California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 1, 2002
Sierra Sands Unified School District v. Student
SEHO Case No. SN 2198-02 · Hearing Officer Van T. Vu
Sierra Sands Unified is responsible for an adult student who moved from New Jersey without her parents; IEP meeting ordered.
This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.
Summary
Sierra Sands Unified School District filed for a hearing to establish that it was not responsible for an 18-year-old student with significant physical disabilities. In New Jersey she had been eligible for special education as "multiply handicapped." She did not graduate. Soon after she turned 18, she moved into her older sister's home within the District. Her parents stayed in New Jersey. The parties agreed she still needs special education. They asked the Hearing Officer to decide the case on stipulated facts and written arguments.
The District relied on Education Code section 56041. Under that section, an adult student's responsible district stays the last district where the parents lived before the student turned 18. The District argued this made the New Jersey district responsible. The Hearing Officer disagreed. The legislative history showed the statute was meant to keep funding responsibility with California districts that place students in nonpublic schools in other districts. It was not written for students arriving from other states. New Jersey law bases an adult student's residency on where the student lives, so the District's reading would leave her with no responsible agency in either state. The Hearing Officer found that result absurd and in conflict with the IDEA's guarantee of a free appropriate public education (FAPE). The Hearing Officer also noted possible right-to-travel concerns but did not decide them. Under ordinary residency rules, the student is a District resident. The District was ordered to hold an IEP meeting within 15 days.
Why it matters
The decision shows how SEHO read Education Code section 56041 in 2002. That section ties an adult student's district of residence to the parents' district. SEHO held it did not apply to an adult student who moved to California from another state without her parents. Ordinary residency rules applied instead, so the student's new California district was responsible for her education.
Issues and holdings
- Student prevailedResponsible agency
Issue 1. Is STUDENT a resident of the Sierra Sands Unified School District? (Whether Education Code section 56041, which ties an adult student's district of residence to the parents' residence, applies to an adult student who moves to California from another state without her parents.)
Section 56041 does not apply to adult students who move to California from another state without their parents; under ordinary residency rules the student is a resident of Sierra Sands Unified, which is responsible for her education.
What the Hearing Officer ordered
- Order to convene IEP meeting. District shall convene an IEP meeting within 15 days of the date of the decision to develop a FAPE for the student as required by the IDEA and State law.
- District's request for a determination that the student is not its resident denied; student declared a resident of Sierra Sands Unified School District.
Key authorities
Cal. Educ. Code § 56041; Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5; Renee J. v. Superior Court (2001) 26 Cal.4th 735; People ex rel. Lungren v. Superior Court (1996) 14 Cal.4th 296; Myers v. Philip Morris Cos. (2002) 28 Cal.4th 828; United States v. Guest (1966) 383 U.S. 745; Saenz v. Roe (1999) 526 U.S. 489; Shapiro v. Thompson (1969) 394 U.S. 618
Get new OAH special education decisions by email
A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.
You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.Full text of the decision
Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.
This matter convened by telephone before Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, on October 22, 2002.(Footnote 1)
Petitioner Sierra Sands Unified School District (District) was represented during the telephone hearing by attorney Stacy Inman of the Schools Legal Service. Respondent STUDENT was represented by attorney Dale Mentik from Protection and Advocacy.
In lieu of the presentation of evidence, the parties submitted to the Hearing Office a joint statement of stipulated facts regarding this case. The Hearing Office received the District’s closing arguments on October 31, 2002, and the Student’s closing arguments on November 1, 2002. The record was then closed, and the matter was submitted for decision.
ISSUE
Is STUDENT a resident of the Sierra Sands Unified School District?
FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND
On September 27, 2002, the Hearing Office received from Petitioner Sierra Sands Unified School District a request for a special education due process hearing. The District raised as an issue whether it is the local educational agency (LEA) responsible for providing Respondent STUDENT with special education and related services. On October 16, 2002, the parties submitted to the Hearing Office a joint statement of stipulated facts. From the parties’ joint statement, the following facts are established:
STUDENT is an eighteen-year-old student who was born with thoracic myclomeningocele requiring ventriculoperitoneal shunt at birth. She has spina bifida, hydrocephalus, and paraplegia, among other health conditions, and uses a wheelchair and a service dog. STUDENT presently has a special education qualifying condition and she currently needs special education services.
STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services in New Jersey under the category of “multiply handicapped” until she was seventeen years and eleven months old. STUDENT did not graduate from high school in New Jersey, nor did she receive a standard high school diploma there or in any other state. While in New Jersey, STUDENT lived at home with her parents within the Lenape Regional High School District in Shamong, New Jersey. Soon after STUDENT turned 18 years of age on July 8, 2002, she changed her residence to the home of her older sister in Ridgecrest, California, within the Sierra Sands Unified School District. STUDENT’s parents continue to reside at their same residence in Shamong, New Jersey. STUDENT intends to continue living at her sister’s residence in California.
Since turning eighteen years old, STUDENT has not been under any conservatorship in the state of California or under any legal guardianship or conservatorship in the state of New Jersey. Additionally, STUDENT has not been placed in a licensed children’s institution, a licensed foster home or a family home pursuant to commitment or placement under Chapter 2 of Part 1 of Division 2 of the California Welfare and Institutions Code.
FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Is STUDENT a resident of the Sierra Sands Unified School District?
Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and State law, students with disabilities are entitled to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); California Education Code § 56000.) A school district is generally responsible for providing a FAPE to students with disabilities residing within its jurisdictional boundaries. (34 C.F.R. § 300.220.) In California, adult students between the ages of 18 and 22 are entitled to special education services if they were eligible for special education services prior to reaching the age of majority and have not completed their prescribed course of study, or if they have not met proficiency standards prescribed in Sections 51215 and 51216. When special education students living in California reach the age of eighteen, they acquire all educational rights accorded to a parent under California special education law. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.5.) These rights include the right to represent themselves during the IEP process, to make decisions regarding placement and services, to seek additional assessments, to file compliance complaints with the California Department of Education, and to request hearings. (Cal. Educ. Code §§ 56341.5, 56342.5, 56029, and 56501; 5 C.C.R. § 4630.)
One exception to the rule that nonconserved adult special education students acquire all special education rights their parents possess lies in the area of residency. Pursuant to Section 56041 of the California Education Code, the residency of adult special education students is established by the residency of their parents. Specifically, Section 56041 states:
[T]he last district of residence in effect prior to the pupil’s attaining the age of majority shall become and remain as the responsible local educational agency, as long as and until the parent or parents relocate to a new district of residence. At that time, the new district of residence shall be come the responsible local educational agency. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56041.)(Footnote 2)
Therefore, Section 56041 makes the district where the adult student’s parent(s) resides responsible for the special education of the student regardless of whether the student has moved away from his or her parent(s) to a new school district within California.
The Petitioner argues that Section 56041 also governs adult special education students who move to California from another state. The Respondent disputes Petitioner’s reading and contends instead that Section 56041 is limited to California students who were minors receiving special education services when they reached the age of majority. Because the statute is susceptible to both interpretations, the Hearing Officer turns to the canons of statutory construction to interpret the statute.
The California Supreme Court in Renee J. v. Superior Court of Orange County, et al., 26 Cal.4th 735, 743 (2001) recently articulated that “a fundamental rule of statutory construction is that a court should ascertain the intent of the Legislature so as to effectuate the purpose of the law.” Additionally, “the various parts of a statutory enactment must be harmonized by considering the particular clause or section in the context of the statutory framework as a whole. Renee J. v. Superior Court of Orange County, et al., 26 Cal.4th 735, 743 (2001). Where the language is susceptible to two constructions, one of which will render it reasonable, fair, and harmonious, and the other of which would lead to absurd consequences, the former will be adopted. People ex rel Lungren v. Superior Court (American Standard, Inc.), 14 Cal.4th 296 (1996). Moreover, an established rule of statutory construction requires us to construe statutes to avoid “constitutional infirmities.” Myers v. Phillip Morris Cos., Inc., 28 Cal.4th 828, 846 (2002).
The legislative history of Section 56041 and the incongruities of Petitioner’s interpretation with special education law establish that Section 56041 does not apply to adult students who move to California from another state.
According to the official legislative history of Assembly Bill 2773, Section 56041 was added at the request of the Santa Barbara County Special Education Local Plan Area (SELPA) to address a problem for local educational agencies that are impacted by nonpublic, nonsectarian schools.(Footnote 3) In drafting Section 56041, the legislature was contemplating situations regarding minor students residing in California at nonpublic or nonsectarian schools located outside of the jurisdictional boundaries of the students’ LEAs. Rather than transferring the responsibility for the student’s education to the district where the student is residing when he or she is or becomes an adult, Section 56041 requires the educational agency that placed the student in the nonpublic or nonsectarian school to continue to be responsible for the student’s education. In short, Section 56041 is a provision to maintain funding responsibilities for the adult student’s education with the California school district within which the parents reside. The purpose of the provision is to protect certain school districts and SELPAs that have a large number of residential schools attended by adult special education students from other districts from becoming overwhelmed by the financial responsibility for the education of those adult students. This provision was not intended to deny students residing in California special education and services, nor could it under the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. §§ 1400(d)(1)(A) and 1412(a)(1)(A).)
The legislature could not have intended this statute to apply to adult special education students moving to California from other states. If this statute were applied to adult students moving to California without their parents, as argued by Petitioner, it would in many instances deny adults who are eligible for special education the right to a FAPE guaranteed under the IDEA and comparable State law. Reading the statute as imposing educational responsibility on a school district in another state would defeat the IDEA’s purpose of ensuring disabled students access to an education. Certainly, Petitioner’s reading of Section 56041 would deny STUDENT her right to special education. Under New Jersey law, the school district in which STUDENT’s parents reside has no obligation to provide STUDENT services in California. Because New Jersey state law identifies the responsible LEA by the residency of the adult student and because STUDENT lives and intends to remain in California, she would not qualify for special education services as a resident of New Jersey. (See N.J. Admin. Code tit. 6 §§ 28-2.4 and 14-1.3.) New Jersey does not accept responsibility for students who move out of its state and Petitioner has cited no authority that it must bear such responsibility.(Footnote 4) Accordingly, pursuant to the District’s interpretation of Section 56041, neither New Jersey nor California would be obligated to provide STUDENT with any special education services from either jurisdiction. Thus, an “absurd” result would ensue.
There are good policy reasons for school districts to be relieved of responsibility for the education of students who move out of state. If for whatever reason a state in which the parents resided retained responsibility for an adult who moved out of the state, that responsibility would create enormous logistical problems that would, in effect, deny the student access to special education. For example, individualized education program meetings, assessments, and placements for STUDENT would all have to occur in New Jersey or else New Jersey would have to contract with California districts or agencies to provide the services. (34 C.F.R. § 300.552.) Considering that young adults usually do not attend typical high schools and they often require assistance in obtaining employment and enabling independent living, New Jersey would have to arrange with a panoply of agencies in California (or supervise comparable work by a California some 3000 miles away) to provide assistance in areas such as instruction in accessing transportation, developing social skills and living skills, and acquiring career counseling and training to provide the student with a FAPE. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56460 et seq.) Given the distance separating the Lenape District and STUDENT, the extent and severity of STUDENT’s needs, and the Lenape District’s likely unfamiliarity with services offered in California, the requirement that Lenape provide STUDENT services in California would result in a logistical nightmare and a practical impossibility. There is no reliable way to guarantee that the Lenape District would receive cooperation from the California school district or agencies, nor would STUDENT be in a practical position to obtain that cooperation through a due process hearing. California due process procedures simply do not extend to other states and it is highly unlikely that New Jersey’s do either. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56500 et seq.)
The incongruities of the Petitioner’s interpretation of Section 56041 confirm that the statute does not apply to students moving into California from other states. Certainly, the California legislature did not intend to impose the burden and cost of providing special education services on California districts when the adult student moves out of California and their parents remain. Moreover, if STUDENT’s parents were to move from the school district in New Jersey to a district in another state such as Florida, Petitioner’s interpretation of the statute would impose educational responsibility on a Florida school district that has no connection to STUDENT other than that her parents live there. California does not have authority to impose such a responsibility on another state, and the results are so incongruous that it is apparent that the California legislature must not have intended Section 56041 to apply to a student moving into California from another state.
Given the legislative history of Section 56041, the fact that Petitioner’s interpretation would deny STUDENT special education services in California where she is entitled to live, and the extreme incongruities arising from such an interpretation, the Hearing Officer concludes that Section 56041 does not apply to adult special education students who relocate to California without their parents.(Footnote 5) Inasmuch as Section 56041 does not apply, the ordinary rules governing residency within California govern STUDENT’s residency. The parties agree that if Section 56041 does not apply, STUDENT is a resident of Sierra Sands School District. Therefore, the Sierra Sands District is the district of residence responsible for her education.
ORDER
The Petitioner’s request for a determination that STUDENT is not a resident of the Sierra Sands Unified School District is denied. As found above, STUDENT is a resident of the Sierra Sands Unified School District. District shall convene within 15 days of the date of this decision an IEP meeting to develop a free and appropriate public education for STUDENT as required by the IDEA and State law.
PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE
Pursuant to Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this statute: Respondent STUDENT prevailed on the only issue decided.
RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION
The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code § 56505(i).
DATED: ________________ ____________________________________
Van T. Vu, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office
1 Prior to the first day of hearing, the parties submitted to the Hearing Office a request that this matter be decided on the basis of a joint statement of stipulated facts and each party’s closing arguments, without the need for an evidentiary hearing. After reviewing the file, the Hearing Officer determined the issue presented by the parties involved purely a legal issue and the facts necessary to resolve the legal issue were already stipulated to by the parties. Accordingly, the parties’ request was granted.
2. This provision does not apply to students who meet residency requirements for school attendance pursuant to California Education Code Section 48204(a). Section 48204(a) states that a student shall be deemed to have complied with compulsory education laws if he or she is “placed within the boundaries of that school district in a regularly established licensed children’s institution, or a licensed foster home, or a family home pursuant to a commitment or placement under Chapter 2… of Part 1 of Division 2 of the Welfare and Institutions Code.” The parties stipulated that STUDENT has never been committed or placed at any of these entities and, therefore, Section 48204(a) does not apply to STUDENT or the issue of this case. 3. As a courtesy to the Hearing Officer, both parties submitted with their closing briefs copies of the legislative history of AB 2773. The history to Section 56041 referenced above states, “This proposed amendment adds a new code section clarifying the district of residence responsible for providing special education and related services to pupils between the ages of 18 and 22 years, inclusive, for nonconserved pupils and conserved pupils. This addresses a problem for local educational agencies [that] are impacted by nonpublic, nonsectarian schools. This amendment was recommended by the Santa Barbara County SELPA.” 4. California likewise does not accept responsibility for special education students who move out of California. (Cal. Educ. Code § 48200 et seq.) 5. There also appears to be major constitutional questions that would arise from Petitioner’s interpretation of Section 56041. In 1966, the United States Supreme Court in United States v. Guest, 383 U.S. 745, 757-758 (1966), described the right to travel from one state to another as a fundamental right under our Constitution. Among other things, the right to travel protects the right of travelers who choose to become permanent residents of that state to be treated like other citizens of that state. Rita Saenz, et al., v. Brenda Roe and Anna Roe, 526 U.S. 489, 500 (1999). A classification that has the effect of imposing a penalty on the exercise of the right to travel violates the Equal Protection Clause of the Constitution unless it is shown to be necessary to promote a compelling governmental interest. Shapiro, Commissioner of Welfare of Conecticut v. Thompson, 394 U.S. 618, 634 (1969). As explained above, the District’s interpretation of Section 56041 would result in STUDENT’s being treated differently from other adult special education students in California. However, because the Hearing Officer finds that Section 56041 does not apply to students like STUDENT, it is not necessary to determine whether the District’s interpretation would unconstitutionally infringe upon STUDENT’s right to interstate travel.
