California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · July 15, 2002

Student v. Long Beach Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 220-02 · Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino

Long Beach Unified need not place a student in an APE class but must provide consultative APE services for regular PE.

Student prevailed in part

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A parent filed for due process on behalf of her 10-year-old son, who is eligible for special education under "other health impairment" because of lasting effects from surgery in 1997. He received resource specialist help in reading and math and, until November 2001, adapted physical education (APE). Long Beach Unified School District stopped APE after its assessments found his motor skills average or above. The mother pointed to letters from two doctors and a private physical therapy note. They described balance problems, weakness on his right side, and a higher risk of falling, and they recommended APE.

Hearing Officer Vincent L. Pastorino found that three District APE assessments from October 2000 to April 2002 consistently placed the student at or above average. Two APE teachers testified that the APE class gave him little benefit. The Hearing Officer found that the doctors' specific advice, such as avoiding running with sudden turns, could be followed in a modified regular PE class. That advice did not show a need for the more restrictive APE class. However, the Hearing Officer held that the District's offer could not leave out APE entirely. Under state regulations, APE includes consultative services. An APE specialist was needed to identify the modifications that would let the student take part in regular PE safely. The District was ordered to provide regular PE with modifications plus consultative APE. The IEP team was to meet before the 2002-2003 school year to set the details and write PE goals.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO used California's APE regulation. A student who does not qualify for a separate APE class may still need consultative APE services to take part safely in regular PE. It also shows that general doctors' letters recommending APE, without explaining why regular PE with modifications would not work, carried limited weight.

Issues and holdings

  1. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1. Whether, for purposes of offering a FAPE, the District is required to offer adapted physical education services to Student for the 2002-2003 school year, including but not limited to placement in an APE class, and if so, what those services must include.

    Student did not need placement in an APE class and could be served in regular PE with modifications, but the District's offer could not be devoid of APE; consultative APE services were required to identify modifications for safe participation.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to provide or change services. At the start of the 2002-2003 school year, Student's PE program shall include a regular physical education class with appropriate modifications, plus consultative APE services to identify supplementary aids and services or modifications needed for successful participation in regular PE.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within a reasonable time before the 2002-2003 school year begins, the IEP team shall meet to set the details of consultative APE services and write PE goals and objectives based on present levels of performance.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Cal. Educ. Code § 56363; Cal. Code Regs., tit. 5, § 3051.5; 20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Cal. Educ. Code § 56031

People named in the decision

  • Charles Almand, APE specialist; Student's APE teacher 2000-2001; assessor; District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Leanne Clark, APE specialist; Student's APE teacher fall 2001; assessor; District witness, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Tina Robertson, APE specialist; conducted April 2002 APE assessment, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Susan Melly, SELPA administrator; District representative, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Kathy Catroppa, Administrative coordinator, Long Beach Unified School District
  • Jerry Finklestein, M.D., Private physician; wrote letter recommending APE, Pediatric and Adolescent Hematology-Oncology Associates
  • Thanh Le, M.D., Private neurologist; wrote letter recommending APE with activity limits, Adult & Child Neurology Medical Associates
  • Children's Developmental Center, Private physical therapy provider; March 2002 evaluation/progress note

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacif ic, on June 18, 2002, in Long Beach, California. Petitioner STUDENT (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by his mother, MOTHER. Respondent Long Beach Unified School District (District or Respondent) was represented by Susan Melly, SELPA administrator for the District. Also present on behalf of the District was Kathy Catroppa, administrative coordinator for the District. The Petitioner called MOTHER as his only witness. The District called the following witnesses: Charles Almand and Leanne Clark, adapted physical education (APE) specialists at the District. Oral and documentary evidence was received. Oral closing arguments were made, and the record was closed.

ISSUE PRESENTED FOR HEARING

Is the District required to offer adapted physical education services to STUDENT for the 2002-2003 school year, including but not limited to placement in an APE class?

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT, age 10, was born on [date redacted]. He underwent surgery in 1997 for removal of a brain tumor. Due to the residual effects of his illness and surgery, STUDENT is eligible for special education under the category of “other health impairment.” (Footnote 1) His special education services commenced in November 1997. Resource specialist (RSP) services in reading and math have constituted the core of his special education program. His November 13, 2001 IEP listed his academic levels of performance as generally being about one year below his grade level. Until November 2001, STUDENT’s program included adapted physical education (APE) services.

Charles Almand was STUDENT’s APE teacher for the 2000-2001 school year. In October 2000, he assessed STUDENT using the Adapted Physical Education Assessment Scale (APEAS) and the Test of Gross Motor Development (TGMD). His October 26, 2000 report states that STUDENT had met all of the APE goals and objectives from the prior IEP of April 2000 (Footnote 2). His scores on the APEAS placed him in the average range compared to other boys in his age group. He scored at the 50th percentile or higher in 12 of the 17 items on the test, and he scored in the 99th percentile on 4 of those items. An area of weakness identified by the APEAS was his ability to stand on one foot with his eyes closed. His score was at the 20th percentile for standing on the left foot, and his score was at the 5th percentile for the right foot. On the TGMD, he rated at the 70-75th percentile compared to other boys in his age group. Mr. Almand recommended in his report that STUDENT should be dismissed from APE because his scores placed him “in the range to be eligible for Regular Physical Education.”

Mr. Almand testified that in spite of his October 2000 recommendation for dismissing STUDENT from APE, he continued to provide STUDENT with APE services once per week for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year. He testified that he provided those APE services because STUDENT was not allowed to significantly participate in physical activity at lunch or recess during that school year, and he wanted to assure that STUDENT engaged in some degree of organized physical exercise.

Leanne Clark provided APE services to STUDENT one day per week from September 2001 to November 2001. She assessed STUDENT on November 8, 2001, using the APEAS. Her report states that STUDENT performed gross motor skills at above age-appropriate levels. He scored at the 90th percentile or higher on 6 of the 14 subtests given. His ability to stand on one foot with his eyes closed had improved from the 5th to the 45th percentile for the right foot and 20th to 60th percentile for the left foot. Ms. Clark concluded her report by stating that on the basis of his APEAS scores, STUDENT did not “qualify” for APE services. She recommended that STUDENT be placed in a regular physical education class with appropriate modifications “to insure STUDENT’s safe participation.”

At an IEP meeting on November 13, 2001, STUDENT’s mother expressed her concerns about the recommendation to discontinue APE services. The meeting notes state that she preferred to wait until STUDENT’s doctors evaluated him in December 2001 before making her decision on APE. Part of her concerns arose from her impression that STUDENT was becoming weaker on the right side. STUDENT’s mother initialed the consent line on the November 13, 2001 IEP. However, next to her initials she wrote that, as an exception to her consent, she wanted to talk with STUDENT’s doctors regarding APE. Notwithstanding the above, the District considered the November 13, 2001 IEP to be agreed-upon, and APE services were discontinued.

Following the November 13, 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s mother obtained two letters from his doctors. A January 30, 2002 letter by Jerry Finklestein, M.D., at Pediatric and Adolescent Hematology-Oncology Associates states that STUDENT had been treated and followed by Dr. Finklestein’s colleagues since January 1997. The letter states that STUDENT “does demonstrate some lower extremity ataxia and thus I believe that he would benefit from adaptive physical education program.” A January 20, 2002 letter by Thanh Le, M..D., at Adult & Child Neurology Medical Associates states that STUDENT was a patient in Dr. Le’s office, and that “due to his current medical condition, he should only participate in adaptive physical education. He can participate in activities involving walking, skipping, and jumping. He may also participate in calisthenics-type activities. He should not be required to participate in activities requiring age-equivalent coordination skills, such as running and sudden turns while running. Such activities increase his risk for falls.” No further details were stated in either letter.

On the basis of the above letters, STUDENT’s mother was convinced that he required APE services. On March 27, 2002, the IEP team met to review the letters from STUDENT’s doctors and discuss the matter of APE. The meeting notes document the mother’s belief that STUDENT had regressed since the November 2001 assessment. Accordingly, the team agreed to have a new APE assessment performed. The meeting notes also state that STUDENT’s physical education program had already been modified and that the District was willing to add further modifications. The District did not offer APE at that time (Footnote 3).

District APE specialist Tina Robertson conducted an assessment in April 2002. She administered the APEAS, and she also observed STUDENT and reviewed his previous IEPs and other records. She concluded that STUDENT’s skills appeared to be age-appropriate. He scored at the 90th percentile or higher in 4 of the 13 subtests given. His lowest score was at the 20th percentile for standing on his right foot with his eyes open. The report states, without citation of authority, that to qualify for APE services “4 or more subtest scores must fall at or below the 10th percentile, and the subtests must be in two or more categories.” (Footnote 4) Ms. Robertson recommended that “modifications should be made within the regular physical education class setting to insure STUDENT’s safe participation.” Ms. Robertson’s assessment was reviewed at an IEP meeting on May 30, 2002. The District offered school-based physical therapy to address STUDENT’s “muscle tone/strengthening issues.” The District continued to offer a modified physical education program, but it did not offer APE services.

Meanwhile, on February 4, 2002, STUDENT’s mother had filed a due process hearing request to address her allegation that APE had been stopped without her consent. On February 14, 2002, the parties agreed to take the matter off calendar. On May 30, 2002, the mother requested that the case be scheduled for hearing. At the hearing on June 18, 2002, the parties and the Hearing Officer engaged in a discussion on the record prior to the receipt of evidence. The issue presented for hearing was determined to be whether, for purposes of offering a free appropriate public education to STUDENT, the District is required to offer adapted physical education services for the 2002-2003 school year, including but not limited to placement in an APE class. If the Petitioner is entitled to APE services, the Petitioner seeks a further determination regarding what those services must include.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Individuals with exceptional needs have the right to a “free appropriate public education” (FAPE). 20 U.S.C. Sec. 1400(d), Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56000. Under the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and the decision of the Supreme Court in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson School District, et al. v. Rowley, 458 U.S.176 (1982), an appropriate educational program must be designed to meet the student’s needs, provide the student with some educational benefit, and conform with the IEP. The Court in Rowley concluded that the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available or to provide instruction or services that maximize the student’s abilities. The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to meet the student’s unique needs and provide the student with some educational benefit. Rowley, at 207-208.

Designated instruction and services as specified in the student’s IEP shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the student to benefit from his or her instructional program. Such services may include adapted physical education. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56363. “Adapted physical education is for individuals with exceptional needs who require developmental or corrective instruction and who are precluded from participation in the activities of the general physical education program, modified general physical education program, or in a specially designed physical education program in a special class. Consultative services may be provided to pupils, parents, teachers, or other school personnel for the purpose of identifying supplementary aids and services or modifications necessary for successful participation in the regular physical education program or specially designed physical education programs.” Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3051.5.

Special education law also requires that a student be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE) and mandates that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services cannot be satisfactorily achieved. 20 U.S.C. §1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56031.

In the present case, the District’s most recent program offer is specified in the IEP proposed by the District on May 30, 2002. The proposed IEP is intended to be applicable through November 13, 2002, the date scheduled for the next IEP meeting. For purposes of this hearing, STUDENT’s sole objection to the proposed IEP is that no APE services were offered. STUDENT asserts that he needs APE services because of weakness and balance problems, especially on his right side. He asserts that if those problems are not addressed, he will be at an increased and unacceptable risk for falling and sustaining injury. The District disagrees with the contention that STUDENT needs APE services. The District asserts that a regular physical education class with modifications is appropriate for STUDENT.

The District’s position is supported by the APE assessments performed in October 2000, November 2001, and April 2002. Each assessment was performed by a different APE specialist, using the APEAS. The APEAS testing consistently showed that STUDENT performed at an overall level that was average or above average for his age and gender. The District’s position is also supported by the testimony of Mr. Almand and Ms. Clark, who both referred to their extensive personal observations of STUDENT in their capacity as his APE teacher. Mr. Almand testified that except for the fact that STUDENT was getting some physical exercise, he received no distinct benefit from being in the APE class after October 2000. Mr. Almand added that in his 20-plus years as an APE specialist, his APE classes have basically been comprised of students with profound physical limitations and/or such severe cognitive impairments that they cannot meaningfully participate in a regular education program, even with modifications. Mr. Almand does not believe that STUDENT fits that type of situation. Ms. Clark had the same opinion regarding the lack of benefit from STUDENT being in her APE class in the fall of 2001. They both testified that STUDENT often appeared bored in APE. They believe that STUDENT needs to be in a modified regular education class, and they believe that the building of his overall strength and endurance would be better addressed in a regular physical education class with interaction among typical peers.

When asked whether they had recently observed anything unusual about STUDENT’s physical movements, Ms. Clark and Mr. Almand both testified that STUDENT presented visually as normal, that they saw no abnormalities in his gait when he was walking, and that his running was normal except that occasionally he would tilt his head and then quickly and effectively compensate.

In support of the Petitioner’s position, the mother offered her own testimony and the above-referenced reports from the Petitioner’s doctors. The reports are consistent with the mother’s assertion that STUDENT has some weakness and balance problems putting him at increased risk for falling. However, the reports do not indicate why the more restrictive setting of an APE class would be necessary to address STUDENT’s needs. The crux of Dr. Le’s report is that although STUDENT can participate in walking, skipping, jumping, and calisthenics-type activities, other activities should be avoided, such as running and making sudden turns while running. Dr. Le’s report does not indicate that he considered whether a modified regular physical education program would address his concerns about certain activities. His report neither indicates nor implies that adapted physical education is necessary for STUDENT as a form of developmental or corrective instruction. Dr. Finklestein’s report does not indicate the degree of STUDENT’s lower extremity ataxia or how an APE program would address it. His report does not indicate that he considered a modified physical education program.

The Petitioner also presented a physical therapy evaluation/progress note from Children’s Developmental Center, dated March 18, 2002. (Pet. Ex. 6.) The note states that STUDENT had been referred by a doctor for evaluation following the mother’s report of decreased muscle strength and balance. The note lists the therapist’s clinical examination findings. The findings related to STUDENT’s ability to balance on one foot were interpreted by the examiner as showing that his balance and coordination were decreased on the right side. The note adds that after being able to maintain his balance on one foot for approximately 2 seconds, STUDENT would then collapse on the mat (Footnote 5). The evaluator concluded that STUDENT had generally good strength, tone, and range of motion, but concern was expressed regarding endurance, fatigue, attention to task, balance, coordination, and decreased ability to follow more than one direction at a time. The evaluator recommended that STUDENT would benefit from APE with the overall goal of integrating to regular physical education classes both for social/emotional benefit and motor skill development. More specific goals would be to increase balance, coordination, alertness, attention to task, ability to follow through with directions, and ability to run short distances with changes in direction, thereby facilitating STUDENT’s participation in team sports.

Finally, in support of the Petitioner’s position, the mother testified that STUDENT’s gait was obviously abnormal; she described it as “floppy.” She testified that when STUDENT is seated, his head almost continuously will tilt to one side and then “flop” back into position. She also testified that STUDENT’s skills were inconsistent. For example, on some days he could throw a ball, and on some days he could not throw a ball. She testified that his susceptibility to fatigue contributed to his inconsistent performance (Footnote 6).

In summary, although the IEP team has acknowledged that STUDENT has some issues regarding his balance, strength, and endurance, STUDENT’s overall skills were rated as average to above-average on the three occasions when the APEAS was administered from October 2000 to April 2002. STUDENT’s APE teachers have extensively observed him participating in outdoor activities. They testified that STUDENT’s participation in APE was essentially a waste of his time in comparison to the benefits he would receive from participation in a modified regular education program with typical peers. STUDENT’s doctors and physical therapist specifically referred to APE as part of their written recommendations. However, the details provided in the letter by Dr. Le and in the notes of the physical therapist, including the recommendation that STUDENT participate in walking, skipping, jumping, and calisthenics-type activities; the recommendation that STUDENT avoid running or sudden turns while running; and the recognition of the social/emotional and motor skill development benefits from regular physical education classes, actually were consistent with the recommendations of the APE teachers that STUDENT’s needs would be met in a regular physical education class with modifications.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s unique needs do not require his placement in an APE class. STUDENT’s needs will be met by his participation in a regular physical education class. However, modifications will be necessary to enable him to successfully participate in regular physical education. In STUDENT’s case, successful participation includes safe participation. For purposes of safety, STUDENT’s doctors have recommended certain limitations on STUDENT’s activities, such as the avoidance of making abrupt changes in direction while running. Furthermore, within the range of physical activities that STUDENT can do, activities must be chosen that support a physical education program designed to meet his unique needs for increased balance, coordination, alertness, attention to task, ability to follow through with directions, and ability to run short distances with changes in direction.

Although STUDENT will participate in a regular physical education class with modifications, this does not mean that the District’s program offer for the 2002-2003 school year can be devoid of APE services. As stated in Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3051.5, adapted physical education may include consultative services to pupils, parents, teachers, or other school personnel for the purpose of identifying supplementary aids and services or modifications necessary for a student’s successful participation in a regular physical education program. Because of STUDENT’s above-described limitations and needs, consultative services provided by an APE specialist will be necessary to identify supplementary aids and services or modifications necessary for STUDENT’s successful participation in a regular physical education program. The details regarding provision of consultative APE services and the formulation of goals and objectives with reference to present levels of performance shall be determined by STUDENT’s IEP team.

CONCLUSION

For 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s unique needs related to physical education can be met in a regular physical education class with modifications. Although consultation with an APE specialist will be required, STUDENT’s unique needs do not justify his placement in an APE class.

ORDERS

1. STUDENT is not presently entitled to placement in an APE class.

2. At the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s physical education program shall include placement in a regular physical education class with appropriate modifications. STUDENT’s program shall also include consultative APE services for the purpose of identifying supplementary aids and services or modifications necessary for STUDENT’s successful participation in a regular physical education program.

3. Within a reasonable time prior to the commencement of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT’s IEP team shall meet to determine the details regarding provision of consultative APE services and to formulate goals and objectives for his physical education program with reference to present levels of performance.

4. All of the Petitioner’s other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. To the extent that the Petitioner’s request for placement in an APE class was denied, the District prevailed on the issue heard and decided.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Sec. 56505(i).

Dated: July 15, 2002 ____________________________________ Vincent L. Pastorino, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The term “other health impairment” is used on the District’s IEP forms. The term refers to chronic or acute health problems that cause limited strength, vitality, or alertness, adversely affecting a pupil’s educational performance. See Title 5, C.C.R. Sec. 3030(f).

2. The goals and objectives involved catching a ball thrown from 15 feet, balancing on the left foot for 6 seconds, and jumping rope.

3. The meeting notes also state that the District offered a physical therapy assessment, but the mother declined. STUDENT was receiving private physical therapy at that time.

4. Mr. Almand and Ms. Clark referred to that same eligibility standard in their reports.

5. The note does not state whether the one-leg standing was performed with eyes opened or closed. The District’s APEAS testing in April 2002 showed that STUDENT could maintain balance for 10 seconds on his left foot and 9 seconds on his right foot with his eyes opened (25th and 20th percentiles, respectively), and he could maintain balance on his left foot for 3 seconds and right foot for 2 seconds with his eyes closed (30th and 25th percentiles, respectively).

6. Given the radically different portrayal of STUDENT by his mother in comparison that of Mr. Almand and Ms. Clark, the Hearing Officer requested an opportunity to see STUDENT. The mother complied, and STUDENT was present at the hearing for approximately one hour. The Hearing Officer observed STUDENT to enter the room with a gait that had a slight but obvious tilt. His mother’s use of the word “floppy,” in reference to STUDENTs’s gait, appeared to be appropriate. STUDENT demonstrated the same gait again when the hearing neared its conclusion. While STUDENT was seated at the conference table (for approximately one hour), he initially showed no signs whatsoever of the persistent head tilt that his mother had claimed would occur. During the end of the hour, however, STUDENT appeared to be getting fatigued, and his head did tilt severely to the side on one or two occasions before, somewhat spontaneously, springing back into an upright position.