California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 7, 2003

Student v. San Marcos Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2188-02 · Hearing Officer Jodi L. Clary

San Marcos Unified offered a preschooler with autism a FAPE; parents denied reimbursement for in-home ABA program.

District prevailed on all issues

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The District filed an earlier due process request on April 15, 2002 to reassess without consent. It withdrew that request after the father signed the assessment plan. No later history is noted.

Summary

The parents of a preschool boy eligible for special education under autism filed for due process against San Marcos Unified School District. When he turned three, the District offered a special day class at Twin Oaks Elementary School taught by Cara Ogle. The class used applied behavior analysis (ABA) and came with a 1:1 aide and speech services. The parents never enrolled him. Instead they paid for an in-home ABA program, first through Coyne and Associates and later through the Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention, at up to 35 hours a week. They sought reimbursement for January 2001 through June 2002, when the family moved away.

The Hearing Officer found that the District's October 2000 assessment was done by qualified staff and that the PEP-R was given properly. The assessment covered all areas of suspected disability, including speech and language. Standardized testing was not required. The District made four offers between November 2000 and December 2001. Each was found to meet the student's needs and to be reasonably calculated to give some educational benefit under Rowley. The offers grew over time, reaching 24 classroom hours plus 11 in-home transition hours. The Hearing Officer rejected the claim that ABA had to be delivered at home. Socialization was one of the student's needs, so the class was the least restrictive environment. Claimed notice and participation defects did not deny a FAPE. Because a FAPE was offered, all reimbursement was denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO handled an early-intervention dispute over a district ABA classroom versus a parent-chosen in-home Lovaas program. Under the Rowley standard, the Hearing Officer treated the student's social-skills needs and the least restrictive environment preference as reasons to favor a classroom with peers. Because a FAPE was offered, reimbursement was denied.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue 1. Did the District's assessment of October 19, 2000, properly assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?

    The assessors were qualified and gave the PEP-R as its manual allows. Standardized testing is not required, all areas of suspected disability including speech and language were assessed, and the parent signed an assessment plan.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2. Did the District deny Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 3, 2000, through June 14, 2002?

    The offers of November 30, 2000, January 25, 2001, April 3, 2001 and December 17, 2001 for an ABA-based special day class with a 1:1 aide and related services met Student's unique needs, were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and were in the LRE. Claimed notice and participation defects caused no denial of FAPE.

  3. Issue 3. Are Student's parents entitled to reimbursement for educational services related to Student's in-home program from January 2001 through June 14, 2002?

    Because the District offered a FAPE, the parents were not entitled to reimbursement for the Coyne and Lovaas in-home programs, private speech and language therapy, OT, or other services.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Student's requests for relief denied in their entirety.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith; Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Burlington; Daniel R. v. State Board of Education; Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist.; Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16; Cal. Educ. Code § 56320; Cal. Educ. Code § 56325; Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g)

People named in the decision

  • Jackie Bachman, director of special education, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Marjorie Frye, school psychologist and assessor, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Cara Ogle, special day class teacher and assessor, San Marcos Unified School District, Twin Oaks Elementary School
  • Jane DeLeeuw, speech and language specialist and assessor, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Hilary Mayo, speech and language pathologist, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Lola Harlan, program specialist, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Kathie Iacuaniello, adapted physical education specialist, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Shannon O'Brien, registered occupational therapist, witness for District, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Barbara Ostrin, teacher whose class was offered for mainstreaming, witness for District, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Julie Fisher, Ph.D., clinical psychologist and behavior specialist, witness for District, San Marcos Unified School District
  • Paul Alan Dores, Ph.D., psychologist, expert witness for District
  • Mitchel D. Perlman, Ph.D., clinical forensic psychologist, expert witness for Student
  • Melissa Katz, psychologist and case manager, private ABA provider, Coyne and Associates
  • Paul Coyne, private ABA provider, Coyne and Associates
  • Scott Cross, director of clinical services, private ABA provider, Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Miriam Bakcht-Lutbog, case manager and San Diego site manager, private ABA provider, Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Erin Cares, senior instructor, private ABA provider, Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE)
  • Karen Lewis Searey, private speech/language pathologist
  • Melanie Siegel, private speech and language pathologist, San Diego Children's Hospital and Health Center
  • Amy Siegel, Early Start education specialist, San Diego Regional Center
  • Tami Elan, assistant to Student's counsel

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in San Marcos, California, on September 2-5, 9-12 and 17, 2003. Student (Studentor Student ) was represented at hearing by attorney Ralph O. Lewis, Jr. Also present on Student ’s behalf were his parents, and for much of the hearing, Tami Elan (assistant to Mr. Lewis). The San Marcos Unified School District (District) was represented at hearing by attorney Maria E. Gless from the law firm of Best, Best and Krieger. Angelica Daftary of Best, Bestand Krieger was also present on just the first day of hearing. Also present on the District’s behalf was Jackie Bachman, director of special education.

The Student called the following witnesses: Marjorie Frye, school psychologist for the District; Mitchel D. Perlman, Ph.D., clinical forensic psychologist; Cara Ogle, special day class teacher for the District; Hilary Mayo, speech and language pathologist for the District; Lola Harlan, program specialist for the District; Melissa Katz, psychologist and case manager for Coyne and Associates; Scott Cross, director of clinical services Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE); Miriam Bakcht-Lutbog, case manager and San Diego site manager, LIFE; Erin Cares, senior instructor, LIFE; and his parents.

The District called the following witnesses: Paul Alan Dores, Ph.D., psychologist; Kathie Iacuaniello, assistive physical education (APE) specialist for the District; Shannon O’Brien, registered occupational therapist; Jackie Bachman, director of special education for the District; and Julie Fisher, Ph.D., clinical psychologist.

Oral and documentary evidence was received. After the parties’ written closing arguments were received on October 14, 2003, the record was closed and the matter submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the last day of hearing, Student ’s attorney moved to preclude the testimony of Dr. Paul Dores in its entirety. Student argued that Dr. Dores’ testimony was irrelevant because his testimony was based on his observation of Cara Ogle’s special day class in June 2003, over two years after it was offered by the San Marcos Unified School District as a placement for Student. Student argued that because Ms. Ogle’s class had been physically moved to a different classroom, Dr. Dores had no knowledge of the configuration of the classroom that had been offered for Student’s placement in December 2000 and therefore could not testify as to the placement offered. The District argued that the classroom visited by Dr. Dores in 2003 was substantially the same as the 2000 classroom offered to Student. The District further argued that the placement offer involved more than just the physical classroom and included one-on-one aide services, Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA) techniques, and designated related services (DIS). The District also argued that Dr. Dores’ testimony covered topics other than just Cara Ogle’s classroom.

The Hearing Officer denied the motion to preclude Dr. Dores’ testimony in its entirety. Dr. Dores’ lack of knowledge of the physical attributes of the classroom in 2000 and 2001 will be considered in weighing Dr. Dores’ testimony.

ISSUES PRESENTED FOR HEARING1 (Footnote 1)

1. Did the District’s assessment of October 19, 2000, properly assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?

2. Did the District deny Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 3, 2000, through June 14, 2002?

3. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for educational services related to Student’s in-home program from January 2001 through June 14, 2002?

BACKGROUND FACTS

Student is a five-year-nine-month-old student (born [date redacted]) who resided within the boundaries of the San Marcos Unified School District until approximately June 14, 2002. He has been identified as eligible for special education and related services under the category of autism. Student’s parents arranged a private in-home program for Student that started in January 2001. But for this private placement, Student would have entered the public school system at age three (December 3, 2000) and would have attended Twin Oaks Elementary School. He and his family moved out of the District approximately June 14, 2002.

Student was first identified as a child with autism in August or September 2000. His mother had had three previous miscarriages and suffered complications during Student’s gestation. Student reached developmental milestones at a normal rate until age twelve months, when he lost all the words he had learned. By age two, Student had not developed speech and was developing repetitive behaviors and fixations.

Student’s parents took him to the San Diego Children’s Hospital and Health Center (CHHC) for a developmental assessment on September 11, 2000. On September 12, 2000, Student’s mother contacted the San Marcos Unified School District and requested an evaluation for special education and related services, which would begin when Student turned three years old on December 3, 2000.

The District conducted its assessment on October 19, 2000. The assessment was performed by a transdisciplinary team composed of Marjorie Frye, credentialed school psychologist; Cara Ogle, credentialed SDC teacher; and Jane DeLeeuw, licensed speech and language specialist. Julie Fisher, psychologist and behavioral specialist, was also present at the assessment. Student was brought to TOES by his parents and entered the classroom with the speech therapist, school psychologist, classroom teacher and behavior specialist present. Student avoided proximity with the examiners, and their attempts to get him to engage with toys were met with resistance. The testimony at hearing of Marjorie Frye and Cara Ogle confirmed that they experienced great difficulty in engaging Student in any way, and especially in performing the testing protocols. The results of the assessment were based on observations, parent reporting, and Student’s limited response to testing. Student’s testing lasted approximately one to one and one-half hours.

The District administered three tests during its assessment. One of the tests used by the District was the Psychoeducational Profile-Revised (PEP-R). The PEP-R assesses seven developmental areas to determine the subject’s strengths and weaknesses. The District also administered the Preschool Evaluation Scale, which is completed by observation and with parental input. The District lastly administered the Childhood Autism Rating Scale (CARS), which was completed with input from Student’s mother.

Marjorie Frye testified that she wrote a report dated November 30, 2000, based on the assessments performed and observations of the transdisciplinary team. At page two of the report, Ms. Frye writes: “[r]esults are considered a valid measure of his current levels of functioning, but because of his young age, they should not be considered predictive of his future levels of success. Because of selective motivation, his aloofness and resistance to direction, results may be a low estimate of his scholastic potential.”

The team concluded that Student suffered from mild to moderate delays in communication, gross and fine motor abilities, cognition and problem solving, socialization and play, and self-help/daily living skills. The team determined that Student met the educational criteria for special education under the category of autism. The team recommended an intense, highly structured program. The team also recommended that the IEP team should consider all information in determining an appropriate educational program. The team further recommended assessments in adapted physical education (APE), and occupational therapy (OT) should be conducted. Lastly, the team recommended that the IEP team “develop an educational program that would build skills for verbal and non-verbal imitation and following directions. [T]he educational plan should also build receptive and expressive vocabulary, preacademic concepts and skills for independent feeding and toileting.”

At about the same time, Student participated in the following evaluations: speech and language consultation through the San Diego Regional Center on October 20, 2000; speech and language consultation through CHHC on November 2, 2000; and a diagnostic evaluation at the Center for Autism & Related Disorders, Inc. (CARD) on November 13, 2000.

A confusing diagnostic picture emerged from the early testing. The assessments reported Student to have anywhere from a low probability of autism to mild to moderate autism. However, the testing was consistent in finding that Student suffered from the effects of a severe language delay due to receptive and expressive language deficits, and deficits in auditory processing secondary to autism. The assessors consistently recommended intensive behavioral intervention and speech therapy.

The District held an initial individualized educational program (IEP) team meeting on November 30, 2000. The team determined that Student was eligible for special education services under the category of autism. On the basis of its assessment, the District offered the following placement for Student: eighteen hours per week of intensive behavioral intervention at Twin Oaks Elementary School (TOES) in Cara Ogle’s special day class (SDC), with speech consultative services to take place twice per month for fifteen minutes a session. Ms. Ogle’s program is based on the techniques of Applied Behavioral Analysis (ABA), including discrete trial training (DTT), pivotal response training (PRT), TEAACH, and other language-based systems. The schedule for the placement was to be adjusted to allow Student’s participation for three hours per week in the “Mommy and Me” class (he and his mother had been attending since he was age two), as well as his participation in speech therapy at CHHC. Student’s mother signed the IEP agreeing with the goals and objectives and the placement and service recommendations. Student’s father had also attended the IEP team meeting but did not sign, believing that his signature was not necessary. The parents did not provide oral or written objections to the IEP contents.

Student was to start TOES on Monday, December 4, 2000. His parents did not enroll him in the program, and he has never attended school in the San Marcos Unified School District. On December 6, 2000, Student began participating in the speech and language program at CHHC. On January 2, 2001, Student began receiving Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) services consisting of discrete trial training at home, the services delivered by Coyne and Associates. Initially, Coyne provided services at a level of ten hours per week. By March 26, 2001, the level had increased to 23 hours per week, and by October 2001 services were 35 hours per week. On October 22, 2001, Student’s parents switched his service provider to the Lovaas Institute For Early Intervention (LIFE). Student continued to receive 35 hours per week of ABA instruction at home from LIFE at least until his family moved out of the District on June 14, 2002. Student was placed in a kindergarten class for typically developing children in July 2002, in a different school district.

Between December 3, 2000, and June 14, 2002, the District continued to offer a placement for Student in the District. The District initiated IEP meetings for January 25, 2001, April 3, 2001, and December 17, 2001, to discuss Student’s progress in his in-home ABA program and to discuss the district’s offer of a free appropriate public education (FAPE).

By January 19, 2001, according to father’s testimony, relations between the Parents and the District were antagonistic. Father contacted the District by telephone call on that day, to explore reimbursement and funding for the Coyne and Associates in-home ABA program. At one point (perhaps by phone call on January 24, 2001), Father told the District to refrain from contacting him again unless the District was willing to fund the in-home program. The District advised Father by phone and in the IEP team meeting notes that the District was offering a FAPE, and should the parents place Student privately it would be at their own cost. Father testified at hearing that all conversations degenerated into an argument over reimbursement.

During the December 17, 2001 IEP team meeting (the annual IEP), the District presented a new assessment plan and requested parental consent to reassess Student. Consent was denied. Throughout this time, Student’s parents held steadfast to their position that Student was not ready to attend school and that they did not want Student to attend class with disabled children. They held fast to their belief that Student must have an intensive behavioral intervention program at home to acquire the prerequisite skills to allow him to be placed in a classroom with typically developing peers.

The Student’s parents did not sign and return the December 17, 2001 reassessment plan. The District filed a request for due process hearing on April 15, 2002, to seek an order allowing the District to reassess Student. The hearing was scheduled for May 8 and 9, 2002. Father signed the assessment plan on May 7, 2002, which was faxed to District’s counsel on May 8, with a request to cancel the hearing. The District withdrew the request for due process. Father did not check the box on the form that indicated that he agreed to present his child for assessment. The District attempted to contact the Student’s parents to schedule the assessment on June 5, 6 and 7, 2002. An observation had been set for the parent’s home on June 10, 2002. Father contacted the District by letter dated June 7, 2002, advising the District that the family would be moving out of the District (“next week”) and canceling the June 10, 2002 observation.

On September 27, 2002 Student requested a due process hearing to address his contention that the District had not offered him a FAPE and to request that his parents be reimbursed for his in-home program.

CONTENTIONS

Student contends that the District failed to offer him a FAPE in the least restrictive environment. He contends that he was inappropriately assessed in October 2000. He contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability. Student further contends that the District failed to consider the assessment reports of others. Student contends that because the assessments were inappropriate, the current levels of functioning (present levels of educational performance) were inaccurate, the goals and objectives were inappropriate, and the District’s placement was inappropriate. Student also contends that the District failed to properly notice the November 30, 2000 IEP, failed to properly conduct the IEP meeting, failed to properly notice an IEP meeting of January 25, 2001 and again on April 3, 2001, and that his parents and their representatives were not allowed to participate in the development of the IEPs on these dates.

The District contends that it properly assessed Student, assessed him in all areas of suspected disability, properly developed an IEP and made an appropriate offer of placement and related services. The District contends that Student was offered a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

1. Did the District’s assessment of October 19, 2000, properly assess Student in all areas of suspected disability?

Individual assessment of a special education student’s educational needs must precede placement. The tests that are given to a child as a component of the assessment must have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used, must be administered by trained and knowledgeable personnel, and must be administered in accordance with the test protocols or any instructions provided by the producers of such tests. 20 U.S.C.§ 1414(b)(3)(B), 34 C.F.R. § 300.532(c)(1); Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

Furthermore, (a) testing and assessment materials must be selected and administered so as to not be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory, and must (b) meet all of the following: (1) [be in] student’s primary language… (c) be tailored to assess specific areas of educational need and not just provide a single IQ, (d) be selected to assess aptitude, achievement level, or other factors, not impairments. Moreover, (e) no single procedure is to be used as the sole criterion to determine whether a pupil is an individual with exceptional need and to determine the appropriate program for the pupil… (f) [the child is] to be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language, intelligence, academic performance, communication, self-help, orientation and mobility, career/vocational abilities and interest, social and emotional status, and a development history is to be obtained where appropriate; (g) and testing is to be conducted by persons knowledgeable of that disability, attention to be given to the unique educational needs, including, specialized services, materials and equipment. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320.

Student contends he was not properly assessed because the District’s assessors were not qualified to perform the assessments and failed to administer the tests properly and failed to do standardized testing. Student also contends that the District failed to assess him in all areas of suspected disability because the District did not conduct standardized speech and language testing. Student lastly contends that the District did not send the parents an assessment plan which he contends is a fatal procedural defect resulting in a denial of FAPE. The District contends that it properly assessed Student and that its assessors were qualified. The District also contends that if any procedural defects occurred, such defects did not result in the loss of educational opportunity.

Qualifications of the Assessors

Student contended that the assessors were not qualified to administer the tests given. Marjorie Frye and Cara Ogle were called as witnesses by Student and closely examined on their credentials, experience, training and expertise. Marjorie Frye has been a credentialed school psychologist for twenty-three years and has held a Clear California Pupil Personnel Services Credential since 1969. She testified at great length to attending seminars and conferences, workshops and in-service training sessions regarding the education of disabled children and particularly autistic children. She is well-versed in ABA techniques and in delivering instruction via DTT. 2 (Footnote 2)

Cara Ogle has been a credentialed special education teacher since 1980. She has held a specialist permit in special education (severely handicapped) since May 1995. She received a master’s degree in special education in May 1998. Under detailed examination, Ms. Ogle testified to attending an impressive array of seminars, workshops and conferences given by the leaders in the field of autism, and she demonstrated a great depth of knowledge and expertise in educating children with autism. She holds a “supervisor’s certificate” in delivering DTT. She is preparing to take the Behavior Analyst Certificate examination given by the National Board of Behavior Analysts. She is eligible for testing for the certificate because of her graduate level study and mentored experience and must only pass the exam to be certificated. Both Ms. Ogle and Ms. Frye have participated in assessing children for special education eligibility for many years. Jane DeLeeuw did not testify at hearing. Student did not challenge Ms. DeLeeuw’s qualifications.

Student did not present evidence regarding the qualifications required to administer the Preschool Evaluation Scale or CARS. Student did not present persuasive testimony that any of the assessors were not qualified to do the assessments. Ms. Ogle and Ms. Frye have impressive credentials and experience. The Hearing Officer finds that Ms. Ogle and Ms. Frye are trained personnel qualified to administer the PEP-R, the Preschool Evaluation Scale and the CARS as required under Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(b)(3). The Hearing Officer finds that both are persons knowledgeable of autism and capable of giving attention to the unique needs of a child with autism and thus meet the qualifications required under Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(g). Furthermore, the assessment team was completed by a speech and language specialist and a behavioral specialist who contributed to the testing and recommendations. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the assessment team was well-qualified to do the assessment.

Were the tests administered in accordance to the test manuals?

Student contends that the PEP-R was not administered in accordance with the test manuals. Specifically, Student contends that the assessors did not practice on typically developing children prior to testing STUDENT. Student also contends that the assessors modified the administration of the PEP-R so that the results were not valid. Student does not contend that the Preschool Evaluation Scale or CARS were administered improperly. Therefore, these two tests will not be addressed by the Hearing Officer.

Ms. Frye credibly testified that she has administered the PEP-R many times and is familiar with the manuals on how to administer the test. She and Ms. Ogle testified that she did not practice giving the PEP-R on typically developing children prior to testing STUDENT. Although the PEP-R manual suggests giving practice tests to typically developing children if the examiner is not familiar with testing children, such practice is not set forth as a requirement of a valid test.3 (Footnote 3) Ms. Frye also testified that the PEP-R was capable of modification and allowed some flexibility in using materials and toys available (instead of in the testing suitcase) that stimulate the subject to become engaged in the testing. Ms. Frye testified that as difficult as Student was to get engaged in the testing, the assessment team used whatever materials in the classroom that Student was attracted to.4 (Footnote 4) Ms. Frye testified that she performed the imitation, perception, fine motor, hand-eye coordination portions of the PEP-R and teamed with Jane DeLeeuw to conduct the cognitive performance and cognitive verbal portions of the test. Ms. Frye testified that she filled out the protocol forms provided by the originators of the PEP-R in accordance with the instructions.

Ms. Ogle testified that she participated in Student’s PEP-R testing by presenting portions of the test, such as color matching. She testified that the assessment team reviewed the tests and results, and developed the recommendations and Marjorie Frye wrote the report.

The District’s assessment team cannot be called “new examiners” and certainly have substantial experience testing children. The PEP-R manual allows modification and flexibility in administration. The manual stated the PEP-R administration would take forty-five minutes to one and one-half hours. The manual did not require practice on typically developing children.

The Hearing Officer finds that the PEP-R was administered in conformance with the instruction provided by the test manual.

Is the PEP-R valid for the specific purpose for which it was used?

Student contends that the PEP-R is not standardized, and therefore does not provide sufficient information to develop accurate present levels of performance or to develop appropriate goals and objectives and is thus not valid for the purpose for which it was used.

Student did not provide any authority for his contention that assessments must use standardized testing. Cal. Educ. Code § 56320 does not contain such a requirement. Moreover, Dr. Perlman testified that the PEP-R is somewhat standardized, but is not standardized to a “typically developing population.” Furthermore, Dr. Perlman attempted to give Student several standardized tests and testified that Student was unable to complete the tests.5 (Footnote 5)

Marjorie Frye and Cara Ogle both credibly testified that the PEP-R is a play-based assessment tool and is therefore useful in testing pre-verbal children. The test is the only one not based on parent interview and thus works as a good corroborative measure. The District assessors used the PEP-R in conjunction with the CARS, which is a parent interview test. The assessors also relied on parent reports and their own observations (Preschool Evaluation Scale) in making conclusions and recommendations. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified that the PEP-R is a valid test for determining developmental progress.

Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle stressed that the PEP-R was a starting point. At the time that Student came to the District, he had not yet had any early intervention. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified that they did not have any information about Student and that the parents did not provide them with medical records or other evaluations.6 (Footnote 6) It was undisputed that Student had severely delayed communication skills. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified that their first concern was to obtain some measure of “instructional control” over STUDENT. In October 2000, Student did not respond to instruction and responded inconsistently to “no.” Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified that they needed to spend more time with Student, that a one-hour or two-hour assessment would not provide all the information they would like but would provide a starting point. Once Student came into the District, they would be able to adjust his educational program to his unique needs. Because Student was just entering the District, they would provide him an interim placement, which would be reviewed within thirty days pursuant to California law.7 (Footnote 7) Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle credibly testified that the assessment provided them sufficient information to make an educational placement and that the placement would be reviewed and adjusted frequently during Student’s first year with them.

Interestingly, Coyne and Associates administered the PEP-R to Student three times during the period of January to October 2001 as a measure of Student’s progress. Student ’s expert, Dr. Mitchel Perlman, testified that he strongly considered using the PEP-R with Student. The PEP-R was developed to determine areas of need, especially in areas of the population that are difficult to test. According to Dr. Perlman, the test is helpful to develop an educational plan, determine areas to work on, and identify the student’s needs. Dr. Perlman feels that the test “translates” into what tasks will help the student meet his goals and objectives. Dr. Perlman also testified that he did not use the PEP-R because the battery of tests that he did attempt would cover the information developed from the PEP-R. Dr. Perlman noted that he already knew a “pretty decent amount” about Student.

Student did not dispute the use of the Preschool Evaluation Scale or CARS and the Hearing Officer will not address these tests further.

The Hearing Officer finds that the testing (PEP-R, Preschool Evaluation Scale and CARS) was valid for the purposes for which it was used, for determining eligibility, present levels of performance and for developing goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer further finds that the testing was valid for use in determining an initial placement. Standardized testing is not a requirement of the IDEA or California law.

Was Student assessed in all areas of suspected disability?

Student’s parents informed the District that he had been diagnosed as a child with autism. He was reported to suffer from severe language delays, he did not engage with other children or people and he did not show appropriate toy play. He also had serious problems with attention.

Under Cal. Educ. Code Section 56320(f), a child is to be assessed in all areas related to the suspected disability, including, health and development, vision, hearing, motor abilities, language, intelligence, academic performance, communication, self-help, orientation and mobility, career/vocational abilities and interest, social and emotional status. The code section also states that a development history may be appropriate.

The District’s PEP-R testing addressed imitation (verbal and motorically, precursor to language and behavior), perception (visual and auditory sensory modalities), fine motor, gross motor, eye-hand coordination, cognitive performance and cognitive verbal skills. The Preschool Evaluation Scale measured large and small muscle skills, cognitive thinking, expressive language, social/emotional skills and self help skills. The CARS is developed to test how the subject relates to people, as well as the following skills: imitation, adaptation to change, communication, intellectual response and listening and visual responses. Career and vocational interests were not explored since Student was only three years old. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified that attention was a part of all the testing and of concern. The District took health and development information from Student’s parents. Student was described as healthy. His vision and hearing appeared to be normal by parent report. Accordingly, the testing conducted by the District addressed all areas set forth in Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).

Student contends that the District failed to assess him for a speech and language disability. Student further contends that the District should have conducted standardized speech and language testing. While Student was not specifically identified as eligible for special education as a child with a speech and language disability, the assessment plan signed October 19, 2000, by Student’s mother included speech and language testing. The PEP-R, Preschool Evaluation Scale and CARS all have portions directly related to speech and language and communication. The assessment team included a speech and language specialist who observed STUDENT. Because of his severe communication delays, standardized testing was difficult or impossible. The testing done by the District encompassed communication, speech and language and sufficiently identified this area of need. There is no requirement that the testing must be standardized to satisfy the legal requirements of the IDEA and California law.

The Hearing Officer finds that the testing done by the District addressed all areas of suspected disability as required by Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).8 (Footnote 8)

Were the parents provided an assessment plan?

The parents were presented with an assessment plan upon arrival at TOES on October 19, 2000. Student’s mother signed the plan. The Student ’s argument on this point is without merit.

Conclusion

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the assessment was conducted by trained and knowledgeable personnel in conformance with the testing protocols provided by the test developers and that the testing was valid for the purposes for which it was used. The Hearing Officer finds that the District properly assessed Student in all areas of suspected disability and that the parents were provided an assessment plan.

2. Did the District deny Student a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) from December 3, 2000, through June 14, 2002?

Pursuant to the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State special education law, all children with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE) that emphasizes special education and related services designed to meet their unique needs. 20 U.S.C. § 1400(d)(1)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56000. The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to a child at no charge to his or her parent or guardian, meet the standards of the State educational agency, include appropriate preschool, elementary, or secondary school education, and are provided in conformity with the child’s individualized education program (IEP). Such special education and related services must be tailored to meet the unique needs of the child with a disability by means of an IEP. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(8); Polk v. Central Susquehanna Intermediate Unit 16, 853 F.2d 171, 173. Special education law also requires that a child with a disability be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A).

In Board of Educ. of the Hendrick Hudson Central School Dist. v. Rowley (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S. Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court determined that a child’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the child with some educational benefit to satisfy the IDEA, but that the school district is not required to provide the child with the best education available or instruction and services that maximize the child’s abilities. Id. at 198-200. The Court held that a school district is required to provide a “basic floor of opportunity” consisting of access to specialized instruction and related services that are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child. Id. at 201. Consequently, an appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “ some” benefit. Walczak v. Florida Union Free Sch. Dist., 142 F.3d 119, 130 (2nd Cir. 1997).

To constitute an offer of FAPE, the IDEA requires that the District’s placement must (1) be designed to address Student’s unique educational needs, (2) be reasonably calculated to provide him some educational benefit, (3) comport with his IEP. The placement must also provide an education in the least restrictive environment (LRE).

Over the relevant time period, the District held four IEP team meetings. As a result of each of these meetings, the District made a placement offer to Student. Because the offers varied each time, the Hearing Officer will address each IEP and each offer separately below.

Was the District’s offer of November 30, 2000, designed to address Student’s unique educational needs?

Student’s Unique Needs

To determine if the District’s offer was designed to address Student’s unique needs, the Hearing Officer must first determine those needs. The evidence is overwhelming that, as of October 2000, Student had severe language and communication deficits. He also suffered severe attentional problems. The parties do not dispute that Student suffered these deficits. As a result of the October 19, 2000 assessment, the District’s assessment team concluded that Student had mild to moderate delays in communication, gross and fine motor abilities, cognition and problem solving, socialization and play and self-help/daily living skills. While not specifically addressed in the assessment report, the team commented throughout the report about their difficulty in getting and keeping Student’s attention. At hearing, Ms. Ogle, Ms. Frye, and Student’s parents testified that Student had severe attentional problems in October 2000. The assessment report also noted that Student had delays in gross and fine motor abilities and suggested further testing to determine if adapted physical education or occupational therapy would be necessary. The team recommended instruction in an intense, highly structured program using Applied Behavior Analysis (ABA) techniques.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that as of October 17, 2000, Student had unique needs in the following areas: communication, both verbal and pre-verbal, attention, socialization, and self-help/daily living skills. Student also had unique needs in gross and fine motor abilities. The Hearing Officer finds that Student needed an intense, highly structured behavioral intervention program to address these needs. Because evaluations in APE and OT had not yet been accomplished, the Hearing Officer is unable to find that APE and OT services were required as of November 30, 2000.

The IEP

The District’s original offer of placement and services, as presented at the November 30, 2000 IEP team meeting, was for eighteen hours per week of intensive behavior intervention in Cara Ogle’s SDC class utilizing ABA techniques and speech consult twice a month for 15 minutes. The offer also took into account the parents’ desire that Student continue attending the “Mommy and Me” program and continue participating in the speech and language therapy at Children’s Hospital. The offer included the services of a one-to-one aide.

The Student contends that this IEP team meeting was not properly noticed. The evidence showed that the parents were provided sufficient notice and attended the meeting. If the notice was not technically to the letter of the law, no prejudice resulted to the parents, who attended and participated in the meeting.

Present Levels of Performance

Student contends that the offer of November 30, 2000 is inappropriate because the “Present Levels of Educational Performance” contained in the District’s IEP team report of November 11, 2000, were entirely incorrect. Student ’s parents contend that the present levels were incorrect because the assessment did not give enough information to determine present levels. The Hearing Officer has determined above that the assessment was appropriate. Moreover, the District witnesses testified that they also relied on parent report and their own observations to establish present levels.9 (Footnote 9) The District witnesses testified that the present levels were the best they could write with the information they had and that the present levels provided a starting point. Student would be reevaluated after being in the District for thirty days when the District would have a better idea of his levels of performance.

Student’s mother signed the November 30, 2000 IEP and initialed the areas indicating she received a copy of the procedural safeguards, participated in developing the IEP, agreed with the goals and objectives, agreed with the placement and agreed with the service recommendations. Thus it would appear, that as of November 30, 2000, there was no dispute as to Student’s present levels of performance. Student did not withdraw consent to the IEP nor did he submit any objections to the contents of the IEP.

As of November 30, 2000, the evidence shows that four evaluations existed other than the District’s assessment. Although the District did not have the benefit of these reports, the reports corroborate the District’s conclusions. The Developmental Evaluation done by CHHC on September 11, 2000, the speech and language consultation of October 20, 2000 by CHHC, the speech-language pathology evaluation of November 2, 2000 by CHHC and the CARD report of November 13, 2000, all reported that Student had receptive and expressive language and communication delays; deficits in self-help skills and social skills and recommended intensive behavior intervention. The present levels of educational performance found in the November 30, 2000 IEP are consistent with Student’s performance levels as reported by CHHC and CARD. For instance, the District reports that Student had a range of vocalizations, said single words occasionally but inconsistently understands “no.” CHHC reported similar levels of verbal functioning and lack of understanding of instruction in October and November 2000.

Student did not provide persuasive evidence that the present levels were incorrect as of November 30, 2000. 10 (Footnote 10) Based on the information available to the District on November 30, 2000, and as corroborated by the CHHC and CARD reports, the Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance as stated in the November 30, 2000 IEP were accurate.

Goals and Objectives

Student contends that the goals and objectives were incorrect, did not contain baselines, and were not capable of being measured. The IEP of November 30, 2000 contained four goals. The first goal was a communication goal that provided, by December 2001, that Student will use a single word or word approximation to request a desired response/object when given a verbal model. The March 2001 benchmark projected that Student would use the PECS systems to request ten different items, the June benchmark was that Student would receptively identify 35 labels from thematic categories and the September 2001 benchmark was that Student would imitate consonant-vowel combinations from a spoken model with a prompt. The second goal was socialization. By December 2001 Student was to answer social questions such as “what’s your name?” and “how old are you?” The goal had three benchmarks, to imitate oral motor movement, to receptively identify photos, to answer social questions with a verbal model. The third goal was pre-academic and required Student to receptively identify eight colors and five shapes; the fourth goal addressed language communication and behavior, and required Student to follow fifteen one-step instructions by December 2001.

Student ’s witness, Ms. Katz, testified that she did not understand the District’s goals and objectives. However, on questioning, she admitted that she could “guess” what the goals and objectives were and could implement them. She also testified that the goals and objectives did not contain logical benchmarks and steps to obtain the goal. She was concerned that the objectives moved too quickly from an imitative objective to a receptive objective, without the necessary steps in between. She testified that expecting Student to receptively identify objects and cognitively name those objects in a year’s time was not possible. But she also testified that she would use these goals and would write more. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified, based on their experience with autistic children, that the goals and objectives were appropriate and provided logical benchmarks. They also testified that the goals and objectives were flexible and would be revisited after working with Student for thirty days.

Ms. Katz was also concerned that no baselines had been written on the goals and objective pages and testified that the goals could not be measured without baselines. Cara Ogle testified that the fact that “baselines” boxes on the goals and objectives form did not contain any information must have been an oversight. She testified that their assessment gave them sufficient information to write baselines. Dr. Perlman corroborated this testimony when he testified that the PEP-R results obtained by the District would have provided him with a wealth of information to write baselines. Cara Ogle, Marjorie Frye, Julie Fisher and Jackie Bachman all testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate and measurable. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Ms. Katz’ testimony and finds that a plain reading of the IEP demonstrates that the goals and objectives can be understood and are capable of measuring progress. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives written in the November 30, 2000 IEP were appropriate to address Student’s unique needs.

Cara Ogle’s Classroom (the Placement)

Cara Ogle credibly testified at hearing that her class uses a combination of ABA techniques that would be tailored to Student’s unique needs. Ms. Ogle’s first concern was to obtain a measure of instructional control over STUDENT. Ms. Ogle intended to teach Student nonverbal communication using sign language and the Picture Exchange Communication System (PECS) in order to establish communication to begin to teach him the building blocks of language. Ms. Ogle would use DTT, pivotal response, PECS, TEAACH techniques or whatever else it took to reach Student. As of October 2000, teaching imitation was of paramount importance. Cara Ogle credibly testified that her classroom could provide services to Student that would allow him to meet his goals and objectives. As noted above, Ms. Ogle is very qualified to provide ABA services using a mixture of methodologies. She testified that she carefully and fully trains her aides to provide DTT and other techniques to teach skills. The skills of each child are carefully maintained in the logbook, adjusted and modified individually. Ms. Ogle supervises each aide, each child, each task, each day. Student would have a structured learning environment, with a one-on-one aide, closely supervised, which would provide an ABA program. Ms. Ogle is highly trained to provide an ABA program to an autistic child.

The District provided additional testimony from Marjorie Frye, Jackie Bachman, Julie Fisher, Barbara Ostrin and Shannon O’Brien that supports the District’s contention that Ms. Ogle’s class could provide Student with an ABA program that would enable Student to meet his goals and would meet his unique needs. In addition, the Student ’s expert, Dr. Mitchel Perlman, testified that he visited Ms. Ogle’s class and found that the class had some of the components he looks for in determining a “best practices” autism program. He stated that Ms. Ogle uses a recognized theoretical base for teaching (TEAACH, pivotal response, DTT), which follows a curriculum addressing language and communication for autistic children. Dr. Perlman testified that Ms. Ogle appeared to be well-versed in ABA techniques. Dr. Perlman did testify that he felt that the socialization with other students would be harmful for Student at this time. He was unable to comment on parent participation. He could not say that Student would not benefit from Ms. Ogle’s program. Dr. Dores visited Cara Ogle’s class and testified that the program offered by Ms. Ogle would provide Student with educational benefit.

Student ’s contention that the placement at TOES was inappropriate is based on the parents’ belief that the only placement suitable for preparing Student to join a typical preschool or kindergarten class by age five is an in-home intensive behavior intervention program. The Student ’s experts (Perlman, Cross, Bakcht, Katz) all testified that Student was not ready to attend a typical preschool class. They testified that he did not have the attention necessary to learn in a typical preschool environment. Student’s parents testified that they did not want Student to be in class with other disabled children. While this feeling is understandable, it overlooks the fact that the District was not offering placement in a typical preschool class but in a very structured ABA-based class, with six or seven (no more than ten) children, a one-on-one aide and related services.

The Hearing Officer finds interesting Dr. Perlman’s testimony that Student was not ready to attend any classroom setting in March of 2002, yet Student was placed in a “typical” kindergarten in July 2002. Student ’s experts base their philosophy on the 1987 Lovaas study that found that forty-two percent of autistic children with average IQs, after receiving 35-40 hours per week of intensive behavioral intervention, could eventually enter a regular education program. However, the study did not find that the intervention must be conducted in the home. In fact, the study was conducted in clinics at the University of California at Los Angeles. While it may be necessary to limit distractions (as it is in any learning environment) to provide instruction, the testimony was clear that a number of distractions existed at home as well and that Student’s attentional problems were not remediated by being at home. Student also participated in speech and language therapy given at CHHC and was able to travel to a multitude of evaluations and assessments.11 (Footnote 11) Moreover, although Student ’s experts contend that distraction must be reduced to a minimum and that socialization is an undesirable distraction, socialization has been identified as one of Student’s areas of need. As early as September 2000, CHHC reported that Student’s intervention should address his deficits in socialization. The Hearing Officer has found that socialization is one of Student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that an appropriate placement for Student must include a program to address his need to develop socialization skills.

Related Services “Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction to meet the unique needs of the Student, including instruction conducted in the classroom, in the home, in hospital and institutions, and in other settings. 20 U.S.C. § 1401(a)(16). The term “related services,” which is also referred to in California as “designated instruction and services” (DIS), includes developmental, corrective, and supportive services that may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. § 1401 (22); Cal. Educ. Code § 56363.

At the November 30, 2000 IEP team meeting, the District offered speech and language consultation as a related service. The parents signed the IEP plan agreeing to the services but never enrolled STUDENT. Student began receiving speech and language therapy privately at CHHC on December 6, 2000. The therapy was to be two to three times per week for thirty minutes a session.

Student contended that the District’s speech and language services were to be given in a group and that Student was not able to learn in a group setting; therefore, the services were insufficient. The initial offer was for speech and language consultation only. The speech and language specialist was to work with Cara Ogle to determine what services Student may need and when, and the placement was to be revisited in thirty days. While there was testimony to indicate speech and language therapy in Ms. Ogle’s class was usually given in a group setting, the testimony also established that the District provided a flexible, individual program that could have been adjusted for STUDENT. The Student did not present persuasive evidence that the speech and language consultation offered was insufficient as of November 30, 2000.

The District also agreed to provide extended school year services (ESY). APE and OT were to be considered after evaluations were conducted. Student contended that the services were insufficient because the IEP did not specifically address a time schedule for services when school was off track or during ESY. The IEP also did not set out who would provide the services off track or during ESY. The District witnesses testified that APE, OT and speech and language services would be provided off track and during ESY and that the details would have to be worked out. As indicated above, this was to be an initial placement, to be revisited in 30 days and adjusted according to Student’s needs. The District witnesses testified that the related services offered were appropriate and sufficient. The Student did not present persuasive evidence that ESY, APE or OT would be insufficient. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of related services in the November 30, 2000 IEP was appropriate and sufficient.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer consisted of placement in a structured language-based class which utilized ABA techniques, with support of a one-to-one aide, OT and APE (if necessary), and S&L consultation, and was carefully designed to meet Student’s unique needs.

Was the District’s offer reasonably calculated to provide Studen tsome educational benefit?

A free appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential- maximizing” education for the child. Seattle Sch. Dist. No. 1 v. B.S., 82 F.3d 1493, 1500 (9th Cir. 1996); Union Sch. Dist. v. Smith, 15 F.3d 1994, 1524 (9th Cir. 1994), cert. denied 513 U.S. 965 (1994). Results are not guaranteed.

Because Student did not attend Ogle’s SDC class, there is no evidence to show that he received benefit from the program. However, the evidence supports the conclusion that the District’s placement (which includes services) would have provided educational benefit for Student. Student ’s expert, Dr. Perlman, could not say Student would not benefit from participating in Cara Ogle’s class. The District’s witnesses-Ogle, Bachman, Frye, O’Brien, Ostrin, Dores, Fisher and Iacuaniello-all testified that Student would have received educational benefit from Cara Ogle’s class. Student would have received one-on-one instruction by ABA techniques from a trained aide, closely supervised by a highly qualified credentialed special education teacher. The law does not require the District to provide the very best education possible. However, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s program would have provided Student with substantially more than de minimus education.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s placement would have provided educational benefit to Student.

Did the District’s offer of placement comport with Student’s IEP?

Student did not attend the District’s program, however, there was no evidence to indicate that the District could not have provided the placement as set forth in Student’s IEP.

Was the District’s offer provided in the least restrictive environment?

Special education law requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE). 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A) specifically provides:

To the maximum extent appropriate, children with disabilities, including children in public or private institutions or other care facilities, are educated with children who are not disabled, and special classes, separate schooling, or other removal of children with disabilities from the regular education environment occurs only when the nature or severity of the disability of a child is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aides and services cannot be achieved satisfactorily.

The requirement that disabled children be educated to the maximum extent appropriate with nondisabled children is often referred to as “mainstreaming,” or education in the “least restrictive environment” (LRE). The law demonstrates a “strong preference for ‘mainstreaming’ which rises to the level of a rebuttable presumption.” Daniel R. v. State Board of Education, 874 F.2d 1036, 1044-45 (5th Cir. 1989).

Student contends that Student could not be educated around other children and that he must receive intensive behavior intervention at home. Student has a unique need for socialization. He is highly distractible and must learn to overcome this to be successful in school, work and life. The clear intent and mandate of the IDEA is to provide an education that includes contact with peers. The isolation of a home program should be used only when there is no viable educational alternative. Cara Ogle’s SDC class offered a viable alternative and would be the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s offer was in the least restrictive environment.

In conclusion, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of November 30, 2000, was designed to address Student’s unique needs, was calculated to provide educational benefit, and there was no evidence to indicate that the District could not have provided the placement as set forth in Student’s IEP, and was therefore an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Was the District’s placement offer of January 25, 2001 designed to address Student’s unique educational needs, calculated to provide educational benefit and did it comport with Student’s IEP? Was the offer provided in the LRE?

When Student did not appear at school on December 4, 2000, per the IEP, the District contacted the parents to find out why. The parents indicated that they were having a hard time developing a schedule to fit the “Mommy and Me” class and CHHC speech and language therapy into the school schedule. After several such attempts to reach the parents and obtain a schedule for Student to start school, the District attempted to set an IEP meeting to discuss the matter. After receiving no cooperation from the parents, the District set an IEP meeting for January 25, 2001, to discuss the offer of placement and the parents’ concerns. By phone call and fax, Student’s father advised the District that the Parents did not request a meeting on January 25, 2001, to clarify the program offered for Student: “[I]n fact, we specifically told you we saw no need for such a meeting.” At hearing, Father admitted that he told the District not to call him unless they were calling to agree to fund the Coyne program.

An IEP meeting may be conducted without the parent present if the District is unable to convince the parents that they should attend (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341.5(g).) The evidence is clear that the parents felt that the meeting was a waste of time and that the District should not contact him unless and until it had decided to fund the in-home program.12 (Footnote 12)

Between November 30, 2000, and January 25, 2001, there is only one new evaluation for Student. On December 7, 2000, the CHHC provided a neurology consult which found that Student had significant receptive and expressive aphasia (impaired or absent comprehension of or communication by speech), and recommended behavior modification intervention and speech therapy. On January 2, 2001, Student began behavior intervention with Coyne and Associates.

There is no evidence that Student’s unique needs changed between November 30, 2000, and January 25, 2001. The same levels of education performance were listed in the January 25, 2001 IEP as were in the November 30, 2000 IEP. There was no evidence presented that Student’s level of performance had changed since November 30, 2000. Student contends in his closing brief that the District failed again to accurately describe Student’s areas of need, but he does not explain how the District failed. The Hearing Officer finds that as of January 25, 2001, Student’s unique needs remained the same and the present levels were accurate. The January 25, 2001 IEP did not contain any new goals and objectives.

The District’s offer of January 25, 2001, increased the hours of ABA to be provided in Cara Ogle’s SDC to twenty-four hours per week and increased the speech and language offer to thirty minutes of direct therapy and consultation, forty-five times per year. The offer also provided for time in a nearby neighborhood preschool’s circle time for socialization. Ms. Frye and Ms. Ogle testified, as was indicated earlier, that the District’s offer of November 2000 was a starting place and they had intended to modify the offer once they had worked with STUDENT. The earlier offer took into account that Student had not yet received early intervention and would need to transition into a behavior intervention program. While the District did not get the chance to work with Student and thus learn how Student would tolerate the program, the District did learn that Student was tolerating increased hours of ABA services from Coyne, and was receiving speech and language therapy from CHHC. In response to this information, and to encourage the parents to enroll Student in the District, the District modified its offer of ABA services and included speech and language direct services. In response to the parents’ desire to have Student placed with typically developing children, the District also made arrangements for Student to be mainstreamed.

Because there was no change in Student’s unique needs, considering that the earlier offer was found to address Student’s unique needs, and because the District modified their offer according to information received from Student’s parents, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of January 25, 2001 was also designed to meet Student’s unique needs. The Hearing Officer finds that the January 25, 2001offer was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit for STUDENT, there was no evidence to indicate that the District could not have provided the placement as set forth in Student’s IEP and was offered in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the IEP offer of January 25, 2001, was an offer of a FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Was the District’s placement offer of April 3, 2001, designed to address Student’s unique educational needs, calculated to provide educational benefit, and did it comport with Student’s IEP? Was the offer provided in the LRE?

After receiving the information from the January 25, 2001 IEP, Father informed the District that he would contact the District to set the next IEP when his representatives could attend. He failed to do so, and the parents failed to cooperate in setting a mutually agreeable date.13 (Footnote 13) Thus, the District was not able to schedule another IEP until April 3, 2001.

Student’s parents were present at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, accompanied by a representative from Coyne and Associates, Melissa Katz (psychologist and case manager), and Karen Lewis Searey (private speech/language pathologist). Amy Siegel (Early Start Education Specialist) was present from the San Diego Regional Center. Present from the District were Marjorie Frye, Lola Harlan, Jackie Bachman, Cara Ogle, Julie Fisher, Shannon O’Brien, and Barbara Ostrin.

During the period of January 25, 2001, through April 3, 2001, five evaluations were conducted. Two occupational therapy assessments were conducted, the District’s on February 6, 2001, and the parent’s through CHHC on February 9, 2001. The reports reported similar findings. Both assessors found that Student did not have significant difficulty in gross motor skills but that Student did have fine and visual motor difficulties and some sensory processing deficits. CHHC conducted a developmental evaluation on March 5, 2001. The assessor found that Student had severe language deficits and delays in his social skills. CHHC provided a speech and language progress report of March 14, 2001, which noted significant progress in therapy but continuing needs in the areas of expressive and receptive language. Coyne provided its progress report dated March 26, 2001, which covered the period of January 2, 2001, to March 26, 2001. None of these reports identified that Student had any new or different needs. Therefore, the evidence supports the conclusion that Student’s unique needs had not changed between November 30, 2000, and April 3, 2001.

The April 3, 2001 IEP meeting resulted in the following offer of placement: twenty-four hours per week of SDC in Cara Ogle’s class, with twenty minutes per week in Barbara Ostrin’s class for mainstreaming; clinic every other Friday with family and school staff for forty-five minutes to train parents and discuss progress; occupational therapy weekly for thirty minutes; an adaptive physical education evaluation; speech and language therapy (thirty minutes direct and consult, forty-five times per year) and extended school year. The offer included transportation, and the support of a one-on-one aide. During the IEP team meeting, the “Present Levels of Education Performance” were discussed and information provided by the parents and Ms. Katz was added.14 (Footnote 14) While the parents did attend the meeting, they did not accept the offer, and signed the IEP as being “in attendance only.”

The Student contends that the present levels of performance were not correct because the District did not have sufficient information from its inadequate assessments and because it had failed to obtain further information. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District conducted adequate assessments that allowed for the accurate depiction of Student’s present levels of performance as of November 2000 and January 25, 2001. The District’s IEP team meeting notes reflect that the team updated information about Student’s present levels of performance using information provided by Melissa Katz, Student’s parents, and others who attended the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, and the reports presented at that meeting. Moreover, a close comparison of Melissa Katz’s progress report of March 26, 2001, to the April 3, 2001 IEP “Present Levels” reveals that the two documents have similar entries regarding Student’s ability levels in such areas as imitation, matching, sorting, using receptive labels. Both reports find that Student’s goals are to address communication, preacademic skills, attention to task, and self-help (the Katz report does not address socialization). The District’s present levels of performance are consistent with the levels reported by Melissa Katz. The District’s “present levels of performance” are also consistent with the information regarding Student’s abilities found in the CHHC reports.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District considered all information presented at the April 3, 2001 IEP team meeting, and updated its present levels of performance. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that, based on the information available to the District as of April 3, 2001, the present levels of performance were accurate.

The April 3, 2001 IEP contains new goals in self-help (to void on toilet by December 2001), for socialization (to play in parallel manner with peer), for attention to task, and two goals for fine motor skills. The Student contends that the goals and objectives were not correct because the District did not have sufficient information from its inadequate assessments and because it failed to obtain further information. The District contends that the assessments, observations, parent input and the input of the Coyne providers at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting provided sufficient information to develop goals and objectives. The District also contends that the April IEP is a continuation of the first IEP and the goals and objectives are cumulative. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s goals and objectives in November 2000 and January 2001 adequately addressed Student’s unique needs. The new goals added by the District in April 2001 are added in response to further information about Student obtained from the Coyne representative, Children’s Hospital, and from Student’s parents, and are therefore found to be appropriate.

Student further contends that the goals and objectives were inappropriate for Student because he had already mastered each one, with the possible exception of the toileting goal. In the boxes next to the goals and objectives, someone had written numbers. A “4” meant the goal had been met or exceeded. A “3” meant that substantial progress (50% to 99% met) had been made. The testimony was not clear as to who wrote in the numbers, when and at whose direction. There was some testimony that the numbers were written in December 2001. Ms. Katz, the Coyne representative, testified that she recalled discussing goals and objectives at the IEP meeting, and recalled that she reported that she had worked on several of the goals and objectives with Student in her program. She testified that it would be inappropriate to continue to work on mastered goals. The Hearing Officer finds that the explanation for the placement of the numbers next to goals is not satisfactory and is not persuaded that the goals and objectives were met by April 3, 2001. In fact, testimony established that, as of April 3, 2001, Student was not engaging in parallel play with peers, so it was clear that this particular goal was not met. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives of the April 3, 2001 IEP adequately addressed Student’s unique needs.

The Student also contends that the IEP did not contain baselines, and that therefore, progress on goals and objectives would not be measurable. Several of the baseline areas on the IEP were filled in from information provided at that meeting. Some areas were marked as “new goals,” and testimony established that there would be no baselines for new goals. Student ’s witnesses testified that they would not be able to measure progress from the baselines provided in the IEP. The District’s witnesses testified that they would be able to measure progress from the written baselines, especially when coupled with the logbooks used in the classroom. Again, the District’s witnesses testified that they needed to work with Student to have all the information desired. From her review of the written baselines contained in the IEP, along with the credible testimony of the District’s witnesses, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the baselines provided sufficient information to allow progress to be measured.

The Student contends that his parents and representatives were not allowed to participate in the development of his IEP. The evidence shows that the parents and representatives did in fact participate in the IEP process by providing updated levels of educational performance and by discussing goals and objectives.

Student continues his contention that the April 2001offer of placement in Cara Ogle’s classroom was inappropriate because Student must be provided an ABA program at home. The evidence showed that, as of April 3, 2001, Student’s unique needs remained the same. The Hearing Officer has already found that Cara Ogle’s classroom was capable of providing a program designed to address Student’s unique needs and to enable him to meet his goals and objectives. Moreover, the District increased the time that Student would attend Ms. Ogle’s class based on the information provided. The District learned at the April 3, 2001 IEP that Student had been receiving twenty-three hours per week ABA services from Coyne for quite some time. The District’s offer matched this amount of ABA services. On the same basis as above, the Hearing Officer rejects Student ’s contention that ABA services must be delivered at home and finds that the classroom placement is appropriate.

Student continues his contention that the related services were inappropriate because speech and language therapy would be provided in a group setting and the April IEP does not clearly set forth a schedule for related services during summer and ESY. The Hearing Officer has already rejected this contention and found that the related services were appropriate and sufficient. Moreover, the District has increased the offer to include training and progress reports for the parents, occupational therapy per the February 6, 2001 OT evaluation of Shannon O’Brien, and direct speech and language therapy. The offer continues to include ESY, mainstreaming and the support of a one-on-one aide. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the related services offered by the District on April 3, 2001 are appropriate and sufficient.

As found above, the District’s program is designed to address Student’s unique needs, and is calculated to provide educational benefit to Student. There was no evidence presented to demonstrate that the District was not capable of providing the program set forth in Student’s IEP. As found above, the offer is in the least restrictive environment. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of April 3, 2001 was an offer of FAPE in the least restrictive environment.

Was the District’s offer of December 17, 2001, designed to address Student’s unique educational needs, calculated to provide educational benefit and did it comport with Student’s IEP? Was the offer provided in the LRE?

On July 13, 2001 and December 7, 2001, CHHC issued speech and language progress reports. Coyne and Associates issued a progress report on August 23, 2001, covering the period from March 26, 2001, to August 23, 2001. Ms. Katz (Coyne) had readministered the PEP-R in August 2001. Her report of August 23, 2001, noted that Student had made progress and demonstrates emerging speech skills. He was able to imitate 8-10 sounds and words; he used 5 words/word approximations to indicate wants/needs and uses the PECS system to communicate. He demonstrated difficulty in learning new receptive words, following receptive commands, producing well-articulated words, and generalizing social skills to a peer setting. She was to work on increasing Student’s verbal language skills and self-help skills such as toileting and dressing.

The Coyne and CHHC reports demonstrate that Student was making progress in communication. He was able to use PECS and sign language. CHHC reported that Student was using more than one word to make requests such as “draw Pooh,” “I want juice,” “hi daddy,” and “hug mama.” And the reports demonstrate that Student still had unique needs in communication, self-help, and socialization.

While the evidence showed that Student had made significant progress in the area of communication, the evidence also shows that, as of December 17, 2001, Student still had unique needs in communication, socialization, self-help and fine motor skills. He still required an intense behavioral modification program, speech and language and OT. The Hearing Officer finds that Student’s unique needs had not significantly changed.15 (Footnote 15)

Marjorie Frye began her attempts to contact the parents to set Student’s annual IEP meeting in September or October 2001. The testimony and documents showed that the parents did not respond to those attempts and the District eventually set the IEP team meeting for December 17, 2001. Student was represented by counsel at the meeting. Two representatives from LIFE (Miriam Bakcht and Erin Cares) who were actively engaged in Student’s ABA program also attended on Student’s behalf, as well as his parents. The following persons attended on behalf of the District: Cara Ogle, Julie Fisher, Kathi Iacuaniello, Shannon O’Brien, Jackie Bachman, Hilary Mayo, Marjorie Frye, Lola Harlan and District counsel. Testimony was conflicting as to whether the LIFE representatives presented information about Student at the meeting.16 (Footnote 16)

The Parents refused to give consent to reassessment at the meeting. The parents also wanted to review the information exchange forms prior to signing. Counsel for Student submitted a lengthy written “dissent” which asserted, among other allegations, that the District had made no attempt to observe Student in his program, which was allegedly a denial of FAPE.17 (Footnote 17)

At the IEP team meeting, Marjorie Frye gave a progress report regarding the information she had received from the Coyne group. Miriam Bakcht provided information about Student’s current levels of achievement. The IEP team notes reflect Miriam Bakcht’s input as to Student’s limited progress. She reported that Student was easily distracted and needed one-on-one attention, among other things. Hilary Mayo reported on her conversation with Melanie Siegel, Student’s speech and language pathologist from CHHC. The OT, Shannon O’Brien, reported that some sensory issues had been noted; therefore, a new OT assessment would be appropriate. The speech and language therapist also suggested a new speech and language evaluation.

The IEP team notes reflect that Ms. Ogle requested an opportunity to observe Student’s home program. The team requested parental consent for reassessment. The team also requested that the parents sign several information exchange forms so that the District could obtain further information from Coyne, Lovaas and CHHC. The IEP team meeting notes reflect that it was the team’s intent that goals would be added or modified pending the outcome of this further information. Another IEP team meeting was to be scheduled after the assessments were obtained.

The team concluded that the areas of educational need for which goals were needed were health and safety, preacademic skills, attention to task and socialization. The team determined that Student required highly structured instruction, individually and in a small group, use of the PECS system of communication and a modified curriculum, with lots of motivating rewards through verbal reinforcement and toys. He needed instruction from those trained to work with autistic students.

As a result of the IEP team meeting discussions, the District made the following offer of placement to Student: twenty-four hours per week intensive structured ABA in Cara Ogle’s class; eleven hours per week in-home ABA program for transition to full-time school; clinic attendance for family twice a week for thirty minutes per session; up to seven hours per week supervision and observation for the home program; OT weekly for 30 minutes plus consultation once a month; APE to be considered after evaluation; speech and language therapy (to be adjusted after a new evaluation) and ESY. The transitional services plus the time in Cara Ogle’s class provided the same thirty-five hours per week that Student was receiving from LIFE.

Student continued to contend that the present levels of performance set forth on the December 17, 2001 IEP were incorrect, on the same bases as above. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District’s initial assessment was adequate and the initial present levels accurate based on the assessment. The District updated the present levels after obtaining new information at each IEP meeting. The present levels of performance set forth in the December 17, 2001 IEP were based on new information obtained from the LIFE representatives present at the meeting, from Paul Coyne’s group, CHHC and from Student’s parents. The District’s present levels of performance are consistent with the Coyne, LIFE, and CHHC reports. Because Student’s unique needs had not significantly changed, and because the District considered and added new information obtained, and updated the present levels at each IEP (and again on December 17, 2001), the Hearing Officer finds that the present levels of performance to be accurate as reported in the December 17, 2001 IEP.

The December 17, 2001 IEP added goals in emotional/social competence (three goals), self-help (wearing a helmet), self-regulation of behavior, safe/healthy learner goals, personal comprehension goals (touch body parts), and self-care in dressing. The Student continues to contend that the goals and objectives were not appropriate because they were based on incorrect and incomplete assessments. The Hearing Officer has already found that the District conducted adequate assessments that allowed for the accurate depiction of Student’s present levels of performance and development of appropriate goals. Moreover, over the span of four IEP meetings, the District drafted eighteen goals that address communication, self-help, language, fine motor, socialization, preacademics and attention to task. On behalf of Student , Miriam Bakcht (LIFE representative) drafted thirty goals to be presented at the December 17, 2001 IEP team meeting which were to address general behaviors, gross/fine motor skills, language/cognitive skills, pre-academic/school preparation, self-help, and socialization/play, which were essentially the same areas as addressed by the District. A close reading of the two sets of goals reveals many more similarities than differences. Morevoer, Miriam Bakcht testified that the goals and objectives of the District addressed Student’s needs. The District’s witnesses--Ogle, Frye, Bachman, O’Brien, and Fisher--all testified that the goals and objectives were appropriate and would meet Student’s unique needs. On the basis of this testimony and upon her review of the goals and objectives, the Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives were appropriate.

The Student once again contends that the goals and objectives were not appropriate because they were not measurable. The Hearing Officer had already found that the goals and objectives previously written by the District contain sufficient baselines to be measurable. The December 17, 2001 IEP contains new goals and objectives which include baselines. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District’s goals and objectives were capable of measurement. Moreover, Cara Ogle would have used a detailed logbook to catalogue specific tasks assigned to Student’s program, the methology of delivering the program and the results of each trial. The logbook gives the service provider the direction needed to implement the IEP goals and objectives and provides guidance to the individual tutors to promote consistency. The logbook also provides a way to measure progress.

Student contends that the District refused to consider his goals and objectives. The evidence shows the goals and objectives were considered, however, the District is not obligated to adopt the goals and objectives developed from a strict Lovaas program and curriculum.18 (Footnote 18) Ms. Bakcht testified that she was not allowed to present her goals and objectives but admitted that goals and objectives were discussed at the IEP team meeting. The IEP team notes reflect discussion of goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer finds that the goals and objectives presented by Ms. Bakcht were adequately considered.

Student continues to contend that placement in Cara Ogle’s class was inappropriate because Student must have an ABA in-home program. The Hearing Officer has already rejected this contention. The evidence demonstrates, and the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District monitored Student’s progress by discussing his progress at the four IEP meetings, and by obtaining information regarding Student’s progress from CHHC and Paul Coyne’s group. The District modified its offer each time it obtained new information and increased the offer to encourage Student’s parents to enroll him in the District program. In the December 17, 2001 IEP, the District also includes eleven hours of services designed to help Student transition from the in-home ABA program to a school program. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District designed the placement to meet Student’s unique needs as of December 17, 2001.

And lastly, Student contends that the related services are not appropriate because speech and language is provided by the District in a group setting and that a clear schedule for the delivery of related services during summer and ESY is not provided in the IEP. The Hearing Officer has already addressed this issue as well. The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s offer of placement, including related services, is appropriate.

Student contends that throughout this IEP process, his parents and representatives were not allowed to participate in developing his IEP. As above, the Hearing Officer is persuaded that the parents and representatives participated in the IEP process by providing updated present levels of performance and by discussing goals and objectives. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the team considered the reports of Student ’s representatives in developing the IEP.

Because Student’s unique needs had not significantly changed as of December 17, 2001, and because the District offered an intensive, structured ABA program with OT, speech and language, ESY, transition, and a one-on-one aide, the Hearing Officer finds that the offer of December 17, 2001 was designed to address Student’s unique needs, and was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. There is no evidence that the District could not have provided the placement and services as described in Student’s IEP. The offer, which includes opportunity for mainstreaming, is in the LRE. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the District offered a FAPE on December 17, 2001 in the least restrictive environment.

3. Are Student’s parents entitled to reimbursement for educational services related to Student’s in-home program from January 2001 through June 14, 2002?

Parents may be entitled to retroactive reimbursement for the services they procured for their child as “appropriate relief” when the responsible school district denies the child a FAPE. School Comm. of the Town of Burlington v. Dept. of Educ., 471 U.S. 359, 369, 105 S. Ct. 1996 (1985); see also 20 U.S.C. § 1415(i).

The Hearing Officer has found that the District did offer Student FAPE. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the parents are not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of the Coyne and Lovaas in-home programs. 19 (Footnote 19)The parents are also not entitled to reimbursement for the costs of speech and language therapy, OT, or other related educational services.20 (Footnote 20)

CONCLUSIONS

The District properly assessed Student in all areas of suspected disability. The District offered Student a FAPE from December 3, 2000 through June 14, 2002. The parents are therefore not entitled to reimbursement of the in-home Coyne and Lovaas programs or any related educational services. The parents are not entitled to reimbursement of private speech and language, OT or other educational services.

ORDER

Student ’s requests for relief are denied in their entirety.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this statute: The District is the prevailing party on each issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code § 56505(i).

Date: November 7, 2003 ____________________________________ Jodi L. Clary, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1 The issues have been restated to reflect the results of the parties’ discussion to clarify issues at the start of the hearing. The issues have been reorganized for ease of analysis. There have been no substantive changes.

2 Student contends that Ms. Frye had no training in assessing autistic children. However, Ms. Frye testified in detail about her training in ABA techniques and specifically the training she took to administer the PEP-R through the North County Consortium for Special Education (NCCSE).

3 District’s Exhibit 35, “Test Description, Administration, and Scoring” of the PEP-R states that the PEP-R can be administered, scored, and interpreted by anyone who reads and learns the Manual and has some experience in testing young children. Three training tapes were suggested. It was recommended that a “new examiner administer a minimum of five practice PEP-Rs under the direct supervision of an experienced user. Because testing an autistic child requires control of both the test and the child’s behavior, it is helpful to do these first several PEP-Rs with normal children.”

4 District’s Exhibit 35 (PEP-R Manual excerpt) states under “general testing considerations,” that the testing environment should have minimal distractions, …is helpful to have food and drink rewards available….information from the parents as to calming methods. “In addition, if a child has preferred toys or activities, these can be used to elicit and maintain optimum test performance.” Under “administration of developmental items,” the manual states: “[t]he PEP-R examiner also has flexibility in how to administer each test item. Generally, standardized verbal directions have been avoided. Throughout the Manual’s instructions the word indicate has been used, and a specific hierarchy of administrative techniques is implied by this term:…verbal directions,…gestures or cues…demonstrations of how….physical guidance….”

5 Dr. Perlman attempted to test Student in February and March 2002. He testified that Student was very difficult to test, did not complete any of the tests and had “horrid” attention. He tested Student at home.

6 The parents testified that Frye and Ogle did not ask for any other information.

7 California Education Code §56325 requires a school district to immediately provide an interim placement for a period not to exceed 30 days when a student first enters the district. The interim placement is to be in conformity with the student’s IFSP or IEP and shall be reviewed by the IEP team for final recommendation within the 30 days.

8 Student does not contend that the District’s assessment was selected and administered to be racially, culturally, or sexually discriminatory. Testimony established that the testing was conducted in Student’s primary language of English. The report reveals that the testing assessed specific areas of educational need and did not result in a single IQ. The assessment team did not rely on a single procedure in coming to its conclusions. The testing developed Student’s strengths and weaknesses, aptitudes and achievements, and did not simply measure impairments. The Hearing Officer will not further address Cal. Educ. Code §56320 (a), (b)(1), (c), (d), (e) and (h).

9 Cara Ogle, Marjorie Frye, and Julie Fisher all testified as to the development of the present levels and goals and objectives. They also testified that the present levels and goals and objectives were appropriate.

10 In his closing argument, Student contends that the present levels are inappropriate in that no statement of how Student’s deficits affect his involvement and progress in regular education is included as required in Cal. Educ. Code section 56345. For preschool children the code section requires a statement of how the child’s disability affects participation in appropriate activities. Such a statement is found in each of the IEPs, on the page entitled “Special Factors.” Student also asserts that the present levels must contain cognitive functioning, speech-language and psychomotor abilities. The code section does not specifically require these areas but the District has substantially addressed each area in the pages entitled “Present Levels of Educational Performance” and “Special Factors.”

11 The Hearing Officer recognizes that Dr. Perlman, Ms. Katz and Ms. Bakcht tested Student at home.

12 Student contended that his parents did not receive notice of the meeting. Although a written notice was not presented as evidence, sufficient evidence was provided by the District to document their attempts to convince the parents to attend the meeting. Student contended that the District should have offered them an alternative method to attend the meeting, such as a conference call. In the face of Father’s clear message that the meeting was a waste of his time, the Student’s argument that a procedural denial of FAPE resulted is disingenuous.

13 Student contends that this meeting was not properly noticed, and was a procedural violation constituting a denial of FAPE. District’s exhibit 3, p. 11, contains a proper notice. The parents attended the meeting with their representative from Coyne.

14 Testimony was conflicting as to whether the District had requested any further information regarding Student from Coyne and Associates, from the Children’s Hospital, or from Student’s parents. The District witnesses testified that they had not been provided any such information. The Student ’s witnesses testified that the District failed to ask.

15 Dr. Mitchel D. Perlman conducted assessments in February/March 2002. He concluded that Student suffered significant impairments in his ability to communicate intelligibly and had significant difficulty in paying attention and sustaining attention. Dr. Perlman recommended goals to address Student’s speech deficits and attention deficits. After intensive intervention, Studentstill had severe language and attentional deficits in February and March 2002.

16 The LIFE representatives testified that they were not allowed to present information, but on questioning, admitted that they were not prevented from speaking. The District witnesses testified that the LIFE representatives were encouraged to speak, and were asked for their input.

17 Student ’s argument that the District failed to ask to observe his home program in face of his “antagonistic” relationship with the District is disingenuous.

18 Student has not offered any authority to support his contention that the District must adopt his goals and objectives. Cal. Educ. Code §§56341 and 56341.1 set forth the requirements that an IEP team, made up of specific persons knowledgeable about the student and the District’s programs, such as teachers, District representatives and the parents, must convene and develop goals and objectives pursuant to the student’s individualized needs. Information provided by the parents is to be considered by the team. There is no requirement that the information be adopted in its entirety.

19 In addition, if the Hearing Officer was to find that the District is liable for reimbursement, the District requested a finding that its liability for reimbursement be terminated on the date the parents refused to consent to the reassessment. Student contends that the District did not have a right to reassess Student because only a parent or teacher can request reassessment under Cal. Educ. Code § 56381. Student is incorrect. The section requires reassessment at least once every three years, or more frequently, if conditions warrant, or if a parent or teacher requests reassessment. Because of the Hearing Officer’s finding that the District offered a FAPE and was not liable for reimbursement, it is not necessary to determine this issue.

20 Student contended that his parents adequately informed the District of their rejection of services and of their intent to privately place STUDENT. Student contended that written notice was not necessary because the District failed to provide full and complete copies of the procedural safeguards that would inform the parents of the need to make the rejection and the request for reimbursement in writing. In view of the rulings above, it is not necessary to address this issue.