California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · November 26, 2004

Student v. Charter Oak Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 220-03, SN-220-03 · Hearing Officer Deborah M. Cooke

Charter Oak Unified must add reading intervention, fund Stowell therapy plus two years of compensatory services, and reimburse a 2002 assessment.

Split decision: student prevailed on 16 of 25 issues (10 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

The decision took judicial notice of a prior expedited SEHO decision between the same parties (SN02-00822, May 2002). That decision found the District had not conducted a pre-expulsion assessment and could not proceed with expulsion, and it ordered the student returned to Charter Oak High School. No later history is noted.

Summary

A 17-year-old with a specific learning disability filed for hearing in February 2003 against Charter Oak Unified School District. Despite average-range ability, he was still reading at a fourth- to fifth-grade level as a high school senior. The Hearing Officer limited the case to the three-year limitations period. She found he made enough progress from February to April 2000. After that, the District denied a FAPE in reading in every period through the 2003-2004 school year. Its IEPs repeated reading goals and named no specific reading instruction while his scores stalled or fell.

The Hearing Officer also found that the February 2002 triennial wrongly skipped written language, and that writing instruction was inadequate from June 2002 to June 2003. Home instruction during a pending expulsion did not follow the IEP. Several ESY offers were too vague, but only the vague 2004 offer caused a loss of learning. The District won claims on prior notice, IEP team membership, cognitive testing, and a central auditory processing assessment request.

The District must:

- reimburse the parents' October 2002 Lindamood-Bell assessment;

- add intensive reading intervention to the school day;

- finish the 225 hours of Stowell Learning Center therapy, with transportation;

- then reassess and provide two more years of compensatory services.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

This decision shows how SEHO applied Rowley when a student of average ability made almost no reading progress over several years. Repeating the same goals without naming reading instruction denied FAPE. A district's own offer of outside therapy as compensatory education could form the base for a larger compensatory award.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue I. From February 2000 to April 11, 2000, did Student make sufficient educational progress in reading and written language?

    Student's standard scores and teacher reports showed more than minimal progress in reading and written language under the May 1999 IEP.

  2. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue II.A.1. Did the District change Student's placement at the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting to a more restrictive placement without providing prior written notice?

    The SDC placement was proposed in the May 1999 IEP and confirmed by an August 1999 letter, so the parents had prior written notice.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue II.A.2. Did the District fail to make a specific written program offer in the April 12, 2000 IEP for the extended school year?

    An offer of "five weeks" at the "intermediate school" was not specific enough, but it caused no loss of educational opportunity or harm to parent participation.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue II.B. From April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, did the District fail to develop a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The April 2000 IEP denied FAPE in reading because its goals expected no growth and the District did not show how the listed materials would give intensive reading instruction. The writing program was appropriate.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue III. From the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, did the District fail to develop a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    FAPE was denied in reading, where Student's scores slipped. FAPE was provided in written language, where he gained two grade levels in spelling.

  6. District prevailedAssessment

    Issue IV.A. From April 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, did the District fail to appropriately assess Student in all areas of suspected disability by not assessing phonemic awareness deficits and not conducting a full written language assessment for the April 2001 IEP?

    The 1999 triennial testing, the 2001 WRAT, teacher tests and class work gave the team enough information on phonemic awareness and writing. No reassessment was required or requested.

  7. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue IV.B.1.a. Did the District fail to have a general education teacher in attendance at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting?

    The physical education teacher attended and signed the IEP as the general education representative.

  8. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue IV.B.1.b. Did the District fail to make a specific written program offer in the April 3, 2001 IEP for the extended school year?

    No specific 2001 ESY offer was made, but Student attended summer school and passed, so FAPE was not denied.

  9. District prevailedIEP content

    Issue IV.B.2. Did the District fail to develop goals and objectives in the April 3, 2001 IEP to address Student's needs in phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing?

    The word attack and pronunciation reading goal addressed phonemic awareness, auditory processing and visual processing.

  10. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue IV.B.3. Did the District fail to develop a program in the April 3, 2001 IEP designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The District should have revised the program when Student made no reading progress. It repeated the prior reading goal and named no specific reading instruction. The writing program was appropriate.

  11. Student prevailedTransition

    Issue IV.B.4. Did the District fail to develop an individual transition plan in the April 3, 2001 IEP?

    The analysis found the IEP had no statement of transition service needs (the needs section was blank) and concluded this denied FAPE. The prevailing-party section, however, lists the District as prevailing.

  12. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue V.A. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, did the District fail to appropriately assess Student by not conducting a full written language assessment and not doing further cognitive testing after the February 27, 2002 evaluation?

    The February 2002 triennial wrongly left out written language, an area of suspected disability. No further cognitive testing was needed.

  13. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue V.B.1. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, did the District fail to develop a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    FAPE was denied in reading. There was no specific reading instruction, and the District ignored declining test scores. The writing program remained appropriate.

  14. Student prevailedImplementation

    Issue V.B.2. Did the District fail to provide a home instruction program that comported with Student's IEP from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002?

    One hour a day of home instruction limited to word-formation rules did not deliver the IEP's reading, writing and math program, which denied FAPE.

  15. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP procedure

    Issue VI.A. Did the District fail to make a specific written program offer in the June 25, 2002 IEP for the extended school year?

    Writing "TBD" for the ESY level was not a specific offer, but no loss of educational opportunity was shown.

  16. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VI.B. Did the June 25, 2002 IEP fail to provide a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The IEP had no specific reading instruction despite regression. Its writing goals rested on no current assessment of written language. It denied FAPE in both areas.

  17. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VII. From the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, did the District fail to develop a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    Only trivial reading gains were shown, and the teacher called her writing program "marginal." FAPE was denied in reading and written language.

  18. Student prevailed in partAssessment

    Issue VIII.A. At the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting, did the District fail to appropriately assess Student by not doing a full written language assessment before July 2003 and not formally declining the parents' request for a central auditory processing assessment?

    Written language still had not been reassessed. The District properly declined the central auditory processing assessment in writing in its July 9 and July 21, 2003 letters.

  19. Student prevailed in partIEP procedure

    Issue VIII.B.1. Did the District fail to make a specific written program offer in the June 30, 2003 IEP for the extended school year?

    The April 1, 2003 letter offering 136 hours of Lindamood-Bell instruction was a clear 2003 ESY offer. The June 2003 IEP made no specific 2004 ESY offer.

  20. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue VIII.B.2. Did the June 30, 2003 IEP fail to provide a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The team admitted it lacked enough data to write goals. The IEP had no specific reading instruction and was not appropriate for reading or written language.

  21. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue IX.A.1. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to make a specific written offer for the Stowell Learning Center services?

    The Stowell services were offered as compensatory education, not as part of FAPE. The October 31, 2003 letter gave enough detail anyway.

  22. Student prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue IX.A.2. Did the District fail to make a specific written program offer in the September/October 2003 IEP for the extended school year?

    The analysis found that an offer of a "summer class" left the 2004 summer teacher without the IEP or any guidance, causing lost educational opportunity and a procedural denial of FAPE. The prevailing-party section, however, lists the District as prevailing.

  23. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue IX.B. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District fail to develop a program designed to meet Student's needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

    The District kept the same corrective reading program while Student stayed at a fourth- to fifth-grade reading level, which denied FAPE in reading. The Four Square writing program was appropriate and produced progress.

  24. Issue X.A. Is Petitioner entitled to reimbursement for the 2002 and 2004 assessments completed by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center?

    The parents disagreed with the deficient February 2002 assessment, so the October 2002 Lindamood-Bell assessment must be reimbursed. The June 2004 assessment did not respond to any District assessment and is not reimbursable.

  25. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue X.B. Is Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, including transportation?

    Student is owed intensive compensatory education: the rest of the 225 Stowell Learning Center hours plus two more years of services, with transportation. The services may come from Stowell rather than Lindamood-Bell.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • IEE at public expense. Within 30 days of receiving proof of payment, the District must reimburse the parent for the October 2002 Lindamood-Bell assessment. The amount is not stated.
  • Order to convene IEP meeting. Within 15 calendar days of the decision, the IEP team must meet to (a) revise the IEP, (b) specify in writing the ESY services for summer 2005, and (c) decide how to deliver the Stowell Learning Center services, considering that the school will also be delivering FAPE at the same time.
  • Order to provide or change services. The IEP must include an intensive reading intervention program built into the school day, through which the reading goal and objectives can be addressed.
  • The District must invite Jill Stowell to the IEP meeting where delivery of the Stowell Learning Center services is discussed, and arrange for her to attend.
  • Compensatory education. The District must provide the remaining hours of the initial 225-hour Stowell Learning Center educational therapy program. About 82 hours had been delivered as of June 22, 2004.
  • Order to provide or change services. The District must provide one round trip of transportation between home or school and the Stowell Learning Center on scheduled clinic days.
  • Order to assess. After the 225 hours are completed, the District must reassess reading and written language.
  • Compensatory education. After the reassessment, the IEP team must reconvene and decide the specific compensatory services to be provided for two more years, covering decoding, reading fluency, reading comprehension and written language.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Adams v. State of Oregon; Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. of Education; Union School Dist. v. Smith; W.G. v. Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Clyde K. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Seattle School Dist. No. 1 v. B.S.; Walczak v. Florida Union Free School Dist.; Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education; S.V. v. Sherwood School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Vikki Rice, educational advocate for Student (witness)
  • Patrick Castagnaro, director of student services, Charter Oak Unified School District
  • Jill Stowell, director, private educational therapy provider (witness), Stowell Learning Center, Diamond Bar
  • Nikki Jakins, clinic director and independent assessor (witness), Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, Pasadena
  • Rayburn Walker, Jr., special day class teacher; 2004 summer school teacher, Charter Oak High School
  • Stephannie Dyl, school psychologist, Charter Oak Unified School District
  • Janice Magee, special day class English teacher and case carrier, Charter Oak High School
  • Scott Nagel, special day class English and history teacher, Royal Oak Intermediate School
  • Frank Foster, special day class teacher; home instruction teacher; co-assessor on 2002 triennial, Charter Oak High School
  • Marilyn Muzak, physical education teacher; general education member of the IEP team, Charter Oak Unified School District
  • Kathleen Mack, clinical psychologist (testified on cognitive ability)
  • Stowell Learning Center, nonpublic agency providing compensatory educational therapy
  • Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, private provider; independent assessments in 2002 and 2004

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer for the California Special Education Hearing Office (Hearing Office), University of the Pacific’s McGeorge School of Law, in Covina, California, on June 29 and 30, July 8, August 10, 12, and 13, and September 1, 2004.

STUDENT (hereafter STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented at the hearing by attorney Tania Whiteleather. Also present on behalf of Petitioner were his adult sister, SISTER, and Vikki Rice, educational advocate. Charter Oak Unified School District (hereafter District or Respondent) was represented at the hearing by attorney Cynthia Yount, from the law firm of Parker & Covert, LLP. Also present on behalf of the District was Patrick Castagnaro, director of student services for the District.

The following witnesses were called by Petitioner to testify: Vikki Rice; SISTER; MOTHER, STUDENT’s mother; Patrick Castagnaro; Jill Stowell, director of the Stowell Learning Center; Nikki Jakins, clinic director at the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center in Pasadena, California; Rayburn Walker, Jr., special day class teacher at Charter Oak High School; Stehpannie Dyl, school psychologist for the District; and Janice Magee, special day class teacher at Charter Oak High School and STUDENT’s case carrier.

The following witnesses were called by the District to testify: Scott Nagel, special day class teacher at Royal Oak Intermediate School, and STUDENT.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of the parties’ written closing arguments, which were timely postmarked. Following receipt of the parties’ closing arguments, the matter was submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On the first day of hearing, the parties clarified the issues with the Hearing Officer. The following summarizes rulings made by this Hearing Officer regarding the issues. Petitioner’s counsel raised the following issues dating back to May 1999: (1) whether the District failed to conduct any cognitive testing as part of the May 1999 triennial, (2) whether the District failed to make a specific written program offer for the 1999 extended school year, and (3) whether STUDENT made progress pursuant to his May 1999 IEP. Petitioner argued that he is entitled to raise these issues because he previously raised them in a 2002 expedited case (SN02-00822) involving the same parties and, therefore, they meet the three-year statute of limitations requirement. The District argued that Petitioner was barred from raising the three issues dating back to 1999 because they were first raised as part of the instant case in February 2003 and, thus, do not fall within the three-year statute of limitations.

This Hearing Officer reviewed the May 2, 2002 hearing tapes and file of case SN02-00822 to determine whether the above three issues were raised at hearing. The record indicates that Petitioner did not specifically raise the issues regarding cognitive testing, the extended school year, or his progress pursuant to the May 18, 1999 IEP. Moreover, the presiding hearing officer gave no indication that those issues would be part of that expedited case. (Footnote 1) The presiding Hearing Officer stated that she would only hear expedited issues that related to the manifestation determination. Moreover, this Hearing Officer found no affirmative evidence that the hearing officer in SN02-00822 bifurcated any additional nonexpedited issues, placing them off calendar to be heard at a later date.

Petitioner had the option to initiate a separate due process hearing to have any additional issues heard. Once the Decision in SN02-00822 was rendered and sent to the parties in May 2002, Petitioner was clearly on notice that the decision addressed only expedited issues. However, Petitioner did not file the instant action until February 5, 2003.

This Hearing Officer next addressed whether the three issues were timely raised given the filing date of the instant action. Education Code section 56043(p) provides that a request for a special education due process hearing must be filed within three years from the date the party initiating the request knew or had reason to know of facts underlying the basis for the request. Since this case was filed on February 5, 2003, the parties did not dispute the Hearing Officer’s jurisdiction to address issues dating back to February 5, 2000. The parties did dispute, however, whether the three issues dating back to 1999 fell within the statute of limitations.

The Hearing Officer found that Petitioner should have known by May 18, 1999, of facts underlying his claims regarding the 1999 cognitive testing and the 1999 ESY offer. Petitioner’s mother, MOTHER, and his adult sister, SISTER, both attended the May 18, 1999 IEP meeting, at which time the March 1999 evaluation results and present levels of performance were noted on STUDENT’s IEP document. Additionally, MOTHER signed the IEP indicating that she participated in the IEP process and received a copy of the parent rights and procedural safeguards. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, p. 13.) There is no evidence that Petitioner’s mother did not have the opportunity to inform the May 18, 1999 IEP team that she required more specificity in the District’s offer for the ESY. Accordingly, by May 18, 1999, Petitioner had reason to know of facts underlying the basis for his claims regarding the 1999 cognitive testing and the 1999 ESY offer. Thus, the statute of limitations period began to run on May 18, 1999, and the petition regarding those two issues had to have been filed by May 18, 2002.

The basis of Petitioner’s argument regarding his alleged lack of progress was that the District failed to identify any specific reading instruction or program in his IEP to assist with his reading and written language development. However, Petitioner knew or should have known at the May 18, 1999 IEP meeting that his program did not include the specific reading instruction recommended by the evaluation team since both his mother and adult sister attended that IEP meeting and participated in the development of the IEP. Thus, Petitioner needed to have filed his action regarding the program offered in May 1999 by May 2002, but failed to do so.

The Hearing Officer indicated at hearing, however, that the issue regarding STUDENT’s alleged failure to make educational progress pursuant to the May 18, 1999 IEP was within the Hearing Officer’s jurisdiction, because Petitioner potentially either did not know or would not have known whether he made progress in reading and written language until the next IEP meeting convened in April 2000, when Petitioner’s progress on goals and objectives from the May 1999 IEP would have been reviewed.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer will examine the May 18, 1999 IEP to the limited extent that it was the program being implemented as of February 2000, and for the limited purpose of determining whether Petitioner made sufficient progress pursuant to the May 18, 1999 IEP from February 2000 to April 11, 2000.

This matter proceeded to hearing with the issues set forth below.

ISSUES (Footnote 2)

I. From February 2000 to April 11, 2000, did STUDENT make sufficient educational progress in reading and written language?

II. From April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a fee appropriate public education (FAPE) by

A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. changing STUDENT’s placement at the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting to a more restrictive placement without providing prior written notice; and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 12, 2000 IEP for the extended school year; B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

III. From the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

IV. From April 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess phonemic awareness deficits and did not conduct a full assessment in written language in preparation for the April 2001 IEP; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. committing the following procedural errors:

a. failing to have a general education teacher in attendance at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, and b. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 3, 2001 IEP for the extended school year; 2. failing to develop goals and objectives in his April 3, 2001 IEP to address his needs in the areas of phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing;

3. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit; and 4. failing to develop an individual transition plan in the April 3, 2001

IEP?

V. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not conduct a full assessment in written language and did not do further cognitive testing after the February 27, 2002 evaluation;

B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and 2. failing to provide a home instruction program that comported with his IEP from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002?

VI. At the June 25, 2002 IEP meeting, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. failing to make a specific written program offer in the June 25, 2002 IEP for the extended school year, and B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

VII. From the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

VIII. At the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not do a full assessment in written language before July 2003, and did not formally decline the parents’ request to conduct a central auditory processing assessment; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to make a specific written program offer in the June 30, 2003 IEP for the extended school year, and 2. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

IX. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. failing to make a specific written offer for the Stowell Learning Center services, and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the September/October 2003 IEP for the extended school year;

B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

X. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:

A. reimbursement for the 2002 and 2004 assessments completed by the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center and/or B. compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center, including transportation to and from the Center?

BACKGROUND FACTS (Footnote 3)

STUDENT is a seventeen-year-old student who is eligible for special education services as a student with a specific learning disability. STUDENT currently attends Charter Oak High School in the District and will be in the twelfth grade during the 2004-2005 school year.

STUDENT has been eligible for special education since third grade. His eligibility was initially predicated on a specific learning disability due to a severe discrepancy between his intellectual ability and his academic achievement in the areas of basic reading skills, math calculation, and written expression.

STUDENT entered the District in first grade and attended first through fifth grades at the District’s Cedargrove Elementary School. During the third grade, the District placed him in a regular education classroom with resource support program (RSP) services, which he received from the third through the fifth grades. From the sixth through eighth grades, the District placed STUDENT at its Royal Oak Intermediate School. STUDENT was placed in RSP for his sixth-grade year. At the beginning of his seventh grade year, his placement was changed to a special day class (SDC) because the individualized education program (IEP) team determined that he could no longer meet his goals and objectives in a regular education classroom. When STUDENT began the ninth grade, he started attending Charter Oak High School (Charter Oak) and was placed in an SDC.

On February 27, 2002, during STUDENT’s ninth-grade school year, District school psychologist Stephannie Dyl and SDC teacher Frank Foster conducted a psychoeducational assessment of STUDENT as part of his regularly scheduled triennial assessment. On standardized tests, STUDENT scored in the low-average range of intelligence and in the second- through fourth-grade ranges in reading and written expression skills. Ms. Dyl noted that current assessments indicated that STUDENT no longer demonstrated a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement, but that he still demonstrated a need for special education services.

Ms. Dyl also assessed STUDENT in the area of social/emotional skills and described him as a “hard worker with the ability to stay focused on task.” She also described him as having a very positive and helpful attitude. She further stated that “when he is focused, he is at the top of the class. STUDENT has great behavior, he is very respectful, a leader for other students when he is at his best.”

On March 20, 2002, STUDENT was involved in a disciplinary incident that resulted in his being suspended for five days for violation of the District’s zero tolerance policy. He was recommended for expulsion from school. On March 25, 2002, the District convened an IEP meeting to discuss whether STUDENT’s behavior was a manifestation of his disability. The District members of the IEP team determined that STUDENT’s behavior was not a manifestation of his disability and that his placement at the time of the incident was appropriate. The District members also concluded that STUDENT was receiving all necessary supports and services at the time of the incident and that his disability did not impair his ability to understand the impact and consequences of his behavior or his ability to control his behavior. The IEP team agreed to change STUDENT’s placement from his ninth-grade SDC classroom to home teaching pending the expulsion process. Accordingly, from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, STUDENT was placed in home teaching, receiving individual instruction from a special education teacher one hour each day, five days a week.

On April 15, 2002, STUDENT’s parents filed a request for a due process hearing with the Special Education Hearing Office because they disagreed with the IEP team’s manifestation determination made on March 25, 2002 . (Footnote 4) They also contended that STUDENT was not appropriately placed at the time of the manifestation determination and that the District should have conducted a behavior assessment of STUDENT prior to its recommendation to expel him. In that case, the presiding hearing officer found that the District failed to conduct a preexpulsion assessment and concluded that, as a matter of law, the District could not proceed with its recommendation to expel STUDENT for the March 20, 2002 incident. The Hearing Officer ordered the District to immediately return STUDENT to his placement at Charter Oak High School. STUDENT returned to school on or about May 25, 2002.

On June 25, 2002, a triennial IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. The IEP team determined that, according to his February 2002 triennial assessment, no severe discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s ability and achievement. However, he still demonstrated a need for special education support based upon work samples and daily classroom performance. The IEP team agreed that STUDENT would again be placed in an SDC for English, science, and reading, and would be mainstreamed for physical education, up to two electives, and algebra on a six-week trial basis. Goals and objectives were written in the areas of reading, writing, and problem solving. The IEP team also agreed that STUDENT would receive individual counseling services twice a month for thirty minutes. Extended school year (ESY) services were offered, but the IEP indicated “TBD” in the section of the IEP where the level of ESY services was to be specified. STUDENT testified at hearing that he did not attend summer school during the 2002 ESY because he went to Colorado that summer.

During the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT was in the tenth grade and was placed in a special day class for reading, English, and science at Charter Oak High School. STUDENT was placed in regular education classes for algebra and physical education.

On October 3, 2002, STUDENT’s parents arranged for an independent diagnostic evaluation to be conducted by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (LMB) Center in Pasadena, California. According to the LMB assessment, STUDENT demonstrated weaknesses in concept imagery, which causes the propensity to process parts of information rather than wholes (gestalts). Test results also indicated the presence of weakness in phonemic awareness/symbol imagery – the ability to auditorily perceive and visually image the identity, number, and sequence of sounds and letters within words. LMB testing also indicated that STUDENT experienced weakness in perceiving groups of sounds and corresponding letter symbols when and where a sound and letter is added, substituted, omitted, or shifted in a syllable. LMB recommended that STUDENT receive intensive sensory-cognitive training–four hours daily–for a minimum of 200 to 240 hours.

By letter dated April 1, 2003, to Ms. Whiteleather, the District indicated that it had not received the October 2002 LMB testing results until March 2003. The District offered to provide STUDENT with instruction in the LMB methodology by trained District staff members from June 16 through August 1, 2003. The District also offered to conduct a speech and language evaluation and included an assessment plan for the parents to sign. STUDENT attended summer school during the summer of 2003, but he did not receive the LMB services the District had offered. Instead, he took an Algebra A class and earned an “A.” STUDENT ended the 2002-2003 school year with a 3.2 grade point average and no grade lower than a “C.”

On June 30, 2003, an annual IEP meeting was held for STUDENT. Petitioner’s mother and sister, along with attorney Whiteleather and advocate Rice, attended the meeting. The IEP document noted that a severe discrepancy did not exist between STUDENT’s ability and achievement according to his recent triennial assessment. However, he still demonstrated a need for special education support based upon work samples and daily classroom performance. Goals and objectives were written in the areas of math, writing, reading, and social/emotional. It was further recommended that STUDENT be placed in an SDC for reading, English, and U.S. History. The IEP team recommended that STUDENT be mainstreamed for Algebra B, with monitoring, and two electives. Extended school year services were offered, although the IEP team wrote “TBD” in the section where STUDENT’s level was to be specified.

At the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT’s counsel requested an independent education evaluation of STUDENT’s speech and language and central auditory processing skills. The parents disagreed with the statement in the IEP that STUDENT did not meet the eligibility criteria for special education and believed they needed more comprehensive test scores in order to develop an IEP that met STUDENT’s needs. The parents did not sign the IEP and it was never implemented.

By letter dated July 9, 2003, the District responded to the requests made by the parents at the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting. The District proposed to complete some of the parents’ requested assessments during the summer and to complete some of the others in the fall, after the 2003-2004 school year had begun. The District also offered to enlist the services of the Stowell Learning Center (SLC) to administer the Test of Written Language (TOWL), the Woodcock Johnson Reading Mastery Test, the Lindamood-Bell Auditory Conceptualization (LAC) Test, and the Comprehensive Assessment of Spoken Language (CASL). The District submitted a proposed assessment plan to STUDENT’s parents.

The assessment plan was returned to the District with the parent’s signature. In addition, STUDENT’s attorney, Tania Whiteleather, substantially modified the assessment plan by adding the names of specific assessment tests that the parents wanted administered. In a letter to Ms. Whiteleather dated July 21, 2003, the District rejected STUDENT’s assessment proposal and reiterated that it would conduct a speech and language assessment before determining whether a central auditory processing disorder assessment was warranted.

On July 22, 24, and 29, 2003, school psychologist Stephannie Dyl conducted academic and ability testing of STUDENT. Ms. Dyl’s July 29, 2003 report indicated that STUDENT now demonstrated a discrepancy between his ability and achievement, with processing deficits in the areas of auditory and speed of mental processing. In academic areas, STUDENT scored below expectancy in broad reading, broad writing, spelling, and in reading and writing composites. The requested speech and language assessment was not conducted as part of the District’s July 2003 evaluation.

On July 28 and 30, 2003, the Stowell Learning Center (SLC) evaluated STUDENT’s functional academic and learning skills. According to the SLC test results, the SLC concluded STUDENT would benefit from processing and skills development in the areas of auditory processing stimulation, reading and spelling, oral language, reading speed, fluency, intonation, and clarity, and oral and written language expression. Both the District testing and the SLC testing were forwarded to Petitioner’s counsel on July 30, 2003, and August 4, 2003, respectively.

The IEP team convened again on September 12, 2003. STUDENT’s mother was present; however, she declined to go forward with the meeting without her attorney. The IEP meeting was rescheduled to October 22, 2003, and STUDENT’s sister and advocate Vikki Rice attended the meeting. The District’s and the SLC’s testing results were reviewed and the IEP team concluded that STUDENT exhibited a processing disorder in the areas of attention, sensory motor skills, and auditory processing. A severe discrepancy also existed between his ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression.

The District proposed that STUDENT’s placement be changed from the SDC to RSP at the beginning of the second semester and offered him 225 hours of SLC therapy to address auditory stimulation, writing, and reading. The family expressed concerns that the test scores did not show any “narrowing of the gap” since the June 2002 testing. The parents also requested that the SLC report be modified to indicate the specific hours of recommended treatment. The family wanted to consider the District’s offer, so Petitioner’s advocate, Vikki Rice, took a draft of the IEP to be reviewed with Ms. Whiteleather and STUDENT’s mother. The parties agreed that the parents would respond to the proposed IEP by November 7, 2003.

By letter to Ms. Whiteleather and Ms. Rice dated October 31, 2003, the District provided the parents with the requested revised programming recommendations from the SLC, including a breakdown in the number of hours of specific programming components. The District also suggested that the family and Ms. Stowell determine the initial scheduling of the hours per week of the offered SLC services and communicate the final schedule to the District by November 21, 2003. The District also offered to reimburse the family for transporting STUDENT to and from the SLC.

Meanwhile, STUDENT continued attending his SDC at Charter Oak High School. Between January and March 2004, additional letters were exchanged between the parties’ counsel about the SLC services and implementation of the October 2003 IEP. The parents expressed concern about STUDENT’s being subjected to an additional five hours per day of school and travel time by attending the SLC. They also insisted that the District had not made a specific written offer of the SLC services. The parties agreed to convene an IEP meeting on March 4, 2004, at which time the IEP team reviewed the draft October 2003 IEP and agreed to amend STUDENT’s schedule to accommodate his attendance at the SLC. The parents signed the IEP in agreement and it was implemented.

STUDENT began attending the SLC after school on March 5, 2004. The schedule initially included his attending the SLC 2 hours, five days each week, after school. However, according to STUDENT and his sister Mechell, it became too difficult for the family to transport STUDENT back and forth to the SLC in Diamond Bar, California. Therefore, in May 2004, STUDENT’s SLC schedule changed to eliminate the Wednesday and Friday sessions. During the 2004 extended school year, STUDENT was enrolled in an RSP civics/economics class at Charter Oak High School that met from 7:30 a.m. to 1:00 p.m. each day. In addition, three days each week after summer school, STUDENT attended the SLC from 2 to 4 p.m. STUDENT continues to receive services from the SLC and as of June 22, 2004, he had received approximately 82 hours of SLC therapy and is approximately one-half way through the recommended program.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

I. From February 2000 to April 11, 2000, did STUDENT make sufficient educational progress in reading and written language?

STUDENT’s May 18, 1999 IEP was in effect from February 2000 to April 11, 2000. On April 12, 2000, another IEP was developed for STUDENT, which was operative for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer will examine the May 18, 1999 IEP to identify the program and services that were being implemented as of February 2000 and will determine whether Petitioner made sufficient educational progress under the May 1999 IEP from February 2000 to April 11, 2000.

The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeal has endorsed the “snapshot” rule, which holds that the actions of the school cannot “be judged exclusively in hindsight…an IEP must take into account what was, and what was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.” (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999).) (Footnote 5) However, the “snapshot” rule does not eliminate a school district’s obligation to revise a student’s educational program if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the student is not receiving any educational benefit.

Pursuant to the “snapshot” rule, the Hearing Officer must examine the IEP at the time it was developed to determine its appropriateness. Here, because the May 18, 1999 IEP was developed outside the statute of limitations time frame, the Hearing Officer does not address the appropriateness of the IEP at the time it was developed. However, the Hearing Officer will examine STUDENT’s placement and services during this time frame to determine whether he made sufficient educational progress pursuant to his May 1999 IEP.

To be appropriate under the IDEA, the District’s program must be reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. (Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 200, 102 S.Ct. 3034.) While this requires a school district to provide a disabled child with meaningful access to education, it does not mean that the school district is required to guarantee totally successful results. (Walczak v. Florida Union Free School District, 142 F.3d 119, 133 (2d Cir. 1998).) De minimis benefit or only trivial advancement, however, is insufficient to satisfy the Rowley standard of “some” benefit. (Id. at 130.) A child’s academic progress must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his or her disability and must be gauged in relation to the child’s potential. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).)

STUDENT’s Level of Performance

To determine whether STUDENT made sufficient educational progress from February 2000 to April 11, 2000, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s present levels of performance as of February 2000. There was no evidence of STUDENT’s levels of performance precisely as of February 2000, and no record of STUDENT’s progress on the May 1999 goals and objectives. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will examine STUDENT’s levels of performance in reading and written language as indicated by his May 1999 standardized and grade-level scores on standardized testing, his performance in the classroom and on teacher-made tests, and compare that information with his standardized and grade-level test scores, his class performance, and test scores at the time of the April 12, 2000 IEP to determine whether he made sufficient educational progress.

There is no dispute that from February 2000 to April 11, 2000, STUDENT was eligible for special education and related services as a child with a specific learning disability. Additionally, the parties did not dispute that during this time STUDENT demonstrated a disorder in the following basic psychological processes: visual processing, auditory processing, and sensory motor skills, and that a significant discrepancy existed between STUDENT’s intellectual ability and academic achievement in written expression and basic reading skills. (Pet.’s Exh. P-7.) STUDENT was functioning within the average range of intelligence; however, his academic functioning was reported to be below his ability. (Footnote 6) (Id.)

At the time of his May 18, 1999 IEP, STUDENT was able to read and decode at approximately the fourth-grade level, and he required intensive reading instruction to help develop his word recognition, vocabulary, word attack and general comprehension skills. His written language skills were at the fourth-grade level, and he needed to develop skills in the areas of grammar, mechanics, composition, and organization. (Dist.’s Exh. 1; Pet.’s Exh. P.)

Neither party disputed the conclusions reached by the May 18, 1999 IEP team regarding STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance.

Did STUDENT Make Sufficient Educational Progress From February 2000 to April 11, 2000?

Since STUDENT was reading and decoding at about the fourth-grade level, the May 18, 1999 IEP included two reading goals to help him develop word attack skills and general comprehension at the fifth-grade level. The IEP team also designed three written language goals to develop STUDENT’s skills in the areas of grammar, mechanics, composition, and organization. And finally, although STUDENT could perform the basic operations involving whole numbers, he needed to continue to develop skills in fractions and decimals and review division, so the IEP team developed three goals and related objectives to address these areas. (Footnote 7) (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pgs. 3-10.) The IEP provided for STUDENT’s continued placement in RSP for the remainder of the 1998-1999 school year, and placement in a more intensive program in the SDC for reading, math, English, and history at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. Extended school year services at the RSP level were also offered. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 11.)

From February 2000 to April 11, 2000, STUDENT was in the seventh grade and placed in an SDC at Royal Oak Intermediate School.

Reading

Petitioner contends that he did not make sufficient educational progress in reading. According to Petitioner, his reading scores on the March 2000 administration of the Wide Range Achievement Test-Revision 3 (WRAT-3) had not significantly improved from the time the test was last administered. The District argues that Petitioner earned passing grades, and according to the standardized test scores and teacher reports, showed educational progress. (Pet.’s Exh. T.)

The evidence does not support Petitioner’s argument that he made insufficient progress in reading during this time frame. When the WRAT-3 was last administered to STUDENT in May 1998, STUDENT was reading at the third-grade level, with a standard score of 82. (Pet.’s Exh. M-2.) At the time of his May 1999 IEP, STUDENT was reading and decoding at approximately the fourth-grade level, according to his scores on the Woodcock Johnson-Revised Tests of Achievement. STUDENT had a standard score of 75 on the letter-word identification subtest, a standard score of 91 in passage comprehension, and a standard score of 81 in broad reading. (Pet.’s Exh. R.) In March 2000, STUDENT’s score on the reading portion (word recognition) of the WRAT-3 showed his word recognition skills had advanced to the fifth-grade level, with a standard score of 87. (Pet.’s Exh. T-1.)

According to STUDENT’s seventh-grade SDC English and history/social studies teacher, Scott Nagel, STUDENT’s disability profoundly affected his phonemic awareness skills, which caused him to have difficulty with irregularly spelled and multisyllabic words. Because STUDENT was unable to read at grade level, the rate of instruction had to be slowed down to his functional level so that information could be reinforced. Although STUDENT’s SDC reading teacher did not testify at hearing, Mr. Nagel gave persuasive testimony about the progress STUDENT made in reading, as evidenced by his achievement on teacher tests in history and language arts. (Footnote 8) Mr. Nagel testified that an increase in a student’s standard scores, not grade scores, on standardized tests demonstrates progress. By April 11, 2000, STUDENT had increased his word recognition skills by more than two grade levels, and his standard score in that area had increased from 75 to 87 since May 1999. In addition, a comparison of his WRAT-3 standard scores in reading from May 1998 and March 2000 shows an increase from 82 to 87.

The Hearing Officer finds there was sufficient evidence to show that STUDENT made more than minimal progress in reading pursuant to his May 18, 1999 IEP. By April 2000, STUDENT’s standard scores in reading had substantially increased since May 1999, his SDC English and history teacher saw improvement in STUDENT’s reading abilities in his class performance, and STUDENT was beginning to transfer and use word attack skills on multi-syllabic words. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 20.)

Taking into consideration STUDENT’s average intellectual ability and how his disability profoundly impacted his sight word recognition, vocabulary, and word attack skills, the Hearing Officer concludes that STUDENT made sufficient educational progress in reading pursuant to the May 18, 1999 IEP, including the period from February 2000 to April 11, 2000.

Written Language

Petitioner also contends that he did not make appropriate educational progress in written language.

At the time of the May 18, 1999 IEP, STUDENT’s written language skills were between the third- and fourth-grade levels. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pgs. 3-5.) STUDENT’s May 1999 written language goals and objectives were addressed in his SDC English and history classes. Scott Nagel had agreed with the May 1999 IEP team’s decision to move STUDENT to an SDC at the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year since his scores on standardized tests indicated he was three to four years behind in the area of language arts. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pgs. 3-5.) Therefore, STUDENT was placed in Mr. Nagel’s SDC so he could receive more intensive instruction. According to Mr. Nagel, he used writing and spelling programs that were tailored to STUDENT’s instructional level and directed at his writing goals and objectives. Mr. Nagel testified that while in his class, STUDENT received some one-to-one instruction when he had difficulty understanding a certain concept. Mr. Nagel also testified that he used a “phonetically-based” spelling book in his class for language arts. Every Monday in his class, STUDENT would complete a phonics lesson in spelling and participate in writing activities that required him to use the spelling words in sentences to show he could spell correctly and understand the meaning of the words.

STUDENT’s May 1999 IEP goals and objectives anticipated that by April 2000, STUDENT would be able to write a paragraph of five sentences, and in that paragraph, use capital letters at the beginning of each sentence, correct punctuation marks at the end of each sentence, and use a subject and verb in each sentence. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 5.) As of April 12, 2000, STUDENT’s test grades and performance in class reflected he could write a good sentence composed of at least seven words, use correct capitalization, and correctly punctuate the ends of sentences. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 21; testimony of S. Nagel.) STUDENT continued to have difficulty with spelling, however, as evidenced in his March 2000 second-grade-level spelling score on the WRAT-3. (Pet.’s Exh. T-1.) Although STUDENT did not make progress in every area of written language, particularly in spelling, according to teacher reports, he did make progress in some areas of written language, including sentence composition, capitalization, and ending punctuation. (Testimony of S. Nagel; see also Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 21.)

Mr. Nagel testified that although STUDENT’s progress on the May 1999 goals was not noted in the body of the April 12, 2000 IEP, his progress could be inferred from the new benchmarks that were developed. The May 1999 IEP goals and objectives focused on paragraph and sentence development, beginning of sentence capitalization, and end of sentence punctuation. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 5.) STUDENT’s April 2000 IEP reflected his improved written language skills in that the goals and objectives addressed different aspects of sentence structure and paragraph development, including, mid-sentence punctuation, topic sentences, and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 21.)

Although his spelling skills were at the second-grade level, STUDENT’s progress, overall, in written language must be viewed in light of the limitations imposed by his learning disability. (Mrs. B. v. Milford Board of Education, 103 F.3d 1114, 1121 (2d Cir. 1997).) It is not uncommon for students with learning disabilities, particularly those with average-range intelligence such as STUDENT, to have variable skills, thus causing them to perform well in one academic area and perform poorly in another. It is also not uncommon for students with learning disabilities to progress at a pace slower than their regular education peers. Moreover, it is not necessary for a child to improve in every area to obtain educational benefit from his IEP. Considering the profoundness of STUDENT’s disability, particularly in the area of phonemic awareness as identified by Mr. Nagel, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT’s improvement in written language was commensurate with his expected level of achievement.

In light of STUDENT’s having made progress on his IEP written language goals and objectives with respect to his sentence development, capitalization, and end of sentence punctuation, and there being no persuasive evidence to the contrary, the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT made sufficient educational progress in written language pursuant to his May 18, 1999 IEP, including the period from February 2000 to April 11, 2000.

*******

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that with respect to his reading and written language needs from February 2000, to April 11, 2000, STUDENT made sufficient educational progress.

II. From April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. changing STUDENT’s placement at the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting to a more restrictive placement without providing prior written notice, and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 12, 2000 IEP for the extended school year;

B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Under both State law and the federal Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education (FAPE). (20 U.S.C. § 1400(d); Education Code § 56000.) The term “free appropriate public education” means special education and related services that are available to the student at no charge to the parent or guardian, that meet the State educational standards, and that conform to the student=s individualized educational program (IEP). (20 U.S.C. § 1401(8).)

“Special education” is defined as specially designed instruction, at no cost to parents, to meet the unique needs of the student. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(25).) The term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective, and supportive services as may be required to assist a child to benefit from special education. (20 U.S.C. § 1401(22).) California Education Code § 56363(a) similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California=s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.”

In Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 102 S.Ct. 3034, the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the IDEA (now IDEA ‘97). The Court determined that a student’s IEP must be reasonably calculated to provide the student with some educational benefit. (Id. at 200.) According to Rowley, the IDEA does not require school districts to provide special education students with the best education available, or to provide instruction or services that maximize a student=s abilities. (Id. at 198-200.) The Court stated that school districts are required to provide only a “basic floor of opportunity” that consists of access to specialized instruction and related services, which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. (Id. at 201.)

To determine whether the District provided STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE), one must focus on the adequacy of the District=s program. (Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987).) If the District=s program reflected STUDENT’s needs, provided some benefit, and comported with his IEP, the District provided a FAPE, even if the parents preferred another program and even if the parents= preferred program would have resulted in greater educational benefit. (Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314.) Special education law also requires that STUDENT be educated in the least restrictive environment and that removal from the regular education environment occur only when the nature or severity of his disabilities is such that education in regular classes with the use of supplementary aids and services could not have been achieved satisfactorily. (20 U.S.C. § 1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code § 56031.)

To summarize, under the IDEA and Rowley, the District’s proposed program for each time frame in question must have met the following four requirements in order to have constituted a substantively appropriate educational program: (1) been designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs; (2) been reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit; and (3) comported with his IEP. Additionally, the placement must have been provided in the least restrictive environment. (Footnote 9)

Additionally, parents of children with disabilities are provided procedural protections under the IDEA and federal regulations implementing the IDEA. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; 34 C.F.R. § 300 et seq.) Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the appropriate public education to which he/she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. (W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, 960 F.2d 1479, 1483 (9th Cir. 1992).) The Supreme Court noted in Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, (1982) 458 U.S. 176, 205-206, 102 S.Ct. 3034, that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation” at every step “as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP.” Procedural flaws, however, do not automatically require a finding of a denial of a FAPE. (W.G., supra, 960 F.2d at 1484.) Procedural violations which result in a “loss of educational opportunity” or which “seriously infringe the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” (Id.)

A. Alleged Procedural Deficiencies

The analysis of whether a student has been provided a free appropriate public education (FAPE) is twofold, requiring the Hearing Officer to decide whether procedural steps have been followed and whether the proposed program and placement are substantively appropriate.

Petitioner asserts two procedural violations occurred at the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting, each of which will be addressed separately below.

1. Placement Change

Petitioner contends that during the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting, the District changed his placement from the RSP classroom to a more restrictive environment, an SDC, without providing notice prior to the IEP meeting of its intent to do so. The District argues that STUDENT’s change in placement did not occur in April 2000, nor was the change proposed or refused by the District.

Federal law requires that a district provide the parent with prior written notice a reasonable time before the district proposes to change the educational placement of a child or the provision of FAPE to a child. (34 C.F.R. § 300.503.) According to STUDENT’s May 18, 1999 IEP, the IEP team recommended that from May 1999 through June 1999, STUDENT remain in the RSP classroom, and that beginning in September 1999, he be placed in an SDC for English, social studies, reading, and math. (Pet.’s Exh. S, pg. 11.) (Footnote 10) According to the signature page of the May 1999 IEP, STUDENT’s mother and his adult sister, SISTER, both attended that meeting, and STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP acknowledging her participation in the development of the IEP and giving her permission for its implementation. (Pet.’s Exh. S, pg. 13.) In addition, SISTER testified that during the May 18, 1999 IEP meeting, she requested that STUDENT be placed in an SDC. According to SISTER, she wanted STUDENT to be placed in an SDC because she had been informed that he could receive more help with his reading there and she believed the RSP class was not allowing him to make progress.

Because the April 2000 IEP included a recommendation to place STUDENT in an SDC, Petitioner argues that the District was required to provide the parent with reasonable prior written notice. As discussed below, the District appropriately complied.

Petitioner was notified in the May 18, 1999 IEP document that the IEP team was recommending that he be moved to an SDC for the forthcoming 1999-2000 school year. (Dist.’s Exh. 1, pg. 11.) The District also provided the parents with a written notice of STUDENT’s class placement before the beginning of the 1999-2000 school year. By letter dated August 27, 1999, from the District to STUDENT’s parents, the District further informed the parents that STUDENT would be assigned to an SDC at Royal Oaks Intermediate School for the seventh grade. (Dist.’s Exh. 2, pg. 15.) (Footnote 11) STUDENT began attending the SDC at the beginning of his seventh-grade year. (Testimony of S. Nagel.) After the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT continued his placement in the SDC. The evidence presented indicates that the parents were provided with written notice of the District’s intent to change STUDENT’s placement a reasonable time before the actual placement change occurred.

2. ESY Offer

The parties do not dispute that STUDENT=s needs entitled him to receive ESY programming for the summer of 2000. Rather, the parties dispute whether the District made a specific written offer of services for the 2000 ESY. Petitioner alleges that the District failed to identify in writing a specific program for the 2000 ESY in the April 12, 2000 IEP. The District contends that Petitioner failed to show any evidence that the parent did not agree to, understand, or have the opportunity to allow STUDENT to avail himself of the ESY services determined to be appropriate by the IEP team. The District also argues that there was no evidence that the District had not adequately defined the ESY services or that there was any procedural violation of the IEP process.

Extended school year services are defined as special education and related services that are provided to a child with a disability, beyond the district=s normal school year, in accordance with the child=s IEP, at no cost to the parents of the child, and meet the standards of the special education agency. (34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b).) Where a child has been determined eligible for ESY services by his or her IEP team, the written IEP must include an ESY program. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345(b)(3); see also 34 C.F.R. § 300.309(b)(1)(ii); 5 C.C.R. § 3043(f).) Moreover, a school district is required to make a formal offer of placement in writing in order to be in compliance with the IDEA’s procedural requirements. (Union v. Smith (9th Cir. 1994) 15 F.3d 1519, 1526, cert. denied (1994), 115 S.Ct. 428; 20 U.S.C. § (b)(3).)

The District offered STUDENT ESY services for the 2000 extended school year by simply checking the “Yes” box for ESY on the April 12, 2000 IEP, and by specifying STUDENT’s level of placement during the ESY as “five weeks” at the “intermediate school.” (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 18.) However, there is no other specific information included in the April 12, 2000 IEP (i.e., in the IEP meeting notes) about what services the program would include, the number of hours per day, the days per week STUDENT would receive instruction, or the type of classroom in which he would be placed during the summer months.

The District was required under Union to make a written offer of ESY services that was sufficiently clear to satisfy the IDEA, and it failed to do so. The Hearing Officer concludes that offering STUDENT “five weeks” of instruction at the “intermediate level” does not adequately specify the program and services that STUDENT would receive during the ESY.

However, the record indicates that STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, attended the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting and signed the IEP document acknowledging that she participated in the process, received a copy of the parent rights and procedural safeguards, and gave her permission for implementation of the IEP. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 23.) There was no showing that the parents did not agree to, understand, or have the opportunity to avail themselves of the ESY services determined to be appropriate by the IEP team. Additionally, there was no indication that the District’s lack of specificity in its offer of ESY services affected STUDENT’s decision to attend summer school or his parents’ decision regarding the April 2000 IEP.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that, based on the limited facts presented, there was no persuasive evidence that the District’s failure to make a specific written ESY offer caused STUDENT to lose educational opportunity or that it seriously infringed his parents’ opportunity to participate in the formulation of his IEP. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to provide a more detailed written offer for the 2000 ESY did not result in a procedural denial of a FAPE to STUDENT.

B. Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

As stated earlier, the standard for evaluating the substantive appropriateness of the District’s program involves three factors: whether the program was designed to address STUDENT’s unique needs, whether the program was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit, and whether the program conformed to his IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1400 et seq.; Rowley, supra, 458 U.S. 176.)

Petitioner alleges that his April 12, 2000 IEP failed to identify any specific reading instruction or program to meet his needs and assist him in his reading development. Petitioner contends that he made almost no educational progress in the areas of reading and written language.

The District argues that the April 12, 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. According to the District, the IEP document included goals deemed appropriate for STUDENT, based on his present levels of performance in the areas of reading, math, and written language. The District also contends that STUDENT made appropriate educational progress as evidenced by his advancement to the eighth grade, standardized test scores, and teacher reports.

STUDENT’s Needs

To determine whether the District’s program contained in the April 12, 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit, it is first necessary to identify STUDENT’s unique needs. At the time of the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting, STUDENT continued to demonstrate a disorder in sensory motor skills, visual processing, and auditory processing. A severe discrepancy continued to exist between his ability and achievement in basic reading and written expression, and now also in math calculation. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 16.) STUDENT’s reading skills had improved since the May 1999 IEP, as he was reading at the fifth-grade level, but required assistance with phonetics and irregularly spelled words. He also needed to continue working on his word attack and vocabulary skills.

Overall, STUDENT’s written language skills were at the fourth-grade level, but his spelling skills were at the second-grade level. (Testimony of S. Nagel.) STUDENT needed to continue working on his mid-sentence punctuation, spelling, and paragraph development. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 21; Pet.’s Exh. T-3.) Neither party disputed the April 12, 2000 IEP team’s identification of STUDENT’s needs.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Him With Some Educational Benefit

The April 12, 2000 IEP remained operative for the remainder of the 1999-2000 school year. The April 2000 IEP included one reading goal designed to increase STUDENT’s ability to pronounce words, comprehend their meaning, and grasp the main idea. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 20.) STUDENT’s IEP states that, as of April 2000, he was reading at the fifth-grade level, based on his scores on the Wide Range Achievement Test 3 (WRAT-3). The IEP team drafted the reading goal to be met at the fourth- and fifth-grade levels, with 79 percent accuracy. The reading objectives in the April 2000 IEP indicate that the responsible instructor would use the “Reading Master IV” lessons and the “Barefoot Island” and “Ride the Sunrise” books. The April 12, 2000 IEP also included one English goal to address STUDENT’s deficits in the use of middle punctuation, organization of sentences into paragraphs, and spelling. One math goal was included to address STUDENT’s difficulty in applying computation skills to math application problems. STUDENT was placed in an SDC program for English, math, social studies, and reading, and participated in one mainstream elective course and regular education physical education class.

Petitioner does not dispute the appropriateness of the placement offered in the April 12, 2000 IEP. However, Petitioner objects to the appropriateness of the IEP with respect to reading and written language needs.

Reading

Petitioner contends that he required more intensive reading instruction than was offered by the District. Petitioner also argues that the April 12, 2000 IEP’s goals and objectives were not appropriate and that he did not progress.

The District contends that the level of services it offered was appropriate, given STUDENT’s deficits. The District further contends that the April 12, 2000 IEP includes goals deemed appropriate for STUDENT, based on his unrefuted present levels of performance in reading. STUDENT showed educational progress based on standardized test scores and teacher reports, earned passing grades, and advanced to the eighth grade.

The Hearing Officer examines the April 12, 2000 IEP to determine whether the IEP took into account what the IEP team knew or reasonably should have known at the time it was developed.

A review of the April 2000 IEP reading goal and objectives indicates that in spite of STUDENT’s average intelligence, and his reported fifth-grade-level word recognition skills, the IEP team drafted the reading goal and objectives that appeared to expect that, within a year’s time, STUDENT would remain at the fourth- and fifth-grade reading level. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 20.) District witnesses testified that in spite of STUDENT’s learning disabilities, STUDENT had average-range cognitive abilities and could be expected to make progress in reading and read at a good, average level. (Testimonies of S. Nagel and S. Dyl.)

Moreover, the Hearing Officer was provided no explanation as to how the instructional materials listed in the April 2000 IEP were to be used with STUDENT, or whether those materials would provide the intensive reading instruction necessary to meet his needs in reading. STUDENT’s seventh-grade SDC reading teacher did not testify at the hearing.

The general rule is that at the administrative hearing, districts have the burden of proof (burden of persuasion) to show their compliance with the IDEA. (Clyde K. v. Puyallup School District No. 3, 35 F.3d 1396, 1398 (9th Cir. 1994); Seattle School District No. 1 v. B.S., et al., (9th Cir. 1996) 82 F.3d 1493.) In the instant matter, the District failed to show that the April 12, 2000 IEP team developed a program that was designed to address STUDENT’s identified deficits in phonemic awareness, word recognition, word attack, vocabulary, and reading comprehension skills. There was no persuasive evidence as to how or whether the instructional materials listed in the IEP would address STUDENT’s April 12, 2000 IEP reading goals and objectives and no indication that his seventh-grade SDC reading class would be the appropriate placement in which to implement his reading goal and objectives.

Because STUDENT had average cognitive abilities and was already reading at the fifth-grade level, the Hearing Officer finds there was no convincing evidence that the April 2000 IEP reading goal and objectives were designed to meet his needs or reasonably calculated to provide him sufficient educational benefit. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that that April 12, 2000 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s reading needs, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT educational benefit in reading.

Written Language

Petitioner contends that the April 12, 2000 IEP written language goals and objectives were not appropriate and that he failed to make appropriate educational progress in written language. The District contends that the April 12, 2000 IEP identified STUDENT’s present levels of performance and included goals appropriate to address his written language needs.

At the time the April 12, 2000 IEP was drafted, STUDENT still needed much work on mid-sentence punctuation, organization of his sentences into paragraphs, and spelling. STUDENT continued to be offered placement in an SDC English and history class taught by Mr. Nagel and a new English goal and related objectives were drafted to address his specific needs in paragraph development, sentence structures, mid-sentence punctuation, and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 21.) The evidence demonstrated that STUDENT’s English goal would be addressed in STUDENT’s SDC English and history classes. From April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, STUDENT continued to receive the same instruction in Mr. Nagel’s SDC classes that the Hearing Officer found above to be appropriate in meeting STUDENT’s written language needs.

The Hearing Officer found persuasive Mr. Nagel’s testimony about how he used various writing and spelling programs in his SDC classes that were designed for STUDENT’s instructional level and directed at his writing goals and objectives. According to Mr. Nagel, at no time did the IEP team believe STUDENT’s program needed to be changed, because STUDENT was making progress in his classes while working on the April 12, 2000 English goal and objectives. There was no persuasive evidence to the contrary.

In light of all of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the IEP dated April 12, 2000, was designed meet STUDENT’s written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in written language.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner did not assert that the District failed to provide the program and services identified in his April 12, 2000 IEP.

*******

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to substantively provide STUDENT a FAPE with respect to his reading needs from April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year.

III. From the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Petitioner contends that during the 2000-2001 school year, the District failed to provide him a program that was designed to meet his reading and written language needs and calculated to allow him to make appropriate educational progress. The District argues that it provided an educational program that included agreed-upon goals and which addressed STUDENT’s needs in reading, written language, and math. According to the District, although standardized testing did not indicate progress in reading, STUDENT made good progress towards meeting all of his goals and progressed two grade levels in spelling.

There were two IEPs operative during the 2000-2001 school year. (Footnote 12) The April 12, 2000 IEP was developed during the prior school year and remained in effect until April 3, 2001, when another IEP was developed. STUDENT’s Needs

The parties did not dispute that at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT continued to have unique needs in reading and written language that required his placement in an SDC. STUDENT continued to need intensive reading instruction to help him develop his sight word recognition, vocabulary, and word attack skills. He also continued to need much work on middle punctuation, organization of sentences into paragraphs, and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pgs. 20-21.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

Reading

The April 12, 2000 IEP was operative at the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year. The Hearing Officer already determined above that the April 12, 2000 IEP was not appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s reading needs or calculated to provide him educational benefit because the goal and objectives appeared to expect minimal, if any, growth, and the District failed to explain whether the instructional materials listed in the IEP would provide STUDENT the intensive reading instruction he required.

The record does not indicate that STUDENT’s reading program changed during the period from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year through April 2, 2001. Although various instructional materials were listed in the April 2000 IEP, presumably to be utilized in addressing STUDENT’s reading goal and objectives, there was no evidence regarding the appropriateness of those materials to address STUDENT’s reading needs and whether they would be used in STUDENT’s eighth-grade SDC reading class. STUDENT’s SDC reading teacher did not testify at the hearing. Therefore, the Hearing Officer draws a similar conclusion about the April 2000 IEP with respect to the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001 time frame as she did regarding the time frame from April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year.

Petitioner contends that not only was his program not reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, but also he failed to make sufficient reading progress during this time frame. Indeed, the record reflects that STUDENT’s program did not produce more than minimal advancement in reading. STUDENT continued to have weak phonemic awareness skills, as evidenced by his standardized test scores in reading on the WRAT-3, which decreased from 87 in April 2000, to 85 in March 2001, indicating some regression in that area. (Dist.’s Exh. 6.) A March 31, 2001 annual re-evaluation teacher report also reflects STUDENT’s continued difficulty with multisyllabic words and notes his teacher’s recommendation that he continue placement in a special day class. (Id.)

On the basis of the above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to meet its burden of proving that the April 12, 2000 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique reading needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to at least April 2, 2001. Moreover, the evidence establishes that he did not progress.

Written Language

Mr. Nagel continued as STUDENT’s SDC English and history teacher through the entire 2000-2001 school year, providing the same program found in the April 12, 2000 IEP that the Hearing Officer determined above to have been designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit from April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year. Additionally, the Hearing Officer finds persuasive Mr. Nagel’s testimony of how he addressed STUDENT’s needs in his classes. Mr. Nagel was knowledgeable about STUDENT’s learning disability and educational needs. Moreover, STUDENT’s program was personalized to address his difficulties with paragraph development, mid-sentence punctuation, and spelling, and the instruction he received was directed at his IEP goals and objectives and State standards. (Testimony of S. Nagel.)

The evidence shows that the services STUDENT received in Mr. Nagel’s SDC classes from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, continued to be provided in a coordinated and collaborative manner. Not only was the program calculated to provide STUDENT benefit, but the evidence also showed that STUDENT actually progressed in his special education program from the beginning of the school year to April 2, 2001. STUDENT’s March 31, 2001 WRAT scores indicated he had made substantial gains in spelling since March 2000. (Dist.’s Exh. 6.) STUDENT’s spelling score on the WRAT had improved by two grade levels, increasing his standard score from 71 to 77. (Id.) In addition, Mr. Nagel testified that, based on teacher-made tests in social studies (history) and language arts, STUDENT showed much improvement in the length of sentences he could write and short paragraph writing. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 40.) By April 2001, STUDENT had met two of his previous written language objectives and made “good progress” on the April 2000 written language goal. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 41.)

The Hearing Officer concludes that from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to at least April 2, 2001, STUDENT received a FAPE with respect to his written language needs.

Comported with His IEP

Petitioner did not assert that the District failed to provide the program and services identified in the April 12, 2000 IEP during this time frame.

*******

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to substantively provide STUDENT a FAPE from the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, with respect to his reading needs.

IV. From April 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess phonemic awareness deficits and did not conduct a full assessment in written language in preparation for the April 2001 IEP; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. committing the following procedural errors:

a. failing to have a general education teacher in attendance at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, and b. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 3, 2001 IEP for the extended school year;

2. failing to develop goals and objectives in his April 3, 2001 IEP to address his needs in the areas of phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing;

3. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit; and 4. failing to develop an individual transition plan in the April 3,

2001 IEP?

A. Appropriate Assessment

Petitioner alleges that although phonemic awareness was identified as an area of need at the April 2001 IEP meeting, no assessment was done to assess those skills. Petitioner also argues that the District developed a written expression goal in the April 3, 2001 IEP without first determining his grade-level ability in written language through any standardized assessment.

The District contends that it previously assessed Petitioner’s phonemic awareness needs during STUDENT’s triennial evaluation in March 1999 and through testing completed in March 2001. The District argues that reassessment of STUDENT’s phonemic awareness skills was not warranted in April 2001, and that neither the parent nor STUDENT’s teacher requested such reassessment. The District did not express a position regarding the assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills. However, a District witness provided testimony indicating that a written language assessment was not warranted.

Special education law requires that an educational agency assess a student in all areas related to his/her suspected disability. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56320(f).) Furthermore, State and federal law set forth a procedure to be followed when determining whether to reassess a student. California law requires a district to reassess a special education student at least once every three years or more frequently, if conditions warrant a reassessment, or if the student’s parent or teacher requests reassessment and a new IEP to be developed. (See Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2).) The purpose of the assessment is to gather all relevant information that will assist the IEP team in identifying the student as a child with a disability and provide the team with the information it will need to develop an appropriate IEP. (20 U.S.C. § 1414(b)(2)(A).)

Assessing Phonemic Awareness Skills

School psychologist Stephannie Dyl testified that the Letter-Word Identification subtest on the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement-Revised (WJ-R) tests phonemic awareness skills. The District multidisciplinary evaluation team administered the WJ-R to STUDENT in March 1999 and found STUDENT’s letter-word identification skills to be at the 2.8 grade level. (Pet.’s Exh. R-1.) Additionally, Mr. Nagel testified that STUDENT demonstrated difficulty with decoding in class and, according to Jill Stowell, director of the Stowell Learning Center, decoding errors are also indicative of a phonemic awareness deficit. (Footnote 13) (Dist.’s Exh. 36, pg. 180.)

SDC teacher Scott Nagel testified that he administered the Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) to STUDENT in March 2001, which measured his phonemic ability. According to Mr. Nagel, STUDENT’s March 2001 scores on the WRAT demonstrated a slight decrease in his phonemic awareness skills. The test also indicated his difficulty with decoding, particularly with irregularly spelled words and three- to four-syllable words. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 40.) Mr. Nagel also testified that the District’s 1999 testing, along with STUDENT’s performance on class work and on teacher-made tests, provided sufficient information about STUDENT’s phonemic awareness difficulties.

Part of the IEP team’s responsibility in assessing a student is to gather all relevant information that will assist the IEP team in identifying the student as a child with a disability. The evidence demonstrates that the District administered sufficient testing to assess STUDENT’s phonemic awareness skills. According to Mr. Nagel, the April 3, 2001 IEP team relied upon STUDENT’s 2001 WRAT scores, his 1999 triennial evaluation scores, teacher testing, and his class performance to determine that STUDENT’s phonemic awareness skills were still an area of concern. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District properly assessed STUDENT’s phonemic awareness skills.

Assessing Written Language Petitioner claims that it was not until July 2003 that the District assessed his written language skills. Petitioner argues that the April 2001 IEP team simply relied on his March 2001 Wide Range Achievement Test (WRAT) spelling score and failed to determine his grade-level ability in written language through any standardized assessment.

Petitioner’s argument that the District failed to appropriately assess his written language skills is not persuasive. The March 1999 multidisciplinary evaluation team administered the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement, which included an assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills. (Pet.’s Exh. P.) When the IEP team convened in April 2001, it had available information on his class work, his performance on teacher-made tests, and his scores on the WRAT.

Mr. Nagel persuasively testified that the during the April 2001 IEP meeting, the team reviewed STUDENT’s progress on the goals and objectives to assess his present levels of performance. A comparison of the 2000 and 2001 written language goals indicates that the IEP team determined that STUDENT needed to continue working on paragraph development, middle punctuation, and spelling, and that they expected him to increase his functioning in writing from the fourth- to the fifth-grade level. (Dist.’s Exhs. 3, pg. 21 and 7, pg. 37.)

There was no evidence that the parent or teacher had requested a written language assessment. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District was not required to conduct a reassessment of STUDENT’s written language skills at the April 2001 IEP. The IEP team had sufficient information from 1999 and 2001 standardized testing and STUDENT’s teachers to develop appropriate goals and objectives and recommend a placement and services.

B. FAPE

Petitioner asserts two procedural violations occurred with respect to the April 3, 2001 IEP, each of which is addressed separately below.

1. Alleged Procedural Deficiencies a. General Education Teacher at IEP Meeting

Petitioner contends that the District failed to have a general education teacher present at his April 3, 2001 IEP meeting.

Since STUDENT was participating in the regular education environment for physical education and one mainstream elective course, at least one of his regular education teachers was required to be a member of the IEP team. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56341(b)(2).) Petitioner appears to argue that because Ms. Muzak’s signature was not included on what Mr. Nagel described as the “make-shift” sign-off sheet used by the IEP team on April 3, 2001, to indicate that they reviewed STUDENT’s progress on the previous year’s IEP’s goals, she did not attend the April 2001 IEP meeting. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 23.)

However, testimony from Mr. Nagel, who attended the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, indicates that STUDENT’s physical education teacher, Marilyn Muzak, attended that meeting as the general education representative. A copy of the signature page of STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP shows Ms. Muzak’s signature, indicating her attendance at that meeting. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 39.)

Mr. Nagel also testified that although he did not know exactly why Ms. Muzak did not sign the “sign off” sheet pertaining to review of the goals, it simply may have been an oversight, or the IEP team may have felt that it was not necessary for STUDENT’s physical education teacher to sign off regarding his former academic goals.

Petitioner did not refute any of Mr. Nagel’s testimony that Ms. Muzak was present at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting as the general education teacher representative. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that the evidence persuasively indicates that Ms. Muzak was present at the April 2001 IEP meeting and participated, to the extent appropriate, as required by law.

b. ESY Offer

Petitioner again contends that the District failed to identify the ESY services in the April 3, 2001 IEP necessary to help STUDENT maintain his skills. The District argues that the April 3, 2001 IEP states that ESY services were to be at the high school level. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 31.) STUDENT attended summer school during the 2001 summer session, taking a Health and Careers class, and earning a B-. The District therefore argues that there was no evidence that STUDENT lost any educational opportunity.

STUDENT’s SDC English teacher, Scott Nagel, testified that the IEP team typically did not write in the IEP document the classes that it recommended for the ESY because checking the ESY box on the IEP document makes a student automatically eligible for services and guarantees a student a spot in a summer class. According to Mr. Nagel, STUDENT’s summer school program should have been written on another document and would have included his being mainstreamed with regular education students during the ESY.

Neither Mr. Nagel nor any other witness provided testimony regarding discussions at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting about the District’s 2001 ESY offer. Nor was there evidence of any separate document that specified the District’s offered 2001 ESY program for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District failed to make a specific written offer for the 2001 ESY. However, notwithstanding the District’s failure to make a specific written offer of services for the 2001 ESY, the record indicates that STUDENT attended summer school, took one class, and earned a passing grade of B-. (Dist.’s Exh. 63.) There is no showing that the District’s failure resulted in a “loss of educational opportunity” or that it “seriously infringed the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process.” Consequently, the Hearing Officer finds this procedural error did not amount to a denial of FAPE.

2 – 4. Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

Petitioner alleges that the IEP of April 3, 2001, did not include goals and objectives or services to address his identified needs in the areas of phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing. Petitioner argues that the District failed to amend his educational program on April 3, 2001, when he had made no progress on the reading and written language goals and objectives from the prior IEP. Petitioner also alleges that his April 3, 2001 IEP did not include an individual transition plan.

The District contends that STUDENT’s needs, including phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing, were addressed through goals in his IEP pertaining to reading, spelling, and written language. According to the District, throughout the benchmark periods, STUDENT had made progress on almost all of his goals and objectives and that, therefore, a change in his program and services was not warranted. The District also contends that an individual transition plan is included in his April 3, 2001 IEP and his parent agreed to its appropriateness.

STUDENT’s Needs

According to the April 3, 2001 IEP document, STUDENT was still reading at the fourth to fifth-grade level and continued to have difficulty with multisyllabic words and irregular letter combinations and their sounds. He also needed to work further on paragraph development, middle punctuation, and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pgs. 36 and 37.) Therefore, he required the intensive services of a special day class, with specific instruction in reading and written language.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

The April 3, 2001 IEP includes one reading goal and related objectives to address STUDENT’s difficulties with multisyllabic words and irregular letter combinations and their sounds. The IEP also includes one writing goal with objectives to address STUDENT’s need for further development of paragraph writing, mid-sentence punctuation, and spelling. One math goal was also included to assist STUDENT with fraction calculations. The offer continued his placement in the SDC program five days each week for all academic subjects, and participation in regular education for physical education and one elective. Extended school year services were offered at the high school level. (Dist.’s Exh. 7.)

Goals in Phonemic Awareness, Visual Processing, and Auditory Processing

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by Petitioner’s argument that the April 3, 2001 IEP failed to include goals and objectives designed to address his difficulties with phonemic awareness, auditory processing, and visual processing. A review of the IEP reveals a reading goal with related objectives that address STUDENT’s specific needs in these areas. The reading goal focuses on pronouncing words correctly and comprehending concepts presented in reading material composed of stories and passages. The reading objectives address word attack skills and the correct pronunciation and comprehension of various words. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 36.)

According to Jill Stowell, auditory processing is directly related to a person’s level of phonemic awareness – the ability to think about the number, order, and identity of sounds and syllables within words. (Dist.’s Exh. 36, pg. 177.) According to school psychologist Stephannie Dyl, development of STUDENT’s word pronunciation and word attack skills addresses his phonemic awareness and auditory processing needs. Ms. Dyl also testified that the same reading goal and objectives would address a visual processing deficit. Improving STUDENT’s word attack skills would require that STUDENT be able to first see the words printed on a page, attach a meaning to the symbols making up the words, process the words, and then give the appropriate written or verbal response. (Footnote 14)

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the testimony of Ms. Dyl and Ms. Stowell that the reading goal and objectives included in STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP were appropriately designed to address his phonemic awareness, auditory processing, and visual processing needs. However, as discussed below, the District failed to identify a specific reading program in the April 2001 IEP to address his reading goals.

Reading

Petitioner contends that the District failed to amend his program when it was determined at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting that he had not met his reading goal and objectives from the April 2000 IEP. According to Petitioner, his 2001 WRAT grade-level reading scores indicated his reading grade level was actually two standard points lower than it was in April 2000. The District contends that throughout the benchmark periods, STUDENT had made “good progress” on the reading goal and objectives.

As discussed earlier, a school district is obligated to revise a student’s educational program if it becomes apparent over the course of the school year that the student is not receiving educational benefit. (Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141, 1149 (1999), citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993).) The evidence demonstrates that the District failed to amend STUDENT’s educational program at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting so that it was designed to allow him to receive meaningful educational benefit in reading.

At the time of the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, STUDENT was still reading at the fourth- to fifth-grade level, which is the same level at which he read as of the April 2000 IEP. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 40.) STUDENT’s April 2000 reading goal stated that by April 2001, when presented with fourth- and fifth-grade reading books, STUDENT would pronounce words and comprehend their meaning. (Dist.’s Exh. 3, pg. 20.) STUDENT’s April 2000 reading goal was repeated in his April 3, 2001 IEP. The District did not explain why the same reading goal was drafted with the expectation that STUDENT would be reading at the same level as the previous year, particularly since the evidence indicated that STUDENT had the potential to read beyond that level, given his average-range intelligence.

The parties did not dispute that STUDENT’s cognitive abilities were within the average range. STUDENT’s standard scores on various cognitive tests administered from 1996 to 1999 ranged from 88 to 103. (See Pet.’s Exhs. F, P, and ZZ.) According to Ms. Dyl and clinical psychologist Kathleen Mack, standard scores between 85 and 115 on cognitive tests are considered to be within the average range. (Footnote 15) Ms. Dyl testified that she believed STUDENT’s overall cognitive ability was in the low to average range, with a standard score between 85 and 90. Ms. Dyl indicated that she judges a student’s overall cognitive ability based on trends of more than one score from various tests. She does not solely rely on the scores obtained from one test to understand a student’s cognitive ability. Ms. Mack testified that based on her review of cognitive and academic testing conducted by others, she estimated that STUDENT had an average potential to learn. Kathleen Mack testified that if a child has an average potential to learn and is provided an appropriate educational program to help him achieve, she would expect that student to achieve average reading comprehension skills.

STUDENT’s 1999 intelligence test scores indicated average-range cognitive abilities and Mr. Nagel testified that his performance in class showed he could make progress in reading. (Pet.’s P-2.) Both Ms. Dyl and Mr. Nagel testified that in spite of his learning disability, there was no reason STUDENT could not learn to read at an average level. In addition, Ms. Dyl opined that she would expect STUDENT to be able to read at the twelfth-grade level upon his graduation from high school.

As discussed above, the evidence suggests that STUDENT’s cognitive ability is within the average range and that he had the ability in April 2001 to improve his reading skills beyond the fifth-grade level. However, he had not made more than minimal progress in reading since his April 2000 IEP. From April 2000 to April 2001, STUDENT’s standard reading score on the WRAT decreased from 87 to 85, and he remained at the fourth- to fifth-grade reading level. (Pet.’s Exh. W-13.) Moreover, by April 3, 2001, STUDENT continued to have difficulty with multisyllabic words and irregular letter combinations and their sounds. According to Mr. Nagel, with STUDENT’s increased age factored into the score, a decrease in STUDENT’s standard score in reading on the WRAT means that STUDENT lost some ground since the prior year’s testing and that he was still weak in the area of phonemic awareness. (See also Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 40.) The evidence also showed that a lack of effort by STUDENT was not a contributing factor in his lack of progress in reading. Mr. Nagel testified that while in his class, STUDENT gave superior performance, received outstanding citizenship marks, and always gave one hundred percent in effort. Mr. Nagel also reported that during the 2000-2001 school year, STUDENT completed his class work and homework. (Pet.’s Exh. W-13.)

Again, although the April 3, 2001 IEP was generally designed to meet STUDENT’s needs, it did not include any specific reading instruction or services that he required to address his reading needs, particularly since he was reading at the same grade level as the prior year. Moreover, the District failed to provide any evidence as to how STUDENT’s reading goal and objectives would be appropriately addressed in his SDC reading class. STUDENT’s eighth-grade SDC reading teacher did not testify at the hearing.

From the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the April 3, 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s reading needs, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in reading.

Written Language

Petitioner argues that when he failed to make appropriate educational progress in written language, the April 3, 2001 IEP team should have modified his educational program, but it did not.

Mr. Nagel testified that the April 3, 2001 IEP team developed goals and objectives in STUDENT’s April 2001 IEP using STUDENT’s scores on the March 2001 WRAT testing, his work in class, and his performance on tests throughout the year. (Footnote 16) Additionally, Mr. Nagel testified that based on STUDENT’s progress on past goals, the written language goal in the April 3, 2001 IEP was drafted with the expectation that STUDENT would increase his written language skills from the fourth- to the fifth-grade level.

The Hearing Officer finds Mr. Nagel’s testimony persuasive because he had spent two years as STUDENT’s SDC teacher and was familiar with his strengths and weaknesses, he conducted academic testing of STUDENT, and has a vast amount of experience teaching students with learning disabilities similar to STUDENT’s.

The evidence established that STUDENT benefited from Mr. Nagel’s class in the past and the District continued to offer Mr. Nagel’s SDC for language arts and history for the remainder of the 2000-2001 school year, utilizing the same written language and spelling programs that the Hearing Officer found above to have been designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs.

There was no convincing evidence that the District should have modified the program that was developed in the April 3, 2001 IEP, as the evidence establishes that the program was designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him meaningful educational benefit.

Individual Transition Plan

Petitioner alleges that the District failed to create an individual transition plan (ITP) for him in April 2001. The District argues that an ITP document is included in STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP, to which the parent agreed. In addition, the District contends that Petitioner failed to present any evidence to establish that the ITP was inappropriate at the time it was developed.

The IDEA requires that when a student reaches age fourteen, and annually thereafter, the student’s IEP must include a statement of the student’s transition service needs. The statement must be included under the applicable components of the student’s IEP that focus on the student’s courses of study (such as participation in advanced-placement courses or a vocational education program). (20 U.S.C. § 1414(d)(1)(A)(vii)(I).) California law contains similar provisions. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56345.1(a)A.)

STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP includes no statement of his transition service needs. Although the IEP includes an ITP document and provides a space in which the IEP team could have written STUDENT’s transition needs or indicated that none was needed, the “needs” section was left blank. The only markings on the ITP document or anywhere on the IEP regarding transition services include checkmarks on the ITP document indicating that STUDENT did not possess his California driver’s license or identification card, transit identification, or a resume. (Pet.’s Exh. W-5 and 6.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to include the necessary specificity regarding STUDENT’s transition service needs in his IEP dated April 3, 2001.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner did not assert that the District failed to provide the program and services identified in the April 3, 2001 IEP.

*******

In summary, the Hearing Officer finds that because STUDENT had not made sufficient educational progress in reading, the District should have modified STUDENT’s program so that the April 3, 2001 IEP was designed to meet his reading needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in reading. The District also should have included necessary detail in STUDENT’s individual transition plan. The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District failed to substantively provide STUDENT a FAPE from April 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year with respect to his reading needs and his individual transition plan.

V. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not conduct a full assessment in written language and did not do further cognitive testing after the February 27, 2002 evaluation; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and 2. failing to provide a home instruction program that comported with his IEP from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002?

A. Appropriate Assessment

The District’s multidisciplinary evaluation team conducted a psychoeducational triennial evaluation on February 27, 2002. Petitioner alleges that the District failed to fully assess his written language during the 2001-2002 school year, and that it failed to conduct further cognitive testing after the District’s February 27, 2002 testing showed a “decrease” in his cognitive ability scores.

The District did not respond to Petitioner’s allegation regarding the written language assessment for this time frame. With respect to cognitive testing, the District contends there was no credible evidence to support the notion that, at the time of the February 2002 evaluation, additional cognitive testing was warranted, or that the results of Ms. Dyl’s evaluation were incorrect. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 23.)

Written Language Assessment

As discussed earlier, the District had last conducted a standardized assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills during its March 1999 multidisciplinary evaluation. (Pet.’s Exh. P.) Therefore, the District was required to reassess STUDENT’s written language skills by March 2002, or sooner, if conditions warranted, or if STUDENT’s parents or teacher requested a reassessment. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56381; see also 20 U.S.C. § 1414(a)(2).) There was no persuasive evidence that conditions warranted a reassessment or that anyone requested a reassessment of STUDENT’s written language skills prior to March 2002. However, STUDENT’s triennial evaluation, which was conducted by the District a few days shy of March 2002, on February 27, 2002, should have included a reassessment of STUDENT’s written language skills, as this had been, and continued to be, an area of suspected disability for STUDENT. The February 27, 2002 evaluation did not include an assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills, and there was no assessment of those skills until July 2003. (Footnote 17)

Because the District failed to assess STUDENT’s written language skills by March 2002, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability as required by California Education Code section 56320(f).

Cognitive Ability Assessment

Petitioner argues that over the course of six years, his verbal intelligence quotient (VIQ) score on the WISC-III had substantially decreased. According to Petitioner, the District should have conducted additional cognitive testing after comparing his VIQ score of 80 on the District’s 2002 administration of the WISC-III with his VIQ score of 94 on the 1996 WISC-III administration. (Pet.’s Exh. F.) The evidence establishes, however, that additional cognitive testing was not warranted after the February 2002 triennial evaluation.

Ms. Dyl gave persuasive and unrefuted testimony that a student’s cognitive scores may vary over time, reflecting how a student performs on a specific day and time in relation to his/her peers. According to Ms. Dyl, a student does not lose his cognitive ability unless he/she has some type of brain injury. Thus, the difference in STUDENT’s VIQ scores obtained in 1996 and 2002 may have indicated that he was falling behind and not keeping pace with his peers, not declining in intelligence.

Additionally, Ms. Dyl also questioned the reliability of the scores yielded from the 1996 WISC-III testing given her knowledge of the 1996 assessor, who was a psychological intern whom she believed was very inexperienced. Ms. Dyl testified that some of the questions on the WISC-III require the assessor to make judgment calls and the intern who administered the test did not have much testing experience. According to Ms. Dyl, the 1996 WISC-III testing administered by the intern indicated that STUDENT had a weakness in the nonverbal area. However, a review of STUDENT’s testing trends showed that he always tested stronger in the nonverbal area. The WISC-III heavily relies on language, which is an area of relative weakness for STUDENT. Therefore, it was not unusual for STUDENT’s 2002 verbal scores to be lower than his nonverbal scores. Moreover, it was not unusual for STUDENT’s scores on the 1999 administration of the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (TONI) to be higher, since the TONI corresponds to a single theoretical construct, nonverbal cognitive abilities, which is an area of relative strength for STUDENT. (Testimony of S. Dyl.)

The Hearing Officer is not persuaded that the District should have conducted additional cognitive testing after administering the WISC-III to STUDENT in February 2002. Ms. Dyl confirmed that the WISC-III is an appropriate test for assessing STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Ms. Dyl also testified that she was trained to administer the WISC-III and that the test included various subtests, such as the verbal portion of the test, that would assess STUDENT’s relative areas of weakness. (Pet.’s Exh. Z-1.) There was no convincing evidence that the cognitive test results obtained by Ms. Dyl were incorrect or contradictory to any previous cognitive testing. Moreover, the Hearing Officer finds Ms. Dyl’s testimony about cognitive testing persuasive given her experience as a school psychologist who is trained and certified to conduct psychoeducational evaluations employing both formal and informal assessment measures.

Accordingly, the Hearing Officer concludes that additional cognitive testing was not warranted after the testing was conducted in 2002.

B. FAPE

Petitioner contends that during the 2001-2002 school year, the instruction provided to him were not designed to address his reading and written language skills or assist him in meeting his goals. Petitioner also contends that the home instruction services he received from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, did not conform to his IEP. The District argues that it did not deny STUDENT a FAPE because it provided a program that was designed to meet his needs and provided him educational benefit, as demonstrated by the number of credits and the grades he earned during the entire school year.

STUDENT’s Needs

There was no dispute that at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT’s needs had not changed. He continued to have unique needs in reading and written language, requiring placement in an SDC program with specific reading instruction and written language development that included assistance with the correct pronunciation of words, comprehension of concepts, paragraph development, mid-sentence punctuation, and spelling. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pgs. 36 and 37.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

As previously stated, the April 3, 2001 IEP included one reading goal, one writing, and one math goal. The offer continued his placement in the SDC program five days each week for all academic subjects, and participation in regular education for physical education and one elective. Extended school year services were offered at the high school level. (Dist.’s Exh. 7.) STUDENT entered the ninth grade at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year and began attending Charter Oak High School.

Reading The IEP dated April 3, 2001, was operative at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year. The Hearing Officer determined above that the April 2001 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in reading because it did not include specific reading instruction and the reading goal was written at the same level of expected achievement as the April 2000 reading goal. The Hearing Officer similarly finds here that from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to at least June 24, 2002, there was no convincing evidence that specific reading instruction was a part of STUDENT’s educational program, or that STUDENT’s reading goal and related objectives would be appropriately addressed in his ninth-grade SDC English class. None of STUDENT’s ninth-grade teachers testified at the hearing.

Moreover, by February 27, 2002, the District had sufficient information to alert it that STUDENT was not benefiting from his educational program. The triennial evaluation conducted in February 2002 indicated that STUDENT was performing at the 2.8 grade level in basic reading, and at the 4.5 grade level in reading comprehension on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT). (Footnote 18) (Pet.’s Exh. Z-4.) Although in March 2002, STUDENT’s SDC English teacher reported that STUDENT’s academic grade for the current grading period was an “A” and that STUDENT was trying hard to improve his reading skills, STUDENT’s curriculum in the ninth-grade SDC was substantially modified and he was not functioning at grade level in reading. STUDENT’s science teacher reported that he was performing below his ability and that he believed STUDENT could achieve above average grades. (Dist.’s Exh. 10, pgs. 50 and 52.) Notwithstanding these warning signs, the District failed to revise STUDENT’s educational program with respect to reading. Additionally, when the IEP team did convene in March 2002 for a manifestation determination, the only change made to STUDENT’s educational program was his placement in home instruction. (Footnote 19) The District did not convene STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting to discuss, review, and revise any other aspect of his IEP until June 25, 2002.

The California Standards Test, Grade 9, which indicates a child’s performance on test questions that reflect California’s standards of what a student should know and be able to do at each grade level, was administered to STUDENT in April 2002. The English-Language Arts test results indicated that STUDENT was falling far below California’s basic academic standards in reading. (Dist.’s Exh. 12, pg. 66.) Compared to other students across the nation, STUDENT scored at the third percentile in vocabulary and at the first percentile in reading comprehension. (Id. at 67.) These scores demonstrate a consistent downward trend in STUDENT’s reading fluency and comprehension skills. However, the District did not convene an IEP meeting to discuss STUDENT’s performance on the California Standards test.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the District failed to show that STUDENT’s program from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, was designed to meet his unique reading needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in reading. Moreover, teacher reports and standardized testing indicated he was regressing.

Written Language

As to written language, the Hearing Officer found above that the April 3, 2001 IEP was appropriate from April 3, 2001, through the end of the 2000-2001 school year because it included an appropriate written language goal and related objectives that were drafted with the expectation that by April 2002, STUDENT would increase his written language skills from the fourth- to the fifth-grade level.

The Hearing Officer finds that the April 2001 IEP continued to be appropriate at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year as there was no evidence that STUDENT’s written language needs had changed. He continued to need assistance with paragraph development, punctuation, and spelling. Additionally, the offer continued STUDENT’s placement in an SDC where he could continue to receive the intensive instruction he required to further develop his written language skills. However, when STUDENT was on home instruction from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, he claims he did not receive any instruction in English. The Hearing Officer will discuss further below in the “Comports” section the appropriateness of STUDENT’s program during the two-month period that he was on home instruction and whether his written language needs were appropriately addressed during that time frame.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner argued that during the expulsion process, from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, he received no special education services. However, Petitioner testified at hearing that he received home instruction services from SDC teacher Frank Foster for one hour each school day during this two-month time frame, but that the services were limited to reviewing the rules for forming words. The Hearing Officer therefore determines whether the District provided the services in STUDENT’s IEP during the period he was placed in home instruction.

On March 20, 2002, STUDENT was in possession of, and furnished alcohol to another student while at school. As a result, he was suspended from school for five days until a manifestation determination IEP meeting was held on March 25, 2002. At the manifestation determination IEP meeting, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT’s behavior was not a manifestation of his disability and recommended that STUDENT be expelled from school. Accordingly, an addendum to STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP was developed to reflect the IEP team’s agreement to change STUDENT’s placement from his SDC at Charter Oak High School to home teaching while the expulsion process continued. (Dist.’s Exh. 11.)

The March 25, 2002 IEP addendum provides for only one change in STUDENT’s program - his placement. Therefore, during the period that the March 25, 2002 IEP addendum was in effect, the District was required to provide the program identified in STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP through home instruction. (Footnote 20) The evidence establishes that STUDENT’s program was substantially curtailed during the period he received home instruction.

According to STUDENT and his sister, SISTER, from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, each school day for one hour, STUDENT’s case carrier, SDC teacher Frank Foster, provided him individual instruction that consisted solely of reviewing the rules for forming words. The District provided no evidence that STUDENT received the specific reading instruction he required, or that the written language and math goals and objectives from his April 3, 2001 IEP were addressed during his sessions with Mr. Foster. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, the program and services that STUDENT received did not comport with either his April 3, 2001, or March 25, 2002 IEPs.

*******

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to appropriately assess STUDENT’s written language skills. Additionally, the District failed to substantively provide STUDENT a FAPE with respect to his reading needs from the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002. Moreover, from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, STUDENT’s program did not comport with his IEP, which resulted in a denial of a FAPE.

VI. At the June 25, 2002 IEP meeting, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. failing to make a specific written program offer in the June 25, 2002 IEP for the extended school year, and B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

A. Alleged Procedural Deficiency

ESY Offer

Petitioner contends that although the District offered extended school year services in the June 25, 2002 IEP and indicated that his ESY program would later be determined, no ESY program was ever specified. The District did not specifically respond to Petitioner’s allegation regarding the June 2002 IEP and its offer of ESY services pursuant to that IEP.

The Hearing Officer notes that the June 2002 IEP provides for STUDENT’s program to be implemented from April 2002 to April 2003, which includes the 2002 ESY, except for the counseling services, which were to be provided during the following school year, from September 2002 to June 2003. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 81.) A review of the June 25, 2002 IEP indicates that the District offered unspecified ESY services. The June 25, 2002 IEP has the “Yes” box checked for ESY services and states “TBD” in the section designating the specific level of services. (Footnote 21)

The only testimony regarding the 2002 ESY was from STUDENT, who stated that he did not attend summer school during the 2002 ESY because he went to Colorado. (Footnote 22) Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that the June 25, 2002 IEP failed to include a specific written offer for ESY services. However, because there was no showing that the District’s failure resulted in a “loss of educational opportunity” for STUDENT or that it “seriously infringed the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process,” the Hearing Officer finds that this procedural error did not amount to a denial of a FAPE.

B. Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

Petitioner alleges that the District failed to develop a program that allowed him to make sufficient educational progress in reading and written language. The District argues that the program contained in the June 25, 2002 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

STUDENT’s Needs

The parties did not dispute that as of June 25, 2002, STUDENT still demonstrated a need for special education support based upon work samples and daily classroom performance. STUDENT was reading at the fourth-grade level and still had problems with decoding, word attack skills, and reading comprehension and therefore continued to need intensive reading instruction through placement in an SDC because his established goals could not be met in a general education classroom setting. (Dist.’s Exhs. 9 and 16, pg. 82.) In written language, STUDENT continued to test very low in spelling and his sentence structures were not well developed. (Dist.’s Exhs. 9 and 16, pg. 79.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

The June 25, 2002 IEP included one reading goal to help STUDENT improve his reading skills by at least one grade level. The related objectives were drafted at the fourth- and fifth-grade levels. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 78.) One writing goal was included in the IEP to assist STUDENT with expressing his ideas in grammatically complete sentences using correct capitalization, punctuation, and spelling of frequently used words. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 79.) A social-emotional goal was also included in the IEP; however, Petitioner did not dispute this area, so the Hearing Officer will not address the appropriateness of the social-emotional goal. The 2002 IEP offered STUDENT placement in an SDC program for English, science, and reading from April 2002 to April 2003. It also offered counseling services twice each month starting in September 2002, and ending in June 2003. As discussed above, extended school year services were offered in the IEP, but not specified. Additionally, accommodations/modifications were offered that included repeating verbal instructions to ensure understanding, supplementing verbal directions with visual cues whenever possible, allowing STUDENT extra time for completing written work, and allowing him to take his math tests in the SDC setting when needed.

Reading

The Hearing Officer finds there was no convincing evidence that specific reading instruction was a part of the June 25, 2002 IEP, or that STUDENT’s reading goal and related objectives would be appropriately addressed in his SDC class.

The District again failed to revise STUDENT’s educational program with respect to reading even though it had become apparent some time before the June 25, 2002 IEP meeting that STUDENT was not receiving sufficient educational benefit in reading. By June 25, 2002, STUDENT’s scores on the WRAT showed he was reading at the fourth-grade level (SS-75), indicating he had regressed by one grade level since he was last tested in March 2001. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 78.) Moreover, there was no indication whether progress was made on the April 2001 reading goal and objectives. (Id.)

One of STUDENT’s June 25, 2002 reading objectives was drafted at the fourth-grade level of expected achievement, which is one grade level lower than a similar reading objective from the prior year. The evidence suggests that, once again, the IEP team did not take into account that STUDENT was not making more than minimal progress in reading. STUDENT’s then-current level of performance in reading should have alerted the IEP team that the same educational program, year after year, was not providing STUDENT with sufficient educational benefit and that therefore he required a change in programming.

The Hearing Officer finds that the June 25, 2002 IEP was neither designed to meet STUDENT’s unique reading needs nor reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in reading.

Written Language

The District failed to provide sufficient evidence to show that the June 25, 2002 IEP was appropriately designed to address STUDENT’s written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit. District testing that was conducted in 2002 showed STUDENT was spelling at the second-grade level (SS-66), indicating he had regressed by two grade levels since March 2001. The IEP document contains no documentation, however, of STUDENT’s then-present levels in written language. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 79.)

The Hearing Officer found above that the District failed to assess STUDENT’s written language needs during the February 27, 2002 evaluation. Without having conducted an appropriate written language assessment in over three years, it is unlikely that the IEP team could identify STUDENT’s then-present levels of performance in written language or develop goals and objectives and recommend a program to meet STUDENT’s needs.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the June 25, 2002 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner did not assert that the District failed to provide the program and services identified in his June 25, 2002 IEP.

*****

In summary, the Hearing Officer concludes that the June 25, 2002 IEP failed to include a specific written offer for ESY services. However, the District’s procedural violation did not result in a denial of a FAPE. In addition, the June 25, 2002 IEP was not designed to substantively provide STUDENT a FAPE with respect to his reading and written language needs.

VII. From the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide a program that allowed him to make appropriate educational progress during the 2002-2003 school year.

The District contends that it provided STUDENT an educational program that was designed to meet his unique needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with some educational benefit. The District argues that STUDENT’s progress is evidenced by his earning 55 credits toward graduation, a 2.5 grade point average for the fall semester, and a 3.2 grade point average during the spring semester.

STUDENT’s Needs

Neither party disputed that at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year, STUDENT still required the intensive services of a special day program to address his unique needs in the areas of reading and written language.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

The June 25, 2002 IEP remained in effect during the entire 2002-2003 school year. Although another IEP meeting was held for STUDENT on October 29, 2002, the only IEP at issue with respect to this time frame is the June 25, 2002 IEP. (Footnote 23)

Reading

The Hearing Officer determined above that the June 25, 2002 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs in reading because it did not include specific reading instruction.

STUDENT was placed in a reading fundamentals class during his sophomore year; however, his reading teacher did not testify at the hearing. The only evidence presented regarding whether STUDENT’s IEP was appropriately designed to meet his needs and provide some educational benefit was testimony from STUDENT’s tenth and eleventh-grade SDC English teacher, Janice Magee, who stated that STUDENT read the book Of Mice and Men and also read some Greek mythology while in her tenth-grade English class. According to Ms. Magee, STUDENT was initially hesitant about reading orally, but he later became more comfortable with oral reading. The Hearing Officer finds, however, that the trivial advancement that STUDENT made by being able to read orally with more ease does not satisfy the Rowley standard of providing “some” educational benefit. Moreover, the District did not establish that it provided a program and a placement through which STUDENT’s reading goal and objectives would be addressed, or that his educational program included intensive instruction to address his identified difficulties with decoding, spelling, word attack skills, and comprehension.

Consequently, the Hearing Officer concludes that from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, the District failed to provide STUDENT a program that was designed to meet his reading needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit in reading.

Written Language

The Hearing Officer found above that the District did not establish that the June 25, 2002 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs. Moreover, Ms. Magee testified that the writing program she used during the 2002-2003 school year was “marginal” with respect to its appropriateness in addressing STUDENT’s needs. Ms. Magee stated that she tried to help STUDENT organize his writing; however, she was unable to really help him until the following school year, when she started utilizing the Four Square writing program in her English class. Consequently, STUDENT made minimal progress in writing during his sophomore year because Ms. Magee acknowledged, as a new teacher, she did not know exactly how to address STUDENT’s needs.

Petitioner also argued that STUDENT’s SDC teacher, Janice Magee, was not legally qualified to teach an SDC class because she was not a credentialed teacher. (Cal. Educ. Code § 44268.5.) However, because the Hearing Officer finds that the District did not meet its burden of proving that from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, it provided a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him meaningful educational benefit in written language, the Hearing Officer need not reach a finding regarding Ms. Magee’s qualifications to teach. (Footnote 24)

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner does not allege that his program failed to comport with his IEP from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003.

*******

On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District substantively denied STUDENT a FAPE with respect to his reading and written language needs from the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003.

VIII. At the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not do a full assessment in written language before July 2003, and did not formally decline the parents’ request to conduct a central auditory processing assessment;

B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to make a specific written program offer in the June 30, 2003 IEP for the extended school year, and 2. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

A. Appropriate Assessment

Petitioner contends that the District should have conducted a written language assessment prior to its July 2003 assessment. Petitioner also contends that the District did not formally decline to conduct a central auditory processing disorder (CAPD) evaluation when he requested one at the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting. According to Petitioner, the District should have either conducted the CAPD evaluation or alerted him that it declined to do so.

The District did not respond to Petitioner’s allegation regarding the written language assessment. With respect to the CAPD assessment, the District contends that the documentary evidence and testimony clearly establish that by letter dated July 9, 2003, the District responded to Petitioner’s request for the CAPD assessment and declined to conduct a CAPD assessment at that time.

Written Language Assessment

The Hearing Officer already determined above that the District’s February 27, 2002 multidisciplinary evaluation should have included a reassessment of STUDENT’s written language skills since it was, and continued to be, an area of suspected disability for STUDENT. The District did not complete an assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills until after the 2002-2003 regular school year ended, when both District personnel and the Stowell Learning Center administered various standardized tests in July 2003. (Dist.’s Exhs. 35 and 36.) Therefore, for the same reasons stated above, the Hearing Officer finds that the District had failed to conduct an appropriate reassessment of STUDENT’s written language skills at the time of the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting. (Footnote 25)

Central Auditory Processing Disorder Assessment

During the IEP meeting held on June 30, 2003, Petitioner objected to the District’s February 2002 triennial assessment, contending that it failed to assess his identified areas of need. (Dist.’s Exh. 29, pg. 157.) According to the June 2003 IEP meeting notes, the IEP team members discussed whether the WRAT test provided sufficient information as a basis for developing IEP goals. The District offered to conduct additional academic testing, and a number of specific assessment tools were requested on behalf of Petitioner, including an assessment for central auditory processing disorder. (Footnote 26) (Dist.’s Exh. 29, pgs. 154-155.)

By letter dated July 9, 2003, the District’s attorney responded to Petitioner’s June 30, 2003 objection to the triennial assessment and his request for a CAPD assessment. Regarding the CAPD assessment, the District’s attorney stated: “You requested an assessment for central auditory processing disorder (CAPD). When asked what led you to believe STUDENT may have a CAPD, you indicated it was a ‘shot in the dark.’” The letter goes on to state the District’s suggestion that “after reviewing the results of the speech and language assessment in the Fall, the IEP team will discuss and determine the necessity for a CAPD assessment.” (Dist.’s Exh. 31.)

The assessment plan that was returned to the District included several handwritten revisions, including a notation, “CAPD ASSMT,” followed by attorney Whiteleather’s signature. (Dist.’s Exh. 33.) By letter dated July 21, 2003, the District’s attorney responded to the altered assessment plan, reiterating to Ms. Whiteleather the District’s decision not to conduct the CAPD assessment at that time. (Dist’s Exh. 34.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District responded in writing to Petitioner’s request for a CAPD assessment in a timely manner and in compliance with 20 U.S.C. § 1415(b)(3) and (c). In its letter dated July 9, 2003, the District explained why the District refused to conduct the CAPD assessment at that time, stated that the District wanted to first conduct a speech and language evaluation, and acknowledged that Petitioner’s apparent rationale for requesting the assessment was a “shot in the dark.”

******

In light of all the above, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability by not assessing his written language skills. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District properly responded in writing to Petitioner’s request to conduct a CAPD assessment. (Footnote 27)

B. FAPE

The June 25, 2002 IEP was operative at the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year and remained in effect for the entire school year. Another IEP was drafted for STUDENT on June 30, 2003, but it was not to be implemented until September 2003. (Dist.’s Exh. 29, pg. 145.) Moreover, the June 2003 IEP was not signed by the parents and therefore, never implemented. The Hearing Officer will, however, address the appropriateness of the June 30, 2003 IEP as it relates to the specific issues raised by Petitioner.

1. Alleged Procedural Deficiency

Petitioner contends that the June 30, 2003 IEP failed to identify the specific ESY program offered by the District. The District argued that its April 1, 2003 letter that offered to provide LMB services during the 2003 ESY adequately specified the ESY services it intended to provide.

On October 3, 2002, Petitioner’s parents had him independently evaluated by the LMB Learning Processes Center in Pasadena, California. According to the District, on March 12, 2003, the District was first provided the LMB independent report. By letter dated April 1, 2003, addressed to attorney Tania Whiteleather, the District’s counsel informed Ms. Whiteleather that the District had reviewed the October 3, 2002 LMB pre-testing summary that was first provided to the District on March 12, 2003. (Dist.’s Exh. 25.) In that letter, the District offers to provide STUDENT instruction in the LMB methodology from June 16 through August 1, 2003. The letter states that services are to be provided on an individualized, one-to-one basis for four hours each day, five days each week, with pre-testing and post-testing to be conducted by District staff to evaluate the effectiveness of the program for STUDENT. Total hours of instruction, including pre-testing and post-testing, would be 136 hours. (Dist.’s Exh. 25.)

Dr. Castagnaro testified at the hearing that he did not recall whether Ms. Whiteleather or STUDENT’s family responded to the April 1, 2003 letter from the District’s counsel offering LMB services for the summer 2003. Dr. Castagnaro also stated that he was aware of the April 1, 2003 letter, but had no personal knowledge that the letter was actually mailed or faxed to Ms. Whiteleather’s office. However, Ms. Whiteleather, who was present each day of the hearing, did not dispute the account of the events surrounding the District’s April 1, 2003 offer of LMB services. According to Dr. Castagnaro, when the District had not received a response to the April 2003 letter, the next IEP meeting held on June 30, 2003, was the District’s attempt to meet and follow up on its April 2003 offer. Dr. Castagnaro also stated that he expected the District’s attorney to follow up with the offer if the District had not received a response from STUDENT’s attorney or family. The District contends that when the IEP team convened again on June 30, 2003, the offer for LMB services over the summer remained available to STUDENT. (Footnote 28)

According to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, a sufficiently clear offer is necessary to (1) alert the parents to consider seriously whether the district’s offer is appropriate, (2) help the parents determine whether to oppose or accept the placement with supplemental services, and (3) prepare the school district to introduce sufficient relevant evidence of the appropriateness of the placement at a due process hearing. (Union, 15 F.3d at 1526.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District’s April 1, 2003 letter made a sufficiently clear written offer of services to Petitioner for the 2003 ESY that satisfied the IDEA, including the three policy reasons articulated by the Union court. There was no persuasive evidence, either in the June 30, 2003 IEP document or otherwise, that the April 1, 2003 offer to provide the LMB services during the 2003 ESY was revoked by a subsequent IEP.

As to the ESY offer in the June 2003 IEP, as stated earlier, the June 30, 2003 IEP was not intended to take effect until September 2003. Therefore, any ESY offer in that IEP would have been for the 2004 ESY. The District marked the “yes” box in the June 2003 IEP to indicate it was offering ESY services. (Dist.’s Exh. 29, pg. 145.) Another IEP was developed for STUDENT in September/October 2003, which also covered the 2004 ESY time frame, and which the parents ultimately signed, as will be discussed further in the next issue.

2. Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

STUDENT’s Needs

The parties did not dispute that as of June 30, 2003, STUDENT continued to have deficits in reading and written language, thus requiring the intensive services of a special day class.

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

On June 30, 2003, the IEP team convened for STUDENT’s annual IEP meeting and presented a draft IEP document to Petitioner. Similar to the June 2002 IEP, the June 30, 2003 IEP contained one reading and one writing goal, both anticipating that STUDENT would improve his reading and writing skills by one grade level. Additionally, a math goal was included in the IEP to help him improve his algebra skills, and a social-emotional goal was included to address his organizational skills and help him meet his obligations and budget his time. (Dist.’s Exh. 29.) It was also noted in the IEP that STUDENT’s auditory processing may hinder his ability to hear and decipher sounds. The District proposed that STUDENT continue his placement in the SDC for reading, English, and U.S. History, and be mainstreamed for algebra B and two electives. (Dist.’s Exh. 29.)

Accommodations/modifications were included in the IEP that required all teachers to repeat verbal instructions and ensure questions and commands have been understood before work begins. All teachers were also required to supplement verbal directions with visual cues whenever possible and check for understanding. In STUDENT’s general education classes, STUDENT would be allowed extra time for completing written work and had the choice of taking his math tests, when needed, in the SDC setting. (Dist.’s Exh. 29, pg. 144.)

The parents never signed the June 30, 2003 IEP. Therefore, the June 25, 2002 IEP continued to be implemented during the entire 2002-2003 school year. Moreover, the June 30, 2003 IEP document indicates that the program was not intended to be implemented until the following school year in September 2003. (Id. at pg. 124.) Had the parents agreed to the June 2003 IEP, it would have been implemented at the beginning of STUDENT’s eleventh-grade year. However, the Hearing Officer examines the appropriateness of the June 2003 IEP at the time it was written.

Reading and Written Language

The Hearing Officer finds there was no convincing evidence that specific reading instruction was a part of the June 30, 2003 IEP, or that STUDENT’s reading and written language goals and related objectives were appropriately designed to meet his needs or reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. STUDENT’s tenth-grade reading teacher did not testify at the hearing. STUDENT’s tenth-grade English teacher, Janice Magee, did testify, but she did not participate in developing the June 2003 IEP and provided no testimony regarding its appropriateness.

At the time the June 2003 IEP was drafted, the District did not have any information regarding STUDENT’s current reading skills other than his June 21, 2003 WRAT scores. (Pet.’s Exh. JJ.) In addition, the District agreed at the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting that it did not have sufficient information about STUDENT’s skills and therefore needed to conduct additional academic testing before it could draft appropriate IEP goals and objectives. The District and the Stowell Learning Center conducted additional testing of STUDENT’s reading skills in July 2003.

With respect to written language, the Hearing Officer found above that the District should have assessed STUDENT’s written language skills as part of its February 2002 multidisciplinary evaluation, since written language continued to be an area of suspected disability for STUDENT. There had not been a standardized assessment of STUDENT’s written language skills since March 1999, and such testing was not completed until July 2003. Thus, it is unlikely the June 2003 IEP team could make the prescribed findings necessary before developing written language goals and objectives and recommending a placement and services, particularly since this IEP was not intended to be implemented until September 2003.

The Hearing Officer finds that the District failed to demonstrate that the IEP team had sufficient information regarding STUDENT’s reading and written language skills to draft an appropriate IEP in June 2003. This is evidenced by the District’s agreement to conduct additional testing, and as will be discussed below, the District’s development of new goals in September 2003 based on the new testing results. The District also later determined that STUDENT required outside educational therapy services, in addition to his IEP. The District failed to show that the June 30, 2003 IEP was appropriately designed to meet STUDENT’s reading and written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner did not assert that the District failed to provide the program and services identified in the June 30, 2003 IEP.

******

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District made a specific written offer of ESY services for 2003 in its April 1, 2003 letter. However, the June 30, 2003 IEP was not procedurally or substantively designed to provide STUDENT a FAPE in that it failed to make a specific written 2004 ESY offer and failed to include a program that was designed to meet his reading and written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

IX. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. failing to make a specific written offer for the Stowell Learning Center services, and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the September/October 2003 IEP for the extended school year;

B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

A. Alleged Procedural Deficiencies

1. Specific Written Offer for the Stowell Learning Center Services

Petitioner contends that the District failed to make a specific written offer in its IEP dated September 12, 2003, for the services to be provided by the Stowell Learning Center. Specifically, Petitioner alleges that when the District offered to provide him 225 hours of services at the Stowell Learning Center (SLC), it failed to specify the duration and intensity of the services being proposed. According to Petitioner, the District made no written offer of the SLC services until March 2004.

The District argues that the Stowell Learning Center services were offered to Petitioner as compensatory education and that the details of that offer were clearly set forth in the September 2003 draft IEP and the October 2003 IEP documents. The District further contends that the mishandling of correspondence by Ms. Whiteleather, the inability of advocate Vikki Rice to advise the family at the meeting in October 2003, as well as Petitioner’s failure to respond for over two months to District correspondence, was the sole and direct cause of the delay in services to Petitioner.

The evidence establishes that the educational therapy services to be provided by the SLC were not considered to be a part of the District’s offer of a FAPE. Rather, the SLC services were considered to be compensatory education, to be implemented along with STUDENT’s IEP. (Dist.’s opening statement and closing argument, pgs. 34-35.) Petitioner did not refute the District’s assertion at hearing that the SLC services were offered to him as compensatory education.

Accordingly, the District’s offer of compensatory education to be provided by the SLC was not a part of its offer of a FAPE, and therefore, is not subject to the stringent written offer requirements of the IDEA. Nevertheless, the evidence shows that the District’s offer of the SLC program included a breakdown of the number of minutes, hours, and days of specific SLC programming components. (Dist.’s Exh. 48.) The District provided the parents in writing with the anticipated frequency and duration of supplemental services to be provided by the SLC. Furthermore, although Petitioner argues there was excessive delay in providing the compensatory services, the Hearing Officer finds that as early as October 31, 2003, the District had provided Petitioner with sufficient details about the offered compensatory services.

2. ESY Offer

Petitioner contends that the District failed to make a specific written extended school year offer of services in the September/October 2003 IEP. The District argues that the document, developed when the IEP team reconvened on October 22, 2003, states that ESY services would be “summer class.” (Dist.’s Exh. 46, pg. 260.) Since STUDENT attended summer school during the 2004 summer session, taking a civics and economics class and earning a grade of “C,” the District argues that there is no evidence that the District did not adequately define the ESY services in the IEP resulting in a procedural violation of the IEP process. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 30.)

The District’s offer of a “summer class” for the 2004 ESY does not constitute a sufficiently clear written offer that satisfies the IDEA. Although STUDENT did attend summer school during the 2004 summer and earned a passing grade in his civics and economics class, the evidence indicates that he did not receive sufficient educational benefit from that class due to the lack of clarity in his IEP.

STUDENT’s 2004 summer school teacher, Rayburn Walker, Jr., testified that he never saw STUDENT’s IEP and had to call the District’s office to ask what was included in the IEP. However, even after making that telephone call, Mr. Walker testified that he still did not know what goals were included in STUDENT’s IEP, and he was never told what services STUDENT needed. Mr. Walker testified that STUDENT did not complete some homework assignments and turned some of his work in late because he was overwhelmed in the class and he had difficulties retaining information, spelling, and writing. Lack of organization in STUDENT’s writing made it difficult for him to put simple sentences together and form compound paragraphs. According to Mr. Walker, STUDENT is not lazy, but he almost gave up and wanted to drop the summer class because he felt it was too difficult and became discouraged. Mr. Walker testified that it was not until he talked to STUDENT’s sister and discovered that STUDENT had problems with auditory processing, phonemic awareness, receptive language, and recall, that he could then determine how to help STUDENT.

Essentially, a great deal of learning time was wasted for STUDENT during the summer of 2004 because not only did his teacher not have a copy of his IEP, but the IEP document did not specify what program or services STUDENT required to meet his needs during the extended school year. Because of his feeling overwhelmed and not receiving the assistance in class that he required, STUDENT missed some days of class and turned in his work late. (Testimony of R. Walker) Although STUDENT passed, he did not receive a program designed to meet his needs and calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

The Hearing Officer therefore finds that because the District’s 2004 ESY offer failed to specify the program and services to be implemented during the ESY, STUDENT’s ESY teacher was unable to provide STUDENT the type of instruction and assistance he required during summer school. The lack of specificity in the District’s ESY offer, and the District’s failure to provide a copy of the IEP to his ESY teacher, contributed to STUDENT’s difficulty in completing assignments and, ultimately, his receiving a grade lower than he was capable of receiving. This procedural violation resulted in a loss of educational opportunity for STUDENT and therefore, resulted in a procedural denial of FAPE for the 2004 ESY.

B. Alleged Substantive Deficiencies

Petitioner contends that the District failed to take steps to change his program or services when his July 2003 assessment indicated his passage comprehension scores had declined by thirty points. According to Petitioner, he failed to make progress in reading and written language during the 2003-2004 school year.

The District contends that once the IEP meeting convened on October 22, 2003, the District’s offer, based upon assessments conducted in July 2003, included 225 hours of “compensatory education services” to be provided by the Stowell Learning Center, which services were designed to address, among other issues, reading comprehension. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 31.) (Footnote 29)

STUDENT’s Needs

Neither party disputed the District’s July 2003 assessment indications that STUDENT demonstrated a severe discrepancy between ability and achievement in the areas of basic reading skills, reading comprehension, and written expression. As of the September 12, 2003 IEP meeting, STUDENT was reported to still be reading at the fourth- to fifth-grade level and requiring the assistance of a reading intervention program to help him continue to build phonemic awareness and word attack skills. STUDENT’s written language skills were at the mid-fourth-grade level and he needed to improve his spelling and punctuation skills. STUDENT also needed to continue working on improving his sentence structures and writing simple paragraphs. (Dist.’s Exh. 46, pgs. 261-263.)

Jill Stowell, director of the Stowell Learning Center, testified that the testing she conducted at the SLC in July 2003 indicated STUDENT had weaknesses in auditory processing, specifically in the areas of auditory memory and phonemic awareness, which affected his receptive and expressive language. STUDENT demonstrated difficulty expressing his ideas orally and in writing. He often would not write using words that he could not spell and had difficulty expressing ideas in a grammatically correct manner. To make a lasting improvement in STUDENT’s reading and writing skills, Ms. Stowell believed that STUDENT’s underlying thinking processes needed to be remediated so that he could become an independent learner. Specifically, Ms. Stowell believed STUDENT’s auditory processing system needed to be stimulated to increase his articulation, phonemic awareness skills, receptive and expressive language skills. STUDENT also needed to develop his reading and spelling skills to an automatic level. Processing speed, fluency, intonation and clarity in his verbalization were all issues that were identified and for which treatment was recommended. (Dist.’s Exh. 36.)

Designed to Meet STUDENT’s Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit

Although the offer of the SLC services was written in the October 2003 IEP document, according to the District, the SLC services were not considered to be a part of the District’s offer of a FAPE for the 2003-2004 school year, but were offered as compensatory education, to be implemented along with STUDENT’s IEP. Witness testimony and correspondence between the parties confirms the District’s intent to offer the SLC services as compensatory education to be provided separate and apart from its offer of a FAPE. Ms. Dyl testified that the SLC services were offered “outside of school,” on a compensatory basis, to help STUDENT improve his skills, and were not required for STUDENT to graduate. Ms. Dyl also stated that the District never told the parents that the SLC services were a required portion of STUDENT’s school day.

Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider the District’s offer of compensatory educational services by the SLC when analyzing the appropriateness of the District’s offered program for the 2003-2004 school year. The offered SLC services will be addressed, however, in the “Compensatory Education” section of this Decision below. (Footnote 30)

The October 2003 IEP included one reading goal and related objectives designed to improve STUDENT’s decoding, fluency, and comprehension skills. (Testimony of J. Magee.) Two written expression goals were included in the IEP to assist STUDENT with accurately composing simple paragraphs, using correct sentence structures, grammar, spelling, and punctuation. (Dist.’s Exh. 46, pgs. 261-263.) Since STUDENT had been having difficulty completing his math homework, a social-emotional goal was included to help him improve his organizational skills. There was no dispute about STUDENT’s organizational needs; therefore, the Hearing Officer does not address the appropriateness of that goal.

Accommodations/modifications were offered that included having verbal instructions repeated, supplementing verbal instructions with visual cues, allowing extra time for completing written work, checking for understanding, and taking algebra tests and quizzes in the SDC setting. (Id. at 270.) The District offered STUDENT placement in the SDC for English, reading, and U.S. History, and placement in general education for algebra B and two electives. (Id. at 260.)

The Hearing Officer next addresses whether the District’s offered program was designed to meet STUDENT’s identified needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit.

Reading

In the area of reading, Petitioner argued that the District should have changed his educational program when academic testing indicated that his passage comprehension scores on the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement – Third Edition (WJ-III) had dropped almost thirty points from a standard score of 105 in February 2002, to a standard score of 76 in July 2003. (Dist.’s Exh. 35.)

According to STUDENT’s English teacher and case carrier, Janice Magee, she wrote new reading and written expression goals in STUDENT’s September 12, 2003 IEP in conjunction with the school psychologist and based the goals upon STUDENT’s July 2003 scores on the WIAT and WJ-III, her own informal testing, his progress on past IEP goals, and his specific abilities demonstrated in class. (Id.)

The Hearing Officer finds that the District did not take appropriate steps to amend STUDENT’s program after the July 2003 testing conducted by District personnel and the Stowell Learning Center. Although a new reading goal and objectives were drafted based on recent testing results, according to Ms. Magee, STUDENT’s reading teacher continued to utilize the corrective reading program that was used during STUDENT’s tenth-grade year. STUDENT’s SDC reading teacher did not testify at the hearing, and the Hearing Officer does not find convincing Ms. Magee’s testimony that the SRA corrective reading program continued to adequately address STUDENT’s reading needs. STUDENT was still reading at the fourth- to fifth-grade level and he failed to pass the English-Language Arts portion of the California high school exit exam administered in March 2003. (Pet.’s Exh. KK.) Moreover, Ms. Dyl acknowledged that the corrective reading program may not have been an appropriate reading intervention program for STUDENT if his standardized test scores were still declining and he had not progressed past the fifth-grade reading level.

STUDENT’s reading performance level should have alerted the IEP team that continuing with the same educational program as the prior year would not likely allow STUDENT to make sufficient educational progress. Although the IEP team offered to provide the SLC educational therapy services in addition to its offer of a FAPE, the evidence indicates that a change in the programming of STUDENT’s regular school day was warranted.

Having failed to show that the September/October 2003 IEP was designed to meet STUDENT’s reading needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, the Hearing Officer finds that the District denied STUDENT a FAPE with respect to his reading needs.

Written Language

During the 2003-2004 school year, Janice Magee became STUDENT’s case carrier and continued as STUDENT’s English class instructor. Ms. Magee testified that she utilized the Four Square writing program in her English class to address STUDENT’s written expression goals and objectives. The Four Square writing program utilizes a graphic organizer to teach students to first formulate a central theme and then organize each paragraph. Ms. Magee testified that students use this strategy to do expository or narrative writing and it has proven helpful for students who need to visualize the writing process. She also testified that STUDENT still needs to grow in his ability to do multi-paragraph writing and organize his thoughts to a greater extent and that these needs are addressed with the Four Square writing program and instruction in grammar and punctuation.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the Four Square writing program is designed to help STUDENT organize his thoughts and help him grow in his ability to develop simple sentences and paragraphs. In addition, the accommodations offered in STUDENT’s IEP, such as talking with his teacher about assignments, taking tests in Ms. Magee’s English class rather than in his independent study class, and taking extra time to complete is work, address his speed of processing weakness and deficits in auditory processing.

The evidence establishes that not only was the September/October 2003 IEP designed to meet STUDENT’s written language needs and reasonably calculated to provide him educational benefit, but STUDENT, in fact, made progress in written language during the school year. Ms. Magee testified that STUDENT can now write a simple paragraph of five-to- seven sentences, and with some assistance, STUDENT can organize and compose several paragraphs that make sense. When given a writing prompt in the past, STUDENT could not organize his ideas and information or write topic sentences. However, by the end of the 2003-2004 school year, when given a writing prompt, STUDENT was able to write multiple paragraphs.

The Hearing Officer found above that as of June 25, 2002, the District had failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE in written language. STUDENT had been having difficulty with his written language skills since the end of his ninth-grade year, and his performance during the eleventh grade was the first time that he had showed sufficient progress in written language since he entered high school. Ms. Magee testified that improving STUDENT’s writing skills is a long and difficult process and he cannot yet, independently, write a five-to-seven-paragraph paper; however, he can write a single paragraph independently. Ms. Magee indicated that she will continue to address the writing process in her class during the forthcoming school year and that she expects STUDENT to move towards being able to write paragraphs without assistance in his senior year.

Comported with his IEP

Petitioner did not allege that the District failed to provide the services included in his IEP.

*****

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District procedurally denied STUDENT a FAPE during the 2004 ESY when it failed to make a specific written program offer of ESY services. The Hearing Officer also concludes that the District’s September/October 2003 IEP was not designed to meet STUDENT’s reading needs and was not reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit in reading. However, the IEP was appropriate with respect to his written language needs.

X. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:

A. reimbursement for the 2002 and 2004 assessment completed by the Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center and/or B. compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center, including transportation to and from the Center?

A. Reimbursement

2002 Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes assessment

Petitioner contends that his parents should be reimbursed for the diagnostic evaluation performed by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes (LMB) Center in October 2002. (Pet.’s Exh. HH.) The District argues that Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement because the District offered to conduct an LMB assessment and Petitioner never responded. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 87.) The District also contends that the October 3, 2002 LMB assessment was not provided to the IEP team at the meeting convened on October 29, 2002, and in fact, was not provided to the District until March 2003. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 36.)

A parent may obtain an independent educational assessment performed by a qualified specialist at public expense if (1) the parent disagrees with an assessment obtained by the educational agency and (2) the educational agency is unable to show that its assessment was appropriate at a due process hearing. (Cal. Educ. Code § 56329(b); 34 C.F.R. § 300.502(b).)

SISTER testified that she obtained the 2002 LMB assessment for her brother, STUDENT, because the family disagreed with the District’s February 2002 psychoeducational triennial evaluation in which the evaluators failed to assess in all areas of suspected disability, including written language, and determined that STUDENT’s test scores did not demonstrate a discrepancy between his ability and achievement. (Dist.’s Exh. 9, pg. 48.) At the IEP meeting held on June 25, 2002, the parent’s advocate indicated in the IEP meeting notes that the parent did not agree with the District’s triennial evaluation and that they were requesting an LMB assessment. (Dist.’s Exh. 16, pg. 87.) According to Petitioner, the District failed to respond to his request for an LMB assessment. In direct response to their disagreement with the District’s evaluation, the family subsequently obtained an independent evaluation from the LMB clinic in October 2002.

With respect to the appropriateness of the District’s assessment, the Hearing Officer has already found above that the District’s February 2002 assessment failed to assess STUDENT’s written language skills, which was an area of suspected disability. STUDENT’s written language skills were assessed as part of the LMB diagnostic evaluation. LMB clinic director Nikki Jakins testified that, as part of her independent evaluation, she administered LMB’s Informal Tests of Writing, which, in addition to other test results, provided essential information about STUDENT’s ability to comprehend written language and express himself in writing. The LMB test results indicated, among other things, that STUDENT had weakness in concept imagery that contributes to associated weakness in his oral and written language comprehension and expression, problem solving, and following oral directions. (Pet.’s Exh. HH.) The Hearing Officer therefore finds that the October 2002 LMB assessment obtained by the parents appropriately assessed STUDENT’s written language skills.

The District contends that during the June 2002 IEP meeting, it offered to conduct an LMB assessment, and that the parents never responded to the offer. However, there is no evidence to substantiate the District’s claim that it presented a formal assessment plan to the parent. The evidence establishes that the District never conducted an LMB assessment and the District’s vague offer to conduct an LMB assessment does not cure its failure to present a formal assessment plan in response to the parent’s request.

Therefore, given the parents disagreement with the District’s 2002 assessment, the Hearing Officer’s determination above that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability, and the District’s failure to respond to the parent’s request for an LMB assessment, Petitioner is entitled to reimbursement for the 2002 LMB assessment.

2004 Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes assessment

According to STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, and SISTER, the family obtained the June 6, 2004 LMB assessment to determine if STUDENT had made any progress since having attended the SLC. Ms. Rice testified that the parents obtained the 2004 LMB testing because the SLC did not provide pre- and post-testing and they wanted to determine whether STUDENT made any progress.

There is no convincing evidence that the District refused to provide the parents with an update of STUDENT’s progress at the SLC. In fact, the SLC had already conducted pre-testing in July 2003. On April 30, 2004, the SLC developed a client progress report that indicated the amount and type of educational therapy STUDENT had received to date, the progress he had made, and SLC’s recommendation for his continued treatment. The fax notation at the top of the progress report indicates that the SLC faxed the document on May 7, 2004, approximately one month before Petitioner obtained his June 2004 LMB assessment. (Pet.’s Exh. TT.) Additionally, the District had already conducted an addendum to the triennial assessment less than one year earlier in July 2003, and the parents did not indicate any disagreement with that testing. (Dist.’s Exh. 35.)

LMB’s 2004 assessment was not the result of the parent=s disagreement with the District=s assessment. Petitioner=s request, therefore, does not meet the statutory criteria for reimbursement because there was no District assessment with which the parent disagreed and there was no evidence that the District had refused to conduct an assessment. Therefore, the parent did not have the right to an independent assessment at public expense.

B. Compensatory Education

The Hearing Officer determined above that STUDENT was substantively denied a FAPE from April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year and for the 2000-2001 and 2001-2002 school years, as to his reading needs; from June 25, 2002, through the 2002-2003 school year, as to his reading and written language needs; during the 2003-2004 regular school year, as to his reading needs; and during the 2004 ESY, with respect to all of his needs. In light of that determination, the Hearing Officer considers whether compensatory education is warranted. As a remedy for being denied a FAPE, Petitioner requests that the District be ordered to provide him compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood Bell Learning Processes Center, including transportation to and from the Center.

The District argues that it offered in October 2003 and began implementing in April 2004, upon consent of the parent, what it deems to be compensatory education services through the Stowell Learning Center. According to the District, its provision of a FAPE and compensatory education services precludes the necessity for similar compensatory education services provided by another nonpublic agency.

Compensatory education is an equitable remedy that may be available when the school district has failed to provide the student with appropriate, special education services. (Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (9th Cir. 1994) 31 F.3d 1489, 1496; see also S.V. v. Sherwood School District 75 F.Supp.2d 1153, 1157 (D. Oregon, 1999).) Compensatory education does not require day-for-day or session-for-session replacement for opportunity lost or time missed. Its purpose is to Aensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.@ (Puyallup School District, supra, 31 F.3d at 1497.)

It is an inescapable fact that over the course of more than four years, despite being within the average range of intelligence, STUDENT did not advance more than one and one-half grade levels in reading, and is currently reading between a fourth- to fifth-grade level as a senior in high school. In written language, although STUDENT made advances in certain aspects of written language over the years, his overall written language skills currently are only at the mid-fourth-grade level. In the face of STUDENT’s educational decline, the District offered no plan to address his reading difficulties, in spite of the May 1999 District evaluation team’s conclusion that STUDENT required intensive specific reading instruction. Additionally, from June 25, 2002, to September 2003, STUDENT’s educational program did not properly address his written language difficulties. Given the evidence of STUDENT’s stalled academic performance, and the failure of the District to address STUDENT’s difficulties for such an extended period of time, the Hearing Officer finds that intensive compensatory educational services are appropriate and necessary.

The Hearing Officer examines the District’s offer of compensatory services, which are currently being provided to STUDENT, to determine whether the offer would allow STUDENT to be appropriately educated given the number of years he has been denied a FAPE in the areas of reading and written language.

In October 2003, the District offered STUDENT educational therapy services through the SLC, which were designed to address, among other issues, STUDENT’s reading comprehension deficits. (Dist.’s Exh. 47, pg. 278.) Jill Stowell, director of the Stowell Learning Center, testified about the programs and strategies offered as part of STUDENT’s educational therapy sessions at the SLC. The SLC program that was designed for STUDENT includes utilizing the Processing and Cognitive Enhancement (PACE) program for one hour daily, with some daily home listening, to develop auditory and visual processing, processing speed, phonemic awareness, memory, integration and synchrony, and executive function skills. STUDENT’s SLC program also includes auditory and stimulation training using the Samonas Sound Therapy and Learning Ears programs, the Listen-Echo Tap strategy, and a visualizing strategy to develop auditory processing, verbal and reading fluency and comprehension. In addition, instruction in reading, spelling, and writing skills is provided through the “Master the Code” (MTC) program and Rehearsed Reading. The “Improving Student Writing Through Focus” program is utilized to increase STUDENT’s oral and written language grammar and structure. (Pet.’s Exhs. NN and VV; testimony of J. Stowell.)

Ms. Stowell testified that she recommended the PACE and Master the Code programs instead of the Lindamood Phoneme Sequencing program (LIPS) program for STUDENT because the PACE and MTC programs incorporate strategies that develop phonemic awareness through feeling in the mouth and symbol imagery. These programs have eight different procedures that can be used to develop phonemic awareness and utilize the metronome to force temporal processing and automaticity. The MTC program exposes STUDENT to hundreds of words and provides drills to help build his sight vocabulary. SLC also has incorporated LMB’s Visualizing and Verbalizing techniques into its program as they work on comprehension, oral expression, and written expression because visualizing is a key piece of comprehension. (Footnote 31)

Ms. Stowell stated that it would take more than 225 hours of educational therapy for STUDENT to become an independent and fluent reader at grade level, but that STUDENT is starting to apply the skills he has learned at the SLC. She testified that STUDENT can now read high school level books and comprehend well, although his books must be carefully chosen because he decodes slowly and he has not started the multi-syllable portion of the SLC program. STUDENT just completed reading an adult-level book Who Moved My Cheese, which is very “readable” and has fairly large print. He understood the book and enjoyed reading it. He just started reading George Orwell’s “1984,” which has very small print and is written in a very difficult style. STUDENT can decode and comprehend “1984,” but it is too difficult to be a good instructional tool for STUDENT at this time. (Testimony of J. Stowell.)

The Hearing Officer finds persuasive Ms. Stowell’s testimony regarding the potential of STUDENT’s continued success with the SLC program. According to her, as of April 2004, STUDENT’s most noticeable improvement was in the clarity of his articulation and his ability to express his thoughts more clearly and completely. Ms. Stowell also stated that STUDENT now has more stamina and is able to summarize an entire book. (See also Pet.’s Exh. TT.) STUDENT also now knows when he mispronounces letters and words.

By June 2004, STUDENT’s auditory processing skills had greatly improved and he was able to repeat a series of fifteen-word pairs clearly and correctly. He also could repeat sentences of up to nine words correctly, with accurate enunciation, phrasing, and vocal inflection. In the area of oral and written expression skills, the accuracy and sophistication of STUDENT’s sentence structure and vocabulary had improved. STUDENT could write three- to four-sentence paragraphs, and after proofreading his own writing products, he showed approximately seventy percent accuracy with capitalization and punctuation, and seventy to eighty percent accuracy with spelling. STUDENT showed 3.7 years growth in his processing speed, 9.2 years growth in auditory analysis, and 4.1 years growth in logic and reasoning on the Gibson Cognitive Test Battery. STUDENT’s phonemic awareness skills also improved and he was better able to segment sounds and syllables in different ways. (Testimony of J. Stowell; Pet.’s Exh. VV.)

Ms. Stowell stated that she has twenty years of experience working with students who have learning difficulties similar to STUDENT’s. She also has spent a considerable amount of time testing STUDENT and providing instruction to him using SLC’s program and methodologies. Ms. Stowell’s credible testimony about her program and the specific strategies that she successfully uses at the SLC, as well as her explanation of how the goals and objectives she developed were specific to STUDENT’s needs and implemented during STUDENT’s session, establishes that STUDENT is currently being appropriately educated. Therefore, the Hearing Officer finds that appropriate compensatory services may be provided by the SLC. Similar compensatory education by another nonpublic agency, such as Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, is, thus, not necessary.

Ms. Stowell testified that after completing the SLC program she would expect STUDENT to be able to function at the high school level in decoding, reading fluency, and reading comprehension. In writing, she stated that after completing her program, STUDENT should be able to independently organize and write a multiple-paragraph paper with a main idea, topic sentence, and correct capitalization and punctuation. Ms. Stowell stated, however, she would feel more comfortable assessing STUDENT’s progress after his participation in the program on a four-hour-per-day, five-day-per-week basis. Ms. Stowell indicated that her goal was to help STUDENT be the best learner he could be and that she believed STUDENT was capable of performing at a higher level than he was currently performing.

The Hearing Officer finds that although STUDENT is not entitled to day-for-day compensatory education for the educational opportunity that was lost, the District must provide the remaining hours of the SLC educational therapy left from the initial 225-hour recommendation. Ms. Stowell was unable to specify the exact amount of compensatory education services through the SLC that would be necessary for STUDENT to read and write at the high school level; however, she stated that a more accurate assessment of STUDENT’s progress and needs for additional services could be made after he has completed the initial 225 recommended hours of therapy and been reevaluated. Nevertheless, the Hearing Officer finds that after completing the initial 225 hours of SLC educational services, the District must also provide compensatory education services for a period of two years to assist STUDENT with decoding, reading fluency, reading comprehension, and organizing and writing a multiple-paragraph paper with a main idea, topic sentence, correct capitalization, and punctuation. Given the number of years the District has failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE in the areas of reading and written language and given that his reading and writing skills have remained far below grade level, the Hearing Officer finds this level of compensatory education to be appropriate.

In addition, the Hearing Officer finds that the manner in which the supplemental services at the SLC are currently being provided to STUDENT is not appropriate. The current arrangement requires STUDENT to be in school all day and then travel to the SLC in Diamond Bar, California, and receive an additional three hours of instruction after the end of his regular school day. (Testimony of L. Stowell.) Ms. Stowell testified that STUDENT needs to increase the amount of time in the SLC program to become a fluent reader and independent learner. According to Ms. Stowell, STUDENT needs educational therapy at least three hours daily, five days a week, for the entire year until he completes the initial 225 hours of therapy. Given STUDENT’s work and school schedule, Ms. Stowell believed STUDENT would not be able to maintain the three to four-hour daily therapy sessions at the SLC that he required.

The District is required to convene an IEP meeting to determine how to provide STUDENT the compensatory education services and must take into consideration the fact that simultaneously with the delivery of the FAPE, the school may also be implementing the supplemental services provided by the SLC.

Once STUDENT has completed the initial 225 hours of SLC educational therapy, the District shall reassess STUDENT in the areas of reading and written language, and the IEP team shall then determine the specific type of additional compensatory services that will be provided to STUDENT for an additional two-year period to address his deficits in decoding, reading fluency, reading comprehension, and written language. The District must also provide STUDENT transportation to and from the SLC.

ORDER

1. Within 30 days of receipt of proof, the District shall reimburse Petitioner=s parent for the cost of the October 2002 Lindamood-Bell assessment.

2. The District shall invite and arrange for the attendance of Jill Stowell at the IEP meeting at which the determination regarding the provision of the SLC services is discussed.

3. Within 15 calendar days from the date of this Decision, the IEP team shall meet and do the following:

(a) Revise STUDENT’s IEP so that it includes an intensive reading intervention program incorporated into his school day and through which his reading goal and objectives can be addressed.

(b) Specify, in writing, the extended school year services the District intends to provide to STUDENT for the summer 2005.

(c) Determine how to provide STUDENT the Stowell Learning Center educational therapy services. The particulars of the compensatory education implementation plan shall be left to the discretion of the IEP team. However, should the IEP team determine it appropriate to provide those services on days which STUDENT also attends school, the team shall consider the fact that simultaneously with the delivery of the FAPE, the school also will be implementing the supplemental services provided by the SLC.

4. The District shall provide STUDENT transportation of one round-trip between STUDENT’s home or school and the SLC on scheduled clinic days.

5. Once STUDENT has completed the initial 225 hours of SLC educational therapy, the District shall reassess STUDENT in the areas of reading and written language, and the IEP team shall reconvene and determine the specific type of additional compensatory services that will be provided to STUDENT for an additional two-year period to address deficits in decoding, reading fluency, reading comprehension, and written language.

6. All of Petitioner=s remaining claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to California Education Code § 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with this requirement.

I. From February 2000 to April 11, 2000, did STUDENT make sufficient educational progress in reading and written language?

The District prevailed on this issue.

II. From April 12, 2000, to the end of the 1999-2000 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a free appropriate public education (FAPE) by

A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. changing STUDENT’s placement at the April 12, 2000 IEP meeting to a more restrictive placement without providing prior written notice, and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 12, 2000 IEP for the extended school year;

B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The District prevailed on issue II.A.1 and partially prevailed on issue II.A.2 to the extent that the procedural error did not amount to a denial of a FAPE. The District prevailed on issue II.B to the extent that it provided STUDENT a FAPE as to his written language needs. Petitioner prevailed on issue II.B to the extent that the District failed to provide him a FAPE as to his reading needs.

III. From the beginning of the 2000-2001 school year to April 2, 2001, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The District prevailed on this issue to the extent that it provided a FAPE as to STUDENT’s written language needs. Petitioner prevailed on this issue to the extent that the District failed to provide him a FAPE as to his reading needs.

IV. From April 3, 2001, to the end of the 2000-2001 school year, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not assess phonemic awareness deficits and did not conduct a full assessment in written language in preparation for the April 2001 IEP; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. committing the following procedural errors:

a. failing to have a general education teacher in attendance at the April 3, 2001 IEP meeting, and b. failing to make a specific written program offer in the April 3, 2001 IEP for the extended school year; 2. failing to develop goals and objectives in his April 3, 2001 IEP to address his needs in the areas of phonemic awareness, visual processing, and auditory processing, 3. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and 4. failing to develop an individual transition plan in the April 3, 2001

IEP?

The District prevailed on issue IV.A. The District also prevailed on issues IV.B.1.a and partially prevailed on IV.B.1.b to the extent that the procedural error did not amount to a denial of a FAPE. The District prevailed on issues IV.B.2. and IV.B.4. The District prevailed on issue IV.B.3 to the extent that it provided STUDENT a FAPE as to his written language needs. Petitioner prevailed on issue IV.B.3 to the extent that the District failed to provide a FAPE as to his reading needs.

V. From the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year to June 24, 2002, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not conduct a full assessment in written language and did not do further cognitive testing after the February 27, 2002 evaluation; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit, and 2. failing to provide a home instruction program that comported with his IEP from March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002?

Petitioner prevailed on issue V.A to the extent that the District failed to conduct a full assessment of his written language skills. The District prevailed on issue V.A to the extent that it appropriately assessed STUDENT’s cognitive ability. Petitioner prevailed on issue V.B.1. to the extent that the District failed to provide him a FAPE as to his reading needs. The District prevailed on issue V.B.1. to the extent that it provided STUDENT a FAPE as to his written language needs. Petitioner prevailed on issue V.B.2.

VI. At the June 25, 2002 IEP meeting, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. failing to make a specific written offer program offer in the June 25, 2002 IEP for the extended school year, and B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The District prevailed on issue VI.A. to the extent that the procedural error did not amount to a denial of a FAPE. Petitioner prevailed on issue VI.B.

VII. From the beginning of the 2002-2003 school year to June 29, 2003, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by failing to develop a program that was designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Petitioner prevailed on this issue.

VIII. At the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting, did the District

A. fail to appropriately assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability because it did not do a full assessment in written language before July 2003 and did not formally decline the parents’ request to conduct a central auditory processing assessment; B. deny STUDENT a FAPE by 1. failing to make a specific written program offer in the June 30, 2003 IEP for the extended school year, and 2. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

Petitioner partially prevailed on issue VIII.A to the extent that the District failed to conduct a full written language assessment. The District partially prevailed on issue VIII.A. to the extent that it properly declined the parents’ request for a central auditory processing disorder assessment. The District partially prevailed on issue VIII.B.1 to the extent that it made a specific written program offer for the 2003 ESY. Petitioner partially prevailed on issue VIII.B.1 to the extent that the District failed to make a specific written program offer in the June 30, 2003 IEP for the 2004 ESY.

IX. During the 2003-2004 school year, did the District deny STUDENT a FAPE by

A. committing the following procedural errors:

1. failing to make a specific written offer for the Stowell Learning Center services, and 2. failing to make a specific written program offer in the September/October 2003 IEP for the extended school year;

B. failing to develop a program that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit?

The District prevailed on issues IX.A.1 and IX.A.2. Petitioner prevailed on issue IX.B to the extent that the District failed to provide him a FAPE as to his reading needs. The District prevailed on issue IX.B. to the extent that it provided STUDENT a FAPE as to his written language needs.

X. Is Petitioner entitled to the following remedies:

A. reimbursement for the 2002 and 2004 assessments completed by the Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center and/or B. compensatory education consisting of educational therapy services provided by Lindamood-Bell Learning Processes Center, including transportation to and from the Center?

Petitioner prevailed on issue X.A with respect to the 2002 Lindamood-Bell assessment, and the District prevailed with respect to the 2004 Lindamood-Bell assessment. Petitioner prevailed on issue X.B. to the extent that he is entitled to two years of compensatory education, including transportation, in addition to that what is currently being provided by the District. The District prevailed on issue X.B. to the extent that the compensatory education services may be provided by the Stowell Learning Center, with the specifications ordered by the Hearing Officer.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. (California Education Code § 56505(i).)

Dated: November 26, 2004 __________________________________ Deborah M. Cooke, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

The record did indicate that on the first day of the expedited hearing, Petitioner attempted to make an argument regarding achievement testing conducted in 1999 using the Woodcock Johnson Tests of Achievement. However, no issue regarding cognitive testing was raised at that time.

2 The issues listed here differ in numbering and wording from those noticed by Petitioner before the hearing. Changes were made for purposes of clarification or for appropriate analysis.

3 During the hearing in this matter, the Hearing Officer took judicial notice of a prior SEHO decision involving the same parties, case number SN02-00822. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer incorporates by reference into this Decision some of the background facts identified in the 2002 Decision.

4 That matter was case number SN02-00822.

5 Citing Fuhrman v. East Hanover Bd. Of Education, 993 F.2d 1031, 1041 (3rd Cir. 1993)

6 There was some debate between the parties regarding where, in the average range, STUDENT’s cognitive ability lies. The District contends that when all available information is taken into consideration, the best estimate of STUDENT’s overage cognitive ability is within the low average to average range. (Dist.’s closing argument, pg. 2.) Petitioner seems to contend that he has “good” or “average” cognitive abilities. (Pet.’s closing argument, pgs. 10 and 18.) This slight difference of opinion did not prove relevant with respect to the issues in this case because neither party contended that STUDENT was incapable of performing average level work. Additionally, at the conclusion of the hearing, the District provided a protocol for the Test of Nonverbal Intelligence (TONI) that was conducted by the District in 1999. In his closing argument, Petitioner raises two additional issues based on the late-provided scores and asks that they be noted as part of this Decision. Petitioner now alleges that the District failed to provide documents requested by the parent in a written request for records. He also alleges that the District failed to provide the basis for its determination of a specific learning disability (SLD) in 1999 by failing to report the TONI cognitive ability score of 103. (Pet.’s closing argument, pgs. 1-2.) With respect to the request for documents, once the District produced the TONI protocol at hearing, the Hearing Officer gave both parties an opportunity to review the document, the document was admitted into evidence, and both parties had an opportunity to present additional testimony regarding the new information. Therefore, any prejudice that may have been caused by the late-submitted document was alleviated by the Hearing Officer’s granting each party an opportunity to address the new evidence. As for the contention that the District failed to provide its basis for determining in 1999 that STUDENT had an SLD, when the District provided the March 1999 evaluation report to his parents, Petitioner knew or should have known at that time that the report did not include the TONI standard score. Therefore, Petitioner was required to raise this issue by March 2002 for it to come within the statute of limitations.

7Petitioner did not assert that he failed to make progress in math during all time frames at issue. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not analyze whether STUDENT made appropriate educational progress with respect to math.

8 Mr. Nagel stated that he has a master’s degree in history from the University of California, Santa Barbara; a lifetime standard secondary teaching credential; and a learning handicapped certificate from California Polytechnic, Pomona. He has been an SDC teacher with the Charter Oak Unified School District since 1986.

9 The issue of whether or not the programs and services the District offered over the years were provided in the least restrictive environment was not raised by the Student in this matter and, therefore, is not addressed by the Hearing Officer.

10 During the 1998-1999 school year, STUDENT was in the sixth grade and placed in an RSP classroom.

11 Also included in the District’s exhibit packet was the same form letter dated August 16, 1999, in which the District apparently initially informed the parents that STUDENT would be readmitted to the RSP program for the seventh grade. (Dist.’s Exh. 2, pg. 14.) It appears the District later corrected its proposal to inform the parents that STUDENT would, instead, be placed in an SDC.

12 During the school year, two addendums to the IEP were also developed. The first effected a change for STUDENT from an SDC math class to an RSP math class. (Dist.’s Exh. 4.) The second addendum was to provide parent consent for STUDENT’s participation in SAT-9 testing. (Dist.’s Exh. 7.) The Hearing Officer will only address the appropriateness of the April 2000 and April 2001 IEPs during this time frame, as Petitioner did not dispute the appropriateness of the IEP addendums.

13 Ms. Stowell testified that she has a master’s degree in education, with an emphasis on learning handicaps. She also has a California multiple subjects credential, a California learning handicapped credential, a California resource specialist certificate, and a California dyslexia remediation specialist certificate. According to Ms. Stowell, for the past twenty years, the Stowell Learning Center has provided cognitive and educational therapy to students with a variety of learning challenges, such as learning disabilities, autism spectrum disorders, cognitive delays and language delays.

14 Ms. Dyl testified that she is a school psychologist employed by the District with duties that include screening students for disabilities and possible entrance into special education, advising teachers and students on how students can best access education, and providing crisis counseling. Ms. Dyl also stated that she has a master’s degree in counseling and teaching credentials in special education, multiple subjects, and home economics.

15 Ms. Mack testified that she has been a clinical psychologist since 1995, with a specialty in children and adolescents. As part of her practice, she conducts psychoeducational diagnostic and psychotherapy sessions. She has participated in numerous IEP meetings and due process hearings, and regularly conducts assessments on behalf of school districts for purposes of special education determinations.

16 Mr. Nagel testified that he attended STUDENT’s April 3, 2001 IEP meeting as his case carrier and was responsible for writing up the IEP document during the meeting.

17 The WRAT-3, which was last administered by the District in March 2001, assessed only STUDENT’s spelling skills. (Dist.’s Exh. 7, pg. 40; testimony of S. Nagel.)

18 As part of the February 2002 testing, STUDENT also performed at the 11.3 grade level in passage comprehension on the Woodcock-Johnson Tests of Achievement-Third Edition (WJ-III). However, Ms. Dyl explained that the disparity in STUDENT’s reading comprehension scores on the WJ-III and the WIAT was related to the different levels of difficulty on the tests. STUDENT tested much stronger on the WJ-III passage comprehension, where he had to supply a missing word in a sentence, than when he had to read a passage and answer questions about what he read, as indicated by his comprehension scores on the WIAT.

19 On March 20, 2002, STUDENT brought alcohol to school, provided it to a peer, and pursuant to a manifestation determination held by the District, he was subsequently suspended and recommended for expulsion. From March 25, 2002, to May 23, 2002, while the expulsion process was pending, STUDENT received home instruction from SDC teacher Frank Foster. In a separate due process matter, STUDENT’s parents disputed the District’s manifestation determination. (SN02-00822)

20 STUDENT was entitled to return to his IEP placement at Charter Oak High School on May 25, 2002, following a due process hearing and Decision in which the Hearing Officer determined that no assessment had been conducted for the manifestation determination, and that the District had not complied with procedural requirements for a proper manifestation determination.

21 According to student services director Patrick Castagnaro, “TBD” likely meant that the level of ESY services was “to be determined.”

22 Even assuming the June 25, 2002 IEP was to be applicable to the 2003 ESY, the evidence demonstrates that the District later supplemented the June 2002 IEP with a more specific offer of services for the 2003 ESY. See discussion below.

23 The October 29, 2002 IEP team convened to review STUDENT’s functional analysis assessment and develop a behavior teaching plan. There were no other changes made to STUDENT’s program at the October 2002 IEP meeting and Petitioner asserted no issues with respect to that IEP. Therefore, the Hearing Officer will not consider the appropriateness of the October 2002 IEP.

24 This argument is not persuasive with respect to the 2003-2004 school year because Ms. Magee obtained her internship credential before the beginning of the 2003-2004 school year. Ms. Magee testified that she is currently enrolled in a mild to moderate credentialing program and obtained her internship credential in March 2003, which allows her to teach while she pursues her full credential. An internship credential authorizes an individual to serve at the same levels as the regular credential authorizes. (Cal. Educ. Code § 44454.)

25 Petitioner did not dispute the appropriateness of the District’s written language assessments once they were completed in July 2003.

26 In his closing argument, Petitioner seems to assert a new issue, arguing that the District also failed to conduct the speech and language assessment that the parents requested at the June 30, 2003 IEP meeting. (Pet.’s closing argument, pgs. 8-9.) However, Petitioner did not identify this issue for hearing when clarifying the issues on the first day of hearing. Petitioner knew prior to the first day of hearing that the District had not conducted a speech and language assessment, and he had the opportunity on the first day of hearing to raise the issue, but failed to do so. The Hearing Officer will not address this issue.

27 Petitioner did not request as a remedy that the Hearing Officer order the District to conduct a central auditory processing assessment.

28 The June 30, 2003 IEP indicates that it was intended to be implemented from September 2003 to June 2004, and therefore, the District’s ESY offer in that IEP would not have been applicable to the 2003 ESY.

29 The District argues that it attempted to convene an IEP meeting first on August 5, 2003, and then again on September 12, 2003, for the purpose of reviewing assessments and developing an IEP for STUDENT. According to the District, the meeting was rescheduled twice, due to the unavailability or failure to attend by attorney Whiteleather.

30 The fact that the District offered the SLC services as compensatory education appears to indicate that the District, itself, realized it had previously failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE, and that he required supplemental services to make up for educational opportunity lost over the years.

31 LMB’s Visualizing and Verbalizing program develops comprehension skills by visualizing how to put images together into a gestalt. (Pet.’s Exh. HH-4.)