California special education hearing decision (SEHO, before OAH) · February 20, 2003

Student v. Los Angeles Unified School District

SEHO Case No. SN 2249-01 · Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin

Los Angeles Unified must provide a year of added individual and group speech therapy after four years of inadequate services.

Split decision: student prevailed on 5 of 8 issues (4 in part)

This decision was issued by the California Special Education Hearing Office (SEHO) at McGeorge School of Law, which heard special education due process cases until the Office of Administrative Hearings took over new filings in July 2005 (SEHO finished some pending cases later in 2005). It applies the law in effect at the time.

Summary

A student with a specific learning disability and a speech and language disorder (articulation and fluency) brought this case against Los Angeles Unified School District. His family speaks Spanish at home. The case began as an occupational therapy (OT) claim and later grew to cover five school years, 1998-99 through 2002-03. Hearing Officer Michael B. Arkin found that the district-employed interpreters at IEP meetings were skilled enough and that the mother took part in the meetings. He found the district's assessments appropriate, so the district did not have to repay the family for private evaluations. He also found the district's speech therapy adequate for 1998-99. From 1999-2000 on, though, the district kept offering about 60 minutes a week of small-group speech therapy while the student made little progress in speech, reading and language arts. In 1999-2000 the district also missed 450 minutes of required therapy. Twice it failed to tell the mother about her son's extended school year (ESY) placement, so he missed ESY. The Hearing Officer found a denial of FAPE in speech and language for those four years. He upheld the special day class placement and the classroom-based OT. He ordered the IEP amended within 15 days to add three 40-minute individual and two 30-minute small-group speech sessions each week for at least 52 weeks. He also ordered a reassessment before those services are reduced and repayment of the transportation costs the district had agreed to cover.

Go to full decision

Why it matters

The decision shows how SEHO treated a district that correctly identified a student's needs but offered the same speech therapy year after year despite little progress. It also shows that appropriate district assessments defeated a claim for repayment of private evaluations, and that district-employed interpreters with sufficient skill met the interpreter requirement.

Issues and holdings

  1. District prevailedIEP procedure

    Issue 1. Did the District fail to provide a certified interpreter for Student's mother at IEP meetings in all years in issue and, if so, does that failure invalidate the IEP and deny Petitioner a FAPE?

    Education Code section 56341.5(h) requires interpreters with sufficient skill, not a specific certification or independence; district-employed Spanish-speaking interpreters were adequate, and the mother participated in every meeting.

  2. District prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2a. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE for academic year 1998-1999?

    The district assessed promptly once concerns were raised in fall 1998; the February 1999 IEP's 40-60 minutes of weekly small-group speech therapy was designed to meet needs and gave benefit; no ESY was needed and no auditory processing assessment was indicated.

  3. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2b. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE for academic year 1999-2000?

    FAPE denied: the district did not act on clear signs of need in fall 1999, kept the same small-group speech therapy with vague speech goals, missed 450 minutes of therapy, and failed to tell the mother of the ESY placement; its assessments (including methods and no apraxia screening) and RSP support were appropriate.

  4. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2c. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE for academic year 2000-2001?

    FAPE denied because speech and language therapy was not increased despite little progress, which also made the ESY inadequate; the SDC placement and classroom-based OT were appropriate, and the three-month Fast ForWord assessment delay caused no harm.

  5. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2d. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE for academic year 2001-2002?

    The January 2002 psychoeducational assessment was thorough and appropriate, and the SDC addressed academic needs, but the unchanged speech and language program (and the ESY based on it) was not reasonably calculated to provide benefit.

  6. Student prevailed in partFAPE: services offered

    Issue 2e. Did the District fail to provide Student a FAPE for academic year 2002-2003?

    FAPE denied: the June 2002 IEP again offered the same speech program despite no progress, and the district failed to tell the mother of the winter ESY space and transportation, so he missed ESY; assessments and SDC placement were appropriate.

  7. Student prevailedFAPE: services offered

    Issue 3. Should the District be ordered to provide compensatory education to Student and if so in what amount or amounts?

    Compensatory speech and language services ordered for 52 weeks (two hours individual and one hour small group weekly); compensatory OT denied because classroom-based OT was appropriate.

  8. Issue 4. Should the District be required to reimburse Petitioner for costs of private independent evaluations provided at the due process hearing?

    The district's assessments met Education Code section 56320 and correctly identified the student's needs; the dispute was over how the IEP team used them, so reimbursement for the private evaluations was denied.

What the Hearing Officer ordered

  • Order to convene IEP meeting. IEP team to convene within 15 calendar days to amend the June 12, 2002 IEP.
  • Compensatory education. Amended IEP to provide three weekly individual 40-minute sessions and two weekly 30-minute small-group sessions of speech and language therapy (fluency, articulation, auditory processing, receptive and expressive language) for no less than 52 weeks. Individual therapy to be given by a qualified, certified and licensed speech pathologist, continuously during calendar years 2003 and 2004, with breaks of no more than one week at holidays and intersessions.
  • Order to provide or change services. District to implement the June 12, 2002 IEP as amended.
  • Order to assess. IEP team to develop and carry out an assessment plan before reducing or ending the speech and language services, and to decide around the one-year anniversary of the ordered IEP meeting whether to continue, modify or end them.
  • Reimbursement. District to reimburse the mother for the cost of transporting the student to and from school, as the parties agreed, within 15 days after she submits receipts; no amount stated.

Total: 156 hours of compensatory services

Go to full decision

Key authorities

Board of Education v. Rowley; W.G. v. Board of Trustees of Target Range School Dist.; Gregory K. v. Longview School Dist.; Lenn v. Portland School Committee; Cleveland Heights-University Heights City School Dist. v. Boss; M.M. v. School Dist. of Greenville County; Cordrey v. Euckert; Todd v. Andrews; Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School Dist.; Lester H. v. Gilhool; Miener v. State of Missouri; Larry P. v. Riles; Student v. Rescue Union Elementary School Dist.

People named in the decision

  • Gloria Perez, service coordinator and support person for mother; witness for Student, Frank T. Lanterman Regional Center
  • Abby Rozenberg, private speech-language pathologist; expert witness for Student
  • Christine Davidson, Ph.D., psychologist; expert witness for Student
  • Deanna Caudillo, private occupational therapist; expert witness for Student
  • Carol Atkins, audiologist; witness for Student
  • Silvia De La Riva, bilingual school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Susan Glickman, due process specialist and speech pathologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Irene Filimonoff-Haney, special day class teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Judy Tinkess, special day class teacher, Tenth Street Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Margaret Orser (Orser-McGuire), occupational therapist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Jose Gonzales, Ph.D., District psychologist; expert witness for District on bilingual education
  • Victoria McKendall, District representative at hearing, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Agatha Meticheccia, District representative at hearing, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Shari Robertson, District representative at hearing, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Christine Maalouf, bilingual speech pathologist (assessor), Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Diana Sharp, RSP speech and language teacher / resource specialist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Shirley Ornstein, bilingual school psychologist, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Caroline Kwong, classroom teacher, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Ms. Raigoza, classroom teacher, Tenth Street Elementary School, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Diane Carpenter, RSP provider in general education class, Los Angeles Unified School District
  • Ms. Heller, mentioned as acknowledging fine motor needs; role not stated
  • Betty Berg, speech pathologist (2002 evaluation), White Memorial Hospital
  • Arnold E. Herrera, assessor (evaluation considered at March 2001 IEP)

Get new OAH special education decisions by email

A weekly Monday-morning digest of new California OAH due process decisions, each with a short plain-English summary from Vanaman German LLP.

You'll get an email asking you to confirm. Unsubscribe anytime. Subscribing does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Full text of the decision

Text of the SEHO decision as published by the California Department of Education, which replaced student and family names with placeholders such as STUDENT and MOTHER. Names, initials, birthdates, and addresses that were missed have also been removed, and page headers have been dropped.

This matter was heard on January 14, 21-24, 29 and 31 and February 7, 2003, in Los Angeles California, before Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer, California Special Education Hearing Office, McGeorge School of Law, University of the Pacific.(Footnote 1)

Petitioner STUDENT -- (STUDENT or Petitioner) was represented by Michael Jewell, Esq. of Roberts and Adams. His mother, MOTHER also appeared on his behalf.(Footnote 2) Ms. MOTHER was accompanied by Gloria Perez, a support person and service coordinator for the Frank T. Lanterman Regional Center. Los Angeles Unified School District (the District) was represented by Dominic J. Messiha, Esq. of Littler Mendelson. Victoria McKendall and Agatha Meticheccia appeared as District Representatives on January 14, 2003. Thereafter, Shari Robertson appeared for the District.

Petitioner called the following witnesses: Gloria Perez; Abby Rozenberg, speech pathologist; Christine Davidson, psychologist; Deanna Caudillo, occupational therapist; Carol Atkins, audiologist; and MOTHER. District witnesses included the following: Silvia De La Riva, school psychologist; Susan Glickman, due process specialist and speech pathologist; Irene Filimonoff-Haney, special day class teacher; Judy Tinkess, special day class teacher; Margaret Orser, occupational therapist; and Jose Gonzales, District psychologist. Oral testimony and documentary evidence were offered and received.(Footnote 3) The record remained open pending the receipt of written closing arguments. Upon receipt of the written closing arguments by the Hearing Officer, the last of which was received on February 20, 2003, the record was closed and the matter was submitted for decision.

ISSUES(Footnote 4)

1. Procedural Appropriateness of IEP Meetings (all years).

Did the District fail to provide a certified interpreter for STUDENT’s mother at IEP meetings in all years in issue and, if so, does that failure invalidate the IEP and deny Petitioner a FAPE?

2. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for each of the following academic years:

a. Academic Year 1998-1999;(Footnote 5)

b. Academic Year 1999-2000;

c. Academic Year 2000-2001;

d. Academic Year 2001-2002; and e. Academic Year 2002-2003 ?

3. Should the District be ordered to provide compensatory education to STUDENT and if so in what amount or amounts?

4. Should the District be required to reimburse Petitioner for costs of private independent evaluations provided at the due process hearing?

CONTENTIONS OF THE PARTIES

A. Petitioner’s Contentions.(Footnote 6)

Petitioner contended that the District failed to identify and assess STUDENT’s deficits in speech and language, fine and gross motor development and auditory processing, and failed to determine and provide for his unique needs in all years in issue.(Footnote 7) Petitioner asked for an award of compensatory education, for an order requiring that services be provided “as recommended by Petitioner’s experts” and for reimbursement for independent assessments. Petitioner also contended that STUDENT’s IEPs were invalid because the District failed to provide an independent and certified Spanish interpreter for Petitioner’s mother and that her right to participate in the educational process on behalf of her son was abridged.

B. Respondent’s Contentions.

The District contended that it identified and assessed STUDENT’s deficits in speech and language, fine and gross motor development and auditory processing and, further, that it did determine and provide for his unique needs in all years. Having done so, the District contended that it offered Petitioner a FAPE, and that no compensatory education or further services were necessary. The District contended that its evaluations were appropriate and that Petitioner should not be reimbursed for its independent evaluations. It also contended that it provided a Spanish interpreter at each IEP meeting in accordance with the law.

PROCEDURAL MATTERS

At the hearing, the District contended that Petitioner committed a procedural error in that he failed to timely designate the issues to be decided in advance of the hearing pursuant to California Education Code Section 56505(e)(6). Therefore, the District objected to the presentation of Petitioner’s evidence, contending that evidence should be limited to the issue of the District’s alleged failure to provide occupational therapy (O.T.) services to STUDENT, the sole issue designated at the time of the request for due process hearing. The objection was overruled by the Hearing Officer at the hearing. The District’s position was restated in closing argument.

Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing was received by the Special Education Hearing Office on October 16, 2001, designating OT as the only issue. The matter was taken off calendar by stipulation of the parties shortly thereafter. It was placed back on calendar at Petitioner’s request in response to a status inquiry initiated by the Hearing Office. The record reflects that Petitioner’s amended issue statement was received by the Hearing Office on January 3, 2003.

The first day of hearing commenced January 14, 2003, eleven days later. The California Education Code requires that notice of issues be provided ten days in advance of the hearing. Thus the issue statement was, in fact, timely. Notwithstanding, the Hearing Officer observed that a great deal of time had passed between the date of the original request and the commencement of the hearing. Thus, even though the expanded issue statement timely designated the issues, the first day of the hearing was devoted to a discussion of the expanded issues (as well as confidential settlement discussions between the parties). Moreover, testimony was not taken on that first day. At the close of the day on January 14, 2003, the Respondent asked for a brief continuance, stating that it required some time to arrange witness appearances but stating that it would be prepared to go forward the following week. The Hearing Officer granted Respondent’s request in recognition of the scope and breadth of the amended issues and in the spirit of fairness. The second day of hearing did not commence until January 21, 2003.

The Hearing Officer ruled at the hearing that the issues for hearing were not limited to those set forth in the original request for due process hearing. That ruling is affirmed. The issues upon which evidence was taken in this matter and which are considered and resolved in this Decision are those issues enumerated on page 2 of this Decision.

BACKGROUND FACTS

STUDENT -- is a nearly twelve-year-old student who resides within the boundaries of the District. He currently attends Berrendo Middle School (Berrendo) within the District. His eligibility for special education and related services is established under the categories specific learning disability (SLD), speech and language articulation and fluency disorder, and psychological processing disorder. His primary language is Spanish, the only language spoken in his home. He is presently placed in an English language special day class (SDC).

STUDENT’s relevant developmental and educational history is as follows: STUDENT was a premature child weighing five pounds one ounce at birth. Because of his birth weight and a difficult delivery, he was incubated for a period of eight days. At the age of one and one-half, STUDENT was hospitalized at U.S.C. Medical Center with a high fever. His remaining preschool medical history is unremarkable.(Footnote 8) There is no reported familial history of developmental disability, mental illness or hereditary disease.

STUDENT began crawling at the age of eight months, walking at twelve months, and reportedly enunciated his first words, “momma” and “papa,” shortly afterward. His mother, MOTHER, testified that she began to notice speech and language delays when STUDENT began prekindergarten in1996. It was at that time, she testified that she was first able to compare him to other children of his age. She observed that his speech was more difficult to understand and his vocabulary was more limited than that of other children.

STUDENT entered the Tenth Street Elementary School (Tenth Street School), his neighborhood school within the District, during academic year 1996-1997. He was present only part of the year, leaving during the third quarter of the academic year. He was performing academically in the “needs improvement” range in all areas at that time. His cumulative record contains a notation by his teacher that he was having “speech difficulties,” and it appears from the notation that she discussed this observation in a parent-teacher conference with STUDENT’s mother. Shortly thereafter, the family moved to Mexico. While in Mexico, STUDENT did not attend school.

STUDENT, his mother and a younger brother returned to Los Angeles approximately one and one-half years later, in April 1998. The family’s return was under traumatic circumstances and STUDENT was in an emotionally fragile condition at the time. He was again enrolled at Tenth Street School. According to his report card, his grades during the spring 1998 quarter were mixed in the average and below average categories, but his teacher, Ms. Raigoza, reported that he made progress during the period.

By August of 1998, STUDENT was exhibiting increased anxiety and inability to cope. He was reported to have made suicide threats on more than one occasion, and as a result he was referred for mental health evaluation. The evaluation concluded with a diagnosis of “adjustment disorder” with anxiety overlay “due to family division and abandonment issues.” A note appearing in the formal diagnosis references STUDENT’s “developmental delays,” but no other descriptive information explains that observation. Ms. MOTHER testified that after the mental health issues were brought under control, she complained to the school principal about STUDENT’s lack of progress in school. This complaint appeared to have been made after the fall 1998 term commenced (there was no testimony specifying the date). After further discussion among the school principal, Ms. MOTHER, and STUDENT’s teacher, the teacher recommended an assessment. Consequently, an assessment plan was developed and sent home for Ms. MOTHER’s consent, an assessment was scheduled, and STUDENT’s first IEP meeting was scheduled to follow the assessment.

STUDENT’s initial IEP meeting took place February 26, 1999. The IEP team concluded, based upon initial assessment results of Christine Maalouf, the District’s bilingual speech pathologist, that STUDENT was eligible for special education services in the area of speech and language in order to remediate articulation and fluency difficulties.(Footnote 9) Pursuant to the IEP, STUDENT was provided two sessions of small-group speech therapy administered by Diana Sharp, the RSP speech and language teacher, for a total of 40 to 60 minutes per week. From the date of the initial IEP, February 1999, until March 2000, no review or interim IEP meetings were held. The record reflects that no further assessment was initiated by the District until late December of 1999 and early January of 2000, in preparation for the annual IEP. The next IEP meeting was that annual review.

At the annual IEP review meeting on March 14, 2000, the IEP team received reports from Caroline Kwong, STUDENT’s teacher; Ms. Maalouf, the speech pathologist mentioned earlier; Diana Sharp, the RSP instructor; and Shirley Ornstein, the District’s bilingual school psychologist. Concern was expressed by all members of the IEP team because STUDENT had made only limited academic progress since the beginning of the academic year despite receiving speech and language services. Upon the reports and further assessment by the bilingual school psychologist, STUDENT was determined to have a specific learning disability (SLD) and his eligibility was expanded. In reaching that conclusion, the IEP team considered results of alternative testing measures, direct observation, performance on verbal and nonverbal task completion, and related nonverbal testing. STUDENT’s information processing skills were found to be in the low/average range with a significant discrepancy between intellectual ability and academic achievement of more than two years. The discrepancy between his intellectual ability and academic achievement was identified in the areas of reading skills, reading comprehension, spelling, oral expression and writing skills. Shirley Ornstein’s evaluation was admitted into evidence. The report identified STUDENT’s processing disorders in expressive language, auditory discrimination, and short-term sequential visual-auditory memory.

The District responded to the Ornstein, Sharp and Maalouf reports by offering accommodations in curriculum and in STUDENT’s physical placement in the classroom, RSP assistance in a small-group instructional setting, and sixty minutes weekly of speech pathology.(Footnote 10) Additional goals and benchmarks were formulated and adopted in the written IEP, and the prior speech and language goals and benchmarks were modified. An occupational therapy assessment was also recommended.

Because of continuing concerns about STUDENT’s mental health, at a new IEP review commenced June 20, 2000, a referral to the county mental health agency was recommended. The state of his mental health continued to impact his education. Additionally, a summer 2000 ESY was approved for STUDENT at this meeting for the stated purpose of preventing regression. It was noted in the IEP document that he had been in an RSP speech and language program for approximately three months and that his attendance was poor due to “emotional upset.”(Footnote 11)

Another interim IEP review meeting took place in September 2000. The primary purpose of this conference was to review Los Angeles County Mental Health recommendations and an occupational therapy evaluation conducted by the District at Ms. MOTHER’s request. The Department of Mental Health found that STUDENT qualified for AB3632 services, and it agreed to provide such services on an outpatient basis. The goals of these services were to alleviate depression, decrease anxiety, and promote age-appropriate behaviors. On the other principal subject of this meeting, The IEP report noted that STUDENT did have some fine motor needs, but it was the IEP team recommendation that these be addressed in the classroom setting. The report also acknowledged that STUDENT’s speech and language needs had been partially unmet because of 450 minutes of “missed sessions.” The sessions were missed due to the District’s oversight (this was confirmed by the testimony, though never explained). Thus the District scheduled an additional thirty minutes of speech therapy to take place each week until the missed time was recouped. STUDENT’s academic achievement continued to be more than two years below grade level. His placement was thus changed to an SDC, a more restrictive placement where he would receive more assistance. Additionally, a Fast ForWord assessment plan was presented and approved. The purpose of this new assessment was to provide information about STUDENT’s ability to process auditory information and to determine whether he might be a candidate for participation in the Fast ForWord program. (Footnote 12)

The Fast ForWord assessment was conducted October 18, 2000. The assessment identified areas of significant deficit in STUDENT’s auditory processing. The examiner concluded, however, that “many of the errors he made were more representative of a bilingual child rather than a language delayed child.” There was no further explanation of this observation about STUDENT, either in the documentary evidence or by testimony at the hearing.(Footnote 13) The determination as to the methodology utilized to address STUDENT’s auditory processing difficulties was deferred by the assessor to the IEP team. At the IEP meeting of November 16, 2000, the team recommended continued speech and language services, including continuation of the make-up sessions. It also recommended the development of a positive behavior support plan for STUDENT, but the team determined that STUDENT was “not eligible” for the Fast ForWord program. The IEP team had recommended an SDC placement to deal with several of STUDENT’s areas of deficit, including auditory processing.

On January 11, 2001, occupational therapy was the focus of the IEP meeting. While the team identified areas of fine motor deficit, it recommended that STUDENT’s needs be addressed by his RSP teacher in his SDC classroom setting. STUDENT’s annual IEP review took place March 13, 2001. It was reported that STUDENT partially achieved goals in language arts, articulation and fluency (a report that would be disputed at the due process hearing). However, goals were not met in mathematics, in certain of the areas of articulation and fluency, and vocational education. He had developed a sight word vocabulary and functioned in reading and spelling at the first grade level. His depression was being managed with psychotropic medications and his social-emotional adjustment was greatly improved. STUDENT remained eligible for special education services under the categories of speech and language and specific learning disability, receiving speech and language designated instruction and services. Goals and objectives were reviewed and revised, and his placement in the special day class (SDC) instructional setting was reported to be eighty-four percent of the day, with a sixteen percent of the day component in the general population. There was additionally an assistive technology recommendation for flash cards, manipulatives and highlighters. It was determined that STUDENT had five more thirty-minute language sessions to make up and they were scheduled. He remained eligible for mental health services under AB3632. An ESY session and after-school tutoring were offered as well. STUDENT’s mother signed the IEP evidencing her consent.

An IEP meeting, on May 7, 2001, was convened to review STUDENT’s mental health progress. It was reported that he was making positive progress and his suicidal ideation had been reduced, but he continued to exhibit anxiety and frustration with peer relationships and with his stuttering problem. Continuing services were recommended. Ms. MOTHER requested a one-to-one aide for STUDENT. The IEP team denied the request. Ms. MOTHER requested OT services for STUDENT. This request was denied. The District believed his needs could be met generally by working with the RSP teacher in the classroom.

Petitioner’s request for a due process hearing was received by the Special Education Hearing Office on October 16, 2001. The issue designated was OT. Ms. MOTHER, who made the request on Petitioner’s behalf, stated: “I am requesting this due process proceeding because Los Angeles Unified School District denied my request ... for occupational therapy services for STUDENT....” On October 24, 2001, the parties agreed to take the hearing, scheduled to commence November 8, 2001, off calendar.

The three-year IEP review was scheduled for January 18, 2002 . At the meeting, STUDENT’s progress in achieving his goals and objectives was reviewed. His comprehension and fluency were reportedly improved and it was related that he was participating in classroom discussions. However, according to the underlying reports, he was still experiencing fluency and articulation challenges and he was having difficulty decoding multisyllabic words. He was reported to be making reasonable progress in written language skills and was making progress with his mental health issues. However, his assessment results indicated that he still possessed low/average range cognitive abilities and performance abilities. His conversational language skills were significantly below average range in both Spanish and English, and he continued to have deficits in fine motor skills. For example, he had difficulty holding a pencil correctly and thus demonstrated unsteady writing and drawing. Now a fifth-grader, STUDENT was performing at or below the second grade level. Curiously, the IEP team concluded that STUDENT was “improving” but required additional support and assistance. He remained eligible for special education and designated instructional services under the same categories.

The IEP team reconvened June 18, 2002, to discuss STUDENT’s transition to the sixth grade at Berrendo Middle School (Berrendo). It was determined that he would remain in the Tenth Street School until the end of the current calendar year and then attend the 2002 ESY during the winter intersession at Berrendo. The District was to provide transportation to the new school for STUDENT.(Footnote 14)

The team reviewed his progress, noting that he demonstrated strength in mathematics. It was suggested that his math goals be revised to include orally restating directions and practice in a small-group setting. His visual processing deficits were reported to impact his ability to perform grade-level calculations. In the area of health, it was noted that his medication had been changed. Counseling and medication provided under AB3632 were to continue. New goals, including increased interaction and socialization with peers, were adopted. Articulation and fluency goals were modified as well. He was reported to be making progress in both areas, but therapy was to continue because deficits in the areas of receptive and expressive speech continued to disrupt his access to the curriculum. His mother objected to the IEP recommendations.

As mentioned earlier, a request for a due process hearing had been received by the Hearing Office in October 2001. It had been taken off calendar at the request of the parties. In response to correspondence requesting the status of the matter, on December 2, 2002, Petitioner notified the Hearing Office that the parties requested that the matter be placed back on calendar. The hearing was scheduled as requested and commenced January 14, 2003. The due process hearing took place during Berrendo’s winter break. STUDENT had been designated to attend ESY during school intersession, as mentioned above, but he was not attending during this one.

FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW

Under both federal and State law, students with disabilities have the right to a free appropriate public education. 20 U.S.C. ¤¤ 1400 et seq. Cal. Educ. Code ¤¤ 56000 et seq. The purpose of the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) and California’s conforming statutes is to provide handicapped students with access to public education. Board of Education v. Rowley, 458 U.S. 176 (1982). A free appropriate public education in this context consists of special education and related services that are available to the child, at no charge to the parent or guardian, which meet the State educational standards and conform to the child’s individualized education program (IEP). 20 U.S.C. ¤ 1401(8).(Footnote 15)

The package of instruction and services mandated as “special education” is defined as specially designed instruction which meets the unique needs of the child. 20 U.S.C. ¤ 1401(25); Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56031. Under IDEA, the student’s unique needs to be met are those that result from the student’s disability. The special education program is also designed to enable the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum and as the Supreme Court stated in Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, it must be reasonably calculated to provide the pupil with educational benefit. The Act does not require that the benefits conferred permit the student to reach the highest attainable level. Lenn v. Portland Sch. Comm. 998 F.2d 1083 (1st. Cir. 1993). What is required is entry to a “basic floor of opportunity” through access to specialized instruction and related services which are individually designed to provide educational benefit to the student. Board of Education v. Rowley, supra, at 201. That education is to be provided in the least restrictive environment and prepare the student for employment and independent living. 20 U.S.C. ¤ 1412; 34 C.F.R. ¤ 300.550; Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56345. In summary, State law and Rowley provide three factors to be examined in an analysis of whether a school district substantially offered a FAPE. First, the offer must be designed to meet unique needs (those unique needs having been determined at the outset). Second, the program offered must be reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the student. And third, it must conform to the student’s IEP (a fourth factor which may be applicable is that the educational program must be provided in the least restrictive environment).

A school district must first identify the student’s unique educational needs in all areas of the student’s suspected disability. Federal and State law describe the types of disabilities that may qualify a child for special education and related services, but the child’s unique needs arising from his or her disability are the fundamental determinant of an appropriate program for the child. As stated in federal law,“the services and placement needed by each child with a disability to receive a free appropriate public education must be based on the child’s unique needs and not on the child’s disability.” Title 34, C.F.R. Sec. 300.300(a)(3)(ii).

Once those unique needs are determined, the analysis must focus on the adequacy of a district's proposed program. Gregory K. v. Longview Sch. Dist., 811 F.2d 1307, 1314 (9th Cir. 1987). If a district's proposed program addresses the student’s unique needs, provides some educational benefit, and comports with the IEP, then that district has offered a FAPE, even if the parents prefer another program and even if the parents’ preferred program would likely result in greater educational benefit. Rowley, 458 U.S. at 207-208; Gregory K., 811 F.2d at 1314; 20 U.S.C. ¤1401(8), ¤1412 (a) (5) (A); Cal. Educ. Code ¤56031.

The Supreme Court also recognized the importance of adherence to procedural requirements in Rowley, supra at 201. Federal special education law requires states to establish certain procedural safeguards to ensure that each student with a disability receives the FAPE to which the student is entitled and to ensure that parents are involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist. No. 23 (9th Cir. 1992) 960 F.2d 1479, 1483. Procedural flaws do not automatically require a finding of a denial of FAPE. But procedural violations that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G., supra at 1484. (Footnote 16)

Procedural Appropriateness.

1. Procedural Appropriateness of IEP Meetings (all years).

Did the District fail to provide a certified interpreter for STUDENT’s mother at IEP meetings in all years in issue and, if so, does that failure invalidate the IEP and deny Petitioner a FAPE?

Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.5(h) states: “The district, special education local plan area, or county office shall take whatever action is necessary to ensure that the parent understands the proceedings at a meeting, including arranging for an interpreter for parents with deafness or whose native language is other than English.” In addition, case law applicable to procedural requirements for a FAPE provides for parents to be involved in the formulation of the student’s educational program. As stated above, not every procedural violation results in the denial of a FAPE, but those that result in the loss of educational opportunity to the student or seriously infringe on the parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process do result in the denial of a FAPE. W.G. v. Bd. of Trustees of Target Range Sch. Dist., supra.

The Petitioner asserted that the Respondents violated Cal. Educ. Code section 56341.5(h) by failing to have a “qualified, certified, independent” interpreter in Spanish present at the IEP meetings. Of those three qualities, it was made apparent to the Hearing Officer through testimony that the independence of the interpreter was the most important. The Petitioner asserted that the interpreters who attended the meetings were employees of the District who had other duties at the District and were not persons who were interested in assisting her to understand the process. Ms. MOTHER testified that she frequently found herself not knowing “what was going on” at the IEP meetings. The Petitioner asserted that the procedural violation of failing to have an appropriate interpreter present at the IEP meetings resulted in a denial of FAPE. The Petitioner requested an order that a qualified, certified and independent interpreter of Spanish be present at all future IEP meetings. In spite of the Petitioner’s assertions to the contrary, section 56341.5(h) does not require interpreters at IEP meetings to have a specific type of certification or specific qualifications. Instead, section 56341.5(h) requires that interpreters have “sufficient skill” to ensure that language differences do not prevent the parents from understanding the proceedings at the meeting. Ms. MOTHER testified that at each IEP meeting several Spanish-speaking persons were present. They included the school principals, when they attended, the secretary at Tenth Street School, Gloria Perez, STUDENT’s case manager from the Lanterman Regional Center, Ms. Maalouf, Ms. Ornstein and two of STUDENT’s teachers, when they attended. There was only one IEP review at which no interpreter was present initially. In that case, the meeting was recessed until a Spanish-speaking person arrived for the purpose of interpreting for Ms. MOTHER. In each case, the testimony established to the satisfaction of the Hearing Officer that the interpreters at STUDENT’s IEP meeting had the requisite level of skill to satisfy section 56341.5(h). Furthermore, there was no testimony that any interpreter services provided or omitted by the District at any of STUDENT’s IEP meetings caused him to lose educational opportunity or infringed on his parent’s opportunity to participate in the IEP process. Ms. MOTHER did participate in the meetings as evidenced by her signatures appearing on each of the IEP documents attesting to her attendance and signifying her approval of each IEP. In addition, there are statements in each of the IEP documents summarizing Ms. MOTHER’s concerns or position at the meeting. The evidence demonstrates that Ms. MOTHER did participate.

Ms MOTHER’s testimony demonstrated that she did not trust the persons interpreting because for the most part they were employed by the District. However, there was no testimony that would tend to establish that any of them translated inaccurately, incorrectly or dishonestly. Accordingly, the Hearing Officer finds that the interpreters provided by the District at STUDENT’s IEP meetings satisfied the requirements of section 56341.5(h) in all years in issue. The Hearing Officer determines, therefore, that no procedural violation occurred that denied Petitioner a FAPE.

Substantive Appropriateness.

2. Did the District fail to provide STUDENT with a free appropriate public education (FAPE) for each of the following enumerated academic years:

(a) Academic Year 1998-1999.

In this initial academic year, Petitioner contended that STUDENT’s speech and language and auditory processing deficits should have been identified by the District “prior to academic year 1998-1999.” Therefore, Petitioner asserted, STUDENT’s unique need for substantial services of a speech pathologist in both individual and group settings should have been determined and addressed by the District during that academic year. Petitioner’s contention was based on two notations in STUDENT’s cumulative record. One indicated that he was exhibiting “speech difficulties” in prekindergarten (1996). Another entry indicated that Ms. MOTHER attended a parent-teacher conference on that subject in 1996, immediately prior to the family’s move to Mexico.(Footnote 17)

(i) Assessing The Areas of STUDENT’s Suspected Disability.

California law imposes detailed and demanding requirements on school districts to ensure that students who may be disabled are promptly and appropriately assessed. School districts must systematically seek out all individuals with exceptional needs. Cal. Educ. Code section 56300. Districts must establish written policies and procedures for a continuous child-find system, and those policies and procedures must include written notification to all parents of procedures for initiating a referral for assessment. Cal. Educ. Code section 56301; 5 C.C.R. section 3021(a). California requires school districts to take a proactive role in seeking out and assessing children with suspected disabilities.

The evidence demonstrated that in academic year 1998-1999 the District responded reasonably and timely to the indicators that STUDENT was exhibiting speech difficulties. It is true that STUDENT attended prekindergarten for part of academic year 1996-1997. The record does indicate that he was exhibiting some difficulty with speech and that a parent-teacher conference was called to discuss this. However, the family moved to Mexico in November 1996 and the opportunity was lost for the District to assess at that time. STUDENT did not attend school while in Mexico. Thus no assessment took place.

When he returned to Los Angeles and to the District, he re-enrolled at Tenth Street School in April 1998. If he was experiencing speech problems, they were not identified primarily because his participation in class was limited due to depression. His mental health issues were quite severe, requiring immediate attention. He was not only depressed but was also emotionally unstable. The circumstances of his return to Los Angeles included the disruption of his parents’ marriage, which triggered a significant adjustment disorder with marked anxiety overlay. His symptoms included suicidal ideation. Ultimately, his problems resulted in psychotherapy by the California Hospital Medical Center in August 1998. Hospital outpatient progress notes from August 24, 1998, state that there were unspecified developmental delays but that his thought processes were “unremarkable”(Footnote 18) and that he did not exhibit disfluencies (Footnote 19) or appear anxious in a structured one-on-one environment.

STUDENT was treated for his mental health issues with medication and counseling on an outpatient basis and returned to school in the fall of 1998 on schedule. The District first became aware of STUDENT’s educational difficulties in the fall of 1998. Ms. MOTHER testified that she complained to the school about STUDENT’s language delays (however, she did not specify the approximate date of any such complaint). STUDENT’s then current teacher concurred that STUDENT did appear to have speech and language delays and she recommended an assessment. Accordingly, the District developed an assessment plan, and a Spanish language version of that plan was provided to Ms. MOTHER in November 1998. Ms. MOTHER returned her consent in December and an assessment was conducted by Christine Maalouf, one of the District’s bilingual speech and language specialists.(Footnote 20) An IEP meeting was scheduled. Included in the IEP was a statement that STUDENT was assessed because of concerns over his articulation and fluency. The assessment, conducted by Ms. Maalouf in Spanish, revealed some articulation errors and disfluencies as well as some expressive language errors. Ms. Maalouf was present at the IEP meeting to review and explain her assessment. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was eligible for special education services in the speech and language category.

The Hearing Officer does not accept Petitioner’s contention that the District should have identified an auditory processing disorder at this time. STUDENT’s then present levels of performance reflected speech and language delays. He was at a point in his development that he was beginning to develop speech and language skills. He had a limited Spanish vocabulary and more limited English vocabulary. The evaluation demonstrated that STUDENT had articulation and fluency issues, as previously mentioned. No contention was made that this assessment was inappropriate or improper.

With respect to the alleged auditory processing disorder, Petitioner pointed to the result of a subtest within an assessment tool known as the SPELT II. However, expert opinion reveals that the result of that particular subtest does not lead to a conclusion that an auditory processing disorder existed. District due process specialist and speech pathologist Susan Glickman testified that this subtest result was too indirect to have resulted in such a conclusion. It demonstrated that STUDENT made errors in the use of prepositions and pronouns, among other things. But the subtest did not demonstrate that he was having difficulty processing auditory information or following multiple step directions.

The Hearing Officer concludes that the speech and language assessment conducted by Ms. Maalouf was timely, not something that should have been undertaken before academic year 1998-1999, as Petitioner contended.. After school resumed, Ms. MOTHER focused attention on STUDENT’s speech and language difficulties. When Ms. MOTHER expressed concerns, the District responded appropriately and timely by validating her concerns, developing a plan and scheduling an assessment.(Footnote 21) Moreover, there was no evidence to indicate that an assessment for auditory processing disorder should have been conducted.

(ii) Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

The IEP team was provided with assessment results that clearly identified the speech and language deficits first complained of by Ms. MOTHER and observed by STUDENT’s teacher. These deficits were in the areas of articulation and fluency. STUDENT was then in the second grade. His first grade year had been spent mostly out of school while he lived in Mexico. It was determined that STUDENT needed speech therapy. The Hearing Officer finds that it was reasonable to conclude in February 1999 that STUDENT’s speech and language deficits in articulation and fluency would be reduced or eliminated by addressing them directly with speech therapy.

The Hearing Officer will now turn to the issue of whether STUDENT’s unique speech and language needs, having been determined, were appropriately addressed between February 1999 and the close of the regular school year in June1999.

(iii) Designed to meet needs and reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.(Footnote 22)

The February 26, 1999 IEP was the initial IEP for this student.. To address his needs, the District offered a program consisting of 40-60 minutes per week of speech therapy directed to improving articulation and fluency. The speech therapy was divided into two sessions per week, and delivered by an RSP speech and language specialist in a small-group setting. The IEP also contained goals and objectives to address his needs in speech and language. Participants in the IEP meeting included Ms. MOTHER, Ms. Maalouf, Shirley Ornstein, who attended as the designee of the school administrator, the school nurse, and STUDENT’s teacher. Ms. MOTHER signified her consent to the IEP.

Petitioner contended that the IEP was defective because the amount of therapy was not ascertainable, nor was it sufficient in any event.

It is apparent that “40-60 minutes” of speech therapy signifies a range and not a definite or finite amount of time. The Hearing Officer concludes that signifying a range does not deprive the student of a FAPE, as long as the lower limit of the range is adequate to address the student’s unique needs.. Ms. Glickman testified that the provision of forty minutes of speech therapy to STUDENT was designed to meet his needs for articulation and fluency therapy. She stated that the amount was reasonable and that it was intended to provide him with the skills he needed to progress in his education. According to Ms. Glickman, by setting a range of 40-60 minutes, the IEP team was simply giving the speech therapist some flexibility. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Glickman’s testimony persuasive. No expert testified that given the knowledge of STUDENT’s speech and language issues obtained during academic year 1998-1999, it was reasonable to conclude that more than forty minutes per week of speech therapy would be necessary to meet STUDENT’s unique needs through the end of that school year.

Additionally, Petitioner argued that the stated goals and objectives in the IEP were vague and not measurable. For example, the goal in the area of articulation was “will improve articulation skills” and the short-term objective or benchmark was “will produce targeted sounds ....[without identifying the sounds to be targeted].” The goal in fluency was similarly worded, i.e. “...will improve fluency skills.” The objectives or benchmarks in this area were described as “will learn fluency shaping techniques (breath flow) ... and easy onset ....”

The standard for the formulation of goals and objectives in the student’s IEP is governed by California Education Code ¤¤ 56345(a)(2) and 34 C.F.R. ¤¤ 300.346(a)(2). They require that IEPs include annual goals and objectives. Annual goals are “statements that describe what a child with a disability can reasonably be expected to accomplish within a twelve month period in the child’s special education program. There should be a direct relationship between the annual goals and the present levels of educational performance.” 34 C.F.R. Part 300, App. C, Q. 38. Short-term instructional objectives are measurable, intermediate steps between the child’s present levels of educational performance and the annual goals that are established for the child. 34 C.F.R. Pt. 300, App. C, Q. 39 (1996). The objectives should be developed based on a logical breakdown of the major components of the annual goals and should be projected to be accomplished over an extended period of time, such as a school quarter or semester. IEP objectives are necessary in order to provide general benchmarks for measuring the student’s progress toward meeting the annual goals and otherwise gauging the efficacy of the services provided. See also, Cleveland Heights-University Heights City Sch. Dist. v. Boss, 44 F.3d 391, 399 (6th Cir. 1998). California Education Code section 56345(a)(6) requires that an IEP describe objective criteria, evaluation procedures, and schedules for determining whether instructional objectives are being met.

Because the purpose of these measurable objectives or “benchmarks” is to have criteria by which to determine the progress or lack of progress a student has made toward his annual goals, the Hearing Officer must determine whether a speech therapy provider would understand, from a reading of the IEP goals and objectives, what services should be delivered to STUDENT to address his unique needs. Although the Hearing Officer finds that there is some basis for Petitioner’s criticism of the IEP on this ground, a review of the document as a whole reveals several important facts. Most importantly, STUDENT’s present levels of performance were addressed in Ms. Maalouf’s written report. In that report she noted with specificity that STUDENT’s articulation difficulty was with “some multisyllabic words (d/r, d/l), reduction of dr-blend, f/j (fugo/jugo) and k/t (klenes/tienes).” She continued to identify errors in his use of prepositions and verb tenses, reference pronouns and forming “yes/no”and “wh” questions. She identified disfluency errors with equal specificity. It was from STUDENT’s then present levels that progress was to be measured. Susan Glickman testified that reading STUDENT’s IEP as a whole, and recognizing that there were only a few months left in the regular school year, there was sufficient information for an experienced speech and language specialist to be able to measure progress or lack of progress. She testified that Diana Sharp, an experienced speech pathologist, is the RSP instructor who provided STUDENT’s service. (Footnote 23)Susan Glickman’s experience includes service as a due process specialist, a speech therapist, a diagnostic examiner and master teacher. The Hearing Officer finds Ms. Glickman’s testimony persuasive on these points

In summary, STUDENT experienced articulation and fluency deficits. The District identified them and concluded that he needed speech therapy. No one disagreed. Through the IEP process, STUDENT was offered specialized speech and language therapy that was individually designed to provide him with skills that the IEP team believed he needed to progress in school. Despite some degree of imprecision in the drafting of the IEP, the evidence established that an experienced provider of the service would have had no difficulty knowing what and how much to provide or how to assess STUDENT’s progress. STUDENT’s provider was Diana Sharp, an experienced speech therapist. Thus, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District offered STUDENT a program designed to meet his needs.

The Hearing Officer also concludes that the program was also calculated to provide STUDENT with some educational benefit. He responded to the therapy positively. He had only attended a total of twenty-eight days of school prior to the 1998-1999 academic year. The witnesses at the hearing testified that STUDENT made progress in the area of speech and language during the brief period from February 1999 to June 1999 and that consequently he was able to make progress in social and academic areas. His report card at the end of June 1998 reflected that he needed improvement in all areas. His IEP began in February 1999. His teacher, Ms. Raigoza, comments in June 1999 that “STUDENT se has desarrollado como alumna y ha mejorado ensus mathematicas” ( STUDENT was developing socially and making progress in mathematics). His June 1999 report card shows growth or satisfactory progress in all areas with the exception of conceptual thinking and completion of homework. At the beginning of the next academic year, the September 29, 1999, report of the Student Success Team states that STUDENT was then reading at the prekindergarten level. While this was below grade level, it was an improvement over the the beginning of the 1998-1999 school year; at that time, he was unable to even print his name or correctly recite numbers. The Hearing Officer therefore finds that beginning in February 1999 and continuing through the end of the academic year, the District offered and provided STUDENT a program calculated to provide him a FAPE.

(iii) Should an ESY have been provided for STUDENT in 1998-1999?

The February 26, 1999 IEP addressed the ESY session that was to begin at the conclusion of the regular academic year. The written IEP contains the statement “ESY is not recommended as it is not anticipated he will not [sic] experience regression.”(Footnote 24) A school district is required to provide a special education student with an ESY program when the student requires special education and related services in excess of the regular academic year, if the student’s handicap is likely to continue for a prolonged period and the interruption in service of the pupil’s educational programming may cause regression. 5 C.C.R section 3043. Regression is deemed significant if the student has limited recoupment capacity. Morton Sch. Dist. V. Washington State E.A., (2001) 35 IDELR 103; Etowah County Bd. Of Educ. (2001) 34 IDELR 302. The term “extended school year” usually refers to a program during school intersessions, the duration of which will depend the unique needs of the student. 5 C.C.R.3043(c) and (d).(Footnote 25) Thus, a determination regarding ESY services for a student must be based on the educational and skill levels that must be maintained during the intersession with respect to the student’s unique needs. See for example, M.M. v. Sch. Dist. Of Greenville Co., 303 F.3d 523 (4th Cir. 2002);Cordrey v. Euckert, 917 F.2d 1460 (6th Cir. 1990).

The Petitioner contended that he should have been provided an ESY at the conclusion of academic year 1998-1999. The student’s record at that time included the February 26, 1999 IEP and its accompanying assessment reports and STUDENT’s report card and teacher comments.

On that record there is no evidence that STUDENT’s skill levels would likely regress over the intersession. Ms. Glickman testified that it was anticipated that STUDENT would “self-correct” with the regimen of two sessions per week recommended by the IEP team. The Hearing Officer concludes from Ms. Glickman’s testimony that in June 1999, there was no indication of the potential for regression and, therefore it was not appropriate to provide an ESY for 1998-1999.

(iv) Did The Services Delivered to STUDENT Conform to His IEP?

The District did deliver forty minutes weekly of small-group speech therapy to STUDENT as provided in the February 26, 1999 IEP. This fact was later verified by Ms. Maalouf’s second assessment, as well as in the notes of a Student Success Team meeting and the next annual IEP.

In sum, the Hearing Officer finds, as to academic year 1998-1999, that on the basis of the information that it had at the time, the District designed, offered and provided a FAPE to Petitioner for the period from February 26, 1999, to the conclusion of that school year.

(b) Academic Year 1999-2000.

Petitioner contended that for 1999-2000 the District failed to assess in all areas of STUDENT’s suspected disability, that the goals and objectives in the new IEP of March 2000 were vague and were not measurable, that STUDENT did not demonstrate progress, that STUDENT’s speech and language should have been individual, and that services were not delivered to STUDENT in conformity with the IEPs in effect during the academic year. Further, Petitioner contended that the District denied Petitioner access to the ESY authorized for him.

1. September 1999 - December 31, 1999.

(i) Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

No new assessments were initiated during this period, the first half of the new academic year. Thus, the District was providing services based upon the prior assessments.

(ii)Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

There was no new or interim IEP scheduled. Thus the needs identified were those set forth in the most recent IEP, the IEP of February 1999.

(iii) Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

In September 1999, the beginning of academic year 1999-2000, STUDENT’s educational program was being provided pursuant to the IEP of February 26, 1999, which provided for two weekly forty-minute sessions of small-group speech and language. In addition to the services provided for in his IEP, he was also receiving mental health counseling, which was provided by the County.

The evidence established that although STUDENT had shown some academic improvement during the prior school year, he was still behind in all academic areas in September of the 1999-2000 school year (Student Success Team minutes). The Student Success Team (SST) met in September to review his mental health needs and his treatment progress at California Medical Clinic. STUDENT was still depressed and had made some suicidal threats. The SST consisted of his current regular education teacher; Diana Sharp, the RSP provider of speech and language services; Diane Carpenter, the RSP provider who assisted in STUDENT’s regular education class; STUDENT’s principal; Ms. Ornstein, the school psychologist; Ms. MOTHER; and a support person. The meeting record shows that STUDENT’s overall program was discussed at that time. The meeting minutes contain a note stating that a complete psychoeducational assessment should be initiated immediately. The minutes also contain a statement acknowledging STUDENT’s poor academic performance: “This student is behind in all academic areas.” Additionally, in the first reporting period of this academic year, STUDENT was working below grade level in most areas. His reading, writing, social science and science scores were reported as “1" -- the lowest grade possible on the scale the District used at that time. However, no interim IEP meetings were held or scheduled to review progress or discuss performance levels. And no further evaluation of STUDENT was begun until the end of December 1999 in preparation for STUDENT’s next annual IEP. It was not until January 2000 that Ms. Maalouf’s second assessment was completed, February 2000 that the District completed a psychoeducational evaluation, and March 2000 that a new IEP was adopted. Thus, early in the academic year, the District had sufficient information that STUDENT required additional assistance and by failing to act promptly on that information, the District failed to offer a program that was designed to meet his needs and was reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

2. January 2000 through ESY 2000.

Petitioner contended generally that the District failed to properly assess STUDENT. Petitioner’s witnesses and closing brief narrowed the focus of this contention as to this academic year to two specific areas of complaint. First, Petitioner disagreed with the assessment method used by the District. Petitioner viewed the assessment methodology as archaic. Secondly, Petitioner contended that an apraxia screening should have been administered.

(i) Assessing The Areas of STUDENT’s Suspected Disability.

(1) The District’s Assessment Procedure.

The Petitioner alleged that the District failed to appropriately evaluate STUDENT’s auditory processing skills. Ms. Rozenberg testified that she would have explored this area by administering certain standardized formal tests with which she and most experts in the field today were familiar. Christine Davidson, Ph.D., also Petitioner’s expert, criticized the District’s psychoeducational and psychological evaluations for the same reason, failure to administer standardized testing that is commonly used by leading forensic examiners in the field. In short, both of these highly qualified experts would have approached the evaluations somewhat differently than did the District in this case.(Footnote 26)

The testimony demonstrated that although standardized verbal intelligence testing may be a simpler and more direct way of estimating cognitive ability, it is by no means the only acceptable way of doing so. If administered properly, other testing instruments and procedures can give an assessor an accurate understanding of a student’s abilities, deficits and unique needs. In STUDENT’s case, standardized tests of nonverbal abilities were used, and other methods of evaluation, such as direct observation and interviews of teachers and providers, were used to establish his performance levels. Thus the inquiry to which the Hearing Officer turns is whether during the last half of academic year 1999-2000, the District correctly determined STUDENT’s unique needs through the use of its alternative assessment procedures.

Petitioner’s learning disability and his expressive language skills had become more pronounced during the intervening year. Christine Maalouf, who conducted a second informal speech and language assessment, reported that while STUDENT was making “limited progress” in fluency, expressive language and production of multi-syllabic words, he continued to have difficulty with phonemic awareness, auditory discrimination and production of “l” and “r” sounds, particularly in blends. Diana Sharp, STUDENT’s resource specialist, administered alternative tests together with some testing having Spanish language support. She concluded that STUDENT’s deficits were in visual and auditory sequential memory, auditory discrimination, and comprehension, which “may impede his access to the curriculum.” Ms. Ornstein, one of the District’s bilingual school psychologists, reported to the IEP team that STUDENT was functioning in the low average range in nonverbal ability – more than two years below expectancy. Ms. Ornstein assessed STUDENT using alternative methods. She also administered the Wide Range Achievement Test and the Bender Gestalt visual motor test. Her assessment indicated that there was a severe discrepancy between STUDENT’s ability and his academic achievement due to psychological processing disorders in attention, visual-auditory processing and visual-motor integration.

Ms. Ornstein, who performed the psychoeducational assessment for the March 2000 IEP, reported to the IEP team that STUDENT had been in a program of speech therapy for the past year to address problems he had with “blending” and “stuttering” but that his reading level remained at prekindergarten level.(Footnote 27) STUDENT was nine years old at this time. He was still functioning at age six according to the District’s evaluations. The assessments demonstrated severe deficit and psychological processing disorders, visual and auditory processing disorders and visual motor integration disorders. Now that STUDENT had developed some communication skills, he demonstrated more dramatic needs than were identified in the prior academic year. As a result of the District’s assessments, it was determined that STUDENT was functioning more than two grades below level.

As stated above, the conclusions of the District were reached using a combination of alternative test procedures and standardized tests. Petitioner’s principal disagreement appears to be with the methodology employed by the District to identify areas of the student’s disability. The areas identified by Petitioner and those identified by the District through its assessment procedures are the same: speech and language disfluencies and articulation, auditory processing, visual processing and visual-motor integration. Both parties reached the same result, each using a different testing regimen. Thus, Petitioner’s results serve to verify the appropriateness of the District’s assessments.

(2) Apraxia Screening.

Petitioner contended that the District’s assessments contained information that should have triggered a closer look at apraxia.(Footnote 28) The assessments by the District were undertaken to provide information for the March 2000 IEP meeting. The District did not undertake an apraxia screening.

In January 2003, some three years later, Ms. Rozenberg, Petitioner’s expert, did look at apraxia as a possible deficit. She did so because she was alerted to that possibility by portions of her testing. She testified, however, that she did not find that STUDENT had an apraxia problem. Therefore, even if the Hearing Officer accepts the contention that there were indicators of further screening when the District assessment was conducted, the subsequent screening conducted by Ms. Rozenberg ruled out apraxia.(Footnote 29) Therefore, the alleged failure to screen for apraxia had no consequence to STUDENT.

(ii) Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

For a major part of the academic year, September 1999 through March 2000, STUDENT’s educational program was guided by the February 26, 1999 IEP. Diana Sharp, STUDENT’s resource instructor, who had been working with him in class, reported to the IEP team that STUDENT’s regular education teacher was concerned that STUDENT’s academic growth was lagging behind.(Footnote 30) As a result of the District’s December assessments and the reports of the teacher and STUDENT’s parent, the March 14, 2000 IEP team determined STUDENT’s needs to be much greater than they were one year earlier. The result of this annual IEP meeting was a significant change in STUDENT’s eligibility as well as in his written goals and objectives in his areas of need. The IEP team concluded that STUDENT was now eligible for special education services under the category of specific learning disability as well as speech and language impaired.(Footnote 31) The IEP team determined that because of his processing disorders, he had a need for small-group instruction in the areas of language arts, expressive language, vocational education and mathematics, and continued to have a need for DIS to meet his articulation and fluency problems.

(iii) Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

To address his need for small-group instruction and support in the academic areas of mathematics, vocational education, language arts and elementary language development, the IEP provided for RSP instruction in the classroom. (Footnote 32) The IEP addressed STUDENT’s speech and language program needs in essentially the same way as it had in the previous IEPs, with two thirty-minute sessions of speech therapy per week in a small-group setting provided by the speech therapist.(Footnote 33) The IEP also provided for ESY to prevent regression.

The Petitioner contended, as noted above, that specific goals set forth in the written IEP were vague and not measurable. The IEP contained goals and objectives in the areas of academics noted above, and goals and objectives in the area of speech and language. The evidence establishes that the goals and objectives in the academic areas were both sufficiently specific and therefore measurable. There were also sufficient objectives. Morevoer, in this academic year, some of the speech and language objectives were more specific than those in the previous IEP. For example, one of the objectives under the goal “increase decoding skills” was “will begin to sound out CVC words.” On the other hand, some objectives remained quite general, such as “will produce targeted sounds,” without specifying which sounds would be among those to be targeted. As has been established, STUDENT’s articulation and fluency had not improved since September and the District had assessed STUDENT with a significant auditory processing disorder. The Hearing Officer concludes that his speech and language should have been addressed with specific measurable goals and objectives. There was sufficient information available to the IEP team to determine that STUDENT’s needs in this area were not being met, but the written IEP did not address those needs with adequate specificity.(Footnote 34)

Petitioner also contended that the amount of speech and language therapy offered by the District did not meet his needs or provide him with benefit. He asserted that he required individual speech therapy. The Hearing Officer agrees. Although STUDENT showed no improvement during the 1999-2000 school year, the District continued to offer the same sixty minutes per week in two small-group sessions. There was no individual speech and language therapy proposed. No individual speech therapy was offered. No extra sessions were scheduled. Although this approach during the first four months of the IEP in the prior year resulted in some improvement, it should have been clear to the District that by March 2000 he needed additional services. The Hearing Officer questioned why the same basic speech and language program was thought appropriate to address STUDENT’s needs in the current academic year. The District did not address this question directly at the due process hearing. Neither Ms. Maalouf nor Ms. Ornstein was called as a witness to explain why she recommended to the IEP team that the level of speech and language service remain essentially the same, with minor classroom accommodations. In written closing argument, the District approached this issue by criticizing Ms. Rozenberg’s recommendations as excessive, not by explaining its own. The Hearing Officer concludes therefore that this program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s needs or reasonably calculated to provide benefit to him in the area of speech and language.

Having identified a processing disorder amd determined that STUDENT’s needs required attention in six academic areas, the District offered RSP instruction in the classroom. This was an improvement. To that extent, the District’s offer was reasonably designed to meet STUDENT’s needs and provide him with academic benefit.

(iii) Did the District offer an appropriate ESY for 1999-2000?

The IEP did provide for an ESY for STUDENT during the intersession. It was determined that there was a likelihood of regression and STUDENT had demonstrated that he had limited recoupment capacity. The provision of an ESY program was appropriate. However, the ESY program itself was not appropriate as it was no different from the program for the regular school year and did not take into account STUDENT’s increased speech and language needs. Moreover, as established below, the District acknowledged that it failed to notify Ms. MOTHER, as agreed, that an ESY class assignment had been made available for STUDENT.

(iv) Did the services delivered to STUDENT conform to his IEP?

The evidence showed that 450 minutes of speech therapy were “missed” during this important academic year. No explanation for this omission was offered. To make matters worse, even though the District had approved an ESY for STUDENT, it failed to notify Ms. MOTHER that it had been approved, and he missed the entire ESY session. STUDENT’s mother testified to the effect that he seemed to be forgotten by the District.

Thus, STUDENT’s needs went unaddressed during the first half of the academic year; and not only were the speech and language services not increased to address STUDENT’s increased needs during the second part of the academic year, but they were not delivered in accordance with either IEP. Moreover, as stated above, the ESY program provided to prevent STUDENT from regressing at the end of the school year was missed entirely. On the basis of the foregoing, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s program was not designed to meet STUDENT’s unique needs, nor was it reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit. Moreover, the program also did not conform with the IEPs in effect during academic year 1999-2000. Thus, for those reasons the Hearing Officer finds that STUDENT did not receive a FAPE for that year.

(c) Academic Year 2000-2001.

With respect to academic year 2000-2001, Petitioner contended that the District did not adequately address STUDENT’s speech and language needs and that consequently he did not progress academically. In addition, Petitioner contended that the District erred by not providing STUDENT an occupational therapy program.(Footnote 35)

The June 20, 2000 IEP modification approved an OT evaluation, a referral for an AB 3632 evaluation, and STUDENT’s access to a telephone for emotional support. It denied a request for a Fast ForWord program evaluation. It also provided for continuing placement in an RSP program that provided him with academic support in a small-group setting.(Footnote 36) Ms. MOTHER signed the IEP, signifying her agreement.

During this new academic year, STUDENT’s educational program was reviewed in IEP meetings on September 13, 2000, November 16, 2000, January 11, 2001, March 13, 2001, and May 2, 2001.

(i) Assessing the Areas of STUDENT’s Suspected Disability.

Pursuant to Ms. MOTHER’s request, the District conducted an occupational therapy assessment of STUDENT early in the school year, on September 8, 2000. The assessment itself revealed that STUDENT had strengths including adequately integrated reflexes, functional strength and range of motion, and balance and endurance. He demonstrated visual perceptual skills and “scissors skills” in the assessment. However, Margaret Orser-McGuire, the District’s expert, stated that STUDENT exhibited decreased legibility in his handwriting skills. Her OT assessment (consistent with the District’s earlier psychoeducational assessment of January 2000) identified fine motor coordination as an area of deficit.

Petitioner contended that the District’s assessment was inaccurate. Deanna Caudillo, an occupational therapist in private practice, had a somewhat differing opinion from that of the District. She testified that her January 2003 assessment, undertaken for purposes of the hearing, demonstrated that STUDENT did not have adequate visual perception for developing scissors skills. She testified that STUDENT demonstrated a significant deficit in his control of the writing implement. She was expansive in her testimony and suggested that STUDENT’s deficits included gross motor control. Ms. Caudillo’s assessment did not include classroom observation or interviews with STUDENT’s teachers. It was not contemporary with Petitioner’s request for OT in the 2000-2001 school year. Moreover, there was disagreement among Petitioner’s experts. Ms. Rozenberg, who also noted STUDENT’s shaky handwriting during her January 2003 assessment, offered the explanation during her testimony that STUDENT’s tremors and balance may be side effects of his anti-psychotic medication.

It may be fairly stated, however, that the OT assessments conducted by each of the experts identified deficits in fine motor control.

The District also conducted further or ongoing assessment in other areas. The September 13, 2000 IEP contains the following statement indicating that further assessment had been undertaken in speech and language: “Based on informal assessment, observation and consultation with the teacher, STUDENT continues to manifest speech/language difficulties which impact his academic achievement and social growth.” The November 16, 2000 IEP referenced the Fast ForWord assessment. This assessment had been made to evaluate whether the Fast ForWord program would be helpful to STUDENT. Part of the testing, however, identified further his severe auditory processing deficits.

(ii) Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

As a result of his auditory processing disorder, STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the basic academic areas of language arts, expressive language, vocational education, and mathematics and in the area of speech and language, particularly with his decoding, phonemic awareness, articulation and fluency. Ms. Orser-McGuire, the District’s OT specialist, testified that during the District’s OT assessment it was observed that STUDENT had needs in the areas of auditory processing, such as need to participate in a program to develop skills for processing verbal instructions. She indicated that he also needed tools for focusing in the classroom. To address those needs, the District determined that STUDENT required a structured environment and small group instruction, as well as speech and language therapy. There is no contention by the Petitioner to the contrary. During this academic year, in January 2001, the IEP team also agreed that STUDENT had fine motor deficits and therefore required services to address those deficits. The experts all agreed that he needed supervised, repetitive practice focused upon fine motor coordination.

(iii) Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide STUDENT with Educational Benefit.

The September 13, 2000 IEP included an offer of an SDC class at Tenth Street. This placement was designed to provide STUDENT with a qualified special education teacher, a smaller class, a more focused and structured educational setting, and a more appropriate educational peer group. The SDC was also designed to provide more one-on-one assistance, particularly with fine motor coordination and more small-group assistance in academic areas. Additionally, there were classroom accommodations made to assist STUDENT’s visual and auditory processing difficulties. STUDENT was moved to the front of the classroom where he could hear and see more clearly and visual prompts were introduced to accompany oral instructions. The IEP also included 60 minutes per week of small-group speech and language services. The parties did not dispute that the SDC was an appropriate placement; however, Petitioner did dispute the adequacy of both the OT and speech and language services.

Petitioner contended that a program consisting of two dedicated hours per week of OT administered outside of the classroom setting was required to address his fine motor problems. This was based upon Ms. Caudillo’s January 2003 assessment prepared for purposes of the hearing. Ms. Orser-McGuire testified that STUDENT’s needs in this area were appropriately being addressed in the classroom administered by the resource teacher. Ms. Heller also acknowledged STUDENT’s needs in this area. The occupational therapy recommendation of the IEP team was to provide for STUDENT’s needs in the context of the classroom. The September 13, 2000 IEP report contained the statement: “Although he did have concerns related to visual motor it is believed these needs can best be met in the classroom environment through daily repetition ...by classroom staff and the resource specialist.” The District relied on the recommendation of Ms. Orser-McGuire and determined that STUDENT’s OT needs would be met by focusing on OT within the SDC classroom setting. The only expert who supported Ms. MOTHER based her opinion on a January 2003 assessment. All of the experts who evaluated STUDENT’s needs in academic year 2000-2001 concluded that the District appropriately addressed his needs during the academic year. The Hearing Officer is persuaded that the District’s offer of OT services within the SDC class was designed to meet his needs and provide him with academic benefit.

Ms, MOTHER also contended that STUDENT did not receive sufficient speech and language therapy. As indicated above, the September IEP team continued to offer a speech and language program of two thirty-minute sessions of small-group therapy (together with five more thirty-minute make-up sessions). The scope of STUDENT’s needs had been determined correctly, and the offer of an SDC placement was designed to address some of his educational needs, but no additional or individual or intensified services directed to serve his unique needs in speech and language had been adopted.

Ms. Rozenberg, Petitioner’s expert, testified that the District should have addressed these unique needs by designing and providing a more concentrated therapy regimen, in particular individual speech and language therapy supplementing small-group therapy. Given his lack of progress in this area, the Hearing Officer is persuaded by Ms. Rozenberg’s testimony on several points. First of all, STUDENT’s disfluency had a relationship to his mental health issues. Ms. Rozenberg, as well as some District witnesses, testified that when he attempted to speak now, he was showing secondary psychological signs of stuttering, such as grimacing, cringing and other negative body language signifying emotional impact. Moreover, he was emotionally fragile. His anxiety and depression was serious enough for an AB 3632 program. He was medicated with a variety of psychotropic agents that were intended to help him cope with anxiety. From an educational viewpoint, STUDENT made little progress with fluency or articulation improvement the prior year and one note in the September 13, 2000 IEP stated that “he still needs a cue to use the techniques learned ...[and] he has shown emotional sensitivity during various situations.” He continued to have decoding and phonemic awareness needs and did not appear to progress in this area either. His primary improvement was in mathematics. But his unmet needs in speech and language impeded his progress in other areas of academics. In short, the Hearing Officer concludes that the District’s speech and language program was not designed to meet needs and provide him with educational benefit in the area of speech and language.

In November, the IEP team met to review the District’s Fast ForWord assessment. That assessment tool was designed to determine whether the Fast ForWord program would be appropriate to address STUDENT’s speech and language needs.(Footnote 37) The assessment report contained the following statement: “Many of the errors he made were more representative of a bilingual child rather than a language delayed child.” Testimony offered by the District did not shed light on the reason for this observation.(Footnote 38) However, the assessment did identify auditory processing errors, and while the IEP team found STUDENT ineligible for the Fast ForWord program, it did recommend that STUDENT be provided with some classroom accommodation to assist with auditory processing.

The March 13, 2001 IEP was STUDENT’s annual IEP. The written IEP reports that he made progress in mathematics and social-emotional interaction. However, his reading remained at the first grade level and his articulation and fluency issues had not improved significantly.(Footnote 39) The IEP goals and objectives were more specific this year and provided measurable criteria. The District’s offer continued the SDC placement, RSP support, and classroom accommodations. However, STUDENT’s speech and language program did not change. The IEP provided for the same sixty minutes of small-group speech and language therapy, twice weekly. Since STUDENT’s speech and language abilities impacted his academic achievement, the failure to address speech and language adequately was significant.

On May 7, 2001, the final 2000-2001 IEP meeting was convened. The purpose was to review STUDENT’s mental health status. His social-emotional issues were reportedly continuing to improve, and new goals and objectives were adopted. Also at this time, assistive technology devices -- namely flash cards, high lighters and manipulatives -- were recommended.(Footnote 40) No other changes in STUDENT’s educational program were recommended.(Footnote 41)

The Hearing Officer notes that STUDENT was not progressing sufficiently in the curriculum during this school year. The SDC placement was intended to assist STUDENT in academic progress and OT. It did so to some extent. The one note of significant progress was in mathematics. But the areas of the curriculum that depended on speech and language skills, such as reading and language arts, were not accessible to STUDENT. Thus the Hearing Officer finds that the District did deny STUDENT a FAPE for 2000-2001 to the extent that it failed to design and offer a program to address adequately STUDENT’s unique speech and language needs in a manner reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit.

(iv) Should an ESY Program Have Been Provided for STUDENT.

The IEP team recommended an ESY program for STUDENT, thus acknowledging his need for a continuous program to prevent regression. However, the District continued to offer the same amount of speech and language services; consequently, STUDENT’s speech and language needs were not adequately addressed. Therefore, the Hearing Officer concludes that the ESY program was not appropriate.

(d) Academic Year 2001-2002.

Petitioner contended that during academic year 2001-2002, the District failed to conduct an appropriate psychoeducational assessment and to adequately address STUDENT’s unique needs in the areas of speech and language.

In September 2001 STUDENT was receiving the educational program described in the March 2001 IEP, the IEP then in effect (as amended May 7, 2001). He continued to be placed in Judy Tinkess’ SDC class.

(i) Assessing The Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

On January 9, 2002, Silvia De La Riva, the District’s bilingual school psychologist, conducted a psychoeducational evaluation in response to additional concerns expressed by Ms. MOTHER.. At the time of Ms. De La Riva’s evaluation, STUDENT was in the SDC class at Tenth Street School. Because this case was off calendar, Ms. De La Riva chose to take some time with her assessment. She reviewed all of STUDENT’s school records, observed STUDENT in his classroom setting, and conducted her own test regimen over a period of several days. She utilized both English and Spanish in her evaluation as she found appropriate.(Footnote 42)

Ms. De La Riva found significant deficits in STUDENT’s visual sequential memory, short- and long-term visual sequential memory, immediate auditory and sequential memory, auditory word discrimination and auditory thinking and reasoning. His speech and language delays, particularly his fluency and articulation difficulties, were again noted. They had not changed, although it was reported once again that he was making “limited progress.” Finally, the evaluation identified fine motor delays, making particular reference to STUDENT’s difficulty with holding a pencil and resultant shaky handwriting.

In summary, utilizing her eleven and a half years of experience, Ms. De La Riva reviewed the prior assessments for historical context, conducted her own bilingual evaluation, and engaged in direct classroom observation. She identified STUDENT’s areas of deficit and shared the information with STUDENT’s IEP team. The Hearing Officer concludes that Ms. De La Riva’s assessment was thorough and appropriate and that the Petitioner’s criticism of Ms. De La Riva’s assessment methodology was unsupported.

(ii) Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

The parties agreed that at the beginning of the 2001-2002 school year, STUDENT continued to have unique needs in the same general areas. Specifically, STUDENT had needs in the areas of language arts, expressive language, vocational education, mathematics, and the area of speech and language, particularly with his decoding, phonemic awareness, articulation and fluency.

(iii) Desigined to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

STUDENT’s program for the major part of academic year 2001-2002 was governed by the March 13, 2001 IEP as amended. As stated previously, the IEP provided a small structured SDC with academic supports and focus on OT needs. Here again, the Petitioner did not dispute the appropriateness of the placement. However, the Petitioner again contended that to address his needs in the area of speech and language and to progress academically, STUDENT required both small-group and individual speech therapy. The IEP addressed his speech and language needs with the same program as was provided the preceding academic year. Therefore, since the Hearing Officer has concluded that the program offered for the prior year did not provide a FAPE and that STUDENT’s needs did not change, the Hearing Officer further concludes that the program through January of academic year 2001-2002 failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE.

However, the District re-examined its offer at the IEP meeting of January 18, 2002. In this IEP, STUDENT’s present levels of performance were stated in the areas of reading, written language, articulation, fluency, mathematics, social/emotional development, health and vocational education. Goals were established in English language development, articulation, fluency, and vocational education. In the IEP, each of the areas of need are addressed with measurable goals and objectives.

The testimony established that the District believed the SDC class design was adequate to accomplish STUDENT’s goals and objectives, except for fluency and articulation objectives. As to those needs, the IEP again provided small group speech and language therapy in fluency (one 30 minute session per week) and articulation (one 30 minute session per week).

Judy Tinkess, STUDENT’s special education teacher at Tenth Street, had six years’ experience in special education at the time of the hearing. She testified that STUDENT’s abilities were “about average” when compared to the other students in her class. The class size varied, between eleven and thirteen students. Ms. Tinkess used several teaching techniques, including the writing of verbal instructions on the chalkboard and the use of prompts and physical manipulatives, such as flash cards. She also utilized a structured schedule and testified that she was careful to teach her SDC students to observe limits and boundaries. The class had an aide, a Spanish-speaking aide for half the academic year. The morning was devoted to “open court,” a period in which the class concentrated on reading, phonics, “decodables” and writing. The Hearing Officer found Ms. Tinkess to be knowledgeable and credible.

However, considering the magnitude of STUDENT’s delays in speech and language and the effect that his speech and language problems had on areas of academics, the Hearing Officer concludes that those speech and language needs were not effectively addressed in the SDC. That conclusion is supported by expert testimony and the record of STUDENT’s performance.

When one turns to the next IEP, the June 12, 2002 IEP, it becomes apparent that the team knew or should have known that his speech and language program was inadequately designed. The goals in all of the areas of STUDENT’s needs were dependent on his progress in speech and language. As Ms. Rozenberg testified, speech and language was foundational for STUDENT and until he developed in this area, his academic progress would be affected. By June 2002, none of his goals had been met except in the area of mathematics. His reading comprehension was deficient. His decoding skills had not improved. In point was the statement in Section “J” of that IEP: “STUDENT’s visual, auditory, sensory motor and conceptualization processing disorders impact his ability to decode words, spell, comprehend what he reads and express himself orally and in writing, which impedes his acquisition of grade level skills.” He still required prompting for articulation. With respect to fluency, it was reported that he was not able to apply the techniques learned. Instead of making progress, STUDENT’s speech and language skills remained static. The foregoing being the case, the Hearing Officer questions why the District provided STUDENT with the same basic speech and language program again for this academic year.

(iii) Should an ESY Program Have Been Provided for STUDENT.

An ESY was scheduled for STUDENT again. However, STUDENT’s educational program was insufficient in the area of speech and language. Thus despite the fact that ESY time was allocated for STUDENT, to that extent the ESY program itself was deficient.

The Hearing Officer agrees with Petitioner that The District did not offer or provide a program designed to meet his needs or provide him with educational benefit.

(e) Academic Year 2002-2003.

(i) Assessing The Areas of STUDENT’s Disability.

In the current academic year there was no contention that STUDENT’s areas of disability and deficits had changed from the prior year. There was, however, strong indication that his academic performance had not improved and therefore his needs were greater.

Abby Rozenberg’s assessment of January 2003 indicated that the then nearly twelve-year-old STUDENT performed in the four-year-old range in word memory, sentence memory and auditory processing and that he performed in the five-year-ten-month range in his expressive language skills. The comparative data closest in time to Ms. Rozenberg’s assessment is the De La Riva evaluation of January 2002 -- when STUDENT was eleven years eight months. She found that he was functioning in the 1st percentile in visual sequential memory and auditory processing and in the 7th or 8th percentile in visual memory, auditory perception, and visual motor integration. In generic terms, he was functioning at the lowest levels.(Footnote 43) The grade level equivalent for STUDENT’s performance in these areas was 1.6 to1.7. Betty Berg’s 2002 speech pathology evaluation, conducted at White Memorial Hospital, also indicated that STUDENT was performing at approximately age three and a half in auditory processing and age five in expressive language.

In summary, STUDENT’s areas of deficit in the areas of speech and language remained significant during the current year.

(ii) Determining STUDENT’s Unique Needs.

The written IEP of June 12, 2002 is the operative IEP during the current school year. It acknowledged the performance levels described by the recent assessments and it set forth specific goals and objectives in eight categories, notably, articulation, fluency, language arts, reading, written language, mathematics and vocational education. STUDENT needed speech and language therapy directed to articulation and fluency, decoding and phonemic awareness and a program which focused on language arts, reading and written language, as well as, in lesser amounts, vocational education and occupational therapy issues.

The IEP document reflects that the District members discussed adjusting goals and planning STUDENT’s transition from The Tenth Street School to Berrendo, a middle school. He remained eligible for special education services under the same categories, but it was proposed once more to address his speech and language needs with only two thirty minute sessions per week administered by the speech specialist in a small group setting, together with his continuing SDC placement. An ESY program was also authorized for STUDENT during the school intersessions for the purpose of preventing regression.

(iii) Designed to Meet Needs and Reasonably Calculated to Provide Educational Benefit.

The testing continued to show that STUDENT was not progressing. It has been established that there was a relationship between speech and language and his academic progress. While the District continued to have this knowledge, it nevertheless continued to offer the same speech and language program. The program offered was the same as had been offered the past four years, a program the Hearing Officer found deficient previously.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the District failed to offer a program to STUDENT that was reasonably calculated to provide STUDENT with educational benefit during the 2002-2003 academic year. Further, although ESY was again ordered for the proper reasons - to prevent regression - Ms. MOTHER testified that the District failed to advise her that there was space available at Berrendo during the winter intersession and that it also failed to advise her that transportation had been arranged. STUDENT therefore missed the ESY once again. The Hearing Officer accepts this testimony because it is consistent with a similar admitted failure of the District in a prior year and it is plausible. Thus, the program delivered during this period also was not in conformity with the current IEP.

(f) Summary As To substantive FAPE.

In summary, the Hearing Officer has concluded that the District offered and provided a FAPE to STUDENT in academic year 1998-1999. However as to subsequent years, the District failed substantially to provide a FAPE to STUDENT to the extent that it failed to meet his unique needs in speech and language.

In academic year 1999-2000, STUDENT’s unique needs were correctly identified and his eligibility criteria was correctly changed in his IEP report, but the District failed to increase services to meet those needs and failed to deliver even the services it offered, namely 450 minutes of speech therapy and the ESY program. In 2000-2001, even with unique needs appropriately identified, there was no recognition that STUDENT had been negatively impacted by the failure to deliver the ESY program and the District failed to increase his speech therapy services from the 1998 levels, other than to attempt to schedule make-up sessions. In 2001-2002, again STUDENT’s processing problems and his unique needs in the speech and language areas were identified, but nothing more was offered to provide for them. There was an attempt to address academic needs and OT needs with a placement in an SDC and with RSP support. However, his processing problems and speech and language problems impacted all academic areas. And in 2002-2003 while STUDENT continued to struggle with speech and language and related areas, the District again failed to increase STUDENT’s services and once more failed to provide access to the ESY program that was offered. In these latter four academic years, the Hearing Officer concludes that a FAPE was denied STUDENT to the extent that the District failed to provide a speech and language program to him that was designed to meet his needs and reasonably calculated to provide him with educational benefit.

3. Should the District be ordered to provide compensatory education to STUDENT and, if so, in what amounts?

The authority to award compensatory education is derived from 20 U.S.C. section 1415(i)(2)(B)(iii) which authorizes the finder of fact to grant “such relief as it determines appropriate.” Compensatory education may be an appropriate equitable remedy when the responsible educational authority has failed to provide a disabled child with an appropriate education as required by the IDEA. Todd v. Andrews (llth Cir.1991) 933 F.2d 1576. The purpose of compensatory education is to replace lost educational services. Moubry v. Independent School District No. 696 (8th Cir. 1996) 951 F.Supp. 867. There is, however, no obligation to compensate the student by providing a day of education for each educational day lost. “Compensatory education is not a contractual remedy, but an equitable remedy, as part of the court’s resources in crafting appropriate relief .. . relief designed to ensure that the student is appropriately educated within the meaning of IDEA.” Parents of Student W. v. Puyallup School District, ( 11th Cir. 1991) 31 F.3d 1489; see also Lester H. v. K Gilhool and the Chester Upland School District (3d. Cir. 1990) 916 F.2d 865 and Miener v. State of Missouri (8th Cir. 1986) 800 F,.2d 749. When considering a request for compensatory education, it is first necessary to determine whether a school district failed to provide a FAPE. If that question is answered in the affirmative, the subsequent question for determination is not what precise services were missed but, rather, what compensatory services are necessary to provide an appropriate education under the law.

In this case, the Hearing Officer has determined that the District failed to provide STUDENT a FAPE in four of the years in issue because it failed to provide an adequate speech and language program. Petitioner’s experts requested compensatory educational services as follows: fifty-two weeks of individual speech and language services provided for a total of three hours per week by a licensed and certified speech and language pathologist to address auditory processing, receptive and expressive language, articulation and fluency; and fifty-two weeks of small group speech and language therapy twice weekly for one hour (two thirty-minute sessions) to address generalization of skills into social situations with appropriate peers and typical language learners (a combined total of 208 hours) ; and, fifty-two weeks of two thirty-minute sessions of school-based OT per week to address fine motor coordination ( a total of 52 hours).

With respect to the OT services, the Hearing Officer has found that although STUDENT had needs to improve fine motor control, the IEP team recommended that such needs be met in his SDC classroom and that they be provided by the resource teacher. Ms. Rozenberg, Petitioner’s expert, even suggested that the tremors experienced by STUDENT are the result of his medication and that his medications should be re-evaluated. The Hearing Officer concluded, as set forth in the prior discussion of substantive FAPE, that the IEP appropriately addressed STUDENT’s fine motor needs. Therefore no compensatory OT is here ordered.

However the Hearing Officer has found that while the District properly identified speech and language deficits and both visual and auditory processing disorders, STUDENT’s unique needs in those areas were not met in any academic period other than 1998-1999. Further, significant speech and language services directed by the IEPs were not provided in one year and the District caused STUDENT to miss ESY programs in two years, which ESY programs were essential to sustaining any progress he may have made during the regular school year. The District made no attempt to determine what would be needed to compensate for STUDENT’s losses due to the admitted failure to provide those services in the first place. And no attempt was made by the District to determine what it would take to overcome the regression in skill levels which STUDENT experienced because he also missed two essential ESY programs intended to sustain his progress.

The District’s argument that it provided, and continues to provide, the correct level of service -- the amounts described and provided in the IEP reports -- was not persuasive.

Ms. Rozenberg testified that STUDENT needed individual speech and language therapy administered by a qualified speech pathologist and that it should be supplemented with small group speech therapy. In her opinion, the worsening of STUDENT’s problems require more intensive one-on-one attention by a qualified professional. Her testimony was persuasive. Ms Rozenberg’s testimony as to levels of service now required was somewhat different than her written recommendations. At one point in the hearing, she testified that STUDENT required three hours of therapy (“three, three and a half, maybe more”). At another point, she referred to her report and recommended four hours -- three individual and one small-group. She also testified that she would be concerned about pulling him out of class too much.(Footnote 44) This would have a negative effect on his social skills, another area of concern.

The Hearing Officer is also concerned about pulling STUDENT out of class too much. On the other hand, it is clear from the evidence that STUDENT requires individual work with the speech pathologist and continuous service throughout the year in order to compensate for the long breaks in service he has experienced. Thus the Hearing Officer finds that for a period of one calendar year -- fifty-two weeks-- STUDENT is entitled to compensatory education in the form of two hours of individual and one hour of small group speech and language services per week, said services to be focused in articulation and fluency, decoding and phonemic awareness, and language arts. Those services should be provided by a competent and qualified speech pathologist.

4. Should the District be ordered to reimburse Petitioner the cost of private independent evaluations provided at the due process hearing?

The law requires school districts to assess students in all areas of suspected disability. 20 U.S.C. ¤ 1414(B)(3)(C); Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56320. One of the purposes of an assessment is to determine the unique needs of the student by providing relevant information for the development of appropriate individual programs for the student. 20 U.S.C. ¤ 1414(b)(3)(d), Cal. Educ.Code ¤ 56321.

The District in this case developed assessment plans and conducted evaluations of STUDENT beginning in 1998 and continuing through 2002. The Hearing Officer has found previously that the District’s assessments and evaluations correctly identified STUDENT’s disabilities and deficits even though the District did not make an offer to provide him with an appropriate program in four of the years in issue.

Petitioner obtained his own evaluations in January 2003 immediately prior to this hearing. As stated earlier, the evaluations were in the areas of speech and language, psychoeducational assessment, audiology and OT. A parent has the right to obtain an independent educational evaluation of the student if the parent disagrees with an evaluation obtained by the educational agency and the educational agency is unable to show at a due process hearing that its evaluation was “appropriate.” Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56041.5 . The results of an independent educational assessment shall be considered by the school district and may be presented as evidence at a due process hearing pursuant to Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56329(b); 34 C.F.R.¤ 300.502(b). The Petitioner’s evaluations were admitted into evidence at the due process hearing.

In determining whether the cost of those assessments should be reimbursed, the issue for the Hearing Officer to determine is whether the District’s assessments were legally “appropriate.” In order for the District to prevail on this issue, it must show that its assessments have met the statutory requirements set forth in Cal. Educ. Code ¤ 56320. It provides, in pertinent part:

“(a) Testing and assessment materials and procedures used for the purposes of assessment and placement of individuals with exceptional needs are selected and administered so as not to be racially culturally, or sexually discriminatory. (b) Tests and other assessment materials meet all the following requirements: (1) Are provided and administered in the pupil’s primary language or other mode of communication . . . (2) Have been validated for the specific purpose for which they are used. (3) Are administered by trained personnel in conformance with the instructions provided by the producer of the tests and other assessment materials, except that individually administered tests of intellectual or emotional functioning shall be administered by a credentialed school psychologist . . . . (d) Tests are selected and administered to best ensure that when a test administered to a pupil with impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills produces test results that accurately reflect the pupil’’s aptitude, achievement level, or any other factors the test purports to measure and not the pupil’’s impaired sensory, manual, or speaking skills unless those skills are the factors the test purports to measure. . . .”

In this case, the Hearing Officer finds that the District’s assessments were appropriate. Each of the factors set forth in the Education Code have been discussed previously in this Decision in the context of reviewing the assessments in response to Petitioner’s contentions. The materials and procedures used by the District were culturally neutral. The testing was done in STUDENT’s primary language. Validated tests were given by trained personnel according to the protocols. And the tests were designed to accurately reflect the student’s levels of performance and identify his impaired skills. Moreover, the District’s evaluations correctly identified the areas and extent of STUDENT’s disabilities.

The Hearing Officer is persuaded that Petitioner’s real objection in this area is not to the assessments, evaluations or the procedures employed, but it is to the use the IEP team made of those instruments. That, of course, is a different issue. The District may not have correctly used the information it obtained from the assessments, but no other assessments were needed. The information was there for both Petitioner and the District to interpret and employ in developing an educational program for the student. See for example, Student v. Rescue Union Elementary School District (Ca.. 2000) 33 IDELR 261.

The Hearing Officer therefore concludes that the criteria for reimbursement of private assessment costs to Petitioner were not met and his claim for reimbursement of the cost of the assessments of Dr. Davidson, Ms. Rozenberg, Ms. Caudillo and Ms. Atkins is denied.(Footnote 45)

ORDER

1. The IEP team shall convene within fifteen calendar days for the purpose of amending the June 12, 2002 IEP to provide three weekly individual forty-minute sessions and two thirty-minute small-group sessions of speech and language therapy directed to the treatment of Petitioner’s fluency and articulation disorders and auditory processing and receptive and expressive language disorders, which sessions shall continue for a period of no less than fifty-two weeks. The IEP shall provide in addition:

(A) that the individual speech and language therapy will be administered by a qualified, certified and licensed speech pathologist, and (B) that such therapy shall be administered continuously during calendar years 2003 and 2004, except for breaks of no more than one week each during the school holidays or intersessions at Thanksgiving, Christmas, winter and spring break.

2. The District shall implement the June 12, 2002 IEP as amended.

3. The IEP team shall develop an assessment plan to be implemented prior to the reduction or termination of the speech and language services described above. An assessment of STUDENT’s progress shall be made and the IEP team shall consider, on the basis of the assessment, whether the delivery of the speech and language services shall be continued, modified or terminated at or about the one year anniversary date of the IEP team meeting here ordered.

4. The District shall reimburse to Ms. MOTHER the cost of providing transportation to STUDENT to and from school as agreed by the parties. Reimbursement shall be made within fifteen days of the submission to the District of receipts providing proof of incurring such expenses.

5. All other requests for relief are denied.

PREVAILING PARTY ON EACH ISSUE.

Pursuant to California Education Code section 56507(d), the hearing decision must indicate the extent to which each party has prevailed on each issue heard and decided. The following findings are made in accordance with that requirement:

1.. Procedural appropriateness of IEP meetings.

Did the District fail to provide a certified interpreter for STUDENT’s mother as IEP meetings in all years in issue and, if so, does that failure invalidate the IEP and therefore deny Petitioner a FAPE?

The District prevailed on this issue.

2. Did the District fail to provide The Student a free appropriate public education (FAPE) pursuant to the Individuals with Disabilities Education Act (IDEA) for the following enumerated academic years:

(a) Academic Year1998-1999.

The District prevailed on this issue.

(b) Academic Year1999-2000.

The Student prevailed on this issue in that the District failed to provide a program designed to meet the Student’s unique needs in and which was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the Student and in addition failed to provide the services required by the Student’s IEP, specifically 450 minutes of speech therapy and the ESY program which had been approved for the Student. The District prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that the District appropriately assessed the Student’s educational deficits and provided a resource specialist to address them.

(c) Academic Year 2000-2001.

The Student prevailed on this issue in that the District failed to provide a program designed to meet the Student’s unique needs and which was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the Student. The District prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that in March 2001 the District appropriately assessed the Student’s educational deficits in academic areas and provided an SDC placement to address those areas.

(d) Academic Year 2001-2002.

The Student prevailed on this issue in that the District failed to provide a program designed to meet the Student’s unique needs and which was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the Student. The District prevailed on this issue to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that the District appropriately assessed the Student’s educational deficits in academic areas and provided an SDC placement to address those areas.

(e) Academic Year 2002-2003.

The Student prevailed on this issue in that the District failed to provide a program designed to meet the Students’s unique needs and which was reasonably calculated to provide educational benefit to the Student and in addition failed to facilitate the Student’s attendance at and therefore provide the ESY program for which he had been designated. The District prevailed to the limited extent that the Hearing Officer found that the District appropriately assessed the Student’s educational deficits in academic areas and provided an SDC placement to address those areas.

3. Should the District be ordered to provide compensatory education to STUDENT and if so in what amount or amounts?

The Student prevailed on this issue.

4. Should the District be required to reimburse Petitioner for costs of private independent evaluations provided at the due process hearing?

The District prevailed on this issue.

RIGHT TO APPEAL THIS DECISION

The parties to this matter have the right to appeal this Decision to a court of competent jurisdiction. If an appeal is taken, it must be made within ninety (90) days of receipt of this Decision. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56505(i).

Dated: May_______, 2003 __________________________________ Michael B. Arkin, Hearing Officer California Special Education Hearing Office

1. The February 7, 2003 session of the hearing was conducted by telephone conference call by stipulation of all of the parties. 2. A certified Spanish language translator was provided for Ms. MOTHER at each session of the hearing. 3. One document, tendered as Respondent’s Exhibit 60, was offered during the February 7, 2003 session of the hearing. Objection was made on Petitioner’s behalf. Proof of Service establishes that the document was served on Petitioner on February 3, 2003, less than five days before the session of the hearing at which it was to be considered. It therefore is not admitted and was not considered by the Hearing Officer in rendering this decision. 4. The wording and sequence of the issues stated differs somewhat from the statement of the issues filed by Petitioner. At the time of the original request, only occupational therapy was raised as an issue. An issue statement received eleven days before the hearing broadened the issues substantially. The issues were once clarified on January 14, 2003, reclarified on January 21, 2003, and discussed on several occasions during the hearing. They are restated here for purposes of focus and clarity and to facilitate analysis in this decision. No changes in substance have been made. 5. The petition was received by the Hearing Office on October 29, 2001. It designated academic year 1997- 1998 as one of the years in issue. The parties agreed at the outset of the hearing that the first year in issue in this proceeding would be academic year 1998-1999. Petitioner then withdrew his request that the Hearing Officer consider academic year 1997-1998. It is therefore unnecessary to discuss the statute of limitations applicable to these hearings. 6. Petitioner’s position respecting reimbursement of costs of transportation of the student to school was accepted by the District, which, in its closing brief, agreed to reimburse upon presentation by Ms. MOTHER of receipts evidencing the costs of such transportation.. The Hearing Officer accepts that admission and it will be so ordered at the conclusion of this Decision. 7. Subordinate contentions specific to one or more of the years in issue in this matter will be addressed in the discussion of that year or years. 8. While each of the experts who evaluated STUDENT’s educational levels believed it important enough to mention this history in their reports, none of them provided an opinion connecting his medical history to his unique educational needs. 9. The fluency issue identified is more commonly referred to as “stuttering.” The experts for both parties also referred to this disability, from time to time, as a speech disfluency or disfluencies. 10 This is an increase of twenty minutes per week. The prior range, 40-60 minutes, provided until March 2000 was treated by the Hearing Officer as only requiring the minimum, 40 minutes. 11. This statement is somewhat misleading. STUDENT had been in the current program only since the March 2000 IEP. But he had been receiving speech and language services in a small-group setting since his first IEP, February 1999. 12. Fast ForWord is a proprietary language assessment and development program that is computer-based. The District has obtained the program for use in its schools and routinely assesses students to ascertain whether the program would likely benefit them. 13. There was evidence about problems experienced by bilingual children in general, but not about STUDENT. 14. STUDENT did not attend the ESY session. His mother testified that she had been advised by the school that they would call her when he was assigned to a class. She was also told that when transportation was secured, she would be notified. She stated she was never notified that a place had been found for him in the classroom and had not been notified that transportation had been arranged. 15. Each special education student’s program is memorialized in a document referred to as an IEP. Cal. Educ. Code section 56345 describes the required content of an IEP. Section 56345(a)(2)(A-B) provides that an IEP shall contain measurable annual goals, including benchmarks or short-term objectives, related to “meeting the pupil’s needs that result from the pupil’s disability to enable the pupil to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum,”and“meeting each of the pupil’s other educational needs that result from the pupils’s disability.” 16. Finally, although not at issue in the present case, the student’s IEP must provide for the student to be involved in and progress in the general curriculum in accordance with the student’s unique needs and present levels of performance and to participate in extracurricular and other nonacademic activities. 20 U.S.C. ¤1414(d), 34 C.F.R. ¤300.347(a). 17. Those notes in the cumulative record appeared to be made at the conclusion of the semester, thus after the family had moved to Mexico. Therefore, they were not raised in a request for an assessment or IEP meeting and were not brought to anyone’s attention. 18. Not unusual.

19. Stuttering.

20. The assessment plan and consent were part of the record of the case. The speech and language assessment itself was not offered into evidence on behalf of either party. Christine Maalouf, who conducted the assessment, was not called as a witness by either party. However, a summary of the assessment findings were referenced in the IEP of February 26, 1999, which was admitted into evidence. 21. There was no written request for an assessment. A written request would have established the date of the request for assistance with STUDENT’s educational difficulties. And Further, the date of Ms. MOTHER’s conversation or conversations with the school about STUDENT’s speech development was not made clear by testimony or other evidence. However, considering that an assessment plan was delivered to Petitioner in writing as early as November 1998, it may be fairly assumed that the District was responding timely. 22. Designated instruction and services as specified in the IEP shall be available when the instruction and services are necessary for the pupil to benefit educationally. Cal. Educ. Code Section 56363(a). Speech and language services are required if the difficulty a student has understanding or using spoken language is so great that it adversely affects their educational performance and cannot be corrected without special education and related services. 5 C.C.R. Section 3065(j)(1). 23. Abby Rozenberg, Petitioner’s expert, disagreed. However, her opinion is based solely on her work with STUDENT during 2003. She was not present and did not know how this student performed in 1999. Thus her opinion as to 1999 is speculative. The Hearing Officer relies on contemporaneous reports to determine what the District should have provided at that time. 24. The second “not” was written in as an insertion.. The evidence demonstrated that the District did not believe STUDENT would experience regression in the 1999 summer intersession .

25. Compare the federal regulations at 34 C.F.R. section 300.313, which provide that the school district is to ensure ESY services are available to the student “as necessary” to provide FAPE. 26. The District has a policy against administering standardized intelligence tests to any of its minority students in response to the decision in Larry P. v. Riles, 495 F.Supp. 926 (N.D. CA 1979), aff’d in part, rev’d in part, 793 F.2d 969 (9th Cir. 1984), which prohibits the use of such testing instruments with students of African-American descent. In this case, STUDENT is not African American, but the District’s policy has been somewhat broadened. When assessing persons who come from a minority background, the District seeks to avoid the use of tests that are standardized predominantly on a mainstream English-speaking population. While the purpose of using standardized tests is to estimate a student’s cognitive ability, in order to be relevant to the student being examined, the ethnicity or cultural background of the population utilized to obtain standardization must be essentially similar to the student’s. 27. As stated earlier, STUDENT had reached this level in September. He had not made progress since then. Ms. Ornstein’s assessment was conducted in February 2000. 28. Apraxia is a speech production disorder. Persons afflicted are unable to produce combinations of syllables and words. As Petitioner’s experts testified, apraxia reflects an impairment in the student’s ability to produce a desired sequence of sounds. The brain is unable to signal correctly to speech production centers; thus the brain is unable to produce the sequence of words, syllables or sounds. 29. Ms. Rozenberg’s assessment was conducted in January 2003. Although it is remotely possible that STUDENT suffered from apraxia in 1999 and that it had been cured by 2003 when Ms. Rozenberg conducted her evaluation, it is unlikely that this would occur without treatment directed to this specific speech defect and there was no testimony directed to this point. At one point in her testimony, Ms. Rozenberg indicated that “some” apraxia might be present in STUDENT’s speech. From the context of the comment, the Hearing Officer understood this to mean to a de minimis extent. 30. At the hearing it was suggested by the District that STUDENT’s speech and language impediments may have had a second language component. This, Dr. Jose Gonzales testified, contributed to STUDENT’s difficulties. But that contention was only hypothesized and was not directly connected to this student. Jose Gonzales, Ph.D., was called as an expert witness by the District. His major interest is in the education of bilingual children. In that regard, he and colleagues at U.C.L.A. have been developing test instruments to differentiate between students whose deficits are language-based and those whose deficits are both language- and disability-based. Testing standardization and validation is in process but it is not presently available. 31. Under Title 5 C.C.R. Section 3030(j), a pupil is considered eligible for special education with a specific learning disability if “the pupil has a disorder of one or more of the basic psychological processes involved in understanding or using language, spoken or written, which may manifest itself in an impaired ability to listen, think, speak, read, write, spell, or do mathematical calculations, and has a severe discrepancy between intellectual ability and achievement in one or more of the academic areas specified in [ Cal. Educ. Code] Section 56337(a).” 32. STUDENT’s mental health needs were acknowledged by the District and a recommendation for an AB3632 assessment was made to County Mental Health.. STUDENT’s needs in this area continued to be severe. Treatment and medication had been provided through the Frank T. Lanterman Regional Center 33. There was a slight change from the prior year. Instead of 40-60 minutes of speech therapy per week, there was one thirty-minute session to be focused on articulation and one thirty- minute session to be focused on fluency. 34. The formulation of specific measurable goals and objectives is a requirement of California Education Code Section 56345(a)(2) and 34 C.F.R. Section 300.346(a)(2). 35. Petitioner again made the general contention that the District failed to assess STUDENT in all areas of suspected disability. As stated above, the District conducted assessments during the second half of the prior academic year and identified the areas of need previously enumerated. These areas of need continued to require specially designed services and instruction in the current academic year. 36. STUDENT also had continuing mental health needs. With respect to his mental health needs, the County Mental Health department agreed that STUDENT was eligible for AB3632 services and it was providing counseling and medication. STUDENT’s mental health needs and behavioral health program were not contested. 37. Petitioner additionally contended that STUDENT was denied a FAPE because his Fast ForWord assessment was delayed. A Fast ForWord assessment was requested by STUDENT’s mother at the June 20, 2000 IEP meeting. It was denied at that time. However, the assessment was recommended by the IEP team at the September 13, 2000 meeting. It is incontrovertible that there was a delay in attending to STUDENT’s mother’s request for the assessment. The Petitioner did not show, however, that the delay of three months negatively impacted STUDENT’s educational program. The assessment in fact was completed by November and it identified areas of deficit in auditory processing. On one test instrument, the TACL-R his scores were in the first percentile, indicating severe deficit. However this area of deficit, auditory processing, had been acknowledged by the District. So, this did not provide much new information. It is apparent that both Petitioner and District properly identified STUDENT’s processing disorder. 38. Dr. Gonzales’ testimony about problems in bilingual education was excellent. However, he had no specific information about this student. 39. . Evaluations performed by Arnold E. Herrera and Shirley Ornstein were considered at the March 13, 2001 IEP meeting . Dr. Herrera’s assessment team concluded that STUDENT’s intellectual ability was in the “cut-off area between mild delay and borderline functioning.” STUDENT, at the time of the evaluation was an eight year ten month old fourth grade student. Dr. Herrera stated that STUDENT’s intellectual functioning was at the six year eight month level. Academic skills were in the kindergarten to first grade level. Dr. Herrera also found delays in gross and fine motor coordination at the time of the assessment. Shirley Ornsteing found, utilizing nonverbal reasoning tasks, that STUDENT’s ability was low average. She noted that in tasks based on visual perception, he showed lower scores as his visual motor perception was poor. She also identified a twenty-two month lag in fine motor coordination. 40. The testimony established that they were never provided to him. 41. Ms. MOTHER requested a one-to-one aide for STUDENT at the June 2001 IEP. The request was made generally, in furtherance of Ms. MOTHER’s concerns about STUDENT’s progress. The District denied the request. At the due process hearing, testimony established that the District had previously offered a tutor for STUDENT in response to academic concerns expressed by STUDENT’s mother. Ms. MOTHER did not accept the offer. The District’s offer appears to the Hearing Officer to be appropriate. And, Petitioner did not offer additional support for the one-to-one aide request at the hearing. 42. Ms. De La Riva testified that she is fluent and technically competent in both languages. 43. The percentile scale is used to compare students’ performance levels. There are 100 percentiles in the scale. A student scoring in the 7th percentile is performing below 93 percent of the other students in the population. 44. The individual therapy recommended would require that he be removed from his class each time he was scheduled for a session. 45. The Hearing Officer does not express any opinion as to whether the cost of expert witness reports and testimony may be reimbursable as costs of litigation as this is beyond the jurisdiction of the Special Education Hearing Office.