.
ISSUE NO. 2: During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District err by failing to provide Student a preliminary referral to the OCHCA for mental health services at the January 2004 student study team meeting?
Under California law, a district may initiate a referral to a local mental health agency for assessment of a pupil’s social or emotional status and qualification for services. An IEP team may refer a pupil who has been determined to be eligible for special education and who is suspected of needing mental health services to a community mental health service. Cal. Govt. Code § 7576(b). However, a district need not wait for a special education eligibility determination prior to initiating a referral. Instead, based on preliminary results of assessments, a district may refer a pupil who has been determined to be, or is suspected of being, an individual with exceptional needs, and is suspected of needing mental health services, to a community mental health service. Cal. Govt. Code § 7576(d). This preliminary referral must meet the requirements necessary for a referral under section 7576(b) including consent from the pupil’s parent. Cal. Govt. Code § 7576(d).
Student contends that the District should not have waited until the March 9, 2004 IEP meeting to initiate a referral to OCHCA for mental health services. Student asserts that the District should have referred Student to the OCHCA at the time of the January 23, 2004 SST meeting. Student alleges that Student’s social and emotional problems were to a degree that an immediate referral was required. The District asserts that a referral at the SST meeting was not required because it was not requested by anyone at the meeting. In support of Student’s position, Student offered the testimony of Dr. Christine Davidson. (Footnote 12) She testified that the District knew Student’s attendance, sleeping, and academic difficulties. She further stated that despite his current therapy, Student was “not getting better.” Dr. Davidson opined that given this available information at the time of the January 2004 SST meeting, the District should have requested consent from Student’s parent to initiate a mental health referral.
The District argued that a preliminary referral for mental health services at the time of the January 23, 2004 SST meeting was not necessary. It asserts that the referral at the March 9, 2004 IEP meeting was proper given the results of Student’s initial assessments and no referral was required before the March 2004 IEP meeting. As determined above, the January 2004 SST meeting was the first indication that the District knew that Student suffered from depression. At that time, the District first became informed that Student had just begun receiving counseling services from Dr. Dambrucia in late November 2003. The District and the OCHCA questioned Dr. Davidson’s testimony that Student was “not getting better,” despite his therapy. Under cross-examination, Dr. Davidson conceded that she never communicated with Dr. Dambrucia or Dr. Emily Johnson, a psychiatrist, although they both were treating Student at the time in question. Without actually communicating with either treating professional, Dr. Davidson had no basis of fact that Student’s therapy was not effective.
The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s condition did not warrant an immediate preliminary referral for mental health services at the January 23, 2004 SST meeting because the evidence is undisputed that the District had only begun the assessing Student’s social and emotional functioning as part of his initial assessment. In addition, there was no request by any member of the IEP team for a referral for a mental health assessment. The information available to the District coupled with the lack of any request for a preliminary referral supports a finding that a preliminary referral was not required. Moreover, the Hearing Officer does not find Dr. Davidson’s testimony credible. She offered a blanket opinion regarding the need for a preliminary assessment without support. As noted above, she admitted never communicating with Student’s treating therapist or psychiatrist, yet she opined about their efficacy. Because the Hearing Officer finds that Dr. Davidson simply did not have the underlying facts to make such an opinion, her testimony is given little weight. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not err in not making a preliminary referral to OCHCA for a mental health assessment for Student following the January 23, 2004 SST meeting.
ISSUE NO 3: During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny Student a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) in its March 2004 Individualized Education Program (IEP)?
Student contends that the District’s March 9, 2004 IEP offer denied Student a FAPE both procedurally and substantively. Specifically, Student asserts that the District committed procedural errors in (1) failing to include a nurse at the IEP meeting, and (2) failing to timely send a referral packet to the OCHCA to initiate the mental health services process. In addition, Student alleges that the District substantively denied Student a FAPE by (1) not including appropriate present levels of performance, (2) failing to tie the present levels of performance to goals, and (3) failing to offer counseling services.
Procedural Appropriateness
Under both the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a FAPE. 20 U.S.C. § 1400; Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(8). The right to a FAPE also includes the important entitlement to certain procedural protections during the process of developing an individualized education program for a disabled child. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992); Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Cent. Sch. Dist. v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, 205 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1483. In Rowley, the Supreme Court recognized the importance of adherence to the procedural requirements of the IDEA as part of the provision of FAPE. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 205.
The procedural rights that extend to parents and students under the IDEA include the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b). Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process may result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., 960 F.2d at 1484; see also Roland M. v. Concord Sch. Comm., 910 F.2d 983, 994 (1st Cir. 1990).
Nurse at the IEP Meeting
Under both federal and State law, an IEP team meeting must include specific enumerated persons. 5 C.F.R. § 300.344; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b). The team must include one or both of the pupil’s parents, a regular education teacher, a special education teacher, a district representative, and an individual who conducted an assessment or who is knowledgeable about assessment procedures used to assess the pupil. In addition, at the discretion of the parent or district, the meeting may include other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. The party who invites the individual to be a member of the IEP team shall make the determination of whether the individual has knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(6).
Student contends that the District committed a procedural error by not including the school nurse as part of the March 9, 2004 IEP meeting. Student argues that a nurse was a person with special knowledge or expertise regarding Student’s health matters and that the nurse was necessary to discuss the health screening conducted by the District, and to discuss his prescribed medications. In support of his claim, Student offered the testimony of Dr. Davidson. She testified that “someone” should have been present at the March 2004 IEP meeting to explain the medications prescribed by Dr. Johnson for Student.
The District argues that federal and State law do not require the participation of the school nurse in the IEP meeting. Instead, the District claims that it met its requirements of having a person knowledgeable of the assessment present at the meeting. Specifically, Charlotte Smith served as a qualified school psychologist who supervised the assessment process and was knowledgeable about the health screening and attended the IEP meeting. In addition, the District contends that the school nurse’s determination that Student had good health eliminated the need to have a nurse present for the meeting. Specifically, Ms. Smith testified that the nurse’s screening was included in the IEP, in addition to the cognitive, academic and social/emotional testing. (Dist. Ex. 18.) The screening report noted that Student was in good health but had been diagnosed with depression for which he took Prozac, an antidepressant, each morning. (Dist. Ex. 18.) Ms. Smith testified that as the school psychologist and supervisor of the assessment report, she was knowledgeable about the health screening and results. She confirmed the nurse’s report that Student’s physical health was good and no further health assessment or plan was necessary and shared that information with the IEP team.
The Hearing Officer finds that the participation of a nurse at the March 2004 IEP was not necessary. Both federal and State law do not specifically require the participation of a nurse. Instead, a nurse’s presence would not be necessary where someone with knowledge about assessment procedures attends the meeting. Here, Ms. Smith served in that capacity. Moreover, Student did not challenge Ms. Smith’s qualifications as a person knowledgeable of the assessment procedures nor the health screening report. The Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis in either law or the circumstances requiring the presence of a nurse at the March 2004 IEP. Therefore, the District did not commit a procedural error in not including a nurse at the March 2004 IEP.
Timeliness of the Mental Health Referral
Student also contends that the District committed a procedural error in failing to provide its referral packages to the OCHCA within the statutory timeline of five days following consent by his parents. Under California law, referral packages must be provided within five working days of the district’s receipt of parental consent for the referral of the pupil to the community mental health service. Cal. Govt. Code § 60040. Here, the undisputed facts show that Student’s parents consented to the referral for mental health services on Tuesday, March 9, 2004. (Dist. Ex. 20.) It is also undisputed that the District sent the referral package on Friday, March 19, 2004. (HCA Ex. C.) Because the law requires the District to provide the package within five working days, the package should have been forwarded to the OCHCA no later than Tuesday, March 16, 2004. The Hearing Officer finds that the District was late by three working days in sending Student’s referral package to the OCHCA. Accordingly, the District did commit a procedural violation by failing to submit Student’s referral package within the statutory five-day timeline.
As discussed above, not all procedural errors result in a denial of FAPE. Instead, there must be a showing that the procedural violation resulted in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringed on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process.
The District and the OCHCA demonstrated that there was no prejudice to Student or his parents due to the delay. The undisputed evidence shows that the OCHCA attempted to contact Mother on March 30, 2004, to begin the mental health assessment process. (HCA Ex. Q:1.) On April 1, 2004, OCHCA case manager Carlita Hughes-Darby sent a letter to Mother seeking an opportunity to meet to begin the assessment process. (HCA Ex. D.) Mother responded to Ms. Hughes-Darby’s invitation and consented to the assessment plan on April 5, 2004. (HCA Ex. E.) Originally, Mother and Ms. Hughes-Darby agreed to meet on April 8, 2004, to begin the actual assessment; however, Mother subsequently cancelled the meeting and it was rescheduled for April 13, 2004. (HCA Ex. Q:4.) Because Mother cancelled and rescheduled the meeting, the OCHCA was required to request an extension from Mother. (Testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby.) Mother provided consent to the extension. (HCA Ex. H.) Student offered no contrary evidence that Student suffered a loss of educational opportunity from a delay of three days. Nor did Student offer any evidence that Student’s parents were denied an opportunity to participate in the IEP process.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s procedural violation of being tardy by three days in sending its referral package to the OCHCA did not result in prejudice to Student. Once the mental health assessment process began, Mother’s scheduling difficulties delayed the process by two weeks, from March 30, 2004 to April 13, 2004. Given Student’s parents’ scheduling delay and consent to an extension to complete mental health assessment, the Hearing Officer finds no loss of educational opportunity or parental participation. Therefore a procedural denial of FAPE did not result from the District’s failure to timely provide Student’s referral for a mental health assessment.
Substantive Appropriateness
In addition to the important procedural protections afforded special education students, the IDEA and California law provide for significant substantive rights for students entitled to special education. See 20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq. “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospitals and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which also is referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.
An IEP is a written statement that must be developed, reviewed, and revised for each student with a disability. The IEP must include a statement of the goals and objectives, the special education and related services, and of the program modifications or supports for school personnel that are to be provided to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum, and to be educated and participate with disabled and nondisabled peers in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A); 34 C.F.R. § 300.347; Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56343, 56345. The District cannot be held responsible for information it had no basis for knowing at the time it developed the IEP. (See Adams v. Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (9th Cir. 1999) (stating that review must focus on adequacy of proposed program at time it was drafted).) However, “[i]n striving for ‘appropriateness,’ an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable…at the time the IEP was drafted.’” Id. (quoting Fuhrmann v. East Hanover Bd. Of Educ., 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3d Cir. 1993)). Districts are also required to review and revise the IEP when necessary to address any lack of expected progress towards goals and objectives. 34 C.F.R. § 300.343(c).
To determine whether the District provided Student a free appropriate public education, one must focus on the adequacy of the District’s proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). In Rowley, 458 U.S. 176, the United States Supreme Court determined that the student’s individualized education program (IEP) must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. The Rowley Court concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208. De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2d Cir. 1998). A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. Mrs. B. v. Milford Bd. of Educ., 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997). (Footnote 13)
To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program must meet the following substantive requirements to constitute an appropriate educational program: (1) be designed to meet Student’s unique needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, and (3) comport with his IEP.
Student’s Unique Needs
The parties agree that Student suffers from depression, which significantly affects his ability to benefit from his educational environment. To that end, the parties also concur that Student’s depression manifests itself in his general inability to attend school regularly, organize materials for class, and to complete classroom assignments. The parties agree that to address these deficits, Student needs specialized instruction. In addition, the parties are in accord that Student requires counseling services to address his depression.
Designed to Meet His Unique Needs
The March 9, 2004 IEP offered Student a placement with one classroom period of resource specialist program instruction to assist him with attendance, organization, and work completion. It also included accommodations for standardized testing. However the IEP did not offer any counseling services. (Dist. Ex. 19.)
Student does not dispute that his areas of need are identified in the March 9, 2004 IEP. Rather, Student contends that the District failed to adequately articulate the present levels of performance and goals and objectives for particular areas of need. Student specifically alleges that the District violated the IDEA because (1) the March 9, 2004 IEP contained no quantified present levels of performance in each of his deficits areas of attendance, organization and schoolwork completion (Dist. Ex. 19:3-19:4), and (2) the goals and short-term objectives are not tied to the present levels of performance in the areas of attendance and organization. (Dist. Ex. 19:3-19:4.) Student also asserts that counseling should have been offered as service to meet Student’s needs.
a. Present Levels of Performance, Goals and Objectives
California Education Code section 56345(a)(1)(A) requires inclusion of the present levels of performance in the IEP. “In assessing children with disabilities, school districts may use a variety of assessment techniques to determine the extent to which these children can be involved and progress in the general curriculum, such as criterion-referenced tests, standard achievement tests, diagnostic tests, other tests, or any combination of the above.” 34. C.F.R. Part 300, Appendix A, page 34.300-58A (1996) (discussing §300.347). The purpose of using assessments is to determine the child’s present levels of performance so that approaches to the curriculum can be identified. Id. The plain meaning of the section requires that the quantitative results from tests or other quantitative measures be used to describe the present level of performance. From this quantifiable point, goals and objectives can be developed to track progress in the area of need. Correspondingly, California Education Code section 56345(a)(2) states that the IEP must include measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives to meet the student’s needs that result from the student’s disability to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and to meet the student’s other educational needs that result from the student’s disability.
Student contends that the IEP did not contain quantitative present levels of performance in the areas of need of attendance, completion of classroom assignments, and organization. (Dist Ex. 19:3-19:4.) Student also claims a substantive denial of FAPE because the District failed to “tie the goals and objectives” to Student’s present levels of performance. Specifically, the present levels of performance were not sufficiently set forth, and therefore the goals and objectives were without any connection to Student’s current abilities. The District argues that quantifiable present levels of performance are contained in the March 9, 2004 IEP. It further contends that the goals and objectives are appropriately based on Student’s present levels of performance in areas of need.
In reviewing the IEP at hearing, Ms. Longfellow testified that the IEP team understood the present levels of performance and their relationship to the goals and objectives. (Footnote 14) She conceded that the present levels of performance were not written in that specific section but also explained that the requisite numerical information was contained within one chart on a single page for each of Student’s areas of need. She testified that reading the document as a whole would allow the reader to discern the quantitative present levels of performance. In light of Ms. Longfellow’s testimony, the Hearing Officer examines the contents of the IEP to determine if quantifiable present levels of performance are included. A reading of the IEP’s “present levels of performance” sections gives a general description of Student’s current ability in the areas of attendance, assignment completion and organization. Specifically, in the areas of attendance and assignment completion, the section reads in pertinent part, “STUDENT’s attendance has been very poor as he is often unable to get out of bed in the morning. His attention span is short for classroom discussions, he has difficulty organizing and prioritizing his work.” (Dist. Ex. 19:3.)
On the same page and adjacent to the present levels of performance section, the Annual Goal states, “STUDENT will increase his daily attendance from 30% to 100%.” On the same page, the “Short-term Objectives” also include information in the area of classroom assignments. The IEP states, “STUDENT will improve assignment completion in class by: Completing 3 out of 5 assigned tasks per day by April 1, 2004; Completing 4 out of 5 assigned tasks per day by June 20, 2004; Completing 5 out of 5 assigned tasks per day by March 9, 2005.” (Dist. Ex. 19:3.) With respect to Student’s homework assignment completion, the benchmarks similarly state, “STUDENT will improve homework completion in class by: Completing 3 out of 5 homework assignments per day by April 1, 2004, Completing 4 out of 5 homework assignments per day by June 20, 2004, Completing 5 out of 5 homework assignments per day by March 9, 2005.” (Dist. Ex. 19:3.)
On the next page of the IEP, Student’s present levels of performance for organization are also similarly described. Again the section entitled “present levels of performance” states a general description of his current ability for organization. It reads, “STUDENT has a great deal of difficulty organizing his work. He often does not have the essay materials in class. His grandmother reports that he misplaces items frequently.” (Dist. Ex. 19:4.) In the adjacent section, the Annual Goal states, “STUDENT will improve his organizational skills related to schoolwork from 10% to 90%.” (Dist. Ex. 19:4.) On the same page, under the “goals and objectives” section, the IEP states that Student will carry “his materials and assignments to and from activities with 30% success by 4/15/04, increasing to 50% by 6/20/04, increasing to 90% success by 3/9/05.” (Dist. Ex. 19:4.)
The Hearing Officer finds that although the present levels of performance section generally describes Student’s current ability in these areas of need, the IEP nonetheless does sufficiently provide the required quantifiable information. Within the IEP and adjacent to the present levels of performance section, the Annual Goal states, “STUDENT will increase his daily attendance from 30% to 100%.” The Hearing Officer finds that this notation indicates clearly that Student’s present level of performance for attendance was 30%.
Furthermore, on the same page, the “Short-term Objectives” also include information setting forth the numerical value of Student’s current ability in the area of assignment completion. For instance, in the area of classroom assignments, the IEP states, “STUDENT will improve assignment completion in class by: Completing 3 out of 5 assigned tasks per day by April 1, 2004.” (Dist. Ex. 19:3.) From this description, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s present levels of performance in the area of assignment completion are adequately described. Given that the first benchmark calls for completing 3 out of 5 assigned tasks by April 1, 2004, it can be reasonably inferred that Student was currently completing less than 3 out of 5 or less than 60% of assigned tasks at the time of the IEP.
The same conclusion can be reached with respect to Student’s homework assignment completion. The first benchmark states, “STUDENT will improve homework completion in class by: Completing 3 out of 5 homework assignments per day by April 1, 2004.” (Dist. Ex. 19:3.) Here, the benchmark indicates that Student was completing less than 3 out of 5 or 60% of his homework assignments at the time of the IEP. Given these descriptions, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s present levels of performance in the areas of attendance and assignment completion were sufficiently included within the IEP.
On the next page of the IEP, the document also sufficiently provides the numerical information for Student’s present levels of performance with respect to organizational skills. Although the section entitled “present levels of performance” does not contain the quantifiable information, the requisite information can be found on the same page within the annual goal. Specifically, the Annual Goal states, “STUDENT will improve his organizational skills related to schoolwork from 10% to 90%.” (Dist. Ex. 19:4.) Thus, Student’s present level of performance is clearly described as 10% in the area of organizational skills related to schoolwork. Similarly, on the same page, the IEP states that Student will carry “his materials and assignments to and from activities with 30% success by 4/15/04, increasing to 50% by 6/20/04, increasing to 90% success by 3/9/05.” (Dist. Ex. 19:4.) Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP sufficiently identified Student’s present levels of performance in this area also.
The Hearing Officer also finds that the goals and objectives spelled out in the IEP are directly related to Student’s present levels of performance. Here, the IEP clearly shows annual goals in the areas of attendance, completion of classroom assignments, completion of homework assignments, improving organization skills, bringing assignments and materials to class, and increasing school performance. In each of goals, the District included three benchmarks or objectives to progress toward the goals. (Dist. Ex. 19:3-19:4.) Similar goals and objectives are included for the areas of coursework completion and attendance. Ms. Longfellow testified to the relationship between the goals and Student’s present levels of performance. She explained that Student had overall goals in these areas that were to be achieved by the next annual IEP meeting with benchmarks to be met in the interim. Student failed to offer any evidence to the contrary. Moreover, Student did not disagree with the areas of need delineated in the goals and objectives. Although Student pointed out that the numbering of the goals and objectives was somewhat unclear, Student failed to show that the goals and objectives were not related to the present levels of performance and needs. In each instance, the Hearing Officer finds that these goals and objectives are tied to the description of Student’s present levels of performance in coursework completion and attendance.
Taken as a whole, the IEP sufficiently identified Student’s present levels of performance. (Dist. Ex. 19:3-19:4.) Moreover, the goals and objectives listed in the IEP correspond directly to Student’s areas of need discussed above. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer does not find a denial of FAPE with respect to the present levels of performance or goals and objectives in the March 9, 2004 IEP.
b. Counseling Services
Student contends that the District failed to include counseling services as a necessary component of Student’s March 2004 IEP. As discussed above, counseling was an area of need for Student. It is undisputed that Student’s depression caused him to miss school and have difficulty completing work. However, the IEP offer included only an RSP classroom and testing accommodations. Ms. Smith conceded that Student required counseling services; however, she explained that during discussion of potential counseling services, Student’s parents informed the IEP team that they wanted to continue to have Student see his current therapist rather than a new or additional therapist from the school. The District complied with Student’s parent’s request and did not offer counseling services. Nonetheless, Mother testified that had the District offered counseling services, she would have accepted the offer.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District denied Student a FAPE in the March 2004 IEP to the extent that it failed to offer counseling services. Although the District desired to comply with Student’s parent’s request, it was incumbent on the District to at minimum offer the services and allow Student’s parents to accept the services.
In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s educational program incorporated in the March 9, 2004 IEP was designed to meet his unique needs with the exception that it did not include counseling services. Although the District included an RSP program to address his deficits in the areas of attendance, coursework completion and organization, it failed to properly offer counseling services to Student to necessary address these deficits. Thus, the District failed to design a program designed to meet Student’s unique needs to the extent that counseling services were not offered.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that, given its failure to offer counseling services, the program was not substantially designed to meet Student’s unique needs. This same deficiency supports a finding that the program was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Conforms to the IEP
Student did not assert any failure to comport with the IEP as offered for the time period at issue. ****
In summary, the program provided by the District was not designed to meet Student’s unique needs or reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit to the extent it failed to include counseling services. Thus, the program offered in the March 9, 2004 IEP denied Student a FAPE to the extent it did not include counseling services.
ISSUE NO. 4: During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District and the OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in its May 2004 IEP?
Student also contends that the District and the OCHCA failed to offer Student a FAPE in the May 28, 2004 IEP. Specifically, Student alleges that the District committed a procedural error by not including a Ph.D. psychologist or psychiatrist at the IEP meeting. In addition, Student asserts that the District and the OCHCA failed to offer an appropriate level of counseling services to meet Student’s needs. Lastly, Student claims that the District and the OCHCA denied Student a FAPE because they failed to refer Student for residential placement at the time of the IEP meeting.
Procedural Appropriateness
Ph.D. Psychologist or Psychiatrist
Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation by failing to include a doctorate level psychologist or a psychiatrist (M.D.) at the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. Student claims that Student’s level of depression and medications required the attendance of a person with such qualifications.
As discussed above, federal and State law enumerate specific persons who must attend an IEP meeting. 5 C.F.R. § 300.344; Cal Educ. Code § 56341(b). In addition, at the discretion of the parent or district, other individuals who have knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. The party who invites the individual to be a member of the IEP team shall make the determination of whether the individual has knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(6).
Because the relevant statutes do not require the participation of a Ph.D. psychologist or psychiatrist at an IEP meeting, it appears that Students seeks to include this person under the category of an individual having knowledge or special expertise regarding the pupil. In support of his claim, Student offered the testimony of Dr. Emily Johnson. (Footnote 15) Dr. Johnson testified that she was not invited to any of Student’s IEP meetings. She believed that all persons working with Student, including herself would have benefited from the sharing of information. With respect to her work, Dr. Johnson explained her involvement in prescribing and monitoring Student’s medications in the treatment of his depression. She considered this information valuable and noted that she should have shared it with the IEP team. Further, she believed that information from the IEP team would have assisted her in providing treatment to Student.
The District and the OCHCA counter that the law does not require the attendance of a Ph.D. psychologist or psychiatrist at Student’s May IEP meeting. They also point to evidence showing that, in the past, Dr. Johnson participated in IEP meetings for other students and that she was aware of the scheduling of Student’s IEP meetings through discussions with Mother. Dr. Johnson admitted that she never requested an opportunity to attend. Moreover, there is no evidence to suggest that Student’s parents ever invited Dr. Johnson or a Ph.D. psychologist such as Dr. Dambrucia to any IEP meeting.
The Hearing Officer finds that there is no basis in either law or circumstances to require the attendance of a Ph.D. psychologist or psychiatrist at Student’s May 2004 IEP meeting. As noted above, section 56341(b)(6) permits the attendance of other persons with specialized expertise or knowledge regarding the student. However, this attendance is only permitted after there is an invitation by the parent, district or county office. Here, the evidence is undisputed that neither the District, nor OCHCA nor Student’s parents ever invited Dr. Johnson or Dr. Dambrucia to the May 2004 IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer determines that the District did not commit a procedural violation in not inviting a Ph.D. psychologist or psychiatrist to the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting.
Substantive Appropriateness
Student’s Unique Needs
The May 2004 IEP meeting was called to discuss the addition of potential mental health services to Student’s existing March 2004 IEP. The parties continued to agree that as a result of Student’s depression, he had unique needs in the areas of attendance, completion of assignments and organization. There is no dispute that academic support services were appropriate to address these needs. In addition, the parties also agree that counseling or therapy services were required to meet these same needs. They disagree as to the amount of counseling required and whether Student should have been offered residential placement. As discussed above, the District, through the OCHCA, offered thirty minutes twice a month of individual therapy and thirty minutes once a month of collateral therapy. Student contends that Student required higher amounts of both individual and collateral therapy services. (Footnote 16)
Designed to Meet Student’s Needs a. Counseling
Student asserts that by the time of the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting, Student’s depression had increased to the degree that he required intensive therapy. Student contends that he required at least one hour per week of individual and collateral therapy respectively. In support of Student’s position, Mother testified that she observed Student becoming more withdrawn. He appeared not to want to socialize with others, including friends. Moreover, he was still having problems sleeping and attending school. In addition, Dr. Davidson testified that she considered Student to have been “fragile” at that time. She stated that Student required more than one therapy session per week. Dr. Johnson agreed and stated that Student required both individual and collateral therapy for at least one hour per week.
Both the District and the OCHCA contend that thirty minutes twice a month of individual therapy and thirty minutes once a month of collateral therapy were appropriate to address Student’s for depression. In support of its position, the District and the OCHCA rely on the testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby. Ms. Hughes-Darby testified that she met personally with Student, Mother, and school officials in determining Student’s mental health needs. These discussions were memorialized in Ms. Hughes-Darby’s clinical notes. (HCA Ex. Q.) She also testified to the various assessment instruments utilized and her review of pertinent records in making the OCHCA’s recommendations for services.
Specifically, she testified that on April 13, 2004, Student personally reported to her past sleeping difficulties, feelings of hopelessness, difficulty completing schoolwork and lack of interest in things of importance to him. (HCA Ex. Q:7.) Student also related that a psychiatrist was treating him and receiving Prozac (HCA Ex. Q:7.), and that he was seeing an improvement in his mood, motivation, sleep, eating and interests. He also informed her that although he continued to have some depression, he was improving his grades and was able to maintain friendships. (HCA Ex. Q:7.) On the same date, Ms. Hughes-Darby also met with Mother, who informed Ms. Hughes Darby that Student continued to show symptoms of depression and sleep difficulties. However, Mother also reported signs of improved functioning since Student started on his medications and stated that Student was exhibiting normal teenage behaviors, desires and peer relationships. (HCA Ex. Q:6.) Ms. Hughes Darby met with Mother several more times, on April 20, April 27, and May 11, 2004. (HCA Ex. Q:9, Q:12, and Q:17.) At the May 11, 2004 meeting, Mother reported improvement in Student’s mood at that time. (Testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby.)
Ms. Hughes-Darby also testified that she visited Student’s school and discussed his situation with his teachers. (HCA Ex. Q:8.) She also collected and reviewed documents provided by Student’s treating psychiatrist and school, and assessment instruments completed by Mother. (HCA Ex. I, Q:11, Q:13-Q:15, and Stu. Ex. 16.) Ms. Hughes-Darby also discussed Student’s concerns with school psychologist Charlotte Smith. (HCA Ex. Q:10.) In addition, she consulted with OCHCA psychologist, An Le, who was contributing to the mental health assessment report. Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that she went over the OCHCA’s client service plan with Mother both before and at the time of the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. On both occasions, Mother agreed with the treatment services offered by the OCHCA. Ms. Hughes-Darby added that, at the time, Student was not in crisis. Instead, he was demonstrating improvement and also reporting improvement. In her opinion, the amount and type of counseling services offered at the May 2004 IEP were appropriate to meet Student’s needs.
The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby. Ms. Hughes-Darby testified credibly about the current and relevant information regarding Student’s status from April 2004 through the date of the May 2004 IEP meeting. (Footnote 17) Her notes prepared at the time of events clearly show Student’s mental health status at that time. Moreover, Student’s witnesses and documents supported Ms. Hughes-Darby’s testimony regarding Student’s improvement with respect to his depression. In fact, although Mother testified that she observed Student becoming more withdrawn she nevertheless acknowledged that she informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student was showing signs of improvement at the time of the mental health assessment. Student’s witness Dr. Johnson also admitted that her notes reflected Student’s improvement. Specifically, Dr. Johnson stated that her notes of March 2, 2004, indicate that Mother saw improvement in Student’s mood and school attendance. Further, Dr. Johnson testified that her notes of March 24, and April 21, indicated that Mother reported improvement in Student’s attendance and grades.
The only other contradictory evidence provided by Student was Dr. Davidson’s testimony that Student was “fragile” and required intensive therapy. However, the Hearing Officer finds Dr. Davidson’s opinion not persuasive. Dr. Davidson testified that she based her opinion as to the amount of counseling services necessary for Student on her review of his records and her meeting with him on only one occasion for two hours. (Footnote 18) As part of the basis of her opinions, Dr. Davidson administered an assessment to determine Student’s psychological and behavioral functioning. As part of this assessment, she asked Student to answer the questions by placing himself in the position of several months ago. When asked if such questioning was proper under the protocols of the testing instruments, Dr. Davidson was unsure if such a procedure was proper or scientifically valid. Moreover, Dr. Davidson admitted that she had never interviewed any of Student’s teachers, school counselor, or school psychologist. She also never communicated with either Dr. Dambrucia or Dr. Johnson. Dr. Davidson also admitted that she is not licensed to provide therapy or otherwise qualified to provide services under the guidelines set forth in Assembly Bill 3632, which provides for services from local mental health entities. Given Dr. Davidson’s lack of qualifications and incomplete and questionable sources of information, the Hearing Officer gives little or no weight to her opinions regarding Student’s mental status at the time and to the amount of therapy services Student required at the time of the May 2004 IEP. Instead, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Hughes-Darby’s testimony that Student required counseling services in the amount of two thirty-minute individual therapy sessions per month and one thirty-minute collateral therapy session per month at the time of the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting.
Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that Student did have a need for counseling as part of his May 28, 2004 IEP. The Hearing Officer also determines that the OCHCA offered Student appropriate amounts of individual and collateral therapy.
b. Residential Placement
Under California law, residential placement can be considered as part of an IEP meeting. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5. Upon determination that a student is emotionally disturbed, any member of the IEP team can recommend residential placement based on relevant assessment information. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(a). The IEP team is expanded to include a representative of the county mental health department. This expanded IEP team must review the assessment and determine whether residential placement is necessary for the child to benefit from educational services. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(b)(2) and (3). However, the expanded IEP team must also consider whether the child’s needs can be met with less restrictive alternatives. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(b)(1).
Student contends that the District and the OCHCA should have referred him for residential placement consideration at the time of the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. Student asserts that his depression was to such a degree that residential placement should have at least been considered. In support of its position, Student presented the same testimony of Mother regarding the alleged need for intensive therapy or counseling. Student offered no additional evidence that a referral for residential placement was required by May 28, 2004. As discussed previously, Dr. Johnson’s testimony and notes contradict Mother’s recollection. Moreover, Dr. Johnson testified that Student did not require residential placement before July or August 2004. She stated that, given his improvement, there were other less restrictive options, including therapy and medication. In her opinion, residential placement would not have been appropriate because Student’s state was not worsening.
The District and the OCHCA also assert that Student’s condition was not severe enough to require a referral for residential placement. In addition to her above testimony regarding the level of counseling services Student required, Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that residential placement “never entered her mind” for Student at the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting and that it was never discussed because it was not an issue. She stated that to consider a referral for residential placement, there must be a demonstration of dire need for this highly restrictive setting. Ms. Hughes-Darby explained that referrals for residential placement follow from homicidal or suicidal actions, repeated hospitalizations for psychologically related incidents or serious threat to the safety of oneself or others. In her opinion, residential placement reflects a student’s high risk of harm to self or others that requires twenty-four hour supervision. At the May 2004 IEP meeting, residential placement was not discussed because Student did not show any of these signs. Ms. Hughes-Darby also testified that residential placement was not appropriate for Student given his improvement up to the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. As discussed above, both Student and Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby of his improvement in mood, school motivation, sleep, eating and interest. Additionally, Dr. Johnson reported similar improvement in her clinical notes and testimony.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District and the OCHCA were not required to consider Student for residential placement at the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. First, there is no evidence that any member of the IEP team, including Student’s parents, ever requested consideration of residential placement up to the time of or during the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting. It was only after filing a request for a due process hearing that Student asserted that referral for residential placement was required in May 2004. Further, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence did not support Mother’s testimony regarding Student’s declining mental health during the time in question. As discussed above, the testimony and notes of Ms. Hughes-Darby directly contradict Mother’s testimony. In addition, Dr. Johnson’s testimony and notes do not support Mother’s recollection. Moreover, Dr. Johnson testified that Student did not require residential placement before July or August 2004. She testified residential placement would not have been appropriate because Student’s state was not worsening and there were less restrictive options at that time. The Hearing Officer finds Dr. Johnson’s testimony of significant weight because of her qualifications and professional work with Student at this time. Given the credible testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby and the expert opinion by Dr. Johnson, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that Student did not require referral for residential placement consideration at the time of the May 28, 2004 IEP meeting.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that the May 28, 2004 IEP program was designed to meet Student’s unique needs with respect to the amount and type of counseling services offered. The Hearing Officer also concludes that Student did not require a referral for residential placement at this time. This same determination supports a finding that the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Conforms to the IEP
Student did not assert any failure of the program to comport with the IEP as offered for the time period at issue.
****
In summary, the program provided by the District was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Thus, the program developed within the May 28, 2004 IEP offered Student a FAPE.
ISSUE NO 5: During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE?
Student asserts that the District has failed to offer Student a FAPE for the current 2004-2005 school year. Specifically, Student contends that the District committed a procedural violation where it failed to conduct an expanded IEP meeting since Summer 2004. In addition, Student alleges that the District has failed to make the necessary referral for residential placement for Student. Lastly, Student claims that the District has failed to offer a transition plan that would appropriately facilitate his return from Liahona to the District.
Procedural Appropriateness
Expanded IEP Meeting
Under California law, an IEP team meeting must be held under any of the following conditions: (1) a pupil has received an initial formal assessment; (2) the pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress; (3) the parent or teacher requests a meeting to develop, review, or revise the IEP; or (4) at least annual, to review the pupil’s progress. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343; see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.343 (federal equivalent regulation).
Student contends that the District should have called and held an expanded IEP meeting with the OCHCA no later than the summer of 2004. As noted above, on July 27, 2004, Mother informed the OCHCA that she wanted to terminate the OCHCA’s offered services under the May 2004 IEP. On that same day, Ms. Hughes-Darby informed the District by telephone that she wanted an IEP meeting convened to discontinue the services as requested by Mother. Unable to reach anyone at the District due to the summer recess, Ms. Hughes-Darby again telephoned the District and sent a letter to the District on September 9, 2004, requesting an IEP meeting. (HCA Ex. P.) However, to date, no IEP meeting has been scheduled or convened. As a result, Student asserts that the District has continued to deny Student a FAPE.
Student asserts that during summer 2004, Student’s mental health deteriorated and he failed to make progress towards his mental health goals. Given this downturn in progress, Student argues that the District should have held another IEP meeting to discuss these problems and consider modifications to his program. Mother testified that initially Student attended the counseling services offered by the OCHCA. However, as time passed, Student became discouraged about his therapy and did not want to return. Mother stated that Student missed several mental health counseling appointments. In June 2004, Dr. Johnson changed Student’s medications to treat his psychological disorders; however, the changes caused him to become dizzy. Student, without Dr. Johnson’s consent, stopped taking his medications. As the summer progressed, Student’s sleep habits became worse. Mother testified that Student arose around two or three in the afternoon. Moreover, she observed Student becoming very withdrawn from others. He was no longer seeing old friends and did not return to his past summer job.
In July 2004, Mother discovered two disturbing “instant messages” left by Student on the family computer. In these messages, Student described how painful his life was and stated, “I wish to die.” Mother testified that she attempted to call Charlotte Smith and Michelle Geracitano but was unable to reach them due to the summer recess. She further testified that she informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that she was looking into private therapy for Student. Mother stated that she informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student was “getting worse.” On July 27, 2004, she informed the OCHCA that she wanted to terminate the OCHCA’s services. On the same date, Ms. Hughes-Darby telephoned the District to request an IEP meeting. However, she was unable to reach anyone because of the summer recess.
Because of Student’s suicidal potential and the lack of additional services from the District or the OCHCA, Mother felt that she had no alternatives but to place Student at a residential placement. In early August 2004, Student’s parents located and arranged transportation for Student to attend Liahona. On August 13, 2004, they sent a letter to the District informing it that they had placed Student at Liahona. (Stu. Ex. 23.) Mother testified that to date, the District has yet to hold an IEP meeting to discuss Student’s residential placement or otherwise discuss his program.
The District argues that it is not obligated under the special education laws to call an IEP meeting. The District points out that to date, Mother has admitted never requesting another IEP meeting after the May 2004 IEP meeting. Further, the District is not required to hold Student’s annual IEP until May 2005. In addition, the District contends that the OCHCA never requested an IEP for the purposes of reviewing Student’s progress. Ms. Hughes-Darby testified that she requested an IEP meeting during the summer of 2004 for the purposes of discontinuing the mental health services outlined in the May 2004 IEP. However, she stated that the request for an IEP meeting was not to discuss Student’s progress but to end the OCHCA’s services because Student was out of state and no longer participating in the therapy sessions. (Footnote 19)
In addition, the District also argues that the actions of Student’s parents have hampered any attempts to call and hold the IEP meeting they are now seeking. Ms. Smith testified that she attempted to schedule an IEP meeting as soon as the school year began in September 2004. She stated that she called Mother and left messages to arrange a meeting. However, Mother did not return her calls. In addition, she testified that another school staff member called Student’s parents but was informed by them to instead speak with Student’s attorneys. Ms. Smith added that on September 14, 2004, she had faxed to Student’s attorneys a letter offering three dates and several different hours for a meeting. (Dist. Ex. 40.) However, Ms. Smith testified that she received no response to the letter. Ms. Smith stated that she followed up the letter with a call to Student’s attorney and was told by the attorneys’ office that the suggested dates would not be convenient. Ms. Smith testified that there was no cooperation from Student’s attorneys and described their actions as “stonewalling.” As a result, no IEP meeting was ever set.
As discussed above, California law requires that an IEP team meeting must take place if any of the above-noted enumerated circumstances arise. In addition, an IEP team meeting requested by a parent to review an IEP must be held within thirty days, not counting days between the pupil’s regular school sessions, terms, or days of school vacation in excess of five school days, from the date of receipt of the parent’s written request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5. Here, the Hearing Officer considers only applicable the circumstance where “the pupil demonstrates a lack of anticipated progress.” It is undisputed that as of August 13, 2004, the District was made aware of Student’s placement by his parents at Liahona. It is also undisputed that as of September 2004, the OCHCA made a written request to convene an IEP meeting to discuss Student’s mental health services. Because it is clear that Student was no longer receiving these services and not attending Estancia, the Hearing Officer finds that these circumstances indicate a potential lack of anticipated progress from his IEP. Therefore, the District should have convened an IEP meeting to discuss these problems. Given that the District was in summer recess until early September 2004, the IEP meeting should have taken place within thirty days from receipt of the OCHCA’s request. Cal. Educ. Code § 56343.5. Accordingly, the IEP meeting should have taken place no later than October 2004.
Under current law, the District could have held the IEP meeting without Student’s parents where it was unable to convince the parents that they should attend. Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g). Under section 56341.5 (g), the District should have maintained a record of its attempts including telephone calls, letters and visits to the parents’ home, to arrange a mutually agreed-upon time and place for a meeting. After making these efforts, the District could have conducted an IEP meeting to address the concerns of the OCHCA. The Hearing Officer recognizes the District’s initial attempts to meet its statutory requirements in inviting Student’s parents to participate in the IEP meeting process. However, the alleged parents’ failure to cooperate does not excuse the District’s responsibility to give notice to Student’s parents and convene an IEP meeting under the circumstances. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed a procedural error in not conducting an expanded IEP following the commencement of the 2004-2005 school year.
The failure to convene an IEP meeting caused Student to lose educational opportunity. Without the meeting, Student’s parents were not made aware of any potential programs or services available to him. For instance, there was no opportunity for the OCHCA to amend or modify its offer of mental health services to reflect Student’s current mental health needs. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District committed procedural error and denied Student a FAPE in failing to convene an IEP meeting since October 2004.
Substantive Appropriateness
Unique Needs
The parties agree that Student continued to have deficits in the areas of school attendance, organization, and completing assignments. The parties also agree that Student continued to demonstrate symptoms of depression in the summer of 2004; however they do not agree as to the extent of these symptoms and the services necessary to address his depression. Student contends that Student required residential placement as of this time. Both the District and the OCHCA disagree and assert that given the information known at the time, Student did not require residential placement to address his depression. Student also contends that the District failed to include a transition plan to facilitate Student’s return from Liahona back to a District program.
a. Referral for Residential Placement
As stated above, residential placement can be considered as part of an IEP meeting. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5. Upon determination that a student is emotionally disturbed, any member of the IEP team can recommend residential placement based on relevant assessment information. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(a). The expanded IEP team must review the assessment and determine whether residential placement is necessary for the child to benefit from educational services. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(b)(2) and (3). However, the expanded IEP team must also consider whether the child’s needs can be met with less restrictive alternatives. Cal. Govt. Code § 7572.5(b)(1).
Student contends that the District has failed to offer a FAPE for the 2004-2005 school year because it has not made a necessary referral for residential placement. Specifically, Student alleges that Student’s deteriorating condition over the summer of 2004 required the District to make a referral to the OCHCA for residential placement consideration. In support of Student’s position, Student offered the testimony of Mother regarding Student’s problems arising during Summer 2004, previously summarized above. In addition, Student proffered the testimony of Dr. Davidson. Dr. Davidson testified that by Summer 2004, Student required residential placement. She based her opinion on the fact that Student had stopped taking his prescribed medications, stopped socializing with friends, and began sleeping twelve to fifteen hours per day. Dr. Davidson also stated that his therapy was not effective. She also based her opinion on her experience working with many students in residential placement. Dr. Johnson testified similarly, stating that she was concerned that Student was potentially suicidal. She observed that Student’s current program was unable to meet his needs. Overall, Student was becoming worse despite treatment by herself and the OCHCA.
The District counters that the circumstances known to the District and the OCHCA during the summer of 2004 would not have required the District to refer Student for residential placement consideration. Ms. Hughes Darby testified that there were no indications that Student’s mental health had declined until after Mother informed her that Student had been placed at Liahona on August 9, 2004. Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that entering the summer, Student and Mother both reported that he was improving and looking forward to a “fresh start” at the new school year. She testified that Student and his family attended only three individual and three collateral therapy sessions respectively during the summer. Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that when she last saw Student on June 22, 2004, Student appeared positive and open in his discussions regarding academic problems. Ms. Hughes-Darby also recalled that Student had written a note to his mother promising not to miss more school. She considered these actions to be positive steps for Student.
After June 22, 2004, Ms. Hughes-Darby continued to schedule therapy sessions for Student and his family. However, on four occasions, Student would either not show up for the scheduled sessions or Mother would cancel these appointments. (HCA Ex. Q:33-Q:36.) Ms. Hughes-Darby strongly encouraged Mother to try to keep these appointments and also rescheduled the sessions to allow them to take place. Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that these efforts were to no avail. In addition, Ms. Hughes-Darby noted that Mother was not forthcoming in her reasons for canceling the appointments.
Ms. Hughes-Darby also testified that she was never given pertinent information about Student’s declining mental health. She stated that Mother never mentioned that Student wrote two suicidal “instant messages.” She added that Mother never informed her that Student was not taking his prescribed medications. Instead, on July 14, 2004, Mother simply told her without further explanation that Student’s family was looking into the possibility of alternative services for him. (HCA Ex. Q:34.) On July 27, 2004, Mother left a message for Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student’s family was planning to seek private therapy services only. (HCA Ex. Q:36.) Ms. Hughes-Darby attempted to contact Mother to discuss this option but was only able to leave a message. Ms. Hughes-Darby’s next communication with Mother was on August 9, 2004, wherein Mother informed her that Student had already been enrolled at Liahona.
The Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to refer Student for residential placement consideration during the summer of 2004. The Hearing Officer determines that the circumstances known to the District during Summer 2004 would not have invoked its duties to make a referral for residential placement consideration. At the outset, the Hearing Officer notes that a district’s obligation to offer a FAPE involves its knowledge of information about a student at the time an offer was made. A district can only be responsible for information it knew or should have reasonably known about the student in making its determinations regarding special education and services. Adams, 195 F.3d at 1149. Here, it is undisputed that the District was on summer recess from June 18, 2004, to September 1, 2004. (Footnote 20) Student’s IEP contemplated mental health services for the summer but did not require his RSP class during the summer. As a result, the District staff did not have any contact with Student or knowledge of the events of the summer until the beginning of the 2004-2005 school year in September 2004. Moreover, Ms. Hughes-Darby testified without contradiction that prior to the end of the school year, Student was showing improvement as represented by Student and Mother during therapy sessions. In addition, Ms. Hughes-Darby stated that she was never informed about Student’s refusal to take his prescribed medications or his instant messages reflecting suicidal ideation. These were very important pieces of information that were withheld from Ms. Hughes-Darby by Mother. Moreover, Ms. Hughes-Darby was unable to ascertain any additional information because Mother either excused or otherwise facilitated Student’s and the family’s absence from scheduled therapy sessions.
The evidence also shows that Ms. Hughes-Darby attempted to elicit information regarding these absences and Student’s status only to be told by Mother that the family would be looking into alternative treatment options for Student. Shortly thereafter, Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that she would be seeking completely private therapy services for Student. The only indication that there was something amiss was Mother’s comment to Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student was “getting worse.” However, the evidence shows that Mother was not forthcoming with any specifics regarding Student’s decline even when prompted by Ms. Hughes-Darby. Ultimately, Mother informed Ms. Hughes-Darby that Student had been placed at Liahona. Student’s parents did not consult with or otherwise give any indication that they were considering residential placement to any District or OCHCA personnel until after Student had already been enrolled at Liahona.
In addition, the Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the opinions of Dr. Davidson or Dr. Johnson that Student should have been referred and placed in residential placement by the summer of 2004. Each testified that their opinions were based on specific information about Student’s deterioration over the summer. The District was not privy to the same information. Given that prior to his unilateral placement Mother did not provide important information to the District and the OCHCA at that time, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not obligated to refer Student for residential placement. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not deny Student a FAPE by failing to refer him for residential placement consideration during the summer of 2004.
b. Transition Plan
Student alleges that the District failed to address Student’s needs by not developing a transition plan to facilitate Student’s return from Liahona. Student contends that the District should have offered a transition plan that would allow Student to return to a District-provided program. However, Student failed to offer any evidence in support of this allegation.
The District also failed to offer any evidence on this issue. It appears that the District took the position that development of a transition plan was impossible given Student’s refusal to participate in the IEP meeting process. Without cooperation from Student’s parents, the District was unable to ascertain Student’s current needs and could not develop an appropriate program.
In reviewing the available evidence, the Hearing Officer finds that Student’s parents never expressed their desire to have the District provide a transition program to facilitate Student’s return from Liahona. Neither Mother nor Father contacted the District to request a meeting to discuss this option. Instead, Student seeks an order of prospective placement for Student at Liahona for the remainder of current school year. Mother testified that she has seen a marked improvement in Student since his attendance at Liahona and wants him to complete its program and, at this time, there is no indication that Student’s parents want Student to return to a District program. In addition, no District or OCHCA witnesses testified that any request to transition Student back to a District program has been made. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the District failed to offer a transition plan for Student to return from Liahona. Moreover, there is no evidence that Student requests such a plan at this time. However, if Student seeks to return to a District placement or request such a plan from the District, Student’s parents are free to request an IEP meeting, at any time, to discuss these matters. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that a transition plan is not a need at this time.
Designed to Meet Student’s Needs a. Residential Placement
As discussed above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District was not required to refer Student for residential placement consideration during the summer of 2004. Given the information available to the District and the OCHCA, the District did not have sufficient knowledge of Student’s circumstances to invoke a referral for residential placement consideration. In addition, without the ability to hold a meaningful IEP meeting with Student’s parents, referral for residential placement consideration would not be feasible. Accordingly, Student’s current IEP from May 2004 continued to be designed to meet Student’s needs given the information known to the District.
b. Transition Plan
Under the circumstances, there is no evidence to establish that Student requires transition plan at this time. Currently, Student’s parents have expressed no interest in having Student return to a District program. Instead, it appears that they wish to have Student continue attending Liahona’s program through the end of the school year. Accordingly, given the information available to the District at this time, the District has designed a program to address his needs since his May 2004 IEP.
Calculated to Provide Some Educational Benefit
The Hearing Officer found above that the May 28, 2004 IEP was designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The evidence demonstrated that given the information available to the District, Student was offered appropriate mental health and academic services. This same determination supports a finding that the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.
Conforms to the IEP
Student only contests the sufficiency of the IEP’s counseling services and the necessity of a referral for residential placement consideration. Student did not assert any failure to comport with the IEP as offered for the time period at issue.
****
In summary, the program provided by the District was designed to meet Student’s unique needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. Thus, the program developed within the May 28, 2004 IEP continued to offer Student an appropriate program. However, the District denied Student a FAPE procedurally to the extent it has not conducted an IEP meeting since Summer 2004.
ISSUE NO 6: If the District and the OCHCA denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to remedies?
Reimbursement for Residential Placement
Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to provide a FAPE and the private placement or services are determined to be proper under the IDEA. School Comm. Of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup Sch. Dist., 31 F.3d 1489, 1496 (9th Cir. 1994). However, parents are not required to have procured the exact proper placement under the IDEA in order to be entitled to reimbursement. Alamo Heights Ind. Sch. Dist. v. State Bd. of Educ., 79 F.2d 1153, 1161 (5th Cir. 1986). The parents may receive reimbursement so long as their placement met the student’s unique needs and provides the student with educational benefit. Id.
Student contends that the District and the OCHCA’s denial of FAPE entitles Student’s parents to be reimbursed for the costs associated with Student’s placement at Liahona. As discussed above, the Hearing Officer determined that the District failed to offer Student appropriate counseling services from March 9, 2004 to May 28, 2004. In addition, the Hearing Officer found that the District failed to conduct an IEP meeting as required in October 2004. The Hearing Officer also determined that the March and May 2004 IEPs otherwise constituted appropriate offers for Student, given the information available to the District and the OCHCA at that time. Moreover, the Hearing Officer has never found that Student required residential placement to address his unique needs. (Footnote 21) Because residential placement has never been found to be a requirement to meet Student’s needs, any request for reimbursement for his program at Liahona is without support. Moreover, Student did not provide persuasive evidence that the denial of two months of counseling from the March 2004 IEP meeting to the May 2004 IEP meeting requires residential placement as a remedy. Nor did student produce persuasive evidence that residential placement is necessary to remedy the failure to conduct an IEP meeting since October 2004. Accordingly, Student’s request for reimbursement for the private placement at Liahona’s residential placement program is denied.
Prospective Placement
Cal. Educ. Code section 56505.2 prohibits the Hearing Officer from awarding prospective placement at a noncertified private school. Student seeks prospective placement at Liahona for the remainder of the current school year. However, Liahona’s director, Clay AhQuin, testified that Liahona is not certified under California law. Thus, the Hearing Officer cannot award prospective placement for Student for the remainder of the school year at Liahona and his request is denied.
IEP Meeting
Student also seeks an order that the District convene an IEP meeting to discuss how Student’s can make up lost high school credits. As noted above, the Hearing Officer found that after the District learned that Student had enrolled at Liahona, the District should have convened an IEP meeting to discuss Student’s alleged lack of progress. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer orders that the District convene an IEP meeting for the purpose of discussing Student’s current needs and developing a program to meet these needs. As part of the meeting, the IEP team shall also discuss how Student may make up high school credits. As noted above, Student’s parents could have responded positively to the District’s earlier request to schedule and IEP or requested an IEP meeting without an order from the Hearing Officer. California Education Code section 56343(c) mandates the holding of an IEP meeting at a parent’s request. Nevertheless, taking into consideration the District’s failure to schedule and properly notice the Student of an IEP in September, the Hearing Officer grants the Student’s request.
ORDER
1. The District is ordered to convene an IEP meeting within thirty days of the issuance of this Decision for the purpose of discussing Student’s current needs and developing a program to meet these needs.
2. All of Student’s other requests for relief are denied.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided.
1. From February 2003 until the assessment completed in March 2004, did the District fail in its child find duties by not assessing Student for special education eligibility? The District prevailed on this issue.
2. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District err by failing to provide Student a preliminary referral to the OCHCA for mental health services at the January 2004 student study team meeting? The District prevailed on this issue.
3. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny Student a Free Appropriate Public Education (FAPE) in its March 2004 Individualized Education Program (IEP) by:
a. Failing to include a nurse at the IEP meeting;
b. Failing to provide a mental health referral packet to OCHCA within five days of the IEP meeting; c. Failing to include appropriate present levels of performance; d. Failing to tie the IEP goals to the present levels of performance; and e. Failing to offer counseling services.
The District prevailed on issues 3(a)-(d). Student prevailed on issue 3(e).
4. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District and the OCHCA deny Student a FAPE in its May 2004 IEP by:
a. Failing to include a psychiatrist or Ph.D. psychologist at the IEP meeting; b. Failing to offer sufficient levels of mental health services; and c. Failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration?
The District and the OCHCA prevailed on this issue.
5. During the 2004-2005 school year, has the District denied Student a FAPE by:
a. Failing to conduct an expanded IEP meeting;
b. Failing to refer Student for residential placement consideration; and c. Failing to offer a transition plan to return Student from his current residential placement to a District program?
Student prevailed on Issue 5(a). The District prevailed on Issues 5(b) and (c).
6. If the District and the OCHCA denied Student a FAPE, is he entitled to the following remedies:
a. Reimbursement to Student’s parents for Student’s privately placed residential placement program; b. Prospective placement at Student’s current residential placement program; and c. Convening an IEP meeting to discuss how Student can make up lost units towards graduation?
The District and the OCHCA prevailed on this Issues 6(a) and (b). Student prevailed on Issue 6(c).
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).
Dated: March 17, 2005 My T. Huynh, Hearing OfficerCalifornia Special Education Hearing Office
On January 28, 2005, the hearing was convened and completed via telephonic conference call to accommodate the testimony of Meghan Hanna and the parties’ closing arguments.
2 In the alternative, the District moved that the Student’s issues be struck because Student failed to produce Student for testimony. However, since the motion to compel attendance could not be granted, this alternative motion was without any support and also denied.
3 As discussed above, following discussion of the parties’ respective issues, the Hearing Officer consolidated the issues to reflect only those matters that are in dispute. Ultimately, the issues raised reflected the Student’s claims that the District and/or the OCHCA failed to meet their respective obligations under State and federal special education laws. The issues listed here differ slightly in wording and organization from the issues stated by the parties. These differences were made for the purposes of clarification and analysis only and include no substantive changes. In addition, some of the issues raised by the parties were withdrawn during the course of the hearing. Accordingly, they are not included in the list of issues.
4 MOTHER and FATHER are Student’s maternal grandparents. They adopted Student and became his legal parents. Although they consider themselves Student’s grandparents, for the purpose of this Decision, MOTHER and FATHER will be referred to as Student’s mother and father respectively as a reflection of their legal status.
5 Due to absences, Student’s academic testing, unlike the cognitive and social/emotional testing, were not completed until after the completion of the District’s assessment report. However, there is no dispute that Student’s scores were an accurate reflection of his academic ability.
6 The IEP also offered transition services related to post-high-school employment. These services were not in dispute.
7 The CSP described the two therapies as, “at minimum.” The parties understood that “at minimum” reflected the lowest level of services available from the OCHCA as part of its CSP. Ms. Hughes-Darby testified that the OCHCA was willing to offer additional amounts of therapy at the request of Student or his parents. The OCHCA asserted that this lowest level of services was appropriate for Student. As will be discussed below, Student challenges the appropriateness of the CSP’s services at the amounts offered.
8 Ms. Hanna holds a master’s degree and pupil personnel services credential in counseling. Prior to 2004-2005 school year, she served as Tewinkle’s school counselor for two years. Before becoming a school counselor, Ms. Hanna served as a student teacher for a resource specialist program classroom for two years. She testified that she was short six units to complete her special education degree but instead chose to focus on counseling rather than complete her special education degree.
9 Although Student’s claim extends to March 2004, it is undisputed that the District began to assess Student after the January 23, 2004 SST meeting and conducted an IEP meeting on March 9, 2004. Student did not raise any concerns regarding the timeliness of the assessment process once it commenced. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer’s decision reflects the disputed period of time up until January 23, 2004, the date at which Student’s parents consented to an assessment plan.
10 Ms. Ferda earned a bachelor’s degree in physical education with a minor in English. She holds a CLEAR teaching credential and has been an English teacher for ten years. She also serves as Estancia’s girls’ athletic director. For sixteen years, Ms. Ferda also was a full-time substitute teacher in various subjects, including special education.
11 Ms. Geracitano earned bachelor’s degrees in psychology and biology. She also earned a master’s degree in school counseling. Ms. Geracitano has served as a District school counselor for the past five years.
12 Dr. Davidson earned a B.A. in elementary education and a teaching credential. She holds an M.A. in counseling and a school psychology credential. She earned her Ed.D. degree in 1992. Prior to entering private practice, Dr. Davidson served as the director of special education in Tustin, California. She is currently a licensed educational psychologist in private practice.
13 Furthermore, the amended IDEA includes additional requirements for the provision of a FAPE that are not in dispute in the present case, such as the obligation to enable the child to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum. See, e.g., 34 C.F.R. § 300.347(a).
14 Ms. Longfellow holds a bachelor’s degree in home economics. She also earned a master’s degree in counseling. She has taught special education for twenty-one years.
15 Dr. Johnson earned a medical doctor degree in 1987. She is board-certified in two disciplines: psychiatry and neurology, and child and adolescent psychiatry. Since completion of her fellowship, Dr. Johnson has been practicing in the field of child and adolescent psychiatry since 1991. (Stu. Ex. 29.)
16 Collateral therapy services are also known as “family” therapy services. They involve meetings with a client’s family members and the client’s therapist. (Testimony of Ms. Hughes-Darby.)
17 Ms. Hughes-Darby is a qualified mental health professional and has served as a licensed clinical social worker since the early 1980s. She is licensed in two states and has been working in the fields since 1977. Over the past six years alone, she has conducted hundreds of assessments and made recommendations accordingly.
18 Dr. Davidson testified that she met with Student for the first time on Friday, January 21, 2004, four days into the due process hearing.
19 The District concedes that the OCHCA agency requested an expanded IEP meeting to perform a residential placement assessment for Student in its letter dated January 11, 2005. (Testimony of Victor Cota.) However, the District points out that as of the time of the due process hearing, it is still within its statutory timeline to call and hold that meeting. (Testimony of Ms. Smith.)
20 The parties stipulated as to the start and end dates of the school years. 21 Although the District failed to offer appropriate counseling services from March 9, 2004 to May 28, 2004, the, Student did not seek compensatory remedies or reimbursement for counseling services to address this denial of FAPE. Instead, Student’s exclusively requested reimbursement for costs associated with his residential placement at Liahona and continued prospective placement there.
