California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · April 18, 2001

Student v. Las Virgenes Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 221-00 · Hearing Officer Glenna Eubank deCamara

Las Virgenes Unified must reimburse first-semester Summit View tuition and mileage; second-semester and compensatory claims denied.

Split decision: student prevailed on 2 of 7 issues (2 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Noted in the decision

None noted. The decision references the prior decision in SN 1268-98 (January 24, 2000) between the same parties, which found a denial of FAPE for 1997-98 and 1998-99.

Summary

The parents of a seventh grader with a specific learning disability and attention difficulties filed this case. They had rejected Las Virgenes Unified School District's August 1999 IEP offer and enrolled him at Summit View School, a certified nonpublic school. He could not decode words, and his writing was far below grade level. The district offered special day class (SDC) for core subjects and general education for three periods. It also offered two 30-minute occupational therapy (OT) sessions weekly and one-to-one Lindamood-Bell reading instruction: two hours per week in the first semester, rising to three to four hours in January 2000.

The Hearing Officer found the Lindamood-Bell method appropriate. But two hours a week was too little for a student this far behind. She found the planned increase was likely tied to staff training and treated it as an admission that the first-semester amount was too low. That denied FAPE for the first semester. The second-semester offer, plus daily SDC language arts using a sequential reading program, was adequate. The reading and spelling goals were poorly designed, but that defect alone did not deny FAPE. A late IEP meeting after an assistive technology reassessment was a procedural violation that caused no harm. Because the parents consented to no part of the IEP, the district could not provide OT. The district must reimburse first-semester tuition and mileage. Compensatory tutoring, technology and OT were denied.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

Shows how SEHO handled an offer that started a severely delayed reader on fewer remediation hours, apparently because staff were not yet trained. Reimbursement was limited to the semester when the offer fell short. The decision also shows that parents who reject an entire IEP cannot later claim the district failed to provide the services they declined.

Issues and holdings

  1. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEAssessment

    Issue 1A(i). Procedural: whether the District failed to conduct an assistive technology assessment and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results within statutory timelines, denying a FAPE for 1999-2000

    The parent's request at the August 1999 IEP meeting did not trigger a new assessment, and the April 2000 reassessment was timely. Failing to hold an IEP meeting on the results until August 2000 was a procedural violation. It did not deny FAPE because the recommendations were unchanged and the parent took part in the assessment.

  2. Issue 1A(ii). Whether the District denied a FAPE by failing to provide compensatory OT ordered in prior case SN 1268-98

    Under Wyner, enforcing a prior SEHO order is outside SEHO's jurisdiction, so this claim was not addressed.

  3. Procedural violation, no denial of FAPEIEP content

    Issue 1B(i). Whether the District identified and addressed the student's unique needs, including the adequacy of proposed goals and objectives

    The District identified the student's needs and offered adequate accommodations. Its reading, spelling, writing and math goals were not designed to meet his needs, but the Hearing Officer held this defect alone did not deny FAPE.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 1B(ii). Whether the District's offer of Lindamood-Bell remediation was sufficient and reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit for the 1999-2000 school year

    The Lindamood-Bell method was appropriate. However, two hours per week in the first semester was too little for a seventh grader who could not read, and the stated reason was apparently a lack of trained staff, so FAPE was denied for that semester. The second-semester offer of three to four hours per week, plus daily SDC language arts, was a FAPE.

  5. District prevailedImplementation

    Issue 1B(iii). Whether the District denied a FAPE by failing to provide the OT services in the August 20, 1999 IEP

    The parents consented to no part of the August 1999 IEP, so the District had no authority to provide OT. Its failure to provide OT did not deny FAPE.

  6. Issue 2. If the District denied a FAPE for 1999-2000, is the student entitled to reimbursement of tuition and related costs of his unilateral placement at Summit View, a nonpublic school?

    Judged by what the parents knew when they chose it, Summit View was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. This held despite concerns about no nondisabled peers and limited individual remediation. Reimbursement of tuition and mileage was awarded for the first semester only.

  7. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of intensive tutoring, assistive technology services, and OT?

    No compensatory technology, because the late IEP meeting caused no loss. No compensatory tutoring, because nonpublic school reimbursement already compensated for the first semester. No compensatory OT, because the parents declined the OT the District offered.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Reimbursement. Within thirty calendar days of receiving verifying documentation, the District shall reimburse Summit View School tuition costs for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year.
  • Reimbursement. The District shall reimburse round-trip mileage from home to Summit View School, at the District's standard mileage reimbursement rate, for the days actually attended in the first semester of 1999-2000.

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Rowley; Gregory K. v. Longview School District; Union School Dist. v. Smith; Seattle School District v. B.S.; W.G. v. Target Range; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee; Bend-Lapine School District v. D.W.; Adams v. State of Oregon; Burlington; Florence County School District Four v. Carter; Student W. v. Puyallup School District; Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District; Alamo Heights v. State Board of Education; Todd v. Andrews; Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696

People named in the decision

  • Peggy Woodall, director of pupil services, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Sasha Borenstein, Ph.D., director of nonpublic agency providing academic remediation; assessor and witness for Student, The Kelter Center
  • Nancy Rosenfelt, director of nonpublic school, Summit View School
  • Bina Varughese, coordinator of educational services, Summit View School
  • Nita Ferjo, Ph.D., educational psychologist, expert witness for Student
  • Joseph Nardo, director of secondary education, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Sharie Lynne Kromnick, special education teacher
  • Abbe August-Shoor, Ph.D., assistant principal, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Rhea Allen-George, RSP teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Sharon Lee, special day class teacher, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Dianne Erland, secretary, Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Barbara Starr, school psychologist (testified in prior hearing), Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Mary Ann Lowry, resource specialist teacher, academic assessor (testified in prior hearing), Las Virgenes Unified School District
  • Renee Lewis, MFCC, private therapist
  • Adaptive Technology Assessment Center (ATAC), assistive technology assessor
  • Arielle Reinstein, paralegal for Student's counsel, Newman, Aaronson, Vanaman
  • Bill Pugin, sign language interpreter for Student's counsel
  • Catherine Kiwitt, sign language interpreter for Student's counsel
  • Michelle Sarfas, assistant to District counsel, Filarsky & Watt

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard before Glenna Eubank deCamara, Hearing Officer of the California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific, in Calabasas, California, on July 25, August 29, September 11, 12, and October 26, 27, and 30, 2000.

STUDENT (herein after STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by attorney Alexis Kashar with the law firm of Newman, Aaronson, Vanaman. Ms. Kashar’s paralegal, Arielle Reinstein, was present for portions of the hearing. STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, was present throughout the hearing, and his father, FATHER was present for much of the hearing. Bill Pugin and Catherine Kiwitt were present throughout the hearing to provide sign language interpretation for Ms. Kashar.

Las Virgenes Unified School District (hereinafter Las Virgenes or District) was represented by attorney Sharon Watt with the law firm of Filarsky & Watt. Ms. Watt’s assistant, Michelle Sarfas was present for one day of the hearing. Also present on Las Virgenes’ behalf was Peggy Woodall, Las Virgenes’ director of pupil services.

The Petitioner called the following witness to testify: MOTHER, mother of Petitioner; Sasha Borenstein, Ph.D., director of the Kelter Center; Nancy Rosenfelt, director of Summit View School; STUDENT, Petitioner; Nita Ferjo, Ph.D., educational psychologist; Bina Varughese, coordinator of educational services at Summit View School; Joseph Nardo, director of secondary education for Las Virgenes; and Sharie Lynne Kromnick, special education teacher. Las Virgenes called the following witnesses to testify: Abbe August-Shoor, Ph.D., assistant principal; Rhea Allen-George, RSP teacher; Sharon Lee, special day class teacher; and Dianne Erland, secretary for Las Virgenes.

Oral and documentary evidence was received and the record was left open for the submission of written closing arguments. The closing arguments were received, the record was closed, and the issues were submitted for decision.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

On January 24, 2000, this Hearing Officer rendered a decision in case number SN 1268-98. The instant case was filed by the same Petitioner against the same Respondent, and the parties are represented by the same attorney/law firm.

In the Petitioner’s first case, his identified issues involved an appropriate public education (FAPE) for the school years of 1996-97 through 1998-99; compensatory occupational services (OT); and reimbursement for educational expenses. The Hearing Officer denied the Petitioner’s motion to also include the upcoming 1999-2000 school year within the hearing. Because the IEP meeting to determine placement for the 1999-2000 school year had not yet been held, the issue of whether the offer constituted a FAPE was not “ripe” for adjudication.

While the first hearing was ongoing, the parties participated in an IEP meeting on the issue of placement and services for the1999-2000 school year. The Petitioner subsequently filed the instant hearing, maintaining that the District had not offered him a FAPE for that school year.

ISSUES(Footnote !)

1. Did the District provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year?

2. If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year, is he entitled to reimbursement of tuition and related costs of his unilateral placement at Summit View, a nonpublic school?

3. Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of intensive tutoring, assistive technology services, and OT?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

The Petitioner alleges that the District did not provide him with a free and appropriate education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year. As a result, he claims that he is entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and related costs of his unilateral placement at Summit View School (hereinafter Summit View), a certified nonpublic school (NPS). He further contends that the District has not provided him with the occupational therapy (OT) specified in his Individualized Educational Program (IEP) of August 1999. Additionally, the Petitioner asserts that the District failed to conduct an assisted technology assessment and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the assessments within the time-lines prescribed by statute. As a result, he claims that he is entitled to compensatory education consisting of an intensive tutorial program, OT, and assistive technology services.

The District contends that its offer of placement and services constituted a FAPE and would have provided STUDENT with an appropriate education. As a result, he is not entitled to reimbursement for the tuition and costs of his unilateral enrollment in an NPS. The District further maintains that the Petitioner did not avail himself of the OT services that the District had arranged on his behalf. The District also asserts that any procedural violations surrounding the assistive technology assessment did not result in a loss of educational opportunity that deprived the Petitioner of a FAPE. Consequently, the Petitioner is not entitled to compensatory OT, assistive technology services, or tutoring.

BACKGROUND FACTS

Pursuant to his parents’ unilateral placement, STUDENT is currently an eighth-grade student enrolled for his second year at Summit View School, a certified nonpublic educational facility. From the time STUDENT was identified as a special education student in first grade, until his transfer to Summit View, the District provided him with special education services for an attention disorder and a specific learning disability.

STUDENT’s parents have previously disputed the appropriateness of the special education services provided pursuant to his individualized educational programs (IEPs) for the first, second, and third grades. This dispute was resolved through a settlement agreement negotiated between the parties. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT then concurred with their son’s fourth grade IEP, which was signed on April 28, 1997. However, despite their agreement with this IEP, the Petitioner later contended in case number SN 1268-98, that he had consistently been denied a free and appropriate public education (FAPE) since the 1996-97 school year.(Footnote 2)

In the fourth grade, STUDENT was placed in a general education class with resource assistance in his classroom as needed. He also received pull-out services from the resource specialist program (RSP) for reading, math, and language arts, OT and an extended school year (ESY) program. Renee Lewis, MFCC, a private therapist engaged by the family, stated that STUDENT displayed symptoms of depression, poor peer interactions, somatization, poor school performance, anger, and confusion. Thus, the District offered a referral to a County Mental Health (CMH) agency for an assessment. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT initially agreed to the CMH referral, then subsequently withdrew their consent.

During the fifth grade, STUDENT experienced increased difficulties and resulting frustration with the academics in his general education class. Thus, in January 1998, STUDENT was placed in the SDC for 88% of the school day. He remained integrated for science (with aide assistance provided in the regular class), physical education (P.E.), computers, and special activities and projects. In response to the parents' request, the District convened an IEP meeting on May 14, 1998, and offered to return STUDENT to RSP pull-out services for one hundred and twenty minutes per day, five days per week. In the RSP class, he would receive instruction in language arts and math. With special education support from the SDC and RSP staff, he would attend the general education class for core literature and language. His OT would remain one time per week for fifty minutes. As a result of the proposed program changes, his integration with the regular education students would increase to 49% of the school day. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT authorized this placement through June 1998, but continued to express their disagreement.

The IEP team met again and drafted another IEP on June 4, 1998. This IEP returned STUDENT to the SDC each day for math, language arts, social studies, and science. His daily integration with his general education peers was reduced to 33%. The OT services remained unchanged. Pursuant to his parents' request, the District also agreed to conduct a complete assessment of STUDENT to determine his needs as he transitioned to middle school the following year. Although Mr. and Mrs. PARENT did not agree that the SDC was an appropriate placement for their son, they consented to its implementation pending due process proceedings.

The District's multidisciplinary psychoeducational report was completed on July 15, 1998. The school psychologist found a marked discrepancy between STUDENT's verbal intelligence quotient (IQ) score (101) and his performance IQ score (84) on the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children - III (WISC- III). She also noted a marked discrepancy between STUDENT's current and prior IQ scores. When comparing IQ scores on the WISC-III to those of prior years, she found that STUDENT had previously obtained the following stores: 1994 - verbal IQ of 126, performance IQ of 93; 1995 - verbal IQ of 112, performance IQ of 95; and 1997 - verbal IQ of 115, performance IQ of 93. The psychologist stated that STUDENT was not medicated for his attention difficulties at the time of her testing, and hypothesized that the decline in his IQ scores was a consequence of ADD. She indicated that she had reviewed the literature and found that children with problems attending often showed variability in intellectual functioning. Discussions with STUDENT's teacher confirmed that his classroom performance varied from day to day.

The psychologist concluded that STUDENT's actual intellectual functioning was within the above-average range for verbal and the average range for performance abilities, with significant problems in visual processing, attention, motor, and sequencing skills. She further noted significant strength in STUDENT's vocabulary, but major weaknesses in arithmetic, visual sequential reasoning abilities, comprehension of social situations, visual alertness, memory, and attention to detail. He displayed a marked weakness in acquiring new symbolic material and utilizing visual motor coordination. It was noted by the psychologist that these are skills necessary for coding. STUDENT also demonstrated very weak graphic-motor functioning. The psychologist concluded that STUDENT continued to qualify for special education with a disorder in the basic psychological processes governing attention and visual processing. She did not find that he met the criteria for an emotionally disturbed (ED) student.

An academic assessment was conducted by a District resource specialist. STUDENT demonstrated strengths in both receptive and expressive language skills, with strong sequencing abilities. His composite scores on the Wechsler Individual Achievement Test (WIAT) were: reading - 21st percentile, 3.9 grade equivalence; math - 13th percentile, 3.7 grade equivalence; language - 92nd percentile, 12.9 grade equivalence; and writing - 2nd percentile, 1.9 grade equivalence. According to the speech and language report, STUDENT had average to above-average skills in expressive and receptive language when only auditory information was presented. However, when he was required to decipher written or visual symbols, his skills declined dramatically.

On August 31, 1998, the Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) received a request for a due process hearing from the Petitioner. While the case was off calendar, the parties continued to participate in several IEP meetings. An IEP meeting was held when school resumed in the fall of 1998 to consider the assessments conducted during the summer. STUDENT was beginning the sixth grade and had transitioned to his neighborhood middle school campus. At the IEP meeting of September 28, 1998, the District proposed placing STUDENT in an SDC for social studies, language arts, science, and math. An elective and P.E. would be in general education classes. OT services would be provided for sixty minutes, one time per week. An assistive technology assessment had been conducted, and the District agreed to make appropriate software available to STUDENT. Goals and objectives were written, and a list was developed specifying the curriculum modifications STUDENT was to receive in each of his classes. MOTHER signed the IEP, but wrote that she disagreed with the placement offered and was uncertain if she agreed with the goals and objectives proposed. Despite a disagreement with the tendered placement and an existing due process claim, the Petitioner did not seek a "stay put" order from SEHO, nor did he immediately proceed with a hearing. Instead, STUDENT attended middle school and the District provided the services enumerated in the IEP of September 28, 1998.

The parties met again on January 20, 1999, to draft an addendum to the September 1998 IEP. Although the District maintained that STUDENT's existing program was appropriate, it consented to the parents' request to add science as an additional period in regular education. The special education staff would provide support and collaborate with the general education science teacher on the accommodations required by STUDENT. The District agreed to obtain a screening for the FastForWord program as well as additional assessments from The Kelter Center, a vision specialist, and an assistive technology specialist. The District again offered to refer STUDENT to CMH for an initial assessment and to provide STUDENT with school counseling once a week. The parents indicated that they would notify the District if they wanted either of these mental health services. Three mornings a week, STUDENT would receive forty-five minutes of before-school tutoring from the SDC teacher. The District also advised the parents that it would investigate the availability of additional lending libraries with books on tape and consider their request for two semesters of OT make-up sessions. The parties agreed that they would reconvene the IEP meeting after The Kelter Center had completed its assessment. MOTHER signed this addendum without noting any disagreement.

On March 9, 1999, the parties reconvened the IEP meeting to review the assessment results from The Kelter Center and determine an appropriate placement. The assistive technology report was incomplete. It was determined that STUDENT would be provided with an AlphaSmart computer until the technology evaluation was finished and additional technological recommendations were made. The vision specialist reported that STUDENT was able to perform visual work very well. He had good tracking and scanning skills. He did have difficulty with losing his place when he did not know the words he was reading. STUDENT's difficulties were found to be primarily the result of attention problems and an inability to decipher words, rather than the result of vision deficits. A speech and language pathologist conducted the FastForWord screening and found that STUDENT would not benefit as he had already mastered the tasks taught by the program. The Kelter Center reported that STUDENT's phonemic awareness skills were very weak. His knowledge of sound symbol correspondences and phonology was adequate for consonants, but not for vowels. He did not know the rules that would assist him in deciphering the alphabetic code. When he was read to, his comprehension skills were age-appropriate. However, he was not accurate or fluent when reading and spelling words. Handwriting was very "labor intensive" for STUDENT. Pursuant to the IEP addendum, the District agreed to investigate the personnel available to remediate STUDENT's deficits in sound/symbol relationships and correspond with the Petitioner's attorney regarding an offer of placement and services.

When the parties were unable to agree upon an educational program for STUDENT, case number SN 1268-98 proceeded to hearing during the summer of 1999. The issues presented were the appropriateness of the District’s program for STUDENT's fourth, fifth and sixth grade years (1996-97 through the 1998-99), reimbursement for privately obtained educational services, and compensatory occupational therapy (OT). On January 24, 2000, the Hearing Officer issued a decision concluding that STUDENT had been provided a FAPE during the 1996-97 school year, and that he was not entitled to reimbursement for psychological services, tutoring, or books on tape. A further finding was made that STUDENT had been denied a FAPE during the 1997-98 and 1998-99 school years. Consequently, as compensatory education he was to receive two extra hours per day of instruction in the area of reading and all OT sessions that had not been provided by the District.

While the hearing in case number SN 1268-98 was underway, the parties met on August 20, 1999, to determine STUDENT’s placement and services for the 1999-2000 school year. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT believed that the District’s offer to place STUDENT in regular education classes for physical education, science, and an elective, with three periods per day in an SDC, would not meet his needs. They rejected the District’s placement offer and enrolled STUDENT in Summit View for the 1999-2000 school year. On February 4, 2000, the Petitioner filed the instant due process proceeding, alleging a denial of a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year and seeking compensatory education and reimbursement for the tuition and related costs of his nonpublic school placement.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

ISSUE NUMBER ONE

Did the District provide a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for the 1999-2000 school year?

“Special education” is defined as “specially designed instruction at no cost to the parents, to meet the unique needs of a child with a disability . . . ” 20 U.S.C. §1401(25). Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free and appropriate public education. Pursuant to 20 U.S.C. §1401(8), “free and appropriate public education” means special education and related services that meet the standards of the State educational agency and conform with the students individualized education program.

In determining whether a district has offered a free, appropriate public education, the focus is on the adequacy of the district’s proposed placement. The criterion is not whether the parents desire another program, or if that program would result in greater educational benefit to the child. A placement is adequate if it is reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. Gregory K. v. Longview School District, 811 F.2nd 1307 (9th Cir. 1987) In the case of Board of Education of the Hendrick Hudson Central School District, et. al. vs. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175, (1982), the United States Supreme Court addressed the level of instruction and services that must be provided to a student with disabilities to satisfy the requirements of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA). The Court concluded that the IDEA does not require that a student be provided with the best available special education or that the services maximize each child’s potential. The Court held that “the ‘basic floor of opportunity’ provided by the Act consists of access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the child.” An appropriate public education does not mean the absolute best or “potential-maximizing” education for the individual child. See also, Seattle School District v. B.S., 24 IDELR 68 (9th Cir. 1996); Union School District v. Smith 15 F.3d 1519 (9th Cir. 1994).

As part of an appropriate education, the child is also entitled to related services. Pursuant to federal law, the term “related services” includes transportation and other developmental, corrective and supportive services which may be required to assist a child with a disability to benefit from special education. 20 U.S.C. §1401(22). California Education Code §56363 similarly provides that designated instruction and services (DIS), California’s term for related services, shall be provided “when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally from his or her instructional program.” Included in the list of related services are speech and language, orientation and mobility, physical and occupational therapy, counseling, health and nursing services, social worker services, adapted physical education and psychological services. Additional services may include behavioral intervention services and case management.

Special education law also requires that a student must be educated in the least restrictive environment (LRE), and that removal of a child with disabilities from the regular education environment can occur only when the nature and severity of the disability are such that education in regular classes, with the use of supplementary aids and services, cannot be achieved satisfactorily. 20 U.S.C. §1412(a)(5)(A); Education Code §56031.

Pursuant to the above law, a district has complied with its statutory obligations to offer an appropriate education pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA), and the interpreting case law, when its offer of placement and services: (1) identifies and addresses the student’s unique needs, (2) affords the student some educational benefit, (3) conforms to the IEP, and (4) occurs in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq. The Hearing Officer will discuss these issues when determining the appropriateness of the District’s placement offer. A. Procedural Violations

The United States Supreme Court has held that “Congress placed every bit as much emphasis upon compliance with procedures giving parents and guardians a large measure of participation at every stage of the administrative process, as it did upon the measurement of the resulting IEP against a substantive standard.” Board of Education of Hendrick Hudson Central School District v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 175 (1982). Federal special education law requires states to establish and maintain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which he or she is entitled and that parents are involved in the formulation of their child’s educational program. Procedural defects do not automatically result in a finding of a denial of a FAPE, but procedural violations that result in a “loss of educational opportunity,” or that “seriously infringes on the parents’ opportunity to participate in the IEP formulation process clearly result in the denial of a FAPE.” W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23, F.2d 1479 (9th Cir. 1992); Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, 910 F.2d 983 (1st Cir. 1990). The procedural rights that extend to parents include the right to be informed in writing when the educational agency proposes to initiate or change the identification, evaluation, or educational placement of the child; the right to participate in the development of the child’s IEP; the right to examine all relevant educational records; and the opportunity for mediation and a due process hearing. 20 U.S.C. §1415(b).

Assistive Technology Assessment

The Petitioner claims that the District violated his procedural rights and thereby deprived him of a FAPE by failing to conduct an assistive technology assessment and convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results of that assessment in a timely manner. California Education Code §56344 states in relevant part, “An individual education program required as a result of an assessment of a pupil shall be developed within a total time not to exceed 50 days . . . from the date of receipt of the parent’s written consent for assessment . . .” California Code of Regulations, Title 2 §60010(c) defines an assessment as “an individual evaluation of a pupil in all areas of suspected disability in accordance with Sections 56320 through 56329 of the Education Code [supra] and Sections 300.530 through 300.534 of Title 34 of the Code of Federal Regulations.”

An assistive technology assessment was conducted by Adaptive Technology Assessment Center (hereinafter ATAC) at the District’s request on April 22, 1999. ATAC was asked to determine ways in which assistive technology might increase STUDENT’s access to the school curriculum. Handwriting was laborious for STUDENT. Consequently, the assessment focused on potential word processing equipment. Software to enhance his math and spelling abilities was also evaluated. The assessors found that STUDENT’s handwriting was legible and stated that he should continue to be provided with opportunities to practice this functional skill. It was also determined that he could write faster than he could type on the keyboard. The ATAC assessors viewed STUDENT’s attitude toward word processing as apathetic and reported that he expressed a preference for handwriting to keyboarding.

It was suggested by the ATAC that STUDENT use paper and pencil methods when his assignments required short answers, and have the computer available for longer written work. The assessors recommended that STUDENT be provided with a portable word processor, such as the AlphaSmart, and access to software such as “Write Outloud.” Write Outloud is a word processing program with a spell checker capable of discerning phonetic misspellings common to students with learning disabilities. It then “speaks” the word choices aloud so that the user can hear the words suggested. Interactive “text-to-speech” math and spelling programs held STUDENT’s attention and were also proposed for his use. The assessors cautioned that assistive technology should be used judiciously with STUDENT in a manner that augmented and facilitated typical learning experiences, but did not distract from them.

The District provided STUDENT with access to an AlphaSmart, a computer, and the recommended software programs. The Petitioner maintains that this was inadequate technological assistance. At the IEP meeting of August 22, 1999, MOTHER stated that it was easier for STUDENT to produce his work orally and she requested a voice activated computer program for him. The team agreed to seek ATAC’s input on the appropriateness of such a program for STUDENT.

Pursuant to a later assessment plan, a technology reassessment was conducted by ATAC on April 11, 2000. The assessors noted that STUDENT’s keyboarding speed had increased and was equal to his handwriting speed. The recommendations remained for him to use an AlphaSmart, have access to a computer as needed, and use a text-to-speech spell check. For the stated purpose of providing the IEP team with full information regarding available technology for STUDENT, the ATAC team discussed both the benefits and the drawbacks of providing him with a portable computer. The assessors specifically stated, however, that they were not recommending a portable computer for STUDENT’s use. In response to MOTHER’s request for voice-activated software, the ATAC team explained the difficulties with such programs and provided her and STUDENT with a demonstration of a speech-recognition program during the technology evaluation. Following the demonstration, both STUDENT and his mother agreed that this type of software would not be appropriate as it would not increase his writing speed.

The Petitioner contends that his mother’s request at the August 1999 IEP meeting for voice-activated software triggered an obligation by the District to conduct another technology assessment. Hence, the District violated the statutory time lines by failing to conduct the assessment until April 2000. Petitioner also contends that the District then further disregarded its obligation to convene an IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assessment. The District responds that it received the parents’ signed authorization to conduct a second technology assessment on February 29, 2000, and that the April 11, 2000 assessment was completed within the statutory fifty-day time frame. The District acknowledges that it did not convene a timely IEP meeting to discuss the results of the evaluation. The second technology assessment was not addressed until the IEP meeting of August 2000. However, the District maintains that the second technology assessment recommended the same services STUDENT was already receiving, so he suffered no educational prejudice from the delayed IEP meeting.

The transcript of the August 22, 1999 IEP meeting establishes that a duty to reassess was not created and that there was no agreement between the parties to conduct another formal technology assessment. MOTHER states, “I would like to request something with voice activated.” A District team member then says, “I think we should go ahead and recontact the Institute, attach what we’ve done and let them - they are the specialists, let them determine if a speech-activated program will benefit him.” Another District team member states, “Okay, let me make a note of that.” The team members then moved on to a discussion of STUDENT’s goals and objectives.

It is apparent that the IEP team agreed to contact ATAC for input on the usefulness of voice-activated software for STUDENT. However, no assessment plan was prepared by the District or signed by the parents to institute a new, formal technology assessment. The IEP team did not intend to seek a new evaluation of STUDENT’s need for technological support. Rather, the conversation suggests a decision to ask for an informal opinion from evaluators who were familiar with STUDENT’s technoloy needs regarding a single issue – the effectiveness of a voice-activated computer program. Directing a specific question to an evaluator who has previously assessed the student is not the equivalent of a formal assessment, and it does not trigger the statutory time lines.

The District did prepare an assessment plan for a second technology evaluation several months after the August 1999 IEP meeting. STUDENT’s parents returned this executed consent to assess on February 29, 2000, and the assessment was conducted on April 11, 2000. Thus, the assessment was completed within the statutory fifty-day time requirement, but the District did not formally review the results until an IEP meeting held in August 2000.

The failure to hold an IEP meeting following the technology assessment was a violation of STUDENT’s procedural rights. However, the existence of a procedural defect does not automatically constitute a denial of a FAPE. The statutory violation must result in deprivation of educational opportunity or substantially interfere with a parent’s participation in their child’s education. W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District No. 23; Roland M. v. Concord School Committee, (supra).

Although the delayed post-assessment IEP meeting slowed MOTHER’s access to the written report resulting from the technology assessment, it did not prevent her involvement with STUDENT’s education in this area. MOTHER was present during the evaluation and she discussed her questions concerning voice-activated software with the assessors. She and STUDENT were also provided with a demonstration of the capabilities of voice-activated technology. Following the presentation, MOTHER agreed that the voice programs were inappropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs. The delayed IEP meeting, therefore, did not infringe on her right to participate in the development of STUDENT’s assistive technology program. MOTHER already knew and concurred with the recommendations contained in the second assistive technology report. Furthermore, the services recommended in the second technology report remained the same as those suggested in the first report. STUDENT was already receiving these services. Because no new services were recommended, STUDENT was not deprived of any educational opportunities as a result of the failure to hold an IEP meeting. Even had an IEP meeting been convened, there were no additional technology services to be implemented. Therefore, the procedural violations did not rise to the level of the loss of a FAPE. Occupational Therapy Sessions

The Petitioner claims that he was denied a FAPE because he did not receive the OT services specified in the IEP document dated August 20, 1999, nor was he provided with the compensatory OT sessions ordered in the decision rendered in case number SN 1268-98. Both sides presented testimony concerning the unsuccessful efforts to locate a service provider and arrange an OT schedule. The Petitioner’s mother testified that the District delayed in seeking a nonpublic OT provider and then did not follow through to finalize arrangements when potential occupational therapists were located. She further maintains that when the District ultimately obtained OT for STUDENT, it was not compatible with the Petitioner’s schedule. The District provided testimony that it had arranged both morning and afternoon OT appointments for STUDENT with private occupational therapists in the area. However, because STUDENT commuted an hour each way to his private school, neither the OT location nor appointment time was acceptable to MOTHER. The appointments were in conflict with his school and transportation schedule.

After a careful evaluation, the Hearing Officer has discerned that the OT services the parties were attempting to arrange were those owed STUDENT as compensatory sessions pursuant to the Hearing Officer’s order in case number SN 1268-98. Enforcement of a prior order is not within the province of SEHO pursuant to Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District, (supra). Therefore, the allegation that the District did not comply with a prior order to provide compensatory OT services will not be addressed in this decision. The Hearing Officer will consider the Petitioner’s contention that the District was obligated to provide the OT services contained in the August 1999 IEP in the analysis below concerning the substantive appropriateness of the District’s offer of placement and services.

In sum, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s failure to convene a timely IEP meeting to discuss the results of the assistive technology assessment did not rise to the level of a procedural denial of a FAPE. She also concludes that the enforcement of a prior order is not a proper issue for a due process hearing.

B. Substantive Appropriateness

The Hearing Officer will now turn to the Petitioner’s assertion that he was denied a substantive FAPE. To do this, the Hearing Officer will analyze whether the District deprived STUDENTof an appropriate education that was designed to meet his unique needs, provide him with some educational benefit, conform to his individual education program, and serve him in the least restrictive environment. Rowley, supra; 20 U.S.C. §1400 et seq.

Did the District identify and address STUDENT’s unique needs?

1. Identification of STUDENT’s Unique Needs

To determine whether the District’s August 1999 offer of placement and services addressed STUDENT’s needs, it is first necessary to identify his unique needs during that time. During the prior hearing in case number SN 1268-98, some evidence was presented concerning STUDENT’s needs as he entered seventh grade. To avoid redundancy, the parties stipulated to the incorporation of that evidence into this hearing. When referring to testimony from the prior hearing, the Hearing Officer will identify it as such and summarize pertinent parts.

STUDENT’s mother, MOTHER, has a B.A. in child development, a K-12 multiple subject teaching credential, and she is currently working on a special education credential. It was MOTHER’s opinion that her son required a specific program for reading remediation, as well as increased math assistance. She also testified that STUDENT’s handwriting production remained difficult and continued to be illegible. Thus, he needed OT to increase his writing ability. According to MOTHER, classroom modifications should include assistive technology and classroom assistance to accommodate STUDENT’s reading and writing deficits. MOTHER stated that STUDENT had high intellectual abilities and verbal skills. Consequently, he needed the stimulation and challenge of a general education curriculum. However, as a result of his learning disability, STUDENT felt different from his regular education peers and suffered from low self-esteem. At the same time, he was incompatible with many of the students in an SDC placement. MOTHER reported that STUDENT was uncomfortable with the behaviors and decreased abilities of most of the SDC students. She also conveyed STUDENT’s embarrassment at being seen in an SDC by his general education peers, and his perception that he was being stigmatized by such a placement.

Sasha Borenstein, Ph.D., is the director of The Kelter Center, a nonpublic agency that provides academic remediation. Dr. Borenstein had previously assessed STUDENT at the request of the District and provided her opinions regarding his educational needs at the first hearing. During the prior hearing, Dr. Borenstein testified that STUDENT lacked phonemic awareness and could not decode words. He was unable to discriminate when sounds changed, and he could not map sounds and letters. STUDENT could only “read” words he had memorized. To overcome STUDENT’s reading difficulties, Dr. Borenstein recommended a systematic, sequential reading program that first taught phonemic awareness, sound/symbol correspondence, phonics, and sight words. Once these skills were mastered, he would need to increase his reading fluency. STUDENT’s writing deficiencies also required a systematic instructional approach that taught writing skills in the following order: organization of ideas, sentence structure, drafting paragraphs, and essays.

At the present hearing, Dr. Borenstein reiterated her opinion that STUDENT required reading goals that focused on syllabication, fluency, spelling patterns, manipulating sounds, and phonetically irregular words. She stated that to achieve these skills, he must be taught syllable types beginning with single syllables, then moving to combining two, then more syllables, until he could decipher words at a multi-syllable level. Dr. Borenstein further testified that reading requires more than learning to decode. It is also necessary to increase vocabulary, comprehension and fluency. Dr. Borenstein stated that STUDENT needs to improve these skills. She explained that a student can learn sounds and grammar rules, but if he or she is not also taught to fluently use and integrate these sounds and rules, reading can never occur.

Dr. Borenstein testified that spelling is learned systematically. Therefore, STUDENT must be taught to spell in a very sequential manner that consists of acquiring the following skills in the following order: (1) short vowels and closed syllables, (2) spelling rules such as vowel rules and ending sounds, (3) syllable types, and (4) Latin and Greek prefixes and suffixes in English language words. Once these exceptions are mastered, the remaining 86% of the English language is phonetically regular and does not require memorization for the student to spell correctly. In addition to spelling, STUDENT’s program should address his written expression, capitalization, and punctuation deficits. Dr. Borenstein testified that STUDENT needs intense remediation. Because he is an older student, the gaps between his actual skill levels and grade-appropriate abilities are very great. Consequently, STUDENT requires daily remediation and daily reinforcement of the skills being taught. Dr. Borenstein believes that a systematic program consistent with the Lindamood-Bell Learning Process program (hereinafter Lindamood-Bell), is necessary to meet STUDENT’s needs for remediation.

In addition to the remediation program described above, Dr. Borenstein addressed STUDENT’s need for accommodations to help him overcome his disability and to provide him with a mechanism for expressing his knowledge. She explained that assistive technology is such an accommodation. Cognitively, STUDENT understands grade-level material. However, because he cannot read or write well on his own, he is unable to acquire or express his knowledge in the usual ways. For example, he cannot read the material by himself, then express his understanding of it through the handwritten word. He therefore requires appropriate accommodations to circumvent these disabilities. Materials presented orally through audio tapes, or someone reading to him, are methods that would accommodate his decreased reading ability. Dr. Borenstein also suggested a voice-activated computer program and allowing him to provide oral answers to exam questions, as ways to overcome STUDENT’s difficulties with the written word.

The Petitioner retained Nita Ferjo, an educational psychologist, to provide expert testimony regarding STUDENT’s educational needs and an appropriate program. Dr. Ferjo stated that STUDENT is learning disabled with substantial delays in reading and writing. His disabilities impact all of his academic subjects. She determined that he has specific deficits in the areas of visual integration and motor production. These make it very hard for STUDENT to transfer the information from his head, through his hand, to paper. In Dr. Ferjo’s opinion, STUDENT has “great verbal ideas,” but his handwriting “looks like chicken scratch.” He also has very poor spelling. Dr. Ferjo rendered her belief that when a student reaches STUDENT’s age, remediation is no longer possible. The focus must instead be directed toward accommodations and modifications. Given the degree of STUDENT’s disability, she would expect slow but steady progress if STUDENT was provided with appropriate accommodations. Dr. Ferjo further testified that STUDENT requires the “special environment” of an NPS to provide for his academic and emotional needs. Although she did not have “serious concerns” about STUDENT’s emotional condition, and she did not believe that he required therapy, she found him to be “emotionally fragile” and presently unequipped to handle public middle school. He therefore required the more restrictive environment of an NPS.

Bina Varughese is the coordinator of educational services at Summit View, STUDENT’s NPS, and she developed his educational profile. A profile is Summit View’s equivalent of an IEP document. Ms. Varughese determined that STUDENT required instruction in reading strategies and “breaking-down multi-syllable words, including prefixes and suffixes.” He also needed to improve his written expression, which was extremely poor. STUDENT understood math concepts, but as a result of his memory difficulties, he sometimes forgot his calculation facts. Ms. Varughese testified that to respond to STUDENT’s academic delays, he should have remediation incorporated into his daily school program.

Ms. Varughese also expressed her opinion that STUDENT required multiple accommodations and modifications at school. These included a calculator to assist with math, an AlphaSmart word processor for note-taking, and access to his teachers’ notes. She found that STUDENT had very good ideas, but he was unable to adequately express them. The availability of a computer with writing assistance tools such as spell check, would help him convey his thoughts in written form. Ms. Varughese stated that STUDENT’s teacher should preview his reading materials with him and identify and define unknown vocabulary words. STUDENT’s tasks should be broken into small segments. Testing accommodations should consist of providing STUDENT with pretest study guides and open book tests, and allowing him to respond orally to test questions that are read to him. Study skill techniques also need to be addressed with STUDENT. He should be taught organization, test-taking strategies, and how to read to locate important information.

The District had conducted a multidisciplinary psychoeducational evaluation of STUDENT in July 1998. During the prior hearing, the District provided the testimony of school psychologist Barbara Starr to describe STUDENT’s needs as she had identified them in her portion of the psychoeducational evaluation. Ms. Starr found that STUDENT continued to show a discrepancy between his ability and performance scores. He also displayed specific weaknesses in decoding skills and graphic-motor functioning. Mary Ann Lowry was the resource specialist (RSP) teacher who conducted the academic testing for the assessment. She testified at the prior hearing that STUDENT’s reading and math scores were equivalent to those of a third-grade student. His writing abilities were consistent with a child in the ninth month of first grade. STUDENT’s receptive and expressive language was average to above average when only auditory information was presented. However, his skills declined dramatically when he was asked to decipher written or visual symbols. The District witnesses concluded that STUDENT required weekly OT, as well as small-group instruction for intensive remediation in phonemic awareness, sound/symbol relationships, phonics, and written language.

Based upon the information presented at both hearings, the Hearing Officer finds that at the time of the August 1999 IEP meeting, STUDENT had unique needs in the areas of visual processing and motor skills. He had specific difficulties with phonetic analysis, graphic expression, and math. STUDENT lacked phonemic awareness and he could not decode words. He was unable to discriminate sound changes within words, and he could not coordinate letters with their sounds. As a result of STUDENT’s inability to decipher words, he could not acquire knowledge through independent reading. STUDENT could not spell because he was unable to recognize sound/symbol relationships and he did not know language rules. Spelling problems combined with difficulties with handwriting production caused severe delays in STUDENT’s written language skills. STUDENT’s problems with reading and writing also impacted his math performance. The Hearing Officer was not particularly influenced by Dr. Ferjo’s testimony. She was hired specifically to render an opinion at the hearing that STUDENT required an NPS. Her testimony that STUDENT was too “emotionally fragile” to attend public school, yet did not require therapy, is incongruent. In the prior decision, the Hearing Officer noted an undercurrent of concern about STUDENT’s emotional well-being that had been identified by the District. Several times the District offered a county mental health referral and the services of a school counselor. These services should remain available in the event the IEP team determines that STUDENT requires mental health intervention.

2. Addressing STUDENT’s Needs

The Petitioner argues that he was deprived of a FAPE because the goals and objectives drafted by the District were inadequate to meet his needs. The annual goals proposed by the District were to (1) bring appropriate materials to class; (2) independently correct capitalization and punctuation on a prewritten daily oral language assignment; (3) identify, compare, and order equivalent fractions, decimals, and percentages; (4) type twenty-five words within five minutes with less than three mistakes; (5) print legibly four out of five times with one prompt; (6) read a list of one hundred words taken from seventh grade texts that contain the forty-eight most regular sound-letter relationships; and (7) orally spell a list of seventh grade words that contain the most regular sound-letter relationships.

California Education Code §56345(a)(2)(A)(B) states:

The individualized education program is a written statement determined in a meeting of the individualized education program team and shall include, . . . (2) The measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives related to the following:

(A) Meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum.

(B) Meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupil’s disability.

In the case of Bend-Lapine School District v. D.W., 152 F.3d 923 (9th Cir. 1998), the court found that IEP goals must be drafted to provide meaningful educational benefit to the particular child.

MOTHER believed that the goals suggested by the District were inadequate because they did not describe the methods that would be used to teach STUDENT to accomplish his goals. They set forth what he was supposed to learn, but did not describe how he would learn the specified task. Rhea Allen George, the RSP teacher who would have taught STUDENT’s seventh-grade math class had he attended the District’s middle school, testified that the math goal contained in his proposed IEP did not provide her with any information regarding his current level of performance in math. She could not have started working with STUDENT based on the math goal as written.

Dr. Borenstein testified that the writing goal to correctly capitalize and punctuate was “icing on the cake.” It did not address STUDENT’s underlying writing deficit, an inability to spell and form sentences. In reading, STUDENT was still learning single-letter sounds. Dr. Borenstein also said that it was unrealistic to write a goal that expected him to move from isolated sounds to reading a list of seventh-grade words in one year. STUDENT required reading goals that followed a systematic approach to teach sound/symbol relationships, spelling patterns, fluency, phonetically irregular words, and syllabication beginning with one and increasing to multi-syllable words. According to Dr. Borenstein, if STUDENT is to read, he must learn to integrate the sounds and rules, as well as develop fluency. Learning a list of words will not teach him the mechanisms of reading, nor will it increase his vocabulary or comprehension. Dr. Borenstein also testified that the goal to spell from a list of words failed to teach the sequential spelling method necessary for STUDENT to learn to spell.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded by the above testimony and finds that the goals drafted and proposed by the District were not designed to meet his needs. STUDENT needed to learn the fundamental concepts that would enable him to read, write, and spell. It is more likely that “reading” and “spelling” the same list of words, as proposed in the District’s goals, would merely result in memorization of those words; it would not teach basic principles of reading and spelling such as sound/symbol relationships, phonics, or decoding skills.

To meet STUDENT’s need for remediation during the 1999-2000 school year, the District offered one-to-one reading instruction using Lindamood-Bell for two one-hour sessions per week in the special education classroom. In January 2000, the hourly sessions would increase to three to four times each week and continue at that level through the end of the school year. STUDENT was to attend regular education classes for science, physical education, and an elective. Math, language arts, and social studies were to be provided in an SDC. STUDENT was also offered two thirty-minute sessions of direct service OT per week, with a weekly OT/teacher consultation, and ESY services.

The remediation methodology offered by the District to respond to STUDENT’s problems was the Lindamood-Bell program. Dr. Borenstein also recommended Lindamood-Bell as an appropriate remediation program to address STUDENT’s need to start with the basics of sound/letter correspondence in learning to read. In both hearings, Dr. Borenstein impressed the Hearing Officer as a credible, unbiased, and knowledgeable witness. It was apparent that both the Petitioner and the Respondent also sought and respected her opinion; she was chosen by the District to conduct an independent evaluation of STUDENT’s needs and the Petitioner called her to testify regarding his educational needs. The District and Dr. Borenstein both recommend Lindamood-Bell as an appropriate remediation methodology for STUDENT. The Hearing Officer is therefore persuaded that the type of remediation program offered by the District was appropriate to meet STUDENT’s needs.

While the type of remediation the District offered was appropriate, the Hearing Officer finds that the amount of remediation therapy the District offered during the first semester was inadequate to meet his needs. STUDENT is a middle school student with the reading and writing skills of an early elementary school student. He has not mastered the rudimentary prereading knowledge of letter/sound relationships. Therefore, STUDENT must be taught to match sounds to letters. According to testimony presented at the hearing by Dr. Ferjo, time is running out for STUDENT and soon remediation may not be possible. Despite its understanding of the severity of STUDENT’s reading delay, the District’s offer for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year was two hours per week of Lindamood-Bell remediation.

The insufficiency of two hours per week of Lindamood-Bell remediation was further evidenced by the fact that the District offered to increase the Lindamood-Bell therapy to three to four hours per week during the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year. At the August 1999 IEP meeting, which was taped, transcribed, and admitted as an exhibit at the hearing, District personnel maintained that it was beneficial for students to start gradually with Lindamood-Bell, then later increase the therapy as the student demonstrated an understanding of the concepts presented. However, immediately thereafter, District personnel also stated that the staff would be fully trained in each of the Lindamood-Bell components and prepared to provide them by the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year. It is illogical that the educational needs of a seventh-grade student, who cannot read, would be better addressed by beginning his program with less remediation. It is more probable that the second stated reason, a lack of trained personnel, is the more valid explanation for the District’s offer of fewer sessions during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer is not persuaded by the District’s explanation for offering STUDENT a lesser amount of therapy during the first semester, and views the proposed increase during the second semester as a tacit admission that the initial two hours each week was insufficient.

The modifications and accommodations offered by the District did adequately address STUDENT’s above-described needs. The District offered preferential seating, reduced paper-pencil tasks, materials on tape, copies of class notes, access to a computer with spell check, alternate testing methods, extended time, modified grading, study sheets, oral exams, assignment notebook, use of an AlphaSmart word processor, books on tape, taped lectures, and special education aide support in the general education science class. These modifications and accommodations appropriately responded to STUDENT’s disability.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the District identified STUDENT’s unique needs, offered adequate accommodations and modifications to his educational program, and suggested an appropriate remedial methodology to address his needs. The District did not, however, propose goals and objectives designed to meet STUDENT’s needs. More important, it did not offer an adequate quantity of Lindamood-Bell remedial therapy to meet his needs during the first semester of the 1999-2000.

Did the District’s placement provide STUDENTwith educational benefit?

STUDENT enrolled in a nonpublic school and did not attend the program offered by the District. In such a situation, the appropriate question is not whether the District’s program provided educational benefit, but whether the offer of placement and services at the time it was made was designed to convey educational benefit. As stated in the case of Adams v. State of Oregon, 195 F.3d 1141 (9th Cir. 1999), “Instead of asking whether the [IEP](Footnote 3) was adequate in light of [student’s] progress, the district court should have asked the more pertinent question of whether the [IEP] was appropriately designed and implemented so as to convey [student] with a meaningful benefit. We do not judge an [IEP] in hindsight; rather, we look to the [IEP’s] goals and goal achieving methods at the time the plan was implemented and ask whether these methods were reasonably calculated to confer [student] with a meaningful benefit . . . Actions of the school system cannot be judged exclusively in hindsight. An individualized education program (‘IEP’) is a snapshot, not a retrospective. In striving for ‘appropriateness’ an IEP must take into account what was, and was not, objectively reasonable when the snapshot was taken, that is, at the time the IEP was drafted.”

The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District correctly identified STUDENT’s need for an intensive remediation program, curriculum modifications and accommodations. It did not, however, offer STUDENT an adequate amount of remediation or draft goals and objectives designed to confer meaningful benefit. As a result, the District’s offer of placement and services was not reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit.

Did the District’s services conform to STUDENT’s IEP?

The Petitioner contends that the District failed to provide the OT services offered at the IEP meeting of August 20, 1999. At that time, the District offered STUDENT two thirty-minute sessions of direct OT per week, as well as a fifteen to-twenty minute OT/teacher consultation one time a week. STUDENT’s parents did not authorize the provision of any of the services offered by the District in this IEP. Instead, on August 26, 1999, they advised the District that they were unilaterally placing STUDENT in an NPS as a result of their determination that the District’s offer did not constitute a FAPE. On December 29, 1999, MOTHER wrote a letter to the District stating that pursuant to STUDENT’s August 1999 IEP, he was to receive weekly OT. MOTHER misunderstands a district’s obligation to provide services in this situation.

A district cannot impose services upon a student that have not been authorized by the parents. California Education Code §56346(a). So that a student may benefit from those portions of an IEP that are agreed upon by the parties, parents may choose to accept some elements of a district’s offer, while rejecting others. California Education Code §56346(a). Here, Mr. & Mrs. PARENT refused to agree to any portion of the District’s proposed IEP. Thus, the District had no authority to provide occupational therapy to STUDENT during the 1999-2000 school year.

Mr. and Mrs. PARENT never accepted the District’s August 1999 offer for OT. Consequently, the District was not authorized to provide STUDENT with such services. It would be illogical to determine that a parent may refuse to allow a school district to service their child, then claim that the district’s failure to provide the unauthorized service caused the student to be deprived of a FAPE. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the District failure to provide the OT services described in the August 1999 IEP did not deprive STUDENT of a FAPE. (Footnote 4)

Was STUDENT’s placement in the least restrictive environment?

Neither party contends that the District’s offer did not fulfill the legal requirement relating to a least restrictive environment.

After considering the evidence presented, it is the determination of the Hearing Officer that the District offered inadequate remediation during the first half of the 1999-2000 school year. STUDENT’s primary need was to learn to read and write. The District’s failure to offer a program that fully addressed these needs denied him a FAPE during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. In the August 1999 IEP, the District did offer STUDENT appropriate accommodations and modifications, and it identified a methodology for remediation that responded to STUDENT’s needs. Although daily remediation therapy would be optimal, the District’s offer to increase STUDENT’s Lindamood-Bell therapy to three to four times per week during the second semester adequately satisfied the District’s duty to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. During the second semester, the District also could have provided fully trained staff to implement the Lindamood-Bell program. In addition to direct Lindamood-Bell remediation, STUDENT was also offered a daily SDC language arts class that would have provided supplemental remediation in reading, writing, and spelling. Sharon Lee, the teacher of the SDC class that STUDENT would have attended, testified that she provides a daily, sequential writing program that addresses spelling, punctuation, and grammar. Each of her students also works with a sequential computer program for grammar every day for fifteen minutes. Ms. Lee stated that she specifically teaches the handwriting skills of printing, cursive, and spacing. She uses the SRA reading program with her class each day. The SRA provides sequential instruction beginning with letter sounds, then blending sounds, short vowels, long vowels, single and multi-syllable sounds, short sentences, short paragraphs, etc. Weekly spelling words are assigned that correspond with the reading program.

The Hearing Officer therefore determines that the District’s offer for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year provided sufficient remediation to constitute a FAPE. The District’s proposed goals did not specifically set forth the systematic methods by which STUDENT would be taught to read, spell, and write. However, this defect could have been corrected by the IEP team, and by itself, did not rise to the level of a denial of a FAPE. Bend-Lapine School District v. D.W.; Board of Education of Montogomery County v. Brett Y.; Burke County Board of Education v. Denton; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School District, (supra).

ISSUE NUMBER TWO

If the District denied STUDENT a FAPE for the 1999-2000 school year is he entitled to reimbursement of tuition and related costs of his unilateral placement in a nonpublic school?

The Hearing Officer has found that the District’s offer of placement and services was inappropriate for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. Thus, it is necessary to determine whether the District must reimburse Mr. and Mrs. PARENT for the tuition and transportation costs of Summit View School. Parents may be entitled to reimbursement for the costs of placement or services they have procured for their child when the school district has failed to offer a FAPE. However, to receive reimbursement, the parents must establish that the services they obtained were appropriate under the IDEA and that they were reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education, 471 U.S. 359 (1985); Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir. 1994). When considering the appropriateness of parents’ placement of their child for purposes of reimbursement, parents are not required to obtain the best possible private placement to be entitled to reimbursement. Their choice must be designed to meet the student’s unique needs and to provide some educational benefit. Alamo Heights Independent School District v. State Board of Education, 790 F.2d 1153 (5th Cir. 1986); Florence County School District Four v. Carter, 510 U.S. 7 (1993).Mr. and Mrs. PARENT enrolled STUDENT in Summit View for the entire 1999-2000 school year. Nancy Rosenfelt, the director of Summit View, testified that it is a private school established in 1995, which exclusively services students with learning disabilities. All of the school’s 213 students possess average to above-average intelligence, but exhibit significantly decreased performance abilities as a result of learning disabilities, not emotional disturbances. Each class contains twelve students and one teacher. Summit View uses a multi-sensory teaching method. It provides a curriculum approved by the state of California, which it modifies by breaking curriculum into smaller segments and by providing easier reading materials, worksheets, and manipulatives. STUDENT uses an AlphaSmart to take notes, and has access to teacher-provided class notes. Three times a week, he has a computer lab and can produce his work on a computer with spell check. Some form of remediation is taught during each of STUDENT’s four core classes. He also is taught study skill techniques and his tests are modified. MOTHER, Ms. Rosenfelt, and Ms. Varughese all testified that Summit View was meeting STUDENT’s needs and that he was making academic, emotional, and social progress.

The District claimed that Summit View was too restrictive because it admittedly has no nondisabled students. The District’s witnesses also testified that the testing conducted at the NPS did not show academic gains during STUDENT’s year of attendance. Dr. Borenstein concurred that Woodcock-Johnson (WJ) tests given by Summit View in February and July 2000 showed essentially the same standard scores on the subtests of both test administrations, which did not evidence objective academic growth. Dr. Borenstein also testified that with appropriate remediation, she would have expected at least a ten-point increase in standard scores between the first and the second WJ tests. However, Dr. Borenstein also noted that a comparison of STUDENT’s actual written work from February to July 2000 showed improved writing and spelling skills.

When analyzing the NPS placement for purposes of reimbursement, the Hearing Officer considers the same question that was posed concerning the District’s placement offer -- When the decision was made by the parents to enroll STUDENT in Summit View, was it reasonably calculated to meet his needs? School Committee of the Town of Burlington v. Department of Education; Student W. v. Puyallup School District, 31 F.3d 1489 (9th Cir.1994). This requires consideration of the information available at the time the placement was made, not a determination made in hindsight with knowledge of the results. Adams v. State of Oregon, (supra).

The Hearing Officer too has concerns about the absence of integration with nondisabled peers at Summit View. Although STUDENT has significant difficulties with reading and writing, he is very bright, exceptionally verbal, and he needs the intellectual, emotional and social stimulation of normal peer interaction. Interaction with typically developing peers is not available at Summit View. Additionally, no evidence was presented that Summit View provided STUDENT with a systematic, sequential program specifically designed to address his need for remedial reading and writing assistance. The testimony was that some remediation was incorporated into the classroom instruction in the core subjects. It was not provided individually, or in a small group, to meet STUDENT’s individual need for remediation. This may partially account for STUDENT’s failure to make the academic progress that would have been anticipated with appropriate remediation.

Regardless of questions that may have developed during STUDENT’s attendance at the NPS, the Hearing Officer focuses on the information available at the time his parents made the placement decision and finds it was reasonably calculated to meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him with educational benefit. When they chose the NPS, Mr. and Mrs. PARENT knew that although their son was entering the seventh grade, he could not read or write, and the District was not offering enough remediation to meet his needs. In an attempt to acquire the necessary educational services, they located a private school that catered to children with learning disabilities similar to those of their son’s. That school was certified by the state of California to provide special education services, and its staff represented to the parents that it had a successful program for students with STUDENT’s deficits. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT’s decision to place their son at Summit View was a reasonable attempt to meet his educational needs after the District failed to offer a FAPE. They are therefore entitled to reimbursement of the actual tuition cost and daily round-trip mileage (reimbursed at the District’s standard rate) that resulted from STUDENT’s attendance at Summit View for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year.

ISSUE NUMBER THREE

Is the Petitioner entitled to compensatory education consisting of intensive tutoring, assistive technology services, and OT?

Courts have consistently held that the authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. §1415(i)(2)(B)(iii), which authorizes a court to grant such “relief as it determines is appropriate.” “The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services.” Moubry v. Independent School District Number 696, 951 F. Supp. 867 (8th Cir.1996) Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews, 933 F.2d 1576 (11th Cir, 1991). There is, however, no obligation to compensate the child by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, part of the Court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief . . . Appropriate relief is relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of the IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Equitable considerations are therefore appropriate when fashioning compensatory remedies. An application of equitable principles requires that the actions of the parties themselves must be considered when evaluating the circumstances surrounding the child’s lost educational opportunity and in creating an adequate remedy. Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, (supra). Thus, when considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that issue is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.

The Petitioner seeks compensatory tutoring, technology and OT services as recompense for the District’s denial of a FAPE during the 1999-2000 school year. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the District’s failure to convene a timely IEP meeting to discuss the results of the second assistive technology assessment did not deprive STUDENT of educational opportunity. The recommendations resulting from the second evaluation were the same as those contained in the first assessment report. STUDENT was already being provided with the recommended technology. Since there were no new suggestions, the failure to hold an IEP meeting did not prevent STUDENT’s access to additional equipment, and he is not entitled to compensatory technology assistance.

It has been determined that the District’s failure to provide sufficient remedial tutoring sessions during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year deprived STUDENT of a FAPE. Mr. and Mrs. PARENT decided that an NPS placement was the appropriate response to the absence of these services, and they chose a school whose program was intended to provide what the District had not. The Petitioner is to be reimbursed for the costs of that NPS placement for the first semester. Thus, he is being compensated for the lack of adequate remedial tutoring, and he is not also entitled to compensatory education in the form of additional tutoring services.

Both parties have consistently agreed that STUDENT requires OT to address his fine motor difficulties. However, the parents did not authorize the District to provide OT services pursuant to the offer contained in the August 1999 IEP. The Hearing Officer has already determined that the parents may not refuse DIS services offered by the District, then later claim entitlement to such services. The Petitioner is therefore not entitled to compensatory OT sessions as he could have availed himself of this therapy by accepting the OT portion of the August 1999 IEP.

CONCLUSION

The evidence established that the Petitioner was denied a FAPE during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year as a result of the District’s failure to offer a sufficient amount of remedial Lindamood-Bell therapy and its lack of adequately trained staff to implement the program. Because STUDENT was not offered a FAPE, he is entitled to reimbursement for one semester of tuition and transportation costs arising from his attendance at an NPS. However, the Petitioner is not entitled to reimbursement for the costs associated with his NPS placement for the second semester of the 1999-2000 school year, nor is he to receive compensatory tutoring or assisted technology services.

ORDER

1. Within thirty calendar days of receipt of verifying documentation, the District shall reimburse the Petitioner for the tuition costs of Summit View School for the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. The District shall also reimburse the Petitioner for the round-trip milage from home to Summit View School at the District’s standard milage reimbursement rate for the same time period for the days actually attended.

2. All of the Petitioner’s other claims for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE

Pursuant to Education Code §56507(d), this decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following finding is made in accordance with this requirement: The Petitioner prevailed on the denial of a FAPE and NPS reimbursement during the first semester of the 1999-2000 school year. The District prevailed on all remaining issues.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this case have the right to appeal this decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is made, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this decision. Education Code §56505(i).

Dated: April 18, 2001 _________________________________________ GLENNA EUBANK deCAMARA, Hearing Officer, Special Education Hearing Office, University of the Pacific, McGeorge School of Law

Footnote 1: The Petitioner initially presented several issues. The separate issues of a failure to conduct a timely assessment and provide OT services were combined within the issue asserting a denial of a FAPE as allegations of procedural violations. The issue seeking enforcement of the Hearing Officer’s prior orders was removed as enforcement issues are not within the jurisdiction of SEHO per Wyner v. Manhattan Beach Unified School District, 223 F.3d 1026 (9th Cir. 2000).

Footnote 2: For congruity, the Hearing Officer reproduces the relevant portions of the background facts as set forth in case, SN 1268-98.

Footnote 3: The case of Adams v. State of Oregon, (supra), uses the term Individual Family Service Plan (IFSP) for what California terms an Individual Education Program (IEP). The Hearing Officer has changed IFSP to IEP to facilitate clarity. The Hearing Officer has also replaced the name of the child with “student.”

Footnote 4: Since the parents decided to make a unilateral NPS placement and assert a claim for reimbursement without consenting to any of the IEP provisions, the relevant issue is not whether the District’s failure to provide the OT proposed in an unaccepted IEP, by itself, constitutes a denial of a FAPE, but rather, whether STUDENThad a unique need for OT that was unaddressed as a result of a denial of a FAPE. OT services, therefore, are addressed below as part of the Petitioner’s claim for compensatory education.